Date post: | 10-Apr-2018 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | konda-rakesh |
View: | 220 times |
Download: | 0 times |
of 22
8/8/2019 Services Final Print
1/22
TERM PAPER
ON
ROLE OF EMPLOYEES IN PROVIDING QUALITY
SERVICE IN HOSPITALS
SERVICES MARKETING
To:
V.Jayasree
Sr. Asst. Professor-Marketing
Vignana Jyothi Institute of Management
BY Group 5:
Raj vardhan (09134)
Rajavali (09135)
Rakesh Konda (09136)
Chand Pasha (09013)
Solomon Victor (09014)
8/8/2019 Services Final Print
2/22
SERVICES MARKETING Page 2
Contents
1. Introduction ..................................................................................................................................... 32. Objective............................................................................................................................... 43. Scope ............................................................................................................................................... 44. Limitations ...................................................................................................................................... 45. Methodology: .................................................................................................................................. 46. Back Ground of the Study.............................................................................................................. 57. 4 Is Of Hospitals .......................................................................................................................... 58. 7 Ps Of Hospitals ........................................................................................................................... 69. The Service Marketing Triangle In Hospitals............................................................................. 1110.The Effect of Employee Behavior on Service Quality Dimensions: ................................ ......... 1211.Analysis ......................................................................................................................................... 1312.Employees Role In Offering Quality Service In Government Hospitals............................ ..... 1313.Findings from Our Study.............................................................................................................. 1914.Conclusion..................................................................................................................................... 2015.Bibliography.................................................................................................................................. 22
8/8/2019 Services Final Print
3/22
SERVICES MARKETING Page 3
INTRODUCTION
In today's world, services are becoming more and more significant in any country's economy. As
Louis V. Gerstner said in 2001 "Services are going to move in this decade to being the front edge
of the industry". This quote comes from the former CEO of a company which claims to be the
world's largest service business in the world, IBM.
The hospital industry is one of the most important service industry where the quality of service
being provided is mainly varies with the kind of employees. This is one of the sectors where
employees negligence and irresponsibility pays as high as that of a life. The various employees
in hospitals include Doctors, Nurses and other supporting staff. They have a great role to provide
final service to satisfy patients with a human touch. These employees act as the brand
ambassadors of the hospitals. The image of any organization or company will be represented bythe employees of that organization or company. Thats why first a company should satisfy its
employee which leads to satisfaction of the customers. People in hospitals should feel more
when they are providing services to the patients. They have to feel humanity and they should get
satisfaction by seeing happiness in the eyes of the patients rather than salary what they are
getting. In hospitals the services offered vary with the target customers. Though the basic service
provided is cure or treatment, there are various other factors that measure the service quality
depending on the target customers. Hence incase of hospitals the set of target customers have
their own perceptions regarding the service expectations
8/8/2019 Services Final Print
4/22
SERVICES MARKETING Page 4
Objective: The objective is to study the role of employees in providing quality service in
Hospitals.
Scope: The scope is studying and analyzing the employees in hospitals who are service
encounters only. We have not focused much on each and every employee of the hospital. We
found some important departments where employees play a major role in providing service to the
patients and we made our study in those departments only.
Limitations: Due to the limited appointments we got from employees of the hospital we
visited only one Government Hospital and one Private Hospital for our study. Time was one of
the constraints in private hospitals as they are busy and could not spend much time with us.
Methodology: The methodology we adopted for our study was mainly Exploratory Study by
using Primary Data. We went to the hospitals and identified some important departments where
employees play major role in providing service to the patients and interviewed some employees.
Based on the inputs given by them we made our analysis. We also used secondary data for some
part of our study.
8/8/2019 Services Final Print
5/22
SERVICES MARKETING Page 5
Back Ground of the Study
4 IS OF HOSPITALS
Intangibility
Intangibility indicates that the service has no physical attributes and as a result, impossible for
customer to taste, hears, feel or smell before they actually use it. Hospital industry is where the
customers (patients) get treated for physical problems they have. The customers cant really
realize the service provided until they get well. For this they have to provide good supplementary
services. The only way they can provide tangible clues to make the service provided a success.
For e.g. the hospitals provide extra facilities like television, or then friendly personnels can
make a difference.
Inconsistency
1.Its also referred to as heterogeneity or variability. The inconsistency occurs largely because of
2.Different service providers perform differently on different occasions.
3.Interaction between customer and provider may vary from customer to customer.
4.Standardization is hard to maintain.
5.Every doctor is not the same and may not give the same diagnosis. Also a patient may not each
diagnosis in a different way.
6.Also since the quality of work done can be determined only after the service is performed the
providers have to be well trained in case of performing the service process.
Inseparability
Inseparability means that the service can not be separated from the creator-seller of the service.
Here the customer, i.e. the patient has to come up to the hospital to get the treatment. The
customer has to be present when the service is performed. In fact in case of hospitals the service
is created and delivered simultaneously. The type of service to be provided depends on the
customer.
Inventory
Services can not be easily saved, stored or inventoried. This is all due to the perishable nature of
the services. Also theres cost also associated with the carrying of inventory. Here the costs are
more subjective and are related to capacity utilization for e.g. if a doctor is available but theres
8/8/2019 Services Final Print
6/22
SERVICES MARKETING Page 6
no patient during that period, the fixed cost of the idle physicians salary is a high inventory
carrying cost.
7 Ps OF HOSPITALSPRODUCT
The service products of the hospitals have the following features:
Quality level
Supporting services play an important role having the quality of Medicare. These services, which
include laboratory, blood banks, catering, radiology and laundry, in a true sense determine the
quality of services made available by medical and paramedical personnel.
Accessories
This is a very good way of segmenting customers. Many hospitals especially private hospitals
provide additional services such as catering, laundry, yoga sessions, cafeterias, etc. for the
customers who are willing to pay extra. Hospitals have different wards-General and special.
Certain hospitals provide services for the family members of the patients when they are not the
same-city for accommodating and catering.
Packaging
It is the bundling of many services into the core service. E.g. Apollo hospital offers a full
healthcare checkup to the patients.
Product Line
Hospitals through their services offer many choices to the patient and cover a wide range of
customer needs. For example: Remedy has a dental department, cardiology department etc. and
within the dental department it has dental surgery, root canal, etc.
8/8/2019 Services Final Print
7/22
SERVICES MARKETING Page 7
y Brand nameHospitals, to differentiate themselves and their services from others use a brand name. The
intangibility factor of the service makes it all-important for the hospitals to do so.
Government Hospitals:
This as a product is fairly good. In some hospitals like Gandhi hospital in Hyderabad, they
provide quality services at cheaper rates and also is technically well equipped. But most of the
government hospitals in spite of government grants do not provide quality service. Hence it is
perceived as of low quality.
Private hospitals:
Private hospitals like Mamata and Remedy Hospital, Apollo are well equipped and the services
provided are of good quality but they charge huge price for it. Hence the middle-income group
perceives them as elite class hospitals.
PLACE
Incase of hospitals the location plays a very important role. The kind of services a hospital is
rendering is also very important for determining the location of the hospital.
Example: Tata memorial hospital specializes in cancer treatment and is located at a center place
unlike other normal hospitals, which you can find all over other places.
In a country like India which is geographically vast and where majority of the population lives in
the rural areas place factor for a hospital plays a very important role. A typical small village or
town may be having small dispensaries but hey will not have super specialty hospitals. For that
they will have to be independent on the hospitals in the urban areas.
PEOPLE
Under hospital marketing mix people includes all the people involved in the service providing
process which includes doctors, nurses, supporting staff etc. the earliest and best way of having
control on the quality of people will be by approving professionally sound doctors and other
staff.
8/8/2019 Services Final Print
8/22
SERVICES MARKETING Page 8
Hospital is a place where small activity undertaken can be a matter of life and death, so the
people factor is very important.
Under hospital marketing a right person for the right job has to be appointed and they should be
adaptable possess versatility. The patients in the hospitals are already suffering from trauma,
which has to be understood by the doctors and staff. The people of the hospital should be
constantly motivated to give best of their effort.
Government Hospital:
In Indian government hospitals except a few almost all the hospitals and their personnel hardly
find the behavioral dimensions significant. Hence even if the patients get the correct treatment
they are often dissatisfied with the behavioral pattern of the staff.
Private Hospital:
They have pleasing manners and behave softly with the patients. They provide timely care and
are present always in times of need.
PROCESS
Process generally forms the different task that is performed by the hospital. The process factor is
mainly dependant on the size of the hospital and the kind of service it is offering.
Government Hospital:
There is lot of paper work involved in the whole process. Hence the whole process from
admission to discharge is tedious.
Private Hospital: With the advent of information Systems in hospitals all the paper work is
reduced and the process is smooth and fast.
8/8/2019 Services Final Print
9/22
SERVICES MARKETING Page 9
PHYSICALEVIDENCE
It does not play an important role in the health care services, as the core benefit the customer
seeks is proper diagnosis and proper cure of the problem. Physical evidence can be in the form of
smart buildings, logos, mascots etc a smart building infrastructure indicates that the hospitals can
take care of all needs of the patients.
Government Hospital:
Government hospitals have a huge building, but are not properly maintained; hence it creates a
bad impression among its patients that the hospital is unhygienic.
Private Hospital:
Private hospitals has got a smart building, which helps, in developing the minds of the people,
the impression that it is the safest option among the different hospitals available to the people.
PROMOTION
Government Hospital:
They do not undertake major promotion programs and hence are not very popular among the
masses.
Private Hospital:
They undertake extensive promotion. Along with this they undertake massive complex
operations which if successful create a good brand value of the hospitals.
PRICE
Pricing in Government / Trust Hospitals:
The fee strategy for all the hospitals should be in proportion to the incomes of users, which
would engineer a sound foundation for qualitative or quantitative improvements. For social
institutions like government hospitals a discriminatory fee structure is preferred since it provides
even the weaker sections of society, an opportunity to avail the quality medical services. This
enables hospitals to innovate services to keep pace with the latest developments in the medical
sciences.
8/8/2019 Services Final Print
10/22
SERVICES MARKETING Page 10
Pricing in Private Hospitals
Cost based pricing: Price = Direct costs + overhead costs + profit margin. In hospital services,
this method is cumbersome because the tracking and identification of costs are difficult. Fee for
services, however can be used by doctors. Notwithstanding, some hospitals in the private sector
follow this method.
Competition based pricing: using other price as an anchor for the hospitals price, heterogeneity
of service across and within providers makes the approach complicated.
Demand based pricing: Cost based pricing and competition based pricing do not consider
certain criteria. Demand based pricing involves price setting consistent with customer perception
of value. Prices are based on what will par for the services provided.
Price and quality
Price is the indicator of service quality. It is an attraction as well as a repellent variable.
Customers use price as indicator of quality depends on many factors including other information
available to him.
When service cues to quality are readily accessible when brand names provide evidence of
reputation of hospital, customer may use their cues instead of price. Otherwise they think that the
price is the best indicator of quality. It should convey appropriate signal regarding quality.
Pricing too low can lead to inaccurate inferences about the quality, pricing too high can set
expectations that may be too difficult to match in the delivery. Price is used to judged quality
because of the experience and credence properties of services as opposed to goods. Excellent
hospitals like Mamata and Remedy, Care, Apollo have a great brand reputation and can charge a
premium based on sheer perception of quality because of socio-economic issues, poverty levels,
government owned hospitals cannot think of profit objectives. It is a social marketing process of
enhancing the well being of individuals.
8/8/2019 Services Final Print
11/22
SERVICES MARKETING Page 11
THE SERVICE MARKETING TRIANGLE IN HOSPITALS
HOSPITALS: The hospital is the company that dreams up an idea of service offering (treatment)
which will satisfy the customers (patients) expectations (of getting cured).
CUSTOMER: The patient who seeks to get cured is the customer for the hospital as he is the one
who avails the service and pays for it.
EMPLOYEES: Doctor, the inseparable part of the hospital is the provider, as he is the one who
comes in direct contact with the patient. The reputation of the hospital is directly in the hands of
the doctor. A satisfied patient is a very important word of mouth promotion for the organization.
The other employees who form a key role in service quality in hospitals include nurses, other
supporting staff.
8/8/2019 Services Final Print
12/22
SERVICES MARKETING Page 12
The Effectof Employee Behavioron Service Quality Dimensions:
Customer perception of service quality will be impacted by the customer -oriented behavior
of employee. In fact, all of the five dimensions of service quality (reliability, responsiveness,
assurance, empathy, and tangible) can be influenced directly by service employees.
Delivering the service as promised-reliability -is often totally within the control of frontline
employees. Even in the case of automated services (such as ATMs, automated ticketing
machines,or self-serve and pay gasoline pumps),behind the scenes employees are critical for
making sure all the systems are working properly .when services fail or errors are made ,
employees are essential for setting things right and using their judgment to determine the best
course of action for service recovery.
Frontline employee directly influence customer perceptions of responsiveness through their
personal willingness to help and their promptness in serving customers .consider the range of
response you receive from different retail store clerks when you need help finding a particular
item of clothing one employee may ignore your presence , whereas another offers to help you
search and calls other store to locate the item . One may help you immediately and efficiently,
whereas another may move slowly in accommodating even the simplest request.
8/8/2019 Services Final Print
13/22
SERVICES MARKETING Page 13
The assurance dimension of service quality is highly dependent on employee ability to
communicate their credibility and to inspire trust and confidence. the reputation of the
organization will help, but in the and attentive listening skills .d ,individual employees with
whom the customer interact confirm and build trust in the organization or detract from its
reputation and ultimately destroy trust. For startup or relatively unknown organization ,
credibility , trust and confidence will be tied totally to employees actions
It is difficult to imagine how an organization would deliver caring ,individualized attention to
customers independent of its employees .Empathy implies will pay attention ,listen adapt ,and
be flexible in delivering what individual customers need .For example ,research documents that
when employees are customers oriented have good rapport with customers and exhibit
perceptiontive and attentive listening skills .customers will evaluate the service more highly and
be more likely to return. Employee appearance and dress are important aspects of the tangible
dimensions of quality along with many other factors that are independent of service employees
(the service facility, decor, brochure, signage and so on)
Analysis
As we mentioned earlier as part of our study we visited one Government Hospital and two
Private Hospitals namely Mamatha Hospital and Remedy Hospitals to know about role of
employees in providing quality service to the patients in hospitals. Based on our observations we
made the following analysis:
EMPLOYEES ROLE IN OFFERING QUALITY SERVICE IN GOVERNMENT
HOSPITALS:
As part of our study we visited a Government hospital to observe the role of employees in
providing quality service to the patients. We met Dr. kiran over there and asked some inputs
about our topic. He said that hospital is a place where service plays a major role than money.
Since it is an intangible product the employees play a crucial role in providing service to the
patients. Since it is a government hospital the employees are trained before, and the process of
service is a systematic approach. He said a typical government hospital would have the following
departments where patients have to come across them.
8/8/2019 Services Final Print
14/22
SERVICES MARKETING Page 14
1. OP department.2. Doctors of concerned disease3. Nursing Department.4. Medical Department.5. Scanning and tests Department etc.
Through out all these departments employees plays a major role in providing quality
service to the patients. The government hospitals do not charge money for the service
they are offering. So what makes employees happy by providing free service? The
satisfied patients, cured, healthy patients and the best compliments from them make them
happy rather than their salaries. So to achieve this employees are given pre training. To
provide effective service to the patients he said some of the following requirements thatare to be followed by every hospital and also followed in their hospital.
1. Creating Rapport with patients and employees: First the doctors in this hospital tryto create rapport with employees. They believe that employees play a major role in
providing service to the patients. They train how to build rapport with the patients.
First the OP department employees will receive the patients and enter their details and
tells them to which doctor they should meet and assist them how to reach. At this
stage the patients will look for quick response from the employees because sometimes
there may be urgent cases also. In case of emergency cases OP department employees
will immediately call nurses or doctors. Since this is a first meeting point of patients
with hospital employees, the employees should take care of creating positive
impression among the patients.
2. Giving Assurance to patients: hospital is a place where patients require moralsupport than treatment. The employees in hospital should try to give assurance to
patients. In this hospital the patients are mainly from rural areas who are not well
educated and completely rely on hospital employees only. So the duty of the
employees is to provide assurance of the service. Since it is government hospital
patients will have many doubts about the service, but the people in this hospital give
assurance by saying about facilities they are providing, giving good counseling,
instructions, and telling other options that are available.
8/8/2019 Services Final Print
15/22
SERVICES MARKETING Page 15
3. Giving Counseling to Patients: As we said earlier moral support is more importantthan treatment. Here they will give counseling to the patients about the diseases, its
condition, consequences and prognosis. They will also give counseling on what they
have to do, how many days they have to stay in the hospital, what are the precautions
type of counseling provides assurance in the minds of patients that they are going to
receive quality service. But no doubt this cannot be done until the employees are
involved in it.
4. Treatment-Prescriptions: Some times the patients may feel insecure while gettingtreatment. But the employees in this hospital gives treatment to patients in such a way
that they are not treating for outsiders they are treating for their own relatives. After
giving treatment they will give prescriptions how to use medicines and also explains
about the side effects if they are not used properly. They also tell to the patients what
type of diet that have to be taken, how frequently they have to visit, etc. since it is a
government hospital they also explains about the medical benefits they will get from
the government.
5. Drug Compliance: after giving treatment employees have to check compliance ofthe drugs given. In this hospital the employees check continuously monitor the drugs
they give to the patients. If they require more medicines they provide.
Apart from these the employees also should give moral support to the guardians, relatives of the
patients. So from the above points we can observe that employees play a major role in providing
service to the patients. In this hospital we observed that doctors play a vital role in providing
service by giving instructions to staff and patients. The service providers are fulfilling their role
to reduce the service delivery gap.
Role of nurses and other staff in providing service to the patients
Hospital is a place where not only doctors play a role in providing service to the patients there
are others who plays vital role in service providing. The nurses and other staff are among them.
In fact these are the people who make close relationship with the patients than doctors. Keeping
this in mind we also interacted with staff nurse namely Manikyam and she gave the following
inputs how they provide service to the patients.
8/8/2019 Services Final Print
16/22
SERVICES MARKETING Page 16
1. A service provider particularly in hospital should not look for proper time for providingservice. Patients may come at any time. The service provider should be ready at any time
for providing service because there may be emergency cases like accidental cases,
poisonous cases etc,. In this case the nurses and other supporting staff plays major role
like informing seriousness of the patient to the superiors, giving first aid, building
confidence in patient, giving moral support to the patients and his/her family members,
clearing doubts about diseases, etc. She said that they will complete almost 70% of the
treatment before the patient had taken to the doctor. This is because since it is a
government hospital the doctors may not be available at all times. So nurses will take
care of them.
2. She said they will treat patients with affection rather than doing business. When weasked her that they will get their salary regularly even though they dont provide that
quality of service. She replied they will not get satisfaction with the salary they are
getting, they will get real satisfaction when they receive best compliments from the
patients, when the patients are cured, and their family members felt happy. So this
incident tells us that the service provider should feel more responsible in providing
service to the receiver.
3. She said they not only give treatment to the patients they also takes care of patients diet,prescriptions given by the doctors, sanitation, physical and mental support to the patients.
The above inputs clearly mention that service providers should feel empathy, and give assurance,
be responsive, reliable and try to tangibilize their service. She said she will get real satisfaction
when ever patients come again they should give positive word of mouth about the employees. So
whether it is a government hospital and private hospital employees have to provide service in
more responsible way rather than doing business oriented way. Then only the service gap
between provider and supplier can be reduced.
8/8/2019 Services Final Print
17/22
SERVICES MARKETING Page 17
ROLE OF EMPLOYEES IN OFFERING QUALITY SERVICE IN PRIVATE
HOSPITALS:
In contrast to the government hospitals we even selected private hospital (Mamatha and
Remedy hospitals) to extend our analysis and find the differences between the services offered in
private hospitals in comparison to government hospitals. The role of employees also differs in
private hospitals when compared to public hospitals. The following is the role of different
employees in private hospitals.
*Time was one of the constraints in private hospitals as they are busy and could not spend much
time with us.
1. DOCTORS: Doctors play a key role in delivering the final value i.e, the perceived inhospitals which is nothing but treatment. Hospital services can be typically evaluated only after
the treatment i.e, how early the customers (patients) recover from various ailments. So Doctors
are the drivers for this. We identified some qualities of doctors that drive quality service and
customer satisfaction after speaking to the patients and doctors in those hospitals. These are as
follows:
y Interaction with the patients during treatmenty Time of interactiony Number and type of questions they ask about the problem (regarding health)y Answering to the queries of the patientsy Past reputation of the doctorsy Frequent monitoring of health and interaction with patients in case ofIn-patientsy Qualification of Doctors (in few cases even customers feel that higher quality of service
is delivered by highly qualified doctors)
y Moral support given to patientsDoctors actually acts as the brand builders in case of hospitals as the most modes of
marketing takes place through word of mouth in case of hospitals. It is also important to note
that hospital is an industry where a slightest negligence from employees may lead to the
death of the patients.
8/8/2019 Services Final Print
18/22
SERVICES MARKETING Page 18
2 NURSES: The second key important personnel incase of hospitals include nurses. In
fact these are the employees who often spend more time with the customers than the doctors.
The behavior of nurses plays a key role in delivering quality service to customers. Nurses take
care vital works that are linked to the service but not visible to the customers. They are the ones
who are involved in the pre and post treatment given by the doctor. For example, its the nurse
who makes the operation theatre ready, the equipments required for an operation and other
arrangements that are mandatory for the final service.
Nurses in private hospitals are trained enough to tackle patients and their relatives where
they have a great responsibility of handling emotions. Nurses in private hospitals are more
responsive and kind towards the patients. Nurses of private hospitals also helps patients in taking
care of the drug doses, diet requirements etc which makes patients satisfied with the service
provides in the hospitals. The way nurses interact with patients during their stay in the hospital is
also organized leading to the customer satisfaction. Hence on the whole the satisfactory levels of
the service are linked with the behavior of nurses as it involves human touch.
3. SUPPORTING STAFF:
Though the supporting staff have no direct role in the service offered, there is a relation
with the over all satisfaction on the final service. The supporting staff include receptionist, para
medical staff, house keeping staff and others. These supporting staff has a great role to play in
maintaining the ambience of the private hospitals which is a greatest asset to them. Private
hospitals have well trained staff to ensure the cleanliness of the surroundings, appointments with
the doctors, providing laboratory services, diagnostic services to the patients that increases the
satisfaction levels. Private hospitals ensure to have the latest technology that makes patients to
think of greater service quality being offered using the latest technology.
8/8/2019 Services Final Print
19/22
SERVICES MARKETING Page 19
Findings from Our Study
y The target customers i,e. patients for Government hospitals and private hospitals aredifferent .Therefore the service quality expectations will differ.
yThe process of providing service in Government hospital follows a systematic approachwhere as in private hospitals the process may vary from one hospital to other.
y The responsiveness and reliability is relatively less in Government hospitals compared toPrivate Hospitals.
y The service quality of employees in Government Hospitals depends upon the facilitiesthat hospital is having. If more facilities available service quality will be more.
y In government hospitals nurses and other staffs play a major role in providing service tothe patience. This is because doctors checks the patients and gives prescriptions. After
that nurses will take care about the patient. For this purpose proper training will be given
for them before posting.
y The perception of the people that Government hospital does not provide good service isnot always correct. When we did our study we came to know that it was only peoples
perception and awareness should be created.
y The government hospital may not give same and quick response to all patients becausethe inflow of patients is very high compared to private hospitals.
y The government employees may feel unhappy due to more working hours, morepresence, and hence this may effect the service quality
y The employees of govt hospitals are not bothered about the service quality and repetitionof the customers and poor service is mostly delivered.
y The private employees concentrate much on service quality because of their targetcustomers who are ready to pay a premium.
y The perception of customers is that quality is proportional to price being paid by them.y Private hospital employees are trained enough to interact with customers and take
constant feedback to increase the service quality.
y Private employees are profit oriented and hence they focus on repete customers whichhappens by offering quality service.
8/8/2019 Services Final Print
20/22
SERVICES MARKETING Page 20
Conclusion
Whether it is hospitals or any other organizations people play an important role
in service industry. It is one of the important Ps of7Ps that are available. People represent the
image of the company. When we talk about hospitals the role of employees play a crucial role in
providing service to the customers. Here customers are patients. We know that satisfied
employees will provide better quality service and makes customers as a loyal customers. But in
case of hospitals they should not expect loyal customers rather than they should create
satisfaction in the patients. Here it is not enough satisfying only the patient hospitals needs to
satisfy family members of the patients also. For this employees have to play major role in service
providing. It does not matter whether it is a government hospital or private hospital ultimately
people over there should feel responsible and serve the patients. In hospitals there are various
service encounters where employees have to play vital role during these encounters. Employees
in government hospitals need more training when compared to the private hospitals. Private
hospitals also keep in mind that they should serve the people with humanity but not in
commercial point of view. Last but not least people perception has to change that government
hospital provides bad service and private hospitals provide good services. There are many
government hospitals which provide better service than the private hospitals. In this situation
employees will play major role in positioning image in the customers mind. We finally concludethat irrespective of the private or government hospitals employees in the hospitals should feel
empathy, give assurance, responsiveness and reliability to the patients when ever they need
service.
8/8/2019 Services Final Print
21/22
SERVICES MARKETING Page 21
SERVICE EXPERIENCES FROM CUSTOMERS:
As a part of our study we interacted with one patient named Siddhartha a B-Tech student
who is suffering from malaria from the past 2 weeks. He got admitted in Mamatha hospital. We
interacted with him for a period of one week. The following were his experiences regarding the
service quality of the employees in the hospital:
y Due to the heavy fever and decreased WBC (White Blood Cells Count) count the doctorof Mamatha advised to admit in the hospital.
y The first two days of the stay was a bad experience for the patient as well as their familymembers who came there.
y There is heavy rush in the hospital as it is rainy season followed by the out broke ofseveral epidemic diseases.
y The patient demanded for a single room for admitting in the hospital but due to the peakdemand and unavailability of the rooms the doctors promised them that he will be
accommodated in a special room and asked them to join in a shared room with 3 patients.
y Considering the doctors promise Mr. Siddhartha was admitted in the common room. Buthe had a very frustrating experience in the first two days.
y The doctors and nurses were not so responsive due to their busyness to meet the highdemand.
y Even the receptionists were not so responsive because when one of the uncles ofSiddhartha came to the hospital to see him, he enquired about where he was staying and
the receptionist was not responsive and he has to stay 15 min in the reception area to
know where the patient was.
y Doctors came once in the morning and evening and had a casual look at the patient andgoing without explaining about the situation of the patient. This was not welcomed by the
patient.
y The nurses were also not responsive in helping the patient to relax.y The worst conditions in the shared room by the patient made them frustrated and they
decided to change the hospital. Then patients side asked to discharge the patient but then
the doctors immediately meet their demand of an individual room with an air
conditioner.
8/8/2019 Services Final Print
22/22
SERVICES MARKETING Page 22
y Though the conditions were improved in the single room in terms of services offered,they were not sufficient to meet the desired services as they could only meet the adequate
services.
y The doctors and nurses failed to communicate and transfer the information regarding thereports to patients. It was the patients side who continuously asked and forced the
hospital employees regarding the diagnosis reports.
Bibliography
References:
Text Books
y K. Douglas Hoffman, John E. G. Bateson, Essentials ofService Marketing: Concepts,Strategies, & Cases, Second Edition, 2004, Thomson, South- Western, Banglore, India.
y Valarie A Zeithaml, Dwayne D Gremler, Mary Jo Bitner, Ajay Pandit, ServiceMarketing: Integrating CustomerFocus Across the Firm, Fourth Edition, 2008, The Mc
Graw- Hill Companies, New Delhi, India.
y C. Bhattacharjee, Services Marketing concepts, planning and implementation,FirstEdition, 2006, Excel Publishers, New Delhi.
Primary Data Sources
y MAMATHA HOSPITALy REMEDY HOSPITALy AP GOVERNMENT HOSPITAL