+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Reliability and Performability Techniques and Tools: A Survey ...

Reliability and Performability Techniques and Tools: A Survey ...

Date post: 01-Jan-2017
Category:
Upload: lekhue
View: 218 times
Download: 1 times
Share this document with a friend
22
Transcript
Page 1: Reliability and Performability Techniques and Tools: A Survey ...

��������������� ����������������������� ��!�����"�#��$%��&(')�)��*,+-��./�����$0�1�2��.43!5 6�+��879�:�

;:<>=@?BA�CEDGFBH8CI<KJ�LNMO<QPSR1T�UVM1W)TXUB<K=I?)W)T�YK?BA[ZIC T�\]R R^`_�a b[c dfehgjiVkla m c]nQolm"p kjiGq�rholq�a a nQolq�r[sGtue"v�w�xNy�wXzNs_|{�}NaE~�qXol��a n]�QolcQ�Ns�_|{�n]�fph��s�����yN�N��xN� �]x�yNw�zNs�~�������u������tuaIk�k��Vp"�OeNnIp"c]eNnQola � s���ehkl����a@k�s��(�Ex��N���N�

���#���  "¡[¢��N£¥¤ a@k�o>ph��o�k�oKcS�¦phq���bOa nQg�e�n]�ph��o�k�olcQ�§��e��[aIk�olq[r�c]a�m@��qXol¨�{�a ��p"q[�Ec]e�ehkl��Op �Na�Oa�a q©phq©phn]a"p�e"g�kleNcEehg�n]a �]a"p"n]m@�©phm�cQol�NolcQ��olq)c]�[a�k>ph�]c§c]a q��Naªphn]� d#«1ab[n]a �]a�q�c8p��]{�n]�Na �Eehg���o�¬Ba n]a q�cjc]a m@��q�ol¨�{[a ��p"q[��c]e�e"kl�8c]�fphc�m"phq��fa|{��]a �:g­eNn�n]a@�k�o>ph��o�k�oKcS�1phq��®bOa nQg�e�n]�ph��o�k�olcQ�1p"qOp kl���Qol� dV��{[q�o�¯fa �`�¥phc]��a �phcQolmªpªkVg­nIph��a °jeNn]}g�eNn�n]a@k�o>ph��o�k±olcS�¦phq���bOa nQg�e�n]�ph��o�k�olcQ�§��e��[aIkl�Golq�c]a�n]���#ehg�²®phn]}�eh�En]a °�p"n]�:�§e��X�a@kl�|ol��b[n]a �]a�q�c]a �³dB����eNq�r��e���a@k�olq[r®c]a�m@��qXol¨�{�a � s�°8a´��a �]m nQol�Oa�n]a�°�phn]���S�Op"�]a ������[nQol�©�Xola nIp"n]m@��olm"p kE��e��[aIk�olq[r�s�m eN�E�Xolqfphc]e�nQo>pªk§�:{�klcQol�]cIphc]a®�§e��[a@kl� sj¨�{[a�{[a �°µolc]�§�]a n]�Na nj�[n]a"p"}��[e"°�q�� s[m�eN��b�kla cQoleNq®cQol�§a�p"b[b�n]e�p"m@�BsBp"q[��olc]a nIp"cQol�Na���e��[aIk��olq[r�d��Xe"g�cQ°µphn]a8bfphmI}�phrNa��8²®i#��¶X����s���~�²��´�Os����|� ¤|· i8s�� · � · s�p"q[�~8klc]nIpª��X�4�0phn]aEm eNq��Qol��a n]a �®olq®�[a cIp o�k8°���o�kla�_���¸´�|c]e�e"k�s · iu��iu��¹ · i8s · i�� · iG�´sphq��®���#º´i!p"n]a´�[nQolaI»O�®��ol�]m {��]�]a �³d

¼ ½f¾|¿BÀBÁ´ÂEÃ:ÄV¿�Å@Á�¾

ÆVT�ÇBYKZÉÈÊZ@A�YKL"C�TXUOZ�=IËO=IZ@L"Ì1=:ÍBCIA�JO<�MOL�Î A�UOZI<KUOÇB<KZ]Ë®A�Ï�=@L"CIJO<�Î L¦MOLh=IÍB<KZIL�Î A�Ì`Í�A[UBL"UOZ�Ï]T�<KYKÇBCIL"=NFÐ(A�Ñ�L"J[L"C�Ò³ZI?BL�ÍVL"C]ÏQA�CIÌ�T�U�ΪL¦MOL"YK<KJ�L"C@L�M`ÓOË1ZI?³L=IËO=IZ@L"ÌÔÌ-TNË®MOL"Õ[C�T[MOL�FBÖ×J�L"C@Ë1=@<>Ì`ÍBYKLL Ø�TXÌ1ÍBYKL<K=Z@?�T�ZAXÏ(T`Ì`<>C@CIA[CIL�M!MO<K=IÙ!=IËO=IZ@L"Ì©FGH´?BL®=IËO=IZ@L"ÌÚA[Í�L"C T�Z@L"=9TX=YKA�UBÕ)TX=¦T�ZYKL�TX=IZ8A�UBLEM�<>=@Ù<K=�A�ÍVL"C T�ZI<KA[U�T�Y]FNÛQÏ�ÓVA�Z@?®ZI?BLEM�<>=@ÙO=µTXCIL´A[Í�L"C T�Z@<>A[U�T�Y]Ò�Z@?BL"U®Z@?BL´CIL�T[MO=�TXCIL=@L"CIJO<�Î L�M9ÏSCIA[ÌÜZI?³LEMO<K=IÙÑ´<KZI?®Ì`<KUB<K̦ÇBÌÝ=IL"L"Ù®Z@<KÌ1L�FNH´?OÇB=�Z@?BL´=IËO=IZ@L"ÌÞMOL"YK<KJ�L"C@=�?B<KÕ�?³L"CC@L�T�M�ÍVL"CÉÏSA�C@Ì-T�UVÎ L�Ñ´?³L"UÓVA�ZI?�ZI?³L4MO<K=@Ùf=8T�C@L�ÏSdzU�Î ZI<KA[UB<KUBÕ´ZI?�TXUÑ´?BL"U�A�U³L�AXÏ�Z@?BL´MO<K=IÙO=?�TX=�ÏÊT�<KYKL�M#FBßuL"CÉÏSA�C@Ì-TXÓB<KY><KZ]Ë®T�U�TXYKËf=@<K=ET�<KÌ1=�ZIA1Î"TXÍBZIdzCIL�ZI?B<K=E<KUOZILhC�T�ΪZI<KA�U�ÓVL"Z]Ñ�LhL"U©Z@?BLÏÊTX<KY>dzCIL È]CIL"ÍVT�<KC�ÓVL"?�TNJO<KA�CETXU�M®Z@?BLÍVL"C]ÏQA�CIÌ�T�U�ΪL¥M�L"YK<>J[L"CILNM1ÓOË`ZI?BL�=IËO=@ZIL"Ì!FDO<KÕ�U³<là#Î"T�UOZjT[MOJ�T�UVÎ L"=8?�TNJ�L�ÓVL"L"U®Ì-T[MOL�<KUÍVL"C]ÏQA�CIÌ�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]ËEÌ`A�M�L"YK<>U³ÕET�U�MTXU�T�YKËO=I<K=

=@<>UVÎ L§á|L�T�ÇVMOCIË!â ãhä�MOL àVUBL�M�Î A�̮ӳ<>U³L�M�Ì1L�TX=IÇBC@L"=�A�Ï�ÍVL"C]ÏSA[CIÌ�T�U�Î LETXU�M®C@L"YK<�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]˦T�U�MW�LhË�L"CEâ�ã³å�Òfã[æhä�ÍBCIA[Í�A[=IL�M`T:Õ�L"UBLhC�T�Y³ÏSC T�Ì1LhÑ�A[CIÙ:ÏSA�C|Í�L"CÉÏSA�C@Ì-TXÓB<KY><KZ]Ë�T�U�TXY>ËO=@<>=NF�DOL"J�LhC�T�YUBLhÑ�T�YKÕ�A[CI<KZI?³Ì1=�?VTNJ�LEÓVL"L"U`ÍBCIA[Í�A[=IL�M2ÏSA[C�Î"TXY­ÎªÇBY�T�ZI<KUBÕ�Í�L"CÉÏSA�C@Ì-TXÓB<KY><KZ]Ë�Ì1LNT�=IdzCIL"=´T�U�MT�UOÇBÌ®Ó�LhC�A�Ï8ZIAOA�YK=�?�TNJ�L�ÓVL"L"U)MOL"=@<>Õ[UBL�M2ÏSA[C�ÍVL"C]ÏQA�CIÌ�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]˦T�UVT�YKËO=I<K=�F[Û]U�ZI?B<K=�Í�T�ÍVL"C�ÒÑ�L1ÍBC@L"=ILhUfZ�çQ<KU%DOL�ΪZI<KA�U0æ�è�T)ÇBU³<làVL�M!ÏSC T�Ì`L"Ñ�A[CIÙ�ÏQA�C�Í�L"CÉÏSA�C@Ì-TXÓB<KY><KZ]Ë)T�UVMéCILhY><�TXÓB<KYlÈ<KZ]Ë©TXU�T�YKËO=I<K=ÇB=@<KUBÕ©W)TXCIÙ�A�JêCIL"Ñ´T�C MéÌ1ABMOLhY>=NFVëéL®=IÇBC@J�L"Ë0çQ<>U�D�L�Î ZI<KA[U�ì�èT�UOÇBÌ®ÓVL"CAXÏ|M�<lí#L"C@L"UOZEZILNÎI?³UB<�î�dzL"=�Ñ´?B<�ÎI?�?�TNJ[LÓVL"L"U)ÇB=@L�M,ÏSA�C´ÍVL"C]ÏQA�CIÌ�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]Ë9TXU�T�YKËO=I<K=NFBëéL�<KYlÈYKÇB=@ZIC�TXZIL�?BA�ÑÜ=@A�Ì`LA�Ï�Z@?BL"=@L®ZIL�Î@?BUB<�î[ÇBL"=�Ì-TNË®ÓVL®ÇB=@L�MêÏSA�C:CIL"YK<�T�Ó³<>YK<KZ]Ë-TXU�T�YKËO=I<K=NF�ëéLï �|��ol�´°8e�n]}�°�p"�´�]{[b�bOeNn]c]a��2olq�bfphn]c����®c]�[a§��p"cQoleNqfpªk���m@ola q�m a¶�eN{�q[�fphcQole�qê{�q��[a nEð�nIp"q�c�|� ¤ �ÊwXzªxN�Xz�z ñ9phq��`���¦c]�[a§��p ��pªkj��{[nQgòphm a�«-phnQgòphn]a§�µa�q�c]a n�{�q[��a n´r�nIphq�c´��óNx�wNyXzI�ÊwNyª�Ê�u�xXz"ó�zNdïIï �|��ol��°jeNn]}°�ph�jbOa nQg�e�n]��a �®°��Xo�klaEc]��a�p"{[c]��eNn�°�p"��p"c�_|{�}Na§~|q�ol�Na n]�QolcS�Nd�p

Page 2: Reliability and Performability Techniques and Tools: A Survey ...

T�YK=@A®=IÇBC@J�L"Ë!çS<KU©D�L�Î ZI<KA[U��OèET�UOÇBÌ®ÓVL"C´A�Ï�=@A�ÏSZ]Ñ´T�C@L§Z@AOA�YK=´ZI?�TXZE?�TNJ[L�Ó�L"LhU�MOLhJ�L"YKA�ÍVL�MÏSA[CEÍVL"C]ÏSA[CIÌ�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]Ë1T�U�M�C@L"YK<�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]Ë-T�UVT�YKËO=I<K=�F³Û]U©DOL�Î Z@<KA�U��BÒBÑ�L®MO<K=�Î ÇB=@==IA[Ì1L�A�Ï�ZI?BLÎ A[Ì1ÍBÇBZ T�Z@<>A[U�T�YVÍBC@A�ÓBYKL"Ì`=�Z@?�T�ZETXCI<K=IL�<KU1ÍVL"C]ÏQA�CIÌ�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]Ë9TXU�T�YKËO=I<K=NF

� ����IÅ� �:Å��@Å]¿���8¾EÂ����uÀ��"Á�À�����:Å��IÅÉ¿��������fÃ:À����Û]U1Z@?B<K=�=@L�Î Z@<>A[U�ÒOÑ�LEÍBC@L"=IL"UOZET�ÇBUB<±à�L�M9ÏSC�TXÌ1L"Ñ�A�C@Ù�ÏSA[C�CIL"YK<�T�Ó³<>YK<KZ]˦TXU�M®ÍVL"C]ÏQA�CIÌ�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]ËÌ1ABMOLhY>=®<KU Z@L"CIÌ`=®A�ϦW)TXCIÙ�A�J0C@L"Ñ4TXC�M0Ì`ABMOL"YK=�F8ëéL)=@?�T�YKY:=IL"L!ZI?�TXZ1ÍVL"C]ÏQA�CIÌ�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]ËT�UVT�YKËO=I<K=#ÏSC T�Ì`L"Ñ�A[CIÙ�Î"T�U�Ó�L´UVT�ZIdzC�T�YKYK˧T[MBT�ͳZIL�M�ZIA�CILhY><�TXÓB<KY><KZ]ËETXU�T�YKËO=I<K=#ÏQC�T�Ì`L"Ñ�A�CIÙ�ÓOË=Idz<>Z T�ÓBYKLETX=I=I<KÕ[UBÌ1L"UOZuA�Ï#CIL"Ñ´T�C M�C�T�Z@L"=�F[Ö�Î A[Ì1ÍBC@L"?BL"U³=I<KJ�LET[Î"Î A�dzUfZ|A�Ï�W)T�C@Ù�A�JC@L"Ñ4TXC�MÌ1ABMOLhY>=VÏQA�C�ÍVL"CÉÏSA�C@Ì-T�Ó³<>YK<KZ]ËET�UVT�YKËO=I<K=�T�ÍBÍVL�TXCI=8<KU9âKå ��æhäIF�DOLhJ�L"C T�YOCIL ÏQL"CIL"UVÎ L"=�A�U=@A�YKÇBZI<KA[UÌ1LhZI?BABMO=�ÏSA[C�Z@?BLÌ`L�T�=@ÇBCIL"=EM�L à�UBL�M,Ó�L"YKA�Ñ Î"T�U�ÓVL:ÏSA�ÇBUVM1<KU!â æ³å�ÒBì!�³Ò��fãBÒ�"$#BÒ#å ��æhäIF%'&)( *�+$,.-�/10 /324-�56#LhZ87�9�ç):�è<;=:?>@��A�Ó�L®T�Î A�UOZI<KUOÇBA[ÇB=]È]ZI<KÌ1L:à�U³<>Z@L È]=IZ�TXZIL�?BA�Ì`A�Õ[L"UBL"A[ÇB=§W)TXCIÙ[A�J,Î@?�TX<KUçCB�HEWDB´è´Ñ´<KZI?�=IZ T�Z@L¦=@Í�T�Î LFEF�ÖÜΪA�UB=@Z�T�UOZ:CIL"Ñ´T�C M�C�TXZILHGJI�<K=ETX=I=IABÎ <�TXZIL�MêÑ´<KZI?�L�T�Î@?=IZ T�Z@LLKuA�Ï�Z@?BLEW)T�C@Ù�A�J®Î@?�T�<KU�F�ëÝ<>Z@?®ZI?BL:CIL"Ñ´T�C M�C�TXZILE=@Í�LNÎ <±à�Î"T�Z@<KA�UB=NÒOZI?BL?B�HEWMB0Î"T�UÓVL®ZIL"C@Ì1L�M!T�=ONQP�RTS!U�VWRYX<Z[P�RT\H]HU^\$XJ_uç]WM`EW)èhF#ÛQÏ�Z@?BL1WM`EW =IÍVL"U�MO=HaTI´ZI<KÌ`L§Ç³UB<KZI=<KU©=@Z�TXZIL�K@Ò#Z@?BL"UbG<ICaTI´<K=Z@?BL®CILhÑ4TXC�MéT�ÎhÎ ÇBÌ®ÇBY�T�Z@L�M#FVÛ]Z<K=T�YK=IA�ÍVA�=@=I<KÓBYKL®ZIA©TX=I=@A�Ϊ<­TXZILCILhÑ4TXC�M�C T�ZILh=§Ñ´<KZ@?-Z@?BLZ@C�T�U³=I<KZI<KA�U³=´A�Ï�ZI?BLOB�HEWMB�F�ƳA�C´Ì`A�CIL:Ó�T�=@<�Î�<KUOÏSA�C@Ì-TXZI<KA�U®A[UWM`:W�=�Ò³CIL ÏSLhCEZIA�âc�BåªäÉF6GL"Zed ÓVL´ZI?³L´Õ�L"UBLhC�T�Z@A�C8Ì-TXZIC@<lئTXU�M8f9ç):�èuÓ�L�ZI?³L´=IZ�TXZIL´ÍBC@A�Ó�TXÓB<KYK<>Z]Ë:J�L�ΪZIA�C|A�Ï#ZI?BLWM`:WéF�Ð(L"CIL�g I çh:�èEMOL"U³A�ZILh=§Z@?BL�ÍBCIA[Ó�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]Ë®A�Ï�Z@?BL¦WM`:W ÓVL"<KUBÕ®<KU)=IZ T�ZILHK�T�ZEZ@<KÌ1L:�FVH´?BL�ZIC�TXUB=I<KL"UOZ�ÓVL"?�TNJO<KA�CEAXÏ�ZI?B<K=WM`EW <K=EÕ[<KJ�L"U)ÓOË�ZI?³L9;:A�YKÌ`A�Õ�A[CIA�J1MO<±í#L"CILhUfZ@<�T�YL�î[Ç�TXZI<KA�U�i j f�çh:�èj : k f�çh:�èTdl; ç å�èÕ�<KJ[L"U1Z@?BLE<KUB<KZI<�TXYB=IZ T�ZIL�ÍBC@A�Ó�TXÓB<KYK<>Z]Ë�J�L�Î Z@A�Cmf�ç=��èhF�H´?BL:=IZ@L�T�MOË[È]=IZ T�ZIL�ÍBCIA[Ó�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]ËJ�LNÎ@ÈZIA[C8n0T�=@=IÇBÌ`<>U³Õ1ZI?VT�Z�<KZ§LªØ�<K=@ZI=®T�U�Mê<K=§Ç³UB<�î�dzL®<>=�A[ÓBZ�TX<>U³L�M)ÓOË!=IL"Z@ZI<KUBÕ)Z@?BL®Y]F ?�F =�FV<KUo�î[Ç�TXZI<KA�Uéå:ZIAHp"L"C@A1J[L�Î ZIA[C^i nd k ��; ç]æ�è=IdzÓ!q L�Î Z®Z@A©Z@?BL-Î A[U�MO<KZI<KA[Ubr I3s�t nuI k å�F8дLhCIL�nuIE<K=�ZI?BL`=IZ@L�T�MOË[È]=IZ T�ZIL�ÍBC@A�Ó�TXÓB<KYK<>Z]ËA�Ï�ZI?BL®WM`EW Ó�L"<KUBÕ`<KU)=IZ T�ZILHK@Fv6GL"Z�ÇB=�UBA�ÑÜMOL àVUBL9T`Î ÇBÌ®ÇBY�TXZI<KJ�L�=IZ T�Z@L¦ÍBC@A�Ó�TXÓB<KYK<>Z]ËJ�LNÎ ZIA[C§AXÏ�ZI?BL¦WD`EW T�=mw(ç):�è kyxz{ f9çC|Vè j |�F�} I çh:�è´MOL"UBA[ZIL"=�ZI?³LL ØBÍ�LNÎ ZIL�M!Z@A�Z T�Y�Z@<KÌ1L=IÍVL"UOZÓOË1Z@?BL®WM`EW <KU�=IZ T�Z@L~K´MOdzCI<KUBÕ®ZI?³L¦<KUOZIL"C@J�T�Y�â �u;=:�èhFBÛ]UOZILhÕ�C�TXZI<KUBÕ�o�î[Ç�T�Z@<>A[Uéå�ÒÑ�LÕ�L"Z i j w´çh:�èj :�k w(ç):�èTd���f�ç=��è�� ç]ì�èƳA�C-WD`EW�=`Ñ´<>Z@? T�ÓB=@A�CIÓ³<>U³Õé=IZ�TXZIL"=NÒ´ZI?³L)=IZ T�ZIL!=IÍVT�Î LME ÎhT�U ÓVL©ÍVT�CIZ@<KZI<KA�UBLNM�<KUOZIAZ]Ñ�A4i$E���ç]T�ÓB=@A�CIÓ³<>U³Õ=IZ T�ZILh=�è´T�UVMOE���çSZ@C�T�U³=I<KL"UOZ�=@Z�TXZIL"= è"F�B�A�C@CIL"=@Í�A[U�MO<KUBÕ�ZIAZ@?BLEU³A�UOÈT�Ó³=IA�C@ÓB<KUBÕ®=IZ T�Z@L"=�ÒVZI?³L=IÇBÓ³Ì-T�Z@CI<±ØMd���AXÏ�d/Î"T�U)ÓVL¦MOLªà�UBL�M#F³H´?BLÌ`L�T�U`ZI<KÌ1L:=IÍVL"UOZÓOË1Z@?BLWM`EW�<>U`=IZ T�ZIL�K8<K=�Õ�<KJ�LhU1ÓOË�a I k x��{ g I çC|Vè j |uÒ�Ñ´?³<­Î@?)Î"TXU1ÓVL¦Î A�Ì`ÍBÇBZ@L�M®ÓOË<KUOZIL"Õ[C�T�Z@<KUBÕ�o�î[Ç�T�Z@<KA�U©å(ÏSC@A�Ì��Z@A���i

avd����bfL��çC�[è k ��� ç3�fè

Page 3: Reliability and Performability Techniques and Tools: A Survey ...

H´?BL�Ì`L�T�U`ZI<KÌ1L´Z@A1T�ÓB=@A�CIͳZI<KA�U�<KU1=@Ç�Î@?©T¦WêT�CIÙ[A�J1Î@?�T�<KU�<K=´Õ�<KJ�L"U`ÓOËvi������� k �I3s t�� a I � ç=��è

%'& % f +���2��� �����/��)/30���� +�45�����+�56GL"Z���çh:�è k G���� z� ÓVL�ZI?BL�<KUB=IZ T�UOZ�TXUBL"A�dz=�CILhÑ4TXC�M�C�T�Z@L�A�ÏVZI?BL´WM`EW F"H´?BL�T[Î"Î ÇB̮dzY­TXZIL�MC@L"Ñ4TXC�M`A�J�LhCET�Í�L"C@<KA�M`AXÏjZI<KÌ`L¦âc��; :�è8<K=´Õ�<KJ�LhU-ÓOË�i

!Eçh:�è k�" z{ ��ç=|�è j | k�" z{ G ���$# j |�� ç&%�è

H´?BL�L ØBÍVL�Î Z@L�M)<KUB=@Z�TXUfZ T�UBLhA�ÇB=´C@L"Ñ4TXC�M�C T�Z@L¥TXZ´ZI<KÌ1Le:´A�Ï8ZI?BL�WM`EW�<>= i'®â ��ç):�èÊä k � I3s t G I g I çh:�è � ç]ã�è

H´?BL�L ØBÍVL�Î Z@L�M)C@L"Ñ´T�C�M`C T�ZIL�<>U`=IZ@L�T�MOË[È]=IZ T�ZIL�A�Ï�ZI?BLWM`:W <>= i'®â �)(*(Éä k � I3s t G<I1nuI�� ç="�è

H´?BL�L ØBÍVL�Î Z@L�M©T[Î"Î ÇB̮dzY­TXZIL�M2CIL"Ñ´T�C M`<>U�Z@?BL�<>UOZ@L"CIJ�TXY�â �u;=:�è|A�Ï8ZI?BL�WM`EW�<>= i'®â !Eç):�èÊä k �I3s�t G I } I ç):�è � ç=#�è

H´?BL�L ØBÍVL�Î ZILNM1Z@<KÌ1L ÈITNJ�L"C T�Õ[L�M�CILhÑ4TXC�M�<KUZI?³L´<>UOZ@L"CIJ�TXY�âc��; :�è#<K=8Õ�<KJ�L"U�ÓOË r I G I } I ç):�è,+ :�FƳA�C�TXU-WM`:WÔÑ´<KZI?1TXÓB=IA[CIÓB<KUBÕ�=IZ T�Z@L"=�Ò³L ØBÍ�L�ΪZIL�M)T[Î"Î ÇB̮dzY­TXZIL�M�C@L"Ñ´T�C�M2ÇBUOZI<KY#T�ÓB=@A�CIÍ�ÈZ@<>A[U1<K=^i '®â !EçC�0èQä k �I3s t � GJI3aTI�� ç�å ��èH´?BLMO<K=@ZICI<KÓBdzZI<KA�U`A�Ï-��ç):�è�<K=´Î A�Ì`ÍBÇBZILNM-TX=^i

g®â ��ç):�è/.10uä k �2�3547698 I3s�t g I ç):�è � ç�å[å�è

H´?BLéMO<K=IZ@CI<KÓBÇBZ@<KA�U AXÏ�T[Î"Î ÇB̮dzY­TXZIL�M CIL"Ñ´T�C M ÇBUOZ@<>YTXÓB=IA[CIÍBZ@<>A[U�T�UVM MO<K=IZ@CI<KÓBÇBZ@<>A[U A�ÏT[Î"Î ÇBÌ®ÇBY�TXZIL�M2CIL"Ñ´T�C M1A�J[L"CET�à�UB<KZ@L§ÍVL"C@<>ABM`A�Ï8ZI<KÌ1L�Î"T�U)TXY>=@A¦ÓVL¦Î A[Ì1ÍBdzZIL�M#F6#LhZEZI?³LZI<KÌ1L:ZIA�T�Î"Πdz̮ÇBY�T�ZIL�T®Õ[<>J[L"U�CIL"Ñ´T�C MMG�Ó�L¦M�L"UBA�Z@L�MêÓfË;:�çCG�è"F³H´?BL"U)Z@?BLMO<K=@ZICI<KÓBdzZI<KA�U A�Ï<:�ç=G�è�<K=®ÙfU³A�Ñ´U�A�UVÎ L�ZI?BL)MO<K=IZ@CI<KÓBÇBZ@<KA�U�AXÏ¥T[Î"Î ÇBÌ®ÇBY�TXZIL�M CIL"Ñ´T�C M�<K=ÙOUBA�Ñ´U!â �$"hä�i g®â=:ç=G�è>. :]ä k å@? g®â !Eçh:�è-A�Ghä � ç�åNæ�èƳA�C�L Ø�T�Ì`ÍBYKL�ÒOZI?BL�MO<K=IZIC@<KÓBÇBZI<KA[U1A�Ï�Z@<>Ì`LEZ@A1Î A�Ì`ÍBYKL"ZILTeq A�Ó�ZI?VT�Z´CILNî�dz<>C@L"=�GdzUB<KZI=´A�ÏÍBC@ABÎ L"=I=@<KUBÕ®ZI<KÌ1L:A�U�T�=IËO=IZ@L"Ì/Ñ´?³<­Î@?`<>=´Ì`ABMOL"YKL�M®ÓOË1TXU-WM`:W ÎhT�U�Ó�LÎ A[Ì1ÍBdzZIL�M2<>UZ@?B<K=´Ì-T�U³UBL"C�F

Page 4: Reliability and Performability Techniques and Tools: A Survey ...

%'&�� *�+��.+�-�� ����/��3/)0���� +�45��>��+ 5Û]U©T�MOL"ÍVL"U�MBTXÓB<KYK<>Z]Ë`Ì1ABMOL"Y]ÒOT�CIL"Ñ´T�C M�C�TXZIL�A�ÏEå�<K=ET�=@=I<KÕ�U³L�M`ZIA1T�YKY#Z@?BL=IËO=@ZIL"ÌÔA[Í�L"CÉÈT�Z@<KA�U�TXY�=@Z�T�Z@L"=§TXU�M®C@L"Ñ´T�C�M`C T�ZIL���<K=ET�=I=@<KÕ�UBL�M2ZIA1TXY>YVZI?³L§=@ËO=IZILhÌÞÏÊTX<KY>dzCILE=@Z�TXZIL"=NFBH´?BL������P����P���XYU� �LP�V�P��)_ P����)_�����uA�ÏBZI?BL�=IËO=@ZIL"Ì <K=�Z@?BL"U '®â ��ç):�èÊä�T�UVM�� XTP!\������ P� X�P V P��)_ P����)_�������<K=-'®â � (*( äIFNH´?BL��� �]� �_ P���)V�XmU � X<RYP�!�1U��4P�_"��)]~XuAXÏ�ZI?³L´=IËO=IZ@L"Ì <>U�ZI<KÌ`L�<KUfZ@L"CIJ�TXY#â �u;=:�è<K= '®â !Eç):�èÊäIF$#��� X<RJV�P�_�P�V�P��)_ P����)_�����´<K=�ZI?BL�ÍBC@A�ÍVA�CIZ@<KA�U�A�Ï8ZI<KÌ1L�T=@Ëf=@ZIL"ÌÔ<K=�A�ÍVL"C�TXZI<KA�UVT�Y<KU-T�Õ[<KJ�L"U`<>UOZ@L"CIJ�TXY�AXÏ�ZI<KÌ1L´T�U�M2<KZ�<K=�Õ[<>J[L"U®ÓOË '®â !Eç):�èÊä�+ :�F�W�LNT�=IdzCIL"=:CIL"Y�T�Z@L�M®Z@A¦Z@<KÌ1LZIA,à�CI=@Z¦=@Ëf=@ZIL"Ì ÏÊTX<KY>dzCIL®T�CIL1TXYK=IA�A�ÏE<KUOZIL"C@L"=IZNF�H8A)Î A[Ì1ÍBÇBZ@L¦Z@?BL"=@L-Ì`L�T�=@ÇBCILh=�Ò�TXY>Y|ZI?BLÏÊTX<>YKÇBC@L´=IZ T�ZILh=4TXCILEÌ�T�MOL´T�Ó³=IA�C@ÓB<KUBÕ®çQA�ÇBZ@Õ�A�<KUBÕTXC�Î =|ÏSCIA[Ì ZI?BL"=@LE=@Z�T�Z@L"=ET�C@L´CIL"Ì`A�J�L�M³è"F% X<_��1P����h_������<K=§Z@?BL"UéÕ[<>J[L"U!ÓfË '®â ��çh:�èQäIFVH´?BL®YK<lÏQL"ZI<KÌ1L�ç]T�U�TXY>A[Õ�A[ÇB=EZ@A-Î ÇB̮dzY­TXZI<KJ�L�A�ÍOÈL"C T�ZI<KA[U�T�Y8ZI<KÌ`L�è�â�ì!�hä�A�Ï�Z@?BL�=IËO=IZ@L"Ì <KU)<KUOZIL"C@J�T�Y´âc��; :�è�<K= '®â !Eçh:�èQä�T�U�M ]~XTP��&��)]HX'�U���� X<])( P��)_* RTX�ç]W�H´HEÆ8è�<K= '®â !Eç=�%èÊäIF�H´?BLHRYX+� P��)RYP����h_������AXÏjZI?³L§=@ËO=IZILhÌ/<K=´Î A�Ì`ÍBÇBZILNMÓOË©Ì�T�ÙO<KUBÕ1T�YKY8ZI?³L®A�ÍVL"C�TXZI<KA�U�TXY�=IZ T�Z@L"=¦T�Ó³=IA�C@ÓB<KUBÕ©TXU�M)C@L"J�LhCI=I<KUBÕêZI?BL®C@L"Ñ4TXC�M!C T�ZILh=çS<]F L�FKÒOÌ-TXÙO<>U³Õ§C@L"Ñ´T�C�M,C�T�Z@L®å�ZIA���T�U�M`JO<�Î L È]J�L"C@=�T�è:T�U�M`Î A�Ì`ÍBÇBZ@<>U³Õ '®â ��çh:�èQäIF, -/.0.EÀBÁ jÄ"1m��� ¿BÁ������IÅ���EÅ��@Å]¿���j¾:Â����uÀ��"Á�À�����EÅ��IÅÉ¿��2-0¾m��=�m�OÅ��WM`:W ÏSC�TXÌ1L"Ñ�A�C@Ù)<K=UBA�Z�ZI?BL`A�UBYKË)A[UBL-TNJ�TX<>Y�TXÓBYKL�ÏSA�C�Í�L"CÉÏSA�C@Ì-TXÓB<KY><KZ]Ë)T�UVT�YKËO=I<K=�ÓBÇBZ<KZ´<K=EZI?³LÌ1A[=IZ´Î A�Ì`Ì1A�U³YlË�ÇB=IL�M,A�UBL�F³ëéL�UBA�Ñ M�<>= Î ÇB=@=E=ILhJ�L"C T�Y�MO<±í�LhCIL"UOZT�ÍBͳCIAfT[Î@?BL"=ZI?VT�Z´?�TNJ[L§ÓVL"L"Uê=I?BA�Ñ´U�ZIA®ÓVL�ÇB=ILªÏSÇBY#ÏQA�C´ÍVL"C]ÏSA[CIÌ�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]˦T�U�TXYKËf=@<K=�F

�'&)( ������342"4/5H+�6 � ���1� 27�+�=598��:5 �y5�;WM`:W ÏSC�TXÌ1L"Ñ�A�C@Ù1U�TXZIÇBC T�YKYKË�Y>LNT�MO=:ZIA)T®=@L"Í�T�C T�Z@<>A[U)A�Ï�ZI?BL�Í�LhC]ÏSA[CIÌ-TXU�Î L®T�U�M,CIL"YK<�TNÈÓB<KYK<KZ]˦Ì`A�M�L"YK=�A�Ï�Z@?BL�=IËO=IZ@L"Ì©FOßuL"C]ÏSA[CIÌ�T�U�Î L:Ì1ABMOL"Y³<>=�=IA[YKJ�L�M2ZIA�A�ÓBZ T�<KU®CIL"Ñ´T�C M®C T�ZILh=Ñ´?B<�Î@?1T�C@L§T�=@=I<KÕ�U³L�M�ZIAZ@?BL´CILhY><�TXÓB<KY><KZ]Ë�Ì1ABMOLhY�ç]T�YK=IA�ÙfU³A�Ñ´U9TX=<�CR� =� ! �RTP�_�]HU^\$XJ_³â ã[ìhäSè"FдA�Ñ�L"J[L"C�Ò#Z@?B<K=E=@L"Í�T�C T�Z@<>A[U©<KUOZIC@ABMOÇ�Î L"=�T�U©TXÍBÍBCIANØB<KÌ-TXZI<KA�U®<KU)Z@?�T�Z�C@L"Ñ4TXC�MêC�TXZIL"=T�=ÉÈ=I<KÕ[UBL�MéZ@A©T�UOË!=IZ T�ZIL�AXÏEZI?BL`CIL"YK<�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]Ë�Ì1ABMOL"Y�TXCIL`Z]Ëfͳ<­ÎhT�YKYKË©Î A�U³=IZ�TXUOZ¦J�TXY>dzL"=1çQ<]F L[F>ÒZI<KÌ`L ÈÊ<KU�M�L"Í�LhU�MOL"UOZ�èhF�H´?OÇB=NÒ�<KZ8<>=�T�=I=@ÇBÌ1LNMZ@?�T�ZuÏSA[C�ZI?BL´=@A^q A[ÇBCIU®<KU®TE=@Z�TXZILEAXÏ�Z@?BL´CILhY><±ÈT�Ó³<>YK<KZ]Ë�Ì1ABMOL"Y]Ò[ZI?BL�=IËO=@ZIL"Ì ÍBCIA�JO<�MOL"=ET�=IZ@L�T�M�Ë�È]=IZ T�Z@LÍ�LhC]ÏSA[CIÌ-TXU�Î L�FOH´?³L¥T[Î"Î ÇBC T�Î Ë�AXÏZI?³<>=´T�ͳÍBCIANØB<KÌ-TXZI<KA�U¦M�L"Í�LhU�MO=´ÇBÍVA�U`ZI?BL�MO<±í�L"C@L"U�Î L�<>U®Z@?BLEC T�Z@L"=ET�Z�Ñ´?³<­Î@?`ZI?BL:L"J�L"UOZ@=<KU©Z@?BL�Í�L"CÉÏSA�C@Ì-TXU�Î L®T�U�MêZI?BL®MOL"ÍVL"U�M³T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]Ë)Ì1ABMOL"YuABÎ"Î ÇBCNF�DOÌ-TXYKY>LhC´ZI?BL1MO<±í#L"CILhU�Î L�ÒZI?³L§YKL"=@=4T[Î"Î ÇBC T�Z@L§Z@?BLEC@L"=IdzY>Z@=�F³Û]Z�<K=�ÏSA[C�ZI?³<>=�CILNT�=IA[U1Z@?�T�Z�ZI?B<K=´T�ÍBͳCIAfT[Î@?®<>=�=�TX<�M�ZIA�Ó�LÓ�TX=IL�M!A[U�T1Z@<KÌ1L È]=�Î"TXYKL¦MOL�Î A[Ì1ÍVA�=@<>Z@<KA�U�FVÛ]U0â>å ��æhäIÒVÑ�L®ÕOTNJ�L®T�U!L Ø�T�Ì`ÍBYKLÑ´?BL"C@L®ZI?B<K=T�ͳÍBCIAOT�Î@?�Ëf<KL"Y�MO=´<KU�T[Î"Î ÇBC T�Z@LCIL"=@ÇBYKZI=NFƳA�CuZI?BL´Î"T�=@L�Ò[Ñ´?BL"U�CIL"Ñ´T�C MC T�ZILh=�Z�TXÙ�L�A[UBYK˧Z]Ñ�A�J�T�YKÇBL"=NÒ��ET�UVM1å(çÊT�=8<KUC@L"YK<­TXÓB<KYK<>Z]Ë

Ì1ABMOLhY>= è"Ò�M�L-DOA[Ç�p�TêL-DO<KYKJ�T�T�U�M?>TX<KYEâ�æ!"häEÎ A�Ì`ÍBÇBZILNM!ZI?BL�MO<K=IZIC@<KÓBÇBZI<KA[UéA�ÏE<KUOZIL"C@J�T�YTNJ�T�<KY�T�Ó³<>YK<KZ]ËEdz=I<KUBÕÇBU³<lÏQA�CIÌ`< p�T�Z@<>A[U�F^`(ÇBÓB<KUBAT�UVM1DOL"C@<�Î A�Y�T®âc#!�hä#A�Ó³Z�T�<KUBLNM®MO<K=IZIC@<KÓBÇBZI<KA[UA�ÏV<>UOZ@L"CIJ�TXY�TNJ�TX<KY­TXÓB<KYl<KZ]Ë|ÏSA�Cu=IL"Ì`<lÈIW)TXCIÙ�A�J:Ì1ABMOL"YK=#ÇBUVMOL"C8=IA[Ì1L�Î A�UVMO<KZI<KA�UB=NF�>�A�ËfTXY�T�U�MH�T�UOZ�TNÑ´<�â ���häµT�UVM�`(L"<KÓBÌ-TXU1L"Z�T�Y�â "$#häjL"J�TXYKÇ�T�Z@L�M`<>UOZ@L"CIJ�TXY�TNJ�T�<KY�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]ËÓOË1=IA[YKJf<KUBÕ1TÍ�TXCIZI<�TXY�MO<±í�L"C@L"UOZI<�T�YuL�î[Ç�T�Z@<KA�U)ç]ß�@?o�è"FƳA�CET[Î ËBÎ YK<­Î:UBA[UBCILNÎ A�J�L"C T�ÓBYKL¦WD`EW�=�çSÑ´?B<�Î@?)T�CI<K=@L<KU-Î"TX=IL�A�Ï�UBA�U³CIL"Í�TX<KC�T�Ó³Y>L�=@Ëf=ÉÈ

ZILhÌ1=�èhÒ�ZI?³LEMO<K=IZIC@<KÓBÇBZI<KA[U¦AXÏGT[Î"Î ÇBÌ®ÇBY�TXZIL�M�C@L"Ñ´T�C�M�?VT�=�ÓVL"L"U`A�ÓBZ T�<KUBL�M`â�æ!�OÒ��$�BÒ�� %³Ò�ã�æhäIFA´A[UBCILNÎ A�J�L"C T�ÓBYKL®WM`EW,=§T�C@L¦Î@?�T�C T�Î Z@L"CI< p"LNM!ÓfË�T®C@L"Ñ4TXC�M�C T�Z@L¦T�=@=I<KÕ�UBÌ`L"UOZ´<KU-Ñ´?³<­Î@?

Page 5: Reliability and Performability Techniques and Tools: A Survey ...

C@L"Ñ4TXC�M!C T�ZIL`A�ÏET`ÏSÇBZ@ÇBCIL®=@Z�TXZIL1<K=YKL"=@=¦Z@?�T�UéZ@?�T�Z�A�Ï´ZI?BL®ÍBC@L"=ILhUfZ®=@Z�TXZIL�F @:A�U�TXZI<KL"YKYKATXU�MéÛ]Ë[L"C)â�ì��NäEÇB=@L�M�6�T�ͳY­T[Î L1Z@C�TXUB=]ÏSA[CIÌ`=¦Z@A©A[ÓBZ�TX<>U0Î YKA�=@L�M ÏSA�C@ÌÚ=IA[Y>dzZI<KA�U!ÏSA[C¦Z@?B<K=MO<K=@ZICI<KÓBdzZI<KA�U2ÏSA�CET[Î ËBÎ YK<­Î:WM`EW,=´Ñ´<>Z@?BA�dzZ´<>Ì`Í�A[=I<KUBÕ�UBA[UBCIL�ΪA�J�L"C T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]Ë-Î A[U�MO<KZI<KA�UuFƳA�CEÕ[L"UBL"C T�Y�WD`EW�=NÒ�;:ÇBYKÙ�T�CIU³<jLhZ¥TXY´â �$"hä4T�UVM)DOÌ1<KZ@?-LhZ¦T�Y´âc#!"hä�L"J�TXY>ÇVT�ZILNM©MOA[ÇOÈ

ÓBYKL?6�T�ͳY­T[Î LEZ@C�TXUB=]ÏSA[CIÌÞAXÏjZ@?B<K=4MO<K=@ZICI<KÓBdzZI<KA�U�T�U�M`MOL"J�LhY>A[Í�LNM-T�Ì1LhZI?BABM�A�Ï8UOÇBÌ1L"C@<�Î"T�Y<KUOJ�L"C@=I<KA�UuFBÛ]Ë�LhC§LhZ¥TXY�âc���Nä�MOLhJ�L"YKA�ÍVL�M!T�U©TXYKÕ�A�C@<KZI?BÌ ÏSA�C:ZI?BL®Î A[Ì1ÍBÇBZ T�Z@<>A[U1AXÏ4T�YKY�Z@?BLÌ`A�Ì1LhUfZ@=8A�ϵT[Î"Î ÇB̮dzY­TXZIL�M2CIL"Ñ´T�C M#FOH´?BL�ç � �Ýå�è]=@ZEÎ A�UVMO<KZI<KA�U�TXY�Ì`A�Ì`L"UOZjAXϵT[Î"Î ÇBÌ®ÇOÈY�T�Z@L�M�CIL"Ñ´T�C M�<>=8L ØBÍBC@L"=I=@L�M`<KU¦Z@L"CIÌ`=jAXÏ�ͳCIL"JO<KA�ÇB= � Î A[U�MO<KZI<KA[U�T�YOÌ1A[Ì1L"UOZ@=�F ÖEÌ`Ì-TXC#L"ZTXY�â �XäjÎ A�Ì`ÍBÇBZ@L�M`ZI?B<K=§M�<>=@ZIC@<>Ó³ÇBZI<KA�U`ÇB=I<KUBÕ�6�TXÕ�ÇBL"C@CILZ@C�TXUB=]ÏSA[CIÌ`=�FBMOL¦D�A�Ç�p�T®TXU�M >T�<KYâ�æ!#häjΪA�Ì1ͳÇBZIL´Z@?B<K=EMO<K=IZIC@<KÓBÇBZI<KA[U1ÇB=@<>U³Õ¦ÇBU³<lÏQA�CIÌ`< p�T�Z@<>A[U¦Z@L�Î@?BUB<�î[ÇBL�FOH´?B<K=´Ì`L"ZI?BABM�?�TX=Î A[Ì1ÍBdzZ�T�Z@<KA�U�TXY�Î A�Ì`ÍBYKL ØB<KZ]ËZI?�TXZ´<K=�L ØBÍVA�UBLhUfZ@<�T�Y#<KU1Z@?BL�Ufdz̮Ó�L"C�A�Ï�MO<±í�LhCIL"UOZ´CILhÑ4TXC�MC T�ZILh=µTX=I=@<>Õ[UBL�M�Z@AE=@Ëf=@ZIL"Ì×=IZ T�ZILh=�F�@:A�UVT�ZI<KL"YKYKA´T�U�M >¥C�T�=@=I<#â�ì�ìhäB?�TNJ[L�ÍBCIA[Í�A[=IL�M�T�U³A�ZI?³L"CÇBU³<lÏQA�CIÌ`< p�T�Z@<>A[UOÈ]Ó�TN=IL�M2Ì1L"Z@?BABM�ZI?VT�Z§ÎªA�Ì1ͳÇBZIL"=:ZI?B<K=�MO<K=IZIC@<KÓBÇBZI<KA[U)ÓBÇBZ:<>Z@=§Î A[Ì1ÍBdzZ�TNÈZ@<>A[U�T�Y�ΪA�Ì1ͳY>LªØ�<KZ]Ë®<K=EÍVA�YKËOUBA[Ì1<�T�YB<KU�ZILhCIÌ1=:A�Ï�UOÇBÌ®ÓVL"C´A�Ï�=IZ T�Z@L"=T�U�M�C@L"Ñ´T�C�M,C�T�Z@L"=�FH´?BLh˦T�YKYKA�ÑbB�ANØB<­TXUMO<K=IZIC@<KÓBÇBZI<KA[UÏSA[CuÏÊT�<KYKÇBCIL�T�U�M�CIL"ÍVT�<KC8ZI<KÌ1L"=NF�DOL"J�LhC�T�YVT�ÇBZ@?BA�C@=�?�TNJ�LÇB=@L�M!ZI?³L-ß�@?o T�ÍBÍBC@AfT[ÎI?éZ@A©Î A[Ì1ÍBÇBZ@<KUBÕ1Z@?BL1MO<K=IZ@CI<KÓBÇBZ@<>A[U©AXÏ(T[Î"Î ÇB̮dzY­TXZIL�MêCILhÑ4TXC�Mâc"!#OÒ�"$�NäIFH´?BL�WM`EW TXÍBÍBCIAOT�Î@?�?VT�=ÓVL"L"U0L ØBZILhU�MOL�M ZIA!T�YKYKA�ÑÜZI?³L1ÇBU�M�L"CIYKËO<KUBÕ©C@L"YK<�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]Ë

Ì`A�M�L"Y#ZIA`Ó�L=@L"Ì1<±ÈIW)T�C@Ù�A�JO<�T�U)â�æ�æOÒ�� �BÒv�$#häIF�ß8T�Z@ZI<KÍ�T�Z@<jTXU�M�DO?�T�? â "�%hä�L ØBZIL"U�M�L�M)Z@?BLÑ�A�C@Ù®A�ÏjÛ]Ë[L"C´L"ZETXY�â � �Nä�ÓOË1T�YKYKA�Ñ´<>U³ÕEÏQA�C�UBA�UB?³A�Ì1A[Õ�L"U³L"A�ÇB=´W)TXCIÙ�A�J®Ì`ABMOL"YK=�F�ƳÇBC ÎI?OZÉÈÕ[A�ZIZ�T�U�M®W�LhË�L"C�â�ì!"NäVÍBCIA[Í�A[=IL�M�T�Ì`L"ZI?BABM�Z@?�T�Z�ÎhT�U1ÓVLEdz=IL�M9ÏSA�C�T[Î ËBÎ YK<�δUBA[UBCIL�ΪA�J�L"CÉÈTXÓBYKL�=IL"Ì`<±ÈÉW)TXCIÙ[A�J´Ì1ABMOL"YK=�F"Ð(A�Ñ�LhJ�L"CNÒ�Z@?BL´Î A�Ì`ÍBÇBZ�TXZI<KA�UVT�Y�Î A[Ì1ÍBYKL ØB<KZ]Ë´<K=�L ØBÍVA�UBL"UOZ@<­TXY<KU�UOÇBÌ®Ó�LhC´A�Ï�=IZ T�ZILh=§AXÏ�ZI?BLÌ`ABMOL"Y]FBß8T�ZIZ@<KÍ�T�Z@<#L"Z§TXY�âc"!�hä�T�YKYKA�Ñ�T®UBA[UOÈ]?BA�Ì`A�Õ�LhUBL"A�dz=W)TXCIÙ[A�J®Ì1ABMOL"YVÑ´<KZI?�ZI<KÌ1LªÈÉMOLhÍ�L"UVMOL"UOZ´CIL"Ñ´T�C M`C�T�Z@L"=�FH´?BL�WM`EWÔTXÍBÍBCIAOT�Î@?1<K=�U³A�Z´MO<KCIL�Î Z@YKË1T�ÍBÍBYK<�Î"TXÓBYKL´<lÏ�ÍVT�C�TXÌ1L"Z@L"CI=|A�Ï�ZI?³L§C@L"YK<�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]Ë

Ì`A�M�L"YjMOLhÍ�L"UVM!A�U)Í�TXC�TXÌ1L"Z@L"CI=�A�Ï�ZI?BL®ÍVL"C]ÏQA�CIÌ�T�U�ΪLÌ1ABMOL"Y|çSL�F ÕVF>ÒVÑ�A�C@ÙfYKAOT�M)MOLhÍ�L"U�ÈMOLhUfZ�Ï]T�<KYKÇBCIL:C�T�Z@LA�Ï�T=@L"CIJ[L"C�è�TXU�M`Jf<�Î LªÈÊJ[L"CI= TBF

�'& % �<-�0 +�������0 +=� f +���27�� �����/ �3/)0���� 27�+��(UBYK<>Ù[L�ZI?BLͳCIL"JO<KA�ÇB=TXÍBÍBCIAOT�Î@?�Ò³ZI?BL�Í�LhC]ÏSA[CIÌ-TXU�Î LT�UVM�CIL"YK<�T�Ó³<>YK<KZ]Ë®Ì1ABMOLhY>=ETXCIL¦ÎªA�Ì®ÈÓB<KUBLNM�<KU§Z@?B<K=8ZIL�Î@?BUB<�î[ÇBL�Z@AEËO<KL"Y�MT´=@<KUBÕ�YKL8Ì1A[UBA�YK<KZI?B<�ÎGÍ�L"CÉÏSA�C@Ì-TXÓB<KY><KZ]Ë�Ì1ABMOL"Y]F"DOÇVÎI?®T�UA�J[L"C�TXY>Y[Ì1ABMOL"Y�AXÏ�=IËO=@ZIL"Ì×Ó�L"?VTNJf<KA[CjÎ"TXU¦ÍVA�Z@L"UOZI<�T�YKYKËEËO<KL"Y�M:Ì1A�C@L�T�ÎhÎ ÇBC�TXZIL�CIL"=@ÇBYKZI=�Z@?�T�UZ@?BL¦Z@<KÌ1L È]=�Î"TXYKL¥M�L�Î A�Ì`Í�A[=I<KZI<KA[U-Ì`ABMOL"YjΪA�UB=@<­M�L"CIL�M!LNT�CIYK<KL"CNF�Ð(A�Ñ�LhJ�L"CNÒ�Z@?B<K=T�ÍBÍBC@AfT[ÎI?Z]ËOÍB<�Î"TXY>YKË)C@L"=IdzY>Z@=®<KU�T)J[L"CIËéY�T�C@Õ�L1TXU�Mé=@ZI<±í Ì1ABMOL"Y´ç]T�=@=IÇBÌ`<>U³Õ-=@Z�TXZIL È]=IÍ�T[Î L)Ì`A�M�L"YK==@Ç�Î@?,TX=EW)T�C@Ù�A�J1Î@?�TX<>U³=�è"FOÛ]UOZ@ÇB<KZI<KJ�L"YKËOÒ�Y�TXCIÕ�LhUBL"=I=:ABÎ"Î ÇBC@=EÓVL�Î"T�dz=ILAXϵT®Î C@A�=I=ÉÈÊͳCIABMOÇ�Î ZAXÏj=IZ T�Z@L"=EAXÏjZI?³L§ÍVL"CÉÏSA�C@Ì-T�UVÎ L§TXU�M`CIL"YK<�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]˦Ì`ABMOL"YK=�FODOZI<±í#UBL"=@=´A�ÎhÎ ÇBCI=�ÓVL�Î"TXÇB=ILZ@?BLL"J[L"UOZI=�T�=@=IABÎ <�T�Z@L�M�Ñ´<>Z@?¦T:Í�LhC]ÏSA[CIÌ-TXU�Î L�Ì`ABMOL"YBç]T�C@CI<KJ�T�YOT�U�M�=@L"CIJO<�Î L´C T�ZILh=j<KU¦T�î[ÇBL"dzL�èABÎ"ΠdzC�Z]ËOÍB<�Î"T�YKYKËT�Z�T:Ì®Ç�Î@?�ÏÊTX=IZ@L"C�C T�Z@L´ZI?�TXU¦Z@?BL´L"J�LhUfZ@=4TX=I=@A�Ϊ<­TXZIL�M�Ñ´<KZ@?9T�C@L"YK<�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]ËÌ`A�M�L"YVç�ÏÊTX<>YKÇBC@L�C T�Z@L"=�èhF�H´?OÇB=�Z@?BL´ZIC T�MOLhA�í)<KU¦ÍVL"C]ÏQA�CIÌ�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]˧TXU�T�YKËO=I<K=8<K=jZ@?�T�Z|A�Ï#=IA�YKJ[È<KUBÕET(Y­TXCIÕ[L�ÒN=IZI<±í®Ì1ABMOL"Y[ZI?�TXZ�ËO<KL"Y�MO=jT[Î"Î ÇBC T�Z@L´CIL"=@ÇBYKZI=8J�L"C@=IÇB=|=IA�YKJO<KUBÕ´Z]Ñ�AE=IÌ�T�YKYKL"C�Ò YKL"=@==@ZI<±í�Ì`ABMOL"YK=�Z@?�T�Z:ËO<>LhY­M�TXU,TXÍBÍBC@ANØ�<KÌ�T�ZIL:=IA[Y>dzZI<KA�U�F³ëéL�=I?BA[ÇBY�M1U³A�ZIL[Ò�?³A�Ñ�L"J[L"C�Ò³ZI?�TXZUOÇBÌ`L"CI<�Î"TXYjMO<��-Î ÇBYKZ@<>Lh=¥TXCI<K=I<KUBÕ`ÏSC@A�ÌÔY�T�C@Õ�L"U³L"=I=®T�U�Mê=IZ@<±í�UBLh=I=Ì�TNË-J[L"CIËêÑ�L"YKY�U³L"ÕfTXZILZ@?B<K=´ÕfT�<KU�F

Page 6: Reliability and Performability Techniques and Tools: A Survey ...

�'&�� d ��+� +�5 68/30�����+��44+��� ��+ �"37��2"68-H´?BL"=@L1Î"T�U!ÓVL1Î A�UB=@<�MOL"CILNMéT�=�<KUfZ@L"Õ�C T�Z@L�M)ÍVL"CÉÏSA�C@Ì-T�Ó³<>YK<KZ]Ë®Ì1ABMOLhY>=NÒBÓBdzZ§Z@?BL�CIL"=@L�T�C ÎI?<KU©Z@?B<K=¦T�C@L�T`<K==IA�L ØBZILhUB=I<KJ�L`ZI?�TXZ�Ñ�L®Z@CIL�TXZ<KZ§=@L"Í�TXC�T�Z@L"YKËfFGH´?B<K=ÍBCIA[ÓBYKL"Ì ?VT�=�Ó�LhL"U=IZ@Ç�MO<KL�M9ÏSA�C�T�Ì®Ç�Î@?YKA[UBÕ�L"C|ZI<KÌ1L�F�DOA[Ì1L�AXÏ�Z@?BLELNT�CIYK<KL"C�C@L ÏSL"C@L"U�Î Lh=EMBT�Z@LET�=8ÏÊTXC8Ó�T�Î@Ù®T�=å^#$�!"�âKå^�$�häIF��[R��1U R������� �X� ����� �����XJ] ´Ñ´<>Z@?)MO<±í�L"C@L"UOZ§Î dz=IZIA[Ì1L"C:Z]ËOÍ�L"=�T�U�M��� �X� ��������� X<] eZ���� V�P��TP�!�1U����T�C@L�Z]Ñ�AET�ÍBͳCIAfT[Î@?BL"=8ZI?�TXZjÎ"TXUÓVL�ÇB=ILNMZ@AEÌ1ABMOLhY�î�dzL"ÇBL"=�Ñ´<KZ@?=ILhCIJ�LhCÏÊTX<KY>dzCIL"=�T�U�MêCIL"ÍVT�<KC�F#Ö Z]Ñ�A�È]ÍBCI<KA[CI<KZ]Ë-î[ÇBL"dz<>U³Õ-=@ËO=IZILhÌ ÎªA�UB=@<>=@ZI=AXÏ�Z]Ñ�A1Z]ËOÍ�Lh=A�ÏjΪÇB=IZ@A�Ì1LhCI=^i[CILhÕ�ÇBY�T�C�q A�ÓB=8Z@?�T�Z�TXCIC@<>J[LET�Z�T�î�dzL"ÇBL�ÏSA[C�=IL"C@JO<­ÎªL§T�UVM�ÓBCIL�TXÙBMOA�Ñ´Umq A�Ó³=�Fá|CIL�TXÙ�M�A�Ñ´U q A[ÓB=�?VTNJ�L�T(?B<KÕ�?BL"C8ÍBC@L È]L"Ì1ÍBZ@<KJ�L�ÍBC@<KA�CI<KZ]Ë:ZI?�TXU¦C@L"Õ�ÇBY�TXC q A[ÓB=�FNÖEC@CI<KJ�T�Y[A�Ï�TÓBC@L�T�ÙBMOA�Ñ´U[qªA�Ó<KÌ1ͳY><KL"=V=ILhCIJ�LhC�Ï]T�<KYKÇBCIL�T�UVM�ÍBCILªÈÊL"Ì`ÍBZI<KA[U§AXÏ�T�UOË:CIL"Õ[ÇBY�T�C qªA�ÓÎ ÇBC@CIL"UOZIYKËÓVL"<KUBÕ1=@L"CIJO<�Î L�M#FGÖ´ÏSZ@L"C�=IL"C@J�L"C:ÏÊTX<>YKÇBC@L�ÒBZ@?BL=@L"CIJ[L"C�ÇBU�MOL"C@Õ�AOL"=C@L"Í�TX<>C�çS<]F L�FKÒO=IL"C@J�L"=�ZI?BLÓBC@L�T�ÙBMOA�Ñ´U?q A�Ó�èhF��:U�Î L:ZI?BL:CIL"Í�TX<KC�<K=8à�UB<K=I?³L�M#ÒOZI?³LE=ILhCIJ�LhC�C@L"=IÇBÌ`L"=�=IL"C@Jf<�Î <KUBÕ�CIL"Õ[ÇBY�T�Cq A[ÓB=®<±Ï¥T�UOËOF�Ö:YKZIL"C@U�T�Z@<>J[L"YKËfÒuA�U³L,ΪA�ÇBY�M�ΪA�UB=@<­M�L"C1Z@?BL�CIL"Í�TX<KC®Í�L"C@<KA�M AXÏ¥Tê=IL"C@J�L"C�T�==ILhCIJ�LhC¦J�T[Î"T�Z@<>A[U)ÍVL"CI<KABM#FuÛ]U©Z@?B<K=¥ÎhT�=IL[Ò�Z@?BL®Ì1ABMOL"YuÓ�LNÎ A�Ì`L"=¦T�î[ÇBL"ÇB<KUBÕ�Ì1ABMOLhYjÑ´<KZ@?J�T�ÎhT�ZI<KA[UB=�F�H´?BL!=IZ T�U�MBTXC�M0ÍVL"CÉÏSA�C@Ì-T�UVÎ L©Ì`L�T�=@ÇBCILh=)çS=@Ç�Î@?ÜT�=`Ì1L�TXU î[ÇBLhÇBLéYKL"UBÕ�Z@?�ÒÑ´T�<KZI<KUBÕZ@<KÌ1L´MO<K=IZIC@<KÓBÇBZI<KA[UB=�L"Z Î�F�è�A[ÓBZ�TX<>U³L�M®ÓOË®T�U�TXY>Ë�p"<KUBÕ�ZI?BL"=@Lî�dzL"ÇBL"=´T�C@LEZI?³L"U�ZI?BLMOL"=@<KCIL�M�ÍVL"CÉÏSA�C@Ì-T�Ó³<>YK<KZ]Ë�Ì1L�TX=IÇBC@L"=�FH´?BLh=IL¦î[ÇBL"dz<>U³Õ¦Ì`A�M�L"Y#Z]ËOÍ�L"=ETXYK=IA®YKL"U�M`ZI?³L"Ì1=@L"YKJ�L"=�ZIA®Ì`A�M�L"Y�Ì�T�<KUOZIL"UVT�U�Î L:ÍBCIAXÈ

Î L�M�ÇBCIL"=`<KUé=IËO=IZ@L"Ì1=�â�ì!�häIF�`´LhÕ�ÇBY�T�C�Ì-T�<KUOZILhU�T�U�ΪL®<>=�Î CIÇ�Ϊ<­TXY�ÏSA�C�?B<KÕ�?éCILhY><�TXÓB<KY><KZ]ËOFBÛ]UT`ÍBCI<KA[CI<KZ]Ë)î�dzL"ÇB<KUBÕ�=IËO=IZ@L"Ì©Ò#MO<±í#L"CILhUfZ�Ì-T�<KUOZILhU�T�U�ΪL=IZ@C�T�Z@L"Õ�<KL"=�Î"T�U!Ó�L®Ì`ABMOL"YKL�M�ÓOËT�=@=I<KÕ�U³<>U³Õ,TXÍBÍBC@A�ÍBC@<­TXZIL®ÍBC@<KA�CI<KZ]ËéçQCIL"Y�TXZI<KJ�L®Z@A)ZI?BL`ÍBCI<KA[CI<KZ]Ë©T�=@=I<KÕ�U³L�M!ZIA)C@L"Õ�dzY­TXCT�U�MÓBC@L�T�ÙBMOA�Ñ´U�q A�Ó³=�èuZIA:Ì-T�<KUOZILhU�T�U�ΪL4q A�Ó³=�F�DO<KÌ1<KY�T�C@Y>Ë[ÒIZ@?BL´Ì-TX<>UOZ@L"U�T�UVÎ L8Ì-TNËEÓVL´Î A�UB=@<�M[ÈL"C@L�M)=@L"CIJ[L"C�J�T�Î"TXZI<KA�UuFBÖE=@=IÇBÌ`<KUBÕ¦Z@?�T�Z:Ì-TX<>UOZ@L"U�T�UVÎ L.q A�ÓB=´?VTNJ�LYKA�Ñ�L"C´ÍBCI<KA[CI<KZ]Ë1Z@?�T�UCILhÕ�ÇBY�T�C�q A�ÓB=NÒNÌ-T�<KUOZILhU�T�U�ΪL�Ó�LhÕ�<KUB=�Ñ´?BLhU¦Z@?BLEî[ÇBL"ÇBL´ÓVL�Î A[Ì1L"=�LhÌ1ÍBZ]ËOF"ÛQÏ#ZI?BLhCIL´<K=8A�UBYKËA�U³LJ�T�Î"TXZI<KA�U`Í�LhCI<KABM#ÒOZI?BLhU)ZI?BL�Ì1ABMOL"YV<K=´ÙfU³A�Ñ´U,TX='������_ X?V�P��TP���1U��Q]HU^\$XJ_±FOÛQÏ�ZI?BL"C@L<K=�Ì1A[CIL´Z@?�T�U®A[UBL´J�T�Î"TXZI<KA�U�ÍVL"CI<KABM�çQ<ÊF L�FKÒNZI?³LE=ILhCIJ�LhC´=�Î@?BL�MOdzY>Lh=ET�UBA[ZI?BL"C|Ì-T�<KUOZILhU�T�U�ΪLÍVL"CI<KABMé<±ÏETNÏSZ@L"C¦Î A[Ì1ÍBYKL"Z@<>U³Õ,T,Ì-T�<KUOZILhU�T�U�ΪL¦ÍVL"CI<KABM#Òu<KZEàVU�MO=�ZI?BL�î�dzL"ÇBL1Z@A)ÓVL®=IZI<KYKYL"Ì`ÍBZ]ËBè"ÒOZI?³L"U�<>Z´<K=´ÙOUBA�Ñ´U�T�=�]� _�!���4_ X V P��YP�!�3U�� ]~U \!X<_lFƳA�C´T=@ÇBCIJ[L"Ë1A[U1=@<>U³Õ�YKLE=@L"CIJ[L"CEî[ÇBL"ÇB<KUBÕ�=IËO=IZ@L"Ì1=´Ñ´<KZ@?1J�T�ÎhT�ZI<KA[UB=4TXU�M®LhJ�T�YKÇ�T�Z@<KA�U

ZILNÎI?³UB<�î�dzL"=:ÏSA�C�=IZ@L�T�MOË[È]=IZ T�ZIL�Ì1L�TX=IÇBC@L"=�Ò³=IL"L�@:A[=I?B<�â ì$�OÒBì %häIFBDOL"J[L"C�TXY�Õ[L"UBL"C T�YK< p�T�Z@<>A[UB=T�UVM1LªØ�Z@L"UB=@<>A[UB=´ZIA�ZI?³L"=IL¦î[ÇBLhÇB<KUBÕ¦Ì`ABMOL"YK=�?�TNJ[L§ÓVL"L"U�=@ZIÇ�MO<KL�MGF�á�T�Î"Î LhY>YK<�TXU�M®H8CI<KJ[L�MO<âc�NäjTXU�T�YKË�p"L�M`T�U)W���>���æ�=@Z�T�UVMOÓOË1CILNMOÇBU�MBTXUOZ´=IËO=IZ@L"Ì©FBW�<KZ@C�T�U³<�T�U�M2ÖEJO<±ÈÊÛ]Z�p"?�T�Ù!â�ã!�häT�UVT�YKË�p"L�M�Ì®ÇBYKZ@<>=@L"CIJ[L"C§î[ÇBLhÇBL¦Ç³=I<KUBÕ�!X��4XJRTP������ (� �� � ��1U����T�ÍBÍBC@AfT[ÎI?!T�=I=@ÇBÌ1<KUBÕ�ZI?VT�ZÍBC@A�ΪL"=I=@A�CI=2ÏÊT�<KY�T�UVMéT�CIL`CIL"ÍVT�<KCIL�M <KU�MOL"ÍVL"U�MOLhUfZ@YKËfF A´L"dzZI=®T�U�M�6GÇ�Î"T�UOZ@A�UB<Eâc"[æhä(TXU�TNÈYKË�p"L�M�T´=I<KÌ`<>Y�TXCBÌ1ABMOL"Y[Ñ´?BL"C@L�=@L"CIJ[L"CI=�Ì�TNËEî[ÇBL"ÇBL|ÏSA�CuCIL"ÍVT�<KCjTXU�M.q A[Ó¦T�C@CI<KJ�T�Y[C�T�Z@L�Ì-TNËMOL"ÍVL"U�M�ÇBÍVA�UZ@?BL�UOÇBÌ®ÓVL"C#A�ÏBA[Í�L"C T�Z@<>A[U�T�Y[=IL"C@J�L"C@=8ÇB=I<KUBÕO]~P�CR���� ��!XTU�]HX�=R�� �VT�ͳÍBCIAOT�Î@?�FH´?BL"Ë®=@?BA�Ñ�L�M®Z@?�T�Z´Î A�U³Õ�L"=@ZI<KA�U®<KU1î[ÇBL"ÇBL�YKL"UBÕ[ZI?1MOdzLEZIA�=ILhCIJ�LhC�ÏÊT�<KYKÇBCIL´Î"TXÇB=IL"=´Z@?BLELªÏ�ÈÏSL�ΪZ�A�ÏVÏÊT�<KYKÇBC@L"=8ZIA�Ó�L|ÏSL"YKZ8YKA�UBÕT ÏSZIL"C8Z@?BL´CIL"ÍVT�<KC8<>=�Î A[Ì1ÍBYKL"Z@L�M#F!`(L�Î L"UOZ@Y>ËOÒ�B�?�T�ÙOÙ�T:T�U�MW�<KZIC T�UB<:â>åNãhä�=IA[YKJ�L�M!T�UéW���W���A î[ÇBL"ÇBL®Ñ´<KZI?!=ILhCIJ�LhC¦ÓBC@L�T�ÙBMOA�Ñ´U�TXU�MêCIL"Í�TX<KCÇB=I<KUBÕ�� X�� CRTP�_�X�� ��P�� �3U��bP����4RTU^P��� OFBH´?BL"Ë`Õ�L"U³L"C�TXY>< p"L�ÓfË1TXYKY>A�Ñ´<KUBÕ�Ì®ÇBYKZI<KÍBYKL´=I<KÌ®ÇBYKZ�TXUBL"A[ÇB=CILhÍ�T�<KCT�U�M2ÏÊTX<KY>dzCIL"=:Ñ´?B<�ÎI?!Î A�ÇBY�M)M�L"Í�LhU�M)dzÍ�A[U)ZI?BL®T�C@CI<KJ�T�Y�TXU�M)MOLhÍ�T�C@ZIÇBC@L®A�Ï4q A�Ó³=�FÖEC@CI<KJ�T�Y#T�UVM1MOL"ÍVT�CIZ@ÇBCILh=´Ì-TNËABÎ"ΠdzC´<>U®ÓVT�Z�Î@?BLh=´A�Ï#àBØBL�M2A�C�C T�U�MOA[Ì çSÓVA�ÇBU�M�L�MBè�=I< p"L[FD�p"Z@CI<KÙ©TXU�M >��TXY4âKå �!�ªäµÍ³CIA�ÍVA�=@L�MéT®C@L�Î ÇBC@=I<KJ�L1ΪA�Ì1ͳÇBZ�TXZI<KA�U�TXY#ZIL�Î@?BU³<­î[ÇBL�ZIA�L"J�TXYKÇ�T�Z@LT�Ì®ÇBYKZI<±ÈÊZ@L"CIÌ`<lU�TXY�=@Ëf=@ZIL"Ì Ñ´<>Z@?1T�B´ß ��F=>�L"<K=IZ�LhZ4TXYjâ � �hä#ÍBC@A�ÍVA�=ILNM®ÍVL"C�Î LhÍBZI<KA�U�ÈÊÓ�TX=IL�MÌ1LNT�=IdzCIL"=´Z@?�T�Z´Î"T�ͳZIÇBC@L§ÓVA�Z@?1Z@?BL�Ì1L�TXU1T�U�M2J�T�CI<�TXÓB<KY><KZ]ËAXÏ�CIL"=@Í�A[UB=IL�ZI<KÌ1L´<KU-T¥Ì®ÇBY±È

Page 7: Reliability and Performability Techniques and Tools: A Survey ...

Z@<>=@L"CIJ[L"CEî[ÇBL"ÇBL:Ñ´<KZI?®Ï]T�<KYKÇBCIL"=NFf;:<KUBÕ¦TXU�M®W�<KZIC T�UB<�âc�[ãhä�ÍBC@L"=ILhUfZ@L�M)TXU®L"Ì1ÍB<KC@<­ÎhT�YB=@ZIÇ�MOËAXϵT�Ì®ÇBYKZI<K=@L"CIJ[L"C�=@ËO=IZILhÌ/Ñ´<KZI?`ÏÊTX<KY>dzCIL"=NF;:ÇBYKÙ�T�C@UB<jTXU�M�B�?BA�<�â %$�häµTXU�T�YKË�p"L�M�=@ZIL�T[MOË[ÈÊ=@Z�TXZIL�Ó�L"?VTNJf<KA[C´A�Ï�T®=@<>U³Õ�YKL�=IL"C@J�L"C�CILªÈ

Z@CI<�T�YOî�dzL"ÇBL´çQÑ´?BL"CILEΪÇB=IZ@A�Ì1LhCI=jΪA�U�MOÇVÎ Z8CIL"Z@CI<�T�YK=�dzUfZ@<KY�ZI?³L"Ë:à�U�M�Z@?BL�=@L"CIJ[L"C8ZIA:Ó�L|ÏSCILhL�èÑ´<KZI?�=@L"CIJ[L"C�ÏÊTX<>YKÇBC@L"=ET�UVM�CIL"ÍVT�<KCI=:ÇB=I<KUBÕ�W)T�C@Ù�A�J1C@L"Õ�LhUBL"C�TXZI<KJ�L�ÍBC@A�ΪL"=I=@L"=�FuÖEYKZI<KA[Ù©â�ìhäTXU�T�YKË�p"L�M =IZILNT�MOË[È]=IZ�TXZIL)ÓVL"?�TNJO<KA�C�A�ÏT)=@<KUBÕ�YKL1=@L"CIJ[L"C-î[ÇBLhÇB<KUBÕ©Ì`ABMOL"Y�Ñ´<>Z@?éÏÊTX<KY>dzCIL"=Ñ´?BLhCIL�=IL"C@JO<­ÎªL¦T�U�M2CIL"ÍVT�<KC´ZI<KÌ1Lh=4TXCILT�YKYKA�Ñ�LNM�ZIA�Ó�L�Ì1<±ØBZIdzCIL"=�A�Ï8Õ�L"UBLhC�T�YK< p"L�M�o8C@Y�T�UBÕMO<K=@ZICI<KÓBdzZI<KA�UB=NFfW,<lØBZ@ÇBCIL"=�A�Ï8Õ�L"U³L"C�TXY>< p"LNM�o8C@Y­TXUBÕ¦MO<K=@ZICI<KÓBdzZI<KA�UB=´Î"TXU-T�ͳÍBCIANØB<KÌ-TXZIL´T�UOËÕ[L"UBL"C T�Y#MO<K=IZIC@<KÓBÇBZI<KA[U�F���TXU9@E< q Ù`â ì[æhäGΪA�Ì1ͳÇBZIL�M�=@<KÌ1ÍBYKL�ÓVA�ÇBUVMO=�AXÏ�=IZ@L�T�MOË[È]=IZ T�ZIL�Î A�U�ÈÕ[L"=IZ@<>A[U�TXU�M!ZI?³CIA�dzÕ�?BÍBdzZ�ÏSA�C�Ì®ÇBYKZI<K=IL"C@J�L"C�=@Ëf=@ZIL"Ì`=Ñ´<KZI?êÏÊT�<KYKÇBC@L"=�F#H´?³L®A�ÍVL"C�TXZI<KA�U�TXYTXU�M�Ï]T�<KYKL�MÍVL"C@<>ABMO=´Î"TXU®Ó�L:Õ�L"UBLhC�T�YKYK˦MO<K=@ZICI<KÓBdzZIL�M#F[H´?BL"=@L�Ó�A[ÇBU�MO=�M�L"Í�LhU�M®A[UBYKËÇBÍVA�UZ@?BL®Ì1L�TXU©AXÏ4A[Í�LhC�T�Z@<KA�U�TXY�T�U�M,ÏÊTX<>YKL�MêÍVL"CI<KABMO=�FuÖEYKY�Z@?BL"=@L-T�ͳÍBCIAOT�Î@?BL"=�ÏQA�ΪÇB=A�UéZ@?BL=@ZIL�T[MOË[ÈÊ=@Z�T�Z@LÓVL"?�TNJO<KA�C�F

�'&�� d ��+ ��/3- ���W+ 0�6�27��3�5 8 d ��5�;?/3- f +���2��� �����/ �1/h0 � � 27��+�3/1- �

DBÎ@?BAOL"U âc# %hä§Î A[UB=I<�MOL"C@=1á[B´Wêß/â=%hä��'A´=�<KU�Ñ´?B<�Î@?éÏ]T�<KYKÇBCIL®C T�ZIL�MOL"ÍVL"U�MO=`ÇBÍVA�U�Z@?BLÑ�A�C@ÙfYKAOT�M#FNW�ÇBYKYKL"C]È�B�YKA�=IZ@L"CIÌ�T�UBU�?�T�=Eâ�ã$"hä�T�U�TXYKË phL�M¦T�Î Y�TX=I=�AXÏGMOLhÕ�C�T[MBT�Ó³Y>L�'A´=´çQ=I<KÌ®È<KY�T�C#Z@A§áeB´W)ß��'A(=�èuÑ´?BL"C@L´L�T�Î@?=@L"CIJ[L"C�Ì-TNË´A[Í�LhC�T�Z@LET�Zu=IL"J[L"C�TXYfYKL"J[L"YK=8A�Ï#çÊMOLhÕ�C�T[MOL�MBèÍVL"C]ÏQA�CIÌ�T�U�ΪL�F�Ð(L¦A[ÓBZ�TX<>U³L�M)T�ͳÍBCIANØB<KÌ-TXZILEͳCIABMOÇ�Î ZÉÈSÏQA�CIÌÔ=@A�YKÇBZ@<>A[UB=�ÏSA[CE=IZ@L�T�M�Ë�È]=IZ T�Z@LÍBC@A�Ó�TXÓB<KYK<>Z]Ë)MO<K=@ZICI<KÓBdzZI<KA�UB=�ÓfËéLªØ�ͳY>A[<KZI<KUBÕ�ZI?BL®U³L�T�C@Y>Ë[ÈIÎ A�Ì`ÍBYKL"ZIL1M�L�Î A�Ì`Í�A[=�TXÓB<KY><KZ]Ë�A�ÏZ@?BL"=IL�� A(=�F#ÐETNJ[L"CIÙ[A�C@ZET�U�M A´<KL"Ì`L"Õ�LhL"CI=�â ��"häjÍBC@A�ÍVA�=@L�Mb\�����P�]�� � �� �X� �����9�4X CZeU�RTS�ç�@EË��'A´= è�Ñ´?B<�Î@? ΪA�Ì®ÓB<KUBL®Í�TXC�TXÌ1L"Z@L"CI< p"L�M �'A´=�T�U�M Õ[L"UBL"C T�YK< p"L�M =IZ@A�Î@?�TX=IZ@<­Îêß�LhZICI<UBLhZI=!ç!>D³ß�A´= è"F´Ö ÓVL"?�TNJO<KA�C�TXYMOL�Î A[Ì1ÍVA�=I<KZ@<>A[U T�ÍBÍBC@AfT[ÎI? <K=�L"Ì1ÍBYKA�Ë[L�M Ñ´?BL"CILéZ@?BL�'A Ì`ABMOL"YK=EZ@?BL¦ÍVL"CÉÏSA�C@Ì-T�UVÎ LÓBÇBZ�=@A�Ì1L�AXÏ�<KZI=�Í�T�C T�Ì`L"ZIL"C@=§TXCIL�A�ÓBZ T�<KUBL�M`ÏQCIA�ÌÔZ@?BL>D³ß�A Ñ´?³<­Î@?�Ì1ABMOLhY>=|ZI?BLC@L"YK<�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]ËfF�D p�ÎTp"L"C@ÓB<�Î@Ù�T)âc#!#häjÎ A[Ì®ÓB<KUBL�M��'A´=�T�U�M >DBß�A(=ÏSA[C®Í�LhC]ÏSA[CIÌ-TXÓB<KYK<>Z]ËéT�UVT�YKËO=I<K=®ÓBÇBZ`=IA�YKJ[L�M0ZI?³L"=IL!Ì1ABMOL"YK=®ÇB=@<KUBÕ�MOL�Î A[Ì1ÍVA�=@<>Z@<KA�U T�U�MTXÕ�Õ�C@L"ÕfTXZI<KA�UuFDBÐ(ÖL`Eß o0ÏÊT[Î <KYK<>Z T�Z@L"=E=@Í�L�Ϊ<là#Î"T�Z@<>A[U�TXU�Mê=IA�YKÇBZ@<KA�U�A�Ï�?³<>LhC�T�C Î@?B<�Î"T�Y�Ì`ABMOL"YK=´Ñ´?BL"C@L

=@ÇBÓBÌ1ABMOLhY>=�Î"T�U Ó�L"YKA[UBÕ)ZIA!T)Y�T�C@Õ�L1Î Y�TX=I=�A�ÏEÌ1ABMOLhY�Z]ËOÍVL"=¦<KU�ΪY>ÇVMO<KUBÕ)ÍBC@A�M�Ç�Î Z�ÏSA�C@Ìî[ÇBL"dz<>U³Õ1UBL"Z]Ñ�A�C@ÙO=�Ò >DBß�A(=�Ò#W)TXCIÙ�A�J�C@L"Ñ4TXC�MêÌ1ABMOL"YK=NÒ[ÏÊT�ÇBYKZÉÈÊZ@CIL"L"=NÒ#CILhY><�TXÓB<KY><KZ]Ë®ÓBYKABÎ@ÙMO<�TXÕ�C�TXÌ1=NÒ�L"Z�ÎXF�ƳA�C�ÍVL"C]ÏSA[CIÌ�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]˦T�ÍBͳY><�Î"TXZI<KA�U³=�AXϵDBÐ(ÖL`Eß o´ÒB=@L"L1â=%�ìOÒ���æhäIF�'&�� �<0^+����0 / 4�+ � 27�+�3/1- ��� � �>��2������ÛQÏ8ZI?BLÍVT�C�TXÌ1L"Z@L"CI=´AXÏ�ZI?BLC@L"YK<�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]˦Ì`A�M�L"Y�TXU�M`ZI?BL�Í�L"CÉÏSA�C@Ì-TXU�Î L�Ì1ABMOL"Y�TXCIL�<KUOZIL"CÉÈMOLhÍ�L"UVMOL"UOZ�Ò8Z@?BL"U�T�Ué<KZ@L"C�TXZI<KJ�L®=@A�YKÇBZI<KA[U�TXÍBÍBCIAOT�Î@?éÌ-TNË�ÓVL-TXÍBÍBYK<KL�M#F >�L"YKL"UOÓVL1L"Z¦TXYâ �fæhäEÎ A[UB=I<�MOL"C1T!MO<K=IZ@CI<KÓBÇBZ@L�M =IËO=IZ@L"ÌÚ<KU�Ñ´?³<­Î@? UBABMOL"=®CILNÎ A�J�L"C�ÏQCIA�Ì ÏÊTX<KY>dzCIL"=�Ó�T�=@L�MA[U�T)Î@?BL�Î@ÙOÍ�A[<>UOZ@<>U³Õ)=IZ@C�T�Z@L"Õ�ËOF8H´?BL`Ñ�A[CIÙOYKAfT�MêA�ϧT-ÏÊT�<KYKL�M!UBABMOL`<>=�CIA�dzZIL�M ZIA)=@A�Ì1LA[Í�L"C T�Z@<>A[U�T�Y8UBABMOL�ZI?OÇB=�TNí#L�Î ZI<KUBÕ�Z@?BL¦ÍVL"CÉÏSA�C@Ì-T�UVÎ L¦AXÏ4Z@?�T�Z�UBABMOLXçS=�è¥Ñ´?B<�ÎI?!<KU)ZIdzCIU<KU���dzL"U�Î L"=|ZI?BL�ZIA[Z�T�YOC@L�Î A�J�LhCIË�ZI<KÌ1L�AXÏ�T:UBABMOL�ZI?BC@A�ÇBÕ[?9Î@?BL�Î@ÙOÍVA�<KUOZI<KUBÕE=@ZIC T�ZILhÕ�ËOF�DOÇ�Î@?Ì`A�M�L"YK=�Ì-TNË�ÓVLE=@A�YKJ�L�M�ÇB=@<>U³Õ¦T�U�<KZIL"C T�ZI<KJ[L´=IA�YKÇBZ@<KA�U®T�ÍBÍBC@AfT[ÎI?uF�Û]U�ÍBCI<KU�Ϊ<>ͳY>L[Ò�Z@?BL´CIL"YK<±ÈTXÓB<KY><KZ]˦TXU�M®ÍVL"CÉÏSA�C@Ì-T�UVÎ LEÌ`A�M�L"YK=�T�C@LE=ILhÍ�T�C T�ZILNM#F�Ð(A�Ñ�L"J[L"C�ÒO<KUB=@ZIL�T[M`A�Ï�=IA[YKJf<KUBÕ�Ó�A[ZI?Z@?BL"=IL´Ì`ABMOL"YK=8<>U�<K=IA[Y­TXZI<KA�UuÒ�T�U�<KZIL"C T�Z@<>A[U¦= Î@?BL"Ì1L�çQL�F Õ�FKÒhàBØBL�M[È]Í�A[<KUfZ8<KZILhC�T�Z@<KA�U�=�Î@?BL"Ì`L�è<K=�MOL"JO<K=IL�M2Ñ´?B<�Î@?¦A[ÓBZ�TX<>U³=jZ@?BLE=@A�YKÇBZ@<>A[U<KU1T�Î A�Ì®ÓB<KUBLNM�Ì-TXUBUBL"CNF�Û]U¦Õ[L"UBL"C T�Y]Ò[<>Z@L"C�TXZI<KJ�L

Page 8: Reliability and Performability Techniques and Tools: A Survey ...

=�Î@?BLhÌ1L"=�ËO<KL"Y�M-TXÍBÍBC@ANØ�<KÌ�T�ZIL:=IA[Y>dzZI<KA�UB=NF4B�A[UfJ[L"CIÕ[L"U�Î L�A�Ï�Z@?BL<KZIL"C T�Z@<>J[L=�Î@?BLhÌ1L"=�T�U�MÇBUB<�î[ÇBL"U³L"=I=�A�Ï8ZI?BL�=@A�YKÇBZI<KA[U1CILhÌ-T�<KU�T�U)T�C@L�T�A�Ï�T�Î Z@<>J[L�CIL"=@L�T�C ÎI?uF

�'&�� �L2� ?�>�1+�0 /12�-��?/ �+ � � ����2������H´?BL1Î A[Ì1ÍBYKL"Z@<KA�U)Z@<>Ì`L¦Í³CIA�Ó³Y>LhÌ T�=@=IÇBÌ`L"=T�Z�TX=IÙ)A[CI<KL"UOZILNMéJO<KL"Ñ TX=A�ÍBÍVA�=@L�M!ZIA)T[Î@ÈÎ ÇB̮dzY­TXZIL�M�C@L"Ñ´T�C�M�TXÍBÍBCIAOT�Î@?1Ñ´?³<­Î@?�T�=I=@ÇBÌ1Lh=�T=@ËO=IZILhÌ/A[CI<KL"UOZIL�M2JO<>LhÑ A�Ï8Í�L"CÉÏSA�C@Ì-T ÈÓB<KYK<KZ]Ë)â>å �häIFBÛ]U�ZI?BL�WM`EW T�ͳÍBCIAOT�Î@?�ÒBZ@?BLÇBU³=IZ�TXZIL�MêT�=I=@ÇBÌ1ͳZI<KA�U�Ñ´T�=´ZI?VT�Z´UBA`Y>A[=I=´AXÏCILhÑ4TXC�M®ABÎ"ΪÇBCI=�Ñ´?BL"U1T�=@Z�TXZIL´ZIC T�UB=@<KZI<KA�U®ABÎ"ΠdzCI=:çS<]F L�FKÒ�T�Î"ΪÇBÌ®ÇBY�T�Z@L�M�CILhÑ4TXC�M®Ç³UfZ@<KY�T�UOËZI<KÌ`LE<KUB=IZ T�UOZ´<K=´ÍBCILh=IL"C@J�L�MBèhF#H´?B<K=´<K=EÙOUBA�Ñ´U�T�= ��RYXTX<] �"!�)V�X?RTX�� �]~X ��U�_�� ����F³Û]U,î[ÇBLhÇOÈ<KUBÕ�=IËO=IZ@L"Ì1=�Ñ´<>Z@?é=IL"C@J�L"C�ÏÊTX<>YKÇBC@L"=�ÒuT�Î"Πdz̮ÇBY�T�ZILNM)C@L"Ñ4TXC�M!Ì�TNË-ÓVL®YKA�=@ZÇBÍVA�Ué=ILhCIJ�LhCÏÊTX<>YKÇBC@L¦â�ì!#häIFOH´?B<K=´<K=´Î Y�T�=I=@<±à�L�M)TX=<�4RYXTX<] �"!�hV X?RTX���XTP�#ÍVA�YK<�Î ËfF�B´T�=@ZI<KYKYKA9TXU�M1DO<KL"Ñ´<KC@AfLhÙâKå %hä4TXU�M);:ÇBYKÙ�T�C@UB<8L"Z¦TXY4âc�$"häµA[ÓBZ�TX<KUBL�M�Z@?BL®Z�TX=IÙ©Î A[Ì1ÍBYKL"Z@<KA�U�ZI<KÌ1LMO<K=@ZICI<KÓBdzZI<KA�UêÏSA�CT®W)TXCIÙ�A�JO<�T�U®=@L"CIJ[L"C�FV;:ÇBYKÙ�T�CIU³<#L"ZET�Y8âc�!#Nä#L ØBZILhU�MOL�M�Z@?B<K=´ZIA�=IL"Ì`<±ÈÉW)TXCIÙ[A�Jf<�TXU¦=@L"CIJ[L"C�Fá|A�ÓBÓB<KA�T�U�M�H8C@<>J[L�MO<´âKå�ìhä�Î A[Ì1ÍBÇBZ@L�M)Î A[Ì1ÍBYKL"Z@<KA�U1Z@<KÌ1LMO<K=IZ@CI<KÓBÇBZ@<>A[U)Ñ´?BL"U!Ñ�A�CIÙ�C@L Èî[ÇB<KCIL"Ì`L"UOZ�<>=�ß�ÐÞMO<K=@ZICI<KÓBdzZIL�MêÇB=I<KUBÕ�ÍB?VT�=ILªÈÊZ]ËOÍVL®L ØBÍ�T�UB=@<KA�UB=NF�á|A�Ó³ÓB<KA,TXU�MM`(A�ÓVL"CIZ@<âKå�å@ä§Î A[Ì1ÍBdzZIL�MéMO<K=@ZICI<KÓBdzZI<KA�U A�ÏEÌ1<KUB<KÌ1TXYjÎ A[Ì1ÍBYKL"Z@<>A[U©Z@<KÌ1L�ÏSA[C¦Í�TXC�TXY>YKL"Y|Z�T�=@ÙO=®L ØBL ÈÎ ÇBZ@<KUBÕ®A�U)T�=IL"Ì`<lÈIW)TXCIÙ�A�JO<�T�U�=IËO=@ZIL"Ì!F=@EÇVMBT1â�ì[ãNäjT�UVM1;:ÇBYKÙ�T�C@UB<#L"ZET�Y�â=%$�häµT�YKYKA�Ñ ÏSA�CÎ@?BL�Î@ÙOÍ�A[<KUfZ@<KUBÕ�F �´=@<KUBÕ-Î A[Ì1ÍBYKL"Z@<KA�U�ZI<KÌ1LTX=¥T2Ó�T�=@<K=�Ò³ÏSÇBC@ZI?BL"Cî[ÇBL"dzL"<KUBÕ)T�U�TXY>ËO=@<>=´?VT�=ÓVL"L"UéÎ"T�C@CI<KL�MêA�ÇBZ:<>U�A[C�MOL"C�Z@A-Î A[Ì1ÍBÇBZ@L�ZI?BL�Ì1L�TXUéâ " �BÒ7%$�NäµTXU�M�Z@?BL¦MO<K=IZ@CI<KÓBÇBZ@<KA�U)AXÏCILh=IÍVA�UB=@L¦Z@<>Ì`L¦âKå^"häIF�'&�� �����30 /��T5J0���0 +�L2� ���/3->��0^2���/ ����� 27�+�C5H´?B<K=¦TXÍBÍBCIAOT�Î@?�<K==@<KÌ1<KY�T�C´ZIAêZI?BL�WM`EW TXÍBÍBCIAOT�Î@?é<KUéZI?�TXZCILhY><�TXÓB<KY><KZ]Ë)T�UVM!Í�L"CÉÏSA�CÉÈÌ-TXU�Î L`Ì1ABMOL"Y�TXCIL�=ILhÍ�T�C T�ZILNM%TXU�MéZ@?�T�Z�ÍVL"C]ÏSA[CIÌ�T�U�Î L`Ì1L�TX=IÇBC@L"=®T�CIL�T�=@=IABÎ <�T�Z@L�M0T�=CILhÑ4TXC�M�C T�ZILh=EÑ´<KZI?�=IËO=@ZIL"ÌÔ=@Z�T�Z@L"=E<KU`ZI?BLC@L"YK<�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]˦Ì`A�M�L"Y]FfÐ(A�Ñ�L"J[L"C�Ò³ÇBUBYK<KÙ�LWM`:WT�ͳÍBCIAOT�Î@?�Ò#Z@?BL¦C@L"YK<�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]Ë1Ì1ABMOLhY�<KU)ZI?³<>=Î"TX=IL®<K=T1Î A[Ì®ÓB<KU�T�Z@A�C@<­TXY#Ì1ABMOL"Yu=IÇ�Î@?�TX=¥TÓBYKABÎ@Ù1MO<�T�Õ�C T�Ì A�C´T¥ÏÊT�ÇBYKZÉÈÊZ@CIL"L�F��|L"L"C�TXC�TXÕ�?�TNJ�TXU1T�U�M2HjC@<KJ�L�MO<�âKå ��ìªä�=I?BA�Ñ ?³A�Ñ Ì®ÇBYKZI<±È=IZ T�Z@L9Î A[Ì®ÓB<KU�T�Z@A�C@<­TXY�Ì`ABMOL"YK=EÎ"T�UêÓ�Ldz=IL�M,ÏSA�C´ÍVL"CÉÏSA�C@Ì-T�Ó³<>YK<KZ]Ë1T�UVT�YKËO=I<K=�F �(UBYK<>Ù[L�ZIC�T ÈMO<KZI<KA[U�T�Y�Î A[Ì®ÓB<KU�T�Z@A�C@<­TXY�Ì`ABMOL"YK=�Ñ´?³L"CIL¦T2=IËO=IZ@L"Ì çSA[CET1Î A[Ì1ÍVA�UBLhUfZ è�ÎhT�U)ÓVL<KU�A�UBYKËZ]Ñ�A-=@Z�TXZIL"=�ç�Ï]T�<KYKL�M�A�C�A[Í�L"C T�Z@<>A[U�T�Y�èhÒBZI?³L"=IL`Ì1ABMOL"YK=ET�YKYKA�ÑÝÏSA�C:Ì®ÇBYKZI<KÍBYKL�=IËO=IZ@L"ÌÚç]T�U�MÎ A[Ì1ÍVA�UBL"UOZ è�=IZ�TXZIL"=:=IA®Z@?�T�ZEMOLhÕ�C�T[MBT�Ó³Y>L�=@Ëf=@ZIL"Ì ÓVL"?�TNJO<KA�CEÎ"TXU-ÓVLÌ`A�M�L"YKL�M#F

�¦Á´Á.�����"Á�À ����À �ªÁ|À�����EÅ��IÅ]¿���8¾EÂ�����IÅ���:Å��IÅÉ¿��2-0¾m�� �m�fÅ��Û]U®ZI?³<>=|=IL�Î Z@<KA�U�Ò[Ñ�L�ÏQA�ΪÇB=�A�U�=IAXÏSZ]Ñ´T�CIL´ÍVT�Î@Ù�T�Õ[L"=�ZI?VT�Z�TXY>YKA�ÑéÓVA�Z@?¦Z@?BLEÍVL"C]ÏQA�CIÌ�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]ËT�UVM1C@L"YK<�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]Ë9TXU�T�YKËO=I<K=�F=A(L�T�C@YKË-T�YKY#Z@?BLZIAOA[Y>=´Z@?�T�ZEÎhT�U�Ó�L�ÇB=IL�M-ÏSA�C´ÍVL"C]ÏQA�CIÌ�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]ËT�UVT�YKËO=I<K=4ÎhT�U)T�YK=IA®ÓVL�ÇB=ILNM`ÏSA�C�CILhY><�TXÓB<KY><KZ]Ë®T�U�TXYKËf=@<K=�ÒBT�YKZ@?BA�ÇBÕ[?®ZI?BLh=IL�Ì-TNË�UBA�Z�Ó�L�ZI?BLÌ1A[=IZ�L �-Î <KL"UOZ®ZIAOA[Y>=�ÏSA[C¦C@L"YK<­TXÓB<KYK<>Z]ËéT�UVT�YKËO=I<K=�F8ÆBA[C1T)=@ÇBCIJ[L"Ë�A[U0=IA�ÏQZ]Ñ4TXCIL1Z@AOA�YK=�ÏSA�CCILhY><�TXÓB<KY><KZ]Ë®T�U�TXYKËf=@<K=�ÒOÑ�LECILªÏSL"CEZ@?BL�CIL�T[MOL"C:ZIA)â ��å�Ò��$�BÒ�%!"OÒBã�%NäIFBƳA�C�L�T�C@Y><KL"C´=@ÇBCIJ[L"ËO=EA[UÍVL"C]ÏSA[CIÌ�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]˦Ì`A�M�L"YK<>U³Õ¦Z@AfA[YK=�ÒO=ILhL-â � "OÒ��!�häIFBH´?³L=IAXÏSZ]Ñ4TXCIL�ZIAOA[Y>=´Z@?�T�Z:Ñ�LÎ A[UB=I<�MOLhCT�C@L!i�WDo8HEÆ[ÖmB�Ò A �:W�Ö§DGÒ�ß.o�A:ß.o8HÒ#DBÐ(ÖL`Eß o´ÒBDBß�A:ß8Ò�T�UVM �(YKZIC�T[DOÖ A�F

Page 9: Reliability and Performability Techniques and Tools: A Survey ...

�&)( ��� ��� � �

H´?B<K=´Z@AfA[Y#?�T�=´ÓVL"L"U!ÓVL"L"U©MOLhJ�L"YKA�ÍVL�M)TXZEßuA�YKËOZIL�Î@?BUB<�Î"TXY �´UB<KJ[L"CI=@<>Z]Ë�AXÏ B´T�Z T�YKÇBUOËfT�ÓOËB´TXCIC�TX=�Î A�T�U�M�Æu<KÕ�ÇBLhC�T�=�âKå^�häIFBÛ]Z´<K=EÑ´C@<KZIZILhU)<KU,ƳA�C@ZIC T�U©ã[ã®T�U�M`CIdzUB=EA[U ��Ö�� ����W)D=@Ëf=@ZIL"Ì`=�FNH´?BL�Ì1ABMOL"Y[<K=j<KUBͳÇBZ�ÓOË�Ì1L�TXUB=�AXÏ�ÍBC@A�M�Ç�Î ZI<KA[U¦C@ÇBYKL"=8Ñ´?B<�ÎI?�ÍBC@A�Jf<�MOL�T´?B<KÕ�?³L"CYKL"J[L"YOÓ�L"?VTNJf<KA[C�T�YBMOLh=�Î C@<>ͳZI<KA�U�A�Ï�Z@?BL´=IËO=@ZIL"Ì!F�H´?³L"=IL´C@ÇBYKL"=�MOL"=�ΪCI<KÓ�LETXU¦LhJ�L"UOZ�ÒXZI?BL�C�TXZILTXZ´Ñ´?B<�ÎI?êZI?BL�L"J�LhUfZÎ"TXU)ABÎ"Î ÇBCTXU�M�<KZI=:CIL"=@Í�A[UB=IL�FuÆBA[CEL Ø�T�Ì`ÍBYKL�ÒBT�UêL"J�L"UOZ�Î A�ÇBY�M�ÓVLZ@?BLEABÎ"ΠdzCICILhU�Î LAXÏjT:ÏÊT�dzY>Z�T�U�M�<KZI=|CIL"=@Í�A[UB=IL¦ÎªA�ÇBY�M�ÓVLECILhÍ�T�<KC�Ò[ÍVL"C]ÏSA[CIÌ�T�U�Î L�MOL"Õ[C�T�M³TNÈZ@<>A[U�ÒBA[CE=@Ëf=@ZIL"Ì�ÏÊT�<KYKÇBC@L�FBH´?BL�ÍBC@A�M�Ç�Î ZI<KA[U)CIÇBYKL®MOL"= Î CI<KÍBZ@<>A[U©AXÏ�ZI?BL�=IËO=IZ@L"Ì Ì`ABMOL"Y�<K=TXÇBZIA[Ì-T�Z@<�Î"T�YKYKË1Î A�UOJ[L"CIZ@L�M!ZIA)T�B�HEWMB�F�Ð(A�Ñ�L"J[L"C�ÒGZI?BL�CIL"Ñ´T�C M!C�TXZIL"=®çQ<±Ï(TXUfËBè:Ì®ÇB=@ZÓVLÌ-TXUOÇ�T�YKYKË=IÍVL�Î <±à�LNM�ÏSA[CEL"J[L"CIË�=@Z�T�Z@L�FVH´?B<K=´<K=ET1MOC TNÑ´Ó�T�Î@Ù®ÏQA�C´Ì1ABMOLhY>=´Ñ´<KZ@?-Y�TXCIÕ�L=@Z�T�Z@L È]=IÍ�T[Î L"=�FH8C�TXUB=I<KL"UOZ-TXU�MÝ=IZILNT�MOË[È]=IZ�TXZIL!Ì1L�TX=IÇBC@L"=)Î"T�U ÓVL©A[ÓBZ�TX<>U³L�M#F�Ö Î Ç³Ì®ÇBY�T�ZI<KJ[L-ÍVL"CÉÈ

ÏSA[CIÌ�T�ÓB<KYK<lZ]Ë)Ì`L�T�=@ÇBCIL�ÙOUBA�Ñ´U T�= ^X<RJV�� �TXYP����h_�����1Î"TXU Ó�L�A[ÓBZ�TX<>U³L�M#F�Û]Z®<K=1MOLªà�UBL�M TX=Z@?BLÍBC@A�Ó�TXÓB<KY><KZ]Ë�A�Ï�Î A[Ì1ÍBYKL"Z@<>U³Õ9T®Î LhCIZ�TX<KU©T�Ì`A�ÇBUOZ�A�Ï�Ñ�A[CIÙ`Ó�L ÏQA�CIL¥à�CI=@ZE=IËO=@ZIL"Ì ÏÊTX<KYlÈÇBC@L�F#Ö:Ì1A�U³Õ-T`J�T�C@<>LhZ]Ë)A�Ï´A�Z@?BL"C�Ì1L�TX=IÇBC@L"=�ZI?�TXZ¦Î"T�UéÓVL1Î A[Ì1ÍBÇBZ@L�M!T�CIL$i#CIL"YK<�T�Ó³<>YK<KZ]ËOÒTNJ�TX<>Y�TXÓB<KY><±Z]ËçQ<>U³=IZ�TXUOZ�T�U³L"A�ÇB=�A�C|=IZILNT�MOË[È]=IZ�TXZIL�èhÒBÌ�T�<KUOZ�T�<KU�TXÓB<lYK<±Z]ËfÒ YK<±ÏSL ÈIÎ ËBÎ YKL´CIL"YK<�T�Ó³<>YK<KZ]ËOÒYK<±ÏSL ÈIÎ ËBÎ YKL®Ì-TX<>UOZ T�<KU�T�Ó³<lYK<KZ]Ë�ÒBÌ`L�T�U!ÇBÍ�Z@<KÌ1L�ÒVÌ1LNT�U!ZI<KÌ1L�ZIAêÏÊT�<KYKÇBC@L�Ò#Ì1LNT�U!ZI<KÌ1L�Ó�LªÈZ]Ñ�L"L"U�Ï]T�<KYKÇBCIL"=NÒ#T�U�M�Ì`L�T�U`ZI<KÌ1L�Z@A1A�ÍVL"C T�ZI<KA[U©TNÏSZ@L"C§T2=IËO=IZ@L"ÌÔÏ]T�<KYKÇBCIL�F�B�A�=@Z]È]CIL"Y�T�Z@L�MÌ`L�T�=@ÇBCIL"=Î"TXU�TXYK=IA1ÓVL1Î A[Ì1ÍBÇBZ@L�M#F#дA�Ñ�L"J[L"C�Ò#U³A�ZT�YKY8Í�LhC]ÏSA[CIÌ-TXÓB<KYK<>Z]Ë®Ì`L�T�=@ÇBCILh=¥ÎhT�UÓVLÎ A�Ì`ÍBÇBZILNM#FDOZ@L�T�MOË[È]=IZ T�ZIL�=IA[YKÇBZI<KA�U�<>=uA�ÓBZ T�<KUBL�M¥ÓfË�6 ��MOL�ΪA�Ì1ÍVA�=@<KZI<KA�U�L ØBÍBYKA�<KZ@<>U³Õ´=IÍ�TXCI=IL�=IZ@A�CÉÈ

TXÕ�L�FNÆBA[C�ZIC T�UB=@<KL"UOZ�=IA[YKÇBZI<KA�UuÒ�T´Ì®Ç³Y>Z@<KÍBYKL#A�C�M�L"C�ÒNÌ®ÇBYKZI<±È]=IZ@L"Í >�L�T�CNÒ"<KÌ1ͳY><�Î <KZVÌ1L"Z@?BABM(ÏSA�C<KUOZIL"Õ[C�TXZI<KUBÕ§T¥=IËO=IZ@L"Ì A�Ï#A�C�M�<>UVT�CIË�MO<±í�L"C@L"UOZI<�T�YVL�î[Ç�TXZI<KA�UB=�ç�� @?o8= è�<K=8L"Ì`ÍBYKA�Ë�L�M#FNH´?B<K=Ì`L"ZI?BABM2<>=´L �-Î <KL"UOZET�U�M`=IZ T�ÓBYKL:ÏSA[C´=IZI<±í©Ì`ABMOL"YK=�F[ÛQÏ�ZI?BL�=IZ T�Z@L ÈÊ=@Í�T�ΪL¦<K=´Y�T�C@Õ�L�ÒOZ@?BL"U©TZ@L�Î@?BUB<�î[ÇBL§Î"TXYKY>LNM �P��X?\����^U�_* �!�1U���<K=�ÇB=ILNM®<KU®Ñ´?B<�Î@?®=IZ�TXZIL"=�Ñ´<KZI?®=@Ì-T�YKYOÍBC@A�Ó�TXÓB<KY><KZ@<>Lh=TXCILMO<K=I=@A�YKJ�L�M`<KUOZIA�Í�T�C@L"UOZ´=IZ T�ZILh=EÑ´?BA[=ILZ@C�T�U³=I<KZI<KA�U`C�TXZIL"=�T�CIL�Ì`A�M�<làVL�M®=@ÇB<KZ�T�Ó³Y>ËOF

�& % ���;� � �

A �EW�Ö�D!ç!A �´Ì1LhCI<�Î"T�Y8W�L"Z@?BABMO=:ÏSA�C´Z@?BLÖEUVT�YKËO=I<K=EAXÏ|ΪA�Ì1ͳÇBZIL"C�DOËO=IZ@L"Ì1= è�?�T�=:Ó�L"LhUMOLhJ�L"YKA�ÍVL�M�ÓOË�W�ÇBYKYKL"C]È�B�YKA�=IZ@L"CIÌ�T�UBU�T�Z´Z@?BL �´U³<>J[L"CI=@<KZ]Ë-AXÏ @:A�C@ZIÌ®ÇBUVM)â�ã�ãhäIFBÛ]Z´<K=:<>Ì2ÈÍBYKL"Ì`L"UOZIL�M,<>UéDO<KÌ®ÇBY�T %�ã�ÏQA�CDO<KL"Ì1LhUB=§á�DBæ!�$�!�2=IËO=IZ@L"Ì1=NF�á�Lh=I<�MOL"=Z@?BL®ÍVL"C]ÏSA[CIÌ�T�U�Î LTXU�T�YKËO=I<K=�ÒN<KZ�=@ÇBÍBÍVA�C@ZI=�Í�L"CÉÏSA�C@Ì-TXÓB<KY><KZ]ËETXU�T�YKËO=I<K=8JO<­T:MOL"Õ[C�T�M³T�ÓBYKL´î�dzL"ÇB<KUBÕ�UBL"Z]Ñ�A�C@Ùf=NF�Û]UZ@?BL"=IL�UBLhZ]Ñ�A[CIÙO=�ÒOL�T[Î@?-=@L"CIJ[L"C´Ì-TNË�A�ÍVL"C T�ZILTXZ�MO<±í�LhCIL"UOZ�çÊM�L"Õ�C T�MOL�M³è´YKL"J�LhY>=�A�Ï�ÍVL"CÉÏSA�CÉÈÌ�T�U�Î L[F�H´?BL¥ÏÊT�<KYKÇBCIL�T�U�M`C@L"Í�T�<KC´AXϵLNT�Î@?�=IL"C@J�L"C�Z�TXÙ�L"=´Í³Y­T[Î L<KU�MOLhÍ�L"UVMOL"UOZIYKË1AXÏ�A�ZI?³L"C=@L"CIJ[L"CI=NF�дA�Ñ�L"J[L"C�Ò8Z@?BL`ÏÊT�<KYKÇBCIL`C�TXZIL�Ì-TNË)ÓVL�YKAfT�MfÈÉMOLhÍ�L"UVMOL"UOZ1T�U�M ZI?BL`CIL"ÍVT�<KC®C�TXZILÌ�TNË9MOLhÍ�L"UVM�ÇBÍVA�U�ZI?BL�UOÇBÌ®ÓVL"C�A�Ï�A�ÍVL"C�TXZI<KA�UVT�Y#=ILhCIJ�LhCI=�FH´?BL®Ì`A�M�L"YuÏSA�C A �:W�Ö§DéÎhT�UéÓVL®<>U³ÍBÇBZJO<�T®Z]Ñ�A©MO<±í#L"CIL"UOZ<KUOZILhC]ÏÊT[Î L"=^i8T�U!<KUOZIL"CÉÈ

T[Î ZI<KJ�L9A �EW�Ö�D!<KUfZ@L"C]Ï]T�Î L®A[CZI?BL�дÛ]H×Ì1ABMOL"YK<KUBÕ1Z@AOA�Y�MOLhJ�L"YKA�ÍVL�M ÓfË!á�L"<KYKUBL"C�L"Z¦TXYâc"häIFBá�A[ZI?�ZI?³L§<KUOZILhC]ÏÊT[Î L"=§TXYKY>A�Ñ0=@Í�L�Ϊ<là#Î"T�Z@<>A[U�A�ϵM�L"Õ�C T�MBTXÓBYKL¥î[ÇBLhÇB<KUBÕ¦U³L"Z]Ñ�A[CIÙO=�F³H´?BLA[ÇBZIÍBdzZ§Ì`L�T�=@ÇBCILh=¥TXCIL�CIL"ÍVA�C@ZIL�M Ó�T�Î@Ù)<KU)Z@L"CIÌ`=�A�Ï�<KUBÍBdzZ§Ì`ABMOL"Y�çÊTXU�M�UBA[Z§<KU!ZIL"C@Ì1=AXÏ4Z@?BL1W)T�C@Ù�A�J©Î@?�TX<KU©ÇB=@L�M!ÏQA�C�=IA[Y>dzZI<KA�U�èhF#H´?BL"=@L1=@Í�L�Ϊ<là#Î"T�Z@<>A[UB=®T�CIL1TXÇBZIA[Ì-TXZI<�Î"T�YKYKËZ@C�T�U³=IY�T�Z@L�M<KUOZIAT¥çSY�T�C@Õ�L�è8W)TXCIÙ�A�J�ÎI?VT�<KU�FNH�ËOÍB<�Î"TXYKY>ËOÒ ZI?³<>=�W)T�C@Ù�A�JÎ@?�T�<KU�<>=uJ�L"C@˦Y�TXCIÕ�L=@<>UVÎ LL"J[L"CIË`=IZ�TXZIL<K=EMOLªà�UBL�M�ÓOË`ZI?BLUOÇBÌ®ÓVL"C�A�Ï�Î ÇB=IZ@A�Ì`L"CI=�T�Z´L"J[L"CIË�=ILhCIJ�LhC§T�UVM1Z@?BLMOLhÕ�C�T[MBT�Z@<KA�U1Ì`ABMOLEAXÏjL�T[ÎI?ê=IL"C@J�L"CNF

Page 10: Reliability and Performability Techniques and Tools: A Survey ...

H´?BLEM�L"Õ�C T�MBTXZI<KA�U�Ì1ABMOL"=8AXÏ�Z@?BLE=@Ëf=@ZIL"ÌÞTXCIL´A�Ó³Z�T�<KUBLNM�ÓfË�Z�T�ÙO<KUBÕT�Î CIA[=I=ÉÈÊÍBC@ABMOÇ�Î ZA�Ï´MOL"Õ�C T�MBTXZI<KA�UêÌ1ABMOL"=:A�Ï4TXY>Yu=IL"C@J�L"C@=�FuH8A®A�J�L"C Î A�Ì`LY�T�CIÕ[L"UBL"=@=�ÍBCIA[ÓBYKL"Ì©Ò³ZI?BL�=IZ T�ZILh=Ñ´<KZI?!ZI?BL�=�TXÌ1L�=IËO=@ZIL"ÌÚMOL"Õ[C�T[MBT�Z@<>A[U)Ì1ABMOLTXCIL�Ì1L"C@Õ�L�M�<KUOZIA�T®=@<>U³Õ�YKL¦Ì�T�Î C@A®=IZ T�ZIL[FH´?B<K=®T�Õ�Õ[CIL"ÕOT�Z@<>A[Ué<K=¦Ó�TX=IL�M A[UéZI?BL�A�Ó³=IL"C@J�T�ZI<KA[U�ZI?VT�Z�ZIC�TXUB=I<KZ@<>A[UB=�Ñ´<>Z@?B<KU�T)Ì�T�Î C@A=IZ T�Z@L%Z T�Ù[LéÍBY�T�Î L0T�Z©T0Ì®ÇVÎI?ÝÏÊTX=IZILhC©C T�ZIL ZI?�TXU ZI?BL ZIC T�UB=@<>Z@<KA�UB=!Ó�LhZ]Ñ�L"LhU Ì�T�Î C@A=IZ T�Z@L"=)çQ=I<KU�Î L)Z@?BL"=@L)ZIC T�UB=@<>Z@<KA�UB=�<KÌ1ÍBYKË)=@Ëf=@ZIL"Ì ÇBÍBÕ[C�T[MOL ��M�L"Õ�C T�MOL)Ñ´?³<­Î@? <>=®C T�C@L"C�èhFH´?BL®Ì�T�Î C@A1=IZ T�Z@L"=¦MOL àVUBL1T�UéT�Õ[Õ�CILhÕfT�Z@L�MêÌ-T�Z@CI<±Ø-Ñ´?³<­Î@?!<K=E=IA[YKJ�L�M,ÏSA�C�=@ZIL�T[MOË[ÈÊ=@Z�T�Z@LÌ1LNT�=IdzCIL"=NF�H´?³L©ÍVL"C]ÏQA�CIÌ�T�U�ΪL)Ì1ABMOL"Y�çSÑ´?B<�Î@? <K=-T W)T�C@Ù�A�J =IÇBÓBÌ`ABMOL"Y�è1TX=I=IABÎ <�TXZIL�MÑ´<KZI?éZ@?BL®=IZ T�ZILh=®Ñ´<>Z@?B<KU©LNT�Î@?éÌ-T[Î CIA�=IZ T�Z@L1<K=�=IA�YKJ[L�M#FuH´?BL"=IL`CIL"=@ÇBYKZI=®T�C@L®Í�T�=@=IL�M T�=Í�TXC�T�Ì`L"ZILhCI=Z@A©T�Õ[Õ�CILhÕfT�Z@L�M!Ì1ABMOLhYÊFGH´?fdz=¦T�U�TXÍBÍBCIANØB<KÌ-TXZILA�J[L"C�TXYKY�Ì1ABMOL"Y8=@A�YKÇBZI<KA[U<K=´A�ÓBZ T�<KUBL�M`ÓOË1<KZ@L"C�TXZI<KJ�LT�UVM1T�Õ[Õ�C@L"ÕfTXZI<KA�U`Ì1L"Z@?BABMO=�FBDOZ@L�T�M�Ë�È]=IZ T�Z@LÍBCIA[Ó�T�Ó³<>YK<KZ]Ë®J�LNÎ@ÈZIA[CI=�T�CIL�A�ÓBZ T�<KUBL�M�ÓOË`<>Z@L"C�TXZI<KJ�L�T�Õ�Õ[CIL"ÕOT�Z@<>A[U�Ò=>TXÇB=I=ÉÈÉDOLh<­M�L"Y�<KZILhC�T�Z@<KA�UB=NÒBA�C'>T�dz=I=I<�TXUL"YK<KÌ1<KU�TXZI<KA�U�F

A �EW�Ö�D)Î"T�U�ÍVL"C]ÏQA�CIÌÔ=@ZIL�T[MOË[ÈÊ=@Z�TXZIL®T�U�TXY>ËO=@<>=�A�Ï�J[L"CIË�Y�T�C@Õ�LW)T�C@Ù�A�JO<�T�U`Ì1ABMOL"YK=�FдA�Ñ�L"J[L"C�Ò#U³A-=@ÇBÍBÍVA�C@Z<K=EÍBC@A�Jf<�MOLNM�ÏSA[C�ZIC�TXUB=I<KL"UOZT�UVT�YKËO=I<K=�FVH´?OÇB=�Ì-TXUfË`A�Ï�Z@?BL®CILhY><±ÈT�Ó³<>YK<KZ]Ë1Ì`L�T�=@ÇBCILh=§T�UVM)Î ÇBÌ®ÇBY�TXZI<KJ�L:Í�L"CÉÏSA�C@Ì-TXÓB<KY><KZ]Ë®Ì`L�T�=@ÇBCIL"=�Î"T�U³UBA�Z�ÓVL¦Î A�Ì`ÍBÇBZ@L�M#F@:L"ÍVL"U�MOL"UVÎ <KL"=�Ó�L"Z]Ñ�L"L"UêÏÊTX<>YKÇBC@L"=�A�Ï�=IL"C@J�L"C@=§Î"TXUBUBA[Z´Ó�LÌ`ABMOL"YKL�M#F

�&�� ��� � 5 f �DBÐ(ÖL`Eß o çÊDOËOÌ®ÓVA�YK<�ΦÐ(<KL"C�TXC�Î@?B<�Î"T�Y:ÖEÇBZ@A�Ì�T�ZILNMb`´LhY><�TXÓB<KY><KZ]Ë ��ßuL"CÉÏSA�C@Ì1T�U�ΪL�o8J�T�YKÇ�T ÈZIA[C�è�Ñ4TX=A�C@<KÕ�<KU�T�YKYKË)MOL"J[L"YKA�ÍVL�Mé<KU å^#$" %`ÓOË�D³T�?BUBLhC9TXU�M!H8CI<KJ�L�M�<§âc#�æhäIF#Û]Z�?�TX=Ó�LhL"U=I<KÕ[UB<±à�Î"T�UOZ@Y>Ë�ÇBÍ#MBTXZIL�M�<KU1å^#$#BåEâc#[ìhäÉFhÛ]Z8<>=8Ñ´C@<>Z@ZIL"U�<KU8BéT�UVMC@ÇBUB=8A�U �0A´Û � T�UVM ��W)D#FH´?BL´Ì�T�<KU�ÏSL�TXZIÇBC@L´A�Ï�DBдÖ?`Eß.o!<K=�Z@?�T�Z8?OËOÓBCI<�M®TXU�M?³<>LhC�T�C Î@?B<�Î"T�YBÌ`ABMOL"YK=�Î"T�U®ÓVL´L�T�=ÉÈ<KYKË,ΪA�UB=@ZICIÇVÎ ZIL�MGF8H´?BL¦A�J[L"C�TXYKYj=@ËO=IZILhÌ Ì1ABMOLhYjÌ�TNË-Î A[UB=I<K=@Z§AXÏ�=ILhJ�L"C T�Y�=IÇBÓBÌ`ABMOL"YK=EAXÏÍVA�=I=@<KÓBYK˦MO<±í�LhCIL"UOZ�Z]ËOÍVL"=�F�H´?³L�Ì`A�M�L"Y�Z]ËOÍVL"=�T�YKYKA�Ñ�L�MT�C@L�Ï]T�ÇBYKZ]È]ZIC@L"L"=NÒ�CIL"YK<�T�Ó³<>YK<KZ]ËEÓ³Y>ABÎ@ÙMO<�T�Õ[C�TXÌ1=�ÒOC@L"YK<�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]Ë®Õ�C�TXÍB?B=NÒ�WêT�CIÙ[A�J)ÎI?VT�<KUB=�ÒVT�Î ËBÎ YK<�Î�=IL"Ì`<lÈIW)TXCIÙ�A�J1Î@?�TX<KUB=�ÒV=I<KUBÕ[YKLT�UVMÌ®ÇBYKZ@<lÈIÎ@?�T�<KU:ÍBCIABMOÇ�ΪZ8ÏSA�C@Ì î[ÇBL"dz<>U³ÕEUBL"Z]Ñ�A�C@ÙO=�Ò�>D³ß�A´=NÒ�T�U�M�=ILhCI<KL"=]È]Í�TXC�T�YKYKL"YBZ T�=@ÙÕ�C T�ÍB?³=�F�ƳA�C´LªØ³TXÌ1ÍBYKL�ÒOZ@?BLC@L"YK<­TXÓB<KYK<>Z]Ë�A�Ï�T�=@Ëf=@ZIL"Ì ÎhT�U)ÓVLÌ1ABMOLhY>LNM®ÓOË-T�C@L"YK<­TXÓB<KYK<>Z]ËÓBYKABÎ@Ù,M�<­TXÕ�C T�ÌÞÑ´?BLhCIL�CIL"YK<�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]Ë®A�Ï�L�T[ÎI?êÓBYKA�Î@Ù�<K=EÎ A�Ì`ÍBÇBZ@L�M`ÓfË�=@A�YKJO<>U³Õ1T®W)T�C@Ù�A�JÎ@?�T�<KU�F[ÛQÏjT:=I<KUBÕ[Y>LEWêT�CIÙ[A�J¦Ì`ABMOL"Y[ÏSA�C|=IÇ�Î@?-T¥=IËO=IZ@L"ÌÞÑ´T�=�Î A[UB=IZ@CIÇ�ΪZIL�M#Ò³ZI?BLhU1<KZ�Î A�ÇBY�M?�TNJ[LET�=IZ T�ZIL:=IÍ�T[Î LEAXÏ�LªØ�ÍVA�U³L"UOZI<�T�YV=I< p"L�FOд<KL"C T�C ÎI?³<­ÎhT�YVÌ1ABMOL"YK<KUBÕET�YKYKL"JO<�T�Z@L"=�ZI?³L´ÍBCIA[ÓOÈYKL"Ì1=�A�Ï8Ì1ABMOL"Y#Y�TXCIÕ�LhUBL"=I=�T�U�M2=IZ@<lí#UBL"=@=�ZIA®T�Y­TXCIÕ[L§LªØ�Z@L"UOZ�FH´?BL�Ì`A�M�L"Y4ÎhT�U0Ó�L�<KUBÍBdzZ¦L"<KZ@?BL"C1<KU <>UOZ@L"C�T[Î ZI<KJ�L�Ì`A�M�L®A�C®ÓOËéÌ1L�TXUB=�A�ϧÓVT�Z�Î@?

à�YKL"=NF4D�ÇBÓBÌ1ABMOLhY>=`Ì-TNËéÓVL)=IÍVL�Î <±à�LNM <>UÝZI?BL!=IËOUOZ�T Ø AXϦT�ÍBÍBC@A�ÍBC@<�T�ZILêÌ1ABMOL"Y:Z]ËfÍVL"=NFH´?BL"=@L�=IÇBÓBÌ`ABMOL"YK=�Ì�TNËZI?³L"U1ÓVL�ÇB=IL�M2<KU-MOL àVUB<KUBÕ?B<KÕ�?³L"C�YKL"J[L"Y#Ì1ABMOLhY>=NF�д<KL"C T�C ÎI?OË®<K=L"=@Z�T�Ó³Y><K=@?BL�M�ÓOË1ÍVT�=I=@<KUBÕ®Í�T�C T�Ì`L"ZIL"C@=´ÏSC@A�ÌÞYKA�Ñ�L"C´YKL"J�LhY�Ì1ABMOLhY>=�ZIA®?³<>Õ[?BL"C´YKL"J[L"Y�Ì`A�MfÈL"YK=ET�=´=@Í�LNÎ <±à�L�M�ÓOË®ZI?³LÇB=ILhC�F4o|T�Î@?�Ì1ABMOL"YV<K=�=@Í�L�Ϊ<làVL�M)ÓOË®Z@?BL�ÇB=IL"C:Ì-TXUfÇVT�YKYK˧Ѵ?³<­Î@?Î A[ÇBY�M0Ó�L!TéMOC�TNÑ´Ó�T[Î@Ù%<±Ï:ÏSA�C®<KUB=@Z�T�UVÎ L�T!Y�TXCIÕ�L)W)TXCIÙ[A�J%Î@?�T�<KU0<K=1Z@AéÓ�L)=@Í�LNÎ <±à�L�M#FDBÐ(ÖL`Eß oÜT�YKYKA�Ñ´=�L ØBÍ�A[UBL"UOZI<�TXY�Í�A[YKËfU³A�Ì1<�TXY�ç r���� � :���� ��� z èM�<>=@ZIC@<>Ó³ÇBZI<KA�U³=ZIA)ÓVL-TXZ]ÈZ�T[Î@?BL�MêZIA-ΪA�Ì1ÍVA�U³L"UOZI=çQZ�TX=IÙO=�Ò#=@Z�TXZIL"= è"F#H´?OÇB=(ÏÊT�<KYKÇBCIL�MO<K=IZIC@<KÓBÇBZI<KA[U©T�=@=IABÎ <�T�Z@L�M)Ñ´<KZ@?Ó�TX=I<�ΦΪA�Ì1ÍVA�U³L"UOZI=E<KU©ÎhT�=IL�A�Ï´Î A�Ì®ÓB<KU�TXZIA[CI<�T�YVÌ1ABMOL"YK=�çòÏÊT�ÇBYKZÉÈÊZ@CIL"L"=NÒ#ÓBYKABÎ@Ù,M�<­TXÕ�C T�Ì1=NÒT�UVM®CILhY><�TXÓB<KY><KZ]ËÕ[C�TXÍB?B=�è|A�C�=IA q A�ÇBC@UOÈ]ZI<KÌ1L´MO<K=IZ@CI<KÓBÇBZ@<>A[U-TX=I=IABÎ <�TXZIL�M2Ñ´<>Z@?1=@Z�T�Z@LEZ@C�T�U³=I<±ÈZI<KA[UB=´<KU,T2çS=@L"Ì1<�èÊÈÉW)TXCIÙ[A�J9Î@?�TX<>U)Î A[ÇBY�M`Ó�LT�U�L ØBÍVA�UBLhUfZ@<�T�Y#ÍVA�YKËOUBA�Ì`<­TXY]FH´?BL�Î A[Ì®ÓB<KU�T�Z@A�C@<­TXY�Ì`ABMOL"YK=�çòÏÊT�dzY>ZÉÈÊZ@CIL"Lh=�ÒNÓBYKABÎIÙ�MO<�T�Õ[C�T�Ì`=�ÒITXU�M�C@L"YK<­TXÓB<KYK<>Z]Ë�Õ�C T�ÍB?³=�è

T�C@LÇB=@L�M`ÏSA[C´CIL"YK<�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]Ë9TXU�M�TNJ�T�<KY�T�ÓB<KY±<>Z]Ë�T�U�TXY>ËO=@<>=NFOë <KZI?`L�T�Î@?©Î A[Ì1ÍVA�UBLhUfZ:çSA[C´YK<>U³Ù�è

Page 11: Reliability and Performability Techniques and Tools: A Survey ...

T¥ÏÊT�<KYKÇBC@L ÈÊZ@<KÌ1L´MO<K=IZIC@<KÓBÇBZI<KA[U1Ì-TNË�Ó�L�=IÍVL�Î <±à�LNM)T�=ETXU1L ØBÍVA�UBL"UOZ@<­TXY#Í�A[YKËfU³A�Ì1<�TXY�çQ=IËOÌ®ÈÓVA�YK<�Î�<KUH:�è"FBD³Ð´ÖL`:ß.o0Î A�Ì`ÍBÇBZ@L"=4M�<>=@ZIC@<>Ó³ÇBZI<KA�U2ÏSÇBU�ΪZI<KA�UêçS=IËOÌ®ÓVA�YK<�Î�<KU :�è"ÒOÌ1LNT�U�ÒOT�U�MJ�TXCI<�T�U�ΪL1A�ÏZ@<>Ì`L®ZIA!ÏÊTX<KY>dzCIL1AXϧZ@?BL)=IËO=@ZIL"Ì!F �´=ILhC1Ì-TNË!A�ͳZ�ÏSA�C�UOÇBÌ1L"C@<�ή=IA[YKÇBZI<KA�U<KU)Ñ´?B<�Î@?éÎ"T�=@L1T1UOÇBÌ`L"CI<�Î�J�TXYKÇBL¦AXÏ�ZI?³L1MO<K=IZIC@<KÓBÇBZI<KA[U)ÏSdzU�Î ZI<KA[U�TXZ§T`Õ�<KJ�LhU©Z@<>Ì`L?:§<K=Î A[Ì1ÍBdzZIL�M#FXÛQÏ#ÏÊT�<KYKÇBCIL´Í³CIA�ÓVT�ÓB<KYK<KZ]ËA�C�TNJ�TX<KY­TXÓB<KYK<>Z]Ë�çS<KUB=@Z�T�UOZ T�UBL"A[ÇB=�A�C�=IZILNT�MOË[È]=IZ�TXZIL�è�<K==@Í�L�Ϊ<làVL�M ÏSA�CLNT�Î@?�Î A�Ì`Í�A[UBL"UOZ�ÒuZI?³L"U�=@Ëf=@ZIL"Ì ÏÊT�<KYKÇBCIL�ÍBC@A�Ó�TXÓB<KY><KZ]Ë)A[C¦=@ËO=IZILhÌ TNJ�T�<KY±ÈTXÓB<KY><KZ]Ë)<K=®A[ÇBZIÍBdzZ�F�DOÍVL�Î <�T�YK< p"L�M =@A�YKÇBZI<KA[U�T�YKÕ�A[CI<KZI?BÌ`=T�CIL�ÇB=@L�M ÏSA[C9M�<lí#L"C@L"UOZ®Ì1ABMOL"YZ]ËOÍVL"=�FçS=@L"Ì1<�èÊÈÉW)TXCIÙ[A�J�Î@?�TX<>U³=®Ì-TNË!Ó�L)dz=IL�M ÏQA�C�Ó�A[ZI?0CIL"YK<�T�Ó³<>YK<KZ]ËéT�U�M ÍVL"C]ÏSA[CIÌ�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]Ë

TXU�T�YKËO=I<K=�FVDOL"Ì`<lÈIW)TXCIÙ�A�J�Î@?�T�<KUB=�Ì®ÇB=@Z´Ó�L1T[Î ËBÎ YK<­Î�A�C�<KCIC@L�MOÇ�Ϊ<>Ó³Y>L[F#H´?BL�=IA^q A[ÇBCIU�ÈÊZ@<>Ì`LMO<K=@ZICI<KÓBdzZI<KA�Ué<KU�Î"TX=IL�A�ϧT�=@L"Ì1<±ÈIW)T�C@Ù�A�J©Î@?�TX<KU�Î A�ÇBY�M T�UéL ØBÍVA�UBL"UOZ@<­TXY�ÍVA�YKËOUBA[Ì1<�T�Y]F`(L"Ñ4TXC�MêC�TXZIL"=�Ì-TNË`Ó�L1TX=I=IABÎ <�TXZIL�M Ñ´<>Z@?©=@Z�TXZIL"=AXÏ(T�çS=ILhÌ1<�èQÈIW)T�C@Ù�A�J�ÎI?VT�<KU�T�U�MêCILªÈÑ´T�C M®Ó�TX=IL�M�ÍVL"CÉÏSA�C@Ì-T�Ó³<>YK<KZ]Ë�Ì1L�TX=IÇBC@L"=EÎ"T�U�ÓVL¦Î A[Ì1ÍBÇBZ@L�M#FOH´?BLh=ILC@L"Ñ4TXC�M�C T�Z@L"=´Ì-TNËÓVL®=IÍVL�Î <±à�L�M L"<KZ@?BL"C®T�=¦T`UOÇBÌ1LhCI<�ÎJ�TXYKÇBL®A�C¦TX=ZI?³L®A�ÇBZ@ÍBÇBZAXϧT1ÍVL"CÉÏSA�C@Ì-T�UVÎ L®=IÇBÓ�ÈÌ`A�M�L"YB=IÍVL�Î <±à�LNM1ÓOË1T�î[ÇBL"ÇB<KUBÕU³L"Z]Ñ�A[CIÙ#ÒO=ILhCI<KL"=]È]Í�TXC�T�YKYKL"Y#Z T�=IÙ®Õ[C�TXÍB?�Ò³çS=ILhÌ1<�èQÈIW)T�C@Ù�A�JÎ@?�TX<>UuÒBA�CET >DBß�A�FBÛ]U�ZI?³<>=�Î"T�=@L�ÒVZI?BL�ÍVL"C]ÏSA[CIÌ�T�U�Î L�Ì`A�M�L"Y#<K=´à�C@=IZE=@A�YKJ�LNM�ZIA®A[ÓBZ�TX<>UT�UOÇBÌ1L"C@<�δJ�T�YKÇBL(ÏSA�C�ZI?³L§C@L"Ñ´T�C�M`C T�ZIL[F�ƳA�C�<>C@CIL�M�Ç�Î <KÓBYKL¦Î@?�T�<KUB=NÒBDBдÖ?`Eß.o0Î A[Ì1ÍBdzZIL"=L ØBÍVL�Î Z@L�M®=@ZIL�T[MOË[ÈÊ=@Z�T�Z@LEC@L"Ñ4TXC�M�C�TXZIL�FOÆBA[C�ÎI?VT�<KUB=8Ñ´<KZI?®T�U®T�ÓB=@A�CIÓ³<>U³Õ§=@Z�TXZIL�Ò�D³Ð´ÖL`:ß.oÎ A[Ì1ÍBdzZIL"=�M�<>=@ZIC@<>Ó³ÇBZI<KA�U`A�ÏjT[Î"Î ÇBÌ®ÇBY�TXZIL�M�C@L"Ñ4TXC�M2ÇBUOZI<KY�TXÓB=IA[CIÍBZ@<KA�U�Ò[L ØBÍ�LNÎ ZIL�M,<>U³=IZ�TXUOÈZ T�UBL"A[ÇB=´CILhÑ4TXC�M�C T�ZIL[Ò�T�UVM®L ØBÍVL�Î ZILNM©T[Î"Î ÇBÌ®ÇBY�TXZIL�M2CIL"Ñ´T�C M�ÇBUOZI<KY�T�Õ�<KJ�L"U�Z@<>Ì`Le:�FƳA�C�<>C@CIL�M�Ç�Î <KÓBYKL¦W)TXCIÙ�A�J®Î@?�T�<KUB=NÒ�D �?`ÝA�C >TXÇB=I=ÉÈÉD�L"<�MOL"Y�<K=�ÇB=ILNM`ÏSA�C�=IZ@L�T�M�Ë�È]=IZ T�Z@L

=@A�YKÇBZI<KA[U�FBÆBA[C´ZIC T�UB=@<>LhUfZTXU�T�YKËO=I<K=�ÒOdzUB<±ÏSA�C@Ì1< p�T�Z@<KA�U®Ñ´<KZI?�=IZ@L�T�M�Ë�È]=IZ T�Z@L9MOLhZIL�Î Z@<KA�U0â "³å@ä<K=�ÇB=@L�M#FVDOËOÌ®Ó�A[Y><�Î|=IA[Y>dzZI<KA�U®AXÏ�=IZ�TXZIL�ÍBC@A�Ó�TXÓB<KY><KZ@<>Lh=�<K=�A[ÓBZ�TX<>U³L�M®ÇB=@<KUBÕ86�TXÍBY�T�Î L:ZIC T�UB=ÉÈÏSA[CIÌÞT�UVM�Í�T�C@ZI<�T�Y³ÏSC�T[Î ZI<KA[U®L ØBÍ�T�UB=@<KA�U1T�ͳÍBCIAOT�Î@?©âc"�ãhäIFOÆBA[C8ÏÊTXÇBYKZ]È]ZICILhL"=4TXU�M®C@L"YK<�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]ËÕ[C�T�ͳ?B=�ÒBT®MO<K= q A�<KUOZ�=@ÇBÌ A�Ï�ÍBCIABMOÇVÎ ZI=�T�YKÕ�A[CI<KZI?BÌ <K=´ÇB=@L�MéâKå^� �NäÉFBƳA�C´Z T�=@Ù1Õ�C T�ÍB?³=�ÒBZ@?BLTXY>Õ[A�C@<>Z@?BÌ ÇB=ILNM�<K=4MO<K= Î ÇB=I=@L�Mê<>U!âc#Bå@äIF�&�� � f � fDBß AEß çÊDOZ@A�Î@?�TX=IZ@<­Î®ßuL"Z@CI<<A´L"Z�ßjT[Î@Ù�T�Õ�LNèE?VT�=�Ó�LhL"U�MOL"J[L"YKA�ÍVL�M!ÓOËQB�<�T�C�M�A1L"Z¦TXY´â æ[ìhäTXZ @:ÇBÙ[L �´UB<KJ[L"CI=@<>Z]ËOF#Û]Z<K=Ñ´C@<KZIZILhU�<KU B TXU�M!CIÇBU³=A�U�T�J�TXCI<KL"Z]Ë)AXÏ4A[Í�LhC�T�Z@<KUBÕ)=IËO=ÉÈZ@L"Ì1=8<KU�Î YKÇ�MO<KUBÕ �0A´Û �¦ÒXÖEÛ �¦Ò���D ��æ³Ò�T�UVM��§W)D#FXH´?BLEÌ`A�M�L"YOZ]ËfÍVL´ÇB=@L�M�ÏSA[C�<KUBÍBÇBZ8<K=�T��U �� P� �� �FRYX<Z[P�RT\��4X �ç]D�` A:è"F�Du` A´=´<KU�ΪA�CIÍVA�C T�Z@L=IL"J[L"C�TXY8=IZIC@Ç�Î Z@ÇBC�TXYjLªØ�Z@L"UB=@<>A[UB=�ZIA>D³ß�A´=â�æhäj=@Ç�Î@?)T�=´Ì-TXCIÙO<KUBÕ¦MOLhÍ�L"UVMOL"U�Î <KL"=2çSÌ-TXCIÙO<KUBÕ¦MOLhÍ�L"UVMOL"UOZ§TXC�ÎÎ"TXC�MO<KU�TXYK<>Z@<KL"=�ÒL"UVT�ÓBYK<KUBÕ´ÏQÇBU�Î Z@<>A[UB=�ÒNL"Z Î�F�è8T�U�M�T�YKYKA�Ñ©C@L"Ñ´T�C�M�C�TXZIL"=|ZIA�Ó�L´T�=@=IABÎ <�T�Z@L�M�Ñ´<KZI?LNT�Î@?¦Ì�T�C@Ù�È<KUBÕVF�H´?BL�C@L"Ñ4TXC�M2ÏSÇBUVÎ ZI<KA�U�Î"T�U`Ó�L�Ì-T�C@ÙO<>U³Õ¥M�L"Í�LhU�MOL"UOZ§TX=�Ñ�L"YKY]FBD�` A(=4TXCIL�=IÍVL�Î <±à�LNMÇB=@<KUBÕ�B´DBß.6êçCB Ó�TX=IL�M�DBß�A 6uT�UBÕ[Ç�T�Õ[L�èuÑ´?B<�Î@?¦<K=�T�U®L ØBZ@L"UB=I<KA[U®A�ÏvB Ñ´<>Z@?9T[MBMO<KZI<KA[U�T�YÎ A[UB=IZ@CIÇ�ΪZI=|ÏSA�C8MOL"=�ΪCI<KÓB<KUBÕ�ZI?BLED³ß�A Ì1ABMOL"YK=�FNë ?³L"CIL�TX=.B´DBß.6`L ØBÍBYKA�<KZI=8Z@?BL�ÏSÇBYKY�ÍVA�Ñ�L"CAXÏ B T�UVM�Ì-TXÙ�L"=�ZI?BL�D�` A =IÍVL�Î <±à�Î"TXZI<KA�U)J[L"CIË ��LªØ�<KÓBYKL�Ò³<KZET�YK=IA®Ì�T�Ù�Lh=´<>Z´<KÌ`Í�L"C T�Z@<>J[LZ@?�T�Z8ZI?³L�ÇB=@L"C�ÙOUBA�Ñ´=.B�F�H´?BLhCIL´<K=8UBA�<>UOZ@L"C�T[Î ZI<KJ�L�<KUOZIL"CÉÏÊT�Î L[Ò�ÓBÇBZ�T:Õ�C T�ÍB?B<�Î"TXYO<>UOZ@L"C]ÏÊT[Î LL ØB<K=IZ@=�F[H´?BLEdz=IL"C´Î"T�U`L"<KZI?BLhC�=@Í�L�Ϊ<lÏQ˦Z@?BL§D�`0A0Õ�C T�ÍB?³<­ÎhT�YKYKËA�C�Z]ËOÍVLE<KU®ZI?³LLB´DBß.6-à�YKL�FD�`0A =IÍVL�Î <±à�Î"TXZI<KA�UB=�T�C@L¦T�ÇBZ@A�Ì�T�ZI<�Î"TXYKY>Ë�Î A�UOJ�LhCIZILNM)<KUOZIA®T�U©WD`EWÔÑ´?³<­Î@?)<K=´Z@?BL"U

=@A�YKJ�L�M¥ZIAEÎ A[Ì1ÍBÇBZ@L�T´J�TXCI<KL"Z]Ë:A�ÏBZIC T�UB=@<>LhUfZNÒN=IZILNT�MOË[È]=IZ�TXZIL�Ò[Î ÇBÌ®ÇBY�T�Z@<KJ�L�Ò"TXU�M�=ILhUB=I<KZI<KJO<KZ]ËÌ`L�T�=@ÇBCIL"=â�æ³å@äÉFVDOZ�TXU�MBTXC�M`Ì1L�TX=IÇBC@L"=E=@Ç�Î@?©T�=�TNJ�L"C T�Õ[L§UOÇBÌ®ÓVL"C´AXϵZ@A�Ù[L"UB=E<KU)T�ÍBY�T�ΪL�ÒTNJ[L"C�TXÕ�L´ZI?³CIA�dzÕ�?BÍBdzZ�A�ÏjT�Z@<KÌ1L�M�Z@C�TXUB=I<KZI<KA[U�Ò�ͳCIA�ÓVT�ÓB<KYK<KZ]˦çQZIC T�UB=@<>LhUfZ�A�C|=IZILNT�MOË[È]=IZ�TXZIL�èZ@?�T�Z�T¥ÍBY�T�Î L:<>=|UBA�Z�LhÌ1ÍBZ]ËOÒ�T�UVM�ÍBCIA[Ó�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]ËZI?VT�Z�T�Z@<KÌ1L�M�ZIC T�UB=@<>Z@<KA�U®<K=�LhU�T�ÓBYKL�M®ÎhT�U

Page 12: Reliability and Performability Techniques and Tools: A Survey ...

ÓVL1Î A�Ì`ÍBÇBZILNM#FVH´?BL"=IL®ÓVT�=I<�Î�Ì1L�TX=IÇBC@L"=T�C@L9Î A[Ì®ÓB<KUBL�M�A[C�<>UOZ@L"CIÍBC@L"ZILNM çÊT�ÎhÎ A�C MO<KUBÕ�ZIAZI?³LÇB=ILhC�è´Z@A¦ËO<KL"Y�M`J�T�C@<>A[ÇB=�CIL"YK<�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]ËfÒNÍVL"C]ÏQA�CIÌ�T�U�ΪL�Ò�TXU�M®ÍVL"C]ÏQA�CIÌ�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]ËÌ1LNT�=IdzCIL"=NFƳA�C�L Ø�T�Ì1ͳY>L[Ò�=IÇBͳÍ�A[=IL�ZI?�TXZ4T�ZIA[Ù�L"U`<KU®ÍBY�T�Î L��1<KÌ1ͳY><KL"=8Z@?�T�Z�ZI?BL:=IËO=IZ@L"Ì ?�T�=|ÏÊT�<KYKL�M#FH´?BL"UéZ@?BL®ÍBC@A�Ó�TXÓB<KY><KZ]Ë�A�ÏET`ZIA[Ù�L"U!<KU©ÍBY�T[Î L��éT�Z�ZI<KÌ1L :§<K=�ZI?BL®ÇBU³CIL"YK<�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]Ë�A�Ï´ZI?BL=IËO=@ZIL"Ì!F�ÆBA[C¦T`Õ�<KJ�LhU©C@L"Ñ4TXC�MêÏSdzU�Î ZI<KA[U�Ò#L ØBÍVL�Î ZILNM�J�TXYKÇBL¦AXÏ4Z@?BL�ÏSÇBUVÎ ZI<KA�UuÒ#L ØBÍ�LNÎ ZIL�MT�ÎhÎ ÇBÌ®ÇBY�T�Z@L�M�C@L"Ñ4TXC�M�A�J[L"C�T�à�U³<>Z@L�ZI<KÌ`Lj<KUOZILhCIJ�T�Y]ÒNT�U�M�Z@<KÌ1L ÈITNJ�L"C T�Õ[L�M:L ØBÍ�L�ΪZIL�M�J�TXY>dzLÎ"TXU-ÓVLÎ A�Ì`ÍBÇBZ@L�M#FOÆBA[C4D�`0A´=�Ñ´<KZI?-TXÓB=IA[CIÓB<KUBÕ�Ì-TXCIÙO<KUBÕ�=NÒ�Ì1LNT�U®ZI<KÌ`L´ZIA1T�Ó³=IA�C@ÍBZI<KA[UT�UVM1LªØ�ÍVL�Î Z@L�M!T�Î"Πdz̮ÇBY�T�ZILNM®CILhÑ4TXC�M�ÇBUOZ@<>Y�TXÓB=IA[CIÍBZ@<KA�U-ÎhT�U�Ó�L�Î A�Ì`ÍBÇBZILNM#FƳA�C´Z@C�T�U³=I<KL"UOZ§TXU�T�YKËO=I<K=�ÒBT2?B<KÕ�?BYKË1T[Î"Î ÇBC T�ZIL®T�UVM1L �-Î <KL"UOZEJ�LhCI=I<KA[U)A�Ï�ÇBUB<±ÏSA[CIÌ`< pNTNÈ

ZI<KA[U�<K=�L"Ì1ͳY>A�Ë[L�M#F|H´?B<K=1<KU�Î A[CIÍVA�C�TXZIL"=ê=IZILNT�MOË[È]=IZ�TXZIL0MOL"ZILNÎ ZI<KA�U AXϦZI?³LéÇBU�MOL"C@YKËf<KUBÕMO<K=�ΪCIL"Z@L ÈÊZ@<KÌ1L¦W)TXCIÙ[A�J1ÎI?VT�<KU)T�U�M�Î A[Ì1ÍBÇBZ T�Z@<>A[U®A�Ï�ß�A[<K=I=IA[U�ÍBCIA[Ó�T�ÓB<KYK<KZI<KL"=�ÇB=I<KUBÕ1ƳANØT�UVM >�YKËOUBU�� =#Ì1L"Z@?BABM®â=%!�häIF�ƳA�C#=@ZIL�T[MOË[ÈÊ=@Z�TXZIL´=IA[YKÇBZI<KA�UuÒ >TXÇB=I=ÉÈÉDOLh<­M�L"YOA�C�U³L�T�CÉÈÊA[ÍBZI<KÌ-TXYD �?` Ì`L"ZI?³A�M â æ³å@äj<K=Edz=IL�M#FuDOL"UB=@<>Z@<KJf<KZ]Ë�T�U�TXY>ËO=@<>=:Ì-TNË1TXY>=@A®Ó�L®Î"TXCICI<KL�MêA�dzZEÓOË)Î A�Ì2ÈÍBÇBZ@<KUBÕ®ZI?BLMOLhCI<KJ�T�Z@<>J[L"=´A�Ï8=IA[Ì1LEAXÏ�ZI?BL�A�dzZIÍBÇBZ´Ì`L�T�=@ÇBCILh=´ÑF CNF Z�FOÌ1ABMOLhY#Í�T�C T�Ì1LhZIL"C@=�Fд<KL"C T�C ÎI?³<­ÎhT�Y�Ì1ABMOL"YK=§ÎhT�U!Ó�L1Î A[UB=IZ@CIÇ�ΪZIL�M ÓOË)Í�TXC�T�Ì`L"ZILhC§ÍVT�=I=@<KUBÕ`ÏSCIA[Ì YKA�Ñ�LhC§YKL"J[L"YÌ1ABMOLhY>=�çQ=IÇBÓBU³L"ZI= èZ@A-?³<>Õ[?BL"CYKL"J[L"Y�Ì`A�M�L"YK=çS=@ÇBÓBUBLhZI=�èhF8Û]ZIL"C T�Z@<>J[L®=IA[Y>dzZI<KA�U©TXÍBÍBC@AfT�Î@?â�æ!�OÒOæ��Nä�ÓVT�=ILNM®A�U�àBØBL�M[È]ÍVA�<KUOZj<KZ@L"C�TXZI<KA�U1Î"TXU®Ó�L´LhÌ1ÍBYKA�Ë�LNM�ÓOËÍ�T�C T�Ì`L"ZIL"C|Í�T�=@=I<KUBÕ�JO<­TT�=I?³L"YKY#à�YKL�FBDOZ T�Z@LZIC@ÇBU�Î"TXZI<KA�U�<K=4TXYK=IA®L�TX=IË1Z@A®<KU�Î A�C@Í�A[C�TXZIL®âc� %OÒ4"$�häIF�&�� � � ��� 5 � �H8Ö A0>�`´Ö�W ?�T�=:Ó�LhL"U�MOL"J[L"YKA�ÍVL�M)ÓOË)á|L"CI=@A�U!L"ZT�Y�âc# äµT�Z �(UB<KJ�L"C@=I<KZ]Ë�A�Ï[B´T�YK<±ÏSA�C@UB<�TT�Z?6#A[=´ÖEUBÕ[L"YKL"=�FVÛ]Z´<K=EÑ´C@<>Z@ZIL"Uê<>U�A[Ó!q L�Î Z:A�CI<KL"UOZ@L�M)ß8C@A�YKA�Õ1TXU�M�B�TXU�M�CIdzUB=EA[U,D � Aì�=@Ëf=@ZIL"Ì`=�FuÛ]ZÍBC@A�Jf<�MOLh=¦T�UéA[Ó!q L�Î ZÉÈÊA[CI<KL"UOZIL�M L"UOJO<>C@A�UBÌ`L"UOZ:ÏSA�CÌ`ABMOL"Y8=IÍVL�Î <±à�Î"TXZI<KA�UuFDOÇBÓ³Ì1ABMOL"YK=�TXCILMOL à�U³L�M`<>U®Z@L"CIÌ`=�AXÏ�<KUB=IZ T�U�Î Lh=´A�Ï�A�Ó!qªL�Î ZI=ETXU�M®<KUOZILhC�T�ΪZI<KA�UB=�ÓVL"Z]Ñ�LhL"UZI?³L®A�Ó!q L�ΪZI=�Fo�T�Î@?!A�Ó!q L�ΪZ§?VT�=T�U)<KUOZILhCIU�TXYj=@Z�TXZIL�Ñ´?B<�ÎI?!Ì-TNË1Î@?�TXUBÕ�L�L"<KZI?³L"CMOÇBL�ZIAT�UéLhJ�L"UOZ�A�ÎhÎ ÇBCIC@<KUBÕ©Ñ´<KZ@?B<KU©Z@?BL1A[Ó!q L�Î Z�A�C¦M�ÇBL1Z@A©T`Ì1L"=@=�T�Õ[L®CIL�ΪL"<KJ�L�M ÏSC@A�Ì =@A�Ì`LA�Z@?BL"C®A[Ó!q L�Î ZNF�Ö Y><KÓBC T�C@Ë©AXϧA�Ó!qªL�Î Z®Z]ËOÍ�Lh=®<>=�ÍBC@A�Jf<�MOLNM#F8H´?BL1dz=IL"C®Ì�TNË�TXY>=@A©MOL àVUBLT�ͳÍBYK<­ÎhT�ZI<KA[U-=@Í�LNÎ <±à�ÎA[Ó!q L�Î Z:Z]ËOÍ�L"=TXU�M�Î A�Ì®ÓB<KUBL�Z@?BA�=@LÑ´<KZI?)A[Ó!q L�Î Z:Z]ËfÍVL"=:ÏSC@A�Ì ZI?BLYK<KÓBC�TXCIËOF�д<KL"C T�C ÎI?³<­ÎhT�Y�Ì`ABMOL"YK<KUBÕ¦<K=:Í�A[=I=I<KÓBYKL�F @:L"Í�LhU�MOL"U�Ϊ<>Lh=¦T�Ì`A�UBÕ�A�Ó!q LNÎ ZI=�<K=EÌ`A�MfÈL"YKL�M�ÓOË`Ì1L"=@=�T�Õ[L�ZIC�TXUB=IÌ`<K=I=I<KA[UB=4TXÌ1A[UBÕZI?³L"Ì©FBƳA�C´L Ø�TXÌ1ÍBYKL�ÒOÎ A�U³=I<�MOL"C:ZI?BL= Î L"U�TXCI<KAÑ´?BL"UêÏÊTX<>YKÇBC@L�A�Ï�T1Î A[Ì1ÍVA�UBLhUfZ´Ì�T�Ù[L"=´=IL"J[L"C�TXY8A�ZI?³L"C§Î A[Ì1ÍVA�UBLhUfZ@=§MOA[CIÌ�T�UOZ�FOH´?B<K=´<K=Ì1ABMOLhY>LNM®ÓOË®=I<KÌ1ͳY>Ë�ZIC T�UB=@Ì1<KZIZ@<KUBÕT�Ì1L"=@=�T�Õ[L§T ÏSZIL"C´Z@?BLÎ A�Ì`Í�A[UBL"UOZ|ÏÊT�<KYKÇBCIL´Z@A®A�Z@?BL"CMOL"ÍVL"U�M�L"UOZEÎ A�Ì`Í�A[UBL"UOZI=8Ñ´?B<�Î@?1Î@?�T�UBÕ[L´ZI?BLh<>C|<>UOZ@L"CIU�TXY�=@Z�TXZIL´ZIA�MOA�C@Ì-T�UOZuÌ1ABMOL�FNH´?B<K=Õ�LhUBL"C�TXYK<>Z]Ë�T�U�M ��LªØ�<KÓB<KYK<KZ]˦Ì�T�Ù[L´HjÖ'A >�`(Ö§W T�Í�A�Ñ�L"C]ÏQÇBY#Ì1ABMOL"YK<KUBÕZ@AOA�Y]FH´?BL!A�J�LhC�T�YKY�Ì1ABMOLhYE<K=�=IÍVL�Î <±à�L�M TX=,T0Î A[YKY>LNÎ ZI<KA�UÝA�ϦA[Ó!q L�Î Z@=©T�U�MÝ<KUOZIL"C T�Î Z@<>A[UB=

T�Ì`A�UBÕ´Z@?BL"Ì!F�Ö0Õ[C�T�ͳ?B<�Î"T�YB<KUOZILhC]ÏÊT[Î L�<K=8ÍBC@A�Jf<�MOLNMZ@?�T�Z�<K=8ÇB=@L�M�ZIAMOL àVUBL´<�Î A�UB=uÏSA[C8A�ÓOÈq L�ΪZ�Z]ËOÍVL"=�F�`´L"Ñ´T�C M�C�TXZIL"=�Ì�TNË�Ó�L�T�=I=@ABÎ <�T�ZILNM�Ñ´<>Z@?®<KUfZ@L"CIUVT�YB=@Z�T�Z@L"=�A�Ï#ZI?BL:A�Ó!q L�ΪZI=�F[ÖW)TXCIÙ�A�J�CILhÑ4TXC�M®Ì`ABMOL"YB<K=�TXÇBZIA[Ì-T�Z@<�Î"T�YKYKËEÕ[L"UBL"C T�ZILNM®ÏQCIA�Ì×ZI?BL:=IÍVL�Î <±à�Î"TXZI<KA�U³=´A�Ï#J�T�CI<±ÈA�dz=´A�Ó!q L�ΪZ´Z]ËfÍVL"=NF�дA�Ñ�L"J[L"C�ÒOZ@?BL�ZIC�TXUB=I<KZ@<>A[U1C T�ZIL:Ì-TXZICI<±Ø®<K=�<KU�Î C@L"Ì1LhUfZ T�YKYK˦ӳÇB<KY>Z�T�U�MA�U³Y>Ë�ZI?³LECILNT�Î@?�T�Ó³Y>L:=IZ T�ZILh=4TXCILEYKAOA�Ù[L�M�T�Z�FOƳA�C�=@ZIL�T[MOË[ÈÊ=@Z�T�Z@LT�U�TXY>ËO=@<>=NÒ�ÍVA�Ñ�L"C|Ì1L"Z@?BABM<K=�ÇB=IL�MGF�ÆBA[C�ZIC�TXUB=I<KL"UOZT�UVT�YKËO=I<K=�Ò³ÇBUB<±ÏSA�C@Ì1< p�TXZI<KA�U`<>=�ÇB=@L�M#F�`(L"Ñ´T�C�MêÓ�TX=IL�MêÌ1L�TX=IÇBC@L"=T�C@LÎ A�Ì`ÍBÇBZILNM®T�=�Ñ�L"<KÕ[?fZ@L�M®=@ÇBÌ1=|A�Ïj=@Z�TXZILEͳCIA�ÓVT�ÓB<KYK<KZI<KL"=�TXU�M®C@L"Ñ4TXC�M2C�T�Z@L"=�F³Û]Z�<K=�U³A�ZÎ YKL�TXCE<±ÏµÎ dz̮ÇBY�T�ZI<KJ[L´Í�L"CÉÏSA�C@Ì-TXÓB<KY><KZ]ËÌ`L�T�=@ÇBCILh=EÎ"T�U�ÓVL¦Î A�Ì`ÍBÇBZ@L�M#F

�:ÇBZ@ÍBÇBZEÌ`L�T�=@ÇBCILh=ET�CIL�A�ÓBZ T�<KUBL�M`ÓOË-T®î[ÇBL"C@ËO<>U³Õ®Ì1L�Î@?�TXUB<K=IÌ©F��:ÇBL"C@<>Lh=ECILhÕfT�C MO<KUBÕ<KUOZIL"C@U�T�Y8=IZ T�Z@L"=�A�Ï�A[Ó!q L�Î Z@=¥TXU�M�C@L"Ñ4TXC�MO=�Ì�TNË®Ó�L®MOL à�U³L�M#F�B�A�U�ΪL"ÍBZIÇVT�YKYKËfÒVDBдÖ?`Eß.o

Page 13: Reliability and Performability Techniques and Tools: A Survey ...

TXU�M)H8Ö'A >�`(Ö§W Ó�A[ZI?�T�YKYKA�Ñ ?B<KL"C T�C�Î@?B<�Î"TXY�Ì`ABMOL"YK<KUBÕ�F³ÖÞÓ�T�=@<�ήMO<±í�L"C@L"U�Î L`Ó�LhZ]Ñ�L"LhUZ@?BL©Z]Ñ�A%TXÍBÍBC@AfT�Î@?BLh=-<K=`ZI?�TXZ-H8Ö'A >�`(Ö§W Î A�UOJ[L"CIZ@=,TXYKY§Z@?BL!A�Ó!q L�ΪZ-Z]ËOÍVL"=�<KUfZ@A%T=@<>U³Õ�YKL�ÒNÍ�A[=I=@<>Ó³Y>Ë�Y�T�C@Õ�L´T�U�M¥=IZI<±í�Ò�W)TXCIÙ�A�J�Ì`A�M�L"Y�ÏSA[C�T�U�TXY>ËO=@<>=uÑ´?BL"C@L�T�=�D³Ð´ÖL`:ß.oêÇB=IL"==@Í�L�Ϊ<­TXYK< phL�M�=IA[YKÇBZI<KA�U)TXY>Õ[A�C@<>Z@?BÌ1=|ÏSA[C§MO<±í#L"CIL"UOZ�Ì1ABMOLhY#Z]ËfÍVL"=T�UVM)MOAOL"=EU³A�ZEÕ[L"UBL"C T�Z@LT�=I<KUBÕ[Y>L�Y�T�C@Õ�L:Ì1ABMOL"Y]F

�&�� � �30 ��� � � ��(Y>Z@C�T[DOÖ A0?VT�=�ÓVL"L"U1MOLhJ�L"YKA�ÍVL�M2ÓfË®DBTXU�MOL"C@=�L"Z´T�Y�â�æ %hä#T�Z�Z@?BL �´UB<KJ[L"CI=@<>Z]Ë�A�Ï#ÖEC@< p"A�U�T³FÛ]Z8<K=�Ñ´CI<KZ@ZIL"U®ÇB=@<KUBÕ�B�T�UVM�� Ñ´<KU�M�A�Ñ�<KUOZIL"CÉÏÊT�Î L´YK<KÓBC T�CIËTXU�M�CIÇBU³=�A�U � A(Û � A�U @?o.B�ÒD �0AÒ�TXU�M�Ö�H��:H0Ñ�A[CIÙO=IZ T�Z@<>A[UB=�FXÛ]Z�<K=�T�=IÇVÎ"Î L"=@=IA�C´AXÏGWDo8H8Ö§DOÖ'AÒOT�ZIAOA�Y³ÍBCIL"JO<KA�dz=IYKËMOLhJ�L"YKA�ÍVL�M�T�Z �´UB<KJ�LhCI=I<KZ]Ë�A�Ï#W�<�ÎI?³<>ÕOT�UT�UVM�ZI?BL�Û]U�MOdz=IZIC@<�T�YOH8L�Î@?BUBA�YKA[Õ�ËEÛ]U³=IZI<KZ@ÇBZIL�âc#���äIF`(L"YK<­TXÓB<KYK<>Z]ËOÒ]ÍVL"C]ÏQA�CIÌ�T�U�ΪL�Ò�T�U�M�ÍVL"CÉÏSA�C@Ì-T�Ó³<>YK<KZ]ËET�UVT�YKËO=I<K=#Ó�T�=@L�M�A�U=@ZIABÎ@?�T�=@ZI<�Î�T[Î ZI<KJO<KZ]ËUBLhZ]Ñ�A[CIÙO=�çÊDOÖ'A´=�è`â�ã��Nä�Î"TXUéÓ�L®ÍVL"C]ÏQA�CIÌ`L�MêÇB=I<KUBÕ �´YKZ@C�T�D�Ö AFouØBZIL"UB=@<KJ�L®=IdzÍBÍ�A[CIZ<K=ÍBC@A�JO<­M�L�M ÏSA�C�Í�LhC]ÏSA[CIÌ-TXÓB<KYK<>Z]ËéT�UVT�YKËO=I<K=�F8DOÖ A(=-TXCIL�L ØBZIL"U³=I<KA�UB=`A�Ï�>DBß A´=)â�æhä§Ñ´<KZI?ÍBC@<KÌ1<KZI<KJ�Lh=�=@Ç�Î@?¦T�=uÍBY�T�Î L"=NÒ�T�Î Z@<>JO<KZI<KL"=|çS= T�Ì1L�TX=�ZIC T�UB=@<KZI<KA�UB= è"Òh<>U³ÍBÇBZ�ÕOT�Z@L"=�Ò�T�UVMEA[ÇBZIͳÇBZÕOT�ZILh=�F�H´?BL:<KUBÍBÇBZ�T�UVM�A�ÇBZ@ÍBÇBZ�ÕOT�ZILh=�T�C@LEÇB=@L�M�ZIAÌ`ABMOL"YOL"U�TXÓBYK<>U³Õ¥TXU�M®Î A[Ì1ÍBYKL"Z@<>A[UA�ÏTXU9T[Î ZI<KJO<KZ]˧C@L"=IÍVL�Î Z@<KJ�L"YKËOFfá|A�Z@?®<>Ì`ÍBÇBYK=ILªÈÊÓ�TX=IL�M�T�U�M�C�TXZIL È]Ó�T�=@L�M�CILhÑ4TXC�MO=´T�C@L4TXY>YKA�Ñ�L�M#FÛ]Ì`ÍBÇBYK=IL È]Ó�TX=IL�M CIL"Ñ´T�C MO=1T�C@L©T�=@=IABÎ <�T�Z@L�M Ñ´<>Z@?�Z@?BL)Î A�Ì`ÍBYKL"ZI<KA�UéAXÏ¥TXU T[Î ZI<KJO<KZ]Ë�T�U�MC T�ZILªÈÊÓ�TX=IL�M,CIL"Ñ´T�C MO=ET�C@L¦T�=@=IABÎ <�T�Z@L�M`Ñ´<>Z@?�Ì-T�C@ÙO<>U³Õ�=�FH´?BL¦D�Ö A <K=´<KUBÍBÇBZ:Õ�C�TXÍB?B<�Î"TXY>YKË�ÇBU�MOLhC§Z@?BL �ÜÑ´<KU�MOA�ÑÝL"UOJf<KC@A�UBÌ`L"UOZ�FOH´?BLLhUfZ@<KCIL

Ì`A�M�L"YEMOL"= Î CI<KÍBZ@<>A[U <K=-MOA[UBL)<KU0ZI?BC@L"L!Í�T�C@ZI=�F�DOZIC@Ç�Î Z@ÇBCIL!à�YKL)<K=®ÇB=@L�MÝZIA�MOL àVUBL©Z@?BL=@ZICIÇVÎ ZIÇBC@L�AXÏBZI?BL�D�Ö A0çQÍBY�T�Î Lh=�Ò�T�Î Z@<KJf<KZ@<>Lh=�Ò"LhZ�Î�F�è"F ouØBÍ�LhCI<KÌ1L"UOZGà�YKLj<K=uÇB=IL�M¥ZIAEMOL àVUBL�Z@?BLMOLh=I<KCIL�M¥A�ÇBZ@ÍBÇBZ�Ì`L�T�=@ÇBCILh=�T�U�M�=@A�YKÇBZ@<>A[UEÌ`L"ZI?BABM#F H´?³L"=IL|à�YKL"=jTXCIL�<KU�M�L"Í�LhU�MOL"UOZ�AXÏBL�T�Î@?A[ZI?BL"C�T�U�M!Z@?BL"CILªÏSA�C@L-MO<±í#L"CIL"UOZ�L ØBÍ�LhCI<KÌ1L"UOZ@=Ì-TNË`Ó�L`=IÍVL�Î <±à�L�M�ÏSA�C�ZI?³L1=�TXÌ1L®DOÖ A�FÆu<KU�T�YKYKËOÒ"TE=@Í�LNÎ <±à�Î"T�Z@<KA�U�ÏSA�C�Î A[Ì®ÓB<KUB<KUBÕ´J�T�C@<>A[ÇB=�=@ÇBÓBÌ`A�M�L"YK=�<KU9T:?B<KL"C T�C ÎI?³<­ÎhT�YOÌ-TXUBUBL"CÌ�TNË4TXY>=@A´Ó�L|ÍBCIA�JO<�MOL�M#F Û]U�ZI?BL�LªØ�ÍVL"C@<>Ì`L"UOZVà�YKL�Ò"Z]Ñ�A´Z]ËOÍ�Lh=�A�ÏOÍ�LhC]ÏSA[CIÌ-TXÓB<KYK<>Z]Ë�J�T�C@<�T�ÓBYKL"=Ì�TN˦ÓVL�=IÍVL�Î <±à�L�M�i#T[Î ZI<KJO<KZ]Ë1J�T�C@<�T�ÓBYKL"=´T�U�M`C@L"Ñ4TXC�M`J�T�C@<�T�ÓBYKL"=NFO֧ΠZ@<>JO<KZ]Ë1J�TXCI<�T�Ó³Y>Lh=4TXCIL=@Í�L�Ϊ<làVL�M�ÏQA�C§TXU©T�ΪZI<KJO<>Z]Ë)TXU�M�L"=@ZI<KÌ-TXZIL�ZI?BL�ZI<KÌ`L§ÓVL"Z]Ñ�L"L"UéZ]Ñ�A1Î A�Ì`ÍBYKL"ZI<KA[UB=´A�Ï�Z@?BLT[Î ZI<KJO<KZ]ËfF�`´L"Ñ´T�C M J�T�CI<�TXÓBYKL"=®<KU�Î YKÇ�MOL�ZI?³L)C�TXZIL È]Ó�T�=@L�M TXU�M <>Ì`ÍBÇBYK=ILªÈÊÓ�TX=IL�M CIL"Ñ´T�C MO=�FÛ]UB=@Z�TXUfZ T�UBLhA�ÇB=:J�T�YKÇBL"=�A�Ï�ZI?³L"=IL�J�T�C@<­TXÓBYKL"=´T�ZET�Õ�<KJ[L"U1Z@<>Ì`L�ÒBT�ÎhÎ ÇBÌ®ÇBY�T�Z@L�M®J�TXYKÇBL�A�J�L"CT�Z@<>Ì`LE<KUOZIL"C@J�T�Y]Ò�TXU�M`ZI<KÌ1LªÈÉTNJ[L"C�TXÕ�L�M�T�ÎhÎ ÇBÌ®ÇBY�T�Z@L�M`J�T�YKÇBL"=´A�J[L"C§TXU�<>UOZ@L"CIJ�TXY�Ì-TNË®ÓVLÎ A[Ì1ÍBdzZIL�M#FƳA�C�=IA�YKÇBZ@<KA�U�ÒOT¦D�Ö A <K=4ΪA�UOJ�L"C@ZIL�M`<KUOZIA®T=@Z�TXZIL È]YKL"J�L"YuCIL"ͳCIL"=@L"UOZ�T�Z@<KA�UéçQJf<�T�Ì�T�C@Ù�È

<KUBÕ[=�è�Î"T�YKYKL�MéDOZ@ABÎI?VT�=IZ@<�ή֧ΪZI<KJO<>Z]Ë!DOËO=IZILhÌ çÊDOÖ�DBè"FuÛQÏ´ZI?B<K=<K=¦W)TXCIÙ[A�Jf<�TXU©<KU!U�T�Z@ÇBCIL�ÒZ@?BL"U)T®W)T�C@Ù�A�J`Ì1ABMOL"YV<K=´Õ�L"UBLhC�T�Z@L�M#F#DOZ@L�T�MOË[È]=IZ T�ZIL�=IA�YKÇBZ@<KA�U1<K=´A[ÓBZ�TX<>U³L�M`ÓfË�6 � MOLªÈÎ A[Ì1ÍVA�=@<>Z@<KA�U®A�CETXU1<KZILhC�T�Z@<KJ�L�Ì1L"Z@?BABM®YK<KÙ�L�D �?`FOH8C�TXUB=I<KL"UOZ´=IA[YKÇBZI<KA�U`<K=´A�ÓBZ T�<KUBL�M`ÓOËÇBU³<lÏQA�CIÌ`< p�T�Z@<>A[U�F!6uT�CIÕ[L"UBL"=@=�A�Ï�=IZ T�ZILªÈÊ=@Í�T�Î L®<K=´A�J[L"C�Î A[Ì1L�ÓOË)Î A�UB=@ZIC@Ç�Î ZI<KUBÕ�T®C@L�MOÇ�Î LNMÓ�TX=IL:Ì1ABMOL"Y�âc#$�häÉFXH´?B<K=�Ì`A�M�L"YBCILhZ�T�<KUB=�A�U³Y>Ë�ZI?³LEUBL�ΪL"=I= T�CIË`<KUOÏSA�C@Ì-TXZI<KA�U�ÏQA�C�TM�L"=I<KCILNMA[ÇBZIÍBdzZ�Ì1L�TX=IÇBC@L�F�`´L"Ñ´T�C M®Ó�TX=IL�M2Í�L"CÉÏSA�C@Ì-TXÓB<KY><KZ]Ë�Ì1LNT�=IdzCIL"=´T�C@L§Î A[Ì1ÍBÇBZ@L�M�ÇB=@<>U³ÕÓ�LªÈ?�TNJO<KA�C T�YBMOL�ΪA�Ì1ÍVA�=@<KZI<KA�U`çS<]F L�FKÒNÍ�L"CÉÏSA�C@Ì-TXU�Î L´Ì1ABMOLhYf<K=�=@A�YKJ�LNM�ZIAA[ÓBZ�TX<>U�CILhÑ4TXC�M®C T�Z@L"=ÏSA[CCILhY><�TXÓB<KY><KZ]Ë�Ì1ABMOLhY­èhF#ÆBA[CUBA�U�ÈÉW)TXCIÙ[A�Jf<�TXU�TXU�MéT�U�TXYKËfZ@<�Î"T�YKYKË�<>UOZ@C�T�ΪZ�T�Ó³Y>L®Ì`ABMOL"YK=�Ò=@<>̮dzY­TXZI<KA�U�çQZIC�TXUB=I<KL"UOZ´T�U�M�=IZ@L�T�M�Ë�È]=IZ T�Z@L�è�<K=�ÍBCIA�JO<�MOL�MGF�дA�Ñ�L"J�LhC�Ò[Ó�L"?VTNJf<KA[C�T�YVMOL�Î A[Ì®ÈÍVA�=@<>Z@<KA�U!<>=�UBA�ZLhÌ1ÍBYKA�Ë�LNM`ÏSA�C�Í�L"CÉÏSA�C@Ì-TXÓB<KY><KZ]Ë�T�U�TXY>ËO=@<>=�Jf<�T`=I<KÌ®ÇBY�TXZI<KA�U�F³Û]UB=IZ@L�T�MGÒjT=@<>U³Õ�YKL�Í�L"CÉÏSA�C@Ì-TXÓB<KY><KZ]Ë�Ì1ABMOL"Y#<K=:=I<KÌ®ÇBY�T�Z@L�M#F[H´?BLZI<KÌ`<>U³Õ¦MO<K=IZ@CI<KÓBÇBZ@<>A[UB=E<KU�ZI?³L¦DOÖ A(=TXCIL¦TXY>YKA�Ñ�L�M�Z@A1ÓVL¦Õ[L"UBL"C T�Y]F �´YKZIC T�DOÖ'AÜ<K=:A�UBLAXÏ�ZI?³LÏSLhÑÜÍVL"C]ÏSA[CIÌ�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]Ë®Ì1ABMOL"YK<KUBÕ

Page 14: Reliability and Performability Techniques and Tools: A Survey ...

ZIAOA[Y>=�ZI?VT�Z´T�YKYKA�Ñ´=�=I<KÌ®ÇBY�T�Z@<KA�U�F�дLhU�Î L=@L"J�L"C T�Y#Ì`A�M�L"YK=�Ñ´?B<�Î@?-Î"TXUBUBA�Z´ÓVL§TXU�T�YKËOZI<�Î"TXYKY>Ë=IA[YKJ�L�M�Î"TXU-U³L"J�L"C@ZI?BLhY>Lh=I=�Ó�L�=IA�YKJ[L�M#F

�&�� �80�� +� � 2�27�=5H´?BL"C@L-TXCIL�=IL"J[L"C�TXY�A[ZI?BL"C�ZIAOA�YK=§TXYK=IA)TNJ�T�<KY�T�ÓBYKL:ÏSA[C§ÍVL"CÉÏSA�C@Ì-T�Ó³<>YK<KZ]Ë1T�UVT�YKËO=I<K=�F @:ÇBL�ZIA=IÍVT�Î LYK<KÌ1<KZ T�ZI<KA[UB=�Ò�Ñ�L�Ì1L"UOZ@<>A[U®ZI?BLh=ILA[UBYKË®ÓBCI<KL ��ËOF

@:Ë��'A´ZIAOA[YOç!@:ËOU�T�Ì`<­Î �:ÇBL"ÇB<KUBÕ A(L"Z]Ñ�A[CIÙ�ZIAOA[Y­è³?�TX=�ÓVL"L"U¦MOLhJ�L"YKA�ÍVL�M�ÓOË�ÐETNJ�LhCIÙ�A[CIZL"Z�T�Y�â ��#häµT�Z �´UB<KJ[L"CI=@<>Z]Ë`A�Ï�H´Ñ�L"UOZIL�FVÖ >DBß A Ì1ABMOLhY>=�ZI?³LCIL"YK<�T�Ó³<>YK<KZ]ˮѴ?B<KYKL�Í�L"CÉÏSA�CÉÈÌ-TXU�Î L�Ì1L�TX=IÇBC@L"=T�C@L9Î A[Ì1ÍBdzZIL�M)TX=�ÍBCIABMOÇ�ΪZ]ÈQÏSA�C@Ì =IA[YKÇBZI<KA�UêA�ÏET1MOËOU�TXÌ1<�Îî[ÇBL"ÇB<KUBÕUBL"Z]Ñ�A�C@Ù#F�Ö:=<KU�WM`EW TXÍBÍBCIAOT�Î@?�Ò�TêW)T�C@Ù�A�J)C@L"Ñ4TXC�M!Ì`A�M�L"Y�<K=Õ�LhUBL"C�TXZIL�M�ÏSA�C�Í�L"CÉÈÏSA[CIÌ-TXÓB<KYK<>Z]Ë®T�UVT�YKËO=I<K=�FBÐ(A�Ñ�L"J[L"C�ÒVZ@?BL¦ÍVT�C�TXÌ1L"Z@L"CI=:A�Ï�ZI?³L¦MOËOU�T�Ì`<�ÎEî[ÇBL"ÇB<KUBÕ`UBL"Z]Ñ�A�C@ÙÌ-TNË®MOL"ÍVL"U�M,ÇBÍ�A[U�ZI?BL=@Z�TXZIL"=:A�ÏjZ@?BLC@L"YK<­TXÓB<KYK<>Z]Ë�Ì1ABMOLhYÊFß.o Amo.6 �§ß o0?�T�=:Ó�LhL"U©MOL"J[L"YKA�ÍVL�M�ÓOË-W,ÇBUBÙ�LhCIZ§TXU�M�MOLW�L"L"C®â�ã!#häIFOÛ]Z´<K=´ÇBUB<�î[ÇBL

<KU)ZI?VT�ZE<KZETXY>YKA�Ñ´=�ÏSA[CEÍVL"C]ÏQA�CIÌ�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]˦LhJ�T�YKÇ�T�Z@<KA�U)T�U�M`A[ÍBZI<KÌ1< p�TXZI<KA�UuF�Û]Z:ÇB=IL"=WM`:W�=Ñ´?B<�Î@?�TXCIL®L ØBZ@L"U�MOL�M ÓOË©T�YKYKA�Ñ´<KUBÕÏQA�C�<KÌ1ÍBÇBYK=@LCIL"Ñ´T�C MO=¦TXU�M)C@L�Î A[UOà�Õ�dzC�T�Z@<KA�U!L�MOÕ�Lh=â�ìBå@äIFNH´?BL�CIL�Î A[UOà�Õ[ÇBC�TXZI<KA�U�L�MOÕ[L"=�<KÌ1ÍBYKË´Z@?BL´UBA�Z@<KA�UAXÏ�MOL�Î <K=@<>A[U¦Ì�T�ÙO<KUBÕ�Ò <]F L�FKÒ"Ñ´?³L"ZI?BLhCA�C:UBA�Z:ZIA`CIL�Î A[UOà�Õ[ÇBCIL1T2=IËO=IZ@L"Ì <KU)T®Õ[<>J[L"U�=IZ T�ZIL[F#H´?B<K=EZ@AfA[YjÎ A[Ì1ÍBdzZIL"=�T�U)A[ÍBZI<KÌ-TXY=IZ@C�TXZIL"Õ[Ë©AXÏ�ZI?BL�=IËO=@ZIL"Ì ÓOË�A�ÍBZ@<>Ì`< p"<KUBÕ¦=@A�Ì`LÍ�LhC]ÏSA[CIÌ-TXÓB<KYK<>Z]Ë®Ì`L�T�=@ÇBCIL[F�á|A�Z@?©Z@C�TXUOÈ=I<KL"UOZ�T�U�M2=IZILNT�MOË[È]=IZ�TXZIL�A�ÍBZ@<KÌ1< p�T�Z@<KA�U�<>=´T�YKYKA�Ñ�L�M#Fß.o AEß.o8H×çÊß o8ZIC@<7A´L"Z´Ó�TX=IL�M�ßuL"CÉÏSA�C@Ì-T�Ó³<>YK<KZ]Ë�o8J�T�YKÇ�TXZI<KA�U�H8AOA�Y�è8?�TX=�ÓVL"L"U)MOL"J[L"Y±È

A�ÍVL�M!ÓOËM6#L"ÍVA�Y�MêL"ZT�Y´â=%Bå@äIFVÛ]Z�<>=MOLh=I<KÕ�UBLNM�ÏSA[CEÍVL"C]ÏQA�CIÌ�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]Ë1L"J�TXYKÇ�T�Z@<>A[U�A�Ï�ÏÊTXÇBYKZ]ÈZIA[YKL"C�TXUfZ�Ì®ÇBYKZ@<>ͳCIABÎ L"=@=IA�C�=@Ëf=@ZIL"Ì`=Ó�TX=IL�MêA�UéWM`EW T�ͳÍBCIAOT�Î@?�F7>D³ß�A´=T�C@L®ÇB=ILNMéT�=ZI?³L®Ì1ABMOL"YuZ]ËfÍVL�F�`(L"Ñ´T�C�MêC�TXZIL"=¥ÏSA�CMO<±í#L"CIL"UOZ=@ËO=IZILhÌ =IZ T�Z@L"=¦<KU©T`C@L"YK<­TXÓB<KYK<>Z]Ë`Ì1ABMOL"YçÊT >�DBß�AEè´TXCIL�A�Ó³Z�T�<KUBLNM-TX=´Í�LhC]ÏSA[CIÌ-TXU�Î L�Ì1LNT�=IdzCIL"=´ÓOË1=@A�YKJO<KUBÕ�>DBß A´=�FDOÖ �Lo çÊDOËO=IZ@L"ÌÚÖ ��T�<KY�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]ËMo8=IZ@<>Ì�T�Z@A�C�è:?�TX=¦ÓVL"L"U0MOL"J[L"YKA�ÍVL�MéÓOË?>�A�ËfTXY�L"Z®T�Y

â �fìhä q A[<KUfZ@YKË©T�Z�ÛIá�W T�U�M @:ÇBÙ�L �´UB<KJ�LhCI=I<KZ]ËOF�Û]Z�L"Ì`ÍBYKA�Ëf=WM`:W TXÍBÍBCIAOT�Î@?éÏQA�C�Í�L"CÉÈÏSA[CIÌ-TXÓB<KYK<>Z]Ë�T�U�TXYKËf=@<K=�F�H´?BLhCILE<K=�U³A§=@ÇBÍBÍVA�C@Z�Ñ´<KZI?³<>U®DOÖ �LoéZ@A¦Î A[Ì1ÍBÇBZ@L�C@L"Ñ´T�C�M2C�TXZIL"=NFH´?BL"=@L©Ì®Ç³=IZ�Ó�L�=IdzÍBÍBYK<KL�M ÓfË ZI?BL�ÇB=@L"C�F�H8C�TXUB=I<KL"UOZNÒ�=IZ@L�T�M�Ë�È]=IZ T�Z@L�Ò�TXU�M0Î ÇBÌ®ÇBY�T�Z@<KJ�LÌ1LNT�=IdzCIL"=:A�Ï�WM`EW,=EÎ"T�U)ÓVLÎ A�Ì`ÍBÇBZ@L�M#F�D�<>̮dzY­TXZI<KA�U�ÇB=@<>U³Õ®<>Ì`Í�A[CIZ T�U�Î L:=�TXÌ1ÍBYK<KUBÕ<K=T�YK=@A1T�U1A[ÍBZI<KA[U�F

� �©Á.� .EÃ(¿��¿BÅ@Á�¾m����êÀBÁ.�m�������������´¿���¾ �fÅ@Á�¾m����8¾EÂ�©Ã:ÀBÀ���¾|¿��À���¾:Âm�ƳCIA�Ì ZI?BL�MO<K=�Î ÇB=@=I<KA�U³=ET�ÓVA�J�L�Ò[=IL"J[L"C�TXY#Ó�A[ZIZ@Y>LhUBL�Î@ÙO=E<KU®Í�LhC]ÏSA[CIÌ-TXÓB<KYK<>Z]Ë�T�U�M�C@L"YK<­TXÓB<KYK<>Z]ËT�UVT�YKËO=I<K=´Ó�LNÎ A�Ì`L§Î YKL�TXC�FBëéLMO<K= Î ÇB=I=:=IA[Ì1LEAXÏjZ@?BL�Ì-TJq A[C�<K=@=IÇBL"= i�'&)( w ��� ��+�-�+ 5 56�TXCIÕ[L"UBL"=@=´A�Ï�=IZ T�Z@L ÈÊ=@Í�T�ΪL§<K=�T¥Ì-TJq A[C�ÍBC@A�ÓBYKL"Ì×ÏSA[C�W)TXCIÙ�A�JO<�T�U�Ì1ABMOLhY>=NF�H8A�A�J�L"C Î A�Ì`LZI?³<>=´Í³CIA�Ó³Y>LhÌ©Ò�Ñ�LEÌ�TNËCIL"=@A�C@Z´ZIA�L"<KZI?BL"C´Y�TXCIÕ�LhUBL"=I=ÉÈÊZ@A�YKL"C T�U�Î L�A�C�Y­TXCIÕ[L"UBL"=@=]ÈITNJ�A�<�MBTXU�Î L=�Î@?BLhÌ1L"=NF�Û]U�ZI?BL8ÏQA�CIÌ`L"C�T�ͳÍBCIAOT�Î@?�Ò�T�Y�TXCIÕ�L8A�J[L"C�TXY>Y[Ì1ABMOL"Y�<K=�TXÇBZIA[Ì-T�Z@<�Î"T�YKYKË�Õ[L"UBL"C T�Z@L�M=IZ T�C@ZI<KUBÕ1Ñ´<KZ@?©T®Ì`A�CILÎ A[U�Î <K=IL®MOL"= Î CI<KÍBZ@<KA�U0â �$�häIFBH´?BL�Ì1ABMOL"Y#<K=:=IA�YKJ[L�M�ÇB=@<>U³Õ1=IÍVT�CI=@L=IZ@A�C T�Õ�L`ZIL�Î@?BU³<­î[ÇBLh=9TXU�M)=@Í�T�C@=I<KZ]Ë!ÍBCIL"=@L"CIJO<KUBÕ!L �-Î <KL"UOZ�UfdzÌ1L"C@<­ÎhT�Y8Ì1L"Z@?BABMO=�FGÛ]UéZI?BL

Page 15: Reliability and Performability Techniques and Tools: A Survey ...

Y�T�Z@ZIL"C�TXÍBÍBCIAOT�Î@?�ÒNZI?³L´Ì1ABMOL"Y[=I< p"L´<K=8CIL�MOÇVÎ L�M1M�ÇBCI<KUBÕ�Ì1ABMOLhY�Õ�LhUBL"C�TXZI<KA�U®T�UVMZ@?BL"CILªÏSA�C@LT(Y­TXCIÕ[L�Ì1ABMOL"Y[<K=jU³A�Z�Õ[L"UBL"C T�Z@L�M#FODOZ�TXZIL�ZICIdzU�Î"T�Z@<KA�U�Ì1L"Z@?BABMO=�âc"!�häIÒN?B<KL"C T�C�Î@?B<�Î"TXYOÌ1ABMOL"Y=@A�YKÇBZI<KA[U©â=%�ãhäIÒOT�U�M`?OËOÓBCI<�M®Ì`ABMOL"YK=�Z@?�T�Z�qªÇ�MO<�Î <KA�ÇB=@YKË9Î A[Ì®ÓB<KUBL§M�<lí#L"C@L"UOZ´Ì1ABMOL"Y#Z]ËOÍVL"=âc��ìhäjTXCIL�L Ø�T�Ì`ÍBYKL"=�A�Ï�Y�T�CIÕ[L"UBL"=@=ETNJ�A[<­M³T�U�Î L[F�'& % ��0 /��e- +�5 5DOZ@<±í�UBLh=I=�A�ÏZI?³L)Ì1ABMOL"Y:<K=1T�UBA[ZI?BL"C�ÍBC@A�ÓBYKL"Ì ZI?VT�Z1ͳY­TXÕ�ÇBLh=1<KZI=®=@A�YKÇBZI<KA[U�F�Û]Z�T�CI<K=@L"=Ì�T�<KUBYKËEMOÇBL´Z@A§Y�TXCIÕ�L´MO<±í#L"CIL"UVÎ LE<KU�ÏÊTX<KY>dzCIL´T�U�M�CIL"ÍVT�<KC8C�T�Z@L"=�A[C�Ï]T�<KYKÇBCIL�TXU�Meq A�Ó®T�C@CI<KJ�T�YC T�ZILh=�FBH´?³L¦WM`EW TXÍBÍBCIAOT�Î@?�CIL�M�Ç�Î L"==@ZI<±í#UBL"=I=:ÓOË1=ILhÍ�T�C T�ZI<KUBÕ`ZI?BL�Í�L"CÉÏSA�C@Ì-TXU�Î LT�U�MC@L"YK<­TXÓB<KYK<>Z]Ë´Ì`ABMOL"YK=#ÓBÇBZ8ZI?³L�=@ZI<±í�U³L"=I=�Ñ´<KZ@?B<KUCIL"YK<�T�Ó³<>YK<KZ]Ë´Ì1ABMOLhY�CILhÌ-T�<KUB=NF�DOZ@<±í�UBLh=I=8Ì-TNËÓVL1TNJ�A[<­M�L�M!ÓOË©ÇB=@<KUBÕ)T�Õ�Õ[CIL"ÕOT�Z@<>A[U%âKå<�BÒ�åNìNä�Z@?�T�ZËO<KL"Y�MO=¦TXÍBÍBC@ANØ�<KÌ�T�ZIL�=IA[YKÇBZI<KA�UuF�H8AZ@A�YKL"C�TXZIL�=IZ@<±í�UBLh=I=�ÒV=@Í�L�Ϊ<­TXY�=@Z�T�Ó³Y>L�=@ZI<±í©=IA[YKJ�L"C@=EÌ-TNË�ÓVL§Ç³=IL�Méâ=%$#OÒ�%���Ò�"$"NäIF�'&�� �W2�- � ������3�2=4�/ ��- � 27��+�=5Û]U)DOL�ΪZI<KA�U)ìBF�ì³Ò�Ñ�L�Ì1L"UOZI<KA[U1=ILhJ�L"C T�Y�=@ZIÇ�M�<>Lh=EZI?VT�Z�ÏSABÎ ÇB=´A[U�Í�L"CÉÏSA�C@Ì-TXÓB<KY><KZ]˦TXU�T�YKËO=I<K=AXÏ|î[ÇBLhÇBL"=Ñ´<KZI?�=@L"CIJ[L"C�ÏÊTX<>YKÇBC@L"=E<KU�Ñ´?B<�Î@?©MO<±í#L"CIL"UOZ¦M�<>=@ZIC@<>Ó³ÇBZI<KA�U³=ç qªA�Ó�<KUfZ@L"C]ÈIT�C@CI<KJ�T�Y]Ò=@L"CIJO<�Î L®ZI<KÌ`L�ÒOÏÊTX<KY>dzCIL�ZI<KÌ1L[ÒBCILhÍ�T�<KC�ZI<KÌ1L[ÒBL"Z Î�F�è§TXCIL®T�YKYKA�Ñ�LNM�ZIA`Ó�L®UBA[UOÈ]L ØBÍ�A[UBL"UOZI<�T�Y]FÐ(A�Ñ�L"J[L"C�ÒXZI?BL"C@L§MOAOL"=|UBA�Z8=ILhL"ÌÞZIA�ÓVL´Ì®Ç�Î@?=IAXÏSZ]Ñ´T�CIL´=@ÇBÍBÍVA�C@Z8ÏSA�C8Z@?BL"=IL�T�ÍBͳCIAfT[Î@?BL"=�FW�A[=IZ®AXÏ¥Z@?BL)=@A�ÏSZ]Ñ´T�C@L-ÍVT�Î@Ù�T�Õ[L"=1=@ÇBÍBÍVA�CIZ`Í�LhC]ÏSA[CIÌ-TXÓB<KYK<>Z]ËéT�UVT�YKËO=I<K=¦JO<�TéWM`:W TXÍOÈÍBC@AfT[ÎI?uFƳA�C´T�U�TXY>Ë�p"<KUBÕ�UBA[UOÈÉWêT�CIÙ[A�JO<­TXU®Ì1ABMOL"YK=NÒOZI?BL"C@L¦T�C@L�ZI?BC@L"L¦MO<±í#L"CIL"UOZ�T�ÍBÍBC@AfT[ÎI?³L"=^i

��� �� �JRTX��X��YX<V�X��� ��)]� �_ P�!�1U��´A�ÏVZI?BL�U³A�UOÈIW)T�C@Ù�A�JO<�T�U�Ì1ABMOLhYÊF H´?³L�CIL�T[MOL"C�ÎhT�UL�TX=I<KYKËA[ÓBZ�TX<>U`ZI?BL�J�T�=IZ´YK<KZILhC�T�Z@ÇBCIL�A[U-Z@?B<K=´=IÇBÓ!qªL�Î Z�F

� � �P�^X ��!����X8X���� P�����1U��®AXÏ�ZI?BL�UBA[UOÈ]L ØBÍ�A[UBL"UOZI<�T�Y�M�<>=@ZIC@<>Ó³ÇBZI<KA�U³=�FOH´?BL"C@L�?�TNJ�L:Ó�L"LhU=@L"J�L"C T�YuL í�A[CIZ@=´ZIA¦TXU�T�YKË�p"LEU³A�UOÈIW)T�C@Ù�A�JO<�T�U�CIL"YK<�T�Ó³<>YK<KZ]ËÌ`A�M�L"YK=�ÇB=I<KUBÕ�ÍB?�TX=IL:Z]ËfÍVLL ØBÍ�TXUB=I<KA[UÜâc#�ãhäIF�ƳA�C®A[ZI?BL"C`CIL ÏQL"CIL"UVÎ L"=�Ò:=ILhL%âc��æOÒ@% %³ÒEå^�³å@äIF�ƳA�C®ÍVL"C]ÏSA[CIÌ�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]ËTXU�T�YKËO=I<K=�AXÏ�UBA�UOÈIW)TXCIÙ�A�JO<�T�U�Ì1ABMOLhY>=NÒ�ZI?³L"CIL�?�TNJ[LEÓVL"L"U-T¥ÏSL"Ñ0L í#A�C@ZI=´<KU®ZI?³L§ÍVT�=IZNFá|A�ÓBÓ³<>A!âKå^�häj?VT�=EͳCIA�ÍVA�=@L�Mê?BA�ÑÜDBß�A(=EÑ´<KZI?)Õ[L"UBL"C T�YKYKË-MO<K=@ZICI<KÓBdzZIL�M,à�CI<KUBÕ`ZI<KÌ1Lh=Î"TXU¦ÓVL�ÇB=IL�M�Z@AEÕ[L"UBL"C T�ZIL´=@ZIABÎ@?�T�=@ZI<�Î�CILhÑ4TXC�M�Ì1ABMOL"YK=VÏSA[CjÍVL"CÉÏSA�C@Ì-T�Ó³<>YK<KZ]ËET�UVT�YKËO=I<K=�FÐ(L§U³A�ZILh=´ZI?�TXZ´ZI?BLT�YKÕ[A�CI<KZ@?BÌ1=8ÍBC@A�ÍVA�=ILNM1<KU!â æ[ãOÒBã!� ä�ZIA�=IA�YKJ[LEZI?³L¥ÎªY­TX=I=´AXϵDBß�A(=Ñ´<KZI?)ß�Ð×MO<K=IZ@CI<KÓBÇBZ@L�M`ZIC�TXUB=I<KZ@<>A[U`à�CI<KUBÕ®Z@<>Ì`L"=´Î"T�U�ÓVLÇB=ILNM�ZIA®=@A�YKJ�LÎ A[Ì1ÍBYKL"Z@<>A[UZ@<>Ì`L§MO<K=@ZICI<KÓBdzZI<KA�U�ÍBC@A�ÓBYKL"Ì Ñ´?BL"U�Ñ�A�CIÙ`CIL�î[ÇB<KC@L"Ì1L"UOZ´<K=§T�ß�Ð C�T�UVMOA�Ì J�T�C@<­TXÓBYKLâKå�æhäIF B�ÇBÌ-TXUB<Bâ�æ�ãhäB?�T�=u<KÌ1ÍBYKL"Ì`L"UOZIL�M�o�D³ß)Í�T[Î@Ù�T�Õ�L|ZI?�TXZjT�YKYKA�Ñ´=#T�U�TXY>ËO=@<>=#AXÏ�ZI<KÌ`L�MßuL"Z@CI<UBLhZI=�Ñ´<KZI? ß�Ð MO<K=IZ@CI<KÓBÇBZ@L�M à�C@<>U³Õ�ZI<KÌ`L"=®ÇB=I<KUBÕ ÍB?�TX=IL È]Z]ËOÍ�L!L ØBÍ�T�U³=I<KA�UB=NF@:<K=IZ@CI<KÓBÇBZ@<>A[U�A�Ï�Î A�Ì`ÍBYKL"ZI<KA[U´ZI<KÌ1L�Î"TXU§ÓVL�A[ÓBZ�TX<>U³L�M#F�ƳÇBC@ZI?BL"CuUOÇBÌ1L"C@<�Î"T�Y�L Ø�TXÌ1ÍBYKL"=AXϵΠA[Ì1ÍBÇBZ@<KUBÕ¦ÍVL"CÉÏSA�C@Ì-T�Ó³<>YK<KZ]ËÌ`L�T�=@ÇBCIL"=´Ç³=I<KUBÕ�o�DBß0TXCIL<KU©âc"[ìhäÉFëéL®?�TNJ[L®<KÌ1ÍBYKL"Ì`L"UOZIL�M)T2ÏSC@A�UOZ]È]L"U�M Í�T�Î@Ù�TXÕ�L�ZIA©DBÐ(ÖL`:ß.oÜÎ"TXYKY>LNM?>DBдÖ?`Eß.oâ=% %häIÒ´Ñ´?³<­Î@? Í�LhCIÌ1<KZ@=,TXU�T�YKËO=I<K=�A�Ï1T Î Y�TX=I=)AXÏ9UBA[UOÈIW)T�C@Ù�A�JO<�T�U C@L"Ñ4TXC�M Ì`A�M�L"YK=çQÑ´?BL"CIL)T ÏSZIL"C®T)Î@?�TXUBÕ�L®AXÏE=IZ�TXZIL`<>UéZ@?BL1C@L"YK<�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]Ë)Ì1ABMOL"Y]ÒVZI?³L1=IËO=@ZIL"Ì ÎhT�UBUBA[ZÙ[L"L"Í!ZIC�T[Î@Ù-AXÏ�ZI?³LÍ�T�=@ZT�U�M)TXUOË1Z�TX=IÙ)ÓVL"<KUBÕ`L ØBL�Î ÇBZ@L�M!A�U�ZI?³L¦=@Ëf=@ZIL"Ì Ì®ÇB=IZ´ÓVLC@L"=IZ T�CIZ@L�M��®ZI?BL�ÍBC@L"L"Ì`ÍBZI<KJ�L:CIL"ÍVL�TXZ§MO<±í#L"CIL"UOZ´ÍVA�YK<�Î ËBè"F[H´?BL�UBA�U�ÈÉW)TXCIÙ[A�Jf<�TXU�çSCILªÈÑ´T�C MBè�Ì1ABMOL"Y³<>=EΪA�UOJ�L"C@ZIL�M`Z@A1T¦W)TXCIÙ[A�J1çQCIL"Ñ´T�C MBè´Ì`A�M�L"YBÇB=@<>U³Õ®ÍB?�T�=@LT�ÍBÍBC@ANØB<lÈÌ�T�ZI<KA[UB=�Ñ´?³<­Î@?<K=uZI?BL"U�=IA[YKJ�L�M�ÓOËDBÐ(ÖL`Eß o´FNÖEYKY�Z@?BL�A[ZI?BLhC�ÏQL�T�Z@ÇBCIL"=8AXϳD³Ð´ÖL`:ß.o

Page 16: Reliability and Performability Techniques and Tools: A Survey ...

TXCIL:=IÇBÍBÍVA�C@ZIL�M�TXU�M®ÍVL"C]ÏQA�CIÌ�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]ËT�U�TXY>ËO=@<>=�T�=�=@ÇBÍBÍVA�CIZ@L�M`ÓOË1DBдÖ?`Eß.o Î"T�U`Ó�LÎhT�CIC@<KL�M�A�dzZ�F

��� ��P�_����� �0�= �]HXJR�� �<^U _� �!�3U��AXÏ�Z@?BLEU³A�UOÈIW)T�C@Ù�A�JO<�T�U�Ì1ABMOL"Y]F�`´LNÎ L"UOZIYKË®ZI?³L"CIL:?�TNJ�LÓVL"L"Uê=I<KÕ�UB<±à�ÎhT�UOZ�U³L"ÑÜMOL"J[L"YKA�ÍBÌ`L"UOZI=�<>U`ZI?B<K=ETXCIL�T³FBÖ qªÌ1A�U³LEW)T�C@=�T�U)TXU�M�B�?B<KA�Y�TâKå@ä�T�UVT�YKË�p"L�M�=@ZIABÎ@?�T�=@ZI<�ΦßuL"Z@CI<�U³L"ZI=�Ñ´<KZI?©M�L"ZIL"C@Ì1<KUB<K=IZ@<�ÎT�U�M,L ØBÍ�A[UBL"UOZI<�T�YKYKË)MO<K=]ÈZ@CI<KÓBÇBZ@L�M�àVCI<KUBÕZ@<>Ì`L"=8Ñ´?B<�Î@?1?�TNJ[LEÎ A�Ì`L�Z@AÓ�L:ÙOUBA�Ñ´U1T�=<@�DBß�A´=:çÊM�L"ZIL"C@Ì1<KUB<K=IZ@<�ÎTXU�M`=IZ@A�Î@?�TX=IZ@<­Î�ß�LhZICI<8UBLhZI=�èhF46G<>UVMOL"Ì-TXUBU©â=%[æhäj?�TX=EMOL"=I<KÕ[UBL�M)T�=IAXÏSZ]Ñ4TXCILÍVT�Î@Ù�T�Õ[LÎhT�YKYKL�M @�DBß�A(L ØBÍBCIL"=@=¦Z@?�T�ZTXY>YKA�Ñ´=´=@ZIL�T[MOË[ÈÊ=@Z�T�Z@L1T�U�TXYKËf=@<K=EA�Ï<@§D³ß�A´=�ÇBU�M�L"CÎ L"C]ÈZ T�<KU�CIL"=@ZICI<�Î Z@<KJ�L§ÎªA�U�MO<KZ@<>A[UB=�F�B�?BA[<BL"Z�TXY�âKå^#hä�?VTNJ�L�ÍBCIA[Í�A[=IL�M®T�Ì`A�C@L�Õ�L"U³L"C�TXY�Î Y�TX=I=AXÏ�ZI<KÌ`L�MßuL"ZIC@<BUBL"Z@=�ÙOUBA�Ñ´U¦TX=µWêT�CIÙ[A�J�CIL"Õ[L"UBL"C T�ZI<KJ[L´=IZIABÎ@?�TX=IZI<�δßuL"Z@CI<BUBLhZI=´ç]WM`�ÈD³ß�A´= è"FVH´?BL"=@L9TXCILT�U�TXYKË phL�M�ÓOË-W)TXCIÙ[A�J1CILhÕ�L"UBLhC�T�Z@<KJ�LÍBC@ABÎ L"=I=@L"=ÇBUVMOL"CÎ L"C@Z�T�<KUC@L"=IZ@CI<�Î Z@<>J[L9ΪA�U�MO<KZ@<>A[UB=�F#á|A�Z@?)ZI?BL�ZIC T�UB=@<KL"UOZ¥TXU�M�=@ZIL�T[MOË[ÈÊ=@Z�T�Z@L®=IA[Y>dzZI<KA�UB=EÎhT�U!Ó�LA[ÓBZ�TX<KUBL�M�UOÇBÌ`L"CI<�Î"TXY>YKËOFOÖEYKZI?³A�ÇBÕ[?)UBA�U³L¦AXϵZ@?BL"=@L®=IZIÇVMO<KL"=¦MO<K=�ΪÇB=I=C@L"Ñ´T�C�MêÓ�TX=IL�MÌ`L�T�=@ÇBCILh=�Ò�CIL"Ñ´T�C M0C�TXZIL"=�Ì�TNËéÓ�LéT�=@=IABÎ <�T�Z@L�M0Ñ´<KZI? Ì�T�C@Ùf<KUBÕ[=¦AXÏZI?BL!UBL"Z�T�U�MC@L"Ñ´T�C�MfÈÊÓ�TX=IL�MêÍVL"C]ÏSA[CIÌ�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]˦Ì`L�T�=@ÇBCIL"=�Î"T�UêÓ�L¦ÎªA�Ì1ͳÇBZIL�MGF�ß8C@L"=IL"UOZ@Y>ËOÒBZ@?BL"C@L¦<K=U³A§=@A�ÏSZ]Ñ´T�C@L�ÍVT�Î@Ù�T�Õ[L�ZI?�TXZ�=IdzÍBÍ�A[CIZ@=�Í�LhC]ÏSA[CIÌ-TXÓB<KYK<>Z]Ë´A[C8CIL"YK<�T�ÓB<KYK<KZ]˧TXU�T�YKËO=I<K=8ÇB=I<KUBÕZ@?BL"=@L¦Î Y�T�=@=IL"=:A�Ï�ZI<KÌ1LNM®ß�LhZICI<8UBLhZI=�F

�����J��Àu��¾EÄ���z�d´²`df���]�§eNq�a@�ʲ®phn]�Iphq,phq���ð:df�8�Xole"k>pXd9¹�q · a c]nQo�q�a c]�E°µolc]�1��a c]a n]�:olq�ol�]cQolm1phq���a v�bOe"�q�a q�cQo>p k�kl�`��ol�]c]nQol�[{�c]a �®¯OnQolq�rcQol��a � d��Qq���� ��������������������� �!��"$#%�����&�$'&���&�(�� sN��ehkl{���ay�óNó�sObfphrNa��:z"��y*)fz ñ�+�d��Xb�nQolq�rNa nQ�Sº�a nQk>phr�suzªwN�N��dy�d´²`df���]�§eNq�a@�ʲ®phn]�IphqBs�ð:df�8eNq�c]a�s8p"q[��ð:dft8p kl�Oe[d��Üm@k>ph�]�¦ehg(ð�a q[a�nIpªk�o-, a �%��c]e�m@�fph�Q�cQolm · a�c]nQo���a c]�(g­eNnEc]�[abOa nQg­eNn]�p"q[m aa ��p kl{Op"cQoleNqéehgµ�:{�klcQolb[n]e�m�a �]�]eNn¦�]���]c]a ��� d/.0�213 ��4��5�64�&�������5�7��� �!��"$#%�����&�7'8 �6��� "9�Is�y;:Sy=<?>�w��*)OzªyNy�sVz"w��hñ�d��d��´d��|klcQole�}Odé¸�{�a {�olq[r-��e��[aIk�olq[r©ehg4p2�Qolq�rhkla1b�n]e�m a �]�]eNn°8olc]��gSpªo�kl{�n]a � dA@$�&�-B�����"C4��(��D�E 4GF-�54���������s�w�>�w��*)OzªxNy�sVz"w��Nw�dñ�d´�´d������p"n s��Od�²`d ¤ d2�S�Qk>ph��s�p"q[�©�Odf_|a q�r[d · a�nQg�eNn]�p"�Xo�k�olcS�©phqfpªkl���Qol��e"g�bfphnIpªk�klaIk´p"q[���ol�]c]nQol��{[c]a �-pªklr�eNnQolc]����� d$�Sq�@$�H� &I%�JBLK���M�N��(��F-ILOP����QG�SR(�?#����T@$�&�����U�9�&���74��(M9@�� �-B����JV"W4��(���1��&M���FX�@s"bfphr�a ��yNy�z?)�y�yN��d5�Êiui�i)�8eN��b�{[c]a�n��Xe�mIola cQ� · n]a �]� sf�No�kl�Na n���b[nQolq�r[s�²®_(s�"{�q�a�zªwN�Nw�d

+�d´¶ud�t8phm�m a@k�k�oµphq�� Y:d ��df�#nQol�Na ��o�dE��qfpªkl���Qol�Eehgµphq1²�Z�ð9ZNy��]cIp"q[�����®n]a ��{[q��fphq�cE�]���]c]a ��d�Sq��:d���rNnIp °�pªk>pEphq���OdXY:d��#nQolbfphc]��o�s[a��Xolc]e�n]� sU@ D\[L]�^�[ 1T.9�0� D`_ a K�s"bfphr�a ��ñ�+N��)�ñ �NóXd��eNn]c]���Ê�|ehk�k>p"q[�Bs�z"wN���Xdó�d´¶ud�t8ph�]}�a c]c s�Y:d�²`dG�µ�fphq����Ns ¤ d ¤ dj²�{�q�cJ,Ns�p"q[��¶ud�ð:d · pªk>phmIoleN� d%¹�bOa qBs�m@kleN�]a �Bs�p"q[��Eolv�a � q�a cS°8eNn]}��¦ehgE¨�{�a {[a��®°µolc]�é��o�¬Ba n]a�q�c®m@k>ph�]�]a �®e"gEm {��]c]eN��a n]� d�b������?�(4GFc�JB��dR(�.0�21¦sBy�y;:SyG<?> yhñ �*)XyNóNx�s#z"w��G+Xd��d´²`d�tua"p"{[��n]�Nd · a�nQg�eNn]�p"q[m�a:n]a@k>p"c]a �®n]a@k�o>p"�Xo�k�o>cQ�®g�eNn�m e���b�{[c]a n��]���]c]a ��� d�N D\D�De3 ��4��5��V4�&�������5����� �!��"$#%�����&�J�@sX�j�Êy��;> +hñ�x�)�+"ñ��Xs��"{[q�az"wN���Xd��d´�´dftua@o�klq�a n s#��df²®pha c]a n sXphq��®�(d�«1a@ol�]�]a q��Oa�n]r[d8�#e"°�p"n]�[�µp(bOa�nQg�eNn]�p"q[m�a´��e��[aIk�olq[ra q���Noln]e�q[�§a q�c�>��|a °��8e"g��7�Q�´d!�Qq ¤ d · {�olr��Iphq�a n´p"q[�9_(d · eNcQola n sfa �Xolc]e�n]� s21f� M���F-���hg 3 ���R5V�i��j&�5���T4��(M 3 �&�GFX��B����/�!��"c#%�����&�C@$�&�-B�����"C4��(�� D�E 4GF-�54���������sBbOp"rNa �P+N��)��=+Xd · kla q�{��· n]a �]� s�z"wN��wXdw�d´�OdBt�a n]�]eNqBs�i8d[��aE��eN{�,"p�a� o�kl��p�s�phq�� ¤ d ¤ dG²�{[q�cJ,Nd¦� ��a c]��e���ehkleNr���g�eNn´c]��a�]bOa m@o��¯fm"p"cQoleNqép"q[�©rNa q�a nIp"cQoleNq!e"g��phn]}�eh�-��e��[aIkl� dk�Qq�«�d±��d���c]a °�p"n]c s#a ��olc]eNn s7�9��"W� �����4GF'l�GF-�5�������T�JB�1�4��HQ�� E �lR(4����5�Is�bOp"rNa �EzNz�)��Nó�d�²®phn]m aIk�_|a�}�}Na n s�z"wNw�zNd

Page 17: Reliability and Performability Techniques and Tools: A Survey ...

zªxXd´�EdOt�eN���Xole�d · a c]nQo q�a c]�Ôr�a q[a�nIphcQolq�r ²®p"n]}Ne"� n]a�°�phn]� ��e���a@kl� g�e�n bOa nQg­eNnQ��p"q[m�a&Zhn]a@k�o>p"�Xo�klolcQ�-phqfpªkl���Qol�´e"g��[a�rNnIph�fph��kla��]���]c]a �§� d��Sq ¤ d · {�olr��Iphq�a n´p"q[�1_´d · eNcQola n sa ��olc]eNn]� s71f� M���F-���hg 3 ���R(�(��j&�5���W4��(M 3 �&�GFX��B���� �!��"$#%�����&�C@��&�dB6���?"W4��(�� D�E 4GF-�54���������d· kla q�{�� · n]a �]� sVzªwN��wXd

z�zNd´�EdOt�eN���Xole4phq����#d ¤ e��Oa n]cQo�dj_µol�]c]nQol��{[cQole�q�e"g�c]�[a8�EolqXol�p kOm�eN��b�kla cQoleNq§cQol��a8ehgfbfphnIpªk�klaIkcIp"�]}��Golq¦�:{�klcQo��Sn]a °�phn]��]a �Eo��Q�¥phn]}Ne"���e���a@kl� d7@$�&�-B�����"C4��(�� D�E 4GF-�54���������shz�ñ5> yN��w*)�y=+Nó�szªwNwNy�d

zªyXd´�EdOt�eN���Xole©phq�� Y:d��#nQol��a �Xo�d �µe���b�{[cIp"cQoleNqéehg4c]�[a¦�Xol�]c]nQol��{�cQoleNq0e"g´c]��a�m e���bXkla�cQoleNqcQol��a¦°��[a q)c]��a°8eNn]}�n]a�¨�{Xoln]a �§a q�c�ol�p · � nIphq���eN�Ô��phnQo>p"�XklaNdA'���&�R(4G�����-C1��&M���FX�@só�>±zª�N�*)fz ñ wXsVzªwNw�xXd

zª�Xd´�EdOt�eN���XoleEp"q[� Y:d��#nQol�Na ��o�dj�µe���b�{[cQolq�r´m {��:{�k>phcQol��a���a"p"�]{[n]a��#ehgf�]cQo�¬®²®p"n]}Ne"�´mI�Op olq[�{��Qolq[r§phr�rNn]a r phcQole�q³dcN D�D\D 3 ��4�����4�&�������5�\��� � ��"c#%����� �J�Is���w;:]z"x=<?>±zªyNw�z?)OzªyNw��Xsf¹�m c]eN�fa nzªwNwNx�d

z�ñ[d´�EdOt�eN���Xole¦phq��/Y:d ��df�#nQol�Na ��o�d8��q®phr�rNn]a r phcQole�q`c]a mI��qXol¨�{�a:g�e�n|c]��a´c]nIphq��Qola q�cEp"qOp kl���Qol�e"g#�]cQo�¬-²®phn]}�e"��mI�Op olq[� dcN D�D\D`3 ��4��5�64�&��� ���5�7��� � ��"c#%����� �J�Is��u�]�=+;:Sw=<?>���xN�*)X�Xz�ñ[sB��a b�czªwN�Nó�d

z*+Xd���d �:df��phn]nIp"�]m e¦phq�����dO¶³olr�{[a�nIph� dE²®i#��¶X����>f_|a �Qolr�q�p"q[�®ol��b�kla ��a q�cIp"cQoleNq)ehgjp��]ehg­cQ�°�p"n]a:c]e�e"kug­eNn��§e��[a@k�olq�r)p"q[�1a ��pªkl{fphcQole�qêe"g�m e���bXkla�v2gSp"{XklcQ�Sc]e"kla nIphq�c�m�eN��b�{[cQolq�r®�]���Q�c]a �§� d9�Qqk@$�H�& I\�JB9N D\D�D ��� �-R ] 4��;F-��V 3 �GF-�&��4��(�7�!��"$#%�5�����hg '8="c#i�G�6����"(s�bfphrNa��:ñ yhñ )ñ yNwXs��"{Xkl�1z"w��NóXd

zªóXd��EdO��p"�]cQo�k�kle1phq���_´d · d��Nola °8oleNn]a }Od§� bOa nQg�e�n]�phq�m a�n]a@k�o>p"�Xo�k�o>cQ�-��e��[aIk#g�eNn´m e���b�{[cQolq�r�]���]c]a �§� d0�Qqk@����&?����M�����gG���JB0�-R(� ��� �-R�N��(��� ���(4���������4GF('8="c#i�G�6���5" ��� ] 4���F-��V 3 �GF-�&�H4��(��!��"$#%����� ��gNsNbfphr�a �:zª�N�*)fz"w�yXs#�"{�q[a�zªwN�Nx�d

zª�Xd ¤ df�8�Op"}�}Np¦phq�� �Idf²�olc]nIphq�o�d:� q�{���a nQolm"p k��]ehkl{�cQoleNq-��a c]��e��2g�e�n��E{XklcQolb�n]e�m a �]�]e�n��]���Q�c]a �§�8°8olc]��rNa�q[a nIp k��[n]a"p"}��[e"°�q��´phq���n]a�bOp oln]� d$�Qq ¤ d · e�e"kla �¦phq��`��df�µo�k�kl�]c]e�q³s�a ��olc]eNn]� s�!��"$#%�����&�7@$�&�-B����?"W4��(�� D�E 4GF-�54��������[s�bfphrNa��´yN��w*)XyNwNw�dB��a b�c]a �:�fa n:zªwNwNy�d

zª�Xd · df�8�Xol��a�q�c]e[d/'8 �6��� " #i�&�dB�����"W4��(?� ��� 4WB�4��dF-������Vd#%�H���(�C�&� E ���H���("W� �i�­d · �f_ c]��a �Qol� s_�a bOp"n]c]��a q�c�ehg��8e���b[{�c]a n4�Xm@ola�q[m a�s�_|{�}Na§~|q�ol�Na n]�QolcS�Ns�_|{�n]�Op"��s�����sBz"w��N��d

zªwXdE�´dO�8��eho�s"ºEdOð:d=Y�{�kl}�phn]q�o�s�phq�� Y:dO�Od"�#nQol�Na��Xo�dj²®phn]}�e"� ¤ a�rNa q�a nIphcQol��a��Xc]e�mI�Op"�]cQolm · a c]nQo��a c]� d �Sq ��� �-R�N ] N?@ OPI��7IGIdKfN��(� _ F!'8="CI���� � ��"c#%����� �9@�� �-B�����"C4��i?�01��&M���F�F-���hg��1f�?4G�6�5�H�&"C�&�(�\4��(M D�E 4GF-��4��������� �@�� �-B�����"C4��i?� _ � K��"s ¤ e���aNs%�QcIp kl�Ns#��a bBduzªwNw��Xs#�#e¦phb��bOaªphn d

y�xXdE�´dO�8��ehoGphq�� Y:df�OdO�#nQol�Na��Xo�d´��b[b�n]e"vNol�phc]a§bOa nQg�e�n]�phq�m a���e���a@kl�´e"g�bOehk�k�olq�r`�]���]c]a����{��Qolq[r�]c]e�mI�Op"�]cQolm · a c]nQo#q�a c]� d$�Sq @����&&I!�JB7N D�D\D N���B��&���" ��� s�bfphr�a �´y��Nx�ó*)�y��Xz�ñ[s�¶³kleh�n]a q�m a9�ScIpªkl�Ns�²®pª�1z"w�wNyXd

y�zNdEð:df�uo>phn]��e[s��EdftGk>ph}�a ��eNn]a�s · df¶ud �µ��ol��a q�c]e�sO��diY:d�²�{�b�bOp k>pXsfphq��TY:df��d��#nQol�Na��Xo�dj��{��c]e��phc]a �®r�a q�a nIphcQole�q)phq���p"qOp kl���Qol��ehgj²®p"n]}Ne"�®n]a °�p"n]�`�§e��[a@kl�´{��Qolq�r1�Xc]e�mI�Op"�]cQolm ¤ a@�°�p"n]�)�|a�c]� d��Qq)��df²�a ��a nphq�� ¤ d³��d · kla ����e�q[� sja �Xolc]e�n]� s7�!���(��4���.�F g����&��4��$1f4���Q�� E�R(4�� �5����4��(M��$���&�5�&���hg 1��&M���FX���$N?1 .��i�GF-��"C���T���k1�4��-R(�&"C4�������T4��iM ����� .c#�#F-� ?4GV�������5�Is��Nehkl{���aEñ���dB��b[nQolq�rNa nQ�Sº�a nQk>phr�s#��a@ol��a@kl�Oa n]r�s#ð�a n]�¥phq��Ns�z"wNw�yXd

y�yXdEð:df�uo>phn]��e[s ¤ df²®p"nQolaNst|df��a nQolm e"k>pXs¦phq��eY:df��dE�#nQol�Na��Xo�d · a nQg�e�n]�ph��o�k�olcQ�Üp"qOp kl���Qol�{��Qolq[r%�]a �:o��ʲ®phn]}�eh�%n]a °�phn]� b�n]e�m a �]�]a � d N D�D\D 3 ��4��5�64�&��� ���5�/��� �!��"$#%�5���&�J�@s4�u���w;:]z"x=<?>±zªyG+�z?)OzªyNó"ñ[s�¹�m c d�z"wNw�xXd

y��XdEð:df�uo>phn]��e[sO��d Y:d�²�{�b[bfpªk>p�sOp"q[� Y:d��OdN�#nQol��a ��o�d8� · � · >���c]e�m@�fph�]cQolm · a�c]nQoB��a c · p"m@}�p"rNaNd�Sq @����&&I2N��(��F-I�OP���HQh�SR(�?# ��� @$�&����� ��� ����4��(M0@$�&�-B����?"W4��(�� 1f�&M��*FX�Is�bOp"rNa ��z�ñ�y�)Oz&+�xXd�Êiui�i!�8eN�§b[{�c]a n��Xe�mIola cQ� · n]a �]� slY��Ne�c]e[sV��p"bOp"q³s�_�a mNd�z"wN��wXd

y"ñ[dEð:df�uo>phn]��ephq��PY:d��Od��#nQol�Na ��o�d�� ��a m e���bOe��QolcQoleNq-phb�b[n]e phmI��g�e�n8�]c]e�m@�fph�]cQolm´n]a�°�phn]�q�a c��e���a@kl� d 3 � 4?#�#i��4��7��� @$�&�-B�����"C4��(�� D�E 4GF-��4��������[d

y=+XdEt|df�uolm@o>p"qXo�phq��º:dfð�nIph�]�Qo�d · a nQg�e�n]�ph��o�k�olcQ�¦a ��pªkl{fphcQoleNq®e"gBgSph{�klcQ�Sc]ehkla nIp"q�c|�Ip"c]a@k�k�olc]a´�]���Q�c]a �§� d$N D\D\D`3 �H4��5�64� ���������7��� �!��"W"C���(���4��������5�Is��=+;:�ñ�<?> ñ�x��*) ñ�xNw�s#z"w��N�Xd

Page 18: Reliability and Performability Techniques and Tools: A Survey ...

yNó�d:��d �:d��8e�{[�No�k�k�ole�qVs ¤ d�¶[n]a@oln]aNs ¤ dB�"eN��q[�]e�q³s�«�d�_´d�¹��fpªki�J�@s�²`d �:d�¸�{�n]a �]��o�s�²`d ¤ pªo�s�«�d��´d��phq���a n]� s#p"q[�)��d iµdf�#nQol�Na ��o�d · a nQg�eNn]�¥ph��o�k�olcQ����e���a@k�olq�r®°8olc]��~8klc]nIpN���´�(d�N D\D�D ���JB6� V�4��H� sB�;> óNw�)���xXsB��a b�c dVzªwNwXz�d

yN��d��Edf�µ{��p"qXo�d�iu� · )�� bfphmI}�phr�a�g�eNn�c]��a�a��Np kl{Op"cQoleNqée"g´�]c]e�mI�Op"�]cQolm · a c]nQo�q�a c]��°8olc]�b��fph�]a@�ScQ��bfa���ol�]c]nQol�[{�c]a �)c]nIphq��QolcQoleNq)cQol��a � dT�Sq @����&&I$�JB9N��i���&���(4���������4GF$OP����QG�SR(�?#k���3 ��"C��M @��&���?�2��� ���Is�bfphrNa��:z ñ�ñ )fz&+Xz�sB�#eNnQolq�e[si�QcIpªkl��sV�"{�kl�`z"w��G+�d

yN��d´i8dO��aE��eN{�,"p:a´�No�kl��pphq��®�(d ¤ dfð´pªo�k�dµ�|p klm {�k>phcQolq�r�m {��:{�k>phcQol��a:e�bOa nIp"cQoleNqfpªk�cQol��a��Xol�Q�c]nQol��{�cQoleNq��®ehg´n]a�bOp olnIph��kla�m eN�§b[{�c]a n�]���]c]a ��� d N D�D\D 3 ��4��5�64�&�������5� ��� �!��"$#%�5���&�J�@s�u�Ê�G+�:�ñ�<?> �Ny�y*)����Ny�sB��b�n dVz"w��Nó�d

yNw�d´i8dO��aE��eN{�,"p:a-� o�kl��péphq����(d ¤ d�ð´pªo�k�d �|p klm {�k>phcQolq�r�pª��p o�k>ph��o�k±o>cQ� p"q[�ébfa nQg�eNn]�¥ph��o�k��olcS� �§a"ph�]{�n]a �®ehg¥n]a bOp olnIph��kla!m e���b�{[c]a n1�]���]c]a ���®{��Qolq�rénIphq��[e��:o-,"phcQole�q³d b�I.0�21�Ils��ó;:]z*<?>±zª�Xz?)fz"w��Xs#��phqBdVzªwN��wXd

�Nx�d´i8dO��aE��eN{�,"p:a´�No�kl��p�phq��¦�(d ¤ d�ð´pªo�k�d · a nQg�e�n]�ph��o�k�olcQ�9phqfpªkl���Qol��e"g#m e���b�{[c]a nj�]���]c]a ����>g­n]eN� ��e���a@k#�]bfa m@o�¯fm"phcQole�q`c]e��]e"kl{[cQole�q³d9@��&�dB6���?"W4��(�� D�E 4GF-��4��������[s�z�ñ5>lz&+N��)OzªwNóXs#zªwNw�yXd

�Xz�d´�´df_|a"²�a a�n d �#nIphq��Qola q�c]a kla@ol�]c]{�q[r��]�Oa °8a�n]c]{[qOr {[q�� eNb�cQol�:ola n]{�q�r n]a }�eNq�¯Or�{Xola�nQ��fphn]a�n:g�a ��kla n]c]ehkla�nIphq�c]a nn]a mI�[a�q[�]���]c]a �§aNd . ����� � � � ��� �����R(���CM�����N?1 1��9M��&���!�(� E �&�J�������4��D �JF-4���g�� ��V���������&" �?�&� g s�y=+;:]zªxG<@sB¹�m�c]eN�Oa nEz"w�wNyXd

�Ny�d´�´d�²`d�ºjphq-_µo �]}Od§�Nol��b�kla��Oe�{[q��[�´g�e�n�¨�{�a {[aIolq[r1�]���]c]a ���´°8olc]�1�[n]a"p"}��[e"°�q�� d @�� �-B����JV"W4��(�� D�E 4GF-�54���������s��;:SyG<?>lzNzª�*)fz"yN��s#z"w��N�Xd

�N��d´�#dB_�eNqfphcQola@k�kle©phq���ºEdOð�nIp"�]�Qo�d-¹�q�a ��pªkl{fphcQolq�r)c]�[am {��:{�k>phcQol��a®bOa nQg�e�n]�phq�m a¦�Xol�]c]nQo����{�cQoleNqéehg´gòph{�klcQ�Qc]e"kla nIphq�c¦m eN�§b[{�c]a n�]���]c]a ��� d N D�D\D 3 ��4��5�64�&�������5� ��� �!��"$#%�5���&�J�@sñ x;:]z�z&<?>lz"�Nx�z?)fz"�Nx��Xs�z"w�wXzNd

�hñ�d´�#dB_�eNqfphcQola@k�kle�p"q[��t|d ¤ d7�Q��a n d0��qOp kl���Qol�®ehg§p�m e���bOeN�Qolc]a-bOa nQg�e�n]�phq�m a1n]a@k�o>ph��o�k±olcS��§a"ph�]{�n]a2g­eNn�gSph{�klcQ�Sc]ehkla nIp"q�c��]���]c]a �§� d b��������(4GFB����P�dR(�T.9�?�6�&&��4�������� �JB � ��"c#%��������g1f4��R(���(�&�?8"s��hñ�:]z&<?>lz"��w*)OzªwNw�s#��phq�{fphn]�`zªwN���Xd

�G+�d´t�d �´df_|e��]�Xo�d�¸�{�a {�olq[r�]���]c]a ����°8olc]����phm"p"cQoleNq�� d �$���&�5���hgC'8 �6��� "9�IsOzG> yNw�)�óNó�sVzªwN�Nó�d�Nó�d´t�d �´dj_|e��]�Xo�d ð�a q[a�nIpªk�o-,"p"cQoleNq��`e"gEc]�[a®�]c]e�mI�Op"�]cQolm`��a m e���bOe��QolcQoleNq0n]a �]{�klc]��g­eNn��Qolq�rhkla�]a�n]�Na n�¨�{[a {�a ��°µolc]�¦��phm"p"cQoleNq�� d9'��� �R(4G�6����$1��&M���FX�@s�ó�:SyG<?> �Nx��*)����N��s#z"wNw�xXd

�N��d��Edf_|{��Op�d:����a�a@¬Ba�m c]�´ehgjm@��a mI}�bOeholq�cQolq�r1eNq1b[n]e�rNnIph� a v�a m {�cQoleNq�cQol�§aNd N���B�����"C4��������@����&����?�6����gC��&�����&� �IsOz"ó�>�y�yXz�)�yNy�wXs#zªwN�N��d

�N��d´_´dBð:df¶[{�n]m@��c]r�eNc]c�phq��`��df¶udf²�a ��a n d�� bOa�nQg�eNn]�p"�Xo�k�olcS�®�]ehkl{�cQoleNq1��a c]��e���g�e�n8��a rNnIp"�X�p"�XklaEq�eNq�n]a bOp olnIph��kla��]���]c]a ��� d�N D\D�D 3 �H4��5��4�&�������5����� � ��"c#%����� �J�Is��u�]���;:Só=<?>X+=+Nx*);+G+"ñ[s�"{�q�a�zªwN�hñ�d

�Nw�d´_´d · d�ð´p �Na n d��°�pªolcQolq�r2k�olq�a�°8olc]�`olq�c]a�n]n]{[b�c]a �)�]a n]�Nolm aNs�olq[m@kl{���olq[r)b�nQoleNnQolcQola � dkb�I [ I'l��4����d�6��IU'�&&I±s�tjyhñ5> �N��)�w�xXs#z"w�óNy�d

ñ�x�d ¤ d�ð�a@ol�]c s�²`dY:d��X��e�c]�[a�n]�phqBs!Y:df�OdO�#nQol��a �Xo�s�phq��)��dOt�d�_|{�r�phqBd´����a:n]a@k�o>p"�Xo�k�olcS��ehgk�o�g­a@�Sm nQolcQolm"pªkj�]���]c]a ��� dc.�&��49N���B�����"C4������4Ns yN�;> óNy�z?)Xóhñ�y�s#z"w��NóXd

ñ[z�d ¤ d�ð�aIol�]c�phq��PY:d��Od���nQol�Na ��o�d ¤ a@k�o>p"�Xo�k�o>cQ�¦a �]cQol�p"cQoleNq�e"gBgSph{�klcQ�Sc]ehkla nIp"q�c|�]���]c]a�����>��#e�e"kl�p"q[�®c]a�m@��qXol¨�{�a � d�N D\D�D �!��"$#%�5���&�Ésfy��;> +Ny*)XóXz�s#�"{Xkl�®z"w�wNx�d

ñ�y�d´i8dBð�aIkla q��OaNs�_´dO¶³olq�}NaIk�s#p"q[�1�OdXY:d��#nQolbfphc]��o�d�����pªo�k>p"�Xo�klolcQ�-ehg�p���ol�]c]nQol�[{�c]a �1m eN�§b[{�c]a n�]���]c]a��×°8olc]��gòpªo�kl{�n]a � d�.�&��49N���B�����"C4������4Ns yN�;> óhñ �*)XóG+G+�s#z"w��NóXd

ñ���d��Edfð�eh� pªk�s�«�d���d���phn]c]a�n s8i8d��[aE��eN{�,"p�a®�No�kl��pXs��Od��Osj�Vp �Na�q��Oa n]r[sµphq�� Y:d ��d��#nQol��a �Xo�d����a�]���]c]a �Ôp ��pªo�k>p"�Xo�k�o>cQ�©a �]cQol�phc]e�n d��Qq @$�H� &I7�JB9N D\D�D ��� �-R ] 4���F-��V 3 �GF-�&�H4��(�L� ��" V#%��������gC'8="c#i�G�6����"(s�bfphr�a ���hñ&)��Nw�s#�"{Xkl�1z"w��NóXd

ñNñ�d��Edfð�eh� pªk�p"q[�-�:df�(dB��p"q�cIpª°8o�d¦i#��pªkl{fphcQoleNq©ehg�bfa nQg�eNn]�¥ph��o�k�olcQ��g�eNn´��a r�nIph�fph��kla�m e��:�b�{�c]a n��]���]c]a �§� d$N D\D\De3 ��4�����4�&�������5�7��� � ��"c#%����� �J�Is��Nó�:SóG<?> �N�N��)��"ñNñ[s#�"{�q�a�z"wN���Xd

ñ�+�d��Edfð�eh� pªk�phq���:d �(d���phq�cIp °8o�d��é��a"ph�]{�n]a�e"g#r�{Op"nIphq�c]a a �9p �Np o�k>ph��o�k�oKcS�1phq���olc]�8q�{[�§a nQ�olmªpªk�a ��pªkl{fphcQole�q³d�N D\D\De3 ��4�����4�&�������5�7��� � ��"c#%����� �J�Is��N��:]z&<?> yG+*)X�Ny�sVz"w��N��d

Page 19: Reliability and Performability Techniques and Tools: A Survey ...

ñ óXd´ºEdOð�nIp"�]�Qo�sf�Gdf_|e�qOp"cQola@k�kKe�s�phq��®ð:d��]p&, a e"k�k>pXd · a�nQg�eNn]�p"�Xo�k�olcS�®a ��pªkl{fphcQole�q®ehg#�E{�klcQolm eN�:�bOe�q[a�q�c�gSph{�klcQ�Sc]ehkla nIp"q�c´�]���]c]a ��� dWN D\D�De3 ��4��5�64�&�������5����� [ ��F-��4��&�dF-����8hs �N��:SyG<?> yXzªó*)�y�yNy�szªwN�N��d

ñ �XdEt|d ¤ df��p �Na n]}�eNn]c d�@$�&�-B����?"W4��&�dF-����8�1��&M���F-����g 3 �&�GFX��� D�E 4GF-�54�������� 3 �?�R(�(� j �������%4��(MW.$#V#F-���4��������5�]d · �O_0c]��a �Qol� s�~|q�ol�Na�n]�QolcQ��e"g���°8a q�c]aNsf�|a�c]�[a nQk>p"q[��� s�z"wNw�xXd

ñ �XdEt|d ¤ df��p �Na n]}�eNn]c�phq����@d ð:df�µola �§a rNa a�n]� d8���]{[n]��a ��e"g�bOa nQg�e�n]�ph��o�k�olcQ�®��e���a@k�olq�r®c]e�ehkl� d�\V�@�4G�?��#i���?�Ks �;>lz?)OzªyXs�¹�m c]e��Oa n´z"w��Nw�d

ñ wXdEt|d ¤ d���p ��a n]}Ne�n]c s(�@d ð:d��8ola ��a r�a a n]� sBp"q[� · d º:d���phq��Bphq�c]a qBd�_���¸´�|c]e�ehk)¥p(bfa nQg�eNn]�¥pª���o�k�olcQ�¦��e��[aIk�olq[r�c]e�e"k��Op"�]a �eNqc]�[a��[��qfph�Eolm´¨�{[a {�olq�r�¨�{�a {�a@olq�r�q[a�cQ°8e�n]}�m eNq�m a b�c d\�Qqð:dft8p kl�Oe1phq���ð:d��Xa�n]nIp ,@o�s�a ��olc]eNn]� s9�!��"$#%�����&��@��&�dB�����"W4��(?� D$E 4GF-��4���� ��� �21f� M���F�F-� ��g3 �?�R(�(��j&�����74��(M 3 � �GFX�Is�bOp"rNa �Ez"��z?)OzªwG+�dBiVkl�]a �Nola n s�z"wNw�yXd

+�xXdEt|d ¤ df��p �Na n]}�eNn]c�p"q[�/Y:d �Od��#nQol�Na ��o�d���bOa mIo�¯Om"p"cQoleNq)p"q[�¦rNa q�a nIp"cQoleNq®ehg��phn]}�e"��n]a�°�phn]���e���a@kl� dj�#e�p"b[bOaªphn d

+�zNd ¤ d��:d���eh°µphn]�Bd �98=�(4�"C� �@$�H���?4��&�dF-�-������!'8 �6���&" ��� �i�GF-IXNJN��G'�&"W�dV�1f4���Q�� E 4��iM �9�� �-�������@����&��*���6�*�Id#�"eN��q®«êo�kla��1�0�Xe�q[� s���a °���eNn]}OsVzªwN��zNd

+�yXdE²`df��d#���]{[a��³s ¤ dlY:d2�S�Na n s�p"q[� Y:dO�Od#�#nQol��a �Xo�d · a nQg­eNn]�p"�Xo�k�olcS�!��e���a@k�olq�r��Op"�]a �)eNqn]a"p k´�fphcIp�>�� m"ph�]a1�]c]{��[�Nd N D\D�D 3 ��4��5�64�&��� ���5�T��� �!��"$#%�5���&�J�@sj�u�Ê�N�;:�ñh<?> ñ �N��)�ñ��"ñ[s��b[nQo�kjz"wN���Xd

+��XdE¹:df��d2�S�OaNs ¤ dO��d��|e"°8aNs�phq�� Y:df��d��#nQol�Na ��o�d®��b[b�n]e"vNol�phc]a1p ��pªo�k>p"�Xo�k�o>cQ��phqfpªkl���Qol�ehgº#� ��m@kl{��]c]a n��]���]c]a �§� d N D�D\D 3 ��4��5�64�&��� ���5�W��� [ ��F-��4��&�dF-����8hs ¤ �Ê�N��:]z&<?>lz ñ�ó�)Oz*+NyXsj��b�n dzªwN�Nw�d

+"ñ[dEt|d ¤ d7�Q��a n s��Gdf_�eNqfphcQola@k�kle�s�p"q[� · df�|a@ol��a@kl�Oa n]r�a n d ��qOp kl���Qol�`e"g�bfa nQg�eNn]�¥ph��o�k�olcQ�0g�eNn�]c]e�mI�Op"�]cQolm���e���a@kl��e"g�gSph{�klcQ�Sc]ehkla nIp"q�c��]���]c]a���� d/N D\D�D 3 ��4��5�64�&�������5�W��� �!��"$#%�����&�J�@s�u�Ê�G+�:]z"xG<?> wNx�y*)XwNxN��sB¹�m c]e��Oa nEz"wN��óXd

+=+Xd´�Ed�²`d��"eN��q[�]e�q�p"q[�-²`d�²®pªkla }Od(�X{�n]�Na �1ehg��]e"g�cQ°µphn]aEc]e�ehkl��g�e�n�a ��pªkl{fphcQolq�r1n]a@k�o>ph��o�k�oKcS�Nsp ��pªo�k>p"�Xo�k�o>cQ�)p"q[�®�]a�n]�Nolm a"ph��o�k�o>cQ�NdW.0�21 �!��"$#%�5������g0'��� E �&8 �Is�y�x;:�ñ�<?> yNy��*)XyNóNw�s�_|a m�a �:��Oa�n(zªwN���Xd

+�óXdE�´d(Y´p"q�cJ,´p"q[�fY:d��Od��#nQol�Na��Xo�d ¤ aIk�o>ph��o�k±o>cQ�®��e���a@k�olq�rehg�²�� ¤ ���]���]c]a � >���m"p"�]a´�]c]{[���olq®c]��a:{��]aEehg���o�¬Ba n]a q�c´c]e�e"kl�Ephq��®c]a m@��q�ol¨�{[a � d��Qq/N��(���&�?�i4���� ���(4 F\OP����QG�SR(�?# ��� @��&���?���� ����4��(MC@��&�dB6���?"W4��(���1��&M���FX�@sf²�a@kl�Oe�{[n]q�aNsB��{[�]c]nIp k�o>pXs�z"wNw�zNd

+��Xd · dl��d�t|diY|olq�r¦phq����@df²�olc]nIphq�o�d´²�{�klcQol�]a n]��a n:�]���]c]a������]{����]a m c�c]e��[n]aªph}���eh°�q���>B��q®a �E�b�olnQolm"pªk��]c]{����Nd7N D\D�D 3 �H4��5��4�&�������5�c��� �!��"c#%�����&� �Is��u�Ê�Ny;:]zªxG<?> wNó�)�wN��s#z"w��N�Xd

+��Xd´ºEd(Y�{�kl}�phn]q�o�s�º:d ¶ud#�8olm ehk>p�s ¤ d�²`d����:olc]�Bs�phq��kY:d ��d��#nQol�Na��Xo�d-�|{���a nQolmªpªk�a ��p kl{Op"cQoleNqe"g�bOa nQg�e�n]�ph��o�k�olcQ�)��aªph�]{�n]a ��p"q[�P�]eN��m�eN��b�kla cQoleNq©cQol��a�olq�n]a bfpªolnIp"�Xkla�gSp"{XklcQ�Sc]e"kla nIphq�c�]���]c]a �§� d!�QqT@$�H�& I ��� �dR�N��(��F-I5'8="c#%I���� ] 4���F-� 3 �GF-�&��4��(�!�!��"$#%����� ��gNs@º�ola q�qOp�s���{��]c]nQo>pXs�"{�kl�®z"wN��óXd�Êiui�iµd

+�wXd´ºEdOð:d;Y�{Xkl}�phn]q�o�sOºEdf¶udO�8olm ehk>p�sfphq���Y:df��d �#nQol�Na ��o�d8����a�m e���bXkla�cQoleNq®cQol��a�ehg�pc�ÊeN�eNq�E{XklcQol�§e��[a��]���]c]a���� d�.�M E 4��(?���7� �T.c#�#F-����M @�������4��&�dF-����8hs�z"w�>�w��Ny�)�wG+"ñ[s#zªwN�N��d

ó�xXd´ºEdOð:d�Y�{�kl}�phn]q�o�s�º:df¶udj�µolm e"k>pXs�phq�� Y:df�Od��#nQol�Na ��o�d%i�¬Ba�m c]��e"g´mI�[a mI}�bOe"olq�cQolq[r�p"q[�¨�{�a {�a@olq[r¦eNq¦b[n]e�rNnIph�ÜbOa nQg­eNn]�p"q[m a�d�'���&�R(4G������$1��&M���FX�Is�ó;:�ñh<?>�ó�z&+*)Xóhñ �Xs#z"w�wNx�d

ó�zNd ¤ df�³a bfehkl�Bd · a q[bfa c�>O�0q�a °%phb�b[n]e phmI�`c]e§bOa nQg�e�n]�ph��o�k�olcQ�1��e���a@k�olq[r¦{[�Qolq�r��]c]e�mI�fph�]cQolmbOa�c]nQoEq[a c]� d �Qq�t|d ¤ d���p �Na n]}�eNn]c s7�Id�ð:dµ�µola ��a�rNa a n]� s4phq��%�(d ²`d8��phq%_µo �]}Os�a ��olc]eNn]� s@����&&I��JBW�-R(� ] ���J��� N��(��F-I OP���HQh�SR(�?# ��� @��&�dB6���?"W4��&�dF-����8C1��&M���F�F-���hg0�JB �!��"$#%�5���&�94��(M�!��"W"W�5�(� ?4��������0'8&�����&" �Is�bfphr�a �´��)Oz"��dVzªwNwNy�d

ó�yXdE��df��olq��[a��phq�q³s�²`df²®pªkl��eNc]nIpXs�phq��PY:d��OdN�#nQol��a ��o�d��|{���a nQolmªpªk���a c]��e��[��g�eNn8n]aIk�o>ph��o�k�olcQ�a ��p kl{Op"cQoleNq!e"g�m@kle��]a ��gSph{�klcQ�Sc]ehkla nIp"q�c��]���]c]a ��� d�#a mI��qXolm"p k ¤ a�bOeNn]c§_�~�Y´i��Ê����� ¤ �ÊwNy �x�z"�Xs��8a q�c]a n8g�eNnµ�µe���b�{[c]a n4�X���]c]a���� ¤ a �]a"p"n]m@�BsB_�{[}�a�~�qXol��a n]�QolcQ��s#z"wNw�yXd

ó��XdE�´dO�BeNbOa6,@�Êtua q�olc]a�,�phq�� Y:d��Od"�#nQol�Na ��o�dj²�{XklcQolb�n]e�m a �]�]e�n8bOa nQg­eNn]�p"�Xo�k�olcS�phqfpªkl���Qol� dcN D�D\D3 ��4��5�64�&��� ���5�7��� [ ��F-��4��&�dF-����8hs _|a�mNdVzªwNwN��d��#ephb�bOa"p"n d

Page 20: Reliability and Performability Techniques and Tools: A Survey ...

óhñ�d´²`d�²®pªkl��eNc]nIp�d�� m eN�§b[{�cIphcQole�qOp k�kK��a��m@ola q�cEc]a mI�[q�ol¨�{[a�g�e�n�c]nIp"q[�Qola q�c§phqfpªkl���Qol�§ehgjn]a@�bfpªolnIp"�Xkla,²®phn]}Ne"�No>p"q!�]���]c]a ��� d)�#e1p"b[bfa"phn�olq @��&�dB6���?"W4��(�� D�E F-4��54���������]{��;�Êa m c�c]en]a��Nol�QoleNqBsuzªwNwN��d

óG+�d´²`d�²®pªkl��eNc]nIp�s|��diY:d�²�{�b�bOp k>pXs�p"q[� Y:df�Od#�#nQol�Na ��o�d)��cQo�¬Bq�a �]�Q�Sc]ehkla nIp"q�c���a�c]�[e����:g�e�nc]nIp"q[�Qola�q�c´phqfpªkl���Qol��ehg��]cQo�¬-²®phn]}�e"��m@�fpªolq�� d8�#a�m@��qXolmªpªk ¤ a bfeNn]c�_�~�Y´iV�]����� ¤ �Êw�yª�ÊxNx��Xs�8a q�c]a�nµg­eNn��8eN��b�{[c]a�n������]c]a ��� ¤ a �]a"phn]mI�Bs�_|{�}Na§~|q�ol�Na n]�QolcS�Ns#z"w�wNyXd

óNó�d´²`d�²®pªkl��eNc]nIp®p"q[�1�:d �Gd ¤ aIol�[�p"q³d§��a@kla m cQolq�r-phq��2ol��b�kla ��a�q�cQolq[r1b[�fph�]a¥phb�b[n]e"vNol�p �cQole�q[��g�eNn��]a �Eo��]²®p"n]}Ne"�®��e���a@kl� d8�#e§phb�bOa"p"n|olq '���&�R(4G������71��&M���FX�@sfz"wNw��Xd

óN��d´²`d�²®pªkl��eNc]nIp¦phq��/Y:dO�OdO�#nQol��a ��o�d ¤ a@k�o>p"�Xo�kloKcS��p"qOp kl���Qol�:e"g�n]a ��{[q��Op"q�c�p"n]nIp ����ehg#olq�a vN�bfa q[�Qol��a���ol�]}�� d b��������(4GF!�JBC@�4���4GF F-�*F 4��(M ���d�6����� �&������M��!��"$#%�5������gNs�z"�;>lz ñ ó*)fz&+Xz�s8��phqBdzªwNw��Xd

óN��d´²`d�²®pªkl��eNc]nIp�s�Y:df�OdN�#nQol��a �Xo�s ��d �:d"«-phq�r[s phq���²`d�º�a a nIphnIp"rN�fp �Np"q³d ¤ a@k�o>p"�Xo�klolcQ���e����aIk�olq[rE°8olc]�:m e���b�{[c]a nQ�S�fph�]a �c]e�e"kl� d��Sq��´d �´dª��phr"kla�phq�� ¤ dB��mI�[q�a@ol��a n s�a ��olc]eNn]� s ���54GF-� ��84��iM [ ��F-��4��&�dF-����8������!��"$#%�����&�JV��74G�6��M�1���M���?4GF�@����&M���&� �Id"�#�´t�Z �]i�i�i · n]a��]� s³zªwNw��Xd��#ep"b[bfa"phn d

óNw�d´²`d�²®pªkl��eNc]nIp´p"q[� Y:d��Od"�#nQol�Na��Xo�dj�µolr��[a�nQ�Qe�n]�[a�nu��a�c]�[e����Vg�eNn#c]nIp"q[�Qola�q�c8p"qOp kl���Qol�8ehgf�]cQo�¬²®p"n]}Ne"��mI�fpªolq�� d7�Qq 3 R(���HM ���(���&���(4��������54GFi�����B��&���&�(��7��� @$�&�-B����?"W4��(��9�JB �9�d�6���?� � �����?M'l8 �6���&"9��4��(MWN��(����g���4�����M � ��"C"W�5�i��?4��������0��� �

����HQG�@s�Y���eNc]e�sV��phbfphqBsVzªwNw�zNd

�Nx�d´²`df���]�§eNq�a²®phn]�Ip"q³s�ð:dft8p kl�Oe[s��:dftueN����ole[sjð:df�µe�q�c]aNs�phq����:df�8{[�¥phq�o�d¦¹�q · a�c]nQoq�a c]�°8olc]�!�]c]e�mI�Op"�]cQolm�cQol�:olq�r[dA�Qq @����&��?��M�����gG�T�JBP�dR(�TN��i���&���(4��������(4&F9O ���HQG�JR(�?# ���3 ��"C��M @��&���?�2��� ���Is�bfphrNa��´�Nx�)����XsO�#e�nQolq[eT�ScIpªkl�Ns��"{Xkl�1z"wN�=+Xd

�Xz�d:��df²�a ��a n dܹ�qéa ��p kl{Op"cQolq[r�c]�[a1bOa nQg­eNn]�p"�Xo�k�olcS�Ýe"g���a r�nIph�fph��klaêm�eN��b�{[c]a�n®�]���]c]a ��� dN D\D\De3 ��4�����4�&�������5�7��� � ��"c#%����� �J�Is��u�]y�w;> �Ny�x*)����Xz�sO��{�r®z"w��NxXd

�Ny�d:��df¶ud�²�a ��a n d �jkle��]a ���òg­eNn]� �]e"kl{[cQole�q[�1ehg§bOa nQg�e�n]�ph��o�k�olcQ��d N D\D�D 3 ��4��5�64�&��� ���5�T���� ��"c#%����� �J�IsO�u�Ê�Xz=:S�G<?> óhñ �*)�ó=+N��sV�"{�kl�`z"w��Ny�d

�N��d:��d ¶ud�²�a��Na n d · a�nQg�eNn]�p"�Xo�k�olcS�(>Ep�n]a c]n]eN�]bfa m cQol�Na©p"q[���]eN��a1bOe"olq�c]a n]�`c]e)c]��a2g­{[c]{�n]aNd@��&�dB6���?"W4��(�� D$E 4GF-��4���� ���[s[z�ñ5>lz"��w*)Oz*+Nó�s#z"wNw�yXd

�hñ�d:��d ¶ud�²�a ��a n sN�Edf²�eh��p"rN�fphn s phq��:«�d��´d���phq��[a�n]� d��Xc]e�mI�fph�]cQolm´p"m cQol�NolcQ�Eq�a cQ°8e�n]}���>���c]n]{�m@�c]{�n]aNs��Oa �fp �NoleNn sµphq��!p"b[b�k�olm"p"cQole�q³d �Qq N��(���&�?�i4���� ���(4 F�O ���HQG�JR(�?# ���k@$�&�����c���&� � 4��(M@��&�dB6���?"W4��(���1��&M���FX�@s�bfphrNa��(zªxNó�)OzNz*+XsB�#e�nQolq[e�s�QcIpªkl��sV�"{�kl�`z"w��G+�d

�G+�d��Idf²�olc]nIphq�oEphq��©t|d����No��H�QcJ,��Op"}Od)� �phq��N�S�]a n]��a n¨�{[a {�a�°8olc]�)�]a n]�Nolm a�olq�c]a�n]n]{[b�cQoleNq�� d^ #i� �H4��������5� [ ���6�?4��H�R[sOz"ó�:S�G<?> óNyN��)�ó��N�Xs#zªwNó��Xd

�Nó�d´²`d�²�{Xk>p&,�,"p"qXojp"q[�/Y:df�OdO�#nQol�Na��Xo�dµ_|a bOa�q[�fph��o�k�oKcS�`b�n]a ��olm cQoleNqk>B�8e���bOp"nQol�]eNq®e"g�c]e�ehkl�p"q[�®c]a�m@��qXol¨�{�a � d7�Sq�N ] . � ';. ]!D � ^ 1P@ @����&&I±s��#e�{Xkle��]aNs�¶[nIphq�m aNs�z"w��NóXd

�N��d´t�dB²��{�k�kla nQ�Ê�jkle��]c]a n]�p"q[qBdE��~�²��´�OsBp:c]e�e"kVg�e�n�q�{[��a�nQolm"pªkµphqfpªkl���Qol�Eehg�m e���b�{[c]a n��]���Q�c]a���� d!�Qq¥_(d · e�cQola n s�a ��olc]eNn s1f� M���F-���hg 3 �?�R(�(� j �����\4��(M 3 �&�GFX�B�����@��&�dB6���?"W4��(���.9�(4GFXV8&���-�@s�bfphrNa��(z�ñ[z�)Oz&+"ñ[d���eNn]c]���]��ehk�k>p"q[�BsV�����]c]a n]�fph��s�z"w��G+Xd

�N��d´t�dB²��{�k�kla nQ�Ê�jkle��]c]a n]�p"q[qBd���q1phb�b[n]e"vNol�p"c]a�b�n]e���{[m c�g­eNn]� g�eNn4p¥mIk>ph�]�´ehgj��a rNnIp"�Op"�Xkla¨�{�a {�olq[r¦q[a�cQ°8e�n]}�� d�@�� �-B�����"C4��i?� D�E 4GF-�54��������[s"bfphr�a �:zªóG+�)Oz"��zNs#zªwN�N��d

�Nw�d´¶ud�²�{[q�}Na�n]c�phq��¦�(d��[aE²�a�a n d � · a q�a@kleNbfa:{��]a n�rN{�ol�[aNdj�#a mI�[q�olm"pªk�n]a bfeNn]c sB�"{[q�a:zªwNw��Xd�Nx�d:��d Y:dB²�{�b�bOp k>pXs#�Ed��OdB��phc]�fp �NaNs ¤ d���dB��e"°8aNsBp"q[� Y:d ��dB�#nQol��a �Xo�d(_|a bOa�q[�fph��o�k�oKcS����e����aIk�olq[r�ehg¦p)�[a�c]a n]eNr�a q[e�{[�-º#� ��mIkl{[�]c]a n®�]���]c]a�� {[�Qolq�r��]c]e�m@�fph�]cQolm)n]a °�p"n]� q�a c]� d��Qq_´dO���Na n]a �]}���s�a �Xolc]e�n s��94��HM

�4����/4��(M '�JB��

�4��H� ] 4���F-� 3 �GF-�&��4��(������ @�4���4GF�F-��F9� ��" V

#%��������gC'8&�����&"9�@d�iVk�k�ol�E�|e�n]°8e�e��®�Bc]�³dlsVzªwNw�yXd�Xz�d:��d Y:d�²�{�b[bfpªk>p¦phq���Y:d ��d �#nQol�Na ��o�d���{[��a�nQolm"pªk�c]nIphq��Qola q�c´p"qOp kl���Qol�´ehgV¯fq�olc]a´�phn]}�eh�No>p"q¨�{�a {�a@olq�r��]���]c]a ��� d\�Sq®~(d �(dXtu�Op"c�phq�� �@d º:dXt8ph�Ip °�p�sOa ��olc]eNn]� s �$��� ���&����gW4��(M [ �*F-4�����M1f�&M��*FX�Is�bOp"rNa ��y�óNy*)XyN�"ñ[d�¹�vNg�e�n]�®~|q�ol�Na�n]�QolcQ� · n]a �]� sVzªwNwNy�d

�Ny�d´²`d ¶ud��|a�{[c]�4phq��1_(d ²`d��³{�m"phq�c]e�qXo�d´��²®p"n]}Ne"�No>phq�¨�{�a {�a:°8olc]�-� �]a n]��a n]�´�]{[���]a�m c�c]e��n]a"p"}��[e"°�q[�Ep"q[�¦n]a bfpªoln]� d91�4��i4&g;�&"W�&�(�U'&���&�(�� s�y=+;:Sw=<?>��"ñ�w*)X�Nó�zNs#z"w��Nw�d

Page 21: Reliability and Performability Techniques and Tools: A Survey ...

���Xd´ºEdO¶udµ�µolm e"k>pXs��EdOt�eN���Xole�s´p"q[� Y:df��dj�#nQol�Na ��o�d � {[q�o�¯Oa��0bOa nQg�e�n]�phq�m a�n]aIk�o>ph��o�k�olcQ�p"qOp kl���Qol��e"g4p��]���]c]a �Þ°µolc]�©p�m {��E{Xk>p"cQol�Na®��eh°�q�cQol�§a�m e�q[�]c]nIp olq�c d 1f��&���&��F-�?&�������i����4��(M [ ��F-��4��&�dF-����8"s���y;> ñ�w*)XóG+�sVz"w�wNy�d

�"ñ[d´ºEdO¶ud��8olm ehk>p�s�ºEdfð:d�Y�{Xkl}�phn]q�o�s§phq�� Y:df�Od��#nQol�Na ��o�dÞ¸�{�a {�a@olq�r0p"qOp kl���Qol��ehgEgSph{�klcQ�c]e"kla nIphq�c m e���b[{�c]a n �]���]c]a ��� d N D\D�D 3 �H4��5�64� ���������A��� 'l�JB�� � 4���� D ��g����(���&�?� ��gNszª�;:S�G<?> �Nó��*)X�N�G+�s�²®phn]mI�`zªwN�N��d

�=+XdWY:d ¤ d · phc]cQolbfphcQo�s �:df�Oo�s�phq����´d �Ed · dftGkleN�¦d´�0{�qXo�¯fa �`g�nIp"��a °8e�n]}�g�e�n�c]��a:bfa nQg�eNn]�¥pª���o�k�olcQ��a��Np kl{Op"cQoleNq¦ehgOgSp"{XklcQ�Sc]e"kla nIphq�c�m e���b[{�c]a n��]���]c]a ��� d\N D\D\DA3 �H4��5��4�&�������5�\���P�!��" V#%����� �J�Is�ñ�y�:S�G<?> �Xz"y�)���yG+Xs#zªwNw��Xd

��óXdWY:d ¤ d · phc]cQolbfphcQo�p"q[�)�Od �:d����Op"�³d¦¹�q1c]�[am e���b�{[cIp"cQoleNqfpªk4ph�]bOa�m c]�:e"g8bfa nQg�eNn]�¥ph��o�k�olcQ���e���a@kl�ehg�gSp"{XklcQ�Sc]e"kla nIphq�cm e���b[{�c]a n�]���]c]a ��� d N D�D\D�3 �H4��5��4�&�������5�W��� �!��"$#%�����&�J�@s��w;:S�G<?> �N��y*)X�N�Nó�s#�"{Xkl�®zªwNwNx�d

���Xd´�Ed ºEd ¤ p"��a �]�%phq�� Y:d ��dj�#nQol�Na ��o�dÜ��a �:o��Sq�{���a nQolm"p kc]nIphq��Qola q�c1phqfpªkl���Qol�1ehg§�p"n]}Ne"���e���a@kl� dµ�X{��[�Eolc]c]a �2g­eNn8b�{[��k�olm"p"cQoKe�q³s8zªwNw��Xd

���Xd´�Ed ¤ a@ol���p"q!p"q[� Y:d��OdV�#nQol��a ��o�d���{[�§a nQolm"pªkµc]nIphq��Qola q�cphqfpªkl���Qol�e"g´²®p"n]}Ne"�1��e��[aIkl� d�!��"$#%�����&�J��4��(M ^ #i�&��4��������5� [ ������4����R[sOz*+;:]z*<?>±zªw*)���óXs�z"wN���Xd

��wXd´�Ed ¤ a@ol���p"q³s�Y:d��Od8�#nQol��a ��o�s�phq�� ¤ df�X�Eolc]�³d ²®phn]}�eh��p"q[��²®p"n]}Ne"�!n]a�°�phn]�é��e���a@kc]nIp"q[�Qola q�c§phqfpªkl���Qol��>���q1e"�Na n]�Nola ° e"g�q�{���a nQolm"p k�phb�b[n]e phmI�[a�� d D �����?#i��4�� b��������(4GF!�JB^ #(�&�H4���� ���5� [ �*�6��4����R[s�ñ�x�:SyG<?> yG+��*)�y�óN��s#z"wN��wXd

w�xXdEð:d ¤ {[��olq�e�p"q[�-t|df�Xa�nQolm ehk>p�d �Sq�c]a n]��pªkµpª��p o�k>ph��o�k�oKcS�!p"qOp kl���Qol��{��Qolq[r®e�bOa nIphcQole�qOp k�bOa nQo��e���� d7@$�&�-B����?"W4��(�� D$E 4GF-��4��������[s�z ñ�>�y=+N��)�yN��yXs#zªwNwNy�d

w�zNd ¤ d �:d���ph��q[a nµphq��TY:d��Od��#nQol�Na ��o�d · a nQg�eNn]�¥phq�m a�phq���n]aIk�o>ph��o�k�oKcS��p"qOp kl���Qol��{[�Qolq�r:��oln]a m c]a��p"m ��m@k�olm�r�nIphb��[� dPN D\D\D 3 �H4��5��4�&�������5����� '�JB�� � 4��H� D �hg;� �(�?�&������gNsBz ñ�:]z"xG<?>lzNzªxG+�)OzNz�z ñ�s¹�m c dBzªwN�N��d

w�yXd ¤ d �:d���ph��q[a n�p"q[� Y:d��Od"�#nQol�Na ��o�d ¤ a@k�o>ph��o�k�oKcS���e��[aIk�olq[rE{[�Qolq�rE���|� ¤�· iµd N D�D\D 3 ��4��5��V4�&�������5�7��� [ ��F-��4��&�dF-����8hs ¤ �Ê�Nó�:SyG<?>lz"��ó*)OzªwN��su�"{�q[a�zªwN���Xd

w��Xd ¤ d �:d���ph��q�a n1phq��AY:d��Od8�#nQol��a ��o�d � �]ehg­cQ°�p"n]a`c]e�e"k´g�eNn�kla"p"n]qXolq�r�ph�Oe�{[c®�]c]e�mI�fph�]cQolm��e���a@kl� dcN D�D\D`3 ��4��5�64�&��� ���5�7��� D M��5�4��������[s �Nó;:]z*<?>X+�ó*)XóXzNs�¶[a �BdVzªwNwN��d

w"ñ[d´«�d��´d8��phq���a n]�1phq��0��d�¶udj²�a ��a n d ²®i#���´���´�9>8�ÜbOa nQg�e�n]�ph��o�k�olcQ�0a��Np kl{Op"cQoleNq0c]e�e"k�fph�]a �1eNq®�]c]e�mI�fph�]cQolm¦phm cQol�NolcS�`q�a cS°8eNn]}�� d9�Sq @����&&I%. �%1 V�N D\D\D �!��"$#%�����&��'�&&I ] 4GF�Fb������i�$�!��"c#%�����&�C�!����B6I±s�bOp"rNa ���Nx��*)X�Xz"ó�s��³e��|��k>ph�:olc]e�� s���pªk�o�g]dls#�"{Xkl�®zªwN�Nó�d

w=+Xd´«�d��´d��[p"q[��a n]�¦phq��é��d�¶udG²�a �Na n d ¤ a �[{�m a �©�Op"�]a���e���a@k�m e�q[�]c]n]{�m cQoleNqé�§a c]�[e�����g�eNn�]c]e�mI�Op"�]cQolmEphm cQol�NolcS�q[a cS°8eNn]}�� d�N D\D�D '��F-�?&����M7. �H�?4G�c�JBC�!��"W"C���(���4��������5�Is bfphr�a ��yG+*)��óXsV��p"q³dBzªwNwXz�d

w�óXdE¹:df��m@��e�a qBdܹ�q�p`m@k>p"�]�`e"g´olq�c]a rNnIp"c]a �0bOa nQg­eNn]�p"q[m a*Zhn]a@k�o>p"�Xolk�oKcS�0��e���a@kl�®�fph�]a ��eNq¨�{�a {�olq[r¦q[a cS°8eNn]}�� d\�Sq @����&&I ]�3 �2' ��� s[bfphr�a �´w�x*)XwG+Xs�z"w��NóXd

w��XdE��df� olq�rN�Bs ¤ dftGo�k�k�olq�c]eNq�sOp"q[�¥��df�³a�aNd#���[aj��a c]��e���ehgf�]cIphr�a �Gg­eNn#q�eNq��]²®p"n]}Ne"�No>phq��e����a@kl� d�N D\D�De3 ��4��5�64�&�������5�7��� [ ��F-��4��&�dF-����8hs ¤ �ÊyNó�:]z&<?>lz"�G+�)Ozª�N�Xs#�"{�q�a�z"wN���Xd

w��Xd ¤ d ²`dB���:olc]�³s%Y:d �Od[�#nQol��a ��o�s#p"q[�®�Ed ºEd ¤ p"��a �]�Bd · a nQg�eNn]�¥ph��o�k�olcQ�1phqfpªkl���Qol��>���a"ph�]{�n]a � sp"q�p klrNeNnQolc]����s�p"q[�¥pµmªph�]a��]c]{[���Nd\N D\D\D 3 ��4��5�64�&��� ���5�!��� � ��"c#%����� �J�Is"�N��:�ñ�<?> ñ�x�ó*)�ñ�z"��s��b[nQo�kjz"wN���Xd

w�wXdE�´dO��, m�,�a n]�XolmI}�pXd´� m e��:��olq�a ��¨�{�a {Xolq�r®q�a cQ°8e�n]}®p"q[�1�]c]e�m@�fph�]cQolm · a c]nQo�q�a c4phb�b[n]e phmI�g�e�nBa ��pªkl{fphcQolq�r:c]��aubfa nQg�eNn]�¥ph��o�k�olcQ��e"g[gSp"{XklcQ�Sc]e"kla nIphq�c�m eN�§b[{�c]a nV�]���]c]a���� d$@�� �-B�����"C4��i?�D�E 4GF-�54��������[s�z�ñ5> yXzª�*)�y�yNó�s#z"wNw�yXd

z"x�xXd���df��, c]nQol}�p"q[�§�(dfð��p k�d#�!n]a m�{[n]�Qol��a��]ehkl{�cQoleNq¦ehg�p�¨�{[a�{Xolq�r:�§e��[a@kfg�eNn�p��:{�klcQo��Sc]a n]�:olqfpªk�]���]c]a � �]{����]a m c�c]e���n]a"ph}���e"°|q�� d�@��&�dB6���?"W4��(�� D$E 4GF-��4���� ���[s�zNz=>±z�)��Xs�z"w�wNxXd

z"x�zNdWY:d ��df�#nQol�Na ��o�d0@�������4��&�dF-����8C4��iM 'l��4����d�6����������-R [ ��F-��4��&�dF-����8 � �$���&�5���hg�� 4��(M��!��"$#%�5���&�

'&���&�(��$.$#�#F-���4���� ���;�Id · n]a q�cQolm a@�Ê��pªk�k�s�iGq�rhkla °je�e��X�Ê�uk�o�¬B�"s#�´��s³zªwN��yXdz"x�yXdWY:d ��d��#nQol�Na��Xo�s���dXY:d ²�{[b�bfpªk>pXs���d · d�«1e�ehkla c s�phq���t�d ¤ d���pª��a n]}Ne�n]c dj�µe���bOe��Qolc]a�bOa nQg­eNnQ��p"q[m�aEphq��®�[a bfa q[�fph��o�k�o>cQ�-phqfpªkl���Qol� d9@�� �-B�����"C4��i?� D�E 4GF-�54��������[s�z�ñ5>lz"w��*)�y�z&+�s#z"wNw�yXd

Page 22: Reliability and Performability Techniques and Tools: A Survey ...

z"x��XdE²`dfºua�a nIphnIp"rN�fpª��p"q�p"q[�PY:d ��d �#nQol�Na ��o�dj�µe���bOe��Qolc]a´bOa nQg�e�n]�phq�m a´p"q[�n]a@k�o>p"�Xo�k�o>cQ�9phqfpªk�����Qol�´{��Qolq�r�m e��:��olqOp"c]eNnQo>p k8�E{XklcQol�]cIp"c]a���e���a@kl� d��#e�p"b[bOaªphn�olq/N D\D�De3 ��4��5�64�&��� ���5�7���� ��"c#%����� �J�Id

z"x"ñ[dE²`dfºua�a nIphnIp"rN�fpª��p"q)phq�� Y:d �OdV�#nQol��a �Xo�d§��q®ol��b�n]eh��a �)p klrNeNnQolc]��� g­eNn´�]���E�Oehk�olm¦n]a@k�o>pª���o�k�olcQ�1p"qOp kl���Qol� d�N D�D\D`3 ��4��5�64�&�������5����� [ �*F-� 4�� �-F-����8hs ¤ �Sñ�x;:S�=<?>��"ñ���)��G+��Xsf��{�rN{��]c(zªwNw�zNd

z"x=+XdE�´d���d�«©�Xolc]aEp"q[�9�Gd ��dX�µ��nQol�]cQolaNdµ¸�{[a {�olq�r�°8olc]��b�n]a a ��b�cQol�Na´b�nQoleNnQolcQola ��eNn8��n]a"p"}��[e"°�q³d^ #i� �H4��������5� [ ���6�?4��H�R[s�ó;> �Nw�)�wG+�sVzªwG+N��d

���Xol�4phn]cQolm@klaE°�p"�|b�n]e�m a �]�]a��`{��Qolq[rc]��aE� � � i �0�p"m n]e�bfphmI}Np"rNaE°8olc]�®�V���������]cS�Nkla


Recommended