Date post: | 26-Dec-2014 |
Category: |
Business |
Upload: | sternekessler |
View: | 305 times |
Download: | 0 times |
USPTO13th Annual Independent Inventors
Conference August 8, 2008
Commercializing Intellectual Property Through Licensing
Michael LeeSterne, Kessler, Goldstein & Fox
Washington, DC
2
What is LES?
� A professional society, established in 1965, dedicated to high standards and ethics among persons engaged in licensing
� A community of 6,000 licensing professionals inthe USA and Canada
� A network of more than 12,000 licensing professionals around the world (LESI)
� A forum to share best practices, current standards, and trends in licensing and intellectual asset management
3
In What Industries do
LES Members Work?
29%
9%
10%
5% 3%
39%
Health Care
High Technology
Chemicals Energy &
Materials
Industry/University
Government Transactions
Consumer Products
Financial Markets
4
At What Types of Organizations?
34%
22%
14%
11%
5%
4%
4%3%2%1%
Corporation
Law Firm
Consultancy
University
Research
Sole Propreitor
Service Provider
Financial Services
Government
Student
5
What are the Benefits of
LES Membership?
� Networking
� Extensive formal andinformal opportunities
� Seasonal and annual meetings
� Industry-specific contacts and content
� Shared best practices
� Mentoring
� Education
� Local and national programs
� Learning from experts in the field
� Curriculum-based and experience-driven professional development
6
What are the Benefits of
LES Membership?
� LES Worldwide Membership Directory
� Publications
� les Nouvelles, the professional journal of licensing
� LES Viewpoints, the quarterly LES newsletter
� Licensing Consultants & Brokers Directory
� Access to the leading meetings on current licensing topics
� Reduced registration fees for meetings and educational programs
� Access to exclusive content on the LES website
� Opportunity to serve your profession and to be a member of a global organization
7
LES Education
2008 LES Technology Transfer SeminarSan Diego, CA, September 15-16, 2008
8
2008 LES ANNUAL MEETING
9
Licensing Certification
CLP Registry:
http://www.licensingcertification.org/
10
How Can You Learn More
About LES?
� Visit www.usa-canada.les.org
� Email: [email protected]
� Call: (703) 836-3106
� Attend: A Local LES Chapter Meeting
� Ask: Any Current LES Member
Commercializing IP
Common Goals & Themes
Licensing to support and further your present and future business objectives
(Requirement: Business Plan)
Maintaining control of your intellectual property
Managing risk as opposed to eliminating risk
12
Development and
Commercialization Timeline
� Development� Consultant agreement� Joint Development agreement� Material Transfer Agreement
� Marketing� Non-Disclosure Agreement (NDA) /
Confidentiality Agreement� Option Agreements
� Commercialization� License agreement� Collaboration / Partnering agreement� Manufacturing agreement
13
Importance of NDAs
Meeting with
Potential
Licensee/Partner/
Customer
File Patent Application Patent Issues
T1
T2
T1: Pendency at the USPTO
T2: Trade Secret & Contractual Protection (i.e., NDA)
T3: Contractual Protection
T4: Patent & Contractual Protection
T3 T4
14
Anatomy of a Confidentiality
Agreement (1)
� Control Disclosure� �hold all Confidential Information in
strict confidence�
�Exclude (or precisely define) subsidiaries, parents, affiliates, etc.
�Define �Confidential Information�� Subject matter as well as medium (i.e.,
software, test boards)
� Return of Confidential Information
15
Anatomy of a Confidentiality
Agreement (2)
� Control Use
� �use the Confidential Information only for evaluating a possible business transaction between the Parties�
� No license to any IPRs
� Retain ownership
� No obligation to disclose
16
Anatomy of a Confidentiality
Agreement (3)
� Term�Typically equal to the time needed to
exchange, analyze and assess the Confidential Information
�Obligations concerning disclosure and use should survive expiration or termination� Consider when your patent applications
will publish
17
Anatomy of a Confidentiality
Agreement (4)
Beware of Residuals Clauses� �The obligations on use shall not apply to Confidential
Information which the Receiving Party can demonstrate was retained in the unaided memories of the Receiving Party�
� Rights are limited to use, not disclosure� Do patents trump?� �The foregoing will not be deemed to grant to Recipient a
license under Disclosing Party�s copyrights, patents or other intellectual property rights.�
� Unaided memory; without reference to documents or materials
� If you are forced to sign a NDA with a residuals clause, limit what you disclose; negotiate a new NDA ASAP
18
Review: Development and
Commercialization Timeline
� Development� Consultant agreement� Joint Development agreement� Material Transfer Agreement
� Marketing� Non-Disclosure Agreement (NDA) / Confidentiality
Agreement� Option Agreements
� Commercialization� License agreement� Collaboration / Partnering agreement� Manufacturing agreement
19
Consultant Agreement (1)
� Ownership of Intellectual Property� Secure ownership of the IP where the consultant is a co-
inventor � Joint and Several ownership. Each joint owner of a patent
can sell or license without the consent or accounting to the other owners
� �All worldwide rights, title and interest in and to the Work Product, and all intellectual property rights in and to the WorkProduct, shall belong exclusively to Company.�
� �Work Product includes any intellectual property conceived, produced or reduced to practice by Consultant, alone or with others, resulting from or relating to the consulting services for Company.�
� Consider extending this obligation for a reasonable period of time after termination of the consultant agreement
20
Consultant Agreement (2)
� Present assignment of IP to be developed in the future (promise to assign is not sufficient)� �Consultant hereby assigns and
transfers to Company all of Consultant's worldwide rights, title and interest in and to all Work Product.�
� List Consultant�s Pre-Existing IP
21
Consultant Agreement (3)
� Reporting requirement
� �Consultant and Company shall meet at least once per month, and Consultant shall promptly disclose all Work Product in writing to Company during such meetings.�
� Reasonable non-compete
� Defined by subject matter and/or competitors
� Reasonable period of time
22
Joint Development Agreement (1)
� Ownership� Company 1 Pre-Existing IP
� Company 2 Pre-Existing IP
� Jointly Developed IP (who owns?)
� Joint ownership: Each owner can sell and license without consent of or accounting to the other owners
� Party 1 owns; Party 2 is granted a license
� Each party is given rights in a separate entity that owns the IP
23
Joint Development Agreement (2)
� Potential encumbrances on the other party�s Pre-Existing IP� Technology licensed from third parties� Ownership issues� Open source
� Patent Prosecution� Who controls? Who pays?� What happens if there is a disagreement on
which inventions to patent, and/or countries to pursue?
� Enforcement
24
Review: Development and
Commercialization Timeline
� Development� Consultant agreement� Joint Development agreement� Material Transfer Agreement
� Marketing� Non-Disclosure Agreement (NDA) / Confidentiality
Agreement� Option Agreements
� Commercialization� License agreement� Collaboration / Partnering agreement� Manufacturing agreement
25
The Effect of a License Agreement
Licensor Licensee
Consideration
IP Rights
Royalties Services Improvements
TimeField of
Use Territory ExclusivityImprovements
Other
Consideration
26
IP That Can Be Licensed
� Patents
� Know-How
� Trade Secrets
� Copyrights
� Trademarks
� Domain Names
27
Rights That Can Be Licensed (1)
� Patents� Make
� Use
� Sell
� Example� License 1: Make and Sell Widgets
� License 2: Use Widgets in government applications
� License 3: Use Widgets in non-government applications
28
Rights That Can Be Licensed (2)
� Copyrights
- Reproduce
- Distribute
- Display
- Transmit
- Publicly Perform
- Prepare Derivative works
� Example
� License 1: Reproduce and distribute Licensed Music
� License 2: Publicly perform Licensed Music
29
Types of License Agreements (1)
� In-Licenses: Others license their IP to you
� Out-Licenses: You license your IP to others
30
Types of License Agreements (2)
� Trade Secret / Know-How License� Maintenance of trade secrets (and penalties
for disclosure of trade secrets)� Training (possible opportunity for consultant
agreement)
� Patent License� Geographical and temporal scope of
royalties
� Hybrid License� Patents + Trade Secrets + Know-How� Allocate royalties among patents & TS/KH
31
Types of License Agreements (3)
� Exclusive: All rights granted to a single licensee�Performance milestones / minimum
royalties
� �best efforts�
� Sole: A single licensee, but licensor may also practice the IP
� Non-Exclusive: Multiple licensees
32
Anatomy of a License Agreement
� Recitals� Definitions� Grant� Royalty� Term/Termination� Assignability/Transferability� Representations and Warranties� Confidentiality
33
Recitals
� Specifies the nature of the transaction and the intent of the parties
� Useful to educate the reader
34
Definitions
� Defines terms that are used throughout the agreement
� Example: �Licensed Subject Matter
� Patents, trademarks, copyrights: Listed in schedules
� Trade Secrets and Know-how: Important to carefully define and establish boundaries
35
Grant
� What is being licensed?
�Definition of the Licensed Subject Matter is key
�What rights are being granted (for example, make/use/sell for patents?)
� Who is being licensed?
�Parents, subsidiaries, affiliates
36
Grant � Specifications/Limitations
� Use�Government vs. private sector
�WIFI vs. cellular
�Commercial vs. non-commercial
� Time�For the next 5 years
� Geography�Country / State / City / County
37
Grant - Example
� Licensor grants to Licensee a license under the Licensed Patents to make and sell Widgets in the United States east of the Mississippi River.� Who? Licensee� What? Licensed Patents� Rights? Make and sell� Field of Use? Widgets� Geographical scope? East of the Mississippi� Length? Specified in Term/Termination
section
38
Grant � Other Considerations
� Release from past infringement
� Right to sub-license
� Grantbacks
39
Royalty � Advanced / Upfront
Payments
� Generally, more common in exclusive licenses
� Sometimes applied against future royalties
� Sometimes paid upon satisfaction of milestones
40
Royalty � Ongoing Payments
� Royalty schedule
� Volume discount
� Increase upon issuance of patents
� What is the base?
� RF transceiver or the cell phone?
� Exclusive license
� Performance milestones / minimum royalties / cure by cash
� Convert to non-exclusive license
41
Royalties � Other Considerations
� Paid up license
�Discount for the time value of money
� Reporting/Auditing
�Mechanisms for licensee to report royalty calculation and licensor to verify accuracy.
42
Term/Termination
� Term�Defines the length of the license
� Future date certain
� �last to expire patent�
� Termination�Mechanisms for early termination of
the agreement� Breach
� Failure to satisfy milestones
43
Term/Terminator � Survival of
Clauses
� Some terms should survive expiration/termination
�Confidentiality
�Sell Off
� Patent Indemnification
44
Assignment
� Defines whether agreement may be assigned/transferred to another party
� Very important that individuals / small companies be able to assign in the event of an acquisition
45
Representations and Warranties
� Representation: A statement of fact made to induce another to enter a contract.
� Warranty: A part of the contract that must remain true in accordance with its terms.
� Examples:� Ownership
� Patent infringement (knowledge qualified)
46
Confidentiality
� Cannot disclose terms of the license
� Cannot disclose the existence of the license�Exception for legal counsel,
accountants, potential acquiring parties, potential licensees
�Exception for press release; identification as licensee on website
47
Other Terms
� Most favored licensee
� Best efforts
� Waiver
� Arbitration
� Governing law
� Integration, Severability, Force Majeure, Notices
48
Licensing Timeline Example
1. Invent and prepare a prototype� Consultant agreement� Joint development agreement
2. Select and implement IP protection strategy� Patents, trade secrets, trademark, copyright
3. Develop business plan; identify markets / partners / customers
4. Develop licensing strategy5. Meetings with potential partners / customers
� Non-disclosure agreement
6. Negotiate key terms� Term Sheet
7. Draft license agreement� Joint development agreement
� Collaboration / Partnering agreement� Manufacturing agreement
8. Negotiate and execute license agreement9. Post execution maintenance
Questions?
Licensing Executives Society (U.S.A. and Canada), Inc.
1800 Diagonal Road, Suite 280Alexandria, VA 22314
(703) 836-3106www.usa-canada.les.org
Michael LeeSterne, Kessler, Goldstein & Fox
Michael Lee is a patent attorney and Director with Sterne, Kessler, Goldstein & Fox, an IP firm in Washington, DC. Mr. Lee is an experienced licensing attorney, and has been awarded Certified Licensing Professional status. He works with clients of all sizes to strategically protect, leverage and license their intellectual assets to support and further their business objectives.
Mr. Lee earned his law degree from Georgetown University, and holds Masters and Bachelors degrees in electrical engineering from theUniversities of Maryland and Virginia, respectively.
Mr. Lee is a Trustee and a Vice President-elect of the Licensing Executives Society. He served as Meeting Chair of the LES Winter Meeting 2007 in San Francisco, and is currently Program Chair of the 2008 LES Annual Meeting in Orlando, FL.