1
Sex-Typing of Leisure Activities: A Test of Two Theories
Presented to ACR 2003, Toronto ON
• George M. Zinkhan, University of Georgia• Penelope Prenshaw, Millsaps College• Angeline Grace Close, University of Georgia
2
Leisure as Consumption
Consumption and tourist behavior is a salient aspect of tourism Hoch (2002).
Purpose: Study the relationship between gender
schema and leisure activitiesTest rival predictions about gender schema Test competing theories: Bem (1981) v.s.
Spence (1984)
3
Research Questions
• Does one gender sex-type leisure activities to a greater extent than the other?
• What are the predictors of sex typing?
• Which of the two competeting theories best explains sex-typing of leisure activities?
4
Literature Review
• Differences exist in leisure behavior between men and women.
• Gender ideologies structure perceptions of leisure.
• Are bases of differences are biological and/or the result of socialization experiences ?
5
Hypotheses
• H1: Men are more likely to sex-type leisure activities than women.
• H2: “Masculine” men and “feminine” women, as defined by the Bem Sex Role Inventory, are more likely to sex-type leisure activities than are men and women with nontraditional gender-role attitudes.
• H3: Men and women with traditional gender-role attitudes will label leisure activities as either “more masculine” or “more feminine”.
6
Gender
• Sociological concept referring to a category scheme
• Mutually exclusive categories (Sherif 1982)
• Cultural definitions of appropriate male or female behavior (Henderson 1989)
• Masculinity-femininity dimension
7
Sex-Typing
Sex typing: societal transformation: male masculinefemale feminine
{Masculine---------Non-Sex Typed---------Feminine}
• defined within specific cultures • role assignments• Sex-specific personality attributes
8
Competing Theories
Sex-typing of leisure activities is related to two individual difference measures:
• Gender personality (Bem 1981)
• Gender-role attitudes (Spence 1984)
9
Bem’s (1981) Unifactorial Gender Schema Theory
• Bem links notions of sex-typing to gender schemata.
• Proposes that sex-typed individuals have a greater readiness to engage in gender-schematic processing (i.e., a network of sex-linked associations that organizes and guides an individual’s perceptions).
• Non-sex-typed individuals=aschematic individuals relatively unresponsive to stereotypically masculine and feminine cues when processing information.
10
Bem’s Theory Operationalized• (BSRI)• Self-report measure• Individuals can be classified into one of three
categories: • (a) masculine sex-typed• (b) feminine sex-typed• (c) non-sex-typed
11
Spence’s (1984) Multi-factorial Theory of Gender Identity
• Opposes Bem’s view• Emerging sense of gender identity stimulates
adoption of gender-stereotyped behaviors/beliefs• Once gender identity is firmly established, other
factors (i.e., gender role attitudes) protect/confirm sense of gender identity
• Variables leading to individual differences= situational factors, internal dispositions, attitudes toward maintaining traditional gender role distinctions, personal preferences, and perceptions (realistic or unrealistic) of the consequences of acting in certain ways.
12
Spence’s (1984) Multi-factorial Theory of Gender Identity, cont.
Variables leading to individual differences:• situational factors• internal dispositions• attitudes toward maintaining traditional gender
role distinctions• personal preferences• perceptions (realistic or unrealistic) of the
consequences of acting in certain ways
13
Method
• 271 R’s (2 samples)• Mailed to 200 Adult Girl Scout Council
Members• Administered to business students• Rs are provided with a list of 75 leisure
activities• List derived from past taxonomies of
participation
14
Leisure Activities Tested
Some of the 75 activities include:
Media Related Activities
Sports
15
Sex-typing Measures
• 7 point scale • asked to indicate whether they felt the activity
was:
extremely masculine neutral extremely feminine
/------------/------------/-----------/-----------/------------/
somewhat in between
16
Gender Role Attitude Measures
• Attitudes Toward Women Scale (Spence and Helmreich 1978)
• 15 item instrument of statements describing the rights, roles, and privileges women ought to have or be permitted to have
• Agreement with each statement on a 4-point scale from “agree strongly” to “disagree strongly”
• Low scores= more traditional, conservative attitude toward gender roles
17
MeasuresMasculinity-Femininity: Personal attribute questionnaire (Spence and Helmreich and Stapp 1975)a) M-scale: 8 items describing characteristics descriptive
of masculine personality traitsb) F-scale: 8 items describing qualities more
characteristic of feminine personality traits• Respondents indicated on a 5-point scale the extent to
which each phrase describes him or her• summed M score and a F score for each • Sex-typed individuals score high on one sexual
dimension & low on the other
18
Regression
• determine the degree of sex-typing
• OLS
• Sex Typing = f (Biological Sex, Gender-Role Attitudes, Gender Identity)
19
Findings
Neutral (i.e., not sex-typed by > half of the sample): • many leisure activities are not sex-typed. • 33 were identified as neutral (greater than 50% of
the sample). • Neutrality found of media-related: watching TV,
listening to the music, going to movies, renting movies and reading magazines
• outdoor activities: jogging, bicycling, playing tennis and swimming.
• individual activities: reading a book for pleasure, taking a nap, and doing crossword puzzles
20
Findings
Masculine (i.e., sex-typed by >half of the sample):• Requiring physical activity (e.g., playing football,
playing basketball, working out at a gym)• Outdoor activities (e.g., hunting, fishing,
canoeing)• Passive activities (reading newspapers, taking a
nap)
21
Findings
Feminine (i.e., sex-typed by > half of the sample):
• Sewing, aerobics, shopping, cooking, talking on the phone
• Cultural activities (e.g., attendance at the ballet, opera and theater plays, visiting art museums, playing the piano, and painting or drawing)
22
Findings
Masculine (i.e., sex-typed by > half of the sample):
• Sports (participating and viewing) (e.g., football, basketball, billiards, golf, skiing)
• Outdoor (e.g., hunting, fishing, camping, hiking, archery, rafting, canoeing, sailing)
• Woodworking, collecting• Games (e.g., chess, checkers, cards)
23
Findings• Higher proportion of males sex-typed leisure
activities for both sexes• Chi-square tests: the sex difference was
statistically significant (p< .05) for most masculine-typed activities (23 of 28)
• Greater consensus between the sexes for the feminine-typed activities
• More females identified more as neutral (Significant (p < .05) for 48 of the activities sex-
typed as “either”)
24
Findings
• We do not find support for Bem’s (1981) theory
• We do find partial support for Spence’s (1984) theory
• Males sex-type leisure activities to a greater extent than females
• Sex and gender-role attitudes are significant (p < .05) predictors of sex-typing
25
Conclusions
• Relationship exists between gender schema and sex-typing of leisure (consumption) activities
• Brings competing psychological (e.g., Bem) and sociological (e.g., Spence) theories into a consumer behavior perspective
• We find that leisure activities, as a subset of consumption experiences, may be sex-typed-- especially by males.
26
Changing Roles
• As gender roles change in society, these patterns may change.
• “Appropriate” roles less defined
• Women: hunt, bet on football games
• Men: knit, fine arts performances
• Fostering an androgynous society
27
Further Research
Test gender theory via:• Tourists’ consumption habits (and other
patterns) of natives• “Hotspots” or experimental experiences• Is the Internet a leisure activity that may be
sex-typed? Implications?• Expand activities (e.g., online gaming,
Kazaa, fantasy sports, chat, IM, e-dating)
28
Thank you!
• Please refer to tables 1-3
Dr. Zinkhan and I welcome your feedback/questions!
