+ All Categories
Home > Documents > TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5...

TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5...

Date post: 11-Oct-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 0 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
44
Technical Report—Racial and Ethnic Disparities in the Health and Health Care of Children abstract OBJECTIVE: This technical report reviews and synthesizes the pub- lished literature on racial/ethnic disparities in children’s health and health care. METHODS: A systematic review of the literature was conducted for articles published between 1950 and March 2007. Inclusion criteria were peer-reviewed, original research articles in English on racial/ ethnic disparities in the health and health care of US children. Search terms used included “child,” “disparities,” and the Index Medicus terms for each racial/ethnic minority group. RESULTS: Of 781 articles initially reviewed, 111 met inclusion criteria and constituted the final database. Review of the literature revealed that racial/ethnic disparities in children’s health and health care are quite extensive, pervasive, and persistent. Disparities were noted across the spectrum of health and health care, including in mortality rates, access to care and use of services, prevention and population health, health status, adolescent health, chronic diseases, special health care needs, quality of care, and organ transplantation. Mortality-rate disparities were noted for children in all 4 major US racial/ethnic minority groups, including substantially greater risks than white children of all-cause mortality; death from drowning, from acute lymphoblastic leukemia, and after congenital heart defect sur- gery; and an earlier median age at death for those with Down syn- drome and congenital heart defects. Certain methodologic flaws were commonly observed among excluded studies, including failure to eval- uate children separately from adults (22%), combining all nonwhite children into 1 group (9%), and failure to provide a white comparison group (8%). Among studies in the final database, 22% did not perform multivariable or stratified analyses to ensure that disparities per- sisted after adjustment for potential confounders. CONCLUSIONS: Racial/ethnic disparities in children’s health and health care are extensive, pervasive, and persistent, and occur across the spectrum of health and health care. Methodologic flaws were iden- tified in how such disparities are sometimes documented and analyzed. Optimal health and health care for all children will require recognition of disparities as pervasive problems, methodologically sound disparities studies, and rigorous evaluation of disparities interventions. Pediatrics 2010;125:e979–e1020 Glenn Flores, MD, THE COMMITTEE ON PEDIATRIC RESEARCH KEY WORDS health care disparities, ethnic groups, Hispanic Americans, African Americans, Asian Americans, Indians, North American ABBREVIATIONS CDC—Centers for Disease Control and Prevention CI— confidence interval AAP—American Academy of Pediatrics AA—African American API—Asian/Pacific Islander AI/AN—American Indian/Alaska Native ALL—acute lymphoblastic leukemia ED— emergency department SCHIP—State Children’s Health Insurance Program ADHD—attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder SES—socioeconomic status This document is copyrighted and is property of the American Academy of Pediatrics and its Board of Directors. All authors have filed conflict of interest statements with the American Academy of Pediatrics. Any conflicts have been resolved through a process approved by the Board of Directors. The American Academy of Pediatrics has neither solicited nor accepted any commercial involvement in the development of the content of this publication. The guidance in this report does not indicate an exclusive course of treatment or serve as a standard of medical care. Variations, taking into account individual circumstances, may be appropriate. www.pediatrics.org/cgi/doi/10.1542/peds.2010-0188 doi:10.1542/peds.2010-0188 All technical reports from the American Academy of Pediatrics automatically expire 5 years after publication unless reaffirmed, revised, or retired at or before that time. PEDIATRICS (ISSN Numbers: Print, 0031-4005; Online, 1098-4275). Copyright © 2010 by the American Academy of Pediatrics FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS PEDIATRICS Volume 125, Number 4, April 2010 e979 by guest on March 5, 2021 www.aappublications.org/news Downloaded from
Transcript
Page 1: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

Technical Report—Racial and Ethnic Disparities inthe Health and Health Care of Children

abstractOBJECTIVE: This technical report reviews and synthesizes the pub-lished literature on racial/ethnic disparities in children’s health andhealth care.

METHODS: A systematic review of the literature was conducted forarticles published between 1950 and March 2007. Inclusion criteriawere peer-reviewed, original research articles in English on racial/ethnic disparities in the health and health care of US children. Searchterms used included “child,” “disparities,” and the Index Medicusterms for each racial/ethnic minority group.

RESULTS: Of 781 articles initially reviewed, 111 met inclusion criteriaand constituted the final database. Review of the literature revealedthat racial/ethnic disparities in children’s health and health care arequite extensive, pervasive, and persistent. Disparities were notedacross the spectrum of health and health care, including in mortalityrates, access to care and use of services, prevention and populationhealth, health status, adolescent health, chronic diseases, specialhealth care needs, quality of care, and organ transplantation.Mortality-rate disparities were noted for children in all 4 major USracial/ethnic minority groups, including substantially greater risksthan white children of all-cause mortality; death from drowning, fromacute lymphoblastic leukemia, and after congenital heart defect sur-gery; and an earlier median age at death for those with Down syn-drome and congenital heart defects. Certain methodologic flaws werecommonly observed among excluded studies, including failure to eval-uate children separately from adults (22%), combining all nonwhitechildren into 1 group (9%), and failure to provide a white comparisongroup (8%). Among studies in the final database, 22% did not performmultivariable or stratified analyses to ensure that disparities per-sisted after adjustment for potential confounders.

CONCLUSIONS: Racial/ethnic disparities in children’s health andhealth care are extensive, pervasive, and persistent, and occur acrossthe spectrum of health and health care. Methodologic flaws were iden-tified in how such disparities are sometimes documented and analyzed.Optimal health and health care for all children will require recognition ofdisparities as pervasive problems, methodologically sound disparitiesstudies, and rigorous evaluation of disparities interventions. Pediatrics2010;125:e979–e1020

Glenn Flores, MD, THE COMMITTEE ON PEDIATRIC RESEARCH

KEY WORDShealth care disparities, ethnic groups, Hispanic Americans,African Americans, Asian Americans, Indians, North American

ABBREVIATIONSCDC—Centers for Disease Control and PreventionCI—confidence intervalAAP—American Academy of PediatricsAA—African AmericanAPI—Asian/Pacific IslanderAI/AN—American Indian/Alaska NativeALL—acute lymphoblastic leukemiaED—emergency departmentSCHIP—State Children’s Health Insurance ProgramADHD—attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorderSES—socioeconomic status

This document is copyrighted and is property of the AmericanAcademy of Pediatrics and its Board of Directors. All authorshave filed conflict of interest statements with the AmericanAcademy of Pediatrics. Any conflicts have been resolved througha process approved by the Board of Directors. The AmericanAcademy of Pediatrics has neither solicited nor accepted anycommercial involvement in the development of the content ofthis publication.

The guidance in this report does not indicate an exclusivecourse of treatment or serve as a standard of medical care.Variations, taking into account individual circumstances, may beappropriate.

www.pediatrics.org/cgi/doi/10.1542/peds.2010-0188

doi:10.1542/peds.2010-0188

All technical reports from the American Academy of Pediatricsautomatically expire 5 years after publication unless reaffirmed,revised, or retired at or before that time.

PEDIATRICS (ISSN Numbers: Print, 0031-4005; Online, 1098-4275).

Copyright © 2010 by the American Academy of Pediatrics

FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS

PEDIATRICS Volume 125, Number 4, April 2010 e979 by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 2: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

INTRODUCTION

Racial/ethnic disparities in health andhealth care recently have receivedconsiderable attention. The Agency forHealthcare Research and Quality hasissued an annual national health caredisparities report since 2003.1,2 Reduc-tion and elimination of disparities isone of the major goals of Healthy Peo-ple 2010,3 part of the strategic plan ofthe Eunice Kennedy Shriver National In-stitute of Child Health and Human De-velopment,4 and part of the strategicimperatives of the Centers for DiseaseControl and Prevention (CDC).5 A sepa-rate National Institutes of Health cen-ter devoted to minority health andhealth disparities (the National Centerfor Minority Health and Health Dispar-ities) was founded in 2000.6 The Insti-tute of Medicine released a land-mark monograph on disparities,7

and a federal bipartisan bill target-ing health care disparities recentlywas introduced.8

Little attention has been paid, how-ever, to racial/ethnic disparities in thehealth and health care of children. Forexample, only 5 of 103 studies in theInstitute of Medicine’s extensive re-view of the literature on health caredisparities specifically addressed ra-cial/ethnic disparities in children’shealth care.7 The purpose of this tech-nical report, therefore, is to reviewand synthesize the published litera-ture on racial/ethnic disparities inchildren’s health and health care. Thereport begins with definitions of keyterms and an overview of sociodemo-graphic trends in minority children.Specific minority groups, the impor-tance of racial/ethnic subgroups, stud-ies of interventions to reduce racial/ethnic disparities, and methodologicissues are then reviewed.

DEFINITIONS

“Race/ethnicity” is defined as thechild’s racial or ethnic group (includ-

ing “multiracial”), as designated bythe parent and/or child. “Minority”will be the term used for children ofnonwhite race/ethnicity. Althoughmul-tiple definitions have been proposedfor the term “disparities,” the HealthResources and Services Administra-tion definition of disparities was used,whichdefinesdisparities as “population-specific differences in the presenceof disease, health outcomes, or accessto care.”9

METHODS

Only statistically significant disparitiesare reported herein (ie, those with ei-ther a P value of less than .05 or 95%confidence intervals [CIs] that are non-overlapping with non-Latino white chil-dren). The only exception to this rulewas inclusion of certain crude out-come rates in large population-basedsamples in which the differences wereconsidered quantitatively or clinicallysignificant (ie, when there was at leasta 50% difference in rates between aspecific racial/ethnic minority groupand the white population). Only studiesthat examined racial/ethnic dispari-ties in the context of comparisons towhite children were included in the lit-erature review. Notation was made ofwhether disparities included adjust-ment for relevant covariates. When ap-propriate data were available, seculartrends for specific disparities are de-scribed. Unless otherwise noted, thereference group for any racial/ethnicdisparity is non-Latino white children.

LITERATURE SEARCH

The scope of published literature onracial/ethnic disparities is broad. Inaddition, although racial/ethnic dis-parities in neonatal and infant mor-tality rates10 and dental care11 havebeen fairly well described, relativelylittle has been published on racial/ethnic disparities in children and ado-lescents. The terms that have beenused to describe disparities also have

been neither standardized nor consis-tent. As a consequence, the literaturesearch was limited to only those stud-ies that specifically examined racial/ethnic disparities for US children andadolescents, to ensure a focus on dis-parities and a body of literature in ur-gent need of a systematic review. Thus,articles on racial/ethnic disparities inneonatal and infant mortality and den-tal care were excluded, because dis-parities in these domains have com-paratively been more well described,and articles on pediatric workforce di-versity, an area that was addressed ina recent American Academy of Pediat-rics (AAP) policy statement,12 alsowere excluded.

The database used for the literaturesearch was Ovid Medline; the searchencompassed the years 1950 throughthe first week of March 2007. The initialsearch strategy included the terms“child” and “disparities” (both as med-ical subject heading terms and keywords), which yielded 666 citations. Toensure that no relevant citations weremissed, individual searches also wereperformed by using “disparities,”“child,” and Index Medicus terms foreach racial/ethnic minority group,which yielded the following children’sdisparities references: “African conti-nental ancestry group,” n� 35; “Asiancontinental ancestry group,” n � 5;“Pacific Islanders,” n � 2; “Indians,North American,” n� 17; “multiracial,”n� 1; and “Hispanic Americans,” n�55. The initial total of all citations was,therefore, 781 articles. To ensure theconsistency and reproducibility of thisliterature search, additional second-ary references were not included fromthe citation lists of the primary articlesincluded in the database.

Abstracts for all 781 articles were re-viewed. Because the focus of the liter-ature review was original, peer-reviewed articles in English on racial/ethnic disparities in the health and

e980 FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 3: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

health care of US children, review arti-cles, editorials, commentaries, per-spective pieces, theoretical or concep-tual pieces, transcripts of speeches,letters to the editor, dental care arti-cles, articles that addressed adults orthe elderly, articles without analysis ofracial/ethnic disparities, articles onneonatal or infant mortality issues, ar-ticles on workforce diversity, articlesthat did not examine disparities in thehealth of US children, and duplicate ci-tations were excluded. Application ofthese exclusion criteria yielded 227 ar-ticles. The full print versions of theseremaining 227 articles were reviewed,and reapplication of the exclusion cri-teria yielded a final database of 111articles, 2 of which examined interven-tions aimed at reducing racial/ethnicdisparities (and were consideredseparately).

SOCIODEMOGRAPHICS OFMINORITY CHILDREN IN THEUNITED STATES

The United States is experiencing a de-mographic surge in minority children(Fig 1). There are 31.4 million children(younger than 18 years old) of non-white race/ethnicity in the UnitedStates,13 comprising 43% of children,and representing an 11% increase

since 200014 and a 58% increase since1990.15 Since 2000,minorities have rep-resented more than half of the popula-tion of the nation’s 100 largest cities,and 42 of the 100 largest US cities are“minority majority” (defined as popu-lations in which racial/ethnic minori-ties outnumber the white popula-tion).16 In California, the largest statein the nation, minorities have outnum-bered whites since 2000, and currentlyrepresent 57% of the state’s popula-tion.17,18 Conservative estimates indi-cate that minorities will constitute halfof US children by 2040.19

Latinos are the largest and fastest-growing minority group of US children(Fig 1), representing 20% of children inAmerica (equivalent to 15 million).13,20

African Americans (AAs) are thesecond-largest minority group of USchildren, representing 15% of childrenin America (equivalent to 10.9 mil-lion)13; between 1990 and 2006, theirpopulation proportion slightly de-creased. Asians/Pacific Islanders(APIs) are the third-largest minoritygroup of US children, representing 4%of children in America (equivalent to 3million)13; between 2000 and 2006,their population proportion grew by14% (1990 US Census data are not

available on API children). American In-dians/Alaska Natives (AIs/ANs) repre-sent 1% of children in America (equiv-alent to �661 000)13; between 1990and 2006, their population proportiondecreased by 18%. The number of mul-tiracial children in the United States(ie, self-designated by the caregiver asbelonging to 2 or more races) in 2006was 2.9 million, representing 4% of theUS population of children,13 a propor-tion that has not changed since 1990.

HEALTH AND HEALTH CAREDISPARITIES IN SPECIFIC RACIAL/ETHNIC GROUPS OF CHILDREN

African Americans

The vast majority of articles (94 of 109[86%]) addressed disparities in AAchildren (Table 1).

Mortality

Eight articles documented AA/whitedisparities in mortality rates. Overallchildhood mortality rates were foundto be consistently higher for AA chil-dren; national data for a 43-year pe-riod revealed marked crude mortality-rate disparities in young children 1 to 4years of age (twice that of white chil-dren) and older children 5 to 14 yearsof age and increases in the mortality-disparity ratio in the most recent 10-year period. Two other studies thatadjusted for relevant covariates docu-mented significantly higher mortalityrates for AA children versus white chil-dren in the Detroit tri-county area forboys and older girls (10–19 years old)and among children without congeni-tal anomalies in the state of Michigan.AA children also experience higherrisks of death from drowning in aswimming pool, especially in publicpools, with the drowning rate in hotel/motel pools disproportionately higher.Significant disease-specific mortality-rate disparities were identified foracute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL),median age at death for Down syn-

4 4

-18.2

1.13.6

15.112.2

68.9

31.1

0.94.1

14.8

20.3

57.3

42.7

0

13.9

-2.0

-16.8

58.5

66.4

-30

-20

-10

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

% o

f p

op

ula

tion

1990 Census2006 ACSInterval increase

Nonwhite

White(non-Latino) Latino

AA API

AI/ANMultiracial

FIGURE 1Growth of racial/ethnic minority population of US children between 1990 and 2006. ACS indicatesAmerican Community Survey. Data were unavailable for APIs for the 1990 US Census, so data depictedare from the 2000 US Census.

FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS

PEDIATRICS Volume 125, Number 4, April 2010 e981 by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 4: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

TABLE1DisparitiesintheHealthandHealthCareofAAChildren

Disparity(vsWhiteChildren)

StudyDesign

SampleSize(s)

Notes

RefNo.

Accesstocare

Loweraccessibilitytopediatricprimarycareproviders

Analysisofspatialaccessibilitytopediatric

USCensusdataonallchildren

Notadjustedforcovariates

27NeighborhoodAAracemorestronglyassociatedwithaccessto

pediatricprimarycareprovidersthanneighborhoodincome

primarycareprovidersinWashington,DC

andAmericanMedical

Association/American

OsteopathicAssociation

dataonconcentrationofall

pediatricprimarycare

providersinWashington,DC

Doubletheadjustedoddsofhavingnousualsourceofcare

Analysisofhouseholdcomponentof1996and

AA:n

�2189;Latino:n

�Adjustedfor8covariates;doublethe

28Doubletheadjustedoddsofnohealthprofessional/doctorvisitin

pastyear

2000MEPS

4091;Asian:n

�325;white:

n�6362

adjustedoddsofdissatisfaction

withqualityofcarein1996butnot

2000

Higheradjustedoddsofappendicitisrupture

Cross-sectionalanalysisoffull-yearsamples

ofhospitaldischargerecordsforacute

appendicitisfromCaliforniaandNewYork

children4–18yofage

California:AA,n

�297;Latino,

n�4304;API,n

�459;

white,n

�4017;NewYork:

AA,n

�342;Latino,n

�444;API,n

�80;white,n

�2379

Adjustedfor7covariates

29

Higheradjustedproportioninfairorpoorhealthamongnew

SCHIPenrolleesinFlorida

AnalysisofCHIRIdataonnewSCHIPenrollees

in4states(�18yoldinAlabama,Kansas,

Totalsample:n

�8975b

Adjustedfor10covariates

30

LoweradjustedproportionhadusualsourceofcarebeforeSCHIP

amongnewSCHIPenrolleesinNewYork

andNewYork,and11.5–17.9yoldin

Florida)

BeforeenrollmentinSCHIP

InterviewsofparentsinNewYorkStateatthe

Totalsample:N

�2644b

Adjustedfor12covariates;1

31Loweradjustedrateofhavingusualsourceofcare

timeofSCHIPenrollmentoftheirchild

(baseline)andN

�2290

unadjustedquality-of-caredisparity

Higheradjustedrateofhavingunmetneedsforhealthcare

(baseline)and1yafterenrollment

(1-yfollow-up)

wasnotedbutnotadjustedfor

Greateradjustedoddsofnotbeingreferredtospecialistbyhealth

careprovider

Analysisofdataonchildren4–35moofage

fromtheNationalSurveyofEarly

ChildhoodHealth

AA:n

�477;Latino:n

�817;

white:n

�718

Adjustedfor9covariates

32

Adolescents

Higherlikelihoodoffairtopoorhealthamongadolescents

recentlyenrolledinSCHIP

AnalysisofCHIRItelephoneinterviewdataof

adolescentsnewlyenrolledinSCHIPin

Totalsample:N

�2036b

Nomultivariableadjustments

performed

33

Lesslikelytousedoctor’sofficesastheirusualsourceofcare

amongadolescentsrecentlyenrolledinSCHIP

FloridaandNewYork(andtheirparents)

Significantlyloweradjustedoddsofuseofsubstanceabuse

servicesamongadolescents

Analysisof5yofTennesseeMedicaid

(TennCare)enrollment,encounter,and

AA:n

�60104;white:n

�110552

Adjustedfor4covariates

34

Significantlyolderageatfirstuseofsubstanceabuseservices

claimsdataforsubstanceabuseservices

usebyadolescents12–17yofage

AAgirlsatparticularriskofunderuseofsubstanceabuse

services,withonly1in25AAfemaleteenagedsubstance

abusersaccessingsubstanceabuseservices

Femaleadolescents:higherriskofskippingbreakfast,obesity,

lackinghealthinsurance,needingbutnotgettingmedical

care,anysexuallytransmitteddisease,perpetratingviolence,

andbeingavictimofviolence

AnalysisofAddHealth(waves1and2),a

nationallyrepresentativeschool-based

studyofyouthsingrades7–12,withfollow-

upintoadulthood

AA:n

�3038;Latino:n

�2340;API:n

�1021;AI/AN:

n�136;white:n

�7728

Prevalenceinpublishedtableswasnot

adjusted;authorsstatedthat

adjustmentsforincomeand

parentaleducationhadminimal

influenceonfindings;significant

disparitieswereidentifiedbyusing

95%CIsthatdidnotoverlapwith

measureforwhitechildren;no

formalstatisticalevaluationof

disparitieswereprovidedinarticle

35

e982 FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 5: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

TABLE1Continued Disparity(vsWhiteChildren)

StudyDesign

SampleSize(s)

Notes

RefNo.

Maleadolescents:higherriskofperpetratingviolenceandbeing

victimofviolence

Livebirthratefor15-to17y-oldgirlswas

�3timeshigher

1990–1998natalityfilesfromtheNational

VitalStatisticssystem

Notprovided

Expressedasratesper1000;rates

werenotadjustedforany

covariates

36

Birthratefor15-to17y-oldgirlswas4–5timeshigher

AnalysisofvitalrecordsfromtheIllinoisand

Chicagodepartmentsofpublichealth

Notprovided

Notadjustedforcovariates

37AA/whitedisparityratioworsenedby23%between1990and1998

Birthratefor15-to19-y-oldgirlsmorethantwiceashigh

BirthcertificatedatareportedtoCDC

NationalCenterforHealthStatistics

Notprovided

Notadjustedforcovariates;noP

valuesor95%CIs

38

Greateradjustedoddsofalcoholtestingamongfemale

adolescentsadmittedtoEDsfortraumaticinjury

AnalysisofdatafromtheNationalTrauma

DataBank(includes64USinstitutions)on

adolescents12–17yofageadmittedtoEDs

withtraumaticinjury

AA:n

�1760;Latino:n

�396;

white:n

�5584

Adjustedfor7covariates

39

Asthmaandallergies

Highestasthmaprevalenceofanyracial/ethnicgroup(26%higher

vswhitechildren)

Trendsinasthmaovertimeforchildren0–17

yofageusingdatafrom5NationalCenter

Notprovided

Nostatisticalcomparisonsperformed

or95%CIsprovided;only

40

Highestasthma-attackprevalenceofanyracial/ethnicgroup(44%

highervswhitechildren)

forHealthStatisticssources:National

HealthInterviewSurvey,National

unadjustedrateswerepresented

Disparityvswhitechildrenhaswidenedprogressivelyover16-y

period,from15%higherprevalenceto26%higher

prevalencevswhitechildren

AmbulatoryMedicalCareSurvey,National

HospitalAmbulatoryMedicalCareSurvey,

NationalHospitalDischargeSurvey,and

Higherasthmaoffice-visitrate

mortalitycomponentoftheNationalVital

TripletherateofasthmaEDvisits

Statisticssystem

Tripletherateofhospitaloutpatientvisitsforasthma

Ambulatoryasthma-visitrate(alloutpatientvisittypes)1.6times

higher

Hospitalizationrate3.6timeshigher

Hospitalizationrateincreasedatmorethandoubletherateof

whitechildren

Highestasthmamortalityrateofanyracial/ethnicgroup,4.6times

higherthanthatofwhitechildren

Asthmamortalityrateincreasedover19y(vsremainedthesame

inwhitechildren)

Greaterlikelihoodofcurrentasthma

Nationaldatabase(NHIS)

AA:n

�14487;white:n

�Adjustedfor8covariates

41GreaterlikelihoodofEDvisitforasthmainpastyear

49042

Greateradjustedodds(adjustedoddsratio,2.5

�95%CI:1.3–4.8

�)ofphysician-diagnosedasthma,evenafteradjustmentfor

familyincome

RhodeIslandHealthInterviewSurvey

AA:n

�142;Latino:n

�353;

white:n

�1274

Adjustedfor7covariates

42

FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS

PEDIATRICS Volume 125, Number 4, April 2010 e983 by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 6: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

TABLE1Continued Disparity(vsWhiteChildren)

StudyDesign

SampleSize(s)

Notes

RefNo.

Higheradjustedoddsofasthma

Secondaryanalysisof2yofMEPSdataon

Total1996MEPSsamplesize:

Adjustedfor6–8covariates;in1

43Loweradjustedoddsofambulatoryvisits

children2–18yofage

N�3955;total1997MEPS

surveyyearbutnottheother,

Loweradjustedoddsofprescriptionsfilled

samplesize:N

�5933

significantlyloweradjustedoddsof

EDvisitsandinternalizingand

externalizingbehavioralconditions

Higherasthmamortalityrate,bothforunderlyingcauseandany

mention

Analysisof12yofdatafromthemultiple

cause-of-deathfilesfromtheNational

CenterforHealthStatistics

Totalsample:N

�4091a,b

Unadjustedrates,notadjustedforSES

orinsurancecoverage;asthma

mortalityratealsohigherthanthat

ofLatinoandAPIchildren

44

HigheradjustedoddsofanasthmaEDvisitorhospitalization

Analysisofdatafromparent-response

questionnairesadministeredin26

randomlyselectedNewYorkCitypublic

elementaryschools

Totalsample:N

�5250b

Adjustedfor4covariates

45

Higherdiagnosedasthmaprevalence(18%)

Cross-sectionalanalysisofparent-report

AA:n

�2938;Latino:n

�Notadjustedforcovariates

46Highertotalpotentialasthmaburden(diagnosedpluspossiblebut

undiagnosedasthma)

questionnairedatafrom14low-income,

diverseChicagopublicelementaryschools

6002;white:n

�1560

Morethandoubletheadjustedoddsofhavingacurrentasthma

diagnosis

AnalysisofNHANESIIIonchildren1–16yof

age

Totalsample:N

�11181b

Adjustedfor14covariates;samplesize

ofthosewithasthmawasnot

provided

47

Worseasthmaphysicalhealthscores

Cross-sectionalstudyusingparental

AA:n

�636;Latino:n

�313;

AdjustedforSES,healthstatus,age,

48Loweradjustedoddsofdailyanti-inflammatoryuseforasthma

telephoneinterviewsandelectronic

recordsforMedicaid-insuredchildren

2–16yofagewithasthmain5managed

careorganizationsinCalifornia,

Washington,andMassachusetts

white:n

�512

gender,andother

sociodemographicvariables

Higheradjustedoddsofcockroachallergensensitivity

Cross-sectionalanalysisofchildren

AA:n

�1502;Mexican

Adjustedfor8covariates

49Higheradjustedoddsofdustmiteallergensensitivity

6–16yofagewhoparticipatedinallergen

American:n

�1546;white:

Higheradjustedoddsofmoldallergensensitivity

testingintheNHANESIII

n�1116

Higheradjustedoddsofasthma

AnalysisofdatafromtheLosAngelesCounty

AA:n

�566;Latino:n

�3675;

Adjustedfor8covariates

50Higheradjustedoddsofneedforurgentmedicalcareforasthma

inpast12mo

HealthSurveyonchildren

�18yofage

API:n

�361;white:n

�1278

Loweradjustedoddsofuseof

�2-agonists

AnalysisofdatafromtheChildhoodAsthma

AA:n

�139;Latino:n

�255;

Adjustedfor9covariates

51Loweradjustedoddsofuseofinhaledsteroids

SeverityStudy,whichuseda12-mo,

retrospective,parent-reported

questionnaireonasthmainacommunity

sampleofchildren

�13yofageand

residinginConnecticutandMassachusetts

white:n

�549

Higheradjustedprevalenceofasthmaoverall

AnalysisofNHISdataonchildren0–17yofage

Adjustedfor8covariates;stratified

52Amongchildrenwithfamilyincomelessthanhalfthefederal

povertylevel,higherprevalenceofasthma

analysessuggesteddisparitiesonly

forpoorestchildren,butsample

sizesforotherstratamaynothave

beenadequate(andnotindicatedin

study)

e984 FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 7: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

TABLE1Continued Disparity(vsWhiteChildren)

StudyDesign

SampleSize(s)

Notes

RefNo.

Breastfeeding

Lowerproportionofchildreneverbreastfed

Analysisofbreastfeedingdataonchildren

AA:n

�1845;Mexican

Notadjustedforanycovariates

53Lowerproportionofchildrenwhoreceivedanyhumanmilkat6

moofage

12–71moofageintheNHANESIII(1988–

1994)

American:n

�2118;white:

n�1869

Lowerproportionofchildrenexclusivelybreastfedat4moofage

Cardiovascularandhypertension

Higherrelativeriskofallstrokes

AnalysesofdatabasesoftheOfficeof

Notprovided

Notadjustedforcovariates(except

54Higherrelativeriskofintracerebralhemorrhage

StatewideHealthPlanningand

sicklecelldisease)

Higherrelativeriskofsubarachnoidhemorrhage

DevelopmentofCaliforniafor10yonall

Higherrelativeriskofischemicstrokeafterexclusionofsicklecell

disease

admissionstononfederalhospitalsin

California

Healthstatus

Loweradjustedoddsofbeinginexcellent/verygoodhealth

Analysisofcross-sectionaldataonchildren

0–19yofagefromtheCaliforniaHealth

InterviewSurvey

Totalsample:N

�19485b

Adjustedfor4covariates;higher

adjustedoddsofmakingaphysician

visitinthepreviousyear

55

Higheradjustedlikelihoodoffairorpoorhealth

AnalysisofNHISdata

AA:n

�5776;API:n

�1088;

Notadjustedforfamilyincomeor

56Higheradjustedlikelihoodofactivitylimitations

Latino:n

�4785;white:

healthinsurancecoverage(adjusted

Higheradjustedlikelihoodofschoollimitations

n�20717

onlyforage,gender,andparental

education);loweradjusted

likelihoodofacuterespiratory

illnessandinjuries;interactions

notedbetweenrace/ethnicityand

parentaleducationforselected

outcomesinselectedgroups

Greateradjustedscoresofglobalstressinpreviousmonthamong

adolescents

Cohortofadolescentsingrades7–12in1

suburbanMidwesternpublicschool

district

AA:n

�550;white:n

�659

Adjustedfor7covariates;interaction

notedbetweenraceandcollege

education;stressrelatedtoracism

notexamined

57

Higheradjustedoddsofpoor,fair,orgoodhealthstatus(vs

excellent/verygood)

AnalysisofdatafromNationalSurveyofEarly

ChildhoodHealthonchildren4–35moof

age

Totalsample:N

�2068b

Adjustedfor8covariates

58

Greateradjustedoddsofnotbeinginexcellentorverygood

health

Analysisofdataonchildren4–35moofage

fromtheNationalSurveyofEarly

ChildhoodHealth

AA:n

�477;Latino:n

�817;

white:n

�718

Adjustedfor9covariates

32

HIV/AIDS

RepresentlargestpercentagesofnewHIV/AIDSdiagnosesinevery

agegroupofchildrenandadolescentsandinperinatal

transmission

DiagnosesofHIV/AIDSreportedtotheCDCin

2001–2004by33statesthatused

confidential,name-basedreportingofHIV/

AA:n

�11554;Latino:n

�3249;white:n

�3707a

No95%CIsorPvaluespresented;not

adjustedforSESorothercovariates

59

NumberofnewHIV/AIDSdiagnosesineveryagegroupofchildren

andadolescentsandinperinataltransmissionexceedthose

ofallotherracial/ethnicgroupscombined

AIDScasesforatleast4y

Amongfemales,percentagesofnewpediatricHIV/AIDSdiagnoses

are4–9timesthatforwhitefemales

Amongmales,percentagesofnewpediatricHIV/AIDSdiagnoses

are2–7timesthatforwhitemales

LongeradjustedlengthofhospitalstayforHIV-infectedchildren

CohortstudyofpediatricpatientswithHIVat

4sitesspecializinginthecareofpediatric

HIV-infectedpatients

AA:n

�390;Latino:n

�112;

white:n

�66

Adjustedfor8covariates;inpatient

length-of-staydataavailableononly

79patients

60

FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS

PEDIATRICS Volume 125, Number 4, April 2010 e985 by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 8: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

TABLE1Continued Disparity(vsWhiteChildren)

StudyDesign

SampleSize(s)

Notes

RefNo.

Hospitalizations

HigherhospitalizationratesforACSCs

Analysisof6yofdataonchildren1–14y

AA:n

�17599;white:n

�Notadjustedforcovariates;only

61HigherproportionofallhospitaldischargesattributabletoACSCs

ofagefromNationalHospitalDischarge

Surveys,USCensus,andtheNHIS

66270

examined6ACSCs

AsthmacomprisedmuchhigherproportionofallACSCs

Whiteracecategoryincludedallthose

withmissingrace

Immunization

Forchildren

�48moold,lowestrateofbeingup-to-dateon4:3:1:

3:3immunizationseries

RetrospectivecohortstudybasedonChicago

publicschools’computerized

Totalsample:N

�66556b

Notadjustedforcovariates

62

Substantiallygreaterdelayandlatermeanageforall

immunizationcategoriesanddoses

immunizationdatabaseonallchildren

completingkindergartenina2-yperiod

Infectiousdiseases(otherthanHIV/AIDS)

Higherrateratioofinvasivepneumococcaldiseaseamongall3

agegroupsanalyzed(�2,2–4,and5–17yofage)

Analysisofage-andrace-specific

pneumococcaldiseaseincidencerates

fromtheActiveBacterialCore

Surveillance/EmergingInfectionsProgram

Network,anactive,population-based

surveillancesystemin7states,usingdata

frombetweenJanuary1,1998,and

December31,2002

Notstatedforchildren

Notadjustedforcovariates

63

Higherincidencerateoftuberculosis

Analysisof8yofdataonchildren

�15yof

agefromtheNorthCarolinaTuberculosis

InformationManagementSystemdatabase

AA:n

�114;Latino:n

�33;

API:n

�12;white:n

�21

Notadjustedforanycovariates

64

Injuries

Firearminjuryrate

�13timeshigher

AnalysisofdatafromMinnesotaDepartment

ofHealth’sMinnesotaTraumaDataBankon

firearminjuriesinchildren0–19yofage

Totalsample:N

�175b

Notadjustedforcovariates

65

Higheradjustedoddsofnotputtingupstairgate

Analysisofdataonchildren4–35moofage

AA:n

�477;Latino:n

�817;

Adjustedfor9covariates

66Higheradjustedoddsofnotinstallingsafetylatchesorlockson

cabinets

fromtheNationalSurveyofEarly

ChildhoodHealth

white:n

�718

Higheradjustedoddsofnotturningdownhot-waterthermostat

setting

Mentalhealthandbehavioral/developmentalissues

Loweradjustedoddsofreceivingtreatmentfordepressionfroma

mentalhealthspecialist

AnalysisofNationalLongitudinalSurveyof

YouthandtheChild/YoungAdult

supplement,anationallyrepresentative

sampleof7-to14-y-oldchildren

Totalsample:N

�2482b

Adjustedfor28covariates;no

differencesforanyvisitorbehavior

problemvisit

67

LoweradjustedoddofbeingdiagnosedwithADHDwithouta

learningdisability

Analysisof5yoftheNHIS

AA:n

�3562;Latino:n

�5552;white:n

�11287

Adjustedforbirthweight,income,and

healthinsurancecoverage

68

LoweradjustedoddofbeingdiagnosedwithADHDwithalearning

disability

LoweradjustedoddsamongthosewithADHDofreceivingany

prescriptionmedication

e986 FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 9: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

TABLE1Continued Disparity(vsWhiteChildren)

StudyDesign

SampleSize(s)

Notes

RefNo.

Loweradjustedoddsofanymentalhealthserviceuse

Analysisofoutcomesforarandomsampleof

AA:n

�282;Latino:n

�332;

Parentsandchildrenwithlimited

69Loweradjustedoddsofoutpatientmentalhealthserviceuse

6-to18-y-oldyouthsreceivingservicesin

API:n

�88;white:n

�554

Englishproficiencywereexcluded;

Loweradjustedoddsofinformalmentalhealthserviceuse(self-

helpgroups,peercounseling,clergycounseling,or

alternativehealers)

�1of5SanDiegoCountypublicsectorsof

care(alcoholanddrugabuse,child

welfare,juvenilejustice,mentalhealth,

andpublicschooleducationservices)over

a1.5-yperiod

adjustmentfor12covariates

Amongthosewithautism,receivediagnosis1.4ylaterthanwhite

children(afteradjustment)

Analysisof7yofPhiladelphiaCounty

Medicaidclaimsdataforchildrenand

AA:n

�242;Latino:n

�33;

white:n

�118

Adjustedfor3covariates;Latino

childrendidnotsignificantlydiffer

70

Amongthosewithautism,inmentalhealthtreatmentanaverage

of13molongerthanwhitechildrenbeforereceiving

diagnosisofautism(afteradjustment)

adolescentswithautism

fromAAchildrenforanyfinding,but

nodirectLatino-whitecomparison

made

HigherproportionofparentswithchildrenwithADHDhad

negativeexpectationsaboutADHDtreatment(ie,thought

treatmentcouldnothelp)

District-widestratifiedrandomsampleof

1615elementary-schoolchildren

(kindergartenthrough5thgrade)innorth

AA:n

�201;white:n

�188

Adjustedfor8covariates,except

parent-reportedbarriers,which

wereunadjusted

71

AmongthosewithADHDorathighriskforADHD

centralFloridapublicschool;included

Loweradjustedoddsofreceivingprofessionalevaluationfor

ADHD

telephonecontacts,homevisits,and

teachersymptom-screeningquestionnaire

LoweradjustedoddsreceivingADHDdiagnosis

LoweradjustedoddsofcurrentlyreceivingtreatmentforADHD

Higheradjustedoddsofuseofstate-fundedmentalhealth

services

AnalysisofNewYorkCitydataonreceiptof

servicesfromstate-fundedmentalhealth

carefacilities

Totalsample:N

�78085

(includingadults)b

Adjustedfor7covariates

72

Higheradjustedoddsofdevelopmentaldelays(basedonparental

concerns)

AnalysisofdatafromNationalSurveyofEarly

ChildhoodHealthonchildren4–35moof

age

Totalsample:N

�2068b

Adjustedfor8covariates

58

Loweradjustedoddsofuseofspecialtymentalhealthservices

amongchildrenforwhomaninvestigationofabuseor

neglecthadbeenopenedbythechildwelfaresystem

AnalysisofdatafromtheNationalSurveyof

ChildandAdolescentWell-beingonuseof

specialtymentalhealthservicesfor1y

aftercontactwithchildwelfareamonga

cohortofchildren2–14yofage

AA:n

�899;Latino:n

�487;

white:n

�1208

Adjustedfor11covariatesand2

interactionterms

73

Loweradjustedoddsofreceiptofpsychotropicmedications

Cross-sectionalanalysisofcomputerized

AA:n

�112488;white:n

�Adjustedfor3covariates;disparities

74Loweradjustedoddsofreceiptofstimulantmedications

claimsforchildren2–19yofage

56858

persistedacross4categoriesof

Loweradjustedoddsofreceiptofantidepressants

continuouslyenrolledinamid-Atlantic

Medicaideligibility(SCHIP,

Loweradjustedoddsofreceiptofneuroleptics

stateMedicaidprogramfor1y

TemporaryAssistancetoNeedy

Families

�TANF�,fostercare,and

SupplementalSecurityIncome

�SSI

�)Higheradjustedoddsofchild’smealsnotbeingatthesametime

daily

Analysisofdataonchildren4–35moofage

fromtheNationalSurveyofEarly

AA:n

�477;Latino:n

�817;

white:n

�718

Adjustedfor9covariates

66

Higheradjustedoddsoffamilyeatinglunchordinnertogether

lessoftenthaneveryday

ChildhoodHealth

Higheradjustedoddsoffamilynevereatinglunchordinner

together

Watchanadjustedmeanof45minmoreoftelevisiondaily

Higheradjustedoddsofreadingtochildlessoftenthaneveryday

Loweradjustedmeannumberofchildren’sbooksinhome

FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS

PEDIATRICS Volume 125, Number 4, April 2010 e987 by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 10: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

TABLE1Continued Disparity(vsWhiteChildren)

StudyDesign

SampleSize(s)

Notes

RefNo.

Mortality

Higheradjustedratesofdrowninginaswimmingpool

Analysisof4yofnationaldatafromthe

AA:n

�316;Latino:n

�81;

Adjustedforincome;valuesexpressed

75Higheradjustedratesofdrowninginpublicpools,especially

hotel/motelpools

ConsumerProductsSafetyCommissionon

drowningdeathsofchildren5–24yofage

fromdeathcertificates,medicalexaminer

reports,andnewspaperclippings

AI/AN:n

�18;white:n

�222

asrateratiosand95%CIs,butnoP

valuesprovided

HigheradjustedchildmortalityrateamongboysintheDetroit

tri-countyarea

Combineddeath-certificateandcensusdata

onchildhoodmortalityin3major

AA:n

�13744;white:n

�54846

Adjustedforage,gender,andcensus

tractincome;noconsistentadjusted

76

Higheradjustedchildmortalityrateamong10-to19-y-oldgirlsin

theDetroittri-countyarea

metropolitanareas:Chicago,Detroit,and

NewYork

disparitiesobservedforother2

citiesanalyzed(NewYorkand

Chicago)

MedianageatdeathforthosewithDownsyndromesubstantially

lower(25vs50yamongwhiteindividuals)

Analysisofdatafrommultiple-cause

mortalityfilesonalldeathswitha

Notindicated

Notadjustedforcovariates;includedin

thisanalysisbecauseDown

77

Substantiallyloweraverageincreaseinmedianageatdeathfor

thosewithDownsyndromebetween1968and1997(0.7vs1.9

inwhiteindividuals)

diagnosticcodeforDownsyndrome

syndromecustomarilyviewedas

primarilyapediatricentity

Mortalityfromcongenitalheartdefects19%higheranddeclined

moreslowlyover18-yperiod

Analysisofdatafrommultiple-cause

mortalityfilescompiledbytheNational

Notindicated

Notadjustedforcovariates;small

samplesizesforchildren1–4y

78

Infantmortalityrateforventricularseptaldefecthigherand

persistentlyhigherover18-yperiod

CenterforHealthStatisticsfromalldeath

certificatesfiledintheUnitedStateswith

Lowerincreaseofaverageageatdeathfromcongenitalheart

defectsovertime

anymentionofacongenitalheartdefect

Averageageatdeathfromcongenitalheartdefects3–6times

lower

Abouthalftheaverageageatdeathvswhiteindividualsfor5

specificcongenitalheartdefects:transpositionofthegreat

arteries,tetralogyofFallot,ventricularseptaldefect,

pulmonaryvalveanomalies,andsingleventricle

Almosttwicethemortalityrateforchildren1–4yofagebetween

1950and1993

Analysisof43yofdataonchildren5–14yof

agefromtheNationalVitalStatistics

Notindicated(exceptfortwo

3-yintervals)

Notadjustedforcovariates;presented

onlyaspopulationrates;no

79

Black/whitedisparityratioinmortalityrateforchildren1–4yof

ageincreasedsomewhatduringthemostrecent10-yperiod

examined

System,theNationalLongitudinalMortality

Study,andtheAreaResourceFile

statisticalcomparisonsor95%CIs

Approximately50%highermortalityrateforchildren5–14yof

agebetween1950and1993

Black/whitedisparityratioinmortalityrateforchildren5–14yof

ageincreasedsomewhatduringmostrecent10-yperiod

examined

Higheradjustedrelativeriskofdeathamongchildrenwithout

congenitalanomalies

Retrospectivecohortstudyoflinkedbirth

anddeathfilesforstateofMichiganover

6-yperiod

Totalmortalitysample:N

�8362b

Adjustedfor4covariates;nomortality

disparitiesamongchildrenwith

congenitalanomalies

80

e988 FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 11: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

TABLE1Continued Disparity(vsWhiteChildren)

StudyDesign

SampleSize(s)

Notes

RefNo.

HigheradjustedriskofdeathamongthosewithALL

Analysisof9population-basedregistriesof

theNationalCancerInstitute’s

Surveillance,Epidemiology,andEnd

Resultsprogram

AA:n

�356;Latino:n

�504;

NA:n

�61;API:n

�410;

white:n

�3621

Adjustedfor3covariates;didnot

adjustforSESorinsurance

coverage

81

Higheradjustedoddsofin-hospitaldeathaftercongenitalheart

surgery

AnalysisofdatafromtheKID2000ofthe

HCUP,limitedto19stateswithadequate

race/ethnicitydata

AA:n

�860;Latino:n

�1835;

white:n

�4134

Adjustedfor8covariates

82

Nephrology

Amongthosewithend-stagerenaldisease,2.4timesmorelikelyto

beonhemodialysisratherthanperitonealdialysis

AnalysisofdatafromMedicareEnd-Stage

RenalDiseaseregistryonallMedicare-

eligiblechildren0–19yofageundergoing

renalreplacementtherapyintheUnited

States

AA:n

�368;white:n

�870

Adjustedfor10covariates

83

Loweradjustedhemodialysisdose

Childrenandadolescents

�18yoldwithin

AA:n

�65;white:n

�46

Adjustedfor6covariates

84Fourto5timesgreateradjustedlikelihoodofinadequate

hemodialysisdose

theNorthAmericanPediatricRenal

TransplantCooperativeStudyregistrywho

beganmaintenancehemodialysisduringa

6.5-yperiodandwhoreceivedatleast6

consecutivemoofhemodialysis

Amongchildrenwithend-stagerenaldisease,loweradjusted

likelihoodtobeactivatedonthekidneytransplantwaiting

list

Nationallongitudinalcohortstudyusingdata

fromUSRenalDataSystemonchildren

0–18yofagewithend-stagerenaldisease

AA:n

�1122;white:n

�2162

Adjustedfor5covariates;stratified

Kaplan-Meieranalysessuggested

thatracialdisparitiesmayvaryby

SES,withsignificantdifferencesin

lowestbutnothighestSESquartile

85

Obesity,physicalactivity,andnutrition

Selectlargerbodysizeforidealadultbodysizeandidealopposite-

genderadultbodysize

Cross-sectionalsurveyofrandomsampleof

all4th-and6th-gradersinSouthCarolina

AA:n

�749;white:n

�848

Adjustedfor2–3covariates

86

Lesspersonalandfamily/peerconcernaboutweight

publicschools

Significantlyfewertryingtoloseweight

Loweradjustedaerobicfitnesslevel

Progressivetreadmillprotocolevaluationof

aerobicfitness(V̇O 2peak)ofLosAngeles

children7–14yofage,adjustingfor

gender,maturationalstage,andbody

composition

AA:n

�19;Latino:n

�36;

white:n

�18

Adjustedfor3covariatesbutdidnot

includeSES

87

Higheradjustedoddsofoverweight

Analysisofheightandweightdatacollected

during3moofphysicalfitnesstestingof

studentsingrades5,7,and9intheLos

AngelesCountypublicschoolsystem

Totalsample:N

�281630b

Adjustedfor4covariates

88

Higheradjustedlikelihoodofinsulinresistance(cross-sectional

assessment)

Analysisof3yoflongitudinaldatafromthe

PrincetonSchoolDistrictStudyof5th-to

12th-gradersin1suburbanMidwestern

publicschooldistrict

AA:n

�542;white:n

�625

Adjustedfor9covariates;no

significantassociationwithchange

ininsulinresistanceovertime

89

Higherprevalenceofoverweightinboysamong8th-graders(35%)

and10th-graders(35%)

Analysisof10–17yofdatafromMonitoring

theFuture,anationallyrepresentative

Totalsample:N

�4800–17074perstudy

Notadjustedforcovariates

90

Higherprevalenceofoverweightingirlsamong8th-graders

(32%),10th-graders(34%),and12th-graders(28%)(highest

prevalenceamongallracial/ethnicgroupsstudied)

sampleofstudentsinthe8th,10th,and

12thgrades

interval,dependingon

gradeandyeara

Lowerlikelihoodofeatingbreakfastregularly

FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS

PEDIATRICS Volume 125, Number 4, April 2010 e989 by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 12: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

TABLE1Continued Disparity(vsWhiteChildren)

StudyDesign

SampleSize(s)

Notes

RefNo.

Lesslikelytoregularlyexercisevigorouslyamonggirls

Highernumberofhoursoftelevision-viewingonaverageweekday

Higherprevalenceofoverweightandobesityamonggirls(highest

ofanyracial/ethnicgroup)

Cross-sectionalsurveyofadolescents11–18y

ofagein31publicschoolsinthe

Totalsample:N

�4746b

Notadjustedforcovariates,butthe

authorsstatedthatstratified

91

Morelikelytoconsume

�30%ofcaloriesasfatand

�10%of

caloriesassaturatedfat(highestofanyracial/ethnicgroup)

Minneapolis,StPaul,andOsseoschool

districtsofMinnesota

analysesadjustingforgradeand

SESwereperformedbutnot

Lowercalciumintake

reported,becausetheygenerally

showedpatternssimilartothoseof

unadjustedanalyses

HighermeanBMI

Cross-sectionalsurveyandweightandheight

AA:n

�121;Latino:n

�70;

Notadjustedforcovariates;unclear

92HigherBMIpercentile

measurementsofallchildrenin5thgrade

white:n

�12

whatproportionofpotential

Lowermeanconsumptionoffiberper1000kcal

in2middleschoolsinScottCounty,

participantsrefusedtoparticipate

Lowermeanscoresonself-administeredhealthknowledge

questionnaire

Mississippi

Higherprevalenceofoverweight

AnalysisofNHANESdataonchildren2–19yof

agefrom1999–2000and2001–2002

AA:n

�1274;Latino:n

�1475;white:n

�1094

Notadjustedforcovariates

93Higherprevalenceofoverweightamong6-to11-y-olds

Higherprevalenceofoverweightamong12-to19-y-olds

Higherprevalenceofoverweightamonggirls

Higherprevalenceofoverweightamong6-to11-y-oldgirls

Higherprevalenceofoverweightamong12-to19-y-oldgirls

Higherprevalenceofatriskofoverweightoroverweight

Higherprevalenceofatriskofoverweightoroverweightamong

12-to19-y-olds

Higherprevalenceofatriskofoverweightoroverweightamong

girls

Higherprevalenceofatriskofoverweightoroverweightamong

12-to19-y-oldgirls

Higheradjustedoddsofoverweight

Cross-sectionalsampleofCaliforniapublic

AA:n

�58491;Latino:n

�Adjustedfor2covariatesandstratified

94Sloweradjusted1-milerun/walktime

school5th,7th,and9th-graders(10–15y

ofage)

330758;Asian:n

�63292;

PacificIslanders:n

�7977;

Filipino:n

�22598;NA:n

�7977;white:275722

accordingtoage

Ophthalmology

Loweradjustedoddsofbeingdiagnosedwithanyeyeorvision

condition

Analysisof6yofdataforchildren0–17yof

ageintheMEPS

Totalsample:N

�2813b

Adjustedfor13covariates;theauthors

concludedthatdisparitiesindicate

95

Loweradjustedoddsofbeingdiagnosedwithaneyeorvision

conditionotherthanconjunctivitis

possibleunderdiagnosis,

undertreatment,orboth

Orthopedicissues

Fortreatmentofsupracondylarhumerusfractures,morelikelyto

undergoclosedreductionwithinternalfixation

(percutaneouspinning)

Retrospectiveexaminationofselected

pediatricfracturesintheKIDoftheHCUP

AA:n

�207;Latino:n

�659;

white:n

�1478

Notadjustedforcovariates;no

disparitiesforfemurorforearm

fractures

96

Quality

Loweradjustedoddsofreceivinganycounselingduringwell-child

visits

Cross-sectionalanalysisof10yofdataon

children0–18yofagefromtheNational

AmbulatoryMedicalCareSurvey

Totalsample:N

�2892b

Adjustedfor7covariates

97

e990 FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 13: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

TABLE1Continued Disparity(vsWhiteChildren)

StudyDesign

SampleSize(s)

Notes

RefNo.

Loweradjustedoddsofreceivinganyscreeningduringwell-child

visits

Loweradjustedlikelihoodofmeetingrecommendednumberof

well-childvisits

Analysisof3yofdataforchildren0–17yof

ageintheMEPS

AA:n

�5137;API:n

�890;

Latino:n

�9392;white:n

�14041

Adjustedfor10covariates

98

ChildrenwithcardiovasculardiseasehadbidirectionalGlenn

surgeryatsignificantlyoldermedianage(11vs6moofage

amongwhiteinfants)

ReviewofsurgicaldatabaseatDuke

UniversityMedicalCenterofallchildren

whounderwentbidirectionalGlennor

AA:n

�20;white:n

�47

Althoughnotadjustedforcovariates,

nosignificantdifferencesfound

betweenAAandwhitechildrenin

99

ChildrenwithcardiovasculardiseasehadFontanprocedureat

significantlyoldermedianage(60vs36moofageamong

whitechildren)

Fontanstagesofsingle-ventriclepalliation

overa4-yperiod

medianfamilyincomeforeither

measure

Lowerprimarycareproviderstrength-of-affiliationscores

(unadjustedandadjusted)

Telephonesurveyofparentsofrandom

sampleof413childrenattending

AA:n

�100;API:n

�91;

Latino:n

�84;white:

Adjustedfor11covariates

100

Lowerprimarycareproviderinterpersonalrelationshipscores

(unadjustedandadjusted

�ifrequiredbymanagedcare

organizationtostayinnetwork�)

elementaryschoolin3suburban

communitiesinSanBernardinoCounty,

California

n�102

Loweradjustedscoresfortimelinessofcare

Analysisofparentalsurveydataonchildren

AA:n

�1344;Latino:n

�842;

Adjustedfor4covariates

101

Loweradjustedscoresforhealthinsuranceplanservice

0–17yofagefromthenationalCAHPS

API:n

�291;AI/AN:n

�Loweradjustedscoresforgettingneededmedicalcare

BenchmarkingDatabase1.0administered

byMedicaidsponsorscomprising33

healthmaintenanceorganizationsfrom

Arkansas,Kansas,Minnesota,Oklahoma,

Vermont,andWashington

330;white:n

�6328

Loweradjustedscoresforcomprehensivenessofprimarycare

Cross-sectionalsurveyofparentsofchildren

in228classes,fromkindergartenthrough

6thgrade,at18elementaryschoolsina

largeurbanschooldistrictinCalifornia

AA:n

�458;API:n

�1158;

Latino:n

�1292;white:n

�479

Adjustedfor5covariates

102

Greateradjustedoddsofchildbeingassignedtohealthcare

provider

Analysisofdataonchildren4–35moofage

fromtheNationalSurveyofEarly

AA:n

�477;Latino:n

�817;

white:n

�718

Adjustedfor9covariates

32

Greateradjustedoddsofhealthcareprovidernever/only

sometimesunderstandinghowparentpreferstorearchild

ChildhoodHealth

Greateradjustedoddsofdiscussingviolenceinthecommunity,

smokinginthehousehold,useofalcoholordrugsin

household,troublepayingforchild’sneeds,andspouse/

partnersupportiveofparentingefforts

Specialhealthcareneeds

Loweradjustedoddsofreceivingadequatetimeandinformation

fromchild’shealthcareprovider,amongchildrenwith

specialhealthcareneeds

AnalysisofNationalSurveyofChildrenWith

SpecialHealthCareNeeds

Totalsample:N

�38866b

Adjustedfor6covariates;no

disparitiesinanyunmetneedor

problemwithspecialtyreferral

103

Amongchildrenwithspecialhealthcareneeds

Analysisofdataonchildren0–17yofage

AA:n

�1762;Latino:n

�Adjustedfor9–10covariates

104

Higheradjustedoddsofnotidentifyingaregularclinician

withspecialhealthcareneedsintheNHIS

1777;white:n

�6365

Loweradjustedoddsofusualsourceofcarebeingdoctor’s

privateofficeorhealthmaintenanceorganization

ondisability

Average2fewerdoctorvisitsperyear

Amongchildrenwithspecialhealthcareneeds

Analysisofdataonchildren0–17yofage

Notindicated

Adjustedfor6covariates

105

Higheradjustedoddsofchildhavingnophysicianornurse

fromNationalSurveyofChildrenwith

Higheradjustedoddsofdissatisfactionwithcare

SpecialHealthCareNeeds

FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS

PEDIATRICS Volume 125, Number 4, April 2010 e991 by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 14: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

TABLE1Continued Disparity(vsWhiteChildren)

StudyDesign

SampleSize(s)

Notes

RefNo.

Amongchildrenwithspecialneeds

Analysisofdataonspecialneedschildren

AA:n

�3820;Latino:n

�Adjustedfor13covariates

106

Greateradjustedoddsofproblemswitheaseofusinghealth

careservices

0–17yofagefromtheNationalSurveyof

ChildrenWithSpecialHealthCareNeeds

3210;white:n

�28916

Surgery

Forthosehospitalizedforappendicitis

Analysisofdataonchildren1–17yofage

Totalsample:N

�428463b

Notadjustedforcovariatesfortimeto

107

Longertimetooperation(regardlessofdiseaseseverity)

withappendicitisfromtheNationwide

operation,lengthofstay,orhospital

Longerlengthofstay(regardlessofdiseaseseverity)

InpatientSampleandtheKID

charges;otheroutcomesinclude

Higherhospitalcharges(regardlessofdiseaseseverity)

adjustmentfor6covariates

Higheradjustedoddsofperforationorothercomplicating

factors

Loweradjustedoddsofalaparoscopicprocedure

Transplantation

Lowerproportion(0%)receivedpreemptivetransplants

Retrospectiveanalysisoftransplantdatabase

AA:n

�37;white:n

�192

RelativelysmallsamplesizeofAA

108

Fewerlivingtransplantsandmorecadaverictransplantsinmost

recenttimeperiod

atCincinnatiChildren’sHospital

children;notadjustedforcovariates

Causeofend-stagerenaldiseasemorelikelytobeacquiredand

lesslikelytobecongenitalormetabolic

Approximatelydoubletheadjustedoddsofhearttransplantation

graftfailure

Analysisof18yofdatafromtheUnited

NetworkforOrganSharing,including

AA:n

�717;white:n

�3510

Adjustmentfor13covariates

109

Lower5-yhearttransplantgraftsurvivalrate

annualfollow-upoftransplantrecipients

Medianhearttransplantgraftsurvivalrate(5.3y)

�6ylower

thanthatforwhitechildren(11.0)

Medianageathearttransplant(8y)5yolderthanthatforwhite

children(3y)

MorelikelytohaveHLAmismatch

Useofhealthservices

Reducedphysicianvisitsundermandatoryenrollmentinmanaged

careamongthosewithMedicaid

Difference-in-differenceanalysisofpre/post

impactofmandatoryenrollmentin

managedcareforMedicaidbeneficiaries

in2unnamedcountiesinanunnamed

Midwesternstate

AA:n

�4891;white:n

�4460

Adjustedfor3covariates(allsubjects

enrolledinMedicaid,sonoSES

adjustment);nodifferences

observedinhospitalizationsorED

use

110

HigheradjustedlikelihoodofmedicallyunnecessaryEMS

transports

AnalysisoflinkedEMSandEDbillingrecords

forallEMS-to-hospitaltransportsof

children0–17yoldoriginatingin3

countiesinSouthCarolinaover27mo

AA:n

�4331;Latino:n

�75;

other:n

�48;white:n

�1239

Adjustedfor4covariates

111

Greateradjustedoddsof

�1ysincelastphysicianvisit

Analysisof3yofNHISdataonchildren0–17y

AA:n

�17324;Latino:n

�Adjustedfor4covariates

112

Loweradjustednumberofphysicianvisitsinprevious12mo

old

12765;API:n

�2516;AI/AN:

Doubletheoddsofsuboptimalhealthstatus

n�1067;white:n

�62572

Amongthosehospitalizedforpneumonia

Analysisof3yofdataonchildren0–17y

AA:n

�17095;Latino:n

�Adjustedfor6–7covariates

113

HigheradjustedriskratioofadmissionthroughEDs

ofagehospitalizedforpneumoniafromthe

15152;API:n

�2050;white:

Loweradjustedoddsofbronchoscopy

NationalInpatientSampleoftheHCUP

n�43180

Loweradjustedoddsofmechanicalventilation

Shorteradjustedlengthofstay

Higheradjustedcharges

e992 FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 15: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

drome, congenital heart defects (bothin terms of the fatality rate and a loweraverage age at death), and in-hospitaldeath after congenital heart surgery.

Access to Care and Use of Services

Multiple noteworthy disparities weredocumented in access to health careand use of health services (Table 1).Disparities in access to care includehigher rates than those of white chil-dren of unmet health care needs,lower rates of access to primary careproviders (including race being morestrongly associated with this outcomethan income), a higher likelihood ofhaving no usual source of care,greater odds of not being referred to aspecialist by the health care provider,higher hospitalization rates for ambu-latory care–sensitive conditions, andhigher odds of appendicitis rupture(considered an access indicator, be-cause it indicates failed access totimely, appropriate care early in thecourse of appendicitis). Disparities inthe use of health services includelower physician-visit rates and higherodds of going 1 year or longer from thelast physician visit, a higher rate ofemergency department (ED) visits,greater likelihood of medically unnec-essary Emergency Medical Servicestransports, fewer calls to physicians’offices, and, among those with Medic-aid coverage, lower odds of well-childcare and diagnosis and treatment forvarious pediatric conditions, andlower expenditures for outpatient andED care and for prescriptions.

Prevention and Population Health

Disparities were identified in breast-feeding, immunization rates, injuries,obesity, physical activity, and nutrition(Table 1). Breastfeeding is significantlyless likely among AA versus white in-fants, whethermeasured by ever beingbreastfed, the proportion exclusivelybreastfed, or the proportion receivingany human milk. AA children have theTA

BLE1Continued Disparity(vsWhiteChildren)

StudyDesign

SampleSize(s)

Notes

RefNo.

AmongMedicaid-coveredchildren

AnalysisofdataonNorthCarolinaMedicaid-

AA:n

�9288;white:n

�11351c

Adjustedfor8–9covariates

114

Loweradjustedoddsofwell-childcarevisitinpreviousyear(at

1,2,and4yofage)

coveredchildren1–4yofagefromlinked

Medicaid,WICservice,andbirthcertificate

data

Loweradjustedoddsofdiagnosisandtreatmentforotitis

media

Loweradjustedoddsofdiagnosisandtreatmentforupper

respiratoryinfections

Loweradjustedoddsofdiagnosisandtreatmentforlower

respiratoryinfections

Loweradjustedoddsofdiagnosisandtreatmentfor

gastroenteritis

Higheradjustedoddsofdiagnosisandtreatmentforasthma

LoweradjustedoutpatientMedicaidexpenditures

LoweradjustedEDMedicaidexpenditures(for3-and4-y-olds)

LoweradjustedprescriptiondrugMedicaidexpenditures

Loweradjustedmeannumberofcallstodoctor’sofficeinpast

year

Analysisofdataonchildren4–35moofage

fromtheNationalSurveyofEarly

AA:n

�477;Latino:n

�817;

white:n

�718

Adjustedfor9covariates

32

Greateradjustedoddsofatleast1EDvisitinpreviousyear

ChildhoodHealth

MEPSindicatesMedicalExpenditurePanelSurvey;CHIRI,ChildHealthInsuranceResearchInitiative;AddHealth,NationalLongitudinalStudyofAdolescentHealth;NHIS,NationalHealthInterviewSurvey;NHANES,NationalHealthandNutritionExamination

Survey;ACSC,ambulatory-care–sensitivecondition;4:3:1:3:3,combinedseriescomposedof

�4dosesofdiphtheriaandtetanustoxoidsandpertussis/diphtheriaandtetanustoxoids/diphtheriaandtetanustoxoidsandacellularpertussisvaccine,

�3

dosesofpoliovirusvaccine,

�1doseofmeasles-containingvaccine,

�3dosesofHaemophilusinfluenzaetypebvaccine,and

�3dosesofhepatitisBvaccine;V̇ O2,oxygenconsumptionperunittime;KID,Kid’sInpatientDatabase;HCUP,HealthcareCost

andUtilizationProject;CAHPS,ConsumerAssessmentofHealthPlansStudy;EMS,EmergencyMedicalServices;WIC,SupplementalNutritionProgramforWomen,Infants,andChildren.

aSamplesizesincludethose0to24yofage,becausethose15to24yofageweregroupedtogether.

bSamplesizeswerenotdisaggregatedinarticleaccordingtorace/ethnicity.

cSamplesizesforinitialcohort(1-y-olds)

FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS

PEDIATRICS Volume 125, Number 4, April 2010 e993 by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 16: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

lowest immunization rates for the pri-mary immunization series and havesubstantially greater delays and alater mean age for multiple immuniza-tion categories and doses. They have asubstantially higher firearm injuryrate and, as young children, havehigher odds of living in householdswithout stair gates, cabinet safetylatches or locks, or hot-water thermo-stat settings that have been turneddown.

Studies consistently document higherrates of obesity and overweight in AAchildren (Table 1). One study also re-vealed selection of larger body sizewhen asked to identify ideal adult bodysize; less personal, family, and peerconcern about weight; and fewer chil-dren trying to lose weight. Disparitiesalso have been identified in lower aer-obic fitness levels, slower 1-mile run/walk time, lower likelihood of vigorousexercise in females, and higher num-bers of television-viewing hours. Nutri-tional disparities include a higher like-lihood of consuming more calories asfat and saturated fat, lower mean con-sumption of fiber and calcium, andlower likelihood of eating breakfastregularly.

Adolescent Health Issues

AA female adolescents have higherrisks versus white female adolescentsof skipping breakfast, being obese,lacking health insurance, needing butnot getting medical care, having anysexually transmitted disease, perpe-trating violence, and being a victim ofviolence (Table 1). Several studieshave also documented live birth ratesthat are 2 to 5 times higher than forwhite female adolescents, and the dis-parity ratio has worsened over time.AA female adolescents also havegreater adjusted odds of alcohol test-ing when seen in the ED for traumaticinjury and are particularly at high riskof underusing substance abuse ser-

vices. Male AA adolescents have ahigher risk of perpetrating violenceand being a victim of violence. For AAadolescents of both genders, higherrisks were identified for underuse ofsubstance abuse services, older age atfirst use of substance abuse services,and suboptimal health status andlower use of physicians’ offices as theusual source of care among those re-cently enrolled in a State Children’sHealth Insurance Program (SCHIP).

Health Status

Multiple studies have documentedhealth-status disparities for AA chil-dren, whether analyzing global healthstatus or the prevalence of specificconditions (Table 1). Three studies re-vealed that AA children have higher ad-justed odds of fair or poor health andlower odds of excellent or very goodhealth. Higher rates of activity limita-tions, school limitations, and globalstress also were noted. Significantlyhigher crude rates than in white chil-dren have been seen for all stroke cat-egories (both hemorrhagic and isch-emic), invasive pneumococcal disease,and tuberculosis. HIV/AIDS disparitiesare substantial, and include the larg-est percentages and numbers of newdiagnoses in every age group of chil-dren and adolescents and via perinataltransmission, as well as longer ad-justed lengths of stay for those whoare hospitalized.

Asthma, Mental Health Care, andSpecial Health Care Needs

A particularly extensive body of litera-ture is available on disparities for 3specific issues: asthma, mental healthcare (including behavioral and devel-opmental issues), and special healthcare needs (Table 1).

Several studies have documented thatAA children have the highest asthmaprevalence of any racial/ethnic group,and this prevalence is substantiallyhigher than that for white children

(Table 1). Secular-trend data indicatethat this disparity has widened overtime. Compared with white children,AA children also experience substan-tially higher rates of asthma mortality,hospitalizations, ED visits, and officevisits, and the disparities in asthmamortality and hospitalizations havewidened over time. Additional asthmadisparities include higher attack prev-alence; lower rates of filled prescrip-tions; higher potential disease burden(diagnosed plus possible but undiag-nosed disease); worse asthma physicalhealth scores; lower odds of use of �2-agonists, inhaled steroids, anddaily anti-inflammatory medication; and higherodds of sensitivities to cockroach, dustmite, and mold allergens.

Several key disparities were noted inmental health care and behavioral/de-velopmental disorders. Most study re-sults have indicated lower use of men-tal health services, including loweradjusted odds of any mental healthservice use, outpatient service use, in-formal service use (such as self-helpand peer counseling), receiving treat-ment for depression from mentalhealth specialists, and receipt of psy-chotropic, stimulant, antidepressant,or neuroleptic medications (Table 1).One study, however, found higher oddsof use of state-funded mental healthservices in New York City. Higher ad-justed odds of developmental delayshave been noted, but underdiagnosis,undertreatment, and other disparitiesfor attention-deficit/hyperactivity dis-order (ADHD)were found in other stud-ies, including lower adjusted odds ofevaluation, receiving a diagnosis, andreceiving medication or treatment,and higher proportions of parentswith negative expectations abouttreatment helpfulness. AA childrenalso were found to receive a diagnosisof autism 1.4 years later than whitechildren and to be in mental healthtreatment an average of 13 months

e994 FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 17: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

longer than white children before re-ceiving the autism diagnosis.

National data reveal several dispari-ties for AA children with special healthcare needs (Table 1), including higherodds of having no regular health careprovider, averaging fewer physicianvisits, being dissatisfied with care, en-countering problems with ease of useof services, and not receiving ade-quate time and information from chil-dren’s health care providers.

Quality

Numerous disparities were identifiedin quality of care (Table 1). Lower ad-justed odds versus white childrenwere noted for meeting the recom-mended number of well-child visitsand receiving any counseling orscreening during well-child visits.Lower adjusted scores were observedfor timeliness of care, health insur-ance plan service, getting neededmed-ical care, primary care comprehen-siveness, primary care providerstrength of affiliation, and primarycare provider interpersonal relation-ships. Greater adjusted odds werefound for the child being assigned tothe health care provider; the providernever/only sometimes understandinghow the parent prefers to rear thechild; and the provider discussing vio-lence in the community, smoking in thehousehold, using alcohol or drugs inhousehold, trouble paying for child’sneeds, and spouse/partner support ofparenting efforts.

Among those with end-stage renal dis-ease, AA children are substantially lesslikely than white children to be acti-vated on the kidney transplant waitinglist but are significantly more likely toreceive hemodialysis rather than peri-toneal dialysis and to receive an inad-equate hemodialysis dose. AA childrenhave lower odds than white children ofbeing diagnosed with any eye or visioncondition, are more likely to undergo

closed reduction with internal fixationof supracondylar humerus fractures,undergo bidirectional Glenn and Fon-tan procedures at significantly olderages among those with cardiovasculardisease, and have longer time to oper-ation and lengths of stay, higher hospi-tal charges, higher odds of perforationand other complications, and lowersodds of laparoscopic proceduresamong those with appendicitis. AA pa-tients who have a heart transplanthave double the odds of graft failure,lower graft survival rates, a mediangraft survival time that is 6 yearslower, a median age at heart trans-plant that is 5 years greater, and ahigher likelihood of HLA mismatch. AAchildren are less likely to receive pre-emptive kidney transplants, and theyreceive fewer living transplants andmore cadaveric transplants.

Asians/Pacific Islanders

There were 24 articles (24 of 109[22%]) that addressed disparities inAPI children (Table 2).

Mortality

Only 1 study (Table 2) examined mor-tality among APIs; it revealed that na-tive Hawaiian children have a highercrude mortality rate than that of whitechildren.

Access to Care and Use of Services

Several studies found disparities forAPI versus white children in access tohealth care and use of health services(Table 2). API children have greater ad-justed odds of having no usual sourceof care, having made no visit to a phy-sician or other health care provider inthe past year, and going more than 1year since the last physician visit, aswell as a lower adjusted number ofphysician visits in the past year.Higher adjusted odds of appendicitisrupture also were noted. Among chil-dren with cancer, Pacific Islandershad significantly greater odds of

death, untimely treatment, not com-pleting treatment as recommended,and loss to follow-up.

Prevention and Population Health

Disparities were identified in injuries,lead intoxication, obesity, and nutrition(Table 2). Data from the state of Minne-sota revealed triple the crude firearminjury rate of that in white children. APIchildren were found to have the high-est proportion of elevated blood leadconcentrations in the state of RhodeIsland and are the only racial/ethnicgroup whose rate increased over time.Higher adjusted odds of overweightoccur among Pacific Islander, Filipino,and Asian children, and slower ad-justed 1-mile run/walk times werenoted for most age groups of API chil-dren. API children also have a lowercalcium intake—the lowest of anyracial/ethnic group.

Adolescent Health Issues

Compared with white adolescents, APIadolescents were found to have loweradjusted odds of seatbelt use, sun-screen use, and weekly physical activ-ity and greater adjusted daily hoursof television/video-game screen time(Table 2).

Health Status

APIs have a higher adjusted likelihoodthan that of whites to have fair or poorhealth status (Table 2). Data from thestate of Hawaii revealed that Filipinoand Chinese boys have the highestrates of leukemia, and Chinese boyshave the highest ALL rate.

Mental Health Care

API children have been found to havelower adjusted odds of any mentalhealth service use, outpatient mentalhealth service use, and 24-hour-careservice use (ie, inpatient, residential,group-home, or alcohol/drug abusetreatment) (Table 2). New York Citydata, however, indicate higher ad-

FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS

PEDIATRICS Volume 125, Number 4, April 2010 e995 by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 18: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

TABLE2DisparitiesintheHealthandHealthCareofAPIChildren

Disparity(vsWhiteChildren)

StudyDesign

SampleSize(s)

Notes

RefNo.

Accesstocare

Doubletotripleadjustedoddsofhavingnousual

sourceofcare

Analysisofhouseholdcomponentofthe1996

and2000MEPS

Asian:n

�325;AA:n

�2189;Latino:

n�4091;white:n

�6362

Adjustedfor8covariates;5timestheadjusted

oddsofdissatisfactionwithqualityofcare

28

Doubletotripleadjustedoddsofnohealth

professional/doctorvisitinpreviousyear

in2000butnot1996

Higheradjustedoddsofappendicitisrupture

Cross-sectionalanalysisoffull-yearsamplesof

hospitaldischargerecordsforacute

appendicitisfromCaliforniaandNewYork

children4–18yofage

California:API,n

�459;AA,n

�297;

Latino,n

�4304;white,n

�4017;

NewYork:API,n

�80;AA,n

�342;Latino,n

�444;white,n

�2379

Adjustedfor7covariates

29

Amongchildrenwithcancer,comparedwith

Hawaiianresidents,PacificIslandershad

significantlygreateroddsofdeath,untimely

treatment,notcompletingtreatmentas

recommended,andlosstofollowup

Retrospectivecase-comparisonstudy

PacificIslander:n

�100;Hawaiian

residents:n

�100

Notadjustedforcovariates

115

Adolescents

Loweradjustedoddsofseatbeltuse

AnalysisofCaliforniaHealthInterviewSurvey

API:n

�376;Latino:n

�1515;

Adjustedfor5covariates;interactionsnoted

116

Loweradjustedoddsofsunscreenuse

dataonadolescents12–17yofage

white:n

�3263

withgenerationalstatusforcertain

Loweradjustedoddsofweeklyphysicalactivity

outcomes

Greateradjusteddailyhoursoftelevision/video-

gamescreentime

Cancer

AmongHawaiianracial/ethnicgroups,Filipinoand

Chineseboyshavehighestratesofleukemia,

andChineseboyshavehighestALLrate

Tumorregistryanalysis

Totalcancercases:N

�1237

Adjustedonlyforage

117

Healthstatus

Higheradjustedlikelihoodoffairorpoorhealth

AnalysisofNHISdata

API:n

�1088;AA:n

�5776;Latino:

n�4785;white:n

�20717

Adjustedfor3covariates(butnotfamily

incomeorhealthinsurancecoverage)

56

Interactionsbetweenrace/ethnicityand

parentaleducationforselectedoutcomes

inselectedgroups

Injuries

Triplethefirearminjuryrate

AnalysisofdatafromMinnesotaDepartmentof

Health’sMinnesotaTraumaDataBankon

fatalandnonfatalfirearminjuriesin

children0–19yofage

Totalsample:N

�175a

Notadjustedforcovariates

65

Leadintoxication

APIchildrenhavethehighestproportionofelevated

bloodleadlevels(23%)inRhodeIslandand

areonlygroupwhoseproportionincreased

overtime

RhodeIslandDepartmentofHealth

SurveillanceData

Notstated

NotadjustedforSESorothercovariates

118

Mentalhealthandbehavioral/developmental

issues

Loweradjustedoddsofanymentalhealthservice

use

Analysisofoutcomesforrandomsampleof6-

to18-y-oldyouthsreceivingservicesin

�1

of5SanDiegoCountypublicsectorsofcare

(alcoholanddrugabuse,childwelfare,

juvenilejustice,mentalhealth,andpublic

schooleducationservices)over1.5-yperiod

API:n

�88;AA:n

�282;Latino:n

�332;white:n

�554

ParentsandchildrenwithlimitedEnglish

proficiencywereexcluded

69

e996 FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 19: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

TABLE2Continued

Disparity(vsWhiteChildren)

StudyDesign

SampleSize(s)

Notes

RefNo.

Loweradjustedoddsofoutpatientmentalhealth

serviceuse

Adjustedfor12covariates

Loweradjustedoddsof24-h-careserviceuse

(inpatient,residentialgrouphome,oralcohol/

drugabusetreatment)

Higheradjustedoddsofuseofstate-fundedmental

healthservices

AnalysisofNewYorkCitydataonreceiptof

servicesfromstate-fundedmentalhealth

carefacilities

Totalsample:N

�78085(including

adults)a

Adjustedfor7covariates

72

Mortality

Approximately50%highermortalityratefor

children1–4yofage

Analysisof43yofdataonchildren5–14yof

agefromtheNationalVitalStatistics

Hawaiianresidents:n

�142;white:

67200

Notadjustedforcovariates;presentedonlyas

populationrates;nostatistical

79

Almost50%highermortalityrateforchildren

5–14yofage

System,theNationalLongitudinalMortality

Study,andtheAreaResourceFile

comparisonsor95%CIs;smallsamplesizes

forHawaiianresidents

Obesity,physicalactivity,andnutrition

HigheradjustedoddsofoverweightamongPacific

Islanderchildren

Analysisofheightandweightdatacollected

during3moofphysicalfitnesstestingof

studentsingrades5,7,and9intheLos

AngelesCountypublicschoolsystem

Totalsample:N

�281630a

Adjustedfor4covariates;Asians(asopposed

toPacificIslanders)hadloweradjusted

odds(vswhitechildren)ofoverweight

88

Lowercalciumintake(lowestofanyracial/ethnic

group)

Cross-sectionalsurveyofadolescents11–18y

ofagein31publicschoolsinthe

Minneapolis,StPaul,andOsseoschool

districtsofMinnesota

Totalsample:N

�4746a

Notadjustedforcovariates;theauthorsstated

thatstratifiedanalysesadjustingforgrade

andSESwereperformedbutnotreported

becausetheygenerallyshowedpatterns

similartothoseofunadjustedanalyses

91

HigheradjustedoddsofoverweightinFilipinos,

PacificIslanders,andAsians(butonlyinmales

forAsians)

Cross-sectionalsampleofCaliforniapublic

school5th-,7th-,and9th-graders(10–15yof

age)

Asian:n

�63292;PacificIslander:

n�7977;Filipino:n

�22598;AA:

n�58491;Latino:n

�330758;

Adjustedfor2covariatesandstratified

accordingtoage;APIchildrenstratifiedas

Asian,Filipino,andPacificIslander;run/

94

Sloweradjusted1-milerun/walktime

NA:n

�7977;white:275722

walktimedifferencesnotsignificantfor

certainspecificagestrataforAsian(2),

Filipino(4),andPacificIslander(7)

Quality

Lowerqualityofprimarycare(accordingto

parentalassessment)

Cross-sectionalsurveyofparentsof

elementary-schoolchildren5–12yofagein

1schooldistrict,usingPrimaryCare

AssessmentTool

API:n

�96;AA:n

�106;Latino:n

�96;white:n

�105

Adjustedfor12covariates;smallersample

size(n

�135)forfullmultivariable

analysismayhavehadlimitedpowerto

detectotherdisparities

119

Lowerprimarycareproviderinterpersonal

relationshipscores(unadjustedandadjusted)

Telephonesurveyofparentsofrandomsample

of413childrenattendingelementaryschool

in3suburbancommunitiesinSan

BernardinoCounty,California

API:n

�91;AA:n

�100;Latino:n

�84;white:n

�102

Adjustedfor11covariates

100

Amongthoseinwhichtheprimarylanguagespoken

athomeisalanguageotherthanEnglish

Analysisofparentalsurveydataonchildren

0–17yofagefromthenationalCAHPS

API:n

�291;AA:n

�1344;Latino:

n�842;AI/AN:n

�330;white:

Adjustedfor4covariates;nodisparitiesfor

APIchildreninhouseholdsinwhichEnglish

101

Loweradjustedscoresfortimelinessofcare

BenchmarkingDatabase1.0administered

n�6328

isprimarylanguage;surveywas

Loweradjustedscoresforprovider

communication

byMedicaidsponsorscomprising33health

maintenanceorganizationsfromArkansas,

administeredonlyinEnglishandSpanish

Loweradjustedscoresforstaffhelpfulness

Kansas,Minnesota,Oklahoma,Vermont,and

Washington

FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS

PEDIATRICS Volume 125, Number 4, April 2010 e997 by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 20: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

TABLE2Continued

Disparity(vsWhiteChildren)

StudyDesign

SampleSize(s)

Notes

RefNo.

Loweradjustedscoresforhealthinsuranceplan

service

Loweradjustedscoresforgettingneeded

medicalcare

Loweradjustedratingsofchild’shealthcare

Loweradjustedoverallqualityofprimarycare

scores

Cross-sectionalsurveyofparentsofchildren

in228classes,fromkindergartenthrough

6thgrade,at18elementaryschoolsina

largeurbanschooldistrictinCalifornia

API:n

�1158;AA:n

�458;Latino:n

�1292;white:n

�479

Adjustedfor5covariates

102

ForthoseinterviewedinEnglish

Loweradjustedscoresontimelyandconvenient

accesstoprimarycare

Loweradjustedscoresonhowwellprimarycare

physicianlistensandexplainsduring

interactions

Loweradjustedscoresforcomprehensivenessof

primarycare

Loweradjustedscoresoncoordinationof

primarycare

Amongthosehospitalizedforpneumonia

Analysisof3yofdataonchildren0–17yof

API:n

�2050;AA:n

�17095;

Adjustedfor6–7covariates

113

Loweradjustedoddsofbronchoscopy

agehospitalizedforpneumoniafrom

Latino:n

�15152;white:n

�Loweradjustedoddsofmechanicalventilation

theNationalInpatientSampleoftheHCUP

43180

Longeradjustedlengthofstay

Higheradjustedcharges

Loweradjustedscoresforinterpersonal

relationshipwithprimarycareprovider

Telephonesurveysonprimarycare

experiencesofchildrenbyusingarandom,

API:n

�88;AA:n

�94;Latino:n

�84;white:n

�92

Adjustedfor9covariates;findingsheldtrue

regardlessofwhethertherewaspatient/

120

Loweradjustedscoresforspecificprimarycare

servicesavailabletochild

cross-sectionalsampleofparentsof

elementaryschoolchildren5–12yofagein

aschooldistrictinSanBernardino,CA

providerracial/ethnicconcordance

Useofhealthservices

Analysisofcross-sectionaldataonchildren

Loweradjustedoddsofbeinginexcellent/verygood

0–19yofagefromtheCaliforniaHealth

Totalsample:N

�19485

Adjustedfor7covariates

55health

Loweradjustedoddsofmakingaphysicianvisitin

InterviewSurvey

Analysisof3yofdataforchildren0–17yof

API:n

�890;AA:n

�5137;Latino:

n�9392;white:n

�14041

Adjustedfor10covariates

Adjustedfor4covariates

98 112

thepreviousyear

Loweradjustedlikelihoodofmeetingrecommended

numberofwell-childvisits

ageintheMEPS

Analysisof3yofNHISdataonchildren

0–17yofage

API:n

�2516;AA:n

�17324;

Latino:n

�12765;AI/AN:n

�1067;white:n

�62572

Greateradjustedoddsof

�1ysincelastphysician

visit

Loweradjustednumberofphysicianvisitsin

previous12mo

Greateradjustedoddsofsuboptimalhealthstatus

MEPSindicatesMedicalExpenditurePanelSurvey;NHIS,NationalHealthInterviewSurvey;HCUP,HealthcareCostandUtilizationProject;CAHPS,ConsumerAssessmentofHealthPlansStudy.

aSamplesizeswerenotdisaggregatedinarticleaccordingtorace/ethnicity.

e998 FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 21: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

justed odds of use of state-fundedmental health services.

Quality

Several studies have documented APIdisparities in primary care quality, in-cluding lower overall quality of pri-mary care scores, lower primary careprovider interpersonal relationshipscores, and lower scores for specificprimary care services available to thechild (Table 2). Lower adjusted pri-mary care quality scores have beenfound for 4 elements of care among APIparents interviewed in English and 6elements of care among API parentsfor whom the primary language spo-ken at home is not English. Amongthose hospitalized for pneumonia, APIchildren have lower adjusted odds ofbronchoscopy and mechanical ventila-tion, a longer adjusted length of stay,and higher adjusted charges.

Latinos

There were 66 articles (67 of 109[61%]) that addressed disparities inLatino children (Table 3).

Mortality

Puerto Rican children 1 to 4 years ofage were found to have a higher crudemortality rate than their white coun-terparts (Table 3). A higher drowningrate in neighborhood pools for Latinosalso was found, along with higherswimming pool drowning rates in gen-eral for Latino male adolescents.Higher adjusted risks of death existamong Latinos (versus whites) withALL and after congenital heart surgery.

Access to Care and Use of Services

Multiple studies have documented awide range of disparities in access tocare and use of services for Latino chil-dren (Table 3). In comparison withwhite children, Latino children havegreater adjusted odds of being unin-sured, having no usual source of careor health care provider, having made

no physician visit in the past year, hav-ing gone 1 year or more since the lastphysician visit, making fewer physi-cian visits in the past year, makingfewer calls to physicians’ offices, notbeing referred to a specialist, having aperforated appendicitis, and never oronly sometimes getting medical carewithout long waits, getting timely rou-tine care or telephone help, and get-ting brief wait times for medical ap-pointments. Similar findings werenoted in studies that focused on Lati-nos before or at the time of enrollmentin SCHIP and amongMexican Americanchildren.

Prevention and Population Health

Disparities were identified in breast-feeding, injuries, obesity, physical ac-tivity, and nutrition (Table 3). Com-pared with white infants, a lowercrude proportion of Mexican-Americaninfants are ever breastfed. Latinohouseholds with children 4 to 35months of age have lower adjustedodds than do white households of put-ting up stair gates. Multiple studieshave documented significantly higheradjusted odds of overweight and obe-sity, including 2 studies that showedthat Latinos have the highest adjustedrates of overweight and obesity of anyracial/ethnic group. Physical-activitydisparities included lower adjustedaerobic fitness, slower 1-mile run/walk times, higher average number oftelevision-viewing hours on the aver-age weekday, and lower regular vigor-ous physical activity among females.Lower calcium intake has been noted,as has as a higher likelihood of con-sumption of more than 10% of caloriesas saturated fat.

Adolescent Health Issues

Latina adolescents have a higher riskthan do white adolescents of not hav-ing health insurance, perpetrating vio-lence, and being a victim of violence.Disparities for male adolescents in-

clude a higher risk of no health insur-ance, going more than 2 years sincethe last physical examination, and be-ing a victim of violence (Table 3). Latinoadolescents recently enrolled in SCHIPhave a higher crude likelihood of fairor poor health and are less likely touse physician’s offices as their usualsource of care. Latina adolescents 15to 19 years of age have a crude birthrate 3 times higher than their whitecounterparts and the highest of any ra-cial/ethnic group. Latino adolescentshave a lower adjusted odds of beingtreated in the ED for sexually transmit-ted diseases, but male Latino adoles-cents with traumatic injuries have ahigher adjusted odds of alcohol testingin the ED. Latino adolescents also havelower adjusted odds of bicycle helmetand sunscreen use.

Health Status

National data reveal a higher adjustedlikelihood of fair or poor health in Lati-nos (Table 3). Compared with whites,Latinos also have twice the percentageof new HIV/AIDS diagnoses amongthose younger than 13 years old, inperinatal transmission, and amongother pediatric cases. They also have ahigher crude incidence rate of tuber-culosis. In terms of Latino subgroups,both Mexican American and PuertoRican children have higher adjustedodds of fair or poor health status.

Asthma, Mental Health Care, andSpecial Health Care Needs

An analysis of national data revealedthat Latinos have a higher asthmaprevalence than do whites, and therehas been a substantial increase inLatino asthma prevalence over time(Table 3). Several studies have docu-mented a particularly high asthmaprevalence among Puerto Ricans.Other asthma disparities includehigher adjusted odds of asthma ED vis-its, hospitalizations, activity limita-tions, and the need for urgent care in

FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS

PEDIATRICS Volume 125, Number 4, April 2010 e999 by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 22: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

TABLE3DisparitiesintheHealthandHealthCareofLatinoChildren

Disparity(vsWhiteChildren)

StudyDesign

SampleSize(s)

Notes

RefNo.

Accesstocare

Tripletheadjustedoddsofhavingnousualsource

ofcare

AnalysisofHouseholdComponentof1996

and2000MEPS

Latino:n

�4091;AA:n

�2189;

Asian:n

�325;white:n

�Adjustedfor8covariates;doubletheadjusted

oddsofdissatisfactionwithqualityofcare

28

Doubletheadjustedoddsofnohealth

professional/doctorvisitinpreviousyear

6362

in1996butnot2000

Loweradjustedoddsofhavingaregularsourceof

care

Analysisofcross-sectionaldataon

children0–19yofagefromthe

Totalsample:N

�19485

Adjustedfor7covariates

55

Loweradjustedoddsofsuretyofaccessinghealth

careamongadolescents

CaliforniaHealthInterviewSurvey

Loweradjustedoddsofbeinginexcellent/very

goodhealth

AmongMexicanAmericanchildren

Cross-sectional,population-based,

MexicanAmerican:n

�2052;

Adjustedfor17covariates;samefindingwhen

121

Loweradjustedoddsofalways/usually

obtainingappointmentforregularorroutine

care

random-digit-dialingsurveyof

parents/guardiansofchildren3–18y

ofageresidingin111countiesinwest

white:n

�2655

MexicanAmericanchildrenstratifiedby

languagespokenathome

Loweradjustedoddsofalways/usually

obtainingcareforillnessorinjury

Texasusing4itemsfromtheCAHPS

Loweradjustedoddsofalways/usually

obtainingadvice/helpovertelephone

Higheradjustedoddsofalways/usuallyhavinga

longwaitindoctor’soffice

Higheradjustedoddsofappendicitisrupturein

California

Cross-sectionalanalysisoffull-year

samplesofhospitaldischargerecords

foracuteappendicitisfromCalifornia

andNewYorkchildren4–18yofage

California:Latino,n

�4304;

API,n

�459;AA,n

�297;

white,n

�4017;NewYork:

API,n

�80;AA,n

�342;

Latino,n

�444;white,n

�2379

Adjustedfor7covariates;nonsignificant

trendobservedinNewYork

29

Higheradjustedproportioninfairorpoorhealth

amongnewSCHIPenrolleesinFloridaand

NewYork

AnalysisofCHIRIdataonnewSCHIP

enrolleesin4states(�18yoldin

Alabama,Kansas,andNewYork,and

Totalsample:N

�8975b

Adjustedfor10covariates

30

Loweradjustedproportionhadpreventivecare

visitsbeforeSCHIPamongnewSCHIP

enrolleesinFloridaandNewYork

11.5–17.9yofageinFlorida)

Loweradjustedproportionhadusualsourceof

carebeforeSCHIPamongnewSCHIP

enrolleesinFloridaandNewYork

BeforeenrollmentinSCHIP

InterviewsofparentsinNewYorkState

Totalsample:N

�2644

Adjustedfor12covariates;1unadjusted

31Loweradjustedrateofhavingusualsourceof

care

atthetimeofSCHIPenrollmentoftheir

child(baseline)and1yafter

(baseline)andN

�2290

(1-yfollow-up)b

quality-of-caredisparitynoted

Higheradjustedrateofhavingunmetneedsfor

healthcare

enrollment

Loweradjustedoddsofalwaysgettingtimely

medicalcarewithoutwaits

AnalysisofCAHPSdataoncross-sectional

cohortfromtheMEPS

Latino:n

�1236;AA:n

�700;

white:n

�2184

Adjustedfor6covariates

122

Loweradjustedoddsofalwaysgettingtimely

telephonehelpformedicalcare

e1000 FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 23: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

TABLE3Continued

Disparity(vsWhiteChildren)

StudyDesign

SampleSize(s)

Notes

RefNo.

Loweradjustedoddsofbriefwaittimesfor

medicalappointments

Higheradjustedoddsofnever/onlysometimes

gettingmedicalcarewithoutlongwaits

Higheradjustedoddsofnever/onlysometimes

gettingtimelyroutinecare

Higheradjustedoddsofnever/onlysometimes

gettingtimelytelephonehelp

Higheradjustedoddsofnever/onlysometimes

gettingbriefwaittimesformedical

appointments

Greateradjustedoddsofbeinguninsured

Analysisofdataonchildren4–35mo

Latino:n

�817;AA:n

�477;

Adjustedfor9covariates

32Greateradjustedoddsofnotbeingreferredto

specialistbyhealthcareprovider

ofagefromtheNationalSurveyof

EarlyChildhoodHealth

white:n

�718

Adolescents

Femaleadolescents:higherriskofnohealth

insurance,perpetratingviolence,andbeinga

victimofviolence

AnalysisofAddHealth(waves1and2),a

nationallyrepresentativeschool-based

studyofyouthsingrades7–12,with

Latino:n

�2340;AA:n

�3038;

API:n

�1021;AI/AN:n

�136;white:n

�7728

Prevalenceinpublishedtableswasnot

adjusted;theauthorsstatedthat

adjustmentsforincomeandparental

35

Maleadolescents:higherriskofnohealth

insurance,lastphysicalexamination

�2y

ago,andbeingavictimofviolence

follow-upintoadulthood

educationhadminimalinfluenceon

findings;significantdisparitieswere

identifiedbyusing95%CIsthatdidnot

overlapwithmeasureforwhite

adolescents;noformalstatistical

evaluationofdisparitieswasprovidedin

article

Loweradjustedoddsofbicyclehelmetuse

AnalysisofCaliforniaHealthInterview

Latino:n

�1515;API:n

�376;

Adjustedfor5covariates;interactionsnoted

116

Loweradjustedoddsofsunscreenuse

Surveydataonadolescents12–17yof

age

white:n

�3263

withgenerationalstatusforcertain

outcomes

Livebirthrateforadolescentgirls15–17yofage

�3timeshigher(andhighestforanyracial/

ethnicgroup)

1990–1998natalityfilesfromtheNational

VitalStatisticsSystem

Notprovided

Expressedasratesper1000;ratesnot

adjustedforanycovariates

36

Higherlikelihoodoffair-to-poorhealthamong

adolescentsrecentlyenrolledinSCHIP

AnalysisofCHIRItelephoneinterviewdata

ofadolescentsnewlyenrolledinSCHIP

Totalsample:N

�2036b

Notadjustedforcovariates

33

Lesslikelytousedoctor’sofficesastheirusual

sourceofcareamongadolescentsrecently

enrolledinSCHIP

inFloridaandNewYork(andtheir

parents)

Loweradjustedoddsofbeingtreatedforsexually

transmittedinfectionsintheED

Analysisof7yofdatafromtheNational

HospitalAmbulatoryMedicalCare

Surveyonchildren12–19yofage

Latino:n

�1710;AA:n

�8170;

white:n

�8930

Adjustedfor4covariates

123

Birthratefor15-to19-y-oldgirlsalmost3times

ashigh

BirthcertificatedatareportedtoCDC

NationalCenterforHealthStatistics

Notprovided

Notadjustedforcovariates;noPvaluesor

95%CIs

38

Greateradjustedoddsofalcoholtestingamong

maleadolescentsadmittedtoEDsfor

traumaticinjury

AnalysisofdatafromtheNational

TraumaDataBank(includes64US

institutions)onadolescents12–17yof

ageadmittedtoEDswithtraumatic

injury

Latino:n

�396;AA:n

�1760;

white:n

�5584

Adjustedfor7covariates

39

FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS

PEDIATRICS Volume 125, Number 4, April 2010 e1001 by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 24: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

TABLE3Continued

Disparity(vsWhiteChildren)

StudyDesign

SampleSize(s)

Notes

RefNo.

Asthmaandallergies

PuertoRicanchildrenhavesignificantlyhigher

adjustedoddsofhavingcurrentasthma(and

areonlyracial/ethnicminoritygroupwith

higheroddsafteradjustmentforincomeand

neighborhoodfactors)

Cross-sectionalparentalsurveyof26

randomlyselectedNewYorkCity

publicelementaryschools

Latino:n

�2058;AA:n

�1171;

white:n

�798;Asian:n

�646

Adjustedfor4covariates;Asianchildrenhad

significantlyloweradjustedoddsofhaving

currentasthma(vswhitechildren)

124

HigheradjustedoddsofanasthmaEDvisitor

hospitalization

Analysisofdatafromparent-response

questionnairesadministeredin26

Totalsample:N

�5250b

Adjustedfor4covariates

45

HigheradjustedoddsofanasthmaEDvisitor

hospitalizationamongPuertoRicans,

Dominicans,and“otherLatinos”butnot

Mexicans

randomlyselectedNewYorkCity

publicelementaryschools

Higherdiagnosedasthmaprevalenceamong

PuertoRicanchildren(22%)

Cross-sectionalanalysisofparent-report

questionnairedatafrom14low-

Latino:n

�6002(PuertoRican:

n�473);AA:n

�2938;

Notadjustedforcovariates

46

Highertotalpotentialasthmaburden(diagnosed

pluspossiblebutundiagnosedasthma)

amongPuertoRicanchildren

income,diverseChicagopublic

elementaryschools

white:n

�1560

Higherasthmaprevalence

Trendsinasthmaovertimeforchildren

Notprovided

Onlyunadjustedrateswerepresented;no

40Substantialriseinasthmaprevalenceover11-y

period(morethandoubled)

0–17yofageusingdatafrom5

NationalCenterforHealthStatistics

sources:NationalHealthInterview

Survey,NationalAmbulatoryMedical

CareSurvey,NationalHospital

AmbulatoryMedicalCareSurvey,

NationalHospitalDischargeSurvey,

andMortalityComponentofNational

VitalStatisticsSystem

differencesorlowerrateofasthmaattack

prevalencevswhitechildren;nostatistical

comparisonsperformedor95%CIs

provided

Loweradjustedoddsofdailyanti-inflammatory

useforasthma

Cross-sectionalstudyusingparental

telephoneinterviewsandelectronic

recordsforMedicaid-insuredchildren

2–16yofagewithasthmain5

managedcareorganizationsin

California,Washington,and

Massachusetts

Latino:n

�313;AA:n

�636;

white:n

�512

AdjustedforSES,healthstatus,age,gender,

andothersociodemographicvariables

48

Higheradjustedoddsofcockroachallergen

sensitivityamongMexicanAmericanchildren

Cross-sectionalanalysisofchildren

6–16yofagewhoparticipatedin

MexicanAmerican:n

�1546;

AA:n

�1502;white:n

�Adjustedfor8covariates;MexicanAmerican

childrenweretheonlyLatinochildren

49

Higheradjustedoddsofdustmiteallergen

sensitivityamongMexicanAmericanchildren

allergentestingintheNHANESIII

1116

examined

Higheradjustedoddsofasthma-associated

activitylimitations

AnalysisofdatafromtheLosAngeles

CountyHealthSurveyonchildren

Latino:n

�3675;AA:n

�566;

API:n

�361;white:n

�Adjustedfor8covariates

50

Higheradjustedoddsofneedforurgentmedical

careforasthmainpast12mo

�18yofage

1278

Loweradjustedoddsofuseofinhaledsteroids

AnalysisofdatafromtheChildhood

Latino:n

�255;AA:n

�139;

Adjustedfor9covariates

51Loweradjustedoddsofuseofinhaledsteroids

amongthosecaredforinprivatepractices

AsthmaSeverityStudy,whichuseda

12-mo,retrospective,parent-reported

questionnaireonasthmaina

communitysampleofchildren

�13y

ofageresidinginConnecticutand

Massachusetts

white:n

�549

e1002 FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 25: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

TABLE3Continued

Disparity(vsWhiteChildren)

StudyDesign

SampleSize(s)

Notes

RefNo.

ForPuertoRicanchildren,higheradjustedoddsof

physician-diagnosedasthma

AnalysisofNHISdataon3-to17-y-oldscurrently

symptomaticwithwheezing

PuertoRican:n

�40;Mexican:

n�122;AA:n

�174;white:

n�610

Adjustedfor10covariates

125

Breastfeeding

Lowerproportionofchildreneverbreastfed

amongMexicanAmericanchildren

Analysisofbreastfeedingdataonchildren12–

71moofageintheNHANESIII(1988–1994)

MexicanAmerican:n

�2118;

AA:n

�1845;white:n

�1869

Notadjustedforanycovariates

53

Healthstatus

Higheradjustedlikelihoodoffairorpoorhealth

Analysisof3yofNHISdataonchildren0–17yof

age

Latino:n

�12765;API:n

�2516;AA:n

�17324;AI/AN:

n�1067;white:n

�62572

Adjustedfor4covariates

112

HIV/AIDS

ApproximatelytwicethepercentageofnewHIV/

AIDSdiagnosesvswhitechildrenforthose

�13yofage,perinataltransmission,and

otherpediatriccases

DiagnosesofHIV/AIDSreportedtotheCDCin

2001–2004by33statesthatused

confidential,name-basedreportingofHIV/

AIDScasesforatleast4y

Latino:n

�3249;AA:n

�11554;white:n

�3707a

No95%CIsorPvaluespresentedfor

children;notadjustedforcovariates

59

NumberofnewHIV/AIDSdiagnosesexceedsthat

forwhitechildrenforthose

�13yofage,

perinataltransmission,andotherpediatric

cases

AlthoughLatinochildrenconstitute14%ofUS

children,numberofnewHIV/AIDSdiagnoses

amongthose0–24yofagea(n

�3249)

almostequaltothatofwhiteindividualsof

sameage(n

�3707)

Infectiousdiseases(otherthanHIV/AIDS)

Higherincidencerateoftuberculosis

Analysisof8yofdataonchildren

�15yofage

fromNorthCarolinaTuberculosis

InformationManagementSystemdatabase

Latino:n

�33;AA:n

�114;

API:n

�12;white:n

�21

Notadjustedforanycovariates

64

Injuries

Higheradjustedoddsofnotputtingupstairgate

Analysisofdataonchildren4–35moofage

fromtheNationalSurveyofEarlyChildhood

Health

Latino:n

�817;AA:n

�477;

white:n

�718

Adjustedfor9covariates

66

Mentalhealthandbehavioral/developmental

issues

Significantlyloweradjustedoddsofexternalizing

behavioraldisorders

Secondaryanalysisof2yofMEPSdataon

children2–18yofage

Total1996MEPSsamplesize:

N�3955;total1997MEPS

Adjustedfor7–9covariates

43

Significantlyloweradjustedoddsofambulatory

visits

samplesize:N

�5933

Loweradjustedlikelihoodofmentalhealth

servicesuseamongMedicaid-eligible

adolescentsinsubstanceabusetreatment

AnalysisofOregon’ssubstanceabusetreatment

database(ClientProcessingMonitoring

System)foradolescents12–17yofage

admittedtopubliclyfundedtreatmentfora

substanceusedisorderduringa9-yperiod

Totalsample:N

�25813b

Adjustedfor17covariates

126

Loweradjustedoddsofreceivingtreatmentfor

anyconditionfromamentalhealthspecialist

AnalysisofNationalLongitudinalSurveyof

YouthandtheChild/YoungAdultsupplement,

anationallyrepresentativesampleof7-to

14-y-oldchildren

Totalsample:N

�2482b

Adjustedfor28covariates

67

FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS

PEDIATRICS Volume 125, Number 4, April 2010 e1003 by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 26: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

TABLE3Continued

Disparity(vsWhiteChildren)

StudyDesign

SampleSize(s)

Notes

RefNo.

Loweradjustedoddsofreceivingtreatmentfor

behaviorproblemsfromamentalhealth

specialist

Loweradjustedoddsofreceivingtreatmentfor

depressionfromamentalhealthspecialist

Tripletheadjustedoddsofunmetneedformental

healthcare

Cross-sectionalanalysesofdataon

children3–17yofagefromtheNHIS,

theNationalSurveyofAmerican

Families,andtheCommunityTracking

Survey

Latino:n

�695;AA:n

�867;

white:n

�3049

Adjustedfor8covariates

127

Within6moofanewepisodeofdepression

AnalysisofWashingtonstateMedicaid

Latino:n

�90;AI/AN:n

�154;

Adjustedfor5covariates

128

Loweradjustedoddsoffillingan

antidepressantprescription

claimsforchildren5–18yofage

white:n

�1048

Loweradjustedoddsofanymentalhealthvisit

Loweradjustedoddsofanymentalhealthvisit

orantidepressantprescriptionfilled

(combined)

Higherrateofunmetneedformentalhealth

services(noservicesamongchildrenwith

identifiedneed)

AnalysisofdatafromNationalSurveyof

America’sFamiliesforchildren6–17y

ofage

Latino:n

�6022;AA:n

�6371;

white:n

�31240

Notadjustedforcovariates

129

Higheradjustedoddsofuseofstate-funded

mentalhealthservices

AnalysisofNewYorkCitydataonreceipt

ofservicesfromstate-fundedmental

healthcarefacilities

Totalsample:N

�78085

(includingadults)b

Adjustedfor7covariates

72

Substantiallyloweradjustedoddsofreceivingan

ADHDdiagnosisduringoutpatientprimary

careprovidervisits

Analysisof6yofdataonchildren3–18y

ofagefromNationalAmbulatory

MedicalCareSurveyandNational

Latino:n

�4117;AA:n

�5074;

white:n

�16406

Adjustedfor3covariates

130

Substantiallyloweradjustedoddsofreceivinga

stimulantprescriptionduringoutpatient

primarycareprovidervisits

HospitalAmbulatoryMedicalCare

Survey

Substantiallyloweradjustedoddsofreceivingan

ADHDdiagnosisorstimulantprescription

duringoutpatientprimarycareprovider

visits

Higheradjustedoddsofdevelopmentaldelays

(basedonparentalconcerns)

AnalysisofdatafromNationalSurveyof

EarlyChildhoodHealthonchildren

4–35moofage

Totalsample:N

�2068b

Adjustedfor8covariates

58

Loweradjustedoddsofuseofspecialtymental

healthservicesamongchildrenforwhoman

investigationofabuseorneglecthadbeen

openedbythechildwelfaresystem

AnalysisofdatafromtheNationalSurvey

ofChildandAdolescentWell-beingon

useofspecialtymentalhealthservices

for1yaftercontactwithchildwelfare

amongacohortofchildren2–14yof

age

Latino:n

�487;AA:n

�899;

white:n

�1208

Adjustedfor11covariatesand2interaction

terms;nolongersignificantadjustedodds

in1of3models(whenprovidersupply,

linkagevariables,andinteractionsadded)

73

Higheradjustedoddsoffamilynevereatinglunch

ordinnertogether

Analysisofdataonchildren4–35moof

agefromtheNationalSurveyofEarly

Latino:n

�817;AA:n

�477;

white:n

�718

Adjustedfor9covariates

66

Higheradjustedoddsofreadingtochildlessthan

everyday

ChildhoodHealth

e1004 FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 27: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

TABLE3Continued

Disparity(vsWhiteChildren)

StudyDesign

SampleSize(s)

Notes

RefNo.

Loweradjustedmeannumberofchildren’sbooks

inhome

Mortality

Higherswimmingpooldrowningratesfor

adolescentboys

Analysisof4yofnationaldatafromthe

ConsumerProductsSafety

Latino:n

�81;AA:n

�316;

AI/AN:n

�18;white:n

�Adjustedforincome;valuesexpressedasrate

ratiosand95%CIs,butnoPvalueswere

75

Higherratesofdrowninginneighborhoodpools,

includingcommunitysharedapartmentand

housingcomplexpools

Commissionondrowningdeathsof

children5–24yofagefromdeath

certificates,medicalexaminerreports,

andnewspaperclippings

222

provided

HighermortalityrateforPuertoRicanchildren

1–4yofage

Analysisof6yofdataonchildren5–14y

ofagefromtheNationalVitalStatistics

System,theNationalLongitudinal

MortalityStudy,andtheAreaResource

File

PuertoRican:n

�265;white:n

�67200

Notadjustedforcovariates;presentedonlyas

populationrates;nostatistical

comparisonsor95%CIs;smallsample

sizesin1979–1981interval

79

Higheradjustedriskofdeathamongthosewith

ALL

Analysisof9population-basedregistries

oftheNationalCancerInstitute’s

Surveillance,Epidemiology,andEnd

Resultsprogram

Latino:n

�504;AA:n

�356;

AI/AN:n

�61;API:n

�410;

white:n

�3621

Adjustedfor3covariates;didnotadjustfor

SESorinsurancecoverage

81

Higheradjustedoddsofin-hospitaldeathafter

congenitalheartsurgery

Analysisofdatafromthe2000KIDofthe

HCUP,limitedto19stateswith

adequaterace/ethnicitydata

Latino:n

�1835;AA:n

�860;

white:n

�4134

Adjustedfor8covariates;infullmodel,P

valueforLatinoethnicitywas.05

82

Obesity,physicalactivity,andnutrition

Significantlyloweradjustedaerobicfitnesslevel

Progressivetreadmillprotocolevaluation

ofaerobicfitness(V̇O 2peak)ofLos

Angeleschildren7–14yofage,

adjustingforgender,maturational

stage,andbodycomposition

Latino:n

�36;AA:n

�19;

white:n

�18

Adjustedfor3covariatesbutnotSES

87

Doubletheadjustedoddsofoverweight

Analysisofheightandweightdata

Totalsample:N

�281630b

Adjustedfor4covariates

88Highestoverweightprevalenceofanyracial/ethnic

group

collectedin3moofphysicalfitness

testingofstudentsingrades5,7,and

9intheLosAngelesCountypublic

schoolsystem

Higherprevalenceofoverweightinboysamong

8th-graders(35%),10th-graders(40%),and

12th-graders(30%)(highestprevalence

amongallracial/ethnicgroupsstudied)

Analysisof10–17yofdatafrom

MonitoringtheFuture,anationally

representativesampleofstudentsin

the8th,10th,and12thgrades

Totalsample:N

�4800–17074

perstudyinterval,

dependingongradeand

yearb

Notadjustedforcovariates

90

Higherprevalenceofoverweightingirlsamong

8th-graders(27%),10th-graders(32%),and

12th-graders(19%)(highestprevalence

amongallracial/ethnicgroupsstudied)

Lowerlikelihoodofeatingbreakfastregularly

Lesslikelytoregularlyexercisevigorouslyamong

girls

Highernumberofhoursoftelevision-viewingon

averageweekday

FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS

PEDIATRICS Volume 125, Number 4, April 2010 e1005 by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 28: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

TABLE3Continued

Disparity(vsWhiteChildren)

StudyDesign

SampleSize(s)

Notes

RefNo.

Higherprevalenceofoverweightandobesity

Cross-sectionalsurveyofadolescents

Totalsample:N

�4746b

Notadjustedforcovariates,butstratified

91Boysmorelikelytoconsume

�10%ofcaloriesas

saturatedfat

11–18yofagein31publicschoolsin

theMinneapolis,StPaul,andOsseo

analysesadjustingforgradeandSESwere

performedbutnotreportedbecause

Lowercalciumintake

schooldistrictsofMinnesota

generallyshowedpatternssimilartothose

ofunadjustedanalyses

AmongMexicanAmericans

AnalysisofNHANESdataonchildren2–19

Latino:n

�1475;AA:n

�1274;

Notadjustedforcovariates;Mexican

93Higherprevalenceofoverweight

yoldfrom1999–2000and2001–2002

white:n

�1094

AmericansonlyLatinogroupanalyzed

Higherprevalenceofoverweightamong6-to

11-y-olds

Higherprevalenceofoverweightamong12-to

19-y-olds

Higherprevalenceofoverweightamongboys

(andhighestofallracial/ethnicgroups

analyzed)

Higherprevalenceofoverweightamong6-to

11-y-oldboys(andhighestofallracial/ethnic

groupsanalyzed)

Higherprevalenceofoverweightamong12-to

19-y-oldboys

Higherprevalenceofoverweightamonggirls

Higherprevalenceofatriskofoverweightor

overweight(andhighestofallracial/ethnic

groupsanalyzed)

Higherprevalenceofatriskofoverweightor

overweightamong6-to11-y-olds

Higherprevalenceofatriskofoverweightor

overweightamong12-to19-y-olds

Higherprevalenceofatriskofoverweightor

overweightamongboys(andhighestofall

racial/ethnicgroupsanalyzed)

Higherprevalenceofatriskofoverweightor

overweightamong6-to11-y-oldboys(and

highestofallracial/ethnicgroupsanalyzed)

Higherprevalenceofatriskofoverweightor

overweightamong12-to19-y-oldboys(and

highestofallracial/ethnicgroupsanalyzed)

Higherprevalenceofatriskofoverweightor

overweightamonggirls

Higherprevalenceofatriskofoverweightor

overweightamong12-to19-y-oldgirls

Higheradjustedoddsofoverweightandhighest

adjustedoddsofanyracial/ethnicgroup

Cross-sectionalsampleofCalifornia

publicschool5th,7th,and9th-graders

Latino:n

�330758;AA:n

�58491;Asian:n

�63292;

Adjustedfor2covariatesandstratified

accordingtoage

94

Sloweradjusted1-milerun/walktime

(10–15yold)

PacificIslander:n

�7977;

Filipino:n

�22598;AI/AN:n

�7977;white:n

�275722

e1006 FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 29: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

TABLE3Continued

Disparity(vsWhiteChildren)

StudyDesign

SampleSize(s)

Notes

RefNo.

Orthopedics

Fortreatmentofsupracondylarhumerus

fractures,morelikelytoundergoclosed

reductionwithinternalfixation

(percutaneouspinning)

Retrospectiveexaminationofselected

pediatricfracturesintheKIDofthe

HCUP

Latino:n

�659;AA:n

�207;

white:n

�1478

Notadjustedforcovariates;nodisparities

seenforfemurorforearmfractures

96

Quality

Loweradjustedoddsofreceivinganycounseling

duringwell-childvisits

Cross-sectionalanalysisof10yofdata

onchildren0–18yofagefromthe

Totalsample:N

�2892b

Nomultivariableadjustmentsperformedfor

visitduration;counselingfindingswere

97

Shorterwell-childvisitduration

NationalAmbulatoryMedicalCare

Survey

adjustedfor7covariates

Lowerprimarycareproviderstrength-of-affiliation

scores(unadjustedandadjusted)

Telephonesurveyofparentsofrandom

sampleof413childrenattending

Latino:n

�84;AA:n

�100;

API:n

�91;white:n

�102

Adjustedfor11covariates

100

Lowerprimarycareproviderinterpersonal

relationshipscores(unadjustedand

adjusted

�ifrequiredbymanagedcare

organizationtoseekreferralandtostayin

network�)

elementaryschoolin3suburban

communitiesinSanBernardino

County,California

Amongthoseinwhichtheprimarylanguage

spokenathomeisalanguageotherthan

English

Analysisofparentalsurveydataon

children0–17yofagefromthe

nationalCAHPSBenchmarking

Latino:n

�842;AA:n

�1344;

API:n

�291;AI/AN:n

�330;

white:n

�6328

Adjustedfor4covariates;nodisparitiesnoted

forLatinochildreninhouseholdsinwhich

Englishisprimarylanguage

101

Loweradjustedscoresfortimelinessofcare

Database1.0administeredby

Loweradjustedscoresforprovider

communication

Medicaidsponsorscomprising33

healthmaintenanceorganizations

fromArkansas,Kansas,Minnesota,

Loweradjustedscoresforstaffhelpfulness

Oklahoma,Vermont,and

Loweradjustedscoresforhealthinsurance

planservice

Washington

Loweradjustedratingsofchild’spersonal

doctor

Loweradjustedratingsofspecialist

Loweradjustedratingsofhealthplan

AmongthoseseenintheEDforacute

gastroenteritis

AllpatientsseenintheEDovera6-mo

periodwithadischargediagnosisof

Latino:n

�143;AA:n

�122;

white:n

�132

Adjustedfor7covariates

131

Loweradjustedlikelihoodtoundergo

�2

diagnostictests

acutegastroenteritisasidentified

throughacomputerizedpatientlog

Loweradjustedlikelihoodofhavingundergone

radiography

Lowermeanparticipatorydecision-making

scoreforchild’sphysician

Cross-sectional,population-based,

random-digit-dialingsurveyof

parents/guardiansofchildren3–18y

ofageresidingin111countiesinwest

Texas

Latino:n

�1720;white:n

�2156

Adjustedfor11covariates

132

Loweradjustedscoresforcomprehensivenessof

primarycare

Cross-sectionalsurveyofparentsof

childrenin228classes,from

kindergartenthrough6thgrade,at18

elementaryschoolsinalargeurban

schooldistrictinCalifornia

Latino:n

�1292;API:n

�1158;AA:n

�458;white:

n�479

Adjustedfor5covariates

102

FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS

PEDIATRICS Volume 125, Number 4, April 2010 e1007 by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 30: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

TABLE3Continued

Disparity(vsWhiteChildren)

StudyDesign

SampleSize(s)

Notes

RefNo.

Amongthosehospitalizedforpneumonia

Analysisof3yofdataonchildren

Latino:n

�15152;API:n

�Adjustedfor6–7covariates

113

Higheradjustedriskratioofadmissionthrough

EDs

0–17yofagehospitalizedfor

pneumoniafromtheNationalInpatient

2050;AA:n

�17095;white:

n�43180

Loweradjustedoddsofbronchoscopy

SampleoftheHCUP

Loweradjustedoddsofmechanicalventilation

Longeradjustedlengthofstay

Higheradjustedcharges

Greateradjustedoddsofchildbeingassignedto

healthcareprovider

Analysisofdataonchildren4–35moof

agefromtheNationalSurveyofEarly

Latino:n

�817;AA:n

�477;

white:n

�718

Adjustedfor9covariates

32

Greateradjustedoddsofparentbeingnotvery

likelytorecommendchild’swell-childcare

provider

ChildhoodHealth

Greateradjustedoddsofhealthcareprovider

never/onlysometimesunderstandinghow

parentpreferstorearchild

Greateradjustedoddsofhealthcareprovider

never/onlysometimesunderstandingchild’s

specificneeds

Greateradjustedoddsofdiscussingviolencein

thecommunity,anduseofalcoholordrugs

inhousehold

Specialhealthcareneeds

Amongchildrenwithspecialhealthcareneeds

Analysisofdataonchildren0–17yofage

Latino:n

�1777;AA:n

�1762;

Adjustedfor9–10covariates

104

Higheradjustedoddsofbeinguninsured

withspecialhealthcareneedsinthe

white:n

�6365

Higheradjustedoddsofhavingnousualsource

ofcare

NHISondisability

Higheradjustedoddsofnotidentifyinga

regularclinician

Higheradjustedoddsofnotbeingsatisfiedwith

care

Higheradjustedoddsofbeingunabletoget

neededmedicalcare

Loweradjustedoddsofusualsourceofcare

beingdoctor’sprivateofficeorhealth

maintenanceorganization

Higheradjustedoddsofnothavingseendoctor

inprevious12mo

Average2fewerdoctorvisitsperyear

Loweradjustedoddsofreceivingadequatetime

andinformationfromchild’shealthcare

provider

AnalysisofNationalSurveyofChildren

WithSpecialHealthCareNeeds

Totalsample:N

�38866b

Adjustedfor6covariates;nodisparitiesin

anyunmetneedorproblemwithspecialty

referral

103

Amongchildrenwithspecialhealthcareneeds

Analysisofdataonchildren0–17yofage

Notindicated

Adjustedfor6covariates

105

Higheradjustedoddsofhavingnousualsource

ofcare

fromtheNationalSurveyofChildren

WithSpecialHealthCareNeeds

Higheradjustedoddsofhavingdifficulty

receivingreferralsforspecialtycare

e1008 FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 31: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

TABLE3Continued

Disparity(vsWhiteChildren)

StudyDesign

SampleSize(s)

Notes

RefNo.

Higheradjustedoddsofdissatisfactionwith

care

Higheradjustedoddsoffamilymembershaving

toreduceorstopemploymentbecauseof

child’scondition

Amongchildrenwithspecialhealthcareneeds

Analysisofdataonchildren0–17yofage

Latino:n

�3424;API:n

�197;

Adjustedfor6covariates

133

Higheradjustedoddsofnotreceivingfamily-

centeredcare

fromtheNationalSurveyofChildren

WithSpecialHealthCareNeeds

AA:n

�3833;white:n

�28967

Higheradjustedoddsofparentsexperiencing

employmentconsequencesasaresultof

child’scondition

Amongchildrenwithspecialneeds

Analysisofdataonspecial-needs

Latino:n

�3210;AA:n

�3820;

Adjustedfor13covariates

106

Greateradjustedoddsofproblemswitheaseof

usinghealthcareservices

children0–17yofagefromthe

NationalSurveyofChildrenWith

SpecialHealthCareNeeds

white:n

�28916

Surgery

Forthosehospitalizedforappendicitis

Analysisofdataonchildren1–17yofage

Totalsample:N

�428463b

Notadjustedforcovariatesfortimeto

107

Longertimetooperation(regardlessofdisease

severity)

withappendicitisfromtheNationwide

InpatientSampleandtheKID

operation,lengthofstay,orhospital

charges;otheroutcomesinclude

Longerlengthofstay(regardlessofdisease

severity)

adjustmentfor6covariates

Higherhospitalcharges(regardlessofdisease

severity)

Higheradjustedappendicitisrate

Higheradjustedoddsofperforationorother

complicatingfactors

Useofhealthservices

Greateradjustedoddsof

�1ysincelastphysician

visit

Analysisof3yofNHISdataonchildren

0–17yofage

Latino:n

�12765;AA:n

�17324;API:n

�2516;AI/AN:

Adjustedfor4covariates

112

Loweradjustednumberofphysicianvisitsin

previous12mo

n�1067;white:n

�62572

Greateradjustedoddsofsuboptimalhealthstatus

GreateradjustedoddsamongPuertoRican

childrenofsuboptimalhealthstatus

MexicanAmericanchildrenhadgreateradjusted

oddsofsuboptimalhealthstatusand

�1y

sincelastphysicianvisitandmadealower

adjustednumberofphysicianvisitsinthe

previousyear

Loweradjustedmeannumberofcallstodoctor’s

officeinpreviousyear

Analysisofdataonchildren4–35moof

agefromtheNationalSurveyofEarly

ChildhoodHealth

Latino:n

�817;AA:n

�477;

white:n

�718

Adjustedfor9covariates

32

MEPSindicatesMedicalExpenditurePanelSurvey;CHIRI,ChildHealthInsuranceResearchInitiative;AddHealth,NationalLongitudinalStudyofAdolescentHealth;NHIS,NationalHealthInterviewSurvey;NHANES,NationalHealthandNutritionExamination

Survey;KID,Kid’sInpatientDatabase;HCUP,HealthcareCostandUtilizationProject;CAHPS,ConsumerAssessmentofHealthPlansStudy;V̇ O2,oxygenconsumptionperunittime.

aSamplesizesincludesthose0to24yearsofage,becausetheCDCgroupedthose15to24yearsofagetogether.

bSamplesizeswerenotdisaggregatedinarticleaccordingtorace/ethnicity.

FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS

PEDIATRICS Volume 125, Number 4, April 2010 e1009 by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 32: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

the previous 12 months, as well as ahigher potential asthma burden (diag-nosed plus possible but undiagnosedasthma). Latinos have lower adjustedodds of use of inhaled steroids and ofdaily anti-inflammatory medications.Disparities among Latino subgroups(compared with white children) in-clude higher adjusted odds of asthmaED visits and hospitalizations amongPuerto Ricans, Dominicans, and “otherLatinos” (except Mexican Americans)and higher adjusted odds of cockroachand dust mite allergen sensitivityamong Mexican Americans.

Eleven studies documented Latino dis-parities in mental health care and be-havioral/developmental issues (Table3). Disparities included significantlyhigher unmet need for mental healthcare, and lower odds of any mentalhealth visit, outpatient visits, antide-pressant prescriptions, and receivingtreatment from a mental health spe-cialist for any condition, behaviorproblems, or depression. Latinos havehigher odds of developmental delaysbut lower odds of being diagnosedwith externalizing behavioral disor-ders. Lower odds were noted for use ofmental health services among chil-dren being investigated for possibleabuse or neglect and among Medicaid-eligible teenagers in substance abusetreatment, although 1 study foundhigher odds of use of state-fundedmental health services in New YorkCity. Latinos have substantially loweradjusted odds of receiving an ADHD di-agnosis or receiving stimulant pre-scriptions during outpatient primarycare visits. Young Latino children havehigher adjusted odds of being read toless than every day, of having fewernumbers of children’s books in thehousehold, and of the family never eat-ing lunch or dinner together.

Many disparities have been docu-mented for Latino children with spe-cial health care needs, including

higher adjusted odds of being unin-sured, having no usual source of care,parental dissatisfaction with care,having unmet medical care needs, nothaving seen the physician in the pastyear, not receiving adequate time andinformation from the health care pro-vider, averaging fewer doctor visitsper year, experiencing difficulties re-ceiving specialty referrals, having fam-ily members reduce or stop employ-ment because of the child’s condition,not receiving family-centered care,and experiencing problems with easeof use of health care services.

Quality

Compared with white children, Latinochildren have higher adjusted odds ofbeing assigned to a health care pro-vider and lower adjusted scores forcomprehensiveness of primary careand primary care provider strength ofaffiliation, interpersonal relationship,and participatory decision-making (Ta-ble 3). Latino children have a shorteraverage well-child visit duration, loweradjusted odds of receiving any coun-seling during well-child visits, andgreater adjusted odds of the parentnot being very likely to recommend thechild’s health care provider, of thehealth care provider never or onlysometimes understanding the child’sspecific needs and how the parent pre-fers to rear the child, and of the pro-vider discussing violence in the com-munity and use of alcohol or drugs inthe household. Similar disparities inthe quality of primary care were notedfor Latino children living in householdsin which English is not the primary lan-guage spoken (in comparison withwhite children).

Among those seen in the ED with acutegastroenteritis, Latino children hadlower adjusted odds than white chil-dren of undergoing 2 or more diagnos-tic tests and of having undergone radi-ography (Table 3). Among children

with supracondylar humerus frac-tures, Latinos were more likely to un-dergo closed reduction with internalfixation.

American Indians and AlaskaNatives

Sixteen articles (15%) addressed dis-parities in AI/AN children, which is thefewest articles for any racial/ethnicgroup (Table 4).

Mortality

AI/AN children have a higher age-specific crude mortality rate com-pared with that of white children, bothin national and urban samples (Table4). A higher adjusted risk of death alsohas been documented for AI/AN chil-dren with ALL.

Use of Health Services

AI/AN children have higher adjustedodds than white children of going 1year or longer since their last physi-cian visit (Table 4).

Prevention and Population Health

Data from the state of Minnesota re-veal a firearm injury rate for AI/AN chil-dren that is more than 7 times higherthan that for their white counterparts(Table 4). Several studies have docu-mented higher adjusted odds of over-weight and obesity among AI/AN chil-dren. Other studies have shown aslower adjusted 1-mile run/walk timeand lower calcium intake among AI/ANboys.

Adolescent Health Issues

Female AI/AN adolescents have higherrisks than their white counterparts ofneeding but not getting medical careand of perpetrating violence (Table 4).Male AI/AN adolescents have a higherrisk than their white counterparts ofskipping breakfast, having poor/fairhealth status, and perpetrating vio-lence. National data from 2 studies re-vealed that the birth rate for AI/AN fe-

e1010 FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 33: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

TABLE4DisparitiesintheHealthandHealthCareofAI/ANChildren

Disparity(vsWhiteChildren)

StudyDesign

SampleSize(s)

Notes

RefNo.

Adolescents

Femaleadolescents:higherrisksofneedingbut

notgettingmedicalcareandperpetrating

violence

AnalysisofAddHealth(waves1and2),anationally

representativeschool-basedstudyofyouthsin

grades7–12,withfollow-upintoadulthood

AI/AN:n

�136;AA:n

�3038;

API:n

�1021;Latino:n

�2340;white:n

�7728

Prevalenceinpublishedtablesnotadjusted,

butauthorsstatedthatadjustmentsfor

incomeandparentaleducationhad

35

Maleadolescents:higherriskofskipping

breakfast,poor/fairhealthstatus,and

perpetratingviolence

minimalinfluenceonfindings;significant

disparitieswereidentifiedbyusing95%

CIsthatdidnotoverlapwithmeasurefor

whiteadolescents;noformalstatistical

evaluationofdisparitiesprovided

Livebirthrateforadolescentgirls15–17yof

age

�2timeshigher

1990–1998natalityfilesfromtheNationalVital

StatisticsSystem

Notprovided

Expressedasratesper1000;notadjusted

forcovariates

36

Birthratefor15–19y-oldgirlsalmost3times

ashigh

BirthcertificatedatareportedtotheCDCNational

CenterforHealthStatistics

Notprovided

Notadjustedforcovariates;noPvaluesor

95%CIs

38

Injuries

Firearminjuryrate

�7timeshigher

AnalysisofdatafromMinnesotaDepartmentof

Totalsample:N

�175a

Notadjustedforcovariates

65Health’sMinnesotaTraumaDataBankonfatal

andnonfatalfirearminjuriesinchildren0–19y

ofage

Mentalhealthandbehavioral/developmental

issues

Loweradjustedlikelihoodofmentalhealth

servicesuseamongMedicaid-eligibleand

non–Medicaid-eligibleadolescentsin

substanceabusetreatment

AnalysisofOregon’ssubstanceabusetreatment

database(ClientProcessingMonitoringSystem)

foradolescents12–17yofageadmittedto

publiclyfundedtreatmentforasubstanceuse

disorderduringa9-yperiod

Totalsample:N

�25813a

Adjustedfor17covariates

126

Within6moofanewepisodeofdepression

AnalysisofWashingtonStateMedicaidclaimsfor

children5–18yofage

AI/AN:n

�154;Latino:n

�90;

white:n

�1048

Adjustedfor5covariates

128

Loweradjustedoddsoffillingan

antidepressantprescription

Loweradjustedoddsofanymentalhealth

visitorantidepressantprescriptionfilled

Mortality

Significantlyhigherage-specificmortalityrate

among1-to14-y-oldurbanchildren(vs

urbanwhitechildren)

Vitalstatisticsdatafor10yfromKingCounty,

Washington

Notstatedforthisoutcome

Notadjustedforcovariates

134

Approximately50%highermortalityratefor

children1–4yofage

Analysisof6yofdataonchildren5–14yofage

fromtheNationalVitalStatisticsSystem,the

AI/AN:n

�1336;white:n

�67200

Notadjustedforcovariates;presentedonly

aspopulationrates;nostatistical

79

Highermortalityrateforchildren5–14yofage

NationalLongitudinalMortalityStudy,andthe

AreaResourceFile

comparisonsor95%CIs

Higheradjustedriskofdeathamongthosewith

ALL

Analysisof9population-basedregistriesofthe

NationalCancerInstitute’sSurveillance,

Epidemiology,andEndResultsprogram

AI/AN:n

�61;AA:n

�356;

API:n

�410;Latino:n

�504;white:n

�3621

Adjustedfor3covariates;notadjustedfor

SESorinsurancecoverage

81

Obesityphysicalactivityandnutrition

Higheradjustedoddsofoverweight

Analysisofheightandweightdatacollectedin3

moofphysicalfitnesstestingofstudentsin

grades5,7,and9intheLosAngelesCounty

publicschoolsystem

Totalsample:N

�281630a

Adjustedfor4covariates

88

FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS

PEDIATRICS Volume 125, Number 4, April 2010 e1011 by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 34: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

TABLE4Continued

Disparity(vsWhiteChildren)

StudyDesign

SampleSize(s)

Notes

RefNo.

Higherprevalenceofoverweightandobesity

(highestprevalenceofanyracial/ethnic

groupforboys)

Cross-sectionalsurveyofadolescents11–18yof

agein31publicschoolsintheMinneapolis,

StPaul,andOsseoschooldistrictsofMinnesota

Totalsample:N

�4746a

Notadjustedforcovariates,butauthors

statedthatstratifiedanalysesadjusting

forgradeandSESwereperformedbut

91

Lowercalciumintakeamongboys

notreportedbecausetheygenerally

showedpatternssimilartothoseof

unadjustedanalyses

Higheradjustedoddsofoverweight

Cross-sectionalsampleofCaliforniapublicschool

AI/AN:n

�7977;AA:n

�Adjustedfor2covariatesandstratified

94Sloweradjusted1-milerun/walktime

5th-,7th-,and9th-graders(10–15yold)

58491;Asian:n

�63292;

Filipino:n

�22598;Latino:

n�330758;Pacific

Islander:n

�7977;white:

275722

accordingtoage;run/walktimesnot

significantlydifferentfor2olderstrata

forbothgenders

Ophthalmology

Loweradjustedoddsofbeingdiagnosedwith

anyeyeorvisioncondition

Analysisof6yofdataforchildren0–17yofagein

theMEPS

Totalsample:N

�2813a

Adjustedfor13covariates;theauthors

concludedthatdisparitiesindicated

possibleunderdiagnosis,

undertreatment,orboth;nodisparitiesin

beingdiagnosedwithaneyeorvision

conditionotherthanconjunctivitis

95

QualityLoweradjustedscoresfortimelinessofcare

Analysisofparentalsurveydataonchildren

AI/AN:n

�330;AA:n

�1344;

Adjustedfor4covariates

101

Loweradjustedscoresforprovider

communication

0–17yofagefromtheCAHPSBenchmarking

Database1.0administeredbyMedicaid

API:n

�291;Latino:n

�842;white:n

�6328

Loweradjustedscoresforhealthinsurance

planservice

sponsorscomprising33healthmaintenance

organizationsfromArkansas,Kansas,

Loweradjustedratingsofchild’spersonal

doctor

Minnesota,Oklahoma,Vermont,andWashington

Loweradjustedratingsofhealthplan

Useofhealthservices

Greateradjustedoddsof

�1ysincelast

physicianvisit

Analysisof3yofNHISdataonchildren0–17yof

age

AI/AN:n

�1067;API:n

�2516;AA:n

�17324;

Adjustedfor4covariates

112

Morethandoubletheadjustedoddsof

suboptimalhealthstatusandhighest

prevalenceofanyracial/ethnicgroup

Latino:n

�12765;white:

n�62572

MEPSindicatesMedicalExpenditurePanelSurvey;AddHealth,NationalLongitudinalStudyofAdolescentHealth;NHIS,NationalHealthInterviewSurvey;CAHPS,ConsumerAssessmentofHealthPlans.

aSamplesizeswerenotdisaggregatedinarticleaccordingtorace/ethnicity.

e1012 FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 35: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

male adolescents is 2 to 3 times higherthan that of white adolescents.

Health Status

AI/AN children have higher adjustedodds than do white children of beingin poor or fair health and the highestprevalence of these suboptimalhealth ratings of any racial/ethnicgroup (Table 4).

Mental Health Care

Within 6 months of a new episode ofdepression, AI/AN children have loweradjusted odds than white children ofany mental health visit or antidepres-sant prescription being filled. AI/ANyouth in treatment for substanceabuse also have a lower adjusted like-lihood of mental health services use.

Quality

Compared with the parents of whitechildren, the parents of AI/AN childrengave lower adjusted scores for their

child’s health care timeliness, healthcare provider communication, andhealth insurance plan service, andlower adjusted ratings for their child’spersonal doctor and health plan (Table4). National data also reveal lower ad-justed odds of being diagnosed withany eye or vision condition.

Multiracial Children

The search terms did not yield any ar-ticles on disparities amongmultiracialchildren.

DISPARITIES AMONGRACIAL/ETHNIC SUBGROUPS

Fifteen studies (14%) included analy-ses of disparities in 1 or more racial/ethnic subgroup (in comparison withwhite children). Five studies of APIs(21% of all studies of APIs) and 10 stud-ies of Latinos (15% of all studies of Lati-nos) examined racial/ethnic subgroupdisparities; none of the analyses for AA

or AI/AN children included subgroupanalyses.

STUDIES EVALUATINGINTERVENTIONS TO REDUCEDISPARITIES

The search terms yielded only 2 stud-ies that evaluated interventions to re-duce racial/ethnic disparities (Table5). A quasi-experimental evaluation ofa school-based Internet and video in-tervention that focused on healthsnacks and gym labs resulted in signif-icant reductions in dietary fat intakeamong all 3 minority groups as well asamong those in the white group, andsignificant increases in physical activ-ity among low-income children in all 3minority groups and white children. Itwas unclear, however, what the con-trol group received, there was nooverall difference between interven-tion and control children in fat-intake reduction, and participants in

TABLE 5 Results of Studies Evaluating Interventions to Reduce Disparities in the Health and Health Care of Minority Children

Disparity Targeted Findings Study Design Sample Size(s) Notes Ref No.

Nutrition and exercise inmiddle-school children

Dietary fat intake significantlyreduced in intervention-group girls for AA, Latino,AI/AN, and white children;significantly increasedphysical activity amongthose with lowest incomeamong AA, Latino, Asian,and white children

Quasi-experimental evaluationof a 4-session Internet andvideo intervention withhealthy snack and gymlabs; intervention occurredin 2 urban, low- to middle-income middle schools(gym lab in 1) in theMidwest

AA: n� 58; white: n�47; Asian: n� 9;Latino: n� 4; AI/AN:n� 4

Small sample sizes from only2 schools; unclear whatcontrol group received (ifanything); unclear whenpostinterventionevaluation occurred; nooverall difference betweenintervention and controlchildren in fat intakereduction; both groupsactually decreased theiramount of physical activity

135

Immunization rates among0- to 2-y-olds

No statistically significantdifferences (vs whitechildren) inpostinterventionpopulation immunizationrates for 24-mo-oldsamong AA and Latinochildren; no statisticallysignificant difference (vswhite children) inpostinterventionpopulation immunizationrate for Latino (but not AA)12-mo-olds

Prepopulation/postpopulationstudy in Monroe County,New York, of impact ofcommunity-wide reminder,recall, and outreachsystem for childhoodimmunizationsadministered by layoutreach workers in 8practices (expanded to 10after 4 y). Outcomes weremonitored in a 10%random sample selectedfrom suburban practicesand a 25% random samplefrom urban practices.

Total sample: N�20 132a

9%–74% of cohort(depending on studyregion) did not receiveintervention; immunizationrates unadjusted (notadjusted for any potentialconfounders)

136

a Sample sizes were not disaggregated in article according to race/ethnicity.

FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS

PEDIATRICS Volume 125, Number 4, April 2010 e1013 by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 36: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

both the intervention and controlgroups decreased their amount ofphysical activity.

A preintervention and postinterventionstudy in an upstate New York county ofthe effects of a community-wide re-minder, recall, and outreach systemfor childhood immunizations resultedin no statistically significant differ-ences from 24-month-old white chil-dren in postintervention immunizationrates for 24-month-old AA and Latinochildren, and no statistically signifi-cant difference between only Latinoand white 12-month-old children inpostintervention immunization rates.Up to 74% of the cohort, however, didnot receive the intervention in somecounty regions, and the immunizationrates were not adjusted for confound-ers.

METHODOLOGIC ISSUES

Failure to evaluate children separatelyfrom adults was the most commonreason for exclusion of studies fromthe final database, accounting for 27(22%) of the excluded studies. Anothercommonly encountered methodologicissue was the combination of all non-white children into 1 group, which oc-curred in 11 (9%) of the excluded stud-ies. An additional 10 studies (8%) failedto provide a white comparison group.Among the 109 studies in the final da-tabase, 27 (22%) did not perform mul-tivariable or stratified analyses to en-sure that racial/ethnic disparitiespersisted after adjustment for socio-economic status (SES) and other po-tential confounders.

IMPLICATIONS

Extensiveness and Pervasivenessof Disparities

A comprehensive review of the litera-ture revealed that racial/ethnic dis-parities in children’s health and healthcare are quite extensive, pervasive,and persistent. Disparities were noted

across the spectrum of health andhealth care, including in mortality rates,access to care and use of services, pre-vention and population health, healthstatus, adolescent health, chronic dis-eases, special health care needs, qual-ity of care, and organ transplantation.In addition, the data indicate that ra-cial/ethnic disparities are persistingor worsening over time, at least in thefew areas for which data from secular-trend studies are available, such asoverall mortality rates, elevated bloodlead concentrations, and asthma prev-alence, mortality, and hospitalizations.

Mortality and Chronic Disease

Although racial/ethnic disparities inadult mortality21 and chronic disease22

rates have receivedmuch attention, lit-tle attention has been paid to these is-sues in children (other than for infantmortality). Nevertheless, review of theliterature identified disparities in mor-tality rates for all 4 major racial/ethnicgroups of US children. The extent anddiversity of these mortality-rate dis-parities are concerning: these dispar-ities include substantially greaterrisks than for white children of all-cause mortality; death from drowning,from ALL, from congenital heart de-fects, and after congenital heart defectsurgery; and an earlier median age atdeath for those with Down syndromeand congenital heart defects. Addi-tional research is needed to determinewhether other racial/ethnic dispari-ties exist in childhood mortality rates,the causes of these disparities, andinterventions that are effective in re-ducing or eliminating mortality-ratedisparities.

Extensive childhood disparities werefound for chronic diseases, includingasthma, cancer, eye disorders, HIV/AIDS, kidney disease, mental health,special health care needs, and stroke.In particular, multiple studies havebeen conducted on disparities in

asthma, mental health, and specialhealth care needs. Nevertheless, manygaps exist in the literature, and fur-ther study is needed to determinethe etiology of and effective interven-tions for disparities in childhoodchronic diseases.

Disparities as a Quality Issue

It has been suggested that a useful ap-proach to addressing racial/ethnicdisparities in children’s health care isto frame disparities as a quality-of-care issue.23 This review of the litera-ture identified multiple racial/ethnicdisparities in the quality of children’shealth care, including inequalities inthe quality of primary care, asthmacare, cardiovascular surgery, mentalhealth care, pneumonia hospitaliza-tions, ophthalmologic care, orthopedicconditions, and care of children withend-stage renal disease. Additionalstudy is warranted, not only of the eti-ology and pervasiveness of disparitiesin the quality of pediatric care, but alsoof interventions that would be effectivein achieving quality improvementamong racial/ethnicminority children.

Research Implications

In the course of reviewing the dispari-ties literature, certain key method-ologic and research issues were iden-tified. Attention to these issues has thepotential to advance the field and en-hance the rigor of studies. A total of 48studies were excluded from the data-base because they combined all minor-ity children into a nebulous “nonwhite”category, failed to include a compari-son group consisting of white children,or did not perform separate analyseswith children disaggregated fromadults.

Occasionally, theremay be statisticallylegitimate reasons to not comparestudy findings for specific minority ra-cial/ethnic groups with those of whitechildren (such as when there truly are

e1014 FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 37: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

small sample sizes for specific minor-ity groups in the study population). Therecurrent findings in the literature,however, of combining minority chil-dren into a “nonwhite group” and fail-ure to collect data for specific, popu-lous minority groups of children raiseseveral key issues. It is critical thatcurrent and future pediatric researchbe relevant, meaningful, and generaliz-able for all children. The explosivegrowth in racial/ethnic diversity of USchildrenmakes it imperative that pedi-atric research funding not ignore spe-cific questions or populations. In addi-tion, as new interventions, practices,and technologies are evaluated, it isimportant to consider translational re-search on the application of these in-novations to diverse populations andsettings.

Almost one-quarter of the excludedstudies did not use multivariable orstratified analyses to adjust for covari-ates that might confound disparitiesfindings. For several domains, such asmental health, asthma, and vision dis-orders, there is an unresolved issuethat warrants further investigation; itis unclear whether (1) a general qual-ity issue exists for minority children ofunderdiagnosis and undertreatmentof certain conditions, (2) there is alower prevalence of these conditionsin certain groups, (3) racial/ethnic dif-ferences occur in access or treatmentpreferences, or (4) some combinationof these phenomena apply.

More disparities research is neededon API and AI/AN children, because apaucity of studies on these groups wasidentified. The few studies that exam-ined relevant subgroups of racial/eth-nic minority children identified note-worthy racial/ethnic disparities. Moreresearch is needed on childhood dis-parities among black subgroups (suchas AAs versus Caribbean blacks versusrecent African immigrants), Latinos

(such as Mexican Americans, PuertoRicans, and Cuban Americans), AIs/ANs (such as major tribal groups), andAPIs (such as Chinese Americans ver-sus Vietnamese versus Hmong). Ourcall for more studies on racial/ethnicsubgroup disparities echoes a recom-mendation published 15 years ago bythe AAP Task Force on Minority Chil-dren’s Access to Pediatric Care thatmore attention be paid to the hetero-geneity of API populations.24

Limitations

Certain limitations of this literature re-view should be noted. The literaturesearch consisted of studies from 1950through March 2007, so studies afterMarch could not be included. Becausethe search strategies only identifiedpublished citations with “disparities”as a key word, studies that reporteddisparities or disparities interventionsbut did not use this key word wouldhave been missed; in particular, re-search from earlier years before the“disparities” term enjoyed wider us-age would have been overlooked. Thefocus was on racial/ethnic disparities,so studies that documented a lack ofdisparities were not reviewed. Only21 studies, however, were excludedthat found no significant differencesaccording to race/ethnicity, equiva-lent to 9% of the database of full-print studies examined, and 17% ofall exclusions.

Interventions to ReduceDisparities

This literature review identified only 2studies that evaluated interventions toreduce racial/ethnic disparities inchildren’s health and health care andthat also compared theminority groupto a white group, and none was a ran-domized, controlled trial. These find-ings suggest that there is a need forrigorous evaluations of interventionsaimed at reducing childhood dispari-ties, especially in light of the substan-

tial number of studies identified thatdocumented a wide variety of racial/ethnic disparities in children’s healthand health care.

Only articles that examined racial/ethnic disparities in the context ofcomparisons to white children wereincluded in the literature review. Forcertain health outcomes for whichracial/ethnic disparities are welldocumented, published studies mayonly have focused on disparities in-terventions limited to a single minor-ity group. Because the literature-search inclusion criteria requiredcomparison between a minoritygroup and a white group, successfuldisparities-intervention studies lim-ited to a single minority group wereexcluded, by necessity, from thistechnical report, such as recent ran-domized trials of interventions to in-sure uninsured Latino children andprevent HIV in AA girls.25,26

CONCLUSIONS

This technical report documents thatracial/ethnic disparities in chil-dren’s health and health care are ex-tensive, pervasive, and persistent.Disparities were noted across thespectrum of health and health care,including in mortality rates, accessto care and use of services, preven-tion and population health, healthstatus, adolescent health, chronicdiseases, special health care needs,quality of care, and organ transplan-tation. Methodologic flaws wereidentified in how such disparities aredocumented and analyzed. Withoutrecognition of child health dispari-ties as pervasive problems, soundmethodologies to assess the magni-tude of disparities, and rigorousevaluation of disparities interven-tions, the pediatric community willnot be able to realize the vision of theAAP to attain optimal physical, men-

FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS

PEDIATRICS Volume 125, Number 4, April 2010 e1015 by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 38: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

tal, and social health and well-beingof all infants, children, adolescents,and young adults.

COMMITTEE ON PEDIATRIC RESEARCH,2008–2009Scott C. Denne, MD, ChairpersonAndrew J. Bauer, MD*Michael D. Cabana, MD, MPHTina L. Cheng, MD†Glenn Flores, MDDaniel A. Notterman, MD

LIAISONSDuane F. Alexander, MD – Eunice KennedyShriver National Institute of Child Healthand Human DevelopmentClifford W. Bogue, MD – Society for PediatricResearchLaurence A. Boxer, MD – American PediatricSocietyChristopher A. DeGraw, MD, MPH – Maternaland Child Health BureauDenise Dougherty, PhD – Agency forHealthcare Research and QualityBenard P. Dreyer, MD – Academic PediatricAssociation

Elizabeth Goodman, MD – Society forAdolescent MedicineA. Craig Hillemeier, MD – Association ofMedical School Pediatric Department ChairsLewis H. Margolis, MD, MPH – American PublicHealth AssociationJessica Shand, MD – AAP Section on ResidentsPaul P. Wang, MD – Society for Developmentaland Behavioral Pediatrics

STAFFWilliam L. Cull, PhD

*Contributing author†Lead author

REFERENCES

1. Agency for Healthcare Research and Qual-ity. National Healthcare Disparities Re-port, 2007. Rockville, MD: US Departmentof Health and Human Services, Agency forHealthcare Research and Quality; 2008.AHRQ publication 08–0041

2. Agency for Healthcare Research and Qual-ity. National Healthcare Disparities Re-port. Rockville, MD: US Department ofHealth and Human Services, Agency forHealthcare Research and Quality; 2003.Available at: www.ahrq.gov/qual/nhdr03/nhdr2003.pdf. Accessed August 20, 2009

3. US Department of Health and Human Ser-vices. Healthy People 2010: Understandingand Improving Health. 2nd ed. Washing-ton, DC: US Government Printing Office;2000

4. National Institute of Child Health and Hu-man Development, National Institutes ofHealth, Department of Health and HumanServices. Health Disparities: Bridging theGap. Washington, DC: US GovernmentPrinting Office; 2000

5. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.Achieving greater health impact: CDC’s stra-tegic imperatives. Available at: www.cdc.gov/osi/goals/SIHPGPostcard.pdf. AccessedAugust 20, 2009

6. National Institutes of Health. The NIH Alma-nac: National Center on Minority Health andHealth Disparities. Available at: www.nih-.gov/about/almanac/organization/NCMH-D.htm. Accessed August 20, 2009

7. Smedley BD, Stith AY, Nelson AR, eds. Un-equal Treatment: Confronting Racial andEthnic Disparities in Health Care. Washing-ton, DC: National Academies Press; 2003

8. S 4024: Minority Health Improvement andHealth Disparity Elimination Act (2006).Available at: www.govtrack.us/congress/bill.xpd?bill�s109-4024. Accessed August20, 2009

9. US Department of Health and Human Ser-vices, Health Resources and Services Ad-

ministration. HRSA Releases New Docu-ment on Eliminating Health Disparities[press release]. Washington, DC: US De-partment of Health and Human Services;2001

10. Wise PH. The anatomy of a disparity in in-fant mortality. Annu Rev Public Health.2003;24:341–362

11. US Department of Health and Human Ser-vices. Oral Health in America: A Report ofthe Surgeon General. Rockville, MD: US De-partment of Health and Human Services,National Institute of Dental and Craniofa-cial Research, National Institutes ofHealth; 2000

12. American Academy of Pediatrics, Commit-tee on Pediatric Workforce. Enhancing thediversity of the pediatrician workforce. Pe-diatrics. 2007;119(4):833–837

13. US Census Bureau. United States: S0901—children characteristics. Available at:http://factfinder.census.gov/servlet/STTable?�bm�y&-qr�name�ACS�2006�EST�G00�S0901&-geo�id�01000US&-ds�name�ACS�2006�EST�G00�&-�lang�en&-format�&CONTEXT�st. Accessed August 20, 2009

14. US Census Bureau. Census 2000 PHC-T-8:race and Hispanic or Latino origin by ageand sex for the United States: 2000. Table8: Hispanic or Latino origin population;white alone not-Hispanic or Latino originpopulation; and population other thanwhite alone not-Hispanic or Latino origin,by age and sex for the United States: 2000.Available at: www.census.gov/population/cen2000/phc-t08/tab08.pdf. Accessed Au-gust 20, 2009

15. Annie E. Casey Foundation. Kids Count cen-sus data online: 2000 census data—summary profile for United States. Se-lected demographic characteristics forchildren: 1990 and 2000. Available at: www.kidscount.org/cgi-bin/aeccensus.cgi?action�profileresults&area�00N&areaparent�

00N&printerfriendly�0&section�0. Ac-cessed August 20, 2009

16. Brookings Institution Center on Urban andMetropolitan Policy. Racial change in thenation’s largest cities: evidence from the2000 census. Available at: www.brookings.edu/es/urban/census/citygrowth.htm. Ac-cessed August 20, 2009

17. US Census Bureau. DP-1: profile of generaldemographic characteristics—2000. Cali-fornia. Available at: http://factfinder.census.gov/servlet/QTTable?_bm�y&-geo�id�04000US06&-qr�name�DEC�2000�SF1�U�DP1&-ds�name�DEC�2000�SF1�U&-�lang�en&-�sse�on. AccessedAugust 20, 2009

18. US Census Bureau. California: general de-mographic characteristics: 2005. Avail-able at: http://factfinder.census.gov/servlet/ADPTable?�bm�y&-geo� id�04000US06&-qr �name�ACS �2005 �EST�G00�DP1&-ds�name�ACS�2005�EST�G00�&-�lang�en&-�sse�on. AccessedAugust 20, 2009

19. US Census Bureau. (NP-T4-F) Projectionsof the total resident population by 5-yearage groups, race, and Hispanic origin withspecial age categories: middle series,2025 to 2045. Available at: www.census.gov/population/projections/nation/summary/np-t4-f.pdf. Accessed August 20,2009

20. US Census Bureau. Minority populationtops 100 million [press release]. Availableat: www.census.gov/Press-Release/www/releases/archives/population/010048.html. Accessed August 20, 2009

21. Williams DR, Jackson PB. Social sources ofracial disparities in health.Health Aff (Mill-wood). 2005;24(2):325–334

22. Redmond LJ, Bowman BA, Mensah GA.Health Disparities: A Selected Bibliogra-phy From the National Center for ChronicDisease Prevention and Health Promo-tion—January 2000–January 2005. At-

e1016 FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 39: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

lanta, GA: Centers for Disease Control andPrevention; 2005

23. Beal AC. Policies to reduce racial and eth-nic disparities in child health and healthcare. Health Aff (Millwood). 2004;23(5):171–179

24. American Academy of Pediatrics, TaskForce on Minority Children’s Access to Pe-diatric Care. Report of the AAP Task Forceon Minority Children’s Access to PediatricCare. Elk Grove Village, IL: American Acad-emy of Pediatrics; 1994

25. Flores G, Abreu M, Chaisson CE, et al. Arandomized trial of the effectiveness ofcommunity-based case management in in-suring uninsured Latino children. Pediat-rics. 2005;116(6):1433–1441

26. DiClemente RJ, Wingood GM, HarringtonKF, et al. Efficacy of an HIV prevention inter-vention for African American adolescentgirls: a randomized controlled trial. JAMA.2004;292(2):171–179

27. Guagliardo MF, Ronzio CR, Cheung I, ChackoE, Joseph JG. Physician accessibility: an ur-bancasestudyof pediatric providers.HealthPlace. 2004;10(3):273–283

28. Shi L, Stevens GD. Disparities in access tocare and satisfaction among U.S. children:the roles of race/ethnicity and poverty sta-tus. Public Health Rep. 2005;120(4):431–441

29. Guagliardo MF, Teach SJ, Huang ZJ, Cham-berlain JM, Joseph JG. Racial and ethnicdisparities in pediatric appendicitis rup-ture rate. Acad Emerg Med. 2003;10(11):1218–1227

30. Shone LP, Dick AW, Brach C, et al. The roleof race and ethnicity in the State Chil-dren’s Health Insurance Program (SCHIP)in four states: are there baseline dispari-ties, and what do they mean for SCHIP?Pediatrics. 2003;112(6 pt 2). Available at:www.pediatrics.org/cgi/content/full/112/6/SE1/e521

31. Shone LP, Dick AW, Klein JD, Zwanziger J,Szilagyi PG. Reduction in racial and ethnicdisparities after enrollment in the StateChildren’s Health Insurance Program. Pe-diatrics. 2005;115(6). Available at:www.pediatrics.org/cgi/content/full/115/6/e697

32. Flores G, Olson L, Tomany-Korman SC. Ra-cial and ethnic disparities in early child-hood health and health care. Pediatrics.2005;115(2). Available at: www.pediatrics.org/cgi/content/full/115/2/e183

33. Klein JD, Shenkman E, Brach C, et al. Priorhealth care experiences of adolescentswho enroll in SCHIP. J Health Care PoorUnderserved. 2006;17(4):789–807

34. Heflinger CA, Chatman J, Saunders RC. Ra-cial and gender differences in utilization ofMedicaid substance abuse servicesamong adolescents. Psychiatr Serv. 2006;57(4):504–511

35. Harris KM, Gordon-Larsen P, Chantala K,Udry JR. Longitudinal trends in race/ethnic disparities in leading health indica-tors from adolescence to young adult-hood. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 2006;160(1):74–81

36. Keppel KG, Pearcy JN, Wagener DK. Trendsin racial and ethnic-specific rates for thehealth status indicators: United States,1990–98. Healthy People 2000 Stat Notes.2002;(23):1–16

37. Margellos H, Silva A, Whitman S. Compari-son of health status indicators in Chicago:are black-white disparities worsening?Am J Public Health. 2004;94(1):116–121

38. Arias E, MacDorman MF, Strobino DM,Guyer B. Annual summary of vitalstatistics: 2002. Pediatrics. 2003;112(6 pt1):1215–1230

39. Marcin JP, Pretzlaff RK, Whittaker HL, KonAA. Evaluation of race and ethnicity on al-cohol and drug testing of adolescents ad-mitted with trauma. Acad Emerg Med.2003;10(11):1253–1259

40. Akinbami LJ, Schoendorf KC. Trends inchildhood asthma: prevalence, healthcare utilization, and mortality. Pediatrics.2002;110(2 pt 1):315–322

41. McDaniel M, Paxson C, Waldfogel J. Racialdisparities in childhood asthma in theUnited States: evidence from the NationalHealth Interview Survey, 1997 to 2003. Pe-diatrics. 2006;117(5). Available at:www.pediatrics.org/cgi/content/full/117/5/e868

42. Pearlman DN, Zierler S, Meersman S, KimHK, Viner-Brown SI, Caron C. Race dispari-ties in childhood asthma: does where youlive matter? J Natl Med Assoc. 2006;98(2):239–247

43. Guevara JP, Mandell DS, Rostain AL, ZhaoH, Hadley TR. Disparities in the reportingand treatment of health conditions inchildren: an analysis of the Medical Expen-diture Panel Survey. Health Serv Res. 2006;41(2):532–549

44. McCoy L, RedelingsM, Sorvillo F, Simon P. Amultiple cause-of-death analysis ofasthma mortality in the United States,1990–2001. J Asthma. 2005;42(9):757–763

45. Stingone JA, Claudio L. Disparities in theuse of urgent health care services amongasthmatic children. Ann Allergy AsthmaImmunol. 2006;97(2):244–250

46. Quinn K, Shalowitz MU, Berry CA, Mijanov-

ich T, Wolf RL. Racial and ethnic disparitiesin diagnosed and possible undiagnosedasthma among public-school children inChicago. Am J Public Health. 2006;96(9):1599–1603

47. Roberts EM. Racial and ethnic disparitiesin childhood asthma diagnosis: the role ofclinical findings. J Natl Med Assoc. 2002;94(4):215–223

48. Lieu TA, Lozano P, Finkelstein JA, et al.Racial/ethnic variation in asthma statusand management practices among chil-dren in managed Medicaid. Pediatrics.2002;109(5):857–865

49. Stevenson LA, Gergen PJ, Hoover DR,Rosenstreich D, Mannino DM, Matte TD. So-ciodemographic correlates of indoor al-lergen sensitivity among United Stateschildren. J Allergy Clin Immunol. 2001;108(5):747–752

50. Simon PA, Zeng Z, Wold CM, Haddock W,Fielding JE. Prevalence of childhoodasthma and associated morbidity in LosAngeles County: impacts of race/ethnicityand income. J Asthma. 2003;40(5):535–543

51. Ortega AN, Gergen PJ, Paltiel AD, BauchnerH, Belanger KD, Leaderer BP. Impact of siteof care, race, and Hispanic ethnicity onmedication use for childhood asthma. Pe-diatrics. 2002;109(1). Available at:www.pediatrics.org/cgi/content/full/109/1/e1

52. Smith LA, Hatcher-Ross JL, Wertheimer R,Kahn RS. Rethinking race/ethnicity, in-come, and childhood asthma: racial/ethnic disparities concentrated amongthe very poor. Public Health Rep. 2005;120(2):109–120

53. Li R, Grummer-Strawn L. Racial and ethnicdisparities in breastfeeding among UnitedStates infants: Third National Health andNutrition Examination Survey, 1988–1994.Birth. 2002;29(4):251–257

54. Fullerton HJ, Wu YW, Zhao S, Johnston SC.Risk of stroke in children: ethnic and gen-der disparities. Neurology. 2003;61(2):189–194

55. Stevens GD, Seid M, Mistry R, Halfon N. Dis-parities in primary care for vulnerablechildren: the influence of multiple risk fac-tors. Health Serv Res. 2006;41(2):507–531

56. Chen E, Martin AD, Matthews KA. Under-standing health disparities: the role ofrace and socioeconomic status in chil-dren’s health. Am J Public Health. 2006;96(4):702–708

57. Goodman E, McEwen BS, Dolan LM,Schafer-Kalkhoff T, Adler NE. Social disad-vantage and adolescent stress. J AdolescHealth. 2005;37(6):484–492

FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS

PEDIATRICS Volume 125, Number 4, April 2010 e1017 by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 40: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

58. Stevens GD. Gradients in the health statusand developmental risks of youngchildren: the combined influences of mul-tiple social risk factors. Matern ChildHealth J. 2006;10(2):187–199

59. Centers for Disease Control and Preven-tion. Racial/ethnic disparities in diag-noses of HIV/AIDS: 33 states, 2001–2004.MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep. 2006;55(5):121–125

60. Rutstein RM, Gebo KA, Siberry GK, et al.Hospital and outpatient health servicesutilization among HIV-infected children incare 2000 –2001. Med Care. 2005;43(9suppl):III31–III39

61. Parker JD, Schoendorf KC. Variation inhospital discharges for ambulatory care-sensitive conditions among children. Pedi-atrics. 2000;106(4 suppl):942–948

62. Dominguez SR, Parrott JS, Lauderdale DS,Daum RS. On-time immunization ratesamong children who enter Chicago publicschools. Pediatrics. 2004;114(6). Availableat: www.pediatrics.org/cgi/content/full/114/6/e741

63. Flannery B, Schrag S, Bennett NM, et al.Impact of childhood vaccination on racialdisparities in invasive Streptococcuspneumoniae infections. JAMA. 2004;291(18):2197–2203

64. Stout JE, Saharia KK, Nageswaran S,Ahmed A, Hamilton CD. Racial and ethnicdisparities in pediatric tuberculosis inNorth Carolina. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med.2006;160(6):631–637

65. Roesler J, Ostercamp M. Pediatric firearminjury in Minnesota, 1998: fatal and nonfa-tal firearm injuries among Minnesotayouth. Minn Med. 2000;83(9):57–60

66. Flores G, Tomany-Korman SC, Olson L. Doesdisadvantage start at home? Racial andethnic disparities in health-related earlychildhood home routines and safety prac-tices. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 2005;159(2):158–165

67. Zimmerman FJ. Social and economic de-terminants of disparities in professionalhelp-seeking for child mental healthproblems: evidence from a national sam-ple. Health Serv Res. 2005;40(5 pt 1):1514–1533

68. Pastor PN, Reuben CA. Racial and ethnicdifferences in ADHD and LD in youngschool-age children: parental reports inthe National Health Interview Survey. Pub-lic Health Rep. 2005;120(4):383–392

69. Garland AF, Lau AS, Yeh M, McCabe KM,Hough RL, Landsverk JA. Racial and ethnicdifferences in utilization of mental health

services among high-risk youths. Am JPsychiatry. 2005;162(7):1336–1343

70. Mandell DS, Listerud J, Levy S, Pinto-MartinJA. Race differences in the age at diagno-sis among Medicaid-eligible children withautism. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychia-try. 2002;41(12):1447–1453

71. Bussing R, Zima BT, Gary FA, Garvan CW.Barriers to detection, help-seeking, andservice use for children with ADHD symp-toms. J Behav Health Serv Res. 2003;30(2):176–189

72. Chow JC, Jaffee K, Snowden L. Racial/eth-nic disparities in the use of mental healthservices in poverty areas. Am J PublicHealth. 2003;93(5):792–797

73. Hurlburt MS, Leslie LK, Landsverk J, et al.Contextual predictors of mental healthservice use among children open to childwelfare. Arch Gen Psychiatry. 2004;61(12):1217–1224

74. Zito JM, Safer DJ, Zuckerman IH, GardnerJF, Soeken K. Effect of Medicaid eligibilitycategory on racial disparities in the use ofpsychotropic medications among youths.Psychiatr Serv. 2005;56(2):157–163

75. Saluja G, Brenner RA, Trumble AC, SmithGS, Schroeder T, Cox C. Swimming pooldrownings among US residents aged 5–24years: understanding racial/ethnic dis-parities. Am J Public Health. 2006;96(4):728–733

76. Hillemeier MM, Geronimus AT, Bound SJ.Widening black/white mortality differen-tials among US children during the 1980s.Ethn Dis. 2001;11(3):469–483

77. Centers for Disease Control and Preven-tion. Racial disparities in median age atdeath of persons with Down syndrome:United States, 1968–1997. MMWR MorbidMortal Wkly Rep. 2001;50(22):463–465

78. Boneva RS, Botto LD, Moore CA, Yang Q,Correa A, Erickson JD. Mortality associ-ated with congenital heart defects in theUnited States: trends and racial dispari-ties, 1979–1997. Circulation. 2001;103(19):2376–2381

79. Singh GK, Yu SM. US childhood mortality,1950 through 1993: trends and socioeco-nomic differentials. Am J Public Health.1996;86(4):505–512

80. Berger KH, Zhu BP, Copeland G. Mortalitythroughout early childhood for Michiganchildren born with congenital anomalies,1992–1998. Birth Defects Res A Clin MolTeratol. 2003;67(9):656–661

81. Kadan-Lottick NS, Ness KK, Bhatia S, Gur-ney JG. Survival variability by race and eth-nicity in childhood acute lymphoblasticleukemia. JAMA. 2003;290(15):2008–2014

82. Benavidez OJ, Gauvreau K, Jenkins KJ. Ra-cial and ethnic disparities in mortality fol-lowing congenital heart surgery. PediatrCardiol. 2006;27(3):321–328

83. Furth SL, Powe NR, Hwang W, Neu AM, Fi-vush BA. Racial differences in choice of di-alysismodality for childrenwith end-stagerenal disease. Pediatrics. 1997:99(4).Available at: www.pediatrics.org/cgi/content/full/99/4/e6

84. Leonard MB, Stablein DM, Ho M, Jabs K,Feldman HI. Racial and center differencesin hemodialysis adequacy in childrentreated at pediatric centers: a North Amer-ican Pediatric Renal Transplant Coopera-tive Study (NAPRTCS) report. J Am SocNephrol. 2004;15(11):2923–2932

85. Furth SL, Garg PP, Neu AM, Hwang W, Fi-vush BA, Powe NR. Racial differences in ac-cess to the kidney transplant waiting listfor children and adolescents with end-stage renal disease. Pediatrics. 2000;106(4):756–761

86. Adams K, Sargent RG, Thompson SH, Rich-ter D, Corwin SJ, Rogan TJ. A study of bodyweight concerns and weight control prac-tices of 4th and 7th grade adolescents.Ethn Health. 2000;5(1):79–94

87. Shaibi GQ, Ball GD, Goran MI. Aerobic fit-ness among Caucasian, African-American,and Latino youth. Ethn Dis. 2006;16(1):120–125

88. Lee NE, De AK, Simon PA. School-basedphysical fitness testing identifies largedisparities in childhood overweight in LosAngeles. J Am Diet Assoc. 2006;106(1):118–121

89. Goodman E, Daniels SR, Dolan LM. Socio-economic disparities in insulin resistance:results from the Princeton School DistrictStudy. Psychosom Med. 2007;69(1):61–67

90. Delva J, O’Malley PM, Johnston LD. Racial/ethnic and socioeconomic status differ-ences in overweight and health-related be-haviors among American students:national trends 1986 –2003. J AdolescHealth. 2006;39(4):536–545

91. Neumark-Sztainer D, Story M, Hannan PJ,Croll J. Overweight status and eating pat-terns among adolescents: where doyouths stand in comparison with theHealthy People 2010 objectives? Am J Pub-lic Health. 2002;92(5):844–851

92. Davy BM, Harrell K, Stewart J, King DS.Body weight status, dietary habits, andphysical activity levels of middle school-aged children in rural Mississippi. SouthMed J. 2004;97(12):571–577

93. Hedley AA, Ogden CL, Johnson CL, CarrollMD, Curtin LR, Flegal KM. Prevalence of

e1018 FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 41: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

overweight and obesity among US chil-dren, adolescents, and adults, 1999–2002.JAMA. 2004;291(23):2847–2850

94. Beets MW, Pitetti KH. One-mile run/walkand body mass index of an ethnically di-verse sample of youth. Med Sci Sports Ex-erc. 2004;36(10):1796–1803

95. Ganz ML, Xuan Z, Hunter DG. Prevalenceand correlates of children’s diagnosed eyeand vision conditions. Ophthalmology.2006;113(12):2298–2306

96. Slover J, Gibson J, Tosteson T, Smith B,Koval K. Racial and economic disparity andthe treatment of pediatric fractures. J Pe-diatr Orthop. 2005;25(6):717–721

97. Hambidge SJ, Emsermann CB, Federico S,Steiner JF. Disparities in pediatric preven-tive care in the United States, 1993–2002.Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 2007;161(1):30–36

98. Selden TM. Compliancewithwell-child visitrecommendations: evidence from theMedical Expenditure Panel Survey,2000–2002. Pediatrics. 2006;118(6). Avail-able at: www.pediatrics.org/cgi/content/full/118/6/e1766

99. Milazzo AS Jr, Sanders SP, Armstrong BE,Li JS. Racial and geographic disparities intiming of bidirectional Glenn and Fontanstages of single-ventricle palliation. J NatlMed Assoc. 2002;94(10):873–878

100. Stevens GD, Shi L. Effect of managed careon children’s relationships with their pri-mary care physicians: differences by race.Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 2002;156(4):369–377

101. Weech-Maldonado R, Morales LS, SpritzerK, Elliott M, Hays RD. Racial and ethnic dif-ferences in parents’ assessments of pedi-atric care in Medicaid managed care.Health Serv Res. 2001;36(3):575–594

102. Seid M, Stevens GD, Varni JW. Parents’ per-ceptions of pediatric primary care quality:effects of race/ethnicity, language, and ac-cess. Health Serv Res. 2003;38(4):1009–1031

103. Inkelas M, Smith KA, Kuo AA, Rudolph L, Ig-daloff S. Health care access for childrenwith special health care needs in Califor-nia.Matern Child Health J. 2005;9(2 suppl):S109–S116

104. Newacheck PW, Hung YY, Wright KK. Racialand ethnic disparities in access to care forchildren with special health care needs.Ambul Pediatr. 2002;2(4):247–254

105. van Dyck PC, Kogan MD, McPherson MG,Weissman GR, Newacheck PW. Prevalenceand characteristics of children with spe-cial health care needs. Arch Pediatr Ado-lesc Med. 2004;158(9):884–890

106. Ngui EM, Flores G. Satisfaction with careand ease of using health care servicesamong parents of children with specialhealth care needs: the roles of race/ethnicity, insurance, language, and ade-quacy of family-centered care. Pediatrics.2006;117(4):1184–1196

107. Kokoska ER, Bird TM, Robbins JM, SmithSD, Corsi JM, Campbell BT. Racial dispari-ties in the management of pediatric ap-pendicitis. J Surg Res. 2007;137(1):83–88

108. Omoloja A, Stolfi A,MitsnefesM. Racial differ-ences in pediatric renal transplantation: 24-year single center experience. J Natl Med As-soc. 2006;98(2):154–157

109. Mahle WT, Kanter KR, Vincent RN. Dispari-ties in outcome for black patients after pe-diatric heart transplantation. J Pediatr.2005;147(6):739–743

110. Tai-Seale M, Freund D, LoSasso A. Racialdisparities in service use among Medicaidbeneficiaries after mandatory enrollmentin managed care: a difference-in-differences approach. Inquiry. 2001;38(1):49–59

111. Patterson PD, Baxley EG, Probst JC, HusseyJR, Moore CG. Medically unnecessaryemergency medical services (EMS) trans-ports among children ages 0 to 17 years.Matern Child Health J. 2006;10(6):527–536

112. Flores G, Bauchner H, Feinstein AR, NguyenUDT. The impact of ethnicity, family in-come, and parental education on chil-dren’s health and use of health services.Am J Public Health. 1999;89(7):1066–1071

113. Washington EL, Shen JJ, Bell R, Coleman C,Shi L. Patterns of hospital-based pediatriccare across diverse ethnicities: the case ofpneumonia. J Health Care Poor Under-served. 2004;15(3):462–473

114. Buescher PA, Horton SJ, Devaney BL, et al.Differences in use of health services be-tween white and African American chil-dren enrolled in Medicaid in North Caro-lina. Matern Child Health J. 2003;7(1):45–52

115. Untalan F, Woodruff K, Hardy C, Liao M,Krupitsky D. Disparities in outcomes forpediatric cancer patients treated inHawai’i: comparing Hawai’i residents tochildren referred from the Pacific Islands.Pac Health Dialog. 2004;11(2):114–119

116. Allen ML, Elliott MN, Morales LS, DiamantAL, Hambarsoomian K, Schuster MA. Ado-lescent participation in preventive healthbehaviors, physical activity, and nutrition:differences across immigrant generationsfor Asians and Latinos compared withwhites. Am J Public Health. 2007;97(2):337–343

117. Wenceslao S, Gotay CC, Cheung LW, White K.Patterns of childhood cancer in Hawai’i be-tween 1975 and 2000. Hawaii Med J. 2006;65(8):221–225

118. Buechner JS. Health disparities among ra-cial and ethnic groups in Rhode Island.Med Health R I. 2000;83(8):257–258

119. Stevens GD, Shi L. Racial and ethnic dispar-ities in the quality of primary care for chil-dren. J Fam Pract. 2002;51(6):573

120. Stevens GD, Shi L, Cooper LA. Patient-provider racial and ethnic concordanceand parent reports of the primary care ex-periences of children. Ann Fam Med. 2003;1(2):105–112

121. Borders TF, Brannon-Goedeke A, Arif A, XuKT. Parents’ reports of children’s medicalcare access: are there Mexican-Americanversus non-Hispanic white disparities?Med Care. 2004;42(9):884–892

122. Brousseau DC, Hoffmann RG, Yauck J,Nattinger AB, Flores G. Disparities forLatino children in the timely receipt ofmedical care. Ambul Pediatr. 2005;5(6):319 –325

123. Beckmann KR, Melzer-Lange MD, Gore-lick MH. Emergency department man-agement of sexually transmitted infec-tions in US adolescents: results from theNational Hospital Ambulatory MedicalCare Survey. Ann Emerg Med. 2004;43(3):333–338

124. Claudio L, Stingone JA, Godbold J. Preva-lence of childhood asthma in urbancommunities: the impact of ethnicity andincome. Ann Epidemiol. 2006;16(5):332–340

125. Akinbami LJ, Rhodes JC, LaraM. Racial andethnic differences in asthma diagnosisamong children who wheeze. Pediatrics.2005;115(5):1254–1260

126. Deck D, Ley KV. Medicaid eligibility and ac-cess to mental health services among ad-olescents in substance abuse treatment.Psychiatr Serv. 2006;57(2):263–265

127. Kataoka SH, Zhang L, Wells KB. Unmet needfor mental health care among U.S.children: variation by ethnicity and insur-ance status. Am J Psychiatry. 2002;159(9):1548–1555

128. Richardson LP, DiGiuseppe D, Garrison M,Christakis DA. Depression in Medicaid-covered youth: differences by race andethnicity. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 2003;157(10):984–989

129. Sturm R, Ringel JS, Andreyeva T. Geo-graphic disparities in children’s mentalhealth care. Pediatrics. 2003;112(4). Avail-able at: www.pediatrics.org/cgi/content/full/112/4/e308

FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS

PEDIATRICS Volume 125, Number 4, April 2010 e1019 by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 42: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

130. Stevens J, Harman JS, Kelleher KJ. Ethnicand regional differences in primary carevisits for attention-deficit hyperactivitydisorder. J Dev Behav Pediatr. 2004;25(5):318–325

131. Quintana J, Goldmann D, Homer C. Socialdisparities in the use of diagnostic testsfor children with gastroenteritis. Int J QualHealth Care. 1997;9(6):419–425

132. Xu KT, Borders TF, Arif AA. Ethnic differ-ences in parents’ perception of participa-tory decision-making style of their chil-

dren’s physicians. Med Care. 2004;42(4):328–335

133. Yu SM, Nyman RM, Kogan MD, Huang ZJ,Schwalberg RH. Parent’s language of inter-view and access to care for children withspecial health care needs. Ambul Pediatr.2004;4(2):181–187

134. Grossman DC, Krieger JW, Sugarman JR,Forquera RA. Health status of urban Amer-ican Indians and Alaska Natives: apopulation-based study. JAMA. 1994;271(11):845–850

135. Frenn M, Malin S, Bansal N, et al. Address-ing health disparities in middle school stu-dents’ nutrition and exercise. J CommunityHealth Nurs. 2003;20(1):1–14

136. Szilagyi PG, Schaffer S, Shone L, et al.Reducing geographic, racial, and ethnicdisparities in childhood immunizationrates by using reminder/recall interven-tions in urban primary care practices.Pediatrics. 2002;110(5). Available at:www.pediatrics.org/cgi/content/full/110/5/e58

e1020 FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 43: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

DOI: 10.1542/peds.2010-0188 originally published online March 29, 2010; 2010;125;e979Pediatrics 

Glenn Flores and THE COMMITTEE ON PEDIATRIC RESEARCHRacial and Ethnic Disparities in the Health and Health Care of Children

ServicesUpdated Information &

http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/125/4/e979including high resolution figures, can be found at:

Referenceshttp://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/125/4/e979#BIBLThis article cites 105 articles, 15 of which you can access for free at:

Subspecialty Collections

ic_researchhttp://www.aappublications.org/cgi/collection/committee_on_pediatrCommittee on Pediatric Researchhttp://www.aappublications.org/cgi/collection/current_policyCurrent Policyfollowing collection(s): This article, along with others on similar topics, appears in the

Permissions & Licensing

http://www.aappublications.org/site/misc/Permissions.xhtmlin its entirety can be found online at: Information about reproducing this article in parts (figures, tables) or

Reprintshttp://www.aappublications.org/site/misc/reprints.xhtmlInformation about ordering reprints can be found online:

by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from

Page 44: TechnicalReport—RacialandEthnicDisparitiesin ...4.1 14.8 20.3 57.3 42.7 0 13.9-2.0-16.8 58.5 66.4-30-20-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 % of population 1990 Census 2006 ACS Interval

DOI: 10.1542/peds.2010-0188 originally published online March 29, 2010; 2010;125;e979Pediatrics 

Glenn Flores and THE COMMITTEE ON PEDIATRIC RESEARCHRacial and Ethnic Disparities in the Health and Health Care of Children

http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/125/4/e979located on the World Wide Web at:

The online version of this article, along with updated information and services, is

by the American Academy of Pediatrics. All rights reserved. Print ISSN: 1073-0397. the American Academy of Pediatrics, 345 Park Avenue, Itasca, Illinois, 60143. Copyright © 2010has been published continuously since 1948. Pediatrics is owned, published, and trademarked by Pediatrics is the official journal of the American Academy of Pediatrics. A monthly publication, it

by guest on March 5, 2021www.aappublications.org/newsDownloaded from


Recommended