+ All Categories
Home > Documents > SPEED AND DELAYED FRACTURE UNION

SPEED AND DELAYED FRACTURE UNION

Date post: 01-Jan-2017
Category:
Upload: haliem
View: 215 times
Download: 1 times
Share this document with a friend
2
491 venous stasis inside the eye is produced. There seems much to support this argument for it is clear that peripheral retinal haemorrhages-which sometimes occur -could not come from direct extension from the nerve sheath. Ballantyne,2 in five fatal cases of subarachnoid haemorrhage, found that there were often scattered haemorrhages throughout the orbit, in the fat and around the ciliary ganglion. They seemed to have no connexion with the subarachnoid hsemorrhage and Ballantyne submits that the old story of direct extension from the cranium will not do. He concludes that the changes he found in the orbit can only be accounted for by some mechanism which produces venous stasis in the whole orbit, and suggests that we have such a mechanism in the sudden and forcible increase in intracranial pressure produced by the haemorrhage, which in turn causes. pressure on the venous sinuses inside the cranium. One would have thought, however, that the extensive alternative venous drainage of the orbit by -way of the facial and deep facial veins would have prevented venous stasis in the orbit. Dup-uy-Dutemps3 3 quotes some experiments by Sicard in which grains of chinese ink injected into the subarachnoid space of living animals found their way through the dural sheath and into the cellular tissues. This seems to offer an alternative explanation to the findings in the orbit in these patients. GLYCOLS IN AIR-DISINFECTION THE bactericidal action of both mists and vapours has been investigated in relation to the control of cross- infection in respiratory diseases, and it is generally agreed that vapours are effective provided they are sufficiently concentrated. But since Bechhold 4 asserted that weight for weight phenolic bactericides were much more efficacious as mists than as vapours attention has been mainly turned to the production of stable and durable mists. Robertson and his colleagues 5 of Chicago have found that propylene glycol, much used by previous workers as a solvent for germicides, is itself germicidal, and is more effective as a vapour than when an equal quantity is dispersed in droplets l,u to 2jM in diameter as an aerosol. At a temperature of 20° C., they say, 1 g. per 1’4 cubic metres of air saturates the atmosphere, though less than half this amount, evapor- ated from Petri dishes overnight, killed the various organisms tested almost at once. They demonstrated a very high lethal effect of the glycol when it was dispersed as an aerosol in a concentration of 1 g. per 2 cubic metres of air, or when dispersed as a vapour in about a quarter of that concentration. Actually vapours are presumably concerned in both cases, for small particles of most of the glycols evaporate completely in a few seconds or even a fraction of a second. Some of the other glycols acted as bactericides in the same way. Propylene glycol, however, has the advantage of being much better tolerated by animals. Cases of glycol poisoning in man, even from inhalation of the vapours, have been reported,, but not, apparently, from propylene glycol. On the other hand, mice are apparently unaffected by living for weeks in an atmosphere supersaturated with ethylene glycol, although there is a limit, especially in females, to the amount they can take by mouth. Stokes and Henle 6 of Philadelphia have found ultraviolet irradiation and vaporisation of propylene glycol highly and about equally effective in preventing air-borne infection of mice with the virus of influenza A. The ultraviolet light was projected as a " curtain " in front of each cubicle and also in the upper part of the ward above the cubicles. The glycol was vaporised from a hot plate placed in front of an electric fan near one of the 2. Ballantyne, J. Glasg. med. J. 1942, 20, 1. 3. These de Paris, 1900. 4. Bechhold, H. 1935. Improvements in rendering micro-organisms innocuous. British patent No. 472,623. 5. Robertson, O. H., Bigg, E., Puck, T. T. and Miller B. F. J. exp. Med. 1942, 75, 593. 6. Stokes. J. and Henle, W. J. Amer. med. Ass. 1942, 120, 16. ward windows so as to give a concentration of 1 in 2-4 million. They also quote an unpublished controlled experiment by T. N. Harris in which a concentration of one part of propylene glycol vapour in 30-40 million parts of air was strikingly successful in protecting children in a convalescent home from respiratory infection. I METABOLISM OF PLASMA PROTEINS THOUGH easily accessible for study or assay, the plasma proteins have always been rather neglected by physio- logists. Starling early established that one of their functions was the exertion of colloidal osmotic pressure in, the circulating medium. This function is now well understood and the part it plays in the formation of lymph and of various types of cedema has been thoroughly explored. For many years Whipple 1 and his colleagues have been studying in dogs the formation and the wider functions of the circulating proteins. One aspect of this work has been the intermittent removal of large amounts of plasma proteins to discover what type of diet will cause the most complete and rapid resynthesis. This approach has led to the conclusion that some dietary proteins are much more efficacious than others and that proteins which favour haemoglobin formation are not necessarily those which favour plasma- protein production; as might be expected, the proteins of serum itself are the most effective that can be taken by mouth. These views have not gone unchallenged however ; Melnick, Cowgill and Burack 2 found that serum proteins, casein and lactalbumin each give an equally good synthesis of plasma proteins. Further experiments in Whipple’s laboratory have shown that dogs which have been depleted’of plasma proteins for some time are abnormally susceptible to infections of many kinds and to poisoning with chloroform and organic arsenicals. The susceptibility can be removed in a day or two by a high protein diet, or immediately if considerable amounts of plasma protein are given intra- venously. The amino-acid methionine has the same effect. These observations may have considerable therapeutic significance. Some of the experimental results of these workers seem a little revolutionary to the ’ conventional physiologists. Thus they have shown that dogs may be maintained in nitrogen equilibrium for weeks solely by the intravenous injection of plasma protein. This suggests either that these proteins must be broken down in the liver and their amino-acids redis- tributed to other tissues according to their needs, or that the plasma proteins themselves must enter the cells of the body, there to be transformed into the proteins characteristic of the cell. Whipple favours the second hypothesis. It would be helpful to see this work con- firmed on another species before the results are accepted as applying to man. SPEED AND DELAYED FRACTURE UNION THE orthopsed has lately been heaping abuse on his own methods of treating the fractured tibia. Excessive traction, the pin, the non-padded cast, long immobilisa- tion have all been blamed, and it has been urged that it would be better to make certain by earlier and more frequent operation. J. P. Campbell at the Nottingham meeting of the Orthopaedic Assocation says : Not at all, lift up your hearts, you are at least as good as your forefathers at the treatment of these fractures. The " modern " delayed union of the tibia, he maintains, is due to the increased severity of the injury ; in the simple fracture union takes no longer than of old. In an analysis of 54 tibial fractures at the junction of middle and lower thirds, he divides the cases into slight-those arising in football, boxing or jumping; and severe- those that followed motor-cycle, gunshot wounds or 1. Whipple, G. H. Amer. J. med. Sci. 1942, 203, 477. 2. Melnick, D., Cowgill, G. R. and Burack, E. J. exp. Med. 1936, 64, 897.
Transcript
Page 1: SPEED AND DELAYED FRACTURE UNION

491

venous stasis inside the eye is produced. There seemsmuch to support this argument for it is clear that

peripheral retinal haemorrhages-which sometimes occur-could not come from direct extension from the nervesheath. Ballantyne,2 in five fatal cases of subarachnoidhaemorrhage, found that there were often scattered

haemorrhages throughout the orbit, in the fat and aroundthe ciliary ganglion. They seemed to have no connexionwith the subarachnoid hsemorrhage and Ballantynesubmits that the old story of direct extension from thecranium will not do. He concludes that the changes hefound in the orbit can only be accounted for by somemechanism which produces venous stasis in the wholeorbit, and suggests that we have such a mechanism in thesudden and forcible increase in intracranial pressureproduced by the haemorrhage, which in turn causes.

pressure on the venous sinuses inside the cranium.One would have thought, however, that the extensivealternative venous drainage of the orbit by -way of thefacial and deep facial veins would have prevented venousstasis in the orbit. Dup-uy-Dutemps3 3 quotes some

experiments by Sicard in which grains of chinese inkinjected into the subarachnoid space of living animalsfound their way through the dural sheath and into thecellular tissues. This seems to offer an alternativeexplanation to the findings in the orbit in these patients.

GLYCOLS IN AIR-DISINFECTION

THE bactericidal action of both mists and vapourshas been investigated in relation to the control of cross-infection in respiratory diseases, and it is generallyagreed that vapours are effective provided they are

sufficiently concentrated. But since Bechhold 4 assertedthat weight for weight phenolic bactericides were muchmore efficacious as mists than as vapours attention hasbeen mainly turned to the production of stable anddurable mists. Robertson and his colleagues 5 of

Chicago have found that propylene glycol, much usedby previous workers as a solvent for germicides, is itselfgermicidal, and is more effective as a vapour than whenan equal quantity is dispersed in droplets l,u to 2jM indiameter as an aerosol. At a temperature of 20° C.,they say, 1 g. per 1’4 cubic metres of air saturates theatmosphere, though less than half this amount, evapor-ated from Petri dishes overnight, killed the various

organisms tested almost at once. They demonstrated avery high lethal effect of the glycol when it was dispersedas an aerosol in a concentration of 1 g. per 2 cubic metresof air, or when dispersed as a vapour in about a quarterof that concentration. Actually vapours are presumablyconcerned in both cases, for small particles of most ofthe glycols evaporate completely in a few seconds oreven a fraction of a second. Some of the other glycolsacted as bactericides in the same way. Propyleneglycol, however, has the advantage of being muchbetter tolerated by animals. Cases of glycol poisoningin man, even from inhalation of the vapours, have beenreported,, but not, apparently, from propylene glycol.On the other hand, mice are apparently unaffected byliving for weeks in an atmosphere supersaturated withethylene glycol, although there is a limit, especially infemales, to the amount they can take by mouth. Stokesand Henle 6 of Philadelphia have found ultravioletirradiation and vaporisation of propylene glycol highlyand about equally effective in preventing air-borneinfection of mice with the virus of influenza A. Theultraviolet light was projected as a " curtain " in frontof each cubicle and also in the upper part of the wardabove the cubicles. The glycol was vaporised from a hotplate placed in front of an electric fan near one of the2. Ballantyne, J. Glasg. med. J. 1942, 20, 1.3. These de Paris, 1900.4. Bechhold, H. 1935. Improvements in rendering micro-organisms

innocuous. British patent No. 472,623.5. Robertson, O. H., Bigg, E., Puck, T. T. and Miller B. F. J. exp.

Med. 1942, 75, 593.6. Stokes. J. and Henle, W. J. Amer. med. Ass. 1942, 120, 16.

ward windows so as to give a concentration of 1 in 2-4million. They also quote an unpublished controlled

experiment by T. N. Harris in which a concentration ofone part of propylene glycol vapour in 30-40 million partsof air was strikingly successful in protecting children in aconvalescent home from respiratory infection. I

METABOLISM OF PLASMA PROTEINS

THOUGH easily accessible for study or assay, the plasmaproteins have always been rather neglected by physio-logists. Starling early established that one of theirfunctions was the exertion of colloidal osmotic pressurein, the circulating medium. This function is now wellunderstood and the part it plays in the formationof lymph and of various types of cedema has beenthoroughly explored. For many years Whipple 1 and his

colleagues have been studying in dogs the formationand the wider functions of the circulating proteins. Oneaspect of this work has been the intermittent removalof large amounts of plasma proteins to discover whattype of diet will cause the most complete and rapidresynthesis. This approach has led to the conclusionthat some dietary proteins are much more efficaciousthan others and that proteins which favour haemoglobinformation are not necessarily those which favour plasma-protein production; as might be expected, the proteins ofserum itself are the most effective that can be taken bymouth. These views have not gone unchallengedhowever ; Melnick, Cowgill and Burack 2 found thatserum proteins, casein and lactalbumin each give anequally good synthesis of plasma proteins. Furtherexperiments in Whipple’s laboratory have shown thatdogs which have been depleted’of plasma proteins forsome time are abnormally susceptible to infections of

many kinds and to poisoning with chloroform and

organic arsenicals. The susceptibility can be removedin a day or two by a high protein diet, or immediately ifconsiderable amounts of plasma protein are given intra-venously. The amino-acid methionine has the sameeffect. These observations may have considerable

therapeutic significance. Some of the experimentalresults of these workers seem a little revolutionary to the ’conventional physiologists. Thus they have shown thatdogs may be maintained in nitrogen equilibrium forweeks solely by the intravenous injection of plasmaprotein. This suggests either that these proteins mustbe broken down in the liver and their amino-acids redis-tributed to other tissues according to their needs, or thatthe plasma proteins themselves must enter the cells ofthe body, there to be transformed into the proteinscharacteristic of the cell. Whipple favours the secondhypothesis. It would be helpful to see this work con-firmed on another species before the results are acceptedas applying to man.

SPEED AND DELAYED FRACTURE UNIONTHE orthopsed has lately been heaping abuse on his

own methods of treating the fractured tibia. Excessivetraction, the pin, the non-padded cast, long immobilisa-tion have all been blamed, and it has been urged that itwould be better to make certain by earlier and morefrequent operation. J. P. Campbell at the Nottinghammeeting of the Orthopaedic Assocation says : Not atall, lift up your hearts, you are at least as good as yourforefathers at the treatment of these fractures. The" modern " delayed union of the tibia, he maintains, isdue to the increased severity of the injury ; in thesimple fracture union takes no longer than of old. In an

analysis of 54 tibial fractures at the junction of middleand lower thirds, he divides the cases into slight-thosearising in football, boxing or jumping; and severe-those that followed motor-cycle, gunshot wounds or

1. Whipple, G. H. Amer. J. med. Sci. 1942, 203, 477.2. Melnick, D., Cowgill, G. R. and Burack, E. J. exp. Med. 1936,

64, 897.

Page 2: SPEED AND DELAYED FRACTURE UNION

492

other explosions. The average period of disability forthe 10 slight cases was 16 weeks and for the 44 severe cases28 weeks. The period of disability for the slight injuryprobably compares favourably with that with treatmentby the older methods. Radiographic evidence was inthese cases the indication for removal of the plaster andthe start of weight-bearing. Campbell found thatplaster immobilisation itself led to weakness, pain or

limitation of movement in joints, which were notpreviously involved. As a rule, the convalescing periodwas about twice the period in plaster, so that the longerthe plaster immobilisation the longer was the subsequentconvalescence ; and this was despite regular exercisesfor toes and knee from the outset and the use of a walkingfoot plate after 4-6 weeks. Campbell has thereforestarted removing the plaster on the first indication ofclinical union, which is several weeks before radiographicunion. The limb is then supported on a plaster backsplint, and non-weight-bearing exercises are begun,weight-bearing being started when X rays show union.In 25 of the 44 severe cases the injury was due to amotor-cycle accident and Campbell recommends a specialmetal shin-guard for the motor cyclist. Rowley BristowHi the discussion said the opinions of a large number ofdirt-track riders and other motor-cyclists have beentaken on shin-guards, and the Army has decided thatthe only effective protection is a guard on the motor-cycle itself. Many motor-cycles have already been thusfitted. He also stressed the importance of care in handling

these fractures ; reduction by the onlooker often results-

in the enclosure of a large mass of dirt between the boneends.

LCC AND MEDICAL STUDY

THE LCC are putting some hard thinking into thepreparation of their evidence for the InterdepartmentalCommittee on Medical Schools. We have alreadydescribed their reactions as a local education authority(Lancet, Oct. 10, p. 444), and now they have spoken theirmind as the major health authority for London, as thelargest civilian employer of medical staff in the country,and as the administrator of hospital and public-healthservices which offer facilities for a complete medicaltraining. The council therefore begin by suggesting tothe interdepartmental committee that not only shouldthese facilities be used to increase available resources forthe teaching of medicine but that an undergraduatemedical school should be set up based on one of theirlarger general hospitals, and making use of specialhospital and institutes as required. They feel that thereis room for more integration m the teaching which nowobtains between the voluntary and municipal hospitalsif continuity of the curriculum is to be ensured and gapsavoided. They suggest that an advisory body, similarto that which now makes appointments to universitychairs, should be established for each combination oflinked municipal and voluntary hospitals. Representa-tives of both kinds of hospitals and of the universitywould sit on these bodies. Junior clinical appointmentswould -be interchangeable between the linked hospitalsand if it is decided that a medical student must afterqualification and before registration hold a house-appointment the council will adjust its staffing arrange-ments. After the war they would be prepared to extendthe arrangements for medical students to live in at theirhospitals to receive instructions in such subjects as

obstetrics and fevers. The council believe that psycho-logical medicine must find a more important place in thetraining of the doctor of the future, and that organisedinstruction supplemented by visits to institutionsshould introduce him to the public health and welfareservices. Every student should attend confinementsin the home as part of his training. The councilthink that there should be better coordination ofLondon postgraduate facilities and suggest that herethe British Postgraduate Medical School, with an office

in the academic centre. of London, has an important partto play in advising graduates where their needs couldbest be met.

ACCIDENTS AND ACCIDENTSTHE National Insurance Gazette of Sept. 24 suggested

that approved societies might help in distinguishingaccident-prone workers in order that this small minoritymight be removed from dangerous occupations. Thesocieties should certainly have among their recordsmany relevant data, but any analysis of them for such apurpose would have to be carefully considered. Thoseworkers named as being accident-prone by the societiesmight be penalised if they were debarred from a danger-ous occupation without being provided with a safer postcarrying comparable rewards, and there might well begrounds for legal complaint against the body which hadso stigmatised them. Nor are the records of approvedsocieties necessarily complete enough to allow of fair

judgment. ’ They usually record only such relativelyserious accidents as keep a man from work for more thanthree days, but take no note of minor accidents. Yetin deciding whether or not a worker is accident-pronecareful records must be kept of all accidents, even themost trivial. As Vernon has pointed out/ for all weknow the trivial accident may be as reliable an index toproneness as the serious one. Even the fact that a

worker has had several minor or major accidents may notmean that he is accident-prone : his job may be intrinsic-ally dangerous, the machines insufficiently guarded, orthe lighting bad ; and others doing the same job maysustain an equal number of accidents. Some accidents,as we all know, are the fault of other people. If he wasone of a group of workers doing the same job undercomparable conditions, and he had many more accidentsthan his mates, a man might perhaps fairly be calledaccident-prone. Even then it would be necessary toensure that he had no physical disability-like defectiveeyesight-the correction of which might do away withthe proneness. Real accident-proneness is presumablypsychological, not physical, and the diagnosis can

perhaps best be made in the factory, and individually,by the works doctor-possibly helped by a psychologist.Physical causes of incoördination must of course beexcluded. If a worker really is accident-prone, he canusually be transferred tactfully to some less dangerousjob without having a label attached to him.

Dr. ROBERT J. ROwLETTE, PRCPI, has been electedpresident of the Royal Academy of Medicine in Ireland." Prof. HARRY PLATT will deliver the Robert Joneslecture at the Royal College of Surgeons on Wednesday,Nov. 4, at 3.15 PM. He will speak on congenitaldislocation of the hip-joint. At the same hour on

Thursday, Nov. 12, Mr. L. R. BRAITHWAITE will give aBradshaw lecture on the role of bile in duodenalregurgitation.

__

1. Vernon, H. M. Accidents and their Prevention, Cambridge, 1936,p. 46.

LABELLING OF CASUALTIES.—Where necessary casualtiesare labelled by first-aid parties (light rescue parties in Londoncivil defence region) at an incident. Tie-on labels, with asymbol written on them, are used and, if possible, the foreheadof the patient is also marked with the same symbol in indeliblepencil. The symbols used for marking and their interpretationare as follows :-x-Requires priority of removal from the incident and of

examination when reaching hospital. This is used mainly, but notexclusively, for wounds of the chest and abdomen, and for internalhaemorrhage.T-A tourniquet has been applied. The time of application of the

tourniquet and subsequent releases should also be indicated on thelabel.H-Severe haemorrhage has occurred.rs-lkIorphine has been given. The time of administration and

dose should be written on the label.c--Contaminated by persistent gas.xx-Poisoned by phosgene gas or suspected of having been so

poisoned.


Recommended