Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar.’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 1
QUARTERLY
REPORT Second Avenue Subway
Phase 1
January, February and March 2016
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar.’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 2
TABLE OF CONTENTS
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ................................................................................................................. 3
MAJOR ACCOMPLISHMENTS………………………………………………………………….. 3
QUARTERLY HIGHLIGHTS .......................................................................................................... 6
STATUS OF THE SAS PROJECT COST……………………………………………………………….. 6
Status of the SAS Project Budget (Expenditures/Cash Flow)…………………………………. 6
FFGA Baseline & Current Budget Summary…………………………………………………. 8
Summary by FTA Standardized Cost Categories……………………………………………... 9
Current Funding Status……………………………………………………………………….. 10
STATUS OF THE SAS PROJECT SCHEDULE………………………………………………………... 11
Overview……………………………………………………………………………………… 11
Completed Milestones…………………………………………………………………………………. 11
Upcoming Milestones………………………………………………………………………… 11
SAS FFGA Schedule Contingency Management……………………………..………………. 13
Integrated Project Schedule Summary………………………………………………………... 15
QUALITY (CONSTRUCTION)……………………………………………………………………….... 16
SAFETY CERTIFICATION PROGRAM PROGRESS………………………………………………… 20
2nd QUARTER 2016 – LOOK AHEAD…………………………………………………………………. 22
STATUS OF CONTRACTS (ACTIVE CONSTRUCTION) ........................................................... 25
96th Street Station – Station Finishes, MEP Systems , Ancillary Buildings and Entrances (Contract
C-26010) ...................................................................................................................................... 25
Change Orders Greater than $100,000 (Approved and/or Negotiated) ............................................... 26
86th Street Station – Cavern Mining, Heavy Civil/Structural Work (Contracts C-26008) ...................... 28
Change Orders Greater than $100,000 (Approved and/or Negotiated) ............................................... 29
86th Street Station – Entrances, Ancillary Bldgs. & MEP(Contracts C-26012) .................................... 30
Change Orders Greater than $100,000 (Approved and/or Negotiated) ............................................... 32
72nd Street Station – Entrances, Ancillary Bldgs. & MEP (Contract C-26011) ……………………… 33
Change Orders Greater than $100,000 (Approved and/or Negotiated) ……………………………… 34
63rd Street Station/Lexington Avenue Station (Contract C-26006) ………………………………… 36
Change Orders Greater than $100,000 (Approved and/or Negotiated) ............................................... 37
Systems – Track, Power, Signals and Communications (Contract C-26009) ....................................... 38
Change Orders Greater than $100,000 (Approved and/or Negotiated) ............................................... 401
STATUS OF CONTRACTS (SUBSTANTIAL COMPLETION)………………………………. 41
72nd Street Station – Station Cavern and Heavy Civil Structural (C-26007)………………………... 41
Change Orders Greater than $100,000 (Approved and/or Negotiated)……………………………... 42
96th Street Station – Heavy Civil, Structural and Utility Relocation (C-26005).................................. 43
Change Orders Greater than $100,000 (Approved and/or Negotiated)……………………………. 44
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar.’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 3
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
MAJOR ACCOMPLISHMENTS
63rd Street Station
Escalator installation is complete and Level 4 testing has been completed.
Elevator installation is complete. Level 4 testing is to commence mid-April.
Fire Life Safety installation is complete. Level 4 testing for the water mist system will
commence mid-April; two of three Dry Fire Stand Pipe tests were completed; all
sprinkler tests are complete.
Tunnel Vent Fans are completely installed. Level 4 testing (startup, local shakedown,
balancing and One and Five hour(s) testing) of the fans is complete. Level 5 testing is
delayed until WAN is available end of April, 2016. Level 6 testing (100 hour test) was
conducted ahead of Level 5 with NYCT approval and is complete.
HVAC system (cooling towers, chillers, AHU’s, and FCU’s) are completely installed.
Level 3 and 4 testing (startup and local shakedown) are complete. Level 5 testing is
next, but must wait on WAN availability end of April 2016. Level 6 testing must wait
until outside temperature reaches 80 degree F.
Third Avenue and 63rd street permanent concrete and asphalt have been placed. This
completes the street restoration work.
Plaza concrete work and finishes (granite and furnishing) is complete.
72nd Street Station
Escalators –Platform escalators are installed. Truss and equipment for Escalator 12
(Entrance 1 Street) has been delivered.
Entrance 1 lower escalator incline arch concrete pours are complete.
Concrete pours for the Ancillary 1 structure (NW corner of 69th St. and 2nd Ave) are
complete. Roof equipment (cooling towers, dry coolers) have been delivered and
connecting piping is being installed.
Wall tile installation at the mezzanine level is complete in the public areas.
Ventilation/Ductwork
Contractor continues to make good progress and is on schedule for mid-June 2016
completion.
Life Safety
Contractor is on schedule for completing by end of May, 2016.
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar.’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 4
86th Street Station
The coordination study for Station Facility Power is complete. Relays have been set
and hi-pot complete. Verizon has installed the phone line. Cable Pulling Switchgear to
Tension Box to PLB Ancillary 2 is complete. Currently Con Ed is completing the trip
check at the North to be followed by Trip Check at the South.
Escalators – All station and entrance escalators are set in place.
Elevators –A full mock up inspection of the Elevator 1 cab was approved with punch
list items remaining.
Contractor has completed all waterproofing and is now at 3rd level above street for
Ancillary 1.
Contractor has completed all waterproofing and is now at street level for Ancillary 2.
Ventilation/Ductwork
Tunnel Fans and motors have been delivered on the north and south ends of the station,
along with the bases and transition pieces.
HVAC Ductwork –Air Handling Units (AHUs) have been installed and wired.
Life Safety
Contractor is one schedule for completion end of May, 2016.
96th Street Station
Station Facility Power – All four feeders into the station have been energized and
permanent power has been provided to the panels in all of the communications rooms
in the station.
Ancillary 1 – The aluminum louvers were installed at the openings on the outside of
the building.
Entrance 2 – The coffer ceiling panels were installed at Entrance 2.
Entrance 3 – The supports for the portal ceilings panels were installed at Entrance 2.
Elevators –Elevator Platform Hold Point Inspection passed on 2/25/16
Ventilation/Ductwork
TSSM (Tunnel Station Smoke Management) – All 8 Tunnel fans installed.
HVAC Ductwork –All Air Handling Units (AHUs) installed and being wired.
Life Safety
Contractor is on schedule for completion by end of May, 2016.
Street Restoration (88th Street to 105th Street)
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar.’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 5
Concrete sub-base for permanent roadway at 90th – 104th Street on the west side is
100% complete with the exception of cross streets and intersections.
Systems
Track Work:
A total of 20,650 LF out of 22,000 LF of track work (approximately 94%) is installed,
including all special work portions (three crossovers).
A total of 18,640 LF out of 22,000 LF of third rail is installed (approximately 85%).
Lubrication system equipment is installed at 96th Station Lubrication Room.
Traction Work:
Completed 72nd Street Traction Power Substation (TPSS) FIAT testing on February
17, 2016. Installed DC Disconnect switches.
Completed 86th Street TPSS DC bus duct installation. Completed control trough
installation.
Completed 96th Street TPSS FIAT testing. Pulled and terminated Medium Voltage
cable from street level into AC switchgear. Con Ed CT’s and PT’s installed and wired
to metering equipment.
Communication Work:
Installed platform cabling for speakers, PA/CIS, help-point and CCTV systems on
both tracks – 63rd Street Station.
Signal - 63rd Street Station:
Installed and wired 5 repeater signals.
Completed work in 1115 CIR for installation of new track circuit, track repeaters and
D relay for #26 signal.
Signal – 72nd Street Station:
Completed relay room breakdown testing.
Signal - 86th Street Station:.
Completed installation and wiring of wall equipment in 1200 Central Instrument Room
(CIR).
Completed pulling rack to rack wires.
Completed relay testing.
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar.’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 6
Signal – 96th Street Station:
Installed Master Control and Trouble Indication Panels in the RTO Tower.
72nd St
Government/Community Affairs
Project Executive Anil Parikh provided a construction update to the Transportation
Committee of Community Board 11 on April 5th as well as an overview of SAS Phase
2.
Held Construction Advisory Committee meetings in late March in each of the four
station areas.
QUARTERLY HIGHLIGHTS
STATUS OF THE SAS PROJECT COST
MTACC is currently managing to a Current Working Budget (Revision 10 Estimate & Post -
Revision 10 updates) of $4.451 Billion, exclusive of $816.614 Million in financing costs. The
MTA Board has approved Local Funds totaling $3.509 Billion. Total Federal participation is
$1.374 Billion, of which $1.251 Billion has been obligated as of June 30, 2015. The 2012 SAS
Grant Amendment (NY-03-0408-09) was executed in the FTA TEAM system on September 19,
2014. The FTA placed a restriction on the 2012 grant outlining that funds could not be
drawndown until MTA and the FTA had executed the revised SAS Phase 1 Full Funding Grant
Agreement (FFGA). The revised SAS FFGA was approved on March 31, 2015.
Status of the SAS Project Budget (Expenditures / Cash Flow)
Budget Total (Exclusive of Financing Costs) (Millions)
Budget Awards Invoiced
$ 4,451.0 B $4,285.0* $3,849.0B
% Budget 96.3% 86.5%
% Awards 89.8%
*As of March, 2016, twelve (12) contracts (incl. Substantial Completions & Close-Outs)
Construction, Substantial Completion & Close-Out Only (Millions)
Budget Awards Invoiced
$ 3,018.5 B $2,982.1* $2,675.4M
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar.’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 7
% Budget 98.8% 88.6%
% Awards 89.7%
*Construction Awards, Substantial Completions, Close-Out and Approved and/or Negotiated
AWOs only
Contingency (Millions)
FFGA Baseline September ’09 Baseline
Current Contingency
Cost Estimate Rev 10*
AWO $214.0 $136.0 ($7.5)*
Executive Reserve $160.0 $160.0 $55.8
Subtotal $374.0 $296.0 $48.3
AFI $209.0 $171.0 $0
Unallocated AFI $0 $0 $0
Subtotal $209.0 $171.0 $0
Total Net Contingency $583.0 $467.0 $48.3
*AWO amount is gross minus value of awarded, negotiated and pending negotiation AWO’s to date. $344.0
(budget) - $351.5 (awarded, negotiated and pending negotiation) = -$7.5
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar.’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 8
FFGA BASELINE & CURRENT BUDGET SUMMARY (As of March 31, 2016)
Design
FFGA Budget**
(A) Current
Working
Budget***
Awarded Value
Expended to
Date
(B) Rev. 10
EAC***
(A-B) Variance
EIS $11,599,831 $11,547,177 $11,547,177 $11,547,177 $11,547,177 $0
PE & FP Engineering**** $227,338,759 $227,227,270* $227,338,759* $227,220,270 $227,227,270 $0
Final Design $172,391,181 $271,827,743 $268,696,012 $259,171,873 $271,827,743 $0
Subtotal Award Value $411,330,771 $510,602,190 $507,581,948 $502,536,190 $510,602,190 $0
FD Reserve****** $(1,330,771) $0 $0 $0
Subtotal $410,000,000 $510,602,190 $507,581,948 $502,536,190 $510,602,190 $0
Construction
FFGA Budget**
(A) Current
Working
Budget***
Awarded Value
Expended to
Date
(B) EAC*** (A-B) Variance
Contracts Awarded & Contingency (incl. AWOs
billed and/or approved) $1,760,307,224 $3,018,539,110 $2,982,062,114 $2,675,361,031 $2,982,062,114 $36,476,996
Contracts Awarded & Contingency (remaining) $36,476,996 $(36,476,996)
Subtotal Including EAC difference $2,686,721,925 $3,018,539,110 2,982,062,114 $2,675,361,031 $2,937,039,110 $0
Current Working Budget – Rev. 10 EAC***** $5,278,075 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0
NYCT Labor $28,000,000 $25,600,000*** $25,600,000 $13,560,029 $25,600,000 $0
EFA $48,000,000 $95,400,000*** $95,400,000 $64,058,359 $95,400,000 $0
Utilities $58,000,000 $91,586,000*** $91,586,000 $58,078,233 $91,586,000 $0
CCM $80,940,647 $170,485,925 $170,485,925 $140,957,857 $170,485,925 $0
Artwork $6,000,000 $6,000,000 $3,687,595 $2,841,505 $6,000,000 $0
Rolling Stock*** 152,999,000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0
Real Estate $240,960,000 $245,000,000 $216,948,428 $210,265,347 $245,000,000 $0
Cost To Cure (incl. Judlau Contracting) $0 $36,500,000 $30,149,957 $28,115,168 $36,500,000 $0
OCIP $160,000,000 $183,000,000 $148,921,676 $148,921,676 $183,000,000 $0
NYCT Force Account $0 $10,343,244 $10,343,244 $3,772,228 $10,343,244 $0
Engineering Services $0 $2,137,406 $2,137,406 $527,583 $2,137,406 $0
Unallocated AFI/Contingency***** $0 $0*** $0 $0 $0 $0
Executive Reserve***** $173,100,353 $55,806,125 $0 $0 $55,806,125 $0
Subtotal $953,278,075 $921,858,700 $795,260,231 $671,097,985 $921,858,700 $0
Total Award Value $4,051,330,771 $4,451,000,000 $4,284,904,293 $3,848,995,205 $4,451,000,000 $0
Total Project Budget/FD Reserve $4,050,000,000 $4,451,000,000 $4,451,000,000 $0
Estimated Financing Cost $816,614,000 $816,614,000 $816,614,000
Totals Including Financing Cost $4,866,614,000 $5,267,614,000 $4,284,904,293 $3,848,995,205 $5,267,614,000 $0
* The Design Consultant, AAJV MODs pending to reduce, PE & FPE CWB/Authorized Contract Value based on final charges.
** The FFGA Budget of $4,050b was based on Rev. 5d (June, 2007). As of December, 2011, SAS is measuring its expenditures and awards in parallel to the approved CWB & EAC.
*** The CWB is based on Rev.10 Estimate & Soft Costs of $4,451B but may appear to be over by $2 due to rounding in Soft Costs & Unallocated AFI (excl. RS). The revised budget includes the deletion of Rolling Stock which the FTA has agreed that Rolling Stock for SAS can be provided from NYCT’s existing fleet
**** Includes Independent Engrg. Consultant (IEC).
***** Unallocated AFI/Contingency funds will be utilized for active contracts Additional Work Order (AWO) needs and/or soft costs. CWB & EACs reflect Rev. 10 Estimate & Soft Costs adjustments. The Unallocated AFI/Contingency based on Post Rev. 10 EAC total is 0.
****** Post Rev. 10 Estimate approx. $2.9M remains for Design Consultant, AAJV (FD/CSS) & MTACC Misc. but funds are encumbered based on Notices to Proceed.
Note Baseline Budget to be finalized with the FFGA.
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar.’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 9
Summary by FTA Standardized Cost Categories (As of March 31, 2016)
Standardized Cost Category Baseline FFGA Current***
Working Budget
SAS Unofficial
CWB/EAC
(Based on 85%
Project Compl)
Award Value**** Paid to Date
10 Guideway & Track Elements $612,404,000 $622,478,000
$189,310,484 $178,091,489 $168,994,391
20 Stations, Stops, Terminals, Intermodal $1,092,836,000 $1,277,642,000
$1,647,638,432 $1,469,943,653 $1,341,146,833
30 Support Facilities: Yards, Shops, Admin. Bldgs $0 $0
$0 $0 $0
40 Sitework & Special Conditions $276,229,000 $524,561,000
$876,979,834 $786,064,876 $753,551,311
50 Systems $322,707,000 $250,134,000
$212,867,395 $196,969,663 $145,953,753
60 ROW, Land, Existing Improvements (incl. Cost-To-
Cure & Judlau Contracting)
$240,960,000 $281,500,000
$281,500,000 $246,636,191* $238,380,515
70 Vehicles ** $152,999,000 $0
$0 $0 $0
80 Professional Services $796,311,000 $1,185,742,929
$1,186,897,730 $1,099,629,946 $984,542,259
90 Unallocated Contingency $555,554,000 $308,942,071
$55,806,125 $307,568,475 $216,426,143
Subtotal $4,050,000,000 $4,451,000,000
$4,451,000,000
$4,284,904,293 $3,848,995,205
Estimated Financing Cost $816,614,000 $816,614,000
$816,614,000
Total
$4,866,614,000
$5,267,614,000
$5,267,614,000
$4,284,904,293
$3,848,995,205
― Notes: PE & FD reflected in 80-Prof. Services-Baseline FFGA. As of the 4th Qtr 2014, Contract C26002 - General Conditions paid to-date of $41.8M Award Value and
Paid To Date were revised and redistributed in SCCs 10. Contract C26002 Award Value adjustment in the approximation of DCB percentages.
― Contract C-26006 (63rd St. Reconstruction) DCBs have been revised by the Contractor. Award Values and Expenditures have been adjusted accordingly to SCCs – 20,
40, 50 & 80. Contract C-26010 (96th St-Shell/Finishes/MEP) Award Value was distributed-SCCs approx.-20- (70%)-40 (25%) & 50 (5%) based on official DCBs received
from the Contractor.
― Contract C-26007 (72nd St.-Heavy Civil & Mining) represents revised DCB awards for SCCs-20 & -40 based on final payment of bid items. Contingency credits are to
be processed. Contract C-26008 (86th Street-Heavy Civil & Mining) represents revised DCB awards for SCCs-20 & 40 per CM. Contract C-26011 (72nd St-Entrances,
Ancillary Bldgs, MEPs was distributed-SCCs.-20- (88.3%)-40 (11.7%) based on official DCBs received from the Contractor. Contract C-26012 (86th St-Entrances,
Ancillary Bldgs, MEPs was distributed-SCCs.-10 (3.6%), -20 (74.8%), -40 (20.8%) & -80 (0.8%) based on official DCBs received from the Contractor. Contract C-26009
(Systems) Award Values and Paid To Date has been revised and redistributed – 10- (19%) -50 (71%) & -80 (10%).
― SCC-90 UC Award Value totals $307,568,475 and represents all contracts contingency of the $344,045,471 budget and $216,426,143 in AWOs paid to-date.
― Baseline budget to be finalized with the FFGA. SAS Unofficial CWB/EAC added to reflect 85% project completion of all construction contracts is subject to monthly
updates.
― Award Values fluctuated due to adjustments in approximations of DCB percentages and Contract C26012 finalized DCBs. In addition, Award Values are not distributed
in SCCs 10, -20, -40, -50, & -80 for AWOs approved/negotiated AWOs.
― * Incl. DHA, Design Consultant - (MOD #57) for $5.7M & Judlau Contracting AWOs for CTC work.
― ** FTA has agreed that Rolling Stock for SAS can be provided from NYCT’s existing fleet.
― *** The CWB of $4,451B is based on Post Rev. 10 Estimate & Soft Costs. RE includes $36.5M for Cost-to-Cure. The CWB-SCCs were updated prior to award of
Contract 2B/2C-96th St. Shell/Finishes/MEP. SAS reassessed the CWB SCCs. The differences in the higher Award Value (i.e. SCCs 20 & 40) in comparison to the
CWB’s derives from the Engineer’s Estimate prior to award and reconciliation with the Contractor(s) SCCs 10-50 reflect 100% construction awards.
― **** Award Values include all contract awards and encumbered Soft Costs. It also includes the increase in TAL which occurred subsequent to Rev. 9. SCC-80
Professional Services include Award Value & Paid To Date for C-26012, C-26006 & C-26009 totaling.
Blue represents revised statement
Pink represents added statement
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar.’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 10
Current Funding Status ($ in Millions) (As of March 31, 2016)
Total Budget (Exclusive of Financing Costs) $ 4,451.0
Budget Federal Local
MTA Capital Programs New
Starts
ARRA
New Start Other
― MTA 1995-1999 Capital Program 0 0 0 0 0
― MTA 2000-2004 Capital Program 1,050 307 0 2.5 741.5
― MTA 2005-2009 Capital Program 1,914 988 79 71.5 774.5
― MTA 2010-2014 Capital Program 1,487 1,487
Total Approved Capital Program $ 4,451 $1,295 $79 $74 $3,003
Value of Contract Awards $ 4,285.0 100%
― Federal Share of Contract Awards
1,171.1 27.3%
― Local Share of Contract Awards
3,113.9 72.7%
Value of Finance Charges Incurred (based on prorate share of
(CWB of $4.451B) $728M
Summary of Federal Grants Received
Grant No. FTA Award Date FFY Obligation
Amount Disbursement
NY030397 –NEW START 6/13/2002 2002 4.980 4.980
Subtotal NY030397 4.980 4.980
NY030408-00 – NEW START 7/08/2003 2003 1.968 1.968
NY030408-01 – NEW START 09/21/2004 2004 1.967 1.967
NY030408-02 – NEW START 8/04/2006 2006 24.503 24.503
NY030408-03 – NEW START 1/08/2007 n/a 0.0000 0.000
NY030408-04 – NEW START 4/9/2008 n/a 0.0000 0.000
NY030408-05 – NEW START 9/25/2008 2008 167.810 167.810
NY030408-06 - NEW START 9/25/2010 2009 274.920 274.920
NY030408-07 – NEW START 9/12/2011 2010 237.849 237.849
NY030408-08 – NEW START 6/22/2012 2011 197.182 197.182
NY030408-09 – NEW START* 9/19/2014 2012 186.566* 107.171
Subtotal NY030408 1.092.765 1.013.370
NY17X00100 - NON NS 9/15/2005 2005 2.460 2.460
Subtotal of NY17X001 2.460 2.460
NY95X009-00-CMAQ – NON NS
(96th Street Station) 9/12/2008 2008 25.633 25.633
Subtotal of NY95X009-00 25.633 25.633
NY95X015-00 – CMAQ-NON NS
(86th & 96th Street Stations) 9/22/2009 2009 45.800 45.800
Subtotal of NY95X015-00 45.800 45.800
NY360001 – ARRA – NS (86th & 96th
Street Stations) 3/2/2010 2010 78.870 78.870
Subtotal of NY360001 78.870 78.870
Total All Grants 1.250.508 1.171.113
*Amend -09 obligation/draw-down approved by FTA since FFGA approved on March 31, 2015.
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar.’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 11
STATUS OF THE SAS PROJECT SCHEDULE
Overview
Schedule information contained within this report reflects schedule status of April 1, 2016.
Through March 31, 2016, construction is 93.4% complete, representing a gain of 2.6% for the
period of January 1, 2016 through March 31, 2016.
Construction progress continues to support MTA’s forecasted Revenue Service Date of
December 30, 2016. This quarter new milestones were established as part of the negotiation of
acceleration agreements. The following milestones were achieved:
Completed Milestones
Contract C-26010 – 96th Street Station: Ancillaries, Entrances, Concrete Work, Finishes
(Arch, MEP):
12 Energize South Facility Power Substation – February 29, 2016
Contract C-26011 – 72nd Street Station: Ancillaries, Entrances, Concrete Work, Finishes
(Arch, MEP):
15 Contract C26009 Access / Turnovers – March 14, 2016
Upcoming Milestones
Contract C-26010 – 96th Street Station: Ancillaries, Entrances, Concrete Work, Finishes
(Arch, MEP):
13 Distribute Facility Power and Miscellaneous
14 Complete Preparations and Installation of Electrical and Mechanical
Systems to Start Level 3/4 Testing
15 Complete Preparations and Installation of TSSM System to Start Level 3/4
Testing
16 Complete Preparations and Installation of Fire and Life Safety Systems to
Start Level 3/4 Testing
17 Complete Level 5a Testing for HVAC, and Fire and Life Safety
18 Complete Preparations and Installation of Elevators and Escalators to Start
Level 3/4 Testing
19 Complete Level 5b Testing for All Systems; Complete All Work
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar.’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 12
Contract C-26011 – 72nd Street Station: Ancillaries, Entrances, Concrete Work, Finishes
(Arch, MEP):
12 Complete work in all Station Service Centers to Allow Full Access.
16 Critical Submittals
17 Complete Facility Power Testing for Energization
18 Complete Facility Power Distribution Testing
19 Start of TSSM Level 3/4 Testing at Ancillary 2
20 Start of TSSM Level 3/4 Testing at Ancillary 1
21a Start of HVAC Level 3/4 Testing – Ancillary 2
21b Start of HVAC Level 3/4 Testing – Ancillary 1
22 Start of Fire and Life Safety Systems Level 3/4 Testing
23 Complete Testing through Level 5a/5b (excluding some Elevators and
Escalators)
24 Complete Testing through Level 5a/5b for Remaining Elevators and
Escalators
Contract C-26012 – 86th Street Station – Excavation, Utility Relocation, and Road
Decking:
11Complete work at station service center for full access.
15 Complete Facility Power Installation and Testing for Energization
16 Complete Installation and Preparation for Level 3/4 Testing of HVAC
Systems
17 Complete Installation and Preparation for Level 3/4 Testing of TSSM
18 Complete Installation and Preparation for Level 3/4 Testing of Fire And Life
Safety Systems
19 Complete Testing through Level 5b
Contract C-26009 – Systems – Track, Power, Signals and Communications
2A and 2B Complete 96th Street WAN/LAN
3A and 3B Complete86th Street WAN/LAN
4A and 4B Complete 72nd Street WAN/LAN
5A and 5B Complete 63rd Street WAN/LAN
6 Complete 72nd Street Traction Power Installation
7 Complete 96th Street Traction Power Installation
8 Complete 86th Street Traction Power Installation
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar.’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 13
9 Complete All Traction Power Installation
10 Complete Track and Third Rail
11 Complete 72nd Street Signal Installation and Level 3/4 Testing
12 Complete 96th Street Signal Installation and Level 3/4 Testing
13 Complete 86th Street Signal Installation and Level 3/4 Testing
14 Complete 63rd Street Signal Installation and Level 3/4 Testing
15 Complete Wayside Signal Installation and Level 3/4 Testing
16 Complete 63rd Comm Systems Build Out
16A Complete 63rd Communications Systems Level 5 Testing
17 Complete 72nd Communications Systems Build Out
17A Complete 72nd Communications Systems Level 5 Testing
18 Complete 86th Communications Systems Build Out
18A Complete 86th Communications Systems Level 5 Testing
19 Complete 96th Communications Systems Build Out
19A Complete 96th Communications Systems Level 5 Testing
20 LAN/WAN Available to All Stations
21 Complete All Testing for All Systems to Start Pre-Revenue Training
SAS FFGA Schedule Contingency Management
To be compliant with Section 6.2 FFGA Schedule Contingency Management of the “Schedule
Management Plan,” MTACC is required to ensure schedule contingency for MTACC is above
the minimums set forth below:
“The FFGA RSD of February 2018 shall apply and a minimum level of schedule contingency of
240 days (i.e., the “trigger point”) through the 3rd Quarter of 2016 (i.e., the “hold point”) shall be
maintained, at which time the schedule contingency minimums will be updated as mutually
agreed. Failure to meet this requirement shall trigger the requirement for a recovery plan.
Ensure that a minimum float of 60 calendar days exists between a contract package’s critical
path “need date” and any ROW/Real Estate activities. All ROW/Real Estate activities are now
complete. Therefore, this is no longer an issue.
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar.’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 14
Minimum differences between the individual Project-level critical path and the next longest
path(s) (namely “near critical” paths) for both projects shall be 25 calendar days.
For period ending March 1, 2016, the MTACC IPS Program schedule is in compliance with the
three of the four (4) ELPEP requirements set forth in the Schedule Management Plan
FFGA SAS RSD
Allowed => February 2018
Actual => December 2016
Real Estate Minimum Float
Allowed => 60 Calendar Days
Actual => All Real Estate Takings are complete as of November 1, 2011 with the last
“Title Vesting” filing occurring on October 25, 2011.
Minimum Secondary Critical Path
Allowed => 25 Calendar Days
Forecast => All critical and potentially critical paths are being monitored on a bi-
weekly basis.
Minimum Schedule Contingency along the Critical Path
Allowed => FFGA 240 CDs through 3rd Qtr 2016 (MTACC Goal - 168 CDs above
FFGA 240 CDs).
Forecast => 59 cds (21 wds) above FFGA 240 cds. Target Revenue Service Date is
December 1, 2016.
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar.’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 15
INTEGRATED PROJECT SCHEDULE SUMMARY
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar. ’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 16
QUALITY (CONSTRUCTION)
Second Avenue Subway Quality Management staff‘s contract specific quality activities included
the following:
96th Street Station: Contract C-26005 (C2A) Heavy Civil
Substantial Completion of Contract achieved.
96th Street Station: Contract C-26010 (C2B) Station Finishes
Daily Inspection Reports (DIRs):
Contractor is not submitting DIRs on a timely manner despite the various requests
to comply with this requirement. Latest DIRs were submitted via EDMS up to 03-
12-16. Currently CTJV is four (4) weeks behind schedule.
QA/QC Meetings:
Quality Meetings were held as follow: 03/09/16 and 4/06/16. Meeting scheduled
for 03/23/16 was canceled as a result of lack of participation of the Contractor
Quality representatives.
Quality Work Plans (QWPs):
A total of One hundred forty one (141) QWPs have been reviewed under this
Contract. Four (4) QWPs were reviewed during the month of March 2016.
Preparatory Phase/Just-in-Time Meetings (PPMs):
A total of seventy four (74) PPMs have been held. One (1) PPM related to Elevator
Enclosures was held this month.
Quarterly Quality Oversights (QQOs):
QQO#13 was conducted on 03/24/16. Report is under preparation...
Inspection and Testing:
Testing Results - not provided on a timely manner. CTJV to provide Pull tests
results performed by Trio (3/22/16) at Platform Floor Pavers and Detectable
Warning Strips prior to stating installation of Platform Pavers
Non Conformance Reports (NCRs):
One Hundred fifty two (152) NCRs have been issued. One hundred twenty nine
(129) have been closed and twenty three (23) are open. A total of thirty seven (37)
NCRs were closed during the month of March 2016.
86th Street Station: Contract C-26008 (C5B) Cavern Mining and Civil/Structural Work
Final vellums, micro-films and as built drawings were completed and delivered.
Substantial completion achieved on 12/16/2014
Ninety-four (94) NCRs were issued all Ninety-four (94) are closed.
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar. ’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 17
86th Street Station: Contract C-26012 (C5C) Station Finishes
Daily Inspection Reports up to 3/7/2016 have been submitted.
Monthly QA/QC meetings were held. Special quality meeting was held on 3/31/2016 to
discuss significant quality issues with 86SCJV senior management and CCM/MTACC and
To date, Eighty One (81) Quality Work Plans (QWPs) have been reviewed for this
contract. Eight (8) QWPs were reviewed during this period.
To date, Fifty Four (54) Preparatory Phase Meetings (PPMs) were held for this contract.
Eleven (11) were held during this period.
Quarterly Quality Oversight#7 was performed on 12/10/2015. Report was issued on
12/16/2015. Eleven findings and two observations were noted. Contractor received a rating
of 85%... QQO# 8 performed on 3/31/2016. Report is in process.
External audit of for JPR conducted 3/18/2016
Inspection & Testing: Results are shown for below items:
Testing of Concrete and Inspection of Rebar- NCRs generated for out of Specification
concrete parameters.
Inspection for fire stopping of masonry wall at beam and wall joints done.
NYCT inspections done for alignment of Escalators and for framing for hydraulic
Elevator.
Mock up inspection for pavers at Mezz
Code compliance inspection by STV for rooms
CCM+86SCJV joint inspection of stairs 3/9/2016of stairs S301,S303
A total of One Hundred and Seventy Eight (178) CNCRs have been issued with Seventy
Four (74) closed and One Hundred Three (103) open (56 are concrete related).
72nd Street Station: Contract C-26007 (C4B) Cavern Mining, and Heavy Civil Structural
As-Built drawings delivered to NYCT.
One hundred twenty-two (122) NCR were issued in this contract. To date, all NCRs are
closed.
Code Compliance certificate issued dated 8/26/2015.
72nd Street Station: Contract C-26011 (C4C) Station Finishes
Daily Inspection Reports were submitted to EDMS up to March 25, 2016.
QA/QC meetings were held on 1/14, 2/11, 2/25, 3/10 and 3/25, 2016.
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar. ’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 18
To date, One Hundred Thirty-four (138) Quality Work Plans (QWPs) have been submitted,
and One Hundred Twenty (132) have been approved. Three QWPs were re-submitted
during this period and approved.
To date Fifty Seven (57) Preparatory Phase Meetings (PPMs) have been held for this
contract. Three (3) PPMs were held during this period for batteries, intumescent pain and
building maintenance equipment. Mock-ups of ceramic tiles, light fixture and platform
service carrier were held during this period.
Inspection & Testing:
Testing of Concrete, grout, mortar and Inspections of rebar and formwork.
Two hundred and twenty four (224) CNCRs have been issued, with one hundred
sixty four (164) closed and sixty (60) open.
Code compliance inspections continued during this period.
Conducted QQOs at C3 and C5 audits.
QQO #9 was held (C4C).
Torqueing of bolts for escalators in Ent. 2.
Duct leakage test was conducted.
Pull tests on granite pavers were conducted.
63rd Street Station: Contract C-26006 (C3) 63rd Street Station Reconstruction
Daily Inspection Reports submittal entered into EDMS is up to 3/28/2016.
QA/QC meetings were held on 1/19, 2/16 and 3/29 as per schedule
To date, one hundred sixty (160) Quality Work Plans (QWPs) have been reviewed.
No QWP revision was reviewed during this reporting period.
To date, fifty-six (56) Preparatory Phase Meetings (PPMs) were held during this
reporting period.
1st quarter 2016 QQO #19 audit was conducted on 02/29/2016. Thirteen findings
were identified. Contractor received a rating of 69%.
Semi-annually scheduled (calendar year) internal (Judlau) audit for December 2015
was carried out at R90 Church Street remote field office on December 31, 2015.
Successfully passed the 100 hour fan test
One System Safety Certification (SSC) meetings were held during this reporting
period on January 27, 2016 and February 26, 2016.
Observation Log training for project staff provided by Bob Daniello was conducted
on March 15, 2016.
Support Securitech door lock testing
Inspection & Testing: Results are satisfactory for all of the below items:
On-going pre-final room inspection throughout station levels
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar. ’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 19
On-going weekly walkthrough inspection with STV and MTACC code
compliance group
Concrete placement and inspection at Plaza sidewalk and elevator, Entrance 1
sidewalk, Entrance 2 stair, level hatch, sidewalk, and roof slab, Resident sidewalk
along 63rd Street.
One hundred and twenty-six (126) NCRs were issued with one hundred-twenty
(120) closed and six (6) open, (1 NA- not applicable), 0 concrete related NCR and 6
regular NCRs).
Systems: Contract C-26009 (C6) Tracks, Power, Signals and Communications
Daily Inspection Reports are current. They are entered into EDMS up to 3/25/2016
QA/QC meetings were held on 1/28, 2/5, 2/17 & 3/23/2016 as scheduled.
To date, Forty-five (45) Quality Work Plans (QWPs) were reviewed for this contract
and Forty-two (42) approved. Three QWPs (3) were reviewed during this period and
comments provided.
To date, Nineteen (19) Preparatory Phase Meetings (PPMs) were held. Four PPMs
were held during this period.
Quarterly Quality Oversight #12 was conducted on 3/22/2016. Report is in process.
Safety Certification meeting were held on 1/21 & 2/26/2016
Configuration Management Plan: CM Office concurred with the letter received from
CSJV to provide configuration management plan as required per contract
specification 17JB, Division 13, 19, 20 & 26.
Draft PQ Manual comments from PMOC was received on 2/16/2016
System Testing & Commissioning meeting were held on with CSJV.
Sixty NCRs were issued to date, 22 NCRs are open (17 Concrete related), 38 NCRs
are closed.
Inspection & Testing: Results were satisfactory for the following items-
Quality Inspection of Installation & Testing of Battery Racks and Batteries
Seismic design review and calculation of signal cable trapeze
Concrete pour Zone 8, 10 & 11 Track S1 1190+60-1210+73
Installation of fire alarm cables & devices
Quality Inspection of Communication, Signal Rooms & TPSS
Splicing Fiber Optic Cables & Copper Cables
Install Speaker cables within the 72nd St complex
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar. ’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 20
Install local signal cables to equipment
Installation speakers, holding lights & prep for CIS screens in 63rd St station
Walk thru with MTACC QA at various work sites for quality workmanship and
contract compliance
Breakdown testing at 72nd St Relay room
Meggering signal cables & plug couplers at 72nd St. Relay Rooms Rack to Rack
SAFETY CERTIFICATION PROGRAM PROGRESS
Safety and Security Certification Program Activities
Safety and Security Certification Checklist:
The checklists for facilities and systems were distributed to all five contractors for final review
and adoption. A meeting was held with all five contractors to explain the changes that were
made to meet the specific requirements of the FTA Safety and Security Certification process.
These checklists represent the project baseline for the completion of the construction/installation
phase of the project.
Body of Evidences (BOEs) to process Safety and Security Certification Requirements
during Construction:
Specific instructions were provided to contractors on what the different Body of Evidences
(BOEs) required are to support the verification of completed Certifiable Items List
(CIL). System Safety Certification program would require various BOEs as follows:
Factory Acceptance Test (FAT) Report
Field Installation Acceptance Test (FIAT) Report
Certificate Of Compliance (COC)
Field Inspection Report (FIR)
Photos
Contract Site Meetings and Visits:
During the work in progress there were meetings held on a monthly basis by the Working Group
at each contract field office. Also there was a field walk-through arranged to see the work in
progress compared to all BOEs submitted by the contractor. All submitted BOEs were reviewed
and verified for their merit. FTA PMOC Representatives and MTA Oversight Representatives
are invited to all TWG meetings. Meeting minutes are distributed to all invitees.
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar. ’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 21
Meeting with FTA, PMOC and MTA Oversight Representatives:
Monthly meetings are held with the above representatives to brief them on the progress of SSC
program.
Administrating SSC Program:
EDMS IT staff uploaded the finalized checklist. IT staff is in the process of modifying the
system to include SSC program, which would provide real-time work progress status. The goal is
to make the EDMS/SSC more effective and user-friendly.
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar. ’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 22
2nd QUARTER 2016 – LOOK AHEAD
Construction
96th Street Station Heavy Civil/Structural Work (Contract C-26005)
Continue C2A contract close-out.
96th Street Station Finishes (Contract C-26010)
Continue the surface utility work on the east side of Second Avenue between 91st and
105th Streets. Complete installation of axial fans for TSSM.
Complete installation of platform elevator.
Complete porcelain tile (artwork) wall at mezzanine, wall and ceiling frame at
entrances.
86th Street Station Civil/Structural Work (Contract C-26008)
STJV will complete sandblasting Entrance 1 architectural finishes at 83rd Street and
Second Avenue.
86th Street Station Entrances, Ancillaries, Station Finishes and MEP Systems (Contract C-26012)
Cotinue installing concrete masonry walls along with doors, HVAC ductwork,
electrical conduit, and escalator machinery in the Platform, Mezzanine, and First
Upper Mezzanine Levels.
Continue waterproofing, reinforcing steel, as well as placing structural concrete
walls and slabs in the Ancillary 1 & 2 areas.
Continue performing street utility work on the west side of Second Avenue between
82nd to 85th Streets.
72nd Street Station: Cavern Mining, G3/G4 Tunnels, and Heavy Civil Structural (Contract
C-26007)
Contractor is expected to finish all punch list items. Release of Final Payment.
72nd Street Station: Entrances, Ancillaries, Station Finishes and MEP Systems (Contract
C-26011)
Axial tunnel ventilation vertical fans will be delivered to the Ancillary 1 Fan room
(3rd Floor).
Facade work (terracotta and granite cladding) will continue on both Ancillary 1 and 2.
BMS panel deliveries will continue. Electrical hookup to HVAC systems will be
installed.
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar. ’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 23
Entrance 1 finish and MEP work will commence.
Con Edison Permanent Enegization will be provided.
Securiplex Watermist system will continue to be installed throughout the project.
Steel stairs throughout the Ancillary buildings above street level will be installed.
Entrance 3 elevator guide rails will be installed and cab deliveries will commence.
63rd Street/Lexington Avenue Station Reconstruction (Contract C-26006)
Continued testing of elevators and escalators
Continued testing of HVAC and fire safety systems.
Continued inspections of all architectural and electrical installations.
Continue architectural installations and finishes to completion at Lower and Upper
Platform (G3, G4, T1 & T2) and all mezzanines.
Upcoming scheduled GOs – One full GO in each month is scheduled for next quarter
to complete ceiling and cable installations.
Tracks, Power, Signals and Communication Systems (Contract C-26009)
Continue wayside breakdown testing on G3/G4 tracks at 63rd Street.
Commence installation of tie-in work for G3 upper level relay room at 63rd Street
between May 2nd thru May 15th.
Commence installation of tie-in work for G4 lower level relay room and 1115 CIR at
63rd Street between May 2nd thru May 15th.
Continue installation of holding/starting and horizontal signals on station platform at
72nd Street.
Continue wayside breakdown testing S1/S2 track at 72nd Street.
Continue wayside visual and breakdown testing S1/S2 track 86th Street.
Continue installation of holding/starting and horizontal signals on station platform at
96th Street.
Continue vital circuit breakdown test 96th St. relay room.
Continue wire termination of Master Control and Track Indication panel in RTO
Master Tower.
Complete installation of Track S1 and S2 in Zones 10 and 11.
Complete 3rd rail installation on Track S1 in Zone 10 and 11.
Continue 3rd rail installation on Track S2 in Zone 10 and 11.
Complete rail distressing in Zones 1, 2, 3, 5, 7, 10, and 11.
Completed air void inspection at all Zones except for the special work portion.
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar. ’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 24
Continue rail painting in Zones 5 and 6.
Continue installation of track lubrication system at 96th and 72nd St. Stations and 72nd
St. Station lubrication room. Completed installation at 96th St Station lubrication
room.
Complete SWP 132A-2 installation north of 72nd Street Station.
Traction Power:
Continue installation of 3rd rail gap jumpers.
Con Ed to witness Hi-pot of 96th Street medium voltage cables.
Con Ed to trip check at 96th Street substation.
86th Street substation FIAT.
Continue the installation of traction power feeder cables to track level from
substations and CBHs.
Communications:
Complete COE Network testing (FIAT/FIST/SIT) in the 63rd Street Station.
Continue copper, fiber and radio antenna cable installation in all stations.
Perform 63rd Street Communication Systems FIAT/FIST (PA/CIS, CCTV, Fire
Alarm, etc.).
Radio UHF Radio Cabinet installation.
Continue COE Network testing (FIAT) in the 96th Street Station.
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar. ’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 25
STATUS OF CONTRACTS – ACTIVE CONSTRUCTION
CONSTRUCTION
96th
Street Station – Station Finishes, MEP Systems , Ancillary Buildings
and Entrances (Contract C-26010)
Contractor: E.E. Cruz/Tully Construction Co. JV Construction Mgr: Martin
Tagliafero Award Date: June 22, 2012
Description: Contract C-26010 is for the station finishes, installation of
mechanical, electrical and plumbing systems in the station, installation of
elevators and escalators, utility restoration, construction of the above ground
structure of the entrances and ancillary facilities, remaining invert slab, street,
sidewalk and tree restoration, and retrofit of the existing tunnel between 99th
and 105th Streets and the base slab of the new bored tunnel from 87th to 92nd
Streets.
Progress, Cost and Schedule Package Milestones C-26010
Station Area - All four feeders into the station have
been energized and permanent power has been provided to the panels in all of the communications
rooms in the station. The platform elevator mockup
was installed, and the track wall tiling is 90% complete. Additionally, the artwork tile at the mezzanine level is
approximately 75% complete.
Ancillary 1 – The aluminum louvers were installed at the openings on the outside of the building.
Ancillary 2 – CTJV is installing dampers for the Tunnel Station Smoke Management (TSSM) System.
Entrance 1 – Framing and clips for the ceiling were installed at Entrance 1. The granite base for the wall
tile is being installed.
Entrance 2 – The coffer ceiling panels were installed
at Entrance 2.
Entrance 3 – The supports for the portal ceilings
panels were installed at Entrance 2.
Street Restoration 88th Street to 105th Street) - Remaining sidewalks on the west side will be installed from 94th to 97th Street and at vent ducts at 104th Street.
East side of 93rd Street backfilled in front of Ancillary
1. Concrete sub-base for permanent roadway at 90th – 104th Street on the west side is 100% complete with the
exception of cross streets and intersections.
Additional Work Orders (AWO’s): As of March 31, 2016, one hundred and ninety-one (191)
Additional Work Orders (AWOs) for a total of $54,977,450 have
been approved and/or negotiated.
Milestone Description Original
Plan
Current Approved
Plan
Actual/Forecast
(Schedule Update #40)
Construction Award 6/22/12 6/22/12 6/22/12 (A)
MS#1–Shared Access 102nd St. 9/22/13 9/22/13 9/21/13 (A)
MS #2-Shared Access 93rd St 3/22/14 3/22/14 2/01/15 (A)
MS#3-Limited Access E&W Sta 10/22/13 10/22/13 10/18/13 (A)
MS#4-Shared Access E&W Sta 9/22/14 9/22/14 03/2/15 (A)
MS#5-Shared Access S. of Sta 2/22/14 2/22/14 6/12/14 (A)
MS#6-Full Access Comms Rms 8/22/14 8/22/14 03/13/15 (A)
MS#7-Full Access Signal Rms 8/22/14 8/22/14 4/31/16
MS#8-Full Access Traction Pwr 8/22/14 8/22/14 11/13/15 (A)
MS#9-Sta Service Centers 11/22/14 11/22/14 1/1/16 (A)
MS#10-All Other Locations 9/22/14 9/22/14 1/31/16 (A)
Substantial Completion 12/22/15 10/5/16 10/5/16
Percent Complete by invoice construction work 88%
Package Costs as of 3/31/2016 Budget Expenditure EAC
Construction Bid $324,600,000 $286,462,848 $324,600,000
Contingency 51,722,000 36,296,057 54,977,450
EFA 9,600,000 5,146,255** 9,600,000
TAL 1,800,000 277,463 1,800,000
Utilities 20,836,734 7,210,795 20,836,734
Total $408,558,734 $335,393,418 $411,814,184
* * Includes Consultant Services expenditures
Construction Costs ($000) as of 3/31/2016 Construction Bid $324,600,000
Construction Bid & Approved/Negotiated AWOs $379,577,450
Contingency $51,722,000
Approved & Negotiated AWOs ($54,977,450)
Remaining Contingency ($3,255,450)
Poured Concrete foundations for lighting/signals at 96th
Street & 2nd Avenue
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar. ’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 26
Safety and Security
Contractor conducted safety tool box
meeting with all crew members every
week.
Contractor secured all
equipment/material storage areas at the
end of shift.
Contractor submitted Safe Work Plans
(SWPs) before the start of each major
activity that were reviewed and
approved by the PB/CCM Safety
Manager. Contractor conducts monthly rolling
safety stand down with all trades.
Safety Statistics
(Cumulative Incidents per 200,000 work-hours)
Project Contract BLS*(“10)
OSHA Recordable Incidents 5.50 5.97 3.2
OSHA Lost Time Accidents 2.14 1.77 1.7
* Bureau of Labor Statistics/National Industry Average
Change Orders Greater than $100,000 (Approved and/or Negotiated this Quarter)
AWO
#
Change Order
Description
Approved/
Negotiated Cost of AWO’s
Impact
Cost Total
38 Door Hardware
Changes Negotiated ($522,300) $0 ($522,300)
121
Con Edison Gas
Layout
Chanes/Support
Negotiated $463,000 $0 $463,000
150
Con Edison Duct
changes from 94th to
99th Street – West Side
Approved $194,000 $0 $194,000
170 Changes to Electrical
nameplates and tags Negotiated $183,500 $0 $183,500
172 Additional surface
restoration work Negotiated $4,000,000 $0 $4,000,000
178 Material change for
fiber optic cable Negotiated $222,000 $0 $222,000
179 Additional work in
lubrication room Negotiated $122,000 $0 $122,000
190
Changes due to
redesign of AFC
equipment and
Facilities
Negotiated $162,500 $0 $162,500
192 Addition of flood wall
plates Negotiated $465,000 $0 $465,000
208 Acceleration of 96th
Street station work Approved $14,000,000 $0 $14,000,000
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar. ’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 27
217
Addition of sprinkler
heads in the fan chiller
room
Negotiated $105,000 $0 $105,000
TOTAL
$19,857,700 $0 $19,857,700
Site Map
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar. ’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 28
STATUS OF CONTRACTS – ACTIVE CONSTRUCTION
CONSTRUCTION
86th Street Station Civil/Structural Work (Contract C-26008)
Contractor: Skanska/Traylor JV Construction Mgr: Martin Hall Award Date: August 4, 2011
Description: Second Avenue Subway Contract C-26008 is for the
construction of the station cavern and entrances for the 86th Street
Station. The scope of work includes mining of the station cavern,
heavy civil work, and construction of the station entrance, ancillary
facilities up to the street and elevator shafts.
Progress, Cost and Schedule Package Milestones C-26008
STJV completed sandblasting activities at Entrance 2 at 86th Street
and Second Avenue.
STJV will start sandblasting Entrance 1 architectural finishes at
Entrance 1 at 83rd and Second Avenue.
Additional Work Orders (AWO’s):
As of March 31, 2016, ninety-niine (99) Additional Work Orders
(AWOs) for a total of $21,757,313 have been approved and/or
negotiated.
Milestone
Description
Original
Plan
Current
Approved
Plan
Actual/Forecast
(Schedule
Update #26)
Milestone 1 (Complete
Station Cavern,
Ancillary 1, Entrance 1,
Surface Work South
85th street and 83rd
street West)
3/04/2014 3/04/2014 4/15/2014 (A)
Substantial
Completion 9/04/2014 9/04/2014 12/26/2014 (A)
Percent Complete by invoice construction work 99%
Package Costs as of 3/31/2016
Budget Expenditure EAC
Construction Bid $301,860,000 $300,679,311 $301,860,000
Contingency 30,186,000 20,906,816 21,757,313
EFA 4,700,000 4,328,820** 4,700,000
TAL 150,000 68,756 150,000
Utilities 3,914,688 355,467 3,914,688
Total $340,810,688 $326,339,170 $332,382,001
* * Includes Consultant Services expenditures
Construction Costs ($000) as of 3/31/2016
Construction Bid $301,860,000
Construction Bid & Approved/Negotiated AWOs $323,617,313
Contingency $30,186,000
Approved & Negotiated AWOs $(21,757,313)
Remaining Contingency $8,428,687
Entrance 1 Decline
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar. ’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 29
Safety and Security
Monthly site safety walkthroughs conducted.
Contractor safe work plans are being submitted
and reviewed by the CCM.
Contractor safety updates are discussed at the
bi-weekly job progress meeting.
Contractor work zone is secured at the end of
the work day.
Safety Statistics
(Cumulative Incidents per 200,000 work-hours)
Project Contract BLS*(“10)
OSHA Recordable Incidents 5.50 0.00 3.2
OSHA Lost Time Accidents 2.14 0.00 1.7
* Bureau of Labor Statistics/National Industry Average
Change Orders Greater than $100,000 (Approved and/or Negotiated this Quarter)
AWO
# Change Order Description
Approved/
Negotiated Cost of AWO’s
Impact
Cost Total
35 Drug and Alcohol Testing Approved $150,610 $0 $150,610
66
Additional Shotcrete in Tunnels and
Pump Room to Meet Waviness
Criteria for Waterproofing
Negotiated $680,000 $0 $680,000
Total $830,610 $0 $830,610
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar. ’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 30
STATUS OF CONTRACTS – CONSTRUCTION
CONSTRUCTION
86th Street Station – Entrances, Ancillaries, Station Finishes and MEP Systems
(Contract C-26012)
Contractor: 86th Street Constructors JV Construction Mgr: Martin Hall Award Date: June 12, 2013
Description: Second Avenue Subway Contract C-26012 is
for the construction of the ancillary facilities above the street,
the installation of station finishes and the mechanical,
electrical and plumbing systems for the 86th Street Station.
The scope includes the installation of station electrical
service, fan plant and pump room equipment, elevators and
escalators.
Mezzanine level inside the station looking South between 84th
& 85th Streets
Progress, Cost and Schedule Package Milestones C-26012
Station Cavern: Installation of HVAC duct
work and electrical conduit continues at all
levels in the station. Installation of wall and
ceiling cladding at the Track/Platform level
and the wall cladding framing at the
Mezzanine level is underway. Mezzanine
service carrier installation is ongoing.
Permanent power equipment and station
systems equipment throughout the station are
being delivered and installed. All thirteen
(13) escalators have been installed in the
station. Work continues on the cladding and
mechanical inter-workings.
Ancillary 1: 86th Street Constructors JV has
completed waterproofing and continues to
install formwork, reinforcing steel, and
placing structural concrete. The Contractor is
now at the third level above the street.
Ancillary 2: 86th Street Constructors JV has
completed waterproofing and continues to
install formwork, reinforcing steel and
placing structural concrete. The Contractor is
now at the street level.
Entrance 1: 86th Street Constructors JV
continues to install escalator machinery
Milestone Description Original
Plan
Current
Approved
Plan
Actual
/Forecast
(Schedule
Update #26)
Construction Award 5/31/2013 6/12/2013
(A) 6/12/2013 (A)
M #1 Complete all work/allow “Vehicle Access” btw
Sta 1209+00 & 1198+00 10/31/2014 11/4/2015 10/24/2014 (A)
M # 2 (North Area) Complete
all work/allow “Limited Access” btw Sta 1209+00 &
1198+00
1/31/2015 1/31/2015 1/31/2015 (A)
M #3 Complete all work/allow “Shared
Access” btw Sta 1209+00 & 1198+00
5/15/2015 5/31/2015 5/31/2015 (A)
M #4 Complete all work/allow “Shared
Access” btw Sta 1198+00 & 1172+00
10/31/2014 10/31/2014 2/27/2015 (A)
M #5 Complete all work/provide “Full
Access”/Turnover of Comm Rms @ South End of
Station
9/30/2014 9/30/2014 4/16/2015 (A)
M #6 Complete all work/provide “ Full
Access”/Turnover of Comm Rms – all locations
except@ South End of Station
3/31/2015 3/31/2015 11/18/2015 (A)
M #7 Complete all work/provide “ Full
Access”/Turnover of Signal Rms located @ 86th St
Station
2/28/2015 2/28/2015 8/17/2015 (A)
M #8 Complete all work/provide “Full 2/28/2015 2/28/2015 8/17/2015 (A)
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar. ’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 31
equipment at Entrance 1, and electrical
conduit.
Entrance 2: 86th Street Constructors JV
continues to install escalator machinery
equipment at Entrance 2. Street level work
on the Entrance 2 elevator at 86th street is
ongoing.
Street Restoration: The Contractor
continues to perform street utility work
between 82nd and 85th Streets west of Second
Avenue..
Additional Work Orders: As of March 31, 2016,
ninety-six (96) Additional Work Orders (AWOs)
for a total of $27,977,916 have been approved
and/or negotiated.
Access”/Turnover of Signal Rms –all other locations
except @ 86th St Station
M #9 Complete all work in Traction
Power Rms @ all locations at North End of Station 2/28/2015 2/28/2015 9/14/2015 (A)
M #10 Complete all work in Traction
Power Rms @ all locations except at North End of
Station
2/28/2015 2/28/2015 8/31/2015 (A)
M #11 Complete all work in the Station
Service Center(s) 3/31/2015 3/31/2015 5/4/2016 (A)
M #14A Provide “Limited” Access to all
other locations South of GL #15 9/30/2015 9/30/2015 9/22/2014 (A)
M #14B Provide “Limited” Access to all
other locations both North & South of GL #15 2/28/2015 2/28/2015 2/28/2015 (A)
M #15 Complete Permanent Power
Work so that it is available & operational including
UPS power.
6/30/2015 4/30/2016 05/25/2016
Substantial Completion 5/31/2016 12/24/2016 12/24/2016
Percent Complete by invoice construction work 78%
Package Costs as of 3/31/2016 Budget Expenditure EAC
Construction Bid $208,376,000 $162,405,173 $208,376,000
Contingency 33,086,320 5,220,942 27,977,916
EFA 10,600,000 3,425,676** 10,600,000
TAL 1,800,000 84,488 1,800,000
Utilities 4,049,188 19,457 4,049,188
Total $257,911,508 $171,155,736 $252,803,104
* * Includes Consultant Services expenditures
Construction Costs ($000) as 3/31/2016 Construction Bid $208,376,000
Construction Bid & Approved/Negotiated AWO’s $236,353,916
Contingency $33,086,320
Approved & Negotiated AWO’s $27,977,916)
Remaining Contingency $5,108,404
Safety and Security
Monthly site safety walkthroughs conducted.
Contractor safe work plans are being submitted
and reviewed by the CCM.
Contractor safety updates are discussed at the
bi-weekly job progress meeting.
Contractor work zone is secured at the end of
the work day.
Safety Statistics
(Cumulative Incidents per 200,000 work-hours)
Project Contract BLS*(“10)
OSHA Recordable Incidents 5.50 1.77 3.2
OSHA Lost Time Accidents 2.14 0.71 1.7
* Bureau of Labor Statistics/National Industry Average
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar. ’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 32
Change Orders Greater than $100,000 (Approved and/or Negotiated this Quarter)
AWO # Change Order
Description
Approved/
Negotiated Cost of AWO’s
Impact
Cost Total
17
Mod #91 Architectural
& MEP changes due to
deletion of SSC AMP
Set 6
Negotiated ($232,000) $0 ($232,000)
73
Replace Marioff
w/Securiplex Water
Mist System
Negotiated $520,000 $0 $520,000
123
Fiber Optics Conduits
Size changes per SK-
140
Negotiated $278,000 $0 $278,000
136
Rearrangement of
Electrical Equipment in
FPR to accommodate
doors from Rooms 3117
A&B
Negotiated $113,600 $0 $113,600
137
Additional Disconnect
Switches in UPS
System
Negotiated $302,000 $0 $302,000
138
72nd Street Station
Entrance 2 Arch
Architectural Cast-In-
Place Concrete
Negotiated $144,00 $0 $144,000
155 Ground and Test
Device in FPR 4103 Negotiated $147,00 $0 $147,000
Total $1,273,400 $0 $1,273,400
Site Map
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar. ’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 33
STATUS OF CONTRACTS – ACTIVE CONSTRUCTION
CONSTRUCTION
72nd Street Station - Station Finishes, MEP Systems, Ancillary Buildings and Entrances
(Contract C-26011)
Contractor: Judlau Contracting, Inc. Construction Mgr: Amitabha Mukherjee Award Date: February 14, 2013
Description: Second Avenue Subway Contract C-26011 is for the
construction of ancillary facilities, 3 entrances, the installation of station
entrances finishes and the mechanical, electrical, and plumbing systems for
the 72nd Street Station. Major construction work includes station electrical
service, fan plant and pump room equipment, elevators and escalators.
Progress, Cost and Schedule Package Milestones C-26011
The platform service carrier grille and conduit
installation is ongoing at the platform level.
Wall tile installation at the mezzanine level is complete
in the public areas.Granite floor tile installation is near
complete.
Entrance 3 (SE corner of 72nd St. & 2nd Ave.) steel
framing for glass and cladding above street level is
ongoing.
Entrance 1 (NE corner of 69th St. and 2nd Ave) street
escalator installation is ongoing. CMU installation in
the basement is ongoing.
Entrance 1 lower escalator incline arch concrete pours
are complete.
Concrete pours for the Ancillary 1 structure (NW corner
of 69th St. and 2nd Ave) are complete. Framing trusses
for the façade cladding has commenced. Roof
equipment (cooling towers, dry coolers) have been
delivered and connecting piping is being installed.
Entrance 2 escalator (Esc. 9, 10, 11) trusses have been
delivered and set in place. Guide rails and balustrades
continue to be installed.
Ancillary 2 (NW corner of 72nd St. and 2nd Ave) finish
work continues throughout all above street level floors.
All final preparations and adjustments to permanent
power equipment within the four facility power rooms
in Ancillary 1 and 2 continue to be made for Con
Edison acceptance.
Milestone Description Original
Plan
Current
Approved
Plan
Actual/Forecast
(Schedule Re-
Baseline #38)
Notice of Award 2/14/2013 2/4/2013 2/14/2013 (A)
M#1 Complete work to allow Vehicle Access
btw 1172+40 & 1163+00 2/14/2014 2/14/2014 2/14/2014 (A)
M#2 Complete work to allow Limited Access
btw 1172+40 & 1163+00 6/14/2014 6/14/2014 6/13/2014 (A)
M#3 Complete work to allow Shared Access
btw 1172+40 & 1163+00 11/29/2014 11/29/2014 12/1/2014 (A)
M#4 Complete work to allow Vehicle Access
btw 1163+00 & 1148+00 2/14/2014 2/14/2014 2/14/2014 (A)
M#5 Complete work to allow Limited Access
btw 1163+00 & 1148+00 4/14/2014 4/14/2014 4/14/2014 (A)
M#6 Complete work to allow Shared Access
btw 1163+00 & 1148+00 6/14/2014 6/14/2014 6/13/2014 (A)
M#7 Complete Work in all Comm. Rooms to
Allow Full Access 8/29/2014 8/29/2014 9/23/2015 (A)
M#8 Complete Work in Signal Rooms to Allow
Full Access 7/14/2014 7/14/2014 12/31/2014 (A)
M#9 Complete Work in All Signal Rooms to
Allow Full Access 9/29/2014 9/29/2014 12/31/2014 (A)
M#10 Complete work in all Traction Power
Rooms @ N. End of Sta to allow Full Access 10/29/2014 10/29/2014 7/27/2015 (A)
M#11 Complete work in all Traction Power
Rooms S. of Sta & 63rd St. to allow Full Access 11/29/2014 11/29/2014 12/31/2014 (A)
M#12 Complete work in all Station Service
Centers to allow Full Access 8/29/2014 8/29/2014 9/23/2015 (A)
M#13 Complete work in all Lubrication Rooms
to allow Full Access 8/29/2014 8/29/2014 12/31/2014 (A)
M#14 Complete work in all Other Traction
Power/Signal/Comm. Rooms to allow Full
Access
8/29/2014 8/29/2014 1/30/2015 (A)
Substantial Completion 11/13/2015 12/312016 12/31/2016
Percent Complete by invoice construction work 77%
Ancillary 1 Installation of Metal Stairs and Truss framing
for Wall Cladding (NW Corner of 69th St. & 2nd Ave.)
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar. ’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 34
Axial tunnel ventilation horizontal fans have been
delivered to the 3rd floor of Ancillary 2 and installation
is ongoing.
Additional Work Orders (AWO’s):
As of March 31, 2016, one hundred seventy-eight (178)
Additional Work Orders (AWOs) for a total of
$52,346,731 have been approved and/or negotiated.
Package Costs as of 3/31/2016
Budget Expenditure EAC
Construction Bid $258,353,000 $186,185,590 $258,353,000
Contingency $63,923,840 27,568,520 $52,346,731
EFA $8,500,000 $4,136,372** $8,500,000
TAL $2,000,000 $144,542 $2,000,000
Utilities $3,333,830 $216,702 $3,333,830
Total $336,110,670 $218,251,726 $324,533,561
* * Includes Consultant Services expenditures
Construction Costs ($000) as of 3/31/2016 Construction Bid $258,353,000
Construction Bid & Approved/Negotiated AWO’s $288,090,539
Contingency $63,923,840
Approved & Negotiated AWO’s $52,346,731
Remaining Contingency $11,577,109
Safety and Security
SWP review is ongoing.
Daily Safety Inspections and JHAT (Joint
Hazard Assessment Team) walkthroughs
are ongoing.
Drug & Alcohol Testing is ongoing.
Random drug testing has been
implemented.
FDNY Inspections are ongoing.
Safety Statistics
(Cumulative Incidents per 200,000 work-hours)
Project Contract BLS*(“10)
OSHA Recordable Incidents 5.50 1.82 3.2
OSHA Lost Time Accidents 2.14 0.81 1.7
* Bureau of Labor Statistics/National Industry Average
Change Orders Greater than $100,000 (Approved and/or Negotiated this Quarter)
AWO
# Change Order Description
Approved/
Negotiated Cost of AWO’s
Impact
Cost Total
18
Remaining Discipline Changes (Arch,
Structural, etc.) due to Con Ed comments
on 30% design drawings
2/3/16 $514,000 $0 $514,000
172 Emergency Lighting for Platform Service
Carrier Changes 1/27/16 $340,000 $0 $340,000
193
Entrance 1 Incline Architectural Stainless
Steel Grill modification to accommodate
changes to JBL Speakers
3/30/16 $219,000 $0 $219,000
194
Wiring and Conduit Changes from Mimic
Panel to Substation and SCADA
equipment
1/27/16 $913,867 $0 $913,867
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar. ’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 35
195 Platform Ceiling Panel Penetrations by
Signal and Strobe Conduits 2/26/16 $110,000 $0 $110,000
198 Facilities Power rooms Pipe encasement 3/10/16 $615,000 $0 $615,000
200 Installation of Sidewalk Bridge at Party
Wall b/w 1322 2nd Ave and 301 E. 69th St. 1/17/16 $110,000 $0 $110,000
215 Station Arch with Coffer Rib CIP
Concrete with Architectural Finish Repair 3/14/16 $236,000 $0 $236,000
TOTAL
$3,057,867
$0
$3,057,867
Site Map
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar. ’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 36
rSTATUS OF CONTRACTS – ACTIVE CONSTRUCTION
CONSTRUCTION
63rd Street Station Reconstruction/Lexington Avenue Station (Contract C-26006)
Contractor: Judlau Contracting Construction Mgr: David Frank Award Date: January 13, 2011
Description: Second Avenue Subway Contract C-26006 includes the
reconstruction of the existing 63rd Street/Lexington Avenue Station. The
work within this contract involves open-cut excavation for the construction
of entrance and ancillary facilities, removal and upgrade of the structural
elements within the existing tunnel, and a traction power connection to the
Lexington Avenue Station on the Q Line.
Progress, Cost and Schedule Package Milestones C-26006
Completion of Mechanical and fire suppression
system installation at various levels and testing
of systems in progress.
Completion of electrical
(Conduit/Lighting/Cable) installation at various
levels. Inspections of electrical installations in
progress.
Completion of installation of Elevator Cars and
Movahle Platforms at area 5. Testing of elevators
in progress.
Completion of installation of the escalator at
Entrance 1. Testing of escalator in progress.
Completion of installation of hydraulic elevator
at Street level. Testing of elevator in progress.
Continue installation of all architectural finishes
at various levels (98% completed). Architectural
inspections throughout the station in progress.
Additional Work Orders (AWO’s):
As of March 31, 2016, two hundred and fifty (250
(excluding Cost-To-Cure & NYCT AWO)) Additional
Work Orders (AWOs) for a total of $27,992,088 has
been approved and/or negotiated
Milestone Description Original
Plan
Current
Approved
Plan
Actual/Forecast
(Schedule Re-
Baseline #51)
Milestone 1&2 - G3 (Upper Level), G4(Lower Level) and Vent Shaft
1/14/2013 1/14/2013
NA (Milestones Eliminated as
part of MOU w/ C-26007)
Milestone 3 - Mezzanine. Levels, Communication Rooms, and Station Service Center
4/15/2013 4/15/2013 2/20/2015 (A)
Milestone 4 - Lower and Upper Platforms and Signal Rooms
10/15/2013 10/15/2013 5/27/2015 (A)
Milestone 5 – Complete all work in Underground Parking Garage
8/302013 8/30/2013 12/30/2013 (A)
Substantial Completion 5/13/2014 TBD 4/28/2016
Percent Complete by invoice construction work 97%
Package Costs as of 3/31/2016 Budget Expenditure EAC
Construction Bid $176,450,000 $170,325,117 $176,450,000
Contingency 29,407,749 23,381,982 27,992,088
EFA 7,700,000 8,065,955** 7,700,000
TAL 10,800,000 10,495,140 10,800,000
Utilities 1,523,305 0 1,523,305
Total $225,881,054 $212,268,194 $224,465,393
* * Includes Consultant Services expenditures
Construction Costs ($000) as of 3/31/2016 Construction Bid $176,450,000
Construction Bid & Approved/Negotiated AWO’s $204,442,088
Contingency $29,407,749
Approved & Negotiated AWO’s $(27,992,088)
Remaining Contingency $1,415,661
Safety and Security
Rebar Installation at Entrance 4
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar. ’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 37
Coordination with FDNY Ladder 16 for
monthly walkthroughs of site/structure.
Ongoing weekly walkthrough with the
Contract Safety Manager/OCIP
Safety Statistics
(Cumulative Incidents per 200,000 work-hours)
Project Contract BLS*(“10)
OSHA Recordable
Incidents 5.50 2.72 3.2
OSHA Lost Time
Accidents 2.14 1.88 1.7
* Bureau of Labor Statistics/National Industry Average
Change Orders Greater than $100,000 (Approved and/or Negotiated this Quarter)
AWO # Change Order Description Approved/
Negotiated
Cost of
AWO’s
Impact
Cost Total
92 Station Service Center Deletion 3/14/2015 ($220,000) $0 ($220,000)
159 Signal Room 2189 HVAC
Modifications 1/6/2016 $115,000 $0 $115,000
165 Additional Fire Dampers in Area 5 3/24/2016 $927,000 $0 $927,000
211 Entrance 1 and Canopy Light Fixtures 2/19/2016 $157,000 $0 $157,000
227 FCU Modifications 3/9/2016 $143,300 $0 $143,300
230 Entrance 1 Miscellaneous Work 2/19/2016 $110,600 $0 $110,600
235 West Fan Plant HVAC Changes 2/4/2016 $130,500 $0 $130,500
249 Platforms in 4” Mezzanine Fan Rooms 2/4/2016 $115,000 $0 $115,000
261 Catwalk/Lighting & IESS Conduit
Extension 3/30/2016 $103,800 $0 $103,800
263 Water Leak Mitigation – Differing Site
Conditions 3/30/2016 $173,000 $0 $173,000
265 Platform Barricades 2/10/2016 $204,000 $0 $204,000
TOTAL $1,961,100 $0 $1,961,100
Site Map
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar. ’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 38
STATUS OF CONTRACTS – ACTIVE CONSTRUCTION
CONSTRUCTION
Systems - Track, Power, Signals and Communications (Contract C-26009)
Contractor: Comstock Skanska JV Construction Mgr: Vyomesh Shah Award Date: January 18, 2012
Description: Second Avenue Subway Contract C-26009 is for the construction of
the tracks, signals, traction power and communication network and equipment for the
Phase 1 stations. The scope of work includes the installation of the low-vibration track,
aluminum rail, way-side signals, and all communication components. This contract also includes the integration of the communication network with the Mechanical –
Electrical – Plumbing Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition (MEP SCADA)
system and commissioning systems for revenue service.
96th Street South Side Protection Board Turnout
Progress, Cost and Schedule Package Milestones C-26009
General: Continued review of submittals and coordination of
Stations Contracts shop drawings.
Traction Power: Wayside negative cables are 90% complete. Positive jumpers are 90% complete.
Continued installation of control wiring and negative power
cables at 63rd Street Circuit Breaker House (CBH).
Completed 72nd Street Traction Power Substation (TPSS) FIAT
testing on February 17, 2016. Installed DC Disconnect switches. Power cable installation - 90% complete.
Continued 72nd Street CBH control cable wiring.
Completed 86th Street TPSS DC bus duct installation. Completed control trough installation. Continued power cable
installation. Commenced installation of DC disconnect
switches – 70% complete. Continued 86th Street CBH lighting and equipment installation.
Completed 96th Street TPSS FIAT testing. Continued
installation of conduits, cable, and equipment at 96th Street TPSS. Installation of power cable and control wiring near
completion. Pulled and terminated Medium Voltage cable from
street level into AC switchgear. ConEd CT’s and PT’s installed and wired to metering equipment - 95% complete
96th Street CBH lighting and equipment installation near
completion.
Communication: Installed platform cabling for speakers, PA/CIS, help-point and
CCTV systems on both tracks - 63rd Street Station.
Installed approximately 90% of all radio antenna cable in
tunnels between 63rd and 96th Street Stations. Continued installing fiber optic cable (80% complete), and PA/CIS cables
(85% complete).
Installed equipment in 20 out of 24 communication rooms. Fiber Optica cable pulling 90% completed at 63rd and 96th
Streets; 5% at 86th Street; and 80% at 72nd Street.
Continued installation of communication equipment in communication closets 63rd Street - 95%.
Milestone Description Original Plan Current
Approved Plan
Actual/Forecast
(Schedule Update
#44)
Construction Award 1/18/2012 1/18/2012 1/18/2012 (A)
Milestone 1 8/18/2012 8/18/2012 9/10/2012 (A)
Milestone 2A/2B (LAN
& WAN) 5/18/2015 6/6/2016 06/06/2016
Milestone 3A/3B (LAN
& WAN) 7/18/2015 6/6/2016 06/6/2016
Milestone 4A/4B (LAN
& WAN) 2/18/2015 6/6/2016 06/6/2016
Milestone 5A/5B (LAN
& WAN) 4/18/2014 6/6/2016 6/6/2016
Milestone 5C 4/18/2014 6/30/2016 06/30/2016
Substantial
Completion 8/18/2016 12/30/2016 1212/2016
Percent Complete by invoice construction work 76%
Package Costs as of 3/31/2016 Budget Expenditure EAC
Construction Bid $261,900,000 $198,050,348 $261,900,000
Contingency 36,952,000 6,442,856 25,231,610
EFA 31,700,002 17,644,944** 31,700,002
TAL 8,241,000 2,123,637 8,241,000
Utilities 870,750 0 870,750
Total 339,663,752 224,261,785 327,943,362
* * Includes Consultant Services expenditures
Construction Costs ($000) as of 3/31/2016 Construction Bid $261,900,000
Construction Bid & Approved/Negotiated AWOs $287,131,610
Contingency $36,952,000
Approved & Negotiated ($25,231,610)
Remaining Contingency $11,720,390
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar. ’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 39
Continued communication room equipment installation at 72nd, 86th, and 96th Street.
Continued wiring equipment and room to room cable pulling.
Completed wayside antenna cable installation, except for the station area is 78% complete.
Signal: 63rd Street Station: Installed and wired 92% of wayside equipment.
Commenced Upper Level relay wayside testing (55% complete). Commenced Lower Level wayside breakdown
testing (45% complete).
Installed and wired 90% of platform signal conduits, signals, and holding lights.
Installed and wired 5 repeater signals.
Completed work in 1115 CIR for installation of new track
circuit, track repeaters and D relay for #26 signal.
Signal – 72rd Street Station: Installed and wired 90% of platform signal conduit, signals,
and holding lights.
Continued termination of wayside equipment from 72nd to 86th Street.
Completed relay room breakdown testing.
Commenced Wayside visual and breakdown testing.
Signal – 86th Street Station: Completed installation and wiring of wall equipment in 1200
Central Instrument Room (CIR).
Completed pulling rack to rack wires.
Completed relay testing. Installation of holding lights and conduit on platform is 90%
complete.
Commenced relay room visual testing.
Signal – 96th Street Station: Platform signal conduits, signals and holding lights – 90%
complete.
Installed Master Control and Trouble Indication Panels in the
RTO Tower. Wiring of panels is 80% complete.
Commenced room breakdown testing.
Continued Dispatchers office contruction - 50% complete.
Track: Installed a total of 21,360 LF out of 22,000 LF of track work -
97% complete. Installed a total of 18,650 LF out of 22,000 LF of third rail.
Continued the installation of LVT block between 72nd and 86th
Street Stations, Track S2. Completed 96th Street Station Lubrication room equipment
installation.
Additional Work Orders (AWO’s):
As of March 31, 2016, one hundred and twenty-two (122) Additional
Work Orders (AWOs) for a total of $25,231,610 have been approved
and/or negotiated
Safety and Security
None for this quarter.
Safety Statistics
(Cumulative Incidents per 200,000 work-hours)
Project Contract BLS*(“10)
OSHA Recordable Incidents 5.50 3.28 3.07
OSHA Lost Time Accidents 2.14 1.09 1.53
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar. ’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 40
Bureau of Labor Statistics/National Industry Average
Change Orders Greater than $100,000 (Approved and/or Negotiated this Quarter)
AWO # Change Order
Description
Approved/
Negotiated Cost of AWO’s
Impact
Cost Total
58
Additional Track
Lubrication
Modifications at 72nd St
Approved $136,000 $0 $136,000
Total $136,000 $0 $136,000
Site Map
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar. ’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 41
STATUS OF CONTRACTS – SUBSTANTIAL COMPLETION
CONSTRUCTION
72nd Street Station - Cavern Mining, G3/G4 Tunnels, and Heavy Civil Structural
(Contract C-26007)
Contractor: Schiavone, Shea, Kiewit (JV) Construction Mgr: Amitabha Mukherjee Award Date: October 1, 2010
Description: Second Avenue Subway Contract C-26007 is for the
construction of the station cavern and G3/G4 tunnels to the existing 63rd
Street/Lexington Avenue Station. Major construction work includes
tunnel mining, tunnel lining, station cavern, station entrance and
elevator shafts. Also includes the demolition of existing buildings at
Ancillary 1 and 2 and utility relocation for support of excavation walls.
Progress, Cost and Schedule Package Milestones C-26007
Substantial completion payment package along with
release of retainage will be submitted to Capital
Payments.
Third Party acceptance from DEP –Water is
completed.
Additional Work Orders (AWO’s):
As of March 31, 2016, ninety-two (92) Additional Work Orders
(AWOs) for a total of $1,325,639 have been approved and/or
negotiated.
Milestone Description Original
Plan
Current
Approved
Plan
Actual/Forecast
(Schedule
Update #38)
Construction Award 7/5/2010 10/1/2010 10/1/2010 (A)
Milestone 1 2/5/2012 7/15/2013 8/9/2013 (A)
Substantial Completion 8/5/2013 1/07/2014 1/14/2014 (A)
Option 1 10/1/2011 10/1/2011 10/1/2011 (A)
Percent Complete by invoice construction work 99%
Package Costs as of 3/31/2016
Budget Expenditure EAC
Construction Bid $446,859,600 $446,859,600 $446,859,600
Contingency 1,381,443 1,381,443 1,325,639
EFA 7,186,292 6,566,030** 7,186,292
TAL 400,000 146,570 1,400,000
Utilities 1,778,208 677,101 1,778,208
Total $457,605,543 $455,630,744 $458,549,739
* * Includes Consultant Services expenditures
Construction Costs ($000) as of 3/31/2016 Construction Bid $446,859,600
Construction Bid & Approved/Negotiated AWO’s $448,185,239
Contingency $1,381,443
Approved & Negotiated AWO’s $(1,325,639)
Remaining Contingency $55,804
Completed High Bench with Manhole in G3 TBM Tunnel
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar. ’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 42
Safety and Security
Housekeeping efforts continue to be observed during
day time shift at street top/underground operations.
PFAS and PPE continue to be maintained.
Perimeter fall (garlocks) protection continues to be
implemented at all leading edge hazards at street
top/underground operations. A temporary mezzanine
deck system continues to be utilized in the main
cavern to access the main cavern arch. Lighting
continues to be maintained under the deck system.
PFAS, PPE, and perimeter fall protection
maintained.
Safety Statistics
(Cumulative Incidents per 200,000 work-hours)
Project Contract BLS*(“10)
OSHA Recordable Incidents 5.50 6.63 3.2
OSHA Lost Time Accidents 2.14 2.95 1.7
* Bureau of Labor Statistics/National Industry Average
Change Orders Greater than $100,000 (Approved and/or Negotiated this Quarter)
AWO
# Change Order Description
Approved/
Negotiated Cost of AWO’s Impact Cost Total
33 Impact costs associated with AWO
#31 & AWO #42 5/7/2014 $0 $930,000 $930,000
TOTAL $0 $930,000 $930,000
Site Map
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar. ’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 43
STATUS OF CONTRACTS – SUBSTANTIAL
COMPLETION
CONSTRUCTION
96th Street Station Heavy Civil, Structural and Utility Relocation (Contract C-26005)
Contractor: E.E. Cruz/Tully
Construction Co. JV
Construction Mgr:
Martin Tagliafero Award Date: May 28, 2009
Description: Second Avenue Subway Contract C-26005 is for the
heavy civil/structural construction involving utility relocation,
demolition of existing buildings, underpinning, slurry wall
construction, excavation, and station invert slab of the 96th Street
main station box, entrances and ancillary facilities.
NOTE: Federal Funds from the American Recovery and
Reinvestment Act (ARRA) were approved for this contract on
March 5, 2010 in the amount of $69,243,887.
Progress, Cost and
Schedule
Package Milestones C-26005
CTJV continues to address the
punchlist items. Approximately
95% of the punchlist items were
completed.
Additional Work Orders
(AWO’s):
As of March 31, 2016, one hundred and
seventy-six (176) Additional Work Orders
(AWOs) for a total of $47,615,409 have been
approved and/or negotiated.
Milestone Description Original Plan Current Approved
Plan
Actual/Forecast
(Schedule Update #52)
Construction Award 10/31/2008 5/28/2009 5/28/2009 (A)
Milestone #1 (North Station
Area – 97th to 99 St. Work) 10/20/2010 4/22/2013 8/19/2013 (A)
Milestone 2 (Ancillary 1,
Entrance 1 and 2, & South
St. Area but excl. Opt 2)
4/21/2011 8/7/2012 11/5/2013 (A)
Substantial Completion 1/11/2012 4/22/2013 11/5/2013 (A)
Percent Complete by invoice construction work 99%
Package Costs as of 3/31/2016 Budget Expenditure EAC
Construction Bid $325,000,000 $325,000,000 $325,000,000
Contingency 49,774,000 47,615,409 47,615,409
EFA 4,850,026 4,738,893** 4,850,026
TAL 57,076 57,056 57,076
Utilities 17,324,882 11,643,798 17,324,882
Total $397,005,984 $389,055,156 $394,847,393
* * Includes Consultant Services expenditures
Construction Costs ($000) as of 3/31/2016 Construction Bid $303,863,700
Option 1 $17,526,300
Option 2 $3,610,000
Construction Bid (Includes Options) $325,000,000
Construction Bid/Options & Approved/Negotiated AWOs $372,615,409
Contingency $49,774,000
Approved & Negotiated AWOs $(47,615,409)
Remaining Contingency $2,158,591
CMU Wall Installation at Entrance 1
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar. ’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 44
Safety and Security
Safety Statistics
(Cumulative Incidents per 200,000 work-hours)
Project Contract BLS*(“10)
OSHA Recordable Incidents 5.50 6.63 3.2
OSHA Lost Time Accidents 2.14 .85 1.7
* Bureau of Labor Statistics/National Industry Average
Change Orders Greater than $100,000 (Approved and/or Negotiated this Quarter)
AWO
# Change Order Description
Approved/
Negotiated
Cost of
AWO’s
Impact
Cost Total
130 Special Inspections Inside
Rainbow Hardware Approved $104,000 $0 $104,000
151
Existing Elevated Train
footings inside of Main
Station Excavation
Approved $275,000 $0 $275,000
TOTAL $379,000 $0 $379,000
Site Map
Quarterly Review Report – 1st Quarter 2016
(Quarterly Report Jan., Feb., Mar. ’16) Second Avenue Subway – Phase 1 (16.0.1) 45