Lanze Berry
9/4/2012
1
Steady State Operating Curve
By Lanze Berry
University of Tennessee at Chattanooga
Engineering 3280L
Blue Team (Khanh Nguyen, Justin Cartwright)
Course: ENGR 3280L
Section: 001
Date: September 4, 2012
Instructor: Dr. Jim Henry
Lanze Berry
9/4/2012
2
Introduction
This laboratory was used to understand a single-input, single-output system and to
observe the relationship between the two in a steady state condition. A motor generator is used
by a single input to provide constant power and the single output is current that was also
generated by the motor generator. The input and output are measured as functions of time by a
computer program and further analyzed. The results obtained will be used to observe the steady
state performance of the system. The main objective of this laboratory is to develop and
interpret a steady state curve of the system and how it will respond to varying power input.
The background and theory of the experiment is discussed. Following the background
and theory is the procedure of the experiment. The results are then presented and followed by
the discussion of the results. The last two sections will include the conclusions and
recommendations and the appendices, which will be at the end of the report containing all the
raw data.
Initially, the “Background and Theory” section will present the physical and
mathematical models used to represent and analyze the data. The “Procedure” section will then
describe how the laboratory was conducted and the method in which it was performed. The
“Results” section will include graphs and tables to explain how the experimental data relates to
the initial objective of the laboratory. The “Discussion” will contain the significance of the
results. The “Conclusions and Recommendations” section will describe the principles that were
demonstrated by the results and the discussion. The “Appendices” will be the last section
containing all the remaining data and graphs involved with the results.
Lanze Berry
9/4/2012
3
Background and Theory:
This laboratory shows the relationship between a single-input and single-output of a
control system in steady state conditions. A steady state operating curve is developed by using
the data acquired by sensors and a computer. This operating curve will help show when steady
state is reached. Then the average values of the output will be analyzed using statistics to find
uncertainties in the measurements.
The materials used in this lab are a computer, motor, generator, controller, transmitters
and light bulbs. A computer program called LabVIEW is used to graph the readings of the
experiment. The computer is used to send a constant input power signal to the motor. The motor
will then cause the generator to produce amps. A signal will then be sent back to the computer
as an output. Once the signal is received by the computer, LabVIEW will then graph the input
and output readings. Once this has been done, the data can be read by EXCEL, which will help
in the analysis of the data. Figure 1 shows the schematic of the motor-generated system.
Figure 1: Schematic of the Motor- Generated System
Computer
Motor Generator
Light Bulbs
JT 101
JRC 101
ERT 101
Lanze Berry
9/4/2012
4
Figure 1 demonstrates in schematic form the procedure of sending an input and receiving the
output. The computer sends a signal to the power transmitter (JT 101) which in turn relays it to
the power-recording controller (JRC 101). Once the signal is received, it is sent to the motor
where the percentage power is the input. The motor begins to turn and the mechanical energy is
converted to electrical energy. The generator uses electromagnetic induction to convert the
energy. The new electrical energy is then used to create current to the light bulbs. The generator
then sends an amps output signal back to the (ERT) and relays the signal to the computer where
it is interpreted in LabVIEW as a graph. The block diagram is shown in Figure 2.
Figure 2: Block Diagram of the Motor-Generated System
Figure 2 shows the input to the system on the left hand side of the block. The input is the time
allotted (in seconds) for the experiment and the motor power (in a percentage from 0 to 100).
The output response from the system is shown on the right side of the block. The output C(t)
demonstrates that it is a function of time. The output also contains the generated amps. The
system responds by giving a different amp output to each different input containing the time and
motor power percentage used.
Motor-
Generator
System
Input M(t)
Motor Power (%)
Output C(t)
Generated Voltage (V) Generated Amps (A)
Lanze Berry
9/4/2012
5
Procedure
The experiment begins with using a computer. A program called LabVIEW is used as
system control and it collects data throughout the duration of the experiment. This program was
accessible through the internet and the Control Systems class website. Once the Current
Information Systems group was selected, a choice appeared to begin collected data for the
Constant input function. Once this was selected, a screen appeared with credentials to fill out
(name, email, etc…). Also, a space was provided to enter the how many seconds the experiment
was to last and there was also a space to enter at what percentage the power should be. Once the
criterion was complete, the program would conduct the experiment according to the time and
percentage entered. The program then records and plots the data into a data base. The
experiment was conducted five times at various percentages to provide an output between three
to four amps. The data was then translated into excel to plot a steady state operating curve and to
statistically analyze the data. Figure 3 shows the flow of information in LabVIEW.
Figure 3: Flow of Information to and from LabVIEW
Lanze Berry
9/4/2012
6
Results
The experimental data was collected using LabVIEW. LabVIEW measured the current
in amps of the input percentage. Once it was collected, it was compiled into graphs using excel.
These graphs represented the power input percentages from 72.5% - 74%. The target output was
3 to 4 amps. Figure 4 is a sample graph that was created using a power input percentage of
72.5%.
Figure 4: Time(s) vs. Input(%) vs. Output(Amps) for 72.5% Power
Figure 4 shows that the system reached steady state around 39 to 40 seconds. Therefore, any
data collected previous to that can be neglected. From 0 seconds to 39 seconds, the data was not
included to find the average or the standard deviation. The average came out to be about 3.6
amps and the standard deviation was calculated to be about 0.007 amps. At 72.5% input power,
the system took about 39 seconds to reach a consistent level thus reaching steady state. Graphs
Lanze Berry
9/4/2012
7
were created for power input percentages of 72.5% - 74% in 0.5% intervals and can be found in
the appendix. The results of the experiments can be represented in Table 1.
Table 1
Input Percentage (%) Output (Amps) Uncertainty (Amps)
72.5 3.6 0.006
73 3.7 0.005
73.5 3.8 0.005
74 3.9 0.006
The average amps and standard deviations in Table 1 were used to create a graph. This graph is
a representation of the steady state operating curve (SSOC). Figure 5 is the graph of the SSOC
for the current system from 72.5% - 74% power inputs at 0.5% intervals.
Figure 5: SSOC
Lanze Berry
9/4/2012
8
Figure 5 shows that the system is stable between 72.5% and 74%. The system output current
through the steady state operating range is 3.6-3.9 amps. The graph shows a linear line with a
constant slope having the equation Amps = 0.2input% - 10.9. This validates the linearity and
constant slope.
Lanze Berry
9/4/2012
9
Discussion
After obtaining the results, this experiment indicates that at a constant steady state is
obtained in the current system with varying input percentages. The steady state operating curves
are linear within the 72.5% - 74% range. This is the primary point of interest of this experiment.
The maximum standard deviation within the steady state operating curve was 0.06 amps. This
shows that the data and the mean of the data had a very close relationship and validates that the
output reached a constant or steady state.
The steady state operating curve provides confidence to the numbers that were obtained
in the experiment. It is proven that the motor in the system can be forced to operate within a
desired region of performance. The motor is able to generate the desired current. Since the
motor level determines the output amps, it was necessary that the motor could produce 3 to 4
amps and make it steady state. The motor was able to do this for all the tested percentages
between 72.5% and 74%. When working with a system, it is important that the system can
operate within a steady state region.
Lanze Berry
9/4/2012
10
Conclusions and Recommendations
Initially, this experiment was to determine the output in volts using a power input
percentage. After some complications, the experiment changed to measuring current. After this
change was made, data was collected on a system by a power input percentage that gave an
output in amps. The results that were obtained in the experiment clearly showed what was
necessary for a steady state operational curve for the system. The experiment validated that a
current system with a constant input has an operating range where steady state can be attained.
The main objective of the lab was to determine a steady state operating curve for a
current system with an input power percentage and an output in amps. To do this, a computer
was used to generate the motor and produce a current. The results obtained clearly present the
necessity for a system to operate within the steady state region of the curve.
Lanze Berry
9/4/2012
11
Appendix
Figure 6: Amps vs. Time for 73% Input Power
Figure 7: Amps vs. Time for 73.5% Input Power
Lanze Berry
9/4/2012
12
Figure 8: Amps vs. Time at 74% Input Power
References:
1) http://chem.engr.utc.edu/329/
2) Carlos A. Smith and Armanso Corripio, Principles and Practice of Automatic
Process Control., John Wiley & Sons Inc., 3rd
Edition, 2006 (Appendix A)