2017-2018 REPORT
MEDIA COUNCIL OF TANZANIA
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA 2017—2018
ii
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA2017— 2018
©Media Council of Tanzania, 2019
First print - 2019
ISBN 978-9987-710-72-0
iii
2017-2018 REPORT
CONTENTS
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ................................................................................................. 11.0 Introduction ....................................................................................................................... 11.1 Objective of the Report .................................................................................................... 11.2 Organisation of the Report ............................................................................................... 12.0 Methodology ...................................................................................................................... 13.0 Key Findings for Tanzania Mainland .............................................................................. 24.0 Key Findings for Tanzania Zanzibar ............................................................................... 45.0 Conclusion .......................................................................................................................... 56.0 Recommendations ............................................................................................................. 6
ABOUT AUTHORS .......................................................................................................... 6PART I .............................................................................................................................................. 9TANZANIASTATE OF THE MEDIA TANZANIA MAINLAND 2017-2018 ............................................. 9
CHAPTER ONE .............................................................................................................. 13Developments in Legal/ Regulatory Framework ............................................................ 131.0 Introduction ..................................................................................................................... 131.1 Legal and Regulatory Framework: Key Issues in 2017 and 2018 .............................. 131.1.1 Media Service Act, 2016 Regulations, 2017 ................................................................. 131.1.2 Access to Information Act Regulations, 2017 .............................................................. 151.1.3 Electronic and Postal Communications (Online Content) Regulations, 2018. ...... 181.1.4 Electronic and Postal Communications (Radio and Television Broadcasting) Regula-
tions, 2018 ......................................................................................................................... 191.2 Amendments of the Statistics Act, 2015 (Cap 351, 2018) .......................................... 201.3 Political developments and their Implications to press freedom .............................. 211.4 Development as the Agenda of the Media ................................................................... 221.5 Press Freedom Violations ............................................................................................... 241.6 Concluding Remarks ....................................................................................................... 251.7 Recommendations ........................................................................................................... 25
CHAPTER TWO ............................................................................................................. 27Current Trends in the Print Media ................................................................................. 272.0 Introduction ..................................................................................................................... 272.2 Current Status of Print Media in Tanzania................................................................... 272.3 Newspapers Ordered to Re-register, No Licence, No Permission to Operate ......... 272.4 Just Few Proprietors Still Dominate Newspaper Landscape ...................................... 292.5 Newspapers Sustainability Issues ................................................................................... 312.5.1 Newspapers in Progress to Re-conquer the Market, Regain Position ...................... 312.5.2 Restrictive Laws an Obstacle to Newspapers Sustainability ...................................... 312.6 Journalists Abused, Clamp Down on Outlets…the List is Long ............................... 32
iv
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
2.6.1 Incidents of Abuses against Print Journalists ............................................................... 322.7 Incidents of Newspaper Suspensions and Banning .................................................... 352.8 Status of Self-censorship and Chill in Coverage of Some Stories .............................. 362.8.1 Restrictive Laws Trigger Fear, Journalists Opt for Self-censorship ........................... 362.8.2 Tough Laws Fuelled Self -Censorship, Ethical Violations .......................................... 382.9 Introduction of Fees for Online Newspapers ............................................................... 412.9.1 High Fees Forced Existing Online Outlets Close Down ............................................ 412.10 Complaints Against Newspapers in 2017/18 ............................................................... 422.11 Concluding Remarks ....................................................................................................... 432.12 Recommendations ........................................................................................................... 43
CHAPTER THREE ......................................................................................................... 47Current Trends in the Radio and TV Broadcasting ....................................................... 473.0 Introduction ..................................................................................................................... 473.1 Current Situation of Radio Broadcasting in Tanzania. ............................................... 473.1.1 Number of Licensed Radio Stations in Tanzania ........................................................ 473.1.2 Radio Plurality and Ownership ..................................................................................... 493.1.3 Radio Proliferation .......................................................................................................... 493.1.4 Radio Development Trend: Community Radios as an Area to Watch ..................... 493. 2. Situation of TV in Tanzania ........................................................................................... 503.2.1 Number of Licensed TV Stations in Tanzania ............................................................. 503.2.2 Television Plurality, Ownership and Diversity. ............................................................ 513.3 Radio/TV Sustainability Issues ...................................................................................... 513.3.1 Financial Constraints ...................................................................................................... 523.3.2 Manpower Challenges ..................................................................................................... 523.3.3 Technical Equipment ..................................................................................................... 533.3.4 Security Challenges ......................................................................................................... 533.3.5 Legal Challenges .............................................................................................................. 533.4 Status of Closure or Hefty Fines in Tanzania Mainland media ................................. 533.5 Highlights of Incidents of Violence, Threats and Intimidation to Broadcasting Jour-
nalists ................................................................................................................................. 563.6 Digital Broadcasting in Tanzania .................................................................................. 573.6.1 Current Situation of Digital Broadcasting in Tanzania .............................................. 583.7 Online TV and Radio Stations in Tanzania ................................................................. 593.8 Ethical Issues in the Broadcasting Industry ................................................................. 613.9 Concluding Remarks ....................................................................................................... 613.10 Recommendations ........................................................................................................... 62
CHAPTER FOUR............................................................................................................ 65Current Trends in the New Media .................................................................................. 654.0 Introduction ..................................................................................................................... 654.1 With Tense Political Atmosphere Online Media Strive to Survive ........................... 654.2 Government Uses Restrictive as Mechanisms to Control Online Space .................. 664.3 Online Content Regulations; a Heavy Nail on the Coffin .......................................... 68
v
2017-2018 REPORT
4.3.1 Stakeholders` Response to Online Regulations Online regulations send bloggers pack-ing ...................................................................................................................................... 69
4.4 The Notorious 2015 Cybercrimes Act Continued to Play Significant Role. ............ 724.5 Incidents of People Punished Under Online Laws ...................................................... 734.6 Shrinking Public Space Alarms Local, International Rights Groups ........................ 744.7 With the Tense Political Situation, What is the Future of Online Media? ............... 764.8 Strategies to Promote Good Use of Online Media ...................................................... 774.9 Concluding Remarks ....................................................................................................... 784.10 Recommendations ........................................................................................................... 79
CHAPTER FIVE ............................................................................................................. 81Media Support in Tanzania Mainland ............................................................................ 815.0 Introduction ..................................................................................................................... 815.1 Organisations Supporting Media in Tanzania ............................................................. 815.2 Internews .......................................................................................................................... 815.3 Tanzania Media Women’s Association .......................................................................... 835.6 FES TANZANIA .............................................................................................................. 855.7 Misa-Tan ........................................................................................................................... 865.8 Tanzania Human Rights Defenders Coalition (THRDC) .......................................... 885.9 Journalists Environmental Association of Tanzania (JET) ........................................ 915.10 Tanzania Media Foundation (TMF) ............................................................................. 925.11 UNESCO and Other Supporters ................................................................................... 945.12 Media Council of Tanzania (MCT) ............................................................................... 945.13 Media Stakeholders Perception ..................................................................................... 985.14 Concluding Remarks ....................................................................................................... 995.15 Recommendations ........................................................................................................... 99
PART II ......................................................................................................................................... 101ZANZIBARThe State of Media Report in Zanzibar in 2017/18 ................................................................. 101
CHAPTER ONE ............................................................................................................ 103Political Context/Legal and Regulatory Framework .................................................... 1031.0 Introduction ................................................................................................................... 1031.1 Key Political Events in 2017/18 and Their Implications to Press Freedom and Journal-
ism ................................................................................................................................... 1031.4 Conclusion ...................................................................................................................... 1091.5 Recommendations ......................................................................................................... 110
CHAPTER TWO ........................................................................................................... 111Current Trends in the Print Media in Zanzibar ........................................................... 1112.0 Introduction ................................................................................................................... 1112.1 Registration of Newspapers .......................................................................................... 111
vi
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
2.2 Sustainability Issues ....................................................................................................... 1122.2.1 Financial Muscles of Newspapers ................................................................................ 1122.2.2 Production ...................................................................................................................... 1132.2.3 Distribution .................................................................................................................... 1132.2.4 Newspaper’s Contents ................................................................................................... 1132.2.5 Maintenance of Labour Force ...................................................................................... 1142.3 Mushrooming of Online Newspapers ......................................................................... 1142.4 Conclusion ...................................................................................................................... 1142.5 Recommendations ......................................................................................................... 114
CHAPTER THREE ....................................................................................................... 117Current Trend in Radio and TV Broadcasting in Zanzibar ......................................... 1173.0 Introduction ................................................................................................................... 1173.1 Registration of New Radio and TV Stations ............................................................. 1173.1.2 Introduction of Decoders and its Implications on Radio and TV .......................... 1183.2 Threats and Intimidation to Journalists ...................................................................... 1183.3 Sustainability Issues ....................................................................................................... 1193.4 Current Status in Digital Broadcasting ....................................................................... 1203.5 Conclusion ...................................................................................................................... 1203.6 Recommendations ......................................................................................................... 120
CHAPTER FOUR.......................................................................................................... 121Current Trends in the New Media ................................................................................ 1214.0 Introduction ................................................................................................................... 1214.1 Registration of New Media ........................................................................................... 1214.2 Current Status of New Media and its Implication on Journalism Practices .......... 1224.3 New Media and its Impact on Traditional Media in Zanzibar ................................ 1224.4 Comparison of Ownership, Press Freedom Violations and Advertising Aspects . 1234.5 Conclusion ...................................................................................................................... 1244.6 Recommendations ......................................................................................................... 124
CHAPTER FIVE ........................................................................................................... 125Media Development Support ........................................................................................ 1255.0 Introduction ................................................................................................................... 1255.1 Grants/Fellowships and Scholarships ......................................................................... 1255.2 Promotion and Protection of Journalists Rights and Welfare ................................. 1265.3 Promotion of Specialised Training in Journalism ..................................................... 1275.4 Provisions of Institutional Support to Media Institutions ........................................ 1275.5 Availability of Research Fund ...................................................................................... 1285.6 Other Development Support ........................................................................................ 1285.7 Conclusion ...................................................................................................................... 1285.8 Recommendations ......................................................................................................... 129
vii
2017-2018 REPORT
CHAPTER SIX .............................................................................................................. 131Professionalism in the Media and Trends in Journalism Training Institutions .......... 1316.0 Introduction ................................................................................................................... 1316.1 Key Ethical Events in 2017/18 ...................................................................................... 1316.2 Media Current Ethical Debates .................................................................................... 1326.2.1 The Right to Reply ......................................................................................................... 1326.2.2. Balance of Information ................................................................................................. 1326.3 The trend in Journalism Training Institution ............................................................ 1326.4 Tertiary Institutions and Quality of Education/Curriculum ................................... 1336.5 Research Status/Consultancies and Community Services ....................................... 1336.6 Sustainability of Journalism Training Institutions .................................................... 1336.7 Conclusion ...................................................................................................................... 1346.8 Recommendations ......................................................................................................... 134
viii
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
1
2017-2018 REPORT
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
1.0 Introduction The‘StateoftheMediaReport’isaflagshipoftheMediaCouncilof
Tanzania(MCT)publishedannuallysince2001.Issueshighlightedinthesereportshavehelpedshedlightoncriticalaspectsoftheindustry which need intervention.
1.1 Objective of the Report Theobjectiveofthisreportistotrack,highlightanddocument
trends,notabledevelopments,challengesaswellasemergingissuesrelatedtolaws,policiesandmediaenvironment,whichprevailedbetween2017/18.Thegoalistoshedlightonpositivedevelopmentswhichneedtobesustained.Italsoaimsatgettinganunderstandingoncriticalissueswhichneedinterventionandgiverecommendationsonhowtomoveforward.
1.2 Organisation of the Report Thisyear’sreportcombineseventsandissuesthatprevailedinthe
mediasectorfortheperiodof2017/18andisdividedintotwoparts.ThefirstparthighlightsthemediasituationinMainlandTanzania,while the second part focuses on Zanzibar. The report covers the followingareas:
*Legalandregulatoryframework; *Trendsintheprintmedia; *TrendsintheradioandTVbroadcasting *TrendsinthenewmediaandmediasupportinTanzania. Furthermore,theZanzibarReporthasachapteron‘Professionalism
intheMediaandTrendsinJournalismTrainingInstitutions’.
2.0 Methodology Inpreparingthisreport,theconsultancyteamemployedamixed-
methodsapproachtocollectdata,bothprimaryandsecondary.Secondarydatawascollectedfromvariousreportsrelatingtomedia,lawsandregulations,policiesaswellasnewspaperarticles.Incollectingprimarydatatocomplementthedesk-workreview,interviews were conducted with selected respondents. Respondents
2
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
werepickedfrommediapractitioners,professionalassociations,mediaandcommunicationanalysts,civilsocietyorganisations,legalpractitionersandindividualsfromhigherlearninginstitutions.Respondents were purposively selected based on their wealth of knowledgeonthesubject.
3.0 Key Findings for Tanzania Mainland
Legal and regulatory framework Oneofthemajordevelopmentsinlegalframeworkwasthepassing
ofregulationstocompletelegislationprocessesoftherecentlyenactedlaws.Theexercisescuttledstakeholders`expectations,sincesuchchangesdidnotaddressmanycontentiousissuesinthelaws.
Aspectssuchasaccreditationofjournalists,licensingofnewspapers,leavingthepowertosuspendorevencancelnewspaperlicensesinthehandsoftheDirectorofInformationServicesDepartment,aresomeoftheareaswhich,instakeholders`view,continuetothreatenthefreedomofindividualjournalists,mediaoutletsandtheindustryasawhole.AmendmentsoftheStatisticsAct,2015,madethelawmoredraconianandabighurdleincollectionanddisseminationofstatisticalinformation.
The period also witnessed a new trend of politicization of developmentagenda,wherejournalistsandotherswhoraisedvoicesagainstwrongdoingsbyGovernmentauthoritieswereconsidered enemies andpersonswhowere againstnationaldevelopment.
Current Trends in the Print Media Printmediacomesoutasastrugglingindustrywhichthroughout
2017/18sufferedmassivesetbacksincludingoperatingundera tensepoliticalenvironmentdominatedbyrepressive laws.Decliningreadershipandadvertisingcontinuedtohaunttheindustry,hencederailingitsdevelopmentandsustainability.
Thelandscapealsocontinuedtobedominatedbyafewproprietors,somethingwhichcontradictsthewholeconceptofmediapluralismanditsbenefitstodemocraticprocesses.Government`sdirectivetore-registerallnewspapersandmagazinesshockedproprietors,leavingthemwithonlyonechoice:toeitherre-registerorclose
3
2017-2018 REPORT
down business. The trendof suspendingorbanningnewspapers accusedof
notcomplyingwiththelaw,plusintimidation,prosecutionandharassmentofjournalists,wereothercriticalaspectswitnessed.Violationsweremany,buttheworstofallwasthedisappearanceofaMwananchiCommunicationLimited(MCL)journalist,AzoryGwanda,whosewhereaboutsisunknowntothisday.
Theunfavourable environment inwhich themedia operate,contributedtothedropofTanzania’spositionintheWorldFreedomIndex(whichis?&comparedtopreviousnr).
Current Trends in Radio and TV Broadcasting Radioandtelevisionstationscontinuedtooperateunderalegal
frameworkwhichwasneitherfriendlynorsupportivetotheirdevelopment.Certainlawsandregulationsguidingbroadcastingindustry were used by authorities for personal purposes and punishingjournalistswhoareviewedasGovernment’scritics.
Punitivemeasureslikeclosureofstationsandfinesweretakenagainstsomemediaestablishmentsonanumberofoccasionsundercircumstanceswhichlegalobserversconsideredunjust.IncidentsofviolenceandthreatstobroadcastingjournalistswereontheriseandtheworstincidentwastheinvasionofCloudsTVbyDar-es-SalaamRegionalCommissioner(RC),PaulMakonda.TheRCstormedthestationwitharmedpolice,reportedlytopressurethestafftoairavideounderminingapopularlocalpastorthatiscriticaloftheCommissioner.
AslightincreaseinthenumberofradioandTVstations,officialopeningofdoorsforonlineradioandtelevisionandalittleprogressondigitalbroadcasting,werenoteworthydevelopmentsintheindustry.
Current Trends in the New Media Onlinemediacontinuedtosurviveunderahostileenvironment
withatensepoliticalatmosphere,resultinginviolationoffreedomofexpressionandshrinkingcivicspace.EnforcementofthenotoriousCybercrimesActandotherrestrictivelawsandregulationscontinuedtoplayasignificantroleinsuppressingvoicesconsideredcriticaltothecurrentGovernmentanditspolicies.
The‘OnlineContentRegulations,2017’wasamajorblowtoonline
4
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
communicationinTanzania.Areasofgreatconcernincludedthe prohibitive fees that operators are required to pay, threats to anonymityandseverepenaltiesforthosecontraveningtheseterms.
Despitethesesetbacks,onlinemediacontinuestoprogresswiththenumberofcitizensaccessingtheInternetandotherdigitaldevicesincreasing.TheGovernmentcontinuestoputinplacemechanismstocontrolmisuseofsocialmediaincludingpostingofindecentcontentontheseplatforms.
Media Support in Tanzania Mainland Anumberoforganisationshavebeensupportingthemediain
Tanzaniainthepastdecade.Areasmostlysupportedincludetraining,continuouslearning,mentorshipandfellowships.
Otherareasare: advocacyon issues related toprotectionofmediafreedomandfreedomofexpression,improvingworkingenvironmentofjournalists,challengingdraconianlaws,monitoringandreportingonhumanrightsabusesagainstjournalistsandresearchonpressfreedomviolationsinthecountryforthepurposeofcompilingreportstobeusedinadvocacywork.
Provisionoflegalaidtojournalistswhohavebeenattackedorprosecutedinthecourseoftheirwork,protectionofmediaworkersaswellasprovidingshorttimerelocationtosomejournalistsreceivingthreatsfromunknownpeople,wereamongactivitiesthat received support.
4.0 Key Findings for Tanzania Zanzibar The‘StateofMediainZanzibar’reportdepictsamixtureofpositive
andnegativedevelopments.Theassessmentinthispublicationshows that someeventswere legalandpolicy-relatedwhileotherstoucheddirectlyonthemediasector.The‘StateofMediainZanzibar’coversthefollowingchapters:
Political/Legal and Regulatory Framework SomemedialawsincludingsectionsofthenewElectionsActof
2018remainachallengetomediaoperationsservingthemasses.
Current Trends in the Print Media in Zanzibar TheprintmediainZanzibarisstilllimping.Foreignandlocal
investorshaveputlessattentioninthisindustry.Lackofexperience
5
2017-2018 REPORT
inrunningnewspaperbusinessinthemodernworldisanotherproblem.
Current Trend in Radio and TV Broadcasting in Zanzibar Thereisapositivedevelopmentintheelectronicmedia.Online
televisionstationshavestartedtosprout,whichisanimportantelementindisseminationofinformationtothepublic.
Trends in the New Media Ownership, press freedom violations and advertising have
affectedtheperformanceofthemedia.Newsjudgmentforpublicconsumptionisusuallypremisedontheinterestsofmediaowners.
Media Development Support Journalists are not sure of their survival and welfare. Matters of
protection,promotionofjournalists’rightsandresearchactivitiesdidnotattractmuchattention.
Professionalism in the Media and Trends in Journalism Training Institutions
Thegapofprofessionalismandviolationofmediaethicsisstillanissueforconsideration.However,thereishopeforjournalismtraininginstitutions,especiallythoseownedbytheGovernment,to continue to survive.
5.0 Conclusion ThesituationofthemediainTanzaniain2017/18,particularlyinthe
Mainland,wasnotpromising.Themedia,beitprint,broadcastingoronline,sufferedmassivesetbacksincludingoperatingundera tensepolitical environmentdominatedby repressive laws.Punitivemeasuressuchassuspensionorbanningofnewspapers,closureofbroadcastingstationsundercircumstancesconsideredunjust,plusviolence,intimidation,prosecutionandharassmentofjournalists,weresomeoftheviolationswitnessedinthetwoyears.TheunfavourableenvironmentinwhichthemediaoperatedwasoneofthefactorsthatexplainwhyTanzania’spositioninPressFreedomIndexdropped.Asonemediaguruputsit:``Thedoorsmaybeshut,buttheyarenotlocked.Lookforalternativestylesandwaysofsendingthesamemessagewithoutangeringrulerswhohavenotbeentolerant.Takeadvantageofopportunitiescreated
6
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
bysocialmedia.Whiletheymaynotbeapanaceatoshrinkingcivicspace,theyare,indeed,abreathingspaceasfarasfreedomofexpressionisconcerned,’’
6.0 Recommendations * Media,civilsocietyandhumanrightssupportersmust
continuetocampaigntoensuredraconianandmediaunfriendlylawandregulationsarereformed;
* Challengetheenforcementoflawsandregulationsthatviolateonlinerights;
* Prepareethicalguidelinesforonlinecommunicationand * Push for media training programmes which make
journalistsandmediainstitutionsmoreindependentand sustainable.
About Authors
Dr Joyce BaziraDrBaziraisamediatrainer,researcherandmentor.SheholdsaDoctorofPhilosophy(PhD)degreeinMassCommunicationfromSt.AugustineUniversityofTanzaniaandaMaster’sdegreeinthesameareaandfromthesameuniversity.ShehastaughtinvariousuniversitiesinTanzaniaatbothundergraduateandgraduatelevels.As a researcher,Dr Bazira has participated in a number ofcommunicationsresearchprojectsundertakeninandoutsideTanzaniawhileherexperienceasamentorhasseenherundertaketrainingassignmentswithorganisationssuchasWorldAssociationofNewspapersandNewsPublishers(WAN-IFRA)forWomeninNewsProgramme;TanzaniaMediaFoundation(TMF),MediaCouncilofTanzania(MCT)andUNWomen,Tanzania.Beforeshiftingintotheacademia,sheworkedasasenioreditorfortheGuardianLimited,aprivatelyownedmediacompany.
7
2017-2018 REPORT
Henry Muhanika HenryMuhanikaisaveteranjournalistwithabackgroundinlibrarianship. He was the Chief Editor with the Tanzania News Agencyinthe1980s.OnleavingGovernmentservice,MuhanikabecamethefirstTanzaniaBureauChiefof‘TheEastAfrican’,aNairobi-basedregionalnewspaper.HelateronlaunchedthePRCommunicationsLtd,apublicrelationsandmediaconsultancycompany.ForthelasteightyearsMuhanikahasbeenservingasExecutiveSecretary of Media Owners Association of Tanzania (MOAT), combininghisdutieswithparttimelecturingatMuslimUniversityofMorogoro(MassCommunicationDept).HehasalsobeenacolumnistforsomelocalEnglishnewspapersandhasauthoredanumberofbooksincluding‘UtenziwaVitavyaKagera’,‘NjiaPanda’and‘KillerDrink’.
Dr Ali UKiDrUki is a lecturer at theZanzibarUniversity andHeadofDepartmentofCommonLaw.HeholdsanLLBfromtheZanzibarUniversity,anLLMfromtheTorinoUniversity,Italy,andaPhDfromtheZanzibarUniversity.HismainareasofinterestareHumanRights,IntellectualPropertyLawandConstitutionalLaw.DrUkihas published over twelve articles in scholarly journals in Tanzania andoutsideTanzania.Heworkedasjournalistfor17yearsfrom1990.DrUkiisamemberofanumberofboardofdirectorsandboardoftrusteesinTanzania.HewasacommissioneroftheLawReviewofZanzibarforsixyearsfrom2012.
8
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
9
2017-2018 REPORT
PART I
TANZANIA
STATE OF THE MEDIA TANZANIA MAINLAND 2017-2018
AUTHORS
Dr. Joyce Bazira
Henry Muhanika
10
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
ABREVIATIONS ACHPR AfricanCharteronHumanandPeoples’
Rights AFEX AfricanFreedomofExpressionExchange AMB AfricaMediaBarometer CoRI CommitteeaswellastheCoalitiononthe
RighttoInformationCommittee EATV East Africa Television ECOPA ElectronicandPostalCommunicationAct FTA Free-to-Air FES FriedrichEbertStiftung FOE FreedomofExpression FGM FemaleGenitalMutilation GBV Gender-BasedViolence ICT InformationandCommunication
Technology ICCPR International Covenant on Civil and
PoliticalRights IJ InvestigativeJournalism ISD InformationServicesDepartment ITU InternationalTelecommunicationsUnion ITV Independent Television JET JournalistsEnvironmentalAssociationof
Tanzania LHRC LegalandHumanRightsCentre Maelezo TanzaniaInformationServices MCT Media Council of Tanzania MISA Media Institute of Southern Africa MISA-TAN Media Institute of Southern Africa-Tanzania
Chapter MOAT Media Owners Association of Tanzania MS Media Services NSS NationalStatisticalSystem RFA Radio Free Africa
11
2017-2018 REPORT
SIDA SwedishInternationalDevelopmentAgency TAMWA TanzaniaAssociationofMediaWomen TASWA Tanzania Sports Association TBC TanzaniaBroadcastingCorporation TCRA TanzaniaCommunicationRegulationAuthority TEF TanzaniaEditorsForum THRDC TanzaniaHumanRightsDefendersCoalition TMF Tanzania Media Foundation TSN Tanzania Standard Newspapers UNESCO UnitedNationsEducational,Scientificand
CulturalOrganisation URT UnitedRepublicofTanzania UTPC UnionofTanzaniaPressClubs UDHR UniversalDeclarationofHumanRights RFA Radio Free Africa
12
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
13
2017-2018 REPORT
Chapter One
Developments in Legal/ Regulatory Framework
1.0 Introduction The chapter looks at major political, legal and regulatory
developments,whichtookplacein2017and2018,payingspecialattentiontotheirimpactonpressfreedom,journalismpracticesandthemediaindustry.Thechapteralsoexplorespoliticaleventsandissuesthattranspiredinthepasttwoyearsandtheirimplications.Itendswithconcludingremarksandrecommendations.
1.1 Legal and Regulatory Framework: Key Issues in 2017 and 2018
Passing of regulations for recently enacted laws ThepassingofregulationsfortherecentlyenactedLawsand
ActamendmentswerethemajordevelopmentsinthelegalandregulatoryframeworkinTanzaniaforthe2017and2018period.TheseincludedMediaServicesAct,2016,AccesstoInformationAct,2016,andElectronicandPostalCommunications(OnlineContent)Regulations,2018,andtheStatisticsAct,2015,Cap315,2018,whichwasamended.Thelaws,whoseimpacttomediaactivitiesandfreedomofexpressionremainsignificant,wereenactedduringthe2015/16period.
1.1.1 Media Service Act, 2016 Regulations, 2017 Media ServicesAct, 2016 regulationswere published in the
GovernmentGazetteinthefirstweekofFebruary2017.Whileaddressingapress conferenceon thisdevelopment, the thenMinisterforInformation,Culture,ArtsandSports,NapeNnauye,pointedoutthatthemovemarkedtheendofenactingcontroversiallaws.
MediastakeholdershadallalongexpressedreservationsaboutthelawonthegroundsthatitcontradictedArticle18oftheUnitedRepublicofTanzaniaConstitution,1977,whichprovidesfreedom
14
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
ofexpressionasafundamentalcivilright.UnderthisConstitution,everypersonhastherighttoseek,receiveandimpartinformationandideasthroughanymediaregardlessoffrontiers(URT,1977).Mediastakeholdershadlookedforwardtoseeingmatterssomehowimprovedthroughtheregulations.Whenthecurtainwasraised,newcomplicationssurfaced.
Underthenewregulations,therearestillanumberofissueswhich are considered contentious. These include accreditation of journalists,mediaownership,newspaperlicensingfees,handlingofGovernmentadvertisementsandthecloutoftheInformationServicesDepartmentdirector.
Onaccreditationofjournalists,theregulationsspecifyadiplomainmediastudiesasaminimumrequirementforajournalisttobeaccreditedinTanzania.Agraceperiodoffiveyears,witheffectfrom1stJanuary,2017,isgiventojournalistswithoutthisbasicqualificationtopursueit.It,however,leavesthequestionswhetherornoteditorsshouldbeuniversitygraduates,andsaysmediaownersshoulddecide(URT2017).
AnothernotableaspectoftheregulationsisonthepoweritgrantstotheDirectoroftheInformationServicesDepartment(ISD),whoisresponsibleforregistrationofprintmediapublicationsinthecountry.Underthelaw,hecanrejectanapplicationwhichdoesnotcomplywiththeprescribedrequirementsforlicensing,andsuspendorcancelalicencewherealicenceefailstocomplywiththeprescribedconditionsofalicence(URT2017).
TheregulationsfurtherstipulatethattheISDdirectorwillbetheGovernmentAdvertisingAgent.ThisrequiresGovernmentministries,departments,agencies,LocalGovernmentAuthoritiesaswellasprojectswithover50percentGovernmentfundingtochanneltheiradvertisementsthroughtheDirectorofInformationServicesDepartmentforsynchronisationbeforebeingpublished(URT2017).
Undertheregulations,theinitiallicensingfeeofanewspaperissetath.Sh1million,renewableannuallyforthesameamount,anditgivestheISDdirectorpowerstoimposeaSh100millionbondtoanyprivateindividualseekingtoestablishaprintinghouseinthecountry(URT2017).
15
2017-2018 REPORT
Implications of the Media Services Act, 2016 Regulations Thereanumberofimplicationsoftheseregulationstojournalists,
journalismpracticeandmediainvestors. Media stakeholders interviewed were of the opinion that the
regulationshavenothelpedtominimisethenegativeimpactoftheMediaServicesAct,2016,asfarasmediafreedomisconcerned.They,forexample,notedthatthepowersoftheISDdirectortosuspendorevencancelanewspaperlicencewithoutreferringadisputetothecourtoflaw,isanobviousthreattomediafreedom.ItisforthisreasonthatsomestakeholdersdecidedtochallengeboththeMediaServicesAct,2016anditsregulationsincourt,whensomeclauseswereusedtosuspendandbansomenewspapersin2017(MCT, 2017).
Thisreport’sfindingsalsoshowthatmediainvestorsarenotcomfortablewiththeideaofdesignatingtheIDSdirectortoserveasGovernmentadvertisingagent,contendingthatthepracticemaybeusedasaweapontopunishmediahousesperceivednottotoethelineofpower-that-bewithregardtocoverageofpoliticalissues.
RespondentsalsonotedthatthepracticeofstateownedmediagettingfirstpriorityinsecuringGovernmentadvertisementshasalwaysbeenacontentiousissue,addingthattheprivatemediaislikelytobeatadisadvantage,asthemalpracticeisnoweffectivelylegalisedunderthenewregulations.
Regardingaccreditation,journalistsinterviewednotedthatthisminimumqualificationhadeasedthetensionwhichexistedwhentheideaofhavingauniversitydegreeasthebasicqualificationfeaturedinthedraftregulations.However,theyfeelthatthisaspectremainsabarrierinjournalismpractice,andthepossibilitythatmany“unqualified”journalistsmightnotmeetthedeadlinestillhauntmany,especiallythosewhohappentobeinthefieldwithoutevenabasiccertificateinjournalism.
1.1.2 Access to Information Act Regulations, 2017 RegulationstoenforceAccesstoInformationActweremadeunder
Section20oftheAccesstoInformationAct,werepublishedintheGovernmentGazetteNo.507of2017on29thDecember2017.(MCT,2018).
16
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
LegalanalystssaidtheseregulationshaveaddressedsomeofthegapsintheAccesstoInformationAct,thusmakinganattempttoincreaseaccesstoandfreeflowofinformation.Howtheytendtoplaythispositiveroleishighlightedintheirperceivedimplicationsbelow.
Journalistsandlegalanalystsinterviewedsaidtheregulationshaveimprovedonsomeprovisionsofthelawbyexpandingthescopeoftheinformationtobeaccessedandtheobligationsofinformationholdersandotheraspectsasfollows:
Areasthathavebeenimprovedincludearegulationwhichprohibitsaninformationholderorofficerfromdemandingthepersonrequestingaccesstoinformationtogivereasonsforsucharequest.ThishasbeentakencareofbyRegulation6andisconsideredabigimprovementontheparentlawwhichdidnotaddresstheissue.
Another area of interest to journalists is the one that requires an informationholderwhoisapublicauthoritytoorganiseapressconferenceonamonthlybasisanddiscloseinformationofpublicinterest.Stakeholdersthoughtthatthroughthisprocedure,outlinedinRegulation10,thepublicwillhaveanopportunitytobeupdatedonvitalinformationonamonthlybasis.
Implications of Access to Information Act Regulations, 2017
Muchassomelawyersandmediastakeholders interviewedcommendtheregulationsforpromotingaccesstoinformation,theystillcriticizedthesameforbeingsilentonfeeswhichtheinformationholdermaychargeaninformationseekertocoveroperationalcosts,anissuewhichmaybeasetbacktoaccessinginformation,especiallyifthechargesareonthehighside.
Anotherissueraisedbysomelawyersisthatsincetheregulationsareinferiortotheparentlaw,someclausesofthelattermaystillbeusedtodefeatthegoodintentionsoftheformer.
InordertoinvestigatehowtheATIlawanditsregulationsareapplicable in practice, in October, 2017, the MCT decided to test theefficacyofthelawbyliningupateamofinformationseekersandsendingitinthefieldtogetinformationfromsomepublicofficesinDaresSalaamaswellasupcountry.AnMCTdocumentreviewedshowthateachinformationseekerintheteamwasgiven
17
2017-2018 REPORT
aquestiontoaskbutwasfreetodesignhis/herlettertobesubmittedtotherelevantmunicipalofficeforforwardingtothetargetedpublicoffice.Theinformationseekersweregivenamaximumof30daystowaitforresponse.Attheendoftheexercise,itwasdiscoveredthatoutof35questionsgiventoDaresSalaaminformationseekers,13werenotsubmitted,implyingthatonly22publicofficeswereaskedforinformation.Andoutof22questionssubmitted,only2gotaresponse.Asforupcountrymunicipal/districtoffices,only4outof10questionssubmittedwererespondedto.
Theconclusionoftheexercisewasthatpublicofficesarestillhesitanttoreleaseinformationtothepublic.Somepublicinformationholderswerequotedassayingthatinformationissupposedtobegiventoinstitutions and not individuals.
The media ownership monitoring case study Anotherincidentshowingaccesstoinformationisstillaproblem
occurredin2018andinvolvedmediaownerswhodeniedordelayedissuinginformationtoateamofresearcherswhowereinvolvedinthe Media Ownership Monitor (MOM) project in Tanzania. MOM wasjointlyimplementedbyMCTandReportersWithoutBorders(RSF),andfundedbytheGermanFederalMinistryofEconomicDevelopmentandCooperation(BMZ)
While undertaking media ownership research in Tanzania,researchers approached targetedmediahouses, gave themaquestionnairetofillandprovideinformationonmediaownership.However,onlythreecompaniesoutofthe21thatwereapproachedrespondedtothequestionnaireintime,whiletherestrespondedafterconstantfollow-upsbyphoneandknockingontheirdoors.
Oneoftheresearchers,DrSamwiluMwaffisi,toldstakeholderswhogatheredtobrainstormonthefindingsthatsomeofthecompanieswhich reluctantly responded to the questionnaire did not answer allthequestionswhileothersleftunnecessarygaps,showingthattheirseriousnessaboutthewholeexerciseleftmuchtobedesired.
MediastakeholdersinterviewedabouttheincidentcategoricallystatedthatthecultureofsecrecyisstillentrenchedinthemindsetofmanyTanzaniansandhastobefoughtfortheAccesstoInformationinitiative to work.
18
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
1.1.3 Electronic and Postal Communications (Online Content) Regulations, 2018.
TheseregulationspublishedbytheGovernmentinMarch,2018,mainlyfocusonregulatingactivitiesundertakenbybloggers,onlineforums,onlinevideoandaudioproducers,aswellassocialmedia.Theregulationshaveattractedpublicdebate,giventhatthey are as controversial as the law itself and perceived to be a threattofreedomofexpression.Theregulationsoutlineanumberofrequirementswhichonlineserviceprovidersmustfulfill.
Theregulationsprohibitonlinecontentserviceprovidersfrompublishingabusivewordscalculatedtooffendanindividualorgrouporfalsecontentwhichislikelytomisleadthepublic.Theyarealsorequiredtousemoderationtoolstofilterprohibitedcontentandaresupposedtohaveinplacemechanismstoidentifysourcesofcontentandensureprohibitedcontentisremoved12hoursuponbeingnotified(UTR,2018). Internetcafésorbusinesscentresarerequiredtoputmechanismsinplacetopreventaccesstoprohibitedcontentandtoinstallsurveillancecamerastorecordand archive activities inside the cafes. They are also directed to haveauserregisterandensureeverypersonusingtheInternetserviceisregistereduponshowingarecognisedidentitycard.Imagesrecordedbysurveillancecamerasandregistersofusersaresupposedtobekeptforperiodoftwelvemonths(URT2018).
Implications of Electronic and Postal Communications (Online Content) Regulations, 2018
Regardingmisleadinginformation,stakeholdersinterviewedwereoftheviewthattheregulationdoesnottakeintoaccounttheintentionofthecontent,whichiswhetheroneintendedtomisleadornotandmayendupprohibitinglegitimatecriticismanddebate.On prohibition of unsuitable contend, they contended that not all serviceproviderscanaffordtobuytheseprotectiveequipment,andmanywillmostlikelyabandonthebusiness.
Highfeesforblogs,websitesandotheronlineserviceproviderswerealsoasourceofconcernformanystakeholders.Undertheregulations,theapplicationfeesforonlineservicesprovisionisSh100,000andtheinitiallicencefeeisSh1million.Stakeholdersthoughtthatsinceblogandwebsiteownerswererequiredto
19
2017-2018 REPORT
register(andpaytheprescribedfees),thiswouldhaveabignegativeimpactononlinedebateasmostoftheblogswhichwouldn’taffordthisfinancialburdenwouldbeforcedtocloseupshop.
The aspect of offences and penalties was considered a noose on the licenceholders’necks.Itisstipulatedintheregulationsthatapersonwhocontravenestheprovisionsoftheregulationscommitsanoffenceandshall,uponconviction,beliabletoafineofnotlessthanSh5millionorimprisonmentforatermofnotlessthan12monthsorboth(URT2018).Lawyerssaidthesepenaltiesareunlimitedandexcessive,addingthatatleastamaximumfineandimprisonmenttermshouldbeprovided.Coupledwiththelackofclarityinkeytermsandthelackofprotectionsforunintentionalbreaches,theseregulationsgiveauthoritieshugepowerstoclosedownonlinespaceforfreedomofexpression(MCT2018).
1.1.4 Electronic and Postal Communications (Radio and Television Broadcasting) Regulations, 2018
Theregulationsareessentiallyabouthowradioandtelevisionbroadcastersshouldoperate,andtheygototheextentofaddressingbroadcastingprofessionalethics.Besidesspecifyingobligationsofpublic,commercialandcommunitybroadcasters,theregulationsalsofocusontherequirementsofcontentprovisionsandguidelinesonissueslikeprotectionofchildren,servicestodisabled,coverageofcourtproceedings,parliamentarysessions,electionsandincidentsof violence are provided.
Undertheregulations,therearealsoguidelinesonhowtohandleadvertisementsandprogrammes.Punishmentforbreachoftheaspectsoftheregulationsisspeltout(URT2018).
Implications of Electronic and Postal Communications (Radio and Television Broadcasting) Regulations, 2018
Somebroadcasterswhowereinterviewedpointedoutthatsomeaspectsoftheregulationscanhelptopromoteprofessionalethics,buttheyhadreservationsonthebreachclausewhichcategoricallystates that a licencee who contravenes any provision of the regulationscommitanoffenceandshall,uponconviction,payafinenotexceedingSh5million.
Aveteranbroadcastercommentedthatlackoflegalself-defenceand
20
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
appealmechanismfortheaccusedisaseriousshortcomingwhichcanleadtovictimisationandcurtailmentofmediafreedom.
Regardingtheconceptsofpublicbroadcasterandcommunitybroadcasterbeinggiventhesamedefinitionsasstipulatedintheregulations,analystsnotedthisconfusioncreateasituationwhereabroadcasterfundedbytheStatecancompetewithtax-payingprivateoperatorsforGovernmentandotheradvertisements.Somerespondents said this is not only unfair, but is a blow to private operatorsanddoesnotencouragegrowthoffreemedia.
OnebroadcastersaidtheregulationshavenotcausedmuchpublicexcitementbecausetheyareanimprovementontheBroadcastingServicesRegulations(2005)whichhavebeenoperationalallalong,addingthatthenewonesaremoreorlessoldwineinanewbottle.
1.2 Amendments of the Statistics Act, 2015 (Cap 351, 2018)
Amendment of the Statistics Act, 2015, was another development in the legal and regulatory framework.
In2018,theGovernmentinitiatedamendmentstotheStatisticsAct,2015whichrespondentsfelthavemadethelawmoredraconianandabighurdleincollectionanddisseminationofstatisticalinformation.Intheamendments“officialstatistics”aredefinedasstatisticsproduced,validated,compiledordisseminatedbyor under the authority of the Tanzania Bureau of Statistics (TBS). ItisstipulatedthattheChiefGovernmentStatisticianshallhavethepowertocommence,varyordiscontinuethecollectionofofficialstatisticsconductedthroughsurveysorcensus,andaperson,GovernmentinstitutionoragencyshallnotauthorisethecommencementofthecollectionofofficialstatisticsthroughsurveysorcensusesexceptwiththeapprovaloftheChiefGovernmentStatistician(URT2018).
UnderSection37oftheamendedlaw,anypersonwhopublishesorcausetobepublishedorcommunicatesanyofficialstatisticsorstatisticalinformationcontrarytotheprovisionsthisActcommitsanoffenceandisliable,onconviction,toafineofnotlessthanSh10millionortonotlessthanthree-yearimprisonmentorboth.Infact,evenapersonauthorisedbytheBureautoprocessanyofficial
21
2017-2018 REPORT
statisticsisnotallowedtopublishorcommunicatesuchinformationtothepublicwithoutauthorisationfromthisagency.Itisalsoanoffencetodisseminateorcommunicatetothepublicanystatisticalinformationwhichisintendedtoinvalidate,distortordiscreditofficialstatistics(URT,2018).
ImplicationsoftheStatisticsAct,2015(Cap351,2018)Amendments Undertheregulations,useofstatisticsinmediareportshasbecome
riskyasoutsourcingthemwronglyormakingmistakesinfiguresisnowcriminal.Alsoitisnolongerpossibletogeneratestoriesfromin-houseoranyothersurveysandopinionpollsexceptthosesanctionedbytheChiefGovernmentStatistician
JournalistsworkingoninvestigativereportswillhaveadifficulttimeinaccessingstatisticaldataasanyofthesameobtainedinthefieldhastobeverifiedbytheChiefGovernmentStatistician.Also,interpretationofGovernmentgeneratedstatisticshasbeenmaderisky,whichisacurtailmentofmediafreedomandfreedomofexpression.
Itwasnotedthatthenegativeimpactofthelawisalreadybeingfelt.OnNovember15,2018,MCTandReportersWithoutBordersannouncedfindingsoftheirjointresearchonMediaOwnershipMonitorinTanzania,inDar-es-Salaam,butgaveacautiontomediastakeholderswhoattendedtheevent.ThecautionwasnothingotherthantellingthejournalistsandwhoeverwantedtosharetheinformationwithothersthatanystatisticalfiguresinthereportshouldnotbedisseminatedbecausetheywerenotyetdeclaredofficialbytheNationalBureauofStatistics(NBS).Hence,journalistshadtoreportthestoryingeneralitiesbyavoidingstatisticscompletely.
Theimplicationofthis,accordingtojournalistsinterviewed,isthatthepublicwillprobablygetdetailedinformationaboutthemediaownershipmonitorprojectafterseveralmonths.SimeonIleta,oneoftherespondentssaidthisamountstogetting“outdatednews”andisunfairtoprofessionalsandmembersofthepublic.
1.3 Political developments and their Implications to press freedom
The5thPhaseGovernmentcametopowerafterthe2015General
22
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
Electionandrightfromthebeginning,PresidentJohnMagufulipronouncedanagendaontakingfastmeasurestobringchangesinvariouspolitical,economic,socialandculturalareas.Sincethen,manysignificantpoliticaldevelopmentshavetakenplaceinthecountry.Someofthesedevelopmentshadsignificantimpactonmediafreedom,rightsandjournalismpractices.Thefollowingarethemostoutstandingoneswhichoccurredin2017/18
1.4 Development as the Agenda of the Media InsomeofthemajorpronouncementsmadebyPresidentMagufuli
duringhisfirstyearinofficeandafter,washisstandthatinapoorcountrylikeTanzania,developmentactivitiesshouldbegivenfirstpriority.Itisforthisreasonthatdebateondevelopment,attractedpublic attention since 2016 and is still in the air to date.
Whilethemediapromotingdevelopmentagendawasandstillissomethingpositive,somepeopleinterviewedclaimedthattheenforcementofthatvisionhadturnedintoanightmare.Intheiropinion,theGovernment,insteadofcomingupwithbeststrategiestocollaboratewiththemediasothattheycanpromotesuchimportantagenda,itusesforce,threats,intimidationandothertacticstoinstillfearwithinthemedia.
TheysaiddevelopmentagendahadbeenpoliticisedtotheextentthatwhoeverraisesavoiceagainstwrongdoingbytheGovernmentincludingthePresidenthimself,isconsideredanenemyofthepeoplewhoisagainstthewellbeingofthenation.Someofmorecriticalmembersoftheoppositionpartiesandsomemediaoutletswhichgivethemaplatformtoairtheirviewsaregroupedinthatcategory.
VictorJoseph,acommunicationanalyst,whoclaimedtohavebeenfollowingcloselyTanzanianpoliticssaidtherearevariousincidentsshowinghowGovernmentinterferewithmediaeditorialautonomyinthenameofdevelopment.HesaidtheincidentwhichoccurredinMarch2017,whenthePresidentpubliclylamentedthatthestoryofWorldBankPresidentYongKim’svisitinTanzaniahadbeenovershadowedbywidereportageonthesackedMinisterofInformation,Culture,ArtsandSports,NapeNnauye,contendingthatthisdemonstratedlackofmediafocusondevelopmentissues,wasamongsuchincidents.
23
2017-2018 REPORT
AnotherincidentoccurredduringtheoccasionofswearinginthenewInformationMinister,afewdaysaftersackingthepreviousone,wherethePresidentpubliclywarnedjournalistsandmediaownersthat they would face dire consequences if they continued to report seditiousinformation.
ExperiencedjournalistsinterviewedpointedoutthatthecommentsbythePresidentweremoreorlessinstructionstotheMinistryofInformationofficialstokeepaclosewatchonthemediaandusethemediaunfriendlylawsinplace,liketheMediaServicesAct,2016todisciplinemediaplatformsinthecountry.
Politicisation of Laws, Regulations and Policies Politicisationoflaws,regulationsandpolicieswasanothermajor
issuethatwaswitnessedinthepasttwoyears.Viewsfrompeopleinterviewed—whopreferredtoremainanonymous—indicatedthatenforcementofsomelawsespeciallythoseenactedrecently,hadbeenpoliticisedforcertainquarters’politicalgain.
TheyelaboratethatlawssuchastheCybercrimeAct,MediaServiceActandtheElectronicandPostalCommunications(OnlineContent)Regulations,allhaveprovisionswhicharevagueandpronetomanipulationandthatauthoritiesstrategicallymanipulatesomeclausestoharass,threatenevenprosecutepeoplecriticisingtheGovernmentanditspolicies.
TheycitedCybercrimeActsayingsinceitcameintooperations,hadbeenusedasatooltocrackdownonpeopletryingtoexposewrongdoingsofGovernmentauthoritiesandtargetedmembersofoppositionparties,humanrightsactivistsandjournalistswhoquestionGovernmentconductandpolicies.
In their view, frequent arrest of opposition leaders, critical journalists andhumanrightsactivists,banningofpoliticalrallies,unwarrantedclosureofmediaoutlets,judicialpersecutionandharassmentofindependent journalists and restrictions on peaceful protests are someoftheconsequencesofpoliticisationstotheselawsandregulations.TheysaidthesamepoliticalgameisusedundertheMediaServiceAct2016andsomeofitsconsequenceshadbeenabusesagainstjournalistsandtheirmediaoutlets.
SomeprovisionsintheElectronicandPostalCommunications(OnlineContent)Regulations,anewlegislationwhichrequires
24
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
allbloggersandpersonsoperatingonlineradioandtelevisionstreamingservicestosecurealicence,arealsosaidtobeusedasamechanismtohindercriticaldebateandpindownthoseusingtheseplatformstoairtheirviews.
Itshouldbenotedthatinrecentyears,socialmediaassumedgreaterimportanceinthecreationanddisseminationofnewsandinformationandtheirpopularityincreasedduetotheirpowerofsharinginformationrapidlywithalargenumbersofpeople.
Socialmediaplatforms’reachandpowertoinfluencearesaidtohaveworriedauthoritiesandinordertosilencethem,leadersofpopularplatformshadalwaysbeenthreatenedandprosecutedundertheCybercrimeAct.However,analystshadalwaysarguedthatsuchthreatsandaccusationshadnolegalfoundationandthatthey were fuelled by political interests.
IndependentmediaanalystBettyMasanjasaidsomepoliticaleventshadnegativeimpactstoindividualjournalists,mediahousesas well as to the industry. She said due to such incidents, violations ofhumanrightsandpressfreedomhaveincreased,makinglivesdifficultforcitizensandjournalists.
TanzaniaHumanRightsReport,2018,indicatedthatin2017(LHRC,2017),thesituationofhumanrightsinTanzaniadeterioratedcomparedtotheyear2016situation,andthatcivilandpoliticalrightsinparticularsufferedmost,withviolationsorrestrictionsofrighttolife,freedomofexpression,freedomofassemblyandrighttolibertyandpersonalsecurityincreasing.
1.5 Press Freedom Violations TheMCT,whichmonitorspressfreedomviolationshasaPress
FreedomViolationsRegisterwherereportedincidentsarereceived,verifiedandrecorded.In2017,83caseswererecorded.Thiswasabadyearasfaraspressfreedomviolationsandfreedomofexpressionisconcerned.Majorviolationswereondenialofaccesstoinformation(18cases)arrestanddetentionofjournalistsbypolice(21cases),harassmentofjournalists(15)andassaultofjournalists (9).
By June2018,MCThad received30 casesofpress freedomviolations,someofwhichhavebeenverifiedandrecorded,while
25
2017-2018 REPORT
otherswerestillunderverification.Theyalsoincludedenialofaccesstoinformation,kidnappings,threatstojournalists,confiscationofequipmentandarrests.
Casesofpressfreedomviolationinbroadcastingmediaarereviewedandcommentedoninthechapteronbroadcastingissueswhilethoserelatedtoprintmediaarealsoaddressedintherelevantchapter.
1.6 Concluding Remarks Thechapterrevisitedmajordevelopmentsinthelegalframework
andpoliticalareainTanzaniaMainland,duringthe2017-2018period,focusingontheirimpacttomediafreedomandfreedomofexpression.Thechapterlookedathowregulationspassedtocompletetheprocessoflegislationsenactedin2015and2016,aswellasamendmentsintheStatisticsAct,2015,curtailedfreedomofexpression.
1.7 Recommendations
This chapter makes the following recommendation: Journalists and Editors should: · Use themedia toraisepublicawarenessaboutpress
freedomissuespubliciseincidentswhichinfringepressfreedomand
· Educatethemselvesonmediarelatedlawsforthepurposeofbeingawareoftheirrightsandresponsibilities
Civilsocietyshould: · Networkonpressfreedomadvocacy; · LobbyParliamentandGovernmenttoamendlawswhich
curtailpressfreedomand · Challengesomeofthebadmedialawsincourt. Mediaownersshould: · Facilitatein-housetrainingonmediarelatedlaws; · Challengesomeof lawsandpress freedomviolation
incidents in court and · Takemeasurestoprotectjournalistsinthecourseoftheir
work. TheGovernmentShould: · Opendoorstoreceivecomplaintsaboutcontroversial
26
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
medialawsandmakeamendmentswherenecessaryand. · Takemeasurestorestrainpoliceandothersecurityofficers
who,insomecases,harassjournalistsandhumanrightsdefenders.
References LHRC(2017)TanzaniaHumanRightsReport,LegalandHuman
RightsCentre,DaresSalaam,Tanzania LHRC(2018)TanzaniaHumanaRightsReport(Jan–June2018),
LegalandHumanRightsCentre,DaresSalaam,Tanzania MCT(2018)AnalysisofAccesstoinformationAct2016,Regulations
(2017)DaresSalaam.Tanzania MCT(2018)AnalysisofElectronicandPostalCommunications
(OnlineContent)Regulations,DaresSalaam,Tanzania MCT(2018)LegalOpiniononFiveTVStationsFinedbyTCRA,
DaresSalaam,Tanzania MCT(2017)PressFreedomViolationsRegisterReport,Dares
Salaam,Tanzania MCT(2018)PressFreedomViolationsRegisterReport(Jan–June
2018),DaresSalaam,Tanzania RSF (2018) Media Ownership Monitor (Tanzania) Report, Media
CouncilofTanzaniaandReporterswithoutBorders,DaresSalaam,Tanzania
URT(1977)ConstitutionoftheUnitedRepublicofTanzaniaof1977,DaresSalaam,Tanzania
URT(2018)ElectronicandPostalCommunications(RadioandTelevisionBroadcastingContent)Regulations,DaresSalaam,Tanzania
URT(2017)MediaServicesAct,2016Regulations(2017)DaresSalaam,Tanzania
URT(2018)AmendmentsoftheStatisticsAct2015,Cap.351,2018,DaresSalaam,Tanzania
URT (2018)ElectronicsandPostalCommunications (OnlineContent)Regulations(2018),DaresSalaam,Tanzania
27
2017-2018 REPORT
Chapter Two
Current Trends in the Print Media
2.0 Introduction This chapter looked at the trend of printmedia industry in
TanzaniaMainlandin2017/18.Printmediaincludesnewspapers,journals,magazines,newslettersandanyotherrelatedpublicationsintendedformassconsumption.However,thechapterfocusedonlyonnewspapersandmagazines.Itspecificallylookedatkeyissues which transpired in the industry in 2017 and 2018 such as deregistrationofnewspapers,theirpenetration,ownershipaswellas issues that raised sustainability concerns in the industry. The chapteralsolookedatthelegalframeworkguidingtheindustrybeforehighlightingincidentsofviolence,threatsandintimidationtoprintmediajournalistsandnewspaperoutlets.Thechapterendswithaconclusionandrecommendations.
2.2 Current Status of Print Media in Tanzania In thepast twoyears, theprintmedia inTanzaniaMainland
progressedincertainareas,butlostgroundinothers.Therewerenotabledevelopmentsinthesectorthatareworthnoting.Thesectorwhich was reported to have been shaken up in the previous years,continuedtorebuilditselfinanefforttoregainitspositionasthecomprehensiveandmosttrustedcommunicationchannel.Whilestrivingtorejuvenate,theindustryfacedalotofchallengesincludingoperatingunderaverytensepoliticalatmospherewithrestrictive laws.
2.3 Newspapers Ordered to Re-register, No Licence, No Permission to Operate
Governmentdirectivetore-registerallnewspapersandmagazinesoperatinginthecountrywasoneoftheexercisesstartledproprietors.Theywereleftwithonlytwochoices:toeitherfulfillGovernmentre-registrationsrequirementsorclosedownbusiness.RegistrationprocesswasdoneincompliancewiththeMediaServiceAct,2016,anditsregulations.In2017,Governmentintroducedregulations
28
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
implementingtheactthatrevisedtherequirementsforregisteringprintmedia.Accordingtotheregulation,allnewspapers,journals,newslettersandmagazinesthatareproducedinthecountrywereregistered.Undertheregulation,allprintmediaproductswererequiredtoregisterbyOctober15,2017.(URT,2017)
Re-registrationannouncementwasmadeonAugust23,2017andmediaorganisationsweregivenuntilOctober15,2017tocompletetheprocessofre-registration.However,thedeadlinewasextendedtoOctober31,2017inanefforttoenablemorepublisherstocomply.
DirectorGeneralofTanzaniaInformationServices(Maelezo)andChiefGovernmentspokesperson,DrHassanAbbas,wasquotedbythemedia(Kolumbia,2017)assayingthat,beyondthedeadline,anypublicationthatwouldnothavefinalisedtheprocedureswouldnotbeallowedtooperate.UntilOctober31,2017,adatesetasadeadlineforregistration,atotalnumberof109newspapershadbeenregisteredand85outofthe109,werere-licencedtocontinuewithoperationswhiletheother24werenewlylicensed.
ThefirstlicensingphasetargetednewspapersthatpossessedlicencesbeforeenforcementoftheMediaServiceslaw(ParliamentaryActNumber12of2016)andrespectiveregulations,buttheGovernmentcontinuedtoregisternewpublications.
DrAbbasfurthersaidthataftercompletingthefirstphaseofregistrationandlicensingofnewspapers,unlicensedinstitutionswereprohibitedtoissuepublicationsuntiltheycomplied.Hewarnedthatanyonepublishinganewspaper, journaloranyotherpublicationwithoutalicenceorspecialpermissiontodoso,commitsacriminaloffence.
AccordingtoSection50(2)(a)oftheMediaServicesAct(2016),apersonfoundguiltyofthesaidoffenceisliabletoapecuniaryfineofbetweenSh5millionandSh10million,a3to5-yearjailsentence—orboth(URT,2016).
The2017registrationshake-upwasnotthefirstintherecenthistoryoftheprintmediainTanzania.In2016,theGovernmentdecidedtocancelregistrationofmorethan400newspapersandmagazines,thereby,reducingthenumberofpublicationsoperatinglegallyinthecountry’smarket,byover50percent.Bazira&Uki,(2017)
29
2017-2018 REPORT
The Shake-up Which Stripped away registrations of 473 publications was carried out in June 2016.
According to the Government Notice No.195 published inGovernmentGazettedatedJune10,2016,SupplementNo.23,thecancellationwascarriedoutincompliancewiththeprovisionsofSection23(1)oftheNewspapersAct,1976,aprovisionwhichindicated clearly that itwas against the law for a registerednewspaper/magazinenottopublishforthreeconsecutiveyears.TheActstipulatesthatwhenapublicationisderegistered,itcannotbepublishedordistributedthroughhardcopyorelectronicallyuntiltheownersubmitsafreshapplicationforregistrationandgetalicence.(URT,1976)
2.4 Just Few Proprietors Still Dominate Newspaper Landscape
Just like in the previous years, in 2017/18, newspapers landscape continuedtobediversewithnumerouspublicationshittingthenewsstandsondaily,weeklyandmonthly(forjustafew)basis.Ownersincludedindividuals,privatecompanies,Governmentandpolitical parties, with control concentrated in the hands of a few proprietors.
Threemonthsinvestigativeresearch,titled,’’TheMediaOwnershipMonitor (MOM)’’ jointly carried out by the Media Council of Tanzania (MCT) and Reporters Without Borders (RSF), indicated that the printmediamarket in Tanzaniawas dominated byMwananchiCommunicationsLimited(MCL),asubsidiaryoftheNationMediaGroup(NMG).MCLisbyfarthemostdominantmarketplayerintermsofreadership.NMG,apubliclistedcompanywhosemajorityshareholderistheAgaKhanDevelopmentFund,has its headquarters in Nairobi.
Otherproprietorsare;theIPPMedia,aprivateenterpriseownedbyabusinessman,Dr.ReginaldMengi,NewHabari(2006)Ltd,associatedwiththepoliticianandbusinessmanRostamAzizandthestate-runTanzaniaStandardNewspapers–TSN(RSF,2018).
SomepublicationssuchasUhuruandTanzaniaDaimaareownedbypoliticalparties.According(RSF,2018),UhuruisownedbytherulingpartyCCMandrunbyUhuruMediaGroup,whileTanzaniaDaimaisassociatedwiththechairmanofTanzania’s
30
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
leadingoppositionparty,Chadema,FreemanMbowe,throughhiswife,whoisthemajorityshareholderofFreeMediaLimited.KiongoziandTumainiLetunewspapersareownedbyreligiousorganisations.
Someveteranjournalistsandmediaanalystsinterviewedontheimplicationsofthiskindofownershipexpressedtheviewthatsuchasituationwasunhealthyintermsofcontentdiversityandthatitcontradictedthewholeconceptofmediapluralismanditsbenefitstodemocraticprocesses.
BettyMasanja,amediaanalyst,saidthatmediacrossownershipgivesaroomformediaownerswiththeirpersonalagendaincludingpoliticalrelatedtomanipulatethecontentoftheiroutletstosuittheirowninterests,somethingwhichisdangerousfornationalsecurityandstability.ThisviewwassupportedbyIbrahimKisinja,anindependentresearcherworkingwiththeIntegrityWatch.
InMasanja`sview,whoeverownsthemediahaspowerandcontrolofthecontentproduced,therefore,byhavingonlyafewpeopledominatingthenewspapermarketmeansallowingopinionsofTanzania’spopulationofmorethan54milliontocontinuebeinginfluencedbyafewpeople.
However,anothermediaanalyst,RamadhaniKabale,wasnotagainstmediacrossownership,althoughhesuggestedthatthereshouldbeamechanismtoensuresuchownersusetheirmediaoutlets for the purpose stipulated in editorial policies.
Hewasalsooftheviewthatstrictmeasuresshouldbeputinplacetoensuresuchownersdonotinterfereormanipulateeditorialworkto suit their personal interests. This view was also shared by Alpha Nuhu, a veteran journalist at the Daily News who thinks editorial workshouldbeleftinhandsofprofessionalsandproprietorsmustnot interfere.
In2017/18,newspaperspublishedinKiswahili,thelanguagewidelyspokenandunderstoodbymostTanzanians,continuedtodominate themarket.Kiswahilinewspapers comprisedawiderrangeoftitlesforreaderstochoosewhileEnglishlanguagepublicationswereseenastargetingtheeliteclass.
31
2017-2018 REPORT
2.5 Newspapers Sustainability Issues
2.5.1 Newspapers in Progress to Re-conquer the Market, Regain Position
In2017/18,therewerenotabledevelopmentsintheprintsectorwhichareworthnoting.Thefirstdevelopmentwasthat,thesectorwhich was reported to have been shaken up in the previous years followingdeclineinreadershipandadvertisingrevenue,inthetwoyears,continuedtorebuilditselfinanefforttoregainitspositionasthecomprehensiveandmosttrustedcommunicationchannel.
Variousnewspaperoutletscontinuedtomoveoutofthetraditionalnewsgathering and dissemination styles by adopting onlineapproaches.Thisshiftwasaresponsetoconsumers`newwayofnewsconsumptionwhichcausestheneedforpublisherstocreatecontentinawaythatmakesitusableacrossdifferentplatforms.
Somejournalistsandcommunicationstakeholdersinterviewedmentionedintegrationoftheirnewsroomstoconformtodigitalrequirements,comingupwithonlineversionofthenewspapersandlaunchingappstargetingdifferentmarketstoensureprovisionsofwhatconsumersare lookingfor,assteps takenduringthetransformationprocess.
SomejournalistswhocommentedonthisincludedPeterNyanje,NewsEditor for Financial Times, SalomeKitomary, a seniorjournalistforNipashe,GodfreyIsmaely,editorforMajiranewspaperandNancymonaIjumba,aCommunicationlectureratSt.AugustineUniversityofTanzania.
RamadhaniKabale,aseasonedjournalistwithTanzaniaBroadcastingCorporation(TBC),narratedseriouschallengestheprintmediahasbeenfacinginrecentyears,andconcludedthat,theindustryisnotoffthehookyetandifurgentmeasuresarenottaken,manypublications would be out of business in not a distant future.
2.5.2 Restrictive Laws an Obstacle to Newspapers Sustainability
Besidestheabovedevelopment,in2017/18,printmediainTanzaniacontinuedtofaceanumberofchallengesjustasithadbeenthecasein2016/17.Thesechallengesincludedshrinkinginadvertisementsrevenue,poordistribution,thegrowinguseofsocialnetworking
32
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
platformsascommunicationchannelsaswellasunfriendlylawsandregulations,achallengewhichwasperhapsthemajorobstacleforprintmedia`ssustainabilityinTanzaniainthetwoyears.
The Government trend of banning newspapers accused ofnotcomplyingwith the lawplus intimidationof journalists,prosecutionandharassment,weresomeoftheaspectswitnessedin the two years which raised sustainability concern to journalists, newspapers proprietors as well as to those who aspired to venture into the business.
Thefollowingsectionhighlightsincidentsofdisappearance/kidnapping,violence, threats, intimidation, interferencewitheditorialfreedomanddenialofaccesstoinformationtoprintjournalists in the last two years.
2.6 Journalists Abused, Clamp Down on Outlets…the List is Long
2.6.1 Incidents of Abuses against Print Journalists Several incidents of abuses were reported across Tanzania and
documentedinvariousreportsincluding(MCT,2017;MCT,2018;LHRC,2017;LHRC,2018;HumanRightsWatch,2017,HumanRightsWatch,2018,AmnestyInternational,2017,FreedomHouse,2018)
OnMarch25,2017duringtheswearinginceremonyofnewMinisterof Information,Culture,ArtandSports,PresidentMagufuliexpressedhisdispleasurewiththewaymediaoutletsaccordedweighttostorieshesaidwerenotimportant.ThePresidentwarnedthemediaownersagainstthinkingthattheywerefreetopublishanythingtheywished.Hewasquotedsaying,``Youarenotthatfree.Watchit!’’Hedirectedtheministertoensurethattheneedfulisdonetoreigninnewsoutlets.Thiswasintimidationandamovetointerferewitheditorialfreedom.
Fourprintjournalists;ZephaniaUbwani(TheCitizen),FilbertRweyemamu (Mwananchi), JanethMushi (Mtanzania) andElihurumaYohane(TanzaniaDaima)werearbitrarilyarrestedbypoliceandlaterreleasedwhencoveringastoryaboutthetragicaccidentinvolvingpupilsofSt.LuckyVincentPrimarySchoolinArusha
33
2017-2018 REPORT
InMarch2017,itwasreportedthatArushaDistrictCommissioner,AlexanderMnyeti,threatenedthosewhowerecoveringaDistrictCouncilmeetingbytellingthemthathewouldorderthepolicetobeatthemup.
OnApril22,2017,journalistsandtheirnewspapersinbrackets;MaryGeoffrey(Nipashe),AshaBahi(Mtanzania),MariamMziwanda(Uhuru),KalundeJamal(Mwananchi)andHenryMwang`onde(TheGuardian)wereambushedbyagroupofpeoplewearingmasksandarmedwithmachetesduringameetingorganisedbyoppositionparty,CivicUnitedFront(CUF).Somejournalistswereinjuredwhiletheirworkingequipmentincludingcameras,gotdamaged.
Mtanzanianewspaperreporter,RamadhaniHassan,wasarrestedandtakentoDodomaCentralPoliceStationforquestioningafterhetookpicturesofcontroversialsceneinvolvingtrafficpoliceofficers.He was detained for three hours and all the pictures he took of the incident were forcibly deleted.
Ajournalistworkingforthesportandentertainmenttabloid,Champion,MusaMateja,waspreventedfromusinghiscamerawhile coveringaConfederationCup footballmatchbetweenSegradaEsperancaandYoungAfricans.ThereporterwhowastheonlyjournalistthathadtravelledwithYoungAfricanTeamtocoverthematchwasdeniedaccesstothefootballgroundbytheleadersof Esperance
OnJuly3,2017IbrahimYamola(TanzaniaDaima)andAzizaMasoud(Mtanzania)wereinterrogatedbypoliceondetailsofapressconferencetheyhadattended.Theconferencewasorganisedbytopleadersofanoppositionparty,Chadema
TanzaniaDaimajournalist,SittaTuma,wasbeatenaftertakingphotographsatapoliticalrallyinMaraRegion
OnNovember21,2017EdithaEdward(HabariLeo),RehemaMatowo (Mwananchi) were assaulted, harassed and threatened by policeaftercoveringriotsataschoolwherepolicewereaccusedofgivingahandtoteacherswhowereallegedlyassaultingstudents.
AreporterfromMwananchiwasapproachedbypeoplewhoclaimedtocomefromDisasterManagementDepartmentandtookawayhisequipmentashewasinterviewingfamilymembersof11peoplewhohadreportedlydiedaftereatingpoisonousmushrooms
34
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
inKilindiDistrict,TangaRegion TheeditorofMawionewspaperreceivedphonecallsthreatening
himafteranarticle linking two formerpresidentsBenjaminMkapaandJakayaKikwetetocontroversialminingcontracts,waspublished by the newspaper. Mkapa was a Third Phase President whileKikwetetookafterhim)
Ajournalistfromaweeklytabloid,SautiHuru,BollenPeterNgettiwaschargedincourtunderCyberCrimesAct,2015forpublishingallegedlyseditiousinformation“whichcouldbringthePresidentintocontempt”.
AnotheralarmingincidenttookplaceinNovember2017whenaMCLjournalist,AzoryGwanda,wasreportedmissingbyhisfamilyinKibitiDistrict,CoastRegion.Hehasnotbeenseensince,deadoralive.Beforehisdisappearance,GwandahadinvestigatedaseriesofmurderstargetingpoliceandlocalofficialsintheCoastRegion.
OnJanuary16,2018,PendoFundisha,ajournalistworkingforMtanzanianewspaperwasdeniedtherighttoperformherdutiesbypoliceofficerswho,aftersnoopingintowhatshewaswritingusingacomputeratthePostOfficeInternetcaféinMbeya,orderedhernottofilethestory.
OnJanuary17,2018,15journalistswhowerehostingadinnerforvisitinginformationofficersfromtheUSEmbassywereambushedbypoliceonthegroundsthatthey(police)hadreceivedintelligencereportsallegingthatoneofjournalistswasdesigningflyersforacertain opposition party
SharonSauwa,ajournalistworkingforMwananchiCommunicationsLtd,wasonFebruary22,2018interrogatedbypoliceforallegedcybercrimes.Ithasyettobeknownwhatshewasbeingaccusedof but police seized her phones.
OnJune4,2018,journalistofMtanzanianewspaper,DerickMiltonwasthrownoutofMeatuDistrictCourtwhenmakingafollow-upofacaseinvolvingasecondaryschoolteacherwhowasaccusedofsexualmolestationofhisstudent
OnAugust8,2018,ajournalistwithTanzaniaDaimawasbrutallyharassedbypoliceofficersinTurwaWard,TarimeDistrictinMaraRegion,afterhewasarrestedwhilecoveringacampaignrally.Hestayedincustodyuntilthefollowingday.
35
2017-2018 REPORT
OnOctober9,2018,FridaySimbayawhoworksforTheGuardianwasarrestedbyTCRAofficersduetoreasonsthatarenotyetclear.HewasarrestedinIringaandtransferredtoDaresSalaamwhereafileonhimwasopened.
SuleimanAbeid fromMajiranewspaperwas thrownout byShinyanga Regional Police Commander SimonHaulewhencollectinginformationaboutwaterproblemsfromShuwasa,aGovernmentagencythatisinchargeofwatersupplyandsanitationintheregion.
Besidesincidentsagainstindividualjournalists,in2017/18,severalcasesofnewspaperbanning,suspensionandbeingthreatswerereportedacrossTanzaniaanddocumentedinvariousreports.Thefollowingsectionhighlightssuchcases.
2.7 Incidents of Newspaper Suspensions and Banning SeveralincidentswerereportedacrossTanzaniaanddocumented
invariousreports,including(MCT,2017;MCT,2018;LHRC,2017;LHRC,2018;HumanRightsWatch,2017,HumanRightsWatch,2018,AmnestyInternational,2017,FreedomHouse,2018)
On15June,theInformation,SportsandCultureMinisterbannedMawionewspaperfortwoyearsoverarticlesitpublishedlinkingtwoformerpresidentswithallegedimproprietiesinminingdealssignedinthe1990sandearly2000s.
On19September,theInformationServicesDepartment(ISD)slappedatwo-yearbanonMwanaHalisinewspaperitaccusingof insulting the President and publishing unethical stories“endangeringnationalsecurity”foranarticlecallingforprayersforTunduLissu,anoppositionpartymember.Thiswasthesecondtimethenewspaperhadbeensuspendedinthreemonths.
InSeptember,theDirectorforInformationServices,announcedabanofanothernewspaper,RaiaMwema,whichwasbeingaccusedofpublishinganarticletitled,`UraisutamshindaRaisMagufuli’(Kiswahilifor‘Magufulipresidencywaslikelytofail’)containing“misquotations”ofthePresident.Thebanlasted90days.
On22October2017,TanzaniaDaimawasbannedfor90daysforwhatwasdescribedbytheDirectorofInformationServicesasacontinuouspublicationoffalseinformation.AccordingtotheletterfromGovernment,thesuspensionwasimposedbecauseofthe
36
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
newspaper`strendtopublishunethical,falseandseditiousnewsandfeatureswhichbroughtfearandhatredamongstmembersofthe public
InOctober,authoritiesbannedRaiaMwema,aweeklynewspaper,for 90days forpublishinganarticle alleged tobedeceitful,seditiousandendangeringnationalsecurityanddeemedcriticalofMagufuli’spresidency.
InMarch2017,theHighCourtofTanzaniadeliveredajudgmentinfavourofthenewspapersfollowingapermanentbanissuedinJanuary2016,whichleadthenewspapertofileapetitioninMarch2016
Theaboveincidents,whichtoalargeextentwerefacilitatedbymedialawsandregulations,areatestimonyofthenegativeimpacttheyhadtoindividualjournalists,printmediaorganisationsandtothegeneralpublic.
Thefollowingsectionwillhighlighttheimplicationsoftheselaws,especially on how they contributed to the current status of self-censorship,whichultimatelyheldbackeffectiveandopenpublicdebate,aspectswhicharecentraltodemocraticdevelopment.
2.8 Status of Self-censorship and Chill in Coverage of Some Stories
2.8.1 Restrictive Laws Trigger Fear, Journalists Opt for Self-censorship
EnforcementoftherecentenactedlawssuchastheCyberCrimeAct,2015,MediaServiceAct,2016,StatisticsAct,2015andtherecentpiecesoflegislation,ElectronicandPostalCommunications(OnlineContent)Regulations2018,justlikeitwasexpectedbymediastakeholdersandhumanrightsdefenders,hadchilleffectsonjournalists,theentireindustryaswellastothegeneralpublic.
Reportsreviewed(LHRC,2017;LHRC,2018;HumanRightsWatch,2017,HumanRightsWatch,2018,AmnestyInternational,2017,FreedomHouse,2018)andopinionsfromrespondents,indicateclearlyhowin2017/18,unfriendlylegalframeworktogetherwithatensepoliticalatmosphereunderFifthPhaseGovernment,managedtosilencemanyjournalistsandtheirsourceswho,duetofearofprosecutionorheavyfines,optedforself-censorship.
37
2017-2018 REPORT
It was revealed that self-censorship was practiced by journalists andeditorsinbothprivateandpublicmediawhencoveringstoriesconcerningGovernmentleadersandpolicies.Forthatreason,thetrendofself-censorshipwasonasharprisetotheextentofalarmingmediastakeholdersandhumanrightsdefendersfrominandoutsideof Tanzania. (ibid).
BettyMasanja,amediaanalystwhoisalsoalawyer,said“Someprovisions under the Media Service Act, had always been manipulatedbyauthoritiesandusedtopunishorsilencejournalists“makingnoises”orthosecriticaltotheGovernment.”
Suchprovisionsincludethosegivingtheministerresponsibleforinformationthediscretionalpowertoprohibitimportationofpublications,punishjournalistsandmediaoutlets,controlovercontentandSection16oftheCyberCrimeActwhichpenalisesanyperson who intentionally and unlawfully receives unauthorised information,
OnepartofthelawblamedbymanycriticsisSection16,whichsaysthatpublishingfalseormisleadinginformationwaspunishablebyatleastsixmonthsinprisonasindicatedbelow:
“Anypersonwhopublishesinformation,dataorfactspresentedinapicture,text,symboloranyotherforminacomputersystemwheresuchinformation,dataorfactisfalse,deceptive,misleadingorinaccuratecommitsanoffence,andshallonconvictionbeliabletoafinenotlessthanthreemillionshillingsortoimprisonmentforatermnotlessthansixmonthsortoboth.“(TheCybercrimeAct(16),2015)
Commentingontheclampingdownofcriticalnewspapers,SalomeKitomary,chairpersonfortheMediaInstituteinSouthernAfrica,Tanzania Chapter (Misa-Tan), said in 2017/18, this trend worsened thesituationtotheextentthatsomenewspaperoutletowners,tosavetheirpublicationsfrombeingsuspendedorbanned,decidedtoplayitsafebyfocusingonneutralstoriesratherthanarticlescriticaloftheGovernmentanditspolicies.
``Somemediaoutletshavebeeneatenupbythe``angrylaw;”andothershavegonequieter–puttingasidestoriestheyperceiveunpleasanttoGovernmentorgoingfullyintofrivolityunlikelytoraisetempers,’’commentedNdimaraTegambwagwe,oneofmediagurusinTanzania.Headdedthat,duetothesamereason,
38
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
newpractitionersarefearfulofcommittingerrorswhilesomeoldjournalistsareheardsaying“Ihaveafamily,whyrisk?”
2.8.2 Tough Laws Fuelled Self -Censorship, Ethical Violations
EnforcementofStatisticsAct,2015,thelawwhichmakesanoffencethepublicationofstatisticalinformationpriortoapprovalbytheNationalBureauofStatistics(NBS),wasalsoblamedforcontributingtothecurrentstatusofcensorshipintheprintmediain Tanzania.
AccordingtoSection37(5)oftheAct,anyagencyorpersonwhopublishesorcommunicatesofficialstatisticalinformationwhichmayresultinthedisinformationoffacts,commitsanoffenceandthisispunishablebyafineorimprisonmentoflessthanthreeyearsorboth(URT,2018).
Tegambwagwe,who isalsoamedia trainer in InvestigativeJournalismsaidstatisticslawdoesnotexpresslybarjournalistsoranyonefromcollectingorgeneratingstatisticalinformation,butitisthe National Bureau of Statistics (NBS) only, which is entitled to set standards for the collection, analysis and publication of statistics to ensureuniformityinquality,adequacyofcoverageandreliabilityofstatisticalinformation.
Explainingwhythislawscaresjournalists,Tegambwagwesaid:``Investigationbymediaisbyitself,research,andcouldgeneratestatisticalinformationthroughthesameordifferentmethodsandmaybewithdifferentresultsandfordifferentpurpose.Theresults,however,donotconstituteofficialstatistics.Herenon-officialstatisticsmaynotnecessarilytallywithofficialstatistics;andifyourstorywasaimedatfact-checkingorchallengingofficialstatisticsorstatisticalinformation,thenyouwillbeinforit.”
Putinsimplewords,itmeansthatifjournalistsfindingsdonottallywithofficialstatistics,ajournalistsconcernedwouldbeintroubleforbreachingthelaw.
Commentingonthat,Kitomary,whoisalsoaninvestigativejournalist,said,thecurrenttrendisthreateningthequalityreportinginthecountrybecausemanyjournalistsarescaredofwritingindepthstoriessupportedbyfigures.Shesaiddatajournalismisthemostaffectedareasinceitsapproachheavilydependsonfigures
39
2017-2018 REPORT
and statistics to tell a story. ``Whetherjournalistsarescaredbecausetheylackenoughknowledge
ontheActorareduetostrictmeasuresstipulatedinthelaw,whatisclearisthat,manyjournalistshavegonebacktothecoverageofstorieswithmanyopinionswithoutfigurestocomplementtheirfacts,’’concludedKitomary,addingthat,thelawhadalsoelicitedfearonsourcesofinformation,whoarealsoreluctanttoprovidefiguresduetothesamereason.
SomecriticswhorequestedtoremainanonymousfeltthattoprohibitpeoplefromqueryingordiscussingstatisticalinformationthatiscontradictoryisnothingshortofcensorshipandpartofabroaderGovernmentcrackdownondissentandcriticismofitspoliticalandeconomicrecord.
Amajorquestionraisedis:“WhyshouldpeoplebeprohibitedfromdiscussingorcastdoubtonstatisticalinformationtheGovernmentoranyofitsassociatedorganisationspublish,ifitisgenuinewithwhatitpublishesanditsstatisticsarefactual?”
Intheirview,thereisanagendabehind,otherwise,itwouldhavewelcomedindependentstatisticiansandresearchers,whosefindings,helptheGovernmentinitsdevelopmentstrategicplanning.
InresponsetocriticismagainsttheStatisticsAct,theGovernmentinsists that the Act was enacted in order to establish and coordinate theNationalStatisticalSystem(NSS)inTanzaniaandwasamendedforthepurposeofcoordinationofdisseminationofstatisticalinformationinordertoavoidconflictingstatisticswithinnationalstatisticalsystem.ItalsodeniedthereisanyprohibitionofpublicdebateofpolicyanditsoutcomesorinterferencewitharticlesoftheConstitutionsuchasfreedomofexpression.
Anotherlawwhoseenforcementcontributedtothecurrentstatusofself-censorshipwastheAccesstoInformationAct(ATI)of2016.RespondentsclaimedthatthislawwhichcameintoforceinJuly,2017,encouragedcensorshipespeciallyforsourcesofinformation.
A study carried out by Misa-Tan, in collaboration with CIPESA, cameupwiththefindingthattherewasaprevailingcultureofsecrecyamongpublicofficialsatbothcentralandlocalGovernmentlevels.
ThesurveywhichassessedtheresponsivenessofLocalGovernment
40
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
Authorities(LGAs)andCentralGovernmentofficesinTanzaniatocitizens’informationrequestsrevealedthat,thisculturehindersjournalists from accessing information necessary formediareportingtowardsincreasedcivilparticipation,transparencyandaccountabilityingovernance.Thestudycoveredsevenregions,withatotalof28informationrequestsfiledto14institutionsduringMarch and April 2017.
AccesstoInformation(ATI)stakeholders,inoneoftheforumsexpressedtheirconcernabouttheprevailingsituation.Theysaid,thisbehaviourultimatelyaffectedthegeneralpublicthatcomprisestheconsumersofmediacontent.
In their view, the law also increased the culture of secrecy. They saidsomesourcesespeciallypublicofficials,deliberatelyorduetoignoranceofthelaw,furtherdisplayedthetendencyofconcealingsomeinformationfromjournalistsondifferentgrounds,andthat,thisautomaticallyaffectedtheworkofjournalistsinTanzania.
Inthesameforum,theGovernmentthroughtheDirectorGeneralof Tanzania Information Services (Maelezo) and the ChiefGovernmentspokesperson,DrHassanAbbas,admittedthattherewaswidespreadlaxityamongofficialsinhandlingandprocessinginformationrequests,poorcustomercare,lackofknowledgeoftheAccesstoInformationLawandreluctanceofStateofficialstosharepublicinformation.
ExperiencessharedduringtheforumbyvariousjournalistsandATIstakeholdersindicatedthattheacthadcomplicatedtheirworkwhenitcametogettinginformationfromGovernmentsources.
``Oneofthecriteriaofaqualitynewsarticleistohavediversesourcesfromdifferentcategoriesincludingpublicauthorities;however,thesedaysitisverydifficulttogetauthoritiestocommentevenwhenthechapterisstraightforward,’’notedonejournalist.
GaudenciaMngumi,whowasonaTanzaniaMediaFoundation(TMF)fellowshipin2018,explainedhowhermanyattemptstoreachsomeofficialsindifferentpublicinstitutionstocommentonher analytical story failed.
Citinganexample,shesaid,afterattemptingseveraltimestogetsomeoneinapositionofauthoritytocommentonherarticle,andtheeditorthreateningnottopublishituntilGovernmentauthoritysourcesgavetheirsideofthestory,sheendedupquotingdocument
41
2017-2018 REPORT
sources. Mngumi’sfrustrationsweresharedbyanumberofjournalists
interviewed,whoexplainedhowinthepasttwoyears,publicauthoritysourceshadbeenverydifficulttoreach.
Somerespondentsgenerally think that the tendency todenyjournalistsinformation,besidesunderminingmedia`scredibilityandencouragingunethicalconductamongmediaprofessionals,italsohinderedpeople`srighttoreceiveinformationrelevanttotheirlives.
2.9 Introduction of Fees for Online Newspapers
2.9.1 High Fees Forced Existing Online Outlets Close Down Therecentpiecesoflegislation,ElectronicandPostalCommunications
(OnlineContent)Regulations2018,alsoaffectedtheprintmediaorganisationsandjournalists.ThisregulationwhichwaspassedbytheNationalAssemblyinSeptember,2017,andsignedintolawinMarch2018,hadmanyareasofcontention,butthemajoronesincludeditsdemandforallonlinecontentserviceproviderstoregisterandpayoverUS$900,whichismorethanSh2millionperyear, to publish online content.
Theintroductionfees,besidescreatingbarriersforpotentialnewmarketplayers,forcedexistingonlineoutletsoutofbusinessasmostofthemcouldnotmeettherequirementoftheregulationandpay the fees.
OthergroupsaffectedbyenforcementofElectronicandPostalCommunications(OnlineContent)Regulations2018weresomeprintjournalistsowningorcontributingarticlesorothermaterialstoonlineforums.
Somejournalistsadmittedthatduetorestrictivesituation,traditionalnewspapers operate in, they either established their own online forumsorcontributeanalyticalarticlestoonlineplatformsusingpseudonyms,andthatthedirectivetoregisterandpayacertainamountofmoneywasablowtothem.
Theyalsoexplainedhowonlineplatformsenabledforumsownedbywritersandindependentjournaliststobecomepowerfulintermsof reach and readership.
GodfreyIsmaelyisoneofthejournalistswhowereaffectedby
42
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
registrationofonlinemediadirective.Hesaidthatduetothehighfeesimposed,hewasunabletoregisterhisblogwhichwaswellestablishedandalreadypopulardueitsinsightfulcoverageofsocial,politicalandeconomicissues
Generally,stakeholdersfeelstronglythatenforcementoftheserestrictivelawshadcontinuedtojeopardisefreedomofexpressionandrightsofpeopletoaccessinformationandexpresstheirviews,somethingwhichhadautomaticallyledtotheshrinkingofcivilspace witnessed today.
ThissituationalarmedrightsdefendersfrominandoutsidethecountryandthereiswidelydocumentedevidenceshowingsuchincidentshadtarnishedtheimageofTanzaniaasfarasrespectandpromotionofhumanrightswereconcerned.
Asaresultoftheserightsviolations,inthepasttwoyears,TanzaniadroppedintheWorldFreedomIndex2017.AccordingtotheWorldFreedomIndexReport,in2016,Tanzaniaranked71butdroppedto83in2017and93in2018.Factorsattributedtothebigfallincludedsuspensionandclosureofmediaoutlets,threatstomediahousesandattacksagainstjournalists(FreedomHouse,2018;LHRC,2017).ThePressFreedomIndexisanannualrankingofcountriescompiledandpublishedbyReportersWithoutBordersbasedupontheorganisation`sassessmentofcountries’pressfreedomrecordsin the previous year.
Therehadbeenmanyeffortsfromdifferentmediastakeholdersandrightsdefenderstointerveneandputincheckhumanrightsabusesandviolations.Sucheffortshadincludedgoingtocourtto challenge some provisions, condemning press violationsincidents,urgingGovernmentstoreviewrestrictivesectionsaswellaspublishingviolationsincidentsinlocalandinternationalpublications.However,theGovernmenthadconsistentlydefendedits position.
2.10 Complaints Against Newspapers in 2017/18 ReportsfromMediaCouncilofTanzania(MCT)indicatethat,
in2017/18,eightcomplaintsagainstnewspapers,werebroughtbeforeMCT`sEthicsCommitteeformediationandarbitration.In2017,accusednewspapers,wereUhuru,MwanaHalisi,Mawio,Tanzanite,DailyNews,MtanzaniaandJamhuriwhilein2018,
43
2017-2018 REPORT
complaintswereagainstRaiaMwemaandJamvilaHabari(2018). AccordingtoMCT,somecasesreachedamediationandnewspapers
apologised.Onecasewasclosedafterthecomplainantdecidedtoseekotheralternatives.AnothercomplaintwasnotvalidwhileinthecaseinvolvingMwanahalisinewspaper,theCouncilcouldnotcontinuewiththecomplaintafterthenewspaperwasbannedfrompublishingfortwoyears.
2.11 Concluding Remarks Inthisarticletheprintmediacomesoutasastrugglingindustry
thatneedsaconduciveenvironmenttoregainground.Itsuffersmassivesetbackswhiletryingtorejuvenateinatensepoliticalenvironment,dominatedbyrepressiveandrestrictivelaws.Thechapterindicatedhowvariouslawsandregulationshavebeenmanipulatedby authoritiesdespite efforts byboth local andinternationalhumanrightsbodiestourgetheGovernmentrescinditsposition.Itpresentedalistofindividualjournalistsandmediahouses abused under such laws.
ThechapteralsoindicatedhowunfavourableenvironmentinwhichtheprintmediaoperateshascontributedtoTanzania’spositionintheWorldFreedomIndexdeclining.Despitesuchsetbacks,thechapterhasindicatedanumberofdevelopmentsinthesector.
2.12 Recommendations Basedontheabovefindingsandconclusion,thisreportmakesthe
followingrecommendations… Journalistsshould: · Challenge the enforcement of laws and regulations
suppressingfreedomofexpression · Have specialisations so as to develop journalists’
professionalcapacityofbecomingexpertsinparticularareasContinueExposingWrongdoingofSomeAuthorities
Printmediaorganisationsshould: Carryoutresearchonaudiencebehaviouralpatternsandmarketing
tohelpthemunderstandhowtoadjusttheirbusinessmodelsinaccordancewithaudienceandadvertising`demands.
44
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
Academicians Gatherevidenceofthenegativeeffectsandconsequencesoflaws
andregulationsviolatingfreedomofexpressionandpushforlawreformstoabolishthosewhichviolatecitizenrights.
FortheGovernment . Reviewlawsandregulationsviolatingpeople’sfreedom
ofexpression · Amendall restrictiveprovisions in theCybercrimes
Act,theElectronicandPostalCommunications(OnlineContent)RegulationsandtheMediaServicesandreplacethembyprogressivesectionsthatwillguaranteefreedomofexpression
· StopthreateningjournalistsandhumanrightsdefenderswhentheyexposewrongdoingofsomeGovernmentleaders.
References AmnestyInternationalReport(2016-2017) Bazira,JandUki,A(2017)StateoftheMediaReport,MediaCouncil
ofTanzania,DaresSalaam FreedomHouse(2018)TanzaniaCountryReportontheFreedom
of the Press, HumanRightsWatch(2017,2018) Kolumbia,L(2017)Governmentlicenses109newspapersbythe
setOctober31deadline,retrievedfromhttps://www.thecitizen.co.tz/News/Govt-issues-licences-to-109-newspapers/1840340-4171670-f2vn3iz/index.html
LHRC(2017)TanzaniaHumanRightsReport,LegalandHumanRightsCentre,DaresSalaam,Tanzania.
LHRC(2018)TanzaniaHumanRightsReport(Jan–June2018),LegalandHumanRightsCentre,DaresSalaam,Tanzania.
MCT(2017)PressFreedomViolationsRegisterReport,DaresSalaam,Tanzania
MCT(2018)PressFreedomViolationsRegisterReport(Jan–June2018),DaresSalaam,Tanzania.
URT(2017)MediaServicesAct,2016Regulations(2017)Dares
45
2017-2018 REPORT
Salaam,Tanzania RSF (2018) Media Ownership Monitor (Tanzania) Report, Media
CouncilofTanzaniaandReporterswithoutBorders,DaresSalaam,Tanzania.
URT(2015).TheCybercrimeAct,2015,DaresSalaam,Tanzania. URT(2018)AmendmentsoftheStatisticsAct2015,Cap.351,2018,
DaresSalaam, URT(2018)ElectronicsandPostalCommunications(OnlineContent)
Regulations(2018),DaresSalaam,Tanzania. URT(1976).TheNewspaperAct,1976,DaresSalaam,Tanzania
46
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
47
2017-2018 REPORT
Chapter Three
Current Trends in the Radio and TV Broadcasting
3.0 Introduction Thischapterslooksatwhattranspiredinthebroadcastingindustry
inTanzaniaMainlandin2017/18.ItmainlyfocusesonradioandTVstationsoperatinglegallyinthecountry,especiallyonthenumberofsuchoutlets,theirpenetration,plurality,ownershipaswell as issues that raised sustainability concerns to the industry. Thechapteralsolooksatthelegalframeworkguidingtheindustrybeforehighlightingincidentsofviolence,threatsandintimidationtobroadcastingjournalistsandtheirstations.Likewise,thechapterlooksatthecurrentsituationofdigitalbroadcasting,itsopportunitiesandchallengesandmajorethicalissuesfacingtheindustry.Thechapterendswithaconclusionandrecommendations.
3.1 Current Situation of Radio Broadcasting in Tanzania. Radiobroadcastingindustrycontinuedtothriveinthepasttwo
years.Apartfromthemainstreamortraditionalradiostations,in2018,doorswereofficiallyopenedforonlineradiothroughlicensingthem,thuswideningtheradiobroadcastingscopeinthecountry.
3.1.1 Number of Licensed Radio Stations in Tanzania AccordingtoTanzaniaCommunicationsRegulatoryAuthority
(TCRA)thecurrentnumberofradiostationsoperatinglegallyinTanzaniais158,aslightincreasefrom156thatweretherein2017.Abigrise,however,wasnotedin2016,whenthenumberincreasedto148from106in2015.Thetrendofradioregistrationinthecountryiscommendablesincetherehadbeenagradualincreaseyearafteryear.In2012thenumberofradioswere86butitshootto156in2017(TCRA, 2017).
Thetremendousincreaseinnumberofradiostationsoperatingthecountryisamajordevelopmentthattheindustryhasrecorded.Itshouldbenotedthatatindependence,in1961,Tanganyika,nowTanzaniaMainland,inheritedacolonialGovernment-controlledRadioTanzania,Dar-es-Salaam(RTD).Theradiostationdominated
48
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
thecountry’sairwavesformanypost-independenceyearsasanational broadcaster before being incorporated in TanzaniaBroadcastingCorporation(TBC).However,thesituationbegantochangeintheearly1990s,followingpoliticalandeconomicliberalisation, which witnessed Tanzania opening doors toestablishmentofprivatelyownedmedia.
TanzaniaRegulatoryAuthority(TCRA)statisticsindicatethatthe158licensedstationshavecoveragevaryingfromnational,regional,districtandcommunity.AccordingtoTCRAcategorisation,stationswithnationalcoveragecoveralmostalltheregions;thosewithregionalcoveragehavepresenceinatleast10regionswhiledistrictstationsoperateinonepointofoneregionandcommunityradiostationsservesmallspecificcommunities.
AcloselookatthelistshowthatwhilemostoftheradiostationsoperatingnationallyarebasedinDaresSalaam,withtheMwanza-basedRadioFreeAfrica(RFA)beinganexception.Thereisasignificantnumberofstationsoperatingatregionallevel.TCRA, 2017).
Itwasnotedthat,inthepasttwoyears,thegeographicalspreadofradiostationscontinuedtoimprove,inasensethattheywerenolongerconcentratedinDar-es-Salaamandotherurbancentres.Ruralareastooweresignificantlyenjoyingthefruitsoftheradiostationsspread.
Justlikeintheprecedingyears,in2017and2018,languagesusedinbroadcastingwereKiswahili,whichisnationallypredominant,andEnglish,usedbyafewradiostationslikeEastAfricaRadio(IPPMedia)ChoiceFM(CloudsMediaGroup)andKissFM(SaharaCommunications).ItisworthnotingthattheTanzaniaBroadcastingServicesAct(Section15)andtheElectronicandPostalCommunications(RadioandTelevisionBroadcastingContent)Regulations,2018,specify,underRegulation29(a),directsthatlanguagestobeusedinbroadcastingareKiswahiliandEnglish,exceptwherespecialauthorisationisgivenduetospecificreasons(URT,2018).
Regardingtherequirementthataradiostationmusthaveadequatelocalcontentintheirprogrammestothetuneof60%,industryprofessionals and stakeholders said, in the two years there were effortsweremadetoachievethat,althoughavailabilityofquality
49
2017-2018 REPORT
andappealinglocalprogrammesremainedasetback.Theyattributethattolackofskilledmanpowerandmodernequipmentfacingprivatecompaniesandindividualswhoventureintolocalradioprogrammesproductionbusiness.
3.1.2 Radio Plurality and Ownership Intermsownership,theTCRAlistoflicensedradiooperatorsshows
thatmoststationswereownedbybusinesspersons,politicians,faithorganisationsandnon-Governmentalorganisations.Itwasnotedthatnewevangelicalchurches,werealsoventuringintoestablishingFM radio stations.
Anotherimportantaspectnotedthroughdocumentreviewswasthefactthattherewerefewcompanieswhich,apartfromowningradio stations, also ran TV stations and even newspapers.
ThoseconversantwithmediadevelopmentinthecountrysaidtheseverycompaniesarefoundermembersoftheMediaOwnersAssociation of Tanzania (MOAT). They include IPP Media which ownsRadioOneandseveralotherstationsincludingITV,EastAfricaTelevisionandCapitalTV.Furthermore,thegroupalsoboastsseveralKiswahiliandEnglishnewspapers.
Andthen,SaharaCommunicationsLimitedownsStarTelevision,RadioFreeAfricaandKissFMwhileCloudsMediaGroupisaproprietor of Clouds FM, Choice FM and Clouds TV.
3.1.3 Radio Proliferation AccordingtoTCRArecords,byNovember2018thenumberof
radiostationsinthecountrywas158comparedto156in2017.Theincrease of two radio stations was the lowest annual increase since 2012astheTablebelowshows:
Table:No.ofRadioStations(2012-2018)Year 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018Numberofradios 86 93 98 106 148 156 158
Source: TCRA
3.1.4 Radio Development Trend: Community Radios as an Area to Watch
As licensing records indicated, an increase in thenumberofradio stations in Tanzania in recent years was partly due to the
50
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
establishmentofmoreFMradiostationsindistrictsandspecificcommunities. Broadcasters and media experts interviewedconsideredthisasagoodthing,withmanyadvantagesincludingdemocratisingthecommunicationprocessinsocietyandusingtheradiomediaasadevelopmentcatalyst.
ProsperKwigize,ChairmanofTADIO,anetworkofcommunitycontent-basedradiostationsinTanzania,mentionedprovisionofciviceducation,creatingawarenessonhealthissues,promotingpeaceandharmonyincommunitiesandofferingplatformsforpeopletoairtheirviewsassomeofthebenefitofthesestations.
3. 2. Situation of TV in Tanzania Justlikereportedinpreviousyears,thegrowthoftelevisionsector
inTanzaniahadnotmatchedthatofradio,duetoanumberoffactors,includinghighcostofentry.However,inthepasttwoyears,thereweresomedevelopmentsintermsoftelevisionaccessibilitynotedinsomepartsofthecountryespeciallyinruralareas.ThissuccesswasattributedpartlytoruralelectrificationprogrammelaunchedbytheGovernmentafewyearsago,whoserollouttoregionsisinphases,hascontributedtotheincreaseinTVuseacrossthe country since lack of power in rural areas had been partially addressed.
3.2.1 Number of Licensed TV Stations in Tanzania TCRArecordsshowthatthenumberofTVstationsinthecountry
increasedfrom46in2016to48in2017.However,in2018,thenumberdropped.TCRArecordsshow,asperNovember2018,licensedTVstationswere34.
AbreakdownofthetypesofTVstationsoperatinglegallyshowsthenumberoffree-to-air(FTA)TVstationswas27in2017comparedto25in2016.TherestoftheTVstations;werecableTV(15in2016and2017respectively),satelliteTV(3inboth2016and2017)andpayDTT(3inboth2016and2017).
SinceTVstations, just like radio,aregovernedby thesamebroadcastinglawsandregulations,thelanguagepolicyisthesame.Hence,TVstationsuseKiswahiliandEnglishintheirprogrammes,althoughKiswahiliispredominantandmorepopular,asthisisthenationallanguageanditisunderstoodbythemajorityof
51
2017-2018 REPORT
Tanzanians.CapitalTVandEATVhaveseveralEnglishlanguageprogrammestargetingforeigners.
AccordingtoTCRA,thereareTVstationswithnationalcoverage,which include TBC1, ITV, Channel 10 and East Africa Television (EATV),whichareDar-es-Salaam-based.TheMwanza-basedStarTVtoohasnationalcoverage.AnumberofotherTVstationshaveregionalcoverageinthesensethattheycovermorethan10regions,asperTCRAdefinition.ItisworthnotingthatsomeTVstationsoperateatdistrictlevel,inthesensethattheycoveroneregiononly(http//www.tcra.go.tz).
3.2.2 Television Plurality, Ownership and Diversity. TCRA records show that the State, private companies, non-
Governmentalorganisations,politiciansandbusinessmenownTVstations.LeadingTVstationsbelongtosamecompanieswhichhaveinterestsinradioandnewspapers.Forexample,ITVandEATV are part of the IPP Media, Start TV is part of the Sahara Communications,CloudsTVbelongstoCloudsMediaGroup.
SomeTVstationsestablishedbylocalGovernmentsinthedistrictshavehelpedtobringTVservicesclosertothepeople,althoughthegeographicalspreadofTVstationsdoesnotmatchthatofradiostationswhichhavepresenceeveninsmallRSF(2018)communities.
3.2.3TelevisionProliferation Regardingthetrendoftelevisionstationsintermsincreasingor
decliningnumbers,observationshowsthatduringthepastsevenyears,thatis,from2012-2017,thenumberremainedmoreorlessconstantwithoutmuchannualvariation.Thetablebelowtellsthewhole story.
Table2:NumberofTVStations(2012-toNov2018)Year 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018NumberofTVstations 46 44 46 46 46 48 34
Source:TCRA:
3.3 Radio/TV Sustainability Issues Whilethereareanumberofdevelopmentsnotedinthebroadcasting
industryinTanzania,includingthefactthatthenumberofradioandTVstationsinthecountryhadbeengrowing,themediahasinthepasttwoyearscontinuedtofacerestraintsinfiveparticular
52
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
areas:finances,manpower,technicalknow-how,legalandsecurityconstraints.
3.3.1 Financial Constraints Interviewswithdifferentbroadcastingstakeholdersshowthat
financiallimitationsareamajorchallengefacingthesectorandtheyattributeittoanumberoffactors,including,measurestakenbythe5thPhaseGovernmentthatareaimedatfightingcorruptionandenforcefinancialdisciplineinGovernmentexpenditure.
Accordingtothestakeholders,thismovebroughtaboutfinancialshockandtightmonetaryliquidity,asituationthataffectedbusinessinmanysectors,includingthatofthemedia.Inrelationtothat,bigcompanieshavetrimmedtheiradvertisingbudgets.
StevenDiallo,thetechnicalmanagerofoneoftheleadingradiostationsinthecountrybasedinMwanzaandDar-es-Salaam,saidinordertocope,hiscompanyhastakenvariousmeasuresincludingimprovingqualityofprogrammes,undertakingregularmonitoringofthestation’sperformanceaswellasdesigningdifferentmarketingstrategiesincludinglearninghowbesttheycanuseonlineplatformstoreachabiggeraudience.
``MostradioandTVstationsarenowusingsocialmediaplatformslike Facebook, twitter, YouTube and others to reach part of the audience that have diverted to these outlets, as well as capture alargerlocalandinternationalaudience…thishashelpedthemtogarnermorepopularityand economicgains,’’notedonecommunicationexpert.
3.3.2 Manpower Challenges Broadcasters and other stakeholders interviewed observed two
majorissuesrelatedtomanpowerchallengesinthebroadcastingsector,namely,ashortageoftrainedbroadcastjournalistsaswellastechnicianstohandlethetechnicalmatterscompetently,andthetendencyofprivatestationsownersnotbeingkeenontrainingtheirstaff,eitherthroughin-houseorexternalarrangements.
Theypointedoutthatthissituationhasfuelledthemalpracticeofusinguntrainedbroadcasters,partlyduetothemisconceptionthatwhoeverisblessedwithagoodvoicecanmakeagoodbroadcaster,evenwithouthavingundergonebasictraininginjournalism.
53
2017-2018 REPORT
NarratingchallengesfacingcommunityradioinTanzania,ProsperKwigize,chairmanofTADIO,anetworkofcommunitycontent-basedradiostationsinTanzania,mentionedlimitedresourcesintermsofpersonnelandequipmentandhightaxesassomeoftheencumbrancesthreateningtheirsurvival.
3.3.3 Technical Equipment Broadcasting,especiallyintheareaoftelevision,requireswell
equipped studios which broadcasters interviewed said are costly toputinplace.OurfindingsrevealedthatwiththeexceptionofbigmediahousesbasedinDar-es-SalaamandMwanza,othersoperate with unprofessional equipment. The argument thatmanybroadcastingstationslackreliablestudioequipmentwassupportedbyamajorityofbroadcastersandradiomanagersthatwereinterviewed.TADIOchairmansaidthesituationisworseincommunityradiostations.
3.3.4 Security Challenges Anotheraspectwhichraisedsustainabilityconcernoverbroadcasting
industrywasrelatedtosecurity.Findingsindicatedthatinthepasttwoyears,therewereanumberofincidentswhichputlivesofbroadcasterindanger.Whilepopularityandtrustpeoplehaveinbroadcastingmediamighthavebeenthereasontheirpersonnelbecametargets,viewsfromdifferentpeopleshowtheywereunderconstantwatchbytheauthoritiesduetotheimmenseinfluencetheyhave over their audiences.
3.3.5 Legal Challenges In the past two years, radio and television stations continued
tooperateunderalegalframeworkwhichwasneitherfriendlynor supportive to theirdevelopment.Broadcastersandotherstakeholdersinterviewedpointedoutthatsomelawsandregulationsguidingbroadcastingindustrywerestilloppressiveandthatinsomecases, were used by authorities for personal or political purposes.
3.4 Status of Closure or Hefty Fines in Tanzania Mainland media
Theynotedwithmuchconcernthatsomesectionsofthecontroversiallawsandregulationspassedinrecentyearsincludingthenew
54
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
BroadcastingRegulations,2018,whichempowerstheTCRA,tofineradioandtelevisionstations(URT,2018),affecttheirday-to-dayfunctionsandintimidatethem.
Communication and legal experts also noted that for thoseengagedinonlinetelevisionandradiooperations,thestronghandoftheElectronicandPostalCommunications(OnlineContent)Regulations,2018,islikelytosqueezethem.UnderRegulation15,theauthorityhastherighttocancelthecontentservicelicence,wherethetermsandconditionsarebreached(URT,2018)
Punitivemeasureslikeclosureofstationsandfineswastakenagainstsomeradioandtelevisionstationsonanumberofoccasions,undercircumstanceswhichlegalobserversconsideredunjust,especiallywhentheaffectedwerenotgiventheopportunitytofreelydefendthemselves.
InFebruary2017,tworadiostations,namelyTimesFMandRadioFreeAfricawerefinedatotalofSh6millionforallegedlyviolatingregulationsgoverningbroadcastinginthecountry.TheywereorderedbyTCRAtopaySh3millioneachandastrongwarningwasissuedagainstthem(MCT2017)
Another incident which raised public debate took place on January 2,2018,whentheTCRAContentCommitteefinedfivemajortelevisionstationsforwhatittermedas“airingseditiouscontent”and contravening the rulesunder theBroadcastingServices(Content)Regulations;2005.ThefiveTVstationswereStarTV,whichwasfinedSh7.5million,AzamTwoTV(Sh7.5million),EastAfricaTV(Sh15million),Channel10(Sh15million)andITV(Sh15million).ThecombinedfinestotaledSh60million.
Reaction to theheftyfineswas instant.Media stakeholdersquestionedthecircumstancesunderwhichaccusationarose.ThetelevisionstationsairedintheirnewsbulletincontentfromapressstatementissuedbytheLegalandHumanRightsCentre(LHRC)onNovember30,2017.
Thepressstatementwasonhumanrightsviolationsobservedduringthecivicby-elections,wheretheorganisationobservedrightsviolationsintheformofphysicalassaults,abuse,detention,andintimationofvoters(MCT2017).
LegalanalystswonderedwhytheTVstationswereaccusedofairing“seditious’’contentwhentheorganisationwhichissued
55
2017-2018 REPORT
thestatementwasnotaccusedofanything.Theyfurtherpointedoutthatacaseinvolving“sedition’’wastooserioustobehandledbyanentityliketheTCRAContentCommittee.Accordingtosomeobservers,theheftyfinescreatedanimpressionthatthemoveagainstthestationswasnothingmorethanawayofraisingmoneyfortheGovernment.
Inanycase,theincident,whichtemptedoneoftheTVaffectedstationstotakethemattertocourt,demonstratedthatthelegalframeworkhasseriousimplicationsonthebroadcastingsector.
Pay TV Saga Raise Public Debate ThethreattorevokelicencesofsomepayTVwasanothermatter
whichlitfireinthesector.InAugust2018,TCRAthreatenedtorevokelicencesofsomepayTVcompanieswhichcontinuedtoinclude free-to-air (FTA) content channels in their subscription packages.TheseincludedAzamLtd,MultichoiceTanzaniaLimited(tradingasDSTV)andSimbanetTanzaniaLimited(tradingasZUKU)
InastatementissuedduringthefirstweekofAugust,TCRADirectorGeneralJamesKilabasaidMultichoiceandSimbanethadbeencautionedseveraltimesbytheauthorityagainstincludingfree-to air channels in their subscription packs contrary to licence requirements,buttheyremaineddefiant.
ReactingtoTCRAnotice,MultichoiceissuedashortstatementsayingthecompanywasawareofthenoticebutnotedthatitcamewhenthematterwasstillbeforetheFairTradeCompetitionTribunal.
Toavoidhavingtheirlicencesrevoked,DSTVandZUKUremovedFTA channels from their subscriptionpackages, thus raisingcomplaints fromusersof theirdecoderswhowereobviouslyinconvenienced.
Thedevelopmentenhancedpublicdebateinthemedia,withsomeobserverswonderingwhyTCRAdecidedtotakeactiononamatterwaitingforahearingbytheFairTradeCompetitionTribunal,whileotherswereoftheopinionthatlicenceobligationsshouldbeobservedtoprovidealevelplayingfieldtooperatorsintheindustry.
WithseveralnationalTVstationsstillprovidingfree-to-aircontent,theGovernmentisnotlikelytobackdownonitsstand,muchassomemembersorthepublicusingdecodersofaffectedcompanies
56
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
mayfeelinconvenienced. Inthepastfewyears,someoftheTVstationsandindividualshad
started to introduce online television operations in order to capture moreviewers,butthesituationchangeddramaticallywhentheGovernmentgazettedtheElectronicandPostalCommunications(OnlineContent)Regulations,2018andmadethemoperationalinMarch2018.Operatorsinthebroadcastingindustryaswellaspotentialoneswaitinginthewingsseemtohaveseenthenewdevelopmentasablessing,fortheytooknotimetoseriouslygeton board.
RadioandtelevisionstationswerealsoaffectedbytheenforcementoftheElectronicandPostalCommunications(OnlineContent)Regulations,2018.Underthislegislation,onlineplatformsincludingonlineradioandTVstationsweredirectedtore-registerbypayingthemandatorySh2millionfeetocontinuetransmissionorshutdown.Itshouldbenotedthatsomeofthestationsintroducedonlinetelevisionoperationsinordertocapturemoreviewers.
3.5 Highlights of Incidents of Violence, Threats and Intimidation to Broadcasting Journalists
Some of the incidents of harassment and insecurity in thebroadcastingmediaduring2017and2018,whichwerereportedtoMCTandinvestigated,arehighlightedbelow:
InvasionofCloudsTVbyDar-es-salaamRegionalCommissioner,PauloMakonda,wasthemostglaringincidentwhichhitnewsheadlinesin2017.TheRCstormedtheTVstationbelongingtoCloudsMediaGroup,whichisbasedatMikocheni,Dar-es-Salaam,witharmedpoliceofficers.Ateamwhichwasformedtoinvestigatethe incident found out that the RC proceeded to one of the studios airingapopularTVshowtoenquirewhyaninterviewrecordedearlier had not been aired.
Itwasreportedthatwhenthepresenterstoldhimtheeditorshadnotapproveditforethicalreasons,hethreatenedtotakemeasuresagainstthem,includingputtingthemonthelistofdrugdealers,amovewhichcouldeasilyleadthemtojail.Theincidentwasuniqueinthehistoryofpost-independenceTanzaniaandgeneratedmuchdebateaswellascondemnationfrommediastakeholdersandmembersofthepublic.
57
2017-2018 REPORT
InMay2017,fourbroadcastingjournalistswereamongthosearrestedinArushabythepoliceforallegedlyattendingunauthorisedmeeting.TheyhadgonetocoveraneventwheretheAssociationofOwnersandManagersofNon-GovernmentalSchoolsandCollegeswasgivingadonationtothefamiliesofthechildrenofLuckyVincentNurseryandPrimarySchool,whohaddiedinatragicroadaccident.TheharassedbroadcastingjournalistswerefromAyoTV,AzamTV,ITVandTripleARadio.Theywerelaterfreedandpoliceclaimedtheyhadbeengivena“lift”totown.
OnFebruary7,2017,twojournalistsincludingareporterworkingfor the Arusha-based Sunrise Radio were arrested, by the police, for notreportingtolocalauthoritiesinthecourseofcoveringastoryinArumeruDistrictofArusha.Thereportershadgonetowitnesswhatwastakingplaceinaquarryoperatedbyaprivatecompany,wherethelocalpeoplehadgrievancesemanatingfromblastingactivitiesinthearea.Theywerelaterreleasedafterquestioning.
OnNovember21,2017,fourjournalistsincludingtwofromthebroadcastingmediawereharassedandassaultedbypoliceandteacherswhentheywenttocoverastudentriotinGeita.ThebroadcastingjournalistsinvolvedwerefromCloudsTVandAzamTV.Itwasreportedthatthepoliceandteacherswerebeatingupstudents and did not like the incident covered.
OnJune7,2018,threebroadcastingjournalistswerethreatenedandforcedtoleavetheareawheretheyhadgonetocoveranevent.TheincidenttookplaceatMtaviraVillageinSingidaRegionwheretwojournalistsfromTBCandanotheronefromStandardRadioweremakingafollow-uponastoryofapastoralistwhowassupposedtopaySh30millionfineforallowinghiscattletograzeintheForestReserve Area.
OnAugust8,2018ajournalistfromWapoRadiowaspubliclybeatenupbypoliceofficersattheNationalStadiuminDar-es-Salaam.Thevictimpleadedformercyasheattemptedtoshowthemhispresscard.Membersofthepubliccouldnotcomprehendwhatwasgoingonasthejournalistgotpunishedlikeapettythief.
3.6 Digital Broadcasting in Tanzania Oneviewwhichmostofthecommunicationexpertsandbroadcasters
interviewedtendtoagreewithisthatthefearanddoubtsthatkey
58
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
stakeholdersinthebroadcastingsectorhadaboutmigratingfromanaloguetodigitalbroadcastinghaveprovedunfoundedastimepasses.
TanzaniatookafirststepinthemigrationprocessbyswitchingoffitsanaloguetelevisionsignalsonDecember31,2012,thussettinganexampletoothercountriesinsub-SaharanAfrica(TCRA,2013)
Someorganisationsandmembersofthepublicwereskepticalaboutthemove,butthemostvocalwereownersofmajorDar-es-Salaam-basedmajorTVstations,whoadvocatedmigratingataslowerpaceandbeingguidedbytheInternationalTelecommunicationUnion(ITU)setdeadlineof2015.
Atthattime,broadcastersinsistedthattheywereunpreparedtoundertakethecostlyexercisewithinashortperiodoftime,claimingthathurriedchangeswouldinconveniencemembersofthe public, especially owners of TV sets who would be required to buydecoders.Availabledocumentsshowthatbroadcastersalsoarguedthatthesupplyofdecodersatshortnoticecouldnotbeguaranteed,andpriceswerelikelytobebeyondthepurchasingpowerofmostTanzanians,whoseincomesweregenerallylow.
TCRAdataonthenumberofdecoderssoldinthecountrybetween2011and2017supporttheobservationsmadebytheconsultant.Theregulator’srecordsshowthenumberofdecoderspurchasedincreasedfrom422,384in2012to2,236,577in2017(TCRA2017)
3.6.1 Current Situation of Digital Broadcasting in Tanzania Interviewsanddocumentsreviewedshowthatdigitalbroadcasting
inTanzaniaisasuccessstory,asmostTVstationshavemigratedand in 2017 and 2018 the preoccupation of operators in the industry hasbeenonhowtoexploitadvantagesofthenewsystemtothemaximum.
HamzaKasongo,aseniorbroadcasterinoneoftheprivateTVstationswhichventuredintomigrationassoonasthedoorswereopened,saiditwasnowpossibletohavemanychannels,thankstodigitaloperations.HepointedoutthatnewcomersinthebroadcastingsectorwhowanttolaunchTVstationsdon’thavetoworryaboutinstallingtowersaswasthecaseinthepast,giventhatthisworkistakencareofbylicensedmultiplexoperators,underthe new set-up.
59
2017-2018 REPORT
Findingsand interviewsalso show that there ismoremediaconvergencewhereTVandradiostationsarelinkingwithonline-basedmediabroadcastingandnon-broadcastingplatformstoreachmoreviewersandlisteners,bothinTanzaniaandabroad,thankstodigitaloperations.Thisisachievedbyinstallingspecialequipment.
Opportunities in Digital Broadcasting Giventhegrowingpacethatdigitalbroadcastinghastakeninthe
pasttwoyears,stakeholdersareoftheviewthat,thesectorhashighpotentialasfarasprovidingopportunitiestobroadcastingmediahouses and journalists is concerned.
Narratingsomeoftheaspectsachievedasadigitaluse,atechnicaldirectorinoneofthemajortelevisioncompaniesincountrynotedthatdigitalbroadcastinghasenabledTVandradiomediahousestohavemorechannels.Consequentlytheyoffermoreservicesontheonehand,whileontheother,theyhavehelpedintheimprovementofqualityofbroadcastingservicesincludingclarityofsignals,picturesandcommercials.Reducedoperationcostsandincreasingaudiencereacharesomeoftheattributedtodigitalbroadcasting.
Somejournalistsareoptimisticthatthereareopportunitiesofself-employmentbyventuringintosomedigitalbroadcastingplatformswhichco-existwithexpandedtraditionalonesthroughconvergence.
Digitalbroadcastingis,however,facinganumberofchallenges,includingtechnical,business,ethicalandlegalissues.
Regardingthetechnicalside,somebroadcasterssaidgenerally,theequipmentusedindigitalbroadcastingissophisticated,expensiveandrequirehightechnicalskillstohandle,thecapacitywhichmanypotential investors lack.
Competitioninthesectorresultingfrommanypeopleventuringinto the industry, ethical concerns and lack of skilled personnel were otherchallengesthatwerepointedout.
Allthatnotwithstanding,manystakeholderssay,thereareanumberofdevelopmentstobecelebrated,andthatoneofthemistheentryofonlineTVandradiowithunprecedentedmomentum.
3.7 Online TV and Radio Stations in Tanzania ThepastfewyearshaveseensomeTVstationsandindividuals
introducing online television operations in order to capture
60
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
moreviewers,butthesituationchangeddramaticallywhentheGovernmentgazettedtheElectronicandPostalCommunications(Onlinecontent)Regulations,2018andmadethemoperationalinMarch2018.Operatorsinthebroadcastingindustryaswellaspotentialoneswaitinginthewingsseemtohaveseenthenewdevelopmentasablessing,fortheytooknotimetogetonboard.
TCRA records of online content services licences issued by October 16,2018,showonlineTVoperatorswere90,animpressivefigureattainedinonly6months.
Six operators obtained online content service (simulcastingtelevision)licenceswhichallowthemtooperatemorethanonecommunicationplatforms.Inthisgroup,establishedcompaniesthat own traditional TV stations have opted to launch online televisions as well. These include ITV, Capital TV, East Africa TV, Star TV and Clouds TV (TCRA 2018).
ApartfromoperatorslicensedtorunbothtraditionalandonlineTVs,thereisalonglistof84operatorslicensedthatprovideonlinetelevisionservicesonly.Ownersofonlinetelevisionplatformsareaninterestingmix,astheyincludeindividuals,newspapercompanies,Governmentagencies,faithministriesandbroadcasters.
Newspapercompanieswhichhaveventuredintoonlinetelevisionbusiness includeUhuruMediaGroup.,NewHabari (2016)Ltd.,TanganyikaStandardNewspapers(TSN)andMwananchiCommunicationsLtd.Observersareoftheopinionthatmorenewspapers will join the pack as they look for opportunities to makesomemoneytocushiontheirdwindlingbusinessfortunes.
JenifferSummi,oneofthebroadcastersinterviewed,madeanobservation in relation to the unprecedented drive by individuals andcompaniestoventureintoonlinetelevisionoperations.Shewonderswhetherthisaffordabilitymightbeoneofthereasonsthenumberoftraditionaltelevisionstationsisnotgrowingattheexpectedpace.
Asfortheonlineradiocategory,therearealsooperatorswhohave opted to run both traditional radio stations and online radio services(undersimulcastingradiocontent)licence.AsofOctober,2018,thelistcarried25stations.TheseincludedestablishedstationslikeCloudsRadio,RadioFreeAfrica,KissFM,CapitalRadio,JRSRadioKwizeraandSibukaMediaLimited.Sixentrantsobtained
61
2017-2018 REPORT
online content (radio) licences. Communicationexpertspredictthatwhathappenedafterafew
monthsofopeningthedoorforonlineTVandradiolicensingmightbeabeginningoftheratracetoestablishtheseplatforms,whoseimpactonthebroadcastingindustryinTanzaniawillbesignificant.
3.8 Ethical Issues in the Broadcasting Industry Ethicalconcernsresultingfromdigitalincludetheemergence
ofpeoplecallingthemselvescitizenjournalistswho,duetotheflexibilityfacilitatedbydigitaldevices,areabletoshareinformation.Thisgroupissaidtohavecausedsocialinconvenienceduetounprofessional and unethical practices involved in free-for-all informationsharing.
Lackofskilledpersonnelisanotherchallengethreateningdigitalworld.Themajorconcernrelatedtothis,are:Howdooneguaranteethatthoseinarushtoestablishonlinetelevisionandradioplatforms,willsticktoethicalandprofessionalconduct?Whatwouldbethekeyethicalprinciplesguidingthem?
“Thereremainsalotneededtobedoneasfarasethicsofonlinemediaisconcerned…legallytherearesomeeffortstoimposecontrolalthoughIthink,theselawsandregulationsareoverlytoughtotheextentofmakingithardforthesectortoflourishandinvestorstobenefit,notedonecommunicationexpert,MsSummi
Besidesthat,increasingself-censorshipamongradioandtelevisionjournalists was another aspect which raised concern in the past twoyears.Asexplainedinthisarticle,journalistsoptedtofilterofinformationduetofearinthewakeofharshlawsandregulationsaswellashostilepoliticalenvironment.
3.9 Concluding Remarks It is clear that in the past two years, broadcasting industry
in Tanzania continued to progress in terms of numbers andpenetration.Andwhilestrivingtocopewithfinancial,technical,manpowerandsecuritychallengesinthetwoyears,theindustrywitnessedjournalistsandtheirstationsoperatingunderlawsandregulationswhichareunfriendly,regulationsthatdon’tprovideroomforbroadcastingmediatogrow.Asaresultofsuchlaws,thetwoyearswitnessedjournalists/broadcastersbeingpunished
62
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
orfacingthreats,intimidationandvariousformsofharassment.WhilemuchpotentialofbroadcastingindustryinTanzaniawasnoted,especiallyondigitalbroadcasting,muchneedstobedone,moresointheareaofresourcesandmanpower.
3.10 Recommendations Thisarticlerecommendsthefollowing: BroadcastingMediaHousesShould: · Acquiremoderndigitalequipmentinordertocopewith
emergingdemands; · Investinbuildingcapacityoftheirpersonnelespecially
indigitalaspects · Improveprogrammestoattractmoreadvertisers,sponsors
and audience · Restructureorganisationalandnewsroomset-upsto
accommodatemulti-mediaplatforms. RadioandTVJournalistsShould: · Specialiseinspecificareasofbroadcastingtobemore
competent; · Lookfortrainingopportunitiesinmulti-mediareporting · Exploit self-employment opportunities in digital
broadcasting. GovernmentandMediaSupportingOrganisations: · Revisitmedialawswhichareathreattooperatorsinthe
broadcastingsector · Workwithotherstakeholderstoprovidemoretraining
tojournalistsinthebroadcastingsector.
References AfricaMediaBarometerReport,2015FriedrichEbertStiftung,
Windhoek,Namibia. MCT/RSF (2018) Media Ownership Monitor in Tanzania Report,
DaresSalaam,Tanzania. TCRA,LicensedOnlineContentServiceProviders.Retrievedfrom
www.tcra.go.tz/images/headlines/licensed online content service providers, accessed on 16th October,2018.
TCRA,LicensedContentServiceProviders.Retrievedfromwww.
63
2017-2018 REPORT
tcra.go.tz/index.phd/licensing/licensed-operators/2-tcra/46-radio,accessedonMarch31st2017.
TCRA,LicensedContentServiceProviders.Retrievedfromwww.tcra.go.tz/index.phd/licensing/licensed-operators/2-tcra/47-television,accessedon31stMarch,2017
URT(2018)TheElectronicandPostalCommunications(RadioandTelevisionContent)Regulations,DaresSalaam,Tanzania.
URT(2003)TanzaniaCommunicationRegulatoryAuthorityAct,2003,DaresSalaam,Tanzania.
URT(1993)TheBroadcastingServicesAct,1993,DaresSalaam,Tanzania.
64
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
65
2017-2018 REPORT
Chapter Four
Current Trends in the New Media
4.0 Introduction ThischapterlooksatthetrendofnewmediainTanzaniaduringthe
2017/18period.Inthischapter,newmediastandsforinteractiveplatformbywhichindividualsandcommunitiescometogethertodiscusscontentthroughexchangingmessagesandcomments.ThechapterstartsbyexploringprogressintheareaincludinganincreaseinpeopleaccessingInternetandotherdigitaldevicesandbenefitsexpectedfromsuchdevelopments.Italsolooksathowonlinemediacontinuedtosurviveunderahostileandtensepoliticalatmosphere,resultingintodeteriorationinfreedomofexpressionandshrinkingofcivicspace.ThechaptergivesaclearpictureofhowthenotoriousCybercrimesActandotherrestrictivelawsandregulationsplayedahugeroleinsuppressingvoicesconsideredtobecriticaltothecurrentGovernmentanditspolicies.
Implicationsoftheenforcementofsuchlawsandhowlocalandinternationalhumanrightsdefendershavereactedtothesituationarealsoexplored.Thechapterendswithconcludingremarksandrecommendations.
4.1 With Tense Political Atmosphere Online Media Strive to Survive
In 2017 and 2018, Tanzania Mainland continued to record a gradualincreaseincitizens’accesstoInformationCommunicationTechnology,(ICT).TheInternetlandscapecontinuedtoexpandalongsideincreasedaccessibilitytomobilebroadbanddevices,smartphones and other Internet enabled handsets.
Theserecordeddevelopments,wereexpectedtoincreasefreedomofexpression(FOE),accesstoinformationandinnovationforsocio-economicgrowth.Instead,theoppositehadbeenthecaseforthelasttwoyearsaswillbeexplainedlaterinthischapter.
AccordingtotheStateofInternetFreedominAfrica2018Report,therewereabout23millionInternetusers(theexactnumberofthe
66
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
populationusingInternetwere22,995,109),translatinginto45%penetrationduringtheyear.Thisisanincreasecomparedto20millionpeopleand40%penetrationin2016.(TCRA,2017,CIPETA,2018)
Table1:TheTrendofInternetPenetrationforthePastSixYears
Year 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017
Penetration 8 9 14 17 20 23
Percentage 17 21 29 34 40 45
In2017/18,thenumberofpeoplewithaccesstomobilephonesalsoincreased.AsperSeptember2018,subscriberswere42,961,449.AccordingtoTCRA,forthepastthreeyears(2015to2018),mobiletelephone subscriptions grew from 39,808,419 SIM cards inDecember2015to42,961,449inSeptember2018,whichisanequivalentof8%growth.
Inthelasttwoyears,companiesprovidingtelecommunicationservicesinTanzaniawereseven—areasonablenumberwhencompared to the situation in other countries inAfrica. ThecompaniesarelistedasAirtel,Smart,Halotel,Vodacom,Tigo,Zantel, and TTCL (TCRA, 2018).
An increase in peoples’ access to ICT has always been a crucial elementintheportrayalofacountry`sdevelopment.ThepromotionofICTincreasescitizen`srightstofreedomofexpressionorfreedomofeverypersontoholdopinionsaswellasfreedomtoreceiveandimpartinformationandideas,eitherorally,inwritingorinprint.Inaddition,Internetaccessfacilitatestherightofaccesstoinformationandisindeedcriticalfortheexpansionoffreespeech.
Therefore,thesedevelopmentsrecordedinthepasttwoyears,wereexpectedtoincreasefreedomofexpression(FOE),accesstoinformationandinnovationforsocio-economicgrowth.Instead,the opposite had been the case for the last two years as will be explainedinthefollowingsection.
4.2 Government Uses Restrictive as Mechanisms to Control Online Space
Primaryandsecondarydataindicatethatthepasttwoyearswere
67
2017-2018 REPORT
worstonmattersrelatedtoInternetandonlinecommunicationinTanzaniaMainland.Pressfreedom,righttoinformationandfreedomofspeechoropinionwhichconstitutefreedomofexpression,werecurtailed. (LHRC, 2017, LHRC, 2018)
Characterisedbyaverytensepolitical tension, the5thPhaseGovernmentcontinuedtoimposedifferentmechanismstocontrolonlinespace.Mechanismsusedincludedenforcementofrecentrestrictivelawsandpassingofnewregulationswithprovisionspronetoabusesandmanipulation(ibid).
Accordingtodocumentsreviewed(LHRC,2017);LHRC,2018),inthelasttwoyears,thesituationwithregardtohumanrightsinTanzaniadeterioratedcomparedtothatof2016.Besidesothercivilandpoliticalrights,freedomofexpressionwasamongthemostviolatedhumanrightsinTanzaniaowingtoattacks,threatstojournalists,banofmediahousesandapplicationoflawsthatarbitrarily,restrictfreedomofexpression,suchastheMediaServiceActandtheCybercrimeAct.
LHRC(2018)paintsagloomypictureofhumanrightssituationinTanzaniaMainlandshowingdegenerationandgrossviolationofhumanrightswithJanuary–June2018asworstrecordedcomparedtothesameperiodin2017,themajorcontributingfactorsbeingcontinuedviolationsofcivicandpoliticalrightsaswellasrestrictionsonfreedomofexpressions.
Twaweza,thecivilsocietyorganisation,whichhasbeenintheforefrontasfarasfreedomofexpressionisconcerned,pointedoutthat2017wasnotahappyyearforTanzaniansasfreeexpressionintheircountrycontinuedtocomeunderattackwiththerestrictivelawswhichresulted intoprivatecitizensbeing threatenedorpunishedforexpressingtheiropinionsonsocialmedia(Twaweza,2017)
Despite stakeholders urgingGovernment officials to refrainfrominterferingwithfreedomofexpressionwithoutreasonablegrounds, incidentsofthreats,harassmentandlegal penaltiesfacilitatedbytherecentlyenactedlawsandregulations,continuedresultingintojournalists,onlineoperatorsanduserstoworkinfearofconsequencesincludingheavyfinesandimprisonment.StakeholderswhohaveconsistentlyurgedtheGovernmentnottointerferewithfreedomofexpressionincludehumanrights
68
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
organisationssuchasTanzaniaLegalandHumanRightsCentre(LHRC);professionalmediaassociationssuchasEditorsForum;mediaregulatorybodiesincludingtheMCTaswellasregionalprofessionalorganisationssuchasMediaInstituteofSouthernAfrica, Tanzania Chapter (Misa-Tan).
Reportspublishedorstatementsissuedbytheseorganisationsplusinterviewswiththeirofficials,confirmwidespreadconcernaboutTanzaniansituationwithregardtofreedomofexpression.Theareasofconcernwillbeexplainedindetaillaterinthischapter.
Asaresultofrightsviolation,inthepasttwoyears,TanzaniadroppedintheWorldFreedomIndex2017.AccordingtotheWorldFreedomIndexReport,in2016,Tanzaniaranked71,butdroppedto83in2017and93in2018.Factorsattributedtothisbigfallincludedsuspensionandclosureofmediaoutlets,threatstomediahousesandattackonmediapractitioners(FreedomHouse,2018;HumanRightreport,2017).ThePressFreedomIndexisanannualrankingofcountriescompiledandpublishedbyReportersWithoutBordersbasedupontheorganisation’sassessmentofthesurveyedcountries’pressfreedomrecordsinthepreviousyear(RSF,2018)
4.3 Online Content Regulations; a Heavy Nail on the Coffin
ThepassingintolawoftheElectronicandPostalCommunications(OnlineContent)Regulations,2017,dealtamajorblowtoonlinecommunication.ThisregulationswaspassedbytheTanzaniaNationalAssemblyinSeptember,2017andsignedintolawinMarch2018,despiteseveralcallsbymembersofthecivilsocietyandinternationalbodiesthaturgedtheGovernmenttoreviseorwithdrawportionsoftheseregulations.Theseregulationsapplytoonlinecontentpublishers—includingbloggers,Internetcafes,onlinecontenthosts,onlineforumsandonlineradio,television,socialmediaandanyotherrelatedcommunication.
Althoughtheregulationissaidtohavemanyshortcomings,stakeholderswereveryconcernedaboutsomeaspectsincludingthehighfeesoperatorswererequiredtopay,threatstoanonymity,liabilityissuesandseverepenaltiesforthosecontraveningtheseterms,equivocalphrasesintheregulationsandtheextensivepowers granted to the TCRA to control online freedom of
69
2017-2018 REPORT
expression. Underthenewlaw,bloggersaswellasonlineradioandTVwebsites
are required to be licensed by the TCRA and pay a prerequisite fee ofmorethanUS$900whichismorethanSh2millionperyearforthemtooperate.(URT,2018)
Regardingthreatstoanonymity,thelawrequiresInternetcafestofilteraccesstoprohibitedcontentandinstallsurveillancecamerastorecordandmonitoractivitiesinsidethecafé.Thecafesarerequiredtoputinplacemechanismstofacilitatethesecontrols(URT,2018).
Onliabilityissues,underthelaw,socialmediausersareresponsibleandaccountablefortheinformationtheypublish.Furthermore,bloggersandInternetforumsareaccountableforallcontentontheirwebsite. In other words, content providers are required to have in placemechanismstoidentifysourcesofcontent,andtocooperatewith the authorities to know the user’s identity when the need arises.
Tomakemattersworse,theregulationsetseverepenaltiestothosecontraveningthesetermswherethefineisnotlessthanSh5millionorimprisonmentfornotlessthantwelvemonths,orboth.
4.3.1 Stakeholders` Response to Online Regulations Online regulations send bloggers packing
Aspartoftheenforcementofthenewregulations,inJune2018,allwebsites,blogsandonlinecontentprovidersincludingJamiiForumwerebannedbyTCRAfrompostinganyadditionalcontentuntiltheycompliedwiththenewlaw.
Thismove,causedpanicamongthemwithmanyofthemgettingconfused,notknowinghowtheyweregoingtoraisesuchahugeamountofmoneyrequiredbeforeresumingoperations.
Jailtermandfineforfailingtocomplywiththelaw,sawsomebloggers,onlineradioandtelevisionoutfitspaythemandatorySh2millionfeeforregistrationtocontinuetransmission,whilethosewhocouldnotaffordcloseddown.AccordingtoTCRA,duringtheperiodstartingfromMarchwhenthenewregulationbecameintoforcetoOctober,2018,atotalnumberof211onlinecontentserviceprovidershadbeenlicensed.Amongthem,88wereblogs,2onlineforums,21onlineradiostationsand90onlinetelevisionstations.(TCRA, 2018)
70
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
TheTCRA,initsquarterlyreportofSeptember,2018,saidthenewregulationsandlicensing,minimisedthemisuseofonlinemedia.However,variousjournalists,civilsociety,communicationstakeholdersandhumanrightgroupsfrominandoutsidethecountry,haddifferentopinionsregardingthemove.Theystronglybelievedthatthislawhadmanynegativeconsequencesnotonlytoonlinecontentprovidersbutalsotothegeneralpublicthatbenefitsfromdiversityofinformationsharedthroughtheseplatforms(ibid).
Theysaidthefeewastoohigh,whichautomaticallyforcedsmalleroutlets to close down as they couldn’t afford it and this eventually thwartedpluralism.
SalomeKitomary,ChairpersonforMediaInstituteinSouthernAfrica,TanzaniaChapter(Misa-Tan),said,regulationsrequirementsincludingtheUS$900registrationfee,wasshatteringnewsformanypeopleespeciallyyounggraduateswhohadstartedtheirownmultimediaplatformsforthepurposeofearningalivingandutilisingtheirknowledge.
Shesaidbesidesthefeebeingtoohigh,therearemanyrequirementswhicharehardtofulfill,hinderingmanypeoplefromventuringinto online business.
GeodfreyIsmaely,editorforMajiranewspaperandRamadhaniKabalewhoisamediaanalyst,contendedthatthefeewastoohighandduetothat,manybloggershadtoshutdowntheirplatforms.Concernaboutthehighfeeswasalsoraisedbyvariousorganisationsintheirreports(LHRC,2018;CIPETA,2018).
Accordingtorespondents,liabilityissuesandseverepenaltiesprovidedintheregulationsencourageself-censorshipamongonlineusers,somethingwhichcontributetoashrinkingpublicspace.
Regarding equivocal phrases in the regulations presumedsubjective,toowordy,vagueandambiguous,theywereconcernedthatsuchtypeofframingwasadeliberateattemptbythepowers-that-be,tostemdissentandcriticism.
Theywerealsoconcernedaboutwhattheytermedtheextensivepowers the Electronic and Postal Communications (OnlineContent)RegulationgrantstotheTCRAtocontrolonlinefreedomofexpression.
71
2017-2018 REPORT
TheysaidthatthepartwhichallowsTCRAtokeeparegisterofbloggers,onlineforums,onlineradioandonlinetelevisionandtheoneempoweringthecommunicationsregulatortoorderremovalofprohibitedcontentmaybemisusedbyauthoritiesfortheirowninterests.
TheirmainfearwasthattheseprovisionscouldbeamechanismbytheGovernmenttohaveadatabaseofonlineusers,somethingwhich can also be used as a tool to harass and persecute users who arecriticaloftheGovernmentaswellasallowtheregulatorybodytofilterandidentifythesourcesofinformationpostedonline.
Commentingontheaboveconditions,PeterNyanje,NewsEditorforFinancialTimesnewspaper,saidimposingregulationswithsomanyrequirementswasnotasolutiontoflawsandgapssurroundingsocialmediauseinthecountry,andthattheGovernmentwassupposedtocomeupwithanothermechanismofpreventingorcontrollingsocialmediaflawswithoutaffectingpeoples’righttoonlinecommunication.
Inhisview,theGovernmentdecisiondidnotonlyaffectthosewhomisusesocialmediaplatforms—italsoaffectedresponsiblecitizenswhowereusingtheminamaturewaytoshareinformation.
Kitomarysaysthatbycomingupwithmeasurestocontrolonlinecommunication,theGovernmenttookapositivestepbutthen,sheargues,themeasurecouldhavebeencarriedoutwithoutaffectingpeoples`freedomintheuseofonlinecommunication.
Dinah Chahali, an editor with Channel Ten, is of the conviction thatwiththeongoingethicalviolationsassociatedwithdigitaluse,itwashightimeGovernmentimposedsomecontrolalthough,sheadmits,someoftheprovisionsaretoughtotheextentofmakingithardthesectortoflourishandbenefitpeople.
Generally,viewsfromdocumentsreviewedplusrespondentsinterviewed,showthatthesenewregulationswereconvenienttoolsandpartofawiderGovernmentschemeaimedatlimitingfreedomsandlibertiesofspeechandparticipatorymultipartypoliticsinTanzania.
Besideschallengescausedbythe2017OnlineContentRegulations,in2017/18,theenforcementofexistinglawsincludingthenotorious2015CybercrimesAct,whichhasbeennamedamongthelawsseverelyrestrictingfreedomofexpression,continuedtoplaya
72
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
significantroleinsuppressingpeople’sfreedomtoexpresstheirviewsandopinions.Thefollowingsectionlooksatthefar-reachingimplicationsofimplementationsofsuchlaws.
4.4 The Notorious 2015 Cybercrimes Act Continued to Play Significant Role.
Cybercrime Act 2015, in September 2018 marked its 3rd year of existence, having been enacted in 2015.
Thislaw,whichwasenactedforagoodcourse,issaidtohavebeenmisappliedtostiflecriticalandalternativethinkingforpoliticalexpediency.DespiteGovernment’sjustificationthattheActwasestablishedtodetercrimesuchascyberfraud,childpornography,hatespeech,andterrorismthatweresaidtobemajorsecuritythreats,criticsclaimthatforthepastthreeyears,theenforcementofthelawhadbeentargetingGovernmentcritics.
However,authoritieshavefromtimetotime,defendedtheAct,arguingthat lawssuchasthispreventmoraldecadenceandpromotenationalsecurityandcohesion.Rightsactivists,however,saytheGovernment’sintentionsweren’tthatclear.
Reports fromvarious institutions show that in the last twoyears,onlinecommunicationuserscontinuedtofacetheriskofprosecutionunderthe2015CybercrimesActandotherlawsforoffensessuchasinsultingthePresidentandGovernmentofficials(LHRC,2017;LHRC,2018;CIPETA,2018).
Duetothat,theActissaidtohavebeenusedextensivelytoreigninvoicescriticalofPresidentMagufuli’sGovernmentanditspolicies.
These reports indicate that, there were instances where law enforcementagenciesfloatedexistinglegislationinwaysthatunderminedprivacy.Furthermore,securityagenciesonseveralinstancesdemandedaccessdetailsofindividualswhohadpostedcontentonline(CIPETA,2018;LHRC,2017;LHRC,2018).TheseactionsweregivenmorecloutbySection32oftheCybercrimesAct2015,whichauthorisesthepolicetodemanddisclosureofdatasourcesforpurposesofcriminalinvestigations.(URT,2015)
Intheperiodunderinvestigation,therewasalsoanemergingtrendinTanzaniawherebylawenforcementagenciesseizedphonesandpersonalcomputersfromindividualsandheldthemforseveral
73
2017-2018 REPORT
daysonthegroundsthattheywereconductinginvestigation(CIPETA, 2018).
It was also observed that not only did Tanzania put in place laws andregulationstoenablecensorshipandsurveillanceaselaboratedin the earlier sections, but authorities continued to threaten online content service providers and users with arbitrary arrests and prosecutions (ibid)
4.5 Incidents of People Punished Under Online Laws Several incidents of people punished under online laws were
reportedacrossTanzaniaanddocumented invariousreportsincluding (MCT,2017;MCT,2018;LHRC,2017;LHRC,2018;HumanRightsWatch,2017,HumanRightsWatch,2018,AmnestyInternational,2017,FreedomHouse,2018).
Thefollowingaresomeoftheincidentsthatoccurredin2017/18: · On21September,ZittoKabwe,oppositionleaderfor
theAllianceforChangeandTransparencyparty,wasarrestedfollowingcommentshemadeonsocialmedia.TheseconcernedtheHouseSpeaker’shandlingofreportsbytwoparliamentarycommitteesformedtoinvestigatetanzaniteanddiamondminingbeforetheyweredebatedinParliament.
· OnOctober 31, ZittoKabwewas again detained bypoliceforallegedlyissuingfalsestatisticsonthenationaleconomicgrowthfigures.HewasaccusedofviolatingtheStatistics Act, 2017.
. OutspokenoppositionMPsTunduLissuandHalimaMdeewere in February and July 2017 arrested and detained for whatwasclaimedasabusingPresidentMagufuli,seditionandincitement.Thevideosoftheirpurportedoffenceswere circulated online.
· AnotheroppositionMP,GodblessLema,wasdetainedforfourmonthsandchargedwithseditionbywayofutteringwhatwasclaimedtobeinsultsagainstPresidentMagufuliinvideoandaudioclipswidelysharedonsocialmedia.
· InMarch2017,Tanzanianmusician,EmmanuelElibariki,famouslyknownasNaywaMitego,wasarrestedanddetainedforadayinrelationtothelyricsofthesongtitled;
74
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
‘Wapo’whichweredeemedabusivetotheGovernmentandPresidentMagufuli.Thesongwaswidelysharedonsocialmediaplatforms.
· In2017,thecaseagainstthecofoundersofthepopulardiscussionsite,JamiiForums,MaxenceMeloandMickeWilliam, continued with proceedings. Their arresthappened inDecember2016.Theywereaccusedofrefusingtoidentifyanonymoususersoftheirplatformwho had written about corruption and other sensitive topics.
· ChisKika,ajournalistworkingwithDar24wasarrestedbytheDaresSalaampoliceafterwritinganarticleonLudewaDistrictCommissioner,AndreaTsere,refutinginformationthatwasviralonsocialmedia.
· OnOctober9,2018,MohabfromOnlineMedia,wasarrestedbyTCRAofficersduetoreasonsthatwerenotdivulged.HewasarrestedinIringaandtransferredtoDaresSalaamwhereafileagainsthimwasopened.
4.6 Shrinking Public Space Alarms Local, International Rights Groups
Criticalreviewofvariousdocumentsincluding(LHRC,2017;LHRC,2018;HumanRightsWatch,2017,HumanRightsWatch,2018,AmnestyInternational,2017,FreedomHouse,2018),revealthatthefastshrinkingpublicspaceinthelasttwoyears,alarmedthemedia,civilsociety,communicationstakeholdersaswellashumanrightsgroupsinandoutsideTanzania.
Documentsindicatedthat,theselawsandregulationswerenotonlyunfriendlytofree,openandsecureonlinecommunication,buttheyalsounderminedcitizens’rightstofreeexpression,privacyandaccesstoinformation.
SuchlawswerealsocondemnedforcontradictingandcontraveninginternationalaswellasregionalinstrumentstowhichTanzaniasubscribedassignatory.TheseincludetheUniversalDeclarationofHumanRights(UDHR),InternationalCovenantonCivilandPoliticalRights(ICCPR)andAfricanCharteronHumanandPeoples’Rights(ACHPR)thatguaranteefreedomofexpression,righttoprivacy,andtherighttoinformation.
75
2017-2018 REPORT
TheLHRCwentfurtherbyrequestingtheMinisterforLegalandConstitutionalAffairstoinitiateaprocessofrevisitingorreviewingfreedomofexpressionasprovidedinpiecesoflegislations,suchastheMediaServiceActandtheCybercrimesAct,withtheviewofremovingormendingproblematicprovisionsincludingambiguousandvagueprovisions(LHRC,2017).
OnepartoftheActwhichisblamedbymanycriticsisSection16,whichsaysthatpublishingfalseormisleadinginformationwaspunishablebyatleastsixmonthsinprison.
InAugust2018,MediaInstituteofSouthernAfricaTanzaniaChapter(Misa-Tan)condemnedSection6implications.Inapublicationentitled,‘SothisisDemocracy?’MISA-Tanexpressedconcernoverviolationsofmediafreedomandfreedomofexpression,callingitanonslaughtagainstthemediainTanzania(MISA,2018)
InJanuary2017,mediastakeholderstookthemattertotheEastAfricanCourtofJustice,challengingtheSectionofthenewlawthatrestrictedmediafreedom.AmongthestakeholdersweretheMediaCouncilofTanzania(MCT),LHRCandTanzaniaHumanRightsDefenders Coalition (THRDC), (LHRC, 2018)
InMarch2018,humanrightsactivistsobtainedaninjunctionbattlingtheapplicationoftheregulationscitingthelawasanaffront to free speech. The injunction was overturned in May 2018 andimplementationofregulationshaltedtheoperationsofsomebloggersincludingJamiiForumwhichceasedforsometimeinorderto avoid the severity of punitive law (LHRC, 2018)
Concerned with this situation, Reporters Without Borders (RSF) called on Tanzanian authorities to repeal sections of the law which barred forumssuchas Jamii frompostinganyreportsbeforeregistration,(RFS,2018)
TheAfricanFreedomofExpressionExchange(AFEX)expresseditsdisappointmentwiththeGovernmentofTanzaniaforpassinginto law the Electronic and Postal Communications (OnlineContent),theregulationsofwhichcontainedclearprovisionsthatcouldfurthertightenthecountry’salreadyrestrictivefreedomofexpressionenvironmentbothonlineandoffline.AFEXappealedtotheGovernmenttotakeintoaccounttheconcernraisedbylocalandinternationalrightsgroupsandrevisetheportionsofthelawthat were an affront to free speech (AFEX, 2018).
76
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
TheAfricanCommissiononHumanandPeoples’Rights(theCommission),alsoissuedastatementexpressingconcernonthegrowingtrendofStatesinEastAfricaadoptingstringentregulationsthatputincheckInternetandonlineplatforms.
ThestatementsaidtheadoptionoftheElectronicandPostalCommunications(OnlineContent)Regulations2018inTanzaniawhich introduced licensing requirements for bloggers,maynegativelyimpacttheabilityofuserstogainaffordableaccesstotheInternet,somethingwhichgoesagainststates’commitmenttoprotecttherightofeveryindividualtoreceiveinformation,aswellastherighttoexpressanddisseminateone’sopinionwithinthelawprovidedunderArticle9oftheAfricanCharteronHumanandPeoples’Rights,(APC,2018)
4.7 With the Tense Political Situation, What is the Future of Online Media?
Despitelegalrelatedchallenges,in2017/18,onlinemediainTanzaniacontinuedtosurvivebutofcourse,notwiththesamemomentumwitnessedinpreviousyears.
Various journalists and other stakeholders interviewed spoke of howsocialmediaincludingblogshaveexpandedthepublicspherebyfacilitatingcommunicationtoTanzanianswhopreviouslylackedaccesstotraditionmedia.ItshouldbenotedthatwiththetypeofmediaownershipTanzaniahave,itisobviousthatjournalistsandeditorsworkingfortraditionalmediaarealwayscontrolledbyinvisible hand of owners and their associates, especially politicians andotherinfluentialpeople.
Commentingonsocialmediabenefits,Tegambwagesaid:“Theirinteractivenaturemakesthemimportantinbothfreeandrestrictivecircumstances,anywhereintheworld.Youhavepeoplebeinginformedfast.Youhavepeopletalkingtofriendsbeyondborders.Youhavepeoplepouringtheirheartsonlineforeveryonetoseeorhear.Youhavetheworldtalkingunfettered.’’
Expressing his conviction of the relevance of socialmedia,Tegambwage,said:“Whiletheymaynotbeapanaceatoshrinkingcivicspace–theyare,indeed,abreathingspaceinasfarasfreedomofexpressionisconcerned,’’
Takingthisfurther,PeterNyanje,saidthatsuchplatformshave
77
2017-2018 REPORT
continuedtoofferwritersandindependentjournalistsaforumtoexpressviewsandreportnewsthatmightnototherwiseappearinmainstreammedia.
Inhisview,theseplatformshavealsoopeneduppossibilitiesforindividualstoestablishprivatenewsoutletsthatproveimmenselypowerfulintermsofreachandreadership.Analysts,BettyMasanjaandRamadhaniKabalesharesimilarviewontherelevanceofsocialmedia.SalomeKitomary,whoisalsoaseniorjournalistforNipashenewspaper,said,theseplatformsaresourcesofincometoyounggraduateswhohadstartedtheirownmultimediaplatformsforthepurposeofearningalivingandutilisingtheirknowledge.
Generally,manyrespondentsadmittedthatinthepasttwoyears,socialmediawerethemajorchannelforpoliticiansespeciallymembersoftheoppositionpartiestoreachouttheirsupportersaftertheGovernmentputabanonpublicrallies.Sincethepresidentialelectionsin2015,Tanzania’sOppositionhasbeenrestrictedbyabanonoppositionralliesandsanctions,intimidation,andpunishmentofcitizensforcriticizingPresidentJohnMagufulioftherulingChamacha Mapinduzi (CCM). Since his election, the President has taken toughmeasuresagainstcorruptionandimprovedgovernanceinthecountry.However,heishighlycriticisedforhisintolerancetocriticism,asituationleadingtonumerousprosecutionsofhiscriticsandsocialmediausers.
However,aftertheonlineregulationswereadopted,theseplatformsarenolongerfreeenoughtoprovideindependentandin-depthanalysis as they used to before the disruptions.
4.8 Strategies to Promote Good Use of Online Media Inthepasttwoyears,theGovernmentcontinuedtakingserious
measuresandlegalactionagainstpeoplepostingindecentcontentonsocialmedia.
Senior leaders, including,made itclear that theGovernmentwouldcontinuetosafeguardthecountry’scultureforpresentandfuturegenerationsandthatitwouldnotallowanyonetopromoteimmoralityonsocialmedia.Italsotooksternlegalactionagainstthoseaccusedofmisusingonlinemedia.Amongthosewhohavetested thesweeterbitterofonlineacts include the following:MusicianNassibAbdul(DiamondPlatnumz),FaustineCharles
78
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
(Nandy)MissTanzania,WemaSepetu,HamisaMobeto,GiftStanford(GigyMoney),SusanMichael,JaneIkunda(Sanchoka),RutyfiaAbubakary(AmberRutty)andSaidBakari(JamesDerious).SomeoftheseartistesweretakentocourtorsummonedbyBasatawheretheywereaskedtoissueapublicapologyandissuedwithdifferentformsofpenaltiesincludingbanning.TheGovernmentthroughtheMinistryofInformation,Culture,SportsandArts,continuedtoworkcloselywithBasataandtheTCRAtoregulatetheTanzaniancreativesectorafterPresidentJohnMagufuliorderedtheTCRAinDecembertotakelegalactionagainstartisteswhoentertain nudity in their videos.
Regardingpublicawareness,inthepasttwoyears,TCRAcontinuedtoimplementfocusedinformationandawarenesscampaignstoeducateconsumersandthegeneralpublicontheirrightsandobligationsandhowtoavoidmobileandInternetfraud.Theeducationalsoaddressedthelegalrequirementsfortheregistrationof SIM cards.
TheTCRAalsolaunchedcampaignsforresponsibleuseofsocialmediawithmessagesagainst the initiatingand transmittingor forwardingofoffensivecontentonline.BetweenJulyandSeptember2018,TCRAcoordinatedtheproductionof24messagesaddressingresponsibleandethicaluseofcommunicationservicesand application (TCRA, 2018)
4.9 Concluding Remarks Fromwhathasbeensaidinthischapter,itisclearthatinlast
twoyears,TanzaniaMainlandcontinuedtomakeprogressintermsofthenumberofcitizensaccessingInternetandotherdigitaldevices.However,thechaptershows,thisprogressdidnotpromotefreedomofexpression(FOE)andaccesstoinformationasexpected.Thechapterdiscussedvariousdrawbackshinderedthegrowthandprogressofonlinemediawhichrangefrompoliticalsituationexecratedaswellasrestrictivelawsandregulations.
The chapter further showed how authorities used restrictive laws asmechanismstocontrolonlinemediaaswellandpunishcertainindividualswhoareperceivedasathreatbytheGovernment.Italsoraisedconcernastohowfaronlinemediawillgogiventhepolitical tension in the country.
79
2017-2018 REPORT
4.10 Recommendations Thisarticlemakesthefollowingrecommendations: FortheMedia: · Inform, educate andmobilise the public to demand
Internetfreedomaswellasreportincidentsofonlinerightsviolations;
· Challengetheenforcementoflawsandregulationsthatviolateonlinerightsandsuppressfreedomofexpressionand
· Sensitizepeopleonconstructiveuseofdigital. For Civil Society · Beonalerttodigitalviolationsandgatherevidenceof
theirnegativeeffectsandconsequenceswhichwouldbeusedinpressuringtheGovernmenttoabolishpracticesthatviolatetherightsofcitizensand
. ContinuemonitoringandpayinggreaterattentiontoviolationsoftherighttoaccessInternet.
Academicians . Gatherevidenceofthenegativeeffectsandconsequences
oflawsandregulationsthatviolatefreedomofexpressionsandpushforlawreformstoabolishthosewhichviolatecitizenrights.
FortheGovernment . Reviewlawsandregulationsthatviolatepeople’srights
toonlinecommunication; · Amend all restrictive provisions in theCybercrimes
Act,theElectronicandPostalCommunications(OnlineContent)RegulationsandtheMediaServicesandreplacethembyprogressivesectionsthatwillguaranteefreedomofexpressionandthemediainlinewithinternationalhumanrightsstandards;
· StopopenthreatsagainstjournalistsandhumanrightsdefenderswhoexposewrongdoingofsomeGovernmentleaders and
· Workwithmediaandotherstakeholders tosensitise
80
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
peopleonconstructiveuseofonlinemedia.
References AmnestyInternationalReport(2016-2017) FreedomHouse(2018).TanzaniaCountryReportontheFreedom
ofthePressretrievedfromhttps://freedomhouse.org/ HumanRightsWatch(2017,2018) LHRC(2017)TanzaniaHumanRightsReport,LegalandHuman
RightsCentre,DaresSalaam,Tanzania. LHRC(2018)TanzaniaHumanRightsReport(Jan–June2018),
LegalandHumanRightsCentre,DaresSalaam,Tanzania. MCT(2017)PressFreedomViolationsRegisterReport,Dares
Salaam,Tanzania MCT(2018)PressFreedomViolationsRegisterReport(Jan–June
2018),DaresSalaam,Tanzania. RSF (2018) Media Ownership Monitor (Tanzania) Report, Media
CouncilofTanzaniaandReporterswithoutBorders,DaresSalaam,Tanzania.
TCRA,(2017)CommunicationStatisticsReportofDecember,DaresSalaam,Tanzania
TCRA,(2018)CommunicationStatisticsReportofSeptember,DaresSalaam,Tanzania
StateofInternetFreedominAfrica2017,CIPETA,www.cipeta.org StateofInternetFreedominAfrica2018,CIPETA,www.cipeta.org URT(2015).TheCybercrimeAct,2015,DaresSalaam,Tanzania. URT(2018)AmendmentsoftheStatisticsAct2015,Cap.351,2018,
DaresSalaam,Tanzania. URT (2018)ElectronicsandPostalCommunications (Online
Content)Regulations(2018),DaresSalaam,Tanzania. (https://rsf.org/en/news/tanzanias-most-popular-site-banned-
posting-new-content) (https://www.apc.org/en/news/concern-growing-trend-
stringent-regulation-Internet-east-african-states) (http://www.africafex.org/country-highlights/tanzanias-
newly-adopted-electronic-and-postal-communication-code-is-retrogressive-and-an-affront-to-free-speech-afex)
81
2017-2018 REPORT
Chapter Five
Media Support in Tanzania Mainland
5.0 Introduction Thischapterfocusesontheroleplayedbyvariousorganisations
insupportingthemediainTanzaniain2017and2018.Someoftheaspectsexploredincludeactivitiesundertakenbysupporters,jointinitiatives,viewsofmediasupportersonhowtoimprovemediadevelopmentsupportandtheperceptionofbeneficiarieson provided support. The chapter ends with a conclusion and recommendations.
5.1 Organisations Supporting Media in Tanzania OrganisationswhichhavebeensupportingthemediainTanzania
inthepastdecadearemoreorlessthesame.AnotablenewcomerisInternews,whichisperceivedbyjournalistsashavingmadeanimpactwithinashorttime.Theseinclude;theMediaCouncilofTanzania, (MCT), Tanzania Media Foundation (TMF), Journalists EnvironmentalAssociationofTanzania(JET),TanzaniaMediaWomenAssociation (TAMWA),UnitedNationalEducationalScientificandCulturalOrganisation(Unesco),MediaInstituteofSouthernAfrica,TanzaniaChapter(Misa-Tan),UnionofTanzaniaPressClubs(UTPC),TanzaniaEditorsForum(TEF)andFriedrichEbert Stiftung (FES). These institutions support the mediasignificantly,especiallyintheareaoftraining,whichtheyhaveallalongpaidmuchattentionto.
5.2 Internews Internewsisaninternationalnon-profitorganisationwhichworks
toensureaccesstotrustedqualityinformationthatempowerspeople to have a voice in their future and live a healthy, secure and rewardinglife.
Theorganisationsupports journalistsinTanzaniaindifferentways includingoffering trainingandothercapacitybuildingopportunities.
WenceslausMushi,theInternewsDirectorofInformationand
82
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
Communicationmention`BoreshaHabari’,afive-yearprojectasoneoftheactivitybenefitingmediaimmensely.Theprojectaimsatimprovingmedianewsqualityandstrengthenthecapacityofcivilorganisationstoengagethemediasothat,people-orientedactivitiesoftheformercanbepublicisedforthebenefitofsociety.
Internews,throughtheBoreshaHabariproject,hassofarprovidedcapacitybuildingtrainingtojournaliststoproducehighqualitylocalnewscoverage,wherein2018,atotalof876journalistsfromTanzania Mainland and Zanzibar were trained on various topics, thepurposebeingtoimprovejournalismandqualityofnewsproduced.
Italsoprovidedcapacitybuildingto20communityradiostationsthroughtraining,coachingandmentorship,trainedyouthandwomenoncommunityradiodevelopmentandprogrammingwherefortheyear2018,atotalof442youthandadultwomenfromTanzaniaMainlandandZanzibarbenefitted.
Othergroupswhichbenefittedfromthetrainingwere58non-statenewsoutletswhosetrainingcoveredvarioustopicsincludingjournalism,newmedialawsinTanzaniaandtheirrequirements.
Journalistsand theirorganisationshavealsobenefited fromprofessional forumsorganisedbytheorganisation includingroundtableworkshops,meetings,awarenesscampaigns,andmarketingforums.Besidesthat,Internews,supportedmedia-sectorCSOsandinstitutionsthatservetostrengthentheindependentmediaorjournalists.
Key Players Working with Internews Inprovidingmediasupport,Internewsisworkingcloselywith
severalorganisationsincludingtheMCT;TanzaniaBoraInitiative,ayouthorganisationwhichmotivatesyoungmenandwomentobeenterprisingandliberatethemselvessociallyandeconomically;JamiiMedia;Geopoll,anorganisationengagedinelectronicmediamonitoringandconductingsurveys;theLegalandHumanRightsCentre;aswellasthreeUniversities,namelyZanzibarJournalismandMassCommunicationCollege,St.AugustineUniversityofTanzania,aswellasUniversityofDaresSalaam’sSchoolofJournalismandMassCommunication.
OnInternewsperceptionoftheimpactofitsactivitiestojournalists
83
2017-2018 REPORT
andmediahouses,Mushisaidhisorganisationisputtingemphasison practical training and hope this approach helps both thejournalistsandmediahousestobemoreprofessional.
RegardinggapsinmediasupportinTanzania,Mushisaidtheyhavenotedthatmentoringyoungjournalistsisyettobetakenseriously,andthereisalackofbasiccontentcollectionequipment,especiallyinbroadcasting.
As for thebestway to supportmediaactivities inTanzania,Mushisuggestedthatitisimportanttogivesupportinequipmentprovision,initiatemoreprojectstomentoryoungjournalistsandhelpthosewhoopttospecialiseinspecificjournalisticareas.
5.3 Tanzania Media Women’s Association TanzaniaMediaWomen’sAssociation(Tamwa)isanorganisation
whosemissionistoadvocatewomenandchildren’srightsbyconducting awareness raising activities to advocate cultural,policyandlegalchangesandtransformsocietythroughtheuseofthemedia.Itpowerswomeninthemediatoensuretheyplayasignificantroleinthisadvocacymissionbyusingdifferentmediaplatforms(TAMWA.
AccordingtoTamwaExecutiveDirectorEddaSanga,theorganisationhasbeensupportingthemediainTanzaniaindifferentways.Thefollowingaresomeofthesupportashighlightedbythedirector:
Tamwasupportsthemediainvariousactivitiesincludingtheareaoftrainingwherein2017itprovidedareportingtrainingto30journalists under a special project jointly sponsored by the French EmbassyandTanzaniaPrivateSectorFoundation,and19journalistsonroadsafetyreportingundertheRoadSafetyProject.
Inthepasttwoyears,theorganisationalsosponsoredtwojournaliststoundertakeonline trainingwhile oneof itsmembersgot ascholarshiptotraininCopenhagen,thankstothesupportofDanishInternationalDevelopmentAgency.
Tamwa’sroleintheRoadSafetyCampaigncontinuedin2018whereabatchof45editorsfromDaresSalaam,CoastandMorogororegionsweretrainedonRoadSafetyreporting.Atotalof43journalistsfromDaresSalaamandMorogororegionsalsogotasimilartraininginApril and July 2018.
84
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
Theassociation’srecordsshowthatatotalof147journalistsandeditorsbenefittedfromseveraltrainingprogrammesin2017-2018.Outofthese,75weremaleand72werefemale,anindicationthatTamwaissensitivetogenderequality.
In2018,Tamwaofferedfellowshipstosevenyoungjournaliststoparticipateintheon-the-jobtrainingandgotoruralareastowritenewsstoriesaswellasnewspaperfeaturearticlesongenderbasedviolence(GBV).RuralareasearmarkedforpracticalworkincludedKisarawe,Mvomero,LindiRural,NewalaandRuangwa.MakumbushoinDaresSalaam’sKinondoniDistrictaswellasKivuleandKitundainDaresSalaam’sIlalaDistrictwerealsotargetedforpracticalwork.MediaoutletswhichbenefittedfromthisprojectincludedMajira,HabariLeo,DailyNews,JamvilaHabari,NipasheandMtanzanianewspapers,aswellasJamiiForumsocialnetwork.
AtthesametimeTamwalinkedsomecommunityradiostoGBVcommitteesintheareasnamedabove,toensuretheygotenoughmediacoverageandcommunitymembersplayaroleintheexchangeofideasongender-basedviolence,ascommunityradiosencourageparticipationofcommunityresidentsinprogrammepreparationandbroadcasting.
BesidesDanida,whichhadbeentheassociation`smainsponsor,Sangasaid,theassociationnetworkswithanumberoforganisationsincludingMCTandmembersoftheCoalitiononNationalRoadSafetyCampaign,incarryingoutitsmediarelatedactivities.
CommentingontheimpactofTamwa’ssupportactivitiestomediahousesandjournalists,SangaobservedthatjournalistswhogettrainingonreportingissueslikeGBVandfemalegenitalmutilation(FGM)endupwritingreadablygoodandrelevantstorieswhentheygotothefield.Sheaddedthattheseeffortsmusthavecontributedtoawarenesscreation,asmostwomeninthecountryareshowingsignsofunderstandingtheirrightsandareaggressivelyclaimingthem.
Asforgapsinthekindofmediasupportbeinggivenbyorganisations,theTamwabosspointedoutthatthebiggestproblemislackofadequatefunds,whichlimitchancesoftrainedjournaliststogotoremoteareas,identifytestimonialcasesandcoverthemindetail.Sheadded:“Youmaynotethatevennewspaperreportsonissues
85
2017-2018 REPORT
likegender-basedviolencedonot,inmostcases,reachthetargetedgroupsasnewspapershardlyventureouttoremoteruralareas.’’
AstowhatshouldbedonetoimprovesupporttomediaorganisationsandjournalistsinTanzania,Sangasuggestedthatsomeresourcesshouldbedirectedtosolvingsomeoftheobviouschallengesfacingthe industry like poor newspaper distribution. She also advocates introducingthekindoftrainingwhichshapeyoungjournaliststobeinquisitiveandanalytical,asopposedtoonlyfocusingonimpartingbasicgeneralwritingskills.
5.6 FES TANZANIA FriedrichEbertStiftung(FES)isanon-profitGermanFoundation
fundedbytheGovernmentoftheFederalRepublicofGermany,committedtotheadvancementofsocial-politicalandeconomicdevelopmentinthespiritsocialdemocracy,throughciviceducation,researchandinternationalcooperation.OneofitsprogrammesinTanzaniaisonmediafreedomandfreedomofexpression(FES).
Media Support Offered by FES Tanzania AccordingtoFESTanzaniaProjectCoordinator,AmonPetro,their
organisationhasbeensupportingthemediainTanzaniaindifferentways.Thefollowingaresomeofthesupportashighlightedbytheproject coordinator.
Inthepasttwoyears,FESundertookseveralactivitiesincludingsupportingprintingofapublicationtitled‘FreedomofExpressionandCriminalLawinTanzania’,abookwhichgivesasnapshotontheuseofcriminallawinregulatingfreedomofexpression.Italsonavigatesthroughtherecentlypassedmediarelatedlaws,analysethethreatsandchallengesposted,andgivesuggestionsonthewayforward.
Italsosupportedcapacitybuildingtrainingtojournalistsinordertoenablethemimprovetheirabilityinproducingnewsstoriesandmediaanalyseswhichareclear,accurate,thorough,cogentandfair,withintheroomprovidedbycurrentmedialawsandtheirregulations.FEStrainingalsoaimedatdevelopingjournalists’skillsonhumanrightsandhumanrightsdefenders.
Thetrainingbenefitted124journalistsfromtwelveregionswhichwere clustered into four zones. These were Central, South, East and
86
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
Northzones.Apartfromtrainingandpublishing,FEShasbeenalong-termpartnerinorganisingtheannualWorldPressFreedomDay event in Tanzania.
Impact of FES media Support CommentingontheimpactofFESmediasupportactivitiestomedia
organisationsandjournalists,FEZTanzaniaProjectCoordinator,AmonPetro,saidfeedbackfromjournalistsindicatedthattheyappreciatedtheknowledgegainedandexpressedthewishtohavemoretrainingsessionsinvariousareasoftheirprofession.
ThecoordinatornotedthatoneoftheshortcomingsofmediasupportinTanzaniaislackofpropermonitoringandassessmenttofindouthowvarioussupportactivitiesmakeadifferenceinpracticalperformance.Hesuggestedthatthisaspectandsponsorshipofmorementorshipprogrammesdeservespecialattention.
5.7 Misa-Tan The Media Institute of Southern African (MISA), is a non-
governmentalorganisationestablishedin1992withitsmajorobjectivebeingtopromoteafree,independentandpluralisticpressinserviceofdemocracyandgoodgovernanceintheSouthernAfricaDevelopmentCommunity(SADC)region.ItsTanzaniaChapter,Misa-Tanwasregisteredin1997undertheSocietiesOrdinance,1954(www.)
Support Offered by Misa-Tan Intheperiodcoveredunderthisreport,theorganisationsupported
themediaindifferentwaysincludingofferingtrainingandinaspectsrelatedtoadvocacyandprotectionofmediafreedomandfreedomofexpression.
According to Misa Acting National Director, SengiyumvaGasirigwa,theirorganisationhasbeensupportingthemediainTanzaniaindifferentways.Thefollowingaresomeofthesupportasnarratedbytheactingdirector.
Aspartofthecampaigntodecriminalisefreeexpressionandchampionfortheestablishmentofprogressivemediaandaccesstoinformationlaws,Misa-Tanorganisedandconductedspecialisedtrainingtolawmakersandmediapractitioners.
About240MembersofParliamentand150journalistsbenefitted
87
2017-2018 REPORT
fromtheseengagementsinthepastthreeyears.Also,about200journalistsandeditorsfromdifferentmediaorganisations,weretrainedonATIissues,Internetuseandelectioncoverageforthelastthreeyears,aspartoftheorganisation’scapacitybuildinginitiatives.
Besidesthat,theorganisationtrainedabout240staffmembersoftheTanzaniaJudiciaryonATIandcustomercareskillssince2015todate.ItisbelievedthatenlighteningJudiciarystaffonpressfreedomandfreedomofexpressionissuesmayhelpthemtohandlerelatedcaseswithunderstandingandmorecompetence.
The organisation also conducted investigations and mediamonitoringonpressfreedomviolationsinthecountryandcompiledreports which are used in advocacy work.
IncollaboratingwithUnesco,theorganisationpreparedactivitiestomarkthe“InternationalDaytoEndImpunity’’,aneventaimedatraisingawarenesstoprotecttherighttofreedomofexpressionandpromoteaccesstojusticeforjournalists,artists,writers,musicians,humanrightsdefendersandactivistsaroundtheworldwhoarepersecutedforexercisingtheirrighttofreedomofexpression.Misa-Tanhadalsobeentakingpartinco-organisingmediastakeholdersperiodic reviewmeetings involvingmediapractitioners,civilsociety,GovernmentrepresentativesandMPstobrainstormonissuesrelatedtopressfreedomandfreedomofexpression.
Key Partners Working with Misa-Tan Inthecourseofimplementingitsactivities,Misa-Tanhadbeen
receivingsupportfromanumberoforganisationsincluding;UnitedNationsTanzaniaOffice,MediaCouncilofTanzania,FESTanzania,Article19EastAfrica,Unesco,UnionofTanzaniaPressClubs,TCRAandotherorganisations.
WithregardtowhethertheMisa-Tansupporttothemediahavehadasignificantimpactto,theorganisationActingNationalDirector,SengiyumvaGasirigwa,pointedoutthattrainingsessionswithjournalistsandeditorsonmedialawshavebeenaneye-opener,astheorganisationrealisedthatmostofthemwerenotconversantwithlegaldevelopmentswhichhaveabigeffectontheirday-to-daywork.
Heobservedthatmuchasitmaylookstrange,manyjournalistsinthesocietyhavenoreadingculture.“Hence,trainingonmedialaws
88
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
havebeenbeneficialtojournalistswhogotachancetoparticipate,aswellastomediahousestheyrepresented,’’hesaid.
Onthegapsinmediasupport,Gasirigwanotedthatsomethingshouldbedonetochangethemindsetofmediahouseowners,whomheaccusedofnotinvestingmuchinstaffdevelopmentbywayofallocatingadequatefundsintheirbudgetsfortrainingpurpose.“Therearecaseswherejournalistswhoopttogoforalongcourse,evenbyself-sponsorship,enduplosingtheirjobs,”notedGasirigwa,furthersuggestingthatsupportersofmediaactivitiesshouldalsohaveprogrammeswhichtargetmediaownersintermsofenlighteningthemabouttheirroleinmediadevelopment.
Anotheraspect,whichGasirigwasaidisasourceofconcern,isthesituationofinadequatemediaresearch,whichleadstothesituationwherenotmuchisknownaboutnumerousmediarelatedareas,likeunemploymentamongjournalists,workingconditions,genderinequality,trainingprovidedbyschoolsofjournalism,mediaownership,investmentsinthemediaindustry,challengesofnewspaperproduction,andmanyothers.Hissuggestionwasthatmediasupportingorganisationsshouldaddressmediaresearchchallengesseriously.
5.8 Tanzania Human Rights Defenders Coalition (THRDC) TanzaniaHumanRightsDefendersCoalition(THRDC)isan
umbrellaorganisationforhumanrightsdefenders,includingjournalists.Theorganisationcomprisesmorethan150membersfromacrossthecountry.
Support Offered by THRDC Realisingthatthemediahasbeengoingthroughadifficultperiod
forthelastthreeyears,characterisedbyenactmentofdraconianlawsandinsecurityofjournalists,THRDChascomeupwithaprogrammetoimprovetheworkingenvironmentofjournalistsandmediahousesthroughcapacitybuilding,advocacy,andprotectionofmediaworkers.
According to THRDC National Coordinator OnesmoOlengurumwa,theirorganisationhasbeensupportingthemediainTanzaniaindifferentways.ThefollowingaresomeofthesupportashighlightedbyOlengurumwa.
89
2017-2018 REPORT
Activitiesundertakenin2017and2018include:*Empoweringmediapractitionersinmainstreamandonlinemediatoprotectthemselves,wherebyrevieweddocumentsshowthatin2017theCoalitionconductedsixcapacitybuildingactivities,reachingabout270beneficiaries,includingjournalists.
. InJuly2018THRDCassisted10journalistsfromTanzaniatoattendasecuritymanagementtrainingforjournalists,whichwasorganisedbyTHRDC’sUganda-basedsisterorganisation,DefendDefenders.The journalistswhoattendedtheKampalacoursewerefromNipashe,TheCitizen,TanzaniaDaimaandMwananchinewspapers.OtherswerefromITV,AzamTV,StarTV,Radio5andLoliondo FM.
Legal Aid Provision to Journalists and Media Organisations Theorganisation’sreportsalsoshowthatithadbeenontheforefront
intheprovisionoflegalaidtojournalistswhohavebeenattackedor prosecuted in the course of their work. In 2018 the Coalition, throughitsProtectionDepartment,providedlegalaidtoprosecutedjournalists,includingEmmanuelKibikiofNjombeRegion,SittaTumawhowasarrestedinTarime,ChristopherGamainaandtwoothersfromMwanza.
THRDCalsoprovidedlegalaidtobloggersMohabFulweandFridaySimbaya,whowerearrestedanddetained for severaldaysforrunningonlineTVswithoutlicencefromtheTanzaniaCommunicationsRegulatoryAuthority(TCRA).
Challenging Draconian Laws Which Limit Media Freedom Inordertochallengedraconianlawswhichwererecordedin2017-
2018,theorganisationteamedupwithotherinstitutionstotakelegalmeasuresagainstsomeoftheselaws.
ItcollaboratedwithMCTandLegalandHumanRightCentre(LHRC)tofilethreemajorstrategiccasesincourt,whichincludedacasefiledinMtwaraHighCourttochallengetheOnlineContentRegulationsof2018.
Andthen,therewasthecasetochallengetheMediaServicesAct(2016)whichwasalsojointlyfiledintheEastAfricanCourtofJustice,whileanothercasetochallengesomeprovisionsoftheMediaServicesAct(2016)wasfiledattheHighCourtinMwanza.
90
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
Monitoring and reporting on human rights abuses againstjournalists,wasanotheractivityimplementedbyTHRDC.In2017,theorganisationrecorded35journalists’securityrelatedincidents.These included physical attacks, prosecution, online attacks and otherthreats.Usingthisdata,theorganisationdevelopsannualreportsonhumanrightssituationinTanzania,whichareusedbyother institutions and coalitions in advocacy work.
Furthermore,inthelasttwoyears,theorganisationissuedanumberofpressreleasescondemningincidentsofpressfreedomviolation,whenever they occurred.
The incidents included banning of newspapers as well asdisappearanceandtortureofjournalists.Insomeoftheseincidents,pressstatementswereissuedincollaborationwithothermediaandhumanrightsorganisations.
ItwasalsorevealedthatTHRDChasbeenprovidingshorttimerelocationtosomejournalistsreceivingthreatsfromunknownpeople and in 2017, they offered this kind of assistance to two journalists.
Key Players Working with THRDC THRDCworkstogetherwithothermediaorganisationssuchas
theMCT,MOATandUTPCundertheambitoftheCoalitiononRighttoInformation(CoRI).Theorganisationalsoworkscloselywithhumanrightsorganisationsatlocal,regionalandinternationallevels.
Issues on THRDC Media Support Commentingon the impactof the supportprovidedbyhis
organisationtojournalistsandmediaorganisations,Olengurumwasaidjournalistswhosetrainingtheysponsorgetequippedwiththeknowledgetokeepthemselvessecurewhilethosewhogotlegalassistance were set free by the courts.
ThecoordinatoralsopointedoutthatthroughTHRDCpublicawarenessprogramme,journalistshavewonrecognitionashumanrightsdefenderswhodeserveprotectionandsecurity.
AsforgapsinmediasupportactivitiesinTanzania,henotedwithconcernthattheTHRDCissofartheonlyorganisationpreoccupiedwiththeprotectionandsecurityofjournalists,addingthatthetaskistoobigtobehandledbyasingleinstitution.
91
2017-2018 REPORT
“Journalistsneedsecuritygearlikespecialjacketswhencoveringassignmentsthatarerifewithrisks,suchaselections,workers’strikesandriots;however,hisorganisationcannotprovideforthemallonabigscaleduetofinancialconstraints,”Olengurumwaobserved.
Commentingon thebestway to supportmediahouses andjournalistsinTanzania,hesuggestedthatmoreplayersshouldcomeforth and participate in the provision of security for journalists, and mediahousesshouldincludepersonnel’ssecurityontheirlistofpriorities.
5.9 Journalists Environmental Association of Tanzania (JET)
JETisanindependent,non-governmentalorganisationwhichusesthemediatopromotetheenvironmentagendainTanzania.Italsoproducesanddisseminateseducationalpublicationsonenvironmentalissues.
Support Offered by JET JETassistsjournaliststogotothefieldwheretheycangather
newsstoriesandfeaturearticlesonenvironmentalmatters.Itofferstrainingforjournalistsandeditorsaswellasorganiseforumstodiscussemergingissuesonenvironment.
AccordingtoJohnChikomo,theOrganisation’sexecutivedirector,in2017,JETconductedarefreshercoursefor30journalistsfromDareSalaam,Iringa,MbeyaandLindionreportinglandrightsinthecountry.
ChikomoobservedthatlanddisputeshavebeenabigprobleminTanzaniaforalongtime,hencetheimportanceoftrainingjournalistsonhowtocoverthissituationanalyticallyandcompetently.
Duringthesameyear,JETorganisedameetingwitheditorstodiscussthebestwaytohandlemediacoverageoftheworldwidebiospherecrisis, which affects Tanzania as well. The JET boss disclosed that in2018,theorganisationintendedtotrain30journalistskeenonspecializinginreportingonenvironmentalissues.
Commentingontheimportanceofthesupportinterventions,Chikomosaid:“Wemonitornewsstoriesandfeaturearticlesinnewspapersaswellaselectronicmediatofindoutwhatispublished
92
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
onenvironmentalissuesandassesstheimpactofourcampaign.On the whole, the journalists we trained have not let us down. Hence,wethinkourinitiativeshaveanimpact,althoughwecanonlyaffordtotrainalimitednumberofreportersandeditors.”
Asforgapsinmediasupport,theJETexecutivedirectorobservedthatthereispoorcoverageofenvironmentaldevelopmentsinruralareas,whereover90percentoftheTanzanianslive,addingthatinadequatefundsareabigsetback.
OnwhatshouldbedonetoimprovemediasupportinTanzania,theJETbosssuggestedthatmediahousesneedtoworkwithenvironmentalcivilorganisationsandstrategisetogetheronhowtoraisefundsforthepurposeofpromotingtheenvironmentalagenda.
5.10 Tanzania Media Foundation (TMF) TanzaniaMediaFoundation(TMF)seekstosupportandpromote
investigativeandpublicinterestjournalismthroughgrantsandlearning,sothatthepublicisbetterinformed,abletodebateanddemandgreateraccountabilityacrossthecountry.
TMF Media Support AccordingtotheFoundation’sInterimExecutiveDirector,Fausta
Musokwa,theirorganisationhasbeensupportingthemediainTanzaniaindifferentways.Thefollowingcomprisesomeofthesupportashighlightedbytheactingexecutivedirector.
TheTMFsupportsthemediathroughtrainingandgrants.Dividedintoinstitutionalandindividualgrants, theyareavailabletocontentproducers,mediaoutletsandjournalists.AccordingtoTMF records, in the past two years, the foundation offered 21 institutionalgrantstocontentproducersandmediaoutletsaswellas80individualgrantstojournalists.
Whileindividualgrantssupportedarangeofissuesincludingraisingruralvoices,reportingondevelopment,healthandroadsafety,institutionalgrantsincluded13contentgrantsonenvironmental,landrightsandconservationaswellashealth(maternalandchild),governanceandwomen’seconomicparticipation.
In2017,eightcontenttransformationgrantswereawardedtomediaoutletswiththeobjectiveofincreasingeachoutlet’scapacity
93
2017-2018 REPORT
toproducequalitycontentandstrengthengovernanceandmediabusiness practices.
TMFalsopromotescontinuouslearningbylinkingjournalistsforpeer-to-peerknowledgesharingandveteranjournalistswithjuniorandmid-careerjournalistsformentorship.In2017and2018,TMForganisedsixlearningactivities,eachofwhichwasattendedby at least 20 journalists. The foundation also introduced a data journalismclubforyoungjournalistsin2018andarrangedfortwodiscussionsessionsonmedialandscape.
Key Players Working with TMF TMFreceivescorefundingfromtheembassiesofIrelandand
Switzerland,anditalsoworkswithHivos,theEuropeanJournalismCentre,theGlobalRoadSafetyPartnership,UNESCOandEvidenceforAction.Locally,TMFisanorganisingcommitteememberofWorldPressFreedomDayaswellasamembertotheCoalitionontheRighttoInformationCommittee(CoRI).ThefoundationalsoworkscloselywiththeMinistryofHealth,CommunityDevelopment,Gender,ElderlyandChildrenaswellasTanzaniaEditorsForum(TEF),TanzaniaMediaWomenAssociation(Tamwa)andtheUnionofTanzaniaPressClubs(UTPC).
CommentingonhowTMFsupporthelpsjournalistsandtheirorganisations, the Musokwa, noted that institutions whichgotthecontentwithtransformationgrantin2018wereabletoaddress structural weaknesses in order to enhance their editorial independence and quality content production. She also pointed out thatmentorshiptobothinstitutionsandjournalistswerehelpfulincapacitybuilding.
Asforgapsinmediasupport,shesaidthereareareaswhichstillneedsupportlikeincreasingdigitalliteracyamongjournalistsandmediainstitutionsasawhole.Musokwafurtherremarked:
“Our assessment reveals that there isminimaluseofdigitalapplications at individual and institutional level, and that institutions havenotbeenabletosufficientlybenefitfinanciallyfromdigitaltechnology.’’
AsforthebestwaytosupportthemediainTanzania,theinterimexecutivedirectorsaidsincethemediasectorinTanzaniaisstillunder-performing,supportshouldaddressfactorsbehindthis
94
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
situation,whichincludelegalframeworkofregulations. Sheaddedthatsupportofthesectorneedtopromotesustainability,
so thatmedia outlets canmanage to stand alone insteadofdependingonpoliticalorbusinesspatronagethatsubsequentlythreatens editorial independence.
5.11 UNESCO and Other Supporters TheUnitedNationsEducationalScientificandCulturalOrganisation
(Unesco)hasbeenabigmediasupporterinTanzaniainthepastaswellasduringthe2017-2018period.Revieweddocumentsshowthatithashelpedtostrengthencommunityradiostationsthroughtraining,equipmentsupport,buildingorganisationalcapacityandinvolvementinmonitoringaswellasassessmentofcommunityradio activities.
Theorganisationhasalsoplayedaroleinprofessionaldevelopmentofmediaworkers,inbothprivateandpublicsectors.ItplaysabigroleinorganisingandfundingtheWorldPressFreedomDaycommemorationinthecountry,aswellasothermediarelatedactivities.
UnionofTanzaniaPressClubs TheUnionofTanzaniaPressClubs(UTPC)isanothermedia
supportingorganisation.Itisanumbrellaorganisationofabout23pressclubsalloverTanzania,anditsmissionistocreateanenvironmentthatenablesstrong,efficientandeffectivepressclubsinTanzania,whichcontributetowardsbuildingademocraticandjust society.
UTPC,whichiscurrentlybeingfundedbytheSwedishInternationalDevelopmentAgency,isengagedincapacitybuildingthroughtraining,researchandconductingstudytoursforjournalists.In2017,itorganisedaspecialcourseforwomenjournalistsandseveralzonalpressclubmembers.TheorganisationparticipatedinmajormediaeventssuchastheWorldPressFreedomDay.
5.12 Media Council of Tanzania (MCT) The Media Council of Tanzania (MCT) is an independent, voluntary,
self-regulatingbodyestablishedin1995withtheobjectiveofpromotingfreedomofthemediaandensuringhighestprofessionalstandards and accountability in the country, (MCT, 2018).
95
2017-2018 REPORT
MCT’s2017AnnualReportpostedonitswebsiterevealsthat,majoractivitiesplannedforimplementationduringtheyearunderreviewwere:
· Toconductadvocacyforconstitutionalandpolicyreforms; · InstitutelitigationagainsttheMediaServicesAct,2016,
documentandinvestigatepressfreedomviolations; · Maintainthepressfreedomviolationsregister(PFVR)and · Engagecollegesonteachingstandardsusingmonitoring
evidence. Otherearmarkedactivitieswere: · OrganisetheExcellenceinJournalismAwardsTanzania
(EJAT)2016; · Advocate review and repeal of anti-media laws in
Zanzibar; · Disseminateadvocacyworkthroughpublishingonline
Media Watch and Barazani Newsletters and · Conductmediationandarbitrationofcomplaintsbrought
before the Council. MCTalsointendedto: · Monitormediaperformance; · Lookingattrendsofprofessionalandethicalstandards
andadviseeditorsaccordingly; · Publish reviewed Code of Ethics for Media Professionals · Mentorandsupporttheprofessionalgrowthforyoung
journaliststhrough.(MCT, 2018) Accordingtothe‘2017AnnualReport’andinterviewswithMCT
deskofficers,theCouncilachievedsuccessinmostoftheactivitiesplannedfor2017and2018,althoughthe2018Reportisstillbeingcompiled.
Advocacy Regardingadvocacy,theCouncilworkedwithitspartnersinthe
CoalitionontheRighttoInformation(CoRI)toundertakeseveralactivities.
In2017,CoRIheldfourmeetingswithkeyagendaitemsfocusingondecreaseinfreedomspaceofcivilsocietyandthemediainTanzania.ThiswasatatimewhentheGovernmentusedtheMediaServicesAct,2016tobanorsuspendsomenewspapers,thustemptingCoRImemberstounanimouslyagreetochallengetheGovernmentin
96
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
courtagainstmeasurestaken(MCT,2017). In2018CoRIheld5meetingsinthefirsthalfoftheyearinwhich
issuesrelatedtotheElectronicandPostalCommunications(OnlineContent)Regulations,2018,aswellasthefiningof5TVStationsbytheContentCommitteeofTanzaniaCommunicationRegulatoryAuthority(TCRA),amongothers,werediscussed.
MCT’s online newsletters, Media Watch and Barazani, were publishedasscheduledinboth2017and2018andwereinstrumentalindisseminatinginformationonadvocacyworkinTanzania.TheCouncilalsoparticipatedinradioandtelevisionprogrammesforadvocacy purposes (MCT, 2017, MCT, 2018).
Litigation In2017and2018,MCTjointlyfiledorsupportedsomecasesfiled
bypartnersinsearchoflegaljusticewheremediafreedomseemedtobeviolatedorendangered.Recordsshowthat,duringtheperiodunderreview,theCouncilwasengagedinonewayoranotherinkeycaseshighlightedbelow:
ThereisthecasethepittedMCT,HumanRightsCentreandTanzaniaHumanRightsDefendersCoalitionagainsttheAttorneyGeneraloftheUnitedRepublicofTanzania.ThiscasewasfiledattheEastAfricanCourt of Justice in Arusha, in 2017.
InthiscasetheapplicantsarechallengingtheprovisionsofMSA,2016,contendingthattheycontravenetheTreatyforestablishmentoftheEastAfricanCommunity.Pleadingsandhearinghavebeenconcluded.Thejudgmentisawaited.(MCT,2018).
ThenthereisthecasebetweenCentreforStrategicLitigationLimitedversustheAttorneyGeneraloftheUnitedRepublicofTanzaniaandSecretaryGeneraloftheEastAfricanCommunity,filedin2018.
InthiscasetheCouncilissupportingtheapplicantswhohavesuedthetworespondents,challengingtheEPOCA(onlinecontent)RegulationsforbeingincontraventionoftheprovisionsoftheTreatyfor theestablishmentof theEastAfricanCommunity.Thecaseisinthepleadingstageandtherespondentshavenotresponded to the reference (MCT, 2018)
Thereisthisothermatter,theConstitutionalCaseNo.2of2016,whichinvolvestheUnionofTanzaniaPressClubsandHaliHalisi
97
2017-2018 REPORT
PublishersversustheMinisterofInformation,Culture,ArtsandSports,TCRAandAttorneyGeneral.ItwasfiledattheHighCourtMwanzaandtheApplicantsspecificallyseekfortheinterpretationof the constitutionality of the MSA, 2016 in relation to Article 18 of theConstitutionoftheUnitedRepublicofTanzania.
Thecasewasdismissedinthepreliminarystage.Dissatisfiedwiththedecision,mediastakeholderslodgedanappealattheCourtofAppealinMwanzaandsameiswaitingforthehearingdatetobescheduled (MCT, 2018).
OnApril30,2018theMCT,LHRCtogetherwiththeTHRDCfiledanapplicationbeforetheHighCourtofTanzaniainMtwaraagainsttheMinisterforInformation,Culture,ArtsandSports,TCRAandtheAttorneyGeneral,seekingcourtpermissiontochallengethe Electronic and Postal Communications (OnlineContent)Regulations.
Thesamewasfiledtogetherwithanapplicationforinjunctionwhichwasgrantedonthesameday.
However,therespondentsfiledpreliminaryobjectionswhichsawtheHighCourtofTanzania,MtwaraDivision,strikingoutthecaseinMay,2018.Theapplicantsre-filedthesameandwereallowedtofileanapplicationforordersofcertioraritochallengetheMinisterofInformationmovetomakeonlineContentRegulations.ThesamehasbeenconcludedandthecourtdismissedtheApplicationonJanuary 9, 2019.
Theapplicantshaveappealedagainstthedecision. Other cases which MCT and partners supported, in one way or
another, include Miscellaneous Case No. 2 (2018) of HaliHalisi PublisherscontestingthebanningthepublicationMwanahalisinewspaperfor24monthsinSeptember,2017andMiscellaneousCivilApplicationNo.2(2017)whereFreeMediaLimitedwaschallengingthebanningofTanzaniaDaimanewspaper.
Mediation and Arbitration In2017and2018,MCTreceivedanumberofcomplaintsagainst
somenewspapersfromindividualsandinstitutionsclaimingtohavebeenwrongedthroughdefamationorbadpublicity.MCTrecordsshowthattheCouncilhandledthem,andmediatedwherenecessary (MCT 2018)
98
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
Press Freedom Monitoring In2017and2018theCouncilcontinuedwithmonitoringand
documentingpressfreedomviolations,aswellasmaintainingthePressFreedomViolationsRegister(MCT2017,MCT2018)
Journalism Awards In2017MCTorganisedtheExcellenceinJournalismAwards
Tanzania(EJAT2017)eventinrecognitionof journalistswhoperformedoutstandinglythepreviousyear.EJATwasestablishednineyearsagobyaconsortiumofmediaorganisationsundertheMedia Council of Tanzania.
AccordingtoMCTReportonEJAT2017,theeventhasbeengainingmorepopularityovertimesinceitsinceptionandhasbecomeTanzania’smostprestigiousmediaawardfunction.
5.13 Media Stakeholders Perception Regardingperceptionofmediastakeholdersonmediasupportin
thecountry,manyappreciatedeffortsmadebytheseorganisationsbutwereoftheviewthatsupportaimingatmakingmediaoutletsindependentandsustainable,wouldaddmorevaluetowhattheyaredoing.
AveteranjournalistwhohasworkedforboththeGovernmentandprivatemediabeforeretirementnotedthatorganisationssupportingthemediainTanzaniaaredoingagoodjobbutarefacedwithfinancialconstraintstotheextentthattheycannotsatisfytheneedsofjournalistsandmediahouses.Hecontendedthattheexternalsupportshouldaimatmakingmediahouseseconomicallyviablesoastobeabletofacilitatein-housetrainingfortheiremployees.
Abroadcastingjournalistwhoparticipatedinoneofthetrainingprogrammesconductedthroughmentorshipsaidthetrainingwasverybeneficialtohim,butnotedthatopportunitiesofthiskindarestill few.
Theapproachoftrainingjournaliststhroughpressclubswashailedbyamediaobserverwhonotedthatprovidingtrainingtopressclubmemberswould,inthelongrun,promotemediacoverageinruralareas,asthosetrainedhaveaccesstovillageswheremostTanzanianslive.Shesuggestedthatmoremediasupportersshould
99
2017-2018 REPORT
thinkaboutworkingthroughpressclubstoensuretheirtrainingpartnershiphasanimpactonawidersociety.
Alawyerwhoparticipatedintrainingjournalistsonmedialaws,onaninvitationofamediasupportingorganisation,pointedoutthatgiventhedraconiannatureofTanzania’srecentlyenactedmedialawsandregulations,morejournalistsshouldbeenlightenedonthem,lesttheyendupinlegaltroubleinthecourseofexecutingtheir duties.
Generally,practitionersinthemediaindustryagreethattherapidlychangingdigitaltechnologyisposingabigchallengetomediaowners,reportersandeditorswho,therefore,needtraininginthisareainordertocopewithmodernity.
Theissueoflackofmonitoringandassessmentoftheimpactoftrainingprovidedbymediasupportingorganisationswasraisedbythekeyplayersthemselveswhentheywereaskedtocommentontheimpactoftheirworktojournalistsandmediahouses.
Respondentsagreedthattheproblemexistsandsuggestedthatoneortwoofthestrongmediasupportingorganisationsshouldvolunteertoundertakethisactivity,asimpactassessmentofprojectsistooimportanttobeignored.
5.14 Concluding Remarks This chapter has reviewed different types of support offered to
themediabyvariousorganisations.Amajorobservationisthatorganisationsinvolvedhaveputsignificantemphasisontrainingjournalistsinseveralareas.Yetithasbeennotedthatmorehastobedoneonthiswork,andtherearegapstobefilled.Thefactthatthereisinadequateresearchonmediarelatedactivities,andthat the situation requires a solution, has been observed as well. A follow-upontrainees’performanceonthejobtoassesstheimpactofthetrainingthathasbeenprovidedisanotherareawhichmediastakeholdershavetolookinto.OnthewholemediasupportinTanzaniaisremainsabigchallenge.
5.15 Recommendations Findingsmadeinthechapterrequirethisreporttomakeafew
recommendationsonbasicissueswhichkeyorganisationsinvolvedinTanzania’smediadevelopmentshouldaddress.
100
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
Theseareoutlinedbelow:
Media owners should · Givemoresupporttoin-housetrainings · Strengthentheirmanagementsystemstobefinancially
viableandsupportmediadevelopment.
Journalists/Editors should: Look for specialised training opportunities and introduce
mentorshipprogrammes
Media Training Institutions should: Initiatemoremediarelatedresearch NetworkonMediaSupport,MonitorandImpactofSupported
Activities Providesupportstrengtheningmediainstitutions,makethem
independent and sustainable
References MISA-TANUnpublishedReport(2018) URT(2017)MediaServiceAct,2016Regulations2017,Dares
Salaam,Tanzania. Retrieved fromhttps://www.tamwa.org/tamwa/index.
php/about-us/about-us1 accessed on 16th October 2018 Retrievedfromhttp://utpc.or.tz/?page_id=38accessedon16th
October 2018 Retrievedfromwww.tmf.or.tzaccessedon16thOctober2018 Retrievedfromhttps://www.fes-tanzania.org/accessedon16th
October 2018 Retrievedfromhttps://mct.or.tz/index.php/mct-constitution
accessed on16th October 2018
101
2017-2018 REPORT
PART II
ZANZIBAR
The State of Media Report in Zanzibar in 2017/18
Author
Dr Ali Uki
102
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
ABBREVIATIONS ACHPR AfricanCharteronHumanandPeoplesRights CD CompactDisk CUR ConstitutionoftheUnitedRepublicofTanzania
of 1977 CZ ConstitutionofZanzibar,1984 FM Frequency Modulation DVD DigitalVersatileDisc GOVT Government GSO GovernmentSecurityOffice HDV HighDefinitionVideo ICCPR International Covenant on Civil and Political
Rights MCT Media Council of Tanzania NACTE National Council for Technical Education NGO Non-Governmentalorganisation SUZA StateUniversityofZanzibar TOR TermsofReference TSN Tanzania Standard Newspapers TV Television UDHR UniversalDeclarationofHumanRights UN UnitedNations V Versus ZBC ZanzibarBroadcastingCommission ZJMMC ZanzibarJournalismandMassMediaCollege ZNZ Zanzibar ZPC Zanzibar Press Club ZSSF Zanzibar Social Security Fund
103
2017-2018 REPORT
Chapter One
Political Context/Legal and Regulatory Framework
1.0 Introduction ThischapterspecificallyfocusesonZanzibarpoliticalsituationin
2017/18aswellasZanzibarMediaRegulatoryFramework.Somekeypoliticalissueshaveemergedduringtheperiodandhavebeenpointed out, discussed and analysed to see how they have directly orindirectlyaffectedthemediaoperations.
1.1 Key Political Events in 2017/18 and Their Implications to Press Freedom and Journalism
Unlikeinthe2016ReportoftheStateofMediainZanzibar,therewereno serious political events that captured national or international. There have, however, been events that had political connotations. ThefirstonewasthenewElectionsActNo.4of2018replacingtheoldElectionsActthatwasinplacesince1984andwhichwasusedforallmulti-partyelections—1995,2000,2005,2010and2015.
TheoldElectionsActhasbeenreplacedbyanewone.AlthoughthereisnosolidevidencethatprovesthattheElectionsActof1984,wasrepealedonpoliticalgrounds,butanalysisshowedthatpoliticalrepercussionthatemergedintheOctober2015GeneralElectionhave been dealt with in the law. As a result, the new Elections Act hasimplicationstopressfreedomandjournalistsinparticularwithregardtotheannouncementofthepresidentialresults.
Intheprocessofaddressingsomechallengesthatemergedintheelections,theRevolutionaryGovernmentofZanzibarpreparedanElectionBilltorepealtheElectionActNo.11of1984andenactElectionsActof2018andothermattersconnected therewith.Amongotherthings,theBill(ZNZGov.Gazette,September1,2017)identifiedtheelectoraloffencesanddeterminedthepenaltiesassociated with such offences.
TheGovernmentBillwaspresented,discussedandpassedbytheHouse of Representatives in Zanzibar. It was later assented by the ZanzibarPresidentandChairmanoftheRevolutionaryCouncil,DrAliMohammedShein,onJanuary16,2018,tobecomealaw.
104
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
(ElectionActNo.4of2018).Itisaconstitutionalrequirementthatalawmustgetapresidentialassentbeforeitbecomesalaw.
InthenewElectionsAct,thereissectiondealingwithmediahouses or journalists. Section 127 (1) of the new Elections Act prohibitsannouncementoftheelectionresultsbyacandidate,apoliticalparty,aninstitutionoranyotherpersonsthroughanymeansofcommunicationbeforetheCommissionannounces.Itisworthnotingthattherewasalmostthesameclauseintherepealedelection law.
Section 127 (2) (a) of the new Elections Act, says that if the offence iscommittedbyacandidatewhoisthereafterfoundguilty,uponconvictionheorshewillbeliabletoimprisonmentforatermofnotlessthanfiveyearsandafineofnotlessSh50millionandheorsheshallnotbeallowedtocontestfortheelectionforatermof10 years.
Section127(2)(b)saysthatiftheoffenceiscommittedbyapoliticalpartyoraninstitutionshallfoundguilty,itshall,uponconviction,beliabletoafineofSh100million,upfromtheSh5millionfineinthe repealed Elections Act.
Furthermore,theActspellsout,iftheoffenceiscommittedbysomeotherperson,heorsheshallbeliabletoimprisonmentforatermof30months,accordingtoSection127(2)(c)ofthenewElectionsAct.
Thismustbeablowtothemediaandjournalists,fortheyarelikelytoworkunderastateoffearandwouldhavetobeextracarefultoavoidconvictionintheexecutionoftheirprofessionaldutiesduringelections.
AlongwiththenewElectionsAct,aBillforanacttoestablishtheZanzibarGovernmentPrintingPressAgencywastabled,discussedandpassedintheHouseofRepresentatives.Bythetimewewenttopress,itwasnotclearwhethertheBillwasalreadysubmittedtotheStateHousetogetanassentfromtheZanzibarPresident.
ThemainpurposeofestablishingtheagencyistomaintaintheconceptofconfidentialityinprintingservicestotheGovernment.Theagencyshallhave theduty toprovide itsservices toallministries, departments, authorities, corporations and allGovernmentinstitutions.
105
2017-2018 REPORT
Inaddition,allGovernmentinstitutions,includingtheState-ownedZanzibarLeonewspaper,shallbeobligedtoseekprintingandstationeryservicesfromtheAgency.Inthepast,ZanzibarLeowasprinted by the Tanzania Standard Newspapers (TSN) Press in Dar esSalaam.Theimplicationoftheproposednewlawmaycreateachainofbureaucratichurdlesforthoseseekingurgentaccesstoinformation.
Key Legal and Regulatory Framework and Their Implications to Press Freedom and Journalism
ThemediasectorisgovernedbyanumberofapplicablelawsinZanzibar.Themedialawswereestablishedonthebasisofinternational and regional instruments.There are sections ininternationalandregionalinstrumentsthatunderscoretherighttofreedomofexpressionandopinion.
ThereisArticle19inboththeUDHRof1948andInternationalCovenantonCivilandPoliticalRightsof1966(ICCPR).Thechapterputsemphasisontherighttofreedomofexpressionandopinion.Therightincludesfreedomtoholdopinionswithoutinterferenceandtoseek,receiveandimpartinformationandideasthroughanymediaregardlessoffrontiers.
The contents ofArticle 19 from international human rightsinstrumentshavefoundaplaceinSection18oftheZanzibarConstitutionof1984whichistheMotherLawandthereisnolawthatshouldcontradictsit.Asitisfamouslyknown,intheeventofalawconflictingwiththeConstitution,theConstitutionprevails.
However,byimplication,theframingofconstitutionalprovisionshasinonewayoranotherlimitedenjoymentoffreedomofinformationandopinion.Forexampleintheconstitutionalprovisionsrelatingtopressfreedomandinformation,therearewordssuchas,“Withoutprejudicetotherelevantlawsoftheland”,usedinSection18(1)oftheCZof1984.
Byimplication,thewords,famouslyknownasclaw-backclause,limitenjoymentofsuchpressandinformationfreedombyusingrelevantlawswhichareinforceinZanzibar.Ifonemakesareferencetothesaidrelevantlaws,onemayconcludethattheypermittherestrictionofguaranteedfreedomintheConstitution.
ThereisalsoSection24(1)oftheCZ,1984,thusprovides:“…
106
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
Thehumanrightsandfreedoms,theprinciplesofwhicharesetout in this Constitution can be restricted by the law enacted by theHouseofRepresentativessaveonlytotheextentthatarenecessaryandacceptableinthedemocraticsystem.Inanywaythatrestrictionshallnot:interferewiththerighttofreedomfromtorture,inhumananddegradingtreatment;interferencewiththehumanrightsprinciples;causemoreeffecttothesocietyfromtheactthatrestrictionisintended.”
Apartfromtheconstitutionalprovisionscitedabove,intheZanzibarsituation,thelawsrelatingtomediaoperationsinZanzibarcanbedividedintotwoparts.Therearelawswhicharedirectlyrelatingtomediaoperationsandtherearelawswhichareindirectlyrelatingtomedia.
ThelawsdirectlyrelatingtothemediaoperationsaretheZanzibarBroadcastingCommissionActand theRegistrationofNewsAgents,NewspapersandBooksAct.Thesearetwomainlawsregulatingthemediaoperations.Thereareanumberofsectionsinbothlawswhichaffectmediaoperations.Forexample,theZanzibarBroadcastingActprovidespowerstoissueandcancelpermittoanyinstitutionsviolatingthelaw.TheActalsoprovidespowerstotheCommissiontosetconditionsthataredeemedfitfornationalinterest.
TheRegistrationofNewsAgents,NewspapersandBooksAct,providesalmostsimilarpowersthathavebeenstipulatedintheBroadcastingAct.Theministerresponsibleforinformationisempowered(underSection30)tosuspendpublicationofanynewspapersiftheministerisoftheopinionthatitisinthepublicinterestorintheinterestofpeaceandgoodordertodoso.
AseniorinformationofficerwiththeministryresponsibleforinformationinZanzibar,MrSalumVuai,confirmedrecently:“AsfarasIcanrecollect,thereisnoplanbytheGovernmenttorevisetheexistingmedialaws.”
Ifthatisthecase,theonlyoptionleftisfornon-governmentalorganisations (NGOs) toplayadvocacyrole topersuade theGovernmenttochangethelawsinplaceorindividualstotestmediarelatinglawsinthecourtsoflaw.
There are other applicable laws in Zanzibar which are not directly relatedtomediaandjournalists,butwhichhavesectionswhich
107
2017-2018 REPORT
somehow,affecttheexecutionoftheirfunctionsofthemedia.Theseinclude:
· The new ElectionsAct No. 4 2018 which has beenextensivelydiscussedabove
· TheNationalSecurityAct,1970,particularlyinSection48which creates sedition offence
· The Penal Act No. 6 of 2018 which creates an offence relatingtodefamation
· TheHouseofRepresentativesAct, Section32ofwhichmakesitanoffencetopublishanyfalseorscandalouslibelontheHouseorCommitteeproceedingsoftheHouseoranyCommittee.Furthermore,thesameSectionprohibitspublishing—savebythegeneralorspecialleaveoftheHouse—areportofanyproceedingsoftheHouseoranycommitteewhoseproceedingswerenotheldinpublic
· TheCensorshipandCinematographyExhibitionAct.ThereisSection4(a)oftheActconcernscensorshipoffilms,videocassettes(CD,DVD,HDV)andotherpublicitymaterialssuchasbannersorpostersorinmagazinesbeforetheycomeintousebyorshowntothepublic
· ThePreventionDetentionDecree,1964,Section2oftheDecree provides powers to the President to issue detention orderswheneverheissatisfiedthatapersonisconductinghimselfsoastobedangeroustothepeaceandgoodorderinanypartofZanzibarorisactinginamannerprejudicialto the defence of Zanzibar or the security of the Republic
All the above cited laws which have either direct or indirect connectiontomediaoperationsinZanzibarraiseinterestingissuesthatinpracticearelikelytocausechallengestomediahousesandjournalists.Inaddition,theexistinglawscurtailingpressfreedomhavenotyetbeentestedinthecourtoflawtogetthejudicialinterpretation and position.
UnlikeinthecaseofTanzaniaMainland,neitheranon-governmentalorganisationnoranindividualinZanzibarhasopenedacaseonmedialaws.Therearemorethan300registeredNGOsthatoperateatdifferentlevelsinZanzibarwhichclaimtoservetheinterestsofthe people.
Courtdecisionswouldnotonlypromotelocaljurisprudenceon
108
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
lawsrelatingtomediaoperationsbutwouldalsostrengthentheargumentsonpressfreedominZanzibar.
Civilsocietiesandindividualsshouldcultivatethehabitofgoingtocourtsthathaveasignificantroleininterpretationofmediaandnon-medialaws.CourtsremaintheonlyinstitutionsthatcandefendandprotecttherightsthatareenshrinedintheLaw.
Thebestexampleofthecourts’roleininterpretationofcountrylawsisinGoodwinv.UnitedKingdom,theEuropeanCourtofHumanRights.TheCourtheldthattheprotectionofjournalisticsourcesisoneofthebasicconditionsofpressfreedom.However,theCourtdidnotruleoutdisclosurecompletelyandinallcircumstances,insteaditimposedverystrictconditions;basedon“necessity”and“proportionality”.
InanothercaseofA.K.Gopalanv.StateofMadras,theCourtheldthatthewholepurposeoftheconstitutionallimitationsistwofolds:namely,thefreedomisnotabsolutebutissubjecttoregulations.Secondly,thelimitationsmustbewithinthepurposeandpurviewintended by the Constitution.
Highlights of incidents of Acts of press freedom violations: Therehavebeencomplaintsofincidentsofpressfreedomviolations
inZanzibar.However,thecomplaintscarrynoweightandcannotbegivenaspaceinseriousdiscussion.ThereareanumberofNGOsoperatinginZanzibarbutnocomplaintshavebeenregisteredforeitherrecordpurposesoractions.Thismeansthereisnothingtowriteaboutintermsofpressfreedomviolationforthelackofconvincingevidence.Thesaidcomplaintsarereducedasstreetrumours.
TheMediaCouncilofTanzania(MCT),ZanzibarOfficeSeniorProgrammesOfficer,MsShifaaHassan,explainedthatatotalof25complaintsconnectedtotheincidentsofactsofmediaviolationshavebeenreportedintheofficeduring2017/18.
Thecomplaintshadrangedfromdenialofinformation,physicalharassments,journalistsbeingbarredfromcoveringsomeeventsonpoliticalgroundsanddenialofaccreditationcardtopractisejournalisminZanzibar.TheMCThasaspecialregisterforrecordingcomplaintsofpressfreedomviolations.
Inaddition,theMCTteamledbytheExecutiveSecretary,Mr.
109
2017-2018 REPORT
KajubiMukajanga,theMCTZanzibarOfficeSeniorProgrammeOfficer,Ms.Hassan,andtheeditorofBarazaandMediaWatchnewsletters,MrHamisMzee,had,onMay4,2018,conductedameetingforjournalistsinPembatogetfirst-handinformationontheirprofessionalactivities.Duringthemeeting,similarcomplaintsofharassmentanddenialofinformationwereraised.AccordingtoMsShifaa,theMCTteamurgedthejournaliststoexerciseahighdegreeoftolerance,remindingthemthatprofessionalhazardsshouldnotstopthemfromdoingtheirwork.
TheconcernthattherewereincidentsofpressfreedomviolationswasalsobackedbythechairmanofZanzibarPressClub(ZPC),MrAbdallaMfaume.However,hesaid,theincidentshavenotbeenreportedtotheirofficeinwriting.“Wehaveheardthecomplaintsbuttheallegedvictimshavenotreportedtousofficially.”
1.4 Conclusion Theexistingmedialawsandregulationshavebeenachallengeto
promotionofmediafreedom.Therearesectionsinthelawsthatstandasobstacles.UnlesseffortsaremadetorequesttheGovernmenttorevisitthelawsandmakechanges,thepressperformancemayendupbeingmuchbelowtheexpectationsofthepeople.
Duringtheperiodunderreview,theMCTmadeseriouseffortstoinfluencechangesinthemediarelatedlaws.Theeffortshavebeenmadeintheformofmeetings,dialogues,trainingandroundtablediscussions.
ItisonrecordthattheMCTofficialshad,onMay02,2017,metwiththeZanzibarSecondVicePresident,AmbassadorSeifAliIddi,athisofficetoexplainprofessionaldifficultiesfacingthemediaintheIsles.
ItwasexplainedbytheMCTSeniorProgrammeOfficer,MsShifaaHassanthattheSecondVicePresidentpromised,tofollowupthematter,forthebettermentofthemediaprofession.Stakeholders’meetingonreviewingtheexistingmedialawsinZanzibarwasconductedbytheMCTasanattempttoimprovethemediaworkingconditions.
During2017/18,theMCTisreportedtohavesentalettertotheZanzibarStateHouserequestingforanappointmentwiththeZanzibarPresident,Dr.AliMohamedShein,toexplaintohimwhy
110
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
numerousthingsneedtobedonetoimprovemediaoperationsinZanzibar.TheMCTisstillwaitingfortheappointmentaswegoto press.
1.5 Recommendations * Repealandamendmentsoflawshinderingpressfreedom
isfundamental * Media stakeholders should continue to lobby for the
repealandamendmentsoflawshinderingjournalists’professionalperformance
* MediaplayersshouldcultivatethehabitofreportingtoMCTofficesorotherinstitutions,actsofviolationsofmediafreedom
* NGOsshouldassistinpushingforpromotionofmediafreedom.
111
2017-2018 REPORT
Chapter Two
Current Trends in the Print Media in Zanzibar
2.0 Introduction Thischapterattemptstoprovidekeyinformationaboutthecurrent
trendsintheprintmediainZanzibar.ItexplainsastowhetherthereisregistrationofnewnewspapersorderegistrationofthosethatwerethereandaboutonlinenewspapersinZanzibarduring2017/18.
2.1 Registration of Newspapers Thelegalframeworkwithregardtoregistrationofnewspapersis
governedbytheRegistrationofNewsAgents,NewspapersandBooks(Act,No.5of1988).Alltherequirementsforregistrationare provided for under the Newspapers Act. In addition, there areregulationswhichmustbeobservedinseekingapplicationfornewspapersregistration.
Oneoftheregulationsisthattheapplicantmustprovidethenameof the editor who would be responsible for the contents of the newspaper.
TheNyalaliCommissionwhichwasresponsibleforcollectingpublicopinionsoverwhetherTanzaniashouldadoptmulti-partysystemornothadcitedtheNewspapersActasoneofthe40oppressivelawsrecommendedforrepeal.However,thelawisstillinplace.
TherewastimetheMCTattemptedtoreviewtheNewspaperAct,splittingitintotwopiecesoflegislation:theMediaServicesActandInformationAct.Itissevenyearsnow,andtheexistingmedialegislationbothfortheprintandelectronicmediaremainsintact.
There were no new newspaper or newsletters that were been registeredin2017/18,accordingtotheRegistrarofNewspapers,Ms.JamilaMahmoud.Shegavenoreasonsthesituation.ThereisonlyonedailynewspaperintheIsles,theGovernment-ownedpublication, ‘Zanzibar Leo’. The contents of the newspaper are well editedtosuittheadministration’sinterests.
Ontheotherhand,theregistrarnoted,someregisterednewsletters
112
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
thatbelongtoNGOsandGovernmentinstitutionshavefailedtocomeoutforlongtime.Atotalof60newsletters,quarterlies,andannualpublications,havebeenregistered.
Thelackoffundswasthemainproblem.AlmostallNGOsaredonor-drivenanditappearsthatsomepartnershave,oflate,changedtheirprioritiestothedisadvantageofsomeNGOs.
Nonewspaperhasbeenderegistered,explainedtheregistrar.ZanzibariswellservedwithnewspaperspublishedfromTanzaniaMainlandandotherEastAfricacountries.Duringthetime,therewasnopublicationthatwasbannedfromimportationtotheIsles.
2.2 Sustainability Issues The question of sustainability is crucial and broad. It depends on the
focusofinterpretationoftheworditself.Inthiscontextsustainabilityissuesareinterpretedinthefollowingaspects:financialmusclesoftheorganisation,production,distribution,influenceofthecontentsofnewspaperstothepublicandmaintenanceoflabourforce.Thischapter,therefore,attemptstoprovidesomekeyinformationonthesustainabilityissuesasmentionedabove.
2.2.1 Financial Muscles of Newspapers Financialmuscleisafundamentalandalifelineofsurvivalof
newspaper.Withoutfinancialcapacity,itisextremelydifficulttosurvive in the news business. It is the cost of resources that are consumedinorganisationactivities.Asearlierexplained,thereisonly one daily newspaper in Zanzibar, the State-owned newspaper “ZanzibarLeo”.
Almost97percentofthenewspaper’sbudgetissourcedfromtheGovernment.Themainsourceofitsownincomeisadvertisementsandcopysales.ThepaperadherestoGovernmentfinanciallaws,regulationsandpolicies.
AbudgetspeechoftheMinistryresponsibleforInformationfor2017/18 which was presented in the House of Representatives indicatedthattheGovernmentpumpedintothenewspapermoneyforallthemainactivities–recurrentanddevelopment.Thisincludessalaries of the staff and contribution to the Zanzibar Social Security Fund (ZSSF).
Theperformanceofthenewspaperentirelyrestsontheshoulders
113
2017-2018 REPORT
oftheTreasury.Inotherwords,theadministrationhascontrolofthe newspaper. (Who pays the piper calls the tune).
2.2.2 Production Newspaperproductionisalongprocessstartingfromassigning
journaliststogoouttotheirrespectivebeatstocollectmaterialfornewsstories,featuresandphotographs.Itfurtherentailswritingopinionpieces,editorials;editing,designing,decidingtheprintorder,solicitingadvertisementsandhandlingthefinalproduct,etc.
Sustainabilityofproductionlargelydependsonfinancialmuscles.Theshortageoffundswillautomaticallyaffectnewspapersineverydepartment.Thismeansthesustainabilityof‘ZanzibarLeo’newspaper, which was launched in 2002, entirely depends on the Governmentforahugepercentofitsfunding.
ThecurrentdailyprintorderofZanzibarLeo’standsat15,000copies,accordingtotheManagingEditorYussufKhamisYussuf.AcopyofthenewspaperissoldatSh500,ofwhichSh300coverstheprintingcharges,Sh100isforthevendor’scommissionandthebalancegoestotheGovernment.
2.2.3 Distribution Unlikeinthepast,thenewspaper’sdistributionhaschanged.
There are only two distribution points in Tanzania Mainland. They arethecapitalcity,DodomaandDaresSalaam,thecountry’scommercialcentre.MrYussuf,theME,saidrecentlythatthetwodistributionpointsintheMainlandwerestrategicallyselectedtoserveGovernmentinterests.Theolddistributionpointswhichwerestruckoutfromthelist:Mwanza,Arusha,Lindi,MtwaraandMorogoro.
2.2.4 Newspaper’s Contents ThecontentsofnewspaperobviouslyfollowtheGovernment’s
editorialpolicy.ItisexpectedtoconveyGovernmentinformationtothepublic.MediacriticshavecomplainedthatmostofthestoriespublishedbythepaperarenothingmorethanofficialstatementsorinformationfromtheGovernmentorGovernmentinstitutionsandcarrieslittleornocriticism.
114
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
2.2.5 Maintenance of Labour Force Asexplainedearlier,Zanzibarhasonlyonedailynewspaperthat
isaGovernment-owned.Thenewspaper’sorganisationstructureremainsasotherGovernmentinstitutions.ThemanagingeditorisappointedbythePresidentofZanzibarandrecruitmentiscarriedoutaspertheGovernmentprocedures.Thenewspapermanagementmustsubmititsrequestforrecruitmenttothecentralestablishmentforapprovalandthelaiddownproceduresmustbefollowed.ThenamesofallemployeesaresubmittedtotheGovernmentSecurityOffice(GSO)forvetting.
Unlikeinsomeprivately-ownedmediahouses,thenewspaperemployeesaresupposedtosignalabourcontractandareassuredoftheirmonthlysalarieswellintime.Inthiscase,thesustainabilityof staff is 100 per cent.
2.3 Mushrooming of Online Newspapers WiththeexceptionofZanzibarLeoNewspaper,thereisnoother
newspaper which is accessible online. The Zanzibar Newspapers Registrar,MsJamilaMahmoud,confirmedthatshereceivednoapplicationfromanyoneseekingtooperateonlinenewspaper.ThismeanstheconceptofonlinenewspaperislaggingbehindinZanzibar.
2.4 Conclusion Theroadtodevelopmentofprintmediaisbumpy.Nationaland
international investors have not focused their attention to the print media.Itiseitherbecauseofstiffcompetitionfromelectronicmediawhichisfasteranduptodateorsoaringcostsinvolvedinprintindustryincludingnewsgathering,employmentofprofessionals,productionanddisseminationofinformation.
Itappears,however,thatlackofexperienceinbusinessdevelopmenttostimulatenewthinkinginrunningthenewspapersbusinessisthemainproblem.Asaresult,newspapermanagementmaintainsthetraditionalmindsetofdependingmoneyfromtheGovernmentcoffers or donors.
2.5 Recommendations * Thereshouldbediversionfromthetraditionalset-upof
115
2017-2018 REPORT
runningnewspaperstothebusinessenvironmentset-upinrunningthenewspaper
* Newspapermanagementshoulddevelopplansthatoutlinestrategiestocompeteinthestiffbusinessenvironment
* International and national institutions should help to mentorandcoachnewspapersmanagementinbusinessdevelopment
* Regularbusinessdevelopmenttrainingonthenewspapermanagementshouldbegiventoppriority.
116
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
117
2017-2018 REPORT
Chapter Three
Current Trend in Radio and TV Broadcasting in Zanzibar
3.0 Introduction Asinthecaseofprintmedia,thereisaBroadcastingCommission
ActwhichregulatestheaffairsofallelectronicmediainZanzibar.TherearealsoasetofregulationsthatareinplacetosupporttheBroadcastingAct.Thischapterspecificallyfocusesonradioandtelevisionregistration,introductionofdecodersanditsimplicationsonradio,televisionanddigitalbroadcastinginZanzibar.
3.1 Registration of New Radio and TV Stations ThereisaninterestingstoryonregistrationofradioandTVstations.
TheCommissionhasforthefirsttimeinhistoryregisteredandlicensedeightonlineTVstationsinZanzibar.“Itisahistoryinbroadcastingindustry,”explainedtheActingExecutiveSecretary,MrChandeOmar.AlltheonlinetelevisionsareownedbyindigenousZanzibaris.ItisexpectedthattheonlineTVstationswillboostdisseminationofinformationtothepublic.
Theeightregisteredandlicensedonlinetelevisionsare: ZanonlineTech; StateHouse,Zanzibar; ZanzibarDepartmentofInformation; AlfatahOnline; · KTVTZOnline; · PembaTV; · Mubashara Media Network and · ZanzinewsCom. However,thenumberofradioandtelevisionstationsonairremains
at25and28respectivelyasitwasthecaseoflastyear,said,MrOmar.
3.1.1 DeregistrationandSuspensionofRadioandTVstations TheCommissionhasnotderegisteredanyradioorTVstation
buthastemporarilysuspendedoperationsofaprivatelyowned
118
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
A-JazeeraCableTelevisioninPembaforwhatithadbeentermedastechnicaladministrativeissues.
TheZBCActingExecutiveSecretarysaidthesuspendedTVstationhadagreedtosortoutalltheshortcomingsnotedbyauthoritiesandwasnowbackonair.HegavetheassurancethattheCommissionwascommittedtopromotebroadcastinginstitutions.But,hemaintainedthatcompliancetothecountry’sapplicablelawsandregulationsisabsolutelynecessarytopromotestandardsandprofessional ethics.
3.1.2 Introduction of Decoders and its Implications on Radio and TV
Asexpected,thenumberofdecodersinstalledinZanzibar(UngujaandPemba)shotupto300from120.PeopleacrosstheIsles,bothinurban and rural areas, have installed decoders to access local and foreignprogrammes,especiallysports.
TheZBCChiefEngineer,MrAliHussein,attributedtheincreaseto installation of satellite dishes by the people. Media analysts saytheincreaseisanindicationthatpeoplepreferforeignnewscomponentwhosequality,analysisandeditorialindependenceseemtobestrongerthanlocalcontent.Theincreaseofdecodersoutshinesradioandtelevisionperformanceandthisshouldnotbetakenlightly.
AccordingtotheZBCChiefEngineer,thecorporationhasengagedateamoflocalmediaexpertstostudyonoperationsoflocalbroadcastingmedia.Amongotherthings,theresearchisexpectedtocomeupwithanumberofdecodersinstalledinZanzibar.
TheZBCregistrar,MrOmarSaid,wasoftheopinionthatthestudywouldindicateareasofstrengthsandweaknesses,amovewhichwouldstimulatenewthinkinginthedevelopmentofbroadcastingmediainZanzibar.
DespitethefactthatZanzibarwasamongthefirstAfricancountriestoestablishabroadcastingmedia,therearesomecountrieswhichareprogressingfaster,especiallywhenitcomestoinvestinginthenewbroadcastingtechnologicalequipment.
3.2 Threats and Intimidation to Journalists Thequestionofthreatsandintimidationdependsonsomeone’s
119
2017-2018 REPORT
interpretation.Generally,itmaybeinterpretedasthelackoffreeenvironmenttoworkfreelyandindependentmind.TheMCTZanzibarOfficehadrecordedatotalof25incidentsofthreatandintimidationtargetingjournalistsfortheYear2017/18.
Assaidearlier,theactsofviolationincludeddenialofinformation,harassmentsandbeatings.AletterdatedMarch01,2018,whichwassenttotheMCTZanzibarOfficebytheZCTVChiefEditorJacobJoseph,explainedthatfivemediaworkerswerebeatenwhileinthecourseofcarryingouttheirprofessionalworkasjournalists.Theworkers,accordingtothecopyoftheletter,weretryingtorecordaroadaccidentinvolvingacarandVespawhichhadoccurredatMaisara.
Theelectronicmediaemployeesareallowedtoworkaspertheexistingbroadcastinglegislationandregulations.ApartfromtheprivatelyownedAl-JazeeraCableTelevisioninPemba,whichwastemporarilybannedforwhathadbeentermed“technicalissues”therewerenomediaworkersthathadbeenharassed.
However,therehavebeenseriouscomplaintsbysomejournalistsworking for themushroomingelectronicprivatemedia,whoclaimtheywerenotgivenemploymentcontracts.Ontopofthat,ittakestoolongforthemtoreceivetheirmonthlysalaries.Byanydefinition,thisfrustratesthejournalistsanditmaybedescribedaspsychologicalthreatandintimidation.ThisfactwasconfirmedbytheZPCchairperson,MrAbdallaMfaume.However,hemaintainedhehadjustheardaboutthis“onthestreets”.HesaidhewouldratherthecomplaintswerebroughtofficiallytotheZPC.
3.3 Sustainability Issues Asthecaseofprintmedia,theelectronicmediaalsosurvivesunder
thecompetitivebusinessenvironment.Theelectronicmedia,withtheexceptionoftheGovernmentownedmediawhichreceivesmoneyfromtheTreasury;thesehavetocompeteforadvertisementsasincomegeneratingmeans.
Thismaybeconsideredasoneofcontributing factors to thedelayofmonthlysalariestosomejournalists.Giventhecurrentbusinesssituation,nomoreadvertisementsaresenttotheradioandtelevisionstations.Inaddition,ittakesabitlongertogetmoneyfrombusinessmen,saidMrMwinyiHamad,amemberin
120
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
themanagementofaprivatelyownedmedia. ThereisalsotheneedofIslesbusinessmentochangetheirmindset
andmakefulluseofavailabilityelectronicmediatoadvertisetheirmerchandise.
3.4 Current Status in Digital Broadcasting Thedigitalbroadcastinghasrecordedanimpressiveperformance
inZanzibarafterreplacingtheanaloguesystem.Bylastyear,allelectronicmediahadswitchedtothedigitalsystem.
Itisnotpossibletocontinueoperatingwiththeoldbroadcastingsystem,saidZBCChiefEngineerAliHussein.Oneoftheconditionssetfortheregistrationofelectronicmediaistoproveyouoperateunderthedigitalsystem.
3.5 Conclusion ThereisapositivedevelopmentintheelectronicmediainZanzibar.
Online TV stations have started to sprout, a sign of digitaldevelopmentandimprovementindisseminationofinformationtothepublic.Anincreaseinthenumberofdecodersinstalledinurbanandruralareasisanothersignofpositivedevelopmentintheelectronicmedia.Itstandsasachallengetoradioandtelevisionindisseminationofinformation.Unlessconcretemeasuresareputinplacetocompetewithonlinetelevisions,radioandtelevisionsmaybepushedoutofthemarket.
3.6 Recommendations Thefollowingarerecommendationsinrespecttothischapter: · TheZBCmanagementshouldcontinuetoencourage
interestedpeopletoinvestintheelectronicmedia. AllregisteredradioandTVstationsmustadheretotheapplicable
lawsandregulationstoavoidunnecessaryfrictionwithauthorities.
121
2017-2018 REPORT
Chapter Four
Current Trends in the New Media
4.0 Introduction Thenewmediaremainsasoneofthechallengingissuestothe
operationsofoldmedia.Ifseriousmeasuresarenotputinplacetocheckthetrend,theoldmediamightcompletelybeovershadowedandpushedoutofthemarket.Bywhateveryardstick,thenewmediaareflourishinganditappearsthatsomesegmentsofthepopulation believe the content they circulate.
Unlikeinthepast,thenewmediatreatthemselvesasfreefromtheGovernmentcontrol.Individuals,non-governmentalorganisations,companies,andothersocialgroupshaveestablishedtheirownwebsites,Facebookandotherplatformsandrelyentirelyonthenewmediatosendmessagestotheirtargetedgroups.
Therewasnoregistrationorlicensingrequirements.Informationwashaphazardlyputincirculationwithouttakingprecautionsinrespectof peace, unity, social and cultural considerations. However, the situationhasnowchangedinZanzibar.TheGovernmentthroughtheZBChasdevelopedthenew2018MediaContentsRegulations.
Underthenewregulations,allsocialmediaoperatorsarerequiredtomakeanapplicationforregistrationtotheZBCbeforestartingto operate.
4.1 Registration of New Media Thedecisiontoregisterandlicenseoperationsofnewmediawas
notbydefaultbutbydesign.Initially,theGovernmentwantedtoamendtheZBCAct(ActNo.7of1997)andcreateasectionofthelawcompellingregistrationofthenewmediainZanzibar.Butanewthinkingcameuptoreviewtheregulations.
TheZBChasissuedathree-monthultimatumbeginningOctober2018toalloperatorsofsocialmediatoapplyforregistrationinordertobegivenanoperationallicence.Thebasicpurposeofregistrationistomaketheoperatorsresponsibleforthecontents.
TheZBCActingExecutiveSecretary,Mr.ChandeOmar,insisted
122
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
thattheregistrationisamatterofabsolutelynecessaryandnon-compliancetotheultimatumwouldattractlegalaction.“Weareveryseriousonthesocialmediaregistration.Someofthesocialmediaoperatorsareirresponsibleforthecontentsandviolatetheisland’sculturalnormsandvalue,”explainedMrChande.
4.2 Current Status of New Media and its Implication on Journalism Practices
Itisanopensecretthatthenewmediahasbroughtimplicationsonjournalismpractices.Alotofinformationthatiscirculatedbythenewmediaisnotinlinewithethicalconsiderationsthatjournalismdemands.Itappearsthatsomeoperatorsinthenewmediaarenottrainedinjournalism.Asaresulttherehasbeenaseriousdeteriorationinkeyjournalismethicssuchasobjectivereporting,balancingofinformation,therightofprivacyandtherighttoreply.
Thenewmediaoperatorsarecompetingwiththetraditionalmediaintermsofnewsgatheringanddissemination.Itisundeniablefactthatpeoplegetinformationabitfasterthroughthenewmediathantheygetitfromthetraditionalmedia.Furthermore,itappearsthatthegeneralpopulationhasbuiltatrustonsomeoftheinformationtheygetthroughthenewmedia.
However,alargenumberofpeoplehavebeencomplainingoverthemannerthenewmediaisoperating.AlotofprivacyissuesarepubliclycirculatedthroughthenewmediacontrarytotheIsles’culturalnormsandsocialvalues.ThisisinfactoneofthereasonsthatpushedtheZBCtoreviewtheregulationswiththemainobjectivebeingtoexercisecontrolonthenewmedia.
Ifthecurrentsituationofthenewmediaisleftunchecked,itmayleadtosocialdisharmonyandendangerpeaceandunity.
4.3 New Media and its Impact on Traditional Media in Zanzibar
ThenewmediahasabigimpactontraditionalmediainZanzibar.Although,therearenoofficialstatistics,itappearsthatprivateandGovernment-ownedTVandradiostationshavelostasubstantialnumberofitserstwhileviewersandlistenersinthewakeofthenewmedia.
Judgingbyviewsgiven in therecent trainingworkshopfor
123
2017-2018 REPORT
journalistsinZanzibar,manypeopleprefertogetnewsandotherinformationthroughthenewmedia.“YoudonothavetoswitchonyourradioorTVtogetthecurrentaffairs.Yougeteverythingthroughthenewmedia,”explainedaparticipantintheworkshoporganisedbyArticle19fromKenya.
AlthoughradioandTVstationsareheretostay,specialeffortmustbemadetocompetewiththenewmediaindisseminationofinformation.CriticalanalysismustundertakenbyradioandTVstationsiftheyaretocontinueattractingviewersandlisteners.
ArandomsurveyconductedinZanzibar’sStoneTownindicatesthatsalesofnewandusedradioshavegonedowndrastically,aclearsignofadropinthenumberoflistenersinbothurbanandrural areas of Zanzibar.
4.4 Comparison of Ownership, Press Freedom Violations and Advertising Aspects
Thequestionofownership,pressfreedomviolationsandadvertisingisanissueintheZanzibarsituation.GovernmentownedmediaandjournalistsworkingforitarestrictlyguidedbytheState’seditorialorientation.AllthenewsandinformationfromtheGovernmentmediamustadheretothecountry’sapplicablelawsandpolicies.
Inanycase,allseniorStateofficialsareappointedtoGovernmentmediapostsinaccordancewiththeprocedureslaiddowninthePublicServiceCommissionActof2011.And,astheadagegoes,“Hewhopaysthepipercallsthetune”.AnyonewhoactscontrarytotheGovernment’sstandpointshouldexpecttobesubjectedtothelaiddowndisciplinarymeasures.
TheGovernmentmediadon’tdependmuchon fundsbeinggenerated fromcopysalesandadvertisements to cover theirdailyoperations.Thebudgetisthere.Intermsofadvertising,withtheexceptionoftheGovernment/donor-fundedprojects,allGovernmentadvertisementsaresenttotheState-ownedprintandelectronicmedia.PaymentsaremadedependingontheTreasuryfundsdisbursement.ThisleadstoaconclusionthatState-ownedmediaworkers,includingjournalists,donothavetobothermuchaboutcopysalesoforadvertisementssincetheyareassuredoftheirmonthlysalaries.
Privatelyrunmediahavetocompeteforadvertisements.Theyhave
124
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
tolobbyheavilywithkeyofficialsintheState-ownedcorporationstogetadvertisements.
Itappearsthatmostofprivatelyownedmediahousessurviveonfundsfromextrasourcesandnotstraightfromadvertisements.However,analysesindicatethatsomeprivateelectronicmediahavecompromisedtheirprofessionalprinciplesintheirbidtobuildgoodpublicrelationstoattractadvertisements.
4.5 Conclusion Intermsofprofessionalism,theissuesofownership,pressfreedom
violationsandadvertisinghaveaffectedtheperformanceofbothGovernmentandprivatemedia.Veryfewjournalistsandmediaownersareindependentincollectionanddisseminationofnews.
4.6 Recommendations Thefollowingarerecommendationsinrespecttothischapter: · Professionalismshouldbegivenatoppriority · Governmentmediaworkersshouldmapoutstrategies
to survive on their own and contribute to the national coffers
125
2017-2018 REPORT
Chapter Five
Media Development Support
5.0 Introduction Thedevelopmentofthemediasectorisimportantifitistoperform
itsprofessionaldutiesbetter.Thedevelopmentincludes,amongotherthings,havingastaffdevelopmentprogrammetosharpenjournalists’skills.Withoutputtinginplaceaspecialdevelopmentplan,mediaplayersmightbeleftbehindespeciallyinthiseraof science and technology. It appears, however, that mediadevelopmentsupportisnotintheprioritylistofbothpublicandprivateestablishments.
5.1 Grants/Fellowships and Scholarships Unlikeinthepast,journalistsandbroadcastersarenolongersent
abroad to pursue further studies in their profession. Journalists and broadcastershavetostruggleontheirownandgetthemoneytopayforundergraduateandpostgraduateprogrammestheydesire.
Like it is the case in other professions, journalists are now forced tocompeteforloansfromtheHigherEducationStudentsLoansBoardtogetmoneyforpursuingfurtherstudies.Theymaysecureadmissiontolocalorforeignjournalismcollegesanduniversities,butgettingsponsorshipwouldbeabigheadache.
TheGovernmenthasdrawnalistofprioritiesforscholarships.Thelistincludesscience,medicine,pharmacy,petrolandgas,engineeringstudiesandagriculturalprogrammes.
Journalismisnotinthelist.Asaresult,thosewishingtotakeupfurtherstudiesinotherprofessions,includingjournalism,haveeithertodigdeeperintotheirpocketsorlookforsponsorsotherthantheGovernment.
TheZanzibar JournalismandMassMediaCollege (ZJMMC)principal,MrChandeOmar,saysalargenumberofCertificateandOrdinaryDiplomastudentshavenotsettledtheirtuitionfees,asituationwhichmakesitdifficultforhisinstitutionattainitsadministrativeandacademictargets.
126
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
It is on record that some Zanzibari students are in ChinapursuingdoctorateprogrammesinjournalismundertheChineseGovernmentscholarships.However,thecompetitiontoclinchaChinesescholarshipisveryhigh.
5.2 Promotion and Protection of Journalists Rights and Welfare
Sofar,themediaprofessionalassociationssuchasZPC,MCTandsomeforeignbodiessuchastheKenya-basedArticle19havetriedtorecordincidentsaffectingthejournalisminorderpromoteandprotectjournalists’rights.
Generally,theyhavepopularisedinternationalandregionallegalinstrumentscontainingarticlesonthejournalists’rights.TheyhavealsoeducatedlocaljournalistsontheCZ,1984,medialawsandlawsrelatingtothemedia(statutes,regulationsandpolicies).
The safety of journalists was also a topic of discussion. This, accordingtoMCTofficialsandArticle19,wasdeliberatelydesignedinanattempttofilltheyawninggapandempowermediaownersandjournaliststodealwiththelegalaspectsoftheirwork.
However,thewelfareofjournalistsremainsathornyissue.Itappearsthatjournalistsaregoodindefendingandexposingotherpeople’sproblemsbutcannotstandupandfightfortheirownwelfare.AccordingtothePresidentofZPC,MrAbdullaMfaume,manyjournalistsworkingwiththeprivateelectronicmediaarenotpaidtheirmonthlysalariesintime.
“Somejournalistshavegonewithoutsalariesforthreemonths,”henotes. But, so far, no action has been taken to rectify the situation. Itwasalsolearntthatsomejournalistsandbroadcastersinprivatemediahavenotevensignedalabourcontract.
AtleastjournalistsworkingwiththeGovernment-ownedmediaarecomfortableintermsoftheirwelfare.Underthecivilservicearrangementsguidedbylegislation,regulationsandpolicies,allcivilservants,areassuredofmonthlysalariesfromtheTreasury.
Inaddition, theemployer(theGovernment)remitsmonthlycontributionstotheZSSFforthebenefitofthemediaworkers.This is plausible.
127
2017-2018 REPORT
5.3 Promotion of Specialised Training in Journalism Neitherschoolsofjournalismnornewsroomshavedevelopeda
cultureofaspecialisedtrainingforjournalists.Generaljournalismsubjectsaretheonesthataretaughtinmediaschools.TheChiefAcademicOfficeroftheZJMMC,MrRashidOmar,acknowledgestheimportanceofspecialisedtraining,butsofarnothinghasbeendone.
StudentsaretaughtDevelopmentStudiesasoneofthecompulsorysubjectsinthefirstsemester.TheassumptionisthatthecontentofDevelopmentStudiestakescareofessentialgeneralknowledgethatthelearnersrequire.However,thefactremainsthatthereisnospecialisationintheIsles’mediaschools.
Likewise,innewsrooms,therearenospecialiseddesksthathavebeenestablished.Journalistsareassignedtocovernewsofanynature.Specialisationisnotpartoftheplanofmanagementsinthenewsrooms,explainstheManagingEditorofaGovernment-ownedmediaoutlet,MrYussufKhamis.HisviewswereechoedbythechiefeditoroftheBombaFM,MrMwinyiSadallah,whosaidthatspecialisationentailsalotofissuesincludinghumanandfinancialresources.
5.4 Provisions of Institutional Support to Media Institutions OnlyGovernmentownedelectronicandprintmediainstitutionsget
theinstitutionalsupport.Theseprepareanannualbudgetcoveringadministrativeexpenses,longandshorttermcostsanddevelopmentplan including technological advancement, recruitment, staffdevelopmentprogrammeandotherrequirements.
Thereafter,thebudgetisincludedintheestimatesoftheministryresponsibleforinformationbeforebeingtabledintheHouseofRepresentatives for deliberations and approval.
Privatemediaestablishmentsareleftontheirowndevices.TheydonotgetapennyfromtheGovernmentkitty,so.theyhavetodeveloptheirbudgetscoveringrecurrentanddevelopmentexpenditureandspendaspertheirownfinancialmuscle.
Thepaceofdevelopmentinprivatemediaisslow.Themediaownershavesettheirownpriorities.Theymayhavegoodplansbutthefinancialcapacityisthemaindeterminingfactorinimplementationoftheinstitutionaldevelopmentplan.Theyhavetofindtheirown
128
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
survivalmeans,especiallythroughadvertisements.Infact,itappearsthatveryfewmediainstitutionshavedevelopedlongandshorttermdevelopmentplans.
5.5 Availability of Research Fund Researchfundingisadistantdreamforbothpublicandprivate
media.Thesituationisworsefortheprivatemedia.Itappearsthatresearchfundingisnoteveninthemindoftheprivatemediaowners.Almostallbudgetoperationsoftheprivatemediaexcluderesearchfunding.Theprivatemediaisallouttoearnandsavemoney.
Foritspart,theGovernmentmediahasstoppedincludingarequestforresearchfundsintheirannualbudget.Nomoneyissetasideformediaresearchfund,explainedtheZanzibarJournalismandMassMediaCollegeChiefAcademicOfficer,MrRashidOmar.
5.6 Other Development Support AllGovernmentmediahousesgetdevelopmentsupportfromthe
nationalcoffers.ItisuptothemanagementofeachGovernmentmediahousetobudgetfordevelopmentsupportandsubmitittotherelevantministryforscrutinyandapproval.Thereafter,thebudgetisincorporatedintheministry’sbudgetandissenttotheMinistryofFinanceandPlanningforinclusioninthenationalbudget.
Thebestexampleofdevelopmentsupportisthemajorrehabilitationof thebuildingshousingtheGovernment-ownedZJMMCatKilimani.TheGovernmenthasreleasedaboutSh100millionfortherehabilitationworkandthepurchaseofmediaequipment.
Thesituationisdifferentwithprivatelyownedmediahouses.There isnobudget fordevelopmentsupport.Ownersof themediahouseshavethefinaldecisionofwhatshouldbedoneforthedevelopmentalinterestofaninstitution.Somemediahousescontinuetorentbuildingsandoffices.
5.7 Conclusion Mediadevelopmentsupportisnotawell-organisedaspect.Itis
notapredictablethingespeciallyinprivatemediasector.WithexceptionofjournalistsinGovernment-ownedmediahouses,the
129
2017-2018 REPORT
restcanneverbesureoftheirwelfare.Promotionandprotectionofjournalists’rightsisnotwelldesigned.Tosuittheirrespectiveinterestsandplans,somelocalandforeigninstitutionshaveshowninteresttopromoteandprotectjournalists.
However,thereisnoofficialplanshowingtheshortandlong-termstrategiestoachievetheobjectivesofthemediadevelopmentplanwhich include the welfare of journalists.
5.8 Recommendations Thefollowingarerecommendationsinrespecttothischapter: · Staffdevelopmentplaninmediahousesisabsolutely
necessary toassist journalists toadvance themselvesprofessionally;
· ThewelfareofjournalistsshouldbegivenpriorityinbothGovernmentandprivatemedia;.
· Thesafetyofjournalistsmustbepromotedand · Researchfundsmustbesetasideonannualbasis.
130
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
131
2017-2018 REPORT
Chapter Six
Professionalism in the Media and Trends in Journalism Training Institutions
6.0 Introduction Professionalismhasbeenanimportantsubjectinthepracticeof
journalismallovertheworld.Thisisanover-emphasisedissue.Lackofprofessionalismmaycauseaseriousblunder,denythepeopletherighttobewellinformedandthecredibilityofinformationsuppliedtothepeoplemaybequestionable.Inanumberofforums,playersinthemediasectorhavebeenurgedtotrytheirbesttosticktoprofessionalethicsinordertowintheconfidenceofthepublic.Thischapterfocusesontheprofessionalism.
6.1 Key Ethical Events in 2017/18 Unlikeinthepastyears,almostalltheintervieweeshaveconfirmed
thatnoofficialethicaleventhasbeenreportedinUngujaandPembain2017/18.Mediaplayershavebeenstrictlyobservingethicsinthepractice of the profession.
TheMCTZanzibarofficehasintroducedaregisterinwhichpeoplewithcomplaintsareinvitedtoreporttotheofficeforconsiderationandredress.“Notasinglecaseethicalissuehasbeenreportedtoouroffice,”saidtheMCTZanzibarOfficeIn-charge,MsShifaaSaid.ThisstatementwasechoedbythePresidentofZanzibarPressClub,MrAbdullaMfaumewhorevealedthattherewasnoofficialreportofethicaleventsduringtheperiod.
Lackofcomplaintsreportedinthetwoofficesdoesnot,however,indicatethatallwaswellintermsofethicalconsiderations.TheremaybeextrafactorsthatmakepeoplenottoreportincidentsofethicalviolationstotheMCTandZPC.Otherfactorsmayincludethe state of fear, lack of cooperation, slow response to incidents ofethicalviolations,awarenessbythepeopleontheexistence,functions and powers of the MCT and the ZPC on the interventions ofethicalissues.Asaresult,someoftheaffectedpeopledonotcomeouttoseeklegalredressandhavedecidedtokeepquiet.
132
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
6.2 Media Current Ethical Debates AnongoingethicaldebatehascenteredontwoissuesinZanzibar.
Oneistherighttoreply.Mediahousesarenotdoingwellinthisscore,andtwo,istheissueofbalancinginformationbeforeitispublishedandcirculated.Theseareveryimportantissuesthatneedimmediateattentionfromthemediahousesforthepurposeofrestoringtheircredibilityintheeyesofthepublicbeforethesituationgetsoutofhand.
6.2.1 The Right to Reply Inthiscontext,therighttoreplymeansthemediahousesmust
offer equal opportunity to people affected by what is published Notdoingthathasimplicationsonthemedia.Somepeoplefeel
unfairlytreatedbythemassmedia.Inaddition,theythinkthemediaisbeingusedtodamagetheirreputationintheeyesofrightthinkingmembersinthesociety.
6.2.2. Balance of Information Whenthereisnobalanceofinformation,itmeansjournalistsarenot
professionallyeffectiveanddonotspendtimeverifyingthecollectedinformationbeforepublishingit.Thisshouldbedistinguishedfromtherighttoreply,whichmeansgivingtheaffectedpersontheopportunitytorespondtowhathasbeenpublishedabouthim.Somejournalistshavedefendedthemselvessayingthatoften,sourcesofinformationdodeliberatelyshyawayunderflimsyexcusesfromspeakingtojournalistsonsomeburningissues.
Thissituationforcessomejournaliststopublishtheirstoryusingthelimitedinformationtheyhavecollectedfromtheirownsourcesprovidedthereisnoelementofdefamationorsedition.
6.3 The trend in Journalism Training Institution Traininginanyprofessionisavitalaspectofdevelopmentand
reforms.Journalismhasbeenchangingwithtime.Itisimpossibletopractiseoldjournalisminthiseraofscienceandtechnology.
Journalistsmustbegiventheopportunitytoattendtrainingprogrammesperiodicallysoastosharpentheirthinkingandequipthemwithnewskills.Developmentjournalismisnotachievablewithouttrainingprogrammes.
133
2017-2018 REPORT
6.4 Tertiary Institutions and Quality of Education/Curriculum
AspertheConstitutionoftheUnitedRepublicofTanzaniaof1977,highereducationisoneofthemattersfallingundertheUnionsphere. A special institution—the National Council for Technical Education(NACTE)—wasestablishedwithitsmainobjectivebeingtoregulate,amongotherthings,qualityassuranceofeducationprogrammeswhichareofferedatalltertiaryinstitutions.
Auditoftheeducationprogrammesisdoneperiodically.Theauditincludesavailabilityofteachersandtheirqualifications,curriculumandsupportivefacilitiesavailableintheinstitutions.JournalismschoolsinZanzibararealsounderNACTEcontrolandmustbeaudited periodically.
6.5 Research Status/Consultancies and Community Services
Assaidearlier,researchstatusandconsultanciesremainaproblem.Inthefirstplace,internationalandnationalinstitutionshavearesearch and consultancypolicy. Interestedparties includingforeignersareinvitedtoapplyforresearchandconsultancies.Thereafter,ashortlistoftheapplicantsismadeandafinalselectioniscarriedoutonthebasisofmerit.Thecompetitionisstiffandlocalapplicantsarerarelyselected.Inmanycases,foreignersaregiventheopportunitytodotheconsultanciesonthegroundsofcompetencyand they do not have any political or social inclination that could influenceresearchoutcome.
6.6 Sustainability of Journalism Training Institutions Thesurvivaloftraininginstitutionsofferingjournalismcourses,
especiallythosethatareprivatelyrun,ishanginginthebalance.Thenumberofstudentshasgonedowndrastically.Thisisattributedtoanumberofreasonsincludingcapacityofparentstopayfeesandalargenumberofpotentialapplicantsoptingforotherprofessions.
TheGovernmentdoesnotsponsorstudentsdoingjournalismasitisnotamongitspriorities.
TheZJMMCChiefAcademicOfficer,MrRashidOmar,saidthenumberofregisteredstudentsforadiplomainJournalismhasdroppedfrom115to5intheacademicyearthatbeganinOctober,
134
STATE OF THE MEDIA IN TANZANIA
2018.However,hedidnotrevealtheminimumnumberofstudentsperaprogramme.However,thegoodnewsisthattheZanzibarGovernmenthasrecentlyformedaspecialtaskforcechargedwiththedutytostudyintowaystomergetheZJMMCwiththeStateownedUniversityofZanzibar(SUZA).
Ifallgoeswell,theState-ownedmediacollegemaybecomepartofSUZAinthenearfutureanditwillabletoofferundergraduateandpostgraduateprogrammes,explainedMr.Omar.
6.7 Conclusion Despiteseveralexcusesthathavebeenadvancedbyjournalists
whofailtobalancetheirstoriesbeforetheypublishthem,butthatisaclearsignofviolationofmediaethics.Ethicsserveasaguidelinetothepracticeoftheprofessionandmustbeadheredtobyeveryjournalist.Thissituationindicatesthatthereisagapofprofessionalismthatneedstobeaddressed.Regardingtraining,thetrendshowsthatthereishopeforjournalismtraininginstitutions,especially those that are State-owned, to survive. What is required isthattheinstitutionsshouldabidebyalltheregulationsgivenbyNACTEinordertoberecognisedandattractstudents.WithoutgettingaccreditationfromNACTE,theschoolsmaybeforcedtoclosedown.Trainingremainsamatterofparamountimportance
6.8 Recommendations Thefollowingarerecommendationsinrespecttothischapter: · EnactmentoftheRighttoInformationAct; · Journalistsmustabidebyprofessionalethics; · Staff development programme in journalism is a
fundamentalissue. · Researchandconsultanciesshouldbegivenaspecial
considerationbyimprovingtheprofessionalcapacitiesof locals so as to win the awards and
· Journalismtraininginstitutionsmustbefinancialback-upinorderforthemtosurvive.
References
Constitutions TheConstitutionoftheUnitedRepublicofTanzaniaof1977.
135
2017-2018 REPORT
TheConstitutionofZanzibar,1984.
Legislation TheZanzibarBroadcastingCommissionAct,Zanzibar(ActNo.7
of 1997). TheCensorshipandCinematographyExhibitionAct,Zanzibar(Act
No. 1 of 2009). TheElectionsAct,Zanzibar(ActNo.42018). TheHouseofRepresentatives(Immunities,PowersandPrivileges,
Zanzibar(ActNo.4of2007). TheNationalSecurityAct,1970(ActNo.3of1970). The Penal Act, Zanzibar (Act No. 6 of 2018). ThePublicServiceCommission,Zanzibar(ActNo.6of2011). TheRegistrationofNewsAgents,NewspapersandBooksAct,
Zanzibar(ActNo.5of1988).
Bill TheZanzibarGovernmentGazette,1stSeptember,2017. TheZanzibarGovernmentPrintingPressAgency.
Cases A.K.Gopalanv.StateofMadrasAIR1950S.C.27. GoodwinvUnitedKingdom(1996)22EHRR123. InternationalHumanRightsInstruments TheInternationalCovenantonCivilandPoliticalRightsof1966. TheUniversalDeclarationofHumanRightsof1948.
Speech TheBudgetSpeechoftheMinistryResponsibleforInformationfor
2017/18 which was presented in the House of Representatives.
Report TheNyalaliCommissionReportonWhetherTanzaniashouldgo
tomulti-partypolitics,1992.
Gazette ZNZGovt.Gazette,1stSeptember,2017.