+ All Categories
Home > Documents > STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of...

STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of...

Date post: 07-Apr-2018
Category:
Upload: acelitigationwatch
View: 218 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
45
{N2248887.1}  -------------------------- CASE NO. 10-30886 -------------------------- IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE FIFTH CIRCUIT STEPHEN MARSHALL GABARICK, on behalf of himself and all others similarly situated; Et Al Plaintiffs v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA) INCORPORATED, Et Al Defendants ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- INDEMNITY INSURANCE COMPANY OF NORTH AMERICA, Plaintiff – Intervenor – Appellant HOUSTON CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY, Intervenor – Appellant v. AMERICAN COMMERCIAL LINES L.L.C.; AMERICAN COMMERCIAL LINES I NCORPORATED, Defendants – Appellees -------------------------------------------------------------- On Appeal from the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Louisiana -------------------------------------------------------------- Case: 10-30886 Document: 00511349640 Page: 1 Date Filed: 01/12/2011
Transcript
Page 1: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 1/45

Page 2: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 2/45

Page 3: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 3/45

Page 4: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 4/45

Page 5: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 5/45

Page 6: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 6/45

Page 7: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 7/45

Page 8: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 8/45

Page 9: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 9/45

Page 10: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 10/45

Page 11: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 11/45

Page 12: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 12/45

Page 13: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 13/45

Page 14: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 14/45

Page 15: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 15/45

Page 16: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 16/45

Page 17: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 17/45

Page 18: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 18/45

Page 19: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 19/45

Page 20: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 20/45

Page 21: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 21/45

Page 22: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 22/45

Page 23: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 23/45

Page 24: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 24/45

Page 25: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 25/45

Page 26: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 26/45

Page 27: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 27/45

Page 28: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 28/45

Page 29: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 29/45

Page 30: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 30/45

Page 31: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 31/45

Page 32: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 32/45

Page 33: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 33/45

Page 34: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 34/45

Page 35: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 35/45

Page 36: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 36/45

Page 37: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 37/45

Page 38: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 38/45

Page 39: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 39/45

Page 40: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 40/45

Page 41: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 41/45

Page 42: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 42/45

Page 43: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 43/45

Page 44: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 44/45

Page 45: STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

8/6/2019 STEPHEN GABARICK, et al v. LAURIN MARITIME (AMERICA), INC, et al Original Brief on Behalf of Appellees

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stephen-gabarick-et-al-v-laurin-maritime-america-inc-et-al-original-brief 45/45


Recommended