Date post: | 06-Jul-2018 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | christos-giannopoulos |
View: | 215 times |
Download: | 0 times |
8/17/2019 SGIR Uneven and Combined Development Paper
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sgir-uneven-and-combined-development-paper 1/29
!"#$#" &"' ()*+,"#' -#$#.)/*#"0 &"' 01# 2"3.)45#6*&" 76#.8'# 0) 99:
8/17/2019 SGIR Uneven and Combined Development Paper
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sgir-uneven-and-combined-development-paper 2/29
2+;06&<0
"#$% &'($)*+ &((+,-(% (. %$(/&(+ (#+ &--'.&)# .0 112 3$(#$4 (#+ ).4(+5( .0 (#+
/4+6+4 &47 ).,8$4+7 7+6+*.-,+4( .0 9$4+(++4(# :+4(/'; </'.-+&4 )&-$(&*$%,="#'./># & ).,-&'&($6+ &4&*;%$% .0 ?+',&4 &47 @'$($%# 7+6+*.-,+4( 3$(#$4 (#+
).4(+5( .0 (#+ +-.)#&* ('&4%$($.4 0'., 0+/7&*$%, (. )&-$(&*$%,A (#+ &'($)*+ -'.-.%+%(#&( +5$%($4> #$%(.'$)&* ,&(+'$&*$%( &47 B+&*$%( /47+'%(&47$4>% .0 (#+ '..(% .0 112&'+ $4&7+C/&(+= B+&*$%( &4&*;%+%A %('+%%$4> (#+ -'$,&); .0 D>+.-.*$($)%EA 0&$* (. -'.6$7+
& ).46$4)$4> +5-*&4&($.4 .0 (#+ -'+)$%+ .'$>$4% .0 ?+',&4 8+**$).%$(;= F4%(+&7 (#+;
&%%/,+ (#&( +5-&4%$.4$%( ?+',&4 8+#&6$./' 3&% &4 $4+6$(&8*+ ).4%+C/+4)+ .0%;%(+,$) &4&')#;= G$%(.'$)&* ,&(+'$&*$%( &))./4(%A -'+0+''$4> & %.)$.*.>$)&*
+5-*&4&($.4A .6+'%(&(+ (#+ $,-.'(&4)+ .0 %;%(+,$) )&-$(&*$%( )'$%$% &47 (#+ </'.-+&4H3$7+ +%)&*&($.4 .0 )*&%% %('/>>*+ 0.' /47+'%(&47$4> (#+ >+4+%$% .0 (#+ 3&'= I($*$%$4>
"'.(%J;E% ).4)+-( .0 /4+6+4 &47 ).,8$4+7 7+6+*.-,+4(A F ).4(+47A +4&8*+% & ,.'+
).,-'+#+4%$6+ /47+'%(&47$4> .0 (#+ .'$>$4% .0 (#+ ).40*$)(=
=#>?)6';
I4+6+4 &47 :.,8$4+7 K+6+*.-,+4(A B+&*$%,A G$%(.'$)&* L&(+'$&*$%,A F4(+'%(&(+
B$6&*';A M$'%( 1.'*7 1&'=
8/17/2019 SGIR Uneven and Combined Development Paper
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sgir-uneven-and-combined-development-paper 3/29
F4 '+)+4( ;+&'% & 8/'>+.4$4> *$(+'&(/'+ #&% +,+'>+7 '+>&'7$4> (#+ &--*$)&($.4 .0
N+.4 "'.(%J;E% ).4)+-( .0 D/4+6+4 &47 ).,8$4+7 7+6+*.-,+4(E OIP:KQ (. (#+7$%)$-*$4+ .0 F4(+'4&($.4&* B+*&($.4%= M&)+7 3$(# (#+ C/+%($.4 .0 3#; B/%%$&4
7+6+*.-,+4( #&7 %J+3+7 %. ,&'J+7*; 0'., (#+ /4$0.', ('&R+)(.'; .0 )&-$(&*$%(7+6+*.-,+4( (#&( L&'5 #&7 &4($)$-&(+7A "'.(%J; (/'4+7 (. IP:K &% & 3&; .0
/47+'%(&47$4> (#+ %$4>/*&'$(; .0 (#+ B/%%$&4 +5-+'$+4)+=$
@/$*7$4> 0'., S/%($4B.%+48+'>E% O2TTUV WXXUQ &%(/(+ +5(+4%$.4 .0 (#+ +5-*&4&(.'; -&'&,+(+'% .0 (#+).4)+-(A %)#.*&'% #&6+ &((+,-(+7 (. /($*$Y+ "'.(%J;E% $7+&% $4 .'7+' (. .6+').,+ (#+
-+')+$6+7 $4&8$*$(; .0 )*&%%$)&* %.)$&* (#+.'; (. +4).,-&%% & 7;4&,$) ).4)+-( .0 (#+
D$4(+'4&($.4&*E 3$(#$4 $(% +5-*&4&(.'; %).-+= @; 8'.&7+4$4> (#+ '+&)# .0 "'.(%J;E%.'$>$4&* /%+ .0 (#+ ).4)+-(A B.%+48+'> OWXXUQ #&% %./>#( (. +%(&8*$%# IP:K &% &
('&4%H#$%(.'$) -'.-+'(; .0 #/,&4 %.)$&* 7+6+*.-,+4(=
F4(+'4&($.4&* B+*&($.4% %)#.*&'%#$- #&% 8++4 #&,%('/4> 8; & *.4>%(&47$4> *+6+*H.0H
&4&*;%$% -'.8*+,&($) OZ$4>+'A 2TU2Q= 9+.HB+&*$%( %)#.*&'% #&6+ ).4R/'+7 (#+7.,$4&4( (#+.'$Y&($.4 .0 (#+ D$4(+'4&($.4&*E$$A 8/( #&6+ &)#$+6+7 (#+$' 0.)/% 8;
('$6$&*$Y$4> (#+ $40*/+4)+ .0 7.,+%($) -.*$($)&* -'.)+%%+% /-.4 >*.8&* -.*$($)%=G$%(.'$)&* ,&(+'$&*$%( &))./4(%A 8; ).4('&%(A #&6+ %('+%%+7 (#+ $,-.'(&4)+ .0 %.)$&*0.')+%A +4>+47+'+7 8; -'.7/)($.4 '+*&($.4%A &% J+; 7+(+',$4&4(% .0 3.'*7 -.*$($)%=
[+( (#+; #&6+ %. 0&' 0&$*+7 (. &7+C/&(+*; $4(+>'&(+ $4(+'%(&(+ 7;4&,$)% 3$(#$4 )'$($)&*(#+.'$+% .0 (#+ FB .0 )&-$(&*$%( ,.7+'4$(;=$$$ :.4%+C/+4(*;A B.%+48+'> &47 .(#+'%
#&6+ )&**+7 0.' %)#.*&'% (. .6+').,+ (#+ 7$)#.(.,; 8+(3++4 (#+ 4&($.4&* &47 (#+
$4(+'4&($.4&* $4 & ,&44+' (#&( )#&**+4>+% (#+ B+&*$%( '+$0$)&($.4 .0 $4(+'4&($.4&*'+*&($.4%=
@; -.%$($4> IP:K &% (#+ .4(.*.>$)&* 8&%$% .0 (#+ D$4(+'4&($.4&*EA %/>>+%(% B.%+48+'>
OWXXU\ ]2WQA 3+ )&4 .6+').,+ 8.(# (#+ &#$%(.'$)&* '+$0$)&($.4 .0 $4(+'4&($.4&*
'+*&($.4% &% & 7$%($4)( %.)$&* '+&*, >.6+'4+7 8; & ($,+*+%% *&3 .0 &4&')#; O4+.HB+&*$%,QA &47 (#+ )'/7+ 7.,+%($) '+7/)($.4$%, (#&( +%)#+3% (#+ %$>4$0$)&4)+ .0
B+&*-.*$($J O)*&%%$)&* %.)$&* (#+.';Q= B.%+48+'> #.-+% (#&( 8; 7.$4> %. 3+ )&4
+%(&8*$%# (#+ 8&%$% 0.' & -'.-+'*; #$%(.'$)&* &47 #.*$%($) &4&*;%$% .0 (#+ 0/** %-+)('/,.0 $4(+'4&($.4&* '+*&($.4%A .4+ (#&( )&-(/'+% (#+ ).44+)($6$(; 8+(3++4 %.)$+(&* &47
$4(+'H%.)$+(&* 7;4&,$)%=
K+%-$(+ (#+ %/8%(&4($&* &,./4( .0 (#+.'+($)&* 7+8&(+ (#&( #&% .))/''+7 '+>&'7$4>
"'.(%J;E% $7+&% &47 (#+$' &--*$)&($.4 (. FB OB.%+48+'>A WXXUV B.%+48+'> P:&**$4$).%A WXX^V _**$4%.4 P _4$+6&%A WXXTV _%#,&4A WXXTQA (#+'+ #&% 8++4 *$((*+
&--*$)&($.4 .0 (#+ ).4)+-( (. ).,-&'&($6+ $4C/$';= _*(#./># IP:K #&% 8++4 .00+'+7
&% &4 &*(+'4&($6+ (. B+&*$%( &4&*;%+% .0 $4(+'4&($.4&* '+*&($.4%A $( #&% ;+( (. 8+ (+%(+7&>&$4%( &*(+'4&($6+ #$%(.'$)&* ,&(+'$&*$%( &--'.&)#+% &((+,-($4> (. %.*6+ %$,$*&'
-'.8*+,%= M'., & #$%(.'$)&* ,&(+'$&*$%( -+'%-+)($6+ (#+ D1.'*7 Z;%(+,% _--'.&)#EO1Z_QA '+-'+%+4(% .4+ .0 (#+ ,.%( %.-#$%($)&(+7 &((+,-(% (. .00+' & ).,-'+#+4%$6+
&))./4( .0 )#&4>+ &47 ).4($4/$(; $4 FB= F4 -&'($)/*&'A ?$.6&44$ _''$>#$ &47 @+6+'*;
Z$*6+' O2TTT\ 2H]`Q #&6+ &((+,-(+7 (. '+0$4+ 1Z_ 8; (&J$4> $4(. ).4%$7+'&($.4 (#+,/(/&**; ).4%($(/($6+ '+*&($.4%#$- 8+(3++4 %.)$&* 0.')+%A %(&(+% &47 (#+ 3.'*7
)&-$(&*$%( %;%(+,=
8/17/2019 SGIR Uneven and Combined Development Paper
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sgir-uneven-and-combined-development-paper 4/29
"#+ 7+&'(# .0 +,-$'$)&* &4&*;%$% $40.',+7 8; (#+.'+($)&* ).4%$7+'&($.4% .0 IP:K#&% ,+&4( (#&( (#+ $4(+'%($)+% 8+(3++4 IP:K &% & ).4)+-(/&* &8%('&)($.4A &47
#$%(.'$)&**; %-+)$0$) %.)$&* 0.')+ %('&(+>$+%A #&6+ %. 0&' '+,&$4+7 /4+5-*.'+7= 1$(#(#$% $4 ,$47 (#+'+0.'+A ,; $4(+4($.4 #+'+ $% (. +5-*.'+ +,-$'$)&**; (#+ &4&*;($)&*
-.(+4($&* .0 IP:K &% &4 &*(+'4&($6+ (. +5$%($4> 0'&,+3.'J% .0 &4&*;%$% 3$(#$4 FB="#$% &'($)*+ 3$** 8+>$4 3$(# & )'$($)&* +4>&>+,+4( 3$(# @+6+'*; Z$*6+'E% OWXX]QA!"#$%&' #) *+,#-$. /#$0&$1' 2#3&4&56' +57 89#,+9:;+6:#5 ':5%& <=>?1 = a&'($)/*&'
&((+4($.4 3$** 8+ -&$7 (. #+' ('+&(,+4( .0 (#+ '+*&($.4%#$- 8+(3++4 -'+H1&'
</'.-+&4 *&8./' ,.6+,+4(%A (#+ ?'+&( K+-'+%%$.4 &% & >*.8&* )'$%$% .0 :&-$(&*$%,&47 (#+ ./(8'+&J .0 112=
"#+ &'>/,+4( 3$** (#+4 ,.6+ (. &4 $46+%($>&($.4 .0 (#+ -'+H1&' -+'$.7A 0.)/%$4>
/-.4 @'$($%# &47 ?+',&4 *&8./' ,.6+,+4(% 3$(#$4 (#+ ).4(+5( .0 )&-$(&*$%(
7+6+*.-,+4(= L; &4&*;%$% 3$** 7+,.4%('&(+ (#+ '+*&($.4%#$- 8+(3++4 IP:KA %.)$&*0.')+ %('&(+>$+% &47 $4(+'%(&(+ '$6&*'$+%= F 3$** -'.-.%+ (#&( Z$*6+'E% &4&*;%$% .0 *&8./'
,.6+,+4(% &47 (#+$' '+*&($.4 (. $4(+'4&($.4&* -.*$($)% %/00+'% 0'., & 7+8$*$(&($4>7+>'++ .0 #$%(.'$)&* $4%+4%$($6$(;= :.4%+C/+4(*;A #+' &4&*;%$% %+6+'+*; .6+'%(&(+% (#+)&/%&* /4$0.',$(; $,-&'(+7 .4(. %(&(+% &47 (#+ )*&%% %('/>>*+% 3$(#$4 (#+,A 8; (#+
)'$%$% (+47+4)$+% 3$(#$4 (#+ )&-$(&*$%( 3.'*7 %;%(+,= Z$*6+'E% $4&8$*$(; (. &))./4( 0.'(#+ 7$6+'%+ -&((+'4% .0 </'.-+&4 7+6+*.-,+4( *+&7% #+' (.3&'7% +''.4+./%
).4)*/%$.4% '+>&'7$4> (#+ 7+>'++ (. 3#$)# (#+'+ $% & )&/%&* '+*&($.4 8+(3++4 *&8./'
/4'+%( &47 $4(+'%(&(+ ).,-+($($.4=
@/$*7$4> 0'., (#+ ).4)*/%$.4% .0 (#+ #$%(.'$)&* $46+%($>&($.4A F 3$** (#+4 +5-./47 (#+-.(+4($&* .0 IP:K &% &4 &*(+'4&($6+ +5-*&4&(.'; ,+)#&4$%, (. +5$%($4> #$%(.'$)&*
,&(+'$&*$%( &47 B+&*$%( &--'.&)#+% (. /47+'%(&47$4> (#+ +,+'>+4)+ .0 _4>*.H
?+',&4 '$6&*'; -'$.' (. 112= F4 .'7+' (. /47+'%(&47 (#+ -'+).47$($.4% .0 112A F3$** %/>>+%(A 3+ ,/%( *..J (.3&'7% 7$00+'+4($&* ('&R+)(.'$+% .0 )&-$(&*$%(
7+6+*.-,+4( 3$(#$4 </'.-+= "#+ %-+)$0$) -&(# .0 ?+',&4 *&(+ 7+6+*.-,+4(A '&(#+'
(#&4 (#+ 4.($.4 .0 &4 .6+'&** %;%(+,$) )#&**+4>+ (. @'$($%# #+>+,.4;A $% .0 -&'($)/*&'$,-.'(&4)+ 0.' /47+'%(&47$4> (#+ -'+*/7+ (. 112= @; 3&; .0 ).4)*/%$.4A F 3$**
%/>>+%( (#&( IP:K +4#&4)+% ./' &8$*$(; (. )&-(/'+ (#+ 0/47&,+4(&* $4(+'&)($6$(; .0)&-$(&*$%( 7+6+*.-,+4(A )*&%% -'&)($)+% &47 %(&(+)'&0(A +4&8*$4> /% (. +,8+7
$4(+'%(&(+ '+*&($.4% 3$(#$4 7+6+*.-,+4(&* 7;4&,$)%=
9)6.' @>;0#*; 2"&.>;,;A B&+)86 C)$#*#"0; &"' D"0#6"&0,)"&. E#.&0,)";FG#$#6.> @,.$#6H; 2<<)8"0
@+6+'*; Z$*6+' OWXX]Q &((+,-(% (. )*&'$0; (#+ )/''+4( %(&(/% .0 *&8./' ,.6+,+4(% 8;
+5&,$4$4> (#+, 3$(#$4 & #$%(.'$)&* 0'&,+3.'J (#&( %('+()#+% 0'., (#+ *&(+ 2T(#
)+4(/'; /- (. (#+ -'+%+4( +'&= _)).'7$4> (. Z$*6+'A ,/)# .0 (#+ %)#.*&'%#$- .4 *&8./',.6+,+4( -.*$($)% #&% 8++4 )#&'&)(+'$%+7 8; & (+47+4); (. ('+&( (#+ %(&(+ &% &4
$47+-+47+4( /4$(= "#$% #&% *+7 (. &4 /47+'H&--'+)$&($.4 .0 (#+ $,-&)( .0 (#+ 3.'*7
8/17/2019 SGIR Uneven and Combined Development Paper
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sgir-uneven-and-combined-development-paper 5/29
+).4.,; $4 %#&-$4> *&8./' ,.6+,+4(% &)'.%% (#+ 3.'*7= Z$*6+'E% %(/7; $% (#+'+0.'+
&4 &((+,-( (. ,.6+ 8+;.47 (#+ D).,-&'&($6+H#$%(.'$)&* *$(+'&(/'+EA (#&( >.+% &8./(D%-*$(($4>E (#+ 3.'*7 *&8./' ,.6+,+4( $4 %+&')# .0 7$%($4)($6+4+%% '&(#+' (#&4
D*/,-$4>E (#+ )&%+% $4 %+&')# .0 ).,,.4&*$($+% &47 >+4+'&*$Y&($.4% OZ$*6+'A WXX]\]`Q=
Z$*6+' .00+'% /% & 7;4&,$) /47+'%(&47$4> .0 (#+ '+*&($.4%#$- 8+(3++4 %(&(+% &47*&8./' ,.6+,+4(% $4 3#$)# *&8./' ,.6+,+4(% &'+ ).4($4/&**; ,&7+ &47 '+,&7+ &%
(#+ %(&(+ +6.*6+%= "#+ ).4)+-(/&* )&(+>.'$+% .0 DL&'5H(;-+E &47 Da.*;&4$H(;-+E *&8./'
/4'+%( &'+ /%+7 8; Z$*6+' &% $7+&*H(;-$)&* )&(+>.'$+% (. %('/)(/'+ (#+ &4&*;%$%= "#+%+(3$4 ).4)+-(% &'+ 0'&,+7 3$(#$4 3#&( Z$*6+' '+0+'% (. &% & D%;%(+,H*+6+* -'.8*+,E
(#&( )#&'&)(+'$%+% )&-$(&*$%,= "#$% %;%(+,H*+6+* -'.8*+, ,&4$0+%(% $(%+*0 $4 (#+ 0.',.0 & 0/47&,+4(&**; ).4('&7$)(.'; *.>$) (#'./># 3#$)# (#+ %-'+&7 .0 )&-$(&*$%,
%('+4>(#+4% *&8./' ,.6+,+4(%A 0.')$4> )&-$(&* (. ,&J+ ).4)+%%$.4% (. *&8./' 8/(
-'.6.J$4> & )'$%$% .0 -'.0$(&8$*$(; $4 7.$4> %.=
9.3A *+( /% '&$%+ %.,+ .8R+)($.4% (. Z$*6+'E% (#+.'+($)&* 0'&,+3.'J= F4 %#$0($4> (#+0.)/% &3&; 0'., (#+ 7:))&$&5%&' 8+(3++4 *&8./' ,.6+,+4(% &47 %(&(+ &)(.'%A &47(.3&'7% (#+ @&5&$+9:6:&' &47 '+*&($.4%#$-% 8+(3++4 (#+,A Z$*6+' ,.6+% 0'., .4+
+5('+,+ -.$4( .0 0.)/% (. (#+ .(#+'= Z('+%%$4> >+4+'&*$(;A Z$*6+' *+&6+% (#+).4%($(/($6+ '.*+ .0 &)(.'% 3$(#$4 (#+ %;%(+, -57:))&$&56:+6&7 V &** &)(.'% &'+
-'+%/,+7 (. 8+ 0/4)($.4&**; %$,$*&'= "#+ #$%(.'$)&* -'.)+%% $% %#&)J*+7 3$(#$4 (#+
(3$4 $7+&*H(;-$)&* '#;(#,% .0 L&'5H(;-+ &47 a.*;&4$H(;-+ 7+6+*.-,+4(= "#+ .4*;7$%($4)($.4 ,&7+ 8+(3++4 7$00+'+4( 0.',% .0 %(&(+H*&8./' ).,-*+5+% $% & 8$4&'; .4+
&( (#+ %;%(+,$) *+6+*V 8+(3++4 *&8./' ,.6+,+4(% &47 %(&(+% $4 >+.>'&-#$)&* &'+&% .0)&-$(&*$%( +5-&4%$.4 &47 ).,,.7$0$)&($.4A .4 (#+ .4+ #&47A &47 (#.%+ (#&( &'+ 8;
).4('&%( '+*&($6+*; 7+).,,.7$0$+7A .4 (#+ .(#+'= :.4%+C/+4(*;A (#+ $,-&)( .0
$47$6$7/&* &47 #$%(.'$)&**; %-+)$0$) %(&(+H)&-$(&*H*&8./' '+*&($.4% .0 )./4('$+% 3$(#$4(#+ 7$00+'+4( a.*;&4$&4 +5('+,$($+% $% *+0( /4+5-*.'+7= "#$% &,./4(% (. & '&(#+'
%#&**.3 (#+.'$Y&($.4 .0 (#+ %(&(+A &% 3$** 8+).,+ )*+&' 3$(# ./' %/8%+C/+4(
+,-$'$)&* $4C/$';=
B&+)86 !"6#;0A D"0#6;0&0# E,$&.6> &"' 01# (6,;,; )I 01# B&0# J,"#0##"01
(#"086>F K1# @/#<,I,<,0> )I 01# 5#6*&" (&;#
"#+ %(.'; (#&( Z$*6+' (+**% $% .0 & >+4+'&* 7+%(&8$*$Y&($.4 .0 +5$%($4> %.)$&* ).,-&)(% $4
</'.-+ (.3&'7% (#+ +47 .0 (#+ 9$4+(++4(# :+4(/';A 3#$)# )'+&(+7 &47 %('+4>(#+4+7
+,+'>+4( 3.'J$4> )*&%%+%A *+&7$4> (. 3$7+%-'+&7 /4'+%(= F4(+'H$,-+'$&*$%( '$6&*'$+%3+'+ 0+7 8;A &47 0+7 $4(. (#+ /4'+%(= "#$% *+7 (. &A D3$7+4$4> &47 7++-+4$4> b6$)$./%
)$')*+c .0 3&' &47 *&8./' /4'+%(E OZ$*6+'A WXX]\ 2WTQ= "#+ J+; ('$>>+' 0&)(.' $4 (#++5-*.%$.4 .0 *&8./' ,$*$(&4); &47 $4(+'4&($.4&* ).40*$)( 3&% (#+ ?'+&( K+-'+%%$.4
O2^`]HTUQ= _4 $4(+4%+ -+'$.7 .0 $4(+'H)&-$(&*$%( ).,-+($($.4 8+>&4 .4 & 3.'*7 %)&*+A
3#$)# *+7 (. %/8%(&4($&* ('&4%0.',&($.4% $4 3.'*7 %)&*+ -'.)+%%+% .0 )&-$(&*&))/,/*&($.4= ?*.8&* ('&4%0.',&($.4% $4 )&-$(&* &))/,/*&($.4 ('&4%*&(+7 $4(. 7++-
&47 '&-$7 ('&4%0.',&($.4% .0 ,.7+'4 *&8./' ,.6+,+4(%A 8.(# $4 1+%(+'4 </'.-+
8/17/2019 SGIR Uneven and Combined Development Paper
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sgir-uneven-and-combined-development-paper 6/29
&47 9.'(# _,+'$)& &% ).,-+($($6+ -'+%%/'+% 3+'+ ('&4%0+''+7 .4(. *&8./'= @; (#+
2^TXE%A D-'$)+% %(&'(+7 (. '$%+ 0&%(+' (#&4 3&>+%A %('/)(/'&* /4+,-*.;,+4( 8+)&,+-+'%$%(+4( &47 (#+'+ 3&% & ('+47 (.3&'7 & >'.3$4> -.*&'$Y&($.4 .0 3+&*(# 8+(3++4
'$)# &47 -..'E OZ$*6+'A WXX]\ 22]Q= 1.'J$4> )*&%% -&'($+% +,+'>+7 &47 7+,&47% 0.'/4$6+'%&* %/00'&>+ -'.*$0+'&(+7 OZ$*6+'A WXX]\ 22]Q= F,-.'(&4(*;A Z$*6+' 6$+3% (#+%+
7+6+*.-,+4(% &% -&'( .0 & 'A'6&4:% %B+99&5@& 6# C$:6:'B B&@&4#5A =
Z$*6+' &((+,-(%A *&/7&8*;A (. $4).'-.'&(+ &4 &4&*;%$% .0 *&8./' ,.6+,+4(% $4(. &
(#+.'+($)&* &--'.&)# (#&( #&% (+47+7 (. %('+%% (#+ )+4('&*$(; .0 #+>+,.4$) &>+4); $4
&*(+'$4> >*.8&* 7;4&,$)% O_''$>#$ P Z$*6+'A 2TTTQ= "#+ -'.8*+, #+'+ $% (#&( (#+ 4++7(. $7+4($0; %;%(+,H3$7+ )'$%+% (+47+4)$+% *+&7% (.3&'7% & %+6+'+*; $4&7+C/&(+
('+&(,+4( .0 (#+ 4/&4)+% .0 *&8./' ,.6+,+4(%= 9.($4> 4&($.4&* 7$00+'+4)+%A Z$*6+'-.$4(% (. 6&'$&($.4% 8+(3++4 (#+ *&8./' ,.6+,+4(% .0 (#+ IZA @'$(&$4 &47 ?+',&4;=
B&(#+' (#&4 )&'';$4> #+' $4C/$'; $4(. 4&($.4&* 7$00+'+4)+% 0/'(#+' #.3+6+'A Z$*6+'
/40.'(/4&(+*; -'+0+'% (. %('+%% (#&( &** .0 (#+%+ 7+6+*.-,+4(% 3+'+ '+*&(+7'+%-.4%+% (. >+4+'&* %;%(+,$) -'+%%/'+% +,&4&($4> 0'., (#+ 3.'*7 ,&'J+(= "#+
%$4>/*&'$(; .0 (#+ ?+',&4 +5-+'$+4)+ &47 (#+ /4-'+)+7+4(+7 -.*$($)$%&($.4 .0 $(%$4)$-$+4( *&8./' ,.6+,+4( &'+ +5-*&$4+7 &%A D(#+ ,.%( %('$J$4> +5&,-*+ .0 & >+4+'&*-'.)+%%E OZ$*6+'A WXX]\ 2]dQA +4%/'$4> (#&( (#+ $4(+>'&* C/&*$(&($6+ 7$00+'+4)+ &47
#$%(.'$)&* %$>4$0$)&4)+ .0 (#+ ?+',&4 *&8./' ,.6+,+4( &'+ >*.%%+7 .6+'=
@; 0.)/%$4> /-.4 (#+ #.,.>+4$Y$4> $,-&)( .0 %;%(+,$) -'+%%/'+%A &47 $>4.'$4>
7$%($4)($.4% 8+(3++4 %(&(+%A Z$*6+' +5&>>+'&(+% (#+ /4$0.',$(; .0 (#+ ?'+&(K+-'+%%$.4E% $,-&)(= Z(&(+ 0.',&($.4A *&8./' ,.6+,+4( +6.*/($.4 &47 $4(+'4&($.4&*
'+*&($.4% &'+ '+7/)+7 (. & %$,-*+ %($,/*/%H'+%-.4%+ $4(+'&)($.4 >+4+'&(+7 8; (#+).4('&7$)($.4% .0 )&-$(&*$%,= 1.'*7 -.*$($)% &47 *&8./' -.*$($)% #&7A %#+ %/>>+%(%A
&*'+&7; 8+).,+ D7++-*; $4(+'(3$4+7E 8; (#+ +6+ .0 112 OZ$*6+'A WXX]\ 2]TQ= B/*+'%
#&7 ).,+ (. 6&*/+ %,&**A +&%$*; 3$44&8*+ 3&'% (#&( %+'6+7 (. +%(&8*$%# %.)$&*).#+%$.4= _** (#$% *+&7% Z$*6+' (. -.'('&; (#+ $,-/*%+ (. 3&' &% 0/47&,+4(&**;
D</'.-+&4EA $4 ).4('&%( (. (#+ $7+& (#&( &4; %$4>*+ %(&(+ 3&% -'$,&'$*; '+%-.4%$8*+ 0.'
(#+ ./(8'+&J .0 ).40*$)(=
G&6$4> +%(&8*$%#+7 (#+ +,-$'$)&* >'./47% 0.' #+' &4&*;%$%A Z$*6+' OWXX]\ 2`eQ (#+4&'($)/*&(+% .4+ .0 (#+ J+; ).4)*/%$.4% .0 #+' $4C/$';V (#&( (#+ '+H+,+'>+4)+ .0
$4(+'%(&(+ ).40*$)( $4 (#+ -'+%+4( ).4R/4)(/'+ 3$** 8+ ($+7 (. (#+ -'.*$0+'&($.4 .0
*&8./' /4'+%(= F4 .'7+' (. )#&**+4>+ Z$*6+'E% )*&$, 3+ ,/%( +5&,$4+ $4 >'+&(+' 7+(&$*(#+ -'.)+%%+% .0 )&-$(&*$%( 7+6+*.-,+4( &((+47&4( (. (#+ -'+H3&' -+'$.7= :&4 3+
+5-*&$4 (#+ ./(8'+&J .0 #.%($*$(; &% & ).4%+C/+4)+ .0 & 3$7+%-'+&7 $,-+(/% (. 3&'
&'$%$4> 0'., (#+ )'$%$% (+47+4)$+% .0 >*.8&* )&-$(&*$%,f g' 7. 3+ 4++7 (. /47+'%(&47(#+ -'+*/7+ (. 112 &% & ).4%+C/+4)+ .0 (#+ 3.'J$4>H./( .0 4&($.4&**; %-+)$0$)
('&R+)(.'$+% .0 %.)$&* 7+6+*.-,+4( &47 )*&%% %('/>>*+f "/'4$4> ./' &((+4($.4 (. (#+)#&'&)(+' .0 (#+ )&-$(&*$%( %(&(+ 3$** &%%$%( ./' $4C/$'; $4(. (#+%+ C/+%($.4%= F 3$**
(#+4 0*+%# ./( &4 &*(+'4&($6+ &))./4( .0 (#+ -'+H112 ,$*$+/ (#&( +,-#&%$Y+% (#+
%$>4$0$)&4)+ .0 *&(+ ?+',&4 7+6+*.-,+4( 3$(#$4 & 3.'*7 ,&'J+( 7.,$4&(+7 8;@'$(&$4 &47 )#&'&)(+'$Y+7 8; D/4+6+44+%%E=
8/17/2019 SGIR Uneven and Combined Development Paper
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sgir-uneven-and-combined-development-paper 7/29
(&/,0&.,;0 -#$#.)/*#"0 &"' 01# @<1,;* G#0?##" 01# L7).,0,<&.H &"' 01#LM<)")*,<H
_% -&'( .0 (#+ ('&4%$($.4 0'., 0+/7&*$%, (. )&-$(&*$%,A (#+ -'$6&($Y+7 -.*$($)&*
-.3+'% .0 (#+ 0+/7&* &--'.-'$&($4> )*&%% 3+'+ >'&7/&**; ('&4%0+''+7 (. (#+%.6+'+$>4 %(&(+=$6"#+ '.*+ .0 0+/7&* *.'7% 3&% '+7/)+7 (. .4+ .0A D-'$6&(+ +5-*.$(&($6+-.3+'% -/'$0$+7 .0 -/8*$)A %.)$&* 0/4)($.4%EA 3#$*%( (#+ )+4('&*$Y+7 -.3+' .0 (#+ %(&(+
$4)'+&%+7 O1..7A 2TTd\ ]TQ= 1$(#$4 )&-$(&*$%,A 0.',&* -.*$($)&* 0/4)($.4% 8+).,+
&D%9-':3&9A E-,9:% (#+'+0.'+ &47 &'+ ('&4%0+''+7 (. (#+ %(&(+= Z/'-*/% $% 4.3&--'.-'$&(+7 (#'./># (#+ 0/4)($.4$4> .0 (#+ ,&'J+( '&(#+' (#&4 (#+ (#'+&( .0 *.'7*;
).+')$.4= "#$% &,./4(% (. & )'/)$&* ('&4%0.',&($.4 .0 (#+ )#$4 $4 3#$)# -.3+' $%+5+')$%+7= M/47&,+4(&**;A (#+ D,+&4% .0 7.,$4&($.4E O).+')$6+ -.*$($)&* )&-&)$(;Q
8+).,+ %+-&'&(+7 ./( 0'., (#+ D,+&4% .0 &--'.-'$&($.4E O(#+ ,&44+' $4 3#$)#
%/'-*/% $% &))/,/*&(+7Q=
F4 ).4('&%( (. (#+ 0+/7&* -'.7/)($6+ )*&%%+%A )&-$(&*$%( 3.'J+'% +4R.; *+>&* 0'++7.,="#+; &'+ 4.4+(#+*+%% %/8R+)(+7 (. (#+ E#F&$ .0 (#+ )&-$(&*$%(%A 3#.%+ ).4('.* .6+'-'$6&(+ -'.-+'(; +4%/'+% (#&( 3.'J+'% &'+ ).,-+**+7 (. %+** (#+$' *&8./' .4 (#+
,&'J+(A &% (#$% $% (#+ .4*; -&(# (. &))+%%$4> (#+ ,+&4% .0 -'.7/)($.4= "#+'+ $%A4+6+'(#+*+%%A & ).+')$6+ /47+'-$44$4> (. )&-$(&*$%,\ & %(&(+ (#&( >/&'&4(++% (#+
%&4)($(; .0 -'$6&(+ -'.-+'(;=
[+( (#+ %(&(+ +6&7+% &4; 7$'+)( $,-*$)&($.4 $4 (#+ +5-*.$(&($6+ '+*&($.4% (#&(
)#&'&)(+'$Y+ (#+ -'.7/)($.4 -'.)+%%= F4 (#$% %+4%+ (#+ )&-$(&*$%( %(&(+ +4R.;% & 7+>'++.0 '+*&($6+ &/(.4.,; 0'., (#+ -'.7/)($.4 -'.)+%%=6 "#+ %(&(+ (&J+% .4 & -/8*$)
0/4)($.4 &47 &--+&'% (. 8+*.4> (. +6+';.4+ $4 +C/&* ,+&%/'+A & ).4%+C/+4)+ .0 (#+
0.',&* %+-&'&($.4 .0 )*&%% -.3+' 0'., %(&(+ -.3+'= "#$% %+-&'&($.4 ,&4$0+%(% $(%+*0$4%($(/($.4&**; $4 (#+ &--+&'&4)+ .0 (#+ %(&(+ &% & %++,$4>*; &/(.4.,./% +4($(; &47
0$47% 0/'(#+' +5-'+%%$.4 $4A D(#+ %+-&'&($.4 .0 (#+ $47$6$7/&*E% '+*&($.4 (. (#+ %(&(+
0'., #$% $,,+7$&(+ '+*&($.4 (. )&-$(&*A $4 (#+ %+-&'&($.4 .0 (#+ 3.'J+' $4(. 3.'J+'&47 )$($Y+4A $4 (#+ %+-&'&($.4 .0 #$% %('/>>*+ $4(. D+).4.,$) %('/>>*+E &47 D-.*$($)&*
%('/>>*+E OG.**.3&; P a$))$.((.A 2TT2\ 22eQ=
g6+'&**A (#+%+ %('/)(/'&* )#&4>+% #&6+ +4.',./% $,-*$)&($.4% 0.' (#+ )#&'&)(+' .0
)*&%% '+*&($.4% 3$(#$4 )&-$(&*$%,= "#+ +5)*/%$.4 .0 -.*$($)% 0'., &'+&% .0 ('&7$($.4&*$46.*6+,+4( *+47% & 4.6+* C/&*$(; (. )*&%% %('/>>*+ 8+)&/%+A D(#+ %('/>>*+ .6+'
&--'.-'$&($.4 &--+&'% 4.( &% & -.*$($)&* %('/>>*+ 8/( &% & ,+669& #3&$ 6B& 6&$4' +57
%#57:6:#5' #) F#$0 E O1..7A 2TTd\ eeA +,-#&%$% &77+7Q= "#$% ('&4%0.',&($.4 $4 (#+-'.0$*+ .0 )*&%% &4(&>.4$%,% ).4%($(/(+% (#+ D*.)&*$Y&($.4 .0 )*&%% %('/>>*+E O1..7A
2TTd\ eeHedQ= B&(#+' (#&4 0.)/%$4> .4 (#+ $4#+'+4(*; -.*$($)&* '+*&($.4%#$-% .0%/'-*/% +5('&)($.4 &47 &--'.-'$&($.4A %('/>>*+ 8+).,+% ).4)+4('&(+7 &( (#+ E#:56 #)
E$#7-%6:#5=
K+%-$(+ (#+ ,&>4$(/7+ .0 (#$% ('&4%0.',&($.4A *&8./' %('/>>*+% $4 )&-$(&*$%( %.)$+($+%
&'+ 4.( +5)*/%$6+*; ).40$4+7 (. D+).4.,$)E -&'&,+(+'%=6$ :*&%% %('/>>*+% 3$(#$4
8/17/2019 SGIR Uneven and Combined Development Paper
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sgir-uneven-and-combined-development-paper 8/29
)&-$(&*$%, &((&$4 & ,.'+ -.*$($)&* #/+ 3#+4 (#+; ,.6+ 8+;.47 (#+ ).40$4+% .0 (#+
$47$6$7/&* 3.'J-*&)+ &47 8+>$4 (. +4>&>+ ,.'+ 7$'+)(*; 3$(# %(&(+ -.3+'A(#'+&(+4$4> (#+ %+-&'&($.4 .0 (#+ (3. %-#+'+%=6$$ 9+6+'(#+*+%%A (#$% .))/'% .4*; &% &
'&%#57+$A 4#4&56 .0 %('/>>*+ 3$(# '+%-+)( (. & ,&(/'+ %.)$&* 0.',&($.4A 3#$)# #&%7+6+*.-+7 $4%($(/($.4% (#&( +4&8*+ (#+ %(&(+H%.)$+(; ).,-*+5 (. &)).,,.7&(+
-'+%%/'+% >+4+'&(+7 8; )&-$(&*$%( %.)$&* '+*&($.4%= F4 (#+ )&%+ .0 & %(&(+ '&-$7*;+,+'>$4> 0'., & ).47$($.4 .0 8&)J3&'74+%% #.3+6+'A 3$(# &4 &))+*+'&(+7 '&(+ .07+6+*.-,+4(A (#+ &((+,-( (. $4)/*)&(+ &47 +4)./'&>+ -'.)+%%+% .0 )&-$(&*$%(
7+6+*.-,+4( ,&; *+&7 (. 7$00+'+4( ./().,+% &47 $4%($(/($.4&* &''&4>+,+4(% (#&(
&'+ *+%% $,,+7$&(+*; &8*+ (. &)).,,.7&(+ (#+ %.'(% .0 %.)$&* &4(&>.4$%,% >+4+'&(+78; )&-$(&*$%,=
G+'+ 3+ #&6+ &''$6+7 &( (#+ 0$'%( %$>4-.%( .4 ./' R./'4+; (.3&'7% /47+'%(&47$4>
(#+ /4+6+4 (+5(/'+ .0 </'.-+&4 7+6+*.-,+4(= "#+ 7$00+'+4($&($.4 .0 (#+ D-.*$($)&*E
0'., (#+ D+).4.,$)E .' (#+ D,+&4% .0 7.,$4&($.4E 0'., (#+ D,+&4% .0 &--'.-'$&($.4E,/%( 8+ 6$+3+7 &% & *.4>H(+', #$%(.'$)&* -'.)+%% .0 )&-$(&*$%( 7+6+*.-,+4(=6$$$ "#+
+5$%(+4)+ .0 (#+ %(&(+A #.3+6+'A *.4> -'+7&(+% (#+ &76+4( .0 )&-$(&*$%( %.)$&* '+*&($.4%&47 $4(+'4&($.4&**;A )&-$(&*$%( 7+6+*.-,+4( #&% 4.( 8++4 & /4$0.', -'.)+%%=:'/)$&**; (#+'+0.'+A )&-$(&*$%( 7+6+*.-,+4( $4 </'.-+ .))/''+7 &( 7$00+'+4( '&(+% &47
3$(#$4 (#+ ).4(+5( .0 ,&'J+7*; 7$00+'+4( 0.',% .0 %(&(+ $=+= /47+' ).47$($.4% .0D/4+6+44+%%E=
"#$% $% 3#+'+ "'.(%J;E% $4%$>#(% '+>&'7$4> 7+6+*.-,+4( 8+).,+ -&'($)/*&'*;%$>4$0$)&4(= "'.(%J; OWXX^\ eQ &'>/+7 (#&( 8&)J3&'7 )./4('$+% )./*7 &%%$,$*&(+A D&**
(#+ ,&(+'$&* &47 $4(+**+)(/&* ).4C/+%(% .0 (#+ &76&4)+7 )./4('$+%E= G.3+6+'A (#$% 7$74.( ,+&4 (#&( (#+; 3./*7 &((+,-( (. '+-*$)&(+ 0/**; &** (#+ -'$.' 7+6+*.-,+4(&*
%(&>+% .0 &76&4)+7 )./4('$+%= F4%(+&7A 8&)J3&'7 )./4('$+% 3./*7 &7.-( (#+$' .34
B:'6#$:%+99A -5:G-& E+6B #) 7&3&9#E4&56 (#&( 3./*7 -'.)++7 $4 & 7$00+'+4( .'7+' (.(#&( +5-+'$+4)+7 8; (#+ &76&4)+7 )./4('$+%= @&)J3&'74+%% )./*7 +6+4 &)).'7 & %.'(
.0 D-'$6$*+>+E (. 7+6+*.-$4> )./4('$+% &% (#+; 3./*7 8+ &8*+ (. &7.-(A &*,.%(
$,,+7$&(+*;A (#+ ,.%( &76&4)+7 (+)#4.*.>$+% &47 ,&)#$4+';A %J$--$4> & %/))+%%$.4.0 $4(+',+7$&(+ %(&>+% $4 (#+ -'.)+%% O"'.(%J;A WXX^\ eQ= "'.(%J;E% 0$'%( *&3 .0 (#+
#$%(.'$)&* -'.)+%%A /4+6+44+%%A )./*7 (#+4 0&)$*$(&(+ #$% %+).47 *&3A (#+ *&3 .0D).,8$4+7 7+6+*.-,+4(E=
:.,8$4+7 7+6+*.-,+4( .))/'% &% (#+ 8&)J3&'7 )/*(/'+ $%A D/47+' (#+ 3#$- .0+5(+'4&* 4+)+%%$(;EA $47/)+7 (.A D,&J+ *+&-%E O"'.(%J;A WXX^\ dQ= "#+ '+%/*(&4(
D).,8$4&($.4E .0 7$00+'+4( ,.,+4(% .0 7+6+*.-,+4(A *+&7% (. &A D7'&3$4>H(.>+(#+' .0
(#+ 7$00+'+4( %(&>+% .0 (#+ R./'4+;A & ).,8$4$4> .0 (#+ %+-&'&(+ %(+-%A &4 &,&*>&, .0&')#&$) 3$(# ,.'+ ).4(+,-.'&'; 0.',%E O"'.(%J;A WXX^\ dQ= Z. 0.' +5&,-*+A 3#$*%(
.4 (#+ .4+ #&47 3+ ,$>#( 0$47 $4 (#+ ,.%( &76&4)+7 )./4('; & 7/'&8*+ ).,8$4&($.4
.0 ).4(+,-.'&'; 0.',%V )&-$(&*$%( -'.7/)($.4 '+*&($.4% 3$(# & '+*&($6+*;
&/(.4.,./%A *$8+'&* %(&(+A 3+ ,$>#( 0$47 $4 & 8&)J3&'7 )./4(';A .4 (#+ .(#+' #&47A &
*+%% ).,-&($8*+ ).,8$4&($.4 8+(3++4 ).4(+,-.'&'; &47 ,.'+ &')#&$) %.)$&* 0.',%V+,+'>+4( )&-$(&*$%( %.)$&* '+*&($.4% &47 & 0.', .0 %(&(+ (#&( *+>$($,$Y+% 0+/7&*
#$+'&')#$+% '&(#+' (#&4 (#+ 4+3 )*&%% 0.')+% &%%.)$&(+7 3$(# )&-$(&*$%,=
8/17/2019 SGIR Uneven and Combined Development Paper
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sgir-uneven-and-combined-development-paper 9/29
I4+6+4 &47 ).,8$4+7 7+6+*.-,+4( (#+'+0.'+A +4&8*+% /% (. &))./4( 0.' (#+:56&$+%6:3:6A #) :56&$5+6:#5+9 7&3&9#E4&56H "#$% $4(+'&)($6$(; $% 8.(# E$#7-%&7 ,A &47
E$#7-%6:3& #) (#+ $4(+47+7 &47 /4$4(+47+7 +00+)(% .0 7+6+*.-,+4(&* %('&(+>$+% &47(#+$' ./().,+%= B+>&'7$4> )&-$(&*$%( 7+6+*.-,+4( (#+ %-+)$0$) D).,8$4&($.4E
+5-+'$+4)+7 $4 & >$6+4 %(&(+ &47 $(% '+*&($6+ 7+6+*.-,+4(&* *+6+* 3$** #&6+ &4 $,-&)(/-.4 &47 8+ $,-&)(+7 8; 0$'%(*;V (#+ 4+55&$ A &47 %+).47*;V (#+ #-6%#4&'A .0 (#+&((+,-( (. %+-&'&(+ (#+ D,+&4% .0 7.,$4&($.4E 0'., (#+ D,+&4% .0 &--'.-'$&($.4E &%
-&'( .0 (#+ ('&4%$($.4 0'., 0+/7&*$%, (. )&-$(&*$%,= 1$(# '+>&'7 (. (#+ 4+55&$ .0 (#+
%+-&'&($.4A 3+ ,/%( +5&,$4+V (#+ ($,+ 0'&,+ .0 $(% .))/''+4)+A (#+ +5(+'4&*-'+%%/'+% (#'./># 3#$)# $( $% ).4(+5(/&*$Y+7 O$=+= (. 3#&( +5(+4( $( $% & '+*&($6+*;
+47.>+4./% .' +5.>+4./% -'.)+%%QA (#+ %('&(+>$+% (#&( &'+ +,-*.;+7 O8.(# 8; (#.%+0.')+% 3#. &'+ %/--.'($6+ .0 (#+ -'.)+%% &47 (#.%+ 3#. &'+ '+%$%(&4(Q &47A )'/)$&**;A
(#+ 7+>'++ (. 3#$)# (#+ %(&(+ -*&;% & '.*+ &% (#+ &>+4( .0 ('&4%0.',&($.4= F4 (+',% .0
(#+ #-6%#4&' .0 (#+ %+-&'&($.4A 3+ ,/%( +5&,$4+V (#+ $4%($(/($.4&* 0.',% (#&( &'+'+%/*(&4(A (#+ J$47% .0 '+%$%(&4)+ (#&( &'+ +4)./4(+'+7 &47 (#+ %/))+%% .' 0&$*/'+ .0
)*&%%+% $4 +%(&8*$%#$4> (#+ %+-&'&($.4 .4 & %(&8*+ $4%($(/($.4&* 8&%$%=
"#$4J$4> $4 (#$% 3&; &**.3% /% (. >. 8+;.47 ).46+4($.4&* #$%(.'$.>'&-#;A 3#$)# #&%
8++4 #&,%('/4> 8; (#+ $4&8$*$(; (. +00+)($6+*; &'($)/*&(+ (#+ '+*&($.4%#$- 8+(3++4/4$6+'%&* &47 -&'($)/*&' &%-+)(% .0 7+6+*.-,+4(= Z)#.*&'% #&6+ (+47+7 +$(#+' (.
+5&>>+'&(+ -&'($)/*&'$(; &47 +5)+-($.4&*$%, 6$%HhH6$% >+4+'&* 7+6+*.-,+4(&*
./().,+% .' 6$)+ 6+'%&= <5+,-*&'; .0 (#$% -'.8*+, $% (#+ ?+',&4 DZ.47+'3+>E(#+%$%= Z.47+'3+> -'.-.4+4(% -.%$(+7 & D%-+)$&*EA 7+6$&4( )./'%+ 0.' ?+',&4
7+6+*.-,+4( (#&( 7$%($4>/$%#+7 $( 0'., (#+ 4.',&* </'.-+&4 +5-+'$+4)+A &))./4($4>0.' ?+',&4 8+**$).%$(; &47 (#+ '$%+ .0 0&%)$%, O@*&)J8/'4 P <*+;A 2T^e\ dH`Q= $5 "#+;
+''.4+./%*; &%%/,+7 (#+ +5$%(+4)+ .0 & D4.',&*E )./'%+ .0 7+6+*.-,+4( 3$(#$4
</'.-+A 0&$*$4> (. 4.(+ (#&( (#+ @'$($%# ,.7+* (&J+4 (. 8+ +5+,-*&'; .0 </'.-+&47+6+*.-,+4( 3&% +C/&**; 7$%($4)($6+ (. (#&( .0 ?+',&4; &47 8; 4. ,+&4% D(;-$)&*E=
_( (#+ .--.%$(+ +47 .0 (#+ %-+)('/, _'4. L&;+'E% O2T^2Q 3.'JA >+4+'&*$Y+% (#+
?+',&4 +5-+'$+4)+A $4(. & ).,,.4 </'.-+&4 -&((+'4= L&;+' *.)&(+% (#+ .'$>$4% .0112 3$(#$4 (#+ ('&4%H</'.-+&4 -+'%$%(+4)+ .0 '+&)($.4&'; &'$%(.)'&($) 0.')+%=
"#+%+ 0.')+% 3+'+ &8*+ (. ).,,&47 %(&(+ -.3+'A '+47+'$4> 0.'+$>4 -.*$); %+'6$*+ (.
(#+$' $7+.*.>; .0 Z.)$&* K&'3$4$%, &47 &>>'+%%$6+ B+&*-.*$($J O2T^2\ ^ P W``HW^WQ=L&;+'E% 8'.&7H8'/%# &4&*;%$% +5&>>+'&(+% (#+ /4$0.',$(; .0 </'.-+&4 7+6+*.-,+4(A
.6+'-*&;$4> (#+ -'$,&); .0 &'$%(.)'&($) -.3+' &47 .6+'*..J$4> (#+ )'/)$&* '.*+ (#&(
3.'J$4> )*&%% ,.6+,+4(% -*&;+7 $4 %#&-$4> (#+ 7$00+'+4( %('&(+>$+% .0 </'.-+&4+*$(+%=
M.**.3$4> L&;+'A Z&47'& G&*-+'$4 OWXXe\ FiHW]Q $7+4($0$+% (#+ -+'%$%(+4)+ .0
&'$%(.)'&($) -.3+' &)'.%% </'.-+ &% & J+; 0&)(.' $4 (#+ +%)&*&($.4 .0 $4(+'%(&(+'$6&*'$+%= B+>'+((&8*;A G&*-+'$4 4+>*+)(% $4(+>'&* 6&'$&($.4% '+*&($4> (. (#+
7+6+*.-,+4( .0 4&($.4&* +).4.,$+% &47 %.)$&* 0.')+%= G+' )*&$, (#&( 7$%($4)($.4%
8/17/2019 SGIR Uneven and Combined Development Paper
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sgir-uneven-and-combined-development-paper 10/29
8+(3++4 (#+ .'$+4(&($.4% &47 -'&)($)+% .0 </'.-+&4 3.'J$4> )*&%%+% 3+'+
+%%+4($&**; 4+>*$>$8*+ OG&*-+'$4A WXXe\ W]Q $% +5('+,+*; 7/8$./%A &% $% (#+ &%%+'($.4(#&( +*$(+ '+%-.4%+% (. 3.'J$4> )*&%% ,.8$*$Y&($.4 3+'+ -'&)($)&**;
$47$%($4>/$%#&8*+= g6+'&**A (#+ %;%(+,$) &'>/,+4(% -'.00+'+7 8; G&*-+'$4A L&;+' &47Z$*6+' &'+ 8*$47 (. (#+ J+; 7+6+*.-,+4(&* %-+)$0$)$($+% (#&( >&6+ '$%+ (. +6.*6$4>
-&((+'4% .0 $4(+'%(&(+ '+*&($.4%= F4 -.%$($4> & '+*&($6+*; /4$0.', ('&4%$($.4 0'.,0+/7&*$%, (. )&-$(&*$%, (#'./>#./( </'.-+A (#+; 4+>*+)( (#+ ).47$($.4$4> $,-+(/% .0IP:K=
IP:K &**.3% /% (. )./4(+' (#+ &0.'+,+4($.4+7 &4&*;($)&* %#.'().,$4>% 8;4+>.($&($4> & )./'%+ (#&( %$,/*(&4+./%*; ).4)+$6+% .0 8.(# (#+ -&'($)/*&' &47
/4$6+'%&* +*+,+4(% .0 </'.-+&4 )&-$(&*$%( 7+6+*.-,+4( 3$(#./( /47/*;%/8.'7$4&($4> .4+ &%-+)( (. (#+ .(#+'= "#+ -&'($)/*&' )./'%+ .0 ?+',&4
7+6+*.-,+4( 3&% ,./*7+7 8; (#+ ).47$($.4$4> 0.')+ 0$+*7 .0 :56&$5+6:#5+9
7&3&9#E4&56 &47 (#+ >'&7/&* /4$6+'%&*$Y&($.4 .0 )&-$(&*$%( %.)$&* '+*&($.4%(#'./>#./( </'.-+= "#+'+ 3&% 4. D(;-$)&*E 0.', .0 7+6+*.-,+4(A .4*; -&'($)/*&'
6&'$+($+% $4%)'$8+7 8; +4).,-&%%$4> $4(+'4&($.4&* -'+%%/'+% (#&( 3+'+ 4&($.4&**;7$00+'+4($&(+7 &)).'7$4> (. (#+ ).4(./'% .0 /4+6+44+%%= :.,-&'$4> @'$(&$4 &47?+',&4; 3$(#$4 (#+ ).4(+5( .0 IP:K +4&8*+% /% (. +5-*.'+ (#+ 7$00+'+4( 3&;% (#&(
(#+ +-.)#&* ('&4%$($.4 (. )&-$(&*$%, #&% /40.*7+7 3$(#$4 7$00+'+4( %(&(+%A (#+0/47&,+4(&* $4(+'&)($6$(; .0 (#+ &((+47&4( -'.)+%%+% &47 (#+$' $,-&)( /-.4 %.)$&*
'+*&($.4%A )*&%% -'&)($)+% &47 $4(+'4&($.4&* '+*&($.4%=
N6)* 7#0#6.)) 0) 7&6.,&*#"0&6> 7&60>F G6,0,;1 B&+)86 &"' G6,0,;1
-#$#.)/*#"0
F4 #$% *&47,&'J %(/7; .0 (#+ <4>*$%# 3.'J$4> )*&%%A <= a= "#.,-%.4 $7+4($0$+7 (#+-+'$.7 2`^XH2^]W &% (#+ >+4+'&($6+ +-.)# .0 (#+ $4)$-$+4( -'.*+(&'$&( O"#.,-%.4A
2TUe\ 22Q= "#+ 7+*$6+'; .0 (#$% 4+3 %.)$&* 0.')+ 3&% 4.( +&%;A $47++7 (#$% $47/%('$&*
)#$*7 +,+'>+7 J$)J$4> &47 %)'+&,$4> &0(+' & -&$40/* &47 7'&34 ./( -+'$.7 .0 *&8./'=B+-'+%%$.4 3&% (#+ $4%($4)($6+ '+%-.4%+ .0 (#+ @'$($%# %(&(+ (. (#+ +,+'>+4)+ .0 (#+
3.'J$4> )*&%%= B+%('$)($6+ :.,8$4&($.4 _)(% 3+'+ $,-.%+7 $4 .'7+' (. %($0*+ (#+-.*$($)&* (+47+4)$+% .0 (#+ 3.'J$4> )*&%%A &47 &( a+(+'*..A ,&%% .'>&4$Y&($.4 3&% ,+(
3$(# ,&%% %*&/>#(+' &% 8+**$>+'+4( &/(#.'$($+% (..J +5)+-($.4 (. (#+ -.*$($)&*
&%-$'&($.4% .0 (#+ ,.8 O"#.,%-.4A 2TUe\ U^eQ= F( 3&% & #$>#*; 6.*&($*+ ,.6+,+4(A $43#$)# -.*$($)&* 7$%&00+)($.4 &47 $47/%('$&* .'>&4$Y&($.4 3+'+ $4+5('$)&8*; *$4J+7=
@'$(&$4 3&% (#+ -$.4++'$4> $47/%('$&* %.)$+(;A $%.*&(+7 8; $(% &76&4)+,+4(A &% $( )&,+(. 7.,$4&(+ (#+ 3.'*7 ,&'J+( .4 (#+ 8&%$% .0 $47/%('$&* -'.7/)($.4= @'$($%# %.)$+(;A
('&4%0.',+7 8; (#+ $47/%('$&* '+6.*/($.4A +5#$8$(+7 %.,+ .0 (#+ ,.%( 7+-*.'&8*+*$6$4> ).47$($.4%A $4 (#+ %*/,% .0 (#+ 4+3 /'8&4 #+&'(*&47%A &47 %.,+ .0 (#+
%#&'-+%( $4+C/$($+% .0 3+&*(#A &% (#+ )&-(&$4% .0 $47/%('; &47 0$4&4)+ &))/,/*&(+7
,&%%$6+ 0.'(/4+% OG.8%8&3,A 2TUTV j+,-A 2T^dQ= "#+ $7+&* ).47$($.4% 0.' & '&7$)&*'+6.*/($.4&'; 3.'J$4> )*&%% ,.6+,+4( &--+&'+7 (. 8+ .4 +6$7+4)+ $4 & %.)$+(; (#&(
3&% %#&'-*; -.*&'$Y+7 8; (#+ 0$'%( #&*0 .0 (#+ 9$4+(++4(# :+4(/';=
8/17/2019 SGIR Uneven and Combined Development Paper
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sgir-uneven-and-combined-development-paper 11/29
[+( 7+%-$(+ (#+ &--&'+4( '$-+4+%% .0 %.)$&* ).47$($.4%A 8.(# (#+ '+6.*/($.4&'; (#'+&(.0 (#+ @'$($%# 3.'J$4> )*&%%A &47 (#+ ,.'+ +5('+,+ ,+&%/'+% .0 %(&(+ '+-'+%%$.4A
#&7 -&%%+7 8; 2^dX 3$(# (#+ 7+0+&( .0 (#+ :#&'($%( ,.6+,+4(= @; (#+ *&%( (#$'7 .0(#+ 9$4+(++4(# :+4(/';A (#+ @'$($%# *&8./' ,.6+,+4( #&7 8+).,+ (#.'./>#*;
'+0.',$%( $4 $(% ./(*..JA &47 +).4.,$%($) $4 $(% -'$.'$($+%= I4$.4$Y+7 +*+,+4(% .0 (#+3.'J$4> )*&%% #&7 &7.-(+7 & '+0.',$%( %('&(+>; .0 D*&8./'$%,E (#&(A D'+).>4$Y+7 (#+-.%%$8$*$($+% .0 %.)$&* )#&4>+ 3$(#$4 +5$%($4> %.)$+(;E OZ&6$**+A 2T^^\ 2eQ=
g4 (#+ ).4($4+4(A ).4('&%($4>*;A (#+ ?+',&4 ZaK #&7 %-&'J+7 & -'.)+%% .0'&7$)&*$Y&($.4 +,8.7$+7 8; $(% *+&7+'%#$- .0 (#+ Z+).47 F4(+'4&($.4&* OS.**A 2T`eV
Z&%%..4A 2TT`QA &47 8.'4 ./( $4 (#+ +*+)(.'&* %/))+%%+% .0 %.)$&*$%( -&'($+% OZ&%%..4A2TT`Q= @'$($%# *&8./' 8/)J+7 (#+ </'.-+&4 ('+47 3$(# $(% &6+'%$.4 (. %.)$&*$%,=
F4%(+&7 (#+; 0&6./'+7 '+0.',$%, &47 3#+4 & -+',&4+4( -.*$($)&* +5-'+%%$.4 0.'
3.'J$4> )*&%% $4(+'+%(% 0$4&**; 7$7 &''$6+ *&(+ .4(. (#+ </'.-+&4 %)+4+A 3$(# (#+0.',&($.4 .0 (#+ N&8./' -&'(; $4 2TXU OZ&6$**+A 2T^^V G/4(A 2T^2V L)j$88$4A 2T^eQA
$( .-+'&(+7 %('$)(*; 3$(#$4 (#+ (3$4 *$,$(% .0 -&'*$&,+4(&'; -+'$,+(+'% &47-$+)+,+&* -'$.'$($+%= "#+ J+; C/+%($.4 (#&( 3+ ,/%( $4(+''.>&(+ (#+'+0.'+ $%V 3#;(#+ @'$($%# 3.'J$4> )*&%%A (#+ 0$'%( &47 *&'>+%( .0 $(% J$47A +5#$8$(+7 %/)# ,&'J+7*;
'+0.',$%( &47 &)).,,.7&($4> (+47+4)$+% 3#+4 ).,-&'+7 (. ?+',&4;f
N+( /% 8+>$4 3$(# (#+ 4+55&$ $4 3#$)# (#+ +-.)#&* %+-&'&($.4 .0 (#+ D-.*$($)&*E 0'.,
(#+ D+).4.,$)E /40.*7+7 $4 @'$(&$4= @'$(&$4 +5-+'$+4)+7 &4 +&'*; &47 +47.>+4./%('&4%$($.4 (. )&-$(&*$%( %.)$&* '+*&($.4% 8+>$44$4> $4 (#+ <&'*; L.7+'4 -+'$.7= "#+
>'&7/&* -'.>'+%%$.4 .0 *&47 +4)*.%/'+ &47 (#+ +'.%$.4 .0 )/%(.,&'; '$>#(% (. *&47/%+ .6+' (#+ -'+)+7$4> )+4(/'$+% #&7 8'./>#( &8./( (#+ ).4%.*$7&($.4 .0 +5)*/%$6+
-'$6&(+ -'.-+'(; &47 (#+ +,+'>+4)+ .0 &>'&'$&4 )&-$(&*$%, O1..7A WXXW\ T`V
@'+44+'A 2T^d\ WT^HTQ= "#+ *&47*.'7 )*&%%A 3$(# (#+$' $4).,+% 7+'$6+7 0'.,)&-$(&*$%( 0&',+'%A +%(&8*$%#+7 (#+$' -.*$($)&* -'+7.,$4&4)+ (#'./># (#+ +5(+4%$.4 .0
-&'*$&,+4(&'; -.3+' &47 )/'8+7 (#+ 7.,&$4 .0 ,.4&')#$)&* &/(#.'$(; (#'./># (#+
?*.'$./% B+6.*/($.4 .0 2U^^= "#+$' ,+&4% .0 3+&*(# &))/,/*&($.4 3+'+ 4.3$47+-+47+4( .0 (#+ 7$'+)( -.*$($)&* -.3+' .0 (#+ %(&(+ &47 $(% ,$*$(&'; &--&'&(/%A
'+%($4> $4%(+&7 /-.4 (#+ 9&@+9 @-+$+56&& #) E$:3+6& E$#E&$6A = "#+ +,+'>+4)+ .0&>'&'$&4 )&-$(&*$%, $4 <4>*&47 #&7 #+'&*7+7A D(#+ +47 .0 (#+ &>+H.*7 b0/%$.4c .0 (#+
b+).4.,$)c &47 (#+ b-.*$($)&*cA &47 (#+ $4$($&* +,+'>+4)+ .0 &4 $4%($(/($.4&*
%+-&'&($.4 8+(3++4 %(&(+ &47 )$6$* %.)$+(;E O@'+44+'A 2T^d\ WTTQ= "#$% ,&'J+7 ./( &7:'6:5%6:3&9A C$:6:'B E+6B #) '#%:#I&%#5#4:% 7&3&9#E4&56 $4 %(&'J ).4('&%( (. (#+
-&((+'4% .0 _8%.*/($%( ,.4&')#; &47 0+/7&* %.)$+(; +6$7+4)+7 %#56:5&56+99AH
@/$*7$4> /-.4 (#+ -'$.' &>'&'$&4 ('&4%0.',&($.4A @'$($%# $47/%('$&* 7+6+*.-,+4(
.))/''+7 $4 & 7$%($4)(*; &57#@&5#-' ,&44+'A 3$(#./( (#+ $4(+4%+ -'+%%/'+% .0 3.'*7,&'J+( ).,-+($($.4 +5-+'$+4)+7 8; *&(+ $47/%('$&*$Y$4> %.)$+($+% Oj+,-A 2T^eV
G.8%8&3,A 2TU`Q= K/'$4> (#+ 2^(# :+4(/'; @'$(&$4 /($*$Y+7 4&6&* %/-'+,&); (.
)&-(/'+ &47 ,.4.-.*$Y+ (#+ +5-.'( ,&'J+(% .0 .(#+' )./4('$+%A 7+%('.;$4> 0.'+$>4).,-+($($.4 $4 (#+ -'.)+%% (#'./># 3&' &47 ).*.4$Y&($.4 OG.8%8&3,A 2TU`\ e^Q=
"#'./># (#$% -'.)+%% $( )&,+ (. ).4%($(/(+ &47 7.,$4&(+ & 3.'*7 ,&'J+( 0.' >..7%=
8/17/2019 SGIR Uneven and Combined Development Paper
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sgir-uneven-and-combined-development-paper 12/29
"#+ &)#$+6+,+4( .0 3.'*7 ,&'J+( 7.,$4&4)+A &( & 6+'; +&'*; %(&>+ .0 $47/%('$&*
7+6+*.-,+4(A 3&% (. ).)..4 @'$(&$4 0'., %+'$./% ).,-+($($6+ -'+%%/'+ /4($* (#+ *&%(C/&'(+' .0 (#+ 9$4+(++4(# :+4(/';= a'$.' (. 112A (#+ -'.7/)($6+ %('/)(/'+% .0 (#+
@'$($%# +).4.,; 3+'+ J++4*; &00+)(+7 8; (#+$' '+*&($6+ +5+,-($.4 0'., $4(+'4&($.4&*).,-+($($.4=5 @; %#+*(+'$4> @'$($%# 0$',% 0'., (#+ 4++7 (. ,.7+'4$Y+A (#+ $4%/*&(+7
-'$6$*+>+ .0 (#+ -$.4++' %/8%+C/+4(*; )&,+ (. %+'6+ &% & 7+8$*$(&($.4 $4 (#+ 0&)+ .0,.'+ 7;4&,$) $47/%('$&* ).,-+($(.'% *+&7$4> (#+ %+).47 F47/%('$&* B+6.*/($.4=
Z(&(+ $46.*6+,+4( $4 %(++'$4> +).4.,$) >'.3(# 3&%A &47 '+,&$4+7A 9:4:6&7 $4 @'$(&$4
Oj+,-A 2T^e\2`V G&'6++A 2TTT\ e^2Q= :&-$(&*$%( +4('+-'+4+/'%A 0$4&4)+7$47+-+47+4(*; .0 (#+ %(&(+H'/4 8&4J% (;-$)&* .0 ).4($4+4(&* 7+6+*.-,+4(A ).47/)(+7
(#+$' 8/%$4+%% 3$(# %)&4( %(&(+ &%%$%(&4)+= _*(#./># (#+ F47/%('$&* B+6.*/($.48'./>#( &8./( +4.',./% )#&4>+% $4 (+',% .0 /'8&4$Y&($.4A -'.7/)($.4 (+)#4$C/+%
&47 .(#+' 0&)+(% .0 %.)$&* *$0+A $( 4+6+'(#+*+%% .))/''+7 3$(#$4 &4 +5$%(+4( 0'&,+ .0
)&-$(&*$%( %.)$&* -'.-+'(; '+*&($.4% Oj+,-A 2T^eV G.8%8&3,A 2TU`V :&$4 P G.-J$4%A2TT]Q (#&( -'+7&(+7 (#+ 7+6+*.-,+4( .0 $47/%('$&*$Y&($.4A *$,$($4> (#+ 7+>'++ .0
'/-(/'+ 8+(3++4 (#+ .*7 &47 (#+ 4+3= :#&4>+ .))/''+7 3$(#$4 (#+ *$,$(% .00/47&,+4(&* ).4($4/$(;=
"#+ 4+55&$ .0 (#+ ('&4%$($.4 0'., 0+/7&*$%, (. )&-$(&*$%, $4 @'$(&$4 #&7 -&'($)/*&'$,-&)(% /-.4 7+6+*.-,+4(&* #-6%#4&'= "#./># -&'*$&,+4(&'; %/-'+,&); 3&% 8;
4. ,+&4% %;4.4;,./% 3$(# 7+,.)'&);A $( '+47+'+7 (#+ %(&(+ 6$%$8*+A &( *+&%(
%;,8.*$)&**;A &% (#+ D-/8*$) (#$4>E= "#+ %/8.'7$4&(+ )*&%%+% 7$7 4.( 6$+3 (#+ %(&(+ &%,+'+*; & -'$6&(+ $4%('/,+4( .0 0+/7&* 7.,$4&($.4A 8/( '&(#+' &4 &'+4& .0 -.*$($)&*
).4(+%(&($.4 8+(3++4 '+-'+%+4(&($6+%V $4 (#$% %+4%+ $( #&7 & 7$%($4)($6+*; 4#7&$5
0.',=5$
N&8./' %('/>>*+% $4 @'$(&$4 3+'+ )#&'&)(+'$Y+7 8; & 0/47&,+4(&* '+%-+)( 0.').4%($(/($.4&* -&'&,+(+'% OG&'6++A 2TTTQ= a&'*$&,+4(E% 0/4)($.4 &% (#+ )+4('+ .0
-.*$($)&* -.3+' +4&8*+7 (#+ '/*$4> )*&%% (. +5#$8$( & 7+>'++ .0 0*+5$8$*$(; &47
&7&-(&8$*$(; (#&( 3&% /4&6&$*&8*+ (. ).4($4+4(&* _8%.*/($%,= B+-+&(+7*;A-&'*$&,+4(&'; '+0.', (..J (#+ %($4> ./( .0 3.'J$4> )*&%% '&7$)&*$%, 3$(# (#+ %+'$+%
.0 B+0.', _)(% -&%%+7 (#'./>#./( (#+ 9$4+(++4(# :+4(/'; OL&)B&$*7 P L&'($4AWXXXQ= "#+%+ B+0.', _)(% '+0*+)(+7 (#+ &7&-(&8$*$(; .0 (#+ @'$($%# %;%(+, OK&/4(.4A
WXXX\ T]Q= "#+ $,-&)( .0 (#$% )./'%+ .0 7+6+*.-,+4( /-.4 '+%$%(&4)+ %('&(+>$+% 3&%
%/)# (#&( 8; (#+ ,$7H9$4+(++4(# :+4(/';A (#+ 3.'J$4> )*&%% 6$+3+7 (#+ %(&(+ &% &5&-6$+9 :5'6:6-6:#5A & %$(/&($.4 (#&( 3&% /4$,&>$4&8*+ $4 ?+',&4; Oa'$)+A 2TTXV
Z&6$**+A 2T^^Q=
B+>&'7$4> (#+ E#9:6:%+9 '6$+6&@:&' .0 (#+ 7.,$4&4( %.)$&* )*&%%+%A (#+ &8%+4)+ .0 &
-.*$($)&**; ).#+%$6+ 8./'>+.$%$+ $4 @'$(&$4A +4%/'+7 (#&( %+)/'$4> (#+ %/--.'( .0 (#+3.'J$4> )*&%% 8+)&,+ $,-.'(&4( 0.' +%(&8*$%#$4> -.*$($)&* 7.,$4&4)+ $4 -&'*$&,+4(
&47 $40*/+4)$4> -.*$);= g0 (#+ (3. '+*&($6+*; 4+3 %./')+% .0 3+&*(# )'+&($.4 $4
@'$(&$4A 0$4&4)+ &47 $47/%(';A $( 3&% 0$4&4)$&* &))/,/*&($.4 (#&( 3&% ,.%( '+&7$*;&))+-(+7 $4(. (#+ 4.',&($6+ &47 -.*$($)&* 0'&,+3.'J .0 (#+ &'$%(.)'&($) *&47H.34$4>
+*$(+A 3#$*%( $47/%('$&* &47 ,&4/0&)(/'$4> )&-$(&*$%(% 3+'+ +5)*/7+7 O:&$4 P
8/17/2019 SGIR Uneven and Combined Development Paper
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sgir-uneven-and-combined-development-paper 13/29
G.-J$4%A 2TT]Q= @'$(&$4E% 7$6$7+7 8./'>+.$%$+ 3&% & ).4%+C/+4)+ .0 #+' %-+)$0$)
7+6+*.-,+4(&* ('&R+)(.';V )#&'&)(+'$Y+7 8; (#+ ).$4)$7+4)+ .0 $47/%('$&*7+6+*.-,+4( 3$(# & -'+H+5$%($4> )*&%% .0 ,+')&4($*+ 0$4&4)$+'% 8&%+7 $4 (#+ :$(;A
3#.%+ %./')+% .0 3+&*(# 3+'+ *&'>+*; $47+-+47+4( 0'., (#.%+ .0 (#+ $47/%('$&*$%(%OF4>#&,A 2T^e\ e]Q=
?&'4+'$4> 3.'J$4> )*&%% %/--.'( 8+)&,+ $4)'+&%$4>*; $,-.'(&4( &% (#+ 0'&4)#$%+3&% +5(+47+7 &47 $47/%('$&* &'+&% &)#$+6+7 -&'*$&,+4(&'; '+-'+%+4(&($.4= a+'$.7%
.0 3.'J$4> )*&%% &>$(&($.4 3+'+ .0(+4 ,+( 8; &)(% .0 '+).4)$*$&($.4 8; (#+ ,$77*+
)*&%%= _0(+' 2^e^ (#+ ,$77*+ )*&%% $4(+'6+4+7 0&' ,.'+ 3$7+*; &47 -.%$($6+*; $43.'J$4> )*&%% *+$%/'+ &)($6$(; O[+.A 2T^2\ 2`dHUQ= B/*$4> )*&%% -.3+' 3&% 8&%+7
/-.4 & $&9-%6+56 8/( $4)'+&%$4>*; %/8%(&4($6+ :5%9-':#5 .0 *&8./' 3$(#$4 (#+ -.*$($)&*-'.)+%%=5$$ F4).'-.'&($.4 3&% ,&7+ -.%%$8*+ $4 -&'( 8; (#+ %*.3+' '#;(#, .0
)&-$(&*$%( 7+6+*.-,+4( $4 @'$(&$4A 3#$)# -'.6$7+7 & ,.'+ >+',&4+ ).4(+5( 0.' (#+
-$+)+,+&* &)).,,.7&($.4 .0 +,+'>$4> %.)$&* 0.')+%= 1$(#./( &)/(+ $4(+'4&($.4&*-'+%%/'+% >+4+'&(+7 8; '+*&($6+ 8&)J3&'74+%% (#+ '+C/$'+,+4( 0.' & '.8/%( %(&(+H
*+7 7+6+*.-,+4(&* %('&(+>; 3&% .86$&(+7A &47 & *+%% &8'&%$6+ D4$>#(H3&()#,&4E-.%(/'+ 3&% +4&8*+7=
K$6$%$.4% 3$(#$4 (#+ 7.,$4&4( )*&%%+% +4%/'+7 (#&( @'$($%# *$8+'&*$%, 3&%
7$%($4)($6+*; .-+4 (.A &47 $4)*/%$6+ .0A (#+ 3.'J$4> )*&%%= "#$% &))./4(% 0.' (#+
-'+-.47+'&4)+ .0 *$8+'&* ('&7+ /4$.4 *+&7+'%A (#+ ).4($4/$(; .0 3.'J$4> )*&%%8&)J$4> 0.' (#+ N$8+'&* a&'(;A &47 (#+ 3+&J4+%% .0 %.)$&*$%( '&7$)&*$%, Ok.**8+'>A
2T^UV a'$)+A 2T^UV L&((#+3V 2TTTQ= <&'*; )&47$7&(+% .0 (#+ F47+-+47+4( N&8./'a&'(; +4R.;+7 ,$4$,&* +*+)(.'&* %/))+%%= "#+ 7$%($4)($.4 8+(3++4 +).4.,$)
'+*&($.4% &47 -.*$($)&* &00&$'% 3&% /-#+*7 &47 '+$40.')+7 8; (#+ ('&7+ /4$.4%= "#+
&7#+'+4)+ (. *$8+'&*$%, '+0*+)(+7 (#+ 7+>'++ .0 $4%($(/($.4&* %+-&'&($.4 8+(3++43#&( 3+'+ ).4%$7+'+7 D+).4.,$)E &47 D-.*$($)&*E $%%/+% $4 @'$($%# %.)$+(;= K+%-$(+ (#+
+&'*; '&7$)&*$%, .0 (#+ 3.'J$4> )*&%%+%A $4 (#+ *.4> '/4 (#+ -'.8*+, .0 %+-&'&($4>
./( (#+ D,+&4% .0 7.,$4&($.4E 0'., (#+ D,+&4% .0 &--'.-'$&($.4E 3&% '+%.*6+7%/))+%%0/**; $4 @'$(&$4= @; (#+ *&(+ 2T(# :+4(/'; (#+ 4+3 0.', .0 %.)$&* .'>&4$Y&($.4
3&% $4%($(/($.4&**; +,8+77+7 &47 %.)$&**; &))+-(+7=5$$$
F4 %/,A 0'., (#+ *&(+ 2^eXE% .4A & '+*&($6+*; 'A5%B$#5#-' -'.)+%% .0 %(&(+
7+,.)'&($Y&($.4 &47 *&8./' 7.,+%($)&($.4 +,+'>+7 (#&( 3&% & ).4%+C/+4)+ .0@'$(&$4E% 7$%($4)($6+ 7+6+*.-,+4( &47 (#+ $4%/*&($.4 &((+47&4( (. $(% %(&(/% &% (#+
0$'%( $47/%('$&*$Y+7 )./4(';= "#+ 3#$- .0 +5(+'4&* 4+)+%%$(; 7$7 4.( 8*..7; (#+ 8&)J
.0 (#+ @'$($%# %(&(+ (#+'+0.'+A &% $( 3&% _*8$.4 3#. 8'&47$%#+7 (#+ 3#$- &*.0(=@'$(&$4E% %(+&7; &47 +&'*; ('&4%$($.4 (. )&-$(&*$%,A &*.4> 3$(# (#+ -'$.'$(; .0
-&'*$&,+4(&'; '/*+A +4&8*+7 & >'&7/&* +6.*/($.4 .0 (#+ %(&(+ &47 *&8./' $4 '+%-.4%+(. %-.'&7$) )*&%% ).40*$)(=
K1# 56)?,"3 7&,"; )I 5#6*&" -#$#.)/*#"0F 2 O);0,.# @0&0# &"' E&',<&.
B&+)86
8/17/2019 SGIR Uneven and Combined Development Paper
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sgir-uneven-and-combined-development-paper 14/29
F4 +&'*; 9$4+(++4(# :+4(/'; ?+',&4;A /4*$J+ @'$(&$4A (#+'+ +5$%(+7 4. '+&* 3.'J$4>)*&%% (. %-+&J .0=5$6 "#+ +,8+'% .0 0+/7&*$%, 3+'+ %($** 8/'4$4> 8'$>#(*; &47 &4;
.8%+'6&8*+ &%-+)(% .0 3&>+ *&8./' 3+'+ +,8+77+7 3$(#$4 6&'$./% -'+H)&-$(&*$%(%.)$&* %('/)(/'+% &47 -'&)($)+% Oj.)J&A 2T^U\ W^`Q= [+( 7+%-$(+ (#+ &8%+4)+ .0 &4
.'>&4$Y+7 3.'J$4> )*&%% ,.6+,+4( 8+0.'+ (#+ 2^dXE%A 8; (#+ +6+ .0 112 (#+?+',&4 *&8./' ,.6+,+4( #&7 >$6+4 '$%+ (. (#+ *&'>+%( &47 ,.%( '&7$)&* ,&%%-.*$($)&* -&'(; $4 </'.-+V (#+ Z.)$&* K+,.)'&($) a&'(; DZaKE=56 F( #&7 &)#$+6+7 (#$%
4.( (#'./># (#+ +%-./%&* .0 *$8+'&* '+0.',$%,A 8/( '&(#+' (#'./># (#+ 3$7+%-'+&7
&7.-($.4 .0 L&'5$%( $7+&% (#&( 3+'+ +5-*$)$(*; #.%($*+ (. %(&(+ -.3+' &47 -'$6&(+-'.-+'(;= G.3 7$7 (#+ *&8./' ,.6+,+4(% $4 @'$(&$4 &47 ?+',&4; +5-+'$+4)+ %/)# &
*&'>+ 7$6+'>+4)+f
"#+ 4+55&$ .0 )&-$(&*$%( ('&4%$($.4 $4 ?+',&4; %(&47% $4 ,&'J+7 ).4('&%( (. (#+
@'$($%# +5-+'$+4)+= M'., (#+ ./(%+(A (#+ ?+',&4 %(&(+A -'.,-(+7 8; (#+ -'+%%/'+% .0+).4.,$) 8&)J3&'74+%%A -*&;+7 &4 +%6:3& '.*+ $4 -/%#$4> (#'./># (#+ '+0.',% &47
*+>&* )#&4>+% 4+)+%%&'; (. *&; (#+ >'./473.'J 0.' )&-$(&*$%( 7+6+*.-,+4( Oj.)J&A2T^U\ WT2V @*&)J8/'4A 2T^eQ= _>'&'$&4 B+0.',% &0(+' 2^X` +%(&8*$%#+7 (#+0'&,+3.'J 0.' (#+ &76&4)+,+4( .0 &>'&'$&4 )&-$(&*$%,= "#+ ('&4%$($.4 3&%
/47+'(&J+4 $4 & 3&; (#&( ,$4$,$Y+7 (#+ #&'7%#$- 0.' (#+ *&47.34+'%V (#+ S/4J+'%3+'+ &8*+ (. /($*$Y+ (#+$' -'$6$*+>+7 %(&(/% (. ,&$4(&$4 -'+7.,$4&4)+ 3$(#$4 %.)$+(;
&47 (.A D8.;).(( '+0.',% .0 (#+ %(&(+E% -.*$($)&* ).4%($(/($.4 &*,.%( +4($'+*;E
OZ)#$%%*+'A 2TT2\ 2XUQ=56$ "#+ %(&(+ -*&;+7 & %$,$*&'*; -'.&)($6+ 0/4)($.4 3$(# '+>&'7(. $47/%('$&* 7+6+*.-,+4( Oj+,-A 2T^e\ TXQA 3#$)# '+&**; >&(#+'+7 -&)+ 0'., (#+
,$7H9$4+(++4(# :+4(/'; .43&'7% O1+#*+'A 2TU`V j.)J&A 2T^UV 9.*&4A 2T^UQ= Z(&(+'+%./')+% 3+'+ +,-*.;+7 (. 0./47 *&'>+ 8&4J% (#&( -'.6$7+7 0$4&4)$&* %/--.'( (.
$47/%(';=
_ %;,-(., .0 $4(+'4&($.4&* /4+6+44+%%A (#+ 7+%$'+ (. )&()#H/- 3$(# @'$(&$4E% ,.'+
&76&4)+7 +).4.,; /47+' (#+ -'+%%/'+% .0 &4 &*'+&7; +5$%($4> 3.'*7 ,&'J+( &47 (#+
$4(+'H%(&(+ '$6&*'$+% .0 )+4('&* </'.-+A &77+7 /'>+4); (. (#+ &((+,-(% .0 %(&(+,&4&>+'% (. #&%(+4 (#+ -'.)+%% .0 ('&4%0.',&($.4= "#+ $+E:7:6A .0 (#+ ('&4%$($.4 $4
?+',&4; 3&% C/$(+ &3+%.,+V (#+ +).4.,; 3&% ('&4%0.',+7 0'., & *&'>+*;&>'&'$&4A 0+/7&* 8&%$% $4 (#+ 0$'%( #&*0 .0 (#+ 9$4+(++4(# :+4(/'; Oj.)J&A 2T^U\ W^]QA
(. (#+ ,.%( ,.7+'4 $47/%('$&* +).4.,; $4 (#+ 3.'*7 &% (#+ %&,+ )+4(/'; 7'+3 (. &
)*.%+=56$$ <&'*$+' @'$($%# 7+6+*.-,+4( #&7 )'+&(+7 & ,&'J+( 0.' ?+',&4 >..7% &47#&7 *+7 @'$($%# )&-$(&* (. -./' $4(. ?+',&4;A %($,/*&($4> &4 $4(+'+%( (. /%+ 4+3
(+)#4.*.>; &47 %-/''$4> '&-$7 $47/%('$&* 7+6+*.-,+4( $4 -$.4++'$4> %+)(.'% %/)# &%
)#+,$)&* -'.7/)($.4 Oj+,-A 2T^d\ T2Q=
<).4.,$) ('&4%0.',&($.4 3&% 0'&,+7 3$(#$4 (#+ %#56&D6 #) 6&$$:6#$:+9 +57 E#9:6:%+9
%#5'#9:7+6:#5V ?+',&4 *&(+ 7+6+*.-,+4( 3&% $4%)'$8+7 4.( .4*; 3$(# &))+*+'&(+7
+).4.,$) ('&4%$($.4 (#+'+0.'+A 8/( &*%. 3$(# & /4$C/+*; %$,/*(&4+./% %.6+'+$>4
).4%.*$7&($.4= @.(# -'.)+%%+% 3+'+ '+%-.4%+% (. (#+ -'+%%/'+% .0 </'.-+&4/4+6+44+%%A 3#$)# 3+'+ ,&4$0+%(+7 $4 (#+ 4++7 (. +4#&4)+ +).4.,$)A -.*$($)&* &47
,$*$(&'; -.3+' $4 .'7+' (. '+(&$4 ?+',&4;E% '+*&($6+ $4(+'4&($.4&* %(&47$4>=
8/17/2019 SGIR Uneven and Combined Development Paper
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sgir-uneven-and-combined-development-paper 15/29
9&($.4&* I4$0$)&($.4 .))/''+7 $4 2^`2A /47+' (#+ 7$'+)($.4 .0 (#+ a'/%%$&4 %(&(+A
3#$)# '+(&$4+7 & %-+)$&* -.%$($.4 3$(#$4 (#+ <,-$'+ O1+#*+'A 2TU`\ deQ=:.4%+C/+4(*;A (#+ .6+'&** ).4%($(/($.4&* %('/)(/'+ .0 F,-+'$&* ?+',&4; 3&%
7+)$7+7*; &/(#.'$(&'$&4 O9.*&4A 2T^UV Z)#.'%J+A 2T^]V j+,-A 2T^eQ= _*(#./>#/4$6+'%&* ,&*+ %/00'&>+ 3&% $4('.7/)+7 $4 2^U`A $( #&7 *$((*+ -'&)($)&* +00+)( &% (#+
-&'*$&,+4( )./*7 8+ 7$%%.*6+7 &( 3$** 8; 8.(# (#+ <,-+'.' &47 M+7+'&* :./4)$*V'+47+'$4> $( +%%+4($&**; $,-.(+4( O9.*&4A 2T^U\ ]dTV 9.*&4A 2T^2V j.)J&A 2T^U\WT2Q=
"#+ &-+5 .0 (#+ F,-+'$&* %(&(+ ).4%$%(+7 $4 &4 /4%(&8*+ /4$(; 8+(3++4 (#+&'$%(.)'&($) S/4J+'% &47 (#+ &%)+47&4( $47/%('$&*$%(%= "#+%+ >'./-% -/'%/+7
7$00+'+4( &47 &( ($,+% ).40*$)($4> E#9:6:%+9 '6$+6&@:&'J
3$(# '+>&'7 (. %+)/'$4> (#+$'-.3+' 3$(#$4 (#+ +,+'>+4( )&-$(&*$%( +).4.,;= "#+ S/4J+'E% &))+-(+7 (#+
(+',$4&($.4 .0 (#+$' *+>&* '$>#(% .6+' (#+ -+&%&4(';A 8/( .4*; $4 '+(/'4 0.' -'$6$*+>+7
&))+%% (.A &47 ).,-.%$($.4 .0A %(&(+ $4%($(/($.4% ON$7(J+A 2TUU\ eV Z)#$%%*+'A 2TT2Q=56$$$ "#+ $4(+'4&* /4+6+44+%% .0 ?+',&4 7+6+*.-,+4( ,+&4( (#&( (#+$' '/'&* -.3+'A
8&%+7 $4 *&47 .34+'%#$-A 3&% 8/(('+%%+7 8; -.-/*&' -+&%&4( %/--.'(=
"#+ >'.3$4> 3+&*(# &47 -.3+' .0 (#+ $47/%('$&* 8./'>+.$%$+ (#'+&(+4+7 (#+('&7$($.4&* 7.,$4&4)+ .0 (#+ &>'&'$&4 S/4J+'%= "#+%+ )*&%%+% 3+'+A #.3+6+'A &8*+ (.
0$47 ).,,.4 )&/%+ $4 (#+$' %(&/4)# .--.%$($.4 (. (#+ ZaK &47 $4 %/--.'( .0
-'.(+)($.4$%, 0'., (#+ *&(+ 2^`XE%= "#'./>#./( (#+ 2^dXE%lUXE%A (#+ S/4J+'% #&7-'.0$(+7 +4.',./%*; (#'./># 0'++ ('&7+ 3$(# @'$(&$4= 1$(# $4)'+&%+7 ).,-+($($.4
0'., (#+ IZ_ &47 :&4&7&A (#+; %3$()#+7 (. a'.(+)($.4$%, 7/'$4> (#+ 2^`XE% &47%/))+%%0/**; +,-*.;+7 %(&(+ -.3+' (. -/'%/+ (#+$' $4(+'+%(% &( >'+&( ).%( (. (#+ '+%(
.0 %.)$+(; OZ)#$%%*+'A 2TT2\ 2XUQ= "#$% %#$0( 8'./>#( (#+$' $4(+'+%(% $4(. *$4+ 3$(# (#+
)&-(&$4% .0 ?+',&4 $47/%(';A 3#. &*%. %./>#( -'.(+)($.4 0'., (#+ %(&(+ 7/'$4> (#+K+-'+%%$.4 +'&= "#+ -+($(H8./'>+.$%$+ &47 /'8&4 ,$77*+ )*&%%+%A #&6$4> 0&$*+7 (.
&)#$+6+ & *$8+'&* '+6.*/($.4 $4 2^e^A ).4%$>4+7 (#+,%+*6+% (. & '+*/)(&4( &))+-(&4)+
.0 &'$%(.)'&($) -'$6$*+>+= "#+; 7$7 %. /47+' (#+ 8&'>&$4 (#&( (#+ %(&(+ 3./*7 %+)/'+(#+$' -'.-+'(; '$>#(% &47 ,&$4(&$4 &4 +%6:3& '6+5%& #) $&E$&'':#5 (.3&'7% (#+
3.'J$4> )*&%%= "#+ %(&(+ &8*; /-#+*7 $(E% %$7+ .0 (#+ 8&'>&$4 (#'./>#./( (#+9$4+(++4(# &47 +&'*; "3+4($+(# :+4(/'$+%=5$5
1#&( (#+4A 3+'+ (#+ #-6%#4&' .0 (#$% )./'%+ .0 7+6+*.-,+4( 3$(#$4 ?+',&4;f "#+/4$.4 8+(3++4 8&4J$4> &47 $47/%('$&* )&-$(&* &47 (#+ /4+&%; &**$&4)+ 0.'>+7 3$(#
S/4J+' ).4%+'6&($%,A -'+%+4(+7 &4 #3&$FB&94:5@9A B#'6:9& '6+6& (#&( 8.'+ 7.34
/-.4 (#+ 3.'J$4> )*&%% 3$(# +4.',./% '+-'+%%$6+ 3+$>#(A %+'6$4> (. $+7:%+9:;& (#+*&8./' ,.6+,+4(= Z(&(+ '+-'+%%$.4 &*$+4&(+7 (#+ 3.'J$4> )*&%% 0'., (#+ %(&(+A
)'+&($4> &4 +&'*; '/-(/'+ 8+(3++4 (#+ %(&(+ &47 (#+ *&8./' ,.6+,+4( (#&( )&%( (#+'+*&($.4%#$- $4 %('$)(*; .--.%$($.4&* (+',% Oj&(Y4+*%.4A 2T^U\ W`V <6&4%A 2T^`\ W22V
N$7(J+A 2TUU\ 2]Q= _% & ).4%+C/+4)+A ?+',&4 3.'J+'E% %('/>>*+% 3+'+A 0'., (#+
6+'; 8+>$44$4>A +5-*$)$(*; -.*$($)&* $4 (#&( '&(#+' (#&4 0.)/%$4> -'$,&'$*; /-.4D$47/%('$&*E .' D+).4.,$)E >'$+6&4)+% %/)# &% 3&>+ *+6+*%A (#+; 3+'+A 8; 4+)+%%$(;
8/17/2019 SGIR Uneven and Combined Development Paper
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sgir-uneven-and-combined-development-paper 16/29
$46.*6+7 $4 & -.*$($)&* %('/>>*+ 0.' )$6$* '$>#(% &47 *+>&* 0'++7., O?/((%,&4A 2T^2\
2dQ=55
"#+ %(&(+H%-.4%.'+7 )'+&($.4 .0 *&'>+H%)&*+ 8&4J%A )*.%+*; ).44+)(+7 (. $47/%(';A>&6+ '$%+ (. #/>+ ).,-&4$+% (#&( ,.4.-.*$Y+7 J+; %+)(.'%= M&)(.'; %$Y+% 3+'+ ,/)#
*&'>+' (#&4 $4 @'$(&$4 &47 (#+ +5+')$%+ .0 7$%)$-*$4+ .6+' (#+ 3.'J+'% 3&% %('.4>+'Oj.)J&A 2T^UV ?'+8$4>A 2TUTV 9.*&4A 2T^2Q= "#+ %('/)(/'+ .0 (#+ ?+',&4 $47/%('$&*+).4.,; +4%/'+7 (#&( ?+',&4 )&-$(&*$%, 3&% D&'>/&8*; (#+ ,.%( %/))+%%0/* $4
'+%('$)($4> 3.'J$4> )*&%% 7+,&47% &( (#+ -.$4( .0 -'.7/)($.4EA (#'./># ('&7+ /4$.4
'+%('$)($.4% &47 8*&)J *$%(% O@*&)J8/'4A 2T^e\ WUUQ=
KB& E$#7-%6:#5 E$#%&'' :6'&9) F+' %B+$+%6&$:;&7 ,A %9+'' 7#4:5+6:#5 &47 (#+ D0'++$4>E/- .0 *&8./' &%%.)$&(+7 3$(# )&-$(&*$%( %.)$&* '+*&($.4% 7$74E( .))/' .4 & %)&*+
).,-&'&8*+ (. (#&( +5-+'$+4)+7 $4 @'$(&$4= "#+ 7$00+'+4( -&(#% (#&( *+7 0'., 0+/7&*
%.)$+(; (.3&'7% )&-$(&*$%, $4 @'$(&$4 &47 ?+',&4;A 7+*$4+&(+7 8; IP:KA (#/% J++4*;7+(+',$4+7 3.'J$4> )*&%% +5-+'$+4)+% $4 (#+ (3. )./4('$+%= F4 ?+',&4;A 3#+'+ (#+
0+/7&* .6+'#&4> $4 (#+ %.)$&* '+*&($.4% .0 -'.7/)($.4 3&% ,/)# ,.'+ -'.4./4)+77/'$4> (#+ *&((+' 9$4+(++4(# :+4(/'; (#&4 $4 @'$(&$4A 3.'J-*&)+ '+*&($.4% 3+'+&)).'7$4>*; ,.'+ +5-*$)$(*; -.*$($)$Y+7= F47/%('$&*$%(%A $,$(&($4> (#+ S/4J+'E%A &7.-(+7
(#+ 0+/7&* &(($(/7+ .0A D,&%(+' $4 ,; .34 #./%+EA $4 (#+$' 7+&*$4>% 3$(# (#+ 3.'J+'%O1+#*+'A 2TU`\ edV 9.*&4A 2T^UQ= "#$% ).47$($.4 3&% &>>'&6&(+7 8; (#+ .4%+( .0 (#+
K+-'+%%$.4A 3#$)# )&/%+7 ).,-&4$+% (. 0.', -.*$($)&* .'>&4$Y&($.4% 7+%$>4+7 (.
*.88; (#+ %(&(+ $4 .'7+' (. '+>/*&(+ -'.7/)($.4 &47 0'/%('&(+ (#+ &%-$'&($.4% .0 (#+3.'J$4> )*&%% O<*+;A 2T^e\ 2XUV 9.*&4A 2T^2\ 2dQ=
=_% & ).4%+C/+4)+ .0 .6+'8+&'$4> %(&(+ &/(#.'$(; &47 (#+ ).4($4/$(; .0 S/4J+'
-'$6$*+>+A ?+',&4 *$8+'&*$%, 3&% 3+&J= F( 3&% 5+6:#5+9:'4 '&(#+' (#&4 *$8+'&*$%,
(#&( %+'6+7 &% (#+ ,&R.' *+>$($,$Y$4> 0.')+ .0 ?+',&4 7+6+*.-,+4(= ?+',&44&($.4&*$%, 3&% -'+,$%+7 /-.4 (#+ $7+& .0 D4+>&($6+ $4(+>'&($.4E O1+#*+'A 2T^dA
-T2Q=55$ @$%,&')J /($*$Y+7 (#+ 4&($.4&* C/+%($.4 +5-+'(*; $4 .'7+' (. 7$%.'$+4(
8./'>+.$%H*$8+'&* .--.%$($.4 8; )*.&J$4> (#+ -'$6&(+A 0+/7&* )*&%% )#&'&)(+' .0 (#+?+',&4 %(&(+ 3$(# & 6+$* .0 -.-/*&' /4$6+'%&*$(;= @$%,&')JE% -'.R+)( 7'.6+ & 3+7>+
8+(3++4 (#+ *$8+'&*%A 3#. 8; $4 *&'>+ &)C/$+%)+7 (. (#+ 4&($.4&*$%( %)#+,+OZ)#$%%*+'A 2TT2\ e]QA &47 (#+ 3.'J$4> )*&%%A 3#. %&3 (#&( (#+ *$8+'&*% )./*7 4.( 8+
)./4(+7 /-.4 &% & '+*$&8*+ &**;= "#+ ?+',&4 -.*$($)&* %;%(+, 3&% 4.( (#+'+0.'+
%/8R+)( (. $4)'+,+4(&* 7+,.)'&($Y&($.4 $4 (#+ 3&; (#&( (#+ @'$(&$4E% #&7 8++4A &47(#+ -.%%$8$*$(; .0 &4 &**+>$&4)+ 8+(3++4 (#+ *$8+'&*E% &47 (#+ *&8./' ,.6+,+4( 3&%
0.'+)*.%+7 +&'*; Ok.*8+'>A 2T^UQ=
F4 %/,A ?+',&4 7+6+*.-,+4( >&6+ '$%+ (. &4 $4&/%-$)$./% ).,8$4&($.4 .0 %.)$&*0.',%V & ,.7+'4 $47/%('$&* +).4.,; )#&'&)(+'$Y+7 8; #$># *+6+*% .0 ).4)+4('&($.4
&47 )&'(+*$Y&($.4A (#&( #.%(+7 '&-$7 3.'J$4> )*&%% 0.',&($.4A 3$(# &4 &')#&$) &47
'$>$7 &/(#.'$(&'$&4 %(&(+ 0.', 8+%+( 8; (#+ 3$*($4> (+47+4)$+% .0 0+/7&* %.)$+(;= "#+$4(+'%+)($.4 &47 %;4(#+($) ).4%/,,&($.4 .0 (#+%+ %.)$+(&* 0.',%A 3$(#$4 (#+
).47$($.4$4> 0.')+ 0$+*7 .0 /4+6+4 $4(+'4&($.4&* 7+6+*.-,+4(A -'.7/)+7 & %$(/&($.4
8/17/2019 SGIR Uneven and Combined Development Paper
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sgir-uneven-and-combined-development-paper 17/29
.0 BAE&$E#9:6:%:;+6:#5 3$(#$4 (#+ ?+',&4 %(&(+ 0.',= "#+ 4/,+'./% 4&($.4&*$%(
-'+%%/'+ >'./-%A .'>&4$Y+7 &>'&'$&4 $4(+'+%(%A $47/%('$&* .'>&4$Y&($.4% &47$4%($(/($.4% .0 .'>&4$Y+7 *&8./' (#&( %./>#( (. +%(&8*$%# & ).4('.**$4> $40*/+4)+ .6+'
%(&(+ -.3+' +5+,-*$0$+7 (#$%= "#+ 3.'J$4> )*&%% +5-+'$+4)+7 $4)'+&%+7 7$%)$-*$4+&47 ).+')$.4 &( (#+ -.$4( .0 -'.7/)($.4A 3#$*%( (#+ 7.,$4&4( )*&%%+% &)#$+6+7 (#+$'
0'&>$*+ ).#+%$.4 8; 3&>$4> & )&,-&$>4 .0 %/8.'7$4&($.4 &>&$4%( 3.'J+'%=
"#+ ?+',&4 %(&(+ +,+'>+7 0'., $(% ).47$($.4 .0 8&)J3&'74+%% #&''$+7 8; (#+
(#'+&(% .0 & '&7$)&* 3.'J$4> )*&%% -&'(; &47 )'&7*$4> 3$(#$4 $(%+*0 (#+ ,&4$0.*7 %)&'%
.0 $(% ).,8$4+7 7+6+*.-,+4(= "#+ $4%($(/($.4&*$Y&($.4 .0 (#+ 4+3 )*&%% '+*&($.4%8'./>#( &8./( 7/'$4> )&-$(&*$%( ('&4%$($.4 3&% :5%#4E9&6& &47 $4)'+7$8*; -5'6+,9&=
"#$% 0&$*/'+ ,&4$0+%(+7 $(%+*0 $4 (#+ '&7$)&*$Y&($.4 .0 (#+ -.*$($)&* %('&(+>$+% .0 (#+7.,$4&4( &47 %/8.'7$4&(+ %.)$&* )*&%%+%A '+%/*($4> $4 & %#&'- -.*&'$(; 8+(3++4 *+0(
&47 '$>#( &47 &4 .6+'&** 7;4&,$) .0 %.)$&* 7$%$4(+>'&($.4= _( (#+ '..( .0 %.)$&*
7$%#&',.4; *&; (#+ >'+&(*; &))+*+'&(+7 (+,-. &( 3#$)# +).4.,$) &47 %.)$&*('&4%0.',&($.4 #&7 .))/''+7 $4 ?+',&4; (#+ %.H)&**+7 D-'$6$*+>+ .0 8&)J3&'74+%%EA
&47 (#+ (+,-.'&* ).$4)$7+4)+ .0 (#+%+ ('&4%0.',&($.4% 3$(# &4 &/(#.'$(&'$&4-.*$($)&* ).4%.*$7&($.4= @.(# -'.)+%%+% 3+'+ ,.($6&(+7 8; (#+ 7+%$'+ .0 ?+',&4+*$(+% (. +%)&-+ (#+ %#&)J*+% .0 8&)J3&'74+%% $4 .'7+' (. %+)/'+ (#+$' -.%$($.4
3$(#$4 (#+ </'.-+&4 $4(+'%(&(+ #$+'&')#;=
2"3.)45#6*&" E,$&.6> &"' 01# 2//6)&<1 )I 99:
"#+ #&/4($4> )'$+% .0 (#+ Z.,,+ 4.3 *$+ 8/'$+7 7++- $4 (#+ &44&*% .0 #$%(.';A
.6+'(&J+4 8; (#+ '&-$7 -&)+ .0 ,.7+'4$(;= F4 (#+ -/8*$) ).4%)$+4)+A (#+; &'+
+5#/,+7 .4*; ,.,+4(&'$*; 8; (#+ %;,8.*$) >+%(/'+ .0 & %$4>*+ '+7 -.--; 3.'4 $4'+,+,8'&4)+= 1$(#$4 (#+ (+''&$4 .0 FB %)#.*&'%#$- #.3+6+'A (#+ >+4+%$% .0 112
%(&47% &% & -+'+44$&* 8&((*+0$+*7A /-.4 3#$)# (#+.'+($)&* %).'+% &'+ %+((*+7 &47+5-*&4&(.'; )'+7$8$*$(; $% &7R/7$)&(+7= [+( 7+%-$(+ (#+ %/8%(&4($&* 6.*/,+ .0 $4J %-$*(
.6+' (#+ )&/%+% .0 (#+ %#&'-+4$4> '$6&*'$+% -'+)+7$4> 112A (#+ &4%3+'% '+,&$4
/4%&($%0&)(.';=
B+&*$%(% -'.)*&$, (#&( (#+ +6+4(% .0 2T2eH2T2^ %(&47 &% & (+%(&,+4( (. (#+
$4+6$(&8*+A D"'&>+7; .0 ?'+&( a.3+' a.*$($)%E OL+&'%#+$,+'A WXX2Q= m$+3+7 (#'./>#B+&*$%( +;+%A (#+ 3.'*7 $% ).47+,4+7 (. -+'-+(/&* >'+&(H-.3+' ).40*$)(= F4 (#+
$4(+'4&($.4&* '+&*,A (#+ .'7+'$4> -'$4)$-*+ .0 &4&')#; ).47$($.4% %(&(+% $4(. &%/'6$6&*$%( ,+4(&*$(;A ,.($6&(+7 8; (#+ /8$C/$(; .0 0+&' OL+&'%#+$,+'A WXX2V 1&*(YA
2T`TQ= a.3+'A 7+0$4+7 -/'+*; $4 (+',% .0 ,&(+'$&* )&-&8$*$($+%A -'.6$7+% (#+
)/''+4); .0 )#&4>+ $4 $4(+'4&($.4&* -.*$($)%= _% %(&(+% '+*&($6+ -.3+' %#$0(% %. 7.+%(#+ ).40$>/'&($.4 .0 (#+ $4(+'4&($.4&* %;%(+,A 3$(# (#+ D8&*&4)+ .0 -.3+'E &)($4> &% &
%+*0H'+>/*&($4> ,+)#&4$%, .0 -.3+' 7$%('$8/($.4 O1&*(YA 2T`T\ 2WXQ=
8/17/2019 SGIR Uneven and Combined Development Paper
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sgir-uneven-and-combined-development-paper 18/29
B+&*$%,E% (#+.'+($)&* -&'%$,.4; +4&8*+% & %$,-*$%($) +5-*&4&($.4 .0 (#+ ./(8'+&J .0#.%($*$($+%= _)).'7$4> (. L+&'%#+$,+' OWXX2\ WQA +,+'>+4( ?'+&( a.3+'% &'+
$4+6$(&8*; D-'$,+7 0.' .00+4%+E= <,8.*7+4+7 8; '&-$7 $47/%('$&*$Y&($.4A ?+',&4;%./>#( (. ,&5$,$Y+ $(% -.3+' &47 3&% (#+'+0.'+A D8+4( .4 /-%+(($4> (#+ </'.-+&4
8&*&4)+ .0 -.3+' &47 $4)'+&%$4> $(% %#&'+ .0 ,$*$(&'; ,$>#(E OL+&'%#+$,+'A WXX2\2dUQ= M.' L+&'%#+$,+'A &>>'+%%$6+ ?+',&4 8+#&6$./' #&7 4. 8+&'$4> /-.4 (#+-.%(/'+ .0 (#+ .(#+' ,&R.' </'.-+&4 -.3+'%=55$$
L+&'%#+$,+'E% &4&*;%$% $% -'+,$%+7 .4 & ).,-*+(+ &8%('&)($.4 0'., (#+ $4(+'4&*).,-*+5$.4 .0 (#+ %(&(+% $46.*6+7 $4 (#+ ).40*$)(A &4 &%-+)( (#&( 3&% &8%.*/(+*;
)'$($)&* $4 7+(+',$4$4> (#+ /40.*7$4> .0 +6+4(% O?.'7.4A 2T`eV j+44+7;A 2T^XQ= "#$%&8%('&)($.4 $% 7+'$6+7 0'., (#+ $4(+>'&* %)#$%, .0 4+.HB+&*$%( (#+.';V (#&( 8+(3++4
(#+ #$+'&')#$)&**; .'7+'+7 4&(/'+ .0 7.,+%($) -.*$($)% .4 (#+ .4+ #&47A &47 (#+
&4&')#$)&* .'7+'$4> .0 $4(+'4&($.4&* -.*$($)% .4 (#+ .(#+' O1&*(YA 2T`T\ ^2Q= F( $% 8;+%%+4($&*$Y$4> &47 7$%&>>'+>&($4> (#+%+ (3. %-#+'+% (#&( 4+.HB+&*$%(% ).4%('/)(
(#+$' 0./47&($.4&* (#+.'+($)&* 0&**&);V (#&( (#+ D7.,+%($)E &47 D$4(+'4&($.4&*E '+&*,%+5$%( &% 7$%($4)( %-#+'+%A ).47$($.4+7 8; 7$00+'+4( *.>$)%A &47 +5$%($4> $4 &'+*&($.4%#$- .0 )&/%&* #$+'&')#; 3#+'+8; >+.%('&(+>$) ).4%$7+'&($.4% /*($,&(+*;
7+(+',$4+ $4(+'4&($.4&* ./().,+%= B+&*$%(% 7$%%.)$&(+ $4(+'4&($.4&* -.*$($)% 0'.,&4; 0.', .0 %.)$.*.>$)&* >'./47$4>A -'+0+''$4> $4%(+&7 (. %('+%% (#+ -'$,&); .0
B+&*-.*$($J= "#+ C/+%($.4 '+,&$4%A #&6+ #$%(.'$)&* ,&(+'$&*$%( &))./4(% 0&$'+7 &4;
8+((+'f
_)).'7$4> (. B.%+48+'>A #$%(.'$)&* ,&(+'$&*$%( &--'.&)#+% (. FBA >'./47+7 $4 &,.7+H.0 -'.7/)($.4 &4&*;%$%A #&6+ (+47+7 (. %/00+' 0'., (3. '+*&(+7 -'.8*+,%= "#+;
+$(#+'\ &Q DZ/-+'$,-.%+ $4('&H%.)$+(&* )&(+>.'$+% .0 %.)$&* %('/)(/'+ .4(. $4(+'H
%.)$+(&* -#+4.,+4&A .8%)/'$4> (#+ 7+(+',$4&($.4% (#&( ,$>#( &'$%+ 0'., (#+ 0&)( .0>+.-.*$($)&* ,/*($-*$)$(; $(%+*0EA .'\ 8Q $,-.%+ &4 &77$($.4&* $4(+'%(&(+ *.>$) (#&(
,.7$0$+% &47 .6+'H7+(+',$4+% (#+ ,.'+ %('$)(*; %.)$.*.>$)&* )&(+>.'$+%= F4 .(#+'
3.'7% (#+A D0&)($)$(; .0 (#+ $4(+'4&($.4&*EA +6&7+% ).4)+-(/&*$Y&($.4 8; #$%(.'$)&*,&(+'$&*$%(% OB.%+48+'> P :&**$4$).%A WXX^Q=55$$$
N+4$4E% O2T`2\ W]WQ (#+.'; .0 F,-+'$&*$%,A 0.' +5&,-*+A /*($,&(+*; '+7/)+% (#+ >'+&(
-.3+' 7;4&,$)% .0 (#+ -+'$.7 (. (#+ )'$%$% (+47+4)$+% .0 &76&4)+7 )&-$(&*$%, 8;
%/>>+%($4> (#&(A DF,-+'$&*$%, $% (#+ ,.4.-.*; %(&>+ .0 )&-$(&*$%,E= N+4$4 $% >/$*(; .0B.%+48+'>E% 0$'%( %$4 (#+'+0.'+ 8; '+7/)$4> $4(+'4&($.4&* 7;4&,$)% (. %/-+'$,-.%+7
%.)$.*.>$)&* )&(+>.'$+%= [+( N+4$4E% 3'$($4> ).4(&$4% (#+ >+', .0 & -'.0$(&8*+ %-+)$+%
.0 &4&*;%$%A 8; &)J4.3*+7>$4> (#+ 0&)( .0 $4(+'H%.)$+(&* /4+6+44+%%= N+4$4 O2T`2Q'+8/(% j&/(%J;E% 4.($.4 .0 & -&)$0$%($) DI*('&HF,-+'$&*$%,E 8; '+0+''$4> (. (#+ /4+6+4
4&(/'+ .0 )&-$(&*$%( 7+6+*.-,+4(A D(#+ +6+4 7+6+*.-,+4( .0 7$00+'+4( /47+'(&J$4>% .0$47/%(';A .' )./4('$+% $% $,-.%%$8*+ /47+' )&-$(&*$%,E= @; %/>>+%($4> (#&( (#+ %#$0($4>
8&%$% .0 -.3+' +4>+47+'+7 8; )&-$(&*$%( %.)$&* '+*&($.4% ,$*$(&(+% &>&$4%( (#+
-+&)+0/* ).+5$%(+4)+ .0 %(&(+%A N+4$4 &--'.5$,&(+% 4+.HB+&*$%,E% &((+4($6+4+%% (.(#+ 7$00+'+4($&* >'.3(# .0 %(&(+ -.3+' &47 $(% $,-&)( /-.4 (#+ -'.%-+)(% 0.' -&)$0$)
$4(+'4&($.4&* '+*&($.4%= "#$% %#./*7 4.( ).,+ &% &4; -&'($)/*&' %/'-'$%+ 8+)&/%+A &%
8/17/2019 SGIR Uneven and Combined Development Paper
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sgir-uneven-and-combined-development-paper 19/29
?$*-$4 O2T^2\ T]Q 4.(+%A 8.(# L&'5$%, &47 B+&*$%,A D+5-*&$4 (#+ 7;4&,$)% .0 FB $4
(+',% .0 (#+ 7$00+'+4($&* >'.3(# .0 -.3+' &,.4> %(&(+%E=55$6
1#&( N+4$4E% &))./4( *&)J% $% (#+ D).,8$4+7E +*+,+4( .0 7+6+*.-,+4(= N+4$4 O2T`2\2^XQ &%%/,+% (#&( (#+ 6&'$./% F,-+'$&*$%( %(&(+% &'+ +C/$6&*+4( &47 (#/% 7+%($4+7 (.
-/'%/+ %$,$*&' ).,-+($($6+ %('&(+>$+%= G$% (#+.'; &**.3% 4. 7$00+'+4($&($.4 8+(3++4(#+ /4$(% (#+,%+*6+%A &47 (#+ -&'($)/*&'$($+% .0 7$00+'+4( '/*$4> )*&%% %('&(+>$+%=Z$*6+'E% &))./4(A %$,$*&'*;A '+).>4$Y+% (#+ 0&)( .0 D/4+6+44+%%E 8; 7$00+'+4($&($4> ).'+
%(&(+% 0'., -+'$-#+'&* .4+%A 8/( ,$%%+% &*(.>+(#+' (#+ &%-+)( .0 D).,8$4&($.4EA 8;
('+&($4> ).'+ %(&(+% &*$J+= "#$% .6+'%$>#( *+&7% #+' (. ,$%(&J+4*; $7+4($0; (#+-'+%%/'+% +,&4&($4> 0'., #$>#*; %-+)$0$) )./'%+% .0 4&($.4&* 7+6+*.-,+4( &47 )*&%%
%('&(+>$+%A &% %;%(+,$) (+47+4)$+% +5-'+%%$6+ .0 & )#&**+4>+ (. @'$($%# #+>+,.4;=9.3A &% 3+ #&6+ %/>>+%(+7 &8.6+A IP:K &**.3% /% (. )&-(/'+ (#+ $4(+'&)($6$(; .0
%.)$&* 7+6+*.-,+4( &47 $(% $,-&)( /-.4 $4(+'4&($.4&* -.*$($)%= F4 .'7+' (.
7+,.4%('&(+ (#$% +,-$'$)&**; 3+ ,/%( '+(/'4 (. 7+6+*.-,+4(&* D./().,+%E .0?+',&4; &47 @'$(&$4A +5-*.'$4> (#+ 0.'+$>4 -.*$); 7$,+4%$.4% .0 (#+%+ ./().,+%=
@; 2TXU (#+ _4>*.H?+',&4 &4(&>.4$%, #&7 8+).,+ 0$',*; %+(= a'+)$-$(./% ?+',&44&6&* +5-&4%$.4 3&% (#+ %('&3 (#&( 0$4&**; 8'.J+ (#+ )&,+*E% 8&)J Oj+44+7;A 2T^X\
]WdQA ;+( $( 3&% (#+ +@@$&'':3& 6#5& .0 ?+',&4 0.'+$>4 -.*$); '&(#+' (#&4 %$,-*;)'/7+ -.3+' )&*)/*&($.4% (#&( #&'7+4+7 (#+ @'$($%# %(&4)+ Oj+44+7;A 2T^X\ e]2V
?.'7.4A 2T`eQ=556 _ 4.(&8*+ 0+&(/'+ .0 *&(+ 2T(# :+4(/'; ?+',&4; 3&% (#+ -'+6&*+4)+
.0 (#+ D4&($.4&* C/+%($.4E 3$(#$4 7.,+%($) -.*$($)%=556$ F4 (#+ ).4(+5( .0 & %#&'-*;7$6$7+7 %.)$+(;A '+%/*(&4( 0'., (#+ '&-$7 ('&4%$($.4 (. )&-$(&*$%( %.)$&* '+*&($.4%A (#+
4&($.4&* C/+%($.4 %+'6+7 8.(# &% & 7$6+'%$.4 0'., (#+ )*&%% -.*$($)% +%-./%+7 8; (#+ZaKA &47 &% & /4$0;$4> $7+.*.>$)&* ,+)#&4$%, (#&( ('&4%)+47+7 -&'(;H-.*$($)&*
7$6$%$.4%= a+)/*$&' (. (#$% %./')+ .0 ).#+%$.4 3&% (#+ 7+>'++ (. 3#$)# $( '+*$+7 /-.4
+5('&(+''$(.'$&* 0./47&($.4%=
"#+%+ 0./47&($.4% &'+ 8+%( /47+'%(..7 $4 (+',% .0 DZ.)$&* F,-+'$&*$%,E= ?+',&4
Z.)$&* F,-+'$&*$%, 3&% &4 +5-&4%$.4$%( 0.', .0 0.'+$>4 -.*$); $4 3#$)# (#+7.,$4&4( ,.($6+ 3&% (#+A D-'+%+'6&($.4 .0 (#+ ('&7$($.4&* %.)$&* #$+'&')#;E O1+#*+'A
2T`X\ 2WWQ= _ 0.', .0 Z.)$&* F,-+'$&*$%, 3&% &*%. +%-./%+7 $4 @'$(&$4 (.3&'7% (#+(/'4 .0 (#+ "3+4($+(# :+4(/'; OZ+,,+*A 2TUXQ= "#+ 0.',A ).4(+4( &47 0&(+ .0 @'$($%#
Z.)$&* F,-+'$&*$%, 3+'+ 0/47&,+4(&**; 7$00+'+4( #.3+6+' OZ+,,+*A 2TUXV ?.'7.4A
2T`eQ= "#+ ).+5$%(+4)+ .0 Z.)$&* F,-+'$&*$%, $4 8.(# @'$(&$4 &47 ?+',&4; %-+&J% (.(#+ 0/47&,+4(&* $4(+'&)($6$(; .0 $4(+'H%.)$+(&* 7+6+*.-,+4( &47 (#+ (+47+4);
(.3&'7% D+,/*&($.4E= "#+ J+; 7$%($4)($.4% $4 (#+ )#&'&)(+'$%($)% .0 @'$($%# &47
?+',&4 %.)$&* $,-+'$&*$%, '+0*+)( (#+ 0/47&,+4(&* 7$6+'>+4)+% $4 (#+$'7+6+*.-,+4(&* ('&R+)(.'$+%=
@$%,&')J $4&/>/'&(+7 ?+',&4 Z.)$&* F,-+'$&*$%, $4 (#+ 2^`XE%= F4$($&**;A F,-+'$&*
+5-&4%$.4 3&% -'+,$%+7 /-.4 (#+ +,/*&($.4 .0 @'$($%# DF40.',&* F,-+'$&*$%,E (#&(
.-+'&(+7 (#'./># (#+ +5(+4%$.4 .0 ,&'J+(% 0.' 0'++ ('&7+ 3$(#./( +4(&$*$4> 0.',&*).*.4$&* ).4('.* O1+#*+'A 2T`X\ 2WdQ= _% (#+ ?'+&( K+-'+%%$.4 /40.*7+7 $4 (#+
2^`XE% #.3+6+'A & -.3+'0/* &**$&4)+ .0 ).4%+'6&($6+ S/4J+'% &47 $47/%('$&*$%(%
8/17/2019 SGIR Uneven and Combined Development Paper
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sgir-uneven-and-combined-development-paper 20/29
3$(#$4 ?+',&4; -'.,-(+7 @$%,&')J (. $4('.7/)+ -'.(+)($.4$%( ,+&%/'+% O1+#*+'A
2T`X\ 2]WQ= @; (#+ +&'*; 2^^XE% ?+',&4; #&7 8+>/4 (. &%%/,+ 0.',&* ).4('.* .0%.,+ ).*.4$&* (+''$(.'$+%A -'.,-(+7 8; >'.3$4> )'$($)$%, .0 (#+ '+>$,+ 0'., 3$(#$4
%.)$+(; &47 (#+ +5-&4%$.4&'; 8+#&6$./' .0 .(#+' ).*.4$&* -.3+'%= _*(#./>#+5-&4%$.4&';A @$%,&')JE% 8'&47 .0 Z.)$&* F,-+'$&*$%, 3&% %#.'4 .0 (#+ '&7$)&*
4&($.4&*$%, &47 D1+*(-.*$($JE (#&( 3./*7 %/8%+C/+4(*; ).,+ (. 7.,$4&(+ ?+',&40.'+$>4 -.*$);=
"#+ ;+&' .0 2^T` ,&'J+7 & (/'4$4> -.$4( $4 ?+',&4 Z.)$&* F,-+'$&*$%,V ?+',&4;E%
0.'+$>4 -.*$); &%%/,+7 &4 $4)'+&%$4>*; ,$*$(&'$%($) 0.', (#&( 3+4( 8+;.47 (#+)&*)/*&(+7 -&'&,+(+'% .0 @$%,&')JE% 8'$4J,&4%#$- (.3&'7 & 0.'(#'$>#(*; &>>'+%%$6+
7$%-.%$($.4 (.3&'7% @'$(&$4=556$$ _% 7.,+%($) (+4%$.4% $4)'+&%+7 $4 *$4+ 3$(# (#+ '$%+.0 (#+ ZaK &47 %('$J+ &)($6$(;A & -*+(#.'& .0 4&($.4&*$%( $4(+**+)(/&*% &47 -&4H
?+',&4% 8+>&4 (. 7+,&47 & /4$0;$4> D1+*(-.*$($JE -'+,$%+7 /-.4 +5(+4%$6+
+5-&4%$.4 .0 ?+',&4 4&6&* -.3+'=556$$$ K.,+%($) 7$%).4(+4( 3$(# (#+ j&$%+' &47 (#+>'.3$4> ,+4&)+ .0 (#+ ZaKA %(.J+7 /- & %(.', .0 4&($.4&*$%($) &47 )#&/6$4$%(
0+'6./'A -'.,-($4> (#+ >.6+'4,+4( (. &((+,-( & '+4+3+7 '+%.*/($.4 .0 (#+ *.4>H%(&47$4> -'.8*+, .0 ?+',&4 %.)$&* $4(+>'&($.4=55$5 "#+ &4($H,.7+'4$%( &47 &4($H@'$($%# &>'&'$&4 0.')+% 8+#$47 (#+ -.3+'0/* D@/47 7+' N&473$'(+E >&6+ 4&($.4&*$%(
%+4($,+4( & -&'($)/*&'*; %#&'- +7>+ Oj+44+7;A 2T^X\ ]W]Q= "#+ >'.3(# .0 '&7$)&*4&($.4&*$%( >'./-% $4 (#+ 2^TXE% '+0*+)(+7 (#+ $4&8$*$(; .0 (#+ ?+',&4 -&'(; %;%(+, (.
&)).,,.7&(+ (#+ 4+3 %.)$&* 0.')+% .0 $47/%('$&* )&-$(&*$%,= <5('+,+ 4&($.4&*$%(
>'./-% %/)# &% (#+ 9&6; N+&>/+ %./>#( (. 8;-&%% (#+ 3+&J &47 7$6$7+7 B+$)#%(&>&47 &--+&* 7$'+)(*; (. (#+ 8/'+&/)'&); O<*+;A 2T`^\ ]e2Q= I*('&H4&($.4&*$%,
).4($4/+7 (. >&(#+' ,.,+4(/, -'$.' (. (#+ 3&' &47 '+)+$6+7 $(% 0$4&* %-/' 0'., (#+ZaKE% +*+)(.'&* ('$/,-# $4 2T2W O?.'7.4A 2T`e\ 2TTV Z)#.'%J+A 2T^]Q= F( 3&%
1+*(-.*$($J &47 (#+ &>>'+%%$6+ 4&($.4&*$%, %-&34+7 8; (#+ ).4('&7$)($.4% .0
?+',&4 7+6+*.-,+4( (#&( -'.,-(+7 (#+ 0.',&($.4 .0 (#+ "'$-*+ <4(+4(+ &47 7'.6+?+',&4; $4+5.'&8*; $4(. ).40*$)( 3$(# M'&4)+A @'$(&$4 &47 B/%%$& $4 2T2e Oj+44+7;A
2T^XV ?.'7.4A 2T`eQ=
Z.)$&* F,-+'$&*$%, 3$(#$4 @'$(&$4A ).4('&%($4>*;A 3&% 7$6$7+7 $4(. %+6+'&* ).,-+($4>
%('&47%= N$8+'&* F,-+'$&*$%(% +%-./%+7 & 6$%$.4 .0 <,-$'+ )#&'&)(+'$Y+7 8;)..-+'&($.4A 0'++ ('&7+ &47 -+&)+0/* ).+5$%(+4)+ OZ+,,+*A 2TUX\ d]Q= "#+ ,.%(
6+#+,+4(*; &76.)&(+7 0.', .0 @'$($%# Z.)$&* F,-+'$&*$%, #.3+6+'A 3&% &%%.)$&(+7
3$(# S.%+-# :#&,8+'*&$4 &47 %/--.'(+'% .0 (#+ "&'$00 B+0.', N+&>/+ &47 F,-+'$&*a'+0+'+4)+ OZ+,,+*A 2TUX\ d]Q= S/%( &% @$%,&')J #&7 +&'*$+' %./>#( (. +,/*&(+
@'$($%# F40.',&* <,-$'+A (#+ -'.-.4+4(% .0 "&'$00 B+0.', 4.3 *..J+7 (. ?+',&4;
&47 (#+ @$%,&')J$&4 ).,8$4&($.4 .0 3+*0&'+ $,-*+,+4(&($.4 &47 4+.H,+')&4($*$%(-'.(+)($.4$%, &% (#+ +5&,-*+ (. 0.**.3 OZ+,,+*A 2TUX\ W]V K/((.4A 2T^2\ 2XeWQ=
_0(+' (#+ >&$4% ,&7+ 8; N&8./' $4 (#+ 2TXU +*+)($.4%A ).4%+'6&($6+ 0.')+% 3$(#$4@'$($%# %.)$+(; &-+7 @$%,&')JA +5&>>+'&($4> (#+ (#'+&( .0 %.)$&*$%, &47 %('+%%$4> (#+
4++7 0.' ).#+%$6+ F,-+'$&*$%, OZ+,,+*A 2TUX\ ^]Q=
K+%-$(+ (#+ 6$>.'./% &76.)&); .0 "&'$00 B+0.', &47 F,-+'$&* a'+0+'+4)+A (#$% 0.', .0
Z.)$&* F,-+'$&*$%, 4+6+' (..J #.*7 (. & 7+>'++ ).,-&'&8*+ (. (#&( +5-+'$+4)+7 $4
8/17/2019 SGIR Uneven and Combined Development Paper
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sgir-uneven-and-combined-development-paper 21/29
?+',&4; O"#.,-%.4A 2TT`\ 2``Q= :'/)$&**;A (#+ ,&44+' .0 @'$($%# 7+6+*.-,+4( #&7
>$6+4 (#+ 3.'J$4> )*&%% & %/8%(&4($&* %(&J+ $4 (#+ %(&(+ 8; (#+ *&(+ 9$4+(++4(#:+4(/';= Z$4)+ (#+ 3.'J$4> )*&%%A &47 (#+ -'.,$4+4( 8&4J$4> $4(+'+%(% .0 (#+ :$(;A
(+47+7 (. #.*7 0$',*; (. (#+ -'$4)$-*+% .0 0'++ ('&7+A (#+ +*+)(.'&* %/--.'( 8&%+ .-+4(. (#+ 4+.H,+')&4($*$%(% 3&% '+%('$)(+7=
M/47&,+4(&**;A (#+ %('&(+>$+% .0 ?+',&4 Z.)$&* F,-+'$&*$%, 3+'+ *$J+*; (. 0&$* $4@'$(&$4= @.(# (#+ %.)$&* 8&%+% .0 -.*$($)&* -.3+'A &47 (#+ 7.,$4&4( $7+.*.>$)&* )'++7A
3+'+ 0/47&,+4(&**; 7$00+'+4( 0'., (#.%+ .0 ?+',&4;= "#+ +5('+,+ '$>#( 3$4> .0
?+',&4 -.*$($)% 73&'0+7 $(% @'$($%# )./4(+'-&'(=555 L.'+.6+'A 3.'J$4> )*&%%$4(+>'&($.4 $4 @'$(&$4 #&7 8++4 &)#$+6+7 -'$,&'$*; /47+' (#+ /,8'+**& .0 *$8+'&*A
'&(#+' (#&4 4&($.4&*$%( $7+.*.>;= "#+ >'&7/&*A $4(+'4&* $4(+>'&($.4 .0 (#+ @'$($%#3.'J$4> )*&%% 3&% 0/47&,+4(&**; 7$%($4)( 0'., ?+',&4 &((+,-(% (. 7$%-*&)+
%++,$4>*; $4('&)(&8*+ 7.,+%($) )*&%% &4(&>.4$%,%A 8&)J $4(. (#+ 0$+*7 .0 $4(+'H%(&(+
).,-+($($.4=
"#+%+ >+4+'&($6+ %.)$+(&* 7$00+'+4)+%A '+%/*(&4( 0'., (#+ $4(+'4&($.4&**; 7$6+'>+4(+5-+'$+4)+% .0 )&-$(&*$%( ('&4%$($.4 ).47$($.4+7 8; IP:KA &'+ )'/)$&* (./47+'%(&47$4> (#+ 7$00+'+4( 0.'+$>4 -.*$); .'$+4(&($.4% .0 ?+',&4; &47 @'$(&$4 -'$.'
(. 112= 1#$*+ ?+',&4 0.'+$>4 -.*$); 3&% &>>'+%%$6+A +5-&4%$.4&';A &4(&>.4$%($)&47 7'$6+4 8; (#+ $,-/*%$6+ 7+,&47% .0 /*('&H4&($.4&*$%( %.)$&* 0.')+%A @'$($%# -.*$);
3&% ).4)+'4+7 3$(# (#+ ,&$4(+4&4)+ .0 (#+ %(&(/% C/. &47 (#+ -+&)+0/*
&)).,,.7&($.4 .0 ?+',&4; $4(. & )..-+'&($6+ $4(+'4&($.4&* .'7+'= Z$4)+ 2^2d (#+%).-+ .0 >'+&( -.3+' ).40*$)( 3$(#$4 </'.-+ #&7 0.' (#+ ,.%( -&'( 8++4 ).40$4+7 (.
*$,$(+7 +4>&>+,+4(% .6+' -+'$-#+'&* ).*.4$&* (+''$(.'$+% O@'.,*+;A 2TTe\ U]Q=?+',&4 -.*$); ,&J+'E% 7+%$>4% /-.4 )+4('&* </'.-+&4 +5-&4%$.4 3+'+ (. )#&4>+
(#&( -&((+'4 (. 7+6&%(&($4> +00+)( $4 2T2e=
B+(/'4$4> (. Z$*6+'E% &4&*;%$%A 3+ )&4 4.3 '+&--'&$%+ #+' &'>/,+4( $4 *$>#( .0 ,;
.34 +,-$'$)&* ).4)*/%$.4%= 1#+'+ Z$*6+'E% &--'.&)# +''% $% $4 /47+'%(&47$4> (#+
'+*&($.4%#$- 8+(3++4 *&8./' /4'+%( &47 (#+ $4(+4%$0$)&($.4 .0 F,-+'$&* '$6&*'$+% &%(#+ ).4%+C/+4)+ .0 & >+4+'&* -'.)+%% (#&( ).4%($(/(+7 & %;%(+,$) )#&**+4>+ (. @'$($%#
#+>+,.4;= G+' &4&*;%$% .6+'*..J% (#+ 0/47&,+4(&* 7$00+'+4)+% 3$(#$4 (#+ D).'+E(#'.34 /- 8; IP:KA &47 (#+ $,-&)( .0 (#+%+ 7$%($4)($.4% /-.4 )*&%% -'&)($)+% &47
$4(+'4&($.4&* ./().,+%= Z$*6+'E% OWXX]\ WTQ $4$($&* &%%/,-($.4 .0 %;%(+,$) @'$($%#
#+>+,.4;A &47 #+' .6+'&** -'+0+'+4)+ 0.' (#+ %;%(+,%H*+6+* .0 &4&*;%$%A ).,-+*% #+'(. %++J (#+ )&/%+% .0 #+>+,.4$) ).4(+%(&($.4 &( (#+ %;%(+,$) *+6+*= _% & '+%/*( %#+
'+,&$4% )&/>#( 3$(#$4 &4 &4&*;($)&* *+4% (#&( $% /4&8*+ (. *.)&(+ (#+ .'$>$4 .0
$4(+'4&($.4&* ).4(+%(&($.4 8+;.47 & >+4+'&* %;%(+,$) )'$%$% .0 )&-$(&*$%, OZ$*6+'AWXX]\ 2]]Q= "#/% Z$*6+' 7.+% 4.( 7$00+'+4($&(+ 8+(3++4 (#+ %$>4$0$)&4)+ .0 *&8./'
/4'+%( $4 7$00+'+4( %(&(+%A &47 %/>>+%(% (#&( (#+ '+%-.4%+ .0 %(&(+ +*$(+% (. (#$%&)($6$(; 3&% /4$0.',=
"#+ %$>4$0$)&4)+ .0 *&8./' /4'+%( 7$7A #.3+6+'A 6&'; %$>4$0$)&4(*; 8+(3++4 ).'+%(&(+% $4 (#+ >*.8&* -.*$($)&* +).4.,;= F4 ?+',&4;A $( -'+%+4(+7 & 6+'; (&4>$8*+
(#'+&( (. (#+ +5$%($4> %.)$&* .'7+' &47 3&% 0'&,+7 3$(#$4 & '&7$)&*A &4($H%(&(+
8/17/2019 SGIR Uneven and Combined Development Paper
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sgir-uneven-and-combined-development-paper 22/29
7$%)./'%+= F4 @'$(&$4A *&8./' -.%+7 & ,/)# *+%% %/8%(&4($&* (#'+&( (. (#+ -.3+' .0 (#+
%(&(+ &47 3&% -'$,&'$*; &'($)/*&(+7 (#'./># & '+0.',$%( &47 &)).,,.7&($4> *$8+'&*7$%)./'%+= Z$,$*&'*;A 3#$*%( ?+',&4 %(&(+ +*$(+% 7$7 %/8%)'$8+ (. (#+ 4.($.4 (#&( &4
+5-&4%$.4&'; 3&' )./*7 8.*%(+' 7.,+%($) %(&8$*$(; OZ)#.'%J+A 2T^]QA @'$($%# .00$)$&*%3+'+ +5('+,+*; ).4)+'4+7 &8./( (#+ -.(+4($&**; 7$%$4(+>'&($6+ $,-&)( .0 ).40*$)(
/-.4 %.)$+(; &47 3+'+ (#+'+0.'+ +5('+,+*; '+*/)(&4( (. +4(+' $4(. ).40*$)( OM'+4)#A2T^WQ= Z$*6+'E% -'+7$*+)($.4 0.' >+4+'&*$(; ,$%%+% (#+ )'$($)&* 7$%($4)($.4% 8+(3++4(#+ ,+&4$4> &47 +00+)(% .0 *&8./' /4'+%( $4 7$00+'+4( %(&(+%= 1+ )&4 .4*; /47+'%(&47
(#+%+ 7$00+'+4)+% 8; /($*$Y$4> IP:K (. /47+'%(&47 (#+ $4(+'&)($6$(; &47
-&'($)/*&'$($+% .0 -&(#% .0 )&-$(&*$%( 7+6+*.-,+4( &47 (#+$' ).4%+C/+4)+% 0.' )*&%%-'&)($)+% &47 $4(+'%(&(+ 7;4&,$)%=
I47+'%(&47$4> (#+ '&7$)&*$Y&($.4 .0 *&8./' ,.6+,+4(% &47 (#+ >'.3(# .0 3.'J$4>
)*&%% -&'($+% &)'.%% </'.-+ '+C/$'+% &4 &--'+)$&($.4 .0 (#+ ,./*7$4> $40*/+4)+ .0
(#+ ZaK OS.**A 2T`eV Z&%%..4A 2TT`Q= "#+ ?+',&4 *&8./' ,.6+,+4( 3&% (#+ 0$'%( (.-'.7/)+ &4 +5-*$)$(*; 3.'J$4> )*&%% -.*$($)&* -&'(; &47 $( &*%. -'.7/)+7 (#+ ,.%(
'&7$)&*A 8+%( 0$4&4)+7 &47 ,.%( $4(+'4&($.4&**; $40*/+4($&* 3.'J$4> )*&%% -&'(;= "#+ZaK *+&7+'%#$- +5+'(+7 %/8%(&4($&* $4(+**+)(/&* $40*/+4)+ (#'./># (#+ Z+).47F4(+'4&($.4&* OS.**A 2T`eQ= "#+ 7+6+*.-,+4( .0 %/8%+C/+4( 3.'J$4> )*&%% -&'($+% $4
</'.-+ %#./*7 8+ /47+'%(..7 -&'(*; &% & ).4%+C/+4)+ .0 &((+,-(% (. &4-9+6& (#+%('&(+>$+% &47 $7+.*.>; .0 (#+ ZaK Ok.*8+'>A 2T^U\ ]TTQ=
@; %('+%%$4> (#+ ?'+&( K+-'+%%$.4 &% (#+ /*($,&(+ )&/%+ .0 $4)'+&%+7 )*&%% (+4%$.4%AZ$*6+' 0&$*% (. &--'+)$&(+ (#+ 7+>'++ (. 3#$)# %(&(+% 3+'+ $,-&)(+7 7$00+'+4(*; 8; (#+
K+-'+%%$.4= "#$% %;%(+,%H*+6+* -'+.))/-&($.4 *+&7% #+' $4(. & 7/&* +''.'\ .4 (#+ .4+#&47A .6+'%(&($4> (#+ '.*+ .0 %-.'&7$) )&-$(&*$%( )'$%$% &47 (#+ /4$0.',$(; .0 (#+$'
+00+)(% $4 7+(+',$4$4> #+>+,.4$) ('&4%$($.4%A &47 .4 (#+ .(#+' #&47A
/47+'+%($,&($4> (#+ %$>4$0$)&4)+ .0 *.4>+' (+',A 4&($.4&**; %-+)$0$) -'.)+%%+% .0)&-$(&*$%( 7+6+*.-,+4( $4 '+%#&-$4> 3.'*7 .'7+'= _ 0/47&,+4(&* &%-+)( .0 4&($.4&*
-'.)+%%+% .0 )&-$(&*$%( 7+6+*.-,+4( 3&% (#+ &((+,-( (. +%(&8*$%# (#+ %('/)(/'&*H
$4%($(/($.4&* #+>+,.4; .0 )&-$(&*$%( %.)$&* '+*&($.4% 3$(#$4 %.)$+(;A .0(+4A &% $4 (#+?+',&4 )&%+A 3$(#./( (#+ #+>+,.4; .0 &4; -&'($)/*&' )*&%%= "#$% $% & -'.)+%% (#&(
'+&**; $4(+4%$0$+7 -'+)$%+*; 3#+4 @'$(&$4E% %/--.%+7 #+>+,.4; 3&% +5-+'$+4)$4> &-'+)$-$(./% 7+)*$4+A ;+( $( $% .6+'*..J+7 8; Z$*6+' $4 #+' )#&'&)(+'$Y&($.4 .0 (#+ *&((+'
9$4+(++4(# :+4(/'; &% & -+'$.7 .0 D%;%(+,$) )#&.%E &47 0./47+'$4> @'$($%#
#+>+,.4;= I47+'%(&47$4> (#+ 4&($.4&**; 7$%($4)( -'.)+%%+% &47 )*&%% %('&(+>$+%$46.*6+7 $4 (#+ ).4%.*$7&($.4 .0 )&-$(&*$%( %.)$&* '+*&($.4% $% )'/)$&**; $,-.'(&4( 0.'
&--'+#+47$4> (#+ 3.'*7 .'7+' ).4(+5( -'$.' (. 112= IP:K +4&8*+% /% (. 8'$4> $4(.
*$>#( (#+ >'&7/&*A /47+'*;$4> (+)(.4$) %#$0(% $4 3.'*7 .'7+' ).40$>/'&($.4% (#&( >$6+'$%+A 7$&)#'.4$)&**;A (. (#+ %;4)#'.4$)A %/'0&)+ D+&'(#C/&J+%E .0 )&-$(&*$%( )'$%$% &47
>+.-.*$($)&* ).40*&>'&($.4=
()"<.8',"3 E#*&6P;
F4 (+',% .0 /47+'%(&47$4> (#+ )#&**+4>+ (. (#+ @'$($%#H7.,$4&(+7 3.'*7 .'7+'A F
#&6+ 7+,.4%('&(+7 (#&( $( $% 4+)+%%&'; (. +,-#&%$Y+ (#+ 7+>'++ (. 3#$)# (#+ ,&R.'
8/17/2019 SGIR Uneven and Combined Development Paper
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sgir-uneven-and-combined-development-paper 23/29
)#&**+4>+ +,&4&(+7 -'$4)$-&**; 0'., (#+ )./'%+ .0 ?+',&4 7+6+*.-,+4(A '&(#+'
(#&4 & %;%(+,$)&**; /4$0.', '+R+)($.4 .0 @'$($%# *+&7+'%#$-=555$ @/( &% F #&6+ %#.34A?+',&4 7+6+*.-,+4( )&4 .4*; 8+ /47+'%(..7 $4 (#+ ).4(+5( .0 $(% '+*&($.4%#$- (.
@'$($%# 7.,$4&4)+A &47 (#+ ).47$($.4$4> +00+)(% .0 (#+ )&-$(&*$%( 3.'*7 ,&'J+( (#&(3+'+ ,&4$0+%(+7 (#'./># IP:K= F #&6+ %./>#( (. )#&**+4>+ (#+ 0./47&($.4% .0 (#+
(3. 7.,$4&4( +5-*&4&($.4% .0 (#+ &--'.&)# .0 112 3$(#$4 FB\ M$'%(*;A (#+ #$%(.'$)&*,&(+'$&*$%( /47+'%(&47$4> (#&( -'$6$*+>+% & %.)$.*.>$)&* +5-*&4&($.4 0.)/%+7 /-.4(#+ )'$%$% (+47+4)$+% .0 (#+ )&-$(&*$%( ,.7+ .0 -'.7/)($.4 &47 )*&%% %('/>>*+ &)'.%%
</'.-+= _47 %+).47*;A (#+ B+&*$%( &))./4(A 3#$)# %('+%%+% (#+ %$>4$0$)&4)+ .0 /4+6+4
-.3+' -.(+4($&* 8+(3++4 %(&(+% 8/( 0&$*% (. ).,-'+#+47 (#+ $4(+'4&* )#&'&)(+'$%($)%.0 7$00+'+4( %.)$&* 0.',&($.4% &47 (#+$' $,-&)( /-.4 0.'+$>4 -.*$);=
B+>&'7$4> Z$*6+'E% #$%(.'$)&* ,&(+'$&*$%( 0'&,+3.'JA (#+ 4.($.4 .0 D%;%(+,$) )#&.%E
(#&( %#+ -'.-.%+% O_''$>#$ P Z$*6+'A 2TT]\ 2]eQ $% /4&8*+ (. )&-(/'+ (#+ +5(+4( (.
3#$)# (#+ ).40*&>'&($.4 .0 2T2e 3&% 4.( .4*; & '+%/*( .0 (#+ )'$%$% .0 (#+ ?'+&(K+-'+%%$.4A 8/( ,.'+ %-+)$0$)&**; & ).4%+C/+4)+ .0 (#+ -&'($)/*&'$($+% .0 ?+',&4
7+6+*.-,+4(= F47++7A ?+',&4; 3&% &4 $4(+>'&* -*&;+' $4 (#+ '+(/'4 (. -'.(+)($.4$%,&47 (#+ '&$%$4> .0 (&'$00E% &0(+' 2^`T OZ+,,+*A 2TUXQ= F4 ,/)# (#+ %&,+ 3&; (#&(7$00+'+4( '/*$4> )*&%%+% #&7 %./># (. +,/*&(+ @'$($%# 0'++ ('&7+ 0.' (#+$' .34
8+4+0$(%A (#+; 4.3 %./>#( (. +,/*&(+ ?+',&4 -'.(+)($.4$%,= F4 & %$,$*&' 6+$4A L&;+'&47 G&*-+'$4E% &4&*;%+% 0&$* (. &))./4( 0.' (#+ %$>4$0$)&4( 7$6+'>+4)+% 8+(3++4
@'$(&$4 &47 ?+',&4; '+>&'7$4> %.)$&* 0.')+ %('&(+>$+%A $4%($(/($.4% &47 0.'+$>4
-.*$); -.%(/'+%=
B+&*$%( &4&*;%+% #&6+ '$>#(*; $7+4($0$+7 (#+ 7+>'++ (. 3#$)# (#+ +,+'>+4)+ .0/4+6+4 -.3+' 7$00+'+4($&*% ,&; )&/%+ 7$%(/'8&4)+% (. 7.,$4&4( -&((+'4% .0 3.'*7
.'7+'= 1#+'+ (#+; 0&$* $% $4 ).,,$(($4> & (3.0.*7 &8%('&)($.4\ 8; &8%('&)($4>
/4+6+44+%% 0'., $(% 8&%$% $4 (#+ 7;4&,$)% .0 & >$6+4 ,.7+ .0 -'.7/)($.4A &47A 8;&8%('&)($4> (#+ ,&(+'$&* &%-+)(% .0 -.3+' 0'., (#+$' $4(+>'&* %.)$&* ).4(+4(= IP:K
+4&8*+% /% 8.(# (. &))./4( 0.' (#+ 7$6+'>+4)+% $4 ,&(+'$&* )&-&8$*$($+% (#&( +,+'>+
0'., /4+6+4 +).4.,$) 7+6+*.-,+4(A &47 (. &))./4( 0.' (#+ 7$00+'+4( )*&%% -'&)($)+%(#&( $46+%( $4(+'%(&(+ %('&(+>$+% 3$(# %.)$&* ).4(+4(=
"#+ -'+%+4( $4C/$'; #&% %#+7 .4*; -&'($&* *$>#( /-.4 (#+ %/8R+)(A &77$($.4&* '+%+&')#
$4(. (#+ 7+6+*.-,+4(&* %-+)$0$)$($+% .0 M'&4)+A B/%%$& &47 _/%('$&HG/4>&'; $% ,/)#
4++7+7 $4 .'7+' (. 0/'(#+' &--'+#+47 (#+ -'+)$%+ ).4(./'% .0 (#+ /47+'*;$4>7;4&,$)% (#&( '+%/*(+7 $4 (#+ ./(8'+&J .0 112= F #&6+ #+'+ ./(*$4+7 .4*; (#+ 0$'%(
%J+()# $4 &4 &((+,-( (. '+7'&3 (#+ (#+.'+($)&* 0'&,+3.'J &47 ).4)+-(% 4+)+%%&';
0.' /47+'%(&47$4> (#+ &--'.&)# .0 (#+ ?'+&( 1&'=
8/17/2019 SGIR Uneven and Combined Development Paper
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sgir-uneven-and-combined-development-paper 24/29
G,+.,)36&/1>
_**$4%.4 : &47 _4$+6&% _ OWXXTQ "#+ I%+% &47 L$%/%+% .0 I4+6+4 &47 :.,8$4+7
K+6+*.-,+4(\ _4 _4&(.,; .0 & :.4)+-(= L+4,$:7@& M&3:&F #) N56&$5+6:#5+9
O))+:$' WWO2Q\ e`HU`=
_47+'%.4 a O2T`eQA *:5&+@&' #) 6B& O,'#9-6:'6 P6+6&= N.47.4\ 9+3 N+0( @..J%=_''$>#$ ? &47 Z$*6+' @ O+7%Q O2TTTQA LB+#' +57 8#3&$5+5%& :5 6B& 2#7&$5 /#$97
PA'6&4= N.47.4\ I4$6+'%$(; .0 L$44+%.(& a'+%%=
@'+44+' B O2T^dQ "#+ _>'&'$&4 B..(% .0 </'.-+&4 :&-$(&*$%,= F4\ _%#(.4 " &47
a#$*-$4 : O+7%Q KB& C$&55&$ Q&,+6&. O@$+$:+5 L9+'' P6$-%6-$& +57 R%#5#4:%
Q&3&9#E4&56 :5 S$&IN57-'6$:+9 R-$#E&= :&,8'$7>+\ :&,8'$7>+ I4$6+'%$(; a'+%%\
W2]H]WT=@'+44+' B O2T^dQ _>'&'$&4 :*&%% Z('/)(/'+ &47 <).4.,$) K+6+*.-,+4( $4 a'+H
F47/%('$&* </'.-+= F4\ _%#(.4 " &47 a#$*-$4 : O+7%Q KB& C$&55&$ Q&,+6&.
O@$+$:+5 L9+'' P6$-%6-$& +57 R%#5#4:% Q&3&9#E4&56 :5 S$&IN57-'6$:+9 R-$#E&=:&,8'$7>+\ :&,8'$7>+ I4$6+'%$(; a'+%%\ 2XHUe=
@'+44+' B O2TT]Q 2&$%B+56' +57 M&3#9-6:#5. L#44&$%:+9 LB+5@&J S#9:6:%+9 L#5)9:%6J+57 *#57#51' T3&$'&+' K$+7&$'J <UU?I<VUW= :&,8'$7>+\ :&,8'$7>+ I4$6+'%$(;a'+%%=
@'.,*+; Z O2TTeQ M&6B:50:5@ 2:779& R+'6 S#9:6:%'H _/%($4\ I4$6+'%$(; .0 "+5&% a'+%%=:&$4 a &47 G.-J$4% _ O2TT]Q C$:6:'B N4E&$:+9:'4. N55#3+6:#5 +57 RDE+5':#5J <V==I
<X<Y= N.47.4\ N.4>,&4=
:&**$4$).% _ &47 B.%+48+'> S OWXX^Q I4+6+4 &47 :.,8$4+7 K+6+*.-,+4(\ "#+Z.)$&*HB+*&($.4&* Z/8%('&(/, .0 D(#+ $4(+'4&($.4&*Ef _4 <5)#&4>+ .0 N+((+'%=
L+4,$:7@& M&3:&F #) N56&$5+6:#5+9 O))+:$' W2O2Q\ ``H2WW=:*&'J+ Z O+7Q O2TT2Q KB& P6+6& Q&,+6&= N.47.4\ L&),$**&4=
:.,4$4+* ? OWXXXQ <4>*$%# M+/7&*$%, &47 (#+ g'$>$4% .0 :&-$(&*$%,H Z#-$5+9 #)
S&+'+56 P6-7:&' W`O2Q\ 2 n d]=K&/4(.4 L OWXXXQ Z.)$+(; &47 <).4.,$) N$0+= F4\ L&((#+3 : O+7Q KB& [:5&6&&56B
L&56-$A. <=<UI<X?< \KB& PB#$6 TD)#$7 ]:'6#$A #) 6B& C$:6:'B N'9&'J <=<UI<X?<^=
g50.'7\ g50.'7 I4$6+'%$(; a'+%%\ e2H^d= K/((.4 K O2T^2Q "#+ I4$.4$%( a&'(; &47 Z.)$&* a.*$);A 2TXUH2T2eH KB& ]:'6#$:%+9
Z#-$5+9 WeOeQ\ ^`2H^^e= <*+; ? O2T`^Q B+%#&-$4> (#+ B$>#(\ B&7$)&* 9&($.4&*$%, &47 (#+ ?+',&4 9&6;
N+&>/+A 2^T^H2TX^= KB& ]:'6#$:%+9 Z#-$5+9 W2OWQ\ ]W`Hde=
<*+; ? O2T^eQ "#+ @'$($%# L.7+* &47 (#+ ?+',&4 B.&7\ B+(#$4J$4> (#+ :./'%+ .0?+',&4 G$%(.'; @+0.'+ 2T2e= F4\ @*&)J8/'4 K &47 <*+; ? O+7%Q KB&
S&%-9:+$:6:&' #) 8&$4+5 ]:'6#$A. C#-$@&#:' P#%:&6A +57 S#9:6:%' :5 [:5&6&&56BI
L&56-$A 8&$4+5A g50.'7\ g50.'7 I4$6+'%$(; a'+%%\ 2H2dd=<6&4% B O2T^`Q M&6B:50:5@ 8&$4+5 ]:'6#$A. [:5&6&&56B L&56-$A 8&$4+5A +57 6B&
T$:@:5' #) 6B& KB:$7 M&:%B= N.47.4\ _**+4 P I43$4=?$*-$4 B O2T^2Q /+$ +57 LB+5@& :5 /#$97 S#9:6:%'= 9+3 [.'J\ :&,8'$7>+ I4$6+'%$(;
a'+%%=
?.'7.4 L O2T`eQ K.,+%($) :.40*$)( &47 (#+ g'$>$4% .0 (#+ M$'%( 1.'*7 1&'\ "#+@'$($%# &47 ?+',&4 :&%+%= KB& Z#-$5+9 #) 2#7&$5 ]:'6#$A eUOWQ\ 2T2HWWU=
8/17/2019 SGIR Uneven and Combined Development Paper
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sgir-uneven-and-combined-development-paper 25/29
?/((%,&4 1 O2T^2Q KB& 8&$4+5 P#%:+9 Q&4#%$+6:% S+$6AJ <=>UI<XWW. "$#4 8B&66# 6#
8#3&$54&56 = N.47.4\ _**+4 P I43$4=G&*-+'$4 Z OWXXeQ /+$ +57 P#%:+9 LB+5@& :5 2#7&$5 R-$#E&. KB& 8$&+6
K$+5')#$4+6:#5 M&3:':6&7 = :&,8'$7>+\ :&,8'$7>+ I4$6+'%$(; a'+%%=G&'6++ : O2TTTQ B+6.*/($.4 &47 (#+ B/*+ .0 N&3= F4\ L.'>&4 j O+7Q O2TTTQ KB&
TD)#$7 ]:'6#$A #) C$:6+:5= g50.'7\ g50.'7 I4$6+'%$(; a'+%%\ e`XHd2^=G.8%8&3, < O2TUTQ N57-'6$A +57 R4E:$&= N.47.4\ a+4>/$4 a/8*$%#+'%=G/4( < O2T^2Q C$:6:'B *+,#-$ ]:'6#$AJ <=<UI<X<Y= N.47.4\ 1+$7+40+*7 &47 9$).*%.4=
F4>#&, ? O2T^eQ L+E:6+9:'4 Q:3:7&7_ KB& L:6A +57 N57-'6$A :5 C$:6:'B P#%:+9
Q&3&9#E4&56 = N.47.4\ L&),$**&4=S.** S O2T`eQ KB& P&%#57 N56&$5+6:#5+9J <==XI<X<Y= N.47.4\ B./(*+7>+=
j&$%+' K O2T^]Q ?+',&4; &47 (#+ g'$>$4% .0 (#+ M$'%( 1.'*7 1&'H KB& Z#-$5+9 #)
2#7&$5 ]:'6#$A ddO]Q\ eeWHe`e=
j&(Y4+*%.4 F O2T^UQ 1.'J$4> :*&%% M.',&($.4\ :.4%('/)($4> :&%+% &47
:.,-&'$%.4%= F4\ F'& j&(Y4+*%.4 &47 k.*8+'> _ O+7%Q /#$0:5@ L9+'' "#$4+6:#5.[:5&6&&56B L&56-$A S+66&$5' :5 /&'6&$5 R-$#E& +57 6B& `5:6&7 P6+6&'= 9+3
S+'%+;\ a'$4)+(.4 I4$6+'%$(; a'+%%\ ]Hed=j+,- " O2T^dQ N57-'6$:+9:;+6:#5 :5 [:5&6&&56B L&56-$A R-$#E&. P&%#57 R7:6:#5=
N.47.4\ N.4>,&4=
j+44+7; a O2T^XQ KB& M:'& #) 6B& O5@9#I8&$4+5 O56+@#5:'4J <=V?I<X<Y= N.47.4\ _**+4 P I43$4=
j+44+7; a O2T^^Q KB& M:'& +57 "+99 #) 6B& 8$&+6 S#F&$'. R%#5#4:% LB+5@& +57
2:9:6+$A L#5)9:%6 "$#4 <U??Ia???= N.47.4\ M.4(&4& a'+%%=j.)J& S O2T^UQ a'.8*+,% .0 1.'J$4>H:*&%% M.',&($.4 $4 ?+',&4;\ "#+ <&'*; [+&'%A
2^XXH2^`d= F4\ j&(Y4+*%.4 F &47 k.*8+'> _ O+7%Q /#$0:5@ L9+'' "#$4+6:#5.
[:5&6&&56B L&56-$A S+66&$5' :5 /&'6&$5 R-$#E& +57 6B& `5:6&7 P6+6&'= 9+3
S+'%+;\ a'$4)+(.4 I4$6+'%$(; a'+%%\ W`TH]dW=
N+4$4 m O2T`2Q P&9&%6&7 /#$0'. T5& b#9-4& R7:6:#5= 9+3 [.'J\ F4(+'4&($.4&*a/8*$%#+'%=
N$7(J+ m O2TUUQ KB& T-69+F&7 S+$6A = 9+3 S+'%+;\ a'$4)+(.4 I4$6+'%$(; a'+%%=
L&)B&$*7 K &47 L&'($4 K OWXXXQ *+,#-$ :5 C$:6:'B P#%:&6A <=W?I<X<Y= N.47.4\L&),$**&4 a'+%%=
L&((#+3 _ O2TTTQ "#+ N$8+'&* _>+\ 2^d2H2T2e= F4\ L.'>&4 j O+7Q O2TTTQ KB& TD)#$7]:'6#$A #) C$:6+:5= g50.'7\ g50.'7 I4$6+'%$(; a'+%%\ d]UHdd]=
L&;+' _ O2T^2Q KB& S&$':'6&5%& #) 6B& T97 M&@:4&. R-$#E& 6# 6B& 8$&+6 /+$H 9+3
[.'J\ a&4(#+.4 @..J%=L)j$88$4 B O2T^eQ /BA /+' KB&$& [# 2+$D:'4 :5 8$&+6 C$:6+:5_ KB& R5@9:'B
]:'6#$:%+9 M&3:&F TTO]T2Q\ WT`H]]2=
L+&'%#+$,+' S OWXX2Q KB& K$+@&7A T) 8$&+6 S#F&$ S#9:6:%'= 9+3 [.'J\ 1= 1= 9.'(.4P :.,-&4;=
L..'+ @ O2T`^Q N5c-'6:%&. KB& P#%:+9 C+'&' #) T,&7:&5%& +57 M&3#96 = 9+3 [.'J\ L= <=Z#&'-+=
9.*&4 L O2T^UQ <).4.,$) :'$%$%A Z(&(+ a.*$);A &47 1.'J$4> :*&%% M.',&($.4 $4
?+',&4;A 2^`XH2TXX= F4\ F'& j&(Y4+*%.4 F &47 k.*8+'> _ O+7%Q /#$0:5@ L9+''
"#$4+6:#5. [:5&6&&56B L&56-$A S+66&$5' :5 /&'6&$5 R-$#E& +57 6B& `5:6&7
P6+6&'= 9+3 S+'%+;\ a'$4)+(.4 I4$6+'%$(; a'+%%\ ]dWH]T`=
8/17/2019 SGIR Uneven and Combined Development Paper
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sgir-uneven-and-combined-development-paper 26/29
a'$)+ B O2TTXQ @'$(&$4= F4\ m&4 7+' N$47+4 L &47 B.R S O+7%Q KB& "#$4+6:#5 #)
*+,#-$ 2#3&4&56' <=>?I<X<Y. O5 N56&$5+6:#5+9 S&$'E&%6:3&= 9+3 [.'J\ <= S=@'$**=
B.%+48+'> S OWXXUQ 1#; $% "#+'+ 9. F4(+'4&($.4&* G$%(.'$)&* Z.)$.*.>;f R-$#E&+5
Z#-$5+9 #) N56&$5+6:#5+9 M&9+6:#5' 2WO]Q\ ]X`H]eX=
Z&%%..4 K O2TT`Q T5& ]-57$&7 d&+$' #) P#%:+9:'4. KB& /&'6 R-$#E&+5 *&)6 :5 6B&KF&56:&6B L&56-$A = N.47.4\ G&'-+' :.**$4%=Z&6$**+ S O2T^^Q KB& *+,#-$
2#3&4&56 :5 C$:6+:5. O L#44&56+$A = N.47.4\ M&8+' &47 M&8+'=
Z)#$%%*+' G O2TT2Q "#+ Z.)$&* &47 a.*$($)&* a.3+' .0 (#+ a'/%%$&4 S/4J+'%= F4\ ?$88.4
B &47 @*$4J#., L O+7%Q *+57#F5&$'B:E +57 S#F&$ :5 2#7&$5 R-$#E&= N.47.4\G&'-+' :.**$4%\ TTH222=
Z)#.'%J+ : O2T^]Q 8&$4+5 P#%:+9 Q&4#%$+%AJ <X?UI<X<>. KB& Q&3&9#E4&56 #) 6B&
8$&+6 P%B:'4= N.47.4\ G&'6&'7 I4$6+'%$(; a'+%%=
Z+,,+* @ O2TUXQ N4E&$:+9:'4 +57 P#%:+9 M&)#$4. R5@9:'B P#%:+9 N4E&$:+9 KB#-@B6J
<=XUI<X<Y= N.47.4\ _**+4 P I43$4=Z$*6+' @ OWXX]Q "#$%&' #) *+,#-$. /#$0&$'1 2#3&4&56' +57 89#,+9:'+6:#5 ':5%& <=>?=
:&,8'$7>+\ :&,8'$7>+ I4$6+'%$(; a'+%%=Z$4>+' S O2TU2Q "#+ N+6+*H.0H_4&*;%$% a'.8*+, $4 F4(+'4&($.4&* B+*&($.4%= /#$97
S#9:6:%' 2eO2Q\ ``HTW=
"+%)#J+ @ OWXX]Q KB& 2A6B #) <VY=. L9+''J 8&#E#9:6:%' +57 6B& 2+0:5@ #) 2#7&$5N56&$5+6:#5+9 M&9+6:#5'= N.47.4\ m+'%.
"+%)#J+ @ OWXXdQ @./'>+.$% B+6.*/($.4A Z(&(+ M.',&($.4 &47 (#+ _8%+4)+ .0 (#+
F4(+'4&($.4&*= ]:'6#$:%+9 2+6&$:+9:'4 2]OWQ\ ]HWU="#.,-%.4 _ O2TT`Q "&'$00 B+0.',\ _4 F,-+'$&* Z('&(+>;A 2TX]H2T2]H KB& ]:'6#$:%+9
Z#-$5+9 eXOeQ\ 2X]]H2Xde="#.,-%.4 < O2TUeQ KB& 2+0:5@ #) 6B& R5@9:'B /#$0:5@ L9+''= N.47.4\ m$)(.'
?.**&4)Y=
"'.(%J; N OWXX^Q ]:'6#$A #) 6B& M-'':+5 M&3#9-6:#5= :#$)&>.\ G&;,&'J+(=1&*(Y j O2T`TQ KB&#$A #) N56&$5+6:#5+9 S#9:6:%'= 9+3 [.'J\ B&47., G./%+=
1+88 B O2T^XQ 2#7&$5 R5@9+57. "$#4 6B& R:@B6&&56B L&56-$A 6# 6B& S$&'&56 =
N.47.4\ G&'-+' P B.3=1+#*+' G O2T`XQ @$%,&')JE% F,-+'$&*$%,A 2^UWH2^TX= S+'6 e S$&'&56 e^\ 22TH2dd=
1+#*+' G O2T^dQ KB& 8&$4+5 R4E:$&J <=><I<X<== N+&,$4>(.4 Z-&\ @+'> a/8*$%#+'%=1+47( _ O2TTdQ :.4%('/)($4> F4(+'4&($.4&* a.*$($)%= N56&$5+6:#5+9 P&%-$:6A W2O2Q\
`2H^2=
1..7 < O2TTdQ Q&4#%$+%A O@+:5'6 L+E:6+9:'4. M&5&F:5@ ]:'6#$:%+9 2+6&$:+9:'4= :&,8'$7>+\ :&,8'$7>+ I4$6+'%$(; a'+%%=
1..7 < OWXXWQ KB& T$:@:5 #) L+E:6+9:'4. O *#5@&$ b:&F = N.47.4\ m+'%.=
[+. < O2T^2Q :/*(/'+ &47 :.4%('&$4( $4 1.'J$4> :*&%% L.6+,+4(%A 2^]XH2^dd= F4\[+. < &47 [+. Z O+7%Q S#E-9+$ L-96-$& +57 L9+'' L#5)9:%6J <UX?I<X<Y.
RDE9#$+6:#5' :5 6B& ]:'6#$A #) *+,#-$ +57 *&:'-$&= Z/%%+5\ G&'6+%(+' a'+%%\ 2ddH2^`=
k.*8+'> _ O2T^UQ G.3 L&4; <5)+-($.4&*$%,%f F4\ j&(Y4+*%.4 F &47 k.*8+'> _ O+7%Q
/#$0:5@ L9+'' "#$4+6:#5. [:5&6&&56B L&56-$A S+66&$5' :5 /&'6&$5 R-$#E& +57
6B& `5:6&7 P6+6&'= 9+3 S+'%+;\ a'$4)+(.4 I4$6+'%$(; a'+%%\ ]T`Hed`=
8/17/2019 SGIR Uneven and Combined Development Paper
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sgir-uneven-and-combined-development-paper 27/29
J)0#;
$ M.' "'.(%J;A (#+ 0&)( (#&( 7$00+'+4( %.)$&* 0.',&($.4% +5-+'$+4)+7 7$00+'+4( '&(+% .0
%.)$&* 7+6+*.-,+4( /47+' *.)&**; %-+)$0$) ).47$($.4%A *+4( &4 D/4+6+44+%%E (. %.)$&*
7+6+*.-,+4(= "#$% /4+6+44+%% )./*7 >$6+ '$%+ (. & D).,8$4&($.4E .0 ,.7+% .0-'.7/)($.4 &47 #$%(.'$)&* %.)$&* 0.',% 3$(#$4 (#+ %(&(+=$$ j+44+(# 1&*(Y O2T`TQ .00+'% (#+ -&'&7$>,&($) %(&(+,+4( .0 (#+ 4+.HB+&*$%(&--'.&)# (. F4(+'4&($.4&* B+*&($.4%= _*(#./># 1&*(YE% &--'.&)# $% *&/7+7 0.' $(%
-&'%$,.4; &47 %)$+4($0$) '$>.'A $(% ,&R.' %#.'().,$4> $% (#+ $4&8$*$(; (. ).,-'+#+47
$4(+'4&($.4&* '+*&($.4% &% & #$%(.'$)&**; 6&'$&8*+ %-#+'+ .0 $4(+'&)($.4 O"+%)#J+2TT^\ ]W^H]WTQ= 1&*(Y %/8.'7$4&(+% 3.'*7 #$%(.'; (. &4 &#$%(.'$)&* %;%(+,$)
).47$($.4 .0 D&4&')#;E (#&( $,-/(+% & 0/4)($.4&* #.,.>+4+$(; /-.4 %(&(+%A '+47+'$4>$4C/$'; $4(. (#+ 7$%($4)($6+ #$%(.'$+%A $4%($(/($.4&* C/&*$($+% &47 )*&%% 0.')+% 3$(#$4%(&(+% %/-+'0*/./%=$$$ "#$% #&% 8++4 7.4+ ,.'+ %/))+%%0/**; 3$(# '+>&'7 (. 0+/7&* $4(+'%(&(+ '+*&($.4%O"+%)#J+A WXX]Q$6 "#$% #&% 4.( 8++4 & /4$0.', -'.)+%%= "#+ 7$00+'+4( -&(#% .0 %(&(+ 0.',&($.4 &47
6&'$+7 7+6+*.-,+4( .0 </'.-+&4 _8%.*/($%, &00+)(+7 (#+ +5-&4%$.4 .0 %(&(+ -.3+'O_47+'%.4A 2T`eQ=6 g0 )./'%+ (#$% $% 4.( (. %&; (#&( (#+ %(&(+ 7.+% 4.( ,&J+ $4(+'6+4($.4% $4(.D+).4.,$)E '+*&($.4%= "#+ %+-&'&($.4 8+(3++4 (#+ -.*$($)&* &47 (#+ +).4.,$) 7.+%
4.( '+0+' (. (#+ +5$%(+4)+ .0 & -+'0+)( 0'++ ,&'J+( &47 ).,-*+(+*; -'$6&(+ .34+'%#$-A
8/( '&(#+' (. (#+ ).47$($.4 $4 3#$)# (#+ *.)/% .0 -.*$($)&* -.3+' $% &*3&;% %+6+'&*%(+-% '+,.6+7 0'., (#+ -'.)+%% .0 -'.7/)($.4 $(%+*0=6$ "#+ %+-&'&($.4 8+(3++4 (#+ -.*$($)&* &47 (#+ +).4.,$) %#./*7 8+ (#./>#( .0 &% &
-+',&4+4( .8R+)( .0 )*&%% %('/>>*+ &47 & 0.',&* )#&'&)(+'$%($) (#&( (#+ %(&(+&((+,-(% (. /-#.*7 $4 .'7+' (. %+( *$,$(% /-.4 (#+ %).-+ .0 %.)$&* %('/>>*+% O:*&'J+A
2TT2\ ]2Q6$$ F( $% $,-.'(&4( (. 4.(+ #+'+ (#&( +6+4 3#+4 %('/>>*+% #&6+ 7+6+*.-+7 (. 0.)/%
/-.4 (#+ '.*+ .0 (#+ %(&(+A (#+ +4>&>+,+4( 3$(# )&-$(&* $% 4&7:+6&7 8; (#+ %(&(+=6$$$ F 3$** /%+ (#+ (3. (+',% $4(+')#&4>+&8*; #+4)+0.'(#=$5 ?+',&4 D+5)+-($.4&*$%,E $% +$(#+' /47+'%(..7 (. #&6+ &'$%+4 0'., $(% *.)&($.4
8+(3++4A ;+( ./(%$7+ .0A 8.(# (#+ _8%.*/($%, .0 (#+ <&%( &47 (#+ 7+,.)'&($)
7+6+*.-,+4( .0 (#+ 1+%(= g' &% & ).4%+C/+4)+ .0 (#+ %/'6$6&* .0 -'+H$47/%('$&*%.)$+(&* (+47+4)$+% O7/+ (. (#+ 0&$*/'+ .0 (#+ 2^e^ '+6.*/($.4Q (#&( *$,$(+7 (#+
7+6+*.-,+4( .0 (#+ %(&(+ &47 -'+6+4(+7 (#+ 8./'>+.$%$+ 0'., &7.-($4> $(% ('/+ '.*+&% &4 &>+4( .0 7+,.)'&($Y&($.4 O<*+;A 2T^e\ eXHeTQ=5 _% & ).4%+C/+4)+A (#+ $47/%('$&* +).4.,; .0 9$4+(++4(# :+4(/'; @'$(&$4 3&% #$>#*;
0'&>,+4(+7 &47 )#&'&)(+'$Y+7 8; %,&**H%)&*+ /4$(% OK&/4(.4A WXXX\ `eQ=
8/17/2019 SGIR Uneven and Combined Development Paper
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sgir-uneven-and-combined-development-paper 28/29
5$ "#+ *$,$(+7 '$>#(% &47 *$8+'($+% ).4(&$4+7 $4 (#+ @$** .0 B$>#(% -'.6$7+7 &).4%($(/($.4&* ).,,$(,+4( (. 8&%$) 0'++7.,% &47 >/&'&4(++7 (#+ '$>#( .0
).,,.4+'% (. -+($($.4 a&'*$&,+4( O1+88A 2T^X\ dXQ=5$$ "#$% .))/''+7 &( 0$'%( (#'./># (#+ '+-'+%+4(&($.4 .00+'+7 8; '&7$)&* *$8+'&*% %/)#
&% 1$**$&, :.88+( O1+88A 2T^X\ 2d2Q= _'./47 (#+ ,$77*+ .0 (#+ 9$4+(++4(# :+4(/';A1#$>% 0.',+7 -.*$($)&* %.)$+($+%A &((+,-($4> (. /4$(+ (#+ )*&%%+% /47+' & ).,,.4'+0.',$%( )&/%+ O[+.A 2T^2\ 2`dQ= _0(+' (#+ Z+).47 B+0.', _)( .0 2^U` (#+'+ 3&% &
7$%($4)( ,.7+'&($.4 .0 7+,&47% ).,$4> 0'., 8+*.3 OZ&6$**+A 2T^^\ 22Q=5$$$ "#+%+ &''&4>+,+4(% 3+'+ $4%($(/($.4&**; +,8+77+7 (#'./># (#+ 7+6+*.-,+4( .0(#+ @.&'7 .0 "'&7+A ).**+)($6+ 8&'>&$4$4> &47 (#+ -'.)+%% .0 $47/%('$&* '+*&($.4%
).4)$*$&($.4 OG/4(A 2T^2\ W^2V Z&6$**+A 2T^^\ eXQ=5$6 1.'J$4>H)*&%% -&'($)$-&($.4 $4 (#+ 0&$*+7 '+6.*/($.4 .0 2^e^ 3&% *$,$(+7A ).,$4>
,&$4*; 0'., &'($%&4&* 3.'J+'% 3#. 3+'+ %($** +,8+77+7 3$(#$4 (#+ 0+/7&* %;%(+, .0
+%(&(+ #$+'&')#; &47 >/$*7 .'>&4$Y&($.4 OL..'+A 2T`^\ 2WTV ?'+8$4>A 2TUT\ WUQ=56 L+,8+'%#$- +5)++7+7 .4+ ,$**$.4 8; 2T2e Oj&(Y4+*%.4A 2T^U\ W`V Z&%%..4A 2TT`V
9.*&4A 2T^UQ=56$ "#+ a'/%%$&4 S/4J+'%A >'+&( *&47+7 4.8*+%A 3+'+ & #$>#*; ).#+%$6+ )*&%% (#&(+4R.;+7 &4 $4($,&(+ '+*&($.4%#$- 3$(# (#+ a'/%%$&4 %(&(+ O<*+;A 2T^eV 1$*%.4A WXXeQ=56$$ F4 (&47+, 3$(# $47/%('$&* 7+6+*.-,+4(A ?+',&4; +5-+'$+4)+7 &4 +5-*.%$6+>'.3(# $4 -.-/*&($.4A &% 3+** &% /'8&4$Y&($.4 .4 & ,&%%$6+ %)&*+ O1+#*+'A 2TU`Q=56$$$ "#+ S/4J+'% 3+'+ (#+ ,&$4%(&; .0 (#+ %(&(+ 8/'+&/)'&); &47 (#+ ,$*$(&'; O<*+;A
2T^e\ 2WdQ=5$5 "#+ %(&(+E% ).,,$(,+4( (. %($0*$4> 3.'J$4> )*&%% .--.%$($.4 3&% +5+,-*$0$+7 8;
(#+ 6$>.'./%*; +40.')+7 _4($HZ.)$&*$%( *&3 .0 2^`U O<6&4%A 2T^`Q=55 I4*$J+ $4 @'$(&$4A +).4.,$) $%%/+% '+,&$4+7 $4($,&(+*; ).44+)(+7 (. C/+%($.4% .0
%.)$&* &47 -.*$($)&* -.3+'=
55$ "#$% ).4%$%(+7 $4 (#+ /4$0$)&($.4 .0 (#+ '/*$4> %('&(& &47 (#+ ,$77*+ )*&%% 8;&--+&*$4> (. & ).4)+-( .0 4&($.4&* /4$(; (#&( 3&% -'+,$%+7 /-.4 (#+ .%('&)$%, .0 (#+
ZaK &47 $(% 0.**.3+'% 3#. 3+'+ 7++,+7 D/4-&('$.($)E 7/+ (. (#+$' -'+0+'+4)+ 0.'
)*&%% -.*$($)% OZ)#.'%J+A 2T^]\ U2Q=55$$ "#$% $% 8+)&/%+A 0.' L+&'%#+$,+' OWXX2\ W2dQA (#+ 0.',&($.4 .0 (#+ "'$-*+ <4(+4(+
$4 2TXd &47 (#+ #&'7+4$4> .0 (#+ @'$($%# %(&4)+ (.3&'7% ?+',&4; &'.%+ +5)*/%$6+*;&% & ).4%+C/+4)+ .0 D)#&4>+% $4 (#+ &')#$(+)(/'+ .0 (#+ </'.-+&4 %;%(+,EA 8'./>#(
.4 8; ?+',&4;E% $4)'+&%+7 ,&(+'$&* -.3+'=55$$$ B.%+48+'> OWXX^Q #.-+% (#&( IP:K )&4 .6+').,+ (#$% -'.8*+,&($) &4($4.,; 8;)&-(/'$4> (#+A D7;4&,$)A $4(+'&)($6+ (+5(/'+ .0 %.)$&* '+&*$(;E=55$6 1#+'+ (#+; 7$00+' $% (#&( 3#$*+ L&'5$%(% $7+4($0; (#+ /47+'*;$4> 7;4&,$) &% (#+
D-'.0$( ,.($6+ .0 )&-$(&*$%( %.)$+($+%EA B+&*$%(% %('+%% (#+ D-.3+' %('/>>*+ &,.4>%(&(+%E O?$*-$4A 2T^2\ T]Q=556 B+&*$%( %)#.*&'%A 3+77+7 (. & -/'+*; ,&(+'$&*$%( &4&*;%$%A 0&$* (. &)J4.3*+7>+ (#+%$>4$0$)&4)+ .0 & %(&(+E% 8+#&6$./' $4 7+(+',$4$4> (#+ -.%(/'+ .0 .(#+' %(&(+%= "#+;
&((+,-( (. 7$%)./4( -+')+-($.4% .0 8+#&6$./' 0'., (#+ )&/%+% .0 )#&4>+% $4 (#+
8&*&4)+ .0 -.3+'= _% _*+5&47+' 1+47( O2TTdQ %/>>+%(%A 3#+(#+' %(&(+% &'+ D0'$+47%.' +4+,$+%E ,&((+'% 3$(# '+>&'7 (. 0.'+$>4 -.*$); )&*)/*&($.4%=
8/17/2019 SGIR Uneven and Combined Development Paper
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sgir-uneven-and-combined-development-paper 29/29
556$ F4 ?+',&4;A 4&($.4&*$%, '&(#+' (#&4 *$8+'&*$%, 0/4)($.4+7 &% (#+ ,&R.'$7+.*.>$)&* 0.')+ &)).,-&4;$4> (#+ ('&4%$($.4 0'., 0+/7&*$%, (. )&-$(&*$%, &47 (#+
).4%.*$7&($.4 .0 (#+ /4$0$+7 %(&(+=556$$ "#$4J$4> .0 (#$% %#$0( $4 (+',% .0 & ,.6+ 0'., DZ.)$&* F,-+'$&*$%,E (. DL$*$(&'$Y+7
F,-+'$&*$%,E ,&; 8+ #+*-0/*= "#+ *&((+' (+', 7+4.($4> & 0.', .0 F,-+'$&*$%, (#&(+5#$8$(% &4 $4)'+&%$4>*; 8+**$).%+ 7$%-.%$($.4 +5+,-*$0$+7 8; -'+)$-$(./% $4)'+&%+% $4,$*$(&'; )&-&8$*$(;=556$$$ <5-&4%$.4 3&% >+&'+7 (.3&'7% '$6&**$4> @'$(&$4E% 4&6&* -'+7.,$4&4)+= F( 3&%
#.-+7 (#&( (#$% 3./*7 #+*- ?+',&4; &)#$+6+ $(% D-*&)+ $4 (#+ %/4E Oj+44+7;A 2T^X\WW]V j&$%+'A 2T^]\ eeeQ=55$5 @$%,&')JE% %('&(+>; 0.' &)#$+6$4> >'+&(+' $4(+>'&($.4 #&7 8++4 8&%+7 /-.4 (#++5(+4%$.4 .0 & 3$7+H'&4>$4> 3+*0&'+ -'.>'&,,+ 7+%$>4+7 (. 8*/4( (#+ '&7$)&*$%, .0
(#+ ?+',&4 3.'J$4> )*&%%= F( 7$7 4.( #.3+6+'A >. 0&' +4./># (. &--+&%+ (#+ -.*$($)&*
&%-$'&($.4% .' (#+ ,&(+'$&* 4++7% .0 (#+ 3.'J$4> )*&%% &%-$'&($.4% ON$7(J+A 2TUU\2dTQ
555 _ %$,$*&'*; -.3+'0/* &47 -.*$($)&**; -'$6$*+>+7 &4($H,.7+'4 &>'&'$&4 %.)$&* 8&%+(. (#&( .0 ?+',&4; 7$7 4.( +5$%( 3$(#$4 @'$(&$4 O?.'7.4A 2T`eQ=555$ <5-*&$4$4> -+'$-#+'&* )#&**+4>+% (. @'$(&$4E% F,-+'$&* .'7+' 3./*7 .86$./%*;
'+C/$'+ & %/8%(&4($&**; 7$00+'+4( &4&*;%$%=