Social Assistance in China main challenges for the policy design
and implementation
Marzena Breza, PhD EU Resident Expert
EU-China Social Protection Reform Project
Geneva, Nov 19th-20th, 2015
United Nations Economic Commission for Europe
Working Group on Ageing
Presentation is under the sole responsibility of its author and do not necessarily reflect the views of the European Commission or the Consortium of the EU-China Social Protection Reform Project.
China as a transition economy
• „The government gradually developed new social assistance schemes and increased financial investment to establish a basic policy framework of social assistance that adapts to the system of market economy.” Baseline report, C3 EU-China SPRP, 2015
Challenges for China – socio-economic aspects
• From central planning to market economy • Ageing population • Increase of Social Assistance spending • Increase in number of Social Assistance recipients • Regional (province) disparities in development
and wellbeing of the citizens • Urban-rural gap (income, social infrastructure
facilities, labour market demand, ect.) • Social Assistance organization – legal provisions
Social Assistance Benefits - Introduction
• Benefits in kind • Benefits in cash • Eligibility – income/assets test • Dibao Beneficiaries 5% (70 milion) of the total
population • Different benefits levels for urban and rural areas • Differentiations between provinces:
– 500 RMB (70 euro) – e.g. Shanghai, Beijing – 200 RMB (29 euro) – e.g. Henan, Sichuan
• Target group vs. Low rate of the benefits
Social Assistance Benefits (1) • Minimum Livelihood Guarantee – Dibao – benefit in
cash (as a pilot project introduced in early 90s in Shanghai) from 1999 in cities and from 2007 in rural areas
The MLGS is an income supplementary assistance system, which makes sure that the income of the population in poverty can be kept at a certain level (Dibao line), so that they have the capacity to purchase basic living consumables (1st assessment report, C3 EU-China SPRP, 2015) • Urban • Rural
Social Assistance Benefits (2)
• Five guarantee (in rural areas) since 1950s – for food, fuel, clothing, education and burial.
• Medical Assistance • Temporary Assistance • Disaster Assistance • Others
Table 1. Expenditures of urban & rural MLGS (RMB)
Year Total expenditure (100 million)
Local financial expenditure Central financial subsidy Amount
(100 million) Proportion (%)
Amount
(100 million) Proportion (%)
1999 13.8 9.8 71% 4 28.9% 2000 25.6 17.6 69% 8 31% 2001 46.3 23.3 50% 23 50% 2002 115.8 69.8 60% 46 40% 2003 162.4 70.4 43% 92 57% 2004 188.9 86.9 46% 102 54% 2005 191.5 105.2 48% 112 52% 2006 267.6 131.6 49% 136 51% 2007 386.4 196.4 51% 190 49% 2008 622.1 266.1 43% 356 57% 2009 845.1 304.3 36% 540.8 64% 2010 969.7 335.1 36.7% 634.6 63.3% 2011 1327.6 323.0 24.3% 1004.6 75.7% 2012 1392.3 521.8 37.5% 870.5 62.4% 2013 1623.6 455.7 29.1% 1167.9 71.9% 2014 1592.0 570.6 35.9% 1021.4 64.1%
Data source: Annual China Social Service Development Report (various years) and internal data from Ministry of Civil Affairs. 1st assessment report, C3 EU-China SPRP, 2015
Figure 1. Number of Urban and Rural MLGS recipients
Source: Ministry of Civil Affairs, China Civil Affairs' Statistical Yearbook, 2014 1st assessment report, C3 EU-China SPRP, 2015
Figure 2. Average Dibao received by eligible households and minimum living standard in urban areas, by province, 2013
Data source: Annual China Social Service Development Report (various years) and internal data from Ministry of Civil Affairs. 1st assessment report, C3 EU-China SPRP, 2015
Figure 3. Total Expenditures for Medical Assistance
12813.7
15776.23
21625.021
0
5000
10000
15000
20000
25000
2009 2010 2011
Mill
ion
Yua
n
Year
0.05% GDP
Sources: China Civil Affairs Statistical Yearbook 2012, Finance Yearbook of China 2012 1st assessment report, C3 EU-China SPRP, 2015
Figure 4. National Expenditures for Disaster relief
35781.879
34714.85
4065.401
4001.205 5294.9
6257.977 7900.9 7984.0
60980.837
19919.08 23718.3
12870.262
0
10000
20000
30000
40000
50000
60000
70000
1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
Mill
ion
Yua
n
Year
Less than 0.1% GDP
Source: China Civil Affairs Statistical Yearbook 2012 1st assessment report, C3 EU-China SPRP, 2015
Figure 5. Expenditures for Temporary Assistance
1802.436 1603.409
3405.845
5009.254
8415.099
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
7000
8000
9000
2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
Mill
ion
Yua
n
Year
0.032% GDP
Sources:China Civil Affairs Statistical Yearbook 2012 1st assessment report, C3 EU-China SPRP, 2015
Legal provisions on Social Assistance in China
• Interim Measures for Social Assistance (2014) - the highest level of authority document
• Several other notices, legal acts established on provincial or city level
• Lack of one comprehensive legal act on Social Assistance in China
To be further developed…
General Social Assistance Law Sharing responsibilities/information/supervision
– central, province, local level State Owned Enterprices vs. Social Assistance
demand Professional knowledge and skills of social
assistance workers Cooperation with NGOs Social Assistance Dependency Social Assistance Benefits overlapping issue
EU-China SPRP
Main goal: to exchange the best practices in the social assistance between the EU and China EU partners – public authorities from BE, CZ,
FR, IT, PL, RO and ES. CN main Stakeholders: NDRC, MoF, MoCA Project implementation period Nov 2014 -
Nov 2018
EU-China SPRP – cooperation opportunities
• Exchange practices and experiences by EU experts in China
• Involvement in the activities held in Europe for Chinese stakeholders
• Sharing knowledge and other kind of contribution on working level