+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities · Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural...

Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities · Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural...

Date post: 11-Jun-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 0 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
31
1/18/18 1 Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities John Gale, MS, Senior Research Associate Rural Health Research Gateway Webinar January 18, 2018 Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center Acknowledgements Support for this work was provided by the Federal Office of Rural Health Policy within the Health Services and Resources Administration. Research Team: Strategies study: John Gale, Anush Hansen, Martha Elbaum Prevalence study: Jennifer Lenardson, John Gale, Erika Ziller
Transcript
Page 1: Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities · Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities JohnGale, MS, Senior Research Associate Rural Health Research Gateway

1/18/18

1

StrategiestoCombatOpioidUseinRuralCommunities

John Gale,MS,SeniorResearchAssociate

Rural Health Research Gateway WebinarJanuary18,2018

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

AcknowledgementsSupportforthisworkwasprovidedbytheFederalOfficeofRuralHealthPolicywithintheHealthServicesandResourcesAdministration.

ResearchTeam:

Strategiesstudy:JohnGale,AnushHansen,MarthaElbaum

Prevalencestudy:JenniferLenardson,JohnGale,ErikaZiller

Page 2: Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities · Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities JohnGale, MS, Senior Research Associate Rural Health Research Gateway

1/18/18

2

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

TopicstoBeCovered• Keytakeawaymessages• Opioiduseacrossruralsettings•Whatisdifferentaboutruralareas?• Driversofruralopioiduse• Burdenofopioiduseinruralcommunities• Evidence-basedprevention,treatment,andrecoverystrategiestoaddressruralopioiduse

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

KeyTakeAwayMessages• Ittakesavillage- Communityengagementandinvolvementarecentraltoaddressingopioiduse• Opioiduseiscommoninruralareasanddrivenbyacomplexmixofsocioeconomicissues• Ruralareasufferdisproportionatelyfromtheseissues• Travelbarriersandisolationexacerbatetheseproblems• Significantgapsexistinsubstanceuseprevention,treatment,andrecoveryinruralcommunities•Modelsmustbeadaptedtothegeographic,resource,andculturalrealitiesofruralareas

Page 3: Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities · Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities JohnGale, MS, Senior Research Associate Rural Health Research Gateway

1/18/18

3

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

OpioidUse– AComplexProblem• Thegood:‒ Aclassofprescriptionmedicationsprovidingsignificantbenefitstopatientswithacuteseverepain• Thebad:‒ Undueinfluenceofpharmaceuticalcompanies‒ Earlyfailuretoacknowledgetherisksofprescriptionopioids‒ Slowadoptionofevidence-basedprescribingguidelines‒ Growingpatientdemandforopioids• Complications:‒ Directlinkagebetweenprescriptionopioidandheroinuse‒ Multiple,interrelatedpathwaystoopioidaddiction

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

RuralOpioidIssues• Opioiduseistheprimarycauseofunintentionaldrugoverdosedeaths• Severalruralstatesareexperiencingthehighestratesofoverdosedeaths- WV,NM,NH,andKY•Misuseofpainrelieversishigheramongruralyouth,womenwhoarepregnantorexperiencingpartnerviolence,personswithco-occurringdisorders,andfelonyprobationers• Heroinusehasbeguntomigrateawayfromurbancommunitiesandnowmoretypicallyoccursinsmallurbanornon-urbanareas• Prescriptionopioidandheroinusearestronglylinked

Page 4: Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities · Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities JohnGale, MS, Senior Research Associate Rural Health Research Gateway

1/18/18

4

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

Page 5: Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities · Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities JohnGale, MS, Senior Research Associate Rural Health Research Gateway

1/18/18

5

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

FactorsAssociatedwithRuralOpioidUse• Controllingfor:residence,age,sex,race/ethnicity,health,education,maritalstatus,employment,healthinsurance&income,ruralpersons:‒ Were20%lesslikelytohavepastyearopioidusethanurban‒ Ages12-19were70%morelikelytouseopioidsthan30-49‒ Under30hadhigheroddsofopioidusethan30andover‒ Whoweremarriedhad40%reducedoddsofusecomparedtoruralpersonswhowerenotmarried

‒ Maleswere30%morelikelythanfemalestouseopioids‒ Inpoorhealth,withlimitededucation,andnohealthinsurancehadhigheroddsofopioiduse

‒ Whowereuninsuredhad58%higheroddsofopioidusecomparedtothosewithprivatecoverage.

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

SocioeconomicDriversofRuralOpioidUse

Page 6: Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities · Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities JohnGale, MS, Senior Research Associate Rural Health Research Gateway

1/18/18

6

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

RoleofRuralPlaceasaDriverofOpioidUse• Ruralplacessufferfromavarietyofhealthandsocio-economicdisparities‒ Greatersenseofstigma‒ Highersenseofisolationandhopelessness‒ Lowereducationrates‒ Higherratesofpoverty‒ Feweropportunitiesforemployment‒ Higherratesofchronicillnesses• Influenceofcultural,ethnic,religiousdifferences

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

RiskFactorsforOU• Familyhistoryofsubstanceabuse• Personalhistoryofsubstanceabuse• Youngage• Historyofcriminalactivityand/orlegalproblems• Regularcontactwithhigh-riskpeopleorenvironments•Mentaldisorders• Risktakingorthrillseekingbehavior.• Heavytobaccouse.• Historyofseveredepressionoranxiety.• Psychosocialstressors.• Priordrugand/oralcoholrehabilitation

Page 7: Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities · Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities JohnGale, MS, Senior Research Associate Rural Health Research Gateway

1/18/18

7

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

InteractionbetweenOpioidUseandRiskFactors• Opioiduseisdrivenbysocioeconomicfactors• Italsocontributestoaself-perpetuatingcyclethatisdifficulttobreak• Individualswithopioidusedisordershavelowerlevelsofacademicachievement,arrestrecords,greaterratesofpoverty,etc.• Intergenerationalsubstanceuse• Intergenerationaltrauma• Stigmaplaysacrucialrole

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

OtherRuralIssues• Longstandingissueinruralcommunities• Non-medicaluseofprescriptionopiatesinruralareas• Heroinasasubstituteforprescriptionopioidsbythosewithouthealthinsurance– Maine•Majorinitiatives– Vermont,Ohio,otherruralstates• Heroinischeap,accessible,andstronger• Limitedtreatment&lawenforcementresources• Substantialvariationsinopioidprescribingrates

Page 8: Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities · Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities JohnGale, MS, Senior Research Associate Rural Health Research Gateway

1/18/18

8

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

PolicyImplications• Despitesocialvulnerabilities,ruralopioidusershaveslightlylowerprevalenceratesthanurbanopioidusers‒ Socialties,support,andotherbuffersmayprotectruralresidentsfromevenhigherprevalencerates

• Preventioneffortshavenoteffectivelyreachedruralresidents– especiallyyoungpeopleandmen– whodonotperceiverisksfromheroinuse• Harmreductionandsyringeexchangeprogramsarealsoimportant,thoughfarlesscommon,inruralareas• Significanteffortstomanageopioidprescribingratesareneeded

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

APublicHealthModelforOU• Systematicdatacollectiononscope,characteristics,andconsequencesofsubstancemisuse• IdentifyriskandprotectivefactorsforOUandfactorsthatcouldbemodifiedthroughinterventions• Collaborativeeffortstoaddresssocial,environmental,oreconomicdriversofOU• Effectivepreventionandtreatmentinterventionsandrecoverysupportsinawiderangeofsettings•MonitortheimpactofinterventionsonOU,relatedproblems,andriskandprotectivefactors• CommunityleadershipthatmobilizescommunityorganizationsandresourcestoaddressOU

Page 9: Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities · Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities JohnGale, MS, Senior Research Associate Rural Health Research Gateway

1/18/18

9

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

CommunityStrategies• Keytoaddressingtheproblematthelocallevel• Importantcomponents‒ Broad-basedsupportandengagement‒ Stigmareduction‒ Prevention‒ Harmreduction– naloxoneandneedleexchanges‒ Engagedlawenforcementthatavoidscriminalizingusers‒ Engagedprovidersusingevidence-basedprescribingguidelinesandofferingmedicationassistedtherapy

‒ Accesstoevidence-basedtreatmentservices,integratedwithmainstreamhealthcare

‒ Peersupportandrecoveryservices

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

EngagingHospitalsandPrimaryCareProviders• Problemsarenotlimitedtoopioiduseonly,butincludemanyotherhealthandsafetyproblems• Hospitals,emergencydepartments,andprimarycarecontributetotheopioidproblemthroughprescribingpractices• Tax-exemptandpubliclyownedhospitalshaveanobligationtoaddressunmetcommunityneeds• Ruralhospitalsandprimarycareproviderscanplayaneffectiveroleinaddressingopioidusebyfillinggapsinspecialtycaresystem• Itprovidesanopportunityforcollaborativeactionbyhospitals,medical,andcommunitystakeholders

Page 10: Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities · Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities JohnGale, MS, Senior Research Associate Rural Health Research Gateway

1/18/18

10

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

BarrierstoTreatmentAccessinRuralAreas

CHAPTER 5. EVIDENCE-BASED DRUG TREATMENT STRATEGIES FOR RURAL SETTINGS 67

Rural substance use disorder treatment services are  less likely to provide more intensive, specialized services or services tailored to the needs of vul-nerable  populations, or those with unique cultural needs.185,186

The development and operation of rural substance use treatment programmes are hindered by numerous challenges including:

¹⁸⁵ Gamm, L.D. “Mental Health and Substance Abuse Services Among Rural Minorities”, The Journal of Rural Health. 2004; 20:206-210.¹⁸⁶ Sung, H.E., Mahoney, A.M. and Mellow, J. “Substance abuse treatment gap among adult parolees: prevalence, correlates, and barriers”,

Criminal Justice Review. 2011; 36:40-57.

• Difficulty recruiting appropriately trained and credentialed clinical staff

• Population densities that are insufficient to support viable services

• Limited access to referral and specialty services • Poor economic conditions, lower rates of health

insurance coverage and financing, and higher rates of poverty that further hamper the ability to develop a self-sustaining practice

FIGURE 5.1 ELEMENTS CONTRIBUTING TO A LOWER LEVEL OF ACCESS TO SUBSTANCE USE TREATMENT SERVICES FOR THE RURAL POPULATIONa, b

FEWER FACILITES

GEOGRAPHIC BARRIERS

LESS ANONYMITY

FEWER TREATMENT

PROFESSIONALS

LIMITED PUBLIC

TRANSPORTATION

LOWER TREATMENT ACCESS IN

RURAL AREAS

STIGMATIZATION AND

CRIMINALIZATION

aOser, C., Leukefeld, C., Tindal,l. M., Garrity, T., Carlson, R., Falck, R., Wang, J., and Booth, B. “Rural drug users: factors associ-ated with substance abuse treatment utilization”, International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology. 20.11;55:567–586.

bSexton, R.L., Carlson, R.G., Leukefeld, C.G., and Booth B.M. “Barriers to formal drug abuse treatment in the rural south: a preliminary ethnographic assessment”, Journal of Psychoactive Drugs. 2008; 40:121–129.

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

BarrierstoOUTreatment• PoorcoverageforMATservices– OTPsarecashonlyservicesinsomestates• Servicesareoftenclusteredaroundurbancenters–requiringlongtraveldistancesforruralresidents•Manybuprenorphineprovidersoperatebelowcapacity•MATservicesarenotenough– substanceuse,mentalhealth,carecoordinationareneeded• Greaterattentionisneededonwhathappensaftertreatment– peersupportandrecoveryservicesareneededtoreducelikelihoodofrelapse

Page 11: Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities · Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities JohnGale, MS, Senior Research Associate Rural Health Research Gateway

1/18/18

11

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

ImportantStrategyArea#1- Prevention• Opioidharmsnotrestrictedsolelytothoseusingheroinormisusingprescriptionmedications• Discourage/delayonsetofOU•Minimizerelatedhighriskbehaviors• Focusonchildren,adolescents,andyoungadults• Communityfocusedstrategies‒ Communityorganizingandeducation• Providerfocusedstrategies‒ Reducingsupplyofopioidsprescribed‒ Useofprescriptiondrugmonitoringprograms‒ Offeralternativepain-managementstrategies‒ Provideopportunitiestodisposeofunneededmedications

Page 12: Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities · Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities JohnGale, MS, Senior Research Associate Rural Health Research Gateway

1/18/18

12

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

Prevention• Aprimarycomponentofahealth-centeredsystemtoaddressOUuse• Evidence-based(EB)preventionprogramseffectivelypreventinitiation,harmfuluse,andrelatedproblems• Preventioniscost-effectiveatdifferentstagesoflife•Mustbeadaptedtotheuniquecontextofeachcommunitywithfidelitytotheinterventiononwhichtheevidenceisbased• Communitiesareanorganizingforcetobringeffectivepreventionprogramstoscale• Key:Crosssectorcommunitycoalitionstoassesslocalriskandprotectivefactors,OUproblems,andimplementinterventionstomatchlocalpriorities

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

ActivitiestoEngageCommunities• CommunityOrganizationandEngagement• Prescribereducationandbehavior• Supplyreductionanddiversioncontrol• Painpatientservicesanddrugsafety• Drugtreatmentanddemandreduction• Harmreduction• Community-basedpreventioneducation

Page 13: Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities · Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities JohnGale, MS, Senior Research Associate Rural Health Research Gateway

1/18/18

13

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

Keyelementsofeffectivecommunitycoalitions• Understandingthecommunity’sneedsandresources•Widelysharedandcomprehensivevision• Clearandfocusedstrategicplan• Diversemembership:keycommunityleaders,localgovernmentofficials,andvolunteers• Strongleadershipandcommittedpartners• Diversifiedfunding•Well-managedstructure:organizedadministration,effectivecommunicationamongparticipants,andacomprehensiveevaluationplan

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

Evidence-basedcommunityorganizingmodels• ProjectLazarus-‒ InallNorthCarolinaCounties‒ Inruralcommunitiesacrossthecountry- ProjectBaldEagle,Williamsport,PA.WinnebagoCountyHeroinTaskForceinWisconsin,ClarkCountyCollaborativeinOhio,andWashtenawHealthInitiativeOpioidProjectinMichigan

• ProjectVision,Rutland,VT‒ UsesaDrugMarketInterventionmodelandcommunitycollaboration/engagementtoreducethesupplyofopioids

• SAMHSA’SRecoveryOrientedSystemsofCare• CommunitiesThatCare

Page 14: Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities · Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities JohnGale, MS, Senior Research Associate Rural Health Research Gateway

1/18/18

14

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

ProjectLazarus– HubActivities• Hubactivitiesarecentralcomponentssupportingallotheractivitiesandreflectacommunity-based,bottom-uppublichealthapproach‒ Buildpublicawarenessofsubstanceusethroughbroad-basededucationaleffortsandtheuseoflocaldatatodriveawareness

‒ Coalitionbuildingandactiontoengageabroadrangeofcommunityproviders,agencies,andorganizations

‒ Identifydataneedsforplanningandevaluationtobuildawareness,tailorprogramstolocalneeds,trackprogress,andsustainsupportandfunding

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

ProjectLazarus– SpokeActivities• Spokeactivitiesareoptionalareasofevidence-basedpreventioninitiativesthatcommunitiescanselectandreflectamedicalandlawenforcement-based,top-downpublichealthapproach₋ Communityeducation₋ Providereducation₋ Hospitalemergencydepartmentpolicies₋ Diversioncontrol₋ Painpatientsupport₋ Addressingtheconsequencesofuse₋ Addictiontreatment

Page 15: Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities · Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities JohnGale, MS, Senior Research Associate Rural Health Research Gateway

1/18/18

15

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

ProjectVision– AddressingSupplyIssues• ProjectVision,Rutland,VT‒ Goals:empowercommunities,strengthenneighborhoods,helppeople,changethefuture

‒ Committees:Crime/Safety,SubstanceAbuse,Community/Neighborhoods/Housing

‒ UseaDrugMarketInterventionmodelandcommunitycollaboration/engagementtoreducethesupplyofopioids(heroinandillicitlydistributedprescriptionopioids)inruralRutlandVT

Page 16: Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities · Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities JohnGale, MS, Senior Research Associate Rural Health Research Gateway

1/18/18

16

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

PrescriberEducationandBehaviour• One-on-oneprescribereducationonpainmanagement• Continuingmedicaleducationonpainmanagement• Licensingactionsagainstcriminalprescribing• Implementandmonitorevidence-basedprescribingguidelinesamongallproviders‒ CDCguidelines,stateprogramssuchasWashingtonstate• Strongly encourageuseofprescriptiondrugmonitoringprograms• Thinkaboutan“oxyfree”emergencydepartment• HarmReduction- NaloxoneandOpioidusereducationonoverdosepreventionandresponse

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

HospitalPreventionStrategies• Participateincommunity-basedpreventionprogramsaspartofhospital’scommunitybenefitand/orcommunity/populationhealthinitiatives• Qualityimprovement:Focusonsupplyreduction‒ Prescribingguidelines‒ Encouragegreateruseofprescriptiondrugmonitoringprograms

‒ UseProjectECHOtosupportprescribingandpainmanagementcapacityoflocalproviders

‒ Implementan“oxy-free”emergencydepartment‒ Engageinharmreductionstrategies

Page 17: Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities · Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities JohnGale, MS, Senior Research Associate Rural Health Research Gateway

1/18/18

17

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

MidcoastMainePrescriptionOpioidReductionProgram

• ImplementedopioidprescribingguidelinesfordentalpainintworuralEDsinMaine

• DrivenbyEDchairmanwithinputfromphysiciangroup• EDpatientswhorequestrefillsofcontrolledprescriptions,havemultiplecontrolledsubstanceprescriptions,orhavemultiplepreviousEDvisitsforpainfulconditions

• Guidelinesrecommendtheuseofanalgesicalternativessuchasnerveblocksandimmobilization

• Resultsafter12months- reductionsinratesofopioidprescriptionsandvisitsfordentalpain

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

Oxy-FreeEmergencyDepartments(EDs)• EDsareasignificantsourceofopioidprescriptionsandafrequenttargetforthoseseekingopioids• EDprescribingdevelopedbytheWashingtonStateDepartmentofHealth,theWACollegeofEmergencyPhysiciansandtheWAHospitalAssociation• IncludedlimitationsontheprescriptionofopioidsinEDsandtheconceptofan“oxy-freezone”• LowerratesofEDvisitsby“frequentusers”withlowacuitydiagnosesseekingopioids• WAMedicaidestimated$33.6millioninEDsavings• Hospitalsarepleasedwiththestrategybutsomeexperiencedearlyreductionsinpatientsatisfactionscoresrelatedtopainmanagement

Page 18: Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities · Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities JohnGale, MS, Senior Research Associate Rural Health Research Gateway

1/18/18

18

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

“Oxy-Free”EDs–McKenzieHealthSystem

• InFebruary2013,McKenzieHealthSystem'sEDdiscontinueddispensingnarcoticandsedativemedicationsforcomplaintsofchronicpain

• Results– 60%reductioninopioidprescriptionabusewithina12monthperiodandreducedutilizationofunnecessaryandcostlydiagnosticwork-ups

• Staffmetwithcommunitymentalhealthofficials,countyhealthofficials,localprimarycareproviders,lawenforcement,pharmaciestoexplaintheinitiative

• Engagedinpatienteducation

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

“Oxy-Free”EDs–McKenzieHealthSystem(con’t)• Process:

– Thoroughmedicalexamtoruleoutmedicalemergencies– Reviewofpatient'scompletefile,includinginternalhealthrecords,outsidehealthrecords,drugscreeningtests

– Ifpatientpresentswithachronicpainconditionorsuspectednarcoticsabuses,physicianwillinformpatientofthedangersofnarcoticdrugabuseandmaynotprescribeanarcoticpainmedication

– Mayreceiveanon-narcoticpainmedicationandinformationaboutO/SUprogramsand/orpainmanagementspecialists

– Ifanarcoticpainmedicationisprescribedaftercarefulreviewbythephysician,itisonlyforaverylimitedamountofpills,untilthepatientcanbeseenbyhisorherphysician

Page 19: Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities · Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities JohnGale, MS, Senior Research Associate Rural Health Research Gateway

1/18/18

19

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

ReducingOpioidPrescribingbyProvidingPainManagementServices

• Duetothelimitedavailabilityofpainmanagementservicesinruralcommunities,manyprovidersrelyonprescriptionopioidsasaprimarytreatmentmodality

• Ruralprimarycareprovidersoftenhavelimitedexperiencewiththemanagementofchronicpain

• Strategies– Expandaccesstopainmanagementservicesthroughcontractsand/ortelehealth

– ImprovethecapacityoflocalproviderstomanagepainthroughuseofprogramsuchasProjectECHO

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

ExpandingLocalPainManagementServices:SalemTownshipHospital

• SalemTownshiprecruitedapainspecialisttotravelanhourfromMarion,Ill.,twiceamonthtotreatpatients.– Consideringexpansiontothreetofourtimesamonth.

• Patientsareseeninonehourincrements• Providestrigger-pointinjectionsforlong-termpainandpromotesphysicaltherapyandalternativetreatments

• Patientscontinuingwithopioidsmustagreetoregulardrugtestsandnotaskforearlyrefills

• Over3to4months,only3outof56patientshavechosentostickwithopioids

• Minimalinvestment- $25,000forcapitalequipment

Page 20: Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities · Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities JohnGale, MS, Senior Research Associate Rural Health Research Gateway

1/18/18

20

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

Telehealth-BasedPainManagementProgram:Martha’sVineyardHospital(MVH)

• DuetoitsislandlocationoffCapeCod,MVHworkedwithMassachusettsGeneralHospital’sCenterforPainManagementtoofferapainserviceviatelehealth

• MGHprovidersseepatientsinatelepainclinic3dayspermonthandconducton-sitevisitstwicepermonth

• Servicesincludeinitialconsultsandfollow-upvisits• Vitalsigns/patientsnotesarerecordedinasharedEHR• AnRN,trainedinphysicalexaminationofpainandmedicalmanagement,performspatientexamsunderdirectphysiciansupervisionvialivevideoconferenceandalsoverballyannouncedallfindings

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

Telehealth-BasedPainManagementProgram:Martha’sVineyardHospital(con’t)

• Physicalexaminationsarerepeatedbythephysicianduringon-sitevisitspriortopatientintervention

• LaboratorydataandimagingstudiesarereviewedinthesharedHER

• Over13months,49patientsparticipatedin238telepainvideoclinicsand121on-siteinterventions

• Patientsreportreducedtravelcosts,improvedaccesstocare,andgeneralsatisfactionwiththeservice

• Patientsratedtheirsatisfactionwithcarereceivedbytelepainlowerthanin-personvisitsandthoughtithardertodeveloparelationshipwiththedoctor

• Thishighlightsthechallengeofbuildingapatient-physicianrelationshipremotely

Page 21: Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities · Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities JohnGale, MS, Senior Research Associate Rural Health Research Gateway

1/18/18

21

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

ImportantStrategyArea#2- Treatment• ImplementconsistentOUscreeningforallpatients• DevelopreferralrelationshipswithSU/MHproviders• Explorelocaltreatmentopportunities‒ Medicationassistedtreatment– buprenorphine‒ Integratedbehavioralhealth/SU/primarycareservices‒ Specialtysubstanceuseservices• Collaborativetreatmentprograms– hubandspoke• Exploreuseoftechnologytoexpandaccesstocare• Overdosereversalprograms• Alternativepainmanagementprograms•Workwithlawenforcementtoprovideatreatmentalternativetoincarceration

Page 22: Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities · Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities JohnGale, MS, Senior Research Associate Rural Health Research Gateway

1/18/18

22

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

ProviderStrategiesandTreatmentServices• Ruralresidentsdeservethesamelevelofaccesstothefullrangeofsubstanceusetreatmentservicesasurbanresidents• Substanceuseisachronic,relapsingdisease‒ Requiresongoinglevelofservices‒ Reflectsaprimarycare-basedsystemofcareframework‒ Conservesresourcesbymatchingservicestopatientneedsusingalevelofcarecriteria

‒ Professionally-directed,post-dischargecarecanenhancerecovery,butrelativelyfewreceivesuchcare

‒ Distancetoservicesiscorrelatedwithtreatmentcompletion(longertraveldistancesareassociatedwithlowerratesofcompletion)

DefinitionofaSystemofCare

• Anintegratedspectrumofeffective,community-basedservicesandsupportsforruralpeopleandtheirfamiliesatriskfororstrugglingwithOUchallenges‒ Organizedintoacoordinatednetwork‒ Buildsmeaningfulpartnershipswithindividualsandtheirfamilies‒ Addressestheirculturalandlinguisticneeds,tohelpthemfunctionbetterathome,inschool,inthecommunity,andthroughoutlife.

Page 23: Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities · Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities JohnGale, MS, Senior Research Associate Rural Health Research Gateway

1/18/18

23

StructureofTreatmentServices• Useofaregionalorientation/model• Reflectstherealitiesofruralresourcelimitations‒ Usestechnology(e.g.,telehealth,mobilephones,etc.)toaddressdistancebarriersandmaldistributionofresourcesacrossurbanandruralareas

• Integrationacrossservicessystems:‒ Substanceuse,‒ Mentalhealth,and‒ Primarycare

PrincipalsforTreatment• Treatmentmustbeavailable,accessible,attractive,andappropriateforneeds

• Ethicalstandardsmustbeobserved• Requireseffectivecoordinationbetweenthecriminaljusticesystemandhealthandsocialservices

• OUDsshouldbeviewedasahealthproblemratherthancriminalbehavior:usersshouldbetreatedinthehealthcareratherthanthecriminaljusticesystemwhenpossible

Page 24: Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities · Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities JohnGale, MS, Senior Research Associate Rural Health Research Gateway

1/18/18

24

PrincipalsforTreatment(cont’d)• Basedonscientificevidenceandrespondtospecificneedsofindividualswithouds

• Shouldrespondtotheneedsofspecialsubgroupsandconditions

• ShouldensuregoodclinicalgovernanceoftreatmentservicesandprogramsforOUDs

• Integratedtreatmentpolicies,services,procedures,approachesandlinkagesmustbeconstantlymonitoredandevaluated

OpioidScreeningTools

• Canbeusedacrossdifferenthealthcaresettings‒ ScreenerandOpioidAssessmentforPatientsinPainRevised(SOAPP-R)

‒ CurrentOpioidMisuseMeasure(COMM)‒ OpioidRiskTool(ORT)‒ Diagnosis,Intractability,Risk,andEfficacy(DIRE)‒ ScreeningInstrumentforSubstanceAbusePotential(SISAP)‒ (vi)ThePainAssessmentandDocumentationTool(PADT)

Page 25: Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities · Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities JohnGale, MS, Senior Research Associate Rural Health Research Gateway

1/18/18

25

BridgtonHospitalBuprenorphineClinic• CoordinatedeffortsbetweenBridgtonHospital,NorthBridgtonFamilyPractice,CrookedRiverCounseling

‒ Programhasenrolled200patientsinaruralMainecommunity‒ Startedin2009‒ Fourphysiciansandtwonursepractitionersprescribebuprenorphineintheirprimarycarepractice(NorthBridgton)

‒ CrookedRiverCounselingprovidesintensiveoutpatientcounselingandgrouptherapyforthepatients

‒ BridgtonHospitalprovidescomprehensivematernitycaretowomenwithOUDduringtheirpregnancy

‒ Servicesareinterconnectedandcoordinatedacrossproviders‒ Keyisthecollaborativeapproachandcommunication

BridgtonHospitalBuprenorphineClinic• Benefits‒ Lowerregulatory/licensurebarriersthanmethadoneprograms‒ SAMHSAprescribingwaiveriscomparativelyeasytoobtain‒ Canbeintegratedintoprimarycaresystem‒ Goldstandardoftreatmentforopioids

• Challenges‒ Buprenorphinealoneisnotsufficienttomeetallpatientneeds‒ Canbedifficulttoincorporateintoabusypracticewithoutadditionalsupport

‒ Linkageswithbiggersystemsofcareareneeded

Page 26: Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities · Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities JohnGale, MS, Senior Research Associate Rural Health Research Gateway

1/18/18

26

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

SupportingMATandOUDServices- Vermont• Vermont’sHubandSpokemodelsupportstheuseofbuprenorphinebyprimarycareandcommunityproviders₋ Comprehensivecaremanagement₋ Carecoordinationandreferraltolocalresources₋ Caretransitions₋ Individualandfamilysupports₋ Healthpromotion₋ Expandsuseofbuprenorphineinprimarycare₋ Recognizesimportanceofmentalhealthandtraditionalsubstanceuseservicesintreatingopioidproblems

₋ Efficientuseofscarceresources₋ Providescareinlessstigmatizingsettings

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

VermontHubandSpoke(cont’d)• Regionalspecialtytreatmentcentersserveasthehubs₋ CoordinatecareofindividualswithcomplexOUDsandco-occurringSUandMHdisorders

₋ ProvidefullrangeofOUDcareandsupportcommunityprovidersbyprovidingconsultativesupporttoprimarycareandotherprovidersprescribingbuprenorphine

• Physiciansprescribingbuprenorphineandcollaboratinghealthandaddictionsprofessionalsserveasthespokes₋ Dispensebuprenorphine,monitoradherencetotreatment,coordinateaccesstorecoverysupports,andprovidecounseling,contingencymgt,andcasemgtservices

• FundedthroughMedicaidwaiver

Page 27: Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities · Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities JohnGale, MS, Senior Research Associate Rural Health Research Gateway

1/18/18

27

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

ImportantStrategyArea#3- Recovery• ThethirdandoftenoverlookedstrategytoaddressOUdisorders• Providesupportthroughprogramsorastructuredmilieutosupportsobrietyandsubstancefreeliving• Ideally,recoverybeginsbeforetreatment• Addressessocial,rehabilitation,andvocationalissues• Providesacommunitytoreinforcesobriety

Page 28: Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities · Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities JohnGale, MS, Senior Research Associate Rural Health Research Gateway

1/18/18

28

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

Recovery• “Recoveryisaprocessofchangethroughwhichanindividualachievesabstinenceandimprovedhealth,wellnessandqualityoflife.”SAMHSA• Fourdimensionsthatdefineahealthylifeinrecovery:‒ Health- Managingone’sdisease(s)orsymptoms;makinginformedchoicesthatsupportphysical/emotionalwellbeing

‒ Home– Havingasafeandstableplacetolive‒ Purpose– Participatinginmeaningfuldailyactivitiesandhavingtheindependence,income,resourcestoparticipateinsociety

‒ Community– Engaginginrelationshipsandsocialnetworksthatprovidesupport,friendship,love,andhope

• Hospitalscancoordinatewithlocalrecoveryprograms

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

Recovery– CommunityPrograms• Doescommunitycreateasupportiveenvironmentforrecovery?‒ Stigmareduction– opportunitiesforanewstart‒ Employmentopportunities‒ Educationalopportunities‒ Social,recreationaloutlets‒ Connectiontoculturalheritage‒ Twelvestepprograms‒ Peersupport

Page 29: Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities · Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities JohnGale, MS, Senior Research Associate Rural Health Research Gateway

1/18/18

29

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

Evidence-BasedRecoveryPrograms• DepartmentofVeteran’sAffairs– PeerRecovery‒ Recruitveteransinrecoverytosupportthosegoingthroughtheprocess

• Australianmentalhealthpeersupport‒ Goal– avoidanceofunnecessaryhospitalizations

• TurningPointCenter,Rutland,VT‒ PartoftheVermontRecoveryNetwork

• SupportingPeerRecovery:TheRECOVERProject,FranklinCounty,MA

• ProjectAngels,Gloucester,MA‒ Providestreatmentasanalternativetoincarceration

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

ChallengestoDevelopingRuralPrograms• Programs“imported”fromoutsidethelocalareaareoftenviewedwithsuspicion• Community-basedprogramsareimportanttocreatelocallydeveloped,culturallyappropriateinterventions‒ Mustbesensitivetolocalcultural,religions,andethnicissues(culturalhumility)andengagelocalleaders

‒ Limitedopportunitiesaftertreatment,stigma,restrictedsocialsupportsfrequentlyleadstorelapse– mustsupportsoberliving

• Continuumofprevention,treatment,andrecoveryservicesmustbedevelopedsimultaneouslytoaddresstheneedsofruralresidents“wheretheyare”

Page 30: Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities · Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities JohnGale, MS, Senior Research Associate Rural Health Research Gateway

1/18/18

30

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

Recommendations• TheCommunityiskey!!• Supportthedevelopmentandimplementationofcommunitycoalitions- ProjectLazarusorProjectVision• Engageproviders,businesses,schools,residents,lawenforcement• Conductbroad-basededucationonthedangersofopioids• Buildalocalsystemofcarethatintegratesprevention,treatment,andrecoveryandengagesmentalhealth,andsubstanceuseproviders

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

TheRuralHealthResearchGatewayprovidesaccesstoallpublicationsandprojectsfromsevenresearchcentersfundedbytheFederalOfficeofRuralHealthPolicy

Visitourwebsiteformoreinformation:http://www.ruralhealthresearch.org/

SignupforemailorRSSalertsat:http://www.ruralhealthresearch.org/alerts

Page 31: Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities · Strategies to Combat Opioid Use in Rural Communities JohnGale, MS, Senior Research Associate Rural Health Research Gateway

1/18/18

31

Muskie School of Public Service Maine Rural Health Research Center

ContactInformationJohnA,Gale,MSSeniorResearchAssociateMaineRuralHealthResearchCenterMuskieSchoolofPublicServiceUniversityofSouthernMainePOBox9300Portland,ME04104-9300

[email protected]


Recommended