+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Reduced Emergency Department Utilization by Patients With ......SAP To improve education and enhance...

Reduced Emergency Department Utilization by Patients With ......SAP To improve education and enhance...

Date post: 15-Nov-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 1 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
10
Reduced Emergency Department Utilization by Patients With Epilepsy Using QI Methodology Anup D. Patel, MD, a,b Eric G. Wood, BSISE, MBA, a Daniel M. Cohen, MD a,c a Department of Pediatrics, Nationwide Children’s Hospital, Columbus, Ohio; and Divisions of b Neurology and c Emergency Medicine, College of Medicine, The Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio Drs Patel and Cohen conceptualized and designed the study, drafted the initial manuscript, carried out the initial analyses, and reviewed and revised the manuscript; Mr Wood drafted the initial manuscript, carried out the initial analyses, and reviewed and revised the manuscript; and all authors approved the final manuscript as submitted. DOI: 10.1542/peds.2015-2358 Accepted for publication Aug 17, 2016 Address correspondence to Anup Patel, MD, ED533, 700 Children’s Dr, Columbus, OH 43205. E-mail: anup. [email protected] PEDIATRICS (ISSN Numbers: Print, 0031-4005; Online, 1098-4275). Copyright © 2017 by the American Academy of Pediatrics FINANCIAL DISCLOSURE: The authors have indicated they have no financial relationships relevant to this article to disclose. FUNDING: No external funding. POTENTIAL CONFLICT OF INTEREST: Dr Patel has research support from Pediatric Epilepsy Research Foundation and GW Pharmaceuticals, he provided consultation for Health Logix and Cyberonics, and he participated in webinar development for the American Academy of Neurology; Dr Cohen has research support from Pediatric Emergency Care Applied Research Network; and Mr Wood has indicated he has no potential conflicts of interest to disclose. At Nationwide Children’s Hospital, over 600 patients with epilepsy are seen in the emergency department (ED) each year. Throughout the United States, epilepsy or seizure care is the most common neurologic condition that presents to an ED, accounting for more than 1 million visits annually. 1 The majority of these cases are for children younger than 5 years. 2 Many such ED visits are preventable for children with epilepsy. 3 ED visits are costly and can consume time for caregivers and patients. 4 Attempts to improve the management of asthma in children and to decrease ED utilization by using quality improvement (QI) have been made with some success. 5–9 To date, no similar studies have been performed in pediatric epilepsy. A previous study suggested variables that if changed may prevent an ED visit in the first instance. 3 Therefore, we developed a comprehensive QI project utilizing the Institute for Healthcare Improvement model 10 in hopes of decreasing ED utilization for children with epilepsy. abstract BACKGROUND: Epilepsy or seizure care is the most common neurologic condition that presents to an emergency department (ED) and accounts for a large number of annual cases. Our aim was to decrease seizure-related ED visits from our baseline of 17 ED visits per month per 1000 patients to 13.6 ED visits per month per 1000 patients (20%) by July 2014. METHODS: Our strategy was to develop a quality improvement (QI) project utilizing the Institute for Healthcare Improvement model. Our defined outcome was to decrease ED utilization for children with epilepsy. Rate of ED visits as well as unplanned hospitalizations for epilepsy patients and associated health care costs were determined. A QI team was developed for this project. Plan do study act cycles were used with adjustments made when needed. RESULTS: Nineteen months after implementation of the interventions, ED visits were reduced by 28% (from 17 visits per month per 1000 patients to 12.2 per month per 1000 patients) during the past year. The average number of inpatient hospitalizations per month was reduced by 43% from 7 admissions per month per 1000 patients to 4 admissions per month per 1000 patients. For both outcome measures, a 2-sample Poisson rate exact test yielded a P value < .0001. Health care claims paid were less with $115 200 reduction for ED visits and $1 951 137 reduction for hospitalizations. CONCLUSIONS: Applying QI methodology was highly effective in reducing ED utilization and unplanned hospitalizations for children with epilepsy at a free-standing children’s hospital. QUALITY REPORT PEDIATRICS Volume 139, number 2, February 2017:e20152358 To cite: Patel AD, Wood EG, Cohen DM. Reduced Emergency Department Utilization by Patients With Epilepsy Using QI Methodology. Pediatrics. 2017;139(2):e20152358 by guest on April 28, 2021 www.aappublications.org/news Downloaded from
Transcript
Page 1: Reduced Emergency Department Utilization by Patients With ......SAP To improve education and enhance communication among patients with epilepsy and providers, we developed a SAP. By

Reduced Emergency Department Utilization by Patients With Epilepsy Using QI MethodologyAnup D. Patel, MD, a, b Eric G. Wood, BSISE, MBA, a Daniel M. Cohen, MDa, c

aDepartment of Pediatrics, Nationwide Children’s

Hospital, Columbus, Ohio; and Divisions of bNeurology and cEmergency Medicine, College of Medicine, The Ohio State

University, Columbus, Ohio

Drs Patel and Cohen conceptualized and designed

the study, drafted the initial manuscript, carried out

the initial analyses, and reviewed and revised the

manuscript; Mr Wood drafted the initial manuscript,

carried out the initial analyses, and reviewed and

revised the manuscript; and all authors approved

the fi nal manuscript as submitted.

DOI: 10.1542/peds.2015-2358

Accepted for publication Aug 17, 2016

Address correspondence to Anup Patel, MD, ED533,

700 Children’s Dr, Columbus, OH 43205. E-mail: anup.

[email protected]

PEDIATRICS (ISSN Numbers: Print, 0031-4005; Online,

1098-4275).

Copyright © 2017 by the American Academy of

Pediatrics

FINANCIAL DISCLOSURE: The authors have

indicated they have no fi nancial relationships

relevant to this article to disclose.

FUNDING: No external funding.

POTENTIAL CONFLICT OF INTEREST: Dr Patel has

research support from Pediatric Epilepsy Research

Foundation and GW Pharmaceuticals, he provided

consultation for Health Logix and Cyberonics,

and he participated in webinar development for

the American Academy of Neurology; Dr Cohen

has research support from Pediatric Emergency

Care Applied Research Network; and Mr Wood has

indicated he has no potential confl icts of interest

to disclose.

At Nationwide Children’s Hospital,

over 600 patients with epilepsy are

seen in the emergency department

(ED) each year. Throughout the United

States, epilepsy or seizure care is the

most common neurologic condition

that presents to an ED, accounting for

more than 1 million visits annually. 1

The majority of these cases are for

children younger than 5 years. 2 Many

such ED visits are preventable for

children with epilepsy. 3 ED visits

are costly and can consume time for

caregivers and patients. 4

Attempts to improve the management

of asthma in children and to decrease

ED utilization by using quality

improvement (QI) have been made

with some success. 5 –9 To date, no

similar studies have been performed

in pediatric epilepsy. A previous study

suggested variables that if changed

may prevent an ED visit in the first

instance. 3 Therefore, we developed a

comprehensive QI project utilizing the

Institute for Healthcare Improvement

model 10 in hopes of decreasing ED

utilization for children with epilepsy.

abstractBACKGROUND: Epilepsy or seizure care is the most common neurologic

condition that presents to an emergency department (ED) and accounts for

a large number of annual cases. Our aim was to decrease seizure-related ED

visits from our baseline of 17 ED visits per month per 1000 patients to 13.6

ED visits per month per 1000 patients (20%) by July 2014.

METHODS: Our strategy was to develop a quality improvement (QI) project

utilizing the Institute for Healthcare Improvement model. Our defined

outcome was to decrease ED utilization for children with epilepsy. Rate of

ED visits as well as unplanned hospitalizations for epilepsy patients and

associated health care costs were determined. A QI team was developed

for this project. Plan do study act cycles were used with adjustments made

when needed.

RESULTS: Nineteen months after implementation of the interventions, ED

visits were reduced by 28% (from 17 visits per month per 1000 patients

to 12.2 per month per 1000 patients) during the past year. The average

number of inpatient hospitalizations per month was reduced by 43%

from 7 admissions per month per 1000 patients to 4 admissions per

month per 1000 patients. For both outcome measures, a 2-sample Poisson

rate exact test yielded a P value < .0001. Health care claims paid were

less with $115 200 reduction for ED visits and $1 951 137 reduction for

hospitalizations.

CONCLUSIONS: Applying QI methodology was highly effective in reducing ED

utilization and unplanned hospitalizations for children with epilepsy at a

free-standing children’s hospital.

QUALITY REPORTPEDIATRICS Volume 139 , number 2 , February 2017 :e 20152358

To cite: Patel AD, Wood EG, Cohen DM. Reduced

Emergency Department Utilization by Patients

With Epilepsy Using QI Methodology. Pediatrics.

2017;139(2):e20152358

by guest on April 28, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 2: Reduced Emergency Department Utilization by Patients With ......SAP To improve education and enhance communication among patients with epilepsy and providers, we developed a SAP. By

PATEL et al

Our goal was to decrease ED visits

and unplanned hospitalization

to improve the quality of care for

the patient, improve patient and

caregiver experience by providing

improved access to specialty

outpatient care and education, and to

decrease health care costs as a result.

Our primary aim statement defined

our targeted improvement goal: to

decrease ED visits from our baseline

of 17 ED visits per month per 1000

patients to 13.6 ED visits per month

per 1000 patients (20%) by July 2014

and sustain the decrease ( Fig 1). In

addition, a secondary aim was to

decrease unplanned hospitalizations

as defined by a patient being

admitted after being seen in the ED

from 7 admissions per month per

1000 patients to 5.6 admissions per

month per 1000 patients by 20%

from our baseline. The balancing

measures for our project included

readmissions to the hospital within

30 days, overall mortality of our

epilepsy population, and patients

seen again in the ED within 72 hours

of an ED visit.

METHODS

Context

Nationwide Children’s is a

freestanding pediatric hospital

with 427 licensed beds and the sole

pediatric tertiary care facility in

Central Ohio. The ED has 62 beds

and is a level 1 American College

of Surgeons certified pediatric

trauma center with 86 060 visits in

2014. Nationwide Children’s serves

over 3000 children with epilepsy.

Epilepsy patients are seen by a

pediatric neurology service that

includes 29 neurology physicians

with 9 specifically trained in epilepsy

care. In addition, 6 advanced

practice nurses and 1 physician

assistant provide patient care. The

neurology division completes over

7000 epilepsy-related patient care

visits in the outpatient setting each

year. Outpatient clinics occur 5

days a week (Monday to Friday)

from 8 AM to 5 PM. A comprehensive

multidisciplinary outpatient epilepsy

center exists and serves ∼50% of the

active epilepsy patients and occurs 2

days per week. This center is staffed

by the 9 epilepsy physicians and 3

advanced practice nurses. In addition,

the center consists of social work and

other related care providers to assist

epilepsy patients and their families.

Interventions around each key

driver were developed with 5 being

implemented sequentially over the

subsequent 12 months. The 5 major

e2

FIGURE 1Key driver diagram.

by guest on April 28, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 3: Reduced Emergency Department Utilization by Patients With ......SAP To improve education and enhance communication among patients with epilepsy and providers, we developed a SAP. By

PEDIATRICS Volume 139 , number 2 , February 2017

interventions, annotated in Figs 2

and 3, included the following: (1)

beginning an established urgent

epilepsy clinic (UEC) to improve

access; (2) deploying a seizure action

plan (SAP) to improve knowledge

around home seizure management;

(3) supporting proper dosing of

abortive seizure medications via

the electronic health record (EHR);

(4) providing reminder magnets

with instructions of use for abortive

seizure medications; and (5) review

of previous high utilizers of the ED

for epilepsy care to address unique

issues.

Interventions

UEC

Our first and highest intensity

intervention was the established UEC

that developed the ability to access

outpatient epilepsy care urgently.

The UEC was not created de-novo,

but instead was a reorganization

of an existing clinic to allow for

2 additional appointments with

additional time allocated. The UEC

was staffed by an epilepsy nurse

practitioner and an epilepsy social

worker. The clinic was held 4 days a

week, either morning or afternoon

(Monday, Tuesday, Thursday,

and Friday). Two such clinic

appointments were available per

each session with extended patient

time (60 or more minutes) to ensure

all issues were addressed properly

and education about epilepsy

care was given. Appointments

were scheduled flexibly as add-on

appointments as triggered by the

neurology triage nurses who were

given a list of “red flags” and by

any neurology provider, including

residents while taking night call for

neurology.

SAP

To improve education and enhance

communication among patients with

epilepsy and providers, we developed

a SAP. By analogy, an asthma action

plan has been successfully used

previously. 5 However, minimal work

in this area has been performed

in epilepsy. 11 –14 The action plan

was developed to mirror the

appearance of the asthma action plan.

Information about seizure baseline,

when caregivers should contact

neurology, and other important

information were available on the

plan in a color-coded scheme utilizing

green, yellow, and red zones.

Abortive Seizure Medication Dosing and Magnets

One variable known to increase ED

utilization is not having or having

inappropriate dosing of abortive

seizure medication. 3 Therefore,

e3

FIGURE 2ED visits for epilepsy patients.

by guest on April 28, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 4: Reduced Emergency Department Utilization by Patients With ......SAP To improve education and enhance communication among patients with epilepsy and providers, we developed a SAP. By

PATEL et al

utilizing the EHR, a dosing guide

and alert system was developed to

assist providers in prescribing the

correct dose for abortive seizure

medication. If incorrect doses were

selected, an EHR alert would notify

the prescriber of the recommended

dose. Additionally, a dosing guide

with recommendations on the basis

of age and weight was attached to

the order. To improve education and

reminders for caregivers, a magnet

was given for the prescribed abortive

medication with detailed instructions

on proper medication administration.

It was given in conjunction with the

SAP.

Review of High Utilizing Patients

During the last 9 months (November

2014 to July) of the project, we

deployed extrapolation and review

of data from EPIC by developing

and utilizing a dashboard. We used

Qlikview, which is a data processing

and analysis software tool (Qlik,

Lund, Sweden). This enabled the

presentation of daily updates and

trends of actionable information

including no-shows to our outpatient

epilepsy clinic, ED visits, and

hospitalizations. Review of patients

with high ED utilization occurred

monthly by the QI team to determine

if further action was needed.

Study of the Interventions

For each of the above 5 interventions,

plan do study act (PDSA) cycles were

used with adjustments made as

necessary on the basis of the analysis

of the cycle. By design, we initiated

our highest intensity intervention,

the UEC, first to evaluate the effect of

that isolated intervention. The UEC

was initiated in October 2013. Our

PDSA cycles for each intervention

consisted of obtaining feedback

provided by staff and patients. For

the UEC, feedback was obtained

after the first 20 patients were seen.

Feedback was obtained for all other

interventions implemented. This

approach was felt most useful as

changes to work flow and caregiver

engagement was the major focus of

our interventions.

Measures

To identify patients for this project,

International Classification of Diseases, Ninth Revision codes were

used. Our population consisted of

those with a completed office visit

within a rolling 13 months who had

a primary or secondary diagnosis of

epilepsy (345.xx). Current Procedural Terminology codes were used to

identify the completed office visit.

e4

FIGURE 3Unplanned hospitalizations to the inpatient neurology unit for epilepsy patients.

by guest on April 28, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 5: Reduced Emergency Department Utilization by Patients With ......SAP To improve education and enhance communication among patients with epilepsy and providers, we developed a SAP. By

PEDIATRICS Volume 139 , number 2 , February 2017

An ED visit was included if the visit

was related to a seizure (780.39)

or epilepsy (345.xx) as either

the primary or secondary reason

listed for the visit. An unplanned

hospitalization was counted if the

ED visit resulted in the patient being

admitted to the inpatient neurology

service at Nationwide Children’s

Hospital.

For the financial analysis, health

care utilizations costs required

estimation, as the outcome was a

lack of ED visit or hospitalization.

Therefore, these costs were

estimated by previous average claims

paid data available during the study

period at our institutions, which

were as follows: $640 per visit per

ED visit and $18 066 per unplanned

hospitalization. We considered the

additional costs attributed to the UEC

in our final total savings calculations

for the level 5 office visit, which

amounts to $133 in each claim paid

for each visit. These add-on cases

were felt to be a portion of the full

effort for the nurse practitioner and

social worker and not additional

utilization of resources. SAP

implementation was monitored

during the project.

The Institute for Healthcare

Improvement model for QI 11

was used as the foundation of

this initiative and study design.

Baseline ED visits were measured

over a retrospective period of 18

months (from January 2012 to

June 2013) before initiating any

interventions. The baseline period

established that ED visits ( Fig 2)

shows a process in control, with

no special cause variation trends

and no seasonality associated with

epilepsy patient care activity. The

same held true for the baseline for

unplanned hospitalizations ( Fig 3).

The improvement time, after the

first successful intervention, was a

19-month period (from November

2013 through July 2015). A 20%

reduction was chosen on the basis of

our group’s consensus of feasibility.

We used mortality and hospital

readmissions as balancing measures

for this project.

Key drivers or barriers for ED

use were identified by using

several techniques such as process

maps and an affinity diagram

from brainstorming sessions. In

addition, previous literature and

best practices were used for key

driver development. 3 Major drivers

identified were as follows: system

and communication issues within and

outside of neurology; lack of access to

resources by family and other health

care providers; patient and caregiver

comorbidities and beliefs; and a need

to enhance education about epilepsy

care for patients and caregivers.

Analysis

For the purposes of our analysis,

we defined a shift in data as 8

consecutive data points below our

baseline. 15 The primary data were

generated from our EHR system

(EPIC). Two analysts performed an

independent review and validation to

verify accuracy of our data queries.

Control charts (a Statistical Process

Control tool) 15 were employed

to monitor the outcome metrics:

monthly baseline ED visits and

unplanned hospitalizations, with

the interventions recorded as

implemented over time ( Figs 2 and 3).

The particular type of chart used

to monitor the ED and inpatient

processes (the U chart) displays the

number of random events occurring

during an opportunity “window” as

measured by calendar days, patient

days, etc, as appropriate for the

type of events being measured. We

used a U chart to control for the

increase in unique patients with

epilepsy seen at our institution,

which started at 3167 patients and

consisted of 3426 patients at our

last data point. Epilepsy ED visits

per 1000 patients per month is our

illustration. The Poisson statistical

distribution, the distribution

assumed by the U chart, is typically

well suited for representing such

events. Accordingly, tests for

statistical significance made use

of the 2-sample Poisson rate test.

For SAP monitoring, tracking of

implementation was monitored when

used within the EHR.

Ethical Considerations

This QI project was discussed

and approved by the Director of

Quality Improvement at Nationwide

Children’s Hospital. Updates were

provided monthly via written reports

and presented quarterly to the QI

administration team consisting of

the Division Chief of Neurology,

Director of Quality Improvement, and

Chief Medical Officer at Nationwide

Children’s Hospital. Institutional

review board approval at our

institution is not required, nor is

a letter of exemption needed to

perform QI as the work performed

was for QI purposes.

RESULTS

Nineteen months after

implementation of the interventions

to reduce ED utilization, ED visits

were decreased from 17 visits per

month per 1000 patients to 12.2

per month per 1000 patients (28%;

Fig 2), P < .0001. Additionally,

the average number of inpatient

hospitalizations per month was

reduced by 43% from 7 admissions

per month per 1000 patients to 4

admissions per month per 1000

patients ( Fig 3) per year, P < .0001.

Improvements occurred over time

with implementation of each of the

5 interventions ( Fig 1). The greatest

impact was associated with use of

the UEC. After implementation of the

established UEC in October 2013, a

shift in our baseline was noted ( Fig 2).

Two hundred ninety-one patients

were seen in this clinic during the

time of the project. Overall, 93%

of the scheduled patients attended

the clinic. The average show rate

for neurology patients at our center

e5 by guest on April 28, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 6: Reduced Emergency Department Utilization by Patients With ......SAP To improve education and enhance communication among patients with epilepsy and providers, we developed a SAP. By

PATEL et al

is 80%. The estimated time spent

per patient was 1.5 hours for the

nurse practitioner for visit time

and documentation, 1.75 hours

per patient for social worker, and

minimal additional administrative

assistant support. A PDSA after

the first 20 patients revealed that

families felt more comfortable with

the epilepsy care after the visit. Most

families have expressed appreciation

of the quickness the appointment

was scheduled and the time spent.

Utilization of the SAP increased

over time through dissemination

mostly from the outpatient clinics

in the Pediatric Epilepsy Center at

Nationwide Children’s Hospital.

SAP implementation improved from

a baseline of 0 to ∼418 (of 3426

epilepsy patients served at our

center) by July 2015. During our

PDSA for the SAP, we sampled 10

families who received the SAP and

surveyed utilizing providers. When

we inquired during our PDSA cycles,

families reported having a better

comfort and understanding of what

to do during an epileptic seizure.

Additional information in the form of

specific instructions on whom to call

was added.

After implementation of the

dosing reminder into our EHR,

the proportion of seizure patients

prescribed an accurate abortive

medication for seizure care improved

when implemented in September

2014 from a baseline of 0 to 100%

after being built into our EHR. In

addition, the instruction magnet for

abortive medications was used for

all patients. Feedback from epilepsy

providers, nurses, and caregivers

of patients were obtained during

the initial PDSA and changes to the

magnet design and instructions were

made before full implementation was

performed.

In regards to health care costs,

given the reduction in ED visits and

unplanned hospitalizations, we

calculated a savings in health care

utilization of $115 200 for ED visits

and $1 951 137 for hospitalizations.

To attribute additional costs of

the UEC, a level 5 follow-up visit

was billed for these appointments

with a claims paid associated with

$133 per visit. Approximately 291

patients were seen in the established

UEC through July 2015. Therefore,

$39 867 was attributed to the cost of

this intervention in generated claims.

Other costs of supplies, material

preparation, and changes to EHR

modules could not be calculated

because they are not separately

collected at our institution and part

of our overall structure.

Our balancing measures

included seizure-related hospital

readmissions, which decreased

from a baseline of 22 in 2012 to

12 in 2014, whereas readmissions

for other neurologic conditions

remained virtually unchanged (18 to

21). A second balancing measure was

mortality of patients with epilepsy in

our population. It remained the same

in the overall epilepsy population

(10 in 2012 and 9 in 2014). A third

measure was patients seen back

in the ED within 72 hours where

our baseline was 4.0% and with

1.7% noted during our intervention

implementation period.

DISCUSSION

Summary

For this QI project, our team was

able to decrease seizure-related

ED visits by 28% and unplanned

hospitalizations by 43% for children

with epilepsy at Nationwide

Children’s Hospital. Cost savings to

the health care system was noted as a

result of the reduction in health care

utilization. Phased interventions for

epilepsy patients to reduce ED visits

and unplanned hospitalizations were

employed with success by improving

access to ambulatory outpatient

epilepsy care and increased

education on epilepsy management.

The intervention determined most

successful was the development of

the established UEC staffed by an

epilepsy nurse practitioner and a

social worker. We felt that the social

work support was equally important

as the medical decision-making.

A significant amount of time spent

in this clinic was for education,

counseling, and addressing

psychosocial risk factors. Given the

psychosocial complexities of helping

families manage seizures, including

parental concerns and anxiety, as

well as school- and work-related

contingencies, the role of social

workers may be important to the

success of our model. Future work is

needed to validate this finding.

Lack of proper knowledge about

epilepsy emergency care was

targeted via the SAP. It was also used

as an educational tool for providers

in discussing how to approach

emergency care for acute seizures.

The SAP appeared to be well received

by our patients and their families

with potential expansion of use to

the school system on the basis of the

informal feedback obtained. Further

studies evaluating improvement on

the impact of epilepsy are ongoing.

Our SAP was different from a recent

published study. 14 This study

discussed limitations that may have

resulted in their lack of change

noted. They note that their SAP was

not color coded and had a lot of

information about daily medications,

which may have confused the patient.

They implemented their plan in the

inpatient setting only. 14 We used

color coding, simplified language,

and implemented the plan in all

care settings. The low rate of SAP

implementation was felt secondary

to the time needed for it to be built

within our EHR and dissemination by

providers. Therefore, it was not likely

a major contributing factor to the ED

and hospital reduction.

Previous literature has demonstrated

that improper dosing or lack of an

abortive medication when applicable

e6 by guest on April 28, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 7: Reduced Emergency Department Utilization by Patients With ......SAP To improve education and enhance communication among patients with epilepsy and providers, we developed a SAP. By

PEDIATRICS Volume 139 , number 2 , February 2017

may contribute to increased health

care utilization. 3 Often, the medical

provider does not audit dosing to

determine if changes are needed

to account for patient growth.

Reminders to providers using

behavioral economic principles 16, 17

have been used previously with other

medications and can be a successful

technique when built into an EHR

used for prescribing medications.

In addition, the magnets served

as reminders of how to give an

abortive medication and allowed for

additional caregivers not present for

the initial education to have a basic

understanding of abortive medication

administration. Further, it served

to remind caregivers on where the

medication was located within the

home setting. These reminder cues

as a behavioral economic principle 17

can also be helpful for caregivers.

We began reviewing patients with

high ED utilization as an intervention.

A high risk ED utilizing patient is

defined currently as one that has

used the ED for their epilepsy-related

care 4 or more times in the previous

year. Unlike asthma, where high

ED utilization in 1 year does not

necessarily predict subsequent high

utilization, 18 the same cannot be said

about epilepsy. Recent publications

highlighted that high ED utilization

in 1 year is predictive of high ED

utilization the following year. 19 – 21

Interpretation

Applying QI methodology can be very

effective in reducing unnecessary

ED utilization and unplanned

hospitalizations for children with

epilepsy. Reducing such utilization

can have a significant cost savings

to the overall health care system.

In previous studies, it was noted

that such utilization accounted for

the majority of health care costs for

patients with epilepsy. 16

Limitations

Limitations exist in our ability to

calculate a true cost savings because

we could not calculate the exact cost

of intervention implementation. Until

models such as the University of

Utah’s program to calculate true costs

become available, this limitation will

exist in any similar study. 22 Costing

out the professionals’ time provides

the most conservative estimate of

the costs of improvement, which

would allow others who wish to

replicate this effort a more accurate

understanding of the percent effort

required to duplicate the UEC

locally. At our institution, we did

not use additional resources. These

appointments were in addition to

the normally scheduled visits and

considered a portion of the full effort

used in salary determination for our

nurse practitioner and social work

positions.

Another limitation is how 1 specific

intervention affects the entirety of

the study period. To account for this

limitation, interventions were phased

in from our key driver diagram.

Further, randomized control trials,

which traditionally serve as the gold

standard study method, were not

performed and not easily possible

in this setting. Patient care occurs in

real time and interventions need to

be applied actively and aggressively

for active substantial improvement

to be seen. Further, external factors

unknown to the QI team may have

an effect on the overall population of

epilepsy patients seen at Nationwide

Children’s Hospital. Our balancing

measures performed well for the

project, suggesting more harm was

not performed elsewhere in the

system.

CONCLUSIONS

As provisions of the Affordable Care

Act become further implemented, 23

focusing on value and quality,

compared with quantity, will be

increasingly crucial. Health care

currently consumes a great portion

of our gross domestic product with

control of costs while maintaining or

increasing quality of care desperately

needed. Medical providers are

best suited for controlling health

care costs. One technique for cost

reduction is by implementing QI

methodology, which has been

found successful in other models of

care. 24 Efforts to increase outpatient

clinic utilization while decreasing

unnecessary less effective utilization

will continue to improve the patient

experience, increase the quality of

care, and reduce health care costs,

thus achieving the Triple Aim of

Healthcare.

ABBREVIATIONS

ED:  emergency department

EHR:  electronic health record

PDSA:  plan do study act

QI:  quality improvement

SAP:  seizure action plan

UEC:  urgent epilepsy clinic

REFERENCES

1. Pallin DJ, Goldstein JN, Moussally

JS, Pelletier AJ, Green AR, Camargo

CA Jr. Seizure visits in US emergency

departments: epidemiology and

potential disparities in care. Int J

Emerg Med. 2008;1(2):97–105

2. Martindale JL, Goldstein JN, Pallin

DJ. Emergency department seizure

epidemiology. Emerg Med Clin North

Am. 2011;29(1):15–27

3. Patel AD. Variables associated with

emergency department and/or

unplanned hospital utilization for

children with epilepsy. Epilepsy Behav.

2014;31:172–175

4. Ryan JL, McGrady ME, Guilfoyle SM,

Junger K, Arnett AD, Modi AC. Health

care charges for youth with newly

diagnosed epilepsy. Neurology.

2015;85(6):490–497

5. Teach SJ, Crain EF, Quint DM, Hylan

ML, Joseph JG. Improved asthma

outcomes in a high-morbidity pediatric

population: results of an emergency

department-based randomized clinical

trial. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med.

2006;160(5):535–541

e7 by guest on April 28, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 8: Reduced Emergency Department Utilization by Patients With ......SAP To improve education and enhance communication among patients with epilepsy and providers, we developed a SAP. By

PATEL et al

6. Teach SJ, Gergen PJ, Szefl er SJ, et al.

Seasonal risk factors for asthma

exacerbations among inner-city

children. J Allergy Clin Immunol.

2015;135(6):1465–73.e5

7. Alpern ER, Calello DP, Windreich R,

Osterhoudt K, Shaw KN. Utilization and

unexpected hospitalization rates of

a pediatric emergency department

23-hour observation unit. Pediatr

Emerg Care. 2008;24(9):589–594

8. Alpern ER, Clark AE, Alessandrini

EA, et al; Pediatric Emergency Care

Applied Research Network (PECARN).

Recurrent and high-frequency use

of the emergency department by

pediatric patients. Acad Emerg Med.

2014;21(4):365–373

9. Adams RJ, Smith BJ, Ruffi n RE. Factors

associated with hospital admissions

and repeat emergency department

visits for adults with asthma. Thorax.

2000;55(7):566–573

10. Berwick DM, Nolan TW, Whittington

J. The triple aim: care, health,

and cost. Health Aff (Millwood).

2008;27(3):759–769

11. Davidoff F, Batalden P, Stevens D, Ogrinc

G, Mooney SE; SQUIRE development

group. Publication guidelines for

quality improvement studies in health

care: evolution of the SQUIRE project.

BMJ. 2009;338:a3152

12. Ogrinc G, Davies L, Goodman D,

Batalden P, Davidoff F, Stevens D.

SQUIRE 2.0 (Standards for Quality

Improvement Reporting Excellence):

revised publication guidelines from a

detailed consensus process. BMJ Qual

Saf. 2015;bmjqs-2015-004411

13. Ogrinc G, Davies L, Goodman D,

Batalden P, Davidoff F, Stevens D.

SQUIRE 2.0 (Standards for Quality

Improvement Reporting Excellence):

revised publication guidelines from a

detailed consensus process. Am J Med

Qual. 2015;30(6):543–549

14. Roundy LM, Filloux FM, Kerr L, Rimer

A, Bonkowsky JL. Seizure action plans

do not reduce health care utilization

in pediatric epilepsy patients. J Child

Neurol. 2016;31(4):433–438

15. Benneyan JC, Lloyd RC, Plsek PE.

Statistical process control as a

tool for research and healthcare

improvement. Qual Saf Health Care.

2003;12(6):458–464

16. Manjunath R, Paradis PE, Parisé H, et al.

Burden of uncontrolled epilepsy in

patients requiring an emergency room

visit or hospitalization. Neurology.

2012;79(18):1908–1916

17. Stevens J. Behavioral economics

as a promising framework for

promoting treatment adherence to

pediatric regimens. J Pediatr Psychol.

2014;39(10):1097–1103

18. Nash DR, Childs GE, Kelleher KJ.

A cohort study of resource use by

Medicaid children with asthma.

Pediatrics. 1999;104(2 pt 1):310–312

19. Grinspan ZM, Abramson EL, Banerjee

S, Kern LM, Kaushal R, Shapiro JS.

People with epilepsy who use multiple

hospitals; prevalence and associated

factors assessed via a health

information exchange. Epilepsia.

2014;55(5):734–745

20. Grinspan ZM, Shapiro JS, Abramson

EL, Jung HY, Kaushal R, Kern LM.

Hospital crossover increases

utilization for people with epilepsy: a

retrospective cohort study. Epilepsia.

2015;56(1):147–157

21. Grinspan ZM, Shapiro JS, Abramson

EL, Hooker G, Kaushal R, Kern LM.

Predicting frequent ED use by

people with epilepsy with health

information exchange data. Neurology.

2015;85(12):1031–1038

22. Kawamoto K, Martin CJ, Williams K,

et al. Value Driven Outcomes (VDO): a

pragmatic, modular, and extensible

software framework for understanding

and improving health care costs and

outcomes. J Am Med Inform Assoc.

2015;22(1):223–235

23. Molinari C. Does the Accountable Care

Act aim to promote quality, health,

and control costs or has it missed the

mark? Comment on “Health system

reform in the United States”. Int J

Health Policy Manag. 2014;2(2):97–99

24. Kelleher KJ, Cooper J, Deans K, et al.

Cost saving and quality of care

in a pediatric accountable care

organization. Pediatrics. 2015;135(3).

Available at: www. pediatrics. org/ cgi/

content/ full/ 135/ 3/ e582

e8 by guest on April 28, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 9: Reduced Emergency Department Utilization by Patients With ......SAP To improve education and enhance communication among patients with epilepsy and providers, we developed a SAP. By

DOI: 10.1542/peds.2015-2358 originally published online January 20, 2017; 2017;139;Pediatrics 

Anup D. Patel, Eric G. Wood and Daniel M. CohenMethodology

Reduced Emergency Department Utilization by Patients With Epilepsy Using QI

ServicesUpdated Information &

http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/139/2/e20152358including high resolution figures, can be found at:

Referenceshttp://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/139/2/e20152358#BIBLThis article cites 24 articles, 9 of which you can access for free at:

Subspecialty Collections

subhttp://www.aappublications.org/cgi/collection/neurologic_disorders_Neurologic Disordershttp://www.aappublications.org/cgi/collection/neurology_subNeurologysubhttp://www.aappublications.org/cgi/collection/quality_improvement_Quality Improvement_management_subhttp://www.aappublications.org/cgi/collection/administration:practiceAdministration/Practice Managementfollowing collection(s): This article, along with others on similar topics, appears in the

Permissions & Licensing

http://www.aappublications.org/site/misc/Permissions.xhtmlin its entirety can be found online at: Information about reproducing this article in parts (figures, tables) or

Reprintshttp://www.aappublications.org/site/misc/reprints.xhtmlInformation about ordering reprints can be found online:

by guest on April 28, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 10: Reduced Emergency Department Utilization by Patients With ......SAP To improve education and enhance communication among patients with epilepsy and providers, we developed a SAP. By

DOI: 10.1542/peds.2015-2358 originally published online January 20, 2017; 2017;139;Pediatrics 

Anup D. Patel, Eric G. Wood and Daniel M. CohenMethodology

Reduced Emergency Department Utilization by Patients With Epilepsy Using QI

http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/139/2/e20152358located on the World Wide Web at:

The online version of this article, along with updated information and services, is

by the American Academy of Pediatrics. All rights reserved. Print ISSN: 1073-0397. the American Academy of Pediatrics, 345 Park Avenue, Itasca, Illinois, 60143. Copyright © 2017has been published continuously since 1948. Pediatrics is owned, published, and trademarked by Pediatrics is the official journal of the American Academy of Pediatrics. A monthly publication, it

by guest on April 28, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from


Recommended