+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ......

Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ......

Date post: 27-Jun-2018
Category:
Upload: votruc
View: 212 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
48
Mark Strikman, Penn State University LANL, April 11, 2005 Small x physics: from HERA to LHC
Transcript
Page 1: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

Mark Strikman, Penn State University

LANL, April 11, 2005

Small x physics: from HERA to LHC

Page 2: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

• Imaging a fast nucleon.

• Onset of black regime of interaction for small dipoles

• Centrality trigger for pp collisions.

Outline

Page 3: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

Role of High energy QCD: ☛ Understanding the dynamics of strong gluon

fields at small x: interesting by itself ; important for effective searches for new particles

New unique probes of the nucleon structure

Forward QCD dynamics is crucial for interpretationof the cosmic ray interactions near GZK cutoff

Page 4: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

So far major successes of QCD in describing high energy hadron hadron collisions were for hard inclusive processes - collision of two partons. Sufficient to know only longitudinal single parton densities.Knowledge of ☛ the transverse spread of partons ☛ longitudinal and transverse correlations of partons which depend on flavor, x polarization of the parton, is necessary for◈ building a realistic description of the global structure of the final states in pp collisions ◈ understanding microscopic structure of nucleon bound state.

Progress in the recent years was due to the study of hard diffraction at HERA and related studies at Tevatron.

Page 5: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

Sensitive to small differences in sea quark distribution

• pT and rapidity distributions are very sensitive to pdf• particularly sensitive variable:

ratio of W+/W− cross section measures u(x)/d(x)

PDF from W/Z production

Example: study for 0.1 fb-1, i.e. 2·106 W→µν produced

Three years from now LHC will dramatically change the field of QCD studies - parton densities, final states, etc

J.Mnich: SM physics at LHC

Study of final states in this reaction will allow also to compare transverse sizes of configurations in the nucleon with leading u-quark and leading d-quark. MS

Page 6: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

Want to be able to take CT scans of nucleon

in 3 D in quark and gluon light at different momentum resolutions

Learn how nucleon responds to various stimuli:

instead of one dimensional scans - parton densities - which should continue especially at very small x.

Correlations between partons

Correlations between longitudinal momenta of partons and transverse size of the nucleon.

Implications for propagation of partons through nuclei and for leading twist nuclear shadowing

Page 7: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

Image of nucleon at different resolutions, q. Rest frame.

1000 > q > 300 MeV/c

q > 1000 MeV/c

Constituent quarks, pions (picture inspired by chiral QCD)

pQCD evolution

qq̄ pair in π

+ + ...

resolution 1 fm, q < 300 MeV/c

resolution 1/3 fm

Page 8: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

Key features of high energy QCD:Slow space-time evolution of the fast component of the high energy wave functions of colliding hadrons (Lorentz slow down)

Already at a rather modest resolution of the probe, Q~ 2 GeV, nucleon consists of not simply three quarks and few gluons but of tens of constituents and the number of constituents rapidly grows with energy.

u−quark gluon

Q2= 40 GeV

2

Q2= 4 GeV

2

CTEQ5M

Gluons carry ~50% of the nucleon momentum at the resolution scales as low as (nonperturbative dynamics). Speeds up generation of strong gluon fields at small x.

Q2 ∼ m2N

Page 9: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

HERA F2

0

1

2

3

4

5

1 10 10 2 10 3 10 4 10 5

F 2 em-lo

g 10(x

)

Q2(GeV2)

ZEUS NLO QCD fit

H1 PDF 2000 fit

H1 94-00

H1 (prel.) 99/00

ZEUS 96/97

BCDMS

E665

NMC

x=6.32E-5 x=0.000102x=0.000161

x=0.000253x=0.0004

x=0.0005x=0.000632

x=0.0008

x=0.0013

x=0.0021

x=0.0032

x=0.005

x=0.008

x=0.013

x=0.021

x=0.032

x=0.05

x=0.08

x=0.13

x=0.18

x=0.25

x=0.4

x=0.65

Page 10: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

Fits: F2p(x,Q2) ∝ x−λ

xg(x,Q2) ∝ x−λxq̄(x,Q2) ∝ x−λ

Page 11: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

l coh

12

4

1

3

34

2

d

(a) (b)

(c) longitudinal momentum transverse coordinate

Image of nucleon at different resolutions, q. Fast frame.

Energy dependence of the transverse size of small x partons.

R2(n)≈ nk2t0 Random walk in b-space (Gribov 70). (Drunken sailor walk)

Page 12: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

n ∝ y =⇒ R2 = R20+ cy≡ R20+ c′ lns

Length of the walk rapidity, y as each step a change in rapidity of few units.

Implications:

(a) The transverse size of the soft wee parton cloud should logarithmically grow with energy.

Logarithmic increase of the t-slope of the elastic hadron-hadron scattering amplitude with energy:

f (t) ∝ exp(Bt/2), B(s) = B0+2α′ ln(s/s0)

α′ ∝ 1/k2t0

Page 13: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

Momentum P in z directiontr

ansv

erse

siz

e of

the

par

ton

clou

d

→←wee parton are spread over 1 fm even at high energies

→ →

z= rN< x>

xP

z= rN< x>

xP

Transverse size of x>0.1 quarks and gluons is smaller than the average proton size

due to the pion predominantly due to the

pion cloud effects - Frankfurt, MS, Weiss

Projection of the fast nucleon in transverse coordinate/longitudinal momentum - low resolution scale

Page 14: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

Longitudinal momentum/transverse Image at High resolution

Implications: (b) Gribov diffusion is much weaker as the transverse momenta in most of the decay ladder are much larger than the soft scale. Transverse size shrinks with increase of resolution scale!!! No analogous effect in classical mechanics (brain images).

Evidence: for the process

α′γ + p→ J/ψ + p

is smaller than for soft processes by a factor of two.

Additional important effect: transverse distribution of x≥.05 gluons in the nucleon is significantly smaller than a naive guess based on the e.m. radius of the nucleus.

Confirms our prediction of 94 - BFGMS

Page 15: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

Implication - hard processes correspond to collisions where nucleons overlap stronger & more partons hit each other - use hard collision trigger to study central collisions.

x1 x2

x1,2 = 2 / W ~ 10−2

hard dijetq

T = 100 GeV

qT

"central"

b

soft

hard

"peripheral"(dominate totalcross section)

b

Page 16: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

x2 = 4p2⊥/x1s

Why this is interesting/ important? ● Amplification of the small x effects: in proton - proton collisions a parton with given x1 resolves partons in another nucleon with

x1 = 0.01, p⊥ = 2GeV/c ⇒ x2 ∼ 10−5At LHC● Resulting strong difference between the semi-soft component of hadronic final states at LHC &Tevatron in events with production of Z, W, Higgs, SUSY,... and in minimal bias events.

⇒ Necessary to account for new QCD phenomena related to a rapid growth of the gluon fields at small x: parton “1” propagates through the strong gluon field of nucleon “2”.

Hence, accumulation of higher twist effects and possible divergence of the perturbative series.

In proton-ion, ion-ion collisions collisions at small impact parameters are strongly different from the minimal bias events. Is this true also for pp collisions?

Page 17: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

● Determination of the transverse distribution of gluons.

● Strength of of “small dipole”-nucleon interactions at high energies

To quantify the difference of the impact parameters and the role of small x gluon field we can use theoretical analyses of the hard phenomena studied at HERA:

Page 18: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

QCD factrorization theorem for DIS exclusive processes (Brodsky,Frankfurt, Gunion,Mueller, MS 94 - vector mesons,small x;

general case Collins, Frankfurt, MS 97)

!"#$%&'( )("$$*#'&+ !#%(*)), -.'(. ') ("/(0/"1/* '& !%-*#) %2 3 4.* '&5'(*) /"1*/

$.* 5'22*#*&$ !"#$%& )!*('*)3 4.* (%&$#'10$'%& %2 5'"+#"6) '& -.'(. $.* ."#5 )("$$*#'&+ !#%(*))

'&7%/7*) 6%#* $."& $.* 6'&'606 &061*# %2 !"#$%&) ') )0!!#*))*5 18 3 9& '6!%#$"&$ (%&:

)*;0*&(* %2 2"($%#'<"$'%& ') $."$ $.* =5*!*&5*&(* %2 $.* "6!/'$05* #*)$) *&$'#*/8 '& $.* >?@3

4.0), 5'22*#*&$ !#%(*))*) !#%1'&+ $.* )"6* >?@ ).%0/5 *A.'1'$ $.* )"6* =5*!*&5*&(*3

4.2 Space–time picture: “Squeezing” of hadrons

4.* !.8)'() %2 ."#5 *A(/0)'7* !#%(*))*) "$ )6"// 1*(%6*) 6%)$ $#"&)!"#*&$ -.*& 2%//%-'&+

$.* )!"(*=$'6* *7%/0$'%& '& $.* $"#+*$ #*)$ 2#"6*3 9) '& $.* (")* %2 '&(/0)'7* )("$$*#'&+, $.')

"!!#%"(. "//%-) %&* $% *A!%)* $.* /'6'$) %2 $.* /*"5'&+=$-')$ "!!#%A'6"$'%&, "&5 $% ;0"&$'28

!%-*# (%##*($'%&) 50* $% $.* !&'$* $#"&)7*#)* )'<* %2 $.* !#%50(*5 6*)%&3

B& *A(/0)'7* 7*($%# 6*)%& !#%50($'%&, , %&* ("& '5*&$'28 $.#** 5')$'&($ )$"+*)

'& $.* $'6* *7%/0$'%& '& $.* $"#+*$ #*)$ 2#"6*3 4.* 7'#$0"/ !.%$%& 5'))%('"$*) '&$% " 5'!%/*

%2 $#"&)7*#)* )'<* "$ " $'6* (%. 1*2%#* '&$*#"($'&+ -'$. $.*

$"#+*$, !"# C;3 DEF3 4.* 5'!%/* $.*& )("$$*#) 2#%6 $.* $"#+*$, "&5 G/'7*)H 2%# " $'6*

1*2%#* 2%#6'&+ $.* !&"/ )$"$* 7*($%# 6*)%&3 4.* 5'22*#*&(* '& $.* $'6* )("/*) ') 50* $% $.*

)6"//*# $#"&)7*#)* 6%6*&$" D7'#$0"/'$'*)F "//%-*5 18 $.* 6*)%& -"7* 20&($'%& ") (%6!"#*5 $%

$.* 7'#$0"/ !.%$%&3

B& $.* /*"5'&+ /%+"#'$.6'( "!!#%A'6"$'%& '& IJ@ , $.* *22*($) %2 IJ@ #"5'"$'%& ("&

"+"'& 1* "1)%#1*5 '& $.* "6!/'$05* 2%# $.* )("$$*#'&+ %2 $.* )6"//=)'<* 5'!%/* %22 $.* $"#+*$3 B$

("& 1* ).%-& 18 5'#*($ ("/(0/"$'%& %2 K*8&6"& 5'"+#"6) $."$ $.* /*"5'&+ $*#6 2%# )6"// 5'!%/*

)'<*) ') !#%!%#$'%&"/ $% $.* +*&*#"/'<*5 +/0%& 5')$#'10$'%&, *22 , -.*#* *22

LMN3 9 )'6!/*# "!!#%"(. ') $% '&2*# $.* #*)0/$ 2%# $.* '6"+'&"#8 !"#$ %2 $.* "6!/'$05* 2#%6

$.* *A!#*))'%& 2%# $.* (#%)) )*($'%&, C;3 DOF, 7'" $.* %!$'("/ $.*%#*63 4.* '6"+'&"#8 !"#$ ')

!#%!%#$'%&"/ $% $.* +*&*#"/'<*5 +/0%& 5')$#'10$'%& "$ "&5 3 9$ )02!('*&$/8 /"#+*

$

%P

!%%P

!#%(*))Q"#5R)("$$*#'&+

"6!/'$05*S*)%&R5')$#'10$'%&

>*&*#"/'<*5!"#$%&R5')$#'10$'%&

"

&

!"T'

(

K'+0#* UV K"($%#'<"$'%& %2 $.* "6!/'$05* %2 ."#5 *A(/0)'7* 6*)%& !#%50($'%&, C;3 DPWF3

PX

Page 19: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

Extensive data on VM production from HERA support dominance of the pQCD dynamics. Numerical calculations including finite transverse size effects explain key elements of high data. The most important ones are:

Q2

Energy dependence of production; absolute cross section of production.

J/ψ

J/ψ,ϒ

Absolute cross section and energy dependence of ρ-meson production at . Explanation of the data at lower is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties of the low gluon densities.

Q2 ≥ 20 GeV 2 Q2

Q2

●●

Page 20: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

Universal t-slope: process is dominated by the scattering of quark-antiquark pair in a small size configuration - t-dependence is predominantly due to the transverse spread of the gluons in the nucleon - two gluon nucleon form factor,

Onset of universal regime FKS[Frankfurt,Koepf, MS] 97.

Convergence of the t-slopes, B ( ), of ρ-meson electroproduction to the slope of J/psi photo(electro)production.

rT ∝1Q

(1mc

)! rN

Transverse distribution of gluons can be extracted from

dσdt

= Aexp(Bt)

γ+ p→ J/ψ+N

Fg(x, t). dσ/dt ∝ F2g (x, t).

3456789

10111213

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40

ρ ZEUS (prel.)ρ ZEUS

φ ZEUS (prel.)φ ZEUSJ/ψ ZEUSJ/ψ H1

ρ H1

Q2 (GeV2)B

(GeV

-2)

ρ

J/ψ

d

Page 21: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

γ + p J/ψ + p, <E > = 100 GeVγ Theoretical analysis of photoproduction at corresponds to the two-gluon form factor of the nucleon for

which is larger than e.m. dipole mass

m2e.m. = 0.7 GeV 2.

The difference is likely due to the chiral dynamics - lack of scattering off the pion field at x>0.05 (Weiss &MS 03)

(FS02)

Binkley et al 82

☝ ☝ ☝ Large difference between impact parameters of soft interactions and hard interactions especially for xparton > 0.01.

J/ψ100 GeV ≥ Eγ ≥ 10 GeV

0.03≤ x≤ 0.2, Q20 ∼ 3 GeV 2,−t ≤ 2 GeV 2Fg(x,Q2, t) = (1− t/m2g)−2. m2g = 1.1 GeV 2

Page 22: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

The gluon transverse distribution is given by the Fourier transform of the two gluon form factor as

Fg(x,ρ;Q2) ≡Z d2Δ⊥

(2π)2 ei(Δ⊥ρ) Fg(x, t =−Δ2⊥;Q2)

It is normalized to unit integral over the transverse plane:Zd2ρ Fg(x,ρ;Q2) = 1.

Fg(x,ρ) =m2g2π

(mgρ2

)K1(mgρ)

The dependence is accounted using LO DGLAP evolution at fixed . Q2 ρ

Fg(x, t) = 1/(1− t/mg(x)2),m2g(x= 0.05)∼ 1GeV 2,m2g(x= 0.001)∼ 0.6GeV 2.For x=0.05 it is much harder than e.m. form factor (dynamical origin - chiral dynamics) ⇒ more narrow transverse distribution of gluons than a naive

expectation. (Frankfurt, MS , Weiss -02-03)

2

x-dependence of transverse distribution of gluons

Page 23: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

In order to analyze the strengths of interaction with the gluon fields at small x it is convenient to consider virtual photon - nucleon scattering in the nucleon rest frame.

Space-time picture of DIS, exclusive vector meson production - a three step process:

Slow evolution of this wave package.

● transition γ∗ → h where h are various qq̄,qq̄g . . .configurations long before the target:

lcoh ∼ c(Q2)q0/Q2,c(Q2)≤ 1

interaction of the evolved configurations with the target,

formation of the final state.

Page 24: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

A delicate point: in pQCD the cross section depends both on thetransverse separation between quark and antiquark and the off-shellness (virtuality) of the probe which produced the pair. In most of the models on the market this is ignored.

Convenient to introduce a notion of the cross section of the interaction of a small dipole with the nucleon. Such a cross sectioncan be legitimately calculated in the leading log approximation. One can also try to extend it to large size dipoles hoping that a reasonably smooth matching with nonperturbative regime is possible.

qq̄

Page 25: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

σinel =π2

3 F2d2αs(λ/d2)xGT(x.λ/d2)

d

F2 Casimir operator of color SU(3)

F2 F2(quark) =4/3 (gluon)=3

Consider first “small dipole - hadron” cross section

Comment: This simple picture is valid only in LO. NLO would require introducing mixing of different components.

Page 26: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

= 10

= 4 x = 0.0001

x = 0.001

x = 0.01

d (fm)

10.90.80.70.60.50.40.30.20.10

45

40

35

30

25

20

15

10

5

0

qq

N−

!

""

(d

, x

, Q

)

(m

b)

2

The interaction cross-section, σ̂ for CTEQ4L, x = 0.01, 0.001, 0.0001,λ = 4, 10. Based on pQCD expression for σ̂ at small dt, soft dynamics atlarge b, and smooth interpolation. Provides a good description of F2p atHERA and J/ψ photoproduction.

Frankfurt, Guzey, McDermott, MS 2000-2001

M.Strikman

HERA data confirm increase of the cross sections of small dipoles predicted by pQCD

Provided a reasonable prediction for σL

Page 27: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

σtot = 2Zd2bReΓ(s,b)

σinel =Zd2b(1− (1−ReΓ(s,b))2− [ImΓ(s,b)]2

σel =Zd2b|Γ(s,b)|2

Impact parameter distribution in “h”(dipole)p interactionStudy of the elastic scattering allows to determine how the strength of the interaction depends on the impact parameter, b:

Γh(s,b) =12is

1(2π)2

Zd2!qei!q!bAhN(s, t)

Γ(b) = 1 ≡ σinel = σel

- black body limit.

; ImA= sσtot exp(Bt/2)

)

Note that elastic unitarity: 12ImA= |A|2+ ... allows Γ(b)≤ 2

Page 28: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

0 0.5

0.5

1

1b (fm)b (fm)b (fm) 0

0.5

1

ΓΓΓΓ Γ Γ qq ggqqqq

d = .5 (fm)

0 0.5

0.50.5

1

1 1

0

0.5

1

d = .1 (fm)

x = 10−2

x = 10−3

x = 10−4

x = 10−5

0 0.5 10

0.5

1

d = .3 (fm)

gggg

Using information on the exclusive hard processes we can also estimate t-dependence of the elastic dipole-nucleon scattering and hence estimate

Γqq̄ f rom σ(qq̄N).

In the case gg-N scattering we assume pQCD relation Γgg =94Γqq̄

Page 29: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

Can use hard diffraction to check proximity to BBL

xP

t

H

MX

Hard scatteringprocess

Diffractive partondistribution

g, q, q−

QCD factorization theorem for diffractive processes consistent withthe data to define universal diffractive parton densities:

f Dj (xxIP

,Q2,xIP, t)

Page 30: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

Pj(x,Q2)

To test proximity to BBL it is useful to define and calculate the probability of diffractive scattering depending on the type of parton coupling to the hard probe

If is close to 1/2 interaction of “J” parton approaches BBL

0

0.5

1

10-5 10-4 10-3 10-2 10-1

P u-

x

anti-u

Q = 2 GeV5 GeV

10 GeV

0

0.5

1

10-5 10-4 10-3 10-2 10-1

P g

x

gluon

Q = 2 GeV5 GeV

10 GeV

Pg(x≤ 3 ·10−4,Q2 = 4GeV 2)≥ 0.4 !!! FS98

Pj(x,Q2) =Zdt

ZdxIP f Dj (x/xIP,Q2,xIP, t)

/f j(x,Q2)

Page 31: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

ConclusionIncident partons which have large enough energies to resolvex ∼ 10−4 ÷ 10−5 in the target nucleon and which pass close

enough b ≤ 0.5fm from the nucleon, interact with the nucleon in aregime which is likely to be close to the black body regime.

M.Strikman

Page 32: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

Implications for LHC - impact parameters for collisions with new particle production vs generic inelastic collisions

Hard dynamics governs the BLACK BODY (BB) regime inhadron-hadron collisions at small impact parameters (FSZ 04)

New hard dynamics for fragmentation in pA and AA collisions

Page 33: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

First consider central pA collisions

1x ~10 !1

pT

x ~102

!5

Black body limit in central collisions: Leading partons in the proton, x1, interact with a dense medium of small x2– gluons in the nucleus (shaded area), acquiring a large transverse momentum, . p⊥

Page 34: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

What happens when a parton goes through strong gluon fields? It will be resolved to its constituents if interaction is strong. To estimate the transverse momenta of the resolved system use a second parton as a regularization - consider the propagation of a small dipole of transverse size d, which interacts in LO pQCD with cross section:

σinel =π2

3 F2d2αs(λ/d2)xGT(x.λ/d2)

Casimir operator of color SU(3)

F2(quark) =4/3 (gluon)=3

F2

F2

Page 35: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

Q2e f f ∼ 4p2⊥

To estimate the maximum transverse momentum for interactions close to the BBL, we can treat the leading parton as one of the constituents of a small dipole scattering from the target. This “trick” allows us to apply the results of our study of the dipole –hadron scattering. In this analogy, the effective scale in the gluon distribution is , corresponding to an effective dipole size of d ≈ 3/2p⊥

Criterion of proximity to BBL:

Γ”dipole”A(b= 0)≥ Γcrit ∼ 0.5 corresponding to probability of inelastic collision of .75

Page 36: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

0

1

0 50 100

!dA

(b=0

)

p2" [GeV2]

12C

206Pb

!crit

x1 = 0.10.2

0

20

40

60

0.001 0.01 0.1 1

p2 ! ,B

BL

[GeV

2 ]

x1

" s = 14 TeV

12C206Pb

Black–body limit in central collisions (a) The profile function for the scattering of a leading gluon in the proton (regarded as a constituent of a dipole) from the nucleus at zero impact parameter, , as a function of the transverse momentum squared, (b) The maximum transverse momentum squared, BBL, for which the interaction of the leading gluonis“black” (for quarks it is a factor of two smaller).

Page 37: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

fast partons in a nucleon before collisions

fast partons in a nucleon after central collisions

g gqq

Characteristics of the final state in the central pA(pp) collisions

Page 38: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

1N

(dNdz

)pp→h+X= ∑

a=q,g

Zdxx fa(x,Q2e f f )Dh/a(z/x,Q2e f f )

The leading particle spectrum will be strongly suppressedcompared to minimal bias events since each parton fragments independently and splits into a couple of partons with comparable energies. The especially pronounced suppression for nucleons: for the differential multiplicity of pions should exceed that of nucleons.

z≥ 0.1

Page 39: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

Can one study the same effects in pp?

Main idea/Qualitative expectation: hard partons are more localized in transverse plane - gluon density in a nucleon at small impact parameters is comparable to that in nuclei at small b. Hence in events with hard interaction spectator partons experience much stronger gluon fields.

x1 x2

x1,2 = 2 / W ~ 10−2

hard dijetq

T = 100 GeV

qT

"central"

b

soft

hard

"peripheral"(dominate totalcross section)

b

Page 40: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

Impact parameter distribution for a hard multijet trigger.

For simplicity take x1 = x2 for colliding partons producing two jets withx1x2 = 4q2

⊥/s. Answer is not sensitive to a significant variation of xi for

fixed q⊥.

The overlap integral of parton distributions in the transverse plane, definingthe b–distribution for binary parton collisions producing a dijet follows fromthe figure:

!

!

1

2

b

M.Strikman

Page 41: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

Study of the elastic scattering allows to determine how the strength of the interaction depends on the impact parameter, b:

Γh(s,b) =12is

1(2π)2

Zd2!qei!q!bAhN(s, t)

Γ(b) = 1 ≡ σinel = σel

P(b) = 2 ReΓ(b)− |Γ(b)|2Probability of inel. interaction:

- black body limit.

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

0 1 2

| Γpp

(b) |

2

b [fm]

s1/2 = 500 GeV1.8 TeV14 TeV

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

0 1 2

2 Re

Γpp

- | Γ

pp |2

b [fm]

Calculation uses model of Islam et al

Impact parameter distribution in pp interaction

Broadening of the distribution over b is primerely a result of Gribov diffusion.

Page 42: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

0

1

2

0 1 2 3

2 !

b P

(b)

/ fm

-1

b / fm

s1/2

=

14000 GeV

P2

P4

Pin

0

1

2

0 1 2 3

2 !

b P

(b)

/ fm

-1

b / fm

s1/2

=

1800 GeV

P2

P4

Pin

0

1

2

0 1 2 3

2 !

b P

(b)

/ fm

-1

b / fm

s1/2

=

500 GeV

P2

P4

Pin

Difference between b-distributions forminimal bias and dijet, four jet events

strongly increases with increase of incidentenergy. Solid lines: b–distributions for thedijet trigger, P2(b), with q⊥ = 25 GeV , as

obtained from the dipole–type gluonρ–profile. Long–dashed line: b–distribution

for double dijet events, P4(b).Short–dashed line: b–distribution for

generic inelastic collisions.

M.Strikman

Page 43: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

Let us estimate what average transverse momenta are obtained by a parton in the collision at a fixed b. Estimate involves several steps.

for given ρ - distance of the parton from the center of another nucleon - determining maximum virtuality - minimal size of the dipole- d, for which Γ =0.5.

● converting from d to average < p2⊥ >

● taking into account distribution over ρ for given b

Fixing fast parton’s x (x1) resolved by collision with partons

in other proton

Determining what minimal x are resolved in the second proton for given virtuality

acquired bya spectator partonp⊥ ≈ Maximal for which

interaction remains black for given

p⊥

x=4p2⊥x1s

,Q2 = 4p2⊥ small x↔ largex1

x1

Page 44: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

Also, a spectator parton in the BBL regime loses a significant fraction of its energy similar to electron energy loss in backscattering of laser off a fast electron beam.

0

10

20

30

0 0.5 1

p2 ⊥, B

BL

[GeV

2 ]

b [fm]

√ s = 14 TeV

x1 = 0.10.20.3

0

10

20

30

0 0.5 1

p2 ⊥, B

BL

[GeV

2 ]

b [fm]

√ s = 1.8 TeV

x1 = 0.10.20.3

The critical transverse momentum squared, below which the interaction of a leading gluon with the other proton is close to the black body limit, as a function b (x1)For leading quarks, the values of are about half of those for gluons. p2⊥,BBL

0

10

20

0.001 0.01 0.1 1

<p2 !

, BBL

> [G

eV2 ]

x1

" s = 14 TeV

P2P4

0

10

20

0.001 0.01 0.1 1<p

2 ! ,

BBL>

[G

eV2 ]

x1

" s = 1.8 TeV

P2P4

Page 45: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

≡ |1−Γ(b)|2

If a leading parton got a transverse momentum p⊥

probability for a nucleon to remain intact is

In central pp collision at collider energies leading quarks get transverse momenta > 1 GeV/c

Pq ∼ F2N(p2⊥)

If 〈p⊥〉> 1GeV/c=⇒ Pq% 1/2

However there are three leading quarks (and also leading gluons) in each nucleon.

⇒ Probability not to interact ≤ [Pq]6 ∼ 0

☛ Γ(b∼ 0) = 1 !!!Explains the elastic pp data for small b, predicts an increase of b range, b<bF where Γ=0, bF=c ln s - Froissart regime.

Page 46: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

Qualitative predictions for properties of the final states with dijet trigger

● The leading particle spectrum will be strongly suppressedcompared to minimal bias events since each parton fragments independently and splits into a couple of partons with comparable energies. The especially pronounced suppression for nucleons: for the differential multiplicity of pions should exceed that of nucleons.

z≥ 0.1

● Average transverse momenta of the leading particles ≥ 1 GeV/c

Many similarities with expectations for spectra of leading hadrons in central pA collisions.

A large fraction of the dijet tagged events will have no particles with $ . This suppression will occur simultaneously in both fragmentation regions, corresponding to the emergence of long--range rapidity correlations between the fragmentation regions ⇒ large

z≥ 0.02−0.05

energy release at rapidities y=4 -6.

Page 47: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

Background cannot be modeled based on study of minimal bias events.

Implications for the searches of new heavy particles at LHC.

☛ Events with production of heavy particles should contain a significant fraction of hadrons with transverse momenta originating from fragmentation of partons which passed through by the strong gluon field. Transverse momenta of these hadrons are unrelated to the transverse momenta of the jets. Strong increase of multiplicity at central rapidities: a factor ~2 increase observed at FNAL, much larger at LHC.

p⊥ ∼ p⊥,BBL

p⊥ ( jet)" p⊥,BBL⇒ Difficult to identify jets, isolated leptons,... unless

⇒Significant corrections to the LT approximation results for total cross sections and small differential cross setions of new particle production.

p⊥ ≤ p⊥,BBL

Page 48: Small x physics: from HERA to LHC - LANL · Small x physics: from HERA to LHC ... Higgs, SUSY, ... and in minimal ... is more sensitive to the higher twist effects, and uncertainties

Conclusions

★ Small x physics is an unavoidable component of the new particle physics production at LHC. Significant effects already for Tevatron.

Minijet activity in events with heavy particles should be much larger than in the minimum bias events or if it is modeled based on soft extrapolation from Tevatron.

★ Significant corrects for the LT predictions especially for moderate transverse momenta.

Double hard processes at Tevatron provides evidence for transverse correlations between partons. Maybe due to lumpy structure of nucleon at low scale (constituent quarks) [ did not have time to discuss]. Further studies of transverse correlations are necessary both at Tevatron and at RHIC in pp and pA scattering to improve modeling of LHC event structure.

★ Total opacity at small b ( ) in pp collisions is due transition from soft to semi hard QCD - consistent with expected changes of the inelastic events for small impact parameters.

Γ= 1


Recommended