Page 1
Sep 18 2815 11:31:38 288-388-1388
Michno! C. Creamer. ISB # 4030 Mi~bacl P .. Ll\wrcneet ISll"# 7.288 GIVENS PURSLEY LLP' 601. W, J34'tmOOJt. St. J>;O. ijox 2720 Bo!!c. Idaho 83701-2720 Telephone: ZQS" .. 388-1200 Fait: 2C>a·388-1300
Atlori1tys fo,· Cilj of :fltlilay
Scott L Campbell, JSB # 22-S:l Mfttthcw J. MoOoc; ISB # 7979 MOf1flA1T• THOMAS;BARRbTf.ROCK& F,m.os, Ctt1'RTn1um · • 161 s.t:apitot.Bl"d,, lQlh .F~t>1· P~t.Of{ioo ~~ 829 Boiso,.l<l'1\o 83701 Teleph<>ite: '(208).343 .. .2000 F'wt: (208).'l~-s3·34
A.IIQrne~/or Stm '1!41/<1)' Cl'IHl{>(lltJ~
Susan B. Buitton, ISB.# 404i
->
Cliero&e ·o. McL:o,n~ .. lSB # 191 J ~ -·S~R BUXTQ~.& TURC~E!
9,0 w. Banri()(;k st) s,c; •. .s20 BQUe;.tdaho· S3?02 · Telephone: (208)·33 t. rsoo Pax:-.(aQ8)J3t .. l202
A.ttm-n~ fi,,,1'tt1 Cltlu. of Kct.ql,~n,. muf Fajf:field . . . . . . ..
28873&2121 Giuens Pt1rsely LLP Page 882
Candice M. Mc.liu!PI. IS.l3 .# $998 Chris.M.-Bf:<>tnlo-y, JSB ti 6S~O. MtHUOH BROMLE?,; PLLC 38() $. 4d, St., Ste. J'03· Boise, 'Idaho ·g3702 Telephone: 20R-2R74>99 l Pt1l(; 208-287-0864
JOSl!VH P. jJ\MS'$, JSB' #· S BROWN. & JAMBS 130 Fourth Aveuue We.lit Ooodin~ Jdaoo 83)30 Ti!tepmme:. '208-934-8 l SS Filxr 208·93'4--410J ·
District Co
At«1r1tv;-;J;}<ir Big & Lifi/4 .WO<>d Wniar Us<!/"$ A~o<:(utltm
LAW.REN'CI.G. WA$D1tN A'li'ORNBY OBNERAL
CLIVE J. STRONO ocpury A'tfomoy aonerai ciuer, Natural ~ -Divfaton.
QA'IUUC-K L. BAXTlt~ ISB #6301 EMMI L. BLADES, ISB #868'2 Dq>uty Attomoys.Ooneml. Idaho ~roncnt <Sf Water R8$0ut'c:c, P.O. Uox .83?20 Boise. Jdaho .83720..0098 Teleph6M:· (208)··237.:4800 ~m·ilc! (:zt>~) :287.'6700 [email protected] ,a<>v [email protected] ,gov
A ltornd)ltl for aa,,, Spadunan and the ./dcifto D"J>al't1trtmt-of W~tar R,sourt11..t ·
JN -THE DISTRICT COURT ,OF THE FOURTH .JUDICJA:l~ DISTRICT OF THE
STATE()F IOAHO,JN·AND FOR 11IE.COUNTY OF ADA
CITY OF HAILEY, ail ·Idaho municipal cotpOration. lffd CJTY OF BBT,.L.EVUe; an tdabo municipal corporation,
Page 2
Sep 18 2815 11:31:43 288-388-1388 ->
OAAY SPACKMAN in b1s ·offloiftl cnpa\.ily,A11 the Dlreotoroflhe·IOAHO DBPARTMBN'J\ OF-WATER .RBSOL!RCBS; and the JDAHO DEPARTMEN'.f OP·'!{ ATER RESO~RGBS,
Respond~.
S'UN VALLEY COMPANY, u Wyoming ~t'Dtlon,
v~.
OARY SPAC~MAN in hit offici61 C'apftCity ·a'S' the Plroctot-0f .ffic ldaho .Oapormuu1t .()f W11111 Rcaourc.oa. t1nd.thc JDAflb DI!PAR.TMENT OF' WATlUt MSOURCBS,
IN THI:! MATTER O.P DJS'JJUBUTION OF WA1'BR TO WAtBR .RJOHTS HIU.D &V Mf!MBB'RS OF·ms BIO WOOD. tin'Ln· WOOD WATEfUJSERS A$$0C1ATION ~lVER.TlNO PROM.t.He B(O:wooo AND LIITLB WOOD RJVB'RS .
21117362121 Giuens Pursely W Page 883
CORREC.'TED STJPLUATlON
CORR.J:CTED STiPLUATION . ,· ..
The Ci\)' Qf Hailer .(''HRlloy")i thc.~lt)I ofl3eltevue ("Bell<;Vue");- Sun Vall&y,Company
(11SVC"); the Bia it Llttle Wood Watet• Users Assocfatlon ('WUN'): tho City. c,f'Kotehum
("Ketchum1 ; th.c Clt)' .of .,f alrfleld {"Fairfleld'', and .•ho Idaho I?cPartment o(Water RCS<?utees
t"DC~rtmtnl'.'),and Gary Spaclcman, Di~ol'·~r .~ DcpfQ'tmont;by·ll'n<i lhrough.1~r ftJSl)Cetive·
attomcyS.-<~f' rcco.rd, h'creby·.cntcr into -this S1,pulatiu11 :fo·tl~ a'biwixaptti>ned ma1~~ ..
STIPUt..\T~ON·;
Page 3
Sep 18 2815 11:31:54 288-388-1388 -) 28873&2121 Giuens PllrSelY LLP Page 11K
BACKGROUND
1. The WUA, through their counsel~ submiUcd .written requests to the Oep11rtmeol
that the Waterrnaster of Water DistJ'icts 37-and 37B udmtnisu,r junior ground watenights that .. . .
the WUA oUeges·-arc causing,malerlal injury·ltHhe' surfaco wat~·t13ht:s ·ofthe WUA 'i..rnem.~
2. The Departmont·dcemed lbe WUA 'li're<(uestitij.1:Je delivery ~JU as d~fmod in the,
r~rtmenl'• Conjunctivo.M1nagcmcot Rutcs,.JDJ\PA 37.03 •. 1 J (11CM.Rutes'1), ftnd initiiltcd
contClited .Cll.116 pruct!t'<fhlQS for.ti1e Blg Wood 'Oclivorr CAii (Ot'l<:kUt Nn. CM-{?C'·20J~~J} ll9.d
ttw LittlQ Wood Delivery.Call {~~et No. CM·DC·201S..{J()2) (MDtli~cfJ Olll111·ulld,r Cfvi . . . . .. . . . .
Rul•r40.
J , Jfi a:totterdou.-dMal'en .:zo,:20J·S, tho Ocpartn1efit.l\01mcid holdm t)f certaUi
around water.t.ighta.w·ilhi.n . .Wittar D'h1irictil 1'7 ·Hnd 37l3 of lhc filins of the. Wl.JA 's requ~ts for
adininistration. Tho Department also publi8't11xl notice ofihc Dcliv~ Coll~ in the f®hd
Mountain E~press '1nd Camas Comicron March 2s1h,.2015 a AptiJ 111\ 201 s~·and tltifTimos . . . ' , ..
News on March 2611r, '20 l·S & April 2M,.20l S.
a. Hailey, Bellevue1 l<.etchum, Faiffield 11'hd SVC, among others, .flied noticc&.of
intont·to partici'pate in 1h0 Delivery. Calli,
5. On Juno 2~ •. 2015, SVC .filed its M()tion !o D/!mi.ft "1n~led C~e J>roct1atl/n~
('\'iU!f r,'!l{~Y~ M<?~'1~~tgulng. nmong_othcr things, lhe-WUA fa~lod to m~.pelitionsfor
dclWfQ' ~alls cffmp1i61Yt Witlf th'o r«i\iir«ntoo.ts or Idabo:Co'dc'f iiZ-2l 7b;.the Octpartmcnt~i . Jtu le:.,
of'P-roceduro. anti ·fht CM Rules;
6. On June 26; 2015, lulloY. an<fBolhwue ,f'iled their JolnJ Motion ,o Dulgnote . . . . , .
ACG_.WS by RJtl~rn.ak~tg and ~o Di~·m.ts,, ~llw1y·Call1 C'Clltl't' MnU01f'?·1tl'ti\iii\i that ~be
I)epaJ:tfttmt ~Y t~t-administer arouhd ·waterrighll m wa·,m= ·oiattic-..·.31 a-nd.j7B in .~~.t'O
a do1ivefy-cafl ilil.det'CM·Role40 m,lesa-and ,mti1 the,D6partmc111s through 1'Ulema~ing,
Sl'JPVl.,ATJON· 3
Page 4
Sep 18 2815 11:32:86 2111-388-1388 -> 2807362121 Giuens Pursely LLP Page 885
C$lablishes an a1'C3 of c01.nmon gl'Q,_md w.atcr 1>ur,ply ("AC:OWS") thm c:t1c.ompai.~s the WUA 's
men;bctst ·wntcr riah~ Rl'l<l palC'nti8lty iriiplicafod Ju1rior :gfound water righl.J!:
7. On July 22r 20 t 5 the Department issued .ib Ordel· Denying Sun V e,/ley CIJmpart)l '.s
Mallon !o-f)Lvff!ls,v tS,m Valley ~rder'') denying~'w1 Yl"ley:9 Moli<11T, and it".Order J.)enylng
Jnh:ft Motion liJ' Designate A.C<J'Tf.S·by Rulc11wki1Jlf pftiJ lo Dlsmlas 1)elJw,ry Cilfl!I ( 11if CGWS ·
01'dcr,..., d~YintJ· 1he l'illi, .. Morion. Netnm' the· ..S:wt :Vrilie.y .Qt'd_et nor U\~ . .AC'<l.WS Ortle!'
contallt«l l1U1~uoaeor waa .OClCOtn.,anfod b~ a.do.c\lment co.11titinins ln,,g\Ulpindfoodng.tboy
were .recommended ordo~ pro!Jmin~ ordon or tlnnl orders. Thus. under the Dcpartmt.-nt1t
Rulc·of ~ure·7l0, the.-SJtn ¥al/eJ! Order and ACGWS Order are. fut¢oeutoty orders. . . ,; . .. . , .
8.. Ort Aug~t ~ and .111.io1 s. ttlSJ)CCtivol)\ svc timely .filed je& M<;twn]or Rw~W:of
fnlttrfriciitor}l'Ordar andJi'.ailoy'Md 8ellev'it&.ii{nC:11 fil«J 'tbc'ir Joilll Motin'lf/of R<r'rileW of
/11terlocutory Order in the DeUvery Calla (together thcl'Rtllir !J./1 Mallon.,'') seekin1 review of . .
the Sun Valley Order ond·thc ACGWS Order under.tho Ocpattmcnt.'s Rule of.J>toceduro ?rt,
IDAPA-37.'()J.01.11 J.. As<>f this date. the Director has iaken no action to rescind, aJtcr onn\'end . ; , .
the Suit YtttleY Order or the ACG WS ()rder in -responso .. to .IJte Rule '!11 Motion.,;
'i.. On Auaust 18, 201S,Hculey and Bellovue filed their Petlllo11forJudiclal'h.vkw
<>/ Agency Actlon ("CfJit,f ' l'~tltlnn~") in Ada County l)lstrlct Court, Case No. CV-OC-1514419, . . .
seek~ng.Judiof al review or.~ A cc;;ws Ordr.r PU1'\1AttUQ :fdaho C.9do H· ~ 1 ~sm 1100 6 7 ·~·211 (~ . . ,, . . . . . . . . . . .
a8en.cy iratloi\ ott -~ -around, ·tnilt ~view of ftn'Al qooos, Aetiiii1 will not.pmvl.cte them· with an udequate remedy.
1 O. On August .l?, io lSi -SVC f!Jecf lts Potltt<>n for ,lftdlt:lal R.C1Ylew ,SJ'C Perltton")
in Adil County_·Di-rriot. Court~ Case· No: C,V-'OC-l-S l 4S~, .. scilkina·judicic'1 rc,,ieW ~f11to.Su~
Valley O,rderpisrs\Ulnt to Iclsoo~Code·§§ -67.5270· ittrd:67-'S'271{2)· 1md ·Rt•l<':'81' ofth'o lcUllio Rillcs
Page 5
Sep 18 2815 11:32:28 288-3111-1388 -> 2807362121 Gi uens Purse ly W Page 886
o( Civil Procedure, ~ecking judici~l review of an int.errnedinte tlg~ncy action on lhe gmundi, that
rtVi&H of':fmal flgcncyact1on·wilJ :not r,rovide.tbem with·an adequate remedy,
H. The Cilfus ' Petlli<m nnd ttie SYC.Petltlon (logcther the "Petltlm1:l') hlwe been
toa118i~ from tho Fourth.District to·th'G Snake Riv.er Ba~in Adjudlcutfon Dilrtrkt Coti.rt of the . . . .
Fifth .ludioial _Disttici. TI10-CJ1Je., t Polition waft ronumbon'ld by the ~t't .. &o.11\ CV-QC-! S,14419
to·C.V-W~·19lS.·144t9. Tho.SPC Pell/l~WliS·ronum~eroo by tho:euurt rtou1,CV-OC-1$t4SOO
ro cv .. w~-~r!-14·500 •.
1·2'. 11,e t')opartm.onC-61~putos that-tlto.ACG~·O,dar•nd UioStm Patl~Orc/qr·may
be 1-eviowed by the OitUrict C.ourt: .at.tll!A tfnlC,
t 3; ~n -of t:hv:panl~ tcHhi11:Stlpula1.frµt agree thlttexpedited jtt~icial -rcview-of:llic
i11(1esriliiii:xt by tl'icfCili"s 'Mri!Jd;tat'id ,~rm Yalli1)~'s MriJld,rt'oti t1~·terl\'Js·~ forih below ja·in.tbo
int~m or edm·it,islmtive•And judicinl eeonQmy.
STJP'UliA'tJON
14. Destgnation of thqACGWS.Ordar·pnd thc.S,m -Vq//l!J> Order as final Ordera,.
~t Q(f~U9QL and Augmentation of Rc<;ords ou Appenl. The.partiCJS to this
SHpt'ilt'iliofl agree &a take the tollowing actions with respect to the A CGWS OrtleY' and the $u11
'I/alley Orda.r, lho Pcttltl,m.v1 and the, rooords on npJ)601:
o. lietiloy. Bellevue~ K\!ltchum, fairtield ~ SVC will ~IC:~ motio~ ~~ting th~
D~tor ~aignlite _the·~ CGW$ Onl,r ~ril;f .t~e· $mr Ya.lldJI Dl.'tf ilt' 111 finl\l .Qrdots
purw·a·nt ttr Oto-~mcnt·\i R~l6f(Qf.Pfoel'(fure'?10·ant1·?50 ·w1t1t.~cl: to
isaue9 i,i'C$ented by the Chit~' Ml>lion .a,td Srm Vnlley ',~·· Mol1nn (1'Motion to
Oesiamrte"}, If~ objootto;1 is fficd to 9to_ Mott~ to DQ.,ipu,,.lho Din,c.tor wJII
isaue-scpara10 onk,rs.tloeiw,ati~g.U\c ACGWS Omtifnd tho·Sitn ·YallctjOrdcf ia . . . . ..
Prooedm~ 740. ~·Designallon Orders~). If iln objection is timely fifed to the
s:rlPL/LATION• $
Page 6
Sep 18 2815 11 : 32: 33 288-318-1388 -> 2887362121 Givens Pursely LLP Page 887
Motiou to Des.ignato, 1he Oi1wtor will consid~r 1he objection nnd n1lc on the
merits ofU1e motion and objection 11ccordingly.
b. Hailoy, Bel1evt1o1 Ketchum. Fnfrfield. SVC, and the WU~ agree nol to seek
J-CCO:O~iderntion·~f.,ur filc·ex~ptmn~ .to, the Designation ()rdcrs.
c. P..romptlyfollow1ng ex~1raikm af tbeUmo ellow~d for other porffe& to tho
Delivery cans who tU'e not p.llrtfouo this Stipulation .to Jtook fOOOI\Sidenrtion. file
exceptions or «:q\lest 8 .hearios on tho Designation Ordcm1, usaumin,g.no pa.l'tlcs • •• •• # # . • • • • • •
he.ve ~<lnc,IIO-t H"iloy .a1~d llellevui: .sn~ SVC wiiJ take 8Pl)rop-ri'i(te MeJSa' lo/i.m'~Td . . . . . . . . thclrfc;Jpeotive·1,tUJ_ton;r- in.11~ ~ittr~t C6'ii_l'I. ~relt~t llmt'thtiy nre)c~kt111.
Judlliinl 11.•vfowuf.fmal lli(eney uetions:. ·Within twcnty-0110 (2.l) dayt-ofthe tllin,
of the seuled rocurm. the parties wUJ ta1'o appro1>riato ateps to augmettl lhe
records beforo th<! Dist.riot Court ~jth ~o M~fon t~ ~a~trte and Desipttion
Ordcrs.Jit acc~rdo~ with -Rule 84(1)~ ldBho:-RuJ<.-. 6fCj~iJ ·Proctdure;
d. The .patties ,agree not ·m.oppom, fhe,aoo'1~tibed:nmcndmcnta to. ilfo· Petltinh.,,.
or to asscrl.tlml Hailey and .Bellavuc.or 8\7C havc.fftilod lO exhawt.fldministrativ.e
rcn1edi011, or to tako any other aodon to }Wevont rcv.iow by the Disuiol Court1 on
lho merits, of the.l111uc11.11nt'let1sed.
e. 1.n ttie ~l 1he Diteetor tak~ ;tn,Y. action io respbn~ tQ 'thc:~ule 1 JI Motif1n.,
withit\''C\,VcntY•Ofle·'(lt )' dil'ya .of the tilif~:of tho scttl.ed ·roeQrd11, the p.attica a~
trnttHaUey·and Bellevue.and ·SVC wilt tl\ko nw.ropriate ll~P tc,.111ncnd.thcir
P~tillrm~, it noocssacy, a.nd -the p8rties wm take IIJ)J'mpriate ~tcps to augment tho • .. • • • • • .,1
records bofore·the Diftrict Court with any record :(')r evideneo·O_f 11uoh:ticti6rr in
accoidaiitc witfr'Rt,tc. 84{J), Idal)o Rul~ . of Civ'il J>'rocedu~.
f. None .of ihe _parlies ·&hdll be .d e,empd ffr'have wmv«l.any olaiin or ,def~,.
it\cluding without limltntfnn ch1itM or d.of6n$ca conccnuns adequtt~e remedi~
STIJ>lJL.ATION- 6
Page 7
Sep 18 2815 11:32:45 288-388-1388 -> 21117362121 Giuens Pursely LLP Page 1111
cxhaup;tiou of adminislr~I ive remedies a1!(1 tho.se cl.uim11, def~\sesr, H~ument$,
findings ot conc.lusiobs cQntained in the, cm,,·· M,r,tJoh1 Stm VnUey ',v Mo1lon. the
ACGWS Orefer, the Sun Palley Order, or the Petlt{On$ In the ov011t the Dh,trict
Court does not rocognize u1e Ocsignalion Ol'denl and/or Hailey and Bellcvue's.ot•
SVC's.amendments'.oflho PetJti.on, .as.coofcninajuriMliction on lho.COllrt·to
~ ~tw·the A COWS qrd,r ~ tho Su; ·Ya/lay 0/fdar il,. ~1 agency action~.
I 5. St{i)ula]um to BX~itc·Judici8l ,&,viow. The parl~ ugretHo. tukc all .toaat11111bJo
steps to expedite the Oi11frict111 Court Judicial review .of the Pu(itlm.M',
16~ lo!nL M~tis>.n.."1..fil~Q.tlt@{llgd Qlt!e PrP$RgQWJd_.
a. "111iiey; _BcJlcvue, J<'Ottlhum, .PAlrfi~t.d., svc~.and. tboWU~ will file with"chc
~rtrmmt ft' Ji;int. Miitioit Jot ~krji ofDq//ve'",j.C,i1lfsub$tantiAU}'·in lbo' J'oim
attaclied hn6 n~·AtlDSrllttlent.A ( .. MQflon /or Sllty"'J, Which is hereby·
incorponrt1ld hy refcnmce.
b. Cor111istcn1 with th~ DapartmC!'t's Rule of Procc:d11re .270. any pctrtyto ~he
Del ivory C:ills !'\IY tu~· I mponi.ive·pteading .to th'e.Mot/oif for' S,ay Within
fburt~ (14) days ,~{'tt,'6 filing ~>f thc·motlon.
c. TheDcpartmon{ will a,tpcdite !ts dcclsi0.n.on the.Motltm/or.Stfly,
d~ Poltowina issuance ofltulo S4' flnal .and appcnbi~lo Judgm~~ on b(,th pe1.Jlion., . . . . .. . .. . ' ' .
~y ~he. Dutt_t'icf ~l~, .th'<s ~4't'I· -~m ~ptly l'IOtie~ ~k~ling:(;f" ~ttitue.
confffilnCe.iitwhic1fth'o:l58rr~-~ -1h1 .Dellv«i c.nund·lhe ~6ftt wut
conRult-conccming the procodurnl'sU,J>S retfulrcd .to .givo etTect·to tbc.Di11t1i'et
Cotn't' s <kcislons, .inc.fudina wlthou, limilallon, dismlm.1 orth~ contested cues,
o~ oatabl1shin; e hearina ~hedule ..
1.1. Sli®JatiM os m liemoa Sch@Je u.12 Further PrnceccUna iu th52 Inlixm
STJPULA'fl()N. 7
Page 8
Sep 18 2815 11:32:57 288-388-1388 -> 28873&2121 Giuens Pursely LLP Page 889
11, trprocoodln&ll l'~urno on tho OoUvc,y CnUa followl"B, the 1rt1ty ordorod pun1uan1
io mo MtJtltm fi>r Su,-,, &ho pArtica to the Oclivcry C1dl• ahatt be .. ,otd to o
iwhcdu~ providing 1bo lollowin; timo cmtnos nt • minimum:
l. ()hscovcry. Tho ptU'tica to thu Oolivcry C.lh1 wit be onthlod tu roamnt
dl8COV&:1'Y na lluthL1rl~c:tl b)' &ho l)lrcew•i Mi.y 13, 2c>t,, 01vl,r
Amhn1'/:f/1tp l>l.9COWJr)I,' Nt11t,:e 'fl' P,-,../let1l'l11g Cu,r/brcmCl(r, tbr o 1nin!o1um
period or ono hundred olghty ( t 80) da~ ondll\fl no Oflrtior U\On thirt)' (30)
dayll prior tho Heorfng.
it ~LW.il!.\va..DtlQ~. The [l8rtle11 to the Delivery Call• shall
diaok>.o OXport willlCQOS ~~ to t~tlfy et tho Houina. lncl'1CUttt
i11rom,11tion n,quircd by I.R.C.P. 16(,)(1) al'ld 24(b)(4)(A). no later ttlu11
slxty (60) da~ flrlor 10 lho Honrlng.
Iii. J:ismiwl. Any ovidcnti11ry hearlnaic on I.he Oolmry Calla shell ho hold na
oarllot tb4tl 1w~ huod,'Cd for1y (240) chi~ (ollowin1 the c.onclud~ of ttio
euiy otdcrod punuant lo Mf111on for Suo,.
DATl.lD thla /$.f\ay or ~~ts.
CUVBNS P~IRSLBY f.,f.,P
~~~ A rtol'MP Jbr ar, u.r I /#It.,
MOPFATT, ·n-mMAS, BARRE'rr. ROCK A FmLl)S, CHARTERED
MCHUOH BllOMLBY. PLLC
BROWN &.JAMBS
8~ ;g'.i/~_._.. _ By. ~2~~' Matthow J, McOoe Jo1oph F. JMnOB Afft"1t¥Jlll.for Sutt Yt1I~ Co•JHHIY ,41tomey11 Jb1• lit d l.lltk Wnod Wom- lhm Anoclnrll'ltl
STtPULATION· A
Page 9
Sep 18 2815 11:33:111 288-388-1388 -> 2881362121 Giuens P11rsely LLP Page 818
MOOtta ~MITH BUXTON & TURCK.I!. IOAHO OBP /\RTM&N't' Or w /\'l'EH Cti'l'l>. RClSOURCBS
~~-By: }:llis:__ o.,~ A"'1t1u.:.1<J Ji,r Cltlc11 ,,( K t4"'1Rlfl tmd F11lrjlchl A fff,,.,,.,Y,/ttr tit,• frlt,J,n I kf'tHW'trtfl qf IYflll!I' 1{~11.,
"'It# t:ur,1t ,\'tHlt),lltledj, l'11'f'd(lf' ff(tlttt ,_., lk/#ftl'tflH»l n( ~r ltNIHll'J:,•,1
ll'TfPUt.ATION· 9
Page 10
Sep 18 2815 11:33:12 288-388-1388 -> 2887362121 Givens Pursely LLP Page 811
CERTIFlCA'flt 01<' SERVICE
I HEREBY CERTIFY that 01\ this J ... l1oy of,Septembet· 2015. I caused a true and corre« C<lPY of lho foregoing dooumon.t 10 be filed wtth the C<»1rt ~i,d served m1 tho fbllowing parties by &ho ltldicated methods:
Orlgi1u1/ to;
SRBA OISTIUCT COlJR.T
253 3RD A VE NORTH
POB0X2707
TWtN FALI..S lD 83303-2707
t"acslmHc: (208) 736-2121
CANDTCB MCHUOH CHRIS M BROMLEY MCHUGH 'BROMLEY PLL.C 380 S 411! STRBET $TB IOl BOISE JO 83 702 [email protected] [email protected]
MICHAEL C CREAMER MICHAEL P LAWRENCE OJVBNS PURSLEY LLJ> POB0X2720 BOJSE ID 83701 .. 2720 mco!iaimJ1pUrllqy,yQltl [email protected] &0m
scorr L CAMPBELL NORMAN M SEMANKO MA TTHSW J MCOflE MOPFATI' THOMAS FO BOX 829 BOlSE IDAHO 83701 1IQ(Qbnoffatt,com oml@moff;u.oom [email protected] >m
GARRICK L BAXTER BMMl L BLADES ID DEPT OF WATER RESOURCES ro BOX83720 BOISE ID 83720..0098 uai9k,butdi4wc,idaha.19y emmi.blade.,@idwr,idaho,aov
sr1rULATION- IQ
( ) U.S. Mail, 1>ostage Prepaid ( ) Hand Delivery (x) f7acsitnlle ( ) E-mnil
(x) U.S. MRil, Postage Prc1>11id ( ) Hand Dolivcry ( ) Fe~i,nito (X) fi-aneJI
(x) U.S. Mail, J>ost3gc Propeid ( ) Hand Doli\'Cty ( ) Focslmilo (x) E-mail
(x) U.S. Mail, J>Qllttgo l'ret)llid ( ) Hand Delivery ( ) l 1act1lmUe (x) E•mnll
(it) U.S. Mall, Posta&e Prepaid { ) Hn.nd P.cllvery ( ) Facsimile (x) E-mail
Page 11
Sep 18 2815 11:33:23 286-388-1388
SUSAN E BUXTON CHERBSB D MCLAIN
->
MOORE SMITH BUXTON & TURKE 950 W BANNOCK STREET SUITB S20 BOISE ID 83702 4'[email protected] s;stm~Jow,com
JOSBPff F JAMES BROWN & JAMES l 30 FOURTH A VENUE WEST OOODING ID 83330 idbm:wn(BDlGBltW,com
DYJ.,AN I.A WRF.NCB VARIN WARDWELL THOMAS +
Kl)NKEL.L~ 242 N. 8TH ST., SUn'E 220 BOtSB. ID 83702 dyJapJewmogq@,y1DAY<1Jdwtll.com
Al.,BBRT P. BARKER BARKER ROSHOLT & SIMPSON UJ> tOJO W. JijFf.ERSON ST., SUITE 102 P.O. BOX 2139 BOTSB1 lO 83701-21!9 1Pb@idabow1t~a,com
JAMES P. SPECK SPBCK & AANESTAO l20E. AVE. P.O. B0X987 KETCHUM, ID 83340 ji~ndMDtaltsi,R9Jll
2887362121 Giuens Pursely W Page 812
(x} U.S. MnH, Postogo 1•1-cpeid C ) Htmd DcllVQl'y ( ) r:ecidrnilc (le) P.-m11il
(x.) U.S. Moll, Po.toge Prepaid ( ) Htmd Dcilivc:ry ( ) Fncaitl'lle (x) J!-inail
(l() U.S. Mall, 1'0!!111~ Proi>«id ( ) Hand Oclivory ( ) P&csil\'\ilQ (x) E-mail
(x) U.S. Mail, J)o.<age f>foP8ld ( ) Hand Delivery ( ) Fnct1hnilc {it) E-moil
(x.) U.S. Mail, P~e Prcf"lld ( ) Hnnd Dolivcry ( } 1111cahnilc (it) B-1nnil
~a 2-_.· ___
S'l'IJIUI..ATION· l 1
Michllel C. Creamer Altom~ for City <lf HAiley
Page 12
Sep 18 2815 11:33:32 288-388-1388 -> 2887362121 Giuens Pursely W Page 813
Michael C. Creamer, lSB # 4039 Michael P. Lawren~.e, ISB.'# 7288.. OIVBNS-PURStEY LLP. 60 t W. Bannock St. P.O. Box 2720 . Soi.le ld!illd 8'3101-l720 ' . •, . Teleph~ne: 208~388-1200 Fu: 208-3'88-tjOO
Atforneys for Clty qf Hailey
Scott L. ~pbell, ISB # 2251 Matthew. J. McGee, ISB· #. 79'J9 MOFFATl';'TflOMAs,.l3AAJ~.Eit. Rocx & FU~W>S, CHARTPR~ 101 S. Capi~I Blvd., 10th Floor Poit:Offict Bo·Jt '829 Bolsc~ Ida'ho :8f101
Candice M. McHugh., ISB I!- 5908 Chris.:M .. Bromley~.ISB # 6S30 MCHUGH.BROMLEY~ PLLC' 380 S. 4th St., Ste. 103 Boise, Idaho 83702. · Telcplione: 2os .. 2a1-099'1 Fax.: 208-287-0'864
Attorneys for City of Bellew-e
Josq>h·F. James, lSB # 57?1 BR.OWN &-·JAMES 130'Fourth-Avcnuc.Wcst Gooding, Idaho 83330 Telephorie: 208,;9J4:..8 J 8S Fax:. 208-934410·1
Telephone: {208) 34S-2000 Fax: (208} :38S-S384
At1.or12eys.Jor Big & Littkt _Wood Wotv Use,s AiiociitiiJn · · · ·
Atiorneyifor.Surt .. P'alley-Company
Su.cmn B; Buxton, [SB # 404 t Cherese·D. McLam •. lSB # 79ll MOORE SMTT'fl BOXTOl'-i' & TURac:E. CHTD. 9S0 W. Bannoclc St., Ste. 520 Boise, Idaho 83102 . . T_elephOM: {208) 3~:1-1.800 F'ax: (208) 3'.3 l-1'202
A:uprns~ for the CilidJ -0{ Ketc~um.and Fairfield
.BEFORE T.HE DEPARTMENT OP WATER.RESOURClS
OF.THE STAT.It OF IDAHO
IN THE·MATT'£!R OF' DlSTRJBt.mON·OF WATER··TO.WA1'ER RIGHTS HELD BY . NfEMBijl\$ OF THE:BlO WOOD'&. -UTTLB WOOOWATER USERS ASSOCIATION =:TJ~O FRO¥ T~B B~O \Y~D
IN'THB··MA. ER OJrDJSTIUBtrrIO OF WATER TO WATER RIGHTS Hi!LD'BY MEMBERS OP·THB.BIO WOOD & LITTLE
.DooketNO'. CM-DC-2015,-001
Docket No.cM .. DC-201 S.002
JOINT MOTION FOR STAY OF D&LIVIR.V CALLS -p.1
.A_ttacbment A.
Page 13
Sep 18 2815 11:33:45 288-389-1388 ->
WOOD WAT.ER USERS ASSOCIATION DIVERTING FROM THE.LITTLE WOOD RIVER
2881362121 Givens Pursely LLP Page 814
JOINT MOTION FOR STAY OF DELIVERY CALLS
Tho City clHailCY,·{~HaflC):'0 ),:thc.City ofBellcvuef'Bellevue•'), Sun Valley Company
(0 SVC"), the. Big· &.·Little Wood Watcr'Users.Assooiation ("WUA''), the City of Ketchum
("Ketchum"').; and the City of'Fairfield (''~airt'ie1d")' (collectively,. the ·'Movantsj~ by and
through ·tneirfcspettive.altomeys of record, jointly file this Joirtt Moticm for Stay of Delivery
Ca!L, (14Joilft'AlotJon!i requesting the Director ( .. Directorj oftne Idaho Department of Water . .
Resources. C.'Department'') stay. allJurther proceeding.CJ fo. thc,.abovc,.captio~ matters (the
"Delivery Calls") for the reasons and upon the terms-set forlh.herein:
RECITALS
l. The WUA, through their attorney, iniliated proceedings before Ote..l)ep811ment
seeking administration of.ju!]for ground water rights in Water.Districts 'J.7 ~d 37B alleging that·
diversions of water undcr .. such junior g1-ound·water rights cause material injury. to the surface
water rights of the WUA's.mcmbe:,s.
2. On Auguat.13, 2015, Hailey and:Betlewe filed.their Peti.tionforJudieial Review
of Agency Action ec1tl8t Petlll_m,'lin Ada County District Cour4 Case No. CV-OC"Ul4419,
scekin.gjudicjal review of the July ·22/ 2015,.0rder .DenyinirJaint Motion t.o Designate ACGWS
l!J Rulemetklng and w Disnti.u Dell~ CaJI, {'f,A.CG~ .Order,,) i~ ~y ~ Dir=tor.
3. On A~Lf9; 201~; SVC rtled iii Petition for Judicial Review e'SPC Pdlticmj
ip._Ada C~nty Pisu:ict-Cou.rt, ~se·No. c:;v.qc.1 s~4:s~. ~~ngj~~oial ~icw Qf.the July 22,
2QJS, (),<k, Denyb,g.Ssm .JloJ/ey.tompa,ty.;sMotion To Dimti1s.("Sun. P(flltji.Or.der~') issued by . . . .
the Director.
JOJNT'"10110N·JfOR8TAl'OFDELIV!RYC'ALLS··p.·1
Page 14
Sep 18 2815 11:33:59 288-:BJ-1388 -> 28873&2121 Giuens Pursely W Page 815
4. The. Cities ' Petition nod the SYC PelitiOlt .(together ~e "Petitions!') have been
reassigned from the Fourth-District .to .the Snake Rive.- Basin Adjudication District-Court of the
F~ Judicial District. The .. c_Jtit!s.: Pultwn ~as renumbe~ by -the Court from CY-OC-1 $ l.4419
toCV~WA·201S-.14419, TheSYC PotiJion was .renumbered by the Cowt.from.CV~OC-1'.514500
to CV-WA .. 201S-J4S00.
5-: Concurrent wjth the eMecution of lhis JahtJ Motl.on, the Movants and the
O~_ent :~ered ~to. a.Stlftu(atiQr?, ln ~bich lli~y ~gree4: (~).that .Ha_ite1, ~elJev\le, Ke.tcbum,
Fairltt4d iii<! SVC'wo\tld.filc-a motion-requesting tM Dit«tor destQfiate thoACG.WS Order .and
~ Vq/ley 0't,le;r 8' 11~.al·Qrdors:pursua,nt to the; Departm~t.~s.RuJ~ of·f~ure;?lQ~.7~
subjoci-tojlidioiafi'mewtii1der'th~Jdalfo Adrrilnttttaltve ProoedurcAct.:ldaho-Code §.61 ..
S27<?(3)~ ~) ·that:the·~~ts wout~ fite-tlm Join~ MO(jQn .rcq~~g that. ~ :D_iroc~r-,cay ~l
1<1rnin:lsttative p~irt_gs on the Oeli'v~cyCiits, inchidinifwithouf limitation all dJscoyery Md
mo.tion.practiee, until tho-DistriotCourt assu.es-Rulo 54 final and appoolab.tejudgmen.~ on the " . ~ . . . . . . ; . ' . . . . . .
Cirle.f' P~fiil6n·lfld me svc Petlttottr l'UUl'tcJ tlrai ·tJie:terffli ·IJ\c1 eonditibt\1 or tho,siay would l>e-
Mt forth·m.r.his Jou,t.·MotJon. ' .. · . . .. ..
JOINT MOTION
6. The Movants hereby move the Director to;
a. qrdcr the s~y,of all edtninistralive proceedings-on the Delivery Calls~
including .without limitation all discoveey and motion practice, until the :District Court .has issued
Rule 54 final and .oppeat~~lc.jud~cmts on bothJbc Ci(ics' Ptfltio'7 end the.SVC Petition (the
"Siay'?i and
b. Order that, foll(J~ing-issuance of Rule .S4 .final and .opp:ea1able.jud-gmcnf!
by the D'ffflict Court on both the Cilies ' Pe.Lilion and thc:SVC Petlfi,m, whichever rs later, tho
Department will proi:nptly ,notice acbedulins. of a .status.conference at which the parties. t~_.the:
JOlm'MO"i'lONFOR STAY OFDUIVERY'CALLS • p.-.1
Page 15
Sep 18 2815 11 : 34: 12 289-389-1388 -> 2887362121 Giuens Pursely LLP Page 816
Deliver)' Calls .and the Deportment will consult concen~ing rhe procedural stcpa required to .give
ctreet:to the District Court's decisions, including without-.limitation. (!ismissal of the contested
casca. or establishing a,hcaring.-sohcdule. Any f:ui:ther_procccdjngs shall be consistent with the
time,frames set.forth in the Stipulation.
7. The_Movants further agree.a.~ follows:.
a. All rights m further admi:nistrative~nd judiciol proceedings arc reserved to
tbe parties ofsuch p~ings, and the S(ay-_shatl not affec.t such rights, including ~ithout . - . . . ' . . . , . ~ ' . .
limitaiion the right o( any party ot"lhe .J)cpartmctit to seoi'. rccomideration .or·appellato .review of
th~ District CQUl't·~ d~~l~iQns <m lhe·qi~I.C?S' J.'~tllio1.' ·tn4 ~e. ~rc_fet~t~, :Q't.~~ -<?thet ·~Ji.cf
pto'.litteti :btlilW;
b. NuthiO.S. .&~n-Prectud~ any-~~y-or pcr~~-ti"Q?l ~ o ~11iy,qnmy
othet'l'C1iOf}Stovia«f"lsy·l6w.in-tnyat1mlftistrativc !ind,judi~ial pn)Ceedtng: and
c. No_.party ~r Pt?t-son.,srees ~<? uny·~tay-~f t,roc~i~QS e)!:~laa..oxpre$sly
provided hmlrt.
D~"r.~D .~i, .....,,..,,... day ~f'$epte_mber 201 s.
OIVENS.-PURSLEY LLP- MCRUO'fl 13ROMLBY.-PLLC.
By: ___________ By: ........ ___ ·-Michael C.-Creamer Candice M: Mcffugh. Attoffl(f}'j for Cil)J of Hailf)> :Attorn~Yt for CltY_"O/ Bellev~
MOFfAIT~ THOMAS, BARRETT; llOCl< & FlELDS;~ftA:R'l"BRi.ID
BROWN.&JAM~
By:,__ ____________ )3y: _____________ _
Matthew J. McGee Joseph F. James AIU>l'M)': /or.:SUH Yalltf Compa11y AttQrtto)lf for ffig &: Littltt Wood WoJtr U.fCr~· AA,wc/oI/q,i
lOll'ti MOTION FOR STAY OF DE~IVERY CALLS • p. 4·
Page 16
Sep 1B 2815 11:34:21 288-388-1388 ->
MOORE SMITH BUXTON & TURCKEt CHTD.
By: ___________ _
Susan B, Buxton AtWrtutJs far CJ!lu of Kele/tum n11d Fni,fleld
2887362121 Giuens Pursely LLP Page 817
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
J HEREBY CERTTFY that, on this _ day of 20J S, 1 served a true and correct copy of th~ foregoing document to an pttrties listed on tbo Combined Certificate of Services List pomed oo the Department's website at http://idw,.idaho.gov/legal•actions/delivezycaU-actionsjgis-woog-river.httnJ and bStl>:{li<l,wr,i<W)o,SQV/]~IJ-a9tjonmlivm-c&Jlactions/little-wood-river,html updated the 19th day of August201,. by the following method:
D Placing a copy of the document in the United States mail, postage prepaid and properly addressed.
0 Bmailina only to parties who have consented to se1vice by email as indicated on the above--describcd Certificate of Service List; placit1g a copy of the document in the United States mail, postage prepaid and property addressed, to parties who have not consented to service by email; and emailing to parties who provided email addresses to the Depanment but have not consented to service by email.
Michael C .. Cremner Attorneys for City of Hailey
JOINT MOTION FOR STAY OF DELIVERY CALLS • p. S
