+ All Categories
Home > Documents > QVO - Columbia Universitygelman/research/unpublished/...Jun 05, 2014  · i kw]xtm wn lmkilm[ wz...

QVO - Columbia Universitygelman/research/unpublished/...Jun 05, 2014  · i kw]xtm wn lmkilm[ wz...

Date post: 12-Aug-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 0 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
25
<PM /ZMI\ ;WKQM\a :MIOIV¼[ :M^WT]\QWV IVL /MVMZI\QWV[ WN 8ZM[QLMV\QIT >W\QVO AIQZ /PQ\bI )VLZM_ /MTUIV 2]VM ?7:316/ 8)8-: )J[\ZIK\ ?M J]QTL I OMVMZI\QWVIT UWLMT WN XZM[QLMV\QIT ^W\QVO QV _PQKP TWVO\MZU XIZ\Q[IV XZM[Q LMV\QIT ^W\QVO XZMNMZMVKM[ IZM NWZUML QV TIZOM XIZ\ \PZW]OP I _MQOP\ML ¹Z]VVQVO \ITTaº WN ZM\ZW[XMK\Q^M XZM[QLMV\QIT M^IT]I\QWV[ _PMZM _MQOP\[ IZM LM\MZUQVML Ja \PM IOM QV _PQKP \PM M^IT]I\QWV _I[ UILM =VLMZ \PM UWLMT \PM /ITT]X 8ZM[QLMV\QIT )XXZW^IT :I\QVO \QUM [MZQM[ Q[ [PW_V \W JM I OWWL IXXZW`QUI\QWV \W \PM XWTQ\QKIT M^MV\[ \PI\ QVNWZU ZM\ZW[XMK \Q^M XZM[QLMV\QIT M^IT]I\QWV[ <PM XWTQ\QKIT M^MV\[ WN I ^W\MZ¼[ \MMVIOM IVL MIZTa IL]T\ aMIZ[ KMV\MZML IZW]VL \PM IOM WN IZM MVWZUW][Ta QUXWZ\IV\ QV \PM NWZUI\QWV WN \PM[M TWVO \MZU XIZ\Q[IV XZMNMZMVKM[ <PM UWLMT Q[ [PW_V \W JM XW_MZN]T M`XTIQVQVO I []J[\IV\QIT IUW]V\ WN \PM UIKZWTM^MT ^W\QVO \ZMVL[ WN \PM TI[\ PITN KMV\]Za M[XMKQITTa NWZ _PQ\M ^W\MZ[ IVL VWV;W]\PMZV _PQ\M[ QV XIZ\QK]TIZ ?M ][M I VIZZI\Q^M WN XZM[QLMV\QIT XWTQ\QKIT M^MV\[ NZWU \PM ![ \W \PM XZM[MV\ LIa \W LM[KZQJM \PM UWLMT QTT][\ZI\QVO \PM NWZUI\QWV WN Å^M UIQV OMVMZI\QWV[ WN XZM[QLMV\QIT ^W\MZ[ +PQMN ;KQMV\Q[\ +I\ITQ[\# 8P, +IVLQLI\M ,MXIZ\UMV\ WN 8WTQ\QKIT ;KQMVKM +WT]UJQI =VQ^MZ[Q\a ,MXIZ\UMV\[ WN ;\I\Q[\QK[ IVL 8WTQ\QKIT ;KQMVKM +WT]UJQI =VQ^MZ[Q\a
Transcript
Page 1: QVO - Columbia Universitygelman/research/unpublished/...Jun 05, 2014  · i kw]xtm wn lmkilm[ wz tm[[ .wz m`iuxtm wvm wn \pm nmi\]zm[ wn \pm mizta li\i kqzki \pm ! [ ! [ _i[ \pm wj[mz^i\qwv

<PM�/ZMI\�;WKQM\a� :MIOIV¼[�:M^WT]\QWV� IVL

/MVMZI\QWV[�WN �8ZM[QLMV\QIT�>W\QVO

AIQZ�/PQ\bI� )VLZM_�/MTUIV�

2]VM��� ����

?7:316/ 8)8-:

)J[\ZIK\

?M�J]QTL�I�OMVMZI\QWVIT�UWLMT�WN �XZM[QLMV\QIT�^W\QVO� QV�_PQKP� TWVO�\MZU�XIZ\Q[IV�XZM[Q�LMV\QIT�^W\QVO�XZMNMZMVKM[�IZM�NWZUML� QV�TIZOM�XIZ\� \PZW]OP�I�_MQOP\ML�¹Z]VVQVO�\ITTaº�WNZM\ZW[XMK\Q^M�XZM[QLMV\QIT�M^IT]I\QWV[� _PMZM�_MQOP\[�IZM�LM\MZUQVML�Ja�\PM�IOM� QV�_PQKP\PM�M^IT]I\QWV�_I[�UILM� =VLMZ�\PM�UWLMT� \PM�/ITT]X�8ZM[QLMV\QIT�)XXZW^IT�:I\QVO�\QUM[MZQM[� Q[� [PW_V�\W�JM�I�OWWL�IXXZW`QUI\QWV�\W� \PM�XWTQ\QKIT�M^MV\[� \PI\� QVNWZU�ZM\ZW[XMK�\Q^M�XZM[QLMV\QIT�M^IT]I\QWV[� <PM�XWTQ\QKIT�M^MV\[�WN �I�^W\MZ¼[�\MMVIOM�IVL�MIZTa�IL]T\�aMIZ[�KMV\MZML�IZW]VL�\PM�IOM�WN �� � IZM�MVWZUW][Ta�QUXWZ\IV\�QV�\PM�NWZUI\QWV�WN �\PM[M�TWVO�\MZU�XIZ\Q[IV�XZMNMZMVKM[� <PM�UWLMT� Q[� [PW_V� \W�JM�XW_MZN]T� M`XTIQVQVO�I� []J[\IV\QITIUW]V\�WN �\PM�UIKZW�TM^MT�^W\QVO�\ZMVL[�WN �\PM�TI[\�PITN �KMV\]Za� M[XMKQITTa�NWZ�_PQ\M�^W\MZ[IVL�VWV�;W]\PMZV�_PQ\M[�QV�XIZ\QK]TIZ� ?M�][M�I�VIZZI\Q^M�WN �XZM[QLMV\QIT�XWTQ\QKIT�M^MV\[NZWU�\PM��!��[�\W�\PM�XZM[MV\�LIa�\W�LM[KZQJM�\PM�UWLMT� QTT][\ZI\QVO�\PM�NWZUI\QWV�WN �Å^MUIQV�OMVMZI\QWV[�WN �XZM[QLMV\QIT�^W\MZ[�

�+PQMN �;KQMV\Q[\� +I\ITQ[\# 8P�,��+IVLQLI\M� ,MXIZ\UMV\�WN �8WTQ\QKIT�;KQMVKM�+WT]UJQI�=VQ^MZ[Q\a

�,MXIZ\UMV\[�WN �;\I\Q[\QK[�IVL�8WTQ\QKIT�;KQMVKM� +WT]UJQI�=VQ^MZ[Q\a

Page 2: QVO - Columbia Universitygelman/research/unpublished/...Jun 05, 2014  · i kw]xtm wn lmkilm[ wz tm[[ .wz m`iuxtm wvm wn \pm nmi\]zm[ wn \pm mizta li\i kqzki \pm ! [ ! [ _i[ \pm wj[mz^i\qwv

7V� 6W^MUJMZ� �� ����� ,MUWKZI\QK� 8ZM[QLMV\� *IZIKS7JIUI�_I[�ZMMTMK\ML�\W�\PM�)UMZQKIV�XZM[QLMVKa�Ja�LMNMI\�QVO� :MX]JTQKIV� 5Q\\� :WUVMa� _Q\P� I� ����� � UIZOQV� WZ�MY]Q^ITMV\Ta� Ja����� �WN �\PM�\_W�XIZ\a�^W\M� )T\PW]OP�\PQ[_I[�IV�QUXWZ\IV\�IVL�KMTMJZI\ML�^QK\WZa� 7JIUI¼[�^W\M�[PIZM_I[�[UITTMZ�\PIV�\PI\�WN �PQ[���� �MTMK\QWV� QV�_PQKP�PM�LM�NMI\ML�;MV� 2WPV�5K+IQV�_Q\P����� �WN �\PM�\_W�XIZ\a�^W\M�<PM�ZW]OPTa���XMZKMV\IOM�XWQV\�[_QVO�\W_IZL[�\PM�:MX]JTQ�KIV�KIVLQLI\M�_I[�VW\�MVW]OP�NWZ�:WUVMa�\W�_QV�\PM�MTMK\QWV�J]\� Q\�LQL�ZMÆMK\� []J[\IV\QIT� TW[[M[� NWZ�7JIUI�IUWVO�[WUM[]J�XWX]TI\QWV[�_Q\PQV�\PM�MTMK\WZI\M� 7VM�OZW]X�WN �XIZ\QK]�TIZ�QV\MZM[\�Q[�aW]VO�^W\MZ[� _PW�_MZM�IV�QUXWZ\IV\�XQMKM�WN7JIUI¼[���� �KWITQ\QWV� )KKWZLQVO�\W�\PM�M`Q\�XWTT[� 7JIUITW[\���XWQV\[�IUWVO�^W\MZ[�IOML�� ��!�_PMV�KWUXIZML�\W�\PM��� �ZM[]T\�� I�LMÅKQ\� \PI\�OZW_[� \W�!�XWQV\[�_PMV�_M� TWWSWVTa�I\�VWV�0Q[XIVQK�_PQ\M[�� <PM�\Z]M�[_QVO�IUWVO�aW]VO_PQ\M�^W\MZ[�UIa�QV�NIK\�PI^M�JMMV�[UITTMZ�\PIV�QVLQKI\ML�Ja\PM�M`Q\�XWTT[�� J]\�\PM[M�LI\I�KMZ\IQVTa�[]OOM[\�I�[]J[\IV\QITKPIVOM�W^MZ�7JIUI¼[�ÅZ[\�\MZU� ?Pa�_I[�\PMZM�[]KP�I�LZI�UI\QK�[PQN\�IUWVO�\PQ[�XIZ\QK]TIZ�OZW]X�WN �^W\MZ[' )VL�_PI\QUXIK\�UQOP\�\PQ[�KPIVOM�QUXTa�NWZ�N]\]ZM�MTMK\QWV['

?M�IV[_MZ�\PQ[�Y]M[\QWV�Ja�VW\�WVTa�M`IUQVQVO�\PQ[�XIZ\QK�]TIZ�OZW]X� J]\�Ja�J]QTLQVO�I�JZWILMZ�UWLMT�WN �OMVMZI\QWVIT^W\QVO�QV�)UMZQKIV�XZM[QLMV\QIT�MTMK\QWV[� 1V�\PM�UWLMT� TWVO�\MZU�XZM[QLMV\QIT�^W\QVO�XZMNMZMVKM[�IZM�NWZUML� QV�TIZOM�XIZ\�Ja�I� Z]VVQVO� \ITTa�WN � ZM\ZW[XMK\Q^M�XZM[QLMV\QIT� M^IT]I\QWV[�*]QTLQVO� NZWU� [QUQTIZ�UWLMT[� LM^MTWXML� Ja� W\PMZ� [KPWTIZ[�_M�[PW_�\PI\�\PM[M�ZM\ZW[XMK\Q^M�M^IT]I\QWV[�IZM�JM[\�KPIZIK�\MZQbML�I[�I�_MQOP\ML�I^MZIOM� QV�_PQKP�XZM[QLMV\QIT�XWTQ\QKITM^MV\[� NZWU�I�^W\MZ[¼� \MMVIOM�IVL�MIZTa�IL]T\�aMIZ[� \ISM�WV[]J[\IV\QITTa�UWZM�_MQOP\�

<PM�UWLMT�IKKW]V\[�NWZ�I�[]J[\IV\QIT�XWZ\QWV�WN �\PM�UIKZW�TM^MT�^IZQI\QWV�QV�^W\QVO�\ZMVL[�WN �\PM�XI[\�PITN �KMV\]Za� ?M[PW_�\PI\�\PM������[PQN\�IUWVO�aW]VO�^W\MZ[�_I[�QV�VW�_Ia�IZ�JQ\ZIZa� ZI\PMZ�Q\�_I[�QVLQKI\Q^M�WN �I�[a[\MUI\QK�\ZMVL�QV�_PQKPXWTQ\QKIT�M^MV\[�LQ[XZWXWZ\QWVI\MTa�QUXIK\�\PM�XWTQ\QKIT�XZMNMZ�MVKM[�WN �aW]VO�^W\MZ[� M[XMKQITTa�aW]VO�_PQ\M�^W\MZ[� IVL�XIZ�\Q[IV�XZM[QLMV\QIT�^W\QVO�I\\IKPUMV\[�ZMUIQV�ZMTI\Q^MTa�KWV[Q[�\MV\�W^MZ�UIVa�[]J[MY]MV\�LMKILM[� 1V�[PWZ\� 7JIUI¼[�TW[[M[

�7JIUI¼[�\_W�XIZ\a�^W\M�[PIZM�_I[������ �QV���� �IVL����� �QV�������7JIUI¼[������ �IL^IV\IOM�_I[�ÆQXXML�\W������ �QV�NI^WZ�WN �:WUVMa�QV�����

�?PMV�KWV[QLMZQVO�UIZOQV[�WN �MZZWZ�IZW]VL�\PM�M`Q\�XWTT�M[\QUI\M[� ITWVO_Q\P�[WUM�WN �\PM�SVW_V�LQNÅK]T\QM[�QV�KWVL]K\QVO�M`Q\�XWTT[� \PM�!�XMZKMV\IOMXWQV\�LQNNMZMVKM�[PW]TL�WVTa�JM�KWV[QLMZML�I�ZW]OP�M[\QUI\M�

IUWVO�aW]VO�XMWXTM�_MZM�ZMÆMK\ML�QV�PQ[�KWUXIZI\Q^MTa�XWWZXZM[QLMV\QIT�XMZNWZUIVKM�ZI\QVO[�TMILQVO�]X�\W�\PM������MTMK�\QWV[� IVL�\PW[M�TW[\�^W\M[�IZM�TQSMTa�\W�KIZZa�\W�N]\]ZM�XZM[Q�LMV\QIT�MTMK\QWV[�IUWVO�\PQ[�VM_�OMVMZI\QWV�WN �^W\MZ[�

<PM�XWTQ\QKIT�XZMNMZMVKM[�WN �aW]VO�^W\MZ[� IVL�\PM�NWZUI�\QWV�WN �\PW[M�XZMNMZMVKM[� PI^M�TWVO�JMMV�QUXWZ\IV\�IZMI[�WN[\]La�_Q\PQV�XWTQ\QKIT� [KQMVKM� [WKQWTWOa� IVL�[WKQIT�X[aKPWT�WOa� 1VLMML� \PM�[\]La�WN �¹XWTQ\QKIT�[WKQITQbI\QWV�º I[�VIUMLJa� 0aUIV� ��!�!�� \W]KPML� [WUM� WN � \PM� [MUQVIT� _WZS[� QV)UMZQKIV�XWTQ\QKIT�JMPI^QWZ� []KP�I[ <PM�)UMZQKIV�>W\MZ� .WZ+IUXJMTT�M\ IT����!���� XIZ\a�QLMV\QÅKI\QWV� _PQKP�[\Z]K\]ZM[XWTQ\QKIT�I\\Q\]LM[�IVL�^W\QVO�JMPI^QWZ� Q[�NWZUML�MIZTa�QV�TQNMIVL�Q[�LQZMK\ML�QV�TIZOM�XIZ\�Ja�XIZMV\IT�QVÆ]MVKM� 5]KP�WN\PM�MIZTa�TQ\MZI\]ZM�QV�\PM�ÅMTL�KWV\QV]ML�[\]LaQVO�aW]VO�XMW�XTM[¼�XZMNMZMVKM[�QV�\PQ[�ZMOIZL� WN\MV�][QVO�XIVMT�[\]LQM[�WNPQOP�[KPWWT�[\]LMV\[� IVL�[WUM\QUM[�WN �\PMQZ�XIZMV\[� \W�QLMV�\QNa�\PM�UQKZW�TM^MT�NW]VLI\QWV[�WN �XWTQ\QKIT�I\\Q\]LM[�IVL�JM�PI^QWZ[��

?PQTM�\PM�MIZTa�[\]LQM[�JMOIV�TWWSQVO�I\ UIKZW�TM^MT�QUXTQ�KI\QWV[�WN �\PM[M�UQKZW�\ZMVL[� \PMa�_MZM�TQUQ\ML�Ja�\PM�ZMTI�\Q^MTa�[PWZ\�\QUM�NZIUM[�\PI\�\PMQZ�[]Z^Ma[�KW^MZML¸VWZUITTaI�KW]XTM�WN �LMKILM[�WZ�TM[[� .WZ�M`IUXTM� WVM�WN �\PM�NMI\]ZM[�WN\PM�MIZTa�LI\I� KQZKI�\PM��!��[��!��[� _I[�\PM�WJ[MZ^I\QWV�\PI\WTLMZ�^W\MZ[�\MVLML�\W�QLMV\QNa�UWZM�I[�:MX]JTQKIV[� 5]KPQVS�_I[� [XQTTML� I\\MUX\QVO� \W� LQ[MV\IVOTM�_PM\PMZ� \PQ[�_I[L]M�\W�IOQVO� QV�_PQKP�[WUM�[WKQIT�WZ�X[aKPWTWOQKIT�XZWKM[[X][PML�QVLQ^QL]IT[�\W_IZL[�I�KWV[MZ^I\Q^M�^QM_XWQV\�TI\MZ�QVTQNM� WZ�OMVMZI\QWVIT�MNNMK\[� QV�_PQKP�\PM�[PIZML�TQNM�M^MV\[�WN\PI\�XIZ\QK]TIZ�JQZ\P�KWPWZ\�X]\�\PMU�UWZM�QV�TQVM�_Q\P�\PM�:M�X]JTQKIV�XIZ\a� +ZQ\\MVLWV���!���� ][QVO�LI\I�W^MZ�\PM�KW]Z[MWN ����aMIZ[� [M\\TML�WV�I�KWVKT][QWV�WN �IOQVO�MNNMK\[� _PQTM�+]\�TMZ���!���� /TMVV�IVL�0MNVMZ���!���� IVL�W\PMZ[� _Q\P�\PM�JMV�MÅ\�WN �ILLQ\QWVIT�LI\I�OI\PMZML�W^MZ�\PM�[]J[MY]MV\�LMKILM�KWVKT]LML�\PI\�\PM�ZMTI\QWV[PQX�_I[�I�OMVMZI\QWVIT�WVM�

-^MV\]ITTa� [KPWTIZ[� JMOIV� \W� ZMKWOVQbM� \PM� LQNÅK]T\a� QVN]TTa�LQ[MV\IVOTQVO�IOM� KWPWZ\� IVL�XMZQWL�MNNMK\[� \PM�TI[\�WN_PQKP�ZMNMZ[�\W�[XMKQÅK�[PWZ\�\MZU�QVÆ]MVKM[�WV�XWTQ\QKIT�I\�\Q\]LM[� <PM�XZWJTMU�_Q\P�\PQ[�TQVM�WN �Y]M[\QWVQVO�Q[�\PI\�WVMWN �\PM�\PZMM�MNNMK\[�Q[�N]TTa�LM\MZUQVML�Ja�\PM�KWUJQVI\QWV�WN\PM�W\PMZ�\_W¸QN �_M�KW]TL�N]TTa�M[\QUI\M�KWPWZ\�IVL�XMZQWL

�<PMZM�IZM�UIVa�M`\MV[Q^M�ZM^QM_[�WN �\PM�MIZTa�XMZQWL� M�O� �6QMUQ�IVL�;W�JQM[bMS���!��#�,MTTQ�+IZXQVQ���! !#�6QMUQ�IVL�0MXJ]ZV���!!��� 7VM�JWWSWN �XIZ\QK]TIZ�VW\M�Q[�2MVVQVO[�IVL�6QMUQ���! ��� _PQKP�[]UUIZQbM[�UIVa�WN\PMQZ�[]J[\IV\QIT�KWV\ZQJ]\QWV[�

Page 3: QVO - Columbia Universitygelman/research/unpublished/...Jun 05, 2014  · i kw]xtm wn lmkilm[ wz tm[[ .wz m`iuxtm wvm wn \pm nmi\]zm[ wn \pm mizta li\i kqzki \pm ! [ ! [ _i[ \pm wj[mz^i\qwv

MNNMK\[� ITWVO�_Q\P�\PM�QV\MZIK\QWV�JM\_MMV�\PM�\_W� \PMV�\PMXZMNMZMVKM[�WN �ITT�IOM�OZW]X[�_W]TL�JM�N]TTa�QLMV\QÅML��+WV�^MZ[M���!��#�/TMVV���!��#�5IZS][���! ��� )\\MUX\[�\W�M[\Q�UI\M�ITT� \PZMM�\WOM\PMZ�ZMTa�WV�UWLMTQVO�I[[]UX\QWV[� []KPI[�TQVMIZQ\a�IVL�ILLQ\Q^Q\a�WN �MNNMK\[�

*IZ\MT[�IVL�2IKSUIV��������ZMKWOVQbM�\PM[M�XZWJTMU[�IVLLM^MTWX� IV� IT\MZVI\Q^M�UWLMT� UWZM� M`XTQKQ\Ta� OZW]VLML� QV\PMWZQM[�WN �XWTQ\QKIT�TMIZVQVO"

:I\PMZ�\PIV�I\\MUX\QVO�\W�XIZ\Q\QWV�WJ[MZ^ML�^IZQ�IVKM� QV\W� ILLQ\Q^M� ¹XMZQWLº� IVL� ¹KWPWZ\º� MNNMK\[Ja�JZ]\M�NWZKM� _M�XW[Q\�I�[QVOTM�XZWKM[[�WN �XWTQ\Q�KIT�TMIZVQVO�QV�_PQKP�\PM�\_W�QUXWZ\IV\�MTMUMV\[IZM� ����XMZQWL�[XMKQÅK�¹[PWKS[º�ZMÆMK\QVO�\PM�LQ[�\QVK\Q^M�XWTQ\QKIT�M^MV\[�WN �I�OQ^MV�\QUM�XMZQWL� IVL���� IOM�[XMKQÅK� ¹_MQOP\[º� ZMÆMK\QVO� \PM� M`\MV\� \W_PQKP�\PM[M�[PWKS[�IZM�QV\MZVITQbML�Ja�QVLQ^QL]IT[I\�^IZQW][�XWQV\[�QV�\PM�TQNM�KaKTM� /MVMZI\QWVIT�XI\�\MZV[�WN �XWTQ\QKIT�KPIVOM�IZQ[M�MVLWOMVW][Ta�NZWU\PM�QV\MZIK\QWV�WN �\PM[M�JI[QK�MTMUMV\[¸I�NWZU�WNQV\MZIK\QWV�\PI\�KIVVW\�JM�KIX\]ZML�_Q\PQV�\PM�KWV�^MV\QWVIT�ILLQ\Q^M�CIOM�XMZQWL�KWPWZ\E�NZIUM_WZS�

<PM�*IZ\MT[�IVL�2IKSUIV�UWLMT�Q[�IV�I\\ZIK\Q^M�OMVMZITQbI�\QWV�WN � \PM�¹Z]VVQVO� \ITTaº�UWLMT� _PMZMJa� IV� QVLQ^QL]IT¼[XIZ\Q[IV� QLMV\QÅKI\QWV� Q[�I� N]VK\QWV�WN � ZM\ZW[XMK\Q^M�M^IT]I�\QWV[�WN �MIKP�XIZ\a¼[�XMZNWZUIVKM�W^MZ�\PM�KW]Z[M�WN �PQ[�WZ�PMZTQNM\QUM� �.QWZQVI���! �#�)KPMV���!!��� <PM�¹Z]VVQVO� \ITTaºUWLMT�Q[�I�[QUXTM�*IaM[QIV�TMIZVQVO�UWLMT� QV�_PQKP�M^IT]�I\QWV[�J]QTL�WV�\WX�WN �MIKP�W\PMZ� ITT�WN �\PMU�PI^QVO�MY]IT_MQOP\� ZMOIZLTM[[� WN � IOM� WZ� ZMKMVKa� )[� I� ZM[]T\� XWTQ\QKITM^MV\[�WKK]ZZQVO�MIZTa�QV�TQNM�IZM�VW�UWZM�WZ�TM[[� QUXWZ\IV\QV�NWZUQVO�XIZ\Q[IV�WXQVQWV[�\PIV�M^MV\[�NZWU�TI\MZ�WV� /MZ�JMZ�IVL�/ZMMV���!! ��XZW^QLM�IVW\PMZ�OMVMZITQbI\QWV�WN �\PM¹Z]VVQVO�\ITTaº�UWLMT� J]\�\PM�*IZ\MT[�IVL�2IKSUIV�UWLMT�_Q\P�XW\MV\QITTa�LQNNMZMV\�_MQOP\[�I[[WKQI\ML�_Q\P�IVa�IOM� Q[\PM�UW[\�ÆM`QJTM�

<PW]OP�\PM�*IZ\MT[�IVL�2IKSUIV�UWLMT�Q[�Y]Q\M�[I\Q[NaQVOWV�\PMWZM\QKIT�OZW]VL[� Å\\QVO�\PM�UWLMT�MUXQZQKITTa�XZW^M[KPITTMVOQVO� <PMa�\]ZV�\PMQZ�UWLMT�\W_IZL[�M[\QUI\QVO�XIZ�\Q[IV� QLMV\QÅKI\QWV� ][QVO� \PM� LQNNMZMV\QIT� XIZ\Q[IV[PQX� ZI\M[IKZW[[�\PM�)UMZQKIV�6I\QWVIT�-TMK\QWV�;\]La��)6-;� K]U]�TI\Q^M�LI\I[M\� <PM�)6-; Q[� I� OZMI\� ZM[W]ZKM� NWZ� \PQ[� \aXMWN �[\]La¸Q\�KIX\]ZM[�[]Z^Ma�ZM[XWV[M[�NZWU��!������ � IVL

I[� []KP�KW^MZ[�I����aMIZ� \QUM�XMZQWL�IVL�I�_QLM�^IZQM\a�WNOMVMZI\QWVIT�KWPWZ\[�W^MZ�UIVa�MTMK\QWV[� *]\�\PMQZ�MUXQZQKITUWLMT�\ZQM[�\W�M[\QUI\M JW\P \PM�XIZ\Q[IV�[PWKS[�IVL�\PM�IOM�[XMKQÅK�_MQOP\[� NZWU�\PM� [IUM�LI\I� )T\PW]OP� \PM�XIZIU�M\MZ[�WN �\PMQZ�UWLMT�IZM�VW\�KWUXTM\MTa�]VLMZQLMV\QÅML�� \PMUWLMT�IXXMIZ[�[\I\Q[\QKITTa�]VLMZXW_MZML� <PQ[�Q[�ZMÆMK\ML�QV\PMQZ�ZM[]T\[� QV�_PQKP�\PM�IOM�[XMKQÅK�_MQOP\[�Y]QKSTa�W[KQTTI\MJM\_MMV� VMOI\Q^M� IVL� XW[Q\Q^M� IVL� \PM� ]VKMZ\IQV\a� JW]VL[IZW]VL�\PW[M�_MQOP\[�IZM�TIZOM� \W�\PM�XWQV\�\PI\�ITUW[\�VWVMIZM�[\I\Q[\QKITTa�LQ[\QVO]Q[PIJTM�NZWU�bMZW�

1V�\PQ[�XIXMZ� _M�J]QTL�I�[QUQTIZ�UWLMT�IVL�][M� Q\� \W�]V�LMZ[\IVL� I� LQNNMZMV\� XPMVWUMVWV� \PI\�WN �XZM[QLMV\QIT�^W\�QVO� XZMNMZMVKM[� 8ZM[QLMV\QIT� ^W\QVO� Q[� IV� QLMIT� KPWQKM� NWZM[\QUI\QVO� \PQ[� XIZ\QK]TIZ�UWLMT� NWZ� \PZMM� ZMI[WV[� .QZ[\Ta�\PM�IK\QWV[�IVL�M^IT]I\QWV[�WN �\PM�XZM[QLMV\�IZM�IUWVO�\PMUW[\�X]JTQK�IVL�VW\IJTM�QV�)UMZQKIV�XWTQ\QK[� 1N� QV�\PM�[XQZQ\WN �5IVVPMQU���!���¼[� \PMWZa� _M� M`XMK\� OMVMZI\QWV[� \W� JM[PIXML�Ja�\PM�[PIZML�PQ[\WZQKIT�M^MV\[�\PI\�LWUQVI\ML�\PMQZaW]\P� Q\� Q[� TQSMTa� \PI\� XWTQ\QKITTa� \PW[M� M^MV\[�_QTT� WN\MV� JMI[[WKQI\ML�_Q\P�\PM�XZM[QLMV\� ;MKWVL� XZM[QLMV\QIT�MTMK\QWV[IZM�\PM�UW[\�[ITQMV\�XWTQ\QKIT�M^MV\[� QV�)UMZQKIV�XWTQ\QK[� I\TMI[\�IUWVO�\PW[M�\PI\�IZM�ZMO]TIZTa�[KPML]TML� <PMa�LZI_\PM�UW[\�I\\MV\QWV�WN �JW\P�\PM�UMLQI�IVL�\PM�OMVMZIT�X]JTQK�IVL�XZM[QLMV\QIT�\]ZVW]\�ZI\M[�IZM�PQOPMZ� Ja�I�_QLM�UIZOQV�\PIV�IVa�W\PMZ�NWZU�WN �XWTQ\QKIT�XIZ\QKQXI\QWV� *MKI][M�WN �\PQ[�XZM[QLMV\QIT�^W\QVO�XZMNMZMVKM[�IZM�IV�QUXWZ\IV\�XTIKM�\W�TWWSNWZ�\PM�M`XZM[[QWV�WN �OMVMZI\QWVIT�XWTQ\QKIT�XZMNMZMVKM[�

4I[\Ta� \PM� X]JTQK¼[� M^IT]I\QWV� WN � \PM� XZM[QLMV\� PI[� JMMVUMI[]ZML�WV�IV�WVOWQVO�JI[Q[�[QVKM�\PM��!��[� QV�\PM�NWZU�WN/ITT]X¼[�8ZM[QLMV\QIT�)XXZW^IT�:I\QVO� ?PMV�IXXTQML�\W�\PMY]M[\QWV�WN �XIZ\Q[IV�XZM[QLMV\QIT�^W\QVO�XZMNMZMVKM[� \PQ[�ZQKP\QUM�[MZQM[�KIV�JM�][ML�I[�IV�IXXZW`QUI\QWV�\W�\PM�XIZ\Q[IV[PWKS[� \PI\�UIa� QVÆ]MVKM�^W\QVO�XI\\MZV[� ,WQVO�[W� TMI^M[\PM� UWLMT� ZM[XWV[QJTM� NWZ� M[\QUI\QVO� WVTa� \PM� IOM�[XMKQÅK_MQOP\[�� ITTW_QVO�U]KP�UWZM�XZMKQ[M�M[\QUI\M[� \PIV� QN �_M_MZM�\W�Å\�\PM�IOM�_MQOP\[�IVL�\PM�XIZ\Q[IV�[PWKS[�I\�\PM�[IUM\QUM�

1VKQLMV\ITTa� Q\�[PW]TL�JM�VW\ML�\PI\�\PM�\WXQK�WN �OMVMZI\QWV[QV�XZM[QLMV\QIT�^W\QVO�PI[�ZMKMV\Ta�OIZVMZML�[WUM�I\\MV\QWV�QV\PM�XWX]TIZ� XZM[[� ) ZMXWZ\� ZMTMI[ML�Ja� \PM�8M_�:M[MIZKP+MV\MZ�QV�IL^IVKM�WN �\PM������MTMK\QWV�NW]VL�ZMTI\Q^MTa�KWV�

�;MM�NWW\VW\M���� �*IZ\MT[�IVL�2IKSUIV������" XO�����)TWVO�_Q\P�I�ZMTI\Q^MTa�[UITT�V]UJMZ�WN �ILLQ\QWVIT�XIZIUM\MZ[� I[�M`XTIQVMLTI\MZ�

Page 4: QVO - Columbia Universitygelman/research/unpublished/...Jun 05, 2014  · i kw]xtm wn lmkilm[ wz tm[[ .wz m`iuxtm wvm wn \pm nmi\]zm[ wn \pm mizta li\i kqzki \pm ! [ ! [ _i[ \pm wj[mz^i\qwv

[Q[\MV\�XZM[QLMV\QIT�^W\QVO�XI\\MZV[�NWZ�OMVMZI\QWV[�WN �^W\MZ[�_Q\P� \PW[M�OMVMZI\QWV[�LMÅVML�Ja�_PW�_I[�XZM[QLMV\�_PMV\PMa�\]ZVML�� ��3WP]\�M\ IT�������" XO� ����

7V� \WX�WN � [_Q\KPQVO� \PM� NWK][� \W�XZM[QLMV\QIT�^W\QVO� _MOMVMZITQbM�\PM�XZM^QW][Ta�LQ[K][[ML�UWLMT[�Ja�ITTW_QVO�\PM�IOM_MQOP\[�\W�^IZa� QV�I�TQUQ\ML�_Ia� Ja�ZIKM�IVL�ZMOQWV� /Q^MV\PM�[]J[\IV\QIT�LQNNMZMVKM[�JM\_MMV�UQVWZQ\QM[�IVL�_PQ\M�XMW�XTM� IVL� JM\_MMV� ;W]\PMZV� IVL� VWV�;W]\PMZV�_PQ\M[� Q\� Q[NI]T\a� \W� I[[]UM� \PI\� \PM� [IUM�UWLMT� WN � XWTQ\QKIT� TMIZVQVO[PW]TL�JM�IXXTQML�\W�ITT�\PZMM� *IZ\MT[�IVL�2IKSUIV� NWZ�M`IU�XTM� ZMKWOVQbM�\PQ[�IVL�ZMUW^M�_PQ\M�;W]\PMZVMZ[�IVL�)NZQKIV)UMZQKIV[�MV\QZMTa�NZWU�\PMQZ�IVITa[Q[� 1V[\MIL� _M�QVKWZXW�ZI\M�\PMU�QV\W�\PM�IVITa[Q[�IVL�M[\QUI\M�PW_�_MTT�\PM�OMVMZ�I\QWVIT�UWLMT�Å\[�\PMQZ�WJ[MZ^ML�XWTQ\QKIT�LM^MTWXUMV\�

<PZW]OP� \PQ[� IVITa[Q[� _M� ÅVL� [\ZWVO� IVL� QV\]Q\Q^M� IOM_MQOP\[� IUWVO� _PQ\M� ^W\MZ[� XIZ\QK]TIZTa� VWV�;W]\PMZV_PQ\M[� <PM�NWZUI\QWV�WN �XIZ\Q[IV�XZM[QLMV\QIT�^W\QVO�\ZMVL[XMIS[�IZW]VL�\PM�IOM[�WN ������� _Q\P�I� []J[\IV\QIT�J]QTL]XIVL�LZI_LW_V�QV�\PW[M�_MQOP\[�]V\QT�ZW]OPTa�\PM�IOM�WN ����<PM�QUXIK\�WN �\PW[M�IOM�_MQOP\[� KWUJQVML�_Q\P�LQNNMZMV\�TM^�MT[�WN �XZM[QLMV\QIT�IXXZW^IT� NWZ�LQNNMZMV\�JQZ\P�KWPWZ\[� TMILVI\]ZITTa�\W�[]J[\IV\QIT�OMVMZI\QWVIT�\ZMVL[¸\W�\ISM�I�XZWUQ�VMV\�M`IUXTM� _PQ\M�^W\MZ[�JWZV�QV��!��� _PW�_MZM�UIQVTa[WKQITQbML�L]ZQVO�\PM�3MVVMLa�IVL�2WPV[WV�ILUQVQ[\ZI\QWV[�IZM� KWV[Q[\MV\Ta� ����� XMZKMV\IOM� XWQV\[�UWZM� TQSMTa� \W� []X�XWZ\�,MUWKZI\QK�XZM[QLMV\QIT�KIVLQLI\M[�\PIV�\PW[M�JWZV�QV�!� � _PW�_MZM�QVÆ]MVKML�UWZM�[\ZWVOTa�Ja�\PM�XZM[QLMVKQM[WN �+IZ\MZ� :MIOIV� IVL�*][P�1��<PM�IOM�_MQOP\[�NWZ�UQVWZQ�\QM[� QV�KWV\ZI[\� IZM�U]KP�TM[[�XW_MZN]T� []OOM[\QVO�\PI\�\PMQZXWTQ\QKIT�[WKQITQbI\QWV�XZWKM[[�Q[�[WUMPW_�LQNNMZMV\�\PIV�\PI\WN �_PQ\M�^W\MZ[� 4I[\Ta� \PM�LI\I�QVLQKI\M�\PI\�JZWIL�MTMK\QWV�Ja�MTMK\QWV�KPIVOM[¸VWZUITTa�\MZUML XMZQWL�MNNMK\[ QV�\PM�TQ\�MZI\]ZM� IVL� Y]Q\M� QUXWZ\IV\� _PMV� M[\QUI\QVO� XZM[QLMV\QIT^W\M�KPWQKM�I[�WXXW[ML�\W�XIZ\a�QLMV\QÅKI\QWV¸IZM�[WUM_PI\TIZOMZ�NWZ�aW]VO�^W\MZ[�QV�\PM�QUXZM[[QWVIJTM�IOM�ZIVOM�\PIVNWZ�WTLMZ�^W\MZ[� ) UWLMT�QVKWZXWZI\QVO�ITT�WN �\PM[M�NIK\WZ[�M`�XTIQV[�[]J[\IV\QITTa�UWZM�UIKZW�TM^MT�^IZQI\QWV�\PIV�I�[QUXTMUWLMT�IKKW]V\QVO�NWZ�XMZQWL�IVL�ZIKM�ZMOQWV�MNNMK\[�ITWVM�

<PM�XIXMZ�_QTT�XZWKMML�Ja�LM[KZQJQVO�\PM�LI\I�IVL�[\I\Q[�\QKIT�UWLMT� ?M�\PMV�[PW_�\PM�UWLMT�ZM[]T\[�IVL�PW_�\PW[MZM[]T\[�KIV�JM�QV\MZXZM\ML�\W�LM[KZQJM�\PM�XWTQ\QKIT�[WKQITQbI�\QWV�XZWKM[[� NWZ�XIZ\Q[IV�XZM[QLMV\QIT� ^W\M� KPWQKM� 4I[\� _MXZW^QLM�I�PQ[\WZQKIT�VIZZI\Q^M�WN �XZM[QLMV\QIT�IXXZW^IT�W^MZ�\PM

XI[\�PITN �KMV\]Za� MUXPI[QbQVO�PW_�XIZ\QK]TIZ�XZM[QLMV\[�IVLM^MV\[�PIL�I�LQNNMZMV\QIT�QUXIK\�WV�^IZQW][�OMVMZI\QWV[�WN �\PM)UMZQKIV�^W\QVO�X]JTQK� ?M�KTW[M�_Q\P�LQ[K][[QWV�

,I\I�IVL�8ZMTQUQVIZa�-^QLMVKM

*MNWZM�LM[KZQJQVO� \PM� [\I\Q[\QKIT�UWLMT� QV� N]TT� Q\� Q[�][MN]T� \WLM[KZQJM�\PM�LI\I�[W]ZKM[�IVL�LQ[XTIa�[WUM�XZMTQUQVIZa�M^Q�LMVKM� 4IZOM�[IUXTM�[QbM�Q[�I�VMKM[[IZa�XZMZMY]Q[Q\M�NWZ�\PMIVITa[Q[� JMKI][M�_M�_IV\�\PM�ÆM`QJQTQ\a�\W�LMÅVM�\PM�OMVMZ�I\QWVIT�KWPWZ\[�][QVO�QVLQ^QL]IT�JQZ\P�aMIZ[� )UMZQKIV�XZM[Q�LMV\QIT�MTMK\QWV[�JMVMÅ\�NZWU�I�[]J[\IV\QIT�IUW]V\�WN �XWTTQVO�ITTW_QVO�][�\W�TM^MZIOM�U]T\QXTM�PQOP�Y]ITQ\a�[]Z^Ma[�W^MZ�\PMKW]Z[M�WN �LMKILM[�

?M�KWUJQVM�NW]Z�UIRWZ�[W]ZKM[�WN �XWTTQVO" ����\PM�INWZM�UMV\QWVML�)6-; K]U]TI\Q^M�LI\I[M\�KW^MZQVO�\PM��!������ \QUM[XIV# ���� QVLQ^QL]ITTa�KWLML�/ITT]X�XZM[QLMV\QIT�XWTTQVOLI\I� I^IQTIJTM�NZWU�\PM�:WXMZ�+MV\MZ¼[�Q8WTT�LI\IJI[M�OWQVOJIKS�\W��!��# ����\PM������ ����� IVL���� �)VVMVJMZO�6I�\QWVIT�-TMK\QWV�;\]LQM[� TIZOM�[IUXTM�[]Z^Ma[�OQ^QVO�I�XIZ\QK�]TIZTa�LM\IQTML�^QM_�WN �\PW[M�\PZMM�MTMK\QWV[# IVL�����I�[MZQM[WN �QV\MZVIT�KIUXIQOV�XWTT[�KWVL]K\ML�Ja�/ZMMVJMZO�9]QVTIV:W[VMZ�:M[MIZKP�W^MZ�\PM�KW]Z[M�WN �\PM������MTMK\QWV�KaKTM�\W�XZW^QLM�KW^MZIOM�NWZ�\PQ[�UW[\�ZMKMV\�MTMK\QWV� <PQ[�LI\I_I[�XZW^QLML� NWZ� \PQ[� ZM[MIZKP�Ja�+I\ITQ[\� 44+��I�XWTQ\QKITLI\I�^MVLWZ�� .WZ�\PM�)6-; IVL�/ITT]X�LI\I[M\[� _M�WVTa�][MLI\I�NZWU�XZM[QLMV\QIT�MTMK\QWV�aMIZ[� )N\MZ�ZMUW^QVO�UQ[[QVOLI\I � _M�PI^M���������WJ[MZ^I\QWV[�QV�\W\IT�

)[�I�ÅZ[\�[\MX� Q\�Q[�PMTXN]T�\W�M`IUQVM�\PM�ZI_�LI\I�NWZ�\PMNW]Z�UW[\�ZMKMV\�MTMK\QWV[� <PM�ZMTI\QWV[PQX�JM\_MMV�IOM�IVLXZM[QLMV\QIT�^W\M�KPWQKM�Q[�LQ[XTIaML�QV�\PM�\PZMM�XIVMT[�WN �.QO�]ZM �� 0MZM�_M�¹KWV\ZWTº�NWZ�ZIKM�Ja�WVTa�LQ[XTIaQVO�LI\I�NWZ_PQ\M�^W\MZ[� ?M�LM[KZQJM� \PM[M�OZIXP[� QV�LM\IQT� \W� QVNWZUQV\]Q\QWV[�IVL�UW\Q^I\M�\PM�KWV[\Z]K\QWV�WN �\PM�UWLMT!�

<PM�TMN\�XIVMT�[PW_[�\PM�ZMTI\QWV[PQX�JM\_MMV�IOM�IVL�^W\�QVO�NWZ�\PM���� �MTMK\QWV� *MKI][M�_M�PI^M�W^MZ��������ZM�

�<PM������XWTT[�IZM�VW\�X]JTQKTa�I^IQTIJTM� J]\�\PM�ZMTM^IV\�LI\I�Q[�I^IQTIJTMNWZ�ZMXTQKI\QWV�X]ZXW[M[�WV�ZMY]M[\�

>IZQIJTM[�WN �QV\MZM[\�IZM�XZM[QLMV\QIT�^W\M�KPWQKM� M\PVQKQ\a� [\I\M�WN �ZM[QLMVKM\W�LM\MZUQVM�_PM\PMZ�_PQ\M�^W\MZ[� TQ^M� QV� \PM�;W]\P� IVL�IOM� �WZ� MY]Q^�ITMV\Ta� JQZ\P�aMIZ� LMÅVML�PMZM�I[�\PM�aMIZ�WN �\PM�[]Z^Ma�ZM[XWV[M�UQV][IOM��

!.WZ� \PQ[�XZMTQUQVIZa�IVITa[Q[� _M�KWUJQVM�ITT�WN � \PM�LI\I�[W]ZKM[�IVL�LWVW\�KWV[QLMZ�PW][M�MNNMK\[�WZ�W\PMZ�WUQ\\ML�^IZQIJTM[� <PM�N]TT�UWLMT�_QTTUWZM�NWZUITTa�M[\QUI\M�\PM�ZMTI\QWV[PQX[�[PW_V�PMZM� IVL�_M�_QTT�LM[KZQJMZWJ][\VM[[�KPMKS[�\PI\�\ISM�WUQ\\ML�^IZQIJTM[�QV\W�IKKW]V\�

Page 5: QVO - Columbia Universitygelman/research/unpublished/...Jun 05, 2014  · i kw]xtm wn lmkilm[ wz tm[[ .wz m`iuxtm wvm wn \pm nmi\]zm[ wn \pm mizta li\i kqzki \pm ! [ ! [ _i[ \pm wj[mz^i\qwv

Rep

ub

lican V

ote

Age

2008

McC

ain

Vo

te

20 40 60 80

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

Non−Monotonic Age Curve in 2008

Age

Rep

ub

lican V

ote

2000200420082012

20 40 60 800.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

Non−Monotonicity in Other Elections

Birth Year

Rep

ub

lican V

ote

2000200420082012

1990 1970 1950 1930

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

Lining up by Birth Year

.QO]ZM �" :I_�LI\I�IVL�47-;; K]Z^M[� QVLQKI\QVO�\PM�ZMTI\QWV[PQX�JM\_MMV�IOM�IVL�XZM[QLMV\QIT�^W\QVO�XZMN�MZMVKM[�IUWVO�VWV�0Q[XIVQK�_PQ\M�^W\MZ[�NWZ� \PM�����������MTMK\QWV[� �4� <PM�ZMTI\QWV[PQX�Q[�KTMIZTa�VWV�UWVW\WVQK� IVL�Y]Q\M� XMK]TQIZ� QV���� # QV[\MIL�WN �I� TQVMIZ�WZ�M^MV�Y]ILZI\QK�ZMTI\QWV[PQX� \PM� K]Z^M� KPIVOM[LQZMK\QWV[�U]T\QXTM�\QUM[� �+� 6WV�UWVW\WVQKQ\a�Q[�I�NMI\]ZM�WN �\PM�W\PMZ�MTMK\QWV[�I[�_MTT� \PW]OP�VW�KTMIZ�XI\\MZVQ[�IXXIZMV\�NZWU�\PQ[�OZIXP�ITWVM� �:� <PM�\Z]M�ZMTI\QWV[PQX�MUMZOM[�_PMV�\PM�K]Z^M[�IZM�TQVML�]X�Ja�JQZ\P�aMIZQV[\MIL�WN �IOM� <PM�XMIS[�IVL�^ITTMa[�WKK]Z�QV�ITUW[\�QLMV\QKIT�TWKI\QWV[� [\ZWVOTa�[]OOM[\QVO�I�OMVMZI\QWVIT�\ZMVL�

[XWV[M[�NWZ�_PQ\M�^W\MZ[�QV���� � _M�PI^M�\PM�[\I\Q[\QKIT�XW_MZ\W�[MXIZI\M�\PM�LI\I�QV\W�QVLQ^QL]IT�IOM�J]KSM\[¸MIKP�J]J�JTM�Q[�I�[QVOTM�aMIZ�WN �IOM� _Q\P�\PM y�I`Q[�QVLQKI\QVO�TM^MT�WN:MX]JTQKIV�[]XXWZ\� QV�\PQ[�KI[M� NWZ�;MVI\WZ�2WPV�5K+IQV�IVL�\PM�[QbM�WN �MIKP�J]JJTM�QVLQKI\QVO�[IUXTM�[QbM� <PM�Å\\MLK]Z^M�Q[�I�[QUXTM�TWKITTa�_MQOP\ML�ZMOZM[[QWV��47-;;� K]Z^M�

?M�QUUMLQI\MTa�VW\QKM�I�[\ZQSQVO�ZMTI\QWV[PQX� :MX]JTQKIV^W\M�[PIZM�Q[�VMQ\PMZ�TQVMIZTa�ZMTI\ML�\W�IOM��I[�_I[�\PM�KI[MQV�\PM�LI\I�NZWU�\PM��!��[�� VWZ�Q[�\PMZM�I�[QUXTM�Y]ILZI\QKZMTI\QWV[PQX� QV�_PQKP�UQLLTM�IOML�^W\MZ[�IZM�UWZM�TQSMTa�\W^W\M�NWZ�\PM�:MX]JTQKIV�_PQTM�JW\P�aW]VO�IVL�WTL�^W\MZ[�IZMUWZM�,MUWKZI\QK� 1V[\MIL� _M�[MM�I�KTMIZ�VWV�UWVW\WVQK�ZM�TI\QWV[PQX� QV�_PQKP�����aW]VO�_PQ\M�^W\MZ[�[\ZWVOTa�[]XXWZ\ML\PMV�KIVLQLI\M�7JIUI� _Q\P�� �aMIZ�WTL[�I\�IJW]\��� �NWZ5K+IQV# ����5K+IQV¼[�^W\M�OZW_[�_Q\P�IOM� ]X�\W��� �I\�IOM��# ����\PM�K]Z^M�ZM^MZ[M[�LQZMK\QWV� LMKZMI[QVO�\W�� �NWZ����aMIZ�WTL[# ����5K+IQV¼[�^W\M�KTQUJ[�IOIQV� \W�Q\¼[�XMIS�WN ��� I\�IOM���# ����\PM�K]Z^M�\ISM[�I�ÅVIT�\]ZV� LMKZMI[QVO�NWZ�\PM�ZM�UIQVLMZ�WN �\PM�OZIXP�IVL�[\WXXQVO�IZW]VL��� �NWZ�\PM�WTLM[\ZM[XWVLMV\[�

5W^QVO�\W�\PM�KMV\MZ�XIVMT� _M�W^MZTIa�I�[QUQTIZ�K]Z^M�NWZ\PM������ ����� IVL������MTMK\QWV[� ZMUW^QVO�\PM�J]JJTM[�\WMI[M�QV\MZXZM\IJQTQ\a� ?M�VW\QKM�VWV�UWVW\WVQK�ZMTI\QWV[PQX[

NWZ�ITT�NW]Z�WN �\PM[M�MTMK\QWV[� J]\�\PM�K]Z^M[�IZM�UM[[a�IVL�LWVW\�ZM^MIT�I�KTMIZ�XI\\MZV�

.QVITTa� QV�\PM�ZQOP\�PIVL�XIVMT� \PM�\Z]M�QV[QOP\�Q[�ZM^MITML�0MZM� _M�TQVM�\PM�K]Z^M[�]X�Ja�JQZ\P�aMIZ�QV[\MIL�WN �Ja�IOM� IVL\PM�KWV[Q[\MV\�XI\\MZV�MUMZOM[�KTMIZTa� )TT�NW]Z�K]Z^M[�ITUW[\XMZNMK\Ta�QV�TQVM" \PM�XMIS[�IVL�^ITTMa[�IZM�VMIZTa�QLMV\QKIT�QVM^MZa�K]Z^M� IVL� _Q\P�\PM�M`KMX\QWV�WN �\PM���� �MTMK\QWV� ITTK]Z^M[�IZM�M[[MV\QITTa�ZQOP\�WV�\WX�WN �MIKP�W\PMZ� M[XMKQITTa�NWZ^W\MZ[�JWZV�JM\_MMV��!���IVL��!��� _PMZM�\PM�J]TS�WN �\PMLI\I�TQM� <PM�\_W�XMIS[�QV�\PM�LI\I�WKK]Z�ZW]OPTa�IZW]VL�\PMJQZ\P�aMIZ[�WN ��!���IVL��!� � _Q\P�\PM�XZW�,MUWKZI\QK�^ITTMaIZW]VL��!��� 0MZM� _M�MUXPI[QbM�\PI\�\PQ[�ZMTI\QWV[PQX�ZM�UIQV[�KTMIZ�IVL�[\ZWVO�W^MZ�\PM�KW]Z[M�WN ����aMIZ[� UMI[]ZMLIKZW[[�U]T\QXTM�[]Z^Ma[�KWVL]K\ML�Ja�LQNNMZMV\�WZOIVQbI\QWV[�IVL�]VIT\MZML�Ja�IVa�KWUXTQKI\ML�[\I\Q[\QKIT�UWLMT� <PQ[�IX�XMIZ[�\W�JM�VW�[\I\Q[\QKIT�IZ\QNIK\�

?Q\PW]\� \ZMILQVO� \WW� NIZ� QV\W� \PM� LZMILML� IOM�XMZQWL�KWPWZ\�NZIUM_WZS� Q\� Q[�IT[W�QUXWZ\IV\�\W�XWQV\�W]\�\PI\�\PM��� �K]Z^M�Q[�TW_MZ�\PIV�\PM�ZMUIQVQVO�K]Z^M[�NWZ�ITUW[\�ITTJQZ\P�KWPWZ\[� :MKITT�\PM�W^MZITT�^W\M�\W\IT[�NWZ�MIKP�WN �\PM[MMTMK\QWV[��� ?PQTM������ ����� IVL������_MZM�ITT�LMKQLML�Ja

��<PM�,MUWKZI\QK�\_W�XIZ\a�^W\M�[PIZM�NWZ�\PM�����������MTMK\QWV[�_MZM� QVWZLMZ� �� � �! � �� �IVL��� # Q\�[PW]TL�JM�VW\ML�\PI\�\PM[M�ZMÆMK\�\PM^W\M�\W\IT[�NWZ�\PM�N]TT�MTMK\WZI\M� VW\�NWZ�_PQ\M�^W\MZ[�WVTa� I[�Q[�[PW_V�QV

Page 6: QVO - Columbia Universitygelman/research/unpublished/...Jun 05, 2014  · i kw]xtm wn lmkilm[ wz tm[[ .wz m`iuxtm wvm wn \pm nmi\]zm[ wn \pm mizta li\i kqzki \pm ! [ ! [ _i[ \pm wj[mz^i\qwv

Gal

lup

Pre

side

ntia

l App

rova

lA

ppro

ve /

(App

rove

+ D

isap

prov

e)

Roo

seve

lt

Trum

an

Eise

nhow

er

Ken

nedy

John

son

Nix

on

Ford

Car

ter

Rea

gan

Bus

h I

Clin

ton

Bus

h II

Oba

ma

1940 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010

025

5075

100

.QO]ZM �" <PM�/ITT]X�7ZOIVQbI\QWV¼[�8ZM[QLMV\QIT�)XXZW^IT�:I\QVO�\QUM�[MZQM[� UMI[]ZML�NZWU��!��������?M�][M�\PQ[�LI\I�\W�IXXZW`QUI\M�XIZ\Q[IV�[PWKS[�QVPMZMV\�QV�XWTQ\QKIT�M^MV\[�I\�\PM�XZM[QLMV\QIT�TM^MT�

[UITT�UIZOQV[� ��� �_I[�I�ZMTI\Q^MTa�ZWJ][\�^QK\WZa�NWZ�,MUW�KZI\QK� KIVLQLI\M�8ZM[� 7JIUI� ?M�IVL�W\PMZ[�PI^M� KWU�UMV\ML�WV�\PM�VI\]ZM�WN �¹]VQNWZU�[_QVO[º�QV�8ZM[QLMV\QIT�^W\�QVO��/PQ\bI�IVL�/MTUIV�������� IVL�Q\�KMZ\IQVTa�[MMU[�NZWU\PQ[�LI\I�\PI\�\PMZM�_I[�I�_QLM[XZMIL� QN �VW\�]VQNWZU� [_QVO\W_IZL[�7JIUI�QV���� �

1V�[]U� \PM�LI\I�Q[�[\ZWVOTa�[]OOM[\Q^M�WN �I�UWLMT�QV�_PQKP^W\M�KPWQKM�Q[�OMVMZI\QWVIT� I\�TMI[\�IUWVO�_PQ\M�^W\MZ[� 1V�[\MIL�WN �I�X]ZMTa�OMVMZI\QWVIT�M`XTIVI\QWV� PW_M^MZ� Q\� IX�XMIZ[�VMKM[[IZa�\W�QVKT]LM�XMZQWL�MNNMK\[�\W�ZMÆMK\�KPIVOQVOMKWVWUQK� KQZK]U[\IVKM[� KaKTQKIT� ^W\QVO� PIJQ\[� KIVLQLI\M�KMV\ZQK�Y]ITQ\QM[� IVL�W\PMZ�JZWIL�LQNNMZMVKM[�JM\_MMV�MTMK�\QWV[� 1\�[PW]TL�JM�VW\ML� PW_M^MZ� \PI\�\PM[M�XMZQWL�MNNMK\[VMML�VW\�JM�MV\QZMTa�]VQNWZU� I�NMI\]ZM�_M�_QTT�M`XTWZM�QV�\PMUWLMT�

*M[QLM[� QVLQ^QL]IT� []Z^Ma�ZM[XWV[M[� \PM�W\PMZ�UIQV�LI\I_M�][M�Q[�\PM�/ITT]X�7ZOIVQbI\QWV¼[� TWVO�Z]VVQVO�8ZM[QLMV�\QIT�)XXZW^IT�:I\QVO�\QUM�[MZQM[� LQ[XTIaML�QV�.QO]ZM �� ?M][M�\PQ[�[MZQM[�I[�IV�IXXZW`QUI\QWV�\W�\PM�XIZ\Q[IV�[PWKS[�\PI\\PM� X]JTQK� M`XMZQMVKM[� L]M� \W� XWTQ\QKIT� M^MV\[� I\� \PM� XZM[Q�LMV\QIT�TM^MT� :MKITT�\PI\�QV�\PM��I[�aM\�QVNWZUITTa�LM[KZQJML�

.QO]ZM ��

UWLMT� XZM[QLMV\QIT�^W\QVO�KPWQKM[�IZM�QVNWZUML�Ja�I�_MQOP\ML¹Z]VVQVO�\ITTaº�WN �ZM\ZW[XMK\Q^M�M^IT]I\QWV[�WN �XI[\�XZM[QLMV�\QIT�XMZNWZUIVKM� _Q\P�LQNNMZMV\QIT�_MQOP\[�OQ^MV�\W�XWTQ\QKITM^MV\[�JI[ML�WV�_PMV�\PMa�WKK]ZZML� QV�IV� QVLQ^QL]IT¼[� TQNM�\QUM� 1N �\PQ[�Q[�QVLMML�\PM�KI[M� \PMV�\PM�/ITT]X�\QUM�[MZQM[�Q[IV�QLMIT�UMI[]ZMUMV\�WN �\PW[M�M^IT]I\QWV[� M^MV�QN �Q\�WVTa�IX�XZW`QUI\M[�\PM�[PWKS[�M`XMZQMVKML�Ja�\PM�X]JTQK�L]M�\W�MIKPXWTQ\QKIT�M^MV\�

7VM�]VNWZ\]VI\M�TQUQ\I\QWV�WN �][QVO�\PQ[�\QUM�[MZQM[� PW_�M^MZ� Q[�\PI\�LM[XQ\M�JMQVO�WVM�WN �\PM�TWVOM[\�Z]VVQVO�\QUM�[M�ZQM[�I^IQTIJTM�QV�\PM�[\]La�WN �)UMZQKIV�XWTQ\QKIT�JMPI^QWZ� Q\Q[�¹WVTaº�I^IQTIJTM�NZWU��!���WV_IZL� *MKI][M�\PM�IVITa[Q[NWK][M[�WV�LQNNMZMV\QIT�IOM�_MQOP\[�\PZW]OP�\PM MV\QZM TQNM�Ka�KTM� IVL�L]M�\W�\PM�QUXWZ\IVKM�WN �MIZTa�TQNM�XWTQ\QKIT�[WKQITQbI�\QWV�[]OOM[\ML�QV�\PM�TQ\MZI\]ZM� _M�IZM�NWZKML�\W�LQ[KIZL�IVaWJ[MZ^I\QWV[�QV�_PQKP�_M�LW�VW\�PI^M�XZM[QLMV\QIT�IXXZW^ITLI\I�NWZ�\PM�ZM[XWVLMV\[¼�MV\QZM�TQNM�[XIV� 1V�W\PMZ�_WZL[� _MLZWX�ZM[XWVLMV\[�JWZV�JMNWZM��!���NZWU�\PM�IVITa[Q[� <PMZM[]T\QVO�LQ[\ZQJ]\QWV�WN �\PM�LI\I� \W\ITQVO�����!���ZM[XWV[M[�Q[�[MXIZI\ML�Ja�MTMK\QWV�aMIZ�IVL�\PMV�Ja�aMIZ�WN �JQZ\P�QV�.QO�]ZM �� <PM�LI\I�KW^MZ�\PM��!��������MTMK\QWV[� _Q\P�I�[\ZWVOMUXPI[Q[�WV� \PM�UW[\� ZMKMV\� NW]Z�MTMK\QWV[� MIKP�PI^QVO�I\

Page 7: QVO - Columbia Universitygelman/research/unpublished/...Jun 05, 2014  · i kw]xtm wn lmkilm[ wz tm[[ .wz m`iuxtm wvm wn \pm nmi\]zm[ wn \pm mizta li\i kqzki \pm ! [ ! [ _i[ \pm wj[mz^i\qwv

Num

ber

of S

urv

ey

Resp

onse

s In

clu

ded

in A

naly

sis

Sample Size by Election Year

1960

1964

1968

1972

1976

1980

1984

1988

1992

1996

2000

2004

2008

2012

010,0

00

20,0

00

30,0

00

40,0

00

50,0

00

Sample Size by Birth Year

1940

1945

1950

1955

1960

1965

1970

1975

1980

1985

1990

02,0

00

4,0

00

6,0

00

.QO]ZM �" )N\MZ�ZMUW^QVO�[]Z^Ma�ZM[XWVLMV\[�JWZV�JMNWZM��!��� \PM�IVITa[Q[�QVKT]LM[�����!���[]Z^Ma�ZM[XWV�LMV\[�QV�\W\IT� PMZM�LQ[XTIaML�Ja�MTMK\QWV�aMIZ�IVL�aMIZ�WN �JQZ\P� <PM�LI\I� IVL�\P][�\PM�IVITa[Q[� PI[�I�[\ZWVOMUXPI[Q[�\W_IZL[�\PM�UW[\�ZMKMV\�NW]Z�MTMK\QWV[� IVL�[W�Q\�KIV�JM�QV\MZXZM\ML�I[�JMQVO�_MQOP\ML�\W_IZL[�\PM�KWV�\MUXWZIZa�XWTQ\QKIT�KTQUI\M� <PM�LI\I�MVKWUXI[[�OMVMZI\QWVIT�KWPWZ\[�LMÅVML�Ja�\PMQZ�QVLQ^QL]IT�JQZ\P�aMIZ�NZWU�!����!!�� _Q\P�I\�TMI[\�������ZM[XWV[M[�NWZ�MIKP�JQZ\P�aMIZ�]V\QT��! ��

TMI[\��������ZM[XWV[M[� )[�NWZ�OMVMZI\QWVIT�KWPWZ\[�LMÅVML�JaJQZ\P�aMIZ� \PM�LI\I�MVKWUXI[[�\PM��!����!!��KWPWZ\[� _Q\PI\� TMI[\�������ZM[XWV[M[� NWZ�MIKP� QVLQ^QL]IT�aMIZ�]V\QT��! ��\PM�TI[\�JQZ\P�aMIZ�MTQOQJTM�NWZ�\PM������MTMK\QWV��

;\I\Q[\QKIT�5WLMT

?M� IZM� QV\MZM[\ML� QV� UWLMTQVO� XZM[QLMV\QIT� ^W\M� KPWQKM� JaJQZ\P�aMIZ�KWPWZ\�W^MZ�\PM��!��������MTMK\QWV[� LQ[\QVO]Q[P�QVO� \PM� XWTQ\QKIT� [WKQITQbI\QWV� UMKPIVQ[U� Ja� ZIKM� IVL� ZM�OQWV� )[� []KP� MIKP� []Z^Ma� ZM[XWVLMV\� Q[� QVLM`ML�Ja� \PZMMI\\ZQJ]\M[" ���� PQ[�PMZ� JQZ\P� aMIZ� KWPWZ\ c ! C =

{1937, 1938, . . . , 1994}� ���� \PM� aMIZ� WN � \PM� MTMK\QWV t !T = {1960, 1961, . . . , 2012}� IVL� ���� \PM� ZIKM�ZMOQWVOZW]X g ! G = {VWV�;W]\PMZV�_PQ\M� ;W]\PMZV�_PQ\M� IVLUQVWZQ\a}� 6W\QKM�\PI\ T QVKT]LM[�VWV�MTMK\QWV�aMIZ[¸]VLMZ\PQ[�NWZU]TI\QWV� QVLQ^QL]IT[�PWTL�XIZ\Q[IV�XZM[QLMV\QIT�^W\QVO\MVLMVKQM[�M^MV�QV�VWV�XZM[QLMV\QIT�aMIZ[� M^MV�\PW]OP�\PMaUIQVTa�M`XZM[[�\PMQZ�XZMNMZMVKM[�\PZW]OP�^W\QVO�QV�IV�MTMK\QWVM^MZa�NW]Z�aMIZ[��� )T[W�VW\QKM�\PI\�UQVWZQ\QM[�IZM�OZW]XML�\W�

��<PM�UWLMT�Q[� QV�NIK\� Å\�][QVO�LI\I�WJ[MZ^ML�L]ZQVO�XZM[QLMV\QIT�MTMK\QWVaMIZ[�ITWVM� )[�[]KP� \PQ[�LQ[\QVK\QWV�Q[�I�\PMWZM\QKIT�WVM�NIKQTQ\I\QVO�\PM�QLMIWN �TI\MV\�XZM[QLMV\QIT�^W\QVO�XZMNMZMVKM[�\PI\�XMZ[Q[\�M^MV�QV�VWV�MTMK\QWV

OM\PMZ�QV\W�I�[QVOTM�OZW]X� 1\�_W]TL�JM�XZMNMZIJTM�\W�[MXIZI\M)NZQKIV�)UMZQKIV[� 0Q[XIVQK[� IVL�W\PMZ�OZW]X[� J]\�\PM�LI\INZWU�MIZTQMZ�aMIZ[�LWM[�VW\�IT_Ia[�WZ�KWV[Q[\MV\Ta�LQ[\QVO]Q[PJM\_MMV�UQVWZQ\a�OZW]X[� NWZKQVO�][�\W�OZW]X�UQVWZQ\QM[�\W�OM\PMZ�NWZ�\PM�XZM[MV\�IVITa[Q[�

?Q\P�MIKP�ZM[XWVLMV\�QVLM`ML�IKKWZLQVO�\W�\PM[M�KPIZIK�\MZQ[\QK[� _M�KIV�ZMXZM[MV\� \PM�LI\I�I[ J U]\]ITTa�M`KT][Q^MKMTT[� _Q\P� MIKP� KMTT� ZMXZM[MV\QVO� I� ]VQY]M� KWUJQVI\QWV� WN\PM�\PZMM�QVLQKM[� <PQ[�_QTT�PMTX�][�SMMX�I�KTMIVMZ�VW\I\QWV\PZW]OP�\PM�ZMUIQVLMZ�WN �\PQ[�[MK\QWV� ?M�TIJMT�\PM�W]\KWUM^IZQIJTM� XZM[QLMV\QIT�^W\M�KPWQKM�QV�\PM�WJ[MZ^ML�MTMK\QWV� I[y IVL� _Q\PQV�IVa�KMTT j� _M� TIJMT yj I[�\PM�V]UJMZ�WN �ZM�[XWVLMV\[� XZMNMZZQVO� \PM�:MX]JTQKIV� KIVLQLI\M� IVL nj I[\PM�V]UJMZ�WN �ZM[XWVLMV\[�QVLQKI\QVO�I�:MX]JTQKIV�WZ�,MUW�KZI\QK�XZMNMZMVKM��]VLMKQLML�^W\MZ[�IZM�LQ[KIZLML�� <PM�LI\IUWLMT� \PMV� Q["

yj " *QVWUQIT (nj , !j) , ���

_PMZM !j Q[�_PI\�_M�_IV\�\W�M[\QUI\M" \PM�XZWXWZ\QWV�WN �:M�X]JTQKIV�XZM[QLMV\QIT�[]XXWZ\�_Q\PQV�KMTT j� *MNWZM�N]TTa�LMÅV�QVO !j � Q\�Q[�][MN]T�\W�QV\ZWL]KM�I�JQ\�WN �ILLQ\QWVIT�VW\I\QWV�

aMIZ[�

Page 8: QVO - Columbia Universitygelman/research/unpublished/...Jun 05, 2014  · i kw]xtm wn lmkilm[ wz tm[[ .wz m`iuxtm wvm wn \pm nmi\]zm[ wn \pm mizta li\i kqzki \pm ! [ ! [ _i[ \pm wj[mz^i\qwv

.WZ�MIKP�KMTT j� xj,i QVLQKI\M[ :MX]JTQKIV�LQZMK\QWVIT XZM[QLMV�\QIT�IXXZW^IT�NWZ�IOM i ! I = {1, 2, . . . , 70} NWZ�\PM�JQZ\P�aMIZKWPWZ\�ZMXZM[MV\ML�QV�\PI\�KMTT� <W�KWV[\Z]K\�\PQ[� _M�����[]J�\ZIK\��� �NZWU�\PM�/ITT]X�)XXZW^IT�\QUM�[MZQM[� IVL�����U]T�\QXTa�\PM�ZM[]T\QVO�V]UJMZ�Ja #1 _PMV�\PM�[Q\\QVO�XZM[QLMV\_I[�I�,MUWKZI\� <PM�ZM[]T\QVO :MX]JTQKIV�LQZMK\QWVIT IXXZW^IT_QTT� JM�XW[Q\Q^M�]VLMZ� \_W� KWVLQ\QWV[" MQ\PMZ� I�:MX]JTQKIVXZM[QLMV\�PI[�ZI\QVO[�IJW^M��� � WZ�I�,MUWKZI\QK�XZM[QLMV\PI[�ZI\QVO[�JMTW_��� � +WV^MZ[MTa� \PM�ZI\QVO�_QTT�JM�VMOI�\Q^M�]VLMZ�I�XWX]TIZ�,MUWKZI\QK�WZ�IV�]VXWX]TIZ�:MX]JTQKIVXZM[QLMV\�

<PQ[�Q[�I�VI\]ZIT�_Ia�\W�QVKT]LM�LQZMK\QWVIT�IXXZW^IT�ZI\�QVO[�QV\W�\PM�UWLMT� _PMZM y = 1 QVLQKI\M[�:MX]JTQKIV�[]X�XWZ\� )[�IV�M`IUXTM� KWV[QLMZ�\PM�KWPWZ\�JWZV�QV��!�!� 1V�!����IOM�%���� \PM�I^MZIOM�IXXZW^IT�ZI\QVO�NWZ�\PM�:MX]JTQ�KIV�8ZM[QLMV\�-Q[MVPW_MZ�_I[��� � [W xj,1 = +21 � 1V�!����IOM�%���� \PM�XZM[QLMVKa�ÆQXXML�\W�,MUWKZI\QK�8ZM[Q�LMV\�3MVVMLa� _PW�PIL�IV�I^MZIOM�ZI\QVO�WN � � aQMTLQVOxj,2 = #1$ (88# 50) = #38 ���

<PM x¼[� \PMV� IXXZW`QUI\M�XIZ\Q[IV�XWTQ\QKIT�[PWKS[�\PI\IZM�ZMTI\ML�\W�\PM�8ZM[QLMVKa� 6W_�\PI\�\PM[M�IZM�[XMKQÅML�_M�LMÅVM�\PM OMVMZI\QWVIT�MNNMK\ WV�I�XIZ\QK]TIZ�KMTT"

"j = #g[j]

70!

i=1

wixj,i, ���

_PMZM wi QVLQKI\M[� \PM IOM�[XMKQÅK�_MQOP\ I\� IOM i� IVL #g[j]

ZMÆMK\[� \PM� QUXWZ\IVKM�WN � \PM�IOM�[XMKQÅK�_MQOP\[� NWZ�MIKPZIKM�ZMOQWV�OZW]X� <PM[M�IZM�\PM�XZQUIZa�NWKQ�WN �\PM�IVITa�[Q[� 1N �\PM w \MZU[�IZM�ITT�ZW]OPTa�\PM�[IUM�UIOVQ\]LM� \PI\_W]TL�QUXTa�\PI\�\PM�[QUXTM�]V_MQOP\ML�¹Z]VVQVO�\ITTaº�Q[�IVIXXZWXZQI\M�UWLMT�WN �ZM\ZW[XMK\Q^M�XZM[QLMV\QIT�M^IT]I\QWV[�1N� PW_M^MZ� \PMa� IZM�U]KP� PQOPMZ� NWZ� [WUM� XIZ\QK]TIZ� IOMZIVOM� \PMV�\PW[M�IOM[�IZM�\PM�NW]VLI\QWVIT�IOM[�WN �XZM[QLMV�\QIT�XWTQ\QKIT�[WKQITQbI\QWV� <W�[\Z]K\]ZM�\PM�IVITa[Q[�I�TQ\\TM�JQ\�_M�QUXW[M�IV�):���ZM[\ZQK\QWV�WV�\PM w _MQOP\[� ]VLMZ�\PMM`XMK\I\QWV�\PI\�\PMa�\ISM�WV�I�[WUM_PI\�[UWW\P�[\Z]K\]ZIT

��<_W�W\PMZ�VW\M[" ����<PM x¼[�IZM�\WX�KMV[WZML�I\�IOM����JMKI][M� I[�LQ[�K][[ML�MIZTQMZ� _M�ZM[\ZQK\�\PM�IVITa[Q[�\W�XMWXTM�JWZV�IN\MZ��!���IVL�\PMZMIZM�I�^MZa�[UITT�V]UJMZ�WN �WJ[MZ^IJTM�IXXZW^IT�ZI\QVO[�IJW^M�\PI\�IOM# ���ZI\QVO[� NWZ�IOM[�\PI\�WKK]ZZML�IN\MZ�\PM�MTMK\QWV�aMIZ t ZMÆMK\ML�QV�KMTT jIZM�[M\�\W��# \PW[M�ZI\QVO[�IZM�NZWU�\PM�N]\]ZM� QV�KWUXIZQ[WV�\W�\PM�[]Z�^Ma�ZM[XWV[M� IVL�\P][�[PW]TL�PI^M�VW�QUXIK\�WV�ZM\ZW[XMK\Q^M�XZM[QLMV\QITM^IT]I\QWV[�

NWZU"

wi " 6WZUIT (wi!1, 1) , ���

_Q\P�VW�XZQWZ�M`XMK\I\QWV�WV w1�

<PM�X]ZXW[M�WN �\PM# \MZU�Q[�\W�M[\QUI\M�\PM�M`\MV\�\W�_PQKP\PM�XWTQ\QKIT�[WKQITQbI\QWV�XZWKM[[�QUXTQML�Ja�\PM�IOM�_MQOP\[w Q[�LQNNMZMV\�NWZ�MIKP�ZIKM�ZMOQWV�OZW]X� QVLM`ML�WV g[j]� )XZQWZQ� _M�M`XMK\�UQVWZQ\QM[� \W�JM� TM[[� QUXIK\ML�Ja� \PM�IOM_MQOP\[� L]M� \W� �I�� KWV[Q[\MV\Ta� [\ZWVO�,MUWKZI\QK� []XXWZ\IUWVO�)NZQKIV�)UMZQKIV[� IVL� �J�� \PM� NIK\� \PI\�UIVa�0Q[�XIVQK�^W\MZ[�UIa�JM�QUUQOZIV\[� IVL�\PMZMNWZM�LQL�VW\�M`XM�ZQMVKM�\PM�XWTQ\QKIT�[PWKS[�I[�[\ZWVOTa�I[�_PQ\M�^W\MZ[�_PW�PI^MTQ^ML�QV�\PM�=VQ\ML�;\I\M[�NWZ�\PMQZ�MV\QZM�TQ^M[� ?M�LW�VW\�QU�XW[M�\PQ[�M`XMK\I\QWV�\PZW]OP�XZQWZ[�QV�\PM�UWLMT� J]\�\PM #\MZU[�ITTW_�][�\W�M`IUQVM�\PM�Y]M[\QWV� .QVITTa� \W�SMMX�\PMUWLMT�QLMV\QÅML� \PM�ZIVLWU�_ITS�QV�\PM w \MZU[�Q[�LZI_V_Q\P�I�[KITM�XIZIUM\MZ $ = 1� I[�[PW_V�IJW^M� IVL�\PM w¼[\PMU[MT^M[�IZM�ZM[\ZQK\ML�\W�[]U�\W���

*MKI][M�_M�IZM�UWLMTQVO�XZM[QLMV\QIT�^W\M�KPWQKM� Q\�Q[�VMK�M[[IZa� \W� QVKT]LM�JZWIL� MTMK\QWV�Ja�MTMK\QWV period MNNMK\[�LMVW\ML %t,g " 6WZUIT(0,$!)� 6W\QKM�\PI\�\PM %¼[�IZM�QV�LM`ML�Ja t IVL g� ZMÆMK\QVO�XW\MV\QITTa� LQNNMZMV\� MNNMK\[� JaMTMK\QWV�aMIZ�IVL�ZIKM�ZMOQWVIT�OZW]X� 1V[\MIL�WN �ILLQVO�\PMXMZQWL�MNNMK\[�QV�\PM�[IUM�_Ia�NWZ�ITT�IOM�OZW]X[� _M�OMVMZIT�QbM�\PM�XMZQWL�MNNMK\�\PZW]OP�IV�QV\MZIK\QWV�\MZU� &g[j ]� <PMÅVIT�XMZQWL�MNNMK\ Aj NWZ�KMTT j� \PMV� Q["

Aj = %t[j],g[j] + &g[j]wi[j]%t[j],g[j] ���

="1 + &g[j]wi[j]

#%t[j],g[j]. ���

<PQ[� OMVMZITQbI\QWV� Q[� QUXWZ\IV\� JMKI][M�QN �QVLQ^QL]IT[�IZMUWZM�TQSMTa�\W�JM�QUXIK\ML�Ja�XWTQ\QKIT�M^MV\[�I\�I�KMZ\IQV�IOM�\PMV�Q\�Q[�IT[W�ZMI[WVIJTM�\W�I[S�_PM\PMZ�MTMK\QWV�\W�MTMK\QWVXMZQWL� MNNMK\[� IZM�UWZM�XZWVW]VKML� I\� \PI\� QUXZM[[QWVIJTMIOM� I[� _MTT� ?M� QVLM` & WV� \PM� OZW]X g QV� KMTT j� \W� IT�TW_� \PQ[� QV\MZIK\QWV� \W� ^IZa� Ja� ZIKM�ZMOQWV� IVL� _M� LZI_& " 0ITN�6WZUIT (0,$") \W�VWZUITQbM�\PM�QV\MZIK\QWV�MNNMK\\W_IZL�bMZW� )LLQVO�\PM[M�\_W�\MZU[�\WOM\PMZ"

!j = "j +Aj ���

KWUXTM\M[�\PM�UWLMT�

+WUX]\I\QWVITTa� _M�Å\�\PM�UWLMT�][QVO�;\IV��;\IV�,M^MT�

Page 9: QVO - Columbia Universitygelman/research/unpublished/...Jun 05, 2014  · i kw]xtm wn lmkilm[ wz tm[[ .wz m`iuxtm wvm wn \pm nmi\]zm[ wn \pm mizta li\i kqzki \pm ! [ ! [ _i[ \pm wj[mz^i\qwv

WXUMV\�<MIU��������QV�KWVR]VK\QWV�_Q\P�: �: +WZM�<MIU������� ;\IV�][M[�\PM�6W�=�<]ZV��6=<;� [IUXTMZ��0WNNUIVIVL�/MTUIV��1V�XZM[[�� IV�M`\MV[QWV�\W�0IUQT\WVQIV�5WV\M+IZTW� �05+� [IUXTQVO� �,]IVM�M\ IT��� �! ��� _PQKP� QV�IVLWN �Q\[MTN �Q[�I�NWZU�WN �5IZSW^�+PIQV�5WV\M�+IZTW��5M\ZWXWTQ[M\ IT����!���� ?M�OMVMZI\M���KPIQV[� MIKP�Z]V�NWZ������Q\MZI�\QWV[� IVL�_M�[I^M�\PM�ÅVIT�����Q\MZI\QWV[�WN �MIKP�KPIQV� _PQKPIZM�[]NÅKQMV\�\W�QVLQKI\M�KWV^MZOMVKM�\PZW]OP�XW[\�UWLMTQVOLQIOVW[\QK[�[]KP�I[�/MTUIV�:]JQV R̂ �/MTUIV�M\ IT���������

5WLMT�:M[]T\[

*MKI][M�\PM�[\I\Q[\QKIT�UWLMT�KWV[Q[\[�WN �UIVa�[M\[�WN �XIZIU�M\MZ[� \PM�MI[QM[\�_Ia�\W�LM[KZQJM�ZM[]T\[�Q[�\PZW]OP�I�[MZQM[�WNOZIXP[� LQ[XTIaQVO�\PM�XW[\MZQWZ�LMV[Q\a�WN �\PM�XIZIUM\MZ[�WNQV\MZM[\�

)OM�?MQOP\[

.QO]ZM � LQ[XTIa[�\PM�UIQV�ZM[]T\�WN �\PM�XIXMZ" M[\QUI\M[�NWZ\PM OMVMZI\QWVIT \ZMVL[� QUXTQML�Ja� \PM�UWLMT� <PM� TMN\�PIVLXIVMT� [PW_[�M[\QUI\M[� NWZ� \PM�IOM�[XMKQÅK�_MQOP\[ w� ITWVO_Q\P��� �IVL�!� �KZMLQJTM�QV\MZ^IT[� <PM[M�_MQOP\[�ZMÆMK\\PM�NWZUI\Q^M�aMIZ[�WN �XWTQ\QKIT�[WKQITQbI\QWV¸QN� I[�\PM�UWLMTXW[Q\[� XIZ\Q[IV�XZM[QLMV\QIT�^W\QVO�Q[�I�¹Z]VVQVO�\ITTaº�ZMÆMK\�QVO�\PM�ZM\ZW[XMK\Q^M�M^IT]I\QWV[�WN �XI[\�,MUWKZI\QK�IVL�:M�X]JTQKIV�XZM[QLMV\[� \PMV�\PM[M�_MQOP\[�[\ZWVOTa�QVLQKI\M�\PW[MM^IT]I\QWV[�IZM�U]KP�UWZM�UMIVQVON]T�IZW]VL�\PM�IOM�WN �� \PIV�TI\MZ�QV�TQNM�

1\�Q[�PMTXN]T�\W�M`IUQVM�\PM�KPIZIK\MZQ[\QK[�WN �\PQ[�OZIXP�QVUWZM�LM\IQT� JMKI][M�\PMa�JW\P�J]QTL�KWVÅLMVKM�QV�\PM�XTI]�[QJQTQ\a�WN � \PM�UWLMT�IVL�[MMU�\W�M`XTIQV�Y]Q\M�I�JQ\�IJW]\\PM�XWTQ\QKIT� [WKQITQbI\QWV�XZWKM[[� 6W\QKM� \PI\ w1� \PM� IOM_MQOP\�I\�IOM��� Q[�M[[MV\QITTa�bMZW� <PQ[�UISM[�[MV[M� I[�XW�TQ\QKIT�M^MV\[�I\�[]KP�I�aW]VO�IOM�_W]TL�[MMU�]VTQSMTa�\W�PI^MI�[\ZWVO�QUXIK\�WV�TWVO�\MZU�XZMNMZMVKM[� )T[W�VW\QKM�\PI\_MQOP\[�NWZ�ITT�aMIZ[�IZM�MQ\PMZ�XW[Q\Q^M� WZ� QV�\PM�^MZa�MIZTaIVL� TI\MZ� aMIZ[� QVLQ[\QVO]Q[PIJTM� NZWU� bMZW� ;\ZWVO� VMOI�\Q^M�_MQOP\[�_W]TL�JM�XZWJTMUI\QK� JMKI][M�\PMa�_W]TL�QUXTa[WUM�[WZ\�WN �XZM[QLMV\QIT�IXXZW^IT�JIKSTI[P�I\�I�KMZ\IQV�IOM� [WQ\�Q[�VQKM�\W�[MM�\PI\�\PMa�IZM�IJ[MV\�PMZM� 6MQ\PMZ�WN �\PM[M�NMI�\]ZM[�_MZM�QUXW[ML�WV�\PM�UWLMT� ZI\PMZ�\PMa�IZW[M�VI\]ZITTaIVL�\P][�XZW^QLM�OWWL�NIKM�^ITQLI\QWV�

<PM�[]J[\IV\Q^M�QV\MZXZM\I\QWV�WN �\PM�_MQOP\[�IT[W�IXXMIZ

Y]Q\M�KTMIZ� )\�I�^MZa�aW]VO�IOM� M^IT]I\QWV[�WN �\PM�XZM[QLMV\[MMU�\W�PI^M�TQ\\TM�QUXIK\� *]\�\PM�_MQOP\[�QVKZMI[M�[\MILQTa�XMISQVO�IZW]VL�\PM�IOM[�WN �������IVL�OZIL]ITTa�LMKZMI[QVOIN\MZ�\PI\� *a�\PM�IOM�WN �ZW]OPTa����WV_IZL� \PMa�JMKWUM� WVWVM�PIVL� [\I\Q[\QKITTa�QVLQ[\QVO]Q[PIJTM�NZWU�bMZW� *]\�WV�\PMW\PMZ� \PMa�[MMU�\W�ZMUIQV�[TQOP\Ta�IJW^M�bMZW�NWZ�\PM�L]ZI\QWVWN �\PM�K]Z^M� <PMZM�IZM�[WUM�[TQOP\�\_Q[\[�]X�IVL�LW_V� J]\\PW[M�IZM�TQSMTa�L]M�\W�VWQ[M�QV�\PM�UWLMT�IVL�LW�VW\�IXXMIZXIZ\QK]TIZTa�UMIVQVON]T� )[�I�_PWTM� \PMV� \PM�QUXWZ\IVKM�WNXZM[QLMV\QIT�M^IT]I\QWV[�VM^MZ�\Z]Ta� NITT[� \W�bMZW# Q\�ZMUIQV[�ITJMQ\�[]J[\IV\QITTa�TM[[�QUXWZ\IV\�\PIV�QV�MIZTQMZ�aMIZ[�

<PQ[� IOM�_MQOP\� K]Z^M� Q[� Y]Q\M� QV\]Q\Q^M� <PM� NWZUI\Q^MaMIZ[�NWZ�ZM\ZW[XMK\Q^M�XZM[QLMV\QIT�M^IT]I\QWV[�IZM�I\�ZW]OPTa\PM�IOM[�WN ������� )V�MVWZUW][�TQ\MZI\]ZM�QV�[WKQIT�X[aKPWT�WOa�XWQV\�\W�TI\M�ILWTM[KMVKM�IVL�MIZTa�IL]T\PWWL�I[�QUXWZ�\IV\�aMIZ[�WN �[WKQITQbI\QWV� IVL�QVLMML�W\PMZ�[KPWTIZ[� QV�\PMMIZTa� TQ\MZI\]ZM� NW]VL�\PQ[�ZW]OP�IOM�ZIVOM�\W�JM� QUXWZ\IV\aMIZ[�NWZ�XWTQ\QKIT�[WKQITQbI\QWV� ?PMV�\PMa�M`IUQVML�UIKZW�XIZ\Q[IV�\ZMVL[�IUWVO�IL]T\[� NWZ�M`IUXTM� -ZQS[WV� 5IK3�]MV�IVL�;\QU[WV��������NW]VL�I�ZW]OPTa�[QUQTIZ�XI\\MZV� QV_PQKP�XWTQ\QKIT� M^MV\[�PIL� \PM� TIZOM[\� QUXIK\� I\� IOM�� ��!�_Q\P�QUXIK\�LMKTQVQVO�XZWOZM[[Q^MTa�NZWU�\PMZM�

?Q\P� \PI\� QV�UQVL� \PM�LMÅVQ\QWV�WN �IOM[�������Q[�W^MZTa[XMKQÅK� 1VLMML� _MQOP\[�I\�IOM����WZ����IZM�[\I\Q[\QKITTa�QV�LQ[\QVO]Q[PIJTM�NZWU�\PM�XMIS�aMIZ[� IVL�M^IT]I\QWV[�ZMUIQVY]Q\M�PMI^QTa�_MQOP\ML�NWZ�[WUM�\QUM�IN\MZ�\PM�IOM�WN ���� -^MVTI\MZ�QV�TQNM� \PM�_MQOP\[�LW�VW\�OW�ITT�\PM�_Ia�LW_V�\W�bMZW�<PW]OP�\PM�QUXWZ\IVKM�WN �XWTQ\QKIT�M^MV\[�QV�NWZUQVO�TWVO�\MZU�XZMNMZMVKM[�LWM[�LQUQVQ[P� Q\�LWM[�XMZ[Q[\� \W� [WUM�LM�OZMM�

.WZ�\PM�[ISM�WN �KTIZQ\a� Q\�UIa�JM�PMTXN]T�\W�ZM�MUXPI[QbM�\PMLI\I� \PI\� QVNWZU[� \PM�IOM�_MQOP\�K]Z^M� 1V�XIZ\QK]TIZ� PW_KIV�\PM�UWLMT�LM\MZUQVM�\PM�QUXWZ\IVKM�WN �XWTQ\QKIT�M^MV\[\PI\� WKK]Z�_PMV� I� []Z^Ma� ZM[XWVLMV\� Q[� [Ia� ��� aMIZ[� WTL�_PMV�\PMZM�IZM�VW�IK\]IT�[]Z^Ma�ZM[XWV[M[�NWZ����aMIZ�WTL['<PM�\ZQKS�PMZM�Q[�\PI\� LM[XQ\M�VW\�IK\]ITTa�QV\MZ^QM_QVO�IVa���aMIZ�WTL[� ITT�WN �\PM�[]Z^Ma[�ZMKWZLML�IOM� IVL�\PMZMNWZM�JW\P�I��\PM�aMIZ�\PI\�\PM�ZM[XWVLMV\�_I[����aMIZ[�WTL� IVL��J��\PM8ZM[QLMV\QIT�)XXZW^IT�ZI\QVO�L]ZQVO�\PI\�aMIZ� IZM�JW\P�IXXIZ�MV\� .WZ�M`IUXTM� QUIOQVM�I����aMIZ�WTL�_PW�_I[�QV\MZ^QM_MLQV������ <PQ[�ZM[XWVLMV\�_I[�JWZV�QV��!���IVL�_I[����aMIZ[WTL�QV��! �� <PMZMNWZM� LM[XQ\M�\PM�NIK\�\PI\�\PMZM�IZM�VW�[]Z�^Ma�QV\MZ^QM_[�WN �\PQ[�XMZ[WV�I\�IOM���� _M�SVW_�\PI\�:WVITL

Page 10: QVO - Columbia Universitygelman/research/unpublished/...Jun 05, 2014  · i kw]xtm wn lmkilm[ wz tm[[ .wz m`iuxtm wvm wn \pm nmi\]zm[ wn \pm mizta li\i kqzki \pm ! [ ! [ _i[ \pm wj[mz^i\qwv

The Formative Years

Age

Ag

e−S

pecifi

c W

eig

hts

(w

)

●●

●●

●●

●●●

●●●●●●●

●●

●●●

●●●●

●●●●

●●●●

●●●●●●●

●●

●●●●●

●●●●

●●

●●

●● ●

Posterior Mean50% C.I.95% C.I.

18

10 20 30 40 50 60 70

−0.0

10

.00

0.0

10.0

20

.03

0.0

4

Formative Years Not AsImportant for Minorities

Estimate of βgP

ost

erio

r D

ensi

ty

Non−Southern WhiteSouthern WhiteMinority

0 5 10 15 20

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

.QO]ZM �" -[\QUI\M[�NWZ�\PM�OMVMZI\QWVIT�I[XMK\[�WN �\PM�UWLMT� �4� <PM�ZW]OP�IOM�ZIVOM�WN �������Q[�NW]VL�\WJM�WN �XIZIUW]V\�QUXWZ\IVKM�QV�\PM�NWZUI\QWV�WN �TWVO�\MZU�XZM[QLMV\QIT�^W\QVO�XZMNMZMVKM[� 8WTQ\QKIT�M^MV\[�I\�I^MZa�aW]VO�IOM�PI^M�^MZa�TQ\\TM�QUXIK\� IVL�IN\MZ�\PM�IOM�WN ���� \PM�IOM�_MQOP\[�LMKZMI[M� [\IaQVO�I\�I�[UITT�[\MILaUIOVQ\]LM�NZWU�IJW]\�\PM�IOM�WN ����WV_IZL� �:� <PM[M�IOM�_MQOP\[� IVL� \PM�XWTQ\QKIT�[WKQITQbI\QWV�XZWKM[[QUXTQML�Ja�\PMU� IZM�[]J[\IV\QITTa�UWZM�QUXWZ\IV\�NWZ�VWV�0Q[XIVQK�_PQ\M[�\PIV�NWZ�UQVWZQ\QM[�I[�I�_PWTM�

:MIOIV�_I[�8ZM[QLMV\�I\�\PI\�\QUM� _Q\P�IV�I^MZIOM�8ZM[QLMV�\QIT�)XXZW^IT�WN ��� �L]ZQVO�\PI\�aMIZ� <PM�ZM\ZW[XMK\Q^M�^W\�QVO�UWLMT�XW[Q\[�\PI\�\PW[M�M^MV\[�QV��! ��PIL�[WUM�MNNMK\�WV\PQ[�^W\MZ¼[�TWVO�TI[\QVO�XWTQ\QKIT�XZMNMZMVKM[� IVL�\PM�XIZ\QK�]TIZ�UWLMT�XZM[MV\ML�PMZM�XW[Q\[� \PI\� \PMZM�IZM�IOM�[XMKQÅK_MQOP\[�IVL�W\PMZ�NMI\]ZM[� I[�LM[KZQJML�MIZTQMZ� <PM�[]Z^MaZM[XWV[M�NZWU������ITTW_[�\PM�UWLMT�\W�WJ[MZ^M�\PM�XZMNMZ�MVKM�WN �\PQ[�^W\MZ�NZWU����� I\�IOM���� *]\� \PM�UWLMT�M[[MV�\QITTa�¹JIKS[�W]\º�\PM�MNNMK\�WN �\PI\��! ��[PWKS� IVL�QVLMML�\PMMNNMK\[�WN �ITT�XWTQ\QKIT�[PWKS[� I[�\PMa�_MZM�IXXTQML�L]ZQVO�\PMIXXZWXZQI\M�IOM�IVL�aMIZ� <PQ[�Q[�_PI\�ITTW_[�\PM�M[\QUI\QWVWN �\PM�IOM�_MQOP\�K]Z^M�

1UXWZ\IVKM�Ja�:IKM�IVL�:MOQWV

?Q\P�\PM�IOM�K]Z^M�N]TTa�LMÅVML� _M�UW^M�\W�\PM�ZQOP\�PIVLXIVMT�WN �.QO]ZM �� 0MZM�_M�LQ[XTIa�M[\QUI\M[�NWZ�\PM QUXWZ\IVKMWN �\PM�IOM�K]Z^M� I[�ZMXZM[MV\ML�Ja�\PM #g \MZU�QV�-Y]I\QWV����WN �\PM�UWLMT� <PM�V]UMZQK�UIOVQ\]LM�WN �\PM�MNNMK\��[PW_VWV�\PM x�I`Q[�� Q[�LQNÅK]T\� \W� QV\MZXZM\� IVL�_M�_QTT�ZM\]ZV�\W

\PQ[�QV\MZXZM\I\QWV�TI\MZ�WV# J]\�\PM�UIQV�\ISMI_Ia�Q[�\PI\�\PMIOM�K]Z^M� Q[� []J[\IV\QITTa� TM[[� QUXWZ\IV\� NWZ�UQVWZQ\QM[� \PIVNWZ�VWV�0Q[XIVQK�_PQ\M[� <PM�I^MZIOM�M[\QUI\M[�NWZ�\PM�\PZMMOZW]X[¸VWV�;W]\PMZV�_PQ\M[� ;W]\PMZV�_PQ\M[� IVL�UQVWZQ�\QM[¸IZM� ��� �� � IVL����� ZM[XMK\Q^MTa� )T\PW]OP�\PM�LQNNMZ�MVKM�JM\_MMV�;W]\PMZV�IVL�VWV�;W]\PMZV�_PQ\M[�LWM[�VW\IXXMIZ�\W�JM�UMIVQVON]T� \PM�OMVMZI\QWVIT�MNNMK\�Q[�W^MZ�\_QKMI[�TIZOM�NWZ�_PQ\M[�I[�NWZ�UQVWZQ\QM[�I[�I�_PWTM� 1\�[PW]TL�JMVW\ML� QV�ILLQ\QWV� \PI\� \PM #¼[� IZM�ITT�XW[Q\Q^M� LM[XQ\M�VW\JMQVO�KWV[\ZIQVML�\W�JM�[W�QV�\PM�UWLMT� QVLQKI\QVO�[\I\Q[\QKIT[QOVQÅKIVKM�

<PQ[� ZM[]T\� Q[� QV� TQVM� _Q\P� I� XZQWZQ� M`XMK\I\QWV[� \PW]OPIOIQV� \PW[M� M`XMK\I\QWV[� _MZM� VW\� QUXW[ML� WV� \PM�UWLMT�)NZQKIV�)UMZQKIV[�PI^M�KWV[Q[\MV\Ta�^W\ML�_Q\P� \PM�,MUW�KZI\QK� XIZ\a� IVL� I[� []KP� Q\� Q[� LQNÅK]T\� NWZ� \PM� IOM� _MQOP\[IVL�XIZ\Q[IV�[PWKS[�\W�PI^M�I�[]J[\IV\QIT�QUXIK\�WV�\PMQZ�^W\�QVO�XI\\MZV[� .WZ�0Q[XIVQK[� \PM�XWTQ\QKIT� [WKQITQbI\QWV�XZW�KM[[� Q[� TQSMTa� \W�JM� []J[\IV\QITTa�UWZM�KWUXTM`� ;WUM�0Q[�XIVQK�^W\MZ[� IZM�VI\Q^M�JWZV�KQ\QbMV[�IVL�PI^M�M`XMZQMVKML

!

Page 11: QVO - Columbia Universitygelman/research/unpublished/...Jun 05, 2014  · i kw]xtm wn lmkilm[ wz tm[[ .wz m`iuxtm wvm wn \pm nmi\]zm[ wn \pm mizta li\i kqzki \pm ! [ ! [ _i[ \pm wj[mz^i\qwv

Period Effectsby Race/Region

Election

Mo

del C

oeffic

ient

(αt,

g)

● ●

●●

● ●●

Non−Southern WhiteSouthern WhiteMinority

1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010

−4−2

02

4

Are Period Effects StrongerDuring Formative Years?

Effect Size Ratio, (Age 18 / Age 70)P

ost

erio

r D

ensi

ty

Non−Southern WhiteSouthern WhiteMinority

1.00 1.25 1.50 1.75 2.00

05

10

15

.QO]ZM �" -[\QUI\M[�NWZ�\PM�MTMK\QWV�\W�MTMK\QWV�XMZQWL�MNNMK\[�QV�\PM�UWLMT� �4� 5QVWZQ\QM[�IZM�KWV[Q[\MV\Ta�UWZMTQSMTa�\W�^W\M�NWZ�,MUWKZI\QK�XZM[QLMV\[� IVL�;W]\PMZV�_PQ\M[�PI^M�[\MILQTa�\ZMVLML�XZW�:MX]JTQKIV�W^MZ�\PM�XI[\���aMIZ[� �:� 8MZQWL�MNNMK\[�IZM�ZW]OPTa�[QUQTIZ�JM\_MMV�aW]VO�IVL�WTL�^W\MZ[�IUWVO�UQVWZQ\QM[�IVL�QV�\PM�;W]\P#M^QLMVKM�Q[�QVKWVKT][Q^M�NWZ�VWV�;W]\PMZV�_PQ\M[�

\PM�[IUM�XWTQ\QKIT�[PWKS[�I[�VWV�0Q[XIVQK�_PQ\M[��\PW]OP�\PMaUIa�PI^M�M`XMZQMVKML�\PMU�LQNNMZMV\Ta�� 7\PMZ[�IZM� QUUQ�OZIV\[�IVL�UIa�PI^M�VW\�TQ^ML�PMZM�NWZ�UIVa�WN �\PM�M^MV\[�\PI\KWUXZQ[M�\PM�[PWKS[�\PI\�IZM�UMI[]ZML�QV�\PM�/ITT]X�[MZQM[�7V�\WX�WN �\PQ[� VI\]ZITQbML�KQ\QbMV[�UIa�[MTN�[MTMK\�QV\W�XWTQ\�QKIT�XIZ\QKQXI\QWV�I\�LQNNMZMV\� ZI\M[�JI[ML�WV� \PM� [ITQMVKM�WNXWTQ\QKIT�IK\Q^Q\a�IUWVO�\PMQZ�KWUU]VQ\a��8IV\WRI� :IUQZMbIVL�;MO]ZI�������� ILLQVO�ILLQ\QWVIT�KWUXTQKI\QVO�NIK\WZ[�

1V�[PWZ\� Q\�IXXMIZ[�\PI\�\PM�[\ZIQOP\�NWZ_IZL�XWTQ\QKIT�[W�KQITQbI\QWV�XZWKM[[�LM[KZQJML�NWZ�_PQ\M�^W\MZ[�PMZM�Q[�VW\�VMK�M[[IZQTa�IXXTQKIJTM�NWZ�UQVWZQ\QM[� ?M�[PW]TL�VW\M� PW_M^MZ�\PI\�QV�[WUM�[MV[M�\PQ[�M[\QUI\M�Q[�\WW�KZ]LM¸XWWTQVO�ITT�UQ�VWZQ\QM[�\WOM\PMZ�UIa�QVIXXZWXZQI\MTa�QVÆI\M�\PQ[ # \MZU�NWZ)NZQKIV�)UMZQKIV[�IVL�LMÆI\M�Q\�NWZ�0Q[XIVQK[� TMILQVO�][�\W]VLMZM[\QUI\M�\PM�QUXIK\�WN �\PQ[�[WKQITQbI\QWV�XZWKM[[�WV�0Q[�XIVQK�^W\MZ[� *]\�\PM�LI\I�TQUQ\I\QWV[�VMKM[[Q\I\M�\PQ[�XWWTQVOXZWKML]ZM� IVL� [W�I�LM\IQTML� QV^M[\QOI\QWV� NWZ� \PW[M�OZW]X[U][\�JM�TMN\�NWZ�IVW\PMZ�\QUM�

8MZQWL�-NNMK\[

6M`\� .QO]ZM � PWTL[�I�[]UUIZa�WN �\PM�MTMK\QWV�\W�MTMK\QWVXMZQWL MNNMK\[� M[\QUI\ML� Ja� \PM� UWLMT� :MKITT� \PI\� \PM� XM�ZQWL�MNNMK\[�_MZM�ITTW_ML�\W�^IZa�Ja�ZIKM�ZMOQWV� IVL�[W�ITT\PZMM�¹\QUM� [MZQM[º�IZM�XTW\\ML�WV� \PM� TMN\� ITWVO�_Q\P� \PMQZ�� �IVL�!� �KZMLQJTM� QV\MZ^IT[� <PM[M�MNNMK\[�IZM�ITT� ZMI�[WVIJTM¸UQVWZQ\QM[�IZM�KWV[Q[\MV\Ta�UWZM� TQSMTa� \W�^W\M� NWZ,MUWKZI\QK� XZM[QLMV\[� IVL� ;W]\PMZV� _PQ\M[� PI^M� [\MILQTa\ZMVLML�XZW�:MX]JTQKIV�W^MZ�\PM�XI[\����aMIZ[�

<PM� ZQOP\�PIVL�XTW\� Q[� I� \ZIV[NWZUI\QWV�WN � \PM & MNNMK\[NZWU�-Y]I\QWV[�����IVL����� :MKITT�\PI\�\PM[M�\MZU[�_MZM�X]\QV� \PM�UWLMT� [W� \PI\�_M�KW]TL�I[S� IZM�XMZQWL�MNNMK\[�UWZMXZWVW]VKML�L]ZQVO�\PM� NWZUI\Q^M�aMIZ[�[PW_V�QV�.QO]ZM �'0MZM�_M�IZM�VW\�XTW\\QVO�\PM & M[\QUI\M[�LQZMK\Ta� L]M�\W�\PMLQNÅK]T\a�QV�LQZMK\Ta�QV\MZXZM\QVO�QV\MZIK\QWV�MNNMK\[��/MTUIVIVL�0QTT�������� I�KPITTMVOM�\PI\�Q[�M`IKMZJI\ML�_Q\P�I�UWLMTWN �\PQ[�KWUXTM`Q\a� 1V[\MIL�_M�LQ[XTIa�\PM�\PM�QUXTQML ZI\QW WNXMZQWL�MNNMK\[¸\PM�V]UMZI\WZ�Q[�\PM�QUXTQML�XMZQWL�MNNMK\�NWZIV�� �aMIZ�WTL�^W\MZ��\PM�XMIS�WN �\PM�IOM�_MQOP\�K]Z^M�� IVLLMVWUQVI\WZ�\PM�QUXTQML�MNNMK\�I\�IOM�����ZW]OPTa�\PM�JW\\WU

��

Page 12: QVO - Columbia Universitygelman/research/unpublished/...Jun 05, 2014  · i kw]xtm wn lmkilm[ wz tm[[ .wz m`iuxtm wvm wn \pm nmi\]zm[ wn \pm mizta li\i kqzki \pm ! [ ! [ _i[ \pm wj[mz^i\qwv

WN �\PM�K]Z^M��

<PM� M^QLMVKM� PMZM� IXXMIZ[� QVKWVKT][Q^M� .WZ� ;W]\PMZV_PQ\M[�IVL�UQVWZQ\QM[� \PM�UWLM�WN �\PM�ZI\QW�OI\PMZ[�I\�\PMJW]VLIZa����� QUXTaQVO�VW�LQNNMZMV\QIT�MNNMK\�I\�ITT� .WZ�VWV�;W]\PMZV�_PQ\M[� PW_M^MZ� \PMZM�Q[�I�ZI\PMZ�_QLM�M[\QUI\M�KMV�\MZQVO�IZW]VL������ J]\�PI^QVO�[]J[\IV\QIT�UI[[�NZWU�����\W���� <PQ[�UMIV[�\PI\�XMZQWL�MNNMK\[�NWZ�VWV�;W]\PMZV�_PQ\M[IZM�[WUM_PMZM�JM\_MMV�� �IVL��� �OZMI\MZ�NWZ�aW]VO�^W\�MZ[�\PIV�WTL�^W\MZ[� <PM�PQOP�MVL� WZ�M^MV�\PM�UWLM�IZW]VL����� _W]TL�QUXTa�Y]Q\M�I�TIZOM�LQNNMZMVKM� J]\�\PM�UWLMT¼[�QV�IJQTQ\a�\W�XZMKQ[MTa�M[\QUI\M�\PM�UIOVQ\]LM�WN �\PM�MNNMK\�TMI^M[\PQ[�XIZ\QK]TIZ�Y]M[\QWV�]VIV[_MZML�

-`XTIVI\WZa�8W_MZ

6W_�\PI\�XIZIUM\MZ�M[\QUI\M[�PI^M�JMMV�LM[KZQJML� WVM�Y]M[�\QWV� ZMUIQV[" PW_� []J[\IV\Q^MTa�UMIVQVON]T� IZM� \PM[M� OMV�MZI\QWVIT� \ZMVL[' <PM # M[\QUI\M[� QV� .QO]ZM � IV[_MZ� \PMY]M[\QWV�[\I\Q[\QKITTa� J]\�\PW[M�M[\QUI\M[�IZM�VW\�XIZ\QK]TIZTaUMIVQVON]T�WZ�]VLMZ[\IVLIJTM� 1V[\MIL� VW\QKM�.QO]ZM �� )VI\]ZIT�_Ia�\W�QV\MZXZM\�\PM�UIOVQ\]LM�WN �MNNMK\[�Q[�QV�\PM�KWV�\M`\�WN �PW_�_MTT� \PMa�M`XTIQV�\PM�UIKZW�TM^MT�^W\QVO�\ZMVL[XZM[MV\� QV�\PM�LI\I� 7VM�KTMIZ�[\I\Q[\QK� QV�\PQ[�ZMOIZL�Q[� \PM[IUXTM�[QbM�_MQOP\ML R2 NWZ�MIKP�WN �\PM�KMTT[¸PW_�U]KP�WN\PM�^IZQI\QWV�Q[�M`XTIQVML�Ja�\PM�UWLMT'

<PM W^MZITT ZM[]T\[�IZM�[PW_V�QV�JTIKS¸\PM�UWLMT�M`XTIQV[N]TTa�!� �WN �\PM�^IZQIVKM�QV�\PM�LI\I <PQ[�V]UJMZ�Q[�UQ[�TMILQVO� PW_M^MZ� JMKI][M�UW[\�WN �\PI\�^IZQI\QWV�KW]TL�JM�IK�KW]V\ML�NWZ�_Q\P�I�U]KP�[QUXTMZ�UWLMT� QVKWZXWZI\QVO�WVTaMTMK\QWV�\W�MTMK\QWV�XMZQWL�IVL�ZIKM�ZMOQWV�OZW]X�MNNMK\[� )N�\MZ�ITT� \PMZM�IZM�JQO�LQNNMZMVKM[�JM\_MMV�UQVWZQ\QM[�IVL�VWV�UQVWZQ\QM[� IVL�JQO�LQNNMZMVKM[�JM\_MMV�MTMK\QWV[�

;M^MZIT�KWUXIZQ[WV[�IZM�\P][�[PW_V�NWZ�KWV\M`\� ) UWLMTQVKWZXWZI\QVO�WVTa�\PM�MTMK\QWV�\W�MTMK\QWV�XMZQWL�MNNMK\[� JZW�SMV�W]\�Ja�ZIKM�ZMOQWV�OZW]X�I[�JMNWZM� M`XTIQV[� ! �WN �\PMW^MZITT�^IZQIVKM� <PM�ZMIT�[]J[\IV\Q^M�XW_MZ�WN �\PM�UWLMT�Q[NW]VL�Ja�TWWSQVO _Q\PQV OZW]X[� ?Q\PQV�MIKP�OZW]X� \PM�LI\IQ[�U]KP�TM[[�[XZMIL�W]\� [W�\PM R2 Q[�TW_MZ�W^MZITT� *]\�\PMN]TT�UWLMT� Q[�Y]Q\M�IV� QUXZW^MUMV\�W^MZ�\PM�[QUXTMZ�UWLMTIUWVO�VWV�;W]\PMZV�_PQ\M[� QUXZW^QVO�\PM�UWLMT�Å\�NZWU���\W��� � )UWVO�;W]\PMZV�_PQ\M[� \PM�Å\�Q[�[TQOP\Ta�QUXZW^ML�OWQVO�NZWU����\W��� � )VL�NWZ�UQVWZQ\QM[� \PM�LQNNMZMVKM�Q[ZI\PMZ�UQVQ[K]TM� 7V�\WX�WN �\PQ[� ^Q[]IT�QV[XMK\QWV�WN �\PM�Å\�\ML�UWLMT�^IT]M[� �Q�M� XW[\�XZMLQK\Q^M�UWLMT�KPMKSQVO� �/MT�

UIV�M\ IT����������ZM^MIT[�\PM�UWLMT�KIX\]ZQVO�\PM�Y]ITQ\I\Q^M^IZQI\QWV�NW]VL�QV�.QO]ZM � Y]Q\M�_MTT�

1V�[]U� \PM�UWLMT�IKKW]V\[�NWZ�I�[]J[\IV\QIT�XWZ\QWV�WN �\PM^IZQI\QWV�QV�XZM[QLMV\QIT�^W\QVO�W^MZ�\PM�TI[\�PITN �KMV\]Za� )T�\PW]OP�U]KP�WN �\PI\�^IZQI\QWV�KW]TL�JM�IKKW]V\ML�NWZ�_Q\P�I[QUXTMZ�UWLMT� \PM�ILLML�OMVMZI\QWVIT�MNNMK\[�QUXTQML�Ja�\PMIOM�_MQOP\[�IUW]V\�\W�I�[]J[\IV\QIT�QUXZW^MUMV\�QV�UWLMTÅ\� M[XMKQITTa�IUWVO�VWV�;W]\PMZV�_PQ\M[�

/MVMZI\QWV[�WN �8ZM[QLMV\QIT�>W\QVO

6W_�\PI\�\PM�UWLMT�Q[�KWUXTM\M� _M�MUJIZS�WV�I�[PWZ\�VIZZI�\Q^M�WN �\PM�8ZM[QLMV\QIT�)XXZW^IT�\QUM�[MZQM[� ZMKW]V\QVO�XQMKM[WN �\PM�PQ[\WZQKIT�XZM[QLMV\QIT�ZMKWZL�NZWU�\PM��!��[�\W�XZM[MV\LIa� <PM�X]ZXW[M�WN �\PQ[�VIZZI\Q^M�Q[�VW\�[QUXTa�\W�LM[KZQJMXZM[QLMV\QIT� PQ[\WZa� VWZ� Q[� Q\� \W� XZW^QLM� I� LM\IQTML� IKKW]V\WN �\PM�NWZUI\QWV�WN �UIRWZ�X]JTQK�XWTQKQM[� 1V[\MIL� _M� M`�IUQVM�M^MV\[�\PZW]OP�\PM�TMV[�WN �\PM�UWLMT� ?M� QV\MVL� \WLM[KZQJM�\PM�UIRWZ�XWTQ\QKIT�M^MV\[�\PI\�NWZUML�\PM�XZM[QLMV�\QIT�^W\QVO�KPIZIK\MZ�WN �LQNNMZMV\�OMVMZI\QWV[� <PM[M�M^MV\[KIV�IVL�[PW]TL�JM�QV\MZXZM\ML�QV�ZMTI\Q^MTa�JZWIL�NI[PQWV� NWZQN �_M�M`XMK\�\PMU�\W�PI^M�I�_QLM�QUXIK\�WV�MV\QZM�OMVMZI�\QWV[�WN �^W\MZ[� \PMQZ�M`IK\�LM\IQT[�IZM�WN �ZMTI\Q^MTa�TQ\\TM�KWV[M�Y]MVKM� <PZW]OP�\PQ[�VIZZI\Q^M� _M�PWXM�\W�XZW^QLM�I�JQ\�WNKWTWZ�IVL�[]J[\IVKM�\W�\PM�IVITa[Q[� IVL�_M�PWXM�\W�LM^MTWXI�UWZM�Y]ITQ\I\Q^M�NMMT�NWZ�\PM�Y]IV\Q\I\Q^M�UWLMTQVO�ZM[]T\[�

.WZ� \PQ[� [MK\QWV� _M� NWK][� M`KT][Q^MTa� WV� VWV�0Q[XIVQK_PQ\M[� )T\PW]OP� \PM�XWTQ\QKIT� [WKQITQbI\QWV�WN �UQVWZQ\QM[� Q[IV�QUXWZ\IV\�\WXQK� \PM�VW\ML�[\ZMVO\P�WN �\PM�UWLMT�IUWVO_PQ\M[�IVL�ZMTI\Q^M�TIKS�WN �[\ZMVO\P�IUWVO�UQVWZQ\QM[�QVLQKI\M\PI\�\PQ[�PQ[\WZa�Q[�UW[\�IXXZWXZQI\MTa�LM[KZQJML�QV�\PQ[�UIV�VMZ�

<PZW]OP�\PM�XZMTQUQVIZa�IVITa[Q[�IVL�UWLMTQVO�MNNWZ\[� _MPI^M�KWUM�\W�I�V]UJMZ�WN � [\ZWVO�KWVKT][QWV[� <PM�XWTQ\Q�KIT�M^MV\[�[]ZZW]VLQVO�\PM�NWZUI\Q^M�aMIZ[�IZW]VL�������IZMWN �XIZIUW]V\�QUXWZ\IVKM�QV�[\Z]K\]ZQVO�TQNM�TWVO�XZM[QLMV\QIT^W\QVO�XZMNMZMVKM[# \PW[M�M^MV\[�IZM�_MTT�IXXZW`QUI\ML�Ja�\PM8ZM[QLMV\QIT�)XXZW^IT�\QUM�[MZQM[# IVL�\PW[M�M^MV\[�[MMU�\WPI^M�MVLWOMVW][Ta�KZMI\ML�Å^M�JZWIL�OMVMZI\QWV[�WN �^W\MZ[�<PMa�KIV�JM�LMVW\ML� NWZ�VW_� Ja�\PMQZ�aMIZ�WN �JQZ\P¸^W\MZ[JWZV�QV�\PM��!��[�WZ�MIZTQMZ��XZW�,MUWKZI\�# �!����:MX]JTQ�KIV�# �!����,MUWKZI\�# �!� ��:MX]JTQKIV�# IVL�\PM��! �[�WZTI\MZ��,MUWKZI\�� <PM[M�aMIZ[�IZM�KPW[MV�JMKI][M�\PM�^W\MZ[

��

Page 13: QVO - Columbia Universitygelman/research/unpublished/...Jun 05, 2014  · i kw]xtm wn lmkilm[ wz tm[[ .wz m`iuxtm wvm wn \pm nmi\]zm[ wn \pm mizta li\i kqzki \pm ! [ ! [ _i[ \pm wj[mz^i\qwv

How Well Does the Model Explain Macro−Level Vote Choice?

Per

cent

of V

aria

nce

Expl

aine

d

89% 92%

53%

71%

50%56% 57% 58%

Per

iod/

Gro

upEf

fect

s M

odel

Full

Mod

el

Per

iod/

Gro

upEf

fect

s M

odel

Full

Mod

el

Per

iod/

Gro

upEf

fect

s M

odel

Full

Mod

el

Per

iod/

Gro

upEf

fect

s M

odel

Full

Mod

el0%25

%50

%75

%10

0%Overall Non−Southern

WhiteSouthern

WhiteMinority

.QO]ZM �" \PM�UWLMT�IKKW]V\[�NWZ�!� �WN �\PM�UIKZW�TM^MT�^IZQIVKM�QV�^W\QVO�\ZMVL[�W^MZ�\PM�XI[\�PITN �KMV\]Za�<PI\�[IQL� U]KP�[QUXTMZ�UWLMT[� QVKWZXWZI\QVO�WVTa�XMZQWL�OZW]X�MNNMK\[� _W]TL�IT[W�IKKW]V\�NWZ�U]KP�WN �\PM^IZQIVKM� <PM�ZMIT�[]J[\IV\Q^M�XW_MZ�WN �\PM�UWLMT�Q[�[MMV�QV�PW_�Q\�QUXZW^M[�UWLMT�Å\�_Q\PQV�ZIKM�ZMOQWV�OZW]X[�XIZ\QK]TIZTa�IUWVO�VWV�;W]\PMZV�_PQ\M[�

JWZV�QV�\PM[M�aMIZ[�IXXMIZ�\W�MXQ\WUQbM�\PM�KPIZIK\MZ�WN �\PMÅ^M�UIQV�OMVMZI\QWV[�NW]VL�\PZW]OP�\PM�UWLMT� ?M�_QTT�M`�IUQVM�MIKP�WN �\PMU�QV�\]ZV�

6M_�,MIT�,MUWKZI\[

.WZ�\PM�ÅZ[\�OMVMZI\QWV� JWZV�QV�\PM��!��[�WZ�MIZTQMZ� _M�IZMIK\]ITTa�Y]Q\M�[PWZ\�PIVLML�QV�LM[KZQX\Q^M�KIXIJQTQ\QM[� NWZ�IV]UJMZ�WN �ZMI[WV[� .QZ[\� \PQ[� Q[�I� TIZOM�IVL�_QLMTa�LQ^MZ[MOZW]X ?Q\PQV�\PM�LI\I[M\� \PM�MIZTQM[\�_MZM�JWZV�QV�� ��� [W_PMV�KWV[QLMZML�I[�I�_PWTM�\PMQZ�XWTQ\QKIT�TQNM�M`XMZQMVKM[�IZMY]Q\M�^IZQML� ;MKWVL� \PM�IVITa[Q[�[XMKQÅKITTa�IVL�QV\MV\QWV�ITTa�M`KT]LML�\PM�^I[\�UIRWZQ\a�WN �\PQ[�OZW]X� L]M�\W�\PM�TIKS�WNXZM[QLMV\QIT�IXXZW^IT�LI\I�I^IQTIJTM�NWZ�U]KP�WN �\PMQZ�TQ^M[� )[I�ZM[]T\� \PM�UWLMT�Q[�VW\�NWZUITTa�IXXZWXZQI\M�NWZ�\PQ[�XIZ\QK�]TIZ�OMVMZI\QWV� ?Q\P�\PM[M�KI^MI\[�QV�UQVL� _M�KIV�[\QTT�\ISM\PM�OMVMZIT�XZQVKQXTM[�TMIZVML�NZWU�\PM�UWLMT�IVL�[XMK]TI\MI[�\W�PW_�\PMa�UQOP\�PI^M�INNMK\ML�\PQ[�OZW]X�

1V� ZMOIZL[� \W�]VLMZ[\IVLQVO�^W\QVO�XI\\MZV[� QV� \PM� TI\\MZ

PITN �WN �\PM�\_MV\QM\P�KMV\]Za� _M�KIV�NWK][�\PM�VIZZI\Q^M�WV\WXMWXTM�JWZV�NZWU�ZW]OPTa��!����!��� JMKI][M�XMWXTM�JWZVJMNWZM��!���KWUXZQ[M�WVTa�I�[UITT�UQVWZQ\a�WN �^W\MZ[�W^MZ�\PQ[XMZQWL� .WZ\]VI\MTa� \PQ[�UISM[�\PM�IVITa[Q[�ZMTI\Q^MTa�[\ZIQOP\�NWZ_IZL� <PMZM�Q[�I�[QVOTM�\W_MZQVO�ÅO]ZM�\PI\�KW]TL�PI^M�IN�NMK\ML�\PQ[�OZW]X¼[�XZM[QLMV\QIT�M^IT]I\QWV[" .ZIVSTQV�,MTIVW:WW[M^MT\� .,:¼[�IKPQM^MUMV\[�IZM�UWV]UMV\IT� 0M�O]QLML\PM�KW]V\Za� \PZW]OP� \PM�/ZMI\�,MXZM[[QWV�IVL�?WZTL�?IZ11��IVL�QV�\PM�6M_�,MIT�PM�TIQL�\PM�NW]VLI\QWV�NWZ�\PM�UWL�MZV�)UMZQKIV�_MTNIZM�[\I\M� 0M�[MZ^ML�I[�XZM[QLMV\�NWZ�\_MT^MaMIZ[� JMQVO�MTMK\ML�NW]Z�\QUM[� JW\P�UWZM�\PIV�IVa�XZM[QLMV\QV�)UMZQKIV�PQ[\WZa�

.WZ�^W\MZ[�JWZV�QV�\PM��!��[�IVL��!��[� \PMQZ�XMIS�NWZUI�\Q^M�aMIZ[�_MZM�[XMV\�L]ZQVO�\PM�/ZMI\�,MXZM[[QWV�IVL�?WZTL?IZ�11��<PMa�M`XMZQMVKML�:MX]JTQKIV�8ZM[QLMV\�0WW^MZ¼[�QV�IJQTQ\a�\W�PMTX�\PM�KW]V\Za�\PZW]OP�\PQ[�LQNÅK]T\�XMZQWL� IVL�I[KPQTLZMV�IVL�aW]VO�IL]T\[�\PMa�[I_�\PM�KW]V\Za�ZMKW^MZ�]VLMZ\PM�,MUWKZI\�.,:��<PQ[�_I[� NWTTW_ML� QUUMLQI\MTa�Ja� \PMOZMI\M[\�_IZ�QV�_WZTL�PQ[\WZa� _PMZM�\PMa�[I_�.,: O]QLM�\PM

��

Page 14: QVO - Columbia Universitygelman/research/unpublished/...Jun 05, 2014  · i kw]xtm wn lmkilm[ wz tm[[ .wz m`iuxtm wvm wn \pm nmi\]zm[ wn \pm mizta li\i kqzki \pm ! [ ! [ _i[ \pm wj[mz^i\qwv

KW]V\Za�\PZW]OP�IVL�MUMZOM�I[�WVM�WN �\PM�_WZTL¼[�[]XMZXW_�MZ[� <W�\PQ[�OMVMZI\QWV� \PMV� \PM�=VQ\ML�;\I\M[�JMKIUM�\PMTMILMZ[�WN �\PM�NZMM�_WZTL�]VLMZ�8ZM[QLMV\�:WW[M^MT\¼[�_I\KP�<PM[M�M^MV\[�[]ZMTa�PIL�IV�QUXIK\�WV�\PMQZ�XZM[QLMV\QIT�^W\QVOXZMNMZMVKM[� IVL�\PW[M�XZMNMZMVKM[�ZMUIQV�\W�\PM�XZM[MV\�LIa�:MKITT�.QO]ZM �� _PMZM�\PM[M�VW_�MTLMZTa�^W\MZ[�KWV\QV]M�\WPI^M�KWUXIZI\Q^MTa�XZW�,MUWKZI\QK�XZMNMZMVKM[�\PZW]OP�\PM����������MTMK\QWV[�

.WZ�^W\MZ[�JWZV�QV�\PM��!��[� \PMQZ�M`XW[]ZM�\W�.,: _I[UWZM�TQUQ\ML�\PIV�\PM�MIZTQMZ�OZW]X� <PMQZ�NWZUI\Q^M�aMIZ[WKK]ZZML�UW[\Ta� IN\MZ� \PM� KW]V\Za� ZMKW^MZML� NZWU� \PM�,M�XZM[[QWV� IVL� NWZ�UIVa� M^MV�IN\MZ�?WZTL�?IZ�11��<PMa�_MZMM`XW[ML�\W�.,:¼[�TI\MZ�aMIZ[� \PW]OP� IVL�\PMZMNWZM�M`XMZQ�MVKML�\PM�\IQT�MVL�WN �PQ[�XZM[QLMVKa� _PQKP� ZMKITTQVO�\PM�)X�XZW^IT� [MZQM[� NZWU�.QO]ZM �� ZMUIQVML�MVWZUW][Ta�XWX]TIZ�5W[\�WN �\PMQZ�XMIS�aMIZ[� PW_M^MZ� IZM�[XMV\�_Q\P�8ZM[QLMV\<Z]UIV�I\�\PM�PMTU� <Z]UIV�PIL�UQ`ML�IVL�TQUQ\ML�XWX�]TIZQ\a�W^MZ�PQ[�\_W�\MZU[� MVLQVO�PQ[�XZM[QLMVKa�I\��� �IX�XZW^IT� )[�[]KP� \PQ[�OZW]X¼[�TWVO�\MZU�^W\QVO�XZMNMZMVKM[�IZMUQ`ML� IVL�\PMa�TMIL�QV\W�\PM�VM`\�OMVMZI\QWV�

-Q[MVPW_MZ�:MX]JTQKIV[

.ZWU�\PQ[�XWQV\�NWZ_IZL� Y]IV\Q\I\Q^M�LI\I�KIV�JM�][ML�\W�IQL\PM�LQ[K][[QWV� <PM�)XXZW^IT�[MZQM[�Q[�I^IQTIJTM�NWZ�\PM�N]TT�TQNM�[XIV�WN �\PM�ZMUIQVQVO�OMVMZI\QWV[� IVL�[W�_M�IXXTa�\PM�UWLMTQV�N]TT�IVL�[MM�\PM�ZM[]T\[�I[�\PMa�KPIVOM�W^MZ�\QUM� <PM�ÅZ[\WN �[]KP�OZIXP[�Q[�[PW_V�QV�.QO]ZM �� <PQ[�\aXM�WN �OZIXP�_QTTJM�[PW_V�NWZ�MIKP�WN �\PM�ZMUIQVQVO�NW]Z�OMVMZI\QWV[� [W�Q\�Q[QUXWZ\IV\�\W�LM[KZQJM�Q\�QV�[WUM�LM\IQT�

<PM�\WX�XIVMT�[PW_[�\PM�NIUQTQIZ�8ZM[QLMV\QIT�)XXZW^IT�[M�ZQM[� VW_�PQOPTQOP\ML�\W�MUXPI[QbM�\PM�OMVMZI\QWVIT�QUXIK\�WNMIKP�\QUM�XMZQWL� <PM�[MZQM[�Q[�KWTWZML�ZML�\W�JT]M� _Q\P�LIZSZML�ZMÆMK\QVO�XZW�:MX]JTQKIV�IXXZW^IT�ZI\QVO[� LIZS�JT]M�I[XZW�,MUWKZI\� IVL�[PILM[�WN �TQOP\MZ�KWTWZ[�IVL�OZMa�QV�JM�\_MMV��� <PM�_QL\P�WN �\PM�[MZQM[�ZMÆMK\[�IOM�[XMKQÅK�_MQOP\[w I[�LM\MZUQVML�Ja�\PM�UWLMT� <PM�OZIXP�\P][�MUXPI[QbM[\PM�XMIS� NWZUI\Q^M�aMIZ[� _PMZM� \PM� M^MV\[� ZMÆMK\ML� QV� \PM)XXZW^IT�[MZQM[�_MZM�UW[\�XW_MZN]T�NWZ�\PQ[�XIZ\QK]TIZ�OMVMZ�I\QWV�

<PM�JW\\WU�XIVMT�QV\MOZI\M[�W^MZ�\PM�[PW_V�)XXZW^IT�[M�ZQM[�IVL�Q[�\P][�ZMÆMK\Q^M�WN �\PM K]U]TI\Q^M OMVMZI\QWVIT�MNNMK\[

��6W\M�\PI\�\PQ[�KWTWZQVO�[KPMUM�XMZNMK\Ta�ZMÆMK\[ :MX]JTQKIV�LQZMK\QWVIT XZM[Q�LMV\QIT�IXXZW^IT� I[�_I[�QVKT]LML�QV�\PM�UWLMT�IVL�LM[KZQJML�MIZTQMZ�

NZWU�\QUM�WN �JQZ\P� <PQ[�K]Z^M�ZMXZM[MV\[�\PM�[]U�XZM[QLMV�\QIT�^W\QVO�\MVLMVKQM[�WN �\PM�KWPWZ\� I\�MIKP�XIZ\QK]TIZ�IOM� I[UIZSML�WV�\PM x�I`Q[� <PM�[MZQM[�[\IZ\[�WV�\PM�UQLLTM�OZMaTQVM� JMKI][M�\PMZM�PI^M�JMMV�VW�M^MV\[�\W�IT\MZ�OMVMZI\QWVIT\MVLMVKQM[�I\�IOM��� 1UXWZ\IV\Ta� MTMK\QWV�\W�MTMK\QWV XMZQWLMNNMK\[�IZM�QV\MV\QWVITTa�M`KT]LML¸\PQ[�OZIXP�Q[�VW\�UMIV\�\WJM�ZMÆMK\Q^M�WN �^W\QVO�QV�XIZ\QK]TIZ�MTMK\QWV[� ZI\PMZ�Q\�MVKWU�XI[[M[�\PM OMVMZIT XIZ\Q[IV�\MVLMVKQM[�WN �\PM�KWPWZ\[� QVLMXMV�LMV\�WN �\PM�XIZ\QK]TIZ[�WN �MIKP�[XMKQÅK�ZIKM�

?Q\P�\PM[M�LI\I�I[�\PM�[\IZ\QVO�XWQV\� _M�KIV�M`IUQVM�\PMZWW\[�WN � \PM��!���KWPWZ\¼[�XIZ\Q[IV�XZM[QLMV\QIT�XZMNMZMVKM[QV�LM\IQT� <PM[M�^W\MZ[�_MZM�\WW�aW]VO�\W�ZMUMUJMZ�.,:¼[UIVa�IKKWUXTQ[PUMV\[� QV[\MIL�MV\MZQVO�\PMQZ�aMIZ[�WN �XWTQ\�QKIT�[WKQITQbI\QWV�QV�IV\Q�,MUWKZI\�WZ�XZW�:MX]JTQKIV�\QUM[�1V�.QO]ZM � IVL�\PW[M�\W�NWTTW_� \PM�UW[\�QUXWZ\IV\�\QUM[�IZM\PM�WVM[�ZMÆMK\ML�_Q\P�\PM�LIZSM[\�IVL�_QLM[\�JIVL[� 1V�\PQ[OZIXP� \PM�ÅZ[\�[]KP�UWUMV\�WKK]Z[�_PMV�\PQ[�OMVMZI\QWV�Q[ZW]OPTa����aMIZ[�WTL� QV��!��� 8ZM[QLMV\�<Z]UIV� _PW�PILJIZMTa�_WV�ZMMTMK\QWV�\PZMM�aMIZ[�MIZTQMZ� PIL�[MV\�)UMZQKIV\ZWWX[�QV\W�3WZMI� IVL�VW_�\PM�_IZ�_I[�\]ZVQVO�QV\W�I�LQ[I[�\MZ� )N\MZ�\PM�]VKWVLQ\QWVIT�^QK\WZa�WN �?WZTL�?IZ�11��)UMZQ�KIV[�_MZM�]VIKK][\WUML�\W�\PM�IXXIZMV\�[\ITMUI\M�QV�3WZMI�IVL�<Z]UIV¼[�XWX]TIZQ\a�XT]UUM\ML�

?PMV�8ZM[QLMV\�-Q[MVPW_MZ�I[[]UML�WNÅKM� QV��!��� PQ[IXXZW^IT�ZI\QVO�_I[�MVWZUW][Ta�PQOP� [\IZ\QVO�I\�!� � 5W[\XZM[QLMV\QIT�\MZU[�[\IZ\�W]\�_Q\P�PQOP�ZI\QVO[� I[�VW\ML�MT[M�_PMZM� �-ZQS[WV� 5IK3]MV� IVL� ;\QU[WV�� ������ J]\� ]VTQSMUW[\� -Q[MVPW_MZ�ZMUIQVML�XWX]TIZ�W^MZ�\PM�MV\QZM\a�WN �PQ[XZM[QLMVKa� <PM�PMZWQK�?WZTL�?IZ�11 OMVMZIT�PIL�XZWUQ[ML\W�MVL�\PM�3WZMIV�?IZ�L]ZQVO�PQ[�KIUXIQOV�IVL�Y]QKSTa�LQL[W� ][PMZQVO�QV�IV�MZI�WN �WN �ZMTI\Q^M�XMIKM� )T\PW]OP�PM�LQLVW\�[]KKMML�QV�MVLQVO�\PM�+WTL�?IZ� I[�PM�LM[QZML� ITT�QV\MZ�VI\QWVIT�KWVÆQK\[�W^MZ�PQ[�\MV]ZM�_MZM�ZMTI\Q^MTa�UQVWZ� 7V\PM�LWUM[\QK�NZWV\� \PM��!��[�_MZM�I�\QUM�WN �MKWVWUQK�XZW[�XMZQ\a�IVL�XZWOZM[[� -Q[MVPW_MZ�W^MZ[I_�\PM�KZMI\QWV�WN �\PM1V\MZ[\I\M�0QOP_Ia�;a[\MU�IVL�[QOVML�\PM�+Q^QT�:QOP\[�)K\�WN�!���QV\W�TI_�

<PM�UW[\�XZWUQVMV\�LQX�QV�-Q[MVPW_MZ¼[�XWX]TIZQ\a�KIUMIZW]VL��!����!� � <PM�KW]V\Za�_I[�QV�ZMKM[[QWV� \PM�;W^QM\=VQWV�PIL�TI]VKPML�;X]\VQS�IVL�IXXMIZML�\W�JM�_QVVQVO�\PM[XIKM�ZIKM� IVL�-Q[MVPW_MZ�_I[�NWZKML�\W�[MVL�NMLMZIT�\ZWWX[\W�4Q\\TM�:WKS� \W�MVNWZKM�I� NMLMZIT�LM[MOZMOI\QWV�XWTQKa� QV�LQKI\Q^M�WN �I�_QLMZ�\MV[QWV�W^MZ�KQ^QT�ZQOP\[�IKZW[[�\PM�KW]V\Za�

��

Page 15: QVO - Columbia Universitygelman/research/unpublished/...Jun 05, 2014  · i kw]xtm wn lmkilm[ wz tm[[ .wz m`iuxtm wvm wn \pm nmi\]zm[ wn \pm mizta li\i kqzki \pm ! [ ! [ _i[ \pm wj[mz^i\qwv

.QO]ZM �" <PM�8ZM[QLMV\QIT�)XXZW^IT�\QUM�[MZQM[� IVL�\PM�K]U]TI\Q^M�OMVMZI\QWVIT�MNNMK\[�WN �\PI\�[MZQM[� NWZ�-Q[MV�PW_MZ�:MX]JTQKIV[� JWZV�QV��!��� <PM�[MZQM[�Q[�LZI_V�\W�MUXPI[QbM�\PQ[�OMVMZI\QWV¼[�XMIS�aMIZ[�WN �[WKQITQbI\QWV�IKKWZLQVO�\W�\PM�IOM�_MQOP\[�NW]VL�Ja�\PM�UWLMT� ,IZS�JT]M�QVLQKI\M[�[\ZWVOTa�XZW�,MUWKZI\QK�aMIZ[� LIZS�ZMLNWZ�XZW�:MX]JTQKIV� IVL�[PILM[�WN �OZMa�QV�JM\_MMV� <PQ[�OMVMZI\QWV�UQ[[ML�UW[\�WN �\PM�.,: aMIZ[�IVL�_MZM[WKQITQbML�\PZW]OP����[\ZIQOP\�XZW�:MX]JTQKIV�aMIZ[� [XIVVQVO�\PM�MVL�WN �\PM�<Z]UIV�XZM[QLMVKa�IVL�MQOP\�aMIZ[WN �\PM�XWX]TIZ�:MX]JTQKIV�8ZM[QLMV\�-Q[MVPW_MZ� <PMQZ�XIZ\Q[IV�^W\QVO�\MVLMVKQM[�_MZM�[WUM_PI\�[\IJQTQbML�JIKS\W_IZL[�\PM�VM]\ZIT�OZMa�TQVM�Ja�\PM�XZW�,MUWKZI\QK��!��[� IVL�\PMa�ZMIKPML�I�ZW]OP�MY]QTQJZQ]U�Ja�\PM�MVL�WN\PM�6Q`WV�XZM[QLMVKa�

AM\�PQ[�IXXZW^IT�ZI\QVO[�LQXXML�WVTa�NWZ�I�[PWZ\�_PQTM� ZMIKP�QVO�I�JW\\WU�XWQV\�WN ��� �QV�5IZKP� �!� � IVL�ZMJW]VLQVOY]QKSTa�JIKS�\W�\PM���� � �ZIVOM� -Q[MVPW_MZ�_I[�IJTM�\WVI^QOI\M�\PM[M�XZWJTMU[� IVL�QV�[]U�PIL�IV�MVWZUW][Ta�XWX�]TIZ�XZM[QLMVKa� TMI^QVO�WNÅKM�_Q\P�I��! �IXXZW^IT�ZI\QVO�

<PM��!���OMVMZI\QWV� \PMV� PIL�M`XMZQMVKML���� [\ZIQOP\aMIZ[� WN � XZW�:MX]JTQKIV� XZM[QLMV\QIT� M^IT]I\QWV[� NZWUZW]OPTa�\PM�IOM[�WN ������� U]KP�_Q\PQV�\PM�XMIS�aMIZ[�WN �[W�

KQITQbI\QWV� <PM�QUXIK\�WN �\PQ[�XMZQWL�WV�\PMQZ�TWVO�\MZU�XZM[�QLMV\QIT�^W\QVO�XZMNMZMVKM[�Q[�IXXIZMV\�QV�\PM�JW\\WU�XIVMT�WN.QO]ZM �� 6W\QKM�\PM�K]Z^M¼[�[\MMX�I[KMV\� XMISQVO�I\�\PM�MVLWN �\PM�-Q[MVPW_MZ�ILUQVQ[\ZI\QWV� +WV\QV]QVO�WV�\PQ[�K]Z^M�\PM�3MVVMLa�IVL�2WPV[WV�aMIZ[� [\IJQTQbML� \PMQZ�^W\QVO� \MV�LMVKQM[�\W�I�LMOZMM� [PQN\QVO�\PMU�JIKS�\W_IZL[�\PM�UQLLTMOZMa�TQVM� <PW[M�XIZ\QK]TIZ�M^MV\[�IZM�JM[\�LM[KZQJML�QV�\PMVIZZI\Q^M� NWZ� \PM�VM`\�OMVMZI\QWV� J]\� \PM�UWLMT�LWM[� QVLQ�

��

Page 16: QVO - Columbia Universitygelman/research/unpublished/...Jun 05, 2014  · i kw]xtm wn lmkilm[ wz tm[[ .wz m`iuxtm wvm wn \pm nmi\]zm[ wn \pm mizta li\i kqzki \pm ! [ ! [ _i[ \pm wj[mz^i\qwv

KI\M� \PI\� \PM�XZW�,MUWKZI\QK��!��[� QVÆ]MVKML� \PM[M�^W\MZ[I[�_MTT� <PM�K]U]TI\Q^M�OMVMZI\QWV�MNNMK\�KWUM[�\W�I�ZW]OPMY]QTQJZQ]U�Ja�\PM�MVL�WN �\PM�6Q`WV�8ZM[QLMVKa� *a�\PM�UQL�!��[� \PQ[�KWPWZ\�_I[�XI[\�\PM�IOM�WN ���� IVL�\PM�UIRWZ�KPIZ�IK\MZQbI\QWV�WN �\PMQZ�XZM[QLMV\QIT�^W\QVO�XI\\MZV[�PIL�JMMV�[M\�<PM�K]Z^M�KWV\QV]M[�\W�_QOOTM�]X�IVL�LW_V� J]\�\PM�QUXIK\WN �M^MV\[�NZWU�\PQ[�XWQV\�NWZ_IZL�Q[�ZMTI\Q^MTa�[UITT�

<PM��!���KWPWZ\�KIV�\P][�JM[\�JM�LM[KZQJML�I[ -Q[MVPW_MZ:MX]JTQKIV[� \PW]OP� _M� [PW]TL� VW\� \ISM� \PM� \MZU� \WW� TQ\MZ�ITTa� )[�_M�PI^M�LM[KZQJML� \PQ[� OMVMZI\QWV�IVL�W\PMZ[� IZMVW\�\PM�JaXZWL]K\�WN �I�[QVOTM�aMIZ¸NWZ�QV[\IVKM� _PMV�\PMa\]ZV�� ¸WZ�WN �I�[QVOTM�XZM[QLMV\� :I\PMZ�\PMQZ�XZMNMZMVKM[ZMÆMK\�I�_MQOP\ML�[]UUI\QWV�WN �\PMQZ�N]TT�TQNM�M`XMZQMVKM�

*IJa�*WWUMZ[

?M� \]ZV�VM`\� \W� \PM��!��[� I�LMKILM�ÅTTML�_Q\P�I� [MZQM[�WNPQOPTa�LZIUI\QK�XWTQ\QKIT�M^MV\[�_Q\P�TWVO�TI[\QVO�QUXIK\�WV\PM�XZM[QLMV\QIT�TM^MT� )KKWZLQVO�\W�\PM�UWLMT� \PM�OMVMZI\QWVUW[\�QVÆ]MVKML�Ja�\PM[M�M^MV\[�_MZM�\PW[M�_M�OMVMZQKITTa�ZM�NMZ�\W�I[ *IJa�*WWUMZ[� IVL�\PMa�QV�\]ZV�IZM�MXQ\WUQbML�Ja�^W\�MZ[�JWZV�QV��!��� <PM�KWV[XQK]W][�XZW�,MUWKZI\QK�LQX�[MMVMIZTQMZ�_I[�IUWVO�\PM[M�^W\MZ[� IVL�QV�\PI\�[MV[M�\PQ[�OZW]XXZW^QLM[�I�OZMI\�LMIT�WN � \PM�^IZQI\QWV�QV�XZM[QLMV\QIT�^W\QVOXZMNMZMVKM[�[MMV�QV�\PM�LI\I[M\� )[�I�ZM[]T\� \PQ[�OZW]X� IVL\PM�M^MV\[�WN �\PM��!��[�W^MZITT� IZM�WN �XIZ\QK]TIZ�QUXWZ\IVKM\W�\PM�VIZZI\Q^M�

)[�KIV�JM�[MMV�QV�.QO]ZM � \PM�-Q[MVPW_MZ�aMIZ[�WKK]ZZML\WW�MIZTa�QV�\PMQZ�TQ^M[�\W�PI^M�TWVO�TI[\QVO�QVÆ]MVKM�WV�^W\QVOXZMNMZMVKM[� 1V[\MIL� \PMa�KIUM�WN �IOM�L]ZQVO�\PM�3MVVMLa�2WPV[WV� IVL� QUXWZ\IV\Ta� 6Q`WV�aMIZ[� 3MVVMLa� TQSM�-Q[MV�PW_MZ�JMNWZM�PQU� JMOIV�PQ[�XZM[QLMVKa�_Q\P�QUUMV[M�XWX�]TIZQ\a� ZMÆMK\ML�QV�PQ[�!� �IXXZW^IT�ZI\QVO� 0M�KIUM�QV\WWNÅKM�I\�I�\QUM�_PMV�\PM�XWTQ\QKIT�UWWL�WN �\PM�KW]V\Za�_I[�I\I�TQJMZIT�PQOP�XWQV\��;\QU[WV���!!��� IVL�PQ[�JWTL�¹6M_�.ZWV�\QMZº�IOMVLI�ZMÆMK\ML�\PI\�UWWL� 0Q[�LWUM[\QK�XWTQKa�OWIT[_MZM�_QLM�ZIVOQVO�IVL� ZMÆMK\ML�IV�WX\QUQ[U� QV�)UMZQKI¼[IJQTQ\QM[�QV�\PM�XW[\�?WZTL�?IZ�11 MZI¸IV�M`XIVLML�OW^MZV�UMV\�ZWTM�QV�KWUJI\\QVO�XW^MZ\a� QVKZMI[ML�NMLMZIT�IQL�\W�QU�XZW^M�ML]KI\QWV� UMLQKIT�KIZM�NWZ�\PM�MTLMZTa� XZWOZM[[QVO�\PMKI][M�WN �KQ^QT�ZQOP\[� IVL�UWZM� .IUW][Ta� 3MVVMLa�MUXPI�[QbML�\PM�QUXWZ\IVKM�WN �[KQMVKM�IVL�\MKPVWTWOa�IVL�KWUUQ\�\ML�\W�[MVLQVO�I�UIV�\W�\PM�UWWV�Ja�\PM�MVL�WN �\PM�LMKILM�)\�\PM�[IUM�\QUM� PQ[�[PWZ\�XZM[QLMVKa�_I[�KPIZIK\MZQbML�Ja

IV�]V][]ITTa�\]U]T\]W][�[MZQM[�WN �NWZMQOV�XWTQKa�M^MV\[� 0M_I[�I\�\PM�PMTU�L]ZQVO�\PM�NIQTML�*Ia�WN �8QO[�QV^I[QWV� IVL\PM�+]JIV�5Q[[QTM�+ZQ[Q[�_I[�XMZPIX[� \PM�KTW[M[\� \PM�_WZTLKIUM�\W�[MMQVO�\PM�+WTL�?IZ�\]ZV�PW\�

<PW]OP�PM�[]KKMMLML�QV�XI[[QVO�I�V]UJMZ�WN �PQ[�LWUM[\QKXWTQKa�QVQ\QI\Q^M[�IVL�QV�I^MZ\QVO�_IZ� 3MVVMLa¼[�[PWZ\�XZM[�QLMVKa�_I[�Ja�VW�UMIV[�IV�QZZMN]\IJTM�[]KKM[[� 5IVa�Y]M[�\QWVML�PQ[�[\ZMVO\P�I[�I�TMILMZ�QV�\PM�NIKM�WN �\PM�;W^QM\�=VQWV�IVL�PQ[�TQJMZIT�IOMVLI�_I[�I\�\QUM[�[\ITTML�QV�+WVOZM[[� 0Q[IXXZW^IT� ZI\QVO[�IZM� \P][� KPIZIK\MZQbML�Ja�I� [\MILa�LMKTQVMW^MZ�PQ[�\PZMM�aMIZ�XZM[QLMVKa� QV\MZZ]X\ML�Ja�I�[PWZ\�XW[Q\Q^MJ]Z[\�NWTTW_QVO�\PM�+]JIV�5Q[[QTM�+ZQ[Q[� 1VLMML� _PMV�IV�I[�[I[[QV¼[�J]TTM\�\ZIOQKITTa�MVLML�PQ[�XZM[QLMVKa�VMIZ�\PM�MVL�WN�!��� PQ[�IXXZW^IT�ZI\QVO[�_MZM�I\�\PMQZ�TW_M[\�XWQV\�I\��� �

1ZWVQKITTa� QV� [WUM� [MV[M� \PM� \ZIOQK� MVL� \W� \PM�3MVVMLaXZM[QLMVKa�UIa� PI^M� PMTXML� KMUMV\� PQ[� TMOIKa� 0Q[\WZQKITKW]V\MZNIK\]IT[�IZM�IT_Ia[�I�L]JQW][�XZWXW[Q\QWV¸J]\�XMZ�PIX[�3MVVMLa�_W]TL�PI^M�JMMV�I�ZMTI\Q^MTa�]VXWX]TIZ�XZM[�QLMV\� [PIKSTML�_Q\P�I�LMKTQVQVO�IXXZW^IT� ZI\QVO� [\Z]OOTQVO\W�XI[[�\PM�ZMUIQVLMZ�WN �PQ[�XWTQKQM[� 1V[\MIL�WN �\PQ[�]VÆI\\MZ�QVO�XWZ\ZIQ\� 3MVVMLa�Q[�_QLMTa�ZMUMUJMZML�NWZ�PQ[�KPIZQ[UI�QUIOM[�WN �PQ[�JMI]\QN]T�IVL�[WXPQ[\QKI\ML�NIUQTa� IVL�PQ[�WX�\QUQ[\QK�^Q[QWV�WN �\PM�N]\]ZM� .WZ�\PM JIJa�JWWUMZ OMVMZI\QWV�JWZV�QV��!���IVL�ZW]OPTa����aMIZ[�WTL�I\�\PM�\QUM�WN �PQ[�I[�[I[[QVI\QWV� []ZMTa�\PM[M�IZM�\PM�[\ZWVOMZ�TI[\QVO�UMUWZQM[�

9]IV\Q\I\Q^MTa� 3MVVMLa¼[�I[[I[[QVI\QWV�LZW^M�I�]VQY]M�WK�K]ZZMVKM� QV� \PM�)XXZW^IT� \QUM� [MZQM[¸\_W� MVWZUW][� XWX�]TIZQ\a� [XQSM[� QV� TM[[� \PIV� I� \PZMM�aMIZ� \QUM� [XIV� ?PMV8ZM[QLMV\�2WPV[WV�\WWS�\PM�PMTU�I\�\PM�MVL�WN ��!��� I�[MK�WVL�,MUWKZI\QK�8ZM[QLMV\�R]UXML�IJW^M�\PM�!� �ZIVOM� \PQ[\QUM� \W� !� � IXXZW^IT� \PM� PQOPM[\� QV� \PM� [MZQM[� 2WPV[WV\WWS�\PQ[�WXXWZ\]VQ\a� ITWVO�_Q\P�PQ[�[QVO]TIZ�IJQTQ\QM[�I[�\PMY]QV\M[[MV\QIT�?I[PQVO\WV�QV[QLMZ� \W�IKPQM^M�3MVVMLa¼[�OWIT[QV�\PM�VIUM�WN �\PM�NITTMV�XZM[QLMV\� *]QTLQVO�NZWU�3MVVMLa¼[¹6M_�.ZWV\QMZ�º PM�_IV\ML�\W�VW\�WVTa�XI[[�I�[M\�WN �LQ[KZM\MXWTQKa�XZWXW[IT[� J]\�\W�J]QTL�)UMZQKI�QV\W�I�/ZMI\�;WKQM\a"

<PM�/ZMI\�;WKQM\a�ZM[\[�WV�IJ]VLIVKM�IVL�TQJMZ\aNWZ�ITT� 1\�LMUIVL[�IV�MVL�\W�XW^MZ\a�IVL�ZIKQITQVR][\QKM� \W�_PQKP�_M�IZM�\W\ITTa�KWUUQ\\ML�QV�W]Z\QUM� *]\�\PI\�Q[�R][\�\PM�JMOQVVQVO� <PM�/ZMI\�;W�KQM\a�Q[�I�XTIKM�_PMZM�M^MZa�KPQTL�KIV�ÅVL�SVW_T�MLOM�\W�MVZQKP�PQ[�UQVL�IVL�\W�MVTIZOM�PQ[�\ITMV\[�1\�Q[�I�XTIKM�_PMZM�TMQ[]ZM�Q[�I�_MTKWUM�KPIVKM�\W

��

Page 17: QVO - Columbia Universitygelman/research/unpublished/...Jun 05, 2014  · i kw]xtm wn lmkilm[ wz tm[[ .wz m`iuxtm wvm wn \pm nmi\]zm[ wn \pm mizta li\i kqzki \pm ! [ ! [ _i[ \pm wj[mz^i\qwv

.QO]ZM " <PM�OMVMZI\QWV�_M�ZMNMZ�\W�I[�*IJa�*WWUMZ[�IZM�JM[\�MXQ\WUQbML�Ja�\PM�KWPWZ\�JWZV�QV��!��� _PW[MXZM[QLMV\QIT�XWTQ\QKIT�M^MV\[�IZM�MUXPI[QbML�PMZM� <WW�aW]VO�\W�JM�PQOPTa�QVÆ]MVKML�Ja�\PM�-Q[MVPW_MZ�aMIZ[� \PMaM`XMZQMVKML�IV�QV\MV[M�XMZQWL�WN �XZW�,MUWKZI\QK�[MV\QUMV\�L]ZQVO�\PM��!��[� PQOPTQOP\ML�Ja�\PM�I[[I[[QVI\QWVWN �8ZM[QLMV\�3MVVMLa�IVL�\PM�[]J[MY]MV\�/ZMI\�;WKQM\a�TMOQ[TI\QWV�XI[[ML�Ja�8ZM[QLMV\�2WPV[WV� )N\MZ��!� �PW_M^MZ� ZW]OPTa����aMIZ[�WN �VMIZ�KWV[Q[\MV\�XZW�:MX]JTQKIV�M^MV\[�VM]\ZITQbML�\PMQZ�XZM[QLMV\QIT�^W\QVO�XZMNMZMVKM[W^MZ�\PI\�TWVO�[\ZM\KP�WN �\QUM�

J]QTL�IVL�ZMÆMK\� VW\�I�NMIZML�KI][M�WN �JWZMLWUIVL�ZM[\TM[[VM[[� 1\�Q[�I�XTIKM�_PMZM�\PM�KQ\a�WN �UIV[MZ^M[�VW\�WVTa�\PM�VMML[�WN �\PM�JWLa�IVL�\PM�LM�UIVL[�WN �KWUUMZKM�J]\�\PM�LM[QZM�NWZ�JMI]\a�IVL\PM�P]VOMZ�NWZ�KWUU]VQ\a� 1\�Q[�I�XTIKM�_PMZM�UIVKIV�ZMVM_�KWV\IK\�_Q\P�VI\]ZM� 1\�Q[�I�XTIKM�_PQKPPWVWZ[� KZMI\QWV� NWZ� Q\[� W_V� [ISM� IVL� NWZ�_PI\� Q[ILL[�\W�\PM�]VLMZ[\IVLQVO�WN �\PM�ZIKM� 1\�Q[�I�XTIKM_PMZM�UMV�IZM�UWZM�KWVKMZVML�_Q\P�\PM�Y]ITQ\a�WN\PMQZ�OWIT[�\PIV�\PM�Y]IV\Q\a�WN �\PMQZ�OWWL[� *]\

UW[\�WN �ITT� \PM�/ZMI\� ;WKQM\a� Q[� VW\� I� [INM� PIZ�JWZ� I� ZM[\QVO� XTIKM� I� ÅVIT� WJRMK\Q^M� I� ÅVQ[PML_WZS� 1\�Q[�I�KPITTMVOM�KWV[\IV\Ta�ZMVM_ML� JMKSWV�QVO�][�\W_IZL�I�LM[\QVa�_PMZM�\PM�UMIVQVO�WN �W]ZTQ^M[�UI\KPM[�\PM�UIZ^MTW][�XZWL]K\[�WN �W]Z�TIJWZ��2WPV[WV���!���

.WZ� I� \QUM� Q\� [MMUML� I[� \PW]OP� 2WPV[WV� UQOP\� []K�KMML� QV� XI[[QVO� TMOQ[TI\QWV� \W�UI\KP� PQ[� TWN\a� ZPM\WZQK� 0MXI[[ML�\PM�+Q^QT�:QOP\[�)K\�WN ��!���IVL�\PM�>W\QVO�:QOP\[)K\�WN ��!��¸\PM� NW]VLI\QWVIT�XQMKM[�WN � NMLMZIT� TMOQ[TI\QWV

��

Page 18: QVO - Columbia Universitygelman/research/unpublished/...Jun 05, 2014  · i kw]xtm wn lmkilm[ wz tm[[ .wz m`iuxtm wvm wn \pm nmi\]zm[ wn \pm mizta li\i kqzki \pm ! [ ! [ _i[ \pm wj[mz^i\qwv

WN � \PM�KQ^QT�ZQOP\[�MZI¸W]\TI_QVO�LQ[KZQUQVI\WZa�XWTQKQM[� QV[KPWWT[� X]JTQK�XTIKM[� IVL�\PM�^W\QVO�JWW\P� 0M�M[\IJTQ[PMLTIVLUIZS�XZWOZIU[� \W� IQL� TW_� QVKWUM� NIUQTQM[� IVL� \PM� MT�LMZTa¸5MLQKIZM�IVL�5MLQKIQL� \PM�NMLMZIT�NWWL�[\IUX�XZW�OZIU� \PM�,MXIZ\UMV\�WN �0W][QVO�IVL�=ZJIV�,M^MTWXUMV\�0=,���IVL�W\PMZ[� 0M�NWK][ML�WV�ML]KI\QWV�\PZW]OP�XZW�OZIU[�[]KP�I[�8ZWRMK\�0MIL�;\IZ\� M`XIVLML�[\]LMV\� TWIV[�QVKZMI[ML�NMLMZIT�N]VLQVO�\W�]VQ^MZ[Q\QM[� IVL�\PM�VWVOW^MZV�UMV\IT�+WZXWZI\QWV�NWZ�8]JTK�*ZWILKI[\QVO� )VL�PM�XI[[MLTMOQ[TI\QWV� \W� XZW\MK\� \PM� MV^QZWVUMV\� ZMO]TI\QVO� XWTT]\QWV\PZW]OP�\PM�?I\MZ�9]ITQ\a�)K\�IVL�)QZ�9]ITQ\a�)K\� IVL�M[�\IJTQ[PQVO�\PM�VI\QWVIT�_QTLMZVM[[� ZQ^MZ[� IVL�\ZIQT[�[a[\MU[���1V�[]U� PQ[�TMOQ[TI\Q^M�IKKWUXTQ[PUMV\[�_MZM�OIZOIV\]IV� IVL\PM�TMOIKa�WN �\PW[M�XZWOZIU[�Q[�NMT\�\W�\PQ[�LIa�

2WPV[WV�IT[W�MVRWaML�QUUMV[M�XWX]TIZQ\a�NWZ�IV�M`\MVLMLXMZQWL�WN �\QUM� I[�ZMÆMK\ML�QV�PQ[�PQOP�IXXZW^IT�ZI\QVO[�IVLPQ[�TIVL[TQLM�MTMK\QWV�^QK\WZa�W^MZ�*IZZa�/WTL_I\MZ�QV��!���2WPV[WV¼[�XZM[QLMVKa� IVL�PQ[�TMOIKa� PW_M^MZ� _MZM�UIZZML�Ja\PM�[\IZ\�WN �\PM�>QM\VIU�?IZ�IVL�QVKZMI[QVO�ZIKQIT�IVL�[WKQIT\MV[QWV�QV�\PM�TI\M��!��[� *a��!��� PQ[�IXXZW^IT�ZI\QVO[�PILNITTMV�QV\W�\PM������ �ZIVOM� IVL�Ja��!� �\PM�WVKM�XW_MZN]T8ZM[QLMV\�IVL�TQNMTWVO�XWTQ\QKQIV�LMKQLML�IOIQV[\�Z]VVQVO�NWZZMMTMK\QWV�

1\� Q[� JW\P� QV\MZM[\QVO� IVL� QTT]UQVI\QVO� \W� ZMÆMK\� WV� PW_\PM[M�M^MV\[�[PIXML�\PM�XZM[QLMV\QIT�^W\QVO�\MVLMVKQM[�WN �\PMJIJa� JWWUMZ OMVMZI\QWV� I[�LM[KZQJML�PMZM� <PM�UIRWZQ\a�WN\PM[M�M^MV\[�IK\]ITTa�\WWS�XTIKM�JMNWZM�\PMQZ�aMIZ[�WN �XMIS�[W�KQITQbI\QWV� <PM� [\ZWVO�XZW�,MUWKZI\QK� aMIZ[� QV� \PM� [MV[MWN �XZM[QLMV\QIT�IXXZW^IT�ZI\QVO[� _MZM��!����!��� _PMV�\PM[M^W\MZ[� JWZV�QV��!��� _MZM�ZW]OPTa�!����aMIZ[�WTL� )T\PW]OP\PQ[� Q[� R][\� JMNWZM� \PM�XMIS� aMIZ[� ZMKITT� NZWU�.QO]ZM \PI\\PM[M�M^MV\[�[\QTT�PIL�I�[]J[\IV\QIT�K]U]TI\Q^M�QUXIK\�WV�\PMQZXZM[QLMV\QIT�^W\QVO�\MVLMVKQM[� )[�_M�[\I\ML�MIZTQMZ� \PM�IOM[WN �������IZM�\PM�[\ZWVOM[\� J]\�\PMa�IZM�VW\�\PM�WVTa�aMIZ[�\PI\UI\\MZ� 0MZM� \PM�ZMTI\Q^MTa�TIZOM�_MQOP\[�NZWU�IOM�!���� QVKWUJQVI\QWV�_Q\P�\PM�XIZ\QK]TIZTa�PQOP�,MUWKZI\QK�IXXZW^ITZI\QVO[�WN �\PI\�MZI� _MZM�MVW]OP�\W�[_Ia�\PM[M�^W\MZ[�NWZ�UIVaaMIZ[�\W�KWUM�

<PM�aMIZ[�IN\MZ�2WPV[WV¼[�LMKTQVM� NZWU��!���WV_IZL� ZM�UIQV�QV[\Z]K\Q^M� <PQ[�_I[�I�XIZ\QK]TIZTa�QV\MZM[\QVO�\QUM�QV)UMZQKIV�PQ[\WZa� M[XMKQITTa�NWZ�aW]VO�XMWXTM�QV�\PMQZ�\MMVIOM

��) T Q [ \� W N � \PM[M� XW T QK QM [� _MZM� X]T TML� N ZWU� \PM� _MJ[ Q \M___�XZM[QLMV\QIT\QUMTQVM�WZO�

aMIZ[� L]M�\W�\PM�IV\Q�>QM\VIU�XZW\M[\�UW^MUMV\�IVL�\PM�ZQ[MWN �\PM�KW]V\MZ�K]T\]ZM� 2WPV[WV¼[�IXXZW^IT�ZI\QVO�¹WVTaº�NMTT\W�IJW]\��� �I\�\PI\�\QUM� QUXTaQVO� QV�\PM�UWLMT� JIZMTa�IVaXW[Q\Q^M�WZ�VMOI\Q^M�KPIVOM�QV�TWVO�\MZU�XZM[QLMV\QIT�^W\QVOXZMNMZMVKM[� <PQVSQVO�W]\[QLM� \PM�UWLMT� \PW]OP� Q\� [MMU[]VY]M[\QWVIJTM� \PI\�aW]VO�XMWXTM�PIL�VMOI\Q^M� NMMTQVO[� \W�_IZL[�2WPV[WV�I\�\PM�\QUM� ;W�PW_�KIV�_M�IKKW]V\�NWZ�\PQ['

<PMZM� IZM� \_W� ZM[XWV[M[� .QZ[\� _M� LW� VW\� KTIQU� \PI\\PM�UWLMT�XMZNMK\Ta� KIX\]ZM[�ITT� I[XMK\[�WN �XZM[QLMV\QIT�PQ[�\WZa� WVTa� \PI\� \PM� )XXZW^IT� [MZQM[� IVL� \PM� I[[WKQI\ML� IOM_MQOP\[� IZM� I� OWWL� IXXZW`QUI\QWV� \W� \PM� PQ[\WZQKIT� M^MV\[\PI\�[PIXML�TWVO�\MZU�^W\QVO�XZMNMZMVKM[� 1V�\PQ[�ZMOIZL� LM�[XQ\M�\PQ[�IXXIZMV\�_MISVM[[�QV�\PM�UWLMT� \PM�ÅVIT�ZM[]T\[�[\QTT[MMU�WV�\IZOM\� _Q\P�\PQ[�OMVMZI\QWV�MVLQVO�]X�ZMTI\Q^MTa�XZW�,MUWKZI\QK�

;MKWVL� \PM�>QM\VIU�?IZ�IVL�\PQ[�OMVMZI\QWV¼[�ZM[XWV[M\W�Q\�Q[�ZI\PMZ�KWUXTQKI\ML� 1V��!���IVL��!� � >QM\VIU�_I[2WPV[WV¼[�_IZ� *]\�UW^QVO�QV\W�\PM��!��[�Q\�JMKIUM�6Q`WV¼[_IZ� \W�UIVa� IVL� \PM�XZW\M[\[� [PQN\ML� NZWU�IV\Q�2WPV[WV� \WIV\Q�6Q`WV� 1\�Q[�XTI][QJTM�\PI\�\PQ[�[PQN\�_I[�XIZ\QK]TIZTa�XZW�VW]VKML�IUWVO[\�\PM��!���OMVMZI\QWV� <PMa�_MZM�VW\�aM\�� aMIZ[�WTL�]VLMZ�2WPV[WV�IVL�_MZM�\P][�I\�PQOPM[\�ZQ[S�WN �JMQVOLZIN\ML�Ja�6Q`WV� )VL�_PMV�6Q`WV�_WV�\PM��!� �MTMK\QWVJa� [XMISQVO� \W� \PM�¹[QTMV\�UIRWZQ\a�º PM�LQL� [W�Ja�M`XTQKQ\TaLMVW]VKQVO�\PM�XWTQ\QKIT�KWVKMZV[�WN �\PM[M�XIZ\QK]TIZ�^W\MZ[�aW]VO�XMWXTM�_PW�XZW\M[\ML�QV�\PM��!��[��ITWVO�_Q\P�UQVWZQ�\QM[��

<PM�QUXTQKI\QWV[�WN �\PQ[�KIV�JM�[MMV�QV�XIZ\�QV�6Q`WV¼[��!��ZMMTMK\QWV� KIUXIQOV� <PM� <_MV\a�;Q`\P� )UMVLUMV\� PILR][\�XI[[ML� [M\\QVO�\PM�VI\QWVIT�^W\QVO�IOM�\W�� � )KKWZLQVO\W�\PM�LI\I� _PQ\M�^W\MZ[�]VLMZ�\PM�IOM�WN �����ÅZ[\�\QUM�^W\�MZ[�QV��!����[]XXWZ\ML�6Q`WV�I\�WVTa��� ��N = 1242�� QVKWUXIZQ[WV�\W��� �NWZ�_PQ\M�^W\MZ[����WZ�WTLMZ��N = 8162��<PQ[����XWQV\�OIX�Q[�Ja�NIZ�\PM�TIZOM[\� QV�\PM�LI\I[M\� VM^MZM`KMMLQVO�!�XWQV\[�QV�IVa�W\PMZ�MTMK\QWV�

,M[XQ\M�\PQ[�IV\Q�6Q`WV�[MV\QUMV\� \PM�K]U]TI\Q^M�K]Z^M�WN.QO]ZM []OOM[\[�\PI\��!� �_I[�\PM�PQOP�XWQV\�WN �\PQ[�OMVMZ�I\QWV¼[�XZW�,MUWKZI\QK�NMMTQVO[� 6Q`WV�_I[�QV�NIK\�I�XWX]TIZXZM[QLMV\�NWZ�I�\QUM� IVL�\PM�[\IZ\�WN �PQ[�ILUQVQ[\ZI\QWV�][P�MZML� QV�ZW]OPTa����aMIZ[�WN �ITUW[\�MV\QZMTa�XZW�:MX]JTQKIVXZM[QLMV\QIT� XMZNWZUIVKM� .W]Z�WN � \PM�VM`\�Å^M�XZM[QLMV\[_MZM�:MX]JTQKIV[� IVL�_Q\P�I�NM_�[PWZ\�\MZU�M`KMX\QWV[� ITTWN � \PW[M�aMIZ[�_MZM� QV� \PM�:MX]JTQKIV[¼� NI^WZ� )[� I� ZM[]T\�

��

Page 19: QVO - Columbia Universitygelman/research/unpublished/...Jun 05, 2014  · i kw]xtm wn lmkilm[ wz tm[[ .wz m`iuxtm wvm wn \pm nmi\]zm[ wn \pm mizta li\i kqzki \pm ! [ ! [ _i[ \pm wj[mz^i\qwv

\PM�K]U]TI\Q^M�K]Z^M�NMI\]ZM[�I�[TW_�IVL�[\MILa�QVKTQVM�W^MZ\PI\�XMZQWL� *a�\PM�\QUM�8ZM[QLMV\�+TQV\WV�KIUM�QV\W�WNÅKMQV��!!�� \PQ[�KWPWZ\� I\����aMIZ[�WN �IOM� PIL�ZMIKPML�I�[\MILa[\I\M�IZW]VL�\PM�VM]\ZIT�OZMa�TQVM� ;QVKM�\PMV� \PMQZ�OMVMZITTMIVQVO[�PI^M�JMMV�M[[MV\QITTa�VM]\ZIT� VMQ\PMZ�LMKQLMLTa�XZW�,MUWKZI\�VWZ�XZW�:MX]JTQKIV� <PQ[� Q\�[PW]TL�JM�VW\ML� Q[QV�KWV\ZI[\�\W�JW\P�\PM -Q[MVPW_MZ�:MX]JTQKIV[� LM[KZQJML�MIZ�TQMZ� IVL�\PM�OMVMZI\QWV�_M�LM[KZQJM�I[ :MIOIV�+WV[MZ^I\Q^M[� \W_PQKP�_M�\]ZV�VM`\�

:MIOIV�+WV[MZ^I\Q^M[

1\�Q[� QV�[WUM�[MV[M� I�KWQVKQLMVKM�\PI\�\PM�VM`\�OMVMZI\QWV�WN^W\MZ[�Q[�JM[\�LM[KZQJML�Ja�\PW[M�JWZV�QV��!� � \PM�aMIZ�WN �[]KP\]ZUWQT�IVL�KPIVOM�IUWVO�\PM�JIJa�JWWUMZ[� 7V�\PM�W\PMZPIVL� \PQ[�XIZ\QK]TIZ�JQZ\P�aMIZ�MV[]ZM[�VW� QVÆ]MVKM�WN � \PM3MVVMLa�IVL�2WPV[WV�aMIZ[�WV�\PQ[�:MX]JTQKIV�KWPWZ\¼[�TWVO\MZU�^W\QVO�XZMNMZMVKM[� ]VLMZ�\PM�UWLMT� <PMQZ�)XXZW^IT[MZQM[�Q[�[PW_V�QV�.QO]ZM !�

.WZ� \PQ[� OMVMZI\QWV� JW\P� \PM� XWTIZQbML� 6Q`WV� XZM[Q�LMVKa¸KPIZIK\MZQbML�Ja� aMIZ[� WN � PQOP�XWX]TIZQ\a� NWTTW_MLJa� \PM�LMX\P[�WN �?I\MZOI\M¸IVL� \PM�UQLLTQVO�.WZL�XZM[Q�LMVKa�PIL� TQ\\TM� QUXIK\� <PMQZ�XWTQ\QKIT� [WKQITQbI\QWV� [MMU[\W�PI^M�[\IZ\ML�_Q\P�8ZM[QLMV\�+IZ\MZ� 4QSM�\PW[M�JMNWZM�PQU�PM�JMOIV�PQ[�\MZU�_Q\P�PQOP�XWX]TIZQ\a� J]\�PQ[�ZI\QVO[�Y]QKSTaL_QVLTML�I[�IL^MZ[M�XWTQ\QKIT�M^MV\[�W^MZ\WWS�PQ[�XZM[QLMVKa�*a�\PM�\QUM�PM�TMN\�WNÅKM� IV�MVMZOa�KZQ[Q[� [\IOÆI\QWV� IVL�\PM1ZIV�PW[\IOM�KZQ[Q[� IUWVO�W\PMZ�M^MV\[� PIL�TMN\�PQU�QV�\PM����� �ZIVOM�

<PQ[� TML� QV\W�8ZM[QLMV\�:MIOIV¼[�KIUXIQOV�IVL�PQ[�WX\Q�UQ[\QK�^Q[QWV�WN �)UMZQKI�I[�I�[PQVQVO�KQ\a�WV�I�PQTT� <PW]OPPQ[�MIZTa�aMIZ[�_MZM�LMÅVML�Ja�I�TIKS�WN �MKWVWUQK�ZMKW^MZaIVL�\PM�:MX]JTQKIV[¼�LMNMI\[�QV�\PM��! ��UQL\MZU�MTMK\QWV[�:MIOIV¼[�XWX]TIZQ\a�LQXXML�JMTW_��� �NWZ�WVTa�I�ZMTI\Q^MTa[PWZ\�XMZQWL� <PM�ZMKW^MZa�PQ\�N]TT�[_QVO�[PWZ\Ta�\PMZMIN\MZ�IVL�:MIOIV� _PW[M�KIUXIQOV�NIUW][Ta�LMKTIZML�\PI\�Q\�_I[¹5WZVQVO� QV�)UMZQKIº�IOIQV� _I[� ZMMTMK\ML� QV�I� TIVL[TQLM�_QVVQVO��!�WN ����[\I\M[� <PQ[�XW_MZN]T�QUIOMZa�IVL�\PM�IX�XIZMV\Ta�W^MZ_PMTUQVO�[]XXWZ\�WN � \PM�)UMZQKIV�XMWXTM�VWLW]J\�PIL�I�XW_MZN]T�QUXIK\�WV�\PM�aW]VO�KWPWZ\� _PW� ��aMIZ[�WTL�I\�\PM�\QUM� _MZM�[Y]IZMTa�QV�\PM�UQLLTM�WN �\PMQZ�XMISaMIZ[�WN �XWTQ\QKIT�[WKQITQbI\QWV� ,M[XQ\M�\PM�1ZIV�+WV\ZI�[KIV�LIT�IVL�JITTWWVQVO�LMÅKQ\[�VMIZ�\PM�MVL�WN �PQ[�[MKWVL�\MZU�:MIOIV¼[�¹:M^WT]\QWVº�MVLML�_Q\P�PQ[�XZM[QLMVKa�I\�I��

IXXZW^IT�ZI\QVO�

8ZM[QLMV\�*][P�1¼[�XZM[QLMVKa�[MMU[�\W�PI^M�M`\MVLML�XZW�:MX]JTQKIV� [MV\QUMV\� QV�_Ia[� \PI\�IZM� XMZPIX[� ]VLMZM[\Q�UI\ML�QV�\PM�KWTTMK\Q^M�X]JTQK�UMUWZa� .ZWU�I�NWZMQOV�XWTQKaXMZ[XMK\Q^M� *][P�_I[�MVWZUW][Ta�[]KKM[[N]T� <PM�NITT�WN �\PM*MZTQV�?ITT�IVL�\PM�MVL�WN �\PM�+WTL�?IZ�JW\P�KIUM�]VLMZ�PQ[_I\KP� VW\�:MIOIV¼[� IVL�7XMZI\QWV�,M[MZ\�;\WZU�_I[�I�\M[�\IUMV\�\W�\PM�XW_MZ�WN �)UMZQKIV�TMILMZ[PQX�QV�\PM�XW[\�+WTL?IZ�MZI� )[�I�ZM[]T\�WN �\PM[M�[]KKM[[M[� *][P¼[�ZI\QVO[�ZIZMTaNMTT�JMTW_� � �NWZ�W^MZ���aMIZ[� WVTa�LQXXQVO�JMTW_��� �ZQOP\VMIZ�\PM�MVL�WN �PQ[�\MZU�

=VNWZ\]VI\MTa�NWZ�PQ[�XMZ[WVIT�TMOIKa� MKWVWUQK�XZWJTMU[I\�PWUM�LWWUML�PQ[�XZM[QLMVKa� <PM�+TQV\WV�KIUXIQOV�LM�KTIZML� ¹1\¼[�\PM�-KWVWUa� ;\]XQL�º IVL�_Q\P�\PQ[�I[�\PMQZ�NW�K][� \PMa�_WV�\PM�XZM[QLMVKa�JIKS�\W�\PM�,MUWKZI\[�QV��!!��MVLQVO�W^MZ�I�LMKILM�WN �VMIZTa�KWV\QV]W][�XZW�:MX]JTQKIV��WZIV\Q�,MUWKZI\�]VLMZ�8ZM[QLMV\�+IZ\MZ��[MV\QUMV\� <PM�XZW�,MUWKZI\QK�+TQV\WV�aMIZ[�VM]\ZITQbML�\PQ[�OMVMZI\QWV¼[�TWVO\MZU�XZMNMZMVKM[�\W�I�KMZ\IQV�LMOZMM� J]\�\PMa�_MZM�ZW]OPTa���aMIZ[�WTL� XI[\�\PM�IOM�WN �XMIS�[WKQITQbI\QWV� Ja�\PM�\QUM+TQV\WV�ZMIKPML�PQ[�XMIS�XWX]TIZQ\a�QV�\PM�TI\M��!!�[�

4WWSQVO�I\�.QO]ZM !� Q\�Q[�XMZPIX[�]VNIQZ�\W�TIJMT�\PQ[�OMVMZ�I\QWV�I[ :MIOIV QV[\MIL�WN *][P�+WV[MZ^I\Q^M[� J]\�IVaJWLa�_Q\PI�XI[[QVO�NIUQTQIZQ\a�WN �KWV\MUXWZIZa�)UMZQKIV�XWTQ\QK[�KIVZMKWOVQbM�\PM�\MZU¸:MIOIV�KWV\QV]M[�\W�JM�TI]LML�\W�\PQ[LIa�NWZ�PQ[�NWZMQOV�XWTQKa�\W]OPVM[[� NWZ�XI[[QVO�KWV[MZ^I\Q^MMKWVWUQK�TMOQ[TI\QWV� IVL�NWZ�_QVVQVO�I�TIVL[TQLM�ZMMTMK\QWV�QV�! �� *][P� _PW�NWTTW_ML�\PZW]OP�WV�:MIOIV¼[�NWZMQOV�XWT�QKa�ZPM\WZQK�IVL�[]KKM[[N]TTa�TML�\PM�=�;��QV\W�\PM�XW[\�+WTL?IZ�MZI� Q[�VW\�LQ[K][[ML�I[�NWVLTa�Ja�\PM�:MX]JTQKIV�XIZ\aNIQ\PN]T� :MOIZLTM[[� \PMQZ� RWQV\� ZMQOV�I[�XWX]TIZ�XZM[QLMV\[KMZ\IQVTa�[MMU[�\W�PI^M�TMN\�I�XW_MZN]T�TMOIKa� M[XMKQITTa�NWZ\PQ[�OMVMZI\QWV�

/MVMZI\QWV�A IVL�5QTTMVQIT[

.WZ�\PM�TI[\�OZW]X� JWZV�QV��! �� \PMZM�Q[�VW\�U]KP�LI\I�_Q\P_PQKP�\W�_WZS� I[�\PMa�WVTa�PI^M����aMIZ[�WN �XWTQ\QKIT�M`XM�ZQMVKM�Ja�\PM������MTMK\QWV[� \PM�TI\M[\�QV�\PM�LI\I[M\� *]\�QV.QO]ZM ��� \PM�XZM[QLMV\QIT�QVÆ]MVKM[�\PI\�PI^M�[PIXML�\PMQZ^W\QVO�XZMNMZMVKM[�\P][�NIZ�IZM�[MMV�KTMIZTa� 1N �\PM�ZM[]T\[�WN �\PMUWLMT�PWTL� Q\�Q[�TQSMTa�\PI\�\PM[M�aMIZ[�_QTT�ZMUIQV�QVÆ]MV\QITW^MZ�\PM�ZMUIQVLMZ�WN �\PMQZ�TQ^M[�

.WZ�\PQ[�OMVMZI\QWV� \PM�]VKMZ\IQV\a�WN �\PM�+WTL�?IZ�Q[�TWVO

Page 20: QVO - Columbia Universitygelman/research/unpublished/...Jun 05, 2014  · i kw]xtm wn lmkilm[ wz tm[[ .wz m`iuxtm wvm wn \pm nmi\]zm[ wn \pm mizta li\i kqzki \pm ! [ ! [ _i[ \pm wj[mz^i\qwv

.QO]ZM !" <PM�)XXZW^IT�[MZQM[�I[�[MMV�Ja�\PM�OMVMZI\QWV�_M�KITT�:MIOIV�+WV[MZ^I\Q^M[� JM[\�MXQ\WUQbML�Ja�\PMKWPWZ\�JWZV�QV��!� � <PQ[�OMVMZI\QWV�UQ[[ML�\PM�3MVVMLa�IVL�2WPV[WV�aMIZ[�MV\QZMTa� IVL�\PMQZ�XMIS�[WKQITQbI\QWVNMTT�]VLMZ�\PM�XWX]TIZ�:MX]JTQKIV�8ZM[QLMV\[�:MIOIV�IVL�*][P�1��*a�\PM�\QUM�\PM�,MUWKZI\QK�8ZM[QLMV\�+TQV\WVZMIKPML�PQ[�XMIS�XWX]TIZQ\a�QV�\PM�TI\M��!!�[� \PMa�_MZM�ITZMILa�ZW]OPTa����aMIZ[�WTL�

OWVM� IVL�\PM�NWZMQOV�XWTQKa�[]KKM[[M[�WN �\PM�:MIOIV�IVL�*][PILUQVQ[\ZI\QWV[� \PW]OP�LQ[K][[ML�I\�\QUM[�QV�KWV\MUXWZIZaXWTQ\QKIT�LQ[KW]Z[M� IZM�UMUWZQM[�WN �W\PMZ�OMVMZI\QWV[¼�TQ^M[�VW\�WN �\PMQZ�W_V� 1VLMML� \PM�ÅZ[\�XZM[QLMV\�\W�QVÆ]MVKM�\PMQZ^W\QVO�XI\\MZV[�QV�I�[]J[\IV\QIT�_Ia�Q[�\PM�,MUWKZI\QK�8ZM[Q�LMV\�+TQV\WV� +TQV\WV¼[�JQOOM[\�XWTQ\QKIT�LMNMI\� QV�\PM�NIKM�WN\PM�:MX]JTQKIV[¼�+WV\ZIK\�_Q\P�)UMZQKI� \WWS�XTIKM�QV��!!�_PMV�\PM[M�^W\MZ[�_MZM�WVTa�!�aMIZ[�WTL� <PMa�MV\MZML�\PMQZXMIS�[WKQITQbI\QWV�aMIZ[�QV��!!!¸\PM�NMLMZIT�LMÅKQ\�PIL�JMMVMZILQKI\ML� \PM�KW]V\Za�_I[�M`XMZQMVKQVO�I�XMZQWL�WN �QUUMV[MMKWVWUQK�OZW_\P�IVL�XZW[XMZQ\a� IVL�)UMZQKI�ZMUIQVML�\PM

TMILMZ�WN �\PM�NZMM�_WZTL�IVL�\PM�OTWJM¼[�TWVM�[]XMZXW_MZ� ,M�[XQ\M� PQ[� QUXMIKPUMV\� IVL� \PM�5WVQKI� 4M_QV[Sa� [KIVLIT�+TQV\WV�PIL�OIZVMZML�XW[Q\Q^M� IXXZW^IT� ZI\QVO[� NWZ� ZW]OPTaNW]Z�[\ZIQOP\�aMIZ[� IVL�PM�SMX\�PQ[�XWX]TIZQ\a�\PZW]OP�\PM�ZM�UIQVLMZ�WN �PQ[�\MZU� MVLQVO�PQ[�XZM[QLMVKa�_Q\P�I��� �ZI\QVO�

1V������ \PM�:MX]JTQKIV�*][P�11 \WWS�WNÅKM� IVL�\P][�JM�OIV�WVM�WN �\PM�UW[\�\]ZJ]TMV\�XZM[QLMVKQM[�QV�)UMZQKIV�PQ[�\WZa� +IUXIQOVQVO�I[�I�UWLMZI\M�IVL�¹+WUXI[[QWVI\M�+WV�[MZ^I\Q^M�º *][P�11 JMKIUM�I�LMMXTa�XWTIZQbQVO�IVL�]T\QUI\MTa]VXWX]TIZ�ÅO]ZM� <PM�\MZZWZQ[\�I\\IKS[�WN �!����LZW^M�PQ[�XWX�]TIZQ\a� \W� !� � I� \QUM� QV�_PQKP� \PM� aW]VOM[\� KWPWZ\� \MU�

�!

Page 21: QVO - Columbia Universitygelman/research/unpublished/...Jun 05, 2014  · i kw]xtm wn lmkilm[ wz tm[[ .wz m`iuxtm wvm wn \pm nmi\]zm[ wn \pm mizta li\i kqzki \pm ! [ ! [ _i[ \pm wj[mz^i\qwv

.QO]ZM ��" <PM�)XXZW^IT� [MZQM[�I[� [MMV�Ja� \PM� TI[\� OMVMZI\QWV� ZMNMZZML� \W�Ja� \PMQZ�VWVXWTQ\QKIT�LM[KZQX\WZ[�/MVMZI\QWV�A IVL�\PM�5QTTMVQIT[� <PMQZ�M`XMZQMVKM�PIL�WVTa�TI[\ML����aMIZ[�Ja�\PM������MTMK\QWV� J]\�\PM�UWLMTQVLQKI\M[�\PI\�\PM[M�aMIZ[�[PW]TL�ZMUIQV�PQOPTa�QVÆ]MV\QIT�W^MZ�\PM�ZM[\�WN �\PMQZ�TQ^M[� <PMQZ�NWZUI\Q^M�aMIZ[�PI^MJMMV�XZQUIZQTa�KPIZIK\MZQbML�Ja�\PM�XWX]TIZ�,MUWKZI\QK�8ZM[QLMV\�+TQV\WV�IVL�\PM�]VXWX]TIZ�:MX]JTQKIV�*][P11��ZM[]T\QVO�QV�\PMQZ�ZMTI\Q^MTa�[\ZWVO�XZW�,MUWKZI\QK�[MV\QUMV\�

XWZIZQTa�[PQN\ML�QV�I�XZW�:MX]JTQKIV�LQZMK\QWV� *]\�IN\MZ�\PM[MPMQOP\[� PM�M`XMZQMVKML�I�[\MILa�IVL�KITIUQ\W][�LMKTQVM� 7V\PM�NWZMQOV�XWTQKa�NZWV\� PQ[�ILUQVQ[\ZI\QWV�]VLMZ\WWS�KW[\TaIVL�]VXWX]TIZ�_IZ[�QV�\_W�KW]V\ZQM[�IVL�UWZM�JZWILTa�LM�KTIZML�I�OTWJIT�¹?IZ�WV�<MZZWZ�º <PW]OP�[WUM�[]XXWZ\ML\PM�8ZM[QLMV\¼[�^Q[QWV�WN �)UMZQKI�I[�I�KZ][ILMZ�NWZ�LMUWKZIKaIZW]VL�\PM�_WZTL� W\PMZ[�KWV[QLMZML�PQ[�XWTQKQM[� XIZ\QK]TIZTa\PM�_IZ� QV�1ZIY� I[�LMMXTa�XZWJTMUI\QK�^MV\]ZM[�_PQKP�KW[\)UMZQKIV�TQ^M[�IVL�\ZMI[]ZM� _MISMVML�)UMZQKI¼[�[\IVLQVO�QV\PM�_WZTL� IVL�XZWL]KML�TQ\\TM� QN �IVa� OIQV[� 1V�\MZU[�WN �LW�UM[\QK� XWTQKa� *][P� 11¼[�UW[\� VW\IJTM� IKKWUXTQ[PUMV\¸PQ[

�����\I`�K]\[¸]T\QUI\MTa�ZM[]T\ML�QV�\PM�[]ZXT][M[�IKPQM^ML]VLMZ� \PM�+TQV\WV�ILUQVQ[\ZI\QWV� \]ZVQVO� WVKM�IOIQV� QV\WUI[[Q^M�NMLMZIT�LMÅKQ\[� 7V�\WX�WN �\PQ[� \PM�MVL�WN �PQ[�XZM[Q�LMVKa�_I[�PMILTQVML�Ja�\PM�TIZOM[\�ÅVIVKQIT�KZQ[Q[�\PM�KW]V\ZaPIL�NIKML�[QVKM�\PM�/ZMI\�,MXZM[[QWV� ,M[XQ\M�XI[[QVO�MNNMK�\Q^M�MTM^MV\P�PW]Z�TMOQ[TI\QWV�QV�\PM�NWZU�WN �\PM�<ZW]JTML�)[[M\:MTQMN �8ZWOZIU��<):8� \W�I^MZ\�\PM�KZQ[Q[� UIVa�[\QTT�TIa�\PQ[KITIUQ\a�I\�PQ[�NMM\�

9]IV\Q\I\Q^MTa� \PM[M�XZWJTMU[�IZM�KTMIZTa�ZMÆMK\ML�QV�PQ[IXXZW^IT�ZI\QVO[� *][P�11 ÅZ[\�NMTT�JMTW_��� �IXXZW^IT�QV�5IaWN ������ 0M�JIZMTa�_WV�ZMMTMK\QWV�\PI\�aMIZ� IVL�QV�LWQVO�[W

��

Page 22: QVO - Columbia Universitygelman/research/unpublished/...Jun 05, 2014  · i kw]xtm wn lmkilm[ wz tm[[ .wz m`iuxtm wvm wn \pm nmi\]zm[ wn \pm mizta li\i kqzki \pm ! [ ! [ _i[ \pm wj[mz^i\qwv

ZMKMQ^ML�WVTa�I�[TQOP\�J]UX�\W�PQ[�IXXZW^IT�ZI\QVO[� .ITTQVOJMTW_��� �IOIQV�QV�5IZKP������ WVTa�\_W�UWV\P[�IN\MZ�PQ[[MKWVL�QVI]O]ZI\QWV� PQ[�ZI\QVO[�[\IaML�QV�VMOI\Q^M�\MZZQ\WZaNWZ� \PM�ZMUIQVLMZ�WN �PQ[�XZM[QLMVKa¸ITUW[\�IV�MV\QZM� NW]ZaMIZ[� Ja�NIZ�\PM�TWVOM[\�[]KP�[\ZM\KP�QV�\PM�[MZQM[� 0Q[�IXXZW^ITPQ\�Q\¼[�TW_�XWQV\�WN ��� �QV�7K\WJMZ�WN ���� � QV�\PM�UQL[\�WN �\PMÅVIVKQIT�KZQ[Q[� IVL�_I[�[TW_ML� Q\�[MMU[� WVTa�Ja�PQ[�UMZKQN]TLMXIZ\]ZM�NZWU�WNÅKM�\PZMM�UWV\P[�TI\MZ�

<PQ[�JZQVO[�][�\W�\PM�K]ZZMV\�,MUWKZI\QK�8ZM[QLMV\�*IZIKS7JIUI�IVL�\W�\PM�MVL�WN �\PM�[MZQM[� 7JIUI� TQSM�\PM�W\PMZXZM[QLMV\[� JMOIV�_Q\P�I�PQOP��� �ZI\QVO¸TM[[�\PIV�\PM�!� TM^MT[�NZWU�MIZTQMZ�QV�\PM�[MZQM[� J]\�QV�TQVM�_Q\P�\PM�UWZM�ZM�KMV\�8ZM[QLMV\[�+TQV\WV�IVL�*][P�11��0Q[�XWX]TIZQ\a�Y]QKSTaLMKTQVML� PW_M^MZ� QV�XIZ\�L]M�\W�\PM�WVOWQVO�ÅVIVKQIT�KZQ�[Q[�_PQKP�JMOIV�]VLMZ�*][P�11��0Q[�ZI\QVO�LQXXML�\W��� �QV.MJZ]IZa�WN ������ IVL�PI[�ZMUIQVML�QV�\PI\�ZIVOM�W^MZ�\PM[]J[MY]MV\�\PZMM�aMIZ[�

.WZ�\PM� TI[\�OMVMZI\QWV�WN �^W\MZ[� \PMV� \PMQZ�XZM[QLMV\QIT^W\QVO�XZMNMZMVKM[�\P][�NIZ�[MMU�\W�UW[\Ta�ZMÆMK\�\PM�XWX]�TIZ�,MUWKZI\�+TQV\WV�IVL�\PM�LMMXTa�]VXWX]TIZ�:MX]JTQKIV*][P�11��)\�\PM�UQLXWQV\�WN �PQ[�XZM[QLMVKa� \PM�TMOIKa�WN �8ZM[�QLMV\�7JIUI�IVL�PQ[�]T\QUI\M�QVÆ]MVKM�WV�\PQ[�VM_M[\�OMV�MZI\QWV�WN �_PQ\M�^W\MZ[�ZMUIQV[�]VLM\MZUQVML�

<PM�+PIVOQVO�?PQ\M�-TMK\WZI\M

6W_�\PI\�_M�PI^M�LM[KZQJML�MIKP�WN �\PM�Å^M�OMVMZI\QWV[�[MX�IZI\MTa� _M�M`IUQVM�\PMQZ�QUXIK\�WV�\PM�W^MZITT�_PQ\M�^W\M�QV\IVLMU� ?M�LW�[W�QV�.QO]ZM ��� 0MZM�_M�XTW\�MIKP�WN �\PM�K]�U]TI\Q^M�OMVMZI\QWV�K]Z^M[�NZWU�\PM�MIZTQMZ�ÅO]ZM[�WV�I�[QVOTMOZIXP� _Q\P�I�NM_�UWLQÅKI\QWV[�

.QZ[\� \PM�LMÅVQ\QWV[�NWZ�MIKP�WN �\PM�OMVMZI\QWV[�PI^M�JM�KWUM�TWW[MZ� .WZ�\PM�VIZZI\Q^M�[MK\QWV� Q\�_I[�PMTXN]T�\W�\ISM\PM�JQZ\P�aMIZ�UW[\�MUJTMUI\QK�WN �MIKP�OZW]X� J]\�PMZM�_MJZWILMV�\W�LMÅVM�MIKP�OMVMZI\QWV�WV�\PM�[KITM�WN �LMKILM[� IT�TW_QVO�][�\W�UWVQ\WZ�\PM�MV\QZM�MTMK\WZI\M�I\�WVKM� ,M[XQ\M�\PMKPIVOM� \PM�JI[QK�VIZZI\Q^M[�ZMUIQV�\PM�[IUM¸IVL�QVLMML�W^MZTa�[XMKQÅK�LMÅVQ\QWV[�WN �OMVMZI\QWV[�IZM�VW\�[]XXWZ\ML�Ja\PM� M^QLMVKM� ;MKWVL� VW\QKM� \PM�KPIVOQVO�_QL\P[�WN �MIKPK]Z^M� <PM[M�ZMÆMK\�\PM�XZWXWZ\QWV�WN �\PM�MTMK\WZI\M�\PI\�MIKPOMVMZI\QWV�ZMXZM[MV\[�I\�IVa�OQ^MV�\QUM� )\�\PM�[\IZ\�WN �\PM�[M�ZQM[� \PM�WTLM[\�OMVMZI\QWV�ZMÆMK\[�\PM�MV\QZM�_PQ\M�MTMK\WZI\M#I[�\QUM�UIZKPM[�WV� \PMa�JMKWUM�I�[UITTMZ�IVL�[UITTMZ�XWZ�\QWV� IVL�Ja������ITT�Å^M�OMVMZI\QWV[�IZM�ZMXZM[MV\ML� <PQZL�

QV[\MIL�WN �XTW\\QVO�MIKP�OMVMZI\QWV¼[ N]TT K]Z^M�NZWU�IOM�bMZWWV_IZL� _M�WVTa�XTW\�\PM�K]Z^M[�NZWU�\PMQZ�ÅZ[\�MV\Za�QV\W�\PM^W\QVO MTMK\WZI\M� Q�M� NZWU�\PMQZ�ÅZ[\�MTMK\QWV�WV_IZL� 4I[\�_M�PI^M�QVKT]LML�\PM 6M_�,MIT�,MUWKZI\[ IVL�WTLMZ�^W\MZ[�QV\PQ[�OZIXP� LM[XQ\M�\PM�NIK\�\PI\�\PM�[\I\Q[\QKIT�UWLMT�LQL�VW\M`XTQKQ\Ta�QVKT]LM�\PMU���

.ZWU�\PQ[�OZIXP� _M�KIV�UWZM�KTMIZTa�[MM�\PM�QVÆ]MVKM�WNMIKP�OMVMZI\QWV� _PQTM�IT[W�XTW\\QVO�\PM�\MVLMVKQM[�WN �\PM�N]TT_PQ\M�MTMK\WZI\M� [PW_V�QV�OZMMV� 1V�\PM��!��[� _PQ\M[�_MZM[TQOP\Ta�,MUWKZI\QK�L]M�\W�\PM�QVÆ]MVKM�WN �.,:��<PZW]OP\PM� �!��[� \PM -Q[MVPW_MZ� :MX]JTQKIV[ MV\MZML� \PM� MTMK\WZI\MIVL� [PQN\ML� _PQ\M[� \W_IZL[� \PM� VM]\ZIT� �� � TQVM� _Q\P� \PM3MVVMLa�2WPV[WV� aMIZ[� UW^QVO� \PM� MTMK\WZI\M� JIKS� LW_VW^MZ�\PM�KW]Z[M�WN �\PM��!��[� <P][�JMOIV�\PM�TWVO�XMZQWL�WN:MX]JTQKIV� I[KMVLIVKa¸[TQOP\Ta� \ZMVLQVO� ]X_IZL� \PZW]OP\PM�6Q`WV�IVL�.WZL�aMIZ[� [TW_ML�QV�XIZ\�Ja�\PM�MV\Za�WN �\PM*IJa� *WWUMZ[� *]\� \PM� WV[M\� WN � \PM�:MIOIV� ILUQVQ[\ZI\QWVUW^ML�ITUW[\�ITT�OMVMZI\QWV[�]X_IZL¸\PM6M_�,MIT�,MUWKZI\[_MZM� \WW�WTL�I\� \PI\�XWQV\� \W�PI^M�IVa�UMIVQVON]T� KPIVOM�J]\�\PM�ZMUIQVQVO�OMVMZI\QWV[� M[XMKQITTa�\PM :MIOIV�+WV[MZ^I�\Q^M[� UW^ML�LZIUI\QKITTa� _Q\P� \PM�OZMMV�K]Z^M�KZW[[QVO� \PM�� �JW]VLIZa� TQVM� QV� TI\M� �! �� <PW[M� [IUM :MIOIV�+WV�[MZ^I\Q^M[¸VW_�LMÅVML�I[�I�OZW]X�OWQVO�]V\QT�\PM�JQZ\P�aMIZWN ��!�!¸VM]\ZITQbML�I�JQ\�]VLMZ�\PM�+TQV\WV�XZM[QLMVKa� J]\\PI\�KPIVOM�_I[�VW\�UMIVQVON]T�MVW]OP�\W�TIZOMTa�UW^M�\PMMTMK\WZI\M�I[�I�_PWTM� *][P�11¼[�!����[XQSM�UW^ML�ITT�OZW]X[[TQOP\Ta� IVL�PQ[�[TW_�IVL�[\MILa�LMKTQVM�IT[W�[MZ^ML�\W�UW^MUW[\�OZW]X[�WVKM�IOIQV�

<PQ[�OZIXP�LWM[�VW\�QV�NIK\�ZMXZM[MV\�\PM�KWUXTM\M�WXQV�QWV�\ZMVL[�WN �MIKP�WN �\PM[M�OMVMZI\QWV[� )N\MZ�ITT� \PM�UWLMTLWM[�VW\�Å\���� �WN �\PM�^IZQIVKM�QV�\PM�LI\I� *]\�Q\�LWM[�QV�LQKI\M�\PI\�\PQ[�ZMTI\Q^MTa�[QUXTM�UWLMT�KIV�M`XTIQV�Y]Q\M�I�JQ\IJW]\�\PM�W^MZITT�^W\QVO�KPIZIK\MZ�WN �\PM�_PQ\M�MTMK\WZI\M� 1V�LMML� \PM�OZIXP�Q[ MV\QZMTa LZQ^MV�Ja�\PM�XZM[QLMV\QIT�XWTQ\QKITM^MV\[�ZMXZM[MV\ML�QV�\PM�)XXZW^IT�[MZQM[�IVL�\PM�IOM�_MQOP\[�<PM�_PQ\M�MTMK\WZI\M�UW^M[�QV�UMIVQVON]T�_Ia[� IVL�\PM�NI�UQTQIZ�¹XIZITTMT� TQVM[º�WN �X]JTQK�WXQVQWV� QV�_PQKP�LQNNMZMV\OZW]X[�ZM[XWVL�\W�XWTQ\QKIT�M^MV\[�QV�[QUQTIZ�_Ia[� IZM�IXXIZ�MV\��8IOM�IVL�;PIXQZW���!!��� 1V�\PM�UWLMT� KPIVOM[�_PQKP

��<W�KWV[\Z]K\�\PQ[�OZW]X¼[�OMVMZI\QWV�K]Z^M� _M�IXXTa�\PM�[\I\Q[\QKIT�UWLMTNWZ�\PM�aMIZ[�KW^MZML�Ja�\PM�\QUM�[MZQM[� QVKT]LQVO�JW\P�OMVMZI\QWV�IVL�XM�ZQWL�MNNMK\[� ?M�\PMV�Å\�IV�ILLQ\QWVIT�ZMOZM[[QWV�UWLMT�\W�ÅVL�IV�QV\MZKMX\ILR][\UMV\�NWZ�\PQ[�OZW]X� XTIKQVO�\PMU�QV�TQVM�_Q\P�\PMQZ�M`XMK\ML�^W\QVOXZMNMZMVKM[�QV�IV�I^MZIOM�MTMK\QWV� )V�¹I^MZIOMº�MTMK\QWV�Q[�LMÅVML�I[�WVMQV�_PQKP�\PM�XMZQWL�MNNMK\[�IZM�[M\�\W�bMZW�

��

Page 23: QVO - Columbia Universitygelman/research/unpublished/...Jun 05, 2014  · i kw]xtm wn lmkilm[ wz tm[[ .wz m`iuxtm wvm wn \pm nmi\]zm[ wn \pm mizta li\i kqzki \pm ! [ ! [ _i[ \pm wj[mz^i\qwv

.QO]ZM ��" <PM�K]U]TI\Q^M�XZMNMZMVKM[�WN �MIKP�OMVMZI\QWV�Q[�[PW_V� ITWVO�_Q\P�\PM�_MQOP\ML�[]UUI\QWV�WN �\PMN]TT�_PQ\M�MTMK\WZI\M� <PM�OMVMZI\QWV[�IZM�VW_�UWZM�TWW[MTa�LMÅVML� \W�ITTW_�\PM�MV\QZM�MTMK\WZI\M�\W�JM�XTW\\ML�I\WVKM� _Q\P�\PM�_QL\P�WN �MIKP�K]Z^M�QVLQKI\QVO�\PM�XZWXWZ\QWV�WN �\PM�_PQ\M�MTMK\WZI\M�\PI\�MIKP�OMVMZI\QWV�ZMÆMK\[I\�IVa�OQ^MV�\QUM� <PM�UWLMT¸QV�\PQ[�OZIXP�ZMÆMK\QVO�WVTa�\PM�)XXZW^IT�\QUM�[MZQM[�IVL�\PM�IOM�_MQOP\[¸KIVM`XTIQV�Y]Q\M�I�JQ\�IJW]\�\PM�^W\QVO�\MVLMVKQM[�WN �\PM�_PQ\M�MTMK\WZI\M�W^MZ�\QUM�

IZM�QV�[WUM�[MV[M[�¹[UITTº�[MMU�\W�PI^M�I�JQO�QUXIK\�WV�XWT�QKa�IVL�WV�\PM�W^MZITT�KPIZIK\MZ�WN �\PM�MTMK\WZI\M¸\PM�OZMMVK]Z^M� ZMXZM[MV\QVO�\PM�N]TT�_PQ\M�MTMK\WZI\M� [XIV[�WVTa���XMZ�KMV\IOM�XWQV\[�IT\WOM\PMZ� 1V�\PM�OZIVL�[KPMUM�WN �XZM[QLMV�\QIT�XWTQ\QK[� PW_M^MZ� I�KWV[Q[\MV\���XWQV\�[_QVO�Q[�MVWZUW][TaUMIVQVON]T�

,Q[K][[QWV

6W_�\PI\�\PM�UWLMT�Q[�KWUXTM\M� Q\�Q[�IV�IXXZWXZQI\M�UWUMV\\W�ZM^Q[Q\�\PM�WJ[MZ^I\QWV�_PQKP�WXMVML�\PM�XIXMZ� <W�ZM[\I\M�

�� � WN � _PQ\M� ^W\MZ[� IOML� � ��!� ^W\ML� NWZ� \PMV�KIVLQLI\M7JIUI� QV���� � IVL� \PI\�IL^IV\IOM�ÆQXXML� \W��� � QV� NI�^WZ�WN �\PM�:MX]JTQKIV�KIVLQLI\M�:WUVMa�QV������ ?Pa�LQL\PQ[�PIXXMV' <PM�IV[_MZ� Q\� [MMU[� Q[�VW_�KTMIZ� 0MILQVOQV\W� ��� � aW]VO� ^W\MZ[� PIL� WVTa� M`XMZQMVKML� \PM� XWX]TIZ+TQV\WV� IVL�]VXWX]TIZ�*][P� 11 aMIZ[� <PM�_QVL[�_MZM� QV7JIUI¼[�NI^WZ� IVL�\PM[M�^W\MZ[�QV�XIZ\QK]TIZ�_MZM�QV�I�XW[Q�\QWV�\W�JM�UW[\�ZMKMX\Q^M�\W�\PW[M�MTMK\QWV�\W�MTMK\QWV�XMZQWLMNNMK\[� /WQVO�QV\W������ PW_M^MZ� \PM�UW[\�ZMKMV\�aMIZ[�WNXWWZ�*][P�11 XMZNWZUIVKM�_MZM�ZMXTIKML�Ja�UMLQWKZM�ZI\QVO[WN �7JIUI�PQU[MTN� )[�\PM�KW]V\Za�UW^ML�ZW]OPTa���XWQV\[

��

Page 24: QVO - Columbia Universitygelman/research/unpublished/...Jun 05, 2014  · i kw]xtm wn lmkilm[ wz tm[[ .wz m`iuxtm wvm wn \pm nmi\]zm[ wn \pm mizta li\i kqzki \pm ! [ ! [ _i[ \pm wj[mz^i\qwv

I_Ia�NZWU�7JIUI�I[�I�_PWTM� \PM[M�aW]VO�_PQ\M�^W\MZ[� QV�WZVMIZ�\PMQZ�XMIS�aMIZ[�WN �[WKQITQbI\QWV� _MZM�QV�XW[Q\QWV�\W�JMUW^ML�\PM�UW[\� <PI\�Q[�QVLMML�_PI\�PIXXMVML� IVL�\PM�MVLZM[]T\�_I[�I�TIZOMZ�TW[[�IUWVO�\PQ[�aW]VO�OZW]X�

1\�Q[� WN �KW]Z[M� LQNÅK]T\�\W�NWZMKI[\�\PM�M`IK\�QUXTQKI\QWV[WN �\PQ[�TW[[�WV�N]\]ZM�8ZM[QLMV\QIT�MTMK\QWV[� *]\�QN �\PM�UWLMTZM[]T\[� IZM� IVa� QVLQKI\QWV� \PQ[� Q[� I� KPIVOM� \PI\�UIa� ZM^MZ�JMZI\M�_MTT�QV\W�\PM�N]\]ZM� )T\MZVI\Q^MTa� _M�UQOP\�[\I\M�\PQ[ZM[]T\� QV� I� XW[Q\Q^M� \WVM� NWZ� \PM�,MUWKZI\[¸XMZPIX[� ��� _I[�I�[XMKQIT�aMIZ� [QUQTIZ�\W��!��� QV�_PQKP�I�[\ZWVOTa�XZW�,MUWKZI\QK� KWPWZ\� MV\MZML� \PM�MTMK\WZI\M� QV� \PM�_ISM�WN �ILMMXTa�]VXWX]TIZ�:MX]JTQKIV�XZM[QLMV\� 8MZPIX[�\PM[M�ÅZ[\�\QUM�^W\MZ[� JWZV�IZW]VL��!!�� _QTT� ZMUMUJMZ� \PM�+TQV\WVIVL�*][P�11 aMIZ[�\PZW]OP�\PMQZ�TQNM\QUM[�IVL�PWTL�XMZ[Q[\MV\XZW�,MUWKZI\QK�^QM_[�NWZ�\PM�ZMUIQVLMZ�WN �\PMQZ�^W\QVO�TQ^M[�1N �[W� \PMV������_I[�VW\�\PM�W]\TQMZ� J]\�ZI\PMZ�I�ZM\]ZV�\W�VWZ�UITKa� IVL�\PM��!!��KWPWZ\�_QTT�JM�IV�QVÆMK\QWV�XWQV\� [QUQTIZ\W�\PM�KWPWZ\�JWZV�QV��!���

:MOIZLTM[[�WN �PW_�_M�QV\MZXZM\�\PM�ZM[]T\�NZWU�\PM[M�\_W�ZM�KMV\�MTMK\QWV[� \PM�TIZOMZ�\ZMVL�Q[�KTMIZ�IVL�[\ZWVO� <PM�¹Z]V�VQVO�\ITTaº�UWLMT�IXXMIZ[�^QVLQKI\ML�NZWU�\PM�XMZ[XMK\Q^M�WNXZM[QLMV\QIT�^W\QVO� IVL� QV�XIZ\QK]TIZ�_M�[MM� \PI\�ZM\ZW[XMK�\Q^M�M^IT]I\QWV[�WN �\PM�XZM[QLMV\¼[�XMZNWZUIVKM�IZM�XIZ\QK]�TIZTa�UMIVQVON]T�L]ZQVO�\PM�\MMVIOM�aMIZ[�IVL�aW]VO�IL]T\�PWWL� XMISQVO�IZW]VL�\PM�IOM[�WN ������� <PM�)XXZW^IT�:I\�QVO[�\QUM�[MZQM[�IXXMIZ�\W�JM�I�OWWL�IXXZW`QUI\QWV�\W�\PM�XW�TQ\QKIT�M^MV\[�QVNWZUQVO�\PW[M�ZM\ZW[XMK\Q^M�M^IT]I\QWV[� IVL�IUWLMT�_PQKP�IKKW]V\[�NWZ�\PM[M�M^MV\[�KIV�\MTT�][�Y]Q\M�I�JQ\IJW]\�\PM�^W\QVO�KPIZIK\MZ�WN �\PM�_PQ\M�MTMK\WZI\M�W^MZ�\PM�TI[\PITN �KMV\]Za�

7V�\WX�WN �\PM�Y]IV\Q\I\Q^M�ZM[]T\[� \PM�JZQMN �VIZZI\Q^M�PI[PMTXML� KTIZQNa� [WUM� WN � \PM� Y]ITQ\I\Q^M� LM\IQT[� WN � \PM� [\WZa�?PMV�_M� \PQVS�IJW]\�OMVMZI\QWV[�WN �XZM[QLMV\QIT�^W\QVO� Q\Q[�QUXWZ\IV\�VW\�\W�\PQVS�IJW]\�I�[QVOTM�MTMK\QWV�WZ�WN �I�[QV�OTM� LMÅVQVO� XWTQ\QKIT� M^MV\� :I\PMZ� OMVMZI\QWV[� IXXMIZ� \WJM�NWZUML�\PZW]OP�I�XZWTWVOML�XMZQWL�WN �XZM[QLMV\QIT�M`KMT�TMVKM� .,: IVL�\PM�6M_�,MIT� -Q[MVPW_MZ� 3MVVMLa�IVL2WPV[WV¼[�/ZMI\�;WKQM\a� \PM�:MIOIV�*][P�KWV[MZ^I\Q^M�ZM^W�T]\QWV� IVL�\PM�+TQV\WV�aMIZ[�IZM�ITT�KPIZIK\MZQbML�Ja�TWVO�XM�ZQWL[�WN �PQOP�IXXZW^IT�ZI\QVO[� MIKP�WN �_PQKP�[\MILQTa�X][PML\PM�K]U]TI\Q^M�^W\QVO�XZMNMZMVKM[�WN �I�OMVMZI\QWV�QV�WVM�LQ�ZMK\QWV�WZ�IVW\PMZ� <PM�WVTa�UIRWZ�M`KMX\QWV�IXXMIZ[�\W�JM\PM�TI[\¸\PM�+TQV\WV�aMIZ[�_MZM�IQLML�VW\�Ja�IV�ILLQ\QWVIT

[]KKM[[N]T�,MUWKZI\� J]\�Ja�\PM�LMMXTa�]VXWX]TIZ�:MX]JTQ�KIV�*][P�11�

:MNMZMVKM[

)KPMV� +PZQ[\WXPMZ 0���!!�� ¹;WKQIT�8[aKPWTWOa�,MUWOZIXPQK�>IZQIJTM[� IVL�4QVMIZ�:MOZM[[QWV" *ZMISQVO\PM�1ZWV�<ZQIVOTM�QV�>W\QVO�:M[MIZKP�º 8WTQ\QKIT�*MPI^QWZ�����"�!�·����

*IZ\MT[� 4IZZa�IVL�;QUWV�2IKSUIV������� ¹) /MVMZI\QWVIT5WLMT�WN �8WTQ\QKIT�4MIZVQVO�º?WZSQVO�8IXMZ �

+IUXJMTT� )VO][� 8PQTQX -��+WV^MZ[M� ?IZZMV -��5QTTMZ�IVL,WVITL -��;\WSM[���!��� <PM�)UMZQKIV�>W\MZ� ?QTMa�

+WV^MZ[M� 8PQTTQX -���!��� <PM�,aVIUQK[�WN �8IZ\a�;]XXWZ\"+WPWZ\�)VITabQVO�8IZ\a�1LMV\QÅKI\QWV� ;IOM�8]JTQKI\QWV[�

+ZQ\\MVLWV� 2WPV���!��� ¹)OQVO�IVL�8IZ\a�)NÅTQI\QWV�º 8]JTQK7XQVQWV�9]IZ\MZTa �����"�� ·����

+]\TMZ� 6MIT -���!��� ¹/MVMZI\QWV� 5I\]ZI\QWV� IVL�8IZ\a)NÅTQI\QWV" ) +WPWZ\�)VITa[Q[�º 8]JTQK�7XQVQWV�9]IZ\MZTa��"� �·� �

,MTTQ�+IZXQVQ� 5QKPIMT @���! !� )OM�IVL�0Q[\WZa"/MVMZI\QWV[�IVL�;WKQWXWTQ\QKIT�+PIVOM��1V 8WTQ\QKIT4MIZVQVO�QV�)L]T\PWWL" ) ;W]ZKMJWWS�WN �<PMWZa�IVL�:M[MIZKP� ML�:WJMZ\I ;��;QOMT� =VQ^MZ[Q\a�WN �+PQKIOW�8ZM[[�

,]IVM� ;QUWV� )V\PWVa ,��3MVVMLa� *ZQIV 2��8MVLTM\WVIVL�,]VKIV�:W_M\P���! �� ¹0aJZQL�5WV\M�+IZTW�º8Pa[QK[�TM\\MZ[�* �!����"���·����

-ZQS[WV� :WJMZ\ ;�� 5QKPIMT *��5IK3]MV�IVL�2IUM[ )�;\QU[WV������� <PM�5IKZW�8WTQ\a� +IUJZQLOM�=VQ^MZ[Q\a8ZM[[�

.QWZQVI� 5WZZQ[ 8���! �� :M\ZW[XMK\Q^M�>W\QVO�QV�)UMZQKIV�6I\QWVIT-TMK\QWV[� AITM�=VQ^MZ[Q\a�8ZM[[�

/MTUIV� )VLZM_�IVL�2MVVQNMZ�0QTT������� ,I\I�)VITa[Q[�=[QVO:MOZM[[QWV�IVL�5]T\QTM^MT�0QMZIZKPQKIT�5WLMT[� +IUJZQLOM=VQ^MZ[Q\a�8ZM[[�

/MTUIV� )VLZM_� 2WPV *��+IZTQV� 0IT ;��;\MZV�IVL,WVITL *��:]JQV������� *IaM[QIV�,I\I�)VITa[Q[� +PIXUIVIVL�0ITT�+:+�

��

Page 25: QVO - Columbia Universitygelman/research/unpublished/...Jun 05, 2014  · i kw]xtm wn lmkilm[ wz tm[[ .wz m`iuxtm wvm wn \pm nmi\]zm[ wn \pm mizta li\i kqzki \pm ! [ ! [ _i[ \pm wj[mz^i\qwv

/MZJMZ� )TIV�IVL�,WVITL 8��/ZMMV���!! � ¹:I\QWVIT4MIZVQVO�IVL�8IZ\Q[IV�)\\Q\]LM[�º )UMZQKIV�2W]ZVIT�WN8WTQ\QKIT�;KQMVKM �����"�!�· � �

/PQ\bI� AIQZ�IVL�)VLZM_�/MTUIV������� ¹,MMX1V\MZIK\QWV[�_Q\P�5:8"�-TMK\QWV�<]ZVW]\�IVL�>W\QVO8I\\MZV[�)UWVO�;UITT�-TMK\WZIT�;]JOZW]X[�º )UMZQKIV2W]ZVIT�WN �8WTQ\QKIT�;KQMVKM �����"���·����

/TMVV� 6WZ^IT ,���!��� ¹+WPWZ\�)VITa[\[¼�.]\QTM�9]M[\";\I\Q[\QKIT�)\\MUX\[�\W�;MXIZI\M�)OM� 8MZQWL�IVL�+WPWZ\-NNMK\[�º )UMZQKIV�;WKQWTWOQKIT�:M^QM_ �����"!��·!���

/TMVV� 6WZ^IT ,��IVL�<ML�0MNVMZ���!��� ¹.]Z\PMZ�-^QLMVKMWV�)OQVO�IVL�8IZ\a�1LMV\QÅKI\QWV�º 8]JTQK�7XQVQWV�9]IZ\MZTa��"��·���

0WNNUIV� 5I\\PM_ ,��IVL�)VLZM_�/MTUIV��1V�XZM[[� ¹<PM6W�=�<]ZV�;IUXTMZ" )LIX\Q^MTa�;M\\QVO�8I\P�4MVO\P[�QV0IUQT\WVQIV�5WV\M�+IZTW�º 2W]ZVIT�WN �5IKPQVM�4MIZVQVO:M[MIZKP �

0aUIV� 0MZJMZ\���!�!� 8WTQ\QKIT�;WKQITQbI\QWV" ) ;\]La�QV�\PM8[aKPWTWOa�WN �8WTQ\QKIT�*MPI^QWZ� .ZMM�8ZM[[�

2MVVQVO[� 5� 3MV\�IVL�:QKPIZL�6QMUQ���! �� /MVMZI\QWV[�IVL8WTQ\QK[" ) 8IVMT�;\]La�WN �AW]VO�)L]T\[�IVL�<PMQZ�8IZMV\[�8ZQVKM\WV�=VQ^MZ[Q\a�8ZM[[�

2WPV[WV� 4aVLWV *IQVM[���!��� ;XMMKP�=:4"P\\X"��___�IUMZQKIVZPM\WZQK�KWU�[XMMKPM[�TJR\PMOZMI\[WKQM\a�P\U

3WP]\� )VLZM_� 8I]T�<IaTWZ� ;KW\\�3MM\MZ� +IZZWTT�,WPMZ\a�5QKPIMT�,QUWKS�IVL�3QU�8IZSMZ������� ¹<PM/MVMZI\QWV�/IX�IVL�\PM������-TMK\QWV�º 8M_�:M[MIZKP+MV\MZ �

5IVVPMQU� 3IZT���!��� <PM�8ZWJTMU�WN �/MVMZI\QWV[��1V-[[Ia[�WV�\PM�;WKQWTWOa�WN �3VW_TMLOM� ML��8��3MK[SMUM\Q�:W]\TMLOM�

5IZS][� /ZMOWZa 8���! �� ¹,aVIUQK�5WLMTQVO�WN �+WPWZ\+PIVOM" <PM�+I[M�WN �8WTQ\QKIT�8IZ\Q[IV[PQX�º )UMZQKIV2W]ZVIT�WN �8WTQ\QKIT�;KQMVKM �����"���·��!�

5M\ZWXWTQ[� 6QKPWTI[� )ZQIVVI ?��:W[MVJT]\P� 5IZ[PITT 6�:W[MVJT]\P� )]O][\I 0��<MTTMZ�IVL�-L_IZL�<MTTMZ���!���¹-Y]I\QWV�WN �;\I\M�+ITK]TI\QWV[�Ja�.I[\�+WUX]\QVO5IKPQVM[�º 2W]ZVIT�WN �+PMUQKIT�8Pa[QK[ ���

6QMUQ� :QKPIZL /��IVL�*IZJIZI 1��;WJQM[bMS���!���¹8WTQ\QKIT�;WKQITQbI\QWV�º )VV]IT�:M^QM_�WN �;WKQWTWOa �

6QMUQ� :QKPIZL /��IVL�5IZa )��0MXJ]ZV���!!�� ¹<PM:MJQZ\P�WN �8WTQ\QKIT�;WKQITQbI\QWV�º 8MZ[XMK\Q^M[�WV�8WTQ\QKIT;KQMVKM �����"�·���

8IOM� *MVRIUQV 1��IVL�:WJMZ\ A��;PIXQZW���!!�� <PM�:I\QWVIT8]JTQK" .QN\a�AMIZ[�WN �<ZMVL[�QV�)UMZQKIV[¼�8WTQKa�8ZMNMZMVKM[�=VQ^MZ[Q\a�WN �+PQKIOW�8ZM[[�

8IV\WRI� )LZQIV ,�� :QKIZLW�:IUQZMb�IVL�/IZa 5��;MO]ZI������ ¹+Q\QbMV[�*a�+PWQKM� >W\MZ[�*a�6MKM[[Q\a" 8I\\MZV[1V�8WTQ\QKIT�5WJQTQbI\QWV�*a�6I\]ZITQbML�4I\QVW[�º 8WTQ\QKIT:M[MIZKP�9]IZ\MZTa �����"��!·����

: +WZM�<MIU������� :"�) 4IVO]IOM�IVL�-V^QZWVUMV\�NWZ;\I\Q[\QKIT�+WUX]\QVO� >QMVVI� )][\ZQI" : .W]VLI\QWV�NWZ;\I\Q[\QKIT�+WUX]\QVO� 1;*6 ��!�����������=:4" P\\X"��___�:�XZWRMK\�WZO�

;\IV�,M^MTWXUMV\�<MIU������� ¹;\IV" ) +���4QJZIZa�NWZ8ZWJIJQTQ\a�IVL�;IUXTQVO� >MZ[QWV�����º�=:4" P\\X"��UK�[\IV�WZO�

;\QU[WV� 2IUM[ )���!!�� 8]JTQK�7XQVQWV�QV�)UMZQKI" 5WWL[�+aKTM[� IVL�;_QVO[� ?M[\^QM_�

��


Recommended