PSFC/JA-18-59

Experimental and Numerical Studies on a Method to Mitigate Screening Current-Induced Field for No-Insulation REBCO Coils

Jiho Lee, Dongkeun Park, Yi Li, Yoon Hyuck Choi, Philip C. Michael, Juan Bascuñân, Yukikazu Iwasa

October 2018

Plasma Science and Fusion Center Massachusetts Institute of Technology

Cambridge MA 02139 USA

This study was supported by the National Institute of General Medical Sciences of the National Institutes of Health under award R01GM114834. Reproduction, translation, publication, use and disposal, in whole or in part, by or for the United States government is permitted.

Submitted to IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity

!"#$%&'()* %*

&J.,35-,610/*069*K<-,35A0/*E1<95,4*$6*0*L,1C$9*1$*L515=01,*EA3,,656=*M<33,61'?69<A,9*N5,/9*D$3*K$'

?64</015$6*O&PMQ*M$5/!*

R5C$*",,:*S$6=T,<6*#03T:*U5*"5:*U$$6*VB<AT*MC$5:*#C5/5.*M8*L5AC0,/:*R<06*P04A<WX6:*069*U<T5T0Y<*?@040!***!"#$%&'$"#$!%&$'$()!$*%$&+,$()-.!-(/!(0,$&+1-.!')0/+$'!2(!-!

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

&$'2(-(1$! 7G<H;! '%$1)&2,$)$&! ,-4($)Q! '1&$$(+(4! 10&&$()5+(/01$/!6+$./!789:;!

?8! *?K+OQSZM+?QK*K*+V?E*.0.,3:*@,*954A<44*1C,*4A3,,656=*A<33,61'569<A,9*D5,/9*[EMN\* -515=015$6* -,1C$9* D$3* 6$'564</015$6* [K?\* O&PMQ*

A$5/:*@C5AC*@5//*C,/.*1$*A$6413<A1*1C,*EMN*-515=015$6*4A,6035$*D$3*1C,*L?+*%8]'^VY*"+EGV+E*KLO*-0=6,1*[%8]^\8*N$3*$<3*%8]^:*@,*C02,*AC$4,6*0*_D5,/9'4C0T56=`*1,AC65a<,:*$6,*$D*1C,*.3$2,6*-,1C$94* 1$*-515=01,* 1C,* EMN* 56*O&PMQ* 10.,*@$<69*-0=6,148* +C,* %8]^* A$645414* $D* 06* 7(('LVY* O&PMQ* 564,31*-0=6,1* [V7((\* 069* 0* b(('LVY* "+E* H0AT=3$<69* -0=6,1**L06<4A35.1*3,A,5.1*069*0AA,.106A,*901,4*@5//*H,*564,31,9*C,3,8*+C54*41<9B*@04*

4<..$31,9*HB*1C,*K015$60/*?64151<1,*$D*^,6,30/*L,95A0/*EA5,6A,4*$D*1C,*K015$60/*?64151<1,4* $D*V,0/1C* <69,3* 0@039* 6<-H,3*O(%^L%%!7]!8* "#$%%&'($)*+),! -./01$%2!3+1$!4&&56!+C,*0<1C$34* 03,*@51C* 1C,*N306A54*P511,3*L0=6,1*"0H$301$3B* [NPL"\G#/04-0*

EA5,6A,* 069* N<45$6* M,61,3* [#ENM\* $D* L0440AC<4,114* ?64151<1,* $D* +,AC6$/$=B*[L?+\:*%>(*;/H06B*E13,,1:*M0-H359=,:*L;*()%]c:*ZE;*[,'-05/F*d5C$e-518,9<\8*M$/$3*2,345$64*$D*$6,*$3*-$3,*$D*1C,*D5=<3,4*56*1C54*.0.,3*03,*0205/0H/,*$6/56,*

01*C11.FGG5,,,J./$3,85,,,8$3=8*S5=510/*QHd,A1*?9,615D5,3*@5//*H,*564,31,9*C,3,*<.$6*0AA,.106A,8*

["b((\*f%:*)g8*"b((*54*4$*/$6=,3*1C06*V7((*1C01*51*A06*=,6,301,*-$41/B* 0J50/* D5,/9* 1$*V7((* 3,=5$68*M$6459,356=* 1C,*=,$-,13B*$D*1C,*%8]^:*@,*H,/5,2,*1C01*"b((*54*1C,*$6/B*.30A15A0/*4$<3A,*$D*1C,*4C0T56=*D5,/9*069*=$56=*1$*H,*<4,9*04*0*4C0T56=*-0=6,1*1$*-515=01,*EMN*$D*V7((*56*%8]^*$.,3015$68*?6*.3,25$<4*41<9B:*1C,*9,95A01,9*4C0T56=*A$5/* 13064.$3156=*h(*VY*0/1,360156=*A<3'3,61*-515=01,9* 1C,* 45=65D5A061* 0-$<61*$D* 1C,*EMN* 56* 1C,*V+E*564,31*@51C*i7(*4C0T56=*51,3015$64*f]g8*V$@,2,3:*56*%8]^*$.,3'015$6:*5D*@,*<4,*"b((*04*0*4C0T56=*-0=6,1:*1C,*6<-H,3*$D*1C,*4C0T56=*51,3015$6*A06*H,*/5-51,9*HB*1C,*.$@,3*95445.015$6*069*1C,* /5a<59* C,/5<-* A$64<-.15$6* D3$-* "b((8* +C,3,D$3,:* D$3*%8]^:*1C,*130.,Y$590/*D5,/9'4C0T56=*<456=*"b((*54*=$56=*1$*H,*A$69<A1,9*1$*-515=01,*1C,*EMN*$D*V7((*f!g8*?6*1C54*.0.,3:*@,*

=! *N5=8*%8*#$4515$64*$D*1C,*K?*O&PMQ*A$5/*069*1C,*"+E*H0AT=3$<69*-0=6,1*069*1C,*-,04<3,-,61*-,1C$9* $D*-0=6,15A* D5,/9*78* 1$* a<0615DB* 069* A$-.03,* 1C,*EMN8*P/<,*033$@4*-,06*1C,*-,04<3,-,61*.$561*$D*788**

*N5=8*)8*M53A<51*950=30-*$D*1C3,,*1,414*56*1C54*41<9B8*

*

*

)*

9,0/*@51C*1C,*D5,/9'4C0T56=*1$*-515=01,*1C,*EMN*56*1C,*413,6=1C*$D* 3,/0152,/B* C5=C* -0=6,15A* D5,/9* @51C* 3,/0152,/B* 0* 4-0//,3*

6<-H,3*$D*4C0T56=*51,3015$648*

??8! &j#&O?L&K+;"*;K;"UE?E*QK*L?+?^;+?QK*QN*EMN*PU*N?&"S'EV;k?K^*

?6* 1C,* .3,25$<4* 41<9B:* @,* 569<A,9* 1C,* EMN* HB* 1C,* D5,/9'A$$/56=* $D* O&PMQ* A$5/4* @51C$<1* 06B* 13064.$31015$6* A<33,61*069*060/BY,9*1C,*,DD,A1*$D*D5,/9'4C0T56=*f!g8*?6*1C54*41<9B:*D$3*0*H,11,3*<69,34106956=*$D*D5,/9'4C0T56=*1,AC65a<,*1$*-515=01,*1C,*EMN* 56*K?*O&PMQ*A$5/*069*H,11,3* 45-</015$6*$D*K?*O&PMQ*A$5/l4* H,C025$3*@51C*"+E* H0AT=3$<69*-0=6,1:*@,* A$69<A1,9*1C3,,*1,414*1$*45-</01,*1C,*D5,/9'4C0T56=*$D*1C,*K?*O&PMQ*A$5/*56*%8]^8*N5=8*%*069*)*4C$@*1C,*,J.,35-,610/*A$6D5=<3015$6*$D*1C3,,* 1,414* 56* 1C54* 41<9B8* +0H/,* ?* 9,4A35H,4* 1C,* A$69515$64* $D*,0AC* 1,418* ?6* 0//* 1C3,,* 1,414:* 1C,* 30-.* 301,* $D* 1C,* "+E* H0AT'=3$<69*-0=6,1*@04*%*;G-568*+C,*K?*O&PMQ*A$5/*C04*0*#ME*4@51AC*01*1C,*,69*1<36*$D*<..,3*.06A0T,*10.,:*069*0*606$'$C-*4A0/,*H359=,*d$561*H,1@,,6*H$1C*.06A0T,4l*10.,*,6948*

+;P"&*?*+&E+E*#&ONQOL&S*?K*+V?E*E+ZSU*

m* EMN*569<A15$6* N5,/9'4C0T56=*561,6451B*f-+g*

#ME*C,01,3* O,-03T*

%* N5,/9'A$$/56=0* %((*069*)((* Q6*A** K$*13064.$31*A<33,61*)* N5,/9'A$$/56=0* %((*069*)((* QDD* K$*13064.$31*A<33,61*

]* E,/D'D5,/9*H** b(*069*%((* Q6*A* +3064.$31*A<33,61*$D*b ;*

0+$*569<A,*$6/B*1C,*EMN*@51C$<1*13064.$31*A<33,61:*1C,*D5,/9'A$$/56=*@04*<4,9*40-,*04*.3,25$<4*41<9B*f!g8*HO&PMQ* A$5/* ,JA51015$6*-,064* 1C01* 1C,* A$5/* @04* AC03=,9* HB* ,J1,360/* .$@,3*4<../B8*A#ME*C,01,3*_$6`*-,064*1C,*K?*O&PMQ*A$5/*54*$.,6*/$$.8*+C,3,D$3,:*9<356=*1C,*D5,/9'4C0T56=:*1C,*569<A,9*A<33,61*$D*1C,*A$5/*54*-565-5Y,9*069*0/-$41*6,=/5=5'H/,8*?6*1C,*40-,*@0B:*_$DD`*-,064*1C,*K?*O&PMQ*A$5/*54*A/$4,9*/$$.8**

*N5=8*]8* +C,*3,4</1*$D*1,41*4,1%*@C,6*1C,*4C0T56='D5,/9*54*%((*-+8*+C,*D5,/9*-0..56=*0/$6=*1C,*Y'0J54*@04*-,04<3,9*01*1C,*56459,*$D*O&PMQ*A$5/*4<..$31*356=:* %n>!8b*--8* l)1Cl*-0..56=*-,064* 1C,*-0..56=* 9010* 0D1,3* o)1Cl* D5,/9'4C0T56=8**

*N5=8*!8* +C,*3,4</1*$D*1,41*4,1%*@C,6*1C,*4C0T56='D5,/9*54*)((*-+8*+C,*D5,/9*-0..56=*0/$6=*1C,*Y'0J54*@04*-,04<3,9*01*1C,*56459,*$D*O&PMQ*A$5/*4<..$31*356=:*%n>!8b*--8**

*

*N5=8*b8* N5,/9'4C0T56=*1,41*3,4</14*$D*1,41*4,1%*56*A$-.0354$6*@51C*1C,*6$3-0/'5Y,9*EMN*20/<,4*D3$-*-,04<3,9*90108***

*N5=8*h8*39G39:*$D*1C,*O&PMQ*A$5/*01*;n(*--:*0AA$3956=*1$*1C,*0../5,9*D5,/9*D3$-*"+E*H0AT=3$<69*-0=6,1*56*1C54*41<9B8**

*

*

]*

<5! =&'0/>2!?#@!+)*.90+$)!AB!C+&D*/9$$D+),!-)*!C+&D*/'1-E+),!$C!F$(&)/D$$(G!8H7#I!9$+D!?6* %8]^* $.,3015$6:* -0=6,15A* D5,/9* 6,03* 1C,* ,69'./06,* $D*

V7((*A$610564*45=65D5A061*30950/*D5,/9*A$-.$6,618*?6*1C54*1,41'%:*1$*569<A,*1C,*EMN*56*1C,*K?*O&PMQ*A$5/:*@,*<4,9*1C,*D5,/9'A$$/56=*-,1C$9* 1$*-0T,* 1C,*EMN*40-,*04* 1C,*.3,25$<4*41<9B*f!gp* AC03=56=* 1C,* "+E* H0AT=3$<69* -0=6,1:* ./0A56=* 1C,* K?*O&PMQ* A$5/* 56459,* 514* H$3,* 56* A,31056* 0J50/* /$A015$6:* ;n'%>b*--:* D5//56=* 1C,*6513$=,6* 56459,* 1C,*A3B$4101*H$3,* 1$*-0T,* 1C,*A$5/*4<.,3A$69<A156=:*069*30-.56=*9$@6*1C,*"+E*H0AT=3$<69*-0=6,18*;D1,3*569<A56=*1C,*EMN*069*-0..56=*1C,*30950/*D5,/9:*78:*0/$6=*@51C*1C,*;'0J54*01* 1C,*A$5/l4* 566,3*-$41*1<36:* 1C,*K?*O&PMQ*A$5/*@04*3,/$A01,9*1$*1C,*A,61,3*@C5AC*C04*0/-$41*Y,3$*30950/* D5,/9:* D$3* D5,/9'4C0T56=8*S<356=* 1C,*D5,/9'4C0T56=* 56* 1C,*413,6=1C*$D*%((*069*)((*-+:*@,*1<36,9*$6*1C,*#ME*C,01,3*56'410//,9*56*1C,*K?*O&PMQ*A$5/*1$*-565-5Y,*1C,*569<A,9*A<33,61*56*1C,*0Y5-<1C0/*.01C*56*1C,*K?*O&PMQ*A$5/8*M$6459,356=*1C,*#ME*3,454106A,:*8(9'*$D*i%*-q:*1C,*AC030A1,35415A*3,454106A,:*89*[K?*A$5/l4*D,01<3,*fbg\*$D*]))8%*rq:*069*1C,*569<A106A,:*4J*$D*

i%7*-V:*1C,*569<A,9*A<33,61*9<356=*1C,*D5,/9'4C0T56=*54*s%*;*@C5AC*54*0/-$41*6,=/5=5H/,8*N5=8* ]* 069* !* 4C$@* 1C,* 1,41* 3,4</14* 56* 1C,* 130.,Y$590/* D5,/9'

4C0T56=*413,6=1C*$D*%((*069*)((*-+:*3,4.,A152,/B8*"5T,*-06B*$1C,3* .3,25$<4* 41<95,4* f]:* hg:* 1C,* C5=C,3* 413,6=1C* $D* D5,/9'4C0T56=*-09,* 1C,*-$3,*-515=015$6* $D* 1C,* EMN8*N5=8* b* 4C$@4*1C,*A$-.0354$6*$D*1C,*6$3-0/5Y,9*EMN*$D*,0AC*1,41*0AA$3956=*1$* 1C,* D5,/9'4C0T56=* 51,3015$68*t51C*%]* 51,3015$64*$D* 1C,* D5,/9'4C0T56=:*%((*-+*D5,/9'4C0T56=*A06*3,9<A,*1C,*EMN*1$*ihbu*$D*514*565150/*20/<,4*069*)((*-+*$6,*A06*3,9<A,*51*1$*i](u8*N5=8*h*4C$@4* 1C,*.3$.,31B*$D*E<.,3#$@,3l4*L!* 10.,*<4,9* 56* 1C,*K?*O&PMQ*A$5/:*3G39:*01*1C,*D5,/9*06=/,*$D*(v*[.030//,/*1$*1C,*10.,*4<3D0A,\*0AA$3956=* 1$* 1C,*0../5,9*D5,/9*<.* 1$*%*+8*;1*%((*069*)((*-+:*3G39:!20/<,4*03,*(8ch)*069*(8c)h:*3,4.,A152,/B8*+C,4,*20/<,4*03,*a<51,*C5=C,3* 1C06*1C,*EMN*-515=015$6*20/<,4*$D* 1C,*1,41*3,4</148*+C,3,D$3,:*@,*-0B*A$6A/<9,*1C01*1C,*-515=015$6*$D*1C,*EMN*03$<69*i]bu*069*i>(u*-$41/B*A0-,*D3$-*1C,*,DD,A1*$D*1C,*D5,/9'4C0T56=8**?6*099515$6*1$*1C,*6$3-0/5Y,9*EMN*A$-.0354$6*56*N5=8*b:*1$*

A$-.03,*1C,*,DD,A1*$D*1C,*EMN*-515=015$6*56*1C,*<651*$D*1C,*A<3'3,61:*@,*,415-01,9* 1C,* ,6=56,,356=*A<33,61* 9,6451B*$D* 1,41'%l4*78*-0..56=*90108*N$3* 1C54*,415-015$6:*@,*044<-,9* 1C01*,2,3B*

*N5=8*>8*&415-01,9*,6=56,,356=*A<33,61*9,6451B*H04,9*$6*A3<9,*P,06l4*A3515A0/*4101,*-$9,/8***

*N5=8*78*M$-.0354$6*H,1@,,6*1C,*-,04<3,-,61*9010*069*1C,*A0/A</01,9*9010*<456=*,415-01,9*,6=56,,356=*A<33,61*9,6451B8***

*N5=8*c8*+C,*1,41*3,4</1*$D*1,41*4,1)*56*1C,*D5,/9'4C0T56=*413,6=1C*$D*%((*-+8**

*N5=8*%(8*+C,*1,41*3,4</1*$D*1,41*4,1)*56*1C,*D5,/9'4C0T56=*413,6=1C*$D*%((*-+8*

*

*

!*

1<36* $D* 1C,*K?*O&PMQ* A$5/* C04* 40-,* A<33,61* 954135H<15$6* 04*$6,'1<36*A$5/8*t,*0/4$*044<-,9*1C01*1C,*4A3,,656=*A<33,614*03,*=,6,301,9* H04,9* $6* 1C,* A3<9,* P,06'E/0H* -$9,/* f>g8* @C5AC*-,064*1C,*A<33,61*954135H<15$6*56*,0AC*456=/,*.06A0T,*A$645414*$D* 1@$* 3,=5$64p* ]'--* C5=C* '3* 3,=5$6* 069* ]'--* C5=C* w3* 3,'=5$68*t,*95259,9*,0AC*3,=5$6*561$*b*4,A15$64*069*6<-,35A0//B*A0/A</01,9*1C,*A<33,61*9,6451B*$D*,0AC*4,A15$6*HB*6$6/56,03*3,'=3,445$6*-,1C$98*N5=8*>*4C$@4*1C,*,415-01,9*,6=56,,356=*A<3'3,61* 9,6451B* $D* ,0AC* .031l4* A<33,61* /$$.:* H04,9* $6* 1C,* A3<9,*P,06'E/0H*-$9,/8*+C$<=C*1C54*A0/A</015$6*54*6$1*H04,9*$6*1C,*4A5,615D5A*-$9,/:*H<1*H04,9*$6* 1C,*.30A15A0/* D51156=*-$9,/:*@,*A06* $H4,32,* 1C,* ,DD,A1* $D* 1C,* 3,.,01,9* D5,/9'4C0T56=* $6* 1C,*EMN8*

75! =&'0/K2!?#@!+)*.90+$)!AB!C+&D*/9$$D+),!-)*!C+&D*/'1-E+),!$C!F9D$'&*/D$$(G!8H7#I!9$+D!?6*1C54*1,41'):*@,*565150//B*569<A,9*1C,*EMN*56*1C,*40-,*@0B*

04* 1,41'%8* P,A0<4,* 1C,* K?* O&PMQ* A$5/* 069* 1C,* "+E* H0AT'=3$<69* -0=6,1* 03,* -0=6,15A0//B* A$<./,9:* 1C,* AC06=,* $D* 1C,*A<33,61* 56* 1C,* H0AT=3$<69*-0=6,1* 569<A,4* 1C,* A<33,61* 56* 1C,*566,3*K?*O&PMQ*A$5/8*+C,3,D$3,:*<6/5T,*1C,*1,41'%:*@,*1<36,9*$DD*1C,*#ME*C,01,3*1$*-0T,*1C,*K?*O&PMQ*A$5/*A/$4,9'/$$.*1$*=,6,301,* -$3,* 569<A,9* A<33,61* 56* 1C,* 0Y5-<1C0/* .01C* $D* 1C,*A$5/:*9<356=* D5,/9'4C0T56=8*M$6459,356=* 1C,*89* 069*4J:* 1C,* 56'9<A,9* A<33,61* 9<356=* 1C,* %((* 069* )((*-+* D5,/9'4C0T56=* 03,*i%(*;8*N5=8*c*069*%(*4C$@*1C,*3,4</14*$D*1,41')8*?6*H$1C*1,414:*3,=039/,44*$D*1C,*565150/*569<A,9*EMN:*1C,*D5,/9'4C0T56=*959*6$1*-0T,* 1C,*EMN*-515=015$6:*H<1* 1C,*$1C,3* 4C0.,*H,A0<4,*$D* 1C,*3,/0152,/B*C5=C,3*-0=651<9,*$D* 1C,*569<A,9*A<33,61* 56* 1C,*0Y5'-<1C0/* .01C* 56* 1C,* K?* O&PMQ* A$5/* 1C06* 1C,* 565150/* 569<A,9*4A3,,656=*A<33,618*+C54*A06*H,*,J./056,9*HB*1C01*1C,*-0=651<9,*$D*1C,*.,6,13015$6*D5,/9:*7(*,a<0/4*i%)%8h*-+*@C5AC*54*C5=C,3*1C06*%((*-+*069*/$@,3*1C06*)((*-+8*?6*1C,*130.,Y$590/*D5,/9'4C0T56=:*@C,6* 1C,* 0../5,9* D5,/9* 54* %((*-+* 069* H0AT* 1$* (*+:*1C,6* $6/B* 1C,* 3,459<0/* D5,/9* 3,-0564* 56* ,0AC* 1<36* $D* 1C,* K?*O&PMQ* A$5/8* V$@,2,3:* @C,6* 1C,* 0../5,9* D5,/9* 54* )((* -+*@C5AC*54*C5=C,3*1C06*7(*$D*1C,*O&PMQ*10.,:*1C,3,*-0B*H,*6$*-$3,*569<A,9*A<33,61*01*1C,*D5,/9*C5=C,3*1C06*7(:*069*@C,6*1C,*

0../5,9* D5,/9* 54*H0AT* 1$*Y,3$:* 1C,3,*-0B*H,* 562,34,/B* 569<A,9*A<33,61*D3$-*514*565150/*4101,8*

#5! ?#@!+)*.90+$)!AB!'&DC/0%-)'($%0!-)*!C+&D*/'1-E+),!$C!F$(&)/D$$(G!8H7#I!9$+D!?6*1,41']:*<6/5T,*1,414'%*069*'):*@,*13064.$31,9*1C,*A<33,61*56*

1C,*K?*O&PMQ*A$5/8*;4*4C$@6*56*N5=8*%%:*1C,*D5,/9'4C0T56=*56*1C,*413,6=1C*$D*b(*069*%((*-+*4C5D1,9*1C,*-0=6,15A*D5,/9*.,0T*.$561* 1$@039* 1C,* A,61,3* .$4515$6* 56* 1C,* ;'0J548* P,A0<4,* 1C,*-0=651<9,*$D*1C,*569<A,9*A<33,61*$D*%((*-+*54*/03=,3*1C06*1C01*$D*b(*-+:*1C,*.,0T*4C5D1*$D*%((*-+*D5,/9'4C0T56=*54*-$3,*1C06*1C01*$D*b(*-+*D5,/9'4C0T56=8*+C54*.C,6$-,6$6:*.,0T*4C5D1*1$'@0394*56459,*A$33,4.$694*1$*1C,*,DD,A1*$D*1C,*A<33,61*4@,,.*3,'2,340/*-,1C$9*f7g8*+C,3,D$3,:*1C54*.,0T*4C5D1*-,064*1C,*4A3,,6'56=*A<33,61*-$2,9*D3$-*1C,*,9=,*$D*1C,*10.,*1$*A,61,38*

???8! MQKM"ZE?QK*+C,* ,DD,A1* $D* 1C,* D5,/9'4C0T56=* $6* 1C,*K?*O&PMQ* A$5/* HB*

"+E* H0AT=3$<69* -0=6,1* C04* H,,6* 060/BY,9* HB* ,J.,35-,614*069*514*6<-,35A0/*060/B4548*+C,*4A3,,656=*A<33,61'569<A,9*D5,/9*[EMN\*54* 1C,*-0d$3*D5,/9*,33$3* 1$*56A$3.$301,*0*O&PMQ*564,31*D$3*0*C5=C*D5,/9*"+EGV+E*-0=6,18*+C,*D5,/9'4C0T56=*1,AC65a<,*54*=$56=*1$*H,*<4,9*1$*-515=01,*1C,*EMN*$D*7(('LVY*O&PMQ*564,31*-0=6,1*[V7((\*D$3*L?+*%8]'^VY*"+EGV+E*KLO*-0='6,1*[%8]^\8*M$6459,356=*1C,*,DD,A152,6,44*$D*1C,*D5,/9'4C0T56=:*b(('LVY*"+E*H0AT=3$<69*-0=6,1* ["b((\* 54* 1C,*$6/B*.30A15'A0/* 4$<3A,* $D* 1C,* D5,/9'4C0T56=* 1$* -515=01,* EMN* $D* V7((* 56*%8]^* $.,3015$68*V$@,2,3:* 9<,* 1$* 1C,* C<=,* 4,/D'* 069*-<1<0/'569<A106A,* $D* V7((* 069* "b((:* A$62,615$60/* 3,/0152,/B* D041*D5,/9'4C0T56=*41<95,4*@C5AC*A06*H,*$H4,32,9*56*1C,*A04,*<456=*1C,* 9,95A01,9* A$..,3* [$3* PEMMQ\* 4C0T56=* A$5/* $.,301,9* HB*C5=C'D3,a<,6AB* 0/1,360156=* A<33,61* A066$1* H,* 0../5,9* 1$* $<3*%8]^8*?D*1C,*30-.*301,*$D*1C,*D5,/9'4C0T56=*54*4<DD5A5,61/B*D041*1$*569<A,* 0* C5=C* A<33,61* 56* V7((* A$-.$4,9* $D* 6$'564</015$6*O&PMQ*A$5/4:*1C,*569<A,9*A<33,61*D3$-*1C,*D5,/9'4C0T56=*A06*H,*099,9* 1$* 1C,* 13064.$31*A<33,61*069*A0<4,*-$3,*A3515A0/*069*906=,3$<4*$.,30156=*451<015$6*D$3*V7((*4<AC*04*06*$2,3'413056*451<015$6* $3* a<,6AC* $D* 1C,*@C$/,* %8]^*-0=6,148* +C$<=C* 1C,*30-.*301,*$D*"b((*A06*H,*/5-51,9*HB*1C,*.$@,3*95445.015$6*069*/5a<59* C,/5<-* A$64<-.15$6:* 5D* @,* A06*-565-5Y,* 1C,* 569<A,9*A<33,61*9<356=*1C,*D5,/9'4C0T56=:*@,*A06*,J.,A1*1C01*1C,*,DD,A'152,*-515=015$6*$D*1C,*EMN*04*4C$@6*56*1,41'%8*

O&N&O&KM&E*f%g! U<T5T0Y<* ?@040:* R<06* P04A<Wx6:* E,<6=B$6=* V0C6:* R$C6* y$AA5$:*

U$<6=d0,* k5-:* +C5H0</1* "z,A3,2544,:* R<6=H56* E$6=:* 069* k0Y<C53$*k0d5T0@0:* _;* V5=C'O,4$/<15$6* %8]'^VYGb!'--* "+EGV+E* KLO*L0=6,1:`*LHHH!=%-)'5!<((D5!?.(&%9$)*5:*2$/8*)b:*6$8*]:*R<68*)(%b:*;318*6$8*!](%)(b8*

f)g! S8* #03T:* R8* P04A<Wx6:* #8* M8* L5AC0,/:* R8* ",,:* E8* V0C6:* 069* U8* ?@040:*_M$6413<A15$6*069*+,41*O,4</14*$D*M$5/4*)*069*]*$D*0*]'K,41,9'M$5/*7(('LVY* O&PMQ* ?64,31* D$3* 1C,* L?+* %8]'^VY* "+EGV+E* KLO*L0=6,1:`*LHHH! =%-)'5! <((D5! ?.(&%9$)*5:* 2$/8* )7:* 6$8* ]:* ;.38* )(%7:* ;318* 6$8*!](()(b8*

f]g! k0Y<C53$* k0d5T0@0:* ^@,69$/B6* y8* ^,11/5DD,:* U$6=* MC<:* S054<T,*L5B0=5:* +C5H0</1* #8* "{A3,2544,:* E,<6=B$6=*V0C6:* R<06*P04A<Wx6:* 069*U<T5T0Y<* ?@040:* _S,45=64* 069* +,414* $D* EC0T56=* M$5/4* 1$* O,9<A,*

*N5=8*%%8*+C,*1,41*3,4</1*$D*1,41*4,1]*56*1C,*D5,/9'4C0T56=*413,6=1C*$D*[0\*%((*-+:*[H\*b(*-+8*

*

*

b*

EA3,,656=* M<33,614* ?69<A,9* 56* V+E* ?64,31* M$5/4* D$3* KLO* L0=6,1:`*LHHH! =%-)'5! <((D5! ?.(&%9$)*5:* 2$/8* )b:* 6$8* ]:* R<68* )(%b:* ;318* 6$8*!]((](b8*

f!g! R5C$* ",,:* S$6=T,<6* #03T:* #C5/5.* M8* L5AC0,/:* E$* K$=<AC5:* R<06*P04A<Wx6:*069*U<T5T0Y<*?@040:*_;*N5,/9'EC0T56=*EB41,-*1$*O,9<A,*1C,*EA3,,656='M<33,61'?69<A,9*N5,/9*56*1C,*7(('LVY*V+E*?64,31*$D*1C,*L?+*%8]'^VY*"+EGV+E*KLO*L0=6,1F*;*E-0//'L$9,/*E1<9B:`*LHHH!=%-)'5!<((D5!?.(&%9$)*5:*2$/8*)7:*6$8*]:*;.38*)(%7:*;318*6$8*!](%!(b8*

fbg! E8*V0C6:*S8*k8*#03T:* R8*P04A<Wx6:* 069*U8* ?@040:* _V+E*#06A0T,*M$5/4*t51C$<1* +<36'1$'+<36* ?64</015$6:`* LHHH! =%-)'5! <((D5! ?.(&%9$)*5:* 2$/8*)%:*6$8*]:*..8*%bc)|%bcb:*R<68*)(%%8*

fhg! S8*L5B0=5*,1*0/8:*_;6*,J.,35-,610/*41<9B*$6*oD5,/9'4C0T56=l*1,AC65a<,*1$*3,9<A,* 4A3,,656='A<33,61* D5,/94* 56* 0* 6$6564</01,9* O&PMQ* -0=6,1* $D*9$<H/,'.06A0T,* A$5/4:`* .3,4,61,9* 01* ;../8* E<.,3A$698* M$6D8:* S,62,3:*MQ:*ZE;:*E,.8*!|c:*)(%h8*

f>g! M8* #8* P,06:* _L0=6,15Y015$6* $D* C5=C'D5,/9* 4<.,3A$69<A1$34:`*8&M5!N$*5!O1B'5:*2$/8*]h:*6$8*%:*..8*]%|]c:*R068|L038*%ch!8*

f7g! U8*U060=540@0*&0!-D5:*_&DD,A1*$D*A<33,61*4@,,.*3,2,340/*$6*1C,*-0=6,15A*D5,/9*410H5/51B*D$3*0*P5')))]*4<.,3A$69<A156=*4$/,6$59:`*O1B'5!#P!?.(&%/!9$)*5!<((D5:*2$/8*!hc:*6$8*)):*..8*%cch|%ccc:*;<=8*)((c8*