Date post: | 26-Dec-2015 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | amice-austin |
View: | 213 times |
Download: | 0 times |
Rise of Islamic Fundamentalis
m
Afghanistan
Key Events
History of Afghanistan
Afghanistan and the Cold War-The Soviets invaded Afghanistan in 1979 in order to support the Communist Partyrsquos push for power in the Country
-The opposing side was an Islamic Fundamentalist Osama Bin Laden being one of them group that was supported by the United States and Western Allies
-In 1989 the Soviet finally withdrew from Afghanistan
Afghanistan HistoryThe Soviet Union sent troops to Afghanistan to help the communist government there in a civil war
bull Then the Soviet Union invaded Afghanistan to set up a pro-Moscow government
bull For the next 9 years a civil war broke out with different tribes of Afghanistan against and with the Soviet forces
bull The Soviets pulled out in 1989 but they left a pro-Moscow government who fell with the Soviet Union in 1992
bull Over 1 million Afghans were killed 5 million Afghans fled to Pakistan and Iran
bull Another 2 million Afghans were displaced within the country
Russian Invasion
bull In the 1980s one out of two refugees in the world was an Afghan
bull Vital parts of the Afghan economy were destroyed including Irrigations systems to provide water for farming
Afghanistan HistoryThis led to a long war
between Soviet troops and Afghan rebels (Mujahedeen)
The United States was supporting the Afghan rebels
In 1989 an alliance of Afghan rebel groups took power and the Soviet troops left
The Talibanrsquos primary opposition was called the Northern Alliance and by 2001 the Northern Alliance had been pushed back to only 10 of Afghanistan to the north
Then as we all know the events of September 11th 2001
The United States knew that Osama Bin Laden was in Afghanistan and that we were going to go in there and get him
United States Invasion
bull In October of 2001 the United States invaded and in a short time by December of 2001 swept through and took control of the major cities and pushed the Taliban and Al Qaeda to the Pakistan-Afghanistan border and we helped to establish a new government that is in place today
Compare and contrast the Russian and United States invasions
Do in a T-Chart or a Venn Diagram
On your Left Side
In 1979 Afghanistan was invaded and eventually controlled by the Soviet Union
In 1989 Afghanistan and the Soviet Union signed a peace agreement
In 1995 the Taliban promising traditional Islamic values came into power imposing strict Islamic law including revoking many womenrsquos rights
In 2001 American troops force the Taliban from power
In 2004 Hamid Karzai became the first elected Afghan president
Late 1970s-2004
Taliban Rule
Gained strength in 1995 Formed by Sunni Muslim Pashtun students
intellectuals and disaffected Mujaheddin (holy warriors)
Trained in Pakistan fundamentalists committed to lsquoSharia Lawrsquo
(the traditional Islamic law and moral code that prescribes how Muslims should best conduct their lives)
Who is the Taliban
Under the Talibanrsquos rule human rights and civil liberties were slowly peeled away
bull The Taliban instituted cruel and inhumane treatment of those who opposed them in order to solidify their power over Afghanistanrsquos citizens
The Taliban (Talib is Arabic for lsquoIslamic studentrsquo)
Turmoil in Afghanistan continued and in the mid-1990rsquos a radical Muslim group called the Taliban arose
The Taliban took over most of Afghanistan and ruled strictly
The Taliban forced women to wear veils and stop working outside the home
Afghanistan History
Burka Fashion
AfghanistanTaliban came to
power in most Afghanistan by 1996
Osama bin Laden moved his terrorist activities there
Used mountain hideouts as a base of operations for his terrorist network called al-Qaeda
Map of Afghanistan in 1996 showing the amount of Taliban territory captured at that time (yellow) The Afghan Civil War commenced between 1996-2001 before coalition forces headed by the United States began air strikes against the Taliban
The TalibanPrior to 2001 the Taliban led by Mullah Mohammad Omar ruled Afghanistan under Islamic law
During this time women had virtually no rights and received no education
Watching television and listening to music were forbidden as were playing games and sports
The United States entered Afghanistan in October 2001 and replaced the Taliban with an elected president
While the Taliban lost some power and the people regained some rights the Taliban has not gone away
Instead it has worked to regain power by promising to help Afghanistanrsquos poorest people and aligning itself with warlords al-Qaida and other militant groups to gain financial support and recruit new fighters
Taliban Leader Mullah Mohammad Omar
Examples of abuses three men accused of a crime had been sentenced to death by being partially buried in the ground and then having a wall pushed over on them by a bulldozer a bizarre and labor-intensive form of execution dreamed up by the supreme leader of the Taliban
After another accused criminal was hanged his corpse was driven around the city swinging from a crane
A young woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man who was not her relative was stoned to death
On another occasion it was announced over the airwaves that 225 women had been rounded up and sentenced to a lashing for violating the dress code
When the Taliban castrated and then hanged the former communist president and his brother in 1996 they left their bloodied bodies dangling from lampposts in busy downtown Kabul for three days
Photographs of the corpses appeared in news magazines and newspapers around the world
Abuses of Power
The Taliban imposed their harsh brand of Islamic law in the 90 percent of Afghanistan under their control
The Taliban say their version of Islam is a pure one that follows a literal interpretation of the Muslim holy book The Koran
Under Taliban laws murderers were publicly executed by the relatives of their victims
Adulterers are stoned to death and the limbs of thieves were amputated
Lesser crimes were punished by public beatings
Taliban brought order and fundamental Islam at a price
19
Taliban executing a rebel on the spot
Dead bodies left in the street to rot by Taliban in Heart People forbidden to bury the bodies
Executions by the Taliban
20
There were almost weekly executions or amputations of criminals in the Kabul stadium before November 1999 when a woman was killed for hacking to death her abusive husband
The hiatus in public executions after that was attributed to a decline in crime in the capital
Public amputations amp executions
21
Rules for Everyone
No television No music No movies No picnics No wedding parties No New Year celebrations No kind of mixed-sex gathering No childrens toys including dolls and kites No card and board games No cameras No photographs and paintings of people and animals No pet parakeets No cigarettes and alcohol No magazines and newspapers and most books They even forbade applause -- a moot point since there was nothing left to
applaud The only books available must be approved by the Taliban Enemies of the Taliban are put in jail Protesting is not permitted All windows must be painted black so that no-one is able to see inside Photographs are illegal
Rules for Everyone
Bamyan Buddha before (left) After the explosion (right)
Taliban intolerant destruction of Historic Buddhist Religious Art
24
Taliban Draws World Attention
In 2001 blew up ancient Buddhist statues (1500 years old) near city of Bamiyan
Allowed al-Qaeda amp Osama bin Laden to operate within the countryTo give one an idea of scale note the
two individuals sitting herehttpwwwusatodaycomnewssciencearchaeology2001-03-22-afghan-buddhashtm
Treatment of Women under Taliban Rule
February 27 1998 --Thirty-thousand men and boys poured into the sports stadium in Kabul capital of Afghanistan Nuts biscuits and tea were sold to the waiting crowd
The scheduled entertainment They were there to see a young woman receive 100 lashes and to watch two thieves have their right hands amputated The woman had been arrested walking with a man who was not a relative a sufficient crime for her to be found guilty of adultery Since she was single it was punishable by flogging had she been married she would have been publicly stoned to death
As the young woman completely covered in the shroud-like burqa veil was forced to kneel and then whipped Taliban cheerleaders had the stadium ringing with the chants of onlookers
Among those present there were just three women the young Afghan and two female relatives who had accompanied her
The crowd fell silent only when the thieves were driven into the arena and pushed to the ground
Physicians using surgical scalpels promptly carried out the amputations Holding the severed hands aloft by the index fingers a grinning Taliban fighter warned the huge crowd These are the chopped-off hands of thieves the punishment for any of you caught stealingldquo
Then to restore the party atmosphere the thieves were driven in a jeep once around the stadium a flourish that brought the crowd to their feet as was intended
It would probably be quicker to list what the Taliban hadnt banned The regime even outlawed paper bags Like many of their laws this would be laughable if the penalties werent so severe
Break the Talibans law and you risked imprisonment flogging or worse
Key Events
History of Afghanistan
Afghanistan and the Cold War-The Soviets invaded Afghanistan in 1979 in order to support the Communist Partyrsquos push for power in the Country
-The opposing side was an Islamic Fundamentalist Osama Bin Laden being one of them group that was supported by the United States and Western Allies
-In 1989 the Soviet finally withdrew from Afghanistan
Afghanistan HistoryThe Soviet Union sent troops to Afghanistan to help the communist government there in a civil war
bull Then the Soviet Union invaded Afghanistan to set up a pro-Moscow government
bull For the next 9 years a civil war broke out with different tribes of Afghanistan against and with the Soviet forces
bull The Soviets pulled out in 1989 but they left a pro-Moscow government who fell with the Soviet Union in 1992
bull Over 1 million Afghans were killed 5 million Afghans fled to Pakistan and Iran
bull Another 2 million Afghans were displaced within the country
Russian Invasion
bull In the 1980s one out of two refugees in the world was an Afghan
bull Vital parts of the Afghan economy were destroyed including Irrigations systems to provide water for farming
Afghanistan HistoryThis led to a long war
between Soviet troops and Afghan rebels (Mujahedeen)
The United States was supporting the Afghan rebels
In 1989 an alliance of Afghan rebel groups took power and the Soviet troops left
The Talibanrsquos primary opposition was called the Northern Alliance and by 2001 the Northern Alliance had been pushed back to only 10 of Afghanistan to the north
Then as we all know the events of September 11th 2001
The United States knew that Osama Bin Laden was in Afghanistan and that we were going to go in there and get him
United States Invasion
bull In October of 2001 the United States invaded and in a short time by December of 2001 swept through and took control of the major cities and pushed the Taliban and Al Qaeda to the Pakistan-Afghanistan border and we helped to establish a new government that is in place today
Compare and contrast the Russian and United States invasions
Do in a T-Chart or a Venn Diagram
On your Left Side
In 1979 Afghanistan was invaded and eventually controlled by the Soviet Union
In 1989 Afghanistan and the Soviet Union signed a peace agreement
In 1995 the Taliban promising traditional Islamic values came into power imposing strict Islamic law including revoking many womenrsquos rights
In 2001 American troops force the Taliban from power
In 2004 Hamid Karzai became the first elected Afghan president
Late 1970s-2004
Taliban Rule
Gained strength in 1995 Formed by Sunni Muslim Pashtun students
intellectuals and disaffected Mujaheddin (holy warriors)
Trained in Pakistan fundamentalists committed to lsquoSharia Lawrsquo
(the traditional Islamic law and moral code that prescribes how Muslims should best conduct their lives)
Who is the Taliban
Under the Talibanrsquos rule human rights and civil liberties were slowly peeled away
bull The Taliban instituted cruel and inhumane treatment of those who opposed them in order to solidify their power over Afghanistanrsquos citizens
The Taliban (Talib is Arabic for lsquoIslamic studentrsquo)
Turmoil in Afghanistan continued and in the mid-1990rsquos a radical Muslim group called the Taliban arose
The Taliban took over most of Afghanistan and ruled strictly
The Taliban forced women to wear veils and stop working outside the home
Afghanistan History
Burka Fashion
AfghanistanTaliban came to
power in most Afghanistan by 1996
Osama bin Laden moved his terrorist activities there
Used mountain hideouts as a base of operations for his terrorist network called al-Qaeda
Map of Afghanistan in 1996 showing the amount of Taliban territory captured at that time (yellow) The Afghan Civil War commenced between 1996-2001 before coalition forces headed by the United States began air strikes against the Taliban
The TalibanPrior to 2001 the Taliban led by Mullah Mohammad Omar ruled Afghanistan under Islamic law
During this time women had virtually no rights and received no education
Watching television and listening to music were forbidden as were playing games and sports
The United States entered Afghanistan in October 2001 and replaced the Taliban with an elected president
While the Taliban lost some power and the people regained some rights the Taliban has not gone away
Instead it has worked to regain power by promising to help Afghanistanrsquos poorest people and aligning itself with warlords al-Qaida and other militant groups to gain financial support and recruit new fighters
Taliban Leader Mullah Mohammad Omar
Examples of abuses three men accused of a crime had been sentenced to death by being partially buried in the ground and then having a wall pushed over on them by a bulldozer a bizarre and labor-intensive form of execution dreamed up by the supreme leader of the Taliban
After another accused criminal was hanged his corpse was driven around the city swinging from a crane
A young woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man who was not her relative was stoned to death
On another occasion it was announced over the airwaves that 225 women had been rounded up and sentenced to a lashing for violating the dress code
When the Taliban castrated and then hanged the former communist president and his brother in 1996 they left their bloodied bodies dangling from lampposts in busy downtown Kabul for three days
Photographs of the corpses appeared in news magazines and newspapers around the world
Abuses of Power
The Taliban imposed their harsh brand of Islamic law in the 90 percent of Afghanistan under their control
The Taliban say their version of Islam is a pure one that follows a literal interpretation of the Muslim holy book The Koran
Under Taliban laws murderers were publicly executed by the relatives of their victims
Adulterers are stoned to death and the limbs of thieves were amputated
Lesser crimes were punished by public beatings
Taliban brought order and fundamental Islam at a price
19
Taliban executing a rebel on the spot
Dead bodies left in the street to rot by Taliban in Heart People forbidden to bury the bodies
Executions by the Taliban
20
There were almost weekly executions or amputations of criminals in the Kabul stadium before November 1999 when a woman was killed for hacking to death her abusive husband
The hiatus in public executions after that was attributed to a decline in crime in the capital
Public amputations amp executions
21
Rules for Everyone
No television No music No movies No picnics No wedding parties No New Year celebrations No kind of mixed-sex gathering No childrens toys including dolls and kites No card and board games No cameras No photographs and paintings of people and animals No pet parakeets No cigarettes and alcohol No magazines and newspapers and most books They even forbade applause -- a moot point since there was nothing left to
applaud The only books available must be approved by the Taliban Enemies of the Taliban are put in jail Protesting is not permitted All windows must be painted black so that no-one is able to see inside Photographs are illegal
Rules for Everyone
Bamyan Buddha before (left) After the explosion (right)
Taliban intolerant destruction of Historic Buddhist Religious Art
24
Taliban Draws World Attention
In 2001 blew up ancient Buddhist statues (1500 years old) near city of Bamiyan
Allowed al-Qaeda amp Osama bin Laden to operate within the countryTo give one an idea of scale note the
two individuals sitting herehttpwwwusatodaycomnewssciencearchaeology2001-03-22-afghan-buddhashtm
Treatment of Women under Taliban Rule
February 27 1998 --Thirty-thousand men and boys poured into the sports stadium in Kabul capital of Afghanistan Nuts biscuits and tea were sold to the waiting crowd
The scheduled entertainment They were there to see a young woman receive 100 lashes and to watch two thieves have their right hands amputated The woman had been arrested walking with a man who was not a relative a sufficient crime for her to be found guilty of adultery Since she was single it was punishable by flogging had she been married she would have been publicly stoned to death
As the young woman completely covered in the shroud-like burqa veil was forced to kneel and then whipped Taliban cheerleaders had the stadium ringing with the chants of onlookers
Among those present there were just three women the young Afghan and two female relatives who had accompanied her
The crowd fell silent only when the thieves were driven into the arena and pushed to the ground
Physicians using surgical scalpels promptly carried out the amputations Holding the severed hands aloft by the index fingers a grinning Taliban fighter warned the huge crowd These are the chopped-off hands of thieves the punishment for any of you caught stealingldquo
Then to restore the party atmosphere the thieves were driven in a jeep once around the stadium a flourish that brought the crowd to their feet as was intended
It would probably be quicker to list what the Taliban hadnt banned The regime even outlawed paper bags Like many of their laws this would be laughable if the penalties werent so severe
Break the Talibans law and you risked imprisonment flogging or worse
Afghanistan and the Cold War-The Soviets invaded Afghanistan in 1979 in order to support the Communist Partyrsquos push for power in the Country
-The opposing side was an Islamic Fundamentalist Osama Bin Laden being one of them group that was supported by the United States and Western Allies
-In 1989 the Soviet finally withdrew from Afghanistan
Afghanistan HistoryThe Soviet Union sent troops to Afghanistan to help the communist government there in a civil war
bull Then the Soviet Union invaded Afghanistan to set up a pro-Moscow government
bull For the next 9 years a civil war broke out with different tribes of Afghanistan against and with the Soviet forces
bull The Soviets pulled out in 1989 but they left a pro-Moscow government who fell with the Soviet Union in 1992
bull Over 1 million Afghans were killed 5 million Afghans fled to Pakistan and Iran
bull Another 2 million Afghans were displaced within the country
Russian Invasion
bull In the 1980s one out of two refugees in the world was an Afghan
bull Vital parts of the Afghan economy were destroyed including Irrigations systems to provide water for farming
Afghanistan HistoryThis led to a long war
between Soviet troops and Afghan rebels (Mujahedeen)
The United States was supporting the Afghan rebels
In 1989 an alliance of Afghan rebel groups took power and the Soviet troops left
The Talibanrsquos primary opposition was called the Northern Alliance and by 2001 the Northern Alliance had been pushed back to only 10 of Afghanistan to the north
Then as we all know the events of September 11th 2001
The United States knew that Osama Bin Laden was in Afghanistan and that we were going to go in there and get him
United States Invasion
bull In October of 2001 the United States invaded and in a short time by December of 2001 swept through and took control of the major cities and pushed the Taliban and Al Qaeda to the Pakistan-Afghanistan border and we helped to establish a new government that is in place today
Compare and contrast the Russian and United States invasions
Do in a T-Chart or a Venn Diagram
On your Left Side
In 1979 Afghanistan was invaded and eventually controlled by the Soviet Union
In 1989 Afghanistan and the Soviet Union signed a peace agreement
In 1995 the Taliban promising traditional Islamic values came into power imposing strict Islamic law including revoking many womenrsquos rights
In 2001 American troops force the Taliban from power
In 2004 Hamid Karzai became the first elected Afghan president
Late 1970s-2004
Taliban Rule
Gained strength in 1995 Formed by Sunni Muslim Pashtun students
intellectuals and disaffected Mujaheddin (holy warriors)
Trained in Pakistan fundamentalists committed to lsquoSharia Lawrsquo
(the traditional Islamic law and moral code that prescribes how Muslims should best conduct their lives)
Who is the Taliban
Under the Talibanrsquos rule human rights and civil liberties were slowly peeled away
bull The Taliban instituted cruel and inhumane treatment of those who opposed them in order to solidify their power over Afghanistanrsquos citizens
The Taliban (Talib is Arabic for lsquoIslamic studentrsquo)
Turmoil in Afghanistan continued and in the mid-1990rsquos a radical Muslim group called the Taliban arose
The Taliban took over most of Afghanistan and ruled strictly
The Taliban forced women to wear veils and stop working outside the home
Afghanistan History
Burka Fashion
AfghanistanTaliban came to
power in most Afghanistan by 1996
Osama bin Laden moved his terrorist activities there
Used mountain hideouts as a base of operations for his terrorist network called al-Qaeda
Map of Afghanistan in 1996 showing the amount of Taliban territory captured at that time (yellow) The Afghan Civil War commenced between 1996-2001 before coalition forces headed by the United States began air strikes against the Taliban
The TalibanPrior to 2001 the Taliban led by Mullah Mohammad Omar ruled Afghanistan under Islamic law
During this time women had virtually no rights and received no education
Watching television and listening to music were forbidden as were playing games and sports
The United States entered Afghanistan in October 2001 and replaced the Taliban with an elected president
While the Taliban lost some power and the people regained some rights the Taliban has not gone away
Instead it has worked to regain power by promising to help Afghanistanrsquos poorest people and aligning itself with warlords al-Qaida and other militant groups to gain financial support and recruit new fighters
Taliban Leader Mullah Mohammad Omar
Examples of abuses three men accused of a crime had been sentenced to death by being partially buried in the ground and then having a wall pushed over on them by a bulldozer a bizarre and labor-intensive form of execution dreamed up by the supreme leader of the Taliban
After another accused criminal was hanged his corpse was driven around the city swinging from a crane
A young woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man who was not her relative was stoned to death
On another occasion it was announced over the airwaves that 225 women had been rounded up and sentenced to a lashing for violating the dress code
When the Taliban castrated and then hanged the former communist president and his brother in 1996 they left their bloodied bodies dangling from lampposts in busy downtown Kabul for three days
Photographs of the corpses appeared in news magazines and newspapers around the world
Abuses of Power
The Taliban imposed their harsh brand of Islamic law in the 90 percent of Afghanistan under their control
The Taliban say their version of Islam is a pure one that follows a literal interpretation of the Muslim holy book The Koran
Under Taliban laws murderers were publicly executed by the relatives of their victims
Adulterers are stoned to death and the limbs of thieves were amputated
Lesser crimes were punished by public beatings
Taliban brought order and fundamental Islam at a price
19
Taliban executing a rebel on the spot
Dead bodies left in the street to rot by Taliban in Heart People forbidden to bury the bodies
Executions by the Taliban
20
There were almost weekly executions or amputations of criminals in the Kabul stadium before November 1999 when a woman was killed for hacking to death her abusive husband
The hiatus in public executions after that was attributed to a decline in crime in the capital
Public amputations amp executions
21
Rules for Everyone
No television No music No movies No picnics No wedding parties No New Year celebrations No kind of mixed-sex gathering No childrens toys including dolls and kites No card and board games No cameras No photographs and paintings of people and animals No pet parakeets No cigarettes and alcohol No magazines and newspapers and most books They even forbade applause -- a moot point since there was nothing left to
applaud The only books available must be approved by the Taliban Enemies of the Taliban are put in jail Protesting is not permitted All windows must be painted black so that no-one is able to see inside Photographs are illegal
Rules for Everyone
Bamyan Buddha before (left) After the explosion (right)
Taliban intolerant destruction of Historic Buddhist Religious Art
24
Taliban Draws World Attention
In 2001 blew up ancient Buddhist statues (1500 years old) near city of Bamiyan
Allowed al-Qaeda amp Osama bin Laden to operate within the countryTo give one an idea of scale note the
two individuals sitting herehttpwwwusatodaycomnewssciencearchaeology2001-03-22-afghan-buddhashtm
Treatment of Women under Taliban Rule
February 27 1998 --Thirty-thousand men and boys poured into the sports stadium in Kabul capital of Afghanistan Nuts biscuits and tea were sold to the waiting crowd
The scheduled entertainment They were there to see a young woman receive 100 lashes and to watch two thieves have their right hands amputated The woman had been arrested walking with a man who was not a relative a sufficient crime for her to be found guilty of adultery Since she was single it was punishable by flogging had she been married she would have been publicly stoned to death
As the young woman completely covered in the shroud-like burqa veil was forced to kneel and then whipped Taliban cheerleaders had the stadium ringing with the chants of onlookers
Among those present there were just three women the young Afghan and two female relatives who had accompanied her
The crowd fell silent only when the thieves were driven into the arena and pushed to the ground
Physicians using surgical scalpels promptly carried out the amputations Holding the severed hands aloft by the index fingers a grinning Taliban fighter warned the huge crowd These are the chopped-off hands of thieves the punishment for any of you caught stealingldquo
Then to restore the party atmosphere the thieves were driven in a jeep once around the stadium a flourish that brought the crowd to their feet as was intended
It would probably be quicker to list what the Taliban hadnt banned The regime even outlawed paper bags Like many of their laws this would be laughable if the penalties werent so severe
Break the Talibans law and you risked imprisonment flogging or worse
Afghanistan HistoryThe Soviet Union sent troops to Afghanistan to help the communist government there in a civil war
bull Then the Soviet Union invaded Afghanistan to set up a pro-Moscow government
bull For the next 9 years a civil war broke out with different tribes of Afghanistan against and with the Soviet forces
bull The Soviets pulled out in 1989 but they left a pro-Moscow government who fell with the Soviet Union in 1992
bull Over 1 million Afghans were killed 5 million Afghans fled to Pakistan and Iran
bull Another 2 million Afghans were displaced within the country
Russian Invasion
bull In the 1980s one out of two refugees in the world was an Afghan
bull Vital parts of the Afghan economy were destroyed including Irrigations systems to provide water for farming
Afghanistan HistoryThis led to a long war
between Soviet troops and Afghan rebels (Mujahedeen)
The United States was supporting the Afghan rebels
In 1989 an alliance of Afghan rebel groups took power and the Soviet troops left
The Talibanrsquos primary opposition was called the Northern Alliance and by 2001 the Northern Alliance had been pushed back to only 10 of Afghanistan to the north
Then as we all know the events of September 11th 2001
The United States knew that Osama Bin Laden was in Afghanistan and that we were going to go in there and get him
United States Invasion
bull In October of 2001 the United States invaded and in a short time by December of 2001 swept through and took control of the major cities and pushed the Taliban and Al Qaeda to the Pakistan-Afghanistan border and we helped to establish a new government that is in place today
Compare and contrast the Russian and United States invasions
Do in a T-Chart or a Venn Diagram
On your Left Side
In 1979 Afghanistan was invaded and eventually controlled by the Soviet Union
In 1989 Afghanistan and the Soviet Union signed a peace agreement
In 1995 the Taliban promising traditional Islamic values came into power imposing strict Islamic law including revoking many womenrsquos rights
In 2001 American troops force the Taliban from power
In 2004 Hamid Karzai became the first elected Afghan president
Late 1970s-2004
Taliban Rule
Gained strength in 1995 Formed by Sunni Muslim Pashtun students
intellectuals and disaffected Mujaheddin (holy warriors)
Trained in Pakistan fundamentalists committed to lsquoSharia Lawrsquo
(the traditional Islamic law and moral code that prescribes how Muslims should best conduct their lives)
Who is the Taliban
Under the Talibanrsquos rule human rights and civil liberties were slowly peeled away
bull The Taliban instituted cruel and inhumane treatment of those who opposed them in order to solidify their power over Afghanistanrsquos citizens
The Taliban (Talib is Arabic for lsquoIslamic studentrsquo)
Turmoil in Afghanistan continued and in the mid-1990rsquos a radical Muslim group called the Taliban arose
The Taliban took over most of Afghanistan and ruled strictly
The Taliban forced women to wear veils and stop working outside the home
Afghanistan History
Burka Fashion
AfghanistanTaliban came to
power in most Afghanistan by 1996
Osama bin Laden moved his terrorist activities there
Used mountain hideouts as a base of operations for his terrorist network called al-Qaeda
Map of Afghanistan in 1996 showing the amount of Taliban territory captured at that time (yellow) The Afghan Civil War commenced between 1996-2001 before coalition forces headed by the United States began air strikes against the Taliban
The TalibanPrior to 2001 the Taliban led by Mullah Mohammad Omar ruled Afghanistan under Islamic law
During this time women had virtually no rights and received no education
Watching television and listening to music were forbidden as were playing games and sports
The United States entered Afghanistan in October 2001 and replaced the Taliban with an elected president
While the Taliban lost some power and the people regained some rights the Taliban has not gone away
Instead it has worked to regain power by promising to help Afghanistanrsquos poorest people and aligning itself with warlords al-Qaida and other militant groups to gain financial support and recruit new fighters
Taliban Leader Mullah Mohammad Omar
Examples of abuses three men accused of a crime had been sentenced to death by being partially buried in the ground and then having a wall pushed over on them by a bulldozer a bizarre and labor-intensive form of execution dreamed up by the supreme leader of the Taliban
After another accused criminal was hanged his corpse was driven around the city swinging from a crane
A young woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man who was not her relative was stoned to death
On another occasion it was announced over the airwaves that 225 women had been rounded up and sentenced to a lashing for violating the dress code
When the Taliban castrated and then hanged the former communist president and his brother in 1996 they left their bloodied bodies dangling from lampposts in busy downtown Kabul for three days
Photographs of the corpses appeared in news magazines and newspapers around the world
Abuses of Power
The Taliban imposed their harsh brand of Islamic law in the 90 percent of Afghanistan under their control
The Taliban say their version of Islam is a pure one that follows a literal interpretation of the Muslim holy book The Koran
Under Taliban laws murderers were publicly executed by the relatives of their victims
Adulterers are stoned to death and the limbs of thieves were amputated
Lesser crimes were punished by public beatings
Taliban brought order and fundamental Islam at a price
19
Taliban executing a rebel on the spot
Dead bodies left in the street to rot by Taliban in Heart People forbidden to bury the bodies
Executions by the Taliban
20
There were almost weekly executions or amputations of criminals in the Kabul stadium before November 1999 when a woman was killed for hacking to death her abusive husband
The hiatus in public executions after that was attributed to a decline in crime in the capital
Public amputations amp executions
21
Rules for Everyone
No television No music No movies No picnics No wedding parties No New Year celebrations No kind of mixed-sex gathering No childrens toys including dolls and kites No card and board games No cameras No photographs and paintings of people and animals No pet parakeets No cigarettes and alcohol No magazines and newspapers and most books They even forbade applause -- a moot point since there was nothing left to
applaud The only books available must be approved by the Taliban Enemies of the Taliban are put in jail Protesting is not permitted All windows must be painted black so that no-one is able to see inside Photographs are illegal
Rules for Everyone
Bamyan Buddha before (left) After the explosion (right)
Taliban intolerant destruction of Historic Buddhist Religious Art
24
Taliban Draws World Attention
In 2001 blew up ancient Buddhist statues (1500 years old) near city of Bamiyan
Allowed al-Qaeda amp Osama bin Laden to operate within the countryTo give one an idea of scale note the
two individuals sitting herehttpwwwusatodaycomnewssciencearchaeology2001-03-22-afghan-buddhashtm
Treatment of Women under Taliban Rule
February 27 1998 --Thirty-thousand men and boys poured into the sports stadium in Kabul capital of Afghanistan Nuts biscuits and tea were sold to the waiting crowd
The scheduled entertainment They were there to see a young woman receive 100 lashes and to watch two thieves have their right hands amputated The woman had been arrested walking with a man who was not a relative a sufficient crime for her to be found guilty of adultery Since she was single it was punishable by flogging had she been married she would have been publicly stoned to death
As the young woman completely covered in the shroud-like burqa veil was forced to kneel and then whipped Taliban cheerleaders had the stadium ringing with the chants of onlookers
Among those present there were just three women the young Afghan and two female relatives who had accompanied her
The crowd fell silent only when the thieves were driven into the arena and pushed to the ground
Physicians using surgical scalpels promptly carried out the amputations Holding the severed hands aloft by the index fingers a grinning Taliban fighter warned the huge crowd These are the chopped-off hands of thieves the punishment for any of you caught stealingldquo
Then to restore the party atmosphere the thieves were driven in a jeep once around the stadium a flourish that brought the crowd to their feet as was intended
It would probably be quicker to list what the Taliban hadnt banned The regime even outlawed paper bags Like many of their laws this would be laughable if the penalties werent so severe
Break the Talibans law and you risked imprisonment flogging or worse
bull Then the Soviet Union invaded Afghanistan to set up a pro-Moscow government
bull For the next 9 years a civil war broke out with different tribes of Afghanistan against and with the Soviet forces
bull The Soviets pulled out in 1989 but they left a pro-Moscow government who fell with the Soviet Union in 1992
bull Over 1 million Afghans were killed 5 million Afghans fled to Pakistan and Iran
bull Another 2 million Afghans were displaced within the country
Russian Invasion
bull In the 1980s one out of two refugees in the world was an Afghan
bull Vital parts of the Afghan economy were destroyed including Irrigations systems to provide water for farming
Afghanistan HistoryThis led to a long war
between Soviet troops and Afghan rebels (Mujahedeen)
The United States was supporting the Afghan rebels
In 1989 an alliance of Afghan rebel groups took power and the Soviet troops left
The Talibanrsquos primary opposition was called the Northern Alliance and by 2001 the Northern Alliance had been pushed back to only 10 of Afghanistan to the north
Then as we all know the events of September 11th 2001
The United States knew that Osama Bin Laden was in Afghanistan and that we were going to go in there and get him
United States Invasion
bull In October of 2001 the United States invaded and in a short time by December of 2001 swept through and took control of the major cities and pushed the Taliban and Al Qaeda to the Pakistan-Afghanistan border and we helped to establish a new government that is in place today
Compare and contrast the Russian and United States invasions
Do in a T-Chart or a Venn Diagram
On your Left Side
In 1979 Afghanistan was invaded and eventually controlled by the Soviet Union
In 1989 Afghanistan and the Soviet Union signed a peace agreement
In 1995 the Taliban promising traditional Islamic values came into power imposing strict Islamic law including revoking many womenrsquos rights
In 2001 American troops force the Taliban from power
In 2004 Hamid Karzai became the first elected Afghan president
Late 1970s-2004
Taliban Rule
Gained strength in 1995 Formed by Sunni Muslim Pashtun students
intellectuals and disaffected Mujaheddin (holy warriors)
Trained in Pakistan fundamentalists committed to lsquoSharia Lawrsquo
(the traditional Islamic law and moral code that prescribes how Muslims should best conduct their lives)
Who is the Taliban
Under the Talibanrsquos rule human rights and civil liberties were slowly peeled away
bull The Taliban instituted cruel and inhumane treatment of those who opposed them in order to solidify their power over Afghanistanrsquos citizens
The Taliban (Talib is Arabic for lsquoIslamic studentrsquo)
Turmoil in Afghanistan continued and in the mid-1990rsquos a radical Muslim group called the Taliban arose
The Taliban took over most of Afghanistan and ruled strictly
The Taliban forced women to wear veils and stop working outside the home
Afghanistan History
Burka Fashion
AfghanistanTaliban came to
power in most Afghanistan by 1996
Osama bin Laden moved his terrorist activities there
Used mountain hideouts as a base of operations for his terrorist network called al-Qaeda
Map of Afghanistan in 1996 showing the amount of Taliban territory captured at that time (yellow) The Afghan Civil War commenced between 1996-2001 before coalition forces headed by the United States began air strikes against the Taliban
The TalibanPrior to 2001 the Taliban led by Mullah Mohammad Omar ruled Afghanistan under Islamic law
During this time women had virtually no rights and received no education
Watching television and listening to music were forbidden as were playing games and sports
The United States entered Afghanistan in October 2001 and replaced the Taliban with an elected president
While the Taliban lost some power and the people regained some rights the Taliban has not gone away
Instead it has worked to regain power by promising to help Afghanistanrsquos poorest people and aligning itself with warlords al-Qaida and other militant groups to gain financial support and recruit new fighters
Taliban Leader Mullah Mohammad Omar
Examples of abuses three men accused of a crime had been sentenced to death by being partially buried in the ground and then having a wall pushed over on them by a bulldozer a bizarre and labor-intensive form of execution dreamed up by the supreme leader of the Taliban
After another accused criminal was hanged his corpse was driven around the city swinging from a crane
A young woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man who was not her relative was stoned to death
On another occasion it was announced over the airwaves that 225 women had been rounded up and sentenced to a lashing for violating the dress code
When the Taliban castrated and then hanged the former communist president and his brother in 1996 they left their bloodied bodies dangling from lampposts in busy downtown Kabul for three days
Photographs of the corpses appeared in news magazines and newspapers around the world
Abuses of Power
The Taliban imposed their harsh brand of Islamic law in the 90 percent of Afghanistan under their control
The Taliban say their version of Islam is a pure one that follows a literal interpretation of the Muslim holy book The Koran
Under Taliban laws murderers were publicly executed by the relatives of their victims
Adulterers are stoned to death and the limbs of thieves were amputated
Lesser crimes were punished by public beatings
Taliban brought order and fundamental Islam at a price
19
Taliban executing a rebel on the spot
Dead bodies left in the street to rot by Taliban in Heart People forbidden to bury the bodies
Executions by the Taliban
20
There were almost weekly executions or amputations of criminals in the Kabul stadium before November 1999 when a woman was killed for hacking to death her abusive husband
The hiatus in public executions after that was attributed to a decline in crime in the capital
Public amputations amp executions
21
Rules for Everyone
No television No music No movies No picnics No wedding parties No New Year celebrations No kind of mixed-sex gathering No childrens toys including dolls and kites No card and board games No cameras No photographs and paintings of people and animals No pet parakeets No cigarettes and alcohol No magazines and newspapers and most books They even forbade applause -- a moot point since there was nothing left to
applaud The only books available must be approved by the Taliban Enemies of the Taliban are put in jail Protesting is not permitted All windows must be painted black so that no-one is able to see inside Photographs are illegal
Rules for Everyone
Bamyan Buddha before (left) After the explosion (right)
Taliban intolerant destruction of Historic Buddhist Religious Art
24
Taliban Draws World Attention
In 2001 blew up ancient Buddhist statues (1500 years old) near city of Bamiyan
Allowed al-Qaeda amp Osama bin Laden to operate within the countryTo give one an idea of scale note the
two individuals sitting herehttpwwwusatodaycomnewssciencearchaeology2001-03-22-afghan-buddhashtm
Treatment of Women under Taliban Rule
February 27 1998 --Thirty-thousand men and boys poured into the sports stadium in Kabul capital of Afghanistan Nuts biscuits and tea were sold to the waiting crowd
The scheduled entertainment They were there to see a young woman receive 100 lashes and to watch two thieves have their right hands amputated The woman had been arrested walking with a man who was not a relative a sufficient crime for her to be found guilty of adultery Since she was single it was punishable by flogging had she been married she would have been publicly stoned to death
As the young woman completely covered in the shroud-like burqa veil was forced to kneel and then whipped Taliban cheerleaders had the stadium ringing with the chants of onlookers
Among those present there were just three women the young Afghan and two female relatives who had accompanied her
The crowd fell silent only when the thieves were driven into the arena and pushed to the ground
Physicians using surgical scalpels promptly carried out the amputations Holding the severed hands aloft by the index fingers a grinning Taliban fighter warned the huge crowd These are the chopped-off hands of thieves the punishment for any of you caught stealingldquo
Then to restore the party atmosphere the thieves were driven in a jeep once around the stadium a flourish that brought the crowd to their feet as was intended
It would probably be quicker to list what the Taliban hadnt banned The regime even outlawed paper bags Like many of their laws this would be laughable if the penalties werent so severe
Break the Talibans law and you risked imprisonment flogging or worse
Afghanistan HistoryThis led to a long war
between Soviet troops and Afghan rebels (Mujahedeen)
The United States was supporting the Afghan rebels
In 1989 an alliance of Afghan rebel groups took power and the Soviet troops left
The Talibanrsquos primary opposition was called the Northern Alliance and by 2001 the Northern Alliance had been pushed back to only 10 of Afghanistan to the north
Then as we all know the events of September 11th 2001
The United States knew that Osama Bin Laden was in Afghanistan and that we were going to go in there and get him
United States Invasion
bull In October of 2001 the United States invaded and in a short time by December of 2001 swept through and took control of the major cities and pushed the Taliban and Al Qaeda to the Pakistan-Afghanistan border and we helped to establish a new government that is in place today
Compare and contrast the Russian and United States invasions
Do in a T-Chart or a Venn Diagram
On your Left Side
In 1979 Afghanistan was invaded and eventually controlled by the Soviet Union
In 1989 Afghanistan and the Soviet Union signed a peace agreement
In 1995 the Taliban promising traditional Islamic values came into power imposing strict Islamic law including revoking many womenrsquos rights
In 2001 American troops force the Taliban from power
In 2004 Hamid Karzai became the first elected Afghan president
Late 1970s-2004
Taliban Rule
Gained strength in 1995 Formed by Sunni Muslim Pashtun students
intellectuals and disaffected Mujaheddin (holy warriors)
Trained in Pakistan fundamentalists committed to lsquoSharia Lawrsquo
(the traditional Islamic law and moral code that prescribes how Muslims should best conduct their lives)
Who is the Taliban
Under the Talibanrsquos rule human rights and civil liberties were slowly peeled away
bull The Taliban instituted cruel and inhumane treatment of those who opposed them in order to solidify their power over Afghanistanrsquos citizens
The Taliban (Talib is Arabic for lsquoIslamic studentrsquo)
Turmoil in Afghanistan continued and in the mid-1990rsquos a radical Muslim group called the Taliban arose
The Taliban took over most of Afghanistan and ruled strictly
The Taliban forced women to wear veils and stop working outside the home
Afghanistan History
Burka Fashion
AfghanistanTaliban came to
power in most Afghanistan by 1996
Osama bin Laden moved his terrorist activities there
Used mountain hideouts as a base of operations for his terrorist network called al-Qaeda
Map of Afghanistan in 1996 showing the amount of Taliban territory captured at that time (yellow) The Afghan Civil War commenced between 1996-2001 before coalition forces headed by the United States began air strikes against the Taliban
The TalibanPrior to 2001 the Taliban led by Mullah Mohammad Omar ruled Afghanistan under Islamic law
During this time women had virtually no rights and received no education
Watching television and listening to music were forbidden as were playing games and sports
The United States entered Afghanistan in October 2001 and replaced the Taliban with an elected president
While the Taliban lost some power and the people regained some rights the Taliban has not gone away
Instead it has worked to regain power by promising to help Afghanistanrsquos poorest people and aligning itself with warlords al-Qaida and other militant groups to gain financial support and recruit new fighters
Taliban Leader Mullah Mohammad Omar
Examples of abuses three men accused of a crime had been sentenced to death by being partially buried in the ground and then having a wall pushed over on them by a bulldozer a bizarre and labor-intensive form of execution dreamed up by the supreme leader of the Taliban
After another accused criminal was hanged his corpse was driven around the city swinging from a crane
A young woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man who was not her relative was stoned to death
On another occasion it was announced over the airwaves that 225 women had been rounded up and sentenced to a lashing for violating the dress code
When the Taliban castrated and then hanged the former communist president and his brother in 1996 they left their bloodied bodies dangling from lampposts in busy downtown Kabul for three days
Photographs of the corpses appeared in news magazines and newspapers around the world
Abuses of Power
The Taliban imposed their harsh brand of Islamic law in the 90 percent of Afghanistan under their control
The Taliban say their version of Islam is a pure one that follows a literal interpretation of the Muslim holy book The Koran
Under Taliban laws murderers were publicly executed by the relatives of their victims
Adulterers are stoned to death and the limbs of thieves were amputated
Lesser crimes were punished by public beatings
Taliban brought order and fundamental Islam at a price
19
Taliban executing a rebel on the spot
Dead bodies left in the street to rot by Taliban in Heart People forbidden to bury the bodies
Executions by the Taliban
20
There were almost weekly executions or amputations of criminals in the Kabul stadium before November 1999 when a woman was killed for hacking to death her abusive husband
The hiatus in public executions after that was attributed to a decline in crime in the capital
Public amputations amp executions
21
Rules for Everyone
No television No music No movies No picnics No wedding parties No New Year celebrations No kind of mixed-sex gathering No childrens toys including dolls and kites No card and board games No cameras No photographs and paintings of people and animals No pet parakeets No cigarettes and alcohol No magazines and newspapers and most books They even forbade applause -- a moot point since there was nothing left to
applaud The only books available must be approved by the Taliban Enemies of the Taliban are put in jail Protesting is not permitted All windows must be painted black so that no-one is able to see inside Photographs are illegal
Rules for Everyone
Bamyan Buddha before (left) After the explosion (right)
Taliban intolerant destruction of Historic Buddhist Religious Art
24
Taliban Draws World Attention
In 2001 blew up ancient Buddhist statues (1500 years old) near city of Bamiyan
Allowed al-Qaeda amp Osama bin Laden to operate within the countryTo give one an idea of scale note the
two individuals sitting herehttpwwwusatodaycomnewssciencearchaeology2001-03-22-afghan-buddhashtm
Treatment of Women under Taliban Rule
February 27 1998 --Thirty-thousand men and boys poured into the sports stadium in Kabul capital of Afghanistan Nuts biscuits and tea were sold to the waiting crowd
The scheduled entertainment They were there to see a young woman receive 100 lashes and to watch two thieves have their right hands amputated The woman had been arrested walking with a man who was not a relative a sufficient crime for her to be found guilty of adultery Since she was single it was punishable by flogging had she been married she would have been publicly stoned to death
As the young woman completely covered in the shroud-like burqa veil was forced to kneel and then whipped Taliban cheerleaders had the stadium ringing with the chants of onlookers
Among those present there were just three women the young Afghan and two female relatives who had accompanied her
The crowd fell silent only when the thieves were driven into the arena and pushed to the ground
Physicians using surgical scalpels promptly carried out the amputations Holding the severed hands aloft by the index fingers a grinning Taliban fighter warned the huge crowd These are the chopped-off hands of thieves the punishment for any of you caught stealingldquo
Then to restore the party atmosphere the thieves were driven in a jeep once around the stadium a flourish that brought the crowd to their feet as was intended
It would probably be quicker to list what the Taliban hadnt banned The regime even outlawed paper bags Like many of their laws this would be laughable if the penalties werent so severe
Break the Talibans law and you risked imprisonment flogging or worse
The Talibanrsquos primary opposition was called the Northern Alliance and by 2001 the Northern Alliance had been pushed back to only 10 of Afghanistan to the north
Then as we all know the events of September 11th 2001
The United States knew that Osama Bin Laden was in Afghanistan and that we were going to go in there and get him
United States Invasion
bull In October of 2001 the United States invaded and in a short time by December of 2001 swept through and took control of the major cities and pushed the Taliban and Al Qaeda to the Pakistan-Afghanistan border and we helped to establish a new government that is in place today
Compare and contrast the Russian and United States invasions
Do in a T-Chart or a Venn Diagram
On your Left Side
In 1979 Afghanistan was invaded and eventually controlled by the Soviet Union
In 1989 Afghanistan and the Soviet Union signed a peace agreement
In 1995 the Taliban promising traditional Islamic values came into power imposing strict Islamic law including revoking many womenrsquos rights
In 2001 American troops force the Taliban from power
In 2004 Hamid Karzai became the first elected Afghan president
Late 1970s-2004
Taliban Rule
Gained strength in 1995 Formed by Sunni Muslim Pashtun students
intellectuals and disaffected Mujaheddin (holy warriors)
Trained in Pakistan fundamentalists committed to lsquoSharia Lawrsquo
(the traditional Islamic law and moral code that prescribes how Muslims should best conduct their lives)
Who is the Taliban
Under the Talibanrsquos rule human rights and civil liberties were slowly peeled away
bull The Taliban instituted cruel and inhumane treatment of those who opposed them in order to solidify their power over Afghanistanrsquos citizens
The Taliban (Talib is Arabic for lsquoIslamic studentrsquo)
Turmoil in Afghanistan continued and in the mid-1990rsquos a radical Muslim group called the Taliban arose
The Taliban took over most of Afghanistan and ruled strictly
The Taliban forced women to wear veils and stop working outside the home
Afghanistan History
Burka Fashion
AfghanistanTaliban came to
power in most Afghanistan by 1996
Osama bin Laden moved his terrorist activities there
Used mountain hideouts as a base of operations for his terrorist network called al-Qaeda
Map of Afghanistan in 1996 showing the amount of Taliban territory captured at that time (yellow) The Afghan Civil War commenced between 1996-2001 before coalition forces headed by the United States began air strikes against the Taliban
The TalibanPrior to 2001 the Taliban led by Mullah Mohammad Omar ruled Afghanistan under Islamic law
During this time women had virtually no rights and received no education
Watching television and listening to music were forbidden as were playing games and sports
The United States entered Afghanistan in October 2001 and replaced the Taliban with an elected president
While the Taliban lost some power and the people regained some rights the Taliban has not gone away
Instead it has worked to regain power by promising to help Afghanistanrsquos poorest people and aligning itself with warlords al-Qaida and other militant groups to gain financial support and recruit new fighters
Taliban Leader Mullah Mohammad Omar
Examples of abuses three men accused of a crime had been sentenced to death by being partially buried in the ground and then having a wall pushed over on them by a bulldozer a bizarre and labor-intensive form of execution dreamed up by the supreme leader of the Taliban
After another accused criminal was hanged his corpse was driven around the city swinging from a crane
A young woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man who was not her relative was stoned to death
On another occasion it was announced over the airwaves that 225 women had been rounded up and sentenced to a lashing for violating the dress code
When the Taliban castrated and then hanged the former communist president and his brother in 1996 they left their bloodied bodies dangling from lampposts in busy downtown Kabul for three days
Photographs of the corpses appeared in news magazines and newspapers around the world
Abuses of Power
The Taliban imposed their harsh brand of Islamic law in the 90 percent of Afghanistan under their control
The Taliban say their version of Islam is a pure one that follows a literal interpretation of the Muslim holy book The Koran
Under Taliban laws murderers were publicly executed by the relatives of their victims
Adulterers are stoned to death and the limbs of thieves were amputated
Lesser crimes were punished by public beatings
Taliban brought order and fundamental Islam at a price
19
Taliban executing a rebel on the spot
Dead bodies left in the street to rot by Taliban in Heart People forbidden to bury the bodies
Executions by the Taliban
20
There were almost weekly executions or amputations of criminals in the Kabul stadium before November 1999 when a woman was killed for hacking to death her abusive husband
The hiatus in public executions after that was attributed to a decline in crime in the capital
Public amputations amp executions
21
Rules for Everyone
No television No music No movies No picnics No wedding parties No New Year celebrations No kind of mixed-sex gathering No childrens toys including dolls and kites No card and board games No cameras No photographs and paintings of people and animals No pet parakeets No cigarettes and alcohol No magazines and newspapers and most books They even forbade applause -- a moot point since there was nothing left to
applaud The only books available must be approved by the Taliban Enemies of the Taliban are put in jail Protesting is not permitted All windows must be painted black so that no-one is able to see inside Photographs are illegal
Rules for Everyone
Bamyan Buddha before (left) After the explosion (right)
Taliban intolerant destruction of Historic Buddhist Religious Art
24
Taliban Draws World Attention
In 2001 blew up ancient Buddhist statues (1500 years old) near city of Bamiyan
Allowed al-Qaeda amp Osama bin Laden to operate within the countryTo give one an idea of scale note the
two individuals sitting herehttpwwwusatodaycomnewssciencearchaeology2001-03-22-afghan-buddhashtm
Treatment of Women under Taliban Rule
February 27 1998 --Thirty-thousand men and boys poured into the sports stadium in Kabul capital of Afghanistan Nuts biscuits and tea were sold to the waiting crowd
The scheduled entertainment They were there to see a young woman receive 100 lashes and to watch two thieves have their right hands amputated The woman had been arrested walking with a man who was not a relative a sufficient crime for her to be found guilty of adultery Since she was single it was punishable by flogging had she been married she would have been publicly stoned to death
As the young woman completely covered in the shroud-like burqa veil was forced to kneel and then whipped Taliban cheerleaders had the stadium ringing with the chants of onlookers
Among those present there were just three women the young Afghan and two female relatives who had accompanied her
The crowd fell silent only when the thieves were driven into the arena and pushed to the ground
Physicians using surgical scalpels promptly carried out the amputations Holding the severed hands aloft by the index fingers a grinning Taliban fighter warned the huge crowd These are the chopped-off hands of thieves the punishment for any of you caught stealingldquo
Then to restore the party atmosphere the thieves were driven in a jeep once around the stadium a flourish that brought the crowd to their feet as was intended
It would probably be quicker to list what the Taliban hadnt banned The regime even outlawed paper bags Like many of their laws this would be laughable if the penalties werent so severe
Break the Talibans law and you risked imprisonment flogging or worse
Compare and contrast the Russian and United States invasions
Do in a T-Chart or a Venn Diagram
On your Left Side
In 1979 Afghanistan was invaded and eventually controlled by the Soviet Union
In 1989 Afghanistan and the Soviet Union signed a peace agreement
In 1995 the Taliban promising traditional Islamic values came into power imposing strict Islamic law including revoking many womenrsquos rights
In 2001 American troops force the Taliban from power
In 2004 Hamid Karzai became the first elected Afghan president
Late 1970s-2004
Taliban Rule
Gained strength in 1995 Formed by Sunni Muslim Pashtun students
intellectuals and disaffected Mujaheddin (holy warriors)
Trained in Pakistan fundamentalists committed to lsquoSharia Lawrsquo
(the traditional Islamic law and moral code that prescribes how Muslims should best conduct their lives)
Who is the Taliban
Under the Talibanrsquos rule human rights and civil liberties were slowly peeled away
bull The Taliban instituted cruel and inhumane treatment of those who opposed them in order to solidify their power over Afghanistanrsquos citizens
The Taliban (Talib is Arabic for lsquoIslamic studentrsquo)
Turmoil in Afghanistan continued and in the mid-1990rsquos a radical Muslim group called the Taliban arose
The Taliban took over most of Afghanistan and ruled strictly
The Taliban forced women to wear veils and stop working outside the home
Afghanistan History
Burka Fashion
AfghanistanTaliban came to
power in most Afghanistan by 1996
Osama bin Laden moved his terrorist activities there
Used mountain hideouts as a base of operations for his terrorist network called al-Qaeda
Map of Afghanistan in 1996 showing the amount of Taliban territory captured at that time (yellow) The Afghan Civil War commenced between 1996-2001 before coalition forces headed by the United States began air strikes against the Taliban
The TalibanPrior to 2001 the Taliban led by Mullah Mohammad Omar ruled Afghanistan under Islamic law
During this time women had virtually no rights and received no education
Watching television and listening to music were forbidden as were playing games and sports
The United States entered Afghanistan in October 2001 and replaced the Taliban with an elected president
While the Taliban lost some power and the people regained some rights the Taliban has not gone away
Instead it has worked to regain power by promising to help Afghanistanrsquos poorest people and aligning itself with warlords al-Qaida and other militant groups to gain financial support and recruit new fighters
Taliban Leader Mullah Mohammad Omar
Examples of abuses three men accused of a crime had been sentenced to death by being partially buried in the ground and then having a wall pushed over on them by a bulldozer a bizarre and labor-intensive form of execution dreamed up by the supreme leader of the Taliban
After another accused criminal was hanged his corpse was driven around the city swinging from a crane
A young woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man who was not her relative was stoned to death
On another occasion it was announced over the airwaves that 225 women had been rounded up and sentenced to a lashing for violating the dress code
When the Taliban castrated and then hanged the former communist president and his brother in 1996 they left their bloodied bodies dangling from lampposts in busy downtown Kabul for three days
Photographs of the corpses appeared in news magazines and newspapers around the world
Abuses of Power
The Taliban imposed their harsh brand of Islamic law in the 90 percent of Afghanistan under their control
The Taliban say their version of Islam is a pure one that follows a literal interpretation of the Muslim holy book The Koran
Under Taliban laws murderers were publicly executed by the relatives of their victims
Adulterers are stoned to death and the limbs of thieves were amputated
Lesser crimes were punished by public beatings
Taliban brought order and fundamental Islam at a price
19
Taliban executing a rebel on the spot
Dead bodies left in the street to rot by Taliban in Heart People forbidden to bury the bodies
Executions by the Taliban
20
There were almost weekly executions or amputations of criminals in the Kabul stadium before November 1999 when a woman was killed for hacking to death her abusive husband
The hiatus in public executions after that was attributed to a decline in crime in the capital
Public amputations amp executions
21
Rules for Everyone
No television No music No movies No picnics No wedding parties No New Year celebrations No kind of mixed-sex gathering No childrens toys including dolls and kites No card and board games No cameras No photographs and paintings of people and animals No pet parakeets No cigarettes and alcohol No magazines and newspapers and most books They even forbade applause -- a moot point since there was nothing left to
applaud The only books available must be approved by the Taliban Enemies of the Taliban are put in jail Protesting is not permitted All windows must be painted black so that no-one is able to see inside Photographs are illegal
Rules for Everyone
Bamyan Buddha before (left) After the explosion (right)
Taliban intolerant destruction of Historic Buddhist Religious Art
24
Taliban Draws World Attention
In 2001 blew up ancient Buddhist statues (1500 years old) near city of Bamiyan
Allowed al-Qaeda amp Osama bin Laden to operate within the countryTo give one an idea of scale note the
two individuals sitting herehttpwwwusatodaycomnewssciencearchaeology2001-03-22-afghan-buddhashtm
Treatment of Women under Taliban Rule
February 27 1998 --Thirty-thousand men and boys poured into the sports stadium in Kabul capital of Afghanistan Nuts biscuits and tea were sold to the waiting crowd
The scheduled entertainment They were there to see a young woman receive 100 lashes and to watch two thieves have their right hands amputated The woman had been arrested walking with a man who was not a relative a sufficient crime for her to be found guilty of adultery Since she was single it was punishable by flogging had she been married she would have been publicly stoned to death
As the young woman completely covered in the shroud-like burqa veil was forced to kneel and then whipped Taliban cheerleaders had the stadium ringing with the chants of onlookers
Among those present there were just three women the young Afghan and two female relatives who had accompanied her
The crowd fell silent only when the thieves were driven into the arena and pushed to the ground
Physicians using surgical scalpels promptly carried out the amputations Holding the severed hands aloft by the index fingers a grinning Taliban fighter warned the huge crowd These are the chopped-off hands of thieves the punishment for any of you caught stealingldquo
Then to restore the party atmosphere the thieves were driven in a jeep once around the stadium a flourish that brought the crowd to their feet as was intended
It would probably be quicker to list what the Taliban hadnt banned The regime even outlawed paper bags Like many of their laws this would be laughable if the penalties werent so severe
Break the Talibans law and you risked imprisonment flogging or worse
In 1979 Afghanistan was invaded and eventually controlled by the Soviet Union
In 1989 Afghanistan and the Soviet Union signed a peace agreement
In 1995 the Taliban promising traditional Islamic values came into power imposing strict Islamic law including revoking many womenrsquos rights
In 2001 American troops force the Taliban from power
In 2004 Hamid Karzai became the first elected Afghan president
Late 1970s-2004
Taliban Rule
Gained strength in 1995 Formed by Sunni Muslim Pashtun students
intellectuals and disaffected Mujaheddin (holy warriors)
Trained in Pakistan fundamentalists committed to lsquoSharia Lawrsquo
(the traditional Islamic law and moral code that prescribes how Muslims should best conduct their lives)
Who is the Taliban
Under the Talibanrsquos rule human rights and civil liberties were slowly peeled away
bull The Taliban instituted cruel and inhumane treatment of those who opposed them in order to solidify their power over Afghanistanrsquos citizens
The Taliban (Talib is Arabic for lsquoIslamic studentrsquo)
Turmoil in Afghanistan continued and in the mid-1990rsquos a radical Muslim group called the Taliban arose
The Taliban took over most of Afghanistan and ruled strictly
The Taliban forced women to wear veils and stop working outside the home
Afghanistan History
Burka Fashion
AfghanistanTaliban came to
power in most Afghanistan by 1996
Osama bin Laden moved his terrorist activities there
Used mountain hideouts as a base of operations for his terrorist network called al-Qaeda
Map of Afghanistan in 1996 showing the amount of Taliban territory captured at that time (yellow) The Afghan Civil War commenced between 1996-2001 before coalition forces headed by the United States began air strikes against the Taliban
The TalibanPrior to 2001 the Taliban led by Mullah Mohammad Omar ruled Afghanistan under Islamic law
During this time women had virtually no rights and received no education
Watching television and listening to music were forbidden as were playing games and sports
The United States entered Afghanistan in October 2001 and replaced the Taliban with an elected president
While the Taliban lost some power and the people regained some rights the Taliban has not gone away
Instead it has worked to regain power by promising to help Afghanistanrsquos poorest people and aligning itself with warlords al-Qaida and other militant groups to gain financial support and recruit new fighters
Taliban Leader Mullah Mohammad Omar
Examples of abuses three men accused of a crime had been sentenced to death by being partially buried in the ground and then having a wall pushed over on them by a bulldozer a bizarre and labor-intensive form of execution dreamed up by the supreme leader of the Taliban
After another accused criminal was hanged his corpse was driven around the city swinging from a crane
A young woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man who was not her relative was stoned to death
On another occasion it was announced over the airwaves that 225 women had been rounded up and sentenced to a lashing for violating the dress code
When the Taliban castrated and then hanged the former communist president and his brother in 1996 they left their bloodied bodies dangling from lampposts in busy downtown Kabul for three days
Photographs of the corpses appeared in news magazines and newspapers around the world
Abuses of Power
The Taliban imposed their harsh brand of Islamic law in the 90 percent of Afghanistan under their control
The Taliban say their version of Islam is a pure one that follows a literal interpretation of the Muslim holy book The Koran
Under Taliban laws murderers were publicly executed by the relatives of their victims
Adulterers are stoned to death and the limbs of thieves were amputated
Lesser crimes were punished by public beatings
Taliban brought order and fundamental Islam at a price
19
Taliban executing a rebel on the spot
Dead bodies left in the street to rot by Taliban in Heart People forbidden to bury the bodies
Executions by the Taliban
20
There were almost weekly executions or amputations of criminals in the Kabul stadium before November 1999 when a woman was killed for hacking to death her abusive husband
The hiatus in public executions after that was attributed to a decline in crime in the capital
Public amputations amp executions
21
Rules for Everyone
No television No music No movies No picnics No wedding parties No New Year celebrations No kind of mixed-sex gathering No childrens toys including dolls and kites No card and board games No cameras No photographs and paintings of people and animals No pet parakeets No cigarettes and alcohol No magazines and newspapers and most books They even forbade applause -- a moot point since there was nothing left to
applaud The only books available must be approved by the Taliban Enemies of the Taliban are put in jail Protesting is not permitted All windows must be painted black so that no-one is able to see inside Photographs are illegal
Rules for Everyone
Bamyan Buddha before (left) After the explosion (right)
Taliban intolerant destruction of Historic Buddhist Religious Art
24
Taliban Draws World Attention
In 2001 blew up ancient Buddhist statues (1500 years old) near city of Bamiyan
Allowed al-Qaeda amp Osama bin Laden to operate within the countryTo give one an idea of scale note the
two individuals sitting herehttpwwwusatodaycomnewssciencearchaeology2001-03-22-afghan-buddhashtm
Treatment of Women under Taliban Rule
February 27 1998 --Thirty-thousand men and boys poured into the sports stadium in Kabul capital of Afghanistan Nuts biscuits and tea were sold to the waiting crowd
The scheduled entertainment They were there to see a young woman receive 100 lashes and to watch two thieves have their right hands amputated The woman had been arrested walking with a man who was not a relative a sufficient crime for her to be found guilty of adultery Since she was single it was punishable by flogging had she been married she would have been publicly stoned to death
As the young woman completely covered in the shroud-like burqa veil was forced to kneel and then whipped Taliban cheerleaders had the stadium ringing with the chants of onlookers
Among those present there were just three women the young Afghan and two female relatives who had accompanied her
The crowd fell silent only when the thieves were driven into the arena and pushed to the ground
Physicians using surgical scalpels promptly carried out the amputations Holding the severed hands aloft by the index fingers a grinning Taliban fighter warned the huge crowd These are the chopped-off hands of thieves the punishment for any of you caught stealingldquo
Then to restore the party atmosphere the thieves were driven in a jeep once around the stadium a flourish that brought the crowd to their feet as was intended
It would probably be quicker to list what the Taliban hadnt banned The regime even outlawed paper bags Like many of their laws this would be laughable if the penalties werent so severe
Break the Talibans law and you risked imprisonment flogging or worse
Taliban Rule
Gained strength in 1995 Formed by Sunni Muslim Pashtun students
intellectuals and disaffected Mujaheddin (holy warriors)
Trained in Pakistan fundamentalists committed to lsquoSharia Lawrsquo
(the traditional Islamic law and moral code that prescribes how Muslims should best conduct their lives)
Who is the Taliban
Under the Talibanrsquos rule human rights and civil liberties were slowly peeled away
bull The Taliban instituted cruel and inhumane treatment of those who opposed them in order to solidify their power over Afghanistanrsquos citizens
The Taliban (Talib is Arabic for lsquoIslamic studentrsquo)
Turmoil in Afghanistan continued and in the mid-1990rsquos a radical Muslim group called the Taliban arose
The Taliban took over most of Afghanistan and ruled strictly
The Taliban forced women to wear veils and stop working outside the home
Afghanistan History
Burka Fashion
AfghanistanTaliban came to
power in most Afghanistan by 1996
Osama bin Laden moved his terrorist activities there
Used mountain hideouts as a base of operations for his terrorist network called al-Qaeda
Map of Afghanistan in 1996 showing the amount of Taliban territory captured at that time (yellow) The Afghan Civil War commenced between 1996-2001 before coalition forces headed by the United States began air strikes against the Taliban
The TalibanPrior to 2001 the Taliban led by Mullah Mohammad Omar ruled Afghanistan under Islamic law
During this time women had virtually no rights and received no education
Watching television and listening to music were forbidden as were playing games and sports
The United States entered Afghanistan in October 2001 and replaced the Taliban with an elected president
While the Taliban lost some power and the people regained some rights the Taliban has not gone away
Instead it has worked to regain power by promising to help Afghanistanrsquos poorest people and aligning itself with warlords al-Qaida and other militant groups to gain financial support and recruit new fighters
Taliban Leader Mullah Mohammad Omar
Examples of abuses three men accused of a crime had been sentenced to death by being partially buried in the ground and then having a wall pushed over on them by a bulldozer a bizarre and labor-intensive form of execution dreamed up by the supreme leader of the Taliban
After another accused criminal was hanged his corpse was driven around the city swinging from a crane
A young woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man who was not her relative was stoned to death
On another occasion it was announced over the airwaves that 225 women had been rounded up and sentenced to a lashing for violating the dress code
When the Taliban castrated and then hanged the former communist president and his brother in 1996 they left their bloodied bodies dangling from lampposts in busy downtown Kabul for three days
Photographs of the corpses appeared in news magazines and newspapers around the world
Abuses of Power
The Taliban imposed their harsh brand of Islamic law in the 90 percent of Afghanistan under their control
The Taliban say their version of Islam is a pure one that follows a literal interpretation of the Muslim holy book The Koran
Under Taliban laws murderers were publicly executed by the relatives of their victims
Adulterers are stoned to death and the limbs of thieves were amputated
Lesser crimes were punished by public beatings
Taliban brought order and fundamental Islam at a price
19
Taliban executing a rebel on the spot
Dead bodies left in the street to rot by Taliban in Heart People forbidden to bury the bodies
Executions by the Taliban
20
There were almost weekly executions or amputations of criminals in the Kabul stadium before November 1999 when a woman was killed for hacking to death her abusive husband
The hiatus in public executions after that was attributed to a decline in crime in the capital
Public amputations amp executions
21
Rules for Everyone
No television No music No movies No picnics No wedding parties No New Year celebrations No kind of mixed-sex gathering No childrens toys including dolls and kites No card and board games No cameras No photographs and paintings of people and animals No pet parakeets No cigarettes and alcohol No magazines and newspapers and most books They even forbade applause -- a moot point since there was nothing left to
applaud The only books available must be approved by the Taliban Enemies of the Taliban are put in jail Protesting is not permitted All windows must be painted black so that no-one is able to see inside Photographs are illegal
Rules for Everyone
Bamyan Buddha before (left) After the explosion (right)
Taliban intolerant destruction of Historic Buddhist Religious Art
24
Taliban Draws World Attention
In 2001 blew up ancient Buddhist statues (1500 years old) near city of Bamiyan
Allowed al-Qaeda amp Osama bin Laden to operate within the countryTo give one an idea of scale note the
two individuals sitting herehttpwwwusatodaycomnewssciencearchaeology2001-03-22-afghan-buddhashtm
Treatment of Women under Taliban Rule
February 27 1998 --Thirty-thousand men and boys poured into the sports stadium in Kabul capital of Afghanistan Nuts biscuits and tea were sold to the waiting crowd
The scheduled entertainment They were there to see a young woman receive 100 lashes and to watch two thieves have their right hands amputated The woman had been arrested walking with a man who was not a relative a sufficient crime for her to be found guilty of adultery Since she was single it was punishable by flogging had she been married she would have been publicly stoned to death
As the young woman completely covered in the shroud-like burqa veil was forced to kneel and then whipped Taliban cheerleaders had the stadium ringing with the chants of onlookers
Among those present there were just three women the young Afghan and two female relatives who had accompanied her
The crowd fell silent only when the thieves were driven into the arena and pushed to the ground
Physicians using surgical scalpels promptly carried out the amputations Holding the severed hands aloft by the index fingers a grinning Taliban fighter warned the huge crowd These are the chopped-off hands of thieves the punishment for any of you caught stealingldquo
Then to restore the party atmosphere the thieves were driven in a jeep once around the stadium a flourish that brought the crowd to their feet as was intended
It would probably be quicker to list what the Taliban hadnt banned The regime even outlawed paper bags Like many of their laws this would be laughable if the penalties werent so severe
Break the Talibans law and you risked imprisonment flogging or worse
Gained strength in 1995 Formed by Sunni Muslim Pashtun students
intellectuals and disaffected Mujaheddin (holy warriors)
Trained in Pakistan fundamentalists committed to lsquoSharia Lawrsquo
(the traditional Islamic law and moral code that prescribes how Muslims should best conduct their lives)
Who is the Taliban
Under the Talibanrsquos rule human rights and civil liberties were slowly peeled away
bull The Taliban instituted cruel and inhumane treatment of those who opposed them in order to solidify their power over Afghanistanrsquos citizens
The Taliban (Talib is Arabic for lsquoIslamic studentrsquo)
Turmoil in Afghanistan continued and in the mid-1990rsquos a radical Muslim group called the Taliban arose
The Taliban took over most of Afghanistan and ruled strictly
The Taliban forced women to wear veils and stop working outside the home
Afghanistan History
Burka Fashion
AfghanistanTaliban came to
power in most Afghanistan by 1996
Osama bin Laden moved his terrorist activities there
Used mountain hideouts as a base of operations for his terrorist network called al-Qaeda
Map of Afghanistan in 1996 showing the amount of Taliban territory captured at that time (yellow) The Afghan Civil War commenced between 1996-2001 before coalition forces headed by the United States began air strikes against the Taliban
The TalibanPrior to 2001 the Taliban led by Mullah Mohammad Omar ruled Afghanistan under Islamic law
During this time women had virtually no rights and received no education
Watching television and listening to music were forbidden as were playing games and sports
The United States entered Afghanistan in October 2001 and replaced the Taliban with an elected president
While the Taliban lost some power and the people regained some rights the Taliban has not gone away
Instead it has worked to regain power by promising to help Afghanistanrsquos poorest people and aligning itself with warlords al-Qaida and other militant groups to gain financial support and recruit new fighters
Taliban Leader Mullah Mohammad Omar
Examples of abuses three men accused of a crime had been sentenced to death by being partially buried in the ground and then having a wall pushed over on them by a bulldozer a bizarre and labor-intensive form of execution dreamed up by the supreme leader of the Taliban
After another accused criminal was hanged his corpse was driven around the city swinging from a crane
A young woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man who was not her relative was stoned to death
On another occasion it was announced over the airwaves that 225 women had been rounded up and sentenced to a lashing for violating the dress code
When the Taliban castrated and then hanged the former communist president and his brother in 1996 they left their bloodied bodies dangling from lampposts in busy downtown Kabul for three days
Photographs of the corpses appeared in news magazines and newspapers around the world
Abuses of Power
The Taliban imposed their harsh brand of Islamic law in the 90 percent of Afghanistan under their control
The Taliban say their version of Islam is a pure one that follows a literal interpretation of the Muslim holy book The Koran
Under Taliban laws murderers were publicly executed by the relatives of their victims
Adulterers are stoned to death and the limbs of thieves were amputated
Lesser crimes were punished by public beatings
Taliban brought order and fundamental Islam at a price
19
Taliban executing a rebel on the spot
Dead bodies left in the street to rot by Taliban in Heart People forbidden to bury the bodies
Executions by the Taliban
20
There were almost weekly executions or amputations of criminals in the Kabul stadium before November 1999 when a woman was killed for hacking to death her abusive husband
The hiatus in public executions after that was attributed to a decline in crime in the capital
Public amputations amp executions
21
Rules for Everyone
No television No music No movies No picnics No wedding parties No New Year celebrations No kind of mixed-sex gathering No childrens toys including dolls and kites No card and board games No cameras No photographs and paintings of people and animals No pet parakeets No cigarettes and alcohol No magazines and newspapers and most books They even forbade applause -- a moot point since there was nothing left to
applaud The only books available must be approved by the Taliban Enemies of the Taliban are put in jail Protesting is not permitted All windows must be painted black so that no-one is able to see inside Photographs are illegal
Rules for Everyone
Bamyan Buddha before (left) After the explosion (right)
Taliban intolerant destruction of Historic Buddhist Religious Art
24
Taliban Draws World Attention
In 2001 blew up ancient Buddhist statues (1500 years old) near city of Bamiyan
Allowed al-Qaeda amp Osama bin Laden to operate within the countryTo give one an idea of scale note the
two individuals sitting herehttpwwwusatodaycomnewssciencearchaeology2001-03-22-afghan-buddhashtm
Treatment of Women under Taliban Rule
February 27 1998 --Thirty-thousand men and boys poured into the sports stadium in Kabul capital of Afghanistan Nuts biscuits and tea were sold to the waiting crowd
The scheduled entertainment They were there to see a young woman receive 100 lashes and to watch two thieves have their right hands amputated The woman had been arrested walking with a man who was not a relative a sufficient crime for her to be found guilty of adultery Since she was single it was punishable by flogging had she been married she would have been publicly stoned to death
As the young woman completely covered in the shroud-like burqa veil was forced to kneel and then whipped Taliban cheerleaders had the stadium ringing with the chants of onlookers
Among those present there were just three women the young Afghan and two female relatives who had accompanied her
The crowd fell silent only when the thieves were driven into the arena and pushed to the ground
Physicians using surgical scalpels promptly carried out the amputations Holding the severed hands aloft by the index fingers a grinning Taliban fighter warned the huge crowd These are the chopped-off hands of thieves the punishment for any of you caught stealingldquo
Then to restore the party atmosphere the thieves were driven in a jeep once around the stadium a flourish that brought the crowd to their feet as was intended
It would probably be quicker to list what the Taliban hadnt banned The regime even outlawed paper bags Like many of their laws this would be laughable if the penalties werent so severe
Break the Talibans law and you risked imprisonment flogging or worse
Under the Talibanrsquos rule human rights and civil liberties were slowly peeled away
bull The Taliban instituted cruel and inhumane treatment of those who opposed them in order to solidify their power over Afghanistanrsquos citizens
The Taliban (Talib is Arabic for lsquoIslamic studentrsquo)
Turmoil in Afghanistan continued and in the mid-1990rsquos a radical Muslim group called the Taliban arose
The Taliban took over most of Afghanistan and ruled strictly
The Taliban forced women to wear veils and stop working outside the home
Afghanistan History
Burka Fashion
AfghanistanTaliban came to
power in most Afghanistan by 1996
Osama bin Laden moved his terrorist activities there
Used mountain hideouts as a base of operations for his terrorist network called al-Qaeda
Map of Afghanistan in 1996 showing the amount of Taliban territory captured at that time (yellow) The Afghan Civil War commenced between 1996-2001 before coalition forces headed by the United States began air strikes against the Taliban
The TalibanPrior to 2001 the Taliban led by Mullah Mohammad Omar ruled Afghanistan under Islamic law
During this time women had virtually no rights and received no education
Watching television and listening to music were forbidden as were playing games and sports
The United States entered Afghanistan in October 2001 and replaced the Taliban with an elected president
While the Taliban lost some power and the people regained some rights the Taliban has not gone away
Instead it has worked to regain power by promising to help Afghanistanrsquos poorest people and aligning itself with warlords al-Qaida and other militant groups to gain financial support and recruit new fighters
Taliban Leader Mullah Mohammad Omar
Examples of abuses three men accused of a crime had been sentenced to death by being partially buried in the ground and then having a wall pushed over on them by a bulldozer a bizarre and labor-intensive form of execution dreamed up by the supreme leader of the Taliban
After another accused criminal was hanged his corpse was driven around the city swinging from a crane
A young woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man who was not her relative was stoned to death
On another occasion it was announced over the airwaves that 225 women had been rounded up and sentenced to a lashing for violating the dress code
When the Taliban castrated and then hanged the former communist president and his brother in 1996 they left their bloodied bodies dangling from lampposts in busy downtown Kabul for three days
Photographs of the corpses appeared in news magazines and newspapers around the world
Abuses of Power
The Taliban imposed their harsh brand of Islamic law in the 90 percent of Afghanistan under their control
The Taliban say their version of Islam is a pure one that follows a literal interpretation of the Muslim holy book The Koran
Under Taliban laws murderers were publicly executed by the relatives of their victims
Adulterers are stoned to death and the limbs of thieves were amputated
Lesser crimes were punished by public beatings
Taliban brought order and fundamental Islam at a price
19
Taliban executing a rebel on the spot
Dead bodies left in the street to rot by Taliban in Heart People forbidden to bury the bodies
Executions by the Taliban
20
There were almost weekly executions or amputations of criminals in the Kabul stadium before November 1999 when a woman was killed for hacking to death her abusive husband
The hiatus in public executions after that was attributed to a decline in crime in the capital
Public amputations amp executions
21
Rules for Everyone
No television No music No movies No picnics No wedding parties No New Year celebrations No kind of mixed-sex gathering No childrens toys including dolls and kites No card and board games No cameras No photographs and paintings of people and animals No pet parakeets No cigarettes and alcohol No magazines and newspapers and most books They even forbade applause -- a moot point since there was nothing left to
applaud The only books available must be approved by the Taliban Enemies of the Taliban are put in jail Protesting is not permitted All windows must be painted black so that no-one is able to see inside Photographs are illegal
Rules for Everyone
Bamyan Buddha before (left) After the explosion (right)
Taliban intolerant destruction of Historic Buddhist Religious Art
24
Taliban Draws World Attention
In 2001 blew up ancient Buddhist statues (1500 years old) near city of Bamiyan
Allowed al-Qaeda amp Osama bin Laden to operate within the countryTo give one an idea of scale note the
two individuals sitting herehttpwwwusatodaycomnewssciencearchaeology2001-03-22-afghan-buddhashtm
Treatment of Women under Taliban Rule
February 27 1998 --Thirty-thousand men and boys poured into the sports stadium in Kabul capital of Afghanistan Nuts biscuits and tea were sold to the waiting crowd
The scheduled entertainment They were there to see a young woman receive 100 lashes and to watch two thieves have their right hands amputated The woman had been arrested walking with a man who was not a relative a sufficient crime for her to be found guilty of adultery Since she was single it was punishable by flogging had she been married she would have been publicly stoned to death
As the young woman completely covered in the shroud-like burqa veil was forced to kneel and then whipped Taliban cheerleaders had the stadium ringing with the chants of onlookers
Among those present there were just three women the young Afghan and two female relatives who had accompanied her
The crowd fell silent only when the thieves were driven into the arena and pushed to the ground
Physicians using surgical scalpels promptly carried out the amputations Holding the severed hands aloft by the index fingers a grinning Taliban fighter warned the huge crowd These are the chopped-off hands of thieves the punishment for any of you caught stealingldquo
Then to restore the party atmosphere the thieves were driven in a jeep once around the stadium a flourish that brought the crowd to their feet as was intended
It would probably be quicker to list what the Taliban hadnt banned The regime even outlawed paper bags Like many of their laws this would be laughable if the penalties werent so severe
Break the Talibans law and you risked imprisonment flogging or worse
Turmoil in Afghanistan continued and in the mid-1990rsquos a radical Muslim group called the Taliban arose
The Taliban took over most of Afghanistan and ruled strictly
The Taliban forced women to wear veils and stop working outside the home
Afghanistan History
Burka Fashion
AfghanistanTaliban came to
power in most Afghanistan by 1996
Osama bin Laden moved his terrorist activities there
Used mountain hideouts as a base of operations for his terrorist network called al-Qaeda
Map of Afghanistan in 1996 showing the amount of Taliban territory captured at that time (yellow) The Afghan Civil War commenced between 1996-2001 before coalition forces headed by the United States began air strikes against the Taliban
The TalibanPrior to 2001 the Taliban led by Mullah Mohammad Omar ruled Afghanistan under Islamic law
During this time women had virtually no rights and received no education
Watching television and listening to music were forbidden as were playing games and sports
The United States entered Afghanistan in October 2001 and replaced the Taliban with an elected president
While the Taliban lost some power and the people regained some rights the Taliban has not gone away
Instead it has worked to regain power by promising to help Afghanistanrsquos poorest people and aligning itself with warlords al-Qaida and other militant groups to gain financial support and recruit new fighters
Taliban Leader Mullah Mohammad Omar
Examples of abuses three men accused of a crime had been sentenced to death by being partially buried in the ground and then having a wall pushed over on them by a bulldozer a bizarre and labor-intensive form of execution dreamed up by the supreme leader of the Taliban
After another accused criminal was hanged his corpse was driven around the city swinging from a crane
A young woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man who was not her relative was stoned to death
On another occasion it was announced over the airwaves that 225 women had been rounded up and sentenced to a lashing for violating the dress code
When the Taliban castrated and then hanged the former communist president and his brother in 1996 they left their bloodied bodies dangling from lampposts in busy downtown Kabul for three days
Photographs of the corpses appeared in news magazines and newspapers around the world
Abuses of Power
The Taliban imposed their harsh brand of Islamic law in the 90 percent of Afghanistan under their control
The Taliban say their version of Islam is a pure one that follows a literal interpretation of the Muslim holy book The Koran
Under Taliban laws murderers were publicly executed by the relatives of their victims
Adulterers are stoned to death and the limbs of thieves were amputated
Lesser crimes were punished by public beatings
Taliban brought order and fundamental Islam at a price
19
Taliban executing a rebel on the spot
Dead bodies left in the street to rot by Taliban in Heart People forbidden to bury the bodies
Executions by the Taliban
20
There were almost weekly executions or amputations of criminals in the Kabul stadium before November 1999 when a woman was killed for hacking to death her abusive husband
The hiatus in public executions after that was attributed to a decline in crime in the capital
Public amputations amp executions
21
Rules for Everyone
No television No music No movies No picnics No wedding parties No New Year celebrations No kind of mixed-sex gathering No childrens toys including dolls and kites No card and board games No cameras No photographs and paintings of people and animals No pet parakeets No cigarettes and alcohol No magazines and newspapers and most books They even forbade applause -- a moot point since there was nothing left to
applaud The only books available must be approved by the Taliban Enemies of the Taliban are put in jail Protesting is not permitted All windows must be painted black so that no-one is able to see inside Photographs are illegal
Rules for Everyone
Bamyan Buddha before (left) After the explosion (right)
Taliban intolerant destruction of Historic Buddhist Religious Art
24
Taliban Draws World Attention
In 2001 blew up ancient Buddhist statues (1500 years old) near city of Bamiyan
Allowed al-Qaeda amp Osama bin Laden to operate within the countryTo give one an idea of scale note the
two individuals sitting herehttpwwwusatodaycomnewssciencearchaeology2001-03-22-afghan-buddhashtm
Treatment of Women under Taliban Rule
February 27 1998 --Thirty-thousand men and boys poured into the sports stadium in Kabul capital of Afghanistan Nuts biscuits and tea were sold to the waiting crowd
The scheduled entertainment They were there to see a young woman receive 100 lashes and to watch two thieves have their right hands amputated The woman had been arrested walking with a man who was not a relative a sufficient crime for her to be found guilty of adultery Since she was single it was punishable by flogging had she been married she would have been publicly stoned to death
As the young woman completely covered in the shroud-like burqa veil was forced to kneel and then whipped Taliban cheerleaders had the stadium ringing with the chants of onlookers
Among those present there were just three women the young Afghan and two female relatives who had accompanied her
The crowd fell silent only when the thieves were driven into the arena and pushed to the ground
Physicians using surgical scalpels promptly carried out the amputations Holding the severed hands aloft by the index fingers a grinning Taliban fighter warned the huge crowd These are the chopped-off hands of thieves the punishment for any of you caught stealingldquo
Then to restore the party atmosphere the thieves were driven in a jeep once around the stadium a flourish that brought the crowd to their feet as was intended
It would probably be quicker to list what the Taliban hadnt banned The regime even outlawed paper bags Like many of their laws this would be laughable if the penalties werent so severe
Break the Talibans law and you risked imprisonment flogging or worse
Burka Fashion
AfghanistanTaliban came to
power in most Afghanistan by 1996
Osama bin Laden moved his terrorist activities there
Used mountain hideouts as a base of operations for his terrorist network called al-Qaeda
Map of Afghanistan in 1996 showing the amount of Taliban territory captured at that time (yellow) The Afghan Civil War commenced between 1996-2001 before coalition forces headed by the United States began air strikes against the Taliban
The TalibanPrior to 2001 the Taliban led by Mullah Mohammad Omar ruled Afghanistan under Islamic law
During this time women had virtually no rights and received no education
Watching television and listening to music were forbidden as were playing games and sports
The United States entered Afghanistan in October 2001 and replaced the Taliban with an elected president
While the Taliban lost some power and the people regained some rights the Taliban has not gone away
Instead it has worked to regain power by promising to help Afghanistanrsquos poorest people and aligning itself with warlords al-Qaida and other militant groups to gain financial support and recruit new fighters
Taliban Leader Mullah Mohammad Omar
Examples of abuses three men accused of a crime had been sentenced to death by being partially buried in the ground and then having a wall pushed over on them by a bulldozer a bizarre and labor-intensive form of execution dreamed up by the supreme leader of the Taliban
After another accused criminal was hanged his corpse was driven around the city swinging from a crane
A young woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man who was not her relative was stoned to death
On another occasion it was announced over the airwaves that 225 women had been rounded up and sentenced to a lashing for violating the dress code
When the Taliban castrated and then hanged the former communist president and his brother in 1996 they left their bloodied bodies dangling from lampposts in busy downtown Kabul for three days
Photographs of the corpses appeared in news magazines and newspapers around the world
Abuses of Power
The Taliban imposed their harsh brand of Islamic law in the 90 percent of Afghanistan under their control
The Taliban say their version of Islam is a pure one that follows a literal interpretation of the Muslim holy book The Koran
Under Taliban laws murderers were publicly executed by the relatives of their victims
Adulterers are stoned to death and the limbs of thieves were amputated
Lesser crimes were punished by public beatings
Taliban brought order and fundamental Islam at a price
19
Taliban executing a rebel on the spot
Dead bodies left in the street to rot by Taliban in Heart People forbidden to bury the bodies
Executions by the Taliban
20
There were almost weekly executions or amputations of criminals in the Kabul stadium before November 1999 when a woman was killed for hacking to death her abusive husband
The hiatus in public executions after that was attributed to a decline in crime in the capital
Public amputations amp executions
21
Rules for Everyone
No television No music No movies No picnics No wedding parties No New Year celebrations No kind of mixed-sex gathering No childrens toys including dolls and kites No card and board games No cameras No photographs and paintings of people and animals No pet parakeets No cigarettes and alcohol No magazines and newspapers and most books They even forbade applause -- a moot point since there was nothing left to
applaud The only books available must be approved by the Taliban Enemies of the Taliban are put in jail Protesting is not permitted All windows must be painted black so that no-one is able to see inside Photographs are illegal
Rules for Everyone
Bamyan Buddha before (left) After the explosion (right)
Taliban intolerant destruction of Historic Buddhist Religious Art
24
Taliban Draws World Attention
In 2001 blew up ancient Buddhist statues (1500 years old) near city of Bamiyan
Allowed al-Qaeda amp Osama bin Laden to operate within the countryTo give one an idea of scale note the
two individuals sitting herehttpwwwusatodaycomnewssciencearchaeology2001-03-22-afghan-buddhashtm
Treatment of Women under Taliban Rule
February 27 1998 --Thirty-thousand men and boys poured into the sports stadium in Kabul capital of Afghanistan Nuts biscuits and tea were sold to the waiting crowd
The scheduled entertainment They were there to see a young woman receive 100 lashes and to watch two thieves have their right hands amputated The woman had been arrested walking with a man who was not a relative a sufficient crime for her to be found guilty of adultery Since she was single it was punishable by flogging had she been married she would have been publicly stoned to death
As the young woman completely covered in the shroud-like burqa veil was forced to kneel and then whipped Taliban cheerleaders had the stadium ringing with the chants of onlookers
Among those present there were just three women the young Afghan and two female relatives who had accompanied her
The crowd fell silent only when the thieves were driven into the arena and pushed to the ground
Physicians using surgical scalpels promptly carried out the amputations Holding the severed hands aloft by the index fingers a grinning Taliban fighter warned the huge crowd These are the chopped-off hands of thieves the punishment for any of you caught stealingldquo
Then to restore the party atmosphere the thieves were driven in a jeep once around the stadium a flourish that brought the crowd to their feet as was intended
It would probably be quicker to list what the Taliban hadnt banned The regime even outlawed paper bags Like many of their laws this would be laughable if the penalties werent so severe
Break the Talibans law and you risked imprisonment flogging or worse
AfghanistanTaliban came to
power in most Afghanistan by 1996
Osama bin Laden moved his terrorist activities there
Used mountain hideouts as a base of operations for his terrorist network called al-Qaeda
Map of Afghanistan in 1996 showing the amount of Taliban territory captured at that time (yellow) The Afghan Civil War commenced between 1996-2001 before coalition forces headed by the United States began air strikes against the Taliban
The TalibanPrior to 2001 the Taliban led by Mullah Mohammad Omar ruled Afghanistan under Islamic law
During this time women had virtually no rights and received no education
Watching television and listening to music were forbidden as were playing games and sports
The United States entered Afghanistan in October 2001 and replaced the Taliban with an elected president
While the Taliban lost some power and the people regained some rights the Taliban has not gone away
Instead it has worked to regain power by promising to help Afghanistanrsquos poorest people and aligning itself with warlords al-Qaida and other militant groups to gain financial support and recruit new fighters
Taliban Leader Mullah Mohammad Omar
Examples of abuses three men accused of a crime had been sentenced to death by being partially buried in the ground and then having a wall pushed over on them by a bulldozer a bizarre and labor-intensive form of execution dreamed up by the supreme leader of the Taliban
After another accused criminal was hanged his corpse was driven around the city swinging from a crane
A young woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man who was not her relative was stoned to death
On another occasion it was announced over the airwaves that 225 women had been rounded up and sentenced to a lashing for violating the dress code
When the Taliban castrated and then hanged the former communist president and his brother in 1996 they left their bloodied bodies dangling from lampposts in busy downtown Kabul for three days
Photographs of the corpses appeared in news magazines and newspapers around the world
Abuses of Power
The Taliban imposed their harsh brand of Islamic law in the 90 percent of Afghanistan under their control
The Taliban say their version of Islam is a pure one that follows a literal interpretation of the Muslim holy book The Koran
Under Taliban laws murderers were publicly executed by the relatives of their victims
Adulterers are stoned to death and the limbs of thieves were amputated
Lesser crimes were punished by public beatings
Taliban brought order and fundamental Islam at a price
19
Taliban executing a rebel on the spot
Dead bodies left in the street to rot by Taliban in Heart People forbidden to bury the bodies
Executions by the Taliban
20
There were almost weekly executions or amputations of criminals in the Kabul stadium before November 1999 when a woman was killed for hacking to death her abusive husband
The hiatus in public executions after that was attributed to a decline in crime in the capital
Public amputations amp executions
21
Rules for Everyone
No television No music No movies No picnics No wedding parties No New Year celebrations No kind of mixed-sex gathering No childrens toys including dolls and kites No card and board games No cameras No photographs and paintings of people and animals No pet parakeets No cigarettes and alcohol No magazines and newspapers and most books They even forbade applause -- a moot point since there was nothing left to
applaud The only books available must be approved by the Taliban Enemies of the Taliban are put in jail Protesting is not permitted All windows must be painted black so that no-one is able to see inside Photographs are illegal
Rules for Everyone
Bamyan Buddha before (left) After the explosion (right)
Taliban intolerant destruction of Historic Buddhist Religious Art
24
Taliban Draws World Attention
In 2001 blew up ancient Buddhist statues (1500 years old) near city of Bamiyan
Allowed al-Qaeda amp Osama bin Laden to operate within the countryTo give one an idea of scale note the
two individuals sitting herehttpwwwusatodaycomnewssciencearchaeology2001-03-22-afghan-buddhashtm
Treatment of Women under Taliban Rule
February 27 1998 --Thirty-thousand men and boys poured into the sports stadium in Kabul capital of Afghanistan Nuts biscuits and tea were sold to the waiting crowd
The scheduled entertainment They were there to see a young woman receive 100 lashes and to watch two thieves have their right hands amputated The woman had been arrested walking with a man who was not a relative a sufficient crime for her to be found guilty of adultery Since she was single it was punishable by flogging had she been married she would have been publicly stoned to death
As the young woman completely covered in the shroud-like burqa veil was forced to kneel and then whipped Taliban cheerleaders had the stadium ringing with the chants of onlookers
Among those present there were just three women the young Afghan and two female relatives who had accompanied her
The crowd fell silent only when the thieves were driven into the arena and pushed to the ground
Physicians using surgical scalpels promptly carried out the amputations Holding the severed hands aloft by the index fingers a grinning Taliban fighter warned the huge crowd These are the chopped-off hands of thieves the punishment for any of you caught stealingldquo
Then to restore the party atmosphere the thieves were driven in a jeep once around the stadium a flourish that brought the crowd to their feet as was intended
It would probably be quicker to list what the Taliban hadnt banned The regime even outlawed paper bags Like many of their laws this would be laughable if the penalties werent so severe
Break the Talibans law and you risked imprisonment flogging or worse
The TalibanPrior to 2001 the Taliban led by Mullah Mohammad Omar ruled Afghanistan under Islamic law
During this time women had virtually no rights and received no education
Watching television and listening to music were forbidden as were playing games and sports
The United States entered Afghanistan in October 2001 and replaced the Taliban with an elected president
While the Taliban lost some power and the people regained some rights the Taliban has not gone away
Instead it has worked to regain power by promising to help Afghanistanrsquos poorest people and aligning itself with warlords al-Qaida and other militant groups to gain financial support and recruit new fighters
Taliban Leader Mullah Mohammad Omar
Examples of abuses three men accused of a crime had been sentenced to death by being partially buried in the ground and then having a wall pushed over on them by a bulldozer a bizarre and labor-intensive form of execution dreamed up by the supreme leader of the Taliban
After another accused criminal was hanged his corpse was driven around the city swinging from a crane
A young woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man who was not her relative was stoned to death
On another occasion it was announced over the airwaves that 225 women had been rounded up and sentenced to a lashing for violating the dress code
When the Taliban castrated and then hanged the former communist president and his brother in 1996 they left their bloodied bodies dangling from lampposts in busy downtown Kabul for three days
Photographs of the corpses appeared in news magazines and newspapers around the world
Abuses of Power
The Taliban imposed their harsh brand of Islamic law in the 90 percent of Afghanistan under their control
The Taliban say their version of Islam is a pure one that follows a literal interpretation of the Muslim holy book The Koran
Under Taliban laws murderers were publicly executed by the relatives of their victims
Adulterers are stoned to death and the limbs of thieves were amputated
Lesser crimes were punished by public beatings
Taliban brought order and fundamental Islam at a price
19
Taliban executing a rebel on the spot
Dead bodies left in the street to rot by Taliban in Heart People forbidden to bury the bodies
Executions by the Taliban
20
There were almost weekly executions or amputations of criminals in the Kabul stadium before November 1999 when a woman was killed for hacking to death her abusive husband
The hiatus in public executions after that was attributed to a decline in crime in the capital
Public amputations amp executions
21
Rules for Everyone
No television No music No movies No picnics No wedding parties No New Year celebrations No kind of mixed-sex gathering No childrens toys including dolls and kites No card and board games No cameras No photographs and paintings of people and animals No pet parakeets No cigarettes and alcohol No magazines and newspapers and most books They even forbade applause -- a moot point since there was nothing left to
applaud The only books available must be approved by the Taliban Enemies of the Taliban are put in jail Protesting is not permitted All windows must be painted black so that no-one is able to see inside Photographs are illegal
Rules for Everyone
Bamyan Buddha before (left) After the explosion (right)
Taliban intolerant destruction of Historic Buddhist Religious Art
24
Taliban Draws World Attention
In 2001 blew up ancient Buddhist statues (1500 years old) near city of Bamiyan
Allowed al-Qaeda amp Osama bin Laden to operate within the countryTo give one an idea of scale note the
two individuals sitting herehttpwwwusatodaycomnewssciencearchaeology2001-03-22-afghan-buddhashtm
Treatment of Women under Taliban Rule
February 27 1998 --Thirty-thousand men and boys poured into the sports stadium in Kabul capital of Afghanistan Nuts biscuits and tea were sold to the waiting crowd
The scheduled entertainment They were there to see a young woman receive 100 lashes and to watch two thieves have their right hands amputated The woman had been arrested walking with a man who was not a relative a sufficient crime for her to be found guilty of adultery Since she was single it was punishable by flogging had she been married she would have been publicly stoned to death
As the young woman completely covered in the shroud-like burqa veil was forced to kneel and then whipped Taliban cheerleaders had the stadium ringing with the chants of onlookers
Among those present there were just three women the young Afghan and two female relatives who had accompanied her
The crowd fell silent only when the thieves were driven into the arena and pushed to the ground
Physicians using surgical scalpels promptly carried out the amputations Holding the severed hands aloft by the index fingers a grinning Taliban fighter warned the huge crowd These are the chopped-off hands of thieves the punishment for any of you caught stealingldquo
Then to restore the party atmosphere the thieves were driven in a jeep once around the stadium a flourish that brought the crowd to their feet as was intended
It would probably be quicker to list what the Taliban hadnt banned The regime even outlawed paper bags Like many of their laws this would be laughable if the penalties werent so severe
Break the Talibans law and you risked imprisonment flogging or worse
Examples of abuses three men accused of a crime had been sentenced to death by being partially buried in the ground and then having a wall pushed over on them by a bulldozer a bizarre and labor-intensive form of execution dreamed up by the supreme leader of the Taliban
After another accused criminal was hanged his corpse was driven around the city swinging from a crane
A young woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man who was not her relative was stoned to death
On another occasion it was announced over the airwaves that 225 women had been rounded up and sentenced to a lashing for violating the dress code
When the Taliban castrated and then hanged the former communist president and his brother in 1996 they left their bloodied bodies dangling from lampposts in busy downtown Kabul for three days
Photographs of the corpses appeared in news magazines and newspapers around the world
Abuses of Power
The Taliban imposed their harsh brand of Islamic law in the 90 percent of Afghanistan under their control
The Taliban say their version of Islam is a pure one that follows a literal interpretation of the Muslim holy book The Koran
Under Taliban laws murderers were publicly executed by the relatives of their victims
Adulterers are stoned to death and the limbs of thieves were amputated
Lesser crimes were punished by public beatings
Taliban brought order and fundamental Islam at a price
19
Taliban executing a rebel on the spot
Dead bodies left in the street to rot by Taliban in Heart People forbidden to bury the bodies
Executions by the Taliban
20
There were almost weekly executions or amputations of criminals in the Kabul stadium before November 1999 when a woman was killed for hacking to death her abusive husband
The hiatus in public executions after that was attributed to a decline in crime in the capital
Public amputations amp executions
21
Rules for Everyone
No television No music No movies No picnics No wedding parties No New Year celebrations No kind of mixed-sex gathering No childrens toys including dolls and kites No card and board games No cameras No photographs and paintings of people and animals No pet parakeets No cigarettes and alcohol No magazines and newspapers and most books They even forbade applause -- a moot point since there was nothing left to
applaud The only books available must be approved by the Taliban Enemies of the Taliban are put in jail Protesting is not permitted All windows must be painted black so that no-one is able to see inside Photographs are illegal
Rules for Everyone
Bamyan Buddha before (left) After the explosion (right)
Taliban intolerant destruction of Historic Buddhist Religious Art
24
Taliban Draws World Attention
In 2001 blew up ancient Buddhist statues (1500 years old) near city of Bamiyan
Allowed al-Qaeda amp Osama bin Laden to operate within the countryTo give one an idea of scale note the
two individuals sitting herehttpwwwusatodaycomnewssciencearchaeology2001-03-22-afghan-buddhashtm
Treatment of Women under Taliban Rule
February 27 1998 --Thirty-thousand men and boys poured into the sports stadium in Kabul capital of Afghanistan Nuts biscuits and tea were sold to the waiting crowd
The scheduled entertainment They were there to see a young woman receive 100 lashes and to watch two thieves have their right hands amputated The woman had been arrested walking with a man who was not a relative a sufficient crime for her to be found guilty of adultery Since she was single it was punishable by flogging had she been married she would have been publicly stoned to death
As the young woman completely covered in the shroud-like burqa veil was forced to kneel and then whipped Taliban cheerleaders had the stadium ringing with the chants of onlookers
Among those present there were just three women the young Afghan and two female relatives who had accompanied her
The crowd fell silent only when the thieves were driven into the arena and pushed to the ground
Physicians using surgical scalpels promptly carried out the amputations Holding the severed hands aloft by the index fingers a grinning Taliban fighter warned the huge crowd These are the chopped-off hands of thieves the punishment for any of you caught stealingldquo
Then to restore the party atmosphere the thieves were driven in a jeep once around the stadium a flourish that brought the crowd to their feet as was intended
It would probably be quicker to list what the Taliban hadnt banned The regime even outlawed paper bags Like many of their laws this would be laughable if the penalties werent so severe
Break the Talibans law and you risked imprisonment flogging or worse
After another accused criminal was hanged his corpse was driven around the city swinging from a crane
A young woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man who was not her relative was stoned to death
On another occasion it was announced over the airwaves that 225 women had been rounded up and sentenced to a lashing for violating the dress code
When the Taliban castrated and then hanged the former communist president and his brother in 1996 they left their bloodied bodies dangling from lampposts in busy downtown Kabul for three days
Photographs of the corpses appeared in news magazines and newspapers around the world
Abuses of Power
The Taliban imposed their harsh brand of Islamic law in the 90 percent of Afghanistan under their control
The Taliban say their version of Islam is a pure one that follows a literal interpretation of the Muslim holy book The Koran
Under Taliban laws murderers were publicly executed by the relatives of their victims
Adulterers are stoned to death and the limbs of thieves were amputated
Lesser crimes were punished by public beatings
Taliban brought order and fundamental Islam at a price
19
Taliban executing a rebel on the spot
Dead bodies left in the street to rot by Taliban in Heart People forbidden to bury the bodies
Executions by the Taliban
20
There were almost weekly executions or amputations of criminals in the Kabul stadium before November 1999 when a woman was killed for hacking to death her abusive husband
The hiatus in public executions after that was attributed to a decline in crime in the capital
Public amputations amp executions
21
Rules for Everyone
No television No music No movies No picnics No wedding parties No New Year celebrations No kind of mixed-sex gathering No childrens toys including dolls and kites No card and board games No cameras No photographs and paintings of people and animals No pet parakeets No cigarettes and alcohol No magazines and newspapers and most books They even forbade applause -- a moot point since there was nothing left to
applaud The only books available must be approved by the Taliban Enemies of the Taliban are put in jail Protesting is not permitted All windows must be painted black so that no-one is able to see inside Photographs are illegal
Rules for Everyone
Bamyan Buddha before (left) After the explosion (right)
Taliban intolerant destruction of Historic Buddhist Religious Art
24
Taliban Draws World Attention
In 2001 blew up ancient Buddhist statues (1500 years old) near city of Bamiyan
Allowed al-Qaeda amp Osama bin Laden to operate within the countryTo give one an idea of scale note the
two individuals sitting herehttpwwwusatodaycomnewssciencearchaeology2001-03-22-afghan-buddhashtm
Treatment of Women under Taliban Rule
February 27 1998 --Thirty-thousand men and boys poured into the sports stadium in Kabul capital of Afghanistan Nuts biscuits and tea were sold to the waiting crowd
The scheduled entertainment They were there to see a young woman receive 100 lashes and to watch two thieves have their right hands amputated The woman had been arrested walking with a man who was not a relative a sufficient crime for her to be found guilty of adultery Since she was single it was punishable by flogging had she been married she would have been publicly stoned to death
As the young woman completely covered in the shroud-like burqa veil was forced to kneel and then whipped Taliban cheerleaders had the stadium ringing with the chants of onlookers
Among those present there were just three women the young Afghan and two female relatives who had accompanied her
The crowd fell silent only when the thieves were driven into the arena and pushed to the ground
Physicians using surgical scalpels promptly carried out the amputations Holding the severed hands aloft by the index fingers a grinning Taliban fighter warned the huge crowd These are the chopped-off hands of thieves the punishment for any of you caught stealingldquo
Then to restore the party atmosphere the thieves were driven in a jeep once around the stadium a flourish that brought the crowd to their feet as was intended
It would probably be quicker to list what the Taliban hadnt banned The regime even outlawed paper bags Like many of their laws this would be laughable if the penalties werent so severe
Break the Talibans law and you risked imprisonment flogging or worse
The Taliban imposed their harsh brand of Islamic law in the 90 percent of Afghanistan under their control
The Taliban say their version of Islam is a pure one that follows a literal interpretation of the Muslim holy book The Koran
Under Taliban laws murderers were publicly executed by the relatives of their victims
Adulterers are stoned to death and the limbs of thieves were amputated
Lesser crimes were punished by public beatings
Taliban brought order and fundamental Islam at a price
19
Taliban executing a rebel on the spot
Dead bodies left in the street to rot by Taliban in Heart People forbidden to bury the bodies
Executions by the Taliban
20
There were almost weekly executions or amputations of criminals in the Kabul stadium before November 1999 when a woman was killed for hacking to death her abusive husband
The hiatus in public executions after that was attributed to a decline in crime in the capital
Public amputations amp executions
21
Rules for Everyone
No television No music No movies No picnics No wedding parties No New Year celebrations No kind of mixed-sex gathering No childrens toys including dolls and kites No card and board games No cameras No photographs and paintings of people and animals No pet parakeets No cigarettes and alcohol No magazines and newspapers and most books They even forbade applause -- a moot point since there was nothing left to
applaud The only books available must be approved by the Taliban Enemies of the Taliban are put in jail Protesting is not permitted All windows must be painted black so that no-one is able to see inside Photographs are illegal
Rules for Everyone
Bamyan Buddha before (left) After the explosion (right)
Taliban intolerant destruction of Historic Buddhist Religious Art
24
Taliban Draws World Attention
In 2001 blew up ancient Buddhist statues (1500 years old) near city of Bamiyan
Allowed al-Qaeda amp Osama bin Laden to operate within the countryTo give one an idea of scale note the
two individuals sitting herehttpwwwusatodaycomnewssciencearchaeology2001-03-22-afghan-buddhashtm
Treatment of Women under Taliban Rule
February 27 1998 --Thirty-thousand men and boys poured into the sports stadium in Kabul capital of Afghanistan Nuts biscuits and tea were sold to the waiting crowd
The scheduled entertainment They were there to see a young woman receive 100 lashes and to watch two thieves have their right hands amputated The woman had been arrested walking with a man who was not a relative a sufficient crime for her to be found guilty of adultery Since she was single it was punishable by flogging had she been married she would have been publicly stoned to death
As the young woman completely covered in the shroud-like burqa veil was forced to kneel and then whipped Taliban cheerleaders had the stadium ringing with the chants of onlookers
Among those present there were just three women the young Afghan and two female relatives who had accompanied her
The crowd fell silent only when the thieves were driven into the arena and pushed to the ground
Physicians using surgical scalpels promptly carried out the amputations Holding the severed hands aloft by the index fingers a grinning Taliban fighter warned the huge crowd These are the chopped-off hands of thieves the punishment for any of you caught stealingldquo
Then to restore the party atmosphere the thieves were driven in a jeep once around the stadium a flourish that brought the crowd to their feet as was intended
It would probably be quicker to list what the Taliban hadnt banned The regime even outlawed paper bags Like many of their laws this would be laughable if the penalties werent so severe
Break the Talibans law and you risked imprisonment flogging or worse
Taliban executing a rebel on the spot
Dead bodies left in the street to rot by Taliban in Heart People forbidden to bury the bodies
Executions by the Taliban
20
There were almost weekly executions or amputations of criminals in the Kabul stadium before November 1999 when a woman was killed for hacking to death her abusive husband
The hiatus in public executions after that was attributed to a decline in crime in the capital
Public amputations amp executions
21
Rules for Everyone
No television No music No movies No picnics No wedding parties No New Year celebrations No kind of mixed-sex gathering No childrens toys including dolls and kites No card and board games No cameras No photographs and paintings of people and animals No pet parakeets No cigarettes and alcohol No magazines and newspapers and most books They even forbade applause -- a moot point since there was nothing left to
applaud The only books available must be approved by the Taliban Enemies of the Taliban are put in jail Protesting is not permitted All windows must be painted black so that no-one is able to see inside Photographs are illegal
Rules for Everyone
Bamyan Buddha before (left) After the explosion (right)
Taliban intolerant destruction of Historic Buddhist Religious Art
24
Taliban Draws World Attention
In 2001 blew up ancient Buddhist statues (1500 years old) near city of Bamiyan
Allowed al-Qaeda amp Osama bin Laden to operate within the countryTo give one an idea of scale note the
two individuals sitting herehttpwwwusatodaycomnewssciencearchaeology2001-03-22-afghan-buddhashtm
Treatment of Women under Taliban Rule
February 27 1998 --Thirty-thousand men and boys poured into the sports stadium in Kabul capital of Afghanistan Nuts biscuits and tea were sold to the waiting crowd
The scheduled entertainment They were there to see a young woman receive 100 lashes and to watch two thieves have their right hands amputated The woman had been arrested walking with a man who was not a relative a sufficient crime for her to be found guilty of adultery Since she was single it was punishable by flogging had she been married she would have been publicly stoned to death
As the young woman completely covered in the shroud-like burqa veil was forced to kneel and then whipped Taliban cheerleaders had the stadium ringing with the chants of onlookers
Among those present there were just three women the young Afghan and two female relatives who had accompanied her
The crowd fell silent only when the thieves were driven into the arena and pushed to the ground
Physicians using surgical scalpels promptly carried out the amputations Holding the severed hands aloft by the index fingers a grinning Taliban fighter warned the huge crowd These are the chopped-off hands of thieves the punishment for any of you caught stealingldquo
Then to restore the party atmosphere the thieves were driven in a jeep once around the stadium a flourish that brought the crowd to their feet as was intended
It would probably be quicker to list what the Taliban hadnt banned The regime even outlawed paper bags Like many of their laws this would be laughable if the penalties werent so severe
Break the Talibans law and you risked imprisonment flogging or worse
There were almost weekly executions or amputations of criminals in the Kabul stadium before November 1999 when a woman was killed for hacking to death her abusive husband
The hiatus in public executions after that was attributed to a decline in crime in the capital
Public amputations amp executions
21
Rules for Everyone
No television No music No movies No picnics No wedding parties No New Year celebrations No kind of mixed-sex gathering No childrens toys including dolls and kites No card and board games No cameras No photographs and paintings of people and animals No pet parakeets No cigarettes and alcohol No magazines and newspapers and most books They even forbade applause -- a moot point since there was nothing left to
applaud The only books available must be approved by the Taliban Enemies of the Taliban are put in jail Protesting is not permitted All windows must be painted black so that no-one is able to see inside Photographs are illegal
Rules for Everyone
Bamyan Buddha before (left) After the explosion (right)
Taliban intolerant destruction of Historic Buddhist Religious Art
24
Taliban Draws World Attention
In 2001 blew up ancient Buddhist statues (1500 years old) near city of Bamiyan
Allowed al-Qaeda amp Osama bin Laden to operate within the countryTo give one an idea of scale note the
two individuals sitting herehttpwwwusatodaycomnewssciencearchaeology2001-03-22-afghan-buddhashtm
Treatment of Women under Taliban Rule
February 27 1998 --Thirty-thousand men and boys poured into the sports stadium in Kabul capital of Afghanistan Nuts biscuits and tea were sold to the waiting crowd
The scheduled entertainment They were there to see a young woman receive 100 lashes and to watch two thieves have their right hands amputated The woman had been arrested walking with a man who was not a relative a sufficient crime for her to be found guilty of adultery Since she was single it was punishable by flogging had she been married she would have been publicly stoned to death
As the young woman completely covered in the shroud-like burqa veil was forced to kneel and then whipped Taliban cheerleaders had the stadium ringing with the chants of onlookers
Among those present there were just three women the young Afghan and two female relatives who had accompanied her
The crowd fell silent only when the thieves were driven into the arena and pushed to the ground
Physicians using surgical scalpels promptly carried out the amputations Holding the severed hands aloft by the index fingers a grinning Taliban fighter warned the huge crowd These are the chopped-off hands of thieves the punishment for any of you caught stealingldquo
Then to restore the party atmosphere the thieves were driven in a jeep once around the stadium a flourish that brought the crowd to their feet as was intended
It would probably be quicker to list what the Taliban hadnt banned The regime even outlawed paper bags Like many of their laws this would be laughable if the penalties werent so severe
Break the Talibans law and you risked imprisonment flogging or worse
Rules for Everyone
No television No music No movies No picnics No wedding parties No New Year celebrations No kind of mixed-sex gathering No childrens toys including dolls and kites No card and board games No cameras No photographs and paintings of people and animals No pet parakeets No cigarettes and alcohol No magazines and newspapers and most books They even forbade applause -- a moot point since there was nothing left to
applaud The only books available must be approved by the Taliban Enemies of the Taliban are put in jail Protesting is not permitted All windows must be painted black so that no-one is able to see inside Photographs are illegal
Rules for Everyone
Bamyan Buddha before (left) After the explosion (right)
Taliban intolerant destruction of Historic Buddhist Religious Art
24
Taliban Draws World Attention
In 2001 blew up ancient Buddhist statues (1500 years old) near city of Bamiyan
Allowed al-Qaeda amp Osama bin Laden to operate within the countryTo give one an idea of scale note the
two individuals sitting herehttpwwwusatodaycomnewssciencearchaeology2001-03-22-afghan-buddhashtm
Treatment of Women under Taliban Rule
February 27 1998 --Thirty-thousand men and boys poured into the sports stadium in Kabul capital of Afghanistan Nuts biscuits and tea were sold to the waiting crowd
The scheduled entertainment They were there to see a young woman receive 100 lashes and to watch two thieves have their right hands amputated The woman had been arrested walking with a man who was not a relative a sufficient crime for her to be found guilty of adultery Since she was single it was punishable by flogging had she been married she would have been publicly stoned to death
As the young woman completely covered in the shroud-like burqa veil was forced to kneel and then whipped Taliban cheerleaders had the stadium ringing with the chants of onlookers
Among those present there were just three women the young Afghan and two female relatives who had accompanied her
The crowd fell silent only when the thieves were driven into the arena and pushed to the ground
Physicians using surgical scalpels promptly carried out the amputations Holding the severed hands aloft by the index fingers a grinning Taliban fighter warned the huge crowd These are the chopped-off hands of thieves the punishment for any of you caught stealingldquo
Then to restore the party atmosphere the thieves were driven in a jeep once around the stadium a flourish that brought the crowd to their feet as was intended
It would probably be quicker to list what the Taliban hadnt banned The regime even outlawed paper bags Like many of their laws this would be laughable if the penalties werent so severe
Break the Talibans law and you risked imprisonment flogging or worse
No television No music No movies No picnics No wedding parties No New Year celebrations No kind of mixed-sex gathering No childrens toys including dolls and kites No card and board games No cameras No photographs and paintings of people and animals No pet parakeets No cigarettes and alcohol No magazines and newspapers and most books They even forbade applause -- a moot point since there was nothing left to
applaud The only books available must be approved by the Taliban Enemies of the Taliban are put in jail Protesting is not permitted All windows must be painted black so that no-one is able to see inside Photographs are illegal
Rules for Everyone
Bamyan Buddha before (left) After the explosion (right)
Taliban intolerant destruction of Historic Buddhist Religious Art
24
Taliban Draws World Attention
In 2001 blew up ancient Buddhist statues (1500 years old) near city of Bamiyan
Allowed al-Qaeda amp Osama bin Laden to operate within the countryTo give one an idea of scale note the
two individuals sitting herehttpwwwusatodaycomnewssciencearchaeology2001-03-22-afghan-buddhashtm
Treatment of Women under Taliban Rule
February 27 1998 --Thirty-thousand men and boys poured into the sports stadium in Kabul capital of Afghanistan Nuts biscuits and tea were sold to the waiting crowd
The scheduled entertainment They were there to see a young woman receive 100 lashes and to watch two thieves have their right hands amputated The woman had been arrested walking with a man who was not a relative a sufficient crime for her to be found guilty of adultery Since she was single it was punishable by flogging had she been married she would have been publicly stoned to death
As the young woman completely covered in the shroud-like burqa veil was forced to kneel and then whipped Taliban cheerleaders had the stadium ringing with the chants of onlookers
Among those present there were just three women the young Afghan and two female relatives who had accompanied her
The crowd fell silent only when the thieves were driven into the arena and pushed to the ground
Physicians using surgical scalpels promptly carried out the amputations Holding the severed hands aloft by the index fingers a grinning Taliban fighter warned the huge crowd These are the chopped-off hands of thieves the punishment for any of you caught stealingldquo
Then to restore the party atmosphere the thieves were driven in a jeep once around the stadium a flourish that brought the crowd to their feet as was intended
It would probably be quicker to list what the Taliban hadnt banned The regime even outlawed paper bags Like many of their laws this would be laughable if the penalties werent so severe
Break the Talibans law and you risked imprisonment flogging or worse
Bamyan Buddha before (left) After the explosion (right)
Taliban intolerant destruction of Historic Buddhist Religious Art
24
Taliban Draws World Attention
In 2001 blew up ancient Buddhist statues (1500 years old) near city of Bamiyan
Allowed al-Qaeda amp Osama bin Laden to operate within the countryTo give one an idea of scale note the
two individuals sitting herehttpwwwusatodaycomnewssciencearchaeology2001-03-22-afghan-buddhashtm
Treatment of Women under Taliban Rule
February 27 1998 --Thirty-thousand men and boys poured into the sports stadium in Kabul capital of Afghanistan Nuts biscuits and tea were sold to the waiting crowd
The scheduled entertainment They were there to see a young woman receive 100 lashes and to watch two thieves have their right hands amputated The woman had been arrested walking with a man who was not a relative a sufficient crime for her to be found guilty of adultery Since she was single it was punishable by flogging had she been married she would have been publicly stoned to death
As the young woman completely covered in the shroud-like burqa veil was forced to kneel and then whipped Taliban cheerleaders had the stadium ringing with the chants of onlookers
Among those present there were just three women the young Afghan and two female relatives who had accompanied her
The crowd fell silent only when the thieves were driven into the arena and pushed to the ground
Physicians using surgical scalpels promptly carried out the amputations Holding the severed hands aloft by the index fingers a grinning Taliban fighter warned the huge crowd These are the chopped-off hands of thieves the punishment for any of you caught stealingldquo
Then to restore the party atmosphere the thieves were driven in a jeep once around the stadium a flourish that brought the crowd to their feet as was intended
It would probably be quicker to list what the Taliban hadnt banned The regime even outlawed paper bags Like many of their laws this would be laughable if the penalties werent so severe
Break the Talibans law and you risked imprisonment flogging or worse
Taliban Draws World Attention
In 2001 blew up ancient Buddhist statues (1500 years old) near city of Bamiyan
Allowed al-Qaeda amp Osama bin Laden to operate within the countryTo give one an idea of scale note the
two individuals sitting herehttpwwwusatodaycomnewssciencearchaeology2001-03-22-afghan-buddhashtm
Treatment of Women under Taliban Rule
February 27 1998 --Thirty-thousand men and boys poured into the sports stadium in Kabul capital of Afghanistan Nuts biscuits and tea were sold to the waiting crowd
The scheduled entertainment They were there to see a young woman receive 100 lashes and to watch two thieves have their right hands amputated The woman had been arrested walking with a man who was not a relative a sufficient crime for her to be found guilty of adultery Since she was single it was punishable by flogging had she been married she would have been publicly stoned to death
As the young woman completely covered in the shroud-like burqa veil was forced to kneel and then whipped Taliban cheerleaders had the stadium ringing with the chants of onlookers
Among those present there were just three women the young Afghan and two female relatives who had accompanied her
The crowd fell silent only when the thieves were driven into the arena and pushed to the ground
Physicians using surgical scalpels promptly carried out the amputations Holding the severed hands aloft by the index fingers a grinning Taliban fighter warned the huge crowd These are the chopped-off hands of thieves the punishment for any of you caught stealingldquo
Then to restore the party atmosphere the thieves were driven in a jeep once around the stadium a flourish that brought the crowd to their feet as was intended
It would probably be quicker to list what the Taliban hadnt banned The regime even outlawed paper bags Like many of their laws this would be laughable if the penalties werent so severe
Break the Talibans law and you risked imprisonment flogging or worse
Treatment of Women under Taliban Rule
February 27 1998 --Thirty-thousand men and boys poured into the sports stadium in Kabul capital of Afghanistan Nuts biscuits and tea were sold to the waiting crowd
The scheduled entertainment They were there to see a young woman receive 100 lashes and to watch two thieves have their right hands amputated The woman had been arrested walking with a man who was not a relative a sufficient crime for her to be found guilty of adultery Since she was single it was punishable by flogging had she been married she would have been publicly stoned to death
As the young woman completely covered in the shroud-like burqa veil was forced to kneel and then whipped Taliban cheerleaders had the stadium ringing with the chants of onlookers
Among those present there were just three women the young Afghan and two female relatives who had accompanied her
The crowd fell silent only when the thieves were driven into the arena and pushed to the ground
Physicians using surgical scalpels promptly carried out the amputations Holding the severed hands aloft by the index fingers a grinning Taliban fighter warned the huge crowd These are the chopped-off hands of thieves the punishment for any of you caught stealingldquo
Then to restore the party atmosphere the thieves were driven in a jeep once around the stadium a flourish that brought the crowd to their feet as was intended
It would probably be quicker to list what the Taliban hadnt banned The regime even outlawed paper bags Like many of their laws this would be laughable if the penalties werent so severe
Break the Talibans law and you risked imprisonment flogging or worse
February 27 1998 --Thirty-thousand men and boys poured into the sports stadium in Kabul capital of Afghanistan Nuts biscuits and tea were sold to the waiting crowd
The scheduled entertainment They were there to see a young woman receive 100 lashes and to watch two thieves have their right hands amputated The woman had been arrested walking with a man who was not a relative a sufficient crime for her to be found guilty of adultery Since she was single it was punishable by flogging had she been married she would have been publicly stoned to death
As the young woman completely covered in the shroud-like burqa veil was forced to kneel and then whipped Taliban cheerleaders had the stadium ringing with the chants of onlookers
Among those present there were just three women the young Afghan and two female relatives who had accompanied her
The crowd fell silent only when the thieves were driven into the arena and pushed to the ground
Physicians using surgical scalpels promptly carried out the amputations Holding the severed hands aloft by the index fingers a grinning Taliban fighter warned the huge crowd These are the chopped-off hands of thieves the punishment for any of you caught stealingldquo
Then to restore the party atmosphere the thieves were driven in a jeep once around the stadium a flourish that brought the crowd to their feet as was intended
It would probably be quicker to list what the Taliban hadnt banned The regime even outlawed paper bags Like many of their laws this would be laughable if the penalties werent so severe
Break the Talibans law and you risked imprisonment flogging or worse
As the young woman completely covered in the shroud-like burqa veil was forced to kneel and then whipped Taliban cheerleaders had the stadium ringing with the chants of onlookers
Among those present there were just three women the young Afghan and two female relatives who had accompanied her
The crowd fell silent only when the thieves were driven into the arena and pushed to the ground
Physicians using surgical scalpels promptly carried out the amputations Holding the severed hands aloft by the index fingers a grinning Taliban fighter warned the huge crowd These are the chopped-off hands of thieves the punishment for any of you caught stealingldquo
Then to restore the party atmosphere the thieves were driven in a jeep once around the stadium a flourish that brought the crowd to their feet as was intended
It would probably be quicker to list what the Taliban hadnt banned The regime even outlawed paper bags Like many of their laws this would be laughable if the penalties werent so severe
Break the Talibans law and you risked imprisonment flogging or worse
The crowd fell silent only when the thieves were driven into the arena and pushed to the ground
Physicians using surgical scalpels promptly carried out the amputations Holding the severed hands aloft by the index fingers a grinning Taliban fighter warned the huge crowd These are the chopped-off hands of thieves the punishment for any of you caught stealingldquo
Then to restore the party atmosphere the thieves were driven in a jeep once around the stadium a flourish that brought the crowd to their feet as was intended
It would probably be quicker to list what the Taliban hadnt banned The regime even outlawed paper bags Like many of their laws this would be laughable if the penalties werent so severe
Break the Talibans law and you risked imprisonment flogging or worse
It would probably be quicker to list what the Taliban hadnt banned The regime even outlawed paper bags Like many of their laws this would be laughable if the penalties werent so severe
Break the Talibans law and you risked imprisonment flogging or worse
Freedom from Fear
Freedom to Vote
Freedom of Speech
Freedom from Torture
Freedom of Choice
Freedom of Religion
Freedom from enslavement
May not work outside the homeMay not participate in any activity outside the home unless accompanied by her husband or male relative (no shopping walkinghellip)May not be treated by male doctorMay not study at any institutions including schools and universities
Taliban Rules for Womenbull Must wear the long veil (burqaburka) which covers them from head to toe
bull If found guilty of adultery will be publically stoned to death
bull May not laugh loudly ndash no stranger should hear a womanrsquos voice
bull May not wear high heels ndash no man should hear a womanrsquos footsteps
Before During After
Women carried out businesses transactions
Education for women and their right to vote was introduced to the constitution in 1964
Job positions held by women- 70 teachers- 50 civil servants- 40 doctors
Taliban took over in the 1990rsquos
Restricted and violated womenrsquos right on education work and freedom of movement
Imposed harsh penalties on women for breaking such rules Eg public lashings
Restricted access to health care services
Strict dress code
Taliban was overthrown in 2001
Over one million girls are attending school
Access to health care services
Afghan government and NGO has set up programs to improve womenrsquos status and public participations
Women were educated amp employed50 of students
70 of teachers 50 government workers40 of doctors
Prior To the Taliban
bull Before the Taliban took over women
had the right to education were
represented in government and
worked in offices
Forty percent of the countrys doctors
were women
Life for Women Before Taliban
No Rights At All Discrimination Against Afghanistan Women In Afganistan the year 1996 the Tailbanian took over and began their enforcement of laws mostly against women Some laws include
bull Girls over 12 must wear a burqa
bull Girls over 12 are forbidden to leave the home without a male relative and cannot go to WORK or SCHOOL
bull No video cassettes music cameras
bull No white socks
bull In every house where a women lives the windows must be painted black
Treatment of Women in Taliban-controlled Afghanistan
Taliban rules WomenMust always be escorted in public
by male relative and wearing burqa
Must not wear high heeled shoes (sound of womenrsquos footsteps excite men)
Cannot speak in publicWomen cannot be seen from street
mdashall ground and first floor windows must be painted over
No photography of womenPlace names not to be womenrsquosMay not appear on balconiesMay not appear in the media
Above a Taliban religious policeman beats a woman in for being in public without a male relative Left Afghan women are dressed in the burqa
Must wear a burqa outside their home Must wear a burqa inside if a male is present
In public women
must be covered from
head to toe by a
burqa an oppressive
garment that has only
a tiny mesh opening
over the eyes
Through the burga the woman is unable to breath or see properly
She is unable to feel the sunshine or receive beneficial vitamin C from the sun
View through a veil or burka which all Afghan women are required to wear outside the home
Restricted vision has reportedly caused numerous accidents involving vehicles and women pedestrians
View Through the Burka
43
Since enforced veiling a growing number of women have been hit by vehicles because the burqa leaves them unable to walk fast or see where they are going
Once a Taliban tank rolled right over a veiled woman
Fortunately she fell between the tracks
Instead of being crushed to death she was not seriously hurt but was severely traumatized
Laws under the Taliban
Its now illegal to wear makeup nail polish
jewelry pluck your eyebrows cut your hair
short wear colorful or stylish clothes sheer
stockings white socks and shoes high heel
shoes walk loudly talk loudly laugh in
public or to participate in sports
One woman had the top of her thumb amputated for the crime of wearing nail polish
Female education from kindergarten through graduate school banned
Must do all of the household chores
Must not travel on a bus without a man or note authorizing permission
Employment for women banned
In fact the government didnt believe women should go out at all Women you should not step outside your residence read one of the Taliban dictates
Beating women (left)Executing a woman publicly (right)
Harsh Treatment of Women by Taliban
51
A young mother Torpeka was shot repeatedly by the Taliban while rushing her seriously ill toddler to a doctor
Veiled as the law requires she was spotted by a teenage Taliban guard who tried to stop her because she shouldnt have left her home
Afraid her child might die if she were delayed Torpeka kept going
The guard aimed his machine-gun and fired several rounds directly at her
She was hit but didnt die on the spot as she could have Instead Afghans watching the incident in the marketplace
stepped in and Torpeka and her child received prompt medical attention
When her family later complained to the Taliban authorities they were informed that it was the injured womans fault
She had no right being out in public in the first place
The Taliban took control of
Kabul on Sept 26 1996 and
began a reign of terror
Because of the civil unrest
many Afghan women are
widows -- there are 30000 in
Kabul alone - without close
male relatives and they are the
sole supporters of their
children
15000 women in the Kabul region of Afghanistan are widows but the law of the Taliban the Islamic fundamentalist groups that rule the region forbids them from leaving their homes without a male family member as an escort (John MooreAP Photo)
Yet by Taliban law they are unable to work to support the children or leave the house without a male family member to buy food
If there isnrsquot a male family member they face the possibility of a beating every time they leave their home
There are a few supplemental houses which provide free food to widows and orphans but many are forced to beg in the streets for money
Thousands of Afghan war-widows have no other option but to beg to save their children from hunger Any Taliban man can flog these ill-fated women in the streets because most of them have to leave their houses without a close male relative
Afghan women begging to survive
Talibs like these boys are authorized to use weapons and whips on women if they decide any are breaking the Talibans repressive laws
Taliban ldquoreligious policerdquo beating a woman in public
Prohibited women and girls from
being examined by male physicians
while at the same time prohibited
most female doctors and nurses
from working
There were only a few selected
female doctors allowed to operate
in segregated wards
Medical Issues for Women
At one of the rare hospitals for women a
reporter found still nearly lifeless
bodies lying motionless on top of beds
wrapped in their burqua unwilling to
speak eat or do anything but slowly
wasting away
Others have gone mad and were seen
crouched in corners perpetually rocking
or crying most of them in fear
Medical Issues for Women
Conditions were so deplorable for women under the Taliban that many became severely depressed
Without the resources to leave the country an increasing number were choosing suicide once rare there as a means of escape
Doctors are seeing a lot of esophageal burns Women are swallowing battery acid or poisonous household cleansers because they are easy to find But its a very painful way to die
Medical Issues for Women
Women have died of treatable ailments because male doctors were not allowed to treat them
Many women now forcibly housebound have attempted suicide by swallowing household cleaner rather than continuing to live under these conditions
97 of Afghan women surveyed by Physicians for Human Rights exhibit signs of major depression
The Medical Results of a Taliban Rule
At a huge risk of women students continue their education in an underground school
A woman who dared to defy Taliban orders by running a home school for girls was shot and killed in front of her husband daughter and students
A woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man not related to her was stoned to death for adultery
An elderly woman was brutally beaten with a metal cable until her leg was broken because her ankle was accidentally showing from underneath her burqa
The Consequences Breaking a Taliban Rule
Although the new constitution guarantees equal rights an opportunities for both men and womenhellipthat is not always the case
Health careChild birth
highest maternal death ratein the world
Male doctorsMen amp boys take precedence
in the few emergency rooms that exist (very few hospitals after Taliban rule)
Unequal opportunities jobs divorce custody
Women Today
Taliban Insurgencies ndash harsh policies for womenAfghanistanrsquos Human Rights Commission
1500 atrocities against women (2008)13 domestic violence cases200 forcibly married98 set themselves on fire100+ tried to commit suicide
by taking poisonIncreasing number of women
taking drugsJudgments against women (Jirgas)New ldquoRape Lawrdquo against Shiite women
Womenrsquos Problems
Imagine your were an older woman who lived under the prior government and was used to all the freedoms
How would you feel now that you are under the control of the Taliban
How is your life differentExplain
On your Left Side
The September 11 2001 terrorist attacks were traced to Osama bin Laden and his al Qaeda network based in Afghanistan
Afghanistan History
On your Left SideWhat do your remember of Sept 11 2001Where were you
Al-Qaeda Defined A very complex
organization that has been in existence since the late 1980rsquos
Commits acts of violence aimed at America and Western Allies
Al-Qaeda training camp
1989-95 Birth and DevelopmentAl-Qaeda starts in the aftermath of Soviet invasion
1987By 1989 begins to target AmericaRecruits from across the globe including AmericaNo solid base (Afghanistan Egypt Iraq) 1991-1996 primarily based in SudanMuch soldier training and a system of Hierarchy
stabilized (Bin Laden Deputy 5 committees)
Conflict with bin Laden Escalates
Offers to raise a mujahidin army to defend Saudi Arabia from a potential invasion from Iraq in 1990
Saudi Arabia declines his offer opting instead to accept the assistance of the US and allow American troops (including women soldiers) in Saudi Arabia
Moves to Sudan by invitation of the Sudanese government in 1991
Supports several small to medium attacks against Western interests
Moves to Afghanistan in 1996 by invitation of the Taliban
Cruise missiles fired at al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan to kill bin Laden in 1998
Al-Qaedarsquos Strategy
Soldiers operate in fast moving light forces Work in complete secrecy to complete complex strategic strikes
Avoids engagement in conventional fighting (forces are not strong enough)
Spreads rumors fear and discouragement among enemy forces
Relies on a force of over 20000 professionally trained soldiers throughout the world
The organizationrsquos strengths are itsrsquo secrecy extensive influence and planning
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
May not work outside the homeMay not participate in any activity outside the home unless accompanied by her husband or male relative (no shopping walkinghellip)May not be treated by male doctorMay not study at any institutions including schools and universities
Taliban Rules for Womenbull Must wear the long veil (burqaburka) which covers them from head to toe
bull If found guilty of adultery will be publically stoned to death
bull May not laugh loudly ndash no stranger should hear a womanrsquos voice
bull May not wear high heels ndash no man should hear a womanrsquos footsteps
Before During After
Women carried out businesses transactions
Education for women and their right to vote was introduced to the constitution in 1964
Job positions held by women- 70 teachers- 50 civil servants- 40 doctors
Taliban took over in the 1990rsquos
Restricted and violated womenrsquos right on education work and freedom of movement
Imposed harsh penalties on women for breaking such rules Eg public lashings
Restricted access to health care services
Strict dress code
Taliban was overthrown in 2001
Over one million girls are attending school
Access to health care services
Afghan government and NGO has set up programs to improve womenrsquos status and public participations
Women were educated amp employed50 of students
70 of teachers 50 government workers40 of doctors
Prior To the Taliban
bull Before the Taliban took over women
had the right to education were
represented in government and
worked in offices
Forty percent of the countrys doctors
were women
Life for Women Before Taliban
No Rights At All Discrimination Against Afghanistan Women In Afganistan the year 1996 the Tailbanian took over and began their enforcement of laws mostly against women Some laws include
bull Girls over 12 must wear a burqa
bull Girls over 12 are forbidden to leave the home without a male relative and cannot go to WORK or SCHOOL
bull No video cassettes music cameras
bull No white socks
bull In every house where a women lives the windows must be painted black
Treatment of Women in Taliban-controlled Afghanistan
Taliban rules WomenMust always be escorted in public
by male relative and wearing burqa
Must not wear high heeled shoes (sound of womenrsquos footsteps excite men)
Cannot speak in publicWomen cannot be seen from street
mdashall ground and first floor windows must be painted over
No photography of womenPlace names not to be womenrsquosMay not appear on balconiesMay not appear in the media
Above a Taliban religious policeman beats a woman in for being in public without a male relative Left Afghan women are dressed in the burqa
Must wear a burqa outside their home Must wear a burqa inside if a male is present
In public women
must be covered from
head to toe by a
burqa an oppressive
garment that has only
a tiny mesh opening
over the eyes
Through the burga the woman is unable to breath or see properly
She is unable to feel the sunshine or receive beneficial vitamin C from the sun
View through a veil or burka which all Afghan women are required to wear outside the home
Restricted vision has reportedly caused numerous accidents involving vehicles and women pedestrians
View Through the Burka
43
Since enforced veiling a growing number of women have been hit by vehicles because the burqa leaves them unable to walk fast or see where they are going
Once a Taliban tank rolled right over a veiled woman
Fortunately she fell between the tracks
Instead of being crushed to death she was not seriously hurt but was severely traumatized
Laws under the Taliban
Its now illegal to wear makeup nail polish
jewelry pluck your eyebrows cut your hair
short wear colorful or stylish clothes sheer
stockings white socks and shoes high heel
shoes walk loudly talk loudly laugh in
public or to participate in sports
One woman had the top of her thumb amputated for the crime of wearing nail polish
Female education from kindergarten through graduate school banned
Must do all of the household chores
Must not travel on a bus without a man or note authorizing permission
Employment for women banned
In fact the government didnt believe women should go out at all Women you should not step outside your residence read one of the Taliban dictates
Beating women (left)Executing a woman publicly (right)
Harsh Treatment of Women by Taliban
51
A young mother Torpeka was shot repeatedly by the Taliban while rushing her seriously ill toddler to a doctor
Veiled as the law requires she was spotted by a teenage Taliban guard who tried to stop her because she shouldnt have left her home
Afraid her child might die if she were delayed Torpeka kept going
The guard aimed his machine-gun and fired several rounds directly at her
She was hit but didnt die on the spot as she could have Instead Afghans watching the incident in the marketplace
stepped in and Torpeka and her child received prompt medical attention
When her family later complained to the Taliban authorities they were informed that it was the injured womans fault
She had no right being out in public in the first place
The Taliban took control of
Kabul on Sept 26 1996 and
began a reign of terror
Because of the civil unrest
many Afghan women are
widows -- there are 30000 in
Kabul alone - without close
male relatives and they are the
sole supporters of their
children
15000 women in the Kabul region of Afghanistan are widows but the law of the Taliban the Islamic fundamentalist groups that rule the region forbids them from leaving their homes without a male family member as an escort (John MooreAP Photo)
Yet by Taliban law they are unable to work to support the children or leave the house without a male family member to buy food
If there isnrsquot a male family member they face the possibility of a beating every time they leave their home
There are a few supplemental houses which provide free food to widows and orphans but many are forced to beg in the streets for money
Thousands of Afghan war-widows have no other option but to beg to save their children from hunger Any Taliban man can flog these ill-fated women in the streets because most of them have to leave their houses without a close male relative
Afghan women begging to survive
Talibs like these boys are authorized to use weapons and whips on women if they decide any are breaking the Talibans repressive laws
Taliban ldquoreligious policerdquo beating a woman in public
Prohibited women and girls from
being examined by male physicians
while at the same time prohibited
most female doctors and nurses
from working
There were only a few selected
female doctors allowed to operate
in segregated wards
Medical Issues for Women
At one of the rare hospitals for women a
reporter found still nearly lifeless
bodies lying motionless on top of beds
wrapped in their burqua unwilling to
speak eat or do anything but slowly
wasting away
Others have gone mad and were seen
crouched in corners perpetually rocking
or crying most of them in fear
Medical Issues for Women
Conditions were so deplorable for women under the Taliban that many became severely depressed
Without the resources to leave the country an increasing number were choosing suicide once rare there as a means of escape
Doctors are seeing a lot of esophageal burns Women are swallowing battery acid or poisonous household cleansers because they are easy to find But its a very painful way to die
Medical Issues for Women
Women have died of treatable ailments because male doctors were not allowed to treat them
Many women now forcibly housebound have attempted suicide by swallowing household cleaner rather than continuing to live under these conditions
97 of Afghan women surveyed by Physicians for Human Rights exhibit signs of major depression
The Medical Results of a Taliban Rule
At a huge risk of women students continue their education in an underground school
A woman who dared to defy Taliban orders by running a home school for girls was shot and killed in front of her husband daughter and students
A woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man not related to her was stoned to death for adultery
An elderly woman was brutally beaten with a metal cable until her leg was broken because her ankle was accidentally showing from underneath her burqa
The Consequences Breaking a Taliban Rule
Although the new constitution guarantees equal rights an opportunities for both men and womenhellipthat is not always the case
Health careChild birth
highest maternal death ratein the world
Male doctorsMen amp boys take precedence
in the few emergency rooms that exist (very few hospitals after Taliban rule)
Unequal opportunities jobs divorce custody
Women Today
Taliban Insurgencies ndash harsh policies for womenAfghanistanrsquos Human Rights Commission
1500 atrocities against women (2008)13 domestic violence cases200 forcibly married98 set themselves on fire100+ tried to commit suicide
by taking poisonIncreasing number of women
taking drugsJudgments against women (Jirgas)New ldquoRape Lawrdquo against Shiite women
Womenrsquos Problems
Imagine your were an older woman who lived under the prior government and was used to all the freedoms
How would you feel now that you are under the control of the Taliban
How is your life differentExplain
On your Left Side
The September 11 2001 terrorist attacks were traced to Osama bin Laden and his al Qaeda network based in Afghanistan
Afghanistan History
On your Left SideWhat do your remember of Sept 11 2001Where were you
Al-Qaeda Defined A very complex
organization that has been in existence since the late 1980rsquos
Commits acts of violence aimed at America and Western Allies
Al-Qaeda training camp
1989-95 Birth and DevelopmentAl-Qaeda starts in the aftermath of Soviet invasion
1987By 1989 begins to target AmericaRecruits from across the globe including AmericaNo solid base (Afghanistan Egypt Iraq) 1991-1996 primarily based in SudanMuch soldier training and a system of Hierarchy
stabilized (Bin Laden Deputy 5 committees)
Conflict with bin Laden Escalates
Offers to raise a mujahidin army to defend Saudi Arabia from a potential invasion from Iraq in 1990
Saudi Arabia declines his offer opting instead to accept the assistance of the US and allow American troops (including women soldiers) in Saudi Arabia
Moves to Sudan by invitation of the Sudanese government in 1991
Supports several small to medium attacks against Western interests
Moves to Afghanistan in 1996 by invitation of the Taliban
Cruise missiles fired at al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan to kill bin Laden in 1998
Al-Qaedarsquos Strategy
Soldiers operate in fast moving light forces Work in complete secrecy to complete complex strategic strikes
Avoids engagement in conventional fighting (forces are not strong enough)
Spreads rumors fear and discouragement among enemy forces
Relies on a force of over 20000 professionally trained soldiers throughout the world
The organizationrsquos strengths are itsrsquo secrecy extensive influence and planning
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Before During After
Women carried out businesses transactions
Education for women and their right to vote was introduced to the constitution in 1964
Job positions held by women- 70 teachers- 50 civil servants- 40 doctors
Taliban took over in the 1990rsquos
Restricted and violated womenrsquos right on education work and freedom of movement
Imposed harsh penalties on women for breaking such rules Eg public lashings
Restricted access to health care services
Strict dress code
Taliban was overthrown in 2001
Over one million girls are attending school
Access to health care services
Afghan government and NGO has set up programs to improve womenrsquos status and public participations
Women were educated amp employed50 of students
70 of teachers 50 government workers40 of doctors
Prior To the Taliban
bull Before the Taliban took over women
had the right to education were
represented in government and
worked in offices
Forty percent of the countrys doctors
were women
Life for Women Before Taliban
No Rights At All Discrimination Against Afghanistan Women In Afganistan the year 1996 the Tailbanian took over and began their enforcement of laws mostly against women Some laws include
bull Girls over 12 must wear a burqa
bull Girls over 12 are forbidden to leave the home without a male relative and cannot go to WORK or SCHOOL
bull No video cassettes music cameras
bull No white socks
bull In every house where a women lives the windows must be painted black
Treatment of Women in Taliban-controlled Afghanistan
Taliban rules WomenMust always be escorted in public
by male relative and wearing burqa
Must not wear high heeled shoes (sound of womenrsquos footsteps excite men)
Cannot speak in publicWomen cannot be seen from street
mdashall ground and first floor windows must be painted over
No photography of womenPlace names not to be womenrsquosMay not appear on balconiesMay not appear in the media
Above a Taliban religious policeman beats a woman in for being in public without a male relative Left Afghan women are dressed in the burqa
Must wear a burqa outside their home Must wear a burqa inside if a male is present
In public women
must be covered from
head to toe by a
burqa an oppressive
garment that has only
a tiny mesh opening
over the eyes
Through the burga the woman is unable to breath or see properly
She is unable to feel the sunshine or receive beneficial vitamin C from the sun
View through a veil or burka which all Afghan women are required to wear outside the home
Restricted vision has reportedly caused numerous accidents involving vehicles and women pedestrians
View Through the Burka
43
Since enforced veiling a growing number of women have been hit by vehicles because the burqa leaves them unable to walk fast or see where they are going
Once a Taliban tank rolled right over a veiled woman
Fortunately she fell between the tracks
Instead of being crushed to death she was not seriously hurt but was severely traumatized
Laws under the Taliban
Its now illegal to wear makeup nail polish
jewelry pluck your eyebrows cut your hair
short wear colorful or stylish clothes sheer
stockings white socks and shoes high heel
shoes walk loudly talk loudly laugh in
public or to participate in sports
One woman had the top of her thumb amputated for the crime of wearing nail polish
Female education from kindergarten through graduate school banned
Must do all of the household chores
Must not travel on a bus without a man or note authorizing permission
Employment for women banned
In fact the government didnt believe women should go out at all Women you should not step outside your residence read one of the Taliban dictates
Beating women (left)Executing a woman publicly (right)
Harsh Treatment of Women by Taliban
51
A young mother Torpeka was shot repeatedly by the Taliban while rushing her seriously ill toddler to a doctor
Veiled as the law requires she was spotted by a teenage Taliban guard who tried to stop her because she shouldnt have left her home
Afraid her child might die if she were delayed Torpeka kept going
The guard aimed his machine-gun and fired several rounds directly at her
She was hit but didnt die on the spot as she could have Instead Afghans watching the incident in the marketplace
stepped in and Torpeka and her child received prompt medical attention
When her family later complained to the Taliban authorities they were informed that it was the injured womans fault
She had no right being out in public in the first place
The Taliban took control of
Kabul on Sept 26 1996 and
began a reign of terror
Because of the civil unrest
many Afghan women are
widows -- there are 30000 in
Kabul alone - without close
male relatives and they are the
sole supporters of their
children
15000 women in the Kabul region of Afghanistan are widows but the law of the Taliban the Islamic fundamentalist groups that rule the region forbids them from leaving their homes without a male family member as an escort (John MooreAP Photo)
Yet by Taliban law they are unable to work to support the children or leave the house without a male family member to buy food
If there isnrsquot a male family member they face the possibility of a beating every time they leave their home
There are a few supplemental houses which provide free food to widows and orphans but many are forced to beg in the streets for money
Thousands of Afghan war-widows have no other option but to beg to save their children from hunger Any Taliban man can flog these ill-fated women in the streets because most of them have to leave their houses without a close male relative
Afghan women begging to survive
Talibs like these boys are authorized to use weapons and whips on women if they decide any are breaking the Talibans repressive laws
Taliban ldquoreligious policerdquo beating a woman in public
Prohibited women and girls from
being examined by male physicians
while at the same time prohibited
most female doctors and nurses
from working
There were only a few selected
female doctors allowed to operate
in segregated wards
Medical Issues for Women
At one of the rare hospitals for women a
reporter found still nearly lifeless
bodies lying motionless on top of beds
wrapped in their burqua unwilling to
speak eat or do anything but slowly
wasting away
Others have gone mad and were seen
crouched in corners perpetually rocking
or crying most of them in fear
Medical Issues for Women
Conditions were so deplorable for women under the Taliban that many became severely depressed
Without the resources to leave the country an increasing number were choosing suicide once rare there as a means of escape
Doctors are seeing a lot of esophageal burns Women are swallowing battery acid or poisonous household cleansers because they are easy to find But its a very painful way to die
Medical Issues for Women
Women have died of treatable ailments because male doctors were not allowed to treat them
Many women now forcibly housebound have attempted suicide by swallowing household cleaner rather than continuing to live under these conditions
97 of Afghan women surveyed by Physicians for Human Rights exhibit signs of major depression
The Medical Results of a Taliban Rule
At a huge risk of women students continue their education in an underground school
A woman who dared to defy Taliban orders by running a home school for girls was shot and killed in front of her husband daughter and students
A woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man not related to her was stoned to death for adultery
An elderly woman was brutally beaten with a metal cable until her leg was broken because her ankle was accidentally showing from underneath her burqa
The Consequences Breaking a Taliban Rule
Although the new constitution guarantees equal rights an opportunities for both men and womenhellipthat is not always the case
Health careChild birth
highest maternal death ratein the world
Male doctorsMen amp boys take precedence
in the few emergency rooms that exist (very few hospitals after Taliban rule)
Unequal opportunities jobs divorce custody
Women Today
Taliban Insurgencies ndash harsh policies for womenAfghanistanrsquos Human Rights Commission
1500 atrocities against women (2008)13 domestic violence cases200 forcibly married98 set themselves on fire100+ tried to commit suicide
by taking poisonIncreasing number of women
taking drugsJudgments against women (Jirgas)New ldquoRape Lawrdquo against Shiite women
Womenrsquos Problems
Imagine your were an older woman who lived under the prior government and was used to all the freedoms
How would you feel now that you are under the control of the Taliban
How is your life differentExplain
On your Left Side
The September 11 2001 terrorist attacks were traced to Osama bin Laden and his al Qaeda network based in Afghanistan
Afghanistan History
On your Left SideWhat do your remember of Sept 11 2001Where were you
Al-Qaeda Defined A very complex
organization that has been in existence since the late 1980rsquos
Commits acts of violence aimed at America and Western Allies
Al-Qaeda training camp
1989-95 Birth and DevelopmentAl-Qaeda starts in the aftermath of Soviet invasion
1987By 1989 begins to target AmericaRecruits from across the globe including AmericaNo solid base (Afghanistan Egypt Iraq) 1991-1996 primarily based in SudanMuch soldier training and a system of Hierarchy
stabilized (Bin Laden Deputy 5 committees)
Conflict with bin Laden Escalates
Offers to raise a mujahidin army to defend Saudi Arabia from a potential invasion from Iraq in 1990
Saudi Arabia declines his offer opting instead to accept the assistance of the US and allow American troops (including women soldiers) in Saudi Arabia
Moves to Sudan by invitation of the Sudanese government in 1991
Supports several small to medium attacks against Western interests
Moves to Afghanistan in 1996 by invitation of the Taliban
Cruise missiles fired at al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan to kill bin Laden in 1998
Al-Qaedarsquos Strategy
Soldiers operate in fast moving light forces Work in complete secrecy to complete complex strategic strikes
Avoids engagement in conventional fighting (forces are not strong enough)
Spreads rumors fear and discouragement among enemy forces
Relies on a force of over 20000 professionally trained soldiers throughout the world
The organizationrsquos strengths are itsrsquo secrecy extensive influence and planning
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Women were educated amp employed50 of students
70 of teachers 50 government workers40 of doctors
Prior To the Taliban
bull Before the Taliban took over women
had the right to education were
represented in government and
worked in offices
Forty percent of the countrys doctors
were women
Life for Women Before Taliban
No Rights At All Discrimination Against Afghanistan Women In Afganistan the year 1996 the Tailbanian took over and began their enforcement of laws mostly against women Some laws include
bull Girls over 12 must wear a burqa
bull Girls over 12 are forbidden to leave the home without a male relative and cannot go to WORK or SCHOOL
bull No video cassettes music cameras
bull No white socks
bull In every house where a women lives the windows must be painted black
Treatment of Women in Taliban-controlled Afghanistan
Taliban rules WomenMust always be escorted in public
by male relative and wearing burqa
Must not wear high heeled shoes (sound of womenrsquos footsteps excite men)
Cannot speak in publicWomen cannot be seen from street
mdashall ground and first floor windows must be painted over
No photography of womenPlace names not to be womenrsquosMay not appear on balconiesMay not appear in the media
Above a Taliban religious policeman beats a woman in for being in public without a male relative Left Afghan women are dressed in the burqa
Must wear a burqa outside their home Must wear a burqa inside if a male is present
In public women
must be covered from
head to toe by a
burqa an oppressive
garment that has only
a tiny mesh opening
over the eyes
Through the burga the woman is unable to breath or see properly
She is unable to feel the sunshine or receive beneficial vitamin C from the sun
View through a veil or burka which all Afghan women are required to wear outside the home
Restricted vision has reportedly caused numerous accidents involving vehicles and women pedestrians
View Through the Burka
43
Since enforced veiling a growing number of women have been hit by vehicles because the burqa leaves them unable to walk fast or see where they are going
Once a Taliban tank rolled right over a veiled woman
Fortunately she fell between the tracks
Instead of being crushed to death she was not seriously hurt but was severely traumatized
Laws under the Taliban
Its now illegal to wear makeup nail polish
jewelry pluck your eyebrows cut your hair
short wear colorful or stylish clothes sheer
stockings white socks and shoes high heel
shoes walk loudly talk loudly laugh in
public or to participate in sports
One woman had the top of her thumb amputated for the crime of wearing nail polish
Female education from kindergarten through graduate school banned
Must do all of the household chores
Must not travel on a bus without a man or note authorizing permission
Employment for women banned
In fact the government didnt believe women should go out at all Women you should not step outside your residence read one of the Taliban dictates
Beating women (left)Executing a woman publicly (right)
Harsh Treatment of Women by Taliban
51
A young mother Torpeka was shot repeatedly by the Taliban while rushing her seriously ill toddler to a doctor
Veiled as the law requires she was spotted by a teenage Taliban guard who tried to stop her because she shouldnt have left her home
Afraid her child might die if she were delayed Torpeka kept going
The guard aimed his machine-gun and fired several rounds directly at her
She was hit but didnt die on the spot as she could have Instead Afghans watching the incident in the marketplace
stepped in and Torpeka and her child received prompt medical attention
When her family later complained to the Taliban authorities they were informed that it was the injured womans fault
She had no right being out in public in the first place
The Taliban took control of
Kabul on Sept 26 1996 and
began a reign of terror
Because of the civil unrest
many Afghan women are
widows -- there are 30000 in
Kabul alone - without close
male relatives and they are the
sole supporters of their
children
15000 women in the Kabul region of Afghanistan are widows but the law of the Taliban the Islamic fundamentalist groups that rule the region forbids them from leaving their homes without a male family member as an escort (John MooreAP Photo)
Yet by Taliban law they are unable to work to support the children or leave the house without a male family member to buy food
If there isnrsquot a male family member they face the possibility of a beating every time they leave their home
There are a few supplemental houses which provide free food to widows and orphans but many are forced to beg in the streets for money
Thousands of Afghan war-widows have no other option but to beg to save their children from hunger Any Taliban man can flog these ill-fated women in the streets because most of them have to leave their houses without a close male relative
Afghan women begging to survive
Talibs like these boys are authorized to use weapons and whips on women if they decide any are breaking the Talibans repressive laws
Taliban ldquoreligious policerdquo beating a woman in public
Prohibited women and girls from
being examined by male physicians
while at the same time prohibited
most female doctors and nurses
from working
There were only a few selected
female doctors allowed to operate
in segregated wards
Medical Issues for Women
At one of the rare hospitals for women a
reporter found still nearly lifeless
bodies lying motionless on top of beds
wrapped in their burqua unwilling to
speak eat or do anything but slowly
wasting away
Others have gone mad and were seen
crouched in corners perpetually rocking
or crying most of them in fear
Medical Issues for Women
Conditions were so deplorable for women under the Taliban that many became severely depressed
Without the resources to leave the country an increasing number were choosing suicide once rare there as a means of escape
Doctors are seeing a lot of esophageal burns Women are swallowing battery acid or poisonous household cleansers because they are easy to find But its a very painful way to die
Medical Issues for Women
Women have died of treatable ailments because male doctors were not allowed to treat them
Many women now forcibly housebound have attempted suicide by swallowing household cleaner rather than continuing to live under these conditions
97 of Afghan women surveyed by Physicians for Human Rights exhibit signs of major depression
The Medical Results of a Taliban Rule
At a huge risk of women students continue their education in an underground school
A woman who dared to defy Taliban orders by running a home school for girls was shot and killed in front of her husband daughter and students
A woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man not related to her was stoned to death for adultery
An elderly woman was brutally beaten with a metal cable until her leg was broken because her ankle was accidentally showing from underneath her burqa
The Consequences Breaking a Taliban Rule
Although the new constitution guarantees equal rights an opportunities for both men and womenhellipthat is not always the case
Health careChild birth
highest maternal death ratein the world
Male doctorsMen amp boys take precedence
in the few emergency rooms that exist (very few hospitals after Taliban rule)
Unequal opportunities jobs divorce custody
Women Today
Taliban Insurgencies ndash harsh policies for womenAfghanistanrsquos Human Rights Commission
1500 atrocities against women (2008)13 domestic violence cases200 forcibly married98 set themselves on fire100+ tried to commit suicide
by taking poisonIncreasing number of women
taking drugsJudgments against women (Jirgas)New ldquoRape Lawrdquo against Shiite women
Womenrsquos Problems
Imagine your were an older woman who lived under the prior government and was used to all the freedoms
How would you feel now that you are under the control of the Taliban
How is your life differentExplain
On your Left Side
The September 11 2001 terrorist attacks were traced to Osama bin Laden and his al Qaeda network based in Afghanistan
Afghanistan History
On your Left SideWhat do your remember of Sept 11 2001Where were you
Al-Qaeda Defined A very complex
organization that has been in existence since the late 1980rsquos
Commits acts of violence aimed at America and Western Allies
Al-Qaeda training camp
1989-95 Birth and DevelopmentAl-Qaeda starts in the aftermath of Soviet invasion
1987By 1989 begins to target AmericaRecruits from across the globe including AmericaNo solid base (Afghanistan Egypt Iraq) 1991-1996 primarily based in SudanMuch soldier training and a system of Hierarchy
stabilized (Bin Laden Deputy 5 committees)
Conflict with bin Laden Escalates
Offers to raise a mujahidin army to defend Saudi Arabia from a potential invasion from Iraq in 1990
Saudi Arabia declines his offer opting instead to accept the assistance of the US and allow American troops (including women soldiers) in Saudi Arabia
Moves to Sudan by invitation of the Sudanese government in 1991
Supports several small to medium attacks against Western interests
Moves to Afghanistan in 1996 by invitation of the Taliban
Cruise missiles fired at al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan to kill bin Laden in 1998
Al-Qaedarsquos Strategy
Soldiers operate in fast moving light forces Work in complete secrecy to complete complex strategic strikes
Avoids engagement in conventional fighting (forces are not strong enough)
Spreads rumors fear and discouragement among enemy forces
Relies on a force of over 20000 professionally trained soldiers throughout the world
The organizationrsquos strengths are itsrsquo secrecy extensive influence and planning
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
bull Before the Taliban took over women
had the right to education were
represented in government and
worked in offices
Forty percent of the countrys doctors
were women
Life for Women Before Taliban
No Rights At All Discrimination Against Afghanistan Women In Afganistan the year 1996 the Tailbanian took over and began their enforcement of laws mostly against women Some laws include
bull Girls over 12 must wear a burqa
bull Girls over 12 are forbidden to leave the home without a male relative and cannot go to WORK or SCHOOL
bull No video cassettes music cameras
bull No white socks
bull In every house where a women lives the windows must be painted black
Treatment of Women in Taliban-controlled Afghanistan
Taliban rules WomenMust always be escorted in public
by male relative and wearing burqa
Must not wear high heeled shoes (sound of womenrsquos footsteps excite men)
Cannot speak in publicWomen cannot be seen from street
mdashall ground and first floor windows must be painted over
No photography of womenPlace names not to be womenrsquosMay not appear on balconiesMay not appear in the media
Above a Taliban religious policeman beats a woman in for being in public without a male relative Left Afghan women are dressed in the burqa
Must wear a burqa outside their home Must wear a burqa inside if a male is present
In public women
must be covered from
head to toe by a
burqa an oppressive
garment that has only
a tiny mesh opening
over the eyes
Through the burga the woman is unable to breath or see properly
She is unable to feel the sunshine or receive beneficial vitamin C from the sun
View through a veil or burka which all Afghan women are required to wear outside the home
Restricted vision has reportedly caused numerous accidents involving vehicles and women pedestrians
View Through the Burka
43
Since enforced veiling a growing number of women have been hit by vehicles because the burqa leaves them unable to walk fast or see where they are going
Once a Taliban tank rolled right over a veiled woman
Fortunately she fell between the tracks
Instead of being crushed to death she was not seriously hurt but was severely traumatized
Laws under the Taliban
Its now illegal to wear makeup nail polish
jewelry pluck your eyebrows cut your hair
short wear colorful or stylish clothes sheer
stockings white socks and shoes high heel
shoes walk loudly talk loudly laugh in
public or to participate in sports
One woman had the top of her thumb amputated for the crime of wearing nail polish
Female education from kindergarten through graduate school banned
Must do all of the household chores
Must not travel on a bus without a man or note authorizing permission
Employment for women banned
In fact the government didnt believe women should go out at all Women you should not step outside your residence read one of the Taliban dictates
Beating women (left)Executing a woman publicly (right)
Harsh Treatment of Women by Taliban
51
A young mother Torpeka was shot repeatedly by the Taliban while rushing her seriously ill toddler to a doctor
Veiled as the law requires she was spotted by a teenage Taliban guard who tried to stop her because she shouldnt have left her home
Afraid her child might die if she were delayed Torpeka kept going
The guard aimed his machine-gun and fired several rounds directly at her
She was hit but didnt die on the spot as she could have Instead Afghans watching the incident in the marketplace
stepped in and Torpeka and her child received prompt medical attention
When her family later complained to the Taliban authorities they were informed that it was the injured womans fault
She had no right being out in public in the first place
The Taliban took control of
Kabul on Sept 26 1996 and
began a reign of terror
Because of the civil unrest
many Afghan women are
widows -- there are 30000 in
Kabul alone - without close
male relatives and they are the
sole supporters of their
children
15000 women in the Kabul region of Afghanistan are widows but the law of the Taliban the Islamic fundamentalist groups that rule the region forbids them from leaving their homes without a male family member as an escort (John MooreAP Photo)
Yet by Taliban law they are unable to work to support the children or leave the house without a male family member to buy food
If there isnrsquot a male family member they face the possibility of a beating every time they leave their home
There are a few supplemental houses which provide free food to widows and orphans but many are forced to beg in the streets for money
Thousands of Afghan war-widows have no other option but to beg to save their children from hunger Any Taliban man can flog these ill-fated women in the streets because most of them have to leave their houses without a close male relative
Afghan women begging to survive
Talibs like these boys are authorized to use weapons and whips on women if they decide any are breaking the Talibans repressive laws
Taliban ldquoreligious policerdquo beating a woman in public
Prohibited women and girls from
being examined by male physicians
while at the same time prohibited
most female doctors and nurses
from working
There were only a few selected
female doctors allowed to operate
in segregated wards
Medical Issues for Women
At one of the rare hospitals for women a
reporter found still nearly lifeless
bodies lying motionless on top of beds
wrapped in their burqua unwilling to
speak eat or do anything but slowly
wasting away
Others have gone mad and were seen
crouched in corners perpetually rocking
or crying most of them in fear
Medical Issues for Women
Conditions were so deplorable for women under the Taliban that many became severely depressed
Without the resources to leave the country an increasing number were choosing suicide once rare there as a means of escape
Doctors are seeing a lot of esophageal burns Women are swallowing battery acid or poisonous household cleansers because they are easy to find But its a very painful way to die
Medical Issues for Women
Women have died of treatable ailments because male doctors were not allowed to treat them
Many women now forcibly housebound have attempted suicide by swallowing household cleaner rather than continuing to live under these conditions
97 of Afghan women surveyed by Physicians for Human Rights exhibit signs of major depression
The Medical Results of a Taliban Rule
At a huge risk of women students continue their education in an underground school
A woman who dared to defy Taliban orders by running a home school for girls was shot and killed in front of her husband daughter and students
A woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man not related to her was stoned to death for adultery
An elderly woman was brutally beaten with a metal cable until her leg was broken because her ankle was accidentally showing from underneath her burqa
The Consequences Breaking a Taliban Rule
Although the new constitution guarantees equal rights an opportunities for both men and womenhellipthat is not always the case
Health careChild birth
highest maternal death ratein the world
Male doctorsMen amp boys take precedence
in the few emergency rooms that exist (very few hospitals after Taliban rule)
Unequal opportunities jobs divorce custody
Women Today
Taliban Insurgencies ndash harsh policies for womenAfghanistanrsquos Human Rights Commission
1500 atrocities against women (2008)13 domestic violence cases200 forcibly married98 set themselves on fire100+ tried to commit suicide
by taking poisonIncreasing number of women
taking drugsJudgments against women (Jirgas)New ldquoRape Lawrdquo against Shiite women
Womenrsquos Problems
Imagine your were an older woman who lived under the prior government and was used to all the freedoms
How would you feel now that you are under the control of the Taliban
How is your life differentExplain
On your Left Side
The September 11 2001 terrorist attacks were traced to Osama bin Laden and his al Qaeda network based in Afghanistan
Afghanistan History
On your Left SideWhat do your remember of Sept 11 2001Where were you
Al-Qaeda Defined A very complex
organization that has been in existence since the late 1980rsquos
Commits acts of violence aimed at America and Western Allies
Al-Qaeda training camp
1989-95 Birth and DevelopmentAl-Qaeda starts in the aftermath of Soviet invasion
1987By 1989 begins to target AmericaRecruits from across the globe including AmericaNo solid base (Afghanistan Egypt Iraq) 1991-1996 primarily based in SudanMuch soldier training and a system of Hierarchy
stabilized (Bin Laden Deputy 5 committees)
Conflict with bin Laden Escalates
Offers to raise a mujahidin army to defend Saudi Arabia from a potential invasion from Iraq in 1990
Saudi Arabia declines his offer opting instead to accept the assistance of the US and allow American troops (including women soldiers) in Saudi Arabia
Moves to Sudan by invitation of the Sudanese government in 1991
Supports several small to medium attacks against Western interests
Moves to Afghanistan in 1996 by invitation of the Taliban
Cruise missiles fired at al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan to kill bin Laden in 1998
Al-Qaedarsquos Strategy
Soldiers operate in fast moving light forces Work in complete secrecy to complete complex strategic strikes
Avoids engagement in conventional fighting (forces are not strong enough)
Spreads rumors fear and discouragement among enemy forces
Relies on a force of over 20000 professionally trained soldiers throughout the world
The organizationrsquos strengths are itsrsquo secrecy extensive influence and planning
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
No Rights At All Discrimination Against Afghanistan Women In Afganistan the year 1996 the Tailbanian took over and began their enforcement of laws mostly against women Some laws include
bull Girls over 12 must wear a burqa
bull Girls over 12 are forbidden to leave the home without a male relative and cannot go to WORK or SCHOOL
bull No video cassettes music cameras
bull No white socks
bull In every house where a women lives the windows must be painted black
Treatment of Women in Taliban-controlled Afghanistan
Taliban rules WomenMust always be escorted in public
by male relative and wearing burqa
Must not wear high heeled shoes (sound of womenrsquos footsteps excite men)
Cannot speak in publicWomen cannot be seen from street
mdashall ground and first floor windows must be painted over
No photography of womenPlace names not to be womenrsquosMay not appear on balconiesMay not appear in the media
Above a Taliban religious policeman beats a woman in for being in public without a male relative Left Afghan women are dressed in the burqa
Must wear a burqa outside their home Must wear a burqa inside if a male is present
In public women
must be covered from
head to toe by a
burqa an oppressive
garment that has only
a tiny mesh opening
over the eyes
Through the burga the woman is unable to breath or see properly
She is unable to feel the sunshine or receive beneficial vitamin C from the sun
View through a veil or burka which all Afghan women are required to wear outside the home
Restricted vision has reportedly caused numerous accidents involving vehicles and women pedestrians
View Through the Burka
43
Since enforced veiling a growing number of women have been hit by vehicles because the burqa leaves them unable to walk fast or see where they are going
Once a Taliban tank rolled right over a veiled woman
Fortunately she fell between the tracks
Instead of being crushed to death she was not seriously hurt but was severely traumatized
Laws under the Taliban
Its now illegal to wear makeup nail polish
jewelry pluck your eyebrows cut your hair
short wear colorful or stylish clothes sheer
stockings white socks and shoes high heel
shoes walk loudly talk loudly laugh in
public or to participate in sports
One woman had the top of her thumb amputated for the crime of wearing nail polish
Female education from kindergarten through graduate school banned
Must do all of the household chores
Must not travel on a bus without a man or note authorizing permission
Employment for women banned
In fact the government didnt believe women should go out at all Women you should not step outside your residence read one of the Taliban dictates
Beating women (left)Executing a woman publicly (right)
Harsh Treatment of Women by Taliban
51
A young mother Torpeka was shot repeatedly by the Taliban while rushing her seriously ill toddler to a doctor
Veiled as the law requires she was spotted by a teenage Taliban guard who tried to stop her because she shouldnt have left her home
Afraid her child might die if she were delayed Torpeka kept going
The guard aimed his machine-gun and fired several rounds directly at her
She was hit but didnt die on the spot as she could have Instead Afghans watching the incident in the marketplace
stepped in and Torpeka and her child received prompt medical attention
When her family later complained to the Taliban authorities they were informed that it was the injured womans fault
She had no right being out in public in the first place
The Taliban took control of
Kabul on Sept 26 1996 and
began a reign of terror
Because of the civil unrest
many Afghan women are
widows -- there are 30000 in
Kabul alone - without close
male relatives and they are the
sole supporters of their
children
15000 women in the Kabul region of Afghanistan are widows but the law of the Taliban the Islamic fundamentalist groups that rule the region forbids them from leaving their homes without a male family member as an escort (John MooreAP Photo)
Yet by Taliban law they are unable to work to support the children or leave the house without a male family member to buy food
If there isnrsquot a male family member they face the possibility of a beating every time they leave their home
There are a few supplemental houses which provide free food to widows and orphans but many are forced to beg in the streets for money
Thousands of Afghan war-widows have no other option but to beg to save their children from hunger Any Taliban man can flog these ill-fated women in the streets because most of them have to leave their houses without a close male relative
Afghan women begging to survive
Talibs like these boys are authorized to use weapons and whips on women if they decide any are breaking the Talibans repressive laws
Taliban ldquoreligious policerdquo beating a woman in public
Prohibited women and girls from
being examined by male physicians
while at the same time prohibited
most female doctors and nurses
from working
There were only a few selected
female doctors allowed to operate
in segregated wards
Medical Issues for Women
At one of the rare hospitals for women a
reporter found still nearly lifeless
bodies lying motionless on top of beds
wrapped in their burqua unwilling to
speak eat or do anything but slowly
wasting away
Others have gone mad and were seen
crouched in corners perpetually rocking
or crying most of them in fear
Medical Issues for Women
Conditions were so deplorable for women under the Taliban that many became severely depressed
Without the resources to leave the country an increasing number were choosing suicide once rare there as a means of escape
Doctors are seeing a lot of esophageal burns Women are swallowing battery acid or poisonous household cleansers because they are easy to find But its a very painful way to die
Medical Issues for Women
Women have died of treatable ailments because male doctors were not allowed to treat them
Many women now forcibly housebound have attempted suicide by swallowing household cleaner rather than continuing to live under these conditions
97 of Afghan women surveyed by Physicians for Human Rights exhibit signs of major depression
The Medical Results of a Taliban Rule
At a huge risk of women students continue their education in an underground school
A woman who dared to defy Taliban orders by running a home school for girls was shot and killed in front of her husband daughter and students
A woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man not related to her was stoned to death for adultery
An elderly woman was brutally beaten with a metal cable until her leg was broken because her ankle was accidentally showing from underneath her burqa
The Consequences Breaking a Taliban Rule
Although the new constitution guarantees equal rights an opportunities for both men and womenhellipthat is not always the case
Health careChild birth
highest maternal death ratein the world
Male doctorsMen amp boys take precedence
in the few emergency rooms that exist (very few hospitals after Taliban rule)
Unequal opportunities jobs divorce custody
Women Today
Taliban Insurgencies ndash harsh policies for womenAfghanistanrsquos Human Rights Commission
1500 atrocities against women (2008)13 domestic violence cases200 forcibly married98 set themselves on fire100+ tried to commit suicide
by taking poisonIncreasing number of women
taking drugsJudgments against women (Jirgas)New ldquoRape Lawrdquo against Shiite women
Womenrsquos Problems
Imagine your were an older woman who lived under the prior government and was used to all the freedoms
How would you feel now that you are under the control of the Taliban
How is your life differentExplain
On your Left Side
The September 11 2001 terrorist attacks were traced to Osama bin Laden and his al Qaeda network based in Afghanistan
Afghanistan History
On your Left SideWhat do your remember of Sept 11 2001Where were you
Al-Qaeda Defined A very complex
organization that has been in existence since the late 1980rsquos
Commits acts of violence aimed at America and Western Allies
Al-Qaeda training camp
1989-95 Birth and DevelopmentAl-Qaeda starts in the aftermath of Soviet invasion
1987By 1989 begins to target AmericaRecruits from across the globe including AmericaNo solid base (Afghanistan Egypt Iraq) 1991-1996 primarily based in SudanMuch soldier training and a system of Hierarchy
stabilized (Bin Laden Deputy 5 committees)
Conflict with bin Laden Escalates
Offers to raise a mujahidin army to defend Saudi Arabia from a potential invasion from Iraq in 1990
Saudi Arabia declines his offer opting instead to accept the assistance of the US and allow American troops (including women soldiers) in Saudi Arabia
Moves to Sudan by invitation of the Sudanese government in 1991
Supports several small to medium attacks against Western interests
Moves to Afghanistan in 1996 by invitation of the Taliban
Cruise missiles fired at al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan to kill bin Laden in 1998
Al-Qaedarsquos Strategy
Soldiers operate in fast moving light forces Work in complete secrecy to complete complex strategic strikes
Avoids engagement in conventional fighting (forces are not strong enough)
Spreads rumors fear and discouragement among enemy forces
Relies on a force of over 20000 professionally trained soldiers throughout the world
The organizationrsquos strengths are itsrsquo secrecy extensive influence and planning
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Treatment of Women in Taliban-controlled Afghanistan
Taliban rules WomenMust always be escorted in public
by male relative and wearing burqa
Must not wear high heeled shoes (sound of womenrsquos footsteps excite men)
Cannot speak in publicWomen cannot be seen from street
mdashall ground and first floor windows must be painted over
No photography of womenPlace names not to be womenrsquosMay not appear on balconiesMay not appear in the media
Above a Taliban religious policeman beats a woman in for being in public without a male relative Left Afghan women are dressed in the burqa
Must wear a burqa outside their home Must wear a burqa inside if a male is present
In public women
must be covered from
head to toe by a
burqa an oppressive
garment that has only
a tiny mesh opening
over the eyes
Through the burga the woman is unable to breath or see properly
She is unable to feel the sunshine or receive beneficial vitamin C from the sun
View through a veil or burka which all Afghan women are required to wear outside the home
Restricted vision has reportedly caused numerous accidents involving vehicles and women pedestrians
View Through the Burka
43
Since enforced veiling a growing number of women have been hit by vehicles because the burqa leaves them unable to walk fast or see where they are going
Once a Taliban tank rolled right over a veiled woman
Fortunately she fell between the tracks
Instead of being crushed to death she was not seriously hurt but was severely traumatized
Laws under the Taliban
Its now illegal to wear makeup nail polish
jewelry pluck your eyebrows cut your hair
short wear colorful or stylish clothes sheer
stockings white socks and shoes high heel
shoes walk loudly talk loudly laugh in
public or to participate in sports
One woman had the top of her thumb amputated for the crime of wearing nail polish
Female education from kindergarten through graduate school banned
Must do all of the household chores
Must not travel on a bus without a man or note authorizing permission
Employment for women banned
In fact the government didnt believe women should go out at all Women you should not step outside your residence read one of the Taliban dictates
Beating women (left)Executing a woman publicly (right)
Harsh Treatment of Women by Taliban
51
A young mother Torpeka was shot repeatedly by the Taliban while rushing her seriously ill toddler to a doctor
Veiled as the law requires she was spotted by a teenage Taliban guard who tried to stop her because she shouldnt have left her home
Afraid her child might die if she were delayed Torpeka kept going
The guard aimed his machine-gun and fired several rounds directly at her
She was hit but didnt die on the spot as she could have Instead Afghans watching the incident in the marketplace
stepped in and Torpeka and her child received prompt medical attention
When her family later complained to the Taliban authorities they were informed that it was the injured womans fault
She had no right being out in public in the first place
The Taliban took control of
Kabul on Sept 26 1996 and
began a reign of terror
Because of the civil unrest
many Afghan women are
widows -- there are 30000 in
Kabul alone - without close
male relatives and they are the
sole supporters of their
children
15000 women in the Kabul region of Afghanistan are widows but the law of the Taliban the Islamic fundamentalist groups that rule the region forbids them from leaving their homes without a male family member as an escort (John MooreAP Photo)
Yet by Taliban law they are unable to work to support the children or leave the house without a male family member to buy food
If there isnrsquot a male family member they face the possibility of a beating every time they leave their home
There are a few supplemental houses which provide free food to widows and orphans but many are forced to beg in the streets for money
Thousands of Afghan war-widows have no other option but to beg to save their children from hunger Any Taliban man can flog these ill-fated women in the streets because most of them have to leave their houses without a close male relative
Afghan women begging to survive
Talibs like these boys are authorized to use weapons and whips on women if they decide any are breaking the Talibans repressive laws
Taliban ldquoreligious policerdquo beating a woman in public
Prohibited women and girls from
being examined by male physicians
while at the same time prohibited
most female doctors and nurses
from working
There were only a few selected
female doctors allowed to operate
in segregated wards
Medical Issues for Women
At one of the rare hospitals for women a
reporter found still nearly lifeless
bodies lying motionless on top of beds
wrapped in their burqua unwilling to
speak eat or do anything but slowly
wasting away
Others have gone mad and were seen
crouched in corners perpetually rocking
or crying most of them in fear
Medical Issues for Women
Conditions were so deplorable for women under the Taliban that many became severely depressed
Without the resources to leave the country an increasing number were choosing suicide once rare there as a means of escape
Doctors are seeing a lot of esophageal burns Women are swallowing battery acid or poisonous household cleansers because they are easy to find But its a very painful way to die
Medical Issues for Women
Women have died of treatable ailments because male doctors were not allowed to treat them
Many women now forcibly housebound have attempted suicide by swallowing household cleaner rather than continuing to live under these conditions
97 of Afghan women surveyed by Physicians for Human Rights exhibit signs of major depression
The Medical Results of a Taliban Rule
At a huge risk of women students continue their education in an underground school
A woman who dared to defy Taliban orders by running a home school for girls was shot and killed in front of her husband daughter and students
A woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man not related to her was stoned to death for adultery
An elderly woman was brutally beaten with a metal cable until her leg was broken because her ankle was accidentally showing from underneath her burqa
The Consequences Breaking a Taliban Rule
Although the new constitution guarantees equal rights an opportunities for both men and womenhellipthat is not always the case
Health careChild birth
highest maternal death ratein the world
Male doctorsMen amp boys take precedence
in the few emergency rooms that exist (very few hospitals after Taliban rule)
Unequal opportunities jobs divorce custody
Women Today
Taliban Insurgencies ndash harsh policies for womenAfghanistanrsquos Human Rights Commission
1500 atrocities against women (2008)13 domestic violence cases200 forcibly married98 set themselves on fire100+ tried to commit suicide
by taking poisonIncreasing number of women
taking drugsJudgments against women (Jirgas)New ldquoRape Lawrdquo against Shiite women
Womenrsquos Problems
Imagine your were an older woman who lived under the prior government and was used to all the freedoms
How would you feel now that you are under the control of the Taliban
How is your life differentExplain
On your Left Side
The September 11 2001 terrorist attacks were traced to Osama bin Laden and his al Qaeda network based in Afghanistan
Afghanistan History
On your Left SideWhat do your remember of Sept 11 2001Where were you
Al-Qaeda Defined A very complex
organization that has been in existence since the late 1980rsquos
Commits acts of violence aimed at America and Western Allies
Al-Qaeda training camp
1989-95 Birth and DevelopmentAl-Qaeda starts in the aftermath of Soviet invasion
1987By 1989 begins to target AmericaRecruits from across the globe including AmericaNo solid base (Afghanistan Egypt Iraq) 1991-1996 primarily based in SudanMuch soldier training and a system of Hierarchy
stabilized (Bin Laden Deputy 5 committees)
Conflict with bin Laden Escalates
Offers to raise a mujahidin army to defend Saudi Arabia from a potential invasion from Iraq in 1990
Saudi Arabia declines his offer opting instead to accept the assistance of the US and allow American troops (including women soldiers) in Saudi Arabia
Moves to Sudan by invitation of the Sudanese government in 1991
Supports several small to medium attacks against Western interests
Moves to Afghanistan in 1996 by invitation of the Taliban
Cruise missiles fired at al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan to kill bin Laden in 1998
Al-Qaedarsquos Strategy
Soldiers operate in fast moving light forces Work in complete secrecy to complete complex strategic strikes
Avoids engagement in conventional fighting (forces are not strong enough)
Spreads rumors fear and discouragement among enemy forces
Relies on a force of over 20000 professionally trained soldiers throughout the world
The organizationrsquos strengths are itsrsquo secrecy extensive influence and planning
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Must wear a burqa outside their home Must wear a burqa inside if a male is present
In public women
must be covered from
head to toe by a
burqa an oppressive
garment that has only
a tiny mesh opening
over the eyes
Through the burga the woman is unable to breath or see properly
She is unable to feel the sunshine or receive beneficial vitamin C from the sun
View through a veil or burka which all Afghan women are required to wear outside the home
Restricted vision has reportedly caused numerous accidents involving vehicles and women pedestrians
View Through the Burka
43
Since enforced veiling a growing number of women have been hit by vehicles because the burqa leaves them unable to walk fast or see where they are going
Once a Taliban tank rolled right over a veiled woman
Fortunately she fell between the tracks
Instead of being crushed to death she was not seriously hurt but was severely traumatized
Laws under the Taliban
Its now illegal to wear makeup nail polish
jewelry pluck your eyebrows cut your hair
short wear colorful or stylish clothes sheer
stockings white socks and shoes high heel
shoes walk loudly talk loudly laugh in
public or to participate in sports
One woman had the top of her thumb amputated for the crime of wearing nail polish
Female education from kindergarten through graduate school banned
Must do all of the household chores
Must not travel on a bus without a man or note authorizing permission
Employment for women banned
In fact the government didnt believe women should go out at all Women you should not step outside your residence read one of the Taliban dictates
Beating women (left)Executing a woman publicly (right)
Harsh Treatment of Women by Taliban
51
A young mother Torpeka was shot repeatedly by the Taliban while rushing her seriously ill toddler to a doctor
Veiled as the law requires she was spotted by a teenage Taliban guard who tried to stop her because she shouldnt have left her home
Afraid her child might die if she were delayed Torpeka kept going
The guard aimed his machine-gun and fired several rounds directly at her
She was hit but didnt die on the spot as she could have Instead Afghans watching the incident in the marketplace
stepped in and Torpeka and her child received prompt medical attention
When her family later complained to the Taliban authorities they were informed that it was the injured womans fault
She had no right being out in public in the first place
The Taliban took control of
Kabul on Sept 26 1996 and
began a reign of terror
Because of the civil unrest
many Afghan women are
widows -- there are 30000 in
Kabul alone - without close
male relatives and they are the
sole supporters of their
children
15000 women in the Kabul region of Afghanistan are widows but the law of the Taliban the Islamic fundamentalist groups that rule the region forbids them from leaving their homes without a male family member as an escort (John MooreAP Photo)
Yet by Taliban law they are unable to work to support the children or leave the house without a male family member to buy food
If there isnrsquot a male family member they face the possibility of a beating every time they leave their home
There are a few supplemental houses which provide free food to widows and orphans but many are forced to beg in the streets for money
Thousands of Afghan war-widows have no other option but to beg to save their children from hunger Any Taliban man can flog these ill-fated women in the streets because most of them have to leave their houses without a close male relative
Afghan women begging to survive
Talibs like these boys are authorized to use weapons and whips on women if they decide any are breaking the Talibans repressive laws
Taliban ldquoreligious policerdquo beating a woman in public
Prohibited women and girls from
being examined by male physicians
while at the same time prohibited
most female doctors and nurses
from working
There were only a few selected
female doctors allowed to operate
in segregated wards
Medical Issues for Women
At one of the rare hospitals for women a
reporter found still nearly lifeless
bodies lying motionless on top of beds
wrapped in their burqua unwilling to
speak eat or do anything but slowly
wasting away
Others have gone mad and were seen
crouched in corners perpetually rocking
or crying most of them in fear
Medical Issues for Women
Conditions were so deplorable for women under the Taliban that many became severely depressed
Without the resources to leave the country an increasing number were choosing suicide once rare there as a means of escape
Doctors are seeing a lot of esophageal burns Women are swallowing battery acid or poisonous household cleansers because they are easy to find But its a very painful way to die
Medical Issues for Women
Women have died of treatable ailments because male doctors were not allowed to treat them
Many women now forcibly housebound have attempted suicide by swallowing household cleaner rather than continuing to live under these conditions
97 of Afghan women surveyed by Physicians for Human Rights exhibit signs of major depression
The Medical Results of a Taliban Rule
At a huge risk of women students continue their education in an underground school
A woman who dared to defy Taliban orders by running a home school for girls was shot and killed in front of her husband daughter and students
A woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man not related to her was stoned to death for adultery
An elderly woman was brutally beaten with a metal cable until her leg was broken because her ankle was accidentally showing from underneath her burqa
The Consequences Breaking a Taliban Rule
Although the new constitution guarantees equal rights an opportunities for both men and womenhellipthat is not always the case
Health careChild birth
highest maternal death ratein the world
Male doctorsMen amp boys take precedence
in the few emergency rooms that exist (very few hospitals after Taliban rule)
Unequal opportunities jobs divorce custody
Women Today
Taliban Insurgencies ndash harsh policies for womenAfghanistanrsquos Human Rights Commission
1500 atrocities against women (2008)13 domestic violence cases200 forcibly married98 set themselves on fire100+ tried to commit suicide
by taking poisonIncreasing number of women
taking drugsJudgments against women (Jirgas)New ldquoRape Lawrdquo against Shiite women
Womenrsquos Problems
Imagine your were an older woman who lived under the prior government and was used to all the freedoms
How would you feel now that you are under the control of the Taliban
How is your life differentExplain
On your Left Side
The September 11 2001 terrorist attacks were traced to Osama bin Laden and his al Qaeda network based in Afghanistan
Afghanistan History
On your Left SideWhat do your remember of Sept 11 2001Where were you
Al-Qaeda Defined A very complex
organization that has been in existence since the late 1980rsquos
Commits acts of violence aimed at America and Western Allies
Al-Qaeda training camp
1989-95 Birth and DevelopmentAl-Qaeda starts in the aftermath of Soviet invasion
1987By 1989 begins to target AmericaRecruits from across the globe including AmericaNo solid base (Afghanistan Egypt Iraq) 1991-1996 primarily based in SudanMuch soldier training and a system of Hierarchy
stabilized (Bin Laden Deputy 5 committees)
Conflict with bin Laden Escalates
Offers to raise a mujahidin army to defend Saudi Arabia from a potential invasion from Iraq in 1990
Saudi Arabia declines his offer opting instead to accept the assistance of the US and allow American troops (including women soldiers) in Saudi Arabia
Moves to Sudan by invitation of the Sudanese government in 1991
Supports several small to medium attacks against Western interests
Moves to Afghanistan in 1996 by invitation of the Taliban
Cruise missiles fired at al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan to kill bin Laden in 1998
Al-Qaedarsquos Strategy
Soldiers operate in fast moving light forces Work in complete secrecy to complete complex strategic strikes
Avoids engagement in conventional fighting (forces are not strong enough)
Spreads rumors fear and discouragement among enemy forces
Relies on a force of over 20000 professionally trained soldiers throughout the world
The organizationrsquos strengths are itsrsquo secrecy extensive influence and planning
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
In public women
must be covered from
head to toe by a
burqa an oppressive
garment that has only
a tiny mesh opening
over the eyes
Through the burga the woman is unable to breath or see properly
She is unable to feel the sunshine or receive beneficial vitamin C from the sun
View through a veil or burka which all Afghan women are required to wear outside the home
Restricted vision has reportedly caused numerous accidents involving vehicles and women pedestrians
View Through the Burka
43
Since enforced veiling a growing number of women have been hit by vehicles because the burqa leaves them unable to walk fast or see where they are going
Once a Taliban tank rolled right over a veiled woman
Fortunately she fell between the tracks
Instead of being crushed to death she was not seriously hurt but was severely traumatized
Laws under the Taliban
Its now illegal to wear makeup nail polish
jewelry pluck your eyebrows cut your hair
short wear colorful or stylish clothes sheer
stockings white socks and shoes high heel
shoes walk loudly talk loudly laugh in
public or to participate in sports
One woman had the top of her thumb amputated for the crime of wearing nail polish
Female education from kindergarten through graduate school banned
Must do all of the household chores
Must not travel on a bus without a man or note authorizing permission
Employment for women banned
In fact the government didnt believe women should go out at all Women you should not step outside your residence read one of the Taliban dictates
Beating women (left)Executing a woman publicly (right)
Harsh Treatment of Women by Taliban
51
A young mother Torpeka was shot repeatedly by the Taliban while rushing her seriously ill toddler to a doctor
Veiled as the law requires she was spotted by a teenage Taliban guard who tried to stop her because she shouldnt have left her home
Afraid her child might die if she were delayed Torpeka kept going
The guard aimed his machine-gun and fired several rounds directly at her
She was hit but didnt die on the spot as she could have Instead Afghans watching the incident in the marketplace
stepped in and Torpeka and her child received prompt medical attention
When her family later complained to the Taliban authorities they were informed that it was the injured womans fault
She had no right being out in public in the first place
The Taliban took control of
Kabul on Sept 26 1996 and
began a reign of terror
Because of the civil unrest
many Afghan women are
widows -- there are 30000 in
Kabul alone - without close
male relatives and they are the
sole supporters of their
children
15000 women in the Kabul region of Afghanistan are widows but the law of the Taliban the Islamic fundamentalist groups that rule the region forbids them from leaving their homes without a male family member as an escort (John MooreAP Photo)
Yet by Taliban law they are unable to work to support the children or leave the house without a male family member to buy food
If there isnrsquot a male family member they face the possibility of a beating every time they leave their home
There are a few supplemental houses which provide free food to widows and orphans but many are forced to beg in the streets for money
Thousands of Afghan war-widows have no other option but to beg to save their children from hunger Any Taliban man can flog these ill-fated women in the streets because most of them have to leave their houses without a close male relative
Afghan women begging to survive
Talibs like these boys are authorized to use weapons and whips on women if they decide any are breaking the Talibans repressive laws
Taliban ldquoreligious policerdquo beating a woman in public
Prohibited women and girls from
being examined by male physicians
while at the same time prohibited
most female doctors and nurses
from working
There were only a few selected
female doctors allowed to operate
in segregated wards
Medical Issues for Women
At one of the rare hospitals for women a
reporter found still nearly lifeless
bodies lying motionless on top of beds
wrapped in their burqua unwilling to
speak eat or do anything but slowly
wasting away
Others have gone mad and were seen
crouched in corners perpetually rocking
or crying most of them in fear
Medical Issues for Women
Conditions were so deplorable for women under the Taliban that many became severely depressed
Without the resources to leave the country an increasing number were choosing suicide once rare there as a means of escape
Doctors are seeing a lot of esophageal burns Women are swallowing battery acid or poisonous household cleansers because they are easy to find But its a very painful way to die
Medical Issues for Women
Women have died of treatable ailments because male doctors were not allowed to treat them
Many women now forcibly housebound have attempted suicide by swallowing household cleaner rather than continuing to live under these conditions
97 of Afghan women surveyed by Physicians for Human Rights exhibit signs of major depression
The Medical Results of a Taliban Rule
At a huge risk of women students continue their education in an underground school
A woman who dared to defy Taliban orders by running a home school for girls was shot and killed in front of her husband daughter and students
A woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man not related to her was stoned to death for adultery
An elderly woman was brutally beaten with a metal cable until her leg was broken because her ankle was accidentally showing from underneath her burqa
The Consequences Breaking a Taliban Rule
Although the new constitution guarantees equal rights an opportunities for both men and womenhellipthat is not always the case
Health careChild birth
highest maternal death ratein the world
Male doctorsMen amp boys take precedence
in the few emergency rooms that exist (very few hospitals after Taliban rule)
Unequal opportunities jobs divorce custody
Women Today
Taliban Insurgencies ndash harsh policies for womenAfghanistanrsquos Human Rights Commission
1500 atrocities against women (2008)13 domestic violence cases200 forcibly married98 set themselves on fire100+ tried to commit suicide
by taking poisonIncreasing number of women
taking drugsJudgments against women (Jirgas)New ldquoRape Lawrdquo against Shiite women
Womenrsquos Problems
Imagine your were an older woman who lived under the prior government and was used to all the freedoms
How would you feel now that you are under the control of the Taliban
How is your life differentExplain
On your Left Side
The September 11 2001 terrorist attacks were traced to Osama bin Laden and his al Qaeda network based in Afghanistan
Afghanistan History
On your Left SideWhat do your remember of Sept 11 2001Where were you
Al-Qaeda Defined A very complex
organization that has been in existence since the late 1980rsquos
Commits acts of violence aimed at America and Western Allies
Al-Qaeda training camp
1989-95 Birth and DevelopmentAl-Qaeda starts in the aftermath of Soviet invasion
1987By 1989 begins to target AmericaRecruits from across the globe including AmericaNo solid base (Afghanistan Egypt Iraq) 1991-1996 primarily based in SudanMuch soldier training and a system of Hierarchy
stabilized (Bin Laden Deputy 5 committees)
Conflict with bin Laden Escalates
Offers to raise a mujahidin army to defend Saudi Arabia from a potential invasion from Iraq in 1990
Saudi Arabia declines his offer opting instead to accept the assistance of the US and allow American troops (including women soldiers) in Saudi Arabia
Moves to Sudan by invitation of the Sudanese government in 1991
Supports several small to medium attacks against Western interests
Moves to Afghanistan in 1996 by invitation of the Taliban
Cruise missiles fired at al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan to kill bin Laden in 1998
Al-Qaedarsquos Strategy
Soldiers operate in fast moving light forces Work in complete secrecy to complete complex strategic strikes
Avoids engagement in conventional fighting (forces are not strong enough)
Spreads rumors fear and discouragement among enemy forces
Relies on a force of over 20000 professionally trained soldiers throughout the world
The organizationrsquos strengths are itsrsquo secrecy extensive influence and planning
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Through the burga the woman is unable to breath or see properly
She is unable to feel the sunshine or receive beneficial vitamin C from the sun
View through a veil or burka which all Afghan women are required to wear outside the home
Restricted vision has reportedly caused numerous accidents involving vehicles and women pedestrians
View Through the Burka
43
Since enforced veiling a growing number of women have been hit by vehicles because the burqa leaves them unable to walk fast or see where they are going
Once a Taliban tank rolled right over a veiled woman
Fortunately she fell between the tracks
Instead of being crushed to death she was not seriously hurt but was severely traumatized
Laws under the Taliban
Its now illegal to wear makeup nail polish
jewelry pluck your eyebrows cut your hair
short wear colorful or stylish clothes sheer
stockings white socks and shoes high heel
shoes walk loudly talk loudly laugh in
public or to participate in sports
One woman had the top of her thumb amputated for the crime of wearing nail polish
Female education from kindergarten through graduate school banned
Must do all of the household chores
Must not travel on a bus without a man or note authorizing permission
Employment for women banned
In fact the government didnt believe women should go out at all Women you should not step outside your residence read one of the Taliban dictates
Beating women (left)Executing a woman publicly (right)
Harsh Treatment of Women by Taliban
51
A young mother Torpeka was shot repeatedly by the Taliban while rushing her seriously ill toddler to a doctor
Veiled as the law requires she was spotted by a teenage Taliban guard who tried to stop her because she shouldnt have left her home
Afraid her child might die if she were delayed Torpeka kept going
The guard aimed his machine-gun and fired several rounds directly at her
She was hit but didnt die on the spot as she could have Instead Afghans watching the incident in the marketplace
stepped in and Torpeka and her child received prompt medical attention
When her family later complained to the Taliban authorities they were informed that it was the injured womans fault
She had no right being out in public in the first place
The Taliban took control of
Kabul on Sept 26 1996 and
began a reign of terror
Because of the civil unrest
many Afghan women are
widows -- there are 30000 in
Kabul alone - without close
male relatives and they are the
sole supporters of their
children
15000 women in the Kabul region of Afghanistan are widows but the law of the Taliban the Islamic fundamentalist groups that rule the region forbids them from leaving their homes without a male family member as an escort (John MooreAP Photo)
Yet by Taliban law they are unable to work to support the children or leave the house without a male family member to buy food
If there isnrsquot a male family member they face the possibility of a beating every time they leave their home
There are a few supplemental houses which provide free food to widows and orphans but many are forced to beg in the streets for money
Thousands of Afghan war-widows have no other option but to beg to save their children from hunger Any Taliban man can flog these ill-fated women in the streets because most of them have to leave their houses without a close male relative
Afghan women begging to survive
Talibs like these boys are authorized to use weapons and whips on women if they decide any are breaking the Talibans repressive laws
Taliban ldquoreligious policerdquo beating a woman in public
Prohibited women and girls from
being examined by male physicians
while at the same time prohibited
most female doctors and nurses
from working
There were only a few selected
female doctors allowed to operate
in segregated wards
Medical Issues for Women
At one of the rare hospitals for women a
reporter found still nearly lifeless
bodies lying motionless on top of beds
wrapped in their burqua unwilling to
speak eat or do anything but slowly
wasting away
Others have gone mad and were seen
crouched in corners perpetually rocking
or crying most of them in fear
Medical Issues for Women
Conditions were so deplorable for women under the Taliban that many became severely depressed
Without the resources to leave the country an increasing number were choosing suicide once rare there as a means of escape
Doctors are seeing a lot of esophageal burns Women are swallowing battery acid or poisonous household cleansers because they are easy to find But its a very painful way to die
Medical Issues for Women
Women have died of treatable ailments because male doctors were not allowed to treat them
Many women now forcibly housebound have attempted suicide by swallowing household cleaner rather than continuing to live under these conditions
97 of Afghan women surveyed by Physicians for Human Rights exhibit signs of major depression
The Medical Results of a Taliban Rule
At a huge risk of women students continue their education in an underground school
A woman who dared to defy Taliban orders by running a home school for girls was shot and killed in front of her husband daughter and students
A woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man not related to her was stoned to death for adultery
An elderly woman was brutally beaten with a metal cable until her leg was broken because her ankle was accidentally showing from underneath her burqa
The Consequences Breaking a Taliban Rule
Although the new constitution guarantees equal rights an opportunities for both men and womenhellipthat is not always the case
Health careChild birth
highest maternal death ratein the world
Male doctorsMen amp boys take precedence
in the few emergency rooms that exist (very few hospitals after Taliban rule)
Unequal opportunities jobs divorce custody
Women Today
Taliban Insurgencies ndash harsh policies for womenAfghanistanrsquos Human Rights Commission
1500 atrocities against women (2008)13 domestic violence cases200 forcibly married98 set themselves on fire100+ tried to commit suicide
by taking poisonIncreasing number of women
taking drugsJudgments against women (Jirgas)New ldquoRape Lawrdquo against Shiite women
Womenrsquos Problems
Imagine your were an older woman who lived under the prior government and was used to all the freedoms
How would you feel now that you are under the control of the Taliban
How is your life differentExplain
On your Left Side
The September 11 2001 terrorist attacks were traced to Osama bin Laden and his al Qaeda network based in Afghanistan
Afghanistan History
On your Left SideWhat do your remember of Sept 11 2001Where were you
Al-Qaeda Defined A very complex
organization that has been in existence since the late 1980rsquos
Commits acts of violence aimed at America and Western Allies
Al-Qaeda training camp
1989-95 Birth and DevelopmentAl-Qaeda starts in the aftermath of Soviet invasion
1987By 1989 begins to target AmericaRecruits from across the globe including AmericaNo solid base (Afghanistan Egypt Iraq) 1991-1996 primarily based in SudanMuch soldier training and a system of Hierarchy
stabilized (Bin Laden Deputy 5 committees)
Conflict with bin Laden Escalates
Offers to raise a mujahidin army to defend Saudi Arabia from a potential invasion from Iraq in 1990
Saudi Arabia declines his offer opting instead to accept the assistance of the US and allow American troops (including women soldiers) in Saudi Arabia
Moves to Sudan by invitation of the Sudanese government in 1991
Supports several small to medium attacks against Western interests
Moves to Afghanistan in 1996 by invitation of the Taliban
Cruise missiles fired at al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan to kill bin Laden in 1998
Al-Qaedarsquos Strategy
Soldiers operate in fast moving light forces Work in complete secrecy to complete complex strategic strikes
Avoids engagement in conventional fighting (forces are not strong enough)
Spreads rumors fear and discouragement among enemy forces
Relies on a force of over 20000 professionally trained soldiers throughout the world
The organizationrsquos strengths are itsrsquo secrecy extensive influence and planning
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
View through a veil or burka which all Afghan women are required to wear outside the home
Restricted vision has reportedly caused numerous accidents involving vehicles and women pedestrians
View Through the Burka
43
Since enforced veiling a growing number of women have been hit by vehicles because the burqa leaves them unable to walk fast or see where they are going
Once a Taliban tank rolled right over a veiled woman
Fortunately she fell between the tracks
Instead of being crushed to death she was not seriously hurt but was severely traumatized
Laws under the Taliban
Its now illegal to wear makeup nail polish
jewelry pluck your eyebrows cut your hair
short wear colorful or stylish clothes sheer
stockings white socks and shoes high heel
shoes walk loudly talk loudly laugh in
public or to participate in sports
One woman had the top of her thumb amputated for the crime of wearing nail polish
Female education from kindergarten through graduate school banned
Must do all of the household chores
Must not travel on a bus without a man or note authorizing permission
Employment for women banned
In fact the government didnt believe women should go out at all Women you should not step outside your residence read one of the Taliban dictates
Beating women (left)Executing a woman publicly (right)
Harsh Treatment of Women by Taliban
51
A young mother Torpeka was shot repeatedly by the Taliban while rushing her seriously ill toddler to a doctor
Veiled as the law requires she was spotted by a teenage Taliban guard who tried to stop her because she shouldnt have left her home
Afraid her child might die if she were delayed Torpeka kept going
The guard aimed his machine-gun and fired several rounds directly at her
She was hit but didnt die on the spot as she could have Instead Afghans watching the incident in the marketplace
stepped in and Torpeka and her child received prompt medical attention
When her family later complained to the Taliban authorities they were informed that it was the injured womans fault
She had no right being out in public in the first place
The Taliban took control of
Kabul on Sept 26 1996 and
began a reign of terror
Because of the civil unrest
many Afghan women are
widows -- there are 30000 in
Kabul alone - without close
male relatives and they are the
sole supporters of their
children
15000 women in the Kabul region of Afghanistan are widows but the law of the Taliban the Islamic fundamentalist groups that rule the region forbids them from leaving their homes without a male family member as an escort (John MooreAP Photo)
Yet by Taliban law they are unable to work to support the children or leave the house without a male family member to buy food
If there isnrsquot a male family member they face the possibility of a beating every time they leave their home
There are a few supplemental houses which provide free food to widows and orphans but many are forced to beg in the streets for money
Thousands of Afghan war-widows have no other option but to beg to save their children from hunger Any Taliban man can flog these ill-fated women in the streets because most of them have to leave their houses without a close male relative
Afghan women begging to survive
Talibs like these boys are authorized to use weapons and whips on women if they decide any are breaking the Talibans repressive laws
Taliban ldquoreligious policerdquo beating a woman in public
Prohibited women and girls from
being examined by male physicians
while at the same time prohibited
most female doctors and nurses
from working
There were only a few selected
female doctors allowed to operate
in segregated wards
Medical Issues for Women
At one of the rare hospitals for women a
reporter found still nearly lifeless
bodies lying motionless on top of beds
wrapped in their burqua unwilling to
speak eat or do anything but slowly
wasting away
Others have gone mad and were seen
crouched in corners perpetually rocking
or crying most of them in fear
Medical Issues for Women
Conditions were so deplorable for women under the Taliban that many became severely depressed
Without the resources to leave the country an increasing number were choosing suicide once rare there as a means of escape
Doctors are seeing a lot of esophageal burns Women are swallowing battery acid or poisonous household cleansers because they are easy to find But its a very painful way to die
Medical Issues for Women
Women have died of treatable ailments because male doctors were not allowed to treat them
Many women now forcibly housebound have attempted suicide by swallowing household cleaner rather than continuing to live under these conditions
97 of Afghan women surveyed by Physicians for Human Rights exhibit signs of major depression
The Medical Results of a Taliban Rule
At a huge risk of women students continue their education in an underground school
A woman who dared to defy Taliban orders by running a home school for girls was shot and killed in front of her husband daughter and students
A woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man not related to her was stoned to death for adultery
An elderly woman was brutally beaten with a metal cable until her leg was broken because her ankle was accidentally showing from underneath her burqa
The Consequences Breaking a Taliban Rule
Although the new constitution guarantees equal rights an opportunities for both men and womenhellipthat is not always the case
Health careChild birth
highest maternal death ratein the world
Male doctorsMen amp boys take precedence
in the few emergency rooms that exist (very few hospitals after Taliban rule)
Unequal opportunities jobs divorce custody
Women Today
Taliban Insurgencies ndash harsh policies for womenAfghanistanrsquos Human Rights Commission
1500 atrocities against women (2008)13 domestic violence cases200 forcibly married98 set themselves on fire100+ tried to commit suicide
by taking poisonIncreasing number of women
taking drugsJudgments against women (Jirgas)New ldquoRape Lawrdquo against Shiite women
Womenrsquos Problems
Imagine your were an older woman who lived under the prior government and was used to all the freedoms
How would you feel now that you are under the control of the Taliban
How is your life differentExplain
On your Left Side
The September 11 2001 terrorist attacks were traced to Osama bin Laden and his al Qaeda network based in Afghanistan
Afghanistan History
On your Left SideWhat do your remember of Sept 11 2001Where were you
Al-Qaeda Defined A very complex
organization that has been in existence since the late 1980rsquos
Commits acts of violence aimed at America and Western Allies
Al-Qaeda training camp
1989-95 Birth and DevelopmentAl-Qaeda starts in the aftermath of Soviet invasion
1987By 1989 begins to target AmericaRecruits from across the globe including AmericaNo solid base (Afghanistan Egypt Iraq) 1991-1996 primarily based in SudanMuch soldier training and a system of Hierarchy
stabilized (Bin Laden Deputy 5 committees)
Conflict with bin Laden Escalates
Offers to raise a mujahidin army to defend Saudi Arabia from a potential invasion from Iraq in 1990
Saudi Arabia declines his offer opting instead to accept the assistance of the US and allow American troops (including women soldiers) in Saudi Arabia
Moves to Sudan by invitation of the Sudanese government in 1991
Supports several small to medium attacks against Western interests
Moves to Afghanistan in 1996 by invitation of the Taliban
Cruise missiles fired at al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan to kill bin Laden in 1998
Al-Qaedarsquos Strategy
Soldiers operate in fast moving light forces Work in complete secrecy to complete complex strategic strikes
Avoids engagement in conventional fighting (forces are not strong enough)
Spreads rumors fear and discouragement among enemy forces
Relies on a force of over 20000 professionally trained soldiers throughout the world
The organizationrsquos strengths are itsrsquo secrecy extensive influence and planning
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Since enforced veiling a growing number of women have been hit by vehicles because the burqa leaves them unable to walk fast or see where they are going
Once a Taliban tank rolled right over a veiled woman
Fortunately she fell between the tracks
Instead of being crushed to death she was not seriously hurt but was severely traumatized
Laws under the Taliban
Its now illegal to wear makeup nail polish
jewelry pluck your eyebrows cut your hair
short wear colorful or stylish clothes sheer
stockings white socks and shoes high heel
shoes walk loudly talk loudly laugh in
public or to participate in sports
One woman had the top of her thumb amputated for the crime of wearing nail polish
Female education from kindergarten through graduate school banned
Must do all of the household chores
Must not travel on a bus without a man or note authorizing permission
Employment for women banned
In fact the government didnt believe women should go out at all Women you should not step outside your residence read one of the Taliban dictates
Beating women (left)Executing a woman publicly (right)
Harsh Treatment of Women by Taliban
51
A young mother Torpeka was shot repeatedly by the Taliban while rushing her seriously ill toddler to a doctor
Veiled as the law requires she was spotted by a teenage Taliban guard who tried to stop her because she shouldnt have left her home
Afraid her child might die if she were delayed Torpeka kept going
The guard aimed his machine-gun and fired several rounds directly at her
She was hit but didnt die on the spot as she could have Instead Afghans watching the incident in the marketplace
stepped in and Torpeka and her child received prompt medical attention
When her family later complained to the Taliban authorities they were informed that it was the injured womans fault
She had no right being out in public in the first place
The Taliban took control of
Kabul on Sept 26 1996 and
began a reign of terror
Because of the civil unrest
many Afghan women are
widows -- there are 30000 in
Kabul alone - without close
male relatives and they are the
sole supporters of their
children
15000 women in the Kabul region of Afghanistan are widows but the law of the Taliban the Islamic fundamentalist groups that rule the region forbids them from leaving their homes without a male family member as an escort (John MooreAP Photo)
Yet by Taliban law they are unable to work to support the children or leave the house without a male family member to buy food
If there isnrsquot a male family member they face the possibility of a beating every time they leave their home
There are a few supplemental houses which provide free food to widows and orphans but many are forced to beg in the streets for money
Thousands of Afghan war-widows have no other option but to beg to save their children from hunger Any Taliban man can flog these ill-fated women in the streets because most of them have to leave their houses without a close male relative
Afghan women begging to survive
Talibs like these boys are authorized to use weapons and whips on women if they decide any are breaking the Talibans repressive laws
Taliban ldquoreligious policerdquo beating a woman in public
Prohibited women and girls from
being examined by male physicians
while at the same time prohibited
most female doctors and nurses
from working
There were only a few selected
female doctors allowed to operate
in segregated wards
Medical Issues for Women
At one of the rare hospitals for women a
reporter found still nearly lifeless
bodies lying motionless on top of beds
wrapped in their burqua unwilling to
speak eat or do anything but slowly
wasting away
Others have gone mad and were seen
crouched in corners perpetually rocking
or crying most of them in fear
Medical Issues for Women
Conditions were so deplorable for women under the Taliban that many became severely depressed
Without the resources to leave the country an increasing number were choosing suicide once rare there as a means of escape
Doctors are seeing a lot of esophageal burns Women are swallowing battery acid or poisonous household cleansers because they are easy to find But its a very painful way to die
Medical Issues for Women
Women have died of treatable ailments because male doctors were not allowed to treat them
Many women now forcibly housebound have attempted suicide by swallowing household cleaner rather than continuing to live under these conditions
97 of Afghan women surveyed by Physicians for Human Rights exhibit signs of major depression
The Medical Results of a Taliban Rule
At a huge risk of women students continue their education in an underground school
A woman who dared to defy Taliban orders by running a home school for girls was shot and killed in front of her husband daughter and students
A woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man not related to her was stoned to death for adultery
An elderly woman was brutally beaten with a metal cable until her leg was broken because her ankle was accidentally showing from underneath her burqa
The Consequences Breaking a Taliban Rule
Although the new constitution guarantees equal rights an opportunities for both men and womenhellipthat is not always the case
Health careChild birth
highest maternal death ratein the world
Male doctorsMen amp boys take precedence
in the few emergency rooms that exist (very few hospitals after Taliban rule)
Unequal opportunities jobs divorce custody
Women Today
Taliban Insurgencies ndash harsh policies for womenAfghanistanrsquos Human Rights Commission
1500 atrocities against women (2008)13 domestic violence cases200 forcibly married98 set themselves on fire100+ tried to commit suicide
by taking poisonIncreasing number of women
taking drugsJudgments against women (Jirgas)New ldquoRape Lawrdquo against Shiite women
Womenrsquos Problems
Imagine your were an older woman who lived under the prior government and was used to all the freedoms
How would you feel now that you are under the control of the Taliban
How is your life differentExplain
On your Left Side
The September 11 2001 terrorist attacks were traced to Osama bin Laden and his al Qaeda network based in Afghanistan
Afghanistan History
On your Left SideWhat do your remember of Sept 11 2001Where were you
Al-Qaeda Defined A very complex
organization that has been in existence since the late 1980rsquos
Commits acts of violence aimed at America and Western Allies
Al-Qaeda training camp
1989-95 Birth and DevelopmentAl-Qaeda starts in the aftermath of Soviet invasion
1987By 1989 begins to target AmericaRecruits from across the globe including AmericaNo solid base (Afghanistan Egypt Iraq) 1991-1996 primarily based in SudanMuch soldier training and a system of Hierarchy
stabilized (Bin Laden Deputy 5 committees)
Conflict with bin Laden Escalates
Offers to raise a mujahidin army to defend Saudi Arabia from a potential invasion from Iraq in 1990
Saudi Arabia declines his offer opting instead to accept the assistance of the US and allow American troops (including women soldiers) in Saudi Arabia
Moves to Sudan by invitation of the Sudanese government in 1991
Supports several small to medium attacks against Western interests
Moves to Afghanistan in 1996 by invitation of the Taliban
Cruise missiles fired at al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan to kill bin Laden in 1998
Al-Qaedarsquos Strategy
Soldiers operate in fast moving light forces Work in complete secrecy to complete complex strategic strikes
Avoids engagement in conventional fighting (forces are not strong enough)
Spreads rumors fear and discouragement among enemy forces
Relies on a force of over 20000 professionally trained soldiers throughout the world
The organizationrsquos strengths are itsrsquo secrecy extensive influence and planning
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Laws under the Taliban
Its now illegal to wear makeup nail polish
jewelry pluck your eyebrows cut your hair
short wear colorful or stylish clothes sheer
stockings white socks and shoes high heel
shoes walk loudly talk loudly laugh in
public or to participate in sports
One woman had the top of her thumb amputated for the crime of wearing nail polish
Female education from kindergarten through graduate school banned
Must do all of the household chores
Must not travel on a bus without a man or note authorizing permission
Employment for women banned
In fact the government didnt believe women should go out at all Women you should not step outside your residence read one of the Taliban dictates
Beating women (left)Executing a woman publicly (right)
Harsh Treatment of Women by Taliban
51
A young mother Torpeka was shot repeatedly by the Taliban while rushing her seriously ill toddler to a doctor
Veiled as the law requires she was spotted by a teenage Taliban guard who tried to stop her because she shouldnt have left her home
Afraid her child might die if she were delayed Torpeka kept going
The guard aimed his machine-gun and fired several rounds directly at her
She was hit but didnt die on the spot as she could have Instead Afghans watching the incident in the marketplace
stepped in and Torpeka and her child received prompt medical attention
When her family later complained to the Taliban authorities they were informed that it was the injured womans fault
She had no right being out in public in the first place
The Taliban took control of
Kabul on Sept 26 1996 and
began a reign of terror
Because of the civil unrest
many Afghan women are
widows -- there are 30000 in
Kabul alone - without close
male relatives and they are the
sole supporters of their
children
15000 women in the Kabul region of Afghanistan are widows but the law of the Taliban the Islamic fundamentalist groups that rule the region forbids them from leaving their homes without a male family member as an escort (John MooreAP Photo)
Yet by Taliban law they are unable to work to support the children or leave the house without a male family member to buy food
If there isnrsquot a male family member they face the possibility of a beating every time they leave their home
There are a few supplemental houses which provide free food to widows and orphans but many are forced to beg in the streets for money
Thousands of Afghan war-widows have no other option but to beg to save their children from hunger Any Taliban man can flog these ill-fated women in the streets because most of them have to leave their houses without a close male relative
Afghan women begging to survive
Talibs like these boys are authorized to use weapons and whips on women if they decide any are breaking the Talibans repressive laws
Taliban ldquoreligious policerdquo beating a woman in public
Prohibited women and girls from
being examined by male physicians
while at the same time prohibited
most female doctors and nurses
from working
There were only a few selected
female doctors allowed to operate
in segregated wards
Medical Issues for Women
At one of the rare hospitals for women a
reporter found still nearly lifeless
bodies lying motionless on top of beds
wrapped in their burqua unwilling to
speak eat or do anything but slowly
wasting away
Others have gone mad and were seen
crouched in corners perpetually rocking
or crying most of them in fear
Medical Issues for Women
Conditions were so deplorable for women under the Taliban that many became severely depressed
Without the resources to leave the country an increasing number were choosing suicide once rare there as a means of escape
Doctors are seeing a lot of esophageal burns Women are swallowing battery acid or poisonous household cleansers because they are easy to find But its a very painful way to die
Medical Issues for Women
Women have died of treatable ailments because male doctors were not allowed to treat them
Many women now forcibly housebound have attempted suicide by swallowing household cleaner rather than continuing to live under these conditions
97 of Afghan women surveyed by Physicians for Human Rights exhibit signs of major depression
The Medical Results of a Taliban Rule
At a huge risk of women students continue their education in an underground school
A woman who dared to defy Taliban orders by running a home school for girls was shot and killed in front of her husband daughter and students
A woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man not related to her was stoned to death for adultery
An elderly woman was brutally beaten with a metal cable until her leg was broken because her ankle was accidentally showing from underneath her burqa
The Consequences Breaking a Taliban Rule
Although the new constitution guarantees equal rights an opportunities for both men and womenhellipthat is not always the case
Health careChild birth
highest maternal death ratein the world
Male doctorsMen amp boys take precedence
in the few emergency rooms that exist (very few hospitals after Taliban rule)
Unequal opportunities jobs divorce custody
Women Today
Taliban Insurgencies ndash harsh policies for womenAfghanistanrsquos Human Rights Commission
1500 atrocities against women (2008)13 domestic violence cases200 forcibly married98 set themselves on fire100+ tried to commit suicide
by taking poisonIncreasing number of women
taking drugsJudgments against women (Jirgas)New ldquoRape Lawrdquo against Shiite women
Womenrsquos Problems
Imagine your were an older woman who lived under the prior government and was used to all the freedoms
How would you feel now that you are under the control of the Taliban
How is your life differentExplain
On your Left Side
The September 11 2001 terrorist attacks were traced to Osama bin Laden and his al Qaeda network based in Afghanistan
Afghanistan History
On your Left SideWhat do your remember of Sept 11 2001Where were you
Al-Qaeda Defined A very complex
organization that has been in existence since the late 1980rsquos
Commits acts of violence aimed at America and Western Allies
Al-Qaeda training camp
1989-95 Birth and DevelopmentAl-Qaeda starts in the aftermath of Soviet invasion
1987By 1989 begins to target AmericaRecruits from across the globe including AmericaNo solid base (Afghanistan Egypt Iraq) 1991-1996 primarily based in SudanMuch soldier training and a system of Hierarchy
stabilized (Bin Laden Deputy 5 committees)
Conflict with bin Laden Escalates
Offers to raise a mujahidin army to defend Saudi Arabia from a potential invasion from Iraq in 1990
Saudi Arabia declines his offer opting instead to accept the assistance of the US and allow American troops (including women soldiers) in Saudi Arabia
Moves to Sudan by invitation of the Sudanese government in 1991
Supports several small to medium attacks against Western interests
Moves to Afghanistan in 1996 by invitation of the Taliban
Cruise missiles fired at al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan to kill bin Laden in 1998
Al-Qaedarsquos Strategy
Soldiers operate in fast moving light forces Work in complete secrecy to complete complex strategic strikes
Avoids engagement in conventional fighting (forces are not strong enough)
Spreads rumors fear and discouragement among enemy forces
Relies on a force of over 20000 professionally trained soldiers throughout the world
The organizationrsquos strengths are itsrsquo secrecy extensive influence and planning
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
One woman had the top of her thumb amputated for the crime of wearing nail polish
Female education from kindergarten through graduate school banned
Must do all of the household chores
Must not travel on a bus without a man or note authorizing permission
Employment for women banned
In fact the government didnt believe women should go out at all Women you should not step outside your residence read one of the Taliban dictates
Beating women (left)Executing a woman publicly (right)
Harsh Treatment of Women by Taliban
51
A young mother Torpeka was shot repeatedly by the Taliban while rushing her seriously ill toddler to a doctor
Veiled as the law requires she was spotted by a teenage Taliban guard who tried to stop her because she shouldnt have left her home
Afraid her child might die if she were delayed Torpeka kept going
The guard aimed his machine-gun and fired several rounds directly at her
She was hit but didnt die on the spot as she could have Instead Afghans watching the incident in the marketplace
stepped in and Torpeka and her child received prompt medical attention
When her family later complained to the Taliban authorities they were informed that it was the injured womans fault
She had no right being out in public in the first place
The Taliban took control of
Kabul on Sept 26 1996 and
began a reign of terror
Because of the civil unrest
many Afghan women are
widows -- there are 30000 in
Kabul alone - without close
male relatives and they are the
sole supporters of their
children
15000 women in the Kabul region of Afghanistan are widows but the law of the Taliban the Islamic fundamentalist groups that rule the region forbids them from leaving their homes without a male family member as an escort (John MooreAP Photo)
Yet by Taliban law they are unable to work to support the children or leave the house without a male family member to buy food
If there isnrsquot a male family member they face the possibility of a beating every time they leave their home
There are a few supplemental houses which provide free food to widows and orphans but many are forced to beg in the streets for money
Thousands of Afghan war-widows have no other option but to beg to save their children from hunger Any Taliban man can flog these ill-fated women in the streets because most of them have to leave their houses without a close male relative
Afghan women begging to survive
Talibs like these boys are authorized to use weapons and whips on women if they decide any are breaking the Talibans repressive laws
Taliban ldquoreligious policerdquo beating a woman in public
Prohibited women and girls from
being examined by male physicians
while at the same time prohibited
most female doctors and nurses
from working
There were only a few selected
female doctors allowed to operate
in segregated wards
Medical Issues for Women
At one of the rare hospitals for women a
reporter found still nearly lifeless
bodies lying motionless on top of beds
wrapped in their burqua unwilling to
speak eat or do anything but slowly
wasting away
Others have gone mad and were seen
crouched in corners perpetually rocking
or crying most of them in fear
Medical Issues for Women
Conditions were so deplorable for women under the Taliban that many became severely depressed
Without the resources to leave the country an increasing number were choosing suicide once rare there as a means of escape
Doctors are seeing a lot of esophageal burns Women are swallowing battery acid or poisonous household cleansers because they are easy to find But its a very painful way to die
Medical Issues for Women
Women have died of treatable ailments because male doctors were not allowed to treat them
Many women now forcibly housebound have attempted suicide by swallowing household cleaner rather than continuing to live under these conditions
97 of Afghan women surveyed by Physicians for Human Rights exhibit signs of major depression
The Medical Results of a Taliban Rule
At a huge risk of women students continue their education in an underground school
A woman who dared to defy Taliban orders by running a home school for girls was shot and killed in front of her husband daughter and students
A woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man not related to her was stoned to death for adultery
An elderly woman was brutally beaten with a metal cable until her leg was broken because her ankle was accidentally showing from underneath her burqa
The Consequences Breaking a Taliban Rule
Although the new constitution guarantees equal rights an opportunities for both men and womenhellipthat is not always the case
Health careChild birth
highest maternal death ratein the world
Male doctorsMen amp boys take precedence
in the few emergency rooms that exist (very few hospitals after Taliban rule)
Unequal opportunities jobs divorce custody
Women Today
Taliban Insurgencies ndash harsh policies for womenAfghanistanrsquos Human Rights Commission
1500 atrocities against women (2008)13 domestic violence cases200 forcibly married98 set themselves on fire100+ tried to commit suicide
by taking poisonIncreasing number of women
taking drugsJudgments against women (Jirgas)New ldquoRape Lawrdquo against Shiite women
Womenrsquos Problems
Imagine your were an older woman who lived under the prior government and was used to all the freedoms
How would you feel now that you are under the control of the Taliban
How is your life differentExplain
On your Left Side
The September 11 2001 terrorist attacks were traced to Osama bin Laden and his al Qaeda network based in Afghanistan
Afghanistan History
On your Left SideWhat do your remember of Sept 11 2001Where were you
Al-Qaeda Defined A very complex
organization that has been in existence since the late 1980rsquos
Commits acts of violence aimed at America and Western Allies
Al-Qaeda training camp
1989-95 Birth and DevelopmentAl-Qaeda starts in the aftermath of Soviet invasion
1987By 1989 begins to target AmericaRecruits from across the globe including AmericaNo solid base (Afghanistan Egypt Iraq) 1991-1996 primarily based in SudanMuch soldier training and a system of Hierarchy
stabilized (Bin Laden Deputy 5 committees)
Conflict with bin Laden Escalates
Offers to raise a mujahidin army to defend Saudi Arabia from a potential invasion from Iraq in 1990
Saudi Arabia declines his offer opting instead to accept the assistance of the US and allow American troops (including women soldiers) in Saudi Arabia
Moves to Sudan by invitation of the Sudanese government in 1991
Supports several small to medium attacks against Western interests
Moves to Afghanistan in 1996 by invitation of the Taliban
Cruise missiles fired at al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan to kill bin Laden in 1998
Al-Qaedarsquos Strategy
Soldiers operate in fast moving light forces Work in complete secrecy to complete complex strategic strikes
Avoids engagement in conventional fighting (forces are not strong enough)
Spreads rumors fear and discouragement among enemy forces
Relies on a force of over 20000 professionally trained soldiers throughout the world
The organizationrsquos strengths are itsrsquo secrecy extensive influence and planning
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Female education from kindergarten through graduate school banned
Must do all of the household chores
Must not travel on a bus without a man or note authorizing permission
Employment for women banned
In fact the government didnt believe women should go out at all Women you should not step outside your residence read one of the Taliban dictates
Beating women (left)Executing a woman publicly (right)
Harsh Treatment of Women by Taliban
51
A young mother Torpeka was shot repeatedly by the Taliban while rushing her seriously ill toddler to a doctor
Veiled as the law requires she was spotted by a teenage Taliban guard who tried to stop her because she shouldnt have left her home
Afraid her child might die if she were delayed Torpeka kept going
The guard aimed his machine-gun and fired several rounds directly at her
She was hit but didnt die on the spot as she could have Instead Afghans watching the incident in the marketplace
stepped in and Torpeka and her child received prompt medical attention
When her family later complained to the Taliban authorities they were informed that it was the injured womans fault
She had no right being out in public in the first place
The Taliban took control of
Kabul on Sept 26 1996 and
began a reign of terror
Because of the civil unrest
many Afghan women are
widows -- there are 30000 in
Kabul alone - without close
male relatives and they are the
sole supporters of their
children
15000 women in the Kabul region of Afghanistan are widows but the law of the Taliban the Islamic fundamentalist groups that rule the region forbids them from leaving their homes without a male family member as an escort (John MooreAP Photo)
Yet by Taliban law they are unable to work to support the children or leave the house without a male family member to buy food
If there isnrsquot a male family member they face the possibility of a beating every time they leave their home
There are a few supplemental houses which provide free food to widows and orphans but many are forced to beg in the streets for money
Thousands of Afghan war-widows have no other option but to beg to save their children from hunger Any Taliban man can flog these ill-fated women in the streets because most of them have to leave their houses without a close male relative
Afghan women begging to survive
Talibs like these boys are authorized to use weapons and whips on women if they decide any are breaking the Talibans repressive laws
Taliban ldquoreligious policerdquo beating a woman in public
Prohibited women and girls from
being examined by male physicians
while at the same time prohibited
most female doctors and nurses
from working
There were only a few selected
female doctors allowed to operate
in segregated wards
Medical Issues for Women
At one of the rare hospitals for women a
reporter found still nearly lifeless
bodies lying motionless on top of beds
wrapped in their burqua unwilling to
speak eat or do anything but slowly
wasting away
Others have gone mad and were seen
crouched in corners perpetually rocking
or crying most of them in fear
Medical Issues for Women
Conditions were so deplorable for women under the Taliban that many became severely depressed
Without the resources to leave the country an increasing number were choosing suicide once rare there as a means of escape
Doctors are seeing a lot of esophageal burns Women are swallowing battery acid or poisonous household cleansers because they are easy to find But its a very painful way to die
Medical Issues for Women
Women have died of treatable ailments because male doctors were not allowed to treat them
Many women now forcibly housebound have attempted suicide by swallowing household cleaner rather than continuing to live under these conditions
97 of Afghan women surveyed by Physicians for Human Rights exhibit signs of major depression
The Medical Results of a Taliban Rule
At a huge risk of women students continue their education in an underground school
A woman who dared to defy Taliban orders by running a home school for girls was shot and killed in front of her husband daughter and students
A woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man not related to her was stoned to death for adultery
An elderly woman was brutally beaten with a metal cable until her leg was broken because her ankle was accidentally showing from underneath her burqa
The Consequences Breaking a Taliban Rule
Although the new constitution guarantees equal rights an opportunities for both men and womenhellipthat is not always the case
Health careChild birth
highest maternal death ratein the world
Male doctorsMen amp boys take precedence
in the few emergency rooms that exist (very few hospitals after Taliban rule)
Unequal opportunities jobs divorce custody
Women Today
Taliban Insurgencies ndash harsh policies for womenAfghanistanrsquos Human Rights Commission
1500 atrocities against women (2008)13 domestic violence cases200 forcibly married98 set themselves on fire100+ tried to commit suicide
by taking poisonIncreasing number of women
taking drugsJudgments against women (Jirgas)New ldquoRape Lawrdquo against Shiite women
Womenrsquos Problems
Imagine your were an older woman who lived under the prior government and was used to all the freedoms
How would you feel now that you are under the control of the Taliban
How is your life differentExplain
On your Left Side
The September 11 2001 terrorist attacks were traced to Osama bin Laden and his al Qaeda network based in Afghanistan
Afghanistan History
On your Left SideWhat do your remember of Sept 11 2001Where were you
Al-Qaeda Defined A very complex
organization that has been in existence since the late 1980rsquos
Commits acts of violence aimed at America and Western Allies
Al-Qaeda training camp
1989-95 Birth and DevelopmentAl-Qaeda starts in the aftermath of Soviet invasion
1987By 1989 begins to target AmericaRecruits from across the globe including AmericaNo solid base (Afghanistan Egypt Iraq) 1991-1996 primarily based in SudanMuch soldier training and a system of Hierarchy
stabilized (Bin Laden Deputy 5 committees)
Conflict with bin Laden Escalates
Offers to raise a mujahidin army to defend Saudi Arabia from a potential invasion from Iraq in 1990
Saudi Arabia declines his offer opting instead to accept the assistance of the US and allow American troops (including women soldiers) in Saudi Arabia
Moves to Sudan by invitation of the Sudanese government in 1991
Supports several small to medium attacks against Western interests
Moves to Afghanistan in 1996 by invitation of the Taliban
Cruise missiles fired at al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan to kill bin Laden in 1998
Al-Qaedarsquos Strategy
Soldiers operate in fast moving light forces Work in complete secrecy to complete complex strategic strikes
Avoids engagement in conventional fighting (forces are not strong enough)
Spreads rumors fear and discouragement among enemy forces
Relies on a force of over 20000 professionally trained soldiers throughout the world
The organizationrsquos strengths are itsrsquo secrecy extensive influence and planning
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
In fact the government didnt believe women should go out at all Women you should not step outside your residence read one of the Taliban dictates
Beating women (left)Executing a woman publicly (right)
Harsh Treatment of Women by Taliban
51
A young mother Torpeka was shot repeatedly by the Taliban while rushing her seriously ill toddler to a doctor
Veiled as the law requires she was spotted by a teenage Taliban guard who tried to stop her because she shouldnt have left her home
Afraid her child might die if she were delayed Torpeka kept going
The guard aimed his machine-gun and fired several rounds directly at her
She was hit but didnt die on the spot as she could have Instead Afghans watching the incident in the marketplace
stepped in and Torpeka and her child received prompt medical attention
When her family later complained to the Taliban authorities they were informed that it was the injured womans fault
She had no right being out in public in the first place
The Taliban took control of
Kabul on Sept 26 1996 and
began a reign of terror
Because of the civil unrest
many Afghan women are
widows -- there are 30000 in
Kabul alone - without close
male relatives and they are the
sole supporters of their
children
15000 women in the Kabul region of Afghanistan are widows but the law of the Taliban the Islamic fundamentalist groups that rule the region forbids them from leaving their homes without a male family member as an escort (John MooreAP Photo)
Yet by Taliban law they are unable to work to support the children or leave the house without a male family member to buy food
If there isnrsquot a male family member they face the possibility of a beating every time they leave their home
There are a few supplemental houses which provide free food to widows and orphans but many are forced to beg in the streets for money
Thousands of Afghan war-widows have no other option but to beg to save their children from hunger Any Taliban man can flog these ill-fated women in the streets because most of them have to leave their houses without a close male relative
Afghan women begging to survive
Talibs like these boys are authorized to use weapons and whips on women if they decide any are breaking the Talibans repressive laws
Taliban ldquoreligious policerdquo beating a woman in public
Prohibited women and girls from
being examined by male physicians
while at the same time prohibited
most female doctors and nurses
from working
There were only a few selected
female doctors allowed to operate
in segregated wards
Medical Issues for Women
At one of the rare hospitals for women a
reporter found still nearly lifeless
bodies lying motionless on top of beds
wrapped in their burqua unwilling to
speak eat or do anything but slowly
wasting away
Others have gone mad and were seen
crouched in corners perpetually rocking
or crying most of them in fear
Medical Issues for Women
Conditions were so deplorable for women under the Taliban that many became severely depressed
Without the resources to leave the country an increasing number were choosing suicide once rare there as a means of escape
Doctors are seeing a lot of esophageal burns Women are swallowing battery acid or poisonous household cleansers because they are easy to find But its a very painful way to die
Medical Issues for Women
Women have died of treatable ailments because male doctors were not allowed to treat them
Many women now forcibly housebound have attempted suicide by swallowing household cleaner rather than continuing to live under these conditions
97 of Afghan women surveyed by Physicians for Human Rights exhibit signs of major depression
The Medical Results of a Taliban Rule
At a huge risk of women students continue their education in an underground school
A woman who dared to defy Taliban orders by running a home school for girls was shot and killed in front of her husband daughter and students
A woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man not related to her was stoned to death for adultery
An elderly woman was brutally beaten with a metal cable until her leg was broken because her ankle was accidentally showing from underneath her burqa
The Consequences Breaking a Taliban Rule
Although the new constitution guarantees equal rights an opportunities for both men and womenhellipthat is not always the case
Health careChild birth
highest maternal death ratein the world
Male doctorsMen amp boys take precedence
in the few emergency rooms that exist (very few hospitals after Taliban rule)
Unequal opportunities jobs divorce custody
Women Today
Taliban Insurgencies ndash harsh policies for womenAfghanistanrsquos Human Rights Commission
1500 atrocities against women (2008)13 domestic violence cases200 forcibly married98 set themselves on fire100+ tried to commit suicide
by taking poisonIncreasing number of women
taking drugsJudgments against women (Jirgas)New ldquoRape Lawrdquo against Shiite women
Womenrsquos Problems
Imagine your were an older woman who lived under the prior government and was used to all the freedoms
How would you feel now that you are under the control of the Taliban
How is your life differentExplain
On your Left Side
The September 11 2001 terrorist attacks were traced to Osama bin Laden and his al Qaeda network based in Afghanistan
Afghanistan History
On your Left SideWhat do your remember of Sept 11 2001Where were you
Al-Qaeda Defined A very complex
organization that has been in existence since the late 1980rsquos
Commits acts of violence aimed at America and Western Allies
Al-Qaeda training camp
1989-95 Birth and DevelopmentAl-Qaeda starts in the aftermath of Soviet invasion
1987By 1989 begins to target AmericaRecruits from across the globe including AmericaNo solid base (Afghanistan Egypt Iraq) 1991-1996 primarily based in SudanMuch soldier training and a system of Hierarchy
stabilized (Bin Laden Deputy 5 committees)
Conflict with bin Laden Escalates
Offers to raise a mujahidin army to defend Saudi Arabia from a potential invasion from Iraq in 1990
Saudi Arabia declines his offer opting instead to accept the assistance of the US and allow American troops (including women soldiers) in Saudi Arabia
Moves to Sudan by invitation of the Sudanese government in 1991
Supports several small to medium attacks against Western interests
Moves to Afghanistan in 1996 by invitation of the Taliban
Cruise missiles fired at al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan to kill bin Laden in 1998
Al-Qaedarsquos Strategy
Soldiers operate in fast moving light forces Work in complete secrecy to complete complex strategic strikes
Avoids engagement in conventional fighting (forces are not strong enough)
Spreads rumors fear and discouragement among enemy forces
Relies on a force of over 20000 professionally trained soldiers throughout the world
The organizationrsquos strengths are itsrsquo secrecy extensive influence and planning
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Beating women (left)Executing a woman publicly (right)
Harsh Treatment of Women by Taliban
51
A young mother Torpeka was shot repeatedly by the Taliban while rushing her seriously ill toddler to a doctor
Veiled as the law requires she was spotted by a teenage Taliban guard who tried to stop her because she shouldnt have left her home
Afraid her child might die if she were delayed Torpeka kept going
The guard aimed his machine-gun and fired several rounds directly at her
She was hit but didnt die on the spot as she could have Instead Afghans watching the incident in the marketplace
stepped in and Torpeka and her child received prompt medical attention
When her family later complained to the Taliban authorities they were informed that it was the injured womans fault
She had no right being out in public in the first place
The Taliban took control of
Kabul on Sept 26 1996 and
began a reign of terror
Because of the civil unrest
many Afghan women are
widows -- there are 30000 in
Kabul alone - without close
male relatives and they are the
sole supporters of their
children
15000 women in the Kabul region of Afghanistan are widows but the law of the Taliban the Islamic fundamentalist groups that rule the region forbids them from leaving their homes without a male family member as an escort (John MooreAP Photo)
Yet by Taliban law they are unable to work to support the children or leave the house without a male family member to buy food
If there isnrsquot a male family member they face the possibility of a beating every time they leave their home
There are a few supplemental houses which provide free food to widows and orphans but many are forced to beg in the streets for money
Thousands of Afghan war-widows have no other option but to beg to save their children from hunger Any Taliban man can flog these ill-fated women in the streets because most of them have to leave their houses without a close male relative
Afghan women begging to survive
Talibs like these boys are authorized to use weapons and whips on women if they decide any are breaking the Talibans repressive laws
Taliban ldquoreligious policerdquo beating a woman in public
Prohibited women and girls from
being examined by male physicians
while at the same time prohibited
most female doctors and nurses
from working
There were only a few selected
female doctors allowed to operate
in segregated wards
Medical Issues for Women
At one of the rare hospitals for women a
reporter found still nearly lifeless
bodies lying motionless on top of beds
wrapped in their burqua unwilling to
speak eat or do anything but slowly
wasting away
Others have gone mad and were seen
crouched in corners perpetually rocking
or crying most of them in fear
Medical Issues for Women
Conditions were so deplorable for women under the Taliban that many became severely depressed
Without the resources to leave the country an increasing number were choosing suicide once rare there as a means of escape
Doctors are seeing a lot of esophageal burns Women are swallowing battery acid or poisonous household cleansers because they are easy to find But its a very painful way to die
Medical Issues for Women
Women have died of treatable ailments because male doctors were not allowed to treat them
Many women now forcibly housebound have attempted suicide by swallowing household cleaner rather than continuing to live under these conditions
97 of Afghan women surveyed by Physicians for Human Rights exhibit signs of major depression
The Medical Results of a Taliban Rule
At a huge risk of women students continue their education in an underground school
A woman who dared to defy Taliban orders by running a home school for girls was shot and killed in front of her husband daughter and students
A woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man not related to her was stoned to death for adultery
An elderly woman was brutally beaten with a metal cable until her leg was broken because her ankle was accidentally showing from underneath her burqa
The Consequences Breaking a Taliban Rule
Although the new constitution guarantees equal rights an opportunities for both men and womenhellipthat is not always the case
Health careChild birth
highest maternal death ratein the world
Male doctorsMen amp boys take precedence
in the few emergency rooms that exist (very few hospitals after Taliban rule)
Unequal opportunities jobs divorce custody
Women Today
Taliban Insurgencies ndash harsh policies for womenAfghanistanrsquos Human Rights Commission
1500 atrocities against women (2008)13 domestic violence cases200 forcibly married98 set themselves on fire100+ tried to commit suicide
by taking poisonIncreasing number of women
taking drugsJudgments against women (Jirgas)New ldquoRape Lawrdquo against Shiite women
Womenrsquos Problems
Imagine your were an older woman who lived under the prior government and was used to all the freedoms
How would you feel now that you are under the control of the Taliban
How is your life differentExplain
On your Left Side
The September 11 2001 terrorist attacks were traced to Osama bin Laden and his al Qaeda network based in Afghanistan
Afghanistan History
On your Left SideWhat do your remember of Sept 11 2001Where were you
Al-Qaeda Defined A very complex
organization that has been in existence since the late 1980rsquos
Commits acts of violence aimed at America and Western Allies
Al-Qaeda training camp
1989-95 Birth and DevelopmentAl-Qaeda starts in the aftermath of Soviet invasion
1987By 1989 begins to target AmericaRecruits from across the globe including AmericaNo solid base (Afghanistan Egypt Iraq) 1991-1996 primarily based in SudanMuch soldier training and a system of Hierarchy
stabilized (Bin Laden Deputy 5 committees)
Conflict with bin Laden Escalates
Offers to raise a mujahidin army to defend Saudi Arabia from a potential invasion from Iraq in 1990
Saudi Arabia declines his offer opting instead to accept the assistance of the US and allow American troops (including women soldiers) in Saudi Arabia
Moves to Sudan by invitation of the Sudanese government in 1991
Supports several small to medium attacks against Western interests
Moves to Afghanistan in 1996 by invitation of the Taliban
Cruise missiles fired at al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan to kill bin Laden in 1998
Al-Qaedarsquos Strategy
Soldiers operate in fast moving light forces Work in complete secrecy to complete complex strategic strikes
Avoids engagement in conventional fighting (forces are not strong enough)
Spreads rumors fear and discouragement among enemy forces
Relies on a force of over 20000 professionally trained soldiers throughout the world
The organizationrsquos strengths are itsrsquo secrecy extensive influence and planning
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
A young mother Torpeka was shot repeatedly by the Taliban while rushing her seriously ill toddler to a doctor
Veiled as the law requires she was spotted by a teenage Taliban guard who tried to stop her because she shouldnt have left her home
Afraid her child might die if she were delayed Torpeka kept going
The guard aimed his machine-gun and fired several rounds directly at her
She was hit but didnt die on the spot as she could have Instead Afghans watching the incident in the marketplace
stepped in and Torpeka and her child received prompt medical attention
When her family later complained to the Taliban authorities they were informed that it was the injured womans fault
She had no right being out in public in the first place
The Taliban took control of
Kabul on Sept 26 1996 and
began a reign of terror
Because of the civil unrest
many Afghan women are
widows -- there are 30000 in
Kabul alone - without close
male relatives and they are the
sole supporters of their
children
15000 women in the Kabul region of Afghanistan are widows but the law of the Taliban the Islamic fundamentalist groups that rule the region forbids them from leaving their homes without a male family member as an escort (John MooreAP Photo)
Yet by Taliban law they are unable to work to support the children or leave the house without a male family member to buy food
If there isnrsquot a male family member they face the possibility of a beating every time they leave their home
There are a few supplemental houses which provide free food to widows and orphans but many are forced to beg in the streets for money
Thousands of Afghan war-widows have no other option but to beg to save their children from hunger Any Taliban man can flog these ill-fated women in the streets because most of them have to leave their houses without a close male relative
Afghan women begging to survive
Talibs like these boys are authorized to use weapons and whips on women if they decide any are breaking the Talibans repressive laws
Taliban ldquoreligious policerdquo beating a woman in public
Prohibited women and girls from
being examined by male physicians
while at the same time prohibited
most female doctors and nurses
from working
There were only a few selected
female doctors allowed to operate
in segregated wards
Medical Issues for Women
At one of the rare hospitals for women a
reporter found still nearly lifeless
bodies lying motionless on top of beds
wrapped in their burqua unwilling to
speak eat or do anything but slowly
wasting away
Others have gone mad and were seen
crouched in corners perpetually rocking
or crying most of them in fear
Medical Issues for Women
Conditions were so deplorable for women under the Taliban that many became severely depressed
Without the resources to leave the country an increasing number were choosing suicide once rare there as a means of escape
Doctors are seeing a lot of esophageal burns Women are swallowing battery acid or poisonous household cleansers because they are easy to find But its a very painful way to die
Medical Issues for Women
Women have died of treatable ailments because male doctors were not allowed to treat them
Many women now forcibly housebound have attempted suicide by swallowing household cleaner rather than continuing to live under these conditions
97 of Afghan women surveyed by Physicians for Human Rights exhibit signs of major depression
The Medical Results of a Taliban Rule
At a huge risk of women students continue their education in an underground school
A woman who dared to defy Taliban orders by running a home school for girls was shot and killed in front of her husband daughter and students
A woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man not related to her was stoned to death for adultery
An elderly woman was brutally beaten with a metal cable until her leg was broken because her ankle was accidentally showing from underneath her burqa
The Consequences Breaking a Taliban Rule
Although the new constitution guarantees equal rights an opportunities for both men and womenhellipthat is not always the case
Health careChild birth
highest maternal death ratein the world
Male doctorsMen amp boys take precedence
in the few emergency rooms that exist (very few hospitals after Taliban rule)
Unequal opportunities jobs divorce custody
Women Today
Taliban Insurgencies ndash harsh policies for womenAfghanistanrsquos Human Rights Commission
1500 atrocities against women (2008)13 domestic violence cases200 forcibly married98 set themselves on fire100+ tried to commit suicide
by taking poisonIncreasing number of women
taking drugsJudgments against women (Jirgas)New ldquoRape Lawrdquo against Shiite women
Womenrsquos Problems
Imagine your were an older woman who lived under the prior government and was used to all the freedoms
How would you feel now that you are under the control of the Taliban
How is your life differentExplain
On your Left Side
The September 11 2001 terrorist attacks were traced to Osama bin Laden and his al Qaeda network based in Afghanistan
Afghanistan History
On your Left SideWhat do your remember of Sept 11 2001Where were you
Al-Qaeda Defined A very complex
organization that has been in existence since the late 1980rsquos
Commits acts of violence aimed at America and Western Allies
Al-Qaeda training camp
1989-95 Birth and DevelopmentAl-Qaeda starts in the aftermath of Soviet invasion
1987By 1989 begins to target AmericaRecruits from across the globe including AmericaNo solid base (Afghanistan Egypt Iraq) 1991-1996 primarily based in SudanMuch soldier training and a system of Hierarchy
stabilized (Bin Laden Deputy 5 committees)
Conflict with bin Laden Escalates
Offers to raise a mujahidin army to defend Saudi Arabia from a potential invasion from Iraq in 1990
Saudi Arabia declines his offer opting instead to accept the assistance of the US and allow American troops (including women soldiers) in Saudi Arabia
Moves to Sudan by invitation of the Sudanese government in 1991
Supports several small to medium attacks against Western interests
Moves to Afghanistan in 1996 by invitation of the Taliban
Cruise missiles fired at al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan to kill bin Laden in 1998
Al-Qaedarsquos Strategy
Soldiers operate in fast moving light forces Work in complete secrecy to complete complex strategic strikes
Avoids engagement in conventional fighting (forces are not strong enough)
Spreads rumors fear and discouragement among enemy forces
Relies on a force of over 20000 professionally trained soldiers throughout the world
The organizationrsquos strengths are itsrsquo secrecy extensive influence and planning
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
The Taliban took control of
Kabul on Sept 26 1996 and
began a reign of terror
Because of the civil unrest
many Afghan women are
widows -- there are 30000 in
Kabul alone - without close
male relatives and they are the
sole supporters of their
children
15000 women in the Kabul region of Afghanistan are widows but the law of the Taliban the Islamic fundamentalist groups that rule the region forbids them from leaving their homes without a male family member as an escort (John MooreAP Photo)
Yet by Taliban law they are unable to work to support the children or leave the house without a male family member to buy food
If there isnrsquot a male family member they face the possibility of a beating every time they leave their home
There are a few supplemental houses which provide free food to widows and orphans but many are forced to beg in the streets for money
Thousands of Afghan war-widows have no other option but to beg to save their children from hunger Any Taliban man can flog these ill-fated women in the streets because most of them have to leave their houses without a close male relative
Afghan women begging to survive
Talibs like these boys are authorized to use weapons and whips on women if they decide any are breaking the Talibans repressive laws
Taliban ldquoreligious policerdquo beating a woman in public
Prohibited women and girls from
being examined by male physicians
while at the same time prohibited
most female doctors and nurses
from working
There were only a few selected
female doctors allowed to operate
in segregated wards
Medical Issues for Women
At one of the rare hospitals for women a
reporter found still nearly lifeless
bodies lying motionless on top of beds
wrapped in their burqua unwilling to
speak eat or do anything but slowly
wasting away
Others have gone mad and were seen
crouched in corners perpetually rocking
or crying most of them in fear
Medical Issues for Women
Conditions were so deplorable for women under the Taliban that many became severely depressed
Without the resources to leave the country an increasing number were choosing suicide once rare there as a means of escape
Doctors are seeing a lot of esophageal burns Women are swallowing battery acid or poisonous household cleansers because they are easy to find But its a very painful way to die
Medical Issues for Women
Women have died of treatable ailments because male doctors were not allowed to treat them
Many women now forcibly housebound have attempted suicide by swallowing household cleaner rather than continuing to live under these conditions
97 of Afghan women surveyed by Physicians for Human Rights exhibit signs of major depression
The Medical Results of a Taliban Rule
At a huge risk of women students continue their education in an underground school
A woman who dared to defy Taliban orders by running a home school for girls was shot and killed in front of her husband daughter and students
A woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man not related to her was stoned to death for adultery
An elderly woman was brutally beaten with a metal cable until her leg was broken because her ankle was accidentally showing from underneath her burqa
The Consequences Breaking a Taliban Rule
Although the new constitution guarantees equal rights an opportunities for both men and womenhellipthat is not always the case
Health careChild birth
highest maternal death ratein the world
Male doctorsMen amp boys take precedence
in the few emergency rooms that exist (very few hospitals after Taliban rule)
Unequal opportunities jobs divorce custody
Women Today
Taliban Insurgencies ndash harsh policies for womenAfghanistanrsquos Human Rights Commission
1500 atrocities against women (2008)13 domestic violence cases200 forcibly married98 set themselves on fire100+ tried to commit suicide
by taking poisonIncreasing number of women
taking drugsJudgments against women (Jirgas)New ldquoRape Lawrdquo against Shiite women
Womenrsquos Problems
Imagine your were an older woman who lived under the prior government and was used to all the freedoms
How would you feel now that you are under the control of the Taliban
How is your life differentExplain
On your Left Side
The September 11 2001 terrorist attacks were traced to Osama bin Laden and his al Qaeda network based in Afghanistan
Afghanistan History
On your Left SideWhat do your remember of Sept 11 2001Where were you
Al-Qaeda Defined A very complex
organization that has been in existence since the late 1980rsquos
Commits acts of violence aimed at America and Western Allies
Al-Qaeda training camp
1989-95 Birth and DevelopmentAl-Qaeda starts in the aftermath of Soviet invasion
1987By 1989 begins to target AmericaRecruits from across the globe including AmericaNo solid base (Afghanistan Egypt Iraq) 1991-1996 primarily based in SudanMuch soldier training and a system of Hierarchy
stabilized (Bin Laden Deputy 5 committees)
Conflict with bin Laden Escalates
Offers to raise a mujahidin army to defend Saudi Arabia from a potential invasion from Iraq in 1990
Saudi Arabia declines his offer opting instead to accept the assistance of the US and allow American troops (including women soldiers) in Saudi Arabia
Moves to Sudan by invitation of the Sudanese government in 1991
Supports several small to medium attacks against Western interests
Moves to Afghanistan in 1996 by invitation of the Taliban
Cruise missiles fired at al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan to kill bin Laden in 1998
Al-Qaedarsquos Strategy
Soldiers operate in fast moving light forces Work in complete secrecy to complete complex strategic strikes
Avoids engagement in conventional fighting (forces are not strong enough)
Spreads rumors fear and discouragement among enemy forces
Relies on a force of over 20000 professionally trained soldiers throughout the world
The organizationrsquos strengths are itsrsquo secrecy extensive influence and planning
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
15000 women in the Kabul region of Afghanistan are widows but the law of the Taliban the Islamic fundamentalist groups that rule the region forbids them from leaving their homes without a male family member as an escort (John MooreAP Photo)
Yet by Taliban law they are unable to work to support the children or leave the house without a male family member to buy food
If there isnrsquot a male family member they face the possibility of a beating every time they leave their home
There are a few supplemental houses which provide free food to widows and orphans but many are forced to beg in the streets for money
Thousands of Afghan war-widows have no other option but to beg to save their children from hunger Any Taliban man can flog these ill-fated women in the streets because most of them have to leave their houses without a close male relative
Afghan women begging to survive
Talibs like these boys are authorized to use weapons and whips on women if they decide any are breaking the Talibans repressive laws
Taliban ldquoreligious policerdquo beating a woman in public
Prohibited women and girls from
being examined by male physicians
while at the same time prohibited
most female doctors and nurses
from working
There were only a few selected
female doctors allowed to operate
in segregated wards
Medical Issues for Women
At one of the rare hospitals for women a
reporter found still nearly lifeless
bodies lying motionless on top of beds
wrapped in their burqua unwilling to
speak eat or do anything but slowly
wasting away
Others have gone mad and were seen
crouched in corners perpetually rocking
or crying most of them in fear
Medical Issues for Women
Conditions were so deplorable for women under the Taliban that many became severely depressed
Without the resources to leave the country an increasing number were choosing suicide once rare there as a means of escape
Doctors are seeing a lot of esophageal burns Women are swallowing battery acid or poisonous household cleansers because they are easy to find But its a very painful way to die
Medical Issues for Women
Women have died of treatable ailments because male doctors were not allowed to treat them
Many women now forcibly housebound have attempted suicide by swallowing household cleaner rather than continuing to live under these conditions
97 of Afghan women surveyed by Physicians for Human Rights exhibit signs of major depression
The Medical Results of a Taliban Rule
At a huge risk of women students continue their education in an underground school
A woman who dared to defy Taliban orders by running a home school for girls was shot and killed in front of her husband daughter and students
A woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man not related to her was stoned to death for adultery
An elderly woman was brutally beaten with a metal cable until her leg was broken because her ankle was accidentally showing from underneath her burqa
The Consequences Breaking a Taliban Rule
Although the new constitution guarantees equal rights an opportunities for both men and womenhellipthat is not always the case
Health careChild birth
highest maternal death ratein the world
Male doctorsMen amp boys take precedence
in the few emergency rooms that exist (very few hospitals after Taliban rule)
Unequal opportunities jobs divorce custody
Women Today
Taliban Insurgencies ndash harsh policies for womenAfghanistanrsquos Human Rights Commission
1500 atrocities against women (2008)13 domestic violence cases200 forcibly married98 set themselves on fire100+ tried to commit suicide
by taking poisonIncreasing number of women
taking drugsJudgments against women (Jirgas)New ldquoRape Lawrdquo against Shiite women
Womenrsquos Problems
Imagine your were an older woman who lived under the prior government and was used to all the freedoms
How would you feel now that you are under the control of the Taliban
How is your life differentExplain
On your Left Side
The September 11 2001 terrorist attacks were traced to Osama bin Laden and his al Qaeda network based in Afghanistan
Afghanistan History
On your Left SideWhat do your remember of Sept 11 2001Where were you
Al-Qaeda Defined A very complex
organization that has been in existence since the late 1980rsquos
Commits acts of violence aimed at America and Western Allies
Al-Qaeda training camp
1989-95 Birth and DevelopmentAl-Qaeda starts in the aftermath of Soviet invasion
1987By 1989 begins to target AmericaRecruits from across the globe including AmericaNo solid base (Afghanistan Egypt Iraq) 1991-1996 primarily based in SudanMuch soldier training and a system of Hierarchy
stabilized (Bin Laden Deputy 5 committees)
Conflict with bin Laden Escalates
Offers to raise a mujahidin army to defend Saudi Arabia from a potential invasion from Iraq in 1990
Saudi Arabia declines his offer opting instead to accept the assistance of the US and allow American troops (including women soldiers) in Saudi Arabia
Moves to Sudan by invitation of the Sudanese government in 1991
Supports several small to medium attacks against Western interests
Moves to Afghanistan in 1996 by invitation of the Taliban
Cruise missiles fired at al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan to kill bin Laden in 1998
Al-Qaedarsquos Strategy
Soldiers operate in fast moving light forces Work in complete secrecy to complete complex strategic strikes
Avoids engagement in conventional fighting (forces are not strong enough)
Spreads rumors fear and discouragement among enemy forces
Relies on a force of over 20000 professionally trained soldiers throughout the world
The organizationrsquos strengths are itsrsquo secrecy extensive influence and planning
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Yet by Taliban law they are unable to work to support the children or leave the house without a male family member to buy food
If there isnrsquot a male family member they face the possibility of a beating every time they leave their home
There are a few supplemental houses which provide free food to widows and orphans but many are forced to beg in the streets for money
Thousands of Afghan war-widows have no other option but to beg to save their children from hunger Any Taliban man can flog these ill-fated women in the streets because most of them have to leave their houses without a close male relative
Afghan women begging to survive
Talibs like these boys are authorized to use weapons and whips on women if they decide any are breaking the Talibans repressive laws
Taliban ldquoreligious policerdquo beating a woman in public
Prohibited women and girls from
being examined by male physicians
while at the same time prohibited
most female doctors and nurses
from working
There were only a few selected
female doctors allowed to operate
in segregated wards
Medical Issues for Women
At one of the rare hospitals for women a
reporter found still nearly lifeless
bodies lying motionless on top of beds
wrapped in their burqua unwilling to
speak eat or do anything but slowly
wasting away
Others have gone mad and were seen
crouched in corners perpetually rocking
or crying most of them in fear
Medical Issues for Women
Conditions were so deplorable for women under the Taliban that many became severely depressed
Without the resources to leave the country an increasing number were choosing suicide once rare there as a means of escape
Doctors are seeing a lot of esophageal burns Women are swallowing battery acid or poisonous household cleansers because they are easy to find But its a very painful way to die
Medical Issues for Women
Women have died of treatable ailments because male doctors were not allowed to treat them
Many women now forcibly housebound have attempted suicide by swallowing household cleaner rather than continuing to live under these conditions
97 of Afghan women surveyed by Physicians for Human Rights exhibit signs of major depression
The Medical Results of a Taliban Rule
At a huge risk of women students continue their education in an underground school
A woman who dared to defy Taliban orders by running a home school for girls was shot and killed in front of her husband daughter and students
A woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man not related to her was stoned to death for adultery
An elderly woman was brutally beaten with a metal cable until her leg was broken because her ankle was accidentally showing from underneath her burqa
The Consequences Breaking a Taliban Rule
Although the new constitution guarantees equal rights an opportunities for both men and womenhellipthat is not always the case
Health careChild birth
highest maternal death ratein the world
Male doctorsMen amp boys take precedence
in the few emergency rooms that exist (very few hospitals after Taliban rule)
Unequal opportunities jobs divorce custody
Women Today
Taliban Insurgencies ndash harsh policies for womenAfghanistanrsquos Human Rights Commission
1500 atrocities against women (2008)13 domestic violence cases200 forcibly married98 set themselves on fire100+ tried to commit suicide
by taking poisonIncreasing number of women
taking drugsJudgments against women (Jirgas)New ldquoRape Lawrdquo against Shiite women
Womenrsquos Problems
Imagine your were an older woman who lived under the prior government and was used to all the freedoms
How would you feel now that you are under the control of the Taliban
How is your life differentExplain
On your Left Side
The September 11 2001 terrorist attacks were traced to Osama bin Laden and his al Qaeda network based in Afghanistan
Afghanistan History
On your Left SideWhat do your remember of Sept 11 2001Where were you
Al-Qaeda Defined A very complex
organization that has been in existence since the late 1980rsquos
Commits acts of violence aimed at America and Western Allies
Al-Qaeda training camp
1989-95 Birth and DevelopmentAl-Qaeda starts in the aftermath of Soviet invasion
1987By 1989 begins to target AmericaRecruits from across the globe including AmericaNo solid base (Afghanistan Egypt Iraq) 1991-1996 primarily based in SudanMuch soldier training and a system of Hierarchy
stabilized (Bin Laden Deputy 5 committees)
Conflict with bin Laden Escalates
Offers to raise a mujahidin army to defend Saudi Arabia from a potential invasion from Iraq in 1990
Saudi Arabia declines his offer opting instead to accept the assistance of the US and allow American troops (including women soldiers) in Saudi Arabia
Moves to Sudan by invitation of the Sudanese government in 1991
Supports several small to medium attacks against Western interests
Moves to Afghanistan in 1996 by invitation of the Taliban
Cruise missiles fired at al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan to kill bin Laden in 1998
Al-Qaedarsquos Strategy
Soldiers operate in fast moving light forces Work in complete secrecy to complete complex strategic strikes
Avoids engagement in conventional fighting (forces are not strong enough)
Spreads rumors fear and discouragement among enemy forces
Relies on a force of over 20000 professionally trained soldiers throughout the world
The organizationrsquos strengths are itsrsquo secrecy extensive influence and planning
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Thousands of Afghan war-widows have no other option but to beg to save their children from hunger Any Taliban man can flog these ill-fated women in the streets because most of them have to leave their houses without a close male relative
Afghan women begging to survive
Talibs like these boys are authorized to use weapons and whips on women if they decide any are breaking the Talibans repressive laws
Taliban ldquoreligious policerdquo beating a woman in public
Prohibited women and girls from
being examined by male physicians
while at the same time prohibited
most female doctors and nurses
from working
There were only a few selected
female doctors allowed to operate
in segregated wards
Medical Issues for Women
At one of the rare hospitals for women a
reporter found still nearly lifeless
bodies lying motionless on top of beds
wrapped in their burqua unwilling to
speak eat or do anything but slowly
wasting away
Others have gone mad and were seen
crouched in corners perpetually rocking
or crying most of them in fear
Medical Issues for Women
Conditions were so deplorable for women under the Taliban that many became severely depressed
Without the resources to leave the country an increasing number were choosing suicide once rare there as a means of escape
Doctors are seeing a lot of esophageal burns Women are swallowing battery acid or poisonous household cleansers because they are easy to find But its a very painful way to die
Medical Issues for Women
Women have died of treatable ailments because male doctors were not allowed to treat them
Many women now forcibly housebound have attempted suicide by swallowing household cleaner rather than continuing to live under these conditions
97 of Afghan women surveyed by Physicians for Human Rights exhibit signs of major depression
The Medical Results of a Taliban Rule
At a huge risk of women students continue their education in an underground school
A woman who dared to defy Taliban orders by running a home school for girls was shot and killed in front of her husband daughter and students
A woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man not related to her was stoned to death for adultery
An elderly woman was brutally beaten with a metal cable until her leg was broken because her ankle was accidentally showing from underneath her burqa
The Consequences Breaking a Taliban Rule
Although the new constitution guarantees equal rights an opportunities for both men and womenhellipthat is not always the case
Health careChild birth
highest maternal death ratein the world
Male doctorsMen amp boys take precedence
in the few emergency rooms that exist (very few hospitals after Taliban rule)
Unequal opportunities jobs divorce custody
Women Today
Taliban Insurgencies ndash harsh policies for womenAfghanistanrsquos Human Rights Commission
1500 atrocities against women (2008)13 domestic violence cases200 forcibly married98 set themselves on fire100+ tried to commit suicide
by taking poisonIncreasing number of women
taking drugsJudgments against women (Jirgas)New ldquoRape Lawrdquo against Shiite women
Womenrsquos Problems
Imagine your were an older woman who lived under the prior government and was used to all the freedoms
How would you feel now that you are under the control of the Taliban
How is your life differentExplain
On your Left Side
The September 11 2001 terrorist attacks were traced to Osama bin Laden and his al Qaeda network based in Afghanistan
Afghanistan History
On your Left SideWhat do your remember of Sept 11 2001Where were you
Al-Qaeda Defined A very complex
organization that has been in existence since the late 1980rsquos
Commits acts of violence aimed at America and Western Allies
Al-Qaeda training camp
1989-95 Birth and DevelopmentAl-Qaeda starts in the aftermath of Soviet invasion
1987By 1989 begins to target AmericaRecruits from across the globe including AmericaNo solid base (Afghanistan Egypt Iraq) 1991-1996 primarily based in SudanMuch soldier training and a system of Hierarchy
stabilized (Bin Laden Deputy 5 committees)
Conflict with bin Laden Escalates
Offers to raise a mujahidin army to defend Saudi Arabia from a potential invasion from Iraq in 1990
Saudi Arabia declines his offer opting instead to accept the assistance of the US and allow American troops (including women soldiers) in Saudi Arabia
Moves to Sudan by invitation of the Sudanese government in 1991
Supports several small to medium attacks against Western interests
Moves to Afghanistan in 1996 by invitation of the Taliban
Cruise missiles fired at al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan to kill bin Laden in 1998
Al-Qaedarsquos Strategy
Soldiers operate in fast moving light forces Work in complete secrecy to complete complex strategic strikes
Avoids engagement in conventional fighting (forces are not strong enough)
Spreads rumors fear and discouragement among enemy forces
Relies on a force of over 20000 professionally trained soldiers throughout the world
The organizationrsquos strengths are itsrsquo secrecy extensive influence and planning
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Afghan women begging to survive
Talibs like these boys are authorized to use weapons and whips on women if they decide any are breaking the Talibans repressive laws
Taliban ldquoreligious policerdquo beating a woman in public
Prohibited women and girls from
being examined by male physicians
while at the same time prohibited
most female doctors and nurses
from working
There were only a few selected
female doctors allowed to operate
in segregated wards
Medical Issues for Women
At one of the rare hospitals for women a
reporter found still nearly lifeless
bodies lying motionless on top of beds
wrapped in their burqua unwilling to
speak eat or do anything but slowly
wasting away
Others have gone mad and were seen
crouched in corners perpetually rocking
or crying most of them in fear
Medical Issues for Women
Conditions were so deplorable for women under the Taliban that many became severely depressed
Without the resources to leave the country an increasing number were choosing suicide once rare there as a means of escape
Doctors are seeing a lot of esophageal burns Women are swallowing battery acid or poisonous household cleansers because they are easy to find But its a very painful way to die
Medical Issues for Women
Women have died of treatable ailments because male doctors were not allowed to treat them
Many women now forcibly housebound have attempted suicide by swallowing household cleaner rather than continuing to live under these conditions
97 of Afghan women surveyed by Physicians for Human Rights exhibit signs of major depression
The Medical Results of a Taliban Rule
At a huge risk of women students continue their education in an underground school
A woman who dared to defy Taliban orders by running a home school for girls was shot and killed in front of her husband daughter and students
A woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man not related to her was stoned to death for adultery
An elderly woman was brutally beaten with a metal cable until her leg was broken because her ankle was accidentally showing from underneath her burqa
The Consequences Breaking a Taliban Rule
Although the new constitution guarantees equal rights an opportunities for both men and womenhellipthat is not always the case
Health careChild birth
highest maternal death ratein the world
Male doctorsMen amp boys take precedence
in the few emergency rooms that exist (very few hospitals after Taliban rule)
Unequal opportunities jobs divorce custody
Women Today
Taliban Insurgencies ndash harsh policies for womenAfghanistanrsquos Human Rights Commission
1500 atrocities against women (2008)13 domestic violence cases200 forcibly married98 set themselves on fire100+ tried to commit suicide
by taking poisonIncreasing number of women
taking drugsJudgments against women (Jirgas)New ldquoRape Lawrdquo against Shiite women
Womenrsquos Problems
Imagine your were an older woman who lived under the prior government and was used to all the freedoms
How would you feel now that you are under the control of the Taliban
How is your life differentExplain
On your Left Side
The September 11 2001 terrorist attacks were traced to Osama bin Laden and his al Qaeda network based in Afghanistan
Afghanistan History
On your Left SideWhat do your remember of Sept 11 2001Where were you
Al-Qaeda Defined A very complex
organization that has been in existence since the late 1980rsquos
Commits acts of violence aimed at America and Western Allies
Al-Qaeda training camp
1989-95 Birth and DevelopmentAl-Qaeda starts in the aftermath of Soviet invasion
1987By 1989 begins to target AmericaRecruits from across the globe including AmericaNo solid base (Afghanistan Egypt Iraq) 1991-1996 primarily based in SudanMuch soldier training and a system of Hierarchy
stabilized (Bin Laden Deputy 5 committees)
Conflict with bin Laden Escalates
Offers to raise a mujahidin army to defend Saudi Arabia from a potential invasion from Iraq in 1990
Saudi Arabia declines his offer opting instead to accept the assistance of the US and allow American troops (including women soldiers) in Saudi Arabia
Moves to Sudan by invitation of the Sudanese government in 1991
Supports several small to medium attacks against Western interests
Moves to Afghanistan in 1996 by invitation of the Taliban
Cruise missiles fired at al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan to kill bin Laden in 1998
Al-Qaedarsquos Strategy
Soldiers operate in fast moving light forces Work in complete secrecy to complete complex strategic strikes
Avoids engagement in conventional fighting (forces are not strong enough)
Spreads rumors fear and discouragement among enemy forces
Relies on a force of over 20000 professionally trained soldiers throughout the world
The organizationrsquos strengths are itsrsquo secrecy extensive influence and planning
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Talibs like these boys are authorized to use weapons and whips on women if they decide any are breaking the Talibans repressive laws
Taliban ldquoreligious policerdquo beating a woman in public
Prohibited women and girls from
being examined by male physicians
while at the same time prohibited
most female doctors and nurses
from working
There were only a few selected
female doctors allowed to operate
in segregated wards
Medical Issues for Women
At one of the rare hospitals for women a
reporter found still nearly lifeless
bodies lying motionless on top of beds
wrapped in their burqua unwilling to
speak eat or do anything but slowly
wasting away
Others have gone mad and were seen
crouched in corners perpetually rocking
or crying most of them in fear
Medical Issues for Women
Conditions were so deplorable for women under the Taliban that many became severely depressed
Without the resources to leave the country an increasing number were choosing suicide once rare there as a means of escape
Doctors are seeing a lot of esophageal burns Women are swallowing battery acid or poisonous household cleansers because they are easy to find But its a very painful way to die
Medical Issues for Women
Women have died of treatable ailments because male doctors were not allowed to treat them
Many women now forcibly housebound have attempted suicide by swallowing household cleaner rather than continuing to live under these conditions
97 of Afghan women surveyed by Physicians for Human Rights exhibit signs of major depression
The Medical Results of a Taliban Rule
At a huge risk of women students continue their education in an underground school
A woman who dared to defy Taliban orders by running a home school for girls was shot and killed in front of her husband daughter and students
A woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man not related to her was stoned to death for adultery
An elderly woman was brutally beaten with a metal cable until her leg was broken because her ankle was accidentally showing from underneath her burqa
The Consequences Breaking a Taliban Rule
Although the new constitution guarantees equal rights an opportunities for both men and womenhellipthat is not always the case
Health careChild birth
highest maternal death ratein the world
Male doctorsMen amp boys take precedence
in the few emergency rooms that exist (very few hospitals after Taliban rule)
Unequal opportunities jobs divorce custody
Women Today
Taliban Insurgencies ndash harsh policies for womenAfghanistanrsquos Human Rights Commission
1500 atrocities against women (2008)13 domestic violence cases200 forcibly married98 set themselves on fire100+ tried to commit suicide
by taking poisonIncreasing number of women
taking drugsJudgments against women (Jirgas)New ldquoRape Lawrdquo against Shiite women
Womenrsquos Problems
Imagine your were an older woman who lived under the prior government and was used to all the freedoms
How would you feel now that you are under the control of the Taliban
How is your life differentExplain
On your Left Side
The September 11 2001 terrorist attacks were traced to Osama bin Laden and his al Qaeda network based in Afghanistan
Afghanistan History
On your Left SideWhat do your remember of Sept 11 2001Where were you
Al-Qaeda Defined A very complex
organization that has been in existence since the late 1980rsquos
Commits acts of violence aimed at America and Western Allies
Al-Qaeda training camp
1989-95 Birth and DevelopmentAl-Qaeda starts in the aftermath of Soviet invasion
1987By 1989 begins to target AmericaRecruits from across the globe including AmericaNo solid base (Afghanistan Egypt Iraq) 1991-1996 primarily based in SudanMuch soldier training and a system of Hierarchy
stabilized (Bin Laden Deputy 5 committees)
Conflict with bin Laden Escalates
Offers to raise a mujahidin army to defend Saudi Arabia from a potential invasion from Iraq in 1990
Saudi Arabia declines his offer opting instead to accept the assistance of the US and allow American troops (including women soldiers) in Saudi Arabia
Moves to Sudan by invitation of the Sudanese government in 1991
Supports several small to medium attacks against Western interests
Moves to Afghanistan in 1996 by invitation of the Taliban
Cruise missiles fired at al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan to kill bin Laden in 1998
Al-Qaedarsquos Strategy
Soldiers operate in fast moving light forces Work in complete secrecy to complete complex strategic strikes
Avoids engagement in conventional fighting (forces are not strong enough)
Spreads rumors fear and discouragement among enemy forces
Relies on a force of over 20000 professionally trained soldiers throughout the world
The organizationrsquos strengths are itsrsquo secrecy extensive influence and planning
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Taliban ldquoreligious policerdquo beating a woman in public
Prohibited women and girls from
being examined by male physicians
while at the same time prohibited
most female doctors and nurses
from working
There were only a few selected
female doctors allowed to operate
in segregated wards
Medical Issues for Women
At one of the rare hospitals for women a
reporter found still nearly lifeless
bodies lying motionless on top of beds
wrapped in their burqua unwilling to
speak eat or do anything but slowly
wasting away
Others have gone mad and were seen
crouched in corners perpetually rocking
or crying most of them in fear
Medical Issues for Women
Conditions were so deplorable for women under the Taliban that many became severely depressed
Without the resources to leave the country an increasing number were choosing suicide once rare there as a means of escape
Doctors are seeing a lot of esophageal burns Women are swallowing battery acid or poisonous household cleansers because they are easy to find But its a very painful way to die
Medical Issues for Women
Women have died of treatable ailments because male doctors were not allowed to treat them
Many women now forcibly housebound have attempted suicide by swallowing household cleaner rather than continuing to live under these conditions
97 of Afghan women surveyed by Physicians for Human Rights exhibit signs of major depression
The Medical Results of a Taliban Rule
At a huge risk of women students continue their education in an underground school
A woman who dared to defy Taliban orders by running a home school for girls was shot and killed in front of her husband daughter and students
A woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man not related to her was stoned to death for adultery
An elderly woman was brutally beaten with a metal cable until her leg was broken because her ankle was accidentally showing from underneath her burqa
The Consequences Breaking a Taliban Rule
Although the new constitution guarantees equal rights an opportunities for both men and womenhellipthat is not always the case
Health careChild birth
highest maternal death ratein the world
Male doctorsMen amp boys take precedence
in the few emergency rooms that exist (very few hospitals after Taliban rule)
Unequal opportunities jobs divorce custody
Women Today
Taliban Insurgencies ndash harsh policies for womenAfghanistanrsquos Human Rights Commission
1500 atrocities against women (2008)13 domestic violence cases200 forcibly married98 set themselves on fire100+ tried to commit suicide
by taking poisonIncreasing number of women
taking drugsJudgments against women (Jirgas)New ldquoRape Lawrdquo against Shiite women
Womenrsquos Problems
Imagine your were an older woman who lived under the prior government and was used to all the freedoms
How would you feel now that you are under the control of the Taliban
How is your life differentExplain
On your Left Side
The September 11 2001 terrorist attacks were traced to Osama bin Laden and his al Qaeda network based in Afghanistan
Afghanistan History
On your Left SideWhat do your remember of Sept 11 2001Where were you
Al-Qaeda Defined A very complex
organization that has been in existence since the late 1980rsquos
Commits acts of violence aimed at America and Western Allies
Al-Qaeda training camp
1989-95 Birth and DevelopmentAl-Qaeda starts in the aftermath of Soviet invasion
1987By 1989 begins to target AmericaRecruits from across the globe including AmericaNo solid base (Afghanistan Egypt Iraq) 1991-1996 primarily based in SudanMuch soldier training and a system of Hierarchy
stabilized (Bin Laden Deputy 5 committees)
Conflict with bin Laden Escalates
Offers to raise a mujahidin army to defend Saudi Arabia from a potential invasion from Iraq in 1990
Saudi Arabia declines his offer opting instead to accept the assistance of the US and allow American troops (including women soldiers) in Saudi Arabia
Moves to Sudan by invitation of the Sudanese government in 1991
Supports several small to medium attacks against Western interests
Moves to Afghanistan in 1996 by invitation of the Taliban
Cruise missiles fired at al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan to kill bin Laden in 1998
Al-Qaedarsquos Strategy
Soldiers operate in fast moving light forces Work in complete secrecy to complete complex strategic strikes
Avoids engagement in conventional fighting (forces are not strong enough)
Spreads rumors fear and discouragement among enemy forces
Relies on a force of over 20000 professionally trained soldiers throughout the world
The organizationrsquos strengths are itsrsquo secrecy extensive influence and planning
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Prohibited women and girls from
being examined by male physicians
while at the same time prohibited
most female doctors and nurses
from working
There were only a few selected
female doctors allowed to operate
in segregated wards
Medical Issues for Women
At one of the rare hospitals for women a
reporter found still nearly lifeless
bodies lying motionless on top of beds
wrapped in their burqua unwilling to
speak eat or do anything but slowly
wasting away
Others have gone mad and were seen
crouched in corners perpetually rocking
or crying most of them in fear
Medical Issues for Women
Conditions were so deplorable for women under the Taliban that many became severely depressed
Without the resources to leave the country an increasing number were choosing suicide once rare there as a means of escape
Doctors are seeing a lot of esophageal burns Women are swallowing battery acid or poisonous household cleansers because they are easy to find But its a very painful way to die
Medical Issues for Women
Women have died of treatable ailments because male doctors were not allowed to treat them
Many women now forcibly housebound have attempted suicide by swallowing household cleaner rather than continuing to live under these conditions
97 of Afghan women surveyed by Physicians for Human Rights exhibit signs of major depression
The Medical Results of a Taliban Rule
At a huge risk of women students continue their education in an underground school
A woman who dared to defy Taliban orders by running a home school for girls was shot and killed in front of her husband daughter and students
A woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man not related to her was stoned to death for adultery
An elderly woman was brutally beaten with a metal cable until her leg was broken because her ankle was accidentally showing from underneath her burqa
The Consequences Breaking a Taliban Rule
Although the new constitution guarantees equal rights an opportunities for both men and womenhellipthat is not always the case
Health careChild birth
highest maternal death ratein the world
Male doctorsMen amp boys take precedence
in the few emergency rooms that exist (very few hospitals after Taliban rule)
Unequal opportunities jobs divorce custody
Women Today
Taliban Insurgencies ndash harsh policies for womenAfghanistanrsquos Human Rights Commission
1500 atrocities against women (2008)13 domestic violence cases200 forcibly married98 set themselves on fire100+ tried to commit suicide
by taking poisonIncreasing number of women
taking drugsJudgments against women (Jirgas)New ldquoRape Lawrdquo against Shiite women
Womenrsquos Problems
Imagine your were an older woman who lived under the prior government and was used to all the freedoms
How would you feel now that you are under the control of the Taliban
How is your life differentExplain
On your Left Side
The September 11 2001 terrorist attacks were traced to Osama bin Laden and his al Qaeda network based in Afghanistan
Afghanistan History
On your Left SideWhat do your remember of Sept 11 2001Where were you
Al-Qaeda Defined A very complex
organization that has been in existence since the late 1980rsquos
Commits acts of violence aimed at America and Western Allies
Al-Qaeda training camp
1989-95 Birth and DevelopmentAl-Qaeda starts in the aftermath of Soviet invasion
1987By 1989 begins to target AmericaRecruits from across the globe including AmericaNo solid base (Afghanistan Egypt Iraq) 1991-1996 primarily based in SudanMuch soldier training and a system of Hierarchy
stabilized (Bin Laden Deputy 5 committees)
Conflict with bin Laden Escalates
Offers to raise a mujahidin army to defend Saudi Arabia from a potential invasion from Iraq in 1990
Saudi Arabia declines his offer opting instead to accept the assistance of the US and allow American troops (including women soldiers) in Saudi Arabia
Moves to Sudan by invitation of the Sudanese government in 1991
Supports several small to medium attacks against Western interests
Moves to Afghanistan in 1996 by invitation of the Taliban
Cruise missiles fired at al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan to kill bin Laden in 1998
Al-Qaedarsquos Strategy
Soldiers operate in fast moving light forces Work in complete secrecy to complete complex strategic strikes
Avoids engagement in conventional fighting (forces are not strong enough)
Spreads rumors fear and discouragement among enemy forces
Relies on a force of over 20000 professionally trained soldiers throughout the world
The organizationrsquos strengths are itsrsquo secrecy extensive influence and planning
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
At one of the rare hospitals for women a
reporter found still nearly lifeless
bodies lying motionless on top of beds
wrapped in their burqua unwilling to
speak eat or do anything but slowly
wasting away
Others have gone mad and were seen
crouched in corners perpetually rocking
or crying most of them in fear
Medical Issues for Women
Conditions were so deplorable for women under the Taliban that many became severely depressed
Without the resources to leave the country an increasing number were choosing suicide once rare there as a means of escape
Doctors are seeing a lot of esophageal burns Women are swallowing battery acid or poisonous household cleansers because they are easy to find But its a very painful way to die
Medical Issues for Women
Women have died of treatable ailments because male doctors were not allowed to treat them
Many women now forcibly housebound have attempted suicide by swallowing household cleaner rather than continuing to live under these conditions
97 of Afghan women surveyed by Physicians for Human Rights exhibit signs of major depression
The Medical Results of a Taliban Rule
At a huge risk of women students continue their education in an underground school
A woman who dared to defy Taliban orders by running a home school for girls was shot and killed in front of her husband daughter and students
A woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man not related to her was stoned to death for adultery
An elderly woman was brutally beaten with a metal cable until her leg was broken because her ankle was accidentally showing from underneath her burqa
The Consequences Breaking a Taliban Rule
Although the new constitution guarantees equal rights an opportunities for both men and womenhellipthat is not always the case
Health careChild birth
highest maternal death ratein the world
Male doctorsMen amp boys take precedence
in the few emergency rooms that exist (very few hospitals after Taliban rule)
Unequal opportunities jobs divorce custody
Women Today
Taliban Insurgencies ndash harsh policies for womenAfghanistanrsquos Human Rights Commission
1500 atrocities against women (2008)13 domestic violence cases200 forcibly married98 set themselves on fire100+ tried to commit suicide
by taking poisonIncreasing number of women
taking drugsJudgments against women (Jirgas)New ldquoRape Lawrdquo against Shiite women
Womenrsquos Problems
Imagine your were an older woman who lived under the prior government and was used to all the freedoms
How would you feel now that you are under the control of the Taliban
How is your life differentExplain
On your Left Side
The September 11 2001 terrorist attacks were traced to Osama bin Laden and his al Qaeda network based in Afghanistan
Afghanistan History
On your Left SideWhat do your remember of Sept 11 2001Where were you
Al-Qaeda Defined A very complex
organization that has been in existence since the late 1980rsquos
Commits acts of violence aimed at America and Western Allies
Al-Qaeda training camp
1989-95 Birth and DevelopmentAl-Qaeda starts in the aftermath of Soviet invasion
1987By 1989 begins to target AmericaRecruits from across the globe including AmericaNo solid base (Afghanistan Egypt Iraq) 1991-1996 primarily based in SudanMuch soldier training and a system of Hierarchy
stabilized (Bin Laden Deputy 5 committees)
Conflict with bin Laden Escalates
Offers to raise a mujahidin army to defend Saudi Arabia from a potential invasion from Iraq in 1990
Saudi Arabia declines his offer opting instead to accept the assistance of the US and allow American troops (including women soldiers) in Saudi Arabia
Moves to Sudan by invitation of the Sudanese government in 1991
Supports several small to medium attacks against Western interests
Moves to Afghanistan in 1996 by invitation of the Taliban
Cruise missiles fired at al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan to kill bin Laden in 1998
Al-Qaedarsquos Strategy
Soldiers operate in fast moving light forces Work in complete secrecy to complete complex strategic strikes
Avoids engagement in conventional fighting (forces are not strong enough)
Spreads rumors fear and discouragement among enemy forces
Relies on a force of over 20000 professionally trained soldiers throughout the world
The organizationrsquos strengths are itsrsquo secrecy extensive influence and planning
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Conditions were so deplorable for women under the Taliban that many became severely depressed
Without the resources to leave the country an increasing number were choosing suicide once rare there as a means of escape
Doctors are seeing a lot of esophageal burns Women are swallowing battery acid or poisonous household cleansers because they are easy to find But its a very painful way to die
Medical Issues for Women
Women have died of treatable ailments because male doctors were not allowed to treat them
Many women now forcibly housebound have attempted suicide by swallowing household cleaner rather than continuing to live under these conditions
97 of Afghan women surveyed by Physicians for Human Rights exhibit signs of major depression
The Medical Results of a Taliban Rule
At a huge risk of women students continue their education in an underground school
A woman who dared to defy Taliban orders by running a home school for girls was shot and killed in front of her husband daughter and students
A woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man not related to her was stoned to death for adultery
An elderly woman was brutally beaten with a metal cable until her leg was broken because her ankle was accidentally showing from underneath her burqa
The Consequences Breaking a Taliban Rule
Although the new constitution guarantees equal rights an opportunities for both men and womenhellipthat is not always the case
Health careChild birth
highest maternal death ratein the world
Male doctorsMen amp boys take precedence
in the few emergency rooms that exist (very few hospitals after Taliban rule)
Unequal opportunities jobs divorce custody
Women Today
Taliban Insurgencies ndash harsh policies for womenAfghanistanrsquos Human Rights Commission
1500 atrocities against women (2008)13 domestic violence cases200 forcibly married98 set themselves on fire100+ tried to commit suicide
by taking poisonIncreasing number of women
taking drugsJudgments against women (Jirgas)New ldquoRape Lawrdquo against Shiite women
Womenrsquos Problems
Imagine your were an older woman who lived under the prior government and was used to all the freedoms
How would you feel now that you are under the control of the Taliban
How is your life differentExplain
On your Left Side
The September 11 2001 terrorist attacks were traced to Osama bin Laden and his al Qaeda network based in Afghanistan
Afghanistan History
On your Left SideWhat do your remember of Sept 11 2001Where were you
Al-Qaeda Defined A very complex
organization that has been in existence since the late 1980rsquos
Commits acts of violence aimed at America and Western Allies
Al-Qaeda training camp
1989-95 Birth and DevelopmentAl-Qaeda starts in the aftermath of Soviet invasion
1987By 1989 begins to target AmericaRecruits from across the globe including AmericaNo solid base (Afghanistan Egypt Iraq) 1991-1996 primarily based in SudanMuch soldier training and a system of Hierarchy
stabilized (Bin Laden Deputy 5 committees)
Conflict with bin Laden Escalates
Offers to raise a mujahidin army to defend Saudi Arabia from a potential invasion from Iraq in 1990
Saudi Arabia declines his offer opting instead to accept the assistance of the US and allow American troops (including women soldiers) in Saudi Arabia
Moves to Sudan by invitation of the Sudanese government in 1991
Supports several small to medium attacks against Western interests
Moves to Afghanistan in 1996 by invitation of the Taliban
Cruise missiles fired at al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan to kill bin Laden in 1998
Al-Qaedarsquos Strategy
Soldiers operate in fast moving light forces Work in complete secrecy to complete complex strategic strikes
Avoids engagement in conventional fighting (forces are not strong enough)
Spreads rumors fear and discouragement among enemy forces
Relies on a force of over 20000 professionally trained soldiers throughout the world
The organizationrsquos strengths are itsrsquo secrecy extensive influence and planning
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Women have died of treatable ailments because male doctors were not allowed to treat them
Many women now forcibly housebound have attempted suicide by swallowing household cleaner rather than continuing to live under these conditions
97 of Afghan women surveyed by Physicians for Human Rights exhibit signs of major depression
The Medical Results of a Taliban Rule
At a huge risk of women students continue their education in an underground school
A woman who dared to defy Taliban orders by running a home school for girls was shot and killed in front of her husband daughter and students
A woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man not related to her was stoned to death for adultery
An elderly woman was brutally beaten with a metal cable until her leg was broken because her ankle was accidentally showing from underneath her burqa
The Consequences Breaking a Taliban Rule
Although the new constitution guarantees equal rights an opportunities for both men and womenhellipthat is not always the case
Health careChild birth
highest maternal death ratein the world
Male doctorsMen amp boys take precedence
in the few emergency rooms that exist (very few hospitals after Taliban rule)
Unequal opportunities jobs divorce custody
Women Today
Taliban Insurgencies ndash harsh policies for womenAfghanistanrsquos Human Rights Commission
1500 atrocities against women (2008)13 domestic violence cases200 forcibly married98 set themselves on fire100+ tried to commit suicide
by taking poisonIncreasing number of women
taking drugsJudgments against women (Jirgas)New ldquoRape Lawrdquo against Shiite women
Womenrsquos Problems
Imagine your were an older woman who lived under the prior government and was used to all the freedoms
How would you feel now that you are under the control of the Taliban
How is your life differentExplain
On your Left Side
The September 11 2001 terrorist attacks were traced to Osama bin Laden and his al Qaeda network based in Afghanistan
Afghanistan History
On your Left SideWhat do your remember of Sept 11 2001Where were you
Al-Qaeda Defined A very complex
organization that has been in existence since the late 1980rsquos
Commits acts of violence aimed at America and Western Allies
Al-Qaeda training camp
1989-95 Birth and DevelopmentAl-Qaeda starts in the aftermath of Soviet invasion
1987By 1989 begins to target AmericaRecruits from across the globe including AmericaNo solid base (Afghanistan Egypt Iraq) 1991-1996 primarily based in SudanMuch soldier training and a system of Hierarchy
stabilized (Bin Laden Deputy 5 committees)
Conflict with bin Laden Escalates
Offers to raise a mujahidin army to defend Saudi Arabia from a potential invasion from Iraq in 1990
Saudi Arabia declines his offer opting instead to accept the assistance of the US and allow American troops (including women soldiers) in Saudi Arabia
Moves to Sudan by invitation of the Sudanese government in 1991
Supports several small to medium attacks against Western interests
Moves to Afghanistan in 1996 by invitation of the Taliban
Cruise missiles fired at al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan to kill bin Laden in 1998
Al-Qaedarsquos Strategy
Soldiers operate in fast moving light forces Work in complete secrecy to complete complex strategic strikes
Avoids engagement in conventional fighting (forces are not strong enough)
Spreads rumors fear and discouragement among enemy forces
Relies on a force of over 20000 professionally trained soldiers throughout the world
The organizationrsquos strengths are itsrsquo secrecy extensive influence and planning
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
At a huge risk of women students continue their education in an underground school
A woman who dared to defy Taliban orders by running a home school for girls was shot and killed in front of her husband daughter and students
A woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man not related to her was stoned to death for adultery
An elderly woman was brutally beaten with a metal cable until her leg was broken because her ankle was accidentally showing from underneath her burqa
The Consequences Breaking a Taliban Rule
Although the new constitution guarantees equal rights an opportunities for both men and womenhellipthat is not always the case
Health careChild birth
highest maternal death ratein the world
Male doctorsMen amp boys take precedence
in the few emergency rooms that exist (very few hospitals after Taliban rule)
Unequal opportunities jobs divorce custody
Women Today
Taliban Insurgencies ndash harsh policies for womenAfghanistanrsquos Human Rights Commission
1500 atrocities against women (2008)13 domestic violence cases200 forcibly married98 set themselves on fire100+ tried to commit suicide
by taking poisonIncreasing number of women
taking drugsJudgments against women (Jirgas)New ldquoRape Lawrdquo against Shiite women
Womenrsquos Problems
Imagine your were an older woman who lived under the prior government and was used to all the freedoms
How would you feel now that you are under the control of the Taliban
How is your life differentExplain
On your Left Side
The September 11 2001 terrorist attacks were traced to Osama bin Laden and his al Qaeda network based in Afghanistan
Afghanistan History
On your Left SideWhat do your remember of Sept 11 2001Where were you
Al-Qaeda Defined A very complex
organization that has been in existence since the late 1980rsquos
Commits acts of violence aimed at America and Western Allies
Al-Qaeda training camp
1989-95 Birth and DevelopmentAl-Qaeda starts in the aftermath of Soviet invasion
1987By 1989 begins to target AmericaRecruits from across the globe including AmericaNo solid base (Afghanistan Egypt Iraq) 1991-1996 primarily based in SudanMuch soldier training and a system of Hierarchy
stabilized (Bin Laden Deputy 5 committees)
Conflict with bin Laden Escalates
Offers to raise a mujahidin army to defend Saudi Arabia from a potential invasion from Iraq in 1990
Saudi Arabia declines his offer opting instead to accept the assistance of the US and allow American troops (including women soldiers) in Saudi Arabia
Moves to Sudan by invitation of the Sudanese government in 1991
Supports several small to medium attacks against Western interests
Moves to Afghanistan in 1996 by invitation of the Taliban
Cruise missiles fired at al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan to kill bin Laden in 1998
Al-Qaedarsquos Strategy
Soldiers operate in fast moving light forces Work in complete secrecy to complete complex strategic strikes
Avoids engagement in conventional fighting (forces are not strong enough)
Spreads rumors fear and discouragement among enemy forces
Relies on a force of over 20000 professionally trained soldiers throughout the world
The organizationrsquos strengths are itsrsquo secrecy extensive influence and planning
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
A woman who dared to defy Taliban orders by running a home school for girls was shot and killed in front of her husband daughter and students
A woman caught trying to flee Afghanistan with a man not related to her was stoned to death for adultery
An elderly woman was brutally beaten with a metal cable until her leg was broken because her ankle was accidentally showing from underneath her burqa
The Consequences Breaking a Taliban Rule
Although the new constitution guarantees equal rights an opportunities for both men and womenhellipthat is not always the case
Health careChild birth
highest maternal death ratein the world
Male doctorsMen amp boys take precedence
in the few emergency rooms that exist (very few hospitals after Taliban rule)
Unequal opportunities jobs divorce custody
Women Today
Taliban Insurgencies ndash harsh policies for womenAfghanistanrsquos Human Rights Commission
1500 atrocities against women (2008)13 domestic violence cases200 forcibly married98 set themselves on fire100+ tried to commit suicide
by taking poisonIncreasing number of women
taking drugsJudgments against women (Jirgas)New ldquoRape Lawrdquo against Shiite women
Womenrsquos Problems
Imagine your were an older woman who lived under the prior government and was used to all the freedoms
How would you feel now that you are under the control of the Taliban
How is your life differentExplain
On your Left Side
The September 11 2001 terrorist attacks were traced to Osama bin Laden and his al Qaeda network based in Afghanistan
Afghanistan History
On your Left SideWhat do your remember of Sept 11 2001Where were you
Al-Qaeda Defined A very complex
organization that has been in existence since the late 1980rsquos
Commits acts of violence aimed at America and Western Allies
Al-Qaeda training camp
1989-95 Birth and DevelopmentAl-Qaeda starts in the aftermath of Soviet invasion
1987By 1989 begins to target AmericaRecruits from across the globe including AmericaNo solid base (Afghanistan Egypt Iraq) 1991-1996 primarily based in SudanMuch soldier training and a system of Hierarchy
stabilized (Bin Laden Deputy 5 committees)
Conflict with bin Laden Escalates
Offers to raise a mujahidin army to defend Saudi Arabia from a potential invasion from Iraq in 1990
Saudi Arabia declines his offer opting instead to accept the assistance of the US and allow American troops (including women soldiers) in Saudi Arabia
Moves to Sudan by invitation of the Sudanese government in 1991
Supports several small to medium attacks against Western interests
Moves to Afghanistan in 1996 by invitation of the Taliban
Cruise missiles fired at al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan to kill bin Laden in 1998
Al-Qaedarsquos Strategy
Soldiers operate in fast moving light forces Work in complete secrecy to complete complex strategic strikes
Avoids engagement in conventional fighting (forces are not strong enough)
Spreads rumors fear and discouragement among enemy forces
Relies on a force of over 20000 professionally trained soldiers throughout the world
The organizationrsquos strengths are itsrsquo secrecy extensive influence and planning
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Although the new constitution guarantees equal rights an opportunities for both men and womenhellipthat is not always the case
Health careChild birth
highest maternal death ratein the world
Male doctorsMen amp boys take precedence
in the few emergency rooms that exist (very few hospitals after Taliban rule)
Unequal opportunities jobs divorce custody
Women Today
Taliban Insurgencies ndash harsh policies for womenAfghanistanrsquos Human Rights Commission
1500 atrocities against women (2008)13 domestic violence cases200 forcibly married98 set themselves on fire100+ tried to commit suicide
by taking poisonIncreasing number of women
taking drugsJudgments against women (Jirgas)New ldquoRape Lawrdquo against Shiite women
Womenrsquos Problems
Imagine your were an older woman who lived under the prior government and was used to all the freedoms
How would you feel now that you are under the control of the Taliban
How is your life differentExplain
On your Left Side
The September 11 2001 terrorist attacks were traced to Osama bin Laden and his al Qaeda network based in Afghanistan
Afghanistan History
On your Left SideWhat do your remember of Sept 11 2001Where were you
Al-Qaeda Defined A very complex
organization that has been in existence since the late 1980rsquos
Commits acts of violence aimed at America and Western Allies
Al-Qaeda training camp
1989-95 Birth and DevelopmentAl-Qaeda starts in the aftermath of Soviet invasion
1987By 1989 begins to target AmericaRecruits from across the globe including AmericaNo solid base (Afghanistan Egypt Iraq) 1991-1996 primarily based in SudanMuch soldier training and a system of Hierarchy
stabilized (Bin Laden Deputy 5 committees)
Conflict with bin Laden Escalates
Offers to raise a mujahidin army to defend Saudi Arabia from a potential invasion from Iraq in 1990
Saudi Arabia declines his offer opting instead to accept the assistance of the US and allow American troops (including women soldiers) in Saudi Arabia
Moves to Sudan by invitation of the Sudanese government in 1991
Supports several small to medium attacks against Western interests
Moves to Afghanistan in 1996 by invitation of the Taliban
Cruise missiles fired at al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan to kill bin Laden in 1998
Al-Qaedarsquos Strategy
Soldiers operate in fast moving light forces Work in complete secrecy to complete complex strategic strikes
Avoids engagement in conventional fighting (forces are not strong enough)
Spreads rumors fear and discouragement among enemy forces
Relies on a force of over 20000 professionally trained soldiers throughout the world
The organizationrsquos strengths are itsrsquo secrecy extensive influence and planning
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Taliban Insurgencies ndash harsh policies for womenAfghanistanrsquos Human Rights Commission
1500 atrocities against women (2008)13 domestic violence cases200 forcibly married98 set themselves on fire100+ tried to commit suicide
by taking poisonIncreasing number of women
taking drugsJudgments against women (Jirgas)New ldquoRape Lawrdquo against Shiite women
Womenrsquos Problems
Imagine your were an older woman who lived under the prior government and was used to all the freedoms
How would you feel now that you are under the control of the Taliban
How is your life differentExplain
On your Left Side
The September 11 2001 terrorist attacks were traced to Osama bin Laden and his al Qaeda network based in Afghanistan
Afghanistan History
On your Left SideWhat do your remember of Sept 11 2001Where were you
Al-Qaeda Defined A very complex
organization that has been in existence since the late 1980rsquos
Commits acts of violence aimed at America and Western Allies
Al-Qaeda training camp
1989-95 Birth and DevelopmentAl-Qaeda starts in the aftermath of Soviet invasion
1987By 1989 begins to target AmericaRecruits from across the globe including AmericaNo solid base (Afghanistan Egypt Iraq) 1991-1996 primarily based in SudanMuch soldier training and a system of Hierarchy
stabilized (Bin Laden Deputy 5 committees)
Conflict with bin Laden Escalates
Offers to raise a mujahidin army to defend Saudi Arabia from a potential invasion from Iraq in 1990
Saudi Arabia declines his offer opting instead to accept the assistance of the US and allow American troops (including women soldiers) in Saudi Arabia
Moves to Sudan by invitation of the Sudanese government in 1991
Supports several small to medium attacks against Western interests
Moves to Afghanistan in 1996 by invitation of the Taliban
Cruise missiles fired at al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan to kill bin Laden in 1998
Al-Qaedarsquos Strategy
Soldiers operate in fast moving light forces Work in complete secrecy to complete complex strategic strikes
Avoids engagement in conventional fighting (forces are not strong enough)
Spreads rumors fear and discouragement among enemy forces
Relies on a force of over 20000 professionally trained soldiers throughout the world
The organizationrsquos strengths are itsrsquo secrecy extensive influence and planning
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Imagine your were an older woman who lived under the prior government and was used to all the freedoms
How would you feel now that you are under the control of the Taliban
How is your life differentExplain
On your Left Side
The September 11 2001 terrorist attacks were traced to Osama bin Laden and his al Qaeda network based in Afghanistan
Afghanistan History
On your Left SideWhat do your remember of Sept 11 2001Where were you
Al-Qaeda Defined A very complex
organization that has been in existence since the late 1980rsquos
Commits acts of violence aimed at America and Western Allies
Al-Qaeda training camp
1989-95 Birth and DevelopmentAl-Qaeda starts in the aftermath of Soviet invasion
1987By 1989 begins to target AmericaRecruits from across the globe including AmericaNo solid base (Afghanistan Egypt Iraq) 1991-1996 primarily based in SudanMuch soldier training and a system of Hierarchy
stabilized (Bin Laden Deputy 5 committees)
Conflict with bin Laden Escalates
Offers to raise a mujahidin army to defend Saudi Arabia from a potential invasion from Iraq in 1990
Saudi Arabia declines his offer opting instead to accept the assistance of the US and allow American troops (including women soldiers) in Saudi Arabia
Moves to Sudan by invitation of the Sudanese government in 1991
Supports several small to medium attacks against Western interests
Moves to Afghanistan in 1996 by invitation of the Taliban
Cruise missiles fired at al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan to kill bin Laden in 1998
Al-Qaedarsquos Strategy
Soldiers operate in fast moving light forces Work in complete secrecy to complete complex strategic strikes
Avoids engagement in conventional fighting (forces are not strong enough)
Spreads rumors fear and discouragement among enemy forces
Relies on a force of over 20000 professionally trained soldiers throughout the world
The organizationrsquos strengths are itsrsquo secrecy extensive influence and planning
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
The September 11 2001 terrorist attacks were traced to Osama bin Laden and his al Qaeda network based in Afghanistan
Afghanistan History
On your Left SideWhat do your remember of Sept 11 2001Where were you
Al-Qaeda Defined A very complex
organization that has been in existence since the late 1980rsquos
Commits acts of violence aimed at America and Western Allies
Al-Qaeda training camp
1989-95 Birth and DevelopmentAl-Qaeda starts in the aftermath of Soviet invasion
1987By 1989 begins to target AmericaRecruits from across the globe including AmericaNo solid base (Afghanistan Egypt Iraq) 1991-1996 primarily based in SudanMuch soldier training and a system of Hierarchy
stabilized (Bin Laden Deputy 5 committees)
Conflict with bin Laden Escalates
Offers to raise a mujahidin army to defend Saudi Arabia from a potential invasion from Iraq in 1990
Saudi Arabia declines his offer opting instead to accept the assistance of the US and allow American troops (including women soldiers) in Saudi Arabia
Moves to Sudan by invitation of the Sudanese government in 1991
Supports several small to medium attacks against Western interests
Moves to Afghanistan in 1996 by invitation of the Taliban
Cruise missiles fired at al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan to kill bin Laden in 1998
Al-Qaedarsquos Strategy
Soldiers operate in fast moving light forces Work in complete secrecy to complete complex strategic strikes
Avoids engagement in conventional fighting (forces are not strong enough)
Spreads rumors fear and discouragement among enemy forces
Relies on a force of over 20000 professionally trained soldiers throughout the world
The organizationrsquos strengths are itsrsquo secrecy extensive influence and planning
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
On your Left SideWhat do your remember of Sept 11 2001Where were you
Al-Qaeda Defined A very complex
organization that has been in existence since the late 1980rsquos
Commits acts of violence aimed at America and Western Allies
Al-Qaeda training camp
1989-95 Birth and DevelopmentAl-Qaeda starts in the aftermath of Soviet invasion
1987By 1989 begins to target AmericaRecruits from across the globe including AmericaNo solid base (Afghanistan Egypt Iraq) 1991-1996 primarily based in SudanMuch soldier training and a system of Hierarchy
stabilized (Bin Laden Deputy 5 committees)
Conflict with bin Laden Escalates
Offers to raise a mujahidin army to defend Saudi Arabia from a potential invasion from Iraq in 1990
Saudi Arabia declines his offer opting instead to accept the assistance of the US and allow American troops (including women soldiers) in Saudi Arabia
Moves to Sudan by invitation of the Sudanese government in 1991
Supports several small to medium attacks against Western interests
Moves to Afghanistan in 1996 by invitation of the Taliban
Cruise missiles fired at al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan to kill bin Laden in 1998
Al-Qaedarsquos Strategy
Soldiers operate in fast moving light forces Work in complete secrecy to complete complex strategic strikes
Avoids engagement in conventional fighting (forces are not strong enough)
Spreads rumors fear and discouragement among enemy forces
Relies on a force of over 20000 professionally trained soldiers throughout the world
The organizationrsquos strengths are itsrsquo secrecy extensive influence and planning
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Al-Qaeda Defined A very complex
organization that has been in existence since the late 1980rsquos
Commits acts of violence aimed at America and Western Allies
Al-Qaeda training camp
1989-95 Birth and DevelopmentAl-Qaeda starts in the aftermath of Soviet invasion
1987By 1989 begins to target AmericaRecruits from across the globe including AmericaNo solid base (Afghanistan Egypt Iraq) 1991-1996 primarily based in SudanMuch soldier training and a system of Hierarchy
stabilized (Bin Laden Deputy 5 committees)
Conflict with bin Laden Escalates
Offers to raise a mujahidin army to defend Saudi Arabia from a potential invasion from Iraq in 1990
Saudi Arabia declines his offer opting instead to accept the assistance of the US and allow American troops (including women soldiers) in Saudi Arabia
Moves to Sudan by invitation of the Sudanese government in 1991
Supports several small to medium attacks against Western interests
Moves to Afghanistan in 1996 by invitation of the Taliban
Cruise missiles fired at al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan to kill bin Laden in 1998
Al-Qaedarsquos Strategy
Soldiers operate in fast moving light forces Work in complete secrecy to complete complex strategic strikes
Avoids engagement in conventional fighting (forces are not strong enough)
Spreads rumors fear and discouragement among enemy forces
Relies on a force of over 20000 professionally trained soldiers throughout the world
The organizationrsquos strengths are itsrsquo secrecy extensive influence and planning
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
1989-95 Birth and DevelopmentAl-Qaeda starts in the aftermath of Soviet invasion
1987By 1989 begins to target AmericaRecruits from across the globe including AmericaNo solid base (Afghanistan Egypt Iraq) 1991-1996 primarily based in SudanMuch soldier training and a system of Hierarchy
stabilized (Bin Laden Deputy 5 committees)
Conflict with bin Laden Escalates
Offers to raise a mujahidin army to defend Saudi Arabia from a potential invasion from Iraq in 1990
Saudi Arabia declines his offer opting instead to accept the assistance of the US and allow American troops (including women soldiers) in Saudi Arabia
Moves to Sudan by invitation of the Sudanese government in 1991
Supports several small to medium attacks against Western interests
Moves to Afghanistan in 1996 by invitation of the Taliban
Cruise missiles fired at al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan to kill bin Laden in 1998
Al-Qaedarsquos Strategy
Soldiers operate in fast moving light forces Work in complete secrecy to complete complex strategic strikes
Avoids engagement in conventional fighting (forces are not strong enough)
Spreads rumors fear and discouragement among enemy forces
Relies on a force of over 20000 professionally trained soldiers throughout the world
The organizationrsquos strengths are itsrsquo secrecy extensive influence and planning
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Conflict with bin Laden Escalates
Offers to raise a mujahidin army to defend Saudi Arabia from a potential invasion from Iraq in 1990
Saudi Arabia declines his offer opting instead to accept the assistance of the US and allow American troops (including women soldiers) in Saudi Arabia
Moves to Sudan by invitation of the Sudanese government in 1991
Supports several small to medium attacks against Western interests
Moves to Afghanistan in 1996 by invitation of the Taliban
Cruise missiles fired at al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan to kill bin Laden in 1998
Al-Qaedarsquos Strategy
Soldiers operate in fast moving light forces Work in complete secrecy to complete complex strategic strikes
Avoids engagement in conventional fighting (forces are not strong enough)
Spreads rumors fear and discouragement among enemy forces
Relies on a force of over 20000 professionally trained soldiers throughout the world
The organizationrsquos strengths are itsrsquo secrecy extensive influence and planning
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Al-Qaedarsquos Strategy
Soldiers operate in fast moving light forces Work in complete secrecy to complete complex strategic strikes
Avoids engagement in conventional fighting (forces are not strong enough)
Spreads rumors fear and discouragement among enemy forces
Relies on a force of over 20000 professionally trained soldiers throughout the world
The organizationrsquos strengths are itsrsquo secrecy extensive influence and planning
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Al Qaeda - Formed in 1988A Attacks 1 World Trade Center
ndash 19932 Tanzanian and
Kenyan US Embassies ndash 1998
3 USS Cole ndash 20004 World Trade Center
20015 Kenyan Hotel -20026 Bali nightclub ndash
20027 Many attacks in
Saudi Arabia ndash 2001-2004
8 Istanbul synagogue and HSBC bank ndash 2004
B Goals 1 to unite Muslims to
fight against the US as a way of defeating Israel
2 overthrowing non-Islamic regimes
3 expelling westerners and non-Muslims from Muslim countries
4 merged with Egyptian Islamic Jihad in 2001
5 merged with al-Zarqawirsquos group -2004
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Al Qaeda (cont)C Individuals1 Usama bin Laden2 Abu Musrsquoab al-
Zarqawi3 Ayman al-Zawahiri
D Financing1 personal wealth -
Usama2 fund raising ndashfalse
Muslim and humanitarian charities
3 wealthy Arab sheiks (Saudi Arabia)4 individuals and businesses 5 the heroin trade
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
International Front for Jihad against the Jews and Crusaders
ldquoThe ruling to kill the Americans and their alliescivilians and militaryis an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it rdquo
Fatwa issued by Osama bin Laden amp Ayman al-Zawahiri on 23 February 1998
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
AfricaAl-Qaeda cells operate in
African countries as well1998 bombings occurred
at the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania leaving 200 dead and more than 5000 people injured
The US responded with missile strikes against terrorist facilities in Afghanistan and Sudan Bin Laden was based in Sudan from 1991-1996
Predator drones used to attack terrorist bases in Sudan and Afghanistan
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Usama or Osama bin Laden
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
I am not afraid of death I came here to die Some of my supporters followed me here just to die for the cause of Islam They are ready to defend me and to kill anyone who thinks of attacking our positions or sites Osama Bin Laden
Osama Bin Laden
81
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
The US government charges that Osama bin Laden heads an international terrorist network called Al Qaeda an Arabic word meaning the base
Al Qaeda
83
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Afghans did not carry out the terrorist attacks on the US Al-Qaeda a terrorist network operating within Afghanistan and other places did
Many Afghans expressed their solidarity with the people of the US after Sept 11
After September 11 the US invaded Afghanistan and toppled the Taliban for sheltering Osama bin Laden
US and NATO forces remain in Afghanistan today
The link between September 11 and Afghanistan
httpwwwindiadailyorgimages9_11_attackjpg
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Al-QaedaClaims responsibility for attack on USA
Taliban lets Al-Qaeda hide out in their county because they are allies
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
According to Bin Laden he is concerned withAmerican foreign policy towards and
American actions in the Muslim world US support for Israel in its ongoing theft of
Arab landUS support for corrupt and repressive
regimes in the Muslim world (Egypt Jordan Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states)
Post 911 the US has added to an already long list of Muslim grievances by occupying Afghanistan and Iraq
Why did these people want to attack America
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
According to Bin Laden he has never said that the attacks were are or will be because of American freedoms the rights of our citizens or even because of our religious differences
He has said that the reasons for the attacks of the past as well as those of the future will be because of the way the US and its allies treat the Muslim World
Why did these people want to attack America
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
The DestructionFuelmdashThe flights were near their start
therefore the tanks were full Explosions and fires weakened the skyscrapers and both towers fell within two hours
Pentagon damage confined to only one section of the building
Human Death Toll about 3000All passengersWTC workersvisitors340 NYC firefighters60 NYC police officers
Attack on the United States
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
American Airlines Flight 11
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit North
Tower (WTC 1) at 846 AM
92 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
United Airlines Flight 175
Scheduled route Boston to LA
Aircraft Boeing 767Building Hit South
Tower (WTC 2) at 903 AM
65 on board
The hijackers
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
United Airlines Flight 175 crashes into the south tower
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Map showing the attacks on the World Trade Center (the planes are not drawn to scale)
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Diagram of how parts of the airplanes fell to the ground
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
American Airlines Flight 77
Route Washington DC (Dulles) to LA
Aircraft Boeing 757Building Hit
Pentagon Arlington VA
58 on board
The hijackers
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Aerial view of the Pentagon during rescue operations post-September 11 attack
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
United Airlines Flight 93 ldquoLetrsquos Rollrdquo
Scheduled Route Newark NJ to San Francisco
Aircraft Boeing 575Terrorists Target Speculated to
be Washington DCCrash Site Somerset County
PA44 on boardThe passengers revolted
against the hijackers and the aircraft crashed before reaching its intended target
The hijackers
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
If you had been on that planeHow would you have felt knowing your fateWhat would you have doneExplain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Crash Site of United Flight 93
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
2002-03 Regroup and PrivatizeThe full-scale war brought by America was
expectedAl-Qaeda groups become almost separate
working loosely with mother Al-Qaeda (Southeast Asia North America Europe Iraq North Africa and East Africa)
Aside from war in Iraq since 2002 groups have made attacks on the US and seven of our allies (18 major attacks in 11 countries)
Each Al-Qaeda group is strengthened by perceived injustices to that country (ie radical Egyptians in North Africa)
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
The Iraq ConnectionAbu Musab al-Zarqawi is believed to have
formed Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad in Afghanistan during the 1980sMay have received some funds from al-Qaeda but
operated independentlyOriginal objective was to overthrow the Jordanian
government and establish an Islamic stateExpanded urban guerilla warfare in Iraq to
include terrorist tactics also targeting IraqisOfficially merged with al-Qaeda 21 October
2004 (finally providing an al-Qaeda connection to Iraq)
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
2001 Anthrax Attacks 5 deaths (including 2 postal workers) 17 infections Suspected perpetrator Bruce Edward Irvins
(died July 29 2008 of suicide after he was informed he would be prosecuted for murder) a microbiologist and vaccinologist who was supposed to develop vaccines against anthrax
However many people doubt the governmentrsquos conclusions about Irvins Some coworkers said they would have noticed him develop the anthrax that was used
One historian believes the anthrax Irvins developed was stolen by an al-Qaida sympathizer at George Mason University because of lax security
We will probably never know The cost of the cleanup to decontaminate
buildings where anthrax was found was about $1 billion
A letter sent to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle containing anthrax powder killed two postal workers
Targets ABC NewsCBS NewsNBC NewsNew York PostNational EnquirerSenatorsTom DaschlePatrick Leahy
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
FAA orders airlines to install bars on cockpit doors
Plain clothed sky marshals assigned to fly on planes
National Guard patrolled airportsAviation and Transportation Act (2001)mdash
airport security became the responsibility of the federal government ALL baggage (even checked baggage) is screened
Aviation Security
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Why canrsquot we find Osama bin Laden or at least win and end the current war in Afghanistan
The rugged terrain makes it difficult to organize fight and rule people
Afghanistan Terrain causes Political Problems
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Osama bin Laden evaded capture for almost 10 years
In the mean time the United States had engaged in wars in Iraq (looking for weapons of mass destruction) and in Afghanistan (against the Taliban who supported terrorism)
bin Laden was suspected of hiding out in the mountainous regions of Afghanistan
Hiding Out
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Seeking Bin Laden ndash Tora Bora
109
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Attacking Tora Bora
110
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed
Early on the CIA sought to identify al-Qaeda couriers (messengers who pass information) who might have contact with bin Laden
Detainees in the CIArsquos secret prison system revealed the name of an al-Qaeda courier with the pseudonym Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti
When No 3 al-Qaeda leader Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was captured by the CIA he admitted knowing al-Kuwaiti but said he was not operating in al-Qaeda The CIA believed he was protecting the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 1
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
In 2004 a top operative for al-Qaeda was captured in Iraq named Hassan Ghul
Ghul revealed to the CIA that al-Kuwaiti was indeed a key courier in the al-Qaida organization close to operational commander Faraj al-Libi
In May 2005 Faraj al-Libi was captured by the CIA but he adamantly denied that al-Kuwaiti was the secret courier
This convinced the CIA that he as well as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was protecting the identity of the courier
Tracking Bin Laden 2
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
After years detainees revealed the real name of the courier al-Kuwaiti as Sheikh Abu Ahmed a Pakistani born in Kuwait
One detainee gave false information that Abu Ahmed was wounded fleeing US forces and died in his arms
But in the middle of 2010 Abu Ahmed used the telephone and his conversation was monitored by US officials
In August 2010 Abu Ahmed was tracked to the mysterious compound in Abbottabad
It had unusually high walls No one came or went There was no telephone or internet US authorities
became convinced that a high level terrorist was living there
Tracking Bin Laden 3
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
CIA aerial view of the bin Laden compound
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Politics President KarzaiPresident Hamid Karzai was the first elected president in the history of Afghanistan
He came to power after the Taliban was overthrown in late 2001
He was formally elected to a five-year term in 2004
Karzai has survived numerous assassination attempts and has been assigned the task of rebuilding Afghanistan
Some of the major problems he must address include providing the country with an infrastructure so that citizens have the basic necessities of life keeping the Taliban out of power and controlling the warlords who perpetuate the illegal drug trade
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Prime Minister Hamid Karzai (left)Deputy Premier Dr Sima Samar (right) ndash one of
two women in the government
President amp Female Ministers
116
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
If you were President Karzai what would be the top three changes or programs you would implement immediately in Afghanistan
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Current Governmentbull Islamic Republicbull 3 branch system executive judicial legislativebull President Hamid Karzai elected 2004
bull Target of assassination attempt in September 2002
bull Karzairsquos one mission is to ldquobring peace to Afghanistanrdquo
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
War lords control large parts of Afghanistan When the Taliban were removed cooperation among war lords decreased
War Lords
119
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Corruption very highbull 15 amp 176180 CPIbull Drug related (Opium) issues
are dominant bull History of unqualified appointeesbull Poor judiciary amp legal enforcement systemsbull Karzai amp other government officials accused of
using connections for profit including his brother
bull ldquoForeigners have defamed Afghanistan so badly in terms of corruption But its not as serious as they thinkrdquo
Government Corruption
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
ldquocorruption and inefficiency in Afghanistan were as much to blame as the Taliban insurgency for the countrys instabilityrdquo
frac12 said corruption had increased among officials and the police in Afghanistan
anti-corruption department and a more open government
Even More Corruption
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
How do you combat government corruption like this
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Recovering from decades of conflict
Has improved since the fall of the Taliban in 2001
Highly dependent on foreign aid
Instability inhibits economic growth
Economy of Afghanistan
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
- Budget sustainability- Job creation- Corruption- Rebuilding war-torn infrastructure
Economic Long-Term Challenges
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
-GDP 35 billion (2007)-GDP Real Growth Rate 75-GDP per capita $1000 (2007)
-Ranks 157th in the World-Inflation Rate 13-Unemployment Rate 40 (2005)-Labor Force approximately 15 million
-Agriculture 80 Industry 10 Services 10
Afghanistan- Economic Indicators
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Imports Capital goods food textiles petroleum
products
ExportsOpium fruits nuts hand-woven carpets wool
cotton precious gems
Imports and Exports
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Lifeblood of Afghan economy 38 of GDP non-opium
agriculture12 of land is arable and
only half that is cultivatedAccounts for 80 of
workforceNot self-sufficient in
agriculture and must rely on food aid to meet domestic needs
Increasing agricultural production has been a focus of development efforts in Afghanistan
Agriculture
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Greatest illicit opium producer in the world
In 2007 93 of the opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan (export value of 4 billion)
High rate of return on investment from opium poppy cultivation has driven an agricultural shift in Afghanistan from growing traditional crops to growing opium poppy
Shortage of food and other crop production (wheat fruit nuts etc)
Opium
Opium Production
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Unexploited mining territory
Geological surveys are incomplete additional energy and mineral deposits likely to be found
As economic conditions improve Afghanistan will be in a better position to attract investment
World Bank estimates value of mineral production could be $253 million compared to $60 million currently
Natural ResourcesMay be a key to long-term economic development
Produces natural gas copper ironHas deposits of marble salt gold and silver
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Important and growing component in economy
Trade deficit Increased in recent years
as more development aid and equipment have entered country
Inflow of foreign aid is large enough to wipe out current deficit help to keep monetary conditions stable
Trade and Investment
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Population 33609937 people
Age Breakdown
0-14 years 445 (male 7664670female 7300446) 15-64 years 53 (male 9147846female 8679800) 65 years and over 24 (male 394572female 422603)
Life Expectancy total population 4464 years male 4447 years female 4481 years
Median Age 176 years
Pop Growth Rate 2629
Birth Rate 4582 births1000 population
Death Rate 1956 deaths1000 population
Sex Ratio total population 105 male(s)female
The People
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
WHO ndash ldquoAfghanistans health status is one of the worst in the worldrdquo
HIVAIDS Percentage 001
This number is expected to rise as the number of drug users goes up (ie heroin opium)
Major Diseases bacterial and protozoal diarrhea hepatitis A and typhoid fever malaria rabies
Health Sector is dismal at best Lackshellip
infrastructure competent workers supplies open channels of communication terrible information systems
Health related expenses amount to 5 of GDP
1 doctor6000 patients
1 nurse2500 patients
Health
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Updateimprove information systems
Restoreupdate facilities
Extend care to rural areas
Drug availabilityHire more trained
workersBoost efficiency of
response time to natural disasters
Improving the Healthcare System
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
39 of children under age five are underweight
48 of children under age five are under height
61 of the population is without sustainable access to an improved water source
Access to safe water 23 Access to adequate sanitation
12 In 2001 8 of poprsquon had access
to basic healthcare Most used alternative
healthcare ie Midwives
Why
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
7 yoEats breakfast 7AM every
morning1 loaf of bread lasts her her
two brothers and her parents 3 days
10 AM gets 12 small biscuits from school Eats 6 brings home the rest to family
Lunchtime goes home and has bread with some oil
9PM eats bread with a little yogurt for dinner
Rahera amp Malnutrition
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
More than 10 million children have suffered under 10 years of drought and civil warAfghanistan ranks
number 1 in worldwide maternal mortality
One in three Afghan children is an orphan
Almost half of Afghan children suffer from chronic malnutrition
Suffer the Little Children
136
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Looking in garbage (above left)
Picking wheat grains from ground (below)
Hungry Children
137
Kids wait in line for food aid (right)
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
50 of pop is under 18UNICEF says 30 of primary school aged
children are working21 of child laborers work in shops13 work as street vendors
Poverty is the driving forceParents canrsquot pay for schoolingOpportunity cost of schooling is high
Child Labor
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Two Types Religious Schooling Secular Schooling (introduced in
1964)Post-Taliban resurgence in
educationSchools are in a disarray though
funding is limited and unstableSecurity of Schools is a problem
Taliban destroy secular schools Illiteracy 56 men 87 women
Hinderance in workforce
Education
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Rights of women enshrined in the new Constitution
Women can participate in every walk of life91 of 361 members of Parliament are women
It is becoming ok to talk about forced marriages rapes honor killings etcHuman rights groups are starting to document and
publicize atrocitiesGroups amp campaigns fighting
for Muslim womenrsquos rightsPolygamy inheritance custody
consent to marryInternational attention
ldquoRape Lawrdquo to be amendedRights groups around the world
Hope
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
As of today Afghanistan is still a LDCSecurity against Taliban is shakeyUS troop deploymentTaliban are numerous amp attack the few govrsquot
services availableTheir goal is to demoralize the country amp
international community 2100 Afghanirsquos dead from insurgent attacks
Security amp Overall Well-Being
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
As of 2006 Afghanirsquos are feeling hopelessSurveyed 1000 citizens from 13 provinces
and balanced the different ethnic groupsSurveyed on Pillars of Reconstruction
SecurityGovernanceJusticeEconomic OpportunitySocial Well-Being
Afghanistan An Evaluation
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
Kals Cartoonshttpwwwkaltoonscomwordpress200912kal-economist-afghanistan-cartoons
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side
After watching the DVD and this lecture what do you think is the best way for Afghanistan to get back on its feet
Explain
On your Left Side