Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
The non-material nature of substances and medicines
Dr Keith Scott-Mumby Open International University for
Complementary Medicines Colombo, Sri Lanka
New perspectives on the action and efficacy of medicines
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
“Less than one billionth of the universe is matter. The rest is
energy and information..” Carlo Rubbia, Nobel laureate 1984
It follows therefore that the problem with disease is not the physical manifestation, which is merely the result, but the information-energy process surrounding it, which is where the cause lies.
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
The zero point field
FACT: there is no vacuum! It is a plenum (full!) It is a sea of quantum interchanges, energy giving rise to matter The total energy of the field exceeds all the energy contained in matter by a factor of 1040 The energy of one cubic metre of this “vacuum” would boil all the oceans of the world (Richard Feynman) NOTE: Western medicine the only healing system which does not use energy in therapy but is stuck in the material
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
PROPAGATION OF CONTROVERSY
All other sciences are subsumed to physics; that includes medicine and
biology
• Doctors don’t know enough physics
• Doctors don’t know enough medicine!
• Medical correctness
• scientific dogma
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
Important new emergent paradigm:
That information is senior to and regulates matter, energy and form The information field is there, whether the matter is or not. This has been forced on us by quantum
physics.
FACT: information implies consciousness
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
Classical vs. Quantum Physics
Atoms and molecules confined to defined locations in space and time Only the probability of finding the state of a given atom or molecule. In quantum physics both matter and EM radiation regarded as quanta that fluctuate in space and time
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
Proposition under attack:
Only weighable substances with a rest mass and a sufficient biochemical gradient can affect biological organisms
Fact: Unweighable (nonmaterial) substances have profound measurable biological effects and this may even be the paramount mechanism.
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
American pioneer
ALBERT ABRAMS neurologist
studied with Virchow and Wasserman MD in Heidelberg 1882 Professor of Pathology at Cooper College SF President of SF Medico- Chirurgical Society 1893
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
DULL TUMMY NOT SO DULL RESEARCH!
THE ABRAMS’ REFLEX SUBJECT FACING WEST LOSS OF RESONANCE PERCUSSING UPPER ABDOMEN (dullness) REFLEX EXCITED BY CANCER, TB etc PROXIMITY TO SPECIMEN SURROGATES
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
The reflexophone
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
Recognition of therapeutic substances
Quinine would cancel the signal in malaria specimens similarly mercury with syphilis
Unfortunately, Abrams announced that he could dispense with the patient altogether and work with
blood or urine. Trouble is on the way!
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
The Oscilloclast co-developed with Samuel O. Hoffman
Settings he called “rates” Frequencies characteristics of each tissue state (thus cancer 50, syphilis 20, tuberculosis 15 Directory of diseases and oscillations broadcasting frequencies with therapeutic results
Ref: New Concepts in Diagnosis and Treatment: Physico-clinical Medicine, San Francisco, 1916.
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
Inevitable controversy
Abrams unwisely says he can do it by telephone! Denounced in 18 consecutive editions of
SCIENTIFIC AMERICAN!! Accusations of mercenary motive the Oscilloclast vanishes into history as the infamous “black box”
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
William Boyd’s “Emanometer”
Replicates Abrams’ findings able to identify disease tissue able to choose a homeopathic similimum Presentation to International Homeopathic Conference, London 1927 Sir Thomas Horder’s report to the Royal Society of Medicine 1924
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
William Boyd’s “Emanometer”
Replicates Abrams’ findings able to identify disease tissue able to choose a homeopathic similimum Presentation to International Homeopathic Conference, London 1927
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
"If someone were to set about the task of selecting the greatest medical quack in history, he would find a long list of colorful competitors.... In recent times, our country has produced no greater charlatan than Albert Abrams".
(AMA magazine Hygeia, January 1939, p. 53.)
STRIKING AN EFFECTIVE BLOW FOR IGNORANCE…
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
Clearly some non-local emanation is radiating from disease tissues and
remedial substances QUESTION: what phenomenon had
Abrams discovered?
• CLUE: the singing of Caruso! • CLUE: the patient must be oriented east-west!
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
CYCLOTRON RESONANCE
The “Adey Window” Physiological response (efflux of calcium ions from in vitro chick neurones) in response to low-frequency signals:
• around 16 Hz
• critical extremely low intensity (above or below this window = no effect)
• kills the idea that strong means more and introduces information as the key element
Bawin S and Adey WR in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 73 (1976):1999. First report of ELF fields producing calcium efflux from nerve cells
“A number of combinations [of low frequency (15- 45 Hz) magnetic fields and static fields (25- 76 µ Tessla)] correspond to the cyclotron resonance condition of free circulating ions”
Liboff AR (1985a) Cell-field interactions at extremely low frequencies. Bull Am Physical Soc 30;548a.
“..the intrinsic helical structure of the protein subunits that form transmembrane channels represents a particularly appropriate geometry in which to obtain cyclotron resonance”
Liboff AR (1985b) Cyclotron resonance in membrane transport, in Chiabera A, Nicolini C, Schwan HP (eds.) “Interactions Between Electromagnetic Fields and Cells” London: Plenum Press pp. 279 294
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
Low-Intensity Magnetic Fields Alter Operant Behaviour in Rats
• Combination of 60 Hz and
2.6 x 10-5 Tessla (about half the geomagnetic field)
• STATIC FIELD: ν = (1/2π)(ρ/ϕ)Β
Condition for single ion (unhydrated) lithium.
JR Thomas, J Schrot and AR Liboff, Low-Intensity Magnetic Fields Alter Operant Behaviour in Rats. Biolectromagnetics
7:349-357 (1986)
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
Low-Intensity Magnetic Fields Alter Operant Behaviour in Rats
Biolectromagnetics 7:349-357 (1986)
FOUR FIELD CONDITIONS
• 60 Hz alone
• lithium frequency alone
• both fields in combination
• sham field (neither)
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
Low-Intensity Magnetic Fields Alter Operant Behaviour in Rats
Biolectromagnetics 7:349-357 (1986)
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
Low-Intensity Magnetic Fields Alter Operant Behaviour in Rats
“Quite apart from the question of resonance, the present results tend to suggest a functional dependence of behaviour on the geomagnetic field”
“There is a good likelihood of occasional human exposure to the particular combination of 60 Hz and 0.25 x 10-5 Tessla magnetostatic field.”
Biolectromagnetics 7:349-357 (1986)
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
QUESTION: might all substances and medicines be subject to the geo-magnetic field? QUESTION: might current artificial radiation levels be interfering with basic metabolism of nutrients and medicines?
Other theoretically affected physiological significant ions: Na+, K+, Cl-, Ca2+, Mg2+
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
YES! Proton magnetic resonance at very low levels in the ambient field caused sub-capsular cateracts in bovine eye lenses. Lysozyme effects on Micrococcus lysodeikticus was shown to be nutrition-sensitive in the conditions for magnetic resonance and solutions had “memory”. (Fröhlich H, 1988 Theoretical Physics and Biology. In: Fröhlich, H (Ed.) Biological Coherence and Response to External Stimuli. Berlin: Springer-Verlag, 1- 24
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
Homeopathy in one slide!
Substances to mimic the symptom pattern = similimum diluted many times: 10x10x10 etc or 100x100x100x100 etc (eg. 10X or C30) shaken or succussed at each dilution increasing strength called potentizing
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
BEWARE! EARTH’S MAGNETIC FIELD CRITICAL for the retention of imprinted frequencies! Magnetically shielding a specimen (homeo-pathic preparation) by placing it in a steel or mumetal box with a good overlapping lid will immediately and completely erase all imprinting. Smith CW., Is a Living System a Macroscopic Quantum System? Frontier Perspectives, Vol 7, number 1, Fall/Winter 1998 pp 9-15
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
Homeopathy: does it work?
Dilutions beyond the Avogadro (Loschmidt) number: (1 x 1023) ergo no weighable “substance” present Incompatible with known biochemical laws of concentration gradients (QUANTITATIVE STRUCTURE-ACTIVITY RELATIONSHIP)
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
The LANCET fiasco
"What could be more absurd than the notion that a substance is therapeutically active in dilutions so great that the patient is unlikely to receive a single molecule of it?" (Editorial, Lancet Dec 10, 1994:344, p 1585).
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
Science or slander? "... we must ask if the technique of randomized controlled trials is fundamentally flawed, and capable of producing evidence for effects that do not exist, by, for example, the effects of clinicians' expectations of outcome transmitting by subtle effects that circumvent double blinding?"
(Lancet 1994;344;1601- 06)
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
The “memory of water” fiasco
(Davenas E, Benveniste J et al. 'Human basophil degranulation triggered by very dilute antiserum against IgE' NATURE, 1988, 333: 816-818)
“Fraud!”
“Dubious science?”
“A cruel hoax!”
“Pseudo-science!”
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
Mechanisms for the “Memory of Water” effect
Reducing “noise” clathrates dipole molecules acting as chips Variable phase hydrogen bonds cyclotron resonance or NMR quantum information field
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
Water dipoles
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
As a gas it is one of lightest known As a liquid it is much denser than expected As a solid it is much lighter than expected. Unusually high melting point. Unusually high boiling point. Water shrinks on melting. Only substance known to commonly exist as solid, liquid and gas. http://www.lsbu.ac.uk/water/anmlies.html (lists 64 anomalous behaviors)
So-called “anomalous properties of water”
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
Mechanisms for the “Memory of Water” effect 2
LIGHT Rey applied techniques of thermo- luminescence to ultra high dilutions of lithium and sodium chloride. Even beyond the Avogadro number, light retained substance specificity (Rey L, Thermoluminescence of ultra-high dilutions of lithium chloride and sodium chloride. Physica A 2003;323:67-74)
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
Mechanisms for the “Memory of Water”- 2
Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and its Applications, Volume 323, 15 May 2003, Pages 67-74
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
Confirmatory studies Activity and chronopharmacology of very low doses of physiological immune inducers, Immunology Today (6:234-235) 1985, M. Bastide, M. Doucet Jaboeuf, V. Daurat.
Effects of embryonic bursectomy and in ovo administration of highly diluted bursin on a adrenocorticotropic and immune response to chickens. International Journal of Immunotherapy (IX:169-180) 1993, B.J. Youbicier-Simo, F. Boudard, M. Mekaouche, M. Bastide, J.D. Baylé.
The effect of highly diluted agitated thyroxine of the climbing activity of frogs. Veterinary and Human Toxicology (36:56-59) 1994, P.C. Endler, W. Pongratz, G. Kastberger, F.A.C. Wiegant, J.
Schulte.
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
Potentized Belladonna- spectroscopic analysis
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
Belladonna- Rockland signal analyzer
Kolisko L Wirkamseit kleinster Entitaten bei 7 metallen. Phil. Anthr. Verlag, Dornach 1926
Pelikan W and Unger G, Die Wirkung potenzierter Substanzen. Phil Anthr. Verlag, Dornach 1965.
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
CONCLUSION: homeopathy is an information system; it regulates matter and energy and not the other way round. It is superordinate to and independent of weighable substance. QED: a substance which doesn’t exist can influence biological and physical structure
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
Enter digital transfer technology! • All cells communicate via molecular resonance
• mutual resonance extends outwards, like chain reactions, spreading to other molecules (piano strings!)
• All fields extend to the ends of the universe
• instant (speed of light)
• every substance known to have characteristic frequencies which can be detected right across the universe
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
QSAR or “lock-and-key” theory
Direct contact random collision trial-and-error basis statistically virtually impossible the simplest biological event would require a very long time
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
“Electromagnetic signalling” theory
No direct contact distance not a problem ELFs work at very attenuated levels even high-frequency molecules can “beat” at ELF resonance enabled by geomagnetic field instantaneous
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
Digitalized acetyl choline perfusion of isolated guinea pig hearts
digitally recorded activity of acetylcholine (d-ACh). Water (d-W) as control. 16 bits, 22 KHz, for 1-5 sec, via an especially designed transducer, on the hard disk of a computer equipped with a Sound Blaster 16 card Files were digitally amplified and the signature signal of ACh or W was replayed for 15 min to create test sample solution
1996 Digital recording/transmission of the cholinergic signal. FASEB Journal
(10:A1479(abs)). J. Benveniste, P. Jurgens, J. Aïssa.
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
Digitalized acetyl choline perfusion of isolated guinea pig hearts - results
In 13 open experiments there was a highly significant coronary flow response to digitized acetyl choline, equivalent to the normal pharmacological effect no effect from the d-water both acetyl choline and d-acetyl choline were blocked by atropine He was able to send the digital information down the telephone and have the results repeated elsewhere!!
1996 Digital recording/transmission of the cholinergic signal. FASEB Journal (10:A1479(abs)). J. Benveniste, P. Jurgens, J. Aïssa.
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
Confirming studies Transmission of hormone information by non-molecular means. FASEB Journal (8:A400(abs)) 1995 P.C. Endler, W. Pongratz, R. van Wijk, K. Waltl, H. Hilgers, R. Brandmaier. Hormone effects by CD record/replay. FASEB Journal (9: A392(abs)) 1995, F. Senekowitsch, P.C.Endler, W. Pongratz, C.W. Smith. Water as a free electric dipole laser. Physical Reviews Letter (61:1085-1088) 1988, E. del Giudice, G. Preparata, G. Vitiello.
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
"electronic" phorbol myristate acetate (PMA) test
“informed water” treated with PMA resonance signal compared to the effect of control water Oscillator on and then off Testing neutrophil production of reactive oxygen metabolites (ROM) Test effect of SOD blockage
1996 Modulation of human neutrophil activation by “electronic” phorbol myristate acetate (PMA) Federation of American Societies for Experimental Biology Journal (10:A1479(abs)) Y Thomas, H Litime, J Benveniste
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
PMA test - results
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
PAMA test - results 2
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
Biology via the Internet! As well as replicating these results elsewhere Benveniste and colleagues at the Northwestern University in Chicago have been able to send digitized biological information
• via TELEPHONE • On a floppy disc • via INTERNET • even as an E-MAIL ATTACHMENT!
and still replicate the effects at the other end
1997 Transatlantic transfer of digitized antigen signal by telephone link. Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology (99:S175 (abs.) J. Benveniste, P. Jurgens, W. Hsueh, J. Aïssa.
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
The future: Western version of energy medicine?
Use of digitally recorded medicines (will there be side effects?) Use of digital isodes, nosodes and sarcodes instead of “therapeutics” Digitalized mineral and nutrient enhancement Digital signals to destroy or limit pathogens (?Rife microscope) “Healing” software
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
Remember Albert Abrams
He did it first and did it with great panache he anticipated modern digital technology by over 80 years! A genius
Copyright 2002 by Keith Scott-Mumby
Contact details:
Dr Keith Scott-Mumby MB ChB 13A Udaya Mawatha, Mount Lavinia,
Sri Lanka ++94 12 71 31 93
e-mail: [email protected] website: www.alternative-doctor.com to congratulate Jacques Benveniste
www.digibio.com