9/25/2014
1
Staying Focused Every Day: The 12
Touchstones of Good Teaching
Bryan Goodwin, CEO
Michigan Association of State and Federal Program Specialists
2014 Fall Directors’ InstituteOctober 1, 2014
Research ● Evaluation ● Instruction ● School Improvement ● Learning Innovation ● Educator Effectiveness ● Systems Transformation
Making a difference in the quality of education and learning for all through excellence in
applied research, product development, and service.
9/25/2014
2
Research ● Evaluation ● Instruction ● School Improvement ● Learning Innovation ● Educator Effectiveness ● Systems Transformation
Denver
Nashville Charleston
Honolulu
Melbourne
McREL International
9/25/2014
3
Why does this happen?
Are we doing too little?
Or too much?
•
•
•
•
•
•
9/25/2014
4
Literacy blocks
Direct Instruction
Differentiated instruction
Culturally responsive teaching
Walkthroughs
Parent involvement
P.T.A. meetings
Accountability committee
Bus schedules
Lyme disease prevention
Curriculum mapping
AfterschoolData
committees
Gifted & Talented
Halloween Party
Halloween PartyFall
Festival
Special education
IEPsRtI
DDDM
PLCs
Reading First
PhonicsWhole
Language
PhonicsBalanced LiteracyPep Assembly
Spelling Bee
Morning Announcements
School Improvement
Plans
FTEs
Bilingual EdDual Immersion
ESL
TGIF!
Staff Development Performance
Reviews
MathNew MathNew, New Math
Success for All
Open CourtEveryday MathSaxon Math
ConstructivistTeaching
Induction
Mentoring
CoachingState tests
District tests
Value addedGrowth models
Formative assessment
Career prep
College for all
Student learningCharacter education
NCLBAP
Multi-age Classrooms
Ability grouping
De-tracking
Sex Ed
Technology Integration
Positive Behavior Support
Lunch programs
Multicultural education
Courageous conversations
Interactive Whiteboards
Portfolio Assessment
Block Scheduling
Safe & Drug Free Schools
Abstinence Only
What’s on your to-do list right now?Write down what you need to do this week, month, school year.
Can you get it all done?
Can you get it all done well?
If you could do only one thing well this year, what would it be?
What would you put on your stop doing list?
Where would you focus your efforts?
Reflection & Discussion
9/25/2014
5
What if you could scrap your to-do list and start all over with what matters most?
Where would you begin?
The What Matters Most™ Framework
GUARANTEE CHALLENGING, ENGAGING & INTENTIONAL INSTRUCTION
GUARANTEE CHALLENGING, ENGAGING & INTENTIONAL INSTRUCTION
This morning
This afternoon
9/25/2014
6
Morning session objectives
Describe 3 imperatives of good teaching
Help you to focus your improvement efforts
Introduce a new way of addressing complexity
Introduce 12 touchstones of good teaching
What makes teaching so difficult?
9/25/2014
7
Backwards map!
Use RTI!Differentiate instruction!
Set learning targets!
Flip your classroom!
Integrate technology!
Teach to learning styles!
Where do I start? And how does
this stuff connect?
Use data!
Support positive behavior!
Use rubrics!
Use Bloom’s …… no
Webb’s!
8 mathematical practices!
Have a growth mindset!
Use formative assessment!
Motivate!Engage your
students!
Create cross-curricular lessons!
More rigor! Less filling … er, fluff!
More non-fiction!
… no MTSS!
Where should we focus?
9/25/2014
8
How am doing on time?
I need to get Connor re-
engaged.
Kaisha is ready for a different cooperative
learning group.
Okay, let’s check for
understanding.
Tyler looks upset. I should e-mail his mom about what happened today at recess.
Jaslyn knows this stuff, but is
so quiet.
Good thing I use the “no opt-out” strategy.
Gotta remember to collect the
parent permission forms.
Oh, wait. There’s a faculty meeting
afterschool.
Seriously? A P.A. announcement
right now?
Langston and Chase are still mixing up their b’s and d’s. I’ll
help them with that.
9/25/2014
9
Is teaching any less complicated than ….
Aviation? Emergency medicine?
Condense staggering amounts of new knowledge
Apply research & experience to practice
Put the pieces together
Respond to unpredictable circumstances
What’s the solution?Checklists
Medical checklists saved 1,500 lives and $175 million in Michigan alone
Helps professionals translate research to action
Must be simple enough to be memorable
Helps to create teamwork & professionalism
Every new aviation safety bulletin translated into a checklist
9/25/2014
10
Not a READ-DO, but a DO-CONFIRM list
READ-DO LISTS
DO-CONFIRM
LISTS
9/25/2014
11
Table talk
• What teacher had the most impact in your life?
• What made them special?
• What do you remember most about them?
3 imperatives of great teaching
Be demandingAlign teaching with high expectations for learning
Be supportiveProvide a nurturing environment
Be intentionalKnow why you’re doing what you’re doing
9/25/2014
12
Supp
ortiv
e en
viro
nmen
ts
Great teaching
Supportive environments
Great teachingNot so
9/25/2014
13
Be demandingAlign teaching with
high expectations for learning
Some common misconceptions about what it means to be demanding
9/25/2014
14
Rigor means lots and lots of homework
Giving bad grades
makes me a good teacher
9/25/2014
15
Be demandingAlign teaching with high expectations for learning
I use standards to guide every learning opportunity
I ensure students set personal learning objectives for each lesson
I peel back the curtain & make my performance expectations clear
I measure understanding against high expectations
Self-Reflection 1Page 3
9/25/2014
16
I use standards to guide every learning opportunity
What school factor has the strongest correlation to student achievement?
Opportunity to learn
Clearly articulated curriculumAligned with assessments
Enacted in classrooms
Related practices
Look for big ideas in the standardsFocus lesson and unit planning
Planning by looking back and aheadUsing standards to get creative
Using standards to guide every learning opportunity
9/25/2014
17
Getting on the same sheet of music
Unleashing creativity
Ensuring conformity
Punishing wrongdoers
Stan
dard
s
9/25/2014
18
Stan
dard
s
Multiple Pathways
Standards in the 20th Century
• Industrial model• Compliance • Efficiency• Consistency• Any color you want, as long
as it’s black
Standards in the 21st Century
• Technological model• Collaboration• Creativity• Choice• Any color you want
9/25/2014
19
Uses text organizers to determine the main ideas and to locate information in a text.
Describe and demonstrate how to set up a wall.
Uses text organizers to determine the main ideas and to locate information in a text.
Read the contract, blueprints, specifications, and standards and codes specific to the contract .
Estimate the materials needed, check figures, order the equipment and materials.
9/25/2014
20
I ensure students set personal learning objectives for each lesson
Translating standards into steps toward mastery
9/25/2014
21
Helping students set personal learning objectives
Learning objective:Master writing mechanics.
Learning objective:Use supporting details.
Learning objective:Develop original thesis.
Long-term stretch goal:
Write a persuasive essay.
I can put commas where
they belong.
I can support my ideas with facts.
I can develop a compelling, big
idea.
I want to write a letter to the
editor that persuades
people to start high school later in the morning.
9/25/2014
22
9/25/2014
23
9/25/2014
24
Activity: Unpacking One Standard
I peel back the curtain & make
my performance expectations clear
9/25/2014
25
The GUESS WHAT
YOUR TEACHER WANTS YOU TO KNOW AND DO
Show!
Use rubrics to open the black box of grading
Higher grades
Student motivation
New dynamic
9/25/2014
26
Guidelines for creating rubrics
Identify proficiency first
Partial understanding/performance
Advanced understanding/performance
Minimal proficiency / performance
Focus on growth (e.g., “not enough evidence to assess understanding”)
I measure understanding against high expectations
9/25/2014
27
High school GPA has risen while 12th
grade NAEP scores have declined
2.68
2.98
292286
307 307
150
170
190
210
230
250
270
290
310
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
4
1992 2005
GPA
Reading
Math
More students get straight As in high school as more drop out of college
7.7
15.6
1976 20060
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
% of high school students with straight As
52.8
36
1983 20130
10
20
30
40
50
60
% of 4-year public college freshmen graduating in 5 years
9/25/2014
28
Student grades are often a hodgepodge of factors
Tests/quizzes, 32%
Class work, 12%
Term paper, 7%
Individual project, 9%
Final, 9%
Homework, 18%
Group work, 3%Participation, 4%
Other, 7%
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
Reflection & Discussion
On a scale from 1-10, how strongly do you agree with the following statements?
Homework should be factored into final grades
Effort should be factored into final grades.
Grades should only reflect student mastery of content.
Behavior should be factored into final grades.
1 Strongly Agree
10 Strongly Disagree
5Undecided
9/25/2014
29
What it really means toBe demanding
Rigorous standards to guide learning
= High expectations
Student buy-in to learning objectives
+
High performance
criteria+
Evaluation aligned with standards
& criteria
+
Reflection & discussion
Be demandingAlign teaching with high expectations for learning
I use standards to guide every learning opportunity
I ensure students set personal learning objectives for each lesson
I peel back the curtain & make my performance expectations clear
I measure understanding against high expectations
Personal reflectionDo these checklist items make sense to you?
Group discussionWhich of these items would be your school or district’s biggest opportunity for improvement?
Report outWhat would it take to do these things well in our classrooms?
Group protocol1 minute quiet reflection4 minute everyone share out10 minutes select one item and discuss what it would take
9/25/2014
30
Be supportiveProvide a nurturing
environment
9/25/2014
31
ExpectationsHighLow
Rel
atio
nshi
ps w
ith
stud
ents
Strong
Weak
Sophisticates
Warm Demanders
Traditionalists
Sentimentalists
Kleinfeld, J. (1972). Effective teachers of Indian and Eskimo high school students .
Marva Collins: A Warm Demander in the Classroom
Collins: Sweetheart, what are you going to do? Use your life or throw it away?
Gary: I’m not gonna do any damn work.
Collins: I am not going to give up on you. I am not going to let you give up on yourself. If you sit there leaning against this wall all day, you are going to end up leaning on something or someone all your life. And all that brilliance bottled up inside you will go to waste.
Gary relents to going up to the board, but then digs in his heels again, refusing to work.
Collins: If you do not want to participate, go to the telephone and tell your mother, ‘Mother, in this school we have to learn, and Mrs. Collins says I can’t fool around, so will you please pick me up.’
Source: Adapted from Colilns, M. & Tamarkin, C. (1990). Marva Collins’ Way. New York: Penguin Putnam Inc.
9/25/2014
32
Common misconceptions about being supportive
Misconception:
Motivate with prizes & rewards
9/25/2014
33
Extrinsic rewards often backfire
Misconception
Kids these days have to be entertained
9/25/2014
34
Be supportiveProvide a nurturing environment
I engage student interest with every lesson
I interact meaningfully with every student every day
I use feedback to encourage effort
I create an oasis of safety and respect in my classroom
Self-Reflection 2Page 9
9/25/2014
35
I engage student interest with every lesson
What’s more important?
Motivation?Intelligence? or
9/25/2014
36
Teachers13%
Schools7%
Home environment
33%Student interest & motivation
14%
Prior achievement & knowledge
33%
Factors Related to Student Success(% variance in achievement)
Source: Marzano, R.J. (2000). A New Era of School Reform. Aurora, CO: McREL.
Teachers13%
Schools7%
Home environment
33%Student interest & motivation
14%
Prior achievement & knowledge
27%
IQ6%
Factors Related to Student Success(% variance in achievement)
Source: Marzano, R.J. (2000). A New Era of School Reform. Aurora, CO: McREL.
9/25/2014
37
Hard workbeats talent
when talent doesn’t work hard
Students’ intrinsic motivation decreases as they progress through school
50
60
70
80
90
100
110
Age 9 Age 10 Age 13 Age 16 Age 17
Reading
Math
Science
Source: Gottfried, A.E., Fleming, J. , Gottfried, A.W. (2001). Continuity of academic intrinsic motivation from childhood through late adolescence: A longitudinal study. Journal of Educational Psychology, 93 (1) 3-13.
9/25/2014
38
Do I really need to learn
this stuff?
Brain RuleKids, like adults, don’t pay attention to boring things (they like mysteries & puzzles)
9/25/2014
39
Our brains are wired for
Mystery Who dunnit? (Who is that?)
Puzzles & Problem SolvingWhat don’t I know? (Why is he standing there?)
What’s the answer? (How can I figure out what’s going on?)
Suspense What’s going to happen? (Is he going to murder someone?)
TellingLearn this (That guy is waiting for a bus.)
PredictabilityToday is like yesterday & tomorrow (His bus will arrive on time.)
Directing & InsistingDo this (Watch him wait for the bus. Because I said so. Yes, it’s on the test.)
Classrooms are often wired for
9/25/2014
40
Creating classroom intrigue
Mystery • Why are leaves green?• How could a rag tag band of
rebels defeat an empire?
Puzzles & Problem Solving• Notice any pattern in triangle
hypotenuses?
Suspense• What do you think the main
character will do next?• What does this foreign language
message say?
Narrative Advance Organizer
9/25/2014
41
• Interesting lessons take more work & thought
• When kids are off-task, we might ask, What’s the task? Is it worth doing?
• Some teachers may insist boredom builds character
• But should the purpose of schooling really be to get kids acclimated to mind-numbing tasks?
Boring is easy
CENTRAL HIGH SCHOOLAcclimating Kids To Boredom Since 1965
9/25/2014
42
Table talk
• Picture an engaging classroom.
• What makes it engaging?
• Why aren’t all classes engaging?
• What would it take for us to make all
lessons and classrooms engaging?
I interact meaningfully with every student
16%
84%
% elementary & middle school
students who feel supported by teachers
% of elementary students with
supportive teacher interactions
25%
75%
% of middle & high school students who feel valued in their
schools
50%50%
9/25/2014
43
Powerful teacher-student relationship
variables
• Non-directivity• Empathy• Warmth• Encouraging critical thinking• Encouraging learning• Adapting to differences
Cornelius-White, J. (2007). Learner-centered teacher-student relationships are effective: A meta-analysis. Review of Educational Research (p. 131). 77 (1) 113–143.
Jacob
9/25/2014
44
Maggie
Activity (p. 11)
Write down the name of students in your school or classroom.
Rate your interactions with them using this scale below.
I interact regularly with this student regarding both school work and on informal subjects. We have a good rapport. I feel that I know him or her well.
OKWe have a good teacher/student relationship. Our conversations are professional, but comfortable. I know a little about his or her hobbies and interests. We interact frequently, but not daily.
I do not know this child very well. Our conversations can be strained or awkward. I don’t know his/her hobbies. Our interactions are strictly formal.
How would your colleagues rate their interactions with them?
9/25/2014
45
I use feedback to encourage effort
Feedback
Effective feedback correlated with 28 point percentile gain in achievement
Done poorly, it can actually diminish
student motivation and performance
9/25/2014
46
I’m disappointed in your performance. You
should’ve done what Irecommended.(controlling)
If this book is too tough for you, we should
probably find an easier one for you to read.
(fixed mindset)
You received all 10 points allotted in the grading rubric for descriptions.
(evaluative)
Here’s your paper from … er, three weeks ago. You
didn’t do so well.(not immediate)
Wow. You got 8 right. That’s a really good
score. You must be really smart at this.
Wow. You got 8 right. That’s a really good score. You must have
worked really hard at this.
Dweck, C. (2006). Mindset (p. 71–72). New York: Random House.
9/25/2014
47
Growth vs. fixed mindset feedbackGrowth mindset Fixed mindset
You blazed right through those problems! You’re a math whiz.
It’s okay. Not everyone is a natural at this. We’ll move on to something you’re better at.
Wow. This is beautiful. You’re such a good artist!
This book is for advanced readers. Let’s find one that’s easier one for you to read.
Your practice is really paying off. You’re getting your math facts down.
I know you’re frustrated. Everyone learns differently. We’ll keep at it and find your best way to master this.
Drawing in 3-D perspective is very difficult. I can tell you had to work hard at this.
I know there are a lot of big words in this book, but as long as you’re not bumping into more than five words per page that you don’t know, keep with it. It’s making your brain stronger.
Debra, I don't know why your rolls are all left. I liked them. The burnt part gave
them some flavor.
Not all feedback is welcome
9/25/2014
48
Non-controlling
Non-controlling vs. controlling feedback
Controlling
I’m disappointed in your performance.You should’ve done what Irecommended.
Your essay was good. That’s the level ofwork you should be doing if you’re serious about college.
You had a lot of careless mistakes inyour homework. You should check itmore carefully before turning it in to me.
You’d better buckle down and studyhard for this test.
I’m so pleased with your report! Keep upthe great work.
Your work on this particular assignmentdidn’t reflect advanced performance. Iknow you can do better.
I see you worked hard and put a lot ofthought into that essay. It was collegecaliber.
I noticed a lot of careless mistakes inyour homework. I think you would’vecaught them yourself if you had double-checked your work before turning it in.
I think there’s a great student inside youjust waiting to come out. But I can’t makehim/her come out. That’s up to you.You worked hard to include facts in your report that people might not know and did a nice job of anticipating misconceptions.
Self-actualization
Self-esteem
Love
Safety
Physiological
I create an oasis of safety & respect in my classroom
Maslow’s Hierarch of Needs
9/25/2014
49
4%
96%
% bullying incidents seen by teachers
% of high school students who report
being bullied
47%53%
I create an oasis of safety & respect in my classroom
Establishing rules & consequences for behavior
We will:
Respect each other’s opinions, personalities, and preferences as
we wish to be respected
Take responsibility for our own actions and duties
Commit 100 percent to our work
Seek win-win solutions in every situation
“I see one group already on task …”
Caught you …doing good!
“I saw some really great behavior today …”
What if students don’t meet these
expectations?
9/25/2014
50
Creating an oasis of safety with morning meetings
Greeting Teaches students to make eye contact & greet one another
SharingChildren share concerns, thoughts, what they are excited about
Group activityStudents interact & work together
MessageTeacher’s hand-written letter related to character
Source: Lauren Marrocco,
New Jersey 2013 Teacher of the Year
Table Talk ActivityApplying the Touchstones to a Case Example
I engage student interestwith every lesson
I interact meaningfully with every student every day
I use feedback to encourage effort
I create an oasis of safety and respect in my classroom
I am a first year, long-term substitute teacher. I have inherited an unruly, poorly behaved fourth-grade class.
To keep them in line, I’ve resorted to giving them little treats for good behavior. It has helped a bit, but seems to have diminishing returns.
What should I do?
Develop a 5-step action plan for this teacher
9/25/2014
51
Be intentionalKnow why you’re
doing what you’re doing
Oh, sure, I use research-based
strategies all the time
Misperception about what it means to be
intentional
9/25/2014
52
Setting objectives
Note-taking & summarizing
Nonlinguistic representation
Questions, cues & advance
organizers
Today we will learn:Latitude & longitude
9 Categories of Effective Instruction
1. Identifying similarities & differences
2. Summarizing & note taking
3. Reinforcing effort & providing recognition
4. Homework & practice
5. Nonlinguistic representations
6. Cooperative learning
7. Setting objectives & providing feedback
8. Generating & testing hypotheses
9. Questions, cues, and advance organizers
9/25/2014
53
Classroom Instruction that Works Why It Works
Identifying similarities & differences Supports acquisition of new knowledge by linking to prior learningDeepens knowledge with critical thinking (analysis)
Summarizing & note taking Focuses learning on important contentDeepens knowledge with critical thinking (analysis), review & revisionDemonstrates understanding and identifies misconceptions
Reinforcing effort & providing recognition Motivates learning through positive reinforcementMotivates learning by developing growth mindset in students
Homework & practice Motivates learning through development of good work habitsDeepens knowledge through applicationDemonstrates understanding & identifies misconceptions
Nonlinguistic representations Supports acquisition of new knowledge through visual learningDeepens knowledge, supports recall through visual learning
Cooperative learning Motivates through “positive interdependence”Deepens knowledge through problem-based learning
Setting objectives & providing feedback Focuses learning on important contentMotivates by personalizing learningSupports acquisition of new knowledge by surfacing misconceptions
Generating & testing hypotheses Motivates by accessing “mental set” for problem-solvingDeepens knowledge through critical thinking (evaluating, creating)
Questions, cues, and advance organizers Focuses learning on important contentMotivates by increasing student curiosity, interest in topicSupports acquisition of new knowledge by linking to prior learningDeepens knowledge through critical thinking (analyzing, evaluating)
Setting objectives
Note-taking & summarizing
Nonlinguistic representation
Questions, cues & advance
organizers
Focus & personalize learning
Activate prior knowledge
Access visual mode of learning
Deepen knowledge through review &
revision
Today we will learn:Latitude & longitude
9/25/2014
54
Self-Reflection 3Page 16
Be intentionalKnow why you’re doing what you’re doing
I make the most of every minute
I help students develop deep knowledge
I coach students to mastery
I help students do something with their learning
9/25/2014
55
I make the most of every minute
What school factor far exceeds socioeconomic status as a predictor of student success?
Time spent on instruction
How much time are students actually learning?
Time learning
Time teaching
Time in class
Time in school
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
9/25/2014
56
Conduct a time audit
… opening routines?closing routines?
… transitions?… teacher-led instruction?
… student-led instruction?
How much time do I spend on …
www.timeandlearning.org
Reflection & DiscussionWhat would this graph look like in your school or district?
What things could your school/district do to improve its use of time?
What things should we stop doing?
Time learning
Time teaching
Time in class
Time in school
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
9/25/2014
57
I help students develop deep knowledge
How much knowledge do students actually retain when tested months later?
Only about half
9/25/2014
58
6 Essential Cs for Deep KnowledgeCuriosityMotivation
ConnectionLink to prior knowledge
CoherenceMeaningful patterns Concentration
Thinking about learning
CoachingGuided practice
ContextReal-world application
How important is prior knowledge?
9/25/2014
59
Irish U19s blast their way to a place in the finalsBy Ian CallenderTuesday, 9 August 2011
Ireland Under-19s sealed their place at next year’s World Cup finals in Australia last night with fittingly with their most impressive batting performance of the tournament.Set 246 to win their rearranged game against Namibia at Coleraine yesterday, the Irish made their usual faltering start, slumping to 32 for three, but lost only one more wicket as they won with three overs to spare.
Jason van der Merwe made 72 and Shane Getkate, showing his all-round ability, finished 61 not out from 53 balls, with three fours and a six.
Straddling partnerships of 99 and 117 was the captain George Dockrell who again proved why he is batting at No5 in this line-up. Dockrell hit an unbeaten 82, with just five fours, but on the day it was the perfect innings to get the job done. And that, along with his bowling figures of three for 35 there was no doubt who deserved the man of the match.
How to connect students with prior knowledge
Strategy Example
Provide cues Tell what’s coming next, with a link to what they already know
Ask connecting questions
Provide advance organizers
“Today, we’re going to learn about inertia, which is the tendency for objects at rest to stay at rest and objects in motion to stay in motion.”
“How many of you have ever been in a car when the driver had to suddenly hit the brakes? What happened to the people and things in the car?”
Graphic (a picture of inertia)Expository (quick factual overview)Narrative (tell a story)Quick skim of text
9/25/2014
60
6 Essential Cs for Deep KnowledgeCuriosityMotivation
ConnectionLink to prior knowledge
CoherenceMeaningful patterns Concentration
Thinking about learning
CoachingGuided practice
ContextReal-world application
AbolitionistAntebellumBorder statesEmancipation proclamation Gettysburg addressRobert E. LeeUlysses S. GrantAbraham Lincoln1863John Wilkes BoothMonitor & MerrimacMason-Dixon lineFrederick DouglassJohn BrownLincoln-Douglas debatesMissouri Compromise
What are the big ideas?
How was the Civil War a political, economic, and social
turning point?
Is war ever justified?
How did political, economic, and cultural differences between the
north and south lead to the Civil War?
9/25/2014
61
6 Essential Cs for Deep KnowledgeCuriosityMotivation
ConnectionLink to prior knowledge
CoherenceMeaningful patterns Concentration
Thinking about learning
CoachingGuided practice
ContextReal-world application
Why am I asking students to do this?
What do I want them to think about when they do it?
9/25/2014
62
Why won’t my third horse stand up?
Should I use glue or paste?
Will my teacher care that I don’t have a
sky on the right side?
My brown marker is about to run out.
What would like this life have been like?
How did they actually build that
teepee?
How would I communicate with a tribe that spoke a different language?
Why did they have a nomadic lifestyle?
9/25/2014
63
Think-Pair-Share Discussion
What examples have you seen of projects that don’t ask students to concentrate on deep knowledge?
Why do teachers use these projects?
6 Essential Cs for Deep KnowledgeCuriosityMotivation
ConnectionLink to prior knowledge
CoherenceMeaningful patterns Concentration
Thinking about learning
CoachingGuided practice
ContextReal-world application
9/25/2014
64
I coach students to mastery
What single practice separates elite performers from all others?
Coaches who guide deliberate practice
What behavior separates elite performers from those who remain
sub-elite?
Focusing practice sessions on mastering what they have not yet
mastered or most needs improvement
9/25/2014
65
Tips for making practice deliberate
Be clear about the purpose of practice
Focus practice on improvement
Show students how to practice
Provide multiple opportunities for knowledge retrieval
Observe students as they practice
Provide corrective feedback
6 Essential Cs for Deep KnowledgeCuriosityMotivation
ConnectionLink to prior knowledge
CoherenceMeaningful patterns Concentration
Thinking about learning
CoachingGuided practice
ContextReal-world application
9/25/2014
66
I help students do something with their learning
What’s different about U.S. classrooms that causes students to fall behind global peers?
We tend to downgrade complex problems into simple procedural chores
New knowledge fades without applicationFuture jobs will require solving complex problems
Students find procedural chores un-engagingReal-world learning engages & motivates
Not all project-based learning is effective
9/25/2014
67
Key to project-based learning: The driving question
Go build a rocket
What rocket design makes rockets fly highest?
Barron, B.J.S., Schwartz, D.L., Vye, N.J., Moore, A., Petrosino, A., Linda, Zech, L., Bransford, J.D. (1998). Doing with understanding: Lessons from research on problem- and project-based learning. The Journal of the Learning Sciences, 7, (3&4), 271-311.
Discussion: 6 Essential Cs for Deep KnowledgeWhere do our greatest opportunities for improvement lie?
CuriosityMotivation
ConnectionLink to prior knowledge
CoherenceMeaningful patterns Concentration
Thinking about learning
CoachingGuided practice
ContextReal-world application
9/25/2014
68
Final thoughts & reflection
What are three things you learned today?
9/25/2014
69
What two things do you want to learn more about?
What one thing are you inspired to start doing?
9/25/2014
70
What makes a teacher great?
Here’s what real people say about the best teachers they ever had.
(Compiled on http://www.etni.org.il/bestteacherever.htm)
My favorite teacher was my freshman math teacher. He was one of the goofiest people I ever knew, but incredibly nice and you could really tell he cared about the subject and all of his students.
He was always so clear in his explanations and I could always understand what he was trying to get at.
He always came into the classroom bringing a positive attitude that set us all going.
9/25/2014
71
Believe it or not my favorite teacher was named Mr. Yelle.
He spoke to us “at eye level,” and had infinite patience and tolerance for anything except unkindness.
We did incredible projects for the science fairs. To this day (and I'm talking 40 years ago) I remember our lessons on meteorology.
By the way, he didn't yell.
My best ever teacher was my geography teacher in high school.
She explained everything extremely clearly, then checked every student's notebook to make sure the student had written down what she said and drawn the maps and diagrams correctly.
I can still remember a large part of what she taught decades later! Discipline problems didn't exist in her class because there was never an idle moment or a boring one.
9/25/2014
72
The best teacher I ever had was my eighth grade science teacher, Mr. Jack Herr.
Every class was fun and I actually learned stuff about science.
He was the one person who really understood me and he changed my life dramatically
… and I forever thank him for that.
Professor Roston is the best teacher ever. His lectures are well organized, interesting and put across with a dramatic flair.
He turned me on to English literature.
Moreover, he was approachable and always had time for students.
His comments on papers were constructive and encouraging.
9/25/2014
73
[The best teacher I ever had] made us think. I think it was the first time I was really made to think in high school.
Instead of just learning about the major revolutions in history, we relived them. … He forced us to look at the world through the eyes of the people involved.
We took their parts and argued their causes. This way, we understood the complexity of history … and no longer conceived of it simply as a time line to be memorized.
Gail Anderson was my grade 9 English teacher.
She took the time to … write meaningful comments and suggestions for writing, organizing and presenting better work. We always wanted to please her and in the end pleased ourselves.
She made a difference in our lives. She shaped our destiny and gave us confidence.
That is why I teach today.
9/25/2014
74
Great teachers are as differentas snowflakes
yet alike in that they focus on doing what matters most.
They challenge us.
“He made us think.”
“There was never an idle
moment.” “He forced us to look at the world through the
eyes of the people involved.”
9/25/2014
75
They connect with us.
“He was the one person who really understood me.”
“His comments were constructive and
encouraging.”
“She took the time to … write meaningful
comments.”
They teach with clarity & purpose.“He was always so
clear in his explanations.”
“His lectures were well organized and interesting.”
“We did incredible projects.”
9/25/2014
76
What would you like your students to say about you in the
future?
But remember … great teaching doesn’t happen
overnight.
It happens one step at a time.
What step will you take?
9/25/2014
77
Stay connected
McREL.org
@McREL@bryanrgoodwin
Company/McREL
Get free resourcesMcREL.org
Thank You