M.Demestre
RESPONSE OF BENTHIC COMMUNITIES AND SEDIMENTTO DIFFERENT REGIMENS OF FISHING DISTURBANCE
IN EUROPEAN COASTAL WATERS
Proposal No: QLRT-2001-00787
RESPONSERESPONSE
M.Demestre
RESPONSERESPONSE QLRT-2001-787RESPONSERESPONSE QLRT-2001-787
Organisations
CSIC-RRD-ICM Barcelona, Spain Co-ordinator CSIC-MGG-ICM Barcelona, Spain http://www.cmima.csic.es/ http://www.cmima.csic.es/
Institut de Ciències del Mar –CMIMA Institut de Ciències del Mar –CMIMAPasseig Maritim de la Barceloneta 37-49 Passeig Maritim de la Barceloneta 37-4908003 Barcelona- Spain 08003 Barcelona- SpainPhone: 00 34 932309500 Fax: 0034 93230 95 55 Phone: 00 34 932309500 Fax: 0034 93230 95 55Co-ordinating scientist: Dr. Montserrat Demestre [email protected] Co-ordinating scientist: Dr. Albert Palanques [email protected]
IEO Murcia, Spain MSM, Alacant, Spain http://www.ieo.es/centros.html http://www.mediterraneoserviciosmarinos.com/
Centro Oceanográfico de Murcia Mediterráneo Servicios Marinos, S.L.Antigua Estación Marítima. Muelle de Levante s/n.Instituto Español de Oceanografía 03001 Alicante. Spain30740 Lo Pagán-San Pedro del Pinatar (Murcia) Phone: 00 34 965 202 201 Fax: 00 34 965 206 927c/ Varadero, 1 Co-ordinating scientist: Manuel MarhuendaPhone: 0034 968 18 05 00 Fax: 968 18 44 41 [email protected] Co-ordinating scientist: Dr. Julio Mas [email protected]
AWI, Bremerhaven, Germany UWB, Bangor, UK http://www.awi-bremerhaven.de/ http://www.sos.bangor.ac.uk/
Alfred-Wegener-Institut fuer Polar- und Meeresforschung School of Ocean Sciences,Sektion Vergleichende Ökosystemforschung University of Wales, BANGORColumbusstraße Postfach 120161 Menai BridgeD-27515 Bremerhaven Anglesey,Phone : 0049-471-4831-1734 Fax : +49-471-4831-1724 LL59 5EY, UKCo-ordinating scientist: Dr. Rainer Knust [email protected] Phone: 00 44 (0) 1248 382846 Fax: 00 44 (0) 1248 716367
Co-ordinating scientist: Dr. Michel J. Kaiser [email protected]
CIBM, Livorno, Italy http://www.cibm.it/
Centro Interuniversitario di Biologia MarinaPiazzale Mascagni, 157127 Livorno - ItalyPhone: 00 39 (0)586 807287 Fax: 00 39 (0)586 809 149Co-ordinating scientist: Anna Maria de Biasi [email protected]
M.Demestre
About the RESPONSE Project
RESPONSERESPONSE QLRT-2001-787
It is the aim of RESPONSE to improve our knowledge
of the direct and indirect consequences of trawling activities
and to understand the processes driving the loss of
biodiversity and ecosystem functioning
at the level of the European coastal waters.
M.Demestre
Objectives and expected achievements
RESPONSERESPONSE QLRT-2001-787
The main scientific objective of RESPONSE is to understand the effects of fishing perturbation on the seabed by considering different approaches:
Closed seasons and Closed areas. Cessation of fishing activity: exploited areas closed to fishing practices Areas that experience different regimens of fishing
disturbance. Different levels of fishing activity: high fishing activity and low fishing activity
M.Demestre
Objectives and expected achievements
RESPONSERESPONSE QLRT-2001-787
RESPONSE will offer an opportunity to provide new perspectives and management options to the CFP in order to achieve the sustainability of marine resources and protection of biodiversity on marine communities.
The results can be used in the development of a Common Fishery and Environment Policy in the implementation of fishing regulation. They can help clarify the potential effectiveness of: 1) using different time limited closure periods 2) the most appropriate level of fishing effort
M.Demestre
RESPONSERESPONSE QLRT-2001-787
Objectives
The specific research objectives of RESPPONSE:
1. To identify Appropriate Study Areas (ASA’s)
2. To estimate the fishing activity and fishing effort in the ASA’s during a whole year
( WP1)
M.Demestre
RESPONSERESPONSE QLRT-2001-787
Objectives The specific research objectives...
3. To analyse the physical and biological response of the benthic ecosystem to different regimens of fishing activity in the ASA’s
Multidisciplinary study considering physical and biological ( WP 2 and WP3)
4. To estimate the secondary production of suprabenthos and infauna in the ASA’s ( WP 4)
5. Synthesis and recommendations ( WP 5)
M.Demestre
RESPONSERESPONSE QLRT-2001-787
Workplan and methodology
The workplan is broken down into 6 workpackages. WP1-WP5 are multidisciplinary, interrelated, complementary and progressive WP6 is entirely devoted to the co-ordination and management of RESPONSE
The overall methodology used will consist mainly of: 1) preparation, organisation and review work2) exhaustive field work with a series of research cruises3) laboratory work based on the processing of the samples 4) analysis of the data
M.Demestre
RESPONSERESPONSE QLRT-2001-787
WPNo
Workpackage Responsible StartMonth
EndMonth
DeliverableNº.
1 Estimation of fishing activity and fishingeffort. Identification of the AppropriateStudy Areas (ASA’s)
MSM 2 28 2, 3, 4, 5,10, 21, 22
2 Response of the benthic communitiesand sediments to cessation of fisheryactivity
CIBM 4 33 7, 12, 17,22, 24
3 Response of the benthic communitiesand sediments to different levels offishing activity
CSIC- MGG 6 33 8, 13, 18, 22, 25
4 Secondary production AWI 4 33 9, 14, 19, 26
5 Synthesis and Recommendations UWB 11 35 15, 20, 27
6 Co-ordination and Management CSIC- RRD 0-1 36 1, 6,11,16,23 28, 29
M.Demestre
RESPONSERESPONSE QLRT-2001-787
Workpackages
WP1. Estimation of fishing activity and fishing effort. Identification of the Appropriate Study Areas (ASA’s).
•Experimental cruises will be performed to identify the ASA’s within which commercial trawl fleets regularly exploit target species.
•Four selected areas undergo heavy exploitation and different temporal fishing strategies. Control areas
M.Demestre
RESPONSERESPONSE QLRT-2001-787
Barcelona
Tarragona
L’Ametllade Mar
Sant Carlesde laRàpita
0º 30’ 1º 00’ 2º 00’1º 30’ E
41º 20’
41º 00’
40º 40’
40º 20’
N
Irish Sea
Mediterranean - Catalan Sea
Ancona
Senigallia
Fano
e tr l i tic S a
P saro
0
:600 00
N
EW
S
43°45' 43°45'
44°00' 44°00'
4 15
'
44°15'
13°00'
13 00'
13°15'
13°15'
13°30'
13°30'
13°45'
13°45'Mediterranean - Adriatic Sea
Ancona
Senigallia
Fano
Central Adriatic Sea
Pesaro
30
20
50
1:600000
N
EW
S
43°45 ' 43°45 '
44°00 ' 44°00 '
44°15 ' 44°15 '
13°00 '
13°00 '
13°15 '
13°15 '
13°30 '
13°30 '
13°45 '
13°45 '
M.Demestre
RESPONSERESPONSE QLRT-2001-787
Workpackages
WP1. Estimation of fishing activity and fishing effort. Identification of the Appropriate Study Areas (ASA’s).
• The spatial and temporal variability of different regimes and trawl activity in these ASA’s will be estimated
(i) Monitoring spatial distribution and temporal variability of the trawl fleet, (ii) Mapping trawl tracks and estimating fishing intensity(iii) Temporal variability of discards (iv) Linking fishing effort variability with physical changes on the seabed
• Historical data set of the spatial and temporal distribution of fish effort will be analysed to determine an average yearly pattern
M.Demestre
RESPONSERESPONSE QLRT-2001-787
Workpackages
Table I. Methodology of WP1Response AREA
ASA selected&
Monitoring techniques
Spatio-temporalfishing effort
1 year sampling
Variabilitydiscards
1year sampling
Partnerresponsible
North Sea Closure area: Pilot Wind FarmStart in March 200354ºN 7ºE
SSS, Video & photo
-Monitoring trawl fleetfrom ResearchPlatform in Pilot WindFarm (fortnightly)
- Side scan sonar *
4 – AWI
Irish Sea Fishing ground: different levelsof fishing activity54ºN 4ªE
SSS, Video & photo
-Fisheries statistics
-DEFRA Overflight (fortnightly)
- Side scan sonar *
5 – UWB
AdriaticSea
Fishing ground: closed season& different levels of fishingactivity44º50’N 13º15’E
SSS, Video & photo
-Monitoring trawl fleet(fortnightly)
-On board (7 samples during 1 year)-Fisheries statistics
- Side scan sonar *
-Monitoring trawl fleet-On board (7 samples during 1 year)
6 – CIBM
CatalanSea
Fishing ground: closed season& different levels of fishingactivity40º22’N 0º42’E
SSS, Video & photo
-Monitoring trawl fleet(fortnightly)
-On board (7 samples during 1 year)
-Fisheries statistics
- Side scan sonar *
-Monitoring trawl fleet-On board (7 samples during 1 year)
3 – MSM
(*) To estimate the fishing effort by side scan sonar 1km squared as standard surface unit has been selected.
M.Demestre
RESPONSERESPONSE QLRT-2001-787
Workpackages
WP2. Response of the benthic communities and sediment to cessation of fishery activity
The main objective is to study the response and recovery of both communities and sediments to different time periods of cessation fishing activity in real fishing grounds.
The North SeaThe Mediterranean Sea: Adriatic Sea and Catalan coast.
The physical issues: analysis of morphology, texture and composition of sediments, water turbidity
The biological issues: changes in the fish community, epifauna and infauna structure variability, and variations in the composition of discards.
M.Demestre
RESPONSERESPONSE QLRT-2001-787
Workpackages
Biological aspects WP2ResponseAREA
Experimentalcruises WP2
Partnerresponsible
North SeaC1 March’ 03C2 June’ 03C3 Sep’ 03C4 March ’04C5 June’ 04C6 Sep‘ 04
4 – AWI
Adriatic Sea
C1 July’03C2 August’03C3 August’03C4 August’03C5 Sep’03C6 Nov’03
6 – CIBM
Catalan Sea
C1 June’03C2 July’03C3 July’3C4 August’03C5 Sep’03C6 Nov’03
Infauna
5 replicates(3 or moresamplesdependingon benthoscommunity)
0.1 m2
van Veengrab
Epifauna
3 replicates
benthicdredge1 cmmesh/size
1.1– ICM-DRR
M.Demestre
RESPONSERESPONSE QLRT-2001-787
Workpackages
Physical aspects WP2AREA Experimental
cruisesResuspensioneffects
BottomSedimentGranulom& organiccontent
Partnersresponsible
NorthSea
AdriaticSea
CatalanSea
C1 March’03C2 June’03C3 Sep’03C4 March’04C5 June’ 04C6 Sep‘ 04
C1 July’03C2 August’03C3 August’03C4 Sept’03C5 Oct’03C6 Nov’03
C1 June’03C2 July’03C3 July’3C4 August’03C5 Sep’03C6 Nov’03
CTD+
waterturbidity
grids ofCTD
+transmissometer
+fluorometer
+water
samplingmoored current
meter+
turbidimeter
SSS(morphol
character)
+
5replicatesvan Veen
grab1-2 cmsurface
VerticaldistributionSediment
1-3 samplevertical core
(dependingspatial
variability)
slides eachcm the first
5 cmthen slideseach 5 cm
4 – AWI
6 – CIBM
1.2– ICM-MGG
M.Demestre
RESPONSERESPONSE QLRT-2001-787
Workpackages
WP3. Response of the benthic communities and sediment to different levels of fishing activity.
The aim of this WP is to determine the physical and biological response of both organism and sediments to different levels of fishing disturbance in real fishing grounds.
The Irish SeaThe Mediterranean Sea: Adriatic Sea and Catalan coast.
The physical issues: analysis of morphology, texture and composition of sediments, water turbidity
The biological issues: changes in the fish community, epifauna and infauna structure variability, and variations in the composition of discards.
M.Demestre
RESPONSERESPONSE QLRT-2001-787
Workpackages
Biological aspects WP3ResponseAREA
ExperimentalcruisesWP3
Demersal fishandinvertebrates
Partnersresponsible
Irish SeaHigh activityC1 Feb’ 03C3 Feb’ 04Low activityC2 August’ 03C4 August’ 04
5 – UWB
AdriaticSea
High activityC1 Jul’ 03C3 Sep’ 04Low activityC2 Mar’ 03C4 Mar’ 04
From commercialtrawls
6 – CIBM
CatalanSea
High activityC1 Dec ’02C3 Nov’ 03Low activityC2 June’ 03C4 June’ 04
Infauna
5 replicates
(3 or moresamplesdependingon benthoscommunity)
0.1 m2
van Veengrab
Epifauna
3 replicates
benthicdredge1 cmmesh/size
From commercialtrawls
1.1– ICM-DRR
M.Demestre
RESPONSERESPONSE QLRT-2001-787
Workpackages
Physical aspects WP3
AREA ExperimentalcruisesWP3
Resuspensioneffects
BottomSedimentGranulom& organiccontent
Partnersresponsible
IrishSea
AdriaticSea
CatalanSea
High activityC1 Feb’ 03C3 Feb’ 04Low activityC2 August’ 03C4 August’ 04
High activityC1 Jul’ 03C3 Sep’ 04Low activityC2 Mar’ 03C4 Mar’ 04
High activityC1 Dec’ 02C3 Nov’ 03Low activityC2 June’ 03C4 June’ 04
CTD+
waterturbidity
grids ofCTD
+transmissometer
+fluorometer
+water
samplingmooredcurrentmeter
+turbidimeter
SSS(morphol
character)
+
5replicatesvan Veen
grab1-2 cmsurface
VerticaldistributionSediment
1-3 samplevertical core(depending on
spatialvariability)
slides eachcm the first
5 cmthen slides
each 5 cm
5 – UWG
6 – CIBM
1.2–ICM-MGG
M.Demestre
RESPONSERESPONSE QLRT-2001-787
Timetable of cruisesOct 02 Jan 03 Jun 03 Jan 04 Jun 04 Sep 040-1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Part.
Mediterranean Sea – Catalan Sea WP2 Closed season
0-1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 C1 C2C3
C4 C5 13 C6 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 1.1, 1.2,2, and 3
WP3 high low high low0-1 C2
2C1 4 5 6 7 8 C2 10 11 12 13 C3 15 16 17 18 19 20 C4 22 23 24 1.1, 1.2, 2
, and 3
Mediterranean Sea – Adriatic Sea WP2 Closed season
0-1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 C1 C2C4
C5 13 C6 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 6 , 3, 1.1and 1.2
WP3 low high high low0-1 2 33 4 5 C1 7 8 9 C2 11 C3 13 14 15 16 17 C4 19 20 21 22 23 24 6, 3, 1.1
and 1.2
North Sea WP2 Closure area
0-1 2 3 4 5 C1 7 8 C2 10 11 C3 13 14 15 16 17 C4 19 20 C5 22 23 C6 4, 3, 1.1and 1.2
Irish Sea WP3 high low high low
0-1 22 3 4 C1 6 7 8 9 10 C2 12 13 14 15 16 C3 18 19 20 21 22 C4 24 5 ,3, 1.1
M.Demestre
RESPONSERESPONSE QLRT-2001-787
Workpackages
WP 4. Estimation of secondary production of the lowest trophic levels.
WP 4 will estimate the effects of different fishing strategies on Secondary Production for swimming suprabenthos and infauna
The analyses will be carried out:• at the level of population structure (size-frequency) for target species representative of the studied community• on the whole community of organisms: changes in biomass and abundance
M.Demestre
RESPONSERESPONSE QLRT-2001-787
Workpackages
WP5. Synthesis and Recommendations
The main objective of this WP will be to bring together the working groups and to combine the results in the form of a synthesis.
It consists of an analysis of the synthesis and recommendations combined with the results from the North Sea, the Irish Sea and the Mediterranean Sea, and compare them with older data of fisheries, impact and benthos.
M.Demestre
RESPONSERESPONSE QLRT-2001-787
Workpackages
WP5. Synthesis and Recommendations
•Two basic and independent database are necessary to organise and bank the :
a) Historical and existing data: fishing, benthos and impact
b) Data generated by RESPONSE. The project will generate a large body of inter-related data.
M.Demestre
RESPONSERESPONSE QLRT-2001-787
Workpackages
WP5. Synthesis and Recommendations
The expected results will be very important to the EU. The combination of the results from the different geographical areas will generate information in support of recommendations of the CFP about the response of benthic communities and sediments to the same kind of disturbance produced by different regimens of trawl activity.
M.Demestre
RESPONSERESPONSE QLRT-2001-787
Workpackages
WP6. Co-ordination and Management.
This WP is fully devoted to the aspects of organisation, co-ordination and management: To improve the efficiency of project development To assure communication between the partners Organise steering and Co-ordination meetings Organise Workshops and Meetings to interface with end-users groups and policy-makers Produce a Final Report including management recommendations Dissemination of the results
M.Demestre
RESPONSERESPONSE QLRT-2001-787
Management structure.
WP1 (1.1, 1.2, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6) Identification of Appropriated Study Areas (ASA’s) Estimation of fishing activity and fishing effort.
WP2 (1.1,1.2,2,3, 4, 6)
Response tocessation offishing activity
WP3(1.1, 1.2, 2, 3, 5, 6)Response todifferent fishinglevels
WP4 (1.1, 2, 4, 6)
Secondaryproduction
WP5 (1.1, 1.2, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6) Synthesis and Recommendations
Exi
stin
g/hi
stor
ical
dat
a
WP 6 (1.1,1.2,2,3,4,5,6)
Co-ordination and Management
Fishingintensity
&
Impact
&
Benthos
M.Demestre
RESPONSERESPONSE QLRT-2001-787
“Informal Cluster” INTERACT Interaction between environment and fisheries
The sustainable management of fisheries can only be achieved by understanding all the effects of such fisheries on the environment. The informal cluster will promote interactions between scientists rather than research activities.
In order to achieve these aims the work plan of the cluster is fully devoted to organise: 1) meetings between the projects involved 2) an open conference or workshop, to which external scientists will be invited.
M.Demestre
RESPONSERESPONSE QLRT-2001-787
September 2003September 2003 Co-ordination Meeting RESPONSE 1st-3rd SeptemberFirst Internal Report
Organised by MSM, S.L. Alicante
Second Cluster Meeting 4Second Cluster Meeting 4thth & 5 & 5thth September September
March 2004March 2004
Internal Meeting RESPONSE 22nd & 23rd WS 1 RESPONSE 24th, 25th & 26th
Organised by CIBM PISA
First Cluster Workshop 25First Cluster Workshop 25thth/26/26thth March March
M.Demestre
RESPONSERESPONSE QLRT-2001-787
August/September 2004August/September 2004 Co-ordination Meeting 30th-31st Aug. & 1st Sep.Second Internal ReportOrganised by AWI Bremerhaven
January 2005January 2005 Internal Meeting RESPONSE 24th & 25th Second WS RESPONSE 26th, 27th & 28th Organised by UWB Bangor
Second Cluster Workshop 27Second Cluster Workshop 27thth/28/28thth January January
August/September 2005August/September 2005 Co-ordination & Public Meeting RESPONSEFinal Report
Organised by CSIC-ICM Barcelona