--~ - .... ~ .· ·.~,: _.,

REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES GOVERNMENT SERVICE INSURANCE SYSTEM

FINANCIAL CENTER, ROXAS BOULEVARD, PASAY CITY

BOARD OF TRUSTEES

IN THE MATTER OF THE CLAIM FOR DIVIDENDS, RESUMPTION OF LOAN PRIVILEGES, INSURANCE, RETIREMENT, PENSION, DEATH, SURVIVORSHIP AND FUNERAL BENEFITS AND DAMAGES FOR PNR EMPLOYEES

RODOLFO V. DELA ROSA, BENJAMIN T. GUINTO, JAIME S. OBLIGACION, RODOLFO P. VAVARRO, AURELIO CAL VELO, JR., ADOLFO D. PARAYNO, RODOLFO S. ZARCO, JACINTO S. MANALO, BRIGIDO B. DIZON, HENRY T. REYES, ARTURO E. BRAZA, SR., ROLANDO 0. JAURIGUE, EDUARDA B. MALIG, FELIXBERTO P. VILLAMOR, PEDRO T. ERANDO, CRISTOBAL G. CODINA and CORSINO C. ARCEGA, represented by his daughter BERNADETTE G. ARCEGA,

Petitioners.

GSIS CASE NO. 006-05

}(-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------}(

RESOLUTION

Before this Board is a Petition filed by Petitioners, RODOLFO

V. DELA ROSA, ET AL., on 12 May 2005, seeking the payment of

dividends, the resumption of loan privileges, the payment of

' - ... ' ·, •, ,

Page 2 of 8

In the Matter of the Claim for Dividends, Resumption of Loan Privileges, Insurance. Retirement, Pension. Death,

Survivorship and Funeral Benefits and Damages for PNR Employees, Rodolfo 11. De/a Rosa, et al., Petitioners

GSIS Case No. 006-05

insurance, retirement pension, death, survivorship and funeral

benefits, as well as damages for employees of the Philippine National

Railways (PNR).

Petitioners allege that despite the fact that their employer, the

PNR, regularly deducted from their respective monthly salaries their

GSIS premium contributions and notwithstanding Sections 8 1 and

41(w)2 of R.A. No. 8291, the then GSIS Caloocan District Office, the

Operating Unit Concerned (OUC) in this case, stopped the payment

of dividends and suspended the loan privileges of PNR Employees

starting sometime in 1991. They further claim that after their

retirement from the PNR, they applied for payment of their

insurance benefits but the OUC unjustifiably refused to pay the

same. The OUC allegedly refused to pay their retirement and

pension benefits as well. Moreover, when Petitioner Corsinio C.

Arcega died, the OUC allegedly refused to pay the death,

survivorship and funeral benefits to his beneficiaries.

1 SECfiON 8. Government Guarantee. -The government of the Republic of the Philippines hereby guarantees the fulfillment of the obligations of the GSIS to its members as and when they fall due.

2 SECfiON 41. Powers and Functions of the GSIS. - The GSIS shall exercise the following powers and functions:

XXX XXX XXX

(w) to ensure the collection or recovery of all indebtedness, liabilities and/or accountabilities, including unpaid premiums or contributions in favor of the GSIS arising from any cause or source whatsoever, due from all obligors, whether public or private. The Board shall demand payment or settlement of the obligations referred to herein within thirty (30) days from the date the obligation becomes due, and in the event of failure or refusal of the obligor or debtor to comply with the demand, to initiate or institute the necessary or proper actions or suits, criminal, civil or administrative or otherwise, before the courts, tribunals, commissions, boards, or bodies of proper jurisdiction within thirty (30) days reckoned from the expiry date of the period fixed in the demand within which to pay or settle the account;

.. ' : .. ' · ....... Page 3 of 8

In the Matter of the Claim for Dividends, Resumption of Loan Privileges, Insurance, Retirement, Pension, Death,

Survivorship and Funeral Benefits and Damages for PNR Employees, Rodolfo V. DeJa Rosa, et al., Petitioners

GSIS Case No. 006·05

Petitioners claim to have been deprived of the social protection

and the benefits guaranteed by the Philippine Government under

Section 8 of R.A. No. 8291. Despite repeated representations, verbal

and written demands, the OUC continued to refuse to grant to the

Petitioners the benefits they were claiming. Hence, the filing of the

Petition.

After summons was served, the OUC filed its Answer

contending that the mandate of the GSIS to provide the necessary

protection to its members is linked to the payment of the monthly

premium obligations of its members. This led to GSIS' adoption of

the "Premium Based Policy". As of 31 May 2005, the PNR had

incurred compulsory premium arrearages for the period December

1988 to April 2005, in the amount of ONE BILLION 1WO HUNDRED

NINE1Y-FOUR MILLION 1WEN1Y 1WO THOUSAND 1WO

reason of PNR' s compulsory premium arrearages and pursuant to

the "Premium Based Policy", the OUC had valid and legal bases not

to pay the retirement claims and other social insurance benefits of

the Petitioners.

A preliminary conference was held on 15 August 2005. The

parties, through their respective counsels, were then required to file

and serve upon the other party their pre-hearing briefs. Briefs for

3 Paragraph 12 of the Answer filed by the OUC.

.. . . . .. • .. Page 4 of8

ln the Matter of the Claim for Dividends, Resumption of Loan Privileges, Insurance, Retirement, Pension, Death,

Survivorship and Funeral Benefits and Damages for PNR Employees, Rodolfo V. DeJa Rosa, et al., Petitioners

GSIS Case No. 006-05

the Petitioners and the OUC were filed on 22 August 2005 and 23

August 2005, respectively.

On 28 June 2006, the Hearing Officer received Atty. Rogelio B.

De Guzman's withdrawal as counsel for the Petitioners. No other

counsel entered his/her appearance for the Petitioners thereafter.

As there were no further motions, pleadings or

communications received from the Petitioners for the succeeding

years, the new Hearing Officer, in an Order4 dated 01 April 2009,

directed the Petitioners to express their interest to pursue the case

by filing their position paper within fifteen (15) days from receipt

thereof, otherwise he would dismiss the case for failure to prosecute.

Having received no position paper or any response whatsoever

from the Petitioners, individually or as a group, the Hearing Officer,

on 29 June 2009, issued an Order 5 considering the Petition

withdrawn for Petitioners' lack of interest to prosecute. Petitioners

did not file any other pleading after the issuance of the same.

Further, upon verification with the NCRl Department6, the

department presently handling the claims of PNR employees, it was

determined that all of the benefits due the Petitioners have already

been paid to them 7 •

4 Copy attached as Annex "A". 5 Copy attached as Annex "B". 6 Beginning November 2013 7 The listing of benefits paid to the petitioners, as provided by the NCR I, is attached as Annex "C".

. ' Page 5 of8

In the Matter of the Claim for Dividends, Resumption of Loan Privileges, Insuran ce, Retirement, Pension, Death,

Survivorship an d Funeral Benefits and Damages for PNR Employ ees, Rodolfo V. DeJa Rosa, et al., Petitioners

GSIS Case No. 006-05

In view of the settlement of all the claims of the Petitioners,

the petition has been rendered moot and academic. A case becomes

moot and academic when there is no more actual controversy

between the parties or no useful purpose can be served in passing

upon the merits. 8 A moot and academic case is one that ceases to

present a justiciable controversy by virtue of supervening events, so

that a declaration thereon would be of no practical use or value.

Generally, courts decline jurisdiction over such case or dismiss it

on ground of mootness. 9

In this case, considering that the claims of the Petitioners have

already been settled, the case ceases to present a justiciable

controversy and a declaration thereon would be of no practical value.

It becomes incumbent upon this Board, inherent in its power to

adjudicate, to dismiss the case motu propio for being moot and

academic.

Moreover, due to Petitioners' lack of interest to prosecute the

present petition and the absence of any pleading filed by Petitioners

after their pre-hearing brief, it is but proper under the circumstances

for the Board to dismiss the petition.

8 Quiiio, et al. vs. Comelec, et al., G.R. No. 197466, 13 November 2012; Enrile vs. Senate Electoral Tribunal, G.R. No. 132986, 19 May 2004; PNB vs. CA , G.R. No. 121251, 26 June 1998. 9 Magdalo Para sa Pagbabago vs. Comelec, G.R. No. 190793, 19 June 2012; Funa vs. Executive Secretary Ermita, G.R. No. 184740, 11 February 2010; David vs. Macapagal-Arroyo, 522 Phil. 705 (2006).

• • .. f I ,..

DECISION

Page6of8 In the Matter of the Claim for Dividends, Resumption of Loan Privileges, Insurance, Retirement, Pension, Death,

Survivorship and Funeral Benefits and Damages for PNR Employees, Rodolfo V. DeJa Rosa, et al., Petitioners

GSJS Case No. 006-05

WHEREFORE, considering that all the claims of the

Petitioners have been paid to them, the case is DISMISSED for being

moot and academic.

SO ORDERED.

Pasay City, Philippines, --------------------2 6 MAR 2014

IEL L. LACSON, Jr.

ERTG.~ARA ice Chairman

Chairman

ROMEO M. ALIP Trustee Trustee

iL GERALDINE MARIE BERBERABE-MARTINEZ

Trustee

FRANCISCO T. DUQUE nr Trustee

• Did not participate in the discussion

Trustee

. ~ . . . ; ..

Copy furnished:

RODOLFO V. DELA ROSA PNR Compound, Tayuman Tondo, Manila

BENJAMIN T. GUINTO No. 40 Aluminio St. Tugatog, Malabon City

JAIME S. OBLIGACION Bgy. Manguisan Lopez, Quezon

RODOLFO P. VAVARRO No. 04 7 Municipal Cite Calamba City

AURELIO CALVELO, JR. San Vicente, Gumaca Quezon

ADOLFO D. PARAYNO Dinalaoen Riverside Calasiao, Pangasinan

RODOLFO S. ZARCO No. 850 Argueros St. Tondo, Manila

JACINTO S. MANALO PNR Compound, Tayuman Tondo, Manila

BRIGIDO B. DIZON San Fernando City

HENRY T. REYES No. 12 Felipe St. Chrysanthemum Village San Pedro, Laguna

ARTURO E. BRAZA, SR. No. 419 San Pedro St., Isabel Village Tabang, Plaridet Bulacan

ROLANDO 0. JAURIGUE Bgy. Buensoceso, Gumaca Quezon

Page 7 of8 In the Matter of the Claim for Dividends, Resumption of Loan Privileges, Insurance. Retirement. Pension, Death,

Survivorship and Funeral Benefits and Damages for PNR Employees, Rodolfo V. DeJa Rosa, et al., Petit:Joners

GSIS Case No. 006-05

. . . · ..

EDUARDA B. MALIG No. 226 Bry. Salumague Panique, Tarlac

FELIXBERTO P. VILLAMOR Block II, Lot 26 Soustone St. Palmera II, Taytay, Rizal

PEDRO T. ERANDO Bgy. Poblacion Tagkawayan, Quezon

CRISTOBAL G. CODINA Bgy. Poblacion Tagkawayan, Quezon

CORSINO C. ARCEGA No. 285 M. Crisostomo St. San Vicente, Malolos

LEGAL SERVICES GROUP GSIS Bldg. Financial Center, Pasay City

Page 8 of8 In the Matter of the Claim for Dividends, Resumption of Loan Privileges, Insurance, Retirement, Pension, Death,

Survivorship and Funeral Benefits and Damages for PNR Employees, Rodolfo V. DeJa Rosa, et al., Petitioners

GSIS Case No. 006-05

..

CERTIFICATION

Pursuant to Board Resolution No. 198-A of September 15, 2004, t ALEXEI P. CARDENAS, Attorney Vt Adjudication Department having been assigned to review the records and to prepare a draft Decision on the Petition filed by Rodolfo V. Dela Rosa, et al. in Board of Trustees Case No. 006-05 entitled "In the Matter of the Claim for Dividends, Resumption of Loan Privileges, Insurance, Retirement, Pension, Death, Survivorship and Funeral Benefits, and Damages for PNR Employees" hereby certify that the statement of facts herein stated and being presented before this Board is accurate and true, and are entirely based on the records of the case, the pleadings and other documents submitted by the parties.

This certification is issued in compliance with Board Resolution No. 198-A adopted on September 15, 2004.

____ , Pasay City. I

(};(v--e-L ~ AL~ E P. CARDENAS

Hearing Officer '

y

. .. . ·. '1:t+1{' f,/JNfiX ''A II

Republic of the Philippines GOVERNMENT SERVICE INSURANCE SYSTEM

.Pasay City, Metro Manila

BOARD OF TRUSTEES

RODOLFO v. DEIA ROSAI ET. AL.I Petitioners,

-versus-

MARILOU GARCIA

GSIS CASE NO. 006-05

In her official capacity as Manager of The Caloocan District Office of the GSIS,

Responde·nt. ){---------- - --- -------------------------------------------------------------~---------------------){

0 R D E R

. The petitioners are hereby directed to· express their interest

to pursue this case by filing their position. paper within 15 days from

receipt hereof., otherwise, the undersigned shall be constrained to

dismiss the Petition.

Issued this 1 sl day of April 2009 at Pasay City.

CC:

RODOLFO V. DELAROSA PNR Compound, Tayuman Tondo, Manila

BENJAMIN T. GUINTO · No. 40 Aluminio St., Tugntog, Malabon City

_..--.----------

ce·

JAIMES. OBLIGACION Bgy .. Manguisian. Lopez, Quezon

RODOLFO P. NAVARRO No. 04 7 Municipal Cite Calamba City

AURELIO CALVELO, JR. San Vicente, Gumaca Quezon ·

ADOLFO D. PARAYNO Dinalaoen Riverside, Calasiao, Pangasinan

RODOLFO S. ZARCO No. 850 Argueros St., Tondo, Manila

JACINTO S. MANALO PNR Compound, Tayuman Tondo, Manila

BRIGIDO B. DIZON San Fema,ndo City

HENRY T. REYES No. 12 Felipe St. , Chrysanthemon Village San Pedro, Laguna

ARTURO E. BRAZA, SR. No. 419 San Pedro St. , Isabel Village Tabang, PlarideL Bulacan

ROLANDO 0 . JAURIGUE Bgy. Buensoceso, Gumaca Quezon

EDUARDA B. MALIG No. 226 Bgy. salumague Panique, Tarlac

FELIXBERTO P. VILLAMOR Block U Lot 26 Soustone St., Palmera II, Taytay, Rizal

PEDRO T. ERANDO, JR. Bgy. Poblacion Tagkawayan, Quezon

REGISTRV·RECEIPT. o:s· Po8t ort(C:·e;- : -:-.~-------·.- .. -::-· ·--::-=-- -:-~

' . .. .) -~,.t.a.U u~ l '~o.., :.. r- ~·t'" .

Letteri, .. ~I~~~--~!=-!. -~_cw. ~~;~~-.w· .--_-.--~-~ . ...1.-.-

0-

4'-t-

.. Posta ~~··~ ·.M~ii (\~-· ~. ~:·1 'Postrzi S,~uop

. Leaorrecka?·~~ .. :~.~; cd tv1 a i I : I REGISTRY RECEIPT

. :~~~a!Sfar,·'Rec~l;ori----. . . · ·~ .h·- ·.~L>:.~Jil t dtal Sratioa 0 Poet Olfice ,. :· ~ ~~ -' -~ ';; ;:•::d M. a i 1 ·1

L~tl,/~ackade-~~.! l 4f' · . ---J · J Poat .d ~~ · · "" dbM'>,. ..

. . REGISTRY RECE!PT .

Pool Orfk::e;

AEGISTRY·RECEIPT. . ·--..... .

I. ''iA ~l~---;:--:---·---· Poet or,~_' .ll:i ~ o.r Atnil Po;:t;ol Sial.ion t:.oner/ffaelua~.J}_if9:s~ered i~z-iJ4 f

AEGiSJ RY RE_CEIPT

to t

--Post P'8M 1i\J ~x-tF;-f;· r,;~:::?~~--,..--_:._~ . Lettff/Pac~-zno· N~ . sw . ostal Sraiion

t.Y¥2Jat - . . .

REGISTRY RECEIPT 12 Po&t~~~l I' -r- • p 1 C -:--r ... s,.t er A:n:tost,, Jralioo . . ·- ~ ·-· . . .. " · I

· .,.~8~GISTAY RECEIPT. "t ._ . .... ..._~ 1

·' ~A1 r.~-(1 .. · --- 3 Poat o~lce··· ·1:':~ 1 0.1 A.sm Postal 'StatioD.'

j • ·~ ..... ;;:. : ' l • - c (.J ........ :u l,.~tterl7ackag(Nii ---:-.:______, . . Po-=•-..,.. · - . .

- .. . . . ...

r

~-

CRISTOBAL G. CODINA Bgy. Poblacion Tagkawayan, Quezon

CORSINIO C. ARCEGA No. 285 ~- Crisostomo St. , San Vicente, Malolos

. ..

REGISTRY RECEIPT ~ ... ~--· -----:

rJi!\tlr~~i:.r~~~~-t~.~Stati~ l tothu e "':· !? L" ......... -::-JI:P __:;~...:_.. .

EQISTk• • ·---!PT ·

Poet a e------.. . . . . ·. .

\]. 11

S!J~M. cf PJ;ia Post&! Stati;;L :Po$~~d n . R.eg1S·r red Maiio_. -1-----

Proaorv this r

ft''.

''

.. ··

... .

•I

·"

,..

·' :•

r Republic of the Philippines

GOVERNMENT SERVICE INSURANCE SYSTEM Pasay City, Metro Manila

RODOLFO V. DELA ROS~ ET. AL., Petitioners,

-versus-

MARILOU GARCIA In ·her offlciaJ capacity as Manager of The Caloocan District Office of the GSIS,

Respondent. ·

GSIS CASE NO. 006-05

){------------------------------------------------------~-----------------~------------------------){

ORDER

Inasmuch as this Peti~on has been pending since 2005, .an

Order was issued on 1 April 2009 directing the petitioners to

express their intere_st to pursue this case by filing their position

paper· within 1.5 days from receipt thereat otherwise, the

undersigned Hearing Officer shall be constrained to dismiss the

Petition.

As of this date, the petitioners have not submitted their

position paper despite the fact that each one of them were

furnished a copy of said Order of 1 April 2009 at their respective

given address.

This being the case, the undersigned is constrained to

consider this Petition withdrawn for lack of interest to prosecute

the same.

SO ORDERED.

Issued this 29th day ~f june 2009 at Pasay City, Metro

Manila.

CC:

RODOLFO V. DELAROSA PNR Compound, Tayuman Tondo, Manila

BENJAMIN T. GUINTO No. 40 Aluminio St.,_ Tugatog, Malahon City

JAIME S. OBLIGACION Bgy., Manguisian, Lopez, Quezon

RODOLFOP.NAVARRO No .. 047 Municipal Cite Calamba City

AURELIO CALVELO,JR. San Vicente, ·"G~maca Quezon ·

ADOLFO D. PARAYNO Dinalaoen Riverside, Calasiao, Pangasinan

RODOLFO S. ZARCO No. 850 Argueros St., Tondo, Manila

JACINTO S. MANALO PNR Compound, Tayuman Tondo, -Manila

BRIGIDO B. DIZON San Fernando City

HENRY T. REYES No. 12 Felipe St., Chrysanthemon Village San Pedro, Laguna

ARTURO E. BRAZA, SR. No. 419 San Pedro St., Isabel Village Tabang, Plaridel, Bulacan

ROLANDO 0. JAURIGUE Bgy. Buensoceso, Gumaca Q!Jezon

EDUARDA B. MALIG No. 226 Bgy. salumague Panfque, Tarlac

FELIXBERTO P. VILLAMOR Block II Lot 26 Soustone St., Palmera II, Taytay, Rizal

PEDRO T. ERANDO, JR. -Bgy. Poblacion Tagkawayan, Quezon

CRISTOBAL G. CODINA Bgy. Poblacion Tagkawayan, Quezon

CORSINIO C. ARCEGA No. 285 M~ Crisostomo St., San Vicen~e, Malolos

f - . . . .

. . - Cardenas, Alexei P.

From: Sent: To: Cc: Subject: Attachments:

SIR,

Calida, Lanie C. Friday, January 03, 2014 3:37 PM Cardenas, Alexei P. Lagua, Flawrence Lovely L. FW: UPDATED_PNR_employees DELAROSA BOARD CASE_Ol032014.xlsx UPDATED_PNR_employees DELAROSA BOARD CASE_Ol032014.xlsx

Please see updated file for PNR employees (latest -with highlight).

Thank you.

1

,

HO - mmqp MAllE~~-=- •...MJ~1L ~ ----

-~ Jt.HECifNO. .......... ........ ~DATE ----- ~ "'P""~ 'I'IIS-..c>./ ~lURKS .. - - ....:..

1 RODOLFO V. DELA ROSA 2000966436 CSVCLAIM not available in the System not available in the System 8,440.98 TMS not yet available RETIREMENT CLAIM %A399260 05/22/2007 699.576.96 TMS not yet available RECOMPREnREMENTCLAIM %A110282 03/0712008 17,087.40 TMS not yet available RECOMP REnREMENT CLAIM 0000000583071 05/2212010 17,531.22 R-20091121-000212 RECOMP REnREMENT CLAIM 0000000806700 05/10/2011 12,628.94 R-20110209~9 REFUND PIA 0000609981 07/14/2011 23,834.80 R-201 00921-000032 REFUND PIA 0000565081 07/03/2012 23,834.80 R-2011 0913-000052

2 BENJAMIN T. GUINTO 2000853829 CSVCLAIM not available in the System not available in the System 7,208.79 TMS not yet available RETIREMENT CLAIM %A399240 05/18/2007 387,823.82 TMS not yet available REFUND PIA 0000420232 11/06/2012 23,026.92 R-20120716-000063

3 JAIMES. OBUGACION 2000887443 MATURITY CLAIM ZERO PROCEEDS ZERO PROCEEDS ZERO PROCEEDS TMS not yet available REnREMENT CLAIM %A399298 05!28/2007 587,627.40 TMS not yet available RECOMP RETIREMENT CLAIM 100001851043 06/23/2010 4,583.05 TMS-20100717.021180 REFUND PIA 0000510940 10/03/2012 22,907.68 R-20101112-000184

4 RODOLFO P. NAVARRO 2000965198 MATURITY CLAIM ZERO PROCEEDS ZERO PROCEEDS ZERO PROCEEDS TMS NOT YET AVAILABLE RETIREMENT CLAIM %A399249 05/21/2007 453,304.97 TMS NOT YET AVAILABLE RECOMP RETIREMENT CLAIM 0000000963544 12/19/2011 77,089.56 R-20110223-000020 REFUND PIA 0000420397 11/15/2012 44,399.31 R-20120622-000220

5 AUREUO V. CALVELO 2001072021 MATURITY CLAIM ZERO PROCEEDS ZERO PROCEEDS ZERO PROCEEDS TMS not yet available RETIREMENT CLAIM %A399294 05!28/2007 181,573.82 TMS not yet available

6 ADOLFO D. PARAYNO 2001058081 CSVCLAIM ZERO PROCEEDS ZERO PROCEEDS ZERO PROCEEDS TMS not yet available RETIREMENT CLAIM %A399241 05/18/2007 297,611.10 TMS not yet available RECOMP RETIREMENT CLAIM %A112282 03/31/2008 35,312.40 TMS not yet available REFUND PIA 0001317642 07/19/2013 24,862.68 R-20111017-000209

1 ~~S7'ZAi~d>' · - .. ~ MATURITY CLAIM ZERO PROCEEDS ZERO PROCEEDS ZERO PROCEEDS TMS not yet available RETIREMENT CLAIM %A399243 05/18/2007 730,005.78 TMS not yet available RECOMP RETIREMENT CLAIM 0000001316553 07/24/2013 22,335.71 R-20130327-000056 REFUND PIA - - ~- -·---- 0001387170

~

~'tL :-- - 5§:;182.28 ~R'-20130~~ = - - - - - ..

8JACI~S~~O "lOOO&Qli 11 MATURITY CLAIM ZERO PROCEEDS ZERO PROCEEDS ZERO PROCEEDS TMS not yet available RETIREMENT CLAIM ZERO PROCEEDS ZERO PROCEEDS ZERO PROCEEDS TMS not yet available RECOMP RETIREMENT CLAIM 0000000698664 11/02/2010 277,372.25 R-20100524-000232 REFUND PIA 0000564739 06/01/2012 32,295.37 R-20110512-000155 AOJIRECOMfiR~Etn., - " ~~CfPROCEEOS : ZeRO~ "'f.J:r:-'~Fio P!Q.CEE~ A-20f366~Wih~llgned~bef ---REFUND SALARY LOAN 0001304896 06/22/2013 19,439.65 R-20130620-000094

9 BRJGIDO B. DIZON 2000854001 CSVCLAIM not available in the System not available in the System 551.22 TMS not yet available RETIREMENT CLAIM %A399224 05/11/2007 287,126.03 TMS not yet available RECOMP RETIREMENT CLAIM 0000001140654 10/25/2012 66,803.21 PAM-20120626-000038

10 H~iJ._~ 'I 20001164907 MATURITY CLAIM ZERO PROCEEDS ZERO PROCEEDS ZERO PROCEEDS TMS not yet available RETIREMENT CLAIM %A399229 05/16/2007 708,478.63 TMS not yet available RECOMP RETIREMENT CLAIM 0000001316556 07/24/2013 1,858.71 R-201 20716-0001 14 f!.f;FUNO PtA

n ;:::::;:: ~-;;:: ·.::.ooot~~tee TW5!2Qj3 = ~::=-.-;.- <16,;!58.82 R:20120D6'000208;~~Relllas8d ::J'li!h.:L-~ ..... ~ ...:.ti-lt

...

' . 11 ARTURO E. BRAZA 2001070360 MATURITY CLAIM ZERO PROCEEDS ZERO PROCEEDS ZERO PROCEEDS TMS not yet available

RETIREMENT CLAIM %A399301 05/2812007 576,944.26 TMS not yet available ADJ/RECOMP LIFE 0000157893 11/26/2011 34,003.50 R-20091006~183

12 ROlANDO 0. JAURIGUE 2000969334 MATURITY CLAIM ZERO PROCEEDS ZERO PROCEEDS ZERO PROCEEDS TMS not yet available RETIREMENT CLAIM %A399261 05/22/2007 881,294.71 TMS not yet available RECOMP RETIREMENT CLAIM 0000000591003 07/16/2010 254.89 R-20091114~76

13 EDUARDA B MALIG 2001053963 CSVCLAIM ZERO PROCEEDS ZERO PROCEEDS ZERO PROCEEDS TMS not yet available •marned name - Eduarda Maqayaga RETIREMENT CLAIM 'lbA399223 05/11/2007 464,907.12 TMS nol yet ava1lable

RECOMP RETIREMENT CLAIM 0000001315952 07/20/2013 74,981 .48 R-20110813-000262 REFUND PIA 0001304554 06/19/2013 20,747.77 R·20110822~393

14 FEUXBERTO P. VlLLAMOR 2000859950 CSVCLAIM DEFICIT CLAIM DEFICIT CLAIM DEFICIT CLAIM TMS not yet available RETIREMENT CLAJM %A399242 05/18/2007 307,163.77 TMS not yet available RECOMP RETIREMENT CLAIM 0000000779836 02/21/2011 31,693.22 R-20100616~51

15 PEDRO T ERANDIO, JR 2000923054 CSVCLAIM ZERO PROCEEDS ZERO PROCEEDS ZERO PROCEEDS TMS not yet ava1lable RETIREMENT CLAIM DB295446 10/17/2003 105.683.09 TMS not yet available RECOMP RETIREMENT CLAIM 'lbA432603 07/10/2007 294,50940 TMS not yet available RECOMP RETIREMENT CLAIM 0000000593883 08/17/2010 56.337.96 R·20091114 ·000243 REFUND PIA 00005103 08/17/2012 5,81658 R-20 1 00629-{)00077

CSVCLAIM not available In the System not available In the System 23,650.92 TMS not yet available 16 CRISTOBAL G. COOINA 2000854630 RETIREMENT CLAIM %A399286 05/25/2007 466,137.90 TMS not yet available

RECOMP RETIREMENT CLAIM 0000000583053 05/22/2010 24,374.46 R-20091121 .()()()()88

REFUND PIA 0001293652 05/31/2013 29.122.01 R-20110503~92

17 CORSINIO C. ARCEGA 2000854534 SURVIVORSHIP CLAIM not available In the System not available In the System 129,763.36 TMS not yet available FUNERAL BENEFITS not available In the System not available In the System 20,000.00 TMS not yet available

RESOLUTION NO. 34

BOARD MEETING NO. 6 26 MARCH 2014

Page 33

WHEREAS, a Petition was filed on 12 May 2005 before the GSIS Board of Trustees by Rodolfo V. Dela Rosa, et al ., docketed as GSIS Case No. 006-05, seeking th e payment of dividends, the resumption of loan privileges, the payment of insurance, retirement, pension, death, survivorship, and funeral benefits, as well as damages for employees of the Philippine National Railways (PNR); ~

OFFICIAL COPY

-·

BOARD MEETING NO. 6 26 MARCH 2014

Page 34

WHEREAS, pursuant to Section 30 of R.A. No. 8291, the GSIS has original and exclusive jurisdiction to settle any dispute arising from the application of the laws administered by the GSIS;

RESOLVED, to APPROVE and CONFIRM the Resolution in GSIS Case No. 006-05, entitled In the Matter of the Claim for Dividends, Resumption of Loan Privileges, Insurance, Retirement, Pension, Death, Survivorship and Funeral Benefits and Damages for PNR Employees, Rodolfo V. Dela Rosa, et al., Petitioners, the dispositive portion of which states:

"WHEREFORE, considering that all the claims of the Petitioners have been paid to them, the case is DISMISSED for being moot and academic.

"SO ORDERED."

A copy of the Resolution in GSIS Case No. 006-05 is attached and made an integral part of this Resolution.