NASHVILLE ELECTRIC SERVICE |
The Smart Grid for Today’s Electric
Utility and Tomorrow’s Needs
November 2, 2010
NASHVILLE ELECTRIC SERVICE |
• Presentation Agenda:
– Introduction to Smart Grid components
– Smart Grid industry status update
– The Smart Grid at NES
– Smart Grid project benefits
2
NES is the 12th largest public power utility in the US
• Established in 1939
• 357,000 customers
• ~700 square miles of Davidson County
and portions of 6 others
• 2,700 MW peak demand
• 52 substations and ~300 feeders
• Purchase power from TVA
NASHVILLE ELECTRIC SERVICE |
The Tennessee Valley is transitioning to time differentiated rates which has created significant interest in demand response
• Introduction to Smart Grid components and considerations for the distribution system
NASHVILLE ELECTRIC SERVICE |
4
NASHVILLE ELECTRIC SERVICE |
DOE characterizes the Smart Grid as having 7 major components.
The basic concept of Smart Grid is to add monitoring, analysis, control and
communication capabilities to the national electric grid in order to improve
reliability, maximize throughput, increase energy efficiency, provide
consumer participation and allow diverse generation and storage options.
– NEMA
5
The Smart Grid is a platform for continuous value enhancement from generation to the customer’s uses.
DOE defines the SG for its SGIG Program as including:
– AMI: interval meter reading, power outage, provisioning, customer links (HAN) etc.
– Demand Response: optimizing load using prices and or controls
– Distribution Automation: optimizing distribution system operation
NASHVILLE ELECTRIC SERVICE |
6
• SG industry status update
NASHVILLE ELECTRIC SERVICE |
7
Smart Grid is real and happening with $4 billion of projects underway in the US alone and more outside the US
NASHVILLE ELECTRIC SERVICE |
8
Smart Grid implementation requires planning to enable future proofed investments.
Aggregate Benefit Potential
Time
Basic AMI System
• AMI
• Outage
• Surgical disconnect
• Basic load control
• Limited SCADA
• Limited DA
Smart Grid
• DA
• Reduced forecast
error
• Backup generation
• Integrated disconnect
• Energy Info Display
• Energy management
• 2-Way load control
• 3rd party uses
Advanced Smart Grid
• Intelligent applications
• Integrated applications
–Generation
–Transmission
–Distribution
–End Use Application
• Micro-grids
•Vehicle to grid
•Distributed generation
• Customer energy automation
• Energy trading
• 3rd party uses
NASHVILLE ELECTRIC SERVICE |
9
DOE-NIST and the major industry suppliers are driving the adoption of standards (NIST SP 1108).
• Proposed benefit: Interoperability and future proofing
• Major new examples:
– Communication - 802.15.4g, e; 6LowPAN, RoLL
– NIST Cyber Security: AES 128, etc.
– IT: CIM, DLMS
• Increased planning, due diligence, testing and implementation needs
NASHVILLE ELECTRIC SERVICE |
10
NES’s Smart Grid components reflect a broad view of applications and enabling technologies.
NASHVILLE ELECTRIC SERVICE |
NES Representative VPP Layered Architecture
SA (AVM)
FAN NODE
TVA-GENERATION
SUBSTATION
ICCP
(existing)
ICCP for
VPP (new)
ICCP
(existing)
VPP
(new)
SYS
Ops
XFMR LTC CAP BANK
Power Layer
Communications Layer
Applications Layer
Primary
SCADA
AVMDispatch
Control
VPPGateway-
SettlementOMS
NES- SYSTEM OPERATIONS
MDMSHESALM/CPP
ControllerCIS
User
Energy
Portal
NES-DATA CENTER
Regional Area Network (RAN)
Volt-
VAR
sensor
Feeder
Capacitor
Switch
DA (AVM)
DISTRIBUTION
Voltage
Regu-
lator
GSA2
AMI Network (NAN – Mesh or Star, RF or PLC)
VPP: AVM, ALC, ALR, CPP
CUSTOMER
ALR
ALC
CPP
AVM AMI
Substation
SCADA-RTU
NES Private Fiber Network (FAN)TVA Private Fiber Carrier-Based Connectivity (WAN)
11
NES’s Smart Grid will support AMI, DA
and DR applications in order to address
NES needs.
AMI
Meter
Sectionalizer
& Recloser
Line
Sensors
Capacitor
Bank
Controller
Faulted
Circuit
Indicator
Direct
Load
Control
DRIHD
PCT
DLC
REMS
DG
PHEV
Smart
Transformer
Smart
Substation
• Sensors
• Controllers
• Voltage Reg.
• Cameras
DG
• Solar
• Wind
• Etc.
Distribution Automation AMI DR
NASHVILLE ELECTRIC SERVICE |
NES Virtual Power Plant Focus
12
The HAN was intended to help customers understand their energy use.
• Provide energy use data in to consumer devices
• Original vision: dedicated devices like PCT, IHD etc.
• Emerging vision: existing device like TV, cell phone, PC, laptop etc.
• Issues to be addressed
– Cost
– Technology risk
– Customer adoption
– “Standards”
NASHVILLE ELECTRIC SERVICE |
13
A clear SG vision is crucial to implementing a “future proofed”system meeting long term needs.
Core SG Uses
Advanced SG Uses
Unlikely SG Uses
NASHVILLE ELECTRIC SERVICE |
14
Technical criteria selection creates the foundation for the Smart Grid solution that maximizes value.
Criteria to Consider
•Data rate
•Latency
•Security
•Functionality
•Scalability
Network
Needs
Industry
Standards
Endpoint
Need
NASHVILLE ELECTRIC SERVICE |
15
•Interoperability
•Open
•Future Proofing
•Incremental Uses
� Functionality:
� 1,440 readings per month
� 4 channels
� Power outage reporting
� Voltage reporting
� Tamper
� Reprogrammability
� Reconfigurability
� 200A connect switch
How are today’s Smart Meters different than your dad’s meter?
NASHVILLE ELECTRIC SERVICE |
16
• Smart Grid at NES
NASHVILLE ELECTRIC SERVICE |
17
NASHVILLE ELECTRIC SERVICE |
NES’ Smart Grid Guiding Principles will
drive the implementation of a solution to
meet long term needs
• Align with NES corporate vision and strategy.
• Use the NES fiber system for backhaul communications where feasible.
• Implement a system that can readily incorporate new requirements.
• Minimize disruption to operations when implementing AMI.
• Avoid commitments to limited lifetime and proprietary technology.
• Purchase off-the-shelf components, including software, where practical.
• Follow industry standards wherever possible.
18
NASHVILLE ELECTRIC SERVICE |
NES’ Smart Grid Vision Statement
Smart Grid will significantly enhance NES’ ability to accomplish its mission of
providing safe, reliable and economical electric power for the comfort,
convenience and security of its customers by:
– Empowering customers to make intelligent energy choices
– Enabling NES to offer new initiatives
– Supporting key societal conservation efforts and TVA demand response initiatives
– Facilitating effective management of key operating costs
19
NASHVILLE ELECTRIC SERVICE |
Our project team has experienced internal and external resources to maximize project success factors.
• Smart Grid Core Team
– Tony Richman - Program Manager
– Vic Hatridge - MDMS Project Team Lead
– Ty Jones - Meter & Installation Team Lead
– Sylvia Smith – Business and Financial Management Team Lead
– Landon Roeder - AMI Network Team Lead
– Bruce Mackie – Advanced Voltage Management Team Lead
– Jim Purcell- Advanced Load Managmenent Team Lead
• MW Consulting
– Strategy, communications, IT, security, implementation planning
20
NASHVILLE ELECTRIC SERVICE |
21
NES’ Smart Grid plan is based on a
detailed strategic plan activity.
• Smart Grid benefits
NASHVILLE ELECTRIC SERVICE |
22
NES has an AMI business case that is being enhanced to include DA and DR.
NASHVILLE ELECTRIC SERVICE |
23
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90
Value in Cents/Meter/Month
reading
reduced hard to reads
improved accuracy
meter testing
eliminate locks
estimated bills
theft
read to bill time
collectibles
accounting
call center
DSM
outage
outage mgmt
lost sales
Be
ne
fit
Fa
mil
ies
Potential AMR Benefits
Maximum
Minimum
Example of Potential AMI Only Benefits
NASHVILLE ELECTRIC SERVICE |
NES is also going to explore tomorrow’s Smart Grid areas such as PHEV for benefits and impacts.
• Governor’s Zero Emission Vehicle Partnership
• Partnering with TVA and EPRI on PHEV impact study
• Member of the eTec DOE-FOA-28 Partnership
• Participating in site determination of public charging infrastructure, EVSE data analysis, and R&D work which could include various battery technologies and piloting new rates
24
NASHVILLE ELECTRIC SERVICE |
Questions?
25