f oe e et vl v ie r w
PROFILEWHAT DOES AN AVERAGE FLEET CONSIST
OF? WHAT ARE COMMONLY OUTSOURCED SERVICES, AND HOW DO FLEETS
REMARKET THEIR VEHICLES? EXPLORE THIS AND OTHER STATISTICS IN THIS
FLEET OVERVIEW SECTION, WHICH INCLUDES RESPONSES FROM MORE
THAN 200 SURVEYED FLEETS.
Information for this overview of the public
fl eet industry comes from the 2012 Govern-
ment Fleet Industry Profi le survey, which
had more than 200 responses. City fl eets
comprise nearly half of all fl eets surveyed,
and more than a quarter of fl eets service
areas of less than 50,000 people.
Some highlights from this section: Bud-
gets have increased for 17% of fl eets who
responded, mostly due to increased fuel
costs and increased labor costs, but also, in
one case, to increased fl eet size due to an
insourcing contract. Th e most commonly
outsourced service is body and paint work,
with 86% of fl eets reporting they send out
this type of work. Finally, use of in-house
and local auctions are tied in use with on-
line auctions for remarketing, and many
fl eets opt for both methods.
From tool allowances to common cus-
tomer departments, GF compiled a profi le of
the average fl eet operation based on survey
respondents and broke down data based on
population size, agency type, and fl eet size.
RESEARCH
GOVERNMENT FLEET I FACT BOOK 20128
376
$2.9 MILLION
65% 67%UNITSMEDIAN ROLLING STOCK FLEET SIZE
OF FLEETS HAVE A FORMAL REPLACEMENT PROGRAM
OF FLEETS ARE ANINTERNAL SERVICE FUND
SERVE A POPULATION SIZE OF LESS THAN 50,000 PEOPLE
MEDIAN FLEET BUDGET(LESS CAPITAL) $
SOURCE: 2012 INDUSTRY PROFILE SURVEY
GFFB12overview.indd 8GFFB12overview.indd 8 8/27/12 3:43 PM8/27/12 3:43 PM
GOVERNMENT FLEET I FACT BOOK 2012 9
FLEETS BY AGENCY TYPE
MEDIAN ANNUAL BUDGET (LESS CAPITAL) BY AGENCY TYPE
CITY ................. $2,100,000
COUNTY ............ $3,487,818
STATE AGENCY .... $8,000,000
FEDERAL* .......... $5,050,000
COUNTY 26%
STATE 10%UTILITY 7%
CITY 47%
UNIVERSITY 4% SCHOOLDISTRICT
3%
FEDERAL3%
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
25%
30%
26%Less than
50,000
50,00099,999
100,000199,999
200,000299,999 300,000
399,999400,000499,999
500,000999,999
1,000,0004,999,999
5,000,00010,000,000
More than10,000,000
19%
14%
6% 5%
2%
10%
12%
5%
1%
POPULATION
PERC
ENT
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
25%
30%
35%
2%
6% 7%
16%
31%
23%
9%
4%2%
INCR
EASE
D 10
-14.
9%
INCR
EASE
D 15
% O
R M
ORE
INCR
EASE
D 5-
9.9%
INCR
EASE
D 0.
1-4.
9%
NO C
HANG
E
DECR
EASE
D 0.
1-4.
9%
DECR
EASE
D 5-
9.9%
DECR
EASE
D 10
-14.
9%
DECR
EASE
D 15
% O
R M
ORE
CHANGE IN BUDGET
PERC
ENT C
HANG
E
Nearly half of all fl eet agencies reporting their information are city agencies, while school districts and federal fl eets are the least common fl eets analyzed. Each state agency that manag-es its own fl eet reported separate numbers. These agencies include Department of Transportation, Motor Pool, and Admin-istrative fl eets. Universities are counted separately.
*DATA WAS COLLECTED FROM GF READERSHIP AND MAY NOT REFLECT ENTIRE INDUSTRY TOTALS.
The most common population size of the area for which a fl eet agency is responsible is less than 50,000.
Seventeen percent of respondents reported an increase in budget, while 67% reported a de-creased budget. Fleet managers cited rising fuel costs more than any other factor as the reason for their increased budgets. Other fac-tors identifi ed include higher maintenance costs due to aging vehicles, increased labor costs, and additional work through insourcing. One reason cited for reduced costs is improved effi ciencies.
*CURRENT FISCAL YEAR VS. PREVIOUS FISCAL YEAR
POPULATION SIZE
CHANGE IN ANNUAL BUDGET* (LESS CAPITAL)
City fl eets have the smallest budget, while state agencies are reported to have the largest budgets.
*LOW RESPONSE RATE MAY INFLUENCE AVERAGE.
SOURCE: INDUSTRY PROFILE SURVEY
GFFB12overview.indd 9GFFB12overview.indd 9 8/27/12 3:43 PM8/27/12 3:43 PM
GOVERNMENT FLEET I FACT BOOK 201210
f oe e et vl v ie r w
4%DIRECTOR OF
FINANCE
DIRECTOR OFPUBLIC WORKS
5%
3%
24%3%
1%
3%
2%
8%
4%6%
9%
6%
CITY MANAGER9%9%
6%6%
8%8%DIRECTOR OFOPERATIONS
SHERIFF
GENERALMANAGER
ASSISTANTCITYMANAGER
DEPUTYCITY
MANAGER
CHIEF OF POLICEDIRECTOR OF
ADMINISTRATIVESERVICES
4%244%24
3%3% 2%2%
OTHER
6%6%1%1%1%1
3%3%
4%4%3%3%
DIRECTOR OFTRANSPORTATION
ASSISTANTDIRECTOR OF
PUBLIC WORKS
DIRECTOR OFGENERAL SERVICES
22%
The most common agency overseeing fl eet services is Public Works, with 28% of fl eet managers reporting to its director or assistant director. This data is calculated from actual titles reported. Variances in titles are included in the “other” category.
TITLE OF SUPERVISOR OVERSEEING FLEET MANAGEMENT
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%53%
20% 20%
6% 5% 4% 3% 2%
17%
IN-H
OUSE
AND
LOCA
L AUC
TION
OTHE
R*
ONLIN
E AUC
TION:
GOV
DEAL
S
ONLIN
E AUC
TION:
PU
BLIC
SURP
LUS
TRAD
E-IN
OR
BUYB
ACK
ONLIN
E AUC
TION:
EB
AY
ONLIN
E AUC
TION:
PR
OPER
TY R
OOM
ONLIN
E AUC
TION:
MU
NICI
BID
ONLIN
E AUC
TION:
CR
AIGS
LIST
PERC
ENT O
F USE
AUCTION VENUE
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%44%
21%17%
12%
1% 1% 1% 1%
24%
IN-H
OUSE
AND
LOCA
L AUC
TION
OTHE
R*
ONLIN
E AUC
TION:
GOV
DEAL
S
ONLIN
E AUC
TION:
PU
BLIC
SURP
LUS
TRAD
E-IN
OR
BUYB
ACK
ONLIN
E AUC
TION:
EB
AY
ONLIN
E AUC
TION:
PR
OPER
TY R
OOM
ONLIN
E AUC
TION:
MU
NICI
BID
ONLIN
E AUC
TION:
CR
AIGS
LIST
PERC
ENT O
F USE
AUCTION VENUE
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50% 46%
20% 18%
11%
5% 3% 2%
19%
IN-H
OUSE
AND
LOCA
L AUC
TION
OTHE
R*
ONLIN
E AUC
TION:
GOV
DEAL
S
ONLIN
E AUC
TION:
PU
BLIC
SURP
LUS
TRAD
E-IN
OR
BUYB
ACK
ONLIN
E AUC
TION:
EB
AY
ONLIN
E AUC
TION:
PR
OPER
TY R
OOM
ONLIN
E AUC
TION:
MU
NICI
BID
PERC
ENT O
F USE
AUCTION VENUE
For online remarketing, Govdeals and Public Surplus are the most commonly used auction websites. In-house and local auctions and online auctions prove to be in use equally.
*OTHER REMARKETING SERVICES INCLUDE SEALED BIDS, RECYCLE PROGRAMS, AND OTHER ONLINE AUCTION SOURCES.
MORE THAN ONE RESPONSE POSSIBLE
AUCTION VENUES FOR LIGHT-DUTY VEHICLES
AUCTION VENUES FOR OFF-ROAD VEHICLES
AUCTION VENUES FOR HEAVY-DUTY VEHICLES(EXCLUDING OFF-ROAD EQUIPMENT)
PERCENT OF ANNUAL BILLED TECHNICIAN HOURS
Out of a total 2,080 possible bill-able hours, fl eet managers surveyed reported that technicians bill on av-erage 72%, or about 1,500 hours annually.
72%
SOURCE: INDUSTRY PROFILE SURVEY
GFFB12overview.indd 10GFFB12overview.indd 10 8/27/12 3:43 PM8/27/12 3:43 PM
f oe e et vl v ie r w
SYES6565%YES65% NO
355%%NO35%
CITY YES 63% NO 37%
COUNTY YES 66% NO 34%
STATE AGENCY YES 77% NO 23%
UTILITY YES 50% NO 50%
BREAKDOWN BY AGENCY TYPE
Data shows that utility fl eets are least likely to have a formal replacement program.
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
86%80%
71%64%
53% 52%
25%
17%10% 10%
BODY
AND
PAIN
T
TOW
ING
TRAN
SMIS
SION
WOR
K
REPA
IR R
EQUI
RING
SPEC
IAL E
QUIP
MENT
HEAV
Y-DU
TY TI
RE R
EPAI
RAN
D RE
PLAC
EMEN
T
COMP
UTER
-REL
ATED
REPA
IR IS
SUES
PM/R
EPAI
R FO
RAL
T-FUE
LED
VEHI
CLES
GLAS
S RE
PAIR
/RE
PLAC
EMEN
T
SPRI
NG R
EPAI
R
PART
S MA
NAGE
MENT
PERC
ENT
SERVICES OUTSOURCED
The most commonly outsourced fl eet function is body and paint work, followed by towing. Other outsourced repairs not listed here but reported by fl eet managers include major engine repairs, welding, wheel alignments, warranty work, detailing, washes, and component rebuilds.
MORE THAN ON RESPONSE POSSIBLE. PERCENTAGES INCLUDE THOSE FLEETS THAT OUTSOURCE ALL MAINTENANCE WORK.
SERVICES OUTSOURCED
FORMAL REPLACEMENT PROGRAM
GOVERNMENT FLEET I FACT BOOK 201212
SOURCE: INDUSTRY PROFILE SURVEY
GF0712gpsna.indd 1 6/29/12 3:19 PM
GFFB12overview.indd 12GFFB12overview.indd 12 8/27/12 3:43 PM8/27/12 3:43 PM
GF0312chevin.indd 1 2/21/12 11:13 AM
SYES6767%YES67% NO
333%%NO33%
CITY YES 71% NO 29%
COUNTY YES 66% NO 34%
STATE AGENCY YES 75% NO 25%
UTILITY YES 57% NO 43%
BREAKDOWN BY AGENCY TYPE
City fl eets are more likely to have internal service funds than County fl eets.
SYES5858%YES58% NO
422%%NO42%
CITY YES 62% NO 38%
COUNTY YES 65% NO 35%
STATE AGENCY YES 46% NO 54%
UTILITY YES 50% NO 50%
BREAKDOWN BY AGENCY TYPE
More cities and counties require techni-cians to provide their own tools than other fl eet agency types.
SYESS38%YESSYESYESSS383838383838383838%%%%%%%
NO6222%%%NONONO622262622222%%%%%%%%%
PROVIDES TOOL ALLOWANCE
AGENCIES REQUIRING TECHNICIANS TO PROVIDE THEIR OWN TOOLS
INTERNAL SERVICE FUND
GOVERNMENT FLEET I FACT BOOK 2012 13
$500MEDIAN ANNUAL TOOL
ALLOWANCE PER TECHNICIAN FOR
AGENCIES THAT OFFER IT
SOURCE: INDUSTRY PROFILE SURVEY
GFFB12overview.indd 13GFFB12overview.indd 13 8/27/12 3:43 PM8/27/12 3:43 PM
GF05-20fcs_fp.indd 1 5/18/11 3:22:02 PM
GOVERNMENT FLEET I FACT BOOK 201214
f oe e et vl v ie r w
PUBLIC WORKS
POLICE
STREETS MAINTENANCE
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
ENGINEERING
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%
DEPA
RTME
NT
PERCENT
89%87%
86%
76%
76%
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
62%69%
61% 61%57%56% 55%
50%48%45% 43%41% 41%
35%32%
27%22%21% 19%
16%16% 15%
6% 6%
PUBLI
C WOR
KS
STREET
MAINT
ENANC
E
ENGINE
ERING
DEPAR
TMENT
POLIC
E DEPA
RTMENT
AGENC
Y ADM
INISTR
ATION
PARKS
DEPAR
TMENT
COMM
UNITY
DEVEL
OPME
NT
BUILD
ING PE
RMITS
FIRE D
EPARTM
ENT
WATER
DEPAR
TMENT
WASTE
WATER
DEPAR
TMENT
TRANS
PORTA
TION D
EPARTM
ENT
CONS
TRUCTI
ON DE
PARTM
ENT
EMERG
ENCY S
ERVICE
S (AM
BULAN
CE)
ELECTE
D OFFI
CIALS
ELECTR
IC DEAP
RTMENT
SHERI
FF’S D
EPARTM
ENT
ASSESS
ORS D
EPARTM
ENT
AIRPO
RT
GENERA
L PUB
LIC
DISTRI
BUTIO
N DEPA
RTMENT
TRANS
MISSIO
N DEPA
RTMENT
MOUN
TAIN R
ESCUE
GAS D
EPARTM
ENT
PERCEN
T
AGENCY TYPE
SOLID
WASTE
SHERIFF
PUBLIC WORKS
PARKS
AGENCY ADMINISTRATION
ENGINEERING
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80%
DEPA
RTME
NT
PERCENT
56%54%
56%
60%
62%
54
PUBLIC WORKS
AGENCY ADMINISTRATION
POLICE
PARKS
ENGINEERING DEPARTMENT
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80%
DEPA
RTME
NT
PERCENT
78%
76%
72%
76%
76%
PUBLIC WORKS
STREETS MAINTENANCE
ENGINEERING
POLICE
AGENCY ADMINISTRATION
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80%
DEPA
RTME
NT
PERCENT
64%
54%
49%
61%
56%
TRANSPORTATION
POLICE
AGENCY ADMNISTRATION
CONSTRUCTION
PARKS
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60%
DEPA
RTME
NT
PERCENT
52%
52%
57%
48%
38%
AGENCY ADMINISTRATION
CONSTRUCTION
ELECTRIC
ENGINEERING
WATER
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60%
DEPA
RTME
NT
PERCENT
54%
46%
46%
46%
46%
Public Works is on the top 5 customers list for both cities and counties, and another common overlapping department is Engineering. For state and utili-ty fl eets, Transportation and Agency Administration top the list, respectively. MORE THAN ONE RESPONSE POSSIBLE.
Public Works is the most com-monly reported fl eet customer. Mountain Rescue, the Gas De-partment, and the Transmission Department are the least com-mon fl eet customers.
MORE THAN ONE RESPONSE POSSIBLE.
Broken down by fl eet size, Public Works is the most common customer for all fl eet sizes. For this ranking, “Large” is defi ned as more than 1,000 vehi-cles, while “Small/Medium” is defi ned as 1,000 vehilces or fewer. MORE THAN ONE RESPONSE POSSIBLE.
TOP 5 CUSTOMERS BY AGENCY TYPE
FLEET CUSTOMER DEPARTMENTS
TOP 5 CUSTOMERS BY LARGE FLEETS TOP 5 CUSTOMERS BY SMALL/MEDIUM FLEETS
SOURCE: INDUSTRY PROFILE SURVEY
GFFB12overview.indd 14GFFB12overview.indd 14 8/27/12 3:43 PM8/27/12 3:43 PM