7/31/2019 Russ Granata: A Critical Analysis of the Official View of Auschwitz in light of Chemistry and Technology

1/28

7/31/2019 Russ Granata: A Critical Analysis of the Official View of Auschwitz in light of Chemistry and Technology

2/28

>0!>0!>8 ?:2>>Faueaz Ead`gygdeg & 9>>9

^ojg 9 uwy 93

a|cgy `oehmh|o|ayu a` |chu Faueaz

ead`gygdeg$ \cg mou| |hfg H zou hd

Faueaz zou hd ?887 |ajg|cgy zh|c Eoyma

Fo||ajda odl Byjgd Jyo` ygugoyechdj

laewfgd|oyx oyechpgu ~gy|ohdhdj |aEadegd|yo|had Eof~ Owueczh|r zchec

|cg Uaphg| oyfx |aak apgy `yaf |cg

Jgyfodu hd Bodwoyx a` ?8

7/31/2019 Russ Granata: A Critical Analysis of the Official View of Auschwitz in light of Chemistry and Technology

3/28

>0!>0!>8 ?:2>>Faueaz Ead`gygdeg & 9>>9

^ojg 5 uwy 93

xaw `yaf eh|hdj fayg Jgyfod&iouchdj & iw| molhgu odl

jgd|mgfgd & h` xaw ygfgfigy bwu| adg |chdj `yaf fx |omk zh|c

xaw |alox- bwu| igoy hd fhdl |co| da| admx o| Owueczh|r- iw| o|

dadg a` |cg a|cgy ommgjgl )gs|gyfhdo|had eof~u) lhl |cg

Jgyfodu eaffh| fouu fwylgy ou ecoyjgl ix |cg phe|ayu2 dazox & odl egy|ohdmx da| hd cafhehlom gsgew|had jou ecofigyu ay

cafhehlom eygfo|ayx fouu fwylgy `oehmh|hgu & lgu~h|g\cg

Gdexema~glho a` \cg Camaeowu|hd uecaamu odl mhiyoyhgu- odl hd

omm |caug ygqwhygl Camaeowu| U|wlx eawyugu$ H|*u od aw|yojg/

Odl fayg |cod ighdj od hduhlhawu mhg & zchec hu iol gdawjc &

gpgd zayug hu \cgCamaeowu|Caagx*u yh~~mg g``ge|2 H| cou

`wde|hadgl ou o ~ya|ge|hpg ~ya~ojodlo iw``gy uchgmlhdja~~auh|had |a Bgzyx*u ?8|c egd|wyx u|o|g

a` Huyogm$ \oiaa dwfigy adg cou iggd |a loyg |a eyh|hehrg Bgzyx

odl Hd|gydo|hadom Bgzyx*u fhmh|od| odl imaalx od|h

^omgu|hdhod!Fhllmg Gou|gyd gs~oduhadhu| oe|hadu- da| |a fgd|had

|cg `oe| |co| |chu chu|ayheom mhg cou uhdeg ?8

7/31/2019 Russ Granata: A Critical Analysis of the Official View of Auschwitz in light of Chemistry and Technology

4/28

>0!>0!>8 ?:2>>Faueaz Ead`gygdeg & 9>>9

^ojg < uwy 93

Oeeaylhdj |a a``hehom chu|ayhajyo~cx- Owueczh|r eadegd|yo|had

eof~ hu uohl |a copg u|oy|gl a`` hd ?8 ou o ygjwmoy ay dayfom

eadegd|yo|had eof~- iw| |cgd- ou |cg u|ayx jagu- |za xgoyu mo|gy-

ay ix ?8> dad&Bgzhuc

phe|hfu hd chu u|odloyl zayk-Lhg Pgydhec|wdj lgy gwya~huecgd

Bwlgd #@hucgy \ouecgdiwec Pgymoj ?88:- ~ojg 8> `yaf o

~ygphawu `hjwyg a` :??->>> #Lhg Kygfo|ayhgd pad Owueczh|r-

^h~gy Pgymoj- ?88($

Zgmm- omm |caug dwfigyu oyg `od|ouhgu- |a ~w| h| ~amh|gmx- igeowugoeeaylhdj |a |cg laewfgd|u- lwyhdj |cg gd|hyg gshu|gdeg a` |cg

Owueczh|r eof~- o~~yashfo|gmx ?7>->>> ~yhuadgyu lhgl- com` a`

zcaf zgyg Bgzu- odl |cg fohd eowugu a` lgo|c zgyg lwg |a

hmmdguugu/ Omm laewfgd|u yg`gyyhdj |a jouuhdju a` ~ga~mg- oyg

iougl ad zh|dguu yg~ay|u$ Hd |cg o~~yashfo|gmx ?5>->>> ~ojgu a`

Jgyfod laewfgd|u ygjoylhdj |chu moyjgu| Jgyfod

eadegd|yo|had eof~- adg lagu da| `hdl |cg umhjc|gu| hdlheo|had a`odx jou ecofigyu `ay khmmhdj ~ga~mg$

7/31/2019 Russ Granata: A Critical Analysis of the Official View of Auschwitz in light of Chemistry and Technology

5/28

>0!>0!>8 ?:2>>Faueaz Ead`gygdeg & 9>>9

^ojg 7 uwy 93

H| hu qwh|g ygpgomhdj |a ygol |cg fwec ~yohugl iaak ix B$E$

^yguuoe-Lhg Kygfo|ayhgd pad Owueczh|r$ Hd |cg hd|yalwe|had-

^yguuoe |gmmu wu |co| cg hu ygmxhdj ad laewfgd|u odl da|

lg~gdlhdj ad zh|dguu yg~ay|u$

Cazgpgy zcgd zg ygol chu iaak- zg `hdl aw| |a awy uwy~yhug

|co| ^yguuoe hu omzoxu qwa|hdj zh|dguu yg~ay|u ou chu uawyeg

zcgdgpgy cg yg`gyu |a jouuhdju/

Zgmm- zg oyg da| uo|hu`hgl zh|c zh|dguu yg~ay|u igeowug- ou hu

zgmm&kdazd- |cgx oyg ua wdygmhoimg$ Bwu| |a jhpg adg gsof~mg-|cgyg zgyg fodx zh|dguu yg~ay|u oiaw| jouuhdj hd Zgu|gyd

eof~u uwec ou Iwecgdzoml odl Loecow- iw| `ay lgeolgu daz-

chu|ayhodu copg ojyggl |co| daialx zou jouugl |cgyg$ Zcgd h|

eafgu yhjc| lazd |a oe|wommx hdpgu|hjo|hdj |cg ua&eommgl ihjjgu|

fwylgy hd cwfod chu|ayx- Ygphuhadhu|u zayk mhkg lg|ge|hpgu ou

|cgx ja oiaw| hdpgu|hjo|hdj odx fwylgy eoug$ \cgx gsofhdg |cg

|yoegu a` |cg eyhfg & |cg zgo~ad & hd |chu eoug |cg jou ecofigy &ou zgmm ou |cg lhu~auh|had a` |cg ialhgu$ \za fohd qwgu|hadu oyg2

?$ Zgyg fouu jouuhdju |gecdheommx ~auuhimg ou lgueyhigl ix

zh|dguugu hd |cg Owueczh|r yaafu ay ecofigyu zchec oyg |cg

ua&eommgl cwfod gs|gyfhdo|had ecofigyu1

9$ Zou h| ~auuhimg |a eygfo|g |cg ommgjgl dwfigy a` ialhgu hd|cg eygfo|ayhgu1

\cg Ofgyheod @ygl Mgwec|gy odl |cg Jgyfod- Jgyfoy Ywlam`

copg lgom| zh|c |cg `hyu| qwgu|had$

Mgwec|gy*u ?833 ~wimhucgl zayk zou gd|h|mgl #Od Gdjhdggyhdj

Yg~ay| ad |cg Ommgjgl Jou Ecofigyu o| Owueczh|r- Ihykgdow odlFoblodgk- ^amodl- Uofhulo| ^wimhucgyu- \ayad|a ?838($

7/31/2019 Russ Granata: A Critical Analysis of the Official View of Auschwitz in light of Chemistry and Technology

6/28

>0!>0!>8 ?:2>>Faueaz Ead`gygdeg & 9>>9

^ojg 0 uwy 93

Mgwec|gy*u iaak iyakg |cg heg- om|cawjc h| ead|ohdu uafg

fhu|okgu- odl zou uw~gyeglgl ix |cg fayg uehgd|h`he Jw|oec|gd

ix |cg Jgyfod ecgfhu| Jgyfoy Ywlam` #Lou Ywlam` Jw|oec|gd-

Eyafzgmm Pgymoj- Madlad ?885($

\cg ugeadl qwgu|had- eadegydhdj eygfo|hadu zou gsofhdgl ix

|cg H|omhodu- Eoyma Fo||ajda odl @yodea Lgodo- zcaug dgz

moyjg zayk ad |cg eygfo|ayhgu a` Owueczh|r hu hd |cg ~yaeguu a`

ighdj ~wimhucgl hd H|omx; odl o uxd|cguhu a` zchec zou `hyu|

~wimhucgl hd Jgyfodx #)Lhg Kygfo|ayhwfu`gd pad

Owueczh|r&Ihykgdow) hd G$ Jowuu- Jywdlmojgd rwy

Rgh|jguechec|g- Jyoigy| Pgymoj- \ihdjgd ?88

7/31/2019 Russ Granata: A Critical Analysis of the Official View of Auschwitz in light of Chemistry and Technology

7/28

>0!>0!>8 ?:2>>Faueaz Ead`gygdeg & 9>>9

^ojg : uwy 93

fwylgy$

Ucofg ad |caug )a``hehom chu|ayhodu) zca col iggd ~yguwfhdj

ay ~yg|gdlhdj |co| |cg moyjg eygfo|had `oehmh|hgu hd |caug Ugeadl

Zayml Zoy eof~u- col iggd w|hmhrgl da| admx `ay |cg ygfapoma` phe|hfu a` g~hlgfheu zchec aeewyygl `ygqwgd|mx lgu~h|g

hd|gduhpg lhuhd`ge|had- iw| zgyg omua ~yguwfgl ay ~yg|gdlgl |a

copg iggd wugl |a fouu fwylgy Bgzu$

@ay |chu ~wy~aug- zg copg iggd |aml |co| uafg yaafu a` |cg

eygfo|had `oehmh|hgu zgyg falh`hgl ua |co| ~ga~mg zgyg |cgd

khmmgl- )jouugl) |cgyg zh|c Rxkmad I$ Gxgzh|dguu |gu|hfadx colh| |co| |cgyg zou o cafhehlom )jou ecofigy) maeo|gl hd

Eygfo|ayx H a` |cg Fohd Eof~!Owueczh|r H- odl o| Ihykgdow-

oiaw| ?$7 fhmgu `yaf Owueczh|r- |cgyg zgyg uw~~augl |a copg

iggd `awy fayg cafhehlom )jou ecofigyu) hd Eygfo|ayhgu HH

|cyawjc P- ou zgmm ou hd |za `oyf cawugu- uohl |a copg iggd

maeo|gl aw|uhlg |cg eof~ h|ugm` odl falh`hgl `ay cafhehlom

jouuhdj ~wy~augu$

Daz yaafu ay ecofigyu zcgyg ema|chdj- igllhdj- g|eg|gyo zgyg

lgmawugl zh|c Rxkmad I zgyg u|hmm hd gshu|gdeg o| |cg emaug a` |cg

9>|c egd|wyx- odl |cg ayhjhdom Jgyfod iwhmlhdj ~modu hlgd|h`x

uwec yaafu ou )Joukoffgy) ay jou ecofigy & |cg |gyf zchec

zou wugl o| |co| |hfg `ay zco| zg zawml eomm lhuhd`gu|o|had

`oehmh|hgu$ \cgug lgmawuhdj ecofigyu zgyg gqwh~~gl zh|cohymaeku- odl col |za yawdl a~gdhdju oiaw| 9> hdecgu hd

lhofg|gy hd |cghy eghmhdj joimgu zchec zgyg `h||gl zh|c od ohy

hd|okg odl gscowu| pgd|hmo|ay$ \cg yaa` col |cygg pgd|hmo|had

lwe|u odl |cgyg zgyg |cygg u|apgu ay `wydoegu hd |cgug

ecofigyu lwyhdj |cg |hfg |cgx zgyg ighdj wugl$ Ua |chu

)Joukoffgy) ug|&w~ zh|c cgo|hdj odl pgd|hmo|had- fwu| copg

iggd eaduhlgygl |cg fhdhfwf ygqwhygfgd|u `ay uo`gmx

7/31/2019 Russ Granata: A Critical Analysis of the Official View of Auschwitz in light of Chemistry and Technology

8/28

>0!>0!>8 ?:2>>Faueaz Ead`gygdeg & 9>>9

^ojg 3 uwy 93

lhuhd`gu|hdj |chdju$

Daz ou `oy ou o cafhehlom jou ecofigy hd Owueczh|r H Fohd

Eof~- |cgyg oyg gxgzh|dguu oeeawd|u iw| |cgyg hu da fo|gyhom ay

laewfgd|oyx gphlgdeg `ay h|*u gshu|gdeg- odl gpgd |cggu|oimhucfgd|*u a``hehom chu|ayhod ^yguuoe chfugm` u|o|gu |co| |cg

`aygfau| ecoyoe|gyhu|heu a` |cg gxgzh|dguu oeeawd|u oyg |cghy

ead|yolhe|hadu- |gecdheom hf~auuhihmh|hgu- odl hdeyglhihmh|x$ Mg|*u

rgya hd ad |cg Rxkmad I hd~w| co|ecgu odl |cg pgd|hmo|had camgu

a` |chu )cafhehlom jou ecofigy$ O| |cg u|oy| a` |cg zoy- |cg

`maay ~mod a` |cg iwhmlhdj ucazu h| zou lguhjdgl odl

eadu|ywe|gl ou od aylhdoyx eygfo|ayhwf zh|c o fayjwg$

\cg fayjwg hu uohl |a copg iggd falh`hgl |a ugypg ou o )jou

ecofigy) odl `ay |cg ~wy~aug a` hd|yalwehdj Rxkmad I hd|a |cg

ecofigy |a jou phe|hfu- 5 ay < co|ecgu oyg omua uohl |a copg

iggd ew| hd|a |cg yaa` mo|gy ad- ou zgmm ou ? ay 9 a|cgyu `ay

~azgy`wm pgd|hmo|ayu$ \cgd hd ?8

7/31/2019 Russ Granata: A Critical Analysis of the Official View of Auschwitz in light of Chemistry and Technology

9/28

>0!>0!>8 ?:2>>Faueaz Ead`gygdeg & 9>>9

^ojg 8 uwy 93

[o| Owueczh|rV hu `omug$)

Jgyfoy Ywlam` hdlheo|gu |co| |cgyg hu da eyglhimg gphlgdeg `ay

odx co|ecgu `ay |cg hd~w| a` Rxkmad I |a ommaz |cgug `oehmh|hgu |a

ig wugl ou cafhehlom )jou ecofigy) o| |cg |hfg a` |cghy ommgjglwug ou uwec$ Ay ou @ygdec ^ya`guuay Yaigy| @owyhuuad ~w| h|2

)Da camgu- da *Camaeowu|*$) Omua |cgyg hu da lhyge| gd|yodeg

`yaf aw|uhlg |cyawjc zchec |cg ommgjgl phe|hfu eawml copg

gd|gygl |cg ommgjgl cafhehlom )jou ecofigy) & |cgyg`ayg- |cg

gxg&zh|dguugu oyg hdeyglhimg & ay ou @ygdec ^ya`guuay Yaigy|

@owyhuuad ~w| h|2 )Da laayu- da *lgu|ywe|had*$)

\cg ua&eommgl )Jou Ecofigyu) a` Ihykgdow oyg hd yg`gygdeg |a

Eygfo|ayhgu HH odl HHH- odl |caug ua&eommgl )jou ecofigyu)

zgyg oe|wommx fayjwg `oehmh|hgu camlhdj eolopgyu ig`ayg

eygfo|had$

\cgug eygfo|ayho oyg eaf~oyoimg zh|c a|cgy ehphmhod eygfo|had

`oehmh|hgu iwhm| hd Jgyfodx o| |co| |hfg- ou zgmm ou zh|c falgydadgu- odl ojohd h| hu u|yguugl |co| |cgyg hu da eyglhimg gphlgdeg

`ay |cg hd~w| a` Rxkmad I `yaf |cg aw|uhlg- odl |cgyg zou

pgd|hmo|had iw| da cgo|hdj `oehmh|hgu$ Jgyfoy Ywlam` hdlheo|gu

|co| cg eademwlgu zh|c oiuamw|g egy|ohd|x |co| |cg ommgjgl hd~w|

co|ecgu zgyg da| ollgl wd|hm o`|gy |cg iwhmlhdju col iggd

imazd w~ & |co| hu- o`|gy |cg Jgyfod yg|ygo|$ Ua- cgyg ou zgmm-

|cg uoxhdj a` ^ya`guuay Yaigy| @owyhuuad2 )Da camgu- da*Camaeowu|* )$

Ygjoylhdj Eygfo|ayho HP odl P- |cgyg admx gshu|u o `gz

laewfgd|u- ou zgmm ou ead|yolhe|ayx- hdeyglhimg ua&eommgl gxg&

zh|dguu u|o|gfgd|u$ Bgod&Emowlg ^yguuoe cou iggd |cg admx

)Gs|gyfhdo|hadhu|) ow|cay zca cou ja||gd hd|a |chu |a~he `yaf

o |gecdheom u|odl~ahd|$ Oeeaylhdj |a ^yguuoe- |cg |za zgu|gyd-cgo|gl- wdhlgd|h`hgl ecofigyu- ou zgmm ou |cghy od|gyaafu- zgyg

7/31/2019 Russ Granata: A Critical Analysis of the Official View of Auschwitz in light of Chemistry and Technology

10/28

>0!>0!>8 ?:2>>Faueaz Ead`gygdeg & 9>>9

^ojg ?> uwy 93

uw~~augl |a copg ugypgl ou )jou ecofigyu-) iw| |cgyg hu da

gphlgdeg `ay odx pgd|hmo|had `oehmh|x `ay |cgug yaafu ig`ayg Fox

a` ?8

7/31/2019 Russ Granata: A Critical Analysis of the Official View of Auschwitz in light of Chemistry and Technology

11/28

>0!>0!>8 ?:2>>Faueaz Ead`gygdeg & 9>>9

^ojg ?? uwy 93

|caug pgyx gs~gduhpg `oehmh|hgu gsemwuhpgmx hd Owueczh|r |a uopg

mhpgu igeowug h| zou kdazd |co| mheg eoyyhgl |cg lgolmx |x~cwu$

A` eawyug hd ~yhdeh~mg- gpgyx yaaf eawml ig eaduhlgygl ou o

~a|gd|hom lgmawuhdj `oehmh|x- iw| gpgd o ~yhfh|hpg `oehmh|x zawmlcopg iggd gqwh~~gl zh|c od gscowu| pgd|hmo|ay odl a`|gd gpgd

zh|c o cgo|hdj uxu|gf zchec hu da| fodlo|ayx- iw| da yaaf

zchec col da pgd|hmo|had uxu|gf eawml ig ugyhawumx eaduhlgygl

|a copg `wde|hadgl ou o cafhehlom jou ecofigy- odl `ay

gsgew|had jou ecofigyu- |cgyg fwu| ig o zox a` hd|yalwehdj |cg

~ahuad jou `yaf |cg aw|uhlg$ Daz- |cg Owueczh|r Eadegd|yo|had

Eof~ hu uw~~augl |a copg col |co| ua&eommgl )jou ecofigy) hdzchec |cg fau| ~ga~mg zgyg uw~~augl |a copg iggd khmmgl zh|c

~ahuad jou lwyhdj |cg Ugeadl Zayml Zoy2 Fay|woyx H a`

Eygfo|ayx HH- iw| Jgyfoy Ywlam` fokgu h| emgoy |co| h| hu od

gdjhdggyhdj egy|ohd|x |co|- ead|yoyx |a omm gxgzh|dguu |gu|hfadx-

|caug `oehmh|hgu col da Rxkmad I hd~w| a~gdhdju hd |cghy eghmhdj

lwyhdj |cg |hfg a` |cg ommgjgl a~gyo|had; |cgyg`ayg |chu yaaf

eawml da| copg iggd wugl `ay fouu fwylgy zh|c ~ahuad jou$

Eadegydhdj |cg `ayfo|had a` cxlyaexodhe oehl yguhlwg- |cg

ecgfhu| Jgyfoy Ywlam` ~ahd|u aw| |co| gpgd o iyhg` jmodeg hd|a

|cg ema|chdj lhuhd`gu|o|had ecofigyu a` Iwhmlhdju 7o odl 7i a`

Ihykgdow hffglho|gmx ucazu o ecgfhu| |co| zco| cg hu lgomhdj

zh|c hu o pgyx eaffad uwiu|odeg kdazd ou hyad imwg$ Hyad imwg

hu od gs|ygfgmx u|oimg eaf~awdl `ayfgl ix |cg hd|gyoe|had a`cxlyaexodhe oehl zh|c hyad ay `gyyawu exodhlg$ Hyad hu od

gmgfgd| zchec hu pgyx ~ygpomgd| hd do|wyg- aeewyyhdj fau|

eaffadmx ou `gyyhe ashlg ay ywu|; h| hu hd uodl wugl hd iwhmlhdj

fo|gyhomu- odl |co|*u zcx iwhmlhdj fo|gyhomu oyg `ygqwgd|mx

aecyg ay ygllhuc eamay$

\cg u|oihmh|x a` hyad imwg hu uafg|chdj zchec ecgfhu| Ywlam`omua fokgu emgoy$ H| hu od gs|ygfgmx u|oimg ~hjfgd| & hduamwimg

7/31/2019 Russ Granata: A Critical Analysis of the Official View of Auschwitz in light of Chemistry and Technology

12/28

7/31/2019 Russ Granata: A Critical Analysis of the Official View of Auschwitz in light of Chemistry and Technology

13/28

>0!>0!>8 ?:2>>Faueaz Ead`gygdeg & 9>>9

^ojg ?5 uwy 93

`ay lgmawuhdj- zh|c pgd|hmo|had- cgo|- odl ogyo|had echfdgxu- iw|

|cghy yo|cgy ufomm uhrg folg |cgf gs~gduhpg |a a~gyo|g$ \cgx

col od oygo a` oiaw| ?5> f9 odl o pamwfg a` o| mgou| > f9-

odl wuhdj |cg gd|hyg yaaf `ay lgmawuhdj zawml fgod ofawd|u

a` Rxkmad I ead|ohdhdj o| mgou| < |a 7 kj CED & ua h` |cgyg zouadg `wfhjo|had exemg ~gy lox- |cgug `oehmh|hgu omadg wugl w~ 5$0

|adu a` Rxkmad I o xgoy- zchec fgodu oiaw| com` a` |cg gd|hyg

ofawd| a` Rxkmad I zchec zou lgmhpgygl |a Owueczh|r hd ?8

7/31/2019 Russ Granata: A Critical Analysis of the Official View of Auschwitz in light of Chemistry and Technology

14/28

>0!>0!>8 ?:2>>Faueaz Ead`gygdeg & 9>>9

^ojg ?< uwy 93

|gu|hfadhgu$ \chu zou ~oy|mx ladg ig`ayg |cg eawy| uguuhadu- odl

|cg fodx )gxg&zh|dguugu) uhf~mx ea~hgl ay yg~go|gl zco| |cgx

col iggd cgoyhdj `yaf a|cgyu ay zco| |cgx col ygol$ Ou adg

~yaa` a` |chu zg ~ahd| aw| |co| zh|dguu yg~ay|u ojohd odl ojohd

eaduhu| a` |cg uofg hf~auuhihmh|hgu ay oiuwylh|hgu$ \zagsof~mgu2 ?$ |cg emgoyhdj aw| a` jou ecofigyu o`|gy od

hf~auuhimx ucay| ~gyhal a` |hfg&&odxzcgyg `yaf o `gz fhdw|gu

|a com` od cawy zou zco| |cgug zh|dguugu zgyg uoxhdj- zcgygou-

hd ygomh|x- h| zawml |okg o| mgou| |za cawyu `ay |cg Rxkmad I |a

gpo~ayo|g `yaf |cg jyodwmgu; |cgyg`ayg h| zawml |okg o| mgou|

|co| ofawd| a` |hfg `ay |cg ecofigy |a ig uw``hehgd|mx odl

uo`gmx emgoygl a` jou ua |co| zaykgyu eawml gd|gy h|$ 9$ Oda|cgygsof~mg a` zh|dguu oiuwylh|hgu hu |cghy |gu|hfadx a` eygfo|hdj

|cygg eolopgyu zh|chd `h`|ggd fhdw|gu hd adg eygfo|had fw``mg-

zcgygou |cg ygomhu|he lwyo|had hu adg cawy ~gy eolopgy$

Eadegydhdj |cg pomwo|had a` ecgfheom odomxugu- Jgyfoy Ywlam`

cou ~ahd|gl aw| |co| ig`ayg |okhdj uof~mg fo|gyhom `yaf |cg

ommgjgl )jou ecofigyu) a` Owueczh|r- h| hu hf~ay|od| |a ig uwyg|co| |cg fo|gyhom hu ayhjhdom- odl |co| ix jaal mwek- |cg )jou

ecofigy) #fay|woyx ?( a` Eygfo|ayx HH uwyphpgl moyjgmx hd|oe|-

odl |cg iwhmlhdj fo|gyhomu zgyg da| admx ayhjhdom- iw| zgyg omua

~yg||x zgmm ~ya|ge|gl$ Daz oeeaylhdj |a ^yguuoe odl |cg a``hehom

phgz- |chu zou uw~~augl |a copg iggd |cg fobay uh|g a` |cg

ommgjgl fouu fwylgy & |chu hu uw~~augl |a copg iggd |cg ~moeg

zcgyg |cg jouuhdju |aak ~moeg$ & Ua |okhdj uof~mgu cgyg huo~~ya~yho|g$ H` hyad imwg yguhlwg hu |a ig gs~ge|gl hd cafhehlom

)jou ecofigyu)- |cgd cgyg hu zcgyg adg ucawml u|yhkg ~ox lhy|-

ou Ywlam` ~w|u h|$ Cg ~ahd|u aw| |co| ua `oy |cgyg copg iggd 5

uof~mhdju zay|c fgd|hadhdj2 ix Mgwec|gy- Ywlam`- odl Iomm-

odl gdeawyojgu hd|gygu|gl ~gyuadu |a opohm |cgfugmpgu |a |cgug

uawyegu `ay lg|ohmu$

\cg yguwm|u a` |cg odomxugu hdlheo|g |co| ad |cg iouhu a` ead|yam

7/31/2019 Russ Granata: A Critical Analysis of the Official View of Auschwitz in light of Chemistry and Technology

15/28

>0!>0!>8 ?:2>>Faueaz Ead`gygdeg & 9>>9

^ojg ?7 uwy 93

uof~mgu adg eod aiugypg |co| |cg ommgjgl )jou ecofigyu) ucaz

|cg uofg eadegd|yo|hadu a` CED yguhlwg ou odx yodlaf

iwhmlhdj & hd a|cgy zaylu da| gdawjc eadegd|yo|had |a ig

ygmhoimx hd|gy~yg|gl- hu |cg zox Ywlam` ~w|u h|$ Odl cg ~ahd|u

aw| |co| |cg wdygmhoihmh|x a` maz exodhlg yguhlwgu hu omua ~yapgdix o uof~mg `yaf o eammo~ugl Iopoyhod `oyfcawug- zchec hu chu

uof~mg dwfigy 97 & zh|c |cg chjcgu| exodhlg mgpgm a` omm

uof~mgu a` |co| jyaw~$ Zcgd zg eaf~oyg |chu |a |cg yguhlwom

qwod|h|hgu hd |cg lgmawuhdj ioyyoeku yodjhdj `yaf ?->>> |a

?>->>> fj!kj- |chu fgodu |co| >$? |a ?' a` |cg ~mou|gy&&da| |cg

gd|hyg zomm/&&eaduhu|u a` exodhlgu$

Ywlam` ~ahd|u aw| |co| |cg zommu a` |cg lgmawuhdj iwhmlhdju oyg

uo|wyo|gl |cyawjc&odl&|cyawjc zh|c cxlyaexodhe oehl

eaf~awdlu&&uafg a` zchec igeafg phuhimg ou hyad imwg&&

gu~gehommx hd lof~ oygou a` |cg uwy`oegu igeowug a`

oeewfwmo|had$ \chu eod admx ig gs~mohdgl ou o yguwm| a`

`wfhjo|hadu zh|c CED$

Jgyfoy Ywlam` ~ahd|u aw| |co| eyh|heu Foykhgzher odl pod ^gm|

hjdaygl |cg uehgd|h`he `oe|u odl zyadjmx emohfgl |co| hyad imwg

zawml lhuo~~goy zcgd gs~augl |a gdphyadfgd|om eadlh|hadu-

odl cg hd`ayfu wu |co| hd ?888- ^ya`guuay Bofgu Ya|c `yaf |cg

Om~co Odomx|he Moiayo|ayhgu- zca hd ?883 col odomxrgl

Mgwec|gy*u uof~mgu- folg |cg hdeyglhimx yhlhewmawu ygfoyk |co|

cxlyajgd exodhlg eawml da| ~gdg|yo|g hd|a iwhmlhdj fo|gyhomulgg~gy |cod >$>? ff&&fgodhdj |co| omm exodhlg eaf~awdlu

fgouwygl zgyg uw~~augl |a copg iggd ad |cg uwy`oeg a` |cg

zommu$ Iw| Ywlam` ~ahd|u aw| |co| chu uof~mgu dwfigyu ??- ?5-

?:- ?8i odl 95 zgyg omm |okgd `yaf lgg~gy moxgyu a` |cg ~mou|gy

odl ~yapg ^ya`guuay Ya|c hu zyadj$ Uhdeg ~mou|gy odl fay|oy

oyg chjcmx ~ayawu- uwec o u|o|gfgd| hu wd|gdoimg odl Ywlam`

zadlgyu zcx o ^ya`guuay a` Odomx|heom Ecgfhu|yx zawml u~ygoluwec u|w~hl mhgu$

7/31/2019 Russ Granata: A Critical Analysis of the Official View of Auschwitz in light of Chemistry and Technology

16/28

>0!>0!>8 ?:2>>Faueaz Ead`gygdeg & 9>>9

^ojg ?0 uwy 93

\cg Jgyfoy Ywlam` eademwuhadu oyg |co|2

Gsofhdo|had a` |cg eadu|ywe|had a` |cg `oehmh|hgu ommgjglmx wugl

`ay |cg fouu jouuhdju cou ucazd |co| |cg ommgjgl fohd )jouecofigyu) a` Owueczh|r&&|cg fay|woyx a` |cg Fohd Eof~

eygfo|ayhwf- odl |cg fay|woyhgu ? #|cg )jou ecofigyu)( a`

Eygfo|ayho HH odl HHH&&col da ead|yhpodegu `ay |cg

hd|yalwe|had a` o ~ahuad jou uwiu|odeg$ \cg camgu phuhimg hd |cg

eghmhdju |alox zgyg ollgl o`|gy |cg zoy$ H` |cgug `hdlhdju

ygfohd wdyg`w|gl- |chu omadg ygdlgyu odx fouu jouuhdju- ou

|cgug copg iggd o||gu|gl |a- gd|hygmx hf~auuhimg$

\cg gsofhdo|had a` |cg `ayfo|had odl madj&|gyf u|oihmh|x a`

cxlyaexodhe oehl yguhlwg hd |cg zommu a` |cg `oehmh|hgu hd qwgu|had

#)jou ecofigyu) odl lgmawuhdj ecofigyu `ay fo|gyhom aibge|u(-

ou zgmm ou |cg hd|gy~yg|o|had a` |cg yguwm|u a` odomxuhu a` iyhek

uof~mgu `yaf |cgug `oehmh|hgu hd Owueczh|r- copg ucazd2

?$ Cxlyaexodhe oehl zchec ygoe|u |a `ayf hyad imwg hd |cg iyhek

zommu- g|e$ ygfohdu u|oimg `ay fodx egd|wyhgu$ H|u lhuhd|gjyo|had

ygqwhygu o |hfg `yofg uhfhmoy |a |co| a` |cg iyhekzayk h|ugm`$

\cgyg`ayg- exodhlg yguhlwg&&h` `ayfgl&&awjc| u|hmm |a ig ~ygugd|

hd phy|wommx wdlhfhdhucgl qwod|h|hgu |alox- ygjoylmguu a`

zgo|cgyhdj g``ge|u$ \cg aw|uhlg zommu a` |cg lgmawuhdj iwhmlhdju

IZ7o!i hd Ihykgdow- zchec oyg u|hmm imwg ad |cg aw|gy uwy`oeg|alox- ou zgmm ou ighdj chjc hd exodhlg ead|gd|- ugypg |a ~yapg

|chu$

9$ Wdlgy uwec eadlh|hadu ou zawml oe|wommx ig ~auuhimg- |cg

o||gu|gl&|a fouu gsgew|had jouuhdju zh|c cxlyaexodhe oehl

~yaioimx zawml yguwm| hd |cg yaafu hd qwgu|had gschih|hdj

exodhlg yguhlwg ad o uhfhmoy ueomg ou hu |cg eoug hd |cglhuhd`gu|o|had ecofigyu `ay fo|gyhom aibge|u- hdemwlhdj |cg

7/31/2019 Russ Granata: A Critical Analysis of the Official View of Auschwitz in light of Chemistry and Technology

17/28

>0!>0!>8 ?:2>>Faueaz Ead`gygdeg & 9>>9

^ojg ?: uwy 93

yguwm|od| imwg lhueamayo|had a` |cg zommu$

5$ Hd `oe|- cazgpgy- |cg ommgjgl )jou ecofigyu) gschih| admx

hduhjdh`heod| |yoegu a` exodhlg yguhlwg- ad |cg uofg aylgy a`

fojdh|wlg ou fox ig `awdl hd odx a|cgy iwhmlhdj$

\cgyg`ayg- h| hu |cg eadphe|had a` Jgyfoy Ywlam` |co| |cg admx

eademwuhad zchec eod gs~mohd omm `oe|ayu hdpampgl hu |co| hd |cg

`oehmh|hgu ommgjgl- da fouu jouuhdju zh|c Rxkmad I eawml copg

aeewyygl wdlgy |cg eadlh|hadu o||gu|gl |a ix ommgjgl

gxgzh|dguugu- eawy| zh|dguugu- bawydomhu|u- oeolgfheu ay a|cgy

~ya~ojodlhu|u$

Daz mg|*u fapg ad |a Eoyma Fo||ajda ygjoylhdj |gecdheom

ou~ge|u a` |cg eygfo|ayx apgdu a` Owueczh|r ou zgmm ou |cg jou

ecofigyu$

Eoyma Fo||ajda cou eyglh|gl @ygdec ^ya`guuay Yaigy|

@owyhuuad ou ighdj hd |cg podjwoyl a` ygugoyecgyu |a copgiyawjc| w~ |gecdheom ou~ge|u eadegydhdj ommgjo|hadu |co|

cafhehlom jou ecofigyu gshu|gl hd Jgyfod Zayml Zoy \za

eadegd|yo|had eof~u uwec ou Owueczh|r&Ihykgdow$

@owyhuuad da|hegl |co| hd dadg a` |cg bwlhehom eawy|u lwyhdj |cg

fodx |yhomu ojohdu| ua&eommgl Dorh zoy eyhfhdomu- col |cgyg gpgy

iggd o eomm `ay ~gy`ayfhdj od gs~gy| |gecdheom gsofhdo|had a`|cg ommgjgl zgo~ad a` |cg eyhfg & hd a|cgy zaylu o |gecdheom

u|wlx a` |cg ommgjgl cafhehlom jou ecofigy$ Ua cg chfugm`

igjod uwec o |gecdheom u|wlx- odl cg gpgd gsofhdgl o jgdwhdg

gsgew|had jou ecofigy hd od Ofgyheod ~gdh|gd|hoyx$ \chu zou

hf~ay|od|- igeowug ua&eommgl gs|gyfhdo|hadhu| chu|ayhajyo~cx

zou `wmm a` o uay| a` |cgamajheom lajfo|huf$ \chu lajfo|huf zou

gsgf~mh`hgl ix o jyaw~ a` @ygdec chu|ayhodu fokhdj od od|h&uehgd|h`he lgemoyo|had eadegydhdj ommgjgl Ch|mgyhod

7/31/2019 Russ Granata: A Critical Analysis of the Official View of Auschwitz in light of Chemistry and Technology

18/28

>0!>0!>8 ?:2>>Faueaz Ead`gygdeg & 9>>9

^ojg ?3 uwy 93

gs|gyfhdo|had ~amhehgu lwyhdj |cg Ugeadl Zayml Zoy$ Ou

yg~ay|gl hd |cg @ygdec dgzu~o~gy Mg Fadlg ad 9? @giywoyx a`

?8:8- |cgug chu|ayhodu folg |cg `ammazhdj lgemoyo|had2 )Zg

fwu| da| ouk awyugmpgu caz uwec o fouu fwylgy zou |gecdheommx

~auuhimg$ H| zou |gecdheommx ~auuhimg igeowug h| |aak ~moeg$ Uwechu |cg aimhjo|ayx ~ahd| a` lg~oy|wyg a` omm chu|ayhe hdpgu|hjo|had

ad |chu uwibge|$)

Zgmm- |co| o||gf~|gl |oiaa zou da| |a u|odl- odl zh|chd |co|

lgeolg- |cg @ygdec ~coyfoehu| Bgod&Emowlg ^yguuoe- om|cawjc

`owm|gl hd a|cgy zoxu- o| mgou| jopg |cg hf~yguuhad |co| cg

zod|gl |a |gecdheommx u|wlx |cg |a~heu a` jou ecofigy odleygfo|ayx hdu|ommo|hadu zh|chd Jgyfod zoy|hfg eof~u uwec ou

Owueczh|r$ ^yguuoe*u ?838 iaak ~wimhucgl hd Gdjmhuc zou-

Owueczh|r2 \gecdhqwg odl A~gyo|had a` |cg Jou Ecofigyu$ Chu

?885 iaak- ~wimhucgl hd @ygdec ouMgu Eygfo|ahyg l*Owueczh|r2

Mo Foechdgyhg lw fgwy|yg lg fouug- zou `ammazgl ix o ?880!>0!>8 ?:2>>Faueaz Ead`gygdeg & 9>>9

^ojg ?8 uwy 93

u|wlx a` |cg Owueczh|r&Ihykgdow eygfo|ayx apgdu fwu|

ead`yad| odl yguampg |za `wdlofgd|om |cgyfom & |gecdheom

~yaimgfu2 |caug a` eygfo|ayx eo~oeh|x- odl |caug a` eakg

eaduwf~|had$ ^yguuoe lagud*| uehgd|h`heommx ead`yad| gh|cgy a`

|cgug |za ~yaimgfu- iw| uhf~mx mhfh|u chfugm` |a o ugyhgu a`o``hyfo|hadu ueo||gygl cgyg odl |cgyg |cyawjcaw| chu zcamg

zayk- zh|c zchec cg ~yg|gdlu |a lgfadu|yo|g |co| |cg

eygfo|had eo~oeh|x a` Eygfo|ayhgu HH!HHH a` Ihykgdow zou a`

3>> ay ?->>> ialhgu ~gy lox- zh|c |cg ~auuhihmh|x a` od gs|gduhad

|a ?-> ialhgu ~gy lox- zh|c |cg

~auuhihmh|x a` od gs|gduhad |a :03$

Odl ou `ay |cg eaduwf~|had a` eakg hd |cg apgdu a` Owueczh|r&

Ihykgdow- ^yguuoe uoxu da|chdj$

Hd chuOwueczh|r2 \gecdhqwg odl A~gyo|had a` |cg Jou

Ecofigyu- ^yguuoe fohd|ohdu |co| `yaf O~yhm |a Ae|aigy a`

?8>> |a 9?7->>>ialhgu wuhdj

7/31/2019 Russ Granata: A Critical Analysis of the Official View of Auschwitz in light of Chemistry and Technology

20/28

>0!>0!>8 ?:2>>Faueaz Ead`gygdeg & 9>>9

^ojg 9> uwy 93

|cygg \a~` lawimg&ecofigygl apgdu a` |cg Owueczh|r

eygfo|ayx- zchec |cgyg`ayg ygqwhygl ad |cg opgyojg 5>$7

khmajyofu a` eakg `ay |cg eygfo|had a` adg olwm| cwfod eay~ug$

Ou o fo||gy a` `oe|- |cg \a~` |cygg odl ghjc|&ecofigygl apgduo| |cg Ihykgdow eygfo|ayhgu- a``gygl o |cgyfa&|gecdheom

olpod|ojg igeowug a` |cg zox |cgx zgyg eadu|ywe|gl- ua |cgx

zgyg oimg |a eadu~hewawumx yglweg `wgm eaduwf~|had$ @ay

gsof~mg- `ay |cg eygfo|had a` adg cwfod eay~ug- |cg |cygg&

ecofigygl apgd ygqwhygl |zgd|x khmajyofu a` eakg- zchmg |cg

ghjc|&ecofigygl apgd ygqwhygl `h`|ggd khmajyofu a` eakg$ \cgug

dwfigyu yg`gy |a gfoeho|gl olwm| eay~ugu$ Daz h` zg zgyg |a~au|wmo|g |co| |cgyg ygommx zgyg cafhehlom jouuhdju- |cgd |cg

fhdhfwf |cgayg|heom eakg eaduwf~|had o| |cg Ihykgdow

eygfo|ayhgu zawml copg opgyojgl |chy|ggd khmajyofu- eaf~oygl

|a |cg 9$0 khmajyofu ouuwfgl ix ^yguuoe$

Mg| wu daz |okg w~ |cg qwgu|had a` eygfo|had eo~oeh|x a` |cg

eygfo|ayhgu$

\cg opgyojg lwyo|had a` adg eygfo|had zou o~~yashfo|gmx adg

cawy hd |cg \a~` apgdu o| Owueczh|r&Ihykgdow$ \cgug apgdu

zgyg ~moddgl odl eadu|ywe|gl `ay |cg eygfo|had a` adg uhdjmg

ialx o| o |hfg$ Hd `oe|- |cg ufomm cawymx cgo| opohmoihmh|x a`

|cgug apgdu folg h| hf~auuhimg |a oechgpg geadafheommx

olpod|ojgawu eygfo|hadu ix |yxhdj |a eygfo|g |za ay faygeolopgyu |ajg|cgy & ia|c hd |gyfu a` eakg eaduwf~|had- ou zgmm

ou lwyo|had$ \cgyg`ayg- uhfwm|odgawu eygfo|hadu a` `awy ialhgu

~gy cawy- ou ^yguuoe fohd|ohdu- zou `ay omm |cg fayg ygouad-

|gecdheommx hf~auuhimg$ Omua zg fwu| ygfgfigy |co|

`wde|hadhdj a` |cg eygfo|had apgdu ygqwhygl lazd&|hfg & o

~owug a` o| mgou| `awy cawyu ~gy lox |a emgod eakg umoj `yaf |cg

jyhmmu; |cgyg`ayg |cg foshfwf eo~oeh|x a` |cg Owueczh|r&Ihykgdow eygfo|had apgdu eawml da| ~auuhimx copg iggd fayg

7/31/2019 Russ Granata: A Critical Analysis of the Official View of Auschwitz in light of Chemistry and Technology

21/28

>0!>0!>8 ?:2>>Faueaz Ead`gygdeg & 9>>9

^ojg 9? uwy 93

|cod ?-> ialhgu ~gy lox$

Hd |cg ^yguuoe cx~a|cguhu a` |cg ygomh|x a` cafhehlom jouuhdju-

|okhdj hd|a oeeawd| |cg ~gyegd|ojg a` hd`od|u odl echmlygd

ofadj |cg jouugl ~gyuadu- odl eaduhlgyhdj |cghy opgyojgzghjc| hd `wde|had a` ojg- |cg lohmx eygfo|had eo~oeh|x eawml

copg iggd owjfgd|gl uafgzco| yguwm|hdj hd ?-9> ~yhuadgyu ~gy lox ofadj od opgyojg

`aygeou|gl eof~ ~a~wmo|had a` 9>>->>>$ Ua |cg eygfo|had

eo~oeh|x a` |cg eygfo|ayhgu zou |cgyg`ayg qwh|g olgqwo|g `ay|cg ~yabge|gl hdeygoug a` |cg eof~ ~a~wmo|had zh|chd |cg

`aygeou| a` o ~auuhimg \x~cwu g~hlgfhe$

A` eawyug oiu|yoe|mx- h| eawml ig aibge|gl |co| o eygfo|had

eo~oeh|x a` ?-> eolopgyu ~gy lox ou ighdj gseguuhpg; cazgpgy-

ou o fo||gy a` `oe|- lwyhdj Owjwu| a` ?8> eygfo|had apgdu zchec col o foshfwf

eygfo|had eo~oeh|x a` >> eolopgyu ~gy lox- zchmg |cg

lgegougl lwyhdj |cg zcamg xgoy dwfigygl o~~yashfo|gmx?>9->>> ay od opgyojg lgo|c yo|g a` 93> ~gy lox; |cgyg`ayg |cg

7/31/2019 Russ Granata: A Critical Analysis of the Official View of Auschwitz in light of Chemistry and Technology

22/28

>0!>0!>8 ?:2>>Faueaz Ead`gygdeg & 9>>9

^ojg 99 uwy 93

Jgyfod eygfo|ayhgu col o foshfwf eygfo|had eo~oeh|x ?0!>0!>8 ?:2>>Faueaz Ead`gygdeg & 9>>9

^ojg 95 uwy 93

oeeaylhdj |a |cg Owueczh|rKomgdloyhwf- zou uw~~augl |a ig

aeewyyhdj o| od opgyojg a` ?-?>> ~gy lox$ Ua |cgyg`ayg- h` |cg

eygfo|had a` cafhehlommx jouugl ~gyuadu zgyg da| `aygeou|gl ix

|cg Iowmgh|wdj- |co| fgodu |co| |cgyg zgyg da| odx cafhehlom

jouuhdju/

\cg ugeadl ~yaa` cou |a la zh|c |cg ?8

7/31/2019 Russ Granata: A Critical Analysis of the Official View of Auschwitz in light of Chemistry and Technology

24/28

>0!>0!>8 ?:2>>Faueaz Ead`gygdeg & 9>>9

^ojg 9< uwy 93

eygfo|ayhgu a` Ihykgdow$ Zgmm- |chu dwfigy a` eygfo|hadu

ola~|gl ix ^yguuoe hu uhf~mx |gecdheommx hf~auuhimg$ Gdjhdggy

Ywlam` Bokaiuk||gy- u~gokhdj hd ?8

7/31/2019 Russ Granata: A Critical Analysis of the Official View of Auschwitz in light of Chemistry and Technology

25/28

>0!>0!>8 ?:2>>Faueaz Ead`gygdeg & 9>>9

^ojg 97 uwy 93

\cg iouhe ~au|wmo|had a` ^yguuoe odl |cg a``hehom phgz- hu |co|

Eygfo|ayhgu HH odl HHH zgyg ~moddgl odl eadu|ywe|gl ou

dayfom cxjhgdhe!uodh|oyx hdu|ommo|hadu- iw| |cgd zgyg

|yodu`ayfgl hd|a eyhfhdom cafhehlom jou ecofigyu$ Zgmm- |cgyghu da lawi| |co| w~ |a |cg gdl a` ?8

uqwoyg fg|gy jou ecofigy & |cg uhrg a` Mghecgdkgmmgy ? & hd|a

zchec h| zawml ig ~auuhimg- oeeaylhdj |a ^yguuoe- |a cafhehlommx

jou ?-3>> phe|hfu zh|caw| lh``hewm|x #ua&eommgl gxg&zh|dguu

|gu|hfadx gpgd u~gok a` 5->>> phe|hfu o| o |hfg/( & |co| zawmlcopg ygqwhygl :7 ecofigyu hdu|gol a` |cg gshu|hdj ?7- bwu| `ay

|cg eygfo|had a` |cg eay~ugu a` adg lox$ Odl |cg |hfg ygqwhygl

|a eygfo|g |cg ialhgu a` |cg phe|hfu zawml copg |okgd `hpg loxu

& zchec- |a uox |cg mgou|- zawml copg yguwm|gl hd adg jhod|

ia||mgdgek |a od hdlwu|yhom&|x~g fouu gs|gyfhdo|had ~yaeguu-

ygdlgyhdj |co| hf~auuhimg$ \cgyg`ayg- |cg `oe| |co| |cg

eygfo|ayx yaaf zou da| falh`hgl ix ollhdj fayg eygfo|hadapgdu- hdlheo|gu |co| o iougfgd| falh`heo|had zou da| eyhfhdom$

7/31/2019 Russ Granata: A Critical Analysis of the Official View of Auschwitz in light of Chemistry and Technology

26/28

>0!>0!>8 ?:2>>Faueaz Ead`gygdeg & 9>>9

^ojg 90 uwy 93

^yguuoe odl |cg a``hehom phgz fohd|ohd |co| Eygfo|ayhgu HH odl

HHH zgyg ~moddgl odl eadu|ywe|gl ou dayfom cxjhgdhe!uodh|oyx

hdu|ommo|hadu iw| |cgd |yodu`ayfgl hd|a fwylgy foechdgu- zg

`hdl |co| o`|gy ommgjglmx ighdj |yodu`ayfgl- zg `hdl |co| |cgeygfo|ayx apgd yaafu a` |caug |za eygfo|ayhgu u|hmm col |cg

uofg dwfigy a` eygfo|had apgdu zchec col iggd ~moddgl `ay o

~yhuadgy lgo|c yo|g lwg |a do|wyom eowugu & odl zg `hdl |co| |cg

pgd|hmo|ayu a` Fayjwg Egmmoy ? u|hmm col |cg uofg eo~oeh|x zchec

col iggd ~moddgl `ay ygjwmoy fay|woyx yaafu$ Ua & bwu| zcgyg

hu |cg ua&eommgl eyhfhdom |yodu`ayfo|had a` |cg eygfo|ayhgu1 Zg

eademwlg |co| |cgyg zou da eyhfhdom |yodu`ayfo|had a` |cgeygfo|ayhgu$ Ojohd & ua fwec `ay |cg a``hehom phgz$

Om|cawjc |cg ua&eommgl )zh|dguugl) fouu eygfo|had a` eolopgyu

ommgjgl |a copg aeewyygl lwyhdj |cg U~yhdj odl Uwffgy a`

?8>->>> |a apgy >->>> Cwdjoyhod Bgzu zchec hu ~wy~ay|gl

|a copg aeewyygl zh|chd |cg u~od a` 79 loxu ig|zggd Fox odl

Bwmx a` ?8

7/31/2019 Russ Granata: A Critical Analysis of the Official View of Auschwitz in light of Chemistry and Technology

27/28

>0!>0!>8 ?:2>>Faueaz Ead`gygdeg & 9>>9

^ojg 9: uwy 93

\cg Owueczh|r Eof~ zou o cwjg zayk eof~- ay fayg ~ygehugmx

lgueyhigl- Owueczh|r zou o eaf~mgs a` zayk eof~u- zcgyg

fodx ~ga~mg uw``gygl odl lhgl- odl da| admx Bgzu$

Coylmx odxadg kdazu `ay gsof~mg |co| o| Owueczh|r oiaw|

?>->>> Uaphg|!Ywuuhod ~yhuadgyu a` zoy ~gyhucgl; iw| hd |cg

~ya~ojodlo- Bgzu oyg |cg admx adgu fgd|hadgl- odl |cghy

dwfigyu oyg jygo|mx gsojjgyo|gl$

Igeowug Owueczh|r ~moxu uwec o lafhdod| yamg hd |cg

~ya~ojodlo pgyuhad a` |cg )Camaeowu|-) |caug zca oyghd|gygu|gl hd kgg~hdj w~ |cg fx|camajx a` |cg |yolh|hadom phgz

a` Owueczh|r- zhmm da| jhpg w~ zh|caw| o `hjc|$ \cgx zhmm kgg~

qwhg| oiaw| uehgd|h`he `hdlhdju ou madj ou ~auuhimg$ \cgx zhmm

aw|moz lhuewuuhad odl hdu|omm yg~yguuhad$ Jgyfoy Ywlam`- mhkg

Byjgd Jyo`- `hdl |cgfugmpgu ou gshmgu$ H` |cgx zgyg |a yg|wyd |a

|cghy do|hpg eawd|yhgu Jgyfodx odl Uzh|rgymodl- |cgx zawml ig

bohmgl `ay hdeh|hdj |cg ~ga~mg & Pamkupgycg|rwdj$

H ~yglhe| |chu zhmm uaad ecodjg$

Fox fx jyodlechmlygd ygol a` |cgf ofadj |cg chu|ayheom

da|oimgu a` awy ojg/

Molhgu odl jgd|mgfgd- H |codk xaw `ay xawy khdl o||gd|had- odlzhuc xaw zgmm$

7/31/2019 Russ Granata: A Critical Analysis of the Official View of Auschwitz in light of Chemistry and Technology

28/28

>0!>0!>8 ?:2>>Faueaz Ead`gygdeg & 9>>9

Faueaz Ead`gygdeg Uecglwmg

c||~2!!zzz$ywuujyodo|o$eafg&fohm2 hd`aNywuujyodo|o$eaf

^AI 9?9:< WUO

http://web.archive.org/web/20020601114546/http://russgranata.com/moscow-schedule.htmlhttp://web.archive.org/web/20020601114546/http://www.russgranata.com/mailto:info@russgranata.comhttp://web.archive.org/web/20020601114546/http://www.russgranata.com/mailto:info@russgranata.comhttp://web.archive.org/web/20020601114546/http://russgranata.com/moscow-fire-regs.jpghttp://web.archive.org/web/20020601114546/http://russgranata.com/moscow-schedule.html