S , S.BROWN UNIVERSITYPROVIDENCE, R. I.
I AFCRLd 949
EQUIVALENT CIRCUIT PARAMETER FOR ANINHOMOGENEOUS BIFURCATED WAVEGUIDE
BY
H. M. CRONSON MA._• DAXTU 9 AUJY OYDMPAUOI
ABBRDLEN I ROT'NG GWU= • XD'
6 ARF9(604)-4561 z .Orepo - 456113
S• 1961
AFCRI 949
IEQUIVALENT CIRCUIT PAR-METER FOR AN
3 INHOMOGENEOUS B ,URCATED WAVEGUIDE
By
I H. M. Cronson
U Scientific Report AF 4561A/3
3 DIVISION OF ENG1NEERING
BROWN UNIVERSITY
PROCVIDENCE, RHODE ISLAND
September 1961
Contract Monitor: Dr. Werner W. Gerbes
I "The research reported in this document has been sponsored in part by theElectronics Research Directorate of the Air Force Cambridge Research Lab-oratories, Office of Aerospace Research, and by the Office of Naval Re-search and the David Taylor Model Basin. The publication of this reportdoes not necessarily constitute approval by the Air Force of the findingsor conclusions contained herein."Contract title: iResearch Directed r th study of Radiation of Elec-
tromagnetic Wavesi
I Contract number: AF 19(604)-4561
I
I003i
III
"Requests for additional copies by Agencies of the Depart-ment of Defense, their contractors, and other Government agenciesshould be directed to the:
I ARMED SERVICES TECHNICAL INFORMATION AGENCYARLINGTON HALL STATIONARLINGTON 12, VIRGINIA"
"All other persons and organizations should apply to the:
U. S. DEPAR'ThfLW OF CO-ERCEOFFICE OF TECHNIICAL SERVICES
WASHINGTON 25, D.C."
IINIIIII
I
TABLE OF CONTENTS
PAGE
Abstract ....... ii
I. Introduction 0.0
II. Field Equations 000
A. Reduction to a Half-Space Problem ...... o ....... ... • 3
B. Field representation in the Half-Space Guide .......... 3
III. Equivalent Circuit Representation ...................... •• 7
A. The Transmission Line Analogy of a Parallel
Plate Waveguide................7............... •. 7
B. The Waveguide Junction as an Equivalent Circuit .*.... 9
IV. Determination of the Network Capacitances .... o. * ........ .... 14
V. Solution of the Equations ........ ................... •.. 20
A. Parameters 20
B. Method of Approxima~tion ,....o....... *........... ..... 20
C. Coiipaftfson with the Results Obtained by Marcuvitz
for Ej = 60 . . 25
VI. Scattering Description 29
References .0...... . .. ..0.000000000000.00000.0000000 ....... . . 35
I
I
I.
ABSTRACT
In this report an approximate solution for an equivalent circuit
representation of a two dimensional waveguide junction is obtained over
several ranges of Isignificant parameters. The junction is formed by a
semi-infinite, dielectric filled, parallel plate guide contained symmet,
rically within an infinite parallel plate guide. The structure is first
reduced to a half-space problem and formulated in terms of the appropriate
field modes in each of the parallel plate guides forming the junction.
These modes are matched at the plane of discontinuity and the resulting
equations rearranged to resemble ordinary circuit equations. The circuit
elements of the equivalent circuit representation are identified from the
equations. The determination of the values of these elements requires
the solution of an infinite set of inhomogeneous algebraic equations.
Solutions are obtained by approximate methods with the aid of an IBM 7070
computer. The approximate solutions are checked by comparing the results
obtained for the degenerate case, in which the dielectric vanishes, with
known exact results0 This check suggests that the approximate results
for the case of non-vanishing dielectric should be within a few per cent
I of the correct values.
I
II
I. Introduction
This report concerns the determination of an equivalent circuit rep-
resentation for a waveguide junction formed by a semi-infinite, dielectric
filled, parallel plate guide contained symmetrically within an infinite
parallel plate guide (see Fig. I). We will assume that the dimensions of
the guide are such that only the T.E.M. mode will propagate in each guide
at the excitation frequency, and that the exciting source is so polarized
that there will be no field variations in the x-directiono
The literature on waveguide discontinuities discloses the closely
related problem of a homogeneous E-plane bifurcation, which can be solved1
exactly using integral transform methods° However a preliminary inves-
tigation of these transform procedures applied to the problem considered
in this report revealed that the inhomogeneity introduced by the dielectric
in guide B made these methods impractical to apply. Another approach,
better suited to the type of discontinuity considered here, is an approx-
imate method originally due to Whinnery and Jamieson. 2 Their approach is
based on mode matching at the discontinuity. It has the advantage of
being relatively straightforward, inherently providing a clear physical
picture of the propagating and non-propagating waves in the guide. More-
over, it is particularly adaptable to the two dimensional equivalent
1N. Marcuvitz, "Waveguide Handbook!', M. I. T. Radiation Laboratory
Series, Vol. 10 (McGraw-Hill Book Company, Inc., 1951), pp. 160.167°
. RoWhinnery and H. W. Jamieson,. "Equivalent Circuits for Dis-
continuities in Transmission Lines"!, Proc0 IoR.Eo, 32, 98-114, Feb., 1944.
I* 2
circuit formulation of the problem.
In the structure examined here, the method consists of finding the
evanescent mode amplitudes excited in the guide of height 2a* After con-
siderable manipulation of the field equations at the plane Z = 0, we
obtain an expression for the equivalent capacitances of the junction in
terms of these non-propagating mode amplitudes which, in turn, are defined
by an infinite set of non-homogeneous equations. An approximate solution
to these equations over a convenient range of parameters is obtained by
machine calculation using an IBM 7070 computer. The procedure is checked
by comparing the results for the degenerate case, in which E = Eo ,
with the value s given by Marcuvitz. 1
II
II3
II. Field Equations
A. Reduction to a Half-Space Problem.
The given waveguide configuration can be simplified by the following
* considerations.
(1) Due to the method of excitation and the nature of the discontinuity,
there will be no H-modes in the guide..
(2) The symmetry of the structure allows us to place an infinite perfec-
tly conducting plane at the plane y 0 without disturbing the fields.
Thus instead of solving the original problem, it is sufficient to solve
the half-space problem shown in Fig. 2. (See Appendix of reference 3 for
the justification of these statements.)a
B. Field Representation in the Half4Space Guide.
I The field in each of the guides shown in Fig. 2 can be represented
by an incident And reflected T.EoM. mode plus an infinite sum of evanescent
E modes. Using harmonic time dependence, e and assuming T.E.M. sources
at frequency in guides B and C at Z =--oo and in guide A at Z = oo, the
y component of the electric field in guide B is given by:
for -and
where nd T k I are always real.
3 H. M. CronsonI "Equivalent Circuit Parameters for an InhomogeneousI Bifurcated Waveguide", Master's thesis, Brown University, (1961).
I •.
I 4
The x component of magnetic field in guide B can be obtained
from MaxwellIs Equation j = , using the fact that since
only E modes are present, Hy = z 0. This yields
F .DQ
I H=-4~ [ih9..~a j+jc*E M cIr (2)
for :! Aý and
Similarly, for the fields in Guide A we can write
E, Cj 0' + i,, 3
I ' I1
1 forO• o• and •> . .•iq .. .•...
where k " andq/ / .•.-
I Also, in Guide 0, letting y = y-b,
IA,
Alo in Gudllttn -(6)
I ...
I
II S.
for O C: and Z O
where C ( Z
For subsequent calculations it is convenient to define the following
I quantities,
,, AO 0,• .OA A],,I0 6-j (6a)
+ "I v)
II &- 2, , , (8)
I
II
Hence equations (1) through (6) can be written, at Z =0, as
Ey (11)
III!0
I0
I6I
fZ A 0 + A,(12)
*,-, CJ, ,, o + Y , o 0,,(13)
iw ( 0 (1=4 )
We now employ the condition of continuity of the tangential E and
to fields at Z = 0 to give,
I pa
I~
I
DO 00
Th aov reatoshp betee th A, n ilbeuiie ae
to prvd anA eqiaetcrutrpeetton for th wvegud juncion
I0
IC"I"ýrr Y
II7
III. Equivalent Circuit Representation
A. The Transmission Line Analogy of a Parallel Plate Waveguide.
Consider an infinite parallel plate waveguide of height d in which
the T.E.M. mode is propagating in the positive Z direction (see Fig. 3).
The T.E.Mo wave may be written for harmonic time dependence ejwt as
where D is a constant determined by the strength of the source.
Maxwell's equations within the waveguide may be written in the form
\7XE VXH =
or as H (20)
I (21)I
We want to define a "ivoltage"l depending on Ey and a "current"
depending on Hx so that equations (20) and (21) can be viewed as
transmission line equations. We define
* - E•, (22)
For the parallel plate guide
-y (23)
!8
We also define!A= kv o (24)
where -. is the current per unit length on the surface of the top plateA
(y = d), w is a length in the x direction, and Z is the unit vector
in the Z direction, (see Fig. 3). On the surface of a perfect conductor
A x H = 2 where for this case n is the normal pointing into the guide.
Similarly
We note
- A x
Therefore
We further define
Substitution of equations (23) and (25) into (20) and (21) yields
Sd V( I-jA ) (26)-- I -
II9
* -~V(~)(27)
I The appropriate transmission line equations are given by Marcuvitz
(op. cit.) in the form
ýý -J Z,..9 (28)I--
I ~-&/Y2 (29)
where 2 and J are the voltage and current respectively in the transmission
line, k - , and Z = i/Y is the characteristic impedance. In comparing
equations (26) and (27) with (28) and (30), we see that the T.E.M. mode in a
parallel plate waveguide can be completely represented by a transmission line
with characteristic impedance.
S(29-a)
Note that the power flow in the guide through a cross section w x d is
H9P P j4- uH~ Z4d0 W-&~ H1which is the expression for the power flow in a transmission line.
B. the Waveguide Junction as an Equivalent Circuit.
Since a parallel plate waveguide can be represented by a transmission
line, it is convenient to represent the junction by a lumped network. The
junction in Fig. 2 stores energy with no dissipation in a local region close
10
to the plane Z b. Thus it is reasonable to represent the junction by
a lossless, lumped network. In this section we will show that the field
equations at the junction, expressed in terms of our defined voltage and
current, correspond to the nodal equations for a certain lumped, lossless,
Iand passive network.
The voltage from 0 to b in guide B at the plane Z = 0 is determined
using equations (10) and (22):
* VC)/ :Vefo 6 (= E, +
The voltage from 0 to a in guide A and from 0 to c in guide C at
Z 0 are found to be
We note that, since thecosine dependent modes integrate to(9 •b)e.
Svoltages at Z = 0 are due only to the electric field of the dominant T.E.M.
i mode.
If equation .(16) is integrated with respect to y from 0 to b and
added to the result obtained when equation (17) is integrated with respect
to y from b to c, one obtains
SI + iCnc =A. a-or in terms of' voltages',
*O V 08 V ~VOA (30)
I, 11
The defined current on the top plate in guide B at Z ='0 can be
found from equations (25) and (13.) as
I 7Jjo)/ -jL- •4-hoc§4o)= . oo.-, -
Similarly, the defined current on the top plate in guide C and guide A
at Z = 0 can be written as
IWi C. ;(V
We designate the currents of the dominant mode asI
Integrating equation (18) with respect to y from 0 to y.. .re obtain
i- Ami, At; Ir
Substituting equation (7) we have
ax MM6(31-a)
We can also show that equation (19) can be written
, Y C.... .(32-a)
7]I.p rI oCA
12
Suppose the summation term in equations (31-a) and (32-a) is
multiplied by 16- CO and we define
• "O.- - ..t-a, (33)
We may then write equations (31-a)- and (32-a) as
Y~& =Y 0A-O6 +J'CYco C -Yo (Aa O +,6-L,0 .J60.-IFCO
Using these equations and the definitions of the currents in terms of the
admittances, we obtain
3 A W U , eU o (31-b)
Ic 16T A , WLIf UW +4 (32-b)
I Substituting VOC = VOA -VOB and VOB = VOA - VOC in equations (31-b)
and (32-b) and remembering that a b + c, we have
I1L3 1, -t-j UrUr
SI
V
I. TI C 'I ,,
313
Define
U F -
F3r CA (36)bc
Substituting these definitions in the previous equations yields
15 A I-A J (ACB8VO' +-J CA V4Ae4* 4QCV, + AeuCA VAA
which are the nodal equations of the network shown in Fig. 4. Thus, the
waveguide junction can be represented by a lumped, lossless, and passive
network.
IIII
I
I ... i.•'
_U
I
1 114
IV. Determination of the Network Capacitances
SFrom equations (34)., (35), (36), we see that the capacitances couldAm
be determined if F were known. To find F we must find B . We shall0 00
now determine equations for this unknown,
We multiply equation (16) by cos MTU and integrate with respecta+
to y from 0 to b. This equation is then added to the result obtained when
equation (17) is multiplied by cos m and integrated with respect toa
j y from b to c. These operations result in
SA,, I L7i- V (7
g=
where ,
Next we multiply equation (18) by cos and integratewith respect• .b
to y from 0 to b.o The result is
a-~ (38)
IEquation (19) is multiplied by cos q'E y' and integrated with respect
I
I
,i 15
to y' from 0 to C. This gives
I~i Y J39)~~A~nr
Substituting the B and C from equations (38) and (39) into (37) yields
r
4
A^ 1
0..
DO Do8
g•.
3 (equation continued on next page ).
I0 ,LZlIC
I°"16
I PI
•k .(o)
I.17
where EB E- and the encircled numbers designate the terms of
the equation for subsequent identification.
,Next, each term is rearranged so that Ap appears only under the
first summation. For instance term is rearranged by noting that
3 where is the wavelength in guide B and also by
changing the order of summationITerm becomes
T 6 Z9tCL4 2-)MCI)
b
In order to group all the Am terms together in equationto.G we also separate
term 0 into two parts. One including all the Ap save Am and the other
1 just containing Am. When all the terms have heen suitably rearranged
u equation (40) becomes
• i,'7#" 4..
2. A41'w +,,rX4) 7r_ t IN ,.r-
(equation continued on next page)UU
18I ..
o44
3 +
p~r#)
I - ® ® ,-
I m~_b 4]
m 1to Ao " 1 ifbmsa integer
Iwhere X(m) = J .and misa n
Cb7
ar'•[B•-CcI 0 if• m is not an integer
We nwwrite equation (33) as Fz Qw- L A¶•Al7 ()
I31U
I0Iz2
19
Using equations (36) and (42) we write
CA ~ r L 4K/ r (43)
From equations (35) and (36) we note
C B C-LA(4
I
3 The remainder of this report will be concerned with determining CA
by solving equation (41) by approximate methods.
I One check on the correctness of equations (t11) and (43) is provided
by noting in Fig. 4 that for the case E = C- G0 CA should not change
I when the dimensions of guides B and C are interchanged. In accordance
with this physical observation it can be shown (see Appendix of reference 3)
using equations (4l) and (43) for the case =1 that CA is invariant to
I the transformation replacing b by c and c by b. Thus in this respect the
equations check.I
* 20
V. Solution of the Equations
A. Parameters
3 The main objective of this report is to determine the guidecapacitances for various combinations of , B' and Since
I the analysis is based on only the ToEoMo modes propagating in each guide,
there is the restriction that 2a 2b .2 are not greater than 1.
The values chosen for this report are
I ~b-a= 0.1, 0.5, 0.9
E B ' 1I1 2.5, lo., loo
II = O. o06, 1.0
in order that results may be obtained over a wide range of parameters.
Since it can easily be shown that a , those
permutations of the parameters for which 2 b 1 will not be allowed.
I B. Method of Approximation
The infinite number of unknowns X(m) can, in principle, be determined
from the infinite set of simultaneous equations represented by equation (41).
5 The X(m) are then used to calculate the capacitance CA , by employing
equation (43). The other capacitances immediately follow from equations (44)
I and (45). In practice, however, equation (41) must be solved by some method
of approximation. The method utilized in this report attempts to approximate
the exact answer by solving only finite sets of simultaneous linear equations.
I
I1 21
I We will solve equation (41) as a set of simultaneous equations of rank 4., 5,
and 6 and from the behavior of these solutions determine an approximate
capacitance. The validity of this approximation will be examined by a com-
parison with the exact results for the case E B = 1
I The quantity we are interested in obtaining is the capacitance CA
given by equation (43). We define
CA 4K /Y Vi(4t6)n? - e #,L 0" •
where X(m) are the solutions to the infinite set of equations represented
by (Mi). Let the index m in equation (a1) be restricted to the integers
3 from 1 to 6. The solutions to this 6 x 6 set will be called /X6 (m) Thus
one approximation to C ,could be
C _W__ (47)
This approximation has 2 sources of error. The first is the error arising
from the fact that /K 6 (m) • X(m) for m = 1,6. The second is the error
3 due to the exclusion of
PO X&ft)I "•7
It is our aim to determine a refinement of the approximation given by
U equation (47) based on the computed results, which will reduce the errors
mentioned above,
The computer program was designed to solve the system of equations
Iof rank 4t, 5, and 6. It was felt that a plot of these results for a few
Io ak4 ,ad oI etta
I
I 22
Stypical cases and an extrapolation would indicate the probable solutions
for the first four unknowns (X(m), m = 1, 4) and also serve to exhibit
I the behavior of the unknowns for m > 4. As an example of this procedure
I for one set of parameters, Figs. 5, 6, and 7 show respectively the
dependence of the solutions on the equation set size, a rough estimate of
Sthe values ofA X(m) for m = 1, 4 extrapolated from the finite sets, and
the extrapolated values of X(m). An examination of the computed and
graphical results reveals the following information:
I (1) X(m) sin (, b) is always positive
I (2) The extrapolated value of X(m) is very close to x6(m)
(3) The extrapolated value of x(m) for m> 5 decreases
roughly as 1 . Here we must make an exception for
b = 0.5 because the results show (2m + 1) >> x (2m)Ia Ix II 1
But in this case the odd values of m decrease as 1 and these are them
only values that enter into the computation of C
Based on the above observations a suitable refinement to equation (47)
is
I () 4 5I. /,r/ (48)
The series is roughly the same if is 0.1, 0.5,
3 or 0.9.
I23
We note for b = 0.5 the value of this series can be determined
a
from the well known result
00 . 00S(2/M
Am=
From this we find
0= 0.826144
Our approximation is now given by
IC(2) =C(l) + o-413 K (5)IIor using equation (48)
-X C 652 (4~9)... •_ C•• _C_ _ __,__N c)! •
i>c-r £ur c 77'
where IX
The computed results are tabulated below. Figures 8 through 13 show
these results in graphical form,
I
ý.O co '0 H 24~trA 'LN V\ ' '\ \C) I 0C\J C) (NJ -:T I 04i 04
C ~ c I fu\ I\
0 * 0 0 5-40 0)
0 0)
Go Go o aai)4
('4 H 04J IA \0 ON r- coa IH ( H H '- C ON I H 1 I 4,
r- 04l H H (04 H- H 4 .0j 0 * 0
to 0 0
co H co \4'C 4 tr 0 ON Elb H 4 C CN 0( CH I IA I I 0
0 ~ '400 r- 040O 0
\ 0 0 0. '0
0 H 0 0 0 0 0
04 0 04 1.r C0aN 04 O .~ r.
0 0 0 0 0 m 0 0 T
_A cn V. \ oC - 0 n -I0 ON 0 - O'0 C) d
H0
I08 Hq H 0 H 0 0) ) 0) 0) 0
0 0 04 H H H 0) C 0
H H H .d to
H UN' O\ H IA' ON H C\' ON H L1' ONC.O cuI* C) C ) C C; CG C) C; C; 0 0; C3
25
C. Comparison with the Results Obtained by Marcuvitz for ea= Ce.
O On pages 353-355 of Marcuvitz (op. cit.) the E-plane bifurcation
problem is discussed and the results given graphically for an exact solution
of this problem using integral transform methods, These results can be
compared to those of this report for the case 6B = 1. We use the notation
on page 353 but to avoid confusion; since b denotes different dimensions
in this report and in Marcuvitz, we let the b of Marcuvitz be called
3 The dimension Marcuvitz labels b is the dimension of guide A in this
report. Comparing Fig. 4 in this report to Figure 6.4 - 2 in Marcuvitz
3 we observe
X =- co I ,
where X = 2-L
For this problem and the characteristic impedance is given
by
3 Therefore
/ _ -
Using = 2T we have
2nZ
""I- (50)S27T-
Ii
I1 26
When >0 we, have t(51)
Using the graph on page 354 we can construct the table below and compare
CA with the computed C42 of this report.
fiE ~E
II1IUI
27
0 Q co bK0\ 0\ 0' 'i
. C4 8 A Aý C
oC~j 0 cm c'j
to 0 H ,0 10 m
I; oC\J 0" \ 0 C'j tr
~\10I8 r
In ~ %0 'o ONj
a "0 %4D 0
'0
0 0 0 0 0 0
Ii 28
From the above results we see that in all but one case the error is within
4% of Marcuvitz' results. Thus C is a fairly good approximation toIOe f B 1. Since the structure ofB he equatiorsis the same for
CB 1 1, and the computed results manifest no drastic change foreB i 1, we
3 may expect that 66 will be within a few per cent of the correct value
for all BiIiiIIiiIiIII
29
VI. Scattering Description
This section will be concerned with transforming the impedance
description of the guide to a scattering description. Since we know now
the values of the capacitances in the equivalent circuit, all other wave-
guide quantities such as reflection coefficient, standing wave radio, etc.,
may be determined. We will assume, for the sake of simplicity, that only
guide B is excited and that guides A and C are terminated in their character-
istic impedance. To calculate the reflection coefficient at the junction,
I-r(0 ), we use equation (30) given on page 14 of "Waveguide Handbook" (op.
cit.).
+-(52)I + ('(s)
where Y'(Z) = Y(Z)/Y°
and Y(Z) is the admittance of the transmission line at Rý and YO
is the characteristic admittance of the transmission line.o
We note that the circuit shown in Fig. 4 corresponds to the half-space
problem. However, due to symmetry, the reflection coefficient of the
original guide in Fig. 1 is the same as the half-space guide. The circuit
we consider is shown in Fig. 14., where the characteristic admittances are
found from equation (29-a). We make the following definitions:
YA-YA JCA (53)
B (514)
30
YC= YA0 +>WcC (55)
We then have
Yo) Y- YS Y, (56)
YBO yol y
Using equations (29-a) and (45) we write equation (55) as
p F a - • CA • (57)
We make use of the quantity - CA computed in part V by defining the
positive number CV
CV-CA (58)
We now substitute equation (58) into (57) to yield
YC + i-li(59but since C) 2- 7r 2Tr equation (59) can be written asI
Y •- + J" lz CV (60)
Similarly equation (53) can be written as
I -, cv (61)
I- a
I31
After a few of these substitutions equation (56) may be written as
Y1J (I+~ A C 12-c)+ jCLC -)-~~CAL+ C) (62)
I where A -Z-L
and C- VISubstituting (62) into (52) we can calculate the reflection coefficient
r(o).
Let us now examine the behavior of the reflection coefficient for
two simple cases.
Case 1. - 0I .
If ___ = 0, then CL = 0 and equation (62) becomes_L
-i-O (63)
Substituting equation (63) into (52) we obtain
P ý- .(64)
We note when A 1
and when<.
rIo
32
B , equation (64) becomes,
A'Iso i 8 BP O ) = I - b(6 5)
This is in agreement with the physical result that as b ->l., the guide
3 .,ceases'to become bifurcated and no reflections occur.
Case 2 ~
A study of the Table of Computed Capacitance in section v-C shows
that this is a fairly good approximation when 20--/A 0.6. Since
A -. 1 ,we also have C2«< A. With this approximationb I L
equation (62) can be written
Y'(o=+f (66)
This tells us the obvious fact that the best match., i.e. Y'(o) = 1 occurs
when A-->1 and4TE --> 1.
It is also interesting to inquire how the wave entering from guide B
-:-is divi~ded between guides A and C. Using equations (6-a) and (29-b) we
obtain
VOAALOU c~ (67)
where A. and C~are the complex amplitudes of the outgoing waves
pr6pagating in guides A and C respectively. We have the relations
(68)VOA VAVO
I 33where I is shown in Fig. 14. Combining equations (60), (61), (67),
I and (68) we get -
Call I -JC (69)
and I'O
(70)Iwhich gives the result that the magnitudes of the transmitted waves in
guides A and C are always the same. To find the ratio of the powers flowing
into guides A and C, assuming them terminated by their characteristic:
I impedance we employ the equationI~~~ A=Jv2.L
PA !VOA 12YA C,(1
_ c
This is a general result independent of t' B and subject to the restriction
that 2 0-
We now give a table of computed I(a) for the range of parameters
considered in this problem.
34
Table of Computed j0)j
.b : 1B 00a •rc •l
0.1 1 .90 .90 .90015 1 .5o .50 .370.9 1 .10 .10 .100.1 2,5 .94 .93 .92o.5 2e5 .65 .61 .350.9 2.5 .32 .32 -011 10 .97 .98 .95o.5 10 .81 .77 -0.9 10 .59 -0.1 100 .99 .99 .99I 0.5 100 .94 - -0.9 100 .85 -
These results show that increasing E B and decreasing and
tends to increase MlCLIa
I
The dash -). indicates that F, 2- 0 and thus solutions'
with these sets of parameters are excluded from this analysis.
IReferences
1N. Marcuvitz, "Waveguide Handbook". M.I.T. Radiation LaboratorySeries, Vol. 10 (McGraw-Hill Book Company, Inc., 1951).
2. J. R. Whinnery and H. W. Jamieson, "Equivalent Circuit for Discon-
tinuities in Transmission Lines", Proc. I.R.E., 32, 98-114,February, 1944.
3. H. M. Cronson, "Equivalent Circuit Parameters for an InhomogeneousBifurcated Waveguide", Master's thesis, Brown University,(1961).
IIIII
IIIIIIi
II
IyI ~(conductor)
C(conductor)
IxI
I (conductor)
I (conductor)
I FIG. I A SEMI - INFINITE , DIELECTRIC FILLED, PARALLELPLATE GUIDE CONTAINED SYMMETRICALLY IN AN
INFINITE PARALLEL PLATE GUIDE.
IIIIII
I y(conductor)
I C guide C (conductor)
3b guide B guide A a
3 (conductor) x z
I FIG. 2 THE INHOMOGENEOUS BIFURCATED GUIDE
III,
I -"-"_ z___ __ J
I FIG. 3 ORIENTATIONS OF ,t, AND HX
Vooc
IoIol
' I
I -- i OA
ov _b cc 'Io / I-o
I I
108 IA
FIG. 4 EQUIVALENT CIRCUIT REPRESENTATION
Iw
I w
z0
DD
0 a
11 w
0 (D MIa I I IHD
cLi~o 31 zI 0 w 0
0w U)I--
0-w0
w
00I~~C _ _ _ __O
LL
(%j to LL 0,
0<
0_
0"
U-
(DU
II-(0L
x0
XILi
* (9
C~ ci0 0 0 0
(M* (0
I IL
w 6
flic
IM 0
(0 0
~ii-J-
00xw
I-
IcI2
I; 0JV
0w X
I _L _ _
a<nI - 4 < (D
L~w
00I ZO (D
I 0:
0 0
I> 4
CD0 ,Z
00
LOON I-,-
I0
0Iz W
IIw
101 0Iw>0
>0
zW
00I 0 00
>IIIwIUI
Io
IW <
I>
I-wz
WI-I (00LU 4
>0
I w0
W-
tO Cj0C
I0
0
Icz w
00
~i4 CDwc'w
'-0
W gi
*z 5~ CJ
G 6J
I CtD
*c 0,6IO
0 0 0
I0U0
*w 0
UW
04
-:> w
W W
I 0,
IIII
I CHARACTERISTIC CcADMITTANCE
YBI
Y--- CB
CA YA A
TA
II
I FIG. 14 EQUIVALENT CIRCUIT OF THE HALF SPACEGUIDE WITH GUIDES A AND C TERMINATEDIN THEIR CHARACTERISTIC ADMITTANCES
ILIST S-SI
ORGANIZATION No. of Copies
APGC (PGTRI, Tech Library)Eglin Air Force BaseFlorida
RADC (RAYLD)Attn: Documents LibraryGriffiss Air Force BaseNew York
AF Missile Dev. Cen. (MDGRT)Attn: Technical LibraryHolloman Air Force BaseNew Mexico
AUTJIfaxMrell Air Force BaseAlabama
AF Missile Test CenterPatrick Air Force BaseFlorida
Attn: AY'ý,.TC, Tech Library, MU-135
ASD (ASAPBL)Wright-Patterson Air Force BaseOhio
USAF Security Service (CLR)San Antonio, Texas
Hq. USAD (Major R. L. Stell)Tactical Air GroupWashington 25, D.C.
AFOSR (SRY, Technical Director)14th Street and Constitution AvenueWashington, D.C.
Hq. USAF (AFOAC-S/E)I Communications-Electronics DirectorateWashington 25, D.C.
I
i
I
I/
List S-S - page 2
ORGANIZATION No. of Copies
Director of Air Force Research DivisionAPRDWashington, D.C.
WADD (WCLRSA, Mr. Portune)Wright-Patterson Air Force BaseOhio
ASD (AsR1RE-3)Attn: Mr. Paul SpringerWright-Patterson Air Force Base
I Ohio
Director, Electronics DivisionAir Technical Intelligence CenterAttn: AFCIN-)EIl, Colonel H. K. GilbertWright Patterson Air Force BaseOhio
I WADD (WWDRTR, Mr. A. D. Clark)Directorate of System EngineeringDyna Soar Engineering OfficeWright-Patterson Air Force BaseOhio
Lt. Col. Jensen (SSRTJ)Space Systems DivisionAir Force Unit Post Office
Los Angeles 45, California
DirectorU. S. Army OrdnanceBallistic Research LaboratoriesAberdeen Proving Ground, MarylandAttn: Ballistic Measurements Laboratory
Ballistic Research Laboratories 1Aberdeen Proving Ground, MarylandAttn: Technical Information Branch
Director 1Evans Signal LaboratoryBelmar, New JerseyAttn: Mr. 0. C. Woodyard
IList S-S - page 3
ORGANIZATION No. of Copies
Commanding General JUSASRDT,
Ft. Monmouth, New JerseyAttn: Tech. Doc. Ctr.
SIGRA/SL-ADTU Commanding General, SIGFN/EL-PC
USASRDLForth Monmouth, New JerseyAttn: Dr. Horst H. Kedesy
Deputy Chief, Chem-Physics Branch
3 Commanding GeneralUSARDLFort Monmouth, New Jersey3 Attn: SIGFM/EL -AT
Commanding GeneralUSASRDLFort Monmouth, New JerseyAttn: Mr. F. J. Triola
ConmmanderArmy Rocket & Guided Missile AgencyRedstone Arsenal, Alabama3 Attn: Technical Library, ORDXR-OTL
Department of the ArmyOffice of the Chief Signal OfficerWashington 25, D.C.Attn: SIGRD-4a-2
Office of Chief 3ignal OfficerEngineering and Technical DivisionWashington 25, D.C.3 Attn: SIGNET-5
Advisory Group on Electr6nic PartsRoom 103, Moore School Building200 South 33 rd StreetPhiladelphia 4, Pennsylvania
I3 List S-S page 4
ORGANIZATION No. of Copies
ASTIA 10Arlington Hall StationArlington 12, Virginia
National Aeronautical Space Agency 1Langley Aeronautical Research LaboratoryLangley, VirginiaAttn: Mr. Cliff Nelson
Library 1National Bureau of StandardsBoulder LaboratoriesBoulder, Colorado
National Bureau of Standards 1I U. S. Department of CommerceWashington 25, D.C.Attn: Mr. A. G. McNish
National Bureau of Standards 1U. S. Department of CommerceWashington 25, D.C.Attn: Gustave Shapiro, Chief
Engineering Electronics SectionElectricity and Electronics Division
Director 1National Security AgencyFort George G. Meade, MarylandAttn: C3141 (Room 2C087)
AFCRL, Office of Aerospace Research (CRRELT) 10L. G. Hanscom FieldBedford, Massachusetts
3 AFCRL, Office of Aerospace Research (CRRD) 2Attn: Contract FilesL. G. Hanscom FieldBedford, Massachusetts
AFCRL, Office of Aerospace Research (CRRD) 3-Attn: Carlyle J. SlettenL. G. Hanscom FieldBedford, MassachusettsI
List S-S - page 5
ORGANIZATION No. of Copies
Hq. ESD (ESRDW, Capt. John J. Hobson)L. G. Hanscom FieldBedford, Massachusetts
NASA (Dr. R. V. Hess)Langley Research CenterHampton, Virginia
Director, Avionics Division (AV)Bureau of AeronauticsDepartment of the NavyWashington 25, D.C.
Commander 1U. S. Naval Air Missile Test CenterPoint Mugu, CaliforniaAttn: Code 366
LibrarianU. S. Naval Post graduate SchoolMonterey, California
DirectorU. S. Naval Research LaboratoryWashington 25, D.C.Attn: Code 2027
Dr. J. I. Bohnert, Code 5210U. S. Naval Research LaboratoryWashington 25, D.C.
Chief of Naval ResearchDepartment of the NavyWashington 25, D.C.Attn: Code 427
Commanding OfficerU. S. Naval Air Development CenterJohnsville, PennsylvaniaAttn: NADC Library
IList S-S - page 6
ORGANIZATION No. of Copies
Commanding Officer and Director 1U. S. Navy Electronics Laboratory (Library)San Diego 52, California
Chief, Bureau of OrdnanceDepartment of the NavySurface Guided Missile BranchWashington 25, D.C.Attn: Code ReSl-3
Department of the NavyBureau of AeronauticsTechnical Data Division, Code 4106Washington 25, D.C.
CommanderU. S. Naval Air Test CenterPatuxent River, MarylandAttn: ET-315, Antenna Branch
ARDC Regional Office.c/o Department of the NavyRoom 4549, Munitions BuildingWashington 25, D.C.
Airborne Instruments Laboratory, Inc. 1Division of Cutler HammerWalt Whitman RoadMilville, L. I. New YorkAttn: Library
Aircom, Inc.48 Cummington StreetBoston, Massachusetts
3 ACF Industries, Inc.Southeast Corner, 52nd Avenue
and Jackson StreetBladensburg, Prince George's CountyMarylandAttn: LibrarianI
List S-S - page 7
I ORGANIZATION No. of Copies
Battelle Memorial Institute505 King AvenueColumbus 1, OhioAttn: Wayne E. Rife, Project Leader
Electrical Engineering Division
Bell Aircraft CorporationPost Office Box OneBuffalo 5, New YorkAttn: Eunice P. Hazelton, Librarian
Bell Telephone LaboratoriesMurray HillNew Jersey
I Bell Telephone Laboratories, Inc.Whippany LaboratoryWhippany, New JerseyAttn: Technical Information Library
Aerospace Corp.Box 95o85Los Angeles 45, CaliforniaAttn: Library
I Bendix Radio Division 1Bendix Aviation CorporationE. Joppa RoadTowson 4, MarylandAttn: Dr. D. M. Allison, Jr.
Director Engineering & Research
Bjorksten Research Laboratories, Inc.P. 0. Box 265Madison, WisconsinAttn: Librarian
Boeing Airplane Company 1Pilotless Aircraft DivisionP. 0. Box 3707Seattle 24, WashingtonAttn: R. R. Barber, Library Supervisor
List S-S - page 8
ORGANIZATION No. of Copies
Chance Vought Aircraft, Inc.9314 West Jefferson StreetDallas, TexasAttn: A. D. Pattullo, librarian
Chance Vought CorporationVought Electronics DivisionP. 0. Box 5907Dallas 22, Texas
Chu AssociatesP. 0. Box 387Whitcomb Avenue
Littleton, Massachusetts
Collins Radio Company855 35th Street, N.E.Cedar Rapids, IowaAttn: Dr. R. L. McCreary
Collins Radio Company1200 North Alma RoadRichardson, Texas
Attn: C. D. Tipt6n
I Convair, A Division of General Dynamics Corp. 1Fort'Worth, TexasAttn: K. G. Brown
Division Research Librarian
Convair, A Division of General Dynamics Corp. 13165 Pacific HighwaySan Diego 12, CaliforniaAttn: Mrs. Dora B. Burke
Engineering Librarian
Cornell Aeronautical Laboratory, Inc.4455 Genesee StreetI Buffalo 21, New YorkAttn: Librarian
III
List S-S - page 9
ORGANIZATION No. of Copies
Dalmo Victor CompanyA Division of Textron, Inc.1515 Industrial WayBelmont, CaliforniaAttn: Mary Ellen Addems, Technical Librarian
Dome and Margolin, Inc.29 New York AvenueWestbury, Long Island, New York
Douglas Aircraft Company, Inc.827 Lapham StreetEl Segundo, CaliforniaAttn: Engineering Library
Douglas Aircraft Company, Inc.3000 Ocean Park BoulevardSanta Monica, CaliforniaAttn: Peter Duyan, Jr.
Chief, Electrical/Electronics Section
Douglas Aircraft Company, Inc.2000 North Memorial DriveTulsa, OklahomaAttn: Engineering Librarian, D-250
Electromagnetic Research Corporation5001 College AvenueCollege Park, MarylandAttn: Mr. Martin Katzin
Electronics Communication1830 York RoadTimonium, Maryland
Electronic Specialty Company5121 San Fernando RoadLos Angeles 39, CaliforniaAttn: Donald L. Margerum
Chief Engineer, Radiating Systems Division
Emerson Electric Mfg. Company8100 West Florissant AvenueSt. Louis 21, MissouriAttn: Mr. E. R. Bresl~h, Librarian
IList S-S - page 10
ORGANIZATION No. of Copies
Emerson Radio-Phonograph Corp. 1Emerson Research Laboratories701 Lamont Street, N.W.Washington 10, D.C.Attn: Mrs. R. Corbin, Librarian
Fairchild Aircraft-Missiles DivisionFairchild Eng. and Airplane Cor.Hagerstown, MarylandAttn: Library
Federal Telecommunication Laboratories500 Washington AvenueNutley 10, New JerseyAttn: Technical Library
General Electric CompanyElectronics ParkSyracuse, New YorkAttn: Documents LibraryB. Fletcher, Building 3-1h3A
General Electric Company 1Missile and Space Vehicle Department3198 Chestnut StreetPhiladelphia, PennsylvaniaAttn: Documents Library
Gabriel Electronics DivisionMain and Pleasant StreetsMillis, MassachusettsAttn: Dr. Edward Altshuler
General Electric Comapny3750 D StreetPhiladelphia 211, PennsylvaniaAttn: Mr. II. G. Lew
Missile and Space Vehicle Department
IList S-S - page 11
ORGANIZATION No. of Copies
General Precision Laboratory, Inc.63 Bedford RoadPleasantville, New YorkAttn: Librarian
Goodyear Aircraft Corporation1210 Massillon RoadAkron 15, OhioAttn: Library, Plant G
Granger AssociatesElectronic Systems974 Commercial StreetPalo Alto, CaliforniaAttn: John V. N. Granger, President
The Hallicrafters Company5th and Kostner AvenuesChicago 24, IllinoisAttn: Henry Hodara, Head of Space Communication
Hughes Aircraft CompanyAntenna DepartmentBuilding 12, Mail Station 2714Culver City, CaliforniaAttn: Dr. W. H. Kuminer
Hughes Aircraft CompanyFlorence Avenue and Teale StreetsCulver City, CaliforniaAttn: Louis L. Bailin
Manager, Antenna Dept.
ITT Laboratories3700 East Pontiac StreetFort Wayne 1, IndianaAttn: Technical Library
Jansky and Bailey, Inc. 11339 Wicsonsin Avenue, N.W.Washington 7, D.C.Attn: Mr. Delmer C. Ports
I
I .
* List S-S - page 12
ORGANIZATION No. of Copies
Dr. Henry Jasik, Consulting Engineer298 Shames DriveBrush Hollow Industrial ParkWestbury, New York
I Lockheed Aircraft Corporation2555 N. Hollywood WayCalifornia Division Engineering LibraryDepartment 72-25, Plant A-l, Building 63-1Burbank, CaliforniaAttn: N. C. Harnois
Lockheed Aircraft CorporationMissile Systems Division Research LibraryBox 504., Sunnyvale, CaliforniaAttn: Miss Eva Lou Robertson, Chief Librarian
The Martin CompanyP. 0. Box 179Denver 1, ColoradoAttn: Mr. Jack McCormick
The Martin CompanyBaltimore 3, MarylandAttn: Engineering Library
Antenna Design Group
I McDonnell Aircraft Corporation, Dept. 644 1Box 516, St. Louis 66, MissouriAttn: C. E. Zoller
Engineering Library
Melpar, Inc. 13000 Arlington BoulevardFalls Church, VirginiaAttn: Engineering Technical Library
Hughes •Aircraft Company 1Attn: Mr. L. Stark, Microwave Dept.Radar Laboratory, P. 0. Box 2097Building 600, Mail Station C-152Fullerton, California
List S-S - page 13
ORGANIZATION No. of Copies
The Mitre Corporation 1244 Wood StreetLexington 73, MassachusettsAttn: Mrs. Jean E. Claflin, Librarian
Motorola, Inc.Phoenix Research Laboratory3102 N. 56th StreetPhoenix, ArizonaAttn: Dr. A. L. Aden
National Research CouncilRadio & Electrical Engineering DivisionOttawa, Ontario, CanadaAttn: Dr. G. A. Miller, Head
Microwave Section
North American Aviation, Inc. 112214 Lakewood BoulevardDowney, CaliforniaAttn: Technical Information Center (495-12)
Space & Information Systems Division
North American Aviation, Ind.Los Angeles International AirportLos Angeles 45, CaliforniaAttn: Engineering Technical File
Northrop CorporationNorair Division1001 E. BroadwayHawthorne, CaliforniaAttn: Mr. E. A. Freitas, Library Dept. 3145
Page Communications Engineers, Inc.2001 Wisconsin Avenue, N.W.Washington 7, D.C.Attn: (Mrs.) Ruth Temple, Librarian
I Philco CorporationResearch DivisionUnion Meeting PondBlue Bell, PennsylvaniaAttn: Research Librarian
I
List S-S - page 14
ORGANIZATION No. of Copies
Pickard and Burns, Inc. 1240 Highland AvenueNeedham 94, MassachusettsAttn: Dr. Richard 11. Woodward
Polytechnic Research & Development Co., Inc. 1202 Tillary StreetBrooklyn 1, New YorkAttn: Technical Library
Radiation Engineering LaboratoryMain StreetMaynard, MassachusettsAttn: Dr. John Ruze
Radiation,. Inc.Melbourne, FloridaAttn: R F Systems Division
Technical Information Center
Radiation Systems, Inc. 1440 Swanm AvenueAlexandria, VirginiaAttn: Library
RCA Laboratories 1
David Sarnoff Research CenterPrinceton, New JerseyAttn: Miss Fern Cloak, Librarian
Radio Corporation of AmericaDefense Electronic ProductsBuilding 10, Floor 7Camden 2, New JerseyAttn: Mr. Harold J. Schrader, Staff Engineer
Organization of Chief Technical Administrator
Radio Corporation of America 1Surface Communications Systems Laboratory75 Varick Street
New York 13, New York
IList S-S - page 15
ORGANIZATION No. of Copies
Radio Corporation of AmericaWest Coast Missile and Surface Radar DivisionEngineering LibraryBuilding 306/2Attn: L. R. Hund, Librarian8500 Balboa BoulevardVan Nuys, California
Radio Corporation of AmericaDefense Electronic ProductsAdvanced Military SystemsPrinceton, New JerseyAttn: Mr. David Shore
I Director, USAF Project RANDVia: AF Liaison OfficeThe Rand Corporation1700 Main StreetSanta Monica, California
The Rand Corporation1700 Main StreetSanta Monica, CaliforniaAttn: Technical Library
Rantec Corporation23999 Ventura BoulevardCalabasas, CaliforniaAttn: Grace Keener, Office Manager
Raytheon CompanyWayland LaboratoryWayland, MassachusettsAttn: Miss Alice G. Anderson, Librarian
Raytheon CompanyMissile Systems DivisionHartwell RoadBedford, MassachusettsAttn: Donald H. ArcherI
I
I
List S-S - page 16IORGANIZATION No. of Copies
Republic Aviati on Corporation 1Farmingdale, Long Island, New YorkAttn: Engineering Library
Sanders Associates, Inc. 195 Canal StreetNashua, New HampshireAttn: Mr. Norman R. Wild
Sandia CorporationSandia BaseP. 0. Box 5800Alburque, New MexicoAttn: Classified Document Division
I Sandia CorporationAttn: Organization 1423Sandia BaseAlburque, New Mexico
Scanwell Laboratories, Inc.6601 Scanwell LaneSpringfield, Virginia
STL Technical Library 1Document AcquisitionsSpace Technology Laboratories, Inc.
P. o. Box 950olLos Angeles 45, California
Sperry Gyroscope CompanyGreat Neck, Long Island, New YorkAttn: Florence W. Turnbull.
Engineering Librarian
Stanford Research InstituteDocuments CenterMe nlo Park, CaliforniaAttn: Acquisitions
List S-S - page 17
ORGAMIZATION No. of Copies
Sylvania Electric Products, Inc. 1100 First AvenueWaltham 54, MassachusettsAttn: Charles A. Thornhill, Report Librarian
Waltham Laboratories Library
Sylvania Reconnaissance Systems Lab. 1Box 188Mountain View, CaliforniaAttn: Marvin D. Waldman
I TRG, Inc.400 Border StreetEast Boston, Massachusetts3 Attn: Dr. Alan F. Kay
A. S. Thomas, Inc.355 Providence HighwayWestwood, MassachusettsAttn: A. S. Thomas, President
Texas Instruments, Inc.6000 Lemmon AvenueDallas 9, TexasAttn: John B. Travis
Systems Planning Branch
Westinghouse Electric Corp.Electronics DivisionFriendship Int'l Airport Box 1897Baltimore 3, Maryland
Brown University 1Department of Electrical EngineeringProvidence, Rhode IslandAttn: Dr. C. 1. Angulo
California Institute of TechnologyJet Propulsion Laboratory4800 Oak Grove DrivePasadena, CaliforniaAttn: Mr. I. E. Newlan
List S-S - page 10
ORGANIZATION No. of Copies
California Institute of Technology1201 E. California StreetPasadena, CaliforniaAttn: Dr. C. Papas
Space Sciences LaboratoryLeuschner ObservatoryUniversity of CaliforniaBerkeley 4, CaliforniaAttn: Dr. Samuel Silver, Professor of Engineering Science
and Director, Space Sciences Laboratory
University of California 1Electronics Research Lab.332 Cory HallBerkeley 4, CaliforniaAttn: J. R. Whinnery
I Universityr of Southern CalifOrnia 1University ParkLos Angeles, CaliforniaAttn: Dr. Raymond L. Chuan
Director, Engineering Center
Case Institute of Technology1Electrical Engineering Department10900 Euclid AvenueCleveland, OhioAttn: Professor Robert Plonsey
Columbia UniversityDepartment of Electrical EngineeringlIorningside HeightsNew York, New York
Attn: Dr. Schlesinger
University of Southern CaliforniaUniversity ParkLos Angeles 7, CaliforniaAttn: Z. A. Kaprielian
Associate Professor of Electrical Engineering
List S-S - page 19
ORGANIZATION No. of Copies
Cornell UniversitySchool of Electrical EngineeringIthaca, New YorkAttn: Professor G. C. Dalman
University of FloridaDepartment of Electrical EngineeringGainesville, FloridaAttn: Professor M. H. Latour, Library
LibraryGeorgia Technology Research InstituteEngineering Experiment Station722 Cherry Street, N.W.Atlanta, GeorgiaAttn: Mrs. J. H. Crosland, Librarian
Harvard UniversityTechnical Reports CollectionGordon McKay Library303 Pierce HallOxford StreetCambridge 38, MassachusettsAttn: Librarian
University of IllinoisDocuments Division LibraryUrbana, Illinois
University of IllinoisCollege of EngineeringUrbana, IllinoisAttn: Dr. P. E. Mayes, Department of
Electrical Engineering
Illinois Institute of Technology3301 S. Dearborn StreetChicago 16, IllinoisAttn: Dr. George I. Cohn
/
IList S-S - page 20IORGANIZATION No. of Copies
Illinois Institute of TechnologyI Technology Center
Department of Electrical EngineeringChicago 16, IllinoisAttn: Paul C. Yuen
Electronics Research Laboratory
The John Hopkins UniversityI Homewood CampusBaltimore 18, MarylandAttn: Dr. Donald E. Kerr, Department of Physics
The Johns Hopkins UniversityApplied Physics Laboratory8621 Georgia AvenueSilver Spring, MarylandAttn: Mr. George L. Seielstad
University of KansasElectrical Engineering DepartmentLawrence, KansasAttn: Dr. H. Unz
Lowell Technological Institute 1Research FoundationP. 0. Box 709Lowell, MassachusettsAttn: Dr. Charles R. Mingins
Massachusetts Institute of Technology 1Research Laboratory of ElectronicsBuilding 26, Room 327Cambridge 39, MassachusettsAttn: John H. Hewitt
I Massachusetts Institute of TechnologyLincoln LaboratoryP. 0. Box 73Lexington 73, MassachusettsAttn: Mary A. Granese, Librarian
IIII
List S-S - page 21,
I ORGANIZATION No. of Copies
McGill UniversityMontreal, CanadaAttn: Professor G. A. Woonton
Director, The Eaton ElectronicsResearch Laboratory
University of MichiganElectronic Defense GroupEngineering Research InstituteAnn Arbor, MichiganAttn: J. A. Boyd, Supervisor
University of MichiganEngineering Research InstituteWillow Run Laboratories,Willow Run AirportYpsilanti, MichiganAttn: Librarian
University of MinnesotaMinneapolis 14, MinnesotaAttn: Mr. Robert H. Stumm, Library
Physical Science LaboratoryNew Mexico College of Agriculture
and Mechanics ArtsState College, New MexicoAttn: Mr. H. W. Haas
New York UniversityInstitute of Mathematical SciencesRoom 80225 Waverly PlaceNew York 3, New YorkAttn: Professor Morris Kline
Northwestern UniversityMicrowave LaboratoriesEvanston, Illinoisi Attn: R. E. Beam
II
List S-S - page 22
ORGANIZATION No. of Copies
Ohio State University Research Foundation1314 Kinnear RoadColumbus 8, OhioAttn: Dr. T. E. Tice
Department of Electrical Engineering
The University of OklahomaResearch InstituteNorman, OklahomaAttn: Professor C. L. Farrar, Chairman
Electrical Engineering
The Pennsylvania State University 1Department of Electrical EngineeringUniversity Park, Pennsylvania
University of Pennsylvania 1Institute of Cooperative Research3400 Walnut StreetPhiladelphia, PennsylvaniaAttn: Department of Electrical Engineering
Polytechnic Institute of BrooklynMicrowave Research Institute55 Johnson StreetBrooklyn, New YorkAttn: Dr. Arthur A. Oliner
Polytechnic Institute of BrooklynMicrowave Research Institute55 Johnson StreetBrooklyn, New YorkAttn: Mr. A. E. Laemmel
Purude University 1Department of Electrical EngineeringLafayette, IndianaAttn: Dr. Schultz
Library 1W. W. Hansen Laboratory of PhysicsStanford UniversityStanford, California
List S-S - page 23
OnRGANITION No. of Copies
Syracuse University Research Institute1I Collendale Campus
Syracuse 10, New York
Attn: Dr. C. S. Grove, Jr.Director of Engineering Research
Technical University 1Oestervoldgade 10 GCopenhagen, DenmarkAttn: Professor Hans Lottrup Knudsen
University of TennesseeFerris HallW. Cumberland AvenueKnoxville 16, Tennessee
The University of TexasElectrical Engineering Research Lab.P. 0. Box 8026University StationAustin 12, TexasAttn: Mr. John R. Gerhardt
Assistant Director
The University of TexasDefense Research LaboratoryAustin, TexasAttn: Claude W. Horton, Physics Library
University of Toronto 1Department of Electrical EngineeringToronto, CanadaAttn: Professor G. Sinclair
University of WashingtonDepartment of Electrical EngineeringSeattle 5, WashingtonAttn: D. K. Reynolds
University of WisconsinDepartment of Electrical EngineeringMadisonj WisconsinAttn: Dr. Scheibe