Tackling the Illicit Tobacco Trade
• Thetobaccoindustrycontributesintheregionof£11.5billionperannumtotheExchequer.Throughoutthesupplychainandinforwardlinkages,theindustrysupportstensofthousandsofjobsintheUK.
• TheTMA’smembercompaniesalsoinvestheavilyinresearchanddevelopment,particularlyinregardtonextgenerationproductssuchase-cigarettes.
• However,theillicittradeintobaccoproductsremainsasignificantchallengeforthesectorandathreattotobaccotaxrevenues.In2015/16,theconsumptionofillicittobaccointheUKcosttheExchequer£2.4billioninlosttaxrevenue1,thesecondhighestsinglelosstotheTreasuryafterVATavoidance.
Overview
• Thelandscapewithinthetobaccosectorhaschangeddramaticallyoverthepastyearwiththeintroductionoffar-reachinglegislation.TheEUTobaccoProductsDirective(TPD)whichhasbannedpacksoffewerthan20cigarettesandhandrollingpouchesoflessthan30gandtheintroductionof(plain)standardisedtobaccopackagingarecreatingnewchallengesintacklingillicittobaccoproductsassmokerscannolongerpurchasetheirpacksizeofchoicethroughlegitimatechannels.Counterfeit plain packaging has already been seized in parts the UK.
• BrexitpresentsmanypotentialchallengesbutthereareopportunitiesfortheGovernmenttoconsidertoo.TheintroductionoffixedlimitsonpersonalimportsfromtheEUintotheUK,bringingitintolinewithcurrentduty-freeallowances,wouldprovideclarityforBorderForceofficers.
Changing landscape
Sources:1:TobaccoTaxGapEstimates2015-16;2:https://a-cg.org/asset/011916_counting_the_cost_of_counterfeit_goods-ipo-report-manchester.pdf
Tackling illicit tradeThe industry takes the threat from the illicit market very seriously and is working across the globe with law enforcement and other stakeholders to counter the threat posed by smugglers and the organised criminal groups who dominate the illicit trade.
IntheUK,muchoftheindustryactivitytotackletheillegalmarketcomesundertheMemorandumofUnderstanding(MoU)thattheTMAmembercompanieseachhavewithHMRevenue&Customs(HMRC).ThisMoUcreatesacomprehensiveframeworkforco-operationaimedatcombatingthesmugglingofbothgenuineandcounterfeittobaccoproductsintotheUKaswellasseekingtodeterallaspectsoftheillicittradeintobaccoproducts.
Fromanindustryperspectivethiscanbesummarisedasafivestepapproach:
1.Intelligence
2.Insight
3.Technology
4.CollaborativeWorking
5.MobilisingSupport
CASE STUDY
Cheetham HillThetobaccoindustryplayedaconsiderableroleinthedisruptionoftheillicittobaccotradeinCheethamHill,Manchester,the‘counterfeitcapital’oftheUK.Theindustrydeliveredintelligencetoenforcementagenciesaspartofabroaderclampdownonillegalcounterfeitgoods.Intotalaround£5mofcounterfeitgoodswereseizedandledtotheclosureofmorethan30premises.
FurtherdetailscanbefoundintheIPO’sreportontheoutcomesoftheoperation2.
PUB
POLICE LINE DO NOT CROSS POLICE LINE DO NOT CROSS POLICE LINE DO NOT CROSS POLICE LINE DO NOT CROSS POLICE LINE DO NOT CROSS POLICE LINE DO NOT CROSS
£5m
Source:ManchesterEveningNews,January2016
Illicit tobacco presents significant challenges for legitimate businesses, law enforcement, government revenues and communities. This briefing sets out the role of the TMA in tackling this pernicious trade.
£2.4bn
IN2015/16,THECONSUMPTIONOFILLICITTOBACCOINTHE
UKCOSTTHEEXCHEQUER£2.4BILLIONINLOSTTAXREVENUE1
FAKE FAKE
Intelligence:theindustrygeneratesconsiderableintelligenceontheillegaltobaccomarketataninternational,nationalandlocallevel.Withanon-the-groundpresencetheindustryisabletoprovideintelligenceanywhereintheUK.Thisissharedwiththeappropriatelawenforcementagencies.In2016,TMAmembercompaniesassistedHMRCwithover1,100piecesofintelligenceandrespondedtoover1,500requestsfromenforcementagenciesforassistancesuchasperformingbrandanalysis.ThevolumeofintelligencegeneratedanddeliveredbytheindustryhassupportedenforcementactionacrosstheUKandinturnledtoasignificantincreaseinnumberofseizuresandprosecutions.
1
TACKLINGTHEILLICITTOBACCOTRADE
Tackling illicit trade
1107
356556
694
981
1055
931 1686
881
1493
1300 1025
Technology:thetobaccoindustryhasdevelopedtrackandtracetechnologywhichallowsenforcementtoeasilyidentifylegitimatetobaccoanditssource.
3
Collaborative working:protocolsareinplaceforHMRCandthetobaccoindustrytomeet,todiscussandagreeonappropriateactionaroundareastotackletheillicitmarket.TheTMAworkswiththeScottishAnti-IllicitTradeGroupandtheNorthernIrelandIntellectualPropertyCrimeGroupandcoordinatestheTobaccoSecurityForumtosupporttheworkofNationalBusinessCrimeSolutions.Thesegroupsshareinsighttoaidtheworkofenforcementagencies.ThedevelopmentoftheNationalAnti-IllicitTradegroupwillbringtogetheracross-sectionoflawenforcementtofocusonspecificsectors.
4
Scotland
NI
NorthEast
NorthWest
Wales
EastMidlands
WestMidlands
Southwest
Southeast
London
EastofEngland
YorkshireandHumber
Survey total = 12,065ThesurveysampleisrepresentativeoftheUKpopulationbygovernmentofficeregion.
Insight:theTMA’smembercompaniescollectandanalysealargeamountofdataonthetobaccomarket,includingadetailedpictureofthedynamicsofnon-UKdutypaid(NUKDP)consumption.TheTMA’ssurveyof12,000adultsmokersprovidesuniqueinsightintoadultsmokerbehaviour,awarenessandattitudestowardstheillegalmarket.
2
DODGY BUSINESS
KE
KE
FA
FA FA
FAKE FA
Mobilising support:theTMAanditsmembercompaniesconductregularcampaignsacrossnational,regionalandtrademediainordertoraiseawarenessoftheimpactofillegaltobaccoandtoencouragereporting.Thebreadthofindustrycampaignswithastrongcalltoactionhasplayedanimportantroleindeliveringactionableintelligencetolawenforcement.TMAlaunchedcampaignstargetingpassengerstravellingthroughmajornationalandregionalairportsaswellastheUK’slargestferryport.In2017thecampaignwasextendedtocoverspecificroutesfromEasternEurope.
BELFASTAIRPORT
EDINBURGHAIRPORT
GLASGOWAIRPORT
CARDIFFAIRPORT HEATHROW
AIRPORT
STANSTEDAIRPORT
DOVERPORT
FROMPOLAND
BATOverthepasttwelvemonths,BritishAmericanTobacco,UKandIreland,hasbeenworkingtohighlighttheissueofillicittradewithretailersacrossthecountry.AspartofourTradeengagementprogramme,wehaveworkedtohighlightandaddressthespreadofillicittradeanditsnegativeimpactonlegitimatebusinesses,retailersandconsumers.Aswellasdirectcommunicationwithindividualretailerswehaveundertakenanumberofroundtableeventsacrossthecountry.Theseeventsaimtodemonstrateandtobuildanunderstandingamongtheretailcommunityofhowwecanbestaddressthechallengeofillicittrade.
Overthecomingtwelvemonths,BATintendstolaunchanewAnti-IllicitTradeprogrammewhichwillseektotargetbothretailersandconsumersincommunitieswithhighlevelsofillicittradeandworktospecificallyhighlightthedangersoftheblackmarket.Thiswillbesupportedbyatargetedmediacampaign.
Imperial Tobacco LtdIn2017ImperialhasbeeninvolvedintwonationwidecampaignswithUKtradeassociations,theNationalFederationofRetailNewsagents(NFRN)andtheFederationofWholesaleDistributors(FWD)toraisetheprofileofouranti-illicittradeactivities.Inthetradepress,Imperialhasfocusedonthemesincludingacrackdownonsellingcounterfeittobaccooversocialmediaandtheincreasinguseofsnifferdogstohelpsniffoutillicittraders.Internally,thefocusisondistributingassetsfromtheSuspectit?Reportit!campaigntoassistImperialcolleaguesinotherkeyEuropeanmarkets(includingFranceandPoland)underthreatfromillegaltobacco.
JTIJTI’slongestablishedandsuccessfulDon’tBeTemptedcampaignmovedtoLondoninMay(2017),highlightingthescaleofillegaltobaccobeingsoldinretailoutletsinthecapital.Testpurchasingundertakenin400outletsshowedthat50ofthemweresellingillegaltobacco.Thisshockingfindingresultedin18newspaperarticles,sevenradioitemsandonetelevisioninterview.Oneofthemostpositiveoutcomesofthecampaignwasthereactionofthepublicwhichmanifesteditselfina12-foldincreaseinthenumberofcallstoCrimestoppersrelatedtoillegaltobaccosales.AlltheinformationfromthetestpurchaseshasbeenmadeavailabletotherelevantTradingStandardsdepartments.
5
Mobilising support: TMA member case studies
DODGY CIGARETTES AND TOBACCO BRING CRIME INTO YOUR COMMUNITY
If you have any information on those selling illegal tobacco contact the independent charity Crimestoppers anonymously on 0800 555 111 or through the Anonymous Online Form at www.crimestoppers-uk.org.
Alternatively contact HMRC’s Fraud Hotline on 0800 788 887.
JTI Anti Illegal Tobacco Campaign Ad 250x114mm.indd 1 10/05/2017 12:58
In addition to the issues raised through HMRC’s sanctions consultation, the Government should also:
• reviewtheLocalGovernmentDeclarationonTobaccoControlanditsimpactontacklingillicittrade
• ensurethatonlineplatformssuchassocialmediawebsitestakegreaterresponsibilityforthepromotionorsaleofillegaltobaccoviatheirplatforms
• introducefixedlimitsonpersonalimportsoftobaccointotheUKfromEUcountries
• makeitmandatoryforlandlordstoevicttenantswhoarecaughttradinginillegaltobacco.
DODGY BUSINESS
KE
KE
FA
FA FA
FAKE FA
TACKLINGTHEILLICITTOBACCOTRADE
Industry supports Government’s approachSanctions:theTMAhaslongcalledformoreeffectivesanctionsagainstthecriminalswhotradeinillegaltobaccoandhassetoutrecommendationsinresponsetoHMRC’sconsultationonthisissue.Manyofthemeasuresoutlinedinthe2017consultationreceivedstrongsupportfromadultsmokers.
Risingfinancialpenaltiesforrepeatoffenders
Onthespotfinesforthosesellingillegaltobacco
Makelandownersandlandlordsmoreresponsibleforillegalgoodssoldontheirpremises
Makeiteasiertonameandshamepeopleorcompaniesthatillegallyevadetobaccotax
PUBPUB
PUBPUB
Challenges remain
Practical solutions to help tackle the illegal trade
Experience has shown that action on this front is most effective when it is coordinated, involves the industry and all levels of law enforcement.
However,seriousoperationalandstructuralbarriersstillremain,mostnotably,atthelocallevelaroundtherole,effectivenessandcapacityofTradingStandardsandtheimpactoftheLocalGovernmentDeclarationonTobaccoControl(LGDTC),whichattimeshasbeenmisinterpretedbysomeTradingStandardsdepartments,resultingindisengagementwiththeindustry.
TMAmembercompaniesworkcloselywiththoseTradingStandardsdepartmentsthatarewillingtoengageonanumberofoperationalissuesthroughtheworkofbrandenforcementofficers,forexample,inauthenticatingseizedgoodsandprovidingintelligenceanddataforprosecutions.It’s vital that all local authorities take action to ensure engagement is allowed in an open and transparent manner, to effectively tackle the illicit tobacco trade.
PUBPUB
PUBPUB
SUPERMARKET PUBPUB
£££ DODGY BUSINESS
DODGY BUSINESS
EVICTED
107LIKES
NAME AND SHAME
FAKE