Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 1Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 1
Flammable Cryogenic Liquid Carriers
Thank You to the Seminar Sponsor
Seminar Provider and Host
Saturday, March 19, 2016
Newport County, Rhode Island, USA
Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 2Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 2
Agenda & Topics
Morning 0830 - 1230
01 Introduction
02 LNG Properties and Characteristics
03 LNG Hazards
04 LNG Industry overview
Afternoon
1330 – 1630 Interactive Work Shop
05 LNG Fuel Vessel Design and Construction
06 Fuel Tanks and Fuel Supply Systems
07 Gas Atmosphere Control and Monitoring, Venting,
Inerting, unique repair hazards
Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 3Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 3
02 Physical & Chemical Properties
Properties and Characteristics of LNG and natural gas
Pressure and Temperature, including vapor pressure / temperature relationship
Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 4
LNG Properties and Characteristics
• LNG is natural gas which has been converted to liquid form for ease of transport and storage
• LNG is composed of mostly methane, with ethane, propane, butane, pentane and other trace liquid gases
• When liquefied the natural gas volume is reduced by a factor of about 600 to 1
• LNG is odorless, colorless, non-corrosive, non-flammable, and non-toxic
• The properties that make LNG a good source of energy can also make it hazardous if not fully contained
Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 5Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 5
Interactive Exercise
Refer to the LNG Safety Data Sheet:
• What is the boiling point of LNG?
• - 162°C (~- 160°C, varies with composition)
• What is the flashpoint of LNG?
• -187.8°C
• What is the specific gravity of LNG?
• 0.45 t/m3 (varies with composition)
• What are the flammable limits for LNG?
• 5%-15% (gas, by volume in air)
• What is the auto ignition temperature of LNG?
• 537°C
• What is the chemical formula for methane?
• CH4
• Based on the SDS, what are the primary hazards?
• Flammability, cryogenic hazard, asphyxiation
Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 6Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 6
LNG Properties
Minimum ignition energy: < 1mJ
-162° C
-188° C
5% - 15%
537 ° C
Not much!
1.333 Bar
Lighter than air*
Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 7
Composition of LNG
Chemical Chemical
Formula
Low High
Methane CH4 87% 99%
Ethane C2H6 <1% 10%
Propane C3H8 >1% 5%
Butane C4H10 >1% >1%
Nitrogen N2 0.1% 1%
Other
Hydrocarbons
Various Trace Trace
Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 8
Cryogenic Liquids
• LNG boiling point ~ -160 °C (at
atmospheric pressure, depending on
composition)
• LNG is one of the “warmer”
cryogens
• Most materials become brittle at
cryogenic temperatures
•Steel
•Many plastics
•Rubber (i.e. gaskets)
•Skin
• Suitable materials for LNG service:
•Stainless Steel
•Nickel Steel (9% Ni, Invar,
etc.)
•Aluminum
• Common Cryogens
• Boiling Points:
• Ethane, -83.3 °C
• Ethylene, -104 ° C
• LNG (methane) -162 °C
• Oxygen, -183 ° C
• Argon, -186 ° C
• Nitrogen, -196 ° C
• Hydrogen, -253 ° C
• Helium, -269 ° C
Cryogenic fluids are gases that
have been liquefied by having
their temperature brought below –
150°C*
All cryogenic liquids are gases at normal temperatures and pressures.(http://www.ccohs.ca/oshanswers/prevention/cryogens.html)
Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 9
LNG Characteristics
• Like all liquid fuels, LNG in it’s liquid state is not explosive and cannot burn
• In order to burn LNG must first be vaporized, mixed with air into the correct proportions and then ignited
• Vaporized LNG is NOT explosive. The flame speed is very slow
• (~ 6.4 kmh- the risk of unconfined Vapor Cloud Explosion is low
• Cold vapor is heavier than air and can form flammable mixtures in low / enclosed spots– venting consideration
Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 10
Heat of Combustion
• LNG burns hot, which is why it’s such a great fuel…
But… The radiant heat of an LNG fire is a safety concern of government regulators , fire and safety officials, and the public.
Combustion of spilled LNG vapor clouds will involve combustion of “heavies”(propane, ethane and butane), adding uncertainty to thermal radiation calculations
Gasoline 2087°C
Methane 1950°C
Propane 1980 °C
Fuel Oil ( Diesel / IFO / HFO) 2100°C
Natural Gas 1960°C
Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 11Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 11
LNG Energy Content
Energy Content:1 gal of Diesel = ~139,000 Btu1 Gal of LNG = ~ 82,000 Btu1 Diesel Gal Equivalent (DGE) = 1.7 [139,000btu/82,000Btu = 1.7DGE]
Energy Density:1 gal of LNG weighs 3.8 lb1 gal of diesel weighs 6.9 lb
Pound for pound, more energy in LNG:Diesel = ~20,145 Btu/lbLNG = 21,579 Btu / lb
Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 12
Conversions and Equivalents
cubic
metre gas
cubic foot
gas
million Btu therm gigajoule kilowatt
hour
cubic metre of
LNG
ton of
LNG
1 cubic
meter
gas
1 35.3 0.036 0.36 0.038 10.54 0.00171 0.000725
1 cubic
foot gas0.0283 1 0.00102 0.0102 0.00108 0.299 0.00005 0.00002
1-million
Btu27.8 981 1 10 1.054 292.7 0.048 0.0192
1 therm2.78 98.1 0.1 1 0.105448 29.27 0.0048 0.00192
1
gigajoule26.3 930 0.95 9.5 1 277.5 0.045 0.018
1 kilowatt
hour0.0949 3.3 0.003415 0.03418 0.0036 1 0.000162 0.000065
1 cubic
meter
LNG
584 20 631 21.04 210.4 22.19 6,173 1 0.405
1 ton
LNG1,379 48 690 52 520 54.8 15 222 2.47 1
• The LNG Business is unit-challenged!
Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 13
Conversions and Equivalent Units
• There’s an App for that!
• www.natgas.info, Chart, Air Products, DNV
• Available for iPhone and Android
Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 14
Boiling Point
• The Boiling Point of LNG is about -160°C (260ºF)
• LNG continuously warms due to contact with the warmer surrounding environment.
• The continuous boiling process presents challenges in the safe storage and containment of LNG
• Boiling produces LNG Vapor known as boil-off gas (BOG)
Heat In-leak
Boil-off
Vapor
Liquid
Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 15
Boiling Point of LNG Components
• Common components of LNG boil at widely varying temperatures:
• Composition of LNG can change as it boils – if vented or consumed, it
“weathers”
• Components with the lowest boiling points, nitrogen and methane, will
evaporate first.
• Proportion of “heavies” increases as methane boils off
FuelBoiling
Point (oC)
Methane (Natural
Gas)-161.5
Ethane -89.0
Propane -42.0
IsoButane -11.7
n-Butane -1.0
IsoPentane 27.7
n-Pentane 36
n-Hexane 68
Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 16
Rule 2:Don’t let LNG come in contact
with Air!
The flammable range for Methane in air is approximately 5% to 15%
Flammable Range
Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 17
Density of LNG
•The density of LNG falls between 430 kg/m3 and 470 kg/m3
depending upon actual composition.
•LNG is less than half the density of water; therefore an LNG spill will
always float on water.
– Density of MDO: 890kg/m3
Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 18
Relative Density of Methane Vapor
• Methane vapor is lighter than
air at temperatures above -
100°C
• This makes CH4 a relatively
safe gas to handle as leaks
will not create ‘puddles’ of
flammable vapor
• Operators must beware of
the potential for vented gas
to be heavier than air initially
• Significant during LNG
fueling, particularly in active
port areas
0.656 kg/m3 @ 25 °C, 1 atm
0.716 kg/m3 @ 0 °C, 1 atm
Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 19
Understanding the ‘Gas Laws’
• All gases have 3 quantifiable characteristics:
•volume, temperature, and pressure, all of which may
change
• The Ideal Gas Law 𝑷𝑽 = 𝒏𝑹𝑻
explains the behavior of gases
when temperature, pressure
and volume are changing
Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 20
• Boyle’s Law: for a fixed amount of gas at a fixed temperature, the pressure and volume are inversely proportional.
pV = constant
Vo
lum
e V
Pressure P
Pressure increase = Volume decrease
LNG Properties and Characteristics
Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 21
• Charles’s Law says that for a fixed amount of gas at a fixed pressure, the volume is proportional to the temperature.
V/T = constant
Volume V
Tem
per
atu
re (
T)
Temperature increase = Volume increase
LNG Fuel Properties and Characteristics
Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 22
• Gay-Lussac’s Law says that for a fixed amount of gas at a fixed volume, the pressure is proportional to the temperature.
Tem
per
atu
re T
Pressure P
Temperature increase = Pressure increase
LNG Fuel Properties and Characteristics
P/T = constant
Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 23Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 23
Volume / Pressure / Temperature Relationship
About 600XLNGNatural
Gas
1. Fixed amount, fixed temperature:
Pressure increase = Volume decrease
2. Fixed amount, fixed pressure:
Temperature increase = Volume increase
3. Fixed amount, fixed volume:Temperature increase = Pressure increase
Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 24Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 24
Saturated Vapor Pressure (SVP)
• Bubbles form and break through the
surface to occupy the space above as
vapor
• Some vapor molecules near the surface
re-condense to liquid
• Saturation pressure is the pressure at
which the liquid and vapor phase can
exist in equilibrium with each other at a
given temperature.
• As the pressure is increased so is the
saturation temperature, until the critical
point is reached
The pressure exerted by a saturated vapor at a particular temperature
Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 25Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 25
Boiling Point vs Pressure
25
Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 26Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 26
Temperature and Density
Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 27
Weathering (aka “Ageing”):
• Boil-off process of LNG changes its composition
• Produces a liquid with a changing heating value and density, altering the value of the LNG
Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 28Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 28
Critical Temperature and Pressure
● The temperature above which the substance cannot be liquefied however great the pressure
● The pressure at which a substance exists in the liquid state at its critical temperature.
● Equal to the saturation pressure at the critical temperature.
● It is the pressure required to compress a gas to its liquid state at its critical temperature
LNG Critical pressure: 44.7 Bar
LNG Critical Temp: -82.5 C
-82.5 °C (-117 F) 44.7 bar (648 PSI)
Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 29Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 29
Knowledge Check
• What are the primary components of LNG?
• Methane Ethane Propane Butane Nitrogen
• What is the molecular structure of methane?
• 1 carbon atom and 4 hydrogen atoms
• Can the properties of LNG change over time?
• Yes- boil-off can change composition, heating value and density
• True or False? LNG burns hotter than conventional fuels
• False- gasoline, diesel, propane, HFO all burn hotter
• Define Saturated Vapor Pressure (SVP):
• Liquid phase and vapor phase are in equilibrium
• True or False? You need nearly 2 times more LNG fuel to get the same
amount of energy in diesel fuel
• True, LNG / diesel energy equivalent is 1.7x
29
Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 30Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 30
End of Section
Questions?
Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 31Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 31
References
CG –OES Policy Letter No. 01-15, GUIDELINES FOR LIQUEFIED NATURAL GAS FUEL TRANSFER OPERATIONS AND TRAINING OF PERSONNEL ON VESSELS USING NATURAL GAS AS FUEL, February 19, 2015
IMO MSC 285(86), Interim Guidelines on Safety for Natural Gas-Fuelled Engine Installations in Ships, 1 June 2009
CG-521 Policy Letter -1-12 DESIGN CRITERIA FOR NATURAL GAS SYSTEMS, April 19, 2012
IMO STCW.7 Circ 23, Interim Guidance on training for seafarers on board ships using gases or other low-flashpoint fuels
HTW 1/17 Development of the International Code of Safety for Ships Using Gases or Low-Flashpoint Fuels (IGF Code)
IMO CCC 1/13/Add.1., Annex 4, DRAFT INTERNATIONAL CODE OF SAFETY FOR SHIPS USING GASES OR OTHER LOW-FLASHPOINT FUELS (IGF CODE)
ISO TS 18683 Jan 2015, Guidelines for systems and installations for supply of LNG as fuel to ships
Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 32Copyright © 2016 United States Maritime Resource Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 32
References (continued)
ISGOTT 5th Edition
SIGTTO Liquefied Gas Handling Principles on Ships and in Terminals , 3rd Edition 2000
SIGTTO LNG Drip Trays Guidance
SIGTTO Guidance for the Prevention of Rollover in LNG Ships Contents
SIGTTO LNG Transfer Arms and Manifold Draining, Purging and Disconnection Procedure
SIGTTO Use of Insulation Flanges (and Electrically Discontinuous Hoses) at the Ship/Shore and Ship/Ship Interface
ABS Guide for PROPULSION AND AUXILIARY SYSTEMS FOR GAS FUELED SHIPS (May 2011, updated February 2014)
ABS Bunkering of Liquefied Natural Gas-fueled Marine Vessels in North America 2ND EDITION