A Consensus Meeting
for The Definitions of Subcortical
lesions, Lacunes, Microbleeds, and Subcortical
White Matter Change
Jei Kim, MD
M/71, 2011. 1. 28
M/71, 2011. 1. 28
M/71, 2011. 1. 28
Subcortical lesions
4. Microbleeds
3. Subcortical white matter changes
1. Perivascular spaces (etat crible)
2. Lacunes
Perivascular spaces (etat
crible)
1) Histopathologic definition (ref. 1)
1. Perivascular spaces (etat
crible)
: the dilatation of perivascular spaces around
cerebral arterioles in the brain of elderly patients
(Virchow-Robin space)
2) MRI definition (ref. 1)
: the punctiform dilatations of the perivascular
spaces often seen by brain MRI in the white
matter and in the basal ganglia
1. Perivascular spaces (etat
crible)2) MRI definition: the punctiform dilatations of the perivascular spaces
often seen by brain MRI in the white matter and
in the basal ganglia
: On T2WI – high intensity,
same as the intensity of CSF
: On FLAIR – dark (low), same as the intensity of CSF
: On T1WI – dark (low), same as the intensity of CSF
http://www.radiologyassistant.nl/en/4556dea65db62
M/80, 2011. 10. 13
Lacune
s
2. Lacunes
1) Histopathologic definition
: a small, cystic cavity of the brain substance that
usually results from an ischemic infarction in the
territory of a penetrating arteriole (ref. 1)
2. Lacunes
2) Vascular pathology of lacunes (ref. 13)
3) Perforating arteries
(1) Anterior perforating arteries
(2) Posterior perforating arteries
(3) Arterial supply of the brainstem
2. Lacunes
(1) Anterior perforating arteries
A. Perforating branches arising from ACA
and the recurrent artery of Heubner
(1) Anterior perforating arteries
B. Perforating branches arising from MCA
a. Perforating branches arising from MCA
(1) Anterior perforating arteries
b. Percentage of perforating arteries arising
from MCA trunk and its branches
(1) Anterior perforating arteries
B. Perforating branches arising from MCA
c. Origin of perforating arteries arising
from MCA trunk and its branches
(1) Anterior perforating arteries
B. Perforating branches arising from MCA
d. Number of perforating arteries arising
from different distances from the origin of MCA
(1) Anterior perforating arteries
B. Perforating branches arising from MCA
e. Branching characteristics of 508 perforating arteries
arising from common stems of MCA
(1) Anterior perforating arteries
B. Perforating branches arising from MCA
(2) Posterior perforating arteries
(3) Arterial supply of the brainstem
A. Perforating arteries of the midbrain
B. Perforating arteries of the pons
(3) Arterial supply of the brainstem
C. Perforating arteries of the midbrain
(3) Arterial supply of the brainstem
Schematic diagram of origin of deep
perforating branches from a parent artery
4) Pathogenic implications of microcirculation
1) Stenosis or complete occlusion by atherosclerosis
2) Stenosis or occlusion of ostium of a branch point
3) Atherosclerotic narrowing of a parent artery
4) Proximal thrombus or embolus in atherosclerotic
artery
(1) Perforating arteries
(2) Cortical branches
2. Lacunes
4) Pathogenic implications of microcirculation
A. Stenosis or complete occlusion by atherosclerosis
(1) Perforating arteries
B. Stenosis or occlusion of ostium of a branch point
4) Pathogenic implications of microcirculation
(1) Perforating arteries
C. Atherosclerotic narrowing of a parent artery
4) Pathogenic implications of microcirculation
(1) Perforating arteries
D. Proximal thrombus or embolus in atherosclerotic
artery
4) Pathogenic implications of microcirculation
(1) Perforating arteries
(2) Cortical branches
4) Pathogenic implications of microcirculation
5) MRI definition
2. Lacunes
(ref. 2)
: small hyperintense lesions on T2WI (ref. 2)
: corresponding distinctive low intensity area on T1WI
: Maximum size of lacune (ref. 4)
- with a diameter of 5-10 mm
: On CT (ref. 4)
- areas of more or less complete focal tissue destruction
- clearly defined borders with marked central
hypodensity on CT
: On MRI (ref. 4)
- low intensity on T1WI, proton-density and FLAIR scans
- high intensity on T2WI
-> isointense to CSF
5) MRI definition
2. Lacunes
(ref. 17)
2. Lacunes
1) Histopathologic definition
: a small, cystic cavity of the brain substance that
usually results from an ischemic infarction in the
territory of a penetrating arteriole (ref. 1)
: defined as cavitated microinfarcts or encephalomalacic
lesions, 2 mm or smaller in greatest dimension, not
identifiable with certainty on gross inspection of the
brain or non-cavitated microinfarcts, focal gliotic areas
without a cystic cavity (ref. 3)
M/80, 2011. 10. 13
6) Grading of lacunes
2. Lacunes
(ref. 2)
(1) Absent
(2) Mild – 1-3
(3) Moderate – 4-10
(4) Severe - >10
7) Locations of lacunes (ref. 2)
(1) Cortico-subcortical
(2) Basal ganglia
(3) Thalamus
(4) Brain stem
(5) Cerebellum
Subcortical white matter change
3. Subcortical white matter change
1) Definition of Binswanger‟s disease (1894)
: pronounced atrophy of the white matter, either confined
to one or more gyri of the brain or in several sections
of the hemisphere
: in the most severe cases the entire white matter
of a cerebral lobe appears to have completely wasted away
: a severe atheromatosis of the arteries of the brain is always
present in these cases
: extensive atrophic degeneration or fatty degeneration
of the small arterial and venous vessels
: partial thickening of the inner and middle vascular
membranes
: the lumen is correspondingly narrowed
3. Subcortical white matter change
: loss of density of the periventricular white matter
observed by CT of the brain
: the white matter changes commonly observed in the
elderly by MRI of the brain
2) Definition of leukoaraiosis (Hachinski et al., 1987)
3. Subcortical white matter change
3) Mechanisms hypothesized to be involved
in the pathogenesis of white matter change (ref. 14)
4) Small vessel changes related to white matter changes
(ref. 14)
3. Subcortical white matter change
3. Subcortical white matter change
5) Evolution of white matter lesions (ref. 16)
3. Subcortical white matter change
6) Definition of „Periventricular‟ and „Deep white matter‟
change (ref.5)
(1) Periventricular
- Start directly at the ventricular border
3. Subcortical white matter change
6) Definition of „Periventricular‟ and „Deep white matter‟
change (ref.5)
(2) Both periventricular and deep white matter
- If the periventricular abnormalities extend > 1 cm
into the adjacent white matter
6) Definition of „Periventricular‟ and „Deep white matter‟
change (ref.5)
3. Subcortical white matter change
(3) Selective deep white matter lesion
- usually characterized by a rim of normal-appearing
tissue which separates them from the periventricular
region
3. Subcortical white matter change
6) Definition of „Periventricular‟ and „Deep white matter‟
change (ref.5)
(4) Basal ganglia hypodensities on CT or hyperintensity on MRI
(M/82)
6) Definition of „Periventricular‟ and „Deep white matter‟
change (ref.24)
3. Subcortical white matter change
3. Subcortical white matter change
6) Definition of „Periventricular‟ and „Deep white matter‟
change – (1) (ref.5)
(1) Periventricular hyperintensity
0 = absence
1 = “caps” or pencil-thin lining
2 = smooth “halo”
3 = irregular PVH extending into the deep white matter
(2) Deep white matter hyperintense signal
0 = absence
1 = punctuate foci
2 = beginning confluence of foci
3 = large confluent areas
3. Subcortical white matter change
7) Definition of „Periventricular‟ and „Deep white matter‟ –(3)
(ref. 6)
(1) White matter lesions
0 = no lesions
(including symmetrical, well-defined caps or bands)
1 = Focal lesions
2 = Beginning confluence of lesions
3 = Diffuse involvement of the entire region,
with or without involvement of U fibers
(2) Basal ganglia lesions
0 = No lesions
1 = 1 focal lesion (≥ 5 mm)
2 = > 1 focal lesion
3 = Confluent lesions
3. Subcortical white matter change
7) Definition of „Periventricular‟ and „Deep white matter‟ –(3)
(ref. 6)
1. Score of 1
3. Subcortical white matter change
7) Definition of „Periventricular‟ and „Deep white matter‟ –(3)
(ref. 6)
2. Score of 2
3. Subcortical white matter change
7) Definition of „Periventricular‟ and „Deep white matter‟ –(3)
(ref. 6)
3. Score of 3
1 = Focal lesions
(1) White matter lesions
3. Subcortical white matter change
(1) White matter lesions
2 = Beginning confluence of lesions
3. Subcortical white matter change
(1) White matter lesions
3 = Diffuse involvement of the entire region,
with or without involvement of U fibers
(M/75)
3. Subcortical white matter change
(1) White matter lesions
3 = Diffuse involvement of the entire region,
with or without involvement of U fibers
(M/60)
3. Subcortical white matter change
(2) Basal ganglia lesions
1 = 1 focal lesion (≥ 5 mm)
3. Subcortical white matter change
(2) Basal ganglia lesions
2 = > 1 focal lesion
3. Subcortical white matter change
(2) Basal ganglia lesions
3 = Confluent lesions
3. Subcortical white matter change
Microbleeds
4. Microbleeds
1) Histopathologic and MRI definition
: paramagnetic material which produces local susceptibility
gradients and thereby causes a faster decay of transverse
magnetization on gradient-echo acquisition (ref. 18)
: remnants of even minor blood leakage through
damaged vessel walls
4. Microbleeds
1) Histopathologic definition
: Postmortem gradient-echo-T2*-weighted MRI and
histopathologic finding (ref. 19)
4. Microbleeds
Figure 1. Grading of CAA severity in single
brain samples (ref. 27)
0: No cerebral vessels showed immunopositivity
for beta amyloid
1+: Amyloid is restricted to a rim around smooth
muscle fibers in the media of occasional
normal vessels
2+: The media is thicker than normal and
circumferentially replaced by amyloid
in a few vessels
3+: Widespread medial thickening and
circumferential amyloid deposition
with a small halo of immunoreactivity
in the surrounding parenchyma
: A focus of wall leakage as evidenced
by fresh hemorrhage or hemosiderin-laden
macrophages, or occlusion, or recanalization
2) Severity of amyloid angiopathy (ref. 27)
4. Microbleeds
3) MRI definition of microbleed (ref. 2, 19, 20, 21)
(1) Homogeneous round signal loss lesion with a
diameter of up to 5 mm (or <10 mm)
on gradient echo image
(2)Distinct from
a. Vascular flow voids on subarachnoid space
b. Leptomeningeal hemasiderosis
c. Non-hemorrhagic subcortical mineralization
• Non-hemorrhagic subcortical mineralization (ref. 26)
• Non-hemorrhagic subcortical mineralization
(M/80)
• Leptomeningeal hemasiderosis
1. Superficial cortical hemosidersosis (ref. 25)
• Leptomeningeal hemasiderosis
2. Subarachnoid hemosidersosis (ref. 25)
• Leptomeningeal hemasiderosis
3. Schematic drawing illustrating subarachnoid hemosiderosis
and superficial corical hemosidersosi (ref. 25)
4. Microbleeds
3) MRI definition of microbleed (ref. 20)
• In CAA Pt. • In CADASIL
Pt.
• In H/T Pt.
4. Microbleeds
3) MRI definition of microbleed (ref. 21)
4. Microbleeds
4) Degree of severity of microbleeds (ref. 2)
(1) Absent
(2) Mild – total number of MBs, 1-5
(3) Moderate – total number of MBs, 6-15
(4) Severe – total number of MBs, >15
4. Microbleeds
5) The locations of the microbleeds and lacunes (ref. 2)
(1) Cortico-subcortical
(2) Basal ganglia
(3) Thalamus
(4) Brain stem
(5) Cerebellum
Evaluation of the vessel stenosis
1) Significant stenosis - >50%
2) No significant stenosis - <50%
Definition of coronary artery stenosis (ref. 8)
The degrees of stenoocclusive disease (ref. 7)
1) Normal – 0% - 29% diameter stenosis
2) Mildly stenotic – 30% - 49%
3) Moderately stenotic – 50% - 79%
4) Severely stenotic – 80%- 99%
5) Occluded
Regional location of stenosis (ref. 9)
: Schematic representation of 11 arterial segments studied
by transcranial Doppler and duplex ultrasound
MCA – 1 and 2
ACA – 3 and 4
PCA – 5 and 6
Siphon ICA – 7 and 8
Extracranial ICA - 9 and 10
Vertebrobasilar artery – 11
Measuement of vessel stenosis (ref. 10)
1. Equation for measuring intracranial arterial stenosis
: Percent stenosis = [(1-(Dstenosis/Dnormal))] x 100
• Dstenosis: the diameter of the artery at the site of the
most severe degree of stenosis
• Dnormal: the diameter of the proximal normal artery
Measuement of vessel stenosis (ref. 10)
2. Criteria for normal proximal artery
1) For the MCA, intracranial VA, and BA
(1) First choice
- the diameter of the proximal part of the artery
at its widest , non-tortuous, normal segment was
chosen
(2) Second choice
- if the proximal artery was diseased
-> the diameter of the distal portion of the artery
at its widest, parallel
Measuement of vessel stenosis (ref. 10)
2. Criteria for normal proximal artery
(3) Third choice
A. If the entire intracranial artery was diseased
-> the most distal, parallel, non-tortous normal
segment of the feeding artery
B. If the entire middle cerebral artery was diseased
-> measured at the most distal, parallel segement
of the supraaclinoid carotid artery
C. If the entire intracranial vertebral artery was diseased
-> measured at the most distal, parallel,
non-tortous normal segment of the extracranial
vertebral artery
Measuement of vessel stenosis (ref. 10)
2. Criteria for normal proximal artery
2) For the ICA
(1) First choice
: The precavernous, cavernous, and postcavernous
stenoses of ICA
-> measured at the widest, non-tortous, normal
portion of the petrous carotid artery that had
parallel margins
Measuement of vessel stenosis (ref. 10)
2. Criteria for normal proximal artery
2) For the ICA
(2) Second choice
- If the entire petrous carotid was diseased
-> the most distal, parallel part of the extracranial
internal carotid artery was substituted
- If tandem intracranial lesions were present
-> percent stenosis of both sites was measured
and the more severe stenosis was selected
- When a “gap sign” was present
-- the lumen of the vessel could not be visualized
at the site of severe stenosis
-- could not be measured
-- defined as 99% luminal stenosis
1. Equation for measuring intracranial arterial stenosis
Measuement of vessel stenosis (ref. 10)
2. Equation for measuring extracranial arterial stenosis
Measuement of vessel stenosis
1) Severity of intracranial stenosis (ref. 11, 12)
(1) Mild - <30%
(2) Moderate – 30% - 69%
(3) Severe – 70% - 99%
- in case of segmental signal void
-> the stenosis was graded as severe (>70%)
(4) Occluded
2. Equation for measuring extracranial arterial stenosis
Measuement of vessel stenosis
2) Measurement of the carotid artery stenosis (ref. 12)
(1) NASCET
: (1-md/C)x100%
(2) ECST
: (1-md/B)x100%
(3) CC
: (1-md/A)x100%