Independent RIAs Weigh in on What’s Ahead in 2017
January 10, 2017
1/9/2017
TD Ameritrade Institutional
RIA Sentiment Survey
About TD Ameritrade Institutional
TD Ameritrade Institutional is a leading provider of comprehensive brokerage and custody services to
more than 5,000 fee-based, independent registered investment advisors and their clients. Our
advanced technology platform, coupled with personal support from our dedicated service teams,
allows investment advisors to run their practices more efficiently and effectively while optimizing time
with clients. TD Ameritrade Institutional is a division of TD Ameritrade, Inc., a brokerage subsidiary of
TD Ameritrade Holding Corporation.
About TD Ameritrade Holding Corporation
Millions of investors and independent registered investment advisors turn to TD Ameritrade (Nasdaq:
AMTD) technology, people and education resources to help make investing and trading easier. Online
or over the phone. In a branch or with an independent RIA. First-timer or sophisticated trader. Our
clients want to take control, and we help them decide how - bringing Wall Street to Main Street for
more than 40 years. An official sponsor of the National Football League for the 2016 season, TD
Ameritrade has time and again been recognized as a leader in investment services. Visit TD
Ameritrade's newsroom or amtd.com for more information.
Brokerage services provided by TD Ameritrade, Inc., member FINRA /SIPC
TD Ameritrade Institutional is a division of TD Ameritrade, Inc., a brokerage subsidiary of TD
Ameritrade Holding Corporation.
Carefully consider the investment objectives, risks, charges and expenses
before investing in ETFs. A prospectus, obtained by calling 866-766-4015 ,
contains this and other important information about an investment company.
Read carefully before investing.
Past performance does not predict future results.
RIA optimism highest since 2009
More than half of independent registered investment advisors (“RIAs”) say they feel good about the
global economy, and seven out of 10 are optimistic on the US economy.
They are bullish on the US stock market and in particular, expect financials to do well under the
incoming Trump administration.
They’re watching interest rates and corporate earnings for their impact on client portfolios, and are
paying attention to the new administration and to oil as well.
RIAs use equity index and sector ETFs the most, and say that the quality of the underlying index is
the #1 reason to choose an ETF, followed by performance and total cost.
Enthusiasm for the new year comes on the heels of a successful 2016
In 2016, three out of five RIAs saw revenues increase, seven out of 10 had client assets increase,
and more of the same is expected for this year.
Nearly a third of new clients come to RIAs from full-commissioned brokers, followed by self-directed
investors seeking help from an RIA.
Though RIAs saw their tech spending increase the most in 2016, they say they’ll give their marketing
budgets the biggest boost in 2017 to achieve growth.
RIAs are ramping up marketing to fuel growth in 2017
Marketing is one of this year’s top three management initiatives among RIA firms
Marketing is to be the top business strategy for attracting clients of all ages and stages.
RIAs are using technology to improve the client experience, whether by investing in performance
reporting or financial planning tools, or by moving to e-signature or cloud based solutions.
RIAs are taking the changing competitive landscape in stride
More than eight out of 10 RIAs say they aren’t all that concerned about the ability of robo-advisors to
upend their client base.
Similarly, independent RIAs say they are ready for the April 10 deadline for compliance with the new
DOL conflicts of interest rule.
They’re taking business continuity planning seriously: 57% have finished plans and 32% have some
type of plan in the works.
RIAs on the Economy and Markets
61/9/2017
54% 69%
RIAs feel good about the economy
71/9/2017
Base: Total Respondents (n=306)
Q3. Looking ahead to the next six months, what is your outlook for the global economy through the first half of 2017? Would you say it is very
pessimistic, somewhat pessimistic, neutral, somewhat optimistic or very optimistic?
Q4. Again, looking ahead to the next six months, what is your outlook for the U.S. Economy through the first half of 2917?
2017 Outlook on Economy
9% 8%
36%
23%
45%
54%
9%15%
Global Economy Outlook US Economy Outlook
Very Optimistic
Somewhat Optimistic
Neutral
Somewhat Pessimistic
Very Pessimistic
Very Optimistic
Somewhat Optimist
Neutral
Somewhat Pessimistic
Very Pessimistic
15%
RIA optimism for the US economy is high
Trend in U.S. Economic Outlook
81/9/2017
Base: Total Respondents (n=306)
Q4. Again, looking ahead to the next six months, what is your outlook for the U.S. Economy through the first half of 2017?
In 2017, "Very Optimistic"
surged to 15%, the highest
recorded by this annual
benchmarking survey
RIAs are bullish on equities
Base: Total Respondents (n=306)
Q5. What is your outlook on the U.S. stock market through the first half of 2017? Do you think the stock market will… ?
Q6. What is your outlook on the U.S. bond market through the first half of 2017? Do you think the bond market will…?
9
1/9/2017
2017 Market Outlook: Stocks vs. Fixed-Income
Increase Remain / Same Decline
70%
12%
22%
35%
8%
53%
BondsStocks
101/9/2017
Base: Total (n=306)
Q8. With a new president soon taking office, what's your outlook for these sectors?
RIAs see most gains in financials, industrials & materials
Equity Sector Performance Outlook Under New Administration
Better Same Worse
Consumer Discretionary
Consumer Staples
Financials Materials Industrials Energy
Health Care IT Telecoms Utilities
111/9/2017
Base: Total (n=306)
Q7. Which of the following headlines are you watching for their potential impact on client portfolios?
RIAs are watching interest rates, corporate earnings
Factors Impacting Client Portfolios
Unemployment Potential China Slowdown Middle East Strife
Rate Increase Corporate Earnings Incoming Administration Oil/Gas Prices
Apply Now
121/9/2017
RIAs are keeping client assets diversified
Base: Total Respondents (n=306)
Q9. Approximately what percentage of assets that you manage for clients today is allocated to the following asset categories? (Mean with zero included)
Q10. Approximately what percentage of assets that you manage for clients today is allocated to the following asset categories Equities? (Mean with zero included)
Q11. Approximately what percentage of assets that you manage for clients today is allocated to the following asset categories Fixed Income? (Mean with zero included)
Equities
Fixed Income
Average Percent of Assets in Each Category
Corporates, 42%Government, 26%
Municipals, 20%International, 9%
Other, 3%
Spotlight on Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs)
131/9/2017
14
Base: Total (n=306)
Q48. What are your top reasons for buying or switching ETFs?
Asset allocation is the top reason advisors use ETFs
Top 5 Reasons RIAs use ETFs
Liquidity
Transaction Costs
Asset Allocation
Lower Costs of ETFs
Access New Asset Classes
15
Base: Total (n=259)
Q50: How frequently do you use these ETFs in client portfolios…?
RIAs favor equity index and sector ETFs for clients
Frequency of ETF Usage in Client Portfolios
Smart-Beta/
Fundamental Index Inverse/Leveraged
SometimesAlways Rarely/ Never
16
Base: Total (n=259)
Q49: What's the #1 factor influencing your decision to purchase a specific ETF?
Index quality is top factor when RIAs choose ETFs
What's the #1 Factor Influencing Your Decision to Purchase a Specific ETF?
1%
2%
6%
8%
14%
15%
35%Quality of the
Underlying Index
Performance
Total Costs
Liquidity of the ETF
Trading Costs
Brand
Tracking Error
Expense Ratio
20%
15%
14%
8%
6%
2%
1%
RIAs on Growth
171/9/2017
20162016
18
RIAs increased clients and revenue last year
New Client Growth - Past Six Months Revenue Growth - Past Six Months
Q15: Has the total number of clients served by your firm decreased, increased, or remained about the same over the past 6 months? (n=306)
Q16: ...By approximately what percentage has your firm's client base grown? Base: Those who increased clients (n=172)
Q21. Over the past six months, has your firm's revenue decreased, increased or remained the same? (n=306)
Q22. …By approximately what percentage has your firm's revenue grown? (n=184)
Remained about the same
Decreased
Increased
Average Growth Rate: 17%
vs 13% at the end of 2015
Average Growth Rate: 16%
vs 14% at the end of 2015
19
RIAs also increased assets under management
AUM Growth – Past Six Months AUM Outlook for 2017
Q15: Has the total number of clients served by your firm decreased, increased, or remained about the same over the past 6 months? (n=306)
Q16: ...By approximately what percentage has your firm's client base grown? Base: Those who increased clients (n=172)
Q21. Over the past six months, has your firm's revenue decreased, increased or remained the same? (n=306)
Q22. …By approximately what percentage has your firm's revenue grown? (n=184)
Remained about the same
Decreased
Increased
Average AUM Growth Rate
17% in late 2016, versus 15%
in year-ago period
20
Base: Total (n=306)
Q24: Over the past six months, from which type of competitor did the majority of your firm’s new client assets come?
Most new RIA clients came from commissioned brokers
2016
2017
6%
10%
13%
Full-commission brokers
Other RIAs
Banks
Self-directed investors
Clients who are new to investing
Merger, acquisition, or new advisor
onboarding*
Other places
*Asked for first time in 2017
Sources of New Clients – Past Six Months
21
Base: Total (n=306)
Q33: In 2016, in which of the following areas did your firm see the biggest increase in spending?
Q34: In 2016, in which of the following areas did your firm see the biggest decrease in spending?
Most RIAs said they spent more on technology…
* % of RIA Firms with a change
2016
RIAs Say Biggest Decreases in
Spending Were on...
33%
22%
15%
RIAs Say Biggest Increases in
Spending Were on...
Technology
Legal/
Compliance
Marketing
21%
17%
16%
Hiring/HR
Legal/
Compliance
Real Estate/
Related
… and cut back on hiring, real estate, legal and compliance
221/9/2017
Where Do RIAs Intend Increase Their 2017 Spending?
Base: Total (n=306)
Q35: In 2017, in which of the following areas do you expect your firm will realize the biggest increase in spending?
Marketing, technology are top priorities for higher
2017 spending
Marketing Technology Hiring/ HR Legal / Compliance
Client Relations Professional Development Real Estate Real Estate Outsourcing
Economy
Managing Firm Growth
Regulation
Average Client Age*
Succession Planning
Hiring/ Retaining Talent
Competition*
Technology*
The economy seen as impacting RIAs the most
231/9/2017
Base: Total (n=306)
Q13. Which of the following has the potential to have the greatest impact on your firm in 2017?
What Will Have the Biggest Impact on Your Firm?
* Not asked in 2015
Regulators seen as top threat to RIA firm growth
241/9/2017
Base: Total (n=306)
Q14. What are the top competitive threats to your business growth in 2017?
When asked what were the top competitive threats to the
growth of their firms, RIAs responded…
25
Base: Total (n=306)
Q32: Which of the following operational and business management initiatives are you currently implementing or planning to implement in 2017 to help your firm
grow? (Multiple responses accepted)
Marketing is among top priorities for RIAs in 2017
Operational / Management Initiatives Planned for 2017
Improve Efficiency Enhance Client Experience Marketing/ Social Media Invest in technology
Compliance Staff Development Merger and Acquisition Real Estate Outsourcing
26
Base: Total (n=306)
Q36: In 2017, which of the following new business strategies do you plan to pursue to attract new clients? (Multiple responses accepted)
Marketing is Top New Business Strategy for 2017
Planned Strategies for Attracting New Clients
*New in 2017
2017
2016
27
Base: Total (n=306)
Q37: Which of the following best describes your main planned strategy for attracting younger investors as clients?
RIAs will shift marketing to win next gen clients
Planned Strategies to Attract Younger Clients
Not currently working on strategy
Lower asset minimums
Change networking/marketing
Manage 401k plans
Hire younger advisors
Low Cost/ Robo
28
Base: Total (n=306)
Q39: Which ONE of the following technologies are you considering investing in most to help drive your growth in 2017?
Tech investments aim to improve the client experience
Technologies Under Consideration in 2017
29
Base: Total (n=306)
Q40: Which of the following advanced technology services or applications are you interested in introducing to your practice in the upcoming year? (Multiple
responses accepted)
When it comes to new tech, RIAs express most
interested in e-signature
Advanced Technologies Under Consideration for 2017
Aggregation
Rebalancing
Social Media
Video Chat
Cloud-Based Solutions
Mobile Payment
and Deposits
Robo
Advisor
E-Signature
RIAs on the 2017 Industry Landscape
301/9/2017
Not at all / Not
Very Concerned
31
Base: Total (n=306)
Q43: How concerned are you that "robo-advisors" pose a threat to your firm?
Base: Those extremely concerned (rated Q43 as 1-8 on 10 pt. scale) (n=300)
Q44: Why don't robo-advisors pose a significant threat to your firm?
Eight in 10 RIAs not overly concerned about robos
RIA Concern over Robo-Advisors
We attract a
different type of
client
Our growth has not
been impacted
Clients haven't
expressed any interest
in them
We are winning
business from
robos
We have launched our
own robo-offering
No significant
differences
compared to
2016 and 2015
Why Robo-Advisors Aren't a Threat
53%
2%
17%
28%
53%
Not at all
concerned
Not very
concerned
Somewhat
concerned
Extremely
concerned
81%
32
Base: Total (n=306)
Q45: How was the new DOL fiduciary rule impacted your business? (Multiple responses accepted)
Most RIAs say DOL rule has not impacted their firms
How Has the New DOL Fiduciary Rule Impacted Your Business?
M&A
Adding staff / retirement plans
Business as usual
Higher Legal/
Compliance
Expanding
retirement business
Exiting retirement business
Selling the firm
33
Base: Total (n=306)
Q26: Do you have a formal, documented business continuity and transition plan in place?
Q27: Are you aware of the SEC's proposed rule that would require RIAs to adopt and implement business continuity and transition plans (Rule 2006(4)-4)?
Continuity plans are underway, if not completed
Status of Business Continuity Plans Awareness of Proposed SEC Rule
206(4)-4 to Require Such Plans
Methodology
Results are based on a telephone survey, conducted by MaritzCX on behalf of TD
Ameritrade Institutional, a division of TD Ameritrade, Inc., between Nov. 14 and
Dec. 5, 2016.
306 independent registered investment advisors (RIAs) participated in this study.
Participants, both clients of TD Ameritrade Institutional and non-clients, were
asked to share their views on economy, the outlook for their firms and the RIA
market overall.
The margin of error is ± 5.6%. This means that in just over one case out of 20,
survey results based on 300 respondents will differ by not more than 5.6
percentage points in either direction from what would have been obtained by
seeking the opinions of all eligible RIAs.
MaritzCX and TD Ameritrade and separate and not affiliated and not responsible
for each other's services or policies
34