REPORT— MARCH 2019
SECONDARY AGE REVIEW
01
SPORT NEW ZEALAND
FOREWORD PAGE03
INTRODUCTION PAGE04
PREVIOUSREVIEWS PAGE07
WHATDOESPARTICIPATIONLOOKLIKEINTHISAGEGROUP? PAGE10
THEPHYSICALACTIVITYENVIRONMENT PAGE18
THEWORLDYOUNGPEOPLELIVEIN PAGE22
KEYTHEMES,RISKSANDAPPROACHES PAGE26
ACTIVATINGTHISREVIEW PAGE36
SUMMARY PAGE37
CONTENTS
03
SPORT NEW ZEALAND
SportNZisinthefourthyearofitscurrentfive-yearstrategicperiodwithworkwellunderwaytotransitiontoanewstrategyspanning2020-24.Acrossthistransition,ourfocuswillremainonminimisingthedrop-offinphysicalactivityforyoungpeople,whichincludessustainingthelevelofthosewhoareactiveand,equallyimportantly,improvingoutcomesforthosewhoarelessactive.
ThesecondaryagegroupisatriskinNewZealand.WeknowfromthenationwideActiveNZ2017surveythatparticipationisatitshighestfromages12to14.Meanwhilethefirstsignificantdrop-offbothintimespentandfrequencyofbeingphysicallyactiveoccursatage15.Mostwillneverrecoverfromthisdrop-offacrosstheirlifetime.
Toaddressthesignificantchallengesteenagersarefacing,forexample,pressuresatschoolandwidermentalhealth,wemustunderstandtheworldouryoungpeopleliveinandprovidequalityopportunitiestoparticipatethatmeettheirholisticneeds.Inrecentyearswehaverecognisedthatmeetingparticipants’changingneedsmeansfocusingourworkondemand–whattoday’sparticipantswant–ratherthanwhattheplay,activerecreationandsportsystemhastraditionallysupplied.
ThisReviewhasdemonstratedthatwe’renotthereyet.Ithasbroughttolightkeyinsights,namelythatteenagersarenotahomogeneousgroup,andtheissuestheyfacediffer,forexample,bygender,andforaYear9studentcomparedtoaYear13student.Theopportunitiesweprovidemustbeasdiverseastheyare.
Thesecondaryagegroupiswhenyoungpeoplecometounderstandthevalueof,andwiderhealthandwellbeingbenefitsaffordedby,aphysicallyactivelife.Unlessweprovidevaluedexperiencesthatmeettheirneeds,theywillspendtheirtimeinotherways–whichmeansdramaticlong-termnegativeimpactsonourhealthsystemandoursocialandcommunityconnectedness.
Althoughthisreviewiswiderthansportinthetraditionalsense,thisisalsotheagegroupwheretalentisrevealed.Inthisrespect,manyofourtalentedyoungathletesareatriskofintegrityissuessuchasearlyspecialisationanddoping.Wehavetakenstepstoimproveexperiencesforyoungpeopleincompetitivesportthroughimprovedcoaching,targetedinvestmentintogrowthsportsandthroughkeymessagesthatbalanceisbetterandhavingfunisparamount.Yetthereisstillmuchworktodo.
Weencourageorganisationsacrossthesystem–sport,activerecreationandothers–tocollaborateandinnovateatthesystemleveltoprovideequitableandqualityexperienceswhichmakecollectiveimpacttobringaboutchange.Asanexample,Councilsshouldworkwithclubsandschools,andphysicalactivityprovidersshouldworkwithchurchesandyouthgroupstoshareapassionforactiveopportunities.
Finally,wechampionlocalsolutionsandco-design–weneedtohearyoungpeople’svoicesinconversationsanddecisionsaboutthem.Youngpeopleunderstandthewellbeingissuestheyfaceandarebestplacedtoworkwithadultsandco-designmeaningfulsolutionswhichhavelong-lasting,empoweringimpact.I’dliketothankalloftheyoungpeopleandthoseworkingacrossthesectorwhosevoicesarereflectedinandhavecontributedtothisreport.
PETER MISKIMMIN CHIEF EXECUTIVE SPORT NZ
WE ARE PLEASED TO SHARE THE FINDINGS OF OUR REVIEW INTO SECONDARY AGE YOUNG PEOPLE IN SPORT AND ACTIVE RECREATION
Theteenagelifestageisoneofthemostat-riskforestablishingongoinghabitsandalife-longloveofparticipatinginsportandphysicalactivity.
Afterincreasesthroughouttheprimaryyears,teenageparticipationdropsinallareas–timespent,numberofactivities,involvement–andtheproportionofparticipantsspendingnotimeatallbeingactiveclimbsfromaroundtheageof15.1
Girls,inparticular,haveasignificantfocusonself-drivenactivitiessuchaswalkingforfitness,swimmingandrunning/joggingratherthanorganisedteamsport.OurActiveNZSurvey(2017)suggeststhatre-engagementinsportbeyondschoolisincreasinglychallenging,withasignificantreductioninactivityof13.9percentinthe18-24-year-oldagegroupduringthepast16years.2
Studiesshowtheproportionofparticipantswhodon’tlikesportalsoincreasesthroughtheteenageyears,suggestingthesportofferingisnotmeetingtheirneeds.3
Significantissuesthatimpactthequalityofyoungpeople’sexperiencesinclude:
� Self-confidence,self-esteemandbodyimage� Overemphasisoncompetitionandwinning� Earlyspecialisation� Poorplayermanagement–overuseinjuries,pressuretosucceed,selection/
deselection� Lackofability/skills/physicalcompetence� Peerpressure� Parentalpressureandinfluence� Competingdemandsontimeandinterest–study,friends,family,sport,work� Clubvsschoolcompetingdemands� Sportstructuresandofferingsnotrespondingtoyouthexpectations/lifestyle.
“I do realise that it’s quite competitive. You get a bit nervous because you dont want to lose because everyone would be angry with you ‘cos you’d let the ball go past. But most of the time you’re just there to try and enjoy it”-14YEAROLDRESPONDENT,TOUCHPLAYER
1 sportnz.org.nz/managing-sport/search-for-a-resource/research/active-nz-survey-2017 2 Sport and Active Recreation in New Zealand. The 16-Year Adult Participation Trends 1998 to 2014, 20163 Young People’s Survey (YPS), Sport NZ 2011
INTRODUCTION04
SECONDARY AGE REVIEW
When you’re young there’s heaps of teams that you can get into but as you get older it slowly fades out and there’s just less and less teams and to get into them you have to be like highly competitive to even find a team to play in.”
- TEENAGE SPORTS FOCUS GROUP PARTICIPANT
Thisreviewaimsto:
� understandthepatterns,barriersandmotivationsforparticipationinsportandphysicalactivitybyyoungteenageNewZealanders
� developanunderstandingofthecurrentandfutureenvironmental/societalandintra-personalimpactsonthatparticipation
� identifyapproachesthatmightbeadoptedbythoseresponsiblefortheprovisionofsportandactiverecreationopportunitiesforthisagegroup.
Someoftheseapproacheswillbeestablishedthroughotherworkcurrentlyunderwayorinimplementation–including:
� SportNZ’snewSportDevelopmentteamfocusesonthecompetitivesportexperiencesofsecondary-agedparticipants
� WearepromotingourTalentDevelopmentPlan,‘BalanceisBetter’,andestablishingAthleteDevelopmentLeaderstoactivatethatplan
� WehaveundertakenreviewsofSportIntegrity,Ma-oriParticipationandtheKiwiSportRegionalPartnershipFund
� WearelookingtoexpandtheGoodSportspilot,designedtocommunicatethecharacteristicsofaqualityexperiencetoprovidersandsupportersofsportforyoungpeople
� WearerespondingtotheGovernment’sStrategyforWomenandGirlsinSportandActiveRecreation4withoursetofcommitments5
� WearepromotingandfurtherdevelopingourPhysicalLiteracy,LocallyLedDeliveryandInsightsapproaches6
� WeareimplementingourActiveRecreationReview7
� Valueseducationprogrammesareavailabletoschools,suchasSportinEducation,TLC(Talent–Leadership–Character),GoodCleanSport(DrugfreeSportNZ)andtheOlympicValuesEducationProgramme
� Weprovideprofessionaldevelopmentsupportforschoolsportpersonnel,includingRSDsandsportscoordinators
� Educationsystemreformsareunderway.8
Thisreviewisinformedbymanyoftheaboveinitiatives,andsomekeypiecesofresearchthatarestillinprogress:ourActiveNZparticipationsurvey,ourVoiceofParticipant(Clubs)andtheVoiceofParticipant(Schools)workledbySportTaranakiandSportTasman.Someofthedatawillbeupdatedasthesepiecesofworkarefinalised.
Thereviewanditsresultingimplementationplanswillalsoinformour2020-24strategy.
4 sportnz.org.nz/assets/Uploads/Women-and-Girls-Govt-Strategy.pdf 5 sportnz.org.nz/assets/Uploads/Women-and-Girls-Sport-NZ-Commitments.pdf 6 sportnz.org.nz/about-us/who-we-are/what-were-working-towards/three-approaches/ 7 sportnz.org.nz/about-us/our-publications/sport-nz-active-recreation-sector-sept-2016 8 conversation.education.govt.nz
06
SECONDARY AGE REVIEW
SchoolSportFuturesIn2014and2015,SportNZundertookacomprehensivereviewofschoolsportandphysicaleducation,theSchoolSportFuturesProject.9Wecompletedthisworkinresponsetolong-standingconcernsaboutthequalityandquantityofphysicalactivity,PEandsportavailabletoyoungpeopleinNewZealand–thereportmade11recommendations:
Supportschools
� ProvideschoolswithaccesstoPEmentorsandteacherprofessionaldevelopment(primary)
� ProvideschoolswithexpertiseinunderstandinganddeliveringaqualityPEcurriculum(primary)
� Engageschool-basedstafftoalignsportandphysicalactivityopportunitieswiththecurriculum,andtoconnectschoolandcommunityopportunities(primaryandsecondary).
Communitiesleadandmanagetheirownsolutions
� Establishcommunityalliancestoensureconsistencyofopportunityandexperienceforyoungpeopleintheircommunities
� EstablishsharedoperatingmodelsforfacilitiesandplacesbetweenschoolsandCouncils
� EstablishaQualityAssuranceprocessforcommunitysportproviderswhoaccessschoolenvironments.
Governmentleadership
� Long-term,cross-partyandcross-agencygovernmentcommitmenttotheplaceofsportandphysicalactivityinyoungpeople’slives
� AdoptaPhysicalLiteracyapproach� Betterresearch,monitorandevaluateyoungpeople’sinitiativestoensuretheyare
meetingtheirneeds� Areviewofinitialteachereducation(ITE).
Parenteducationandinformation
� Betterunderstandwhatmakesaqualityexperienceforyoungpeople,andtherolethatparentsandothersupportersplay.
Thereviewrecommendations,particularlysupportforschools,havebeenimplementedlargelyintheprimarysettingtodatethroughPlay.sport.10Inaddition,wehaveinitiatedaqualityassuranceprocessforproviders,ourPhysicalLiteracyapproach11iswelldeveloped,andweareworkingtoestablishcollaborativepartnershipsbetweenschoolandcommunityfacilityowners.
9 sportnz.org.nz/assets/Uploads/attachments/managing-sport/young-people/School-Sport-Futures- Project-Final-Report.pdf 10 sportnz.org.nz/about-us/who-we-are/what-were-working-towards/play-sport 11 sportnz.org.nz/assets/Uploads/SPNZ-AG1039-SPNZ-Physical-Literacy-AW4.pdf
PREVIOUS REVIEWS
07
SPORT NEW ZEALAND
08
SECONDARY AGE REVIEW
BestpracticereviewofsportandPAinterventionsfor13-18-year-olds12
ThemostsignificantNewZealandreviewintothesecondaryagecohortwascompletedin2006andmadeanumberofrecommendationsandobservations:
� Useclearandmoreconsistentterminology(physicalactivity,sportetc)� Establishphysicalactivityguidelines,andmonitorthemmoreeffectively� NationalleadershipfromSPARC(SportNZ)� Clearerrolesandresponsibilitiesforsportprovisiontothisagegroup� Reducethenumberofexternalsport/PAagenciesworkinginschools� MergeschoolsportorganisationswithRSTs,andadoptSchoolSportUnitswithin
thoseRSTs� Makeschoolsportgovernancetheresponsibilityofprincipals’groups,whowouldact
asadvisorstoRSTs� Betterevaluateandmonitorsportandphysicalactivitystrategiesandplans� Increasefocusonunstructured,non-competitiveandnon-sportopportunities,that
fitaroundchangingyouthlifestylesandareinformedbyyoungpeople� Increaseresourcingandsupportforteacherswhosupportsport,andforsports
coordinators� Betterintegrateschoolsport/physicalactivitywithclub/communityopportunities� Anationwidemarketingcampaignaimedat13-18-year-olds.
12 Best Practice Review of Sport and Physical Activity Interventions for Young People Aged 13-18yrs; Kolt et al 2006
09
SPORT NEW ZEALAND
TalentdevelopmentIn2015,SportNZconsultedthesectorabouttalentidentificationanddevelopmentaspartofestablishingourTalentStrategy–‘BalanceisBetter’.13Similarthemeswereidentifiedthroughthisprocess:
� Theselection,playerdevelopmentprocessesandcompetitionstructuresadoptedbythesectorareoftennotfocusedonyoungpeoples’needs
� Thereisalackofholisticapproachestodevelopmentandathletemanagement� Therearepoorconnectionsandalignment,andunclearpathways,betweendelivery
agencies–NSOs,RSOs,schools� Parentsupportandunderstandingiscritical� Accesstoqualitycoachingisanimportantenabler� Multiplesportexperiences,ratherthanearlyspecialisation,areimportantintalent
development� Sportinschoolsisoftenseenasamarketingtoolbyschoolleaders,anda
professionalcareeropportunitybyparents.Theeducativevalueofsportisoftenbeinglostinthepursuitofresultsandtrophies.
Inadditiontothesetwokeypiecesofwork,anumberofNewZealandandoverseasresearchershaveregularlyidentifiedtheenablersandbarrierstoparticipationbysecondary-agedyoungpeople.SeveralNSOshaveundertaken,orareconducting,reviewsoftheirsportsinthisagegroup(e.g.NewZealandFootball,NewZealandRugby,NetballNewZealand,VolleyballNewZealand)inresponsetodecreasingparticipationandmembership,andinsightsgatheredthroughresearchtoolssuchastheVoiceofParticipantSurvey.
Similarly,insightsintothepatterns,enablersandbarriersofparticipationinwiderphysicalactivity,particularlyforgirls,havebeenundertakeninestablishinginitiativessuchasShift,HERAandThisisMe(SportWaikato).
Anumberoftherecommendationsfromthesepreviousreviewsandresearchinquirieshavebeenimplemented–forexample,PhysicalActivityguidelines,improvednationalleadership–buttheissuesidentifiedbythemarestillprevalentinthe13-18-yearagegroup.
13 sportnz.org.nz/assets/Uploads/SportNZ-BalanceIsBetter.pdf
10
SECONDARY AGE REVIEW
WHAT DOES PARTICIPATION LOOK LIKE IN THIS AGE GROUP?
Althoughyoungpeople’sparticipationinsportandphysicalactivityisrelativelyhigh,theteenageyearsaremarkedbyreductionsin:
� timespentparticipating� theproportionoftimespentbeingactiveincurriculumtime(largelyduetoPE
becominganoptionalsubjectafterYear10)� thenumberofactivities� timespentplayingwithfriends� confidenceandperceivedcompetence� theenjoymentofplayingsport.
Whatandhowmuchdotheydo?
Theearlysecondaryyearsaremarkedbythehighestparticipationratesofthelifecourse–98percentof12-14-year-oldsparticipateinsportand/orphysicalactivityatleastonceaweek,foranaverageof12.5hours.However,thesemetricsdecreasesignificantlyforthe15-17-yearagegroup–only89percentreportweeklyphysicalactivityandforareducedamountoftime(average8.3hours).
Thesereductionscanbeseenintheproportionoftimespentinorganised(PE,competitionandcoach-ledtraining)vsinformalactivity(playandself-directedtraining).Theproportionoftimespentinorganisedactivitychangesacrosstheagecohortsfromanaverageof6.1hoursperweekto3.8hoursperweek,largelyattributabletoareductioninPEasthesubjectbecomesoptionalatYear11.ThephysicalactivityassociatedwithPEisnotreplacedbyotherincidentalactivity.
Similarly,thetimespentinplay(withandwithoutfriends)dropsfrom5.5hoursperweekinthe12-14-yearagegroupto3.0hoursperweekinthe15-17-yearagegroup.Atthesametimeasthereisadecreaseintrainingforcompetitionwithacoach(0.6hrs)thereisaslightincreaseintrainingalone,withoutacompetitiveaim(0.2hrs).
Overall,60percentofsecondary-agedyoungpeopleparticipate(onaweeklybasis)inactiverecreation(non-sport)activitiesonly.Thirty-threepercentparticipateinbothcompetitivesportandactiverecreationactivities,andonly1percentparticipatesolelyincompetitivesport.
Physicaleducationisasignificantcontributortothetotaltimespentbeingactive–71percentof12-14-year-oldswereactiveinPE,reducingto40percentwhenPEbecomesanoptionalsubjectinYear11.Thenumbersinvolveddropyear-on-yearafterYear11asthesubjectbecomesmoreacademic,andyoungpeopleleaveschool.TheaveragetimespentinPEforthe12-14-yearagegroupis2.4hoursperweek,reducingto1.1hoursperweekfortheolderagegroup.
11
SPORT NEW ZEALAND
FIGURE 2
WEEKLY PARTICIPATION, AVERAGE NUMBER OF HOURS PER WEEK SPENT PARTICIPATING AND AVERAGE NUMBER OF SPORTS AND ACTIVITIES BY AGE.
Young people are much more active than adults. In any given week, 95 per cent of young people and 73 per cent of adults participate. Young people spend an average of 11 hours participating in 5.4 sports and activities. Adults average 5.3 hours in 2.3 sports and activities.
For young people, weekly participation, time spent participating and number of sports and activities peak between ages 12–14, before declining between ages 15–17. Participation is relatively stable throughout adult years before declining again from age 65.
FIGURE 3
WEEKLY PARTICIPATION AND AVERAGE NUMBER OF HOURS PER WEEK SPENT PARTICIPATING BY AGE AND GENDER.
Weekly participation is the same for males and females, except between ages 50–64 when more females are participating. However, males spend more time participating: an extra hour for young males and half an hour for adult males – with the largest gap at ages 18–24. There is no difference in the average number of sports and activities by age and gender and the trend line reflects that in figure 2.
YOUNG PEOPLE ADULTS
Average # hours per week
Average # sports and activities per week
Weeklyparticipation
10.6
5.1 5.4
11.412.5
8.3
5.95.1 5.1 5.4
5.7
4.4
5–7
94%
18–24
75%
25–34
75%
50–64
72%
8–11
96%
12–14
98%
15–17
89%
35–49
77%
65–74
69%
75+
62%
11
95%
5.3
2.3
73%
5.4
6.4
3.9
2.5 2.6 2.62.1 1.9 1.4
Significantly higher/lower than total
PARTICIPATION
YOUNG PEOPLE ADULTS
73
%
74
%
5.6 5.0
11.6 10.4
5–7 8–11 12–14 15–17 18–24 25–34 35–49 50–64 65–74 75+
Average# hours
Weeklyparticipation
94%95% 92% 95% 96% 98% 98% 89% 89% 77% 74% 78% 74% 76% 78% 70% 75% 68% 71% 62% 61%
11.211.8
11.0 11.7
8.2
5.2
13.2
8.5
6.9
5.3
4.9 5.4 5.7
3.8
5.4 5.4 5.85.1
10.0
4.895
%
94
%
MaleMale participation
FemaleFemale participation
Significantly higher/lower than the other gender in the same age group
FIGURES 2 & 3Base: All respondents, excluding not answered.
Q7. (18+) Thinking back over the last 7 days (not including today) have you done any physical activity that was specifically for the purpose of sport, exercise or recreation? Q12. (5–17) In the last 7 days (not including today) have you done any physical activity specifically for sport, physical education (PE), exercise or fun? Q19. (18+).
Still thinking about the physical activities you have done in the last 7 days, in total how many hours did you spend being physically active for sport, exercise or recreation? Q16b. (5–17) In total in the last 7 days how many hours did you spend being physically active for sport, PE, exercise or fun? Q8. (18+) Which of the following have you done in the last 7 days, and which have you done in the last 12 months? Please only
select the activities where you have been physically active specifically for sport, exercise or recreation. Note: reporting is based on responses to the 7 days component of the question. AND Q97. Please select the additional activities you have done in the last 7 days. Q13. (5 to 17) Please tick all the ways you have been physically active for sport, PE, exercise or fun in the last 7 days (not including today).
14
ACTIVE NZ 2017
FIGURE 1WEEKLY PARTICIPATION, TIME AND NUMBER OF ACTIVITIES.
FIGURE 20
WEEKLY PARTICIPATION, I.E, PHYSICALLY ACTIVE IN PE OR CLASS AT SCHOOL PAST 7 DAYS, AND ENJOYMENT OF PE.
Being physically active in any given week in PE or class is highest from ages 8–14, then drops between ages 15–17 when PE is no longer a compulsory subject in the education curriculum.4 Fifty-three per cent continue to be physically active in PE or class at age 15. This drops to 33 per cent at age 16, and 24 per cent at age 17.5 However, overall enjoyment among those taking PE is high.
FIGURE 19
AVERAGE TIME (HOURS) SPENT PER WEEK PARTICIPATING IN DIFFERENT TYPES OF ORGANISED AND INFORMAL SPORTS AND ACTIVITIES BY AGE.
Young people aged 5–7 spend 7.3 hours or 69 per cent of their time participating through play. Those aged 12–14 spend 6.1 hours participating in organised sports and activities – the most of all other age groups. The amount of time spent participating drops by 4.2 hours between aged 12–14 and 15–17, mostly accounted for by a reduction in time spent in play (2.5 hours) and PE (1.3 hours).
5–7
0.2 0.1
8–11
12–14
15–17
Total (hours)
2.1
2.3
2.4
1.1 0.8 1.9 1.5 1.9 1.1 8.3
1.2 2.5 1.3 3.9 1.6
0.7 1.7 0.3 5.0 1.6
0.9 5.3 2.0
12.5
11.4
10.6
PE (or class at school) Competition Training (with a coach)
Extra training
Organised:
Informal: Playing with friends Playing alone
YOUNG PEOPLE
% Physically active in PE/Class in the past 7 days
Enjoyment (total % agree or strongly agree), for those aged 15–17, this is enjoyment among those who chose to continue doing PE after it was no longer compulsory
Enjoyment (total % agree or strongly agree), among those who stopped doing PE after it was no longer compulsory
5–7 8–11 12–14 1515-17 16 17
65% 68% 71% 53%40% 38% 24%
85% 83% 81%89% 89% 90% 87%
29%28% 33%
26%
Significantly higher/ lower than total
FIGURE 20Base: All respondents aged 5–17.
Q12. In the last 7 days (not including today) have you done any physical activity specifically for sport, physical education (PE), exercise or fun? Q16. Where or how did you do <insert activity> in the last 7 days? Q39a. (5–17) Please select a box on each line to show how much you agree or disagree with each statement. (R1) I like/liked PE or fitness class at school.
4. Weekly participation in PE or class between ages 5–14 when a compulsory school subject does not total 100%, as the reported figure is based on one calendar year, not the school year. It does not consider non-attendance or no physical activity undertaken as part of class.
5. The decline is accounted forby fewer young people taking PE with each successive year and less time spent being active in PE or class.
35
SPORT NEW ZEALAND
FIGURE 2AVERAGE TIME SPENT PARTICIPATING IN SPORT AND ACTIVE RECREATION ACTIVITIES.
12
SECONDARY AGE REVIEW
FIGURE 3NON-COMPETITIVE SPORT PARTICIPATION IN THE LAST WEEK.
GenderdifferencesGenderdifferencesinthetimespentparticipatingareevidentinthe12-14-yearagegroup(13.2hoursforboys,11.7hoursforgirls),butthe15-17-yearagegroupshowslittledifference(8.5hoursforboysvs8.2hoursforgirls).
Thereisnosignificantgenderdifferenceinparticipationincompetitiveornon-competitiveactivities.For13-17-year-olds,35percentofgirlsand33percentofboyshaveparticipatedincompetitiveactivities,andforasimilaramountoftime(1.1hoursperweekand1hourperweek,respectively).Fortypercentof12-14-year-oldsparticipateincompetitivesportweekly,droppingto29percentinthe15-17-yeargroup.
Thereisalsolittlegenderdifferenceinthenumberofactivities(average6.4for12-14-year-oldsand3.9for15-17-year-olds).
Themainactivitiestheseagegroupsparticipateinaretypifiedbyhealthandfitnessactivities,play,andgamesinthe12-14-yeargroup,andhealthandfitnessintheolderagecohort.Theonlysportsthatappearinthetopeightactivitiesarenetballforgirls,andfootballandbasketball(for15-17-year-oldsonly)forboys.
OurActiveNZSurvey(2017)alsoclarifiesthatalthoughsomeactivitiesmaybetraditionallyviewedassport,manyparticipantsviewtheirengagementwiththemasnon-competitive.Forexample,acrossthewholeyoungpeopleagerange(5-18-years)only30percentviewedtheirparticipationinfootballascompetitive,26percentinbasketball,50percentinnetballand42percentinrugby.
FIGURE 11
WEEKLY PARTICIPATION IN NON-COMPETITIVE SPORTS AND ACTIVITIES IN THE PAST 7 DAYS BY AGE AND GENDER.
There is no gender difference among young people when it comes to weekly participation in non-competitive sports and activities. On average, female adults are more likely to participate in non-competitive sports and activities, particularly between ages 35–74.
FIGURE 12
WEEKLY PARTICIPATION IN NON-COMPETITIVE SPORTS AND ACTIVITIES BY ETHNICITY AND GENDER.
Among young people, there is little difference in weekly participation in non-competitive sports and activities by ethnicity. Among adults, M-aori, Pacific and Asian are less likely than average to take part, while European and M-aori adult females are more likely to participate in non-competitive activities.
5–7
Male Female
8–11 12–14 15–17 18–24 25–34 35–49 50–64 65–74 75+
YOUNG PEOPLE ADULTS
62
%
64
%
57
%
64
%
Significantly higher/lower than the other gender in the same age group
75%
58% 56%
62%
54%57% 60% 58%
53%
46%
81%
62%59%
57%
58%62%
69% 69%64%
52%
64%
63%
65%
59%
58%
61%
59%
64%
55%
66%
65%
68%
59%
63%
*
57%
*
61%
50%
*
72%
*
67%
68%
67%
9% gap7% gap
63%
YOUNG PEOPLE
Ma-ori Pacific Asian Samoan Indian ChineseEuropean
Ma-ori Pacific Asian Samoan Indian ChineseEuropean
ADULTS
61%
62%
58%
67%
55%
51%
58%
49%
48%
51%
57%
58%
57%
47%
40%
51%
59%
63%
56%
57%
59%
55%
Ethnicity result is significantly higher/lower than the total
Significant gender difference within ethnicityTotal
Male
Female *Base size less than n=100
FIGURES 10, 11 & 12Base: All respondents, excluding not answered.
Q15. (18+) In the last 7 days, have you done this as a competitive sport or a competitive activity? Q16a. (5–17) Where or how did you do <insert activity> in the last 7 days?
27
SPORT NEW ZEALAND
13
SPORT NEW ZEALAND
TABLE 1TOP 8 ACTIVITIES BY AGE. 12-14yrs 15-17yrs
Running, jogging or cross-country Running, jogging or cross-country
Games (e.g. four square, tag, bull rush, dodgeball)
Walking for fitness
Walking for fitness Workout (weights or cardio)
Playing (e.g. running around, climbing trees, make-believe)
Netball
Swimming Swimming
Netball Games (e.g. four square, tag, bull rush, dodgeball)
Dance/dancing (e.g. ballet, hip hop etc)
Dance/dancing (e.g. ballet, hip hop etc)
Trampoline Group exercise class (e.g. aerobics, CrossFit, Jump Jam)
GIRLS
12-14yrs 15-17yrs
Running, jogging or cross-country Running, jogging or cross-country
Games (e.g. four square, tag, bull rush, dodgeball)
Workout (weights or cardio)
Walking for fitness Walking for fitness
Football, soccer or futsal Football, soccer or futsal
Playing (e.g. running around, climbing trees, make-believe)
Cycling or biking
Cycling or biking Games (e.g. four square, tag, bull rush, dodgeball)
Swimming Basketball or Mini-ball
Trampoline Swimming
BOYS
Wheredotheydoit?Themajorityofsecondary-agedyoungpeopleparticipateinsportandphysicalactivityatschool(65percent),57percentathomeandbetween50-58percentinindoorandoutdoorsportfacilities.Themajorityofparticipationshiftsfromclubtoschoolinthesecondaryyears.14
14 sportnz.org.nz/managing-sport/search-for-a-resource/research/young-peoples-survey-2011
14
SECONDARY AGE REVIEW
FIGURE 4WEEKLY PARTICIPATION FOR FUN OR PHYSICAL WELLBEING.
Whatenablesorstopsthemdoingit?
Enablers
Thekeyfactorsthatmotivateadolescentyouthtobephysicallyactiveareorientatedaroundthethemesoffun(physicalactivitymustbeenjoyable),bodyimage(concernsandperceivedoutcomesofbeingphysicallyactiveassociatedwith‘notbeingfat’),friends(socialacceptancebypeersandinteraction),asenseofachievement,andenhancedsportperformance.15
Themajority(76percent)ofyoungpeopleparticipateinphysicalactivityforfun,tohangoutwithfriends(45percent)forfitnessandhealth(31percent)andtolearnnewskills(31percent).Thesemotivationsdifferbytypeofactivity,andtheprimarymotivationshiftsfromfuntohealthandfitnessthroughtheteenageyears.Thistrendismoreevidentforgirls(6percentdifferencethroughouttheteenageyears),andgirlsaresignificantlymorelikelytobeactivetoloseormaintainweight,particularlyinthe15-17yearagegroup(22percentvs10percent).16
Foradolescents,higherlevelsofself-esteemarealsothoughttopositivelypredictactivitylevels.Forexample,Reynoldsetal.researchin2004,foundthatself-efficacycorrelatedpositivelywithphysicalactivitybehaviour,andpredictedweeklyphysicalactivityparticipationinUSadolescentsaged14-16years.17Additionally,inareviewofphysicalactivitybehavioursamongchildrenandadolescents,KohlandHobbs(1998)statedthatyoungpeopleparticipateinphysicalactivitiesforwhichtheyhavepositivefeelings.18NewZealandadolescentshavealsoidentifiedbuildingself-confidenceasareasontheyfindsportappealing.19
15 Leslie et al., 1999; O’Dea, 2003; Park & Wright, 2000; Schofield et al., 2002; Wendell et al., 199916 Active NZ 201717 Reynolds et al (2004): Three-step validation of exercise behaviour processes of change in an adolescent sample. Measurement in Physical Education and Exercise Science18 Kohl and Hobbs (1998): Development of physical activity behaviours among children and adolescents Paediatrics.19 Sport NZ (2005): The Value of Sport: attitudes, barriers and motivations for participation in sport by 11-14-year-olds
MOTIVATION
FIGURE 22
WEEKLY PARTICIPATION IN AT LEAST ONE SPORT OR ACTIVITY FOR FUN OR PHYSICAL WELLBEING BY AGE.
With increasing age, participation for fun declines and wellbeing increases. Between ages 15–17 participation for fun drops. Participating for physical wellbeing begins between ages 12–17. Younger adults aged between 18–34 are less likely to participate for physical wellbeing than those adged 50+.
FIGURE 23
WEEKLY PARTICIPATION IN AT LEAST ONE SPORT OR ACTIVITY FOR FUN BY AGE AND GENDER.
Overall, males are more likely to participate for fun. For young people, this appears to emerge between ages 15–17 when the gap between males and females is the greatest.
5–7 8–11 12–14 15–17 18–24 25–34 35–49 50–64 65–74 75+
YOUNG PEOPLE ADULTS
For fun Physical wellbeing
75+
Significantly higher/lower than the other gender in the same age group
84%
8%
78%
57%
77%
47%54%
78%
24%
82%
23%
79%
18%19%
65% 66%
73%
36% 33%
27%31%
27%
73%
76%
Physical wellbeing
Fun Physical wellbeing
Fun
77
%
74
%
30
%
25
%
5–7 8–11 12–14 15–17 18–24 25–34 35–49 50–64 65–74 75+
YOUNG PEOPLE ADULTS
Male Female Significantly higher/lower than the other gender in the same age group
86%
77%
78%
61%
39% 35% 31% 26% 26%19%
83%80%
76%
54%
33% 31%24% 21% 20% 15%
40
ACTIVE NZ 2017
16
SECONDARY AGE REVIEW
Thevaluethatpeople,organisationsandsocietiesplaceonsportandactiverecreationisalsoapredictorofactivity.WoldandHendry(1998)observed,“Nationsandcountriesdifferinthevalueandmeaningattachedtophysicalactivityintheircultureandthesedifferencesareexpectedtoresultindifferentactivitylevels”.20OurActiveNZSurvey(2017)andtheActiveRecreationreview21identifieddifferencesinparticipationpatternsacrossdifferentethnicgroups,particularlyAsian22,thatmaybeattributabletothisresearchfinding.
Enjoymentishighforallyoungpeople’sagegroups,andthereisrelativelylittlegenderdifference–enjoymentofsportfor15-17-year-oldsis85percent.
Barriers
Irrespectiveofthelevelofactivitytheyarecurrentlyundertaking,allsecondary-agedyoungpeoplewishtodomoreactivity(73percent),particularlygirlsinthe12-14-yearagegroup.
Themainbarriertoincreasingparticipationistime–48percentofthosewhowouldliketobemoreactivearetoobusy.Busylivesassumegreatersignificanceasyoungpeopleprogressthroughtheirteens–41percentof12-14-year-oldsciteothercommitmentsasthereasonwhytheydon’tdoasmuchactivityastheywouldlike,climbingto55percentinthe15-17-yearagegroup,andcontinuingtoincreasepost-secondaryschool.
Seventy-ninepercentofsecondaryschoolstudentsidentifiedschoolworkastheprimaryreasonforthisbusyness–46percentreportedotherhobbies,35percentotherphysicalactivityand20percentemploymentresponsibilities.Schoolworkassumesgreaterimportanceacrosstheagegroups,andtheintroductionofworkandjobsinthe15-17-yearagegroupcorrespondswithsignificantreductionsinotherphysicalactivityandhobbies.
20 Best Practice Review of Sport and Physical Activity Interventions for Young People aged 13-18, pg 57 Auckland University of Technology (2006) ibid.21 sportnz.org.nz/about-us/our-publications/sport-nz-active-recreation-sector-sept-201622 sportnz.org.nz/managing-sport/search-for-a-resource/research/active-nz-survey-2017
17
SPORT NEW ZEALAND
FIGURE 5KEY BARRIERS TO PARTICIPATION.
Eighteenpercent(of12-14-year-olds)and30percent(of15-17-year-olds)don’thavetheenergyandsimilarproportions(16percentand27percent,respectively)can’tmotivatethemselvestobeactive.Asignificantproportion(21percent)areaffectedbyjudgementbarriers:lackofconfidence,fitnessorfearoffailure.Judgementbarriersaremoreprevalentforgirls(25percentforgirlscf.16percentforboys).
Fifteenpercentofyoungpeopleinthisagegrouparealsoimpactedbysocialbarriers:nothavinganyonetoparticipatewith,orapeergroupthatisnotactiveintheactivitiessoughtbytheyoungperson.
Physicalandculturalsafetyplayaroleinenablingaccesstophysicalactivity.Theconcernforsafetyregardingactivetransportationwasespeciallyacknowledgedbyfemalestudents23and25percentofmothersworrythattheirchildrenwillgethurtwhentheydophysicalactivity.24Differentethnicgroupsmaybeunabletoparticipateforreligiousorculturalreasons(e.g.respectingreligiousdressrequirements).25
Supplycanalsopresentabarriertoparticipation–thisisparticularlyevidentinlowdecile,highdeprivationareas,andgeographicallyisolatedcommunities.Thesecommunitiestypicallydonothaveaccesstoawidevarietyofsportandactivityproviders,sportandrecreationfacilitiesorequipment.Logisticalbarrierssuchasalackoftransportoptions,eventsandactivitiesthatareonatthe‘wrong’timeandfinancialconstraintsalsopresentsignificantchallenges.
23 Auckland University of Technology (2006) Best Practice Review of Sport and Physical Activity Interventions for Young People aged 13-18, pg 6224 sportnz.org.nz/managing-sport/search-for-a-resource/research/active-nz-survey-201725 School Sport Futures Project, Discussion document 1: Background Information, pg 6
FIGURE 32
HOW KEY BARRIERS CHANGE BY AGE (AGES 8+).
As a barrier, other commitments taking priority or being too busy is higher between ages aged 15–17 and continues to be higher for adults aged 18–49, peaking between ages 25 and 49. Other commitments, preferring to spend time on other interests, and already doing a good amount of activity are barriers for an equal proportion of those aged 65–74. Twenty-four per cent of those aged 18–24 prefer to spend time on other interests and hobbies. This emerges again as more of a barrier from age 65.
FIGURE 33
HOW KEY BARRIERS CHANGE BY AGE (AGES 8+).
Lack of energy and lack of self-motivation are more prominent barriers for adults than young people, although they do surface between ages 15–17. Among adults, lack of energy and self-motivation peak between ages 18–24 before becoming less of a barrier from age 50.
FIGURES 31 32 & 33Base: All respondents, excluding not answered.
Q32. (18+) For what reasons are you not doing as much physical activity as you would like? For what reasons do you not want to do more physical activity than you are currently doing?
Q23. (8-17) Why are you not doing as much physical activity as you would like? Why do you not want to do more than you are currently doing?
49
SPORT NEW ZEALAND
Other commitments are taking priority (e.g, work, family)/too busyI prefer to spend my time on other interests / hobbiesI already do a good amount of physical activity
8–11 12–14 15–17 18–24 25–34 35–49 50–64 65–74 75+
YOUNG PEOPLE ADULTS
42
%
13
%
17
%
58
%
21
%
17
%
Significantly higher/lower than total
35%23%
15%
55%
12%11%
41%
14%12%
63%
11%
24%
72%
9%17%
73%
12%
14%
56%
30%38%
35%
15%
30%29%
19%
19%
8–11 12–14 15–17 18–24 25–34 35–49 50–64 65–74 75+
YOUNG PEOPLE ADULTS
I struggle to motivate myselfI am too tired or don’t have the energy Significantly higher/lower than total
10%
8%
30%
27%18%
16%
35%
39% 34%31%
26%
24% 11%
7%9%
12%20%
19%
17
%
16
%
24
%
23
%
““I got really sick of it because I missed the tryouts because they didn’t give the notices out for where they were…and it was my first year but others knew because they had been there for like four years...” -YEAR9GIRL
NewZealandhasarelativelywell-structuredsystemtosupportsportandactiverecreationforteenagers.Morethan50percentofsecondaryschoolstudentsparticipateinaschoolsportsteam,andmorethan50percentareengagedinsportoractiverecreationthroughacommunityorganisationsuchasaclub–overallsportandphysicalactivityparticipationforsecondary-agedyoungpeopleis93percent.26
TheNewZealandenvironmentislargelyaccessibletoanyonewhowishestobephysicallyactivethroughactiverecreationandplay–localauthoritiesspendanestimated$800millionperyeardevelopingandmaintainingcommunityfacilitiesandspaces.OurActiveNZSurvey(2017)resultssuggestthatthesearewellutilisedbyyoungpeople–58percentofteenagersuseoutdoorsportsfacilitiesand56percentuseoutdoorrecreationlocations.
SchoolsettingGivenmostyoungpeopleattendschool,thisisthemostequitableandaccessibleenvironmentforphysicalactivityandsport,providingtheschoolcultureenablesandencouragesparticipationandactivitybyensuringaccesstotheseopportunitiesforall.
Almostallsecondaryschoolshaveaccesstoadedicatedsportscoordinator(orcoordinators)–manyalsohaveadirector/headofsportresponsibleforsettingthestrategicdirectionofsportintheirschools,andincreasinglyschoolsareaddingsportsexpertiseandathletedevelopmentprogrammestocaterfortalentedathletes.Around6,000teachers,3,700studentsand8,600communitypersonnelcoachschoolteams.
Sportscoordinators,however,areunderpressuretocatertoanincreasingdemandforvarietyandchoiceinthesportoffering.Theytypically:
� arepart-time(54percent)� havebeenintheroleforlessthan3years(53percent)� haveotherschoolrolessuchasteachingorsupportstaff(65percent)� areover46-years-old(50percent)� arefemale(67percent).27
Increasedresourcingforsportscoordinatorshasbeenregularlyproposedthroughreviews–mostrecentlytheGrahamTaskForceReport(2000)28andtheBestPracticeReview(2006)29–andworkloadpressureisregularlycitedasareasonwhytherangeofoptionsavailableinschoolscannotbeexpanded,norinnovativepracticesintroduced.
Schoolsportisalsosupportedbyanetworkofregionalsportsdirectors,andtheNZSecondarySchoolsSportsCouncil(NZSSSC).Theserolestypicallyareresponsibleforcoordinatinganddeliveringacalendarofinter-schoolsportcompetitions,forsupportingtheschoolsportworkforcewithplanningandprofessionaldevelopmentopportunities,andforadvocatingforthevalueofsporttoseniorleadership.Theyalsobrokertherelationshipbetweenthesport(clubs)andtheeducation(school)sectors.
26 Physical activity at least once in the past 7 days for sport, PE, exercise or fun27 nzsssc.org.nz/NZSSSC-Census-Data/Sports-Coordinator-Survey-Report 28 Getting Set for an Active Nation, Prof R McConnell, 200029 Best Practice Review, 2006
THE PHYSICAL ACTIVITY ENVIRONMENT
18
SECONDARY AGE REVIEW
Morethan200nationalinter-schoolsportseventsarecoordinatedbytheNZSSSC,whichalsodevelopsandimplementspoliciesandproceduresdesignedtoenhancethequalityoftheexperienceforsecondaryschoolparticipants.
Thesettingsforengagementinsportsthroughthesecondaryyearsaresharedbetweentheschoolandtheclubsystem–insomecasesthereisanagreementbyonesettingoranothertobetheprimaryprovider(e.g.rugbythroughschools,swimmingthroughclubs)whileforothercodesthereiscompetitionbetweensettingsformembersandparticipants,particularlyinfootball.
Schoolscontendtheyarebestplacedtounderstandthepressuresfacingyoungpeopleandcanensuretheirsportprovisiontakesthisintoaccount.Clubsontheotherhandarguethedisruptionfromparticipationinacommunitysettingthroughtheprimaryyearsisasignificantcontributortodrop-offpost-secondaryschool,withyoungpeoplefindingitdifficulttore-integrateintotheclubsystemafterfiveyearsawayfromit.
PhysicalEducation(PE)isacompulsorysubjectinsecondaryschoolsuntilYear10,afterwhichitbecomesoptionalinmostschools.OurActiveNZSurvey(2017)reportsthat53percentofstudentscontinuewithPEatYear11,butthatthisproportionreducesthroughtheremainderofthesecondaryyears,to33percentinYear12and24percentinYear13.ThosetakingPEbeyondYear10enjoythesubject(89percent),whilethosethatdon’thaveapoorerviewoftheirtimespentinPEuptoYear10(29percent).
PhysicalEducationispartoftheHealthandPhysicalEducation(HPE)curriculumarea,whichiscentredonhauoraandwellbeing.DespitethecommonlyexpressedviewthatsportandPEaresynonymous,theHPEcurriculumismorecomplex,andsportisonlyoneofmanycontextsthatareusedtodeliverfourstrandsofthesubject:PersonalHealthandDevelopment,MovementConceptsandMotorSkills,RelationshipswithOtherPeopleandHealthyCommunitiesandEnvironments.
In2015,theSchoolSportFuturesprojectobservedthecurriculumdeliveryfromYear11toYear13oftenbecomesmoreacademic,andthatthesubjectareacanfightforacademiclegitimacyamongthemanyoptionsthatareofferedinseniorschool.
FIGURE 6FOUR DIMENSIONS OF HAUORA, TE WHARE TAPA WHA, DR MASON DURIE.
19
SPORT NEW ZEALAND
TAHA HINENGARO Mental healthInseparability of mind and body; expressing thoughts and feelings.
TAHA WHANAU Extended family healthWider social systems; belonging, sharing and caring.
TAHA WAIRUA Spiritual healthUnseen and unspoken energies; faith and spiritual awareness.
TAHA TINANA Physical healthGood physical health.
CommunitysettingMorethan50percentofteenagersparticipateoutsidetheschoolsetting,throughclubs,privateproviderssuchashealthandfitnessbusinessesandfacilityproviders,andoutdoors.
SportNZ’sVoiceofParticipantsurvey(VoP)showedrelativelyhigherdisaffectionthanotheragecohortswiththeclubexperienceamongyoungpeopleinselectedsports.Theywereparticularlydissatisfiedwiththeregistrationprocess,andwerelesslikelythanotheragegroupstorecommendtheclubtoothers.Girls,inparticular,arelesssatisfiedthanboys,particularlyintheareasoffairness,facilitiesandinclusiveness.
Secondary-agedyoungpeoplearemorelikelytojoinacommunityclubforcompetition,seekimprovedcoachingthroughthatenvironmentandtohavebeeninjuredinthepast12months,whencomparedwithotheragecohorts.Clubmembersinthisagegrouparesignificantlylesslikelytobemale,(48percentmalecomparedwith64percentacrossallagegroups),European/Pakeha(66percentcf.80percent)andtobeplayingortraininglessthanonceperweek(9percentcf.24percent).30
30 sportnz.org.nz/managing-sport/voice-of-participant/club-member-experience-survey/
20
SECONDARY AGE REVIEW
HomesettingThehomesettingistheprimarylocationforphysicalactivityinthepre-schoolyears–thisshiftstoclubsandcommunityintheprimary/intermediateyearsandtoschoolsinthesecondaryyears.31
Thehomeenvironmentisincreasinglymarkedbysocietalanddemographicshifts.Morefamilieshavetwoworkingparents,18percentofyoungpeopleliveinsingle-parenthomes,andthereisanincreasingnumberofcouple-onlyfamilies(41percentofallfamilyhouseholds).Theaveragenumberofchildrenperfamilyistwo,andtheageatwhichwomenaregivingbirthtotheirfirstchildisincreasing(29years).32
Theincreasingethnicallydiversepopulationhasanimpactonsupportforsportandphysicalactivity,asparents’valuesdetermineparentalsupportfor,andfamilyprioritisationof,sportandactivity.Increasingproportionsofourpopulationdidnotgrowupwithaheritageofsportandoutdooractivity.Further,someculturesexpectthatyoungpeopleworkinthefamilybusiness,carefortheirsiblingsandwiderwha-nau,orobservereligiouspracticesthatmayconflictwithweekendgames,practicesessionsandactiverecreation/sportopportunitiesoutsidetheschoolsetting.
Parentalinfluenceplaysanimportantroleindeterminingyoungpeople’sactivitybehaviour,eitherdirectlythroughmodelling,orindirectly(Kohl&Hobbs,1998;Sallis,2000a),andhasbeenshowntohavebothpositiveandnegativeeffectsonyoungpeople’ssportandphysicalactivitybehaviour.33The2011YoungPeople’sSurveyshowedthatparentsaretheprimaryinfluencersforboysandgirlsaged10-14years.
Thenumberofactivitiespresentedinthehomesettinginearlierchildhoodhasbeenshowntohaveaneffectonpersistentactivity,persistentinactivity,anddecliningparticipationinadolescence34andpsychologicalfactorsarealsowidelyacceptedasdeterminantsofphysicalactivitybehaviourinyoungpeople(Sallisetal.,2000;Strauss,Rodzilsky,Burack,&Colin,2001).
Parentsarethefunders,transportersandsupportersofsportandactiverecreationforyoungpeopleandassucharemajordeterminantsinthefrequency,timeandlocationofthatactivity.Inadditiontothepositivecontributiontheymake,theirvaluesandattitudescandrivenegativebehaviourssuchasanemphasisonearlyspecialisation,afocusonwinningoverdevelopment,poorsidelinebehaviour,andpursuitoftalentdevelopmentopportunitiesatyoungagesthroughacademiesandcamps.
31 sportnz.org.nz/managing-sport/search-for-a-resource/research/young-peoples-survey-201132 Statistics NZ, 2013 Census33 As cited in Best Practice Review of Sport and Physical Activity Interventions for Young People aged 13-18, (2006) pg 5934 Richards, R., Poulton, R., Reeder, A.I., Williams, S.M. (2009).Childhood and contemporaneous correlates of adolescent physical inactivity: a longitudinal study. Journal of Adolescent Health, 2009, 44(44), 260-267.
21
SPORT NEW ZEALAND
GenerationZToday’ssecondary-agedyoungpeoplearepartoftheGenZgeneration(oriGen,orFoundersorCentennials,bornafter1996)comprising25percentoftheUSpopulation(morethanBabyBoomersandMillennials).
GenZarehighlyeducated,wanttomakeadifferenceintheworldandaremorediversethanMillennials.Theyareincreasinglyself-aware,self-reliant,innovativeandgoal-oriented.
GenZarethefirstgenerationnottohaveknownlifewithoutsocialmedia–42percentfeelthatsocialmediahasadirectimpactonhowtheyfeelaboutthemselves,andthesamepercentagesaysocialmediaaffectshowpeopleseethem(comparedto28percentofthepreviousgeneration).Socialmediaalsoimpactsontheirhappiness(37percent)andself-esteem(39percent).
ResearchersintheUShaveshownGenZyouthhavelowerteenpregnancyrates,lesssubstanceabuse,andhigheron-timesecondaryschoolgraduationratescomparedwithMillennials.Theycomparedteensfrom2008and2014andfounda40percentdropinteenpregnancy,a38percentdropindrugandalcoholabuse,anda28percentdropinthepercentageofteenswhodidnotgraduateontimefromsecondaryschool.35
Theyprefertobecommunicatedwithviasocialmedia,prefer‘coolproducts’over‘coolexperiences’andrespondto‘edgy’campaigns(preferablythroughvideo).Seventy-fivepercentwanttoconverttheirhobbiestofulltimejobs,and61percentwouldratherbeanentrepreneurthananemployeeaftertheyfinishschool.36
WellbeingandhealthAlthoughmostteenagersarerelativelywellandhappy,thereisanincreasingprevalenceofthosewithmentalhealthconcerns,particularlyforgirls.Thirty-sevenpercentofsecondary-agedstudentsreportedsleepproblemsthathadlastedmorethanonemonth,19percentreporteddepressionand17percentanxiety.37Ratesofyouthsuicideinthisagegrouparethehighestintheworldforboys,andfourthhighestforgirls.Highdeprivationcommunitiespresentelevatedmentalandphysicalhealthissues.
Screentimeandsocialmediausehavebeenshowntocorrelatetoincreasedfeelingsoflonelinessandfeelingleftout,andincreasedlikelihoodofdepression.38Anti-depressantuseamong14-18-year-oldsinNewZealandhasincreased102percentsince2006.39
Weightandbodyimageissuesaresignificantforthisagegroup,andyoungpeopleincreasinglycitephysicalwellbeingastheprimarymotivatorfortheirengagementinsportandphysicalactivity.Pressuretoconformtoabodyshapeandsizeiswelldocumentedandhasbeenexacerbatedbypublicmedia,advertisingandsocialmediacampaignswhichportrayimagesthatfewyoungpeoplecanidentifywith,butneverthelessaspireto.
OurActiveNZSurvey(2017)showsapositivecorrelationbetweentheamountoftimespentbeingactive,andaseriesofwellbeingindicators:emotionalwellbeing,healthyeating,sleepandreducedscreentime.
THE WORLD YOUNG PEOPLE LIVE IN
35 aecf.org/blog/who-is-generation-z 36 VisionCritical 201537 Youth 2000 Survey Series – The Health & Wellbeing of NZ Secondary School Students 201238 Jean M. Twenge: iGen: Why Today’s Super-Connected Kids are Growing Up Less Rebellious, More Tolerant, Less Happy..”39 Amy Wiggins: NZ Herald 7 June 2017
22
SECONDARY AGE REVIEW
Wellbeingisalsoanincreasinglyimportantpoliticaldrivergivenitscontributiontothehealthsystem,workforceproductivityandeducation.Initialfindingsfromtheeducationreformconsultationssuggestwellbeingwillbeacentralplankoftheeducationsystemofthefuture,andgovernmentagenciesareincreasinglyincorporatingwellbeingoutcomesintheirplanning.
TechnologyandthefutureTechnologyisnowanintegralpartofyoungpeople’slives,anditsimpactandconsequencesforsportandphysicalactivityissignificant.Sincethewidespreadadoptionofthesmartphonein2012,youngpeoplehaveunlimitedaccesstoknowledgeandinformation,acommunicationsandsocialnetworkingtool,apersonaltrainer,andawayofcapturing,recordingandcommentingontheirandtheirpeers’lives.
Technologyissignificantlychangingyoungpeople’sexpectations,andthequalityoftheirexperiences.Wearabletechnologyprovidesinstantfeedbackonperformanceandactivity–hapticsensorsinclothingandequipmentarenotonlyacentralpartofthegamingexperience,butarewidelyusedtoenhancetheactiverecreationandsportexperienceaswell.Feedbackondistancetravelled,heartrates,calorieexpenditureandsleeppatternsarewidelyaccessedviaFitbitsandwatches,andthephonehasbecomeatrackingandrecord-keepingtoolthatshowsprogressagainstselforcoach-imposedprogrammesandregimes.
Thedatacollatedthroughthesetoolscanbeusedbyalgorithmsto‘push’productsandmessagestoyoungpeople,andwilleventuallybeusedasawayofpersonalisingandtargetingtherecreationandsportopportunitiesavailabletothem.ArtificialIntelligence(AI)willalsoprocessdatastreamstoenablereal-timeadjustmentstodecisionmakingandgamestrategies–theNBAhasalreadycommencedworkinthisarea.
Theabilitytoenhanceandmodifyaperson’smakeup,byeditinggenesresponsibleformusclemass,bonedensity,oxygendeliveryandpain,forexample,isbecomingmoreaccessibleandwidespreadandwillfundamentallychangethelevelplayingfieldofperformance.Itmayalsorenderthecurrenteffortstodetectandpunishathleteswhouseexternallyappliedperformanceenhancementproducts–includingdoping–redundant.
23
SPORT NEW ZEALAND
Themostcommonlogisticalbarrierstoparticipation–transport,equipmentandtime–willalsobeimpactedbyadvancesintechnology.Self-drivingcarsareinthefinalstagesofdevelopmentandtesting,3Dprintingisnowsoadvancedthatitcanreliablyproducesportandrecreationgearandclothingcustomisedfortheparticipant’sneeds,andvirtualandaugmentedrealityadvances,coupledwithsocialnetworking,meansmanysportandrecreationexperienceswillbeabletobeaccessedfromhomeratherthaninaphysicalspaceorplace.
Thenextgenerationwirelesscoverage(5G)willbeabletorenderimagerythatisalmostindistinguishablefromreality,enablingVRandARactivityenvironmentstobeaccessiblethroughphonesandwearables.Themergingoftechnologyandthedeliveryofsportwillbeasignificanttrendthesectorwillneedtoaccommodateifsportandrecreationaretoremainrelevantinyoungpeople’slives.
DiversityandinclusionNewZealand’sincreasingethnicdiversityrequiresanincreasedrangeofoptionstoensuremigrantcommunities’needs,experiencesandskillsetsarerecognisedandmet.Oftenthereisnooneavailableinschoolsorthecommunitywhohasexperienceorknowledgeoftherelevantcodes(e.g.kabaddi,sepaktakraw,variousmartialarts),andthesportandrecreationsectorisrelativelyslowatrespondingtochangingmarketneeds.
ResearchsuggestsPacificIslandgirlsaretheleastactive(52percentactive)amongdifferentethnicgroupsstudied.Thismaybeexplainedbytheresultsofaqualitativestudyonthevalueofsportin11-14-year-oldswhichreportedthatsomePacificIslandparentswerefoundtobeveryprotectiveoftheirdaughtersandwouldnotallowthemtoassociatewithboysorparticipateinmale-dominatedsports.Additionally,somePacificIslandfemalesbelievedtheywereexpectedtorestricttheirfocusonsportandconcentrateonacademicormusicalactivities.40
Youngpeoplearelookingformeaningfulexperiencestheycanuseasawayofhavingfun,developingsocialandphysicalskills,anddevelopingtheirfitness.GillandOverdorfstatethatapsychosocialfactorinfluencingexerciseparticipationisthemeaningoftheexerciseexperienceforthatperson.41Whenthatexperienceisviewedasmeaningful,apersonwillbemoremotivatedtoparticipateinthatactivity.Inaddition,thepositivephysicalchangesthatcanresultfromincreasedphysicalactivitywillonlyservetoempowerteenagegirls(WrightandDewar,1997).42Thisconceptofmeaningfulnessneedstobeunderstoodinthecontextofdifferentgenders,ethnicities,sexualorientations,agesandevenacrosstime–whatmightbemeaningfultodaymaynotbetomorrow.
BiddleandMurtriestatethat,“experiencingpreviousachievementandhavingabilityatsportsleadkidstocontinue,butitisthelevelofself-efficacy(theconfidenceanindividualhasinbeingabletoperformabehaviour),inparticular,thathasbeenwidelylinkedwithphysicalactivitybehaviourinadults.”43Self-efficacyenablesyoungpeopletoaccessopportunitiesbutreliesonthedevelopmentoftheirconfidenceinearlieryears.
40 Sport NZ (2005): The Value of Sport: attitudes, barriers and motivations for participation in sport by 11 to 14-year-olds41 Gill and Overdorf (1994): Incentives for exercise in younger and older women, Journal of Sport Behaviour42 Wright and Dewar (1997): On Prejudice and Pain: Women Speak Out About Physical Activity43 Biddle and Mutrie (2001): Psychology of Physical Activity: Determinants, well-being and interventions
24
SECONDARY AGE REVIEW
Disabledyoungpeopleareregularlyexcludedfromsportandactiverecreationopportunities,eitherthroughalackofopportunities(particularlysportcompetitions),oralackofsupport.Therearefewrelatabledisabledrolemodels,andschoolsoftendonotplaceahighvalueontheachievementsofdisabledathletesthroughpromotion,opportunitycustomisation,orrecognition.
Similarly,theLGBTQIcommunityregularlyexperiencesexclusionfromactivityonthebasisoftheirgenderidentity–thiscanrangefromlogisticalissuessuchasaccesstochangingfacilitiesandexclusionaryteameligibilitycriteria,toconsciousandunconsciousbiasincoachingandothersupportsystems,andpeerexclusionpractices.Arecentsurveyof17,00013-17-year-oldsintheUSidentifiedthatonly24percentofLGBTQyouthplayaschoolsport,comparedto68percentofnon-LGBTQyouth.Andthenumbersgetworsewhenyoubreakthemdown:only14percentoftransgenderboysandnonbinaryyouth,and12percentoftransgendergirls,participateinschoolsports.44
RiskandadventureAdventureandactionsportsandactivitiesarenowchallengingtraditionalcodesforviewershipandengagement,andunlikemoretraditionalcodes,thenumbersinvolvedaregrowing.Theseactivitiesincludefreestyleversionsofcycling(e.g.MTBandBMX),skate,snowandsurfsports,climbingandskydiving,andmotorsports.Aconsequenceoftheriseinpopularityofadventureandactionsportsistheplethoraofnationalandinternationalevents,typifiedthroughhighlymonetisedandpromotedeventssuchastheX-Games.
Manyoftheseeventsandaction/adventureactivitiesaredrivenbysocialmedia–GoProcamerasalesintheUSwereexpectedtoreach9millionin2018andgrowingatnearly50percentannually.AdventuresportslendthemselveswelltovideoandareoneofthemostpopularcategoriesonYouTube–morethan400hoursofvideoisuploadedeveryminuteworldwideanditisthemostpopularsocialmediaplatforminNewZealand,justaheadofFacebook.
PersonalisationandchoiceYoungpeopleareincreasinglyseekingacustomised,personalisedexperienceinsportandactiverecreation.Theprovisionofopportunitiesneedstoaccommodateworkloadsatschool(increasing),theneedtoremainconnectedto(anddevelopnew)peergroups,after-schoolresponsibilities,andtoprovideapositive,reinforcingexperiencefromtheirinvolvement.Theabilityandtendencytooptinandoutofactivitydependingonthe‘fit’withyoungpeople’sliveshasimplicationsforthecurrentsportdeliverymodel.
Youngpeoplewilldeterminewhattheyneedandwhentheyneedit–theincreasinguseofonlinemediasuchasNetflixandYouTuberatherthanTV,pay-for-playaccesstogymsatanytimeofthedayornight,onlineshopping,accesstocloud-basedcoachingandpersonaltrainingprogrammes,andtheriseofthe‘virtualclub’thatisorganisedbytextorsocialmediaareexamplesofthismovetoindividualismandpersonalisation.
SummarySecondary-agedyoungpeoplearecharacterisedbyadesireforconnectivity,relevanceandchoice.Increasinglyitistechnologythatisprovidingthesethingsratherthanthesportandactiverecreationexperience.Ratherthanadiscretesetofopportunitiesdeliveredbymultiple,unconnectedproviders,thedemandfromyoungpeopleistobeabletoaccessanopportunityatalevel,time,costandlocationthatsuitsthem,irrespectiveoftheprovider.
44 Play to Win: Improving the Lives of LGBTQ Youth in Sports 2018
25
SPORT NEW ZEALAND
26
SECONDARY AGE REVIEW
Howdoweknow?InNewZealand,andglobally,itisrecognisedthatphysicalactivityisreducing,andthereisadeclineintheimportanceplacedon,andpracticeof,qualityPE.SchoolsettingsprioritisesubjectsotherthanPE(intermsofsupportforteachers,teachertraining,andqualityandquantityofdelivery),infavourofafocusonnumeracy,literacyandcoursesthatequipyoungpeopleforcareersorfurthereducation.ThereispoorunderstandingoftherolethatqualityPE,sportandactiverecreationplayinestablishingemployabilityskills,self-management,confidence,andyoungpeople’sdevelopment.
Parentsareoftenfocusedonthewin/loseoutcomesofsport,ratherthanyoungpeople’sdevelopmentthroughsport.Theyareregularlycapturedbyargumentsputforwardbythesportsectortospecialiseearly,eitherovertly,orthroughpracticessuchaslengtheningseasons,punitiveselectionprocesses,and/oryear-roundofferings.Atthesametime,talentedathletesareincreasinglyseentobedevelopingasenseofentitlement,particularlythosewithhighmediaattentionandfinancialrewards.45Andthereareregular,andwidelyreported,incidencesofpoorsidelinebehaviour.
Thereisdisparityinthesportsystemforgirls,particularlyinthehighperformancesystem.Fewerresourcesareallocated,therearefewercareerpathways,lessprofile,andlowerfinancialrewards.Mediacoverageofgirlsandwomen’ssportispoor–fewrolemodelsareportrayeddespitehighlevelsofsuccess.Similarly,thevoiceofwomenandgirlsisnotheardatthegovernancelevelofsport.
Finally,therearemedium-highdensityhousingpressuresalongsidearelativelylowprioritygivenbyCouncilstoplanningforbothoutdoorandindoorsportandrecreationplacesandspaces.Overall,moreyoungpeopleunderstandthevalueofsportandphysicalactivitythanreportpersonalbenefitfromit.46Clearlythevalueascribedtobeingactivesitsbelowotherchoices.
KEY THEMES, RISKS AND APPROACHES
45 Respect & Responsibility Review, NZ Rugby 201746 sportnz.org.nz/assets/Uploads/Angus-Associates-Value-of-Sport-FINAL.pdf
Thevalueofbeingactiveisn’talwaysrecognised,realisedorpromotedbyschools,parentsandcommunityorganisations.
27
SPORT NEW ZEALAND
Whataretheimplications?Unlessyoungpeopleunderstandthevaluethatsportofferstothempersonally,theywillnotprioritisephysicalactivityandsportintheirlivesevenwhenthebarrierstoparticipatingarereduced.
Severalsignificantrisksexistinthepresentenvironment:
� AnylossofPEasacurriculumsubject,oritscontinuedmarginalisationinschools,willbecatastrophicforthesportsystemandforthevaluethatyoungpeopleplaceonbeingactive.ThefoundationskillsandknowledgedevelopedthroughtheHPEcurriculumcannotbereplacedbytheprivatesector.
� Parentswilldriveschoolsandsportstonarrowtheirfocustocaterforconfident,talentedathletes,andtoseesportasacareeropportunityratherthanasaworthypursuitinitsownright.
� Thesportsystemwillincreasinglyfocusonpracticesassociatedwithhighperformanceandprofessionalism,andreducetheirresourcingandsupportforsportforall.
� Continuedpoorsidelinebehaviourwillleadtothelossofparticipants,coachesandofficials.
� Thepositiveimpactofaphysicallyactivelifestyleonteenagers’mentalandphysicalhealthwillbereduced(throughouttheirlives).
� Agrowingsenseofentitlementamongyoungpeopleandexitfromthesportsystemif/whentheirexpectationsarenotmet.
� Anincreasednumberof‘remedial’programmeswillbedesignedtoequipyouthwithskillsforlife,ratherthanmaximisingtheestablishmentofthesethroughsportandphysicalactivity.
� Urbandesigndoesnotenableorprovidesafeopportunitiesforpeopletobeactive.
28
SECONDARY AGE REVIEW
Whatmightwedoaboutit?Firstandforemost,weneedtoprovideeducationaboutyoungpeople’sneeds,developmentalstages,theimportanceofplayandactiverecreationinteenagers’lives,andtherealitiesoftalentdevelopmentandtransfer.Thisshouldbedirectedtoadultswhoprovideopportunitiesandsupportforyoungpeople,particularlyparentsandcoaches.
Oursuggestedapproachesinclude:
� Improvetheprofileandarticulationofthevalueofsportandactiverecreationwithnationalandlocalgovernmentagencies,educationandhealthprovidersandinstitutions,andyoungpeople.
� Establishyouthsportchampionswithappropriatemessagesthathighlightthevalueofsportwiththeirpeers.
� Establishandsupportarolemodellingprogrammeensuringcoverageofgirls,disabledyoungpeople,youngpeoplefromvariousethnicgroupsandotherlowparticipatingcommunities,andparticipantsfromsmallersportsorrecreationactivities.
� Dedicatesecondary-ageexpertiseinsideRSTs,NSOsandotherprovidersthatusesinsightsandthevoiceofparticipanttoadviseonappropriatedesignanddeliveryofopportunitiestosecondary-agedyoungpeople.
� Developandusemarketsegmentationtotargetcustomisedofferings,valuepropositionsandpromotions.
� Supportteacherengagement,confidenceandcompetenceinusingtheconceptsofsportandactiverecreationasateachingandlearningcontext.
� Inputintotheeducationreforms–wellbeinghasbeenidentifiedasthetoppriorityforeducationandtheconsultationunderwayisanopportunitytolinksportandrecreationmorecloselytotheeducationsystemofthefuture.
29
SPORT NEW ZEALAND
Howdoweknow?Youngpeopletellussportandphysicalactivitybecomelessenjoyableastheyprogressthroughtheirteens–theyareamongtheleastsatisfiedwiththeirclubsportexperiences.
Whilethesportsystemgenerallyaccommodatesdisparityinsizeandskilllevelthroughcustomisedcompetitions,theretendstobeaconsistentdeliverymodel(e.g.16-weekcompetitions,selectionandtrials,standardandinflexibleteamsizes,formalisedcoaching)thatdoesnotfitthechanginglifestylesofyouthnoraccommodatetheirchangingmotivationstobeinvolved.Year9competitionstructurestendtomirrorthoseinYear13,buttheaudienceisdifferent.
AfterYear10,participationdecreasesyear-on-yearinbothsportandactiverecreationinthisagegroup.47Youngpeopletellustheywouldplaymoresportiftheycouldtrydifferentcodesbeforetheycommittedtoplaying,couldplayfriendlygameswheretheresultwasnotafocus,andiftheywerebetteratthesportsavailable.Oneofthemostregularlyreporteddisincentivestoparticipationisthecompetitivenatureoftheavailableofferings,particularlyforgirls.
Choiceisincreasinglyimpactedbylengthenedandclashingsportsseasons,andadrivebysportsorganisationstodeliveryear-roundofferings.Thismeansyoungpeopledonothaveabreakbetweenseasons,andincreasinglyarebeingforcedtochooseeitherawinterorsummersport–butnotboth.
Thereisanincreasingprevalenceofoveruseinjuriesinteenagersmorecommonlyseeninolderathletes,includingACLreconstructions,patellartendonitis,shinsplintsandtenniselbow.
Whataretheimplications?Establishingandmaintainingactivelifestylesinyouthisapredictorofparticipationasanadult.48Failuretoaccommodateteenagers’activerecreationandsportneedswillresultinreducedadultparticipationandincreaseassociatedhealthandproductivitydownsides.
Highdeprivationareaswillbeparticularlyimpactedbybarrierssuchastransportandcost.Aslifebecomesmorecomplexandbusy(employment,studypressures,sociallives)thesegroupswouldbenefitsignificantlyfromadoptingahealthyactivelifestyle–conversely,failuretodosocompoundsmanyoftheotherchallengesfacedinthesecommunities,includingmentalandphysicalhealth.
Activerecreationandsportofferingsarenotmeetingtheneedsofallteenagers.
47 YPS 201148 Sports Participation Among Females from Adolescence to Adulthood – A Longitudinal Study, International Review of the Sociology of Sport, Dec 2006. Sport participation by youth as a predictor of physical activity – A longitudinal study, Murphy, Rowe, Woods 2015
30
SECONDARY AGE REVIEW
Severalsignificantrisksexistinthepresentsituation:
� Failuretomeettheneedsofdiversecommunitieswillresultinoverrepresentationofthesegroupsinsedentary/inactive/disengagedyoungpeople–thecurrentlowparticipatinggroupssuchasdisabled,certainethnicities,andsociallydisadvantagedwillcontinuetomissoutonthebenefitsofaphysicallyactivelifestyle.
� Reducedoptionsfortraditional,team,organisedsportsandincreaseinpay-for-play,smallerandself-selectedteams,andsocialmedia-drivenactivityoptionshaveimplicationsforthecurrentsportssystem.Inparticular,thevolunteerinfrastructurethatisdriventhroughthetraditionalsportsystem,andtheconnectednessandcontributionthatthesportsystemoffers,couldbelost.
� Astherelevanceofexistingsportstructuresandsystemstoteensdecreases,theresultingreducedmembershipwillreducethetraditionalsportssystem’srevenueandcapacity.
� A‘lostgeneration’nolongerfamiliarwithandengagedinacultureofactivelifestyleshassignificantconsequences.Ourpatternsofbehaviour,attitudesandvaluesaretransferredtoourchildren–itishighlyunlikelythatwewillbeabletorecreatethiscultureonceitislost.
Whatmightwedoaboutit?Asthemajorityofsecondary-agedyoungpeopleparticipateinsportandphysicalactivityatschool,itstartswiththeschoolcontext.Werecommendreviewingthecompetitivesportstructureandofferingsavailabletosecondary-agedpeopleandcustomisefortheirneeds–particularlytheneedsofthosecurrentlydisengagedorinactive.Inparticular,distinguishbetweenYear9-10,andYear11-13cohortsandpresentawiderrangeofoffersintheolderagegroup.
Somefurthersuggestedapproachesinclude:
� Make‘choice’afundamentalprinciple;enforceseasonality,discourageearlyspecialisationandyear-roundofferingstoyoungpeople,andincentivisevarietyinofferingstoyoungpeople.
� Establishclearprinciplesandpracticesacrossthesectoraboutrepresentativeteams,ensuringchoiceanddevelopmentforallarekeyunderpinningprinciples.
� Sportsandschoolsshouldreviewtheirselectionprocessestobetterunderstandthepathwaysandopportunitiesavailableforthosewhoare‘deselected’.Opportunitiesforself-selectedteamsshouldbewidelyavailableandaccommodated.
� Maximisetimeontaskbycustomisingtraditionalsportformats.SomeNSOsarealreadyresearchingtheeffectsofdifferentcompetitionformats,forexample,onnumberoftouchesorgoalshootingopportunities.
� Thesportsystemshouldadoptmoreagileapproachestosportdesignanddeliveryandbepreparedtoregularlychangetheirofferingsasyoungpeople’smotivationsandpersonalcircumstanceschange.
� Establishandmakeavailableamenuofoptionsthatmeetyoungpeople’sconfidenceandcompetencelevels,ratherthantechnicalandtacticalsportskillsandknowledge.Theseoptionsshouldrangefromplay,tohealthandfitnessactivities,tooutdoorrecreation,tosportskilldevelopmentopportunities–andshouldaccommodateyoungpeople’ssocialneeds.
� Specificinitiativesandsupportstructuresshouldbedevelopedforthosewiththemostsignificantbarrierstoparticipation–particularlydisabledyoungpeopleorthosefromhighdeprivationcommunities.
31
SPORT NEW ZEALAND
49 sportnz.org.nz/assets/Uploads/attachments/Sport-New-Zealand-Play-Principles-Nov-2017.pdf
� ApplySportNZ’sPlayPrinciples49tothesecondarysetting,andworktoprovideplayasalegitimateactivityoptionforteenagers.
� Clarify,negotiateandagreerolesandresponsibilitiesbetweencommunityproviders,clubsandschoolsinprovidingandsupportingactiverecreationandsportatalocallevel.Ensuretherearenopenaltiesforthepathwaychoicesmadebyyoungpeople.
� Proactivelyusetechnologytoenhanceyoungpeople’sactiverecreationandsportexperience.Considerestablishinglinkswithe-gamingorganisationsandindustrywithaviewtogainingabetterunderstandingoftheopportunitiespresentedbyincorporatingvirtualandaugmentedrealityintothesportandrecreationoffering.
� Bettercommunicateopportunitiestoyoungpeople,throughappsandsocialmedia.Smartphonesshouldbetheprimarysourceofinformation,enrolmentorregistrationforopportunities.Sectororganisationsshouldpushmessagestothemthroughthesechannels,ratherthanexpectingthemtofindthemamongtheplethoraofplatformsandsitesavailabletothem.
� Usesegmentationtocustomisethesportandrecreationopportunitiesandsupportofferedtoyoungpeople.Ensurethesportandrecreationofferingisinformed,designedanddeliveredbygroupswhoincorporatemeaningfulparticipationforyoungpeople–empowerandresourceyoungpeopletoimplementactivitiesforthemselves,theirpeersandcommunities.
� Incorporate(andvalue)eventsintotheschoolsetting,ratherthanlonger-termsportcompetitionleagues.Initiatepop-upeventsdeliveredbystudents.
� Makegender-exclusivehealthandfitnessopportunitiesavailableinschoolstoaddresscostandjudgementbarriers.
� Bemoreovertaboutourroleandfocusonphysicalactivity,includingactivetransport,astheseopportunitiesbettermeettheneedsofyoungpeopleinthesecondaryyearsandmaintainaleveloffitnessandconfidencethatwillequipthemtore-enterthesportsystemwhentheyareable.
32
SECONDARY AGE REVIEW
Howdoweknow?Thereisnocommon,agreedunderstandingoftheoutcomesweareseekingforyoungpeopleinNewZealandacrossagencies–governmentorcommunity.Noristhereacommonapproachtoplacingyoungpeopleatthecentreofourdecision-making,ortheroletheyshouldplayindesigninganddeliveringthesportandrecreationexperienceforthemselvesandtheirpeers.
Similarly,thereisnocommonunderstandingofteenagers’lives–theirneedsanddesires–andnocommonplantoensuretheseneedsanddesiresaremet.
Theincreasingrelevanceandintegrationoftechnologyandsocialmediainteenagers’livesisoftennotappreciatedbypreviousgenerationswhoarelargelyresponsiblefortheprovision(anddesign)ofopportunitiesforthisagegroup.Insomecases,theyareactivelyopposingitsadoptionratherthanworkingtounderstandhowitcanbeusedtoenhancethequalityoftheexperienceforyoungpeople.
Althoughsomeschools,clubsandregionsreachagreementsonscheduling(e.g.weekdayvsweekendcompetitions)andselection,thereisstillcompetitioninmanyregionsbetweenschoolsandclubsforplayers,timeandfacilities.Relativelyfewformalisedschool-clubagreementsareinplace,eventhoughschool-clublinkshavebeenidentifiedasasolutiontoreducedparticipationsincethe1980s.
Disadvantagedgroups–suchasthosewhoaredisabled,indeprivedcommunitiesorgeographicallyisolated–reportdifficultyinunderstandinghoworganisationsintheircommunityworktogethertoprovideanexperienceforthem.The‘entryandre-entrypoints’toanactiverecreationorsportopportunityarenotclearandconsistent.OurDisabilitySportandActiveRecreationReviewhasidentifiedunclearrolesandresponsibilities,andconfusedpathwaysfordisabledyoungpeople.50
Thetimeframesforteamselectionandcompetitiondeliveryinschoolsareoftendrivenbyanationalorregionalqualificationmodelthatdoesnotalwaysmeettheworkload,familiarisationandsocialisingneedsofsecondary-agedyoungpeople,particularlyinYear9.Earlyselectionprocessesandpre-seasongamesforwinterteams,andexistingYear8clubcommitmentsforsummercodesareparticularlyproblematic.
Thereislittletransferofsportandactivityinformation(includingleadershipdevelopment)tosecondaryschoolsfromfeederintermediateschools.Increasinglyacademiesandtalentdevelopmentprogrammesarebeingestablishedinschoolswithlittlereferenceto,orintegrationwith,thesportsinvolved.
TheconsultationsthatinformedourTalentPlanandSportDevelopmentApproachidentifiedsignificantissueswithpoorplayermanagementandwelfarearisingfrompoorschool-clubrelationships.51Overuseinjuriesandheavyworkloads,particularlyfortalentedathletes,areprevalent.
Overall,theValueofSporttogovernmentagendas(particularlyeducationandhealth)isnotwellunderstoodoractivated.52Governmentdriversandaccountabilitiesaretypicallyshortterm,notwelljoinedupandofteninconsistent.
Organisationsaren’tworkingeffectivelytogethertoprovidequalityexperiencesforyoungpeople.
50 sportnz.org.nz/about-us/who-we-are/what-were-working-towards/disability-sport-and-recreation-review/ 51 sportnz.org.nz/about-us/our-publications/our-plans-and-programmes/talent-plan/ 52 sportnz.org.nz/news-and-events/media-releases-and-updates/articles/value-of-sport
33
SPORT NEW ZEALAND
Whataretheimplications?Severalsignificantrisksexist:
� Disjointed,inconsistentandduplicatedprovisionofsportandrecreationopportunitiesforyoungpeople.
� LeadershipdevelopmentinprimaryandintermediateschoolisnotrecognisedatYear9–weare‘missing’asignificantcohortofpotentialcoaches,managers,officialsandeventorganisersinthesecondaryenvironmentbyonlyrecognisingleadersinthesenioryears.
� Newentrantstosecondaryschoolsarebeingaskedtotrialforsportsteamsbeforetheyhavedevelopedthesocialandothernetworksthatwillsupporttheirexperience.Studentslackingconfidence,inparticular,willoptoutoftrialsandmayfinditdifficulttore-enterthesportsystem.
� Alackofunderstandingacrossgovernmentoftherolethatsportandactiverecreationmightplayintheiroutcomesandaccountabilities,andSportNZ’srole.
� Competitionforplayers,officialsandcoachesbetweenschoolsandcommunityorganisations.
� Entryandre-entrytosportandactivitybecomestoohard,andyoungpeopleoptout.
Whatmightwedoaboutit?Aswearealldealingwiththesameissues,wecanstartwithestablishingbestpracticeinitiatives,insightsandknowledgeavailableandsharedonaplatform.Sportagencies,suchasRSTsandNSOs,shouldincorporate(oraccess)expertiseandfocusonsecondary-agedyoungpeople,withthemandatetodevelopcross-organisationunderstandingandactiontoaccommodateyoungpeople’sneeds.
Somesuggestedapproachesinclude:
� Puttheprinciplesofyouthdevelopmentandmeaningfulengagementandempowermentfrontandcentreintheapproachofanydeliveryagencythatcatersforthisagegroup.
� Align,collaborateandensurequalityexperiencesinfacilitysharinganddevelopment.� Improvenationalandregionalleadership–incentivisecollaborationthroughaligned
outcomesandinvestment.� Betterclarifyandpossiblyredefinetherolesofsomesportsectoragencies,and
othersthatprovideactiverecreationopportunitiesforteenagers.OrganisationssuchasHalbergFoundation,SpecialOlympicsNewZealand,NZSSSC,PhysicalEducationNewZealandandregionalMinistryofEducationofficeshaveanadvisoryroletoplaywithNSOs(andtheiraffiliates)andRSTs.
� Long-term,cross-partyandcross-agencygovernmentcommitmenttotheplaceofsportandphysicalactivityinyoungpeople’slives.
� Clearlyidentifycommunityassets,programmesandpeople,aswellaslocalisedplansestablishedwithmandates,definedroles,responsibilitiesandaccountabilities.
� Localauthoritiesestablishcommunityalliancesinvolvingacross-sectionofthesportandrecreationprovidernetworkthatareresponsibleforparticipant-centricdesignapproachesforsport,recreation,urbandesign,transport,education,etc.
34
SECONDARY AGE REVIEW
Howdoweknow?Selectionprocessesareexclusionaryandarehappeningatyoungerandyoungerages.Inthesecondaryschoolenvironment,competitionandwinningareoftenastrongerfocusthandevelopment.Competition,coaching,resourcesanddevelopmentopportunitiesareconcentratedinfewerandfewerplayersassportsseektominetalent.Secondaryschoolsportisincreasinglynotprovidingasport-for-allenvironment.
Despitepracticesandpoliciestodissuadeit,schoolsarestillincentivisingyoungpeopletotransferschoolsonthebasisoftheirsportingability,inordertoenhanceaschool’sprospectsofwinningcompetitionsandtrophies.Thisisdrivenpartlybyaneedtoincreaseschoolrollsandthereforefunding–schoolsuccessandtheestablishmentofspecialisedacademiesisoftenmoreaboutprovidingacompetitiveedgethangenuineconcernsforplayerwelfareandeducationalbenefits.
Fairnessisasignificantenablerofthesportexperienceforyoungpeople.
Therewardsinsport–financial,publicprofile,positionsofresponsibility–arenowdrivingincreasinglysophisticatedwaysofenhancingperformance.Theuseoftechnologyinparticularpresentsarisktothelevelplayingfieldthatplayersexpect.
Evidenceofsupplementuseinsecondary-agedyoungpeopleisbeingdrivenbydesire/pressuretoenteraprofessionalsportpathwayandtoreceivetherewardsthatcomewithit.Thereappearstoberelativelylittleattentionpaidtotheunevenplayingfieldthiscreates,orthehealthrisksthatgowithit.
Playeragentsaresigningyoungathletestocontractsatatimewhentheyshouldbefocusingontheireducation–despiteguidelines,NewZealandandoverseasagentsarenowactiveonthesidelinesofintermediatecompetitionssuchastheAIMSGames.
Unsafeandunethicalpracticesareinadvertentlyincentivisedinthehighperformancesystem–resultsaretiedtofunding,andthedrivetoretainthisrevenuecanleadtoalackofdeclarationandactionaboutanythingthatmayjeopardisethissupport.
Beyondthesportsystem,theincreasingdiversityofNewZealand’spopulationmeansamoresignificantproportionhavenotgrownupwithaheritageofactivelifestyles.ThecultureofsportandphysicalactivityinNewZealandischanging.
Socialmedia,andmediaingeneral,isportrayingmessagesthatareatoddswithreality:mostyoungpeopledonothavethebodyshapeandsize,speedandaccuracy,andsocialskillsthatareidealisedinsportandactivitythroughthemedia.Thisleadstodisaffectionwiththerealityoftheirexperience,orthepursuitoftheideal–weightlossandbodyimageissues,performanceenhancementoptions,anxiety,embarrassmentandmentalhealthissuesareconsequencesofthewidespreadportrayalofthese‘ideals’.
Thecultureandethosofouractivelifestylesisunderthreat.
35
SPORT NEW ZEALAND
Whataretheimplications?Severalsignificantrisksexistundercurrentcircumstances:
� Youngpeopleareseenasamarkettotap,aspotentialhighperformanceathletes,andasrevenuestreams.
� Theincreasingdevelopmentofgeneticmodificationtechniques,bionicadvancements,andfeedbackmechanismsdirecttotheathletewillmeanperformanceenhancementwillbecomealmostimpossibletodetectand/orprove.Itispossiblethattheresourcescurrentlydirectedatdrugcheatswillbemisplacedasthecostsofmaintainingalevelplayingfieldwillbetoohigh.
� Increasingprevalenceofeatingdisordersandmentalhealthissues,particularlyforgirls.
� Continuedlossofresilienceandsoftskillsthataredevelopedthroughsport.� Dropout–theacademy/talentdevelopmentsystemraisesexpectationsthatcannot
befulfilledgiventhelimitednumberofhighperformanceopportunitiesinNewZealand.SeriousmentalhealthissuesarebeingreportedintheUKfootballsystemasyoungpeoplearerecruitedearlytocamps,andprogressivelyexcludedthroughde-selectionatvariouspointsofthetalentdevelopmentpathway.
Whatmightwedoaboutit?Weknowthatfairnessisimportanttothesportexperience,andwemustproactivelyhighlightthedownsidesofperformanceenhancement,particularlytoyoungpeopleandparentsaskeyinfluencers.
Somesuggestedapproachesinclude:
� Watchingbriefoninternationaltrendsanddevelopresponsesasappropriate.� Exploretheimplicationsofcompetitionformatsthatlegitimiseperformance
enhancedathletes,whilemaintainingnon-enhancedcompetitions–re-establishalevelplayingfieldthatrecognisestherealityofthefuture.
� Promotesafesportpracticesandmonitortheirapplicationandimplementation.� ImplementthefindingsofourSportIntegrityReview.53
� Promotethebenefitsofactivelifestyleswidely–establishrolemodellingprogrammes,andprovideinformationtoparentsandotherkeyinfluencersaboutyoungpeople’sexperiencese.g.throughsocialmediacampaigns.
� Understandandmeetthesportandrecreationneedsoflowerparticipatinggroups,particularlynewmigrants,certainethnicgroupsanddisabledyoungpeople.
� Workwithplayers’associationstoensureappropriatemessagingandinformationisprovidedtoplayers,andagreewithagentsonappropriaterecruitmentpractices.
53 sportnz.org.nz/managing-sport/search-for-a-resource/research/have-your-say-sport-integrity-review
Giventheincreasinglydiversepopulationinthisagerange,andtheneedforyoungpeopletoreceivemeaningful,personalisedexperiencesthattheyvalue,solutionstothesechallengesneedtobehighlycustomised,local,andinformedanddesigned(andinsomecasesdelivered)byyoungpeople.
Developingthesesolutionsmustthereforebeaniterativeprocessimplementedinthecommunity,ratherthannationally.Whilethispaperhasmadesomehighlevelrecommendationsaboutpotentialsolutions,theimplementationwillbecustomisedandtargetedthroughfurtherconsultationandempowerment.
Establishingsolutionstothesefourchallengesneedstoincorporatethefollowingprinciples:
�� Solutions�must�be�local–anynationalapproachesshouldbetheresultofcommonalitiesoreconomiesarisingfromlocalsolutions.
�� A�youth�development�and�empowerment�approachshouldbeadopted.�� Flexible�and�agile�design�and�delivery�modelsshouldbeused.�� Choice�and�inclusionareparamount-multipleoptions,pathwaysandsteppingstones
areneeded.� Agreedandclear�roles�and�responsibilities,promotedandmandated.�� Technology�should�be�embracedwhereitenhancesthequalityoftheexperience.
SportNZwillexploresolutionstothefourchallengesidentifiedby:
a. collatingexistinggoodpracticeandsharingthiswithschoolsandthecommunity
b. resourcingaseriesofdesign-ledinitiativesusingyoungpeopletodevelopand testsolutions
c. socialisingthefindingsofthisreview,andanyresultingsolutions,withall organisationsprovidingsportandphysicalactivityopportunitiesfor secondary-agedyoungpeople
d. usingtheresultsofexistingandnewprototypestoinformourfuturestrategiesfor thesportsector,inparticulartoclarifyorganisationalrolesandresponsibilities.
ACTIVATING THIS REVIEW
36
SECONDARY AGE REVIEW
Theteenagelifestageisoneofthemostat-riskforestablishingandmaintainingongoinghabitsandalife-longloveofparticipatinginsportandphysicalactivity.Thecostsofdecliningparticipationandenjoymentofbeingactivearehigh–toindividuals,educationinstitutions,wha-nau/families,andsociety.
Solutionstoaddressthedeclineinparticipationthroughtheteenageyearsarecomplex.Ifwearetocontinuetomeetthesportandphysicalactivityneedsofsecondary-agedyoungpeopleoverthenext10years,whichimportantlyincludesensuringtheirexperiencesarehighquality,wellsupportedandaccessible,weneedtoaddressthefourthemesdevelopedthroughthisreview:
� Thevalueofbeingactiveisn’talwaysrecognised,realisedorpromotedbyparents,schoolsandcommunityorganisations
� Activerecreationandsportofferingsarenotmeetingtheneedsofallteenagers� Organisationsarenotworkingeffectivelytogethertoprovidequalityexperiencesfor
youngpeople� Thecultureandethosofouractivelifestylesisunderthreat.
Thisreviewconsiderstheevidencethathasledtothesefindings,observessometrendsthatmayworkagainstareversalofthecurrentparticipationdeclinesinthe13-18-yearagegroup,andproposesthatsolutionstothesechallengesmustcomefromyoungpeoplethemselves.
SUMMARY
SPORT NEW ZEALAND
37
Level 1, Harbour City Centre 29 Brandon Street Wellington 6011, New Zealand PO Box 2251 Wellington 6140 Phone: +64 4 472 8058 SPORTNZ.ORG.NZ
SPNZ00016ISBN 978-0-947502-89-8
WANT TO FIND OUT MORE?Forfurtherinformationpleasecontact:
RogerWoodYoungPeopleConsultant–SecondarySportNewZealandPhone:[email protected]