National Fire Protection Association
1 Batterymarch Park, Quincy, MA 02169-7471
Phone: 617-770-3000 • Fax: 617-770-0700 • www.nfpa.org
M E M O R A N D U M
TO: NFPA Technical Committee on Hazardous Chemicals
FROM: Joanne Goyette, Administrator, Technical Projects
DATE: December 29, 2014
SUBJECT: NFPA 400 SD TC Ballot Circulation (A2015)
The December 26, 2014 date for receipt of the NFPA 400 Second Draft ballot has passed.
The preliminary Second Draft ballot results are shown on the attached report.
29 Members Eligible to Vote
7 Ballots Not Returned (H. Febo, R. James, K. Kreitman, J. Miles, K. Mueller, J. Vigerust, and
J. Wallace)
In accordance with the NFPA Regulations Governing the Development of NFPA Standards,
attached are reasons for negative votes for review so you may change your ballot if you wish.
Abstentions and affirmative comments are also included. Ballots received from alternate members
are not included unless the ballot from the principal member was not received.
If you wish to change your vote, the change must be received at NFPA on or Monday,
January 5, 2015. Members who have not returned a ballot may do so now. Such changes
should be submitted through the NFPA Vote.net Ballot Site.
The return of ballots is required by the Regulations Governing the Development of NFPA
Standards.
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu OK
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu OK
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu OK
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 20
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu OK
Negative 0
Abstain 1
Jerrold Sameth CGA did not establish a technical consensus for this SR.
SR-153, Global Comment, See SR-153
December 29, 2014Results by Revision
SR-108, Global Comment, See SR-108
Total Voted : 22
NFPA 400 HCS-AAA (A2015) Second Draft Ballot
Circulation Explanations
SR-127, Detail, See SR-127
Total Voted : 22
SR-176, Global Comment, See SR-176
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
SR-175, Detail, See SR-175
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu OK
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu OK
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu OK
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu OK
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
SR-168, Section No. 1.1.2.2, See SR-168
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
SR-170, Section No. 2.3.1, See SR-170
SR-169, Section No. 2.2, See SR-169
Total Voted : 22
SR-82, Section No. 2.3.5, See SR-82
Noel Hsu OK
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu OK
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu OK
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu OK
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 20
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu OK
Negative 0
Abstain 1
Jerrold Sameth CGA did not establish a technical consensus for this SR.
SR-171, Section No. 2.4, See SR-171
SR-174, Section No. 2.3.12, See SR-174
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
SR-105, New Section after 3.3.7, See SR-105
Total Voted : 22
SR-83, Section No. 3.3.2.2, See SR-83
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
SR-24, Section No. 3.3.8, See SR-24
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu OK
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu OK
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu OK
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu OK
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
SR-110, Section No. 3.3.9, See SR-110
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
SR-111, Section No. 3.3.11, See SR-111
SR-109, Section No. 3.3.10, See SR-109
Total Voted : 22
SR-154, Section No. 3.3.16, See SR-154
Noel Hsu OK
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu OK
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu OK
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu OK
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu OK
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
SR-155, Section No. 3.3.19.2, See SR-155
SR-84, Section No. 3.3.18, See SR-84
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
SR-156, Section No. 3.3.19.11.1, See SR-156
Total Voted : 22
SR-25, Section No. 3.3.19.10.1, See SR-25
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
SR-26, Section No. 3.3.19.16, See SR-26
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu OK
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu OK
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu OK
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu OK
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu OK
SR-27, Section No. 3.3.19.17, See SR-27
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
SR-28, Section No. 3.3.47.7, See SR-28
SR-157, Section No. 3.3.24, See SR-157
Total Voted : 22
SR-29, Section No. 3.3.47.10, See SR-29
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu OK
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu OK
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu OK
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu OK
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
SR-85, Section No. 3.3.53, See SR-85
SR-30, Section No. 3.3.51, See SR-30
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
SR-86, Section No. 3.3.62, See SR-86
Total Voted : 22
SR-31, Section No. 3.3.59, See SR-31
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
SR-112, New Section after 3.3.66, See SR-112
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu OK
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu OK
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu OK
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu OK
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 19
Affirmative with Comment 3
SR-32, Section No. 3.3.68.6 [Excluding any Sub-Sections], See SR-32
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
SR-158, Section No. 3.3.79, See SR-158
SR-33, Section No. 3.3.73, See SR-33
Total Voted : 22
SR-128, Section No. 5.2.1.1.3, See SR-128
Martin T. Gresho errors remain in Table 5.2.1.1.3. I believe they are editorial and can be fixed via errata if SR-128 passes
ballot. Hence the affirmative vote. Issue 1: For Flammable gas in the LP row for the USE - Closed Systems
Gas column. Footnotes o, p and q are included but a straight extract from 55 would only include footnote
q. The reference to footnotes o and p should be deleted here to make this extract correct. Issue 2:
Unstable (reactive) gas row.In the Class column The text reads "Gaseous 3 or 4 detonable" To be a correct
extract (and to not be technically wrong) this text should read "Gaseous" then next row down ""4 or 3
detonable" Issue 3: Unstable (reactive) liquified gas row. Just place the word "Liquified" in its own row
and the extract will be correct and not misleading as it is now.
Mark J. Dossett Table 5.2.1.1.3 should be reviewed for editorial errors.
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu OK
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
SR-130, Section No. 5.2.1.3, See SR-130
SR-129, Section No. 5.2.1.2, See SR-129
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
SR-132, Section No. 5.2.1.5, See SR-132
SR-131, Section No. 5.2.1.4, See SR-131
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 18
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 3
Total Voted : 22
SR-134, Section No. 5.2.1.7, See SR-134
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
SR-133, Section No. 5.2.1.6, See SR-133
SR-34, Section No. 5.3.7, See SR-34
SR-135, Section No. 5.2.1.8, See SR-135
Total Voted : 22
Martin T. Gresho I believe this was a staff action to correlate extracts but it was done incorrectly. Table 5.3.7 in NFPA 400-
is intended to address solids and liquids (NFPA 400 scope) as well as gases (NFPA 55 scope). This Table
needs to be only a partial extract from NFPA 55 to address gases and the solids and liquids header (NFPA
400 scope) needs to be retained. The location of the extract tag in current version of the table is
confusing but it is better to retain that for now than to make this edit which breaks the code and would
require a TIA to fix if it passes. I urge TC members to vote negative on SR-34.
Mark J. Dossett Table should only be a partial extract from 55 to address gasses.
Lynne M. Kilpatrick The proposal to modify the material column header to only address Gases is incorrect. Additionally, the
liquid and solid column header and the gas column header should not be deleted as proposed.
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Total Voted : 22
SR-36, Section No. 6.2.1.1, See SR-36
SR-35, Section No. 6.2.1 [Excluding any Sub-Sections], See SR-35
Total Voted : 22
SR-136, Section No. 5.4.1.2, See SR-136
Total Voted : 22
SR-37, Section No. 6.2.1.2, See SR-37
Total Voted : 22
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
SR-145, Section No. 6.2.1.4, See SR-145
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
SR-40, Section No. 6.2.1.5.8, See SR-40
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
SR-39, Sections 6.2.1.5.1, 6.2.1.5.2, 6.2.1.5.3, See SR-39
SR-41, Section No. 6.2.1.6, See SR-41
Total Voted : 22
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 20
Affirmative with Comment 2
Martin T. Gresho the text added that states "and NFPA 5000" is not extract from 5000 and should likely be bracketed for
clarity.
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Total Voted : 22
SR-42, Section No. 6.2.1.8.1, See SR-42
SR-44, Section No. 6.2.3.4.2, See SR-44
SR-43, Section No. 6.2.3.4.1, See SR-43
Total Voted : 22
SR-161, Section No. 6.2.3.3.1, See SR-161
Total Voted : 22
SR-162, Section No. 6.2.4.3.1, See SR-162
Total Voted : 22
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 20
Affirmative with Comment 2
Martin T. Gresho similar issues to SR-44 with brackets here as the extract material has been edited to work in 400
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 20
Affirmative with Comment 2
Martin T. Gresho review use of brackets where extract text has been modified to work with 400.
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
SR-45, Sections 6.2.4.4.1, 6.2.4.4.2, See SR-45
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
SR-47, Section No. 6.2.5.1, See SR-47
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
SR-46, Section No. 6.2.4.5, See SR-46
SR-149, New Section after 6.2.5.2, See SR-149
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 20
Affirmative with Comment 2
Martin T. Gresho review use of brackets in extract text
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Total Voted : 22
SR-48, Section No. 6.2.6, See SR-48
Total Voted : 22
SR-144, Section No. 6.3.1.4.2.10, See SR-144
SR-51, Section No. 6.3.1.3, See SR-51
Total Voted : 22
SR-49, Section No. 6.2.7.2, See SR-49
Total Voted : 22
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
SR-55, Section No. 6.3.2.1.4.1, See SR-55
Total Voted : 22
SR-54, Sections 6.3.2.1.2.1, 6.3.2.1.2.2, 6.3.2.1.2.3, See SR-54
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
SR-57, Section No. 6.3.2.2.4.1, See SR-57
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
SR-143, Section No. 6.3.2.2.3, See SR-143
SR-152, Section No. 6.3.2.2.4.2(B), See SR-152
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 18
Affirmative with Comment 2
Total Voted : 22
SR-58, Section No. 6.3.2.3.3.2, See SR-58
Total Voted : 22
SR-103, Chapter 11, See SR-103
SR-81, Sections 6.3.3.3.2.1, 6.3.3.3.2.2, See SR-81
Total Voted : 22
SR-80, Sections 6.3.3.2.2.1, 6.3.3.2.2.2, See SR-80
Total Voted : 22
Noel Hsu 11.1.5.3 - Public notification system. This could be onerous since the notification must reach all residents
within the 1 mile radius. Guidance should be provided to ensure that a practicable system is
implemented. 11.2.7.1.1 and 11.2.15.1.1 - fighting incipient fires. Incipient is highly subjective. A fire that
has been smouldering for a while may not be seen. Fighting such a fire could put the first responder at
risk. All fires involving AN should not be fought, without exception. Committee comment on ventilation.
There is no evidence that 'freely vented fires do not present an explosion risk'.
Ronald Thomas 11.2.3 - the new addition of mechanical ventilation and the requirement of such has never been proven
in literature or accident investigation to be a preventative measure. Most non-combustible storage has
passive but protected ventilation. 11.2.7.1.1 - the use of any type of extinguisher to fight a fire involving
AN should not be allowed. By the time external fire departments arrive on the scene the fire is usually
beyond a beginning stage. Employees in the AN are specially trained on handling a fire involving the site
but not the inclusion of AN in the fire. 11.2.8.2 - the 2 hour supply was added after the tech committee
mat and agreed on the language. This requirement may not be feasible in rural or remote areas.
Negative 1
Anthony M. Ordile Public Notification System requirements in 11.1.5.3 and 11.2.12.2 fail to indicate who is responsible for
implementing, maintaining, and testing this system. Have the AN storage facility responsible for
evacuating a 1-mile radius places a responsibility on the management of such facilities that they are not
capable of performing. Also, this completely new requirement was introduced after the first draft when
no public or emergency responder input could be reviewed by the TC regarding the best way to install
and maintain such systems. Technology is not even available for a voice notification system to project a
message up to 1-mile away. Additionally, 11.2.12.2 under the General Storage Requirements section
requires the Public Notification System when "AN can detonate when exposed to fire conditions in
quantities in excess of 1,000 lbs", but no annex material is presented to guide the public when such
conditions could occur. Detonation is different from deflagration, but the general public and some code
officials would just consider them explosions. In contrast to Section 11.2.12.2, Section 11.1.5.3 under the
Protection of Existing Buildings section only requires the Public Notification System retroactive to Type III,
IV, or V constructed buildings with no mention to the potential for detonation. The Public Notification
requirement needs more consideration before it is adopted in an enforceable code. Separate of the
previous comments; the reference in Section 11.2.12.2 to complying with 11.1.5.2.2 has no applicability
as 11.1.5.2.2 has to do with on-site notification and not an off-site Public Notification System. Also,
reference in Section 11.5.5 to Section 11.2.6 should be changed to 11.2.5, which deals with sprinklers and
not 11.2.6, which deals with fire detection.
Abstain 1
Jerrold Sameth CGA did not establish a technical consensus for this SR.
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
SR-92, New Section after 15.3, See SR-92
SR-91, New Section after 15.2.9, See SR-91
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Total Voted : 22
SR-93, Section No. 15.3.1.4.13.1, See SR-93
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
SR-146, Section No. 15.3.1.4.7, See SR-146
Total Voted : 22
SR-95, Section No. 15.3.1.4.13.5, See SR-95
SR-148, Section No. 15.3.1.4.13.4, See SR-148
Total Voted : 22
SR-147, Section No. 15.3.4.2.13.2, See SR-147
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
SR-113, Chapter 21 [Title Only], See SR-113
SR-96, New Section after 15.5.9, See SR-96
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
SR-164, Section No. 21.2.3.1 [Excluding any Sub-Sections], See SR-164
SR-163, Section No. 21.1.2.5, See SR-163
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Total Voted : 22
SR-64, Section No. 21.2.7.1.2, See SR-64
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
SR-63, Section No. 21.2.4 [Excluding any Sub-Sections], See SR-63
Total Voted : 22
SR-165, Section No. 21.2.11, See SR-165
SR-65, Section No. 21.2.10.2, See SR-65
Total Voted : 22
SR-66, Section No. 21.2.12.1.3, See SR-66
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
SR-68, Section No. 21.2.16.1, See SR-68
SR-67, Section No. 21.2.16 [Excluding any Sub-Sections], See SR-67
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
SR-69, Section No. 21.2.16.5, See SR-69
SR-123, Section No. 21.2.16.4, See SR-123
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Total Voted : 22
SR-116, Section No. 21.3.1.3, See SR-116
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
SR-124, Section No. 21.3.1.2, See SR-124
Total Voted : 22
SR-72, Section No. 21.3.1.4.4, See SR-72
SR-166, Section No. 21.3.1.4.2.2, See SR-166
Total Voted : 22
SR-73, Section No. 21.3.1.9.2, See SR-73
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
SR-173, Section No. 21.3.1.15, See SR-173
SR-167, Section No. 21.3.1.9.3 [Excluding any Sub-Sections], See SR-167
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
SR-74, Sections 21.3.1.16.4, 21.3.1.16.5, See SR-74
SR-120, Section No. 21.3.1.16.2, See SR-120
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Total Voted : 22
SR-125, Section No. 21.3.3.1.3 [Excluding any Sub-Sections], See SR-125
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
SR-122, Section No. 21.3.1.16.7, See SR-122
Total Voted : 22
SR-115, Section No. 21.3.6.2.1, See SR-115
SR-121, Section No. 21.3.3.1.12, See SR-121
Total Voted : 22
SR-126, Section No. 21.3.6.2.2, See SR-126
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
SR-118, New Section after 21.11, See SR-118
SR-117, Section No. 21.6, See SR-117
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
SR-4, Section No. A.3.3.15, See SR-4
SR-1, Section No. A.3.3.1, See SR-1
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 20
Affirmative with Comment 2
Noel Hsu ok
Jerrold Sameth No comment
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Total Voted : 22
SR-160, Section No. A.3.3.19.10.1, See SR-160
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
SR-159, Section No. A.3.3.19.6, See SR-159
Total Voted : 22
SR-6, Section No. A.3.3.26, See SR-6
SR-5, Section No. A.3.3.19.11.2, See SR-5
Total Voted : 22
SR-7, Section No. A.3.3.37, See SR-7
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
SR-11, Section No. A.3.3.56, See SR-11
SR-76, Section No. A.3.3.50, See SR-76
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
SR-14, Section No. A.3.3.61.11, See SR-14
SR-12, Section No. A.3.3.57, See SR-12
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Total Voted : 22
SR-97, Section No. A.4.1, See SR-97
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
SR-15, Section No. A.3.3.86, See SR-15
Total Voted : 22
SR-17, Sections A.21.1.1.2.1(5), A.21.1.1.2.1(6), See SR-17
SR-16, Section No. A.21.1.1.2.1(3), See SR-16
Total Voted : 22
SR-18, Section No. A.21.2.9, See SR-18
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
SR-20, Section No. A.21.3.1.5.2, See SR-20
SR-19, Section No. A.21.3.1.1, See SR-19
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
SR-23, Section No. A.21.4.2.4.5.1, See SR-23
SR-22, Section No. A.21.4.2, See SR-22
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu Fighting of 'incipient fires' should not be permitted. Determination of 'incipient' not always
straightforward, and could place the fire fighter at risk.
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Total Voted : 22
SR-104, Chapter E, See SR-104
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
SR-79, Chapter B, See SR-79
Total Voted : 22
SR-138, Section No. F.2.3, See SR-138
SR-137, Section No. F.1, See SR-137
Total Voted : 22
SR-139, Section No. F.3.3, See SR-139
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 20
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
SR-141, Section No. F.5.3, See SR-141
SR-140, Section No. F.4.3, See SR-140
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
SR-98, Section No. G.1.1, See SR-98
SR-142, Section No. F.6.3, See SR-142
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
Abstain 1
Jerrold Sameth CGA did not establish a technical consensus for this SR.
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 17
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 3
Martin T. Gresho This classifies ammonium nitrate as a class 2 oxidizer. This conflicts with other expert based classifications
(HMEX) of AN which conclude that it is both a class 3 oxidizer and an unstable/reactive class 3 detonable.
For the oxidizer classification I disagree with the use of small scale testing for AN. Likely OK for other
oxidizers but not for AN. Also the test report makes no discussion of quality assurance protocols or other
measures taken to assure independent repeatability of results Finally, this text is misleading because
classifying AN as ONLY an oxidizer ignores the indisputable anecdotal evidence that it can also detonate.
Mark J. Dossett The change classifies AN as a class 2 oxidizer which is in conflict with references used by AHJ’s. The
change also does not appear to also classify AN as an unstable (reactive) 3. Downgrading the widely used
classification of AN as an OX3/UR3, also tends to downgrade by default, the code requirements for
protecting this material, protecting the public and first responders. Representing the fire service, I cannot
support any change that would potentially lessen requirements for a material that has been involved in
so many disasters without conducting full-scale testing.
Lynne M. Kilpatrick This proposal classifies ammonium nitrate as a Class 2 oxidizer. This conflicts with other expert-based
classifications (HMEx) of AN which conclude that it is both a Class 3 oxidizer and a Class 3
Unstable/reactive (detonable). I disagree with basing the classification on small scale testing of AN. Also,
the test report makes no discussion of quality assurance protocols or other measures taken to ensure
repeatability of the results. Finally, classifying AN as ONLY an oxidizer ignores the indisputable anecdotal
evidence that it can also detonate.
Abstain 1
Jerrold Sameth CGA did not establish a technical consensus for this SR.
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 17
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 3
Martin T. Gresho This section is misleading because 1) the basis for classifying AN as a Class 2 oxidizer is insufficient as
explained in the negative ballot statement for SR-99 2) the classification conflicts with other expert based
methodologies for classifying HAZMAT (HMEX) with no explanation offered for the difference 3)
publishing this information will create conflict for many AHJs who use resources such as HMEX to classify
AN 4) The text ignores the classification of AN as a class 3 unstable reactive detonable solid by HMEX
which would go a long way to raising awareness for dealing with this hazardous material.
Mark J. Dossett See negative ballot statement for SR-99.
Total Voted : 22
SR-100, New Section after G.4, See SR-100
Total Voted : 22
SR-99, Section No. G.2.3, See SR-99
Lynne M. Kilpatrick This Section is misleading because 1) the basis for classifying AN as a Class 2 oxidizer is insufficient as
explained in the negative ballot statement for SR-99. 2) the classification conflicts with other expert-
based methodologies for classifying hazardous materials (i.e. HMEx) with no explanation offered for the
difference. 3) publishing this information will create conflict for many AHJs who use resources such as
HMEx to classify AN. 4) The text ignores the classification of AN as a Class 3 unstable reactive detonable
solid by HMEx which would go a long way to raising awareness for dealing with this hazardous material.
Abstain 1
Jerrold Sameth CGA did not establish a technical consensus for this SR.
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 29
Not Returned : 7
Henry L. Febo, Jr., Robert J. James, Kevin Kreitman,
Joyce Miles, Ken Scott Mueller, James O. Vigerust,
Jr., and Jerry W. Wallace
Vote Selection Votes Comments
Affirmative 21
Affirmative with Comment 1
Noel Hsu ok
Negative 0
Abstain 0
Total Voted : 22
Total Voted : 22
SR-150, Section No. G.5, See SR-150
SR-101, Section No. G.4, See SR-101
Total Voted : 22