Research Report
AN EXAMINATION OF TDSB POST-SECONDARY PATTERNS: 17 Year Old Students, 2007 Dr. Robert S. Brown Research Co-ordinator 09/10 – 04 November 2009
Issued by Organizational Development/ Research and Information Services
An Examination of TDSB Post-secondary Patterns: 17 Year Old Students, 2007
Dr. Robert S. Brown Copyright © November 2009 Toronto District School Board
Reproduction of this document for use in schools of the Toronto District School Board is encouraged.
For any other purpose, permission must be requested and obtained in writing from: Organizational Development / Research and Information Services
Toronto District School Board 1 Civic Centre Court, Lower Level Etobicoke, ON M9C 2B3
Tel.: 416-394-4929 Fax: 416-394-4946 Every reasonable precaution has been taken to trace the owners of copyrighted material and to make due acknowledgement. Any omission will gladly be rectified in future printings.
R04(Demographic Data\2008-09\ExamPostSec17YrOld07\PostSec07Final)rb.3457 i
TABLE OF CONTENTS
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ........................................................................................ Pg. 1
INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................... Pg. 7
METHODOLOGY ................................................................................................... Pg. 7
The Post-secondary Applications Process .................................................. Pg. 7
The TDSB Student Census ......................................................................... Pg. 8
Overall Post-secondary Results .................................................................. Pg. 8
STUDENT DEMOGRAPHIC CHARACTERISTICS AND STUDENT ACHIEVEMENT...................................................................................................... Pg. 9
Gender ........................................................................................................ Pg. 9
Student’s Region of Birth ............................................................................. Pg. 9
Student’s Racial Background ....................................................................... Pg. 10
Student’s Language .................................................................................... Pg. 12
FAMILY BACKGROUND AND STUDENT ACHIEVEMENT.................................. Pg. 14
Parent’s Place of Birth ................................................................................ Pg. 14
Parental Presence at Home ......................................................................... Pg. 14
Parent’s Educational Background ............................................................... Pg. 15
Family Occupation ...................................................................................... Pg. 16
STUDENT’S POST-SECONDARY PLANS AND RELATED INFORMATION FROM THE 2006 STUDENT CENSUS .................................................................. Pg. 17
Student’s Progress at School (Self-rated) ................................................... Pg. 17
Student’s Post-secondary Plans and Parent’s Post-secondary Plans for Their Child.................................................................................................... Pg. 17
Future Career or Occupation ....................................................................... Pg. 19
Hours of Work Per Week.............................................................................. Pg. 20
Hours of Homework Per Week .................................................................... Pg. 22
R04(Demographic Data\2008-09\ExamPostSec17YrOld07\PostSec07Final)rb.3457 ii
STUDENT’S PROGRAM OF STUDY ..................................................................... Pg. 23
Program of Study – Grades 9 and 10 .......................................................... Pg. 23
Program of Study – Grades 11 and 12 ........................................................ Pg. 26
FUTURE DIRECTIONS .......................................................................................... Pg. 27
REFERENCES ..................................................................................................... Pg. 29
APPENDICES
Appendix A – What do Confirmations Miss Compared to Registrations and Applications? .................................................................. Pg. 31
TABLES
Table 1 – Region of Birth by Confirmed Post-secondary ............................. Pg. 10
Table 2 – Student Language by Confirmed Post-secondary........................ Pg. 12
FIGURES
Figure 1 – Gender – Post-secondary Confirmations .................................... Pg. 9
Figure 2 – Student Racial Background – Post-secondary Confirmations..... Pg. 11
Figure 3 – Region of Birth for Race Sub-category – Post-secondary Confirmations .............................................................................. Pg. 12
Figure 4 – Parent’s Place of Birth – Post-secondary Confirmations ............ Pg. 14
Figure 5 – Parental Presence at Home – Post-secondary Confirmations .... Pg. 15
Figure 6 – Parental Education Level – Post-secondary Confirmations ........ Pg. 15
Figure 7 – Parental Socio-Economic Status (SES) – Post-secondary Confirmations .............................................................................. Pg. 16
Figure 8 – Student Progress at School (Self-rated) – Post-secondary Confirmations .............................................................................. Pg. 17
Figure 9 – Plans After High School – Post-secondary Confirmations ......... Pg. 18
Figure 10 – Plans After High School: Parent/Caregiver Expectations Post-secondary Confirmations ................................................. Pg. 19
Figure 11 – Future Career or Occupation – Post-secondary Confirmations .. Pg. 20
Figure 12 – Hours of Work Per Week – Post-secondary Confirmations ...... Pg. 21
R04(Demographic Data\2008-09\ExamPostSec17YrOld07\PostSec07Final)rb.3457 iii
Figure 13 – Hours of Work – Post-secondary Confirmations ....................... Pg. 21
Figure 14 – Hours of Homework Per Week – Post-secondary Confirmations ... Pg. 22
Figure 15 – Hours of Homework – Post-secondary Confirmations............... Pg. 23
Figure 16 – Gr. 9 and 10 Academic Program (2006-07) – Post-secondary Confirmations ........................................................................... Pg. 24
Figure 17 – Academic Level Gr. 11 and 12 Courses (2006-07) – Post-secondary Confirmations ................................................ Pg. 26
R04(Demographic Data\2008-09\ExamPostSec17YrOld07\PostSec07Final)rb.3457 iv
R04(Demographic Data\2008-09\ExamPostSec17YrOld07\PostSec07Final)rb.3457 1
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY In fall 2006, the Toronto District School Board’s (TDSB) Organizational Development/ Research
and Information Services (OD/RIS) implemented the Student Census at the request of the
Board. This is the third in a series of Research Reports on the 2006 Student Census. The first
looked in detailed at the overall results (Yau and O’Reilly, 2007). The second examined
academic achievement of Grade 7-10 students (Brown and Sinay, 2008). This report looks at
the patterns of 17 year old TDSB students applying to Ontario post-secondary institutions over
the 2006-07 school year.
It is clear that post-secondary access is becoming one of the most important issues in Ontario
education. On the one hand, the current consensus is that two thirds or more of new jobs will
require post-secondary experience. In a pattern not unrelated, Ontario and TDSB post-
secondary applications have been increasing over time. The 2007 application cycle was only
the second time that the number of TDSB 17 year old students applying to post-secondary
outnumbered the number who did not apply. Given the importance of post-secondary access, it
is important to examine the patterns of who applies and who does not.
The Post-secondary Applications Process
Applications to Ontario post-secondary institutions go through the Ontario University
Applications Centre (OUAC) and the Ontario College Applications Centre (OCAS). Students
normally apply in the spring of a given year and then attend post-secondary starting in
September (although there are some minor exceptions to this). The TDSB receives information
on confirmations i.e. which students write back, confirming the acceptance of an offer of
admission.
For each applications cycle (e.g. the 2007 applications cycle) information on TDSB applications
and confirmations are sent to OD/RIS using a standardized format. The information is then
linked to the Secondary Success Indicator dataset for the year in question, a dataset of
information on all students in the regular school year. There were 19,081 17 year old students
present as of October 31, 2006. These students are age-appropriate for Grade 12 Year – the
most frequent age for students to apply directly to post-secondary institutions from high school
(students will also apply when they are older, and as adult students). Over the 2007, post-
secondary applications cycle (our 2006-07 school year):
6,655 students of TDSB 17 year olds (35%) confirmed an offer of admission to Ontario
universities;
R04(Demographic Data\2008-09\ExamPostSec17YrOld07\PostSec07Final)rb.3457 2
1,297 students of TDSB 17 year olds (7%) confirmed an offer of admission to Ontario
Community Colleges (CAAT's);
2,020 students of TDSB 17 year olds (11%) had applied to post-secondary in Ontario
but did not confirm an offer of admission;
9,109 students of TDSB 17 year olds (48%) had not applied to post-secondary in
Ontario in 2007.
The TDSB Student Census
Grade 7-12 students completed the TDSB Student Census in Fall 2006 (see Yau and O’Reilly,
2007; Brown and Sinay, 2008). Information from the 2006 Student Census has also been
merged with the Secondary Success Indicator dataset. Almost three quarters (73%) of 17 year
olds present as of October 31, 2006 completed the TDSB Student Census.
DEMOGRAPHIC CHARACTERISTICS Gender
Male students are much less likely to confirm an offer of admission than female students. One
key exception to this is community college, where both male and female students are equally as
likely to be accepted – a finding that replicates earlier research.
Student’s Region of Birth
Post-secondary patterns according to region of birth are very similar to region of birth patterns
seen in earlier TDSB research. Students born in South Asia, Eastern Europe, and East Asia had
confirmation patterns above that of the TDSB. Students born in Canada had confirmation results
typical of the TDSB; students born in the English-speaking Caribbean, Central and South
America/Mexico, and Eastern Africa had the lowest proportion of post-secondary confirmations,
and the highest proportion of students not applying to post-secondary (two thirds or more). There
is one pattern somewhat different from earlier results: students born in Southeast Asia also had a
lower post-secondary participation rate.
Student’s Racial Background
Results here are consistent with earlier TDSB research. South Asian and East Asian students
had the highest post-secondary achievement pattern: the highest proportion of applications and
the highest proportion of confirmations. White and Southeast Asian students had post-
secondary achievement slightly above the TDSB total, while students of self-described Mixed
race had post-secondary achievement fairly representative of the TDSB. Students of Middle
R04(Demographic Data\2008-09\ExamPostSec17YrOld07\PostSec07Final)rb.3457 3
Eastern extraction were slightly lower, while Latin and Black students had post-secondary
access much lower than the TDSB total.
As in the earlier report on Grade 9 achievement, we examined achievement of self-identified
Black students in more detail, by examining three regions of birth: Canada, the English-
speaking Caribbean, and Africa. Students from all three regions had post-secondary
confirmation patterns lower than the TDSB total.
Student's Language
These findings are similar but not identical to previous TDSB research. The TDSB is one of the
most diverse school boards in the world and many languages are reflected in the student
population. Out of the 17 year olds in 2006-07, there were 23 languages spoken by 100 or more
students, accounting for 17,492 out of 19,081 students or 92%. Of these key language groups,
students speaking Dari, Portuguese, Spanish, and Tagalog had the lowest post-secondary
application rates. Students speaking English only had confirmation patterns slightly lower than
the TDSB total. In contrast, Bengali, Chinese, Gujarati, Hindi, Punjabi, Romanian, Serbian, and
Tamil students were more likely to apply to post-secondary and were more likely to confirm an
offer of admission, than other language groups.
Parent’s Place of Birth
Demographically, parent’s place of birth yielded limited information, in that there was little
difference between students whose parents were born in Canada or in another country.
However, it is quite possible that a more detailed examination of parents’ region of birth will yield
differences, as looking at student region of birth found large differences.
Family Background
Students living with two parents were much more likely to confirm an offer of admission from an
Ontario university than students living with one parent or in other family situations. Those with
university-educated parents were much more likely to confirm an offer of admission than other
students. Students with parents from professional backgrounds were much more likely to
confirm an offer of admission than other students. Generally, socio-economic status has been
considered among the most influential factors in looking at post-secondary access, as with
overall achievement. The results here are consistent with the literature.
R04(Demographic Data\2008-09\ExamPostSec17YrOld07\PostSec07Final)rb.3457 4
POST-SECONDARY PLANS, HOMEWORK, AND PART-TIME WORK
Self-rated Progress at School
Participants had been asked to rate their progress at school. Perhaps not surprisingly, after
three years in secondary school, 17 year old students had an accurate measure of their own
achievement. Well over three quarters of those who described their progress as 'excellent' had
applied to post-secondary and two thirds of them (67%) confirmed an offer of admission (the
vast majority from universities). In contrast, only a third of those “Having Difficulty” applied to
post-secondary and slightly less than a quarter (22%) confirmed an offer.
Post-secondary Plans
Students were asked what they thought they would be doing after high school, and they were
asked what their parents thought they (the students) would be doing after high school. The two
answers were extremely close: most students who thought that they would attend university
also thought their parents were in agreement with this direction. There was however, a
pronounced difference in the post-secondary access patterns of those who thought they would
attend university versus those who thought they would attend college. That is, of students who
planned to attend university, three quarters applied to post-secondary in 2007 and almost two
thirds accepted an offer of admission. However, less than a quarter of students who thought
they would attend college ended up confirming a post-secondary offer of admission. Many
others will attend college as older students. There also may be a mismatch between college
plans and actual actions.
Hours of Work Per Week
In looking at hours of work, those who did not work at all or worked an hour a week had a
slightly lower rate of post-secondary confirmations, compared to those who worked 2-8 hours
per week. This pattern was seen in an earlier generation of Toronto students (Yau et al., 1993).
Generally, working 15 or fewer hours per week had no obvious negative relationship to post-
secondary access, but when students worked more than 16 hours per week, their rate of post-
secondary access declined.
Hours of Homework Per Week
Students in Grade 12 also had a balancing act of working and homework. Generally, the more
homework, the greater the chance of post-secondary access, and the more part-time work, the
lower the chance of post-secondary access – but the relationship in neither case was entirely
linear. Thus, if students did five or fewer hours of homework a week, they had a limited chance
R04(Demographic Data\2008-09\ExamPostSec17YrOld07\PostSec07Final)rb.3457 5
of post-secondary access; likewise, less than half of students who engaged in 6-10 hours of
homework confirmed a post-secondary offer. Of students who engaged in 11-15 hours of
homework per week, a majority (56%) confirmed an offer. However, there appears to be limited
differences among those who engaged in 16 or more hours per week.
PROGRAM OF STUDY
As in previous research we have looked at Grade 9-10 program of study according to the majority
of courses taken – the patterns of which closely resemble the characteristics of the Advanced,
General, and Basic streams of the former OS:IS curriculum. Thus, examination of Ontario’s
programs of study is an examination of streaming, similar to earlier studies of streaming. Perhaps
more importantly, these programs of study/streams are very closely related to post-secondary
access. Attending post-secondary after four years of high school is for the most part a function
of taking Academic courses: 94% of 17 year old post-secondary confirmations took Academic
courses. This includes twice as many Academic as Applied students who confirmed acceptance
at Ontario Community Colleges (CAAT’s). The one year of 2007 applications looked at in this
study is not the full picture, particularly in looking at college. Many students will attend college
after five or six years of high school, that is, the 2008 and 2009 applications cycles that were not
looked at here; and others will attend college as adults. Still, it may be appropriate for the
Ministry to re-examine the focus and direction of the Grade 9 and 10 Program of Study.
R04(Demographic Data\2008-09\ExamPostSec17YrOld07\PostSec07Final)rb.3457 6
FUTURE DIRECTIONS Preliminary research has indicated that two thirds of students who start in Grade 9 will end up
taking some sort of post-secondary education. The information on one application cycle of 17 year
olds as shown here is necessarily limited. In particular, it understates those going to college, who
tend to apply as older students and as adults. Following the Grade 9 cohort of 2006-07 over time
will provide a greater wealth of detail on this complex subject (we will have results on two years of
post-secondary applications by fall 2011).
As with the earlier report looking at Grade 7-10 achievement this investigative analysis
examines relationships between variables, without being able to attribute which of these
variables are causal factors. Attributing cause in highly related variables can be difficult, and in
fact, the journey promises to be long and challenging. Some recent research shows possible
directions. Recent related research using Hierarchical Linear Modeling (HLM) multiple research
shows promising directions, but also reinforces the complexities in this type of analysis, e.g.
complicated results around student region of birth. A final proviso is that the information here
provides a broader range of ‘standard’ variables than in earlier studies, but the Student Census
has even greater possibilities through examining student attitudes and participation in the
secondary school culture – e.g., attitudes towards school, and school safety issues. We are in
the midst of analyzing these environmental variables.
R04(Demographic Data\2008-09\ExamPostSec17YrOld07\PostSec07Final)rb.3457 7
INTRODUCTION In fall 2006, the Toronto District School Board’s (TDSB) Organizational Development/ Research
and Information Services department (OD/RIS) implemented the Student Census at the request
of the Board. This study is part of TDSB’s major initiative to conduct research for:
Developing programs and services for students who need specific interventions and
support;
Assessing the effectiveness of programs established to address specific student needs;
Allocating resources to support students in need; and
Identifying systemic barriers to student achievement and implementing changes to
remove those barriers.
This is the third in a series of Research Reports on the 2006 Student Census. The first looked
in detailed at the overall results (Yau and O’Reilly, 2007). The second examined academic
achievement of Grade 7-10 students (Brown and Sinay, 2008). This report looks at the patterns
of 17 year old TDSB students applying to Ontario post-secondary institutions over the 2006-07
school year.
METHODOLOGY
The Post-secondary Applications Process
Applications to Ontario post-secondary institutions go through the Ontario University
Applications Centre (OUAC) and the Community College Applications Centre (OCAS). Students
normally apply in the spring of a given year and then attend post-secondary starting in
September (although there are some minor exceptions to this).
From the data end, there are three 'phases':
Applications: Students apply to programs in Ontario universities or community colleges
(or, in many cases, both).
Confirmations: Students write back confirming an Ontario university or community
college offer of admission.
Registrations: Students enroll as a student in an Ontario university or community
college (the TDSB receives information about applications and confirmations but NOT
registrations).
R04(Demographic Data\2008-09\ExamPostSec17YrOld07\PostSec07Final)rb.3457 8
University applications and confirmations are collected by OUAC, while college applications and
confirmations are collected by OCAS. For each applications cycle (e.g., the 2007 applications
cycle) information on TDSB applications and confirmations are sent to OD/RIS using a
standardized format. The information is then linked to the Secondary Success Indicator dataset
for the year in question, a dataset of information on all students in the regular school year.1
The TDSB Student Census
Grade 7-12 students completed the TDSB Student Census in Fall 2006 (see Yau and O’Reilly,
2007; Brown and Sinay, 2008). Information from the 2006 Student Census has also been
merged to the Secondary Success Indicator dataset. Almost three quarters (73%) of 17 year
olds present as of October 31, 2006 completed the TDSB Student Census.
Overall Post-secondary Results
There were 19,081 17 year old students present as of October 31, 2006. Over the 2007, post-
secondary applications cycle (our 2006-07 school year):
6,655 students (35%) confirmed an offer of admission to Ontario universities;
1,297 students (7%) confirmed an offer of admission to Ontario CAAT's;
2,020 students (11%) had applied to post-secondary in Ontario but did not confirm an
offer of admission;
9,109 students (48%) had not applied to post-secondary in Ontario in 2007.
For more details about the matrix process, and post-secondary confirmations see Appendix A.
1 OUAC (university) applications and acceptances data is linked through the students’ TDSB (Trillium) number; OCAS (community college) applications and acceptances data has a multiple link matching method, involving the students’ TDSB (Trillium) number, Ontario Education Number (OEN), and an alphanumeric number of common information.
STUDENT DEMOGRAPHIC CHARACTERISTICS AND STUDENT ACHIEVEMENT Gender
The gender gap between male and female students seen in earlier grade measures Grade 3
and 6 EQAO, Grade 9 credit accumulation, and Grade 10 literacy results, has if anything
increased in looking at post-secondary access. Thus, the majority of males (55%) did not apply
to post-secondary in the 2007 cycle, compared to 41% of female students (see Figure 1).
Therefore, while 41% of female students confirmed an offer for an Ontario university, only 29%
of male students confirmed an offer.
Figure 1: Gender – Post-secondary Confirmations
Gender – Post-secondary Confirmations
41%
29%
7%
6%
11%
10%
41%
55%
9184
9897
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 120%
Female
Male
Gen
der
% of Students
Confirmed university Confirmed college Apply post-secondary but non-confirmed Did not apply 2007
Count
Student’s Region of Birth
Key Regions of Birth are shown in Table 1. The pattern replicates earlier research on Grade 9
credit accumulation and cohort graduation (e.g., Brown, 2006; Brown and Sinay, 2008; Anisef et
al., 2008). Students born in South Asia, Eastern Europe, and East Asia had confirmation patterns
above that of the TDSB. Students born in Canada have confirmation patterns typical of the TDSB;
students born in the English-speaking Caribbean, Central and South America/Mexico, and
Eastern Africa had the lowest proportion of post-secondary confirmations, and the highest
proportion of students not applying to post-secondary (two thirds or more). Students born in
Southeast Asia also had a lower post-secondary participation rate, something somewhat different
from earlier research.
R04(Demographic Data\2008-09\ExamPostSec17YrOld07\PostSec07Final)rb.3457 9
R04(Demographic Data\2008-09\ExamPostSec17YrOld07\PostSec07Final)rb.3457 10
Table 1: Region of Birth By Confirmed Post-secondary
Confirmed Post-secondary 2007 Country Confirmed
University Confirmed
College Apply Post-secondary But
Not Confirmed Did Not
Apply 2007 Total
Canada 33% 8% 12% 47% 10931
Central & South American /Mexico 15% 10% 9% 67% 407 Eastern Africa 19% 5% 11% 64% 361 East Asia 45% 2% 8% 45% 2305 Eastern Europe 42% 8% 9% 41% 917
English-speaking Caribbean and region 12% 6% 8% 74% 473 South & Western Europe 33% 5% 11% 51% 249 South Asia 46% 6% 11% 37% 1857 Southeast Asia 26% 5% 9% 61% 259 US 29% 4% 20% 48% 113 Western Asia 31% 7% 9% 53% 887 TOTALS 35% 7% 11% 48% 19079
Student’s Racial Background
Figure 2 shows the confirmation patterns of students according to self-described racial groups.
These patterns were similar to Grade 9 cohort achievement seen in the earlier report (Brown
and Sinay, 2008). South Asian and East Asian students had the highest proportion of post-
secondary applications: 67% of South Asians and 64% of East Asians. They also had the
highest proportion of confirmations: 57% of South Asians and 56% of East Asians.
White and Southeast Asian students had post-secondary confirmation rates slightly above the
42% TDSB total. Forty-one percent of White students and 43% of Southeast Asian students did
not apply to post-secondary.
Students of self-described Mixed race had post-secondary confirmation rate fairly representative
of the TDSB: 39% confirmed post-secondary attendance, slightly below the 42% TDSB total,
while almost half (48%) did not apply at all, the same as the TDSB. Students of Middle Eastern
extraction were slightly lower, with 38% confirming post-secondary and 53% not applying.
Latin and Black students had post-secondary access much lower than the 42% TDSB total.
Twenty-one percent of Latin and 24% of Black students confirmed post-secondary (the
proportion of college confirmations was consistent with the TDSB total but the proportion of
university confirmations was half the TDSB total). Seventy percent of Latin students and 66% of
Black students did not apply at all in the 2007 cycle.
Figure 2: Student Racial Background – Post-secondary Confirmations
Student Racial Background – Post-secondary Confirmations
39%
37%
48%
32%
30%
13%
53%
15%
7%
9%
9%
7%
8%
8%
3%
9%
13%
11%
11%
13%
10%
10%
9%
10%
41%
43%
33%
48%
53%
70%
36%
66%
4680
386
2761
652
666
280
2995
1455
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 120%
White
Southeast Asian
South Asian
Mixed
Middle Eastern
Latin
East Asian
Black
Rac
ial
Bac
kgro
un
d
% of Students
Confirmed university Confirmed college Apply post-secondary but non-confirmed Did not apply 2007
Count
As in the earlier report (Brown and Sinay, 2008) we look in more detail at the pattern of post-
secondary confirmations of self-identified Black students, by examining three regions of birth:
Canada, the English-speaking Caribbean, and Africa (the five regions of birth combined into one).
As seen in Figure 3, students from all three regions had post-secondary access patterns lower
than the 42% TDSB total. Twenty-five percent of Canadian-born, 24% of African-born, and 18%
of English-speaking Caribbean-born students confirmed their acceptance to university or college,
while 65% of those born in Canada, 66% born in Africa and 74% born in the English-speaking
Caribbean did not apply at all in the 2007 cycle.
R04(Demographic Data\2008-09\ExamPostSec17YrOld07\PostSec07Final)rb.3457 11
Figure 3: Region of Birth for Race Sub-category – Post-secondary Confirmations
Region of Birth for Race Sub-category – Post-secondary Confirmations
17%
9%
17%
16%
17%
9%
7%
9%
15%
8%
11%
10%
51%
74%
66%
65%
76
266
329
784
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 120%
Other
English Speaking Caribbean
Africa
Canada
Reg
ion
of
Bir
th
% of Students
Confirmed university Confirmed college Apply post-secondary but non-confirmed Did not apply 2007
Count
Student's Language
As one of the most diverse school boards in the world, many languages are reflected in the
student population. Among 17 year old students attending in 2006-07, there were 23 languages
spoken by 100 or more students, accounting for 17,492 out of 19,081 students or 92%.
Table 2: Student Language By Confirmed Post-secondary
Confirmed Post-secondary 2007 Student Language Confirmed
University Confirmed
College Apply Post-secondary But
Not Confirmed Did Not
Apply 2007 Total
Albanian 35% 7% 11% 47% 133 Arabic 30% 12% 8% 50% 214 Bengali 57% 3% 13% 27% 267 Chinese 49% 3% 9% 39% 2849 Dari 15% 7% 5% 73% 131 English 29% 8% 11% 52% 8760 French 35% 6% 10% 49% 119 Greek 26% 10% 9% 55% 174 Gujarati 47% 11% 10% 33% 304 Hindi 52% 5% 12% 31% 169 Korean 44% 3% 12% 41% 423 Persian (Farsi) 33% 7% 9% 51% 431 Portuguese 22% 12% 5% 62% 135 Punjabi 37% 15% 13% 36% 266 Romanian 60% 5% 8% 27% 125 Russian 40% 8% 10% 42% 437 Serbian 50% 9% 12% 29% 102 Somali 21% 6% 15% 59% 294 Spanish 11% 6% 9% 75% 349 Tagalog (Pilipino) 17% 9% 9% 65% 141 Tamil 52% 5% 15% 28% 808 Urdu 39% 9% 8% 43% 589 Vietnamese 39% 9% 10% 42% 272 TOTALS 35% 7% 11% 47% 17492
R04(Demographic Data\2008-09\ExamPostSec17YrOld07\PostSec07Final)rb.3457 12
R04(Demographic Data\2008-09\ExamPostSec17YrOld07\PostSec07Final)rb.3457 13
Students speaking Dari, Portuguese, Spanish, and Tagalog had the lowest post-secondary
application rates: 75% of Spanish-speaking, 73% of Dari-speaking, 65% of Tagalog-speaking
and 62% of Portuguese-speaking students did not apply to post-secondary in the 2007 cycle.
Students speaking English only had confirmation patterns slightly lower than the TDSB total
(that is, they were slightly less likely to apply to post-secondary and slightly less likely to confirm
an offer of admission than the TDSB total).
In contrast, Bengali, Chinese, Gujarati, Hindi, Punjabi, Romanian, Serbian, and Tamil students
are more likely to apply to post-secondary and more likely to confirm an offer of admission, than
other language groups.
These findings are similar but not identical to previous TDSB research. The lower participation
rates amongst Tagalog-speaking students had not been seen in earlier research. Somali-
speaking students had been identified as highly at-risk in looking at Grade 9 cohort students;
although their post-secondary confirmation patterns as seen in Table 2 are indeed below the
TDSB total, they appear to have done somewhat better than might have been anticipated from
earlier research.
FAMILY BACKGROUND AND STUDENT ACHIEVEMENT Parents’ Place of Birth
The TDSB student population is, for the most part, a first or second-generation population, with
over 80% of one or both of our students’ parents born outside of Canada. As seen in earlier
research, simple breakdown of parental birth, like simple breakdown of student birthplaces,
shows little important differences. Thus, 44% of those with both parents born in Canada applied
to post-secondary, compared to 45% of those with one parent born in Canada and one parent
born outside Canada, and 48% of those with both parents born outside Canada. There was
limited difference in looking at students who did not apply to post-secondary: 43% of those with
both parents born in Canada, 41% of those with one parent born in Canada, and 42% of those
with both parents born outside Canada (see Figure 4). A more detailed analysis of parents’ place
of birth may provide more information that is useful.
Figure 4: Parents’ Place of Birth – Post-secondary Confirmations
Parents' Place of Birth – Post-secondary Confirmations
41%
37%
37%
7%
8%
7%
10%
14%
13%
42%
41%
43%
10037
1206
2593
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 120%
Outside Canada
Canada and Another Country
Canada
Pla
ce o
f B
irth
% of Students
Confirmed university Confirmed college Apply post-secondary but non-confirmed Did not apply 2007
Count
Parental Presence at Home
Post-secondary confirmations parallels earlier research showing the very strong relationship of
parental presence to students’ achievement. A majority of 17 year old students from two parent
families confirmed offers of admission from Ontario post-secondary institutions (45% confirmed
offers from universities, 7% confirmed offers from colleges). By contrast, a majority of students
living with one parent did not apply to post-secondary (55% living with mother only and 59%
living with father only), while nearly three quarters (71%) of those living in some other family
arrangement did not apply. A little over a third of those living with mother only, less than a third
of those living with father only, and a fifth of those living in other arrangements confirmed a post-
secondary offer of admission (see Figure 5).
R04(Demographic Data\2008-09\ExamPostSec17YrOld07\PostSec07Final)rb.3457 14
Figure 5: Parental Presence at Home – Post-secondary Confirmations
Parental Presence at Home – Post-secondary Confirmations
16%
21%
28%
45%
4%
7%
7%
7%
9%
12%
11%
11%
71%
59%
55%
36%
685
374
2430
10207
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 120%
Other Adults or on Their Own
Father only
Mother only
Two Parents
Par
enta
l P
rese
nce
% of Students
Confirmed university Confirmed college Apply post-secondary but non-confirmed Did not apply 2007
Count
Parents’ Educational Background
As might be expected, parents' level of education also parallels the literature in being closely
related to student post-secondary access. Two thirds of students with university-educated
parents applied to Ontario post-secondary and a majority (56%) confirmed offers of admission. A
majority of students with college-educated parents applied but the proportion was much lower
than those from university-educated backgrounds (55% compared to 69%) and less than half
(44%) confirmed an offer of admission (see Figure 6). Less than half (47%) of students whose
parents had high school education applied to post-secondary (47%) and those who did not
know their parents' education had the lowest application rate (42%).
Figure 6: Parents’ Educational Background – Post-secondary Confirmations
Parents' Educational Background – Post-secondary Confirmations
25%
30%
33%
51%
8%
8%
11%
5%
9%
9%
11%
13%
58%
53%
46%
32%
2156
2396
2207
6797
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 120%
Don't know
High School
College
University
Ed
uca
tio
n L
evel
% of Students
Confirmed university Confirmed college Apply post-secondary but non-confirmed Did not apply 2007
Count
R04(Demographic Data\2008-09\ExamPostSec17YrOld07\PostSec07Final)rb.3457 15
Family Occupation
Family occupation has traditionally been associated with high achievement patterns (e.g., Brown,
1996; Brown and Sinay, 2008) and Figure 7 demonstrates this pattern very clearly. The majority of
17 year olds in the TDSB were from Professional (31%) or Semi-professional (32%) backgrounds.
These students were most likely to apply to post-secondary: 74% of students with parents from
Professional and 63% from Semi-Professional backgrounds applied to post-secondary in 2007,
compared to 56% of students with parents from Skilled clerical, 46% of students with parents from
Unskilled clerical, and 35% of students with parents from Non-remunerative backgrounds. They
were also most likely to confirm an offer of admission: 60% of students with parents from
Professional and 51% of students with parents from Semi-professional backgrounds confirmed an
offer of admission, compared to 46% of students with parents from Skilled clerical, 36% of
students with parents from Unskilled clerical and 27% of students with parents from Non-
remunerative backgrounds.
Note that the proportion of students who applied to post-secondary but did not confirm an offer
was slightly higher (14%) amongst students whose parents had professional backgrounds. This
may be explained in part because students who attended post-secondary outside Ontario would
not accept an offer in Ontario, and these students are more likely to be in the higher Socio-
economic Status (SES) categories.
Figure 7: Parental Socio-economic Status (SES) – Post-secondary Confirmations
Parental Socio-economic Status (SES) – Post-secondary Confirmations
21%
28%
37%
44%
55%
6%
8%
9%
7%
5%
8%
10%
10%
12%
14%
65%
54%
45%
37%
26%
249
1055
2353
3216
3147
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 120%
Non-remunerative
Unskilled clerical
Skilled clerical
Semi-professional
Professional
Fam
ily
SE
S
% of Students
Confirmed university Confirmed college Apply post-secondary but non-confirmed Did not apply 2007
Count
R04(Demographic Data\2008-09\ExamPostSec17YrOld07\PostSec07Final)rb.3457 16
STUDENT’S POST-SECONDARY PLANS AND RELATED INFORMATION
FROM THE 2006 STUDENT CENSUS
Student's Progress at School (Self-rated)
Participants had been asked to rate their progress at school. Perhaps not surprisingly, after
three years in secondary school, 17 year old students had an accurate measure of their own
achievement. Well over three quarters of those who described their progress as 'Excellent' had
applied to post-secondary and three quarters of them (67%) confirmed an offer of admission
(the vast majority from universities). About half the students rated themselves as “Good” and of
those about two thirds applied to post-secondary and slightly over half (53%) confirmed an offer
of admission. Fewer than half of the 'Fair/Average' students applied to post-secondary in 2007
and a little over a third (35%) confirmed a post-secondary offer. Only a third of those “Having
Difficulty” applied to post-secondary and slightly less than a quarter (22%) confirmed an offer
(see Figure 8).
Figure 8: Student Progress at School (Self-rated) – Post-secondary Confirmations
Student Progress at School (Self-rated) – Post-secondary Confirmations
15%
26%
46%
63%
7%
9%
7%
4%
10%
12%
11%
10%
67%
53%
37%
23%
827
3925
6325
2136
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 120%
Having Difficulty
Fair/Average
Good
Excellent
Rat
ing
% of Students
Confirmed university Confirmed college Apply post-secondary but non-confirmed Did not apply 2007
Count
Student’s Post-secondary Plans and Parents’ Post-secondary Plans for Their Child
Students were asked what they planned to do after high school, and what their parents or
caregivers thought they would be doing. Not surprisingly, there was a very close relationship
between the two: generally, most students who thought they would attend university also
thought that their parents had similar ambitions for them (95%) and most students who thought
they would attend college also thought that their parents were in agreement (71%). 2
R04(Demographic Data\2008-09\ExamPostSec17YrOld07\PostSec07Final)rb.3457 17
2 Sixteen percent of students who thought they would attend college said that their parents expected them to attend university – not college.
There was a difference, in access to post-secondary, between those whose post-secondary
plans included university, and all other students. That is, of the students who planned to attend
university, three quarters applied to post-secondary in 2007 and almost two thirds (63%)
accepted an offer of admission (nearly all, 60%, accepted an offer from university). Only a third
(34%) of students who thought they would attend college, applied to post-secondary, and
slightly less than a quarter (23%) accepted an offer of admission from an Ontario college (see
Figure 9). From other research, we have found that students are more likely to get into college
as 18-19 year olds. It may be that many who plan to go to college but did not in the 2007
application cycle will do so in future years. Nonetheless, the gap is large enough to suggest a
mismatch between college plans and actual actions.
Figure 9: Plans After High School – Post-secondary Confirmations
Plans After High School – Post-secondary Confirmations
13%
19%
60%
7%
7%
23%
3%
7%
12%
10%
13%
73%
91%
63%
87%
67%
25%
1%
1%
3% 3%
7%
4%
5%
659
150
313
221
1062
4306
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 120%
Not sure
Work
Other plans
An Apprenticeship
Attend College
Attend University
Stu
den
t R
esp
on
se
% of Students
Confirmed university Confirmed college Apply post-secondary but non-confirmed Did not apply 2007
Count
For those students planning on a future without college or university, comparatively few applied
to post-secondary (between 9% to 37% applied) and consequently, comparatively few accepted
an offer of admission (6% to 26%). Similar patterns are seen in parent/caregiver expectations
(see Figure 10).
R04(Demographic Data\2008-09\ExamPostSec17YrOld07\PostSec07Final)rb.3457 18
Figure 10: Plans after High School: Parent/Caregiver Expectations Post-secondary Confirmations
13%
24%
56%
7%
8%
22%
4%
6%
11%
8%
13%
74%
89%
57%
87%
70%
28%
1%
1%
1%
5%
2%
8%
8%
625
98
231
105
1009
4651
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 120%
Not sure
Work
Other plans
An Apprenticeship
Attend College
Attend University
Stu
den
t R
esp
on
se
% of Students
Confirmed university Confirmed college Apply post-secondary but non-confirmed Did not apply 2007
Count
Plans After High School: Parent/Caregiver Expectations – Post-secondary Confirmations
Future Career or Occupation
Students were asked if they had decided on a future career or occupation. Forty percent had
decided on a career, while 52% were still thinking about it, and 8% had no idea of their plans.
There was a slight difference in terms of post-secondary access between those who decided on
their career plans and those still thinking about it: 62% of those who had decided on a career
applied to post-secondary, compared to 58% who had been thinking about it. Slightly over half or
52% of those who had decided on a career confirmed an offer of admission, while just under half
or 46% of those who had been thinking about a career did so.
The comparatively small proportions of students with no idea of their future occupation (8%) were
also less likely to go onto post-secondary: only 43% applied to post-secondary and a little over a
third (35%) confirmed an offer of admission (see Figure 11). These students also had a lower self-
assessment of their academic achievement (a majority or 55% rated their achievement below
'Good' while only 9% rated their achievement as ‘Excellent’). Thus, these students may not have
had a career in mind, or they may have been weighing alternatives, because they were uncertain
as to what would happen in the immediate future.
R04(Demographic Data\2008-09\ExamPostSec17YrOld07\PostSec07Final)rb.3457 19
Figure 11: Future Career or Occupation – Post-secondary Confirmations
Future Career or Occupation – Post-secondary Confirmations
30%
40%
44%
5%
6%
8%
9%
11%
11%
57%
42%
38%
525
3484
2696
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 120%
No, I've no idea about it
Yes, I've been thinking about it
Yes, I've decided on it
Stu
den
t R
esp
on
se
% of Students
Confirmed university Confirmed college Apply post-secondary but non-confirmed Did not apply 2007
Count
Hours of Work Per Week
There is a relationship between students’ hours of work and post-secondary access. Generally,
the more hours worked, the lower the chance a student would continue onto post-secondary –
but the relationship is not completely linear. Thus, the students who did not work at all or worked
one hour a week had a slightly lower rate of post-secondary confirmation than students who
worked 2-8 hours per week. Nevertheless, there was limited difference between working under
15 hours per week and post-secondary patterns: almost two thirds of students applied to post-
secondary and around half confirmed an offer of admission (53% of those working 0-5 hours,
51% of those working 6-10 hours and 49% of those working 11-15 hours). Students working 16
or more hours per week in general were less likely to confirm an offer of admission: 44% of
those working 16-20 hours, 34% of those working 21-25 hours and 20% of those working 26-35
hours confirmed an offer of admission (see Figure 12).3
Figure 12 shows the proportion according to categories (0-5 hours, 6-10 hours, etc.) while
Figure 13 shows a line graph showing post-secondary applications according to each hour of
work (up to 35 hours per week).
R04(Demographic Data\2008-09\ExamPostSec17YrOld07\PostSec07Final)rb.3457 20
3 Interestingly, 27% of those working 36+ hours confirmed an offer of admission, a higher rate than those working 26-35 hours per week. However, the number of students is comparatively small—143—and it may be that some of these students either wrote the wrong information or it was coded incorrectly—what was 17 hours per week to 70, for example.
Figure 12: Hours of Work Per Week – Post-secondary Confirmations
Hours of Work Per Week – Post-secondary Confirmations
20%
9%
26%
34%
43%
44%
47%
7%
11%
8%
10%
6%
7%
6%
11%
11%
15%
11%
12%
14%
11%
63%
69%
50%
44%
39%
35%
37%
143
200
244
636
628
682
3675
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 120%
36+ hours
26-35 hours
21-25 hours
16-20 hours
11-15 hours
6-10 hours
0-5 hours
Nu
mb
er o
f H
ou
rs p
er W
eek
% of Students
Confirmed university Confirmed college Apply post-secondary but non-confirmed Did not apply 2007
Count
Figure 13: Hours of Work – Post-secondary Confirmations
Post-secondary Confirmations and Hours of Work
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26 28 30 32 34
Post-secondary Confirmations
Linear (Post-secondary Confirmations)
R04(Demographic Data\2008-09\ExamPostSec17YrOld07\PostSec07Final)rb.3457 21
Hours of Homework Per Week
There is a direct relationship between hours of homework and post-secondary access – up to a
point. If students do five or fewer hours of homework per week, they have a limited chance of
getting into post-secondary: only a third applied and little more than a quarter (26%) confirmed
an offer of admission. The majority of students who allocated between 6-10 hours per week for
homework applied to post-secondary (59%) although less than half (46%) accepted an offer of
admission. Two thirds of students who allocated between 11-15 hours of homework applied to
post-secondary, and over half (56%) confirmed an offer of admission. There appears to be
limited differences among those who engaged in over 16 hours of homework per week: about
three quarters of students applied, and slightly less than two thirds confirmed an offer of
admission. Yet the difference in success was minimal between those who engaged in 16 hours
per week and 32 hours per week. Figure 14 shows the proportion according to categories (0-5
hours, 6-10 hours etc) while Figure 15 shows a line graph showing post-secondary applications
according to each hour of homework (up to 35 hours per week).
Figure 14: Hours of Homework Per Week – Post-secondary Confirmations
Hours of Homework Per Week – Post-secondary Confirmations
59%
61%
57%
56%
50%
38%
17%
4%
4%
6%
6%
6%
8%
9%
9%
10%
9%
12%
11%
13%
10%
28%
25%
28%
26%
33%
41%
64%
407
518
467
700
1129
1735
1602
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 120%
36+ hours
26-35 hours
21-25 hours
16-20 hours
11-15 hours
6-10 hours
0-5 hours
Nu
mb
er o
f H
ou
rs p
er W
eek
% of Students
Confirmed university Confirmed college Apply post-secondary but non-confirmed Did not apply 2007
Count
R04(Demographic Data\2008-09\ExamPostSec17YrOld07\PostSec07Final)rb.3457 22
Figure 15: Hours of Homework – Post-secondary Confirmations
Post-secondary Confirmations and Hours of Homework
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26 28 30 32 34
Post-secondary Confirmations
Linear (Post-secondary Confirmations)
STUDENT’S PROGRAM OF STUDY Program of Study – Grades 9 and 10
Under the Ontario Secondary School (OSS) curriculum streaming was, in theory, eliminated.
Instead, students take courses in Academic (university), Applied (college), and Locally-
developed programs of study in Grades 9 and 10, and University, College, Mixed
(University/College), and Workplace courses in Grades 11-12.
A number of studies have shown clear relationships with Grade 9 Program of Study and
achievement in high school. Students taking a majority of their courses in the Academic
Program of Study are more likely to do well in Grade 9 and Grade 10, more likely to graduate,
and more likely to apply to post-secondary. Students taking a majority of their courses in the
Applied or Locally-developed programs of study are more at-risk in Grades 9 and 10, are less
likely to graduate and apply to post-secondary (Brown and Sinay, 2008; Anisef et al., 2008;
Brown, 2009; Brown, 2006; King, 2005). These patterns closely resemble the characteristics of
the Advanced, General, and Basic streams of the former Ontario Schools: Intermediate and
Senior divisions (OSIS) curriculum. Thus, examination of Ontario’s programs of study is an
examination of streaming, similar to earlier studies of streaming.
R04(Demographic Data\2008-09\ExamPostSec17YrOld07\PostSec07Final)rb.3457 23
Figure 16: Gr. 9 and 10 Academic Program (2006-07) – Post-secondary Confirmations
Gr. 9 and 10 Academic Program (2006-07) – Post-secondary Confirmations
48% 6% 13%
96%
83%
33%
2%
0%
10%
2%
5%
2% 555
4459
13546
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 120%
Locally-developed
Applied
Academic
Stu
den
t P
rog
ram
% of Students
Confirmed university Confirmed college Apply post-secondary but non-confirmed Did not apply 2007
Count
As seen in Figure 16, the majority of the 13,546 17 year old students in 2006-7 who had taken a
majority of their Grade 9/10 courses in the Academic program of study were accepted into post-
secondary: 48% confirmed a university offer (6,474 students) while 6% confirmed a community
college offer (828 students). In contrast, comparatively few of the 4,459 students who had taken
a majority of their Grade 9/10 courses in the Applied program of study were accepted into post-
secondary: 2% confirmed a university offer (88 students) while 10% confirmed a community
college offer (443 students).
Since 1) there are three times as many students taking Academic than Applied courses, and 2)
so few students taking Applied courses confirm a post-secondary offer of admission, this means
that attending post-secondary after four years of high school is, for the most part, a function of
taking Academic courses in Grades 9 and 10. Out of 7,847 17 year old post-secondary
confirmations, nearly all (7,302 or 93%) had taken a majority of Grade 9-10 courses in the
Academic program of study. This includes about twice as many College confirmations from
those taking Academic (828) as students taking Applied (443). The one year of 2007
applications examined in this study is not the full picture, particularly in looking at college. Many
students will attend college after five or six years of high school, that is, the 2008 and 2009
applications cycles that were not looked at here; and others will attend college as adults. Still,
given that the Applied program is intended for students planning to attend Colleges, the
evidence shows a mismatch between the intended Ministry goal, and the achieved result.
R04(Demographic Data\2008-09\ExamPostSec17YrOld07\PostSec07Final)rb.3457 24
R04(Demographic Data\2008-09\ExamPostSec17YrOld07\PostSec07Final)rb.3457 25
It should be noted that this is, if anything, an optimistic picture, in that it looks only at students
who have made it into their fourth year of secondary school. From our cohort studies, we know
that many students taking Applied or Locally-developed courses in Grade 9 and 10 have left the
TDSB by this point (e.g., Brown, 2006). Moreover, the number of students who had taken
Applied courses in Grade 9 and 10 and then make it into community colleges may be a
comparably small number, but their fate in community college is even more uncertain. The
College Mathematics Project looked at Ontario community college students in their first year of
post-secondary study. It found that “Most students (71.7%) who followed the Academic pathway
through Grades 9 and 10 received good grades in college; that number dropped to 48.7% when
the corresponding Applied courses were selected” (York-Seneca Institute for Mathematics,
Science and Technology Education, 2008, 38).
Program of Study – Grades 11 and 12
As seen in Figure 17, patterns of students taking a majority of courses in the University, College,
Mixed University-College, and Workplace programs of study are similar to those taking a
majority of Academic, Applied, and Locally-developed courses4.
Not surprisingly, the majority of students taking a majority of University courses accepted an
offer of admission: 55% from an Ontario university, 4% from a community college. In contrast,
most students taking a majority of their courses in the College program of study did not accept a
post-secondary offer of admission: 2% accepted a university offer and 14% accepted a college
offer (less than a quarter applied at all). Students taking a majority of Mixed courses had
characteristics midway between those taking University and those taking College courses.
Figure 17: Academic Level Gr. 11 and 12 Courses (2006-07) – Post-secondary Confirmations
21%
55%
11%
14%
10%
6%
14%
100%
90%
58%
78%
27%
3%
2%
3%
4%
4%
391
990
2709
3349
10955
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 120%
Could Not Define
Workplace
Mixed
College
University
Aca
dem
ic L
evel
Gr.
11
and
12
Co
urs
es
% of Students
Confirmed university Confirmed college Apply post-secondary but non-confirmed Did not apply 2007
Count
Academic Level Gr. 11 and 12 Courses (2006-07) – Post-secondary Confirmations
R04(Demographic Data\2008-09\ExamPostSec17YrOld07\PostSec07Final)rb.3457 26
4 Grade 9/10 and Grade 11/12 programs of study are similar but not identical. In a recent cohort study, 96% of students taking a majority of courses in the Grade 11/12 University program of study had taken a majority of Academic courses in Grades 9/10. The relationship between other Grade 9/10 and 11/12 programs of study are not as strong. Slightly less than two thirds of students taking College courses had earlier taken Applied courses, while slightly over a third had taken Academic courses. Over three quarters of students taking Mixed courses in Grades 11-12 had taken Academic courses in Grades 9-10 (see Brown, 2009).
R04(Demographic Data\2008-09\ExamPostSec17YrOld07\PostSec07Final)rb.3457 27
FUTURE DIRECTIONS Preliminary research (e.g., Brown, 2006) has indicated that two thirds of students who start in
Grade 9 will end up taking some sort of post-secondary education. However, the pathways to
post-secondary education are complex. Examination of secondary Mathematics courses taken
by first-year Mathematics students in Greater Toronto Area (GTA) colleges have found these
students had literally hundreds of combinations of Grade 9-12 Mathematics courses – with well
over a hundred more frequently-chosen combinations. Likewise, students apply to both college
and university over multiple years as high school students, and will also apply and/or reapply as
adult students. The information on one application cycle of 17 year olds as shown here is
necessarily limited, in that it only shows one progression (the 2007 applications cycle).
Following the Grade 9 cohort of 2006-07 over time will provide a greater wealth of detail on this
complex subject5.
As with the earlier report looking at Grade 7-10 achievement (Brown and Sinay, 2008), this
analysis examines relationships between variables, without being able to attribute which of
these variables are causal factors. Attributing cause in highly related variables can be difficult,
and in fact, the journey promises to be long and challenging. Some recent research shows
possible directions. Anisef et al (2008) examined an earlier TDSB cohort, those who started
Grade 9 in Fall 2000, focusing on immigration characteristics. Using an HLM analysis, it was
found that many of the factors outlined above played an important role in graduation over six
years: region of birth, neighborhood income, Grade 9-10 program of study, gender, and parental
presence at home.
However, the relationships of regions of birth were complex. For example, when all available
variables were included, achievement of students born in East Asia, South Asia, and Africa were
significantly higher than the Canadian-born population. However, students born in the English-
speaking Caribbean were not statistically different from the Canadian-born population once
these other factors were taken into account – since Caribbean-born students were more likely to
take non-Academic courses, have lower credit accumulation, live in lower income areas, and be
more likely to live in one-parent households. This research needs to be supplemented – it
looked only at dropout rather than post-secondary access, for example, and did not have some
of the key variables present in the Student Census.
5 The more comprehensive nature of a cohort study may help resolve another challenge. Our analysis of self-described sexual orientation has found an inconsistent relationship to student achievement. For example, self-described LGBTQ students were more at-risk in the initial Grade 9 cohort study than with Grade 10 results (Brown and Sinay, 2008, 2). Due to this inconsistency, we have not examined sexual orientation in terms of 17 year old applicants in the 2007 application cycle; instead, we are looking at the cohort study and multiple years of applications to provide a more complete picture.
R04(Demographic Data\2008-09\ExamPostSec17YrOld07\PostSec07Final)rb.3457 28
A final proviso is that the information here provides a broad range of ‘standard’ variables than in
earlier studies, but the Student Census has even greater possibilities through examining student
attitudes and participation in the secondary school culture (e.g., attitudes towards school, school
safety issues). We are in the midst of analyzing these environmental variables.
R04(Demographic Data\2008-09\ExamPostSec17YrOld07\PostSec07Final)rb.3457 29
REFERENCES Anisef, P., Brown, R.S., Phythian, K., Sweet, R., & Walters, D. (2008). Early School Leaving
Among Immigrants in Toronto Secondary Schools. Metropolis Working Paper No. 67. Toronto:
CERIS. Retrieved in March 2009 from
<http://ceris.metropolis.net/Virtual%20Library/WKPP%20List/WKPP2008/CWP67.pdf>
Brown, R. S. (2006). The TDSB Grade 9 Cohort Study: A Five-Year Analysis 2000-2005.
Toronto: Research and Information Services, TDSB.
Brown, R. S. (2009). The Grade 9 Cohort of Fall 2002: A Five-Year Cohort Study, 2002-2007.
Toronto: Research and Information Services, TDSB.
Brown, R. S., & Sinay, E. (2008). The 2006 Student Census: Linking Demographic Data with
Student Achievement. Toronto: Research and Information Services, TDSB.
King, A. (2005). Double Cohort Study: Phase 4 Report. Toronto: Ministry of Education.
Retrieved in March 2009 from
<http://www.edu.gov.on.ca/eng/document/reports/phase4/report4.pdf>
Yau, M. & O'Reilly, J. (2007). The 2006 Student Census, Grades 7-12: System Overview.
Toronto: Research and Information Services, TDSB.
York-Seneca Institute for Mathematics, Science, and Technology Education (2008). College
Mathematics Project 2007. Toronto: Seneca College of Applied Arts and Technology. Retrieved
in March 2009 from
<http://collegemathproject.senecac.on.ca/cmp/pdf/CMP2007_Final_Report_19Feb08.pdf>
R04(Demographic Data\2008-09\ExamPostSec17YrOld07\PostSec07Final)rb.3457 30
R04(Demographic Data\2008-09\ExamPostSec17YrOld07\PostSec07Final)rb.3457 31
What do Confirmations Miss Compared to Registrations and Applications? Because we had information from all three phases up to the 2005 applications cycle, we can
provide an approximation. Most students who confirm an offer will enroll, but some will not and
some students without confirmations will enroll (students who somehow did not send the
confirmations back, were on a 'shortlist' or were told of admission just before school begins).
Generally, about 75% of TDSB students who apply will confirm offers of admission, and about
71% will actually enroll.
Both confirmations and registrations miss the students who go to a university or college outside
the province (e.g. McGill, University of British Columbia, and Dalhousie). We used to receive
information on who applied to these out-of-Ontario institutions and were able to extrapolate that
2-3% of 17 year old students would go outside Ontario, (they show up as applicants because
OUAC sends student marks to these post-secondary institutions). These missing out-of-Ontario
students are concentrated in a small number of more socio-economically advantaged schools,
and hence we do not release confirmation and registration data at the school level: the TDSB
Secondary Success Indicators focus on applications. For general TDSB-level trends,
confirmations are a more useful variable than applications, since confirmations provide a close-
to-complete picture of post-secondary success.
Date of Comparison
In the TDSB Secondary Success Indicators (post-secondary applications), we use status of
students as of March 31 (e.g. for the 2007 application cycle, 17 year old students in the TDSB
as of March 31, 2007). This is the best fit with the post-secondary applications cycle, since
students apply in late winter-early spring. However, because our focus is the 2006 Student
Census data, we have a slightly better match rate (73%) if we use students present as of
October 31, 2006, which was when the Census was conducted. A couple of hundred 17 year
old students left between October 31, 2006 and March 31, 2007. Therefore, we look at students
present as of October 31, 2006, for the purpose of Confirmation data for this 2007 cycle.
What about 18-21 year old students?
The match rate with the Student Census was much lower among 18-21 year olds (56%) than with
17 year old students (73%). Since the characteristics of students not participating in the Census
were different (more at-risk) than those participating, looking at some of the Census variables
among this older age group could be potentially problematic.
APPENDIX A
R04(Demographic Data\2008-09\ExamPostSec17YrOld07\PostSec07Final)rb.3457 32
What about students who did not apply in 2007?
Students will apply in multiple school years: many students who did not apply in 2007 (or are
unsuccessful) will apply again in 2008 or 2009. We know this from our TDSB Grade 9 cohort
studies; the best way to look at multiple post-secondary application years for the Student
Census is to follow the Grade 9 cohort of Fall 2006 for the three years of Grade 12 (i.e., the
2011, 2012 and 2013 applications cycles). This is already planned as part of our Grade 9 cohort
studies/Student Census analyses.
R04(Demographic Data\2008-09\ExamPostSec17YrOld07\PostSec07Final)rb.3457 33