<doc.: IEEE 802.15-11-0186-00-004k>

Submission

<March 2011>

<David A. Howard (On-Ramp Wireless), John Geiger (GE Energy Services)>

Slide 1

Project: IEEE P802.15 Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks (WPANs)Project: IEEE P802.15 Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks (WPANs)

Submission Title: [Smart Grid: Faulted Circuit Indicator]Date Submitted: [March 7, 2011]Source: [David A. Howard, John Geiger] Company [On-Ramp Wireless, GE Energy Services]Address [10920 Via Frontera Suite 200, San Diego, CA 92129 USA]Voice:[+1(858)592-6008], FAX: [+1(858)592-6009], E-Mail:[david.a.howard@ieee.org, john.geiger@ge.com]

Re: [January 2011, IEEE 802.15.4k LECIM Task Group Call For Applications DCN: 0105]

Abstract: [Wireless Faulted Circuit Indicator application]

Purpose: [Response to 802.15.4k CFA, for use in generating application requirements]

Notice: This document has been prepared to assist the IEEE P802.15. It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s). The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study. The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add, amend or withdraw material contained herein.Release: The contributor acknowledges and accepts that this contribution becomes the property of IEEE and may be made publicly available by P802.15.

<doc.: IEEE 802.15-11-0186-00-004k>

Submission

Faulted Circuit Indicator (FCI)

• Faulted circuit indicators were introduced in Germany in 1946. Since that time FCIs have been used to locate problems on medium voltage electrical distribution circuits throughout the world.

• Also known as ground fault indicators, earth fault indicators, short-circuit indicators, or simply fault indicators

• Used to improve power system reliability• Can help identify problem areas of distribution

system (fault localization)

<March 2011>

<David A. Howard (On-Ramp Wireless), John Geiger (GE Energy Services)>

Slide 2

<doc.: IEEE 802.15-11-0186-00-004k>

Submission

FCI (continued)

<March 2011>

<David A. Howard (On-Ramp Wireless), John Geiger (GE Energy Services)>

Slide 3

Schematic example of legacy FCI use in electric distribution

<doc.: IEEE 802.15-11-0186-00-004k>

Submission

FCI Benefits (traditional)

• Reduction of outage duration– Enables service crews to rapidly identify

location of fault by patrolling area

• Improve system reliability

• Reduction of operating costs

<March 2011>

<David A. Howard (On-Ramp Wireless), John Geiger (GE Energy Services)>

Slide 4

<doc.: IEEE 802.15-11-0186-00-004k>

Submission

FCI Benefits (wireless)

• New functionality possible with wireless solutions– Enable crews to be dispatch directly to the fault area

– Locate momentary/transient faults

– Coordinate automated reclosing schemes

– Monitor load current, voltage, temperature, and events

• improved modeling of grid events, and reliability metrics

– Change fault thresholds

– Improved planning based on load data

– Safety, e.g. Fire prevention

<March 2011>

<David A. Howard (On-Ramp Wireless), John Geiger (GE Energy Services)>

Slide 5

<doc.: IEEE 802.15-11-0186-00-004k>

Submission

FCI Benefits (wireless with Time Sync)

• New functionality possible with single digit uS timing accuracy– Determine location of fault with ~100 meter accuracy

– Pin-point location of momentary/transient faults

– Increase distance between FCI in rural areas

– Synchronized monitoring load current, voltage, temperature, and events

– Improved modeling of grid events, and reliability metrics

<month year>

<author>, <company>Slide 6

<March 2011>

<David A. Howard (On-Ramp Wireless), John Geiger (GE Energy Services)>

Slide 6

<doc.: IEEE 802.15-11-0186-00-004k>

Submission

<March 2011>

<David A. Howard (On-Ramp Wireless), John Geiger (GE Energy Services)>

Slide 7

FCI Data Model

UpLink•Periodic/scheduled

– Once per day– <100 octets– Average load, temperature, transient/momentary events

statistics, battery status•Event/asynchronous/unscheduled/alarm

– 50 (?) per FCI per year– <100 octets– Average load, temperature, transient/momentary events

statistics, battery status

<doc.: IEEE 802.15-11-0186-00-004k>

Submission

FCI Data Model (continued)

• Downlink– Reliable transmission feedback (e.g. ACK)

• <10 octets; infrequent (see uplink)– Parameter changes (thresholds, etc.)

• <10 octets; infrequent– Firmware update

• Potentially 100’s of Kbytes; extremely rare• Latency

– 10’s of seconds

<March 2011>

<David A. Howard (On-Ramp Wireless), John Geiger (GE Energy Services)>

Slide 8

<doc.: IEEE 802.15-11-0186-00-004k>

Submission

Deployment Scenarios

• FCI– Above ground

• Elevated• Pad mount cabinet

– Below ground

• Access Point/Aggregator– Tower/shared space

<March 2011>

<David A. Howard (On-Ramp Wireless), John Geiger (GE Energy Services)>

Slide 9

<doc.: IEEE 802.15-11-0186-00-004k>

Submission

FCI: above ground deployment(elevated)

<March 2011>

<David A. Howard (On-Ramp Wireless), John Geiger (GE Energy Services)>

Slide 10

<doc.: IEEE 802.15-11-0186-00-004k>

Submission

FCI: above ground deploymentpad mount cabinet, ~15-20dB path loss

<March 2011>

<David A. Howard (On-Ramp Wireless), John Geiger (GE Energy Services)>

Slide 11

<doc.: IEEE 802.15-11-0186-00-004k>

Submission

FCI: below ground deploymentvault/manhole ~ 15-30dB path loss

<March 2011>

<David A. Howard (On-Ramp Wireless), John Geiger (GE Energy Services)>

Slide 12

<doc.: IEEE 802.15-11-0186-00-004k>

Submission

Access Point/Aggregator

<March 2011>

<David A. Howard (On-Ramp Wireless), John Geiger (GE Energy Services)>

Slide 13

Tower Shared Space / High interference(10-15dB above thermal noise floor)

<doc.: IEEE 802.15-11-0186-00-004k>

Submission

Power requirements

• Faulted Circuit Indicator (10-20 yr service life)

– Battery (e.g. Lithium Thionyl Chloride Li-SOCl2)

– Power scavenging (e.g. inductive + super capacitor)

• Access Point/Aggregator– Mains powered, UPS/Generator backup

<March 2011>

<David A. Howard (On-Ramp Wireless), John Geiger (GE Energy Services)>

Slide 14

<doc.: IEEE 802.15-11-0186-00-004k>

Submission

Market Size (distribution, estimate)

• USA 3M

• EU 3M

• Japan 614K

• World 10M

• Based on number of customers, customers per transformer (~10-15), and transformers per FCI (~5-10)

<March 2011>

<David A. Howard (On-Ramp Wireless), John Geiger (GE Energy Services)>

Slide 15

<doc.: IEEE 802.15-11-0186-00-004k>

Submission

Application Requirements

• Low infrastructure costs– Point to multi-thousands of point communications– Address spectrum availability/cost issues

• Easily deployable– Minimal network complexity and number of active nodes– Access point/Standard network interface – IP– Standard device interface – Serial or IP

• Able to communicate to underground/enclosed assets• Endpoint able to operate without primary power for many years

– Small payload per day– Latency in seconds– Event time accurate to single digit uS

• Available embedded through OEM’s

<March 2011>

<David A. Howard (On-Ramp Wireless), John Geiger (GE Energy Services)>

Slide 16