Page 1
NBER WORKING PAPER SERIES
REFERENCE PRICES AND NOMINAL RIGIDITIES
Martin EichenbaumNir JaimovichSergio Rebelo
Working Paper 13829http://www.nber.org/papers/w13829
NATIONAL BUREAU OF ECONOMIC RESEARCH1050 Massachusetts Avenue
Cambridge, MA 02138March 2008
We would like to thank Eric Anderson, Liran Einav, Pete Klenow, John Leahy, Aviv Nevo, FrankSmets, and Sofia Villas-Boas for their comments. We gratefully acknowledge financial support fromthe National Science Foundation. The views expressed herein are those of the author(s) and do notnecessarily reflect the views of the National Bureau of Economic Research.
NBER working papers are circulated for discussion and comment purposes. They have not been peer-reviewed or been subject to the review by the NBER Board of Directors that accompanies officialNBER publications.
© 2008 by Martin Eichenbaum, Nir Jaimovich, and Sergio Rebelo. All rights reserved. Short sectionsof text, not to exceed two paragraphs, may be quoted without explicit permission provided that fullcredit, including © notice, is given to the source.
Page 2
Reference Prices and Nominal RigiditiesMartin Eichenbaum, Nir Jaimovich, and Sergio RebeloNBER Working Paper No. 13829March 2008, Revised September 2009JEL No. E30
ABSTRACT
We assess the importance of nominal rigidities using a new weekly scanner data set. We find that nominalrigidities are important but do not take the form of sticky prices. Instead, they take the form of inertiain reference prices and costs, defined as the most common prices and costs within a given quarter.Reference prices are particularly inertial and have an average duration of roughly one year, even thoughweekly prices change roughly every two weeks. We document the relation between prices and costsand find sharp evidence of state dependence in the probability of reference price changes and in themagnitude of these changes. We use a simple model to argue that reference prices and costs are usefulstatistics for macroeconomic analysis.
Martin EichenbaumDepartment of EconomicsNorthwestern University2003 Sheridan RoadEvanston, IL 60208and [email protected]
Nir JaimovichDepartment of Economics579 Serra MallStanford UniversityStanford, CA 94305-6072and [email protected]
Sergio RebeloNorthwestern UniversityKellogg School of ManagementDepartment of FinanceLeverone HallEvanston, IL 60208-2001and [email protected]
Page 37
!"#$%&'(&)"*+,&*-".*.,*&
/0+1"02&
3"-"&*%-
451+6+,7*&
3"-"&*%-
!"#$%&#'"(#(%#
80",.56&59&:%%7*&*;%6-&"-&-<%&0%9%0%6,%&;0+,% =>?@ =>AA
80",.56&59&:%%7*&*;%6-&"-&-<%&0%9%0%6,%&,5*- =>BC 6>">
80",.56&59&DE"0-%0*&+6&:<+,<&:%%7$2&;0+,%*&"0%&,56*-"6-&950&-<%&:<5$%&DE"0-%0 =>'' =>'F
80",.56&59&DE"0-%0*&+6&:<+,<&:%%7$2&,5*-&+*&,56*-"6-&950&-<%&:<5$%&DE"0-%0 =>=? 6>">
80",.56&59&656G0%9%0%6,%&;0+,%*&-<"-&"0%&"#5H%&0%9%0%6,%&;0+,%*II 0.21 =>J=
80",.56&59&;0+,%&,<"6K%*&-<"-&"0%&9051&"&656G0%9%0%6,%&;0+,%&-5&"&0%9%0%6,%&;0+,% =>@F =>C'
80",.56&59&,5*-&,<"6K%*&-<"-&"0%&9051&"&656G0%9%0%6,%&,5*-&-5&"&0%9%0%6,%&,5*- =>@B 6>">
80",.56&59&DE"6..%*&*5$3&"-&0%9%0%6,%&;0+,%* =>CF =>??
80",.56&59&0%H%6E%&,5$$%,-%3&"-&0%9%0%6,%&;0+,%* 0.54 =>?L
/05#"#+$+-2&59&:%%7$2&;0+,%&,<"6K+6K&:<%6&:%%7$2&,5*-&35%*&65-&,<"6K% =>=J 6>">
/05#"#+$+-2&59&0%9%0%6,%&;0+,%&,<"6K+6K&:<%6&0%9%0%6,%&,5*-&35%*&65-&,<"6K% =>'B 6>">
IIM51;E-%3&5E-&59&-<%&-5-"$&:%%7*&+6&:<+,<&-<%&:%%7$2&;0+,%&+*&3+N%0%6-&9051&-<%&0%9%0%6,%&;0+,%>
Page 38
!"#$%&'(&)*$"+$,-.&/0*/%0+%1
20,3"0.&
4"-"&1%-
5*3,6,781&
4"-"&1%-
9!:;5:<5&5=)>:!>?;&?@&A=)=A9
!"#$%#&%'%()*#+,$',-'./#$++(0
A*BCD%%8$.&EF"6+-.G& 0.53 HIJK
A*BCEF"6++%1&1*$4&"-&0%L%0%67%&/0,7%G& 0.42 HIMN
A*BCEF"6++%1&1*$4&"-&6*6O0%L%0%67%&/0,7%1G& 0.43 HIM'
!"#$%#&%'%()*#+,$',-'1&*2(0
A*BCD%%8$.&/0,7%G& 0.14 HINN
A*BC0%L%0%67%&/0,7%G& 0.08 HIHK
A*BCD%%8$.&/0,7%GP&7*64,+*6"$&*6&D%%8$.&/0,7%&7Q"6B% 0.15 HINR
A*BC0%L%0%67%&/0,7%GP&7*64,+*6"$&*6&0%L%0%67%&/0,7%&7Q"6B% 0.10 HIHK
!"#$%#&%'%()*#+,$',-'2,0"0
A*BCD%%8$.&7*1-G 0.12 6I"I
A*BC0%L%0%67%&7*1-G 0.07 6I"I
A*BCD%%8$.&7*1-GP&7*64,+*6"$&*6&7*1-&7Q"6B% 0.13 6I"I
A*BC0%L%0%67%&7*1-GP&7*64,+*6"$&*6&7*1-&7Q"6B% 0.08 6I"I
!"#$%#&%'%()*#+,$',-'1&*2(03!"#$%#&%'%()*#+,$',-'2,0"04
S%%8$.&/0,7%1TD%%8$.&7*1-1 1.08 6I"I
<%L%0%67%&/0,7%1T0%L%0%67%&7*1-1 1.15 6I"I
S%%8$.&/0,7%1P&7*64,+*6"$&*6&/0,7%&7Q"6B%1TD%%8$.&7*1-&7*64,+*6"$&*6&7*1-&7Q"6B% 1.08 6I"I
<%L%0%67%&/0,7%P&7*64,+*6"$&*6&/0,7%&7Q"6B%1T0%L%0%67%&7*1-P&7*64,+*6"$&*6&7*1-&7Q"6B%1 1.17 6I"I
!"#$%#&%'%()*#+,$',-'5#&6/1
A*BCD%%8$.&3"08F/G& HINN 6I"I
A*BC0%L%0%67%&3"08F/G& 0.09 6I"I
9!:;5:<5&5=)>:!>?;&?@&UV:;W=9
!"#$%#&%'%()*#+,$',-'1&*2(0
A*B&7Q"6B%1&,6&D%%8$.&/0,7%1 0.14 HIHX
A*B&7Q"6B%1&,6&0%L%0%67%&/0,7%1 0.08 HIHM
A*B&7Q"6B%1&,6&D%%8$.&/0,7%1P&7*64,+*6"$&*6&/0,7%&7Q"6B% 0.20 HINX
A*B&7Q"6B%1&,6&0%L%0%67%&/0,7%1P&7*64,+*6"$&*6&/0,7%&7Q"6B% 0.14 HIHK
!"#$%#&%'%()*#+,$',-'2,0"0
A*B&7Q"6B%1&,6&D%%8$.&7*1- 0.11 6I"I
A*B&7Q"6B%1&,6&0%L%0%67%&7*1- 0.06 6I"I
A*B&7Q"6B%1&,6&D%%8$.&7*1-P&7*64,+*6"$&*6&7*1-&7Q"6B% 0.15 6I"I
A*B&7Q"6B%1&,6&0%L%0%67%&7*1-P&7*64,+*6"$&*6&7*1-&7Q"6B% 0.09 6I"I
!"#$%#&%'%()*#+,$',-'1&*2(03!"#$%#&%'%()*#+,$',-'2,0"04
S%%8$.&B0*D-Q&0"-%&*L&/0,7%1TD%%8$.&B0*D-Q&0"-%&*L&7*1-1 1.10 6I"I
<%L%0%67%&B0*D-Q&0"-%&*L&/0,7%1TB0*D-Q&0"-%&*L&7*1-1 1.13 6I"I
S%%8$.&B0*D-Q&0"-%&*L&/0,7%P&7*64,+*6"$&*6&/0,7%&7Q"6B%1TD%%8$.&B0*D-Q&0"-%&*L&7*1-P&7*64,+*6"$&*6&7*1-&
7Q"6B% 1.20 6I"I
W0*D-Q&0"-%&*L&0%L%0%67%&/0,7%1&7*64,+*6"$&*6&/0,7%&7Q"6B%1TB0*D-Q&0"-%&*L&0%L%0%67%&7*1-1P&7*64,+*6"$&
*6&7*1-&7Q"6B%1 1.25 6I"I
Y;*-%(&-Q%&3%4,"6&*L&-Q%&0"+*&*L&1-"64"04&4%Z,"+*61&,1&6*-&-Q%&0"+*&*L&-Q%&3%4,"6&1-"64"04&4%Z,"+*61I
Page 39
!"#$%&'(&)%*+,+-%./%&0*10%*2%+
)*,3"*4&
5"-"&+%-
613,.,/7+&
5"-"&+%-
!"#$%&'%"(#()%*$%
)*1#"#,$,-4&18&"&9%%7$4&0*,/%&/:".;% <=>' <=?>
@30$,%5&9%%7$4&0*,/%&5A*"21.&B,.&CA"*-%*+D <=EF <='?
)*1#"#,$,-4&18&*%8%*%./%&0*,/%&/:".;%+ <=?G <=''
@30$,%5&*%8%*%./%&0*,/%&5A*"21.&B,.&CA"*-%*+D '=G< '=<'
+,()&'%"(#()%*$%
)*1#"#,$,-4&18&9%%7$4&/1+-&/:".;%+ <=>H .="=
@30$,%5&9%%7$4&/1+-&5A*"21.&B,.&CA"*-%*+D <=EI .="=
)*1#"#,$,-4&18&*%8%*%./%&/1+-&/:".;%+ <=>J .="=
@30$,%5&*%8%*%./%&/1+-&5A*"21.&B,.&CA"*-%*+D ?=?? .="=
Page 40
!"#$%&'(&)*++%$",*-&.+*.%+,%/
!"##$%&'"()*+,#-.&#/+0&1&+)$1
$-01%%2$3&
.+45%6
$-01%%2$3&
78"-,936
$-01%%2$3&
5*/96
$-01%%2$3&
:"+28.6
$-01%%2$3&.+45%6 ; -0.47 0.71 0.51
$-01%%2$3&78"-,936 ; -0.28 -0.20
$-01%%2$3&5*/96 ; -0.34
$-01%%2$3&:"+28.6 ;
$-0+%<%+%-5%&
.+45%6
$-0+%<%+%-5%&
78"-,936
$-0+%<%+%-5%&
5*/96
$-0+%<%+%-5%&
:"+28.6
$-0+%<%+%-5%&.+45%6 ; =>?;@ >?'' >?@>
$-0+%<%+%-5%&78"-,936 ; > =>?;A
$-0+%<%+%-5%&5*/96 ; =>?'A
$-0+%<%+%-5%&:"+28.6 ;
!"##$%&'"()*+2".-(-34)+0&1&+)$1
$-01%%2$3&
.+45%6
$-01%%2$3&
78"-,936
$-01%%2$3&.+45%6 ; =>?B@
$-01%%2$3&78"-,936 ;
$-0+%<%+%-5%&
.+45%6
$-0+%<%+%-5%&
78"-,936
$-0+%<%+%-5%&.+45%6 ; =>?>C
$-0+%<%+%-5%&78"-,936 ;
Page 41
!"#$%&'(&)"*"&"+,&-.,%$&/*"0/01/
Data
Sticky plan
model
Menu cost
calibrated to
the frequency
of weekly price
changes
Menu cost
model calibrated
to frequency of
reference price
changes
Menu cost value as percentage of steady state cash flow 0.0525 0.0100 0.4593
Weekly cost volatility 0.120 0.112 0.113 0.112
Weekly price volatility 0.140 0.111 0.113 0.075
Weekly quantity volatility 0.530 0.600 0.599 0.416
Frequency of weekly price changes 0.430 0.375 0.402 0.155
Frequency of weekly cost changes 0.490 0.577 0.574 0.576
Frequency of reference price changes 0.270 0.268 0.670 0.269
Frequency of reference costs changes 0.450 0.634 0.628 0.635
Fraction of price changes without cost changes 0.030 0.011 0.009 0.003
Frequency of plan changes 0.023
Page 42
!"#$%&'('
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 10
0.05
0.1
0.15
0.2
0.25
Distribution of percentage of weeks spent at reference price
Percentage
Fre
quency
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 10
0.005
0.01
0.015
0.02
0.025
0.03
0.035
Distribution of percentage ot total quantity sold at reference price
Percentage
Fre
quency
Page 43
!"#$%&'('
0 50 100 1500
0.02
0.04
0.06
0.08
0.1
0.12
0.14
Distribution of weekly price duration
weeks
Fre
quency
0 50 100 1500
0.05
0.1
0.15
0.2
0.25
0.3
0.35
Distribution of reference price duration
weeks
Fre
quency
Page 44
!"#$%&'('
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.90
0.05
0.1
0.15
0.2
0.25
Distribution of percentage of weeks spent at reference cost
Percentage
Fre
quency
Page 45
!"#$%&'('
0 50 100 1500
0.02
0.04
0.06
0.08
0.1
0.12
0.14
0.16
Distribution of weekly cost duration
weeks
Fre
quency
0 50 100 1500
0.02
0.04
0.06
0.08
0.1
0.12
0.14
0.16
0.18
Distribution of reference cost duration
weeks
Fre
quency
Page 46
!"#$%&'('
!!"# !!"!$ !!"!% !!"!& !!"!' ! !"!' !"!& !"!% !"!$ !"#!
!"!(
!"#
!"#(
!"'
!"'(
!")
!")(
*+,-+./01+23+450/56.27,68204+,01+280,9:;
<,+=:+.->
Page 47
!"#$%&'('
!!"# !!"!$ ! !"!$ !"#!
!"%
!"&
!"'
()*+,-./0#01)+*,2*3
40526-+,-./07*.80+62*+9208+*:);
!!"# !!"!$ ! !"!$ !"#!
!"#
!"%
!"<
()*+,-./0%01)+*,2*3
40526-+,-./07*.80+62*+9208+*:);
!!"# !!"!$ ! !"!$ !"#!
!"#
!"%
!"<
()*+,-./0<01)+*,2*3
40526-+,-./07*.80+62*+9208+*:);
!!"# !!"!$ ! !"!$ !"#!
!"#
!"%
!"<
()*+,-./0&01)+*,2*3
40526-+,-./07*.80+62*+9208+*:);
!!"# !!"!$ ! !"!$ !"#!
!"#
!"%
()*+,-./0$01)+*,2*3
40526-+,-./07*.80+62*+9208+*:);
!!"# !!"!$ ! !"!$ !"#!
!"#
!"%
()*+,-./0'01)+*,2*3
40526-+,-./07*.80+62*+9208+*:);
!!"# !!"!$ ! !"!$ !"#!
!"#
!"%
()*+,-./0=01)+*,2*3
40526-+,-./07*.80+62*+9208+*:);
!!"# !!"!$ ! !"!$ !"#!
!"#
!"%
()*+,-./0>01)+*,2*3
40526-+,-./07*.80+62*+9208+*:);
!!"# !!"!$ ! !"!$ !"#!
!"#
!"%
()*+,-./0?01)+*,2*3
40526-+,-./07*.80+62*+9208+*:);
!!"# !!"!$ ! !"!$ !"#!
!"!$
!"#
!"#$
!"%
()*+,-./0#!01)+*,2*3
40526-+,-./07*.80+62*+9208+*:);
!!"# !!"!$ ! !"!$ !"#!
!"#
!"%
()*+,-./0##01)+*,2*3
40526-+,-./07*.80+62*+9208+*:);
!!"# !!"!$ ! !"!$ !"#!
!"!$
!"#
!"#$
!"%
()*+,-./0#%01)+*,2*3
40526-+,-./07*.80+62*+9208+*:);
Page 48
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 10
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1
Pro
babili
ty o
f a c
hange in the r
efe
rence p
rice
(P
)
Probability of a change in the reference cost (C)
!"#$%&'('
)'*'+,-,./('0',-/,1,23'
45'*',-6,'
Page 49
!"#$%&'('
!!"# !!"!$ ! !"!$ !"# !"#$
!"%
!"%$
!"&
!"&$
!"'
!"'$
!"$
!"$$
()*+,+-.-/01*21,1)323)345316)-53157,483
(3)534/,83193:-,/-*4;1*21706*/73/-5,.1<,)=>612)*<1,:3),831<,)=>6
!!"# !!"!$ ! !"!$ !"# !"#$
!!"#
!!"!$
!
!"!$
!"#
!"#$
?3,.-@391)323)34531<,)=>61,;163)534/,83193:-,/-*412)*<1,:3),831<,)=>6A15*49-/-*4,.1*41,1)323)345316)-53157,483
(3)534/,83193:-,/-*4;1*21706*/73/-5,.1<,)=>612)*<1,:3),831<,)=>6
Page 50
!"#$%&'('
)%*+,+"-"./'*0'%&0&%&12&'3%"2&'24,1#&',5','0$126*1'*0'
3&%2&1.,#&'7&8",6*1'*0'4/3*.4&62,-'9,%:$3'0%*9',8&%,#&'9,%:$3''
0*%'#**75';".4'7"<&%&1.'3%"2&'7$%,6*1'
!!"# !!"!$ ! !"!$ !"# !"#$!"%&
!"%%
!"'
!"'(
!"')
*+,-./012(23+-,.4,5
!!"# !!"!$ ! !"!$ !"# !"#$
!"6
!"6$
!"%
!"%$
*+,-./012723+-,.4,5
!!"# !!"!$ ! !"!$ !"# !"#$
!"&
!"&$
!"6
!"6$
*+,-./012)23+-,.4,5
!!"# !!"!$ ! !"!$ !"# !"#$
!"$
!"$$
!"&
!"&$
*+,-./012$23+-,.4,5
!!"# !!"!$ ! !"!$ !"# !"#$
!")
!")$
!"$
!"$$
!"&
*+,-./012&23+-,.4,5
!!"# !!"!$ ! !"!$ !"# !"#$
!"7
!")
!"$
*+,-./012623+-,.4,5
!!"# !!"!$ ! !"!$ !"# !"#$
!"7
!")
!"$
*+,-./012%23+-,.4,5
!!"# !!"!$ ! !"!$ !"# !"#$
!"(
!"7
!")
*+,-./012'23+-,.4,5
!!"# !!"!$ ! !"!$ !"# !"#$
!"#
!"(
!"7
*+,-./012#!23+-,.4,5
!!"# !!"!$ ! !"!$ !"# !"#$
!"!$
!"#
!"#$
!"(
!"($
*+,-./012##23+-,.4,5
Page 51
!"#$%&'()'
'*%+,-,"."/0'+1'%&1&%&23&'4%"3&'35-2#&'-6'-'1$237+2'+1'
4&%3&2/-#&'8&9"-7+2'+1'504+/5&73-.':-%;$4'1%+:'-9&%-#&':-%;$4''
1+%'#++86'<"/5'8"=&%&2/'3+6/'9+.-7."/0'
!!"# !!"!$ ! !"!$ !"# !"#$
!"%
!"&
!"'
!"$
!"(
)*+,-+.-/-012+*23,/34/.040.0,50/536*7/!!$8
!!"# !!"!$ ! !"!$ !"# !"#$
!"%$
!"&
!"&$
!"'
!"'$
!"$
!"$$
)*+,-+.-/-012+*23,/34/.040.0,50/536*7/$!#!8
!!"# !!"!$ ! !"!$ !"# !"#$
!"%$
!"&
!"&$
!"'
!"'$
!"$
!"$$
)*+,-+.-/-012+*23,/34/.040.0,50/536*7/#!!#$8
!!"# !!"!$ ! !"!$ !"# !"#$
!"&
!"&$
!"'
!"'$
!"$
!"$$
)*+,-+.-/-012+*23,/34/.040.0,50/536*7/#$!%!8
!!"# !!"!$ ! !"!$ !"# !"#$
!"&
!"&$
!"'
!"'$
!"$
!"$$
)*+,-+.-/-012+*23,/34/.040.0,50/536*7/%!!%$8
!!"# !!"!$ ! !"!$ !"# !"#$
!"&$
!"'
!"'$
!"$
!"$$
!"(
)*+,-+.-/-012+*23,/34/.040.0,50/536*7/%$!&!8
Page 52
!"#$%&'(('
!!" !# !$ !% !& !' !( !) !* !! "
!"+"%
!"+"&
!"+"'
!"+"(
!"+")
!"+"*
!"+"!
"
,-./01-234.567830938-50:23;3.<38-5=-9;.>-32-?0.;0:93@5:43;04-!1-5:34.5678
A7.5;-5<3B-@:5-3850=-309=5-.<-<
!!" !# !$ !% !& !' !( !) !* !! ""
"+"!
"+"*
"+")
"+"(
"+"'
"+"&
"+"%
"+"$
"+"#
"+!
,-./01-234.567830938-50:23;3.<38-5=-9;.>-32-?0.;0:93@5:43;04-!1-5:34.5678
A7.5;-5<3B-@:5-3850=-32-=5-.<-<
Page 53
!"#$%&'()*'+,-$./&'%&/-01/&'20'3',01&23%4'/5067'
89674'-.31',0:&.'
;&1$'60/2',0:&.'
63."<%32&:'20'=%&>$&164'
0='%&=&%&16&'-%"6&'
6531#&'
;&1$'60/2',0:&.'
63."<%32&:'20'=%&>$&164'0='?&&7.4'-%"6&'6531#&'
