+ All Categories
Home > Documents > SURGERY OF THE WAR.

SURGERY OF THE WAR.

Date post: 31-Dec-2016
Category:
Upload: haduong
View: 217 times
Download: 4 times
Share this document with a friend
2
249 remedy in Spain. Other medicines may of course, be given with this " opiate and oleaginous" course, suitable to each par- ticular case. Thus, where there is evident distension of sto- mach, with vomiting of acid matters, full doses of bi-carbonate of soda are indicated, and these should be given at once, as a preliminary measure. Oleaginous injections with laudanum, swathing the whole body in blankets steeped in oil; astringent pills of acetate of lead and opium; calomel (in scruple doses) with opium, are all useful adjuvants in the treatment. Opium, freely given, soothes irritation, and checks discharge; calomel, as above indicated, also soothes and equalizes the circulation (hence its utility in our Indian plague); astringents contract the mucous tissues; and an oleaginous envelope checks exuda- tion from the sudoriferous duets. I have written very hastily, with but little regard to arrange- ment or language; but, as the idea may be useful, I would rather send it at once than delay it to dress up. Yours verv truly, Nynee Tal, Dec. 17th, 1854. C. R. FRANCIS, M.B. Lond., Bengal Medical Service. THE "MARSDEN" TRIAL IN PARIS. WILLIAM MARSDEN. To the Editor of THE LANCET. SIR,—At the request of many friends I am induced to ask the favour of the insertion of this note, in reference to the unfortunate case of a Dr. Marsden and his daughters, now under investigation in the Court of Assize, Paris, and a report of which has appeared in many of the English newspapers. The said Dr. Marsden is no relative or connexion of mine, neither have I any knowledge either of him or of any of his family. I am not a widower, neither have I any daughters, and I believe I am the only one of the name in the medical profession in London. I am, Sir, vour obedient servant. Lincoln’s-inn-fields, Feb. 1855. SURGERY OF THE WAR. IN continuing the history of the medical arrangements of the war, it is gratifying to find that almost all accounts agree that the month of MARCH finds the sanitary state of the British forces in camp much improved to what their condition was at the end of last year. The climate, as we expected, has got quite mild, and forms a very insignificant element in the disaster of battle and bombardment now daily threatening. Except at Scutari, where a bad kind of fever has broken out, which we had feared for some time, there is little this month of such a depressing nature as that we have gone through since December. While we are told of this great increase of fever, which we fear to call by its true name, plague, we are assured by other and better judges, perhaps, that it is only typhoid. Another medical correspondent, writing about the middle of February, from one of the hospital wards at Scutari, tells us, on the contrary, that the hospital there is now " twice as efficient as it was a month ago; the over- crowded wards and corridors are becoming gradually thinned, to the manifest advantage of both surgeons and patients. We are not without expectations of a large influx, however, of sick and wounded, and fever patients, as the French, who always anticipate great battles by surgical movements, are fast pre- paring 5000 new beds in their hospital. Medicines with us, however, are now promptly supplied from London-thanks to the authorities at home stirring up the medical purveyor." And he then goes on to give his opinion, that it is quite im- possible to conduct large military hospitals, like Scutari, with- out an admixture of civil practitioners, as intended at Smyrna; but we fear the simple answer to this will be-How do the French do it ? Even our terrible enemies the Russians, do not they teach us how to establish a medical military staff and hospitals ? No organization can keep off plague. Sardinia has now a military hospital for 2000 beds at Pera. Every one who looks at the question with an unjaundiced eye must at once perceive the danger of divided responsibility. The Army Medical Department should be enabled to extend itself spon- taneously, and not be crippled by a divided allegiance, other- wise our army surgeons must be ever in doubt and difficulty, and unfairly deprived of the chief stimulus in their arduous duties-viz., promotion in the medical service—like the often quoted tent of the fairy Pari Banon, in the "Arabian Nights," Dr. A. Smith should carry his system in his hand in times of peace, but it should carry within it the machinery of extension, and spread abroad its wings to entire armies at the first blast of war. This, we believe, has been impossible, from the cheeseparing character of Parliament and the Horse Guards, now, happily, we learn, likely to be changed. We must either have our Army Medical Department complete, like that of France, Austria, or Sardinia, or incomplete, if crippled by the civil authorities, colleges, or other departments. We have never despaired of our brave soldiers. We now find the effective force in the Crimea, in the middle of February, to be 26,000 men, exclusive of the large number of 5773 under medical care in the camp hospitals, and about twice this number sick and convalescent at Scutari-12,344; making-with supernumeraries (2632)-something in all like 45,000 men. The French general can, at any minute, bring 60,000 men (shall we say under the eye of the Emperor him- self ?) to attack Fort Malacoff. A new Turkish contingent of 20,000 troops, also in want of surgical assistants, has been organized. Heaven grant that we have not disasters enough in the future ! A hundred British ships are again ready for the Baltic, with fifty ships of our allies-the French. The cholera, so very prevalent under Sir W. Burnett’s medical command last year, (who, by the way, has resigned,) is, by some medical authorities, believed to have been of sporadic or local origin in the fleet; the Russian fleet having also suffered from various endemic affections of the same kind, which this year they have learned to avoid. It appears hope- less, however, to raise the condition of our navy surgeons in the eyes of the Admiralty; so we must be content, perhaps, with new cholera reports, and meaningless controversies, as to the occult nature of this fell disease. In the Russian navy in the Baltic ports, even in March and April, ice continued in the ship holds. About the first week in May, as expected, the frozen bilge-water began to thaw, when the officers and men were almost universally attael:Pd with cholera, typhus, diarrhœa, &c.; even the exhalations from the bottom of the ships producing bad ophthalmia. There is a curious coincidence between the attacks of cholera at opposite points of Europe. From the 9th to the 15th of July almost every one in the Russian fleet in the Baltic had been attacked by these diseases, though Sir Charles Napier was not aware of it; while on the night of the 16th of July, as we stated before, (THE LANCET, Jan. 6th, p. 24,) the crew of the ships in the Black Sea and in the fleet anchored off Varna or Baljik, both English and French, were also first attacked-disease, with its fell grasp, thus levelling all alike. We believe this point needs no further illustration except this, that the Russian surgeons all ascribed the disease to the thawing of ice and exhalations of bilge-water in the ships; and according as they got rid of the causes the effects ceased. We seem to have e invoked Allah and the Prophet, and gone on shore amongst Turkish mosques and minarets for some supernatural agent, Sir W. Burnett not looking for any cause amongst his surgeons afloat" as not scientific enough. It seems to us that these scenes will be all acted over again this year. Surgeons in the Navy, it is said, are becoming scarce, and several of our poor Army fellows are sick. New arrangements have been made in the Admiralty. It will not answer to do away with the name "assistant,"’ and replace it by the terms " first and "second" surgeons, as suggested; the general position of the Navy medical officers must be upheld. Our ships should not be fitted out so early this year, nor manned by men who have not been acclimatized. The moral position and value of our Navy and Army surgeons should be the same, afloat or ashore; Parliament should make them one. Medical science is now second to no other as a liberal and humanizing study. We have never joined in the hue and cry against the Director-General of the Medical Department of the Army, for the simple reason that we knew he was doing his best. We blame the higher authorities. It appears, notwithstanding the obloquy thrown on Dr. A. Smith, that nobody has been more anxious for the motion for inquiry before Parliament. We have been told, on the best authority, that the Russians have 35,000 in hospital, and more than one French regiment has also been swept away by disease; we cannot expect, then, that Dr. A. Smith, working against un- heard-of difficulties as regards the commissariat, can have been infallible. We believe this is not a time for fault-finding. We may have at any moment new battles equal to Inkermann and Alma. Large supplies of medical necessaries have, however,. arrived at Balaklava and Scutari. The fever now raging at the latter has taken off seven medical men in one month, and , is represented as the product of animal emanations, from the
Transcript
Page 1: SURGERY OF THE WAR.

249

remedy in Spain. Other medicines may of course, be givenwith this " opiate and oleaginous" course, suitable to each par-ticular case. Thus, where there is evident distension of sto-mach, with vomiting of acid matters, full doses of bi-carbonateof soda are indicated, and these should be given at once, as apreliminary measure. Oleaginous injections with laudanum,swathing the whole body in blankets steeped in oil; astringentpills of acetate of lead and opium; calomel (in scruple doses)with opium, are all useful adjuvants in the treatment. Opium,freely given, soothes irritation, and checks discharge; calomel,as above indicated, also soothes and equalizes the circulation(hence its utility in our Indian plague); astringents contractthe mucous tissues; and an oleaginous envelope checks exuda-tion from the sudoriferous duets.

I have written very hastily, with but little regard to arrange-ment or language; but, as the idea may be useful, I wouldrather send it at once than delay it to dress up.

Yours verv truly,

Nynee Tal, Dec. 17th, 1854.C. R. FRANCIS, M.B. Lond.,

Bengal Medical Service.

THE "MARSDEN" TRIAL IN PARIS.

WILLIAM MARSDEN.

To the Editor of THE LANCET.SIR,—At the request of many friends I am induced to ask

the favour of the insertion of this note, in reference to theunfortunate case of a Dr. Marsden and his daughters, nowunder investigation in the Court of Assize, Paris, and a reportof which has appeared in many of the English newspapers.The said Dr. Marsden is no relative or connexion of mine,

neither have I any knowledge either of him or of any of hisfamily. I am not a widower, neither have I any daughters,and I believe I am the only one of the name in the medicalprofession in London.

I am, Sir, vour obedient servant.

Lincoln’s-inn-fields, Feb. 1855.

SURGERY OF THE WAR.

IN continuing the history of the medical arrangements of thewar, it is gratifying to find that almost all accounts agree thatthe month of MARCH finds the sanitary state of the Britishforces in camp much improved to what their conditionwas at the end of last year. The climate, as we expected, hasgot quite mild, and forms a very insignificant element in thedisaster of battle and bombardment now daily threatening.Except at Scutari, where a bad kind of fever has broken out,which we had feared for some time, there is little this monthof such a depressing nature as that we have gone throughsince December. While we are told of this great increase offever, which we fear to call by its true name, plague, we areassured by other and better judges, perhaps, that it is onlytyphoid. Another medical correspondent, writing aboutthe middle of February, from one of the hospital wardsat Scutari, tells us, on the contrary, that the hospital there isnow " twice as efficient as it was a month ago; the over-crowded wards and corridors are becoming gradually thinned,to the manifest advantage of both surgeons and patients. Weare not without expectations of a large influx, however, of sickand wounded, and fever patients, as the French, who alwaysanticipate great battles by surgical movements, are fast pre-

paring 5000 new beds in their hospital. Medicines with us,however, are now promptly supplied from London-thanks tothe authorities at home stirring up the medical purveyor."And he then goes on to give his opinion, that it is quite im-possible to conduct large military hospitals, like Scutari, with-out an admixture of civil practitioners, as intended at Smyrna;but we fear the simple answer to this will be-How do theFrench do it ? Even our terrible enemies the Russians, do notthey teach us how to establish a medical military staff andhospitals ? No organization can keep off plague. Sardinia hasnow a military hospital for 2000 beds at Pera. Every one wholooks at the question with an unjaundiced eye must at onceperceive the danger of divided responsibility. The ArmyMedical Department should be enabled to extend itself spon-taneously, and not be crippled by a divided allegiance, other-wise our army surgeons must be ever in doubt and difficulty,and unfairly deprived of the chief stimulus in their arduousduties-viz., promotion in the medical service—like the often

quoted tent of the fairy Pari Banon, in the "Arabian Nights,"Dr. A. Smith should carry his system in his hand in times ofpeace, but it should carry within it the machinery of extension,and spread abroad its wings to entire armies at the firstblast of war. This, we believe, has been impossible, from thecheeseparing character of Parliament and the Horse Guards,now, happily, we learn, likely to be changed. We musteither have our Army Medical Department complete, like thatof France, Austria, or Sardinia, or incomplete, if crippled bythe civil authorities, colleges, or other departments.We have never despaired of our brave soldiers. We now

find the effective force in the Crimea, in the middle of

February, to be 26,000 men, exclusive of the large number of5773 under medical care in the camp hospitals, and abouttwice this number sick and convalescent at Scutari-12,344;making-with supernumeraries (2632)-something in all like45,000 men. The French general can, at any minute, bring60,000 men (shall we say under the eye of the Emperor him-self ?) to attack Fort Malacoff. A new Turkish contingent of20,000 troops, also in want of surgical assistants, has beenorganized. Heaven grant that we have not disasters enoughin the future ! A hundred British ships are again readyfor the Baltic, with fifty ships of our allies-the French.The cholera, so very prevalent under Sir W. Burnett’s medicalcommand last year, (who, by the way, has resigned,) is, bysome medical authorities, believed to have been of sporadicor local origin in the fleet; the Russian fleet having alsosuffered from various endemic affections of the same kind,which this year they have learned to avoid. It appears hope-less, however, to raise the condition of our navy surgeons inthe eyes of the Admiralty; so we must be content, perhaps,with new cholera reports, and meaningless controversies, as tothe occult nature of this fell disease.In the Russian navy in the Baltic ports, even in March and

April, ice continued in the ship holds. About the first weekin May, as expected, the frozen bilge-water began to thaw,when the officers and men were almost universally attael:Pdwith cholera, typhus, diarrhœa, &c.; even the exhalations fromthe bottom of the ships producing bad ophthalmia. There isa curious coincidence between the attacks of cholera at oppositepoints of Europe. From the 9th to the 15th of July almostevery one in the Russian fleet in the Baltic had been attackedby these diseases, though Sir Charles Napier was not aware ofit; while on the night of the 16th of July, as we stated before,(THE LANCET, Jan. 6th, p. 24,) the crew of the ships in theBlack Sea and in the fleet anchored off Varna or Baljik, bothEnglish and French, were also first attacked-disease, withits fell grasp, thus levelling all alike. We believe this pointneeds no further illustration except this, that the Russiansurgeons all ascribed the disease to the thawing of ice andexhalations of bilge-water in the ships; and according as theygot rid of the causes the effects ceased. We seem to have einvoked Allah and the Prophet, and gone on shore amongstTurkish mosques and minarets for some supernatural agent, SirW. Burnett not looking for any cause amongst his surgeons afloat"as not scientific enough. It seems to us that these scenes willbe all acted over again this year. Surgeons in the Navy, it issaid, are becoming scarce, and several of our poor Army fellowsare sick. New arrangements have been made in the Admiralty.It will not answer to do away with the name "assistant,"’and replace it by the terms " first and "second" surgeons,as suggested; the general position of the Navy medical officersmust be upheld. Our ships should not be fitted out so earlythis year, nor manned by men who have not been acclimatized.The moral position and value of our Navy and Army surgeonsshould be the same, afloat or ashore; Parliament should makethem one. Medical science is now second to no other as aliberal and humanizing study. We have never joined in thehue and cry against the Director-General of the Medical

Department of the Army, for the simple reason that we knewhe was doing his best. We blame the higher authorities. Itappears, notwithstanding the obloquy thrown on Dr. A. Smith,that nobody has been more anxious for the motion for inquirybefore Parliament. We have been told, on the best authority,that the Russians have 35,000 in hospital, and more than oneFrench regiment has also been swept away by disease; wecannot expect, then, that Dr. A. Smith, working against un-heard-of difficulties as regards the commissariat, can have beeninfallible.We believe this is not a time for fault-finding. We may

have at any moment new battles equal to Inkermann andAlma. Large supplies of medical necessaries have, however,.arrived at Balaklava and Scutari. The fever now raging atthe latter has taken off seven medical men in one month, and

, is represented as the product of animal emanations, from the

Page 2: SURGERY OF THE WAR.

250

accumulated mass of putrid matters collected in the vicinity.By some surgeons it is called " bilious remittent," by others"typhoid," of a bad character. We fear it is plague. It isnow at length understood, as we have several times explained,that scurvy is caused by want of fresh vegetables, (corroboratingthe views of Dr. Budd.) The true cause being known, wemay hope to hear less of its effects. Our practical medicineand surgery have been almost as bad perhaps as our cookery isdescribed to be; this arises from want of medical concours, asin the French medical arrangements, and is rather due to adeficient state of general medical education. We have spokenof chloroform and excision of joints, and improvements ofmodern surgery; but we fear the ultimate returns will showthat we have gone backwards rather than forwards. The ArmyMedical Department has raised its curriculum above that of theCollege of Surgeons; thus compromising the object held in viewby students-namely, employment. This may be a very smallthing ; but it is at the root of all our disorganization, and want ofmedical men now felt in the army. Government is ready toestablish chairs of Military Surgery in London and Dublin,and Lord Palmerston has sent a commission to Paris to reporton the French medical system. All these are moves in theright direction. We must, however, have a higher style ofmedical education, and more harmony between all our medicaland military boards and colleges, before we can expect to beas perfect in our arrangements as our French neighbours, orafford our troops in future the benefits of the resources ofmodern medical science, so very much to be desired, and whichthey so much require in the field. We can gain very little bylooking to the past-to that experience which, like the stern-lights of a ship, only illumine the dangers we have passed.Our surgery and medicine are every year changing, and morehopeful. Chloroform alone promises to remodel all our science.We must look, then, to future improvements, and all labouralike to raise the status of medical men, whether in the armyor navy. NVitli such an object in view, all subsequent organi-zation will be plain and simple; without it, we must ever re- Imain as we are.

THE ROYAL MEDICAL COLLEGE.

THE third anniversary festival of the Medical BenevolentCollege (henceforward to be styled, in accordance with thegracious permission of Her Majesty, the " Royal Medical Col-lege") was celebrated on Wednesday evening at the LondonTavern. Although the number of guests was upwards of 200,the party was unusually select, consisting, for the most part, ofthe clerical and medical professions. The Right Hon. the Earlof Carlisle presided. The noble Earl was supported by ViscountEbrington, M.P., the Rev. Dr. Croly, Rev. Sir J. Hayes, Mr.J. Lloyd Davies, M.P., Major Palmer, Sir G. Staunton, Mr. J.Phillips, M.P., Dr. Wilson, Dr. Babington, &c.

After the usual loyal toasts, the noble Earl proposed " TheArmy and Navy," which was drunk with enthusiasm.The toast of the evening, " Prosperity to the Royal Medical

College," was proposed by the noble Chairman in a most elo-quent and feeling speech, in which his Lordship ably advocatedthe claims of the ill-requited profession of medicine to publicsupport and sympathy, and forcibly dwelt on the inadeqateremuneration of medical officers under the Poor-law Act.

Mr. PROPERT, the treasurer and founder of the institution,then rose, and gave a very favourable account of the College,which is to be opened in the course of the ensuing summer forthe reception of one hundred pupils, the sons of medical men,and a certain number of decayed medical men, or their widowsand orphans. The list of subscriptions announced by Mr.Propert in the course of the evening amounted to upwards of£2100.The Rev. Dr. CROLY afterwards delivered an eloquent speech

in favour of the medical profession, in which he urged the ex-pediency of blending medical with theological education, espe-cially for missionaries.The health of the noble Chairman was proposed by Lord

EBRINGTON, under the style and title of " the new Lord Lieu-tenant of Ireland." This toast was enthusiastically received,and the noble Earl, in returning thanks, -,teIT-nowled,,ed the highhonour of the office " which had been conferred upon him byhis noble friend."

THE COLLEGE LECTURES.—Mr. Prescott Hewett hasjust been appointed Professor of Surgery, and will deliver acourse of lectures on " Injuries and Diseases of the Head."Professor Owen, as usual, will deliver a course on "Compara-tive Anatomy. "

Medical News.ROYAL COLLEGE OF SURGEONS.—The following gentle-

men having undergone the necessary examinations for the

diploma, were admitted Members of the College at the meetingof the Court of Examiners on the 23rd ult. :-

BATES, JOHN PICKERING, Royal Navy.BROWN, AUGUSTUS, H.E.I.Co.’s Service.COOKE, ROBINS WILLIAM, Australia.FARR, SEPTIMUS BRIGGS, Dunstable, Bedfordshire.FOTHERGILL, MICHAEL, Bedale, Yorkshire.GARLAND, EDWARD CHARLES, Bath.HAMERTON, FREDERICK ACLAND, Upper Seymour-street,

Euston-square.HARDING, WILLIAM WOODS, Woolwich.HAYES, WILLIAM HENRY, Calcutta.HITCHINS, CHARLES VERNON, Tiverton, Bath.M’PHERSON, DoNALD, Army.RANKE, HENRY, Smyrna Hospital.R,oLLASON, HENRY, Erdington, Warwickshire.THORNTON, JAMES HOWARD, H.E. I. Co.’s Service.

AroTHECABiES’ HALL.—Names of gentlemen who passedtheir examination in the science and practice of Medicine, andreceived certificates to practise, on-

Thursday, February 22nd, 1855.BLACKMAN, FREDERICK, Blackfriars-road.CoATl;s, CHARLES, Leeds, Yorkshire.CORNER, FRANCIS MEAD, Whitby, Yorkshire.STAPLETON, JOHN HUTTON, Trowbridge, Wilts.WooD, GEORGE JACOB, Norwich.WooDWARD, WILLIAM, Ledbury, Herefordshire.

SMYRNA HOSPITAL.—The establishment at Smyrna isto consist of three physicians and six assistant-physicians, fivesurgeons and ten assistant-surgeons, one lady superintendent,forty nurses, and eighty orderlies. Beds for at least 1200 sickand wounded have been fitted up. Amongst the names of thestaff already chosen, or about to be appointed, in addition tothose of Dr. Myer, Mr. Wells, and Dr. Leared, we findthose of Dr. Coote, Messrs. H. Coote and Rollestone, (St.Bartholomew’s;) Messrs. Jardine and Complin, (St. Thomas’s;)Mr. Wordsworth, Drs. Fraser and Gibbon, (London Hospital;)Mr. Statham, Dr. Gibb, and Mr. Holthouse, (WestminsterHospital.)ROYAL MEDICAL AND CHIRURGICAL SOCIETY.—At the

anniversary meeting on Thursday, the opponents of the Councilin the late proceedings respecting THE LANCET, moved thatthe report of the Council should not be received. For themotion, 28. Against it, 58. Majority for the Council andTHE LANCET, 30.

APPOINTMENT.—Dr. T. Thomson, F.L.S., Surgeon of theBengal Army, has been appointed Superintendent of the Hon.Company’s Gardens at Calcutta. Dr. Thomson is the sonof the late Dr. Thomas Thomson, of Glasgow. He was en-

gaged in active service in Affghaunistan, was taken prisoner atGhuznee, and was marched with his fellow captives toBamseau, where they were released by bribing the Affghaunchief. Dr. Thomson was subsequently two years in Tibet, ascommissioner, and one year in the Eastern Himalaya, on hisown resources. He served in the Punjaub campaign, andwears two medals.

NAVAL MEDICAL OFFICERS.—We are glad to find thatthe claims of the naval medical profession are at last to comefairly before the public in the Parliamentary inquiry about totake place, when it is to be hoped that every member of theprofession able to give information calculated to be of serviceto the cause will place himself in communication with somemember of the committee, in order that justice may be done tothe service and to the public. It is gratifying to find that ourpublic orators are beginning to give our friends a lift, as wasthe case a day or two ago, when, in an assembly of from 6000to 7000 persons in the Town Hall of Birmingham, convened forthe purpose of petitioning Parliament to prosecute an inquiryinto the causes of the disasters in the Crimea, and on the systemof appointments in the Army and Navy, Mr. George Dawson,in eloquent terms depicted the miserable condition of ourbrave troops, and said :-" He would put it to them of menlying for hours after battle, uncared for, unattended, stiffeningslowly into death. Oh!’ said the aristocracy, ’that was themedical department; it was their fault; we have nothing to


Recommended