of 42
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
1/42
BITSPilaniHyderabad Campus
FEASIBILITY OF ESTABLISING
AIRPORTS IN MEDIUM CITY
Kaashyap Sarma-2011A2PS378HCourse Name: Study Project
Supervisor: Dr.V. Vinayaka Ram
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
2/42
BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus
Objectives of the Project
1. To study the factors controlling airport planning and
establishment
Segregating the factors into two broad sectors:
Technical point of View
Financial Point of View
2. Understanding the factors & aspects from the abovementioned outlooks.
3. Study a sample case study pertaining to the above study.
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
3/42
BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus
What is Planning?
Planning Philosophy in Airport Design
The efficient airport as a whole is that which provides the
required capacity for aircraft, passenger, cargo and vehicle
movement with maximum passenger, operator and staff
convenience and at lowest capital and costs.
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
4/42
BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus
Broad determination of the land area required.
Evaluating of factors affecting airport location.
Preliminary office study of possible sites.
Site inspection.
Environmental study.
Review of potential sites.
Preparation of outline plans and estimates of costs
and revenues.Final evaluation and selections.
Report and recommendations.
Airport Site Assessment andSelection
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
5/42
BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus
Regional Plan
Airport Use
Proximity to other airports
Ground accessibility
Obstruction Clearance
Visibility
Topography
Wind factor Noise Effect
Weather Factors
Soil Characteristics
Airport Site Selection
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
6/42
BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus
Aranmula Airport-Kerala
This airport is said to be planned to be built upon 700
acres of land Total Budget Cost-Around 2000 Crore Rupees.
The terminal building is being designed to handle 1,000
passengers at a time.
The main advantage of installing this airport is it wouldboost up the employment rate by creating 1500 direct
and 6000 indirect jobs.
Sample Case Study
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
7/42BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus
The airport, which is less than 100 km from Cochin InternationalAirport and Trivandrum International Airport, is expected to serve
four districts in Kerala state, namely Pathanamthitta and some areas
of Kottayam, Idukki and Alappuzha.
The project is being funded through equity and debt. The equity
portion accounts for around Rs 10 billion. The debt-equity ratio is1:1. Three banks including ICICI, IDBI Bank and SBI have funded
the debt portion.
The Kerala government has a 10% stake in the company and has
nominated one member to the board of the company, while the
Government owned oil company Indian Oil Corporation isnegotiating to pick up a 10% stake. The first phase of the project is
expected to cost Rs 7.50 billion.
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
8/42BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus
ECONOMIC FEASIBILTY
The Enviro Care report states that the Aviation market in
the state of Kerala grew faster than the rest of the nation
which is one of the fastest growing aviation industries in
the world.
The government's partial open sky policy has led to
many overseas players entering the market and the
industry has been growing both in terms of players and
number of aircraft.
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
9/42BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus
Year Duration
Passenger Traffic Growth RATE- INDIA
Passenger Traffic Growth RATE- Kerala
Air Traffic Growth Rate
Year Duration Passenger Traffic Growth
RATE- INDIA
Passenger Traffic Growth
RATE- Kerala
2003-04 11%
2004-05 22%
2005-06 24%
2006-07 31% 31.28%
2007-08 21% 23.74%
2008-09 6.85% 3.15%
2009-10 15% 11.66%
2010-11 16% 10.23%
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
10/42BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus
The proposed Airport would provide transport infrastructure topilgrims who wish to travel by air to Sabarimala, the second
largest pilgrim center in India with annual pilgrims of around 60
Million (as per Government data for the year 2011).
The airport is expected to serve Central Travancore region,
comprising parts of five districts in Kerala state namelyPathanamthitta, Alappuzha, Kottayam, Idukki and Kollam. Out of the
foreign and domestic tourists' arrival to Kerala, these five districts
together account for about 21 per cent of foreign tourists and 14
percent of domestic tourists
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
11/42BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus
A Forecast of Indian air traffic has concluded that the domesticpassenger throughput would grow at an average annual rate of
around 12% between FY-12 and FY-17. The domestic passenger
throughput is expected to touch around 209 million by FY-17 from 106
million in FY-11. Similarly, international passenger throughput is
estimated to grow at an average annual rate of 8% to reach 60 millionpassengers by FY-17 from 38 million in FY-11.
Global comparison of air travel penetration shows that India stands
far behind the developed countries like US and Australia (2 air-trips
per capita per annum). Chinas domestic traffic is five times that ofIndia despite having a population just 10% larger. There is significant
growth potential as high as 50 times for the Indian civil aviation
industry as the economy grows, disposable incomes rise and the
value of time becomes more precious.
Air Traffic Demand
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
12/42BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus
Even though Kerala has only 2.75% of the overall population of India,
the International aircraft movement in Kerala is 15.28% of overall
international aircraft movement of India in the year 201112
During the year 201112, the total number of air passengers to Kerala
is 9,742,000 compared with 162.3 million air passengers throughout
India.
In Kerala, air traffic is evenly spread over the 3 existing airports-Kochi,
Trivandrum and Kozhikode unlike its neighboring three states of Tamil
Nadu, Andhra Pradesh and Karnataka where one
airport viz. Chennai, Hyderabad and Bangalore caters to 80% of the airtraffic of the entire state.
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
13/42BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus
ALL was seeming so well financially,
wasntit?
Promoters get their piece of pie,
employment rate boosts up. So itsa win-win, right?
Apparently it was not!
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
14/42BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus
The Kerala State Biodiversity Board observed that 80% of the 500acres earmarked for the project were paddy fields. Conversion of a
portion of the 3,500-acre paddy field would "impact on the remaining
wetlands, disturb the food chain, and accelerate the depletion of fish
resources as well as other flora and fauna in the Pamba river basin.
The runway is being constructed over the Kozhithode canal, which
is a tributary of the Pamba river. Several species of fish migrate
upstream from the river through the canals to the water-logged
paddy fields. Reclamation of these wetlands would deprive the fishof their breeding grounds. Razing hills in the neighborhood for soil to
reclaim the fields could lead to biodiversity loss and water shortage.
Heres the Problem
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
15/42BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus
Clearly this environmental violation is a cause for whichmany people are protesting against and the people of
that area quote that such a large project would cause
irreparable and devastating damage to the environment
and ecosystem
Conclusion
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
16/42BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus
The case study which I have adopted for my study post
mid-semester is on the Navi Mumbai International
Airport(NMIA)
The proposed airport at Navi Mumbai is located nearPanvel Town on NH4B at a distance of35 km from the
existing Sahar International Airport in Mumbai. A total
area of about 2054 Ha is earmarked for the development
of Navi Mumbai International Airport consisting of airportzone and the area required for offsite infrastructure
CASE STUDY-2
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
17/42BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus
The project is proposed to be executed on the basis ofpublic-private-partnership (PPP)
The main feasibility analysis is obtained by considering 4
factors:
Air Traffic Demand
Site Evaluation and Project Detailing
Project Phasing and Cost
Preliminary Analysis
INTRODUCTION
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
18/42BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus
The Navi Mumbai International Airport (NMIA) isproposed to be developed in an area of 2,054 hectares,
accommodating parallel independent runways for
simultaneous and independent operations.
The airport site is large enough to develop a two runway
system and is located next to two very important
communication corridors.
SITE SELECTION AND PROJECTDETAILING
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
19/42BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus
Airport Layout Plan
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
20/42BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus
The site has a very good railway connection, whichwould be completed with branches linking directly to the
current lines with the airport. From the point of view of
railway connections, this site has great accessibility.
The site is also said to be suitable considering the windfactors.
However not all the clearances were sanctioned, a
few objections were raised too
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
21/42BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus
Objections were raised by the Union Ministry of Environment andForests on the current proposed location of NMIA, apparently
because the construction of the airport would involve reclamation of
low-lying areas in an ecologically fragile zone as well as destruction
of several hectares of mangroves.
There are serious environmental issues. Its construction woulddamage mangrove cultivation in the 2,000 ha (4,900 acres), besides
the diversion of Gadhi and Ulwe rivers, which according to the Union
Environment and Forests Ministry is a very serious issue
considering the destruction Mumbai faced during the 26 July 2005
floods. As a result of these new developments other locations wereconsidered.
OBJECTIONS RAISED
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
22/42
BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus
The airport is facing hurdles in the acquisition of private land. Theairport requires 2,042 ha CIDCO needs to acquire 424 ha of
privately owned land for which CIDCO officials and the State
Government have been negotiating with the residents of seven
villages.
Land acquisition is stuck as the villagers (5,000 families) aredemanding a higher compensation package of 200 million per
acre. CIDCO then formed a committee composed of the divisional
commissioner of the Konkan division and local politicians. The
committee had offered the project-affected-people (PAP) two
rehabilitation-related compensation options:a) 12.5% of developed land at the ready reckoner rates, in addition to
monetary compensation
b) 22.5% developed land in Navi Mumbai.
LAND ACQUISTION
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
23/42
BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus
India has been experiencing a major expansion of the air
transportation industry. The total number of commercial
passengers using Indian airports almost doubled over
the four years between 2004-05 and 2007-08 from 59 tomore than 116 million.
This growth has averaged 24.4% per year and has been
particularly high for domestic traffic.
AIR TRAFFIC DEMAND
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
24/42
BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus
The primary Air traffic analysis was done by looking at the
Historical Air traffic trend of MMR
MMR Demand Forecast
NMIR Demand Forecast
It has to be observed that from whatever data we will be
having, the speculation or the forecast is done initially for
the MMR zone and then this forecast is projected on to
the NMIR Demand.
ANALYSIS
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
25/42
BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus
The driving forces behind this rapid growth in air traffic are:
1. Deregulation of the aviation sector.
2. Positive macro economic trends
3. Tourism
4. The Emergence of Low Cost and Premium Service
Carriers
Why the Rapid Growth??
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
26/42
BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus
CSIA experienced relatively modest slow growth in the number ofpassengers over the two decades preceding the liberalization of the
Indian air transportation industry during 2003-04, doubling from 6.4
to 13.3 million passengers (at an annual average compound growth
rate of 3.5%).
This growth trend has been interrupted during the current year(2008-09); initially by spiking fuel prices last summer, followed by
the impact of the worldwide financial crises.
Though the overall trend during those two decades was generally
positive, there was significant year to year variation, with temporary
declines in traffic during the economic recession of the early 1990sand in the period immediately following the terrorist attacks of
September 11, 2001
HISTORICAL TREND
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
27/42
BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus
During both previous periods, the number of domesticpassengers had grown at over twice the rate of
international passengers, but it is also the traffic segment
most affected by the current crisis.
Though it is not indicated in these tables, this boomperiod seems to have recently come to an end as the
industry was hit hard by high fuel costs this past summer
and the current worldwide financial crisis.
HISTORICAL TREND
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
28/42
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
29/42
BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
30/42
BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus
These forecasts were developed using a two step process:
1. Develop econometric forecasting models according to
industry practices.
2. Adjust forecasts for short-term and long-term industry
trends not reflected in the econometric modelling.
MMR Demand Forecast
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
31/42
BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus
The specific factors that were considered in this particular case are:
1. The extent and duration of the impact of the current downturn in air
traffic caused by fluctuating fuel costs and what has become a
worldwide financial crisis.
2. The extent to which an eventual recovery of the world economy will
lead to a return to the projected medium to long-term trend line (asestablished by the econometric model).
3. Whether it is feasible to assume that domestic traffic will indefinitely
continue growing faster than international traffic.
4. Whether the long-term growth rates resulting from the econometric
analysis are sustainable in the very long-run once the market begins
to mature.
MMR Demand Forecast
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
32/42
BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
33/42
BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus
The base forecasts for the High and Low scenarios wereestimated using the same equations, but applying High
and Low forecasts of the primary independent variables.
The same adjustment was carried out for 2008-09. In the
case of 2009-10, the following adjustments were made:
High: The growth rate predicted by the regression
equation was multiplied by 0.8.
Low: The regression growth rate was multiplied by 0.2.
These multiplication factors are obtained from the
previous regression constants
Forecast Scenarios
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
34/42
BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus
The procedure followed to allocate potential passengertraffic is the following:
Review airline preferences and plans
Estimate the proportion of the passenger and cargo
markets for which NMIA has a comparative advantage
Analyse saturation levels at CSIA
Derive passenger levels at NMIA
Derive cargo levels at NMIA
NMIA Passenger Forecast
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
35/42
BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus
The primary results are:
NMIA is forecasted to handle over 20 million passengers by the end
of Phase 1 in 2017-18. This would increase to just under 40 million
passengers by 2022-23 and almost 62 million by 2031-32.
International passengers are forecasted to reach over 10 million
passengers by the end of Phase 2 and over 16 million by 2031-32
Domestic passengers are forecasted to reach over 28 million by
2022-23 andover 44 million over the long run.
Direct international transit passengers are forecasted to increase toover 1 million over the first 24 years of operation of the airport.
RESULTS
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
36/42
BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus
Phase 1 (2013-14 to 2016-17): In Phase 1, the airport is initiallydesigned with a level of service adequate to satisfy the demand of
10 million passengers.
Phase 2 (2017-18 to 2021-22): The Phase 2 development at the
airport is designed to meet the demand for 25 million passengers.
Phase 3 (2022-23 to 2026-27): The Phase 3 development of theairport is designed with a level of service adequate to satisfy a 45
million passenger's demand.
Phase 4 (2027-28 to 2031-32): The airport is ultimately designed
with a level of serviceadequate to satisfy a 60 million passengers
demand by providing NMIA with additional boarding gates and apronarea to satisfy the additional demand
PROJECT PHASING
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
37/42
BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus
Development Stages
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
38/42
BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus
Project Cost by Phases
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
39/42
BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus
The primary results of this analysis are presented in termsof the following indicators:
Net Present Value (NPV) of the annual net cash flows
Internal Rate of Return (IRR)
FINANCIAL FEASIBILITY
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
40/42
BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus
The final results which were obtained included the followingmethodology
Estimating revenues at each Airport over the various development
phases, based on traffic projections and the price and tariff for use of
the terminals, facilities and services
Project annual Operating Costs (OPEX) for the various facilities,including personnel, administration and maintenance;
Incorporate the preliminary cost estimates (CAPEX) for investment
requirements
Prepare annual cash flows for the established planning horizon (30
years)
Determine the financial viability of the project in terms of its
Financial Internal Rate of Return (IRR) under different scenarios
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
41/42
BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus
FINAL RESULTS
8/11/2019 SOP Airport1 Final
42/42
BITSPilaniHyderabad Campus
Thank You