QuarterlyRevenueReport:FiscalYear2015‐Q4
TaxRevenueResearch,UpdatesbyQuarterIncludingMonthlyRevenue
TableIllinoisDepartmentofRevenue
2
TableofContents
EconomicReports Page
NationalEconomy .............3
IllinoisEconomy .............7
IncomeTaxReports
IndividualIncomeTax(IIT) .............8
CorporateIncomeTax(CIT) .............11
Sales&ExciseTaxReports
Sales&UseTax .............13
PublicUtilitiesTaxes .............14
LiquorTax .............15
MotorFuelTaxes .............16
CigaretteandCigaretteUseTaxes .............17
OtherTobaccoProductsTax .............17
HotelOperators’OccupationTax(HOOT) ............. 18
EstateTax .............20
RealEstateTransferTax(RETT) .............21
Appendix
ComparisonwithLastFiscalYearandIDORForecasts ............. 23
US&IllinoisEmployment ............. 24
Acknowledgements .............25
3
NationalEconomy
BankingandCreditMarketsTheFederalOpenMarketsCommittee(FOMC)reaffirmeditsFederalFundsInterestratetargetrangeofbetweenzeropercentand¼percentattheJune16‐17meeting.Meetingminutesindicatethatthecommitteewillnotadoptapolicyofahighertargetrateuntilitis“reasonablyconfident”thatinflationwillapproachtwopercentinthemediumtermandlabormarketconditionswillimprove.EvenifeconomicconditionsproceedinthedirectiontheFOMCdesires,thismaynotleadtosubstantiallyhigherinterestrates.TheFOMCfinallystatedthatit“currentlyanticipatesthat,evenafteremploymentandinflationarenearmandate‐consistentlevels,economicconditionsmay,forsometime,warrantkeepingthetargetfederalfundsratebelowlevelstheCommitteeviewsasnormalinthelongerrun.”1Excessreservesofdepositoryinstitutionsarenearly$2.5trillionandaremotivatedbyacombinationofinterestpaidofonexcessreservesbytheFederalReserveBank(Fed)andageneralperceptionamongloanofficersinthebankingindustryofcounterpartyrisk.2TheFedbeganpayinginterestonexcessreservesbackinOctober2008aspartoftheFederalServicesRegulatorReliefActof2006.3TheFedwilllikelyincreasetheInterestonExcessReserves(IOER)rate,currently¼percent,inordertopressuptheFederalFundsRate.4IftheFedincreasestheIOERrate,itreducestheincentiveforbankstoloanexcessreserves,evenifriskperceptiondeclines.BanksareexpectedtocontinueholdinglargeexcessreservesuntiltheperceivedriskislowenoughrelativetotheIOERratetomakelendingtheexcessreservespreferredtomaintainingthereserves.Chart1
1 Meeting Minutes of the Federal Open Markets Committee, June 16th and 17th, 2015 http://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/files/fomcminutes20150617.pdf 2 FRED Economic Data, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis https://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/EXCSRESNS/ 3 Regulation D: Reserve Requirements for Depository Institutions, Final Rule, By order of the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, June 17, 2015. 4 Ibid
0
500000
1000000
1500000
2000000
2500000
3000000
Excess Reserves of Depository Institutions ($ in Millions)
Excess Reserves of Depository Institutions
4
Source:FederalReserveBankofSt.Louis
TheAprilSeniorLoanOfficer’sOpinionSurveyonBankLendingPracticessuggestsbanksremainriskaverseandunwillingtobroadlylowercommerciallendingstandards.Forexample,commercialandindustriallending(C&I)haschangedverylittleinrecentmonths.Afewbanksreportedeasingofstandardswhileotherbanksreportedtighterstandards.TheoverallchangeinthesupplyofC&Iloansisnotmeaningful.Meanwhile,demandforC&Iloanshasbeenmixed.WhilethemajorityofbanksexperiencednoincreaseindemandforC&Iloans,afewdidhavemoredemandforloansrelatedtoplantsandequipment,financingreceivables,andinventoryaccumulationwhilesomeexperienceddemanddecreasedformergersandacquisition(M&A)financingandcustomerborrowingduetomovingborrowingactivitytoanotherbankornon‐banksource.Commercialrealestatelendingstandardshaveloosenedsomewhat.Lendingstandardsfornon‐farmnon‐residentialpropertieshaveeased.Afewlargebankshaveeasedlendingstandardsforconstructionandlanddevelopmentloans,aswellasmultifamilyproperties.Anincreasingnetfractionofbanksarereportingstrongerdemandforconstructionandlanddevelopmentloans.5Residentialrealestatelendingstandardsremaingenerallytight,withtheexceptionofloanseligibleforpurchasebygovernmentsponsoredenterprisesandqualifiedmortgagejumboloans.Demandforresidentialrealestateloanshasincreasedmodestlyduringthesurveyperiod.Lendingstandardsforautoloansandconsumerloans,otherthancreditcards,easedatafewlargebanks.GDPAggregates,Employment,andtheNationalDebtEconomicactivitydeclinedinsomesectorsofthenationaleconomybutincreasedinothersduringthefirstquarterof2015.RealGrossDomesticProduct(RGDP),decreasedatanannualrateof0.2percentinthefirstquarterof2015.6Importantly,themajorityofeconomicsectorsperformedquitewell.Fairlylargedeclineswereexperiencedinsomesectorsoftheeconomybutnotsufficienttoraiseconcernsofageneralslowdownintheeconomy.Infact,consumereconomicactivityincreasedbroadlyacrosstheeconomy,asdidcertainkindsofinvestment.TheU.S.BureauofEconomicAnalysisestimatesrealpersonalconsumptionexpendituresincreased2.1percent.Theservicesectorexperiencedthestrongestgrowthat2.7percent,whiledurablegoodsandnondurablegoodsincreased1.3percentand0.8percent,respectively.7Mostmeasuresofinvestmentimprovedduringthefirstquarter.Investmentinequipment,intellectualpropertyandresidentialfixedinvestmentallincreasedby2.6percent,4.9percentand6.5percentrespectively.Notwithstandinggrowthintheaboveinvestmentsectors,nonresidentialfixedinvestmentintotaldeclined2.0percentasacategorybecauseofthe18.8percentdecreaseinnonresidentialstructureinvestment.Thedeclineinnonresidentialinvestmentisnotexpectedtopersist.AscitedearlierfromtheFederalReserveBank’sSeniorLoanOfficer’sOpinionSurvey,morebanksarenowexperiencingincreaseddemandforcommercialconstructionandlanddevelopmentloans.Furtherevidencefromstrongindustrial
5 The April 2015 Senior Loan Officer Opinion Survey on Bank Lending Practices, http://www.federalreserve.gov/boarddocs/snloansurvey/201505/default.htm 6 U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis, National Income and Product Accounts, Gross Domestic Product: First Quarter 2015 (Third Estimate) http://www.bea.gov/newsreleases/national/gdp/gdpnewsrelease.htm 7 Ibid
5
capacityutilization–discussedindetailbelow–suggestlittlelikelihoodofaprolongednonresidentialstructureinvestmentslump.ThetwoothersourcesoftherecentdeclineinrealGDPareexchangerates/internationaltradeandstateandlocalgovernmentspending.ThestrongU.S.dollarvis‐à‐vistheEuroandothercurrenciescausedrealexportstodecline5.9percentandrealimportstoincrease7.1percent.Whiletotalgovernmentspendingremainedflat,thestateandlocalshareofgovernmentspendingdeclined1.0percent.8Federaldebtasashareoftheeconomyhasstabilizedatahistoricallyhighlevelsincethefirstquarterof2013fluctuatinginarangebetween100percentofGrossDomesticProduct(GDP)to102percentofGDP.ThemostrecentdebttoGDPfigures(firstquarterof2015)remainedelevated,slightlyinexcessof102percentGDP.9TheEurozone,bycomparison,ended2014withadebttoGDPratioofjustunder92percent.Greece,Italy,Portugal,Ireland,Cyprus,andBelgiumaretheonlyEurozonenationswithdebttoGDPratiosexceedingtheUnitedStates.BycomparisontheOfficeforBudgetResponsibility,expectsBritaintohaveadebttoGDPratioofjustover80percentbytheendofthefiscalyear.10,11Chart2
Source:FederalReserveBankofSt.Louis
Totalnonfarmpayrollemploymentincreasedby223,000inJuneandtheunemploymentratefellto5.3percent.Householdsurveydatasaysunemploymentratesremainhigherthanthenationalaveragefornon‐Asianminoritiesandteenagers.Thenumberoflong‐termunemployed
8 Ibid 9 FRED Economic Data, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis and U.S. Office of Management and Budget https://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/GFDEGDQ188S/ 10 http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/economics/11552293/Europes-debt-mountain-just-got-bigger.html 11 http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/budget/11480283/Budget-2015-Government-will-use-borrowing-windfall-to-pay-down-Britains-debt-mountain.html
0.0%
20.0%
40.0%
60.0%
80.0%
100.0%
120.0%
Federal Debt ‐ Percent of GDP Seasonally Adjusted
Total Public Debt as Percent of GDP
6
fellby381,000.Thesurveydatashouldbeobservedagainstthebackdropofacivilianlaborforcethatdeclinedby432,000inJunefollowingasimilarmagnitudeinMay.12Whenfewerpeopleparticipateinthelaborforcefewmustbeemployedtokeeptheunemploymentratelow.Laborforceparticipationdeclinedby0.3percentinJune.Someeconomistsprefertheemploymenttopopulationratioasasuperiormeasureofunemploymenttotheunemploymentrate.InJune,theemploymenttopopulationratioisjust59.3percent.Inthe25yearsfrom1984to2008theemploymenttopopulationratioaveraged62.5percent.Theratiohasnotexceeded60percentsinceFebruary2009.13
PricesandProductionTheConsumerPriceIndexforallitems(CPI‐U)experiencedzeroincreaseinthetwelvemonthsendingMay2015.Oncefoodandenergypricesarebackedoutoftheindex,pricesincreased1.7percentoverthesameperiod.Whilemanyitemshavebecomemoreexpensiveoverthelastyear,energypriceshavedeclinedsubstantiallyoffsettinginflationelsewhere.Gasolineandfueloilfell25percentand27.6percent,respectively,overthelastyear,butpriceshaverecentlystartedsurgingbackup.InMay,gaspricesincreased9.6percent,andfueloilincreased10.4percent,comparedwithApril.14TheProducerPriceindex(PPI)forfinaldemandincreased0.5percentinMaycomparedtoAprilbutdeclinedby1.1percentcomparedwiththesamemonthoneyearago.Thisisthefourthconsecutivemonthofyear‐over‐yeardeclinesinproducerprices.Aswasthecaseinconsumerprices,theproducerpriceindexforgasolineincreased17percentinMay.Pricesfordieselfuel,chickeneggs,jetfuel,pharmaceuticalpreparations,andmotorfuelalsoincreased.Pricesfornaturalgas,hay,hayseeds,oilseeds,andbasicorganicchemicalsalldecreased.ThepriceofintermediategoodsalsoincreasedinMay,comparedwithApril.Theindexwasdrivenupprimarilybya5.8‐percentriseinthepriceforprocessedenergygoods.15Industrialproductiondecreased0.2percentinMaybecauseofdeclinesinmanufacturingandminingoutput.Miningproductionwasparticularlyaffectedbydeclinesinoilandgaswelldrillingactivity.Industrialproductionofmotorvehiclesandpartsleadincreasedproductionwitha1.7percentgain.Capacityutilizationfortheindustrialsectordecreased0.2percentinMayto78.1percent,aratethatis2.0percentagepointsbelowitslong‐run(1972–2014)average.16
12 U.S. Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics, Employment Situation New Release, July 2, 2015. http://www.bls.gov/news.release/archives/empsit_07022015.htm 13 Ibid 14 U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Consumer Price Index News Release May 2015, http://www.bls.gov/news.release/cpi.nr0.htm 15 U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Producer Price Index News Release May 2015 http://www.bls.gov/news.release/ppi.nr0.htm 16 Industrial Production and Capacity Utilization – G.17 Release Date June 15, 2015 http://www.federalreserve.gov/releases/g17/Current/default.htm
7
IllinoisEconomyUncertaintycontinuestoweighupontheIllinoiseconomy.TheSupremeCourtdecisiononIllinoisworkerpensionswillmakeachievingsavingsthroughreductionsinthe$100billionunfundedactuarialaccruedliabilitymoredifficultandaddslong‐termuncertaintyabouttaxesandthestatebudget.Furthermore,theinabilityofpolicymakerstoachieveabudgetdealaddsadditionalshort‐rununcertaintyforhouseholdsandentrepreneursregardinghowtheStatemightgoaboutclosingabudgetgapofmorethan$4billion.WhenentrepreneursweightheeconomicupsideofIllinois—awell‐educatedworkforce,excellenttransportationinfrastructure,andindustrialdiversity—againsttheuncertaintyofhigherstateincometaxesorcostsbeingpasseddowntolocalgovernments(creatingpropertytaxuncertainty)inboththeshortandlongterm,theirinvestmentcalculuswillnodoubtbeinfluencedvis‐à‐visotherstateswithmorestablefiscalconditionsandsimilareconomicpositives.Ameasureofnear‐termeconomicgrowthexpectationsisthePhiladelphiaFederalReserveBankIndexofLeadingEconomicIndicators.Theindexmeasuresthesix‐monthgrowthinthestate’scoincidentindex.Thecoincidentindextakesintoaccountfourstate‐levelvariables,includingnonfarmpayrollemployment,averagehoursworkedinmanufacturing,theunemploymentrate,andwageandsalarydisbursementsdeflatedbytheconsumerpriceindex(U.S.cityaverage).Thetrendforeachstate’sindexissettothetrendofitsgrossdomesticproduct(GDP),solong‐termgrowthinthestate’sindexmatcheslong‐termgrowthinitsGDP.17Illinoiscoincidentindexisexpectedtogrowjust1.07percentinthenextsixmonths,comparedwithanationalaverageof1.64percent.18 InspiteofIllinois’growingpopulation,thelaborforceissmallerandfewerpeopleareworking.TheIllinoislaborforcehasbeeninsteadydeclinesince2007.19Thelaborforcehasdeclinedbymorethan224thousandworkersoverthatperiodandhasdemonstratednosignofrecoverysincetheendofthegreatrecession.Andeventhoughtheunemploymentrateis5.9percent,thereare237thousandfeweremployedworkersinIllinoisthantherewereatthe2007peak.Itisestimatedthatbetween2007and2014theIllinoispopulationovertheageof16grewbetween2007and2014bymorethan309thousandpeople,butparticipationinthelaborforceshrankby3.5percentfrom68.4percentto64.9percentfromthe2007peaklevels.20Theemploymenttopopulationration,belowinTable3,hasbeenindeclinesince1999,fromahighof66.5percenttoitscurrentlevelof60.3percent.Illinoislevelofemploymentincreasedby9,200jobsinMay,buttheprivatesectorgrewbyjust6,900afterbackingoutnewgovernmentjobs.Amongthetopperformingsectorswerebusinessandprofessionalservicesadding6,900jobstothepayroll,whileleisureandhospitalityadded
17 Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia, State Coincident Index, https://www.philadelphiafed.org/research-and-data/regional-economy/indexes/coincident 18 Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia, Leading Index Revised Data, downloaded from: https://www.philadelphiafed.org/ on July 15, 2015 19 Population is growing because of immigration. Net domestic migration is negative in Illinois. U.S. Department of Commerce, U.S. Census Bureau, State-to-State migration flows, Table 1. http://www.census.gov/hhes/migration/data/acs/state-to-state.html 20 United States Bureau of Labor Statistics, Employment status of the civilian non-institutional population 16 years of age and over by region, division, and state and Local Area Employment Statistics. http://www.bls.gov/news.release/srgune.t01.htm
8
another3,300jobs.Mostjoblosseswereinthreesectors:Manufacturing(2,500jobs),TradeTransportationandUtilities(2,300jobs),andFinancialActivities(1,200jobs).21AveragehourlywagesforallindustriesonaverageremainedrelativelyflatinMay–up16centsperhour—comparedwithApril.Hourlywageratesformostindustrieschangedlessthan$1perhourcomparedwithoneyearago.Industrieswithaveragehourlywagegreaterthan$1perhourinclude:Construction($2.66),PrintingandRelated($1.52),andWholesaleElectronicMarkets($4.20).AveragehoursworkedforallindustriesremainedunchangedinMay,comparedwithApril.Threeindustriesexperiencedachangeinaveragehoursofworkofonehourormore.TheFoodManufacturingindustryincreasedtheaverageworkweekbyonehourwhileMotorVehicleandPartsDealersreducedtheaverageworkweekonehour.WholesaleElectronicMarketsreducedtheaverageworkweekthefurthest,withadeclineof1.2hours.22Table3
21 Illinois Department of Employment Security, Current Employment Statistics, Monthly Statewide Data (2000-Present) Seasonally Adjusted Report, downloaded from: http://www.ides.illinois.gov/LMI/Pages/CES.aspx on July 15, 2015 22 Illinois Department of Employment Security, Current Employment Statistics, Ave Hrs Worked, Hourly Earnings, Hrs Worked – Hourly Earnings (Monthly 2003 – Current) Downloaded from http://www.ides.illinois.gov/LMI/Pages/CES.aspx on July 15, 2015
52
54
56
58
60
62
64
66
68
Illinois Employment to Population Ratio
Employment as a Percent of Civilian Noninstituional Population (over 16)
Poly. (Employment as a Percent of Civilian Noninstituional Population (over 16))
9
IndividualIncomeTax(IIT)
IITrevenueendedthefiscalyearat$17,682million,3.8percent($705.7million)belowFY2014but4.1percent($688.9million)aboveIDORfiscalyear2015forecast.TheratedecreaseineffectsinceJanuaryof2015pushedIITrevenuedowninthesecondpartofthefiscalyearcomparedwiththeyearbefore.Ontheotherhand,however,bothwithholdingsandnon‐withholdingsperformedbetterthanexpected,resultinginabetterthanforecastresultfortheyear.IITreceiptswere4.4percentabovetheHR389estimate.
Chart4
Withholdingreceipts(WIT)WITreceiptsendedthefiscalyear7.5percent($1,093.9million)belowfiscalyear2014becausetheindividualincometaxratedecrease,from5.0%to3.75%effectivesinceJanuary1,2015.
Withholdingreceiptsperformedconsiderablybetterthanforecastendingthefiscalyear3.4percent($443.3million)aboveestimate.TheDepartmentofRevenueestimatesthatapproximately52percent($230million)ofthewithholdingsinexcessofforecastareduetoslowadjustmentstothechangeinthetaxrate.Inotherwords,someemployerscontinuetowithholdatthe5percentrateinsteadofthelowerrateafterJanuary1,2015.Thatover‐withholdingamountwillbereflectedinlowerfinalpaymentsand/orhigherrefundsduringtheJanuary2016toApril2016taxfilingseason.Excludingtheover‐withheldamount,the“true”revenueaboveforecastisabout$213.3million.
Non‐withholdingreceipts(non‐WIT)Non‐WITreceiptsendedthefiscalyearat$4,204.5million,10.2percent($388.2million)abovelastfiscalyearanda6.2percent($245.6millions)aboveourforecast.
$0
$1,000
$2,000
$3,000
$4,000
$5,000
$6,000
$7,000
$Millions
Fiscalyearandquarter
IITRevenue
10
Weexpectedthatthiscomponentwouldnotdeclineproportionatelytotheratedecreasebecausetaxpayerstendtobaseestimatedpaymentsontheprioryearliabilitytomitigatepenaltyrisk.Theunexpectedincreaseislikelyrelatedtocapitalgainsrealizations.Abouthalfofthegrowthofnon‐WITcameviaextensionpayments;therestofthegrowthisalmostevenlysplitbetweenfinalandestimatedpayments.Asinthecaseoftheover‐withholdingamountmentionedabove,thehighFY2015estimatedpaymentsamountwilllikelyhavesomedetrimentalimpactonrevenuenexttaxseason,bydecreasingfinalpaymentsorincreasingrefunddemands.
Payment totals match the Comptroller’s receipts. Withholding and estimated and final payments are derived from IDOR collection data and in-transit fund data. Totals may not equal individual components due to rounding.
Components Year‐to‐Date ($ millions)
Actual Forecast $ Difference % Difference Withholding $13,477.4 $13,034.2 $443.3 3.4% Non‐Withholding $4,204.5 $3,958.9 $245.6 6.2% Total $17,682.0 $16,993.1 $688.9 4.1%
FY2014 FY2015 $ Difference % Difference Withholding $14,571.4 $13,477.4 ‐$1,093.9 ‐7.5% Non‐Withholding $3,816.3 $4,204.5 $388.2 10.2% Total $18,387.7 $17,682.0 ‐$705.7 ‐3.8%
11
CorporateIncomeTax(CIT)
CorporateIncomeTaxreceiptsfinishedfiscalyear2015at$3,129.1billion,adeclineof14.0percentcomparedtofiscalyear2014.Receiptswere0.9percent($29.1million)abovetherevisedforecast.Therearethreereasonsfordecliningcorporateincometaxreceipts:(1) Thecorporateincometaxratefellfrom7.00percentto5.25percentstartingJanuary1,
2015.ThiseffectwasseeninestimatedpaymentsreceivedinAprilandJuneoffiscalyear2015.Thosepaymentscameinslightlyhigherthanexpected,suggestingthatbusinesseshaveadjustedtothelowerrateinapredictablefashionandthatthereisnoneedforarevisionatthistime.
(2) Theexpirationofthe$100,000caponIllinoisNetOperatingLossdeductions(NOLs)hurtreceiptsaswell.ThecapwasliftedfortaxyearsendingonorafterDecember31,2014.
(3) Corporateprofitshavefallentwoconsecutiveyears.Changesincurrentyeartaxreceiptsaregenerallypredictedbychangesinprioryearprofits.
Chart5illustratestheexpecteddeclineingrosstaxreceiptsnextfiscalyear.Chart6belowplotsthechangeinprioryearprofitsnexttothechangeintaxreceiptssince2001.Lastly,Chart7providesagraphicofthedeclineingrosscorporatetaxreceiptseachquarterofFiscalYear2015withthepriorfiscalyear.Chart5
2,800.0
‐
500.0
1,000.0
1,500.0
2,000.0
2,500.0
3,000.0
3,500.0
4,000.0
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
Gross Receipts, $
in M
illions
Fiscal Year
Gross (before refunds) Corporate Income Tax Receipts, net of Amnesty FY 2000 ‐ FY 2016
Actual
Forecast
12
Chart6
Chart7
‐30.0%
‐20.0%
‐10.0%
0.0%
10.0%
20.0%
30.0%
40.0%
50.0%
60.0%
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Relationship between Corporate Income Tax and Prior Year Profits
CIT Change Profits t‐1
(300.00)
(200.00)
(100.00)
‐
100.00
200.00
300.00
400.00
Q1 2013
Q2 2013
Q3 2013
Q4 2013
Q1 2014
Q2 2014
Q3 2014
Q4 2014
Q1 2015
Q2 2015
Q3 2015
Q4 2015
CIT Receipts ($ in
millions)
Fiscal Year Quarter
Change in Gross CIT Receipts Year over Year
13
Sales&UseTaxFinalstatesalesandusetaxreceiptsforfiscalyear2015were4.6percentabovefiscalyear2014’sreceiptsandjust1.0percentaboveIDOR’sforecast.
Thestoryforstatesalesandusetaxinfiscalyear2015wasoneofstable,reliablegrowth.Indeed,foreveryquarter,thestoryhasbeenthesame—broad‐basedgrowthintaxableconsumption,especiallymotorvehiclesales.Salesandusetaxreceiptsfrommotorfuelsalesdeclinebecauseoflowerprices,buttheassociatedsavingsmakeapositive,offsettingcontributiontoconsumersentimentandspending.Thetableaboveshowsthefinalnumbersforfiscalyear2015.
Thegrowthinstatesalesandusetaxreceiptsforfiscalyear2015isparticularlyimpressivewhenviewedinlightofassociatedpriceinflationofonly0.4percent,whichisthepercentagechangeintheseasonallyadjusted,all‐items‐less‐food,ConsumerPriceIndexforAllUrbanConsumersduringfiscalyear2015.Thismeansthatverylittleoffiscalyear2015’sgrowthwasduetohigherprices.Instead,thegrowthwasdueprimarilytoconsumersbuyingmoretaxableitems.Thisso‐calledrealgrowthisanindicatorofimprovingeconomicconditionsoverthelastfiscalyear,includinggrowthinemploymentandpersonalincome,andastrongerIllinoisrealestatemarket.
ThefactorsbehindIllinois’strongmotorvehiclesaleshavebeendiscussedinpastreports,butitisworthmentioningagainherebecausenotonlydidfinalreceiptsfrommotorvehiclesalesendfiscalyear2015atanall‐timehigh,butfiscalyear2015wasthefifthconsecutiveyearofverystronggrowth.Theaverageannualgrowthinreceiptsfrommotorvehiclesalesfromfiscalyear2011to2015was8.9percent.ThegraphbelowshowsreceiptsfromsalesinIllinoisbyIllinoismotorvehicledealersbacktofiscalyear2000.
Motorvehiclesalesarebeingdrivenprimarilybyconsumers’needtoreplaceagingvehicles(theaveragelightvehicletodayisover11yearsold)andbyrecord‐lowinterestrates,whichlowerthecostofautofinancing.Thefinancerateonconsumerinstallmentloansatcommercialbanks(48‐monthloanforanewautomobile)hashoveredbetween4percentand5percentforthelastfewyears.Theseareamongthelowestratesofthelastfortyyears,duringwhichtimetheaverageratewasnearlydoubleatapproximately9.7percent.
Year‐to‐DateComparisonbyComponent($millions) FY2014 FY2015 $Difference %DifferenceVehicles $1,158.8 $1,271.2 $112.4 9.7% Motorfuel* $782.9 $643.4 -$139.5 -17.8% Allelse $5,733.7 $6,115.7 $382.0 6.7%
$7,675.4 $8,030.2 $354.8 4.6% *Estimated.IDORdoesnothaveactualdataonsales&usetaxfrommotorfuel.
14
Chart8
PublicUtilitiesTaxes
PublicUtilitiesTaxreceiptsfinishedfiscalyear2015at$1,005million,0.8percentbelowlastyearand0.9percentbelowourrevisedforecastof$1,015million.ElectricityExciseTaxfinishedtheyearlowerthanexpected,TelecommunicationExciseTaxbouncedbackfromartificiallowsoffiscalyear2014butnotashighasexpected,andtheNaturalGasTaxfinishedtheyearhigherthanexpected.TelecommunicationsTelecommunicationExciseTaxreceiptswere$434.2millioninfiscalyear2015,2.8percentabovefiscalyear2014.Telecomtaxwasexpectedtogrowinfiscalyear2015,comparedtofiscalyear2014,duetotheuseof$60millionincreditcarryforwardsin2014.However,thegrowthinfiscal2015waslowerthanexpected.ThebaseforTelecommunicationsExciseTaxhaserodedfasterthanexpected,asconsumersabandonlandlineservicesandgravitatetosmartdevicesandservicesnottaxableundertheTelecomExciseTax.AccordingtotheCentersforDiseaseControl,40.8percentofIllinoisadultslivedinahouseholdthatdidnothavealandlinein2013,anincreasefrom38.0percentin2012.ElectricityTheElectricityExciseTaxcameinat$393.1millioninfiscalyear2015,belowthe$402.5
15
millionreceivedinthepriorfiscalyear.Themodestdeclineinrevenuesisinlinewiththemodestdeclineinelectricityusestatewide.AccordingtotheEnergyInformationAdministration(EIA),correspondingquarterlyretailsalesofelectricityinIllinoisweredown3.0percentyearoveryearforthemonthsofJanuarythroughMarch.ThiscorrespondstotheoverallElectricitytaxreceiptstotalforfiscalyear2015.ElectricityExciseTaxfellshortofexpectations,comingin$9.4million(2.3percent)belowforecast.
NaturalGasNaturalGasreceiptsfinishedtheyearat$178.2million,downfromthe$188.4millionreceivedinfiscalyear2014.HeatingdegreedaydatafromtheNOAAshoweda3.5‐percentdropyearoveryearforthemonthscorrespondingtofourthquarterreceipts.Thisdecreasetrackswithoverallreceiptperformance.
LiquorTax
LiquortaxreceiptstotheGeneralRevenueFundinfiscalyear2015were1.4percentabovethelastfiscalyearand0.5percentaboveIDOR’sforecast.Year‐to‐dateperformanceisinthetablebelow.Statisticsforfiscalyear2014showthatthetaxableconsumptionofbeerincreased1.2percentcomparedtofiscalyear2013,whilethetaxableconsumptionofwineandspiritswerebasicallyflatat‐0.1percentand0.1percent,respectively.Spiritsmadeupthelargestshareoffiscalyear2014liquortaxreceiptstotheGeneralRevenueFund(54.7percent),followedbybeer(29.9percent)andwine(15.4percent).Apreliminaryconsumptionbreakdownforfiscalyear2015willbeavailableinournextwrittenreport,whichwillbepublishedinOctober2015.
Year‐to‐Date($millions)*IncludesGeneralRevenueFund
Actual IDORForecast
$Difference
%Difference
AllFunds* $283.2 $282.1 $1.1 0.4%
GeneralRevenueFund $166.8 $166.0 $0.8 0.5%
Actual HR389
Forecast$Difference
%Difference
GeneralRevenueFund $166.8 $165.0 $1.8 1.1%
FY2014 FY2015 $Difference %DifferenceAllFunds* $279.6 $283.2 $3.6 1.3%
GeneralRevenueFund $164.5 $166.8 $2.3 1.4%
16
MotorFuelTaxesCombinedmotorfueltaxreceiptsinfiscalyear2015were0.1percent($0.7million)belowfiscalyear2014and1.5percent($20.0million)belowIDOR’sforecast.Mostofthisforecastdeviation,aswellasthenegativeresultversuslastfiscalyear,wasrelatedtocashflowvolatilityinpaymentsmadeundertheInternationalFuelTaxAgreement(IFTA),whichisanagreementbetweenthelower48statesoftheUnitedStatesandtheCanadianprovincestosimplifythereportingoffuelusebymotorcarriersthatoperateinmorethanonejurisdiction.IFTApaymentsarehandledviaaclearinghousesystemwherebyeachjurisdictionreceivesapaymentreflectingthedifferencebetweenwhatitscarriersowetoallotherjurisdictionsandwhatcarriersfromallotherjurisdictionowetoit.Inotherwords,IFTAreceiptsarethenetpaymentsduetoIllinoisafterbalancingIllinois’saccountwithallothermemberaccounts.ThisapproachcanresultinsignificantannualchangesinIFTAreceiptsascarrierdistributionpatternsormembertaxrateschange.Forexample,Illinois’IFTAreceiptsforfiscalyear2015weredown22.5percentcomparedtofiscalyear2014.Clearly,thislargeofachangeisfargreaterthanwhatonewouldseeifIFTAreceiptsreflectedonlyfueldemandbycarriersoperatingacrossIllinois,asfueldemandchangesverygraduallyovertime.IfweremoveIFTAreceiptsandlookseparatelyatreceiptsfortheregularmotorfueltaxandfortheadditionalleviesoftheUndergroundStorageTankFund,weseeresultsthatmorecloselyreflectactualfueldemandinIllinois.Regularmotorfueltaxreceiptsincreased1.2percentoverfiscalyear2014andwerejust0.3percentbelowIDOR’sforecast.ThetaxesfortheUndergroundStorageTankFundincreased0.3percentinfiscalyear2015andwere1.2percentbelowIDOR’sforecast.TheregularmotorfueltaxappliestofuelusedinmotorvehiclesorwatercraftoperatingonIllinois’publichighwaysorwaterways.ThetaxesfortheUndergroundStorageTankFundhaveaslightlybroaderbase,whichincludesallgasoline,diesel,aviationfuel(unlesssoldatO’HareorMidwayAirports),kerosene,andhomeheatingoilsoldorusedinIllinois.
17
CigaretteandCigaretteUseTax
Attheendoffiscalyear2015,CigaretteTaxreceiptsfinishednearlyonforecast.Year‐to‐dateCigaretteTaxreceiptsexceededestimatesby0.8percent($6.2million).Comparedtolastyear,receiptsarealmostflatcominginat0.2percent($1.4million)abovethepreviousyear.Mayreceiptsdrovemuchofthemuchoftheunexpectedgrowthinthefourthquarter.Mayreceiptscamein17.0percent($10.0million)overforecast.
Year‐to‐Date ($ millions) *Includes the General Revenue Fund
Actual
Estimate
$ Difference
% Difference
All Funds* $825.2 $819.0 $6.2 0.8%
General Revenue Fund $353.4 $355.0 ‐$1.6 ‐0.5%
FY 2014 FY 2015 $ Difference % Difference
All Funds* $823.8 $825.2 $1.4 0.2%
General Revenue Fund $353.5 $353.4 ‐$0.1 0.0%
OtherTobaccoProductsTax(OTP)
Attheendoffiscalyear2015,OtherTobaccoProductsTaxreceiptsfinishedtheyearbelowexpectation.Totalyear‐to‐datereceiptsare8.0percent($3.2million)belowforecast.Comparedtofiscalyear2014receiptsshowagrowthof2.2percent($0.8million).Atthispoint,lowerthanexpectedannualgrowthlikelyindicatesthattheIllinoistobaccoproductsmarkethasreturnedtothelong‐termtrendfollowingthetaxchangesthatoccurredin2012and2013.LowerthanexpectedreceiptsinthemonthsofAprilandJuneexplaintheexpansionofthegapbetweenactualreceiptsandforecast.BothJuneandAprilreceiptswereeach14.0percent($0.5million)shortofforecast.
18
HotelOperator’sOccupationTax(HOOT)
TheHotelOperator’sOccupationTaxendedthefiscalyearwithreceiptsfinishingaboveexpectation.Attheendoftheyear,receiptswere7.0percent($16.7million)aboveforecastfor2015.Comparedwithlastyear,thisquarter’sreceiptsgrew13.0percent($29.5million)yearoveryear.Juneaccountedforaportionofthegrowthaboveforecast.Themonth’stotalcameinat38.2percent($7.6million)aboveforecast.
Thefollowingtwotablesshowaveragedailyroomrate(ADR)andtheoccupancyrate(Occ)statisticsfortheChicagohotelmarket.Bothtablesshowdatabymonthcomparedwithlastyear’slevel.Thisgrowth,particularlyinADR,issignificantandhelpsexplainperformance.Basedonavailableinformation,thiskindofyear‐over‐yeargrowthintheseindicators,andthereforestatereceipts,islikelytocontinueintothefirstquarterof2016withthecontinuedincreaseinactivityrelatingtoconventions,events,andthesummertourismseason.However,giventhatMaypostedADRbelowlastyear’slevelandOccjustaboutheldflatcomparedtolastyear,annualgrowthmaybegintoplateauduring2016.
Chart9
Source:ChooseChicago.MonthlyOccupancyandADRStatistics.23
23 http://www.choosechicago.com/articles/view/monthly-occupancy-and-adr-statistics/72/
$170.61
$200.47
$254.88
$158.35
$174.62
$277.59
$‐
$50.00
$100.00
$150.00
$200.00
$250.00
$300.00
March April May
ADR by Fiscal Year
FY 2015 FY 2014
19
Chart10
Source:ChooseChicago.MonthlyOccupancyandADRStatistics.24
Year‐to‐Date ($ millions) *Includes the General Revenue Fund
Actual
Estimate
$ Difference
% Difference
All Funds* $256.7 $240.0 $16.7 7.0%
General Revenue Fund $46.1 $39.9 $6.2 15.5%
FY 2014 FY 2015 $ Difference % Difference
All Funds* $227.2 $256.7 $29.5 13.0%
General Revenue Fund $37.5 $46.1 $8.6 22.9%
24 http://www.choosechicago.com/articles/view/monthly-occupancy-and-adr-statistics/72/
71.2%
79.3%
86.0%
68.2%
76.6%
85.2%
0.0%
10.0%
20.0%
30.0%
40.0%
50.0%
60.0%
70.0%
80.0%
90.0%
100.0%
March April May
Occ by Fiscal Year
FY 2015 FY 2014
20
EstateTax
EstateTaxGeneralRevenueFunds(GRF)receiptsendedfiscalyear201528.9percent($74.8million)aboveforecast.Whencomparedwithlastyear,GRFreceiptsfinishedyear‐to‐dateup20.5percent($56.8million).ThereceiptsfromMayandJunesignificantlyaddedtotheyear‐endtotal.Maysawreceipts106.2percent($22.9million)aboveforecastwhileJunereceiptstotaled56.0percent($12.0million)aboveforecast.
Year‐to‐Date ($ millions) *Includes the General Revenue Fund
Actual
Estimate
$ Difference
% Difference
All Funds* $354.6 $275.0 $79.6 28.9%
General Revenue Fund $333.3 $258.5 $74.8 28.9%
FY 2014 FY 2015 $ Difference % Difference
All Funds* $294.1 $354.6 $60.5 20.6%
General Revenue Fund $276.5 $333.3 $56.8 20.5%
21
RealEstateTransferTax(RETT)
Yeartodatefiscalyear2015fourthquarterRETTreceiptstotaled$66.1million,whichwas10.1percent($6.1million)higherthantheforecastof$60.0million.ThemonthofJunedrovereceiptswithatotalthatwas43.5percent($2.4million)overforecast.ThiswasoffsetsomewhatbyperformanceinMaywhichwas25.2below($1.5million)forecast.MarketFactorsImpactonRETTReceiptsIllinoisHomePrices:AccordingtodatareleasedbytheIllinoisAssociationofRealtors,IllinoisMay2015medianhomepriceshadanincreaseof8.7percentoverMayof2014.HomessoldinMayincreasedby5.6percentwhencomparedwithMay2014.AsRETTreceiptsareafunctionofbothpricesandnumberofsales,anincreaseinpriceandvolumeofsalesoverlastyearhelpsexplainthelevelofreceiptsforthesourceattheendofthequarter.ForeclosureInventory:Corelogic,aprominentindustrydataandanalyticsfirm,definesforeclosureinventoryastheshareofmortgagehomesthathavebeenplacedintheprocessofforeclosurebythelender.TheanalyticsfirmreleasesamonthlyNationalForeclosureReportwhichtracksforeclosureinventoryatthenationalandstatelevel.ThelatestMay2015reportshowsadecreaseintheforeclosureinventoryratesbothatthenationallevelandinIllinois.TheIllinoisratedroppedto1.6percent,andnationally,theratedroppedto1.3percent.25Thisisthefirstdropinthelevelofforeclosedinventoryforboththestateandthenationinfivemonths.Highforeclosureinventoryratescanhaveanegativeimpacton“puremarket”salesespeciallythoseincloseproximitytoaforeclosuresale.Generally,areductionintheforeclosureinventorycanhaveapositiveeffectonmediansaleprice. Chart 11
25 National Foreclosure Report. Rep. May 2015. Corelogic, 2015. Web. 16 July. 2015. http://www.corelogic.com/research/foreclosure-report/national-foreclosure-report-february-2015.pdf
1.0%
1.5%
2.0%
2.5%
3.0%
3.5%
4.0%
4.5%
5.0%
5.5%
6.0%
Aug‐11
Oct‐11
Dec‐11
Feb‐12
Apr‐12
Jun‐12
Aug‐12
Oct‐12
Dec‐12
Feb‐13
Apr‐13
Jun‐13
Aug‐13
Oct‐13
Dec‐13
Feb‐14
Apr‐14
Jun‐14
Aug‐14
Oct‐14
Dec‐14
Feb‐15
Apr‐15
Source: CoreLogic
Foreclosure Inventory
National Illinois
22
NegativeEquityShare:Corelogic,inits2015firstquarterequityreport,showedthatIllinois’negativeequityrateincreasedto16.8percent,6.6percentagepointshigherthanthenationalrateof10.2percent.26Illinoisremainsoneofthirteenstateswithahighernegativeequitysharethanthenationalaverage.Thisrelativelyhighratecontinuestobeacontributingfactorinthecurrenttightinventoryofhomesavailableonthemarket.Chart12
26 Equity Report. Rep. First Quarter 2015. CoreLogic, 2015. Web. 16 July. 2015. http://www.corelogic.com/about-us/researchtrends/equity-report.aspx#
10.0%
15.0%
20.0%
25.0%
30.0%
Source: CoreLogic
Negative Equity Share
National Illinois
23
ComparisonwithLastFiscalYearandIDORForecast
24
U.S.andIllinoisEmployment
25
IllinoisDepartmentofRevenueResearchDepartment
HansZigmund,M.A.DirectorofResearch
AndyChupick,M.P.A.
TaxEconomist
MichaelPijan,M.P.A.TaxEconomist
HectorVielma,Ph.D.Macroeconomist