34
STEEM DIGITAL ASSET REPORT: STEEM Review And Investment Grade Crypto Briefing Research Department April 5, 2019
STEEM DIGITAL ASSET REPORT:STEEM Review And Investment Grade
Crypto Briefing Research Department
April 5, 2019
© 2019 SIMETRI and Decentral Media Inc. – simetri.cryptobriefing.com 2
Fundamental Factors ............................................................................. 3
Grade ................................................................................................... 4
Introduction ........................................................................................... 5
Market Opportunity ................................................................................ 6
Underlying Technology ......................................................................... 11
Ecosystem Development ..................................................................... 15
Token Economics ................................................................................ 22
Core Team .......................................................................................... 25
Roadmap Progress .............................................................................. 27
Token Performance .............................................................................. 28
Conclusion .......................................................................................... 32
Disclaimer ........................................................................................... 33
Contents
© 2019 SIMETRI and Decentral Media Inc. – simetri.cryptobriefing.com 3
Fundamental Factors
Market Opportunity
Core Team
Ecosystem Development
Token Performance
Underlying Technology
Roadmap Progress
Token Economics
6.5
6.0
7.0
5.0
7.0
6.6
6.0
Combined Score: 6.3
© 2019 SIMETRI and Decentral Media Inc. – simetri.cryptobriefing.com 4
GradeUsability issues present substantial issue for token; significant uncertainty,
but project still demonstrates moderate progress on development or
ecosystem fronts, having passed important milestones, albeit with delays.
Adverse conditions in the market pose major risk to value of token.
Methodology
For a full description of our methodology, please click on:https://simetri.cryptobriefing.com/methodology/
C
© 2019 SIMETRI and Decentral Media Inc. – simetri.cryptobriefing.com 5
Steem is a blockchain that targets the social media sector and enables users to monetize their content. The blockchain is best known for the flagship application Steemit.com, a blogging website that surpassed 1M users in May of 2018. Since then, its popularity has been declining due to the abuse of its reward distribution system and the overall market downtrend.
The entity behind Steam, Steemit Inc. has also been facing funding problems and had to lay off almost 70% of its employees, due to the steep drop in cryptocurrency prices.
However, the technology behind the project is still generating interest amongst developers. Besides Steemit, the project hosts over 100 applications on its blockchain and plans the release of the Smart Media Tokens (SMT) platform, which will enable publishers to launch tokens on the Steem blockchain and monetize their content.
Nevertheless, at present, the future success of the project is questionable as it faces many problems and stiff market competition, which are threatening its long-term development.
Introduction
1M USERS
© 2019 SIMETRI and Decentral Media Inc. – simetri.cryptobriefing.com 6
Steem is a social blockchain where developers can create various dApps as alternatives to existing social networks. The project targets the social media market, which is dominated by giants like Facebook, YouTube, Instagram, etc. The size of the social media market is expected to grow to $39 billion by the end of 2019.
In 2019, it is also estimated that there will be around 2.77 billion social media users around the globe, up from 2.46 billion in 2017, the number of users is forecasted to grow at around 3% annually.
Market Opportunity
Most popular social networks worldwide as of January 2019, ranked by number of active users (in millions)
YouTube
Facebook Messenger
QZone
Douyin/Tik Tok
Sina Weibo
2 271
1 900
1 500
1 300
1 083
1 000
803
531
500
446
330
© 2019 SIMETRI and Decentral Media Inc. – simetri.cryptobriefing.com 7
Steem has already developed various social networking apps on its platform, like Steemit (analog of Medium and Reddit), Steepshot (analog of Instagram), and DTube (analog of YouTube). While Steem as a layer 1 blockchain faces competition mainly from other blockchain networks, its most popular dApps are competing with products that are currently dominating the social media market.
The major competitors to Steem in the blockchain industry are Ethereum, Tron, and EOS, which remain the most popular choices for dApp developers.
Compared to Ethereuem, Steem provides higher scalability and free transactions, which makes it a better fit for content-driven dApps.
Consider Sapien Network, a social media platform built on Ethereum that is analogous to Steemit. The latter has more advanced technology and a client base of over 1 million users. Sapien only has about 5,656 users and is limited by Ethereum throughput capabilities.
The narrative is consistent for other Ethereum based social media projects.
However, the two other major rivals, EOS and Tron, have much more active ecosystems. These blockchains are similar to Steem from a technology perspective, but have more dApps, more transactions per day, and wider communities. Currently Steem dApps are more popular than the EOS (ONO) and Tron (TronChat) alternatives, but due to the rapidly expanding user bases of the respective networks, they will become more prevalent in the marketspace.
Our conversations with projects building dApps on the Steem blockchain revealed that startups are attracted to the platform because it has a lower entry barrier for developers than many of its competitors.
Web developers who are comfortable with Javascript and Python can make an easy transition to working on Steem dApps.
© 2019 SIMETRI and Decentral Media Inc. – simetri.cryptobriefing.com 8
Competition in the Blockchain Space
$85.9M
Market CapKey FeaturesLaunch DateTickerProject Name
$0.2M
$14.6B
$1.6B
$3.1B- Delegated Proof of Stake consensus - Block time - 0.5 sec - 3,996 tps, no fees
- Delegated Proof of Stake consensus - Block time - 3 sec - 2,000 tps, no fees
- Proof of Work consensus- Block time - 14 sec, 25 tps- Turing Complete smart contracts- Biggest dApps ecosystem
- Proof of Work consensus - Block time - 14 sec, 25 tps- Turing Complete smart contracts - Biggest dApp ecosystem
- Delegated Proof of Stake consensus- Block time – 3 sec- 10,000 tps, no fees- Steemit, social media and blogging platform, Smart Media Tokens
Started in 2016STEEMSteem
SPNSapien Network
ETHEthereum
TRXTron
EOSEOS
Started in 2018
Started in 2014. Frontier Launched in 2015
Started in 2017
Started in 2017Block producers elected in 2018
© 2019 SIMETRI and Decentral Media Inc. – simetri.cryptobriefing.com 9
The competitiveness of Steem dApps relative to their centralized alternatives is very low. The main features that differentiate Steem’s applications from its traditional analogs are content being saved on the blockchain and crypto rewards for content creation. However, the rewards content creators can currently obtain on Steem’s social application cannot compare to the advertising revenue available to them on YouTube, Instagram or others.
The situation has been different with Steemit.com, where popular authors could expect to get paid, as opposed to receiving nothing posting on Medium or Reddit. However, the fall of cryptocurrency prices and flaws in Steemit reward distribution led to authors starting to leave the platform, decreasing the overall quality of the content.
For the most part, Steem’s most popular applications are trying to disrupt markets that are already established and monopolized by a few players. At the same time, these applications are not offering anything new, besides the rewards, which are not enough to attract a large user base. If we compare the activity of these social applications with the activity of well-known social networks, Steem is far behind. Due to the competitors’ network effects, it is highly unlikely that current Steem dApps will ever receive the same recognition.
From the market opportunity perspective, at its current state Steem will not be able to sustain competition from the already established social networks and will most likely continue to lose positions to its blockchain rivals.
STEEM WILL NOT BE ABLE TO SUSTAIN NETWORK COMPETITION AND WILL MOST LIKELY CONTINUE TO LOSE POSITIONS TO ITS BLOCKCHAIN RIVALS
© 2019 SIMETRI and Decentral Media Inc. – simetri.cryptobriefing.com 10
Steemit vs Medium and Reddit
Steepshot vs Instagram
DTube vs YouTube
-
-
330M
58M
2.8M
196M~1MNumber of users
Number of users
Monthly views
70KVotes per day
Photos uploaded per day
Average visit duration
25KComments per day
~2K
Indicator
Indicator
Indicator
Steepshot
DTube
YouTube
Steemit Medium Reddit
~4K
1M
55B4.4M
~ 5 minutes 40 minutes
95M
© 2019 SIMETRI and Decentral Media Inc. – simetri.cryptobriefing.com 11
Steem is a scalable blockchain protocol with a fast and feeless digital token (STEEM). Its creators wanted to make a blockchain that would be suitable for micro-payments and would allow such use cases as tipping an author. The blockchain adopted a DPoS consensus algorithm according to which 21 witnesses (nodes) are selected to create blocks every 3 seconds. The block production is done in rounds, and each round lasts 63 seconds (or 21 blocks).
In total, there are over 100 nodes, but only the top-21 participate in the consensus, 20 out of 21 witnesses (full-time witnesses) are selected by approval voting and 1 witness (backup witness) rotates through a list of witnesses outside of the top 20.
Witnesses participate in block creation and approve hard forks.
Steem hard forks take effect if at least 67% of the active witnesses have upgraded to the latest update. This procedure ensures that there is a single persistent chain after a fork. It also makes the update mechanism convenient for developers. As a result, the Steem blockchain has already successfully forked 20 times.
Although Steem has developed a good mechanism to decentralize the network with its witnesses, centralization still appears when it comes to core developers team.
In 2018, the whole blockchain simply stopped, and only the developers could roll down a patch for witnesses to fix the issue. The main team has all the power to implement the necessary fixes, but it also represents a central point of failure.
Underlying Technology
THE STEEM BLOCKCHAIN HAS ALREADY SUCCESSFULLY FORKED 20 TIMES
© 2019 SIMETRI and Decentral Media Inc. – simetri.cryptobriefing.com 12
The team behind Steem tried to develop technical features that would enhance the user experience:
Native Name System – user name is used as the wallet address. This is much more convenient than using long public keys.
Hierarchical Private Key Structure – there are three private keys: Posting, Active and Owner. The first allows the user to post, comment, edit, vote, and follow other accounts. The second one is used to transfer funds, power up/down transactions, vote for witnesses, reset the posting key, place market orders on the internal decentralized exchange. The owner key is the most powerful, because it can change the other private keys and prove ownership during an account recovery. This hierarchical private keys structure increases the security of using wallets.
Stolen Account Recovery – if a user’s account is compromised, it is possible to change private keys using the Owner key.
Steem is also planning an important release of Smart Media Tokens technology. SMT – is a token issuance protocol (like ERC-20) which enables any website, company or content library across the Internet to facilitate fundraising and integrate tokens into its interface (more detailed information is available here). The launch of this protocol was planned for March but has been postponed. Nevertheless, if fully implemented it will positively affect the adoption of Steem blockchain.
The Steem blockchain can handle a large number of transactions per second almost instantly, which puts it among the most technologically advanced blockchains.
STEEM CAN HANDLE A LARGE NUMBER OF TRANSACTIONS PER SECOND,WHICH PUTS IT AMONG THE MOST TECHNOLOGICALLY ADVANCED BLOCKCHAINS
© 2019 SIMETRI and Decentral Media Inc. – simetri.cryptobriefing.com 13
The activity of the main repository in its GitHub has dropped significantly in the last two months, while other repositories are in an active state. Developers are currently focused on optimizing the blockchain (DevOps solutions, reduction of Staging and Testing nodes, pruning, etc.). This will decrease the costs of running full Steem nodes which should lower the adoption barrier for application developers and exchanges.
Developers are also working on improving Consender, the open
source software that powers steemit.com, which should reduce its maintaining costs.
From the technological point, the Steem blockchain solves the problems it was meant to solve. Although the network is dependent on the developer team and even experienced a shutdown, it still has good throughput capabilities, which attracts dApps creators and drives adoption.
Scalability Comparison
Steem
Sapien Network
Ethereum
Tron
EOS
STEEM
SPN
ETH
TRX
EOS
DPoS
PoW
PoW
DPoS
DPoS
~10,000
25
25
2,000
3,996
3 sec
6 min
6 min
3 sec
5 sec
Project Name Ticker Consensus Protocol TPS Indicator
© 2019 SIMETRI and Decentral Media Inc. – simetri.cryptobriefing.com 14
GitHub activity | Source: cryptomiso.com
© 2019 SIMETRI and Decentral Media Inc. – simetri.cryptobriefing.com 15
Steem is a social media blockchain that utilizes the DPoS consensus algorithm. Its network is supported by two types of nodes (witnesses):
- Top-20 witnesses – store the whole blockchain, create blocks and confirm transactions.
- 21st witness rotates through a list of witnesses outside of the top 20, and can also participate in the consensus, if chosen in a certain round. The higher the rank of the witness, the higher the probability of it being part of the consensus.
- All other witnesses – store the whole blockchain and maintain its functionality.
However, the potential witness candidates need to own powerful and reliable servers, have technical experience, and convince the community that they can become good node operators. In fact, for witnesses, marketing plays an important role, since they have to promote themselves in order to get votes from the community. Witnesses use different marketing strategies, some even offer to spend 80% of the block reward to advertise Steem on Facebook, YouTube, and Google every day.
Any user can vote for up to 30 witnesses at any time. These votes can be added or canceled at any time. The ranking for witnesses plays an important role. A witness at rank 25 will be producing more blocks per hour than a witness at rank 50, which will directly affect its profitability. Witnesses are paid proportionally to how high they are in the rank. Current, top-20 witness pay is about $3,800 per month (approximately) based on the current feed price. Such a structure incentivizes a free market competition among node operators, which in general is beneficial for the network.
The Steem network is highly centralized. The project has had a questionable launch in 2016 with the network being allegedly rigged to ensure that founders had a major stake in token supply.
This led to a situation where most of the coins were accumulated in the hands of a small number of people, which is not reflected on the STEEM rich list. According to steemdb.com, the top-10 wallets hold 25.7% of coins (exchange wallets – 22.7%), and the top-100 wallets – 29.2%, which shows a relatively low level of centralization.
Ecosystem Development
OF THE BLOCK REWARD TO ADVERTISE STEEM
© 2019 SIMETRI and Decentral Media Inc. – simetri.cryptobriefing.com 16
Oh wow, another vote for the staker thing dominated by insiders who started with an inside advantage and, worse than that, cheated their way there.
I’ve put the whole picture together now and it doesn’t paint a pretty picture. You have done far worse than free trade ever did. Let me explain it to our audience.
Dear reader: please continue to the end, it gets worse with every sentence.
Let me start from the beginning: Dev, first you have the shittiest shitcoin launch in history, having all your miners fired up from the beginning.
Not only do you not have a pool or windows wallets, but you don’t even have build instructions. You even have to be an advanced git user to insert the external repositories in the right place to build. You need a special boost that isn’t included in the most common and supported linux distros, like Ubuntu 14.04. In short, you gave yourself a huge advantage.
Then you started cheating. The first cheat were your incorrect example mining commands that left out key characters, like single quoting the double quoted witness name. It’s a detail, but very hard to figure out why the parser is failing. Then you have a shitty nonce selection where if the same key is mining from two different machines it will produce double work and get booted. You knew of this but no miner did. That doesn’t make you smart, it makes you a cheater because you were raping the coin the whole time.
To prove that you were raping it to the exclusion of everyone else, anyone can go read the original thread where you acknowledge that when your miners went down, no one else was mining. You made it impossible to mine for anyone else who didn’t have insider’s knowledge of the coin.
That doesn’t make you smarter than your average coward, because anyone can set a booby trap. It makes you someone who is too dumb to figure out how to win by being smart.
Now here’s where it gets bad. For the second night in a row your miners crashed. I actually anticipated that because dumbfucks usually make the same mistake more than once. So I had 40 cores going when you went to bed. I brought in nearly every block that night and when you woke up you saw what happened and decided to do a relaunch.
You failed at cheating and the only way to win at it was to cheat some more with a relaunch. Of course I lost all my coins, but you had to do it to guarantee yourself an insurmountable insider advantage when it came to voting yourself a staker.
But only after mining with about $200 day for 3 days do you spring this thing about insider’s selecting the stakers. Maybe, being a complete idiot, you think that we should read the code and put $200.00 a day on this coin like you. But no one has time to read the code of every shitcoin that comes along. No one can do it. Again, you aren’t smart for having insider knowledge and taking advantage of it. You are basically an idiot who has to cheat because you can’t cheat so well.
And, dear reader, this is the story of the beginning of this coin. You have a dev who has cheated at every step, cheats when they fuck up cheating, then cheats some more.
Bitcointalk thread on Steem launch (2016)
© 2019 SIMETRI and Decentral Media Inc. – simetri.cryptobriefing.com 17
TOP-10 Wallet Distribution
However, the STEEM rich list is not showcasing the real situation. The Steem blockchain has complicated token economics. It operates on three tokens: STEEM, STEEM Power (SP), and STEEM Dollar. Users can voluntarily obtain STEEM Power, by locking-up
STEEM tokens in the system. The more STEEM Power a user has, the more influence they have in the system, which is expressed when voting for witnesses or for content that is posted on the blockchain.
bitterx
binance8
poloniex
steemit
huobi-withdrawal
binance-hot
steemit2
ned
hendrikdegrote
bithumb.live
-
-
Exchange
Exchange
Exchange
Exchange
Exchange
Exchange
-
-
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Top-10
Top-100
41 094 619 STEEM
13 194 408 STEEM
9 959 831 STEEM
4 806 645 STEEM
3 778 432 STEEM
2 993 478 STEEM
1 617 561 STEEM
1 326 453 STEEM
1 100 459 STEEM
753 159 STEEM
80 625 044 STEEM
91 422 074 STEEM
13.11%
4.21%
3.18%
1.53%
1.21%
0.95%
0.52%
0.42%
0.35%
0.24%
25.72%
29.16%
Generator№ Info Balance Network Share
© 2019 SIMETRI and Decentral Media Inc. – simetri.cryptobriefing.com 18
Currently, around 40% of STEEM Power is concentrated in 100 accounts. It’s also possible that many of them are duplicates, making the system highly dependent on a small number of people. Such a concentration of SP has produced a lot of problems for Steem’s main application Steemit, a blogging platform where users get paid for creating and curating content. The payment is received from newly issued tokens, and 75% of the new tokens are distributed among content creators and curators. The content rating is based on the upvotes received from holders of STEEM Power. The more upvotes from large STEEM Power holders an article receives, the more money is distributed to its author.
As a result, STEEM Power holders are not incentivized to be interested in the quality of the content, they are participating in the ecosystem simply to receive the reward, killing the whole point behind the platform.
Centralization of STEEM Power is also supported by bots. Any user can simply pay directly to the bot owner and receive an upvote for his article. The upvote from the bot is usually worth less than the reward
the user would receive from Steem. It appears that the platform has been overrun with people who are there to make money and don’t care about the quality of the content.
Looking at Steemit.com’s trending page, readers can find either sponsored or low quality articles. Moreover, the platform has been criticized for having a poor user experience, plagiarized content and censorship. In fact, the content that users are posting is saved on the Steem blockchain, but it is not necessarily posted on Steemit.com, the website has its Terms of Service for what is acceptable and what is not. It is understandable, that in order to comply with regulations, Steemit has to have an editorial policy. Nevertheless, it contradicts the non-censorable notion of the blockchain.
The overall Steemit statistics shows that the number of authors and posts has decreased dramatically since January 2018. Although Steemit was able to build a large community around itself, its long-term prospects are highly questionable due to loss of interest from users.
CENTRALIZATION OF STEEM POWER IS ALSO SUPPORTED BY BOTS
© 2019 SIMETRI and Decentral Media Inc. – simetri.cryptobriefing.com 19
The entity that supports Steem ecosystem development is Steemit Inc. It is a privately held company based in New York that officially launched Steem and Steemit in 2016. However, the company has been under serious pressure because of the fall in cryptocurrency
prices and in Q4 2018 announced that it has been forced to lay off close to 70% of the team. This is concerning since without financial and human resources the company will not be able to solve its current problems and expand its user base and ecosystem.
Steemit.com Posts vs. Authors | Source tool.steem.world/Post/Stat
© 2019 SIMETRI and Decentral Media Inc. – simetri.cryptobriefing.com 20
The team has not been active in terms of partnership development. In 2017, Steem Inc. announced a partnership with the Global Blockchain Technologies Corp, according to which both companies signed a non-binding agreement to create a joint venture and establish $20 mln Steem Fund that would support startups building solutions on the Steem blockchain. However, after the announcement, there was no more information on the progress of this initiative, and during our conversation with the team, it was confirmed that the team decided not to move forward with it.
In general, Steem lacks good partnerships, which means it is not prioritizing business development, which is a negative sign for the ecosystem.Although most of the factors above negatively affected ecosystem development in 2018, there are also some positive developments expected in 2019.
The company is planning the release of the Smart Media Tokens
(SMT) platform, which will allow companies to create their own tokens. Tokens can be used to raise funds via an ‘Initial Coin Offering’ (ICO) or can be distributed via posting and upvoting rewards. SMT will allow publishers to issue their own tokens and integrate Steemit.com functionality on their websites. This will increase the demand for STEEM since users will have to acquire it to use the blockchain. However, it is still unknown whether the tool will be popular among companies, and how these tokens will be valued by different readers. More over, the project has been announced in 2017 and is still under development. The team planned the release of the mainnet in March 2019, but it has been delayed, since the team is working on cutting down the cost of running the chain.
From the community perspective, compared to its blockchain rivals, Steem is far behind in terms of social media followers. However, the number of on-chain operations (to not be confused with on-chain transactions) is quite high, indicating that the established community is very active and is using the ecosystem.
THE SMART MEDIA TOKENS (SMT) PLATFORM WILL ALLOW COMPANIES TO CREATE THEIR OWN TOKENS
© 2019 SIMETRI and Decentral Media Inc. – simetri.cryptobriefing.com 21
From the ecosystem perspective, Steem developed products that are used by a large community. Still, these products are facing serious problems and losing their user-base. Moreover, further
developments of the platform would most likely continue to be slow since the team is currently more focused on cutting costs, rather than expanding the ecosystem.
Community Involvement Comparison
© 2019 SIMETRI and Decentral Media Inc. – simetri.cryptobriefing.com 22
Steem blockchain utilizes a triple token economy model and has no fees to support its ecosystem.
STEEM is a liquid unit of account on the Steem blockchain, which can be bought or sold on exchanges and transferred to other users.
STEEM Power indicates how much influence a user holds on the system. To power up STEEM Power, users can convert their STEEM to STEEM Power by pressing a few buttons in the wallet. However, in order to convert STEEM power back to STEEM users would have to wait 13 weeks to receive the full amount, since the tokens will be unlocked at a rate of 1/13th per week. STEEM Power tokens are not tradable, they are only used within the blockchain (upvoting the content, voting for witnesses, etc).
STEEM Dollar is used to encourage and reward social application users. When a post receives a payout, the user obtains a reward in the form of 50% STEEM Dollars and 50% STEEM Power. Steem
Dollar is a stable-coin-like currency pegged to the dollar, with the price maintained around $1.00. The coin can be redeemed at any time for STEEM, but the processing time takes around 3 days. Steem Dollar is also freely traded on several exchanges, which creates problems with maintaining the exchange rate.
Although currently its rate is around $1, its price has been fluctuating from $0.8 in August 2017 to $12 in December 2017. Witnesses maintain the price stability. If the price of SBD is less than $1, traders will have an incentive to buy it and redeem it for STEEM worth $1, which will drive SBD price up. However, if the price of SBD goes above $1, the process becomes harder since the only way to increase the supply is through posting.
Witnesses can also alter the interest rate of STEEM Dollar, making it equal to 0% with the SBD price being higher than $1. Presumably this should decrease the incentive to hold SBD.
Token Economics
STEEM BLOCKCHAIN UTILIZES A TRIPLE TOKEN ECONOMY MODEL AND HAS NO FEES TO SUPPORT ITS ECOSYSTEM
© 2019 SIMETRI and Decentral Media Inc. – simetri.cryptobriefing.com 23
Newly issued tokens are spread amongst content creators, curators, users, and node holders. The blockchain is only issuing new STEEM Power or SBD (no STEEM):
• 75% of new tokens are distributed among content creators and curators (50% SBD and 50% STEEM Power);
• 15% of new tokens are distributed among the STEEM Power holders;
• 10% of new tokens are distributed to witnesses;
Token inflation is the driver of this distribution. When Steem launched, initial inflation was 100% a year, and 90% of generated tokens went to existing STEEM Power owners, creating a large voting power inequality, with a small number of accounts holding the majority of the voting power, thus centralizing the network.
The current inflation rate is around 8.54%, which will constantly decrease until the annual inflation rate reaches 0.5% (~ mid-2037). The overall inflation rate is higher if we compare Steem to its competitors. However, low inflation with the current STEEM prices would hurt the Steem ecosystem even more, since the authors’ rewards would be lower.
As an example of how Steem works, consider Steemit.com. There are many articles on Steemit uploaded by different authors, and users have the ability to upvote them. However, not all upvotes are equal. The more STEEM Power a user has, the more their upvote is worth. Currently, according to the upvote calculator, an account with 1,000,000 STEEM Power can produce an upvote that would grant the author up to $30, while an account with 50,000 STEEM Power can produce an upvote worth only up to $1.54.
THE MORE STEEM POWER A USER HAS, THE MORE THEIR UPVOTE IS WORTH
© 2019 SIMETRI and Decentral Media Inc. – simetri.cryptobriefing.com 24
Users are free to make multiple upvotes. But after each upvote the user loses 2% of the current voting power (STEEM Power). The voting power recovers at a constant rate that equals to 20% per day.
The problem such setup generates is that it encourages unethical behavior from users. Large STEEM Power owners have the incentive to upvote their own articles or sell the upvotes and receive rewards.
The fact that STEEM Power can be delegated also produced automated services that offer users to invest their STEEM Power,
concentrating it in the hands of a small number of people. This resulted in the community being more incentivized to make money rather than work on the quality of the content.
Although in the beginning Steem was thought to be a platform that would be community driven and would encourage authors to publish quality content, the flaws in its token economy encouraged user behavior that was detrimental to the quality of content and led to an alternative development course.
Supply Comparison
99B
Infinite
Infinite
Infinite
67BTRXTron
1BEOSEOS
105METHEthereum
327M 8.54%
~4.84%
~0.5%
5%
- payment.- tokens.- dApps.
- payment.- tokens.- dApps.
- payment.- tokens.- dApps.
- payment.- tokens.- dApps.
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
STEEMSteem
Project Name Ticker UIA Key Uses Current Supply Total SupplyInflation, % annual rate
© 2019 SIMETRI and Decentral Media Inc. – simetri.cryptobriefing.com 25
Core Team
Ned Scott
Ned Scott - Founder and Executive Chairman. He is also the ICO Advisor at Matchpool. Before launching the Steem blockchain, Ned Scott worked as a Financial Analyst at Gellert Global Group.
David Jefferys
David Jefferys - Business Development at Steemit Inc. He graduated from Canisius College with a BS in Accounting. He has 10+ years of experience in business development and worked for New Era Cap, ShoptoCook Inc., Pyramid Brokerage Company.
Elizabeth Powell
Elizabeth Powell - Managing Director. She graduated from Texas A&M University with a BA in Journalism. Elizabeth has wide experience in marketing, business development and communications.
© 2019 SIMETRI and Decentral Media Inc. – simetri.cryptobriefing.com 26
Steemit Inc. was founded in 2016 by Dan Larimer and Ned Scott. However, Dan left the project in 2017 and started the well-known EOS. There were no corporate conflicts, but Dan wanted to create “something bigger” than Steem.
Following the departure, Steem peaked in January 2018 and begun slipping down during the entirety of the year. Steemit Inc. reported that it laid off 70% of its employees. According to our sources, the team was reduced from around 50 people to 10. The decision was caused by a 96% decrease of the STEEM price, which led to a significant loss of the company’s finances.
The announcement of the staff layoff at the end of 2018 left community dissatisfied with the way the project was running. Two major problems identified with Steem Inc were “planning and the other is the delivery”. There were calls for the CEO to step down. To assuage concerns, Elizabeth Powell was appointed as a Managing Director at the start of 2019, to help move the project forward.
As a result, the project found a new direction (cost reduction, advertisements, etc.), which was positively perceived by the community. Our conversations confirmed excitement within the community regarding the progress the project has made over the last few months.
Nevertheless, despite having a good idea, the project was unable to get mainstream success which it was aiming for. An unclear strategy and poor decision making during the downtrend of the cryptocurrency market forced the company to rethink its priorities and outline a new direction for the project.
Although the team is taking steps to get out of the crisis, the success of their new strategy is not guaranteed, given the fact that the old strategy proved to be unsuccessful.
STEEMIT INC. REPORTED THAT IT LAID OFF 70% OF ITS EMPLOYEES
© 2019 SIMETRI and Decentral Media Inc. – simetri.cryptobriefing.com 27
Facing many issues in 2018, the company proposed a new strategy that it would implement in 2019.
Steemit.com – the company is working on improving Consender, open source software that powers steemit.com. The company bears a large cost maintaining it, and while it was justifiable during the bull market, currently it is not.
Lowering Node Costs – the company aims to lower the cost of operating the nodes, so it would be less expensive for the 3rd parties to run their own full nodes. This should also increase profits for witnesses.
Advertisements – the company plans to integrate advertisement into steemit.com in order to generate revenue to pay for front end back-end infrastructure necessary to power steemit.com and the overall project.
Real Solutions – the project wants to improve its economic sustainability by developing a workable business model that generates revenue needed to support the growing ecosystem.
The company will also focus on implementing Version 1 of Smart Media Tokens (SMT) platform and RockDB, the solution that would help to store Steem data more efficiently.
The company has developed an anti-crisis plan. However, as every plan of such nature, it focuses more on saving what project already has, rather than new developments and ecosystem expansion. The project also did not provide any clear dates for the much anticipated SMT platform, so it is not clear when Version 1 will be released.
Overall, the project is working on solving short-term problems, while its long-term mission still remains quite vague, which raises questions about its long-term sustainability.
Roadmap Progress
STEEM’S LONG-TERM MISSION STILL REMAINS QUITE VAGUE, WHICH RAISES QUESTIONS ABOUT ITS LONG-TERM SUSTAINABILITY
© 2019 SIMETRI and Decentral Media Inc. – simetri.cryptobriefing.com 28
STEEM is in the top-45 coins by market capitalization and it is in the top-59 coins by trading volume (24H).
STEEM price increased significantly a few months after the Steem blockchain launch, pushing it into the third place by market
capitalization after Bitcoin and Ethereum. Steem’s ATH occurred in January 2018 reaching $8.57 during the last peak of the cryptocurrency market. Since then the price has suffered a significant drop of 96%, while prices of its competitors have diminished a little less: Ethereum – 91%, Tron – 93%, EOS – 85%.
Token Performance
Price Comparison
© 2019 SIMETRI and Decentral Media Inc. – simetri.cryptobriefing.com 29
The main trading pairs are STEEM/BTC (48%) and STEEM/KRW (40%), which are mostly traded on top exchanges such as Binance, Bithumb, and Upbit. The coin is quite liquid.
STEEM trading volume is significantly lower than that of its competitors. Also, changes in trading volume among all cryptocurrencies have the same downward trend since January 2018.
STEEM price fluctuations lie within a range from -5% to + 8% on average. The same behavior is observed among its competitors. Essentially, STEEM is following the market.
Given the fact that Steem was a number 3 project in 2016 on Coinmarketcap.com, its current 45th place is discouraging. Users and cryptocurrency speculators are losing interest in the project, which is reflected on its price and overall ranking.
STEEM Volume | Source: cryptocurrencychart.com
STEEM Volume by Currency
STEEM - BTC Volume by Exchange
STEEM - KRW Volume by Exchange
Upbit
Bithumb
KRW
BTC
USDT
ETH Binance
Upbit
BitTrex
HitBTC
HuobiProPoloniex
© 2019 SIMETRI and Decentral Media Inc. – simetri.cryptobriefing.com 30
Trading Volume Comparison
© 2019 SIMETRI and Decentral Media Inc. – simetri.cryptobriefing.com 31
Daily Change
© 2019 SIMETRI and Decentral Media Inc. – simetri.cryptobriefing.com 32
DUE TO THE RISKS, STEEM IS GRADED WITH C
Initially Steem as a blockchain was built with a clear use case and by introducing Steemit, achieved good results. The platform attracted authors that could start receiving cryptocurrency for their works, generating good profits for some during the bull run. The platform was also successful in attracting outside developers to build on Steem.
However, after the market turned red, some of the issues that were neglected when the cryptocurrency prices were high started to hinder the project’s development. STEEM Power centralization led to a decrease in the quality of the content, and authors started to leave
Steemit. In addition, the company that supports the development behind the project has faced financial problems and had to lay off nearly 70% of its staff, shifting the team’s focus to cost reduction.
The current prospects of Steem are questionable. Therefore, due to the above risks, it is graded with C.
The author(s) of this report is/are invested in the following coins: Bitcoin.
Conclusion
© 2019 SIMETRI and Decentral Media Inc. – simetri.cryptobriefing.com 33
SIMETRI Research is an Internet based newsletter and publication on the Crypto Briefing site (the “Site”) and is owned by Decentral Media Inc., a Delaware Corporation (the “Company”). Neither SIMETRI Research nor the Company is registered as an investment adviser with any federal or state regulatory agency, or with any other governmental body or organization. To the extent that any portion of the Site content would need to rely upon an exemption from such registration, the Company and/or SIMETRI Research would rely upon the “publisher’s exclusion” from the definition of “investment adviser” as provided under Section 202(a)(11) of the Investment Advisers Act of 1940 and corresponding state securities laws. To the extent reliance on the publisher’s exemption is necessary, the Site and/or SIMETRI Research is a bona fide publication of general and regular circulation offering impersonalized investment-related advice to users and/or prospective users (e.g., not tailored to the specific investment portfolio or needs of current and/or prospective users).
The Site is limited to the dissemination of impersonal and objective investment-related information [together with access to additional impersonal investment-related information and links.] The publication of the Site on the Internet and the publication of any content should not be construed by any user and/or prospective user as SIMETRI Research’s (i) solicitation to effect, or attempt to effect transactions in securities over the Internet, or (ii) provision of any investment related advice or services tailored to any particular individual’s financial situation or investment objective(s).
Users do not receive investment advisory, investment supervisory or investment management services, nor the initial or ongoing review or monitoring of the user’s individual investment portfolio or individual particular needs. Therefore, no user should assume that his/her/its use serves as a substitute for individual personalized advice from an investment professional of the user’s choosing. Rather, the Site is designed solely to provide users with a method to evaluate certain investment-related information and trading methodologies/systems.
The user maintains absolute discretion as to whether or not to follow any portion of the Site content. SIMETRI Research does not offer or provide investment implementation services, nor does it offer or provide initial or ongoing individual personalized advice (neither in person nor via the Internet). It remains the user’s exclusive responsibility to review and evaluate the content and to determine whether to accept or reject any Site content. SIMETRI Research expresses no opinion as to whether any of the Site content is appropriate for a particular user’s investment portfolio, strategy, financial situation, or investment objective(s).
It is the user’s exclusive responsibility to determine if any portion of the investment-related information and trading methodologies/systems on the Site, if any, is suitable or appropriate for his/her financial situation and/or investment objectives, both initially and on an ongoing basis. No current or prospective user should assume that the future performance of any specific investment, investment
Disclaimer
© 2019 SIMETRI and Decentral Media Inc. – simetri.cryptobriefing.com 34
strategy (including the investments or trading methodologies/systems discussed on the Site) or any other Site content will be suitable or profitable for a user’s portfolio, equal historical or anticipated performance level(s), or prove to be correct.
Different types of investments involve varying degrees of risk, and there can be no assurance that any specific investment will either be suitable or profitable for a user or prospective user’s investment portfolio. Investments in cryptocurrencies or digital assets such as tokens are particularly risky and speculative investments. Users do not receive investment advisory, investment supervisory or investment management services, nor the initial or ongoing review or monitoring of the user’s individual investment portfolio or individual particular needs. Therefore, no user should assume that his/her/its use serves as a substitute for individual personalized advice from an investment professional of the user’s choosing.
The information contained on this website and in SIMETRI Research may include, or incorporate by reference, forward-looking statements, which would include any statements that are not statements of historical fact. No representations or warranties are made as to the accuracy of such forward-looking statements.
Any projections, forecasts and estimates contained on this website, our reports, or newsletters are necessarily speculative in nature and are based upon certain assumptions. These forward-looking statements may turn out to be wrong and can be affected by inaccurate assumptions or by known or unknown risks, uncertainties and other factors, most of which are beyond our control. This may include misrepresentations by the project teams, faulty due diligence, or the vagaries and volatility of the nascent cryptocurrencies market and early use stages of blockchain technology. It can be expected that some or all of such forward-looking assumptions will not materialize or will vary significantly from actual results.
RELEASE: Each user or prospective user acknowledges and accepts the limitations of the Site and SIMETRI Research and agrees, as a condition precedent to his/her/its access to the Site, to release and hold harmless Decentral Media Inc., its members, officers, directors, owners, employees, advisors, affiliates, and agents from any and all claims and adverse consequences resulting from his/her/its use, including, but not limited to, losses resulting from the user’s implementation of any of investment-related information, recommendations and/or trading methodologies/systems.
