+ All Categories
Home > Business > Supply Chain Risk Management Step 3: Risk Mitigation

Supply Chain Risk Management Step 3: Risk Mitigation

Date post: 14-Apr-2017
Category:
Upload: heiko-schwarz
View: 1,050 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
2
We recommend sound preparation and a three-step process for implementing adequate and targeted risk- prevention or crisis-response measures: 1) Pool of measures. First, a catalogue of preventive actions, or a pool of measures, must be created and described. For this step it is useful to group the individual preventive actions by topics according to risk factors (risk indicators), e. g. natural hazards, political situa- tions, sanctions, working conditions or strikes. 2) Identification of extent of loss or damage. Risk identification (step 1) provides details regarding which supply chains (more specifically which suppliers, loca- tions, own plants and customers) are affected by a risk event or a change in a risk indicator. Together with the details about the level of impact (step 2) it is possible to make a quick decision in an emergency as to which potential preventive actions should be used from the pool of measures. 3) Effect and origin of preventive actions. The final step involves deciding how to handle the relevant risk. Not all risks are equal: some risks are easy to control and others are difficult to manage. Depending on whe- ther the situation – or in a specific case, the level of impact – is critical/high or non-critical/low, preventive actions with appropriate effect must be derived, that is, risk prevention, risk transfer, risk mitigation or risk acceptance measures. Using the example of a supplier’s production plant being located in an area with a high earthquake risk, the framework of preventive risk management is as follows: a) Low impact: The risk of an earthquake hitting the supplier, or more specifically, the supplier's site can be taken and accepted. b) High impact: The following preventive actions can be derived, for example: • Risk prevention measures, e. g. by establishing an alternative source • Risk transfer measures, e. g. by taking out CBI insurance • Risk mitigation measures, e. g. through structural earthquake protection measures Creation of preventive action catalogue. As already mentioned, the catalogue of preventive actions is a collection of all risk-prevention or crisis-response mea- sures that have been grouped by topics according to risk indicators. Every measure is assigned to at least one risk factor. However, when creating the catalogue of preventive actions, additional steps must also be taken into account. A responsible party must be defined for each measure, and all stakeholders involved must be listed. The parties involved can be from the most diverse departments: Logistics (e. g. emergency logis- tics), Quality (e. g. quality approval concerning re- placement procurement), Corporate Communication (e. g. in case of compliance breaches), Insurance (e. g. where a CBI insurance policy has been taken out), or Legal Division (e. g. in case of sanction matches). To ensure fast response in a risk event, we also recom- mend describing the actual procedure to be followed for each measure. Ideally, specific recommendations Comprehensive risk management along the supply chain creates transparency about risks and impact, and contributes to a sustainable solution for mitigating risks. First, managing risks along the supply chain means identifying and assessing them. These steps provide the basis for addressing risks in a proactive way using appropriate measures to ensure long- term corporate success. SUPPLY CHAIN RISK MANAGEMENT 3. RISK MITIGATION planning RISK Radar 1. 3. ACTION Planner 2. IMpACT Validator CONTROLLING & ANALYTICS
Transcript
Page 1: Supply Chain Risk Management Step 3: Risk Mitigation

We recommend sound preparation and a three-step process for implementing adequate and targeted risk-prevention or crisis-response measures:

1) Pool of measures. First, a catalogue of preventive actions, or a pool of measures, must be created and described. For this step it is useful to group the individual preventive actions by topics according to risk factors (risk indicators), e. g. natural hazards, political situa-tions, sanctions, working conditions or strikes.

2) Identification of extent of loss or damage. Risk identification (step 1) provides details regarding which supply chains (more specifically which suppliers, loca-tions, own plants and customers) are affected by a risk event or a change in a risk indicator. Together with the details about the level of impact (step 2) it is possible to make a quick decision in an emergency as to which potential preventive actions should be used from the pool of measures.

3) Effect and origin of preventive actions. The final step involves deciding how to handle the relevant risk. Not all risks are equal: some risks are easy to control and others are difficult to manage. Depending on whe-ther the situation – or in a specific case, the level of impact – is critical/high or non-critical/low, preventive actions with appropriate effect must be derived, that is, risk prevention, risk transfer, risk mitigation or risk acceptance measures.

Using the example of a supplier’s production plant being located in an area with a high earthquake risk, the framework of preventive risk management is as follows:

a) Low impact: The risk of an earthquake hitting the supplier, or more specifically, the supplier's site can be taken and accepted.

b) High impact: The following preventive actions can be derived, for example:

• Risk prevention measures, e. g. by establishing an alternative source

• Risk transfer measures, e. g. by taking out CBI insurance

• Risk mitigation measures, e. g. through structural earthquake protection measures

Creation of preventive action catalogue. As already mentioned, the catalogue of preventive actions is a collection of all risk-prevention or crisis-response mea-sures that have been grouped by topics according to risk indicators. Every measure is assigned to at least one risk factor. However, when creating the catalogue of preventive actions, additional steps must also be taken into account. A responsible party must be defined for each measure, and all stakeholders involved must be listed. The parties involved can be from the most diverse departments: Logistics (e. g. emergency logis-tics), Quality (e. g. quality approval concerning re-placement procurement), Corporate Communication (e. g. in case of compliance breaches), Insurance (e.g. where a CBI insurance policy has been taken out), or Legal Division (e. g. in case of sanction matches). To ensure fast response in a risk event, we also recom-mend describing the actual procedure to be followed for each measure. Ideally, specific recommendations

Comprehensive risk management along the supply chain creates transparency about risks and impact, and contributes to a sustainable solution for mitigating risks. First, managing risks along the supply chain means identifying and assessing them. These steps provide the basis for addressing risks in a proactive way using appropriate measures to ensure long-term corporate success.

Supply Chain RiSk ManageMent3. RISK MITIGATION planning

RISK Radar1.

3.ACTION Planner

2.IMpACT Validator

ContRolling & analytiCS

Page 2: Supply Chain Risk Management Step 3: Risk Mitigation

Orleansstraße 4 • 81669 München • T: +49 (0)89 9901 648 - 0 • [email protected] • www.riskmethods.net

regarding implementation or support should be added to this description. These could be service providers (e. g. emergency logistics experts, or brokers in the semiconductor or chemical sectors), who can provide valuable support in crisis situations.

Organizational integration. To implement preventive action planning on a sustainable basis and to ensure long-term success, support by top-level management is imperative. Resources as well as budgets must be made available for implementing preventive actions (when planning is possible) and managing risks on a reactive basis (ad hoc). Many companies are still neglecting this practice within the framework of risk management, and instead allocate most of their bud-get and resources towards straightforward supplier development programs. Consequently, it stands to reason that the first step should be the integration of supplier development and risk management. After all, a large number of measures in supplier development actually have a risk-mitigating effect. Leica Camera, for example, has expanded its supplier development to include monitoring, analysis and action planning along the entire supply chain.

Change in thinking required. The increasing added value through suppliers, and the corresponding increase in dependency and increased risk of expo-sure to global risks require a quick change of thinking in Procurement. The focus and objectives of procure-ment in terms of availability, price and quality must be expanded to include risk. Options for implemen-ting this process are the incorporation of risk management in the agreement of objectives, and the introduction of a risk manager role within the purchasing organization. Most certainly, this presents

Benefits of risk management:

• Reduced response times by 1.5 days

• Reduced penalties (1 hour production downtime = penalty of € 200,000)

• Prevention of price increases of up to 16 % resulting from bridging demand at short notice

• Protection against loss of sales of up to 3 % of total sales annually

• Avoidance of reputational damage, and image protection

* Quelle: Studie „Der ROI von Supply Chain Risk Management“, eckseler consult & riskmethods

a challenge that involves changes for procurement, but it also represents an opportunity to play a key role in the company and for the department to position itself as an important strategic partner in terms of overall corporate success. Last but not least, procu-rement helps ensure supply and consequently also sales, making its function an instrumental part in maintaining a positive corporate image.

Marco Rücker, Procurement Team Leader, Leica Camera

˝Setting up supply chain risk management and including the measures in our supplier development activities help us reduce risks in the global supply chains, and this is a critical component for gaining a com-petitive edge."

Supply Chain RiSk ManageMent

Threat / Probability

Impa

ct /

Criti

calit

y

low high

high

Risk Avoidance

Risk Mitigation

Risk Transfer3. RISK MITIGATION planning


Recommended