887
MICHIGAN REPORTS CASES DECIDED IN THE SUPREME COURT OF MICHIGAN FROM May 17, 2013, through August 5, 2013 CORBIN R. DAVIS REPORTER OF DECISIONS VOL. 494 FIRST EDITION 2013
MICHIGAN REPORTS
CASES DECIDED
IN THE
SUPREME COURTOF
MICHIGANFROM
May 17, 2013, through August 5, 2013
CORBIN R. DAVISREPORTER OF DECISIONS
VOL. 494FIRST EDITION
2013
Copyright 2013, by Michigan Supreme Court
The paper used in this publication meets the minimumrequirements of American National Standard for InformationSciences—Permanence of Paper for Printed Library Materials,ANSI Z39.48-1984.
SUPREME COURT
TERM EXPIRESJANUARY 1 OF
CHIEF JUSTICEROBERT P. YOUNG, JR. .............................................................. 2019
JUSTICESMICHAEL F. CAVANAGH............................................................ 2015STEPHEN J. MARKMAN............................................................ 2021MARY BETH KELLY.................................................................... 2019BRIAN K. ZAHRA ........................................................................ 2015BRIDGET M. MCCORMACK ....................................................... 2021DAVID F. VIVIANO ...................................................................... 2015
COMMISSIONERS
DANIEL C. BRUBAKER, CHIEF COMMISSIONERSHARI M. OBERG, DEPUTY CHIEF COMMISSIONER
TIMOTHY J. RAUBINGER MICHAEL S. WELLMANLYNN K. RICHARDSON GARY L. ROGERSNELSON S. LEAVITT RICHARD B. LESLIEDEBRA A. GUTIERREZ-McGUIRE KATHLEEN M. DAWSONANNE-MARIE HYNOUS VOICE RUTH E. ZIMMERMANDON W. ATKINS SAMUEL R. SMITHJÜRGEN O. SKOPPEK ANNE E. ALBERS
STATE COURT ADMINISTRATOR
CHAD C. SCHMUCKER
CLERK: LARRY S. ROYSTER1REPORTER OF DECISIONS: CORBIN R. DAVIS2
CRIER: DAVID G. PALAZZOLO
1 From May 28, 2013.2 From May 28, 2013.
COURT OF APPEALS
TERM EXPIRESJANUARY 1 OF
CHIEF JUDGE
WILLIAM B. MURPHY................................................................. 2019
CHIEF JUDGE PRO TEMDAVID H. SAWYER....................................................................... 2017
JUDGESMARK J. CAVANAGH ................................................................... 2015KATHLEEN JANSEN ................................................................... 2019E. THOMAS FITZGERALD.......................................................... 2015HENRY WILLIAM SAAD.............................................................. 2015JOEL P. HOEKSTRA..................................................................... 2017JANE E. MARKEY......................................................................... 2015PETER D. O’CONNELL ............................................................... 2019WILLIAM C. WHITBECK............................................................. 2017MICHAEL J. TALBOT .................................................................. 2015KURTIS T. WILDER...................................................................... 2017PATRICK M. METER.................................................................... 2015DONALD S. OWENS..................................................................... 2017KIRSTEN FRANK KELLY............................................................ 2019CHRISTOPHER M. MURRAY...................................................... 2015PAT M. DONOFRIO ...................................................................... 2017KAREN FORT HOOD ................................................................... 2015STEPHEN L. BORRELLO............................................................ 2019DEBORAH A. SERVITTO............................................................. 2019JANE M. BECKERING ................................................................. 2019ELIZABETH L. GLEICHER......................................................... 2019CYNTHIA DIANE STEPHENS.................................................... 2017MICHAEL J. KELLY...................................................................... 2015DOUGLAS B. SHAPIRO ............................................................... 2019AMY RONAYNE KRAUSE............................................................ 2015MARK T. BOONSTRA................................................................... 2015MICHAEL J. RIORDAN ................................................................ 2019
CHIEF CLERK/RESEARCH DIRECTOR:LARRY S. ROYSTER1
1 To May 28, 2013.
CIRCUIT JUDGES
TERM EXPIRESJANUARY 1 OF
1. MICHAEL R. SMITH ........................................................ 20152. ALFRED M. BUTZBAUGH .............................................. 2013
JOHN E. DEWANE ........................................................... 2015JOHN M. DONAHUE ....................................................... 2017CHARLES T. LASATA........................................................ 2017
3. DEBORAH ROSS ADAMS................................................ 2019DAVID J. ALLEN............................................................... 2015WENDY M. BAXTER ........................................................ 2019ANNETTE J. BERRY ........................................................ 2019GREGORY D. BILL ........................................................... 2019SUSAN D. BORMAN......................................................... 2015ULYSSES W. BOYKIN....................................................... 2015MARGIE R. BRAXTON..................................................... 2017MEGAN MAHER BRENNAN .......................................... 2015JAMES A. CALLAHAN ..................................................... 2017MICHAEL J. CALLAHAN................................................. 2015JEROME C. CAVANAGH.................................................. 2019ERIC WILLIAM CHOLACK ............................................. 2017JAMES R. CHYLINSKI..................................................... 2017ROBERT J. COLOMBO, JR. ............................................. 2019DAPHNE MEANS CURTIS .............................................. 2015CHRISTOPHER D. DINGELL ......................................... 2015PRENTIS EDWARDS........................................................ 2013CHARLENE M. ELDER.................................................... 2015VONDA R. EVANS............................................................. 2015EDWARD EWELL, JR. ...................................................... 2019PATRICIA SUSAN FRESARD.......................................... 2017SHEILA ANN GIBSON..................................................... 2017JOHN H. GILLIS, JR. ....................................................... 2015DAVID ALAN GRONER ................................................... 2017RICHARD B. HALLORAN, JR. ........................................ 2019AMY PATRICIA HATHAWAY........................................... 2019CYNTHIA GRAY HATHAWAY......................................... 2017MICHAEL M. HATHAWAY .............................................. 2017SUSAN L. HUBBARD ....................................................... 2017
v
TERM EXPIRESJANUARY 1 OF
MURIEL D. HUGHES....................................................... 2017THOMAS EDWARD JACKSON ....................................... 2013VERA MASSEY JONES .................................................... 2015CONNIE MARIE KELLEY ............................................... 2015TIMOTHY MICHAEL KENNY ........................................ 2017ARTHUR J. LOMBARD .................................................... 2015KATHLEEN I. MACDONALD.......................................... 2017KATHLEEN M. MCCARTHY............................................ 2019WADE H. MCCREE............................................................ 2015BRUCE U. MORROW........................................................ 2017JOHN A. MURPHY ........................................................... 2017MARIA L. OXHOLM ......................................................... 2019LINDA V. PARKER ............................................................ 2019LYNNE A. PIERCE............................................................ 2015LITA MASINI POPKE ...................................................... 2017DANIEL P. RYAN............................................................... 2019MICHAEL F. SAPALA ....................................................... 2013RICHARD M. SKUTT ....................................................... 2015MARK T. SLAVENS........................................................... 2017LESLIE KIM SMITH ........................................................ 2019VIRGIL C. SMITH ............................................................. 2019MARTHA M. SNOW.......................................................... 2017JEANNE STEMPIEN........................................................ 2017CRAIG S. STRONG ........................................................... 2015BRIAN R. SULLIVAN ....................................................... 2017LAWRENCE S. TALON .................................................... 2015DEBORAH A. THOMAS ................................................... 2019MARGARET MARY VANHOUTEN .................................. 2015CAROLE F. YOUNGBLOOD............................................. 2013ROBERT L. ZIOLKOWSKI............................................... 2015
4. SUSAN E. BEEBE ............................................................. 2017RICHARD N. LAFLAMME ................................................ 2017JOHN G. MCBAIN, JR. ...................................................... 2015THOMAS D. WILSON....................................................... 2019
5. AMY MCDOWELL.............................................................. 20156. JAMES M. ALEXANDER.................................................. 2015
MARTHA ANDERSON ..................................................... 2015LEO BOWMAN.................................................................. 2019MARY ELLEN BRENNAN ............................................... 2017RAE LEE CHABOT........................................................... 2017LISA ORTLIEB GORCYCA............................................... 2015NANCI J. GRANT.............................................................. 2015SHALINA D. KUMAR ....................................................... 2015DENISE LANGFORD-MORRIS ....................................... 2019
vi
TERM EXPIRESJANUARY 1 OF
CHERYL A. MATTHEWS ................................................. 2017RUDY J. NICHOLS............................................................ 2015COLLEEN A. O’BRIEN .................................................... 2017DANIEL PATRICK O’BRIEN........................................... 2017WENDY LYNN POTTS ..................................................... 2019EDWARD SOSNICK .......................................................... 2013MICHAEL D. WARREN, JR. ............................................. 2019JOAN E. YOUNG .............................................................. 2017
7. DUNCAN M. BEAGLE...................................................... 2017JOSEPH J. FARAH............................................................ 2017JUDITH A. FULLERTON ................................................ 2019JOHN A. GADOLA ............................................................ 2015ARCHIE L. HAYMAN ....................................................... 2019GEOFFREY L. NEITHERCUT ........................................ 2019DAVID J. NEWBLATT ...................................................... 2017MICHAEL J. THEILE ....................................................... 2015RICHARD B. YUILLE....................................................... 2015
8. DAVID A. HOORT ............................................................. 2017SUZANNE KREEGER ...................................................... 2015
9. GARY C. GIGUERE, JR. ................................................... 2015STEPHEN D. GORSALITZ............................................... 2017J. RICHARDSON JOHNSON ........................................... 2017PAMELA L. LIGHTVOET ................................................ 2019ALEXANDER C. LIPSEY.................................................. 2017
10. JANET M. BOES ............................................................... 2019FRED L. BORCHARD....................................................... 2017DARNELL JACKSON........................................................ 2019ROBERT L. KACZMAREK ............................................... 2015
11. WILLIAM W. CARMODY .................................................. 201512. CHARLES R. GOODMAN................................................. 201513. THOMAS G. POWER ........................................................ 2017
PHILIP E. RODGERS, JR. ............................................... 201514. JAMES M. GRAVES, JR. .................................................. 2013
TIMOTHY G. HICKS ........................................................ 2017KATHY HOOGSTRA......................................................... 20151
WILLIAM C. MARIETTI................................................... 201715. PATRICK W. O’GRADY..................................................... 201516. JAMES M. BIERNAT, SR. ................................................. 2019
RICHARD L. CARETTI..................................................... 2017MARY A. CHRZANOWSKI ............................................... 2017DIANE M. DRUZINSKI .................................................... 2015
1 From June 24, 2013.
vii
TERM EXPIRESJANUARY 1 OF
JENNIFER FAUNCE ........................................................ 20192
JOHN C. FOSTER ............................................................. 2015PETER J. MACERONI...................................................... 2015EDWARD A. SERVITTO, JR. ........................................... 2019MARK S. SWITALSKI ....................................................... 2019MATTHEW S. SWITALSKI .............................................. 2015DAVID VIVIANO ............................................................... 20193
TRACEY A. YOKICH ........................................................ 201917. GEORGE S. BUTH............................................................ 2017
PAUL J. DENEFELD......................................................... 2017KATHLEEN A. FEENEY.................................................. 2015DONALD A. JOHNSTON, III........................................... 2019DENNIS B. LEIBER.......................................................... 2019JAMES ROBERT REDFORD............................................ 2017PAUL J. SULLIVAN .......................................................... 2015MARK A. TRUSOCK......................................................... 2019CHRISTOPHER P. YATES................................................ 2019DANIEL V. ZEMAITIS ...................................................... 2015
18. HARRY P. GILL.................................................................. 2017KENNETH W. SCHMIDT ................................................. 2019JOSEPH K. SHEERAN..................................................... 2015
19. JAMES M. BATZER........................................................... 201520. KENT D. ENGLE .............................................................. 2017
JON H. HULSING............................................................. 2015EDWARD R. POST ............................................................ 2017JON VAN ALLSBURG ...................................................... 2019
21. PAUL H. CHAMBERLAIN................................................ 2017MARK H. DUTHIE............................................................ 2019
22. ARCHIE CAMERON BROWN.......................................... 2017TIMOTHY P. CONNORS................................................... 2019MELINDA MORRIS .......................................................... 2013DONALD E. SHELTON .................................................... 2015DAVID S. SWARTZ ............................................................ 2015
23. RONALD M. BERGERON ................................................ 2015WILLIAM F. MYLES.......................................................... 2017
24. DONALD A. TEEPLE ....................................................... 201525. JENNIFER MAZZUCHI.................................................... 2015
THOMAS L. SOLKA.......................................................... 201726. MICHAEL G. MACK ......................................................... 2015
2 From July 23, 2013.3 To July 23, 2013.
viii
TERM EXPIRESJANUARY 1 OF
27. ANTHONY A. MONTON.................................................. 2019TERRENCE R. THOMAS ................................................. 2015
28. WILLIAM M. FAGERMAN ............................................... 201529. MICHELLE M. RICK ........................................................ 2017
RANDY L. TAHVONEN.................................................... 201530. ROSEMARIE ELIZABETH AQUILINA .......................... 2015
LAURA BAIRD................................................................... 2019CLINTON CANADY, III .................................................... 2017WILLIAM E. COLLETTE ................................................. 2015JOYCE DRAGANCHUK.................................................... 2017JANELLE A. LAWLESS.................................................... 2015PAULA J.M. MANDERFIELD .......................................... 2013
31. JAMES P. ADAIR ............................................................... 2013DANIEL J. KELLY............................................................. 2015CYNTHIA A. LANE........................................................... 2017
32. ROY D. GOTHAM.............................................................. 201533. RICHARD M. PAJTAS....................................................... 201534. MICHAEL J. BAUMGARTNER........................................ 201735. GERALD D. LOSTRACCO................................................ 201536. KATHLEEN BRICKLEY................................................... 2019
PAUL E. HAMRE............................................................... 20154
37. ALLEN L. GARBRECHT .................................................. 20175
JAMES C. KINGSLEY....................................................... 2015BRIAN KIRKHAM............................................................. 20176
STEPHEN B. MILLER...................................................... 2017CONRAD J. SINDT ........................................................... 2019
38. JOSEPH A. COSTELLO, JR. ............................................ 2015MICHAEL W. LABEAU...................................................... 2019MICHAEL A. WEIPERT ................................................... 2017DANIEL WHITE................................................................ 2015
39. MARGARET MURRAY-SCHOLZE NOE ......................... 2015TIMOTHY P. PICKARD .................................................... 2019
40. NICK O. HOLOWKA ......................................................... 2017BYRON KONSCHUH........................................................ 2015
41. MARY BROUILLETTE BARGLIND................................ 2017RICHARD J. CELELLO .................................................... 2015
42. MICHAEL J. BEALE ......................................................... 2015STEPHEN CARRAS .......................................................... 20137
4 To August 2, 2013.5 To July 19, 2013.6 From July 19, 2013.7 From July 1, 2013.
ix
TERM EXPIRESJANUARY 1 OF
43. MICHAEL E. DODGE....................................................... 201744. MICHAEL P. HATTY......................................................... 2019
DAVID READER................................................................ 201745. PAUL E. STUTESMAN..................................................... 201946. JANET M. ALLEN............................................................. 2011
GEORGE J. MERTZ .......................................................... 201547. STEPHEN T. DAVIS.......................................................... 201748. MARGARET BAKKER...................................................... 2017
KEVIN W. CRONIN........................................................... 201549. SCOTT P. HILL-KENNEDY ............................................. 2019
RONALD C. NICHOLS ..................................................... 201550. NICHOLAS J. LAMBROS ................................................. 201351. RICHARD I. COOPER ...................................................... 201552. M. RICHARD KNOBLOCK............................................... 201553. SCOTT LEE PAVLICH...................................................... 201754. AMY GIERHART ............................................................... 2019
PATRICK REED JOSLYN................................................. 201355. THOMAS R. EVANS.......................................................... 2015
ROY G. MIENK.................................................................. 201956. THOMAS S. EVELAND .................................................... 2013
CALVIN E. OSTERHAVEN .............................................. 201557. CHARLES W. JOHNSON.................................................. 2019
x
DISTRICT JUDGES
TERM EXPIRESJANUARY 1 OF
1. MARK S. BRAUNLICH...................................................... 2015TERRENCE P. BRONSON................................................. 2019JACK VITALE..................................................................... 2017
2A. LAURA J. SCHAEDLER .................................................... 2017JAMES E. SHERIDAN....................................................... 2015
2B. DONALD L. SANDERSON................................................ 20153A. BRENT R. WEIGLE ........................................................... 20153B. JEFFREY C. MIDDLETON ............................................... 2015
WILLIAM D. WELTY ......................................................... 20134. STACEY A. RENTFROW................................................... 20155. GARY J. BRUCE ................................................................. 2017
ANGELA PASULA.............................................................. 2015SCOTT SCHOFIELD.......................................................... 2015STERLING R. SCHROCK ................................................. 2019DENNIS M. WILEY............................................................ 2017
7. ARTHUR H. CLARKE, III ................................................. 2015ROBERT T. HENTCHEL................................................... 2017
8-1. ANNE E. BLATCHFORD .................................................. 2019PAUL J. BRIDENSTINE.................................................... 2019CAROL A. HUSUM ............................................................ 2017
8-2. ROBERT C. KROPF ........................................................... 20158-3. RICHARD A. SANTONI..................................................... 2015
VINCENT C. WESTRA ...................................................... 201710. SAMUEL I. DURHAM, JR. ................................................ 2017
JOHN A. HALLACY........................................................... 2015JOHN R. HOLMES ............................................................ 2019FRANKLIN K. LINE, JR. .................................................. 2015
12. JOSEPH S. FILIP............................................................... 2017DANIEL GOOSTREY......................................................... 2013JAMES M. JUSTIN ............................................................ 2013MICHAEL J. KLAEREN .................................................... 2015R. DARRYL MAZUR........................................................... 2015
14A. RICHARD E. CONLIN....................................................... 2015J. CEDRIC SIMPSON......................................................... 2019KIRK W. TABBEY............................................................... 2017
14B. CHARLES POPE ................................................................ 201515. JULIE CREAL..................................................................... 2013
xi
TERM EXPIRESJANUARY 1 OF
CHRISTOPHER S. EASTHOPE ....................................... 2015ELIZABETH POLLARD HINES....................................... 2017
16. SEAN P. KAVANAGH ......................................................... 2015KATHLEEN J. MCCANN ................................................... 2019
17. KAREN KHALIL ................................................................ 2017CHARLOTTE L. WIRTH ................................................... 2015
18. SANDRA A. CICIRELLI..................................................... 2019MARK A. MCCONNELL .................................................... 2015
19. WILLIAM C. HULTGREN ................................................. 2017MARK W. SOMERS ............................................................ 2015RICHARD WYGONIK ........................................................ 2013
20. MARK J. PLAWECKI ......................................................... 2015DAVID TURFE.................................................................... 2019
21. RICHARD L. HAMMER, JR. ............................................. 201522. SABRINA JOHNSON......................................................... 201323. GENO SALOMONE ........................................................... 2019
WILLIAM J. SUTHERLAND............................................. 201524. JOHN T. COURTRIGHT.................................................... 2015
RICHARD A. PAGE............................................................ 201725. DAVID A. BAJOREK.......................................................... 2015
DAVID J. ZELENAK........................................................... 201726. MICHAEL F. CIUNGAN .................................................... 201527. RANDY L. KALMBACH..................................................... 201928. JAMES A. KANDREVAS.................................................... 201529. LAURA REDMOND MACK............................................... 201930. BRIGETTE R. OFFICER ................................................... 201731. PAUL J. PARUK.................................................................. 2015
32A. ROGER J. LA ROSE............................................................ 201533. JENNIFER COLEMAN HESSON .................................... 2017
JAMES KURT KERSTEN.................................................. 2015MICHAEL K. MCNALLY.................................................... 2019
34. TINA BROOKS GREEN .................................................... 2019BRIAN A. OAKLEY............................................................ 2017DAVID M. PARROTT ......................................................... 2015
35. MICHAEL J. GEROU......................................................... 2017RONALD W. LOWE ............................................................ 2019JAMES A. PLAKAS ............................................................ 2015
36. LYDIA NANCE ADAMS..................................................... 2017ROBERTA C. ARCHER...................................................... 2019MARYLIN E. ATKINS........................................................ 2013JOSEPH N. BALTIMORE.................................................. 2015NANCY MCCAUGHAN BLOUNT..................................... 2015IZETTA F. BRIGHT............................................................ 2017ESTHER LYNISE BRYANT-WEEKES.............................. 2015RUTH C. CARTER ............................................................. 2017DONALD COLEMAN......................................................... 2019PRENTIS EDWARDS, JR. ................................................. 2019DEBORAH GERALDINE FORD....................................... 2017RUTH ANN GARRETT ..................................................... 2019
xii
TERM EXPIRESJANUARY 1 OF
RONALD GILES................................................................. 2015KATHERINE HANSEN ..................................................... 2017SHANNON A. HOLMES.................................................... 2015PAULA G. HUMPHRIES ................................................... 2017PATRICIA L. JEFFERSON................................................ 2015VANESA F. JONES-BRADLEY ......................................... 2013KENNETH J. KING ........................................................... 2015DEBORAH L. LANGSTON ............................................... 2019DEMETRIA BRUE ............................................................ 2015LEONIA J. LLOYD............................................................. 2017MIRIAM B. MARTIN-CLARK ........................................... 2017WILLIAM MCCONICO ....................................................... 2019DONNA R. MILHOUSE..................................................... 2019B. PENNIE MILLENDER ................................................. 2017CYLENTHIA L. MILLER .................................................. 2017KEVIN F. ROBBINS ........................................................... 2019DAVID S. ROBINSON, JR. ................................................ 2019BRENDA KAREN SANDERS............................................ 2015MICHAEL E. WAGNER..................................................... 2015
37. DEAN AUSILIO.................................................................. 2017JOHN M. CHMURA ........................................................... 2019JENNIFER FAUNCE ......................................................... 2015DAWNN M. GRUENBURG ............................................... 2017MATTHEW P. SABAUGH .................................................. 2013
38. CARL F. GERDS III ............................................................ 201539. JOSEPH F. BOEDEKER.................................................... 2015
MARCO A. SANTIA ........................................................... 2019CATHERINE B. STEENLAND ......................................... 2017
40. MARK A. FRATARCANGELI ............................................ 2019JOSEPH CRAIGEN OSTER.............................................. 2015
41A. MICHAEL S. MACERONI ................................................. 2015DOUGLAS P. SHEPHERD................................................. 2019STEPHEN S. SIERAWSKI ................................................ 2017KIMBERLEY ANNE WIEGAND....................................... 2019
41B. LINDA DAVIS ..................................................................... 2015CARRIE LYNN FUCA ........................................................ 2017SEBASTIAN LUCIDO........................................................ 2019
42-1. DENIS R. LEDUC ............................................................... 201542-2. WILLIAM H. HACKELL III .............................................. 2019
43. CHARLES G. GOEDERT................................................... 2015KEITH P. HUNT................................................................. 2019JOSEPH LONGO................................................................ 2017
44. TERRENCE H. BRENNAN............................................... 2015DANIEL SAWICKI ............................................................. 2013
45A. JAMES L. WITTENBERG ................................................. 201545B. MICHELLE FRIEDMAN APPEL ..................................... 2015
DAVID M. GUBOW ............................................................ 201546. SHEILA R. JOHNSON....................................................... 2015
SUSAN M. MOISEEV ........................................................ 2013xiii
TERM EXPIRESJANUARY 1 OF
WILLIAM J. RICHARDS.................................................... 201747. JAMES BRADY ................................................................... 2015
MARLA E. PARKER........................................................... 201748. MARC BARRON ................................................................. 2017
DIANE D’AGOSTINI ......................................................... 2019KIMBERLY SMALL............................................................ 2015
50. RONDA FOWLKES GROSS .............................................. 2019MICHAEL C. MARTINEZ.................................................. 2015PRESTON G. THOMAS..................................................... 2017CYNTHIA THOMAS WALKER......................................... 2015
51. JODI R. DEBBRECHT SWITALSKI................................. 2019RICHARD D. KUHN, JR. ................................................... 2015
52-1. ROBERT BONDY ............................................................... 2019BRIAN W. MACKENZIE...................................................... 2015DENNIS N. POWERS ........................................................ 2017
52-2. JOSEPH G. FABRIZIO....................................................... 2015KELLEY RENAE KOSTIN................................................ 2017
52-3. LISA L. ASADOORIAN...................................................... 2019NANCY TOLWIN CARNIAK............................................. 2017JULIE A. NICHOLSON ..................................................... 2015
52-4. WILLIAM E. BOLLE.......................................................... 2015DENNIS C. DRURY............................................................ 2013KIRSTEN NIELSEN HARTIG.......................................... 2017
53. THERESA M. BRENNAN ................................................. 2015L. SUZANNE GEDDIS....................................................... 2017CAROL SUE READER....................................................... 2019
54A. LOUISE ALDERSON ......................................................... 2017PATRICK F. CHERRY ........................................................ 2015FRANK J. DELUCA ............................................................ 2019CHARLES F. FILICE.......................................................... 2015
54B. RICHARD D. BALL ............................................................ 2017DAVID L. JORDON ............................................................ 2013
55. DONALD L. ALLEN........................................................... 2017THOMAS P. BOYD.............................................................. 2015
56A. HARVEY J. HOFFMAN ..................................................... 2017JULIE H. REINCKE .......................................................... 2015
56B. MICHAEL LEE SCHIPPER .............................................. 201957. WILLIAM A. BAILLARGEON........................................... 2019
JOSEPH S. SKOCELAS..................................................... 201558. SUSAN A. JONAS .............................................................. 2015
RICHARD J. KLOOTE....................................................... 2013BRADLEY S. KNOLL......................................................... 2015KENNETH D. POST.......................................................... 2017
59. PETER P. VERSLUIS......................................................... 201760. HAROLD F. CLOSZ, III...................................................... 2015
MARIA LADAS HOOPES .................................................. 2015MICHAEL JEFFREY NOLAN .......................................... 2019ANDREW WIERENGO ...................................................... 2017
61. DAVID J. BUTER................................................................ 2015xiv
TERM EXPIRESJANUARY 1 OF
J. MICHAEL CHRISTENSEN........................................... 2017JEANINE NEMESI LAVILLE ........................................... 2019BEN H. LOGAN, II............................................................. 2019DONALD H. PASSENGER ................................................ 2017KIMBERLY A. SCHAEFER ............................................... 2015
62A. PABLO CORTES................................................................. 2015STEVEN M. TIMMERS ..................................................... 2019
62B. WILLIAM G. KELLY .......................................................... 201563-1. STEVEN R. SERVAAS ....................................................... 201563-2. SARA J. SMOLENSKI........................................................ 201564A. RAYMOND P. VOET........................................................... 201564B. DONALD R. HEMINGSEN ............................................... 201565A. RICHARD D. WELLS......................................................... 201565B. STEWART D. MCDONALD................................................ 2015
66. WARD L. CLARKSON........................................................ 2019TERRANCE P. DIGNAN .................................................... 2015
67-1. DAVID J. GOGGINS........................................................... 201567-2. JOHN L. CONOVER .......................................................... 2015
MARK W. LATCHANA ....................................................... 201767-3. LARRY STECCO................................................................. 201567-4. MARK C. MCCABE ............................................................. 2015
CHRISTOPHER ODETTE................................................. 201968. TRACY L. COLLIER-NIX .................................................. 2015
WILLIAM H. CRAWFORD, II ........................................... 2019MARY CATHERINE DOWD.............................................. 2017HERMAN MARABLE, JR. ................................................. 2019NATHANIEL C. PERRY, III .............................................. 2015
70-1. TERRY L. CLARK .............................................................. 2019M. RANDALL JURRENS................................................... 2017M. T. THOMPSON, JR. ...................................................... 2015
70-2. CHRISTOPHER S. BOYD ................................................. 2017ALFRED T. FRANK............................................................ 2015KYLE HIGGS TARRANT .................................................. 2019
71A. LAURA CHEGER BARNARD ........................................... 2015JOHN T. CONNOLLY ........................................................ 2013
71B. KIM DAVID GLASPIE ....................................................... 201572. MICHAEL L. HULEWICZ ................................................. 2017
JOHN D. MONAGHAN...................................................... 2019CYNTHIA SIEMEN PLATZER ......................................... 2015
73A. GREGORY S. ROSS............................................................ 201573B. DAVID B. HERRINGTON ................................................. 2015
74. MARK E. JANER................................................................ 2015TIMOTHY J. KELLY .......................................................... 2013DAWN A. KILDA ................................................................ 2015
75. STEVEN CARRAS.............................................................. 2017JOHN HENRY HART ........................................................ 2015
76. WILLIAM R. RUSH............................................................ 201577. SUSAN H. GRANT............................................................. 201578. H. KEVIN DRAKE ............................................................. 2015
xv
TERM EXPIRESJANUARY 1 OF
79. PETER J. WADEL .............................................................. 201580. JOSHUA M. FARRELL ...................................................... 201581. ALLEN C. YENIOR ............................................................ 201582. RICHARD E. NOBLE......................................................... 201583. DANIEL L. SUTTON ......................................................... 201584. DAVID A. HOGG ................................................................ 201585. BRENT V. DANIELSON .................................................... 201586. MICHAEL J. HALEY.......................................................... 2015
THOMAS J. PHILLIPS ...................................................... 2013MICHAEL STEPKA ........................................................... 2017
87. PATRICIA A. MORSE ........................................................ 201588. THEODORE O. JOHNSON............................................... 201589. MARIA L. BARTON ........................................................... 201590. RICHARD W. MAY.............................................................. 201591. ELIZABETH BIOLETTE CHURCH................................. 201592. BETH GIBSON................................................................... 201593. MARK E. LUOMA .............................................................. 200994. GLENN A. PEARSON........................................................ 2015
95A. JEFFREY G. BARSTOW.................................................... 201595B. CHRISTOPHER S. NINOMIYA ........................................ 2015
96. DENNIS H. GIRARD ......................................................... 2017ROGER W. KANGAS .......................................................... 2015
97. MARK A. WISTI ................................................................. 201598. ANDERS B. TINGSTAD, JR. ............................................ 2015
xvi
MUNICIPAL JUDGES
TERM EXPIRESJANUARY 1 OF
RUSSELL F. ETHRIDGE....................................................... 2012CARL F. JARBOE ................................................................... 2014THEODORE A. METRY ........................................................ 2011MATTHEW R. RUMORA....................................................... 2014
xvii
PROBATE JUDGES
TERM EXPIRESCOUNTY JANUARY 1 OFAlcona .......................LAURA A. FRAWLEY .............................. 2019Alger/Schoolcraft ......CHARLES C. NEBEL............................... 2019Allegan ......................MICHAEL L. BUCK................................. 2019Alpena .......................THOMAS J. LACROSS ............................. 2019Antrim.......................NORMAN R. HAYES................................ 2019Arenac .......................RICHARD E. VOLLBACH, JR. ................ 2019Baraga.......................TIMOTHY S. BRENNAN ........................ 2019Barry .........................WILLIAM M. DOHERTY......................... 2013Bay ............................KAREN TIGHE ........................................ 2013Benzie........................NANCY A. KIDA....................................... 2013Berrien ......................MABEL JOHNSON MAYFIELD............. 2015Berrien ......................THOMAS E. NELSON............................. 2019Branch.......................FREDERICK L. WOOD ........................... 2013Calhoun.....................MICHAEL L. JACONETTE..................... 2017Cass ...........................SUSAN L. DOBRICH ............................... 2019Cheboygan ................ROBERT JOHN BUTTS.......................... 2019Chippewa ......................................................................................Clare/Gladwin...........THOMAS P. McLAUGHLIN .................... 2019Clinton ......................LISA SULLIVAN....................................... 2019Crawford ...................MONTE BURMEISTER........................... 2019Delta..........................ROBERT E. GOEBEL, JR. ....................... 2019Dickinson ..................THOMAS D. SLAGLE.............................. 2019Eaton.........................THOMAS K. BYERLEY ........................... 2019Emmet/Charlevoix ...FREDERICK R. MULHAUSER .............. 2019Genesee .....................JENNIE E. BARKEY ............................... 2015Genesee .....................F. KAY BEHM ........................................... 2019Gogebic......................JOEL L. MASSIE...................................... 2019Grand Traverse ........DAVID L. STOWE .................................... 2013Gratiot.......................JACK T. ARNOLD .................................... 2013Hillsdale ....................MICHAEL E. NYE.................................... 2013Houghton ..................FRASER T. STROME............................... 2019Huron........................DAVID L. CLABUESCH .......................... 2019Ingham......................R. GEORGE ECONOMY.......................... 2019
xviii
Ingham......................RICHARD JOSEPH GARCIA.................. 2015Ionia ..........................ROBERT SYKES, JR................................. 2019Iosco ..........................JOHN D. HAMILTON.............................. 2013Iron............................C. JOSEPH SCHWEDLER ...................... 2019Isabella......................WILLIAM T. ERVIN ................................. 2019Jackson .....................DIANE M. RAPPLEYE ............................ 2019Kalamazoo ................CURTIS J. BELL, JR................................. 2019Kalamazoo ................PATRICIA N. CONLON ........................... 2017Kalamazoo ................DONALD R. HALSTEAD ........................ 20151
Kalkaska ...................LYNNE MARIE BUDAY .......................... 2019Kent...........................NANARUTH H. CARPENTER ............... 2017Kent...........................PATRICIA D. GARDNER......................... 2019Kent...........................G. PATRICK HILLARY ............................ 2019Kent...........................DAVID M. MURKOWSKI ........................ 2015Kent...........................GEORGE JAY QUIST .............................. 2017Keweenaw.................JAMES G. JAASKELAINEN ................... 2019Lake...........................MARK S. WICKENS................................. 2019Lapeer .......................JUSTUS C. SCOTT .................................. 2019Leelanau ...................LARRY J. NELSON .................................. 2019Lenawee ....................GREGG P. IDDINGS ................................ 2019Livingston.................CAROL HACKETT GARAGIOLA........... 2013Luce/Mackinac..........W. CLAYTON GRAHAM .......................... 2019Macomb.....................KATHRYN A. GEORGE........................... 2015Macomb.....................PAMELA GILBERT O’SULLIVAN ......... 2013Manistee....................THOMAS N. BRUNNER.......................... 2019Marquette .................MICHAEL J. ANDEREGG....................... 2013Mason........................MARK D. RAVEN ..................................... 2013Mecosta/Osceola .......MARCO S. MENEZES.............................. 2019Menominee ...............WILLIAM A. HUPY.................................. 2019Midland.....................DORENE S. ALLEN................................. 2019Missaukee .................CHARLES R. PARSONS .......................... 2019Monroe ......................JOHN A. HOHMAN, JR. .......................... 2019Montcalm..................CHARLES W. SIMON, III ........................ 2019Montmorency............JOHN E. FITZGERALD .......................... 2013Muskegon..................NEIL G. MULLALLY ............................... 2017Muskegon..................GREGORY C. PITTMAN ......................... 2019Newaygo....................GRAYDON W. DIMKOFF ........................ 2019Oakland.....................LINDA S. HALLMARK ............................ 2019Oakland.....................DANIEL A. O’BRIEN............................... 2015Oakland.....................ELIZABETH M. PEZZETTI .................... 2017Oakland.....................KATHLEEN A. RYAN .............................. 2017Oceana ......................BRADLEY G. LAMBRIX.......................... 2019Ogemaw ....................SHANA A. LAMBOURN.......................... 2019
1 To July 17, 2013.
xix
Ontonagon ................JANIS M. BURGESS................................ 2019Oscoda.......................KATHRYN JOAN ROOT ......................... 2019Otsego .......................MICHAEL K. COOPER ........................... 2019Ottawa ......................MARK A. FEYEN ..................................... 2019Presque Isle ..............DONALD J. MCLENNAN ........................ 2019Roscommon ..............DOUGLAS C. DOSSON ........................... 2019Saginaw.....................FAYE M. HARRISON ............................... 2015Saginaw.....................PATRICK J. MCGRAW.............................. 2019St. Clair.....................ELWOOD L. BROWN............................... 2015St. Clair.....................JOHN TOMLINSON................................ 2019St. Joseph .................THOMAS E. SHUMAKER....................... 2013Sanilac.......................R. TERRY MALTBY ................................. 2013Sanilac.......................GREGORY S. ROSS.................................. 2015Shiawassee................JAMES R. CLATTERBAUGH ................. 2013Tuscola......................W. WALLACE KENT, JR........................... 2013Van Buren.................FRANK D. WILLIS................................... 2019Washtenaw................NANCY CORNELIA WHEELER ............ 2015Washtenaw................DARLENE A. O’BRIEN........................... 2019Wayne........................JUNE E. BLACKWELL-HATCHER ....... 2019Wayne........................FREDDIE G. BURTON, JR. ..................... 2019Wayne........................JUDY A. HARTSFIELD ........................... 2015Wayne........................MILTON L. MACK, JR. ............................ 2017Wayne........................MARTIN T. MAHER................................. 2015Wayne........................LISA MARIE NEILSON .......................... 2017Wayne........................FRANK S. SZYMANSKI .......................... 2019Wexford .....................KENNETH L. TACOMA.......................... 2019
xx
JUDICIAL CIRCUITS
County Seat Circuit
Alcona....................Harrisville ......... 26Alger......................Munising ........... 11Allegan ..................Allegan............... 48Alpena ...................Alpena................ 26Antrim...................Bellaire .............. 13Arenac ...................Standish ............ 34
Baraga ...................L’Anse................ 12Barry .....................Hastings ............ 5Bay.........................Bay City............. 18Benzie....................Beulah ............... 19Berrien ..................St. Joseph.......... 2Branch...................Coldwater .......... 15
Calhoun.................Marshall, BattleCreek................ 37
Cass .......................Cassopolis .......... 43Charlevoix.............Charlevoix ......... 33Cheboygan ............Cheboygan......... 53Chippewa ..............Sault Ste. Marie. 50Clare ......................Harrison ............ 55Clinton ..................St. Johns............ 29Crawford ...............Grayling............. 46
Delta......................Escanaba ........... 47Dickinson ..............Iron Mountain .. 41
Eaton.....................Charlotte ........... 5Emmet...................Petoskey ............ 33
Genesee .................Flint ................... 7Gladwin.................Gladwin ............. 55Gogebic..................Bessemer ........... 32Grand Traverse ....Traverse City .... 13Gratiot...................Ithaca................. 29
Hillsdale ................Hillsdale ............ 1Houghton ..............Houghton .......... 12Huron....................Bad Axe ............. 52
Ingham..................Mason, Lansing. 30Ionia ......................Ionia................... 8Iosco ......................Tawas City ........ 23Iron........................Crystal Falls ...... 41Isabella ..................Mount Pleasant. 21
Jackson..................Jackson.............. 4
Kalamazoo ............Kalamazoo......... 9Kalkaska ...............Kalkaska............ 46Kent.......................Grand Rapids .... 17Keweenaw .............Eagle River........ 12
County Seat Circuit
Lake ................Baldwin ................. 51Lapeer .............Lapeer ................... 40Leelanau .........Leland ................... 13Lenawee..........Adrian ................... 39Livingston.......Howell ................... 44Luce.................Newberry .............. 11
Mackinac.........St. Ignace .............. 50Macomb...........Mount Clemens .... 16Manistee .........Manistee................ 19Marquette .......Marquette ............. 25Mason..............Ludington ............. 51Mecosta ...........Big Rapids............. 49Menominee .....Menominee ........... 41Midland...........Midland ................. 42Missaukee .......Lake City .............. 28Monroe............Monroe .................. 38Montcalm........Stanton.................. 8Montmorency .Atlanta .................. 26Muskegon .......Muskegon.............. 14
Newaygo .........White Cloud.......... 27
Oakland ..........Pontiac .................. 6Oceana ............Hart ....................... 27Ogemaw ..........West Branch.......... 34Ontonagon ......Ontonagon ............ 32Osceola............Reed City .............. 49Oscoda.............Mio......................... 23Otsego .............Gaylord.................. 46Ottawa ............Grand Haven ........ 20
Presque Isle....Rogers City ........... 26
Roscommon ....Roscommon........... 34
Saginaw...........Saginaw................. 10St. Clair ..........Port Huron ........... 31St. Joseph .......Centreville............. 45Sanilac.............Sandusky............... 24Schoolcraft......Manistique ............ 11Shiawassee......Corunna ................ 35
Tuscola............Caro ....................... 54
Van Buren.......Paw Paw................ 36
Washtenaw......Ann Arbor............. 22Wayne..............Detroit ................... 3Wexford ...........Cadillac.................. 28
xxi
TABLE OF CASES REPORTED
(Lines set in small type refer to orders entered in cases starting at page 851.)
PAGE
AAFSCME Council 25 Locals 411 & 893,
Macomb County v ............................................ 65Acorn Investment Co v Michigan Basic Property Ins
Ass’n .................................................................................. 863Acosta, People v ..................................................................... 865Adair v State of Michigan ..................................................... 852Adams v Bretton Woods Condo Ass’n, Inc .......................... 869
Adams, In re ......................................................... 162Adkins, People v .................................................................... 869
Admire v Auto-Owners Ins Co ........................... 10Admire v Auto-Owners Ins Co ............................................. 880Ahrens Construction, Inc, Miller-Davis Co v ...................... 861Al-Saady, People v .................................................................. 884Aleksanyan, People v ............................................................. 865Alexander, People v ............................................................... 876Allan, People v (David) ......................................................... 863Allan, People v (Richard) ...................................................... 857Allen, People v ....................................................................... 881Altoonian, People v ................................................................ 882American International Group, Mohney v .......................... 866Anderson v Davis ................................................................... 856Anderson, People v ................................................................ 855Andre, People v ...................................................................... 858Andree, People v .................................................................... 870
xxiii
PAGE
Anheuser-Busch, Inc v Dep’t of Treasury ........................... 886Annon, People v ..................................................................... 882Armstrong, People v .............................................................. 859Ashley Ann Arbor, LLC v Pittsfield Charter Twp ....... 875, 879Atek Thermoforming, Inc, Summit Polymers, Inc v .......... 884Attorney Grievance Comm, Beauchemin v ......................... 858Attorney Grievance Comm, Benton v .................................. 858Attorney Grievance Comm, Burgess v .......................... 858, 873Attorney Grievance Comm, English v ................................. 872Attorney Grievance Comm, Goodman v .............................. 885Attorney Grievance Comm, Knight v .................................. 858Attorney Grievance Comm, Ross v ...................................... 858Attorney Grievance Comm, Wade-Knight v ........................ 858Attorney Grievance Comm, Xiong v .................................... 885Attorney Grievance Comm, Young v .................................... 885Austin, People v ..................................................................... 882Auto Club Ins Ass’n, Harris v ............................ 462Auto-Owners Ins Co v Tax Connection Worldwide, LLC ... 864Auto-Owners Ins Co, Admire v .......................... 10Auto-Owners Ins Co, Admire v ............................................ 880Auto-Owners Ins Co, Dezaak Management, Inc v .............. 873Automobile Club Ins Ass’n v State Farm
Mutual Automobile Ins Co .............................. 475Ayers, People v ....................................................................... 871
BBailey v Schaaf ..................................................... 595Bailey, People v (Mark) ......................................................... 868Bailey, People v (Terrance) ................................................... 882Bajju v State Farm Mutual Automobile Ins Co .................. 883Baker, People v (Andrew) ..................................................... 868Baker, People v (Joseph) ....................................................... 881Bally Total Fitness of the Midwest, Inc, Bonner v ............. 859Bank of New York Mellon v Brezzell ................................... 856Bank of New York Mellon, Karaus v ................................... 883Banks, People v ...................................................................... 883Barrow v Detroit Election Comm ........................................ 866Battles v Battles .................................................................... 857Beauchemin v Attorney Grievance Comm .......................... 858
xxiv 494 MICH REPORTS
PAGE
Beckom, People v.................................................................... 871Beebe, People v ...................................................................... 870Beecher Metropolitan Dist, Wurtz v .................................... 862Benavides, Mackey v ............................................................. 879Bennett, People v ................................................................... 870Benson v Boyle ...................................................................... 883Benton v Attorney Grievance Comm ................................... 858Besok, In re ............................................................................ 879Bickham, People v ................................................................. 860Birge, People v ....................................................................... 855Blackmun, People v ............................................................... 871Blackwell, People v ................................................................ 869Blair Twp, Cherryland Electric Cooperative v .................... 851Bloomfield Hills (The City of) v Froling ............................. 858Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan, Segars v .................... 866Board of Law Examiners, Copas v ....................................... 858Board of Manistee County Rd Comm’rs, Hagerty v ........... 885Bodiford, People v .................................................................. 870Boggs, Citizens Bank v ......................................................... 883Bojaj, People v ........................................................................ 883Bologna, People v .................................................................. 865Bomar, People v ..................................................................... 855Bonner v Bally Total Fitness of the Midwest, Inc .............. 859Bonner v City of Brighton .................................................... 873Booker, Kenney v ................................................................... 852Borom, People v ..................................................................... 859Bowling, People v .................................................................. 884Bowman, People v ................................................................. 851Boykins, People v ................................................................... 855Boyle, Benson v ..................................................................... 883Boynton, In re ........................................................................ 852Bradford, People v ................................................................. 868Bradley Estate, In re ........................................... 367Bretton Woods Condo Ass’n, Inc, Adams v ......................... 869Brezzell, Bank of New York Mellon v .................................. 856Brighton (City of), Bonner v ................................................ 873Bronson Methodist Hospital, Ware v ................................... 880Brookins, People v ................................................................. 871Brown, People v (James) ....................................................... 884
TABLE OF CASES REPORTED xxv
PAGE
Brown, People v (Rodell) ...................................................... 853Brown, People v (Simmion) .................................................. 884Brown, People v (Terry) ........................................................ 885Bryant, People v .................................................................... 858Brzezinski, People v .............................................................. 854Buchanan, People v (Jan-James) ......................................... 881Buchanan, People v (Kevin) ................................................. 881Buie, People v ........................................................................ 854Bull, People v ......................................................................... 857Bullard, People v ................................................................... 869Burgess v Attorney Grievance Comm ........................... 858, 873Burgess v Peoples Trust Credit Union ................................ 870Burks, People v ...................................................................... 884Burlew, People v .................................................................... 857Burns, People v .................................................... 104Burton v Macha ..................................................................... 864Butler, People v ...................................................................... 869
CCannon, People v ................................................................... 872Capitol Ins Corp v Consumers Energy Co .......................... 870Carboloy, Inc, Olewin v ......................................................... 884Carlton, People v ................................................................... 868Carson v Home-Owners Ins Co ............................................ 859Carter, People v ..................................................................... 858Castleberry, People v ............................................................. 881Cavin, People v ...................................................................... 884Chenault, People v ................................................................. 862Cherryland Electric Cooperative v Blair Twp ..................... 851Chichewicz v Salesin ............................................................. 873Chrostowski, Gray v .............................................................. 860Chukwueke, Farm Bureau Ins Co v ..................................... 857CitiGroup Global Markets Realty Corp v Schmitz ............. 854Citizens Bank v Boggs .......................................................... 883Citizens Ins Co, Gagnon v .................................................... 883Citizens United Against Corrupt Government v City of
Detroit Financial Review Team ....................................... 858City of Bloomfield Hills (The) v Froling ............................. 858City of Brighton, Bonner v ................................................... 873
xxvi 494 MICH REPORTS
PAGE
City of Detroit, Tatarian v .................................................... 869City of Detroit Financial Review Team, Citizens United
Against Corrupt Government v ....................................... 858City of Flint, Landon v ......................................................... 872City of Flint, Watts v ............................................................ 857City of Lansing v Rapp ......................................................... 856City of Lansing, Remsing v .................................................. 883City of Oak Park, Congregation Mishkan Israel Nusach
H’Ari v ............................................................................... 870City of Romulus, Pirate Logistics, Inc v .............................. 857Civil Service Comm, Robinson v .......................................... 869Clark, People v (Delandrick) ................................................ 868Clark, People v (Sean) ........................................................... 855Clary, People v ...................................................... 260Clay, People v ......................................................................... 855Clohset v No Name Corp ...................................................... 874Coca-Cola Enterprises, Scharnitzke v ................................. 886Coleman, People v (Davontral) ............................................. 875Coleman, People v (Tommie) ................................................ 882Colston, People v ................................................................... 857Community Health (Dep’t of), Ware v ................................. 884Congregation Mishkan Israel Nusach H’Ari v City of Oak
Park ................................................................................... 870Conklin, People v ................................................................... 884Conley, People v ..................................................................... 852Connections for Deaf Citizens, Inc, Detroit Public
Schools v ............................................................................ 885Consumers Energy Co, Capitol Ins Corp v ......................... 870Coone, People v ...................................................................... 869Cooper, People v ..................................................................... 867Copas v Board of Law Examiners ........................................ 858Cornell, People v .................................................................... 858Corrections (Dep’t of), Green v ............................................ 886Corrections (Dep’t of), Pillette v .......................................... 855Corrections (Dep’t of), Sweezer v ........................................ 855Corrections (Dep’t of), Uncapher v ...................................... 883Corrion, People v ................................................................... 868Coss, People v ........................................................................ 856Craig, People v ....................................................................... 868
TABLE OF CASES REPORTED xxvii
PAGE
Crane v Director of Assessing for the Charter Twp ofWest Bloomfield ................................................................ 872
Crawford, People v ................................................................ 854Cromer, People v .................................................................... 871Cromie v Cromie .................................................................... 858Cronin, People v .................................................................... 867Cross, People v ....................................................................... 857Croton, People v .................................................................... 869
DDalton, People v ..................................................................... 871Danielak, People v ................................................................. 852Daniels, People v ................................................................... 860Davenport, People v .............................................................. 875Davis, Anderson v .................................................................. 856Davis, People v (David) ......................................................... 868Davis, People v (Michael) ...................................................... 881Davis, People v (Ronie) ......................................................... 870Davis, People v (Toby) ........................................................... 871Davis v Wayne County Airport Authority ........................... 885Davison Twp Bd of Trustees, Riddle v ................................ 870Dawson, People v ................................................................... 858Delgado, People v ................................................................... 884Dennis, People v .................................................................... 869Dep’t of Community Health, Ware v ................................... 884Dep’t of Corrections, Green v .............................................. 886Dep’t of Corrections, Pillette v ............................................. 855Dep’t of Corrections, Sweezer v ........................................... 855Dep’t of Corrections, Uncapher v ........................................ 883Dep’t of Environmental Quality v Worth Twp ................... 860Dep’t of Treasury, Anheuser-Busch, Inc v .......................... 886Dep’t of Treasury, Discount Tire Co v ................................. 875Dep’t of Treasury, Huzella v ............................... 237Dep’t of Treasury, International Business Machines
Corp v ................................................................................ 874Dep’t of Treasury, Malpass v .............................. 237Dep’t of Treasury, NACG Leasing v .................................... 851Dep’t of Treasury, Random House, Inc v ............................ 869
xxviii 494 MICH REPORTS
PAGE
Dep’t of Treasury, Wheeler v .............................. 237Dep’t of Treasury, Wheeler Estate v .................. 237Dep’t of Treasury, Wright v ................................ 237Detroit Bd of Ed, Garvin v ................................................... 883Detroit (City of), Tatarian v ................................................. 869Detroit Election Comm, Barrow v ....................................... 866Detroit Financial Review Team (City of), Citizens United
Against Corrupt Government v ....................................... 858Detroit Land Development & Holdings, LLC v MLK-
Buchanan Community Development Corp ..................... 885Detroit Public Schools v Connections for Deaf Citizens,
Inc ...................................................................................... 885Detroit Public Schools, Greer v ............................................ 855Deweese, People v .................................................................. 883Dezaak Management, Inc v Auto-Owners Ins Co ............... 873Dia, People v .......................................................................... 870Dickerson, People v ............................................................... 883Director of Assessing for the Charter Twp of West
Bloomfield, Crane v .......................................................... 872Discount Tire Co v Dep’t of Treasury ................................. 875Diskin, People v ..................................................................... 884Ditta, People v ....................................................................... 868Dixon, People v ................................................................ 854, 857Dodd, People v ....................................................................... 854Domestic Uniform Rental, Fuego Grill, LLC v ................... 869Dothard, People v .................................................................. 882Duncan v State of Michigan ................................................. 879Duncan, People v ................................................. 713Dunigan, People v .................................................................. 870Durr, People v ........................................................................ 856
EEarnest C Brooks Correctional Facility Warden, Miller v ..... 872Edwards, People v ................................................................. 871Elliott, People v .................................................... 292Elmanar, People v .................................................................. 881English v Attorney Grievance Comm .................................. 872Environmental Quality (Dep’t of) v Worth Twp ................ 860
TABLE OF CASES REPORTED xxix
PAGE
Esch, People v ........................................................................ 858Etter, People v ........................................................................ 884
FFarhoud v Rosario ................................................................. 871Farm Bureau Ins Co v Chukwueke ...................................... 857Fenderson, People v ............................................................... 882Ferguson, Thomas v .............................................................. 856Ferrous Processing & Trading Co, Torres v ....................... 886Findling v Parker .................................................................. 884
Fisher Sand & Gravel Co v Neal A Sweebe,Inc ..................................................................... 543
Flanagan, People v ................................................................ 875Fleming, People v .................................................................. 883Fletcher, People v .................................................................. 868Flint (City of), Landon v ....................................................... 872Flint (City of), Watts v .......................................................... 857Forfeiture of Bail Bond, In re ............................................... 871Foster, People v ...................................................................... 855France, People v .................................................................... 882Frazier, People v .................................................................... 858Freydl, Newton v ................................................................... 870Froling, The City of Bloomfield Hills v ............................... 858Fuego Grill, LLC v Domestic Uniform Rental .................... 869Fuller, People v ...................................................................... 882
GGagnon v Citizens Ins Co ..................................................... 883Gaines, People v (Deondre) .................................................. 868Gaines, People v (Robert) ..................................................... 857Garcia, People v ..................................................................... 863Gardner, People v .................................................................. 882Garvin v Detroit Bd of Ed .................................................... 883Gates, People v ...................................................................... 868Gayles, People v ..................................................................... 883General Motors Co, Johnson v ............................................. 871General Motors Co, Patson v ................................................ 871Gibson, People v .................................................................... 854
xxx 494 MICH REPORTS
PAGE
Gidron, People v .................................................................... 885Gipson, People v .................................................................... 882Gleeson, Street v ................................................................... 860
Glenn, People v .................................................... 430Goldberg v Wlezniak ............................................................. 872Gomez, People v (Isaac) ........................................................ 865Gomez, People v (Joel) .......................................................... 851Gonzales, People v ................................................................. 856Goodman v Attorney Grievance Comm ............................... 885Goralewski Estate, In re ....................................................... 853Goss, People v ........................................................................ 870Governor, Makowski v ........................................................... 876Graham, People v .................................................................. 858
Grange Ins Co of Michigan v Lawrence ............ 475Gray v Chrostowski ............................................................... 860Gray, People v ........................................................................ 869Grays, People v ...................................................................... 881Green v Dep’t of Corrections ............................................... 886Green, People v (Thomas) .................................................... 882Green, People v (Tony) ......................................................... 865Greene, People v (Brian) ....................................................... 871Greene, People v (Loren) ...................................................... 882Greenlee, People v ................................................................. 854Greenville Mfg, LLC v Nextenergy Center ......................... 886Greer v Detroit Public Schools ............................................. 855Grievance Administrator v Monroe ..................................... 857Gross, People v ...................................................................... 882Gulley v Smith ....................................................................... 857Guynn, People v ..................................................................... 869
HHagerty v Board of Manistee County Rd Comm’rs ............ 885Hambley, People v ................................................................. 869Hani & Ramiz, Inc v North Pointe Ins ............................... 873Hardaway, People v ............................................................... 856Hardaway v Wayne County ................................ 423Hardy, People v .................................................... 430Hardy, People v ...................................................................... 885
TABLE OF CASES REPORTED xxxi
PAGE
Harris v Auto Club Ins Ass’n ............................. 462Harris, People v ..................................................................... 871Haulcy, People v ..................................................................... 871Hayman, Ketchmark v .......................................................... 886Hays v Lutheran Social Services of Michigan .................... 869Heinzelmann, People v .......................................................... 884Henix, People v ...................................................................... 855Hernandez-Guzman, People v .............................................. 871Herzig, People v ..................................................................... 857Hicks, People v ...................................................................... 870Hill, People v (Tyrone) .......................................................... 882Hill, People v (William) ......................................................... 886Hillier, People v ...................................................................... 870Hills, People of the Twp of Canton v ................................... 884
Hillsdale County, Hillsdale County SeniorServices, Inc v .................................................. 46
Hillsdale County Senior Services, Inc vHillsdale County .............................................. 46
Hinton, People v .................................................................... 884Hoefling, People v .................................................................. 855Hogan, People v ..................................................................... 853Hoking, People v .................................................................... 882Holden, People v .................................................................... 885Holifield, People v .................................................................. 881Hollins, People v .................................................................... 855Holt, People v ......................................................................... 863Home-Owners Ins Co, Carson v ........................................... 859Hon Deborah Ross Adams, In re .......................................... 879Hopwood, People v ................................................................ 857Hornof, People v .................................................................... 875Howard, People v ................................................................... 854Howell, People v (Kevin) ....................................................... 871Howell, People v (Robert) ..................................................... 858Howze, People v ..................................................................... 872Hoyt, People v ........................................................................ 856Hubbert, People v .................................................................. 858Huffman, People v ................................................................. 884Hunter, People v .................................................................... 886
xxxii 494 MICH REPORTS
PAGE
Huzella v Dep’t of Treasury ............................... 237
IIbragimova, People v ............................................................. 866
In re Adams .......................................................... 162In re Besok ............................................................................. 879In re Boynton ......................................................................... 852
In re Bradley Estate ............................................ 367In re Forfeiture of Bail Bond ................................................ 871In re Goralewski Estate ........................................................ 853In re Hon Deborah Ross Adams ........................................... 879In re Jeter/Thomas ................................................................ 873In re Kallabat ......................................................................... 883In re Morris ............................................................................ 851In re NAD ............................................................................... 873In re Nowak Revocable Living Trust ................................... 855In re Raphael ......................................................................... 886In re Request for Advisory Opinion Regarding
Constitutionality of 2012 PA 348 and 2012 PA 349 ...... 876In re Sholberg Estate ............................................................ 867In re Stillwell Trust ............................................................... 868International Business Machines Corp v Dep’t of
Treasury ............................................................................ 874Ireland, People v .................................................................... 856Isaac, People v ....................................................................... 868Ivory, People v ........................................................................ 881
JJackson, People v (Atkinson) ................................................ 856Jackson, People v (Craig) ...................................................... 870Jackson, People v (Michael) .................................................. 869Jackson & Church Co v Kaiser ............................................ 871Jagarlamudi, People v ........................................................... 882Jaskowski, Petipren v .......................................... 190Jefferson, People v ................................................................. 870Jeter/Thomas, In re ............................................................... 873Johns v Wixom Builders Supply, Inc ................................... 872Johnson v General Motors Co .............................................. 871
TABLE OF CASES REPORTED xxxiii
PAGE
Johnson, People v (Calvin) ................................................... 856Johnson, People v (Darryl) ................................................... 882Johnson, People v (Dontya) .................................................. 856Johnson, People v (Henry) .................................................... 883Johnson, People v (Jerry) ..................................................... 883Johnson, People v (Mario) .................................................... 868Johnson, People v (William) ................................................. 871Johnson-El, People v ............................................................. 885Jones, People v (Alvin) .......................................................... 881Jones, People v (Anthony) .................................................... 873Jones, People v (Byron) ........................................................ 880Jones, People v (Charles) ...................................................... 863Jones, People v (Jerome) ...................................................... 868Jones, People v (Joseph) ....................................................... 885Jones, People v (Larry) ......................................................... 884Jones, People v (Mark) .......................................................... 852Jones, People v (Russell) ....................................................... 855Josey, People v ....................................................................... 870Julian, People v ..................................................................... 855
KKaiser, Jackson & Church Co v ...............................
![Criminal Procedure (Justices an [PFP#120645509]](https://static.documents.pub/doc/80x56/6254d871f1b1a4050946e5ba/criminal-procedure-justices-an-pfp120645509.jpg)
