b
[gy
thdjhd;kf(MYTH
VA
y;fiyf;f
[Ref.N
kd;
Raj(n
dk;ghoff; TWf
HS FACTAANAM
Hf epjpeyepfH;j;jg;b
K
DAss
No.:MRP-
ddh; rung
ah Serfojinjrpaj; ju k
f; fhyfSk; bTOR AN
MBAADI
y;iff; FGbgw;w FW
Kidth; k
Dr. M. GOsociate Pr5670/2015
jkpH; ca
Departm
ghrp muR
i GovernmkWkjpg;gPl;L
j";rht{
Thanjav
rdt
Janua
g; g[Jf;btspg;g
ND ITS EI PERIO
Gtpd; (SE
We;jpl;l M
kh.nfhtpe;
OVINDARrofessor of5/SERO-U
auha;t[ ika
ment of Tam
Rf; fy;Y]
ment ColleLf; FGthy; “
t{h;-613 00
vur-613 00
thp - 2020
ary – 2020
f;ftpijghl;L
EXPRESOD POET
ERO-UGC
Ma;t[ - M
juhR
RAJU f Tamil
UGC/Janu
ak;
mil
]hp (jd;d
ege (Auton“A” jFjp bg
05
05
0
jfspy;cj;jpf
SSIONS TRY)
) epjpa[jtMRP]
ary-2015]
dhl;rp)
nomous) gw;wJ)
y fSk;
IN
tpa[ld;
Kidth; kh.nfhtpe;juhR/
,izg; nguhrphpah;/
jkpH; cauha;t[ ikak;/
kd;dh; runghrp muRf; fy;Y]hp (jd;dhl;rp)/
(njrpaj; ju kWkjpg;gPl;Lf; FGthy; “A” jFjp bgw;wJ)
j";rht{h; - 613 005.
Ma;thsh; cWjpbkhHp
ehd;/ gy;fiyf;fHf epjpey;iff; FGtpd; (SERO-UGC) epjpa[jtpa[ld;
“thdk;ghof; fhyg; g[Jf;ftpijfspy; bjhd;kf; TWfSk; btspg;ghl;L
cj;jpfSk;” (MYTHS FACTOR AND ITS EXPRESSIONS IN
VAANAMBAADI PERIOD POETRY) vd;Dk; jiyg;gpy; 2015 rdthp Kjy;
FWe;jpl;l Ma;tpid (Ref.No.MRP-5760/2015/SERO-UGC/January-2015)
nkw;bfhz;nld;. ,e;j Ma;tpy; brhy;yg;gl;l jut[fs; midj;Jk; vd; brhe;j
Kaw;rpahy; nrfhpf;fg;bgw;witahFk;. ,e;j Ma;t[j; jiyg;gpy; xU gFjpnah
gy gFjpfnsh ntW ve;jg; gl;lj;jpw;fhft[k; mspf;fg;gltpy;iy vd;Wk; ,e;j
Ma;ntL vd; brhe;j Kaw;rpahy; vGjg;bgw;wJ vd;Wk; cWjpaspf;fpd;nwd;.
,lk; : j";rht{h;
ehs; :
(kh.nfhtpe;juhR)
ed;wpa[iu
“thdk;ghof; fhyg; g[Jf;ftpijfspy; bjhd;kf; TWfSk; btspg;ghl;L
cj;jpfSk;” vd;Dk; jiyg;gpy; FWe;jpl;l Ma;t[ (MRP) nkw;bfhs;s
mDkjpaspj;J epjpey;ifa[k; bra;j gy;fiyf;fHf epjpey;iff; (UGC-SERO)
FGtpdh;f;F kdkhh;e;j ed;wpia chpj;jhf;fpf; bfhs;fpnwd;.
,e;j Ma;tpid nkw;bfhs;s mDkjpaspj;j ghujpjhrd;
gy;fiyf;fHfj; Jiznte;jh;/ gjpthsh;/ njh;t[ bewpahsh;/ ,af;Feh;
Mfpnahh;f;Fk; ed;wp.
,e;j Ma;tpidr; bra;tjw;F Cf;fkspj;J Mnyhridfis tH';fp
te;j j";rht{h; kd;dh; runghrp muRf; fy;Y]hp (jd;dhl;rp) Kjy;th;fs;
Kidth; f.md;g[ mth;fs;/ Kidth; nrh.md;gHfd; mth;fs;/ Kidth;
jp.mwpt[ilek;gp mth;fs;/ Kidth; bt.bre;jkpH;bry;tp mth;fs;
Mfpnahh;f;F csk;epiwe;j ed;wpa[k; tzf;fKk;.
jkpH;j;Jiwj; jiyth; Kidth; J.nuhrp mth;fSf;Fk; ed;wp. IQAC
xU';fpizg;ghsh; Kidth; gp.khhpag;gd; (cjtpg; nguhrphpah; kw;Wk;
tpy';fpay; Jiwj; jiyth;) mth;fSf;Fk; ed;wp.
Ma;t[j; jiyg;gpidj; njh;e;bjLg;gjpypUe;J vGjp Kof;Fk; tiu
cWJizahf ,Ue;j jkpH;j;Jiw cjtpg; nguhrphpah; Kidth;
bt.rj;aehuhazd; mth;fSf;F edp ed;wp.
thdk;ghof; ftpijfisj; bjhFj;j Kidth; n#.k";Rshnjtp
mth;fSf;Fk; mth;fis Mw;Wg;gLj;jpa ftp"h; rpw;gp mth;fSf;Fk; kpf;f
ed;wp.
Ma;tpidf; fzpdpj; jl;lr;R bra;J/ mHfpa fl;likg;gpy; tH';fpa
ehF fk;g;a{l;lh;!; epWtdj;jhh;f;F be";rk; epiwe;j ed;wpfs; gy.
RUf;ff; FwpaPl;L tpsf;fk;
,.g.j.k. ‐ ,e;jpag; gy;fiyf;fHfj; jkpHhrphpah; kd;wk;
c.M. ‐ ciuahrphpah;
N. ‐ Nj;jpuk;
bjh. ‐ bjhFjp
bjh.M. ‐ bjhFg;ghrphpah;
bjhy;.vGj;J. ‐ bjhy;fhg;gpak; vGj;jjpfhuk;
bjhy;.brhy;. ‐ bjhy;fhg;gpak; brhy;yjpfhuk;
bjhy;.bghUs;. ‐ bjhy;fhg;gpak; bghUsjpfhuk;
ed;. ‐ ed;D]y;
E]. ‐ E]w;gh
g. ‐ gf;fk;
gf;. ‐ gf;f';fs;
g.M. ‐ gjpg;ghrphpah;
bkh.bg. ‐ bkhHpbgah;g;ghsh;
nkyJ. ‐ nkny Fwpg;gpl;l E]y;
NCBH ‐ epa{ br";Rhp g[f; At[!;
bghUslf;fk;
,ay; gf;fk;
Ma;t[ Kd;Diu 1
,ay; 1. ftpij nehf;Fk; nghf;Fk; 7
,ay; 2. thdk;gho ,af;fk; - gpd;g[yk; 40
,ay; 3. g[Jf;ftpijfspy; bjhd;kf; TWfs; 68
,ay; 4. thdk;ghof; ftpijfspy; bjhd;kf; TWfs; 99
,ay; 5. thdk;ghof; ftpijj; bjhd;kKk; fUj;jpay;
btspg;ghLk;
142
Ma;t[ Kot[iu 165
gpd;dpizg;g[ 169
JizE]w; gl;oay;
Le<Ejv!
!
1/1/!olipqBl<!h{<hiMl<!!
! dzgqz<! yu<ouiV! olipqg<Gl<! keqk<ke<jlBl<! sqxh<Hl<! d{<M/!
klqp<olipq!lqgk<!okie<jlbieKA!-zg<gqb!-zg<g{!utr<gjtg<!ogi{<mKA!
osl<olipqk<! kGkqjbh<! ohx<Xt<tK/! ngk<kqbl<?! okiz<gih<hqbl<?! sr<g!
-zg<gqbl<?! nx! -zg<gqbl<?! gih<hqbl<! weh<! hz<ujg! -zg<gqb! -zg<g{s<!
osz<ur<gjth<! ohx<xqVh<hK! klqp<olipqbiGl</! hjpjl! fqjxf<k!
klqp<olipqbqz<! hjpjlbie! h{<hiMgTl<! gi{h<ohXgqe<xe/! -f<kh<!
h{<hiMgjtg<! g{<mxqb! Ou{<Mlieiz<! -zg<gqbr<gjt! Nb<U! osb<b!
Ou{<Ml</!!
!
! -zg<gqbk<kqz<!gVk<Kh<! Hzh<him<M!dk<kqgTt<!ye<X!okie<ll<!NGl</!
okie<ll<! we<hK! hjpb! -zg<gqb! ujggTt<! ye<xig! -Vf<kK/! nK!
gizh<Ohig<gqz<! outqh<him<Mk<! kqxeig! lixquqm<mK/! okie<llieK! himzqe<!
dm<gVk<Kg<gjt! outqh<hMk<kUl<! dt<T{IUh<! ohiVjtk<! kvUl<!
dt<Tjxh<!ohiVjtk<!kvUl<!osb<gqe<xK/!!
!
! -vilib{l<?!hivkl<?!niqs<sf<kqv!Hvi{l<?!sr<g!-zg<gqbl<?!gQp<g<g{g<G!
-zg<gqbl<?! gih<hqbl<! we! -kqgisl<?! -zg<gqbl<?! Hvi{l<! -ux<xqz<! uVl<!
LequIgt<?! kjzjl! lif<kIgt<?! Kj{jl! lif<kIgt<! lx<Xl<! -ui<gtqe<!
osbz<hiMgt<! wz<zil<! okie<ll<! NGl</! -f<kk<! okie<ll<! hjpjlbie!
-zg<gqbk<kqZl<! HKujg! -zg<gqbk<kqZl<! hbe<hMk<kh<hm<miz<! nf<kk<!
okie<lg<! %X! -zg<gqbk<kqe<! dm<gVk<kqje! outqh<hMk<Kl<! nz<zK!
dt<T{IUh<! ohiVjt! outqh<hMk<Kl<! nz<zK! dt<Tjxh<! ohiVjt!
outqh<hMk<Kl</!
!
! -kqgisl<! okimr<gq! -e<X! ujv! olipqbqz<! hjmg<gh<hMl<! hjmh<Hgt<!
njek<Kl<! klqp<h<! h{<him<cje! outqh<hMk<Kgqe<xe/! h{<hiM! olipqObiMl<!
-zg<gqbk<OkiMl<! -jbf<K! lg<gt<! uip<g<jgjbs<! osl<jlh<hMk<Kgqe<xe/!
-f<fqjzbqz<! -Vhkil<! F~x<xi{<cz<! Okie<xqb! HKg<guqjkgt<! olipqjb!
utIh<hKme<! klqp<h<! h{<him<cjeBl<! utIg<gqe<xe/! klqp<s<! sLkibk<kqz<!
gi{h<ohXl<! sqg<gz<gjtk<! kQIg<gUl<! HKg<guqjkgt<! OhiviMgqe<xe/!
2 HKg<guqjkgjt!l{qg<ogic?!wPk<K?!gsmkhx?!uiel<hic?!heqk<Ktqgt<?!J?!
n0?! gj{bipq! Lkzie! sqx<xqkp<gt<! sqz! ogit<jggTme<! utIk<Kt<te/!
-ux<Xt<! ‘uiel<hic’! -kpqje! fmk<kqbuIgt<! uiel<hic! -bg<gk<kqeI/!
-uIgt<! uiel<hic! -kpqje! uqjzbqzi! lmzig! outqbqm<M! lg<gtqmk<kqz<!
ogi{<M! OsIk<keI/! uqjzbqzi! uiel<hic! -kp<gtqz<! guqjkgTl<! guqjk!
lkqh<HjvBl<! outqbibqe/! uiel<hic! -bg<gk<kqeI! yOv! ogit<jgjb! –!
ohiKUjmjlg<! ogit<jgjbh<! hqe<hx<xqbqVf<kiIgt<A! leqkOfbk<kqje!
utIk<kiIgt<A! Hvm<sqjbg<! ogi{<miceiIgt<A! HKjljb! uvOux<xiIgt</!
-uIgtqe<! guqjkgtqz<! okie<lg<! %Xgt<! hz! -ml<ohx<Xt<te/! -f<kk<!
okie<lg<! %Xgt<! lg<gtqe<! h{<him<cjeBl<! lg<gtqe<! hqvs<sjegjtBl<!
hjxsix<Xgqe<xe/!!
!!
1/2/!Nb<uqe<!-e<xqbjlbijl!
! guqjkgjth<!hjmk<K!outqbqMukx<G!YI!-bg<gk<kqje!dVuig<gqk<!
kk<kl<! guqjkgt<! outquVukx<G! Yi<! -kpqje! dVuig<gqbuIgt<!
uiel<hicg<! guqRIgt</! -kp<! outqbQm<Ms<! oszUg<Gk<! kk<kl<! okijgjbh<!
hr<gtqk<K?! -kp<gjt! lg<gtqml<! -zuslig! –! uqjzbqe<xqk<! kf<keI/!
ohiVtQm<Ml<!Lgk<kie<!u{qg!Ofig<gqz<!-kp<gt<!okimr<Gl<!-f<k!dzgk<kqz<?!
uiel<hicg<! guqRIgt<! kk<kl<! ohiVtqjes<! oszU! osb<K! -kp<gjt!
outqbqm<meI! we<xiz<?! nkqz<! WOki! yV! Ofig<gl<! -Vg<g! Ou{<Ml</! nf<k!
Ofig<gk<kqje!outqh<hMk<k!uiel<hicg<!guqjkgjt!Nb<U!osb<b!Ou{<Ml</!
weOu!uiel<hicg<!guqjkgjt!Nb<U!osb<uK!-e<xqbjlbikkigqxK/!!
!
1/3/!Nb<Uk<!kjzh<H!
! uiel<hic! -bg<gk<kqeI! ‘uiel<hic’! -kpqje! fmk<kqeI/! 2:82! Nl<!
N{<M!Lkz<!2:94!Nl<!N{<M!ujv!24!N{<Mgt<!-br<gqeI/!-f<kg<!gizl<!
)2:82.2:94*!“uiel<hicg<!gizl<”!we<X!njpg<gh<ohXgqe<xK/!-f<kg<!gizk<kqz<!
33! -kp<gt<! outqbigqBt<te/! -ux<Xt<! outquf<k! guqjkbqe<! gVk<K?!
dVul<?! outqh<him<Mk<! kqxe<! Ngqbju! Nb<U! osb<bh<hm! Ou{<cbju/!
outqh<him<Mk<! kqxe<! &zl<! gVk<Kl<! ucuLl<! Hzh<hMk<kh<hMl</! dujl?!
dVugl<?!hcll<?!GxqbQM?!Lv{<?!okie<ll<?!nr<gkl<!Lkzie!outqh<him<Mk<!
kqxe<gt<! -Vg<gqe<xe/! -ux<xqx<G! dk<kq! we<X! ohbI/! -f<k! dk<kqgTt<!
Nb<Ug<! giz! wz<jz! gVkqk<! ‘okie<ll<’! lm<Ml<! Nb<Ug<G! wMk<Kg<!
3 ogit<th<ohXgqe<xK/! -f<kk<! okie<ll<! gVk<Kh<! Hzh<him<Mg<G! wr<rel<!
hbe<hMgqe<xK! we<hjk! NviBl<! ujgbqz<! -f<k! Nb<Uk<! kjzh<H!
“uiel<hicg<! gizh<! HKg<guqjkgtqz<! okie<lg<! %XgTl<! outqh<him<M!
dk<kqgTl<”!we<X!njlgqe<xK/!okie<lk<!kqxeib<U!leqkuqbz<?!dtuqbz<?!
kk<Kul<?!-zg<gqbg<!gVk<kqbz<!Ngqbux<jx!yVr<gqj{k<Kg<!gim<Mgqe<xK/!!
!
1/4/!gVKOgit<!!
! uiel<hic! we<El<! hxju! we<hOk! lqgk<! okie<jlbieK/! Neiz<!
-e<Xl<! -Vg<gqe<xK/! -zg<gqbk<kqz<! uVl<! okie<lg<! %Xgt<! njek<Kl<!
HKjlgOtiM!yh<hqMl<!ujgbqz<!dt<te/! weOu! “uiel<hicg<! guqjkgtqz<!
hjpjlBl<! HKjlBl<! ye<jxobie<X! siIf<Kt<te/! nf<kh<! hjpjlg<Gl<!
HKjlg<Gl<!-j{h<Hh<! hizligk<! okie<lg<!%Xgt<!uqtr<Ggqe<xe”!we<hOk!
-f<k!Nb<uqe<!gVKOgit<!NGl</!!
!
1/5/!Nb<uqe<!Ofig<gl<!!
! HKg<guqjkbqe<! olipq! NTjlg<Gl<! gVk<Ks<! osxqUg<Gl<! hbe<hMl<!
okie<lg<! %Xgjth<?! Hvm<sqjb! Wx<hMk<kUl<! sLkib! lix<xr<gjt!
Wx<hMk<kUl<! uiel<hich<! HKg<guqRIgt<! hbe<hMk<kqBt<teI! we<hjk!
outqh<hMk<KuOk!-f<kg<!GXf<kqm<m!Nb<uqe<!Ofig<gl<!NGl</!!
!
1/6/!Nb<U!n[GLjx!!
! yh<hQm<Mk<! kqxeib<U! LjxBl<! uqtg<gk<! kqxeib<U! LjxBl<! -f<k!
Nb<uqz<!Olx<ogit<th<ohXgqe<xe/!!
!
1/7/!Nb<U!wz<jz!!
! -Vhk<kqv{<M! uiel<hic!-kp<gtqz<! outquf<k! 5:2! guqjkgTt<! 287!
guqjkgt<!lm<MOl!-f<kg<!GXf<kqm<m!Nb<Ug<!gt!wz<jzbig!njlf<Kt<te/!!
!
1/7/2/!Lke<jl!Nkivl<!!
! Lz<jz! Nkue<?! HuqbvS?! sqx<hq! LkziOeiI! hjmk<k! 287!
HKg<guqjkgt<!Lke<jl!Nkivligg<!ogit<th<ohXgqe<xe/!!
!
4 1/7/3/!Kj{jl!Nkivl<!!
! uiel<hicg<! guqjkgjth<! hx<xqb! Nb<Ugt<?! kqxeib<U! F~z<gt<?!
Nb<Ug<Ogiju?! HKg<guqjk! okimIhie! kqxeib<U! F~z<gt<?! -kp<gt<?!
uiel<hic! -bg<gl<! lx<Xl<! -kp<<! okimIhie! lkqh<Hjv! F~z<gt<! Lkzie!
njek<Kl<!Kj{jl!Nkivl<!NGl</!!
!
1/8/!Nb<U!Le<Oeicgt<!!
2/ gkqI/lgiOkue<?!okie<ll<!(Myth)?!osz<zh<hi!hkqh<hgl<?!lKjv?!3119/!!
3/ O\/lR<StiOkuq?! liEml<! hicb! uiel<hic?! giu<bi! outqbQM?!
ose<je?!3115/!!
4/ Rieq?! uiel<hicgtqe<! guqjk! -bg<gl<! .! uvziXl<! hch<hqjegTl<?!
giu<bi!outqbQM?!ose<je?!3122/!!
5/ g/hR<sir<gl<?!okie<lk<!kqxeib<U?!ne<el<!outqbQM?!kR<siu,I?!3116/!!
-f<k! fie<G! kqxeib<U! F~z<gTl<! -f<kg<! GXf<kqm<m! Nb<Ug<G!
Le<Oeic!F~z<gtiGl</!
!
1/9/!Nb<uqz<!-bz<!hiGhiM!!
! “uiel<hicg<!gizh<!HKg<guqjkgtqz<!okie<lg<!%XgTl<!outqh<him<M!
dk<kqgTl<” we<El<!-f<kg<!GXf<kqm<m!Nb<U!Le<Ejv?!LcUjv!fQr<gzigh<!
hqe<uVl<!Jf<K!-bz<gtigh<!hGg<gh<ohx<X!Nvibh<ohXgqe<xK/!!
! -bz<!2/!guqjk!Ofig<Gl<!Ohig<Gl<!
! -bz<!3/!uiel<hic!-bg<gl<!.!hqe<Hzl<!
! -bz<!4/!HKg<guqjkgtqz<!okie<lg<!%Xgt<!!
! -bz<!5/!uiel<hicg<!guqjkgtqz<!okie<lg<!%Xgt<!!
! -bz<!6/!uiel<hicg<!guqjkk<!okie<lLl<!gVk<kqbz<!outqh<hiMl<!
!
1/9/2/! “guqjk! Ofig<Gl<! Ohig<Gl<”! we<El<! Lkz<! -bzqz<! guqjkg<!
gm<mjlh<H?! lvHg<! guqjk?! use! guqjk?! HKg<guqjk?! HKg<guqjk!
ohbIg<giv{l<?! HKg<guqjkg<G! OuX! ohbIgt<?! HKg<guqjkbqe<! -zg<g{l<?!
HKg<guqjk! ucul<?! HKg<guqjk! hiMohiVt<?! l{qg<ogicg<! gizk<kqz<!
HKg<guqjk?! wPk<Kg<! gizk<kqz<! HKg<guqjk?! HKg<guqjkjb! utIk<k!
-kp<gt<?! mie<gi! guqjk?! ja%! guqjk?! zqliqg<! guqjk?! g^z<! guqjk!
5 Lkzieux<xqe<! Okix<xLl<! nju! sLkibk<jk! Ofig<Gl<! hiIjuBl<!
gizf<OkiXl<!hz<OuX!lix<xr<gjt!njmf<k!Ohig<Gl<!uqtg<gh<ohXgqe<xe/!!
!
1/9/3/!“uiel<hic!-bg<gl<!.!hqe<Hzl<”!we<El<!-v{<miuK!-bzqz<!uiel<hic!
-bg<gk<kqe<! Okix<xl<?! nke<! Ofig<gl<?! uiel<hic! -kpqe<! Okix<xl<?! nK!
Okix<xl<ohxh<!hqe<Hzr<gt<?!Ogijubqe<!-zg<gqb!njlh<H!–!uiel<hic!-kp<!
uQXogi{<M! wPf<K! lqGutIs<sq! ohXkz<?! uiel<hic! njlh<H! ke<ezl<?!
nkeiz<! uQp<s<sq?! sqx<hqbqe<! -Xkq! Lbx<sq! we<El<! gVk<Kg<gt<! uqtg<gl<!
njmgqe<xe/!!
!
1/9/4/! “HKg<guqjkgtqz<! okie<lg<! %Xgt<”! we<El<! &e<xil<! -bzqz<!
HKg<guqjk!dk<kqgt<?! okie<ll<?! HKg<guqjkbqz<!-vile<?! sQjk?!-viu{e<?!
hi{<muI?!hiR<sijz?!ogtvuI?!ngzqjg?!Hk<kI?!g{<{gq?!likuq?!Ogiuze<!
Lkzie! okie<lg<! %Xgt<! -ml<ohx<Xh<! ohiVjth<! Hzh<hMk<Kl<! Ljx!
uqtg<gl<!ohXgqe<xe/!!
!
1/9/5/!“uiel<hicg<!guqjkgtqz<!okie<lg<!%Xgt<”!we<El<!fie<gil<!-bzqz<?!
-bx<jgk<! okie<ll<?! hqvtbl<! dVuikz<?! -vile<?! sQjk?! ngzqjg?! %eq?!
Wgjzue<?!GVs<Osk<kqvl<?! fte<?!klbf<kq?! sque<?! hiIukq?! hvlhkl<?! sqZju?!
=me<!Okim<ml<?!hi<ki?!Hk<kI?!niqs<sf<kqve<?!g{<{gq?!likuq?!kizim<M!Lkzie!
okie<lg<! %Xgt<! &zl<! outqh<hMk<kh<hMl<! ohiV{<jlgt<!
uqtg<gh<ohXgqe<xe/!!
!
1/9/6/! “uiel<hicg<! guqjkk<! okie<lLl<! gVk<kqbz<! outqh<hiMl<”! we<El<!
Jf<kil<!-bzqz<! ohiKUjmjl?! slki<ll<?! kQ{<mijl!ypqh<H?! Hvm<sq! osb<kz<?!
HKjl! hjmk<kz<?! ncjljb! fQg<Gkz<?! oh{<{cjljbh<! Ohig<Gkz<!
LkziejuBl<?! Dpz<?! jgb,m<M?! sijz! Ng<gqvlqh<H! -ux<jx! ypqk<kz<?!
oh{<[iqjl!OhSkz<?!Ohizqg<!guqRIgjtBl<?!Ohizqh<!h,siiqgjtBl<!siMkz<!
Lkzie! sLkib! uqpqh<H{IUg<! gVk<Kg<gTl<! Hvm<sqs<! sqf<kjeBl<!
ohiKUjmjlk<!kk<KuLl<!uqtg<gh<ohXgqe<xe/!!
!
6 ! Nb<U! LcUjvbqz<! -f<kg<! GXf<kqm<m! Nb<uqz<! g{<mxqbh<ohx<Xt<t!
ohiV{<jlgTl<! olb<l<jlgTl<! uqtg<gh<ohXgqe<xe/! nux<jxk<! okimIf<K?!
-f<k!Nb<uqx<Gh<!hqxG!Olzib<U!osb<ukx<gie!upqLjxgt<!gim<mh<hMgqe<xe/!!
!
! hqe<eqj{h<H!we<El<!-Xkqh<!hGkqbqz<!Nb<uqx<Gh<!hbe<hm<m!Lke<jl!
Nkivr<gTl<! Kj{jl! Nkivr<gTl<! ngv! uiqjsbqz<! kvh<ohx<Xt<te/!
Nb<Oum<ce<!-Xkqbqz<!Nb<Ug<Ogijubqz<!outquf<k”uiel<hicg<!guqjkgtqz<!
okie<ll<?! sqx<hqg<! guqjkgtqz<! okie<lg<%Xgt<”! we<El<! -v{<M! Nb<Ug<!
gm<Mjvgt<!-j{g<gh<!ohx<Xt<te/!!
!
!
-bz<!2!
guqjk!Ofig<Gl<!Ohig<Gl<!
!
!
2/1/!LgUjv!!
! -zg<gqbk<kqe<! nch<hjmg<! %Xgtig! d{Is<sq?! gx<hje?! ucul<?!
gVk<K!Ngqb!fie<Gl<!njlf<Kt<te/!-zg<gqbk<kqe<!ucul<! ohiKfqjzbqz<!
djvfjm?!osb<Bt<!we!-v{<M!ujgh<hMl</!osb<Bt<?!him<M?!guqjk?!himz<!
we<El<!osix<gt<!yVohiVt<!Gxqk<keuibqEl<?!nux<Xg<Gt<!Fm<hlie!ohiVt<!
OuXhiM!d{<M/!guqjk?!use!guqjk?!HKg<guqjk?!mie<gi!guqjk?!ja%!
guqjk?!ose<iqB!guqjk?!zqliqg<!guqjk?!zqoljvg<%!guqjk?!g^z<!guqjk?!
jaHe<!guqjk!weh<!hz!fqjzgtqz<!guqjkbqe<!ucu!utIs<sqh<!hcfqjzgt<!
klqp<olipqbqz<! gi{h<ohXgqe<xe/! -ju! -f<k! Lkz<! -bzqz<!
uqtg<gh<ohXgqe<xe/!!
!
2/2/!guqjk!ucul<!!
! hVh<ohiVt<! njek<kqx<Gl<! outqh<hjmbie! ucul<! d{<M/!
g{<[g<Gk<! okiqBl<! njek<Kh<! ohiVTg<Gl<! dVul<! d{<M/! g{<[g<Gk<!
okiqbikju!nVul<! NGl</! nVuk<jkBl<! olipqbiz<! gim<sqh<hMk<k! LcBl</!
olipqbqz<! hjmg<gh<hMl<! guqjkg<G! dVul<?! dt<tmg<gl<! -v{<Ml<!
-e<xq<bjlbikju/! dVul<! dt<tmg<gk<jks<! sqxh<hqg<Gl<A! dt<tmg<gl<!
dVuk<jks<! sqxh<hqg<g! Ou{<Ml</! yOv! gVk<K! hz! ucur<gtqz<!
outquVujkBl<!gi{Lcgqe<xK/!
!
! -zg<gqbk<kqe<!dVuLl<!dt<tmg<gLl<! gizk<kqx<G! Wx<h! liXgqe<xe/!
-f<k! lix<xk<kqx<G!nvsqbz<?! ui{qgl<?! GMl<hl<?! uXjl?! Hvm<sq?! OhiI?! s&g!
lix<xl<?!sikq?!lkl<!Lkzie!hz<OuX!giv{qgTl<!&zr<gtig!njlgqe<xe/!
gz<uq?! Oujzbqz<zik<! kq{<mim<ml<?! hizqe! OuXhiM?! Dpz<?! N{ikqg<gl<?!
oh{<{ikqg<gl<?! nkqgiv! Nkqg<gl<?! kQ{<mijl! we<heUl<! -e<jxb! $pzqz<!
-zg<gqb!dVu!dt<tmg<gk<kqz<!Lke<jl!ohXgqe<xe/!!
!
! “guqjk!hx<xq!Nvib<f<k!Oleim<M!nxqRIgt<!hzVl<!guqjkjbg<!gV?!
dV! (Content and Form)! we! -v{<migh<! hqiqh<hI/! gqOvg<g! fim<Mg<!
8 guqjkbqbzitIgTl<! Ovil! fim<Mh<! hiuqbzitIgTl<! -k<kjgb! hqiqjuOb!
kr<gt<!Nb<uqz<!g{<Mt<teI/!hqOtm<Omi?!niq <̂mim<cz<!LkzqObiI!guqjkbqe<!
ohVl<! dXh<Hg<gtigg<! gV?!dV! we<hux<jxOb! %xqs<! ose<Xt<teI”2! wes<!
s/ngk<kqbzqr<gl<! guqjk! dVuig<gk<kqx<G! ucuk<kqe<! -e<xqbjlbijl!
Gxqk<Kg<! %Xgqe<xiI/! weOu! guqjkg<Gg<! gVk<Kl<! ucuLl<! dbqIficgt<!
NGl</!!
!
2/2/2/!lvHg<!guqjk!
! leqke<! fiOmicbib<! uip<f<k! gizk<kqOzOb! YjsBme<! %cb! him<M!
okimr<gquqm<mK/! fim<Mh<Hxh<! himz<! utIs<sqBx<X! -e<X! Wpqjsh<! h{<{ig!
dVouMk<kqVg<gqe<xK/! him<ce<! utIs<sqg<G! ujvbjx! Okie<xqbOhiK?! Yjs!
fbk<jkBl<! njs?! sQI?! kjt?! nc?! okijm! Ngqbux<jxBl<! hiGhMk<kq?!
ou{<hi?!Nsqiqbh<hi?!uR<sqh<hi?!gzqh<hi?!lVm<hi!we<El<!hiujggTl<!Kjx?!
kipqjs?! uqVk<kl<! we<El<! hiuqer<gTl<! dVuig<gh<ohx<Xt<te/! -f<k!
njlh<Hg<Gs<!‘osb<Bt<’!we<X!ohbiqmh<ohx<Xt<tK/!!
!
! hje! Yjzbqz<! wPk<ki{q! ogi{<M! lqg! uqiquig! wPk! -bzik!
giv{k<kiz<?! ‘SVr<gs<! osiz<zq! uqtr<g! juk<kz<’! we<El<! dk<kqh<hc?!
-zg<gqbl<?! lVk<Kul<?! uieqbz<?! Osikqml<! Lkzieju!njek<Kl<! osb<Bt<!
ucuqOzOb!-bx<xh<ohx<X!uf<Kt<te/!wPk<K?!njs?!sQI?!kjt?!nc?!okijm!
Lkzieux<xiz<!osb<bh<hMuK!‘osb<Bt<’!NGl</!!
!
! lVk<Kul<?! uieqbz<?! Osikqml<! Lkzie! gVk<Kg<gjtg<! %Xl<!
osb<Btqz<! d{Is<sqBl<?! gx<hjeBl<! njlbi/! -zg<gqbg<! gVk<Kg<gjtg<!
%Xl<!osb<Btqz<!d{Is<sqBl<!gx<hjeBl<!njlf<Kt<te/!d{Is<sq?!gx<hje?!
ucul<?! gVk<K! Ngqb! fie<Gl<! njlf<k! osb<Btqz<! guqjkk<! ke<jl!
)guqk<Kul<*!-Vh<hkiz<?!nkx<Gg<!‘guqjk’!we<X!ohbI/!!
!
! wPk<K?! njs?! sQI?! kjt?! nc?! okijm?! hi?! Yjs! we<El<! osb<Bt<!
dXh<HgTl<!hi!YjsBl<!ujvbjxObiM!njlf<K!uVuK!lvHg<guqjk!we<X!
upr<gh<hMgqe<xK/! wPk<K?! njs?! sQI! Lkzieju! ujvbjxbqe<xq! uVuK!
HKg<guqjk! we<X! upr<gh<hMgqe<xK/! lvhqjeh<! hqe<hx<xqh<! hjmg<gh<hMl<!
9 guqjkjb! ‘lvHg<! guqjk’! we<Xl<?! lvhqjeh<! hqe<hx<xilz<! hjmg<gh<hMl<!
guqjkjbh<!‘HKg<guqjk’!we<Xl<!lg<gt<!%Xgqe<xeI/!!
!
2/2/3/!use!guqjk!
! ns<S! -bf<kqvr<gTl<! gigqkr<gTl<! hbe<him<Mg<G! uf<k! hqxG?!
gVk<Kg<gt<! uqiquig! wPkq! outqbqmh<ohx<xe/! nju! djvfjmbigUl<!
useligUl<! outquf<ke/! djvfjmbqe<! uQs<S! usel<! NGl</! “usel<!
Ozigibk!d{<jljb!nch<hjmbigg<!ogi{<mK/!guqjk!le!ofgqp<s<sqjb?!
le! njsju! nch<hjmbigg<! ogi{<mK”3! we<X! usek<kqx<Gl<! guqjkg<Gl<!
dt<t!OuXhimig!f/hqs<s&Ik<kq!%Xgqe<xiI/!!
!
! usek<jkOb!guqjkk<!ke<jlBme<!hjmk<kiz<!nK!use!guqjkbig!
lixquqMgqe<xK/! Sh<hqvl{qb! hivkqbiI! kl<! -Xkqg<gizk<kqz<! hjmk<k!
“gim<sqgt<”! we<El<! kjzh<hqz<! njlf<Kt<t! -e<hl<?! RibqX?! sg<kq?! gix<X?!
gmz<?! uqMkjz! Lkzieju! use! guqjkgt<! NGl</! use! guqjk! hx<xq!
uqtg<Gl<! hizi?! “YvtU! lvHg<! guqjkbqe<! sibz<! gim<cOb! use! guqjk!
-br<gqbK/! osb<Bt<! ke<jl! ogiR<sLl<! gx<hje! fbLt<t! djvfjm!
ogiR<sLl<! -j{f<K! fjmOhim<me”4! we<X! olipqgqe<xiI/! guqjkh<! hiq{il!
utIs<sqbqz<!use!guqjkBl<!-ml<ohx<Xt<tK/!!
!
! use! guqjk! ofgqp<s<sqbieK?! -kqz<! ohVl<hizie! uiqgtqz<! okimI!
Lx<Xh<ohx<xqVg<Gl</!OlZl<!lvhqe<!kig<gLl<!-Vg<Gl</!Sh<hqvl{qb!hivkqbiiqe<!
use!guqjkOb!klqp<h<!HKg<guqjkg<G!Le<Oeicbib<!njlf<Kt<tK/!!
!
2/2/4/!HKg<guqjk!
! lvHg<!guqjkbqe<!ujvbjxjb!lQxqbKl<!Ohs<Sg<!%Xgt<?!djvfjmk<!
ke<jl?! guqjkk<! ke<jl! Ngqbux<jxg<! ogi{<mKl<! d{Ik<Kl<! dk<kq!
Ljxbqz<!HKjljbg<!ogi{<mKl<!HKg<guqjk!NGl</!!
!
! HKg<guqjk!osxquieKA!Lx<Xk<!okimIgt<!nkqgl<!-z<zikKA!njmk<!
okimIgjtBl<! ws<sk<! okimIgjtBl<! nkqgl<! ogi{<mKA! lvhqe<! kig<gl<!
Gjxuig!-Vg<Gl</!HKg<guqjk!outqh<him<M!Ljxg<G!weh<!Hkqb!dk<kqgt<!
-Vg<gqe<xe/! HKg<guqjk! SVr<gs<! osiz<zq! uqtr<g! jug<Gl<! ke<jljbg<!
10 ogi{<mK/! HKg<guqjkbqz<! nc! ujvbjx! -z<jzA! djvfjmk<! kig<gl<!
d{<M/!!
!
! ncujv! -z<zik! NX! osb<Bt<! ujggtigk<! okiz<gih<hqbI!
)okiz</ohiVt</578*! F~z<?! djv?! hqsq! )uqMgjk*?! LKolipq?! ljxolipq!
)lf<kqvl<*?! %x<xqjm! juk<k! Gxqh<H! Ngqbux<jxg<! %Xgqe<xiI/!
okiz<gih<hqbk<jkBl<!HKg<guqjkjbBl<!yh<hqm<M!Nvib<f<k!ou/-vk<kqe&Ik<kq?!
“-e<jxb!HKg<guqjk!him<M!we<x!osb<Bt<!ujgjbk<!kuqvh<!hqx!djvfjm?!
F~x<hi?! uib<olipq?! hqsq?! nr<gkl<?! LKosiz<! we<x! ncujv! -z<zik! NX!
osb<Bt<! ujggjtBl<! hbe<hMk<kqg<! ogit<gqxK”5! we<X! olipquKl<! -r<G!
Ofig<gk<kg<gkiGl</!!
!
! “HKg<guqjkg<G! Lkx<hc! use! guqjk/! -kqzqVf<K! SObs<si!
guqjkbigq!nMk<kg<!gm<mk<kqz<! HKg<guqjkbig!NeKkie<!guqjk!hiqli{!
liXkz<!nz<zK!kqVh<hl<”6! we<X! sq/S/osz<zh<hi! klqp<g<! guqjkbqe<! hiq{il!
utIs<sq!hx<xqg<!%Xgqe<xiI/!!
!
! djvfjmbqe<! uQs<sigUl<! use!guqjkbqe<! kig<gligUl<! HKg<guqjk!
uqtr<Gukiz<?!sqz!HKg<guqjkgtqz<!guqjkbqe<!ke<jljbuqm!djvfjmbqe<!
ke<jlOb! OlOzir<gqg<! gi{h<ohXgqe<xK/! lvHg<! guqjkbqe<!
bih<hqzg<g{k<jk! lQXukigg<! %Xl<! HKg<guqRIgtqz<! sqzI! olipqbqe<!
gm<mjlh<hqjeOb!lQxqBt<teI/!
!
! “-zg<g{l<! we<gqx! uqzr<GgtqzqVf<K! guqjkjbg<! g]<mh<hm<Mg<!
gpx<xquqm<mkiz<! guqjk! -h<OhiK! Skf<kqvl<! ohx<xqVg<gqxK/! nf<ks<! Skf<kqvl<!
-f<kqbiuqe<! Skf<kqvk<jkh<! Ohiz! wkqI! uqjtUgjtBl<! Wx<hMk<kqbqVg<gqxK!
we<hjk!wuVl<!lXg<g!LcbiK”7!we<X!juvLk<K!%XuKl<!lXg<g!Lcbik!
d{<jlbiGl</!
!
! gizf<OkiXl<! bih<hqzg<g{k<jk! lQxq! -zg<gqbl<! hjmh<hK! upg<glig!
dt<tK/!nf<k!upg<gl<kie<!HKg<guqjk!hjmh<hqZl<!fqgp<f<K!uVgqe<xK/!!
sqxqbgm<!ohxqOe!wlg<gQBl<!le<Oe!
ohiqbgm<!ohxqOe!
11
bil<himk<!kie<lgqp<f<K!d{<[l<!le<Oe!
sqXOsix<!xiEl<!feqhz!gzk<kz<!le<Oe!
ohVR<Osix<!xiEl<!feqhz!gzk<kz<!le<Oe!
we<ohiM!kchM!upqobz<zil<!wlg<gQBl<!le<Oe!
nl<ohiM!Ouz<Fjp!upqobz<zil<!kie<fqx<Gl<!le<Oe!
fvf<kl<!fiXl<!ke<jgbiz<!!
HzUfiXl<!we<kjz!jkuVl<!le<Oe!
nVf<kjz!-Vl<hi{I!nge<l{<jmk<!KjtBiQ-!!
-vh<OhiI!jgBTl<!Ohigqh<!!
Hvh<OhiI!He<g{<!hiju!Osiv!!
nR<osiz<!F{<OkIs<sqh<!HzuI!fiuqz<!
ose<XuQp<f<!ke<X!nue<!
nVfqxk<K!-br<gqb!OuOz!
NsiG!wf<jk!bi{<Mdte<!ogiz<Ozi!!
-eqh<hiMfVl<!-z<jz!hiMfIg<G!ye<X!=GfVl<!-z<jz!
heqk<Kjxh<!hge<jx!fjxg<ogit<!lilzI!
$miK!jugqbir<Gh<!hqxIg<G!ye<X!!
=biK!uQBl<!dbqIkuh<!hzOu8!
we<El<! HxfiE~x<Xh<! himjzh<! hicbuI! ytjubiIA! himh<hm<muI!nkqblie<!
ofMlie<! nR<sq/! nkqblie<! ofMlie<! nR<sq! OhiIg<gtk<kqz<! uQvlv{l<!
njmf<kohiPK!nue<!osbz<hiMgjt!w{<{q!ytjubiI!hiMgqe<xiI/!-f<kh<!
himz<! yh<hiiqh<! himz</! Kg<gl<! oki{<jmjb! njmg<Gl</! nkeiz<! yOv!
slfqjzbqz<! &s<S! uqm! -bziK/! -f<k! fqjzjb! -f<kh<! himzqz<! gi{!
Lcgqe<xK/!nkeiz<!-v{<M!sQI<gjtg<!ogi{<m!)3*!ncBl<?!&e<X!sQIgjtg<!
ogi{<m!)9?!22?!25?!26*!ncgTl<?!fie<G!sQIgjtg<!ogi{<m!)2?!4?!5?!6?!:?!
21?! 23?! 24?! 27?! 29?! 2:?! 31*! ncgTl<?! Jf<K! sQIgjtg<! ogi{<m! )7?! 8?! 28*!
ncgTl<! uqvuq! uf<Kt<te/! Neiz<! okimg<gLl<! LcUl<! fie<G! sQIgjtg<!
ogi{<m! ncgtig! njlf<Kt<te/! -f<kg<! gm<mjlh<hqz<! okiz<gih<hqbI!
gizk<kqz<! Nsqiqbh<hi! ujg! -z<jzA! hqx<gizk<kqz<! Okie<xqb! hqxG?!
bih<hVr<gzl<?! bih<hVr<gzg<giiqjg! Lkzie! bih<hqzg<g{! F~z<gt<! -kx<G!
‘-j{g<Gxt<!Nsqiqbh<hi’!we<X!ohbiqMgqe<xe/!!
fQiqe<!k{<jlBl<!kQbqe<!oul<jlBl<!
sivs<!siIf<K!!
12
kQvk<!kQVl<!!
sivz<!fime<!Og{<jl!!
sivs<!sivs<!siIf<K!!
kQvk<!kQvk<!kQIohiz<!ziOk9!
we<El<! -j{g<Gxt<! Nsqiqbh<hi! NX! Ncgjtg<! ogi{<mK/! -v{<M!
sQIgjtg<!ogi{<m!-v{<M!ncBl<?!&e<X!sQIgjtg<!ogi{<m!-v{<M!ncBl<?!
fie<G! sQIgjtg<! ogi{<m! -v{<M! ncBl<! nmr<gqb! -f<ks<! osb<Bjt!
Ofig<Gr<giz<?!HKg<guqjkbqe<!ucul<!nh<hcOb!gi{h<ohXgqe<xK/!
!
! sqzh<hkqgivg<! gih<hqbk<kqz<! djvh<him<Ml<! djvohX! gm<MjvBl<!
-ml<ohx<xqVh<hK!lvjh!lQxqb!osbziGl</!!
nm<miZl<!hiz<Sjubqx<!Ge<xi!ktutib<!
fm<miZl<!f{<hz<ziI!f{<hz<zI!
ogm<miZl<!Ole<lg<gt<!Ole<lg<g!Otsr<G!
Sm<miZl<!ou{<jl!kVl<:!
we<El<! fie<gc! ou{<hiuqz<?! ‘=x<xc! Ls<sQIA! Wjeb! nc! fix<sQI’! we<El<!
ou{<hiuqe<! uqkq! lQxh<hm<Mt<tK/! -f<k! ou{<hi!LkzcBl<!&e<xil<! ncBl<!
fie<G!sQIgt<! we<El<!LjxbqZl<!-v{<mil<!ncBl<! fie<gil<!ncBl<!&e<X!
sQIgt<!we<El<!LjxbqZl<!njlf<Kt<tK/!!
!
! -h<hcs<! sQI! Gjxf<K! uVl<! ou{<hiUg<G! uQvOsipqbl<! ‘sujz!
ou{<hi’21!we<X!ohbiqm<Mt<tK/!!
! ou{<hi?!Nsqiqbh<hi?!uR<sqh<hi?!gzqh<hi?!hiqhimz<?!lVm<hi!we<El<!hi!
ujggTl<! Kjx?! kipqjs?! uqVk<kl<! we<El<! hiuqer<gTl<! djvh<him<M?!
djvbqjmbqm<m! him<Mjms<! osb<Bt<?! sqf<Kh<! himz<gt<?! user<gt<?! use!
guqjkgt<?! HKg<guqjkgt<! NgqbjuBl<! klqp<g<! guqjkBzgqz<! Wx<hm<m!
utIsqjk!lix<xr<gt<!NGl</!!
!
! HKg<guqjk! hjmh<Hgt<! sqz! lvHg<! guqjk! -zg<g{k<jkh<!
ohx<Xt<te/!HKg<guqjkbqz<!wf<k!lix<xLl<!osb<bh<!ohxilOz!lvHg<!guqjk!
ucuk<kqz<!gi{h<ohXl<!HKg<guqjkgTl<!-Vg<gqe<xe/!!
gikz<!gikz<!we<hA!gikz<!!
ouxqBl<!OfiBl<!ne<OxA!fqjeh<hqe<!
13
-xg<gl<!Ofig<gqh<!hiBl<!fQvil<A!!
sikz<!guqf<k!uip<uqz<!!
uiel<!kf<k!uil!fqzuil</22!
sq/l{qbqe<! -f<kh<! HKg<guqjk?! ‘=x<xbzc! Ls<sQIA! Wjebc! fix<sQI’! we<El<!
bih<hqzg<g{k<jkg<! ogi{<m! ‘Ofiqjs! Nsqiqbh<hi’! we<El<! lvHg<guqjk!
ucuk<kqz<! njlf<Kt<tK/! -g<guqjkbqz<! Ofiqjs! Nsqiqbh<hiUg<Giqb! sQVl<!
kjtBl<!ncBl<!lqgs<!siqbig!uf<Kt<te/!!
gil!ouxqbiqe<!!
gt<t!Lbg<gOl!
gim<M!uqzr<gj{k<!kx<X/23!
! klqpe<heqe<! -f<kh<! HKg<guqjkbqz<! wPk<jkObi! osiz<jzObi!
okimjvObi!lix<xilz<?!Lkzqv{<M!ncjb!Yvcbig!lix<xqeiz<?!!
gil!ouxqbiqe<!gt<t!Lbg<gOl!!
gim<M!uqzr<gj{k<!kx<X!
we<El<! Gxt<! ou{<hi! ucul<! gqjmg<gqe<xK/! -f<k! njlh<hqz<! =x<xc!
Ls<sQviBl<! Lkzc! fie<G! sQviBl<! -Vf<K?! -bx<sQI! ou{<mjtBl<! ou{<sQI!
ou{<mjtBl<!giS!we<El<!uib<hiMl<!gi{h<ohXgqe<xe/!!
gikz<!!
lekqz<!gVk<kiqg<Gl<!!
uf<okkqi<g<Gl<!Olikjz!!
oue<X!LXuzqg<Gl<!
sikzqz<!%cs<!!
siqk<kqvl<!ogit<Tl<!!
Lcuqeqz<!hiceiz<!!
fQTOl!him<M/24!
S/-tr<Ogiuqe<!-f<kh<! HKg<guqjkbqz<! wm<M!uiqgTl<! hkqjef<K!osix<gTl<!
njlf<Kt<te/! -ux<Xt<! wPk<jkObi! osiz<jzObi! okimjvObi! lix<xilz</!
wm<M!uiqgjt!fie<G!uiqbig!fQm<c!njlk<kiz<?!!
gikz<!lekqz<!gVk<kiqg<Gl<!uf<okkqIg<Gl<!!
Olikjz!oue<X!LXuzqg<Gl<!.!sikzqz<!
%cs<!siqk<kqvl<!ogit<Tl<!Lcuqeqz<!
hiceiz<!fQTOl!him<M!
14 we<El<! ‘Ofiqjs! ou{<hi’! gqjmg<gqe<xK/! -f<kh<! himzqz<! Ofiqjs!
ou{<hiUg<Giqb!-zg<g{l<!LPjlBl<!siqbig!njlf<Kt<tK/!!
!
! lvHg<! guqjkbqe<! ncjb! ujtk<kiz<! HKg<guqjk! Okie<XujkBl<?!
HKg<guqjkbqe<! uiqgjts<! OsIk<K! fQm<ceiz<! lvHg<guqjk! Okie<XujkBl<!
gi{Lcgqe<xK/!nkeiz<kie<?!!
ujtbm<Ml<!uiq!
uiq!ujtbzil<!!
ycbg<!%miK!!
h,s<oscbqe<!gqjtOhiz<!ujtbm<Ml<25!
we<X!klqp<fime<!%Xgqe<xiI/!!
!
2/2/4/2/!HKg<guqjk!ohbIg<giv{l<!!
! HKg<guqjkjb! ‘bih<hqzg<g{k<kqzqVf<K! uqMkjz’! we<El<! ohiVtqz<!
‘Free Verse’! we<X! Nr<gqzk<kqz<! njpk<kiIgt</! -K! klqpqz<! okimg<gk<kqz<!
‘use! guqjk’! we<X! njpg<gh<hm<cVg<gqxK/! hqxG! -zG! guqjk?! gm<mx<x!
guqjk?!uqMfqjzh<!hi!weh<!ohbI!ohx<xqVg<gqxK/!nkjek<!okimIf<K!‘New
Verse’! we<X! Nr<gqzk<kqz<! njpk<kqVg<gqxiIgt</! -kjek<! klqpqz<!
olipqohbIk<K! “HKg<guqjk”! we<X! klqpqz<! Lke<Lkzqz<! ohbiqm<M!
njpk<kuI!g/fi/Sh<hqvl{qbe<!NuiI/!!
!
! -Khx<xqg<! g/fi/Sh<hqvl{qbe<! %Xl<OhiK?! “2:6:-z<! fie<! HKg<guqjk!
we<gqx! uiIk<jkjb! wf<k! Olki! uqzisk<KmEl<! osiz<zquqmuqz<jz/! New
Verse! we<X! Nr<gqzk<kqz<! upr<gqb! yV! osiz<jzk<kie<! olipqohbIk<Ks<!
osie<Oee<”26!we<gqe<xiI/!!
!
! “gm<mx<x!guqjk?!use!guqjk!-f<k!-v{<jmBl<!klqp<g<!guqjkbqe<!
dm<hqiqUgtig! Wx<gzil</! HKg<guqjkg<givIgt<! wPKl<! guqjkgjt!
-h<hqiqUgTt<!nmg<gzil</!-jkuqm<Mh<! ‘HKg<guqjk’!we<X!nuIgt<!keqbig!
yV!ohbI!ogiMg<Gl<OhiKkie<!Gph<hl<!Wx<hMgqxK/!HKg<guqjk!we<hK!-f<k!
)-Vhkil<*!F~x<xi{<Mg<!guqjk!njek<jkBl<!Gxqg<Gl<!ohiKs<osiz<”27!we<X!
lQvi!Gxqh<hqMuKl<!-u{<!gueqg<gk<kg<gkiGl</!
15 ! HKg<guqjkjbh<! Hkqb! guqjk?! -g<gizg<! guqjk?! fuQeg<! guqjk?!
fXg<Ggt<!we<oxz<zil<!guqRIgTl<!Nb<uitIgTl<!%xq!uVgqe<xeI/!!
!
2/2/4/2/2/!HKg<guqjkg<G!OuX!ohbIgt<!!
! HKg<guqjk! okimg<gg<! gizk<kqzqVf<K! hzviZl<! hz! ohbIgtiz<!
upr<gh<hm<M! uVgqe<xK/! djvh<hi?! djvuqM! hi?! djvg<guqjk?! use!
guqjk?! -zG! osb<Bt<?! -zG! guqjk?! gm<mx<x! guqjk?! bih<hx<x! guqjk?!
uqMfqjzh<hi?! Hkqi<g<! guqjk?! fu! guqjk?! sQIkqVk<kg<! guqjk?! bih<H! lQxqb!
guqjk?! uqzr<Ggt<! -z<zik! guqjk?! kqxf<koutqg<! guqjk?! Ohs<Sfqjzh<hi?!
Hvm<sqg<!guqjk?!hpGklqp<g<!guqjk?!lqe<ex<!guqjk?!lQxz<!guqjk?!leL{I!
guqjk?!fXg<Gg<!guqjk?!fuQe!guqjk!we<El<!hz!ohbIgt<!HKg<guqjkg<G!
OuX! ohbi<gtigg<! gi{h<ohXgqe<xe/! NbqEl<! yu<ouiV! ohbVg<Gl<! lqg!
Fm<hlie! OuXhiM!d{<M/! nf<kf<kh<! ohbIk<! okimOv! nkeke<! ohiVjtg<!
Gxqh<hig!d{Ik<Kgqe<xK/!!
!
2/2/4/3/!klqpqz<!Lkz<!HKg<guqjk!!
! gizf<OkiXl<! dVuk<kiZl<! dt<tmg<gk<kiZl<! lix<xl<! ohx<X! uVl<!
klqp<g<guqjk! lvhqz<! HKg<guqjk! Okie<xqbKl<! yV! lvOh! NGl</!
klqp<g<guqjk!uvzix<xqz<!lix<xl<!we<hOk!lvhigq!uVgqe<xK/!
!
! “-zg<gqbl<! we<hK! Gxqh<hqm<m! bih<H! ujgg<Gt<tigOui! Gxqh<hqm<m!
ohiVt<! siIHg<Gt<tigOui! wg<gizk<kqZl<! sqjxh<hm<M! fqx<hkqz<jz/! utIf<K!
uVl<! sLkibk<kqe<! d{IUg<Gl<! lixquVl<! gizk<kqe<! Okjug<Gl<! Wx<x!
ujgbqz<! dVg<ogi{<M! utIs<sq! ohXkOz! -zg<gqbk<kqe<! -bz<H”28! we<X!
f/uQ/osbvile<! %XuKl<! guqjk! dVu! dt<tmg<gl<! lix<xl<! njmuKl<!
ohiVk<klib<!dt<te/!
!
! -e<jxg<G! dzgk<! kguz<! okimIH! siker<gt<! lqGkqbib<! utIf<K!
uVgqe<xe/! hqxfim<M! -zg<gqbr<gjtg<! gx<hKl<! nkqgiqk<Kg<ogi{<M!
uVgqe<xK/! sqXgjk?! Hkqel<! Ngqb! -zg<gqb! ujggt<! Oljzfim<M!
-zg<gqbk<kqe<! kig<gk<kiz<! klqpqz<! Okie<xqBt<te/! nux<jxh<! OhizOu!
HKg<guqjkBl<! Oljzfim<Mh<! HKg<guqjkbqe<! kig<gk<kiz<! klqpqz<!
Okie<xqBt<tK/!
16 ! wtqb! hkr<gt<?! wtqb! fjm?! wtqkqz<! nxqf<Kogit<tg<%cb! sf<kl<?!
wtqb!ohiVt<!-ju!hivkqbiiqe<!guqjkgtqz<!gi{h<hMgqe<xe/!Neiz<!nju!
lvHg<! guqjkgt<! NGl</! nux<Xt<! hi?! hiuqel<?! hi! Yjs?! -vigl<?! kitl<!
Lkzieju! Gxqh<hqmh<hm<Mt<te/! -vuQf<kqvfik<! ki%iqe<! gQkiR<szqjbBl<!
uiz<m<! uqm<leqe<! “Hz<zqe<! -kp<gt<”! guqjkgjtBl<! hivkqbii<! hcg<gqe<xiI/!
nux<xqe<!kig<gligh<!hivkqbiI!use!guqjkgjt!-bx<Xgqe<xiI/!!
!
! “hivkq!gim<Ml<!gim<sqgtqe<!hz!hGkqgt<!guqjk!ytq!ohikqf<k!sqXsqX!
hmzr<gtigOu!kqgp<gqe<xe/!NbqEl<!nju!guqjk!Ngquqmi/!‘use!guqjk’!
we<El<! Hkqb! ucuk<kqe<! \QuEt<t! sqk<kqvr<gt<! nju”29! we<X!
uz<zqg<g{<{e<!%Xgqe<xiI/!!
!
! klqpqz<! Lkz<! HKg<guqRI! hvOlSuve<! hqt<jt! we<hK! Svkiuqe<2:!
gVk<kiGl</!Neiz<!nkx<gie!Nkivl<!gqjmg<guqz<jz/!!
!
! hivkqbiI!uiz<m<!uqm<leqe<!guqjkgjth<!hck<K!nux<jxh<!Ohiz!use!
guqjkgt<!hjmk<kjkh<!Ohiz?!f/hqs<s&Ik<kq!uiz<m<!uqm<leqe<!guqjkgjtBl<!
-vuQf<kqvfik<! ki%iqe<! gQkiR<szqjbBl<! hivkqbiiqe<! use! guqjkgjtBl<!
hck<kke<! kig<glig?! 2:45! Nl<! N{<M! “gikz<”! we<El<! HKg<guqjkjbh<!
hjmg<gqe<xiI/!nf<kg<!guqjk!hqe<uVliX!njlf<Kt<tK/!!
lif<Okih<H!u^f<kk<kqe<!hm<mijm!dMk<kqbqVg<gqxK!
lzIgt<!uisl<!glp<gqxK!
lvk<kqzqVf<K!N{<Gbqz<!gk<KgqxK/!
we<e!lKvl<"!we<e!Kbvl<"!!
N{<Gbqz<!osiz<ZgqxK!!
gikx<!gez<!ohVg<ogMk<K!uqm<mK!
gjvgt<!djmf<K!Ohibqe!!
ofR<sk<kqe<!OuIgt<!gVGgqe<xe!
Gbqzq"!gikz<!fQjv!uiIk<Kk<!kQjb!nj{h<hib<!!
gVgqb!OuIgTg<G!dbqjv!Dm<Muib<!!
g<giu,!/!/!/!g<giu,!/!/!/!
!
17
nMk<k!ogiz<jzbqz<!wkqIg<Gvz<!
oh{<Gbqz<!%UgqxK/!!
we<e!Osigl<"!we<e!-eqjl"!!
!
oh{<Gbqz<!osiz<ZgqxK!
keqjl!dbqjvk<!k{zig<gq!uqm<mK!
k{z<!de<!Gvziz<!\<uijzbigqxK!
!
we<!ofVh<H!de<!ofVh<jh!nj{g<Gli@!!
gikz<!kQIujkuqm!-g<gqtIs<sqOb!Ohijk!
-k<Ke<hOl!-e<hl<!
!
Gbqzi"!ofVh<jh!utIh<Ohil<!
g<giu,d!/!/!/!g<giu,d!/!/!/!
!
gikz<!okb<ul<!gix<oxizqBme<!gzf<K!osiz<ZgqxK!
ye<Xhm<miz<!Yb<U{<miGl<!Okg<gl<!d{<miGl<!!
gzf<kiz<!gsh<H!d{<miGl<!
gikx<Gvz<!gm<ch<OhiGl<!
!
hqiquqjebqe<!-e<hl<!-j{bx<xK/!!
okiqbilzi!=sEl<!-bx<jgBl<!Ych<hqcg<gqxiIgt<!!
okb<u!zQjzjb!dvg<gs<!osiz<Z!!
g<giu,d!/!/!/!g<giu,d!/!/!/31!
-f<kg<! guqjkjbk<! ‘klqpqe<! Lkz<! HKg<guqjk’! we<X! Nb<uitIgt<!
%Xgqe<xeI/! f/hqs<s&Ik<kq! w{<hk<K!&e<X! HKg<guqjkgjth<! hjmk<Kt<tiI/!
nuiqe<!Lkz<!HKg<guqjk!‘gikz<’!)2:45*A!-Xkqg<guqjk!‘Okju’!)2:87*/!nui<!
2:55! Lkz<! 2:6:! ujvbqzie! -jmh<hm<m! gizk<kqz<! guqjk! hjmh<hjk!
fqXk<kqBt<tiI/!!
!
! hivkqbiiqe<!use!guqjkjb!nuiqe<!hvl<hjvg<!guqRIgt<!)hivkqkise<!
LkziOeiI*! biuVl<! hqe<hx<xuqz<jz/! 2:32! Nl<! N{<czqVf<K! 2:44! Nl<!
N{<M!ujv!use!guqjkbqe<! utIs<sqjbh<! hx<xq! yVuVl<! sqf<kqg<guqz<jz/!
18 -f<fqjzbqz<! “lixquVl<! sLkib! njlh<Hg<Gl<! n[GLjxg<Gl<! Wx<h?!
guqjkg<! gjzbqZl<! yVujg! lix<xl<! fqgp! Ou{<Mole<hK! hzvK!
Oum<jgbig!-Vf<kKA!-keiz<!dVu!njlh<jhuqm?!gVk<K!outqh<him<Mg<G!
Lke<jl! kvOu{<Ml<! we<x! Gvz<! Yr<gqbK/! weOu! HKg<guqjk! hqxf<kK”32!
we<X!f/uQ/osbvile<!osh<HuKl<!-u{<!Ofig<gk<kg<gkiGl</!!
!
! “gizf<OkiXl<! klqp<g<guqjk! lvhqz<! Wx<hMl<! lix<xLl<! -Vhkil<!
F~x<xi{<Mk<!okimg<gk<kqz<!nvsqbz<!fqjzBl<!sLkib!fqjzBl<!Oljzfim<Mg<!
guqjkk<! kig<gLl<! djvfjm! utIs<sqBl<! klqpqz<! HKg<guqjk! Okie<xg<!
giv{qgtig!-Vf<Kt<te/”33!!
!
! sq/gegshihkq?! ‘klqp<g<! guqjkbqz<! hivkqg<Gh<! hqxG! yV! -jmoutq!
(Rift)! Wx<hm<cVh<hKl<! -zG!osb<Bt<! hi!Ljxbqzie! HKg<guqjk! Okie<xg<!
giv{liGl<”34!we<gqxiI/!!
!
! nh<Kz<! vGlie<?! “hqovR<S?! o\Ileq?! Nr<gqz! olipqgtqz<! Wx<hm<m!
HKg<guqjk! -bg<gk<kqe<! hikqh<H?! klqpqz<! wz<zi! -zg<gqbk<! KjxgtqZl<!
Wx<hm<m! Hk<okPs<sq?! hjpb! kmr<gtqz<! Wx<hm<m! szqh<H?! -zg<gqbk<kqx<oge<Ox!
Okie<xqb! sqx<xqkp<gtqe<! uzqjlbie! hqvs<sivl<! -ju! klqpqz<! HKg<guqjk!
Okie<xg<!giv{libqe”35!we<gqxiI/!!
!
! gi/Ogi/Our<gmvile<?! “HKg<guqjkbqe<! Okix<xk<kqx<G! djvfjmbqe<!
osz<uig<G?! lvHg<! guqjkbqe<! osxquqe<jl?! GcbvS! diqjlbiz<! Wx<hm<m!
gm<Mh<him<M! ouXh<H?! ns<S! -bf<kqvl<! Okie<xqbjl! Ohie<x! hz! giv{r<gt<!
%xh<hm<miZl<!lqgUl<!-e<xqbjlbik!giv{l<!noliqg<gs<!osz<uig<Og”36!we<X!
%XuKl<!-r<Gg<!Gxqh<hqmk<kg<gkiGl</!!
!
! klqpqz<! HKg<guqjk! Okie<xq! oux<xq! ohx<X! fqjzk<K! fqx<hkx<Gg<!
giv{qgtig!N/osgf<fike<?! “Oleim<Mg<! guqjkgjth<! hbqe<x! sqzI! lm<MOl!
-gp<s<sqjbh<! ohiVm<hMk<kiK! HKg<guqjkbqz<! =Mhm<meI/! nke<! uqjtuigh<!
HKg<guqjk! ucul<! klqpqz<! fqjzohx<xK”37! we<X! olipquKl<! sqf<kqg<gk<!
kg<gkiGl</!
19 ! dzgqz<! ‘HKg<guqjkbqe<! kf<jk’! we<X! uiz<m<! uqm<le<! njpg<gh<!
ohXgqe<xiI/! klqpqz<! HKg<guqjkbqe<! kf<jk! we<X! f/hqs<s&Ik<kq! njpg<gh<!
ohXgqe<xiI/! weqEl<?! klqpqz<! HKg<guqjkbqe<! kf<jkjbg<! Gxqh<hqMukqz<!
gVk<K!OuXhiM!gi{h<ohXgqe<xK/!
!
! “klqp<h<! HKg<guqjkbqe<! kf<jk! hivkqbiI! we<X! gV{ifqkq!
Gxqh<hqMgqe<xiI/!klqp<h<!HKg<guqjkbqe<!kf<jk!L/Olk<ki!we<X!h/vuqs<sf<kqve<!
OhSgqe<xiI/! klqp<h<! HKg<guqjkbqe<! kf<jk! hqvlqt<! we<X! OkuOkue<!
%Xgqe<xiI/! weqEl<! f/hqs<s&Ik<kqkie<! klqp<h<! HKg<guqjkbqe<! LjeuI?!
Lkz<uI?!hqkilgeiI!we<X!sq/gegshihkq!uzqBXk<Kgqe<xiI/!-h<hcg<!gVk<K!
OuXhiMgt<! gi{h<hm<miZl<! giz! nch<hjmbqz<! -e<jxb! klqp<! -zg<gqb!
uvzix<xqz<! use! guqjkg<Gh<! hivkqbiVl<! HKg<guqjkg<G! f/hqs<s&Ik<kqBl<!
Le<Oeicgt<!NuI/”38!!
!
2/2/4/4/!HKg<guqjkbqe<!-zg<g{l<!!
! -zg<gqbl<! g{<mkx<G! -zg<g{l<! -bx<XuK! lvhiGl</!
k/svu{k<klqpe<! )bih<H! F~z<*?! s/hizSf<kvl<! )oke<E~z<*?! -vi/-viOsf<kqve<!
)HKg<guqjk! -zg<g{l<*! LkziOeiI! HKg<guqjkgTg<G! -zg<g{l<! %x!
Lbe<Xt<teI/! sq/gegshihkq?! -vi/sf<kqvOsgve<?! hizi?! -vi/Olige<?!
-vi/sl<hk<?! li/Ogiuqf<kviS! LkziOeiI! hz! Nb<Ug<! gm<Mjvgt<! lx<Xl<!
F~z<gt<! &zl<! HKg<guqjkg<G! -zg<g{l<! %x! Lbe<Xt<teI/! L/Olk<ki?!
juvLk<K/! sq/l{q?! S/-tr<Ogi?! ohVr<OgiOuf<ke<! LkziOeiI! kl<!
guqjkgtqz<!HKg<guqjkg<G!-zg<g{l<!%xqBt<teI/!
!
! f/hqs<s&Ik<kq?! “gVk<Kg<gtqe<! -jsOu?! d{Iuqe<! szeOl?! guqki!
sqV]<cbqe<! yVjlOb! HKg<guqjkbiGl<”39! we<gqxiI/! ‘wPk<K’! sq/S/osz<zh<hi?!
“ym<Molik<klie! gVk<K! nr<gg<! gm<Mkie<! HKg<guqjkg<G! nch<hjmbie!
-zg<g{l</!-f<k!nr<gg<!gm<Mg<G!dkUl<!ujgbqz<!bih<jhg<!gjmh<hqck<Kl<!
ofgqp<k<Kl<!lQxqBl<!HKuqkqgt<!OsIg<Gl<”3:!we<X!osh<Hgqe<xiI/!!
bih<Hjmk<k!guqjk!
nj{Bjmk<k!giuqiq!
bih<hx<x!guqjk!
-bx<jgobpqz<!-Vg<g!
20
osbx<jgb{q!wkx<oge<X!
djmBme<!yh<hjeBl<!
fQg<gquqm<m!ge<eq41!
we<X!sq/l{q!HKg<guqjkjbh<!hx<xq!-bl<Hgqe<xiI/!bih<H?!-zg<g{l<?!wKjg?!
Olije?!K~b!klqp<s<osiz<?!Hzjl!-ju!-z<zik!///?!
gVk<Kg<gt<!kl<jlk<!!
kiOl!Ntg<!
gx<Xg<!ogi{<m!
Hkqb!
lg<gtim<sq!LjxOb!
HKg<guqjk42!
we<X! L/Olk<ki! olipqgqe<xiI/! klqpue<?! “hqx! hikqh<hiz<! nc! lek<kqz<!
kig<G{<M! wPgqe<x! geUfqjz! d{IUgjtBl<! w{<{! Ym<mr<gjtBl<!
nux<xqe<! F{<[{IUgjtBl<! wPs<sq! njzgjtBl<! bih<H! LjxgTg<Gg<!
gm<Mh<hmilz<!-zg<g{g<giveqe<!ke<!&h<hie!uqkqgTg<Gs<!osuq!sib<g<gilz<!
hqxf<k!Oleqbigk<!kVuOk!HKg<guqjk”43!we<X!uqtg<Ggqe<xiI/!!
HKg<guqjk!!
we<hK!
osix<gt<!ogi{<miMl<!!
Skf<kqv!kqeuqpi44!
we<X! juvLk<K! HKg<guqjkg<G! uqtg<gl<! kVgqe<xiI/! -r<rel<!
HKg<guqRIgt<!nuvuIg<G!Wx<xuiX!HKg<guqjkg<G!uqtg<gl<!kVgqe<xeI/!!
-K!!
Ouzq!-z<zik!
gix<X!
gjv!-z<zik!
gmz</!
!
-K!!
osbx<jgg<!gjz!-z<jz/!
-bx<jg!wpqz</!!
!
21
osiz<!OkeQg<gt<!!
osif<k!Lbx<sqbqz<!
Hjkk<K!juk<kqVg<Gl<!!
Okejmh<!ohiVt<45!
we<X!S/-tr<Ogi!HKg<guqjk!hx<xqg<!%Xgqe<xiI/!lvHg<!guqjkgtqz<!wPk<K?!
njs?! sQI! we<hju! w{<{q! jug<gh<hMgqe<xe/! Neiz<! HKg<guqjkgtqz<!
nh<hch<hm<m!fqjz!-z<ziuqm<miZl<!osix<gTg<Gt<!-e?!-jbH!nch<hjmbqz<!
yV! ujvbjx! d{<M/! -u<uiX! -jbhig! dt<tjk! -bz<hig! uiqgtig!
njlk<kqVh<hjkh<!hz!HKg<guqjkgtqz<!gi{Lcgqe<xK/!
!
! HKg<guqjkbqe<! dVul<! hx<xqb! -zg<g{ligh<! hqe<uVl<! &e<X!
gVk<Kg<gjth<!ohie<l{q!juvLk<K!%Xgqe<xiI/46!!
2/ bih<hqzqVf<K! uqMhm<Mh<! hiMkz</! NbqEl<! bih<hqzqVf<K!
Ou{<cbOhiK! uqMhm<M?! Ou{<mikOhiK! nguz<?! uqVk<kl<! Ohie<x!
bih<hqe<!sibzqz<!HKh<ohiVt<!hiMkz</!
3/ dVul<! Lke<jlh<hMk<kh<hmilzqVk<kz<?! Yjs! Ofig<gh<hmilz<!
guqjkg<Gg<! guqjk! ouu<OuX! dVul<?! ouu<OuX! yzqfbl<!
njlkz</!
4/ d{IUg<! %IjlBt<t! lek<kqe<! gm<Mh<hMk<kh<hmik! ucgizib<?!
osiMg<gq!uQsh<hm<m!sim<jmbcbib<g<!guqjkjb!njlk<kz</!!
HKg<guqjkbqe<! -bz<Hgtigh<! ohie<l{q! juvLk<K! %Xl<!
HKg<guqjk! ujvbjx?! -e<jxb! klqp<h<! HKg<guq<jk! wz<ziux<xqx<Gl<!
hvuzigh<! ohiVf<kqg<! gi{h<ohXgqe<xK/! lg<gTg<gie! gVk<Kg<gjt! lg<gt<!
wtqkqz<!HiqBl<!ujgbqz<!guqjk!hjmh<hOk!HKg<guqjkbqe<!Ofig<gl<!NGl</!!
!
! HKg<guqjk!SVg<gLl<!osxqUl<!Fm<hLl<!djmbkig!-Vg<g!Ou{<Ml</!
HKg<guqjkbqz<! Gjxf<k! osix<gTl<! fqjxf<k! gVk<Kh<! Hzh<hiMl<!
njlf<kqVg<g! Ou{<Ml</! HKg<guqjkbqe<! dVul<! osxqUl<! -Xg<gLl<!
ogi{<mkig!-Vg<g! Ou{<Ml</! HKg<guqjk!uiq! yV! okimvig! –! yV! Ohs<S!
fqXk<klig! njlb! Ou{<Ml</! Ohs<Ss<! osix<gt<?! Ohs<osizq?! okieqs<! osiz<?!
okimI! H{Ih<H?! osix<gjth<! hmlig<gqg<! gim<Mkz<?! gVk<Kg<gjth<! hclg<!
gim<sqbig<gqg<! gim<Mkz<?! sLkibk<jkh<! hmlig<gqg<! gim<Mkz<?! Hkqb! Hkqb!
outqh<him<M!Ljx!Lkzieju!HKg<guqjkg<G!-e<xqbjlbikjubiGl</!!
22 ! sf<kk<kqe<! uibqzigg<! giK! upqOb! HGf<k! guqjk! lixq?! guqjk!
g{<upqOb! Hg! Ou{<Ml<! we<x! ogit<jg! Okie<xqbK/! nke<! outqh<hiOm!
HKg<guqjk! NGl</! lg<gtqe<! sLkibk<jkh<! hml<hqck<Kg<! gim<m! Ou{<Ml<A!
sLkibs<! sqg<gZg<Gk<! kQIU! gi{! Ou{<Ml<A! Gx<xr<gjt!nr<gkk<kqe<!&zl<!
Gk<kqg<gim<m! Ou{<Ml<A! gVk<Kg<gjtg<! gim<sqh<hMk<kq! d{Ik<k! Ou{<Ml<A!
guqjk! he<Lgh<! Ohig<Gg<! ogi{<mkib<! njlb! Ou{<Ml<A! gVk<jkg<!
GxqbQm<miz<!d{Ik<k!Ou{<Ml<A!Hkqb!gVk<Kg<gjtBl<!Hvm<sqs<!sqf<kjejbBl<!
slk<Kuk<jkBl<! outqh<hMk<k! Ou{<Ml<! Lkzieju! HKg<guqjkbqz<!
njlf<kqVg<g!Ou{<Ml</!!
!
2/2/4/5/!HKg<guqjk!ucul<!
! -zg<gqb!ujg!wz<ziux<Xg<Gl<!ucul<!d{<M/!yu<ouie<xqx<Gl<!ucu!
OuXhiM!gi{h<hMgqe<xK/!HKg<guqjkg<G!ucul<!-z<jz!we<hK!hzVjmb!
gVk<kiGl</! Neiz<?! HKg<guqjkg<G! ucul<! d{<MA! bih<Hg<! gm<Mh<himie!
ucul<!-z<jz/! “olipqbiz<!outqh<hMk<kh<hMgqx!wkx<Gl<!yV!ucul<!d{<M!
///!d{<omeqz<! HKg<guqjkg<Gl<! ucul<!d{<ome<hK! ohxh<hMgqxK”47! we<X!
hi/lkqui{e<!olipquKl<!-u{<!Ofig<gk<kg<gkiGl</!
!
! HKg<guqjkbqz<! lg<gtqe<! Ohs<Solipqg<!%XgTl<! Ohs<Sk<! okimIgTl<!
-ml<ohXgqe<xeA!Oux<Xolipqs<!osix<gTl<!uqvuq!uVgqe<xeA!yzqg<Gxqh<HgTl<!
wPk<K! ucul<! ohXgqe<xeA! guqRiqe<! d{Is<sq! Ougk<kqx<Gl<! Ohs<S!
Ougk<kqx<Gl<! &s<Suqm<Mh<! OhSl<! ke<jlg<Gl<! Wx<h! uiq! njlh<Hgt<!
gm<mjlg<gh<ohXgqe<xe/! yV!uiqbqz<! yV! sqf<kje! fqXk<kl<! -Vg<Gl<A!n0K!
YI!njmk<okimI?!ws<sk<okimI!nz<zK!Lx<Xk<okimvig!-Vg<Gl</! sqf<kjeg<!
gVk<kqe<! ntuqx<G! Wx<h?! uiqbqe<! njlh<H! fQtligOui! fQtl<! Gjxf<Oki!
njlgqe<xK/! nkeiz<! HKg<guqjk! uiqgtqz<! osix<gtqe<! w{<{qg<jg! yOv!
ntuig!-vi/!
!
! guqjkbqe<! gVk<Kg<Ogx<h?! HKg<guqjk! yV! hk<kqbigOui! hz!
hk<kqgtigOui! njlgqe<xK/! nf<kh<! hk<kqgt<! ye<xqx<G! ye<X! ohiVt<!
-jbHmEl<!njlbzil<A! ouu<OuX!ohiVTmEl<!njlbzil<A!-jbhqz<zih<!
ohiVtigUl<! njlbzil</! ohVl<hiZl<! yu<ouiV! hk<kqBl<! ohiVt<!
Lx<Xh<ohx<x! okimviz<! Lcf<kqVg<Gl</! hk<kqgtqz<! uiqgtqe<! w{<{qg<jg!
23 OuXhm<Ml<! -Vg<gzil<A! yOv! ntuigUl<! -Vg<gzil</! sqz! guqjkgtqz<!
hk<kqgt<! yOv! ntU! ogi{<m! uiqgtiz<! njlb! Ou{<Ml<! we<hkx<gigg<!
guqRIgt<?! hk<kqbqe<! Lcju! ws<sk<! okimvig<GuKl<! nf<k! ws<sk<! okimjv!
nMk<k!hk<kqBme<!okimIHhMk<KuKl<!d{<M?!!
!
! yu<ouiV! guqRVl<! hjmg<Gl<! HKg<guqjkgt<! ucu! OuXhim<jmBl<!
olipqfjm! OuXhim<jmBl<! ogi{<Mt<te/! guqjkbqe<! dt<tmg<gk<kqx<Gl<!
guqRiqe<!d{Is<sqg<Gl<! Wx<hg<!guqjkbqe<!dVul<! OuXhMgqe<xK/!guqRiqe<!
gx<hjeg<Gl<! dk<kqg<Gl<! Wx<hg<! guqjkbqe<! dVul<! OuXhMgqe<xK/!
HKg<guqjk! dt<tmg<gk<kqx<Ogx<x! dVuk<kqjeh<! ohxUl<! osb<gqe<xK/!
dVuk<jkBl<! dt<tmg<gk<jkBl<! hqiqg<g! LcbiK! we<X! kqxeib<uitIgt<!
%Xgqe<xeI/!!
!
! uiqgjt! ye<xqe<gQp<! ye<xig! lmg<gq! wPKl<! HKg<guqjkjb?!
yPr<GhMk<kqeiz<! lvHg<guqjk! ucuk<kqx<Gt<! nmg<gquqmzil</! nu<uiX!
lvHg<guqjk! ucuk<kqx<G! yPr<GhMk<kh<hMl<! guqjkgt<! ohVl<hiZl<!
-j{g<Gxt<! Nsqiqbh<hi! ucuk<jkh<! ohXl</! lvHg<guqjk! hjmg<gk<!
okiqf<kuIgTl<! HKg<guqjkjb! lqGkqbigh<! hjmh<hkiz<?! nux<xqz<! lvhqe<!
kig<gl<!lqGkqbig!-Vg<gqe<xK/!
!
! HKg<guqjkbqe<! uiq! ujvbjx?! -v{<M! sQI! ogi{<m! yVuiqg<! guqjk!
sqx<oxz<jzbigUl<! Jf<F~x<Xg<Gl<! Olx<hm<m! uiqgt<! ogi{<m! ofMr<guqjk!
Ohovz<jzbigUl<!gi{h<ohXgqe<xe/!
sqxGk<!kivjg48!!
-K! ‘lqe<lqeq’! we<El<! kjzh<hqz<! njlf<k! nh<Kz<! vGlieqe<! yVuiqg<!
guqjkbiGl</! f/hqs<s&Ik<kqbqe<! ‘dbqi<lgt<’! we<El<! guqjk! 5:8! uiqgjtg<!
ogi{<mkiGl</!!
!
! GXr<guqjkbig! -Vf<kiz<! yOv! hk<kqbigUl<! ofMr<guqjkbig!
-Vf<kiz<! ye<xqx<G! Olx<hm<m! hk<kqgtigUl<!njlf<K! gi{h<ohXgqe<xe/! yV!
hk<kqbqz<! ye<xqx<G! Olx<hm<m! uiqgTl<! ye<xqx<G! Olx<hm<m! okimIgTl<! ye<X!
nz<zK! ye<xqx<G! Olx<hm<m! hbeqjzgTl<! njlgqe<xe/! okimIfqjzs<!
osb<Bjth<! Ohie<x! ofMr<guqjkgTl<! HKg<guqjkbigh<! hjmg<gh<!
24 ohx<Xt<te/!sqx<hqbqe<! ‘olte!lbg<gr<gt<’!we<El<!HKg<guqjk!-u<ujgbqz<!
njlf<Kt<tK/!
!
! klqp<h<! HKg<guqjkgtqz<! ofMr<guqjkgjtuqmg<! GXr<guqjkgOt!
lqGkqbig! -ml<ohx<Xt<te/! HKg<guqjkgtqe<! ucur<gt<! GXr<guqjk?!
ofMr<guqjk?!fim<Mh<Hxh<himz<!ucul<?!sqk<kqvg<!guqjk?!djvg<guqjk!)Ohs<S!
sf<k!ucul<*!Lkzie!hz!ucur<gtqz<!gi{h<ohXgqe<xe/!!
!
2/2/4/6/!l{qg<ogicg<!gizl<!)2:44.2:4:*!!
! l{qg<ogic!2:44!Nl<!N{<M!osh<ml<hI!28!Nl<!fit<!okimr<gh<hm<mK/!
sQequise<?!c/w <̂/osig<gzqr<gl<?!u/vi/!Ngqb!&uiqe<!Lbx<sqbiz<!l{qg<ogic!
-kp<! Okix<xl<! ohx<xK/! -l<&uiqZl<! sQequise<! l{qg<ogicg<gie!
&zgiv{lig! njlf<kiI/! -kpqbz<! Kjxbqz<! nkqg! =MhiMl<! nEhuLl<!
djmbuvig! -Vf<k! sQequisOe! l{qg<ogicg<gie! Le<! kqm<mr<gjt!
uGk<kqVf<kii</!!
!
! gl<heqe<!‘osPl{qg<ogicgt<’!we<x!okimjvs<!sQequisEl<?!hivkqbiiqe<!
‘kibqe<! l{qg<ogic’! we<x! okimjv! u/vi/Ul<! fqjeU%vh<! Hkqb! -kPg<G!
‘l{qg<ogic’! we<X! ohbI! jug<gh<hm<mK/! 2:44.2:4:! Ngqb! Nxi{<Mg<! giz!
uip<uqz<! l{qg<ogic! klqp<h<! h{<him<M! uip<uqe<! osPjlg<oge! lqGkqbie!
hr<gtqh<Hgjts<!osb<kK/! ‘klqp<!lXlzIs<sq!-zg<gqbk<kqe<!out<tq!Ljth<H’!
we<X!l{qg<ogic!-kp<!ke<jeh<!ohVjlbig!nxquqk<Kg<!ogi{<mK/!!
!
! ‘l{qg<ogic’! -zg<gqb! -kpqz<! f/hqs<s&Ik<kq?! G/h/vi\Ogihize<?!
HKjlh<hqk<ke<?! uz<zqg<g{<{e<! LkziOeiI! HKg<guqjkgjt! wPkq!
outqbqm<meI/! okimg<gg<gizh<! HKg<guqjkgt<! usek<! ke<jljbOb!
lqGkqbigh<!ohx<xqVf<ke/!Ohigh<!Ohigg<!guqjkbqz<!ofgqp<s<sq!Gjxf<K!osxqU!
lqGkqbieK/!!
!
! “f/hqs<s&Ik<kq! 2:45-z<! bih<hx<x! guqjk! Lbx<sqgtqz<! =Mhm<mii</!
Hkqbkig! wPk! Ou{<Ml<! we<gqx! w{<{l<! nh<OhiOk! nuVg<gqVf<kK/!
-g<gizg<!guqjkgt<!ohVl<hiZl<!l{qg<ogicbqz<!outqbibqe/”49!!
!
25 ! f/hqs<s&Ik<kqbqe<! Lkz<! HKg<guqjk! l{qg<ogic! -kpqz<! 25/21/2:45!
ne<X! outqbieK/! nkjek<! okimIf<K! hz! HKg<guqjkgt<! l{qg<ogic!
-kpqz<! outquf<ke/! f/hqs<s&Ik<kqbqe<! okimg<ggizg<! guqjkgt<! kk<Kul<!
fqjxf<kkig!-Vf<ke/!!
!
! “lvHme<!ogi{<cVf<k!NOvig<gqblie!hii<jugtiZl<!HKjl!gi{<gqx!
leuqjtuiZl<! l{qg<ogicg<givIgt<! klqPg<ogeh<! Hkqb! guqjkjbg<! gi{!
Lx<hm<meI/! dt<tmg<g! dVur<gtqz<! HKjljbg<! ogi{<m! guqjkgTg<G!
Lbe<xeI/! klK! outq! -zg<gqb! nxqLgk<kiz<! dzgqe<! fqgp<giz!
-zg<gqbr<gTl<! fjmLjxgTl<! nxqbuvk<! klg<ogeg<! guqjk! Gxqk<k!
hiIjugjt! ucujlk<Kg<! ogi{<meI/! nuIgtqe<! sqf<kjebqzqVf<K! gQp<g<!
gi{<hux<jxg<!guqjkg<!Ogim<hiMgtig!uiqjsh<hMk<k!LcgqxK/!!
2/ guqjk!nEhul<!siIf<kK/!guqjkjb!nEhuqk<kz<!)d{Ikz<*!we<hK!
keqleqke<!okimIhieK/!!
3/ guqjkh<!hjmh<hqe<!hbe<!we<hK!Ne<l!uqMkjz/!!
4/ osix<gt<?! gVk<Kgt<! ogi{<cVg<gqx! OugOl!guqjkjb!fqs<sbqg<gqxK/!
-KOu! d{Is<sq! weh<hMgqxK/! -u<U{Is<sqOb! guqjkjbBl<!
fqs<sbqg<gqxK/!!
5/ guqjkg<G! wek<! keqh<hm<m! ucuL{<M/! Neiz<! fqs<sblie! ucul<!
gqjmbiK/!!
6/ guqjkg<G! Yjs! d{<M/! nK! osbx<jgbigs<! osix<gjt! wKjg?!
Olije?! sQI?! okijm! -ju! uv! njlg<gh<hMukiz<! Wx<hMukz<z/!
nu<Ouijs! guqjkg<Gt<! gVk<kqe<! Ougk<kqx<G! Wx<h! -bz<hig! wp!
Ou{<cbK/!!
7/ guqjkg<G!-zg<g{l<!-jsf<K!uvzil</!Neiz<!-zg<g{l<!ohiVf<kq!
uVuKkie<! guqjk! we<X! gqjmbiK/! guqjkg<G!bih<hqzg<g{!nxqU!
Okju!-z<jz/!!
8/ guqjkbqe<! dVul<! we<hK! gVk<Kgtqe<! -jsuiz<?! nkeiz<!
d{<migqx!-jsbiz<!Wx<hMgqxK/!!
9/ guqjkbqe<! OlOzim<mlie! Hxucul<! nkiuK! uiqgtqe<! ucu!
ntuieK! guqReqe<! leg<GvjzBl<! oltek<jkBl<! ym<cbkig!
-Vg<Gl</!nkx<Gh<!hjpb!bih<H!uqkqgjth<!ohiVk<kqg<!gi{g<%miK/!!
:/ liXkz<!we<gqx!fqbkqObiM!guqjkBl<!LPjlbig!dm<hm!Ou{<Ml</!!
26
-g<Ogim<hiMgtiz<! klqp<g<! guqjkg<G! nK! osz<z! Ou{<cb! hijk!
Sm<cg<!gim<mh<hm<mK”4:!we<X!g/dlilOg^<uiq!l{qg<ogicg<!gizg<!guqjkgt<!
hx<xq!olipquK!-u{<!Ofig<gk<kg<gkiGl</!!
!
! HKg<guqjkbqe<! Okix<xLl<! Osikje! Lbx<sqgTl<! l{qg<ogicg<!
gizk<kqz<kie<! fjmohXgqe<xe/! nkeiz<! -e<jxb! HKg<guqjkbqe<! dVu!
dt<tmg<gk<kqzqVf<K?! ne<jxb! HKg<guqjkbqe<! dVu! dt<tmg<gr<gt<!
ohVl<hiZl<!OuXhMgqe<xe/!!
!
2/2/4/7/!wPk<Kg<gizl<!)2:6:.2:81*!
! ‘wPk<K’! -kp<! 2:6:! Nl<! N{<M! seuiq! likl<! sq/S/osz<zh<hiuiz<!
okimr<gh<ohx<xK/! “wPk<K”! Lkz<! -kpqz<! nke<! Ofig<gl<! Gxqk<Ks<!
sq/S/osz<zh<hi?! “fMujgbie! fqjx! Gjx! -v{<jmBl<! wMk<Kg<gim<Ml<! yV!
gVk<K! Ym<mh<Ohig<Og! uqlIsel<! NGl</! -f<k! nch<hjmbqz<kie<! wPk<K!
-br<Gl</!-zg<gqb!nhqh<vibl<!sl<hf<klig!liXhm<m!gVk<Kg<gTg<Gg<!gtlig!
wPk<K! njluK! OhizOu?! -zg<gqbk<! kvlie! wk<kjgb!
HKOsikjegTg<Gl<! wPk<K! -ml<! kVl<”! we<X! nke<! Ofig<gk<jkg<!
Gxqh<hqm<cVf<kiI/!OlZl<!Lkzi{<M!-kp<gtqz<!Lkz<!hg<gk<kqz<!nK?!“HKjl!
-zg<gqb!lik!WM”!we<X!ke<je!nxquqk<Kg<!ogit<gqxK/! hqe<eI?!-v{<mil<!
&e<xil<!N{<Mgtqz<!“-zg<gqb!uqlIse!Gvz<”!we<X!nK!ke<je!njpk<Kg<!
ogit<gqxK/! -zg<gqb! uqlIsel<?! hjmh<Hk<! Kjxbqz<! Osikjegt<! -ux<xqz<!
nkqg!ng<gjx!ogi{<m!lik!-kpigk<!kqgp<f<kK/!!
!
! “kqVl<hk<! kqVl<h?! keK! kjzbr<gl<! Lkx<ogi{<m! hz! hGkqgtqZl<!
HKjl?! Hkqb! hiIju?! Hkqb! Ofig<gl<?! Hkqb! kml<! we<X! osix<oximIgjth<!
hbe<hMk<KgqxK/! Lkz<! kjzbr<gk<kqOzOb! keK! Ofig<gk<jks<! osiz<zq!
uqMuKOhiz?! wPk<kitIgTg<G! njph<H! uqMg<gqe<xOhiK?! “HKh<HK! uqklig!
Ofig<Gl<! hiIjuBl<! ogi{<M! outqbqm<Ms<! osiz<z! Ou{<Ml<”! we<Xl<?! ‘SuM!
okiqgqx! kmk<kqOz! osz<z! lXk<K?! HKk<kml<! Ohim<Mg<! ogi{<M! osz<Zl<!
hjmh<hitIgjt! wPk<K! uvOux<Gl<’! we<Xl<! oktquig! nXkqbqm<Ms<!
osiz<ZuKOhiz<!nK!osiz<gqxK”51!we<X!kq/S/fmvise<!wPk<K!-kp<!Gxqk<Kh<!
OhSgqe<xiI/!
27 ! wPk<K!-kpqz<!f/hqs<s&Ik<kq?!kVL!n'h<!squviL?!G/h/vi\Ogihize<?!
sq/l{q?! kq/Osi/Ou[Ogihize<?! hSub<bi?! w^</juk<kQ̂ <uve<?! fGze<! lx<Xl<!
hzI! kr<gt<! HKg<guqjkgjt! wPkqeI/! wPk<K! -kp<! -zg<gqb! -kpigk<!
kqgp<f<kK/! nkqz<! HKg<guqjk?! HKg<guqjk! hx<xqb! kqxeib<Ug<! gm<Mjvgt<?!
sqXgjkgt<?! okimIgjkgt<! Lkzieju! outqbqmh<ohx<xe/! ‘wPk<K’g<!
gizk<kqz<! klqp<h<! HKg<guqjk! YI! -bg<glig! dVouMk<K! utIf<kK/!
sq/S/osz<zh<hi! ‘wPk<K! hqvSvl<’! we<El<! outqbQm<ce<! &zl<! ‘wPk<K’! lik!
-kjpBl<!-tr<guqRIgtqe<!guqjkgjtk<!okiGk<Kh<! ‘HKg<Gvz<gt<’!we<El<!
HKg<guqjk!F~zigUl<!outqbqm<Mh<!HKg<guqjkgjt!utIk<kiI/!!
!
! sq/S/osz<zh<hi!HKg<guqjk!-kp<gjtBl<!F~z<gjtBl<!kl<!kjzbqZl<!
OkitqZl<! ofR<sqZl<! Slf<K! ose<X! lg<gtqmk<kqz<! .! uisgiqmk<kqz<!
OsIk<Kt<tiI/!-ui<! ‘wPk<K’!-kPg<gigk<!kl<jlOb!nIh<h{qk<Kg<!ogi{<miI/!
nkeiz<kie<! L/klqp<g<Gclge<! -ujvh<! “HKg<guqjk! -bg<gk<kqe<!
osbzitI”52! we<X! hivim<Mgqe<xiI/! sq/S/osz<zh<hi! HKg<guqRIgjt!
Dg<gh<hMk<kq! nuIgtqe<! guqjkgjtk<! ke<! -kpqz<! outqbqm<miI/! Neiz<!
-uI! ke<! osif<kg<! guqjkbig! ye<jxBl<! wPkq! outqbqmuqz<jz/! wPk<K!
-kpqz<!89!HKg<guqRIgt<!HKg<guqjkgjt!wPkqBt<teI/!oh{<!HKg<guqRI!
-vi/lQeim<sq! wPk<K! -kp<! &zl<! nxqLgl<! NgqxiI/! fi/gilvise<?! Oszl<!
klqp<fime<?!li/-jtbohVlit<!Ohie<OxiVl<!wPk<K!-kpqz<!HKg<guqjkgjt!
wPkqBt<teI/!!
!
! sq/S/osz<zh<hi?! g/fi/Sh<hqvl{qbe<?! uz<zqg<g{<{e<?! kVL! squviL/!
ou/silqfike<?! -/LVjgbe<?! sq/gegshihkq?! l/hpeqs<silq! LkziOeiI!
HKg<guqjk! hx<xqb! uqlIseg<! gm<Mjvgjt! wPkq! wPk<K! -kpqz<!
outqbqm<meI/!!
!
! “wPk<Kg<!gizk<Kh<!HKg<guqjkgt<?!klqp<!-zg<gqbk<kqz<!Gxqh<hqm<m!yV!
ujgbie!Ohig<G!nz<zK!osz<ofxqjbh<! hqvkqfqkqk<Kuh<hMk<Kgqe<xe/!fmh<H?!
fmh<Hh<! hqvs<sje?! s&gU{IU?! s&g! wPs<sq?! uip<kz<! hx<xqb! dk<Ougl<?!
fl<hqg<jg!uxm<sq?!uqvg<kq?!ug<gqvl<!Lkzqb!d{IUfqjzgTl<?!dk<kqgTg<G!
Lke<jl?! hcll<?! GxqbQM?! uiqgjt! djmh<hK?! uiIk<jkgTg<Gh<! Hkqb!
hiqli{l<!ogiMh<hK!LkzqbeUl<!ohVl<hie<jlbie!-mk<jkh<!ohXgqe<x!yV!
28 Ohig<Gkie<?!wPk<Kg<!gizk<Kh<!HKg<guqjkgtqe<!Ohig<G!NGl</!Hkqb!kml<!
we<x! osiz<zimzqz<?! wPk<K! -f<k! ujgbie! Ohig<gqjeOb!
njmbith<hMk<kqbqVg<gqxKA!hkqU!osb<kqVg<gqxK/”53!!
!
! ‘wPk<K’g<! gizg<! guqRIgt<! fmh<hqbjzBl<! wkiIk<kk<jkBl<!
%xqBt<teIA! wkqIgizl<! hx<xqs<! sqf<kqk<kiZl<! Hvm<sq?! Ohivim<ml<! Lkzqb!
d{IUgjtk<!K~{<Ml<!guqjkgjth<!hjmg<guqz<jz/!!
!
2/2/4/8/!HKg<guqjkjb!utIk<k!-kp<gt<!!
! klqp<h<! HKg<guqjkgjtk<! okimg<gg<! gizk<kqz<! sqx<xqkp<gOt!
utIk<kqVg<gqe<xe/! l{qg<ogic! )2:44*?! $xiutq! )2:4:*?! gziOligqeq! )2:53*?!
gqvil! Dpqbe<! )2:55*?! nLkSvhq! )2:59*?! sv^<ukq! )2:66*?! kiljv! )2:67*?!
wPk<K!)2:6:*?!Ofig<G!)2:75*?!gj{bipq!)2:76*?!fjm!)2:79*/!gsmkhx!)2:81*/!
Rievkl<!)2:81*?!uiel<hic!)2:82*/!u{<{r<gt<!)2:83*?!heqk<Ktqgt<!)2:84*?!J!
)2:84*?! okVg<%k<K! )2:85*?! kQhl<?! p/! OkeQ?! n0?! -zg<gqb! um<ml<?! guqRe<?!
lQm<sq?!nLkSvhq?!Shlr<gti!)2::2*!Lkzie!-zg<gqb!-kp<gt<!sqx<xqkp<gtig!
-Vf<kiZl<! HKg<guqjkgjt!utIh<hkqz<! Lkzqml<! kf<kqVg<gqe<xe/! ‘flg<Gk<!
okipqz<!guqjk?!fim<cx<G!djpk<kz<?!-jlh<ohiPKl<!OsivikqVk<kz<’!we<El<!
hivkqbiiqe<!ogit<jgjb!&zuig<gqbligg<!‘gqvil!Dpqbe<’!Wx<Xg<!ogi{<mK/!
nkeiz<! nf<k! -kp<! guqjkg<G! Lkzqml<! kf<kK/! “jguVf<kq! djph<huI!
okb<ul<A! guqRI! okb<ul<A! gmUtI! okb<ul<”! we<x! hivkqbiiqe<! uiqgjt!
&zuig<gqblig! Lgh<hqz<! ohixqk<Kg<! ogi{<m! ‘sv^<ukq’! )2:66*! Lx<Ohig<G!
-zg<gqbuikqgtqe<!-kpigk<!kqgp<f<kK/!!
!
! sqx<xqkp<gt<! sqxf<k! Ofig<gk<kqjeg<! ogi{<mjuA! sqxf<k! -zg<gqje!
njmukx<G!njx%uz<gjt!uqMk<keA!nux<jx!-kpqe<!Lkz<!hg<gk<kq<OzOb!
hqvSvl<!osb<ke/!sie<xig?! ‘gsmkhx’!we<El<!-kpqe<!Lkz<!Wm<cz<!hqvSvlie!
nxqg<jg!hqe<uVliX/!!
!
! “gsmkhx! sqf<kqg<gqxuEg<G! -e<jxb! dzgl<! uqMl<! njx%uz<gjt!
Wx<Xg<ogit<t! uf<kqVg<gqxK/! s&gk<kqe<! %m<Mh<! ohiXh<hie! gzis<sivk<kqe<!
Np!ngzr<gjt!-zg<gqbk<kqz<!gim<m!gsmkhx!uf<kqVg<gqxK!/!/!/!wjkBl<!
29 osb<Br<gt<?! Neiz<! -zg<gqbligs<! osb<Br<gt<! we<X! lm<MOl! gsmkhx!
osiz<Zl</”54!!
!
! Rieg<%k<ke<?! hizGlive<?! gzih<hqiqbi?! fQzl{q?! Jviukl<!
w <̂/juk<kQ̂ <uve<?! g/fi/Sh<vl{<bl<?! fGze<?! kVL! n'h<! squvil<?!
ss<sqkief<kl<?! Ou/lizq?! Ogi/vi\ivil<?! gr<jgogi{<mie<?! gz<bi{<\q?!
w <̂/Og/Nk<lifil<! Lkzie! HKg<guqRIgt<! gsmkhx! -kpqz<! guqjkgjt!
wPkqBt<teI/!!
! -Vhkil<!F~x<xi{<cz<!sqx<xqkp<gt<!-zg<gqbk<kqx<G!–!HKg<guqjkg<Gh<!
ohVl<hr<gqje! ntqk<Kt<te/! guqjk?! sqXgjk?! guqjkk<! kqxeib<U?!
-zg<gqbk<! kqxeib<U! Lkzieju! sqx<xqkp<gtqz<! outqbqmh<ohx<Xt<te/!
hz<OuX! gizr<gtqz<! hz<OuX! dbiqb! Ofig<gr<gTg<gigk<! klqp<! -zg<gqb!
-kp<gt<!okimr<gh<ohx<Xt<te/!sie<xig!Lz<jz!-kpqz<!outquf<k!ye<jxg<!
%xzil</!!
!
! “-eqk<! klqpisqiqbIgm<Gk<kie<! Lkzqml</! -eq! nuIgTl<! kjzjl!
NsqiqbI!Ngzil</!We<@!nuIgOt!kjzjl!NsqiqbIgtig!uv!Ou{<Ml<!we<x!
fqjzjlBl<! Wx<hMl<”! )Lz<jz! -kp<! 8?! h/7*! we<X! 2:56-z<! wPf<k!
-u<Ou{<MOgit<! gjzRI! L/gV{ifqkq! nuIgt<! Lkz<uvig! -Vf<kgijz!
fqjxOuxq?!-e<X!klqpisqiqbIgt<!kjzjlbisqiqbIgtigk<!kqgp<ujkh<!hiIg<g!
LcgqxK/! Lz<jz! -kpqe<! klqp<?! klqpisqiqbI! dbIU! Ou{<MOgit<gt<! hz!
hqe<eim<gtqz<!sm<mligqBt<tjk!fe<xqBme<!Sm<m!Ou{<Ml</”55!!
!
! wPk<K! )2:6:*?!Ofig<G! )2:75*?!fjm!)2:79*?!guqRe<! )2:7:*?!uiel<hic!
)2:82*?!u{<{r<gt<! )2:83*?!heqk<Ktqgt<! )2:84*?!J!)2:84*?!okVg<%k<K!)2:85*!
Lkzie!-kp<gt<!HKg<guqjk!utIs<sqg<gigOu!okimr<gh<!ohx<Xt<te/!kQhl<!
)2:76*! -kpqz<! f/hqs<s&Ik<kq?! fi/gilvise<?! =OviM! klqpe<he<?! L/Olk<ki?!
gzih<iqbi?! o\bgif<ke<! LkziOeiI! guqjkgjt! wPkqBt<teI/! klqpqz<!
guqjk! we<xiz<! nK! HKg<guqjkjbOb! Gxqg<Gl<! fqjz! 2:81gtqz<!
dVuibqx<X/!-f<fqjz!dVuigs<!sqx<xqkp<gt<!ohVl<hr<gix<xqBt<te/!!
!
30 2/2/4/9/!HKg<guqjkbqz<!ucug<!Ogizr<gt<!
! HKg<guqjk! ucuk<kqz<! guqjk! lm<Ml<! uvuqz<jzA! fimgl<?!
ohVr<gih<hqbl<?! sqXgih<hqbl<?! Hkqel<?! sqXgjk?! gck! -zg<gqbl<! Ngqb!
-zg<gqb!ujggTl<!wPkh<ohx<Xt<te/!!
! klqp<fime<!.!OkipOv!OkipOv!)fimgl<*!–!2:89!
L/Olk<ki!.!-v{<mil<!ueuisl<!)fimgl<*!–!2:93!
fqIlzi!SOv]<!.!WS!ligiuqbl<!)ohVr<giuqbl<*!–!3111!!
juvLk<K!–!guqvi\e<!gjk!)sqXgih<hqbl<*!–!2::1!
L/Olk<ki!–!ose<je!sqiqg<gqxK!)sqXgjk*!–!2:93!
L/Olk<ki!–!outqs<sl<!outqOb!-z<jz!)sqXgjk*!–!2:93!
! 2:81gTg<Gh<! hqxGkie<! HKg<guqjkbqz<! ucug<Ogizr<gt<! lzIgqe<xe/!
guqjkbqe<! kjzh<Hgt<! g{qkl<?! nxquqbz<! Lkzieux<xqe<! $k<kqv!
ucur<gtqz<!gi{h<ohXgqe<xe/!!
!7
22
45
2MCE 46!
! n'h<! squvilqe<! 2MCE ! we<El<! kjzh<hqzie! guqjk! yV!
uqR<Rieg<! guqjk! we<X! sqx<hq! hizSh<hqvl{qbl<! Gxqh<hqMgqe<xiI/! -f<kg<!
guqjk!hx<xq!nuI!uqtg<GuK!-u{<!Ofig<gk<kg<gK/!!
!
! “hvf<k! n{<mh<! ohVoutqbqzqVf<K! guqReqe<! Ofig<G! n[uqe<!
jlbk<Kg<G! uqjvgqxK/! hqVl<li{<mLl<! hvli[Ul<! wz<ziOl! sg<kqbqe<!
fmeOljm!nz<zui@! ‘ohiVt<! sqjkf<kiz<! sg<kqA! sg<kq! Guqf<kiz<! ohiVt<’! .!
-f<kh<!Hkqb!kk<Kuk<kqjeg<!%If<K!hiIg<gqxK!guqjk/!
! sg<kq!!\ml<!!ytqOugl<3!) 2MCE *!
n[g<gt<!Guqf<k!!
\mh<ohiVt<!biUl<!!
sg<kqbqe<!szel<!!
ytqbqe<!gkqjb!!
ytqbqe<!gkqbiz<!!
ohVg<gqb!Ougl<!
31
\mk<jkh<!H{If<kiz<!
\mOl!sg<kq/!
fl<! g{<Le<! hivkqbqe<! ‘gizlil<! uek<kqz<! n{<mg<Ogizli! lvk<kqe<lQK!
gitqsg<kq!we<x!ohbI!ogi{<m!uqbh<Hg<!gim<sq!uqiqgqe<xK/!!
!
! -f<k!nx<Hklie!d{<jl! –!nÑv! g{qk!ucuqz<! \mligqg<! gqmf<k!
d{<jl?! 2:56! Nl<! N{<M! aqOvisqli?! figsigqbqz<! sg<kqbqe<! hqvtbligq!
ouck<K!fq'h{l<!NgqxK?!vihIm<!Yhe<aqlI!we<x!n[!uqR<Rieq!‘Brighter
than thousand Suns’ we<x! gQjk! olipqbqz<! uV{qk<k! n[G{<Mh<! Ohovitq!
aqOvisqliuqe<!-kbk<kqz<!htQiqm<mK/!guqRI!%XgqxiI;!!
2:56!!
aqOvi]qli!figsigq!!
\mOl!sg<kq!!
g{<{x<x!!
$Ibh<!Ohizqgt<!!
ogg<gzqk<K!!
okiMuie<ujv!sqkXl<!!
g{Ofv!fqpz<gt<!/!/!/!
w{<{x<x! liEm! dbqIgjtg<! gVg<gqg<! Gjzk<K! –! gkqiqbg<gk<kiz<!
kjzLjxbig! nr<gaQeIgtig<gq! –! vk<kLl<! g{<{QVl<! ofVh<H! fkqbqz<!
sr<glqg<g! –! lifgvl<! l{<Olmib<s<! SMgimib<h<! ohiSr<g! /! /! /! Je<̂ <Ceqe<!
sil<bl<!‘\mOl!sg<kq’!fq'h{l<!Ngquqm<mK/!l{<jm!YMgt<!ogg<gzqg<gqe<xe/!!
hsqk<K!
osk<Kg<!ogi{<cVg<Gl<!
squeqe<!!
ghizk<Kg<!
ogg<gzqh<H!!
osb<kq! hxf<kK! Je< <̂CEg<G/! g{g<ogMk<Kh<! hiIk<Okil<! .! dr<gt<! nÑv!
g{qkl<!aqOvi]qli!figsigqbqz<!fq'h{l<!Ngquqm<mK!/!/!/!!
-js!outqbqe<!sqxG!lcf<K!!
gVuq!\mligqxK/!!
hqbiOeiuqe<!^<Vkq!l{<mzl<!
ouxqs<Osicg<!gqmg<gqxK!
32
dzgqe<!Lvm<M!-Vtqz<!!
wr<Ogi!yV!Gpf<jk!nPgqxK!!
Je<̂ <Ceqe<!g{<{QIk<!Ktqbqz<!
okxqg<gqxK!hiqkq/!
! sikjebigh<! hqxf<k! yV! Oljkbqe<! uqR<Ries<! sqf<kje?! g{<{QIg<!
gjx! hcf<k! Osikjebig! Lcf<k! yV! uvzix<xs<! sl<hul<?! n'h<! squvilqe<!
guqjkbigh<! h,k<kqVg<gqxK/! yV! g{h<! hiIjubig! ytqs<sqkxz<gOtiM!
dVuigqbqVg<Gl<! -f<k! uqR<Rieg<! guqjk! klqPg<G! uvOux<Hg<Giqb! yV!
HKjl/”58!!
!
! guqjkk<! kjzh<Hgt<! ohiVt<! kvik! yx<jx! wPk<kqeiZl<! sqz!
GxqgtiZl<!njlf<Kt<te/!!
.!r<!.59!!
@!5:!
%m<mz<! g{g<G! njlh<hqz<! HKg<guqjkbqe<! F~Zl<! guqjkk<! kjzh<Hl<!
kvh<ohx<Xt<te/!!
geUgt<!!gx<hjegt<!!gigqkr<gt<!)lQvi.F~z<*61!!
Gf<kq!!Oliq!!Gh<hl<lit<!)W/ok/Sh<jhbe<?!guqjk*62!
guqjkbqe<!$g<Glh<!ohiVjtk<!K~zh<!ohiVtigg<!gim<Ml<!ucug<!Ogizr<gt<!
gi{h<ohXgqe<xe/!-vuqz<!ohiKuig!fqjeU!npqb!hqxG!dxg<gl<!uVujkk<!
kq/Osi/Ou[Ogihize<?!!
fqjeU!!
! n!
! ! pq!
! ! ! b!
hqe<!fqk<kqjv63!
we<El<! uiq! ucur<gtqz<! gim<Mgqe<xiI/! -f<k! ucu! njlh<hqz<! ‘npqb’!
we<hjk!ohiKuigk<kie<!uisqg<g!LcBl</!nkjeh<!Ohiz!fqjeUl<!olKuig!
npqgqe<xK/!
wm<Mg<giz<!h,s<sq!!
! ! ! ujz!!
! ! ! l<!!!uq!!
! ! ! G!g<!iq64!
33 -f<k! uiqgt<! gVk<kqje! uculig<gqg<! gim<Mgqe<xe/! sqk<kqvg<! guqbqz<!
gVk<Kg<Gl<! ucuk<Kg<Gl<! ohiVk<kl<! -Vg<giK/! HKg<guqjkbqe<! ucug<!
Ogizk<kqx<Gl<!guqjkbqe<!gVk<Kg<Gl<!ohiVk<kl<!-Vg<gqe<xK/!sie<X;!!
njz!! Yb<!! ! z<jz65!!
! gt<! !!!ukq!
!
2/2/5/!mie<gi!guqjk!
! sh<hie<!fim<M!lvHg<!guqjk!ucur<gTt<!ye<X!mie<gi!(Tanka)!NGl</!
-kqz<!Jf<K!uiqgt<!-Vg<Gl</!-f<k!Jf<K!uiqgTl<!LjxOb!6.8.6.8.8!we<El<!
w{<{qg<jg! ogi{<m! njsgjth<! )dbqi<! yzqgt<*! ohx<xqVg<Gl</!
kqVuisgk<kqz<!uVl<!uqei!uqjm!njlh<hie!kqVs<sipjzh<!Ohiz?!mie<giuqe<!
Lkz<! &e<xcgt<! uqeik<okimI! njlh<jhBl<! -Xkq! -v{<M! ncgt<! nf<k!
uqeiuqx<G!uqjm!%Xl<!njlh<jhBl<!ohx<xqVg<Gl</!-f<k!ucuk<kqZl<!klqpqz<!
guqjkgt<!hjmg<gh<ohXgqe<xe/!!
!
2/2/6/!ja%!guqjk!!
! sh<hie<! fim<cz<! ‘mie<gi’uqx<G! nMk<Kk<! Okie<xqb! guqjk! ucul<!
‘ja%’!NGl</! ja%uqe<! ujvbjx!&e<X!ncgjth<! ohx<xqVg<Gl</!nf<k!
ncgt<! LjxOb! 6.8.6! we<El<! njs! )dbqovizq*! w{<{qg<jgjbh<!
ohx<xqVg<Gl</! ja%juk<! klqPg<G! Lke<Lkzqz<! nxqLgh<hMk<kqbuI!
hivkqbiI! NuiI/! ja%uqe<! Lkz<! -v{<M! ncgt<! Yi<! wkqIhiIh<jh!
outqh<hMk<Kl</! &e<xiuK! nc! nf<k! wkqIhiIh<hqx<G! LcU! %Xukig!
njlf<kqVg<gqe<xK/!!
!
! “Lkzqv{<M! ncgTl<! si<u! fqkieLme<! wMh<H?! okiMh<hig! uf<K?!
&e<xiuK! nc! Lk<kib<h<H! Lch<hig! uqp! Ou{<Ml<! we<hK! ja%! fqbkq”66!
we<X! S/Lk<K! %Xgqe<xiI/! Neiz<! klqpqz<! hjmg<gh<ohXl<! ohVl<hizie!
ja%! guqjkgtqz<! 6.8.6! we<El<! dbqvjs! w{<{qg<jg! ujvbjx!
hqe<hx<xh<hmuqz<jz/!sie<X;!!
djph<hqz<!Lke<jl!
uip<g<jgbqz<!gjmsq!!
djph<hue<!uip<g<jg!/!/!/67!
34 ! ja%! ucul<! klqp<olipqbqzqVf<K! sQek<kqx<Gl<! sQe! olipqbqzqVf<K!
sh<hie<! olipqg<Gl<! ose<X?!lQ{<Ml<! klqPg<G!uf<Kt<tK!we<El<!Nvib<s<sqg<!
gVk<Kl<! fqzUgqe<xK/! klqp<! -zg<gqbk<kqz<! gi{h<ohXl<! sqf<kqbz<! ou{<hi!
ucuk<kqe<! kqiqf<k!lix<xOl!ja%!ucul<! we<Xl<! gVkh<hMgqe<xK/!nkeiz<!
nh<Kz<! vGlie<! ‘sqf<kI’! we<X! ja%! guqjkgjtg<! Gxqh<hqMgqe<xiI/!
okiz<gih<hqbl<! Gxqh<hqMl<! ‘nl<jl’! we<El<! ueh<hqx<Gl<! ‘sqf<kqbz<! ou{<hi’!
njlh<hqx<Gl<!ja%!njlh<hqx<Gl<!fqjxb!yx<Xjlgt<!dt<te/!!
!
! ja%juh<! hivkqbii<! ‘oaig<G’! guqjk! we<gqxiI/! -kjek<!
klqp<h<hMk<kq! nb<g<%?! Jg<%?! sqf<kI?! Ktqh<hi?! fXg<Ggt<?! uileg<! guqjk?!
Gg<%?! lqe<lqeqg<! guqjk! we<El<! hz! ohbIgjtg<! guqRIgt<!
hbe<hMk<Kgqe<xeI/!ja%!guqjkjb!yVLjx!hck<kiz<!OlOzim<mligk<kie<!
ohiVt<! uqtr<Gl</! nkeiz<! Gjxf<kK! -VLjxbiuK! hck<kiz<kie<?!
guqjkbqe<!Np<f<k!ohiVjt!d{vLcBl</!nh<Kz<!vGlie<?!“dzgg<!guqjk!
ucur<gtqOzOb! weg<G! lqgUl<! hqck<kK! ja%kie<”68! we<X! olipquKl<!
-u{<!Ofig<gk<kg<gkiGl</!
!
2/2/7/!ose<iqB!!
! sh<hie<! fim<M! lvHg<! guqjk! jagib<! .! ofi! –! ovr<giuqzqVf<K!
Okie<xqbK!ose<iqB!guqjkbiGl</!-K!ja%juh<! Ohiz!&e<X!ncgjtg<!
ogi{<m! guqjkbiGl</! sie<X;! “ja%uqe<! nr<gk! ucul<! ose<iqB/! ja%?!
-bx<jg!dzgqz<!hiIju!osZk<KgqxK!weqz<!lg<gt<?!ohiVt<gt<?!sl<hur<gt<!
Ngqbux<xqe<lQK! hiIjujbg<! Guqh<hK! ose<iqB”6:! we<X! klqpe<he<! ja%!
guqjkbqe<! hiMohiVjtBl<! ose<iqB! guqjkbqe<! hiMohiVjtBl<!
OuXhMk<kqg<!gim<Mgqe<xiI/!!
!
2/2/8/!jaHe<!.!zqliqg<!.!zqoljvg<%!.!g^z<!guqjkgt<!
! ja%Ul<! nz<zilz<! ose<iqBUl<! nz<zilz<! djvfjmk<! ke<jl!
ogi{<m!guqjk! ‘jaHe<’!NGl</! ose<iqBuqzqVf<K! Okie<xqb! Osb<g<! guqjk!
‘zqliqg<’! (Limerik)! we<El<! guqjk! ucul</! -0K! Jf<kcgjtg<! ogi{<m!
guqjkbiGl</!!
!
35 ! zqliqg<!!ja%!gzf<k!ucul<!zqljvg<%!(Limeraiku)!guqjk!ucul<!
NGl</! -kqz<! 6.8.6! we<El<! njs! w{<{qg<jg! ogi{<m! &e<xc! guqjkbqz<!
zqliqg<gqe<! Yjs! gzf<K! uVl<OhiK! nK! zqoljvg<%! guqjkbigqe<xK/!
zqoljvg<%!guqjkgtqz<!sf<kLl<!nr<gkLl<!-ml<ohx<Xt<te/!sie<X;!=OviM!
klqpe<heqe<!“ose<eqljzg<!gqtqObih<hik<vig<gt<”!we<El<!F~ziGl</!!
!
! guqk<Kul<! fqjxf<k! djvfjmg<! gm<MjvBl<! nke<! Lcuqz<! yV!
ja%Ul<! njlf<kiz<! nkx<G! ‘jaHe<’! we<X! ohbI/! lvHg<! gm<Mh<hiMgt<!
Ohigh<! Ohigg<! Gjxf<K! ja%uqzqVf<K! ose<iqBl<?! nkqzqVf<K! zqliqg<Gl<?!
nke<! uti<s<sqbig! zqoljvg<%Ul<?! Le<hGkq! djvfjmBl<! hqe<hGkq!
guqjkBl<! njlf<k! jaHe<El<! dVuigqBt<te/! Nr<gqz! -zg<gqbk<kqe<!
kig<gk<kqeiz<!klqpqz<!HKg<guqjk!Okie<xqbKOhiz?!sh<hie<!fim<M!-zg<gqbk<!
kig<gk<kqeiz<! klqpqz<! zqliqg<?! zqoljvg<%?! jaHe<! Lkzie! guqjk!
ucur<gt<!Okie<xqBt<te/!
!
! ‘g^z<’! (Ghazal)! nvhqbqz<! nVl<hqh<! hivsQgk<kqz<! Ohikigq! dVKuqz<!
lzIf<K! l{l<! uQSl<! -zg<gqb! ucul<! NGl</! g^z<! we<xiz<! ‘gikzqBme<!
OhSkz<’! we<X! nvH! olipqbqz<! ohiVtiGl<! /! /! /! ‘g^z<’! -v{<mcg<!
g{<{qgtiz<!NeK/!yV!g{<{qg<Gl<!nkjek<!okimIf<K!uVl<!g{<{qg<Gl<!
gVk<Kk<! okimIH! -Vg<g! Ou{<Ml<! we<x! nusqblqz<jz/71! sie<X;! nh<Kz<!
vGlieqe<!“lqe<lqeqgtiz<!yV!gckl<”!)g^z<!guqjkk<!okiGh<H*!NGl</!
!
! -u<uiX! outqfim<Mg<! guqjkgtqe<! kig<gk<kqeiz<! klqp<olipqbqZl<!
use!guqjk?!HKg<guqjk?!ja%!guqjk?!zqliqg<!guqjk?!ose<iqB!guqjk?!
g^z<!guqjk!Lkzie!guqjk!ujggt<!-bx<xh<hm<M!uVgqe<xe/!!
!
! use! guqjkbi! HKg<guqjkbi! we<X! Jbl<! Okie<Xl<! ntuqx<G!
-e<jxb! HKg<guqjkgtqz<! sqz! gi{h<ohXgqe<xe/! -e<jxg<G! use!
guqjkgjtBl<! HKg<guqjkbqe<! yV! hqiquigOu! Wx<Xg<ogit<t! Ou{<Ml<!
we<hK! lQvi! Ohie<Oxiiqe<! gVk<kiGl</! -g<gizh<! HKg<guqjkgtqz<! use!
guqjkbqe<! uiqgTl<! use! guqjkgtqz<! HKg<guqjk! njlh<Hl<! gzf<K!
gi{h<ohXgqe<xe/! ja%?! ose<iqB! Lkzie! guqjk! -zg<gqb! lvhqje!
lQxqBl<!klqpqz<!ja%!guqjkgt<!hjmg<gh<ohx<X!uVgqe<xe/!
36 2/3/!okiGh<Hjv!
! gizf<OkiXl<! klqp<g<! guqjkbqe<! dVuLl<! dt<tmg<gLl<! lix<xl<!
ohx<X! uf<kqVg<gqe<xe/! lix<xl<! ohx<x! nju! klqp<g<! guqjkbqe<! uvzix<xqz<!
lvhigqBt<te/! -f<kqbiuqz<! Nr<gqOzbI! uVjgbqeiz<! olipq?! -zg<gqbl<?!
nvsqbz<?! d{U?! djm! Lkzieux<xqz<! hz! lix<xr<gt<! d{<mibqe/!
nux<jxh<! Ohizk<! klqp<g<! guqjk! lvhqZl<! Nr<gqzg<! guqjkgtqe<! kig<gl<!
Wx<hm<mkiz<?! HKg<guqjk! Okie<xqBt<tK/! hzolipqgjtg<! gx<xxqf<k! lgiguq!
Sh<hqvl{qb! hivkqbiiqe<! use! guqjkbieK! klqp<h<! HKg<guqjkg<G!
Le<Oeicbib<k<!kqgp<gqe<xK/!!
!
! klqp<h<! HKg<guqjkbqe<! dVuk<kqx<Gl<! dVuig<gk<kqx<Gl<! &zlig!
f/hqs<s&Ik<kq! uqtr<Ggqe<xiI/! okimg<gk<kqz<! HKg<guqjk! wPkqbuIgt<!
dVuk<kqx<Og! Lke<jl! ogiMk<keI/! nuIgt<! guqjkgtqe<! dt<tmg<gl<!
lvHg<guqjk! dt<tmg<gligUl<! kk<KuligUl<! -Vf<ke/! okimg<gg<! gizh<!
HKg<guqjkgt<!ofgqp<s<sqbigUl<!use!guqjkgtigUl<!gi{h<hMgqe<xe/!!
!
! HKg<guqjkbqz<! hbqx<sqBl<! Lbx<sqBl<! djmb! HKg<guqRIgtqe<!
guqjkgt<! SVr<gs<! osiz<zq! uqtr<g! jug<Gl<! Nx<xZme<! osxquigUl<!
djvuQs<S!Gjxf<Kl<!guqjkk<!ke<jl!lqGf<Kl<!gi{h<hMgqe<xe/!
!
! HKg<guqRIgt<! kr<gtqe<! okimg<gg<! gizg<! guqjkgjt! uiv.lik!
-kp<gtqz<! outqbqm<meI/! hqxG! keqF~zig! outqbqm<meI/! HKg<guqRIgjt!
Dg<gh<hMk<kqb! ohVjlBl<! HKg<guqjkgjt! outqbqm<M! utIk<k! HgPl<!
HKg<guqjkgjtk<! kqxeib<U! osb<K! hiIk<k! lgqp<s<sqBl<! -zg<gqb!
-kp<gtigqb!sqx<xqkp<gjtOb!siVl</!
!
! HKg<guqjkg<G!bih<hqzg<g{g<!gm<Mh<hiM!-z<zikkiz<?! HKg<guqRIgt<!
HKh<HK! ucur<gtqz<! fqgp<giz! fqgp<s<sqgjtBl<! hqvs<sjegjtBl<!
sqg<gz<gjtBl<! okie<lg<! %XgjtBl<! kr<gt<! hjmh<Hgtqz<! hjmk<K!
uVgqe<xeI/! nvsqbz<?! sLkibl<?! olipq?! uip<g<jg?! gz<uq?! oh{<[iqjl?!
slk<Kul<?!ui<g<gh<!Ohivim<ml<?!uXjl?!Oujzbqz<zik<!kq{<mim<ml<?!Gpf<jkk<!
okipqzitI!hqvs<sje?!LkqObiI! hqvs<sje?!lix<Xk<!kqxeitqgtqe<! hqvs<sje?!
uqhk<K?! Ofib<?! ue<Ljx! weh<! hzkvh<hm<m! ohiV{<jlgtqz<!
37 HKg<guqjkgjtBl<! ja%! guqjkgjtBl<! g^z<! guqjkgjtBl<!
HKg<guqRIgt<! hjmk<K! uVgqe<xeI/! wf<k! yV! KjxbqZl<! lvH! lix<xl<!
we<hK!utIs<sqjbk<kie<!gim<MgqxK/!klqp<g<! guqjk!utIs<sqg<G!Nkivlib<h<!
HKg<guqjk! kqgp<gqe<xK/! klqp<g<! guqjkbqe<! utIs<sqg<G! LcU! -z<jz! ///!
utVl<! ///! utIf<K! ogi{<Om! -Vg<Gl</! nkeiz<! -e<jxb! HKg<guqjk!
hqe<oeiV!gizk<kqz<!klqpqe<!lvHg<!guqjkbigk<!kqgPl<!we<hK!kq{<{l</!!
38
sie<ox{<!uqtg<gl<!
!
2/ s/ngk<kqbzqr<gl<?!guqjk!dVuig<gl<.3?!h/35/!!
3/ uz<zqg<g{<{e<!)Olx<Ogit<*?!HKg<guqjkbqe<!Okix<xLl<!utIs<sqBl<?!h/99/!
4/ hizi?!HKg<guqjk!yV!HKh<hiIju?!h/218/!
5/ ou/-vk<kqe&Ik<kq?!okiz<gih<hqb!Ofig<gqz<!HKg<guqjk?!h/35/!
6/ sq/S/osz<zh<hi?!DKuk<kqh<!Hz<?!h/4:/!
7/ juvLk<K?!Ogt<uqgtiz<!yV!Out<uq?!h/4/!!
8/ HxfiE~X?!346/!
9/ bih<hVr<gzg<!giiqjg?!45!NuK!giiqjgg<G!djv!Olx<Ogit<!osb<Bt</!
:/ &Kjv?!5/!!
21/ uQvOsipqbl<?!241/!
22/ sq/l{q?!-Kujv!///?!h/223/!
23/ klqpe<he<?!u{g<gl<!ut<Tu"?!h/238/!
24/ S/-tr<Ogi?!gXh<H!lzIgtqz<!osf<Oke<?!h/51/!
25/ klqp<fime<!guqjkgt<?!h/236/!!
26/ g/fi/Sh<hqvl{qbe<?!f/hqs<s&Ik<kq!fqjeuig?!okiGkq!II?!h/41/!
27/ lQvi?!wkqIgizk<!klqp<g<!guqjk?!hg</39.3:/!!
28/ f/uQ/osbvile<?!HKg<guqjkbqbz<?!h/21/!
29/ uz<zqg<g{<{e<?!HKg<guqjkbqe<!Okix<xLl<!utIs<sqBl<?!h/24/!
2:/ Svki?!“wjmg<gz<”?!OfbI!uqVh<hl<!)nh<Kz<!vGlie<*?!h/8/!!
31/ f/hqs<s&Ik<kq!guqjkgt<?!h/2/!
32/ f/uQ/osbvile<?!HKg<guqjkbqbz<?!hg</37.38/!!
33/ li/Ogiuqf<kviS?!HKg<guqjkg<!gm<mjlh<H?!h/48/!
34/ sq/gegshihkq?! “HKg<guqjkbqe<! dVu! njlh<H”?! -/h/k/l/! )2:7:*!
Nb<Ug<Ogiju?!okiGkq!2?!h/235/!
35/ nh<Kz<!vGlie<?!OsikqlqG!fuguqjk?!h/23/!
36/ gi/Ogi/Our<gmvile<?!klqp<!-zg<gqb!uvziX?!h/44:/!
37/ N/osgf<fike<?!HKg<guqjk!yV!kqxeib<U?!h/25/!!
38/ li/Ogiuqf<kviS?!HKg<guqjkg<!gm<mjlh<H?!h/51/!!
39/ uz<zqg<g{<{e<!)okiG/N/*?!wPk<K!–!sq/S/osz<zh<hi?!h/328/!
3:/ sq/S/osz<zh<hi?!klqpqz<!-zg<gqb!uqlIsel<?!h/292/!
41/ sq/l{q?!-Kujv!///?!h/6:/!
39 42/ L/Olk<ki?!DIuzl<?!h/97/!
43/ klqpue<?!-Vhkqz<!guqjk?!h/249/!
44/ juvLk<K?!kqVk<kq!wPkqb!kQIh<Hgt<?!h/:/!
45/ S/-tr<Ogi?!gXh<H!lzIgtqz<!osf<Oke<?!hg</79.7:/!!
46/ ohie<l{q!juvLk<K?!sr<g!-zg<gqbk<kqz<!HKg<guqjkg<!%Xgt<?!h/:3/!
47/ hi/lkqui{e<?!ncuiel<!Ofig<gqs<!sqz!ncgt<?!hg</51.52/!!
48/ nh<Kz<!vGlie<?!OfbI!uqVh<hl<?!h/:4/!
49/ g/dlilOg <̂uiq?!guqjk!utIk<k!l{qg<ogic?!h/93/!
4:/ OlzK/?!hg</68.69/!
51/ kq/S/fmvise<?! “wPk<K”?!-zg<gqb!-kp<gt<! )h/N/?!-/Sf<kv&Ik<kq*?! hg</352.
353/!!
52/ L/klqp<g<Gclge<?!hk<ki{<Mk<!klqp<g<!guqjkgt<?!h/5/!!
53/ kq/S/fmvise<?!“wPk<K”?!-zg<gqb!-kp<gt<?!h/35:/!!
54/ uz<zqg<g{<{e<!)Olx<Ogit<*?!HKg<guqjkbqe<!Okix<xLl<!utIs<sqBl<?!h/2:9/!
55/ L/-tLVge<?!“Lz<jz”?!-zg<gqb!-kp<gt<?!h/94/!
56/ gzih<iqbi?!lx<xir<Og?!h/99/!!
57/ kVL!n'h<!squvil<?! ,"" 2MCE !!ogir<GOkI!uip<g<jg?!okiGkq!3?!h/58/!!
58/ -vi/Olige<!)h/N/*?!sqx<hqbqe<!gm<Mjvgt<?!hg</33:.341/!!
59/ gzih<iqbi?!lx<xir<Og?!h/37/!
5:/ gz<bi{<\q?!Hziq?!h/:/!!
61/ lQvi?!geUgt<!!gx<hjegt<!!gigqkr<gt<!)3112*/!!
62/ W/ok/Sh<jhbe<?!njx%uz<?!h/67/!
63/ kq/Osi/Ou[Ogihize<?!lQm<sq!uq{<{h<hl<?!h/w/-/!!
64/ fGze<?!-V!fQ{<m!guqjkgt<?!h/28/!!
65/ ]i\gie<?!hm<m!lvr<gt<?!h/69/!!
66/ S/Lk<K?!klqpqz<!ja%?!h/286/!
67/ lqk<vi?!oltel<!Slg<Gl<!uiel<?!h/224/!
68/ nh<Kz<! vGlie<?! “ja%! Yi<! nEhul<”?! \h<hieqb! ja%! )klqpqz<!
kq/zQziukq*?!hg</86.87/!!
69/ =OviM!klqpe<he<?!yV!u{<c!ose<iqB?!lVki!outqbQM?!ose<je?!3112/!!
6:/ =OviM!klqpe<he<?!gjzbi"!jguqjebi"?!h/83/!
71/ nh<Kz<!vGlie<?!lqe<lqeqgtiz<!yV!gckl<?!hg</4.6/!!
-bz<!3!
uiel<hic!-bg<gl<!.!hqe<Hzl<!
!
3/1/!LgUjv!
! klqp<s<!sqx<xqkp<gt<!klqp<h<!HKg<guqjkbqe<!Okix<xk<kqZl<!utIs<sqbqZl<!
ohVl<! hr<gqje! ugqg<gqe<xe/! l{qg<ogic! -kp<! sqXgjk?! HKg<guqjk?!
guqjkk<!kqxeib<U!Lkzieux<jx!outqbqm<M!utIk<ke/!-ux<xqz<!HKjlgt<!
Ohsh<hm<miZl<!lvhqe<!okimIs<sqBl<!gi{h<hMgqe<xe/! ‘wPk<K’!-kpqz<!wPkqb!
guqRIgt<! d{Is<sqgjts<! sqkxcg<gilz<?! yPr<GhMk<kqh<! HKg<guqjkgjth<!
hjmk<Kt<teI/! -uIgtqe<! guqjkgtqz<! Oljzfim<Mg<! guqjkgtqe<! kig<gl<?!
Oljzfim<Mg<! ogit<jggtqe<! kig<gl<?! -V{<jlh<! h{<H! Lkzieju!
gi{h<ohXgqe<xe/! wPk<Kg<! gizg<! guqRIgtqe<! guqjkgt<!
ngubh<hm<mjubigUl<!kx<siIHjmbjubigUl<!leLxqU?!uip<g<jg!ouXh<H?!
fl<hqg<jg! uxm<sq! Lkzie! wkqIljxs<! sqf<kjegjtg<! ogi{<mjubigUl<!
uqtr<Ggqe<xe/! -ux<xqx<G! lixigk<! Okix<xl<! ohx<x! -kp<kie<! “uiel<hic”!
NGl</!-f<k!-kp<! YI!-bg<gligOu!osbz<hm<mK/!-K!hx<xq!-f<k!-bzqz<!
uqtg<gh<hMgqe<xK/!
!
3/2/!uiel<hic!-!Okix<xl<!
! 2:71.81! N{<Mgtqz<! klqpgk<kqz<! hGk<kxqUs<! sqf<kjejbk<! K~{<Ml<!
kqviuqmI! gpgl<?! nvsqbzqz<! kqviuqm! Le<Oex<xg<! gpgl<?! ohiKUjmjl!
-bg<gl<!Lkzieju!kl<!ogit<jggjt!lg<gtqmk<kqz<!ogi{<M!OsIg<gs<!sqz!
dk<kqgjtg<! jgbi{<me/! nux<Xt<! Oljmh<! Ohs<Sl<?! -zg<gqbh<! hjmh<Hl<!
Gxqh<hqmk<kg<ge/!
!
! l{qg<ogic! )2:44.4:*?! $xiutq! )2:4:*?! gziOligqeq! )2:53*?! gqvil!
Dpqbe<!)2:55*?!sqf<kje!)2:58*?!OkeQ!)2:59*?!gikl<hiq!)2:59*?!sv^<ukq!)2:66*!
Lkzie! sqx<xqkp<gt<! hz! HKjlgjts<! osb<kiZl<! nvsqbz<! ogit<jggjt!
uqlIsel<! osb<keOu! kuqv?! nvsqbz<! ogit<jgjb! utIh<hkx<gigk<! kl<jl!
LPjlBl<! =MhMk<kqg<!ogit<tuqz<jz/!guqjkgjt!utIk<kiZl<!guqjkgt<!
&zl<!Gxqh<hqm<m!-bg<gk<jk!yV!Gxqh<hqm<m!nvsqbz<!gm<sqjb!utIh<hkx<Gs<!
sqx<xqkp<gt<!Le<uvuqz<jz/!sqx<xqkp<gt<!njek<Kl<!-zg<gqbk<jk!utv<g<gUl<!
fim<M!fmh<Hgjt!lg<gtqmk<kqz<!ogi{<M!OsIg<gUl<!Ljeh<hib<!-Vf<ke/!
41 ! -f<ks<!$pzqz<!kiljv!)2:67!okimg<gl<! .!-e<Xl<!lik!-kpig!uf<K!
ogi{<cVg<gqxK*! we<El<! sqx<xqkp<! ohiKUjmjlg<! ogit<jggjt!
lg<gtqmk<kqz<! ogi{<M! OsIg<Gl<! Ofig<gk<kqz<! okimr<gh<! ohx<X?! fz<z!
utIs<sqjbh<! ohx<Xt<tK/! NeiZl<! kiljvbqz<! nvsqbz<! lqGkqbigUl<!
-zg<gqbl<!GjxuigUl<!outqbibqe/!
!
! 2:6:!Nl<!N{<M!sq/S/osz<zh<hiuiz<!okimr<gh<!ohx<x!‘wPk<K’!-kpqz<!
Oleim<Mk<! kig<gr<gt<! -Vf<ke/! nkeiz<! hz! HKjlgt<! -Vf<ke/!
HKg<guqjk?! sqXgjk?! Hkqel<?! -zg<gqb! uqlIsel<!Lkzieux<xqx<G! wPk<K!
-kp<! Le<Eiqjl! ogiMk<kK/! g/fi/Sh<hqvl{qbl<! ‘-zg<gqb! um<ml<’! )2:74*!
-kjpk<! okimr<gq?! -zg<gqbr<gjt! uqlIsel<! osb<Kt<tiI/! fi/hiIk<ksivkq!
‘kQhl<’! )2:76*! -kjpBl<?! gq/g^<K~iq! vr<ge<! ‘gj{bipq’! )2:76*! -kjpBl<?!
gqV]<{silq?! f/Lk<Ksilq?! sq/l{q! NgqObiI! ‘fjm’! )2:79*! -kjpBl<!
okimr<gqg<! gm<Mjv?! gjk?! guqjk?! nvsqbz<! weh<! he<Lgh<! hiIjuBme<!
outqbqm<M!uf<keI/!
!
! f/hqs<s&Ik<kq?! sq/S/osz<zh<hi?! g/fi/Sh<hqvl{qbl<! LkziOeiI! yV!
Gxqh<hqm<m! s&gk<jks<! OsIf<kuIgt</! -uIgt<! hjmh<hkqZl<! uqlIsel<!
osb<ukqZl<! -kp<gt<! fmk<KukqZl<! uz<zuIgtig! -Vf<keI/! -uIgt<!
fmk<kqb! -kp<gTg<Gl<! outqh<hMk<kqb! gVk<Kg<gTg<Gl<! wkqIh<H!
okiquqh<hKOhiz<! YI! -kp<! okimr<gh<hm! Ou{<Ml<! we<X! yV! Gxqh<hqm<m!
-bg<gl<! ogit<jggjts<! siIf<kuIgt<! w{<{qeI/! -kx<Gg<! OgibLk<K~jvk<!
kjzjlbqmligg<!ogi{<M!osbz<hmUl<!kqm<mlqm<meI/!
!
! “Ogiju! fgvl<! fQ{<m! ofMr<gizligk<! klqp<! wPs<sqBl<! -zg<gqbk<!
kigLl<!nvsqbz<! =MhiMl<! ogi{<m! fgvl</! -f<k! F~x<xi{<ce<! okimg<gk<kqz<!
-kpqbzitVl<?! hqvl<lsli\qBl<?! klqpqe<! Lkz<! hb{! F~zisqiqbVlie!
w <̂/hq/fvsql<lZ! fiBM! -r<G! uip<f<kqVf<kiI/! squg<guql{q?! Ogijug<gqpiI!
Lkzqb! nxqRIgTl<?! oh/K~ve<?! NI/s{<LgSf<kvl<! Ohie<x! wPk<kitIgTl<!
klqp<utl<!hvh<hqb!fgvl<!Ogiju/!
!
! HKg<guqjk! -bg<gl<! utVl<! Le<Oh! -r<G! lvHg<! guqjkh<!
hjmh<hitqgt<!hzI!-br<gq!uf<keI/!nuIgtqz<!HuqbvSUl<!-tLVGl<!‘OkeQ’!
42 we<x!-kjp!2:78.2:79!Nl<!N{<Mgtqz<!fmk<kq!uf<keI/!lvHsiI!guqRIgt<!
fmk<kq!uf<k! Ogijug<!guqRI!le<xl<?! kQhl<!uisgI!um<mk<kqeqe<X!dVuie!
Ogiju! -zg<gqbh<! Ohvju?! liIg<sqbh<! hiIju! ogi{<m! gl<hvibeqe<!
Okipjlg<! gpgl<?! ohiqbiiqb! liIs<sqbh<! hijkbqz<! fjmOhim<m! sqf<kjeh<!
Ohvju?!hck<k!-jtRIgtqe<!-bg<glig!-Vf<k!h,l<ohipqz<!-zg<gqb!um<ml<!
Lkzie!-bg<gr<gt<!uiel<hicg<G!Le<Oeicbig!-br<gq!uf<ke/”2!
!
! OgibLk<K~iqz<!fz<z!uisgIgTl<!kqxeib<uitIgTl<!hjmh<hitqgTl<!
-Vg<gqe<xeI/! 2:51gtqzqVf<K! -e<Xujv! -zg<gqb! dzgqz<! OgibLk<K~I!
keqs<sqxh<hqjeh<! ohx<X! uVgqe<xK/! klqpgk<kqe<! kjzfgI! ose<jebqz<! hz!
-mr<gtqzqVf<Kl<! uf<K! kr<gq! -zg<gqbh<! h{qjbs<! osb<kiIgt</! sie<xigs<!
sq/S/osz<zh<hi! uk<kzG{<M! )kq{<Mg<gz<! lium<ml<*! we<El<! DiqzqVf<K!
ose<jeg<Gs<! ose<X! “wPk<K”! -kjpk<! okimr<gqh<! HKg<guqjk! -zg<gqb!
utIs<sqg<G! nVl<h{qbix<xqeiI/! Neiz<! ogir<G! fiM! -zg<gqbuikqgt<!
OgibLk<K~iqz<! %c! -zg<gqb! utIs<sqg<G! nVl<h{qbix<xqBt<teI/! nke<!
uqjtuigg<! OgibLk<K~iqz<! ‘OkeQ’! -zg<gqb! -kp<?! Ogiju! guqRI! le<xl<?!
Ogiju!-zg<gqbh<!Ohvju?!Okipjlg<!gpgl<?!sqf<kjeh<!Ohvju?!h,l<ohipqz<!
-zg<gqb! um<ml<! Lkzie! -zg<gqb! njlh<Hgt<! Okie<xqk<! klqp<! -zg<gqbh<!
hjmh<HgjtBl<! kqxeib<UgjtBl<! utIk<ke/! nux<xqe<! ws<slig! <̂mizqe<!
G{Osgve<!we<huviz<!okimr<gh<!ohx<x!“lg<gt<!sqf<kjeh<!Ohvju”!=Ovim<cz<!
-e<Xl<! sqxh<hig! fjmohx<X! uVgqe<xK/! -f<k! njlh<H! klqpgl<! kPuqb!
fqjzbqz<! -zg<gqbh<! hjmh<HgjtBl<?! uqlIser<gjtBl<?! nxqRIgtqe<!
uip<uqbjzBl<! lg<gtqmk<Kl<! li{uIgtqmk<Kl<! ogi{<M! OsIk<K!uVgqe<xK/!
nke<! yV! hGkqbig! N{<MOkiXl<! =Ovim<cz<! “Hk<kgk<! kqVuqpi”! lqgs<!
sqxh<high<! hk<K! fim<gTg<GOlz<! fjmohx<X! uVgqe<xK/! -f<k! njlh<H! hz!
gVk<kvr<GgjtBl<! gjzfqgp<s<sqgjtBl<! fmk<kq! uVgqe<xK/! N{<MOkiXl<!
lqgs<!sqxf<k!-zg<gqbk<!oki{<mIgTg<G!uqVK!upr<gqk<!klqp<!nxqRIgjth<!
Ohix<xq!uVgqe<xK/!
!
! l{qg<ogic?! wPk<K?! gsmkhx! Lkzie! -kp<gtqz<! outqbie!
HKg<guqjkgtqe<! ohiV{<jljb! yVsiviI! Wx<guqz<jz/! Olx<Gxqk<k!
-kp<gtqz<! Lkzitqk<Kuk<jk! wkqIg<Gl<! hjmh<Hgt<! outqbqmuqz<jz/!
slk<Kul<?! ohiKUjmjlh<! hjmh<HgTl<! gi{h<ohxuqz<jz/! -ux<jx!
43 outqbqm<M! lg<gtqml<! ose<X! OsIh<hkx<gig! YI! -bg<gk<jkBl<! -kjpBl<!
okimr<g!Ou{<Ml<!we<X!yVsiviI!sqf<kqk<kiIgt</!nuIgtqe<!sqf<kje!oux<xq!
ohx<xOk!“uiel<hic”!-bg<gLl<!-kPl<!NGl</!
!
! uiel<hic! -bg<gk<kqz<! HuqbvS?! -tLVG?! Rieq! gq/hpeqs<silq?!
Sf<kvl<?! ng<gqeqHk<kqve<! )gez<! jlf<ke<*?! Lz<jz! Nkue<?! gr<jg!
ogi{<mie<?! sqx<hq! hizSh<hqvl{qbl<?!L/Olk<ki?!lQvi/!sg<kqg<gez<?!klqp<fime<?!
fqk<kqze<! LkziOeiI! uiel<hic! -bg<gk<kqjek<! okimr<Gukx<Gk<!
kqm<mlqm<meI/! uiel<hic! -bg<gl<! siIhqz<! ‘uiel<hic’! -kpqjek<! okimr<gqk<!
kr<gt<! gVk<Kg<gjtBl<! ogit<jggjtBl<! outqbqm! Ljef<keI/! nke<!
uqjtuig?! 1:/21/2:82! ne<X! “uiel<hic”! Lkz<! -kp<! OgijubqzqVf<K!
outqbqmh<!ohx<xK/!
!
! “Ogijug<! guqRIgtqe<! %m<mjlh<hqx<G! uiel<hic! we<X! ohbI!
$m<cbuI! -tLVG/! klqp<! %Xl<! fz<Zzgk<kqe<! fix<xqjsbqZl<! hxf<K!
hiIg<gzil<! we<X! uiel<hic?! -kp<! ucul<! ohx<x! uiel<hic! liEml<! hiMl<!
uiel<hic! Nbqx<X/! uiel<hicg<G! ‘liEmk<jk! n{quqk<kuI! guqRI! sqx<hq’”3!
we<X!klqp<fime<!%Xgqe<xiI/!
!
! HuqbvS?! -tLVG?! sqx<hq?! Rieq! LkziOeiI! uiel<hic! -bg<gl<!
okimr<Gukx<G!wMk<k!Lbx<sqbqe<!hbeig!2:82!Nl<!N{<M!ng<OmihI!:!Nl<!
fit<! Ogiju! osR<sqZjus<! sr<gg<! gm<mmk<kqz<! uiel<hic! Lkz<! -kp<!
outqbQm<M! uqpi! fjmohx<xK/! nf<k! uqpiuqx<Gk<! klqpxqRI! l/vi/Ohi/GVsilq!
kjzjl!Wx<xiI/!
!
! uiel<hic!-bg<gl<!ke<!ogit<jggjtg<!guqjk!ucuk<kqz<!outqbqm!
“uiel<hic”! we<El<! -kjpk<! okimr<gqbK/! hqxG?! nf<k! -bg<gl<! s&gs<!
sqf<kjeBt<t! wPk<kitIgtqe<! -bg<gligUl<! guqjkh<! hjmh<higUl<!
dVuieK/!
!
44 3/2/2/!uiel<hic!.!hqe<Hzl<!
! -f<kqbk<! kqVfiM! out<jtbIgtqmlqVf<K! uqMkjz! ohXukx<gig!
uqMkjz! -bg<gl<! dVuig<gh<hm<mK/! -f<kqb! lg<gt<! sLkibk<kqz<! hz!
sqg<gz<gtqzqVf<K!uqMhMl<!ohiVm<M!hz!-bg<gr<gt<!dVuig<gh<hm<me/!hivkq!
-bg<gl<?!kqviuqm!-bg<gl<?!ohiKUjmjl!-bg<gl<?!oh{<!uqMkjz!-bg<gl<?!
Ne<lQg! -bg<gl<?! fik<kqg! -bg<gl<?! kzqk<! uqMkjz! -bg<gl<! weh<! hz!
njlh<Hgt<! sLkib! lg<gtqe<! utIs<sqg<gig! nVl<h{qbix<xq! uVgqe<xe/!
-ux<jxh<! Ohizh<! ohiKUjmjlg<! ogit<jgjb! utIk<K! slk<Kul<! Oh{!
Ou{<Ml<! we<El<! Ofig<gk<kqz<! wPf<k! -bg<gl<kie<! “uiel<hic”! -bg<gl<!
NGl</! uiel<hic! Okix<xk<kqe<! hqe<Hzl<! hx<xqh<! hjmh<hitIgTl<!
kqxeib<uitIgTl<! hz<OuX! gVk<Kg<gjth<! hkqU! osb<Kt<teI/! nux<Xt<!
sqzux<jx! -r<Gg<! Gxqh<hqMuke<! &zl<! uiel<hic! dVuie! hqe<Hzk<jk!
nxqf<K!ogit<t!LcBl</!
!
! “uiel<hicjb!YI!-bg<gligk<kie<!ogi{<M!uf<Okil</!-bg<gl<!kiOe!
ypqb! -kp<! ne<X/! -bg<gk<kqe<! gVk<Kg<gjt! outqh<hMk<kk<kie<! -kp</!
-bg<gl<!we<hK!wf<k!ujgbqz<!we<xiz<?!we<jeh<!ohiXk<kujvg<Gl<!-zg<gqb!
-bg<gl<kie</! gm<sqObiM! nkx<Gk<! okimIhqz<jz/! Neiz<! gm<sq! nEkihqgt<!
nkx<Gt<!-Vf<keI”!!
.!-tLVG/!
!
! “-bg<gl<! we<X! Lkzqz<! osiz<zuqz<jz/! uiel<hicgt<! we<Xkie<!
osiz<zqg<! ogi{<cVf<Okil</! uqlIseg<! %m<mr<gTl<! guqjk! Nb<UgTl<!
okimIf<K! fmf<ke/! guqjkbqz<! we<oee<e! osb<kqgjt! wMk<Ks<! osz<z!
Ou{<Ml<! we<x! hqvs<sjegt<! wr<gTg<G! uf<ke/! nux<jx! wr<gTg<Gt<!
uqiquigh<! Ohsqg<! ogi{<Omil</! hz! kqjsgtqz<! -Vf<K! uf<kuIgt<! we<xiZl<?!
fiTg<G! fit<! yVLgh<hm<m! sqz! Ohig<Ggt<! dVuibqe/! nf<k! ucuk<kqz<!
hk<kqiqjg!we<hK!uf<kK/!Lkz<!-v{<M!N{<Mgt<!nOfglig!wm<M!nz<zK!
ye<hK! -kp<gt<! Lcgqe<xujv! yVLgk<! ke<jl! we<hK! OlOzir<gqbqVf<kK!
we<X! fie<! fqjeg<gqOxe</! -kje! -bg<gl<! we<X! osiz<zzil</! fir<gt<!
-h<hch<! ohbI! juk<Kg<! ogit<tiuqm<miZl<! -bg<gl<! we<X! fqs<sbligs<!
osiz<zzil</! -bg<glig! nMk<k! gm<mk<kqx<Gs<! osz<z! Ou{<cb! $pz<! uf<k!
45 OhiK?! nK! yV! likqiqbigs<! sqjkf<Kuqm<mK/! sqjkf<k! hqxG! gjmsqbigh<!
HuqbvS?!sqx<hq!Ohie<xuIgtqe<!jgg<G!nf<kh<!hk<kqiqjg!OhieK/”!!
-!Ogiju!Rieq!
!
! “uiel<hic! YI! -bg<gl<kie</! -bg<gk<kqx<gie! YI! -kpigk<kie<! nK!
outquf<kK/! nkiuK! guqjk! -bg<gl<! lik<kqvl<! nz<z/! nkx<Gh<! hqe<eiz<!
yV! s&gh<! hqvg<jR! dt<t! wPk<kitIgTjmb! -bg<gligk<kie<! nK!
okimr<gqbK/”!
.!sqx<hq!hizSh<hqvl{qbl<!
!
! “uiel<hic! -bg<gk<kqeI! Nvl<hk<kqz<! hivkqbqe<! g{<O{im<mk<jkh<!
ohx<xeI/! hqxG! gizh<Ohig<gqz<! uqlIser<gTl<! uquikr<gTl<! fqgp<f<ke/!
liIg<sqbk<! kk<Kug<! g{<O{im<mk<kqz<! sLkibh<! hqvs<sjegjtg<! g{<M!
guqjkbig<GuK! we<x! gVk<Kl<! Le<jug<gh<hm<mK/! -f<k! fqjzjlbqz<!
nvsqbz<! gm<sqgtqe<! NkvuitIgtig! yu<ouiVuVl<! liXhm<miZl<! sLkibs<!
sQIOgMgjtBl<! nuzr<gjtBl<! wkqIk<Kg<! guqjk! hjmh<hK! we<x! ohiKg<!
g{<O{im<ml<! Wx<Xg<! ogit<th<hm<mK/! gm<sq! sivik! liIg<sqbg<! g{<O{im<ml<!
djmbuIgTl<!‘uiel<hic!-zg<gqb!um<mk<kqz<’!-Vf<kiIgt</!liIg<sqb!=MhiM!
-z<zikuIgTl<! -f<k! njlh<hqz<! -Vf<kiIgt</! NgOu?! ne<jxb! $pzqz<!
sLkib!nuzr<gjt! wkqIk<Kg<! Gvz<! ogiMh<hK! we<hkqz<! yu<ouiVuVg<Gl<!
ohiKg<! gVk<Ok! -Vf<kK/! -f<k! nch<hjmbqz<! uiel<hic! YI! -bg<gligOu!
osbz<hm<mK/”!
.!sq/NI/-vuQf<kqve<!
!
! “uiel<hic! yV! guqjk! -bg<gl<A! leqk! Ofbk<jk! l{<{qz<! utIg<g!
ljpbib<!ohb<k!-bg<gl<”!
.!sg<kqg<gez<!
!
! “-kpiZl<! dxuiZl<! liEm! Ofbk<kiZl<! dVuie! uiel<hic!
-bg<gl</”!
.!hqvhR<se<!
!
46 ! “OsiIf<K! Ohib<?! yV! okib<U! Wx<hm<cVf<k! gizgm<mk<kqz<! guqjkg<G!
we<X! -bg<glig! -Vf<kK?! nOfglig! oux<xqgvlie! -bg<glig! -Vf<kK!
uiel<hickie</!l{qg<ogicg<Gl<!uiel<hicg<Gl<!-Vf<k!uqk<kqbisOl!-Kkie</!
l{qg<ogic!-kpigk<kie<!-Vf<kK/”!
.!lQvi/!
!
! 2:71gtqz<! OgibLk<K~iqz<! sqxh<hig!-br<gq!uf<k!h,l<ohipqz<!-zg<gqb!
um<ml<?! Hkqb!kjzLjx!kqr<gtqkp<?! sqf<kjeh<! Ohvju!Lkzieju!OsiIU!
ogi{<M! hqe<kr<gqb! fqjzbqz<! osbz<hm<me/! Olx<Gxqk<k! njlh<Hgtqz<!
sLkibs<! sqf<kjeBmEl<! ohiKUjmjlh<! hiIjuBmEl<! wPkqb!
hjmh<hitIgtqe<!%m<M!Lbx<sqBl<!uiel<hic!Okix<xk<kqx<Gh<!hqe<HzliGl</!
!
3/3/!utIs<sq!
! uiel<hicg<! guqRIgt<! s&gs<! sqf<kjeBjmbuIgtig! uqtr<gqeI/!
kr<gt<! hjmh<hqe<! guqjkgt<! outquVukx<gigOu! uiel<hic! -bg<gk<kqeI!
uiel<hic! -kjp! outqbqm<meI/! -uIgtqe<! guqjkgtqz<! d{Is<sq! Yr<gqg<!
gi{h<hMgqxK/! yu<OuiI! -kpqe<! Lgh<Hh<! hg<gk<kqZl<! wPs<sqlqG! Olx<Ogit<!
guqjkgt<! outqbqmh<hm<Mt<te/! hivkqbiI?! uiz<m<! uqm<le<?! c/w^</wzqbm<!
LkziOeiiqe<! guqjk! uiqgt<! uiel<hic! -kpqe<! Lgh<Hh<! hg<gk<kqz<!
gi{h<hMgqe<xe/! uiel<hicg<! guqRIgt<! guqjkjbg<! gikzqbig! w{<{qeI/!
nkeiz<! nuIgtqe<! guqjkgtqz<! dbqVl<! d{IUl<! hbe<lqg<gkib<!
-Vg<gqe<xe/! -Ok! fqjzbqz<?! sLkibk<kqz<! gi{h<hMl<! dbIU! kip<Ugjt!
lix<Xl<! gVuqbig! -! slk<Kuk<jk! dVuig<Gl<! gVuqbigg<! guqjkjbh<!
hbe<hMk<kqeI/!
!
! Lkz<! -kp<! hivkqbiIg<Gl<! sLkibs<! sqf<kjeBt<t! guqRIgTg<Gl<!
hjmbzig!nxquqg<gh<hMgqxK/!
Hkqb!nxk<kqe<!Hkqb!Bgk<jkh<!hic!
kiOe!yV!BgligqBl<!fqjzk<k!
hivkq!ljxf<K!Jl<hki{<MgTl<!ljxf<ke/!
Neiz<!nueK!gz<uqh<!hb{Ll<!h{qh<hb{Ll<!
fqx<gUlqz<jz!ljxbUlqz<jz!
/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!!
47
‘Bgl<OkiXl<!fie<!nukiqg<gqOxe<’!we!
Le<oeiV!nukivk<kqz<!osiz<zqh<!Ohieue<!
-f<k!Bgk<kqe<!lXuqcbZg<gig!uiel<hicgtig!
nukiqk<kqVg<gqxie</!
!
uiel<hicgtqe<!uqSuh<!hjmbz<gt<!
sikiv{g<!g{<gTg<G!wtqkigh<!HiqbiK/!
wf<kg<!g{<gt<!sLkib!uQkqgtqz<!
Okipjljb!uqVl<Hgqe<xeOui!
wf<k!-kbr<gt<!uicb!Lgr<gjtg<!
g{<mOhiokz<zil<!uql<lqk<!Kcg<gqe<xeOui!
wf<k!Nk<lig<gt<!leqk!uip<uqe<!hiqh,v{!
-e<hr<gTg<gigs<!osbzix<Xgqe<xeOui!
!
nf<kg<!g{<gTg<G!
nk<kG!-kbr<gTg<G!
nk<kjgb!Nk<lig<gTg<G!
-f<kh<!hjmbz<gtqe<!Ofig<Gl<!Ohig<Gl<!
uqjtUl<!hbEl<!HzeiGl<!
nuIgTg<Og!-l<lmz<gt<!hjmbzigqe<xe4!
we<X! uiel<hicg<! guqRI! Lz<jz! Nkue<! wPKgqe<xiI/! Lkz<! -kPg<G!
‘%Mgt<!kqxg<gqe<xe’!we<X!ohbiqmh<hm<Mt<tK/!
!
! uiel<hicgtqe<! guqjkgt<! yMg<gh<hm<Omiiqe<! uip<uqbjzBl<! nckm<M!
lg<gtqe<!hqvs<sjegjtBl<!nPk<kligh<!Ohsqe/!
Y"!we<!OkipOv"!
yh<hx<x!
nf<k!leqkihqlieg<!guqjkjb!
fl<lqz<!biI!himh<!OhigqOxil<@5!
we<X!L/Olk<ki!uqei!wPh<hq?!hiMl<!d{Ijuk<!K~{<Mgqe<xiI/!
!
48 ! “uiel<hicbqe<! uvuiz<! fqgp<f<k! Ng<gh,Iulie! uqjtUgt<! hz/! le!
djts<sz<gt<!lm<Mlz<z!-!leqk!sLkibk<kqe<!Kbvr<gTl<!uqMkjzBl<%mg<!
guqjkg<Giqb!hiMohiVt<gt<!NGl<!we<X!uiel<hic!oktqUh<hMk<kqbqVg<gqxK/!
!
! w{<{x<x! -tl<hjmh<hitqgt<! uiel<hicbqe<! &zl<! df<Ksg<kq! ohx<X!
utvg<! gtl<! njlk<Kk<! kvh<hm<mK/! klqpgl<! LPukqZl<! sqx<xqkp<! -bg<gl<!
uZh<ohx!nf<fitqz<!uiel<hic!uvzix<X!jlbligk<!kqgp<f<kqVg<gqxK/!
!
! HKg<guqjkbqe<! uisgI! um<ml<! uqiqf<K! uqsizh<hMukx<G! uiel<hic!
giv{lig!-Vf<Kt<tK/!HKg<guqjk!wkqIh<hitIgtig!-Vf<k!hzjv!Obisqg<g!
juk<kK! uiel<hic/! -ke<! uisgI! um<mk<kqz<! -f<kqbi! LPukqZl<! OkIf<k!
klqp<h<!hch<hitqgt<!-Vf<keI/!/!/!/!HKjlg<G!l{qg<ogicBl<!wPk<Kl<!uqjk!
K~uqe!we<xiz<!fix<Xh<!hik<kqg<Gg<!giuz<!-Vf<kK!uiel<hic/!
!
! wkqIfqjz! ugqk<k! ‘gsmkhx’! GP! hjmh<hitqgjtBl<! s&g!
dt<tmg<gk<jk! Ofig<gq! fgIf<K! uvk<! K~{<c! -Vg<gqxK! we<hKl<%m!
uiel<hicbqe<! yV! hr<gtqh<H! wezil<”6! we<X! sqx<hq! hizSh<hqvl{qbl<!
uiel<hic!-kp<!Nx<xqb!sLkibh<!h{qgjtg<!Gxqh<hqMgqe<xiI/!
!
! uiel<hic! -kp<gtqz<! outqbie! guqjkgtqz<! s&g! d{IU! uQiqbl<!
lqg<gkib<!-Vf<kK/!guqjkg<!gVk<kqz<!nPk<kLl<?!osxqUl<!-Vf<ke/!yVuiqe<!
guqjkjbk<!kvk<kqz<!Lf<k!Ou{<Ml<!we<X!lx<oxiVuI!Ohim<cOhim<Mg<!guqjk!
hjmk<keI/! l{qg<ogic?! wPk<Kg<! gizg<! guqjkgtqzqVf<K! uiel<hicgtqe<!
guqjkgt<!liXhm<M!uqtr<gqe/!uiel<hicg<!gizk<kqz<!wPkh<hm<m!guqjkgjt!
uiel<hicbqe<! guqjk! -bz<! we<X! osiz<Zl<! ntUg<G! nju! sqxh<high<!
hjmg<gh<hm<me/!-f<k!fim<jm!Nth<OhiGl<!nkqgivk<!Okivj{bqz<!guqjkgt<!
-bx<xh<hm<me/! fqgp<giz! Nm<sq! siqbqz<jz/! nkeiz<! Hkqb! Nm<sqjb!
dVuig<GOuil<!we<X!uiel<hicgt<!guqjkgjt!-bx<xqeI/!
-vuqOz!uir<gqOeil<!
-e<El<!
uqcbOu!-z<jz7!
we<X! uiel<hic! ye<hkil<! -kpqz<! w/nvr<gfike<! -f<kqbk<! kqVfim<ce<!
Skf<kqvk<jkg<!Ogzq!osb<gqe<xiI/!
49 ! 2:86! Nl<! N{<M! uiel<hic! -bg<gLl<! -kPl<! hziqe<! %m<M!
Lbx<sqbiz<!fz<z!utIs<sqjbg<!g{<mK/!2:32!Nl<!N{<M!ljxf<k!hivkqbiI?!
-f<kqbi!uqMkjz!ohXukx<G!37!N{<MgTg<G!Le<Oh?!
NMOuiOli!-!ht<Th<!hiMOuiOl!
Nef<k!Skf<kvl<!njmf<K!uqm<Omil<!we<X!
NMOuiOl!ht<T!hiMOuiOl8!
we<X!wkqIgizk<jk!-xf<k!gizk<kqz<!%xqbjkh<!Ohiz?!uiel<hicgt<?!
fir<gt<!uiek<jk!
l{<[g<Gg<!ogi{<M!uf<Kuqm<Omil<!
l{<{qe<lQK!wPl<!HPkqgtqz<!
hb{l<!osb<gqOxil<!
!
fir<gt<!
-f<k!fim<jmOb!
oue<X!uqm<Omil<!
-h<OhiK!fmh<hK!
wr<gt<!-vis<sqbf<kie<9!
we<X!wPKgqe<xeI/!
!
! uiel<hicgtqe<!guqjkgt<!d{<jljb!d{Is<sqObiM!outqh<hMk<kqe/!
Hvm<sqbie!sqf<kjeBl<!Lx<Ohig<Gs<!sqf<kjeBl<!uiel<hicg<!guqRIgtqmk<kqz<!
LPjlbig! -Vf<ke/! nkeiz<! uisgiqe<! dt<tk<jk! dmOe! guqjkgt<!
=Ik<ke/! nf<kg<! gizgm<mk<kqz<! uiel<hicgtqe<! guqjkgjtk<! kuqv?! hqx!
guqjkgTg<G! uisgIgt<! Le<Eiqjl! kvuqz<jz/! lx<x! -kp<gt<! uqjzg<G!
uqx<gh<hm<m! $pzqz<! ‘uiel<hic! -kp<’! uqjzbqe<xq! upr<gh<hm<mKl<! nke<!
guqjk!uQs<Sl<!uisgI!w{<{qg<jgjbh<!ohVg<gqe/!
djpg<Gl<!-ek<kuI!Oll<hM!li{<jh!
dvk<k!Gvzqz<!hiMgqOxe<!.!nf<k!
djph<jhs<!Sv{<c!utIf<kqMl<!He<jljb!
dt<tl<!GLxqOb!siMgqOxe<!!/!/!/!
!
nmg<gh<hMgqx!-ek<kqe<!wPs<sqjb!
NIul<!kKl<hqmg<!gim<MgqOxe<!.!-r<Og!
50
oucg<g!-Vg<Gl<!Hvm<sqg<G!we<Ejm!
uQkl<!ofVh<jhBl<!&m<MgqOxe<!/!/!/!
!
‘fQt<Huqs<!osik<K!ohiKjlOb’!we<x!
fqgvjlg<!ogit<jgjbh<!Ohix<XgqOxe<!.!ouXl<!
Nt<uzqbiOz!dzjg!ujtk<kqMl<!
Nkqg<gs<!sik<kijek<!kig<GgqOxe<:!
we<X! wpqz<! Lkz<ue<! hiMl<! guqjk! uiel<hic! -bg<gk<kqe<! Ofig<gk<jkg<!
gim<Mgqe<xK/! -f<k! Ofig<gl<! fqjxOux! njek<K! uiel<hicg<! guqRIgTl<!
Ljeh<higs<! osbz<hm<meI/! -uIgtqe<! osbz<hm<miz<! uiel<hic! -bg<gLl<!
-kPl<!utIs<sq!ohx<xe/!
!
! uiel<hicgtqe<! uvziX! hx<xqb! gm<Mjvbqz<! Rieq?! ng<gqeq!
Gxqh<hqMuKl<!-u{<!Ofig<gk<kg<gkiGl</! “yV!Gxqh<hqm<m!gizk<kqe<!GxqbQmig!
uiel<hic! sqxgcg<gk<! okimr<gqbK/! uiel<hicg<! %m<mr<gt<! likf<OkiXl<!
fmf<ke/!hqe<?!uiel<hic.uqjzbqzig<!guqlmz<!outqbqMl<!ohiXh<jh!Wx<xeI/!
-f<k! -kPg<G! Wx<hm<m! s&g! nr<gQgivl<! -zg<gqb! -bg<gligs<! osbz<hm!
Wx<xOkiI!$pjzk<!Okix<Xuqk<kK/!
!
! likf<OkiXl<! -zg<gqbh<! hqvs<sjegt<! hx<xqk<! kuxilz<! Nb<uvr<Ggt<!
fjmohx<xe/! klqp<g<! guqjk! nf<kvk<kqz<! kqiqsr<gib<! -Vh<hK! siqbz<z/!
Kiqkgkqbqz<!lixquVl<!dzgs<!$pzqe<!$pzqz<!ke<je!dm<hMk<kqg<!ogit<t!
Ou{<Ml</!klqp<fim<ce<!gzis<siv?!nvsqbz<?!ohiVtikivh<!hqvs<sjegjth<!hx<xq!
-u<uqbg<gl<!siquvk<!okiqf<K!ogit<tilz<?!ke<!gizcjb!Le<jug<gg<!%miK/!
nKUl<! Bgk<kqe<! lQK! SuMgt<! hkqg<g!uqVl<Hl<! uiel<hicgt<!-kjek<! kl<!
guek<kqz<!juk<Kg<!ogit<uK!nusqbl</!hqxolipq!-zg<gqb!nxqLgl<!fl<jl!
utIg<Gl</! -ju! kuqv?! ke<jek<! kie<! Sb! uqlIsel<! osb<K! ogit<tilz<!
kie<!utv!-bziK/!
!
! -f<k! nch<hjmgtqe<Olz<! uiel<hic! -kpqe<! gm<Mlier<gt<! fmf<ke/!
Nb<uvr<Ggtqe<! guqjkh<! hjmbz<gTl<! uqlIser<gTl<! hiqlixqg<!
ogit<th<hm<me/! gjz! -zg<gqb! gVk<Okim<mr<gt<! hx<xq! uquikqg<gh<hm<me/!
uiel<hicgtqe<!uvzix<xqz<!-K!Lkz<!Ohig!nXujmbqe<!gizl</!lvhqzqVf<K!
51 Hkqb! lvhqx<Gh<! hzI! kup<f<K! uf<kKl<?! sqzI! kiuq! uf<kKl<! gjzg<!
g{<O{im<mk<Kme<?! s&gh<! hqvg<jRBme<! lqgs<! sqxf<k! guqjkgt<!
hjmg<gh<hm<mKl<?! guqjkk<! Kjxg<Og! nkqgl<! okimIhqz<zik! hzI?! -ke<!
ohiK! =Ih<hiz<! guIf<kqPg<gh<hm<mKl<! guqjk?! HzuIgtqe<! osb<Bt<!
gm<czqVf<K! uqMhm<M! lg<gtqe<! nvuj{h<hqz<! lgqpk<! Kck<kKl<! Lx<Ohig<G!
w{<{k<Kme<! w{<{x<x! uqjzbqzig<! guqlmz<! outquf<kKl<! .! -bg<gr<gt<!
Nr<gir<G! n{q! kqvtk<! okimr<gqbKl<! .! keqleqk! uikk<Kg<ogkqvie! s&g!
bkiIk<kuikl<! ke<! kk<Ku! hzk<OkiM! uqb,gl<! njlk<kKl<! -f<kg<!
gizk<kqz<kie</”21!
!
3/4/!ds<sfqjz!
! uiel<hic! -bg<gk<kqeI! s&g! utIs<sqg<giUl<! sLkib!
lix<xk<kqx<gigUl<!guqjk!ljpjbh<!ohipqf<keI/!-f<k!ljpbiz<!s&gh<!hbqI!
fe<G! utIf<K! hbetqk<kK/! uiel<! -e<OeiIg<G! we<eiK! wz<OziIg<Gl<!
-zuslig! ljpjbh<! ohipquK! Ohiz?! -uIgTl<! guqjk! -kpqje!
-zusligOu! lg<gtqmk<kqz<! ogi{<M! OsIk<keI/! -f<fqjz! okimIf<K!
Jl<hki{<Mgt<! osbz<hm<cVf<kiz<! klqp<fim<ce<! uvziX! lixqbqVg<Gl</! nf<k!
ntuqx<G! uiel<hic! -bg<gk<kqeI! Ljeh<Hme<! osbz<hm<meIA! guqjkgjt!
d{Is<sq!ohir<g!wPkqeIA!gVk<K!uquikr<gTl<!uqlIser<gTl<!givsivlib<!
fqgp<f<keA! guqRIgtqe<! yx<Xjl! Yr<gqbqVf<kK/! nuIgt<! yx<Xjlbib<!
-Vf<kkiz<kie<! guqjk!-kPg<Gh<! ohiXh<hitIgtig! wz<OziVl<! lixq! lixqs<!
osbz<hm<meI/!
!
! uiel<hic! Lkz<! -kpqje! Lz<jz! NkuEl<! ng<gqeqHk<kqvEl<!
-j{f<K! outqbqm<meI/! HuqbvSl<! ng<gqeqHk<kqvEl<! ohiXh<Ohx<X! -v{<mil<!
-kpqzqVf<K!Wpil<!-kp<!ujv!outqbqm<meI/!HuqbvSl<!gr<jg!ogi{<miEl<!
-j{f<K! wm<miuK! -kpqje! outqbqm<meI/! HuqbvSl<! ng<gqeqHk<kqvEl<!
-j{f<K! ye<hkil<! -kpqje! outqbqm<meI/! -uIgt<! uiel<hic! -kpqe<!
Lgh<Hh<! hg<gk<kqz<! Hvm<sqgvlie!sqf<kjejbk<!K~{<Ml<! Olx<Ogit<!guqjk! -!
uisgr<gjtk<!kf<keI/!-f<k!Olx<Ogit<!guqjkgt<!dzgl<!kPuqb!fqjzbqz<!
-Vf<ke/! “uiel<hic”! uieqz<! ds<sfqjzjbk<! okiMukx<G! uiel<hicgtqe<!
guqjkgt<! njlf<ke/! nkx<G! df<K! sg<kqbib<h<! hivkqbiI/! c/w <̂/wzqbm<?!
libgiu<̂ <gq?! vihIm<! 0h<vi <̂m<?! zqObi! miz<̂ <mib<! LkziOeiI! guqjkgt<!
52 Olx<Ogit<gtib<k<! kvh<hm<cVf<ke/! uiel<hic! Jf<kil<! -kpqe<! Lgh<hqz<!
hivkqbiiqe<!use!guqjk?!
lqe<ejzh<!hiMOuil<!uiVr<gt<"!
flK!uqpqgtqOz!lqe<ez<!hqxf<kqMg"!
flK!ofR<sqOz!lqe<ez<!uqsqxqh<!hib<g"!
flK!uzg<jgbqOz!lqe<ez<!Okie<Xg"!
flK!him<M!lqe<eZjmbk<kiGg"!
flK!uig<G!lqe<Ohiz<!nck<kqMg"22!
we<hK! Olx<Ogitigk<! kvh<hm<cVf<kK/! ye<hkil<! -kp<! nm<jm! Lgh<hqz<!
ohR<slqe<! c^<Ovzq! guqjk! uiqgt<! Olx<Ogitigh<! hkqU! osb<bh<hm<cVf<kK/!
‘-h<OhiK! fie<! njlkqbibqVh<hqEl<! gizl<! yVfit<! uVl</! nh<OhiK! fQ!
we<jeg<!Ogm<hib<’!we<El<!gVk<Kjmb?!
Though I sit down now
The time will come
when you will hear me
- Benjamin Disraeli
we<El<!ohR<slqe<!c <̂Ovzqbqe<!guqjk!uiqgt<?! ‘Hvm<sqgt<!yVfit<!oucg<Gl<’!
we<El<! dm<gVk<kqjeg<! GxqbQmib<! outqh<hMk<Kgqe<xe/! uiel<hicgtqe<!
wkqIgizl<! -f<kh<! Hvm<sqjb! jlblib<g<! ogi{<M! nuIgt<! fqgp<gizg<!
guqjkgjth<! hjmk<keI/! -ju! uiel<hicg<! guqRIgjt! yx<XjlBme<!
Yr<gs<!osb<kKme<?!uisgIgjtBl<!Hvm<sqh<!hijkg<G!njpk<Ks<!ose<xe/!
flg<Gk<!okipqz<!guqjk!fim<cx<!Gjpk<kz<!
-jlh<ohiPKl<!Osivi!kqVk<kz<23!
we<X! hivkqbiI! %xq?! -l<&e<jxBl<! kVliX! uqfibgiqml<! Ou{<Mgqe<xiI/!
libgiu<^<gq! guqjkgjt! NBkligg<! %Xgqe<xiI/! -uI! sLkibk<jkk<!
kqVk<Kukx<gie!-!Hvm<sq!osb<ukx<gie!fz<z!NBkl<!guqjk!we<hjk?!
! ! Songs are our weapons, our power of powers,
Our gold - our voices, just hear us sing!
- Mayakovsky
we<X! guqjk! hjmk<Kt<tiI/! -f<kg<! guqjk! uiqgt<! uiel<hic! hk<kil<!
-kpqe<!kjzbr<gh<!hg<gk<kqz<!Olx<Ogitigk<!kvh<hm<Mt<tK/!
!
53 ! uiel<hicg<! guqRIgt<?! kr<gjtBl<! kr<gt<! ogit<jggjtBl<!
d{Is<sqlqg<g! guqjkgtib<k<! kf<keI/! -f<k! d{Is<sqlqg<g! guqjkgt<!
uisgIgtqml<! fz<z! uvOux<jhh<! ohx<Xt<te/! \Quytq! we<El<! guqRI! “we<!
Gvz<”! we<El<! kjzh<hqz<! wPkqb! guqjk! uiel<hic! &e<xil<! -kpqz<!
outqbieK/!nK!hqe<uVliX;!
wr<Og!.!
lv{k<kqe<!
gqZgqZh<jhs<!sk<kl<!
wZl<H!uib<g<gizqz<!
\qz<zqm<Mh<!hib<gqxOki!/!/!/!!
!wr<Og!-!
lkole<El<!
uqjzlikqe<!Oligqeqs<!sqiqh<H!
fvl<H!F~zqz<!
\qu<oue<Xh<!hmIgqxOki!/!/!/!
!nr<Og!-!
we<Gvz<!wiqsvlib<!
DMVuqg<!gqpqg<gm<Ml<"!
!W/!/!/!leqkOe"!
-Vm<Mzgqe<!lbg<gl<!
deg<ogkx<G!/!/!/@!
!-jlh<ohiPK!uip<f<kiZl<!/!/!/!
yVOgic!lqe<ez<!
lqe<e!Ou{<Ml<"!
!Y"!nKkie<!
nKkie<!leqk!uip<g<jg"24!
-f<kg<! guqjk! ‘NxqZl<! siUA! F~xqZl<! siU’! we<El<! hpolipqjbBl<?!
‘wk<kje!N{<Mgt<! uip<f<Okil<! we<hK! ohiqke<XA! uip<f<k! gizk<kqz<! we<e!
oki{<M! osb<Okil<! we<hKkie<! ohVjl’! we<El<! niqb! gVk<kqjeBl<!
dt<tmg<gqg<!gim<Mgqe<xK/!
54 ! “uiel<hicgtqe<! uvzix<xqzqVf<K! ye<jxg<! g{<mxqf<K! osiz<zzil</!
uiel<hicgtqe<!guqjk!-kp<gtqe<!w{<{qg<jg!33/!hkqeie<gil<!-kpqzqVf<K!
sqx<hq! guqjk! -kPg<Gh<! ohiXh<Ohx<Xg<! ogi{<miI! /! /! /! uiel<hic! Lkz<!
-kp<!2:82!ng<Omihiqz<!outquf<kK/!nMk<k!-v{<M!N{<Mgjt!dt<tmg<gqh<!
hiIg<gqxohiPK! -g<giz! -jmoutqbqz<! outquf<k! wm<M! -kp<gt<! $m<Sl!
uiel<hic! -bg<gl<! we<x! Nkivk<kqz<! outquf<ke/! kQuqvlie! uquikr<gt<!
-g<gizk<kqz<kie<!fjmohx<xe/!guqjk!we<Xl<!kk<Kul<!we<Xl<!klqpqzg<gqbh<!
hivl<hiqbl<!we<Xl<!-g<gizk<kqz<!fqjxbh<!Ohsh<hm<me/!uiel<hicgtqe<!Ng<gg<!
gizl<!we!-jkk<kie<!Gxqh<hqm!Ou{<Ml</!uiel<hicgTg<Gt<!Nx<xz<!kqv{<m!
gizl<! -Kkie</! Lv{<! -bg<gl<kie<! -f<k! Nx<xZg<Gl<! keqk<Ku!
uQiqbk<kqx<Gl<! giv{l</”25! -u<uiX! Rieq! uiel<hicbqe<! ds<sfqjz! Gxqk<Kh<!
OhSgqe<xiI/!
!
! sqx<hq!kjzjlbqz<!HuqbvS?!ng<gqeqHk<kqve<?!Rieq?!gr<jg!ogi{<mie<?!
L/Olk<ki! Ngqb! JuVl<! GPuig! -Vf<K?! uiel<hic! hk<kil<! -kp<! Lkz<!
hkqe<&e<xiuK! -kp<ujv! fie<G! uiel<hicg<! guqjk! -kp<gjts<! sqxh<hig!
outqbqm<meI/! -h<hcs<! sqxh<higg<! guqjkg<! gj{gjt! WUl<! uiel<hicg<!
guqRIgt<!njeuVl<!liEmk<jkh<!hiceiIgt<A!liEm!utIs<sqg<gigg<!Gvz<!
ogiMk<kiIgt</! -uIgtqe<! Gvzqz<! ohiKUjmjlh<! Ohs<Sl<! liIg<sqbk<!
kk<KuLl<!uIg<gh<!Ohivim<mLl<!wkqovizqk<ke/!hivkqbiI/!ohiqbiI?!hivkqkise<!
-uIgtqe<!h{<him<M!nvsqbz<?!Hvm<sqs<!sqf<kje!-ux<xqe<!wPs<sqbqe<!hiq{il!
utIs<sqbig! uiel<hic! -bg<gl<! ds<sfqjzjb! njmf<kK/! uiel<hicbqe<!
hk<K! -kp<gtqOzOb! nke<! ds<sfqjz! okiqf<kK/! “outqs<sr<gt<”! )2:84*?!
“-f<kqvi!-f<kqbi”! )2:86*?! “sqOfg! H]<hr<gt<”! )2:87*!Ngqb!&e<X!F~z<gTl<!
uiel<hic! -bg<gl<! siIhqz<! outqbqmh<! ohx<xe/! -l<&e<X! F~z<gTl<!
hzVjmb!hjmh<hqe<!okiGh<Hgt<!NGl</!-f<k!F~z<!outqbQMl<!uiel<hicbqe<!
ds<sfqjz!utIs<sqjbg<!gim<Mgqe<xK/!
!
3/5/!uQp<s<sq!
! “lqg! ofVr<gqb! f{<hIgt<kil<! hjguIgtig! liXuiIgt<”! we<hK!
kk<Kul</!uiel<hicg<!guqRIgt<!Hvm<sqs<!sqf<kjejbBl<!ohiKUjmjljbBl<!
slk<Kuk<jkBl<! Le<eqXk<kqg<! guqjkgjth<! hjmk<K! uf<keI/! uiel<hic!
-bg<gk<kqz<!GPh<h,sz<!d{<mieK/!nkeiz<!Rieq?!sqx<hq!LkziOeiI!gVk<K!
55 OuXhim<Mme<! osbz<hm<meI/! yVuI! gVk<kqje! lx<oxiVuI! lXk<keI/!
uiel<hic! -kp<! ye<X!Lkz<! ye<hK!ujv! outquf<k! gizk<kqz<! uiel<hic!
-bg<gl<! gm<Mg<Ogih<hig! -Vf<kK/! hk<kil<! -kp<! okimr<gq! -Vhk<kqv{<mil<!
-kp<ujv! outquf<k! gizk<kqz<! -bg<gk<kqz<! gVk<K! OuXhiMgt<!
Okie<xquqm<me/!hkqeie<gil<!-kp<!okimr<gq!-Vhk<kqv{<mil<!-kp<!ujv!sqx<hq!
kjzjlObx<X! outqbqm<Mt<tiI/! uiel<hic! -kp<gt<! outquf<k! fqjzjb!
-v{<M!gm<mligs<!sqx<hq!hGk<Kg<!%Xgqe<xiI/!
!
! “Lkz<! gm<ml<! we<hK! yV! gm<Mg<Ogih<hie! -bg<glig! -Vf<kK/!
yu<ouiV! guqjkBl<! uquikqg<gh<hm<M?! uqlIsel<! osb<bh<hm<M?! nkx<Gh<! hqxG!
ns<sieK/!hjmh<hitIgTl<!kqxeib<uitIgTl<!lXhcBl<!lXhcBl<!sf<kqk<Kh<!
Ohsqg<! ogi{<miIgt</! -kqz<! -Vg<gqe<x! kqxeib<uitIgt<! liIg<sqbk<!
kqxeib<uitvig! -Vf<kiIgt<! we<hK! Gxqh<hqmk<kGf<k! uq]bl</! Rieq?!
\eSf<kvl<! Ohie<xuIgt<! liIg<sqbk<! kqxeib<uitIgtig! -Vf<K!
osbz<hm<miIgt</! nuIgt<! yV! uib<g<gijzk<! k{<{QI! Ohiukx<Gs<!
osKg<gquqm<M! nkqz<! -jmb,xig! -Vh<hjk! wz<zil<! fQg<g! Ou{<Ml<! we<hK!
likqiqbie!yV!sqz!kqVh<hr<gjt!Wx<hMk<kqg<!ogi{<Om!-Vf<kiIgt</!nK?!sqz!
Oujtgtqz<! ogiR<sl<! nkqgligOu! -Vf<kkigh<! hm<mOhiK?! nkqz<! -V!
hqiquqjegt<!Wx<hm<me/!WP?!wm<M!-kp<gTg<Gh<!hqe<eiz<?!-f<k!leh<hie<jl!
nkqgiqk<kK/! hqxG! uiel<hicjbk<! keqbigOu! yVuI! kbiiqg<gqxKr<gx!
likqiqh<!ohiXh<jhg<!ogiMk<kiIgt</!nh<hcg<!ogiMg<Gl<OhiK!nuvuI!uqVh<H?!
ouXh<HgTg<G! Wx<xhc! guqjkgjtk<! OkIf<okMk<kiIgt<! we<x! yV! gVk<Kl<!
nkx<Gt<! uf<kK/! -keqjmOb! -f<k! -bg<g! OuXhiMgt<! nkqgligh<! Ohib<!
-v{<migh<! hqtf<kK/! -v{<migh<! hqtf<kkx<Gh<! hqxG! uf<k! -kp<gTg<Gl<?!
Le<eiz<! uf<k! -kp<gTg<Gl<! nch<hjmbqz<! dt<t! OuXhiM! we<hK?!
liIg<sqbg<!gVk<K!we<hkqz<!uf<kkigs<!osiz<z!LcbiK/!Neiz<!guqjkgjt!
wh<hck<! OkIf<okMh<hK?! wh<hc! outqbqMuK! we<hkqz<! -v{<cZl<! uqk<kqbisl<!
-Vf<kK/!
!
! -v{<miuK?! hqxolipqg<! guqjkgjt! nkqglig! outqbqMuK?!
slgizk<kqEjmb! lx<x! hjmh<hqzg<gqbr<gt<! wh<hc! -Vg<gqe<xe! we<hjkg<!
g{qk<Kh<! hiIh<hK! we<hokz<zil<! liIg<sqbg<! g{<O{im<mk<kqz<! lm<Ml<!
osb<bh<hm<Mg<! ogi{<cVf<kK! Le<eiz</! hqe<eiz<?! keqfhI! nch<hjmbqz<?!
56 nuIgt<! utIf<kqVg<gqe<x! utIs<sqjb! wz<zil<! g{g<gqz<! wMk<Kg<! ogi{<M!
nkje!YI!-zg<gqb!-kpigg<!ogi{<M!uf<Okil</!nkje!uiel<hic!-bg<g!
-kp<!we<hjkuqm?!uiel<hic!-bg<gk<kqEjmb!sivil<sk<jk!wMk<Kg<!ogi{<m!
-zg<gqb! -kp<! we<X! osiz<uKkie<?! hqx<giz! -kp<gjth<! ohiXk<kujv!
svqbibqVg<Gl</”26! Ogiju! Rieq?! uiel<hicbqe<! okimg<gl<! yV! oucG{<M!
Ohizs<!osbz<hm<mK!we<gqxiI/!
!
! uiel<hicbqe<! okimg<gg<giz! -kp<gt<! kk<KuiIk<k! nch<hjmbqz<!
osbz<hm<mK/!nkjek<!okimIf<K!uVl<!-v{<mil<!gm<m!-kp<gt<!keqleqkh<!
Ohim<cgtigg<!gim<sqbtqk<ke/!okimg<gg<giz!-kp<gtqz<!guqjkg<G!Lkzqml<!
kvh<ohx<xK/! -Xkqg<giz! -kp<gtqz<! guqRIgTg<G! Lkzqml<! kvh<ohx<xK/!
okimg<gk<kqz<!uiel<hic!YI!-bg<gligs<! osbz<hm<cVg<gqxK/!Lcuqz<!n0K!
YI!-kpig!lm<MOl!osbz<hm<cVg<gqxK/!
!
3/5/2/!uQp<s<sqg<gie!giv{r<gt<!
! uiel<hicbqe<! uQp<s<sqg<Gg<! giv{lig?!nf<k!-bg<gk<kqz<!-Vf<kuIgt<!
Gxqh<hqMueux<jx!-r<Gs<!Sm<cg<!gim<mzil</! “gjzg<gg<! OgiVuK!kqxeib<U/!
guqRe<! ke<jeg<! gjzk<Kg<ogit<t! lim<Ome<! we<gqxie</! gjzk<Kg<!
ogi{<miz<kie<! hb{l<! okimVl<! we<gqxie<! kqxeib<uite</! nh<ohiPKkie<!
hiIjugt<! uqiqBl<! we<gqxie<! kqxeib<uite</! hjmh<hqe<! SgOl! ohiqK! we<x!
fqjzbqz<! hjmh<hitqjbk<! kqxeib<uiteiz<! Hiqf<K! ogit<t! LcbiK!
we<gqxie<! guqRe</! guqReqe<! -bg<gk<jkh<! hqe<okimIuKkie<!
kqxeib<uiteqe<!h{q!we<gqxie<!guqRe</!-h<hc!yV!Lv{<fqjz!uVl<ohiPK!
guqRe<!upq!keq?!kqxeib<uite<!upq!keq!we<x!hqiqU!OfIgqxK/!Ofvg<!%mik!
hqiqU!-K/!uiel<hicgTg<Gt<!-k<kjgb!hqiqUkie<!OfIf<kK/!s&g!d{Iju!
jlbh<hMk<kq! nke<! Nkivk<kqz<! wPf<k! guqjk! d{Iuqz<! uiel<hicgt<!
lqkf<kiIgt</! klg<Gt<! osbz<hm<m! s&g! d{Iju! liIg<sqb! d{IOuiM!
OsIk<Kh<!hiIg<gqxohiPK!klg<Gt<!Heqk!d{IU!g{<miIgt<!/!/!/!-uIgtqe<!
hiIjug<Gt<! wt<tz<! okieq! yV! Lg<gqblie! %X/! wt<tz<! d{Iju!
wkqiqgjt! Ofig<gqs<! osZk<kqeiIgt</! lvHg<! guqRIgjt! Ofig<gqBl<!
HKg<guqjkbitIgjt! Ofig<gqBl<! osZk<kqeiIgt<! /! /! /! wt<tz<! d{Iju!
klg<Gt<Tl<! -uIgt<! osZk<kqh<! hiIk<kqVg<g! Ou{<Ml<”27! -r<rel<! Rieq!
%Xgqe<xiI/!
57 ! “wz<zi! -bg<gr<gTl<! sqkxqh<! Ohiekx<G! we<e! giv{Oli! nKkie<!
-kx<Gl<! giv{l</! lqgg<! %IjlbiekigUl<! OugligUl<! utIs<sqbjmf<K!
ogi{<cVf<kkiz<! ohiqb! gueqh<jhh<! ohx<xK/! weOu! nkqz<!
Lg<gqb^<kIgtibqVf<k! yu<ouiVuVl<! kie<kie<! nkqz<! ohiqb! Ht<tq! we<X!
yu<ouiVuVl<!fqjek<keI/!wz<OziVl<!hr<G!ogi{<M!fmk<kg<!%cb!-bg<gl<!
we<gqx! hiIju! ogiR<sl<! ogiR<sligg<! Gjxb! Nvl<hqk<kK/! gm<sq! iQkqbigs<!
sqf<kqg<g!Ou{<Ml<!we<hK!Ohie<x!yV!hzuf<kl<!kqxeib<uitIgtqe<!&zlig!
-f<k!-bg<gk<kqzqVf<k!hjmh<hitqgTg<G!Wx<hm<mkig!d{If<Okil</!liIg<sqbl<!
we<hjk!Wx<Xg<!ogi{<OmiOl!kuqv!CPI, CPM, ML!Ohie<x!hiIjugjtk<kie<!
sqk<kiqg<g! Ou{<Ml</! nf<kg<! gm<sq! gVkg<! %cb! uqsbr<gjtk<kie<! osiz<z!
Ou{<Ml<! we<X! nuIgt<! gVkqeiIgOti! -z<jzObi?! we<jeh<!
Ohie<xuIgTg<G! nh<hc! yV! gVk<K! Wx<hm<mK/! fl<fim<M! nvsqbz<!
-bg<gr<gtqjmOb! -V! %Xgt<! utIf<K! ogi{<Om! uf<kqVg<gqe<xe/! kqzgI?!
OgigOz!we<X!-v{<M!-bg<glqVf<kK/!hqe<eiz<!hiIk<kiz<!gif<kqBl<!OhiSl<!.!
-h<hc!fqkie <̂kIgTl<!kQuqvuikqgTl<!we<x!fqjz!wh<OhiKOl!-Vf<Kt<tK/!
-zg<gqbk<kqZl<! -K! Ohie<x! hiIju! utIf<koke<X! osiz<z! Ou{<Ml</!
liIg<sqbuikqgTg<gqjmObBl<!fqkie <̂kIgTl<!kQuqvuikqgTl<!d{<M!/!/!/!
!
! -v{<miuK! giv{l<?! nkx<Gt<Ot! keqleqk! uikl<! we<hK!
kjzK~g<gqbK/! nuIgTg<Gt<OtBl<! flg<Gk<kie<! liIg<sqbl<! okiqBl<?!
-uIgTg<ogz<zil<! ye<Xl<! okiqbiK! we<x! gVk<Kl<! -Vf<kK/! fie<! )sqx<hq*?!
HuqbvS?! Olk<ki?! gr<jg! ogi{<mie<! wz<OziVl<! YI! n{qbqz<! -Vf<Okil</!
Olk<kiuqx<Gl<! gr<jgg<Gl<! dt<Ot! sqz! Lv{<hiMgt<! -Vf<ke/! lx<xuIgt<!
-bg<gl<! we<x! gm<Mh<him<cx<Gt<! nmr<gqeuIgt<! we<X! osiz<zzil</!
lx<xuIgjtuqmk<! kie<! ohiqb! hjmh<hitq! we<x! w{<{l<! Olk<kiuqx<G!
wh<OhiKOl!d{<M/!nkeiz<!-bg<gl<!we<hK!ke<!keqk<ke<jlg<G!-jmb,xig!
fqjek<kiOvi! we<X! Okie<XgqxK/! nkeiz<! lx<xuIgtqmlqVf<K! uqzgq! uv!
Ou{<Ml<! we<x! gVk<jk! OuXuqkg<! giv{r<gjts<! osiz<zq! ux<HXk<kqeiOvi!
we<X! -h<OhiK! fqjeg<gk<! Okie<XgqxK/! kk<Kul<! we<X! osiz<z!
Lcbiuqm<miZl<! kk<Kul<! hx<xqb! g{<O{im<mr<gt<! uqk<kqbish<hm<me”28! we<X!
sqx<hq!kl<!nEhuk<jkg<!%Xgqe<xiI/!
!
58 ! “ng<gqeqHk<kqve<!fie<G!giv{r<gjt!Le<!jug<gqe<xiI/!nju?!
2/ kQuqv! nvsqbz<! fqjzh<him<jms<! sqzI! hqe<hx<x?! nxOu! nvsqbz<!
fqjzh<him<jms<!sqzI!lXk<keI/!
3/ leqkihqlieli@!OhiIg<G{lqg<g!leqkihqlieli@!
4/ gjz!hqvs<sivl<!osb<bzili@!osb<bzil</!Neiz<!gjzbig!we<hK!yV!
GPuqe<! uikl</! hqvs<sivl<! -z<zilz<! gjz! WK@! wK! hqvs<sivl<! wK!
gjz!we<hjk!biI!kQIlieqh<hK@!weK!gjz!deg<Gh<!hqvs<sivl<!.!siq?!
Neiz<! weK! hqvs<sivl<! deg<Gg<! gjz! we<x! NTl<! uIg<g!
fqjzh<him<jm! -!Nth<hMl<!uIg<gg<!gjz!-zg<gqb!fqjzh<hiM!Ng<g!
Lx<hm<mOhiK! hqtU! kuqIg<g! LcbikK! we<hjk! -V! siviVl<!
d{If<keI/!
5/ nxquqbz<!!yPg<gl<! hx<xqb!uqkqgjt!wf<k!ntUg<Gh<! hqe<hx<xzil<@!
yV! Ogih<jhbqOz! we<! GcbqVh<H! we<x! g{<{kiseqe<! Ogim<him<jm!
Wx<xkqZl<?!wkqIk<kkqZl<!L/Olk<ki!!ng<gqeq!-VuVg<Gl<!kgviX/!/!/!
!
! ofVg<gc!fqjz!-f<kqvigif<kqbiz<!)2:86*!hqxh<hqg<gh<hMukx<G!Le<OhOb!
guqjk! -bg<gk<kqx<Gt<! yV! ofVg<gc! fqjz! hqvgmeh<hMk<kh<hMgqxK/!
-f<kqvigif<kqjbs<!squk<kl<li!we<X!osiz<gqxiI!HuqbvS/!liXkjzg<!ogi{<M!
uVgqx! yV! gitqbl<liuigh<! hvisg<kqbigh<! hiIg<gqxiI! HuqbvS/! Neiz<!
fir<gt<!nh<hch<!hiIg<guqz<jz/!nOkOhizs<!sqx<hq!nuIgt<!nuI!siIf<kqVg<gg<!
%cb! sq/hq/J/! -f<kqb! gl<b,eq <̂m<! gm<sq! -f<kqvigif<kqjb?! yV! Hvm<sqgv!
sg<kqbigh<!hiIg<gg<!%cb!yV!fqjzh<him<jm!wMg<gqxK!/!/!/!
!
! nvsqbz<! guqjkjb! yV! hqvs<sivlig! lix<xquqMOli! we<x! YI! ns<sl<!
sqx<hqg<Gl<! HuqbvSg<Gl<! -Vf<kK/! nf<k! ns<sl<! fqbiblieKkie</! nK! kh<H!
we<X! osiz<z! LcbiK/! Neiz<! nkjes<! siqosb<K! ogi{<M! Ohigg<! %cb!
gmjl! fl<lqml<! -Vg<gqxOk! kuqv?! fil<! nf<k! nvsqbjzObi! -gp<uK!
siqbz<z/!/!/”29!
!
! uiel<hic! -bg<g! uQp<s<sqg<Gs<! sq/NI/-vuQf<kqve<! ke<! nEhu!
gVk<Kg<gjtg<! giv{r<gtig! olipqgqe<xiI/! nju;! “uiel<hic.-kp<!
uqlIsek<kqz<!-v{<M! g{<O{im<mr<gt<!Le<!jug<gh<hm<me/! ye<X!liIg<sqbh<!
hiIju/! -e<oeie<X! gjzbl<sh<! hiIju/! liIg<sqbh<! hiIjubqz<! nvsqbz<!
59 g{<O{im<ml<!Lke<jlh<hMk<kh<hm<mK/!gjzbl<sh<!hiIjubqz<!uip<uqbz<!sivl<!
Lke<jlh<hMk<kh<hm<mK/! -keiz<! yV! sivivigh<! hqiqb! Ou{<cb! fqjzjl!
kuqIg<g!Lcbilz<!dVuigqbK/!-f<kh<!hqiquqx<Gh<!hqxG!uiel<hic.uip<uqbz<!
sivk<kqx<G!Lkzqml<!ogiMk<K!outqbigqxK/!/!/!gVk<Kg<gtiz<!yu<ouiVuVl<!
liXhm<m! OhikqZl<! wz<zig<! guqRIgTOl!-e<Xujv! f{<hIgtigOu!-Vf<K!
uVgqxiIgt</!sqjkf<kK!-bg<glieiZl<!OsIf<kqVh<huIgt<!f{<hIgt</”2:!
!
! -tLVG! %Xl<! gVk<K! hqe<uVliX;! “sqjkf<kjlg<Gk<! keqleqkg<!
giv{l<! we<X! fie<! osiz<zlim<Ome</! kk<Ku! ujgh<hm<m! giv{l<! we<Xkie<!
fie<! osiz<ZOue</! Woee<xiz<! yu<ouiVuVl<! yu<ouiV! -bg<gk<jks<!
siIf<kuIgtig! -Vh<hiIgt</! uip<g<jgbqz<! nuIgt<! hqe<hx<xg<! %cb!
kk<Kuk<OkiM! nK! -j{b! Ou{<Ml<! we<X! nuIgt<! fqjek<kqVg<gzil</!
-v{<miuK!giv{l<?!uqlIsel<!hx<xqbK/!wr<gTjmb!Ofig<gl<!we<eoue<xiz<!
uqlIseLl<! hjmh<Hl<! jgOgiIk<Kh<! OhigEl<! we<hK/! sqz! OhI! uqlIseOl!
Ou{<mil<A! hjmh<hitqjbuqm! uqlIsge<! ohiqb! -uez<z/! nuEg<G! we<e!
okiqBl<!.!hjmg<gqxOk!-z<jz/!nue<!Ng<gqb!Osix<xqjes<!sih<hqmxue<kiOeA!
nuEg<G!we<e!okiqBl<!we<x!w{<{h<!Ohig<Gl<!giv{libqVf<kqVg<gzil</”31!
!
! uiel<hic! -bg<g! uQp<s<sqg<Gg<! giv{l<! keqleqk! Eco Olikz<gt<kil<!
we<X!gzih<iqbi!%Xgqe<xiI/!-uVg<G!wkqvig!uiel<hic!-bg<g!uQp<s<sqg<Gg<!
giv{l<?! keqleqkg<! giv{r<gt<! Eco nz<zA! nuIgt<! siIf<kqVf<k! gm<sq!
-bg<gk<kqe<! hqtUkie<! giv{l<! we! \e/Sf<kvl<! osh<Hgqe<xiI/! =OviM!
klqpe<he<?!uiel<hicgtqe<!hqiqUg<Gl<!uQp<s<sqg<Gl<!giv{l<!nuIgt<!nvsqbjz!
wkqIogit<Tkzqz<! Wx<hm<m! gVk<K!Lv{<hiMgt<!NGl<! we<gqxiI/! klqp<fime<!
“-f<kqvi.-f<kqbi’!F~z<! outqbqm<m! OhiK!nvsqbz<! hqtU!dXkqbieK/! sqx<hq?!
Olk<ki?! HuqbvS?!hizi?!klqp<fime<?!sq/NI/-vuQf<kqve<?! sg<kqg<gez<?! Okevse<?!
kq/g/sqkl<hvfike<! LkziOeiI! Yv{qbigUl<?! Rieq?! ng<gqeq! Hk<kqve<?! Nkq!
LkziOeiI! lx<OxiI! n{qbigUl<?! \e/Sf<kvl<?! -tLVG! OuOxiI!
n{qbigUl<! osbz<hmk<! okimr<gqbkiz<! uiel<hic! -bg<gl<! hqtUh<hm<M!
uQp<s<sqjb!Ofig<gqs<!ose<xK/!
!
! kx<Hgp<s<sq?! kx<ohVjl?! ke<Ljeh<H?! gMjlbie! uqlIsel<?!
liIg<sqbk<Kt<! hqtUgt<?! -f<kqb! nvsqbz<! )nusvgiz! fqjz*! we<El<! hz!
60 giv{r<gtiz<! uiel<hic! uQp<s<sqbjmf<kK/! yx<Xjl! OhieKA! Oux<Xjlgt<!
uf<keA! -bg<gl<! uQp<f<kKA! Wlix<xl<! uf<kK/! kqjv! dzgLl<! uiel<hic!
uQp<s<sqg<G!ljxLgg<!giv{lib<!-Vf<Kt<tK/!
!
! uiel<hic! -kp<! 21! -z<?! “OfvcbigOui?! ljxLgligOui! -br<gq!
uVgqe<x! wf<k! nvsqbz<! gm<sqgTmEl<! .! nf<kvr<gligOui! hgqvr<gligOui!
nvsqbz<!iQkqbie!okimIH!wr<gTg<Gg<!gqjmbiK/!-kje!lqg!ue<jlbigUl<!
dXkqbigUl<! dvk<k! Gvzqz<! nxquqg<g! uqjpgqe<Oxil<”! we<El<! nxquqh<Hl<?!
uiel<hic! -bg<gk<kqz<! biI! biI! fQg<gh<hm<miIgt<! we<El<! hm<cbz<! sqX!
K{<mxqg<jgBl<!outqbibqe/!-r<G!nvsqbz<!siIf<kuIgTl<!-bg<gk<kqzqVf<K!
fQg<gh<hm<muIgTl<! keqOb! osbz<hmk<! okimr<gqeI/! uiel<hicg<G! wkqvig!
‘Out<uq’! we<El<! -kjpBl<! okimr<gqeI/! -keiz<! uiel<hic! hzuQel<!
njmf<kKA!uQp<s<sqjb!Ofig<gqs<!ose<xK/!
!
! uiel<hicbqe<! uQp<s<sq! Gxqk<K! ‘Out<uq’! Lkz<! -kpqz<! gVk<K!
outqbqmh<! ohx<xK/! nK! hqe<uVliX/! “uiel<hicg<! guqki! l{<mzk<kqz<!
ke<jes<!sqxf<k!guqReigk<!OkIf<okMg<guqz<jzOb!we<x!niqh<hiz<!.!hqxjvs<!
osiiqb! Lx<hm<mkiz<! wPf<k! le <̂kihr<gt<! /! /! /! Le<kqm<mh<hc?! sqz!
Gph<hr<gjtk<! kQIk<Kuqm<M! 2:83! csl<hiqz<! gif<kqh<! h,r<giuqz<! )OgibLk<K~I*!
sqx<hq! kjzjlbqz<! fmf<k! %m<ml<! uiel<hic! -bg<g! uvzix<xqe<! okimg<g!
Ljebig!-Vf<kK/!uiel<hic!guqjk!-bg<gligOu!-Vg<g!Ou{<Ml</!-kqz<!
uqlIsgIgTg<G! -ml<! -Vg<gg<%miK! we<x! gVk<Kg<gt<! lXg<gh<hm<M?!
uiel<hicjb! .! -zg<gqb! -bg<glig! lix<x! Ou{<Ml<! we<X! LcU!
osb<bh<hm<mK/! /! /! 2:84! seuiqbqz<! osbz<hmk<! okimr<g! Ou{<cb! -bg<gl<!
Juiqz<! &uiqe<! yk<Kjph<hqe<jlbiz<! kjmh<hm<mK/! -bg<glieiz<! -kp<! kl<!
usl<! -z<ziK! OhiGl<! we<hkiz<! .! -bg<gk<jkh<! Hxg<g{qk<Kuqm<M! -kjpk<!
kl<ush<hMk<Kukqz<! guel<! osZk<kqeI/! uiel<hic! uq/sq/w <̂/! gizeq!
Wgikqhk<kqbk<kqx<Gt<!Lmg<gh<hm<mK!/!/! /!okimIf<K!&e<X!likr<gtig!-kp<!
outquvilz<!-bg<gk<kqe<!zm<sqbr<gjt!nfijkgtig!njzbuqm<meI/!gckk<!
okimIHgt<! uqMhm<Mh<! Ohibqe/! uiel<hic! Nb<uvr<gr<gjth<! Hxg<g{qk<keI/!
Ogi]<c!OsIg<Gl<!leh<hie<jl!nkqkQuqvligqbK/! /! /! /!hk<kiuK!-kpqz<!kl<!
Lk<kqjvgjts<!sqjkk<Kg<!ogi{<meI/”32!
!
61 3/6/!sqx<hqbqe<!Lbx<sq!
! uiel<hic! -bg<gk<kqe<! uQp<s<sqbiz<! uiel<hic! -kjp! fmk<Kukqz<!
sqg<gz<! Wx<hm<mK/! weqEl<! sqx<hq! hizSh<hqvl{qbl<! nf<kh<! ohiXh<jh! Wx<Xg<!
ogi{<M! fmk<kqeiI/! wkqv{qbqeI!-f<k!-bg<gk<kqzqVf<K!uqzgqbOkiM?! OuX!
-kp<gtqz<! uqlIseLl<! osb<keI/! sqx<hq! kl<jls<! siIf<kuIgtqmlqVf<K!
guqjkgjth<! ohx<X! uiel<hic! -kpqjek<! okimIf<K! fmk<kqeiI/! sqx<hq!
h{qbix<XuK! ohit<tis<sqbqz<A! uiel<hic! -kp<h<! h{q! Ogijubqz</! nkeiz<!
uiel<hic! -kpqjeg<! OgijubqzqVf<K! kl<! osif<k! Dvie! Nk<Kh<!
ohit<tis<sqg<G! lix<xqg<! ogi{<M?! kl<! -z<zk<kqzqVf<Ok! uiel<hic! -kpqje!
fmk<kqeiI/! -Vh<hqEl<! GMl<hl<?! h{q?! -zus! -kp<?! hqxI! yk<Kjph<hqe<jl!
Lkzie! giv{r<gtiz<! uiel<hic! 33! NuK! -kPme<! fqXk<kh<hm<mK/!
uiel<hic! -bg<gk<kqz<! -Vf<kuIgt<! njeuVl<! WOki! yVujgbqz<!
sqxh<Hg<GiqbuIgt</!
!
! RieqBl<! \e/Sf<kvLl<! liIg<sqbIgt</! HuqbvS?! -tLVG! -VuVl<!
HKg<guqRIgt</!sqx<hq?!ng<gqeq!Hk<kqve<?!Olk<ki?!lQvi!Ngqb!fiz<uVl<!klqp<h<!
OhvisqiqbIgt</! hizi! Nr<gqzh<! OhvisqiqbI/! Lz<jz! NkuEl<!
sq/NI/-vuQf<kqvEl<! -zg<gqb! li{uIgt</! fi/gilvisEl<?! hi/osbh<hqvgisLl<!
-zg<gqbh<!Hvm<sqbitIgt</!sg<kqg<gez<!lvHg<!guqRvigUl<!gr<jg!ogi{<mie<!
gjzRvigUl<! uqtr<gqeI/! gzih<iqbi! ur<gqh<! h{qbitI/! -uIgt<! OsIf<K!
-br<gqb! -bg<gk<kqz<! hqiqU! uf<kK! HKg<guqjkg<G! Wx<hm<m! OsikjebiGl</!
fz<z! sikjejbh<! hjmg<Gl<! we! wkqIhiIg<gh<hm<mK/! -uIgtqe<! okimg<gg<!
giz! osbz<hiMgt<! fim<cje! NTl<! fqjzg<G! uf<kK/! -K! okimIhig!
L/Olk<ki?! “uiel<hicgt<! lm<Ml<! yx<Xjlbig! OlOz! OlOz! hxh<Ohilieiz<!
fil<! nlVl<! %M! klqpgk<kqe<! niqbj{big! -Vg<Gl</! fz<zim<sq! ye<jx!
fmk<kqg<!gim<mzil<!fil<”!we<X!olipquKl<!-u{<!fqjeU%vk<kg<gkiGl</!
!
! uiel<hic! -bg<gk<kqe<! kjzfgI! Ogijubig! -Vf<kiZl<! nf<k!
njlh<hqz<! -Vf<kuIgt<! klqpgl<! kPuqb! fqjzbqz<! gi{h<hm<miIgt</! Rieq!
OgijuA!L/Olk<ki!ohiqbGtl<A!lQviUl<!hiziUl<!squgr<jgjbs<!OsIf<kuIgt<A!
klqp<fime<! Oszk<jks<! siIf<kuIA! =Ovim<jms<! siIf<kuI! klqpe<he<A! sqx<hq!
ohit<tis<sqg<G!nVgqz<!dt<t!Nk<Kh<!ohit<tis<sqjbs<!siIf<kuIA!gzih<iqbi!
kqVofz<Ouzq!lium<mk<jks<! Osif<kuIA!klqpue<!ge<eqbiGliqjbs<!OsIf<kuI/!
62 -uIgt<! klqp<! .! HKjl! -! ohiKUjmjl?! Hvm<sq! -ux<xqz<! ye<Xhm<M!
osbzix<xqeiIgt</! hzVl<! hz! giv{r<gtiz<! hqiqf<K! OhieiZl<! sqx<hq! kl<!
osif<k! ohiXh<hqz<! osif<k! uQm<cz<! uiel<hic! -kp<! outqbqMl<! h{qjb!
-Xkqbigs<!osb<kiI/!nuVjmb!Lbx<sqBl<!33NuK!-kPme<!Lcf<Kuqm<mK/!
!
! uiel<hicg<!guqjkk<!okiGh<H!-kp<gt<!olik<kl<!33!outquf<Kt<te/!
-f<k! 33! -kp<gtqZl<! 5:2! guqjkgTl<! guqjk! F~z<! lkqh<HjvgTl<! sqz!
uqlIseg<!gm<MjvgTl<!OfIgi{Zl<!ns<sigq!outquf<Kt<te/!
!
! 2:94!Nl<!N{<M!-zr<jgbqz<!=pk<!klqpIgTg<gig!uqMkjzh<!Hzqgt<!
Ohivim<ml<! kQuqvl<! njmf<kK/! nkeiz<! sqx<hq! uiel<hic! -Vhk<kqv{<miuK!
-kpqje! .! -Xkq! -kpqje! -zr<jgs<! sqxh<hqkpig! outqbqm<miI/! -f<k!
-kpqz<!-zr<jgg<!guqRIgt<!wl</W/F0lie<?!s{<Lgl<!squzqr<gl<?!n/ObSvisi?!
u/J/s/o\bhize<?!al<sk<ueq!LkziOeiI!wPkqb!guqjkgTl<!outqbibqe/!
-f<k!-kpqz<!“-zr<jg!wiqgqxK”!we<El<!kjzh<hqz<!h/sqkl<hvfikeqe<!guqjk!
outqbigqBt<tK/!=pk<!klqpI!Ohivim<mk<jk!Nkiqk<K!“-eq!fie<!HbziOue<”!
we<El<! kjzh<hqz<! sqx<hq! guqjk! hjmk<K! uiel<hic! 33! Nl<! -kpqz<!
outqbqm<Mt<tiI/! nf<kg<! guqjkjb! LPjlbig! -r<Gg<! Gxqh<hqm<Mg<!
gim<MuK!kGl</!
Hk<kI!hqvieqe<!
osiz<Zg<Gs<!slikqgm<c!
hz<Zg<G!uqpi!wMg<Gl<!
ghm!lgiul<sg<!GVliIgt<!/!/!/!
!
klqp<!dmz<lQK!
Kh<hig<gqg<!gk<kq!Ljegtiz<!
sqr<gt!vk<ks<!sqk<kqvl<!
wPkqg<!gtqg<Gl<!
N{u!vi[ul<!/!/!/!!
!
fqIui{g<!gkxz<!uQxqm!
klqp<!-tl<!h,g<gt<!
uql<lqb!dbqiqe<!nzxjzs<!
63
sr<gQk!n[g<gtib<!vsqk<K!wg<gtqk<k!
liEmg<!gbjl!/!/!/!
!
ogiPl<Hk<!okVg<gtqz<!
kjzLjxgtig!vk<kl<!dxqR<sqb!
Okbqjzg<!gim<M!ljz!OlMgtqz<!.!
Lt<LVr<jgs<!osl<h,!dkqVl<!
gqMG!Ouzqgtqe<!Yvk<kqz<!.!
-eouxqh<!hjgh<Hjg!ofVh<hqz<!
wZl<Hl<!kjsBl<!wiqb!
Dkq!Dkqg<!GtqI!gib<f<k!
Ogi{z<!nvS!/!/!/!
!
sIuikqgivr<gt<!
klg<Gk<!kiOl!wPkqg<!ogit<Tl<!
gjmsq!nk<kqbibl<!
-zr<jgbqz<!okimg<gl<!
hml<!uqiqk<kiMl<!
hikgr<gTg<G!
-h<hck<kie<!-eq!
su!nmg<gl<"!
!
fQzg<!gmx<gjv!l{z<outqgtqz<!
GVkq!Dx<Xg<gt<!ogih<htqk<kOhiK!
Yzlqm<mPk!gmzqml<!
gix<X!Yr<givlqm<M!djvk<kK;!
nPjgjb!fqXk<K!
-eq!fie<!HbziOue<!
sQXl<!HzqbiOue<"!
!
l{<{qe<!Hkz<uIgt<!kl<!
sk<kqbl<!SmIuqMl<!g{<gt<!
vk<kk<!K~tib<!dkqIg<gh<hm<m!OhiK!
64
Heqklib<!lcObf<kqb!
h,lq!osiz<zqx<X;!
ohiXjlbqe<!kip<gt<!
ofiXr<gqe!
uqMkjz!fim<gt<!
ofVr<gqe/!
!
sm<mr<gt<!
Nbqvr<giz!
olipqh<hbqI!OlBOli@!
Kh<hig<gqgt<!
Kh<Hl<!lv{k<kiz<!
juvl<!hib<f<k!
d{IUgt<!OkBOli@!
K~g<Gg<!gbqXgt<!
Gvz<ujtjb!-Xg<Gukiz<!
Skf<kqvk<kqe<!
gQkr<gt<!YBOli@!
!
siqk<kqvk<kqe<!
kQm<s{<bh<!hiIjubqz<!
=pk<kqe<!kjtgt<!okxqg<Gl<!.!
okxqk<Ok!kQVl<"!
njzgmx<gh<hiz<!
yV!HKs<osiI{!Ovjg!
dkqh<hkz<ziK!
Ouoxe<e!OfVl<@33!
3/7/!-Xkqh<!hb{l<!
! uiel<hic! -bg<gk<kqeI! hqtUhm<meI/! uiel<hic! -kPg<Gg<! guqjk!
uvU!Gjxf<kK/!uqjzbqzi!-kpig!fmk<KuK!keq!yVuviz<!-bzik!osbz</!
uiel<hic!-kp<gt<!25!Lkz<!33!ujv!sqx<hqbqe<!ohiXh<hqz<!outquf<ke/!sqx<hq!
ohiXh<Ohx<X! uf<k! -kp<gTg<Gl<! nkx<G! Le<H! uf<k! -kp<gTg<Gl<!
dVuk<kqZl<! dt<tmg<gk<kqZl<! OuXhiMgt<! gi{h<hm<me/! hkqeie<gil<!
65 -kpqz<?! Lgh<Hh<! hg<gk<kqz<! Olx<Ogijt! wMk<kitilz<?! ke<! gVk<kqjeOb!
sqx<hq! wMk<ki{<Mt<tiI/! -kpqz<! guqjkg<G! Wx<x! Yuqbl<?! Hjgh<hmk<kqx<Ogx<x!
guqjk?!Ohm<c!g{<m!gjzRiqe<!Hjgh<hml<!Lkzieju!-kpqe<!nm<jmbqz<!
-ml<ohx<X?!uisgiqe<!lek<jkg<!guIf<ke/!
!
! weqEl<! sqx<hq! hizSh<hqvl{qbl<! OgijubqzqVf<K! uqMhm<M?! Nk<Kh<!
ohit<tis<sq! sqx<X~iqzqVf<Ok! uiel<hic! -kp<gjt! outqbqm<M! uf<kiI/! -uI!
ohit<tis<sqbqz<!nvS!dkuq!ohXl<!gz<Z~iqbqz<!klqp<h<!OhvisqiqbI!h{qjbBl<!
hiIk<Kg<ogi{<M?!uiel<hic!-kjpBl<!outqbqm<M?!nf<k!-kp<gjt!lg<gtqml<!
ogi{<M!OsIg<g!Ou{<cb!h{qjbBl<!osb<Bl<ohiPK!hz!fqjzgtqz<!okib<U!
Wx<hm<mK/!YI!-bg<gl<!fmk<kqb!-kpqje!-!yV!GPuqeI!fmk<kqb!-kpqje!
-! keq! yVuI! fmk<KuK! niqb! osbz<! we<hK! out<tqjmljz/! nkeiz<?!
uiel<hicbqe<! -Xkqh<! hb{l<! -zr<jgs<! sqxh<hqkpib<! outquf<k!
-Vhk<kqv{<mil<!-kpiGl</!
!
! uiel<hic! -kp<gt<! okimg<gl<! Lkz<! -Xkqujv! kl<! ogit<jggjt!
d{Is<sqBmEl<!uQiqbk<KmEl<!ns<slqe<xqBl<!outqbqm<M!uf<Kt<te/!2:82!Nl<!
N{<Mk<! okimr<gq?! 2:94! Nl<! N{<M! fqjxU! ohx<xK/! Lkz<! -kpqz<!
hivkqbiIqe<!guqjkBl<?!-Xkq!-kpqz<!oh/Sf<kvl<! hqt<jtbqe<!lOeie<l{qbl<!
fimgg<!guqjk!ncgTl<!Olx<Ogit<gtigk<!kvh<ohx<Xt<te/!
-e<X!fQI!
sqf<Kl<!
vk<kl<!YI!
KtqBl<!
fqe<X!Bgl<!hzUl<!
fqgp<k<KOl!
we<El<! lOeie<l{qb! fimgk<kqz<! uVl<! %x<X?! uiel<hic! -Xkq! -kpqz<!
Olx<Ogitigk<!kvh<hm<mkx<Gl<?!-f<k!-kp<!-zr<jgs<!sqxh<hqkpib<!uf<kkx<Gl<?!
2:94!Nl<!N{<M!outquf<k!-f<k!-kpqe<!gizk<kqz<!-zr<jgbqz<!=pk<klqpI!
Ohivim<ml<! fmf<K! uf<kkx<Gl<! lqgh<! ohiVk<klib<k<! kqgp<gqe<xK/! -K!
Lh<hki{<Mgjtg<! gmf<kiZl<! -e<El<! nf<ks<! sqg<gz<! kQvuqz<jz/! -kx<G!
nvsqbz<?! ohiVtikivl<?! -el<!Lkzieju!giv{qgtig!-Vg<gqe<xe/!-0K!
wtqkqz<!fmf<KuqmiK/!
66 ! “uIg<gr<gjt! LPjlbig! ypqh<hkx<Gs<! Sv{<mz<givIgjtk<!
Okix<gck<kiz<! lm<Ml<! OhikiK/! dx<hk<kqs<! siker<gtqe<lQK!
djmjlbitIgTg<G! -Vg<Gl<! diqjlgjt! ypqk<kiz<! lm<Ml<! OhikiK/!
dx<hk<kqs<! siker<gtqz<! keq! djmjljb! LPuKl<! ypqg<g! Ou{<Ml</!
fgvr<gTg<Gl<! gqvilr<gTg<Gl<! -jmOb! dt<t! uqk<kqbisr<gjt! ypqg<g!
Ou{<Ml</! dmz<! djph<hitqgTg<Gl<! &jt! djph<hitqgTg<Gl<! -jmOb!
dt<t! OuXhiMgjt! ypqg<g! Ou{<Ml</! -g<gmjlgjt! fqjxOux<x! fQ{<m!
gizl<!NGl<”34!we<El<!ozeqe<!gVk<Kl<!-u{<!Ofig<gk<kg<gkiGl</!
!
3/8/!okiGh<Hjv!
! klqp<h<! HKg<guqjk! dzgqz<! ‘uiel<hic! -bg<gl<’! Gxqh<hqmk<kg<g!
ye<xiGl</! 2:82! Nl<N{<M! Lkz<! 2:94! Nl<! N{<M! ujv! hkqe<&e<X!
N{<Mgtqz<! -Vhk<kqv{<M! -kp<gjt! uqjzbqe<xq! outqbqm<M! lg<gtqmk<kqz<!
HKg<guqjkgjtg<!ogi{<M!OsIk<k!ohVjl!uiel<hicg<!guqRIgjts<!siVl</!
lg<gt<?!nvsqbz<?!s&gl<?!ohiVtikivl<?!uIg<gh<!Ohivim<ml<?!-eh<!Ohivim<ml<?!
olipqh<! Ohivim<ml<! we<El<! he<Lgh<! hiMohiVt<gjt! jlbh<hMk<kq?!
guqjkgjtg<! guqRIgt<! hjmk<Kt<teI/! l{qg<ogic?! wPk<K?! gsmkhx?!
fjm?! lQm<sq! Lkzie! -kp<gtqz<! outquf<k! guqjkgjtuqm?! uiel<hicbqz<!
outquf<k! guqjkgt<! keqk<KuLl<! uQiqbLl<! lqg<gkib<g<! gi{h<ohXgqe<xe/!
uiel<hic! -kp<gt<! okimIf<K! Jl<hki{<Mgt<! okimg<gk<jkh<! OhizOu!
uQs<Sme<! outquf<kqVf<kiz<?! klqp<h<! HKg<guqjk! dzgqz<! Lkzqmk<jkh<!
ohx<xqVg<Gl</!nvsqbzqZl<! sLkibk<kqZl<! ohiVtikivk<kqZl<! hz!lix<xr<gt<!
fqgp<f<kqVg<g!uib<h<H{<M/!
67
sie<ox{<!uqtg<gl<!
!
2/ sqx<hq!hizSh<hqvl{qbl</!“uiel<hic”?!-zg<gqb!-kp<gt<?!h/469/!
3/ klqp<fime<?!yV!uiel<hicbqe<!-zg<gqb!uiel<?!h/9/!
4/ O\/lR<StiOkuq!)oki/N/*?!uiel<hicg<!guqjkgt<?!hg</2.5/!
5/ Olx<hc!F~z<?!h/9/!
6/ sqx<hq!hizSh<hqvl{qbl</!“uiel<hic”?!-zg<gqb!-kp<gt<?!hg</477.478/!
7/ O\/lR<StiOkuq!)oki/N/*?!uiel<hicg<!guqjkgt<?!h/29:/!
8/ hivkqbiI!guqjkgt<?!“Skf<kqvh<!ht<T”?!h/318/!
9/ Rieq?!uiel<hicgtqe<!guqjk!-bg<gl<!.!uvziXl<!hch<hqjeBl<?!h/239/!
:/ O\/lR<StiOkuq!)oki/N/*?!uiel<hicg<!guqjkgt<?!hg</59.5:/!
21/ uz<zqg<g{<{e<! )Olx<Ogit<*?! HKg<guqjkbqe<! Okix<xLl<! utIs<sqBl<?!
hg</332.333/!
22/ hivkqbiI!guqjkgt<?!“gim<sq”?!h/6::/!
23/ hivkqbiI!guqjkgt<?!“uqfibgI!fie<l{q!lijz”?!h/22/!
24/ O\/lR<StiOkuq!)oki/N/*?!uiel<hicg<!guqjkgt<?!h/63/!
25/ Rieq?!uiel<hicgtqe<!guqjk!-bg<gl<!.!uvziXl<!hch<hqjeBl<?!h/215/!
26/ O\/lR<StiOkuq!)sqx<hqBme<!Ohm<c*?!liEml<!hiMl<!uiel<hic?!hg</55.56/!
27/ Rieq?!uiel<hicgtqe<!guqjk!-bg<gl<! .!uvziXl<!hch<hqjeBl<?!hg</219.
21:/!
28/ O\/lR<StiOkuq!)Olx<Ogit<*?!liEml<!hiMl<!uiel<hic?!hg</75.76/!
29/ Olx<hc!F~z<?!hg</78.79/!
2:/ Olx<hc!F~z<?!hg</79.7:/!
31/ Olx<hc!F~z<?!h/7:/!
32/ Olx<hc!F~z<?!hg</88.89/!
33/ O\/lR<StiOkuq!)oki/N/*?!uiel<hicg<!guqjkgt<?!hg</545.547/!
34/ fi/uieliljz!)Olx<Ogit<*?!liIg<sqb!s&guqbz<!ogit<jg?!h/64/!
!
-bz<!4!!
HKg<guqjkgtqz<!okie<ll<!
!
4/1/!LgUjv!
! dVuk<kqZl<! dt<tmg<gk<kqZl<! HKjlgjth<! hjmk<K! uVl<!
HKg<guqjkgt<?! guqjkbqe<! outqh<him<Mk<! kqxe<gtqZl<! hz! HKjlgjts<!
osb<K!uVgqe<xe/! ‘wkjes<!osiz<gqOxil<!we<hkjeuqm?!wh<hcs<!osiz<gqOxil<!
we<hK! Lg<gqbl<’! we<X! nxqRIgt<! %Xgqe<xeI/! -zg<gqbk<kqx<G! d{Is<sq?!
gx<hje?! ucul<?! gVk<K! we<El<! fie<Gl<! Okju! we<hK! wf<k! ntUg<G!
Lg<gqbOli?! nf<k! ntuqx<G! outqh<him<Mk<! kqxe<! Lg<gqbl</! outqh<him<Mk<!
kqxje! outqh<hMk<Kl<! Ljx! we<Xl<! dk<kq! we<Xl<! kqxeib<uitIgt<!
%Xgqe<xeI/! HKg<guqjkgt<! utIf<K! oux<xq! ohx<X! uVukx<G! Lke<jlg<!
giv{lib<! -Vh<hK! guqjkbqz<! gi{h<hMl<! outqh<him<Mk<! kqxe<! NGl</!
weOu?! HKg<guqjk! dk<kqgjtBl<! nux<Xt<! okie<ll<! ohXlqml<! hx<xqBl<!
-f<k!-bz<!uqtg<Ggqe<xK/!!
!
4/2/!HKg<guqjk!dk<kqgt<!
! okiz<gih<hqbI! F~zqe<! dk<kqgtig! ‘Fkzqbkxqkz<’! Lkzie!
Lh<hk<kqv{<cjeg<! Gxqh<hqMgqe<xiI/! -ju! F~Zg<Giqb! fjmbqbz<!
dk<kqgtiGl</! Neiz<! HKg<guqjkgtqz<! yu<ouiV! guqjkjbBl<! osiz<Zl<!
Ljxbqz<!OuXhiMgt<!-Vg<gqe<xe/!yu<ouiV!guqjkg<Gl<!d{Is<sq?!gVk<K?!
osiz<Zl<!Ljx!Lkzieju!OuXhMgqe<xe/!!
osiz<Zl<!LjxOb!dk<kq!biGl<2!
we<hK!HKg<guqjk!-zg<g{liGl</!-K!fjmbqbOziM!ohiVf<kq!uVgqe<xK/!
HKg<guqjkg<G! -zg<g{l<! wPkqb! hiuzOvX! s/hizSf<kvl<?! HKg<guqjk!
dk<kqgjtBl<!Gxqh<hqMgqe<xiI/!!
gx<xuI!lx<xuI!-Vsi!viVl<!
okx<oxe!nxqf<k!klqOpi!mbz<olipqs<!
osxqUjms<!osix<gtie<!guqjkg<!gVh<ohiVm<!!
Ogx<x!hclg<!GxqbQM!OkIf<K!
oktqUl<!SVg<gLl<!kqgPl<!dk<kqobiM!
Yjs!ncokijm!sQIujv!uqe<xqs<!
osiz<zjlh<!OhijsBt<!tmg<g!dVUl<!
69
dull<!dVugl<!kx<Gxqh<!Ohx<xl<!
hqxqK!olipqkz<!Gxqh<H!sqOzjm!
-z<ohiVt<!dull<!Fm<h!ligqb!
n{qfbl<!F{<{qkqe<!ohikqb!FgIOuiI!
K{qkx<!giqb!okiGohiVm<!H{Ih<Hl<!
nr<gkl<!hqsqobEl<!ofxqbie<!-cobek<!
kig<gLl<!lqe<Ohiz<!htqs<osEl<!d{Is<sqBl<!
fQIuQp<s<sq!jbh<Ohiz<!gVk<Kh<!hib<s<sZl<!
kQh<Ohiz<!djxh<Hl<!Okie<xh<!hz<ujg!
Le<eoliM!gqth<hK!HKh<hi!uiGl</3!
! HKg<guqjk!dk<kqgjt!-vi/-viOsf<kqve<!NX! ujggtigh<! hGk<Kg<!
gim<Mgqe<xiI/!!
dk<kq!kiOe!
hcll<!GxqbQM!nr<gkl<!lQolb<l<jl!
LvO{!oktqoue!-V&!ujgk<Ok4!
! SVr<gs<! osiz<zq! uqtr<g! juh<hkx<Gl<?! ye<xqjeg<! %xq?! nke<&zl<!
Ouoxie<xqje!d{v/Hiqb!juh<hkx<Gl<!dk<kq!hbe<hMgqe<xK/!gVk<Kg<gjts<!
osiz<Zl<! Ljxbqz<! HKg<guqjk! hz! sikjegjth<! hjmk<Kt<tK/!
HKg<guqRIgt<!dk<kqg<Gs<!sqxh<hqml<!kf<Kt<teI/!!
!
! yu<ouiV!Kjxg<Gl<!yu<ouiV!ujgbie!dk<kq!-Vg<gqe<xK/!dujl?!
dVugl<?! hcll<?! GxqbQM?! Lv{<?! nr<gkl<?! okie<ll<?! -vm<Mx! olipqkz<?!
djvbimz<?! -zg<gj{?! kqVl<hg<! %xz<?! gjk! %xz<?! fim<Mh<Hxg<! %Xgt<?!
-V{<jl?! uqei! uqjm! dk<kq?! uV{je! dk<kq?! gckLjx! dk<kq?! osiz<!
nMg<gq! uVkz<?! okimI! nMg<gq! uVkz<?! fimg! dk<kq?! Olx<Ogit<! gim<mz<?!
osix<gjts<!sqjkk<kz<?!uiqgjt!ujtk<kz<?!nkqIu,m<mz<!)kqMg<gqmz<!dk<kq*?!
nxquqbz<.g{qkg<! GxqbQMgjth<! hbe<hMk<kz<?! hqxolipqg<! gzh<H! dk<kq?!
Ohs<Solipqg<! gzh<H! dk<kq?! hpr<gjkg<! %Xgjtg<! gzg<Gl<! dk<kq?!
fjgs<Sju?! npgqbz<?! -bx<jg! NTjl?! osbx<jg! NTjl! Lkzieju!
HKg<guqjkgtqz<! dk<kqgtigg<! gi{h<ohXgqe<xe/! HKg<guqjk! dk<kqgjt!
ujvbjx! osb<b! -bzik! ntUg<G?! nke<! hbe<hiM! lqGf<Kt<tK/!
HKg<guqjk!dk<kqgt<!utIf<K!ogi{<Om!osz<gqe<xe/!-kjeg<!Ogzq!osb<Bl<!
ujgbqz<?!!
70
gm<Mjv!fjmbicg<!
guqjkg<Gh<!ohiVt<Okc!
////////////////////////////////!
ujtk<Ks<!sqjkk<kqm<mie<!
ujtouz<zil<!dk<kqobe<xie<!
-zg<gqbl<!osb<uoke<xiz<!
wtqkqz<jz!wPk<kiti////5!
we<X!oh/Ogi/Sf<kvvi\e<!)sqm<c*!%Xgqe<xiI/!!
!
“guqjkbqz<! dt<t! osix<gt<! kl<! OfIh<ohiVjt! -pf<K?! hch<hueqe<!
lek<kqz<! Hkqb! w{<{! njzgjt! –! nkqIUgjt! Wx<hMk<kuz<z! ujgbqz<!
njlg<Gl<! yV! okipqz<Fm<hOl! dk<kq”6! we<X! ou/-vk<kqe&Ik<kq! dk<kqg<G!
ujvbjx!%Xgqe<xiI/!!
!
! HKg<guqjkbqe<! dVuk<KmEl<! dt<tmg<gk<KmEl<! ye<xqg<!
gi{h<hMuK! dk<kqbiGl</! guqjkbqe<! dVuk<kqz<! guqReqe<! olipqh<!
hbe<himigqb! ucu! njlh<Hl<! guqjkbqe<! dt<tmg<gk<kqz<! guqReqe<!
$pZg<G! Wx<h! Fuz<ohiVjth<! hjmg<Gl<! NTjlBl<! nEhuLl<!
outqh<hMgqe<xe/! guqReqe<! olipqk<! kqxjlBl<! NTjlBl<! dk<kqjbs<!
sqxh<higg<!jgbit!dkUgqe<xe/!weOu?!guqRe<!guqjkbqe<!olipqfjmjbs<!
osl<jlbigh<! hqe<hx<x! Ou{<cbkigqxK/! gVk<kqje! uisgI! lek<kqz<!
fqjzfqXk<k!Ou{<Moleqz<!gVk<kqje!d{Ik<Kl<!Ljxbie!dk<kq!sqxh<hig!
njlb! Ou{<Ml</! HKg<guqRIgt<! dk<kqg<Gs<! sqxh<hqml<! kf<Kt<tkiz<?!
HKg<guqjk!keq!YI!-zg<gqb!ujgbig!dVuigq!utIf<K!uVgqe<xK/!!
!
! dujl?! dVugl<?! hcll<?! GxqbQM?! Lv{<?! nr<gkl<?! okie<ll<?!
-V{<jl?! osix<sqjkU! we<X! guqjk! LPjlBl<! dk<kqgjtg<! jgbiTl<!
OhiK?! guqjkbqe<! gVk<K! he<Lgk<! ke<jlBme<! hbe<! dt<tkib<! -Vg<g!
Ou{<Ml</! guqjkbqz<! gVk<kz<zilz<! ouXl<! dk<kqgjt! lm<Ml<! hqe<hx<XuK!
guqjkbqe<! Ofig<gk<jk! fqjxOux<xiK/! hbEjmb! gVk<kqjes<! sqxf<k!
dk<kqbiz<!fz<z!fjmBme<!%XuOk!Ou{<mx<hizK/!!
! hbex<x!gVk<kqjeh<!Hkqb!Hkqb!dk<kqgtqz<!%Xl<!HKg<guqRIgjts<!
sq/-/ljxljz?! “dk<kqgtqz<! dt<tk<jkh<! hxqogiMk<Kuqm<Mg<! gVk<kqz<zilz<!
71 guqjk! wPk! LjeOuiI/! dbqvx<x! uiIk<jkg<! Guqbz<gjth<! Hkqb!
Ogizr<gtqz<! ntqh<hjkOb! klK! h{qbig! w{<{q! fqjxUXgqe<xeI”7! we<X!
siMgqe<xiI/!!
!
! HKg<guqjkbqe<! dVuk<jkBl<! dt<tmg<gk<jkBl<! sqxh<hig!
njlh<hKl<!Ng<GuKl<!outqh<hMk<KuKl<!d{Ik<Kl<!Ljxbigqb!dk<kqgOt!
NGl</!dk<kqgt<!guqRiqe<!olipq!NTjljbg<!gim<Mgqe<xe/!
!
4/2/2/!okie<ll<!
! ‘okiz<’! we<El<! OuIs<osiz<! ‘hjpjl’! we<El<! ohiVjt!
d{Ik<Kgqe<xK/! ‘okiz<! ! jl’! okie<jl! we! uf<kK/! okie<l<! ! nl<! !
okie<ll<!NgqbK/!okie<jl?!okie<ll<!we<he!okipqx<ohbIgt</!okiz<gih<hqbI!
gizk<kqz<!okie<ll<!we<hK!osb<Bt<!dXh<higUl<!osb<BtigUl<!-Vf<kK/8!!
okie<jl!kiOe!osiz<Zr<!gijz!
djvobiM!H{If<k!hjpjl!Olx<Ox9!
we<X!okie<ll<!Gxqk<K!okiz<gih<hqbI!uqtg<gl<!ntqg<gqe<xiI/!!
!
! “okijgs<!$k<kqvk<Kt<?! ‘NXkjzbqm<m!nf<fijzf<Kl<’! )okiz</! osb</2*!
weg<! %X! osb<K! fqxQ-h<?! hqe<eI! wm<MXh<Hg<! %xqeiee<Ox@! -ju!
nux<Oxiomik<k! -zg<g{k<jk! ne<jlbie<A! we<je@! nju! )37*! yOvi!
osb<Bm<Og! Ykqb! dXh<higziEl<?! -ju! )9*! hz<! osb<BTf<! kqv{<mupq!
-u<ou{<ujgBl<!hx<xqk<!okiMg<gh<hMoleg<!%xh<hm<mkigziEl<!we<hK” we<X!
osb<Bt<! dXh<Hgt<! Lh<hk<K! fie<gqjeh<! OhvisqiqbI! -v{<Mujgh<!
h{<Hjmbju! weg<! %Xgqe<xiI/! hz! osb<BTf<! kqv{<m! upq! uVl<! wm<Mt<!
okie<jl!ye<xiGl</ !!!
!
! “okie<jlbiuK! djvobiM! ohiVf<kqh<! Ohif<k! hjpjlk<kigqb!
ohiV{<Olz<! uVue/! nju! -vil! siqkLl<A! hi{<mu! siqkLl<!
Lkzigqbux<xqe<Olz<!uVR<osb<Bt<”!we<X!-tl<h,v{Vl<?!
! “okie<jlobe<hK! djvuqvinb<h<! hjpjlbuigqb! gjkh<ohiVtigs<!
osb<bh<hMuK/! nju! ohVf<Okueivix<! himh<hm<m! hivkLl<?! kg_I!
bik<kqjvBl<!Ohiz<ue”!we<X!OhvisqiqbVl<!okie<jlg<G!uqtg<gl<!kVgqe<xeI/!!
!
72 ! fs<sqeiIg<gqeqbI! Ohvisqiqbiqe<! djvjb! yk<K! wPkq?! OlZl<?!
“sqzh<hkqgivLl<!nke<hix<hMl<”!we<gqxiI/!!
! fim<cz<! upr<Gl<! hjpb! gjkgjtBl<! uvziXgjtBl<! ohiVtigg<!
ogi{<M! himh<ohXl<! okimIfqjzs<! osb<Bt<gt<! okie<jl! we<El<! ueh<H!
njlf<k! -zg<gqbr<gt<! NGl</! djvobiM! H{Ikz<! we<hK! ofMr<gizligh<!
hzviZl<!osiz<zh<hm<M!upr<gq!uVukiGl</!!
!
! ‘okie<jl’!we<El<!osiz<!okiz<gih<hqbI!gizk<kqz<!-kqgisl<?!Hvi{l<?!
gih<hqbl<! Lkzieux<jxg<! Gxqk<kiZl<?! -h<ohiPK! ‘hjpjl’! we<El<!
ohiVjt! lm<Ml<! d{Ik<Kgqe<xK/! Nbqvl<! N{<MgTg<G! Olx<hm<m!
njek<jkBl<! hjpjl! we<El<! okie<jlg<Gt<! nmg<gquqmzil</! Neiz<!
okie<lk<kqe<!okie<l!wz<jzjbg<!gq/L/211?111!Lkz<!gq/L/51?111!ujv!we<X!
nxqRIgt<!Gxqh<hqMgqe<xeI/!!
!
! okie<l! fqgp<Ugt<! keq! yVuiqe<! dt<tk<kqzqVf<K! wPf<kju! nz<z/!
lg<gtqe<! %m<M! w{<{k<kqzqVf<K! hqxf<kjuA! hqxf<k! wz<zik<! okie<lr<gTl<!
fqjzohxuqz<jz?! sqxf<kju! lm<MOl! -e<Xl<! fqjzohx<X! Ohsh<hMgqe<xe/!
okie<ll<! dtuqbOziM! okimIHjmbK/! okie<ll<! -zg<gqbk<OkiM!
okimIHjmbK/! okie<ll<! YI! -zg<gqb! ujgbigUl<! uqtr<GgqxK/!
niq <̂mim<cz<!okie<lk<jk!-zg<gqbk<kqe<!Ne<li!we<X!Gxqh<hqMgqe<xiI/!!
!
! -e<jxb! gizk<kqz<! -kqgisl<?! Hvi{l<?! hjpb! gih<hqbl<?! hjpb!
F~z<gt<?! lkg<Ogim<hiMgt<! Lkzieux<jxh<! hjpjlbieK! okie<jlbieK!
we<El<!ohiVtqz<! ‘okie<ll<’! (Myth) we<El<!osiz<zim<sq!jgbith<hMgqe<xK/!
0hqjv! we<hiI! wz<zi!-zg<gqb!ujggTl<! okie<lk<kqzqVf<Ok! Okix<xLx<xe!
we<gqxiI/! weOu! HKg<guqjkbqe<! Okix<xk<kqZl<! okie<lk<kqe<! hr<G! d{<M/!
HKg<guqjkbqz<!guqRI!kil<!%x!uf<k!gVk<kqje!.!-e<jxb!hqvs<sjejbh<!
hjpb! fqgp<s<sqgTme<! yh<hqm<Mg<! %Xgqe<xiI/! nf<kg<! gim<sqgOt! okie<ll<!
we<El<!dk<kqbiGl</!!
! -vilib{l<?!hivkl<?!hkqoem<Mh<!Hvi{r<gt<?!fie<G!Oukr<gt<?!hguk<!
gQjk?! uquqzqbl<?! kqVg<GINe<?! sr<g! -zg<gqbl<?! -vm<jmg<! gih<hqbl<?!
gjmobP!ut<tz<gt<!weh<!hzuixie!hjpjlgTl<!HKg<guqjkbqe<!gVk<K!
outqh<him<Mg<Gh<! hbe<hMgqe<xe/! guqRIgt<! %x! uf<k! gVk<kqx<G! Wx<h?!
73 okie<lg<! gVk<kqje!nh<hcOb!hbe<hMk<kqBl<! lix<xqg<!%xqBl<! HKh<ohiVjt!
uqjtuqk<Kl<! OuXhMk<kqBl<! kl<! guqjkgtqz<! jgbiTgqe<xeI/! okie<ll<!
HKg<guqjkgtqz<! GxqbQm<Mg<Gl<! Lv[g<Gl<! nr<gkk<kqx<Gl<! hbe<hMk<kh<!
ohx<Xt<tK/! HKg<guqjkgtqz<! okie<ll<! keqk<Kl<! osbz<hMgqe<xK/! weOu?!
HKg<guqjk!dk<kqgtqz<!okie<lLl<!-ml<ohXgqe<xK/:!!
!
! “w <̂/ws</a`g<! we<hiI! okie<lr<gjts<! smr<Gk<! okie<lr<gt<! (Ritual
Myths), &zk<! okie<lr<gt<! (Origin Myths), lvHk<! okie<lr<gt<! (Cult Myths),
ohVlqkk<! okie<lr<gt<! (Prestige Myths), npqUk<!okie<lr<gt<! (Eschatological
Myths) we<X! Jf<K! ujgbigh<! hqiqh<hI/! ohVl<hiZl<! okie<lr<gt<! leqke<?!
uqzr<G?!kiuvl<!Ngqbux<xqe<! Okix<xl<! hx<xqBl<! leqke<! wu<uiX!-h<ohiPK!
dt<t! fqjzg<G! -xh<H?! hiz<! d{IU?! hzujgbie! s&gg<! gm<Mh<hiMgt<!
Ngqbux<xqx<G!Nm<hm<meuig!uf<K!OsIf<kie<!we<he!hx<xqBl<!uqtg<Ggqe<xe!
)hi/lVkfibgl<?! “okie<lk<! kqxeib<U! yV! uqtg<gl<”?! okie<lk<! kqxeib<U!
)g/hR<sir<gl<*?!h/7*/!!!
!
! okie<lk<kqe<! sqxh<hqjes<! sq/gegshihkq?! “hpl<Hvi{l<! osk<K! lcf<k!
dVulz<zA!ouXr<%mie!lqs<slz<z/!hpr<gjkgt<!dzgk<jkg<!gi{h<!h,IuQg!
leqke<!Lkzqz<!ogi{<m!NIur<gt<?!leqkeqe<!lqgh<!hjpb!outqbQm<M!Ljx!
-K/! -l<Ljx! hjpb! leqkeK! Ne<l! Oum<jgg<G! df<Kkz<! ogiMk<kK/!
kjzLjx!kjzLjxbigs<!s&g!yx<Xjlbqe<!dxUg<!gm<jm!Wx<hMk<kqbK”21!
we<X!uqtg<Ggqe<xiI/!!
!
! f/hqs<s&Ik<kqbqe<! ‘dbqIlgt<’22! we<El<! guqjk?! Hvi{r<gtqz<! uVl<!
ngzqjgbqe<! uvzix<jx! uqtg<gqg<! %XukiGl</! 5:8! uiqgt<! ogi{<m!
-g<guqjk! yV! GXr<giuqbl<! Ohiz<! gim<sqbtqg<gqe<xK/! OlZl<!
f/hqs<s&Ik<kqbqe<! ‘upqk<Kj{’! we<El<! guqjk! okie<lk<jk! nch<hjmbigg<!
ogi{<mK/!-K!Gxqk<K!f/hqs<s&Ik<kq!%Xl<OhiK?!“we<Oxi!flK!Hvi{r<gtqz<!
hck<k!yV!gjk!-kx<G!Nkivl<?!gjkbqe<!gVju!lm<Ml<!wMk<Kg<ogi{<Ome</!
gVUg<Gl<!dVUg<Gl<!-jmh<hm<m!sh<k!kiKg<gt<!we<Ejmbju”23!we<gqe<xiI/!
-h<hck<! okie<lk<jkg<! guqRI! kl<! hiIjubqz<! guqjk! LPjljbBl<!
74 uqtg<GuKl<! HKg<guqjkbqz<! d{<M/! guqjkbqe<! yV! hGkqbqz<! yV!
gVk<kqje!uqtg<Gukx<Gl<!okie<lk<jkh<!hbe<hMk<KuKl<!d{<M/!!
!
! fim<M!fmh<H?!nvsqbz<?!-el<?!olipq?!s&gs<!sqg<gz<?!gikz<?!ogit<jg?!
Ogzq?! hpqk<kz<! weh<! hz! gVk<kqjeBl<! HKg<guqjk! &zl<! uqtg<Gukx<Gk<!
okie<ll<! dk<kq! hbe<hMk<kh<hMgqe<xK/! okie<l! fqgp<Ugt<! hclligUl<!
GxqbQmigUl<! nr<gkligUl<! gim<mh<hMgqe<xe/! iqs<sIm<! Os <̂! (Richard Chase)
we<hiI!okie<lOl!guqjk!we<X!ohVjlbigh<!OhSgqe<xiI/!!
!
! ke<! sikqbqz<! l{lge<! gqjmg<gik!yV!oh{<?! sikqg<! gm<Mh<him<ceiz<!
OuX! sikqg<Gt<Tl<! Hg! Lcbilz<! LkqIge<eqbigquqm<mit</! nut<! ke<!
Oukjeg<!Gvjz?!!
\ikqs<!sqZjubqz<!we<!
kr<g!Okgk<jk!
njxf<K!OhieK!biI@24!
we<El<! uqeiuqe<! &zl<! outqh<hMk<Kgqe<xit</! -r<Gs<! “sqZju”! we<hK!
uquqzqbk<kqz<! uvg<! %cbKA! -ObSfikjvs<! sqZjubqz<! juk<K! N{qbiz<!
nck<K?! hz! Ke<hr<gTg<Gh<! hqxG! nuiqe<! dbqiqjeh<! hqiqk<kK/! sqZju!
we<hK! Ke<hk<kqx<Gg<! GxqbQM/! -0K! =vibqvl<! N{<MgTg<Gl<! Le<H!
fqgp<f<kkiz<! okie<ll<! NgqxK/! “\ikq”! Ke<hk<jkk<! kVgqxK! we<hkx<Gs<!
“sqZju”! we<El<! okie<lk<Kme<! -j{k<K! “\ikqs<! sqZju”! we<X!
Gxqh<hqmh<hm<cVh<hK!okie<lg<!GxqbQM!NGl</!!
!
! -e<jxb! nvsim<sqbqz<! oh{<gTg<G! -myKg<gQM! dt<tK/! Neiz<!
‘hqxuih<!ohiqObie<’!we<Xl<! ‘NkqBl<!nf<kLl<!-z<zikue<’!we<Xl<!Ohsh<hMl<!
squohVlie<! ke<! ljeuqbigqb! oh{<[g<G! Jl<hK! uqPg<giM! -myKg<gQM!
kf<Kt<tiI/! -f<kh<! Hvi{! fqgp<U! we<X! fmf<kK! we<hkje! nxqbLcbik!
ntUg<Gk<!okie<jlbieK/!-f<kk<!okie<lk<jk!yh<hqm<Mg<!gim<c?!!
nvS!
Lh<hk<K!&e<X!skuqgqkl<!
squohVlie<!
Jl<hK!skuqgqkl<!
75
fie<!deg<G!yKg<gqbOki!
F~X!skuqgqkl<25!
we<X!gikze<!gikzqbqml<!OhSgqe<xie</!!
!
! -vilib{k<kqz<! uVl<! -vile<! Wghk<kqeq! Ofie<H!djmbue</! ‘-f<kh<!
hqxuqbqz<! -v{<M! oh{<gjt! lek<kqeiZl<! okimlim<Ome<’! we<El<!
ogit<jgBjmbue</! -vileqe<! ljeuq! sQjkjb! uqVl<hqk<! K~g<gqs<! ose<X!
-zr<jg! nOsiguek<Kt<! -viu{e<! sqjx! juk<kie</! sQjkbqe<! nElkq!
gqjmg<gikkiz<! -viu{eqe<! w{<{l<! Njs! fqjxOuxuqz<jz/! -vile<!
sQjkjb!lQm<gg<!gmzqz<!hizl<!nj{!gm<ceiI!we<hjuobz<zil<!Jf<kibqvl<!
N{<MgTg<Gl<! Le<H! fqgp<f<k! -kqgiss<! osb<kqgt<?! ne<jxb! -viljeh<!
OhizOui!sQjkjbh<!OhizOui!dXkqbie!lek<Kme<!-e<jxg<Gg<!g{uOei!
ljeuqObi! -z<jz! we<hjkg<! g/fi/S/! nr<gkk<Kme<! %Xgqe<xiI/! Neiz<!
-viu{e<! lm<Ml<! lixilz<! -e<X! hzI! -Vg<gqe<xeI/! -f<k! nr<gkk<kqx<Gk<!
okie<l!fqgp<uqjes<!Sm<cg<gim<cg<!guqjk!hjmk<Kt<tiI/!guqjkbqe<!kjzh<H!
‘-e<oeiV!viu{e<’!NGl</!nf<kg<!guqjk?!
-e<oeiV!viu{e<!Okie<x!Ou{<Ml<!
-e<Xt<t!viu{Igt<!.!viu{IgTg<G!
we<XOl!hR<slqz<jz!–!sqeqli!uqz<ze<gtig!
zr<jgg<Gh<!OhiGl<!upqbqOzOb!giiqbk<jk!
Lck<Kg<ogi{<M!uqMgqxiIgt</!“JbOgi!
we<!oh{<jljbg<!Gjzk<K!uqm<miIgOt”!we<X!!
gkXl<!sQjkgjth<!hiIk<K!nEkihh<!!
hMhuIgt<!Ohiz!-e<jxb!viu{Igt<!!
%m<mk<OkiM!Ogiuqf<ki!Ohim<M!uqtl<hvl<!
OkMgqxiIgt</!vileqe<!nj{jbg<!gm<m!
Le<Oex<xl<!we<gqx!ohbviz<!nuIgOt!
dkUgqxiIgt</!vileqe<!uvju!!
wkqIOfig<gqg<!gik<kqVg<Gl<!sQjkgTl<!!
-e<X!-z<jz/!nue<!-z<ziuqm<miz<!
-ue<!.!-VuVl<!nvsIgOt!we<X!
kqVh<kqBx<X!uqMgqxiIgt</!
vile<!vileigUl<!viu{e<!viu{eigUl<!
76
sQjk!sQjkbigUl<!-Vg<g!yV!
zr<jgk<!okl<H!Ou{<Ml<!-e<X!
zr<jgOb!zr<jgbig!-z<jzOb"!
wh<hc!vilEl<!sQjkBl<!viu{El<!
Okie<XuiIgt<@!Okie<xqeiZl<!
okiqf<K!osiz<Zl<!uiz<lQgqgt<!wr<Og@26!
! =OviM!klqpe<he<! “=k<K!dug<Gl<!-e<hl<”!we<El<!kjzh<hqz<!guqjk!
hjmk<Kt<tiI/! nkqz<! gjmobP! ut<tz<gtqe<! ogijmk<! ke<jljbh<!
HKg<guqjk! ucuqz<! kf<K?! =m<cb! ohiVjt! wMk<Kg<! ogiMh<hOk! uip<g<jg!
we<X! uqtg<gltqg<gqe<xiI/! Lz<jzg<Gk<! Okiqje! upr<gqb! hiiq?! lbqZg<Gh<!
OhiIju! upr<gqb! Ohge<?! ytjubiVg<G! ofz<zqg<geq! upr<gqb! nkqblie<!
-uIgtqe<! osbz<gjt! =OviM! klqpe<he<! =k<Kug<Gl<! -e<hk<kqx<Gs<!
sie<Xgtib<g<!%Xgqe<xiI/!
Okiqz<!ne<X!
hb{l<!OhieOhiK!njmf<kjkuqm!
nkqg!-e<hk<jk?!
njk!Lz<jzg<!ogicg<G!fqXk<kquqm<M!
fmf<kOhiK!ohx<xie<!hiiq"!
!
ne<X!fqe<Xuqm<m!OkI!
giz!gizlib<g<!guqjkg<Gt<Tl<!
flg<Gt<Tl<!
Ycg<!ogi{<cVg<gqxK"!
!
sr<gh<him<ce<!liiqg<giz!fit<gTg<Gt<!
fie<!fMr<Gl<!Ohiokz<zil<!
OhiIjuObiM!Ohge<!
uVgqxie<!we<Le</!
!
=v!-jpgtiz<!ofb<bh<hm<cVf<Kl<!
nf<kh<!OhiIju!-f<k!fit<ujv!
-x<Xh<!Ohiguqz<jz"!
NMl<!lbqz<gt<!nk<kjeBl<!
77
nkx<G!dk<kvuikl</!
!
lv{uqzg<G!lik<kqjv!
nVofz<zq!we!
nxqf<kqVf<Kl<!
klqp<!ytjug<G!nkjek<!kf<kie<!
kie<!d{<{ilz<!nkqbe</!
!
ytjuBl<!uip<gqxit<!
nkqbEl<!uip<gqxie<!!
-jmbqz<!-Vf<K!nf<k!=jgBl<!
-e<El<!uip<gqxK/!
!
dt<uir<gqb!&s<js!
dmOe!outquqMuK!Ohiz<!
=m<cb!ohiVjt!
wMk<Kg<!ogiMh<hOk!uip<g<jg/27!
! leqke<! leqkje! lkqg<g! Ou{<Ml</! Neiz<! leqkje! lqkqg<gqxie<A!
lkk<jk!utIg<gqxie</!lkl<!leqkk<jk!utIg<gs<!osiz<gqxKA!yVuIg<G!yVuI!
dkuq! osb<K! uips<! osiz<gqxK/! hz! lkk<kqeVl<! uiPl<! fim<cz<! kk<kl<!
lkg<ogit<jgjb! uQm<cz<! juk<Kg<! ogi{<mim! Ou{<Ml<A! uQm<Mg<G! outqOb!
lg<gtqmk<kqz<! leqkk<jkg<! ogi{<mim! Ou{<Ml</! -kx<gigk<kie<! sie<OxiIgt<!
nVl<h{qbix<Xgqe<xiIgt</!
!
! ne<H?! hisl<?! sOgikvk<Kul<?! slk<Kul<?! dkuq! leh<hie<jl?!
uqm<Mg<ogiMg<Gl<! leh<hie<jl?! ohiXk<kVTl<! leh<hie<jl?! leqkIgjt!
lkqk<kz<?! oki{<M! leh<hie<jl?! -be<xtU! nxl<! osb<kz<?! nxl<! osb<b!
-bzik!fqjzbqZl<!hqxVg<Gk<!kQjl!osb<bijl?!lek<Kg<g{<!lisqze<!Nkz<!
Lkzieju! leqkVg<G! -e<xqbjlbikjubiGl</! -ju! -Vf<kiz<! leqkl<!
utVl</! Neiz<! -ux<jxh<! hx<xqs<! sqxqktUl<! sqf<kqg<gilz<! Djv! nck<K!
djzbqz<!OhiMl<!leqkIgtqe<!w{<{qg<jg!ohVgqg<ogi{<M!uVgqxK/!-f<kh<!
Ohig<gqjeh<! HKg<guqjkgtqz<! okie<lr<gtqe<! uibqzigg<! guqRIgt<!
78 g{<cg<gqe<xeI/! “leqkjek<! Okm!liIg<gl<! we<e@”!we<El<!kjzh<hqz<! =OviM!
klqpe<heqe<!guqjkbqz<!sqz!hGkqgjt!-r<Gs<!Sm<cg<!gim<mzil</!!
-jxujek<!Okm!
lkr<gt<!liIg<gr<gt<!we<xiz<!
leqkjek<!Okm!
we<e!liIg<gl<@!
////////////////////////////!
!
-vile<!
-viu{IgOtiM!%m<Ms<!OsIf<K!
ogi{<mie<!
svb,!out<tk<kqz<!
kVlk<kqe<!hq{r<gt</!
////////////////////////////!
!
leqkOl!
leqkEg<G!-bx<jgbieK////!
lkl<!osbx<jg/////!
uQm<Mg<Gt<Ot!lkl<"!
outqOb!leqkl<!
leqkl<!lm<MOl"!
!
Ohikqbigk<kqz<!.!leqkEg<gigh<!
Hk<ke<!
nvs!Ohigr<gjtOb!
NGkq!big<gqeie</!
!
Slf<k!sqZjubqzqVf<K!
WS!
leqkEg<gigk<!keK!
gibr<gjtOb!
geqgtig<gq!dkqIk<kiI/!
!
79
Lgl<lK!–!ke<jek<!
kig<gqb!gx<gTl<!leqkk<Kg<gigh<!
h,g<gjtg<!
gIh<hf<kiqg<gs<!osb<kiI/!
!
ne<X!njzf<k!-viliFsI!
leqkEg<gigk<!
keK!hikr<gjtOb!dVg<gqh<!
hijk!Ohim<miI"!
!
-e<X!Ohikq!lzIgtqz<!sQp<!
gz<uiiqgtqz<!
g{<{QI!nVuq"!
/////////////////////////!
!
-er<gjt?!uGh<Hgjt?!
sikqgjt!
=e<oxMk<kju!slbr<goteqz<?!
nux<xqe<!
gIh<hh<!jhgjtg<!gk<kiqk<okxqOuil<"28!
we<X!guqRI!ohVr<Ogihk<Kme<! OhSgqe<xiI/!-e<jxb!fqjzjl!-h<hck<kie<!
lixq! uVgqe<xK/! -u<uixie! Ohig<G! leqk! s&gk<Kg<G! wkqvieK/! leqk!
OfbLl<!lk!fz<zq{g<gLl<!lg<gt<!njeuiqmk<Kl<!-Vg<g!Ou{<Ml</!gmf<k!
gizk<! okie<lr<gt<! leqkk<jk! uti<k<ke/! fqgp<giz! ue<lr<gt<! leqkk<jk!
npqg<gqe<xe/!!
!
! sikq?! lk! Ohkr<gtiz<! gikz<! gVgquqMgqe<xK/! gikzqe<! sqxh<hqjeg<!
%Xukx<Gl<!guqRIgt<!okie<l!dk<kqjbg<!jgbiTgqe<xeI/!!
kqeLl<!
sf<kqg<gqx!
-k<kje!Lgr<gtqz<!
weg<gie!Lgl<!
wK!
80
we<X!
fQ!
hqxf<kkqzqVf<Ok!
fie<!
de<jek<!Okcg<!ogi{<cVg<gqOxe</!
!
niqs<sf<kqvjeh<!Ohiz<!
weg<G!lm<MOl!
de<je!
njmbitl<!okiqBl</!
!
klbf<kqjbh<!Ohiz<!
we<je!lm<MOl!
Oki<f<okMg<g!
deg<Gl<!okiqBl<////29!
! niqs<sf<kqve<! sf<kqvlkq! uvziXl<?! fte<! klbf<kq! uvziXl<! -kqgisg<!
gizk<kqx<Gl<! Lx<hm<mju/! sf<kqvlkq! gPk<kqz<! n{qf<kqVg<Gl<! kizq!
nuTjmb! g{ue<! niqs<sf<kqvEg<G! lm<MOl! okiqBl<A! OuX! biVg<Gl<!
okiqbiK/! niqs<sf<kqvjeh<! Ohiz! -r<Gg<! gikz<! kjzue</! hz!
oh{<gtqmlqVf<K!kjzuqjb!OuXhMk<kq!njmbitl<!gi{<hue</!!
!
! fiM?! fgvl<?! dme<hqxh<H?! ljeuq?! kie<! we! njek<jkBl<!
$kim<mk<kqz<! Okix<Xh<Ohib<s<! OsiIf<k! fqjzbqz<! -Vf<k! kVlEg<Og! NXkz<!
kVl<! uvzix<Xg<! gjkbig! fte<.klbf<kq! uip<g<jg! njlf<kqVf<kK/!
klbf<kqbqe<! Sbl<uvl<! fqgp<f<kOhiK?! ftjeh<! OhizOu! -f<kqve<! Lkzie!
OkuIgt<!hzVl<!dVul<!lixq!Sbl<uv!l{<mhk<kqz<!fqe<xeI/!d{<jl!fte<?!
Ohizq! fte<! we<hjkg<! g{<mxqb! OkipqliIgtiz<! -bzuqz<jz/! klbf<kq!
lm<MOl! d{<jlbie! ke<! gikze<! ftjeg<! g{<mxqf<kit</! klbf<kqjbh<!
Ohizk<! kjzuqg<Gk<! kjzuje! njmbitl<! gi{k<! okiqBl</! -h<hc!
-Vh<hKkie<! d{<jlg<! gikz</! -kjek<! okie<lg<! gim<sqgt<! &zl<! vi\!
LVGhi{<cbe<!oktqUhMk<kqBt<tiI/!!
!
81 ! -e<jxg<G! -bx<jg! lisjmf<K! uVgqe<xK/! -bx<jgg<G! nch<hjm!
l{<[l<!lvr<gTl<?!l{<[zgqz<!uiPl<!njek<K!dbqiqer<gTg<Gl<!gix<X!
Okju/!dbqIuipk<!Okjubie!dbqIutqjb!)Ng<sq\je*!dx<hk<kq!osb<Bl<!
okipqx<%ml<!lvr<gt<!NGl</!dbqiqer<gt<!ye<xqje!ye<X!siIf<K!uip<gqe<xe/!
hz<Zbqiqeh<! ohVg<gk<kqx<G! nch<hjmbib<! -Vh<hK! kiuvl</! lvl<?! osc?!
ogicgt<!Lkz<! leqkIgt<! ujv!dbqiqer<gtqe<! uip<uqx<G!Lkz<!nch<hjm!
dbqiqelib<k<!kqgp<ue!kiuvr<gt<!NGl</!d{U?!djm?!djxuqml<?!nxqU!
we!nk<kjeg<Gl<!OhVkuqbib<k<!kiuvr<gt<!kqgp<gqe<xe/!lvk<kqe<!sqxh<hqje!
vi\!LVGhi{<cbe<?!
lvk<kqx<Gg<!
gQOpkie<!
leqke<!
leqkeigqxie</!
!
Ohikqlvl<!
Hk<kjek<!kf<kK/////!
!
sqZju!lvl<!
-ObSjuk<!kf<kK/!
!
K~g<Glvl<!
hgk<sqr<jgk<!kf<kK/!
!
de<uQm<M!Ouh<h!lvOli!
yV!
guqRjeOb!kf<kqVg<gqxK/!
!
uQm<Mg<G!uQM!
lvl<!utIh<Ohil<2:!
we<X! hiMgqe<xiI/! Hk<kI?!-ObS! we<El<! okie<lr<gt<!&zl<!-r<G!lvk<kqe<!
ohVjl!Ohsh<hMgqe<xK/!!
!
82 ! 2:81gtqz<! yVfit<! lKjvbqz<! -zuss<! Osjzgt<! upr<gh<hm<me/!
Osjzjbh<! ohXukx<Gh<! ohiKlg<gt<! %m<mlib<! -ck<Kg<! ogi{<M!
ose<xOhiK?!%m<m!ofiqszqz<!hzI!dbqIuqm<meI/!-f<fqgp<uqje!lgihivkk<kqz<!
uVl<!hiR<sizqBme<!okimIHhMk<kq!L/Olk<ki!guqjk!hjmk<Kt<tiI/!!
lKjvbqz<!yVfit<!
Hz<zir<!Gpz<gt<!
Hzl<hqbK!okiqBli@!
%m<mr<!%m<mlib<h<!
hiR<sizqgt<!
-zuss<!Osjzg<G!
-chm<m!OhiK!–!
ofiqszqz<!sqg<gq!
fqjeuqpf<!kiIgtil<!
dbqIs<!sqk<kqvr<gt<!
dbqI!uqm<miIgtil<"31!
we<X! fim<M! fmh<hqjeg<! %Xukx<Gk<! okie<l! dk<kq&zl<! hiR<sizqjbg<!
Gxqh<hqMgqe<xiI/!
!
! ‘n{<{Zl<! Ofig<gqeie<! nuTl<! Ofig<gqeit<’! we<hK! gl<hvilib{k<!
okimI/! -r<G! -viljeBl<! sQjkjbBl<! Gxqg<Gl</! Le<OeiI! olipqjbh<!
ohie<OeOhiz<! Ohix<xqb! L/Olk<ki?! gikz<! Okiz<uqgtqe<! giv{l<! we<e@!
we<El<!uqeiuqx<G!uqjmbig?!
n{<{Zl<!Ofig<gqeie<!
nuTl<!Ofig<gqeit<!
-v{<M!OhjvBl<!
nck<K!ofiXg<Gukx<G!
nh<he<!givEl<!
Ofig<gqeie<32!
we<X! guqjk! uck<Kt<tiI/! ja%! guqjkgtqZl<! okie<l! dk<kq!
hqe<hx<xh<hMgqe<xK/! yV!ja%! guqjkg<Gh<! hz! ohiVt<! Hzh<hMl</! nkje!
uisqg<g!uisqg<gh<!HKh<HKh<!ohiVt<!outqh<hMl</!!
83
g{<{e<!Gpz<!olzqkib<!
OgihqbI!dxg<gl<!Nplib<!
Ogihk<kqz<!kujtgt<33!
!
GVuq!njpk<Kl<!szelx<X!
uqpqkqxuih<!Hk<kI!
nxl<Okc!nZh<H/34!
!
kivjg!Le<olipqb!
hqe<!uijmg<!gix<X!
usf<kl<!uqjkg<Gl<!Hk<kI/35!
! “Hk<klel<”36! we<El<! kjzh<hqz<! 47! uiqgjtg<! ogi{<m! guqjkjbk<!
kqbi'! hjmk<Kt<tiI/! -kqz<! leqk! lek<kqe<! -bz<hqjeg<! %xq?! nke<hqxG!
lel<! hg<Gul<! njmf<k! hqxG! Hk<k! lelig! liXgqxK! we<El<! gVk<K!
d{Ik<kh<hMgqxK/!lvr<gt<!Gjxf<K!uVkz<?!ljpbqe<jl!Lkzie!-bx<jg!
siIf<k! hqvs<sjegjtBl<! kQ{<mijl! hqvs<sjegjtBl<! Hk<kI! Riel<! ohx<x!
Ohikq! lvk<jkBl<! sqjxbqz<! gizf<kip<k<kqk<! kf<k! k{<{Qjv! nVf<kilz<!
liek<Kme<! dbqIuqm<m! Osve<! gj{g<giz<! -Vl<ohijxjbBl<! nxqUlkq!
“gjmsq!ljpk<Ktq”!we<El<!guqjk!F~zqz<!hkqU!osb<K?!nux<xqe<!uibqzig!
uxm<sq?!kQ{<mijl?!liel<!Lkzie!ohiV{<jlgjt!uqtg<Ggqe<xiI/!!
!
! fi/Lk<Kfqzue<! “o\bOa"! o\bo\bOa""”! we<El<! kjzh<hqz<!
njlf<Kt<t! guqjkbqz<! okie<l! fqgp<Ugjt! -g<gizk<Kme<! yh<hqm<M!
nr<gkk<!okieqbqz<!gim<Mgqe<xiI/!!
wkqiqgjt!u{r<gq!
gqV]<{jeg<!GxqhiIg<Gl<!
nIs<SeIgt</!
!
Ks<sikee<!hkx!
hiR<sizqjb!diqg<Gl<!
hi{<muIgt</!
!
84
Ogiuzje!wkqIk<K!
hi{<cbeqml<!fQkq!Ogm<Gl<!
g{<{gqbI/!
!
kqbigqgt<!hkx!
KOvigqgt<!osZk<Kl<!
nvsqbz</!
!
kf<jkg<Gs<!sivibl<!kf<K!
hqt<jtg<Gs<!sk<K{U!OhiMl<!
kqm<mr<gt</////37!
! dm<hjg!%m!-Vf<Ok!Gpqhxqk<kz<?!dt<otie<X!juk<Kh<! Hxolie<X!
OhSkz<?! fe<jl! osb<uKOhiz<! fck<K! kQjl! osb<kz<?! sqxqb! lQjeh<! Ohim<M!
ohiqb! lQjeh<! hqck<kz<! Lkzie! fbuR<sjegTl<! $p<s<sqgTl<! -e<jxb!
gizk<kqz<! lg<gtqml<! lqGkqbib<g<! gi{h<hMgqe<xe/! -ux<jxs<! siMukx<gig!
fi/Lk<Kfqzue<! okie<l! fqgp<Ugjt! Lv{<! njlh<hqz<! kf<K! guqjk!
hjmk<Kt<tiI/! 2:91gtqz<! hz! ht<tqg<! %mr<gtqz<! uGh<hjx! hx<xig<Gjx/!
nkeiz<! sqz!uGh<H! li{uIgt<! lvk<kcbqz<!nlIf<K?!NsqiqbIgtqml<! himl<!
hck<keI/!-kje?!
Ohikq!lvk<kcbqz<!
Hk<kVg<G!Riel<"!
Htqb!lvk<kcbqz<!
li{uIg<Gh<!himl<"!
!
-KOu–!
wr<gt<!gqvilk<K!
RiehQml<"38!!
we<X! fi/Lk<Kfquze<! ne<jxb! Hk<kVg<Gl<! -e<jxb! li{uIg<Gl<! nxqU!
gqjmk<k! -ml<! lvl<! we<hjkg<! %XuKme<?! ht<tqgtqz<! uGh<hjxgt<!
hx<xig<GjxjbBl<! hkqU! osb<gqe<xiI/! -uI?! “>vile<! uq{<{h<hl<”! we<El<!
kjzh<hqzjlf<k!guqjkbqz<!>-vilOv!gl<hiqml<!OhSuKOhiz<!wPkqBt<tiI/!!
!
85 ! Ogijm! uqMLjxg<Gh<! hqxG! ht<tqgt<! $e<! Lkz<! uivk<kqz<!
kqxg<gh<hMgqe<xe/! ht<tqs<sQVjm?! Hk<kgl<?! ht<tqg<gm<m{l<! Lkzie! h{s<!
oszUgTg<Gh<! ohx<OxiIgt<! Ke<HXgqe<xeI/! li{uIgt<! Hk<kgs<! Sjl!
&m<jmjbk<! kir<gqk<! Ke<HXgqe<xeI/! Ke<hk<kqx<Gk<! okie<lg<! GxqbQmigs<!
sqZju! hz! -mr<gtqz<! hbe<hMk<kh<! ohXgqe<xK/! “\`eikqg<gl<”! we<El<!
kjzh<hqz<!guqjk!hjmk<k!ofz<jz!o\bf<ki?!!
ht<tqgt<!
dbqIk<okPl<!
ohx<OxiIgt<!
njxbh<hMuiIgt<"!!
hqt<jtgt<!
sqZju!Slh<hiIgt<39!
we<gqxiI/! Lbe<xiz<! LcbikK! -z<jz/! Ke<hk<jkg<! g{<M! Kutilz<!
-Vf<kiz<?! Ke<hl<! Ku{<MuqMl</! nkx<Gk<! ke<el<hqg<jg! Ou{<Ml</!
Ke<hk<jkBl<!-e<hlig!lix<xzil</! ‘sqZju’!we<El<!okie<lg<!GxqbQM!Ke<hl<!
we<El<! ohiVtqOzOb! jgbith<hMgqe<xK/! -f<kg<! gVk<kqje! N'I!
klqp<fime<?!
liEmk<kqx<G!lzIgtqe<!olipqbqz<!
=vg<!guqjkgt<!wPkqh<!himzil<@!
ke<el<!hqg<jgk<!k{z<flg<!gqVf<kiz<!
sqZjugt<!%ms<!sqxGg!tiGl<3:!
we<X!hiMgqe<xiI/!OlZl<!-uI?!gtUg<gizg<!gikzqbqml<!ogiR<sqh<!OhSgqe<x!
ohiPK%m?! hguk<gQjk?! uquqzqbl<?! kqVg<GIvie<! we<El<! okie<lr<gjtg<!
jgbiTgqe<xiI/!!
ge<eqfqzi!de<epjgg<!
jgkig<gq!fioeeK!
sqe<euqpqg<!Gt<Ot!
sqjx!juk<Oke<"!
!sqe<euOt"!
we<sqjxbqz<!fQBl<!
-Vh<hkiz<?!fiEe<!
ohie<sqjxbqz<!uip<Oue<!HGf<K"!
!
86
we<jhhqt<!de<xe<!
-tl<!hiIju"!OhvLOk!
we<!gQjk!de<xe<!
-js!uiIk<jk"!
.!de<xe<!
kqVuqpqkie<!we<xe<!
kqVg<GIvie<"!gikz<!
gVr<GbqOz!fQbqe<hg<!giM"41!!
-f<kk<! okie<lg<! gim<sq! djvbimzqz<! lkfz<zq{g<gl<! -Vh<hK! guqjkg<Gl<!
gVk<Kg<Gl<!sqxh<hqjek<!kVgqe<xK/!!
!
! -f<kqbk<!kqVfim<cz<!hz!lkr<gt<!-Vg<gqe<xe/!-f<kqbi!lks<!siIhx<x!
fiM/!weOu!lg<gt<!njeuVl<!uQm<cz<!kk<kl<!lkg<ogit<jgjbBl<!outqbqz<!
lkfz<zq{g<gk<jkBl<! hqe<hx<xq!uVgqe<xeI/!-f<kqbiuqz<!lkg<gzuvk<jkuqms<!
sikqg<! gzuvOl! OlOzir<gq! fqx<gqxK/! nkqZl<! Gxqh<hqm<m! sikqbqejvk<!
okimg<%miK!we<El<!kQ{<mijl!-Vf<kK/!-f<kk<!kQ{<mijl!yV!hius<osbz<A!
yV!leqkg<!Gx<xs<!osbz<!we<X!nvsir<gl<!sm<ml<!-bx<xqs<!sikqbqz<!dbIU!
kip<U!%miK!we<X!fjmLjxh<hMk<kqBt<tK/!weqEl<!wr<Ogi!yV!&jzbqz<!
sikqh<!hqvs<sjegt<!uf<Kogi{<Mkil<!-Vg<gqe<xe/!!
!
! lgik<li! gif<kqbcgt<?! n{<{z<! nl<Ohk<gI?! kf<jk! ohiqbiI!
LkziOeiI! sikqjb! ypqh<hkx<G! nVl<hiMhm<meI/! weqEl<! sikqh<!
hiGhiMgjtBl<! nux<xiz<! uVl<! dbIU! kip<UgjtBl<! lg<gt<! -e<El<!
LPjlbig! uqmuqz<jz/! sikqg<! gm<sqgTl<! sikqs<! sr<gr<gTl<! -e<El<!
Okie<xqg<! ogi{<Mkil<! -Vg<gqe<xe/! sikqjb! ypqg<g! lgiguq! hivkqbiI/!
Hvm<sqg<! guqRI! hivkqkise<! LkziOeiI! kk<kl<! guqjkgt<! &zl<!
nVl<h{qbix<xq?! lg<gtqml<! uqpqh<H{Iuqje! d{<mig<gqBt<teI/! sikq!
ypqh<Hg<Gh<!HKg<guqRIgTl<!kl<!hr<gtqh<hqjes<!osb<K!uVgqe<xeI/!sQjkgt<!
.! ngzqjggt<! -uIgjts<! Sm<cg<gim<c?! -f<kk<! okie<l! lif<kIgjt!
fqgp<gizk<! kQ{<mijl! ypqh<Hg<G! dkUliX! Kjv/usf<kvise<! njph<H!
uqMg<gqe<xiI/!!
niqses<!sQjkgtqe<!
ng<gqeqh<!hqvOusr<gt<!!
87
ncg<gc!fmf<Kl<%m!!
nf<k!–!!
nhjzs<!sQjkgtqe<!
gtr<gl<!lm<Ml<!We<!!
lQ{<Ml<!lQ{<Ml<!lQ{<Ml<!
nvr<Ogx<xh<!hMgqxK@!
nuIgjt!–!
wm<c!Bjkg<gqe<x!
giz<gtqz<!ye<OxEl<!
vilEjmb!gizig!-Vg<giOki@!
nf<k!–!!
! niqse!ngzqjggTg<Gs<!
sih!uqOlisel<!gqjmh<hkx<G/!
Y//////!
nuEjmb!giz<gt<!%mui!
nuIgjtk<!
kQ{<mg<!%miK@42!
kQ{<mijl!ypqh<Hg<G!-r<G!ngzqjg?!sQjk?!-vile<!Ngqb!okie<l!lif<kIgt<!
dujlbigUl<!dVugligUl<!GxqbQmigUl<!hbe<hMk<kh<hm<Mt<teI/!!
!
! sqzh<hkqgivk<jk! -tr<Ogiucgt<! -bx<xqBt<tiI/! kie<! nvsqbZg<Ogi!
Nm<sqg<Ogi! uvg<%miK! we<hkx<gig! nuI! Kxuxl<! Olx<ogi{<miI/! -0K!
nf<kg<! gizl</! -e<jxb! Kxuqgt<! yV! gmz<! kQju! uqjzg<G! uir<gqk<! kl<!
fimig! nxquqg<g! LbZl<! fqgp<Ugt<! fjmohx<X! uVgqe<xe/! -f<ks<! $pzqz<!
-Vhk<okie<xil<! F~x<xi{<cz<! -tr<Ogiucgt<! uf<kiZl<! -f<k! nvsqbzqz<!
=MhMuii<A! =Mhm<muI! ‘nvsqbz<! hqjpk<OkiIg<G! nxl<! %x<xiuK~dl<’! we<X!
himlim<miI! we<X! -e<jxb! HKg<guqRI! hiMgqe<xiI/! S/-tr<Ogi! -bx<xqb!
nf<kh<!HKg<guqjk!“Osvei@!Osvie<”!we<El<!kjzh<hqz<!njlf<Kt<tK/!!
nvsqbz<!hqjpk<OkiIg<G!
! nxl<!%x<xiuK~dl<!
djvsiz<!hk<kqeqg<G!
! dbIf<OkiI!Wk<kZl<!!
88
Dp<uqje!dXk<K!uf<K!
! Dm<Ml<!
-h<hcbigs<!sqzl<hck<k!
-tr<Ogiju!njph<Ohil<!
! “ui"!
fQ!we<ekie<!Kxf<kiZl<!
wz<ziux<jxBl<!lxf<kiZl<!
nvs!GMl<hk<Kh<!hqxh<H!kiOe!
nkeiz<?!fgIOsikje!osz<”!
liXOumk<kqz<!
lifgv!Osikjeg<Gs<!ose<X!uf<khqe<!
lXhcBl<!hiceie<!-h<hc;!
nvsqbz<!hqjph<OhiIg<G!
! nxl<!%k<kiuK~dl<!
djmsiz<!hm<ceqg<G!
! dZk<OkiI!uqbk<kZl<!
kQ!uqje!uGk<K!
! ohiVt<!=m<mZl</43!
! hpr<gizk<kqz<! Kxuqgt<! njeuVl<! d{<jlk<! Kxuqgtig! uip<f<K!
gim<ceiIgt</! -f<k! -Vhk<okie<xil<! F~x<xi{<cz<! ohVl<hizie! Kxuqgt<!
Ohizqk<! Kxuqgtig! uip<f<K! sLkibk<jkg<! ogMg<gqe<xeI/! Hk<kI! Kxuxl<!
h,{<miIA! Hk<k! lkl<! Okie<xqbK/! -e<X! dzgolz<zil<! Hk<kiqe<! Hgp<!
Ohsh<hMgqe<xK/!!-tr<Ogi!Kxuxl<!h,{<miIA!sqzh<hkqgivl<!hjmg<gh<!ohx<xKA!
klqpqz<! Okie<xqb! Lkz<! gih<hqbligUl<! Lk<klqp<g<! gih<hqbligUl<!
kqgp<gqe<xK/!-Vhk<okie<xil<!F~x<xi{<cz<!Kxuxl<!h,{<muI!sqjx!osz<gqxiIA!
NBt<gizk<! k{<mje!ohXgqe<xiIA!K~g<gqzqmh<hMgqe<xiIA! lg<gtiz<! ouXk<K!
yKg<gh<hMgqe<xiIA! lK?! liK?! Ohijkg<G! ncjlbigqe<xiI/! nh<hch<hm<m!
silqbiIgjtg<! guqnvr<ge<! ke<! “silqgOt! Ohiz<uI! gbuI”! we<El<!
kjzh<hqzie! guqjkbqz<! siMgqe<xiIA! Hk<kI! osiz<zik! Ohikjegjtbi!
-f<kh<! Ohizqs<! silqbiIgt<! %xh<! OhigqxiIgt<! we<El<! uqeijuBl<!
okiMg<gqe<xiI/!
gzis<sivk<jk!fixcg<Gl<!
uqhs<siv!silqbiIgt<!
89
kus<sivl<!h,{<mokz<zil<!
les<Osivl<!ljxg<gk<kie<!
////////////////////////////!
Ohikq!lvk<kie<!
Hgzik!Ohikjebi@!
Np<f<K!Okib<f<k!Np<uiIgt<!
fbf<k!ne<hqe<!fbe<liIgt<!
hg<kqs<Sju!Okib<f<k!
hz<ujgh<!hiSvr<gt<!
H{<{qb!h,lqbqe<!
kq{<{qb!ofxqgt<!
g{<{qbg<!GjxU!We<@!
lvl<!Ogi{zil<!
lel<!Ogi{zili@44!
he<eqV! Np<uiIgTl<! 74! fibe<liIgTl<! hgvik! hg<kq! ofxqjb! -eq! biI!
uqt<th<! OhigqxiI/! uqt<TuK! Ohiz<! osiz<Zl<! silqbiIgt<! OhizqbieuIgt</!
-f<kh<! Ohizqs<! silqbiIgtiz<! klqp<fim<Mg<Gl<! klqpqek<Kg<Gl<! lieg<OgM/!
silqbiIgTg<G!lek<K~b<jl!lqgUl<!OkjubiGl</!
!
! okie<lk<kqz<! Hk<kI! ogit<jg! Hgp<! uib<f<K! gi{h<hMgqe<xK/! Hk<kI!
nxqU! ohx<x! -ml<! Ohikq! lvl</! weOu! Ohikq! )nvs*! lvLl<! Hgp<! ohx<xK/!
Hk<kjvBl<!Ohikq!lvk<jkBl<!dme<him<Mh<!ohiVTg<Gh<!hbe<hMk<kqg<!guqjk!
hjmh<hjkh<! OhizOu?! wkqIljxh<! ohiVTg<Gl<! hbe<hMk<kqg<! guqjk!
hjmg<gqe<xeI/!!!!!!
!
! leqke<! kuxie! upqgtqz<! dmjzg<! ogMk<Kg<! ogi{<M!
lVk<Kuljeg<Gs<! osz<gqe<xie</! dbqVg<Gh<! OhiviMl<OhiK?! -eq! nf<kk<!
kux<xqjes<! osb<bg<! %miK! we! fqjeh<hie</! lVk<Kuljebqz<! dmz<fqjz!
siqbigq!uQm<Mg<G!uf<kUme<!lQ{<Ml<!nf<kk<!kux<xqjes<!osb<uie</!-h<hch<hm<m!
leqkje! N{<mit<! hqiqbki<]qeq! “Hk<kjek<! okijzk<k! Ohikq”! we<El<!
kjzh<hqzie!guqjkbqz<!g{<cg<gqe<xiI/!!
-f<kh<!Ohikqlvk<Kg<G!d{<M!
dbqI!uisje!
90
!ogiPh<H!ogig<giqh<H!
hf<ki!hgm<M!
njx%uz<!NIh<him<ml<!N{ul<!
Kcg<Gl<!vk<kl<!
oucg<Gl<!ogtvul<!
sgzLl<!
lVk<Ku!uisje!Le<!
lGc!figl<!
//////////!
J/sq/B/!osz<jgbqz<!
^Qb,!osiz<jgbqz<!
leS!liqg<Gl<!
lXsf<kqh<H!d{<mi@!we/////!
!
yVLjx!Fjpf<kiz<OhiKl<!
Ofib<k<!kip<uivk<kqz<!
WOpp<!hqxuqg<Gl<!
g{<kqxg<Gl<!Riel<!
!
uQM!kqVl<hquqm<miOzi!
lXhcBl<!
LVr<jg!WXl<!Oukitl</////!
!
lQkqh<!hb{k<kqz<!
Ohikq!uisje!ljxb!
hqk<ke<!Ljth<hie<!
Hk<kjeh<!Hjkk<K/45!!
! Hk<kI! Ohikq! lvk<kqcbqz<!Riel<! ohx<xK! Ohiz<?! kQb! hpg<gLjmObiI!
lVk<Kuljebqz<! Riel<! ohx<xiZl<?! nf<k! Riel<! uQM! kqVl<hqbKl<!
npqf<KuqMgqxK/!nue<!lQ{<Ml<!kQb!hpg<gk<kqx<Gh<!hqk<ke<!Ngqe<xie</!!
!
! uquqzqbk<kqz<! )jhhqt<*! dzgl<! Okie<xqb! fqgp<U?! lg<gt<! Okie<xqb!
fqgp<U!Lkzieju!-bl<hh<hMgqe<xe/!N{<!Nkil<?!oh{<!Wuit</!NkiLg<G!
91 Nh<hqt<!kf<kK!–!Nkil<!Nh<hqjtg<!gck<kiI!–!kl<!Njmbqz<zik<!Okix<xl<!
fi{k<jkk<! Okix<Xuqk<kz<! .! Nkil<! Wuit<! H{If<K! Gpf<jkh<OhX!
d{<mig<Gkz</! -ju! uquqzqb! uvziX?! -f<k! uvziX! siIz <̂! miIuqeqe<!
dbqiqeh<! hiq{ilg<! Ogim<him<Mg<G! Lv{iekig! -Vf<kiZl<?! lg<gTt<!
yVsiviI!Wx<Xg<ogit<gqe<xeI/!!
!
! Nkil<! Wuit<! ljxg<! gVk<kqje! w^</Oke<olipq! lQt<hiIju!
osb<gqe<xiI/!!
Wuit<!outqOb!ui!
gkUgTg<Gh<!hqe<eiz<!Okue<!
de<ekr<gtqeiz<!deg<G!
Njm!ofb<K!ogi{If<kqVg<gqOxe</!
NkiLg<Gg<!gcg<gg<!ogiMk<kK!
Nh<hqt<!nz<z!–!ncjl!uqMkjz!
hGk<kxqU!\|uijzbqz<!
Lkzqz<!Sm<Mg<ogi{<mK!fQkie<!
Hvm<sqbqe<!Le<jeg<G!Lf<jkb!uqk<K/!!
!
-e<X!
WOke<!Okim<ml<!Okue<gTg<Gh<!hbh<hmik!
h,jegtiz<!fqvl<hqBt<tK/!
lf<jkbqz<!hz!NMgt<!upq!kuxquqm<me/!
sqz!NMgTl<!sqjxbib<!fqjek<Kg<!ogit<gqe<xe/!
!
WOki!yV!GXGXh<hqz<!osiz<gqOxe<!
nMk<k!hjmh<Hzgqz<!
Wuit<!Njmgm<ch<!hjmg<gh<hMuit<!
k{<mjegt<!kqVk<kh<hm<mkib<!
-Vg<gg<!%miK/46!
Wuit<!uquqzqbk<kqe<hc!Njmbqe<xq!-Vk<kz<!.!oh{<!Njmbqe<xq!-Vh<hjkh<!
oh{<{qbl<! lXk<kz<! Lkzie! gVk<Kg<gt<! -f<kg<! guqjk! &zligh<! hkqU!
osb<bh<ohXgqe<xe/!okie<l!fqgp<U?!okie<jlg<!gjklif<kI!Lkzieux<jxg<!
guqjkg<Gk<! kjzh<hig! njlk<Kl<! guqjk! wPKgqe<xeI/! “Nkilqe<!
92 lijzOfvk<!kgqh<H”,36 “nm<sbh<!hik<kqvl<”48!Ngqb!kjzh<Hgtqz<!s/uqsbzm<Slq!
guqjk! hjmk<Kt<tiI/! Neiz<! -f<kk<! okie<ll<! yV! GxqbQmigh<!
hbe<hMk<kh<hMgqxK/!!
!
! uiz<lQgq?! -vile<?! -viu{e<?! uqhQm{e<! Lkzie! -kqgisk<! okie<l!
fqgp<UgTl<!gjklif<kIgTl<!HKg<guqjkbqz<!jgbith<hMgqe<xe/!!
uic!fqe<x!fQ!!
uiz<lQgq!Neib<49!
!
Ou[giel<!
Ou{<mik!Ohs<S!
uqk{<miuikl<!
uqhQ]{!Ou]l<!
uqx<hje!biGOl4:!
!
ftibqeqjbk<!
okiqbik!
fu!figiqgh<!oh{<O{///51!!
-r<G!uiz<lQgq?!uqhQm{e<?! ftibqeq!Ngqb!okie<l!lif<kIgtqe<!G{r<gTl<!
osbz<gTl<!fqgp<gizg<!gjklif<kOviM!yh<hqm<Mg<!gim<mh<hMgqe<xe/!!
!
! lizkq! jlk<iq?! Gm<c! Ovukq! Lkzie! oh{<{qbg<! guqRIgt<! okie<l!
lif<kIgjtk<! kl<! ne<xim! uip<uqbOziM! yh<hqm<Mg<! gim<Mgqe<xeI/!
gmUtibqEl<! nuIgjtBl<! leqkVg<G! Wx<hMl<! -e<h! Ke<hr<gTg<G!
dm<hMk<kqh<!hiIg<gqe<xiIgt<A!N{ikqg<gl<?!oh{<{cjl!-ux<jx!leqkIgtqml<!
hiIh<hKOhiz<?!gmUtqmLl<!hiIk<K?!lel<?!dmz<?!Ohs<S!-ux<xqjeg<!gmUtqe<!
fqjzh<him<OmiM!n[gqg<! gim<Mgqe<xiIgt</! leqkh<! oh{<gTg<G!likf<OkiXl<!
Okie<Xl<!lik!uqzg<gqje!lizkq!jlk<iq?!‘uqzg<gh<hm<m!GVkq!2?!uqzg<gh<hm<m!
GVkq! 3’! we! -v{<M! kjzh<hqz<! guqjkgjth<! hjmk<Kt<tiI/! Lkz<!
guqjkbqz<! nIk<kfiiQ^<uiqbigqb! hiIukq! OkuqjbBl<?! -v{<mil<! guqjkbqz<!
lKjv! lQeim<sqbl<jljbBl<! Gxqh<hqm<Mh<! OhSgqe<xiI/! Lkz<! guqjk!
hqe<uVliX;!
93
gVujx!-VTt<!
keK!yx<jxg<giz<!gMg<g!fqx<gqxit<!
nIk<kfiiQ̂ <uiq!
sqk<kqjvbqe<!oul<jl!GjlBl<!
kipqm<m!gx<sqjxg<Gt<!
!
ouck<K!upqBl<!gVLm<jmg<!gsqU!
Obieqbqz<!hqShqSg<g!
gsgsh<hqz<!oftqBl<!sg<kqjbk<!
keK!yx<jx!uzg<g{<{iz<!
Ljxg<gqxie<!sque<!
!
GVkq!ofc!hvu!
lQkq!dmjz!fqjeuqz<!Slf<khc!
gQpqxr<Gl<!hikqh<!hil<jhh<!
hqck<kqPk<K!-vk<kk<jkk<!
Kjmk<okxqgqxit</!
!
upg<gl<Ohiz<!-z<zilz<!
ohVl<himigs<!siBl<!dkqvk<kiz<!
-e<X!lqGf<k!nZh<jh!d{Vgqxit<!
ke<!dmjzs<!sx<X!NSuish<hMk<k!
squje!uqzgqh<Ohigs<!osiz<gqxit<!
siqhikqbieue<!fqjzGjzgqxie<!
keK!hikqBmZme<!
&e<X!fim<gTg<G!wh<hc!uip<uK!
yh<hf<kk<jk!lQxg<%miK!we<gqxie</!
!
fQbqe<xq!fieqz<jz!we<xhc!!
uzK!gvk<kiz<!-Xg<g!nj{g<gqxie<!
we<!giz<gjt!fQm<c!fie<!nlv!Ou{<Ml<!!
we<!dmZme<!fie<!dxr<g!Ou{<Ml<!
-mK!gvk<kiz<!squjeh<!hqb<k<okxqf<Kuqm<M!
94
keK!hjpbhQmk<kqe<!oux<xqmk<kqz<!
uf<klIgqxit</!
!
hqvgivs<!Sx<Xh<hijk!wr<Gl<!
yx<jxg<!gizcbqe<!
-vk<kk<!kmr<gt</52!
! -r<Gs<! sque<?! nIk<kfiiQ <̂uiq! we<El<! okie<lr<gt<! GxqbQmig!
uf<Kt<te/! okie<lg<! GxqbQMgt<! fqgp<gizk<! Ke<hl<?! uXjl?! dmz<OsiIU?!
N{ikqg<gl<?! oh{<{cjl?! oh{<! dmz<olipq! Lkzieux<jxh<!
Hzh<hMk<Kgqe<xe/! yV! ohiVjt! yu<ouiVuVl<! ouu<OuX! hiIjubqz<!
hiIh<hK! -bz<hiGl</! Ne<lQguikqBl<! oh{<{qbuikqBl<! squohVlijeBl<?!
hiIukqOkuqjbBl<! ouu<OuX! Ogi{r<gtqz<! Ofig<Ggqe<xeI/! -f<k! Ofig<Gh<!
HKg<guqRIgtqml<!lqGkqbib<!dt<tK/!!
!
! “flK! -zg<gqbr<gtqz<! -vilib{?! lgihivkg<! gjkgtqz<! uVl<!
hik<kqvr<gt<?! fqgp<s<sqgt<?! gVk<Kg<gt<! hz!dt<tuiXl<! Oux<XVul<! ohx<Xl<!
uvg<! gi{zil</! -vile<?! hvke<?! -zg<Gue<?! Gge<?! nEle<?! -viu{e<?!
uQm{e<?! Gl<hgV{e<?! sQjk?! kVle<?! uQle<?! uqsbe<?! gI{e<?! hiR<sizq!
NgqObiI! ouu<OuX! G{fze<gtqe<! hqvkqfqkqgtig! nux<xqe<! &z!
hcur<gtigOu!Ng<gh<hm<Mt<teI/!sqzh<hkqgivk<kqe<!kjzbib!hik<kqvr<gtie!
g{<{gq?! likuq?! Ogiuze<! NgqObiiqe<! lix<XVur<gjtBl<! flK!
guqjkgtqZl<!gjkgtqZl<!gi{zil</!!
!
! okie<lr<gtqz<! %xh<hm<Mt<t! gx<hgk<! kVUl<! gilOkEUl<! kqiqsr<G!
osiIg<gLl<! nLkSvhqBl<! -zg<gqbr<gtqz<! nz<zilz<! hilv! lg<gtqe<!
djvbimz<gtqZl<! -ml<ohxz<! gi{zil</! nuIgt<! uqxZg<G! uQljeBl<?!
nxk<Kg<Gk<! kVljeBl<?! OfIjlg<G! -viljeBl<?! gx<Hg<Gs<! sQjkjbBl<!
g{<{gqjbBl<?! ut<t{<jlg<Gg<! gI{jeBl<! &zh<! hcur<gtig!
Wx<Xg<ogi{<Mt<teI/! -viu{je! fz<zueigUl<?! -vilje!
-vg<glx<xueigUl<?! jgOgbqjb! fz<zutigUl<?! uQm{jek<! KOvigqbigUl<!
gim<Ml<! guqjkgTl<! gjkgTl<! -k<okie<lr<gtqe<! osz<uig<jgOb!
gim<Mgqe<xe/! klqp<g<! gmUoteg<! gVkh<hMl<! LVgeqe<! uQvs<! osbz<gTl<!
95 osz<uig<Gjmb! okie<lr<gtiGl<”53! we<X! hi/lVkfibgl<!djvh<hKl<! -u{<!
Ofig<gk<kg<gkiGl</!!
!
! GxqR<sq?! Lz<jz?! lVkl<?! ofb<kz<?! hijz! Lkzie! -bx<jg!
njlh<HgTl<! gmUt<?! Ohb<?! lvl<?! hil<H?! lkk<kjzuIgt<?! RibqX?! fqzi?!
uq{<lQe<?! viG?! OgK! Lkzie! njek<Kl<! okie<lr<gt<! NGl</! -f<kk<!
okie<lr<gt<! fim<Mg<G! fiM?! olipqg<G! olipq! OuXhm<Ml<! ye<Xhm<Ml<!
gi{h<ohXgqe<xe/! sqz! GxqbQMgTl<! hclr<gTl<! okie<lr<gtib<!
uqtr<Ggqe<xe/! OkuI?! nvg<gI! -uIgtqe<! osbz<hiMgTl<! okie<lg<!
%Xgtib<k<! kqgp<gqe<xe/! gizr<gizlib<! yV! fqgp<uqjek<! okimIf<K! lg<gt<!
Ohs<sqZl<! wPk<kqZl<! hbe<hMk<kq! uf<kiZl<! nKUl<! okie<lligg<!
gVkh<hMgqe<xK/! fim<Mh<Hx! -zg<gqbr<gtqz<! okie<lr<gt<! lqgh<! hzuib<k<!
okiqgqe<xe/!!
!
! “lvLl<! hil<Hl<! okie<lr<gtqz<! Ohiqml<! ohx<xe/! lvk<kqz<! gmUt<!
uip<ukigk<!okie<lr<gt<!d{<M/! ‘NzlI!osz<ue<’!we<x!upg<gqjes<!sr<gk<!
klqpqz<! gi{zil</! GVf<jk! lvfqpzqz<! GV! ucuib<k<! Okie<xqb! gmUt<!
l{quisgVg<G!nEh,kq!ntqk<kK!lvr<gt<! okie<lk<kqz<! ohXl<! Ohiqmk<jkk<!
okt<tqkqe<! Sm<Ml</! ‘NzlI! gmUt<’! we<xiz<?! Nzlvk<kqe<! ncbqz<! dt<t!
gmUt<! we<X! ohiVt<! ne<XA! ‘nlI’! we<x! osiz<?! sr<gk<! klqpqz<! ‘uqVh<hl<’!
we<x! ohiVtqz<! uVl<A! Nzlvk<jk! uqVl<hq! djxBl<! gmUt<! we<Ox!
ohiVt<Ogimz<! sizh<! ohiVf<Kl</! Hk<kI! Ohikq! lvk<kcbqz<! Riel<!
ohx<xjljbg<!Gxqh<hqmz<!lvr<gt<!leqk!uip<uqz<!ogi{<m!okimIhqje!fe<G!
gim<Ml<A! leqkIgt<! Okie<Xukx<G! Le<eOv! -f<fqzUzgqz<! lvr<gt<! -Vf<ke/!
okie<jlg<Gk<! okie<jl! weh<hMl<!Nkil<! Wuit<! gjk!-jk! olb<h<hqg<Gl</!
-k<okie<lk<kqz<! lvl<! geqkVkz<! (GARDEN OF EDEN) we<hK! fe<jlg<Gl<!
kQjlg<Gl<! hizlib<! njlf<K! hcll<! Nkjzg<! gi{<gqOxil</! hil<H! nxquqe<!
%i<jlg<G! nz<zK! kQjl! Nx<Xl<! sik<kiEg<Gl<! hclliujkg<! gi{zil<”54!
we<X! gkqI/lgiOkue<! okie<ll<! Gxqk<Ks<! sqz! sie<Xgt<! gim<cbjlBl<!
sqf<kqg<gk<kg<gkiGl</!!
!
96 4/3/!okiGh<Hjv!
! -zg<gqb!ujgjlgt<!gizf<OkiXl<!lix<xl<!ohx<X!utIf<K!uVgqe<xe/!
-ux<xqe<! gVk<Kh<! Hzh<him<Mk<! kqxEg<G! dk<kqgtqe<! hr<G! nth<hiqbK/!
dk<kqgTt<! ‘okie<ll<’!we<hK!keq!-mk<jkh<!ohx<Xs<!sqxf<K!uqtr<Ggqe<xK/!
HKg<guqjkgtqe<! gVk<Kh<! Hzh<him<Mk<! kqxeqz<! outqh<hjmh<! ohiVjt!
nz<zK!HjkohiVjt!uqtg<gUl<!dme<him<Mh<!ohiVjt!nz<zK!wkqIljxh<!
ohiVjt! uqtg<gUl<! okie<l! fqgp<Ugt<! hbe<hMk<kh<! ohXgqe<xe/!
HKg<guqRIgt<! kl<! fiM?! -el<?! olipq! we<El<! GXgqb!um<mk<jkk<! ki{<c?!
dzgtiuqb! hiIjubqz<! okie<l! fqgp<Ugjtg<! jgbiTgqe<xeI/!
okiz<gih<hqbI! gizk<kqz<! ‘okie<ll<’!-zg<gqbh<! hqiquig!-Vf<kiZl<!nf<fqjz!
-g<gizk<kqz<! -z<jz/! HKg<guqjkgtqz<! okie<ll<! dk<kqbigh<!
hqe<hx<xh<hm<Mt<tK/! ngzqjg?! Ohikqlvl<?! sqZju! Lkzie! okie<lr<gt<!
Ofvch<! ohiVjt!uqtg<Gl<! ohiVm<M! keqg<guqjkbig!nz<zK!okimIfqjzg<!
guqjkbigh<! hjmg<gh<! ohxuqz<jz/! lixigg<! Gxqh<Hh<! ohiVjt?! wkqIljxh<!
ohiVjt?!GxqbQm<Mh<!ohiVjt!d{Ik<Kl<!ujgbqz<!HKg<guqjkk<!kjzh<Hl<!
HKg<guqjk! F~z<! kjzh<Hl<! guqjkh<! hjmh<Hl<! gi{h<ohXgqe<xe/! okie<lh<!
hcur<gjt! -e<jxb! liIg<sqbh<! hiIjubqZl<! oh{<{qbh<! hiIjubqZl<!
kzqk<kqbh<! hiIjubqZl<! ohiqbiiqbh<! hiIjubqZl<! gif<kqbh<! hiIjubqZl<!
HKg<guqRIgt<! Ofig<Ggqe<xeI/! yOv! okie<lh<! hclk<jkh<! HKg<guqRIgt<!
ouu<OuX! hiIjubqz<! Ofig<GuKl<! -r<Gg<! Gxqh<hqmk<kg<gK/! nkx<G!
nuIgtqe<! sqf<kjeBl<! ogit<jgBl<! siIf<kqVg<Gl<! -bg<gLl<! giv{qgtig!
njlgqe<xe/!!
97
sie<ox{<!uqtg<gl<!
!
2/ -vi/-viOsf<kqve<?!HKg<guqjk!-zg<g{l<?!265/!
3/ s/hizSf<kvl<?!oke<E~z<?!635/!
4/ -vi/-viOsf<kqve<?!HKg<guqjk!-zg<g{l<?!266/!
5/ sq/S/osz<zh<hi!)oki/N/*?!HKg<Gvz<gt<?!h/34/!
6/ ou/-vk<kqe&Ik<kq?!okiz<gih<hqb!Ofig<gqz<!HKg<guqjk?!h/48/!
7/ sq/-/ljxljz?!HKg<guqjk;!Lh<ohVl<!dk<kqgt<?!h/345/!
8/ okiz<gih<hqbl<?!ohiVtkqgivl<?!421/!!
9/ Olx<hc!F~z</?!649/!
:/ li/Ogiuqf<kviS?!HKg<guqjkg<!gm<mjlh<H?!h/274/!
21/ sq/gegshihkq?!hivkqBl<!hqxGl<!hqs<s&Ik<kqBl<!hqxVl<?!h/242/!
22/ f/hqs<s&Ik<kq!guqjkgt<?!hg</55.71/!
23/ Olx<hc!F~z</?!h/257/!
24/ juvLk<K?!-f<kh<!h,g<gt<!uqx<hjeg<gz<z?!h/87/!
25/ nh<Kz<!vGlie<?!lqe<lqeqgtiz<!yV!gckl<?!h/47/!
26/ g/fi/S/?!guqjkgt<?!h/48/!
27/ =OviM!klqpe<he<?!u{g<gl<!ut<Tu"?!hg</227.228/!
28/ =OviM!klqpe<he<?!fjm!lxf<k!fkqBl<!kqjs!lixqb!YjmBl<?!hg</9:.:6/!
29/ vi\!LVGhi{<cbe<?!we<Xl<!de<///?!h/2:/!
2:/ Olx<hc!F~z</?!h/49/!
31/ L/Olk<ki?!DIuzl<?!hg</41.42/!
32/ Olx<hc!F~z</?!h/99/!
33/ fi/uqs<ufike<?!Lt<tqz<!nlVl<!heqk<Ktq?!h/3:/!
34/ Olx<hc!F~z</?!h/48/!
35/ Olx<hc!F~z</?!h/55/!
36/ kqbi'?!yV!%jm!yV!Ogich<!h,g<gt<?!hg</492.493/!
37/ fi/Lk<Kfqzue<?!Hkqb!lvHgt<?!h/24/!
38/ Olx<hc!F~z</?!h/2:/!
39/ ofz<jz!o\bf<ki?!kqj{!lbg<gl<?!h/59/!
3:/ N'I!klqp<fime<?!sqxGgtiGl<!sqZjugt<?!h/51/!
41/ Olx<hc!F~z</?!h/212/!
42/ Kjv/usf<kvise<?!Gx<xr<gOt!kQIh<H!wPkqeiz<?!h/54/!
98 43/ S/-tr<Ogi?!gXh<H!lzIgtqz<!osf<Oke<?!h/:5/!
44/ guqnvr<ge<?!guqnvr<ge<!guqjkgt<?!hg</298.299/!
45/ N{<mit<!hqiqbki<]qeq?!Lk<kr<gt<!kQIf<Kuqm<me?!hg</9:.:1/!
46/ w <̂/Oke<Olipq?!Kxuq!f{<M?!h/42/!
47/ s/uqsbzm<Slq?!wz<zi!lijzgtqZl<!wiqBoliV!Gcjs?!h/37/!
48/ Olx<hc!F~z</?!h/53/!
49/ kqiqsjm?!heqbiz<!hm<m!hk<K!lvr<gt<?!h/2/!
4:/ Olx<hc!F~z</?!h/22/!
51/ Olx<hc!F~z</?!h/23/!
52/ lizkq!jlk<iq?!fQzq?!hg</77.78/!
53/ hi/lVkfibgl<?! “okie<lk<! kqxeib<U! yV! uqtg<gl<”?! okie<lk<! kqxeib<U!
)g/hR<sir<gl<*?!hg</32.33/!
54/ gkqI/lgiOkue<?!okie<ll<?!hg</32.33/!
-bz<!5!
uiel<hicg<!guqjkgtqz<!okie<lg<!%Xgt<!!
!
5/1/!LgUjv!
! uiel<hic! -bg<gl<! -Vhk<kqv{<M! guqjkk<! okiGh<Hgjt!
outqbqm<Mt<tK/! -f<k! -Vhk<kqv{<M! guqjkk<! okiGh<HgTl<! uqjzbqzi!
-kp<gtig!upr<gh<ohx<Xt<te/!-ux<Xt<!HKg<guqjkgTl<!HKg<guqjk!F~z<!
lkqh<HjvgTl<! sqz! gm<MjvgTl<! yV! OfIgi{Zl<! sqz! K[g<Gg<!
guqjkgTl<! -ml<ohx<Xt<te/! uiel<hicbqeiqe<! guqjkgt<! olik<kl<! 5:2/!
-ux<Xt<! 287! guqjkgt<! -r<G! Nb<Ug<G! dm<hMk<kh<ohXgqe<xe/! -f<kh<!
HKg<guqjkgTt<! 98! guqjkgtqz<! okie<lg<! %Xgt<! dt<teA! 36!
guqjkgtqe<! kjzh<HgOt! okie<lg<! %Xgtib<! njlf<Kt<te/! -f<kg<!
guqjkgTt<! uiq! ujvbjx! sqx<oxz<jz! 14! uiqgt<A! Ohovz<jz! 677! uiqgt<!
NGl</!!
!
! Oukl<?! -vilib{l<?! lgihivkl<?! gih<hqbl<?! Hvi{l<?! fim<Mh<Hxk<!
okb<ul<?! lkl<?! OkuI?! sqk<kI/! LequI?! gjmobP! ut<tz<?! fQkq! -zg<gqbl<?!
-bx<jg?! fqxl<?! le<eI?! HzuI?! figvk<kqel<?! Ohb<?! hqsiS?! fug<gqvgl<?!
hivkliki?! kk<<Kuuikq?! smr<Ggt<! Lkzieju! -f<kqb! l{<{qz<!
gizr<gizlib<! Ohsh<hm<Ml<?! wPkh<ohx<Xl<! uf<Kogi{<cVg<gqe<xe/! -ju!
lg<gtqe<! Ohs<sqZl<! wPk<kqZl<! OfIh<ohiVjt! d{Ik<kUl<! ljxh<ohiVjt!
d{Ik<kUl<! GxqbQm<Mh<! ohiVjt! d{Ik<kUl<! hbe<hMk<kh<! ohXgqe<xe/!
uiel<hicg<! guqjkgtqz<! -ml<ohx<Xt<t! -f<kk<! okie<lg<! %Xgjt! -f<k!
-bz<!uqtg<Ggqe<xK/!!
!
5/2/!-bx<jg!!
! l{<?!ljz?!ljp?!nVuq?!gmz<?!wiqljz?!utq?!uq{<!-e<ee!-bx<jg!
njlh<HgtiGl</! okie<lk<jk! fq'hqk<Kg<! gim<m! -bziK/! nkjeh<! Ohiz?!
-bx<jg! njlh<HgjtBl<! LPjlbig! fq'hqk<Kg<! gim<m! -bziK/!
-g<gVk<kqje!uzqBXk<Kl<!ujgbqz<!hqe<uVl<!gVk<K!gi{h<ohXgqe<xK/!!
!
! “oktquie! nxqU!Nvib<s<sqg<G!dm<hMl<! -bx<jg! nxquqbz<! (Natural
Science) Kjxgtqz<! gi{h<hMl<! “-bx<jg! yPr<G! hx<xqb”! fl<hqg<jg%m! Yi<!
100 nElieOl! (Inference)/!-bx<jg!nxquqbz<!Kjxgt<?!-f<k! ‘nEliek<jk’s<!
osb<Ljxgtqe<! &zl<! LPjlbig! olb<h<hqk<Kg<! gim<c! uqm<moke<xiz<?!
d{<jlbigOu!nju!kr<gt<!gtk<kqz<!Nb<f<K!Lck<Kuqm<me!we<xigquqMl</”2!
-u<uiX!g/hR<sir<gl<!Gxqh<hqMgqe<xiI/!!
!
! ljzbqeK!lim<sq<jljbh<!hx<xqh<!hu{f<kq!LequI?!!
ntg<g!zigi!ntUl<!ohiVTl<!!
Ktg<g!zigi!fqjzBl<!Okix<xLl<!!
uxh<hqEl<!utf<kVl<!u{<jlBl<!ljzg<Og3!
we<X! uqtg<gl<! ntqg<gqe<xiI/! -u<utU! sqxh<Hlqg<g! ljzgtqz<! lqgh<ohiqbK!
-lbljzbiGl</! -lbljzBl<! wuov <̂m<! sqgvLl<! -f<kqbiUg<Gh<! ohVjl!
OsIg<gqe<xe/!nOkOfvl<?!wiqljzgt<!-f<kqbiuqz<!-z<zijlBl<!sqxh<hiGl</!!
!
! =OviM! klqpe<he<?! “fil<”! we<El<! kjzh<hqz<! wPkqb! HKg<guqjk!
uiel<hic!&e<xil<!-kpqz<!outquf<Kt<tK/!-f<kg<!guqjkbqz<!uiel<?!-c?!
$iqbe<?! gmz<?! dzgl<?! -lbljz?! wiqljz! weh<! hz! -bx<jgk<!
okie<lr<gjtg<! Gxqh<hqMgqe<xiI/! uiel<hicg<! guqRIgtqe<! Nx<xzqje!
outqh<hMk<kqg<!gim<m!-f<k!-bx<jgk<!okie<lr<gjt!yh<hqm<Mg<!gim<Mgqe<xiI/!!
uiek<jkg<!gQxqOb!
jugjxgt<!hxqk<okMh<Ohil<"!!
Olieg<!GvZg<Gt<!!
Lpr<Gl<!-c!uqjkh<Ohil<"!!
$iqbjeg<!g{<gtiz<!
Sm<Mh<!ohiSg<GuKl<!
NIg<Gl<!gmzjzjb!
nmg<GuKl<!flg<gqbZl<"!!
flK!sqxgjsh<hqz<!!
Riz!fvl<hkqVl<"!!
!
-lbh<!hxjugt<!fil<"!!
wiqljzbqe<!dt<lel<!fil<"!!
ng<gqeqg<!gix<xqOz!!
101
-kp<uqiqg<Gl<!nVl<Hgt<!fil<"!!
kqg<Ggtqe<!Hkz<uIgt<"4!
-f<kg<! guqjk! 42! uiqgjtg<! ogi{<Mt<tK/! -f<kg<! guqjkbqz<! uiel<hicg<!
guqRIgjt! ‘fil<’! we<X! ke<jlh<! he<jlbqz<! Sm<Mgqe<xiI/! guqjkbqe<!
Lch<hqz<?! “fiolz<zil<! /! /! /! hib<f<K! osz<Zl<! /!nR<sik! /!nlqzfkqbqe<! /!
njzh<hjmgt<@”!we<X!Sm<MukqzqVf<K!uiel<hicg<!guqRIgjt!biVl<!-mv!
LcbiKA! okim! LcbiKA! nuIgt<! nlqzl</! nuIgtqe<! yx<XjlOb!
nlqzfkqbiGl</!!
!
! uiel<hicg<! guqRIgTg<G! fqgvieuIgt<! yVuVl<! -z<jz/! -f<k!
w{<{k<kqOzOb! nuIgtqe<! guqjk! outqh<hiM! gi{h<ohXgqe<xK/! -kx<Gs<!
sie<xig?!!
fie<!///!!
l{<{qz<kie<!fqx<gqOxe<"!!
NeiZl<!
uiek<kqe<!Okijzg<!gqpqk<Kg<!!
giZg<Gs<!osVh<high<!Ohim<Mg<ogit<Tl<!!
uz<zjl!weg<G{<M"!!
!
Hbz<!///!
we<!uqsqxq"!
h,lqjb!!
fMfMr<g!jug<Gl<!
h,gl<hl<!.!weg<G!
DR<sz<!uqjtbim<M"!!
!
-cObijs!///!
we<jek<!
Kbqz<!fQr<g!jug<Gl<!!
kqVh<ht<tq!wPs<sqbqe<!!
-e<eqjs"5!
we<X!L/Olk<ki!Lpr<Gujkg<!Gxqh<hqmzil</!!
!
102 5/2/2/!hqvtbl<!
! -bx<jgjbh<!hx<xq!-Vujgg<!gVk<Kg<gt<!dt<te/!2/!okie<Xokim<M!
uVl<! lvHg<! gVk<K!nz<zK! slbg<! gVk<K! 3/! nxquqbz<! Ofig<G! )nz<zK*!
hGk<kxqUg<! g{<O{im<ml</! hz! ohiVt<gt<! g{<[g<Gk<! okiqBl</! hz!
ohiVt<gt<! g{<[g<Gk<! okiqbi/! g{<[g<Gk<! okiqbih<! ohiVt<gjt!
db<k<K{If<K?!nux<jxh<!hx<xq!Le<OeiIgt<!hz!gVk<Kg<gjtg<!%xqBt<teI/!
dzg! yMg<gl<! nz<zK! npquqjeh<! hqvtbl<! we<X! %Xgqe<xeI/! hqvtbl<!
we<hK! okie<ll<! NGl</! hqvtbl<! we<hkx<G!nhqkie! sqf<kil{q! hqe<uVliX!
uqtg<gl<!ntqg<gqe<xK/!
!
! “hqvtbl<! .! -K! dzg! yMg<gl<A! -K! fqk<kqbl<A! jflqk<kqgl<?!
hqvig<gqVkl<?!Nk<bf<kqgl<! weh<hMl</!-kqz<! fqk<bl<! .! fit<OkiXl<!Nk<lig<gt<!
sqvlhiqgivk<kqe<! ohiVm<Mg<! gmUtiz<! Wx<hMk<kh<hm<m! SPk<kq! Lkzqb!
nuk<jk/! jflqk<kqgl<! .! hqvlOkuEg<G! yVfit<! Lcf<k! -vik<kqiq! gizk<kqz<!
d{<miGl<! dzg! yMg<gl</! hqvig<Vkl<! .! hqvlEg<G! uqkqk<k! NBm<gizk<kqe<!
Lcuqz<!d{<mil<!hqvtb!yMg<gl</!Nk<bf<kqgl<!.!hqvlikq!OkuIgjtBl<!lx<x!
svisvr<gjtBl<! npqg<g! wPf<k! si<usl<livl</! lE]<b! liek<kiz<! sKIBgl<!
Nbqvl<Ljx! kqVl<hqe<! hqvlEg<G! yV! hgz<?! nu<uiOx! -vUliGl</!
nk<kquivik<vl<!%cbK!yVfit</!nf<k!fitqe<!okimg<gk<kqz<!sqVm<cA!nk<kqel<!
Lcuqz<!sr<givl</!-K!kqeh<!hqvtbl</!nf<kk<!kqel<!471!Nbqe<!hqvlEg<G!yV!
uVml</!nf<k! uVml<! hvii<k<ksr<gqjb!NehqxG! hqvgqVkq! ujvbqz<! sr<givl</!
lQ{<Ml<! nf<kh<! hviIk<kgizl<! Nehqe<H! hqvgqVkqbqzqVf<K! G{ikqk<Kur<gt<!
sqVm<cg<gh<hMl</! -u<ujg! sqVm<c! sr<giv! gizk<kqe<! ntU! kquqhvii<k<kliGl</!
-f<kh<! hqvgqVkqujvbqz<! sl<livOl?! nuif<kv! sl<livlil</! -f<kk<! kquqhviIk<k!
gizLl<!hviI<k<klie!hqe<H!libikk<uk<kqZl<?!lgi!lijbbqZl<!kk<usl<livl<!
osb<bh<hMl</! nKkie<! lgisl<livl<! weh<hMl</! hviIk<kl<! ye<X! Lkz<! hk<K!
ogi{<mK/! hk<K! ogi{<mkig! Wx<hm<m! ^<kier<gtqz<! -VhkiuK! <̂kiel<!
hviIk<k!sr<gqjb/”6!!
! uiel<hicg<! guqRI! HuqbvS! “yV! guqReqe<! sqZjuh<hiM”! we<El<!
kjzh<hqz<!wPkqb!365!uiqgjtg<!ogi{<m!fQ{<m!guqjkbqe<!-Xkqbqz<?!!
-Oki"!!
Olx<G!uiel<!!
-vk<ks<!squh<hib<!///!
103
!
YMr<gt<"!!
yV!hqvtbl<!uvh<OhigqxK"7!
we<X! guqjkjb! Lcg<gqe<xiI/! -f<kg<! guqjkbqz<! Lkzitqk<Kul<!
yMg<gh<hMl<?! ohiKUjmjl! wr<Gl<! hvUl<! we<El<! Gxqh<Hh<! ohiVtqje!
Le<jug<gqe<xiI/! dzg! yMg<gl<! /! npqU! we<hK! hz<zibqvl<! N{<MgTg<G!
yVLjx!fmh<hK/!-K!hx<xqb!gVk<Kl<!b,gl<!NGl</!-K!fq'hqg<g!-bzikK/!
nkeiz<!-K!okie<lk<Kt<!jug<gh<ohx<Xt<tK/!!
!
5/3/!-kqgisl<!!
! -f<kqbiuqz<! -kqgis! F~z<gt<! -vilib{Ll<! lgihivkLl<! NGl</!
-ux<xqe<! gizl<!&uibqvl<!N{<MgTg<Gl<!Le<hiGl</! umolipqbqz<! uiz<lQgq!
LequI! -vilib{k<jkBl<! OukuqbisI! lgihivkk<jkBl<! wPk<K! ucuqz<!
F~zig<gl<!osb<keI/!-ju!F~zig<gl<!ohXl<!Le<Oh?!-ux<xqe<!gjkh<Ohig<Gl<!
gjklif<kIgTl<! lg<gtqmk<kqz<! uib<olipqbig! upr<gh<hm<M! uf<Kt<te/!
nkeiz<! -ux<xqe<! Okix<xl<! wh<ohiPK! we<hjk! nxqb! Lcbi! ujgbqz<!
okie<jl! uib<f<kju! -kqgisr<gt<! NGl</! -f<kqbk<! okie<lr<gTt<!
-vilib{Ll<! hivkLl<! Lke<jl! -mk<jkh<! ohXgqe<xe/! -kqgisr<gtqz<!
usqm<mVl<!uqSuilqk<kqvVl<!okie<lr<gtqe<!fibgIgtib<!uqtr<Ggqe<xeI/!!
!
5/3/2/!-vilib{l<!!
! kqVlizqe<! -vil! nukivk<kqje! umolipqbqz<! uiz<lQgqBl<!
klqp<olipqbqz<! gl<hVl<! gih<hqb! -zg<gqbligh<! hjmk<Kt<teI/! uiz<lQgq!
-vilib{k<jkk<! kPuqBl<! klqp<h<! h{<him<cjes<! sqjkg<gilZl<! gl<hI!
-bx<xqb!-vilgijkjbh<!Ohiz?!-f<kqbiuqz<!OuX!olipqgtqZl<!-vilib{l<!
hjmg<gh<! ohx<Xt<tK/! HKg<guqRIgt<! kl<! hjmh<hqz<!%x!uf<k! gVk<kqjek<!
okie<l! dk<kqbqe<! &zl<! uqtg<Gukx<G?! -vilib{g<! gjkg<%XgjtBl<!
gjklif<kIgjtBl<! jgbi{<Mt<teI/! -vile<?! sQjk?! -viu{e<?! %eq?!
ngzqjg?! lqkqjz?! -zg<Gue<! Lkzie! okie<lg<! %Xgt<! uiel<hicg<!
guqjkgtqz<!-ml<ohx<Xt<te/!
!
104 5/3/2/2/!-vile<!!
! sQjk! kjzg<gx<Hjmbut</! nOsiguek<kqz<! -viu{eiz<!
sqjxbqzjmg<gh<hm<cVf<k!sQjkjbg<!gih<hix<xqbK!nuTjmb!gx<Hk<kqxeiGl</!
-vilje! wkqIk<Kh<! Ohsik! sQjkjbk<! kQbqz<! -xr<gq! uvs<! osie<eOhiKl<?!
nf<kk<! kQbqzqVf<K! nujtg<! gih<hix<xqbK! nuTjmb! gx<Hk<! kqxeiGl</!
gIh<hqeqbie! sQjkjbg<! giegk<kqz<! keqjlbqz<! uqm<mohiPKl<! nujtg<!
gih<hix<xqbK!nuTjmb!gx<Hk<!kqxeiGl</!-r<Gs<!sQjk!yV!okie<ll<!NGl</!
gx<H! we<hK! okie<lg<! GxqbQM! NGl</! -f<fqgp<Ugjt! wMk<Kg<! ogi{<M?!
gjklif<kI! sQjkbqe<! G{k<jk! lix<xq?! -vilje! wkqIk<Kh<! OhSukigg<!
guqjk! hjmg<gh<hMgqe<xK/! Sf<kvl<! we<El<! uiel<hicg<! guqRI! wPkqb!
“ngh<hm<Mg<! ogi{<mibi@”! we<El<! kjzh<hqzie! guqjk!uiel<hic! fie<gil<!
-kpqz<!outquf<Kt<tK/!-f<kg<!guqjkbqz<!yV!hGkq;!!
lqkqjzbqz<!we<ohiVm<M!!
uqz<ozick<K!!
=pk<kqz<!weg<gig!!
uQvh<OhiI!Hiqf<k!fQ!///!
Hkqkigh<!ohx<x!
nkqgiv!zm<Slqjb!!
nEhuqh<hkx<gig!!
fqjxlik!gi<h<hqeqbie!!
we<je!///!lXhcBl<!!
giegl<!Kvk<kqeiOb!///"8!
NTl<! nvsEg<G!nvsqjbuqm?!Nm<sq<! nkqgivOl!Lkzqml<! ugqg<gqxK/! -K!
Wghk<kqeq! uqvkl<! ogi{<m! -vileqmLl<! -Vf<kK! we<hjkh<! HKg<guqjk!
Hzh<hMk<Kgqe<xK/!!
!
! -vile<! gi<h<hqeq! sQjkjbg<! giegk<kqz<! keqjlbqz<! uqm<M! uf<kkx<Gg<!
giv{l<?!-vileqe<!yx<xIgt<!%xqb!Yi<! Wjp!u{<{ie<!uiIk<jkgt<!NGl</!
-vilib{k<kqz<! ym<mg<%k<kI! -bx<xqb! WpiuK! gi{<ml<! dk<kvgi{<mk<kqz<!
gIh<hqeq! sQjk! giegl<! ose<X! zuGsi! we<El<! Osb<gjt! =e<xit<! wEl<!
osb<kq!dtK/!!
!
105 5/3/2/3/!sQjk!
! uiel<hic! NxiuK! -kpqz<! nxque<! hjmk<k! “\iegq! Hzl<hz<! ///@”!
we<El<!guqjk!outquf<Kt<tK/!-f<kg<!guqjkbqz<!sQjk!-vilje!uqlIsel<!
osb<gqxit</!!
nf<k!-viu{!sl<aivl<!!
Lcf<K!///!
Nv{<b!uisLl<!
ng<gqeqh<!hqvOusLl<!
Lcf<kOk!///!
W!///!zm<Sl{i!///"!!
uel<!hiIg<goue<X!!
vkl<!Wxs<!osiz<zq?!!
wje!njpk<K!uf<K!
-f<k!fm<m!fMfqsqbqz<!///!
-V{<m!gim<cz<!///!!
gIh<hqeq!we<je!!
fqIg<gkqbig!uqm<Mh<!Ohigg<!
gm<mjtbqm<m!
nf<k!sQki!vileqe<!!
Hk<kqjb!Nt<hue<!!
-e<X!yV!u{<{iei@9!
! -vile<! hkqeie<G! N{<Mgt<! ueuisl<! ose<xOhiK?! -vileqe<!
giz{qgjt! niqbj{lQK! juk<K?! hvke<! Nm<sq! Hiqf<kie</! ‘osVh<Hme<! yV!
Ohm<c’!we<El<!kjzh<hqz<!guqOku<!wPkqb!guqjk!uiel<hic!Wpil<!-kpqz<!
outqbigqBt<tK/!hqvLgI!uQm<Ms<!osVh<Hg<Gg<!%m!Ohm<c!ntqg<Gl<!kGkqgt<!
d{<M! we<X! %Xl<! guqOku<?! osVh<hqml<! hz! uqeig<gjt! wPh<Hgqe<xiI/!
-Xkqbig?!!
kQuqvlig!fQr<gt<!!
wjkh<!hx<xqbiuK!!
sqf<kqh<hK{<mi@!
we<X!Ogm<gqe<xiI/!nkx<Gg<!giz{q?!!
d{<M"!!
sqz!Oksr<gjtBl<!!
106
sqz!Nm<sqgjtBl<!!
hiIg<Gl<!OhiK!!
lQ{<Ml<!fir<gOt!!
sql<lisel<!Wxquqmzili!we<X!!
Obisqh<hK{<M":!
we<X! hkqZjvg<gqe<xK/! “lQ{<Ml<”! we<El<! osiz<@! Le<eOv! Ogisz! fim<cz<!
giz{q! sql<lisek<kqz<! -Vf<kjk! d{Ik<Kgqe<xK/! fim<cz<! Dpz<!
ohVgquqm<mkiz<!lQ{<Ml<!Nm<sqbqz<!nlvzili!we<X!kQuqvligs<!sqf<kqh<hjkBl<!
d{v!Lcgqe<xK/!!
!
5/3/2/4/!ngzqjg!!
! ogtkl!Lequiqe<! ljeuq!ngzqjg/!ngzqjgbqe<!npgqz<! lbr<gqb!
-f<kqve<?!h,je!ucuqz<!ngzqjg!uQm<cz<!Fjpf<K!ogtkl!Lequjvh<!Ohiz<!
ucouMk<K! ngzqjgBme<! H{Is<sqbqz<! =Mhm<M! outqObXgqxie</! ogtkl!
LequI! g{<mxqf<K?! -f<kqvjeBl<! ngzqjgjbBl<! shqg<gqe<xiI/! ngzqjg!
gz<zigqe<xit</! gz<! ucuqz<! gqmg<Gl<! ngzqjglQK! -vile<! gizc! hm<mKl<!
nut<! lQ{<Ml<! ngzqjg! ucuk<jk! njmuit<! we<X! ogtkl! LequI!
sihuqOlisel<! kVgqe<xiI/! -f<fqgp<Ugt<! okie<lr<gt<!NGl</!-f<kk<! okie<l!
ngzqjgjbh<! hjmh<hitIgt<! kr<gt<! gVk<Kg<Ogx<hh<! hz! Ogi{r<gtqZl<!
hjmk<Kt<teI/!!
!
! uiel<hic!Wpil<!-kpqz<!Ogiju!Rieq?!“gz<zqjg”!we<El<!kjzh<hqz<!
677! uiqgjtg<! ogi{<m! fQ{<m! guqjkjbh<! hjmk<Kt<tiI/! -Vhk<kqv{<M!
uiel<hic! -kp<gtqz<! outquf<Kt<t! guqjkgtqz<! -KOu! lqGkqbie!
uiqgjtg<!ogi{<m!fQ{<m!guqjkbiGl</!ngzqjg!gz<zib<!lixqb!fqjzbqZl<!
ngzqjg! ke<je! fqjek<Kh<! hiIg<Gl<! fqjzbqZl<! -f<kg<! guqjkg<G! Rieq!
‘gz<! ! )ng*zqjg! ! gz<zqjg’! weh<! ohbiqm<Mt<tiI/! ngzqjgbqe<! hqxh<H?!
utIh<H?!kqVl{l<?!LkzqvU?!-f<kqveqe<!Njs?!ft<tqvuqz<!-f<kqve<?!ogtkl!
LequI! sihl<?! sihuqOlisel<?! gizl<! gpqkz<?! -vile<! uVjg! Ngqb!
fqgp<UgjtBl<! nux<jx! fqgp<giz! lg<gOtiM! yh<hqm<Ml<! Rieq! guqjk!
hjmk<Kt<tiI/! guqk<Kuk<kqe<! -jmbqjmOb! kk<Kur<gjtBl<! Rieq!
Hzh<hMk<kqBt<tiI/!-f<kg<!guqjkbqe<!gjmsqh<!hGkqjb!Rieq?!!
107
Nkqg<gg<!Ogim<jmjb!njsk<K!ofiXg<gq!!
nke<hijx!-kbk<jkh<!hCoveh<!hqtf<K!
Sv{<mz<!hqsisqe<!okiz<jzbqzqVf<K!!
dzjgg<!gig<Gl<!dk<kle<!!
nOki!///!uVgqxie<!///!!
!
we<je!Ofig<gq!ofVr<gquVl<!nueK!
hikole<lzI!hm<m!g{k<kqz<!
we<!Ne<li!sqzqIk<okPgqxK!///!
sqzqIk<okPf<K!///"!!
!
uq{<j{Bl<!l{<j{Bl<!kl<uslig<gq!
Oukl<!uqiqk<k!LequjeBl<!
uQvl<!hbqe<x!-f<kqvjeBl<!!
klg<Gt<!osiqk<Kg<ogi{<M!!
dzgl<!ohiK!we!dvg<g!Lpr<gq!!
djpg<Gl<!gvr<gjt!dbIk<kqs<!osz<Zl<!!
nf<kg<!Ogic!leqkI!%m<mk<kqz<!
we<!Ne<li!
Lg<kq!Ofig<gq!Le<OeXgqxK!///21!
we<X! Lcg<gqe<xiI/! Dpz<?! Sv{<mz<! we<El<! kQb! osbz<gtqzqVf<K!
dzgk<kqjeg<! gig<g! -vile<! uVgqxie</! ngzqjg! nVgqz<! -vile<!
uVl<ohiPK?!nueqe<!hikl<! )gz<zqjg*!ngzqjglQK!hm<mUme<!gz<!dVul<!
lixq?! ngzqjg! dVulib<! outqh<hMgqxit<A! sqzqIk<okPgqe<xit</! wPf<kut<!
sihl<! -m<m! g{ujeBl<! sihl<! -mg<! giv{lig! -Vf<k! -f<kqvjeBl<!
klg<Gt<! osiqk<Kg<! ogit<gqxit</! “dzgl<! ohiK”! we! Lpr<Gl<!
lg<gm<%m<mk<kqz<! kiEl<! yVk<kqbib<! fqe<X?! dvg<g! Lpr<Ggqxit</! nut<!
Ne<li! lm<Ml<! Lg<kqbjmb! hb{l<! osb<gqe<xK/! -r<Gg<! guqRiqe<!
ohiKUjmjls<!sqk<kif<kk<jk!dm<hMk<kqg<!gim<Mgqe<xiI/!!
!
! uiel<hicg<! guqRI! -tLVG?! uiel<hic! Wpil<! -kpqz<!
“uqjmohXgqOxe<”! we<El<! kjzh<hqz<! njlf<Kt<t! guqjkbqz<?! ngzqjg!
Ohie<x!oh{<gt<!ucg<Gl<!g{<{Qjvk<!Kjmg<gh<!Ohiukigg<!%Xgqe<xiI/!!
108
kusq!ogtkle<!!
-f<kqve<!Ohigh<!!
ohib<jl!dxuqZl<!!
gz<zib<s<!sjlf<k!!
ngzqjgh<!oh{<gt<!!
ucg<Gl<!g{<{QI!!
Kjmg<gh<!OhigqOxe<!!
! gizl<!njpg<gqxK!!
! nOki!gizl<!njpg<gqxK/22!
! gl<hvilib{k<kqz<! hizgi{<ml<! ngzqjgh<! hmzk<kqz<! ngzqjg!
uvziX! %xh<hMgqe<xK/! sr<g! -zg<gqbl<! hiqhimz<! hk<okie<hkil<! himzqz<!
-f<kqveigqb! h,je?! ngzqjg?! ogtkl! LequI?! gz<zig! lixqb! ngzqjg!
Ngqb! sqk<kqv! dVur<gt<! gim<sqh<hMk<kh<hm<Mt<te/! kqVg<Gxtqz<! -f<kqve<!
hx<xqb! Gxqh<Hl<?! kqVg<Gxt<! djv! uqtg<gk<kqz<! -f<kqve<! ngzqjg! hx<xqb!
Gxqh<HgTl<! gi{h<ohXgqe<xe/! Sh<hqvl{qb! LkzqbiI! )2968.2:57*!
ngzqjgbqe<!uvzix<xqje!‘ngzqjg!ou{<hi’!we<El<!F~zqz<!uqtg<Ggqe<xiI/!
fim<Mh<Hx!-zg<gqbr<gtqz<!ngzqjgbqe<!npG?!-f<kqveqe<!$p<s<sq?!ngzqjg!
gx<hqpk<kz<?! ogtkl! Lequiqe<! sihl<?! ngzqjg! gz<zikz<?! -f<kqve<!
dml<ohz<zil<! Obieqbikz<! Lkzieju! gjkgtigUl<! himz<gtigUl<!
upr<gh<ohXgqe<xe/! sqXgjk?! Hkqel<?! HKg<guqjk! Ngqb! -zg<gqb!
ucur<gtqZl<! ngzqjg! hx<xqb! fqgp<Ugt<! hkqU! osb<bh<! ohx<Xt<te/!
oh{<{qbl<! siIf<k! hkqUgtqZl<! ngzqjg! -ml<ohx<X?! HKjljbBl<!
Hvm<sqjbBl<! outqh<hMk<kh<! hjmh<hitIgTg<G! -e<xqbjlbik! lif<kvigk<!
kqgp<gqe<xiI/! hjmh<hitIgt<! kr<gt<! gVk<K! outqh<him<Mg<Gk<! okie<l!
lif<kIgjth<! hbe<hMk<kqg<! ogit<gqe<xeI/! gizf<OkiXl<! okie<ll<! -zg<gqbh<!
hjmh<Hgtqz<!okimIf<K!uf<K!ogi{<cVg<gqe<xK/!!
!
5/3/2/5/!%eq!!
! gl<hvilib{k<kqz<! nObik<kqbi! gi{<ml<! lf<kjv! $p<s<sqh<! hmzk<kqz<!
%eqbqe<! uvziXl<! G{Ll<! osiz<zh<hMgqe<xe/! %eqbqe<! -bx<ohbI! –!
lf<kjv/! LKG! %eqbqVf<kkiz<! ‘%eq’! we<El<! giv{h<ohbI! dVuibqx<X/!
-ut<! dmziz<! %e<! we<hokiM! dt<tk<kiZl<! %eqbiuit</! -viljeg<!
109 gim<Mg<Gh<! hkqeie<G! N{<Mgt<! nEh<Hukx<G! -uOt! &zgiv{liuit</!
nkeiz<kie<!gl<hI?!!
$p<f<k!kQuqje!fqgI!%eq23!
dt<tLl<!Ogicb!ogicbit<24!
we<X! %eqjbh<! hx<xqg<! Gxqh<hqMgqe<xiI/! fim<Mh<Hxuqbzqz<! “GcogMk<k! %eq”!
we<El<! osizujm! upr<gh<hMgqe<xK/! kQjlbqe<! uqjtUg<Gg<! %eq! yV!
okie<lg<!GxqbQmiGl</!!
!
! uiel<hic! Wpil<! -kpqz<! =OviM! klqpe<he<! “njmbitl<”! we<El<!
kjzh<hqz<!guqjk!hjmk<Kt<tiI/!-f<kg<!guqjkbqz<!%eq!we<El<!okie<lg<!
GxqbQM!uqei!uqjm!njlh<hqz<!jgbith<ohx<Xt<tK/!!
gif<kq!g{<m!-vil!vi\<bk<kqz<!!
%eq!d{<mi@!!
%eq!d{<M/!Neiz<!!
fqlqi<f<kqVh<hit<!.!biVg<Gl<!!
njmbitl<!okiqbiK/25!
%eq!njeuiqe<!g{<[g<Gl<!njmbitl<!okiquit</!Neiz<!%eqjbh<!Ohizg<!
G{Lt<tuIgt<?! fqlqIf<kqVh<hkiz<! njmbitl<! okiqukqz<jz/! -g<gizk<kqz<!
dxuicg<! ogMh<huIgTl<! dt<otie<X! juk<Kh<! Hxolie<X! OhShuIgTl<!
fz<zuIgjth<! Ohiz! fcg<Gl<! fbuR<sgIgTl<! nPg<giX! djmbuIgTl<!
Hxr<%XhuIgTl<! dVuk<kqz<! dbIuib<! .! dt<tk<kqz<! gQp<jlbib<!
-Vh<huIgTl<!lqGkqbib<!dt<teI/!%eqg<Gs<!sllieuIgt</!Neiz<!%eqjb!
njmbitl<! gi{<hKOhiz<?! -uIgjt! njmbitl<! gi{<hkiqK/! lgik<li!
gif<kqbcgjts<! Sm<Mg<! ogie<xuEl<! %eqkie</! Neiz<! gif<kqbcgjts<!
SMukx<Gl<! Le<H?! jgbqz<! Kh<hig<gq! Wf<kqs<! ose<x! nuje! biviZl<!
njmbitl<! g{<Mogit<t! -bzuqz<jz/! -h<hc! ne<XLkz<! okie<Xokim<M!
%eqjbh<! Ohizs<! osbz<hMhuIgt<! -e<El<! -Vg<gqe<xiIgt</! nkeiz<!
njeuVl<! ws<siqg<jgbig! -Vg<g! Ou{<Ml<! we<El<! uqpqh<H{Iju! -f<kg<!
guqjk!d{Ik<Kgqe<xK/!!
!
5/3/3/!lgihivkl<!
! le<eI! Gzl</! n{<{e<! kl<hq/! hr<gitqgTg<Gt<! Wx<hMl<! OhiI/!
ohixijlbiz<! uf<k! OhiI! hivkh<! OhiI! NGl</! kVle<?! uQle<?! nVs<See<?!
110 fGze<?! sgiOkue<! Ngqb! JuVl<! hR<shi{<muIgt</! KiqObikee<! Lkzie!
F~x<XuVl<! ogtvuIgt</! hR<sli! hikgr<gTt<! ye<X! $K/! ogtvuIgtqe<!
nPg<giXl<! sGeqbqe<! $Kl<! OsIf<K! hR<shi{<muIgjt! fiM?! fgvl<?!
djmjl?! dbqIjl! we! njek<jkBl<! ncjlbig<gqe/! Lkzqz<! $K!
oue<xK/! hqxG!$kqje!nxl<! oue<xK/! -0K!-bx<jg/! -kje!nIs<See<!
%x<xigh<!hivkqbiI!Gxqh<hqMgqe<xiI/!!
“kVlk<kqe<!uip<ukjes<!$K!gu<Ul<!!
kVll<lX!hcouz<Zl<” wElqbx<jg!!
lVlk<jk!fl<liOz!dzgr<!gx<Gl<!///26!
-g<gVk<kqx<gq{r<g?! $kqz<! Okix<x! hi{<muIgt<?! -Xkqbqz<! GVs<Osk<kqvh<!
Ohiiqz<!oux<xq!ohx<X!-pf<k!njek<jkBl<!ohx<xeI/!!
!
5/3/3/2/!Wgjzue<?!GVs<Osk<kqvl<!!
! lgihivkk<kqz<! uVl<! Oume<! Wgjzue</! lgihivkh<! OhiI! fmf<k!-ml<!
GVs<Osk<kqvl</! Wgzue<! we<huje! Wgjzue<! we<Xl<! njph<hI/! -ujeh<!
hx<xq!nhqkie!sqf<kil{q!hqe<uVliX!Gxqh<hqMgqe<xK/!!
!
! “WgzuEg<G! yV! ohbI! Wgjzue</! )-ue<*! yV! Oume<A! KOvi{I!
uqz<uqk<jk! sQmIgTg<Gg<! gx<hqh<hjk! nxqf<K! nuiqmk<Ks<! ose<X! nujv!
uqz<uqk<jk! gx<Xg<! ogiMg<Gl<hc! Ogm<g?! nuI! lXk<keI/! hqxG! Oume<!
KOvi{jvh<! Ohiz<! dVs<osb<K! nu<UVuk<jkg<! GVuigg<! ogi{<M!
uqz<uqk<jk!LPjlBr<!gx<Xg<!GVkm<sj{!ogiMg<gk<!KOvi{I!Le<H!ose<X!
Ogm<g?! nuI! -uEg<G! nf<k! uqk<jkgt<! hzqbikqVg<g! Ou{<c! -mK!
jgh<ohVuqvz<kjeg<! Ogm<meI/! nu<ujgOb! Oume<! ogiMk<Kh<! hivk!
Bk<kk<kqx<G! Lf<kqg<! gqV]<{eiz<! ogijz! osb<bh<hm<mee</! )-ue<*!
aqv{<bkEue<!Hk<ve<!Oume</”27!!
!
! hi{<muIgTg<Gl<! ogtvuIgTg<Gl<! GVs<Osk<kqvl<! we<El<! -mk<kqz<!
hkqoem<M! fim<gt<! OhiI! fjmohx<xK/! um-f<kqbiuqz<! svSukqbix<xr<gjvbqz<!
dt<t!DI!GVs<Osk<kqvl<!NGl</!
!
! WgjzuEl<!GVs<Osk<kqvLl<! hjmh<hitIgTg<Gk<! okie<lg<!%Xgtib<!
uqtr<Ggqe<xe/!uiel<hicg<!guqRIgt<!Hvm<sq!osb<huIgt<A!ohiKUjmjljbh<!
111 OhShuIgt</! kr<gt<! h{q! s&gh<h{q! we<X! njx%uz<! uqMh<huIgt</!
nuIgTt<!yVuvigqb!sqkl<hvfike<?!!
wr<Ogi!-Vg<gqx!!
GVju!fqjek<K!!
uqk<jkgt<!hpGl<!!
Wgjzue<gt<!!
wr<gtqz<!-r<Og!
wuVl<!-z<jz/!!
!
-f<ks<!s&gOl!!
wr<gt<!GV/!
Woee<xiz<!!
wr<gt<!!
GVOÑk<kqvLl<!!
-r<Ogkie<!-Vg<gqxK28!
we<X! guqjk! hjmk<Kt<tiI/! -f<kg<! guqjk! uiel<hic! 24! NuK! -kpqz<!
outquf<Kt<tK/! sLkibk<kqz<! fmg<Gl<! sqg<gz<gTl<! osbz<gTl<!
guqRIgTg<Gh<! himl<! gx<hqg<gqe<xe/! -f<ks<! sLkibh<! hqvs<sjegTg<gigg<!
guqRIgt<!OhiviMuKl<!-r<Ogkie</!!
!
5/4/!lvl<!!
! -f<kqbiuqz<! jsul<?! ju{ul<?! gi{ihk<kqbl<?! ogtlivl<?! sl{l<?!
ohtk<kl<?! sQg<gqbl<! weh<! hz! lkr<gt<! -Vg<gqe<xe/! lkr<gTg<Gl<!
okie<lr<gTg<Gl<! lqg!ofVr<gqb!okimIHgt<!dt<te/!lkr<gtqe<! hclr<gt<!
okie<ll<! wEl<! olipq! uibqzigg<! gVk<Kg<gjth<! Hzh<hMk<Kgqe<xe/!
okie<lk<jk! uqm<Muqm<M! lkk<jkk<! keqOb! hqiqk<Kh<! hiIg<g! -bziK/!
lg<gTg<G! yPg<gr<gjth<! Ohikqh<hK! lkl</! okie<ll<! lkk<kqe<! uibqzig!
lg<gTg<G!nch<hjm!fqbkqgjtg<!gx<hqg<gqe<xK/!!
!
! “dzgqz<! ohVl<hie<jlbie! okie<lr<gTg<Gk<! kjzue<!
Okjuh<hm<cVg<gqxie</! sikiv{ligk<! okie<lk<kqe<! kjzue<! WOki! yV!
HKjljb! fqXuqbueigOu! -Vh<hie</! HKjlgt<! hx<hz! ujggtqz<!
osb<bh<hMgqe<xe!///!
112 ! WS?!Hk<kI?!fhq?!ut<TuI!Ohie<OxiI!-h<HuqlQK!HkqbokiV!gizk<jkk<!
Okix<Xuqk<kuIgt<!nuIgt<!uip<ju!ym<ch<!hz!okie<lr<gt<!dVuibqe/!!
! lgiuQvI?! Hk<kI?! WS?! fhq! LkziOeiI! Hkqb! slbr<gjtk<!
Okix<Xuqk<keI?! nuIkl<! uip<juBl<! nuIgTg<Gh<! hqe<eIk<! Okie<xqb!
ncbiIgtqe<!uip<juBl<!ym<ch<!hx<hz!okie<lr<gt<!Okie<xqe/”29!
!
5/4/2/!jsul<!!
! jsu!lkk<kqe<!-jxue<!squohVlie<A!-jxuq!hiIukqOkuq/!-uIgtqe<!
Hkz<uIgt<! g{hkq?! LVge</! g{hkqjbg<! gmUtigg<! ogi{<m! lkl<!
gi{ihk<kqbl</! LVgjeg<! gmUtigg<! ogi{<m! lkl<! ogtlivl</!
squecbiIgTg<G! fibe<liIgt<! we<X! ohbI/! fibe<liIgt<! nVtqb!
hkqgr<gtqe<!okiGh<Hg<Gh<!he<eqV!kqVLjxgt<!we<X!ohbI/!!
!
! lgt<! nl<liuqml<! %XuKOhiz<! h/gr<jgogi{<mie<! guqjk!
hjmk<Kt<tiI/!uiel<hic!Wpil<!-kpqz<?!“sqz!jfzie<!geUgt<!wiqgqe<xe!///”!
we<El<! guqjkbqz<! hiIukq! hvlsqul<! hx<xqb! Gxqh<Hgt<! uVgqe<xe/! lgt<!
kibqml<!OhSl<OhiK?!!
weK!Gpf<jkg<G!
fQ!him<cbiGl<!OhikiuK!
nl<li"!
ne<Hg<Giqb!nh<hiuq!nl<li"!!
nuEg<G!
de<!gjkgOtKl<!osiz<ziOk"!!
!
gizl<!kf<k!
gjmsqh<!hqt<jtjbg<!
gm<Ms<OsiX!gm<cg<ogiMk<K!!
gim<M!upqOb!!
keqOb!nEh<hq!!
Nzlvk<kqecbqzue<!
K~r<gqeiz<!///!!
hiIukq!sgqkl<!
hvlsqul<!Okie<xqg<!!
113
Ogm<Gl<!uvr<gt<!!
Ogoteg<!Ogm<Gl<!
gjkgOtKl<!///!
osiz<ziOk!nl<li"!!
!
uiiqbj{k<K!!
uip<k<Kg<gt<!osiz<zqfQ!!
uip<f<kjks<!osiz<Z"!!
uip<g<jgjbs<!osiz<Z""!
!
deK!gjkgTl<!!
weK!geUgOtiM!!
wiqf<K!Lcbm<Ml<"2:!
we<X! kibqe<! uXjlg<! gjkjbObi?! hvlsqueqml<! hiIukq! Ogm<Gl<!
uvk<jkObi! ke<! hqt<jtbqml<! osiz<ziOk"! -juobz<zil<! we<OeiM! wiqf<K!
Lcbm<Ml<! we<X! lgt<! %Xgqe<xit</! GMl<hg<! gjkgOtiMl<! uip<g<jgbqe<!
-e<h! Ke<hr<gOtiMl<! lkLl<! lkl<! siIf<k! okie<lg<! %XgTl<! hqe<eqh<!
hqj{f<K!Ohsh<hMgqe<xe/!!
!
! uiel<hic! -VhkiuK! -kpqz<! “-K! wr<gt<! gqvill<”! we<El<!
kjzh<hqzie! guqjk! outquf<Kt<tK/! -kjeh<! hjmk<kuI! sqx<hq/! nuiqe<!
Diqz<!-Vg<Gl<!g{hkq!gmUjth<!hqe<uVliX!Gxqh<hqMgqe<xiI/!!
he<xqgt<!Olb<s<szqMl<!hg<gk<kqz<!!
dVg<Gjzf<K!!
gx<h,vl<!wiqf<okiqf<K!giqf<k!!
ohVs<sitq!Lgl<!hiIk<K!ofif<K!!
Nx<Xk<!Kjxbqz<!
fQvicg<!gjvObXl<!
=v!dzig<!g{<mhc!
uqpqk<kqVg<Gl<!uqfibgh<ohVlie</31!
!
114 5/4/3/!ju{ul<!
! ju{u!lkk<kqe<!-jxue<!kqVliz<A!-jxuq!kqVlgt</!kqVliz<!hk<K!
nukivr<gjt! wMk<Kt<tiI/! kqVlizqe<! ncbuIgt<! Np<uiIgt<! NuI/!
Np<uiIgt<!nVtqb!hiSvr<gTg<G!fizibqv!kqu<uqbh<! hqvhf<kl<! we<X!ohbI/!
kqVliZg<Gh<!hqck<k!likl<!liIgpq/!-f<k!likk<kqz<!Wgiksq!kqkqbe<X!kqVliz<!
Ogiuqz<gtqz<!hvlhkl<!osiIg<guisz<!kqxg<gh<hMl</!nkeiz<!juG{<m!Wgiksq!
we<X! ohbI/! hvlhk! osiIg<guisz<! kqxh<hjk! lg<gt<! g{<M! gtqk<kiz<!
osiIg<gl<!gqjmg<Gl<!we<x!fl<hqg<jg!d{<M/!
!
! hvlhkl<!we<hK!fe<jljbg<!Gxqg<Gl<!okie<lg<!GxqbQM!NGl</!Neiz<!
nPg<giX! djmbuIgt<! fe<jljb! njmb! uqmilz<! kMh<hiIgt</! fim<cz<!
hzI! kQb! w{<{r<gTme<! uip<gqe<xeI/! nuIgjth<! hx<xqBl<! nuIgjt!
npqg<g! Ou{<cBl<! sqx<hq! “sIh<h! bigl<! ///”! we<El<! kjzh<hqz<! guqjk!
hjmk<Kt<tiI/!-f<kg<!guqjk!uiel<hic!ye<hkil<!-kpqz<!outquf<Kt<tK/!!
!
! -f<kg<! guqjkbqz<! kQjlgjt! npqg<g! bigl<! osb<ukigUl<! nf<k!
bigk<kqx<Gs<! “si<h<h! bigl<”! we<X! ohbI! juk<kqVh<hkigUl<! %Xgqe<xiI/!
Lt<tqje!Lt<tqeiz<! wMh<hK! Ohiz?! fs<Sh<! hil<Hgjt!uqvm<m! sIh<h!bigl<!
osb<gqe<xiI/! guqjk! uQs<sigUl<! Le<eqjz! uqtqbigUl<! njlf<Kt<tK/!
kqVliz<! NkqOsme<! hil<hj{bqz<! ht<tqogi{<cVh<hiI! we<hKl<! -r<Gg<!
Gxqh<hqmk<kg<gK/!!
hvl!hkk<Ks<!
Osihie!hml<!
wr<gt<!Oksl<!!
nkqz<!
gm<mr<gt<!OkiXl<!!
fs<Sh<!hil<Hgt<!!
gik<Kg<!gqmg<gqe<xe"!
///! ///!
Hxh<hm<m!kqjsg<Og!!
uqvm<c!bcg<Gl<!!
-Vm<Mk<!kijvgOt"!!
hvlhkk<kqe<!!
115
kmk<jk!ljxg<Gl<!!
kqVm<Ms<!sijvgOt"!
////! ////!!
hvl!hkk<jk!
yVfiTl<!fQI!
njmf<kqm!uqmlim<CI"!!
///! ///!
wr<gt<!sIh<hbigk<kqz<!
////! ////!
nf<k!
wiqkpx<!sil<hzqz<!!
yV!
hvl!hkk<jk!!
wr<gt<!
sqvl!hkk<kiz<!!
sqV]<ch<Ohil<!!
fir<gt<"32!
! uiel<hicg<! guqRIgtqe<! Gvz<! wh<ohiPKl<! Yr<gqOb! yzqg<gqe<xK/!
-f<kqbk<! kqVfim<jmg<! gig<g! Ou{<Ml</! giuZg<G! -jmb,X! kVhuIgjt!
ncObiM!npqk<Kuqm!Ou{<Ml</!Ng<gh<h,Iulie!hz!hjmh<Hgjth<!hjmk<kqm!
Ou{<Ml<</! nux<jxh<! hjmg<Gl<! ohiXh<hqje! uiel<hicg<! guqRIgt<!
Wx<xqVg<gqxiIgt</! uQm<jmBl<! fim<jmBl<! nvjsBl<! fz<upqh<hMk<kq!
dbIk<kqMuOk!uiel<hicgtqe<!oki{<M!NGl</!!
!
5/4/4/!gqxqk<Kul<!!
! -ObSfikI! kl<! ogit<jggjts<! sQmIgtqe<! dXKj{ObiM!
lg<gtqmk<kqz<! hvh<hq! uf<kiI/! nuiqe<! ogit<jggtiz<! gqxqk<Ku! lkl<!
dVuibqx<X/! -ObSfikiqe<! -Xkqfit<! sqZjujbs<! Slk<kz<?! ncuir<Gkz<?!
ujsolipq!Ogm<mz<?!gz<uiiq!ljzg<Ge<xqz<!sqZjubqz<!njxbh<hMkz<!we<X!
hz!-e<ez<gjt!nEhuqk<kiZl<! -Xkqujv! kl<! ogit<jgbqzqVf<K! lixOu!
-z<jz/! kil<! lg<gTg<G! dhOksqk<kux<jxobz<zil<! kiOl! hm<Ml<!
nEhuqk<Kl<!osb<Kl<!gim<ceiI/!kl<jls<!sqZjubqz<!juk<K!jg?!giz<gtqz<!
N{qogi{<M!nck<Kg<!GVkq!hQxqm<M!uVgqe<xOhiKl<?!kl<!dbqjvh<!Ohig<Gl<!
116 nuIgTg<gig! N{<muiqml<?! “hqkiOu"! -uIgt<! nxqbilz<! osb<Bl<!
-h<hqjpjb!le<eqBl<?!fie<!le<xiMgqe<Oxe<”!we<X!Ou{<ceiI/!!
-e<eiosb<!kijv!yXk<kz<!nuIfi{!!
fe<ebl<!osb<K!uqmz<33!
we<El<!ut<TuI!uig<Gg<G!-{r<g!-ObSfikI!uip<f<kiI/!-uviz<!Okix<xl<!
ohx<x! gqxqk<Ku! lkk<kqz<! sqZju! we<hK! okie<lg<! GxqbQmiGl</! sqZjubqe<!
&zl<! hjmh<hiti<gt<!kr<gt<!gVk<Kg<gjth<! hjmh<Hgtqz<!d{Ik<Kgqe<xeI/!
gqxqk<Kuk<kqz<!sqZju!kjzbib!okie<lg<!GxqbQmib<k<!kqgp<gqe<xK/!!
!
! h/gr<jgogi{<mie<! uiel<hic! Nxil<! -kpqz<! “-jsbqe<! kqiqH! -c!
we<xiz<! ///@”! we<El<! kjzh<hqz<! guqjk! wPkqBt<tiI/! nf<kg<! guqjkbqz<!
dzgl<?! fiM?! s&gl<! weh<! hz! Ogi{r<gtqz<! OhSgqe<xiI/! nr<rel<!
OhSl<ohiPK?!!
wr<gjts<!osiz<zizch<huIgOt"!!
Ousqjbg<!gz<zizck<kuIgTg<G!!
WSgqxq^<K!-bl<hqb!olipqjbk<!!
kqVh<hqs<!osiz<gqOxil<"!!
! ‘dr<gtqz<!wuoviVuI!
hiul<!osb<bikuOvi!///’
nh<hc!!
wuOvEl<!-Vh<hiOvbieiz<!///!!
nuIgt<!wr<gjt!le<eqg<gm<Ml<"!
npUl<!kqvi{qbx<x!wl<jls<!
sqiqg<gs<!osiz<zq!
-jxujek<!kiqsqg<Gl<!!
-gOzigg<!gmUt<gOt"!!
fir<gt<!ovil<hUl<!Wjph<oh{<gt<!
wr<gTg<Gh<!
Hk<ke<Hvig<gOt!nukivr<gt<"34!
we<X! Lcg<gqe<xiI/! Wjph<! oh{<gtqe<! Ohs<Sg<G! -ObSfikiqe<! nxUjvjb!
Olx<Ogitigg<!gim<Mgqe<xiI/!!
!
117 ! Kg<gl<?! Ke<hl<?! Osigl<?! -e<ez<?! uVk<kl<?! uXjl?! ohiXjl! weh<!
hzux<xqx<Gh<! hz! Ogi{r<gtqz<! ‘sqZju’! we<El<! okie<lg<! GxqbQM!
hbe<hMk<kh<ohXgqe<xK/! klqpue<! uiel<hic! hk<kil<! -kpqz<! “de<jeh<!
hiIk<kkiz<! fqgp<f<kK”! we<El<! kjzh<hqzie! guqjkjbh<! hjmk<Kt<tiI/!
nkqz<! ‘sqZjujbk<! okie<lg<! GxqbQmib<h<! hbe<hMk<kqBt<tiI/’! -Vhk<jkf<K!
uiqgjtg<!ogi{<m!nf<kg<!guqjkbqz<!sqz!uiqgt<;!!
Lgg<geuqz<!-Vt<g{<M!!
ogi{<cVf<kib<!
-Vt<uqiqb!Kg<gl<!
dkqk<kK!deg<G!
!
sqZju!ujvf<khc!nPkib<!!
h,k<k!vg <̂br<gt<!!
de<je!ljxk<kKA!deg<G!
uqpqhck<kK!uXjl!!
Oukje!kqxf<kK!siU!nuzl<!///35!!
! gqxqk<kuIgt<! N{<muiqml<! Ou{<Mgqe<xohiPK! ‘hqki! Ske<! hiqSk<k!
Nuqbqe<!ohbviOz!Nole<’! )kf<jk!lge<!K~b!Nuqbqe<!ohbviOz!Nole<*!
we<X! osiz<uiIgt</! gqxqk<Kuk<kqz<! ‘hiu! le<eqh<H’! yV! Lg<gqblieK/!
u{<{fqzue<! “uqMkjz”! we<El<! guqjkjb! uiel<hic! hk<kil<! -kpqz<!
wPkqBt<tiI/! $p<fqjzbiz<! Gx<xl<! -jpk<kuIgt<! N{<muiqml<! le<eqh<H!
Ogm<hiIgt</! dmziz<! hius<! osbz<! osb<uKl<! dt<tk<kiz<! hius<osbz<!
osb<uKl<! d{<M/! Jl<Hze<gTl<! gt<tk<kelieju/! nkeiz<kie<! kqV&zI!
“gt<th<! Hzjef<Kl<”! we<gqxiI/! u{<{fqzue<! guqjkbqz<! dmz<! kuX!
-jpg<guqz<jz/!gm<Hze<!lm<Ml<!kuxqjpg<gqe<xK/!!
!
! g{<{gq?! fqOukqki! LkzieuIgt<! dmziZl<! dt<tk<kiZl<!
Jl<Hze<gtiZl<!K~b<jlbieuIgt<A!kQjl!osb<bikuIgt</!nuIgjth<!Ohiz!
njeuviZl<! uip! LcbiK/! -f<kh<! oh{<gt<! OhSuKOhiz<! guqRI!
wPKgqe<xiI/!!
hqkiOu!!
wr<gTg<G!le<eqBl<!
wr<gt<!dmz<gjt!!
118
nElkqg<gilz<!OhieiZl<!!
wr<gTjmb!g{<gjt!!
nElkqk<kqVg<gqOxil</!!
!
njugt<!.!!
uqhs<sivl<!osb<gqe<xe/!!
we<e!osb<uK@!!
fir<gt<!‘fqOukqki’g<gt<!nz<zOu!
wr<gt<!ge<eqjlgt<!-e<El<!
okimh<hmilzqVg<Gl<OhiK!!
g{<gt<!kqVm<Mk<kelib<!!
uqhsivl<!osb<KuqMgqe<xe/36!
! -ObSfikI! wtqb! uip<g<jgjb! Olx<ogi{<muI/! wz<Oziiqmk<kqZl<!
ne<Hl<! gVj{Bl<! gim<MhuI/! WjpgTg<gigUl<! hiuqgTg<gigUl<!
-vg<gh<hMhui</! NMgjtk<! K~g<gqg<! ogiR<sq! njmg<gzl<! kVhui</! Neiz<!
-e<jxg<G! nh<hch<hm<m! fhjv! dzgqz<! gi{! -bzuqz<jz/! NMgjtk<!
K~g<GgqxiIgt<!.!wjm!hiIk<K!uqjzg<G!uir<gq?!Nm<Mg<gxqjb!uqx<gqe<xiIgt</!
NMgt<! -ObSfikiqml<! Ou{<MuKOhiz<?! sqkl<hvfike<! “fir<gt<”! we<El<!
kjzh<hqz<!guqjk!hjmk<Kt<tiI/!-kqz<!-e<jxb!fim<M!fqjzjljb!NMgt<!
-ObSfikiqml<! %Xgqe<xe/! -f<kg<! guqjk! uiel<hic! hkqoem<mil<! -kpqz<!
outquf<Kt<tK/!!
kqjs!okiqbiK!!
kqiqf<K!ogi{<cVg<gqOxil<!!
-jxui"!wr<gTg<G!
fz<z!Olb<h<hjeg<!ogiM!!
nue<!yV!Sk<k!
jsueigUl<!-Vg<gm<Ml<!!
!
wr<gjtg<!!
jggtqz<!K~g<gqg<ogi{<m!!
gi<k<kOv"!!
!
119
dl<jlh<!OhizOu!!
gsih<Hg<!givEl<!!
wr<gjtk<!K~g<gqg<ogit<gqxie<!
wkx<Gk<!okiqBli@!!
njmg<gzl<!ogiMh<hkx<gz<z!!
wr<gtqe<!!
wjmg<gel<!hiIh<hkx<gig!!
!
jggtqz<!!
K~g<gqg<!ogit<hujvobz<zil<!
gIk<kvigOu!gVkqMl<!!
wr<gt<!Gm<cgTg<Gl<!!
N{<muOv"!!
wh<OhiK!fQ!!
Hk<kqjb!!
upr<GuiObi@37!
-f<kg<! guqjkbqz<! -ObSfikI?! Nm<Mg<Gm<c?! njmg<gzl<! we<hju!
okie<lr<gt<! NGl</! -e<jxg<G! bijvBl<! fl<h! Lcbuqz<jz/! LkqbuIgOt!
Wlix<xh<hMl<OhiK?! nEhul<! -z<zik! -jtRIgt<! wtqkqz<!
Wlix<xh<hMgqe<xiIgt</!OuzqOb!hbqjv!Olb<f<k!gjkbib<?!NM!utIh<huOe!–!
Olb<h<huOe! Nm<cjeg<! ogie<X! kqe<gqxiIgt</! njsul<! d{<huIgt<!
lqGkqbigquqm<miIgt</! -f<ks<! osb<kqgt<! GxqbQM! NGl</! hqxVg<Gk<! kQr<G!
uqjtuqh<OhiIgOt! -e<X! lqGkqbigg<! gi{h<hMgqe<xiIgt</! -f<k! uquvl<!
okiqbilz<!-jtRIgt<!uqtl<hvr<gtqZl<!Nml<hvr<gtqZl<!uQ{<!oszUgtqZl<!
gizk<jkg<! gpqg<gqe<xiIgt</! -uIgjt! njmg<gzlig! Wx<Xg<ogit<t! biVl<!
Le<uVukqz<jz/! -uIgTg<Gh<! ohx<OxiIgTl<! NsqiqbIgTl<! sie<OxiIgTl<!
fz<zxquqjeh<! HGk<k! Ou{<Ml</! wz<OzijvBl<! fl<hq! wf<ks<! osbzqZl<! =Mhm!
Lcbuqz<jz/!fz<zuIgjth<!Ohiz<!fch<huIgOt!fim<cz<!lqGkqbib<!dt<teI!
weh<!he<Lgg<!gVk<Kg<gjtBl<!-f<kk<!okie<l!dk<kqbqe<!&zl<!sqkl<hvfike<!
outqh<hMk<Kgqe<xiI/!
!
! =me<! Okim<mk<kqz<! Nkil<?! Wuit<! Okie<xq?! dzgqz<! lg<gtqel<!
dx<hk<kqbiekig! uquqzqbl<! %Xgqe<xK/! nxqUg<! geqjbk<! kqe<eg<! %miK!
120 we<x! gm<mjtjb! lQxqk<! kqe<xkiz<! -f<k! uqjtU! d{<miekig! Oukl<!
%Xgqe<xK/!-f<fqgp<uqjek<!okie<l!fqgp<uigg<!ogi{<M!Sf<kvl<?!!
=me<!Okim<mk<kqOz!!
fie<!hxqk<Kg<!ogiMk<k!
nxqUg<!geqjbk<!kqe<xKl<!!
we<jeOb!
ncjlbig<gqeiOb!///!
fqjeuqVg<gqxki@38!
we<X!uqeUgqe<xiI/!-r<rel<!=me<!Okim<ml<?!nxqUg<geq?!-ObSfikI?!sqZju?!
Nm<Mg<Gm<c?! -e<ee! gqxqk<Ku! lkk<kqe<! okie<lr<gtig!dt<te/! -ux<jxh<!
hjmh<hiti<gt<! kl<! gVKOgiTg<Gk<! kGf<kuiX! njlk<Kg<ogi{<M?!
gVk<Kg<gjt!outqh<hMk<Kgqe<xeI/!-e<h!fqgp<Ugt<?!GxqbQMgt<!-ux<jxuqmk<!
Ke<hlie?! Osiglie! fqgp<UgOt! njeuiqe<! dt<tk<jk! =Ig<gg<! %cbju/!
gqxqk<Ku! lkk<kqz<! sqZjug<! GxqbQM! okie<lk<kqje! d{Ik<Kl<! sqxf<k!
%xiGl</! -e<jxg<G! dzgqz<! ohVl<hizie! fiMgtqz<! gqxqk<Kuk<kqe<!
ogit<jggt<!hvuqBt<te/!!
!
5/4/5/!-^<zil<!!
! LglK! fhqgt<! fibgl<! Okix<Xuqk<k! - <̂zil<! slbl<! nvHfiMgtqz<!
OgiOzis<Sgqe<xK/! hqx! fiMgtqZl<! - <̂zil<! lkk<kqeI! uip<f<K! uVgqe<xeI/!
NmuI!weqz<!kjzbqz<!okih<hq?!lgtqI!weqz<!Lgk<kqx<Gh<!hIki!we!-^<zil<!
lkk<kqeIg<G! wek<! keq! njmbitr<gt<! -Vg<gqe<xe/! wf<k! yV! lkk<kqZl<!
gi{h<hMl<!sqxh<H!njmbitr<gt<!sqxf<k!nxqUg<!%Ijlbiejubig!-Vg<Gl</!
lkr<gtqz<! %xh<hMl<! uqkqLjx?! hpg<gupg<gr<gt<! njek<Kl<! nxquqbz<!
uqkqLjxgTg<G!dm<hm<mjubiGl</!-^<zil<!lkk<kqe<!ljxF~z<!kqVg<Gi<Ne<!
NGl</!
!
! “Nz<ohIm<!Je<^<Ce<!nxquqbz<!nz<zik!lkl<!Lmujeh<!Ohie<xkiGl</!
lkl<!-z<zik!nxquqbz<!GVmjeh<!Ohie<xkiGl<!weg<!%xqbqVg<gqxiI!///!
! Gi<Ne<! nxquqbzqe<! F~z<! (Book of Science)! nz<z/! lixig?! nK!
nk<kim<sqgtqe<! F~z<! (Book of Signs)! NGl</! -f<k! F~zqz<! Nxibqvk<kqx<Gl<!
nkqglie! nk<kim<sqgt<! nkiuK! Nbk<Kgt<! -Vg<gqe<xe/! nux<Xt<!
121 Wxg<Gjxb! Yvibqvl<! Nbk<Kt<! nxquqboziM! okimIHjmbkib<k<!
kqgPgqe<xe/”39!!
!
! Okjubqz<zikux<jxh<! hiIg<gg<! %miK/! gix<xqz<! dt<t! liS! fisqbqz<!
Hgg<%miK/! -ju! Ohie<x! hz! giv{r<gTg<gig! - <̂zil<! lkh<! oh{<gt<!
‘hi<ki’! n{qf<K! ogit<Tgqe<xiIgt</! -f<kh<! ‘hi<ki’! yV! okie<lg<! GxqbQM!
NGl</! hjmh<hitqgt<! kl<! gVk<kqje! outqh<hMk<k! hz<OuX! dk<kqgjtg<!
jgbiTgqe<xiIgt</! uvkm<sj{! Lkzie! giv{r<gtiz<! hikqg<gh<hm<m!
oh{<gt<?! okVuqz<! dziUl<! uizqhIgTg<Gh<! ‘hi<ki’! Ohims<! osiz<gqxiIgt</!
‘hi<ki’! OhiM<l<! hizqek<jkOb! lix<xqg<! gim<MgqxiI! u{<{fqzue</! ‘uqMkjz’!
we<El<!guqjkbqe<!yV!hGkq;!!
fir<gt<!!
ytqf<kqVf<K!hiI<k<k!!
\e<ezcgt<!!
gr<jg!fQviz<!gPUl<!Le<hig!!
okVuqz<!Ohigqx!!
uizqhIgTg<G!!
Lcf<kiz<!
‘hi<ki’!OhiMr<gt<!.!!
wr<gTg<gz<z/3:!
-f<kg<! guqjk! uiel<hic! hk<kil<! -kpqz<! uf<Kt<tK/! ‘hi<ki’! Ohim!
Ou{<cbuIgt<! - <̂zilqbh<! oh{<gt</! Neiz<! -r<Gh<! ohiKfqjzbqz<! lkl<!
siIf<kqvilz<! oh{<gt<! OhSgqxiIgt</! ‘uQm<cEt<! -Vf<K! ogi{<M! se<ez<!
upqbigk<! okVuqz<! hiIk<Okil</! uvkm<sj{! hqvs<sjebiz<! wr<gt<! Ofig<gl<!
fqjxOuxuqz<jz/!-eq!wr<gjt!wf<k!N{<gTl<! hiIg<gg<!%miKA!fir<gTl<!
uizqhI! Lgk<jkh<! hiIg<gg<! %miK’! we<X! hikqg<gh<hm<m! oh{<gt<! ouG{<M!
OhSgqe<xiIgt</! -f<k! djvbimzqbl<! hjmh<hitiqe<! sqf<kjek<! kqxeqz<!
Okie<xqbkiGl</!!
!
5/4/6/!ohtk<kl<!
! ogtkl! Hk<kviz<! dVuig<gh<ohx<x! lkl<! ohtk<kl<! NGl</! sikqh<!
hiGhiM?! uIg<gh<! hiGhiM! Lkzie! leqkh<! Ohkr<gjt! ngx<Xukx<gigh<!
hiMhm<muI! Hk<kI/! -f<kqbk<! kqVfim<cz<! dVuie! -f<k! lkl<! dzogr<Gl<!
122 hvuqBt<tK/! liuQve<! nozg<si{<mi<! kl<! -Xkqg<! gizk<kqz<! Hk<k! lkk<jkk<!
kPuqeiI/!dbqIgjtg<! ogiz<zg<! %miK?! Ohvijs! -Vg<gg<! %miK?!N[l<!
oh{<[l<! sllieuI! Lkzie! fz<zxr<gjth<! Ohikqk<kuI! Hk<kI! ohVlie</!
-uVg<G!Riel<!gqjmk<k!-ml<!Ohikqlvk<kc/!Ohikq!lvl<!we<hK!klqpgk<kqz<!
gi{h<ohXl<!nvs!lvliGl</!-K!lvr<gTt<!nvse</!-f<kg<!gVk<K!nxquqbz<!
Ljxh<hch<!ohiVf<kq!uVgqe<xK/!!
!
! Hk<kjvBl<! nuI! Riel<! ohx<x! Ohikq! lvk<kcjbBl<! hjmh<hitIgt<!
okie<lr<gtigg<! %xq?! nux<xqe<! &zl<! hz! gVk<Kg<gjt!
outqh<hMk<kqBt<teI/! OgiuzEg<Gl<! likuqg<Gl<! hqxf<k! l{qOlgjz!
l{qhz<zuk<!kQuqz<!Hk<khQcjgjb!uzl<!uf<K!u{r<gq!Lx<hqxuqjb!nxqf<K!
ogi{<mit</! Hk<kIhqvieqe<! kqVuVtiz<! OgiLgqh<! ohib<jgbqz<! nm<sbh<!
hik<kqvk<kqjeh<! ohx<xit</! -KOhie<x! fqgp<Ugjtk<! kx<giz! fqgp<UgOtiM!
hjmh<hitIgt<! yh<hqm<M?! hjmh<hitIgt<! kir<gt<! %x! uVl<! gVk<kqje! –!
GMl<hk<jk!–!fim<jm!–!nvsqbjz!uqtg<gqs<!osz<gqe<xeI/!!
!
! uiel<hic! Jf<kil<! -kpqz<! “hQcjg”! we<El<! kjzh<hqz<!
h/gr<jgogi{<mie<! guqjk! hjmk<Kt<tiI/! nf<kg<! guqjk! )64! uiqgjtg<!
ogi{<mK*!hqe<uVliX;!!
fie<!!
Ohie!hqxuqbqz<!!
fivib{!fill<!\hqg<Gl<!
kiqk<kqveib<k<kie<!
kqiqf<kqVh<Ohe</!!
!
-jk!
fjvk<kqVg<Gl<!lbqiqe<!
fjvg<Gt<Ot!dbqjv!
uiqk<kqVg<Gl<!kf<jkbqe<!
uvziX!!
dXkqh<hMk<Kl</!!
////! ////!!
weg<G!wkx<G!!
123
Lg<gizl<!d{Ik<Kl<!
Hk<khQcjg!kiqsel<@!!
uVr<gizl<!gim<Ml<!
ujgbqoziV!hQcjg!!
-Vg<gqxOki@!!
!
fie<!hck<k!!
hm<mh<!hch<H!!
oum<cbigilz<!!
OujzbqzlIujkg<!
gim<mg<%cbkib<!///!!
!
nXhKgtqe<!-Xkqbqz<!!
ne<ximl<!hiMhMl<!!
nVjlk<!kf<jk!
gm<mib!Yb<UohXujkg<!!
gim<mg<!%cbkib<!///!
!
hm<ceqbqe<xq!!
wz<OziVl<!sllib<!!
-Vg<Gl<!dzgk<jk!!
-bl<hg<!%cbkib<!///!
!
g{<gim<sq!sijzbqOz!!
gmUtIg<gqml<!kf<K!!
g{g<gx<x!%m<ml<!
g{<M!gtqh<hjkg<!!
gim<mg<!%cbkib<!///!
!
uVr<gizl<!gim<Ml<!
ujgbqoziV!hQcjg!!
-Vg<gqxOki@!!
!
124
fiuzf<!kQuqeqz<!!
fie<!njzgqe<Oxe<!!
nXhK!Ogic!!
NHk<kqvIgOtiM"!!
likuqg<Gh<!hqxg<gik!
l{qOlgjzgOtiM"!!
//////////////////////////////////////////41!
! h/gr<jgogi{<mie<! -f<kqbk<! kqVfim<cz<! )2:82! Nl<! N{<Mg<!
g{g<Gh<hc*! dt<t! nXhKOgic! lg<gTg<Gl<! wkqIgizl<! fz<zkib<!
njlf<kqVg<gqxki@! we<hjkg<! gim<Ml<! hQcjgjbk<! OkMgqe<xiI/! -kx<gig!
fiuzf<kQU!Lkzie!hz!-mr<gtqZl<!njzf<K!OkMgqe<xiI/!keg<gig!lm<Ml<!
-z<zilz<! lg<gt<! njeuVl<! hcg<g! Ou{<Ml<?! hck<kuIgt<!
Oujzuib<h<hqjeh<! ohx<Xs<! sllig! uipOu{<Ml<?! lg<gtqmk<kqz<! hsqhm<ceq!
-Vg<gg<%mi/! -f<k! fz<z! fqjzjlgt<! uVr<gizk<kqz<! gqjmg<Gli@!
hjpjljbg<! gim<ch<! hbeqz<jz/! wkqIgizk<jkg<! gim<ceiz<! nkx<Ogx<hk<!
kl<jl!–!kl<!uip<uqje!njlk<Kg<!ogit<tzil<!we<El<!hz!gVk<Kg<gjth<!
‘hQcjg’! we<El<! okie<ll<! &zl<! uqtg<Ggqe<xiI/! nXhK! Ogic! lg<gjtBl<!
NHk<kqvIgtib<s<! Sm<Mgqe<xiI/! -f<kqbh<! oh{<gt<! njeujvBl<!
‘l{qOlgjzgt<’!we<gqxiI/!-Kkie<!slk<Kul<A!-Kkie<!ohiKUjmjl/!!
!
! -zr<jgbqz<! sqr<gtIgt<! hzVl<! ohtk<k! slbk<jks<! siIf<kuIgt<A!
Hk<kI! ohVlieqe<! ogit<jggjtg<! ogi{<muIgt</! Neiz<! dbqIgjtg<!
ogiz<zg<! %miKA! sikq?! -eh<! hiGhiM! hiIg<gg<%miK! we<El<! Hk<kiqe<!
ogit<jgjbh<! hqe<hx<xuqz<jz/! -kjeg<! g{<M! ouG{<omPf<k! sqx<hq?! “-eq!
fie<!HbziOue<”!we<El<!kjzh<hqz<!guqjk!wPkqBt<tiI/!!
Hk<kI!hqvieqe<!
osiz<Zg<Gs<!slikqgm<ch<!!
hz<Zg<G!uqpi!wMg<Gl<!
ghm!lgiul<sg<!GVliIgt<!///!
!
klqp<!dmz<lQK!!
Kh<hig<gqg<!gk<kq!Ljegtiz<!!
sqr<gt!vk<ks<!sqk<kqvl<!!
125
wPkqg<!gtqg<Gl<!!
N{u!vi[ul<!///!
/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!!
sIuikqgivr<gt<!!
klg<Gk<!kiOl!wPkqg<ogit<Tl<!!
gjmsq!nk<kqbibl<!!
/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/42!
-f<ks<! sqx<hqbqe<! guqjk! uiel<hic! -Vhk<kqv{<miuK! -kpqz<!
outquf<Kt<tK/!!
!
5/5/!Hvi{l<!!
! “kqiqsr<Guqe<! Hk<kqve<!niqs<sf<kqve</! -ue<! uV{je!Ofig<gq! weg<Gh<!
Hk<kqvsf<kkq! OfVOlz<! ng<Glvjeh<! HV]h<! hSuigg<! ogi{<M! de<jek<!
kqVh<kq! osb<uqg<gqOxe<! weg<! %xq! nu<ujg! dkqk<k! Glvje!
bigh<hSuig<gikqVf<kee</! kf<jkbqe<! osb<jgB{If<k! Glve<! ke<eqjz!
d{If<K!hbf<K!gim<cz<!usqk<kee</!hqe<H!uV{e<!niqs<sf<kqvEg<G!lOgikv!
OfiB{<mig<gqee</! kf<jk! lOgikvk<kiz<! hQcg<gh<hMgqxioee! uqeUx<X!
fgIOfig<gq! uVjgbqz<?! -f<kqveiz<! uek<kqz<! NX! uV]l<! kjmhm<M! nf<k!
Nxil<! uV]g<! gjmsqbqz<! nsqgqvke<! we<hueqmk<kqz<! Ses<Oshje!
uqjzbigg<!ogi{<M!kf<jkg<G!ntqk<kee</!!
!
! nvse<! Sfs<Oshje! bigh<hSuig<gq! uV{jek<! kqVh<kq! osb<uqk<kee</!
Glve<! kf<jkjb! uV{Ogihk<kiZ{<migqb! lOgikvk<kqeqe<Xl<! fQg<gqee</!
yVLjx! okb<u! sjhbqz<! -f<kqve<?! OkuI! Lkzqbujv! Ofig<gqh<! h,lqbqz<!
sk<kqbf<! kuxikue<! biI! weg<! Ogm<jgbqz<! usqm<mI! wPf<K! we<! sQme<!
niqs<sf<kqve<!sk<kqbf<!kuxikue<!we<xeI/!-jkg<!Ogm<m!uqs<uilqk<kqvI!wPf<K!
nh<hcbibqe<!nujeh<! ohib<! osiz<uqg<gqOxe<! we<X! shkR<! osb<K! ogi{<M!
h,lqbqz<! nObik<kqjbbjmf<K! niqs<sf<kqvjeg<! g{<M! bigR<! osb<b! Ou{<c!
lqGf<k! kqvuqbr<Ogm<M! nue<! ogiMg<gh<ohx<X! nueqmOl! nkje! juk<Ks<!
ose<xeI/!!
!
! sqzfit<! gpqk<K! uqs<uilqk<kqvI! niqs<sf<kqveqml<! uf<K! nue<! h,lqjbk<!
kieligh<! ohx<Xk<! kil<! Le<H! juk<Kh<! Ohie! ohiVtqEg<Gl<! um<c! Ogm<g!
126 nvse<!gisqfgI!ose<X!ljeuqjbBl<!GlvjeBl<!OukqbEg<G!uqx<Xk<!kie<!
HjzbEg<G! ncjlh<hm<M! uqs<uilqk<kqvVg<Gh<! ohiVjt! ntqk<kee</!
uqs<uilqk<kqvI! nvsje! -u<utU! Ke<hh<hMk<kqBl<! ohib<! hqxuijl! g{<M!
niqs<sf<kqve<!Glve<!kI<h<jh!ogib<Br<gijzbqz<!hil<H!gck<kqxg<gs<!osb<keI/!
-kjeg<! %ms<! ose<x! hqt<jtgtiz<! nxqf<k! kib<! ke<! Glvjek<! Okcs<!
ose<X! lbiek<kqm<Mk<! ke<! HV]jeg<! g{<M?! nue<! osix<hc! Oukqbiqml<!
=lg<gme<! ohx<Xuvk<! kqVl<Hjgbqz<! lijzbiz<! uqs<uilqk<kqvI! gisqbvse<!
Hk<kqvjeg<! ogijz! osb<uqk<K! upqbqz<! wxqbs<osb<keI/! nf<kg<! gisqbvse<!
Hk<kqvjek<! ke<! Hk<kqvoee<X!d{If<K! hiIg<jgbqz<! nvse<! giuzI! gMgqh<!
hqt<jtjbg<! ogie<xioteh<! hqck<Ks<! ose<xeI/! nvse<! -utqmk<Kg<!
Gx<xg<Gxq! gi{ikqVf<Kl<! lf<kqiqbI! osiz<ziz<! ogijz! osb<uqg<gg<!
gm<mjtbqm<mee</! giuzI! sf<kqvlkqjbg<! ogijz!osb<Bl<hc!niqs<sf<kqveqml<!
ogiMg<g! niqs<sf<kqve<! oum<ms<! osz<Zjgbqz<! OkuI! LkzqObiI! $pk<!
kqiq&Ik<kqgt<! kiqsel<! kf<K! Glvje! wPh<hq! niqs<sf<kqvEg<G! Ou{<cb!
uvltqk<K!uqs<uilqk<kqve<!shkh<hc!nueK!khk<jkBl<!uir<gqk<!kf<keI/”43!!
!
! dzgqz<! ohib<! osiz<zik! yOv! fhI! niqs<sf<kqve</! ohib<! osiz<zik!
giv{k<kqx<gigk<! ke<! ljeuq! sf<kqvlkq?! lge<! Ozigqkise<?! fiM?! fgvl<?!
ohiVt<!we!njek<jkBl<!niqs<sf<kqve<!-pf<kiI/!ke<!lge<!-xf<kohiPKl<!
gmjlbqz<! kuxilz<?! giz<h{l<! Lpk<K{<M! ohx<Xg<ogi{<m! hqxG! nmg<gl<!
osb<b! nElkqk<kiI/! -f<kk<! okie<l! fqgp<uqje! niqs<sf<kqv! Hvi{k<kqz<!
uQvguqvibI!uqtg<Ggqe<xiI/!-kjes<!Sm<cg<!gim<cb!uiel<hicg<!guqRI!sqhq?!
“fuQe!niqs<sf<kqvI”!we<El<!kjzh<hqz<!guqjk!hjmk<Kt<tiI/!!
giz<!h{Ll<!!
Lpk<!K{<Ml<!!
ogiMk<kiz<kie<!!
niqs<sf<kqve<!!
Smjzbqz<!!
-ml<!gqjmg<Gl</!!
!Lpk<!K{<M!
gqjmk<kiz<!OhiKl<!!
sqjk!OljmbqZl<!Wxs<!!
127
osf<klqp<g<!guqgt<!!
!g<b,!!
uiqjsbqz<!!
kbiI"44!
! -zus! Oum<c! OsjzgTg<G! lg<gt<! Njsh<hMgqe<xeI/! nux<xqjeh<!
ohXl<OhiK! %m<mlib<! -Vf<kiz<?! uiqjsbqz<! fqx<hKl<! %m<mofiqszqz<!
-chiMgTg<G! -jmbqz<! fSr<gq! -xh<hKl<! d{<M/! 2:81gtqz<! -KOhie<x!
fqgp<U! lKjvbqz<! fjmohx<Xt<tK/! guqRIgTl<! Oljmh<Ohs<sitIgTl<!
Oljmbqz<!uQx<xqVg<Gl<OhiK!nuIgTg<Gh<!ohie<eijm!OhiIk<KuKl<! sqxh<Hs<!
osb<uKl<! lvH/! Neiz<! sqz! osf<klqp<g<! guqRIgt<! Lpk<K{<Mg<gigOu!
Oljmbqz<! Wx! uiqjsbqz<! gik<kqVg<gqxiIgt</! -f<fqjzjbs<!
Sm<cg<gim<Mukx<gigs<!sqhq!Olx<hc!guqjkjbh<!hjmk<Kt<tiI/!!
! “-f<kqbh<! hvi{r<gtqz<! kqVliz<! nukivr<gt<! wz<zi! olipqgtqZl<!
Ohsh<hMgqe<xe/”45!!
!
5/6/!gih<hqbl<!!
! gih<hqbr<gtqz<! uVl<! gjkgt<! njek<Kl<! hzF~X! N{<Mgt<!
lg<gtqmk<kqz<! uib<olipqg<! gjkgtigh<! Ohsh<hm<M?! hqe<eOv! wPk<K! ucul<!
ohx<Xt<te/! nkeiz<! gih<hqbr<gtqz<! uVl<! fqgp<UgTl<! lqgh<!
hjpjlbieju/! weOu! -ju! okie<lr<gtigk<! kqgp<gqe<xe/! sqzh<hkqgivl<?!
l{qOlgjz?! sQugsqf<kil{q?! ujtbihkq?! G{<mzOgsq?! bOsikv! giuqbl<?!
$til{q?!fQzOgsq?!dkbGliv!giuqbl<!weg<!%xh<hMl<!gih<hqbr<gtqz<!uVl<!
fqgp<Ugt<?!gjkgt<!njek<Kl<!okie<lr<gt<!NGl</!!
!
5/6/2/!sqzh<hkqgivl<!!
! gq/hq/-v{<mil<! F~x<xi{<cz<! -tr<Ogiucgt<! sqzh<hkqgivk<jk!
-bx<xqeiI/! klqpqz<! hjmk<k!Lkz<! gih<hqbl<!-KuiGl</! Ogiuze<?! g{<{gq!
uvzix<xqjeg<!gih<hqbligh<!hjmk<Kt<tiI/!Neiz<!Ogiuze<?!g{<{gq!gjk!
gih<hqb! ucul<! ohXukx<G! Le<Oh?! lg<gtiz<! osuqupqs<! osb<kqbigg<!
%xh<hm<M! uf<Kt<te/! nke<! kig<gl<?! Ogiuze<?! g{<{gq! hx<xqb! Gxqh<Hgt<!
sr<g!-zg<gqbr<gtqz<!gi{h<hMgqe<xe/!!
128
wiqlVt<!Our<jg!gmUt<!gig<Gl<!
GVgiI!gpeqbqe<!-kjek<!kir<gt<!!
Wkq!zite<!gujz!gux<x!!
yVLjz!nXk<k!kqVli!d{<{q46!
we<X!fx<xqj{!lVke<!-tfigeiI!himzqz<!Gxqh<hqmh<hMl<!fqgp<U!sqzh<hkqgiv!
g{<{gqbqe<!osbZme<!ye<Xhm<Mt<tK/!
! sqzh<hkqgivk<kqz<! -kqgisk<! okie<lr<gt<! dujl! &zLl<! yh<hqMkz<!
&zLl<! Sm<cg<gim<mh<hMgqe<xe/! “Ogiuze<! HgiI! fgjv! uqm<M! fQr<gq! lKjv!
lifgIg<Gg<! g{<{gqBme<! Hxh<hMgqxie</! nue<! HgiI! fgvl<! uqm<M! fQr<gqb!
fqjzbqz<?! nf<fgvl<! -viljeh<! hqiqf<k! nObik<kq! Ohizh<! ohiqKl<! gzr<gq!
uVf<kqbkigg<!ogtsqge<!we<El<!nf<k{e<!%x<xqz<!juk<K?!!
ohVlge<!Wuz<!nz<zK!bir<g[l<!!
nvOs!kR<sl<we<!xVr<gie<!njmf<k!!
nVf<kqxz<!hqiqf<k!nObik<kq!Ohizh<!!
ohVl<ohbI!&K~I!ohVl<OhK!dx<xKl<47!
we<X! -tr<Ogi! hiMuI/! nKlm<Mlqe<xq! lKjv! Ofig<gqh<! Hxh<hm<m! Ogiuze<?!
upqbqx<!gUf<kqbcgt<!we<El<!sl{k<Kxuqjbg<!g{<M!u{r<Ggqxie</!keg<G!
OfIf<k! kir<g! y{<{ik<! Kbvfqjzjbg<! Gxqh<hqm<M! uVf<Kgqxie</! nu<ulbl<!
gUf<kqbcgt<! ‘-vile<! kf<jkbqe<! gm<mjth<hc! giegl<! ose<X?! nr<Og! ke<!
ljeuqbigqb! sQjkbqje! -viu{e<! $p<s<sqbiz<! -pf<K! uVf<kq! hzujg!
-e<ez<gjt! njmf<kee<! we<xiz<! fl<Ohiz<! leqkIgt<! wl<lif<kqvl<’! we<X!
Dpqe<!uzqjljb!yh<hqm<M!Ofig<gq?!!
kijk!Wuzqz<!liKme<!Ohigqg<!!
gikzq!fQr<gg<!gMf<KbI!dpf<Okie<!
Ouk!Lkz<uI!hbf<Okie<!we<hK!
fQ!nxqf<kqjzObi@!ofMolipq!ne<Oxi@48!!
we<X! %xqbK?! okie<lg<%X! HGk<kh<hm<m! Ogiuze<! g{<{gq! gjkg<Gk<!
okie<lk<kqz<! kjzsqxf<K! -f<kqbi! LPjlBl<! uqtr<Gl<! -vilib{k<jkh<!
hbe<hMk<Kkz<! sqxf<k! -zg<gqb! dk<kq/! sqzh<hkqgivk<jk! -f<kqbk<!
okie<lr<gtqe<! uiqjsbqz<! OsIg<g! -tr<Ogiucgt<! kqm<mlqm<miI! we<hjk!
uR<sqg<!gi{<mk<kqz<!gi{zil</”49!!
!
129 ! uiel<hicg<! guqRIgTl<! sqzh<hkqgivk<kqz<! uVl<! Ogiuze<?! g{<{gq?!
likuq?! gx<H!Lkzie!okie<lr<gjts<! Sm<cg<gim<ck<! kr<gtqe<! gVk<Kg<Ogx<h!
nux<jxh<!hbe<hMk<kqBt<teI/!!
!
! “ngh<hm<Mg<! ogi{<mibi! ///@”! we<El<! guqjkbqz<! Sf<kvl<?! g{<{gq!
Ogiuzeqml<!OhSuKOhiz<!yV!hGkqjbh<!hjmk<Kt<tiI/!!
likuqbqml<!!
osz<ul<!-pf<K!!
hi{<cbeqml<!!
we<!sqzl<OhiM!!
de<!dbqjvBl<!
yV!Osvh<!hxqogiMk<K!
lKjvk<!okVg<gtqz<!
we<jek<!kjzuqiq!Ogizlig!!
njzb!juk<kiOb!///"4:!
Ogiuzje!wkqi<k<Kh<!Ohsikut<!sqzh<hkqgivg<!g{<{gq/!Neiz<!Sf<kvl<!%Xl<!
g{<{gq! Ogiuzje! wkqi<k<Kh<! OhSgqxit</! ‘gx<H’! we<xiOz! g{<{gqkie<!
sie<xib<g<!%xh<hMgqe<xit</!Neiz</! gx<hqje!-pf<K!kqVl{!l{<mhl<! gm<m!
giS! =m<Ml<! oh{<@! nf<kk<! kqVl{! l{<mhk<kqx<Gg<! “g{<{gq! gz<bi{!
l{<mhl<”! we<X! ohbI! $m<Mgqe<xit</! -kjek<! klqpe<he<?! “fqkq! u$z<”!
we<El<!kjzh<hqzie!guqjkbqz<!%Xgqe<xiI/!!
We<!fQ!!
uqhs<sivl<!osb<gqxib<@!!
we<X!Ogm<meI!nujt/!!
nut<?!!
g{<{gq!gz<bi{!l{<mhg<!
gm<cmk<kqx<G!
fqkq!u$z<!osb<gqOxe<!we<xit</51!!
! uvkm<sj{biz<! kqVl{l<! Ngik! oh{<gt<! dt<teI/! nui<gt<!
gizolz<zil<! ge<eqh<! oh{<gtib<! -Vh<hKl<!d{<M?! leqk! ubqx<Xg<Gh<! hsq!
Wx<hMuK!-bz<HOhiz<?!leqkh<!hVur<gTG<G!Wx<hh<!hzujgh<!hsqgt<!Wx<hMl</!
nux<Xt<! ye<X! gikz<! d{IU/! dbqiqer<gTg<Gh<! hiZ{IU! we<hK!
-bz<h,g<gl<!NGl</!nK!-z<jzobe<xiz<kie<!Gjxhimigg<!gVkh<hMl</!hVu!
130 ubkqz<! hiZ{IUg<Gk<! kqVl{l<! osb<K! ogit<tiuqm<miz<?! gt<tk<kelib<s<!
osbz<hmk<! K~{<Ml</! -g<gVk<kqje! jlbligg<! ogi{<M?! u{<{fqzue<!
“uqMkjz”!we<El<!guqjkbqz<!yV!hGkqjb?!!
seikeqgOt!!
sQg<gqvlib<!wr<gjt!!
uvkm<sj{bqzqVf<K!!
uqMkjz!osb<Br<gt<!!
-z<jzObz<!
fir<gt<!!
likuqbigh<!OhigqOxil<!
uip<k<k!Ou{<mil<!!
Sl<li!-Vr<gt<52!
we<X! ge<eqh<! oh{<gt<! OhSuKOhiz<! hjmk<Kt<tiI/! ge<eqh<! oh{<gTg<Gk<!
kqVl{l<!Ngik!fqjzbqz<!ubK!Lkqi<U!njmf<K!nuIgt<!LkqIge<eqgtib<!
liXgqe<xeI/! nuIgtqz<! yVsiviI! N{<! s&gl<lQK! ouXh<H! ogit<uKl<!
d{<M/! sqzI! sLkibs<! Osjugtqz<! =MhMgqe<xeI/! sqzI! dzgqjeOb!
ouXk<K! uip<gqe<xeI/! sqzI! Ousqgtigh<! OhigUl<! uqVl<Hgqe<xeI/! -r<G!
-Xkqbqz<!%xh<hm<m!oh{<gt<!OhSuKOhiz<!Olx<Gxqk<k!guqjk!njlf<Kt<tK/!
-kx<G!‘likuq’!we<El<!okie<lh<!hik<kqvk<jkg<!jgbiTgqe<xiI/!!
!
5/7/!fim<Mh<Hxg<!%Xgt<!!
! dzg! olipqgTt<! -zg<gqbl<?! Ogim<hiM! LkziejuBl<?! lg<gtqe<!
hpg<gupg<gr<gt<?! kqVuqpig<gt<?! smr<Ggt<! LkziejuBl<! lg<gtqe<!
uip<g<jgbqzqVf<Kl<! uib<olipqbqzqVf<Kl<! Okie<xqbjubiGl</! lqgh<!
hpr<gizk<kqz<! Okie<xqb! uib<olipq! -zg<gqbl<?! hpg<gupg<gl<! Lkzieju!
gizf<OkiXl<!osl<jlbigq?!-h<OhiK!sqxf<K!uqtr<Ggqe<xe/!kizim<M?!yh<hiiq?!
smr<G?!kqVuqpi?!lf<kqvl<?!Gzokb<u!upqhiM?!kQlqkqk<kz<!weh<!hz!fim<Mh<Hxg<!
%Xgjt!uiel<hicg<!guqRIgt<!jgbi{<M!guqjkgjth<!hjmk<Kt<teI/!!
!
5/7/2/!kizim<M!!
! kiz<! ! Nm<M! ! kizim<M/! kiz<! .! fig<G/! fig<gqje! Nm<ch<! hiMl<!
him<cx<Gk<! kizim<M! we<X!ohbI/!-K!Gpf<jkgjt!dxr<g!jug<gh<! hiMl<!
him<miGl</! -f<kh<! him<M! lg<gtqel<! Okie<xqb! gizk<kqzqVf<K! -Vf<K!
131 uVgqe<xK/! -K! okie<ll<! NGl</! -f<kk<! okie<l! dk<kqjbh<! hbe<hMk<kq!
uiel<hicg<!guqRIgt<!kr<gt<!gVk<kqjeBl<!sLkibs<! sqg<gz<gjtBl<! hkqU!
osb<gqe<xeI/! -uIgt<! K~r<gik! kizim<M?! -e<El<! yV! kizim<M?! kizim<M!
Ogm<gik! okim<cz<gt<?! r<r<gi! ///! we<El<! kjzh<Hgtqz<! guqjkgjth<!
hjmk<Kt<teI/!
dkqIgqe<x!!
-e<jxb!sVGgTg<gib<!!
dVgqb!u{<{Ol!!
ktqIg<gqe<x!fijtg<!ogiPf<Kgm<G!!
fie<!kizim<cjsg<g!-bz<gqxK53!
we<X!Okevse<!hiMgqe<xiI/!uiel<hic!-kp<!he<eqv{<cz<!outquf<k!“K~r<gik!
kizim<M”!we<El<!kjzh<hqz<!guqjk!hjmk<k!sg<kqg<gez<?!uXjl!fqjzjb!
dVg<glib<h<!hiMgqe<xiI/!!
NviOvi!NviOvi!!
nl<li!fQ!g{<[xr<G!!
DOv!dxr<Gjgbqz<!!
deg<oge<e!g{<uqpqh<H@!!
!
Ov]e<!gjm!uiqjs!!
fqe<Xfqe<X!giz<gt<!v{<Ml<!!
Dsqbib<g<!Gk<Kkl<li!!
dk<klqOb!g{<[xr<G/!!
!
Dsqbib<g<!Gk<kqcEl<!.!de<!
dzIf<k!ubqx<Xg<Gg<!
gisqz<jz!hiz<uir<g!–!we<!
g{<{gqOb!g{<[xr<G"!!
!
niqsq!djz!ogikqg<Gl<!.!de<!
nl<li!lel<!ogikqg<Gl<!!
nl<li!lel<!ogikqk<kiz<!
ngqzolz<zil<!kQh<hqcg<Gl<"!!
!
132
ngqzolz<zil<!kQh<hqck<Ok!!
ng<gqeqbib<h<!hx<Xjgbqz<!.!de<!
YVbqVl<!OugiOki@!!
dk<klqOb!g{<[xr<G"!!
!
uxm<cbqOz!kQ!&m<m!!
uieolz<zil<!ofVh<ohiqBl<!
uiek<kqOz!wiqofVh<H!–!de<!!
ubqx<xqZli!wiqgqxK@!!
/////! ! /////!!
hsqk<kiz<!nP!lgOt"!!
hisl<!uf<kiz<!fie<!nPOue<!
hisk<kiz<!kib<!nPkiz<!
hiuqgtqe<!uip<upqBl<!
!
hiuqgtqe<!uip<upqf<kiz<!
hs<jsubz<!gkqIhqcg<Gl<!
hs<jsubz<!sqiqg<g!jug<g!–!we<!!
hig<gqbOl!g{<!utvib<"!!
////////////////////////////////////////!
ht<tqh<!hch<ohkx<G!–!deg<Gh<!
him<omkx<G@!gjk!wkx<G@!!
him<M!gjk!Ogzq!wz<zil<!!
hig<gqbuie<!uip<uqEg<G/!
!
him<M!gjk!osie<eiZl<!.!de<!!
hsq!nmr<gh<!Ohiukqz<jz!!
him<c!gjk!osiz<gqOxe<!.!fQ!!
hsqlxf<K!K~r<gquqM"54!
! oh{<Gpf<jkjbh<! ohx<x! kib<! ke<! GMl<hl<?! uXjl?! ubqx<oxiqs<sz<?!
hsqg<Gl<! ubqX?! oh{<{qe<! g{<{Qi<! kQbujv! npqk<kz<! Lkzie! hz!
-e<ez<gTg<G! Ntigq?! nux<jxobz<zil<! ke<! Gpf<jkbqml<! %XuKOhiz<!
kizim<M!njlf<Kt<tK/!ohiKuigk<!kib<!uXjl!fqjzbqz<!-Vf<kiZl<?!ke<!
133 Gpf<jkjbs<! osz<u! lgOe?! visiOu?! le<euOv?! dk<klOv! we<Xl<!
osz<ulgOt?! visik<kqOb?! vi{qOb?! dk<klqOb?! Gzg<ogiPf<Ok! we<Xl<!
dbIk<kqg<! %xqk<! kizim<MuKkie<! lvH/! Neiz<! fim<ce<! fqjzjljb!
lg<gtqmk<kqz<!%Xukx<Gg<!guqRI!kibqe<!kizim<cjeh<!hbe<hMk<kqg<!guqjk!
hjmg<gqe<xiI/! uXjlbqZl<! hsqbqZl<! -Vg<Gl<! Gpf<jkg<Gk<! K~g<gl<! uviK/!
nkeiz<kie<!guqRI!“K~r<gik!kizim<M”!we<X!kjzh<hqm<Mt<tiI/!!
!
! yVhg<gl<!uXjl!uim<MgqxK/!lx<oxiV!hg<gl<!Dpz<!ohVg<ogMg<gqxK/!
gXh<H! h{l<! Nml<hvs<! osbz<gjts<! osb<gqxK/! GXg<G! upqbqz<! ohiVt<!
=m<MhuIgt<?! fim<Mg<G! uiq! gm<Mukqz<jz/! uVlie! uiqg<g{g<gqz<! OsIg<gik!
gXh<Hh<! h{k<kiz<! yu<ouiVuVl<! le<ejvh<! Ohiz<! kqgp<gqe<xiI/! djpk<k!
h{k<kqjeg<!ogi{<M!YvtU!dbIU!-Vg<Gl</!gXh<Hh<!h{k<kqeiz<!ntUg<G!
lQxqb! dbIU! -Vg<Gl</! fim<cz<! fmg<Gl<! Dpziz<! jgb,m<miz<! ohVGl<!
gXh<Hh<! h{k<kqx<G! “-e<El<! yV! kizim<M”! we<El<! guqjkjbk<! Okevse<!
hjmk<Kt<tiI/! -K! uiel<hic! hkqe<&e<xiuK! -kpqz<! outquf<Kt<tK/!
guqRI!gXh<Hh<!h{k<kqjeg<!“gV’leq’Ob” we<X!uqtqg<gqe<xiI/!‘gXh<H!Money’!
we<hkjeOb!gV!‘leq’!we<gqxiI/!!
g{<O{!gV‘leq’Ob!
g{<[xr<G!g{<[xr<G"!!
w{<[g<G!nmr<gik!
-Vh<OhfQ!g{<[xr<G"!
!
=se<!Kj{bqVg<g!!
wl<ohVlie<!hiIk<kqVg<g!///!
h,js!bjxbqzz<Ozi!
HjkbOz!de<hMg<jg"!!
!
ohiPK!Lgr<g{<miz<!
ohiz<zir<G!OfVlq{<[!!
LPK!LjebqVm<cz<!!
&c!juk<Kg<!gik<kqVg<Ogil<"!!
!
134
uQkqg<G!fQ!uf<ki!!
ouGser<g!g{<[h<hMl</!!
fQkq!Bjeg<g{<mi!!
fQm<_v!ligquqMl</!!
!
him<mitq!liIgtK!!
hs<jsvk<kh<!hiz<uir<gq!!
Dm<c!utIg<jgbqOz!!
deg<oge<e!uf<kkc@!!
!
fQ!Ogm<mi!!
!
kr<gk<kiz<!hq^<Ogik<K"!!
miziqeiz<!Ozizig<G"!
lr<gik!juvl{q"!!
deg<G!
l^<kieib<!outqs<svg<G"!!
!
uVlie!uiq!nk<jk!
lihiuq!ogit<tqg<g{<!!
wiqb!djeh<hiIk<kit<!
we<xi!gzr<Ggqxib<@!!
!
nujts<!siqosb<uiI!
Ncm<mI!de<lile<!
gujz!obiKg<gquqm<Mg<!
g{<&c!fQBxr<G!–!!
!
de<Ejmb!visir<gl<"!!
de<Ejmb!lf<kqiqliI"!!
we<e!GjxBeg<G@!!
wh<hcObi!g{<[xr<G!///55!
135 ! osz<uf<kIgt<! sqzIg<Gg<! Gpf<jkh<OhX! -z<jz/! Wjpgt<! hzIg<G!
w{<{x<x! Gpf<jkgt<! hqxg<gqe<xeI/! kqVl{l<! Ne! Yvi{<Mg<Gt<!
gIh<hligiuqm<miz<?!nf<kh<!oh{<j{h<!hzI!WSuiIgt<A!lzc!we<hiIgt</!nOk!
Ofvk<kqz<!kqVl{l<!Ngilz<!gt<tg<gikzqz<!nz<zK!gtUg<!gikzqz<!=MhMl<!
oh{<gt<!gIh<hligquqMgqe<xeI/!ge<eqh<oh{<!gIh<hh<oh{<{igqg<!Gpf<jkjbh<!
ohx<X?! Gh<jhk<! okim<cz<gtqz<! Ohim<Ms<! osz<gqe<xeI/! nf<kg<! Gh<jhk<!
okim<cbqz<!gqmg<Gl<!Gpf<jk!hsqbiz<!nPl<A!K~g<glqe<xq!nPl<OhiK!kizim<M!
hiMuiI! biVlqz<jz/! -f<fqgp<uqje! L/Olk<ki! “kizim<Mg<! Ogm<gik!
okim<cz<gt<”! we<El<! kjzh<hqz<! guqjk! wPkqBt<tiI/! -K! uiel<hic!
hk<kiuK!-kpqz<!outquf<Kt<tK/!!
geUgtqe<!F~zqjpbiz<!!
jgvim<jm!Sx<Xgqxit<!
kr<gk<!KgotMk<Kk<!
kjvolPgqh<!hiMgqxit<!!
/!/!/!/!!/!/!/!/!/!!
uizqhk<kqe<!h,r<ogik<kqz<!!
uVmz<gt<!
kizqgm<Ml<!Le<Hsqz!!
kiqser<gt<!!
Ouzqbqzi!-tfqzk<kqz<!
uqjkgt<!///!
/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!
he<eQI!lvg<gqjtbqz<!
his-jz!dkqIgizl<!
g{<{QI!lvubqx<xqz<!
gIh<h-jz!dkbl<!/!/!/!
!
oux<xqjzbiz<!dkm<M!!
uqtql<jhs<!squh<hig<gqk<!!
Kh<hquqm<Mh<!Ohie!!
KjvlgOei!uvuqz<jz!!
!
136
likg<!giz{<mI!!
liIhqz<!gel<Gjxb!!
liK!l{qubqx<xqz<!
lcbqz<!gel<utv!!
/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!!
ke<ef<!keqh<hxju!!
kib<h<hxju!bigquqm!/!/!/!!
Nz!lvk<kcbqz<!
NTbvg<!Gh<jhk<okim<c!!
NTbvg<!Gh<jhk<okim<c!!
nPgqe<x!Gvz<Ogm<Gl<!/!/!/!
/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!!
K~g<gq!utIh<hkx<Gk<!!
Okit<hzk<jk!fl<hilz<!
K~g<gq!wxqf<Kuqm<m!
Kbvg<!Gvz<Ogm<Gl<"56!
-u<uiX! fim<M! fmh<H?! lg<gt<! hqvs<sjegjtg<! %Xukx<Gk<! kizim<Ml<! yV!
okie<l!dk<kqbib<h<!hbe<hMgqe<xK/!!
!
5/7/3/!smr<G!!
! leqk! uip<g<jgbqz<! hqxh<H! Lkz<! -xh<H! ujv! hz<OuX! smr<Ggt<!
osb<bh<hm<M!uVgqe<xe/!hqxf<k!Gpf<jkg<Gh<!hkqeixil<!fitqz<!H{<{qbkies<!
smr<G?!sqXhqt<jth<!hVuk<kqz<!gik{qs<!smr<G?!oh{<hqt<jtbqe<!h,h<H!fQvim<M!
uqpis<! smr<G?! kqVl{s<! smr<G?! gIh<hqeqh<! oh{<gTg<G! ujtbz<! gih<H!
uqpis<! smr<G?! Gpf<jk! hqxf<k! hqxG! ohbI$m<M! uqpi?! )LKjlbqz<*!
-xf<kuIgTg<G! =ls<smr<G! weh<! hz! smr<Ggt<! lg<gtqe<! uip<uqbOziM!
ye<xqg<! gi{h<ohXgqe<xe/! -f<ks<! smr<G! Ljxgt<! -ek<kqx<G! -el<!
OuXhMgqe<xe/!-f<ks<! smr<G!Ljxgt<!njek<Kl<! lg<gtqe<! fl<hqg<jgjbs<!
siIf<kjubiGl</!!
!
! “leqke<! hqxh<H! Lkz<! -xh<H! ujv! hzuqk! fl<hqg<jggjtg<!
ogi{<cVg<gg<! gi{<gqOxil</! fl<hqg<jggOt! leqk! uip<uqje! -bg<Ggqe<xe!
we<X! %Xltuqx<G! nue<! uip<uqz<! ohVl<! hr<G! ugqh<hjkBl<! gi{<gqOxil</!
137 leqk! uip<uqz<! fl<hqg<jggt<! we<X! Okie<xqe! we<X! kqm<mum<mligg<! %x!
LcbiK/! weqEl<?! lg<gtqe<! fjmLjx! uip<uqz<! -f<fl<hqg<jggt<! okimIf<K!
uVujkg<! %If<K! Ofig<gqe<! -kjes<! sLkibh<! h{<him<ce<! d{Is<sqg<!
%Xgtqe<! okiGkq! weg<! %xzil</! giv{! giiqbk<! okimIHgTg<G!dm<hm<Ms<!
sie<Xgtqe<! uibqzig! fqXu! Lcujk! fl<hqg<jg! we<Xl<?! sie<Xgtqe<!
nch<hjmbqOzi?! giv{! giiqbk<! okimIhqe<! uibqzigOui! uqtg<g!
Lcbikux<jx! &mfl<hqg<jg! we<Xl<! ujgh<hMk<KuI/! leqk! uip<uqz<!
gi{h<hMl<! fl<hqg<jggTg<Gg<! giv{l<!nxqbLcgqe<xK/! keqleqk! fl<hqg<jg!
gizh<Ohig<gqz<! sLkib! fl<hqg<jgbig! lix<xl<! ohXuK{<M”57! we<X!
S/sg<kqOuz<!%XuKl<!-u{<!Ofig<gk<kg<gkiGl</!!
!
! Out<uq!utIk<kz<?!kQ!lqkqk<kz<?!lf<kqvl<!YKkz<!Lkzie!smr<Ggjt!
uiel<hicg<! guqRIgt<! kr<gt<! gVk<Kh<Ohig<gqx<G! Wx<h! njlk<Kg<! guqjk!
hjmk<Kt<teI/! ng<gqeqHk<kqve<! “sk<kqbOlu! \bOk”! we<El<! kjzh<hqz<!
guqjk! hjmk<Kt<tiI/! -f<kg<! guqjk! uiel<hic! &e<xil<! -kpqz<!
outquf<Kt<tK/!-kqz<!yV!hGkq!uVliX/!!
Y!///!wr<gt<!kibgOl"!!
ng<gqeq!utIk<K!!
NGkqjbs<!osiiqf<K!!
lf<kqvr<gt<!yzqg<g!!
Out<uqjbk<!okimIg"!!
lieqml<!ouz<Zl<!!
uvk<jkg<!ogit<g"!
sk<kqbl<!ouz<Zl<!!
fqk<kqbl<!ohXg"!!
!
Y!///!wr<gt<!hivkOl"!!
nf<k!uvk<kqe<!lgqjlbqeiz<!
gizLl<!s&gLl<!%ch<!!
hqxh<hqg<Gl<!
fqjxh<!hqvsu!lpjzgt<?!!
l{<{qe<!h,g<gtib<!!
h,lqbqe<!hqvtbr<gtib<!
138
gizk<kqe<!usf<kr<gtib<!!
nukiqg<Gl<!ujvbqz<!///!!
!
ng<gqeq!utIk<K!!
NGkqjbs<!osiiqf<K!!
lf<kqvr<gt<!yzqg<g!!
Out<uqjbk<!okim///m///I///g///58!
-r<rel<! fim<ce<! utIs<sqg<G! uvl<! Ogm<hkx<Gg<%m?! uiel<hicg<! guqRIgt<!
ng<gqeq! utIk<kz<?! ofb<! osiiqkz<?! lf<kqvl<! YKkz<! Lkzie! smr<Ggjtg<!
Gxqh<hqMgqe<xeI/! -f<ks<! smr<G! Ljxgt<! wh<ohiPK! biviz<! okimr<gh<!
ohx<xe! we<hkje! nxqb! -bzuqz<jz/! nf<k! ntuqx<G! -kqgisg<!
gizk<kqx<Gl<! Le<Oh! -f<ks<! smr<G! Ljxgt<! -Vh<hkiz<! -ux<jxk<!
okie<lr<gtigg<!Gxqh<hqmzil</!!
!
5/8/!okiGh<Hjv!!
! -f<kqbiuqz<! -kqgisl<! Lkzieju! okie<lr<gtiGl</! lg<gtqel<!
Okie<xq!Lf<F~X!lqz<zqbe<!N{<Mgt<!Ngqe<xe/!lg<gtqel<!Okie<xqb!nf<kg<!
gizk<kqzqVf<K! lg<gt<! uip<uqbzqz<! gi{h<hMl<! nk<kjeBl<! okie<lr<gt<!
NGl</! leqk! -el<! Okie<Xukx<G! Le<Oh! Okie<xqb! hR<sh,kr<gTl<!
okie<lr<gt<! NGl</! -ux<jxh<! hjmh<hitIgt<! kr<gt<! hjmh<Hgtqz<!
Ofvcbigg<! %xq! uqtg<Gue! GjxuiGl<A! ljxLglig! nz<zK! Gxqh<Hh<!
ohiVjt! d{Ik<kOu! guqRIgt<! lqGkqbigh<! hbe<hMk<Kgqe<xeI/! sqz!
okie<l!fqgp<Ugjtg<!guqRIgTt<!sqzI!OgzqBl<!osb<gqe<xeI/!!
!
! uiel<hicg<!guqRIgt<!OfIh<ohiVtqZl<!GxqbQm<Mh<!ohiVtqZl<!nr<gkh<!
ohiVtqZl<! okie<lg<! %Xgjtg<! jgbi{<Mt<teI/! fiM?! nvsqbz<?! oki{<M?!
Dpz<?! GMl<hl<?! uXjl?! gz<uq?! Oujzbqz<zik<! kq{<mim<ml<?! uvkm<sj{?!
LkqIge<eq?! gx<H?! uqjzlgtqI?! Ohizq! leqkI?! ogit<jgg<Gl<! osbZg<Gl<!
OuXhiM?!oh{<{qbl<?!uIg<gh<!Ohivim<ml<?!slkIll<?!ohiKUjmjl?!kizim<M?!
yh<hiiq?! smr<G! weh<! hz! ohiV{<jlgt<! okie<lr<gtqe<! &zl<!
uqtg<gh<ohx<Xt<te/!!
!
139 ! -vile<?! sQjk?! %eq?! Wgjzue<?! GVs<Osk<kqvl<?! sque<?! hiIukq?!
uqfibgI?!LVge<?!hvlhkl<?!sqZju?!Hk<khQcjg?!Ogiuze<?!g{<{gq?!likuq!
wek<!okie<lg<!gjklif<kIgt<!uiel<hicg<!guqRIgtiz<!Gxqh<hqmh<hm<Mt<teI/!
nuIgt<&zl<!hz!fmh<hqbz<!d{<jlgjt!outqh<hMk<kqBt<teI/!!
140
sie<ox{<!uqtg<gl<!
!
2/ g/hR<sir<gl<?!okie<lk<!kqxeib<U?!h/52/!!
3/ fe<E~z<?!39/!
4/ O\/lR<StiOkuq!)oki/N/*?!uiel<hicg<!guqjkgt<?!h/4:/!!
5/ OlzK/?!h/76/!
6/ nhqkie!sqf<kil{q?!hg</2249.224:/!!
7/ O\/lR<StiOkuq!)oki/N/*?!uiel<hicg<!guqjkgt<?!h/295/!!
8/ OlzK/?!h/78/!
9/ OlzK/?!h/231/!
:/ OlzK/?!h/274/!
21/ OlzK/?!h/271/!
22/ OlzK/?!hg</243.244/!!
23/ gl<hvilib{l<?!nObik<kqbi!gi{<ml<?!252/!
24/ OlzK/?!285/!
25/ O\/lR<StiOkuq!)oki/N/*?!uiel<hicg<!guqjkgt<?!h/275/!
26/ hivkqbiI!guqjkgt<!)hiR<sizq!shkl<*?!h/629/!
27/ nhqkie!sqf<kil{q?!h/38:/!
28/ O\/lR<StiOkuq!)oki/N/*?!uiel<hicg<!guqjkgt<?!h/353/!!
29/ gkqI/lgiOkue<?!okie<ll<?!h/34/!!
2:/ O\/lR<StiOkuq!)oki/N/*?!uiel<hicg<!guqjkgt<?!hg</241.242/!
31/ OlzK/?!h/488/!
32/ OlzK/?!hg</2:1.2:3/!!
33/ kqVg<Gxt<!425/!
34/ O\/lR<StiOkuq!)oki/N/*?!uiel<hicg<!guqjkgt<?!h/222/!
35/ OlzK/?!h/313/!
36/ OlzK/?!h/31:/!
37/ OlzK/?!h/453/!
38/ OlzK/?!h/78/!
39/ \igqI!fibg<?!uqR<Rie!ytqbqz<!GINEl<!jhhqTl<?!hg</58.59/!!
3:/ O\/lR<StiOkuq!)oki/N/*?!uiel<hicg<!guqjkgt<?!h/31:/!
41/ OlzK/?!hg</93.94/!!
42/ OlzK/?!h/545/!!
141 43/ nhqkie!sqf<kil{q?!hg</97.98/!!
44/ O\/lR<StiOkuq!)oki/N/*?!uiel<hicg<!guqjkgt<?!h/447/!
45/ gkqI/lgiOkue<?!okie<ll<?!h/5:/!!
46/ fx<xqj{?!327;7.:/!!
47/ sqzh<hkqgivl<?!24;74.77/!!
48/ OlzK/?!25;57.5:/!!
49/ gkqI/lgiOkue<?!okie<ll<?!hg</91.92/!!
4:/ O\/lR<StiOkuq!)oki/N/*?!uiel<hicg<!guqjkgt<?!h/78/!
51/ OlzK/?!h/275/!
52/ OlzK/?!h/321/!
53/ OlzK/?!h/336/!
54/ OlzK/?!hg</338.339/!
55/ OlzK/?!hg</357.358/!!
56/ OlzK/?!hg</315.316/!!
57/ S/sg<kqOuz<?!fim<Mh<Hx!-bz<!Nb<U?!h/29:/!!
58/ O\/lR<StiOkuq!)oki/N/*?!uiel<hicg<!guqjkgt<?!h/65/!
!
-bz<!6!
uiel<hicg<!guqjkk<!okie<lLl<!!gVk<kqbz<!outqh<hiMl<!
!
!
6/1/!LgUjv!!
uiel<hicg<!guqjkgtqz<!hz!okie<lr<gt<!Gxqh<hqmh<hm<Mt<te/!gix<X?!
ljp?! wiqljz?! figl<?! gVme<?! fqzi?!-f<kqve<?!ngzqjg?! hqVl<li?! kQ?! gx<H?!
lkl<?! smr<G?! kizim<M?! fqxl<?! niqs<sf<kqve<! weh<! hz! okie<lg<! %Xgt<!
uiel<hicg<!guqjkgtqz<!gim<mh<hm<Mt<te/!-ju!yu<ouie<Xl<!OfIh<ohiVjt!
d{Ik<KuOkiM! hqxqokiV! ohiVjtBl<! d{Ik<Kgqe<xK/! uiel<hicg<!
guqjkk<!okie<lg<!%Xgt<!slki<ll<?!Hvm<sq?!HKjl!hjmk<kz<?!ohiKUjmjl?!
ncjljb! ypqk<kz<?! uXjljb! ypqk<kz<?! kQ{<mijljb! ypqk<kz<?! Ohizq!
leqkIgjth<!Hml<Ohim<Mg<!gim<Mkz<?!dbIU!kip<uqje!ypqk<kz<!we<El<!hz!
gVk<kqbz<gjt!outqh<hMk<Kgqe<xe/!-ux<jx!-f<k!-bz<!uqtg<Ggqe<xK/!!
!
6/2/!uiel<hicbqe<!Ofig<gl<!!
! uiel<hicbqe<!nch<hjm!Ofig<gl<!fim<cz<!uXjljb!ypqg<g!Ou{<Ml<A!
slki<ll<! Oh{h<hm! Ou{<Ml<A! ohiKUjmjl! lzv! Ou{<Ml<A! Lkzitqk<Kul<!
ypqg<gh<hm! Ou{<Ml<A! nkx<gigh<! hz! Hvm<sqgjts<! osb<b! Ou{<Ml<!
we<heuiGl</! sLkibk<kqz<! gi{h<ohXl<! -pquie! osbz<gjt! ngx<x!
Ou{<Ml</! nkx<Gg<! guqjkjbg<! gVuqbigg<! ogit<t! Ou{<Ml</! -kx<gig!
njlg<gh<ohx<x!uiel<hic!-bg<gl<!guqjkgjth<!hjmk<Kt<teI/!uiel<hicg<!
guqRIgTg<G! lqgh<ohVl<! Nx<xz<! dt<te! we<X! %Xgqe<xeI/! =OviM!
klqpe<he<?!“fil<”!we<El<!kjzh<hqz<!guqjk!hjmk<Kt<tiI/!nkqz<?!!
uiek<jkg<!gQxqOb!!
jugjxgt<!hxqk<okMh<Ohil<"!!
Olieg<!GvZg<Gt<!!
Lpr<Gl<!-c!uqjkh<Ohil<"!!
$iqbjeg<!g{<gtiz<!
Sm<Mh<!ohiSg<GuKl<!!
NIg<Gl<!gmzjzjb!!
nmg<GuKl<!flg<gqbZl<"!!
143
flK!sqxgjsh<hqz<!
Riz!fvl<hkqVl<"!!
/!/!/!/!! /!/!/!/!
fiolz<zil<!/!/!/!
hib<f<K!osz<Zl<!!
nR<sik!!
nlqz!fkqbqe<!!
njzh<hjmgt<"2!
we<gqxiI/! -f<kg<! guqjk! uiel<hic! &e<xil<! -kpqz<! outquf<Kt<tK/!
uiel<hic! -bg<gk<kqeI! gl<b,eqsl<! we<X! %xh<hMl<! ohiKUjmjl!
-bg<gk<jks<! siIf<kuIgt</! -uIgtqe<! guqjkgjt!Nvib<f<kiz<! ohVl<hiZl<!
slkIlLl<!ohiKUjmjlBOl!outqh<hMl</!!
ht<tLl<!OlMl<!!
slh<hm!Ou{<Moleqz<!!
wf<kg<!g{<{e<!!
-r<Gh<!hqxf<kiz<!!
kIl!vi\<bl<!!
^<kihqg<gh<hMl<@3!
we<X! h/gr<jgogi{<mie<! uqei! wPh<Hgqe<xiI/! -r<Gg<! ‘g{<{e<’! we<El<!
okie<lh<! hik<kqvl<! hbe<hMk<kh<hm<Mt<tK/! -f<k! uqeiuqx<G! uqjmbtqh<hK!
Ohiz<?!OlM!ht<tl<!fQr<gqmh<!Hvm<sq!uVl<!we<X!wpqz<Lkz<ue<!%xq?!nkeiz<!
hic!NMukigg<!%Xgqe<xiI/!
uvh<OhiGl<!Osi]!zq^h<Hvm<!sqg<G!!
ucul<!ogiMg<gOu!hiMgqOxe<!.!nK!!
kvh<OhiGl<!-e<hs<!SuIg<gk<jk!w{<{qOb!
‘kk<ki!jk’obe!NMgqOxe<"4!
-r<Gs<! ‘Sui<g<gl<’! we<El<! okie<ll<! hbe<hMk<kh<ohx<Xt<tK/! dzgqz<!
slkIll<! d{<migquqm<miz<?! osiIg<glib<k<! kqgPl</! osiIg<gk<kqz<! -e<hOl!
wf<fiTl<A! Ke<hlqz<jz/! Ofib<! ofic?! uXjl?! dbIU! kip<U! we! wf<kh<!
hiGhiMl<!-z<jz/! sLkibk<kqz<!-Vg<Gl<! OlMht<tk<kqjes<! siqosb<Bl<OhiK!
sqz! sqg<gz<gt<! uVl</! -kjeg<! ‘gmz<’! we<El<! okie<ll<! ogi{<M! hizi!
uqtg<Ggqe<xiI/!!
144
Wgikq!hk<kqbk<kqe<!WOks<sikq!givligg<!!
gmz<!
-e<El<!ke<!wz<jzgjt!uq <̂kiqg<gqxK/!
njzgOti!
kr<gt<!OlMht<tr<gjts<!slh<hMk<Kukx<gig!!
fiTl<!sh<klqMgqe<xe/5!
Lkzitqk<Kul<! gmz</! Neiz<! njzgt<! slkIlk<Kg<gigh<! Ohivicg<!
ogi{<Mt<te/! Okevse<! slkIlk<jkk<! Okujk! we<gqxiI/! uiEzgqz<!
Ou{<cbuIg<G!Ou{<cbju!gqjmg<Gl</!OkuOzigk<kqz<!uiPl<oh{<!Okujk/!
-f<kk<!OkujkobiM!slkIlk<jk!yh<hqm<M?!
slkVl!OkujkOb!!
fuBgk<kqe<!fibgqOb!
w{<{r<gt<!sqzqIg<g!!
deg<OgiI!!
-kbiR<szq/!
!
Wgikqhk<kqbr<gjts<!sr<givR<!osb<k!
vk<k!Bk<kr<gt<!LcUg<G!uf<k!
hqxGkie<!fQ!!
hqvkq]<jm!osb<bh<hm<mib<6!
we<X!slkIll<!oux<xqohx<xjkBl<!Wgikqhk<kqbl<!npqg<gh<hm<mjkBl<!Okevse<!
osh<Hgqe<xiI/!!
!
! “okipqzitIgt<! Nm<sqjbg<! jgh<hx<xqb! hqxG! fjmLjxh<hMk<kh<hm<M!
uVl<! kqm<mlqm<m! ohiVtikivk<kqz<! -e<Xl<! %m<MxU! njlh<Hgt<! Lg<gqb!
-mk<jk!ugqk<K!uVgqe<xe/!Neiz<?!okipqzitIgt<!nkqgivk<jkg<!jgh<hx<xq?!
dx<hk<kqs<! siker<gjtk<! OksUjmjl! Ng<Gukx<G! lix<xigg<! %m<MxU!
njlh<Hgjt! lm<Ml<! Le<juh<hK! nh<hm<mlie! hqx<Ohig<Gk<ke<jl! uib<f<k!
osbz<himiGl</!
!
! Oksqblblig<gh<hm<m?! kqm<mlqm<m?! ohiVtikivk<Kg<G! lix<xig!jmbm<iqs<!
%m<Mxju!nch<hjmbigg<!ogi{<m!gzh<Hh<!ohiVtikivk<jk!Le<olipqgqxiI/!
-zk<kQe<! noliqg<giuqz<! okipqx<sr<g! -bg<glieK! okipqzitIgtqe<! osif<k!
145 nEhuk<kqe<!&zlig!-e<X!Osiszqsk<jk!Ofig<gqb!kqjsupqbqz<!osz<ujkg<!
gim<MgqxK/”7!!
!
6/3/!Hvm<sq!!
! l{qg<ogic! -kp<?! wPk<K! -kp<! -ux<xqz<! outquf<k! guqjkgtqz<!
HKjlgt<! -Vg<gqe<xeA! Hvm<sqgt<! -z<jz/! uiel<hic! -kpqz<! outquf<k!
guqjkgtqz<! HKjlgTl<! Hvm<sqgTl<! Ohivim<mLl<!-Vg<gqe<xe/!uiel<hicg<!
guqRIgtqe<! Hvm<sq! sikiv{! Hvm<sqbe<XA! dzjgOb! lix<Xl<! uz<zjl!
hjmk<k! Hvm<sqbiGl</! -uIgtiz<! Nm<sq! lix<xl<?! h{<him<M! lix<xl<! wz<zil<!
uVl<! we<X! wkqIhiIk<kiIgt</! -uIgtqe<! Hvm<sqjb! ‘ofVh<Hh<! Hvm<sq’! we<X!
nh<Kz<!vGlie<!Gxqh<hqMgqe<xiI/!!
ofVh<Hh<!Hvm<sq!
! bigr<gtqz<!
ofb<jb!-jzgt<!
! osiiqgqe<xe!…"8!
-r<G! ‘bigl<’! we<El<! okie<ll<! &zl<! Hvm<sqjbh<! Hzh<hMk<Kgqe<xiI/!
-bx<jgjb! lix<Xl<! =M-j{bx<x! Nx<xz<! kr<gtqml<! -Vh<hkig!
uiel<hicgt<! Gxqh<hqMgqe<xeI/! njeuiqe<! dt<tg<! gqtIs<sqjbk<! K~{<c?!
nuIgtqe<!Nx<xjzs<!osiMg<gq!uqMgqe<xeI/!lg<gjt!uqtqk<Kh<!hiMgqe<xeI/!!
W!/!/!/!lg<gOt"!we<eqml<!uiVr<gt<"!!
fie<!
l{jzOb!gbqxib<k<!kqiqk<Kk<!kVOue<!…
W!/!/!/"!lg<gOt"!we<eqml<!uiVr<gt<"!!
fie<!
uiek<jkOb!uqz<zib<!ujtk<Kk<!kVOue<!!
/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!!
gijzh<!heqk<Ktqgjt!uiiqobMk<K!!
Ouz<FeqbqZl<!%iqb!!
nl<Hgtib<!lix<xqk<!kVOue<"!!
uiVr<gt<"!OkipOv"!uiVr<gt<"9!
we<X!sqx<hq! hiMgqe<xiI/!-f<kg<! guqjkh<! hGkq!uiel<hic!Jf<kiuK!-kpqz<!
outquf<Kt<tK/! -kqz<! l{z<?! uiel<?! heqk<Ktq! Lkzie! -bx<jgk<!
okie<lg<!%Xgt<!jgbith<ohx<Xt<te/!!
146
h,m<cb!-Vl<Hg<!%m<ce<!gkU!!
! kqxg<gh<hm<mK!sqXk<jkOb!outqbqz<!ui":!
we<X! hivkqkise<! njpg<gqe<xiI/! uiel<hicg<! guqRI! HuqbvS! ncjlbib<!
-Vf<kK!OhiKl</!Hxh<hM"!Hvm<sq!osb<"!HzqOb!wPg"!we<gqxiI/!!
wk<kjeg<!gizl<!-Vtqx<!gqmh<hK!
! -kx<OgiI!Lcuqjzbi@!!
sk<kqbl<!ouz<Zl<!slbl<!uib<k<kK!
! HzqOb!wPf<kqvmi"21!
-g<guqjk!uiel<hic!Jf<kil<!-kpqz<!outquf<Kt<tK/!-kqz<!-Vt<?!sk<kqbl<!
Ngqb!okie<lg<!%Xgt<!uf<Kt<te/!uiel<hicg<!guqRI!HuqbvS!OlZl<!hz!
Hvm<sqgjts<!osb<Oue<!we<gqxiI/!-bx<jgjbOb!lix<xqg<!gim<MOue<!we<gqxiI/!!
Gpjzg<!ogiMr<gt<!DKgqOxe<"!
nejzh<!Hezib<!lix<XgqOxe<"22!
we<X! HuqbvS! hiMgqe<xiI/! -r<Gg<! Gpz<?! nez<?! Hez<! Ngqb! okie<lg<!
%Xgt<! uf<Kt<te/! -r<Gh<! hqmz<! gi^<m<Ovi! we<El<! Hvm<sqbitI! hx<xqb!
osb<kqBl<!Gxqh<hqmk<kg<gK/!!
!
! “2:64! \|jz! 36! ft<tqvU"! sqOhieq! h{<j{bqz<! hqmZl<! nuvK!
NkvuitIgTl<! OhiIg<Ogizl<! h,{<meI/! 611g<Gl<! Olx<hm<OmiI! hbqx<sq!
ohx<xqVf<k! OhikqZl<?! OhiVg<Gh<! Hxh<hmk<! kGkqbie! fqjzbqz<! 276! OhOv!
-Vf<keI!…//!
! olie<gmi! -vi[u! Lgil<! 26! Wg<gI! hvh<htuqz<! Lg<Ogi{! ucuqz<!
-Vf<kK/!-kx<G!&e<X!uisz<gt<!-Vf<ke/!-kx<Gt<!uQvIgt<!hbqx<sq!ohXl<!
jlkiel<?! NBkg<! gqmr<G?! uQvIgtqe<! GcbqVh<Hgt<?! yV! lVk<Kulje!
Ngqbju! -Vf<ke/! -f<k! LgiLg<Gt<! olik<kl<! 511! -vi[u! uQvIgTl<?!
Wvitlie!NBkr<gTl<!-Vf<ke!…//!!
! &e<X! hqiquqeVl<! LgiLg<Gt<! Fjpf<k! hqxG?! NBkg<! gqmr<Gg<Gs<!
ose<X! njkg<! jgh<hx<XuK?! -vi[u! kthkqgjtg<! jgK! osb<uK! hx<xq!
hqmz<! wz<OziVg<Gl<! uqtg<gqeiI/! kig<Gkz<! okiMh<hK! hx<xqh<! himl<! fmk<kq!
Lck<k! hqmz<?! “oux<xq! nz<zK! uQvlv{l<”! we<xiI/! Hvm<sqh<hjm! uQvIgt<!
njeuVl<! NOuslig! njk! NOlikqk<keI/”23! gqb,hijuh<! Hvm<sqh<hjm!
uQvIgt<! Ohiiqm<M! Nm<sq! lix<xk<kqjeg<! ogi{<M! uf<kiIgt</! nkqz<! 0hqmz<!
gi <̂m<Oviuqe<!hr<gtqh<H!lqGkqbiGl</!!
147 !
6/4/!HKjl!!
! “Hkqbe!uqVl<H”24!we<X!hivkqbiI!hiMgqe<xiI/!uiel<hicg<!guqRIgTl<!
kr<gt<!hjmh<Hgtqz<!hz!HKjlgjth<!hjmk<Kt<teI/!sqx<hq?!!
wr<gt<!sIh<hbigk<kqz<!!
sqxqbK!GxqbK!
ohiqbK!ofcbK!!
h,!figl<!Lkz<!ohixqfigl<!ujv!!
wiqBl<!.!wiqBl<"!!
giqBl<!.!giqBl<"!!
nf<k!
wiqkpx<!sil<hzqz<!!
yV!!
hvlhkk<jk!
wr<gt<!!
sqvlhkk<kiz<!!
sq<V]<ch<Ohil<!
fir<gt<"25!
we<X! dzgqjeOb! lix<xq! HKjl! hjmg<gh<Ohiukigg<! %Xgqe<xiI/! -kqz<!
figl<?!bigl<?!hvlhkl<!we<El<!okie<lg<!%Xgt<!uf<Kt<te/!-ux<xqe<!&zl<!
kr<gt<!HKjlh<!hjmh<H!hx<xqg<!%Xgqe<xiI/!
lzvh<!Ohigqe<x!ytqlblieokiV!ohix<gizl<!
geUgtqOzOb!&p<gqh<!Ohigilz<?!nVl<hqg<!
ogi{<cVg<Gl<!HKBgk<kqe<!Nsiv!uiszqOz!
h,hitl<!hicg<!ogi{<cVg<Gl<!uiel<hicjb!!
-eq!likf<OkiXl<!gi[uQIgt<"26!
we<X!uiel<hicgtqe<!HKjljbh<!hx<xq!Lz<jz!NkuEl<!hijz!fqzuEl<!
uqtl<Hgqe<xeI/!-kqz<!geU?!Bgl<!we<El<!okie<lg<!%Xgt<!uf<Kt<te/!!
l{<{qz<!uq{<{qe<!HKjlgt<!gim<c!
leqkjvk<!OkuI!Ng<GgqOxe<27!
we<X!HuqbvS!nx<Hkh<!HKjlgjth<!hjmh<Ohe<!weh<!hiMgqe<xiI/!-kqz<!l{<?!
uq{<!we<El<!okie<lg<!%Xgt<!jgbith<ohx<Xt<te/!!
148
de<Ejmb!himz<!!
we<!uqpqObivg<!gez<fQiqe<!hqVl<li/28!
-K! Lz<jz! Nkueqe<! guqjkh<! hjmh<H/! dzgk<jkBl<! dzg!
dbqiqer<gjtBl<! hjmg<Gl<! gmUt<! hqVl<li/! himOz!hqVl<li/! himz<!&zOl!
hz! HKjlgjth<! hjmg<gzil<! we<hK! uiel<hicg<! guqRIgtqe<!
fl<hqg<jgbiGl</!!
!
! Hvm<sqbitI! hqmz<! gi <̂m<Ovijuh<! hx<xqb! OlZl<! yV! osb<kq! -r<Gg<!
Gxqh<hqmk<kg<gkiGl</!“lg<gjtg<!guVl<!uqkligh<!hqmz<?!“NX!nl<sk<!kqm<ml<”!
we<x! ohbiqz<! gqb,hiuqz<! kie<! osb<buqVg<Gl<! Hvm<sqk<! kqm<mr<gjts<! sqX!
hqvkqgtig!ns<sqm<M?!nux<jx!lg<gtqml<!uqfqObigqg<g!Wx<hiM!osb<kiI/!!
!
! nkqz<?! “fqzlx<x! %zqk<! okipqzitqgTg<G! -zuslig! fqzl<!
upr<gh<hMl<! we<x! nuvK! nxquqh<H?! uXjlg<Ogim<Mg<Gg<! gQOp! uip<f<k! 91!
skuqgqk!gqb,h!lg<gtqe<!ofR<sqz<!fqjzk<K!uqm<mK/!-f<k!yx<jx!nxquqh<hqe<!
&zligOu!gqb,hijuk<!ke<!hqcbqz<!ogi{<M!uf<K!uqm<miI/”29!
!
6/5/!squh<H!fqxl<!
! yu<ouiV! fqxLl<! yu<ouiV! GxqbQm<Mh<! ohiVjt! d{Ik<Kgqe<xe/!
ou{<jl! fqxl<! slikiek<jkg<! Gxqg<gqe<xK/! hSjl! fqxl<! osPjljbg<!
Gxqg<gqe<xK/! squh<H! fqxl<! Ogihk<jkBl<! Ougk<jkBl<! Hvm<sqjbBl<!
Gxqg<gqe<xK/! gXh<H! fqxl<! Ogihk<jkBl<! wkqIh<Hg<! GvjzBl<! Gxqg<gqe<xK/!
uiel<hicg<!guqRIgt<!ohiKUjmjluikqgt</!weOu!nuIgtqe<!guqjkgtqz<!
squh<H! fqxl<! lqGkqbib<g<! jgbith<ohx<Xt<tK/! -keiz<! WjebuIgt<!
ns<sh<hm<meI/!-kjes<!sg<kqg<gez<?!!
wPKl<!we<!uqvzqz<!squh<Hjl!g{<miz<!
WOei!hmhmh<H@2:!
we<El<!himzcgt<!&zl<!okiquqg<gqe<xiI/!squh<H!fqxl<!yV!okie<lg<!%xiGl</!
L/Olk<ki?!!
fl<!!
gvr<gtqe<!djph<jhg<!
gizl<!nzm<sqbh<hMk<Kl<OhiK!
fqxr<gtqz<!squh<jhOb!!
149
fil<!!
fqs<sbqg<g!LcBl<"!
/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!!
-Vm<M!uiek<kqz<!
fil<!!
squh<Hh<!hxjugt<"31!
we<X!hiMgqe<xiI/!
bf<kqvBgk<kqe<!jlbqVtqz<!!
leqk!les<!$eqbk<kqz<!!
squh<Hh<!hxju!nzXgqxK!/!/!/32!
we<X!vuQf<kqve<!hiMgqe<xiI/!
-kb!Out<uqbqe<!!
wiqgezigUl<!
Hkqb!Bgk<kqe<!!
HzI!uqcuigUl<!!
squf<kqVf<k!!
we<!nr<gqjb!!
we<e!osb<kQIgt<@!!
!
squh<jhg<!g{<miz<!!
dr<gTg<G!
nk<kje!ns<sli@33!
we<X! HuqbvS! Ogm<gqe<xiI/! squh<H! fqxl<! Hvm<sqg<Gl<! ohiKUjmjlg<Gl<!
ouGtqg<Gl<! GxqbQmiGl</! guqRIgt<! kr<gtqe<! Hvm<sq?! HKjl?! ohiKUjmjl!
-ux<jxB{Ik<Kukx<Gs<!squh<H!fqxk<jkg<!jgbiTgqe<xeI/!-kje!d{Ik<k!
HuqbvS?!!
-Oki"!!
Olx<G!uiel<!
-vk<ks<!squh<hib<"34!
we<gqxiI/!fqxr<gTt<!njeuIg<Gl<!hqck<klieK!squh<H!fqxl<!NGl</!Neiz<!
-K! okie<lg<! %xib<h<! himz<gtqz<! uVl<OhiK?! -mk<kqx<G! Wx<hh<!
ohiV{<jlgjtg<! gim<Mgqe<xK/! uiel<hicg<! guqRIgt<! squh<H! fqxl<!
we<hkje! okie<lg<! %xib<h<! hbe<hMk<kqBt<teI/! uiel<hicgTg<G!
150 fqxg<GxqbQM! squh<hiGl</! squh<H! Hvm<sqjbBl<! Ohivim<mk<jkBl<!
Hzh<hMk<Kgqe<xK/!!
!
6/6/!ncjljb!fQg<Gkz<!!
! leqkEg<G!leqke<!ncjlbib<!-Vg<gg<!%miK/!h{<j{biIgTg<Gk<!
okipqzitqgt<! ncjlbib<! -Vh<hkje! uiel<hicgt<! wkqIk<keI/! slk<Kul<?!
ohiKUjmjl! lzv! Ou{<Moleqz<! ncjl! ypqb! Ou{<Ml</! okipqzitI!
ncjl?! oh{<{cjl! Lkzieux<jx! fQg<Gukx<G! njeuVl<! ye<Xhm!
Ou{<Ml</!njeuVl<!gz<uq!gx<xiOz!ncjlk<kek<jk!ypqk<K!uqmzil</!!
!
! h/gr<jgogi{<mie<?! “wf<kg<! g{<{e<!-r<Gh<! hqxf<kiz<! /! /! /@! we<El<!
guqjkbqz<! Ohb<ljpbqe<! ogiMjlbqzqVf<K! kh<hqg<g! OgiuIk<ke! ljzjbg<!
g{<{e<!Gjmbigh<!hqcg<g!Ou{<Ml<!we<X!hiMgqe<xiI/!!
Ohb<ljpg<!gvr<gtqe<!
hqj{h<hXg<g!Ou{<Moleqz<!!
wf<kg<!g{<{e<!
-r<Gh<!hqxf<kiz<!
OgiuIk<ker<gt<!
GjmbiGl<@35!
-kqz<!Ohb<?!OgiuIk<ke!ljz!okie<lg<!%Xgtib<!uf<Kt<te/!
!
! uqbm<fil<?! gqb,hi! fiMgt<! ncjlk<kjtbqz<! uicbOhiK!nux<xqx<gig!
uiel<hicgt<! Gvz<ogiMk<keI/! uqbm<fil<! ncjlbqzqVf<K! fQr<gqbjk! ‘nK’!
we<El<! kjzh<hqz<! Rieq! guqjk! hjmk<Kt<tiI/! nK! we<hK! uqbm<fil<!
fim<jmg<!Gxqg<gqe<xK/!
kQbqeiz<!Sm<omiqk<Oke<!…!
G{<Mgtiz<!fqzl<!hqtf<Oke<!…!
uq]uqk<Kg<gjt!wr<Gl<!K~uqOee<!
hijxgTg<gqjmbqz<!
nLk!Dx<Xg<!gqtl<hqbK"!
fqzl<!Gtqi<f<kK!…!
uq]l<!uqzgqbK!…!
Osijz!wPf<kK!…!
151
nK!…!
uqbm<fil<"36!
-f<kg<!guqjkbqz<!fqzl<?!kQ?!nLkDX<X?!Osijz!Lkzie!okie<lg<!%Xgt<!
-ml<ohx<Xt<te/! ncjlk<kjt! ypqb! Ou{<Ml</! slk<KuLl<!
ohiKUjmjlBl<!lzv!Ou{<Ml</!nkx<G!njeuVl<!leqkvib<!lixq?!leqkje!
leqke<!lkqg<g!Ou{<Ml</!-kjeh<!HuqbvS?!!
dmOe!fQr<gt<!
leqkvib<!lixqeiz<!…!
ne<Hme<!fir<gt<!
lVk<Kul<!hiIh<Ohil<"37!
we<gqxiI/!!
!
6/7/!uXjljb!ypqk<kz<!!
! d{U?!djm?!djxuqml<!-l<&e<Xl<!Gjxbqe<xq!fqjxuig!-Vf<kiz<!
lg<gt<! utLme<! uip<gqxiIgt<! we<X! OhSuiIgt</! -ux<Xt<! GjxbqVf<kiz<!
lg<gt<! uXjlg<Ogim<Mg<Gl<! gQOp! -Vg<gqe<xiIgt<! we<X! Gxqh<hqMuiIgt</!
nch<hjm! uskq! gqjmg<gik! fqjzbqVf<kiz<! nK! ‘uXjl’! we<X!
Gxqh<hqmh<hMgqxK/! kqVut<TuI! uXjlbqe<! ogiMjljb! ‘fz<GvU’! we<El<!
nkqgivk<kqz<!uqtg<Ggqe<xiI/!!
nxR<sivi!fz<GvU!=e<xki!biEl<!!
hqxe<Ohiz!Ofig<gh<!hMl<38!!
-e<Xl<!uVuK!ogiz<Ozi!ofVfZl<!
ogie<xK!OhiZl<!fqvh<H/39!
uXjlbiz<!dbqiqpf<kuIgt<!hzI!dt<teI/!uXjlbqe<!ogiMjljb?!!
fir<gt<!hsqjb!
uqvm<MuK!wh<hck<!okiqBli@!!
hm<ceq!gqmf<K"!
!
fir<gt<!Ofijb!!
ypqh<hK!wh<hck<!okiqBli@!!
osk<Kk<!okijzf<K3:!
we<X!klqpue<!hiMgqe<xiI/!djxuqmk<jkh<!hx<xqg<!%Xl<!\Quytq?!!
152
wr<g!Gcjs!we<jeg<GOl!
-Vm<mik<ki!-Vf<kqs<S!…!
wr<gTg<G!Ou{<cbK!!
yOv!yV!olPGuk<kqkie<"41!
we<gqxiI/! ljeuqbqe<! lir<gz<blie! kizqjbg<! %m! nmG! juk<K!
uipOu{<cb!fqjzbqz<!uip<g<jg!uXjlbieK/!-kjek<!klqpe<he<?!!
lir<gz<b!lgqjljb!
ljeuq!nxquit<!
l{ite<!nxquie<!!
-uIgt<!-Vujvuqm!!
liIuicOb!nkqglibxquie<"42!
we<X! uVk<kLme<! hiMgqe<xiI/! Gpf<jkg<Gh<! hiz<! uir<gUl<! h{lqz<zik!
uXjl! fqjz! -Vg<gqe<xK/! -kjek<! kizim<cz<! kib<! hiMuKOhiz<!
sg<kqg<gez<?!!
Dsqbib<g<!Gk<kqcEl<!.!de<!
dzIf<k!ubqx<Xg<Gg<!
gisqz<jz!hiz<uir<g!–!we<!!
g{<{gqOb!g{<[xr<G"43!
we<X!gkxqh<!hiMgqe<xiI/!uQM!-z<jz/!uqtg<G!-z<jz/!hiz<!-z<jz/!hch<H!
wh<hc!utVl</!hsq!lbg<gk<kiz<!jggiz<!fMr<Gl</!-kje!uqe<Ogi!O\gh<?!!
we<!g{<O{"!!
-vuz<!kq{<j{bqz<!
fQ!hcg<g!
osif<k!fqzi!outqs<sl<"!!
!
jggiz<!njsk<K!!
osz<uI!Gpf<jk!fmh<hKOhiz<!!
deg<Gl<!-Vg<Gl<!!
hsqlbg<gl<!.!jggiz<!fMg<gl<44!
we<X!hkqU!osb<gqe<xiI/!-h<hc!d{<{!d{uqe<xq!-Vg<g!-mlqe<xq! hcg<g!
outqs<slqe<xq! -Vg<Gl<! lg<gt<! djpk<K! djpk<K! Ymib<k<! Okb<gqe<xeI/!
-uIgtqe<!fqjzjljb?!!
153
we<!kibgk<kqe<!OgimiEOgic!!
kiqk<kqv!fivib{Igtqe<!vk<k!uqbIjubqz<!
/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!!
nf<k!nh<hiuqgt<?!ym<cb!ubqXl<!
dm<Gpqf<k!ge<er<gTl<!wZl<Hh<!hf<kZlib<!!
fqx<hkx<Gg<!giv{lieuVl<!…/!
nuI!gvr<gtqe<!Osix<jxk<!km<ch<hxqk<K!!
nuIgjt!ubqx<xqzck<Kh<!ohik<kz<!Gcjss<!
sqjxbqz<!kt<tqbuVl<!…/!
-e<eiove<hjk!fie<!nuIgTg<G!
-er<gim<cg<!ogi{<cVg<jgbqz<!…/!
nkeiz<!nuIgt<!uqpqgt<!kqxf<K!!
hiIg<gk<!okimr<Gjgbqz<!…!
fie<!ofVh<Hg<!guqjkgt<!wPkqOee<!…45!
we<X! HuqbvS! guqjk! wPKl<! $pjzg<! Gxqh<hqMgqe<xiI/! uXjljbs<!
Sm<Mukx<Gg<! guqRIgt<?! lir<gz<b! lgqjl?! fqzi! outqs<sl<?! kiqk<kqv!
fivib{Igt<! we<El<! okie<lg<! %Xgjtg<! jgbi{<Mt<teI/! -uIgtqe<!
guqjkgt<!uqpqh<H{IU!kf<K?!uQMOkiXl<!fqzUl<!uXjljb!uqvm<Ml<!we<El<!
fl<hqg<jg!uiel<hicg<!guqRIgtqml<!-Vf<kK/!!
!
6/8/!Dpjz!ypqk<kz<!!
! dzgqz<!DpZl<!jgb,m<Ml<!ohVgq!uVgqe<xe/!-ux<jx!ypqk<kiz<kie<!
djph<Hl<! OfIjlBl<! Yr<gq! utVl</! -ux<xqx<gig! uiel<hicg<! guqRIgt<!
kr<gt<! hr<gtqh<hqjes<! osb<Kt<teI/! Okevse<! “-e<El<! yV! kizim<M”!
we<El<! guqjkbqz<! gXh<Hh<! h{k<kqjeh<! hm<cbzqMgqe<xiI/! gXh<Hh<!
h{k<jkBl<!out<jth<!h{ligk<!k{qg<jgbitIgt<!siqosb<K!uqMgqe<xiIgt</!!
uVlie!uiq!nk<jk/!
lihiuq!ogit<tqg<g{<!!
wiqb!djeh<!hiIk<kit<!
we<xi!gzr<Ggqxib<@!!
!
nujts<!siqosb<uiI!
Ncm<mI!de<lile<!
154
gujz!obiKg<gquqm<Mg<!
g{<&c!fQBxr<G!…46!
-r<G! lihiuq! ogit<tqg<g{<?! kizim<M! we<El<! okie<lg<! %Xgt<!
Gxqh<hqmh<hm<Mt<te/!
!
6/9/!kQ{<mijl!ypqh<H!!
! -f<kqbiuqz<! sikq! Ohkr<gtiz<! kQ{<mijl! we<El<! ohVr<Gx<xl<!
-Vf<Kt<tK/!-kje!ypqg<g!nvsir<gl<!Lbe<X!osbz<hm<Mt<tK/!kQ{<mijl!
yV! hius<osbz<A! leqkje! leqke<! Ofsqg<g! Ou{<Ml</! Neiz<! djph<hue<!
kQ{<mk<kgikueigg<! gVkh<hMl<! fqjzjl! -f<ks<! sLkibk<kqz<!
gi{h<ohXgqe<xK/!-kjek<!“kQm<M”!we<El<!guqjkbqz<!ogi/s/hzvile<?!!
Ogiuqz<!kip<uivk<kqz<!
Ogijm!ljpg<G!yKr<gqOee<!!
hm<mI!we<jek<!
‘kQm<M!yKr<gmi’!we<xiI/!!
nf<kg<!Ogiuqzqe<!
osiIg<g!uisZg<G!
ui{l<!Oki{<cbueqe<!
Ohve<!fie<"47!
we<X! OhSgqe<xiI/! Ogiuqz<?! ljp?! kQm<M?! osiIg<guisz<! Ngqb! okie<lg<!
%Xgt<!-f<kg<!guqjkbqz<!-ml<ohx<Xt<te/!
!
6/:/!oh{<{qbl<!!
! oh{<{qe<! diqjl?! fzl<! Lkzieux<jxh<! OhSkZl<! nux<jx!
Nvib<kZl<! oh{<{qbl<! NGl</! oh{<{qbk<kqx<Gh<! hqe<uVliX! uqtg<gr<gt<!
kvh<hm<Mt<te/!!
!
! “oh{<{qbl<! njek<K! ujgh<! oh{<gTg<Gl<! diqjl! Ou{<MuK/!
N{<?!oh{<!slk<Ku!diqjlgt<?!oh{<gt<!kil<!Olx<ogit<Tl<!njek<Kujg!
uip<g<jg! LjxgTg<Gl<?! h{qgt<! njek<kqx<Gl<! diqjlBjmbuIgtig!
-Vk<kz<!Ou{<Ml<!we<hK/!!
!
155 ! oh{<gtqe<! diqjljbh<! hxqk<K! nuIgjtg<! gm<Mh<hMk<Kl<!
njek<jkBl<!oh{<gt<!Le<Oex<xk<kqx<Gg<! OgM!uqjtuqg<Gl<!njek<jkBl<!
fQg<Gkz</! oh{<gTg<G! uqpqh<H{IU! Dm<c?! nuIgjt! ye<XhMk<kqk<! kl<!
diqjlg<Gh<!OhiviMkz<?!-bg<g!iQkqbig!ye<XhMkZl<!OhiviMkZl<!NGl</!!
!
! oh{<gTg<Gh<! ohiVtikivs<! Skf<kqvk<jk! fqjzfim<Mkz<?!
N{ikqg<gk<jk! njmbitl<! g{<M! nkje! wkqIk<kz<?! oh{<gtqe<! lQkie!
njek<Kujg! yMg<GLjxgjtBl<! Nvib<f<K! nkjeh<! Ohig<Gukx<gie!
kQIUgt<?! uqMkjz! ohXukx<gie! upqLjxgjth<! hqe<hx<Xkz<?! SVg<gligs<!
osie<eiz<! oh{<gtqe<! fzjeh<! Ohix<XkZl<! nkje! njmkZl<!
njmf<kux<jxg<!gik<kZl<!NGl</”48!!
!
! oh{<gt<! gizr<gizlib<s<! shqg<gh<ohx<xuIgt<! we<X! oh{<{qbuikqgt<!
OhSgqe<xeI/! ljzbit! ubziI! viluIli! guqjkjbk<! klqpqz<! sqx<hq!
olipqohbIk<Kt<tiI/! -f<kg<! guqjk! uiel<hic! 29NuK! -kpqz<!
outqbigqBt<tK/!nkqz<!yV!hGkq/!!
nP?!nP?!fQ!nP!…!
nPgqe<x!Gpf<jkg<Og!hiz<!gqjmg<Gl<!
ofif<K!dVGl<!ofR<Sg<Og!fQkq!gqjmg<Gl<!)nP*!!
!
sQjkBl<!DIlqjtBl<!hqxf<k!fit<Lkz<!!
shqg<gh<hm<muI!oh{<gt<!
wk<kje!Ov[jggt<!ngzqjggt<!!
wk<kje!sGf<kjzgt<!!
fqk<kqb!uql<lz<gt<!h,lqbqe<!!
Kg<g!fqjeUgt<!NeiI/!!
okb<uLl<!leqkEl<!hqxf<k!fit<Lkz<!!
uqzg<gh<!hm<muI!oh{<gt</!
nuIgtqe<!hpq!ouxq!ng<gqeqbiGl<"49!!
! “\iegq!Hzl<hz<!…@”!we<El<!guqjkjbh<!hjmk<kui<!nxque</!-kqz<!
-vileqe<!nxquqje!uqlIsel<!osb<gqe<xit</!!
-V{<m!gim<cz<!!
gIh<hqeq!we<je!!
156
fqIg<gkqbig!uqm<Mh<Ohigg<!
gm<mjtbqm<m!!
nf<ks<!sQki!vileqe<!!
Hk<kqjb!Nt<hue<!
-e<X!yV!u{<{iei@4:!
N[g<Gh<! oh{<! ncjlbib<! -Vf<k! sQjk?! DIlqjt?! vile<! Lkzie!
okie<lg<!%Xgtqe<!G{l<?! osbz<!Lkzqbux<jx!uiel<hich<! hjmh<hitqgt<!
lix<xqbjlk<Kh<!oh{<{qbl<!OhSgqe<xeI/!!
!
6/21/!sijz!Ng<gqvlqh<H!
! -f<kqbiuqz<! Gxqh<higk<! klqpgk<kqz<! Wiq?! Gtl<?! sijz?! ohiKuqml<!
Lkzieju! lg<gtiz<! Ng<gqvlqh<H! osb<bh<hMgqe<xe/! Wiq?! Gtr<gjtk<!
K~Ik<K! keqbiIgt<! gm<mmr<gjtg<! gm<MuKl<?! nvsir<gr<gt<! lVk<Kulje?!
OhVf<K! fqjzbl<! njlh<hKl<! fjmohx<X! uVgqe<xe/! sijzObivr<gtqz<!
nf<kf<k! -mr<gtqz<! -Vh<huIgt<! kr<gTjmb! uqfibgI?! LVge<?! ne<je!
liqbit<?! fhqgt<! fibgl<! Ngqb! okb<ur<gTg<G! Ogiuqz<?! Nzbl<?! l$kq!
Ngqbux<jx! njlg<gqe<xeI/! lg<gt<! okijgh<! ohVg<gLl<! uiger<gTl<!
ohVgquVl<! $pzqz<?! sijzh<! Ohig<Guvk<kqx<G! -jmb,Xgtib<! Nr<gir<Og!
sijzg<! gmUt<gt<! gim<sqbtqg<gqe<xeI/! -ux<xqje! uiel<hicg<! guqRIgt<!
g{<cg<gqe<xeI/!!
sijzg<!gmUt<gOt"!fMs<!!
sijzg<!gmUt<gOt"!!
upqbqz<!kjmbib<!Lt<jth<!hvh<hq!!
utIf<K!fqx<Gl<!gt<tqgOt"!!
!
liki!Ogiuqzib<!…!l$kqk<!kzlib<!…!
nvs!fqpzqz<!nlIf<kue<!-z<zlib<!…!
liiqbib<g<!gitqbib<!…!likue<!Ogibqzib<!
wr<Ogi!&jzbqz<!-Vf<k!fQr<gt<!.!!
wr<gt<!upqgtqz<!We<!Ljtg<gqe<xQI@!
…/! …/! …/! …/!
uige!njzgt<!OliKl<!sijzbqz<!…!
leqk!fkqgt<!sr<glk<!Kjxbqz<!!
157
fiTl<!Hkqkib<!Ljtk<Kg<!gqjtg<Gl<!!
fgvs<!sijz!ff<kqgOt"!!
D'I!OkiXl<!uqiqBl<!dxUh<!
hijkgt<!kMg<gqe<xQI"!hiIju!SVg<GgqxQI"!
dr<gt<!uiszqz<!yu<ouiV!oficBl<!!
sg<gvr<gtqz<!sqg<gq!ofiXr<gq!!
&jt!sqkxq?!-vk<kl<!hQxqm!!
h,k<k!geUgt<!ofR<OsiM!Ohig!
-xf<kuI!okijgkie<!wk<kje@!wk<kje@51!
we<X! -tLVG! uqeUgqe<xiI/! -f<kg<! guqjkbqz<! Ogiuqz<?! l$kq?! ff<kqgt<?!
geUgt<! Ngqb! okie<lg<! %Xgt<! jgbith<ohx<Xt<te/! -ux<xqe<! &zl<!
sijzObivr<gtqz<!gmUt<!sqjzgt<!juh<hjkg<!guqRI!g{<cg<gqe<xiI/!!
!
6/22/!oh{<!ogiMjl!
! N[l<! oh{<[l<! sll</! weqEl<! oh{<j{g<! ogiMjl! osb<uKl<!
oh{<{qml<!ue<H{Is<sqbqz<!=MhMuKl<!fmf<Kogi{<Mkie<!-Vg<gqe<xe/!dmz<?!
lel<?! h{l<! Lkzqbux<xiz<! oh{<! ncjlbig<gh<hMgqe<xit<! nz<zK!
ogiMjlh<hMk<kh<! hMgqe<xit</! weOu! oh{<{qb! Nb<Ugt<! Okie<xq?! nf<kg<!
ogiMjlgjt!nl<hzh<hMk<Kgqe<xe/!!
!
! “oh{<{qb!-zg<gqbk<! kqxeib<U?! kf<jk!upqs<! s&gk<kqe<! hivl<hiqbg<!
%Xgjt?! N{ikqg<gg<! Gvjz! uqiqk<Kjvg<gqxK/! ns<s&gk<kqz<! nuIgtqe<!
Nkqg<g! d{Iuqx<Gh<! oh{<gt<! Ntig<gh<hm<cVg<Gl<! fqjzjb?!
yMg<gh<hm<cVg<Gl<! ke<jlgjt! wMk<Kg<gim<MgqxK/! hizqbz<! siIf<k!
hqvs<sjegtqz<!oh{<gtqe<!hizqbz<!hzik<givl<!hx<xqb!sqk<kqvujkgjt!Le<!
juh<hkqz<! lqGf<k! guel<! osZk<KgqxK/! -k<Kme<! hizqbz<! ogit<jg!
oh{<gtqe<lQK! kq{qg<gh<hm<cVg<Gl<! fqjzbqje! wMk<Kg<gim<MgqxK/!
nvsqbzqZl<!oh{<gt<!fSg<gh<hm<cVh<hjkBl<!outqh<hMk<kqg<!gim<MuK!Ohie<x!
hz<OuX!Ofig<gr<gjtg<!ogi{<mK!oh{<{qb!-zg<gqbk<!kqxeib<uiGl</”52!!
!
! fix<hK! N{<MgTg<G! Le<Oh! uiel<hicg<! guqRIgt<! oh{<gtqe<!
fqjzjljb! Nvib<f<K! guqjk! hjmk<Kt<teI/! uqjzlgtqI?! ue<H{Is<sq!
fqjzjlgtqz<! oh{<gtqe<! dmZl<! dt<tLl<! hMl<! him<jmg<! guqRIgt<!
158 hjmh<hig<gl<! osb<K?! nf<kg<! ogiMjlgjt! ypqg<g! njeuVl<! Le<uv!
Ou{<Ml<!we<X!%Xgqe<xeI/!!
gisiz<!…!!
fqzilgt<!!
likuqbib<!
uqjzOhieit<!!
YI!fit</53!
-K!klqp<fime<! guqjkbqz<! yV!hGkq?!-r<G! fqzi! we<El<! okie<lg<!%Xl<!
likuq! we<El<! okie<lh<! hik<kqvLl<! uqjzh<oh{<cI! fqjzjljb! d{Ik<k!
uf<Kt<te/!uqhs<sivl<!osb<K!fqkq!OsIk<K!g{<{gq!kqVl{!l{<mhl<!gm<Ml<!
fqjzjljbk<! klqpe<he<! “fqkqu$z<”! we<El<! kjzh<hqzie! guqjkbqz<!
Gxqh<hqMgqe<xiI/!
!
! -f<kqve<!dVul<!lixq!ngzqjgjbh<!H{If<kie</!osb<kqbxqf<k!ogtkl!
LequI! -f<kqvjeBl<! ngzqjgjbBl<! shqk<kiI/! sihk<kiz<! ngzqjg!
gz<zieit<A! -f<kqve<! dml<ohz<zil<! Nbqvl<! oh{<Gxqgt<! okiqf<ke/!
-f<kqvEg<gigk<! OkuIgt<! Ou{<cbkiz<?! -f<kqve<! dml<hqz<! Nbqvl<! g{<gt<!
lx<xuIg<Gk<! okiqBl</! -f<kqve<! giLgk<! ke<jljbh<! hz! guqRIgt<! hz!
Ogi{r<gtqz<!hjmk<Kt<teI/!
-vuqe<!likul<!Lkqvm<Ml<"!!
-f<kqve<!Nkel<!nkqvm<Ml<!!
-f<kg<!giLg!u{<Mgtqe<!!
sqxgqje!LxqBr<gt<"54!
we<X!nh<Kz<!vGlie<!uzqBXk<Kgqe<xiI/!Hvi{!gizk<kqz<!fmf<k!ue<H{Is<sq!
-e<Xl<!okimIgqxK/!!
!
! “ubqx<Xh<! hqjph<Hg<gig!uQm<jm!uqm<M!outqOb!ose<X!Dkqbl<! =m<mg<!
%cb! oh{<gt<! hizqeg<! ogiMjl! we<gqx! uqjzjbg<! ogiMk<Ok! kQv!
Ou{<cBt<tK/! ohVl<hizie! oh{<gt<! klg<G! -jpg<gh<hMl<! hizqeg<!
ogiMjlgt<! hx<xq! outqbqz<! osiz<uK! gqjmbiK/! Woeeqz<! hizqe!
ue<ogiMjlgjt! -f<ks<! sLkibl<! wu<uiX! Ofig<GgqxKA!
nx<hk<kelig<gqBt<tK! we<hjk! nuIgt<! d{If<Ok! -Vg<gqe<xeI/!
Ogi{z<Hk<kq! hjmk<k! N{<gtqe<! fmk<jkjbh<! Hxg<g{qk<kkiz<?!
159 nzm<sqbh<hMk<kqeiz<!oh{<gt<!hz!sqg<gz<gjtk<!kuqIg<gzil<!we!nuIgjt!
fl<hs<!osb<Kt<teI!nz<zK!nuIgt<!fl<Hgqe<xeI!…!
!
! hizqeg<! ogiMjlbqe<! uqjtUgtiue;! dmz<! iQkqbie! okif<kvUgt<?!
d{IUh<h,Iulie! okiz<jzgt<?! kx<ogijzgt<?! dmZxUk<! kig<Gkziz<!
uqjtBl<! Nhk<kie! fqjz?! kqm<mlqmig<! gVUXkz<?! hiz<uqje! Ofib<gt</”55!
-u<uiX!oh{<gt<!hz!fqjzgtqz<!hikqh<Hg<G!dt<tigqe<xeI/!!
!
6/23/!Ohizqgt<!!
! -zg<g{k<kqOz! ‘wPk<Kh<Ohizq’! d{<M/! lg<gtqZl<! Ohizqgt<! hzI!
dt<teI/!kqVut<TuVl<?!!
lg<gOt!Ohiz<uI!gbuI!…56!!
OkuI!njebI!gbuI!…57!
we<gqxiI/! uiel<hicg<! guqRIgt<! Ohizq! lkuikqgjtBl<! Ohizqh<!
h,siiqgjtBl<!Ohizqg<!guqRIgjtBl<!siMgqe<xeI/!!
!
! -zr<jgbqOz! Hk<k! lkk<kqjeh<! hqe<hx<Xl<! sqr<gtIgt<! Hk<kiqe<!
ogit<jgg<G!wkqvigOu!osbz<hMgqe<xeI/!-uIgTg<Gs<!sqx<hq?!!
Hk<kI!hqvieqe<!
osiz<Zg<Gs<!slikqgm<c!!
hz<Zg<G!uqpi!wMg<Gl<!
ghm!lgiul<sg<!GVliIgt<!…!
!
klqp<!dmz<lQK!!
Kh<hig<gqg<!gk<kq!Ljegtiz<!
sqr<gt!vk<ks<!sqk<kqvl<!
wPkqg<!gtqg<Gl<!!
N{u!vi[ul<!…!
!
fqi<ui{g<!gkxz<!uQxqm!!
klqp<!-tl<!h,g<gt<!!
uql<lqb!dbqiqe<!nzxjzs<!!
160
sr<gQk!n[g<gtib<!vsqk<K!wg<gtqk<k!!
liEmg<!gbjl!…58!!
we<X!sim<jmbc!kVgqe<xiI/!!
!
! h,siiqgt<! kl<! lQK! -jxue<! Wxq! -jxuig<G! nVt<uiI/! lg<gTl<!
fl<hqg<jgObiM! osbz<hMuI/! Neiz<! h,siiq! Oumk<kqz<! osbz<hMhuIgt<! lK!
nVf<KuKl<! hvk<jkbI! yPg<gLl<! ogi{<muvib<g<! gi{h<ohXgqe<xeI/!
-h<hch<hm<m! Ohizqh<! h,siiqgjts<! S/kVlviS! Sm<cg<! gim<Mgqe<xiI/! lg<gt<!
uqpqh<H{IUme<!-Vg<g!Ou{<Ml<!we<X!hkqU!osb<gqe<xiI/!!
Diqz<!
liiqbl<le<!kqVuqpi!…!
sg<kqh<!h,OuiM!!
fiTl<!
silqg<G!wMh<hK!
silqbh<he<!diqjl!!
Nx<X!l{zqz<!!
ng<gqeq!utIk<K!!
nVt<!uv!!
nuOv!YM!K~g<GuiI!!
/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!/!
liiq!h,OuiM!!
Ogibqjz!njmf<K!
sg<kq!gl<hk<kqz<!
sm<cjb!juk<kKl<!
silqbh<he<!
liblib<!ljxuiI!…!
!
nl<le<!Ogibqz<!!
hqe<Hxl<!Osiqbqz<!
Nvibq!Gcjsbqz<!!
silqbh<hEg<G!
!
161
lXhcBl<!
nVt<!uVl<!
Nvibq!ogiMg<Gl<!!
sivibk<kqZl<!
gkgkh<hie!!
nj{h<hqZl<"!
!
silqbh<he<!
fq\lib<!!
silqg<Og!nh<he<"59!
-jxujeOb!Wlix<XhuIgt<!lg<gt</!Ohizq!lkuikqgTl<!Ohizqh<!h,siiqgTl<!
-Vg<gqe<xeI/! -uIgjtg<! guqRIgt<! ujshiceiZl<! guqRIgTt<Tl<! sqz!
Ohizqg<!guqRIgt<!-Vg<gqe<xeI/!!
Lpk<!K{<M!
gqjmk<kiz<!OhiKl<!!
sqjk!OljmbqZl<!Wxs<!
osf<klqp<g<!guqgt<!
g<b,!
uiqjsbqz<!
kbiI"5:!
we<X! Ohizqg<! guqRIgjts<! sqhq! -gp<gqe<xiI/! lg<gt<! -h<hch<! Ohizqgtib<!
-Vh<hkx<G! nch<hjmg<! giv{r<gt<! OhvijsBl<! kx<Hgp<s<sqBl<! NGl</!
kx<Hgp<s<sqg<gigh<!hzI!uqtl<hvr<gt<!osb<uKl<!d{<M/!-kje?!!
Neiz<!-h<Ohiokz<zil<!!
silqgjtuqm!silqbicgTg<Og!!
Dmg!outqs<sk<!kQum<cgt<!nkqgl</!!
nkeiz<!!
lg<gt<!kjzgtqz<!nck<K!lqvm<c!
Nm<mh<!hiIg<gqxiIgt<"61!
we<X!l/-viOsf<kqve<!Sm<cg<gim<Mgqe<xiI/!!
!
162 6/24/!okiGh<Hjv!!
! uiel<hic! -bg<gk<kqjes<! OsIf<k! guqRIgt<! kr<gt<! gVk<Kg<gjth<!
Hzh<hMk<k! hz<OuX! okie<lg<! %Xgjtg<! jgbi{<Mt<teI/! uiel<hicg<!
guqRIgt<! kl<! Ofig<gk<kqje! outqh<hMk<k! -bx<jgjbBl<! kqVliz<!
nukivr<gjtBl<!-f<kqve<!Lkzie!OkuIgjtBl<!Gxqh<hqm<Mt<teIA!g{<{gq?!
likuq?!ngzqjg!Lkzie!oh{<! okie<l! lif<kIgjtg<! ogi{<M! wkqIljxh<!
ohiVjtBl<! dme<him<Mh<! ohiVjtBl<! uqtg<Ggqe<xeI/! ohiKUjmjl?!
slki<ll<?! HKjlgt<! weh<! hz! gVk<Kg<gjt! uqtg<Gukx<Gg<! guqRIgt<!
okie<lg<! %Xgjtg<! jgbi{<Mt<teI/! squh<H! fqxl<! okie<lg<! GxqbQmib<h<!
ohiVT{Ik<Kgqe<xK/!!
!
! Dpz<?! jgb,m<M?! kQ{<mijl?! uXjl?! oh{<{cjl?! ue<H{Is<sq!
Lkzieux<jx! ypqh<hkx<Gg<! guqRIgt<! uQXogi{<M! wPf<K! guqjk!
hjmk<kkqz<! okie<lg<! %Xgjth<! hbe<hMk<kqBt<teI/! sLkibg<!
ogiMjlgjtg<! gjtbUl<?! sLkibs<! sqg<gz<gjtk<! kQIg<gUl<! guqjkgt<!
hjmg<gh<hm<Mt<te/! ohiK! -mr<gjth<! Oh{! Ou{<Ml<?! OhizqbieuIgjtg<!
g{<mxqf<K!dzgqx<Gg<! gim<m! Ou{<Ml<! we<El<!Nvib<s<sqbqZl<! guqjkgtqe<!
gVk<Kg<gt<!Le<eqx<gqe<xe/!olipq?!fiM?!-el<!gmf<K!yOv!dzgl<?!biuVl<!
lg<gt<?! dzgl<! njeuIg<Gl<! ohiK! we<El<! gVk<kqbz<! outqh<hiMl<!
okie<lr<gtqe<!&zl<!uiel<hicg<!guqjkgtqz<!gi{h<ohXgqe<xe/!!
!
163
sie<ox{<!uqtg<gl<!
!
2/ O\/lR<StiOkuq!)oki/N/*?!uiel<hicg<!guqjkgt<?!hg</4:.51/!!
3/ OlzK/?!h/36/!
4/ OlzK/?!h/5:/!
5/ OlzK/?!h/362/!!
6/ OlzK/?!h/37:/!
7/ Nze<! dm<̂ <! )klqpqz<;! -vi/sqShize<*?! OsiszqsLl<! liIg<sqbLl<! .! yV!
zk<kQe<!noliqg<g!djvbimz<?!h/25/!!
8/ O\/lR<StiOkuq!)oki/N/*?!uiel<hicg<!guqjkgt<?!h/41/!!
9/ OlzK/?!hg</8:.91/!!
:/ hivkqkise<!guqjkgt<?!h/336/!!
21/ O\/lR<StiOkuq!)oki/N/*?!uiel<hicg<!guqjkgt<?!h/:7/!!
22/ OlzK/?!h/6/!!
23/ npgqiq!hi{<cbe<?!Hvm<sqbitI!hqmz<!gi^<m<Ovi?!hg</62.64/!!
24/ hivkqbiI!guqjkgt<!)Hkqb!Nk<kq$c?!7:*?!h/411/!
25/ O\/lR<StiOkuq!)oki/N/*?!uiel<hicg<!guqjkgt<?!h/2:3/!
26/ OlzK/?!h/4/!
27/ OlzK/?!h/6/!
28/ OlzK/?!h/7/!
29/ npgqiq!hi{<cbe<?!Hvm<sqbitI!hqmz<!gi^<m<Ovi?!h/216/!
2:/ O\/lR<StiOkuq!)oki/N/*?!uiel<hicg<!guqjkgt<?!h/32/!!
31/ OlzK/?!hg</8.9/!!
32/ OlzK/?!h/2:/!
33/ OlzK/?!h/287/!!
34/ OlzK/?!h/295/!
35/ OlzK/?!h/35/!
36/ OlzK/?!h/228/!
37/ OlzK/?!h/215/!
38/ kqVg<Gxt<?!2158/!!
39/ OlzK/?!2159/!
3:/ O\/lR<StiOkuq!)oki/N/*?!uiel<hicg<!guqjkgt<?!h/73/!
41/ OlzK/?!h/229/!
164 42/ OlzK/?!h/275/!
43/ OlzK/?!h/338/!!
44/ OlzK/?!h/354/!!
45/ OlzK/?!h/71/!
46/ OlzK/?!h/358/!!
47/ OlzK/?!h/:6/!
48/ -vi/ovr<gl<lit<?! sq/uiSgq?! oh{<{qbl<! n[GLjxgTl<! -zg<gqbh<!
hbe<hiMl<?!hg</21.22/!!
49/ O\/lR<StiOkuq!)oki/N/*?!uiel<hicg<!guqjkgt<?!h/452/!!
4:/ OlzK/?!h/231/!
51/ OlzK/?!h/74/!!
52/ os/sivkil<hit<?!oh{<{qb!dth<!hGh<hib<Ul<!oh{<!wPk<Kl<?!h/:/!
53/ O\/lR<StiOkuq!)oki/N/*?!uiel<hicg<!guqjkgt<?!h/286/!!
54/ OlzK/?!h/54/!
55/ G/l/-vilik<kit<?!ohiqbiiqbh<!oh{<{qbl<?!hg</34.35/!
56/ kqVg<Gxt<?!2182/!
57/ OlzK/?!2184/!!
58/ O\/lR<StiOkuq!)oki/N/*?!uiel<hicg<!guqjkgt<?!h/545/!
59/ OlzK/?!hg</435.436/!!
5:/ OlzK/?!h/447/!!
61/ l/-viOsf<kqve<!)h/N/*?!gj{bipq?!lzI;61?!-kp<;21?!seuiq!3131?!h/5/!!
!
Nb<U!LcUjv!
!
! dzg! olipqgTt<! hjpjlg<Gh<! hjpjlbigUl<?! HKjlg<Gh<!
HKjlbigUl<! uqtr<GuK! klqp<olipqbiGl</! klqpqz<! guqjkbqe<! Okix<xl<!
wh<ohiPK! we<hjk! nXkqbqm<Mg<! %x! Lcbik! ntuqx<Gk<! okie<lg<!
gizk<kqOzOb! osb<Bt<! upg<G! -Vf<kqVg<gqxK/! gizf<OkiXl<! guqjkbqe<!
dVu! dt<tmg<gr<gt<! lixqg<ogi{<M! uf<kqVg<gqe<xe/! sr<g! gizk<kqz<!
Nsqiqbh<hi! ucul<! lqGkqbigUl<! Wjeb! hi! ujggt<! GjxuigUl<!
njlf<Kt<te/! nh<ohiPK! gikZl<! uQvLl<! lqGkqbigh<! Ohsh<hm<me/! nju!
ngk<kqj{bigUl<! Hxk<kqj{bigUl<! upr<gh<hMgqe<xe/! sr<gl<! lVuqb!
gizk<kqz<! ou{<hi! ucul<! lqGkqbigh<! hjmg<gh<! ohx<Xt<te/! -ux<xqz<!
nxg<gVk<Kg<gt<! lqGkqBl<! hkquigqBt<te/! gih<hqbr<gtqz<! okimIfqjzs<!
osb<Btig! Nsqiqbh<hig<gTl<! uqVk<kh<hig<gTl<! njlf<Kt<te/!
sqx<xqzg<gqbr<gtqz<!uqVk<kh<hig<gt<!lqGkq/!hg<kqh<himz<gtqZl<!uqVk<kh<hig<gt<!
lqGkq/!!
!
! hivkqbiI?! hivkqkise<?! ou/-vilzqr<gl<hqt<jt?! ui{qkise<?! Lcbvse<!
LkziOeiI! guqjkgtqz<! olipq?! -el<?! fiM?! uqMkjz?! oh{<[iqjl?!
gz<uqBiqjl?! uqpqh<H{IU! Lkzie! hz! ohiV{<jlgt<! Ohsh<hm<Mt<te/!
-jubjek<Kl<! Nsqiqbh<hig<gt</! -Vhkil<! F~x<xi{<Mk<! okimg<gk<kqz<!
hivkqbiI! use! guqjkgjt! wPkqeiI/! use! guqjkgTg<G! bih<hqzg<g{l<!
-z<jz/! f/hqs<s&Ik<kq! hivkqbiiqe<! use! guqjkgjtBl<?! -vuQf<kqvfik<!
ki%iqe<!gQkiR<szqjbBl<?!noliqg<g!fim<M!uiz<m<!uqm<leqe<!Hz<zqe<!-kp<gt<!
guqjkgjtBl<! hck<Kk<! kiEl<! nu<uiX! guqjk! hjmg<g! Ou{<Ml<! we<X!
w{<{qeiIA! bih<Hg<! gm<Mh<hicz<zik! guqjkbigqb! HKg<guqjkjb!
Lke<Lkzqz<!2:45!Nl<!N{<M!wPkqeiI/!!
!
! HKg<guqjkjb! f/hqs<s&Ik<kq?! HKjlh<hqk<ke<?! G/h/visOgihize<?!
sq/S/osz<zh<hi! LkziOeiI! wPkk<! okimr<gqeI/! HKg<guqjkbqe<! hiq{il!
utIs<sqbig!mie<gi!guqjk?!ja%!guqjk?!ose<iqB!guqjk?!zqliqg<!guqjk?!
zqoljvg<%! guqjk?! g^z<! guqjk?! jaHe<! guqjk! weh<! hz! ujggt<!
utIf<Kt<te/! klqp<g<! guqjkgt<! sLkibk<jk! Ofig<Ggqe<xeA! gizk<kqx<G!
Wx<x! ucuk<jk! wMk<Kg<! ogi{<Mt<te/! nju! gizk<kqx<G! Wx<x! sLkibh<!
166 hqvs<sjegjt!jlbligg<!ogi{<M!sLkibs<!sqg<gz<gjth<!Hiqf<K!ogit<Tl<!
ujgbqz<! uqpqh<H{Iu,m<Mgqe<xeA! sqg<gz<gTg<Gk<! kQIUgjtBl<!
Hzh<hMk<Kgqe<xe/!-u<uiX!gizf<OkiXl<!klqp<g<guqjkbqe<!Ofig<Gl<!Ohig<Gl<!
njlf<Kt<te/!!
!
! HKg<guqjk! Okie<xqb! gizk<kqz<! HKg<guqjkgjt! lvHg<guqRIgt<!
gq{<mZl<! OgzqBl<! osb<K! wkqIk<keI/! nf<k! wkqi<h<hqjeBl<! lQxq!
HKg<guqjkgjt! utIh<hkx<G! sqz! njlh<HgTl<! -kp<gTl<! Le<uf<ke/!
nux<Xt<! Gxqh<hqmk<kg<gK! ‘l{qg<ogic’! -kpiGl</! HKg<guqjkg<gigOu!
-kp<gTl<! njlh<HgTl<! okimr<gh<hm<me/! nux<Xt<! wPk<K?! gsmkhx?!
uiel<hic!Lkzieju!Gxqh<hqmk<kg<gjubiGl</!!
!
! OgibLk<K~iqz<! )Ogiju*! -zg<gqbuikqgt<! %c! ‘uiel<hic’!
-bg<gk<kqjek<! Okix<Xuqk<keI/!-f<k!-bg<gk<kqz<!-tLVG?!HuqbvS?!sqx<hq?!
Rieq?! ng<gqeqHk<kqve<?! Lz<jz! Nkue<?! L/Olk<ki?! lQvi?! nh<Kz<! vGlie<?!
sq/NI/-vuQf<kqve<?! sg<kqg<gez<! LkziOeiI! nr<gl<! ugqk<keI/! uiel<hic!
-bg<gk<kqeI! njeuVl<! ohiKUjmjl! -bg<gk<kqjes<! siIf<kqVf<kiIgt<A!
nkeiz<!ogit<jgbqZl<!d{IuqZl<!ye<Xhm<cVf<kiIgt<A!uiel<hic!-bg<gl<!
siIf<k! gVk<Kg<gjt! –! ogit<jggjt! –! uqpqh<H{Iuqje! lg<gtqmk<kqz<!
ogi{<M! OsIg<g! fqjek<kiIgt</! nux<jxg<! guqjk! ucuk<kqz<! hjmk<K!
outqbqm!w{<{q?!nkx<gig!Yi<!-kpqjek<!okimr<gk<!kqm<mlqm<miIgt</!!
!
! 1:/21/2:82! ne<X! uiel<hic! -kp<! Okix<xl<! ohx<xK/! uiel<hic!
-bg<gLl<! -kPl<! Ofvc!nvsqbz<! gm<sqbqz<! hr<Gohxuqz<jz/!Neiz<! givz<!
liIg<̂ <?! wr<ogz<̂ <?! 0hqmz<! gi^<m<Ovi?! OsGOuvi! LkziOeiiqe<!
ogit<jggjt! Wx<Xg<ogi{<M?! nux<jx! lg<gtqmk<kqz<! ogi{<M! OsIg<gg<!
guqjkgjth<! hjmk<Kt<teI/! -ux<xiz<! ohiKUjmjl?! slki<ll<?!
oh{<[iqjl?! gz<uq?! Oujzuib<h<H?! sikqobipqh<H! Lkzie! gVk<Kg<gjt!
lg<gtqmk<kqz<! ogi{<M! OsIk<keI/! -f<kg<! gVk<Kg<gt<! lg<gtqmk<K! lqg!
uqjvuqz<!osz<z!Ou{<Ml<!we<hkx<gigOu!–!uiel<hic!-kpqje!uqjzbqe<xq!
upr<gqeI/! uqjzbqzi! uiel<hic! -kp<! we<hkiz<! njeuVl<! uir<gqh<!
hck<keIA! hbe<! ohx<xeI/! uiel<hic! -bg<gk<kqeVt<! yVsqziqe<! Sbfz!
167 d{Iuiz<! nf<k! -bg<gl<! 24! N{<MgTmEl<! uiel<hic! -kp<! 33!
-kp<gTmEl<!LcUg<G!uf<ke/!!
!
! guqjkbqe<! outqh<him<Mk<! kqxeigqb! dk<kqgTt<! ‘okie<ll<’! we<El<!
dk<kq!lqgs<!sqxf<kkiGl</!klqp<h<!HKg<guqjkgTt<!-vile<?!sQjk?!-zg<Gue<?!
-viu{e<?! uqSuilqk<kqvI?! usqm<mI?! hi{<M?! KiqObikee<?! Ks<sikee<?!
kqovthkq?! kVlI?!nIs<See<?! sGeq?! Wgjzue<?! fte<?! klbf<kq?!nVs<See<?!
hiiq?! giiq?! Yiq?! nkqblie<?! ytjubiI?! kqVut<TuI?! Ogiuze<?! g{<{gq?!
likuq?!l{qOlgjz?!nm<sb!hik<kqvl<?!Hk<kI?!Ohikqlvl<?!-ObSfikI?!sqZju?!
sque<?!hiIukq?!kqVliz<!nukivr<gt<?!fibe<liIgt<?!Np<uiIgt<?!ljz?!gmz<!
Lkzie! -bx<jg?! gkqvue<?! uq{<lQe<?! fqzi?! -f<kqve<?! OkuIgt<! weh<! hz!
fqjzgtqz<! okie<lg<! %Xgt<! uf<Kt<te/! -f<kk<! okie<lg<! %Xgt<!
guqRIgtqe<! w{<{k<kqz<! Dxqbju/! -ju! gVk<Kg<gjt! outqh<hMk<k!
d{IU! fqjzbqZl<! dt<Tjx! fqjzbqZl<! Hzh<him<M! fqjzbqZl<!
hbe<hMgqe<xeA! OfIh<ohiVjtg<! gim<mUl<! ljxLgh<! ohiVjtg<! gim<mUl<!
dkuqbig!dt<te/!!
!
! uiel<hicg<! gizg<! guqjkgTt<! dujl?! dVugl<?! hcll<?! GxqbQM?!
Lv{<?! okie<ll<?! nr<gkl<! Lkzie! hz! dk<kqgt<! jgbith<! ohx<Xt<te/!
-ux<Xt<! okie<ll<! we<El<! dk<kqkie<! lqGkqbie! -mr<gtqz<!
gi{h<ohXgqe<xK/! Oukl<?! -kqgisl<?! gih<hqbl<?! sr<g! -zg<gqbl<?! fQkq!
-zg<gqbl<?! -bx<jg?! fqxl<?! le<eI?! HzuI?! Ohb<?! hqsiS?! fug<gqvgl<?!
hivkliki?! smr<Ggt<?! fim<Mh<Hx! lVk<Kul<! we! w{<{x<x! okie<lg<!%Xgt<!
uiel<hicg<! gizh<! HKg<guqjkgtqz<! -ml<ohx<Xt<te/! -bx<jgjb!nmg<Gl<!
Nx<xz<! uiel<hicg<! guqRIgTg<G! -Vh<hkigg<! %Xgqe<xeI/! yV! HK!
hqvtbk<kqjeOb!dVuig<gh<!Ohiukig!-uIgt<!guqjkgjth<!hjmk<Kt<teI/!!
!
! Hk<kI?! Ohikq!lvl<?! sqZju?!sQjk?!kqovthkq?!g{<{gq?!likuq!Ngqb!
okie<lg<! %Xgt<! uiel<hicg<! guqjkgtqz<! lqGkqbig! uf<Kt<te/! -f<kk<!
okie<lg<! %Xgt<! guqjkbqe<! hiMohiVjt! Ofvcbig! outqh<hMk<kUl<!
d{IU! fqjzbqz<!%Xukx<Gl<!dt<Tjxbigg<!%Xukx<Gl<! hbe<hm<Mt<te/!
yV! gVk<kqje! nh<hcOb! %xqeiz<! uisqh<huI! nz<zK! Ogm<huIg<G! nf<kg<!
gVk<kqje! dt<uir<Gukqz<! NIul<! -Vg<giK/! nkje! YI! dk<kq! &zl<!
168 outqh<hMk<Kl<OhiK! uisqh<hujv! nz<zK! Ogm<hujv! =Ig<gs<! osb<gqe<xK/!
-f<ks<!osbz<him<cz<!okie<lk<kqe<!hr<gtqh<H!-e<xqbjlbikkig!njlgqe<xK/!!
!
! uiel<hicg<! guqjkgtqe<! gVk<K! outqh<him<cz<! okie<lg<! %Xgt<!
Lkzqml<! ohXgqe<xe/! -f<kk<! okie<lg<! %Xgt<! &zl<! ohiKUjmjl?!
slkIll<?! Hvm<sq?! Ohivim<ml<?! HKjl! we<El<! Lx<Ohig<Gg<! gVk<Kg<gt<!
uzqBXk<kh<ohXgqe<xe/!!
!
! squh<H! we<El<! fqxg<GxqbQm<ceiz<! hz! gVk<Kg<gt<!
Hzh<hMk<kh<hMgqe<xe/! lg<gjt! ncjlk<! kjtbqzqVf<K! uqMuqg<g! Ou{<Ml</!
nkx<G!njek<Kl<!njeuIg<Gl<! ohiK! we<El<! ohiKUjmjl!kk<Kuk<jk!
njeuVl<!Olx<ogit<t!Ou{<Ml</!Lkzitqk<Kuk<jk!ypqg<g!Ou{<Ml</!Dpz<?!
jgb,m<M?! kQ{<mijl?! uXjl?! fqx! ncjl?! oh{<{cjl! Lkzieux<jx!
Lx<xqZl<! ypqg<g! Ou{<Ml</!d{<jlbie!djph<hitqjbh<! hivim<m! Ou{<Ml</!
Dkiiqgjt!Wlix<XhuIgjtk<!km<cg<!Ogm<Mg<!ogim<M!jug<g!Ou{<Ml</!oh{<!
ue<H{Is<sq?! uqjzlgtqI! Lkzie! -pqosbz<gt<! klqpI! h{<him<Mg<G!
-pqjuk<! kVl</! -ux<jxg<! gcb! Ou{<Ml</! fim<cz<! Ohizqs<silqbiIgTl<!
Ohizqg<! guqRIgTl<! dVuigq! uVgqe<xeI/! nf<kh<! Ohizq! leqkIgjtg<!
g{<mxqf<K?! lg<gtqmk<K! njmbitl<! gim<c! lg<gt<! uqpqh<H{IUme<! -Vg<g!
Ou{<Ml<! we<hkje! uiel<hicg<! guqjkgtqe<! okie<lg<! %Xgt<!
outqh<hMk<Kgqe<xe/!!
!
! -f<k! Nb<uqe<! okimIs<sqbig! uiel<hicg<! guqjkgtqz<! s&gs<!
sqg<gz<gt<?!uiel<hicg<!guqjkgtqz<! hcll<?!uiel<hicg<!guqjkgtqz<!Lv{<!
dk<kq?!uiel<hic!-kPl<!wPk<K!-kPl<!yh<hQM?!uiel<hic!-kPl<!gsmkhx!
-kPl<! yh<hQM! we<El<! kjzh<Hgtqz<! Olzib<U! osb<bzil<! we!-f<k!Nb<U!
hiqf<Kjv!osb<gqe<xK/!!
!
hqe<eqj{h<H!
Kj{F~x<!hm<cbz<!!
!
Lke<jl!Nkivl<!!
lR<StiOkuq?! O\/! )oki/N/*?! uiel<hicg<! guqjkgt<?! giu<bi! outqbQM?!
ose<je?!3124/!!
!
Kj{jl!Nkivr<gt<!!
ngk<kqbzqr<gl<?! s/?! guqjk! dVuig<gl<.3?! l{quisgI! hkqh<hgl<?! ose<je?!
2:::/!!
nh<Kz<!vGlie<?!OsikqlqG!fuguqjk?!Of]ez<!hh<tq]I^<?!ose<je?!3115/!!
nh<Kz<!vGlie<?!OfbI!uqVh<hl<?!Of]ez<!hh<tq]i<^<?!ose<je?!3114/!!
nh<Kz<! vGlie<?! lqe<lqeqgtiz<! yV! gckl<?! Of]ez<! hh<tq]i<^<?! ose<je?!
3115/!!
npgqiq! hi{<cbe<?! Hvm<sqbitI! hqmz<! gi^<m<Ovi?! hih<HzI! hh<tqOgse<^<?!
ose<je?!3118/!!
N{<mit<! hqiqbki<]qeq?!Lk<kr<gt<! kQIf<Kuqm<me?! Glve<! hkqh<hgl<?! ose<je?!
3115/!!
Nze<! dm< <̂! )klqpig<gl<;! -vi/sqShize<*?! OsiszqsLl<! liIg<sqbLl<! .! yV!
zk<kQe<!noliqg<g!djvbimz<?!NCBH?!ose<je?!311:/!!
-vk<kqe&Ik<kq?! ou/?! okiz<gih<hqb! Ofig<gqz<! HKg<guqjk?! klqpib<U! lb<bl<?!
gt<tqh<hm<c?!3111/!!
-viOsf<kqve<?!-vi/?! HKg<guqjk!-zg<g{l<?!-kbOvi\i! hkqh<hgl<?! ose<je?!
3115/!!
-viOsf<kqve<?!l/!)h/N/*?!gj{bipq?!lzI;65?!-kp<;21?!ose<je?!seuiq!3131/!!
-vilik<kit<?! G/l/?! ohiqbiiqbh<! oh{<{qbl<?! dzgk<! klqpivib<s<sq! fqXuel<?!
ose<je?!3118/!!
-vijlbihqt<jt!)d/N/*?!fx<xqj{?!uIk<kliee<!hkqh<hgl<?!ose<je?!2:::/!!
-tr<Ogi?!S/?!gXh<H!lzIgtqz<!osf<Oke<?!os'hq!hkqh<hgl<?!LVge<Ogim<jm?!
o\br<ogi{<ml<?!311:/!!
-tr<Ogiucgt<?!sqzh<hkqgivl<?!uIk<kliee<!hkqh<hgl<?!ose<je?!2::9/!!
-tl<h,v{I! )d/N/*?!okiz<gih<hqbl<!ohiVtkqgivl<?!gpg!outqbQM?!ose<je?!
2:98/!!
170 dlilOg^<uiq?!g/?!guqjk!utIk<k!l{qg<ogic?!NCBH?!ose<je?!3117/!!
Jbe<!ohVlit<!OgieiI!)d/N?*?!&Kjv?!hpeqbh<hi!hqvki<^<?!ose<je?!2:99/!!
gl<hI?!gl<hvilib{l<?!nObik<kqbi!gi{<ml<?!uIk<kliee<!hkqh<hgl<?!ose<je?!
2::9/!!
gl<hI?!gl<hvilib{l<?!hiz!gi{<ml<?!uIk<kliee<!hkqh<hgl<?!ose<je?!2::9/!!
gzih<iqbi?!lx<xir<Og?!ne<el<!outqbQM?!squgr<jg?!2:8:/!!
gz<bi{<\q?!Hziq?!ne<el<!outqbQM?!squgr<jg?!2:92/!!
guq! nvr<ge<?! guq! nvr<ge<! guqjkgt<?! K~iqjgh<! hkqh<hgl<?! osr<gz<hm<M?!
3122/!!
gegshihkq?! sq/?! hivkqBl<! hqxGl<! hqs<s&Ik<kqBl<! hqxVl<?! osz<li! outqbQM?!
squgr<jg?!2::1/!!
gegshihkq?!sq/?!HKg<guqjkbqe<!dVu!njlh<H”?!-/h/k/l/!Lkz<!gVk<kvr<g!
)2:7:*! Nb<Ug<Ogiju?! okiGkq! 2?! dzgk<! klqpivib<s<sq! fqXuel<?!
ose<je?!3111/!!
Ogiuqf<kviS?!li/?!HKg<guqjkg<!gm<mjlh<H?!NCBH?!ose<je?!3122/!!
sg<kqOuz<?!S/?!fim<Mh<Hx!-bz<!Nb<U?!l{quisgI!hkqh<hgl<?!ose<je?!3118/!!
sivkil<hit<?! os/?! oh{<{qb! dth<hGh<hib<Ul<! oh{<! wPk<Kl<?! dzgk<!
klqpivib<s<sq!fqXuel<?!ose<je?!3116/!!
sqr<givOuZ!LkzqbiI?!N/?! nhqkie! sqf<kil{q?! sivki! hkqh<hgl<?! ose<je?!
3112/!!
Sf<kv&Ik<kq?! -/?! &! nvS?! li/vi/! )h/N/*?! -zg<gqb! -kp<gt<?! dzgk<!
klqpivib<s<sq!fqXuel<?!ose<je?!3115/!!
Sh<hqvl{qbe<?!g/fi/?!g/fi/S/!guqjkgt<?!sf<kqbi!hkqh<hgl<?!ose<je?!3113/!!
Sh<hqvl{qbe<!g/fi/?!f/hqs<s&Ik<kq!fqjeuig?!okiGkq!II?!Ries<Osiq!outqbQM?!
ose<je?!2:9:/!!
Sh<jhbe<?!W/ok/?!njx%uz<?!sqgvl<!outqbQM?!ose<je?!2:91/!!
osgf<fike<?! N/?! HKg<guqjk! yV! kqxeib<U?! kqzge<! hkqh<hgl<?! Oljzb,I?!
2:89/!!
osbvile<?!f/uQ/?!HKg<guqjkbqbz<?!-zg<gqbh<!hkqh<hgl<?!ose<je?!2:91/!!
osz<zh<hi?! sq/S/?! klqpqz<! -zg<gqb! uqlIsel<?! wPk<K! hqvSv! outqbQM?!
ose<je?!2:85/!!
osz<zh<hi?!sq/S/?!DKuk<kqh<!Hz<?!hQgig<!hkqh<hgl<?!ose<je?!2::4/!!
osz<zh<hi?!sq/S/!)oki/N/*?!HKg<Gvz<gt<?!wPk<K!hqvSvl<?!ose<je?!2:85/!!
171 Rieq! )gq/hpeqs<silq*?! uiel<hicgtqe<! guqjk! -bg<gl<! .! uvziXl<!
hch<hqjegTl<?!giu<bi!outqbQM?!ose<je?!3122/!!
klqp{<{z<?! sr<g!-zg<gqb! yh<hQM?!-zg<gqbg<! ogit<jggt<?! lQeim<sq! Hk<kg!
fqjzbl<?!lKjv?!3122/!!
klqpue<?!-Vhkqz<!guqjk?! <̂miI!hqvSvl<?!hijtbr<Ogim<jm?!2:82/!!
klqpe<he<?!=OviM?!yV!u{<c!ose<iqB?!lVki!outqbQM?!ose<je?!3112/!!
klqpe<he<?!=OviM?!gjzbi"!jguqjebi"?!lVki!outqbQM?!ose<je?!3112/!!
klqpe<he<?! =OviM?! fjm! lxf<k! fkqBl<! kqjs! lixqb! YjmBl<?! h,l<HgiI!
hkqh<hgl<?!ose<je?!3115/!!
klqpe<he<?!=OviM?!u{g<gl<!ut<Tu"?!h,l<HgiI!hkqh<hgl<?!ose<je?!3116/!!
klqp<g<Gclge<?! L/?! hk<ki{<Mk<! klqp<g<! guqjkgt<! )2:78.2:87*?! nxqouitq!
hkqh<hgl<?!lKjv?!2:97/!!
klqp<fime<?!yV!uiel<hicbqe<!-zg<gqb!uiel<?!giu<bi!outqbQM?!ohr<g@I?!
2::1/!!
klqp<fime<?!klqp<fime<!guqjkgt<?!giu<bi!outqbQM?!ose<je?!3113/!!
klqp<fime<?!N'I?!sqxGgtiGl<!sqZjugt<?!NCBH?!ose<je?!3113/!!
kqbi'?!yV!%jm!yV!Ogich<!h,g<gt<?!NCBH?!ose<je?!3121/!
kqiqsjm?! heqbiz<! hm<m! hk<K! lvr<gt<?! T.K/okijvsilq! outqbQM?!
kqVuef<kHvl<?!2:89/!!
kqVut<TuI?!kqVg<Gxt<?!gpg!outqbQM?!ose<je?!2::1/!!
Oke<olipq?!w <̂/?!Kxuq!f{<M?!gizs<SuM!hkqh<hgl<?!figIOgiuqz<?!3119/!!
fGze<?!-V!fQ{<m!guqjkgt<?!uqVm<sl<!outqbQM?!ose<je?!2::2/!!
hR<sir<gl<?!g/?!okie<lk<!kqxeib<U?!ne<el<!outqbQM?!kR<siu,I?!3122/!!
hu{f<kq!LequI?!fe<E~z<?!gpg!outqbQM?!ose<je?!2:77/!!
hivkqkise<?!hivkqkise<!guqjkgt<?!NCBH?!ose<je?!2::4/!
hivkqbiI?!hivkqbiI!guqjkgt<?!l{quisgI!hkqh<hgl<?!sqkl<hvl<?!2:98/!!
hizSf<kvl<?!s/?!oke<E~z<?!kiljv!outqbQm<mgl<?!kR<siu,I?!2::2/!!
hizi?!HKg<guqjk!yV!HKh<hiIju?!ngvl<!outqbQM?!Gl<hOgi{l<?!2:::/!!
hqs<s&Ik<kq/!f/?!f/hqs<s&Ik<kq!guqjkgt<?!lkq!fqjzbl<?!ose<je?!3111/!!
Hk<klqk<kqvI?!uQvOsipqbl<?!gpg!outqbQM?!ose<je?!2:81/!!
ohVlit<?! n/gi/?! gizl<OkiXl<! okie<lr<gt<?! klqpqeq! outqbQM?! ose<je?!
3122/!!
172 ohie<l{q! juvLk<K?! sr<g! -zg<gqbk<kqz<! HKg<guqjkg<! %Xgt<?! $Ibi!
outqbQM?!ose<je?!3113/!!
lgiOkue<?!gkqI/?!okie<ll<!(Myth)?!osz<zh<hi!hkqh<hgl<?!lKjv?!3119/!!
lR<StiOkuq?! O\/?! liEml<! hicb! uiel<hic?! giu<bi! outqbQM?! ose<je?!
3115/!!
l{q?!sq/?!-Kujv…?!g<iqbi!outqbQM?!ose<je?!2::7/!!
lkqui{e<?! hi/?! ncuiel<! Ofig<gqs<! sqz! ncgt<?! gif<kq! hkqh<hgl<?!
fim<Ms<sijz?!hm<Mg<Ogim<jm?!3111/!!
ljxljz?! sq/-/?! HKg<guqjk;! Lh<ohVl<! dk<kqgt<?! kqVlgt<! fqjzbl<?!
ose<je?!2:97/!!
li{qg<geiI/!n/!)d/N/*?!HxfiE~X?!uIk<kliee<!hkqh<hgl<?!ose<je?!2:::/!!
lizkq!jlk<iq?!fQzq/?!gizs<SuM!hkqh<hgl<?!figIOgiuqz<?!3118/!!
lqk<vi?!oltel<!Slg<Gl<!uiel<?!sQjk!hkqh<hgl<?!ose<je?!3116/!!
lQvi?!wkqIgizk<!klqp<g<!guqjk?!ne<el<!outqbQM?!kR<siu,I?!3114/!!
lQvi?!geUgt<!+!gx<hjegt<!=!gigqkr<gt<?!ngvl<!outqbQM?!kR<siu,I?!3112/!
Lk<K?!S/?!klqpqz<!ja%?!ne<el<!outqbQM?!squgr<jg?!2::5/!!
Lk<Kfqzue<?!fi/?!Hkqb!lvHgt<?!ngvl<!outqbQM?!kR<siu,I?!3125/!!
Olk<ki?!L/?!DIuzl<?!kqVlgt<!fqjzbl<?!ose<je?!3115/!!
Olige<?! -vi/! )h/N/*?! sqx<hqbqe<! gm<Mjvgt<?! l{quisgI! hkqh<hgl<?! ose<je?!
2::7/!!
vi\liIk<ki{<me<! )oki/N/*?! ogir<GOkI! uip<g<jg?! okiGkq! 3?! Bjeomm<!
jvm<mi<^<?!ose<je?!3115/!!
vi\LVGhi{<cbe<?!we<Xl<!de<!…?!ne<el<!outqbQM?!squgr<jg?!2::5/!!
ovr<gl<lit<?! -vi/?! &! uiSgq?! sq/?! oh{<{qbl<! n[GLjxgTl<! -zg<gqbh<!
hbe<hiMl<?!nxqUh<!hkqh<hgl<?!ose<je?!3116/!!
zQziukq?!kq/!)oli/oh/*?!\h<hieqb!ja%?!ne<el<!outqbQM?!squgr<jg?!2:98/!!
usf<kvise<?! Kjv/?! Gx<xr<gOt! kQIh<H! wPkqeiz<?! -tf<Okuq! hkqh<hgl<?!
GVuvibh<Ohm<jm?!umix<giM?!2:93/!!
uz<zqg<g{<{e<! )oki/N/*?! wPk<K! –! sq/S/osz<zh<hi?! Rieqbivcgt<! klqp<!
le<xl<?!ose<je?!3112/!!
uz<zqg<g{<{e<?! HKg<guqjkbqe<! Okix<xLl<! utIs<sqBl<?! ngvl<! outqbQM?!
kR<siu,I?!3115/!!
173 uieliljz?! fi/?! liIg<sqb! s&guqbz<! ogit<jg?! njzgt<! outqbQm<mgl<?!
ose<je?!3119/!!
uqsbzm<Slq?! s/?! wz<zi! ljzgtqZl<! wiqBoliV! Gcjs?! dbqI! wPk<K!
hkqh<hgl<?!gVl{<mhl<?!kqVs<sq?!3122/!!
uqs<ufike<?! fi/?!Lt<tqz<! nlVl<! heqk<Ktq?! -Vuim<sq! -zg<gqbk<! KjxLg!
outqbQM?!ose<je?!3119/!!
Our<gmvile<?! gi/Ogi/?! klqp<! -zg<gqb! uvziX?! gjzbg! outqbQM?! hvlk<kq!
OuZ~I!–!filg<gz<!lium<ml<?!3112/!!
Ou[Ogihize<?!kq/Osi/?!lQm<sq!uq{<{h<hl<?!g<iqbi!outqbQM?!ose<je?!2:88/!!
juvLk<K?!-f<kh<!h,g<gt<!uqx<hjeg<gz<z?!$Ibi!outqbQM?!ose<je?!3115/!!
juvLk<K?!Ogt<uqgtiz<!yV!Out<uq?!$Ibi!outqbQM?!ose<je?!3114/!!
juvLk<K?!kqVk<kq!wPkqb!kQIh<Hgt<?!$Ibi!outqbQM?!ose<je?!3114/!!
]i\gie<?!hm<m!lvr<gt<?!dli!hqiq{<mI^<?!-jtbie<Gc?!2:91/!!
\igqI! fibg<?! uqR<Rie! ytqbqz<! GINEl<! jhhqTl<?! si\qki! Hg<! ose<mI?!
ose<je?!3123/!!
o\bf<ki?!ofz<jz?!kqj{!lbg<gl<?!Glve<!hkqh<hgl<?!ose<je?!3116/!!