1
IT Project Portfolio Management: Vertical and Horizontal Work Design Problems in
a Public Organization
2
Thanks and welcome to Dr. Per Svejvig and Dr. Shegaw Mengiste
Overview
3
Discussion Analysis
Research process
Research questions
Contributions
Introduction
PhD
- Basis assumptions- Engaged Scholarship - Three cycles of engagement
Theoretical frame
- Five concepts from work design theory
- Use of the five concepts
- Concept map - Recommendations - Each research question's
contribution to the IS literature
- Definitions - Is this IS? - Practical problem (in local governments)- Research gab
(RQ1) how does a public organization design IT PPM, (RQ2) what problems are caused by this design, (RQ3) and what changes can be recommended to improve IT PPM?
4
Introduction
IT Project Portfolio Management (IT PPM)
• Analogy: IT PPM is like team management in professional cycling - it focuses on the team’s overall strategy and allocation of resources. (Fonstad and Robertson 2006).
5
Introduction
Information Systems characteristics:
(1) IT PPM consists of vertical and horizontal mechanisms, linking different stakeholders from the business part and the and IT part of the organization (Fonstad and Robertson 2006).
(2) IT PPM is interrelated with portfolios of IT applications, and portfolios of IT Infrastructure (Kumar et al. 2008).
(3) IT PPM consists of IT projects, which I define as: the implementation or modification of a business unit’s access to information using technical media such as computers, cables or phone switches (Bonham 2005).
6
Introduction
*
Digital initiatives from the Danish government:
• Increased amount of digitalization initiatives during the last 30 years
• “the greatest digital leap so far”
(Regeringen 2011).
Cost cuts in the local governments budgets of historical dimensions:
Budgets are 6 billion d.dk below the level in 2009 14.000 fulltime jobs in are abolish during 2011
(KL’s Økonomiske Sekretariat 2012).
A Practical problem 98 Danish local governments
Pressure
Pressure
7
Introduction
Norlan and McFarlan (2005)
Local governments
Der er bred enighed om at det er strategisk vigtigt at udvikle nye IT systemer og services
Antal indbyggere
I høj grad
I nogen grad
I mindre grad
Slet ikke
40.000 37 47 11 5
40.001-100.00
0
42 55 3 0
Over 100.00
0
80 20 0 0
DISIMIT 2012 (n=55)
Danish Local governments go towards an more offensive mode in IT PPM?
8
Introduction
Local government of Newport
9
Introduktion
From an Information Systems perspective
• Call for more knowledge regarding the vertical and horizontal mechanisms connecting organizations strategy to the local IT projects (Fonstad and Robertson 2006)
• Lack of empirical research identifying what IT PPM related
problems a real life organization experiences. Most IT PPM research gives precedence to theory (Hansen and Kræmmergaard 2011), and will at worst ignore real life IT PPM problems.
• IT PPM practices suggested by the literature do not fit the
reality of local governments. (Pedersen and Hansen 2010; Hansen 2011; Pedersen and Nielsen 2012). *
10
Research questions
(RQ1)How does a public organization design IT PPM, (RQ2) what problems are caused by this design, (RQ3) and what changes can be recommended to improve IT PPM?
11
Research framework
12
Research process
Basic assumptions:
• Research must contribute to practice as well as research otherwise we (in IS) will lose credibility in the long run (Van de Ven 2007).
• Engaging in empirical reality increase the likelihood that research provides relevant results (Van de Ven 2007)
• Analogy – like the work of a miner digging for valuable metal. The miner will never find all the valuable metal below the surface. But the amount of days used on working in the mine and careful planning at night, will increase the likelihood of valuable finding (Kvale 1994).
13
Research process
14
Research process
Cycle of engagement
Period Empirical evidence
1 November 2010to May 201
Interviews of nine IT project managers,Interview of six IT executivesCollection of 35 documentsThree observation studies
2 August 2011 toJanuary 2012
Re-interviews of the six IT executivesRe-interview of an IT project managerInterview of one IT managerInterview of tree vice directorsOne workshop involving the six IT executives Collection of 38 documents
3 March 2012 to June 2012
Three interviews of the Central Unit’s IT executive One workshop involving the organization’s IT executives
15
Analysis
Concept 1: Vertical division of work:
16
Analysis
Level Authority Knowledge ResourcesPolitical organization
Authority to take major decisions regarding the organization’s strategic direction
IT PPM considered as less relevant
Allocate money resources via budgets
Director level Authority to take major decisions regarding major initiatives in the administrative organization
Large knowledge regarding most important strategic IT projects
Allocates resources via approving recommendation
IT executive level
Authority as a level 3 executives
Knowledge regarding content in IT PPM and how IT PPM can be improved
Most of IT executives’ resources are bound to maintaining the current systems
IT project level No authority without steering group
Lack of knowledge regarding IT project management is pronounced in unit based projects
Internal resources are held by units and subunits
Concept 1: Vertical division of work:
17
Analysis
Concept 2: Horizontal division of work:
Archer and Ghasemzadeh 2007
18
Analysis
Phase Seven key IT PPM tasks Main actors
Pre selection Development of IT strategies IT groups
Development of methodology IT groups
Selection Pre screening and individual project analysis IT project teams
Portfolio selection Level of directors
Post selection IT Project development IT project teams
IT project evaluation IT project teams
Concept 2: Horizontal division of work:
19
Research framework
20
Analysis
Concept 3: Hierarchical decomposition problems
Hansen and Kræmmergaard (2012a; 2012b)
21
Analysis
Hansen and Mengiste (2012)
Concept 4: Modularity problems:
22
Analysis
Concept 5: Complex network problems:
23
Research framework
24
Discussion
25
Discussion
Recommendations to address Hierarchical decomposition problems
Hansen and Kræmmergaard (2012b)
26
Discussion
Hansen and Mengiste (2012)
Recommendations to address modularity problems
27
Discussion
Recommendations to address complex network problems
(Cummings 2009)
28
Discussion
Recommendations to address complex network problems
29
Contributions
(RQ1)How does a public organization design IT PPM
• Shows how vertical linking mechanisms, as emphasized by Fonstad and Robertson (2006), not only consist of funding reviews, reward systems, strategy boards: I find that authority, knowledge and resources can be divided across hierarchical levels
• Shows how horizontal linking mechanisms, as emphasized, by Fonstad and Robertson (2006) demands coordinate between units, not only coordination between IT and business units
30
Contributions
(RQ2) what problems are caused by this design?
• My research takes an more empirical driven approach to identify problems (searching in three fundamental problem areas).
•
My research is in contrast to the more normative advises from maturity and decision models in the IT PPM literature
31
Contributions
(RQ3) what changes can be recommended to improve IT PPM?
• The IT PPM principles suggested by the literature does not fit the reality of Danish public organizations (Pedersen and Hansen 2010; Hansen 2011).
• I agree with Verhoef (2002) that use of more formalized mechanisms in IT PPM in an public organization is beneficial But I find that IT PPM is more that rational mechanisms, and therefore differs from the assumption by Verhoef (2002), that organizational stakeholders, like stock-brokers can apply friction-free marked mechanisms to select the most beneficial portfolio of IT projects.
• Thus I follow Hansen and Kræmmergard (2011), arguing that more research must be put on real life problems and conflicting interests, to provide more solid recommendations to improve IT PPM in a public organization