NEXT GENERATIONPUBLIC SAFETYPAUL STEINBERG | CHIEF TECHNOLOGY OFFICER, MOTOROLA SOLUTIONSRADCOMMS 2012, MELBOURNE | 7 JUNE 2012

IT’S A WIRELESS BROADBAND WORLDMOBILE DATA TRAFFICWILL INCREASE…

18x?18x

78%

?

?

GROWING AT A COMPOUNDED ANNUAL GROWTH RATE OF…

Cisco Visual Networking

Index: Global Mobile Data

Traffic Forecast, 2011–

2016, Feb. 2012

OVER A 5-YEAR SPANFROM 2011-2016

SMARTDEVICESPREVAILSMART DEVICE UNITSSHIPPED IN 2011...

NEARLY 1B % OF CHILDREN?REPRESENTINGSALES OF ALMOST...

NEARLY 1BPCs, TABLETS AND SMARTPHONES

$500BSMARTPHONES RULE –Q32011 SMARTPHONES OUTPACEDPC SALES BY NEARLY 30%

% OF CHILDREN0-8 THAT HAVE USED A SMART PHONE, IPOD, IPAD

38%

?

? ?International Data

Corporation (IDC),

March 2012

Common

Sense Media,

Oct. 2011

MEDIA EVERYWHERE, ANYTIME

60 HOURS

CONTENT UPLOADED TO YOUTUBE EVERY MINUTE…

?MORE VIDEO UPLOADED

60 HOURS

60 YEARS

YOUTUBE IS THE LARGEST SOURCE OF MOBILE DATA TRAFFIC ACROSS ALL INTERNATIONAL MARKETS, ACCOUNTING FOR MORE THAN 25% OF TOTAL NETWORK DATAIN SOME REGIONS

?

? YouTube,

May 2012Sandvine, April 2012

IN A MONTHTHAN THE 3 MAJOR U.S. NETWORKS PRODUCED IN LAST…

?

SOCIALNETWORKINGREVOLUTION

901 MILLION

ACTIVE MONTHLYUSERS ON FACEBOOK…

?USERS ACCESSING FACEBOOK THROUGH MOBILE DEVICES…

901 MILLION

>500 MILLION

?

? Facebook,

April 2012

HOW IS PUBLIC SAFETY DOING IN THIS COMPLEX MULTIMEDIA WORLD?

89%PERCENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY DECISION MAKERS WHO BELIEVE DATA IS JUST AS MISSION CRITICAL AS VOICE?

PUBLIC SAFETY GOES SOCIAL

% OF POLICE AGENCIES WHO USE SOCIAL MEDIA TO...

83% 70%

SHARE INFORMATIONWITH THE PUBLIC...

RECEIVE CRIME TIPS FROM THE PUBLIC...

MONITOR FOR INVESTIGATIVE LEADS...

89%? ? ?83% 70% 89%? ? ?

EYES ONTHE STREET

4.2 MILLION

SECURITY CAMERAS INSTALLED IN PUBLIC PLACES IN THE UK

?AGENCIES THAT HAVE INSTALLED VIDEO RECORDERS IN THEIR VEHICLES

70%AGENCIES THAT USE WIRELESS VIDEO STREAMING

46%

4.2 MILLION?

?

?

PUBLIC SAFETYTODAY: MOBILE,BB,MEDIA

TODAY’S PUBLIC SAFETYNEEDS

INTEGRATED COMMUNICATIONS

PERSONAL VEHICULAR INFRASTRUCTURE

ENHANCED SITUATIONAL AWARENESSSAFETY, COLLABORATION, EFFECTIVENESS

BUILT FORTHE STREET

UNMATCHED CONNECTIVITY

HIGH RESOLUTIONVIDEO CAMERA

DEDICATED PTT

BAND 14 PUBLICSAFETY LTE

PTT

LEX 700 MISSION CRITICAL HANDHELDMOTOROLA PUBLIC SAFETY LTE

MISSION CRITICAL BLUETOOTH

BAND 13 PUBLIC CARRIER LTE

MOBILE VPN WITH PRIORITY

3G EVDO REV. A

3G 1XRTT

802.11 A/B/G/N WI-FI

GPS

PTT VOIP CLIENT

P25 RADIO PAIRING

HW ACCELERATED 3D GRAPHICS

ULTRA-BRIGHT TOUCH SCREEN

1.0 GHZ DUAL CORE PROCESSOR

LONG LASTING BATTERY

EXPANSION SLOT

ENTEPRISE ACCESSORIES

DUAL-MIC NOISE REDUCTION

COVERT MODE

DEDICATED PTT BUTTON

RUGGED, SEALED CONSTRUCTION

PTTVOIP CLIENT

THE FIRST DEVICE TO DELIVERSTREET-READY DATA

NEXT GENERATION POLICE CRUISER

INTEGRATED COCKPIT | VOICE ACTIVATION | INTEGRATED PTT | CONTROL HEADP25 LMR | BROADAND LTE | DIGITAL VIDEO RECORDER | WORKSTATION

AUTOMATED LICENSE PLATE RECOGNITION | STREAMING VIDEO

SPECTRUM IS CRITICALUS ALLOCATES PUBLIC SAFETY SPECTRUM

US CONGRESS PASSED BILL TO REALLOCATE D-BLOCK SPECTRUM

TO PUBLIC SAFETY

$7B TO BUILD NATIONWIDE NETWORK$7B TO BUILD NATIONWIDE NETWORK$2B AVAILABLE BEFORE AUCTION

$135M IN STATE PLANNING GRANTS

“OPT-OUT” CLAUSE FOR STATES

GOVERNANCE BY FIRSTNET(FIRST RESPONDER NETWORK AUTHORITY)

REQUIRES RETURN OF UHF T-BANDIN 11 YEARS (470-512 MHZ)

$115M GRANT FUNDING TO STATE & LOCAL EMS AUTHORITIES

ADEQUATE DEDICATED SPECTRUM IS CRITICALLESSONS LEARNED FROM RECENT EMERGENCIES

MINNEAPOLIS INTERSTATE- 35 BRIDGE COLLAPSE, 2007“The voice radio system worked fine; it reached capacity but worked.

Cell phones were absolutely worthless.”

WILDFIRES IN SAN DIEGO, 2007“We were relying on calls back and forth4but fires were eating up

some of the cell phone towers so the cell phone system started

MINNEAPOLIS DEPUTY

POLICE CHIEF

ROB ALLEN

SAN DIEGO POLICE

CHIEF WILLIAM

LANSDOWNE

some of the cell phone towers so the cell phone system started

going down real quick.”

HURRICANE WILMA IN SOUTH FLORIDA, OCTOBER 2005“Even if a commercial system stays up and running, it doesn’t mean

we’ll have access to it....We have to own the spectrum and manage

it to ensure that our data will travel on that network when we need

it.”

MAJOR TOM GROSS

MIAMI-DADE (FLORIDA)

POLICE DEPARTMENT

WASHINGTON, D.C.,

POLICE CHIEF CATHY

LANIER

MID-ATLANTIC EARTHQUAKE, 23 AUGUST 2011“You couldn’t get on the cell phone, you couldn’t send text messages,

so the key for us was quick communication through our command

centers.”

NATIONAL PS BROADBAND NETWORKNETWORK OF NETWORKS LANDSCAPE VIEW

Findings from U.S. National Public

Safety Telecommunications

Council (17/4/2012)

�Public Safety has unique QoS Requirements

� Dynamic / Real-time� Preemptive� Discrete Control

TECHNICAL ADVISORY BOARD FOR FIRST RESPONDER INTEROPERABILITY – 22-May-2012

(http://www.npstc.org/download.jsp?tableId=37&column=217&id=2334&file=

Interop_Board_Final_Report_05_22_12.pdf)

� Discrete Control

� Key Use-cases/conditions� Responder Emergency� Imminent Peril� Jurisdictional Priority� Incident Command System

� A national “prioritization framework” is necessary to accommodate all agencies & applications sharing resources

INTEGRATED PUBLIC SAFETY COMMUNICATIONS SOLUTION

Commercial Carrier

IMS

Carrier Apps

NG Emergency Svcs

IMS-based IETF-based

NENA i3/ATIS Standards

EmergencyContent/ ServiceProviders

IP

Upgraded

Public Safety Agencies/Forces

IP

PBx

PSAP/Control Rooms

MulitmediaDispatchConsoles

M-M CAD / RMSBackup M- PTT

IT Network- AppsMC-Video

analytics/mining

Public Safety LTE

PGW

MVNO orRoaming Relationship

PS Interop GW- Unified Services & Mobile VPN

Carrier Core

Cellular Carrier 3G/4G,Public Wi-Fi Sites

Companion

3G/LTESmartphone

Alarms, Sensors,

Cameras

Carriers/ ISPs

Multiple Access Networks

Alarms, Sensors,

Cameras

Emergency callers

sending multimedia

Data-Enhanced LMR Sites (TEDS)

UpgradedLMR Core w/LTE-readiness

Integrated Voice

& Data LMR Radio

Mobile

Tablet Computing

Public Safety

LTE Core

HSSPCRF

PGW

LTE eNodeB

Collocation

Collocationwhere possible

SGW MME

Converged

LMR/LTE/3G Device

Collaboratingor

Converged Devices

SCANNING SITUATIONAL AWARENESS

TACTICAL DECISION ENABLING

STRATEGIC DECISION ENABLING

ORIGINAL

V1: 128 kbps V2: 384 kbps V3: 1.2 Mbps V4: 3.5 Mbps

� Remotely monitor � Asses magnitude of � capture BOLO images, � Direct real-time response

1.2 MP: 1280x960VGA: 640x480QVGA: 320x240SQVGA: 160x120

VIDEO QUALITY TIERINGVideo samples prepared using x264, with a real-time profile, @ 30 frames/sec, using content typical of a public safety incident scene

multiple cameras looking

for gross anomalies (e.g.

a bridge collapse)

incident to determine

appropriate response

� Identify number of people

and vehicles involved

identify near-field license

plates and vehicles

� Approaching fixed

surveillance video quality

team, positively identify

suspects, assess injuries

� Approaching evidentiary

(transparent) video quality

� Receiver-driven digital PTZ

LIFE CYCLE OF AN INCIDENT – BARRICADED SUSPECT

BROADBAND APPLICATION EXAMPLE (1)

Secure Perimeter (t=15) Special Response Arrives (t=60))Incident Starts (t=0)

Police Vehicle

Fire

SWAT Sniper

Police Command

Helmet Cam

Ambulance

SWAT Vehicle

Swat Command

Throw Phone

Large Robot

Recon Robot

Command/Control

Outer Perimeter

Inner PerimeterSniper VideoRobot VideoRecon Rob VideoSniper Video

Negotiation (t=125) Entry Team Deploys (t=240)

Deploy Throw Phone, Recon Robot(t=120)Special Response Deploys (t=65) Deploy Large Robot (t=90)

Police Vehicle Fire

SWAT Sniper

Police Command

Helmet Cam

Ambulance

SWAT Vehicle

Swat Command

Throw Phone

Large Robot

Outer Perimeter

Inner Perimeter

Recon Robot

BARRICADED SUSPECT INCIDENTENTRY TEAM DEPLOYS

Command/Control

VideoControl

Sniper VideoRobot VideoRecon Rob VideoSniper Video

SecureMulticast

Time: 240 minPolice: 18Fire/EMS: 7SWAT: 30Negotiators: 2FBI: 2Commanders: 2Cmd/CntlVehicles : 1

Ten officers make entry with five lower res video feeds on person (helmet).

Entry Team Deploys

Secures Building and Suspect

10 (5+5) MHz10 (5+5) MHz10 (5+5) MHz10 (5+5) MHz

8.4 Mbps8.4 Mbps8.4 Mbps8.4 Mbps

20 (10+10) MHz20 (10+10) MHz20 (10+10) MHz20 (10+10) MHz

16.7 Mbps16.7 Mbps16.7 Mbps16.7 Mbps

10 (5+5) MHz10 (5+5) MHz10 (5+5) MHz10 (5+5) MHz

8.4 Mbps8.4 Mbps8.4 Mbps8.4 Mbps

20 (10+10) MHz20 (10+10) MHz20 (10+10) MHz20 (10+10) MHz

16.7 Mbps16.7 Mbps16.7 Mbps16.7 Mbps

Time: 240 minPolice: 18Fire/EMS: 7SWAT: 30Negotiators: 2FBI: 2Commanders: 2Cmd/CntlVehicles : 1Ten officers make entry with five lower res video feeds on person (helmet).

10 (5+5) MHz10 (5+5) MHz10 (5+5) MHz10 (5+5) MHz

3.5 Mbps 3.5 Mbps 3.5 Mbps 3.5 Mbps

20 (10+10) MHz20 (10+10) MHz20 (10+10) MHz20 (10+10) MHz

8.0 Mbps 8.0 Mbps 8.0 Mbps 8.0 Mbps

10 (5+5) MHz10 (5+5) MHz10 (5+5) MHz10 (5+5) MHz

3.5 Mbps 3.5 Mbps 3.5 Mbps 3.5 Mbps

20 (10+10) MHz20 (10+10) MHz20 (10+10) MHz20 (10+10) MHz

8.0 Mbps 8.0 Mbps 8.0 Mbps 8.0 Mbps

IDENTIFY(T = 0 MINUTES)

ISOLATE(T = 30 MINUTES)

BROADBAND APPLICATION EXAMPLE (2)

HAZMAT INCIDENT

NOTIFY(T = 75 MINUTES)

MITIGATE(T = 85 MINUTES)

INCIDENT SCENE

FIRE VEHICLETRUCK, SQUAD, ENGINE, HAZMAT

AMBULANCE

INCIDENT COMMAND

POLICE VEHICLE

HEL MET CAMERA

ENVIRONMENTAL SENSOR

MOBILE SURVEILLANCE CAMERA

HELICOPTER AERIAL CAMERA

SURVEILLANCE ROBOT

STATE, FEDERAL VEHICLE

MITIGATE (T=85 MINUTES)INCIDENT RESPONSE TEAMINCIDENT RESPONSE TEAMINCIDENT RESPONSE TEAMINCIDENT RESPONSE TEAM

T=8T=8T=8T=8

5555

COMMAND VAN 1

FIRE TRUCK/SQUAD/ENGINE 9

HAZMAT SUPPORT/DECON/TECH 4

AMBULANCE 4

COMMANDERS, COMMAND

SUPPORT7

FIRE/EMS PERSONNEL 52

POLICE 16

STATE POLICE, EPA AND

FEDERAL10

BROADBAND CAPACITY UTILIZATION - DOWNLINK

15

18 SITUATIONAL UPDATES (V2x1)

AERIAL VIDEO (V3x1)

PERIMETER TRIPOD VIDEO (V2x2)

0.3M

3.5M

0.8M

DOWNLINK APPLICATIONS

MEDIAN CAPACITY10+10 MHz

� All resources are now on scene, including two more chiefs (safety officer, public information)

� Two fully-suited haz-mat techs enter the house with a helmet camera and containment drums

� The first crew nears their air supply limitation and backs out, while the second team enters and continues containment

� Entry team two reports feeling sick and makes their exit, replaced by a third entry team. Ambulance crews begin treatment of the first and second entry teams and transport them to the hospital.

� Command watches in-building video and sensor data from the helmet camera, the camera left by the original entry team and the robot. Command also continues to observe surveillance aerial , perimeters and sector video

� Aerial video shows plume is expanding quickly to the north and command expands hot zone

� Command continues situational updates via video conference.

INCIDENT SCENE ACTIVITY

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

0

3

6

9

12

PERIMETER TRIPOD VIDEO (V2x2)

ROBOT SENSOR DATA, VIDEO (V3x2)

ENTRY TEAM SENSORS, VIDEO (V3, V4)

BUILDING SURV. TRIPOD VIDEO (V2x4)

DASH VIDEO (V2x1)

INCIDENT COMMAND DATA

BACKGROUND TRAFFIC, INCL. CAD

0.8M

2.4M

4.7M

1.5M

0.4M

-

2.0M

SITUATIONAL UPDATES (V2x1)

AERIAL VIDEO (V3x1)

PERIMETER TRIPOD VIDEO (V2x2)

ROBOT SENSOR DATA, VIDEO (V3x2)

ENTRY TEAM SENSORS, VIDEO (V3, V4)

BUILDING SURV. TRIPOD VIDEO (V2x4)

DASH VIDEO (V2x1)

INCIDENT COMMAND DATA

BACKGROUND TRAFFIC, INCL. CAD

0.3M

-

0.8M

2.4M

4.7M

1.5M

0.4M

-

1.0M

UPLINK APPLICATIONSBROADBAND CAPACITY UTILIZATION - UPLINK

MEDIAN CAPACITY10+10 MHz

16.7 Mbps

MEDIAN CAPACITY5+5 MHz

3.5 Mbps

MEDIAN CAPACITY10+10 MHz

8.0 Mbps

MEDIAN CAPACITY5+5 MHz

8.4 Mbps

VIDEO DATA

COVERAGE / CAPACITYCONSIDERATIONS

Incident Scene Detail

• Traffic in Three sectors prioritized for

Incident Scene Use

Move Incident Location from near BS to Cell Edge

0

5

10

15

20

25

y,

km

Simulation Geometry - Normalized Range Sweep

1

12

14

0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 10

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

4

4.5

5DL Spectral Efficiency 0.975 Reliability in 10MHz Bandwidth

Incident Placement Normalized Range

Sp

ectr

al

Eff

icie

ncy,

bp

s/H

z/s

ecto

r

0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 10

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45DL Sector Throughput in 10 + 10MHz channel

Incident Placement Normalized Range

Th

rou

gh

pu

t, M

bp

s

0.5

0.9

0.95

0.975

Incident Locations Mean

3GPP Uniform FB Mean

Background Traffic

• Uniform Geographic

-20 -10 0 10 20-25

-20

-15

-10

-5

x, km

y,

km

0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 10

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

0.25

0.3

0.35

0.4

0.45

0.5UL Spectral Efficiency 0.975 Reliability in 10MHz Bandwidth

Incident Placement Normalized Range

Sp

ectr

al

Eff

icie

ncy,

bp

s/H

z/s

ecto

r

0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 11

2

3

4

5

6

7DL Sector Throughput in 10 + 10MHz channel

Incident Placement Normalized Range

Th

rou

gh

pu

t, M

bp

s

0.5

0.9

0.95

0.975

Incident Locations Mean

3GPP Uniform FB Mean

CONSENSUS ON SPECTRUM NEEDS

SOURCE:European and GlobalHarmonisation of Spectrum for Public Protection and Disaster Relief (PPDR)

BROADBAND PUBLIC SAFETY IN US

• The United States was the first country to allocate broadband public safety

spectrum.

• Initially, 5+5 MHz spectrum was allocated for dedicated broadband public safety

spectrum. Earlier this year, the US Congress passed a law allocating an

additional 5+5 MHz of dedicated PSBB spectrum.

• Recently, Canada has also indicated its intention to follow a similar allocation.

• A number of broadband public safety LTE networks have been implemented in

this band.

• Europe's 700 MHz digital dividend is only 30+30 MHz and all of this will be

791 821 832 862

30 MHz DLIMT LTE

30 MHz ULIMT LTE

1

11 MHzDuplex Gap

Digital Dividend 2 (? MHz)

BROADBAND PUBLIC SAFETY IN EU

• Europe's 700 MHz digital dividend is only 30+30 MHz and all of this will be

allocated to public cellular operators.

• Broadband PPDR spectrum in EU may be found in Digital Dividend 2, which

is expected beyond 2015. The EU has set up a group called FM49 which is

studying the issue to suggest suitable broadband spectrum.

• Some countries in Europe are looking at interim solutions in the lower

frequency bands around 400 MHz.

APT Harmonised FDD Arrangement of 698-806 MHz band (3GPP LTE Band 28)

698 MHz 806 MHz45 MHz 45 MHz

PPDR/ LMR

DT TV

10 MHz

3GPP Band 28 UL 3GPP Band 28 DL

BROADBAND PUBLIC SAFETY IN ASIA

• Many Asian countries will adopt the APT band plan for the 700 MHz Digital

Dividend now adopted by 3GPP as Band 28 for LTE.

• Some countries in Asia will allocate the Lower 10+10 MHz (703-713/758-

768) for broadband PPDR.

• The advantage of the lower portion is that it will provide a buffer for the DTV

below 698 MHz in terms of coexistence and protection of TV services.

APT Harmonised FDD Arrangement of 698-806 MHz band (3GPP LTE Band 28)

803 806 824 849 851 880 890

NarrowBandLMS

NarrowBandLMS

GB EGSM 880 onwards

3GPP Band 26 DL

GSM

3GPP Band 26 UL3GPP Band 28 DL 3GPP Band

27 DL

3GPP Band

27 UL3GPP Band 5 DL

APT 700 DL

3GPP Band 5 UL

UMTS/CDMA

UMTS/CDMA

UMTS/CDMA

OTHER BB PPDR SPECTRUM OPTIONS

• Some Asian countries are looking at the 800 MHz band, which has been

planned by 3GPP for LTE under Bands 5,26 and 27. It is possible to have 10+10

MHz spectrum for broadband public safety within band 26. Australia is

considering broadband public safety spectrum in this band.

• Some Asian countries are also considering using the US band plan. Within the

US 700 MHz band, 3GPP Band 13 or 14 could be used for broadband PPDR

for which PSLTE devices are already available. In addition, China is considering

1.4 GHz band for broadband public safety.

PUBLIC SAFETYTOMORROW

360° REAL-TIME INTELLIGENT SENSINGENHANCING

SITUATIONAL AWARENESS

AUGMENTED REALITY

AUTOMATED CASE PROCESSING

CONTEXT AWARENESS / COORDINATION

360° REAL-TIME INTELLIGENT SENSING

AUGMENTED REALITY FOOT PURSUIT DETECTED SURVEILLANCE OFFICERTAKES ACTIONENHANCING

SITUATIONAL AWARENESS

AUTOMATED CASE PROCESSING

CONTEXT AWARENESS / COORDINATION

REAL-TIME CAMERA TRACKING/ANALYTICS

TO HELP PEOPLE BE THEIR BEST IN THE MOMENTS THAT MATTER, WE ARE…

� INVESTING $1B IN R&D ANNUALLY ON INNOVATION

� DELIVERING UNMATCHED CUSTOMER RESEARCH BY IMMERSING OURSELVES IN THE END-USER EXPERIENCE

� INNOVATE TO DRIVE THE NEXT GENERATION OF PUBLIC SAFETY WITH SOLUTIONS THAT ELEVATE THE USER EXPERINCE

� ADVOCATING FOR THE FUTURE SAFETY AND EFFECTIVENESS OF OUR CUSTOMERS

� BROADBAND TRANSFORMATION

� PUBLIC SAFETY TODAY� HIGH-SPEED DATA & VIDEO

� LTE IS TECHNOLOGY OF CHOICE

� DEDICATED SPECTRUM

SUMMARY

� DEDICATED SPECTRUM

� MINIMUM OF 20 MHz (10+10 MHz) SPECTRUM

� PUBLIC SAFETY TOMORROW� BROADBAND IS

FOUNDATIONAL

PAGE 35