906 First Street East Hastings, MN 55033
USA
[email protected] www.CheetahDevelopment.org +1 (612) 382-3533
Solving the Biggest Puzzle in International Development
Cheetah Development1 is an investor developing solutions that
benefit smallholder farmers. These are the typically farmers with less
than 2 hectares (5 acres), comprising the majority of the poor on
earth. Ironically, although farmers, they usually fail to feed
themselves, while their opportunity is to feed the world. They are the
largest demographic on the planet, some 2 billion people.
Like a Rubik’s Cube, there is
are almost endless
variations for aid,
international development,
and smallholder empowerment, but solving for sustainable
profitability has proven elusive.
Over the past six years, Cheetah
Development has spent millions of
dollars
piloting
a
revolutionary new approach to
smallholder income and
management.
Herein are a series of commonly
asked questions regarding Cheetah
with brief answers. We also have
further documents available and
stand ready for a further discussion.
There are creative solutions that really work. And like the Rubik’s
Cube, the steps to a solution can be learned.
This isn’t just the biggest puzzle in the world, it is the biggest
opportunity.
Don’t suffer a meltdown. Come and see.
1 Within this document, “Cheetah” is inclusive or our investment company, our funds, and companies we start.
Cheetah’s mantra is simple: Turn crops into cash.
P a g e 2
Q: WHAT IS CHEETAH DEVELOPMENT’S APPROACH?
Cheetah Development is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit investor,
managed by business people, creating for-profit
investable opportunities.
Cheetah sustains a double bottom line: we
improve the livelihoods of smallholder farmers
and we make profits. These objectives are not in
conflict – instead, they are perfectly aligned. Every
partner in a healthy value-chain must add value and
receive value. The same is true for smallholders. We
do the obvious: End poverty by creating income.
Cheetah focuses on the key
underlying problems that
have kept farmers poor:
markets and finance. Depending upon perspective,
there are a number of other ways to understand Cheetah’s distinctive approach.
Foundational Approaches Business Model Key Innovations
Philanthropy for Initial Risk Capital: The context of these investments can be perceived as high-risk. Cheetah mitigates that risk by piloting investment opportunities within its nonprofit.
Farmer Market Partnership: In order to end poverty, we need to shift from giving to the poor and start buying from them. Cheetah partners with smallholder farmers, joining our success to theirs.
Making Farmers Investable: Becoming investable is subtle but important distinction from the current efforts undertaken. Every activity needs to be accountable and enforceable. Without it there is not enough money to end poverty.
Business for Self-Sustainability and Returns on Investment: We don’t do projects – we start businesses. The latter has no planned end-date dependent upon donors for extensions. By further providing a return on investment, we are able to attract capital for growth.
Solve Value-Chain Gaps: In agriculture, what is missing are the layers of small and medium businesses that surround smallholder farmers. These are gaps – there is little or nothing there. The solution is not investing in existing entrepreneurs but starting from scratch.
Metafinance: (Not microfinance) Metafinance is a system of engaging local banks in agriculturally related finance to support communities of smallholders. It is a scale of finance not currently available and it overcomes many of the challenges for microfinance in rural areas.
Capital for Scalability: Real economies need massive amounts of capital to grow and exist. Donor will never be able to provide a sufficient infusion of cash to sustainably end the horrors of poverty that these people suffer from. What is needed is to make the pie bigger, not just redistribute wealth.
Franchise-Like Replicability: Having the businesses be replicable lowers the cost of future investments, increases the likelihood of success, causes all business processes to be carefully determined and managed, shares successes between different locations, creates resilience, and helps operations to cross cultures.
Micro Venture Capital: As with metafinance, our Micro Venture Capital model is designed to place investments in the “Missing Middle”. It uses business pilots, franchising, and shared back office support to successfully enter this investment gap.
Don’t give to the poor,
buy from them.
P a g e 3
Q: WHO BENEFITS FROM WORKING WITH CHEETAH?
Cheetah Development simply allows partners to accelerate the
pace and confidence at which they work with smallholder
farmers. It is a model where everybody wins.
1. Smallholder Farmers and Their Communities: Cheetah
creates solutions that typically increase smallholder
incomes ten-fold or more, just in the first year. Crop
yields swell, families start to eat, put their children in
school, and buy medicine. Indeed, we have an
independent study that shows that there is such a jump
in ‘disposable’ income that communications and
transportation show the largest percentage growth in
family spending. These
benefits spread out and
impact entire communities.
2. Value-Chain and Other
Partners: Cheetah designs its
work and investments to
enable smallholders to
successfully engage with
partners. These partners are
typically value chain
companies like crop input
suppliers or food processors,
they are NGOs doing
development work among
smallholders, they are
commercial banks or investors
engaging smallholders or
value-chain companies, or they are government agencies supporting their constituency. Buyers
of crops are able to receive reliable supplies of high quality. Banks are able to consistently achieve
high repayments of loans, while gaining large numbers of new depositors.
3. Investors and Entrepreneurs: Smallholder farmers represent the largest demographic on the
planet, the most intractable problem, AND the biggest opportunity. They occupy a space where
large business opportunities are ready to be developed. The world’s population is still growing
rapidly as are the number of people in the middle class. Developing nations, especially those in
Africa are well positioned to become major food producers worldwide. Investors and business
people working this opportunity are likely to be significantly rewarded for their patience.
Crops from Cheetah farmers and unassisted farmers planted on the same day. Managing the inputs, finance, the logistics and guaranteeing markets is where we really set ourselves apart.
Integrating Smallholders into Economic Opportunities
At Cheetah Development, we
accelerate your ability to work with
smallholder farmers – at scale –
through an innovative business
model that makes smallholders
investible and trustworthy even to
the largest banks and multinational
brands.
This isn’t just the biggest puzzle in the
world, it is the biggest opportunity.
P a g e 4
Q: WHAT IS THE PREMISE OF THE BUSINESS MODEL?
While smallholder farmers may be pre-commercial in reality, they must be treated commercially as small
businessmen tied to profit in order to be successful and not co-dependent. To accomplish this requires
debt (so farmers can produce more) and equity (so value-
chains that connect to farmers are created). The current
situation is a vicious cycle.
Cheetah Development provides both debt capital and equity
investing. Our debt capital differs substantially from
microfinance which finances a single farmer at $30-$300. We
focus on “The Missing Middle” of $5000-$500,000 loaned to
farmer cooperatives (often villages) to become small
businesses that can hire others and mitigate risk. In short, we
finance small and medium enterprises versus individuals. In
addition, we invest in creating markets for smallholder
production filling in gaps where the solution is both scalable
and repeatable (much like a franchise model). Cheetah
expects repayment because of the success in transforming the
smallholders and our execution team both on the ground and
through the use of financial and agronomic technology
ensures the highest performance rates in the industry.
Q: DOES IT WORK FOR SMALLHOLDERS?
As mentioned previously, Cheetah has an independent study demonstrating substantial first year impact.
Although we expect more of these studies to be conducted in the future, Cheetah’s objective is livelihood
development not the more difficult targets like training, health, etc. Therefore, we are able to see
intrinsically measured results – they are a part of our financial data, which is audited. Here are typical
results for smallholder farmers:
An average of $20 free cash to over $200 in the first growing season. These numbers often double
in subsequent years and we have farmers now earning over $1000 in profits.
Crop yields averaging 5 to 10x per acre what was previously produced.
Access to finance at 6 to 10x in the first year and up to 30x by the fourth year.
No group loans have failed to date, with around 50 having been issued.
Farmer repayment rates average around 85% in the first year and then rise to over 95%.
Every farmer receives a bank account, which previously was only around 5% of the population.
No farmers have ever voluntarily left the program.
The finance of smallholder farmers with large loans has been historically a very difficult proposition. It is
one of the reasons commercial banks are reluctant to give loans without external support. Nevertheless,
Cheetah has been able to demonstrate a significant track record of success.
Farmers produce little for sale
• So no commercial loans
• So no reliable market causing much waste
Food businesses lack crop inputs
• So limited growth and investment
• So they import needed volume competing with nearby farmers
The current economic situation is a vicious cycle that requires investments in two spheres simultaneously.
P a g e 5
Q: WHAT IS THE HISTORIC PROBLEM OF FINANCING THE
“MISSING MIDDLE”?
The Missing Middle is
a gap of businesses
that are largely
absent in the
developing world.
The corresponding
lack of funds was
identified in a
worldwide study by
the German Marshal fund as the predominant cause of this gap.
However, investing in Missing Middle is difficult because size of
investment is small compared to needed vetting, accounting,
mentoring, management etc. Therefore, investors have avoided
this space though it is the key size for business development.
Q: HOW DOES CHEETAH SOLVE FOR THE MISSING MIDDLE?
Cheetah has established both a debt and an equity fund. Each of these funds target opportunities
related to creating success for smallholder related businesses. They are usually deployed jointly.
Debt/Metafinance:
We find banks need to have externally mitigated risk at the outset or they will not participate in
lending. Therefore, we place capital equal to the required collateral on deposit. It is placed in
USD so it is not subject to currency risk.
Then with Cheetah’s coordination, the bank makes and manages the loan. Local banks have
more ability to collect on failed loans – a strength that is not lost on the borrower.
The loan is place directly with the farmer group – who is provided the farm inputs/equipment
rather than the money – under management of Cheetah.
The inputs are distributed to individual small groups as in the microloan model. If a small group
fails to repay, the larger group is still responsible.
Finally, Cheetah provides a market for the crops.
Equity/Micro Venture Capital:
Venture capitalists have avoided smaller investments for good reason: they require too much
investment management to achieve returns on that work. Cheetah overcomes this by the following:
Pilot businesses internally in the nonprofit before placing investments.
Use a franchise model to replicate success so that future investments have a lower risk and
reduced cost of investment management.
Share back-office services companies to lower investment costs, risks, and improve quality.
Microfinance: good but not enough
Although one may debate the extent to
which MFI loans transform the lives of the
poor, the simple fact that MFI lending has
reached its current scale is a remarkable
achievement. …However, the structure of
its success in lending to the poor is such
that we cannot count on it to be a
stepping-stone for larger businesses to be
created and financed. Finding ways to
finance medium scale enterprise is the
next big challenge for finance in
developing countries.
-From first major study of microfinance
(conducted by MIT), “Poor Economics: A
Radical Rethinking of the Way to Fight
Global Poverty” by Banerjee and Duflo
The Missing Middle Problem: (Small/Medium companies
lack access to finance of this size)
Microfinance(Typically $30-300; usually
too little to hire people)
Int l Finance & Big Venture Capitalists(Typically over $2 Million; too much
for most early stage companies)
Emp
loye
es
Investment Targets
Inve
stme
nt
Need
ed
100
5
250
1
$Millions
$500,000
$5,000
$0
P a g e 6
Q: HOW DOES CHEETAH MANAGE RISK?
Managing risk is built into all of Cheetah’s work from the ground
up. For example, there are 30 actions taken to mitigate risk in
the Metafinance model.
The fundamental distinction between making a smallholder
investable and all other work engaging with smallholders is
exactly in this area. This means that all activities must be
accountable and enforceable. For example,
smallholders cannot just be offered
training, they must be held accountable
to learning the material and employing
it in their own crop management. Risk management is therefore built into all of
the company’s processes. And as Michael Porter demonstrates, process is not
red-tape, it is competitive advantage.
Since Cheetah uses a franchise-like replicability for its businesses, it is documenting its processes to a
greater degree than is ordinary. This gives us both a competitive advantage and a risk advantage.
Q: WHAT IS CHEETAH’S EQUITY INVESTMENT STRATEGY?
In order of approximate priority, here is what Cheetah seeks when selecting investment opportunities:
1. Profitable 2. High impact – change livelihoods significantly 3. Ag or ag/food/inputs value chain 4. Replicable – can be replayed and cross
cultures 5. Scalable and able to grow quickly meeting the
needs of many
6. High need, fills a critical gap, ‘last mile’ to farmers
7. High leverage – few employees or low investment changes many lives
8. Cluster – fit with other investments to multiply effect
Q: WHAT ARE THE GREATEST CHALLENGES CHEETAH FACES?
Mindsets are very difficult, both of the farmers we work with and
the people who want to help them or engage with them. We think
of this as managing poverty of the mind. It may be our greatest challenge.
Corruption in developing nations is always a challenge and can be very disheartening. We strictly
forbid participating in it at any time and severely sanction or prosecute staff and partners that are
found acting corruptly. Managing corruption is being built into everything we do but it is a smaller
and simpler problem than the cost of labor in developed nations or intense competition.
Staff development of local people whom are the vast majority of our work force requires more
time and resources than typical in developed nations that take a well-educated work-force for
granted. For some of our staff, they are the first person in their family to ever hold a job. We need
to teach them how to work.
Risk Management
Don’t start with risk.
Start with the threats and hazards specific
to the business, activity, or location. Next
mitigate those with treatments,
processes or other activities integral to
the business. Build it in everywhere.
Then you deal with remaining risk:
Avoid, Accept, Reduce, or Transfer.
Assets (Exposure)Hazards
Vulnerability – Coping Capacity
Risks
We must manage poverty of the mind – both in the poor and those that seek to help them.
P a g e 7
Q: WHAT ARE SOME WAYS YOU CAN WORK WITH CHEETAH?
1. We can advise you on how you
work with smallholder farmers.
2. We can organize and manage
your smallholder farmers for you
whether less than a 100 smallholders in a
single district or a hundred thousand
smallholders in multiple Countries.
3. We fill in missing middle of
capital ($5000-$500,000 USD) for villages
and cooperatives of smallholders using a
unique model tied to commercial banks,
collateralizing the initial debt taken on by
a village, establishing credit ratings of
villages so debt can be acquired by
commercial banks with less and less outside collateralization and a movement to “cutting the
umbilical cord” with smallholders as they become successful small businessmen. You can invest
directly in our collateral fund where you will see a traditional commercial lending rate of return.
4. You can engage as a bank to provide backed and reliable funding to smallholders.
5. You can purchase crops or food products from Cheetah supported smallholder farmers.
6. In partnership with us you can provide products or services to our smallholders.
7. We fill in the missing markets ideally thru large multinational off-taker partners and governments
but often also as a direct investor in “missing industries” which can be scaled and replicated in an
almost franchise like model (often later by our multinational partners) across a Country or Region.
You can invest directly in our Equity Fund which is built to provide a private equity type rate of
return.
8. You can be a partner NGO or donor and better achieve your mission objectives.
9. We can work with select investors and partners on specific joint venture projects provided they
can be scaled and replicated much like projects in our equity fund and meet our social impact
mission and business model.
10. We can certify your food brands and products to be
Sunborn™ which allows consumers to know the
product came from smallholder farmers who are
carefully managed for quality. This mark can be used
generically or to tie to a region Sunborn™ in Africa or
Sunborn™ in Tanzania. You choose. Our certification
comes with almost no additional restrictions other than
the ensuring the product is sourced primarily from smallholder farmers.
11. You can be an impact investor or a donor, whether as a foundation, company, or individual.
12. Please request our document CURRENT PIPELINE OPPORTUNITIES.
P a g e 8
Q: WHO MAKES UP CHEETAH?
Cheetah was founded by leading entrepreneurs, experts in finance (both debt and equity), and industry
principals in food and agriculture. With a business centric team in place, Cheetah expanded its core
leadership to include pioneers in social impact investing, international development and technology. It
is an impressive team, with impressive references and impressive results highlighted in our documents
and website.
Q: WHAT IS CHEETAH’S HISTORY, ACHIEVEMENTS, AND PLANS FOR THE FUTURE?
Founded February of 2009 by Raymond Menard, Cheetah Development started with a handful of simple
but audacious concepts. Mr. Menard is a serial entrepreneur and for him this was a faith calling. He
received blessings and support from a growing cadre of friends and family. The first phase of the plan was
to take a few years and demonstrate the workability of these concepts. It took almost six years, but there
was a lot to be learned and the difficulties faced were daunting. On the other hand, far more was achieved
than was expected. The following diagram shows the starting concepts, a very brief summary of what was
achieved, and the next phase.
Launched two new companies
Launched two new companies. Pearl
Foods is a comprehensive farmer service
company. Reservoir is providing food
preservation equipment to address post-
harvest food losses.
Have worked in Tanzania and DR Congo, expanding now to Malawi and planning expansion to Uganda in 2015
P a g e 9
Q: IS CHEETAH A FAITH BASED ORGANIZATION?
No. While several of the key executives of Cheetah have a deep faith and were drawn by that faith into
the mission, we strongly believe that the role of supporting smallholders and moving them from
subsistence to small businesses is universal across faiths and philosophies. Our mission is profit for the
smallholder farmer. We welcome all and are comfortable for any company, donor or investor to join with
us so long as they have a passion for helping smallholders increase income.
On the other hand, Cheetah frequently works with faith based organizations working on smallholder
empowerment.
Q: WHO BACKS / SUPPORTS / WORKS WITH CHEETAH?
The following is not an exhaustive list and we apologize to the many supporters without whom we would
not have made it to where we are today. Also, most private donors and investors prefer not to be named
and so we have kept all names private.
Partner Type Past and Present Pending
Donor USAID (3 Sub-grants) Numerous private donors Family and corporate foundations Churches and other faith based orgs
Numerous (unable to disclose)
NGO Concern Fintrac DAI Africare International Potato Center
World Vision ADRA CARE International Tetra Tech
Investor Family foundations Lion’s Head Global Partners (private equity) AgriVie (private equity)
Supply Chain Syngenta (seed and chemicals) Yara (fertilizer) AFGRI (largest ag and food co in Africa, a
strategic partner) Mtanga LTD (potato seeds)
Numerous (Diversity of companies and products already in process ranging from farmer services, soil testing, transport bicycles, solar dryers, farming tools, dairy, horticulture, grains, grain bins, cold storage, and seed supply)
Banking CRDB Mufindi Community Bank Tanzania Investment Bank National Microfinance Bank Wells Fargo (business banking) Barclays (business banking)
Opportunity International Vision Fund
University University of Minnesota (Carlson School of Business, ag school, Humphrey Institute of Public Policy)
University of Tumaini (business school and Tumaini Ag Institute)
University of Dar es Salaam (Entrepreneurship Center)
University of St. Thomas
IT Agro Tech LTD
P a g e 10
Q: What is Cheetah’s vision?
The objective of Cheetah for the next 5 years is to demonstrate that without question our models work,
cross cultures, and scale. We believe that then they will be widely adopted and in a generation spread
around the globe. (This happened with microfinance.) We are ready to assist with this expansion and we
will open source our methodology. We genuinely believe that most of the worst poverty on earth can be
eliminated in a generation. Not all will be farmers for as economies grow many will shift into new
occupations, since they will be given that chance. We don’t need to live with
a world in this condition, with 2 billion people trapped in rural poverty. This
is not the work of one company – it must become a movement.
Q: HOW CAN I LEARN MORE?
Each Concept is further explained in our short Power Point Presentation: What is Different About
Running With a Cheetah? Our Debt, Equity and Smallholder Organization Models and in our 5
Year Business Plan and other attached documents.
POWERPOINT: How Cheetah Debt, Equity and Farmer Organization Models Work
(Comprehensive and Technical)
PDF CASESTUDY: A Case Study Approach to How Cheetah
Models Work
PDF WHITEPAPER: Many available including, How Cheetah
Organizes Smallholders
PDF Business Plan: Comprehensive 5 Year Business Plan for
Cheetah
PDF Case Study: Example of Due Diligence Done on Investing
in New Regions
Please also visit us online at cheetahdevelopment.org and
watch our videos of key board members, founders and
stakeholders explain why Cheetah works.
Poverty is no more impossible to solve than a Rubik’s cube. We just have to work together.
Ready to run with the Cheetahs?