Saltwater intrusion into tidal freshwater
wetlands initiates change across multiple
levels of ecological organization
Scott C. Neubauer1, Rima B. Franklin2, Michael F. Piehler3
1 University of South Carolina, Baruch Marine Field Laboratory 2 Virginia Commonwealth University, Department of Biology 3 University of North Carolina, Institute of Marine Sciences
Marsh TypeAverage AnnualSalinity
< 0.5 ppt
< 5.0 ppt
< 18.0 ppt
< 30.0 ppt
OceanEuhaline(Marine)
Mesohaline
Polyhaline
Oligohaline
TidalFreshwater
NontidalFreshwater
Limit of tidalinfluence
The diversity of coastal wetland
types is tremendous
Tidal freshwater marsh
Salt marsh Mangrove forest
Cypress swamp
Odum et al. 1984. FWS/OBS-83/17
Research questions
How do saltwater intrusion and altered hydrology …
… affect soil microbial processes and dynamics ?
… modify wetland plant communities ?
… impact ecosystem carbon cycling ?
… influence marsh resilience and sustainability ?
*
Atlantic coast of
North America
¿ Where am I working ?
• Brookgreen
» Tidal freshwater marsh
» 30+ herbaceous plant species
» Organic-rich soils (~60% organic, ~30% C)
» Semi-diurnal tides, doesn’t flood every tide
Experimental design
» 5 “control” plots = no manipulation
» 5 “+fresh” plots = add fresh water
» 5 “+salt” plots = add brackish water
» Started 16 June 2008, repeated ~2x per
week through 15 Nov 2011
» Add 40 L fresh or brackish water to each
+fresh and +salt plot
• freshwater from 180 m well
• brackish water is diluted seawater
» 338 water addition dates
» ~133,000 L water
¡ Salty marsh = success !
Control, +fresh, and +salt data: n = 5 plots x 2 depths (10 & 25 cm) per plot;
Ambient data: n = 2 locations x 2 depths per location
means ± std dev
Porewater
Research questions
How do saltwater intrusion and altered hydrology …
… affect soil microbial processes and dynamics ?
… modify wetland plant communities ?
… impact ecosystem carbon cycling ?
… influence marsh resilience and sustainability ?
• Microbial community structure (TRFLP, qPCR)
• Rates of CO2 and CH4 production, soil O2 demand
• Denitrification and DNRA
• Extracellular enzyme activity
Soil CO2 and CH4 production
Soil slurries mimic field salinities (S = 0
for control and +fresh; S = 2 for +salt)
Treatment means ± standard deviation, n = 5 plots per data point
Soils collected
Nov 2011
» CO2 production …
… decreases with depth
… in surface soils, is highest in control
and +fresh plots
… in deeper soils, no differences
» CH4 production …
… more variable than CO2 prod.
… shows similar depth and treatment
patterns
Aerobic–anaerobic coupling
» “Denitrification” …
… highest in control plots
… lowest in +salt plots
… driven by nitrification rather than uptake of water-
column NO3-
Net N2 production
(flux out of soil)
C > S
Whole-core incubations. Treatment means ± standard error, n = 5 plots
» Aerobic biogeochemical activity …
… lowest in +salt plots
… ~6x higher in control plots
Soil O2 demand
(flux into soil)
C > F > S
Research questions
How do saltwater intrusion and altered hydrology …
… affect soil microbial processes and dynamics ?
… modify wetland plant communities ?
… impact ecosystem carbon cycling ?
… influence marsh resilience and sustainability ?
• Species presence/absence, richness, stem density)
• Aboveground biomass (non-destructive)
• Leaf-level photosynthesis and fluorescence
• Belowground root/rhizome biomass
Plant responses …
Bold points are treatment medians; faint symbols are for individual plots
Cicuta maculata
Spotted water hemlock
Ste
m d
ensity (
# m
-2)
(C = F) > S
+salt
+fresh control
Symphyotrichum sp.
Aster
Zizaniopsis miliacea
Giant cutgrass
… to salinity
… to freshwater •
– 1)
… to salinity
… to freshwater +
–
– 2) … to salinity
… to freshwater •
+ • 3)
F > C > S
+salt
+fresh
control
S > (C=F)
+salt
+fresh control
Community richness and biomass
» Freshwater inputs increased total*
biomass
» Elevated salinity decreased total*
biomass
» Total* biomass ~85% of total plot
biomass (range: 42-97%, 5 external
plots each in Aug and Sep 2011; all
treatment plots in Nov 2011)
Species richness Total* biomass
» Salinity reduced species richness
by 50-75%
» Richness was slightly lower in
+fresh plots relative to controls
Points are means ± standard deviation, n = 5 plots per data point.
C > F > S F > C > S
Research questions
How do saltwater intrusion and altered hydrology …
… affect soil microbial processes and dynamics ?
… modify wetland plant communities ?
… impact ecosystem carbon cycling ?
… influence marsh resilience and sustainability ?
• Gross ecosystem production
• Ecosystem CO2 and CH4 emissions
• Net ecosystem production
• Soil C/N inventories, 137Cs accretion
Ecosystem carbon fluxes
» Marsh-atmosphere CO2 and CH4 exchanges … temperature-controlled chambers
… ~ monthly from May 2008 thru Nov 2011
» Modeled monthly and annual fluxes … photosynthesis vs. light curves
… respiration vs. temperature relationships
… weather data
Annual flux summary
» Gross ecosystem production … consistently lowest in +salt treatment
… similar between control and +fresh plots
» Ecosystem respiration … CO2 and CH4: lowest in +salt treatment
… CO2
• 2008/09: higher in control than +fresh
• 2010/11: similar in control and +fresh
… CH4 generally similar in control and +fresh
» Net ecosystem production … positive in all treatments and all years
… lowest in +salt treatment in some years, but
not others
Thanks!
BMFL/USC
• Amanda Rotella
• Rebecca Schwartz
• Liana Nichols
• Olivia De Meo
• Paul Kenny
• Stephen Forehand
• Seth Stewart
UNC – IMS
• Ashley Smyth
VCU
• David Berrier
• Ember Morrissey
• Jaimie Gillespie
• Bonnie Brown
• Leigh McCallister
• Lindsey Koren
VIMS
• Lori Sutter
Other
• Tom Marshall
• Shan Deeter
• Troy Washam
• Michelle, Isabella, Ryleigh Neubauer
• Dorothy Silvernail
• staff of Brookgreen Gardens
Drivers of ecosystem processes
» Tight coupling between CH4 emissions
and precipitation … rainfall affects soil oxygenation?
… effect of freshwater additions greatest in drier
years
… emissions from +salt plots consistently low
» “Rainfall effect” not seen in CO2 fluxes … greatest effect of freshwater additions in
cooler years (2008/2009)
… temperature x treatment interaction?
2008, 2009: 26.3°C
2010, 2011: 27.2°C
Average summer temp.
Disturbance effects across scales
Microbes
Biogeochemical activity
CO2 production:
CH4 production:
Denitrification:
Plants
Community
Richness:
Biomass:
Density:
Biomass:
Populations
Ecosystem functioning
CO2 fixation:
CO2 emissions:
CH4 emissions:
Net ecosystem production:
Incre
ased f
resh
wate
r in
puts
+ +
•
– • + • • + •
–
+
• • –
• • –
• • •
• + •
Environm
enta
l change
Disturbance effects across scales
Microbes
Biogeochemical activity
CO2 production:
CH4 production:
Denitrification:
Plants
Community
Richness:
Biomass:
Density:
Biomass:
Populations
Ecosystem functioning
CO2 fixation:
CO2 emissions:
CH4 emissions:
Net ecosystem production:
Saltw
ate
r in
trusio
n
+
–
–
–
– – • + – – •
– –
– – –
– – –
– – –
– – •
Change in flux
Time scale CO2 production CH4 production
Soil CO2 and CH4 production
3-8 cm soil layer, bars are treatment medians; symbols are values for each plot.
Experiment #2:
Incubate soils at multiple salinities (S = 0, 2, 5)
Short-term (no effect) 96% decrease
Long-term 60% decrease 85% decrease
Gross ecosystem production
(median model results with bars indicating 25th-75th percentiles)
(2008 and 2009 data in Neubauer, Online First article, Estuaries and Coasts)
» Initially, gross ecosystem production initially higher in +salt plots
» During last 3 years, GEP consistently lower in +salt plots than in
other treatments
Ecosystem respiration
(2008 and 2009 data in Neubauer, Online First article, Estuaries and Coasts)
(median model results with bars indicating 25th-75th percentiles)
» Growing season CO2 emissions higher in control and +fresh plots
» Summer peak in CH4 emissions not as pronounced in +salt plots
» Respiration is dominated by non-methanogenic pathways,
regardless of treatment.
Net ecosystem production
(median model results with bars indicating 25th-75th percentiles)
(2008 and 2009 data in Neubauer, Online First article, Estuaries and Coasts)
Soil enzyme activity
Treatment means ± standard error, n = 5.
Soils collected Nov 2011
» No treatment differences in “labile”
enzyme activity
» Considerably lower activity of enzymes for
degrading “recalcitrant’ lignin in +salt plots
Data from RB Franklin.
Enzymes for degrading cellulose
… ß-glucosidase, cellobiosidase
Enzymes for degrading lignin
… phenol oxidase, peroxidase
“labile”
“recalcitrant”
» Patterns may reflect inhibition of phenol oxidase and peroxidase by
… low O2 ?
… salt ?
… sulfide ?
» Similar patterns at 8-13 cm, but few
differences at 23-28 cm
“recalc
itra
nt”
“labile”
Photosynthesis and fluorescence
P. virginica (Apr 2011) Z. miliacea (Oct 2011)
Peltandra virginica
» Increased water inputs decreased leaf photosynthesis by 60%
» Salinity decreased photosynthesis by another 35%
Zizaniopsis miliacea
» No effect of salinity or increased water inputs on …
… leaf photosynthesis
… leaf fluorescence
C > F > S
n.s.
n.s.
Data from LA Sutter, VIMS
Microbial community composition
Surface soils collected Oct 2009
» DNA fingerprinting (TRFLP)
… significant community shifts due to saltwater
intrusion
» Do communities vary with depth?
» Have there been additional changes in
community composition over time?
Aerobic and anaerobic activity
» Aerobic biogeochemical activity …
… lowest in +salt plots
… ~6x higher in control plots
Soil O2 demand
(flux into soil)
» Both aerobic and anaerobic activity
show similar treatment differences …
… but only in near-surface soils
… no correlation in deeper soils
C > F > S
Whole-core incubations. Treatment means ± standard error, n = 5 plots per column.