THE PEW CENTER FOR ARTS & HERITAGE / PCAH.US / @PEWCENTER_ARTS
Capturing the tone, celebrating the work: A conversation with Wendy Rogers & Sara RudnerIntroduced by Lisa Kraus
QUESTIONS OF PRACTICE
Capturing the tone, celebrating the workA conversAtion with wendy rogers And sArA rudner introduced by LisA KrAus
dAte: september 29, 2007pLAce: pAneL room, the pew center for Arts & heritAge
Lisa Kraus: It’smyhonortosayafewwordsbeforeSaraRudnerandWendyRogersspeaktousandshowvideoexamplesoftheworktheymadetogether.Iwanttobeginbymentioninga“behindthescenes”momentIjustwitnessed:WendywaschattingwithSaraaboutsomethingshehadbeenobserving.Ihavenoideawhatitwas.Butitwassomovingtoherthatshehadtogetupanddemonstrate.Notonlydemonstrate,butalsorunaroundinacircle.AndthenSaradoubledoverinlaughter.Theywerelookingateachotherliketherewasnooneontheplanettheywouldratherbetalkingto.AndIbelievethat’swhywe’rehere.
Thefirstthingthatcomestomindistheyear1975.ThatwaswhenSaraputtogetherherfive-hourproject,Dancing-on-View(seeAppendixA),whichwe’regoingtoseeasampleofontape.Thisprojectpremieredin1975,withWendyasaparticipant.
Justthispastspring[2007],anotherversionofthepiecewasperformedattheBaryshnikovArtsCenterinNewYorkCity.Itwasfourhoursratherthanfive.
Ofcourse,around1975,peoplehadbeenlookingatRobertWilson’stheaterworks,whichextendedoursenseoftimeconsiderably.Therehadalsobeenalotofmusicalandperformanceworkthatdealtwithaminimalistaestheticofrepetition,aprocessofrecyclingmaterial.Morethan30yearslateritseemsasifaudiencesareveryexcitedandreadytoreturntothiswork.DeborahJowittwroteabouttheNewYorkCityperformancelastMarchinveryeffusiveterms.Attheendshelistedeverysingleoneofthe17dancers.Jowitt’slastlineinthatreviewwasthatthesedancersare“mykindofheroes.”
SaraRudnerandWendyRogers(lefttoright),November Duets,MerceCunninghamDanceStudio,1977.PhotobyFrancescaBartoccini,courtesySaraRudner.
d A n c e A d v A n c e
PhotoproofsofWendyRogersandSaraRudner,November Duets,MerceCunninghamDanceStudio,1977.PhotosbyFrancescaBartoccini,courtesyWendyRogers.
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 2
WhenImentionedthistoVickyShick,whowasintheshow,shesaid,“Oh,thatwoman[Sara]!Sheworkslikeadog.Andshe’sstillarealdanceratheart.”
VickywentontomentionhowSarahadsatforthreehoursorsoduringthecourseoftheperformance,andthengottenupanddoneanincrediblesolo.Isaidsomethinglike,“Well,sheobviouslyreallylovesthedancing,youknow,”andVickyandItogethersaid,“Well,that’swhatit’sallabout.”
WendyRogersisCalifornianbybirth.AgraduateoftheUniversityofCalifornia,Berkeley,indanceandtheater,shestartedchoreographingquiteearlyandspentsometimeinNewYorkwheretheconnectionwithSarawasforged.Usually,ifI’mspeakingaboutsomebody,I’vehadtheopportunitytolookatalotmoreworkthanI’veseenofWendy’s.SoI’matabitofadisadvantagethatway.I’mactuallygladthatwe’regoingtobeseeingmoretonight.Butmyunderstandingisthatshe’sbeenveryinterestedinasenseofplaceallalong;thatthelandscapeitself,thearchitectures,theenvironmentshavealwaysreallyloomedlarge,aswellastherelationshipswiththepeopleintheworkandhowthattranslatesintowhattheactualmaterialitselfis.
Wendy’swrittenaboutthedifficultyofcontinuingtodoadancewhensomeofthepeoplewhohavecreatedthatdanceareslippingaway,thattheworkitselfwillmorphandchange.Thisisachoreographerwhoactuallymadethechoicetodissolveherdancecompany,whichexistedfrom1977until1990,infavorofmakingamoremalleableinfrastructure.Thischangeisoneofthethingsthatshetalkedaboutinhervisitheretwoyearsago.
Idon’tknowifIcanspeakformorepeopleinthisregard,butIwasverymovedtohearaboutWendy’stransformationasadanceartistinthepresentationshemadeinPhiladelphiaMarch15,2005,alsosponsoredbyDanceAdvance.[See As Seen Through the Windshield (and Other Perspectives on Making Dances),www.pcah.us/m/dance/as-seen-through-the-windshield.pdf]
InWilliamLeastHeat-Moon’sbookRiver-Horse,thecharacterstakeajourneywithcanoes,andtheydoportage.Theirmottois,“Proceedasthewayopens.”InthinkingaboutWendy,Ifindarealconnectionwiththatideabecauseshehasmorphedfromsomeonewhohassucceededinworkingwiththemoreexpectedsortsofinfrastructure—youmakeapieceeveryseason,yougetthegrantfunding,youworkwithinrecognizablestructures—tosomeonewhowasnotafraidtosay,“Waitaminute.Thisformdoesnotquitefitme.Iwanttorelatetomyideasoveralongerhaul.”Thistransformedintoher10-year-longworkcalledMAKESHIFT dancing.
AsIunderstandit,Wendytookacertainkindofbodyofmaterialandsetofinterestsandkeptreworkingthemindifferentcontexts,withdifferentpeople,withthenotionthatitwas
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 3
onelong,continuouspiecetobecompletedoverthecourseofafulldecade.Justpersonally,itwassoliberatingtohearthat,tounderstandhowWendywasworking.Researchingalittlefurther,Isawthatshewasinvitedtomakeafilmin1985,whichwascompletedin1995.Theeditingprocessinvolvedallkindsofshiftsrelativetothematerialandchallengesrelativetohowoneedits.Ithinkit’ssoeasyforustonotgivesufficientvaluetowhatishappeningintheseinterstices.Wendy’smodelhastodowithvaluingprocess,valuingcreatingaformthatisreallyappropriatetowhatwedo,whateachofusdoes.
SaraRudner,anativeNewYorker,attendedBarnard,andgraduatedoneyearafterTwylaTharp.1ShewasdancingwithPaulSanasardoatthetime,whoseworkwasinatheatricalmoderndancemode.ThenshewasinvitedtoauditionforTwyla’sveryfirstgroup.ForareallylongtimeTwylaworkedthemfourhoursaday,sixdaysaweek.
sara rudner: Yes,wedidalotofwork.
Lisa Kraus: Theydidn’tgetapenny.Andyouweredoingclericalwork,Ibelieve?
sara rudner: Yes.
Lisa Kraus: SaraworkedwithTwylafor20yearsand,formanyofthoseyears,alsodirectedtheSaraRudnerPerformanceEnsemblethatincludedanumberofpeoplewhohavegoneontobesuccessfulchoreographersintheirownright.(SeeAppendixB.)Ithinkoneofthemostfascinatingaspectsofbeingindancelonghaulisthesatisfactionofseeinghowpeopledevelopovertime.Sothat’sprobablywhatIlookforwardtohearingaboutmostofallbetweenthetwoofyou:howyourrelationshipandyourworkhavedevelopedovertheyears.Weverymuchappreciateyourbeingwithustoday.
sara rudner: Well,whatyoumighthavewitnessedusdoingatthebeginningofthesessionthisevening—Wendydancingandmedoublingoverwithlaughter—that’sthebasisofourrelationship.
1TwylaTharpfoundedherdanceensemble,Twyla Tharp Dance,in1965.Aseminalfigureinthewesterndanceworld,shehaschoreographedmorethan135dances,fiveHollywoodmovies,anddirectedandchoreographedfourBroadwayshows.Seeherwebsiteforafullbioandlinkstoinformationaboutherincrediblecreativeoutput:www.twylatharp.org.
WendyRogers,Drove She Ducklings,NewYork,1976.PhotobyFrancescaBartoccini,courtesyWendyRogers.
d A n c e A d v A n c e
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 4
Wemeteachothersometimeinthesummerof1974.IhadjustleftTwylaTharp’scompanyforthefirsttimeandIwasinvitedbyCarolynBrowntogotoaloftperformancebeinggivenbyWendyRogers.Ididn’tknowWendyRogers.Isatthereinthisnarrowloft,andwatchedthisdancingandIsaid,“Oh,myGod!”Wendydidamove.Shejustputherrightorleftfootout,andshejustliftedonetoe.Isaid,“I’vegottoworkwiththatperson.”
wendy rogers: Sheinvitedmeoutforaneggcream.IwasfromtheWestCoast.Ihadnoideawhataneggcreamwas.Iwasalittlebitconcerned.
sara rudner: We’reEastCoastpeople,sowehadaneggcream.Itwasveryobvioustome—andithasbeenprovensooverthedecades—thatthisisauniquerelationship,onethatIhaveneverfoundwithanyoneelse:beingabletogointoaroomandcomeoutattheendofanafternoonwitha20-minutedancethathasallsortsofdetailandvarietyandcommitment.Imean,that’sunheardof.
wendy rogers: Ithinkwhatwebothlikeisreallystellarwaysofnotknowingwhatwe’redoing.
IwasjustamazedthatthiscollaborationwasgoingtohappenbecauseIhadseenSaraperform,andbeensotakenwithhermovement.Whenwefirstwentintothestudiotoworkshestartedtwirling,andIstartedjumping.Thenshewouldtwirl,andIwouldjump.Andthat’sjusthowitstarted.Ihadnoideawhatwasgoingonthefirsttimeweworkedtogether.Soitwasveryexciting.SheimmediatelyfoldedmeintoworkthatshehadalreadyinstigatedwithWendyPerron,RisaJaroslow,andReganFrye.Ijuststartedcomingtotherehearsals.LaterIfoundouttheydidn’tknowwhoIwasorwhyIwascomingtotherehearsals!
Sothere’sthiskindofmysteryaspeoplecomeinandoutofSara’swork.OvertheyearsIthinkitreallyshows.Forexample,inthemostrecentfour-hourpiecethatIhadthewonderfulprivilegeofwatching,youcanseethisincrediblecycleofpeoplecomingintocontactandflowingintothework.Ithasawonderfulgenerositytoitandusuallythere’sawillingnessoneveryone’sparttobeinastateofknowingandnotknowingwhat’sgoingon.
sara rudner: In1975BarbaraDilley,whowasknownasBarbaraLloydatthattime,hadlefttheMerceCunninghamcompanyandwashelpingorganizeadance-basedprojectwithamannamedLarryFagan.Itwashisfirstseason,andtheyapproachedseveralpeopleaboutcomingandworkingatthechurchatthattime.Idon’tknowhowmanyofyouarefamiliarwiththatvenue:SaintMark’sChurchintheBowery.Whenwefirstwentin,acceptinganinvitation,thereweresetstationarypews,aredlinoleumfloor,andabigcross.BarbaraaskedmewhatIwantedtodo.IsaidIwanttodanceforsevenhours,eighthours,andwenegotiatedthisdowntofive.Itwasabouthowpeopleinotherpartsoftheworldsawadancein
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 5
performance,thatitwasanongoingevent.Audiencescame,andtheyslept,andtheyate.AndalotofitstemmedfromhavingheardaboutwhathappensinBali,andotherplaces,frommyfriendRussellDumas.2
wendy rogers: Firstofall,whenyouproposedit,Iwasthrilled!BecauseIwasatthatage,anditwaspartofthattimealsojusttosay,“Wecandoit!Let’sdoit!Let’sdanceforfivehours!”Itwasthephysicalexcitementofthatchallengeanddoingtheworkthatwouldbebehindit.Italsomeantwewouldhavetorehearsealot,andthatwasgreatbecausewereallylikedtorehearse.IrememberSaraspecificallysaying,“Well,Idon’tknowifIwanttochoreograph.”AndIsaid,“Whatdoyoumeanyoudon’twanttochoreograph?Youmeanthere’snotgoingtobechoreography?”Ijustrememberhavingthismoment.AndthenSarasaid,“Ijustwantpeopletomaketheirownbeginningsandendings.Theycancomeinwhentheywanttoandleavewhentheyfindtheirownending,andwe’rejustgoingtodance.We’regoingtodowhatwedoandtheaudiencecandecidewhattodoaboutit.”
Itwasn’tthatwedidn’tcareabouttheaudience.Wecaredaboutthemagreatdeal.Wecaredaboutthemsomuchwedidn’twanttoforcethemtowaitfortheendingoranything.Theycouldjusthavetheirendingwhenevertheywanted.
Theprojectinvolvedaconstantofferingofdancetoeachotherandtotheaudience.Anditleteveryonefindanindividualrelationshiptoit.
sara rudner: Thisdancewasabouttherealityofwhatdancersdo.Imean,howmanyhoursdoweputinbeforeanybodyeverseeswhatwedo?Sowe’realwaysdancing,whetherthere’sanaudienceornot.Andoncethereisanaudience,somethingelsewillhappen.Butthisiswhatwedo.Thisisamomenttoreflectuponarealityabouteachoneofuswhoexperiencesthis.It’susuallycurtainup,make-upon,there’sfiveminutes,andthenyou’reoffandthenyou’vefinished.Sothiswasanefforttobreakthatcycle.Itwaskindofgrueling,ifIremembercorrectly.Weworkedallspring.
wendy rogers: Firstofall,wemadeallthematerial,lotsandlotsofmaterial.
sara rudner: Aboutanhourandahalfworthofmaterial.
wendy rogers: Veryprecisematerial.
2ThereferencehereistosomeperformancetraditionsontheislandofBaliinIndonesia(and,indeed,elsewhereinIndonesiaandaroundtheworld)thatinvolvemembersofacommunitythroughoutthenight.Performersenacttalesthroughthemediaofmusicanddance,drama,orpuppetry,whileyoungandoldcomeandgo,engagingwiththeactionandthestory.
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 6
sara rudner: Reallydemandingmaterial.Andsomeofthematerialconsistedonlyofstreamsofmovementthatwedidtogetherinakindofunison.
wendy rogers: Iremembertherunning.Wastherunning30minutes?
sara rudner: Itwascloseto30minutes.
wendy rogers: Itwasawholesectionofrunning.And,althoughIhaddonealotofmovementinmyhistory—withoutcounts,comingfromakindofunusualbackgroundwherefromtheageofnineIwasimprovisingandcollaborating,IhadneverdonesomethingasrigorousaswhatweweredoingwithSara,wheretherewouldn’tbeanycounts[inthis“Running”section].Yet,itwasstillverypreciseandverycomplex.Thattookalotofgrouptimetodealwiththesubjectivityoftime.Wehadtocomeintorehearsalandbeabletofindthesamepatternsoftime—asagroup—thatwasn’tbasedonapulseorabeat.
sara rudner: Ithinktherhythmicimpulseismoreimportantthansettingupastructurebeforehand.Ithinkwediditallrhythmically.Idon’tthinkwediditincounts.
wendy rogers: Sectionsweworkedonwere“Running,”“Walking,”and“BrainDamage.”
sara rudner: Explain“BrainDamage.”
wendy rogers: Itwaswherewewereputtingtogetherdifferentphrasesinimpossibleways.IthadtodowithSararampingupwhatweweresupposedtobedoinguntilitwasjustabsolutelyimpossibletobeabletodoit.Sowhatyougotwasaperformanceofthestrangestphysicalmanifestationsofsomeonewho’sreallypracticedalongtimeandstillcan’tdoit.
sara rudner: Idon’tremembertheexactthing,butitmighthavebeenlikeaseven-countlegphraseandanarmphrasethatwentoveritinaboutnineor11counts.Thedancerswouldhavetokeeponrepeatingsothecoordinationchangedateveryrepeatofthecycle.That’swhywecalledit“BrainDamage,”becauseitwasveryhardtoknow.Itwasalongphraseandinvolvedgoingacrossthespaceandthenhoppingback,sothedirectionswerealsohard.Thearmsdidn’trelate—theyweren’tmadeonthelegs.Sotherefore,wehadtheseglitches.Wendywasgoodatit.
wendy rogers: Oh,yes,WendyPerron.There’ssomethingabouthermind;youcantellWendyPerron,okay,13,10,4,19,andshe’lljustkeepaddinginherhead.
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 7
sara rudner: DoyouknowthatWendyPerronisnoweditorofDance Magazine?She’sachoreographer,writer,andperformer.She’sremarkable.Shewasoneoftheoriginalfour:twoWendys,aSara,andaRisa.
wendy rogers: Yes,RisaJaroslow.Anotherreallywonderfulsectionofmaterialwasthe“OnetoSeventeen,SeventeentoOne.”Itwasanaccumulation—accumulatingupandthende-accumulatingbackdown.Idon’tknowifthat’saword,de-accumulating,butthemainthingaboutitwasthatyouneverpassedthroughcenter.Yourheadwasneveronstraight.Andyouhadtogofromonekindofan“off”toadifferentkindofan“off”andyoumovedverysmoothlyupanddownfromthefloorbutyourheadalwayshadacircuitouspathanditwouldmakeussickwhenwefirstlearnedit.Thenitbecamereallysoothingbecauseyoulearnedthisotherwaytoorientyourselfanditbecamereallysatisfyingtodo.Thentherewerethecircles.
sara rudner: Circles,runningincircles.Thisactually,inthe1999versionofthispiece,hadsomeinfluencesfromRussellDumas.Therunningincircleswas…
wendy rogers: Veryrhythmical,andwejustranincircles.Butagain,itwasoneofthosesituationsofrememberingmany,many,manyverysimilarbutdifferentvariations.
Lisa Kraus: Doyouwanttoshowusany?
wendy rogers: Well,wedon’thaveanythingfrom1975.Althoughvideofolksdidcome,itwasthe‘70s,andtheyjusttookpicturesofourfeetandoursides,youknow.Idon’tknowwhattheyweredoing.
sara rudner: Butfivehours,theygotnothing!3
wendy rogers: Fivehoursandonlybodyparts.
wendy rogers: Thenotionofdocumentationwasn’tpartofthatmoment.
ButwedohavealittleglimpseofaduetthatSaraandImadein’77.
3WendyPerron,RisaJaroslow,andWendyRogersdidatwo-hourversioninOberlin,OH,onOctober17,1975(seeAppendixC).WendyRogersiscurrentlyusingthedocumentationofthatadaptationasshere-workssomeofthedancingforyetanotheriteration.
WendyRogers,Dancing-on-View,St.MarksChurch,NewYork,1975.BackdropbyRobertKushner(seewww.robertkushnerstudio.com).Photo©JohanElbers(1975),courtesySaraRudner.
d A n c e A d v A n c e
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 8
Backgroundphoto:WendyRogersandSaraRudner,November Duets,MerceCunninghamDanceStudio,1977.PhotobyFrancescaBartoccini,courtesyWendyRogers.ArchivalmaterialfromthecollectionofWendyRogers.SeeAppendicesDandE.
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 9
sara rudner: ThenameofitwasNovember Duets.
wendy rogers: WithlivepianobyajazzmusiciannamedPeggyStern.(SeeAppendixF.)
sara rudner: Thisdancehassomeoftheelementsthatweweretalkingaboutintheotherpieces.Sothat’stheclosestwecangetto1975.
[Viewing of dance on tape takes place; applause follows]
wendy rogers: Thatmaterialwasabout25minuteslong,andhadalltheseduetsinit.It’snotinsignificantthatthejazzmusicwewereworkingwithreallyfeltlikeaparallelworld;ithadtherigorofbeinginsidethematerialandbeingabletogetinsidetheotherpersonsothatyoucouldmoveinandoutofstructure.Weenjoyedembracingdifferentkindsofmovementsensibilities.Werehearsed,though,toLauraNyro’sGonna Take a Miracle,tostayfreshforthelivejazz.
And,althoughthatwasn’tafive-hourdance,ithasthesensibilitythatwewereworkingonatthattime.
sara rudner: Wewereonlytwoyearsawayfromourfive-hourbodies.
Audience member: Didyouhaveasenseofthemusic,though,beforeyouperformedthework?
sara rudner: No.Peggycametoseerehearsal.Andsheandweworkedtogetheronwhatthemusicwouldbe.Themusicwasn’trecorded.
wendy rogers: Shewasalsoimprovisingduringperformance.
Sarajustfoldsnewchallengesandpeopleintoourprocess.Ofcoursetherearealwayschallenges.IrememberwehadtopickPeggySternupwithacabbecausesheplayeduntilreallylateatnightintheclubs,andwerehearsedintheday.Weweresittingtheregoing,“Where’sPeggy?Where’sPeggy?”So,finally,whatwehadtodowasgogetherbeforeourrehearsals.
sara rudner: Literallywakeherup.
wendy rogers: “Getthecoffee.Comeon…let’sgotorehearsal.”
Justtoflipbackabit,forthefive-hourpiece,youknow,thatcrucifixdidn’tworkforeitherSaraormeasaset[referringtothealtaratSt.Mark’schurch].IwasreallygoodfriendswithRobertKushner.Hewasatthattimepartofthathugewaveofdecorativepainters.Andwe
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 10
Allphotos:WendyRogersandSaraRudner,November Duets,MerceCunninghamDanceStudio,1977.PhotosbyFrancescaBartoccini,courtesyWendyRogers.ArchivalmaterialcourtesyWendyRogers.SeeAppendixGforhandwrittenandtypedcuesheet,aswellasadditionalmaterialsonNovember Duets.
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 11
said,“Oh,Bob!Bob,canyoupaintussomethingtocoverthiswholewall?”Hecamebackwiththesepanelsoffabricthathehadpaintedinpomegranatesbecausehe’djustbeentoPersia,andwasinspiredbythepomegranatemotif.Andsomeflowers,too?
sara rudner: No,theywereallpomegranates.Andhealsointroducedthefan,thestandingfan.
wendy rogers: Right.
sara rudner: Thefanwouldblowhispaintingssothatwhenwewoulddothingsbehindthemyoucouldseepartsofourbodies.
wendy rogers: Partofthescoreissomeoneturningonthefanhighsothatthepaintingsreallyflap,andyoucanseealot.Ortheymayturnitonlowsotheywavejustabit,andyoucanseehardlyanything.
Therewasnobackstagereally.Thefive-hourdancewassuchatransformationalexperience—inthedoingofit.Imean,weworkedandworkedandworkedonit.Itwasonlyperformedonce,ever.
sara rudner: Thatwastheotherdealabouthavingspentalifetime—seeminglyalifetimeaftertenyears—ofgoingfromtowntotownwithadancecompany[TwylaTharp]andperformingrepertoire:ThisseemedtobesomethingIwouldnevertry.WhywouldIleaveacompanyandasituationthatIhadbasicallydevotedsomuchofmyenergyandtimeandbodyactivityto,ineveryway?WhywouldIwanttoleavesomethingthatIfeltpartofmaking?AndultimatelytheanswerformewasthatthereweresomethingsIwantedtotrythatIknewIwouldneverbeabletotryinthatconstruct.IfeltatthetimethatWendyandIwerestartingtoworktogetherthatIalmosthadtojustifytoTwylawhyIwasnotgoingtocontinueinthecompany.Thatwasveryhard.AndIhaditinmymind,Ifeltwhatitwas;andasIwenton,Iwasabletoarticulateitmorestrongly.
LisatalkedaboutWendydisbandinghercompanystructure.It’salmostuncannythatIfoundmyselfmakingasimilardecisiontohersaroundthesametime,maybealittleearlier.4Itwasinresponsetothatparadigmsetupbymanagersandthewholesysteminwhichdanceisdistributedorproducedinthiscountry.
4Indeed,Sara’sdecisiontodisbandhercompanydidinfluenceWendy’schoicetomakethesamemovein1990.
Fansblowingthebackdrop,Dancing-on-View,St.MarksChurch,NewYork,1975.BackdropbyRobertKushner.Photo©JohanElbers(1975),courtesySaraRudner.
d A n c e A d v A n c e
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 12
Backgroundimage:WendyRogersandSaraRudner,November Duets,MerceCunninghamDanceStudio,1977.PhotobyFrancescaBartoccini,courtesyWendyRogers.DancersontheCable TV Worldcoverfromlefttoright:ShanaMenaker,WendyRogers,RisaJaroslow,RobinDavis,andDeniBanks(sitting).ArchivalmaterialfromthecollectionofWendyRogers.SeeAppendixH.
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 13
wendy rogers: Ithinkweweremakingthedecisionatthesametimetoarticulatetherealizationthatwhatwelovedwasthecreativeprocess,andthatwecertainlywantedanaudiencetosharethatexperiencewithus.Whatwedidn’twantwasallthepackaging.
sara rudner: Yes,thepackagingwashardforus.It’snothardforeverybody,andit’svalidifthat’sthewayyouconceiveofyourworkandwhatyourambitionsare.Ourambitionsweredifferent.SowhatIdidafterIuntangledmyselfwastogobacktoworkwithTwylaforanotherfewyears.Ifinallygottobeadancer,understandingallthepressuresthatachoreographerhastogothrough—allofthem.Anditwas,youknow,like,“MayIcrawlandkissyourfeet?”WhatIcametounderstandfromalltheworkthatIhaddonewithWendywasthatthebarhadbeenraisedintermsofmyownexpectationofinterpersonalrelationshipswiththedancersIwasworkingwithinacompany—ofwhatIwantedtohappenonstage,whetheritwasinimprovisedearlyjazzpiecesoftheTharprepertoireorinherfullychoreographedpieces.
wendy rogers: Ithinkthatit’shardforsomepeoplewhoweren’tinonthisgeneration,ourgeneration,tounderstandthattherewasalotofteachingthatwasverydictatorialandsometimescruel.Eventhoseofuswhohadteachersormentorswegreatlyadmiredandlearnedalotfromexperiencedhowtheycouldalsobemean.Maybenotmeanallthetime,justsomeofthetime.That’sevenworse.Ifit’sallthetime,youcancountonit.
Myfirstteacher,RuthHatfield,wasanamazinganduniquespirit,andshetaughtdancethatwasfullycreativeineveryway,includingtherelationshipsthatshehadwithherstudents.Neveranaudition,youknow.IhadbeendancingwithhersinceIwasalittlegirl.Therewasthisincredible,veryCaliforniakindofspirit,abeliefthateveryonehadcreativity.InmyfirstyearswithRutheverythingwedidwemadeupalltogether:Ididyourmove,youdidmymove.Weimprovised.
LaterIwenttotheseotherplaceswhere—whoa!—itwasaverydifferentwayofrelatingtopeople.SuddenlyIwasinanenvironmentwhereitseemedthatthetraditionconsistedofonepersonwhosaid:Here’sthemovement.Thisisyourphrase.Theseareyourcounts.Thisisyourpart.
Forvariousreasonsit’salsohardwhenyou’rejustcomingofageasanadult,asIwas,tosuddenlyrealizethatthereareallthesewomen,alongwithacoupleofguysinclass,andsomeofthesestudentsreallycan’tdance.Nonetheless,thewomanwhoisthemostbeautifulwiththehighestarchesandtheblondesthairgetstodothemostdancing.Whatisthat?Well,whateveritwas,itdidn’tincludeme.
Sotherewerethesediscoveriesthatwerebrutal,yettypicalinourdancinglives.ButIalsotookincredibleclassesfromMargaretJenkins,MerceCunningham,andViolaFarber.Oh,
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 14
mygoodness,incredibleclasses!Iwasneverinanyofher[ViolaFarber’s]choreography.Butyoudidn’tneedtobe.Justgotoclass,andthereitallwas,amostwonderful,musicalworld.
Weallsharedtheseincredibleexperienceswithteachers.Ineachsituation,IfeltlikeIgotintheriverofwhatthatparticularkinestheticworldwas.
SothislongstoryisjusttosaythatpartofmyexcitementinworkingwithSarawasthatfirstofall,sheisnevermean,whichIreallyappreciate.Ididn’thavetoworryaboutthat.Butalso,therelationshipitselfissoconnectedtothework.Forthefirsttime,Ididn’thavetofigureout,oh,whataretheSarathings?OrtotrytodotheSarathings.SheseemedtolikewhateverIthrewinthere.She’dsay,“Oh,let’susethat.”Manypeoplewereveryseriousbackthen,veryserious,andweweren’t.
sara rudner: Wewerenotparticularists.
wendy rogers: Weoftenevendidsillythingsinourrehearsalsandtheninsistedonputtingsillythingsinthepiecesaswell.Idon’trememberbeingverysillywithotherchoreographers.It’sjustgreattoworkwithsomeonewhoisopentowhateverwecouldcomeupwith.ItwasthatopennessthatwassomovingwhenIsawwhatshewasdoinginthelastfour-hourdance.Stillthere—youknow,embracingwhateverpeoplearebringingintotheroomandmakingitavailable.
sara rudner: Itwaspartofthetimeaswell.Therewerealotofexperiments.TheGrandUnionwashappening.Ultimately,Ithinkourpersonalitiesfitsowellbecausetherewassomethingwewerebothlongingfor,andfindingourwayofdoing.GrandUnionwasahighlyimprovisationalgroupthatwasbornoutofYvonneRainer’sdancecompanyandthenincludedotherpeopleshehadcollaboratedwithovertheyears.5Alltheseinfluenceswerefloatingaroundus.Ialwayshadafantasy,especiallysincetheearly‘70s:Californiawasmyfantasyworld.AndseveraldancerswhohaddancedwithTwylaintheearlydayshaddesertedforSanFrancisco.Iwasverycurious.SowhenSanFranciscoandtheWestCoastcametome,throughWendy,Iwasjustoverjoyed.
wendy rogers: TheWestCoasthaditsownthinggoingon.Alotofthathistorygoterasedbecausewedidn’thavehistorians,wedidn’thaveinfrastructure.TherewerepeoplenooneontheEastCoasthadeverheardof,likeJennyHunter,forexample.WethinkofalotoftheexperimentsasJudson,butshewasdoingtheseincrediblethingsinCalifornia:task-basedevents,and
5TheNewYork-basedGrandUniondancegrouppracticedandperformedcontactimprovisationintheearly1970s.Anumberofpeopleinfluentialinpostmoderndancecircleswereinvolvedwiththisgroup.
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 15
improvisations.IrememberaclassItookfromheroneevening.Allwedidwasmoveourspinesfortwohours.
TherewereradicalexplorationsthatweregoingonontheWestCoast,includingimprovisation,buttheyjusthadadifferentsortofspintothemandadifferentflavor.Andtherewastrafficbackandforth.
sara rudner: TwylaTharpcamefromCalifornia.
wendy rogers: FromRialto.6RightnearwhereIamnow[Riverside,California].
OneofthethingsthathappensovertheyearsisthatwhenSaraandIgetbacktogether,wejustgoinastudio,andwedosomework.Sometimessomethinghappenswiththatstuff,andsometimesitdoesn’t.
6AccordingtoTharp’sbiographyontheAcademyofAchievementwebsite(www.achievement.org),shewasborninPortland,Indiana,andmovedwithherfamilytoRialtowhenshewasstillveryyoung.
PhotoproofsofWendyRogersandSaraRudner,November Duets,MerceCunninghamDanceStudio,1977.PhotosbyFrancescaBartoccini,courtesyWendyRogers.
d A n c e A d v A n c e
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 16
Wejusttapbackin.Andinthatspirit,let’slookatMagma.SarawasvisitingrelativesinSacramento,closeenoughtomethatwejustwentintothestudioanddecidedtomakesomedancing.Andthesearejustourowngoofylittletapes.Sometimeswekeptthesetapesandwouldusethemtodevelopothermaterial,andsometimestheywentnowhere.Thiswasoneofthenowheretapes.
Audience member: Whenwasthis?
wendy rogers: 1989.
Partofthereasonwe’reshowingthisisbecauseit’sanexampleofhowwebegincreating.Thisisraw,butgettingtothephysicalityofsomething.Thenwestartnamingit.
What’sinterestingisthatwenormallydon’tlookatourvideos.Westorethemcarefully,andwedon’tlookatthem.It’sbeenatriptoorganizethispresentation.
Here’saclipfromaperformancecalledConversationsatDanspace.
sara rudner: In1990.
wendy rogers: Thisiswheretherawmaterialstartsgettingarticulatedandshapedandyoucanstillseethemovementbasethatwewereworkingfrom.Andsowe’lljustclickthroughthisstuff.Feelfreetointerrupt.Wecanbeveryirreverenthere.Thisisanotheroneofthetapesfromourprivatecollection:1995,BreezyHill,upstateNewYork.
wendy rogers: It’sasimilarkindofrawinitialinvestigation.Ithinkyou’llseethatthoughwedidn’tnecessarilyturnsomeofthesethingsintoaperformance,it’ssimplypartofaprocessofreconnecting,andthewholeexperiencemightsurfacelater.
sara rudner: Sointhebeginningofworkingtogetherwehadtheluxuryofspendinglonghoursinthestudio,spendingtimewiththemovement.
wendy rogers: [watching Sara dance on the videotape]OneofthethingsthatalwaysamazedmeaboutSarawasherconnectiontothefloor—verydifferentfromwhatIlearnedintechniqueclassesandsomethingthathasinfluencedmemywholelifesince.
sara rudner: HowpersonalshallIget?Iwasgoingthroughadivorce.[observing an arm gesture with a swirling wrist]Andwithmanyofthesemovementsandimages,well,wewerejustcleaningoutthetoilet.
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 17
wendy rogers: Therearealwaystheselittlestoriesthatcomeinundertheformalworkthatdon’tnecessarilyneedtobecommunicated,butexistaspartofthedifferentexperiencesthatwe’rehavingwhilewe’redancing.Wehopetheygivealittlemoresenseoftheconnectionbetweenartandlifethatexistsinourwork.
sara rudner: Wemadesomethingfromexperiencesthatwehadbothsharedandourdancesarepartofajournalofourrelationship.
wendy rogers: What’sinterestingiswegonexttothe1999rehearsal[onvideo],andyouseethebeginningofourreturntothefive-hourdance.And,youknow,bothSaraandIhadbeenthroughamilliondifferentdancesanddanceworldsandsensibilitiesbythetimeweweredoingthisin1999.Somanythingshadhappenedinthedanceworld,differentwaysofapproachingperformanceand—oh,myGod!—thetechniques,theinteractionofsomanybodyknowledgesandtechniques…
sara rudner: Contactimprovisation.
wendy rogers: AndAlexanderandFeldenkraistechniques:Allthesedifferentwaysofexperiencingthebodyhavereallychangedthedanceworldincludingtheless-enforcedseparationofdifferentkindsofdanceformsfromeachother.Sotogobacktothefive-hourformat,todoafour-hourdance,seemedreallyexciting.
sara rudner: Whatcouldwemakeagainwiththefourofus?Becausewewentbacktotheoriginalquarteteventhoughtherewere20performersin1999,allwomen,fromalldifferenttimesinmylife.Thecentralquartetiswhatyou’llseenow.
wendy rogers: Somethingreallydifferenthappenedinthe1999piecebecauseSarabroughtinallthegenerationsofdancersshehadbeenworkingwithandmadefourhourswithsomeofthe—whatdowecallourselves?
sara rudner: OriginalQuartet.
wendy rogers: OriginalQuartet.SotheOriginalQuartetdidsomematerialreminiscentofwhatwehaddone,andwehaddifferentwaysofparticipatingoverthefourhours.ButwewereinthisseaofgorgeouswomendancersfromallthesedifferentpiecesanderasandworkingwithSarawasextremelymoving.Ihadn’tmetmanyofthem,andshehadworkedwiththemseparatelyatdifferenttimesandoccasions.Irememberthefirsttimeweallgottogetherinthesameroom—italmostbroughtmetotears.Itwaswildstuff.Itgavemesuchasenseofphysicalhistoryandrelationships.Weusuallykeepgoing,ontothenextproject.Soitwas
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 18
thefirsttimeI’deverdonesomethingquitelikethis,wherewejustre-immersedourselves,andwehadsuchasenseofalargerscaleofthingsintime.
sara rudner: Itwasahugegroupofpeople.Manyofthemwerenolongerfull-timedancersorweren’tperformingfulltime.Therewasasocialworker.Therewasanacupuncturist.Weallcametogetherandrehearsedwhenwecould.Thismeantthatdifferentrehearsalsweregoingonatthesametimeinthestudiotocatchpeopleup.Iwouldworkwithsomepeopleinthatsmallstudioonasolooraduet,whilegrouppieceswerebeingrehearsed.Itwasaveryactivesetting.
wendy rogers: Sara,Ithinkitwouldbegreatifyouwouldtalkaboutthatinitialprojectthatwestartedinthefive-hourdance—thewaysthattheprocessgottothisbusinessofexposingourdancinglives.
sara rudner: Youmeanintheperformance?
wendy rogers: Yes.
sara rudner: [viewing video sample]Thisis1999atSaintMark’sChurch.BobKushnerpaintedanotherbackdropforusandthisisthatquartetinperformance.There’sstillthatsamesensethatthere’snobackstage;it’sallvisible.
Lisa Kraus: Istheremusicinthefivehours?
sara rudner: Notintheoriginalversion.Itwastotallyinsilence.Butinthisversionwehadtwomusicians,percussionists.AndonMay13[2008],Mother’sDay,inNewYorkCity,therewereagainpercussionistsandrecordingsthatIinheritedfrommymotherfromtheforties,whichwereplayedonaportable78recordplayer.Youcanseepacingissodifferentnow.It’sarealrefugetoreturntoadifferentexpectationofhowmuch,howfast,andhowmanytimes.Whenyouknowaperformanceisgoingtolastforfourhours,youjustsortofletgoofacertainkindofexpectation,asaperformer,Ithink,andasamemberoftheaudience.
wendy rogers: Somepeoplestayforfourhours.Somepeoplestayforfivehours.Thefirsttimewedidit,theystayedallfivehours.Wedidn’texpectthattohappen.
sara rudner: IwaskindofappalledwhenIheardsomeonehadstayedforfourhours.Who’dwanttowatchallthisforthatlong?
wendy rogers: There’sbothimprovisedandsetmaterialandmanydifferentduetsandrelationships;sothatanygroupissortofthesumofalltherelationships,thedifferent,distinctrelationshipswithinthegroup.It’sallaboutthesehighlyarticulatedindividualsworkingasagroupbutwithoutbecominguniform,evenwhensharingasensibilityorsharinganideaorevensharing
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 19
amovement.Iguessthatreallyattractsmetothisworkbecauseitfeelslikeanimportantpoliticalidea,thattherereallycanbecomplex,highlyarticulatedrelationshipsallco-existing.
Lisa Kraus: Howdidyouknowwhenfourhourswere gone?
sara rudner: Oh,everythingwastimed.Wehadatimekeeper.You’llseeawomaninthecornerwayupthere—SonaliPrasad—whowasastudentofmyfriendSheilaRaj.ShecamefromIndiatoNewYork,andSheilasaid,“GolookupSara.”HerperformingexperiencewaswithOdissi-styledance,andwhatweweredoingwasveryforeigntoher.7Butshesaid,“CanIhelpinsomeway?”AndIsaid,“Well....”Shehadastopwatch.“Justtimeeverything,keepnotes,andI’lltellyouwhentostopandstart.”AndsostructuringandorganizingthispiecewasSonalioverhereandmesaying,“Okay.Everybodydothis,this,this,”andshewroteeverythingdown.Itwasalltimed.
wendy rogers: Itwasalltimed.Therewereimprovisations,buttherewasalwaysathrough-line.Soperhapsthepersonwhodidthesoloalwaysenteredatthesametime.Evenifsomethingtookalittlelonger,thatwasokay.Thenitjustoverlappedinaslightlydifferentway.
sara rudner: WhenIthinkaboutwhatwasgoingoninNewYorkatthetimethatwewereworking,Ifeelhowmuchdancehastotallyexploded.It’squiteextraordinary.
wendy rogers: What’sreallyexcitingtomeisthatwe’regettingtoamuchmoreinterestingplacewhere
7OdissiisoneformofIndianclassicaldance.ItsoriginslieinthestateofOrissaonIndia’seastcoast.
SelectionfromtheNewYorkDanceFestivalprogram,September12and13,1976,courtesyWendyRogers.SeeAppendixI.
d A n c e A d v A n c e
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 20
contemporarydanceisaglobalpreoccupation.Contemporarycomesfromeverywhere.Itwasafalseideathatthiswastraditionalandthatwascontemporary.It’sbeenreallystimulatingtometowork[inthedancedepartmentatUniversityofCalifornia,Riverside]withscholarcolleagueswhointerrogateconceptsandtheoriesandpoliticalunderstandingsorquestionsinrelationshiptodance.Ihavebeenveryexcitedmywholelifeaboutanydancing.Butnow,there’smoredimensiontoit,moreunderstandingaboutwhatdancingmightcontain,forexample,thatforthisgroupofpeoplethedancemaymeantheirdeedtothislandorforthisgroupofpeoplethedancingdefinessomethingelse.
Sothedancestudiesfieldhasexploded,andthenumberofbooksontheshelves,andthedifferentpointsofviewthattheyoffergiveusallsortsofquestionstoask.IhavehugequestionsthatIamaskingnowthatIdidn’tbeforeeventhoughthoseyearsinNewYork—well,youknow—theywerefilledwithalotofdancing!
Ithinkearlyontherewassomeideaofmasterythatdrovemeasadancer:IwanttolearntodothisorIwanttolearntodothatorIwanttounderstandthis,orIwanttofigurethisout.Somehowmyunderstandingofthatisquitedifferentnow.ThemoreIdanceorthemoreIthinkaboutthings,themoreconfusedIget.Butitdoesn’tstopmefromdoingprojects—it’sjustprettyconfusing.Ifeelthatit’spartofcontemporarylifenowthatwedon’thavetheluxuryofakindofculturalmono-vision.Atanygivenmomentsomanythingsmakeyouawareofmultiplewaysofperceivingwhatitisyouthinkyou’redoingversuswhatyouareactuallydoing.Ithinkthat’soneoftheinterestingthingsaboutthistimebecauseperceptionissuchajuicyplaceforchoreography,isn’tit?
sara rudner: Andalsootherpeople’sresponsetowhatyou’redoing.
wendy rogers: Yes!
sara rudner: IthinkwhatWendy’stalkingaboutisthatthefieldisgettingwiderwithmoreinformationcomingtoourattention.Imean,eachindividualhastomakeadecisionaboutwhatpathtostartfollowing.Itdoesn’tmeanthatit’sgoingtobestraight.Itmightbranchoffinlotsofways.Ifindthetrickiestthingaboutitistoremaincalmenoughtojustsay,“Yes,whatI’mdoingisinterestingtome.”Ifyoustartworryingaboutwhetherit’sgoingtobeacceptedhereorproducedthere,willIgetthisgrant,willIduhduhduhduhduhduhduh,thenwe’reworkingagainstourselvesinacertainway.
BeingwithWendyneverfailstorekindlesomething.BeforecomingtoPhiladelphiaIwasinmyofficeandIjustneededtohearhervoice.OnceIhearherspeakingIcanbecomecenteredonwhatwearegoingtodotogether.Thefirsttimewewereworkingtogetheronthis,Wendyshowedmethedancingthatshewasmaking.AndIwent,Oh,yes!Irecognize
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 21
that!Isaid,“That’sWendy!”IcanfeelWendy.Ifeelprecision,Ifeelthenonsequitursthatmakesense.Thesearethethingsthathavealwaysdrawnmetoherwork.
wendy rogers: Thereisn’tanyotherrelationshiplikethisone.Ithinkpartofitiswejustlovedancing.WhenIgetbackwithSara,IfeellikeI’mintouchwithmyveryfirstexperiencesofmovement,likewhenI’dseesomethinghappeningandI’dwanttodoit,too.I’dwanttojoinin.Iwanttoedit,Iwanttoshapeit.AndsoIguessthat’swhyItendtoworkwithpeople,fromalldifferentkindsofdancingandmovementbackgrounds—somehowI’vefiguredoutthattheyreallyliketomoveandorganizetheirmovementandopenthemselvesuptofiguringoutmovement.Alotofwhatthisfeelingisaboutishowamazingitiswhenagroupcreatesitsownhistorythroughdanceanddancing.Youspendtimewithpeopleandcreatehistoryandcarryitforward.
Whenwefirstgottogethertotalkaboutthispresentation—andit’ssomethingthathasn’tcomeupinthissessiontonightbutthatwassovividtomeintheplanning—isthatbothofusaredealingwiththeissueofpartsfailure.
sara rudner: Partsfailure.[laughter]
wendy rogers: Asyouknow,itisgreathavingmadealotofdances,andIsupposewegetwiser.Butthepartsstarttofail.OneofthethingsthatIappreciateishavingthespirittoask,“Wherearewenow?”or“Whatcanhappennow?”That’ssuchafascinatingplacetobe,andifyoukeepbeingdisciplined—beingreallyhonestaboutwhatthenowis—it’samazinghowthehistoryandthefutureflowinandoutofthenow.
sara rudner: WhatwasthatquestionsomeoneaskedmeonMay13?Whatwerethegoodolddays?
wendy rogers: Yes,whatwerethegoodolddays?
sara rudner: Idon’tknow.Iwaswhirlingarounddoingsomekindofcrazystuff.AndIsaid,“Thesearethegoodolddays.Thisisit,rightnow.”
Audience member: Iwaswonderingifyoucouldanswerwhatitisthatyouloveaboutmovementandwhy?
sara rudner: Itisawayofexperiencinglife.It’sakindofanenergythatcomesoutofyou.There’ssomethingaboutsomeofus,thewaythingsareputtogether,thewaythey’rearticulated:ourtendons,ourbrains,ourligaments,armmuscles,andsomethingaboutourenergiesthatdefineseventhekindofdancingwedoandwhatwe’regoingtotendtowardsdoinginourwork.
IwasontheroadtoworkingfortheSocialSecurityAdministration.[laughter]YouknowwhatImean?Igotoutofcollege.Myfathersaid,“Youhavetotakethecivilserviceexam.”AndI
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 22
Allphotos:Dancing May’s Dances.MerceCunninghamDanceStudio,NewYork,1976.DancersinphotosincludeDeniBank,RisaJaroslow,FrancescaBartoccini,WendyRogers,ShanaMenaker,SaraRudner,andRobinDavis.Photo©JohanElbers(1976),courtesySaraRudner.Archivalmaterial:WendyRogers’handwrittennotesforDancing May’s Dances,courtesyWendyRogers.SeeAppendixJforthehandwrittenandtypednotes,aswellasadditionalmaterialsonDancing May’s Dances.
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 23
wentandItookit.IgotthejobbeforeIevengraduated.AndIsaidtomyparents,“Justgivemefiveyears.Givemeacoupleofyearstofigureoutmylife.MaybeI’lldosomethingelse…”
Ialwayswantedtodance.AndIfoundthatultimatelyTwylausedtolookatmeandsay,“Well,ifshewasn’tdancingandmakingdances,she’dbeacriminal.She’dbeamurderer.”Andsoinpartthiswasawayoffindingmywayintheworldinapersonallyenhancingandphysicallyhealthyway.Iusethewordhealthinsomeoverallsense.Itenabledmetobringpartsofmyselftogetherthatarestillcomingtogether.
wendy rogers: I’vediscoveredthatmy10yearprojectwasactuallymycomingtoanunderstandingthat,ratherthanmakingpiecesinacompany,whatIreallywantedwastousedanceasawaytolocatemyself,tosortoutthewhoandwhatandwhyofmyself.IrealizedmakingdanceswithotherpeoplewashowIsituatedmyselfintheworld.AndIsaid,“Whycan’tthatactivitybethevehicle?”The10yearswasjusttimeandaconstantprocessofusingdancingasawaytobeintheworld.SoIthinkformemovinghasalwaysbeenhowIknowwheretheheckIamorwhatI’mdoing.That’showIfigureitout.
sara rudner: WhenIwasdancingyearsago,Iusedtoaskmyself,“HowmanyhoursdidIdancetoday?”I’dgo,“one,two,three,four?”NowallIcanthinkaboutishowmuchIwanttodivestmyself.Andthatisamaturingexperience.AndI’mveryhappythatI’velivedlongenoughandmedicalsciencehasenabledmetogoonanddocertainthingsthatImightnothave...let’ssaythingsmygrandmothercouldn’tdobecauseshewascrippledbythesamethingthat,youknow,struckme.
ButeverytimeIwanttoinvestigatesomething,Ihavetohavesomephysicalexperienceofit,eithergeneratingtheactionorexperiencingwhatthedancersaredoing.Sothat’swhyItrytodoallthosethings—tokeepmybodyactivesoitdoesn’tbecomeremovedfrommoving.I’mnotaconceptualist.IsawaYouTubevideoofTwylaTharp.Youhavetocheckthisout.There’ssomeguywhoisinterviewingher.Andshemakeshimdance.It’sgreat.Andshefinallysays,“Youknowyourmindisn’tgoingtoworkifyourbody’snotworking.”
WhenIseepeopledancingandthey’rerealizingwhotheyare,it’slikethebestgiftintheworld.
wendy rogers: Fromthekindofworkwe’vedone,we’vedevelopedtechniqueswhereourphysicalitycanbesharedandlaunched,andwedon’thavetocontrolthedancers.Ihavequestionsaboutperformancerightnow—formyselfandwhatthatmightbe.WhatIreallylikeinmyworkwithdancersistofindwaystobothgivethemsomething,andthenfinddifferentavenuesforwhat
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 24
decisionsImakeandwhatdecisionsIletthemmakeortheirbodiesmake.Ilovelaunchingsomethingandthenseeingwherethedancerstakeitwithallthethingsthattheyknow.
sara rudner: There’sadesire—allofushaveitindifferentdegreesprobably—adesireforcommunity,adesiretohaveanintegratedlife.Ifyou’vebeenadancer,youknowhowquicklythatcanchange,howseparateyoufeelyouhavetobe.Oh,Ihavetogetupatthistimeanddothisanddothis.AndIhavetodomypliésbeforeIdothis.It’saverycontrolled,veryregimentedlifeinmanyways.That’sbrokenapartalittlebitlately.
IamasocialanimalandIcan’tevengointothestudiobymyselftomakeasolo.Ihavetotakealotofpeopleinwithme.It’strue.It’sjustthatIhavetoapologizeandsay,“Please,wouldyouhelpme?Ijustneedpeopletobeherewithme.”Andthen,atsomepoint,Ihavetosay,“Well,okay.Ihavetodothisonmyownnow.”Ihavetoclosethedoor,andsay,okay,thisisasolo.
wendy rogers: Lifehasledtoanunderstandingthatultimatelyyoucan’tcontrolwhatexperiencepeoplearegoingtohave.However,thatdoesn’tmeanitdoesn’tmatter.Itsimplymeansthatyoushapethings,youofferthings,andthenyouinvitetheexperience.Evenifpeoplereallyjusthatewhatyoudo,youhavetobeavailableforthefullrangeofpotentialconnectionordisconnectthatyou’regoingtofeelwithagroupofpeoplewhenyoumakeyouroffering.
This conversation transcribed and edited March 2011–April 2012 by Toni Shapiro-Phim.
WendyRogersandSaraRudner(lefttoright),November Duets,MerceCunninghamDanceStudio,1977.PhotobyFrancescaBartoccini,courtesyWendyRogers.
d A n c e A d v A n c e
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 25
Biography of Sara Rudner
Biography of Lisa Kraus
Biographies of Francesca Bartoccini and Johan Elbers, photographers
Biography of Wendy Rogers
SaraRudneriscurrentlytheDirectorofDanceatSarahLawrenceCollege.From1965–85,sheparticipatedinthedevelopmentandperformanceofTwylaTharp’smoderndancerepertory.ShemadedancesforasmallgroupofdancersknownastheSaraRudnerPerformanceEnsemble,andhaspursuedherinterestsinchoreography,improvisation,andperformingwithcolleaguesWendyRogers,DanaReitz,MikhailBaryshnikov,RussellDumas,andChristopherJanney.RudnerreceivedtheDance Magazineawardin2009,aBessiein1984,andgrantsfromtheNationalEndowmentfortheArts,theJohnSimonGuggenheimMemorialFoundation,andtheNewYorkStateCouncilontheArts.ShehasbeenadjunctfacultyatNewYorkUniversity’sTischSchooloftheArts,ateachingfellowatBenningtonCollege,andguestfacultyatTheJuilliardSchool.RudnerholdsanMFAfromBenningtonCollegeandaBAfromBarnardCollege.
WendyRogersisaprofessorofdanceattheUniversityofCalifornia,Riverside.Shehaschoreographedandperformedcontemporarydancesforover40years.TheWendyRogersDanceCompany(1977–90),andsubsequent10yearprojectsMAKESHIFT dancingandWENDY ROGERS dancing,tourednationallyandinternationally.RogershasreceivedgrantsandfellowshipsfromtheFoundationforContemporaryArts,theIrvineFellowshipsinDance,theJohnSimonGuggenheimFoundation,andtheNationalEndowmentfortheArts,aswellasa2009FulbrightFellowshipforworkinMalaysia.CurrentlySaraRudnerandRogersarerevisitingtheircollaborativeworkdatingfromthe‘70s,withthe‘running’fromDancing-on-View(1975)asapointofdeparture.RogersholdsanMAfromStanfordUniversitySchoolofEducation,andhasstudiedwithJennyHunter,DavidWood,MargaretJenkins,MerceCunningham,CarolynBrown,andViolaFarber,amongothers.
LisaKraus’careerhasincludedperforming(TrishaBrownDanceCompanyandherowncompany),teaching(SwarthmoreCollege,NaropaUniversity,theEuropeanDanceDevelopmentCenter),presenting(asCoordinatorofBrynMawrCollegePerformingArtsSeries),andwriting(Dance Magazine,Philadelphia Inquirer,herblog“WritingMyDancingLife”).SheeditsthINKingDANCE.net,anonlinejournal,andwasa2010NEAFellowinDanceCriticism.HerchoreographyhasbeenpresentedbyvenuesincludingTheKitchen,Danspace,PhiladelphiaDanceProjects,SushiinSanDiego,London’sDanceUmbrella,andSydney’sDanceExchange.ShehasbeenawardedChoreographers’FellowshipsandprojectsupportfromtheNationalEndowmentfortheArts,theNewYorkFoundationfortheArts,ThePewCenterforArts&HeritagethroughDanceAdvance,andthePennsylvaniaCouncilontheArts.
Asayoungactor/dancerFrancescaBartocciniworkedwithSaraRudnerandWendyRogersduringthe70’sinNewYorkCity.Shebeganherphotographycareertakingphotosofindividualdancerswhichledtophotographingmanydancersanddancecompanies includingTheJoffreyBallet,DanWagonerandCompany,andAmericanBalletTheatre,tonameafew.LatershemovedtoCaliforniaandstartedworkinginthefilmindustrywhereshebecameaproductiondesigner. Bartoccinileftthatindustryafter25yearstodesignandremodelhomes—stillwithaneyetomovement,spaceandlight.
JohanElbers’photographiccreditsincludeTheMetropolitanOpera,AmericanBalletTheatre,NewYorkCityBallet,DanceTheatreofHarlem,TheKirovBallet,TheBolshoiBallet,TheParisOperaBalletaswellasmoderndancecompaniesMerceCunninghamDanceCompany,AlvinAileyAmericanDanceTheater,PaulTaylorDanceCompany,MarthaGrahamDanceCompany,TrishaBrownDanceCompanyandothers.HehasalsophotographedtheaterandmusicartistsRobertWilson,RichardForeman,LeeBreuerandJazzmusiciansOrnetteColeman,DizzyGillespieandBettyCarter.
dance Advance|ThePewCenterforArts&Heritage|1608WalnutStreet,18thFloor|Philadelphia,PA19103phone:267.350.4970|fax:267.350.4998|www.pcah.us/dance|[email protected]&Heritage.©2012DanceAdvance
ForbiographicalandartisticinformationonRobertKushner,visitwww.robertkushnerstudio.com
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 26
Capturing the tone, celebrating the workAppendicesAppendixA:page 27 PostcardforDancing-on-ViewfeaturingartworkbyRobertKushner.
AppendixB:page 28 Theatre Crafts MagazinecoverfeaturingtheSaraRudnerPerformanceensemble,March/April1980.
AppendixC:page 29 Programforthetwo-hourversionofDancing-on-ViewperformedatOberlinCollegein1975.
AppendixD:page 30 ScoreandprogramforDancing- on-View,June,1975.
AppendixE:page 34 ProgramforNovember DuetsperformedwithPeggySternattheMerceCunninghamStudio,March1977.
AppendixF:page 35 PostcardfortheperformanceofNovember DuetswithPeggySternattheMerceCunninghamStudio,
March1977.
AppendixG:page 36 WendyRogers’handwrittencuesheetforNovember Duets.page 38 TypedtranscriptionofWendyRogers’cuesheetforNovember Duets.page 40 DanceUmbrellaprogramforasharedeveningwithRachelLampertandDancers,SaraRudnerwith
WendyRogers,andSentaDriver,February1977.page 44 FlyerforDanceUmbrella’sSpringSeason,1977.
AppendixH:page 45 ArticleinCable TV World,May18–21,1976aboutdanceinNewYorkCityfeaturingtheSaraRudner
PerformanceEnsemble.
AppendixI:page 49 NewYorkDanceFestivalProgram,Summer1976.
AppendixJ:page 53 WendyRogers’handwrittennotesforDancing May’s Dances,1976.page 55 TypedtranscriptionofWendyRogers’notesforDancing May’s Dances.page 56 PostcardforDancing May’s DancesattheMerceCunninghamStudio,May1976.page 57 ProgramforDancing May’s DancesattheMerceCunninghamStudio,May1976.
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 27
AppendiX A:
PostcardforDancing-on-ViewfeaturingartworkbyRobertKushner.CourtesyWendyRogers.
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 28
AppendiX b:
Theatre Crafts MagazinecoverfeaturingtheSaraRudnerPerformanceensemble,March/April1980.Lefttoright:SaraRudner,ShanaMenaker,KristineLindahl,LindaCohen,AmySpencer,andVickyShick.CoverphotobyNathanielTileston.CourtesySaraRudner.
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 29
AppendiX c:
Programforthetwo-hourversionofDancing-on-ViewperformedatOberlinCollegein1975.CourtesyWendyRogers.
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 30
AppendiX d:
ScoreandprogramforDancing-on-View,June1975.CourtesyWendyRogers.
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 31
AppendiX d, continued:
ScoreandprogramforDancing-on-View,June1975,continued.CourtesyWendyRogers.
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 32
AppendiX d, continued:
ScoreandprogramforDancing-on-View,June1975,continued.CourtesyWendyRogers.
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 33
AppendiX d, continued:
ScoreandprogramforDancing-on-View,June1975,continued.CourtesyWendyRogers.
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 34
AppendiX e:
ProgramforNovember DuetsperformedwithPeggySternattheMerceCunninghamStudio,March1977.CourtesyWendyRogers.
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 35
AppendiX f:
PostcardfortheperformanceofNovember DuetswithPeggySternattheMerceCunninghamStudio,March1977.CourtesyWendyRogers.
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 36
AppendiX g:
WendyRogers’handwrittencuesheetforNovember Duets.CourtesyWendyRogers.
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 37
AppendiX g, continued:
WendyRogers’handwrittencuesheetforNovember Duets,page2.CourtesyWendyRogers.
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 38
AppendiX g, continued:
WendyRogers’transcribedcuesheetforNovember Duets.CourtesyWendyRogers.TranscribedbyJosieSmith.
NOVEMBER DUETS/MOLLY’S SUITE CUE SHEET Peggy’s Perfection W dancers on ct and end of PP #1 S Joins – her 1 rock is 1 , MUSIC begins on 5 or 6 rock end: S & W on heels in corner , MUSIC ends nearly the same time transition : S does a fragment #2 Peggy counts tempo S begins W joins on 4th twist , MUSIC begins after S 4th twist Open ending W stops transition: W does fragment, S echoes , MUSIC continues #3 S does pre-chicken waves, , MUSIC phases into it W joins 1 chicken wave S & W end on floor, lying, , MUSIC ends afterwards transition: no fragments #4 Peggy starts ----------------------- BACH MUSIC Here’s Johnny: S does 1 W does 2, S-3, W-4, S-5, W-6, S & W ---- 7, 8, 9, 10 ---- S & W end in still position ,MUSIC changes back to Here’s Johnny S & W get chairs #5 Peggy starts ------------------------------------- DARN THAT DREAM W begins after 8, 1 & S & W end music ends a few beats later W starts second part – Does the movement once S joins-------------------------------------------- MUSIC begins S & W sit MUSIC ends
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 39
AppendiX g, continued:
WendyRogers’transcribedcuesheetforNovember Duets,page2.CourtesyWendyRogers.TranscribedbyJosieSmith.
CUE SHEET CONT. #6 S & W ins & outs SILENCE end after slow motion #7 Peggy starts ------------------------------------ TOOTSIE S & W end-------------------------------------- music ends
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 40
AppendiX g, continued:
DanceUmbrellaprogramforasharedeveningwithRachelLampertandDancers,SaraRudnerwithWendyRogers,andSentaDriver,February1977.CourtesyWendyRogers.
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 41
AppendiX g, continued:
DanceUmbrellaprogramforasharedeveningwithRachelLampertandDancers,SaraRudnerwithWendyRogers,andSentaDriver,February1977,continued.CourtesyWendyRogers.
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 42
AppendiX g, continued:
DanceUmbrellaprogramforasharedeveningwithRachelLampertandDancers,SaraRudnerwithWendyRogers,andSentaDriver,February1977,continued.CourtesyWendyRogers.
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 43
AppendiX g, continued:
DanceUmbrellaprogramforasharedeveningwithRachelLampertandDancers,SaraRudnerwithWendyRogers,andSentaDriver,February1977,continued.CourtesyWendyRogers.
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 44
AppendiX g, continued:
FlyerforDanceUmbrella’sSpringSeason,1977.CourtesyWendyRogers.
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 45
AppendiX h:
ArticleinCable TV World(May18–21,197aboutdanceinNewYorkCity,featuringtheSaraRudnerPerformanceEnsemble,alsopicturedonthecover.Fromlefttoright:ShanaMenaker,WendyRogers,RisaJaroslow,RobinDavis,andDeniBanks(sitting).CourtesyWendyRogers.
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 46
AppendiX h, continued:
ArticleinCable TV World(May18–21,1976aboutdanceinNewYorkCity,featuringtheSaraRudnerPerformanceEnsemble,continued.CourtesyWendyRogers.
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 47
AppendiX h, continued:
ArticleinCable TV World(May18–21,1976aboutdanceinNewYorkCity,featuringtheSaraRudnerPerformanceEnsemble,continued.CourtesyWendyRogers.
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 48
AppendiX h, continued:
ArticleinCable TV World(May18–21,1976aboutdanceinNewYorkCity,featuringtheSaraRudnerPerformanceEnsemble,continued.CourtesyWendyRogers.
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 49
AppendiX i:
NewYorkDanceFestivalProgram,Summer1976.CourtesyWendyRogers.
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 50
AppendiX i, continued:
NewYorkDanceFestivalProgram,Summer1976,continued.CourtesyWendyRogers.
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 51
AppendiX i, continued:
NewYorkDanceFestivalProgram,Summer1976,continued.CourtesyWendyRogers.
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 52
AppendiX i, continued:
NewYorkDanceFestivalProgram,Summer1976,continued.CourtesyWendyRogers.
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 53
AppendiX J:
WendyRogers’handwrittennotesforDancing May’s Dances,1976.CourtesyWendyRogers.
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 54
AppendiX J, continued:
WendyRogers’handwrittennotesforDancing May’s Dances,1976,page2.CourtesyWendyRogers.
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 55
AppendiX J, continued:
WendyRogers’transcribednotesforDancing May’s Dances,1976.CourtesyWendyRogers.TranscribedbyJosieSmith.
Friday June 18, 1976 Notes–Sara’s piece “Dancing May’s Dances” My Part Sara starts end up as We walk out and form a line — I’m ↑ second in from stage rt – Robin is on my left. Sara is on my right after she finishes her introduction which travels past each of us acknowledging some part of our dance material. Sara backs into place facing stage left – I paw the ground with my feet – doing the “ready go” from the trio – I rush diagonally out stop – go back join Robin in a jump with head over the top rt left : step step lunge turning to rt (travelling stage left all the while) 2 of Shana’s left shoulder touch (with rt. hand) rt shoulder – hand behind back palm out & 3 step turn – into place in a clump behind Deni – Shana downstage rt. , Risa upstage left close – 6 shoulder shakes forward as back curves sequentially throw head back arch, then forward swing rt (look upstage) swing to left – left hand on chin rt hand on left elbow – FREEZE Wait for Deni’s cue – (leg crossed stop) Start moving stage rt – moderate tempo 3 cts paw ground – face downstage left diagonal 4 cts Shana touch thing, 4 cts paw & run, 4 cts throw rt hand across & up left – rt foot off (“Tracks”) stop rt turn in plié with arms up and lean. 2 cts paw 2 4cts Tracks – touch left, rt hand out – watch Shana – she starts to walk – walk backwards to a place slightly downstage and st. rt of Robin (but basically over on st. left) do arms from trio until Risa says GO. Ct fast 123, 223, 323 slow down to super slow by 623 count one shape rt hip out, ct 2 hands far & cross each other – left knee bent turned in, foot flexed & up, at three hands to side rt as in offer for Chinese partners. Then whisper YA TA TA TA – looking up, hunching shoulders, clench hands softly, elbows bent wait for Francesca to finish windmill arms : [cue] three circles and a punch. Deni’s path upstage – face left – lean downstage with body & arms overhead – reach left leg upstage 3 touches step behind with rt foot – back turn stutter left foot once put weight on it & hop – left arm in ward – step it to turn left 3 steps – reverse left arm out head to ceiling end chop left arm down. Plié walk fwd. doing sections of Risa’s face fingers – freeze – until she’s done – then to low plié head down turn until others catch up & start to jump. Red dog phrase fast, full, in place then turn & do slowly thru everyone. Hands signal – pawing – walk – fall. Up Robins’s [lean] 2 times walk full up, lean 2 times freeze for Robin’s solo – then start phrase small at first each lean change fake jump 2 Shanas, sit down shake into pose – up one track backwards 6 cts – 3 cts of Risa’s face – exit stage left with Deni’s.
# Sitting Trio -4 of us do slow follow: Sara then Shana lead alphabet with heads – once small slowish, once 1 2 3 4 5
big 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10, 1 0 1 0 1 0 10 1 hold small again Animals: st. rt – gorilla, camel, raccoon, bison – [______] throw at F’s feet she leaps over Break – I catch breath – begin next chaos
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 56
AppendiX J, continued:
PostcardforDancing May’s DancesattheMerceCunninghamStudio,May1976.CourtesyWendyRogers.
capturing the tone, celebrating the workAconversationwithWendyRogersandSaraRudnerintroducedbyLisaKraus 57
AppendiX J, continued:
ProgramforDancing May’s DancesattheMerceCunninghamStudio,May1976.CourtesyWendyRogers.