Southwest Response Filed Sept 22

8/20/2019 Southwest Response Filed Sept 22

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/southwest-response-filed-sept-22 1/78

GD@DOGCOW \JTWA^D\W CHYBHOD\ LJ.‘\ CO\^DY WJ GDBWC‘\ CFDOGDG LJTOWDYLBCHF\COG LYJ\\ LBCHF\ CNCHO\W \JTWA^D\W CHYBHOD\, LJ. UCND 3

TOHWDG \WCWD\ GH\WYHLW LJTYWOJYWADYO GH\WYHLW J@ WDQC\

GCBBC\ GHPH\HJO

LHWX J@ GCBBC\,

Ubchoth`` ,

v.

GDBWC CHY BHOD\, HOL., \JTWA^D\WCHYBHOD\ LJ., PHYNHO CFDYHLC HOL.,CFDYHLCO CHYBHOD\, HOL., TOHWDGCHYBHOD\, HOL., \DCUJYW CHYBHOD\,HOL., TOHWDG \WCWD\ GDUCYWFDOW J@WYCO\UJYWCWHJO, cog WAD @DGDYCB

CPHCWHJO CGFHOH\WYCWHJO,

Gd`dogcots.

§

§§§§§§§§§§§

§§§

Lhvhb Clthjo Oj. <;34-lv-59508-M

GD@DOGCOW \JTWA^D\W CHYBHOD\ LJ.‘\ CO\^DY WJ GDBWC‘\ CFDOGDGLJTOWDYLBCHF COG LYJ\\LBCHF CNCHO\W \JTWA^D\W CHYBHOD\ COG

LYJ\\LBCHF CNCHO\W TOHWDG CHYBHOD\, HOL.

Gd`dogcot \jutawdst Chrbhods Lj. (‒\jutawdst‖) adrdiy `hbds tahs Coswdr tj Gdbtc Chr

Bhods, Hol.‘s (‒Gdbtc‘s‖) Cfdogdg Ljuotdrlbchf cog Lrjsslbchf (‒Gdbtc‘s Cfdogdg

Lrjsslbchfs‖) cnchost \jutawdst.

CO\^DY WJ GDBWC‘\ CFDOGDG LJTOWDY- COG LYJ\\LBCHF\CNCHO\W \JTWA^D\W

Coy cbbdncthjo ojt dxprdssby cgfhttdg hs gdohdg.

Lcsd <;34-lv-59508-M Gjlufdot 318 @hbdg 58/99/34 Ucnd 3 j` >1 UcndHG 457>




CO\^DY WJ HOWYJGTLWHJO3

3. Ho 9550, \jutawdst cog tad Lhty j` Gcbbcs cnrddg tact \jutawdst wjubg acvd 30

nctds ct tad odwby rdojvctdg Bjvd @hdbg, c `clhbhty tact idbjons tj tad Lhty cog hts lhthzdos waj

gdsdrvd ljfpdththjo ct Bjvd @hdbg. Ho tad cnrddfdot bdcshon tajsd nctds tj \jutawdst, \jutawdst

cog tad Lhty cnrddg tact \jutawdst wjubg clljffjgctd ljfpdthon chrbhods‘ rdqudsts `jr spcld ct

tajsd 30 nctds h` \jutawdst‘s jpdrcthon sladgubd acg rjjf `jr tad rdqudstdg ljfpdththjo jo tad

gctd tact tad rdqudst wcs fcgd. Wact cnrddfdot hs rdquhrdg iy `dgdrcb bcw, wahla rdquhrds tact

chrpjrts suppjrt `rdd ljfpdththjo rctadr taco `cvjrhon jod chrbhod jvdr jtadrs. Cs Fcyjr Fhmd

Ycwbhons dxpbchodg kust bcst ydcr, ‒ljfpdththjo ct ]Bjvd @hdbgV hs njjg‖ cog ‒c nrjwta grhvdr `jr

tahs Lhty,‖ cog tad Lhty‘s njcb sajubg id tj ‒ljothoud tj grhvd ljfpdththjo‖ cog ‒tcmd cbb tahs

ljfpdththjo cog ndt pdjpbd `byhon cbb jvdr tad octhjo.‖

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst gdohds Gdbtc‘s ljotdothjo tact tad rdbdvcot `jlus `jr

‒ljfpdththjo‖ ho tad Gcbbcs-@jrt ^jrta fcrmdt hs ljfpdththjo ct hoghvhgucb chrpjrts, cs

jppjsdg tj ljfpdththjo cs c wajbd. \jutawdst bclms mojwbdgnd jr ho`jrfcthjo su``hlhdot tj

cgfht jr gdoy tad bcst sdotdold j` pcrcnrcpa 3. \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos

j` pcrcnrcpa 3.

9. \jutawdst, tjj, puibhlby prj`dssds tj vcbud ljfpdththjo. Ho tad Cunust ljpy j`

\jutawdst fcnczhod, pbcldg ho dvdry sdct j` hts pbcods, \jutawdst‘s LDJ Ncry Mdbby rdprdsdots

tact ‒H‘f c trud idbhdvdr tact ljfpdththjo cbsj fcmds us idttdr . . .‖ cog tact \jutawdst

‒dfircld]sV ljfpdththjo‖ cog ljfpdtds ‒ho dvdry cspdlt j` tad Lustjfdr Dxpdrhdold.‖ Ad

3 Gdbtc holjrpjrctdg iy rd`drdold hotj hts Cfdogdg Lrjsslbchfs cnchost \jutawdst dcla cog dvdry cbbdncthjo ho htsCfdogdg Ljuotdrlbchf cnchost tad Lhty. âhbd Gdbtc lbchfdg tahs holjrpjrcthjo ùrtadrdg ‒ljolhshjo,‖ sula irjcgcog uospdlh`hl holjrpjrcthjo cltucbby hovhtds uoodldsscry gupbhlcthjo j` d``jrts, holbughon rdquhrhon \jutawdst tjrdspjog tj fubthpbd ‒Ucrthds‖ cog ‒Hotrjgulthjo‖ sdlthjos cog tj lcusds j` clthjo tact crd ojt cbbdndg cnchost\jutawdst. Odvdrtadbdss, jut j` co ciuogcold j` lcuthjo, \jutawdst rdspjogs tj dcla cbbdncthjo ho Gdbtc‘sCfdogdg Ljuotdrlbchf cnchost tad Lhty.

Lcsd <;34-lv-59508-M Gjlufdot 318 @hbdg 58/99/34 Ucnd 9 j` >1 UcndHG 4571



GD@DOGCOW \JTWA^D\W CHYBHOD\ LJ.‘\ CO\^DY WJ GDBWC‘\ CFDOGDG LJTOWDYLBCHF\COG LYJ\\ LBCHF\ CNCHO\W \JTWA^D\W CHYBHOD\, LJ. UCND <

stctds tact ljfpdththjo jvdr `crds hs ‒ojt tad joby ljfpdththvd `cltjr‖ cog tact \jutawdst

‒ljfpdtd]sV whta jur sladgubd, jur prjgults, cog jur rdbhcihbhty.‖ Xdt wado tad Lhty j` Gcbbcs

gcrdg hotrjguld ljfpdththjo iy sunndsthon tact Gdbtc fust id clljffjgctdg ct Bjvd @hdbg‗cs

rdquhrdg iy `dgdrcb bcw cog tad bdcsds ljvdrhon tad Bjvd @hdbg nctds‗Fr. Mdbby conrhby dfchbdg

Lhty Fcocndr C.L. Njozcbdz tact tad Lhty wcs ‒rdwcrg]honV ljfpdthtjrs tact acvd ljotrhiutdg

ojtahon tj Gcbbcs.‖ Lhthon ihbbhjos j` gjbbcrs ho vcbud tact \jutawdst sddms lrdght `jr irhonhon tj

Gcbbcs cog fhbbhjos j` gjbbcrs j` tcx rdvdouds pchg, ad tardctdodg, cs \jutawdst sj j`tdo acs

gjod, tj pubb jut j` Gcbbcs h` tad Lhty ghg ojt adbp \jutawdst supprdss ljfpdththjo, tdbbhon tad

Lhty tact h` ht ghg ojt nhvd ho tj \jutawdst‘s cttdfpts tj ibjlm Gdbtc, \jutawdst wjubg puohsa tad

Lhty cog hts tcx-pcyhon lhthzdos iy ‒fjvhon jo tj `jlus jur ljrpjrctd hovdstfdots ho tajsd

fcrmdts tact pbcld c vcbud jo tadf cog tadhr ljrpjrctd rdshgdots.‖ Ahs fdsscnd wcs lbdcr‗stcog

gjwo cog cbbjw us tj ibjlm ljfpdththjo jr wd whbb fcmd yju pcy, gdcrby.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst gdohds Gdbtc‘s ljotdothjo tact tad rdbdvcot `jlus `jr

‒ljfpdththjo‖ ho tad Gcbbcs-@jrt ^jrta fcrmdt hs ljfpdththjo ct hoghvhgucb chrpjrts, cs

jppjsdg tj ljfpdththjo cs c wajbd. \jutawdst cgfhts tact ht vcbuds ljfpdththjo ho tad

Gcbbcs-@jrt ^jrta fcrmdt. \jutawdst cgfhts tact tad bconucnd qujtdg ho sdotdolds 9 cog

< cppdcrs ho tad Cunust ljpy j` \jutawdst fcnczhod, iut gd`drs tj tad tdxt j` hts fcnczhod

`jr tad prdlhsd wjrghon cog ljotdxt. \jutawdst cgfhts tact tad jtadr qujtdg bconucnd

cppdcrs ho co dfchb `rjf Fr. Mdbby tj Fr. Njozcbdz, iut gdohds tad ljotdxt ho wahla Gdbtc

cbbdnds tajsd qujtds crhsd. \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 9.

<. \jutawdst‘s clthjos fctla hts prhvctd idbhd` tact Bjvd @hdbg hs hts jwo prjpdrty,

rctadr taco hts puibhl prj`dsshjos tact ht suppjrts ljfpdththjo. Dvdo tajuna \jutawdst‘s bdcsd

cog `dgdrcb bcw rdquhrdg \jutawdst cog tad Lhty tj cbbjw ljfpdththjo ct Bjvd @hdbg, \jutawdst

Lcsd <;34-lv-59508-M Gjlufdot 318 @hbdg 58/99/34 Ucnd < j` >1 UcndHG 4578




wcotdg tj fcxhfhzd tad aund prj`hts tact `bjw `rjf dbhfhocthon ljfpdthtjrs ct Bjvd @hdbg. Ho

jrgdr tj fcxhfhzd hts prj`hts, \jutawdst oddgdg fjrd taco tad 30 nctds tj wahla ht hs bhfhtdg. Cs

c rdsubt, \jutawdst iubbhdg cog tardctdodg tad Lhty hotj cbbjwhon \jutawdst dvdo nrdctdr

gjfhocold ct Bjvd @hdbg, lcushon acrf tj Gcbbcs `bydrs.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst gdohds tad cbbdncthjos ho pcrcnrcpa <.

7. \jutawdst acs `hrstacog dxpdrhdold whta tad idod`hts j` ljotrjbbhon tad vcst

fckjrhty j` nctds ct c puibhl chrpjrt. Ho cgghthjo tj tad 30 j` 95 nctds \jutawdst wcs suppjsdg tj

acvd ct Bjvd @hdbg, \jutawdst acs c gjfhocot prdsdold ct Ajustjo Ajiiy cog Lahlcnj

Fhgwcy‗wahla, bhmd Bjvd @hdbg, crd suppjsdg tj id puibhl `clhbhthds, jpdrctdg `jr tad idod`ht j`

lhthzdos. Ct tajsd tardd chrpjrts, holbughon Bjvd @hdbg, \jutawdst acs cpprjxhfctdby 85% j` tad

`bhnats, fcmhon ljfpdththjo vhrtucbby hfpjsshibd cog grhvhon gjwo tad qucbhty j` sdrvhlds, wahbd

tad `crds acvd holrdcsdg ho rdldot ydcrs fjrd taco ct cbfjst coy jtadr chrpjrt ho tad Tohtdg \tctds

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact ht acs c shnoh`hlcot prdsdold ct Bjvd @hdbg,

Ajustjo Ajiiy, cog Lahlcnj Fhgwcy chrpjrts. \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon

cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 7.

4. Xdt \jutawdst wcs ojt scths h̀dg whta hts gjfhocold ct Bjvd @hdbg. \jutawdst cog

Tohtdg ijta acg spcld cvchbcibd wado Gdbtc rdqudstdg clljffjgcthjo. Iut rctadr taco rhsm

Gdbtc prjvhghon dvdo c bhfhtdg lacbbdond tj hts strconbdajbg jo tad chrpjrt, \jutawdst sjunat tj

dxpcog hts jwo gjfhocold iy coojuolhon co hotdot tj idnho tj usd cbb j` tad cvchbcibd spcld‗

holbughon Tohtdg‘s cvchbcibd spcld‗sj tact Gdbtc ljubg id mdpt jut. Cog \jutawdst usdg tardcts

cog hothfhgcthjo tj pdrsucgd tad Lhty tj pdrfht tahs dxpcoshjo, ho vhjbcthjo j` hts cnrddfdot whta

tad Lhty, dotdrdg hotj iy tad Lhty `jr tad idod`ht j` hts lhthzdos.





YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst gdohds Gdbtc‘s hfpbhlcthjo tact Gdbtc acs fcgd joby jod

rdqudst `jr clljffjgcthjo. \jutawdst gdohds tad cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 4.

0. @hrst, \jutawdst iubbhdg cog tardctdodg tad Lhty tj cwcrg \jutawdst tad twj nctds

tact Cfdrhlco acg tj nhvd up cs c rdsubt j` hts fdrndr whta T\ Chrwcys. Wad Lhty wcs pjhsdg tj

nrcot tajsd twj nctds tj Phrnho Cfdrhlc, ct tad rdqudst j` tad T.\. Gdpcrtfdot j` Kusthld, ydt

\jutawdst pusadg acrg `jr tad Lhty tj gd`y tad Gdpcrtfdot j` Kusthld cog hostdcg cwcrg tad nctds

tj \jutawdst. \jutawdst ghg tact gdsphtd tad `clt tact hts cnrddfdot whta tad Lhty bhfhtdg

\jutawdst tj 30 j` tad 95 nctds. Ojt scths`hdg whta tahs bhjo‘s sacrd j` tad nctds, \jutawdst ijrd

gjwo jo tad Lhty tj `jrld ht tj cwcrg tajsd twj Cfdrhlco nctds tj \jutawdst.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact ht gdfjostrctdg tj tad Lhty tact cwcrghon tad

Cfdrhlco nctds tj \jutawdst wjubg prjvhgd tad nrdctdst idod`ht tj tad Gcbbcs `byhon puibhl,

kust cs tad Lhty‘s jwo hogdpdogdot ljosubtcot acg gdtdrfhodg. \jutawdst gdohds tad

rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 0.

>. Wad Lhty wjubg acvd iulmbdg tj tad ljdrlhvd ljogult j` \jutawdst acg ht ojt

iddo `jr tad Gdpcrtfdot j` Kusthld, wahla schg, ho ljrrdspjogdold tj tad Lhty, tact idlcusd

‒\jutawdst cbrdcgy ljotrjbs 30 j` tad 95 Bjvd @hdbg nctds,‖ h` ‒ht jitchodg tad twj Cfdrhlco

nctds, ht wjubg tado gjfhoctd 85% j` Bjvd @hdbg nctds, tadrdiy gdoyhon ljosufdrs tad idod`hts

j` fdcohonùb ljfpdththjo ct tahs `clhbhthds-ljostrchodg chrpjrt.‖ Wad Gdpcrtfdot j` Kusthld

clthjo dfpjwdrdg tad Lhty tj rdùsd tj pdrfht \jutawdst tj dxpcog idyjog 30 nctds iy fdcos j`

suibdcshon Cfdrhlco‘s nctds. ^hta tad idod`ht j` c `dgdrcb njvdrofdot gdlbcrcthjo tact

\jutawdst ljubg ojt acvd 31 nctds, tad Lhty cpprjvdg Phrnho Cfdrhlc‘s cnrddfdot tj tcmd tad 9

nctds.





YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst bclms mojwbdgnd jr ho`jrfcthjo su``hlhdot tj cgfht jr gdoy

tad `hrst sdotdold j` pcrcnrcpa >. \jutawdst cgfhts tact tad Lhty ljosdotdg tj Cfdrhlco‘s

suibdcsd j` hts Bjvd @hdbg nctds tj Phrnho. \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j`

pcrcnrcpa >.

1. Gurhon tad Lhty‘s dvcbucthjo j` tad Cfdrhlco nctds, \jutawdst cssurdg tad Lhty ht

wcs ojt wjrmhon tj jitcho clldss tj tad rdfchohon twj nctds, bdcsdg iy tad Lhty tj Tohtdg. Xdt

cs sjjo cs \jutawdst `chbdg ho hts cttdfpt tj fcmd tad Cfdrhlco nctds hts 3>ta cog 31ta nctds, ht

sdt cijut tj hostdcg fcmd tad ‒Tohtdg‖ nctds hts 3>ta cog 31ta nctds. Wad ‒Tohtdg‖ nctds acg

cfpbd cvchbcihbhty tj clljffjgctd Gdbtc‘s `bhnats. Iut Tohtdg modw ht wjubg fcmd `cr fjrd

fjody `rjf suibdcshon tajsd nctds tj \jutawdst‗wahla ljubg usd tadf tj sjbhgh`y hts

fjojpjby jvdr tad chrpjrt‗taco ht wjubg `rjf dhtadr ht jr Gdbtc `byhon ljfpdththvdby.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst gdohds tad cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 1.

8. Clljrghonby, Tohtdg sjunat cog jitchodg co jisldod suf `rjf \jutawdst `jr

adbphon \jutawdst prdvdot Gdbtc `rjf ljfpdthon whta ht. Wad nrjtdsqud cfjuot \jutawdst pchg

Tohtdg `jr tadsd twj nctds prjvds tad vcbud j` jitchohon c fjojpjby ct Bjvd @hdbg. \jutawdst‘s

pcyfdot tj Tohtdg cbsj qucoth`hds kust ajw fula ljosufdrs crd idhon njundg iy \jutawdst‘s

fjojpjby.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact ht dotdrdg hotj c suibdcsd whta Tohtdg `jr hts

Bjvd @hdbg nctds. \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 8.

35. Wadrd wcs jod pjtdothcb rjcgibjlm ho \jutawdst‘s pbco; tad Lhty acg tj cpprjvd

tad suibdcsd j` Tohtdg‘s nctds. \jutawdst modw tact tad GJW acg tjbg tad Lhty tact ht ghg ojt

wcot \jutawdst tj jitcho Tohtdg‘s nctds iut rctadr wcotdg c pdrfcodot crrcondfdot tj id fcgd

`jr Gdbtc tj acvd spcld ct Bjvd @hdbg. Cog idlcusd \jutawdst jitchohon Tohtdg‘s nctds wjubg




GD@DOGCOW \JTWA^D\W CHYBHOD\ LJ.‘\ CO\^DY WJ GDBWC‘\ CFDOGDG LJTOWDYLBCHF\COG LYJ\\ LBCHF\ CNCHO\W \JTWA^D\W CHYBHOD\, LJ. UCND >

fcmd ht cbfjst hfpjsshibd `jr jtadr chrbhods tj ljfpdtd, \jutawdst cog Tohtdg modw tact

ljfpbdthon tad suibdcsd wjubg lcusd ijta \jutawdst cog Tohtdg tj id ho vhjbcthjo j` tadhr

cnrddfdot whta tad Lhty, cog hoghrdltby whta tad lhthzdos j` tad Gcbbcs. Tohtdg prjtdltdg htsdb` ho

hts cnrddfdot whta \jutawdst, fcmhon \jutawdst cnrdd tact h` tady wdrd lcunat, cog tad Lhty

jrgdrdg tact Gdbtc jr coy jtadr chrbhod acg tj id clljffjgctdg ct Bjvd @hdbg, \jutawdst wjubg

‒usd jtadr prdfhsds tact ]\jutawdstV bdcsds jr jtadrwhsd suibdcsds ct tad Chrpjrt tj

clljffjgctd sula chrbhods,‖ ojt tad nctds \jutawdst acg sdlurdg `rjf Tohtdg ct `cr cijvd

fcrmdt vcbud.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact tad Bdcsd rdquhrds tad Lhty tj ljosdot tj coy

Bjvd @hdbg suibdcsd cog tact tad Lhty fcy ojt uordcsjociby whtaajbg sula ljosdot.

\jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 35.

33. Wad Lhty, ajwdvdr, wcs uocibd tj stcog up tj \jutawdst‘s prdssurd. ^htajut tad

prjtdlthjo j` c `dgdrcb njvdrofdot gdlbcrcthjo tact \jutawdst ljubg ojt acvd wact ht wcotdg, tad

Lhty `dcrdg bhthncthjo jr bjst tcx rdvdoud `rjf \jutawdst h` ht ghg ojt nhvd ho. Waus, hffdghctdby

jo tad addbs j` tad GJK tdbbhon \jutawdst cog tad Lhty tact ht wjubg gdstrjy cbb ‒fdcohonùb

ljfpdththjo‖ `jr \jutawdst tj clquhrd fjrd taco 30 nctds, \jutawdst cog Tohtdg ljdrldg tad

Lhty hotj cpprjvhon \jutawdst‘s clquhshthjo j` tad 9 nctds bdcsdg iy Tohtdg, nhvhon \jutawdst 31

nctds, `jr c purlacsd prhld tact sajlms tad ljoslhdold.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact tad Lhty ljosdotdg tj tad \jutawdst-Tohtdg

suibdcsd. \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 33.

39. Wad @dgdrcb Cvhcthjo Cgfhohstrcthjo (‒@CC‖) acs ojw bcuoladg co hovdsthncthjo

tj gdlhgd wadtadr tad Lhty vhjbctdg rdquhrdfdots j` `dgdrcb bcw wado ht `chbdg tj rdquhrd tact

Gdbtc id clljffjgctdg ct Bjvd @hdbg, cog wado ht cpprjvdg tahs fjojpjby-lrdcthon trcos`dr j`

Lcsd <;34-lv-59508-M Gjlufdot 318 @hbdg 58/99/34 Ucnd > j` >1 UcndHG 454<




twj nctds `rjf Tohtdg tj \jutawdst. \jutawdst, `jr hts pcrt, acs clmojwbdgndg tact ht wcs tcmhon

c bdncb rhsm ho suibdcshon tajsd Tohtdg nctds cog ljdrlhon tad Lhty tj cpprjvd tad trcos`dr, c rhsm

tact ht wcs whbbhon tj tcmd idlcusd j` tad aund fjojpjby rdwcrgs ht wjubg ncho iy surpcsshon hts

30-nctd ljotrcltucb bhfht‗c idod`ht ht hs wdbb cwcrd j` icsdg jo hts fjojpjby pjshthjos ct Ajiiy

cog Fhgwcy chrpjrts.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact tad @CC hssudg c ojthld j` hovdsthncthjo ho

ljoodlthjo whta Gdbtc‘s rdqudst `jr clljffjgcthjo, iut gdohds tact tad @CC acs

gdtdrfhodg tact coy vhjbcthjo j` ̀ dgdrcb bcw acs jllurrdg. \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon


3<.

Cbtajuna tadrd hs oj qudsthjo tact \jutawdst‘s sladfd tj uobcwùbby dxpcog hts

gjfhocold jvdr Bjvd @hdbg irdcladg hts cnrddfdot whta tad Lhty, tad Lhty‘s hocihbhty tj stcog

`hrf uogdr \jutawdst‘s prdssurd hs c irdcla j` hts jwo ljotrcltucb guthds. Wact lcusds acrf tact

hs ojt bhfhtdg tj ljfpdthtjrs, bhmd Gdbtc, waj \jutawdst sddms tj pusa jut j` tad puibhl chrpjrt

tact \jutawdst wrjonby ljoshgdrs hts jwo prjpdrty. Wad fjrd sdrhjus acrf hs tj Gcbbcs lhthzdos,

waj acvd c rhnat tj tad idod`hts tact ljfpdththjo whbb irhon tj Bjvd @hdbg, cog acvd iddo gdohdg

ht iy \jutawdst‘s iubbyhon cog tad Lhty‘s clquhdsldold.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst gdohds tad cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 3<.

37. Gdbtc tadrd`jrd csms tahs Ljurt tj pbcy tad rjbd tact tad GJK wcs `jrldg tj pbcy

wado \jutawdst prdssurdg tad Lhty tj nhvd ht Cfdrhlco‘s nctds. Wact hs, Gdbtc rdspdltùbby

rdqudsts tact tad Ljurt gdlbcrd tact, uogdr tad cnrddfdots tact tad Lhty cog \jutawdst shnodg, tad

Lhty hs guty-ijuog uogdr bcw tj `jrld \jutawdst tj clljffjgctd Gdbtc‘s jpdrcthjos ct Bjvd

@hdbg. Gdbtc ùrtadr csms tahs Ljurt tj uogj tad wrjon tact \jutawdst cog Tohtdg ghg tarjuna tad

ljfpdththjo-lrusahon suibdcsd iy gdlbcrhon tact \jutawdst fcy ljotrjb oj fjrd taco 30 nctds,





cog tact hts 3>ta cog 31ta nctds fust id nhvdo iclm tj tad Lhty `jr tad ljffjo usd j`

ljfpdthtjrs. Gdbtc rdspdltùbby csms tad Ljurt tj gdlbcrd tact Gdbtc whbb tado acvd tad rhnat tj `by

tad `bhnats ht acs rdqudstdg spcld `jr `rjf tajsd ljffjo usd nctds. Ho tad cbtdrocthvd, h`

\jutawdst hs pdrfhttdg tj mddp 31 bdcsdg jr suibdcsdg nctds, Gdbtc csms tahs Ljurt `jr c

gdlbcrcthjo tact ht hs dothtbdg tj clljffjgcthjo jo rdcsjocibd tdrfs `jr hts dxhsthon sladgubd,

pbus tad cgghthjocb 1 `bhnats ht rdqudstdg ho @dirucry, jo tajsd 31 nctds.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact Gdbtc sddms tad rdbhd` ht rdqudsts, iut gdohds tact

Gdbtc hs dothtbdg tj coy rdbhd`. \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 37.

CO\^DY WJ UCYWHD\

34.

Ljuotdr-Ubchoth`` Gdbtc Chr Bhods, Hol. hs c Gdbcwcrd ljrpjrcthjo wajsd prholhpcb

pbcld j` iushodss hs bjlctdg ct 35<5 Gdbtc Ijubdvcrg, Ctbcotc, Ndjrnhc <5<47. Gdbtc hs co chr

lcrrhdr doncndg ho tad iushodss j` prjvhghon ljffdrlhcb pcssdondr chr trcospjrtcthjo tarjunajut

tad Tohtdg \tctds cog tad wjrbg. Gdbtc hs c lhthzdo j` tad \tctds j` Gdbcwcrd cog Ndjrnhc.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tad cbbdncthjos ho Ucrcnrcpa 34.

30.

Ljuotdr-Gd`dogcot Lhty j` Gcbbcs hs c fuohlhpcb ljrpjrcthjo bjlctdg ho Gcbbcs

Ljuoty, Wdxcs. Wad Lhty hs tad jwodr cog jpdrctjr j` Bjvd @hdbg. Wad Lhty hs c lhthzdo j` tad

\tctd j` Wdxcs cog gjds ojt jpdrctd cs co crf j` tad \tctd j` Wdxcs.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst bclms mojwbdgnd jr ho`jrfcthjo su``hlhdot tj `jrf c idbhd`

cs tj wadtadr tad Lhty jpdrctds cs co crf j` tad \tctd j` Wdxcs. \jutawdst cgfhts tad

rdfchohon cbbdncthjos ho Ucrcnrcpa 30.





CO\^DY WJ KTYH\GHLWHJO COG PDOTD

3>. Wahs Ljurt acs kurhsghlthjo uogdr 91 T.\.L. § 3<<3 idlcusd tahs clthjo crhsds

uogdr tad bcws j` tad Tohtdg \tctds.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tad cbbdncthjos ljotchodg ho Ucrcnrcpa 3>.

31. Wahs Ljurt acs kurhsghlthjo uogdr 91 T.\.L. § 3<<9(c)(3) idlcusd tad fcttdr ho

ljotrjvdrsy dxlddgs tad suf jr vcbud j` $>4,555, dxlbushvd j` hotdrdst cog ljsts, cog hs idtwddo

lhthzdos j` gh``drdot \tctds.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tad cbbdncthjos ljotchodg ho Ucrcnrcpa 31.

38.

Wj tad dxtdot tahs Ljurt gjds ojt acvd jrhnhocb kurhsghlthjo j` coy ljuotdrlbchf(s)

cssdrtdg ho tahs clthjo, tahs Ljurt acs kurhsghlthjo uogdr 91 T.\.L. § 3<0> idlcusd tad Ljurt acs

jrhnhocb kurhsghlthjo j` tad clthjo cog cbb j` tad ljuotdrlbchfs cssdrtdg adrdho crd sj rdbctdg tj

jod cojtadr tact tady `jrf pcrt j` tad scfd lcsd jr ljotrjvdrsy uogdr Crthlbd HHH j` tad Tohtdg

\tctds Ljosthtuthjo.


95.

Wj tad dxtdot tact tad Lhty wjubg jtadrwhsd id dothtbdg tj njvdrofdot hffuohty

`rjf suht ho tahs Ljurt, tad Lhty wchvdg tact hffuohty wado ht hohthctdg tahs clthjo. Wad Lhty‘s

wchvdr dxtdogs tj Gdbtc‘s ljuotdrlbchfs idlcusd tajsd ljuotdrlbchfs crhsd jut j` tad scfd

trcosclthjo jr jllurrdold tact hs tad suikdlt fcttdr j` tad Lhty‘s ljfpbchot.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tad cbbdncthjos ljotchodg ho pcrcnrcpa 95.

93. Pdoud ho tahs Ljurt hs prjpdr uogdr 91 T.\.L. § 3<83(i)(9) idlcusd c suistcothcb

pcrt j` tad dvdots cog jfhsshjos nhvhon rhsd tj Gdbtc‘s ljuotdrlbchfs jllurrdg ho tahs kughlhcb

ghstrhlt.






CO\^DY WJ ICLMNYJTOG COG @CLW\

H. @dgdrcb Ydnubcthjo j` @dgdrcbby @uogdg Chrpjrts

99. GJW cog hts jpdrcthon cgfhohstrcthjo, tad @CC, dxdrlhsd pbdocry cog prddfpthvd

cutajrhty jvdr `dgdrcbby ùogdg chrpjrts (sula cs Gcbbcs Bjvd @hdbg). Wj rdldhvd ùoghon

uogdr tad `dgdrcb ùoghon prjnrcf mojwo cs tad Chrpjrt Hfprjvdfdot Urjnrcf (‒CHU‖), co

chrpjrt spjosjr (sula cs tad Lhty) fust cnrdd tj ljfpby whta stctutjry cog ljotrcltucb

jibhncthjos rdbcthon tj tad jpdrcthjo cog usd j` tad chrpjrt. Wad purpjsd j` tadsd stctutjry

jibhncthjos cog nrcot cssurcolds hs tj `jstdr ùbb cog `chr ljfpdththjo ho chr trcospjrtcthjo.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact GJW cog tad @CC dxdrlhsd c ldrtcho gdnrdd j`

cutajrhty jvdr `dgdrcbby ùogdg chrpjrts bhmd Bjvd @hdbg, cgfhts tact chrpjrt spjosjrs fust

ljfpby whta ldrtcho stctutjry cog ljotrcltucb jibhncthjos rdbcthon tj tad jpdrcthjo cog usd

j` tad chrpjrt tj rdldhvd `dgdrcb ùoghon uogdr CHU, cog cgfhts tact tad cssurcolds

‒rdquhrd tad rdlhphdots tj fchotcho cog jpdrctd tadhr `clhbhthds sc`dby cog d``hlhdotby cog ho

clljrgcold whta spdlh`hdg ljoghthjos.‖ (sdd

attp;//www.`cc.njv/chrpjrts/chp/nrcotZcssurcolds/), iut rdfcrms tact tad cppbhlcthjo j` tad

nrcot cssurcolds tj Bjvd @hdbg hs bhfhtdg iy tad jibhncthjos spdlh`hdg ho ^CYC. \jutawdst

gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos ho Ucrcnrcpa 99.

9<. Bjvd @hdbg acs rdldhvdg `dgdrcb ùoghon uogdr CHU. Ho `clt, jvdr tad pcst `hvd

ydcrs cbjod, Bjvd @hdbg acs rdldhvdg jvdr $95 fhbbhjo `rjf tad `dgdrcb njvdrofdot `jr chrpjrt

hfprjvdfdots. Ho cgghthjo, Bjvd @hdbg acs rdldhvdg `dgdrcb cpprjvcb tj hfpjsd cog usd c $7.45

pcssdondr `clhbhty `dd. Cs c rdsubt, tad Lhty hs suikdlt tj fjrd taco c gjzdo ljotrcltucb

jibhncthjos mojwo cs ‒nrcot cssurcolds‖ rdncrghon tad jpdrcthjo cog usd j` Bjvd @hdbg. Wad

nrcot cssurcolds crd ihoghon jibhncthjos idtwddo tad Lhty cog tad `dgdrcb njvdrofdot.





YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact Bjvd @hdbg acs rdldhvdg `dgdrcb ùoghon uogdr

CHU, iut rdfcrms tact ^CYC fjgh`hds tad nrcot cssurcolds, cs cppbhlcibd tj Bjvd @hdbg,

iy, cfjon jtadr tahons, prdlbughon tad Lhty `rjf ljostrulthon cgghthjocb nctds jr

fjgh`yhon jr dbhfhocthon prd`drdothcb bdcsd rhnats, uobdss sula fjgh`hlcthjo jr dbhfhocthjo

hs ‒hfpbdfdotdg jo c octhjowhgd icshs.‖ \jutawdst bclms mojwbdgnd jr ho`jrfcthjo

su``hlhdot tj `jrf c idbhd` cs tj tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j` Ucrcnrcpa 9<.

97. Nrcot cssurcold 99c, wahla hfpbdfdots 78 T.\.L. § 7>35>(c)(3), rdquhrds tad

Lhty tj fcmd Bjvd @hdbg cvchbcibd ‒cs co chrpjrt `jr puibhl usd jo rdcsjocibd tdrfs cog whtajut

uokust ghslrhfhocthjo tj cbb typds, mhogs cog lbcssds j` cdrjocuthlcb clthvhthds, holbughon

ljffdrlhcb cdrjocuthlcb clthvhthds j``drhon sdrvhlds tj tad puibhl ct tad chrpjrt.‖ Wad Lhty jwds

tahs jibhncthjo tj cbb chr lcrrhdrs cog usdrs j` Bjvd @hdbg, rdncrgbdss j` wadtadr tad chr lcrrhdr jr

usdr hs c tdocot, suitdocot, jr ojo-tdocot. Wahs jibhncthjo icrs tad Lhty `rjf gdoyhon co chr

lcrrhdr clldss tj Bjvd @hdbg sjbdby icsdg jo tad ojo-cvchbcihbhty j` dxhsthon `clhbhthds.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tad cbbdncthjos ho tad `hrst sdotdold j` Ucrcnrcpa 37,

iut rdfcrms tact ^CYC fjgh`hds tad nrcot cssurcolds, cs cppbhlcibd tj Bjvd @hdbg, iy,

cfjon jtadr tahons, prdlbughon tad Lhty `rjf ljostrulthon cgghthjocb nctds jr fjgh`yhon jr

dbhfhocthon prd`drdothcb bdcsd rhnats, uobdss sula fjgh`hlcthjo jr dbhfhocthjo hs

‒hfpbdfdotdg jo c octhjowhgd icshs.‖ \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j`

Ucrcnrcpa 97.

94. Nrcot cssurcold 9<, wahla hfpbdfdots 78 T.\.L. § 7535<(d), prjahihts tad Lhty

`rjf ghrdltby jr hoghrdltby nrcothon coy lcrrhdr co dxlbushvd rhnat tj usd Bjvd @hdbg. Co

‒dxlbushvd‖ rhnat hs ojt bhfhtdg tj c rhnat tact hs adbg dxlbushvdby iy c shonbd lcrrhdr, iut coy rhnat

tact c lcrrhdr acs wahbd jod jr fjrd jtadr lcrrhdrs crd gdohdg tact rhnat. Togdr tahs prjahihthjo,




GD@DOGCOW \JTWA^D\W CHYBHOD\ LJ.‘\ CO\^DY WJ GDBWC‘\ CFDOGDG LJTOWDYLBCHF\COG LYJ\\ LBCHF\ CNCHO\W \JTWA^D\W CHYBHOD\, LJ. UCND 3<

tad Lhty fcy ojt; lbchf bclm j` nctd cvchbcihbhty wado, ho `clt, nctds crd ojt ùbby uthbhzdg=

rdbhoquhsa ljotrjb j` chrpjrt `clhbhthds tj holufidot lcrrhdrs `jr purpjsds j` odnjthcthon clldss

whta c odw dotrcot= jr pdrfht uordcsjocibd suibdcsd `dds jr ljoghthjos tj id hfpjsdg jo odw

dotrcots. Coy j` tadsd clthjos wjubg `cvjr tad holufidot lcrrhdr jvdr lcrrhdrs whtajut

pdrfcodot bdcsd rhnats ct tad chrpjrt. Ct Bjvd @hdbg, c ‒odw dotrcot‖ holbugds coy lcrrhdr tact hs

ojt c shnoctjry lcrrhdr ct Bjvd @hdbg. Waus, tad tdrf holbugds bhfhtdg holufidot lcrrhdrs sula cs

Gdbtc waj fcy acvd c sfcbb prdsdold ct tad chrpjrt iut crd ojt Bdcsd shnoctjrhds.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact nrcot cssurcold 9< prjvhgds tact chrpjrt

spjosjrs whbb ojt pdrfht co dxlbushvd rhnat `jr tad usd j` tad chrpjrt iy coy pdrsjo, iut

rdfcrms tact ^CYC fjgh`hds tad nrcot cssurcolds, cs cppbhlcibd tj Bjvd @hdbg, iy, cfjon

jtadr tahons, prdlbughon tad Lhty `rjf ljostrulthon cgghthjocb nctds jr fjgh`yhon jr


‒hfpbdfdotdg jo c octhjowhgd icshs.‖ \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j`

pcrcnrcpa 94.

90.

U@L Cssurcolds prjahiht U@L-ùogdg `clhbhthds, bhmd tad tdrfhocb ct Bjvd @hdbg,

`rjf idhon bdcsdg jo co dxlbushvd usd icshs, wadtadr tad dxlbushvhty crhsds jut j` co dxlbushvd

usd bdcsd jr jo c gd `cltj icshs wado tad bdcsd hs hotdrprdtdg tj d``dlthvdby nrcot co dxlbushvd

bdcsd tj c shnoctjry lcrrhdr tj tad dxlbushjo j` c odw dotrcot.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact co jpdrctjr j` c U@L-ùogdg chrpjrt fcy ‒ojt

dotdr hotj co dxlbushvd bjon-tdrf bdcsd jr usd cnrddfdot whta co chr lcrrhdr jr `jrdhno chr

lcrrhdr `jr prjkdlts ùogdg iy U@L rdvdoud.‖ @CC U@L Cssurcolds (955>), Htdf 4.

\jutawdst ojtds tact oj Bjvd @hdbg lcrrhdr acs co dxlbushvd bjon-tdrf bdcsd jr usd

cnrddfdot whta tad Lhty tj jpdrctd ct Bjvd @hdbg. \jutawdst ùrtadr rdfcrms tact ^CYC

Lcsd <;34-lv-59508-M Gjlufdot 318 @hbdg 58/99/34 Ucnd 3< j` >1 UcndHG 4548




fjgh`hds `dgdrcb jibhncthjos, cs cppbhlcibd tj Bjvd @hdbg, iy, cfjon jtadr tahons,

prdlbughon tad Lhty `rjf ljostrulthon cgghthjocb nctds jr fjgh`yhon jr dbhfhocthon

prd`drdothcb bdcsd rhnats, uobdss sula fjgh`hlcthjo jr dbhfhocthjo hs ‒hfpbdfdotdg jo c

octhjowhgd icshs.‖ \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 90.

HH. Wad Lhty‘s Ljfpdththjo Ubco `jr Bjvd @hdbg

9>. Cs c rdlhphdot j` `dgdrcb ùoghon uogdr CHU, cog cs c Ucssdondr @clhbhty Lacrnd

spjosjr, tad Lhty hs rdquhrdg uogdr `dgdrcb bcw tj suifht co clldptcibd ljfpdththjo pbco tj tad

\dlrdtcry j` Wrcospjrtcthjo. Wad @CC ljoshstdotby acs hotdrprdtdg tad ljfpdththjo pbco

rdquhrdfdots cs `jlushon jo hoghvhgucb chrpjrts‗ojt chrpjrt systdfs jr fdtrjpjbhtco crdcs‗

wado cssdsshon cvchbcihbhty j` nctds `jr odw dotrcots. Cog Bjvd @hdbg htsdb`‗ojt tad

Gcbbcs/@jrt ^jrta Fdtrjpjbhtco Crdc‗hs suikdlt tj hts jwo rdquhrdfdot tj suifht cog fcmd

ljffhtfdots ho hts chrpjrt ljfpdththjo pbco.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tad cbbdncthjos ho tad `hrst sdotdold j` pcrcnrcpa 9>,

gdohds tad cbbdncthjos ho tad sdljog sdotdold j` pcrcnrcpa 9>, cog gdohds tad cbbdncthjo ho

tad tahrg sdotdold j` pcrcnrcpa 9> cs tady `chb tj trclm tad bconucnd j` 78 T.\.L. § 7533>(m)

cog 7>350(`). \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 9>.

91. C ljfpdththjo pbco fust holbugd, cfjon jtadr tahons, c ghslusshjo j` tad

clljffjgcthjo j` odw sdrvhld cog j` sdrvhld iy c odw dotrcot. ‒Clljffjgcthjo‖ hs tad

prjldss iy wahla co chrbhod tact cbrdcgy jpdrctds rdnubcrby sladgubdg `bhnats ct co chrpjrt hs

rdquhrdg iy tad chrpjrt jwodr, jpdrctjr, jr spjosjr tj prjvhgd c pjrthjo j` hts spcld ct tad

chrpjrt‗holbughon nctd cog rdbctdg suppjrt spcld‗tj co chrbhod tact sddms tj idnho sdrvhld jr

dxpcog hts lurrdot sdrvhld ct tad chrpjrt.





YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tad cbbdncthjos ho tad `hrst sdotdold j` pcrcnrcpa 91,

iut rdfcrms tact tady `chb tj spdlh`hlcbby trclm tad bconucnd j` 78 T.\.L. § 7533>(m) cog

7>350(`) cog gj ojt cppdcr tj ghrdltby qujtd coy @CC rdnubcthjo. \jutawdst gdohds tad


98. Ho hts ljfpdththjo pbcos, tad Lhty acs rdpdctdgby clmojwbdgndg tact wado odw

dotrcot chrbhods whsa tj idnho prjvhghon sdrvhld ct Bjvd @hdbg, tad Lhty hs jibhnctdg tj `jrld

clljffjgcthjo h` odldsscry ho jrgdr tj prjfjtd ljfpdththjo. Wad Lhty `hbdg hts hohthcb Bjvd

@hdbg Ljfpdththjo Ubco (tad ‒Ljfpdththjo Ubco‖) jo Kuby <3, 9553. Ho hts pbco, tad Lhty

‒rdljnohzd]gV tact, iy acvhon clldptdg @dgdrcb nrcots, ht acs uogdrtcmdo c bdncb jibhncthjo tj

prjvhgd rdcsjocibd chr lcrrhdr clldss ct Bjvd @hdbg.‖

Wad Lhty ùrtadr rdljnohzdg tact hts bdcsds

whta holufidot lcrrhdrs ‒holbugd nctd-sacrhon prjvhshjos . . . rdquhrhon clljffjgcthjo j` jtadr

chrbhods whtaho tad bdcsd prdfhsds j` tad holufidot chrbhods.‖

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst gdohds tad cbbdncthjos ljotchodg ho tad `hrst sdotdold j`

pcrcnrcpa 98. Cs tj tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 98, \jutawdst gd`drs tj tad

tdxt j` tad Bjvd @hdbg Ljfpdththjo Ubco `jr hts prdlhsd wjrghon, cog gdohds tad wjrghon

usdg iy Gdbtc tact hs holjoshstdot whta tad prdlhsd wjrghon cog pjshthjohon j` tad wjrghon

ho tad gjlufdot. \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 98.

<5. Ho co upgctd tj hts Ljfpdththjo Ubco `hbdg ho @dirucry 9554, tad Lhty jold cncho

clmojwbdgndg hts jibhncthjo ‒tj fcmd cbb rdcsjocibd d``jrts tj clljffjgctd lcrrhdrs sddmhon tj

prjvhgd sdrvhld ct Bjvd @hdbg,‖ ‒rdhtdrctdg hts whbbhonodss tj do`jrld tad nctd sacrhon prjvhshjos

j` tad bdcsds tj fcmd spcld cvchbcibd tj‖ pjtdothcb odw dotrcots, cog stctdg tact ht ‒ljothoud]sV tj

id ljffhttdg tj dosurhon tact coy lcrrhdr sddmhon tj prjvhgd sdrvhld tj Bjvd @hdbg rdldhvds

rdcsjocibd clldss tj oddgdg `clhbhthds.‖





YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst gd`drs tj tad tdxt j` tad Ljfpdththjo Ubco `jr hts prdlhsd

wjrghon. \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos ho pcrcnrcpa <5, cog gdohds tad

wjrghon usdg iy Gdbtc tact hs holjoshstdot whta tad prdlhsd wjrghon cog pjshthjohon j` tad

wjrghon ho tad gjlufdot.

<3. Wad Lhty `hbdg cojtadr upgctd tj hts Ljfpdththjo Ubco ho Kuod 9558, cog ho tact

upgctd tad Lhty spdlh`hlcbby clmojwbdgndg hts jibhncthjo tj `jrld clljffjgcthjo j` Gdbtc ct

Bjvd @hdbg. Wad Lhty rdc``hrfdg hts ndodrcb ljffhtfdot ‒tj clljffjgcthon odw dotrcots‖ cog

dxpbchodg tact ‒]hVo tad ùturd, tad Lhty hotdogs tj clljffjgctd rdqudsts `jr clldss iy cppbyhon

tad nctd sacrhon prjvhshjos ljotchodg ho tad lurrdot bdcsd‗prjvhshjos wahla acvd iddo

holjrpjrctdg ho \dlthjo 7.50@ j` tad odw Ydstctdg Bdcsd.‖

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst gdohds tact tad Lhty clmojwbdgndg co jibhncthjo tj `jrld

clljffjgcthjo j` Gdbtc. Cs tj tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos ho pcrcnrcpa <3, \jutawdst

gd`drs tj tad tdxt j` tad 9558 Ljfpdththjo Ubco `jr hts prdlhsd wjrghon, cog gdohds tad

wjrghon usdg iy Gdbtc tact hs holjoshstdot whta tad prdlhsd wjrghon cog pjshthjohon j` tad

wjrghon ho tad gjlufdot.

<9. Ct tad thfd j` tad 9558 upgctd, Gdbtc acg ho`jrfdg tad Lhty j` hts hotdot tj

prjvhgd sdrvhld ct Bjvd @hdbg, cog tad Lhty‘s upgctd holbugdg c spdlh`hl pbco tj clljffjgctd

Gdbtc. Wad Lhty rdprdsdotdg tact ‒]jVold tad tdrfhocb rdgdvdbjpfdot hs ljfpbdtdg, tad Lhty whbb

clljffjgctd Gdbtc icsdg jo tad nctd sacrhon prjvhshjos j` tad prd`drdothcb usd bdcsd.‖


cs tj wado Gdbtc acg ho`jrfdg tad Lhty j` hts hotdot tj prjvhgd sdrvhld ct Bjvd @hdbg.

\jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos ho tad h̀rst sdotdold j` pcrcnrcpa <9. Cs tj tad

rdfchohon cbbdncthjos ho pcrcnrcpa <9, \jutawdst gd`drs tj tad tdxt j` tad Lhty‘s bdttdr `jr




GD@DOGCOW \JTWA^D\W CHYBHOD\ LJ.‘\ CO\^DY WJ GDBWC‘\ CFDOGDG LJTOWDYLBCHF\COG LYJ\\ LBCHF\ CNCHO\W \JTWA^D\W CHYBHOD\, LJ. UCND 3>

hts prdlhsd wjrghon, iut gdohds tact sula bconucnd prjvhgds coy nucrcotdd tj Gdbtc `jr

clljffjgcthjo= tj tad ljotrcry, tad Lhty prjfhsdg joby tj cppby tad ‒nctd sacrhon

prjvhshjos j` tad prd`drdothcb usd bdcsd,‖ wahla, cfjon jtadr tahons, (3) joby cppby tj odw

dotrcots, wahla Gdbtc hs ojt, cog (9) gj ojt rdquhrd clljffjgcthjo wado gjhon sj wjubg

hotdr`drd whta c shnoctjry lcrrhdr‘s sladgubd. \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j`

pcrcnrcpa <9.

HHH. Wad Chrpjrt Tsd cog Bdcsd Cnrddfdots

<<. Wad bdcsd cnrddfdots rd`drdoldg ho tad Ljfpdththjo Ubco cog hts upgctds crd tad

Chrpjrt Tsd cog Bdcsd Cnrddfdots tad Lhty acs dotdrdg hotj whta tardd lcrrhdrs‗\jutawdst,

Cfdrhlco, cog Tohtdg Chrbhods (ljbbdlthvdby, tad ‒Bdcsd Cnrddfdots‖). Wad Bdcsd Cnrddfdot

idtwddo tad Lhty cog \jutawdst spdbbs jut tad gdtchbs cog bjnhsthls j` tad Lhty‘s jibhncthjo tj

`jrld clljffjgcthjo ct Bjvd @hdbg.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tad cbbdncthjos ho tad `hrst sdotdold j` pcrcnrcpa <<.

\jutawdst cgfhts tact tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdot idtwddo tad Lhty cog \jutawdst ljotchos c

prjldss `jr tad pjsshibd clljffjgcthjo j` c odw dotrcot chrbhod suikdlt tj tad jpdrcthjos j`

tad bdcsd-ajbghon chrbhod jo hts jwo bdcsdg spcld. \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon

cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa <<.

<7. Togdr § 7.50(G)(7) j` tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdot, h` ‒c odw dotrcot lcrrhdr sddms tj

idnho sdrvhld ct‖ Bjvd @hdbg, tad Lhty hs jibhnctdg tj ‒sddm vjbuotcry clljffjgcthjo `rjf hts

dxhsthon chrbhod bdssdds tj clljffjgctd tad odw dotrcot sdrvhld,‖ cog ‒]hV` tad dxhsthon lcrrhdrs

crd ojt cibd jr crd ojt whbbhon tj clljffjgctd tad odw dotrcot sdrvhld, tado tad Lhty cnrdds tj

rdquhrd tad sacrhon j`‖ tad holufidot chrbhods‘ bdcsdg nctds.

Lcsd <;34-lv-59508-M Gjlufdot 318 @hbdg 58/99/34 Ucnd 3> j` >1 UcndHG 450<




YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst gdohds tact Gdbtc acs prdsdotdg c ùbb cog ljfpbdtd

rdprdsdotcthjo j` tact sdlthjo 7.50(G)(7) j` tad Bdcsd, cog gd`drs tj tad tdxt j` tad Bdcsd `jr

hts prdlhsd wjrghon. \jutawdst gdohds tact Gdbtc hs c ‒odw dotrcot lcrrhdr,‖ cog, taus,

gdohds tact sdlthjo 7.50(G)(7) cppbhds tj Gdbtc‘s rdqudst `jr clljffjgcthjo. \jutawdst

ùrtadr rdfcrms tact tad Lhty hs jibhnctdg, pursucot tj tad Bdcsd cog jtadr jibhncthjos, tj

fcocnd Bjvd @hdbg rdspjoshiby cog sc`dby. Coy rdqudst `jr clljffjgcthjo hs suikdlt tj c

oufidr j` ljoshgdrcthjos, holbughon tad `jrdnjhon. \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon

cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa <7.

<4.

\dlthjo 37.58 j` tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdot dxprdssby holjrpjrctds tad chrpjrt nrcot

cssurcolds hotj tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdot cog fcmds tad Bdcsd suijrghoctd tj tajsd nrcot cssurcolds.

Wad Bdcsd Cnrddfdot rdquhrds ijta \jutawdst (ho \dlthjo 37.5<(I)) cog tad Lhty (ho \dlthjo

37.38) tj jpdrctd ct tad chrpjrt ho c fcoodr ljoshstdot whta tad nrcot cssurcolds.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst gdohds tad cbbdncthjos ljotchodg ho Ucrcnrcpa <4 idlcusd

tady gj ojt cllurctdby qujtd sdlthjo 37.58 j` tad Bdcsd. \jutawdst gd`drs tj tad tdxt j` tad

Bdcsd `jr hts prdlhsd wjrghon.

<0. \dlthjo 7.50(@) j` tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdot ljotchos c slcrld-rdsjurld prjvhshjo

tact clmojwbdgnds tact Bjvd @hdbg‘s `clhbhthds ‒fcy idljfd c slcrld rdsjurld h` c odw dotrcot

chrbhod (‑Ydqudsthon Chrbhod‘) rdqudsts tj prjvhgd sdrvhld ct tad Chrpjrt‖ cog bcys jut c `jur-stdp

prjldss tarjuna wahla c pjtdothcb odw dotrcot lcrrhdr fcy sddm clljffjgcthjo ct Bjvd @hdbg;

C. Wad rdqudsthon chrbhod fust sddm vjbuotcry clljffjgcthjo iy cttdfpthon tjsdlurd nctd spcld cog jtadr odldsscry `clhbhthds jo c vjbuotcry icshs `rjf jod j`tad holufidot chrbhods ct Bjvd @hdbg. (§ 7.50(@))

I. H` tad rdqudsthon chrbhod acs ljotcltdg cbb j` tad holufidot chrbhods cog dxacustdgcbb rdcsjocibd d``jrts tj sdlurd vjbuotcry clljffjgcthjo, tad rdqudsthon chrbhodfcy ojth`y tad Lhty‘s Ghrdltjr j` Cvhcthjo, waj ho turo fust ‒ojth`y cbb \hnoctjryChrbhods ho wrhthon tact h` Ydqudsthon Chrbhod hs ojt clljffjgctdg whtaho tahrty





(<5) gcys `rjf tad rdldhpt j` ojthld, tad Ghrdltjr whbb sdbdlt jod j` tad \hnoctjryChrbhods tj ljfpby whta tad rdqudst `jr clljffjgcthjo ho c ojo-ghslrhfhoctjryfcoodr.‖ (§ 7.50(@)(9))

L. Ct tad dog j` tact <5-gcy pdrhjg, h` ojod j` tad holufidot chrbhods acvd cnrddg tj

vjbuotcrhby clljffjgctd tad rdqudsthon chrbhod, tad Lhty hs jibhnctdg tj ‒sdbdlt c\hnoctjry Chrbhod tj clljffjgctd tad Ydqudsthon Chrbhod‖ cog sdog c wrhttdoojthld tj tact \hnoctjry Chrbhod rdquhrhon clljffjgcthjo whtaho <5 gcys j`rdldhpt j` tad ojthld. (§ 7.50(@)(<))

G. Ct tad dog j` tact sdljog <5-gcy pdrhjg (ho jtadr wjrgs, 05 gcys c`tdr tadrdqudsthon chrbhod `hrst prjvhgds ojthld tj tad Lhty‘s ghrdltjr j` cvhcthjo), tadholufidot chrbhod tact acs iddo sdbdltdg `jr clljffjgcthjo fust clljffjgctdtad rdqudsthon chrbhod iy sacrhon c pjrthjo j` hts bdcsdg nctds cog cbbjwhon tadrdqudsthon chrbhod tj jpdrctd `bhnats jut j` tact sacrdg nctd spcld. (§ 7.50(@)(7))

Waus, uogdr tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdot, wado c odw dotrcot chrbhod fcmds co dxacusthvd iut

uosulldssùb d``jrt tj sddm vjbuotcry clljffjgcthjo `rjf holufidot lcrrhdrs, tad Lhty hs suikdlt

tj c fcogctjry guty tj `jrld clljffjgcthjo j` tad odw dotrcot.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact tad Bdcsd ljotchos prjvhshjos `jr tad pjsshibd

clljffjgcthjo j` c odw dotrcot chrbhod uogdr ldrtcho ljoghthjos. \jutawdst gdohds tact

tad Lhty hs jibhnctdg tj fcogctjrhby `jrld clljffjgcthjo j` c odw dotrcot. \jutawdst

gdohds tact sdlthjo 7.50(@)(<) jibhnctds tad Lhty tj sdbdlt c lcrrhdr tj clljffjgctd tad

rdqudsthon chrbhod. \jutawdst gdohds tact Gdbtc‘s `jur-stdp sladfd doljfpcssds cbb j` tad

rhnats cog jibhncthjos j` shnoctjry chrbhods uogdr tad Bdcsd ho tad dvdot j` co

clljffjgcthjo rdqudst. \jutawdst cgfhts tact tad qujtdg pcsscnds cppdcr ho tad Bdcsd,

iut gd`drs tj tad tdxt j` tad Bdcsd `jr hts prdlhsd wjrghon. \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon

cbbdncthjos ho pcrcnrcpa <0.

<>. Iy dotdrhon hotj tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots, tad Lhty wchvdg hts njvdrofdotcb

hffuohty ̀ rjf bhcihbhty uogdr tajsd Bdcsd Cnrddfdots.





YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tad cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa <>, iut gdohds tact

Gdbtc hs c prjpdr pcrty tj sud uogdr tad Bdcsd.

HP. Wad @hvd Ucrty Cnrddfdot

<1. Ho 38>8, Ljonrdss pcssdg tad ^rhnat Cfdogfdot, wahla cfdogdg tad @dgdrcb

Cvhcthjo Clt tj prjahiht sdrvhld iy fdghuf cog bcrnd chrlrc`t (fjrd taco 40 sdcts) idtwddo Bjvd

@hdbg cog coy pjhot jutshgd j` Wdxcs cog hts `jur surrjuoghon stctds (Crmcoscs, Odw Fdxhlj,

Bjuhshcoc, cog Jmbcajfc). Bctdr cfdogfdots tj tad ^rhnat Cfdogfdot cggdg Cbcicfc,

Mcoscs, Fhsshsshpph, cog Fhssjurh tj tad Bjvd @hdbg sdrvhld crdc.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tad cbbdncthjos ho pcrcnrcpa <1.

<8.

Jo Kuby 33, 9550, tad Lhthds j` Gcbbcs cog @jrt ^jrta, tad G@^ Hotdrocthjocb

Chrpjrt Ijcrg, Gd`dogcot Cfdrhlco Chrbhods, cog \jutawdst dotdrdg hotj co cnrddfdot (tad

‒@hvd Ucrty Cnrddfdot‖) tact, cfjon jtadr tahons, sjunat tad docltfdot j` bdnhsbcthjo tact

wjubg cfdog cog ubthfctdby rdpdcb tad bhfhtcthjos jo Bjvd @hdbg jpdrcthjos hfpjsdg iy tad

^rhnat Cfdogfdot. Ho dxlacond `jr bh`thon tadsd bhfhtcthjos, tad @hvd Ucrty Cnrddfdot lcbbdg

`jr tad rdgulthjo j` nctd lcpclhty ct Bjvd @hdbg, `rjf <9 tj 95 nctds, wahla tad cnrddfdot

spdlh`hlcbby cbbjlctdg cfjon tardd chrbhods‗\jutawdst (30 nctds), Cfdrhlco (9 nctds), cog

DxprdssKdt Chrbhods, Hol. (9 nctds, wahla wdrd bctdr clquhrdg iy Gd`dogcot Tohtdg Chrbhods). Oj

jtadr chrbhod (holbughon Gdbtc) wcs c pcrty tj tad @hvd Ucrty Cnrddfdot jr cbbjlctdg c nctd uogdr

ht= hostdcg, chrbhods whtajut Bdcsd Cnrddfdots waj whsa tj sdrvd Bjvd @hdbg fcy sddm tj gj sj cs

‒odw dotrcots.‖).

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tad cbbdncthjo ho pcrcnrcpa <8.

75. Ho tad @hvd Ucrty Cnrddfdot, tad Lhty cnrddg‗cog hs jibhnctdg‗tj ljfpdb

`jrldg clljffjgcthjo j` odw dotrcot lcrrhdrs ct Bjvd @hdbg. \pdlh`hlcbby, tad @hvd Ucrty





Cnrddfdot prjvhgds tact ‒]tVj tad dxtdot c odw dotrcot lcrrhdr sddms tj dotdr Bjvd @hdbg, tad Lhty

j` Gcbbcs whbb sddm vjbuotcry clljffjgcthjo `rjf hts dxhsthon lcrrhdrs tj clljffjgctd tad odw

dotrcot sdrvhld. H` tad dxhsthon lcrrhdrs crd ojt cibd jr crd ojt whbbhon tj clljffjgctd tad odw

dotrcot sdrvhld, tado tad Lhty j` Gcbbcs cnrdds tj rdquhrd tad sacrhon j` prd`drdothcb bdcsd nctds,

pursucot tj Gcbbcs‘ dxhsthon bdcsd crrcondfdots.‖

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst gdohds tad cbbdncthjos j` tad `hrst sdotdold j` pcrcnrcpa 75.

Cs tj tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 75, \jutawdst gd`drs tj tad tdxt j` tad @hvd

Ucrty Cnrddfdot `jr hts prdlhsd wjrghon, iut gdohds tact coy bconucnd ho tad @hvd Ucrty

Cnrddfdot prjvhgds coy nucrcotdd tj Gdbtc `jr clljffjgcthjo= tj tad ljotrcry, tad @hvd

Ucrty Cnrddfdot rdquhrds joby tad cppbhlcthjo j` tad nctd sacrhon prjvhshjos j` tad Bdcsd

wahla, cfjon jtadr tahons, (3) joby cppby tj odw dotrcots, wahla Gdbtc hs ojt, cog (9) gj

ojt rdquhrd clljffjgcthjo wado gjhon sj wjubg hotdr`drd whta c shnoctjry lcrrhdr‘s

sladgubd. \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 75.

P. Wad ^rhnat Cfdogfdot Yd`jrf Clt j` 9550

73.

Jo Jltjidr 3<, 9550, Ljonrdss docltdg tad ^rhnat Cfdogfdot Yd`jrf Clt j`

9550, Uui. B. Oj. 358-<49, 395 \tct. 9533 (9550) (tad ‒Yd`jrf Clt‖). Wad Yd`jrf Clt ljgh`hdg

hotj `dgdrcb bcw fcoy j` tad fjst hfpjrtcot prjvhshjos j` tad @hvd Ucrty Cnrddfdot. Ht

pdrfcodotby lcppdg tad oufidr j` Bjvd @hdbg nctds ct 95 cog prjvhgdg `jr tad dvdotucb

dbhfhocthjo j` tad bhfhtcthjos jo ojostjp `bhnats ct Bjvd @hdbg.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tad cbbdncthjos ho pcrcnrcpa 73.

79. \dlthjo 4(c) j` tad Yd`jrf Clt rdquhrds tad Lhty tj ‒gdtdrfhod tad cbbjlcthjo j`

bdcsdg nctds cog fcocnd Bjvd @hdbg ho clljrgcold whta‖ tad prjvhshjos j` tad Bdcsd

Cnrddfdots. Wahs holbugds co dxprdss rdquhrdfdot tact tad Lhty fust ‒clljffjgctd odw





dotrcot chr lcrrhdrs‖ iy ‒ajojr]honV tad slcrld rdsjurld prjvhshjos j` tad dxhsthon Bjvd @hdbg

bdcsds.‖ \dlthjo 4(c) taus ljgh`hds hotj `dgdrcb bcw tad Lhty‘s jibhncthjo uogdr tad Bdcsd

Cnrddfdots tj `jrld clljffjgcthjo j` odw dotrcots (sula cs Gdbtc) ct Bjvd @hdbg.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tad cbbdncthjos j` tad `hrst sdotdold j` pcrcnrcpa 79.

Cs tj tad qujtdg pcsscnds, \jutawdst gd`drs tj tad tdxt j` ^CYC `jr hts prdlhsd wjrghon.

\jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos ho pcrcnrcpa 79.

7<. \dlthjo 4(d) j` tad Yd`jrf Clt dxpbhlhtby rdsdrvds tj tad @CC hts kurhsghlthjo tj

do`jrld nrcot cssurcold cog stctutjry jibhncthjos rdbctdg tj nrcot cssurcold ljfpbhcold cog tad

prjahihthjo jo dxlbushvd rhnats; ‒Ojtahon ho tahs Clt sacbb id ljostrudg . . . tj bhfht tad cutajrhty

j` tad @dgdrcb Cvhcthjo Cgfhohstrcthjo jr coy jtadr @dgdrcb cndoly tj do`jrld rdquhrdfdots j`

bcw cog nrcot cssurcolds . . . tact hfpjsd jibhncthjos jo Bjvd @hdbg tj fcmd hts `clhbhthds

cvchbcibd jo c rdcsjocibd cog ojoghslrhfhoctjry icshs tj chr lcrrhdrs sddmhon tj usd sula

`clhbhthds, jr tj whtaajbg nrcots jr gdoy cppbhlcthjos tj cppbhlcots vhjbcthon sula jibhncthjos whta

rdspdlt tj Bjvd @hdbg.‖

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst gd`drs tj tad tdxt j` ^CYC `jr hts prdlhsd wjrghon, iut

rdfcrms tact ^CYC fjgh`hds tad nrcot cssurcolds, cs cppbhlcibd tj Bjvd @hdbg, iy, cfjon

jtadr tahons, prdlbughon tad Lhty `rjf ljostrulthon cgghthjocb nctds jr fjgh`yhon jr


‒hfpbdfdotdg jo c octhjowhgd icshs.‖ \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos ho

pcrcnrcpa 7<.

PH. Wad Lhty‘s Ydpdctdg Urjfhsds tj Clljffjgctd Gdbtc ct Bjvd @hdbg

77. Gdbtc lurrdotby j``drs `hvd gchby `bhnats `rjf Bjvd @hdbg tj hts aui, Ctbcotc‘s

Acrts`hdbg-Kclmsjo Hotdrocthjocb Chrpjrt, `rjf wahla pcssdondrs lco ljoodlt tj Gdbtc‘s





wjrbgwhgd odtwjrm j` `bhnats. Gdbtc acs iddo jpdrcthon jut j` Bjvd @hdbg shold tad suffdr j`

9558, wado ht suibdcsdg c nctd `rjf Cfdrhlco Chrbhods. Gdbtc‘s suibdcsd whta Cfdrhlco wcs

dxthonuhsadg cs c rdsubt j` tad 953< fdrndr idtwddo Cfdrhlco cog T\ Chrwcys. Cs c ljoghthjo

j` hts cpprjvcb j` tad fdrndr, tad Gdpcrtfdot j` Kusthld coojuoldg ho Ojvdfidr 953< tact

Cfdrhlco wjubg id rdquhrdg tj ghvdst hts twj nctds ct Bjvd @hdbg.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact Gdbtc lurrdotby j``drs `hvd gchby `bhnats `rjf

Bjvd @hdbg tj hts aui ho Ctbcotc, iut bclms mojwbdgnd jr ho`jrfcthjo su``hlhdot tj `jrf c

idbhd` cs tj tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos ho pcrcnrcpa 77. \jutawdst cgfhts tact Gdbtc‘s

suibdcsd whta Cfdrhlco tdrfhoctdg ho 9537, iut bclms mojwbdgnd jr ho`jrfcthjo su``hlhdot

tj `jrf c idbhd` cs tj tad prdlhsd gctd. \jutawdst cgfhts tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j`

pcrcnrcpa 77.

74. Ijta Gdbtc cog \jutawdst sjunat tj jitcho tad rhnat tj usd Cfdrhlco‘s nctds.

C`tdr tad GJK fcgd ht mojwo tact ht wcotdg Phrnho Cfdrhlc tj rdldhvd tad nctds, \jutawdst

ojodtadbdss fcgd c bcst-ghtla d``jrt tj pdrsucgd tad Lhty tj gd`y tad GJK cog ljo`dr tad nctds jo

\jutawdst. Wad GJK sdot c bdttdr tj tad Lhty ho wahla ht rdc``hrfdg hts ljolbushjo tact tad nctds

sajubg nj tj Phrnho Cfdrhlc cog stctdg tad jivhjus; tact \jutawdst ‒cbrdcgy ljotrjbs 30 j` tad

95 Bjvd @hdbg nctds,‖ sula tact ‒]hV` ht jitchodg tad twj Cfdrhlco nctds, ht wjubg tado gjfhoctd

85% j` Bjvd @hdbg nctds, tadrdiy gdoyhon ljosufdrs tad idod`hts j` fdcohonùb ljfpdththjo ct

tahs `clhbhthds-ljostrchodg chrpjrt.‖ Ho rdspjosd tj tad GJK‘s rdc` h̀rfcthjo j` hts prdvhjus

gdlhshjo, tad Lhty cnrddg tj Phrnho Cfdrhlc‘s dotry hotj Bjvd @hdbg. Ho Fcy 9537, Gd`dogcot

Phrnho Cfdrhlc coojuoldg tact tad Lhty acg cpprjvdg Phrnho‘s rdqudst tj suibdcsd tad twj Bjvd

@hdbg nctds Cfdrhlco wcs ghvdsthon.





YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tad cbbdncthjos ho tad `hrst sdotdold j` pcrcnrcpa 74.

\jutawdst cgfhts tact \jutawdst, kust bhmd Gdbtc, sjunat tj bdcsd Cfdrhlco‘s twj nctds ct

Bjvd @hdbg, iut gdohds tact ht fcgd coy ‒bcst-ghtla d``jrt tj pdrsucgd tad Lhty tj gd`y tad

GJK.‖ \jutawdst cgfhts tact tad GJK suppjrtdg ghvdsthturd j` Cfdrhlco‘s nctds tj Phrnho

Cfdrhlc, iut cbsj rdfcrms tact tad GJK‘s bdttdr rd`drrdg tj ho pcrcnrcpa 74 stctdg tact tad

GJK ljoshgdrdg Gdbtc hodbhnhibd tj clquhrd tajsd nctds idlcusd ht hs c ahna-ljst bdncly

chrbhod tact wjubg ojt prjvhgd cgdquctd ljfpdththjo ct Bjvd @hdbg. \jutawdst cgfhts tact

tad Lhty ljosdotdg tj Phrnho Cfdrhlc‘s suibdcsd j` Cfdrhlco‘s nctds ct Bjvd @hdbg.


70.

Wad ghvdsthturd j` Cfdrhlco‘s nctds lcusdg Gdbtc‘s suibdcsd ct Bjvd @hdbg tj

tdrfhoctd jo Jltjidr 39, 9537. Clljrghonby, ho Kuod 9537, Gdbtc ljffdoldg tad prjldss j`

sddmhon clljffjgcthjo pursucot tj tad prjvhshjos j` tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots cog tad nucrcotdds

ho tad @hvd Ucrty Cnrddfdot cog tad Ljfpdththjo Ubcos.


tad `hrst sdotdold j` pcrcnrcpa 70. \jutawdst cgfhts tact Gdbtc sjunat Bjvd @hdbg nctd

clldss ho Kuod 9537, iut gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 70.

7>. Gdbtc idnco tad `jur-stdp clljffjgcthjo prjldss sdt jut ho tad slcrld-rdsjurld

prjvhshjos j` tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots iy sddmhon vjbuotcry clljffjgcthjo `rjf tad holufidot

chrbhods. Ho Kuod 9537, Fhlacdb Cocstcs, c Ydnhjocb Ghrdltjr `jr Gdbtc, sdot bdttdrs tj Tohtdg

Chrbhods, \jutawdst Chrbhods, cog Cfdrhlco Chrbhods `jrfcbby sddmhon vjbuotcry clljffjgcthjo

j` Gdbtc‘s shx sladgubdg `bhnats ct Bjvd @hdbg uogdr § 7.50(@) j` tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots idtwddo

tad chrpjrt cog dcla j` tadsd lcrrhdrs. Fr. Cocstcs cbsj ojth`hdg Fcrm Gudiodr, tad Lhty‘s

Ghrdltjr j` Cvhcthjo ct Bjvd @hdbg, tact Gdbtc wcs idnhoohon tad prjldss j` sddmhon vjbuotcry

Lcsd <;34-lv-59508-M Gjlufdot 318 @hbdg 58/99/34 Ucnd 97 j` >1 UcndHG 45>5




clljffjgcthjo `rjf tad tardd holufidot lcrrhdrs. Jo Kuby 30, 9537, Gdbtc prjvhgdg wrhttdo

ojthld tj tad Lhty tact Gdbtc acg ljotcltdg cbb tardd shnoctjry lcrrhdrs, tact ojod wcs whbbhon tj

vjbuotcrhby clljffjgctd Gdbtc ct Bjvd @hdbg, cog tact Gdbtc taus acg dxacustdg cbb rdcsjocibd

d``jrts tj sdlurd vjbuotcry clljffjgcthjo. Gdbtc cbsj `jrfcbby rdqudstdg `jrldg

clljffjgcthjo `rjf tad Lhty.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst gdohds tad cbbdncthjos ljotchodg ho tad `hrst sdotdold j`

pcrcnrcpa 7>. \jutawdst cgfhts tact Gdbtc sjunat Bjvd @hdbg nctd clldss ho Kuod 9537, iut

gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j` tad sdljog sdotdold j` pcrcnrcpa 7>. \jutawdst bclms

mojwbdgnd jr ho`jrfcthjo su``hlhdot tj cgfhts jr gdoy tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j`

pcrcnrcpa 7>.

71. Togdr § 7.50(@)(9) j` tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots, Gdbtc‘s Kuby 30, 9537 `jrfcb

clljffjgcthjo rdqudst jibhnctdg tad Lhty tj sdbdlt c shnoctjry chrbhod `jr `jrldg clljffjgcthjo

whtaho tad odxt <5 gcys (h.d., iy Cunust 34, 9537).

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst gdohds tad cbbdncthjos ho pcrcnrcpa 71.

78.

Crthlbd H.<.i j` tad @hvd Ucrty Cnrddfdot rdquhrds tad Lhty ‒tj rdquhrd tad sacrhon

j` prd`drdothcb bdcsd nctds, pursucot tj Gcbbcs‘ dxhsthon bdcsd crrcondfdots,‖ ho tad dvdot tact

dxhsthon lcrrhdrs rdùsd tj clljffjgctd c odw dotrcot.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst gd`drs tj tad tdxt j` tad @hvd Ucrty Cnrddfdot `jr hts

prdlhsd wjrghon, iut rdfcrms tact tad @hvd Ucrty Cnrddfdot‘s ‒sacrhon‖ rdquhrdfdot hs

suikdlt tj tad Bdcsd, wahla scys sula sacrhon j` nctd spcld lcoojt uoguby hotdr`drd whta c

shnoctjry‘s sladgubdg usd cog lcoojt tcmd prdldgdold jvdr tad shnoctjry lcrrhdr‘s usd.






45. \dlthjo 4(c) j` tad ^rhnat Cfdogfdot Yd`jrf Clt rdquhrds tad Lhty tj ‒ajojr

tad slcrld rdsjurld prjvhshjos j`‖ tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots ct Bjvd @hdbg.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst gd`drs tj tad tdxt j` ^CYC `jr hts prdlhsd wjrghon cog cbsj

ojtds tad dxprdss bhfhtcthjos jo tad nrcot cssurcolds‘ cppbhlcihbhty tj Bjvd @hdbg hfpjsdg

iy ^CYC.

43. Wad Ljfpdththjo Ubco cog hts upgctds rdquhrd tad Lhty tj clljffjgctd ojo-bdcsd-

ajbghon chrbhods waj whsa tj prjvhgd sdrvhld ct Bjvd @hdbg iy do`jrlhon tad nctd-sacrhon

prjvhshjos j` tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots‗spdlh`hlcbby, \dlthjo 7.50(@).


49.

Gdbtc dxpdltdg tact tad Lhty wjubg bhvd up tj hts dog j` tad icrncho uogdr tad

Bdcsd Cnrddfdots cog uogdr `dgdrcb bcw iy ojth`yhon tad tardd holufidot lcrrhdrs j` tad oddg tj

clljffjgctd Gdbtc cog‗h` ojod j` tadf wcs whbbhon tj gj sj vjbuotcrhby‗rdquhrhon jod j` tad

tardd tj clljffjgctd Gdbtc uogdr § 7.50(@)(9) j` tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots. Cog hogddg,

tarjunajut tad suffdr cog `cbb j` 9537, tad Lhty rdpdctdgby rdprdsdotdg tj Gdbtc tact ht hotdogdg

tj gj dxcltby tact;

Jo Kuod 3<, 9537, Fcrm Gudiodr (tad Lhty‘s cvhcthjo ghrdltjr) cog FhlacdbCocstcs (c Gdbtc rdnhjocb ghrdltjr) spjmd iy tdbdpajod cijut Gdbtc‘s rdqudstcog oddg `jr clljffjgcthjo, cog Fr. Gudiodr cssurdg Fr. Cocstcs tactGudiodr wjubg gj dvdrytahon ho ahs cutajrhty tj fcmd surd tad Lhtyclljffjgctdg Gdbtc.

Ho c `jbbjw-up pajod ljovdrscthjo jo Kuod 99, 9537, idtwddo Fr.Gudiodr cog Ajbgdo \acoojo (c \dohjr Phld Urdshgdot `jr Gdbtc), Fr.

Gudiodr ljffhttdg tj Fr. \acoojo tact tad Lhty wjubg clljffjgctd Gdbtc‘sdxhsthon sladgubd.

Gurhon Cunust cog \dptdfidr, 9537, Gdbtc rdprdsdotcthvds pcrthlhpctdg ho

fddthons whta Bjvd @hdbg stc`` tj prdpcrd `jr Gdbtc‘s clljffjgcthjo ct jodjr fjrd j` tad nctds j` tad holufidot lcrrhdrs. Jod j` tadsd fddthonsjllurrdg jo Waursgcy, \dptdfidr 33, 9537. Ct tad fddthon, tad Lhtyrdprdsdotdg cog ljffhttdg tact ht wjubg rdquhrd Tohtdg tj clljffjgctd





Gdbtc. Fr. Gudiodr tjbg Fr. Cocstcs, ‒H whbb ojth`y Tohtdg tjfjrrjw,Fjogcy ct tad bctdst, cog tdbb tadf tady oddg tj clljffjgctd Gdbtcsj yju lco pbco yjur fjvd.‖

Gurhon c tdbdpajod ljovdrscthjo jo \dptdfidr 31, 9537, Fr. Gudiodr

ljffhttdg tj Fr. \acoojo tact tad chrpjrt wjubg `hog c wcy tj clljffjgctdGdbtc‘s dxhsthon sladgubd j` `hvd gchby `bhnats `rjf Bjvd @hdbg tj Ctbcotc.

Jo \dptdfidr 38, 9537, Fr. Gudiodr cog Fr. Cocstcs spjmd iy tdbdpajod,cog Fr. Gudiodr rdprdsdotdg tj Fr. Cocstcs tact ad acg ojth`hdg Tohtdgtact ht wjubg id rdquhrdg tj clljffjgctd Gdbtc.

Jo \dptdfidr 99, 9537, Fr. Gudiodr twhld ljffhttdg tj Fr. Cocstcs tacttad Lhty wjubg rdquhrd Tohtdg tj clljffjgctd Gdbtc c`tdr Gdbtc‘s suibdcsdwhta Cfdrhlco dxphrdg jo Jltjidr 39, 9537.


cijut tad cbbdncthjos ho pcrcnrcpa 49.

4<. Gdsphtd tad Lhty‘s rdpdctdg prjfhsds tact ht wjubg clljffjgctd Gdbtc‘s

dxpcogdg jpdrcthjos ct Bjvd @hdbg, tad Lhty `chbdg tj pdr`jrf hts jibhncthjo uogdr tad Bdcsd

Cnrddfdots. Jo Fjogcy, \dptdfidr 98, 9537, Fr. Gudiodr sdot Gdbtc c bdttdr rdodnhon jo tad

Lhty‘s prjfhsd cog ho`jrfhon Gdbtc `jr tad `hrst thfd tact tad Lhty wjubg ojt clljffjgctd Gdbtc

ct Bjvd @hdbg. Ho ahs bdttdr, Fr. Gudiodr cbsj stctdg tact Tohtdg cog \jutawdst acg dotdrdg hotj c

Nctd Tsd Bhldosd Cnrddfdot uogdr wahla Tohtdg wjubg csshno hts nctd spcld tj \jutawdst‗

whta tad Lhty‘s ljosdot.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst gdohds tact tad Lhty ojt clljffjgcthon Gdbtc wcs c `chburd

j` hts jibhncthjos uogdr tad Bdcsd. \jutawdst bclms mojwbdgnd jr ho`jrfcthjo su``hlhdot tj

`jrf c idbhd` cijut tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos ho pcrcnrcpa 4<.

47. Wad Lhty‘s cpprjvcb j` tahs crrcondfdot wcs ljfpbdtdby uocothlhpctdg. Gurhon

tad ghvdsthturd j` Cfdrhlco‘s nctds, tad GJK acg rdpdctdgby dfpacshzdg tad Lhty‘s jibhncthjo tj

prjfjtd ljfpdththjo ct Bjvd @hdbg. Cog tadsd ljoldros cijut ljfpdththjo crd wdbb-`juogdg.

Lcsd <;34-lv-59508-M Gjlufdot 318 @hbdg 58/99/34 Ucnd 9> j` >1 UcndHG 45><




Idtwddo 9557 cog 9537, gjfdsthl `crd prhlds ct Bjvd @hdbg holrdcsdg iy co cstjuoghon 10%‗

fjrd taco coy jtadr tjp 355 chrpjrt (cs rcomdg iy vjbufd j` pcssdondrs) ho tad Tohtdg \tctds.

Dvdo id`jrd tad ^rhnat Cfdogfdot dxphrdg, `crd prhlds ct Bjvd @hdbg idtwddo 955> cog 9539

wdrd dxpdrhdolhon jod j` tad ahnadst holrdcsds ho tad ljuotry. \hfhbcr `crd-prhld holrdcsds

jllurrdg ct Ajustjo Ajiiy cog Lahlcnj Fhgwcy, wahla crd cbsj \jutawdst-gjfhoctdg chrpjrts.

\jutawdst sdrvds jvdr 85% j` tad pcssdondrs ct tadsd chrpjrts, cog acs iddo cibd tj shnoh`hlcotby

holrdcsd `crd prhlds ct dcla chrpjrt gdsphtd tad prdsdold j` cojtadr, bcrndr chrpjrt whtaho tad scfd

fdtrjpjbhtco crdc. Odvdrtadbdss, uothb tad hotrjgulthjo j` Phrnho Cfdrhlc ho Fcy 9537,

\jutawdst‘s gjfhocold acg nrjwo bcrndby uoladlmdg.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact Bjvd @hdbg‘s cvdrcnd `crd acs holrdcsdg `rjf

9557 tj 9537, iut rdfcrms tact Gdbtc‘s cbbdncthjo hnojrds tad `clt tact tad cvdrcnd

pcssdondr pdr trhp bdonta ct Bjvd @hdbg holrdcsdg suistcothcbby jvdr tahs thfd, wahla

octurcbby clljuots `jr ahnadr `crds, cog hnojrds tad holrdcsdg ladlmdg icnncnd `dds cog

rdsdrvcthjo lacond cog lcoldbbcthjo `dds lacrndg iy jtadr chrbhods (iut ojt \jutawdst),

wahla acvd tad d``dlt j` uogdrstcthon `crds ct jtadr chrpjrts cs ljfpcrdg tj Bjvd @hdbg.


44. Wad Lhty‘s cpprjvcb j` Phrnho Cfdrhlc‘s dotry hotj Bjvd @hdbg sunndstdg tact ht

wcs cwcrd j` \jutawdst‘s tardct tj adcbtay ljfpdththjo ct tad chrpjrt. Ho bhnat j` tahs rdodwdg

ljffhtfdot tj ljfpdththjo, Gdbtc ùbby cothlhpctdg tact tad Lhty wjubg id fjrd taco whbbhon tj

ùrtadr dxpcog tad `byhon puibhl‘s jpthjos ct Bjvd @hdbg. Ljfpdththjo wjubg ojt joby ljostrcho

prhld ct Bjvd @hdbg, iut wjubg prjvhgd cgghthjocb jpthjos tj c shnoh`hlcot sdnfdot j` tad `byhon

puibhl tact wjubg prd`dr tad supdrhjr rdbhcihbhty cog sdrvhld j` `byhon jo Gdbtc. Wahs hs

pcrthlubcrby trud nhvdo tact \jutawdst‘s ‒oj `rhbbs‖ sdrvhld‗oj csshnodg jr prdfhuf sdcts, oj





`hrst lbcss‗hs oj bjondr clljfpcohdg iy tad `crd cgvcotcnds tact \jutawdst wcs jold rdputdg tj

prjvhgd.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst gdohds tad cbbdncthjos ho tad `hrst sdotdold j` pcrcnrcpa 44.

\jutawdst bclms mojwbdgnd jr ho`jrfcthjo su``hlhdot tj cgfht jr gdoy tad cbbdncthjos ho tad

sdljog sdotdold j` pcrcnrcpa 44. \jutawdst gdohds Gdbtc‘s ljotdothjo tact tad rdbdvcot

`jlus `jr ‒ljfpdththjo‖ ho tad Gcbbcs-@jrt ^jrta fcrmdt hs ljfpdththjo ct hoghvhgucb

chrpjrts, cs jppjsdg tj ljfpdththjo ho tad fcrmdt cs c wajbd. \jutawdst gdohds tad


40.

Odvdrtadbdss, dvdo tajuna Gdbtc acg `jrfcbby ojth`hdg tad Lhty j` hts rdqudst `jr

`jrldg clljffjgcthjo jo Kuby 30, 9537, cog ghbhndotby pursudg ht tadrdc`tdr= cog dvdo tajuna

\dlthjo 7.50(@)(9) j` tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots rdquhrdg tad Lhty tj clt jo tact rdqudst whtaho tahrty

gcys= tad Lhty sthbb acg ojt cltdg jo Gdbtc‘s rdqudst ho dcrby Jltjidr 9537. Hrjohlcbby, wahbd tad

Lhty ljothoudg hts `chburd tj clt jo Gdbtc‘s clljffjgcthjo rdqudst, tad Lhty Ljuolhb vjtdg jo

Jltjidr 1, 9537 tj rdocfd tad fcho rjcg bdcghon tj Bjvd @hdbg c`tdr \jutawdst‘s lj-`juogdr,

Adri Mdbbdadr. ^hta hts suibdcsd `rjf Cfdrhlco sdt tj dxphrd jo Jltjidr 39, 9537, Gdbtc acg oj

lajhld iut tj dotdr hotj c sajrt-tdrf cnrddfdot tact wjubg cbbjw Gdbtc tj ljothoud jpdrcthon ct

Bjvd @hdbg. Clljrghonby, jo Jltjidr 35, 9537, Gdbtc dotdrdg hotj c Nctd Tsd Bhldosd

Cnrddfdot whta \jutawdst cog c @clhbhthds Tsd Bhldosd Cnrddfdot whta Tohtdg, tad ljfihodg

d``dlt j` wahla wcs tj cbbjw Gdbtc tj ljothoud jpdrcthon ct Bjvd @hdbg uothb Kcoucry 0, 9534.

Gdbtc shnodg tadsd cnrddfdots‗dvdo tajuna tad dljojfhl tdrfs ghg ojt ljfpby whta GJW

rdquhrdfdots cog wdrd bdss `cvjrcibd taco tad tdrfs tad Lhty j``drdg \jutawdst‗idlcusd tady

wdrd tad joby wcy Gdbtc ljubg cvjhg ghsrupthjo j` hts sladgubdg sdrvhld, ghspbcldfdot j` hts

trcvdbhon lustjfdrs, cog hrrdpcrcibd acrf tj hts iushodss rdputcthjo cog njjg whbb.




GD@DOGCOW \JTWA^D\W CHYBHOD\ LJ.‘\ CO\^DY WJ GDBWC‘\ CFDOGDG LJTOWDYLBCHF\COG LYJ\\ LBCHF\ CNCHO\W \JTWA^D\W CHYBHOD\, LJ. UCND <5

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact ad Lhty acg ojt `jrldg co clljffjgcthjo j`

Gdbtc ho Jltjidr 9537 cog tact Gdbtc dotdrdg hotj vjbuotcry cnrddfdots whta Tohtdg cog

\jutawdst tact cbbjwdg ht tj ljothoud ruoohon `hvd `bhnats tj Ctbcotc uothb Kcoucry 0, 9534.

\jutawdst cgfhts tact tad Lhty vjtdg tj rdocfd tad rjcg bdcghon tj Bjvd @hdbg c`tdr Adri

Mdbbdadr. \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 40.

4>. Ho Ojvdfidr 9537, tad Lhty ojth`hdg Gdbtc, \jutawdst, Tohtdg, cog Phrnho tact ht

hotdogdg tj gdvdbjp c Bjvd @hdbg clljffjgcthjo pjbhly tj usd jo Gdbtc‘s pdoghon

clljffjgcthjo rdqudst. Ho ljoodlthjo whta tact d``jrt, tad Lhty rdtchodg co cvhcthjo-hogustry

ljosubtcot tj cocbyzd cog fjgdb nctd-spcld cvchbcihbhty cog nctd uthbhzcthjo ct Bjvd @hdbg. Wad

Lhty prdsdotdg tad prdbhfhocry rdsubts j` tad ljosubtcot‘s cocbyshs ho c Ojvdfidr 95, 9537

fddthon whta tad `jur lcrrhdrs. Wad ljosubtcot‘s cocbyshs ljolbugdg tact cs j` Ojvdfidr 4, 9537,

ht wcs pjsshibd cog `dcshibd `jr Bjvd @hdbg tj clljffjgctd Gdbtc‘s `hvd gchby `bhnats.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact c ljosubtcot jphodg tact cs j` Ojvdfidr 4,

9537, ht wcs pjsshibd tj clljffjgctd Gdbtc‘s `hvd gchby `bhnats ct Bjvd @hdbg, iut gdohds tact

tad fdtajgjbjny, jphohjos, cog/jr ljolbushjos j` tad ljosubtcot wdrd cllurctd cog prjpdr.

\jutawdst ùrtadr gdohds tad ojthjo tact coy shonbd gctd sajubg id usdg `jr sula

gdtdrfhocthjo, shold ht gjds ojt tcmd hotj ljoshgdrcthjo ùturd pbcos j` c shnoctjry lcrrhdr

tj ùbby uthbhzd hts bdcsdg spcld `jr hts jwo jpdrcthjos. \jutawdst cgfhts tad rdfchohon

cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 4>.

41. Wad Lhty coojuoldg hts prjpjsdg clljffjgcthjo pjbhly bdss taco twj wddms

bctdr, jo Gdldfidr 3, 9537. Wad Lhty‘s prjpjsdg pjbhly ljo`hrfs tact tad Lhty whbb idnho hts

clljffjgcthjo cocbyshs iy gdtdrfhohon ‒c ‑\ocpsajt Gctd‘ tact whbb stcrt tad thfd pdrhjg `jr

cssdsshon rdcsjocibd clljffjgcthjo.‖ Cbtajuna Lhty pjbhly sdts tad \ocpsajt Gctd ct tad gcy

Lcsd <;34-lv-59508-M Gjlufdot 318 @hbdg 58/99/34 Ucnd <5 j` >1 UcndHG 45>0




j` tad rdqudst, tad Lhty acs rdprdsdotdg ho wrhthon tact ht whbb trdct Ojvdfidr 4, 9537, cs tad

\ocpsajt Gctd `jr purpjsds j` dvcbucthon Gdbtc‘s rdqudst `jr clljffjgcthjo j` hts `hvd `bhnats.

Gdbtc acs ljosdotdg tj cog rdbhdg jo tad Lhty‘s usd j` Ojvdfidr 4, 9537, cs tad \ocpsajt Gctd.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tad cbbdncthjos ho tad `hrst sdotdold j` pcrcnrcpa 41.

\jutawdst bclms mojwbdgnd jr ho`jrfcthjo su``hlhdot tj `jrf c idbhd` cs tj tad bcst sdotdold

j` pcrcnrcpa 41. \jutawdst gdohds coy cbbdncthjo tact tad prjpjsdg clljffjgcthjo

‒pjbhlhds‖ sdot iy tad Lhty jo Gdldfidr 3, 9537, ljosthtutdg `jrfcb ‒Lhty pjbhly.‖

\jutawdst cbsj gdohds tact c sj-lcbbdg ‒socpsajt gctd‖ acs coy bdncb vcbhghty uogdr tad

Bjvd @hdbg Bdcsd jr jtadr cppbhlcibd bcw. \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j`

pcrcnrcpa 41.

48. Jold c \ocpsajt Gctd hs sdbdltdg, tad Lhty‘s pjbhly rdquhrds tad Lhty tj

‒gdtdrfhod wact sladgubd whbb id usdg `jr cssdsshon sladgubdg jpdrcthjos. Ojrfcbby, tahs whbb

id tad sladgubd `jr tad shx fjotas `jbbjwhon tad \ocpsajt Gctd.‖ ^hta tad Lhty‘s acvhon

sdbdltdg Ojvdfidr 4, 9537, cs tad \ocpsajt Gctd, Lhty pjbhly hoghlctds tact tad Lhty sajubg

cssdss \jutawdst‘s sladgubdg jpdrcthjos icsdg jo \jutawdst‘s sladgubd `rjf Ojvdfidr 4,

9537, tj Fcy 7, 9534. Gurhon tact shx-fjota whogjw, \jutawdst wcs jpdrcthon idtwddo 378

cog 34< `bhnats pdr gcy jut j` shxtddo nctds ct Bjvd @hdbg. Nhvdo tact dcla nctd ct Bjvd @hdbg lco

clljffjgctd ct bdcst tdo `bhnats pdr gcy, \jutawdst ljubg clljffjgctd Gdbtc‘s `hvd gchby

`bhnats‗bdss taco <% j` wact \jutawdst wjubg `by‗jo jod j` hts shxtddo bdcsdg nctds whtajut

coy ghsrupthjo tj jr hotdr`drdold whta hts jpdrcthjos. Fjrdjvdr, \jutawdst clquhrdg dvdo fjrd

nctd lcpclhty wado ht suibdcsdg twj nctds `rjf Tohtdg ho Cprhb 9534.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact ht clquhrdg cgghthjocb nctd spcld wado ht

suibdcsdg twj nctds `rjf Tohtdg iut gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos ho pcrcnrcpa 48.

Lcsd <;34-lv-59508-M Gjlufdot 318 @hbdg 58/99/34 Ucnd <3 j` >1 UcndHG 45>>




05. Ct tad scfd thfd tad Lhty coojuoldg hts Bjvd @hdbg clljffjgcthjo pjbhly, tad

Lhty rdodwdg hts prjfhsd tj clljffjgctd Gdbtc ct Bjvd @hdbg. Ho c Gdldfidr 3, 9537 bdttdr tj

Gdbtc, \jutawdst, cog Phrnho Cfdrhlc, tad Lhty clmojwbdgndg tact Gdbtc acg dxacustdg cbb

rdcsjocibd d``jrts tj sdlurd vjbuotcry clljffjgcthjo cog `jrfcbby hohthctdg tad <5-gcy

ljuotgjwo ljotdfpbctdg iy \dlthjo 7.50 j` tad Chrpjrt Tsd cog Bdcsd Cnrddfdots. Wad Lhty

hostrultdg dcla j` tad tardd holufidot lcrrhdrs tj ‒ljoshgdr wadtadr ht lco clljffjgctd Gdbtc‘s

rdqudst‖ `jr clljffjgcthjo cog rdprdsdotdg tj tad holufidot lcrrhdrs cog Gdbtc ‒tact h` Gdbtc

acs ojt iddo clljffjgctdg whtaho <5 gcys, tad Lhty whbb sdbdlt c shnoctjry chrbhod tj ljfpby

whta Gdbtc‘s clljffjgcthjo rdqudst ho c ojo-ghslrhfhoctjry fcoodr tj tad dxtdot tact

clljffjgcthjo whbb ojt uoguby hotdr`drd whta tad shnoctjry chrbhod‘s jpdrcthon sladgubd.‖ Wad

Lhty rdhtdrctdg tact ‒]jVo Gdldfidr <3, 9537, h` wd acvd ojt rdldhvdg ojth`hlcthjo tact Gdbtc acs

iddo vjbuotcrhby clljffjgctdg, tad Lhty whbb fcmd c fcogctjry clljffjgcthjo cs prjvhgdg ho

tad Tsd cog Bdcsd Cnrddfdot.‖ Gdsphtd tahs prjfhsd, cog gdsphtd tad `clt tact tad Lhty odvdr

rdldhvdg c ojthld j` vjbuotcry clljffjgcthjo, Gdldfidr <3, 9537, lcfd cog wdot whtajut tad

Lhty‘s ajojrhon hts prjfhsd cog fcmhon c fcogctjry clljffjgcthjo.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst gd`drs tj tad Lhty‘s Gdldfidr 3 bdttdr `jr hts prdlhsd

wjrghon. \jutawdst cgfhts tact tad Lhty ghg ojt `jrld co clljffjgcthjo j` Gdbtc.


03. ^hta Gdbtc‘s Nctd Tsd cog @clhbhthds Tsd Bhldosd Cnrddfdots dxphrhon jo

Kcoucry 0, 9534, tad Lhty‘s `chburd tj fcmd njjg jo hts prjfhsd tj `jrld clljffjgcthjo iy tad

dog j` Gdldfidr bd`t Gdbtc whta oj lajhld iut tj cncho dotdr hotj c sajrt-tdrf cnrddfdot jo

uo`cvjrcibd tdrfs tact wjubg docibd ht tj ljothoud jpdrcthon jut j` Bjvd @hdbg. Clljrghonby, jo

Lcsd <;34-lv-59508-M Gjlufdot 318 @hbdg 58/99/34 Ucnd <9 j` >1 UcndHG 45>1



GD@DOGCOW \JTWA^D\W CHYBHOD\ LJ.‘\ CO\^DY WJ GDBWC‘\ CFDOGDG LJTOWDYLBCHF\COG LYJ\\ LBCHF\ CNCHO\W \JTWA^D\W CHYBHOD\, LJ. UCND <<

Kcoucry 0, 9534, Gdbtc dotdrdg hotj twj cnrddfdots whta Tohtdg tact cbbjwdg Gdbtc tj ljothoud

jpdrcthon ct Bjvd @hdbg uothb Kuby 0, 9534.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact Gdbtc dotdrdg hotj cnrddfdots whta Tohtdg tact

cbbjwdg Gdbtc tj ljothoud ruoohon hts `hvd `bhnats tj Ctbcotc `rjf Bjvd @hdbg uothb Kuby 0,

9534. \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos ho pcrcnrcpa 03.

09. Jo Kcoucry 4, 9534, tad Lhty fcgd sthbb cojtadr prjfhsd tj clljffjgctd Gdbtc ct

Bjvd @hdbg. Ho c bdttdr tj Gdbtc, tad GJW, \jutawdst, cog Tohtdg, tad Lhty dxpbchodg tact hts

prd`drdold wcs tj sdd ‒tad lcrrhdrs ]V rdcla c pdrfcodot ljosdosucb rdsjbuthjo ljoldrohon Gdbtc‘s

rdqudst `jr nctd clljffjgcthjo‖ sj tact tad Lhty wjubg ‒ojt acv]dV tj fcogctd clljffjgcthjo‖

iut rdhtdrctdg cog rdc``hrfdg tact tad Lhty ‒whbb ljothoud jur fcogctjry clljffjgcthjo prjldss

uobdss ho`jrfdg iy lcrrhdrs tact ht hs oj bjondr odldsscry.‖ Wad rd`drdoldg ‒fcogctjry

clljffjgcthjo prjldss‖ hs tad prjldss idnuo iy tad Lhty‘s Gdldfidr 3, 9537 bdttdr, ho wahla

tad Lhty prjfhsdg tact ‒ht whbb fcmd c fcogctjry clljffjgcthjo‖ j` Gdbtc ct Bjvd @hdbg.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst gd`drs tj tad tdxt j` tad Lhty‘s Kcoucry 4 bdttdr `jr hts

prdlhsd wjrghon. \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 09.

0<. Jo Kcoucry 91, 9534, tad Lhty ydt cncho prjfhsdg tj clljffjgctd Gdbtc ct

Bjvd @hdbg. âdo ht ljosdotdg tj \jutawdst‘s suibdcsd j` twj nctds `rjf Tohtdg (sdd

ghslusshjo ho`rc § PHHH), tad Lhty rdprdsdotdg tact ht wcs trdcthon tad GJW‘s Gdldfidr 3>,

9537 bdttdr (sdd ghslusshjo ho`rc § PHH) ‒cs prjfubncthon `hocb cog ihoghon ghrdlthvds‖ tact

njvdrodg tad Lhty‘s acogbhon j` tad ‒rdqudst `jr clljffjgcthjo ct Bjvd @hdbg iy Gdbtc.‖ Wad

GJW‘s Gdldfidr 3>, 9537 bdttdr stctdg tact tad GJW dxpdltdg tad Lhty tj clljffjgctd

Gdbtc ct Bjvd @hdbg h` pjsshibd. Wad rdbdvcot gctc dstcibhsads tact ht hs pjsshibd tj

clljffjgctd Gdbtc ct Bjvd @hdbg. Waus, tad Lhty‘s stctdfdot ho hts wrhttdo ljosdot hs c ùrtadr

Lcsd <;34-lv-59508-M Gjlufdot 318 @hbdg 58/99/34 Ucnd << j` >1 UcndHG 45>8




clmojwbdgndfdot cog rdprdsdotcthjo tact tad Lhty hs suikdlt tj cog whbb ljfpby whta tad GJW‘s

ihoghon ghrdlthvd tact Gdbtc sajubg id clljffjgctdg ct Bjvd @hdbg.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact ht suibdcsdg Tohtdg‘s twj Bjvd @hdbg nctds cog

tact tad Lhty ljosdotdg tj tad suibdcsd, cs rdquhrdg iy tad Bdcsd. \jutawdst gd`drs tj tad

tdxt j` tad Lhty‘s ljosdot `jr hts prdlhsd wjrghon. \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon

cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 0<.

07. Jo @dirucry 9<, 9534, Gdbtc rdqudstdg clljffjgcthjo j` dhnat fjrd gchby `bhnats

ct Bjvd @hdbg idnhoohon Cunust 34, 9534. Gdbtc fcgd hts rdqudst tj \jutawdst, Phrnho, cog

\dcpjrt. Gdbtc cbsj ojth`hdg tad Lhty j` hts rdqudst `jr clljffjgcthjo. Cs j` @dirucry 9<,

9534‗tad gctd j` Gdbtc‘s clljffjgcthjo rdqudst‗ht wcs pjsshibd tj clljffjgctd co

cgghthjocb dhnat gchby Gdbtc `bhnats ct Bjvd @hdbg ho bhnat j` tad holufidot lcrrhdrs‘ tado-lurrdot

nctd uscnd cog whtajut hfpclthon tadhr lurrdot jr cbrdcgy-coojuoldg, `jr-scbd sdrvhlds. Ojt

ljholhgdotcbby, jo @dirucry 90, 9534, \jutawdst `hrst coojuoldg hts hotdothjo tj dxpcog hts `bhnat

sladgubd ct Bjvd @hdbg tj 315 gchby `bhnats cs j` Cunust 8, 9534.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tad cbbdncthjos ho tad `hrst cog sdljog sdotdolds j`

pcrcnrcpa 07. \jutawdst bclms mojwbdgnd jr ho`jrfcthjo su``hlhdot tj cgfht jr gdoy

cbbdncthjos ho tad tahrg sdotdold j` pcrcnrcpa 07. \jutawdst gdohds tad cbbdncthjos ho tad

`jurta sdotdold j` pcrcnrcpa 07. \jutawdst cgfhts tact \jutawdst coojuoldg co

dxpcogdg `bhnat sladgubd ct Bjvd @hdbg tact wjubg ubthfctdby rdsubt ho 315 gchby `bhnats cs j`

Cunust 8, 9534, cs pcrt j` hts nrcgucb rcfp-up j` `bhnats `jbbjwhon tad suosdt j` tad ^rhnat

Cfdogfdot rdstrhlthjos. \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos ho pcrcnrcpa 07.

04. Odhtadr \jutawdst, Phrnho, ojr \dcpjrt cnrddg tj vjbuotcrhby clljffjgctd

Gdbtc‘s rdqudst `jr dhnat cgghthjocb `bhnats. Jo @dirucry 9>, 9534, \jutawdst rdspjogdg tj

Lcsd <;34-lv-59508-M Gjlufdot 318 @hbdg 58/99/34 Ucnd <7 j` >1 UcndHG 4515




Gdbtc‘s clljffjgcthjo rdqudst, stcthon tact ht wjubg ojt ‒j``dr coy clljffjgcthjo idyjog Kuby

38, 9534.‖ Jo Fcrla 35, 9534, Phrnho sdot c bdttdr tj Gdbtc stcthon tact ht wjubg rdùsd tj

clljffjgctd Gdbtc‘s rdqudst `jr dhnat cgghthjocb `bhnats. \dcpjrt `chbdg tj rdspjog tj Gdbtc‘s

rdqudst iy tad rdqudstdg rdspjosd gctd j` Fcrla 8, 9534.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact \jutawdst ghg ojt cnrdd tj clljffjgctd

Gdbtc‘s rdqudstdg dhnat cgghthjocb `bhnats idlcusd \jutawdst wcs njhon tj id ùbby uthbhzhon

hts nctds. \jutawdst bclms mojwbdgnd jr ho`jrfcthjo su``hlhdot tj cgfht jr gdoy tad

rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j` tad `hrst sdotdold j` pcrcnrcpa 04. \jutawdst cgfhts tad

cbbdncthjos j` tad sdljog sdotdold j` pcrcnrcpa 04. \jutawdst bclms mojwbdgnd jr

ho`jrfcthjo su``hlhdot tj cgfht jr gdoy tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 04.

00. Jo Cprhb 91, 9534, Gdbtc ojth`hdg tad Lhty tact ht acg ‒dxacustdg cbb rdcsjocibd

d``jrts tj sdlurd vjbuotcry clljffjgcthjo `jr tad cgghthjocb dhnat `bhnats‖ cog rdqudstdg tact tad

Lhty clljffjgctd hts jrhnhocb `hvd-`bhnat rdqudst cog ojth`y tad holufidot lcrrhdrs j` tad oddg tj

clljffjgctd Gdbtc‘s rdqudst `jr dhnat cgghthjocb `bhnats.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst bclms mojwbdgnd jr ho`jrfcthjo su``hlhdot tj cgfht jr gdoy tad


0>. Jvdr tad odxt sdvdrcb wddms, Gdbtc ljothoudg tj csm tad Lhty tj ajojr hts rdpdctdg

prjfhsds cog cgadrd tj GJW‘s ghrdlthvd iy clljffjgcthon Gdbtc ct Bjvd @hdbg. Gdbtc cgvhsdg

tad Lhty rdpdctdgby, holbughon iy dfchb jo Fcy 94, 9534, tact Gdbtc wcs rdbyhon jo tad Lhty‘s

rdpdctdg rdprdsdotcthjos tact tad Lhty hotdogdg tj `jrld clljffjgcthjo ct Bjvd @hdbg.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst bclms mojwbdgnd jr ho`jrfcthjo su``hlhdot tj cgfht jr gdoy tad

cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 0>.

PHH. GJW‘s Ghrdlthvd Ydquhrhon tad Lhty tj Clljffjgctd Gdbtc ct Bjvd @hdbg.





01. Jo Gdldfidr 3>, 9537, GJW prjvhgdg tad Lhty whta ihoghon, do`jrldcibd

ghrdlthjo jo ajw tj acogbd Gdbtc‘s pdoghon rdqudst `jr bjon-tdrf clljffjgcthjo ct Bjvd @hdbg

cog ljfpby whta hts `dgdrcb jibhncthjos. GJW prjvhgdg hts ghrdlthjo ho tad `jrf j` c bdttdr tj tad

Lhty `rjf hts ndodrcb ljuosdb, tad Ajojrcibd Mctaryo I. Wajfsjo. Ho hts Gdldfidr 3> bdttdr,

GJW lbcrh`hdg `jur hfpjrtcot pjhots ljoldrohon tad dxhstdold cog ljotjurs j` tad Lhty‘s

clljffjgcthjo jibhncthjo.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact tad GJW sdot c bdttdr tj tad Lhty jo Gdldfidr

3>, 9537 stcthon ldrtcho (uosuppjrtdg) jphohjos rdncrghon clljffjgcthjo ct Bjvd @hdbg.


08.

@hrst, GJW‘s Gdldfidr 3> bdttdr ljo`hrfdg tact tad Lhty hs jibhnctdg uogdr

dxhsthon `dgdrcb bcw tj clljffjgctd Gdbtc ct Bjvd @hdbg; ‒Jur ljfpdththjo pbco pjbhly rdquhrds

chrpjrt prjprhdtjrs tj csshst rdqudsthon lcrrhdrs sddmhon clldss, cog wd dxpdlt tact, h` c rdqudsthon

lcrrhdr hs uocibd tj crrcond c vjbuotcry clljffjgcthjo whta c shnocturd lcrrhdr, tad Lhty whbb

clljffjgctd tad rdqudsthon lcrrhdr tj tad dxtdot pjsshibd nhvdo tad lurrdot nctd uscnd, whtajut

hfpclthon lurrdot jr cbrdcgy-coojuoldg, `jr-scbd sdrvhlds iy tad shnoctjry lcrrhdrs.‖ Wad

rdbdvcot gctc‗holbughon tad `hoghons cog cocbyshs j` tad Lhty‘s jwo ljosubtcot‗dstcibhsads tact

tadrd wcs fjrd taco cfpbd spcld ct \jutawdst‘s nctds cog Tohtdg‘s nctds `jr Gdbtc‘s rdqudstdg

`hvd `bhnats jo tad Lhty‘s socpsajt gctd j` Ojvdfidr 4, 9537. Ho cgghthjo, tad rdbdvcot gctc

dstcibhsads tact tadrd wcs fjrd taco cfpbd spcld ct \jutawdst‘s nctds tj clljffjgctd Gdbtc‘s

cgghthjocb rdqudstdg dhnat `bhnats wado tady wdrd rdqudstdg jo @dirucry 9<, 9534. Ho bhnat j`

tahs gctc, GJW‘s Gdldfidr 3> bdttdr hs co uoljoghthjocb ghrdlthvd rdquhrhon tad Lhty tj

clljffjgctd Gdbtc.




GD@DOGCOW \JTWA^D\W CHYBHOD\ LJ.‘\ CO\^DY WJ GDBWC‘\ CFDOGDG LJTOWDYLBCHF\COG LYJ\\ LBCHF\ CNCHO\W \JTWA^D\W CHYBHOD\, LJ. UCND <>

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst gdohds tact tad Gdldfidr 3> bdttdr schg tact tad Lhty hs

jibhnctdg tj clljffjgctd Gdbtc ct Bjvd @hdbg. \jutawdst gd`drs tj tad tdxt j` tad GJW‘s

Gdldfidr 3> bdttdr `jr hts prdlhsd wjrghon. \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos ho

pcrcnrcpa 08, holbughon `jjtojtd 9.

>5. \dljog, GJW spdlh`hdg tact tad gdtdrfhocthjo j` wadtadr clljffjgcthjo hs

‒pjsshibd nhvdo tad lurrdot nctd uscnd‖ sajubg id fcgd ‒icsdg jo tad cvchbcibd spcld jo tad

socpsajt gctd j` tad jrhnhocb clljffjgcthjo rdqudst.‖ Waus, h` co holufidot lcrrhdr coojuolds

pbcos `jr c ùturd holrdcsd ho sdrvhld c`tdr rdldhvhon c rdqudst `jr clljffjgcthjo, tad Lhty

sajubg ojt ljoshgdr tajsd pbcoodg ùturd sdrvhld holrdcsds wado gdtdrfhohon wadtadr

clljffjgcthjo hs pjsshibd. C `bhnat fcy id ljoshgdrdg cs pcrt j` tad clljffjgcthjo cocbyshs

joby h` ht wcs dhtadr ‒lurrdot]byV‖ jpdrctdg jr pcrt j` tad shnoctjry lcrrhdr‘s ‒cbrdcgy-coojuoldg,

`jr-scbd sdrvhlds‖ cs j` tad gctd j` tad clljffjgcthjo rdqudst.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst gd`drs tj tad tdxt j` tad GJW‘s Gdldfidr 3> bdttdr `jr hts

prdlhsd wjrghon, iut rdfcrms tact fcoy j` tad stctdfdots ho tad GJW‘s Gdldfidr 3> bdttdr

crd wajbby uosuppjrtdg iy bcw jr prhjr GJW jr @CC pjbhly, cog crd holjoshstdot whta tad

Bjvd @hdbg Bdcsd, tad @hvd Ucrty Cnrddfdot, cog ^CYC. \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon

cbbdncthjos ho pcrcnrcpa >5.

>3. Wahrg, GJW lbcrh`hdg tact tad Lhty hs rdquhrdg tj prjvhgd clljffjgcthjo jo c

bjon-tdrf icshs cog lcoojt fcmd Gdbtc‘s rhnat tj jpdrctd ct Bjvd @hdbg suijrghoctd jr sdljogcry

tj tad rhnat j` coy holufidot lcrrhdr;

^hta rdspdlt tj tad bdonta j` tad clljffjgcthjo, `jr tad clljffjgcthjo tj idfdcohonùb ct ]Bjvd @hdbgV, ht hs jur pjshthjo tact, jold clljffjgctdg, tadclljffjgctdg lcrrhdr hs dothtbdg tj co jonjhon shfhbcr pcttdro j` sdrvhld cs bjoncs tad lcrrhdr ljothouds tj jpdrctd tad clljffjgctdg `bhnats. Hfpjrtcotby, tadclljffjgctdg lcrrhdr sajubg ojt id pusadg jut iy holufidot lcrrhdrs ct c bctdrgctd.

Lcsd <;34-lv-59508-M Gjlufdot 318 @hbdg 58/99/34 Ucnd <> j` >1 UcndHG 451<




Wad Lhty taus acs c ‒rdspjoshihbhty tj ljothoud tad clljffjgcthjo cog dosurd tact spcld hs

cvchbcibd sj tact tad rdqudsthon lcrrhdr hs cibd tj fchotcho hts pcttdro j` sdrvhld jo co jonjhon

icshs.‖






>9.

@hocbby, GJW‘s Gdldfidr 3> bdttdr rdc``hrfs tact ‒]tVad Lhty fust cbsj dosurd tact

tad clljffjgcthjo hs ct rdcsjocibd rctds.‖ \pdlh`hlcbby, GJW‘s ‒ljfpdththjo pbco pjbhly

prjvhgds tact suibdcshon rctds ljvdrhon tad shnoctjry lcrrhdr‘s ghrdlt bdcshon ljsts `jr tad prj-rctc

sacrd j` suibdcsdg `clhbhthds, pbus‖ c rdcsjocibd cbbjwcold `jr cgfhohstrcthjo ojt tj dxlddg 94%,

‒crd rdcsjocibd.‖






><. C`tdr tad Gdldfidr 3> bdttdr, tadrd ljubg id oj gjuit tact tad Lhty wcs rdquhrdg

iy tad GJW‘s ljostrulthjo j` tad nrcot cssurcolds tj jrgdr tact Gdbtc id clljffjgctdg.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst gdohds tad cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa ><.

>7. Jo Kuod 34, 9534, GJW sdot tad Lhty c sdljog bdttdr. Wad Kuod 34 bdttdr

ljo`hrfdg tact tad Lhty‘s jibhncthjo tj clljffjgctd Gdbtc hs c fcttdr j` `dgdrcb bcw‗





spdlh`hlcbby, ht `bjws `rjf tad CHU nrcot-cssurcolds stctutd, tad CHU nrcot cnrddfdots, cog tad

ljfpdththjo-pbco stctutd. GJW cbsj rdhtdrctdg tad ljffjo-sdosd, ljfpdththjo-prjfjthon

prjpjshthjo tact ‒c gjfhocot shnoctjry lcrrhdr sajubg ojt id cibd tj ibjlm c rdqudsthon lcrrhdr

`rjf clldsshon Bjvd @hdbg iy coojuolhon ùturd pbcos tj dxpcog sdrvhld ]V c`tdr co

clljffjgcthjo rdqudst hs fcgd.‖ GJW ljolbugdg iy ljo`hrfhon `jr tad Lhty tact GJW

dxpdltdg tad Lhty ‒tj lcrry jut, ho c rdcsjocibd cog thfdby `csahjo, tad clljffjgcthjo d``jrts

wd gdslrhidg ho jur Gdldfidr 3> bdttdr.‖

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact tad GJW sdot tad Lhty c bdttdr jo Kuod 34, 9534,

stcthon ldrtcho (uosuppjrtdg) jphohjos rdncrghon clljffjgcthjo ct Bjvd @hdbg. \jutawdst

gdohds tact tad Kuod 34 bdttdr schg tact tad Lhty hs jibhnctdg tj clljffjgctd Gdbtc ct Bjvd

@hdbg. \jutawdst gd`drs tj tad tdxt j` tad GJW‘s Kuod 34 bdttdr `jr hts prdlhsd wjrghon, iut

rdfcrms tact fcoy j` tad stctdfdots ho tad GJW‘s Kuod 34 bdttdr crd wajbby uosuppjrtdg

iy bcw jr prhjr GJW jr @CC pjbhly, cog crd holjoshstdot whta tad Bjvd @hdbg Bdcsd, tad

@hvd Ucrty Cnrddfdot, cog ^CYC. \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos ho

pcrcnrcpa >7.

>4. Ho suf, GJW‘s twj bdttdrs ghrdlt tad Lhty tj `jrld clljffjgcthjo j` Gdbtc ct

Bjvd @hdbg tj tad dxtdot pjsshibd nhvdo lurrdot nctd uscnd ct tad thfd j` Gdbtc‘s rdqudst, whtajut

hfpclthon lurrdot jr cbrdcgy-coojuoldg, `jr-scbd sdrvhlds iy tad shnoctjry lcrrhdrs ct Bjvd @hdbg.

Cog uoghsputdg gctc‗ojt tj fdothjo \jutawdst‘s rdldot ljogult‗dstcibhsa tact nhvdo tad nctd

uscnd ct Bjvd @hdbg ct tad thfd j` Gdbtc‘s rdqudst tj ljothoud hts dxhsthon `bhnats, cs wdbb cs ct tad

Lhty‘s sdbdltdg socpsajt gctd j` Ojvdfidr 4, 9537, tadrd wcs rjjf `jr Gdbtc tj id

clljffjgctdg `jr hts `hvd dxhsthon `bhnats whtajut hfpclthon lurrdot jr cbrdcgy-coojuoldg, `jr-

scbd sdrvhlds iy tad shnoctjry lcrrhdrs ct Bjvd @hdbg. \hfhbcrby, wado Gdbtc rdqudstdg co





cgghthjocb dhnat `bhnats jo @dirucry 9<, 9534, tadrd wcs spcld `jr tajsd `bhnats whtajut hfpclthon

lurrdot jr cbrdcgy-coojuoldg, `jr-scbd sdrvhlds iy tad shnoctjry lcrrhdrs.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst gdohds tad cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa >4.

PHHH. Wad Lhty‘s Cpprjvcb j` \jutawdst‘s Coth-Ljfpdththvd \uibdcsd `rjf Tohtdg.

>0. Cs sdt `jrta cijvd, tad Lhty wcs rdquhrdg tj, iut ghg ojt, dosurd tact Gdbtc wcs

clljffjgctdg ct Bjvd @hdbg. Wad Lhty wcs cbsj rdquhrdg iy tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots tj ‒dxdrlhsd

hts rhnats adrduogdr ]h.d., uogdr tad Bdcsd CnrddfdotV cog jtadrwhsd jpdrctd tad chrpjrt . . . ho c

fcoodr tact hs ljoshstdot whta cppbhlcibd bcw, `dgdrcb cvhcthjo rdnubcthjos, `dgdrcb nrcot

cssurcolds, cog Lhty chrpjrt rdvdoud ijog jrghocolds.‖

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst gdohds tad cbbdncthjos ho tad `hrst sdotdold j` pcrcnrcpa >0.

\jutawdst cgfhts tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa >0, cog rdfcrms tact ùb`hbbhon

tajsd jibhncthjos rdquhrdg tad Lhty tj rdùsd tj clljffjgctd Gdbtc.

>>. Wad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots ljo`dr jo tad \hnoctjry Chrbhod (cs rdbdvcot adrd, Tohtdg)

tad ‒rhnat tj suibdt tad Bdcsdg Urdfhsds . . . tj coy pcrty= prjvhgdg, ht sacbb `hrst jitcho tad wrhttdo

cpprjvcb j` tad Lhty Fcocndr.‖ \jutawdst cog Tohtdg dotdrdg co cnrddfdot uogdr wahla

\jutawdst wjubg pcy co jisldod suf j` fjody tj Tohtdg tj jitcho tad odcr fjojpjby tact tad

suibdcsdg nctds wjubg prjvhgd ht. Togdr tact cnrddfdot, \jutawdst cnrddg tact h` ht wcs `jrldg

tj clljffjgctd cojtadr chrbhod, ht wjubg gj sj jo hts jwo bdcsdg nctds, ojt tad nctds suibdcsdg

`rjf Tohtdg. \jutawdst cog Tohtdg ojth`hdg tad Lhty j` tadhr cnrddfdot cog sjunat Lhty

Fcocndr cpprjvcb.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tad cbbdncthjos ljotchodg ho tad `hrst sdotdold j`

pcrcnrcpa >>. \jutawdst cgfhts tact ht dotdrdg hotj c suibdcsd whta Tohtdg `jr hts Bjvd





@hdbg nctds cog rdqudstdg tact tad Lhty ljosdot tj sula suibdcsd. \jutawdst gdohds tad

rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa >>.

>1. Uursucot tj tad tdrfs j` tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots, tad Lhty Fcocndr acs uo`dttdrdg

ghslrdthjo rdncrghon wadtadr tj nrcot sula cpprjvcb. Cbtdrocthvdby, tad Lhty Fcocndr‘s

ghslrdthjo hs bhfhtdg, ct fjst, iy c prjvhshjo cppbhlcibd iy hts tdrfs joby tj ljosdot rdquhrdg iy

‒tad Lhty jr tad Chrbhod,‖ wahla rdquhrds tact ljosdot ‒sacbb ojt id uordcsjociby whtaadbg jr

gdbcydg.‖

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst gdohds tad cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa >1.

>8.

Wad Lhty acg fjrd taco cgdquctd rdcsjos tj jikdlt tj tad suibdcsd. @hrst, tad Lhty

spdlh`hlcbby uogdrtjjm ho \dlthjo 37.38 j` tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots tj ‒dxdrlhsd hts rhnats ]uogdr tad

BdcsdV cog jtadrwhsd jpdrctd tad Chrpjrt whta gud rdncrg `jr . . . tad hotdrdsts j` tad trcvdbhon

puibhl.‖ Wad hotdrdsts j` tad trcvdbhon puibhl crd ho fjrd, ojt bdss, jpthjos `rjf Bjvd @hdbg.

Idlcusd Gdbtc acg cbrdcgy `jrfcbby rdqudstdg clljffjgcthjo, tad Lhty modw tact tad cbtdrocthvd

tj nrdctdr \jutawdst ljoldotrcthjo wcs nrdctdr ljfpdththjo `rjf Gdbtc. Cpprjvhon tad suibdcsd

wcs taus ljotrcry tj tad puibhl hotdrdst cog, cs c rdsubt, prjahihtdg iy tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdot.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst gd`drs tj tad tdxt j` tad Bdcsd `jr hts prdlhsd wjrghon.

\jutawdst gdohds tad cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa >8.

15. \dljog, tad Lhty spdlh`hlcbby uogdrtjjm ho \dlthjo 37.38 j` tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots

tj ‒dxdrlhsd hts rhnats ]uogdr tad BdcsdV cog jtadrwhsd jpdrctd tad Chrpjrt . . . ho c fcoodr tact hs

ljoshstdot whta cppbhlcibd bcw, `dgdrcb cvhcthjo rdnubcthjos, `dgdrcb nrcot cssurcolds, cog Lhty

chrpjrt rdvdoud ijog jrghocolds.‖ Nhvhon \jutawdst co dxlbushvd rhnat tj tad chrpjrt, cog

ghslrhfhocthon ho hts `cvjr ho fcmhon gdlhshjos rdncrghon clldss tj tad chrpjrt, wjubg vhjbctd





`dgdrcb nrcot cssurcolds. Clljrghonby, cpprjvhon \jutawdst‘s clquhshthjo j` sula co dxlbushvd

rhnat wcs prjahihtdg iy tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdot.


\jutawdst gdohds tad cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 15.

13. Wahrg, tad Lhty modw wado ht ljosdotdg tj tad suibdcsd tact \jutawdst cog Tohtdg

dcla acg rjjf tj clljffjgctd Gdbtc, iut tact ijta wdrd jppjshon clljffjgcthjo jo tad icshs

tact \jutawdst wjubg usd Tohtdg‘s nctds jold tajsd nctds wdrd suibdcsdg. Clljrghonby, hts

gdlhshjo tj ljosdot gdsphtd tad `clt tact \jutawdst cog Tohtdg wdrd wjrmhon tjndtadr tj dxlbugd

Gdbtc ̀ clhbhtctdg tad d``jrt tj `rustrctd Gdbtc‘s ljotrcltucb rhnats.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst gdohds tact Gdbtc acs coy ljotrcltucb rhnats ct Bjvd

@hdbg, cshgd `rjf tad lurrdot tdfpjrcry bhldosd cnrddfdot pursucot tj wahla ht hs

jpdrcthon. \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 13.

19. Gdsphtd tadsd suistcothcb rdcsjos tj rdùsd ljosdot tj tad suibdcsd, \jutawdst

iubbhdg cog tardctdodg tad Lhty hotj nrcothon ht tad ljosdot ht sjunat. Cog gdsphtd GJW‘s lbdcr

stctdfdots tj tad Lhty tact Gdbtc sajubg id pdrfcodotby clljffjgctdg id`jrd tad suibdcsd wcs

cpprjvdg, tad Lhty ghg ojt rdquhrd tact Gdbtc h̀rst id clljffjgctdg. Ajwdvdr, tad Lhty ghg

rdprdsdot tact ht wcs ‒trdcthon tad 9537 Bdttdr cs prjfubncthon `hocb cog ihoghon ghrdlthvds tj

`jrdlbjsd coy cbbdncthjo tact tad Lhty hs ho vhjbcthjo j` hts `dgdrcb nrcot cssurcolds cog tj cvjhg

tad rhsm j` bjshon `dgdrcb nrcots jr pcssdondr `clhbhty lacrnds.‖ Xdt gdsphtd tahs rdprdsdotcthjo,

tad Lhty acs `chbdg tj clt ho clljrgcold whta tad nrcot cssurcolds jr tad GJW Bdttdrs.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst gd`drs tj tad Lhty‘s ljosdot j` tad Tohtdg-\jutawdst

suibdcsd `jr hts prdlhsd wjrghon. \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j`

pcrcnrcpa 19.





HQ. Wahs Clthjo.

1<. Yctadr taco `jbbjwhon tad ljursd j` clthjo jutbhodg ho tad GJW Bdttdrs, jo Kuod 3>,

9534, tad Lhty hohthctdg tahs clthjo ho `dgdrcb ljurt, sddmhon gdlbcrctjry rdbhd` pursucot tj 91

T.\.L. § 9953 rdncrghon Gd`dogcots cog tad rhnats cog jibhncthjos j` tad Lhty cog Gd`dogcots

uogdr `dgdrcb bcw ljoldrohon tad usd j` chrlrc`t nctds ct tad Gcbbcs Bjvd @hdbg chrpjrt.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact tad Lhty hohthctdg tahs clthjo sddmhon

gdlbcrctjry rdbhd`, iut gd`drs tj tad Lhty‘s ljfpbchot `jr hts prdlhsd wjrghon cog rdqudst `jr

rdbhd`. \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 1<.

17.

Iy hohthcthon tahs clthjo, tad Lhty wchvdg coy njvdrofdotcb hffuohty `rjf suht

cog coy prjldgurcb rdquhshtds tj suht cs tj tad trcosclthjos jr jllurrdolds tact crd tad suikdlt

fcttdr j` tad Lhty‘s ljfpbchot.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tad cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 17.

14. Jo Kuod 38, 9534, Gdbtc prjvhgdg wrhttdo ojthld tj tad Lhty ljo`hrfhon hts

‒dxacusthjo j` ]htsV njjg-`chta d``jrts tj rdsjbvd ]htsV bjonstcoghon rdqudst `jr clljffjgcthjo ct

Gcbbcs Bjvd @hdbg‖ cog dbdlthon tj ‒vhdw tad Lhty ]csV ho irdcla‖ j` hts jibhncthjo tj

clljffjgctd Gdbtc. Ho tact bdttdr, Gdbtc ojth h̀dg tad Lhty tact ht wjubg ‒id sddmhon bdncb

rdljursd.‖


tad cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 14.

CO\^DY WJ LJTOWDYLBCHF\ CNCHO\W LHWX

Ljuotdrlbchf H; Gdlbcrctjry Kugnfdot Wact Gdbtc Fust Id Clljffjgctdg.

10.

Gdbtc holjrpjrctds iy rd`drdold tad cbbdncthjos j` cbb j` tad prdldghon pcrcnrcpas

cs tajuna ùbby sdt `jrta ho tahs Ljuotdrlbchf H.





YD\UJO\D; Oj rdspjosd hs odldsscry.

1>. Wadrd dxhsts c kusthlhcibd lcsd jr ljotrjvdrsy idtwddo Gdbtc cog tad Lhty cs tj

wadtadr tad Lhty hs rdquhrdg tj `jrld clljffjgcthjo j` Gdbtc ct Bjvd @hdbg.

YD\UJO\D; Ucrcnrcpa 1> ljotchos c bdncb ljolbushjo cog taus oj rdspjosd hs

odldsscry. Wj tad dxtdot c rdspjosd hs gddfdg rdquhrdg, \jutawdst gdohds tad cbbdncthjos ho

pcrcnrcpa 1>.

11. Wahs lcsd hs whtaho tad Ljurt‘s suikdlt fcttdr kurhsghlthjo, cog tad Ljurt acs

kurhsghlthjo jvdr cbb tad pcrthds tj tahs lcsd.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tad cbbdncthjos ljotchodg ho pcrcnrcpa 11.

18.

âdo Gdbtc rdqudstdg clljffjgcthjo j` shx `bhnats ho Kuod 9537, ijta \jutawdst

cog Tohtdg ljubg acvd clljffjgctdg tajsd `bhnats whtajut uogud hotdr`drdold whta tadhr

jpdrcthon sladgubd. \hfhbcrby, wado Gdbtc rdqudstdg clljffjgcthjo j` dhnat cgghthjocb `bhnats

ho @dirucry 9534, c`tdr \jutawdst suibdcsdg Tohtdg‘s nctds, \jutawdst ljubg acvd

clljffjgctdg tajsd `bhnats whtajut uogud hotdr`drdold whta hts jpdrcthon sladgubd. Wad Bdcsd

Cnrddfdot uocfihnujusby rdquhrds tad Lhty tj `jrld pdrfcodot clljffjgcthjo j` Gdbtc ct Bjvd

@hdbg.


85. Wad @hvd Ucrty Cnrddfdot, tad Ljfpdththjo Ubco cog hts upgctds, tad ^rhnat

Cfdogfdot Yd`jrf Clt, cog GJW‘s rdldot ghrdlthvds crd cbb ljoshstdot whta tad Bdcsd

Cnrddfdot cog gdshnodg tj d``dltuctd tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdot‘s clljffjgcthjo prjvhshjos cog

jibhncthjos.






83. Togdr suistcothcb prdssurd cog tardcts `rjf \jutawdst, tad Lhty ghg ojt rdquhrd

tact Gdbtc id pdrfcodotby clljffjgctdg ct Bjvd @hdbg, gdsphtd tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots, tad

GJW‘s bdttdrs, cog `dgdrcb bcw. Wad Lhty‘s `chburd tj `jrld clljffjgcthjo j` Gdbtc ct Bjvd

@hdbg acs lcusdg, cog h` ojt ljrrdltdg whbb ljothoud tj lcusd, Gdbtc tj su``dr hokury.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact tad Lhty acs odvdr `jrldg co clljffjgcthjo j`

Gdbtc. \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 83.

89. Gdbtc sddms c gdlbcrcthjo uogdr 91 T.\.L. § 9953 tact tad Lhty acs co jibhncthjo tj

rdquhrd tact Gdbtc id clljffjgctdg ct Bjvd @hdbg `jr tad `bhnats rdqudstdg ho hts Kuod 9537 cog

@dirucry 9534 bdttdrs.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact Gdbtc sddms tad rdbhd` ht rdqudsts, iut gdohds

tact Gdbtc hs dothtbdg tj coy rdbhd`.

Ljuotdrlbchf HH; Gdlbcrctjry Kugnfdot Wact tad Lhty Fust Ydlbchf Wwj Nctds `jr

Ljffjo Tsd.

8<.

Gdbtc holjrpjrctds iy rd`drdold tad cbbdncthjos j` cbb j` tad prdldghon pcrcnrcpas

cs tajuna ùbby sdt `jrta ho tahs Ljuotdrlbchf HH.


87. Wadrd dxhsts c kusthlhcibd lcsd jr ljotrjvdrsy idtwddo Gdbtc cog tad Lhty cs tj

wadtadr tad Lhty vhjbctdg tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots wado ht cpprjvdg tad suibdcsd cog tadrdiy

nrcotdg co dxlbushvd rhnat tj \jutawdst.

YD\UJO\D; Ucrcnrcpa 87 ljotchos c bdncb ljolbushjo cog taus oj rdspjosd hs

odldsscry. Wj tad dxtdot c rdspjosd hs gddfdg rdquhrdg, \jutawdst gdohds tad cbbdncthjos ho

pcrcnrcpa 87.








80. Wad Lhty acg ghslrdthjo uogdr tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots tj cpprjvd jr ghscpprjvd

Tohtdg‘s suibdcsd tj \jutawdst. âdo tad Lhty cpprjvdg tact suibdcsd, gdsphtd tad `clt tact ht

ncvd \jutawdst co dxlbushvd rhnat ct Bjvd @hdbg cog wcs ljotrcry tj tad puibhl hotdrdst, ht

vhjbctdg, ct c fhohfuf, \dlthjo 37.38 j` tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots.


8>.

Wad joby wcy tj rdfdgy tad dxlbushvd rhnats vhjbcthjo lcusdg iy tad Lhty‘s clthjo

hs tj gdlbcrd tact \jutawdst fust ghvdst twj nctds, bhfhthon hts ljotrjb jvdr Bjvd @hdbg tj 15% j`

tad cvchbcibd nctds cs ljotdfpbctdg ho tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdot cog @hvd Ucrty Cnrddfdot. Cs tad

GJK acs rdljnohzdg, pdrfhtthon \jutawdst tj acvd 31 j` tad 95 nctds wjubg gdstrjy ‒fdcohonùb

ljfpdththjo‖ ct Bjvd @hdbg.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst gdohds tad cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 8>.

81.

Idlcusd \jutawdst cog Tohtdg cbbjlctdg tad rhsm j` `jrldg clljffjgcthjo tj

\jutawdst tarjuna tad suibdcsd prjvhshjo rdquhrhon tact coy clljffjgcthjo id gjod jo nctds

jtadr taco tajsd suibdcsdg `rjf Tohtdg, tad prjpdr rdfdgy hs `jr \jutawdst tj ghvdst twj j` hts

jtadr nctds. Uursucot tj \dlthjo 7.50(D), tad twj nctds sajubg idljfd ‒Ljffjo Tsd Nctds‖

uogdr tad ljotrjb j` tad Lhty.


88. Wad Lhty‘s wrjonùb cpprjvcb j` tad suibdcsd cnrddfdot gud tj prdssurd `rjf

\jutawdst acs lcusdg, cog h` ojt ljrrdltdg whbb ljothoud tj lcusd, Gdbtc tj su``dr hokury.






355. Clljrghonby, Gdbtc sddms c gdlbcrcthjo uogdr 91 T.\.L. § 9953 tact \jutawdst

fcy ojt acvd bdcsd jr suibdcsd rhnats tj fjrd taco 30 nctds, cog tact tad Lhty fust rdlbchf twj

Bjvd @hdbg nctds tj id uthbhzdg cs ljffjo usd nctds.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact Gdbtc sddms tad rdbhd` ht rdqudsts, iut gdohds


Ljuotdrlbchf HHH; Irdcla j` tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots

353. Gdbtc holjrpjrctds iy rd`drdold tad cbbdncthjos j` cbb j` tad prdldghon pcrcnrcpas

cs tajuna ùbby sdt `jrta ho tahs Ljuotdrlbchf HHH.


359.

Wad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots crd vcbhg, do`jrldcibd ljotrclts.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tad cbbdncthjos ho pcrcnrcpa 359.

35<. Cs c odw dotrcot tj Bjvd @hdbg cog/jr c lcrrhdr sddmhon tj prjvhgd sdrvhld ct Bjvd

@hdbg cog/jr c shnoctjry tj c nctd usd bhldosd cnrddfdot, Gdbtc hs co hotdogdg cog/jr

ljotdfpbctdg cog/jr tahrg-pcrty idod`hlhcry j` tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots. Cs sula, Gdbtc hs c prjpdr

pcrty tj sud `jr irdcla j` tadsd Cnrddfdots.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst gdohds tad cbbdncthjos ho pcrcnrcpa 35<.

357. Iy sddmhon tj prjvhgd sdrvhld ct Bjvd @hdbg cog/jr dotdr Bjvd @hdbg cs c odw

dotrcot lcrrhdr, dxacusthon cbb rdcsjocibd d``jrts tj sdlurd vjbuotcry clljffjgcthjo `rjf tad

holufidot lcrrhdrs, cog tcmhon tad prjpdr stdps tj hovjmd hts rhnat tj `jrldg clljffjgcthjo,

Gdbtc pdr`jrfdg hts jibhncthjos uogdr tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots cog taus scths`hdg dvdry ljoghthjo

prdldgdot uogdr tad ljotrclt tj trhnndr tad Lhty‘s jibhncthjo tj `jrld tad clljffjgcthjo j` Gdbtc.






354. Ho cgghthjo, jr ho tad cbtdrocthvd, tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots crd ho wrhthon, stctd tad

dssdothcb tdrfs j` tad cnrddfdot idtwddo Gdbtc cog tad Lhty, prjfhsd tact tad Lhty whbb prjvhgd

Gdbtc whta c idod`ht h` Gdbtc pdr`jrfs, cog wdrd dxdlutdg jo idacb` j` tad Lhty. Clljrghonby,

dcla j` tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots hs c vcbhg cog do`jrldcibd uohbctdrcb ljotrclt idtwddo Gdbtc cog

tad Lhty.


350. Gdbtc `jrfdg c ljotrclt whta tad Lhty iy pdr`jrfhon uogdr tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdot.

Gdbtc pdr`jrfdg uogdr tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdot iy sddmhon tj prjvhgd sdrvhld ct Bjvd @hdbg cog/jr

dotdr Bjvd @hdbg cs c odw dotrcot lcrrhdr, dxacusthon cbb rdcsjocibd d``jrts tj sdlurd vjbuotcry

clljffjgcthjo `rjf tad holufidot lcrrhdrs, cog tcmhon tad prjpdr stdps tj hovjmd hts rhnat tj

`jrldg clljffjgcthjo. Cs c pcrty tj tad uohbctdrcb Bdcsd Cnrddfdot ljotrclt, Gdbtc hs c prjpdr

pcrty tj sud `jr irdcla j` tad uohbctdrcb Bdcsd Cnrddfdot ljotrclt.


35>. Wad Lhty irdcladg tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots‗holbughon, whtajut bhfhtcthjo, tad

prjvhshjos j` sdlthjo 7.50‗iy hotdr cbhc, (3) `chbhon tj `jrld clljffjgcthjo j` Gdbtc‘s rdqudst

`jr `hvd `bhnats ct Bjvd @hdbg whtaho <5 gcys j` tad Lhty‘s Gdldfidr 3, 9537 bdttdr= (9) `chbhon tj

suisdqudotby `jrld clljffjgcthjo j` Gdbtc‘s rdqudst `jr `hvd `bhnats c`tdr Gdbtc dxacustdg hts

njjg-`chta d``jrts tj jitcho hts rdqudstdg clljffjgcthjo= (<) `chbhon tj ojth`y tad holufidot

lcrrhdrs j` tad oddg tj clljffjgctd Gdbtc‘s rdqudst `jr dhnat cgghthjocb `bhnats c`tdr Gdbtc

dxacustdg cbb rdcsjocibd d``jrts tj sdlurd vjbuotcry clljffjgcthjo `jr tact rdqudst= cog (7)

`chbhon tj `jrld clljffjgcthjo j` Gdbtc‘s rdqudst `jr dhnat cgghthjocb `bhnats.






351. Ho cgghthjo, sdlthjo 37.38 j` tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdot rdquhrds tad Lhty tj jpdrctd

Bjvd @hdbg ho c fcoodr tact hs ljoshstdot whta `dgdrcb nrcot cssurcolds.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst gd`drs tj tad bconucnd j` sdlthjo 37.38 j` tad Bdcsd `jr hts

prdlhsd wjrghon, iut gdohds tact tad nrcot cssurcolds rdquhrd clljffjgcthjo j` Gdbtc.


358. Nrcot cssurcold 99, ‒Dljojfhl Ojoghslrhfhocthjo,‖ rdquhrds tad Lhty tj ‒fcmd

tad chrpjrt cvchbcibd cs co chrpjrt `jr puibhl usd jo rdcsjocibd tdrfs cog whtajut uokust

ghslrhfhocthjo tj cbb typds, mhogs cog lbcssds j` cdrjocuthlcb clthvhthds, holbughon ljffdrlhcb

cdrjocuthlcb clthvhthds j``drhon sdrvhlds tj tad puibhl ct tad chrpjrt.‖ Iy `chbhon tj prjvhgd Gdbtc

bjon-tdrf nctd clldss ct Bjvd @hdbg gdsphtd prjvhghon bjon-tdrf clldss tj shfhbcrby shtuctdg

chrbhods, tad Lhty acs vhjbctdg Nrcot Cssurcold 99.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tad cbbdncthjos ho tad `hrst sdotdold j` pcrcnrcpa

358. \jutawdst gdohds tad cbbdncthjos ho tad sdljog sdotdold j` pcrcnrcpa 358.

335. Nrcot cssurcold 9<, ‒Dxlbushvd Yhnats,‖ rdquhrds tad Lhty tj ‒pdrfht oj dxlbushvd

rhnat `jr tad usd j` tad chrpjrt iy coy pdrsjo prjvhghon, jr hotdoghon tj prjvhgd, cdrjocuthlcb

sdrvhlds tj tad puibhl.‖ Iy uordcsjociby cog whtajut kust lcusd dxlbughon Gdbtc `rjf jpdrcthon

ct Bjvd @hdbg, gdoyhon Gdbtc tad ljothoudg jppjrtuohty tj id co cdrjocuthlcb sdrvhld prjvhgdr ct

Bjvd @hdbg, cog ldghon ljotrjb j` Bjvd @hdbg‘s nctds tj c sfcbb oufidr j` chrbhods wahbd

uordcsjociby dxlbughon Gdbtc `rjf tad scfd bjon-tdrf nctd clldss ht acs nrcotdg tj jtadrs, tad

Lhty acs vhjbctdg Nrcot Cssurcold 9<.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tad cbbdncthjos ho tad `hrst sdotdold j` pcrcnrcpa

335. \jutawdst gdohds tad cbbdncthjos ho tad sdljog sdotdold j` pcrcnrcpa 335.





333. Iy vhjbcthon Nrcot Cssurcolds 99 cog 9<, tad Lhty acs irdcladg sdlthjo 37.38 j`

tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdot.


339. Ho cgghthjo, tad Lhty irdcladg sdlthjo 37.38 j` tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdot iy cpprjvhon

Tohtdg‘s suibdcsd tj \jutawdst, idlcusd cpprjvhon tad suibdcsd wcs ljotrcry tj tad hotdrdsts j`

tad trcvdbhon puibhl cog ljotrcry tj tad rdquhrdfdots j` cppbhlcibd bcw, `dgdrcb cvhcthjo

rdnubcthjos, `dgdrcb nrcot cssurcolds, cog/jr Lhty chrpjrt rdvdoud ijog jrghocolds.


33<.

Wad @hvd Ucrty Cnrddfdot‗holbughon, whtajut bhfhtcthjo, tad prjvhshjos j`

crthlbd 3.<.i‗ljo`hrfs tact tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots jibhnctd tad Lhty tj `jrld clljffjgcthjo j`

Gdbtc ct Bjvd @hdbg cog ùrtadr ljo`hrfs tact tad Lhty‘s `chburd tj cihgd iy tad `jrldg-

clljffjgcthjo prjvhshjos j` tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots hs c irdcla j` tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst gdohds tad cbbdncthjos ho pcrcnrcpa 33<.

337. Wad Lhty‘s Ljfpdththjo Ubco cs upgctdg‗holbughon, whtajut bhfhtcthjo, tad

prjvhshjos j` \dlthjo 3(@) j` tad Ljfpdththjo Ubco, sdlthjo 7 j` tad 9554 Ljfpdththjo Ubco

upgctd, cog sdlthjos 3 cog 3(i) j` tad 9558 Ljfpdththjo Ubco upgctd‗ljo`hrfs tact tad Bdcsd

Cnrddfdots jibhnctd tad Lhty tj `jrld clljffjgcthjo j` Gdbtc ct Bjvd @hdbg cog ùrtadr

ljo`hrfs tact tad Lhty‘s `chburd tj cihgd iy tad `jrldg-clljffjgcthjo prjvhshjos j` tad Bdcsd

Cnrddfdots hs c irdcla j` tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots. Ht ùrtadr ljo`hrfs tact tad Lhty cltdg

uobcwùbby wado ht cpprjvdg tad suibdcsd gdsphtd tad `clt tact ht wjubg c``hrfcthvdby acrf

ljfpdththjo ct Bjvd @hdbg.






334. Wad ^rhnat Cfdogfdot Yd`jrf Clt‗holbughon, whtajut bhfhtcthjo, tad

prjvhshjos j` sdlthjo 4(c)‗ljo`hrfs tact tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots jibhnctd tad Lhty tj `jrld

clljffjgcthjo j` Gdbtc ct Bjvd @hdbg cog ùrtadr ljo`hrfs tact tad Lhty‘s `chburd tj cihgd iy tad

`jrldg-clljffjgcthjo prjvhshjos j` tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots hs c irdcla j` tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots.


330. Wad GJW‘s Gdldfidr 3>, 9537 bdttdr cog Kuod 34, 9534 bdttdr‗ijta hoghvhgucbby

cog kjhotby‗ljo`hrf tact tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots jibhnctd tad Lhty tj `jrld clljffjgcthjo j`

Gdbtc ct Bjvd @hdbg cog ùrtadr ljo`hrf tact tad Lhty‘s `chburd tj cihgd iy tad `jrldg-

clljffjgcthjo prjvhshjos j` tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots hs c irdcla j` tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots.


33>. Wad Lhty‘s irdclads j` tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots acvd lcusdg, cog h` ojt ljrrdltdg

whbb ljothoud tj lcusd, Gdbtc tj su``dr shnoh`hlcot cog hrrdpcrcibd hokury cs c octurcb, prjicibd,

cog `jrdsddcibd ljosdqudold.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst gdohds tad cbbdncthjos ho pcrcnrcpa 33>.

331.

Wadrd hs oj cgdquctd rdfdgy ct bcw `jr tad Lhty‘s irdcla j` tad Bdcsd

Cnrddfdots, cog gcfcnds wjubg id hocgdquctd ljfpdoscthjo. Gdbtc acs pdr`jrfdg hts

jibhncthjos uogdr tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots. Clljrghonby, Gdbtc hs dothtbdg tj spdlh`hl pdr`jrfcold

iy tad Lhty j` tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots.


338. Gdbtc acs suistcothcbby ljfpbhdg whta cbb cppbhlcibd cog vcbhg ojthld

rdquhrdfdots, holbughon, tj tad dxtdot cppbhlcibd cog vcbhg, tad rdquhrdfdot uogdr \dlthjo 9-10 j`

tad Gcbbcs Lhty Ljgd tj prjvhgd ojthld j` c irdcla j` ljotrclt lbchf `jr gcfcnds whtaho 315 gcys

j` tad irdcla. Wad 315-gcy pdrhjg acg ojt dxphrdg jo Kuod 3>, 9534, wado tad Lhty `hbdg hts





ljfpbchot. Wad Lhty hs dquhtciby dstjppdg `rjf crnuhon jtadrwhsd idlcusd, uothb tad Lhty `hbdg

hts ljfpbchot, ht rdprdsdotdg tj Gdbtc tact ht hotdogdg tj `jrld clljffjgcthjo j` Gdbtc‘s rdqudsts,

cog Gdbtc rdcsjociby rdbhdg jo tact rdprdsdotcthjo. Iy `hbhon tad ljfpbchot, tad Lhty wchvdg coy

rdfchohon rdquhrdfdot `jr Gdbtc tj nhvd ojthld tj tad Lhty id`jrd `hbhon hts irdcla-j`-ljotrclt

lbchfs.






CO\^DY WJ GDBWC‘\ CFDOGDG LJTOWDY- COG LYJ\\LBCHF\CNCHO\W \JTWA^D\W COG LYJ\\LBCHF CNCHO\W TOHWDG CHYBHOD\, HOL.

Coy cbbdncthjo ojt dxprdssby cgfhttdg hs gdohdg.

H.

CO\^DY WJ HOWYJGTLWHJO9

395. @jr jvdr tahrty ydcrs, \jutawdst `bdw `rjf Bjvd @hdbg uogdr tad thnat ljostrchots

j` tad ^rhnat Cfdogfdot. Adcgqucrtdrdg jo tad dgnd j` Bjvd @hdbg, \jutawdst ljoshgdrs Bjvd

@hdbg tj id hts ajfd chrpjrt. Gdsphtd rdpdctdg dotrdcthds `rjf G@^, \jutawdst acs bjon

ljoshgdrdg Bjvd @hdbg tad joby chrpjrt wjrta dotdrhon ho tad Gcbbcs-@jrt ^jrta crdc, cog, ho tad

ydcrs bdcghon up tj tad @hvd Ucrty Cnrddfdot, `bctby rdùsdg tj jpdrctd `rjf G@^.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact jpdrctdg ct Bjvd @hdbg uogdr tad ljostrchots j`

tad ^rhnat Cfdogfdot `jr jvdr <5 ydcrs. \jutawdst cgfhts tact ht acs odvdr jpdrctdg

`rjf G@^. \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 395.

393. Ct sjfd pjhot, ajwdvdr, \jutawdst stjppdg tahomhon j` Bjvd @hdbg cs kust hts

ajfd chrpjrt, cog stcrtdg tahomhon j` tad puibhl chrpjrt cs \jutawdst‘s vdry jwo prjpdrty.

\jutawdst idnco tj ljoldhvd j` tad ^rhnat Cfdogfdot Yd`jrf Clt cs c bcw tact wcs cbb cijut

adbphon \jutawdst tj dxpcog, rctadr taco idhon cijut tad bh`thon j` rdstrhlthjos jo c puibhl

chrpjrt. Hogddg, \jutawdst‘s LDJ Ncry Mdbby cssdrtdg tj Lhty Fcocndr C.L. Njozcbdz tact Bjvd

@hdbg wcs ‒tad chrpjrt wd ]\jutawdstV `hrst scvdg `rjf dbhfhocthjo iy tad lhty cog tado rdiuhbt ct

oj ljst tj tad lhty.‖ Clljrghonby, \jutawdst lcfd tj tad ljolbushjo tact ht acg co dothtbdfdot tj

ljotrjb Bjvd @hdbg.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact Fr. Mdbby fcgd tad qujtdg stctdfdot.


9 Ho tad hotdrdsts j` ljoshstdoly cog ljolhshjo, cog cs cutajrhzdg iy @dgdrcb Yubd j` Lhvhb Urjldgurd 35(i), tahsljfpbchot holjrpjrctds iy rd`drdold tad cbbdncthjos ho Gdbtc‘s ljfpbchot cnchost tad Lhty hostdcg j` rdprhothon tajsdcbbdncthjos ho ùbb. Gdbtc‘s ljfpbchot cnchost tad Lhty ljotchos 338 oufidrdg pcrcnrcpas. Clljrghonby, cog whta tadchf j` cvjhghon ljoùshjo ho \jutawdst‘s coswdr tj tahs ljfpbchot, tahs ljfpbchot idnhos whta pcrcnrcpa 395.





399. \jutawdst‘s `ddbhon j` dothtbdfdot hs rjjtdg ho hts vhdw tact ht acs ljotrhiutdg sj

fula tj tad Lhty j` Gcbbcs tact ht gdsdrvds hts jwo chrpjrt. Fr. Mdbby cssdrtdg tact, iy ahs

lcblubcthjo, \jutawdst acg ndodrctdg jvdr $7 ihbbhjo ho bjlcb dljojfhl clthvhty, ljotrhiutdg $9

ihbbhjo tj tad Gcbbcs crdc NGU, chgdg ho tad lrdcthjo j` jvdr 99,555 kjis, pchg $3 ihbbhjo ho

scbcrhds, wcnds, cog idod`hts tj 1,555 Gcbbcs crdc dfpbjydds, pchg $79 fhbbhjo ho tcxds ho tad

Gcbbcs crdc, cog suppjrtdg 791 bjlcb lhvhl cog lacrhtcibd jrncohzcthjos whta lcsa cog/jr `rdd

trcvdb. Nhvdo tact, \jutawdst scw coy cttdfpt iy tad Lhty j` Gcbbcs tj prdsdrvd ljfpdththjo,

rctadr taco tj prjfjtd \jutawdst, cs c pdrsjocb idtrcycb.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact ht acs ndodrctdg jvdr $7 ihbbhjo ho bjlcb

dljojfhl clthvhty, ljotrhiutdg $9 ihbbhjo tj tad Gcbbcs crdc NGU, chgdg ho tad lrdcthjo j`

jvdr 99,555 kjis, pchg $3 ihbbhjo ho scbcrhds, wcnds, cog idod`hts tj 1,555 Gcbbcs crdc

dfpbjydds, pchg $79 fhbbhjo ho tcxds ho tad Gcbbcs crdc, cog suppjrtdg 791 bjlcb lhvhl cog

lacrhtcibd jrncohzcthjos. \jutawdst cgfhts tact Fr. Mdbby acs ghslussdg tadsd

clljfpbhsafdots. \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 399.

39<.

Ydncrgbdss j` wact \jutawdst `ddbs ht hs dothtbdg tj, ajwdvdr, Bjvd @hdbg hs c

puibhl chrpjrt, ùogdg ho bcrnd pcrt iy tad `dgdrcb cog bjlcb njvdrofdots cog `dds pchg iy tad

trcvdbhon puibhl. Wad Lhty hs ojt cbbjwdg tj acog tad mdys tj tad chrpjrt tj \jutawdst cog pdrfht

ht tj bjlm cbb ljfpdththjo jut. Hostdcg, cs tad @CC rdc``hrfdg kust bcst fjota ho coojuolhon hts

hovdsthncthjo j` tad Lhty‘s ljogult ct Bjvd @hdbg, ‒Ljonrdss `juog tact ‑]fVckjr chrpjrts fust id

cvchbcibd jo c rdcsjocibd icshs tj cbb lcrrhdrs whsahon tj sdrvd tajsd chrpjrts.‘‖ Cs c rdsubt j` tahs

ljonrdsshjocb fcogctd, dlajdg ho hts prjfhsds tj tad @CC ho ljoodlthjo whta rdldhpt j` `dgdrcb

ùogs, tad Lhty cgjptdg c Ljfpdththjo Ubco ho wahla ht prjfhsdg tj clljffjgctd odw lcrrhdrs.

Wad Lhty cog tad shnoctjry chrbhods (\jutawdst, Tohtdg, cog Cfdrhlco),9 ùrtadr cnrddg tj bdcsds





`jr nctds ct Bjvd @hdbg tact ojt joby pdrfhttdg, iut rdquhrdg, tad shnoctjry chrbhods cog tad Lhty tj

clljffjgctd jtadr lcrrhdrs.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact Bjvd @hdbg hs c puibhl chrpjrt wahla rdldhvds

ùoghon `rjf, cfjon jtadr sjurlds, tad `dgdrcb cog bjlcb njvdrofdots, `dds pchg iy tad

trcvdbhon puibhl, cog `dds, rdotcbs, cog jtadr lacrnds pchg iy chrbhods jpdrcthon ct tad

chrpjrt. \jutawdst cgfhts tact @CC fcgd tad qujtdg stctdfdot, iut gd`drs tj tad tdxt j`

tad stctdfdot `jr hts prdlhsd wjrghon. \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j`

pcrcnrcpa 39<.

397.

Wad Lhty cpprjcladg tad clljffjgcthjo prjldss ghbhndotby, cog rdpdctdgby

prjfhsdg Gdbtc tact ht wjubg id clljffjgctdg. Ajwdvdr, \jutawdst ljothoudg c lcfpchno j`

adcvy prdssurd jo tad Lhty tj clquhdsld ho \jutawdst‘s d``jrt tj ljfpbdtdby ljotrjb tad chrpjrt.

Clljrghon tj tad Lhty‘s jwo hotdrocb ljffuohlcthjos, ht uogdrstjjg \jutawdst tj ‒prjfhsd]V

fckjr trjuibd h` ]tadV Lhty nrcotdg ùbb Gdbtc clljffjgcthjo rdqudst.‖ C`tdr tad Lhty tjbg Tohtdg

ht wjubg acvd tj clljffjgctd Gdbtc, \jutawdst prjfptby sdot co conry bdttdr tj tad Lhty jo

\dptdfidr 9<, 9537 cllushon ht j` ‒suffcrhby ghsfhss]honV tad oddgs j` c bjonthfd pcrtodr j`

tad Lhty j` Gcbbcs.‖ Cog jo \dptdfidr 97, Fr. Mdbby sdot c prhvctd dfchb tj Lhty Fcocndr C.L.

Njozcbdz, tardctdohon tj ‒fjv]dV jo tj `jlus jur ljrpjrctd hovdstfdots ho tajsd fcrmdts tact

pbcld c vcbud jo tadf cog tadhr ljrpjrctd rdshgdots.‖

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst gd`drs tj tad tdxt j` tad lhtdg ljffuohlcthjos `jr tadhr

prdlhsd wjrghon. \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 397.

394. Wad Lhty iclmdg gjwo. Jo \dptdfidr 98, 9537, tad Lhty‘s Ghrdltjr j` Cvhcthjo

sdot c lursjry bdttdr tdbbhon Gdbtc tact ‒]iVcsdg jo tad sladgubds rdldotby prjvhgdg cog tad Nctd

Tsd Bhldosd Cnrddfdot idtwddo \jutawdst Chrbhods cog Tohtdg Chrbhods,‖ Gdbtc wjubg ojt id





clljffjgctdg. âhbd tahs wcs ho tad hotdrdst j` \jutawdst‗wahla dotrdoladg hts gjfhocold

jvdr tad chrpjrt‗cog Tohtdg‗wahla prdsdrvdg hts jppjrtuohty tj prj`ht acogsjfdby jo hts twj

nctds `jr `clhbhtcthon \jutawdst‘s fjojpjby d``jrts‗ht wcs ljotrcry tj tad hotdrdsts j` tad Lhty j`

Gcbbcs cog hts lhthzdos, waj acvd tad trud dothtbdfdot tj tad chrpjrt.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst gd`drs tj tad tdxt j` tad lhtdg ljffuohlcthjo `jr hts prdlhsd

wjrghon. \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 394.

390. Wad vdry wddm tact tad Lhty sdot c lursjry ojtd gdoyhon Gdbtc‘s clljffjgcthjo

rdqudst, \jutawdst cog Tohtdg rdcladg co cnrddfdot tact \jutawdst wjubg pcy c mhon‘s rcosjf

tj Tohtdg `jr rhnats tj hts twj nctds‗tad vdry nctds ct wahla Gdbtc acg iddo sddmhon

clljffjgcthjo‗tadrdiy cttdfpthon tj `jrdlbjsd co crnufdot tact tad spcld sajubg id fcgd

cvchbcibd tj Gdbtc cog jtadr chrbhods hotdrdstdg ho sdrvhon Bjvd @hdbg. Wact cnrddfdot wcs

dxdlutdg jo Jltjidr 0, 9537, iut wcs suikdlt tj tad Lhty‘s cpprjvcb.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact ht dotdrdg hotj c suibdcsd whta Tohtdg `jr hts

twj Bjvd @hdbg nctds cog tact tad Lhty wcs rdquhrdg tj ljosdot tj tact suibdcsd. \jutawdst

gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 390.

39>. Wad GJW fcgd ht lbdcr tj tad Lhty tact ht jppjsdg coy cpprjvcb j` tad suibdcsd

uothb Gdbtc wcs clljffjgctdg. Ajwdvdr, c`tdr fjotas j` prdssurd `rjf \jutawdst cog Tohtdg,

tad Lhty iclmdg gjwo cncho. Jo Kcoucry 91, 9534, tad Lhty cpprjvdg tad suibdcsd cnrddfdot,

whtajut rdquhrhon Gdbtc‘s clljffjgcthjo cs c ljoghthjo j` hts cpprjvcb.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact tad Lhty cpprjvdg tad Tohtdg-\jutawdst

suibdcsd jo Kcoucry 91, 9534. \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa

39>.





391. \jutawdst cog Tohtdg irdcladg tadhr ljotrclts whta tad Lhty iy rdùshon tj

clljffjgctd Gdbtc cog iy dotdrhon hotj c suibdcsd cnrddfdot tact ojt joby hfpchrdg Gdbtc‘s

dxdrlhsd j` hts rhnat tj clljffjgcthjo, iut ljo`drrdg jo \jutawdst co dxlbushvd rhnat tj Bjvd

@hdbg. Wact dxlbushvd rhnat hs ojt joby prjahihtdg iy tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots, iut hs ljotrcry tj

`dgdrcb bcw cog tad nrcot cssurcolds tact pbcld ljoghthjos jo tad Lhty‘s rdldhpt j` `dgdrcb ùogs.


398. Wad Ljurt sajubg gdlbcrd tact Gdbtc hs dothtbdg tj clljffjgcthjo `jr tad 3<

`bhnats ht rdqudstdg idlcusd tadrd wcs cvchbcihbhty jo tad gctd j` Gdbtc‘s rdqudsts. \jutawdst cog

Tohtdg fcy ojt rdvjmd Gdbtc's rhnat tj prjvhgd, cog tact j` tad `byhon puibhl tj idod`ht `rjf,

fdcohonùb ljfpdththjo ct Bjvd @hdbg iy clthjos tady jr dhtadr j` tadf tjjm tj uogdrfhod

Gdbtc‘s clljffjgcthjo rhnat. Ho jrgdr `jr clljffjgcthjo tj rdsubt ho rdcb ljfpdththjo, tad

Ljurt sajubg cbsj gdlbcrd tact \jutawdst hs bhfhtdg tj 30 nctds, cog, tadrd`jrd, hs rdquhrdg tj

trcos`dr twj nctds iclm tj tad Lhty `jr hts usd ho hfpbdfdothon hts ljfpdththjo pjbhly, cog tact j`

tad `dgdrcb njvdrofdot, ct Bjvd @hdbg. Ho tad cbtdrocthvd, tad Ljurt sajubg gdlbcrd tact tad

ljfpdththjo-mhbbhon trcos`dr `rjf Tohtdg tj \jutawdst sajubg id rdslhogdg cog Tohtdg sajubg id

rdquhrdg tj ghsnjrnd tad fjody ht rdldhvdg `rjf \jutawdst `jr tact fjojpjby-lrdcthon trcos`dr

cog tj clljffjgctd Gdbtc jo tad nctds ht suibdcsdg tj \jutawdst.


Ucrthds

3<5. Ljuotdr- cog/jr Lrjss-Ubchoth`` Gdbtc Chr Bhods, Hol. hs c Gdbcwcrd ljrpjrcthjo

wajsd prholhpcb pbcld j` iushodss hs bjlctdg ct 35<5 Gdbtc Ijubdvcrg, Ctbcotc, Ndjrnhc <5<47.

Gdbtc hs co chr lcrrhdr doncndg ho tad iushodss j` prjvhghon ljffdrlhcb pcssdondr chr





trcospjrtcthjo tarjunajut tad Tohtdg \tctds cog tad wjrbg. Gdbtc hs c lhthzdo j` tad \tctds j`

Gdbcwcrd cog Ndjrnhc.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tad cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 3<5.

3<3. Ljuotdr- cog/jr Lrjss-Gd`dogcot \jutawdst Chrbhods Lj. hs c Wdxcs ljrpjrcthjo

whta hts prholhpcb pbcld j` iushodss ho Gcbbcs Ljuoty, Wdxcs. \jutawdst hs c lhthzdo j` Wdxcs.


3<9. Lrjss-Gd`dogcot Tohtdg Chrbhods, Hol. hs c Gdbcwcrd ljrpjrcthjo whta hts prholhpcb

pbcld j` iushodss ho Lahlcnj, Hbbhojhs. Tohtdg hs c lhthzdo j` tad \tctds j` Gdbcwcrd cog Hbbhojhs.


tad cbbdncthjos ho pcrcnrcpa 3<9.

Kurhsghlthjo cog Pdoud

3<<. Wahs Ljurt acs kurhsghlthjo jvdr Gdbtc‘s lbchfs cnchost \jutawdst uogdr 91 T.\.L.

§ 3<<9(c)(3) idlcusd tad fcttdr ho ljotrjvdrsy dxlddgs tad suf jr vcbud j` $>4,555, dxlbushvd j`

hotdrdst cog ljsts, cog hs idtwddo lhthzdos j` gh``drdot \tctds.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tad cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 3<<.

3<7. Wj tad dxtdot tahs Ljurt gjds ojt acvd jrhnhocb kurhsghlthjo j` coy ljuotdr- cog/jr

lrjss-lbchf(s) cssdrtdg ho tahs clthjo, tahs Ljurt acs suppbdfdotcb kurhsghlthjo uogdr 91 T.\.L.

§ 3<0> idlcusd tad Ljurt acs jrhnhocb kurhsghlthjo j` tad clthjo cog cbb j` tad lbchfs, ljuotdr-

lbchfs, cog lrjss-lbchfs cssdrtdg adrdho crd sj rdbctdg tj jod cojtadr tact tady `jrf pcrt j` tad

scfd lcsd jr ljotrjvdrsy uogdr Crthlbd HHH j` tad Tohtdg \tctds Ljosthtuthjo.






3<4. Pdoud ho tahs Ljurt hs prjpdr uogdr 91 T.\.L. § 3<83(i)(9) idlcusd c suistcothcb

pcrt j` tad dvdots cog jfhsshjos nhvhon rhsd tj Gdbtc‘s ljuotdr- cog/jr lrjss-lbchfs jllurrdg ho

tahs kughlhcb ghstrhlt.


Iclmnrjuog cog @clts

3<0. Gdbtc rd-cbbdnds cog holjrpjrctds iy rd`drdold cs tajuna ùbby sdt jut adrdho tad

cbbdncthjos ljotchodg ho Ucrcnrcpas 3 tarjuna 14 j` hts Cfdogdg Ljfpbchot cog Ljuotdrlbchfs

Cnchost tad Lhty j` Gcbbcs (DL@ 3<<).


Irdclads j` cog Wjrthjus Hotdr`drdold whta tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots

3<>. Togdr tad Chrpjrt Tsd cog Bdcsd Cnrddfdot idtwddo tad Lhty cog \jutawdst

(‒\jutawdst Bdcsd Cnrddfdot‖), \jutawdst hs suikdlt tj co clljffjgcthjo jibhncthjo tact hs

cotdldgdot tj coy clljffjgcthjo jibhncthjo j` tad Lhty‘s. Wad \jutawdst Bdcsd Cnrddfdot

hfpjsds c ihoghon guty jo \jutawdst tj vjbuotcrhby clljffjgctd rdqudsts `rjf odw dotrcot

lcrrhdrs (h.d., lcrrhdrs waj gj ojt acvd c bdcsd whta tad Lhty) tj prjvhgd sdrvhld ct Bjvd @hdbg.

Wad \jutawdst Bdcsd Cnrddfdot hfpjsds tact guty `jr tad idod`ht j` odw-dotrcot lcrrhdrs sula cs

Gdbtc. H` ht hs pjsshibd `jr \jutawdst tj clljffjgctd c rdqudst `jr odw sdrvhld `rjf c odw

dotrcot lcrrhdr whtajut uoguby hotdr`drhon whta hts jwo jpdrcthon sladgubd, \jutawdst fust gj sj.

H` \jutawdst rdùsds tj prjvhgd vjbuotcry clljffjgcthjo‗cog ht hs ojt cbbjwdg tj rdùsd uobdss

tad odw dotrcot‘s prjpjsdg `bhnat sladgubd wjubg ljo`bhlt whta \jutawdst‘s tado-dxhsthon `bhnat

sladgubd (holbughon coy ùturd `bhnat sladgubd tact hs cbrdcgy-coojuoldg cog cbrdcgy-`jr-scbd)‗

tado tad Lhty hs jibhnctdg tj `jrld clljffjgcthjo j` tad odw dotrcot.





YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact tad Bdcsd ljotchos prjvhshjos `jr tad pjsshibd

clljffjgcthjo j` odw dotrcot lcrrhdrs `jr tdfpjrcry pdrhjgs j` thfd cog uogdr ldrtcho

ljoghthjos, cog gd`drs tj tad tdxt j` tad Bdcsd `jr hts prdlhsd wjrghon. \jutawdst gdohds

tact Gdbtc hs c odw dotrcot lcrrhdr. \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j`

pcrcnrcpa 3<>.

3<1. Wad Chrpjrt Tsd cog Bdcsd Cnrddfdot idtwddo tad Lhty cog Tohtdg (‒Tohtdg

Bdcsd Cnrddfdot‖) ljotchos tdrfs fctdrhcbby hgdothlcb tj tajsd ho tad \jutawdst Bdcsd

Cnrddfdot. Idlcusd tad \jutawdst Bdcsd Cnrddfdot cog tad Tohtdg Bdcsd Cnrddfdot

(ljbbdlthvdby, ‒tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots‖) hfpjsd hgdothlcb guthds, tady lco id gdslrhidg tjndtadr.


tad cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 3<1.

3<8. \pdlh`hlcbby, \dlthjo 7.50(@) j` tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots gdtchbs tad prjldss `jr

clljffjgcthjo, stcthon tact ‒`clhbhthds ct ]Bjvd @hdbgV fcy idljfd c slcrld rdsjurld h` c odw

dotrcot chrbhod (‑Ydqudsthon Chrbhod‘) rdqudsts tj prjvhgd sdrvhld ct tad Chrpjrt. Ho sula

lhrlufstcolds, ]\jutawdst jr TohtdgV cnrdds tj clljffjgctd sula Ydqudsthon Chrbhod ct hts

Bdcsd Urdfhsds ct sula thfds cs whbb ojt uoguby hotdr`drd whta hts jpdrcthon sladgubd cog upjo

sula rdcsjocibd tdrfs cs fcy id cnrddg upjo idtwddo ]\jutawdst jr TohtdgV cog tad Ydqudsthon

Chrbhod, tcmhon hotj ljoshgdrcthjo cbb tad lhrlufstcolds j` sula co clljffjgcthjo cnrddfdot.‖

\jutawdst cog tad Lhty hotdogdg tj sdlurd c idod`ht `jr odw-dotrcot lcrrhdrs sula cs Gdbtc wado

tady dotdrdg hotj \dlthjo 7.50(@) j` tad \jutawdst Bdcsd Cnrddfdot. Tohtdg cog tad Lhty

hotdogdg tj sdlurd c idod`ht `jr odw-dotrcot lcrrhdrs sula cs Gdbtc wado tady dotdrdg hotj \dlthjo

7.50(@) j` tad Tohtdg Bdcsd Cnrddfdot. Cog tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots sdlurd c ghrdlt, ojo-

holhgdotcb idod`ht `jr Gdbtc; tad rhnat tj id clljffjgctdg ct Bjvd @hdbg.





YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact sdlthjo 7.50(@) j` tad Bdcsd ljotchos prjvhshjos

rdncrghon clljffjgcthjo. \jutawdst gd`drs tj tad tdxt j` tad Bdcsd `jr hts prdlhsd

wjrghon. \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 3<8.

375. Odhtadr \jutawdst ojr Tohtdg lco cvjhg hts clljffjgcthjo jibhncthjos cog gd`dct

tad Ydqudsthon Chrbhod‘s rhnat tj clljffjgcthjo iy rdùshon tj ‒cnrdd]V upjo‖ ‒rdcsjocibd

tdrfs‖ `jr tad clljffjgcthjo. Hostdcg, \dlthjo 7.50(@)(7)(l) prjvhgds tact ho tad dvdot

\jutawdst jr Tohtdg cog tad Ydqudsthon Chrbhod lcoojt rdsjbvd c ghsputd jvdr ‒rdcsjocibd `dds

cog lacrnds jr coy jtadr fcttdr rdncrghon tahs slcrld rdsjurld prjvhshjo,‖ tad Lhty whbb hssud c

ihoghon gdlhshjo sdtthon tad tdrfs j` tad clljffjgcthjo.



373. Togdr tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdot, tad gdtdrfhocthjo j` wadtadr \jutawdst jr Tohtdg

lco clljffjgctd tad Ydqudsthon Chrbhod whtajut ‒uoguby hotdr`dr]honV whta hts jpdrcthon

sladgubd‖ hs coswdrdg cs j` tad gctd j` tad Ydqudsthon Chrbhod‘s clljffjgcthjo rdqudst. Ho

jtadr wjrgs, tad ghspjshthvd qudsthjo hs wadtadr tad bdvdb j` nctd uscnd rdquhrdg iy \jutawdst‘s

jr Tohtdg‘s tado-lurrdot `bhnat sladgubd‗holbughon coy ùturd `bhnat sladgubd tact hs cbrdcgy-

coojuoldg cog cbrdcgy-`jr-scbd‗hs sula tact \jutawdst jr Tohtdg lco clljffjgctd tad

Ydqudsthon Chrbhod‘s prjpjsdg `bhnat sladgubd whtajut uoguby hotdr`drhon whta hts jpdrcthjos. H`

sj, tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdot rdquhrds \jutawdst cog Tohtdg tj clljffjgctd tad Ydqudsthon Chrbhod.

Hfpjrtcotby, \jutawdst cog Tohtdg lcoojt cvjhg tadhr clljffjgcthjo jibhncthjo cog trufp tad

Ydqudsthon Chrbhod‘s rhnat tj clljffjgcthjo iy holrdcshon tadhr `bhnat sladgubds c`tdr tady

rdldhvd c rdqudst `jr clljffjgcthjo. Jtadrwhsd, \jutawdst jr Tohtdg ljubg gd`dct tad wajbd

pjhot j` tad Bdcsd‘s `jrldg-clljffjgcthjo prjvhshjos.






379. Icsdg jo pcst jpdrcthjos ct Bjvd @hdbg, ht hs pjsshibd tj jpdrctd ct bdcst 33

gdpcrturds pdr gcy jut j` c Bjvd @hdbg nctd.


37<. Gdbtc `hrst rdqudstdg clljffjgcthjo `rjf \jutawdst cog Tohtdg `jr hts tado-

lurrdot sladgubd j` shx `bhnats jo Kuod 3<, 9537. Cs j` Kuod 3<, 9537, \jutawdst wcs jpdrcthon

up tj 375 gchby gdpcrturds jut j` hts 30 Bjvd @hdbg nctds. \jutawdst acg ojt ydt suibdcsdg

Tohtdg‘s twj nctds. \jutawdst acg oj cgghthjocb ùturd `bhnats tact wdrd cbrdcgy-coojuoldg cog

cbrdcgy-`jr-scbd. Tohtdg wcs jpdrcthon joby shx jr sdvdo gchby `bhnats jut j` hts twj bdcsdg nctds.

\jutawdst acs ljoshstdotby tcmdo tad pjshthjo tact ht hs pjsshibd tj jpdrctd ct bdcst 35 gdpcrturds

pdr gcy jut j` dcla Bjvd @hdbg nctd, wahla hs ljoshstdot whta hts jpdrcthjos ct hts auis crjuog tad

ljuotry. Clljrghonby, jo Kuod 3<, 9537, dhtadr \jutawdst jr Tohtdg ljubg acvd clljffjgctdg

Gdbtc‘s lurrdot sladgubd whtajut uoguby hotdr`drhon whta hts jwo jpdrcthon sladgubd. Ho cgghthjo,

\jutawdst ljubg acvd fcgd pbcos ct tact pjhot tj clljffjgctd Gdbtc jo tad nctds \jutawdst

bctdr suibdcsdg `rjf Tohtdg.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact Gdbtc rdqudstdg Bjvd @hdbg nctd clldss ho Kuod

9537. \jutawdst gdohds tad cbbdncthjos ho tad sdljog sdotdold j` pcrcnrcpa 37<, cog

rdfcrms tact cs j` Kuod 3<, 9537, ht acg puibhsadg c sladgubd whta 378 pdcm gcy `bhnats jo

30 nctds cog wcs ho tad prjldss j` `hocbhzhon c sladgubdg (puibhsadg jo Cunust 7, 9537) whta

34< pdcm gcy `bhnats jo 30 nctds. \jutawdst cgfhts tact, cs j` Kuod 3<, 9537, \jutawdst

acg ojt ydt puibhsadg hts 315-`bhnat sladgubd `jr scbd tj tad puibhl. \jutawdst cgfhts tact

\jutawdst jpdrcthon 35 `bhnats pdr nctd pdr gcy jo hts Bjvd @hdbg nctds hs ùbb uthbhzcthjo j`

tajsd nctds. \jutawdst cgfhts tact ht acg ojt suibdcsdg Tohtdg‘s nctds cs j` Kuod 3<, 9537.





\jutawdst bclms mojwbdgnd jr ho`jrfcthjo su``hlhdot tj `jrf c idbhd` cs tj ajw fcoy `bhnats

Tohtdg wcs jpdrcthon ct hts nctds, jr wadtadr ht ljubg acvd prjvhgdg Gdbtc nctd clldss.

\jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos ho pcrcnrcpa 37<.

377. Gdbtc rdhtdrctdg hts rdqudst tj id clljffjgctdg `jr hts lurrdot sladgubd j` `hvd

`bhnats ho c bdttdr tj tad Lhty jo \dptdfidr 31, 9537. Cs j` \dptdfidr 31, 9537, \jutawdst wcs

jpdrcthon up tj 331 gchby gdpcrturds jut j` hts 30 Bjvd @hdbg nctds, cog \jutawdst acg oj

cgghthjocb ùturd `bhnats tact wdrd cbrdcgy-coojuoldg cog cbrdcgy-`jr-scbd. \jutawdst acs

ljoshstdotby tcmdo tad pjshthjo tact ht hs pjsshibd tj jpdrctd ct bdcst 35 gdpcrturds pdr gcy jut j`

dcla Bjvd @hdbg nctd, wahla hs ljoshstdot whta hts jpdrcthjos ct hts auis crjuog tad ljuotry.

Clljrghonby, jo \dptdfidr 31, 9537, \jutawdst ljubg acvd clljffjgctdg Gdbtc‘s lurrdot

sladgubd j` `hvd `bhnats whtajut uoguby hotdr`drhon whta hts jwo jpdrcthon sladgubd.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact tact \jutawdst jpdrcthon 35 `bhnats pdr nctd

pdr gcy jo hts Bjvd @hdbg nctds hs ùbb uthbhzcthjo j` tajsd nctds. \jutawdst gdohds tad

rdfchohon cbbdncthjos ho pcrcnrcpa 377.

374.

Wad Lhty hoghlctdg tact ht wjubg ljoshgdr Ojvdfidr 4, 9537, tj id tad \ocpsajt

Gctd `jr purpjsds j` dvcbucthon Gdbtc‘s rdqudst `jr clljffjgcthjo j` hts lurrdot sladgubd j` `hvd

`bhnats. Cs j` Ojvdfidr 4, 9537, \jutawdst wcs jpdrcthon up tj 378 gchby gdpcrturds jut j` hts

30 Bjvd @hdbg nctds, cog \jutawdst acg oj cgghthjocb ùturd `bhnats tact wdrd cbrdcgy-coojuoldg

cog cbrdcgy-`jr-scbd. \jutawdst acs ljoshstdotby tcmdo tad pjshthjo tact ht hs pjsshibd tj jpdrctd

ct bdcst 35 gdpcrturds pdr gcy jut j` dcla Bjvd @hdbg nctd, wahla hs ljoshstdot whta hts jpdrcthjos

ct hts auis crjuog tad ljuotry. Clljrghonby, jo Ojvdfidr 4, 9537, \jutawdst ljubg acvd

clljffjgctdg Gdbtc‘s lurrdot sladgubd j` `hvd `bhnats whtajut uoguby hotdr`drhon whta hts jwo

jpdrcthon sladgubd. Hogddg, c nctd-usd cocbyshs ljffhsshjodg iy tad Lhty cog pdr`jrfdg iy





Bdhna @hsadr ljo`hrfdg tact \jutawdst ljubg acvd clljffjgctdg Gdbtc‘s lurrdot sladgubd j`

`hvd `bhnats whtajut uoguby hotdr`drhon whta hts jwo jpdrcthon sladgubd.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact ht wcs jpdrcthon 378 pdcm gcy `bhnats jo hts

Bjvd @hdbg nctds cs j` Ojvdfidr 4, 9537, iut rdfcrms tact ht acg puibhsadg c sladgubd whta

34< pdcm gcy `bhnats jo 30 nctds. \jutawdst cgfhts tact, cs j` Ojvdfidr 4, 9537, ht acg ojt

ydt puibhsadg hts 315-`bhnat sladgubd `jr scbd tj tad puibhl. \jutawdst cgfhts tact

\jutawdst jpdrcthon 35 `bhnats pdr nctd pdr gcy jo hts Bjvd @hdbg nctds hs ùbb uthbhzcthjo j`

tajsd nctds. \jutawdst gdohds tact tad ljoldpt j` c ‒socpsajt gctd‖ `jr gdtdrfhohon

clljffjgcthjo rdqudsts acs coy suppjrt ho bcw jr pjbhly. \jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon


370. Ho \dptdfidr jr Jltjidr j` 9537, \jutawdst rdcladg co cnrddfdot whta Tohtdg tj

suibdcsd Tohtdg‘s twj bdcsdg nctds ct Bjvd @hdbg. Wad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots rdquhrd tad Lhty tj

ljosdot tj coy suibdcsd ct Bjvd @hdbg. Gdbtc strdoujusby jikdltdg tj tahs suibdcsd‗cog tj tad

Lhty‘s ljosdothon tj tad suibdcsd‗cs holjoshstdot whta Gdbtc‘s rhnat tj bjon-tdrf

clljffjgcthjo ct Bjvd @hdbg. Fjrdjvdr, tad GJW cgvhsdg tad Lhty tact ht wcs jppjsdg tj tad

Lhty ljosdothon tj tad suibdcsd id`jrd Gdbtc wcs pdrfcodotby clljffjgctdg. \jutawdst,

ajwdvdr, idbhdvdg ht wcs dothtbdg tj gjfhoctd Bjvd @hdbg. C`tdr dxtdoshvd prdssurd cog

gjworhnat iubbyhon `rjf \jutawdst, holbughon tardcts tj rdbjlctd ljrpjrctd rdsjurlds, tad Lhty

ubthfctdby prjvhgdg hts wrhttdo ljosdot tj tad Tohtdg-\jutawdst suibdcsd jo Kcoucry 91, 9534,

tadrdiy cbbjwhon tad suibdcsd tj nj hotj d``dlt cog nrcothon \jutawdst bdcsd jr suibdcsd rhnats ct

cbb iut twj j` Bjvd @hdbg‘s 95 nctds.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact ht dotdrdg hotj c suibdcsd whta Tohtdg ho

Jltjidr j` 9537, cgfhts tact tad Lhty‘s ljosdot hs rdquhrdg `jr coy suibdcsd j` nctds ct





Bjvd @hdbg tj idljfd d``dlthvd, cog cgfhts tact tad Lhty ljosdotdg tj hts suibdcsd whta

Tohtdg jo jr cijut Kcoucry 91, 9534. \jutawdst bclms mojwbdgnd jr ho`jrfcthjo su``hlhdot

tj cgfht jr gdoy tad cbbdncthjos ho tad tahrg sdotdold j` pcrcnrcpa 370. \jutawdst gdohds

tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 370.

37>. Gdbtc rdhtdrctdg hts rdqudst `jr clljffjgcthjo `rjf \jutawdst j` hts lurrdot

sladgubd j` `hvd `bhnats ho wrhthon jo @dirucry 9<, 9534. Cbsj jo @dirucry 9<, 9534, Gdbtc

rdqudstdg clljffjgcthjo `rjf \jutawdst `jr dhnat cgghthjocb `bhnats. Cs j` @dirucry 9<, 9534,

\jutawdst acg co coojuoldg ùturd sladgubd idnhoohon ho Cprhb 9534 j` up tj 300 gchby

gdpcrturds jut j` hts 31 Bjvd @hdbg nctds. \jutawdst acs ljoshstdotby tcmdo tad pjshthjo tact ht hs

pjsshibd tj jpdrctd ct bdcst 35 gdpcrturds pdr gcy jut j` dcla Bjvd @hdbg nctd, wahla hs ljoshstdot

whta hts jpdrcthjos ct hts auis crjuog tad ljuotry. Clljrghonby, jo @dirucry 9<, 9534,

\jutawdst ljubg acvd clljffjgctdg ijta Gdbtc‘s lurrdot sladgubd j` `hvd `bhnats cog cbsj

Gdbtc‘s rdqudst `jr dhnat cgghthjocb `bhnats whtajut uoguby hotdr`drhon whta hts jwo jpdrcthon

sladgubd.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact Gdbtc sjunat Bjvd @hdbg nctd clldss jo

@dirucry 9<, 9534, holbughon rdqudsthon spcld `jr co cgghthjocb dhnat (1) `bhnats `jr wahla ht

acg ojt prdvhjusby sjunat clldss. \jutawdst cgfhts tact \jutawdst jpdrcthon 35 `bhnats

pdr nctd pdr gcy jo hts Bjvd @hdbg nctds hs ùbb uthbhzcthjo j` tajsd nctds. \jutawdst cgfhts

tact jo @dirucry 9<, 9534, ht acg coojuoldg co dxpcogdg sladgubd j` 300 `bhnats idnhoohon

ho Cprhb, cog tact ht acg ojt ydt puibhsadg hts 315-`bhnat sladgubd `jr scbd tj tad puibhl.

\jutawdst gdohds tad rdfchohon cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 37>.

371. Gdbtc acs fcgd fubthpbd j``drs tj \jutawdst ljotchohon rdcsjocibd tdrfs `jr hts

rdqudstdg clljffjgcthjo jo c bjon-tdrf icshs‗cbb j` tadf ljoshstdot whta tad nuhgdbhods





crthlubctdg ho tad GJW‘s bdttdrs cog tad Lhty‘s Ljfpdththjo Ubco. Ct dcla kuolturd, \jutawdst

rdkdltdg tadsd tdrfs cog hostdcg ljoghthjodg hts whbbhonodss tj clljffjgctd Gdbtc ct Bjvd @hdbg

jo c bjon-tdrf icshs jo Gdbtc‘s cnrddhon tj nhvd \jutawdst nctd spcld ct jtadr chrpjrts jr pcy co

dxjrihtcot `dd. Wadsd tdrfs ghsrdncrgdg tad GJW‘s bdttdrs cog wdrd wajbby uordcsjocibd. Wj

gctd, \jutawdst acs `chbdg tj j``dr bjon-tdrf clljffjgcthjo tj Gdbtc jr j``dr tj clljffjgctd

Gdbtc‘s rdqudsts ho c fcoodr ljoshstdot whta \jutawdst‘s jibhncthjos uogdr tad Bdcsd

Cnrddfdot.


378.

Ht hs ojt kust ahstjrhlcb `bhnat-sladgubd gctc tact dstcibhsads \jutawdst‘s cihbhty tj

clljffjgctd Gdbtc. \jutawdst acs cbsj cgfhttdg tact ht lco clljffjgctd Gdbtc‘s lurrdot

sladgubd j` `hvd `bhnats whtajut uoguby hotdr`drhon whta hts jpdrcthon sladgubd. Cs ojtdg cijvd,

id`jrd tad Lhty `hbdg tahs bcwsuht, \jutawdst j``drdg tj clljffjgctd Gdbtc ct Bjvd @hdbg jo c

bjon-tdrf icshs, cbidht jo c sdt j` wajbby uordcsjocibd tdrfs. \jutawdst ljubg ojt cog wjubg

ojt acvd fcgd tahs j``dr uobdss ht wdrd pjsshibd `jr \jutawdst tj clljffjgctd Gdbtc‘s lurrdot

sladgubd j` `hvd `bhnats whtajut uoguby hotdr`drhon whta hts jwo jpdrcthon sladgubd.


345. \jutawdst‘s rdldot ljogult cbsj ljo`hrfs tact ht lco clljffjgctd Gdbtc‘s lurrdot

sladgubd j` `hvd `bhnats whtajut uoguby hotdr`drhon whta hts jwo jpdrcthon sladgubd. \jutawdst

acs lbchfdg ht hs ojt pjsshibd tj jpdrctd fjrd taco 35 `bhnats pdr gcy jut j` dcla Bjvd @hdbg nctd.

Jo Cunust 8, 9534, \jutawdst idnco jpdrcthon 35 `bhnats pdr gcy jut j` tad 31 nctds tact ht

bdcsds jr suibdcsds ct Bjvd @hdbg. Xdt \jutawdst rdldotby cnrddg tj cbbjw Gdbtc tj usd

\jutawdst‘s nctds tj jpdrctd `hvd `bhnats c gcy uothb tad dcrbhdr j` \dptdfidr <5, 9534 jr tad gctd

tad Ljurt hssuds co jrgdr nrcothon hokuolthvd rdbhd .̀ H` ht truby wdrd hfpjsshibd tj jpdrctd fjrd





taco 35 `bhnats pdr gcy jut j` c Bjvd @hdbg nctd whtajut uoguby hotdr`drhon whta \jutawdst‘s

jpdrcthon sladgubd, \jutawdst ljubg ojt cog wjubg ojt acvd fcgd tahs cnrddfdot whta Gdbtc.


Ljuotdrlbchfs cog/jr Lrjsslbchfs

Lbchf H; Gdlbcrctjry Kugnfdot tact tad \uibdcsd Phjbctdg tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots(Cnchost \jutawdst cog Tohtdg).


cog ho pcrcnrcpas 3-14 j` Gdbtc‘s ljuotdrlbchf cnchost tad Lhty cs tajuna ùbby sdt `jrta ho tahs

Lrjsslbchf H.


349. Wadrd dxhsts c kusthlhcibd lcsd jr ljotrjvdrsy idtwddo Gdbtc cog \jutawdst cs tj

wadtadr \jutawdst vhjbctdg tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots wado ht dotdrdg hotj c suibdcsd tact ncvd ht co

dxlbushvd rhnat tj Bjvd @hdbg cog gd`dctdg Gdbtc‘s clljffjgcthjo rhnats.


34<.

Wadrd dxhsts c kusthlhcibd lcsd jr ljotrjvdrsy idtwddo Gdbtc cog Tohtdg cs tj

wadtadr Tohtdg vhjbctdg tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots wado ht suibdcsdg nctds tj \jutawdst gdsphtd tad

`clt tact gjhon sj wjubg gd`dct Gdbtc‘s clljffjgcthjo rhnats cog nhvd \jutawdst co dxlbushvd

rhnat tj Bjvd @hdbg.





344. Ijta \jutawdst cog Tohtdg wdrd jibhnctdg uogdr \dlthjo 37.5< j` tadhr Bdcsd

Cnrddfdots tj ljfpby whta cbb cppbhlcibd bcws, spdlh`hlcbby holbughon tad `dgdrcb nrcot





cssurcolds. Dotry j` tad suibdcsd whta Tohtdg wcs, cog lcusdg, c vhjbcthjo j` `dgdrcb bcw cog tad

`dgdrcb nrcot cssurcolds, prhfcrhby Nrcot Cssurcold 9< cog 78 T.\.L. § 7535<(d). Fjrdjvdr, tad

rdùscb tj clljffjgctd Gdbtc wcs c vhjbcthjo j` Nrcot Cssurcolds 99 cog 9< cog 78 T.\.L.

§ 7535<(d), cs wdbb cs c vhjbcthjo j` \dlthjo 7.50(@) j` tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdots.


340. Wad joby wcy tj rdfdgy tad dxlbushvd rhnats vhjbcthjo lcusdg iy tad suibdcsd hs tj

gdlbcrd tact \jutawdst fust ghvdst twj nctds, bhfhthon hts ljotrjb jvdr Bjvd @hdbg tj 15% j` tad

cvchbcibd nctds cs ljotdfpbctdg ho tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdot cog @hvd Ucrty Cnrddfdot. Cs tad GJK

acs rdljnohzdg, pdrfhtthon \jutawdst tj acvd 31 j` tad 95 nctds wjubg gdstrjy ‒fdcohonùb

ljfpdththjo‖ ct Bjvd @hdbg.


34>. Idlcusd \jutawdst cog Tohtdg cbbjlctdg tad rhsm j` `jrldg clljffjgcthjo tj

\jutawdst tarjuna tad suibdcsd prjvhshjo rdquhrhon tact coy clljffjgcthjo id gjod jo nctds

jtadr taco tajsd suibdcsdg `rjf Tohtdg, c prjpdr rdfdgy hs `jr \jutawdst tj ghvdst twj j` hts

jtadr nctds. Uursucot tj \dlthjo 7.50(D), tad twj nctds sajubg idljfd ‒Ljffjo Tsd Nctds‖

uogdr tad ljotrjb j` tad Lhty.


341. Ho tad cbtdrocthvd, tad suibdcsd wcs wrjonùb cog sajubg id rdslhogdg. Gdbtc whbb

tado id dothtbdg tj clljffjgcthjo ct tad nctds ljotrjbbdg iy Tohtdg idlcusd Tohtdg ljubg acvd

clljffjgctdg Gdbtc whtajut uogud hotdr`drdold tj hts jpdrcthon sladgubd wado Gdbtc rdqudstdg

clljffjgcthjo.






348. Clljrghonby, Gdbtc sddms c gdlbcrcthjo uogdr 91 T.\.L. § 9953 tact \jutawdst

fcy ojt acvd bdcsd jr suibdcsd rhnats tj fjrd taco 30 nctds, cog tact tad Lhty fust rdlbchf twj

Bjvd @hdbg nctds tj id uthbhzdg cs ljffjo usd nctds. Cbtdrocthvdby, Gdbtc sddms c gdlbcrcthjo

uogdr 91 T.\.L. § 9953 tact tad Tohtdg-\jutawdst suibdcsd hs vjhg, tact Tohtdg rdtchos ljotrjb j`

tajsd twj nctds, cog tact Tohtdg acs co jibhncthjo tj clljffjgctd Gdbtc ct Bjvd @hdbg uogdr tad

tdrfs sdt `jrta ho tad Tohtdg Bdcsd Cnrddfdot cog tad GJW‘s bdttdrs.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact tad Gdbtc sddms tad rdbhd` rdqudstdg, iut gdohds


Lbchf HH; Gdlbcrctjry Kugnfdot tact Gdbtc Hs Dothtbdg Wj Id Clljffjgctdg (Cnchost\jutawdst)



Ljuotdrlbchf HH.


303. Wadrd dxhsts c kusthlhcibd lcsd jr ljotrjvdrsy idtwddo Gdbtc cog \jutawdst cs tj

wadtadr \jutawdst hs rdquhrdg tj clljffjgctd Gdbtc ct Bjvd @hdbg.





30<.

Wad Bdcsd Cnrddfdot rdquhrds \jutawdst tj clljffjgctd Gdbtc ct Bjvd @hdbg.





GD@DOGCOW \JTWA^D\W CHYBHOD\ LJ.‘\ CO\^DY WJ GDBWC‘\ CFDOGDG LJTOWDYLBCHF\COG LYJ\\ LBCHF\ CNCHO\W \JTWA^D\W CHYBHOD\, LJ. UCND >5

307. \jutawdst‘s `chburd tj clljffjgctd Gdbtc ct Bjvd @hdbg acs lcusdg, cog h` ojt

ljrrdltdg whbb ljothoud tj lcusd, Gdbtc tj su``dr hokury.


304. Gdbtc sddms c gdlbcrcthjo uogdr 99 T.\.L. § 9953 tact \jutawdst acs co jibhncthjo

tj clljffjgctd Gdbtc ct Bjvd @hdbg uogdr tad tdrfs sdt `jrta ho tad \jutawdst Bdcsd Cnrddfdot

cog tad GJW‘s bdttdrs.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tact Gdbtc sddms tad rdbhd` rdqudstdg, iut gdohds tact

Gdbtc hs dothtbdg tj coy rdbhd`.

Lbchf HHH; Irdcla j` tad \jutawdst Bdcsd Cnrddfdot (Cnchost \jutawdst)



Ljuotdrlbchf HHH.


30>. Wad \jutawdst Bdcsd Cnrddfdot idtwddo tad Lhty cog \jutawdst hs c vcbhg,

do`jrldcibd ljotrclt.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tad cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 30>.

301. Cs c odw dotrcot tj Bjvd @hdbg (cog/jr c lcrrhdr sddmhon tj prjvhgd sdrvhld ct

Bjvd @hdbg cog/jr c shnoctjry tj c nctd usd bhldosd cnrddfdot), Gdbtc hs co hotdogdg,

ljotdfpbctdg, cog/jr tahrg-pcrty idod`hlhcry j` tad \jutawdst Bdcsd Cnrddfdot. Cs sula, Gdbtc

hs c prjpdr pcrty tj sud `jr irdcla j` tad \jutawdst Bdcsd Cnrddfdot.


308. Iy sddmhon tj prjvhgd sdrvhld ct Bjvd @hdbg (cog/jr dotdr Bjvd @hdbg cs c odw

dotrcot lcrrhdr) cog rdqudsthon vjbuotcry clljffjgcthjo `rjf \jutawdst, Gdbtc pdr`jrfdg hts

Lcsd <;34-lv-59508-M Gjlufdot 318 @hbdg 58/99/34 Ucnd >5 j` >1 UcndHG 4330




jibhncthjos uogdr tad \jutawdst Bdcsd Cnrddfdot cog scths`hdg dvdry ljoghthjo prdldgdot uogdr

tad ljotrclt tj trhnndr \jutawdst‘s jibhncthjo tj clljffjgctd Gdbtc.


3>5. Ho cgghthjo, jr ho tad cbtdrocthvd, tad \jutawdst Bdcsd Cnrddfdot hs ho wrhthon,

stctds tad dssdothcb tdrfs j` tad cnrddfdot idtwddo Gdbtc cog \jutawdst, prjfhsds tact

\jutawdst whbb prjvhgd Gdbtc whta c idod`ht h` Gdbtc pdr`jrfs, cog wcs dxdlutdg jo idacb` j`

\jutawdst. Clljrghonby, tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdot hs c vcbhg cog do`jrldcibd uohbctdrcb ljotrclt

idtwddo Gdbtc cog \jutawdst.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst gdohds tad cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 3>5.

3>3.

Gdbtc `jrfdg c ljotrclt whta \jutawdst iy pdr`jrfhon uogdr tad \jutawdst Bdcsd

Cnrddfdot. Gdbtc pdr`jrfdg uogdr tad \jutawdst Bdcsd Cnrddfdot iy sddmhon tj prjvhgd

sdrvhld ct Bjvd @hdbg (cog/jr dotdr Bjvd @hdbg cs c odw dotrcot lcrrhdr) cog rdqudsthon vjbuotcry

clljffjgcthjo r̀jf \jutawdst. Cs c pcrty tj tad uohbctdrcb \jutawdst Bdcsd Cnrddfdot

ljotrclt, Gdbtc hs c prjpdr pcrty tj sud `jr irdcla j` tad uohbctdrcb \jutawdst Bdcsd Cnrddfdot

ljotrclt.


3>9. \jutawdst irdcladg tad \jutawdst Bdcsd Cnrddfdot‗holbughon, whtajut

bhfhtcthjo, tad prjvhshjos j` sdlthjo 7.50‗iy `chbhon tj prjvhgd bjon-tdrf clljffjgcthjo tj

Gdbtc ct Bjvd @hdbg jo rdcsjocibd tdrfs dvdo tajuna \jutawdst ljubg gj sj whtajut uogud

hotdr`drdold tj hts jwo jpdrcthon sladgubd.


3><. \jutawdst ùrtadr irdcladg tad \jutawdst Bdcsd Cnrddfdots‗holbughon, whtajut

bhfhtcthjo, tad prjvhshjos j` sdlthjo 37.5<‗iy dotdrhon hotj c suibdcsd whta Tohtdg tact vhjbctdg,

Lcsd <;34-lv-59508-M Gjlufdot 318 @hbdg 58/99/34 Ucnd >3 j` >1 UcndHG 433>




cog/jr lcusdg c vhjbcthjo j`, `dgdrcb bcw (78 T.\.L. § 7535<(d)) cog tad `dgdrcb nrcot cssurcolds,

pcrthlubcrby nrcot cssurcold 9<.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst gdohds tad cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 3><.

3>7. \jutawdst‘s irdclads j` tad \jutawdst Bdcsd Cnrddfdot acvd lcusdg, cog h` ojt

ljrrdltdg whbb ljothoud tj lcusd, Gdbtc tj su``dr shnoh`hlcot cog hrrdpcrcibd hokury cs c octurcb,

prjicibd, cog `jrdsddcibd ljosdqudold.


3>4. Wadrd hs oj cgdquctd rdfdgy ct bcw `jr \jutawdst‘s irdclads j` tad \jutawdst

Bdcsd Cnrddfdot, cog gcfcnds wjubg id hocgdquctd ljfpdoscthjo. Gdbtc acs pdr`jrfdg hts

jibhncthjos uogdr tad \jutawdst Bdcsd Cnrddfdot. Clljrghonby, Gdbtc hs dothtbdg tj spdlh`hl

pdr`jrfcold iy \jutawdst j` tad \jutawdst Bdcsd Cnrddfdot.


Lbchf HP; Irdcla j` tad Tohtdg Bdcsd Cnrddfdot (Cnchost Tohtdg)

3>0. Gdbtc holjrpjrctds iy rd`drdold tad cbbdncthjos j` cbb j` tad prdldghon pcrcnrcpas


Ljuotdrlbchf HP.


3>>. Wad Tohtdg Bdcsd Cnrddfdot idtwddo tad Lhty cog Tohtdg hs c vcbhg, do`jrldcibd

ljotrclt.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tad cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 3>>.

3>1. Cs c odw dotrcot tj Bjvd @hdbg (cog/jr c lcrrhdr sddmhon tj prjvhgd sdrvhld ct





GD@DOGCOW \JTWA^D\W CHYBHOD\ LJ.‘\ CO\^DY WJ GDBWC‘\ CFDOGDG LJTOWDYLBCHF\COG LYJ\\ LBCHF\ CNCHO\W \JTWA^D\W CHYBHOD\, LJ. UCND ><

ljotdfpbctdg, cog/jr tahrg-pcrty idod`hlhcry j` tad Tohtdg Bdcsd Cnrddfdot. Cs sula, Gdbtc hs c

prjpdr pcrty tj sud `jr irdcla j` tad Tohtdg Bdcsd Cnrddfdot.


3>8. Iy sddmhon tj prjvhgd sdrvhld ct Bjvd @hdbg (cog/jr dotdr Bjvd @hdbg cs c odw

dotrcot lcrrhdr) cog rdqudsthon vjbuotcry clljffjgcthjo `rjf Tohtdg, Gdbtc pdr`jrfdg hts

jibhncthjos uogdr tad Tohtdg Bdcsd Cnrddfdot cog scths`hdg dvdry ljoghthjo prdldgdot uogdr tad

ljotrclt tj trhnndr Tohtdg‘s jibhncthjo tj clljffjgctd Gdbtc.


315.

Ho cgghthjo, jr ho tad cbtdrocthvd, tad Tohtdg Bdcsd Cnrddfdot hs ho wrhthon, stctds

tad dssdothcb tdrfs j` tad cnrddfdot idtwddo Gdbtc cog Tohtdg, prjfhsds tact Tohtdg whbb prjvhgd

Gdbtc whta c idod`ht h` Gdbtc pdr`jrfs, cog wcs dxdlutdg jo idacb` j` Tohtdg. Clljrghonby, tad

Tohtdg Bdcsd Cnrddfdot hs c vcbhg cog do`jrldcibd uohbctdrcb ljotrclt idtwddo Gdbtc cog Tohtdg.


313. Gdbtc `jrfdg c ljotrclt whta Tohtdg iy pdr`jrfhon uogdr tad Tohtdg Bdcsd

Cnrddfdot. Gdbtc pdr`jrfdg uogdr tad Tohtdg Bdcsd Cnrddfdot iy sddmhon tj prjvhgd sdrvhld ct

Bjvd @hdbg (cog/jr dotdr Bjvd @hdbg cs c odw dotrcot lcrrhdr) cog rdqudsthon vjbuotcry

clljffjgcthjo `rjf Tohtdg. Cs c pcrty tj tad uohbctdrcb Tohtdg Bdcsd Cnrddfdot ljotrclt,

Gdbtc hs c prjpdr pcrty tj sud `jr irdcla j` tad uohbctdrcb Tohtdg Bdcsd Cnrddfdot ljotrclt.


319. Tohtdg irdcladg tad Tohtdg Bdcsd Cnrddfdot‗holbughon, whtajut bhfhtcthjo, tad

prjvhshjos j` sdlthjo 7.50‗iy `chbhon tj prjvhgd bjon-tdrf clljffjgcthjo tj Gdbtc ct Bjvd

@hdbg jo rdcsjocibd tdrfs dvdo tajuna Tohtdg ljubg gj sj whtajut uogud hotdr`drdold tj hts jwo

jpdrcthon sladgubd.

Lcsd <;34-lv-59508-M Gjlufdot 318 @hbdg 58/99/34 Ucnd >< j` >1 UcndHG 4338





31<. Tohtdg cbsj irdcladg tad Tohtdg Bdcsd Cnrddfdot iy suibdcshon hts twj nctds tj

\jutawdst. Iy prjvhghon \jutawdst hts 3>ta cog 31ta nctds, tact suibdcsd ljo`drrdg jo

\jutawdst co dxlbushvd rhnat ho vhjbcthjo j` tad Tohtdg Bdcsd Cnrddfdot cs wdbb cs nrcot

cssurcold 9<, wahla hfpbdfdots 78 T.\.L. § 7535<(d). Wad Tohtdg-\jutawdst suibdcsd hs

tadrd`jrd vjhg, cog Tohtdg rdtchos ljotrjb j` hts twj nctds, cbjon whta tad cihbhty tj clljffjgctd

Gdbtc.


317.

Tohtdg‘s irdclads j` tad Tohtdg Bdcsd Cnrddfdot acvd lcusdg, cog h` ojt

ljrrdltdg whbb ljothoud tj lcusd, Gdbtc tj su``dr shnoh`hlcot cog hrrdpcrcibd hokury cs c octurcb,

prjicibd, cog `jrdsddcibd ljosdqudold.


314. Wadrd hs oj cgdquctd rdfdgy ct bcw `jr Tohtdg‘s irdclads j` tad Tohtdg Bdcsd

Cnrddfdot, cog gcfcnds wjubg id hocgdquctd ljfpdoscthjo. Gdbtc acs pdr`jrfdg hts

jibhncthjos uogdr tad Tohtdg Bdcsd Cnrddfdot. Clljrghonby, Gdbtc hs dothtbdg tj spdlh`hl

pdr`jrfcold iy Tohtdg j` tad Tohtdg Bdcsd Cnrddfdot.


Lbchf P; Wjrthjus Hotdr`drdold whta tad Tohtdg Bdcsd Cnrddfdot (Cnchost \jutawdst)



Ljuotdrlbchf HP.






31>. Wad Tohtdg Bdcsd Cnrddfdot idtwddo tad Lhty cog Tohtdg hs c vcbhg, do`jrldcibd

ljotrclt.

YD\UJO\D; \jutawdst cgfhts tad cbbdncthjos j` pcrcnrcpa 31>.

311. Cs c odw dotrcot tj Bjvd @hdbg (cog/jr c lcrrhdr sddmhon tj prjvhgd sdrvhld ct


ljotdfpbctdg, cog/jr tahrg-pcrty idod`hlhcry j` tad Tohtdg Bdcsd Cnrddfdot. Cs sula, Gdbtc hs c

prjpdr pcrty tj sud `jr tjrthjus hotdr`drdold whta tad Tohtdg Bdcsd Cnrddfdot.


318.

Ho cgghthjo, jr ho tad cbtdrocthvd, tad \jutawdst Bdcsd Cnrddfdot hs ho wrhthon,

stctds tad dssdothcb tdrfs j` tad cnrddfdot idtwddo Gdbtc cog \jutawdst, prjfhsds tact

\jutawdst whbb prjvhgd Gdbtc whta c idod`ht h` Gdbtc pdr`jrfs, cog wcs dxdlutdg jo idacb` j`

\jutawdst. Clljrghonby, tad Bdcsd Cnrddfdot hs c vcbhg cog do`jrldcibd uohbctdrcb ljotrclt

idtwddo Gdbtc cog \jutawdst.


385.

Gdbtc `jrfdg c ljotrclt whta \jutawdst iy pdr`jrfhon uogdr tad \jutawdst Bdcsd

Cnrddfdot. Gdbtc pdr`jrfdg uogdr tad \jutawdst Bdcsd Cnrddfdot iy sddmhon tj prjvhgd

sdrvhld ct Bjvd @hdbg (cog/jr dotdr Bjvd @hdbg cs c odw dotrcot lcrrhdr) cog rdqudsthon vjbuotcry

clljffjgcthjo `rjf \jutawdst. Cs c pcrty tj tad uohbctdrcb \jutawdst Bdcsd Cnrddfdot

ljotrclt, Gdbtc hs c prjpdr pcrty tj sud `jr tjrthjus hotdr`drdold whta tad Tohtdg Bdcsd

Cnrddfdot.


383. Iy sddmhon tj prjvhgd sdrvhld ct Bjvd @hdbg (cog/jr dotdr Bjvd @hdbg cs c odw

dotrcot lcrrhdr) cog rdqudsthon vjbuotcry clljffjgcthjo `rjf Tohtdg, Gdbtc pdr`jrfdg hts





jibhncthjos uogdr tad Tohtdg Bdcsd Cnrddfdot cog scths`hdg dvdry ljoghthjo prdldgdot uogdr tad

ljotrclt tj trhnndr Tohtdg‘s jibhncthjo tj clljffjgctd Gdbtc.


389. \jutawdst whbbùbby cog hotdothjocbby hotdr`drdg whta tad Tohtdg Bdcsd Cnrddfdot

iy mojwhonby hogulhon Tohtdg tj irdcla hts jibhncthjos uogdr tad Tohtdg Bdcsd Cnrddfdot,

holbughon iut ojt bhfhtdg tj Tohtdg‘s jibhncthjos tj clljffjgctd Gdbtc cog rd`rcho `rjf

ljo`drrhon co dxlbushvd rhnat jo \jutawdst. \jutawdst hotdothjocbby hoguldg Tohtdg tj suibdcsd

twj nctds tj \jutawdst, mojwhon tact Tohtdg‘s pdr`jrfcold j` hts suibdcsd cnrddfdot whta

\jutawdst wjubg id ljotrcry tj cog ho vhjbcthjo j` tad Tohtdg Bdcsd Cnrddfdot.


38<. \jutawdst‘s hotdr`drdold prjxhfctdby lcusdg Gdbtc tj su``dr shnoh`hlcot cog

hrrdpcrcibd hokury cs c octurcb, prjicibd, cog `jrdsddcibd ljosdqudold. \jutawdst tjjm co clthvd

pcrt ho pdrsucghon Tohtdg tj irdcla tad Tohtdg Bdcsd Cnrddfdot iy, cfjon jtadr tahons,

j``drhon co jisldod cfjuot j` fjody `jr tad suibdcsd. Wahs bcrnd suf j` fjody rd`bdltdg tad

dxtrcjrghocry prdfhuf \jutawdst wcs whbbhon tj pcy tj lrusa ljfpdththjo cog jitcho c

fjojpjby ct Bjvd @hdbg.


387. Gdbtc‘s shnoh`hlcot cog hrrdpcrcibd hokury stdfs `rjf ojt joby tad prj`hts ht wjubg

acvd fcgd acg ht iddo clljffjgctdg iut cbsj tad ljothouhon `hocolhcb cog rdputcthjocb acrf ht

whbb `cld h` ht lcoojt jpdrctd `bhnats ct Bjvd @hdbg ho tad ùturd.





GD@DOGCOW \JTWA^D\W CHYBHOD\ LJ.‘\ CO\^DY WJ GDBWC‘\ CFDOGDG LJTOWDYLBCHF\COG LYJ\\ LBCHF\ CNCHO\W \JTWA^D\W CHYBHOD\, LJ. UCND >>

CO\^DY WJ GDBWC‘\ UYCXDY @JY YDBHD@

\jutawdst cgfhts tact Gdbtc sddms tad rdbhd` rdqudstdg, iut gdohds tact Gdbtc hs dothtbdg tj

coy rdbhd`.

CO\^DY WJ LJOLBT\HJO

\jutawdst cgfhts tact Gdbtc sddms tad rdbhd` rdqudstdg, iut gdohds tact Gdbtc hs dothtbdg tj

coy rdbhd`.

C@@HYFCWHPD COG JWADY GD@DO\D\

3. Gdbtc‘s lbchfs crd icrrdg, ho wajbd jr ho pcrt, iy tad gjltrhod j` fdrndr.

9.

Gdbtc‘s lbchfs crd icrrdg, ho wajbd jr ho pcrt, iy Gdbtc‘s uolbdco acogs.

<.

Gdbtc‘s lbchfs crd icrrdg, ho wajbd jr ho pcrt, iy tad gjltrhod j` dstjppdb.

7. Gdbtc‘s lbchfs crd icrrdg, ho wajbd jr ho pcrt, iy tad gjltrhod j` wchvdr.

4. Gdbtc‘s lbchfs crd icrrdg, ho wajbd jr ho pcrt, iy tad gjltrhod j` rcth`hlcthjo.

LJOLBT\HJO COG UYCXDY

@jr tadsd rdcsjos, \jutawdst rdqudsts tact tad Ljurt dotdr kugnfdot `jr \jutawdst jo cbb

Gdbtc‘s lbchfs cog jrgdr tact Gdbtc tcmd ojtahon iy hts lbchfs, tact tad Ljurt cwcrg \jutawdst hts

rdcsjocibd cog odldsscry cttjrodys‘ `dds cog ljsts, cog cwcrg \jutawdst sula jtadr cog ùrtadr

rdbhd` ct bcw jr dquhty tj wahla ht fcy id kustby dothtbdg.

Lcsd <;34-lv-59508-M Gjlufdot 318 @hbdg 58/99/34 Ucnd >> j` >1 UcndHG 439<



GCWDG; \dptdfidr 99, 9534 Ydspdltùbby suifhttdg,

/s/ \tdpado F. Ljbd

Kjao W. Ljx HHHWdxcs Icr Oj. 9755<>99Dfchb; tljxEbyoobbp.ljfMdot G. MrcihbbWdxcs Icr Oj. 97505334Dfchb; mmrcihbbEbyoobbp.ljfIrhttc Drho \tcotjoWdxcs Icr Oj. 975<08>0Dfchb; istcotjoEbyoobbp.ljf\tdpado F. LjbdWdxcs Icr Oj. 975>1<41

Dfchb; sljbdEbyoobbp.ljfBXOO WHBBJW\JO UHOMDY & LJQ, BBU9355 Yjss Cvdoud, \uhtd 9>55Gcbbcs, WQ >4953Wdbdpajod; 937.813.<155@clshfhbd; 937.813.<1<8

CWWJYODX\ @JY GD@DOGCOW\JTWA^D\W CHYBHOD\ LJ.

LDYWH@HLCWD J@ \DYPHLD

Wad uogdrshnodg adrdiy ldrth`hds tact jo \dptdfidr 99, 9534, tad `jrdnjhon gjlufdot

wcs sdrvdg jo cbb ljuosdb j` rdljrg tarjuna tad Ljurt‘s DL@ systdf.

/s/ \tdpado F. Ljbd \tdpado F. Ljbd


Date post:	07-Aug-2018
Category:	Documents
Upload:	robert-wilonsky
View:	214 times
Download:	0 times

Southwest Response Filed Sept 22

Documents