of 30
8/9/2019 S52: Unmet Challenges in Clinical Research Informatics
1/30
UnmetChallengesResearch
InformaticsFacilitated
Discussion
of
Hands
On
Practitioners
BobDiLaura
ClevelandClinicalandTranslational
ScienceCollaborative
AMIANow!SpringConference
May2527,2010
Phoenix,AZ
8/9/2019 S52: Unmet Challenges in Clinical Research Informatics
2/30
WillWeEverKeepUp?
LeotLeydesdorffshowedthatknowledge
increasedfrom1933to2001byafactorof
approximately27milliontimes. Alittle
mathematicalanalysis
shows
that
this
representsadoublingofknowledgeitself
aboutevery2.75years.
Source:http://www.xenodochy.org/gs/hmod.html
Source:HunterL,CohenKB.BiomedicalLanguage
Processing:What'sBeyondPubMed?MolecularCell,21(5);
3March
2006,
589
594.
8/9/2019 S52: Unmet Challenges in Clinical Research Informatics
3/30
WhoLearnsfromPublications?
Over10yearsofexperienceinseveral
superiorways
to
teach
biomedical
,
healthcareprofessionals.Specific
andshortenthelearningcurveforsuchwork.
Source:Trainin health rofessionalsinbioinformatics.Ex eriencesandlessonslearned.Lo ezCam osG,Lo ez
AlonsoV,MartinSanchezF.MethodsofInformationinMedicine.2010;49(3):299304.
8/9/2019 S52: Unmet Challenges in Clinical Research Informatics
4/30
8/9/2019 S52: Unmet Challenges in Clinical Research Informatics
5/30
Format
for
This Discussion
8/9/2019 S52: Unmet Challenges in Clinical Research Informatics
6/30
InformaticsField FarandWide
BiomedicalInformatics MedicalInformatics Biostatistics
Clinical
Informatics HealthInformatics ComputerScience
Mathematics
Clinical
ImagingInformatics
HealthInformatics
Technology Physics
Patholo? PublicInformatics Neuroinformatics MolecularSystems
RadiologyBiochemistry
Car iacIn ormatics
TranslationalBioinformatics
BiologyScience
8/9/2019 S52: Unmet Challenges in Clinical Research Informatics
7/30
8/9/2019 S52: Unmet Challenges in Clinical Research Informatics
8/30
Terms&Definitions CRI
biomedicalinformaticsconcernedwiththedevelopment,application,andevaluationoftheories,methods,andsystemstooptimizethedesignandconductofclinicalresearchandtheanalysis,interpretation,anddisseminationo thein ormation enerated.
Source:ClinicalResearchInformatics:Challenges,OpportunitiesandDefinitionforanEmergingDomain,byEmbiPand
Payne
P.
J
Am
Med
Inform
Assoc.
2009;16:316
327.
DOI
10.1197/jamia.M3005.
8/9/2019 S52: Unmet Challenges in Clinical Research Informatics
9/30
InformaticsSpectrum
Source:ClinicalResearchInformatics:Challenges,OpportunitiesandDefinitionforanEmergingDomain,byEmbiPand
PayneP.JAmMedInformAssoc.2009;16:316327.DOI10.1197/jamia.M3005.
8/9/2019 S52: Unmet Challenges in Clinical Research Informatics
10/30
HowWeDoinSoFar?
8/9/2019 S52: Unmet Challenges in Clinical Research Informatics
11/30
BiomedicalInformaticsCompetenciesAcquireprofessionalperspective:Summarizeandexplainthehistoryandvaluesofthedisciplineanditsrelationshiptorelatedfieldswhiledemonstratinganabilitytoread,interpret,
andcritiquethecoreliterature
, , ,problemintermsofdata,informationandknowledgecomponents
Producesolutions:Usetheproblemanalysistoidentifyandunderstandthespaceofpossiblesolutionsandgeneratedesignsthatcaptureessentialaspectsofsolutionsandtheir
components
Articulatetherationale:Defendthespecificsolutionanditsadvantageovercompetingoptions
Im lement,evaluate,andrefine:Demonstrateanabilitytocarryoutthesolution,toassessitsvalidity,anditerativelyimproveitsdesign
Innovate:Createnewtheories,typologies,frameworks,representations,methods,andprocessestoaddressbiomedicalandinformaticsproblemsdiversedisciplines
Disseminateanddiscuss:Communicateeffectivelytoaudiencesinmultipledisciplinesinpersuasivewrittenandoralform
Source:AMIAAcademicForumsubcommitteeonBMICompetencies,2010.
8/9/2019 S52: Unmet Challenges in Clinical Research Informatics
12/30
BMI
Competencies
DRAFT
https://www.amia.org/files/shared/e_Competencies_
_Definition_and_Competencies.pdf
Tocomment
on
the
document:
http://www.surveymonkey.com/s/2JHGQWF
8/9/2019 S52: Unmet Challenges in Clinical Research Informatics
13/30
AMIANow!CRI2010Survey
8/9/2019 S52: Unmet Challenges in Clinical Research Informatics
14/30
OurSurvey ResponseCloud
Source:
http://www.tagcrowd.com/
8/9/2019 S52: Unmet Challenges in Clinical Research Informatics
15/30
Survey AnotherCloudView
Source:http://www.wordle.net/
8/9/2019 S52: Unmet Challenges in Clinical Research Informatics
16/30
Survey FinalView
Source:http://www.wordle.net/
8/9/2019 S52: Unmet Challenges in Clinical Research Informatics
17/30
Survey TopFutureChallenges
1. Funding,staffandinfrastructureresourcesforCRI
2. EMR
research
integration
of
workflow
&
data3. Standardizationofdata,protocols,processes&HIE
8/9/2019 S52: Unmet Challenges in Clinical Research Informatics
18/30
HowWeDoinSoFar?
8/9/2019 S52: Unmet Challenges in Clinical Research Informatics
19/30
CTSAPgmGoals&KeyFunctions
Source:
http://www.ctsaweb.org/index.cfm?fuseaction=quicklink.showSGC
8/9/2019 S52: Unmet Challenges in Clinical Research Informatics
20/30
The
800
lb
Gorilla
(patient
HIT)
Source:http://www.healthypeople.gov
8/9/2019 S52: Unmet Challenges in Clinical Research Informatics
21/30
PatientHITfromONC
Source:http://healthit.hhs.gov
8/9/2019 S52: Unmet Challenges in Clinical Research Informatics
22/30
ThemesfortheFutureofBMI
1. Buildouttheenterpriseresearchinfrastructure
2. Researchprocessdesign,portals&workflowmgt
3. Data
storage,
access
and
security4. Systemintegration&researchinfo/dataexchange
5. EHRCRconnections(technical,policy,legal)
6. Knowledge
management. ngo ng ra n ngan e uca on us o eepup
8. More/better/fastercommunication,collaborations
. ,
10. Informaticsleadership
8/9/2019 S52: Unmet Challenges in Clinical Research Informatics
23/30
HowWeDoinSoFar?
8/9/2019 S52: Unmet Challenges in Clinical Research Informatics
24/30
InformaticsCareerPaths
Academic
Scientist Technolo ist
8/9/2019 S52: Unmet Challenges in Clinical Research Informatics
25/30
Metrics&Evaluation
Howdoweknowwhatwe aredoing?
How
do
we define
value or
goals? Whatdoesour datasay?
Howdowe targetorquantifyimprovement?
*
If ignorance is bliss, why aren't more people happy?Thomas Jefferson
Source: Brandenburger A, Nalebuff B. 1996. Co-Opetition: A revolution mindset that combines competition and cooperation.
8/9/2019 S52: Unmet Challenges in Clinical Research Informatics
26/30
BMIMetricsProcessandPlan
Strategic goals Areas of im ortance
Key performance indicators Metrics plan
Reporting and improvements
Ongoing metrics adjustments
Areinvestigators
Source:DraftTwoYearStrategicInformationTechnologyPlan.
Dr.DixieBaker CTO HealthSolutions SAIC March2009.
satisfied
with
informaticssupport
theyreceive?
8/9/2019 S52: Unmet Challenges in Clinical Research Informatics
27/30
HowWeDoinSoFar?
8/9/2019 S52: Unmet Challenges in Clinical Research Informatics
28/30
8/9/2019 S52: Unmet Challenges in Clinical Research Informatics
29/30
8/9/2019 S52: Unmet Challenges in Clinical Research Informatics
30/30
ThankYou
pec a t a n sto au arr s orconceptualdevelopmentoftheClinicalResearchInformaticstrackin
AMIANow!
as
well
as
this
session
This presentation was made possible by the Case Western Reserve
National Center for Research Resources (NCRR), a component of theNational Institutes of Health and NIH roadmap for Medical Research.